Video transcripts, November 13, 2026
Video transcripts
60 of 60 videos with a full transcript
How Democrats Won Back Union Voters full transcript
0:00 Democrats seem to be getting their mojo back in a big way
0:03 with union households.
0:04 In the 2026 midterms, they won these voters by a
0:08 whopping 22 percentage points,
0:10 according to the CNBC Voter Poll.
0:12 That's nearly three times the eight point advantage
0:14 Kamala Harris held in 2024.
0:17 And about one out of every six voters in the CNBC Voter
0:20 Poll said they were either a union member themselves or
0:23 lived in a household with one. It's a pretty dramatic
0:26 turnaround for a party whose relationship with organized
0:29 labor has been showing signs of strain.
0:31 So what changed, and can Democrats keep this
0:34 momentum going into 2028?
0:43 Unions have long been considered a core voting
0:45 bloc for Democrats, but their lead with these
0:47 voters had been shrinking.
0:49 In 2020, they had a 16 point advantage.
0:53 By 2024, that was down to just eight points.
0:57 Then came 2026.
0:59 Suddenly, their advantage was bigger than at any point
1:02 over the last eight years.
1:04 Just two years ago, the relationship between
1:06 Democrats and organized labor looked a lot less
1:09 certain. When do we want it?
1:11 Now! The Teamsters, one of the country's largest
1:13 labor unions, declined to endorse any
1:15 presidential candidate, breaking a streak of six
1:18 consecutive Democratic presidential endorsements.
1:21 And the union's own polling showed more participating
1:23 members favored endorsing Donald Trump than Kamala
1:26 Harris. Now, the Teamsters were hardly representative
1:30 of every union, and some of their local
1:32 chapters backed Harris anyway.
1:34 But the decision illustrated a broader political tension.
1:37 Democrats could no longer take overwhelming support
1:40 from organized labor for granted.
1:42 The United Auto Workers took a different approach,
1:45 endorsing Harris in 2024.
1:47 But its president says party affiliation alone isn't
1:50 enough to win the union's backing.
1:52 The days of just blindly giving our endorsements to
1:54 people because of party affiliation are over.
1:56 They're going to earn our support, and the candidates
1:58 that do not earn it will not get it.
2:02 Fast forward to 2026, and Michigan offers a
2:05 particularly interesting example of this reversal.
2:08 It's a state with a significant union presence,
2:11 especially in the auto industry.
2:13 And the United Auto Workers were actively campaigning
2:16 for Democrats this election.
2:18 According to the UAW, its volunteers knocked on
2:21 100,000 doors in Michigan and made half a million
2:23 phone calls. It called the initiative one part of its
2:26 biggest political organizing efforts in recent history.
2:30 The union also focused on competitive congressional
2:32 districts where its members could make a difference.
2:35 And it was really member driven. They recruited over
2:38 a thousand UAW members to volunteer.
2:41 And look at the results among Michigan Union
2:43 households. In 2024, Kamala Harris won them by
2:47 ten points. This year, Democrat Abdul El-Sayed won
2:50 union households by 25 points in his Senate race.
2:54 And Jocelyn Benson won them by 27 points in the
2:56 governor's race. Now, these are different races,
3:00 and polling alone can't tell us how much that organizing
3:03 contributed. But it does show just how substantial
3:06 Democrats advantage was in a state where unions were
3:09 mobilizing on a massive scale.
3:13 And Michigan wasn't the only place where unions were
3:15 organizing. The AFL-CIO, which is the country's
3:19 largest federation of labor unions,
3:21 says its volunteers to reach nearly 15 million voters
3:24 nationwide since Labor Day.
3:26 That's through door knocking, phone calls and
3:28 workplace outreach. But that activity doesn't mean
3:32 organized labor is suddenly united behind Democrats.
3:35 In fact, Teamsters President Sean O'Brien said he
3:38 personally voted for a Republican Senate candidate
3:40 in Florida this year. The Teamsters declined CNBC's
3:44 request to participate in this report.
3:46 And there's still the question of what motivated
3:49 union household voters.
3:50 The polling doesn't give us a definitive answer on that.
3:53 The richest people in the world keep getting richer,
3:55 and working class people can't afford to live. And so
3:57 I really think this election was a mandate on that.
4:00 People are fed up. They're fed up with being left
4:02 behind, scraping to get by.
4:03 But AFL-CIO data shows that,
4:05 at the very least, there was a lot of
4:07 enthusiasm this time around.
4:09 The organizations had 83% of union voters were very
4:13 motivated to head to the polls this year. That's up
4:15 ten percentage points from 2022.
4:19 But this shift is significant because unions
4:22 have historically been an important part of the
4:24 Democratic coalition.
4:25 And even as union membership has declined over the past
4:28 few decades, nearly 15 million American workers
4:32 still belong to unions.
4:33 The 2026 results suggest Democrats have regained a
4:36 significant advantage with this group.
4:38 But midterm elections and presidential elections can
4:41 look very different.
4:42 I think this election should be a huge wake up call.
4:46 It should be a wake up call for Democrats, too. Because,
4:48 you know, winning is the easy part.
4:50 Taking actions is the big part of this job.
4:53 And with another presidential election coming
4:55 in 2028, the next question is whether that
4:57 advantage can last.
The Housing Freeze 11/13/26 full transcript
0:00 with a CNBC your money minute. I'm
0:02 Jessica Edinger. We're heading into one
0:05 of the slowest times of the year for the
0:07 real estate business. The holidays loom
0:09 and wow, mortgage rates are still above
0:12 7% for a 30-year fixed home loan, and
0:15 that's a block for a lot of people.
0:17 >> We've crossed a very real psychological
0:19 threshold of 7%. The pressure on the
0:21 firsttime home buyer at any decision
0:23 point is affecting everything. That's
0:25 EXP Realy CEO Leo Perea on CNBC.
0:29 >> For the American consumer, it's tough
0:31 right now. Oil crossed $100 a barrel,
0:33 which translates to higher diesel prices
0:36 for freight and groceries and affecting
0:39 everything.
0:39 >> Parea tells CNBC that high prices
0:41 everywhere. That puts pressure on
0:44 wouldbe home buyers.
0:45 >> When you think about what drives
0:46 consumer demand for housing, it's always
0:49 human condition. We need more space. Uh
0:51 we got relocated to another job. You are
0:53 coming out of a lease. you have 90 days
0:55 left on it. You're deciding whether to
0:56 buy a house. You open the news and you
0:59 see it's kind of the perfect storm of
1:00 pressure, right? Cuz the diesel prices
1:02 translates to pressure at the grocery
1:04 store, which makes people think twice
1:06 before spending money.
1:08 >> The home builders have been trying to
1:09 relieve some of that pressure by
1:11 lowering their prices and buying down
1:12 mortgage rates for people just to get
1:14 them into completed new homes. Parea
1:18 says wouldbe buyers should look at newly
1:20 built communities and in towns that got
1:23 popular in CO because people are leaving
1:26 those now and home prices there have
1:28 been coming down.
1:28 >> Parts of Southwest Florida, Texas, most
1:31 of the COVID postboom markets um are
1:34 seeing sharp declines. I live in Miami,
1:36 Florida. We're seeing quite a bit of
1:38 days on market for single family homes.
1:40 >> You can read a lot more on buying a home
1:43 at cnbc.com.
1:45 I'm Jessica Edinger, CNBC.
Mad Money 11/12/26 full transcript
0:01 My mission is simple, to make you money.
0:04 I'm here to level the playing field for
0:06 all investors. There's always a bull
0:09 market somewhere and I promise to help
0:11 you find it. May have money starts now.
0:13 [music]
0:17 Hey, I'm Kramer. Welcome to Mayoney.
0:19 Welcome to Cra, my friends. I'm just
0:22 trying to make a little bit of money
0:23 here. My job is not just to entertain,
0:25 but to do some teaching. So, call me
0:26 1800 743 CNBC. Tweet me, Jim Kramer.
0:31 In the end, Jensen Wong was more of a
0:34 liability to the company he founded and
0:36 ran than a positive. The possibility of
0:39 him being a mark for a Chinese spy,
0:42 giving up key secrets, or even helping
0:45 them get the latest chips, having them
0:48 find their way to the People's Republic
0:50 cannot be ruled out. The ill- advised,
0:52 not very well, a hidden affair with one
0:54 of his direct reports, something five
0:56 invidia executives confirmed to the New
0:58 York Times, is flat out against the
1:00 rules at most companies and is
1:03 embarrassingly unprofessional.
1:07 So, his staying on as CEO of Nvidia just
1:10 because he was Nvidia to many and the
1:13 stock price would be much higher if he
1:15 went removed simply wasn't an option.
1:18 This morning he resigned and yes he did
1:20 resign in disgrace. Did we want him to
1:22 go? If we are shareholders pre- disgrace
1:25 of course not. He was an amazing CEO.
1:27 Post disgrace knowing what we know now
1:30 about the way that this brilliant man
1:32 put the institution he said he loved
1:34 into jeopardy. I have to say yes. In any
1:37 case I don't think the board had any
1:39 other choice. I'm not a mor morality
1:42 coach nor am I a board member of Nvidia.
1:45 I pine on stocks for a living. So in
1:47 this day where the Dow dipped 189
1:49 points, the S&P fell.35% the NASDAQ
1:51 dropped.39%. We have to figure out what
1:54 a Jensenless Nvidia is worth clinically.
1:58 First, let's take something I heard all
2:01 day off the table. He will not be
2:03 allowed to participate in Vidia's
2:04 affairs either in a public or or a
2:07 sidebar fashion. No, Jensen Wong has
2:09 left the building. The company wants him
2:11 as far away as possible because it wants
2:13 to isolate him and keep the multiple
2:15 investigations his actions have caused
2:17 from tainting the day-to-day operations
2:19 of this company.
2:21 Remember this, the board represents you,
2:24 not Jensen. It's bad enough that there
2:26 will be employees investigated to see if
2:28 they turned a blind eye to what might
2:29 have been a clear pipeline of high-end
2:32 Nvidia chips to the PRC via his
2:35 paramor's ties to the Communist Party.
2:37 There will also have to be an
2:38 investigation of the sorted affair Jason
2:41 Jensen Wong had with Kimberly Pal,
2:43 Nvidia's vice president of healthcare,
2:45 an important position that might not
2:47 have been handled as well as it should
2:49 have because of the relationship. So
2:51 then you ask, how come the stock didn't
2:53 go down even more today? First, I remind
2:56 you that it's been going down for months
2:58 and it's not exactly like it's expensive
3:00 here. The company reports next week and
3:02 I believe it'll be a huge quarter.
3:03 Remember this isn't sendant or Enron or
3:06 Worldcom. Horrendous financial scandals
3:10 where there was little to nothing in the
3:12 bank. That's the kind of scandal you
3:13 must run from no matter what. There's
3:15 tens of billions of dollars in the bank
3:17 here. No accounting irregularities.
3:19 This is scandal involving potential
3:22 liability from those orders procured by
3:24 a spy and the sanctions that might be
3:27 placed on Nvidia by the government.
3:29 something that is less likely now that
3:30 Jensen has been cut loose.
3:34 Second, the person named interim CEO
3:37 Colette Crest who is the current CFO. I
3:40 know people think I was close to Wong
3:42 and maintain a good relationship, but
3:44 let me tell you something. My principal
3:45 contact at the company have been Colette
3:47 Crest. She runs the conference call, an
3:50 amazing conference call. She's the
3:52 person who explains things to me and
3:53 answers my questions. Crest knows more
3:56 about the company than Wong does. Not
3:58 the technology, but how the company
4:00 works. She is tough as nails. Yeah, the
4:03 kinds of nails that come out of a nail
4:04 gun. To say that she doesn't suffer
4:06 fools gladly understates her precision
4:09 and her rigor and the lack of viewers if
4:12 you ask something stupid, which I have
4:14 done and regretted immediately. She will
4:17 hold things together well in the
4:19 interim. And with Crest at the helm, the
4:21 idea that there is a financial scandal,
4:23 the kind that makes you have to sell the
4:24 stock goes away because she is the
4:26 keeper of the numbers. She will be on
4:28 full display when they report next
4:30 Tuesday, as she always is on the
4:32 conference calls. I say bravo. The last
4:35 reason that the market didn't fall apart
4:37 today is the upcoming anthropic IPO.
4:39 We're on the verge of what might be the
4:40 biggest IPO of all time and the
4:42 ramifications for the semi, especially
4:44 Nvidia. and that the ecosystem that
4:46 Jensen created with all these
4:48 investments are now going to pay off.
4:50 They may be actually be able to recoup
4:52 most of those investments once this
4:53 happens. Now remember your across
4:55 disciplines here people as I told CBC
4:57 Investing Club members today during our
4:59 morning meeting streaming show at 10:20.
5:01 If you're one of the myriad Nvidia
5:03 millionaires the club and Jensen Wong
5:04 created, thank you Jensen for doing
5:06 that. You need to be sure you take at
5:09 least some of those profits off the
5:11 table. Don't ever turn a successful
5:13 investment into an unsuccessful trade,
5:15 no matter who it's with. We don't know
5:17 what else is going to come out from what
5:20 will almost certainly be multiple
5:21 investigations. Whatever it is, I I
5:23 don't think it's going to be any good.
5:25 You don't want to give up all of your
5:26 gains if the stock falls further. It
5:29 fell further today after many of the
5:30 analysts jump ship and downgrade the
5:32 stock from buy to hold, but I think
5:33 there could be many more of those ahead.
5:36 We don't know what Nvidia's competitor
5:38 is going to do. We know that AMD has
5:39 been catching up with its own product
5:41 lines. Broadcom's quite competitive.
5:42 Google and Amazon less so, but Amazon
5:44 does have what may soon be a $50 billion
5:47 semiconductor business. That's the
5:48 second half of 27. Can they catch up to
5:51 Nvidia with its clear four-year product
5:53 roadmap? If you think, as the analysts
5:56 seem to believe that the other 42,000
5:59 other employees don't matter much, then
6:02 you're going to get cold feet. Even if
6:04 you see the great numbers next Tuesday,
6:06 I can hear the rousing about last good
6:07 quarter all over the place.
6:09 We know that the investigations might
6:11 lead to international export
6:12 curtailments which would would hurt the
6:15 business and lead to number cuts. That
6:17 means that no matter how low the price
6:18 during each multiple gets, the stock
6:20 could still go lower. So where do I come
6:22 out? We've made, you know, look, we've
6:25 made fortunes in Nvidia for the travel
6:27 trust, but we still have too much with
6:29 the stock here at 166. That means it it
6:32 cuts to selling some when we are not
6:35 restricted from doing so. and we've been
6:36 restricted for ages and ages and had to
6:38 ride this one down. But here's something
6:41 you might be happy about. I did a small
6:43 canvas today of executives who I thought
6:45 could be that Tim Cook to Jensen Steve
6:48 Jobs tall order as Cook was a first
6:52 ballot hall of famer. But the caliber of
6:54 candidates here who were interested in
6:56 this job made me feel that there won't
6:59 be a better Nvidia, just a different
7:02 one. one that is better organized
7:04 perhaps and not just throwing money
7:06 around to wrap up companies in the
7:08 Nvidia ecosystem. Maybe we'll get
7:10 someone who decides it's okay to take
7:12 profits on the company's successful
7:14 investments in other companies now that
7:16 the anthropic deal will liquefy the
7:18 ecosystem that Jensen created. Maybe
7:20 we'll have a CEO who does more to
7:22 highlight the company's other 42,000
7:25 employees. The ones who I think are
7:26 insulted by what's happening. The ones
7:29 that don't wear the leather jackets.
7:31 They exist, too. The bottom line, am I
7:34 mad about Jensen? Yes. I liked him so
7:37 damn much. I am crushed by this. I
7:40 thought he was a better guy. Did he
7:42 betray me? Nah. No. It's my job to not
7:45 be betrayed, to be smarter, to have my
7:47 eyes more wide open. He didn't betray
7:49 me. Did he betray you, the shareholders?
7:52 Yeah. End of story. Dennis in Ohio.
7:55 Dennis.
7:56 >> Hey, how are you, Jim?
7:58 >> Dennis, I'm okay. How about you? Hey, I
8:00 woke up today, so it's a good day,
8:02 right?
8:03 >> You know what? I actually said that this
8:05 morning, so yeah, the answer is yeah to
8:07 that. Okay, [laughter]
8:09 >> I'm calling on SNOK. It's gone from 80
8:12 in August down in the low 60s now.
8:14 >> Yeah,
8:15 >> they're having having another record
8:16 year. Uh keep raising their dividends,
8:19 low PE ratio. I just don't get it.
8:22 >> No, I like it. Well, it's going down
8:24 because people feel the war's over. I I
8:25 remember the day it came public and I
8:27 thought, what a great idea. But then
8:28 ago, I was a a son of, you know, grew up
8:30 in Philadelphia. I think this thing's a
8:32 great piece of paper. I think you're in
8:33 good shape. Just own it. If it goes down
8:35 to 6%, buy more. Let's go to Robert New
8:37 York. Who's Robert?
8:39 >> Jim, so nice to hear your voice and how
8:41 positive you are. And I got to tell you
8:43 something. You're doing a great job for
8:45 us with the ups and downs. You're making
8:48 us steady and you're basically telling
8:50 us what to do, which is nibble away at
8:52 some of the stocks going down. And in
8:55 the end, it doesn't matter because this
8:57 has happened 50 times throughout Wall
8:58 Street where the market has corrected up
9:01 10% down 15%. So if you play the Kramer
9:04 rule, which is how to make money in any
9:06 market, you can't lose in the end. You
9:09 will not lose if you listen to Robert.
9:11 You can't see right now, but I'm walking
9:12 down a street right now that I walked
9:15 down in 1981 when the Dow was at a
9:18 thousand and everyone told me it is so
9:20 ridiculously overvalued. Keep your money
9:23 in CDs. I didn't know what a CD was, but
9:25 I knew what a stock was, and I crushed
9:26 it. All right. So, go ahead. I'm sorry.
9:27 >> You cr That's why you are the top guy on
9:30 Wall Street. That's why you're here to
9:31 help.
9:32 >> And there's like guys who are
9:33 billionaires and they're like, "All we
9:34 do is hear from them." And they're
9:35 fantastic because when you're a
9:36 billionaire, you're fantastic.
9:38 >> Just kidding.
9:39 >> You're fantastic because you help the
9:41 common man. And then
9:42 >> I did good. That's what I want. That's
9:44 what Emma wants me to do. That's my
9:46 daughter. Go ahead.
9:47 >> And she's great, your daughter.
9:48 Phenomenal. But anyway,
9:49 >> I like the folds and potato chips. Yeah.
9:52 Let's make the Let's make the listeners
9:54 some money. Or you tell me if I'm wrong
9:56 here. Okay. This next company's latest
9:58 results throw a sharp earnings reset
10:01 with weak appliance demand, inflation,
10:02 and housing softness, pressuring the
10:04 sales and the margins. Now, the
10:06 management is relying on price
10:07 increases, manufacturing changes, and a
10:10 $290 million structural savings to
10:12 support a profitability recovery in
10:14 2027. Now, I own this stock. I bought it
10:18 when the earnings got touted. I met this
10:20 guy out. He used to work for the
10:21 company. He goes, "This is a good
10:22 company down the road. It shouldn't be
10:24 this cheap."
10:27 >> Baby,
10:28 >> uh, you know, okay, so listen, I love
10:30 the I love the product, but maybe it may
10:32 need a kind of a CEO refresh. Uh,
10:35 because someone has to pay for that
10:37 decline, [music] and I think it has to
10:39 be the CEO. I like the guy very much,
10:41 but the decline is too much. I thank you
10:43 for your kind words. If I help the
10:45 common for the regular person, [music]
10:46 that's a heck of a lot better than
10:47 helping all the billionaires I used to
10:49 help. They were never that appreciative
10:51 anyway during group. Anyway, on May
10:54 money tonight, Craft Hind gave a very
10:56 optimistic investor [music] day
10:57 presentation. It could ring today's NYC
10:59 bell. I'm finding out more about the
11:01 path [music] for packaged goods with the
11:03 with the CEO who I just think is great.
11:05 Then I'm rounding out my series [music]
11:06 on anthropics hotly anticipated IPO with
11:10 some of the more unusual aspects of the
11:11 deal [music] that you need to know
11:12 about. And Mona's promising cancer
11:14 vaccine has been propelling the stock
11:16 higher this year. What else is in the
11:18 pipeline? I'm going to find out with a
11:19 company CEO. [music] So stay with RAM.
11:25 [music]
11:30 >> Don't miss [music] a second of MadMoney.
11:31 Follow Jim Kramer on X. Have a question?
11:34 [music] Tweet Kramer #madmentions.
11:38 Send Jim an email to [email protected]
11:41 or give us a call [music] at
11:42 1800743CNBC.
11:45 Miss something? Head to madmoney.c
11:48 cnbc.com. [music]
11:56 [music]
12:01 This will be exciting and it's not about
12:03 Nvidia. This morning, Craft Hinds, the
12:05 package food giant, rang the opening
12:07 bell to celebrate the move from the
12:08 NASDAQ to New York Stock Exchange. Then
12:10 it's a terrific investor day. The
12:12 company said it expects sales and
12:13 operating profits to start growing again
12:15 in the second half of next year. She's
12:17 consistent in accelerated growth by
12:19 2029. Since taking the helm nearly a
12:22 year ago, CEO Steve Kaine has invested
12:24 700 million into the business, hired 400
12:26 new employees. This is so different from
12:28 the old one. Let's check in with Steve,
12:30 the CEO of Craft Clients to find out
12:31 more about his comeback plan. Steve, I
12:33 am so glad to see you're here and I just
12:35 had how much you invest in the company,
12:38 but let's just get started by how much
12:39 have you invested yourself.
12:41 >> Well, thanks for having me, Jim, as
12:42 always. So, shortly after I started with
12:45 the company, obviously I'm paid a lot in
12:47 uh in in stock, but I went into the open
12:49 market and bought $5 million worth of
12:50 Craftine shares because I like to put my
12:52 money where my mouth is on the team that
12:55 I'm going to put together.
12:56 >> I know you sure do. I was going through
12:57 your amazing deck and you had this line.
13:00 I think it kind of epitomizes where we
13:01 are. We always had the right assets to
13:04 win. Now, we are realizing their full
13:07 potential. Those assets are pretty
13:08 great, aren't they?
13:09 >> They're fantastic. Think about the Hines
13:11 brand. I mean, Hines is loved everywhere
13:13 around the world, rejected nowhere,
13:15 right? We've got a huge opportunity to
13:17 grow Hines in its home market of the
13:19 United States, which we've returned it
13:20 to growth. We've got huge opportunities
13:22 all around the world. Hines in Brazil is
13:25 doing phenomenally well. Hines in China
13:28 is opening up whole new occasions with
13:30 eggs and breakfast. And so, Hines plays
13:33 everywhere. Hines soup has just been
13:35 introduced in Canada. It's off to a
13:37 flying start. So, Hines is a phenomenal
13:40 brand and it it really is gold.
13:42 >> Now, you are actually reaching people
13:44 differently from just traditional
13:46 advertising. You've embraced the
13:48 channels that I always thought people
13:49 should start embracing, Meta and Tik
13:50 Tok.
13:51 >> Yeah, there's no question. Look, today's
13:53 consumer shows up differently than they
13:55 did historically. You still have to be
13:56 in historic traditional places, but we
13:59 have to be where the consumer are. We
14:01 has to we have to go meet the consumer
14:02 where they are. That's social, that's
14:04 digital, and the future is it's agentic
14:07 as well. So, we have to continue to
14:09 evolve our capabilities. We have to
14:11 invest in our capabilities, and we have
14:12 to meet the consumer where they are.
14:14 >> State of the consumer seems to be um
14:16 able to buy both your highest end
14:18 products and your more middling
14:19 products.
14:20 >> Yeah. I think, you know, the the
14:21 consumer right now, it stopped getting
14:23 worse, right? The consumer is not in a
14:25 great spot. Uh but they're not in a
14:27 terrible spot. The job market's strong.
14:29 Uh you know, inflation is still a little
14:31 too challenging. gas prices a little too
14:33 challenging, but you know, we're a
14:35 staple in many, many cases, and we're a
14:37 treat in other cases. But we've been
14:39 able to connect with consumers, hold up
14:41 our business, improve our trends, uh, in
14:44 this country and around the world. And
14:45 we expect into next year, probably the
14:47 first half of 27 is still going to be
14:49 somewhat of a challenge, a little bit
14:51 more inflation, but that's okay. That's
14:53 okay. The back half of 27, we start to
14:56 see a lot more a lot more opportunities
14:58 to really get ourselves back to growth.
14:59 Well, one of the reason besides the ex
15:01 moving to the exchange that I wanted to
15:03 have you on was is that I've always
15:05 liked your work, but I did doubt you and
15:07 Kellogg. I thought that Kellogg were
15:08 dead brands that there was nothing
15:10 there. I didn't do it on air, but uh you
15:14 uh did something rather remarkable
15:15 Kellogg. You created a huge amount of
15:17 wealth. How did you go about doing that
15:19 when other people didn't see anything?
15:21 Well, I think the mistake that was made
15:24 at Craft Hind before I arrived in the
15:26 last several years is this notion that
15:28 there's a forever brand. That brands can
15:30 just live on the history of their past.
15:32 That's not true. But equally, brands
15:34 that are existed for a long time are not
15:37 necessarily destined for the dust spin
15:39 of history. And that's what a lot of
15:41 people thought about the brands at Craft
15:42 Hind. And there's simply not. When you
15:44 look at Hines, which I've already talked
15:46 about, but craft mac and cheese, people
15:48 said 90 years old, best days are past,
15:51 new innovation is coming from smaller
15:55 companies. Best days are well, we
15:56 innovated. We launched Craft Power Mac.
16:00 We launched Craft Restaurant Mac and
16:02 Cheese Restaurant Edition. And the brand
16:04 is back to growth. And in Canada, we
16:07 launched a ramen, a cheesy ramen.
16:09 >> Cheesy ramen
16:10 >> under the KD.
16:10 >> Now, I saw that I said, "You got to be
16:12 kidding me." We sold out uh three months
16:14 worth of stock in a week. We're going to
16:16 introduce that next year. So, you have
16:18 to innovate. You have to bring new news.
16:19 You have to bring excitement with your
16:21 brands.
16:22 >> So, is high pre high protein Jell-O is
16:24 that going to be in in a a Costco or a
16:26 Walmart? Yeah, absolutely. And it tastes
16:28 delicious. You know, one of the problems
16:30 with protein is you can't necessarily It
16:33 doesn't go with everything. It's hard to
16:35 match the flavors. Sometimes it's
16:36 chalky. Sometimes it's off-putting to uh
16:39 you know, put into existing brands. But
16:41 [clears throat] our R&D team has cracked
16:43 the code. The chocolate's my favorite.
16:45 Chocolate um jello- pudding with protein
16:47 I think is going to be a real hit.
16:48 >> Okay. So, Philadelphia Cream Cheese is a
16:50 nice brand. Always felt that it was
16:52 under marketed, underdone. Are you
16:54 blowing it out?
16:56 >> Yeah. So, um Philadelphia Cream Cheese
16:58 is a phenomenal brand. We're doing a lot
17:01 especially next year. Uh and it's going
17:03 to be protein le as well. We've got a
17:04 big opportunity to drive protein to
17:07 steal some share from Cottage Cheese.
17:09 Uh, and that's going to come through the
17:10 Philadelphia name. We're going to do
17:12 other things in the back half of next
17:14 year that I think will be equally as
17:16 exciting. But it's a it's one of our
17:18 biggest share gainers this year.
17:20 Philadelphia Cream.
17:21 >> Now, people wanted before, you know, the
17:23 original plan was to split the company
17:24 in two. What did you see that you knew
17:27 that wasn't right?
17:28 >> I saw a lot that was fixable. I saw a
17:31 lot of own goals that we had done. And
17:33 if we spent all of this year separating
17:36 the business into two separate
17:37 companies, we would have continued to
17:39 underinvest in it and we would have
17:41 invested in the wrong things which are
17:43 bankers and lawyers to separate the
17:45 business. We would have ended up with
17:46 two suboptimal businesses. By pausing
17:49 that and by stopping it and by putting
17:51 the 700 incremental dollars on top of
17:54 what we're already spending against the
17:56 brands, I thought we'd be one bigger,
17:58 stronger company. The other thing that a
18:00 lot of businesses like ours have
18:02 forgotten about is scale can be an
18:04 advantage, but you have to know what to
18:06 do with that scale. And so we were going
18:08 to cut the company in half and become
18:10 subscale, but instead we're a $25
18:13 billion business that's going to be
18:15 growing. Again, that's much more
18:17 powerful than two businesses that are
18:18 separated, that are suboptimal, that are
18:20 not growing.
18:21 >> All right, la last question for you,
18:22 Steve, is is that I did you mention
18:25 about the brands or forever brands. I do
18:27 think that certain brands I thought had
18:30 aged out. I thought that both Craft and
18:32 Hind had aged out. That's clearly not
18:35 the case.
18:36 >> It's not the case. And I'll give you an
18:37 example. So, we we rang the bell of the
18:39 stock exchange this morning. Before
18:40 that, we were outside. You know, it was
18:42 all wonderful. We had the Kool-Aid Man
18:44 outside. We had a crowd of New Yorkers
18:47 so excited about seeing the Kool-Aid
18:49 Man, right? They'll buy the t-shirt, but
18:51 we have to contemporize it. We have to
18:53 innovate. We have to get people to want
18:55 to buy the product as well. And we can
18:57 do that because the brands loved.
18:59 >> You sound as fired up as when you did
19:01 the Kellogg. One of the greatest trades
19:03 ever.
19:03 >> Fired up. It's a great company. It's an
19:05 important company. It deserves a bright
19:07 future. And that's what my team and I
19:09 are bound and determined to deliver. A
19:11 bright future for Craft Hind.
19:13 >> I I got to go all in because I I I seen
19:16 you do it once. I think you're going to
19:18 do it again.
19:19 >> I want to thank Steve K. Lane, CEO of
19:21 Craft Hinds. Look guys, I often point to
19:23 decks and they're hard to understand. Is
19:26 there really anything hard to understand
19:27 about ketchup [music] and Philly cream
19:29 cheese? No. May have money's back after
19:31 the break. Thank you, Steve. Thanks,
19:33 Jim.
19:35 Coming up, Kramer's wrapping up his
19:37 anthropic IPO series by identifying what
19:40 else you need to know beyond the
19:42 company's financials. Next,
19:56 Every night this week, I've been
19:58 spending some time trying to prepare you
20:00 for next week's historic Anthropic IPO.
20:04 I've been covering the story from all
20:05 angles, explaining the stakes and the
20:07 broad terms of the deal, looking at
20:08 Anthropic's impressive growth, and
20:10 examining the company's complicated
20:13 profitability profile. Tonight, I want
20:15 to wrap things up for this know your IPO
20:18 series with a quick run through of all
20:19 sorts of other considerations for this
20:21 anthropic deal. Things that aren't
20:23 reflected in the company's financials,
20:24 which is what I focused on so far. I'm
20:26 going to start with the pros. And the
20:28 first thing to call out is the huge cash
20:30 balance that Anthropic will have after
20:33 its IPO. I've noted the company had $132
20:36 billion in cash, cash equivalents, and
20:37 short-term investments at the end of
20:39 September. And it could add around
20:41 hundred billion in cash from next week's
20:43 offering. Now, we do know that they're
20:45 going to need that cash with some $900
20:48 billion in compute commitments on the
20:50 horizon. That's a great buffer to start.
20:53 Another thing I like is the fact that
20:54 90% of contributions to Anthropic's code
20:57 base are actually being written by
20:59 Claude at this point. Just in the third
21:01 quarter, Anthropic saw a 45 times
21:04 increase in code contributed per
21:06 engineer from 2024 levels. That's called
21:09 productivity. In other words, the
21:11 product is increasingly making itself
21:12 and also finding ways to improve itself.
21:14 For example, using compute more
21:16 efficiently. This has all sorts of
21:18 positive benefits. It makes Anthropic
21:20 more efficient. Of course, I don't think
21:21 it's coincidence that the company reach
21:23 profitability at least on an adjusted
21:25 basis as this has happened and it allows
21:28 Anthropic to build new models and
21:30 products faster. All right, now to the
21:32 open questions. The first one is about
21:34 pricing. Anthropic has been cutting
21:36 prices for many of its models recently,
21:38 which some have seen as a bearish
21:41 development and acknowledgment that
21:43 customers are chafing at their claw
21:45 bills and looking for other options like
21:47 the openweight models that are so
21:48 inexpensive. That said, I was encouraged
21:51 to see that Anthropic's revenue growth
21:53 remains strong in October after many of
21:55 these price cuts went through. So, hey,
21:56 they may have the swing right companies
21:58 finding other ways to boost
21:59 [clears throat] revenues as it cuts base
22:01 prices like adding search charges. It's
22:04 actually speed search charges and lower
22:06 prices might be encouraging more overall
22:08 use of claw. Still, I'm going to watch
22:10 the next few months closely to see how
22:11 these price cuts impact the business.
22:14 Now, the next question, what's the next
22:17 big use case going to be? I've told you
22:21 that the extreme growth for Anthropic
22:24 recently has come from primarily code,
22:26 Claude Code, okay, the company's coding
22:29 agent gaining traction in the
22:31 enterprise. And I still think Claude
22:32 Code has plenty of growth ahead, but for
22:36 Anthropic's revenue to reach the levels
22:38 it needs to, and there's some incredible
22:39 levels that they got to reach, I want to
22:41 see more hit products from the company.
22:44 Anthropic debuted the next major
22:45 product, Claude Co-work, earlier this
22:47 year, and they offer some compelling
22:49 stats about re about revenue ramping for
22:52 co-work much more quickly than it did
22:54 for Claude Code. They also rolled the
22:56 out the industry specific tools and just
22:59 this week Anthropic announced some new
23:01 products that intend to take on
23:02 Microsoft Office. Hey, maybe those catch
23:05 on. But what are the use cases that are
23:07 going to lead to the next 100 billion in
23:09 revenue for Anthropic? It might be cyber
23:12 security given how good Claude is at
23:14 spotting code vulnerabilities. Anthropic
23:16 also says that life sciences and
23:17 robotics could be major end markets, but
23:20 we'll have to see if those things pan
23:22 out as well as they expect them to.
23:25 Finally, for the unknowns, how is
23:27 anthropics safety ethos going to impact
23:30 the story? Anthropic CEO Dario Amade
23:34 loves to remind everyone periodically
23:36 about how dangerous frontier AI models
23:38 can be. If he is serious about pacing
23:41 the frontier, is that negative for
23:43 revenue growth? But Anthropic has also
23:45 built its brand about around safety. And
23:47 perhaps that's an asset in a world where
23:49 customers are both eager to adopt AI for
23:51 their business and somewhat wary of it.
23:53 I don't know, a little contradictory to
23:54 me though. The that leads directly to my
23:58 first con. Remember I did the pros.
24:00 Here's the cons, which is the question
24:02 of regulation, even potential liability.
24:03 On the regulatory front, we've already
24:05 seen this year that a new precedent has
24:07 been set where the leading AI labs have
24:10 to work with the government before
24:11 releasing new frontier models. And after
24:14 last year's election, I also wonder
24:16 whether more Democrats in Washington is
24:18 a bad thing for the AI industry. Soon,
24:20 we'll look to 2028 and speculate about
24:23 what a new less AI friendly
24:26 administration really might mean. For
24:28 now, I just worry that there will be
24:30 more regulatory constraints for the
24:31 company either at the infrastructure
24:33 level or at its for its more powerful
24:35 new models. As for liabilities,
24:38 I see here uh there's some issues either
24:42 that an anthropic model is used for some
24:44 major cyber attack and that creates
24:47 legal risk for the company or as the
24:50 company's models get increasingly
24:51 autonomous. They do something they
24:53 shouldn't which negatively impacts the
24:54 customer. Now, I'll add here that I
24:56 think these regulatory and liability
24:58 risks are more of a concern for OpenAI
25:00 than they are for philanthropic given
25:01 the latter safety first culture, but
25:03 they are still risk you need to consider
25:05 for this first major AI IPO. Finally, I
25:09 want to talk about the company's float
25:10 and you got to pay attention. This is
25:12 the biggest issue for me. Uh the float
25:14 and its lockup expiration schedule.
25:17 Important details that will go a long
25:18 way determining how the stock trades
25:21 initially based on the current numbers.
25:24 Next week's offering represents around
25:26 6% of anthropic shares outstanding. Very
25:28 similar proportion to what we saw from
25:30 SpaceX in June. The one difference here
25:32 is that a trunch of shares from
25:34 nonfounder employees will be unlocked on
25:37 the first day of trading. That would
25:38 bring Anthropics float up to around 7%
25:40 on the first day of trading,
25:43 but that's still very small. The rest of
25:46 the shares will be unlocked gradually
25:47 over the course of the next year via a
25:50 series of 22 different lockup releases
25:53 which start less than a month after the
25:55 IPO. The concern here is that we will
25:56 see a big pop initially as excited
25:58 investors are competing for a small
26:00 number of shares. Then as more shares
26:02 get unlocked every few weeks that's
26:04 going to put downward pressure on
26:06 entropic the people who are too eager
26:08 they get hurt. Basically, I fear that
26:10 we're going to see a repeat of what
26:11 happened with SpaceX where the stock
26:12 squeezed from its IPO of 27.35 to a high
26:15 of $225 on its third day of trading,
26:18 then came right back down. SpaceX hasn't
26:21 come close to that initial high since
26:22 then, but not because the story hasn't
26:25 gotten better. I'd argue it has. It's
26:27 just supply and demand. Unfortunately,
26:28 as I told you last Friday, there's still
26:30 many more SpaceX shares that have yet to
26:32 be unlocked. So, there you go. There are
26:34 all kinds of unique considerations for
26:36 this anthropic deal. Some are positive,
26:38 some are negative, and some are
26:39 legitimate open questions, just things
26:41 I'm not sure about. I'll have more on
26:43 the deal next week, of course. But for
26:45 now, I hope this series that we have run
26:49 has you feeling more informed about
26:51 whether to participate in this historic
26:53 IPO. Here's the bottom line. When the
26:55 deal terms are finalized next week, I'm
26:57 going to give you my more formal opinion
26:59 on whether you should buy anthropic
27:01 shares initially or not. For now, I'll
27:03 just tell you that I'm wary of doing so.
27:06 Why? Well, because I I fear a hot open.
27:09 But either way, this is the deal to
27:11 watch. Let's take some calls. Let's go
27:14 to Mark in Michigan. Mark,
27:17 >> Mr. Kramer, it's an honor to speak with
27:19 you, sir.
27:20 >> Oh, thank you, Mark. What's happening?
27:23 >> Well, I've heard you talk a lot about
27:24 lamb research and I'm wondering if at
27:26 this point it's a good entry point.
27:28 >> I think it is. I think it's come down
27:30 enough. I think Tim Archer does a
27:31 terrific job. It is absolutely my
27:32 favorite. Remember all the intellectual
27:34 property when it comes to semiconductors
27:36 really is from the semiconductor capital
27:37 equipment and Lamb's got the best. All
27:39 right, much more mad money ahead
27:41 including my exclusive with Mona.
27:43 [music] Then like I said earlier, I am
27:45 deeply saddened by the news out of
27:46 Nvidia. I'm leaving you with [music] a
27:48 few more thoughts, some a degree costic
27:52 about the situation and oil falls rapid
27:54 fire in tonight's edition of the
27:55 lightning round. So stay [music] with
28:02 >> [music]
28:07 >> Well, you look at the stock of Maderna
28:08 go on August 18th, Madna was a $63
28:11 stock. The next day, it closed above 174
28:15 after Mona and Merc announced that
28:18 adding their personalized cancer shot to
28:20 Merc's Kruda helped keep melanoma from
28:23 coming back after surgery. Merna is now
28:25 up more than 680% for 2026. It did fall
28:29 7% today though. Last week, strong
28:31 vaccine sales helped MONA turn a
28:33 surprise profit and the company raised
28:36 its fullear sales forecast. Today, Mona
28:38 held this analyst day at the
28:40 Massachusetts plant that's already
28:41 making those personalized shots for
28:43 clinical trials. Earlier today, we
28:45 caught up with Stefan Vansel, Merna CEO.
28:49 Take a look.
28:52 Stefan, welcome to the show on a very
28:54 big day for you.
28:57 Yeah, thank you Jim for having me.
28:58 >> Well, I've got to tell you, I've been
29:00 following your progress and first I I
29:02 want to just cover the numbers. You're m
29:04 you're doing so much better. You've got
29:06 a the best flu shot that I can tell.
29:08 You're doing uh co vaccines. People are
29:10 telling me they're the ones that don't
29:12 hurt and don't make you sick. So, you've
29:14 done some traditional things that are
29:15 really just making you a lot of money.
29:18 Correct.
29:20 >> Yeah. I mean, we have really invested on
29:21 our infectious disease business. You
29:23 know, historically that's why we started
29:25 our first product, but we never slept on
29:27 our laurels. You know, the MXP spike
29:29 product, which is the new COVID vaccine,
29:31 is not only new because of a strain,
29:33 which of course we have to do to give
29:34 you the best protection, but we totally
29:37 re-engineered the product. It's a new
29:38 product, like a 2.0 COVID shot, and the
29:41 dose is 1/5if of a dose of what we had
29:44 initially. So, that's why the side
29:45 effect is much better.
29:46 >> All right, that's the one I've got to
29:48 get. Now, I I just want to I usually
29:50 don't do this, but I want to get
29:52 personal for a second. My daughter had
29:55 melanoma bad.
29:57 >> Oh, I'm sorry.
29:57 >> No, but listen. Listen. Your hope
30:02 is that your vaccine can make it so she
30:05 can go back outside and lead a normal
30:08 life and perhaps have a greater chance
30:11 of it being cut back. So we're following
30:14 this thing intensely with everything
30:16 that I can't read the journal and newing
30:18 journal and understand but can you tell
30:20 us where this is because you are the
30:22 hope for tens of thousands of people.
30:26 Oh you're very kind. Well as you know
30:28 we've been working on 10 years on this
30:30 idea of can you teach the immune system
30:33 of a patient
30:35 how to recognize the cancer of a patient
30:37 and to go eat the cancer. That was the
30:39 basic idea and as you I'm sure read a
30:42 lot of people thought it was undoable
30:44 and it's true that the track record of
30:46 cancer vaccine behind us was not very
30:48 good but we thought with a progress with
30:51 made in MRA with what we learned with
30:53 infectious disease vaccine that our
30:55 approach had a serious chance and we
30:57 took that chance and to be fair MC was a
31:00 fantastic partner to take that chance
31:02 and that risk with us and what it does
31:04 basically is when somebody has cancer
31:07 you take a biopsy of a tumor. You take a
31:10 blood draw of a blood and then you
31:13 sequence you next gen sequence. You read
31:14 all the letters of the DNA of a cancer
31:16 and the healthy cell. You send them to
31:18 the cloud and you compare letter by
31:20 letter where is the mutation where is
31:22 the cancer because what we know today is
31:24 cancer is a disease of DNA mutation of
31:28 DNA and then what we do is we
31:30 individualize and I'm just behind me. We
31:32 basically individualize we make a
31:34 product for one human at a time where we
31:36 put in a cassette of one mRNA molecule
31:39 34 mutation of cancer of that patient.
31:43 It's injected in intramuscular every 3
31:45 weeks for nine doors and as you know you
31:48 saw the data recently the data are
31:50 fantastic. I mean compared to ketra
31:52 which is an amazing drug in melanoma
31:54 nobody has been able since 2018 to do
31:57 better than than kitra in melanoma.
31:59 Several companies tried there was three
32:01 phase three that failed but we were able
32:04 to show a 42% improvement for patient
32:07 and what is even more remarkable if you
32:09 look at a phase two study where we have
32:11 five years of data the phase three had
32:13 only two years of data so far we'll of
32:15 course share more data as we get the
32:17 data we show that the data improves over
32:19 time why because the T- cell we created
32:22 in your body because of our mRNA have
32:25 memory
32:26 >> they stay with you to fight cancer
32:28 coming back
32:29 >> wow Well, uh dare I ask when? Uh we're
32:34 all waiting. Uh we have oncologists that
32:37 we check with. They want to be sure that
32:39 things are right before we plunge in.
32:42 When do you think?
32:44 So, as we've said with our partners at
32:46 Mercer, we are working very very
32:48 deliberately to try to get the filing to
32:51 the FDA before the end of the year and
32:53 then we're expecting assuming a good
32:56 review by the regulators that we should
32:58 be able to get the product available to
33:01 Americans.
33:01 >> Well, I'm so glad. I mean, I think if
33:03 you don't have it or you don't even
33:04 look, you can go to the Reddit page for
33:06 the melanomies. You can feel for what
33:08 people have. But as a parent and the
33:10 daughter, we are I never create false
33:13 hopes for for cancer. Lost my mom for
33:16 kidney cancer very very young. I know
33:18 that those who create false hopes are
33:20 not good. You have done the opposite.
33:22 You've not played it high. You have
33:25 waited and waited. How about other
33:27 cancers? Are there hopes for it without
33:30 getting too far ahead and making feel
33:33 people feel that there's a a magic
33:35 bullet out there? Sure. And I agree with
33:38 you Jim. It's very important people are
33:40 suffering with cancer. It's very
33:42 important for them and the family not to
33:43 have false hope. So what we're doing
33:46 beyond melanoma is we have studies on
33:48 going in five different tumor types
33:50 including lung cancer. In lung we're
33:53 both looking at people that have stage
33:55 two or three of lung disease. But we're
33:57 also trying in tisaran. That's the name
34:00 of our medicine in tisaran by itself in
34:03 people that have stage one lung cancer
34:06 because we think given it has a very
34:08 good safety profile our medicine it
34:10 could potentially be used earlier in
34:12 disease to help people get back to a
34:14 normal life without sometime the
34:15 terrible side effect of cancer
34:17 treatment. So we should get data in
34:20 kidney cancer pretty soon either end of
34:23 this year or next year. Those are
34:25 eventdriven studies when people have
34:27 recurrence of disease. So of course we
34:29 do not control the timing. The one after
34:31 should be bladder cancer and the one
34:33 after should be lung. So when we have a
34:35 data like we've always done we will
34:37 share the data with the community
34:38 including the medical community so we
34:40 can review the data. Last night the New
34:43 England Journal of Medicine as you know
34:44 the most prestigious journal release the
34:47 full data set with all the appendix so
34:49 all the melanoma doctors can look at the
34:52 data and understand what the product can
34:54 do and what the product doesn't do. And
34:56 that's where we are and we're going to
34:58 keep investing in the science because as
35:00 you know software is part of drug
35:02 because we have to select from hundreds
35:03 of thousands of mutation 34 that goes in
35:06 the cassette. We think we can learn by
35:09 going and mining the data in a phase
35:11 three study and figure out what can we
35:13 tweak in the software what was working
35:15 well in the software what maybe can we
35:18 improve so we can potentially even
35:19 improve that success rate. Again, it's
35:21 an hypothesis. We need to do the work
35:23 and look at the data. But I'm really
35:25 believing that because of the progress
35:27 that the medical field is making and
35:29 because of the access of AI, when we can
35:31 look at all those data, think about it,
35:34 a, 100 patients, that's a lot of data.
35:37 When you look at all the T- cell and the
35:40 biomarkers and so on, but looking at
35:42 that with big data, this should be able
35:44 to get insight and then to have a
35:46 discussion with the regulators. Is is
35:48 there a way to upgrade the software?
35:50 >> Well, look, congratulations and thank
35:52 you for helping everyone who has this
35:54 disease and their family members. Uh we
35:58 all look forward after that New England
36:00 Journal of Medicine to start getting
36:02 lined up and getting our doctors to be
36:04 aware. Uh remarkable job. I remember
36:06 when I met you, you said this could
36:08 happen and then we got way laid by CO of
36:10 which you helped solve. But uh this is
36:13 nothing short of remarkable and I want
36:15 to thank you uh for everything you've
36:17 done not just for the shareholders but
36:18 for the parents and for the patients.
36:20 Good to see you Stephan.
36:22 >> Thank you so much very kindly.
36:24 >> Absolutely. That's Stephan Benelli. He's
36:26 the Mona CEO at a remarkable moment
36:29 [music] and a great shareholder meeting.
36:31 >> Coming up you've got questions. Kramer's
36:34 got the answers. Get charged up for a
36:36 fast fire lightning round next.
36:43 >> [music]
36:47 >> It is time for the lightning round
36:53 [music]
36:57 and then the lightning round is over.
36:59 Are you ready?
37:01 Dick in Virginia. Dick.
37:04 >> Hi Jim. I'm a club member and I just got
37:07 your book in the mail. Yay.
37:09 >> Oh, thank you. Thank you. Let's go to
37:11 work.
37:12 >> Yeah, I I saw that stock. It said it's
37:16 called Comvault. They're in the [music]
37:18 data recovery business. Um any thoughts
37:22 on it?
37:23 >> I saw the CEO on [music] Dayside. That's
37:25 what we call the watching TV during the
37:28 daytime. And he was excellent. I thought
37:30 he did a very good job. I thought he
37:32 made a good good case for a stock even
37:33 though it's up a lot. I mean, it's good
37:34 good call by you, Jeffrey in
37:36 Massachusetts. Jeffrey,
37:39 >> what's up, my man? How are you on this
37:41 beautiful day?
37:41 >> I'm doing well, Chief. How about you?
37:43 Good to have you on the show.
37:44 >> Not too bad.
37:45 >> Excellent.
37:47 >> So, this stock I've got is down nearly
37:49 48% year to date. Bright Horizons, BFAM.
37:52 [music]
37:52 Fast thoughts?
37:53 >> Well, it's a very inexpensive stock, but
37:55 that typically means to me the earnings
37:56 aren't going to come through. I don't
37:58 want you to mess around with it. I don't
37:59 I'm not done. That's ridiculous. I feel
38:01 like I taken like one call. Let's go to
38:03 Dennis in New York. Dennis.
38:06 Dennis from Hampton Bay. Jim, big fan.
38:08 Thank you.
38:10 >> My executive producers from Hampton Bay.
38:11 I'm going to do a big shout out to her.
38:13 Regina, I'm sorry. [music] Go ahead.
38:16 >> Texas Pacific Land.
38:18 >> You know, I'm not really into the oil
38:19 stocks and we used Well, we made a big
38:21 deal about that stock when it was the
38:22 right time. And I'm glad we got off
38:24 [music] that horse. I'm going to say no
38:26 to Texas Pacific. And that lends up the
38:29 conclusion of the LIGHTNING ROUND.
38:34 THE LIGHTNING Round is sponsored by
38:36 Charles Schwab. [music]
38:38 Coming up, as we wrap up another busy
38:41 day, Kramer has some final thoughts.
38:43 Don't miss his No Huddle next.
38:49 >> Booyah, Jim. Your integrity makes you
38:52 the booyah Saint of Wall Street.
38:56 >> Booyah. Jimmy Chill.
38:57 >> Booyah. Jimmy Chill.
39:00 Booyah. Jim.
39:01 >> Quadruple. That's a lot of booas.
39:07 [music]
39:15 Look, uh, I'm sad. I did love the guy in
39:18 the leather jacket. I liked him from the
39:20 first time I interviewed him in 2010
39:21 when the stock was around 30 cents,
39:23 counting for the various splits over the
39:25 years. Called it a Kramer fave. I
39:27 continued to hear more and more about
39:28 the company in the years that followed,
39:30 including from the CEO of Audi North
39:31 America, who told me that Nvidia's chips
39:33 were the secret behind his self-driving
39:35 technology. At the time, everyone just
39:37 thought this was a gaming chip company.
39:39 In 2017, frustrated how people didn't
39:41 know about the company. I renamed my dog
39:44 Everest, changing it to Nvidia to call
39:47 attention to the incredible company that
39:49 Nvidia was. That late mut half pit bull
39:53 half whatever got a lot of people's
39:55 attention including Jensen. He made a
39:57 badge for Nvidia to get into
39:58 headquarters anytime he wanted to.
40:00 That's kind of that's Jensen's pixie
40:02 humor. Couple months later is when I
40:04 bought the stock for my chapel trust for
40:05 the first time. The stock was around
40:07 four bucks. But I only fully realized
40:09 how special this company was after I
40:11 spent some time at headquarters and saw
40:13 amazing things. And not just the
40:15 employee badge Jensen made for the dog.
40:17 Things like robots being rewarded for
40:19 picking up Jell-O. things like a machine
40:22 drawing a saison seascape in 10 seconds
40:24 when I knew he never painted one but I
40:26 asked the machine to do it anyway. The
40:28 colors were spot on shading amazing. I
40:30 talked about what I say at Nvidia and
40:32 almost at what I saw at Nvidia and
40:34 almost every day for weeks on this show
40:37 and on squawk on the street. You know,
40:39 at one point my partner David told me he
40:41 was sick of my touting Nvidia. I didn't
40:44 care. I kept doing it.
40:47 There were so many other things Jensen
40:49 showed me over the years, especially
40:50 when I started getting going to the
40:52 company's GTC event every year. Each
40:54 time I went out, I learned some new
40:56 things. Sometimes they were hysterical,
40:58 sometimes they were somber, but they
41:00 were always brilliant. He introduced me
41:02 to the Neoclouds like Anibius and I ran.
41:04 He made me realize that his partners
41:06 like Dell and HPE were obvious buys as
41:08 the AI era began. These stocks made
41:11 fortunes for people. I saw robots make
41:13 hospital corners, 10 bar, really super
41:15 stuff. His ke they were dazzling. But
41:18 one of the most meaningful things he did
41:19 was attend a lunch right here at the New
41:21 York Stock Exchange for CBC Investing
41:23 Club members. Most of whom had become
41:25 millionaires because they bought the
41:27 stock of Nvidia. We had 70 guests. I
41:29 wanted a group picture. He said no. He
41:31 wanted individual selfies with
41:33 individual people. Every one of them all
41:35 regular people like you club members who
41:37 believed. I saw his graciousness
41:39 repeatedly. I rejoiced in it. He was
41:42 always so polite and well-meaning. I
41:44 introduced my wife to him. He's one of
41:45 just a few execs in the 22 years I've
41:47 been doing this that I did that. She
41:49 thought he was terrific. He took her
41:51 seriously, asking plenty of questions
41:52 right in her eyes, looked at her,
41:54 showing amazing respect. She was
41:56 impressed. She thought he was
41:57 sensational. Over the last couple years,
41:59 I saw Jensen all over the place. I
42:01 thought he was kind of changing. He's
42:02 having a grand time. Why not? Seemingly
42:04 celebrating and ping around with the
42:05 president. As much as he was working,
42:07 although that was just an impression. At
42:10 one point, I saw him sign a woman's
42:11 shirt in a place that I thought was
42:12 inappropriate. Well, maybe that was the
42:14 new more successful cooler. Why not
42:16 Flora Jensen? But he was right back to
42:19 being serious at the next GTC in San
42:21 Jose.
42:22 At all times, I admit I was thrilled to
42:24 spend time with him. Just thrilled. You
42:26 know, I tried not to idolize him for his
42:28 brilliance. I tried not to put him on a
42:30 pedestal for spectacular innovations.
42:32 And I defended everything, including his
42:34 push to sell previous generation chips
42:36 to Chinese customers because I thought
42:37 he was earnest when he said it was in
42:39 the best interest of our country to hook
42:41 Chinese customers on the Nvidia
42:42 ecosystem rather than have them build
42:44 their own. I still do. Never once did I
42:47 think that there might be other
42:49 motivations, and I still really hope
42:50 that's not the case. In the end, unlike
42:53 so many others, I wanted everything
42:54 negative said about him stopped. At the
42:57 very least, give him a chance to
42:58 explain. Don't take this fine man apart.
43:00 He's too important to our nation's
43:02 future. His body of work was too
43:04 stellar. We can't afford to lose him if
43:06 we are going to be the world's AI
43:07 leader.
43:09 But it was not to be. The man in the
43:12 leather jacket let his wife down. He let
43:15 his kids down. He let his company down.
43:18 He let his co-workers down. He let his
43:20 shareholders down. He let his country
43:22 down. Sadly, he let me, a person who
43:26 just loved the guy down. My dog Invidia
43:29 died a half dozen years ago. Come to
43:31 think of it, maybe he was the only one
43:34 who didn't get let down by the man in
43:36 the leather jacket. He just didn't live
43:39 long enough to see it.
43:41 I like to say that there's always a
43:43 market somewhere, and I promise I find
43:44 it just for you right here on Mad Money.
43:46 [music] I'm Jim Kramer. See you next
43:48 time.
43:51 >> [music]
43:51 >> All opinions expressed by Jim Kramer on
43:53 this podcast are solely Kramer's
43:54 opinions and do not reflect the opinions
43:56 of CNBC or its parent company or
43:58 affiliates and may have been previously
43:59 disseminated by Kramer on television,
44:00 radio, internet, or another medium. You
44:02 should not treat any opinion expressed
44:04 by Kramer as a specific inducement to
44:05 make a particular investment or follow a
44:07 particular strategy, but only as an
44:09 expression of his opinion. Kramer's
44:10 opinions are based upon information he
44:12 considers reliable. But neither CNBC nor
44:14 its affiliates or subsidiaries warrant
44:15 its completeness or accuracy, and it
44:17 should not be relied upon as such. To
44:19 view the full MadMoney disclaimer,
44:20 please visit cnbc.com/madmoney
44:22 disclaimer.
Nvidia’s financing web raises new risks after Jensen Huang’s exit full transcript
0:00 The resignation of Nvidia
0:00 founder and CEO Jensen Huang
0:05 sets up a test for the US economy.
0:07 Jensen Huang was a co-founder of this company,
0:10 has been the only CEO to ever lead this company,
0:13 and the stock has suffered greatly over the
0:16 course of this last week.
0:17 California-based chip maker Nvidia is at the heart of
0:20 the AI boom. Reports of CEO Jensen Huang's affair with a
0:25 woman allegedly recruited by Chinese intelligence agents
0:28 added to a sour month for the broader technology
0:31 sector. In the months leading up to this moment,
0:35 central bankers and regulators began to openly
0:37 wonder: is the AI industry becoming too big to fail?
0:46 Nvidia has an estimated $400 billion in commitments to
0:51 various companies within the AI ecosystem.
0:54 The beneficiaries include frontier AI labs,
0:58 private equity firms, banks,
1:00 and cloud computing providers.
1:02 Take, for example, the frontier AI labs.
1:05 These are companies that build large language models.
1:09 Those LLMs rely on Nvidia's graphics processing units to
1:13 run the massive sets of calculations that deliver
1:16 artificial intelligence.
1:19 In August, Huang estimated that an AI agent could use
1:22 15 to 100 times more computing power than a
1:26 typical human user.
1:27 Estimates like that have led to a rush of financing,
1:31 permitting, and construction of new data centers.
1:34 Nvidia in August told investors that it's put
1:38 nearly $50 billion into these frontier labs to
1:41 assist with further AI infrastructure projects.
1:44 Nvidia also partnered with major asset managers
1:47 including Apollo, BlackRock and Brookfield,
1:50 in a bid to raise up to $500 billion in financing for
1:54 further infrastructure buildouts.
1:57 Nvidia has disclosed guarantee arrangements with
2:00 OpenAI, but hasn't named other labs in a public
2:03 capacity. However, the company acknowledged
2:06 that virtually all the major closed models rely on Nvidia
2:10 hardware. Nvidia is also backstopping some $36
2:15 billion in cloud computing operations,
2:17 also known as neocloud's.
2:19 Nvidia didn't name its specific partners,
2:22 but some neocloud's, including CoreWeave and
2:25 Iren, have separately disclosed their
2:27 relationships with Nvidia.
2:30 In relevant partnerships, Nvidia creates agreements
2:33 that give lenders the confidence to
2:35 underwrite the project.
2:36 They have been a great partner for us for years
2:39 that they will continue to be a great partner for us.
2:43 Bank regulators don't believe that this moment for
2:46 Jensen Huang or Nvidia resembles anything like a
2:49 re-run of the 2007-2008 financial crisis.
2:54 But if things do turn out the worst for Nvidia,
Nvidia needs an outside CEO fast, says D.A. Davidson's Gil Luria full transcript
0:00 IT'S A DISASTER. SO I THINK WE
0:01 ALL SHOULD JUST TAKE A
0:03 COLLECTIVE BK AND BRIAN DNN DAN,
0:05 TIM AND I ARE FINE AND LET'S
0:06 JUST GET ON WITH IT. BACK TO
0:08 YOU.
0:09 >> ALL RIGHT. WELL LET'S GET ON
0:10 WITH MORE ON NVIDIA AND THE
0:12 FALLOUT THERE. DA DAVIDSON HEAD
0:13 OF TECH RESEARCH GILL LORIA. HE
0:15 JUST REITERATED A BUY RATING ON
0:16 NVIDIA, CUT HIS PRICE TARGET TO
0:18 $200, DOWN FROM 300. GILL GREAT
0:20 TO SEE YOU. GOOD TO SEE YOU. SO
0:22 YOU'RE STILL TELLING PEOPLE TO
0:23 BUY THIS STOCK. WHAT DO YOU
0:26 WHAT DO YOU SEE AS THE PATH
0:28 FORWARD HERE. I MEAN AS
0:29 JEN-HSUN HUANG HEADS UP TO THE
0:30 HILL BEFORE THANKSGIVING,
0:32 NVIDIA IS IN THE CROSSHAIRS OF
0:33 I DON'T KNOW HOW MANY
0:35 CONGRESSIONAL COMMITTEES AT
0:36 THIS POINT. WE DON'T KNOW WHAT
0:37 KIND OF PENALTIES THE COMPANY
0:39 MIGHT FACE FOR VIOLATIONS,
0:42 POTENTIAL VIOLATIONS OF
0:43 NATIONAL SECURITY. WE DON'T
0:44 KNOW IF ASIA SHOULD BE
0:45 COMPLETELY COUNTED OUT OF ITS
0:47 MODEL. WHAT DO YOU SEE?
0:51 >> THE PROBABILITY WEIGHT OF
0:53 OUTCOMES IS STILL THAT THEY ARE
0:54 ABLE TO DELIVER THE NUMBERS FOR
0:56 NEXT YEAR, AT WHICH POINT THE
0:57 STOCK WILL BE HIGHER. EVEN IF
1:00 THERE WAS WRONGDOING. EVEN IF
1:01 THEY HAVE TO LIMIT THEIR SALES
1:03 TO ASIA, THEY COULD PROBABLY
1:04 STILL SELL ALL THE CHIPS THEY
1:06 WERE PLANNING TO SELL NEXT YEAR
1:07 AND AND GET TO THOSE SAME
1:09 NUMBERS. THAT DOESN'T MEAN THIS
1:11 ISN'T A RISK. AS YOU'VE TALKED
1:12 ABOUT, THERE COULD STILL BE A
1:14 LOT OF BAD THINGS THAT HAPPENED.
1:16 AND THAT'S THE PRIMARY RISK, IS
1:18 THAT THEIR SALES INTO ASIA ARE
1:20 MORE LIMITED. SO NVIDIA SHOULD
1:23 STILL GO UP NEXT YEAR. THAT'S
1:24 WHY WE KEPT THE BUY. BUT WE
1:27 DEPRIORITIZED IT. AMD BROADCOM
1:29 AND MICRON ARE PROBABLY A
1:31 BETTER WAY TO PLAY THAT SAME
1:33 TREND OF GROWING AI DEMAND.
1:35 THAT WILL TRANSLATE TO MORE
1:36 DATA CENTER BUILD OUT.
1:38 >> GIL THAT'S THAT'S WHERE I
1:38 WANTED TO GO BECAUSE AMD NOW
1:40 TRADES AROUND 60 TIMES FORWARD.
1:42 YOU KNOW, I DON'T KNOW WHERE
1:43 YOUR NUMBERS ARE HERE, BUT BUT
1:45 WE WERE JUST HAVING A
1:46 DISCUSSION ABOUT IS THIS REALLY
1:48 A SUBSTITUTION EFFECT? AND
1:50 HAVEN'T THESE STOCKS PRICED IN
1:51 MAYBE MORE OF THAT IN THE SHORT
1:53 TERM? IN A WORLD WHERE THEY
1:54 WERE DOING EVERYTHING THEY
1:55 COULD DO YESTERDAY?
1:57 >> YEAH. SO AMD IS THE PRICIEST
1:58 OF THE THREE. BUT IF YOU LOOK
2:00 AT BROADCOM AND MICRON THEY'RE
2:01 STILL TRADING AT A MUCH LOWER
2:03 MULTIPLE. AND THEY WILL
2:05 PARTICIPATE IN THE DATA CENTER
2:06 BUILD OUT. REALLY YOU ADD AMD
2:08 TO THAT MIX TO RECONSTRUCT WHAT
2:11 NVIDIA DOES TO THE MARKET.
2:12 NVIDIA IS THE BIGGEST PROFIT
2:13 POOL. BUT IF YOU ADD THE OTHER
2:15 THREE YOU CAN REPLICATE THAT
2:17 PROFIT POOL AND THE BLENDED
2:19 MULTIPLES STILL LOWER THAN THE
2:20 MARKET MULTIPLE. BUT CLEARLY
2:21 AMD IS THE PRICIEST. IT'S
2:23 BECAUSE THEY'VE EXECUTED SO
2:24 WELL AND THERE'S UPSIDE TO
2:25 NUMBERS. BUT BROADCOM AND
2:27 MICRON STILL TRADING AT A BELOW
2:29 MARKET MULTIPLE OR A SINGLE
2:31 DIGIT MULTIPLE IN THE CASE OF
2:32 MICRON. AND THEY'RE GOING TO
2:34 PARTICIPATE REGARDLESS OF WHAT
2:35 HAPPENS TO NVIDIA. THEY'RE A
2:37 BETTER WAY TO PLAY THIS TREND
2:39 RIGHT NOW.
2:39 >> GIL HOW IMPORTANT IS THE
2:40 QUARTER NOW TIM BROUGHT UP
2:42 EARLIER THAT YOU KNOW A LOT OF
2:43 MAYBE WE WOULD BE HERE
2:45 REGARDLESS IF THE QUARTER WAS.
2:46 BUT IS THERE GOING TO BE THERE
2:48 HAS TO BE. I WOULD THINK AN
2:50 ADDED LEVEL OF SCRUTINY GIVEN
2:51 THE QUARTER THEY'RE GOING TO
2:52 REPORT NEXT WEEK. SO THE
2:53 QUESTION IS, IS THIS THE MOST
2:55 IMPORTANT QUARTER WE'VE SEEN IN
2:56 QUITE SOME TIME OUT OF NVIDIA?
2:58 >> ABSOLUTELY. THERE IS NO WAY
2:59 THEY CAN MISS IF THEY MISS
3:01 THERE'S ANOTHER BIG LEG DOWN.
3:03 SO THEY THEY HAVE TO SHOW UP.
3:05 THEY HAVE TO MAKE THE NUMBERS.
3:07 THEY HAVE TO REITERATE THE
3:08 GUIDANCE INCLUDING INTO NEXT
3:09 YEAR. THEY HAVE TO WAIT. THEY
3:10 HAVE TO FIND A WAY TO MAKE THAT
3:12 NUMBER. AND THEY HAVE TO
3:14 COMMUNICATE A VERY CLEAR PLAN
3:15 FOR REPLACING THE CEO. THAT'S
3:16 GOING TO BE REALLY THE KEY ITEM
3:18 RIGHT NOW. THEY CAN'T LET THIS
3:20 DRAG OUT. THEY NEED TO FIND THE
3:22 RIGHT CANDIDATE. WE THINK
3:23 THERE'S SOME REALLY GOOD
3:24 CANDIDATES OUT THERE. IT HAS TO
3:26 BE SOMEBODY EXTERNAL YOU, AS
3:28 YOU TALKED ABOUT IN THE PANEL,
3:30 IF SOMETHING IF THERE WAS
3:31 WRONGDOING, EVERYBODY
3:33 INTERNALLY AT NVIDIA IS
3:34 IMPLICATED. YOU CAN'T FIND
3:35 SOMEBODY INTERNALLY TO TAKE THE
3:37 ROLE RIGHT NOW, BECAUSE YOU MAY
3:38 HAVE TO MOVE ON FROM THEM. AS
3:40 SOON AS THE INVESTIGATION IS
3:41 DONE. IT HAS TO.
3:42 >> BE SOMEBODY, THOUGH, STILL.
3:43 >> I MEAN, I'M JUST WONDERING,
3:45 YOU KNOW, DO YOU THINK THERE'S
3:47 A POSSIBILITY THAT THAT'S WHAT
3:48 IT IS? I MEAN, JEN-HSUN HUANG
3:50 IS NOT THE ONLY ONE SHIPPING
3:52 THOSE CHIPS TO SHELL COMPANIES
3:53 IN SINGAPORE AND MALAYSIA. I
3:55 MEAN, HE'S NOT ACTUALLY PACKING
3:56 THE CHIPS. I MEAN, THERE ARE A
3:58 LOT OF LAYERS THERE, TOO, IN
3:59 TERMS OF PEOPLE WHO MUST HAVE
4:01 KNOWN WHAT WAS GOING ON.
4:02 >> THAT'S RIGHT. SO YOU NEED
4:04 SOMEBODY FROM THE OUTSIDE. LET
4:05 ME GIVE YOU MY FAVORITE
4:06 CANDIDATE, THE ONLY CANDIDATE
4:07 THAT I THINK IS A CLEAN
4:09 CANDIDACY. THAT'S JOHNY SROUJI
4:10 FROM APPLE, THE PERSON WHO WAS
4:12 A CEO CANDIDATE REPLACED JOHN
4:14 TURNER WHEN JOHN TURNER BECAME
4:16 CEO. HE'S BUILT HIS LIFE AROUND
4:18 CHIPS. HE'S BEEN IN THE CHIP
4:19 INDUSTRY, AND HE COMES FROM
4:21 THIS VERY CLEAN STORY. CLEARLY,
4:23 HE HAS CEO AMBITIONS AND HE'S
4:25 READY TO GO. IF I WAS THE BOARD,
4:27 I WOULD GET HIM HIRED RIGHT
4:29 AWAY. SO THERE'S NO TRANSITION
4:31 PERIOD. SO SOMEBODY CAN COME IN
4:32 AND REBUILD THE COMPANY WITHOUT
4:34 ALL THE PEOPLE THAT COULD BE
4:36 IMPLICATED, WITHOUT HAVING 60
4:37 DIRECT REPORTS IN A MANNER THAT
4:40 NVIDIA CAN MOVE FORWARD. NVIDIA
4:41 STILL HAS THE BEST PRODUCTS OUT
4:42 THERE. THAT'S NOT GOING TO
4:43 CHANGE. THEY'RE NOT TO THE
4:45 POINT YOU MADE IN THE PANEL.
4:46 THEY'RE NOT LOSING SHARE IN THE
4:48 NEXT 12 MONTHS TO AMD AND
4:49 BROADCOM. THAT'S NOT WHAT'S
4:50 GOING TO HAPPEN. THEIR PRODUCT
4:52 IS STILL THE MOST
AllianceBernstein's Nelson Yu: Nvidia's concentration was a warning sign full transcript
0:09 >> WELCOME BACK. THE TECH
0:10 SECTOR LOWERED TODAY, BUT ONE
0:11 OF THE TOP PERFORMERS ON THE
0:13 WEEK IS THE NVIDIA SCANDAL,
0:14 OVERSHADOWING A DURABLE BOUNCE
0:15 BACK IN THE AI TRADE. JOINING
0:16 US NOW IS NELSON YU. HE IS HEAD
0:18 OF EQUITIES AT
0:19 ALLIANCEBERNSTEIN NELSON GREAT
0:20 TO HAVE YOU WITH US.
0:21 >> THANK YOU FOR HAVING ME ON.
0:23 >> I WANT TO ASK YOU TO OPINE
0:25 ABOUT NVIDIA AND WHAT HAPPENS
0:26 THERE. BUT IN TERMS OF THE
0:28 IMPACT ON THE AI TRADE, HOW DO
0:29 YOU VIEW THIS. BECAUSE WHAT WE
0:31 SAW THIS WEEK WAS, YOU KNOW
0:32 NVIDIA'S MARKET CAP GOES TO AMD
0:34 AND BROADCOM. THAT'S RIGHT. BUT
0:35 LONGER TERM WHAT WILL WE SEE.
0:37 >> YOU KNOW I THINK. TODAY AND
0:38 THIS WEEK HAS BEEN REALLY GOOD
0:40 REMINDER OF THE IMPORTANCE OF
0:41 TWO THINGS. ONE IS CORPORATE
0:43 RESEARCH AND BOTTOM UP COMPANY
0:45 RESEARCH AND ALSO THE IMPACT OF
0:47 DIVERSIFICATION. I MEAN YOU
0:48 TALKED ABOUT NVIDIA JUST A
0:50 MONTH AGO. NVIDIA WAS OVER 8%
0:52 OF THE OF THE S&P 500. AND NOW
0:54 IT'S AT 6%. AND SO JUST PUTTING
0:57 ALL YOUR SO MUCH OF YOUR EGGS
0:58 INTO THAT ONE BASKET CAN REALLY
1:00 HURT YOUR PORTFOLIO. BUT THE
1:02 SECOND PART IS IF YOU THINK
1:04 ABOUT COMPANY RESEARCH, IT'S SO
1:06 IMPORTANT TO BE DOING THAT
1:07 CORPORATE GOVERNANCE RESEARCH,
1:08 REALLY THINKING ABOUT THE
1:10 STRENGTH OF MANAGEMENT, REALLY
1:11 THINKING ABOUT THE CREDIBILITY
1:12 OF SUCCESSION PLANS. THIS IS
1:13 STUFF THAT WE THINK ABOUT ALL
1:15 THE TIME FOR ALL OF OUR
1:16 COMPANIES.
1:16 >> SO YOU THINK THAT NVIDIA
1:19 WOULD HAVE BEEN KIND OF A
1:20 YELLOW FLAG JUST ON THAT BASIS
1:22 A MONTH AGO?
1:23 >> THE NVIDIA WAS A VERY HIGH
1:25 QUALITY COMPANY. YEAH. RIGHT.
1:26 IT WAS GENERATING LOTS OF
1:27 PROFITS. CASH FLOWS WERE REALLY
1:30 STRONG. THE QUESTION WAS ABOUT
1:31 THE FINANCING AND THE CIRCULAR
1:32 FINANCING. BUT WE WERE REALLY
1:35 WORRIED ABOUT CONCENTRATION.
1:36 AND THAT WAS SOMETHING THAT I
1:38 THINK HAS BEEN, YOU KNOW,
1:40 REALLY HAS COME THROUGH. YOU
1:42 KNOW, WE TALKED ABOUT, YOU KNOW,
1:42 AND YOUR QUESTION WAS AROUND
1:44 THE AI TRADE. I THINK ACTUALLY,
1:45 IF YOU THINK ABOUT HOW HOW MUCH
1:49 CONCENTRATION WAS IN THAT AI
1:51 TRADE, INDEXES WERE MOVING IN
1:52 PERFECT CORRELATION TO WHATEVER
1:54 AI WAS DOING THAT DAY. AND I
1:56 THINK IT'S SO IMPORTANT FOR
1:57 INVESTORS TO THINK BEYOND THIS
1:58 TRADE, RIGHT?
1:59 >> BUT WHEN YOU'RE TALKING
2:00 ABOUT CORPORATE GOVERNANCE, IT
2:01 ALMOST MAKES IT SEEM LIKE
2:03 EVERYBODY SHOULD HAVE BEEN
2:04 SHOULD HAVE KNOWN THAT THIS
2:06 COULD HAVE HAPPENED OR THAT THE,
2:07 YOU KNOW, THE OUTCOME OF
2:08 JEN-HSUN HUANG LEAVING WOULD
2:09 HAVE BEEN REALLY DETRIMENTAL TO
2:10 THE COMPANY BECAUSE OF THE WAY
2:12 THE BOARD WAS, BECAUSE OF THE
2:13 FLAT MANAGEMENT STRUCTURE, ETC.
2:14 BUT YET IT DIDN'T DIDN'T SOUND
2:16 ANY ALARMS. MAYBE IT'S ALMOST A
2:19 SHAME ON ALL OF US FOR NOT
2:20 SEEING THAT. I MEAN, DO YOU SEE,
2:22 DO YOU FEEL THAT A LITTLE BIT,
2:24 BECAUSE I WOULD IMAGINE THAT
2:25 YOUR FUND STILL HELD NVIDIA AT
2:27 LEAST MARKET WEIGHT AND THAT
2:28 THERE WASN'T AN ISSUE ON THAT
2:29 FRONT?
2:29 >> WELL, I WOULD SAY IT IS A
2:32 FLAG THAT WE GO THROUGH WHEN WE
2:33 WHEN WE TALK ABOUT OUR
2:35 CORPORATE RESEARCH AND WE THINK
2:37 ABOUT, WELL, WHAT'S THE QUALITY
2:38 OF THE CASH FLOWS? WHAT'S THE
2:39 QUALITY OF THE BALANCE SHEET?
2:41 WHAT'S THE QUALITY OF
2:41 MANAGEMENT? AND THESE ARE
2:42 THINGS THAT WE CHECK THROUGH.
2:44 NVIDIA WOULDN'T HAVE GOTTEN
2:45 FULL MARKS BECAUSE OF THAT.
2:46 >> WHERE IS THE WORK TAKING YOU
2:49 BOTTOM UP AT THIS POINT IN
2:50 TERMS OF OUTSIDE THE AI TRADE?
2:53 WHAT SEEMS TO MAKE SENSE? HOW
2:54 MUCH OF IT IS DEPENDENT ON, YOU
2:56 KNOW, THE MACRO ENVIRONMENT
2:57 INTO NEXT YEAR AND HOW MUCH OF
2:59 IT IS IS, YOU KNOW, IS NOT.
3:01 >> SO I THINK, YOU KNOW, BEFORE
3:02 WE GO INTO THAT, I THINK IT'S
3:04 REALLY IMPORTANT TO SET UP
3:05 WHAT'S THE BACKDROP? WE'VE GOT
3:07 A BACKDROP WHERE A LOT OF
3:08 GROWTH HAS BEEN DRIVEN BY AI.
3:10 SO YOU REALLY NEED TO HAVE
3:11 THINGS THAT CAN GROW
3:12 INDEPENDENTLY OF AI. THE SECOND
3:14 PART IS YOU ARE IN A HIGHER
3:16 COST OF CAPITAL ENVIRONMENT
3:17 BECAUSE OF THE RISING RATES. SO
3:19 I THINK THE WAY THAT WE LOOK AT
3:21 THINGS IS YOU NEED TO ANCHOR IN
3:23 QUALITY COMPANIES THAT CAN
3:24 GENERATE DURABLE PROFITABILITY,
3:26 YOU KNOW, AHEAD OF THEIR COST
3:27 OF CAPITAL. YOU NEED TO THINK
3:28 ABOUT DIVERSIFICATION AND YOU
3:30 NEED TO THINK ABOUT HOW DO I
3:32 REDUCE VOLATILITY. AND SO WHEN
3:33 I THINK ABOUT THOSE THINGS THAT
3:35 LEADS ME TO YOU HAVE HEALTH
3:37 CARE THAT HAS ACTUALLY BEEN
3:39 ABLE TO GENERATE RETURNS,
3:41 GENERATE CONTINUED EARNINGS
3:42 GROWTH BECAUSE OF AGING
3:43 DEMOGRAPHICS. AND ACTUALLY IT'S
3:45 A BENEFICIARY. IF AI WORKS OUT,
3:47 IT ACTUALLY WORKS AT A REALLY
3:48 GOOD HEDGE. IF TECHNOLOGY
3:50 FALTERS, YOU'VE ALSO GOT IF YOU
3:52 THINK GLOBALLY IN JAPAN, YOU'VE
3:54 GOT STORIES LIKE THIS,
3:55 CORPORATE GOVERNANCE REFORM,
3:57 AGAIN, FOCUSING ON COMPANY
3:59 COMPANY PROFITABILITY,
4:01 COMPANIES THAT CAN CAN COMMIT
4:03 TO RAISING THEIR SHAREHOLDER
4:04 RETURNS AND RAISING
4:05 PROFITABILITY HAVE SEEN
4:06 TREMENDOUS RETURNS.
4:07 >> RIGHT. YOU ALSO MENTIONED
4:08 COMPANIES THAT THRIVE IN RISING
4:10 RATES. AND YOU SAID EUROPEAN
4:11 BANKS. THAT'S RIGHT. BUT NOT
4:12 U.S. BANKS. IS THAT IS THAT A
4:14 VOTE ON VALUATION HERE?
4:16 >> THAT'S THAT'S REALLY MORE
4:16 TOWARDS VALUATION. AND WHAT I
4:18 SEE, WHAT I THINK OF IS IN
4:20 EUROPE, YOU'VE GOT A SET OF
4:22 BANKS THAT ARE VERY HIGH
4:23 QUALITY. THEY'VE REALLY BOOSTED
4:25 THEIR RESERVES. AND WITH THE
4:27 RISING RATE ENVIRONMENT THAT'S
4:28 A BENEFIT TO TO THE EUROPEAN
4:31 BANKS.
4:31 >> AND JUST QUICKLY DO YOU
4:32 EXPECT RATES TO CONTINUE GOING
4:34 UP EITHER PUSHED BY THE FED OR
4:36 MARKET YIELDS NEXT YEAR?
4:38 >> THE TO BE HONEST WITH YOU,
4:39 WE DON'T HAVE I DON'T HAVE A
4:41 CALL ON RATES, BUT I DO THINK
4:44 THAT THIS COST OF CAPITAL IS
4:45 GOING TO BE HIGHER. THIS IS
4:47 REALLY MORE TOWARDS WHAT
4:49 NORMALLY WE SEE. I THINK
Market Close: Stocks Lower, Nvidia Falls After CEO Exit, Oil and Yields Rise full transcript
0:01 CNBC business news update. Market closed
0:04 Thursday. I'm Jessica Edinger. Wall
0:06 Street will open Friday morning after
0:08 the CEO of Nvidia resigned and major
0:11 averages finished lower. Oil and bond
0:13 yields higher Thursday. The rate on the
0:15 10-year note topping 5.1%.
0:18 Let's look at the major averages. The
0:20 Dow down 189 points, 3/10en of a
0:24 percent, led lower by shares of Nvidia
0:27 down 4.3% on Thursday. The S&P 500 index
0:32 was down 26 points. The Nasdaq fell 100
0:35 points. Chipmaker shares were mixed.
0:38 Broadcom and AMD shares were each up 5%.
0:41 Companies whose shares hit fresh
0:42 all-time highs on Thursday include
0:44 Apple, Johnson and Johnson, Eli Liy,
0:47 Costco, Coca-Cola, and Bergkshire
0:49 Hathaway. Class B shares embattled
0:52 Nvidia CEO Jensen Wong resigning
0:54 Thursday after last weekend admitting an
0:57 affair with a woman and apologizing to
0:59 the company's staff and his family. The
1:02 government alleges that woman is a
1:04 Chinese asset or spy. Reports Thursday
1:07 that there are two more women. CNBC's
1:10 Megan Cassella has more from Washington.
1:13 >> That's right, a third reported affair
1:14 now for Jensen Hang and the second one
1:16 believed to be with an employee. This is
1:18 according to Reuters reporting. They
1:20 site two people familiar with the
1:21 matter. Now in Washington, guys, the
1:23 fallout from the news of Fong's affair
1:24 with an alleged spy is only just
1:26 beginning. We now expect to see him on
1:28 Capitol Hill next week testifying in a
1:31 closed- dooror meeting with lawmakers.
1:32 Republican Senator Tom Tillis now is
1:34 also among a growing group of lawmakers
1:36 calling for Commerce Secretary Howard
1:37 Lutnik to also testify before Congress.
1:40 And the top Democrats on two powerful
1:42 committees, Senate Finance and House
1:43 Ways and Means, wrote to Lutnik today to
1:46 say they are launching an investigation
1:48 into the administration's scheme, as
1:49 they call it, to approve and tax exports
1:52 of Nvidia chips to Chinese companies
1:54 with links to the Chinese government,
1:56 military, and sanctioned entities.
1:58 Nvidia's chief financial officer,
2:01 Colette Crest, has been named temporary
2:04 CEO at the company. Here's the author of
2:07 The Thinking Machine, Steven Wit, with
2:09 CNBC's Sarah Eisen.
2:11 >> Everyone's just kind of sad and and
2:14 surprised that someone so brilliant
2:16 could do something so dumb. I mean, are
2:18 you surprised?
2:18 >> You know, I've been hearing rumors this
2:20 year, so I'm not totally surprised. Uh,
2:23 I am very disappointed.
2:25 You know, it's just a classic tale of of
2:27 masculine hubris, right? Classic tale of
2:31 >> overconfidence and believing that you
2:32 can get away with everything until you
2:34 can't, right? Jensen, he had made the
2:37 people around him so wealthy and so they
2:39 were very incentivized to protect him.
2:41 >> The news on Nvidia is fastm moving. Get
2:44 the absolute latest on CNBC television,
2:47 CNBC.com, and the CNBC app on your
2:50 phone. Cisco shares popped up 5% in
2:53 after hours trading on Thursday on
2:55 strong quarterly results. Microsoft with
2:58 an Outlook outage on Thursday for hours
3:01 with Amazon Web Services and Google
3:03 users also reporting issues. Family
3:06 Dollar paying $63 million to settle
3:09 claims it overcharged shoppers. The
3:12 Federal Trade Commission and 17 states
3:15 accused the retailer of charging more at
3:17 the register than it advertises on its
3:20 website and its mobile app. The post
3:22 office adding shipping sir charges 11%
3:25 as diesel prices have soared since
3:27 President Trump sent US missiles into
3:29 Iran back in February. The USPS joins
3:33 FedEx and UPS with new added search
3:36 charges. The new contribution limits for
3:39 retirement accounts are out from the IRS
3:41 for next year. For a 401k, $1,000
3:44 increase, you can put in $25,500.
3:48 The IRA limit is unchanged at 7500. For
3:53 those 50 and older, the catch-up limits
3:55 are going up for a 401k. You can put in
3:57 another $8,500.
4:00 People from age 60 to 63 get a super
4:02 catch-up allowance. They can put in an
4:05 extra $11,750.
4:08 On Friday's watch list, all eyes on
4:11 Nvidia and its next moves and new in
4:14 theaters. Bleecker Street's Victorian
4:15 Psycho, Amazon, MGM's How to Rob a Bank,
4:19 and Paramount's Ebenezer. It's also
4:22 Friday the 13th. Jessica Edinger, CNBC.
Deals with Iran are 'absolutely not' over, says Real Macro's Jeff Currie full transcript
0:07 PLUS.
0:09 >> ALL RIGHT. WELCOME BACK TO
0:11 THE EXCHANGE, EVERYBODY. KELLY
0:12 WILL BE BACK TOMORROW. AND
0:13 BELIEVE IT OR NOT, THERE IS
0:14 NEWS OUTSIDE OF NVIDIA AND
0:17 JEN-HSUN HUANG. AND A BIG PART
0:18 OF THAT INVOLVES ENERGY.
0:19 BECAUSE WHILE OIL ISN'T MOVING
0:20 A LOT RIGHT NOW, THIS IS, MAKE
0:22 NO MISTAKE, A VERY TENSE TIME
0:25 FOR THE GLOBAL ENERGY MARKET,
0:26 BECAUSE THERE'S ALSO SOME REAL
0:28 HOPE FOR SOME SORT OF DEAL OR
0:30 PEACE DEAL WITH IRAN. PRESIDENT
0:32 TRUMP POSTED ON TRUTH SOCIAL
0:34 EARLIER TODAY, QUOTE, WE DON'T
0:35 NEED TO DEAL WITH IRAN. THOSE
0:37 DAYS HAVE LONG SINCE PASSED.
0:39 WE'VE GOT THEIR MONEY, HUNDREDS
0:41 OF BILLIONS OF DOLLARS, AND
0:42 WE'VE GOT THEIR STRAIGHT. MAYBE
0:44 A LOT OF THAT IS UP FOR DEBATE.
0:46 I THINK PEOPLE FORGOT TO MAYBE
0:47 TELL THE HOUTHIS. ANYWAY, LET'S
0:49 TALK MORE ABOUT ALL OF THIS AND
0:50 MORE WITH JEFF CURRIE. HE IS
0:53 THE CEO OF REAL MACRO. THERE'S
0:57 SHIPS THAT ARE STILL BEING HIT
0:58 IN THE REGION. JEFF, DO YOU
1:00 THINK DEALINGS WITH IRAN ARE
1:02 OVER?
1:04 >> ABSOLUTELY NOT. IF ANYTHING
1:06 THEY JUST GOT A LOT MORE
1:07 DIFFICULT. YOU KNOW I LIKE TO
1:09 CALL THE STRAIT THE SCHRODINGER
1:10 STRAIT. REMEMBER THE
1:11 SCHRODINGER CAT. YOU DON'T KNOW
1:12 IF IT'S ALIVE OR DEAD. WE DON'T
1:14 KNOW IF IT'S OPEN OR CLOSED.
1:16 AND I THINK WHAT THAT DOES,
1:18 BECAUSE WE DO HAVE A LOT OF
1:20 VOLUMES COMING OUT. IT CAPS THE
1:21 PROMPT BARREL. BUT IT MAKES THE
1:24 NEXT ONE DOESN'T MAKE IT ANY
1:26 CHEAPER. SO YOU'RE KIND OF
1:27 STUCK IN THIS LIMBO LAND OF US.
1:29 CALL IT 95. YOU KNOW, LET'S SAY
1:32 85 TO $100 RANGE WITHOUT REALLY
1:34 ANY ABILITY TO ESCAPE TO THE
1:36 UPSIDE OR ANY ABILITY TO REALLY
1:38 DROP MUCH LOWER. SO, YOU KNOW,
1:40 THE MARKET IS IN THIS HOLDING
1:42 PATTERN BECAUSE IT'S VERY
1:43 UNCLEAR HOW WE'RE GOING TO GET
1:45 A RESOLUTION HERE.
1:46 >> WELL, WITHOUT GETTING INTO
1:47 THEORETICAL PHYSICS PROBLEMS IN
1:49 THAT CAT, LET'S LET'S TALK
1:53 ABOUT IRAN BECAUSE RIGHT NOW
1:55 THERE'S A LOT OF BARRELS MOVING
1:57 THROUGH THE STRAIT. WE KNOW
1:58 THAT, BUT THEY'RE MOVING
1:59 THROUGH THE STRAIT WITH HUGE
2:01 HELP FROM THE UNITED STATES
2:03 NAVY THAT WILL NOT OR CANNOT
2:05 LAST FOREVER. IRAN KEEPS KIND
2:07 OF CHANGING WHO'S IN CHARGE. WE
2:08 DON'T NEED TO GO INTO IRAN
2:10 POLITICS BECAUSE THEY'RE A
2:11 MYSTERY TO ME AS WELL. BUT IRAN
2:13 COULD RESTART HOSTILITIES AT
2:16 ANY TIME BECAUSE THEY THINK
2:17 THEY NEED TO BE PAID FOR SHIPS
2:19 TO GO THROUGH SAFELY.
2:21 >> YEAH. I MEAN, YOU'RE SEEING
2:22 IT. I MEAN, THEY'RE THEY'RE
2:25 TAKING HITS BACK. THERE WAS ONE
2:26 TODAY, A BIG VLCC GOT HIT BY
2:28 SOME MINES. SO I MEAN THAT'S
2:30 THE POINT HERE. YES. YOU'RE
2:31 GETTING THE VOLUMES OUT. BUT
2:32 THE COST OF THOSE VOLUMES ARE
2:34 EXTRAORDINARILY EXPENSIVE. YOU
2:36 KNOW EVERYTHING FROM LOGISTICS
2:37 TO, YOU KNOW, THE INSURANCE
2:40 INVOLVED, YOU KNOW, THE ABILITY
2:41 TO REFINE THEM, YOU KNOW, TO,
2:43 TO, TO ARGUE THAT HISTORICALLY
2:45 THESE COMMODITY MARKETS WERE
2:46 RELATIVELY SIMPLE. THE
2:48 CONSTRAINT WAS IN THE UPSTREAM
2:49 AND THAT'S ALL YOU REALLY HAD
2:51 TO LOOK AT. YOU KNOW, I LIKE TO
2:53 CALL THIS THING A BUBBLING
2:54 CAULDRON OF SUPPLY AND DEMAND
2:56 IMBALANCES. IS IT INSURANCE
2:57 THIS WEEK? IS IT REFINING THIS
2:59 WEEK? IS IT UPSTREAM? IS IT THE
3:01 TANKERS? I DON'T KNOW WHICH
3:03 ONE'S GOING TO BE THE
3:04 CONSTRAINT. THE ONE THING I
3:05 DEFINITELY KNOW A DELIVERED
3:07 BARREL OF OIL TO A CONSUMING
3:08 PART OF THE WORLD IS FAR MORE
3:10 EXPENSIVE TODAY THAN IT HAS
3:11 BEEN AT ANY OTHER POINT.
3:13 >> BUT IS THERE A.
3:14 >> SUPPLY DEMAND IMBALANCE FOR
3:15 OIL BECAUSE YOU'VE GOT QATAR
3:17 PUMPING A LOT, YOU'VE GOT IRAQ
3:19 PUMPING A LOT. UGI IS ALLEGEDLY
3:21 TALKING ABOUT A THIRD A THIRD
3:24 PIPELINE. SAUDI ARABIA'S
3:26 PUMPING BACK TO PREWAR LEVELS.
3:28 WHO KNOWS WHAT THE REST OF OPEC
3:30 MAY DO? WHAT'S THE THE BARREL
3:33 COUNTING ON THE PHYSICAL BARREL
3:36 RIGHT NOW? JEFF.
3:38 >> I WOULD PUT THE MARKET AS
3:39 RELATIVELY BALANCED, AND THAT'S
3:41 THE WAY IT'S PRICING RIGHT NOW.
3:42 THE FRONT END IS RELATIVELY
3:43 FLAT. IT'S RELATIVELY TAME. BUT
3:45 LET'S NOT FORGET WHILE IT CAPS
3:48 THE PROMPT BARREL, IT DOES
3:49 NOTHING TO CHEAPEN THE NEXT ONE,
3:52 WHICH IS WHY YOU CAN'T GET
3:53 BEARISH HERE, NOR CAN YOU GET
3:55 REALLY BULLISH. SO YOU HAVE
3:59 REALLY EXPENSIVE BARRELS OF OIL
4:00 BEING PUT OUT ONTO THE GLOBAL
4:01 MARKET AND A TENUOUS BALANCE,
4:04 BUT IT DOES NOTHING TO SHIFT
4:07 THE FORWARD. LOOK FOR OUTLOOK
4:08 FOR THE PRICE. IN FACT, YOU
4:10 KNOW, WE PUT OUT A PIECE
4:11 RECENTLY WHERE WE TALKED ABOUT,
4:13 YOU KNOW, WE WANT TO GET, YOU
4:14 KNOW, THE, THE WAR TRADE IS
4:16 OVER. ANY TYPE OF UPSIDE IN
4:17 PRICE IS OVER, BUT THE REGIME
4:19 TRADE IS STILL THERE. YOU WANT
4:20 TO OWN THINGS LIKE THE DRILLERS,
4:22 THE LONG TERM, YOU KNOW,
4:24 STRUCTURAL STORY HERE IS VERY
4:25 MUCH INTACT. SO, YOU KNOW, WE
4:27 LIKE THE THE STRUCTURAL STORY
4:29 LONG DATED OIL, YOU KNOW,
4:31 DRILLERS, PRODUCERS, YOU KNOW,
'AI is still going to dominate the world,' says Strategy CEO Phong Le full transcript
0:10 >> OF COURSE, WE'RE WATCHING
0:11 NVIDIA AND THE TECH TRADE TODAY,
0:14 BUT WE'RE ALSO KEEPING AN EYE
0:15 ON CRYPTO. BITCOIN IS DOWN MORE
0:17 THAN 3%, FALLING BELOW THE
0:19 72,000 MARK TO ITS LOWEST LEVEL
0:21 SINCE AUGUST. STRATEGY. THE
0:23 WORLD'S LARGEST CORPORATE
0:25 BITCOIN HOLDER IS ALSO UNDER
0:27 PRESSURE, DOWN ABOUT 50% FROM
0:29 ITS 52 WEEK HIGH. SO WHAT'S THE
0:32 STRATEGY GOING FORWARD? JOINING
0:34 US NOW IN AN EXCLUSIVE
0:35 INTERVIEW, FENG LI, CEO OF
0:37 STRATEGY. IT'S GREAT TO SEE YOU
0:39 TODAY. FIRST OF ALL, GIVE ME A
0:41 SENSE OF MSCI TAKING STRATEGY
0:46 OUT OF ITS INDEX. WHAT DOES
0:47 THAT MEAN FOR YOU AND FOR THE
0:49 COMPANY AND FOR YOUR ACCESS TO
0:51 CAPITAL.
0:52 >> YEAH. LOOK MSCI HAS BEEN ON
0:54 A MULTIYEAR CAMPAIGN AGAINST
0:56 DIGITAL ASSETS. AND IT'S
0:58 INTERESTING BECAUSE THEIR ROLE
0:59 IS TO BE AN INDEPENDENT ARBITER
1:01 OF THE MARKETS NOT PICKING
1:03 WINNERS AND LOSERS. AND THEY'VE
1:04 CLEARLY DECIDED THAT BITCOIN
1:06 ISN'T SOMETHING THAT PEOPLE
1:07 SHOULD BE INVESTING IN. PUT
1:09 THAT ASIDE. ABOUT 3% OF OUR
1:11 SHARES ARE RELATED TO MSCI
1:14 INDICES, SO IT'S REALLY NOT A
1:16 BIG ISSUE FOR US. I WOULD CALL
1:17 IT IMMATERIAL. THE BIGGER
1:19 QUESTION IS WHY IS MSCI PICKING
1:21 WINNERS AND LOSERS IN THE
1:22 MARKET.
1:23 >> I MENTIONED THAT YOUR SHARES
1:25 ARE DOWN ABOUT 50% FROM YOUR 52
1:27 WEEK HIGH. WHY? TO WHAT DO YOU
1:30 ATTRIBUTE THAT DECLINE?
1:32 >> OVER THE LAST YEAR THERE'S
1:33 BEEN UNPRECEDENTED VOLATILITY
1:35 IN THE MARKET. THERE'S
1:37 VOLATILITY RELATED TO MONETARY
1:38 POLICY, TRADE POLICY, FOREIGN
1:41 POLICY, GEOPOLITICAL U.S.
1:43 POLITICAL ENVIRONMENT AND
1:45 BITCOIN BREEDS ON VOLATILITY
1:47 GOES UP AND DOWN QUITE A BIT IN
1:49 THE LAST YEAR. AND AS BITCOIN
1:50 HAS DECLINED IN THE LAST YEAR,
1:52 SO HAS MSR FONG.
1:54 >> OUTSIDE OF THAT, WE'VE HAD
1:55 THIS THING CALLED THE ELECTION.
1:57 AGAIN. I KNOW IT'S GOTTEN LOST
1:58 IN THE NVIDIA NEWS, BUT IT'S
2:00 KIND OF A BIG DEAL AND IT'S A
2:02 BIG DEAL FOR REGULATION. WE'RE
2:03 GOING TO HAVE A NEW CONGRESS
2:04 COMING IN. WHAT DO YOU THINK
2:06 ABOUT IT. WHAT IS YOUR MESSAGE
2:07 TO THE NEW CONGRESS AND HOW
2:09 MIGHT IT IMPACT THE REGULATORY
2:10 FRAMEWORK THAT YOU AND THE
2:11 ENTIRE CRYPTO INDUSTRY HAS TO
2:13 DEAL WITH EVERY DAY?
2:14 >> I DON'T REALLY THINK BITCOIN
2:16 AND CRYPTO ARE PARTIZAN ISSUES,
2:17 RIGHT? BITCOIN AND CRYPTO ARE
2:19 ABOUT HOW DO WE MODERNIZE THE
2:21 FINANCIAL MARKETS AND HOW DO WE
2:22 CREATE FINANCIAL FREEDOM FOR
2:25 350 AMERICANS AND 8 BILLION
2:27 PEOPLE AROUND THE WORLD? AND
2:30 WHAT YOU SEE HAPPENING THROUGH
2:32 THE EXECUTIVE BRANCH, THE SEC,
2:34 THE CFTC IS A SET OF RULES THAT
2:36 ARE GOING TO ALLOW TOKENIZATION
2:38 OF SECURITIES AND ACCESS TO
2:41 STABLECOINS AND MODERNIZATION
2:42 OF FINANCIAL RAILS. IF I'M A
2:44 DEMOCRAT, I LOVE THAT. IF I'M A
2:46 REPUBLICAN, I LOVE THAT. SO
2:48 SURE, THERE WILL BE SOME SHORT
2:49 TERM VOLATILITY AND AND PERHAPS
2:53 SOME CHANGE RELATED TO WHO'S IN
2:56 CONGRESS. BUT I THINK LONG TERM,
2:57 IT'S A GOOD SETUP FOR CRYPTO
2:59 REGARDLESS OF WHO'S IN THE
3:00 WHITE HOUSE. CAN I ASK YOU.
3:01 >> ABOUT THE THE BINANCE THEFT?
3:04 YOU KNOW, YOU'VE GOT BILLIONS
3:05 OF DOLLARS MANAGING TO LEAVE
3:07 THESE ACCOUNTS. WHAT DID THAT
3:09 MEAN TO YOU AND HOW DID YOU
3:11 INTERPRET WHAT THAT SHOULD,
3:13 WHAT SHOULD BE THE IMPACT FOR
3:14 YOU AND FOR STRATEGY IN TERMS
3:17 OF DEFENSE? GOOD DEFENSE?
3:21 >> YEAH, IT'S A COUPLE OF
3:22 THINGS. WELL, FIRST OF ALL,
3:24 $6.3 BILLION WERE WERE WERE
3:26 TAKEN. ABOUT HALF OF THAT WAS
3:28 RETURNED ALREADY BECAUSE IT WAS
3:29 BASED ON STABLECOINS. AND ALL
3:32 OF IT HAS BEEN REFUNDED TO THE
3:35 OWNERS THAT WERE SITTING ON
3:36 BINANCE. SO I THINK THAT'S A
3:37 PRETTY GOOD STORY OVERALL. THAT
3:39 SAID, YOU KNOW, NOBODY LIKES
3:40 HACKS. NOBODY LIKES THE FACT
3:41 THAT SOME NATION STATE, NORTH
3:43 KOREA, HAS BEEN ABLE TO
3:44 INFILTRATE THAT KIND OF WEALTH.
3:47 WHAT DOES IT MEAN? LOOK, AI IS
3:49 REAL AND PEOPLE HAVE TO BE MORE
3:51 SECURE WHEN IT COMES TO RUNNING
3:52 AI FRONTIER MODELS AGAINST
3:54 THEIR SOFTWARE AND AGAINST
3:56 THEIR CUSTODIANS. WE HOLD ALL
3:58 OF OUR BITCOIN AND US BASED
4:00 CUSTODIANS IN COLD STORAGE. SO
4:03 I DO AGREE IT CREATES
4:05 REPUTATIONAL RISK TO THE SPACE,
4:07 BUT IT'S NOT A REAL HARD RISK
4:09 TO HOW WE'RE HOLDING OUR
4:10 BITCOIN. BUT WE HAVE TO STAY
4:11 VIGILANT.
4:12 >> I GOT TO ASK YOU ABOUT
4:13 NVIDIA TODAY. WHAT ARE YOUR
4:15 THOUGHTS ON THE CHALLENGES
4:16 FACING THAT COMPANY.
4:17 >> WELL I, I, I THINK JENSEN'S
4:19 DONE AN AMAZING THING OVER THE
4:20 LAST 30 YEARS BUILDING A
4:22 COMPANY FROM SCRATCH THAT UNTIL
4:24 TODAY WAS THE MOST VALUABLE
4:25 COMPANY IN THE WORLD.
4:27 EVERYTHING THAT WE TALK ABOUT
4:28 BECAUSE OF AI IS UNDERPINNED BY
4:31 THE TECHNOLOGY HE'S BEEN
4:32 CREATED. CEOS ARE HUMAN, RIGHT?
4:35 AND I DON'T REALLY KNOW WHAT'S
4:36 BEHIND WHAT OCCURRED MOST
4:38 RECENTLY. AI IS BIGGER THAN
4:40 JENSEN AT THIS POINT IN TIME,
4:42 IS A HUGE AREA OF CAPITAL
4:45 INFLOWS. IT'S A HUGE AREA OF
4:47 REALLY FREEDOM FOR INDIVIDUALS
4:50 AND INTELLIGENCE FOR
4:51 INDIVIDUALS AND ABUNDANCE FOR
4:53 INDIVIDUALS. SO I THINK I
Alice Huang owned stakes in Chinese businesses that benefited Huawei during affair with Jensen Huang full transcript
0:01 HAPPEN. JENSEN WAS SUCH A
0:03 COMFORTING. YEAH. ANYWAY.
0:04 >> FOR SURE. EVERYBODY HOLD
0:05 TIGHT. WE GOT SOME BREAKING
0:06 NEWS. LET'S GET TO EAMON JAVERS
0:08 I BELIEVE IN DC EAMON YEAH.
0:11 >> JOHN THAT'S RIGHT. CNBC HAS
0:13 LEARNED OF A SURPRISING
0:14 CONNECTION BETWEEN ALICE WONG,
0:16 THE CHINESE TECH EXECUTIVE AT
0:17 THE CENTER OF THE NVIDIA SEX
0:18 AND SPYING SCANDAL. AND HUAWEI,
0:21 THE CHINESE TECH COMPANY THAT'S
0:22 NVIDIA'S BIGGEST COMPETITOR IN
0:24 THAT COUNTRY. NOW ALICE WONG
0:26 MAY HAVE SIMULTANEOUSLY OWNED
0:29 STAKES IN COMPANIES UP UNTIL
0:31 2024 THAT BENEFITED HUAWEI,
0:33 EVEN AS SHE WAS HAVING AN
0:34 AFFAIR WITH JEN-HSUN HUANG OF
0:35 NVIDIA. NOW, THAT'S ACCORDING
0:36 TO THE PRIVATE INTELLIGENCE
0:37 FIRM TESSERAE, THE FIRM
0:40 ANALYZING CHINESE CORPORATE
0:41 RECORDS AND NEWS ARTICLES
0:42 CONCLUDES THAT THE COMPLICATED
0:44 TANGLE OF INTERLOCKING
0:45 CORPORATIONS CONNECTED TO THE
0:46 ALLEGED SPY ULTIMATELY PROVIDED
0:49 COMPUTING POWER TO HUAWEI IN
0:52 CHINA. NOW, HUAWEI IS
0:53 CONSIDERED A KEY PART OF THE
0:54 CHINESE GOVERNMENT'S PUSH FOR
0:55 GLOBAL TECHNICAL DOMINANCE AND
0:57 IS CLOSELY LINKED TO THE
0:59 CHINESE COMMUNIST PARTY.
1:00 TESSERAE SHARED ITS FINDINGS
1:02 EXCLUSIVELY WITH CNBC. TESSERAE,
1:04 BY THE WAY, PROVIDES
1:05 INTELLIGENCE RESEARCH TO
1:07 PRIVATE COMPANIES AND THE US
1:08 GOVERNMENT. THIS ACTIVITY,
1:10 WHICH SURFACED THROUGH OUR
1:11 ANALYSTS OUR ANALYSIS OF
1:12 ALYSSA'S NETWORK, WARRANTS A
1:14 NATIONAL SECURITY AND
1:16 COUNTER-PROLIFERATION
1:17 INVESTIGATION. THAT'S FROM
1:18 BRIAN ANDERSON, TESLA'S VICE
1:20 PRESIDENT FOR NATIONAL SECURITY
1:22 APPLICATIONS AND A FORMER
1:23 SUPERVISORY SPECIAL AGENT WITH
1:25 HOMELAND SECURITY
1:27 INVESTIGATIONS. HE SAID IF THE
1:28 COMMERCE DEPARTMENT'S BUREAU OF
1:29 INDUSTRY, SECURITY AND HOMELAND
1:31 SECURITY'S INVESTIGATIONS FOUND
1:32 EVIDENCE THAT ANYONE
1:33 TRANSFERRED CONTROL EQUIPMENT
1:36 TO HUAWEI WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION,
1:39 POTENTIAL CHARGES MIGHT INCLUDE
1:40 EXPORT CONTROL VIOLATIONS,
1:43 CONSPIRACY AND SMUGGLING,
1:44 ACCORDING TO DOCUMENTS REVIEWED
1:45 BY CNBC. AT THE END OF A CHAIN
1:48 OF COMPANIES IS A DATA CENTER
1:49 IN SHENZHEN, CHINA, WHICH WAS
1:51 PART OWNED BY AN ALICE WONG
1:53 ENTITY AND RECEIVED LOAN
1:55 GUARANTEES FROM A FIRM THAT WAS
1:56 LINKED TO HER. THAT DATA
1:58 CENTERS KEY CUSTOMER WAS HUAWEI
2:00 CLOUD, A SUBSIDIARY OF THE
2:02 BROADER COMPANY. NOW WE'VE
2:03 REACHED OUT TO HUAWEI, NVIDIA,
2:05 AND THE CORPORATE ENTITIES
2:06 ASSOCIATED WITH ALICE WONG FOR
2:08 COMMENT, BUT WE'VE NOT HEARD
2:09 BACK FROM ANY OF THEM JUST YET.
2:11 BACK OVER TO YOU.
2:12 >> EAMON QUESTION HERE. I'M
2:13 PRETTY SURE THAT MEGA SPEED,
2:15 THE COMPANY THAT WE FIRST HEARD
2:17 OF, ASSOCIATED WITH ALICE WONG,
2:19 SHE WAS SORT OF RUNNING OR IN A
2:22 POSITION TO HAVE VERY MUCH
2:23 INFLUENCE. THERE IS ALSO TIED
2:24 TO ALIBABA. NOW THIS IS A TIE
2:26 TO HUAWEI. THOSE ARE TWO OF THE
2:29 OF THE DOMINANT, IF YOU CAN SAY,
2:32 TO HAVE DOMINANT TECH COMPANIES
2:33 IN CHINA. SO A COUPLE OF THE
2:35 BIGGEST SORT OF LIKE A
2:37 MICROSOFT AND A GOOGLE AT LEAST
2:39 SIZE WISE. YES. SO HOW UNUSUAL
2:42 WOULD IT BE FOR SOMEONE TO HAVE
2:44 HOLDINGS OR CONNECTIONS TO
2:47 COMPANIES THAT HAVE A LOT OF
2:49 TENTACLES THROUGHOUT THE
2:51 ECONOMY OF ASIA?
2:52 >> WELL, IT CERTAINLY SHOWS A
2:53 DEEP DEGREE OF CONNECTION TO
2:55 THE TOP CHINESE COMPANIES IN
2:57 CHINA. RIGHT? THIS IS A COMPANY
2:59 IN MEGA SPEED THAT WAS SET UP
3:01 IN SINGAPORE AND WAS OSTENSIBLY
3:03 SAFE TO EXPORT TO BECAUSE IT
3:05 WAS A SINGAPOREAN COMPANY. BUT
3:07 AT THE SAME TIME, YOU'RE SEEING
3:08 NOW THIS CONNECTION BETWEEN
3:10 ALICE WONG AND HUAWEI AT THIS
3:13 SHENZHEN DATA CENTER IN
3:15 MAINLAND CHINA. AND SO YOU CAN
3:17 START TO CONNECT THE DOTS
3:18 BETWEEN ALICE WONG AND MAINLAND
3:22 CHINA. AND THE QUESTION WILL BE,
3:23 DID THE NVIDIA CHIPS MAKE THEIR
3:25 WAY TO THAT DATA CENTER IN
3:27 MAINLAND CHINA? AND WAS THAT
3:29 ILLEGAL? RIGHT. THAT'S WHAT
3:30 INVESTIGATORS ARE GOING TO WANT
3:31 TO LOOK AT. AND THE QUESTION
3:33 HERE IS, WILL INVESTIGATORS
3:35 EVER GET A CHANCE TO QUESTION
3:37 ALICE WONG? IT'S NOT ENTIRELY
3:38 CLEAR WHERE SHE IS RIGHT NOW.
3:41 THE CHANCES OF HER ENDING UP
3:42 BACK ON U.S. SOIL OBVIOUSLY
3:43 PRETTY SLIM. SO INVESTIGATORS
3:45 ARE GOING TO HAVE TO DO A LOT
3:46 OF THIS RESEARCH FROM A
3:48 DISTANCE AND FROM A REMOVE, BUT
3:49 THEY'RE GOING TO WANT TO LOOK
3:51 AT THE FLOW OF OWNERSHIP, AS WE
3:53 JUST LAID OUT FOR YOU, OF THESE
3:55 SHELL ENTITIES AND INTERLOCKING
3:56 ENTITIES AND THE DATA CENTER IN
3:57 CHINA,
Experts react to Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang’s resignation and succession plan full transcript
0:00 Nvidia's Jensen Huang is stepping down immediately,
0:03 resigning from his post as chairman and CEO of Nvidia.
0:07 Colette Kress is appointed interim CEO.
0:11 The CFO had been the name had been most mentioned as a
0:14 potential replacement for Jensen Huang.
0:16 President posting just moments ago this.
0:19 He says 'now that Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang,
0:21 who has done a fantastic job,
0:23 has resigned. There is only one man to take his place.
0:27 Tim Cook of Apple.
0:29 A legend replaces a legend.'
0:38 Look, she's natural.
0:39 She is someone who has been leading the calls.
0:43 That's funny, Carl, there's 42,000 people
0:46 there. A lot of people feel there's never been anybody
0:50 who really stands for the company or means anything.
0:52 Colette's been my contact person other than Jensen for
0:55 years. She's no nonsense and she is absolutely the one
1:00 that you need right now.
1:01 Because she has the bearing,
1:03 she will accept no nonsense.
1:05 Now I think what what I think everyone feels like
1:07 because it's so political right now, okay, what does
1:09 she know about what did she know about Kimberly Powell?
1:12 And I know Kimberly well.
1:13 She's been the person to run health care for a long time.
1:16 What does she know about this? What does she know
1:17 about that? And all that I can tell you is, is that I
1:20 think that Colette is above all this stuff.
1:23 Now you can say, well, Jim, you thought did
1:25 you like Jenson?
1:26 But you know what?
1:27 At least when it comes to running the call and being
1:30 organized and telling you about the cash,
1:32 which I think at some point people are actually going to
1:34 be worried about because everything else is on the
1:35 table, I trust her.
1:37 I think there is a lot of evidence to suggest this
1:40 board was very deferential to Jensen Huang,
1:42 right? Um, there was no board chair.
1:45 There was no succession plan.
1:47 Um, five of the individuals sitting on the board,
1:50 including Jensen, have been on the board since
1:52 the start. So they have developed very close
1:55 relationships over this period of time and the board
1:58 has a track record of being quite deferential to him.
2:01 And, you know, I this is the difficult
2:04 thing when you have a company with a visionary
2:07 superstar CEO, right?
2:09 Um, this person is creating a lot of value.
2:12 They have a big vision.
2:13 You know, you don't want to rein them in if it's going
2:17 to be costly for the company,
2:18 the company, its prospects, its shareholders.
2:21 Um, and so I think up until this point,
2:24 the board has been playing that role.
2:27 This is the number one thing to figure out right now is
2:29 who is going to lead this company forward. They have a
2:31 great interim CFO or interim CEO who is their former CFO,
2:35 but I don't think she has the operational experience
2:38 that's necessary to move this company forward and so
2:40 this is a five alarm fire moment for the board is how
2:45 do we navigate through this so to minimize the damage?
2:48 And yeah, that's the focus now.
2:50 Um, I think you could argue,
2:52 given where the stock is, that this could be a
2:54 clearing event for the company.
2:56 The stock is now trading at ten times GAAP earnings on
3:00 calendar '27. It's going to generate over $300 billion
3:04 in free cash flow next year.
3:05 We think that there is certainly a lot of talent in
3:09 the company. Certainly retention of that talent
3:11 becomes extremely important going forward.
3:14 But, uh, you know, hopefully the company can
3:17 turn the page and move forward. We're happy with,
3:19 uh, the interim CEO.
3:22 Uh, and we assume that the board will do a rigorous
3:25 search process and we encourage them to obviously
3:29 consider both external and internal candidates.
3:32 There's clearly a lot of talent that's helped Nvidia
3:35 build what they've done over the last number of years.
3:39 Um, and so I think it's appropriate to both consider
3:42 both internal as external.
3:44 There's obviously a question of, you know, who could be
3:46 the logical candidate to run Nvidia,
3:48 whether that's an internal or an external candidate.
3:51 There's a lot of questions about you know, does
3:53 anything change in the strategy? You know, how much
3:54 of the strategy was tied to Jensen's deep convictions
3:57 about where this industry goes,
3:59 how they use their balance sheet, what that look like
4:01 with their ecosystem. So I think a lot of that calls
4:03 into question. Obviously, things we don't have the
4:06 answer for. But I think anytime something like this
4:08 happens and we observe this,
4:10 you know, back in the day with Apple when Steve Jobs
4:12 had cancer and then, you know, inevitably,
4:14 inevitably died, it creates a huge shakeup
4:16 and an impact to the industry and we're going
4:19 through that process right now.
4:21 It is a very sad day.
4:22 Um, you know, we are giving up the lead in
4:26 AI, in my view, to China.
4:28 Uh, Jensen was the most optimistic supporter of AI.
4:32 Obviously created the foundational technology that
4:35 is enabling frontier models and for the US to be a
4:38 leader in AI. And I think that him being forced out,
4:42 uh, is a, is a major loss for Nvidia and also a major
4:45 loss for the United States. So,
4:47 uh, again, a very sad day for not only,
4:49 you know, Jensen, not only for Nvidia,
4:51 but I think also for the country.
Squawk Pod: Jensen Huang resigns: what’s next, & who is Alice Huang? full transcript
0:00 Bring in show music, please.
0:05 >> Hi, I'm CNBC producer Katie Kramer.
0:07 Today on Squawk Pod, Jensen Wong resigns
0:10 from Nvidia.
0:11 >> I felt like we were kind of on smoke for
0:14 the Pope.
0:14 >> The drama hitting Silicon Valley, Wall
0:17 Street, and Washington. CNBC's Aean
0:19 Javvers.
0:20 >> Clearly, there were people in and around
0:22 Jensen Wong's inner circle who knew
0:25 about this, who, you know, were taking
0:27 steps to protect him from himself. Wong
0:29 steps down with an announcement that
0:31 broke while we were on the air.
0:33 >> Colette Crest is appointed the CEO.
0:37 She's the CFO and had been the name had
0:39 been most mentioned as a potential
0:41 replacement for Jensen Wong.
0:43 >> The CFO was perhaps the only person that
0:45 they felt that they that the investment
0:47 world knew.
0:48 >> We check in with Ununice Yun in Beijing
0:50 about the scandal. And who is alleged
0:52 spy Alice Wong? She's uh viewed here as
0:56 in China publicly as what's known as a
1:00 chenu. So somebody who is a commercial
1:03 fixer. Plus who in the Trump
1:05 administration knew what when the sexion
1:08 geopolitics with US trade representative
1:10 Jameson Greer.
1:11 >> I'll just say that our intelligence
1:13 community is is active of course.
1:14 They're always trying to track all kinds
1:16 of issues, national security, economic
1:17 security issues. The president and other
1:19 members of the cabinet, myself included,
1:21 are are briefed regularly.
1:23 It's Thursday, November 12th, 2026.
1:26 Squawk Pod begins right now.
1:29 >> Stand back by in three, two, one. Fuel,
1:32 please.
1:35 >> Good morning everybody. Welcome to
1:36 Squawkbox right here on CNBC. We are
1:39 live from the NASDAQ market site in
1:40 Times Square. I'm Becky Quick along with
1:43 Joe Kernan and Andrew Ross Sorcin. And
1:45 here we go. It's Thursday.
1:47 >> Let's get right to the top story of the
1:49 morning. Nvidia's board weighing now
1:51 whether to remove co Jensen Wong
1:53 following a report of that second
1:54 extrammarital affair with an employee of
1:57 the company. Aean Javvers joining us now
1:59 with the latest. Aean.
2:01 >> Yeah, Andrew. That's right. The New York
2:03 Times reported late Wednesday that
2:04 Nvidia CEO Jensen Wong had a second
2:07 affair in addition to the previously
2:09 reported diance with an alleged Chinese
2:12 spy. In this case, the Times reports his
2:15 partner was Kimberly Powell, Nvidia's
2:17 vice president of healthcare. The paper
2:19 reports that the couple were caught on
2:22 video being affectionate at a San Jose
2:25 hotel during an Nvidia conference this
2:27 past spring. The paper cites five people
2:30 who worked at the company describing the
2:32 relationship between the two and the
2:35 Times notes that Pal is also married to
2:38 another person. separately. The Wall
2:40 Street Journal reported last night that
2:42 the board of Nvidia was preparing to
2:45 meet at that time to consider Wong's
2:47 future at Nvidia. And guys, I would also
2:50 direct your attention to a fascinating
2:53 Wall Street Journal report this morning
2:55 uh which suggests that the person who
2:57 introduced uh the alleged Chinese spy
3:01 Alice Wong to Jensen Wong was in fact
3:04 her husband and business partner. uh
3:07 they had partnered in uh computer gaming
3:10 companies over the years and the husband
3:12 apparently according to the Wall Street
3:14 Journal reporting this morning was the
3:15 one who introduced his wife to Jensen
3:18 Wong and apparently over time uh didn't
3:21 seem to mind that she had a very close
3:24 relationship with Jensen Wong which has
3:26 now been exposed as a romantic
3:28 relationship. So uh there's some human
3:30 entanglements here, there are corporate
3:32 entanglements here, there national
3:33 security entanglements here. very
3:35 complicated situation and the question
3:36 is will Jensen Wong survive the day in
3:39 his job as CEO guys
3:42 >> uh Aean that that second reference by
3:44 the way on the human nature of it with
3:46 the the husband who uh was unbelievable
3:49 the other uh little detail that I
3:52 thought was extraordinary but really
3:54 more importantly about this affair that
3:55 he had had with an employee at the
3:57 company uh was that the team security uh
4:01 sought an NDA from somebody who took a
4:04 picture of it.
4:06 >> Yeah.
4:06 >> And I wonder whether that security team
4:09 >> Yeah.
4:11 >> Yeah. According to the New York Times
4:12 reporting and you know, Andrew, we can't
4:14 match this. I mean, the New York Times
4:15 has been fantastic on this and was way
4:17 ahead of everybody else. Um, but
4:19 according to the Times's reporting, uh,
4:21 there was a an Nvidia employee or a
4:24 group of NVIDIA employees who witnessed
4:25 this canoodling romantic moment,
4:28 whatever it was, uh, and one of them
4:31 pulled out a cell phone and captured
4:33 some of it on video and the security
4:34 team converged on that person and asked
4:36 them to sign an NDA to not disclose
4:39 that. Uh so clearly there were people in
4:42 and around uh Jensen Wong's inner circle
4:45 who knew about this uh who you know were
4:48 taking steps to protect him uh from
4:50 himself. And you got to ask the question
4:52 Andrew you know if you're the board of
4:53 directors here looking at this I mean
4:54 this is aggressive risktaking and you
4:57 know potentially self-destructive risk
4:59 takingaking when you're dealing with an
5:00 employee of your own company. um you
5:03 know does that is that judgment just in
5:05 his personal life or is he also taking
5:07 aggressive and potentially uh
5:09 self-destructive risks in his business
5:11 life as well and that's the kind of
5:13 decision that the board is faced with
5:15 this morning
5:16 >> right Aman let's briefly talk about
5:18 what's happening in Washington as it
5:20 relates to the spy case because that
5:21 seems to be to be the larger overhang
5:24 longer term of the entire company in
5:27 terms of its ability to sell into China
5:28 or rather to sell say sell into
5:31 different parts of the country or the
5:32 world rather. Uh, another report uh that
5:35 came from Axios yesterday uh seemed to
5:38 suggest that there was a real fight uh
5:40 between the commerce department um uh
5:43 Howard Lutnik and Scott Bessant uh and a
5:47 whole number of other members of the
5:49 cabinet about what uh was happening and
5:53 how long um Nvidia has been allowed to
5:56 sell into some of these markets at a
5:58 time when it appears the president had
6:00 been telling uh the commerce department
6:02 uh that they shouldn't be allowed to.
6:05 >> Yeah, fascinating, you know, sort of
6:07 infighting and we don't know exactly
6:09 what happened there, Andrew. But it does
6:11 appear from the reporting uh that there
6:13 is a real schism inside the Trump
6:15 administration about how to handle uh
6:17 Nvidia, how to handle mega speed, and
6:20 this question of chip sales to China. Um
6:22 a and you know, clearly it seems that
6:25 Jensen Wong was courting Donald Trump as
6:28 his sort of political protector so he
6:30 could continue to expand chip sales.
6:32 that was his goal, you know,
6:33 self-announced goal uh to expand that.
6:36 Uh but there's real questions here,
6:38 right? So around the intelligence piece
6:39 and the Chinese spying is one thing, but
6:41 there's also a law enforcement question
6:43 here for Nvidia. And I think, you know,
6:45 it's clear that there's some potential
6:48 criminal exposure uh for Jensen Wong and
6:51 anybody inside Nvidia who knew about
6:54 deliberate efforts to circumvent US
6:56 export controls of advanced chips to
6:59 China. Right. The relationship with
7:00 Megape, Mega Speed's relationship with
7:03 domestic uh data centers in China uh is
7:06 the real question here. Did anybody
7:08 inside Nvidia know that there was a
7:12 deliberate effort and chips were going
7:14 around US law uh into China? If that's
7:16 the case, you know, there are laws on
7:18 the books about that, Andrew, and
7:20 there's jail sentences that are
7:22 potentially attached to that if people
7:24 are investigated and convicted. So that
7:26 risk exists for Nvidia as we sit here
7:29 right now. And the question is how
7:31 aggressively will US law enforcement
7:34 pursue that uh whether or not Jensen
7:37 Wong is to remain as CEO of this
7:39 company. There are other people inside
7:41 the company who could have been aware of
7:44 something like that if it happened. So
7:45 there's a there's legal criminal
7:47 potential exposure here. And then on the
7:49 intelligence side, obviously there
7:51 there's an intelligence uh breach here
7:54 uh that US intelligence is going to have
7:55 to get its arms around and figure out
7:57 how much information was transferred to
7:59 the Chinese and when.
8:01 >> Right. Uh Amy Jabvers, we appreciate it
8:03 this morning. Thank you. Uh Joe, there's
8:06 a lot of supporters though out there for
8:08 him uh at the moment in in Silicon
8:11 Valley.
8:12 >> Yeah, Elon too. Like we were saying, if
8:15 if you know it's a big word, but if it
8:18 wasn't a spy and if it wasn't an
8:19 employee, it's like I'm tired of even
8:21 hearing about it. But I'll tell you one
8:23 thing, we both uh Becky and I both think
8:24 Eric Schmidt, there's a uh
8:28 Why not? Uh okay, that's a good idea. Uh
8:31 but Elon Musk, Andrew,
8:35 I don't know who
8:35 >> I think he's unlikely to get the job
8:37 though
8:39 because I was looking through the list
8:40 of people.
8:40 >> You know the history. You know the
8:41 history. You know what I'm saying? Of
8:42 course I do. Just blow it off.
8:44 >> No, I know exactly what you're saying.
8:45 >> But I would say interestingly the two
8:47 people that are on that list that to me
8:50 make the most sense.
8:51 >> Yeah.
8:52 >> Uh the second though may be
8:53 disqualifying as you said about Eric
8:55 would be Tim and Eric. Tim Tim Cook
8:58 >> on end
9:01 actually Eric's it's all out there. So
9:03 maybe who gives a crap at this point?
9:07 >> It's like finding about him. And you
9:10 know the the name are interesting like
9:12 Tim Cook would be amazing but why would
9:13 he come back if he didn't want to run
9:15 after this to step down and the other
9:17 name would be Lisa Sue but she's she's
9:19 got her own company that has been
9:21 amazing and is taking off. Why step away
9:24 from AMD? Andrew, was that yesterday or
9:26 the day before? There's something with
9:27 his latest paramore that that um
9:30 >> she's mad about
9:31 >> she wants about an he has a stake in
9:33 anthropic that she supposedly
9:35 >> she wants
9:37 back there and and the page six. Yes.
9:39 Okay.
9:40 >> It's crazy. But it's all out there. It's
9:42 like But that's what I mean. Even
9:44 >> but it's reckless for for for I think
9:47 for Jensen. That's that's the problem.
9:49 It's it shows some I mean some it's
9:51 reckless. I I don't care, you know, but
9:53 it just seems reckless.
9:56 >> I don't know. I want to go back to the
9:57 Tim Cook idea for a second. I I the
10:01 what's so interesting about the job
10:02 itself of replacing Jensen, which is
10:05 almost irreplaceable unto itself, um is
10:08 that so much of the job is about having
10:10 the relationship with TSMC, probably
10:13 most especially a lot of the governments
10:15 in Asia. That becomes a particularly
10:17 important point.
10:18 >> He's the ambassador. How do you find an
10:20 ambassador? the engineering piece of it
10:23 uh in a certain way. Um and then and
10:25 then obviously having government
10:26 relations in the US and elsewhere.
10:29 >> I don't know for Tim. I mean, Tim did
10:31 want to step down from Apple, but I feel
10:32 like maybe maybe he he made his run at
10:35 Apple and you know what, everybody's
10:36 looking for an encore, and this could be
10:38 a fascinating uh
10:40 >> no question. He'd be amazing from the
10:42 from being an ambassador with all of
10:44 this because the other thing you think
10:45 about with with Jensen is the bigger um
10:49 ability to move the AI trade. He's been
10:51 the person who has been looking at the
10:53 bottlenecks for AI as an industry and
10:56 trying to find ways to bring it. The
10:57 most recent one being the idea that
10:59 there's not enough financing. He got six
11:01 Wall Street CEOs together and came up
11:03 with half a trillion dollars in
11:05 financing that they were going to put
11:06 together for this. You know, it's it's
11:09 what he does, which by the way is not
11:11 happening right now.
11:12 >> Yeah. Right.
11:13 >> Interesting.
11:14 >> What happens with this? Tim Cook could
11:16 certainly do something like that. Uh
11:18 would he want to? I think would be my
11:19 bigger question.
11:21 >> Right.
11:21 >> I just think of him as a guy who
11:22 understands supply chain. That's a huge
11:24 part of this uh
11:25 >> sort of component part. I it'll be
11:27 interesting. But by the way, with if you
11:29 put the page six piece of it aside, Eric
11:32 Schmidt, given his knowledge of AI and
11:34 how deep he is on also on supply chain,
11:37 I mean, he's been working on some of the
11:38 drones and and things in Ukraine and
11:40 this guy would know how to do it. Again,
11:44 given given some of the history, I don't
11:45 know.
11:45 >> I mean, I wish I didn't care
11:47 >> blackmail somebody who's
11:48 >> right. I wish I didn't care about
11:50 Jensen, but there's um
11:52 >> I do I like him. I know, but I mean I I
11:54 I I wish it wasn't a a fate, you know,
11:59 complaint that that that he's out, but I
12:01 don't that he's I don't see any way
12:02 around it. Uh really, Elon, uh let's
12:05 talk about what
12:06 >> for months on end. Don't you think just
12:07 for months on end this is going to go
12:09 on? I mean, how it'd be hard to manage
12:11 the company during
12:12 >> Not unless Yeah. Not unless they do it
12:13 today.
12:14 >> And as Joe pointed out, look, a Chinese
12:16 spy in one hand trouble with the United
12:18 States government and then an employee
12:20 on the other HR. How does the board not
12:22 handle
12:23 >> exactly
12:25 >> right Elon uh and then you know Elon's
12:29 personal life pretty interesting uh
12:30 anyway he's joining the conversation
12:32 saying not that I care and not that it's
12:34 any of my business saying he's open to
12:35 hiring Jensen Wong if uh inv video lets
12:37 its CEO go last night the financial blog
12:40 Zero Hedge wrote on X uh Elon please
12:45 hire Jensen Musk responded that would be
12:47 an honor
12:49 >> coming up uh much Yeah. Yeah. Go ahead,
12:52 Andrew.
12:52 >> Well, no. All I was going to mention is
12:54 if you really think about the companies
12:56 that are exposed in a certain way to
13:00 Nvidia,
13:02 Elon 500 as
13:05 >> as connected as anything. No, no. in so
13:07 far as Elon's gone all in on Nvidia
13:09 chips, open AI too, but you know
13:12 >> the the vehicles, uh, Optimus,
13:15 >> um, everything he's trying to do in
13:17 terms of the terapabs, it's all based on
13:20 Nvidia chips. He's and and he has this
13:23 special relationship with with Jensen 2,
13:25 who's privileged him in terms of access
13:27 to those chips. And so, you know, you
13:29 start to think about you start to think
13:31 about the access. You certain companies
13:32 have had better access. Core, we've got
13:34 some early access. There's other
13:35 companies got, you know, Apollo's trying
13:37 to have
13:39 >> That's interesting. Does that change the
13:41 chips?
13:42 >> Yeah.
13:42 >> Yeah.
13:43 >> If you had a different CEO, it is all
13:45 based on personal relationships. How
13:46 would all of that work? That actually is
13:48 where the implication is, I think.
13:49 >> That's interesting.
13:50 >> And it's also if he leaves Nvidia, okay,
13:53 so he he paid the price, then he could
13:56 go somewhere else. Well, yeah, we've
13:57 already litigated that and we already we
14:00 knew we knew what we were getting and he
14:02 could go somewhere else, Andrew.
14:04 just he's got to leave Nvidia it seems
14:06 like.
14:06 >> Yeah. But then if you're if you're the
14:08 Nvidia board, you look at this and
14:10 you're like, how do you not from a
14:11 governance perspective take it on,
14:13 >> right?
14:14 >> Then if you have the idea that, oh my
14:15 gosh, now we're going to compete against
14:16 the only guy who has ever run the
14:18 company, one of the co-founders of the
14:19 company who's been there 30 years. Um,
14:22 >> right,
14:22 >> that's a scary prospect, too.
14:24 >> And then you just have to the AI trade
14:26 is so big and it's so all-encompassing.
14:28 It's not one person, but there are
14:30 articles written that the whole AI trade
14:33 is now in question or at least at risk
14:36 or at least uh trembling because
14:39 >> what Andrew mentioned about that, you
14:40 know, half a trillion dollars in
14:41 financing not necessarily being there at
14:43 this point. Um
14:44 >> it's uh we didn't expect this, I'll tell
14:47 you that much.
14:50 >> SquawkPod will be right back.
14:57 You're listening to Squawk Pod.
14:59 >> Good morning. Welcome back to Squawk
15:01 Fox. We are live at the NASDAQ market
15:02 site in Times Square.
15:05 That's where Joe and Becky are this
15:06 morning.
15:07 >> Nvidia shares down again this morning as
15:09 the company's board considers ousting
15:11 its CEO. In the meantime, we're learning
15:13 more about Alice Wong, the woman accused
15:15 of being a Chinese spy who had an affair
15:18 with Jensen Wong. Ununice Yun joins us
15:20 right now with the latest on that.
15:22 Ununice, good morning. Good morning,
15:24 Becky. Well, Alex Wong is reportedly in
15:26 Beijing. Bloomberg is citing sources as
15:29 saying that uh she is here under the
15:31 close close um watchful eye of the
15:34 Chinese authorities. Uh when asked about
15:36 this, the foreign ministry had no
15:39 comment and when we called her number
15:42 that was listed on her business card, uh
15:44 no one picked up. Now, Alex Wong, Alex
15:47 Wang is uh someone who has built a
15:49 career in finance before moving into uh
15:52 the data center business um essentially
15:54 being an executive running a Singaporean
15:57 company that's been accused of smuggling
16:00 Nvidia chips. She's uh viewed here as in
16:04 China publicly as what's known as a
16:07 chenu. So somebody who is a commercial
16:10 fixer and that is a business persona who
16:13 uh drifts uh towards money-making
16:15 opportunities and then leverages off of
16:18 her contacts. So this is how people here
16:20 are explaining why she would be so
16:23 public about her connections with Jensen
16:26 Hong. It was seen as a marketing uh a
16:29 way for her to market her access to
16:31 those chips. And it's also a reason why
16:33 there are many people within the Chinese
16:35 business community who think that she
16:36 might not have been a spy in the sense
16:38 of um a trained intelligence agent, but
16:42 she could have been approached uh for
16:45 information uh by the Ministry of State
16:48 Security. Uh there has been an impact
16:50 though um this whole scandal has had an
16:53 impact on the underground trade of
16:55 Nvidia chips. Um I was speaking with uh
16:58 one uh chip smuggler who said that
17:01 there's been a pause now into next week
17:04 uh through APEC u because of the scandal
17:07 and also because of the expectation that
17:09 there's going to be greater US scrutiny
17:11 uh due to President Trump coming in.
17:13 I've been told that the price of eight
17:16 um B300 chips has uh now reached uh come
17:20 up five times from May at now nearly $3
17:23 million. This is versus the official US
17:26 price of $550,000.
17:29 China AI stocks tank today because of
17:31 this expectation here that the US is
17:34 going to hit harder when it comes to
17:36 export curbs on Nvidia chips. The uh
17:40 traders though uh don't think that the
17:43 demand is going to go away anytime soon.
17:46 They see the prices remaining quite
17:48 robust uh because they said that they're
17:50 seeing hoarding. Guys,
17:52 >> Unice, that's really interesting. I mean
17:54 the the stock market reaction there
17:56 suggests that these were chips that were
17:58 far easier to get your hands on than
18:01 would be implied by what the US export
18:05 controls have said to this point
18:07 >> and just the idea that the prices have
18:09 jumped that much at the idea of
18:11 additional scrutiny.
18:13 >> Right. Absolutely. I mean that's why we
18:14 saw like Alibaba's stock is down 7%. uh
18:18 you know that was one company that um
18:20 was supposedly a uh potential customer
18:23 of Mega Speed, the company that Alice
18:25 Wong had helped manage. Uh Alibaba has
18:28 no comment about that, but there was
18:31 this expectation or this belief that a
18:33 lot of these Chinese companies have been
18:35 looking for different workarounds in
18:36 order to gain access to Nvidia chips.
18:39 >> What do we think of the idea that, you
18:41 know, these H200 chips from Nvidia were
18:44 allowed to be sold earlier this year?
18:47 And the reports were, well, the Chinese
18:49 government didn't want them. Was was
18:51 that just a cover? Were these companies
18:53 looking for those chips anyway?
18:55 >> From from what I understand, the H200
18:57 chips are still very advanced. Uh but
19:00 you know, as we've seen throughout this
19:02 year, the Chinese government has a very
19:04 conflicted relationship um when it comes
19:06 to Nvidia because um we've already heard
19:09 like earlier this week, there were um
19:11 reports that there were, you know,
19:12 600,000 uh H200 chips that were sitting
19:16 in a Hong Kong port that were supposed
19:17 to be coming in, but then weren't
19:19 allowed to come in. And that uh because
19:21 the government here does want to develop
19:23 its own um industry, it doesn't
19:26 necessarily want to have so many Nvidia
19:28 chips here. But when I speak to uh
19:31 people who um are in the AI industry um
19:34 they have said that they cannot do
19:36 without the NVIDIA chips and a lot of
19:38 them said that they don't even want to
19:39 mess around with some of the um local
19:42 chips if they don't have to.
19:44 >> Uh Nikki Haley suggested that President
19:48 Trump should not meet with President Xi
19:50 next week because of the fallout from
19:52 this. What what would be the push back?
19:55 What would happen if that meeting did
19:56 not play take place next week?
19:59 I think that would be pretty bad uh
20:01 because of the fact that the marketing
20:04 around APE is that uh this is uh
20:07 Xiinping's time. He's here to have all
20:10 these different companies uh countries
20:12 and companies actually come to him and
20:15 it's really a time for for China to be
20:16 able to show off and shine. So, um, a
20:19 lot of people have told me that that
20:20 the, um, authorities here want these,
20:23 uh, leaders and the companies to walk
20:25 away thinking that China is essential to
20:28 their business or to their trade. And so
20:31 if President Trump uh decided suddenly
20:33 to pull out at this late stage and not
20:35 show up um that could be taken very
20:38 badly especially because um culturally
20:41 here a Chinese the Chinese you know face
20:44 is just so much more important here than
20:46 it is say in the United States.
20:48 >> Right. Ununice Yun Ununice thank you
20:51 very much. So guys, um I immediately
20:54 thought that Stone Cipher, remember
20:56 Boeing, uh he had Ander, he had some
20:58 apartment in Chicago that that went and
21:01 but
21:01 >> moved the company headquarters there.
21:02 >> Yeah, moved it. This just joged my
21:04 memory though. Mark Herd,
21:06 >> anyone? Anyone? Hullet Packer. Brian
21:09 Kzanic. Anyone in Intel?
21:12 >> Intel. Yeah.
21:13 >> Um Steve Rasterbrook.
21:15 >> McDonald's.
21:16 >> McDonald's. That one I thought of
21:17 earlier. McDonald's.
21:17 >> Um I forgot all these several.
21:20 >> Best Buy. Um it just uh it's not
21:23 >> you go down the list
21:25 >> and every one of those CEOs is gone. It
21:27 >> it's gone. But then
21:29 >> you can manage around it like you know
21:31 if you have divorces and stuff like
21:34 >> single like that was that I thought
21:36 maybe he would survive that at first.
21:38 >> Exactly. But guys get divorced and you
21:40 know Bezos or whatever things happen and
21:43 and um you can be too big to fail I
21:46 think. Um is is there any way that's the
21:49 case here? I I can't I don't know. What
21:51 do you think?
21:53 >> I think the Chinese spy one is the
21:54 toughest one and issues of national
21:56 security.
21:58 >> I think the employee one, oddly enough,
22:01 I I think the employee one might be the
22:03 one that's harder for the board or maybe
22:05 the combination of both.
22:07 >> I don't know.
22:08 >> You know,
22:09 >> if you're the board if you're the board,
22:11 >> look, the board's already being sued. Um
22:14 so, you know, there are going to be
22:16 lawsuits that come from this. That's got
22:17 to play into some of these issues, too.
22:20 Um,
22:21 >> well, but it also glad you're not on
22:23 right now.
22:24 >> I just think if you're the board, how do
22:25 you how would how are you going to
22:27 operate the company?
22:28 >> Yeah.
22:28 >> Meaning, how could he operate the
22:30 company on a daily basis right now?
22:32 >> You you can't, right? Cuz you're going
22:34 to be with lawyers yourself all day.
22:39 >> Up next, China chips. What's left for
22:42 our policy with US Trade Representative
22:44 Jameson Greer. but a view inside the
22:47 administration uh that for whatever
22:49 reason commerce has not moved as fast on
22:53 this as the president has wanted. Can
22:55 you speak to any of this?
22:56 >> Well, I I usually don't comment on on
22:58 the gossip rags and certainly not with
23:00 conversations that that may have
23:01 happened in the local office and
23:03 situation rooms or sensitive
23:04 discussions. I I'll just say that uh you
23:07 know national security is of paramount
23:08 importance to the president.
23:15 Welcome back to Squawk Pod from CNBC.
23:17 We'll jump right into it. Here's Joe.
23:21 >> Joining us now, United States Trade
23:23 Representative, Ambassador uh Jameson
23:25 Greer. Mr. Ambassador, it's good to uh
23:27 to have you on this morning. Welcome.
23:29 >> Good to be here. Thanks for having me.
23:31 >> I don't see how we can um we can just
23:33 talk about anything other than uh what
23:35 we've been talking about all morning. Uh
23:37 what do you make of the the situation at
23:40 Nvidia? uh Jensen Wong, do do you know
23:43 anything we don't know about uh getting
23:46 around export controls and and what may
23:49 have happened, what might have
23:50 transpired? Well, obviously Nvidia is a
23:54 structurally important company. Uh we're
23:56 seeing fluctuations of course and their
23:59 stock value and things like that. Those
24:00 are dayto-day. Uh the reality is the the
24:03 AI buildout, data centers, the next
24:05 industrial revolution that's happening.
24:07 Um obviously from time to time you have
24:10 uh you have scandal or you have
24:12 developments at companies with
24:13 leadership etc. uh that's being you know
24:16 if you listen to Nvidia they have their
24:17 own investigation going on the board's
24:19 looking at it on the US government side
24:21 uh export control agency and the
24:23 commerce department uh they have things
24:25 they go through they have a career staff
24:27 that focus on uh you know potential
24:30 problems. There have been uh a number of
24:32 enforcement actions over the past year,
24:34 two years uh looking into a variety of
24:36 of issues and obviously we remain
24:39 concerned. Uh we want to make sure that
24:41 uh when we're selling our chips to the
24:43 world, we want the world to be on the AI
24:44 stack, but we want the crown jewels uh
24:46 to remain in US hands or in the hands of
24:48 our allies. you you have rec recently
24:52 made some just overall comments uh about
24:56 China and and past trade commitments
24:59 that they've made and and you would like
25:01 them to comply. Are they not complying
25:04 at this point?
25:05 >> Well, it's a it's a partial compliance
25:07 is how we look at it. They committed to
25:10 buy 25 million metric tons of soybeans
25:12 this year. They've done that or they've
25:14 made purchases to that effect or they've
25:15 or they've booked orders to that effect.
25:17 When it comes to rare earths, uh, we're
25:19 getting some of what we need. We always
25:22 want to have it at a at a quicker pace
25:24 and in a higher volume. We'd like it to
25:26 be at the same levels that it was, you
25:27 know, a few years ago, uh, before they
25:29 started cracking down on rare earth at
25:31 the tail end of the Biden administration
25:33 and then again during during our
25:34 administration. They have agricultural
25:36 commitments to buy uh, additional
25:38 billions of dollars worth in non-
25:40 soybean a. Uh, they've made some
25:42 progress on that, but we'd like to see
25:43 see more. So, it's not perfect
25:44 compliance, and this is something that
25:46 we'll talk about in Shenzen next week
25:47 with uh the Chinese side.
25:49 >> We had uh the president make I don't
25:52 know whether it was an off-hand comment
25:53 or or whether it's something that's in
25:56 the works about some caravans of illegal
25:59 uh u immigrants making their way towards
26:03 the US from Mexico if that if that were
26:05 to happen. And he mentioned the the new
26:08 the governor elect of Texas. I don't
26:10 know whether implying that maybe the
26:11 border would be open again, but he said
26:14 an immediate doubling of of tariffs on
26:16 Mexico. Can you shed any light on that?
26:19 Is that is that likely?
26:20 >> Well, well, remember one of the reasons
26:22 the president was elected was to
26:25 normalize the situation at the border,
26:26 which he did quickly. And now with the
26:29 uh the results of the midterms, I think
26:31 people in other countries think it's
26:32 going to be open season again at the
26:34 border. It won't be. the president's
26:35 prepared to take whatever measures he
26:37 needs to, economic or otherwise, uh, to
26:40 maintain the gains that he made in
26:41 shutting down that border. Uh, and so
26:43 I'll I'll work with him if he needs to
26:45 take economic measures.
26:47 >> What is there anything going on? Uh,
26:49 we've heard some rumors about some
26:52 progress being made with our our trading
26:54 partners to the north,
26:56 >> Canada.
26:57 >> Sure. I mean, we we we engage in regular
27:00 conversations uh with our trading
27:02 partners. Uh the president talks to
27:04 Prime Minister Carney with some
27:05 regularity which is what you would
27:06 expect uh for for two countries that
27:08 share the longest undefended land border
27:10 in the world. Uh we regularly speak with
27:12 them uh including within the past few
27:14 days. Uh again they they they would love
27:17 to go back to how things used to be
27:19 where there's just unfettered free trade
27:21 between our two countries. Uh we want to
27:23 have a deal that makes sense for them
27:24 and and for us. Uh part of it means
27:26 protecting our supply chains and getting
27:28 them here. Uh but also making
27:30 accommodation where possible. So there's
27:31 been conversations to that effect. I
27:33 don't want to give a timeline on any of
27:35 that because the substance of the deal
27:37 is more important than a timeline, but
27:38 we certainly are working on it.
27:39 >> Mr. Ambassador, during the sort of the
27:42 post-mortem on the the election,
27:45 Republicans uh obviously licking their
27:49 wounds, looking at a lot of things that
27:50 had to do with affordability. Do you
27:52 think the tariff issue uh it it it did
27:55 come up in exit polls that that that
27:58 maybe exacerbated
28:00 uh the the feeling that people weren't
28:02 weren't keeping up with inflation? Uh is
28:06 are is it full steam ahead in the
28:08 president's view and in your view still
28:09 at this point? Well, when people talk
28:11 about affordability and you look at the
28:13 polls and you look at everything and you
28:14 look at the actual data, uh people are
28:17 really concerned about the cost of
28:18 energy, the cost of gas, and some of the
28:20 price effects we see in our downstream
28:22 from that uh fuel in transportation and
28:25 and transporting goods that that people
28:27 have. I mean, I think we've talked about
28:28 this before when it comes to food, for
28:31 example, the vast majority of food we
28:33 eat in America is in your grocery uh
28:35 cart is made here in America, no duties
28:37 or we import it from Canada and Mexico
28:39 with no duties. So the so the vast
28:41 amount of food just it's not subject to
28:42 tariffs. Never has been. Gas and oil was
28:44 never subject to tariffs. Uh you know so
28:47 I think what the president's view is
28:48 we're going to in my view is we're going
28:50 to keep taking trade actions as
28:51 necessary. I think what we hear what I
28:53 hear from the other side is people don't
28:56 like you know some people characterize
28:58 some of the tariffs as chaotic or
28:59 reckless. Uh you know some people want
29:01 to have more stability with Canada. I
29:02 just talked to you about working on a
29:04 deal with Canada. Uh you know I I agree
29:06 on wanting to have certainty uh on
29:08 tariffs. You know, if I could stop
29:10 having Democrat attorneys general try to
29:12 overturn tariffs or turn a blind eye to
29:14 force labor in other countries and do
29:15 these kinds of things, we could have we
29:17 could have some more of that stability.
29:18 But I look forward to working with
29:19 Congress. Uh to be honest, I think we've
29:22 seen nuance language from some members
29:23 up there about uh tariffs that make
29:26 sense and tariffs that could be helpful.
29:28 So I think there's room to work with
29:29 them.
29:33 Second, uh there there's a report in
29:35 Axios that says that last Thursday you
29:38 were a participant in a meeting uh with
29:40 Bessant Hegsth Rubio, but maybe most
29:44 importantly Lutnik uh where Bessant
29:46 confronted Lutnik over this issue of uh
29:50 chips going to companies, specifically
29:52 Mega Speed. Um and there was a moment at
29:55 which Lutnik appears to say, "I need to
29:56 check with the president." uh the issue
29:59 is then forced. You all walk over to the
30:01 Oval Office. The president effectively
30:04 then says we need to deal with this. Uh
30:07 but a view inside the administration uh
30:10 that for whatever reason commerce has
30:12 not moved as fast on this as the
30:15 president has wanted. Can you speak to
30:16 any of this?
30:17 >> Well, I I usually don't comment on on
30:19 the gossip rags and certainly not with
30:21 conversations that that may have
30:22 happened in the local office and
30:24 situation rooms or sensitive
30:25 discussions. I I'll just say that uh you
30:28 know national security is of paramount
30:29 importance to the presidents. It's of
30:31 paramount important to all of us. Uh you
30:33 know those of us on the economic and
30:35 national security files talk about this
30:37 frequently almost every day. Uh I I
30:39 think if you want further comment you
30:41 know turning to the commerce department
30:42 who who owns the the the agency on that
30:45 point. But this is something that's
30:46 super important to us. The president's
30:47 taken a lot of actions enforcement
30:49 actions. Remember he he geared up uh all
30:52 these export control rules in his first
30:54 term in the first place. So, it's
30:55 important to us.
30:56 >> Can can you speak to just one other
30:57 issue, which is the president very
30:59 specifically uh at that press conference
31:02 earlier this week said that he was
31:04 unaware at the time that they that you
31:07 guys made the trip to China about this
31:10 relationship that Jensen Wong had. And
31:13 then reporting has since emerged uh that
31:16 he was both notified about it months
31:19 earlier but also very specifically by
31:21 Marco Rubio on Air Force One before
31:25 Jensen Wong got on that plane. U were
31:28 you aware of it and do you know if the
31:30 president was aware of it?
31:31 >> Well, I'll just say when it comes to,
31:34 you know, intelligence community content
31:36 or briefings, that's certainly not
31:37 something that we disclose or that we
31:39 talk about uh on on national TV. I'll
31:42 just say that our intelligence community
31:43 is is active. Of course, they're always
31:45 trying to track all kinds of issues,
31:46 national security, economic security
31:48 issues. Uh the president and other
31:50 members of the cabinet, myself included,
31:51 are are briefed regularly. Um you know,
31:54 when you look when you look at the news,
31:55 they don't have access uh to
31:57 intelligence. Uh and so I would just be
32:00 cautious when we look at some of those
32:01 reports about uh who had what when.
32:04 >> Yeah. Ambassador, obviously um you can't
32:06 comment on a lot of the reports that are
32:07 out there, but I will ask you, are you
32:09 frustrated
32:11 um that there hasn't been access cut off
32:13 by to mega speed more quickly in terms
32:16 of access to Nvidia chips?
32:18 >> So, so I I think what you're talking
32:19 about here is the perhaps the also
32:22 remote access, a couple of companies
32:24 that are that are in the news right now
32:26 about uh potentially smuggling or or
32:28 have some suspicion around them.
32:30 Correct. the the some of some some of
32:31 these questions have been around for
32:33 quite some time. Under the Biden
32:34 administration, there was discussion
32:35 about remote access, cutting that off.
32:37 They they declined to do that. Uh there
32:39 are always active discussions about
32:41 this. We continue to have active
32:42 discussions about this in the
32:43 administration. Uh we're sensitive to
32:45 these issues. Uh you know, my own my own
32:48 sense, you know, anyone who knows me has
32:49 known me for a long time. Uh it's
32:51 important for us to uh sell the US tech
32:54 overseas, but it's also really important
32:55 to make sure that the crown jewels
32:56 remain the crown jewels. Uh so I I think
32:59 that uh you will see continued attention
33:01 on this issue and especially in light of
33:03 things that have been uh disclosed or
33:04 announced in recent days. I think
33:06 there'll be a focus on this and if
33:07 further actions needed
33:09 >> will will there will this be an issue
33:10 that is brought up next week with
33:12 President Xi at APEC.
33:14 >> So that I doubt uh these are
33:16 conversations about economic uh security
33:19 and export controls are not things we
33:21 negotiate uh with the Chinese. These are
33:23 internal affairs for us. Uh they
33:25 certainly raise them. They like to talk
33:27 about them sometimes. They don't really
33:28 press us on it because they know uh it's
33:30 something these are domestic affairs. Uh
33:32 we'll decide what our export controls
33:34 are uh and that's how it will be. It
33:36 >> it would it be your brothers that that
33:38 we
33:40 enforce these controls these export
33:42 controls more strenuously?
33:44 >> Well, I think you need to enforce them
33:46 appropriately. I think that again
33:48 President Trump initiated these types of
33:50 export controls in his first term. The
33:52 Biden people kept them and expanded
33:53 them. Uh this administration has
33:55 continued to do this and conducts
33:57 investigations where necessary. Uh so I
33:59 I think that whenever there's
34:00 information that there may be problems,
34:02 uh you can count on the administration
34:04 investigating it.
34:05 >> Mr. Ambassador, the the what we talked
34:08 about with with Canada and the
34:09 willingness to maybe look at at trying
34:11 to bring down uh some of the the tariffs
34:13 with with that country, is it part of an
34:15 overall uh I guess I asked you this
34:18 earlier, but I ask you in a different
34:19 way, an overall softening of of that
34:22 part of of what of the president's
34:26 um policies and and you know, you
34:28 mentioned that food doesn't necessarily
34:29 add into to affordability, but I think
34:33 there's been estimates that maybe a,000
34:35 or,00 $00 a year added to the average
34:38 American's expenses uh in a year because
34:41 of tariffs. Um the the on 60 Minutes the
34:44 president seemed to soften his his uh
34:46 stance on some immigration on on people
34:49 that have been here 10 20 years. Is the
34:51 same thing happening in hindsight with
34:53 what happened during the election with
34:54 tariffs or would you say that that it's
34:56 full speed ahead with with rebalancing
34:59 global trade?
35:00 >> Well, we we have to rebalance global
35:02 trade. No, with the Democrats uh you
35:05 know gaining in the midterms that has
35:07 not changed the fact that we have a
35:08 trillion dollar trade deficit or that
35:09 China has a trillion dollar trade
35:11 surplus or that there are unfair trading
35:13 practices or foreign barriers across the
35:14 world. None of that has changed. Uh the
35:16 idea that we need to re-industrialize is
35:18 a nonpartisan idea. Uh so these are
35:21 things that are going to go forward. I I
35:22 think you know the feedback we get
35:25 frankly from the Democrats and the other
35:26 side is again people they they don't
35:28 like the appearance of of of
35:30 recklessness or other things in the
35:31 tariff program to be clear you know we
35:33 haven't made wide swings in the tariff
35:35 program for for many many months uh
35:38 sometimes when people say they want
35:39 certainty they're saying I want to go
35:40 back to to no tariffs I want to import
35:42 uh freely from China and other places
35:44 that's not going to happen uh for 10
35:46 years we've been going on a pathway
35:47 across administrations across parties of
35:50 trying to protect domestic industry
35:52 I think you know you referred to some
35:54 studies I think it's from the New York
35:55 Fed about $1,100. If you look in the
35:58 past six months or in the first half of
36:00 this year we collected $130 billion in
36:02 tariff revenue when you look at overall
36:05 consumption in in the economy during
36:07 that first half of the year goods and
36:09 services personal and government it's
36:11 like 13 trillion so we're talking about
36:13 $130 billion tariff tariff revenue on 13
36:16 trillion of consumption that's like 1%.
36:18 Uh so I this is not this is not
36:20 something uh that can get all the way
36:22 through in the types of way that that
36:24 the that the New York Fed analyzed. I
36:26 mean we even had Carolyn Freud at UC San
36:28 Diego two months ago came out and said
36:30 now that we have more data it looks like
36:32 foreign exporters absorbed 50% of
36:35 tariffs. So so whatever people think
36:37 it's it's at least half of that and
36:39 probably more. So I I think we've
36:41 learned a lot in the past situation. uh
36:43 uh you know we we've we've taken tariffs
36:45 off of things we don't grow uh things
36:47 where that are in short supply and
36:49 things where we're trying to reshore
36:50 we'll continue to have a protective
36:51 tariff.
36:52 >> Okay, Ambassador Gre, thank you. Thanks
36:54 for your time.
36:55 >> Okay,
36:58 >> there's news flash just in on this that
37:00 we want to make sure we bring to you
37:01 right away. Um it says that Jensen Wong
37:04 is making a transition here.
37:06 >> Yeah. and uh the news that that I guess
37:09 we've kind of been
37:10 >> resigning effective immediately um not
37:13 being the board not having to make the
37:14 decision on this that Jensen Wong is
37:16 resigning effective immediately.
37:18 >> This was kind I felt like we were kind
37:20 of on um smoke watch for the pope um
37:24 throughout this time after hearing this
37:25 news last night. So Jensen Wong saying
37:27 that he is resigning immediately from
37:29 Nvidia. Nvidia shares which have been
37:31 down more than 8% this morning now down
37:33 by about 9 9 and a half%. So in keeping
37:36 with what um had been happening there,
37:38 there had been expectations that uh the
37:41 board might have to act to remove. In
37:42 fact, if you were looking at Cali or any
37:44 of the betting sites, the odds of him
37:46 stepping down or being removed had been
37:48 increas increasing sharply. Again, this
37:51 is all we know at this point that
37:54 Invidia's Jensen Wong is stepping down
37:56 immediately, resigning from his post as
37:59 uh chairman and CEO of Nvidia. That's
38:02 all we know at this point. And I
38:05 was this you moving on to breaking on
38:07 other things. I think we have a new CEO
38:09 that we're going to put the name at the
38:11 bottom. I I would assume uh as
38:14 >> Colette Crest Yeah. is the CFO is going
38:17 to be continuing. Uh I'm not sure where
38:19 we're getting some of these stories at
38:20 this point, but Colette Crest is
38:22 appointed the interim CEO. She's the CFO
38:25 and had been the name had been most
38:27 mentioned as a potential replacement for
38:29 Jensen Wong. Remember, Jensen Wong was a
38:32 co-founder of this company, has been the
38:34 only CEO to ever lead this company. Um,
38:36 and the stock has suffered greatly over
38:38 the course of this last week. We're
38:40 looking right now at the stock down by
38:41 about 10%. If you look over the course
38:44 of this week to date, which has only
38:46 been three trading sessions to this
38:47 point, if you conclude the premarket
38:49 with this, if you're looking at the
38:50 week-toate numbers, you will see that
38:52 that stock is down 16%.
38:53 >> They have a new they have a new chair of
38:55 the board who's the
38:56 >> Harvey Jones. Jones, first ever chair
39:00 chairman of the board
39:01 >> and John Jensen also resigning from the
39:03 board as well as president and CEO.
39:07 >> His ownership his ownership as
39:09 co-founder of the company 3.6% but that
39:11 does not um nearly um color the picture
39:15 for how much influence he has had over
39:17 this company. He has been seen
39:19 singularly as the person that built and
39:22 uh not only this company but was
39:23 responsible largely for bringing along a
39:25 lot of the AI buildout and pushing the
39:28 AI infrastructure build out uh beyond
39:30 just this again
39:32 >> stock is now down double digits down by
39:34 about 10 uh 10 and a half% as we
39:36 continue to watch this
39:39 >> you know guys it's going to be very
39:41 interesting to see you know now the
39:43 stock's coming back a little bit just
39:44 marginally we'll see uh the CFO of the
39:47 of all of the people uh and I I was on
39:50 the phone with a bunch of people last
39:51 night in the investment community trying
39:52 to understand what they thought about
39:54 it. Uh the CFO was perhaps the only
39:56 person uh that they felt that they that
39:58 the investment world uh knew uh along
40:01 with some other of the suppliers and and
40:04 and partners and the like and that's
40:07 going to be a huge part of this job. I
40:10 mean it's not just being an I mean an
40:12 ambassador but there is going to be a
40:14 role of of of being able to connect to
40:16 the investor community. Uh at least the
40:18 one thing I'll say is that
40:20 >> this is an interim position. The board
40:22 is initiating a search for a permanent
40:24 chief executive officer and will
40:25 consider both internal and external
40:27 candidates. You have to assume that
40:28 Crest would be one of the internal
40:30 candidates that they're considering for
40:32 this. Uh but it does say that the board
40:34 is initiating a search for a permanent
40:36 CEO at this point. Crest has been the
40:39 executive vice president and CF CFO of
40:41 the company since she joined in
40:44 September of 2013. So she has some time
40:46 here. She's certainly trusted by Wall
40:48 Street. Um she's led the company's
40:51 finance organization while she's been
40:52 there. She's played a key role in
40:53 Nvidia's growth and evolution. Before
40:56 that, she spent nearly 25 years in
40:58 finance roles at companies including
41:00 Cisco and Microsoft. Um yeah, this is uh
41:07 maybe not completely unexpected. The
41:08 stock 10 down to 10.3% but it was off by
41:11 more than 8% before this news came out.
41:13 Andrew,
41:14 >> right?
41:15 >> Again, to me the big questions and we
41:17 should see what the other stocks are
41:18 trading either in sympathy with or or
41:20 without. You know, so many of the the
41:23 relationships that Jensen has are
41:25 personal. Uh we talked about the
41:27 relationship with SpaceX and Elon Musk.
41:30 uh the fact that they are all in on
41:31 Nvidia chips and have been privileged in
41:33 in a way uh to get access to those chips
41:36 ahead of uh other competitors. Uh I
41:39 remember talking to I think both Elon
41:41 and Sam Alman many years ago when they
41:43 talked about how Jensen physically
41:45 brought over uh one of the first chips
41:47 that was going to power uh what turned
41:49 out to be open AI and so getting access
41:52 to those chips. Coreweave Open AI has
41:55 huge exposure to Nvidia and who runs the
41:58 company and and is able to connect that
42:00 access I think is going to be super
42:02 important. Again, the other piece of
42:04 this is going to be about the
42:05 relationship that the CEO has uh with
42:07 the CEO of TSMC uh which is uh basically
42:11 the most important relationship beyond
42:15 some of the the some of the political
42:16 relationships as well that that come
42:18 into play here. It was just October 6th
42:22 239 on the stock price. So the
42:24 >> stock has lost more than
42:26 >> 27% 23% I thought since October 6. Maybe
42:29 including maybe including today's
42:30 losses.
42:30 >> Maybe including today's Yeah, because
42:32 I'm looking at Yeah, it's 154.
42:35 >> Yeah,
42:35 >> the close was 173. So if you use 154,
42:39 it's a third of its
42:40 >> a third of its value over the course of
42:43 >> which was a big value trillions. Five
42:46 trillion. This was the largest company
42:48 on the planet as recently as a couple of
42:50 months ago. It's only um very recently
42:52 been uh outedged by Apple uh $5
42:56 trillion, but we have watched again a
42:58 third of its market cap rode.
43:00 >> Yeah.
43:00 >> I just I think we we want to just bring
43:02 Jim Kramer into this conversation as
43:04 well. I think uh we can get him on the
43:06 line. Uh he of course has been a
43:08 longtime uh supporter of this stock and
43:10 of Jensen. And what's your reaction?
43:13 >> Well, look, I think it had to happen. I
43:15 think that there's way too much uh
43:17 evidence. I think that he's been
43:19 negotiating for a bit obviously to try
43:21 to figure out where to go. Look, I like
43:23 Colette very much, Colette Crest. I I
43:25 close to her, spoke to her, I don't
43:27 know, hundreds of times. And I think
43:28 she's going to be terrific in trying to
43:30 figure out where the pieces are. Uh I
43:32 know all the analysts have to cut and
43:33 run. They all think that that there's
43:35 42,000 other people there who have
43:37 absolutely no bearing whatsoever because
43:39 the way the company set the was set up
43:41 by Jensen. I think that's just not true.
43:42 Do I want to buy the stock right now?
43:44 who the hell knows what the stock is,
43:45 but I do think that Colette at least uh
43:48 knows how to run, has been the person
43:50 who's been the spokesperson for the
43:51 company for a very long time, and I
43:54 think she'll provide some needed order.
43:55 So, I'm glad that she's the one that
43:57 they've given it to.
43:59 >> When you think about where the stock is
44:00 right now, Jim, uh we're at about 156
44:04 bucks.
44:06 >> I think it's going to be down 10%. It
44:08 should be down 10%, maybe 15. These
44:09 analysts all they're, you know, they're
44:11 rats on a sinking ship. They wanted out
44:13 really bad.
44:14 >> Chriso Chris Casso joined us this
44:15 morning. He actually said with or
44:17 without Jensen this is a buy as he sees
44:19 it at this point.
44:20 >> Well, you know, look, I understand that.
44:22 I I just think that there's a lot of
44:24 investigations that have to occur.
44:26 They report next week. I think it's been
44:28 a really good quarter. They can guide
44:29 up. If Colette, who's really the keeper
44:31 of everything in coming the money, says,
44:32 "Look, we can do a big buyback." That's
44:34 one thing. If they have a guy, uh, I
44:36 think probably have to go outside now
44:38 because who knows how many people knew
44:39 about Kimberly Pal, which is a really
44:41 big problem. She did report directly to
44:43 him healthcare. But as far as I'm
44:46 concerned, it it's a new day and we have
44:48 to see what a company that has 42,000
44:50 people who are probably to some degree
44:52 insulted that they don't seem to matter
44:55 can do things. This company is not made
44:57 up of doofuses. It's made up of really
44:59 brilliant people and I think that Jensen
45:01 proudly put them together.
45:03 >> All right. That uh that is going
45:05 >> big news. Yeah.
45:06 >> Big.
45:09 >> Whoa. Breaking news live, digested in
45:12 real time. That's the magic of
45:14 Squawkbox. And we're bringing it right
45:16 into your ears in Squawk Pod every day.
45:19 Follow and listen to this podcast on
45:21 YouTube, Spotify, Apple Podcasts,
45:23 wherever works for you. Just join us.
45:25 Squawkbox is hosted by Joe Kernan, Becky
45:28 Quick, and Andrew Ross Sorcin. So, what
45:30 could happen tomorrow? We'll meet you
45:32 right back here then. You don't want to
45:34 miss it.
45:35 >> We are clear. Thanks, guys.
The Investment Committee reacts to Nvidia's stock after Jensen Huang's resignation full transcript
0:00 CEO JENSEN WONG'S LARGER THAN
0:02 LIFE VISION INTO NUMBERS. BACK
0:05 TO YOU.
0:06 >> SEEMA MODY WITH THE VERY
0:07 LATEST ON NVIDIA, NVIDIA SHARES
0:08 PULLING BACK JUST ABOUT 5%. AND
0:10 NOW WE GET TO OUR TRADE ALERT.
0:12 STEPHANIE LINK WANT TO COME
0:13 OVER TO YOU. YOU SOLD YOUR
0:15 NVIDIA SHARES. JUST GIVE US
0:16 SOME CONTEXT. YOU BOUGHT BACK
0:17 ON JULY 8TH AT ABOUT 204. YOU
0:19 SOLD YESTERDAY. KIND OF GIVE US
0:21 THE THESIS ON WHY YOU DECIDED
0:22 TO GET OUT.
0:23 >> YEAH, IT.
0:24 >> WAS REALLY HARD.
0:25 >> DECISION THOUGH, FRANK,
0:26 BECAUSE THE FUNDAMENTALS ARE
0:27 VERY, VERY STRONG AT THIS
0:28 COMPANY. AND I EXPECT THE
0:29 QUARTER NEXT WEEK TO BE VERY
0:31 GOOD WITH $300 BILLION IN FREE
0:32 CASH FLOW. NEXT YEAR THEY'RE
0:34 GOING TO GROW REVENUES IN 28 OF
0:37 70% IN GROSS MARGINS IN THE MID
0:39 70S. BUT THIS STOCK IS NOT
0:40 GOING TO TRADE ON FUNDAMENTALS.
0:42 I DON'T THINK FOR A WHILE
0:43 BECAUSE YOU HAVE THE OVERHANG
0:45 OF THE INVESTIGATIONS OF
0:46 LEADERSHIP CHANGES OF POTENTIAL
0:49 DEPARTURES. AND SO I THINK IT'S
0:50 REALLY FOR ME AS AS AN INVESTOR,
0:52 I'M THINKING THE OPPORTUNITY
0:54 COST HERE BECAUSE I DO THINK
0:56 IT'S GOING TO BE KIND OF IN A
0:58 TRADING RANGE FOR THE NEXT 6 TO
0:59 12 MONTHS. IN MY OPINION. I
1:01 WILL NOT HAVE A PROBLEM BUYING
1:02 THE STOCK BACK IF WE GET A
1:04 REALLY AMAZING LEADER AND WE
1:06 CAN GET PAST THIS. BUT I THINK
1:07 WE HAVE TIME. AND AS A RESULT,
1:09 I ACTUALLY ADDED TO MICRON
1:11 BECAUSE THAT STOCK IS DOWN JUST
1:13 AS MUCH FROM ITS HIGH 35%. AND
1:15 THE FUNDAMENTALS ARE VERY
1:17 ATTRACTIVE AND IT'S TRADING AT
1:18 FIVE TIMES EARNINGS. AND I
1:19 THINK THEY'RE GOING TO ANNOUNCE
1:20 A BUYBACK IN WHEN THEY REPORT
1:22 EARNINGS IN EARLY DECEMBER. SO
1:24 THAT HAS CLEAN FUNDAMENTALS
1:26 CLEAN STORY CHEAP STOCK.
1:28 WHEREAS NVIDIA IS JUST NOT
1:30 CLEAN AT THIS POINT.
1:31 >> ALL RIGHT. NOT CALLING IT
1:32 CLEAN BY THE WAY. A LOT OF
1:34 PEOPLE TALKING ABOUT VALUATION
1:35 TRADING AT A VERY LOW VALUATION
1:36 RIGHT NOW. I BELIEVE ABOUT 14
1:38 TIMES FORWARD EARNINGS. MALCOLM
1:39 I WANT TO COME.
1:40 >> OVER TEN TIMES.
1:41 >> IS IT TEN TIMES. OKAY. I'M
1:43 LOOKING AT OUR SYSTEM. WE HAVE
1:44 IT AT ABOUT.
1:45 >> FOUR TIMES. THEY'RE GOING TO
1:46 DO $20 A SHARE IN FISCAL 28. SO
1:48 YEAH.
1:49 >> IT'S IT'S UNBELIEVABLE.
1:50 >> WHO CARES.
1:50 >> YEAH.
1:51 >> WHO CARES. ALL RIGHT. WELL
1:52 WE KNOW WHO DOESN'T CARE. IT'S
1:54 YOU MALCOLM. YOU ALSO SOLD OUT
1:55 OF NVIDIA AS WELL. DO YOU.
1:57 >> CARE IF YOU'RE STILL IN IT?
1:59 YOU DON'T CARE IF YOU'RE OUT.
2:00 >> OF IT. WELL.
2:01 >> I GUESS THE.
2:02 >> QUESTION IS WHAT ARE YOU
2:04 STILL WAITING FOR? BECAUSE I
2:05 SOLD THE SHARES IN AFTER HOURS.
2:06 BECAUSE ESSENTIALLY THE ONLY
2:07 QUESTION I WAS STILL ASKING
2:09 INITIALLY WAS SELL THE STOCK
2:10 AND THEN BUY WHAT? BECAUSE
2:11 THERE'S NOT REALLY A LOT THAT
2:13 YOU CAN USE TO REPLACE A
2:14 COMPANY LIKE THIS THAT'S SEATED
2:15 AT THE CENTER OF THE ENTIRE AI
2:17 TRADE. BUT THEN THE WHOLE
2:18 REASON THAT I WANTED TO OWN THE
2:20 STOCK IN THE FIRST PLACE HAS
2:22 LEFT THE BUILDING. SO I
2:23 UNDERSTAND EVERYTHING.
2:23 >> YOU'RE SAYING. JEN-HSUN
2:24 HUANG.
2:25 >> YES. EVERYTHING RELATED TO
2:27 NVIDIA LEFT WITH THE CEO. SO I
2:30 UNDERSTAND EVERYTHING THAT
2:31 STEPHANIE IS SAYING IN TERMS OF
2:33 THE FUNDAMENTALS AND ALL OF THE
2:34 ALL OF THE REASONS THAT THE
2:35 STOCK IS STILL ATTRACTIVE
2:36 EVENTUALLY. I DON'T UNDERSTAND,
2:38 THOUGH, WHY THERE'S STILL SO
2:39 MANY BUYERS IN THIS NAME. SO
2:41 YES, IF YOU'RE ALREADY IN THE
2:43 STOCK, MAYBE YOU'RE DECIDING
2:44 YOU WANT TO HOLD ON AND SEE
2:45 WHAT HAPPENS OVER THE NEXT 12
2:47 MONTHS. I KNOW JOSH PERSONALLY,
2:49 YOU HAVE A LOW BASIS IN THE
2:50 STOCK. I STARTED BUYING IT IN
2:52 THE 90S AFTER TARIFF LIBERATION
2:53 DAY. SO IT IT MATTERS WHERE YOU
2:56 GOT INTO THE STOCK, BUT THE
2:58 FACT THAT IT'S HOLDING UP THE
2:59 WAY THAT IT IS MEANS THAT
3:01 THERE'S A SUBSTANTIAL AMOUNT OF
3:02 BUYING PRESSURE IN THIS NAME,
3:03 TOO. THAT PART I DON'T REALLY
3:05 UNDERSTAND BECAUSE IT'S GOING
3:06 TO TAKE A VERY LONG TIME BEFORE
3:07 IT TURNS THE SHIP, IF EVER, AND
3:10 EVEN WHEN IT DOES, WITHOUT
3:11 HAVING THE CHAMPION IN JEN-HSUN
3:13 HUANG THAT IT HAS HAD FOR THE
3:15 LAST FOUR YEARS. I DON'T KNOW
3:16 HOW YOU PLACE THE PREMIUM ON
3:18 THIS STOCK THAT YOU HAVE FOR
3:19 THE LAST FOUR YEARS.
3:21 >> THERE'S NO PREMIUM IN THE
3:22 STOCK. SO LET ME DISAGREE WITH
3:24 YOU RIGHT THERE. OKAY. STOCK
3:25 HAS BEEN SELLING AT A BELOW
3:26 MARKET MULTIPLE FOR 24 MONTHS.
3:28 THERE IS NO PREMIUM ON THE
3:29 STOCK. THERE HASN'T BEEN SINCE
3:31 EVEN BEFORE YOU BOUGHT IT.
3:33 >> HOWEVER, THE REASON THAT THE
3:35 STOCK HAS BEEN TRADING THE WAY
3:36 THAT IT HAS IS BECAUSE THERE'S
3:38 BEEN THE PROMISE THAT NVIDIA IS
3:39 AT THE CENTER OF LITERALLY
3:41 EVERYTHING. IF CORE WE'VE WINS,
3:43 SO DOES NVIDIA. IF OPENAI WINS.
3:45 SO DO.
3:46 >> YOU THINK THAT JUST CHANGED.
3:47 >> I DO.
3:48 >> OKAY, I.
3:49 >> THINK I DO. THE REASON I SAY
3:51 THAT IS BECAUSE IT'S GOING TO
3:52 BE VERY HARD FOR THIS COMPANY
3:54 TO MOVE THE WAY IT HAS MOVED IN
3:56 THE PAST WITH THE OVERHANG OF
3:57 WE DON'T KNOW WHAT ALL HAS
3:59 HAPPENED FROM A NATIONAL
4:00 SECURITY PERSPECTIVE. WE DON'T
4:01 KNOW WHAT MEETINGS THEY'LL NOW
4:02 BE SHUT OUT OF. WE DON'T KNOW
4:04 WHAT RELATIONSHIPS HAVE NOW
4:05 BEEN DESTROYED. SO THERE'S JUST
4:06 SO MANY UNKNOWNS HERE THAT I
4:07 THINK IT'S IMPOSSIBLE TO EXPECT
4:09 NVIDIA TO BE ABLE TO MOVE THE
4:11 WAY THAT THEY HAVE AND BE ABLE
4:12 TO COMMAND ANY SORT OF A
4:15 CENTERPIECE RELATIONSHIP THAT
4:16 THEY HAVE TO THE AI.
4:17 >> ALL RIGHT, SO YOU'RE SAYING
4:19 IF JEN-HSUN HUANG IS OUT,
4:20 YOU'RE OUT. BY THE WAY, WILLIAM
4:22 BLAIR COMING OUT SAYING NVIDIA
4:23 IS GOING TO LOSE HIS CREATIVE
4:25 RELATIONSHIP DRIVEN DEAL MAKING.
4:25 IT SOUNDS LIKE YOU SHARE THAT
4:27 SENTIMENT AS WELL. BILL, I WANT
4:28 TO COME TO YOU. YOU AND JOSH
4:30 STILL IN THE NAME. SO GO AHEAD.
4:32 WHY ARE YOU STAYING?
4:33 >> WELL WE.
4:34 >> DID TRIM IT 2173 WEEKS AGO.
4:35 SO THAT DOES HELP A LITTLE BIT
4:37 HERE. IT'S STILL A TOP HOLDING
4:39 OF OURS. NOW. I THINK YOU ALSO
4:40 WANT TO LOOK AT THE PATH. HOW
4:42 DID WE GET HERE AT 165. RIGHT
4:44 NOW.
4:44 >> WE CAN'T GET WE CAN'T GET
4:46 INTO HOW WE GOT HERE.
4:47 >> WELL, BUT IF YOU LOOK AT THE.
4:49 >> SELLING WANT US TO DO THAT.
4:51 >> BUT THE SELLING THAT TOOK
4:52 PLACE THAT BROKE 200 LATE IN
4:54 THE MONTH OF OCTOBER WAS ON THE
4:55 HEELS OF THESE BIG HYPERSCALE
4:57 EARNINGS REPORTS. AND THE
4:58 SENTIMENT AROUND THAT WAS NOT
4:59 ONLY ABOUT THE ELECTION THAT
5:00 CAME THE FOLLOWING WEEK, BUT AS
5:02 WELL, THAT THE HYPERSCALERS ARE
5:03 GOING TO MAYBE PULL BACK ON THE
5:05 CAPEX. A LOT OF BANKS STILL
5:06 BELIEVE THAT THE CAPEX IS STILL
5:08 GOING TO BE THERE. SO I THINK
5:09 THERE WAS ALREADY A TREMENDOUS
5:11 AMOUNT OF SELLING THAT THAT GOT
5:12 US HERE. AND THIS IS JUST THE
5:14 KICK WHILE YOU'RE DOWN. BUT
5:15 YEAH, 1011 FORWARD EARNINGS,
5:17 THE BACKLOG AND CURRENT
5:17 INFRASTRUCTURE, IT'S HIGHLY
5:18 PROBABLE THAT YOU'RE GOING TO
5:19 GET IT ABOVE MARKET RATE OF
5:21 RETURN IN THE FUTURE OFF THIS
5:22 NAME. BUT WHEN YOU START TO
5:24 LOOK 1 TO 2 YEARS OUT, YES,
5:26 THERE'S GOING TO BE QUESTIONS
5:27 ABOUT HOW AND WILL THEY MOVE
5:28 FORWARD. WHERE DOES THAT
5:29 COMPETITION GOING TO COME FROM.
5:30 MAYBE BROADCOM MAYBE AN
5:32 ALPHABET WITH THE TPU. BUT
5:33 AGAIN I THINK THAT WE'RE GOING
5:34 TO SEE WE'VE SEEN THIS
5:36 EXACERBATE A LITTLE BIT TO THE
5:37 DOWNSIDE BECAUSE OF THE NEWS
5:38 THAT CAME PRIOR TO THIS. THE
5:40 HYPERSCALER EARNINGS THE
5:41 SENTIMENT AROUND SEMICONDUCTORS
5:42 AND THEN THE ELECTION. AND THEN
5:43 NOW WE'RE HERE. SO I THINK
5:44 THERE'S A LOT OF SELLING THAT
5:46 HAS HAPPENED EVEN BEFORE THIS,
5:47 AND IT'S BEEN FLUSHED OUT AND
5:49 EVERYBODY'S ALREADY SOLD. WHO
5:50 IS LEFT TO SELL? I WOULD SAY
5:51 THAT WE NEED TO SEE
5:52 COMMUNICATION. WE'VE BEGUN TO
5:54 SEE THAT TODAY. THEY HAVE AN
5:55 INTERIM CEO. THEY HAVE A BOARD
5:56 CHAIR.
5:57 >> I DON'T KNOW ANYTHING.
5:58 >> BUT I DO THINK AND I HEARD
6:00 KRAMER. KRAMER CALL FOR IT ON
6:01 THE NETWORK THIS MORNING. MAYBE
6:03 WE GET A PRE REPORT. I THI
Fmr. WH Special Advisor for AI on Nvidia: This case shows how important AI chips are full transcript
0:00 STARTING TO SEE A LITTLE BIT OF
0:02 THAT TONIGHT. AND IT'LL BE
0:03 INTERESTING TO SEE WHAT HAPPENS.
0:04 YOU KNOW, AS THE KIND OF STORY
0:06 EVOLVES TOMORROW.
0:07 >> EUNICE. THANK YOU. EUNICE
0:08 YOON IN BEIJING TONIGHT. LET'S
0:10 KEEP THE CONVERSATION GOING ON
0:11 NVIDIA AND THE IMPACT OF JENSEN
0:13 WONG'S DEPARTURE ON AMERICA'S
0:15 DOMINANCE IN AI. BEN, BEN
0:16 BUCHANAN JOINS US TODAY, FORMER
0:17 WHITE HOUSE SPECIAL ADVISOR FOR
0:19 AI UNDER THE BIDEN WHITE HOUSE,
0:21 ALSO AUTHOR OF THE NEW BOOK,
0:22 THE BITTER STRUGGLE
0:24 SUPERINTELLIGENCE, SUPERPOWERS
0:25 AND THE FATE OF THE WORLD. BEN.
0:27 APPRECIATE IT. GOOD TO SEE YOU.
0:28 >> THANKS FOR HAVING ME.
0:30 >> WHAT ARE THE IMPORTANT
0:31 LESSONS THAT YOU'VE BEEN SEEING
0:33 SO FAR? AND I GUESS, WHAT ARE
0:36 WHAT DO YOU HOPE GETS ANSWERED
0:37 IN THE WEEKS AND MONTHS TO COME,
0:39 SPECIFICALLY AROUND THE
0:41 ADMINISTRATION'S STANCE ON ON
0:43 REGULATING THIS SUPPLY, THIS
0:44 SMUGGLING.
0:46 >> THIS CASE SHOWS HOW
0:47 IMPORTANT AI CHIPS ARE. THE
0:49 PRODUCTS THAT NVIDIA MAKES ARE
0:51 FUNDAMENTAL TO THE GLOBAL
0:52 ECONOMY AND TO AMERICA'S
0:53 NATIONAL SECURITY. OUR POSTURE
0:55 IN THE BIDEN ADMINISTRATION WAS
0:57 THAT THESE CHIPS WERE TOO
0:58 POWERFUL TO BE SOLD TO CHINA,
1:00 WHERE THEY COULD BE DIVERTED TO
1:01 THE CHINESE MILITARY. THE TRUMP
1:02 ADMINISTRATION HAS, IN KEY
1:04 RESPECTS, WALKED BACK A LOT OF
1:05 THE EXPORT CONTROL POLICY. AND
1:06 I THINK THIS MOMENT IS ONE
1:08 WHERE WE'RE HEARING BIPARTISAN
1:09 CALLS TO SAY, NO, AMERICA MUST
1:10 BE MORE AGGRESSIVE ONCE MORE
1:12 AND DENYING CHINA ACCESS TO
1:14 THIS POWERFUL TECHNOLOGY.
1:15 >> SO YOU THINK THE HAWKS WIN
1:17 FROM HERE?
1:18 >> CERTAINLY. IT SEEMS THAT WAY
1:19 IN THE CONGRESS. THERE'S
1:21 BUILDING MOMENTUM AGAIN FROM
1:21 BOTH SIDES OF THE AISLE. FOLKS
1:23 LIKE SENATOR CRAMER FROM THE
1:24 BANKING COMMITTEE, A REPUBLICAN
1:27 SENATOR, BANKS AND OTHER
1:28 REPUBLICAN ARE SAYING, LOOK,
1:29 THIS IS A REMINDER OF HOW
1:30 POWERFUL THIS TECHNOLOGY IS.
1:32 LET'S SEE WHAT CONGRESS DOES.
1:33 BUT THIS CERTAINLY, I THINK,
1:34 SHOULD BE ANOTHER CALL TO
1:36 ACTION.
1:37 >> WHY DON'T YOU BUY THE IDEA
1:39 THAT THAT JENSEN PUSHED THAT
1:41 THAT WE SHOULD WE SHOULD HAVE
1:43 CHINA, CHINA'S AI BUILT ON
1:47 AMERICAN TECHNOLOGY THAT THAT
1:48 THAT IS IN OUR NATIONAL
1:49 SECURITY INTEREST. I MEAN,
1:50 THERE ARE PLENTY OF EXPERTS WHO
1:51 AGREE WITH THAT.
1:53 >> I THINK THERE'S TWO THINGS
1:54 HERE. THE FIRST IS I'M NOT SURE
1:55 WE WANT CHINA'S AI TO BE THAT
1:57 POWERFUL IN THE FIRST PLACE.
1:58 THERE'S NEVER BEEN A CHINESE AI
2:00 SYSTEM TRAINED ON CHINESE CHIPS.
2:01 SO IT'S A CHOICE TO SELL CHINA
2:03 CHIPS AND LET THEM IN THE GAME.
2:05 AT THE FRONTIER OF AI
2:06 DEVELOPMENT, I'M NOT SURE WE
2:07 SHOULD MAKE THAT CHOICE,
2:08 INCLUDING FOR NATIONAL SECURITY
2:09 REASONS. THE SECOND IS CHINA IS
2:11 DESPERATELY TRYING TO GET AWAY
2:12 FROM AMERICAN CHIPS, AND HAS
2:13 BEEN SINCE 2014, LONG BEFORE
2:16 THE EXPORT CONTROLS WERE IN
2:18 PLACE. XI JINPING IN 2014
2:19 ANNOUNCED A MORE THAN $100
2:21 BILLION EFFORT TO INDIGENIZE
2:23 CHIP PRODUCTION IN CHINA. THE
2:25 PEDAL TO THE METAL ON
2:26 DIGITALIZATION IN CHINA LONG
2:27 BEFORE THE TRUMP ADMINISTRATION
2:29 IN ITS FIRST TERM, OR THE BIDEN
2:31 ADMINISTRATION, OUR TERM TOOK
2:32 ANY ACTION.
2:33 >> WHAT DO YOU THINK THIS DOES
2:35 TO OPEN SOURCE? THERE'S STILL A
2:36 LOT OF ADVOCATES OF OPEN SOURCE
2:38 WHO ARE WHO ARE SORT OF
2:40 MOURNING WANG'S DEPARTURE TODAY.
2:43 >> I EXPECT NVIDIA WILL
2:44 CONTINUE TO BE AN ADVOCATE FOR
2:45 OPEN WEIGHT MODELS, AND
2:47 CERTAINLY THEY WERE BEFORE. I
2:48 IMAGINE THAT WILL CONTINUE TO
2:49 BE THE COMPANY'S STRATEGY. SO I
2:52 EXPECT THAT WILL STILL BE THE
2:53 CASE. AND I THINK IN MANY
2:55 RESPECTS THAT'S A GOOD THING.
2:56 AND WE CERTAINLY TOOK NO ACTION
2:57 TO RESTRICT OPEN WEIGHT MODELS
2:59 AND THE BIDEN ADMINISTRATION TO
3:01 THAT POINT. IN OUR FOUR YEARS.
3:03 >> DO YOU THINK THE UNITED
3:04 STATES BECAME TOO DEPENDENT OR
3:07 DANGEROUSLY DEPENDENT ON ONE
3:08 COMPANY FOR WINNING THE AI RACE,
3:11 AND POTENTIALLY ONE MAN?
3:13 >> NO, I THINK THERE'S GOOD
3:15 COMPETITION IN THE INDUSTRY.
3:17 NVIDIA, OF COURSE, MAKES
3:18 EXCEPTIONAL PRODUCTS, BUT
3:20 GOOGLE AND MICROSOFT AND AMAZON
3:22 ALSO DESIGN THEIR OWN CHIPS
3:24 THAT ARE COMPETITIVE AND
3:25 INCREASINGLY USED. AND I DON'T
3:27 THINK BY ANY STRETCH IS THIS
3:28 THE END OF NVIDIA? I THINK
3:30 NVIDIA HAS GOT A LOT OF VERY
3:31 TALENTED PEOPLE, VERY TALENTED
3:33 ENGINEERS. AND AS LONG AS THEY
3:34 CONTINUE TO MAKE GREAT PRODUCTS,
3:35 THEY'LL STILL BE ABSOLUTELY ONE
3:37 OF THE KEY PILLARS OF THE AI
3:39 ECOSYSTEM.
3:40 >> FASCINATING EXCHANGE
3:42 OVERNIGHT BETWEEN A QUOTE OF
3:45 DARIO MODY ABOUT BASICALLY
3:47 MAKING ALZHEIMER'S AND CANCER
3:48 AND HEART DISEASE RELICS OF THE
3:50 PAST, IN HIS VIEW, IN THE NEXT
3:53 DECADE. AND THEN THE CEO OF
3:54 LILLY RESPONDING, YEAH, THAT
3:56 WOULD BE AMAZING. BUT I DON'T
3:57 THINK THAT'S LIKELY. WHERE ARE
3:58 YOU IN SORT OF THESE THESE
4:01 MOONSHOT PROMISES RIGHT NOW?
4:04 >> LOOK, I'M A NATIONAL
4:05 SECURITY PERSON THROUGH AND
4:06 THROUGH. SO IT'S MY JOB TO HELP
4:08 AMERICA MANAGE THE RISKS OF
4:09 THIS TECHNOLOGY SO THAT WE CAN
4:10 HARNESS THE BENEFITS, HOW SOON
4:11 THOSE BENEFITS COME? I'M NOT
4:13 SURE I WOULD LOVE TO TO HAVE
4:15 ALL THE UPSIDE COME REALLY SOON.
4:16 I TEND TO THINK THE WORLD IS A
4:18 MESSY PLACE. THE CLINICAL
4:19 TRIALS TAKE A LONG TIME AND IT
4:21 WILL TAKE TIME TO TO GET THERE.
4:23 BUT AI HAS SHOWN ENORMOUS
4:24 PROMISE IN THINGS LIKE BIOLOGY.
4:25 I SUSPECT IT WILL TAKE AI
4:27 COMPANIES WORKING WITH PHARMA
4:28 COMPANIES TO MAKE THAT PROMISE
4:30 REAL
Market Midday: Stocks Higher, Nvidia Off Lows After CEO Exit, Washington Probe Ahead full transcript
0:01 CNBC [music] business news update market
0:03 midday. I'm Jessica Edinger. Green on
0:06 the screen this afternoon on Wall
0:08 Street. The NASDAQ turning positive.
0:09 Traders shaking off in the Nvidia CEO
0:13 exit. AMD shares are gaining. Here's a
0:16 look at the major averages. The Dow is
0:18 now up 182 points, led higher by shares
0:21 of Google parent Alphabet. They're up
0:23 more than 2%. The S&P 500 index up 11
0:27 points. The NASDAQ in the green by three
0:29 points. It's precarious, but it's in the
0:31 green. Nvidia shares recovering a bit.
0:34 They're down 5% this afternoon as some
0:38 investors have been buying the morning
0:39 selloff. Shares had plunged 13% at the
0:44 open. Embattled CEO Jensen Wong
0:46 resigning today after admitting an
0:48 affair with a woman the government
0:49 alleges is a Chinese asset or spy.
0:52 CNBC's Sema Modi with the latest. We've
0:54 been working the phones here and here's
0:56 what we know at this point. After a
0:58 report of a second alleged affair
0:59 involving former CEO Jensen Wong and a
1:02 direct report, I'm told by a source
1:04 familiar that sentiment internally uh
1:07 turned and Nvidia's board called a
1:08 meeting on Wednesday afternoon that ran
1:10 into the night, but consensus on Jensen
1:12 Wong's resignation was made last night.
1:15 The team at Nvidia then moved quickly to
1:17 put together their communication
1:19 strategy. That message was then
1:21 delivered this morning. Jensen Wong was
1:22 out. The board also appointed its first
1:24 chairman, Harvey Jones. CFO, Colette
1:27 Crest, was named interim CEO.
1:29 >> Colette Crest is communicating with
1:31 employees today as acting CEO. The
1:34 former CEO, Wong, has agreed to testify
1:37 before Congress. And with the Democrats
1:40 about to control Congress, here come the
1:42 Washington investigations.
1:43 >> Washington is really just gearing up to
1:46 start investigating the administration's
1:47 role in all of this, what they knew, and
1:50 when. And I just got a copy of a letter
1:52 that will be sent later today to
1:53 commerce secretary Howard Lutnik, or
1:55 maybe has already been sent, but it will
1:56 be publicly released shortly. It's to
1:58 Howard Lutnik from the top Democrats on
2:00 the Senate Finance Committee and the
2:01 House Ways and Means Committee. And
2:03 they're informing the Commerce
2:04 Department that they say, and I quote,
2:06 they're beginning an investigation into
2:08 the Trump administration's scheme to
2:09 approve and tax exports of advanced
2:12 NVIDIA AI chips to Chinese companies
2:14 with concerning links to the Chinese
2:16 government, military, and sanctioned
2:17 entities. and they're asking Secretary
2:19 Lutnik and the Commerce Department to
2:21 preserve all records and any
2:23 communications within the department
2:25 with and regarding Jensen Hong or
2:27 Nvidia.
2:28 >> CNBC's Megan Cassella in Washington.
2:31 Here's the author of The Thinking
2:33 Machine, Steven Wit, with CNBC's Sarah
2:36 Eisen.
2:37 >> You wrote the definitive book on Jensen
2:39 Wong. Is Nvidia Nvidia without Jensen?
2:43 >> No. It's like the Bulls without Jordan.
2:45 I mean, I don't know how they're going
2:47 to replace this guy. You know, Jensen
2:49 was Nvidia. He understood every part of
2:52 it. He was a terrific worldclass
2:55 computer scientist. He was the guy who
2:57 could close a deal with a mega customer.
2:59 And he was the guy who could get on the
3:00 phone and scream at Taiwan when the
3:02 chips were late. All in one guy, all in
3:04 one person, right? It's very hard to
3:06 find that combination of people.
3:08 Colette, I think, is an excellent
3:10 executive, but she's not a world-class
3:12 computer scientist. She comes from a
3:14 finance background. Jensen could take a
3:16 diagram of Nvidia equipment, an exploded
3:19 diagram, and draw it by hand from
3:21 memory. It's going to be very hard to
3:23 replace it.
3:24 >> Apple shares hit another all-time high
3:26 today. Intraday. Investors excited about
3:28 some of the demand for new iPhones,
3:31 especially the folding iPhone duo. It's
3:34 now backordered to be available to new
3:36 customers in January after the holidays.
3:39 The post office will charge him more to
3:41 ship something, adding an 11% fuel sir
3:44 charge. As diesel prices have soared
3:46 since President Trump sent US missiles
3:48 into Iran in February, the USPS joins
3:52 FedEx and UPS with those new added
3:54 search charges. Eli Lily shares ticked
3:57 higher after becoming the first drug
3:58 maker to secure Chinese approval for an
4:01 oral GLP-1 weight loss treatment, giving
4:04 it a head start in that competitive
4:07 market. Yeti shares are on pace for
4:09 their worst day today since August. The
4:12 drinkware maker is warning consumers are
4:14 being cautious with their spending and
4:16 that's going to impact this current
4:18 holiday quarter. I'm Jessica Edinger,
4:21 CNBC.
White House Counsel Will Scharf speaks at the 2026 National Lawyers Convention full transcript
0:01 Well, this is maybe
0:04 the highlight that all of you should
0:05 hope to have, which is that you get to
0:06 interview a very close friend of yours
0:08 on stage and get to ask them whatever
0:10 you want. Uh, I think it's really
0:12 important that Sheldon chose governments
0:14 are instituted among men because um,
0:17 something that Will's taught me more
0:18 than anything else is that when you go
0:19 into a role in government, the people
0:22 around you or the the definition of what
0:24 you get done uh, it's not resumes and
0:26 it's not reputations. It's the the
0:28 actual of the person that you're dealing
0:30 with and uh and you taught me that by
0:33 talking a lot about your views of the
0:35 founders. We heard at the last panel
0:37 about how uh nobody occurs nobody learns
0:39 about the founding anymore. But in your
0:42 job, I have a deep suspicion based on
0:44 knowing you that some aspects of what
0:46 you do every day are actually informed
0:48 by or motivated by your view of the
0:51 founders as people. Uh is that true?
0:55 >> Yeah, for sure. Um, you know, first of
0:57 all, just like to start off by by
0:59 thanking the Federalist Society, my dear
1:01 friend Sheldon Gilbert, uh, for for the
1:03 invitation to be here today. Um, it's
1:05 actually it's it's really weird to me to
1:07 be sitting on a stage like this,
1:09 particularly with O. Um, when I was a 1L
1:13 uh at at Harvard, um, I sent a random
1:16 email to a Federalist Society inbox
1:19 asking for information on how to join
1:21 the Federalist Society because I was a
1:23 somewhat precocious gunner of a
1:25 conservative. Um, and the person who
1:27 responded to that email was O. Uh, and
1:30 in all things sort of conservative
1:32 lawyering, as I was learning about the
1:35 law and learning about the practice of
1:36 the law, uh, O was really my first guide
1:39 through that process. Um, and in the
1:41 leadup to the Federalist Society
1:43 convention that November, uh, I I didn't
1:46 think that I could, you know, skip a
1:47 couple days of class and go on this
1:49 junket to DC. I was a 1L and I was
1:51 trying to do well in my classes and oh
1:53 really put his foot down and demanded
1:55 that I join the HLS uh, delegation here
1:58 uh, to the Mayflower. Um, and it was one
2:01 of the the really the best decisions I
2:03 made my 1L year. Certainly um and
2:05 something that obviously had a great
2:07 impact on my life uh going forward uh
2:10 being associated with Fed sock learning
2:12 from uh so many of the great people uh
2:14 that are here for this conference. Uh in
2:16 terms of your question um the White
2:19 House is a place that's sused with
2:21 history uh and it's really tough to you
2:23 know go about daily life there to go
2:25 about the work that we do uh at least
2:27 for me without thinking about that. Um
2:30 you know I have the great honor of
2:31 sitting in the office that uh you know
2:34 like Fred Fielding sat in uh before me.
2:37 Um you know, one of my favorite stories
2:39 was, you know, in the first couple weeks
2:40 of the administration. Um I I had just
2:43 become staff secretary and we were
2:46 looking at issues relating uh to
2:48 appropriate uses of the auto pen. Um
2:51 that was a huge political issue. Um it
2:53 was one that was very important to the
2:55 president. I should note by the way that
2:56 I'm here speaking in a personal capacity
2:58 only. Um so we start researching the
3:02 auto you know, I always want to find um
3:04 you know, the history of an issue and
3:06 really dig deep. And we start pulling
3:08 out these OLC opinions on appropriate
3:11 use of of uh you know, signature
3:13 reproduction and they're written by, you
3:15 know, by Justice Scalia, by Chief
3:18 Justice Ranquist when they were an OLC.
3:20 Uh and we keep pulling at the threads
3:22 and we keep going further and further
3:23 back and we find an attorney general
3:25 opinion uh by William Wart uh that
3:29 refers to, you know, issues about
3:31 mechanical reproduction of a signature
3:33 of um in that case it was I think the
3:35 secretary of the treasury. Um so really
3:38 the history uh everything that came
3:40 before us um it it has an immediate
3:42 impact on the work that we do uh in part
3:45 because the work that we do is so
3:46 unique. Um getting the opportunity to
3:49 you know practice law at this sort of a
3:51 level for the federal government. Um,
3:53 it's truly been the greatest honor of my
3:55 life. And I think, uh, I'd certainly be
3:57 remiss if I didn't, uh, you know, often
4:00 think about, uh, the folks who have been
4:01 similar, been in similar positions
4:03 previously, uh, really going back to the
4:05 founding era. Um, I remember there was
4:08 one moment from a previous Federalist
4:10 Society conference that really sticks
4:11 out in my mind. I was sitting out by the
4:14 old lobby bar of the Mayflower with a
4:16 few other students and we were having
4:18 uh, drinks with Richard Brookheiser. Uh,
4:21 and for those of you who haven't read
4:22 his series of biographies on founding
4:24 era figures, he did a Lincoln. Um,
4:27 they're really just they're some of my
4:28 favorite books. His Gor Morris book, the
4:30 the Rake who wrote the Constitution is
4:33 like I cannot recommend it in high
4:34 enough terms. But we're talking to
4:36 Brookheiser. He had just come out with a
4:38 book and one of my fellow students asked
4:40 him, you know, Mr. Brookheiser, do you
4:42 ever have trouble relating to the
4:44 subjects of your biographies since, you
4:47 know, they all lived so long ago? And
4:50 Brook was clearly waiting for this
4:52 question. I hope he's not in the room
4:53 right now. Um, but was clearly waiting
4:55 for this question and had one of the
4:57 greatest sort of pre-anned answers I've
4:59 ever heard. Um, and he goes, uh, in my
5:02 youth, I once heard a speech uh by
5:05 Alger, you know, the famous communist
5:08 spy and state department official. Uh,
5:10 Alger served as a law clerk to Oliver
5:13 Wendell Holmes. Oliver Wendel Holmes
5:16 famously served alongside uh President
5:19 Abraham Lincoln uh during the Civil War,
5:22 lives at the Battle of Fort Stewart. Um
5:24 and a very young Abraham Lincoln in his
5:27 only term in the House of
5:28 Representatives served alongside John
5:30 Quincy Adams uh who was in his last term
5:32 in the US House of Representatives
5:34 shortly before his death. Brookiser
5:36 pauses and goes, "And Quincy was an
5:39 eyewitness uh to the founding of our
5:42 country and was an eyewitness uh to
5:44 every one of the subjects of of the
5:46 biographies that I've written." And he
5:49 sort of holds up his hands and he goes,
5:51 "You know, me, Alger, Oliver Wendel
5:55 Holmes, Abraham Lincoln, John Quincy
5:58 Adams." That's less than six degrees of
6:01 separation between us and the generation
6:03 that founded this country. clear
6:05 implication was that we were the sixth
6:07 degree of separation as facilitated by
6:09 him and that framing really stuck with
6:12 me. Um we're in the 250th year of our
6:14 country. Uh it's a a monumental
6:17 achievement that the republic has has
6:19 lasted as long as it has in my view. Um
6:21 but really we are a very very young
6:23 country and I had the opportunity as
6:26 staff secretary to get to to travel
6:27 around the world with the president. Uh
6:29 we went to Windsor Castle. Uh you know
6:31 the first bricks of that were laid in
6:33 1066. uh you know with the Norman
6:35 conquest um we are a young country and I
6:38 think that you know that that poses some
6:40 difficulties. We don't have you know the
6:42 historical traditions of uh some of the
6:44 older monarchies. Um but it also means
6:46 that I think our founding is much more
6:48 relatable. Uh that we're a you know
6:50 we're a we're a country that was uh
6:52 created by figures whose political
6:54 concerns whose political animations I
6:56 think can really still speak to all of
6:58 us today. Um, and again, you know,
7:00 serving in the in the role that I've
7:02 I've been, you know, honored to to serve
7:03 in or the roles I've been honored to
7:05 serve in for the last two years, uh,
7:07 that that history really is relevant.
7:10 Um, and it certainly informs what we do
7:12 on a on a daily basis, as was the case
7:14 with, uh, our our, uh, memo on the
7:17 appropriate use of the mechanical
7:19 signature pen. So,
7:21 >> something else that you [clears throat]
7:23 uh, have done a huge job in whenever you
7:26 talk to like my about the founding is
7:29 you make these people feel very human
7:31 and you remind people that they are both
7:33 mythical figures and their
7:34 accomplishments but that they were not
7:36 made of mythical stuff, right? So, so
7:38 there's there's there's an aspect of
7:40 something not being fully written that
7:43 the people in question don't know that
7:44 they will succeed. You've talked about
7:46 this a lot with me. The people in in the
7:48 actions do not know where their story
7:51 will end and we look back and say, "Oh,
7:54 it was written that the Constitution
7:56 would be like thus and the declaration
7:58 would happen like thus and that the
7:59 revolution would be won, right? But you
8:02 always remind me that the people in this
8:04 time did not always know that. They
8:06 didn't always believe it and there they
8:08 they believed it but at a level where it
8:10 was hope, right?
8:11 >> Yeah. I mean, Franklin, you know, we
8:13 must all assuredly hang together or we
8:15 will hang separately. Um, my favorite
8:17 story along those lines though is
8:19 actually from George Washington's post
8:20 presidency. Um, you know, George
8:22 Washington, one of the greatest men in
8:24 history, King William IV of England,
8:26 called him the greatest man who's ever
8:28 lived. Um, a after he leaves the
8:30 presidency, he sort of retreats to Mount
8:33 Vernon and engages in wild land
8:35 speculation out west. Um, and visitors
8:38 to Mount Vernon who are expecting to
8:40 sort of learn at the feet of this
8:41 incredibly great man. Uh, and he truly
8:44 was, uh, were surprised that he would
8:46 pitch them on these sort of land
8:48 speculation deals out west. There's a
8:50 Polish nobleman, I'm blanking on his
8:53 name, he was an eminent poet and a great
8:55 Polish patriot, um, who writes about
8:57 this at some length in his diary of his
8:59 visit to Mount Vernon, uh, that that,
9:02 you know, President Washington keeps
9:03 talking about the the great opportunity
9:05 of these western lands and, you know,
9:07 building canals and and opening up the
9:09 West. Uh, both for patriotic reasons,
9:11 but also because that's where his his
9:13 business interests lay. Um, and it
9:14 brings home that, you know, we we do
9:16 lionize our founders. we should uh they
9:19 were truly great men uh and we live in
9:21 their shadow. Uh but they were still
9:23 men. Uh the thing I like the most about
9:25 you know Brookheiser's Governor Morris
9:27 biography uh is it really personalizes.
9:30 I mean Governor Morris uh incredible
9:32 attorney uh incredible American patriot
9:35 an early abolitionist. I mean just a
9:37 really great man. also a famed womanizer
9:40 um who was proud of the story probably
9:43 apocryphal circulated about him um that
9:45 he wore a peg leg because he had mangled
9:47 his leg uh jumping out of one of his
9:50 paramor's windows late at night. Um I
9:52 think it was actually a carriage
9:54 accident, but the fact that Governor
9:55 Morris was sort of amused by this and
9:57 let it sort of stand out there uh tells
9:59 you about the you know what a character
10:01 he was. Um you read Madison's notes on
10:04 the federal convention uh these were
10:06 brilliant, brilliant people. Um, but
10:08 there's also just a degree of of uh sort
10:11 of pettiness and interpersonal dynamics
10:13 that comes through as well. Uh, Luther
10:15 Martin of Maryland, who is on the wrong
10:18 side of just about everything
10:19 historically, was a noted
10:20 anti-federalist, but was considered one
10:22 of the truly great attorneys of the
10:24 early republic. Uh, you know, Luther
10:26 Martin argues the Maryland side of
10:28 McCullify, Maryland. He defends Aaron
10:29 Bird, his treason trial. Uh defends
10:31 Samuel Chase in his impeachment trial,
10:33 which is one of the most interesting
10:35 moments in early American history to me.
10:37 Uh Luther Martin at one point stands up
10:39 and gives I think like an eight hour
10:42 speech at the federal convention and
10:44 Madison records it in basically a
10:46 paragraph and a half. It's like at this
10:47 point Luther Martin stood up and
10:49 discourse at some length and nobody
10:50 listened to it, which I'm guessing is
10:53 not what actually happened. Um but these
10:55 were two men who were clearly on
10:57 opposite sides of things and and didn't
10:59 have much uh much of that personal
11:01 rapport um you know between them. Um but
11:04 it really just brings home that you know
11:06 the political fights that we have today
11:08 uh the nature of government today you
11:10 know things can seem you know very
11:12 hostile uh very difficult um but we've
11:15 lived through times like that in
11:16 American history before and that was
11:18 certainly the case in the founding era.
11:20 So another thing that you have always
11:23 explicated very carefully to me is this
11:25 idea that people's trajectories they are
11:27 they are judged based on the end and
11:30 they are rarely judged based on these
11:32 moments in between. And I think that you
11:34 brought up Aaron Burr which is your
11:35 favorite topic. Uh Aaron Burr I think is
11:38 a is a perfect example of this or if
11:39 there's others you have of people where
11:41 we look back and think this person was
11:44 great or terrible but there were moments
11:46 along the way where how they were judged
11:48 by their colleagues or where they could
11:50 have gone was not at all where they
11:52 ended up being and I just think that
11:54 that is something that we forget about
11:56 the arc of a person's life because we
11:58 frequently look back and and they get
12:00 two sentences in a book you know my
12:03 children only know about Governor Morris
12:04 because of you. Uh they don't they don't
12:07 >> you can tell that I've sort of corrupted
12:08 his four children at a young age. Uh you
12:11 know I also read children's books like
12:14 Duck for President and Click Clack
12:17 and Will's very aware that Governor
12:18 Morris is perhaps the only founder uh
12:21 with a prosthetic. Uh these are all very
12:23 important things to my family. But you
12:25 talk about this about this idea that
12:27 like somebody gets two sentences in a
12:29 book, right? They had years of their
12:31 lives in between and in the moment
12:33 somebody thinks that some one of them is
12:34 going to be president.
12:35 >> In the moment someone thinks that Aaron
12:37 Burr is going to be something that he
12:38 doesn't end up being right.
12:40 >> Yeah. So Oh knows that if you get me
12:42 going on Aaron Burr
12:43 >> it was a condition of his speech just in
12:45 case anyone's curious.
12:46 >> So Burr is an incredibly complicated
12:48 figure in American history and is
12:50 portrayed as sort of the true villain of
12:51 the early republic and and there are you
12:53 know aspects of truth to that. One thing
12:55 that's always fascinated me when you
12:57 think about history again to get sort of
13:00 about these guys. Um, you know, they say
13:02 that history is written by the winners,
13:04 and I think that's wrong, but history is
13:05 written by elites. Um, and typically
13:08 throughout American history, the same is
13:10 the case in other countries as well. Uh,
13:12 really going back to classical
13:13 antiquity, um, populist movements tend
13:16 to get written out of conventional
13:17 histories. Um, Aaron Burr, more than
13:20 anything else, I think was sort of the
13:22 first great American populist. um and
13:24 created a political machine um in in uh
13:28 in in early New York um that really sets
13:32 the stage for almost everything that
13:33 follows uh in in early American politics
13:36 as opposed to uh you know the the early
13:39 American government. Um so Martin Van
13:41 Burren who's the the figure probably
13:44 more than than any other who makes
13:46 jonianism the the dominant um you know
13:49 political political movement in America.
13:51 He comes out of the Aaron Burr machine,
13:53 the Tam machine in New York. I mean,
13:54 he's originally from Kinderhook, but
13:56 becomes deeply imshed in Tam. Burr
13:59 himself is largely responsible for the
14:01 election of Thomas Jefferson. He flips
14:03 the New York legislature by
14:05 infranchising new voters uh in 1800 in
14:08 time for them to award their electoral
14:10 votes to Jefferson, which is Jefferson's
14:12 electoral margin. Um Aaron Burr is in
14:15 many respects I think uh we owe him a
14:18 lot of credit for our independent
14:19 judiciary that when Jefferson moves hard
14:22 against John Marshall and attempts to
14:24 queue up an impeachment of John Marshall
14:25 by first impeaching Samuel Chase of
14:27 Maryland um who's in and in and of
14:30 himself a fascinating historical figure.
14:33 Uh Burr is the outgoing vice president.
14:35 He presides over that first impeachment
14:37 trial in the US Senate and insists on uh
14:41 you know rules of evidence and procedure
14:44 uh that end up defeating the impeachment
14:45 drive against Samuel Chase uh and and no
14:48 Supreme Court justice has ever been
14:49 impeached since. So again, I think when
14:51 you look at history, you need to, you
14:53 know, you look you need to look at these
14:54 guys, warts and all. We don't need to
14:56 talk about the, you know, the Burr plot
14:58 in the West that results in his
15:00 indictment for treason at this time. Um
15:02 but Burr is one of those figures that I
15:03 think it's it's very easy to caricature,
15:06 but when you actually look at the
15:08 historical record, I mean, he was a
15:09 great American war hero from the
15:11 Revolution. He had tremendous political
15:13 purchase in this time. Uh and as we
15:15 think about the founding era and
15:17 particularly as we look to compare the
15:18 founding era to American politics that
15:21 followed the American political history
15:22 that followed um it behooves us to look
15:25 at sort of early American populism and
15:28 understand how that ties into jonianism.
15:31 Uh frankly how that ties into post civil
15:33 war politics in many parts of the
15:35 country. I think Rosco Conklin is
15:37 another guy who's who's sort of terribly
15:38 misunderstood uh when you think about
15:41 American political history. Um you know
15:43 vilified because of his opposition to
15:45 civil service reform which he called
15:46 snivel service reform. Not taking a
15:48 position on that obviously but Conklin
15:50 again um immensely powerful political
15:53 figure in his time uh who's too often
15:55 caricatured um you know when we when we
15:58 think about conventional history of the
15:59 United States. So when we think about
16:02 this, right, you're describing each of
16:04 these people, who taught them, who they
16:06 worked for. You start talking about the
16:08 tasks that define them, right? One of my
16:10 favorite stories that you tell is how is
16:12 how when Washington marches into New
16:14 York, you know where I'm going with
16:16 this? Washington marches in New York. Do
16:17 you want to me tell the story of this
16:20 very personal thing that he does because
16:22 in that time you don't have the
16:24 internet, these personalized moments
16:26 matter. you want to talk and this is one
16:27 of my stories about
16:29 >> you know I I studied military history as
16:30 an undergrad and that was really my
16:32 first great love. Uh had incredible
16:34 professors at Princeton uh in a
16:36 different world I would have gone on to
16:37 be a military history professor and I
16:39 probably would have slept a lot more and
16:41 had a lot more hair. But uh you know
16:44 Washington crossing the Delaware um by
16:47 all conventional metrics by the way that
16:49 they thought about um you know
16:51 operational arts at that time uh was
16:54 utter madness. Um Washington was the I
16:58 mean the patriot cause was very much on
17:00 a back leg. Uh the army was
17:02 dysfunctional. Um they had just been
17:04 handed a string of terrible defeats. Um
17:06 and Washington decides to roll the dice.
17:09 Um this isn't Caesar, you know, Ali Yaka
17:11 s Caesar knew what he was doing. Caesar
17:14 had a plan. Washington makes this
17:16 incredibly bold stroke. And if you look
17:19 at his writings, which is what I think o
17:21 is referring to, um he didn't know that
17:23 it was going to work. He didn't I think
17:26 think it was going to work. Um, but I
17:28 think in his mind if he wanted to if we
17:30 were going to go down, we were going to
17:31 go down fighting and this was the the
17:34 best plan he had at his disposal. And
17:36 Trenton and Princeton end up being
17:38 absolute master strokes. Um, they keep
17:40 the Patriot cause together for, you
17:42 know, through a terrible winter and into
17:44 another year. Uh, shows the British that
17:46 we still have fight left in us. Shows
17:48 the Hessins that maybe they uh may have
17:51 miscalculated their their involvement in
17:53 in the struggle. Um, it's one of those
17:55 moments in history that really could
17:57 have gone either way. And there's an
17:59 alternate history where, uh, the river
18:01 was a little more frozen. Um, or some of
18:04 the boats got lost or the columns didn't
18:06 converge at exactly the right time. Um,
18:09 where we'd be reading about how
18:10 Washington, you know, gambled away the
18:12 Patriot Cause and lost. And it's those
18:15 decisive moments in history. We think
18:16 Eisenhower before D-Day is very similar.
18:19 Um where we look at them with you know
18:21 with the the uh you know fortunate that
18:23 that we have you know hindsight and we
18:26 can look back and and we know what
18:27 happened. Um but standing in their shoes
18:30 is just remarkably difficult uh because
18:32 they don't have that benefit. Um I think
18:35 about that a lot you know in my current
18:36 role working in the White House. You
18:38 know we make decisions on a day-to-day
18:40 basis um with good information but often
18:43 very imperfect information. Um, and you
18:46 often wonder, you know, how certain
18:48 decisions will be viewed, you know, by
18:50 posterity, you know, in the fullness of
18:51 time. Um, and it's, uh, it's difficult
18:54 to almost accept um, by by thinking of
18:58 of them with reference to to folks who
19:00 have come before. Um, and Washington
19:02 crossing the Delaware, I mean, it's just
19:04 it's an one of the most incredible
19:06 moments of the revolution. Daniel Morgan
19:08 at Cowpens is another another great
19:10 example of that. um where an American
19:12 decides to do something wildly
19:14 unconventional uh and it pans out in a
19:16 way that you know now we view as these
19:18 incredible master strokes uh but in in
19:21 their time must have must have been
19:22 thought of and they must have thought of
19:24 them as just incredibly risky.
19:26 >> Okay, I feel like I have to do something
19:28 that's not just about the founding so
19:30 people can understand you. You're a man
19:31 who uh we went to very similar.
19:33 >> Let's just keep talking about the
19:34 founding so much fun. Should we talk
19:36 about cowpens?
19:38 was one of the great the tactical master
19:39 strokes of the revolution is one of the
19:42 only like unique things that an American
19:43 general did during the revolutionary
19:45 war. Uh Morgan essentially fames a
19:48 retreat. Um he knows the British expect
19:50 expect his militia to run. Um the
19:52 militia always ran in the face of a
19:54 bayonet charge. So he sets things up and
19:57 tells the militia uh that he had at his
19:59 disposal, fire two shots and then run
20:01 away. and he developed his entire uh
20:04 tactical plan for the battle um around
20:06 giving the British what they thought
20:08 they were going to see. And Banister
20:09 Tarlton uh with with his legion falls
20:12 right into the trap. William Washington
20:14 ends up uh closing in from behind with
20:16 his cavalry. Uh the Continental line
20:18 holds and Tarlton's force just collapses
20:21 in on itself. Um but again, you look at
20:23 the battle plan by sort of every
20:25 conventional metric available to them at
20:27 the time and it it should have seemed
20:28 like utter madness. Uhhuh. Another one
20:31 of those great examples in the founding
20:32 era where uh where we got it really
20:34 right and we're all very fortunate that
20:36 they did. So I hope everyone's had a few
20:39 moments to realize that every single No,
20:41 no, this is important. Every single one
20:43 of Will's stories identifies the people
20:46 in the story. This is why I'm very
20:48 grateful that Sheldon chose this panel
20:50 topic. Everybody else, you don't realize
20:53 this. Everyone else would tell the story
20:55 and talk about the American forces, the
20:57 British forces. You identify who who's
21:00 in charge, what their choices were, how
21:03 they made their decisions, and it's
21:05 always personal. So, now I want somebody
21:07 to learn something about you. Why you
21:09 are a man who has grown up and gone to a
21:11 lot of the same institutions I have, and
21:13 you uh Missouri is one of your greatest
21:16 loves. Uh I don't understand it. Uh I
21:19 grew up I grew up in Indiana and I now
21:20 live in Arizona. Um but you when I talk
21:24 to you when you're in Missouri, it's
21:25 different than when you're here. Uh I
21:28 don't know if you want to take a minute
21:29 to describe to what Missouri means to
21:31 you because it's something that I think
21:33 most people uh don't realize. They think
21:36 that you just happened to have landed in
21:38 Missouri, but it's a I mean, normally if
21:40 you were not working at the White House,
21:41 you would have on boots that had the
21:42 Missouri state seal on the front of them
21:44 just but could you talk about that
21:46 because I think it's a defining
21:47 characteristic of you.
21:49 >> Yeah, I uh I'll tell a fun fedsock
21:52 story. When I was at HLS, we used to
21:54 have a poker game. Um, and from time to
21:57 time, you know, conservative lawyers,
21:59 uh, sometimes judges who were in town,
22:02 um, would stop by and and sit in and
22:04 play with us. Um, and Ted Cruz, uh, was
22:07 was one of those folks. He's a very,
22:08 very good poker player. Never sit down
22:10 and play poker with Ted Cruz. Um, but he
22:12 was with Morgan Lewis at the time. He
22:14 was obviously not yet a senator. Um, and
22:16 to us, he was, you know, he was an
22:18 incredible guy. He'd argued Medí at the
22:19 US Supreme Court. He'd been this
22:21 incredible solicitor general of Texas.
22:23 Um, and I actually asked him, you know,
22:26 uh, what advice he would give to, um,
22:29 you know, to someone like me or to, you
22:31 know, folks like us. Um, and he he
22:34 basically said, in a few more words than
22:37 this, you know, get the heck get the
22:38 heck off the coasts. Um, don't fall into
22:41 the New York trap. Don't get sucked into
22:43 DC. Uh, go to a state and do something
22:46 remarkable there. And at the time, I
22:48 remember thinking that's that was very
22:50 unhelpful advice. Like, not all of us
22:52 can just off and become the solicitor
22:54 general of Texas. Um then my first
22:56 clerkship out out of law school was with
22:58 Ray Grunder uh in St. Louis. Uh an
23:01 incredible judge. He's been an
23:02 incredible friend and mentor to me. Um
23:04 and within about a month of landing in
23:06 St. Louis, I just realized that I like
23:08 the Midwest much better uh than the New
23:11 York that I'd grown up in or even the
23:13 Florida where my parents lived. Um I'd
23:15 worked in DC, I'd worked in New York. Um
23:19 Missouri just made a lot more sense to
23:20 me. Uh there's a great sense of
23:22 community there. People really care
23:23 about each other. Um you think about
23:25 what America is supposed to be about.
23:27 You read Toqueville. Um there's a lot of
23:29 that in St. Louis. Uh there's a lot of,
23:31 you know, people coming together. Um
23:33 people really caring about the community
23:35 that they live in. Um and as I got into
23:38 Missouri politics and and worked more
23:40 around the state, uh the smaller and
23:42 smaller you get, the smaller town you go
23:44 to, uh the more of that spirit is really
23:46 present. Um so I became a real Missouri
23:49 devote. Uh, I've bounced around a bit,
23:51 but I've spent basically 15 and a half
23:53 years there now. I still own my home
23:54 there. Uh, I make it back at every
23:56 opportunity. Um, I'm sure there are some
23:59 young lawyers and law students here in
24:01 the room. Um, it's very easy to take
24:04 sort of the welltrod course from elite
24:06 law school to big law firm. Um, you
24:09 know, you go to the big cities because
24:11 that's where the, you know, oftentimes
24:12 the frankly the best legal work is. Um,
24:15 but I'd encourage you to look elsewhere.
24:17 You know, there are incredible
24:18 opportunities in state houses and state
24:20 government. Um there are incredible
24:22 opportunities in in uh smaller cities
24:25 around America and even smaller than
24:27 that. I know my friend Amber Hulse is
24:29 somewhere around here. Uh she's an
24:31 outstanding young lawyer, worked with
24:32 Dylan Law Group or works with Dylan Law
24:34 Group. Uh she's also a state senator in
24:36 South Dakota and is now at a very young
24:38 age in leadership out there. Um she's
24:40 going to have an immense impact on that
24:42 state uh and its politics, its legal
24:45 culture uh for decades into the future.
24:47 Uh I'm sure opportunities to move here
24:49 to DC. I I know she did because we
24:51 offered to bring her into the White
24:52 House. Um I'm sure she'd have great
24:55 opportunities wherever she'd want to go,
24:56 but the fact that she's in her home
24:58 state uh doing great things for it, I
25:00 think is is commendable. Uh and I think
25:02 the founders would look kindly on it. Um
25:04 you know, they were men motivated by a
25:06 common patriot spirit. Um certainly the
25:08 Federalists, you know, wanted to bring
25:10 our country closer together. Um but when
25:12 you look back and and really look at how
25:14 they identified, how they thought about
25:16 themselves, uh distinct cultures,
25:18 distinct local cultures, uh were very
25:21 important to them. Um and that's kind of
25:22 the beauty of federalism that we do have
25:24 a central government. We want energy in
25:26 the executive always. We have a very
25:28 energetic executive in President Trump
25:30 now. Um but there's also this idea that
25:32 uh some things are best left to the
25:34 states. Um some things are better
25:36 decided at a at a more local at a more
25:38 communal level. Um and I think that's
25:40 key to the uh to America. And certainly
25:43 for me, Missouri's been the the home I
25:45 never knew uh that I and when I was uh
25:48 when I was a young child in New York and
25:51 it's been an incredible home to me. I
25:52 know there are a lot of Missurans in the
25:54 room. I I saw a couple of y'all when I
25:55 was walking in. Um but uh but yeah, I
25:58 just take the opportunity to thank the
26:00 great state of Missouri. There are a lot
26:02 of Missurrians in this administration.
26:04 My former law partner John Sour is
26:06 obviously the solicitor general. Uh Eric
26:08 Schmidt, Senator Eric Schmidt refers to
26:10 us as the Missouri mafia. um you can't
26:12 sort of turn a corner in this
26:14 administration without running into a to
26:16 a Missouri lawyer. Um and we're we're
26:18 very proud of uh proud of the work that
26:20 we've done. Okay. So my last question to
26:22 you is I I think every Supreme Court
26:25 fight that has occurred since we became,
26:28 you know, sentient adult lawyers you
26:30 have been uh closely involved in. One of
26:34 the defining characteristics of kind of
26:36 the court as it is in recent years as
26:39 the conservatives and people in this
26:40 room have become ascendant is um
26:44 longstanding
26:45 uh dubious precedents have fallen. Uh I
26:49 think I told you I would ask you some
26:51 question like this. Um when you look
26:53 back, you know, uh what is the case in
26:57 the recent terms that has fixed an
27:00 error, right or wrong, whatever phrase
27:01 you want to use, that you're the most
27:04 excited about or that means the most to
27:06 you there. There's a long line of them
27:07 that we can all check off, but but I
27:09 think it's it's interesting which one
27:11 most people in their own life identify
27:13 with.
27:14 >> Yeah. So, oh knows what my answer is
27:15 going to be. Like we're best friends, so
27:17 like this is this is a setup, but it's
27:19 slaughter. um when we were law students,
27:21 you know, you read Scalia's descent and
27:23 Morrison V. Olsson. Um you know, I came
27:25 of age during sort of the the the Bush
27:28 years. Um when unitary executive theory
27:31 was, I think, first coming into vogue. I
27:33 saw John U when I was walking in. I hope
27:35 I don't tick him off by what I'm about
27:37 to say. Um but Slaughter was an
27:39 immensely important case uh that I think
27:41 corrected uh very very poor and quite
27:45 ancient precedent. Um and uh I think it
27:48 really speaks to to uh what one of the
27:50 what I think of as the principal goals
27:52 of the federalist society uh which is
27:54 bringing American constitutional law uh
27:57 back in line with the constitution um
27:59 you know the vesting clause of article 2
28:01 in my view is is pretty clear uh and a
28:04 president who you know can't control
28:05 who's exercising uh the executive power
28:08 that is vested in him um that's a a
28:12 cabin presidency um I think slaughter uh
28:15 the Supreme Court did a masterful job uh
28:17 really got it right Um I was proud that
28:20 you know we as the White House and
28:22 obviously the Department of Justice uh
28:24 got to play a role in in correcting that
28:26 um you know historic constitutional
28:28 wrong. Um and particularly given uh you
28:32 know given Morrison uh given the history
28:34 given sort of how large those those
28:36 precedents have loomed um getting to be
28:39 a part of the administration that you
28:40 know played a role in in uh in in
28:43 delivering the slaughter opinion. Uh
28:45 very very proud of that. So, by total
28:48 accident and having nothing to do with
28:50 the fact that I talked to Will before
28:51 this, uh we American Jurers Link
28:54 occasionally makes coins uh for great
28:56 Supreme Court cases and uh so will here
28:58 is our Trumper slaughter coin. Uh by
29:01 total accident that's in my pocket. Uh
29:05 I should I should So on the obverse of
29:08 this coin, it says around the outside
29:11 commemorating generational wins at the
29:13 Supreme Court. And I don't think there's
29:15 a better way to describe than that.
29:17 Truly a generational win at the US
29:19 Supreme Court. This is quite beautiful.
29:20 Thank you.
29:21 >> Uh so I should note that I'm supposed to
29:22 read a script here which is that uh
29:24 after this is lunch. Uh lunch will be in
29:27 buffets here but also on the second
29:28 floor and there will be various sock
29:30 sidebar events. Uh there's a lot of
29:32 words. I don't know what all of them
29:33 mean. Uh but if you are proceeding to
29:36 lunch upstairs you will find um several
29:39 hundred coins of trunker slaughter and
29:42 others uh that will be a surprise to
29:44 you. Uh so I highly encourage anybody
29:46 who is even remotely interested in such
29:48 a thing to find their way quickly
29:50 upstairs for the lunch. Um, I also want
29:53 to just ask everyone to to give a round
29:57 of applause for Will. Will Will's job
30:01 [applause]
30:07 the press of Will's job goes beyond
30:10 anything I think any of you could
30:12 possibly comprehend, no matter what your
30:14 imagination may be. and yet he has
30:16 chosen to spend time with us here today
30:18 in the middle of the workday. Uh and I
30:20 think that speaks to how much this place
30:22 means to him, how much this hotel means
30:24 to him um in and how he grew up as a
30:26 lawyer. But I also just think that
30:28 everyone should uh give him a round of
30:29 applause for the time he has taken from
30:30 our country to [applause]
Nebius sinks on weak forecast full transcript
0:00 >> BEN. APPRECIATE IT.
0:02 OBVIOUSLY, WE'RE GOING TO LEARN
0:03 A LOT MORE NEXT WEEK WHEN SOME
0:05 OF THESE HEARINGS GET UNDERWAY
0:06 AND MAYBE THE REPORTING AROUND
0:07 IT. PLEASE COME BACK.
0:08 >> THANKS FOR HAVING ME.
0:10 >> MEANTIME, WE'RE LOOKING AT
0:11 SOME OF THESE OTHER AFFECTED
0:12 STOCKS. SHARES OF CBS ARE
0:14 SINKING THIS MORNING ON THE
0:15 HEELS OF A WEAK FORECAST. SEEMA
0:16 MODY JOINS US WITH MORE.
0:17 >> SEEMA THIS IS A NOTABLE MOVE.
0:19 NAB IS NOT ABLE TO RIDE THE
0:21 SUCCESS OF ITS COMPETITOR CORE
0:23 WEAVE, WHICH SAW ITS STOCK
0:24 SURGE ABOUT 20% YESTERDAY.
0:26 WE'RE WATCHING NAB IS DOWN
0:27 ABOUT 15% AFTER REPORTING
0:29 EARNINGS EARLIER THIS MORNING.
0:30 TOP AND BOTTOM LINE WERE NOT
0:32 THE PROBLEM HERE. IT'S THE
0:33 FORWARD LOOKING GUIDANCE THAT
0:34 IS WEIGHING ON SHARES. ON THE
0:36 EARNINGS CALL, EXECUTIVES SAID
0:37 THEY WERE BEING, QUOTE, VERY
0:39 CONSERVATIVE ABOUT THEIR
0:40 GUIDANCE AND SAID THEY TOOK
0:41 INTO ACCOUNT POTENTIAL DELAYS
0:43 IN NEW CAPACITY COMING ONLINE.
0:45 THEY SAID THAT IF THEY WERE
0:46 ABLE TO DELIVER ON TIME,
0:47 REVENUE SHOULD COME IN AHEAD OF
0:49 GUIDANCE. WORTH WATCHING IS THE
0:51 FALLOUT FROM JENSEN WONG'S
0:53 RESIGNATION AT NVIDIA. NEBULOUS
0:54 EARNINGS CALL DID HAPPEN BEFORE
0:56 THAT NEWS BROKE THIS MORNING.
0:57 THE TWO COMPANIES DO HAVE A
0:59 CLOSE RELATIONSHIP. IN MARCH,
1:01 NVIDIA INVESTED ABOUT $2
1:03 BILLION IN THE NIO CLOUD TO
1:04 ENABLE THE ROLLOUT OF MORE THAN
1:06 FIVE GIGAWATTS OF NVIDIA
1:07 SYSTEMS BY THE END OF 2030. IT
1:09 REMAINS TO BE SEEN HOW NEW
1:11 LEADERSHIP AT NVIDIA MAY AFFECT
1:13 ONGOING DEALS. I KNOW THAT'S
1:14 BEEN AN ACTIVE DISCUSSION THIS
1:15 MORNING. NIO CLOUDS AS A WHOLE.
1:17 AGAIN, THEY DID VERY WELL
1:19 YESTERDAY, BUT STRUGGLING YEAR
1:20 TO DATE LOSING NEARLY HALF OF
1:22 THEIR VALUE OVER THE PAST THREE
1:24 MONTHS. GUYS.
1:25 >> YEAH. WHAT'S NOT HELPING IS
1:26 THAT BORROWING COSTS ARE ON THE
1:28 MARCH HIGHER AGAIN. I MEAN THAT
1:29 WAS THE WHOLE PROBLEM TO BEGIN
1:31 WITH.
1:31 >> FOR SURE. HIGHER COST OF
1:33 CAPITAL, CERTAINLY AN ISSUE FOR
1:34 THE NIO CLOUD SECTOR AS A WHOLE.
1:36 BUT I THINK THE EXECUTIVES ON
1:38 NIO ON THIS CALL ARE VERY
1:41 DIFFERENT TONE THAN WHAT WE
1:42 HEARD FROM COREY CEO MIKE
1:44 INTRATOR YESTERDAY, WHO JOINED
1:46 YOU GUYS ON SET WHERE HE HAD
1:49 DELIVERED REALLY A DOSE OF
1:51 OPTIMISM ABOUT THE FUTURE. AND
1:52 AND ALSO
House Democratic Leader Hakeem Jeffries holds a news conference full transcript
0:00 in this failed Republican economy.
0:04 And the American people have had enough.
0:08 Had enough of the corruption, had enough
0:10 of the extremism,
0:12 had enough of Republicans in Congress,
0:16 focused on the wealthy, the welloff, and
0:18 the well-connected. House Democrats are
0:20 going to focus on making life more
0:23 affordable
0:25 for workingclass Americans, middleclass
0:27 Americans, all those who aspire to be
0:29 part of the middle class and everyday
0:32 Americans in every part of this great
0:34 country.
0:36 We're going to fight for smalltown
0:37 America. We're going to fight for rural
0:40 America. We're going to fight for urban
0:41 America. We're going to fight for the
0:43 heartland of America. We're going to
0:45 fight for black and brown communities
0:48 all across America. We're going to fight
0:51 to make this country affordable, to
0:53 drive down the high cost of living, and
0:56 at the same period of time make sure
0:58 that we're holding the crooks
1:00 accountable who have visited
1:03 unprecedented corruption
1:05 on the American people. Questions? Mr.
1:10 Any concerns that the president or the
1:12 White House may have been compromised by
1:14 the Chinese government over this Jensen
1:16 Wong spy situation?
1:19 >> Congressman Greg Meeks, the next
1:22 chairman of the Foreign Affairs
1:23 Committee, along with Congressman
1:27 Jim Heims, the next chair of the House
1:30 Intel Committee are leading the effort
1:33 to get to the bottom of what has
1:35 happened. There certainly are more
1:38 questions than answers. We had a
1:42 classified briefing earlier
1:44 this week. It was focused primarily on
1:47 the situation in Iran. We need a
1:49 classified briefing made available to
1:52 members of Congress as it relates to the
1:54 Nvidia situation. And to the extent that
1:58 our national security has been
2:00 compromised, the American people deserve
2:03 answers. and we're going to work to make
2:06 sure that happens.
2:10 >> Yeah.
2:10 >> Oh, uh, you've been asked multiple times
2:12 about raising the minimum wage and you
2:13 said it's a priority. What specific
2:15 number or what's the floor of the
2:18 minimum raise that you need to see for
2:20 that?
2:22 Well, that's a great question and it's
2:23 one of the things that we're working out
2:25 between the House and the Senate led by
2:28 the current chairman or soon to be uh
2:31 leaders within the House Democratic
2:33 Caucus, I should say, in the context of
2:37 uh the legislation that's previously
2:39 been introduced. The wage raise the wage
2:42 act does have substantial support within
2:47 the House Democratic Caucus family. It
2:49 is clear that we have to raise the
2:52 minimum wage. $7.25
2:55 unacceptable.
2:56 It hasn't changed in 20 years. And we
3:01 need to actually
3:03 make life more affordable by lowering
3:05 costs and by raising the wages that the
3:10 American people who are working hard and
3:11 playing by the rules receive. And so
3:14 we'll have more to say uh about what the
3:18 legislation will ultimately look like,
3:21 but we need dramatic change.
3:24 >> Thank you.
3:25 >> How do you want to end the conflict with
3:27 Iranian regime by forcing the US troops
3:31 uh withdrawal from the region or then
3:34 how do you want to secure? We're
3:36 >> committed. We're committed to ending the
3:39 reckless and costly war of choice in
3:41 Iran. It's been a disaster for the
3:43 American people. It's raised costs, made
3:46 life more expensive. The American people
3:49 are less safe. The Iranian regime is
3:51 stronger now than it was before the war.
3:54 We should have never entered into it.
3:57 House and Senate Democrats have strongly
3:59 opposed it, and we're going to do
4:01 everything we can to end it.
4:05 >> Thank you, Mr. Leer. You'll be traveling
4:07 to Denver, I believe, to speak at the
4:09 What's Next uh conference. That'll be a
4:11 conversation that Democrats will be
4:13 having about the future. What do you
4:15 hope to bring to this conversation as
4:17 you think about the future given the
4:19 majorities that you've been you've been
4:20 given? And how what do you send to the
4:23 American people who are saying, you
4:24 know, what's the value in looking ahead
4:27 when there are so many issues that need
4:29 to be addressed in this current moment?
4:31 I assume um that
4:35 we're going to have conversations all
4:37 across the country about
4:40 what comes next in terms of when
4:44 Democrats, as a result of what the
4:46 American people have done, have the
4:48 ability to govern on their behalf
4:50 beginning on January 3rd. That's our
4:53 focus as House Democrats because we know
4:56 the American people voted for dramatic
4:59 change and have completely and totally
5:02 repudiated MAGA extremism.
5:05 We've made clear as Democrats that we're
5:08 going to focus on affordability,
5:10 accountability, and lifting up American
5:12 values.
5:13 We need to end the war of choice in
5:17 Iran. We need to stop the Trump tariffs.
5:20 We need to reverse the Medicaid cuts. We
5:23 need to reverse the SNAP cuts. We need
5:25 to extend the Affordable Care Act tax
5:27 credits. We need to take substantial
5:30 steps toward bringing about our
5:33 commitment to universal health care so
5:36 that every single American in this
5:39 country can afford to go see a doctor
5:42 when they need one or when their family
5:46 needs one. We've got to get big money
5:50 out of politics and in Citizens United.
5:54 We have to make sure that we're cleaning
5:57 up the mess here in the Congress with
6:01 the executive branch and at the Supreme
6:04 Court. And that should begin by
6:07 prohibiting members of Congress from
6:10 trading stock. So, what comes next?
6:13 There's a lot that is on the table that
6:16 we plan to deliver meaningful, bold,
6:20 transformational
6:22 change for the American people. Thanks.
6:26 >> A lot of hands today.
6:29 >> One of the things you could do, uh, some
6:31 progressives are saying to end the war
6:32 in Iran is to have a rider on an
6:34 appropri. What do you think about that?
6:36 That could risk a shutdown. Are you
6:38 willing to go that far?
6:39 >> We need to end the reckless and costly
6:40 war of choice in Iran. That's been a
6:43 commitment that we've made. We've been
6:45 strongly opposed to this war from day
6:49 one and we will continue to do
6:51 everything we can to end it. With
6:54 respect to the appropriations process,
6:57 right now uh there are four corners
7:00 negotiations that are ongoing
7:03 led by Rosa Deluro,
7:06 the House top appropriator
7:09 for Democrats and
7:12 She's working through all of our
7:14 Democratic priorities
7:16 to see what's possible in advance of
7:19 December 11. I don't want to get out
7:21 ahead of Congresswoman Deloro,
7:25 but House Democrats have uniformly
7:29 opposed providing any additional money
7:35 to Donald Trump's war machine, to Pete
7:37 Hex's war machine over in the Middle
7:41 East. Taxpayer dollars should be spent
7:44 to make life more affordable for
7:47 everyday Americans, not to drop bombs
7:50 overseas in an endless war that Donald
7:53 Trump and Republicans promised
7:56 they would not get the country into but
7:59 turned around and did the exact
8:01 opposite.
8:02 >> Mr.
8:02 >> Thanks.
8:03 >> Good morning. Thank you.
8:05 >> You talked about affordability. You
8:06 talked about cost of living. You talk
8:08 about investigations, holding the
8:09 administration to account. In your mind,
8:12 which one is more important? Is it 5149
8:14 one way, 59 5149 the other way? Which
8:18 isn't? We've got to do all of the above,
8:20 but we've made clear
8:23 consistently, and I think this is a
8:25 position shared by House and Senate
8:27 Democrats,
8:29 uh, that we have to drive down the high
8:31 cost of living because life is way too
8:33 expensive. And as part of that effort,
8:36 we've got to deal with accountability
8:39 because there's a cost to corruption.
8:42 When you have people in government who
8:46 are stealing from the American people,
8:47 screwing over the American people and
8:49 shortch changing the American people,
8:51 they should be held accountable for
8:54 ripping off taxpayers as opposed to
8:58 putting the focus on actually making
9:00 life better for everyday Americans where
9:03 people are drowning in this failed
9:04 Republican economy.
9:07 Congress has a responsibility to serve
9:10 as a check and balance on an outofc
9:13 control executive branch.
9:15 That is that's not a partisan
9:19 thing. It's a patriotic thing.
9:22 During the very beginning of the journey
9:23 that we've now been on for 250 years,
9:27 James Madison made the observation that
9:28 at its best, Congress effectively should
9:31 be a rival to the executive branch.
9:34 Rival
9:36 These Republicans have been nothing more
9:38 than a reckless rubber stamp for the
9:41 extreme MAGA agenda. That's
9:44 unacceptable. That's not just Hakeim
9:47 Jeff saying it. The American people made
9:49 that clear that they've won a dramatic
9:52 change in direction. So, we've got to
9:56 relentlessly focus on affordability and
9:59 we've got to make sure that we are
10:01 delivering the type of accountability
10:04 that the American people are demanding
10:08 take place beginning in the new
10:12 Congress.
10:13 >> Mr.
10:15 Back to Nvidia, what's your reaction to
10:17 Johnson resigning this morning?
10:20 >> It was the right thing to do. Now we
10:23 have to get to the bottom of whether
10:25 America's national security has been
10:27 compromised.
10:31 >> Thank you, Mr. Leader. Um, you're about
10:33 to potentially take charge here of a
10:36 very big House Democratic majority. Can
10:39 you just explain to us a little bit of
10:41 your thinking? This poses quite an
10:44 opportunity, but also a number of
10:46 challenges. You've got this opportunity
10:48 that gives you some wiggle room. we
10:50 won't have you won't potentially have
10:51 these narrow margins that we've seen in
10:54 the past Congress. Um yet at the same
10:56 time you have the challenge of a lot of
10:59 voices with a lot of opinions coming
11:02 from across the country. Can you just
11:05 address that? How are you approaching
11:07 balancing uh what's ahead for you?
11:12 >> House of Representatives is a
11:14 righteously exuberant place. That's a
11:17 beautiful thing. That's what the framers
11:21 demanded in constructing the institution
11:25 that the house would reflect most
11:27 directly the passions of the American
11:30 people. It's why the house to this day
11:32 remains the only institution
11:34 where one can be directly elected as the
11:38 only way to serve
11:41 in the architecture of the federal
11:42 government. And the House Democratic
11:45 Caucus in the new Congress is going to
11:48 reflect
11:49 most intimately
11:51 the the gorgeous mosaic of the American
11:54 people
11:56 and and to channel the hopes, the
11:58 dreams, the aspirations, the fears, the
12:00 concerns, the anxieties, the life
12:02 experiences in such an incredible way,
12:05 which is what this new class of members
12:06 represents,
12:08 and the passions of the American people,
12:10 as the framers articulated,
12:14 And so we embrace the fact that the
12:16 House of Representatives and the House
12:17 Democratic Caucus is going to be a
12:19 passionate
12:21 place to debate ideas, but always
12:25 focused on trying to find the highest
12:29 common denominator
12:31 so we can make bold progress on behalf
12:34 of the American people, advance the
12:36 ball, and get things done. Thanks,
12:40 >> Leader Jeff. Um, obviously there will be
12:42 a new rules package in the next
12:44 Congress. Do you support new parent
12:46 proxy voting? And additionally, there
12:48 are several Democrats who have committed
12:51 during their campaigns to introducing
12:53 impeachment resolutions. Do you think
12:55 individual members should continue to be
12:57 able to introduce privileged impeachment
13:00 resolutions or do you think that there
13:01 should be further requirements like an
13:03 investigation from a committee?
13:07 I certainly will continue to strongly
13:10 support and I'm thankful for the
13:12 leadership of Britney Patterson uh and
13:15 Sarah Jacobs and other members of the
13:16 House Democratic Caucus in this regard
13:20 support proxy voting for expectant
13:23 mothers and for new parents. And with
13:27 respect to the privilege that currently
13:30 exists in the conversations that I've
13:32 had with uh Jim McGovern and others,
13:35 there's no expectation that that will
13:37 change.
13:40 I usually go back and forth, but you
13:42 know, y'all are overwhelming me right
13:43 now.
13:44 >> Thank you, Mr. Leader. Um Lord Kelly
13:46 with the Hill. Um Senator Van Holland
13:48 has called for removing provisions in
13:50 the NDAA related to deepening defense
13:53 cooperation and intelligence sharing
13:55 with Israel. Do you removing those.
13:57 >> Haven't had a conversation with Senator
13:58 Ben Holland, but what I have said is
14:01 that things have to dramatically change
14:04 over in the Middle East. We need
14:07 dramatic change in the West Bank, which
14:10 is why I strongly support the West Bank
14:12 Violence Protection Act. We need
14:14 dramatic change in Gaza and we need
14:17 dramatic change with respect to the
14:20 memorandum of understanding as it winds
14:22 down. All of which I've previously said
14:24 publicly and we'll work as a caucus to
14:28 make sure that we can bring about the
14:30 just and lasting peace that Israelis and
14:34 Palestinians deserve over in the Middle
14:37 East. The status quo is unacceptable
14:40 and we need dramatic change. And that
14:43 looks like, as far as I'm concerned,
14:45 making sure you have a safe and secure
14:47 Israel,
14:50 living side by side as a Jewish and
14:52 democratic state with an independent
14:54 Palestinian state that provides dignity
14:58 and self-determination for the
15:00 Palestinian people.
15:02 >> Thank you. Um, as was said earlier, you
15:06 know, you are on the precipice of
15:07 perhaps becoming speaker. you don't seem
15:10 to be opposed right now, but there is
15:12 grassroots frustration uh with the
15:15 current, you know, current leadership.
15:16 We're here talking to you. So, what
15:18 message do you have for the grassroots
15:20 and perhaps some of these incoming
15:21 members who've expressed frustration or
15:24 a lack of understanding of of what your
15:26 leadership will mean?
15:28 We're going to continue to uh talk to
15:32 every single member of the House
15:33 Democratic Caucus, both current members
15:37 and incoming members, about what we all
15:40 can do together for the American people
15:42 in the 120th
15:44 Congress.
15:46 confident that we're on a positive
15:48 trajectory as it relates to the vote
15:53 next Wednesday and then the vote on the
15:55 floor in January. But we take nothing
15:58 for granted
15:59 because all of us in the House of
16:02 Representatives are on a 2year
16:05 employment contract. And we have to
16:08 continue to make our case both with
16:11 respect to our track record up until
16:14 this point as well as perhaps even more
16:17 importantly our vision for the future.
16:20 We as House Democrats were written off
16:23 in January of 2025.
16:26 And when I stood here at this podium and
16:28 said they have no mandate,
16:31 we overperformed
16:34 the political environment in 2024, which
16:37 is why we came back and held them to the
16:39 narrowest majority of any party
16:42 since 1930 in the Great Depression.
16:46 I said in February of 2025, confidently
16:50 that House Democrats were going to take
16:52 back control.
16:55 And we did. I made clear that we were
16:58 going to battle Republicans and MAGA
17:01 extremism on every issue.
17:04 And we battle them on the one big ugly
17:06 bill,
17:08 which became the most unpopular
17:11 piece of legislation in modern American
17:14 history. We battled them on the Medicaid
17:16 cuts, battled them on the Affordable
17:18 Care Act tax credits, and forced
17:19 Republicans to vote on it over the
17:22 objection of Mike Johnson and Donald
17:25 Trump. And it passed. We forced votes on
17:28 extending
17:30 TPS for Haitian migrants, forced votes
17:33 to extend benefits to veterans
17:36 successfully, forced votes to override
17:39 Donald Trump's executive order on
17:42 collective bargaining. We force votes
17:45 with respect to making sure we fund our
17:47 allies
17:49 as opposed to supporting brutal
17:51 dictators
17:53 like Vladimir Putin. We force votes
17:56 repeatedly and successfully to end the
17:58 reckless and costly war of choice in
18:00 Iran and we're not going to stop
18:03 until we prevail. We've successfully
18:06 forced votes on Epstein transparency and
18:10 the Epstein files, and we're going to
18:12 continue to work with the brave and
18:14 courageous survivors until they get the
18:18 transparency
18:19 and the accountability that they
18:22 deserve. We've battled them on ICE
18:25 funding. We said we were not going to
18:28 provide an additional dime
18:33 to Donald Trump's violent mass
18:34 deportation machine and we haven't.
18:38 We've battled them on every issue. We
18:42 made clear to the American people
18:45 despite all the skepticism that was out
18:48 there
18:50 that the Republican gerrymandering
18:52 scheme was not going to be successful.
18:56 You had Republican operatives close to
18:59 the president saying that the
19:00 gerrymandering scheme was going to yield
19:03 them 16 seats.
19:06 16 seats.
19:09 Every single Democratic incumbent in a
19:12 gerrymandered district came back. Every
19:16 single one in Texas, in North Carolina,
19:20 in Ohio,
19:22 in Florida, every single
19:26 one came back. And in those states that
19:29 were gerrymandered, we flipped seats in
19:33 Ohio. We flipped a seat in Tennessee. We
19:38 flipped seven seats in North Carolina.
19:43 We held every single gerrymandered seat
19:46 in Florida. We flipped seats in Texas.
19:52 And of course, we flipped five seats
19:54 in California.
19:57 I stood here and said, "Republicans
20:01 have started this gerrymandering war.
20:03 Democrats were going to end it. Promise
20:06 made, promise kept." So, the record
20:10 speaks for itself. But that doesn't mean
20:13 it's not important to talk to every
20:16 single member of the House Democratic
20:18 Caucus family about what the future
20:21 looks like and how we can build upon
20:23 this record
20:26 where everyone doubted our ability to
20:29 aggressively fight back and continue
20:33 to bring about the type of bold,
20:35 dramatic, and decisive change that the
20:38 American people deserve. Thank you
20:41 everyone.
20:52 I
Huang was a 'trendsetter for the industry': Creative Strategies CEO Ben Bajarin full transcript
0:00 WITH INDISPENSABLE MEN. CFO
0:02 COLETTE KRESS HAS BEEN TAPPED
0:03 TO SERVE AS NVIDIA'S INTERIM
0:05 CEO, AS THE COMPANY SAYS IT
0:06 WILL NOW EVALUATE INSIDE AND
0:08 OUTSIDE CANDIDATES FOR A
0:09 PERMANENT REPLACEMENT. OUR NEXT
0:10 GUEST IS A TECH EXPERT AND
0:12 INDUSTRY INSIDER. HIS FIRM
0:13 WORKS CLOSELY WITH TECHNOLOGY
0:15 LEADERSHIP TEAMS. JOINING US IS
0:17 CREATIVE STRATEGY CEO BEN
0:19 BAJARIN. IT'S GREAT TO HAVE YOU,
0:20 BEN. I'M SURE YOUR PHONE IS
0:21 BLOWING UP LIKE OURS IS. ARE
0:23 THERE QUESTIONS ABOUT THE NEXT
0:25 CEO OR JUST PEOPLE IN SHOCK
0:26 ABOUT JENSEN OR WHAT ARE YOU
0:28 HEARING?
0:29 >> YEAH, I THINK IT'S BOTH.
0:31 THERE'S OBVIOUSLY A QUESTION OF,
0:32 YOU KNOW, WHO COULD BE THE
0:34 LOGICAL CANDIDATE TO RUN NVIDIA,
0:35 WHETHER THAT'S AN INTERNAL OR
0:36 AN EXTERNAL CANDIDATE. THERE'S
0:38 A LOT OF QUESTIONS ABOUT, YOU
0:39 KNOW DOES ANYTHING CHANGE IN
0:41 THE STRATEGY. YOU KNOW HOW MUCH
0:42 OF THE STRATEGY WAS TIED TO
0:44 JENSEN'S DEEP CONVICTIONS ABOUT
0:45 WHERE THIS INDUSTRY GOES, HOW
0:46 THEY USE THEIR BALANCE SHEET,
0:47 WHAT THAT LOOK LIKE WITH THEIR
0:49 ECOSYSTEM. SO I THINK A LOT OF
0:50 THAT CALLS INTO QUESTION,
0:51 OBVIOUSLY, THINGS WE WE DON'T
0:53 HAVE THE ANSWER FOR. BUT I
0:54 THINK, YOU KNOW, ANY TIME
0:55 SOMETHING LIKE THIS HAPPENS AND
0:57 WE OBSERVE THIS, YOU KNOW, BACK
0:58 IN THE DAY WITH APPLE WHEN
1:00 STEVE JOBS HAD CANCER AND THEN,
1:01 YOU KNOW, INEVITABLY,
1:02 INEVITABLY DIED, IT CREATES A
1:03 HUGE SHAKEUP AND AN IMPACT TO
1:05 THE INDUSTRY. AND WE'RE GOING
1:06 THROUGH THAT PROCESS RIGHT NOW.
1:08 >> WELL, IT SORT OF REMINDS ME
1:10 OF THIS OF THIS BLANKFEIN TWEET,
1:11 THAT POST THAT WE JUST THAT WE
1:13 JUST SHARED. IS HE AN
1:15 INDISPENSABLE MAN WHEN IT COMES
1:16 TO NVIDIA AND THE BROADER
1:19 ECOSYSTEM?
1:20 >> I THINK THE CHALLENGE IS HE
1:22 WAS VERY CHARISMATIC. AND
1:23 ANYTIME YOU YOU LEARN YOU LOSE
1:25 A FOUNDER LEVEL, YOU KNOW, TYPE
1:26 OF CHARISMA WHO REALLY HAS BEEN
1:28 LOOKED UPON AS KIND OF THE THE
1:30 TRENDSETTER FOR THE INDUSTRY,
1:32 RIGHT? THE, THE SPOKESPERSON
1:33 FOR THIS MOMENT THAT WE HAVE IN
1:35 THIS TECHNOLOGY BUILD OUT, YOU
1:36 KNOW, THAT'S, THAT'S GOING TO
1:37 BE A LOSS. THAT DOESN'T MEAN
1:39 THAT THEIR PRODUCT ROADMAP IS
1:40 STRONG. THAT DOESN'T MEAN THAT
1:41 THEIR EXECUTION CAN CHANGE. YOU
1:43 KNOW, AGAIN, APPLE IS THE BEST
1:44 COMP. WE HAVE TO SEEING HOW NEW
1:46 LEADERSHIP CAN, CAN GROW AND
1:47 SCALE A COMPANY AT AN
1:48 OPERATIONAL LEVEL. BUT THAT
1:50 DOESN'T CHANGE THE FACT THAT
1:51 THERE IS A CULTURE RIGHT SET
1:52 THAT THAT WAS SET, THAT HAS TO
1:54 BE PRESERVED. AND, AND THAT'S
1:56 WHAT WE JUST DON'T KNOW. RIGHT.
1:57 IT WAS A LITTLE BIT EASIER WITH
1:59 APPLE. YOU HAD SOME FAITH IN
2:00 TIM COOK. YOU KNOW, HE'D BEEN
2:02 THERE FOREVER. IT'S DIFFERENT
2:03 WITH NVIDIA UNTIL WE KNOW RIGHT.
2:04 WHO TAKES OVER.
2:05 >> YEAH. I MEAN THAT IS A GOOD
2:07 POINT. AND I SAW YOU POSTED
2:08 THAT AS WELL. THE CULTURE
2:10 SETTER AT CEO AS CULTURE SETTER.
2:11 YOU KNOW WE'RE LEARNING HOW
2:13 MANY ROLES THAT CEOS HAVE TO
2:14 HAVE TO TAKE ON. AND, AND, AND
2:16 IT'S HARD TO FIND, YOU KNOW,
2:17 SOMEONE THAT, THAT ENCOMPASSES
2:19 ALL OF THEM. YOU THINK THAT IAN
2:20 BUCK IS SOMEONE TO WATCH?
2:22 >> YEAH, I THINK IAN'S BEEN
2:23 AROUND, YOU KNOW, REALLY AS
2:24 JENSEN'S RIGHT HAND MAN. HE'S
2:26 DEEPLY TECHNICAL IN THE WEEDS.
2:27 HE UNDERSTANDS THE BUSINESS. I
2:29 THINK HE'S BEEN, YOU KNOW,
2:31 REALLY ONE OF THE FRONT RUNNERS
2:32 IN WORKING WITH ALL OF THEIR
2:33 CUSTOMERS AND ECOSYSTEM. SO HE
2:35 HAS THOSE RELATIONSHIPS. SO I
2:36 MEAN, I THINK HE'S THE MOST
2:38 LOGICAL CANDIDATE. I ASSUME
2:40 THAT THEY'RE GOING TO DO, YOU
2:42 KNOW, EXTERNAL SEARCHES. I KNOW
2:43 YOU'VE HAD, YOU KNOW, NAMES
2:45 THROWN AROUND LIKE JOHNY SROUJI
2:46 FROM APPLE. BUT I THINK, YOU
2:48 KNOW, AGAIN, I THINK WHEN IT
2:50 COMES TO A, A CULTURE, A, A SET
2:54 OF INNOVATION, I THINK INTERNAL
2:55 CANDIDATES ARE TYPICALLY BEST.
2:56 SO I WOULD EXPECT THAT THEY
2:57 LOOK THEIR FIRST.
2:59 >> YEAH. I'M CURIOUS ON THAT
3:01 THOUGH. SO WHY DO YOU FEEL
3:03 INTERNAL CANDIDATES WOULD BE
3:04 BEST IN THIS SITUATION? BECAUSE
3:05 IT IS SORT OF A UNIQUE
3:07 SITUATION TO A CERTAIN EXTENT.
3:08 AND THEY'RE OBVIOUSLY GOING TO
3:09 BE INVESTIGATIONS OF MR. WONG
3:10 IN PARTICULAR OVER TIME. IN
3:13 TERMS OF NATIONAL SECURITY. I
3:14 JUST WONDER WHY YOU DON'T THINK
3:16 IT WOULD BE BENEFICIAL, PERHAPS,
3:18 TO BRING IN AN OUTSIDER.
3:20 >> I MEAN, I THINK THERE'S A
3:21 FEW THINGS, RIGHT? IT'S
3:22 TYPICALLY HARDER FOR AN
3:23 OUTSIDER TO COME IN AND EXECUTE
3:25 AT THIS LEVEL WITH A COMPANY
3:27 WHO, AGAIN, YOU HAVE TO HAVE
3:29 DEEP SEMICONDUCTOR EXPERTISE.
3:29 LIKE IT CAN'T BE SOMEBODY
3:31 OUTSIDE OF THE SEMICONDUCTOR
3:33 INDUSTRY. AND IT'S JUST A VERY
3:34 SHORT LIST, RIGHT? LOOK AT WHAT
3:36 INTEL WENT THROUGH IN REPLACING
3:37 PAT GELSINGER. IT'S A VERY
3:38 SHORT LIST OF PEOPLE WHO CAN DO
3:40 THAT AT THIS SCALE. WHO HAS THE
3:42 SUPPLY CHAIN RELATIONSHIPS. YOU
3:43 KNOW, IAN HAS BEEN AROUND IN
3:45 THAT, YOU KNOW, I DON'T IT
3:47 WOULD BE SPECULATIVE TO SAY
3:48 HE'S GOT ANY TIES TO ANYTHING
3:50 THAT WENT ON WITH JENSEN. BUT
3:52 JUST THE LENGTH OF TIME HE'S
3:53 HAD IN INDUSTRY GROWING THIS
3:56 COMPANY BEEN THERE SINCE VERY,
3:57 VERY EARLY DAYS. IT MAKES HIM
3:59 THE MOST REALISTIC CANDIDATE.
4:01 AND AGAIN, BECAUSE THE SUPPLY
4:04 CHAIN LIKE THIS INDUSTRY,
4:06 SEMICONDUCTORS, IS VERY
4:06 DIFFERENT THAN MANY OTHER
4:08 INDUSTRIES. TYPICALLY, WHY YOU
4:09 WANT PEOPLE WHO'VE, WHO'VE BEEN
4:10 IN THAT ROLE AND INVOLVED IN
4:12 THAT ECOSYSTEM FOR A LONG TIME.
4:14 >> YOU ALSO WANT SOMEBODY WHO
4:15 CAN MAKE SURE YOU KEEP ALL THE
4:17 ENGINEERS. I MEAN, THAT'S THE
4:18 KEY TALENT, ISN'T IT?
4:19 >> THAT AGREED.
4:20 >> THAT WILL GO TO THE FUTURE
4:21 OF THE COMPANY IN ITS SUCCESS.
4:23 >> AGREED. AND THAT GOES BACK
4:24 TO, I THINK, RIGHT. JUST YOU
4:26 KNOW, JENSEN WAS A PERSON THAT
4:27 A LOT OF PEOPLE LOOKED UP TO,
4:29 RIGHT? THEY WANTED TO WORK FOR
4:31 THIS PERSON. THERE WAS PASSION
4:32 AND CONVICTION. THIS IS A
4:33 STRESSFUL INDUSTRY, RIGHT? THIS
4:34 IS A STRESSFUL TIME TO WORK IN.
4:36 AND SO YOU GOT TO BELIEVE IN
4:38 YOUR LEADER. AND I THINK THAT'S
4:39 ALSO REALLY WHAT'S WHAT'S
4:40 WHAT'S HARMING HERE. AND WHAT
4:41 THEY
Faber Report: OpenAI raised $15B at $.125 valuation full transcript
0:08 NOMINATIONS.CNBC.COM.
0:10 >> IF YOU'RE JUST WAKING UP OUT
0:12 WEST, JEN-HSUN HUANG RESIGNS AS
0:13 CEO AND BOARD MEMBER OF NVIDIA
0:15 COMPANY LAUNCHES A SEARCH. CFO
0:17 COLETTE KRESS WILL BE INTERIM
0:19 CEO. STOCK GOT TO 148 80 THIS
0:23 MORNING ON THAT NEWS, ALTHOUGH
0:25 REBOUNDING NOW BACK TO 160 AND
0:27 CHANGE OF COURSE. GUYS THIS WAS
0:28 A $210 STOCK LAST TUESDAY. SO
0:32 WE'LL WATCH IT CLOSELY.
0:33 >> YEAH LOOK IT THERE. THIS IS
0:35 A COMPANY THAT OBVIOUSLY THE
0:37 MOST IMPORTANT PERSON IN
0:40 SEMICONDUCTORS MORE EVEN THAN
0:42 ANDY GROVE. MORE THAN GREG BEAR.
0:43 MORE YOU KNOW MORE THAN GORDON
0:45 MOORE. YES. AND YES. BECAUSE HE
0:47 MADE IT MORE THAN SEMIS.
0:48 REMEMBER SEMIS WERE REALLY
0:49 SECOND RATE TO SOFTWARE.
0:52 >> ANOTHER COMPANY THAT WE OF
0:53 COURSE FOLLOWED CLOSELY HERE
0:55 THAT IS PRIVATE STILL IS OPEN
0:56 AI. AND I DID WANT TO SHARE
0:58 SOME RECENT NEWS ON THAT
0:59 COMPANY. BY THE WAY, A COMPANY
1:00 THAT HAS TAKEN IN SOME $30
1:02 BILLION FROM NVIDIA, SOME $65
1:05 BILLION FROM SOFTBANK, BUT HAS
1:07 HAD THE NEED TO CONTINUE TO
1:08 RAISE MORE MONEY AS A RESULT OF
1:10 WHAT IS AN ENORMOUS CASH BURN,
1:12 DESPITE WHAT IS ALSO
1:13 SIGNIFICANT REVENUE GROWTH AT
1:14 OPEN AI. REMEMBER, WE REPORTED
1:16 YESTERDAY ABOUT 50% REVENUE
1:18 GROWTH FROM THE SECOND TO THE
1:19 THIRD QUARTER FOR THE COMPANY
1:20 CAN TELL YOU NOW, ACCORDING TO
1:22 PEOPLE FAMILIAR WITH WITH THE
1:23 SITUATION, THEY'VE RAISED 15
1:25 BILLION IN THEIR LATEST EFFORT
1:27 TO DO SO AT A $1.25 TRILLION
1:30 VALUATION. RECENT REPORTS HAD
1:31 THE COMPANY AT 11 BILLION. I
1:33 CAN NOW TELL YOU THEY'RE AT 15.
1:35 UNCLEAR WHETHER THEY WILL GO
1:36 BEYOND THAT OR WHETHER THAT
1:38 WILL BE SORT OF WHERE THEY END
1:39 THIS LATEST FUNDRAISING AT OPEN
1:42 AI. AND AGAIN, AT A $1.25
1:45 TRILLION OVERALL VALUE. YOU MAY
1:46 RECALL THE COMPANY ACTUALLY DID
1:48 GO TO THE MARKET WITH THE
1:49 INTENT OF RAISING AS MUCH AS
1:51 $30 BILLION AT A $1.4 TRILLION
1:54 VALUATION. IT HAD A PULLBACK.
1:55 BOTH VALUATION AND ITS
1:57 AMBITIONS FOR RAISING NEW
1:58 CAPITAL AT LEAST BASED ON WHAT
2:02 IT ACTUALLY WAS ABLE TO TO GET
2:05 FROM EXISTING. AND SOME NEW
2:08 INVESTORS AS WELL. THIS OF
2:10 COURSE, COMES AS WE ARE LESS
2:12 THAN A WEEK AWAY GUYS FROM
2:13 ANTHROPIC'S IPO IN WHICH IT IS
2:15 GOING TO BE RAISING AT LEAST
2:16 LET'S CALL IT 80 PLUS $84
2:19 BILLION. SOME $26 BILLION FROM
2:21 STRATEGIC PARTNERS THAT DO
2:22 INCLUDE NVIDIA AND OF COURSE
2:25 FROM THE PUBLIC AS WELL BOTH
2:27 INSTITUTIONAL INVESTORS AND
2:28 INVESTORS AROUND THE WORLD AND
2:31 RETAIL INVESTORS ALSO YOU KNOW
2:33 I AM HEARING SOME POSITIVE
2:35 CHATTER AROUND ANTHROPIC. JIM.
2:37 THE HOPE THAT AS I SORT OF SAID
2:39 ON MONDAY THAT, YOU KNOW, THEY
2:40 TALK ONE 3 TO 1 FOUR, BUT
2:42 REALLY THEY MAY MOVE PRICING UP
2:43 TO AS HIGH AS 1.5 TRILLION.
2:45 >> 1.5, 1.6, 1.6.
2:47 >> AND THEN YOU SEE WHERE IT
2:48 TRADES IN THE AFTERMARKET.
2:50 AGAIN, WE SHALL SEE. UNCLEAR
2:53 EXACTLY HOW THIS NEWS FROM
2:54 NVIDIA THIS MORNING IS GOING TO
2:55 PLAY OUT. BUT I DID OFFER UP
2:57 THE IDEA THAT TO THE EXTENT
2:58 THAT IT LESSENS THE INFLUENCE
3:00 OF OPEN SOURCE GIVING, YOU'VE
3:01 TAKEN THE LARGEST SINGLE
3:04 SUPPORTER OFF THE FIELD IN
3:06 JEN-HSUN HUANG MIGHT BE SEEN AS
3:08 A POSITIVE FOR THE FRONTIER
3:09 LABS.
3:09 >> HOW MUCH DO YOU THINK IT
3:11 MATTERS THAT THEY HAVE THE BIG
3:13 STOCK BASED COMPENSATION? THAT
3:14 IF YOU TOOK AWAY THE YOU KNOW,
3:16 THERE'S THEY'RE SPENDING A LOT
3:18 OF TIME DEFENDING THEIR ACTUAL
3:21 PROFITABILITY.
3:21 >> THIS IS ANTHROPIC YOU'RE
3:22 TALKING ABOUT.
3:23 >> YEAH, BUT THE STOCK BASED
3:24 COMPENSATION IS HUGE.
3:25 >> IT IS HUGE, ALTHOUGH FRANKLY,
3:27 IT'S HUGE THAT A LOT OF OTHER
3:28 PUBLIC COMPANIES AS WELL. AND
3:29 THEN WE SIT HERE AND WE TALK
3:31 ABOUT ADJUSTED EBITDA. AND
3:32 EVERY SO OFTEN I'LL POINT OUT,
3:34 OH, BY THE WAY, IF YOU ADJUST,
3:35 IF YOU ACTUALLY ADD BACK STOCK
3:37 BASED COMPENSATION, THE
3:38 DIFFERENTIAL BETWEEN GAAP
3:39 EARNINGS AND NON-GAAP WAS
3:39 ENORMOUS. SO I DON'T KNOW IS
3:41 THE ANSWER HOW MUCH IT'S GOING
3:42 TO MATTER.
3:43 >> I'M JUST THINKING I MEAN TO
3:45 ME I'VE BEEN GOING OVER THE
3:46 VALUATION. I THINK THE
3:47 VALUATION IS STUNNING. AND I
3:48 KNOW THAT THE NUMBER THAT
3:50 GOLDMAN PUT OUT FOR 2030
3:51 REVENUES IS EXTRAORDINARY,
3:52 RIGHT. SO THEY CAN BE BEAT.
3:53 >> I MEAN, THE NUMBER THAT
3:55 MATTERS IS THE ONE
WNBA Finals MVP Gabby Williams On Golden State’s Championship, WNBA Politics And What Comes Next full transcript
0:00 Coming up this week on CNBC Sport the Podcast, WNBA
0:05 Finals MVP Gabby Williams on how her life has changed already
0:09 since winning the WNBA Championship last week. I'm just
0:13 smiling a lot more, which is great. Plus, what she wants to
0:17 see from the next WNBA Commissioner. I just hope our
0:20 next commissioner takes the time to like get to know us as
0:22 people, and if she thinks the recent election results will
0:27 quiet down outside political attention on the league, being a
0:31 female athlete just automatically becomes
0:33 politicized because we're in a space where maybe we weren't
0:36 welcome before. That's all coming up next this week on CNBC
0:41 Sport the Podcast.
0:45 I am happy to be joined by the reigning WNBA Finals MVP, Gabby.
0:51 Thank you for joining us. Thanks for having us. Is this a
0:54 whirlwind for you? Yeah, absolutely. Every day is like a
0:57 new adventure. I mean, well, all right. I have a couple questions
1:01 to start off with. First of all, let's talk about Game Six. Okay,
1:04 you get the news that the venue is going to be changed, that the
1:07 time is going to be this bizarre time, 1230 in the afternoon.
1:12 What are you thinking when you hear all of this?
1:15 I mean, I
1:17 was worried on a lot of other things. Honestly, that that
1:20 wasn't
1:21 time and place didn't matter too much by game six. I think our
1:25 minds were kind of spiraling, but yeah, it was a tough it was
1:29 a tough start, but we didn't really mind it. So yeah, that
1:33 didn't throw you off. You weren't thinking in the back of
1:35 your head, you know, I can't believe this that they're doing
1:37 this or anything like that. No, not at all. The only thing would
1:40 have been like if we were to have won the ceremony, that
1:44 would have been unfortunate, but a good thing we just did. That's
1:46 what I was gonna say. So in the end, in the back of your mind,
1:49 are you are seriously when then that game's over and you're
1:52 thinking, oh wow, I get to play game seven at home now at
1:55 Valhalla. Are you thinking this is better? Not necessarily
2:00 better, because I mean there's so much stress and unknown.
2:03 Definitely mixed emotions of just like, okay, was that our
2:06 shot? Did we just lose it? But then also I try to stay positive
2:09 and be like, okay, but how good is that going to feel if we do
2:12 get it done? Maybe this is just meant to be and meant for us. So
2:15 try to think of it that way. And now let's talk about Game Seven
2:17 a little bit. 28 points in the second half.
2:20 As you're going through that, this is sort of a question for
2:23 like you know laymen like myself that are not professional
2:27 athletes. Is there some point where you're feeling, oh, I've
2:32 got it today? Like, oh, I've I've like I've hit my flow
2:35 state, or or is it? Are you too in the moment so that it never
2:39 really registers like that. I've had games where you can like
2:43 really recognize
2:45 it. Like I think like Dallas game too. I was like, oh, okay,
2:48 like I'm not missing today, you know. Or there's a couple games
2:50 against Vegas where I was like, oh, I have it. That game, I I
2:54 was just so in the moment and I think like under the pressure
2:56 that I didn't really realize
2:59 how much of like a zone I was in until I like rewatched the game
3:02 back, and I was like, "Oh wow, I really was in the zone." But in
3:06 the moment, I was just there was a lot of pressure, so I think I
3:09 was just taking possession by possession. I've heard you say
3:12 that in the off season when you decided to join Golden State,
3:16 that one of the things that made you make the decision was Joe
3:21 Laco? Is
3:23 that what? What is first of all? What did he say to you to make
3:25 you join the team? But what is your relationship with him like?
3:29 And is it unusual for an owner and a player to have a
3:32 relationship like that, especially right off the bat? I
3:35 think it just depends on the owner how much they want to be
3:38 involved. You know, I've had certain owners who maybe want to
3:41 keep a you know heat or distance than others who are very
3:44 involved and like you can't go to their house have dinner with
3:46 them, but he what stood out to me was just his competitiveness
3:50 on the phone call. Like I didn't expect that to be like what what
3:54 got me to come. You know that was kind of like the tipping
3:56 point for me to come to Golden State. I didn't expect that when
3:58 I got on the call with him, but hearing him talking about his
4:02 investment into the sport, into the franchise, what he had
4:05 envisioned for his athletes,
4:07 that just showed me that, like, okay, this guy's gonna help me
4:09 win one day. Was he super confident that you were gonna
4:12 win a title? Yeah, yeah, absolutely. I mean, I wanted to
4:15 go somewhere that we were gonna contend. He was, you know, he
4:18 talked about how he'd done it before. He it sounded like he
4:21 knew how to build the right culture and have the right
4:23 people, and yeah, he's been proven right. I know you got a
4:26 text from Michael Jordan. Any other interesting texts that
4:30 you've received in the past few days?
4:32 It's just been great. I was at the UConn game yesterday, and
4:36 like I was talking to Alicia Clark, and I was like, the best
4:39 messages I've received have been from players like her, like Sue
4:43 Bird or Nafisa, like players who have kind of seen my trajectory
4:47 for like the last eight years and have seen like you know from
4:50 from the ground up. Those messages meant a lot to me. The
4:52 WNBA is going through a little bit of a transition period now
4:55 in the sense that Kathy Engelbert is leaving as the
4:58 commissioner. What are you?
5:00 For out of the next commissioner of the league, I just hope our
5:03 next commissioner
5:05 takes the time to like get to know us as people. I think
5:08 that's a. I think that will. There's a bit of a disconnect
5:12 sometimes, and I think that can just be easily solved by just
5:14 like I don't know taking a team out to dinner, having a meeting
5:17 with them, getting to know them, hearing their side of the story,
5:19 and realizing like we can work together and we can get to know
5:23 each other. It could also allow us to be more empathetic to the
5:25 commissioner and understand like what that person has to do as
5:28 well in their role. How would you assess the job Kathy did
5:30 with the league? I think obviously we've made great
5:33 strides. I do understand, you know, the positive and the
5:37 negative sides of it. Like I said, I think just her having a
5:40 bit more of a human relationship with the players would have gone
5:42 a long way, but I mean we can't deny what she's created and what
5:46 she's helped grow this league to be. I think she is a big part of
5:50 that as well. There is an association, particularly I
5:54 would say over the past year with the league and cultural and
5:58 political issues. We see it all the time in the media, and some
6:01 of that has to do with gender and sexuality and trans rights,
6:04 which I know you've been particularly outspoken about. We
6:06 just had an election, which was this, you know, blue tsunami. Do
6:11 you think that the election results
6:15 will change the way the outside world treats the league, or do
6:20 you do you can do you think that the connection between sort of
6:25 this political and cultural and the league and these sort of hot
6:29 button issues will just continue?
6:32 I think as a female athlete, we are
6:36 just our existence is political. Unfortunately, you know, we're a
6:39 lot of women who are
6:41 either queer women of color, and just kind of being a female
6:45 athlete just automatically becomes politicized because
6:48 we're in a space where maybe we weren't welcome before. So I
6:51 think that's something that we embrace as athletes. You know, I
6:54 think we understand that we are the the kind of leaders you see
6:57 as
6:58 you know when we were trying to elect Warnock back in 2020, you
7:02 know, the standing up for Black Lives Matter movement, obviously
7:04 being for trailblazers and queer rights. So I think that'll
7:07 continue. Did you expect that coming into the league?
7:11 It was something I remember, like 2016, watching Minnesota,
7:14 the Minnesota Lynx, and that like really,
7:17 like that's like a core memory for me. Watching that while I
7:19 was in college and realizing, like, oh wow, these aren't just
7:21 basketball players; like, these are leaders in our community. So
7:24 I was actually looking forward to that part of the W. There's
7:28 sort of associated with that. I think there's been a lot of
7:31 attention paid on how the league treats Caitlin Clark. Should the
7:35 league be protecting her more? Then I think there was some
7:38 pushback among certain players about, like, should she be the
7:41 face of the league? I'm curious, just your opinion, sort of on
7:46 all of that, like the league's relationship with Caitlin Clark,
7:49 and from a player's perspective, is it fair that people see her
7:52 as the face of the league?
7:55 I think everyone is just everyone's winning right now,
7:58 right? You know, we just had this amazing,
8:01 this prolific CBA, you know, we're hearing a lot more stories
8:04 than Kaylin's. I think the way what Kaylin has to carry is
8:07 probably very, very heavy, and I think she herself would be the
8:11 first person to say like she doesn't need to be protected.
8:13 And I think she's just as competitive. And and I mean,
8:17 I've played against her, and I you can see that. I don't think
8:19 she asks for anything to be easy, as none of us do. We're
8:22 all just athletes, you know. But it's been great just seeing just
8:27 multiple stories be told, multiple women kind of earn
8:31 their praise, and just seeing the game grow collectively. How
8:34 do you expect your life will change now?
8:39 I hope not too much, to be honest, I'm just smiling a lot
8:42 more, which is great. But I, I don't know. I'm still me. I
8:46 still just just love being where I'm at, and I just I just play
8:49 basketball. Well, from a business perspective, have you
8:52 started to talk to your agent at all? Like, are sponsors now
8:55 starting to knock on the door and say, "Hey, let's talk" ? Of
8:59 course, yeah. And I'm obviously embracing that part and loving
9:02 it. My agent is doing a phenomenal job, but I don't
9:06 think it's like it's not changing me. I would love to
9:09 like do more stuff. I think it's an opportunity for me to like do
9:11 more stuff in the community and people recognizing me more.
9:14 Maybe I can have more of an impact to that in that way,
9:16 especially in the Bay Area where I grew up. So looking forward to
9:19 that part. Well, is it gonna physically change you, or are
9:21 you gonna get a new tattoo? That's been the question of the
9:23 day. Everyone's been asking me, so I think eventually, yeah,
9:26 it'll happen. So you haven't thought about it yet, is what
9:29 you're telling me, though. No, King Seven was too much. We
9:32 forgot about it, and we'll come back if we're onto it. What do
9:36 you foresee for Golden State moving forward? Like, how how do
9:40 you maintain this, and how do you repeat? I've told the story
9:42 a couple times, but it's my favorite story from the night
9:44 that we won. Was being in the lounge with with Joe Lacob and
9:48 just congratulating him on what he's created and telling him,
9:51 you know, like about where I came from and just how amazing
9:54 he's done with this franchise. And I was like, you know, you're
9:56 setting the standard. Everyone's going to try to copy you now.
9:58 And he was just like, I hope it.
10:00 Catch up, and that's kind of his goal is just to keep being the
10:03 best franchise. Is there like a secret sauce going on, though? I
10:07 mean, take us inside a little bit. Like you just experienced
10:10 this. You've played on several other teams. Like, was this year
10:13 different in a certain way from other years? Yeah, loads
10:16 different. I've never been a part of anything like this,
10:18 honestly. I mean, it's. I think it's the investment. Obviously,
10:22 it's the investment. It's the dedication. It's the time. I
10:24 mean, he's at every game. He was at every away game. Clearly,
10:27 he's built an atmosphere that's different. Like Valhalla stands
10:30 out as a unique atmosphere that must have contributed to the
10:33 winning environment. I would think. Oh, it did. And being in
10:37 Valhalla allowed me to be myself.
10:39 As soon as I got there, I felt so welcomed. In the preseason
10:42 game, I didn't even play, and people were like screaming for
10:44 me and welcoming me, and it just gives me a confidence that I
10:49 think I can only get from Bajala. You mentioned UConn. I
10:52 did want to ask you a question because we I spoke to your old
10:55 coach Gino Oriama, and he's known for this sort of like
10:59 tough love persona with his players.
11:03 Does that fly in college and not in the WNBA? I'm curious, or
11:06 that player coach relationship. Like, do athletes kind of grow
11:12 out of that a little bit?
11:14 I think you go through like your different phases with coach. I
11:18 think
11:20 you like take so maybe time to reflect on like your college
11:23 career, and then you know if you go pro, you kind of get focused
11:27 on that, and then you look back, and then you well as soon as you
11:29 go pro, you are grateful for everything he taught you about
11:32 being a pro.
11:34 Like you notice the UConn kids are like the ones who run during
11:37 a timeout, you know, run to the bench, who like are always
11:39 cheering, are always good teammates. I think that's part
11:41 of UConn culture, but then as you get older, you really start
11:44 to reflect, and I think he does too, on like what he's built and
11:48 the the legacy that you've become a part of.
11:52 Can you spot a UConn player at the pro level? Like, is there
11:55 something that carries over? I mean, you obviously know who
11:58 they are to some degree, but is there something that makes them
12:02 stand out. Yeah, I think,
12:05 like I said, it's it's the little things. It's like
12:08 the like no phones in locker room, like some of these like
12:10 little things that just kind of stick. But it's just I think the
12:13 way they are as people,
12:15 very unselfish, team before individual kind of mentality,
12:19 and it's just kind of the kid that they go after when they
12:21 recruit. Gabby Williams, Gabby's agents taking your call. If
12:24 you're watching this,
12:26 congratulations. Thank you.
Market Open: Nvidia Shares Plunge 13% After CEO Resignation, Stocks Mixed full transcript
0:01 CNBC business news update. I'm Jessica
0:04 Edinger. Market open Thursday morning.
0:07 Nvidia's embattled CEO stepping down.
0:10 >> And I'm sorry we have to interrupt you.
0:11 If you can hold on for just a moment.
0:12 There is news flash [music] just in on
0:14 this that we want to make sure we bring
0:15 you right away. Um it says that Jensen
0:19 Wong is making a transition here. the
0:21 news that that I guess we've kind of
0:23 been expecting
0:24 >> immediately. Yeah. Um not being the
0:27 board not having to make the decision on
0:28 this that Jensen Wong is resigning
0:30 effective immediately. This was kind I I
0:32 felt like we were kind of on um smoke
0:36 watch for the Pope um throughout this
0:38 time after hearing this news last night.
0:39 >> That's CNBC's Becky Quick with Joe
0:42 Kernan. Nvidia shares down almost 12%
0:45 out of the open this morning, but the
0:47 Dow holding up. It's up 29 points. The
0:50 S&P 500 index is down 56 points
0:53 threequarters percent at the open and
0:55 the Nasdaq plunging 344 points 1.3%.
1:01 Chipmaker shares are mixed. More on
1:04 Nvidia from CNBC's Carl Kintineia.
1:06 >> Big news out of Nvidia today. The
1:08 company's board of directors announcing
1:10 that Jensen Wong has resigned as
1:12 president, chief executive officer, and
1:14 a member of the board effective
1:16 immediately. Colette Crest, the CFO, has
1:18 agreed to serve as interim CEO. She will
1:21 continue to serve as EVP and CFO until a
1:25 permanent successor has been named. The
1:27 board says it is initiating a search for
1:29 a permanent chief executive officer and
1:31 will consider internal and external
1:34 candidates.
1:35 >> A take from Yale's Jeffrey Sonnenfeld
1:38 before the official announcement on
1:40 CNBC.
1:41 >> There are some good people in there
1:42 though. The the sec the chief financial
1:44 officer, she's terrific. Um, I think you
1:46 know, Colette Crest could be a fantastic
1:48 leader here.
1:49 >> And here's a take from Advisers Capitals
1:52 Joanne Feny before the announcement on
1:54 CNBC.
1:55 >> We have very likely not seen all the bad
1:57 news that's going to come out about
2:00 Jensen and and potentially, you know,
2:02 throwing more suspicion on a significant
2:05 chunk of their sales, those sales
2:07 associated with Singapore, right? So,
2:09 even if though we took out those sales,
2:11 right? that still leaves the company uh
2:14 trading at a pretty attractive multiple
2:17 and and so really from here the question
2:19 is what kind of growth can the company
2:21 generate? Full coverage of the change at
2:24 the top of Nvidia at CNBC television,
2:26 CNBC.com and the CNBC app on your phone.
2:30 Meanwhile, William Blair immediately
2:32 upgraded chipmaker AMD. It's seen as
2:35 benefiting from the turmoil at Nvidia.
2:38 AMD shares are up a little more than 1%.
2:41 Broadcom up 4%. Oil prices are jumping
2:44 after President Trump said that no Iran
2:47 deal is needed to end the war. Quote,
2:50 "We've got there straight."
2:52 US crude oil back above $86 a barrel
2:55 today. AAA says the national average for
2:57 a gallon of regulars below $4 for a
3:00 second straight day. Prices plunged 20
3:03 cents a gallon for drivers from one week
3:06 ago today post election as traders
3:08 believed Democrats will try to end the
3:10 war sooner rather than later when they
3:13 take control of Congress in January.
3:15 Scout Motors has nearly a quarter
3:18 million vehicle reservations as its new
3:20 $2 billion South Carolina plant nears
3:23 completion. Scout was an American
3:25 vehicle brand from 1961 to 1980. It's
3:28 coming back now with backing by
3:30 Volkswagen pickups and SUVs in all
3:32 electric and hybrid versions. It's
3:34 taking reservations. American Airlines
3:37 is bringing back fresh food to first
3:39 class between New York and Chicago for
3:41 the first time since before the
3:42 pandemic. Today is the one-year
3:44 anniversary of the US Mint striking the
3:46 final US penny, ending 232 years of
3:50 production. Thanksgiving is two weeks
3:53 from today. Walmart is starting the
3:55 first phase of a three-part Black Friday
3:58 sale today.
Jeffrey Sonnenfeld: There are serious problems with the Nvidia board full transcript
0:00 Firstly, your reaction um to what we're
0:02 seeing here in real time and who would
0:06 actually step in for this company
0:08 assuming that he is in fact ousted.
0:10 >> Well, I'm I'm I'm just blown away and
0:12 flattered that you've read all the
0:13 material. I've shoveled your way all
0:14 through the night. So, thank you. And it
0:16 must be we are both drinking the same
0:18 coffee that the Nvidia board must be
0:20 drinking because the reports are that
0:22 they still haven't broken yet. Maybe
0:24 they have, but so far everybody thinks
0:26 they're still meeting through the night.
0:28 Um, and yes, these monarchs are a
0:30 certain type where we do see they often
0:32 have a strangle hold in a creative
0:34 business. They're in the media world.
0:36 They're often in retail world. We've
0:38 seen the Dub Charie situation. If you
0:40 remember American Apparel where he used
0:42 to show up at meetings wearing a sock
0:44 and the sock wasn't on his feet. Uh, but
0:46 not wearing nothing else. Uh, but there
0:48 are problems where we've seen it in the
0:50 hospitality. Even McDonald's had this
0:52 problem. But but the idea of that
0:54 somebody who get is um identified with
0:56 the company and they co-brand it so you
0:59 you almost can't separate them. This is
1:01 a problem for the company to wrestle
1:02 with and yes shareholders have a lot of
1:05 times I'm cautious about shareholder
1:07 litigation in this case with no
1:08 succession plan 60 direct reports by
1:11 intention so that there was no threat to
1:13 him and you also then have um of course
1:16 a board where there's nobody equipped to
1:18 step in. none of them were former CEOs
1:20 or ever reported to boards of directors
1:22 and things like that. So, they're not
1:23 known to the outside. Uh that uh these
1:26 are a lot of problems and the questions
1:27 that you were, you know, teeing up
1:28 before the break, who knew what when is
1:31 Yeah. I mean, here you've got a company
1:33 that some people say was worth 34
1:35 million $34 million. People over there
1:37 in Singapore, I was just on with some
1:39 Singapore uh experts. They're telling me
1:41 was valued at $4 million that they were
1:43 buying in excess of $5 billion of chips.
1:46 They knew this if this was a drug trade
1:48 this would be called a mule that they
1:50 were a shill for distributing these
1:52 chips. Uh so this is a great concern a
1:55 great risk that the board just didn't
1:57 ask these questions and the board was
1:59 issuing denials even recently saying
2:01 that well we don't we don't know that
2:03 these chips were being sent elsewhere.
2:04 They were these chips are being found in
2:07 the military research universities going
2:09 into weapons in China. So that's just
2:11 seconds away from going into Russian and
2:15 uh you know uh Iranian weapons that is
2:17 coming out of China. So serious problems
2:20 about this board and the uh the sexual
2:23 conduct issues. It's not that we're
2:25 being puritanical here is they have a
2:27 code of conduct.
2:28 >> Yeah.
2:28 >> If the CEO is not held to it, then how
2:30 does it have any credibility for anybody
2:32 else both with the customer uh who turns
2:34 out to apparently be a spy and also
2:37 employees? And it's sort of like a water
2:39 over the dam. You know, once you see a
2:41 little trickle, then the dam bursts, it
2:44 breaches when people don't pay attention
2:46 to these signs.
2:46 >> I mean, above and beyond Nvidia, to me,
2:48 it seems like this raises two major
2:50 questions, two larger stories that will
2:52 continue despite what happens uh at
2:54 NVIDIA with with succession planning and
2:56 as the dust dust settles. The first one,
2:58 I think, is this raises key questions
3:00 about governance. I mean, you got
3:01 Anthropic getting ready to go public
3:03 next week. Um and they have a really
3:06 interesting and exotic maybe not so
3:08 exotic when you look at Palanteer but
3:09 governance structure. I mean similar
3:11 situation at SpaceX and they didn't have
3:12 quite those shareholder structures but I
3:15 mean the idea that you have companies
3:17 increasingly large powerful companies
3:19 that are tied to founders or CEOs or or
3:22 or senior leadership. Um
3:26 do we see a push back by investors in
3:29 Wall Street and others in terms of some
3:31 of these governance structures because
3:32 as we're seeing in real time there's
3:33 such risk associated with it.
3:35 >> Yeah, there a lot of times they're
3:36 beholden. There's this they're smitten
3:38 by the CEO kind of idolatry. There are
3:40 times where I would criticize some of
3:42 the decisions that Elon Musk would make
3:44 and I' I'd hear from Larry Ellison
3:45 saying, you know, who are you of Dustin
3:47 Ashes to challenge the Almighty back
3:48 when Ellison was still on the board and
3:50 he has some of these qualities himself
3:51 at Oracle is as brilliant as they are.
3:54 They've taken on the daunting odds, you
3:56 know, the 99% or more of people would
3:58 fail doing what they did. So, of course,
4:01 we celebrate them. how it's said. You
4:02 know, Ellison will say, "Can you send a
4:04 a a rocket ship a couple hundred
4:06 thousand miles off into space and land
4:08 it within inches in the ocean and then
4:10 reuse that of where it's supposed to
4:11 land?" You know, you know, we can't, but
4:13 still that we can't mean we can't ask
4:15 them questions. So, you often have a
4:17 board that is uh very submissive to the
4:19 CEO. You know, it's been said, Aristotle
4:21 actually said it, there's no genius
4:23 without a a touch of madness, but it
4:26 doesn't mean that the whole company has
4:28 to have that touch of madness. somebody
4:30 needs to ask uh some questions and
4:32 that's that's what's missing here. Of
4:34 course, I really worry about what's
4:35 going on in the government side of this,
4:37 too. And we there's plenty to ask on on
4:39 the the corporate governance side and
4:41 worried about this company and you But
4:44 here you have a company that is uh
4:47 selling um they're buying billions of
4:49 dollars of of this stuff and it turns
4:52 out as you just had Bob Grifile on
4:54 before the break and he was reminding us
4:56 that 21 22% of the revenues of this
5:00 company are going into Singapore, 6
5:02 million people. What's 6 million people?
5:04 That's the size of Atlanta or Miami or
5:06 Philadelphia has 22%. Nobody's asking
5:08 questions. How could Philadelphia or
5:10 Atlanta Miami by 22% of the chips that
5:13 somebody should be asking those
5:15 questions about, you know, what this
5:17 what this place was, who they were and
5:19 uh and in government.
5:20 >> Uh well, that's it. That and that's sort
5:22 of the next thing I wanted to bring up
5:24 with you because that also raises the
5:25 question about what's going on within
5:26 the administration and specifically at
5:28 commerce as we continue to have more
5:30 reporting here. I mean the Biden
5:32 administration according to Wall Street
5:34 Journal launched investigations into
5:36 companies including Alice Wongs for
5:38 diverting US chips to China. Some of
5:40 those uh I think um moves and regulatory
5:44 steps seem to have been according to
5:46 reporting reversed under the current
5:47 commerce department. And even just last
5:49 night, you have Axios reporting that
5:51 Lutnik stalled in Trump's Nvidia China
5:53 chip curves after Oval talks. And
5:56 apparently others in the administration
5:58 uh going after Lutnik in recent days. To
6:01 me, it seems like this is actually
6:02 perhaps the larger story, especially if
6:04 Jensen Wong wasn't even ever briefed on
6:06 the fact that he was potentially
6:07 engaging with a spy, alleged spy.
6:09 >> Yeah. That he wasn't briefed and the
6:10 company wasn't briefed. Now, they didn't
6:12 do their due diligence. shame on them.
6:14 But that that the that the government
6:16 didn't tell them and President Trump
6:17 knew this and didn't tell them and that
6:19 for some reason he was excluded on that
6:21 trip back in May 15th through 17th uh to
6:24 goes to to China and he winds up hopping
6:27 on board in Alaska as a lastminute ad
6:29 because Trump had President Trump had
6:31 been briefed on this and uh that was
6:33 going on after a memo came out in March
6:36 uh of course with with Secretary of
6:38 State Marco Rubio and coming out of the
6:40 National Security Council that there
6:42 This this is a a problem. This is an
6:45 espionage ring happening here. Uh that's
6:47 out in March. And we have a shoutdown
6:48 that's widely reported on. Axios has it
6:51 out this morning with with six very
6:54 solid sources behind it. Nobody denying
6:56 it that Secretary of Treasury Scott
6:58 Besson had one of his famous or infamous
7:01 shoutdowns against with Howard Ludnik
7:03 that was coming close to fisticuffs.
7:05 Who's in the room with him? The attorney
7:07 general Todd Blanch. Who else is there?
7:09 The Secretary of State Marco Rubio. and
7:11 they are not on Secretary Ludnik's side.
7:13 I'm not sure who is right now other than
7:15 perhaps President Trump. You really got
7:17 to ask a question in terms of who's on
7:19 whose side there, who's on whose side in
7:20 the United States. This is not a
7:22 patriotic move to be funding these, you
7:25 know, diverting these highly sensitive
7:27 uh weapons uh artificial intelligence.
7:30 Artificial intelligence is now even
7:32 shockingly showing up in North Korean.
7:34 Now, we don't have Blackwell. Nobody's
7:36 discovering Blackwell chips in there or
7:37 even H200s, but even North Korea now has
7:39 guided missiles with uh that we're we're
7:42 seeing with with AI. If you were asking
7:44 this two months ago, weapons, people
7:46 would tell you, "Oh, no, North Korea
7:47 doesn't have it." They do. Not this
7:49 particular chip. U but this is a a huge
7:53 problem that's got to be asked. And and
7:54 we see that in the government. We
7:56 certainly have the the Senate Banking
7:58 Committee uh of all things is as Senator
8:02 Kramer and Elizabeth Warren uh feel that
8:04 this is their domain and they're asking
8:05 some tough questions and they are
8:06 calling for uh for of course for Jensen
8:09 Hong to to step down already. But it
8:11 goes into the domain of the the Senate
8:14 Intelligence Committee and and that is a
8:17 very strong committee. It's it's Tom
8:18 Cotton and Mark Warner who have very
8:21 different political views, but they
8:22 function as a team very very well. And
8:24 some of the best people in the Senate
8:26 are on the Democrats and Republicans on
8:28 that intelligence committee. We're
8:30 hearing and talking about, you know, the
8:31 House is going to get it together on the
8:33 18th. The Senate's already working on
8:34 it. These are a lot of investigations.
8:36 So, it was impossible for a CEO to even
8:39 if he were being exonerated that he
8:41 couldn't do his job with all these
8:42 investigations taking place. And
8:44 >> there's so much here.
8:46 >> So, yeah, so much. There are some good
8:48 people in there though that the sec the
8:49 chief financial officer, she's terrific.
8:52 I think you know Colette Crest could be
8:54 a fantastic leader here and and the guy
8:56 who actually created you know a lot of
8:58 people wonder about the this the the
9:00 software behind it the Koopa software it
9:02 really it came from a guy who's u Ian
9:05 Bach who's very talented they could be a
9:07 great pairing
9:08 >> he's the u uh the guy really in charge
9:10 of uh you know the key relationships
Jim Cramer on interim Nvidia CEO: 'I like Colette very much,' 'will provide needed order' full transcript
0:00 OVER FOR YOU. YOU TAKE OVER FOR
0:01 ME, ANDREW. IT'S ALL HIS FAULT
0:05 IN THE FIRST PLACE, I THINK WE
0:06 HAD IT WORSE. I KNOW, I KNOW,
0:08 HIS IMMUNE SYSTEM IS LIKE A
0:10 ROCK. CHRIS, WE TALKED EARLIER.
0:13 IT'S HAPPENED. I GUESS.
0:16 >> IT DID.
0:16 >> IT'S SAD, ISN'T IT?
0:18 >> IS IT KIND OF. IT IS SAD. IT
0:20 IS TO SEE IT. IT'S I ICARUS, I
0:24 THINK. TOO CLOSE TO THE SUN
0:25 MAYBE. RIGHT.
0:27 >> YEAH. I MEAN, SOMEONE WHO'S
0:28 BEEN, YOU KNOW, SO IMPORTANT TO
0:30 THE INDUSTRY, THIS IS THIS IS
0:32 NOT HOW YOU WANT IT TO END. BUT
0:35 IT'S AS YOU SAID, IT'S NOT A
0:37 SURPRISE THIS MORNING AT THIS
0:38 POINT.
0:41 >> ANDREW.
0:42 >> HEY, I JUST I THINK WE WANT
0:44 TO JUST BRING JIM CRAMER INTO
0:46 THIS CONVERSATION AS WELL. I
0:48 THINK WE CAN GET HIM ON THE
0:49 LINE. HE, OF COURSE, HAS BEEN A
0:51 LONG TIME SUPPORTER OF THIS
0:52 STOCK AND OF JENSEN. AND WHAT'S
0:54 YOUR REACTION.
0:56 >> WELL LOOK I THINK IT HAD TO
0:58 HAPPEN. I THINK THAT THERE'S
0:59 WAY TOO MUCH EVIDENCE. I THINK
1:01 THAT HE'S BEEN NEGOTIATING FOR
1:02 A BIT OBVIOUSLY TO TRY TO
1:03 FIGURE OUT WHERE TO GO. LOOK I
1:05 LIKE COLETTE VERY MUCH. COLETTE
1:06 KRESS, I CLOSE TO HER SPOKE TO
1:08 HER, I DON'T KNOW, HUNDREDS OF
1:10 TIMES, AND I THINK SHE'S GOING
1:12 TO BE TERRIFIC AT TRYING TO
1:13 FIGURE OUT WHERE THE PIECES ARE.
1:15 I KNOW ALL THE ANALYSTS HAVE TO
1:17 CUT AND RUN. THEY ALL THINK
1:18 THAT THERE'S 42,000 OTHER
1:19 PEOPLE THERE WHO HAVE
1:20 ABSOLUTELY NO BEARING
1:21 WHATSOEVER BECAUSE OF THE WAY
1:22 THE COMPANY SET THE WAS SET UP
1:24 BY JENSEN. I THINK THAT'S JUST
1:25 NOT TRUE. DO I WANT TO BUY THE
1:27 STOCK RIGHT NOW? WHO THE HELL
1:29 KNOWS WHAT THE STOCK IS? BUT I
1:31 DO THINK THE COLETTE AT LEAST
1:32 KNOWS HOW TO RUN. HAS BEEN THE
1:34 PERSON WHO'S BEEN THE
1:35 SPOKESPERSON FOR THE COMPANY
1:36 FOR A VERY LONG TIME, AND I
1:38 THINK SHE'LL PROVIDE SOME
1:39 NEEDED ORDER. SO I'M GLAD THAT
1:40 SHE'S THE ONE THAT THEY'VE
1:41 GIVEN IT TO.
1:43 >> WHEN YOU THINK ABOUT WHERE
1:44 THE STOCK IS RIGHT NOW, JIM,
1:46 WE'RE AT ABOUT 156 BUCKS.
1:49 >> COULD THIS BE. I THINK IT'S
1:51 GOING TO BE DOWN 10%. IT SHOULD
1:53 BE DOWN 10%, MAYBE 15. THESE
1:54 ANALYSTS. ALL RIGHT. THEY'RE
1:55 YOU KNOW, THEY'RE RATS ON A
1:56 SINKING SHIP. THEY WANT IT OUT
1:58 REALLY BADLY.
1:59 >> CHRIS CASO JOINED US THIS
2:00 MORNING. AND HE'S HERE AGAIN
2:01 JIM. AND HE ACTUALLY SAID WITH
2:03 OR WITHOUT JENSEN THIS IS A
2:04 BIAS. HE SEES IT AT THIS POINT.
2:06 >> WELL YOU KNOW LOOK, I
2:07 UNDERSTAND THAT. I JUST THINK
2:09 THAT THERE'S A LOT OF
2:10 INVESTIGATIONS THAT HAVE TO
2:11 OCCUR. THEY REPORT NEXT WEEK. I
2:13 THINK IT'S A REALLY GOOD
2:15 QUARTER. THEY CAN GUIDE UP IF
2:16 COLETTE, WHO IS REALLY THE
2:17 KEEPER OF EVERYTHING, INCLUDING
2:18 THE MONEY, SAYS, LOOK, WE CAN
2:20 DO A BIG BUYBACK. THAT'S ONE
2:21 THING. IF THEY HAVE A GUY I
2:23 THINK PROBABLY HAVE TO GO
2:24 OUTSIDE NOW, BECAUSE WHO KNOWS
2:25 HOW MANY PEOPLE KNEW ABOUT
2:27 KIMBERLY POWELL, WHICH IS A
2:28 REALLY BIG PROBLEM BECAUSE SHE
2:29 DID REPORT DIRECTLY TO HIM.
2:30 HEALTH CARE. BUT AS FAR AS I'M
2:32 CONCERNED, IT'S A NEW DAY AND
2:34 WE HAVE TO SEE WHAT A COMPANY
2:36 THAT HAS 42,000 PEOPLE WHO ARE
2:37 PROBABLY TO SOME DEGREE
2:38 INSULTED THAT THEY DON'T SEEM
2:40 TO MATTER, CAN DO THINGS. THIS
2:42 COMPANY IS NOT MADE UP OF
2:43 DOOFUSES. IT'S MADE UP OF
2:44 REALLY BRILLIANT PEOPLE. AND I
2:46 THINK THAT JENSEN PROBABLY PUT
2:47 THEM TOGETHER.
2:50 >> ALL RIGHT. AND IF I CAN,
2:52 LET'S LET CHRIS GO. CHRIS, ANY
2:54 FINAL COMMENTS BEFORE WE
3:00 AGAIN, REMEMBER THE SILVER
3:01 LINING HERE IS THE INDUSTRY IS
3:03 IN IS IN DEEP, DEEP SHORTAGE
3:05 RIGHT NOW. SO, YOU KNOW, NVIDIA
3:07 SOLD OUT THROUGH THE END OF
3:09 NEXT YEAR. THE ROADMAP IS SET
3:11 THAT THAT CERTAINLY HELPS TO
3:13 AVOID ANY, YOU KNOW SHORT TERM
3:20 GET TO REPLACE. JENSEN. I AGREE
3:22 WITH JIM THAT COLETTE IS GOING
3:23 TO BE A VERY GOOD INTERIM
3:26 REPLACEMENT. AND, YOU KNOW,
3:28 IT'S SORT OF LIKE THE APPLE
3:29 STEVE JOBS MOMENT. YOU KNOW
3:30 THAT THERE'S GOING TO BE
3:32 SOMEBODY NEW. THAT'S NOT JENSEN.
3:33 BUT
Microsoft Outage Hits Businesses, Nvidia Scandal Deepens full transcript
0:16 THIS IS "THE PULSE" WITH FRANCINE LACQUA.
0:21 FRANCINE: GOOD MORNING EVERYONE. WELCOME TO "THE PULSE."
0:23 I'M FRANCINE LACQUA HERE IN LONDON.
0:24 THERE HAVE BEEN MORE DEVELOPMENTS IN THE CRISIS
0:30 ENGULFING ONE OF THE WORLD'S MOST VALUABLE COMPANIES.
0:34 BLOOMBERG LEARNED THAT COMPANY FOUND BID ALICE WANG PROSECURED
0:43 AND SMUGGLED AI CHIPSES. THE DOCUMENTS OFFER THE MOST
0:48 EXPLICIT EVIDENCE YET THEY MANAGED TO GET THEIR HANDS ON
0:53 SMUGGLED NVIDIA HARDWARE. JOINING ME NOW IS BLOOMBERG
0:59 OPINION COLUMNIST IN TECHNOLOGY. I WANT TO START WITH YOU.
1:03 IT IS NOW TAKING ON MUCH MORE OF A CONCERNING NATURE OF THE
1:06 RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN THE U.S. AND CHINA.
1:09 DO YOU THINK THIS IS WHERE THE STORY IS GOING NEXT?
1:14 >> YEAH. I THINK THIS IS GEORGIA WHAT
1:18 HAPPENED TO JENSEN HUANG IS GREAT FOR THE SO-CALLED CHINA
1:22 HAWKS. ANYONE AGAINST THE IDEA OF
1:30 FLOODING THE CHINESE MARKET WITH A POWERFUL AI CHIPS WHICH IS
1:33 SOMETHING HUANG ARGUED FOR. HIS VIEW WAS LET'S MAKE CHINESE
1:37 COMPANIES DEPENDENT ON AMERICAN TECHNOLOGY.
1:41 HAS THE ROAD TO SUPREMACY FOR THEM.
1:43 NOT EVERYBODY AGREES WITH THAT IN THE WHITE HOUSE.
1:50 EVEN WHO IS PUSHING FOR THAT -- AN IMPORTANT ADVOCATE.
1:53 CHINA DOESN'T WANT TO BRING IN LOWER POWERED CHIPS INTO THE
1:55 COUNTRY. THEY HAVE THEIR OWN EXPORT BAN
2:00 ON. THAT COMPANIESES LIKE HUAWEI CAN
2:04 PRODUCE THOSE CHIPS JUST FINE. WHAT IT MEANS BETWEEN CHINA AND
2:10 THE U.S., IT IS GOING TO MAKE SOMETHING LIKE THAT MUCH MORE
2:14 DIFFICULT TO PULL TOGETHER. FRANCINE: STORY ABSOLUTELY
2:15 INCREDIBLE. WITH THE DEPARTURE OF JENSEN
2:18 HUANG. TWO WEEKS AGO STILL CONSIDERED
2:21 AN ABSOLUTE ROCK STAR. THERE IS SO MUCH UNCERTAINTY IN
2:24 THE AI INDUSTRY. WHAT DO YOU THINK OF THE
2:28 RAMIFICATIONS IN ALL OF THIS? >> THE CHINA STORY IS AN
2:32 IMPORTANT PIVOTAL ASPECT OF ALL OF THIS.
2:35 JENSEN HUANG HAS BEEN IN A SENSE A CENTRAL BANKER TO THE AI BOOM.
2:41 NVIDIA HAS CREATED A LOT OF ENERGY.
2:46 THEY HAVE CREDIT GUARANTEES. THEY HAVE ENABLED LOTS LOTS OF
2:51 NEW COMPANIES TO COME INTO THE AI INFRASTRUCTURE TRADE.
2:55 WHAT DIFFERENCE DOES HIS DEPARTURE MEAN IF HE HAS BEEN
3:01 THE MOST PROACTIVE OF ADVOCATES IN THE WORLD.
3:04 FRANCINE: DO YOU THINK IT HAS AN IMPACT ON NVIDIA OR --
3:06 >> BOTH. LET'S START WITH THE SCALE OF IT
3:11 WAS SALES THE SOUTHEAST ASIA. IT IS ABOUT 20% OF THEIR
3:16 BUSINESS. THERE IS ADDITIONAL PRESSURE ON
3:22 WHAT HAS BEEN SOLD TO SINGAPORE AND SOUTHEAST ASIA, THAT IS
3:26 GOING REDUCE THEIR REVEILLE X KNEWS OVER TIME.
3:29 THEN THERE IS THE QUESTION TO HAVE AI TRADE AND WHETHER NVIDIA
3:33 REALLY HAS BEEN THE LYNCH PIN ANYTHING MORE THAN BEING A
3:35 CHEERLEADER. THERE IS SOME NUANCE IN THERE.
3:38 MY VIEW WOULD BE THIS IS VERY GOOD NEWS FOR NVIDIA'S
3:44 COMPETITORS, THE BROADCOMS AND AMD'S OF THE WORLD.
3:46 IT RAISES THE QUESTION WHAT HAPPENS WITH AI INVESTMENT OVER
3:48 THE COMING YEARS. FRANCINE: HOW DO YOU SEE THIS
3:52 CHANGING? THERE IS A LOT OF THINGS THAT
3:57 HAVE US THINKING ABOUT NVIDIA CHANGES, WHETHER THEY CAN STILL
4:01 PRODUCE THE BEST CHIPS IN THE WORLD AND WHO'LL REPLACE HIM?
4:06 >> YEAH, IF QUESTION TAKE A STEP BACK, WE'RE PROBABLY IN THE
4:08 FUTURE GOING TO LOOK BACK ON THIS MOMENT.
4:11 I HOPE WE'LL LOOK BACK ON THIS MOMENT AS A SHIFT, A HEALTHIER
4:17 SHIFT TOWARD THE NEW ERA OF MATURATION FOR THE AI BUSINESS.
4:23 AN ERA OF ACCOUNTABILITY AND GREATER SCRUTINY.
4:26 IT IS INTERESTING WHAT HAPPENED WITH JENSEN HUANG WITHIN THE
4:30 SAME COUPLE OF WEEKS AS THE IPO FOR ANTHROPIC.
4:32 THE COMPANY IS GOING PUBLIC. IT IS GOING TO HAVE TO BE MUCH
4:36 MORE TRANSSPARENT ABOUT ITS BUSINESS PRACTICES.
4:39 FOR A LONG TIME, INVESTORS HAVE BEEN PUTTING MONEY INTO THIS
4:46 BUSINESS BASED A LOT ON FAITH AND BELIEF AND CHARISMATIC
4:50 LEADERS WITH MAYBE IGNORING SOME OF THE RISKS AND HUGE SPENDING
4:56 AND TO SOME EXTENSE AT THE PRESENT TIME CLEAR EVIDENCE
5:00 AROUND ALL OF THIS COMPUTE DATA CENTER SPENDING IS GOING TO BE
5:01 MONETIZED. I THINK WE'RE MOVING INTO THIS
5:05 PHASE WHERE IT IS LIKE OK, AI BUSINESSES ARE GOING TO HAVE
5:08 GREATER SCRUTINY. THERE ARE GOING TO BE LIMITS ON
5:12 WHAT SOME OF THESE LEADERS CAN DO AND WHAT IS SEEN AS
5:19 ACCEPTABLE, THE BEHAVIOR. THEY HAVE TO FOLLOW THE RULES
5:24 AND IF THEY DON'T THERE ARE CONSEQUENCES AS WITH JENSEN
5:26 HUANG. THERE HAS BEEN TOO MUCH HYPE,
5:28 TOO MUCH FAITH. A LOT OF SPECULATION AND.
5:34 FRANCINE: HOW DO YOU THINK IT CHANGES -- WHAT ARE SOME OF THE
5:37 CONVERSATIONS THAT PEOPLE AT ANTHROPIC ARE HAVING, THAT ELON
5:41 MUSK IS HAVING WITH HIS STAFF AND OPENAI?
5:45 >> I THINK ANTHROPIC -- THIS IS SUCH AN IMPORTANT MOMENT FOR THE
5:47 COMPANY. WE'RE GOING TO HAVE A LOT MORE
5:51 WEALTHY PEOPLE AT THAT COMPANY IN PARTICULAR WITH THIS IPO AND
5:57 THEY ARE SORT OF THE BELLWETHER FOR THE INDUSTRY.
6:00 I WAS JUST IN SAN FRANCISCO A FEW WEEKS AGO.
6:06 A LOT OF VENTURE CAPITALISTS ARE HUNKERING DOWN NOT DOING
6:10 ANYTHING UNTIL NEXT WEEK AND THE IPO ITSELF IS OVER.
6:12 THEY WANT TO SEE WHAT THIS MEANS FOR THE REST OF THE INDUSTRY.
6:17 AND AS LONG AS THAT CAN BE SUCCESSFUL I THINK THERE IS SO
6:20 MUCH RIDING ON THIS WITH THE AI TRADE AND NVIDIA BEING THIS
6:23 LYNCH PIN FOR FUNDING. IN A LOT OF WAYS, ANTHROPIC IS
6:31 KIND OF A SYMBOL OF THE CONFIDENCE AND HYPE IN THIS
6:34 WHOLE INDUSTRY AND IF THAT CAN BE SUCCESSFUL, THE MONEY CAN
6:37 KEEP FLOWING FOR NOW. FRANCINE: LOOKING AT SOME OF THE
6:40 FIGURES. NVIDIA SHARES UP MORE THAN
6:45 700,000% SINCE THEY WENT PUBLIC IN 1999.
6:49 THIS IS BY FAR BIGGER GROWTH THAN WE SAW AT AM, AMAZON OR
6:54 MICROSOFT IN QUITE SOMETIME. WITH THE DEPARTMENT OF JENSEN
6:59 HUANG, THE COMPANY IS CHANGED. DOES IT MEAN THERE ARE MORE
7:03 RIVALS -- >> THE COMPANY HAS CHANGED.
7:07 WE WILL GET BETTER QUALITY SCRUTINY FROM AI INVESTMENTS AND
7:11 NOTHING THAT IS -- THAT IS SORELY NEEDED.
7:16 IF YOU HAVE GOOD SCRUTINY, YOU MAKE BETTER INVESTMENTS.
7:18 IT IS MORE SUSTAINABLE OVER THE LONGER PERIOD.
7:21 WE'RE THINKING ABOUT THAT ANTHROPIC IPO COMING UP NEXT
7:23 WEEK. ANTHROPIC IS THE FRONTIER AI
7:27 COMPANY THAT IS LEAST EXPOSED TO NVIDIA.
7:30 ALREADY THEY HAVE STARTED TO DIVERSIFY THEIR CHIPS AWAY FROM
7:33 NVIDIA AND WITHIN ABOUT TWO YEARS, NVIDIA WILL PROVIDE LESS
7:38 THAN A CAR OF OH QUARTER OF THEIR COMPUTING POWER.
7:43 -- QUARTER OF THEIR COMPUTING POWER.
7:45 FOR NVIDIA, WHAT THE RESULTS WILL BE IS YOU WON'T HAVE THE
7:53 FUSE BULLIANS OF JENSEN HUANG SAYING I'LL GIVE YOU $4,500
7:57 BILLION WHICH I HEARD HIM DO IN LONDON TWICE IN THE LAST 18
8:00 MONTH. INSTEAD YOU'LL SEE A MORE
8:04 MEASURED APPROACH. THERE MIGHT BE LESS RISK THAT
8:06 NVIDIA TAKES. IT WILL ALSO CREATE SPACE FOR
8:09 COMPETITORS AND THERE WILL BE A NUMBER OF WINNERS.
8:16 WE TALKED ABOUT AMD AND BROADCOM.
8:17 A&P AMAZON AND GOOGLE MAKE THEIR OWN COMPETITIVE CHIPS.
8:23 THE PERSPECTIVE, THE LONG-TERM TRAJECTORY, IT IS BETTER TO HAVE
8:27 MORE COMPETITION AND SCRUTINY. FRANCINE: DO YOU KNOW WHO THE
8:32 RIGHT PERSON TO LEAD THE COMPANY FORWARD WOULD BE?
8:36 COULD WE SEE A LARGER CLEANUP SIGNED?
8:38 >> I THINK IT IS NOT THE MOST TRANSPARENT.
8:40 RUMOR HAS IT THAT JENSEN HUANG HAD 60 DIRECT REPORTS WHICH IS
8:47 MORE THAN I WOULD CARE TO HAVE MYSELF.
8:50 THERE IS NO SUCCESSION PLAN IN PLACE.
8:53 THE COMPANY HAS TO REORIENT ITSELF AROUND THAT.
8:58 THE NEW INTERIM CEO, CREST, CHOOFS A CFO WILL HAVE TO BE
9:04 VERY MEASURED AND PUT SOME CONTROLS IN PLACE WHILE YOU LOOK
9:07 FOR A NEW LEADER. THAT NEW LEADER WILL NOT BE A
9:11 FOUNDER CEO THE WAY JENSEN HUANG WAS.
9:14 I THINK IT IS TOO EARLY TO SAY WHO THAT WILL BE.
9:17 FRANCINE: WE TALKED ABOUT THE MID-TERMS LAST WEEK AND THE
9:20 IMPACT PACT IT HAS. DOES THE JENSEN HUANG ESPECIALLY
9:26 STORY ADD FUEL TO PUSHBACK FROM AMERICAN CITIZENS?
9:30 >> PERHAPS. WE'RE STILL READING THE TEA
9:35 LEAVES00 THE MID-TERM RESULTS ARE.
9:39 I DON'T THINK THEY NECESSARILY SHOWED BACKLASH AGAINST AI
9:40 ITSELF. MORE ON DATA CENTERS.
9:42 IT IS PROBABLY GOING TO HAPPEN AT THE MUNICIPAL LEVEL IN THE
9:50 U.S., OPPOSED TO THE FEDERAL LEVEL.
9:53 SOCIAL MEDIA IS A BIPARTISAN ISSUE.
9:59 REPUBLICAN AND DEMOCRATS -- NO ONE WAS EVER ABLE TO PUT A BILL
10:03 THROUGH THAT TURNED INTO LAW. DONALD TRUMP IS VERY PRO AI.
10:08 IT HAS BEEN GOOD FOR HIS PRESIDENT SAY.
10:10 THE FEDERAL RESERVE SAID 1/3 OF U.S. GDP GROWTH CAME FROM THE AI
10:14 BUILDOUT. THE ECONOMIST JASON BERMAN PUT
10:20 IT AT 92%. BUILDING THE DATA CENTERS IN THE
10:26 COUNTRIES HAS BEEN SO GREAT FOR THE U.S. ECONOMY.
10:30 IT IS HARD TO SEE ANY REGULATION.
10:32 JENSEN WAS PUSHING BACK ON REGULATION WITH AI.
10:38 JENSEN WAS THE ONE TO WORLD HEALTH ORGANIZATION PUSHED BACK
10:42 ON IT AND ADVISED DONALD TRUMP NOT TO PASS IT.
10:46 I THINK WE'LL CONTINUE TO SEE THE STATUS QUO GOING FORWARD.
10:51 FRANCINE: WHAT DO YOU SEE? >> THIS DEMOCRATS WAVE WILL
10:55 PROVIDE A HEADWIND TOWARDS THE DATA CENTER BUILDOUT BUT I DON'T
10:59 THINK IT WILL CHANGE MUCH FOR 2027.
11:02 INSTEAD, THE DISCUSSION THAT WILL HAPPEN WILL BE HOW SHOULD
11:05 THE LOCAL MUNICIPALITIES AND STATES AND THE PEOPLE WHO LIVE
11:10 THERE SPLIT THE REWARDS OF THESE DATA CENTERS?
11:13 THEY MAKE A TREMENDOUS AMOUNT OF MONEY.
11:16 RIGHT NOW MOST OF THAT GETS FUNNELED AWAY FROM THE
11:19 COMMUNITY. ESTABLISH A NEW TYPE OF SOCIAL
11:22 LICENSE. THAT MIGHT REQUIRE A CALMER
11:28 APPROACH TO DEALING WITH THESE INVESTMENTS THAN STANDING ON A
11:30 STAGE AND THROWING OUT MONEY. I THINK WE MOVE INTO A SLIGHTLY
11:35 MORE MEASURED PATTERN BUT IS THE AGAINST THE FACT AS WE WILL MOST
11:39 LIKELY MIND THE NEXT FEW WEEKS AND MONTHS AS COMPANIES REPORT
11:43 EARNINGS ALWAYS THERE THE CUSTOMER DEMAND FOR AI SERVICES
11:47 IS STILL GROWING AND GROWING RAPIDLY.
11:49 HAS THE CONTEXT TO WHICH ALL OF THIS IS HAPPENING.
11:54 FRANCINE: WHERE IS CHINA IN ALL OF THIS?
11:59 IF YOU LOOK AT -- EXPENSE, HAS GONE DOWN.
12:01 IT IS FLAT. A LOT OF AMERICAN COMPANIES,
12:04 INSTEAD OF BUYING THE MORE EXPENSIVE BETTER MODELS MAY RELY
12:09 ON CHINESE OPEN SOURCE. >> I THINK THEY ARE GOING TO BE
12:17 H MUCH MORE CIRCUMSPECT HOW THEY USE IT.
12:20 YOU CAN'T INSPECT THOSE MODELS WHETHER IT IS A CHINESE ONE OR
12:22 AMERICAN ONE. EVERY COMPANY IN THE U.S. AND
12:27 EUROPE WILL START TO IMPLEMENT COST MANAGEMENT.
12:30 LET'S TALK ABOUT CHINA. JENSEN HUANG WAS AN ADVOCATE FOR
12:33 AMERICAN TECHNOLOGY GETTING TO CHINA.
12:35 THAT CUTS IN TWO DIRECTION. IN ONE WAY, IT GIVES THEM THE
12:40 BEST TECHNOLOGY. IN TORE WAY, IT KEEPS THEM
12:43 DEPENDENT ON AMERICAN TECHNOLOGY.
12:45 THE EXPORT CONTROLS HAVE ALARMINGLY BACK FIRED BASTO
12:51 SMUGGLING ROUTES HAVE WORKED. AND SECONDLY, IT FORCED THE
12:56 CHINESE AI LABS AND CHIP COMPANIES TO WORK REALLY, REALLY
13:01 FAST TO CREATE ALTERNATIVES TO AMERICAN TECHNOLOGY WHICH THEY
13:02 NOW HAVE DONE. IT WAS A VERY DIFFICULT DECISION
13:06 WHEN BIDEN STARTED TO TAKE IT. I DON'T THINK IT HAS WORKED OUT
13:09 IN RIGHT WAY BUT NOW THE CHINA HAWKS HAVE THE AMMUNITION THEY
13:14 NEED TO CUT BACK ON THAT SMUGGLING ROUT ROUT.
13:17 THE CHINESE WILL RESPOND BY DOUBLING DOWN ON HOME GROWN
13:20 INNOVATION. FRANCINE: ARE WE TALKING MONTH?
13:25 THREE MONTHS? SIX MONTHS BEHIND U.S. MODELS OR
13:27 DO WE NOT CARE? >> I THINK WE CARE BUT THERE IS
13:33 ALL SORTS OF WEISS DESCRIBING IT.
13:35 THEY ARE WITHIN THROWING DISTANCE.
13:37 THEY ARE JUST CATCHING UP. CHINESE MODEL MAKERS ARE VERY,
13:41 VERY CLOSE AND THE OPEN WEIGHT MODELS ARE BECOMING MORE PROP
13:44 LAR PARTICULARLY AMONG MAYBE NOT THE BIGGEST ESTABLISHED
13:48 COMPANIES, THE JPMORGANS OF THE WORLDS BUT START-UPS, A LOT OF
13:53 ENGINEERS ARE USING OPEN WEIGHT MODELS FROM CHINA BECAUSE THEY
13:56 ARE SO MUCH CHEAPER AND THEY ARE ALMOST AS GOOD OR GOOD ENOUGH.
14:02 YOU DON'T NECESSARILY NEED THE SMARTEST FRONTIER MODEL FOR WHAT
14:05 YOU'RE DOING IN A LOT OF CASES AS A BUSINESS SO WHY NOT JUST
14:08 USE A CHINESE MODEL. THAT'S WHY A LOT OF THESE MODELS
14:13 ARE BECOMING POPULAR, PARTICULARLY AMONG BUSINESSES.
14:21 FRANCINE: THANK YOU BOTH FOR US. COMING UP, STOCKS SLIP AS
14:26 INVESTORS CONTINUE ASSESSING THE IMPACT OF THE DOWNFALL OF JENSEN
14:29 HUANG. WE'LL DISCUSS THE POTENTIAL
14:32 LONG-TERM MARKET IMPACT NEXT. THIS IS BLOOMBERG.
14:55 ♪ FRANCINE: THE CONVERSATIONS THAT
14:56 MATTER. THE INSIGHTS YOU NEED.
14:59 THIS IS "THE PULSE." I'M FRANCINE LACQUA HERE IN
15:00 LONDON. LET'S BRING YOU MORE ON THIS BIG
15:02 STORY. ANOTHER BIG STORY THIS MORNING.
15:06 MICROSOFT STRUGGLING TO RESTORE ACCESS TO ITS FLAGSHIP SOFTWARE
15:12 IN AN OUTAGE THAT HAS PARALYZED GOVERNMENT OFFICES, TRADERS AND
15:19 BUSINESSES GLOBALLY. TEAMS AND THE CO-PILOT AI TOOL
15:22 HAVE CONTINUED INTO A SECOND DAY.
15:24 PREVIOUS DISRUPTIONS HAVE RARELY LASTED MORE THAN SEVERAL HOURS.
15:27 LET'S GET MORE FROM THE FALLOUT OF THE NVIDIA CRISIS.
15:32 INVESTORS ASSESS A BROADER IMPACT.
15:36 THE STOCK HAS SHED ABOUT $1.7 BILLION IN MARKET CAP DURING ITS
15:41 PEAK. I'M JOINED BY THE GLOBAL HEAD OF
15:45 ECONOMICS AND STRATEGY AT U.S. INVESTMENT BANK AND A SENIOR
15:50 ANALYST AT SWISS CO. THANK YOU BOTE FOR JOINING US.
15:54 FIRST OF ALL, NARROW IT A LITTLE BIT FOR NVIDIA.
15:57 WHAT'LL CHANGE AT NVIDIA? ARE YOU CHANGING YOUR TARGET FOR
16:01 SHARE PRICE AT NVIDIA AND ARE WE GOING TO SEE MORE RIVALS TAKING
16:05 ADVANTAGE OF THIS? >> WELL, YES.
16:08 TODAY WE SEE A RANGE OF RISKS THAT COMES WITH JENSEN HUANG'S
16:12 DEPARTURE FROM SHORT TO LONG-TERM.
16:13 IN THE SHORT-TERM WE WILL BE LOOKING AT HOW MANY CHIPS, HOW
16:17 MANY NVIDIA CHIPS MAY ACCEPTEDDED IN THE WRONG END AND
16:21 WHACKED BE THE IMPACT ON EARN INFORMATION THE SHORT RUN.
16:26 IN MEDIUM TERM, YOU'LL LOOKING AT INVESTMENT DEALS.
16:29 WHAT HAPPENS IF LESS OIL GETS INTO THE CIRCULAR DEALS,
16:31 INVESTMENT COMPLEX AND WHETHER THAT WOULD HAVE AN IMPACT ON
16:36 NVIDIA'S EARNINGS AND THE LONG-TERM IMPACTS WILL BE
16:40 OBVIOUSLY WHAT'LL HAPPEN TO NVIDIA'S TECHNOLOGY AND
16:43 TECHNOLOGY ADVANCE WHEN JENSEN HUANG IS NO LONGER THERE.
16:47 FOR INSTANCE, NVIDIA STILL HAS THIS PRODUCT QUALITY, THIS
16:51 PREMIUM GAP OVER COMPETITION. IT MEANS THE DEMAND FOR HIS
16:54 PRODUCTS REMAIN STRONG. THE QUESTION WILL BE WHETHER THE
17:01 EARNINGS RISKS WILL BE COUNTER WEIGHED BY STRONG DEMAND.
17:04 IN THE NEXT TWO YEARS, WE THINK EARNINGS WILL NOT GET A MAJOR
17:09 MATERIAL HIT BUT IN THE LONG RUN, IT WILL BE IMPORTANT TO SEE
17:12 WHO'LL REPLACE JENSEN HUANG AND WHO'LL WILL THE COMPANY
17:19 REORGANIZE WITHOUT JENSEN HUANG. HOW BE THEY PLANNING TO KEEP
17:24 THAT TECHNOLOGY PREMIUM OVER COMPETITION.
17:25 FRANCINE: THANK YOU. THERE IS A LOT OF QUESTION WES
17:28 NEED TO TRY TO FIGURE OUT. WHEN YOU LOOK AT ALL OF THIS,
17:32 WHERE DOES THIS ACTUALLY LEAVE US BECAUSE FOR ME, IT IS
17:35 UNDERSTANDING WE DON'T REALLY HAVE ACCESS TO A LOT FIGURES
17:39 THAT NVIDIA HAS. ORGANIZATION, WE'RE UNWHAT'S
17:42 HAPPENING. HOW MUCH IS IT THE CULT OF THE
17:47 RECORD THAT MADE THIS COMPANY SUCCESSFUL?
17:50 SHARE BRICES UP 7,000% SINCE THEY LISTED.
17:55 >> IT IS A DEEP BENCH. COMPANY IS ALWAYS MUCH MICHIGAN
17:57 THAN THE LEADER. FROM AN OUTSIDE PERSPECTIVE IT
18:03 IS IMPORTANT IS THE ROLE THEY PLAY THE THE ECOSYSTEM.
18:07 IF YOU'RE PUTTING IT BOOK IS THE ECOSYSTEM AND BASICALLY
18:10 SUPPORTING A LOT OF STARTUPS WE HAVE TO SEE IF THAT CONTINUES AT
18:17 SAME PACE AS WE GO THROUGH THIS TRANSITION.
18:19 THE OTHER POINT, WE HAVE TO NOW SEE WHAT THIS MEANS FOR THE
18:22 REVENUE IS YOU HAVE SCRUTINY ON THE EXPORTS TO ASIA.
18:27 WHAT IS INTERESTING, ALL OF THE FOCUS WAS ON THE HYPER SCALERS.
18:34 FROM A MACRO PERSPECTIVE WHATEVER WHAT EVERYONE WAS
18:36 OBSERVE SAYING ABOUT LAST WEEK WAS HYPER SCALERS CAPEX.
18:41 NVIDIA SNOT ONE OF THE BIG INVESTORS BUILDING THE DATA
18:44 CENTERS. SO IT IS REMARKABLE WE HAVE HAD
18:49 THESE TWO EVENTS, THE MIDTERMS AND JENSEN'S RESIGNATION AND A
18:53 MARKET IF UP 2% FROM THE HIGHS. THAT IS ENCOURAGING.
18:56 THERE IS A RESILIENT THERE. PART OF THAT IS BECAUSE WE HAVE
19:00 HAD A MASSIVE RATING. THE MARKET IS BASICALLY DOWN
19:04 SOMETHING LIKE -- THE MULTIPLE. THERE IS ALSO SOME VALUATION
19:09 SUPPORT THERE WHEN THESE EVENT UNFOLDED.
19:12 FRANCINE: DOES THE DEPARTURE CHANGE ANYTHING THAT NVIDIA HAS
19:18 TO OFFER? >> WELL, THAT IS SOMETHING WE DO
19:20 NOT KNOW JUST YET. WHAT WE KNOW IS NVIDIA HAS
19:26 AROUND 80% OF THE GPU MARKET TODAY.
19:30 THEIR PRODUCTS ARE PERFORMING BETTER, SIGNIFICANTLY BETTER
19:32 THAN THE COMPETITION. BASICALLY AMD, FOR EXAMPLE,
19:38 WHICH IS THE MAJOR RIVAL IN SOME SEGMENT, BETTER VALUE.
19:44 THEY DO NOT OFFER A BETTER PERFORMANCE.
19:46 MANY USERS CONTINUE TO BUY NVIDIA BECAUSE IT PERFORMS
19:48 BETTER. IT DOESN'T HEAT UP AS MUCH.
19:51 WHETHER WE'RE TALKING ABOUT GAMING OR AI DATA CENTERS.
19:55 WE DO HAVE THAT GAP. THE OTHER COMPANIES HAVE BEEN
19:59 WORKING ON THIS AND THEY HAVE NOT YET COME WAKE UP THAT
20:01 TECHNOLOGY GAP. THE QUESTION IS WHETHER NVIDIA
20:10 WILL BE ABLE TO RETAIN AFTER JENSEN HUANG.
20:16 IT IS 80% OF THE GPU MARKET IS NVIDIA PROFIT TODAY.
20:20 FRANCINE: WHEN YOU LOOK AT SOME OF THE VALUATIONS, DOES IT
20:26 REPRICE DEPENDING ON WHO BECOMES -- WE HAVE AN INTERIM CHIEF
20:36 EXECUTIVE AT THE MOMENT. >> WITH COLETECREST COMING IN,
20:40 THIS IS NOT A LONG-TERM DECISION.
20:42 THE COMPANY IS GIVING THE MESSAGE TO THE MARKET THAT THEY
20:45 WILL BE WORKING ON CONTINUE KNEWITY.
20:48 CONTINUE KNEWITY ON THE PRODUCT STRATEGY AND OF ITS SUPPLIERS.
20:59 HOW THEY MADE WITH THE AI COMPLEX.
21:00 JENSEN HUANG WAS A VERY CONNECTED MAN IN TERMS OF HIS
21:03 POLITICAL AND GEO-POLITICAL TIES.
21:05 THAT IS GOING TO BE VERY HARD TO REPLACE.
21:08 WHAT WE SEE IN TERMS OF VALUATION, SINCE JENSEN HUANG'S
21:13 DEPARTURE, THE MARKET HAS REVALUED NVIDIA ONE TRILLION
21:17 U.S. DOLLARS LOWER. ALL OF THESE RISKS HAVE BEEN
21:22 PRICED IN. IF YOU LOOKING AT THE STOCK
21:26 PRICE TODAY, IT IS AROUND $165 PER SHARE.
21:33 THE P/E RATIO IS AROUND 21 AND NEXT YEAR'S EARNINGS RATIO IS
21:39 AROUND 10 TIMES ONLY. THE REEVALUATION HAS ALREADY
21:40 COME THROUGH. THE QUESTION IS WHAT'LL BE THE
21:46 NEXT STEP AND WE HAVE RALLIED JENSEN HUANG'S DEPARTURE.
21:50 WHACKED BE NEXT? THERE WILL BE GOOD.
21:52 THERE WILL BE BAD. THE QUESTION IS WHETHER MORE
21:56 UNPLEASANT NEWS WILL BE COMING IN TO FURTHER DETERIORATE THIS
22:00 COMPANY'S VALUATION. FRANCINE: QUICKLY, ARE YOU
22:05 SURPRISED ACTUALLY DESPITE THE VOLATILITY WE'RE ALMOST BACK TO
22:09 WHERE WE WERE TWO WEEKS AGO ON AI?
22:10 >> ON SOME LEVEL NO. THERE HAS BEEN A DISCONNECT THE
22:14 LAST MONTH I WOULD SAY BETWEEN THE MARKET NARRATE AND THE
22:19 CONCERNS AN COMPANY FUNDAMENTALS.
22:22 WWE LOOK AT THE COMPANY, THE ORDER BOOKS, BACKLOGS,
22:27 EVERYTHING IS NOT GETTING WORSE. EVERYTHING HAS BEEN -- EARNINGS
22:31 MOMENT SUM INCREDIBLE. FRANKFULLY THIS SPACE.
22:36 ASIA THE MOST PUNISHED AND IT DOESN'T MAKE A LOT OF SENSE TO
22:39 US FRANKLY. IN THAT SENSE, NO, NOT
22:41 SURPRISED. I THINK A LOT OF WHAT HAS
22:47 A VOLATILITY SPIKE. A LOT OF FORCED SELLING.
22:52 ON THE REAL MONEY SIDE, I DON'T THINK WE HAVE SEEN AS MUCH
22:55 ACTIVITY. FRANCINE: OK.
22:57 THANK YOU. THANK YOU BOTH.
23:02 SOON MAJOR ANALYST AT SWISS CO. OUR GUESTS STAY WITH US AND
23:04 WE'LL TALK ABOUT THE FED AND THE BROADER MARKETS.
23:07 COMING UP, JENSEN HUANG'S DEPARTURE FROM NVIDIA RAISE
23:10 QUESTIONS ABOUT THE FUTURE OF THE AI TRADE.
23:14 WE'LL DISCUSS THE PERFORMANCE IMPACTS ON INFLATION AND WHAT
23:16 THAT MEANS FOR THE FED. THAT IS NEXT.
23:32 FRANCINE: GOOD MORNING EVERYONE. WELCOME TO "THE PULSE."
23:36 I'M FRANCINE LACQUA IN LONDON. THESE ARE YOUR TOP STORIES.
23:42 BLOOMBERG HAD LEARNED THAT A CHINESE COMPANY FOUNDED
23:43 BY ALICE HUANG SMUGGLED AI CHIPS.
23:52 THE AUSTINED CHAIRMAN JENSEN HUANG AND
23:54 HOWARD LUTNICK FACE QUESTIONS OVER WHETHER THEY DID ENOUGH TO
23:59 KEEP NVIDIA'S PRIZED CHIPS OUT OF CHINA'S HANDS.
24:02 AND MICROSOFT USERS ARE LOCKED OUT OF E-MAIL.
24:07 ONE OF THE MOST SEVERE OUTAGES IN RECENT MEMORIES.
24:23 JENSEN HUANG'S OUSTER THREATENS. >> WE GOT AN INFLATION PROBLEM.
24:27 WE HAVE A LABOR MARKET THAT IS STABLE.
24:29 GROWTH THAT IS GOOD BUT WE DEFINITELY HAVE AN INFLATION
24:32 PROBLEM. RIGHT NOW WE DON'T HAVE AI DOING
24:34 MOST OF THE DRIVING OF INFLATION ALTHOUGH THERE IS A RISK THAT IT
24:39 COULD CRICKET MORE AND WE ALSO DON'T HAVE PRODUCTIVITY GROWTH
24:43 -- CONTRIBUTE MORE AND WE ALSO DON'T HAVE GROWTH IN A WAY THAT
24:47 IS PICKING UP STEAM. FRANCINE: STILL WITH US, UBS
24:52 INVESTMENT BANK AND JOINING US TOM MCKENZIE, BLOOMBERG TECH
24:57 ANCHOR. THANK YOU FOR COMING ON.
25:03 I WANT TO ASK HIM ABOUT WHAT IT MEANS FOR INFLATION BECAUSE OF
25:06 THE AI BUILDOUT WHAT HAPPENED THE IMPLICATIONS ARE FOR THE
25:08 FED. WHAT IS THE READ ACROSS
25:11 REGULATION AND HOW ARE WASHINGTON LOOKING AT THIS?
25:14 WE KNOW JENSEN HUANG WILL TESTIFY NEXT UNIQUE.
25:17 TOM: THEY PICKED UP ONE OF THE BIGGEST TAKEAWAYS .
25:20 THE NEEDLE IS SHIFTING PARTICULARLILE WITH THE
25:22 DEMOCRATS TAKING CONTROL OVER CONGRESS.
25:24 WITH THE REGULATIONS AROUND NVIDIA, SEEMS TO BE REPORT A
25:29 LACK OF OVERSIGHT FROM THE COMMERCE DEPARTMENT IN TERMS OF
25:33 CHIP SALES AND SMUGGLING OF CHIPS.
25:35 THE NEEDLE SEEMS TO BE SWING WHERE THERE ARE GOING TO BE
25:37 RESTRICTIONS. YOU CAN MAKE THAT HYPOTHESIS,
25:43 THERE WILL BE MORE RESTRICTIONS. THE DEMOCRATS ARE NOW IN CONTROL
25:48 OF CONGRESS AND THIS SPY SCANDAL.
25:50 YOU CAN SEE THAT BUILDING NOW. WE EXPECT JENSEN HUANG GIVING
25:56 EVIDENCE NEXT WEEK TO COMMITTEES ON THE HILL.
25:58 THIS IS THE FIRST CHAPTER TO HAVE STORY FOR NVIDIA AND THEN
26:03 THE BROADER READ ACROSS TO THE WIDER ECOSYSTEM AND A REMINDER
26:06 OF THE ROLE NVIDIA PLAYED IN THAT IN FINANCING SO MUCH OF THE
26:12 BUILDOUT ACROSS THE STAFF. EVERYTHING FROM THE BIG FRONTIER
26:15 LABS THEY INVESTED IN LIKE ANTHROPIC, LIKE OPENAI TAKING
26:23 STAKE IN COMPANIES LIKE INTEL. AI AGENTS, ROBERTICS, HEALTHCARE
26:27 AND ACROSS ALL OF THOSE SPACES, NVIDIA HAS PLAYED A ROLE.
26:35 NOW WITH COLLETTE CREST, THE INTERIM CEO, TO WHAT DEGREE THAT
26:39 YOU SEE THAT SUPPORT CONTINUE? WE KNOW SHE CLASHED WITH JENSEN
26:45 IN THE PAST ABOUT THE SIZE OF SOME OF THESE DEALS.
26:52 AN OPENAI DATA CENTER DEAL THAT GENERAL SWEPT ANS FOR $200
26:54 BILLION. SHE PUSHED FOR $100 BILLION.
26:58 FRANCINE: OVERALL HOW MUCH TO HAVE AI BUILD THAT IS SUPPORTING
27:01 THE U.S. ECONOMY NOW? WE DON'T SEE -- WE HAVE NOT IAN
27:05 A READ ACROSS ON INFLATION. BUT IT COULD COME.
27:08 >> WE HAVE TRAIL GALLON AI CAPEX THIS YEAR.
27:12 WE HAVE 1.8 NEXT YEAR. AGGREGATING HYPER SCALERS.
27:16 A TRILLION IS ABOUT 3% OF U.S. GDP.
27:19 THERE IS A LOT OF LEAKAGE. A LOTS OF THIS SPEND IS IS IS GOING TO
27:28 ASIAN MEDIA COMPANIES. 90% OF THAT THE MEMORY.
27:32 UP OUR ESTIMATES I REMEMBER IN THE YEAR WAS THAT AI WAS ALMOST
27:34 ALL OF IT. IF YOU ADDED UP THE CAPEX AND
27:39 THE WEALTH EFFECTS. NOW NUMBER IS DOWN TO 60% OR SO.
27:44 WE HAVE SO MUCH OF THAT. A WEALTH TRANSFER RATHER THAN A
27:48 COMPUTE INCREASE IN THE U.S. STILL A BIG NUMBER.
27:52 60% OF THE U.S. ECONOMY, STILL A BIG NUMBER.
27:56 YOU SEE LABOR PRODUCTIVITY. WHAT YOU'RE DOING IS INCREASING
28:02 OUTLOOK WITH A LOT OF CAPEX. IT LOOKS LIKE PEOPLE ARE MORE
28:07 PRODUCTIVE BUT ONLY 5% OF THAT INCREASE IS DUE EXTRA AI
28:12 ADOPTION. THAT IS DIFFERENT.
28:13 FRANCINE: DOES THAT CHANGE? WE SPOKE TO CHRISTOPHER WALLER
28:18 AND HE SAID A 50 BASIS POINT HIKE IS NOT OUT OF THE QUESTION
28:21 IN DECEMBER BECAUSE OF ALL OF THIS.
28:23 IT COULD LEAD TO STICKIER INFLATION.
28:26 WE'RE NOT NECESSARILY SEEING PRODUCTIVITY IMPACT INFLATION
28:29 STRAIGHT AWAY. >> SEVERAL THINGS HAPPENING.
28:34 ON ONE LEVEL, YES, WHEN YOU LOOK AT THE AI RELATED INFLATION.
28:39 YOU CAN SAY OK. THAT IS AI INFLATION.
28:42 ON THE OTHER HAND WAGE GROWTH IS RUNNING WAY BELOW OUR MODELS.
28:46 THE U.S. IS TRANSITIONING AWAY FROM LABOR-BASED PRODUCTION MUCH
28:51 FASTER THAN ANY COUNTRY IN THE WORLD.
28:52 SO I THINK THERE IS ALREADY A CHILLING EFFECT.
28:56 YOU LOOK AT THE SURVEYS. THE TOP END OWNS 90% OF EQUITY.
29:03 I THINK THERE IS ALREADY A DISINFLATIONARY ELEMENT THAT IS
29:06 HARDER TO PIN POINT, NOT OUTWEIGHING, BALANCING UP
29:08 AGAINST THAT INFLATION. I THINK THE TRUE PRODUCTIVITY,
29:12 THE TRUE GROWTH IN FIGURE OUT WHAT TO DO WITH AI FEELS LIKE IT
29:19 IS A COUPLE OF YEARS AWAY. BECAUSE THE ADOPTION IS A MILE
29:23 WIDE AND AN INCH DEEP. ADOPTION LEVELS ARE 20%.
29:29 AGENTIC AI IS 12%. 2% OF THE FIRMS ARE DOING 50% OF
29:31 THE SPENDING. FOR THE FED THAT THAT MENDIGOS
29:36 TO DEAL WITH WHAT'S IN OF YOU. YOU HAVE SOME PRETTY UGLY
29:38 INFLATION DATA. THE LAST FEW INFLATION PRINTSES,
29:42 A LOT WE DON'T UNDERSTAND. WE THOUGHT IT WAS ALL TARIFFS,
29:45 AI AN ENERGY. NOW THERE ARE COMPONENTS THAT
29:49 LOOK LIKE SPILLOVER. UP I THINK THEY ARE GOING
29:51 RESPOND TO. THAT I THINK THEY WILL ALL HAVE
29:55 COMPETING NARRATIVES WHEN AI BECOMES DISINFLATIONARY.
29:59 I THINK THEY ARE GOING TO ACCELERATE AND SO FOR US THAT
30:05 MEANS YOU MOVE IN DECEMBER AND JANUARY.
30:07 WE HAVE SEEN SOME OF THE OTHER FOR OMC MEMBERS POUR COLD WATER
30:12 ON THAT. FRANCINE: IMPACT IT COULD HAVE
30:18 ON U.S.-CHINA RELATION COULD BE SIGNIFICANT.
30:19 TOM: ABSOLUTELY. WE'RE SEEING THIS FROM OUR OWN
30:21 TEAM. ALICE HUANG IS THE ALLEGED SPY
30:28 WHO HAD THIS FAIR WHICH JENSEN HUANG WAS ABLE TO SMUGGLE CHIPS
30:33 INTO CHINA IN SHANGHAI. THIS TIES TO THE NATIONAL
30:36 SECURITY PIECE OF THIS. DOES IT ACCELERATE THAT PUSH
30:38 FROM CONGRESS, NOT JUST DEMOCRATS BUT ALSO REPUBLICAN
30:43 LAW LAWMAKERS AND WE HAVE THIS MEETING BETWEEN PRESIDENT XI AND
30:45 PRESIDENT TRUMP NEXT WEEK. WE'RE WATCHING THAT.
30:47 PRESIDENT TRUMP SAID HE IS NOT GOING TO BRING THIS UP.
30:50 MAYBE THE NEWS OVER THE LAST FEW DAYS FORCES HIS HAPPENED ON THIS
30:56 ISSUE IN TERMS OVER THE SPY SCANDAL AND CHINA'S ROLE IN
30:58 THAT. WE KNOW ALICE HUANG IS CURRENTLY
31:07 IN BEIJING, THE CHINESE CAPITAL. ASML CONTINUES TO SHIP SOME OF
31:13 ITS LITHOGRAPHY MACHINEES INTO THE CHINESE MARKET.
31:22 A SALE OF GOOD, HARDWARE, SOFTWARE, CHIPS AND PRODUCTES
31:27 INTO THE CHINESE MARKET. INCREASED SCRUTINY OF WHAT
31:31 EXTENT CHINA HAS BEEN ABLE TO LEVERAGE THE LOCH HOLES.
31:33 FRANCINE: HOW DO THE MIDTERMS CHANGE POLICY IN THE U.S.
31:36 ESPECIALLY WHEN IT COMES TO TRADE?
31:38 >> TRADE I DON'T THINK IT CHANGES MOCHA AT ALL.
31:41 FRANCINE: YOU DON'T SEE A PRESIDENT THAT COULD BE MORE
31:46 AGGRESSIVE TO MAKE UP FOR FOR THE POWER HE LOSES ELSEWHERE?
31:51 OR HE IS GOING TO CHILL? >> BIPARTISAN SUPPORT TO
31:53 CRACKDOWN ON EXPORTS OF CRITICAL TECHNOLOGIES.
31:56 THAT WAS THERE UNDER BIDEN AND IS ALSO THERE UNDER TRUMP.
32:00 THAT WILL INCREASE. I WAS THINKING MORE OF OK.
32:05 WE HAVE A DEMOCRATIC MAJORITY. DOES ATEFECT TRADE POLICY?
32:08 IT DOESN'T IN ANY FUND MENTAL WAY.
32:10 MOST IS DONE BY EXECUTIVE ORDER OR THE EXECUTIVE BRANCH.
32:13 I THINK THE WHITE HOUSE REMAINS IN DELIVER AS SEAT.
32:16 THEY WILL GET AN EXTRA PUSH TO TRACK DOWN MORE ON SOME OF THESE
32:21 TECHNOLOGICAL EXPORTS. I DON'T THINK OF THAT AS BEING
32:26 TERRIBLY CONSEQUENTIAL FOR THE OUTLOOK.
32:29 THAT WAS THE DIRECTION OF TRAVEL ANYWAY.
32:32 FRANCINE: WHAT DOES IT MEAN IN TERMS OF PORTFOLIO CONSTRUCTION
32:35 NOW? >>> YOU STILL WANT TO BE IN
32:38 EQUITY. IF YOU LOOK AT HOW THE TWO ASSET
32:43 CLASSES ARE PERFORMING. BONDS HAVE BEEN TERRIBLE.
32:45 NEGATIVE FOR THE LAST FIVE YEARS.
32:49 EQUITY, PLUS 10 OR 12. THE EQUITY BOND CORRELATION.
32:54 YOU'RE LOSING YOUR BONDS. THAT MAY CHANGE NEXT YEAR IF
32:57 INFLATION COMES DOWN. THE CORRELATION FLIPS.
33:00 IT BECOMES A DIVERSE FIRE. IF YOU LOOK AMP A AARON DATA.
33:05 IT IS VERY EXTREME. GLOBALLY IT LOOKS LIKE PEOPLE
33:09 HOLDING 70% OF EQUITIES. 16% IN BONDS, THAT HAS TO START
33:14 SHIFTING EVEN THOUGH YOU WILL MAKE MORE NONE ON EQUITY
33:16 HOLDINGS. WE THINK THAT IS GOING TO START
33:20 TO HAPPEN NEXT YEAR. THAT IS CONTINGENCY ON THE
33:24 MIDDLE EAST RESOLVING ITSELF. THE CENTRAL BANKS DOING WHOM IS
33:31 PRICED. I THINK YOU WANT TOP STAY CLOSE
33:34 TO THE AI TRADE BECAUSE BASICALLY IF YOU THINK ABOUT
33:39 WHAT'S HAPPENING AT A GLOBAL LEVEL, WE COVERED 4,000
33:41 COMPANIES. 10 COMPANIES ARE DRIVING 845% OF
33:45 GLOBAL CORPORATE INVESTMENT. WHEN YOU THINK ABOUT THE
33:49 EARNINGS, LIKE WE'RE NOW BASICALLY IN THE U.S.
33:51 NOT IN THE U.S., FOR ALL-TIME HIGH EARNINGS FOR ENTIRE
33:54 ECONOMY. EVERYTHING IS NOW AT ALL-TIME
33:57 HIGHS. GLOBALLY AT THE 91ST PERCENTILE.
34:02 ALL OF THAT IS COPS TRAITED IN MOSTLY TECH AND FINANCIALS.
34:06 YOU HAVE TO REMAIN EXPOSED TO THAT.
34:10 PEOPLE WILL MOVE UPSTREAM AND DOWNSTREAM.
34:11 EVERYTHING THAT IS GIANT THE HYPER SCALERS.
34:13 WHERE THE MONEY WILL TEND TO MOVE.
34:15 THAT FOR US IS STILL THE RIGHT WAY TO PLAY IT.
34:20 IT IS SO ONE EXEMPTIONAL NOW. THE HYPER SCALERS ARE DRIVING
34:25 BASICALLY ALL OF U.S. INVESTMENT.
34:27 HALF OF GLOBAL EQUITY VALUATIONS AND HALF OF GLOBAL EQUITY TRADE
34:31 AND MOST OF THE GROWTH IN THE AI SUPPLY CHAIN IN ASIA, WHY WOULD
34:35 YOU DO ANYTHING THAN TRY TO BE EXPOSED TO THAT.
34:42 FRANCINE: THANK YOU BOTH COMING UP, HOW RELIABLE IS U.S. SUPPORT
34:46 FOR UKRAINE AFTER PRESIDENT TRUMP'S BRUISING MID-TERMS
34:51 DEFEATS? WE'RE JOINED BY A PROM NATION'S
34:55 CAPITAL KREMLIN KARATE TO TALK ABOUT RETURNS THE RUSSIA AND
34:56 UKRAINE. THAT IS NEXT.
34:59 THIS IS BLOOMBERG. ♪
35:16 FRANCINE: A WEAKENED PRESIDENT TRUMP AFTER A BRUISING MID-TERMS
35:19 DEFEAT IS RAISING CONCERNS ABOUT THE U.S. SUPPORT FOR UKRAINE.
35:25 HIS DECISION TO DROP SANCTIONS ON DIAZ HAS ADDED TO FEARS.
35:31 RUSSIA HAS ABOUT 400,000 DEATHS SINCE THE WAR BEGAN ALMOST FIVE
35:36 YEARS AGO. JOINING THE US NOW IS THE CHIEF
35:40 EXECUTIVE OF HERMITAGE MANAGEMENT.
35:45 AND AWARDS WERE PRESENTED IN LONDON YESTERDAY.
35:48 MASSIVE EFFORTS. DRAGS TO YOU AND YOUR TEAM.
35:52 WHERE ARE WE NOW? I DON'T KNOW IF THE MID-TERMS
35:54 CHANGED THE CALCULUS OF PRESIDENT TRUMP WHEN IT COMES TO
35:58 UKRAINE AND RUSSIA. >> IN SOME WAYS IT CHANGES IT
36:01 TOWARD THE NEGATIVE. A DEMOCRATIC SWEEP OF ALL
36:06 DIFFERENT HOUSES OF CONGRESS AND GOVERNORS MEANS TRUMP'S ABILITY
36:09 TO INFLUENCE U.S. POLICY HAS BEEN BOXED IN.
36:14 WHERE IS HE NOT BOXED IN? FOREIGN POLICY.
36:18 HIS FOREIGN POLICY NOW -- NOT TOTALLY OPEN SEASON BUT PRETTY
36:21 MUCH OPEN SEASON TO DO WHATEVER HE WANTS.
36:25 I THINK YOU'LL SEE OVER THE NEXT TWO YEARS, WATCH CRAZINESS HE
36:29 WAS TRYING-TIME POSE IN AMERICA WHICH WILL BE CONSTRAINED BY
36:34 BUDGET AND DOMESTIC LEGISLATION, THAT CRAZINESS WILL FIND ITSELF
36:38 ON TO THE INTERNATIONAL STAGE. FRANCINE: DO DEMOCRATS WANT TO
36:39 SUPPORT UKRAINE? CAN THEY DO SOMETHING MORE ON
36:41 THEIR SIDE? DO WE UNDERSTAND WHY PRESIDENT
36:47 PUTIN WANTS TO HELP RUSSIA? BECAUSE HE WANTS THE NOBEL PEACE
36:51 PRIZE? >> TRUMP WANTS A NOBEL PEACE
36:54 PRIZE. HE'S A DEAL MAKER.
36:58 WHO IS HE DOING DEALS FOR? PROBABLY FOR HIMSELF.
37:03 THE QATARIS GAVE HIM A GOLD PLATED 747 AND ALL OF A SUDDEN,
37:07 THEY WERE ABLE TO BUILD AN AIR FORCE BASE IF THE UNITED STATES.
37:14 BUILT THERE ARE 500 BILLION. ALL OF A SUDDEN, ABLE TO IMPORT
37:21 ADVANCED U.S. MICROCHIPS WHICH WERE NEVER ALLOWED BEFORE.
37:25 POLICY IS FOR SALE. WHAT IS TRUMP GETTING FROM THE
37:27 RUSSIANS? WE DON'T KNOW YET.
37:32 THEY ARE THINGS ON THE TABLE. LUKOIL.
37:34 INTERNATIONAL AVIETTES BEING SOLD TO A CONSORTIUM THAT ARE
37:39 FINANCIAL BUSINESS PARTNERS OF PEOPLE WITHIN TRUMP'S CIRCLE.
37:43 FRANCINE: WHAT DO YOU MAKE OF PUTIN'S ORDERS TO ALLOW MOSCOW
37:52 CREDIT BANKS TO SEIZE ASSETS. >> FIRST OF ALL, ANY COMPANY
37:56 THAT STILL HAS BUSINESS INTERESTS IN RUSSIA GET NO
38:00 SYMPATHY FROM ME OR ANYBODY ELSE.
38:03 WE SHOULD NOT HAVE -- WE SHOULDN'T ALTER OUR THOUGHT OR
38:10 POLICY IN ANY WAY, BUYER BEWARE. THAT IS THEIR PROBLEM.
38:13 NOBODY SHOULD BE THINKING ABOUT, WORRYING ABOUT OR FIGHTING FOR
38:16 ANY BRITISH COMPANY OR WESTERN COMPANY THAT REMAINS IF RUSSIA.
38:20 THAT IS THEIR PROBLEM. FRANCINE: DOES VLADIMIR PUTIN
38:23 BECOME MORE DANGEROUS IN THIS PHASE OF THE WAR?
38:27 >> HE IS IN A STALEMATE AS YOU MENTIONED IN THE INTRODUCTION.
38:30 RUSSIA HAS LOST MORE THAN 400,000.
38:34 PROBABLY A LOT MORE THAN 400,000 SOLDIERS.
38:38 THEY MADE NO PROGRESS ON UKRAINIAN TERRITORY.
38:41 THE FRONT LINES ARE PRETTY MUCH BLOCKED.
38:47 UKRAINIANS ARE HITTING THEIR OIL REFINERIES.
38:49 WHAT IS HIS OPTION? IT IS WHAT I CALL THE CHECHEN OR
38:52 SYRIAN OPTION. WHICH IS JUST SCORCHED EARTH.
38:56 BOMB CIVILIANS. KILL CIVILIANS.
39:00 DESTROY INFRASTRUCTURE. ELECTRICITY, WATER, BRIDGES,
39:04 WATER, ROADS, TRAINS. WHATEVER WE CAN DO TO MAKE LIFE
39:09 INTOLERABLE FOR THE UKRAINIANS. HE IS NOT WINNING ON THE
39:12 BATTLEFIELD. HE WILL JUST HAVE TO KILL
39:15 INNOCENT PEOPLE. FRANCINE: TO WHAT END?
39:20 >> THEM THE UKRAINIANS GIVE UP. THE TERROR OF RUSSIANS OCCUPYING
39:23 UKRAINE IS GREATER. THEY WON'T GIVE UP ON THAT BASE
39:27 IS. ONE THING HOPING FOR IS WHAT HE
39:31 ACHIEVED WITH THE AMERICANS. THROUGH NO MILITARY MEANS, TO
39:35 GET ONE OF THE -- THE BIGGEST PARTNER OF THE UKRAINIANS,
39:40 AMERICA DONALD TRUMP TO STOP FUNDING AMERICA, TO STOP FUNDING
39:44 UKRAINE 40% OF UKRAINE'S MILITARY AID AT THAT TIME WAS
39:48 COMING FROM AMERICA. THAT STOPPED.
39:49 IF HE CAN ACHIEVE THE SAME THING IN EUROPE, HE HAS ALL SORTS OF
39:54 STUFF GOING ON WITH THE FRENCH. A FRENCH RE-ELECTION COMING UP.
39:58 MARINOL ESPN PRO PUTIN. YOU HAVE THE AMP FD OF GERMANY,
40:02 PRO PUTIN. IF HE CAN GET EUROPE TO FUNDING
40:07 UKRAINE THEN HE CAN WIN. THAT IS HIS MEDIUM TERM
40:10 STRATEGY. FRANCINE: IS THERE A CHANCE?
40:13 WE HAD A GOOD CONVERSATION CAN THE GERMAN CHANCELLOR THREE
40:17 WEEKS AGO. AT THE END OF IT, I ASKED WHAT
40:21 WORRIES YOU? HE SAID RUSSIA AND THIS HYBRID
40:26 WAR AND WE DON'T REALIZE HOW STRONG IT IS.
40:28 HOW CAN THEY FUND THIS? DO YOU THINK IT WILL LEAD TO
40:32 SOMETHING? >> FIRST OF ALL, WE CAN'T USE
40:35 THE TERM HYBRID WAR. IT IS WAR.
40:41 IF YOU'RE ACCEPTING A DREAM TO LEIPZIG AIRPORT, THAT IS WAR.
40:45 FRANCINE: I DON'T KNOW WHY ACTUALLY.
40:47 >> FOR THE SAME REASON WE CALLED IT RUSSIAN-BACKED SEPARATISTS
40:52 WHEN RUSSIA TOOK CRIMEA AND ENTERED UKRAINE.
40:56 WE CAN STICK SOME LANGUAGE. I IT IS LIKE AN INTERIM
40:58 CONFLICT. HYBRID WAR.
41:02 IT IS LIKE A HYBRID RESPONSE. IT IS WAR.
41:04 REAL WAR. THEY ARE AT WAR WITH US.
41:10 IF THEY ARE GOING TO BE BLOWING UP DHL IN THE U.K. OR HIRING
41:15 SOMEONE TO BURN DOWN PRIME MINISTER'S HOUSE, THAT IS WAR.
41:19 FRANCINE: DO YOU SEE ANYONE STANING UP TO RUSSIA?
41:22 >> EVEN WITH THE CURRENT GOVERNMENTS IN PLACE, EVEN WANTS
41:26 TO GO ABOUT LIFE AND HOPE EVERYTHING IS GOING TO BE OK
41:30 BUILD A SPINE. IT IS EASIER THAT WAY.
41:36 IT IS GOING TO TAKE SOME HORRIFIC MASS CASUALTY EVENT
41:41 BEFORE SOMEONE SAYS RUSSIA IS A DANGEROUS, HORRIBLE COUNTRY THAT
41:44 DOES HORRIFIC THINGS TO PEOPLE. FRANCINE: DO YOU SEE THAT
41:46 COMING? WHERE ARE WE GOING TO?
41:49 >> I HOPE NOT. THAT IS WHERE IT GOES.
41:55 THE OTHER THING, PUTIN CANNOT ACHIEVE HIS MILITARY AIMS IN
41:59 UKRAINE, HE IS NOT JUST GOING TO STOP.
42:00 HE IS GOING TO CHANGE THE EQUATION.
42:02 IT MIGHT MEAN -- PROBABLY NOT GOING TO HIT LONDON FIRST.
42:08 HE WILL PROBABLY HIT ESTONIA OR CHURCH OF JESUS CHRIST OF
42:10 LATTER-DAY SAINTS VIA FIRST AND HE WILL HIT SOMETHING TO CHANGE
42:13 THE EQUATION. WE WILL BE SCRATCHING OURSELF
42:16 HOW DID WE LET IT HAPPEN? WE CALLED IT A HYBRID WAR AND
42:19 DIDN'T RESPOND. FRANCINE: YOU DON'T SEE ANY
42:22 PEACE TALKS? YOU DON'T THINK WE COULD GET
42:26 WITH THE U.S. BACKING AND SUPPORT SOME KIND OF DEAL?
42:29 >> FIRST, THE U.S. IS NOT LOOKING FOR PEACE.
42:33 THEY ARE LOOKING FOR CAPITULATION.
42:34 WHAT WAS PROPOSED IN ABU DHABI WAS NOT A PEACE TALK.
42:39 IT WAS HOW CAN WE GET UKRAINIANS TO AGREE TO RUSSIA'S POSITION
42:43 AND FORCE EUROPEANS TO DO THAT? THE ONLY SAVING GRACE IS THAT
42:48 AMERICA HAS GIVEN UPMOST OF ITS LEVERAGE TO FORCE ANYONE TO DO
42:49 ANYTHING. EUROPE HAS ITS OWN AGENCY AND
42:53 THE UKRAINIANS ARE NOT GOING TO GIVE UP AND SURREPPEDDER TO
42:56 RUSSIA. FRANCINE: WHAT DO YOU THINK
43:00 HATCHES IN TEXT COUPLE OF WEEKS? WE TALKED ABOUT SANCTION RELEAST
43:06 LEAF COMING FROM THE U.S. PART. IS THERE DANGER U.S. BACKS DOWN
43:10 ON SANCTION? >> NO, THE E.U. IS NOT BACKING
43:14 DOWN ON SANCTIONS. THEY MAY NOT HAVE ENOUGH OF A
43:18 SPINE DEALING WITH THE ATTACKS BUT THE SANCTIONS ARE GOING TO
43:20 STAY THERE. FRANCINE: DO THEY MAKE A
43:22 DIFFERENCE? >> OF COURSE THEY MAKE A
43:24 DIFFERENCE. THEY ARE ABSOLUTELY PAINFUL FOR
43:27 RUSSIA. TO TEX TENT THAT AMERICA IS
43:29 TALKING ABOUT LIFTING SANCTIONS, THE EUROPEANS ARE NOT TALKING
43:32 ABOUT IT. THE EUROPEAN SANCTIONS ARE MORE
43:35 MEANINGFUL TO RUSSIA THAN THE AMERICAN SANCTIONS.
43:38 AMERICA DOESN'T DO ANY BUSINESS WITH RUSSIA.
43:41 EUROPE IN THE PAST HAS. RUSSIANS TRAVEL 100 TIMES MORE
43:46 TO EUROPE THAN AMERICA. THE EUROPEANS ARE WHAT MATTERS
43:50 TO RUSSIANS. FRANCINE: THANK YOU SO MUCH FOR
43:53 COMING ON. CHIEF EXECUTIVE OF HERMITAGE
43:56 CAPITAL MANAGEMENT. LET'S GET MORE ON THE I WAS TO
44:01 ACHIEVE DEAL IN UKRAINE. PRESIDENT ZELENSKYY I SAID A
44:07 DEAL HAS BEEN MADE IN A PRISONER SWAP DEAL TO INCLUDE EUROPEANS
44:11 IN PEACE TALKS WITH RUSSIA. WHAT PROGRESS IF ANY HAS BEEN
44:16 MADE IN THESE TALKS? OLIVER: AS YOU HAVE BEEN
44:19 OUTLINING, IT HAS BEEN A VERY BUSY WEEK IN TERMS OF INTENSE
44:24 DIPLOMACY LED BY THE UNITED STATES, JARED KUSHNER AND STEVE
44:29 WITKOFF. THE TALKS HAD EFFECTIVELY BEEN
44:34 PUT ON PAUSE SINCE FEBRUARY, THE BEGINNING OF THE WAR IN IRAN AND
44:37 OBVIOUSLY THE AMERICANS DISTRACTED UP TO THAT POINT AND
44:41 THE DIPLOMATIC EFFORTS DISAPPEARED TO THE BACKGROUND.
44:44 NOW THEY ARE BACK IN THE FOREFRONT THIS WEEK.
44:47 AFTER ABU DHABI, THAT TEAM, THE AMERICANS WENT TO MOSCOW.
44:50 THEY MET WITH VLADIMIR PUTIN. WE HEARD SOME OF THE RED LINES
44:53 TALKING ABOUT THE SECURITY ARRANGEMENTS IF EVER THERE IS
44:57 PEACE REACHED IN UKRAINE. ONE OF THE ISSUES HE REITERATED
45:01 WAS THE RED LINE OF HAVING FOREIGN FORCES STATIONED IN
45:04 UKRAINE. THAT CONVERSATION KICKS THINGS
45:07 TO HERE IN DUBLIN WHERE LEADERS HAVE BEEN MEETING TO DISCUSS
45:09 UKRAINE. LAST NIGHT YOU HAD JARED KUSHNER
45:15 AND STEVE WITKOFF MEETING WITH ZELENSKYY.
45:19 WHEN WE THINK OF IT, AFTER ALL OF THIS DIPLOMACY, WHAT DO WE
45:21 GET? THE RESTART OF THE NEGOTIATIONS.
45:26 WE HAD THE PRISONER EXCHANGE, MORE THAN 1,000 PEOPLE.
45:29 MOST SIGNIFICANTLY FOR THE EUROPEANS, THEY SEEM TO HAVE
45:33 OFFICIALLY GOTTEN A SEAT AT THE TABLE.
45:35 THE NEXT SET OF TALKS WILL BE BETWEEN THE UNITED STATES, THE
45:40 RUSSIANS AND THE UKRAINIANS AND SOME EUROPEANS SEATED AT THE
45:44 TABLE. WHO IS GOING TO SIT IN THAT
45:45 SEAT? HAS THE BIG DISCUSSION FOR THE
45:47 EUROPEANS. FRANCINE: WHAT HAPPENS NEXT?
45:52 OLIVER: THEY ARE GOING TO HAVE TO FIGURE OUT WHO IS GOING TO BE
45:56 SEATED AT THE TABLE. LOT OF O NAMES FLOATED AROUND.
45:59 WHETHER IT SHOULD BE THE HEAD OF THE EUROPEAN COUNCIL, THE
46:04 PRESIDENT ANTONIO -- ONE OF THE LEASER FROM GERMANY OR FRANCE.
46:12 THEE-3, U.K. ACTION GERMANY AND PERHAPS THE.
46:15 SOME OTHER NAMES FLOATING AROUND, YOU HAD A PHONE CALL
46:19 BETWEEN THE PRESIDENT OF FINLAND AND THE PRIME MINISTER OF MOORE
46:26 WAY WITH VLADIMIR PUTIN. COULD ALEXANDER WHO HAS A GOOD
46:30 RELATIONSHIP WITH PRESIDENT TRUMP AND GOOD RELATION WITH
46:33 UKRAINE, COULD THAT BE SOMEBODY IN THE DISCUSSION?
46:37 AND ALSO FINANCING UKRAINE. THEY NEED 70 BILLION EUROS IN
46:41 ADDITION TO WHAT THEY GOT NEXT YEAR.
46:45 THE EUROPEANS ARE TRYING TO FURNISH HAS BEEN BILLION OF
46:46 THAT. WE NEED TO FIGURE OUT WHAT THE
46:52 RUT ROUTE TO 45 BILLION IN UKRAINE IS.
46:55 FRANCINE: HOW MUCH TALK IS THERE ABOUT NVIDIA AND AI?
46:58 >> THAT IS GOING TO BE A BIG CONVERSATION TOPIC.
47:03 WE WERE SPEAKING WITH SOME OF THE FOREIGN MINISTERS.
47:09 I ASKED IF ONE OF YOUR EXECUTIVES WAS BEING BOY ISED
47:15 SPIED ON HOW DIFFICULT WOULD THAT I CAN THAT MAKE
47:16 CONVERSATIONS? THE CONVERSATION VERY MUCH TODAY
47:18 AMONG EUROPEAN LEADERS ON AI AND IT IS IMPOSSIBLE TO HAVE A
47:24 CONVERSATION WITH AI WITHOUT TALKING ABOUT NVIDIA NOW.
47:29 FRANCINE: OLIVER CROOK THERE. BLOOMBERG'S CHIEF EUROPE
47:34 CONVERSATION THE AN IN DEPTH LOOK AT NVIDIA'S OUSTED CHIEF
47:37 EXECUTIVE. YOU CAN WATCH THAT ON YOUTUBE AT
47:41 BLOOMBERG.COM. THE BLOOMBERG TERMINAL.
47:44 "BLOOMBERG BRIEF" IS UP NEXT. THEY WILL GO THROUGH SOME OF THE
47:47 MAIN MOVES WHEN IT COMES TO SOME OF THE BIG AI THINGS AND WE KNOW
47:52 MICROSOFT IS STRUGGLING TO REPAIR THE OUTAGE THEY ARE
47:54 SEEING WORLDWIDE. A COUPLE OF OTHER THINGS WE'RE
47:57 WATCHING OUT FOR. A BIT OF AN INFLATION PRINTS IN
48:02 THE U.S. AND THE GLOBAL OIL MARKETS ARE SWINGING TO A
48:06 SURPLUS ON SOME OF THE GULF EXPORTS.
48:07 THAT IS ACCORDING TO THE I.A. THIS IS BLOOMBERG.
Microsoft Races to Fix Outage, Stocks Slip of Inflation Test full transcript
0:02 TOM: GOOD MORNING. HERE IS WHAT'S ON THE AGENDA --
0:09 JENSEN HUANG STUNNING DOWNFALL MARKING A WATERSHED MOMENT FOR
0:11 NVIDIA AND THE AI INDUSTRY. ANTHROPIC'S MEGA IPO DRAWS HUGE
0:18 DEMAND AS THE COMPANY POWERS AHEAD WITH THE POTENTIAL $90
0:21 BILLION RAISE. ENERGY RISKS RESURFACE.
0:27 ANNA: LET'S FOCUS ON THOSE ENERGY RISKS.
0:30 $96 A BARREL ON BRENT. YESTERDAY, IT WAS ON THE RISE.
0:35 WE FACTORED THAT INTO THE EUROPEAN SESSION BUT WE CONTINUE
0:40 TO WATCH THIS AS PRESIDENT TRUMP SEEMS TO BE DOWNPLAYING THE NEED
0:42 TO DO ANY KIND OF DEAL WITH IRAN.
0:45 THE U.S. 10 YEAR YIELD WENT BACK OVER 5%.
0:47 5.12%. YOU ARE STOXX 50 FUTURES, A NEW
0:51 RECORD AROUND THE CLOSE YESTERDAY.
0:54 WHAT DOES ECHO IN THE IMMEDIATE FUTURE?
0:56 IT LOOKS LIKE WE CAN GO DOWNWARD.
1:00 DOWN .5% ON THE EUROPEAN FUTURES.
1:02 THE COUNTDOWN TO THE OPENING TRADE STARTS RIGHT NOW.
1:16 TOM: WE GET A REMINDER THIS MORNING THAT WE ARE IN THE EARLY
1:21 INNINGS, THE OPENING INNINGS OF THIS NVIDIA'S SAGA.
1:29 THE DETAILS AROUND ALICE HUANG, THE ALLEGED CHINESE SPYING WITH
1:30 WHOM JENSEN HUANG HAD THIS AFFAIR, BLOOMBERG REPORTING
1:36 SUGGESTING THE COMPANY OF HERS WAS ABLE TO GET SMUGGLED NVIDIA
1:39 CHIPS INTO A DATA CENTER IN SHANGHAI.
1:42 WE WILL GET MORE DETAILS AND BRING THIS TO YOU THROUGHOUT THE
1:43 NEXT COUPLE OF HOURS. THIS IS A REMINDER THAT THERE
1:49 WILL BE INCREASED SCRUTINY NOT JUST ON NVIDIA, BUT ALSO THE
1:52 COMMERCE DEPARTMENT AND HOWARD LUTNICK AS IT IS TO WHAT EXTENT
1:58 THEY HAVE OVERLOOKED LOOPHOLES THAT ALLOWED SMUGGLED NVIDIA
1:59 CHIPS INTO THE CHINESE MARKET. JENSEN HUANG IS OUT.
2:04 NOW THE CFO IS IN CHARGE ON AN INTERIM BASIS.
2:07 HARVEY JONES WILL BE THE BOARD DIRECTOR.
2:10 THE FIRST TIME THEY'VE HAD THAT ROLE.
2:13 THERE HAS BEEN SOME MOVEMENT IN THE MANAGEMENT STORY.
2:17 WE KNOW THEY ARE LOOKING FOR THAT MORE PERMANENT ROLE AS CEO
2:20 BUT IT IS A REMINDER, WE ARE JUST AT THE BEGINNING OF THIS
2:21 STORY. ANNA: IF YOU ARE IN THE MOOD TO
2:25 REFLECT ON THE ACHIEVEMENTS OF JENSEN HUANG, YOU LOOK AT A
2:31 700,000% SHARE PRICE INCREASE SINCE HE LISTED THIS BUSINESS.
2:34 HE HAS BEEN THE ONLY CEO OF THIS COMPANY WHICH HAS MADE THIS
2:38 INCREDIBLE ACHIEVEMENT AND LEFT ITS INCREDIBLE FOOTPRINT.
2:42 THE HERE AND NOW, THE FOCUS IS VERY MUCH ON THIS NEW TROVE OF
2:45 DOCUMENTS THAT OFFER THIS EXPLICIT EVIDENCE OF WHAT IT IS
2:52 THAT ALICE HUANG WAS ABLE TO DO.
2:54 THE SHIPS THEY'VE IDENTIFIED IN CHINA, THEY CAME ORIGINALLY FROM
2:59 ONE PARTICULAR PARTNER OF NVIDIA.
3:03 WHO KNEW WHAT AND WHEN, THAT IS THE DOTS TO PUT TOGETHER.
3:11 TOM: POSSIBLY TESTIMONY AS SOON AS NEXT WEEK.
3:12 HE HAS LAWYERED UP. THIS IS A REMINDER OF THE WORK
3:19 ON THE TABLE FOR COLETTE BUT ALSO DEAL WITH THE SCRUTINY WITH
3:22 THE LAWMAKERS. I DO CALL WITH SOMEBODY FROM
3:26 NVIDIA AND THEY TALKED ABOUT THEIR SENSE OF ANGER AND
3:27 BETRAYAL. THEY SAID THEY WOULD HAVE QUIT
3:31 THE COMPANY IF JENSEN WAS NOT OUT.
3:34 THEY ALSO UNDERSTAND THE CUSTOMER BASE, THE SUPPLY CHAIN
3:38 AND A SAFE PAIR ENHANCE. ANNA: THAT EMPLOYEE COMING DOWN
3:44 ON THE SIDE OF WHAT'S HAPPENED, ON THE SIDE OF FORCING JENSEN
3:45 OUT. WE'VE HAD TESTIMONY FROM SOME
3:50 INVESTORS WHO ARE ANGRY THAT JENSEN HUANG HAS BEEN PUSHED
3:51 OUT. SAVING THEIR MONEY, KEEPING IT
3:56 TO SEE WHAT HE DOES NEXT. WE WILL TALK ABOUT OTHER NEWS
4:00 FLOW WITHIN THE TECH SPACE BECAUSE I WOKE UP THIS MORNING
4:03 AND JENSEN HUANG WAS NOT THE TOP STORY I SAW.
4:05 IT WAS ACTUALLY ANTHROPIC. THAT ITSELF IS AN INTERESTING
4:08 ACHIEVEMENT. THE IPO, SIX TIMES
4:12 OVERSUBSCRIBED. LOOKING TO RAISE $64 BILLION
4:18 PLUS 26 BILLION DOLLARS IN A PRIVATE PLACEMENT WHICH FEATURES
4:24 $10 BILLION BY NVIDIA AS A STRATEGIC PARTNER.
4:27 THIS WILL BE THE BIGGEST OF ALL TIME IN TERMS OF THESE RAISINGS.
4:33 THAT IS SOMETHING WE WILL CONTINUE TO MONITOR.
4:37 THE VALUATION COULD BE $1.4 TRILLION.
4:40 WHAT ARE THE SIGNALS WE ARE GETTING ABOUT THE AI TRADE POST
4:42 THE DOWNFALL OF JENSEN HUANG? CISCO'S NUMBERS, SOME QUESTIONS
4:48 AROUND A SLOWER RATE OF ORDERS BUT THE BROADCAST BETTER THAN
4:50 EXPECTED. THE STOCK UP 16% AFTER HOURS.
4:58 THIS IS A SAMSUNG STORY, IN TALKS TO BUY THIS DATA CENTER
5:02 EQUIPMENT SUPPLIER, THIS COOLING EQUIPMENT SUPPLIER WHICH GOES TO
5:05 UNDERSCORE FOR MANY PARTS OF THE AI TRADE, THERE IS A LIFE AS
5:09 NORMAL GETTING ON WITH BUSINESS AS IT WAS PRE THE DOWNFALL OF
5:12 JENSEN HUANG. TOM: CERBERUS IS A COMPETITOR TO
5:17 NVIDIA SO THAT'S ANOTHER STORY TO BE TOLD.
5:22 THE BACKING OF ABOUT $10 BILLION IN TERMS OF COMMITMENTS
5:25 FOR ANTHROPIC, THE LATEST IN THIS PRIVATE RAISE.
5:28 A REMINDER OF THE FINANCING THAT HAS COME THROUGH FROM THE
5:32 SO-CALLED CENTRAL BANK OF AI, NVIDIA.
5:34 INTERESTING REPORTING FROM THE WALL STREET JOURNAL TALKING
5:40 ABOUT HOW THE CLASHES THE CO-CEO HAD AROUND THIS FINANCING.
5:42 ANNA: REALLY INTERESTING. TOM: IS THAT FINANCING GOING TO
5:47 CONTINUE AT THE PACE AND EXTENT IT HAD UNDER JENSEN HUANG GIVEN
5:49 THE DIVISIONS THEY APPARENTLY HAD ON THIS QUESTION?
5:53 THAT IS PRETTY FASCINATING. ANNA: AND WHETHER SHE CONTINUES
5:58 THE CIRCULAR FINANCING RELATIONSHIPS WILL BE
5:58 INTERESTING. SHE KNOWS A LOT ABOUT THEM, BUT
6:03 UP ON. IN THE MIDST OF ALL THAT, AROUND
6:10 THE TECH SPACE, WE SAW THE 10 YEAR YIELDS IN THE U.S. ON
6:13 TREASURY GO ABOVE 5%. WE SAW A SUBSTANTIAL TICK UP IN
6:17 OIL PRICES. ALL OF THIS ON A CHANGE OF STAFF
6:20 FROM THE PRESIDENT. TOM: AGAIN, WE HAVE HEARD THIS
6:24 FROM THE PRESIDENT. HE SAYS WE NO LONGER NEED A DEAL
6:27 WITH IRAN. HE HAS GONE FROM SAYING WE ARE
6:32 CLOSE TO A DEAL, WHICH HE HAS SAID MULTIPLE TIMES, TO NOW NOT
6:36 NEEDING WHAT WHICH HE HAS SAID MULTIPLE TIMES.
6:38 POSTURING AGAIN FROM THE PRESIDENT.
6:41 WE WILL SEE HOW REAL THIS IS BUT OIL MOVED HIGHER ON THE BACK OF
6:42 THAT. WE HEARD FROM THE LIKES OF NEW
6:48 YORK FED PRESIDENT JOHN WILLIAMS THINK INFLATION IS TOO HIGH AND
6:49 WE NEED TO TAKE ACTION. MARY DALY SAYING MY BIAS IS FOR
6:54 FURTHER TIGHTENING WILL BE NEEDED.
6:58 MARY DALY SAYING INFLATION IS NOT THE SECTORS THE MOST
6:59 DIRECTLY AFFECTED BY TERROR OF SAID OIL.
7:04 HOW FAR, 25 OR 50 REMAINS AN OPEN QUESTION, BUT THERE IS
7:07 CONSENSUS. ANNA: WE ARE BUSY PRICING IT
7:11 EVEN MORE EXPECTATIONS AROUND FED HIKES.
7:16 I THINK DECEMBER STANDS AT 110% WITH A 25 BASIS POINT HIKE.
7:21 WE GET PPI DATA LATER TODAY. THAT WILL BE CRUCIAL IN THE WAKE
7:22 OF THE STRONG CPI PRINT. WE ARE GETTING THESE LINES THAT
7:26 LEAD THE MARKETS ARE PRICING FURTHER TIGHTENING FROM THE FED.
7:29 WILL PPI BE ANY DIFFERENT OR WILL IT BE OF THE SAME FLAVOR AS
7:33 WE WITNESS THIS CHANGE OF STANCE FROM THE WHITE HOUSE?
7:36 IN THE MIDST OF THAT, WHAT DO STOCKMARKETS DO?
7:40 THE STOCKS IN THE STATES INFLUENCED BY THESE STORY AT THE
7:43 MOMENT BUT U.S. FUTURES LOOKING FLAT TO NEGATIVE.
7:47 STOCKS IN EUROPE LOOKING NEGATIVE AS WELL BUT THAT COMES
7:48 AFTER A RECORD RUN. AS WE CONTINUE TO TALK ABOUT THE
7:54 ROLE EUROPE PLAYS. TOM: LET'S TALK ABOUT THAT.
7:59 EUROPEAN GAS FUTURES, MAY BE IS THE HEADWIND.
8:02 YOU ARE BACK TO 95 RIGHT NOW VON DUTCH FUTURES, UP ABOUT 13% THE
8:04 LAST THREE DAYS. IT WAS NOT THAT LONG AGO THAT
8:10 YOU WERE CLOSER TO 80, SO THAT MOVE HIGHER WILL BE SOME
8:13 INVESTORS WILL BE TAKING ON BOARD AS WE LOOK AT HIGHER
8:14 ENERGY TODAY. ANNA: LET'S TELL YOU ABOUT SOME
8:18 OF THE THINGS COMING UP ON FRIDAYS PROGRAM.
8:23 THE CHIEF U.S. EQUITY STRATEGIST.
8:28 IING'S GLOBAL HEAD OF RESEARCH WILL BE ON, BOTH OF WHOM HAVE
8:33 NVIDIA. ITALIA LIPKHINA WILL BE WITH
8:39 US. HOW WILL THEY PERFORM IN THE
8:43 CONTEXT OF THE LATEST IN THE AI TRADE?
8:47 TOM: LET'S LOOK AT WHAT ELSE WE ARE WATCHING.
8:50 EU LEADERS GATHERING FOR AN INFORMAL SUMMIT IN DUBLIN.
8:56 9:00 A.M. U.K. TIME, THE IEA OIL MARKET REPORT.
8:59 EVIDENCE THAT FLOWS THROUGH THE STRAIT OF HORMUZ HAVE INCREASED.
9:01 U.S. PRODUCER PRICES. AN IMPORTANT GAUGE IN TERMS OF
9:04 THE INFLATION STORY. 4:00 P.M. U.K. TIME, ECB WILL BE
9:11 SPEAKING AT THE BANKING CONFERENCE IN MUNICH.
9:18 LATER, DA RIORIO AMODEI WILL BE JOINED BY JAMIE DIMON AT THE
9:21 COMPANY'S IP A LIVE-STREAMED EVENT.
9:23 ANNA: EU LEADERS GATHER IN IRELAND WITH UKRAINE AND ECB
9:27 SUCCESSION AT THE TOP OF THE AGENDA.
9:31 WE GET AN UPDATE AS EUROPEAN LEADERS GET READY FOR DAY TWO
9:32 FROM THAT SUMMIT. PLUS, WE WILL LOOK AT THE STOCKS
9:37 TO WATCH, INCLUDING RICHEMONT. REPORTING SALES THAT BEAT
9:40 ESTIMATES. RESULTS DELAYED FOR A LITTLE BIT
9:43 BY SOME OF THE ISSUES AROUND MICROSOFT WHICH WE WILL ALSO
9:46 TALK ABOUT LATER. NEXT, WE WILL RETURN TO THE BIG
9:49 STORY OF THE WEEK. JENSEN HUANG OUSTED AS NVIDIA
9:52 CEO. WHAT DOES THAT MEAN FOR
9:54 INVESTORS? IF YOU HAVE ANY QUESTIONS AND
9:58 WANT TO GET INVOLVED IN ANY OF THESE QUESTIONS.
10:02 IT IS A BEAUTIFUL SUNRISE IN LONDON.
10:03 THIS IS BLOOMBERG.
10:22 >> MISSED PROBABLY HAS THE MOST VALUABLE IP ON THE -- NVIDIA
10:26 PROBABLY HAS THE MOST VALUABLE IP ON THE PLANET.
10:27 THE VISION OF NVIDIA WILL BE CALLED INTO QUESTION.
10:30 >> WE HAVE TO VIEW THIS AS A TRANSITIONAL ISSUE AND A BIT
10:32 MORE TACTICAL IN NATURE. >> IS THE AI TRADE ONE MAN OR IS
10:37 IT A COMPANY THAT IS, YOU KNOW, KIND OF LEADING THE CHARGE ON A
10:42 RELATIVE BASIS? >> ESSENTIALLY USING SOMEONE WHO
10:45 CAN BRING TOGETHER ALL THE PARTIES.
10:48 >> I ULTIMATELY THINK THAT WE WILL MOVE FORWARD.
10:50 THAT THE UNDERLYING -- THIS ONCE IN A GENERATION INNOVATION WILL
10:54 CARRY THROUGH. >> INVESTORS WERE SHOCKED BY
10:57 JENSEN LEAVING. BUT COLETTE KRESS IS THE HAND
11:01 THAT WALL STREET TRUSTS AND SUBCOMMITTEE IS THE RIGHT PICK
11:05 FOR AN INTERIM CEO. AND SHE'S GOING TO HAVE A LOT OF
11:11 WORK ON HER HANDS. TOM: SOME OF BLOOMBERG'S GUESTS
11:14 REACTING TO NEWS THAT JENSEN HUANG RESIGNING AS NVIDIA CEO
11:18 AND WHAT MIGHT COME NEXT FOR THE COMPANY.
11:19 ANNA: YES. JOINING US NOW TO GIVE HIS
11:22 THOUGHTS MANISH KABRA, CHIEF U.S. EQUITY STRATEGIST AT
11:25 SOCIETE GENERALE. NICE TO HAVE YOU ON THE PROGRAM.
11:28 WE HEARD ONE OF THE GUESTS REFERRING TO NVIDIA AS A
11:30 TRANSITIONAL ISSUE. ARE YOU CLEAR WHAT WE ARE
11:32 TRANSITIONING TO? WHAT DOES THIS MEAN TO YOU?
11:35 THIS WEEK'S EVENTS? MANISH: I THINK IT MEANS QUITE A
11:39 LOT FOR THE ROTATION TRADE IN THE MARKET.
11:44 YOU TRY TO SEE EXACTLY WHAT WE HAD THIS WEEK.
11:47 $500 BILLION OUT OF ONE COMPANY. BUT $650 BILLION ADDED INTO ALL
11:51 THE OTHER SEMICONDUCTORS ACROSS THE SPACE.
11:55 SO I THINK THE ROTATION, THE BROADENING, THE MESSAGE THAT WE
11:59 SEE ACROSS THE U.S. WHERE YOUR BEST PERFORMING INDEX HERE TO
12:02 DATE HAS BEEN EQUAL WEIGHT S&P 500.
12:04 I THINK THERE'S A CHANGE OF LEADERSHIP WITHIN THE INDEX
12:06 ITSELF. ANNA: OK.
12:09 DOES THIS NECESSARILY MEAN THAT NVIDIA TAKES A STEP BACK AND
12:13 DOESN'T DO -- DOESN'T DO AS WELL FROM HERE?
12:16 OR IS IT TOO SOON TO MAKE EVEN THAT KIND OF CONCLUSION?
12:21 MANISH: TO TAKE FROM ANALYSTS LET THE DUST SETTLE.
12:24 I THINK THAT DUST SETTLING PHASE OF THE MARKET MAKES EVERYTHING
12:29 ELSE, THE MACRO, THE FED, THE OUTLOOK FOR AI CAPEX, AND ALL OF
12:34 THOSE THINGS BECOME CRUCIAL. MORE -- AND IN THIS LAST TWO
12:37 WEEKS OF VOLATILITY THAT WE HAVE SEEN IN THE U.S. STOCKS, AND
12:42 U.S. TECH, WHAT'S GOT MISSED OUT IS THE FIRST ORDER PRINCIPLE OF
12:48 WHY IS IT WE ARE HAVING THIS AI CAPEX AI ECOSYSTEM?
12:52 ULTIMATELY, THERE'S DEMAND FOR AI.
12:55 SO EVERY QUARTER WE LOOK AT THE CLOUD REVENUE GROWTH OF EVERY
12:57 HYPERSCALER. WE LOOK AT CLOUD BACKLOG OF
13:01 EVERY HYPERSCALER THAT'S GONE FROM -- START OF THE YEAR IT WAS
13:06 $1.5 TRILLION AND GONE TO $2.5 TRILLION.
13:08 I THINK THAT CONVICTION FROM HYPERSCALERS IS WHAT IS FEEDING
13:13 INTO THE -- THE AI CAPEX PART. TOM: THE DUST SETTLES.
13:15 THE ISSUE IS THE DUST IS GOING TO TAKE QUITE A LONG TIME FOR
13:18 THE DUST TO SETTLE ARGUABLY. THERE WILL BE AN INVESTIGATION
13:22 ON THE HILL, COMMITTEE HEARINGS. WITH IT -- JENSEN BUT MAYBE
13:25 OTHER EXECUTIVES AT NVIDIA. THIS COULD TAKE A LONG TIME TO
13:27 PLAY OUT. SO IN THE MEANTIME, DO YOU -- DO
13:30 YOU NEED TO SEE THAT DUST SETTLE BEFORE YOU WANT TO TAKE A BIGGER
13:33 STAKE IN SOME OF THESE SEMI NAMES OR WHAT'S THE STRATEGY
13:37 UNTIL WE GET REAL CLARITY? MANISH: YEAH.
13:40 LET'S TAKE -- FOR MACRO INVESTORS, THEY'RE LOOKING AT IF
13:44 WE ARE LOOKING BEYOND AI CAPEX, AND WHAT ARE THE OTHER PARTS OF
13:47 THE MARKET, IS IT CONSUMER, IS IT INDUSTRIAL?
13:50 WHAT -- IS IT POWER CYCLE? THOSE ARE A LOT OF DIFFERENT
13:54 PARTS OF THE MARKET WHICH EQUAL WEIGHT S&P GETS YOU INTO.
13:59 IF YOU PURELY TALK ABOUT AI CAPEX, AND THE WHOLE AI EKE STOW
14:04 SYSTEM WE HAVE SPLIT -- ECOSYSTEM WE HAVE SPLIT IT INTO
14:06 THREE PARTS. THE COMPANIES TRYING TO FIND
14:07 PRODUCTIVITY AND THE COMPANIES TRYING TO SELL AI PRODUCTS AND
14:12 THOSE ARE THE MONETIZERS AND THE COMPANIES LINKED TO THE BUILDING
14:15 OF AI CAPEX CYCLE. SO OUR TAKE FOR 2027 AND WE ARE
14:21 WAY MORE FOCUSED ON MONETIZERS AND PRODUCTIVITY BENEFICIARIES
14:24 WHICH SELL AI AND USE AI RATHER THAN BUILD AI.
14:28 BUT STAYING ON SEMIS, SEMIS HISTORICALLY ARE ALWAYS A YO-YO
14:30 INDEX. IT GOES UP A LOT.
14:34 IT COMES DOWN A LOT. AND HISTORICALLY, AND THIS IS
14:37 WATCHING MID 1990'S AND THROUGHOUT 2000, THE MOMENT FED
14:44 SAYS THE LAST FED HIKE DELIVERY MARKS THE BOTTOM OF SEMI CYCLES.
14:49 SO WE ARE SEEING Q1 NEXT YEAR IS THE PEAK HAWKISHNESS FROM THE
14:51 FED AND THAT WOULD BE THE CLEANEST WAY OR CLEANEST TIMING
14:54 TO POSITION FOR THE SEMICONDUCTORS.
14:55 TOM: INTERESTING. THERE'S A LOT TO UNPACK THERE.
14:58 JUST MEDITATE ON ONE POINT WHICH IS YOU DON'T THINK THE
15:01 CYCLICALITY AROUND THE SEMICONDUCTOR STORY HAS GONE?
15:04 THAT'S STILL A FACTOR FOR THIS SECTOR?
15:05 MANISH: I THINK SO. AND THAT GOES BACK ONTO THE
15:10 THINKING HOW MANY COMPANIES WANT TO ADOPT AI.
15:13 AND THEY -- THE CONVICTION TO ADOPT AI IS FEEDING INTO
15:18 HYPERSCALERS, IT'S FEEDING INTO FRONTIER LABS AND THAT'S WHAT
15:21 BACKWARD FEEDS INTO AI CAPEX CYCLE.
15:24 I THINK THE -- THE FEEDBACK FROM S&P 500 OUTSIDE THE TECH SECTOR
15:28 IS STILL WE WANT TO ADOPT AI AND NOT IGNORE IT.
15:31 ANNA: SO YOU TALKED ABOUT THE FED AND WHEN THE FED DOES ITS
15:35 LAST HIKE, MANISH, BUT IN THE MARKETS WE ALSO LOOK AT THE
15:39 RATES ON TREASURIES AND YOU GOT A NICE LITTLE CHEAT SHEET FOR US
15:44 TO WORK OUT WHERE -- WHERE THESE TREASURY RATES BECOME
15:46 RESTRICTIVE. YOU SAY IF WE HAVE A 4% ON THE
15:49 U.S. 10-YEAR, I THINK THIS IS ON THE U.S. 10-YEAR, AND THAT'S
15:52 GREEN. AI, YOU KNOW, CARRY ON.
15:56 AND AMBER IS AROUND 5%. AND 6% IS RED.
15:58 MANISH: YEAH. ANNA: THAT'S WHAT WE NEED TO
16:01 WATCH IS THAT LINE BETWEEN 5% AND 6% THAT DICTATES WHETHER
16:04 THIS TRADE CONTINUES, IS IT? MANISH: SO THE BOND MARKET IS
16:06 DOING THE JOB. WHICH IS DEFINING THE SPEED OF
16:09 THE BULL MARKET AND DEFINING LITERALLY LIKE A TRAFFIC LIGHT
16:15 SIGNAL WHICH IS HOW DO WE CREATE THEN ESCAPE VELOCITY FOR THE AI
16:18 ECOSYSTEM? ARE WE READY TO BUY HYPERSCALERS
16:21 AND SEMIS TOGETHER? WHICH MARKET HAS NOT DONE THAT
16:23 THIS YEAR. AND I THINK TO GET INTO THE IDEA
16:30 OF VELOCITY OF AI ECOSYSTEM WE NEED MUCH LOWER YIELDS AND
16:33 YIELDS LOWER THAN 4% AND YIELDS NEAR 5% WHICH IS WHAT OUR TAKE
16:36 IS A GRIND HIGHER FOR THE INDEX RATHER THAN EXTREMELY BULLISH.
16:40 TOM: GRIND HIGHER. 5.11% ON THE BENCHMARK 10-YEAR.
16:45 THE FINANCING, POSIT AN IDEA TO YOU.
16:47 COLETTE KRESS IS MAYBE MORE CONSERVATIVE IN TERMS OF
16:49 NVIDIA'S FINANCING FOR THE AI ECOSYSTEM AND THE DEMOCRATS
16:52 PUTTING IN PLACE SOME RESTRICTIONS AROUND DATA CENTER
16:54 BUILDOUT. IS THAT -- IS THAT A -- AN
16:59 EXISTENTIAL RISK FOR THE AI TRADE OR DOES IT MAKE THE WHOLE
17:02 AI ECOSYSTEM RATIONALIZE AND EXTEND OUT FURTHER?
17:05 MANISH: SO WE DEFINITELY TAKE OUT THE SPECULATIVE PART OF THE
17:07 BUILDOUT. AND WHICH IS VERY IMPORTANT.
17:11 WE DON'T WANT TO BUILD EXCESS CAPACITY.
17:13 THE BEARS WHO WE SPEAK WITH IN THE MARKET FOR THEM THE BIGGEST
17:16 FEAR ARE WE ACTUALLY OVERBUILDING DATA CENTERS?
17:20 AS AGAINST THE MESSAGE FROM HYPERSCALERS IS WE ARE STILL
17:23 VERY SHORT OF COMPUTE. AND I THINK THAT -- THAT TEST IS
17:28 GOING TO LET US GO AFTER EVERY ELECTION AND ALL THE STATES HAVE
17:30 THEIR OWN VIEW AND ALL THE STATES WILL COME OUT WITH THEIR
17:34 OWN -- WAY OF APPROACHING THINGS.
17:36 BUT IT'S NOT A MACRO WAY OF SAYING THIS IS A DOWNTURN OF THE
17:39 AI CAPEX CYCLE. ANNA: SO MANISH, THE LAST COUPLE
17:41 OF WEEKS, DO YOU THINK THE MARKETS HAVE DIGESTED THE
17:44 MESSAGE THAT THE DATA CENTER ROLLOUT WILL BE SLOWER?
17:48 AND WE'VE SEEN -- IT'S PRICED NOW OR DO YOU THINK THAT PRICING
17:50 IS STILL TO COME? WE'VE SEEN A KIND OF REMARKABLY
17:53 LITTLE NEGATIVE FALLOUT IF THAT IS THE MESSAGE THAT WE HAVE
17:57 REALLY HEARD. MANISH: THAT'S RIGHT.
17:59 SO S&P IS SLIGHTLY UP SINCE ELECTION DAY.
18:02 DESPITE THE VOL. EVEN SEMICONDUCTORS ARE BARELY
18:07 DOWN 1% DESPITE ALL THE MOVEMENT THAT HAVE HAPPENED.
18:10 SO AS THE MARKET THAT WAS ALREADY DISCOUNTING A SLOWDOWN
18:13 OF THE AI CAPEX CYCLE, WHERE SLOWDOWN HAS NOT EVEN STARTED.
18:16 ANNA: SO SLOWER CAN BE BETTER DO WE THINK?
18:19 MANISH: I THINK IT'S VERY IMPORTANT TO HAVE THIS SECONDARY
18:23 RATE OF SLOWDOWN SO OTHER PARTS OF THE MARKET FEEL SOME LOVE.
18:25 TOM: CAN WE THINK ABOUT OTHER PARTS OF THE MARKET?
18:29 U.S. EQUITY STRATEGY AND LET'S ACKNOWLEDGE THAT.
18:30 BUT WE HAVE SEEN EUROPEAN STOCKS HIT A RALLY, HIT A RECORD THIS
18:35 WEEK AND PARTLY IT SEEMS BECAUSE THEY'RE PROVIDING AN
18:38 ALTERNATIVE. ARE YOU HEARING FROM CLIENTS AND
18:40 INVESTORS? ARE THEY TURNING TO EUROPE?
18:43 DO YOU THIS I THAT EXTENDS HOW YOU THINK ABOUT EUROPEAN
18:44 EQUITIES? MANISH: AS IN EUROPE, OUR TAKE
18:50 IS 20% OF DATA CENTERS AROUND THE WORLD WILL BE BASED IN
18:51 EUROPE. AS IN THE KIND OF COMPANIES THAT
18:55 ARE PRICED THIS WEEK, THEY'RE STILL LINKED TO THE DATA CENTER
18:57 CAPEX CYCLE. SO I THINK EUROPE BENEFITS FROM
18:59 THE DATA CENTER CAPEX. THEN I TRY TO LOOK AT WHAT WE
19:03 HAD YESTERDAY. THE EARLY STAFFING COMPANIES.
19:06 THEY ALSO PRICED ON THE UPSIDE AS IN THE MESSAGE WAS VERY
19:09 CLEAR, THE DEVELOPED MARKET, LABOR CYCLE, IS STILL THERE,
19:12 TEMPORARY STAFFING IS STILL THERE.
19:14 THE MOMENT YOU HAVE THOSE KIND OF CONVICTION, WE DO GET THESE
19:18 GROWTH INFLECTION POINTS IN EUROPE AS WELL.
19:20 ANNA: WHAT DID YOU MAKE OF THAT? WE WERE TALKING SO MUCH ABOUT
19:23 NVIDIA YESTERDAY AND THAT ONE MAN'S JOB.
19:25 WE DIDN'T TALK ABOUT THAT OTHER STORY WHICH WAS YES, TEMPORARY
19:28 STAFFING COMPANIES WITH POSITIVE RESULTS.
19:30 I MEAN, WE HAVE ALL BEEN REALLY WORRIED ABOUT WHAT AI DOES TO
19:34 THE JOB MARKET. SHOULDN'T BE MAYBE.
19:37 OR YET. MANISH: WELL, I THINK THE -- THE
19:42 ULTIMATE IS WATCHING THE S&P 500, WATCHING HOW MUCH REVENUES
19:44 COMPANIES ARE MAKING AND HOW MUCH PROFIT MARGINS COMPANIES
19:46 ARE MAKING. WITH EXISTING NUMBER OF
19:48 EMPLOYEES. I THINK THAT'S QUITE STUNNING.
19:51 ALTHOUGH THOSE NUMBERS -- ALL-TIME HIGHS, SEVEN OUT OF 10
19:55 SECTORS ARE SHOWING EXTREME RETURNS.
19:56 ANNA: THANK YOU SO MUCH FOR JOINING US.
20:00 MANISH KABRA, CHIEF U.S. EQUITY STRATEGIST AT SOCIETE GENERALE
20:01 CIB. TOM: WHAT YOU NEED TO KNOW THIS
20:03 MORNING. VLADIMIR ZELENSKY SAYS PROGRESS
20:06 HAS BEEN MADE DURING A MEETING WITH U.S. ENVOY STEVE WITKOFF
20:10 AND JARED CUSHNER IN IRELAND. HE HAS WELCOMED A PRISONER OF
20:13 WAR EXCHANGE DEAL. AND A DECISION TO INCLUDE
20:16 EUROPEANS IN THE NEXT ROUND OF PEACE TALKS WITH RUSSIA.
20:18 THE MEETING TOOK PLACE HOURS AFTER WITKOFF AND CUSHNER MET
20:24 PRESIDENT VLADIMIR PUTIN IN MOSCOW.
20:26 >> OUR GROUPS WILL HAVE A NEW MEETING AND WE DECIDED IT WILL
20:33 WORK ON AN AGENDA. SOME KIND OF CEASEFIRE.
20:37 SOME KIND OF OF -- AND HOPE IT WILL HELP.
20:43 THE AGENDA, YES. TOM: SPACEX AND TESLA ARE
20:46 PROGRESSING IN NEGOTIATIONS TOWARD A MERGER THAT COULD
20:48 REDEFINE THE LIMITS OF GLOBAL DEAL MAKING.
20:52 BLOOMBERG HAS LEARNED THAT ELON MEASURING'S TWO LARGEST
20:53 COMPANIES COULD ANNOUNCE WHAT WOULD BE THE BIGGEST-EVER DEAL
20:57 AS SOON AS DECEMBER. THE COMPANIES ARE ALSO SAID TO
21:00 HAVE DISCUSSED A SCENARIO IN WHICH AN ANNOUNCEMENT SLIPS INTO
21:04 EARLY 2027. AND MICROSOFT IS STRUGGLING TO
21:08 RESTORE SOME OF ITS BIGGEST SERVICES MORE THAN NINE HOURS
21:11 AFTER AN OUTAGE BEGAN. OUTLOOK TEAMS AND CO-PILOT WERE
21:14 UNAVAILABLE FOR SOME USERS FOR MOST OF THE U.S. WORK DAY.
21:18 WITH THE COMPANY SAYING A CORE PROCESS ON AFFECTED SERVERS WAS
21:23 BECOMING OVERWHELMED. THIS IS HAVING HUGE IMPACTS TO
21:26 THE POINT, ANNA, WHERE SOME COMPANIES HAVE HAD TO DELAY AND
21:28 SUSPEND THEIR EARNINGS RELEASES BECAUSE THEY CAN'T GET THEIR
21:31 EMAILS OUT AND CAN'T GET THEIR SOFTWARE SYSTEMS WORKING.
21:33 BECAUSE THESE ARE CORE PARTS OF THE MICROSOFT SOFTWARE
21:35 OFFERINGS. THAT ARE -- THAT ARE OUT FOR IT
21:39 SEEMS TENS OF THOUSANDS IF NOT HUNCH THOUSANDS OF CUSTOMERS.
21:41 ANNA: YEAH. ABSOLUTELY.
21:42 SO YOU CAN LOOK AT GOVERNMENTS BEING AFFECTED AND YOU CAN LOOK
21:45 AT COMPANIES AND SO FAR WE HAD A DELAY ON THE RICHEMONT EARNINGS
21:48 AND THEY CAME OUT IN THE END. BUT WE DID GET A BIT OF A DELAY
21:51 THERE. AND EURONEXT EMAIL
21:53 COMMUNICATIONS WERE UNAVAILABLE DUE TO MICROSOFT OUTAGE.
21:56 JUST READING IN OUR COVERAGE THAT IN JAPAN, THE GOVERNMENT
22:00 SHARED IT PLATFORM ALSO EXPERIENCED DISRUPTIONS.
22:03 WE'VE SORT OF BEEN HERE BEFORE IN THE SENSE THAT WHENEVER YOU
22:07 SEE THESE LARGE PLAYERS, WITHIN THE TECH LANDSCAPE, THEIR
22:11 SERVICES UNAVAILABLE, THEY JUST -- THEY SERVICE SO MANY
22:12 BUSINESSES. THAT IT HAS REACH.
22:15 THE STORY HAS REACH. TOM: THIS HAS BEEN DESCRIBED AS
22:17 ONE OF THE MOST SEVERE DISRUPTIONS FOR MICROSOFT.
22:19 EVER. SO YOU'RE TALKING OUTLOOK TEAMS.
22:21 CO-PILOT. IS WORTH NOTING THAT THERE IS A
22:24 LINE HERE. MICROSOFT SAYING THEY ARE NOT
22:26 AWARE OF MALICIOUS ACTIVITY. BUT WE CONTINUE TO MONITOR THAT
22:29 STORY FOR YOU. ANNA: OK.
22:31 COMING UP ON THE PROGRAM, THE FALLOUT FROM THE NVIDIA SCANDAL
22:33 CONTINUES TO DOMINATE THE HEADLINES, WE WILL TAKE A LOOK
22:36 AT WHAT IT COULD MEAN FOR EUROPE.
22:39 ING'S CHIEF ECONOMIST AND GLOBAL HEAD OF RESEARCH MARK CRANFIELD MARIEKE BLOM
22:45 WILL BE WITH US AND THE INITIAL IMPACT OF THIS WEIGHING ON THE
22:47 ASML SHARE PRICE. AND ABOUT COMPANY SPECIFICS, IS
22:50 IT ABOUT THE GLOBAL CHIP TRADE? WE'LL TALK ABOUT THAT NEXT.
23:10 ANNA: WELCOME BACK.
23:13 THIS IS THE OPENING TRADE. THIS IS THE PICTURE ON THE
23:18 EUROPEAN FUTURES FOR EQUITIES THIS MORNING.
23:22 WE ARE EXPECTING TO RETREAT A LITTLE.
23:25 EURO STOXX 50 FUTURES DOWN 0.3%. THAT SEEMED TO IMPROVE SLIGHTLY
23:28 FROM A HALF-HOUR AGO. NASDAQ FUTURES ALSO IMPROVING A
23:31 LITTLE, VERY MUCH MORE FLAT THAN THEY WERE.
23:34 BOND MARKET SAW SOME BIG MOVES YESTERDAY ON THE BACK OF THAT
23:36 HIGHER OIL PRICE. TOM: HAWKISH COMMENTARY FROM OIL
23:40 OFFICIALS. BRENT UP 0.3% SO FAR IN THE
23:47 SESSION. PRODUCER PRICES OUT OF THE U.S.
23:51 LATER. YOU'RE SEEING RELATIVE STABILITY
23:54 IN EUROPEAN SOVEREIGN DEBT RIGHT NOW.
23:56 A LITTLE HIGH IN TERMS OF YIELDS ON THE GERMAN BENCHMARK AND A
23:58 SIMILAR PICTURE IN ITALY AND FRANCE.
24:02 BUT NOTHING TOO DRAMATIC. BOND YIELDS MOVING A LITTLE
24:05 HIGHER BETWEEN ONE TO TWO BASIS POINTS.
24:07 MEANWHILE, FALLOUT FROM THE NVIDIA SCANDAL HAS WEIGHED ON
24:10 SENTIMENT ON EUROPEAN SHIP NAMES THIS MORNING, SEEING FALLING
24:18 TREE OPEN AMID CONCERN OVER WHAT FURTHER EXPORT RESTRICTIONS ON
24:21 THE COMPANY COULD MEAN FOR NAMES LIKE ASML THE BROADER EUROPEAN
24:25 TECH SECTOR. LET'S BRING IN MARIEKE BLOM,
24:30 CHIEF ECONOMIST ING, FOR SOME INSIGHTS ON THIS.
24:36 FIRST OF ALL, YOUR REACTION TO WHAT WE'VE HEARD FROM NVIDIA,
24:39 THE DOWNFALL OF JENSEN HUANG, AND WHAT IT COULD MEAN FOR THE
24:42 EUROPEAN SHIP SPACE WITH THE LIKES OF LITHOGRAPHY MAKER ASML
24:44 IN FOCUS? MARIEKE: IF YOU LOOK AT THE
24:52 EUROPEAN SHIP SPACE, I THINK THE MOST IMPORTANT QUESTION THAT IS
24:56 NOW EMERGING IS ABOUT THE FUTURE RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN THE U.S.
24:57 AND CHINA. OF COURSE, THERE IS A LOT MORE
25:01 UNCERTAINTY WHEN IT COMES TO THAT, WHICH IS NOT JUST ON THE
25:07 BACK OF THE NVIDIA SCANDAL, BUT IT IS ALSO BECAUSE WE HAVE A
25:09 DEMOCRATIC SENATE NOW. TYPICALLY DEMOCRATS TEND TO BE
25:18 MORE HAWKISH ON CHINA IN A CONCERTED WAY, WHERE THEY WANT
25:20 TO WORK WITH THEIR ALLIES AGAINST CHINA.
25:24 WHAT THAT COULD MEAN FOR A COMPANY SUCH AS ASML IS ITS
25:28 BUSINESS WITH CHINA WOULD BE RESTRICTED AS A CONSEQUENCE.
25:31 OF COURSE, THAT IS A RISK THAT IS RUNNING OVER THE COMPANY, AND
25:38 IT IS A RISK LOOMING OVER THE DUTCH ECONOMY, WHERE THE COMPANY
25:43 HAS BECOME MORE RELEVANT. THERE IS A NUANCE TO IT, THOUGH,
25:48 BECAUSE SHORT TERM ASL'S ORDER BOOKS ARE MORE THAN FULL, FULL
25:52 TO THE EXTENT THAT THEY PROBABLY CANNOT FULLY DELIVER TO THEM.
25:56 IN A SENSE, YOU WOULD SAY SHORT-TERM THERE IS A BIT OF A
26:00 PUSHING THERE, BUT LONGER TERM THIS IS A VERY CRUCIAL MATTER
26:04 FOR A COMPANY, WHETHER OR NOT IT CAN KEEP DOING BUSINESS WITH
26:05 CHINA. TOM: THAT IS REALLY INTERESTING,
26:09 THE POINT YOU MAKE ABOUT THE ORDER BOOK AT THE BACKLOG FOR
26:13 ASML IS SALIENT AS WE REAL -- WAY OUT THESE RISKS TO THE
26:14 COMPANY. MAYBE MORE ON THE ASML PIECE,
26:21 WHAT IS THE ABILITY FOR THE COMPANY TO ADJUST AROUND FOR THE
26:24 RESTRICTIONS? HOW DEPENDENT IS IT FOR ITS DO
26:32 YOU V -- DUV'S FOR THE CHINA MARKET?
26:35 MARIEKE: WHAT YOU HAVE SEEN IS IN THE SHARES TOTALS, THE SHARE
26:39 FOR CHINA HAS BEEN COMING DOWN OVER TIME.
26:43 A COUPLE YEARS, IT WAS 40%, THEN IT CAME DOWN TO 33%, AND NOW IT
26:46 IS ESTIMATED TO BE ABOUT 20%. BUT I THINK THE LONGER-TERM
26:53 QUESTION IS FOR ASML MAY BE A BIT LESS ABOUT THE DIRECT SALES
26:55 TO CHINA. IT IS MUCH MORE SIMILAR TO WHAT
27:01 NVIDIA, WHAT JENSEN HUANG WAS WARNING FOR.
27:04 WILL THERE BE A CHINESE ALTERNATIVE TO WHAT THEY ARE
27:05 DOING? TO WHAT DEGREE WILL CHINA BE
27:11 ABLE TO COME UP WITH SOMETHING THAT BASICALLY MAKES THEIR
27:14 MACHINES LESS RELEVANT, BOTH WITHIN CHINA AND FOR THE REST OF
27:17 THE WORLD. I THINK THAT IS THE MOST CRUCIAL
27:18 QUESTION FOR THEM. ANNA: AND WHAT DOES CHINESE
27:23 COMPETITION TO ASML LOOK LIKE AT THIS POINT?
27:31 MARIEKE: SO FAR, IT IS A MONOPOLY.
27:33 IN THAT SENSE, THERE IS VERY LIMITED COMPETITION FROM CHINA.
27:37 THIS IS MUCH MORE OF A LONGER-TERM QUESTION.
27:42 LONGER-TERM, THE QUESTION IS, WILL THEY BE ABLE TO COMPLETE
27:47 WITH THE VERY FAST CHIPS. THESE EXTENSIONS ARE ANOTHER
27:51 REASON TO LOOK FOR ALTERNATIVES. ON THE OTHER HAND, IT WILL GIVE
27:59 YET ANOTHER IMPULSE TO THE U.S. WHO WANT TO RAMP UP TO
28:02 PRODUCTION TO BE AS INDEPENDENT AS POSSIBLE.
28:05 MAYBE ASML WILL SEE FASTER GROWTH ON THAT SIDE OF THE
28:09 ATLANTIC AS A CONSEQUENCE OF ALL THIS.
28:14 AGAIN, SHORTER-TERM, THIS IS PROBABLY LESS OF A NEGATIVE FOR
28:18 ASML, BUT LONGER-TERM MAY BE A QUESTION.
28:24 ANNA: WHAT DOES IT MAKE FOR THE DUTCH ECONOMY?
28:28 WE HAVE SEEN TENSIONS BETWEEN THE NETHERLANDS AND THE UNITED
28:30 STATES AS A RESULT OF CHIP CURVES IN THE PAST.
28:33 GIVE US SOME SIZE AND SCOPE ON IF THIS DOES HURT IN THE LONGER
28:39 TERM, AS YOU DESCRIBE, ASML AND THE WIDER CHIP SPACE?
28:42 WHAT DOES THAT DO TO THE DUTCH ECONOMY?
28:48 MARIEKE: THE NETHERLANDS IS PRETTY SPECIAL WHEN IT IS
28:50 COMPARING ITSELF TO THE REST OF EUROPE.
28:53 THE WHOLE CHIPS WAVE IS NOT REALLY HAPPENING WITHIN EUROPE,
28:55 EXCEPT FOR IN THE NETHERLANDS. WE HAVE LOOKED AT THE IMPACT
29:03 ASML HAS ON OUR ECONOMY, THE DUTCH ECONOMY, AND WE ESTIMATE
29:05 ITS BROADER ECOSYSTEM IS CURRENTLY ABOUT 2.2% OF GDP, SO
29:11 THAT IS SIGNIFICANT. OF COURSE, IT HAS BEEN GROWING
29:14 VERY FAST OVER THE LAST COUPLE YEARS.
29:23 SOME 0.3, 0.4% GROWTH COULD COME FROM ASML, AND COULD BE COMING
29:26 FROM ASML IN THE YEARS TO COME. WE HAVE BEEN REVISING GROWTH
29:29 FORECASTS UPWARDS WHEN WE WERE SAYING THEIR REVENUE FORECASTS
29:35 WERE GOING UP. SO, THIS IS PRETTY SIGNIFICANT.
29:39 WHAT WE'VE SAID IS, COULD THIS BECOME ANOTHER NOKIA?
29:44 PROBABLY NOT BECAUSE THE DUTCH ECONOMY IS MUCH MORE BROADER AND
29:46 SMALLER THAN NOKIA USED TO BE. IN FINLAND, IT WAS ABOUT FOUR
29:51 PERCENT OF THE ECONOMY. BUT OF COURSE, IT IS DEFINITELY
29:53 SOMETHING THAT MATTERS. WE KNOW THAT BASICALLY WE SEE
29:58 THE ECONOMIC WAVES GOING THROUGH THE ECOSYSTEM, AND THEREFORE
30:01 ALSO THROUGH THE DUTCH ECONOMY AT MOMENTS IN TIME.
30:05 AGAIN, LOOKING FORWARD FOR THE NEXT COUPLE OF YEARS, WHICH IS
30:10 FORECASTING. WE BELIEVE THERE IS STILL MORE
30:16 DEMAND FOR THE MACHINES AND THEY CAN SUPPLY.
30:23 TOM: MORE BROADLY ACROSS THE EUROPEAN TECH SPACE, WHEN WE
30:25 THINK ABOUT SCHNEIDER ELECTRIC OR SIEMENS, PART OF THE
30:31 CONVERSATION WAS ABOUT ZIEMANN'S PARTNERSHIP WITH NVIDIA.
30:37 IS THERE POTENTIAL MATERIAL IF NVIDIA UNDER COLETTE KRESS
30:39 STARTS TO PULL BACK ON THE SPENDING AND FUNDING THAT NVIDIA
30:42 HAS UP UNTIL THIS DATE PROVIDED FOR THE ECOSYSTEM?
30:45 MARIEKE: OF COURSE. IT IS OBVIOUS IF THEY HAVE A
30:53 WORKING RELATIONSHIP THAT THIS MAY BE RELEVANT FOR THEM AT SOME
30:55 POINT IN TIME. WE HAVE BEEN LOOKING AT THE
31:00 DEGREE TO WHICH THIS SECTOR AND THE GROWTH IN THE CHIP SECTOR
31:04 HAS BEEN RELEVANT FOR EUROPE. ASML, I JUST MENTIONED.
31:08 BUT IF YOU LOOK AT BROADER EXPORTS TO THE U.S., EUROPE HAS
31:14 BENEFITED MAINLY VIA EVERYTHING RELATED TO POWER GENERATION.
31:18 THAT COULD BE, FOR EXAMPLE, COOLING SYSTEMS, POWER
31:21 GENERATION, THOSE KINDS OF TOOLS.
31:25 AND IN THAT SENSE, EUROPE IS ALSO EXPOSED.
31:27 BUT AGAIN, IT IS ONLY A RELATIVELY LIMITED SHARE OF THE
31:30 EUROPEAN ECONOMY. SO, I DON'T EXPECT TO SEE MUCH
31:32 FALLOUT THERE. I THINK IF WE THINK ABOUT THE
31:38 EUROPEAN ECONOMY IN A MORE BROADER SENSE, IT IS ALL ABOUT
31:42 EUROPE AS A USER OF AI. IT IS EXPECTED TO HAVE THE MOST
31:46 SIGNIFICANT IMPACT. ANNA: THANKS FOR JOINING US.
31:52 ING. ON EUROPEAN POLITICS.
31:56 UKRAINIAN PRESIDENT VOLODYMYR ZELENSKYY SAID PROGRESS HAS BEEN
32:01 MADE DURING A MEETING WITH U.S. ENVOYS THAT TOOK PLACE IN
32:03 IRELAND. ZELENSKYY HELD A PRISONER SWAP
32:08 DEAL AND A DECISION TO INCLUDE EUROPEANS IN THE NEXT ROUND OF
32:10 PEACE TALKS WITH RUSSIA. WE ARE JOINED NOW BY BLOOMBERG'S
32:14 CHIEF EUROPE CORRESPONDENT OLIVER CROOK, WHO IS AT THE EU
32:19 OR EUROPEAN LEADERS SUMMIT IN DUBLIN.
32:21 WHAT IS NEXT FOR PEACE TALKS AFTER THIS POSITIVE MEETING?
32:28 OLIVER: IT IS A REALLY INTERESTING WEEK, AND INTENSE
32:32 SHOW OF DIPLOMACY THAT BEGAN IN ABU DHABI WITH TRILATERAL TALKS
32:34 BETWEEN THE UNITED STATES, UKRAINE, AND RUSSIA, WHICH IS TO
32:37 SAY THAT THAT MEETING WAS SIGNIFICANT BECAUSE IT WAS THE
32:39 FIRST TIME THE UNITED STATES PICKED UP THE EFFORT OF THOSE
32:43 TRILATERAL MEETINGS SINCE THE MONTH OF FEBRUARY.
32:45 THE UNITED STATES HAS BEEN DISTRACTED BY THE WAR IN IRAN.
32:48 BUT NOW THOSE CONVERSATIONS RESUME.
32:54 NO WITKOFF IN CHRISTIAN ARE -- NOW WITKOFF AND KUSHNER HEADED
32:58 TO RUSSIA. THEN THEY CAME OVER HERE TO
33:07 DUBLIN AND HAD A MEETING TO THE -- AT THE MILITARY AIRPORT WITH
33:10 PRESIDENT ZELENSKYY AND A COUPLE OTHER EUROPEANS IN THOSE
33:11 DISCUSSIONS. THE REAL FRUIT OF THOSE
33:16 DISCUSSIONS THIS WEEK IS CONCRETELY THAT PRISONER SWAP,
33:19 MORE THAN 1000 PRISONERS ON EACH SIDE BEING SWAPPED.
33:21 THE SECOND, IT SEEMS THAT FINALLY AFTER YEARS OF THESE
33:25 SORTS OF DISCUSSIONS, THE EUROPEANS HAVE EARNED THEMSELVES
33:29 A SEAT AT THE TABLE. THIS IS SOMETHING THE UKRAINIANS
33:32 AND EUROPEANS HAVE BEEN PUSHING FOR.
33:37 THE AMERICANS WERE RETICENT, THE RUSSIANS WERE AGAINST IT.
33:39 IT SEEMS IN ORDER FOR THERE TO BE A PEACE, EVERYONE AGREES
33:47 EUROPE NEEDS TO HAVE A SEAT AT THE TABLE.
33:48 SO WHO WILL SIT IN IT? IT IS SOMETHING WE HAVE BEEN
33:52 PUSHING IN OUR CONVERSATIONS FOR THE LAST SEVERAL YEARS.
33:55 BUT IF THE NEXT MEETING, IT IS NOT JUST A TRILATERAL MEETING
33:58 BUT A MULTILATERAL MEETING WITH EUROPEANS AT THE TABLE, THAT
34:00 PUTS PRESSURE ON EUROPEAN LEADERS WHO ARE MEETING TODAY TO
34:03 FIGURE OUT WHO SITS AT THAT SEAT.
34:07 TOM: THAT IS SOME ON THEY ARE LOOKING FOR WHEN IT COMES TO
34:10 FOREIGN POLICY. EUROPEANS LOOKING FOR THE NEXT
34:12 HEAD OF THE CENTRAL BANK OF EUROPE, THE ECB.
34:15 HOW MUCH WILL THAT FEATURE AT TODAY'S SUMMIT?
34:23 EUROPEANS. THERE ARE THREE SEATS TO FILL.
34:26 THERE'S THE TRIFECTA OF THE THREE SEATS, THE ECB EXECUTIVE
34:28 BOARD. IT IS A REMINDER THAT LAGARDE IS
34:31 STEPPING DOWN IN FEBRUARY. THERE IS THE MAIN POSITION.
34:35 THERE IS THE CHIEF ECONOMIST AND THE HEAD OF THE MARKETS.
34:37 IN THIS DISCUSSION OF THOSE THREE SEATS, IT SEEMS THERE IS
34:41 PROGRESS BEING MADE. IT SEEMS THAT THE SPANISH
34:46 CANDIDATE IS THE ONE PUSHED FORWARD BY THE FRENCH SIDE
34:49 ACCORDING TO SOME LOCAL REPORTS WITH FRANCE AND POTENTIALLY THE
34:52 GERMANS ARE ALIGNED WITH THAT SORT OF IDEA.
34:54 THE GERMANS HAVE PUSHED BACK AND SAID THEY ARE NOT OFFICIALLY
34:56 THERE BUT THAT IS REPORTING WE HAVE SEEN OUT OF FRANCE.
34:59 THAT WOULD LIBERATE THE QUESTION ABOUT WHO WILL BE THE CHIEF
35:01 ECONOMIST. THAT COULD GO TO THE GERMANS.
35:06 AND THE SEAT CAN THEN GO TO THE FRENCH.
35:08 IN THESE CONVERSATIONS, THERE'S ALWAYS A HUGE AMOUNT OF
35:11 FRUSTRATION. IT SEEMS THEY ARE CONVERGING ON
35:14 THIS IDEA OF GETTING THE THREE SEATS FILLED BY THE END OF THE
35:18 YEAR. THAT IS A DISCUSSION VERY
35:19 ACTIVE. THERE ARE THREE MEETINGS WITH
35:23 ALL THE EUROPEAN LEADERS GET TOGETHER BEFORE THE END OF THE
35:24 YEAR. THEY WOULD LIKE TO CLOSE THOSE
35:27 THREE ASSESSMENTS AND THREE SEATS BEFORE THE END OF THE
35:28 YEAR. ANNA: THANKS VERY MUCH.
35:34 MANY CONVERSATIONS ABOUT MANY SEATS.
35:35 OLIVER CROOK IN DUBLIN. TOM: INVESTORS EYE BIG GAINS
35:40 AHEAD OF ANTHROPIC'S IPO. >> I AM EXCEPTING A ONE POINT $4
35:48 TRILLION VALUATION, SO I AM NOT COMPLAINING ON THAT.
35:51 ONLY THREE COMPANIES. OPENAI AND SPACEX AND ANTHROPIC.
35:58 WE ARE MAKING A FEW BILLION DOLLARS IN PROFITS, SO WE ARE
35:59 HAPPY TO SEE IT. TOM: VERY HAPPY.
36:09 JAWANI SPEAKING TO GUY. WE HAVE MORE ON THE PLANNED
36:12 INDOOR BIG IPO NEXT. THIS IS BLOOMBERG.
36:31 TOM: WELCOME BACK.
36:33 HAPPY FRIDAY. WE ARE 15 MINUTES AWAY A LITTLE
36:35 UNDER 15 MINUTES FROM THE OPENING TRADE AT THIS FRIDAY.
36:38 EUROPEAN FUTURES POINTING DOWN BY .4%.
36:41 SO A LITTLE BIT OF NEGATIVITY BUT THIS IN THE CONTEXT OF A
36:44 RECORD RALLY FOR EUROPEAN STOCKS.
36:46 AND WE SAW THAT YESTERDAY. EUROPEAN STOCKS ENDING THE
36:49 SESSION YESTERDAY AT RECORD HIGHS.
36:50 WE DID. RECORD HIGHS.
36:52 LET'S TALK ABOUT WHERE WE GO ON THESE MARKETS NOW IN THREE
36:55 MINUTES ON THE OPENING TRADE WITH PAUL DOBSON, BLOOMBERG'S
36:58 EXECUTIVE EDITOR FOR ASIA MARKETS AND PAUL, EVERYBODY
37:01 FOCUSED ON NVIDIA I SUPPOSE AND WHAT IT MEANS MORE BROADLY.
37:04 A SENSE PERHAPS FROM SOME OF OUR GUESTS OVERNIGHT AT THAT WE'RE
37:07 IN A KIND OF TRANSITIONAL PHASE WHERE THE MARKETS ARE TRYING TO
37:11 WORK OUT WHAT COMES NEXT. PAUL: YES.
37:13 GOOD MORNING, ANNA. FOR THE TECH STOCK SECTOR THAT'S
37:19 DEFINITELY THE CASE. THE MARKET STARTED OFF EXTREMELY
37:23 LOW IN THE U.S. SESSION FOR NVIDIA.
37:26 AND 14% OR THEREABOUTS AND MANAGED TO COME ALL THE WAY BACK
37:28 TO ABOUT 4% DOWN BY THE END OF THE SESSION.
37:30 A LOT OF RETAIL TRADERS PILING IN THERE.
37:34 FROM OUR REPORTING IT SOUNDS LIKE A LOT OF REST OF THE WORLD
37:37 WAS ALSO INTERESTED IN GETTING BACK INTO IT AFTER SUCH A STEEP
37:39 SELLOFF. SO THAT LEFT U.S. STOCKS NOT ALL
37:42 THAT FAR DOWN, ACTUALLY, ON THE DAY IN ASIA TRADE TO START THE
37:46 DAY POSITIVELY BUT BY THE END THAT HAS SORT OF EBBED AS WELL.
37:49 SO THERE'S UNCERTAINTY OUT THERE.
37:50 WHAT'S IT GOING TO MEAN FOR U.S.-CHINA RELATIONS?
37:53 COULD THERE BE A LITTLE BIT MORE FRICTION AND COULD THERE BE MORE
37:57 GUARD RAILS SET UP TO PREVENT U.S. EXPORTS OF HIGHEST
38:02 TECHNOLOGY CHIPS OVER TO CHINA? THOSE ARE SOME.
38:03 QUESTIONS ON PEOPLE' MINDS OF THE A LOT OF MARKET SEEMS TO BE
38:06 SAYING YEAH, JENSEN HUANG, ANYBODY CAN BE REPLACED
38:09 EVENTUALLY BUT OTHERS ARE SAYING THIS GUY WAS A TALENT SPAN FOR
38:13 THE ENTIRE INDUSTRY AND HE IS GOING TO BE A BIG MISS.
38:16 TOM: AND PAUL, TO SOME EXTENT OR A LARGE EXTENT THE NVIDIA STORY
38:20 AND THE JENSEN STORY HAS OVERSHADOWED FOR VERY GOOD
38:21 REASONS WHAT'S HAPPENING IN THE BOND MARKETS.
38:23 BUT THE BOND MARKET MOVES HAVE BEEN SIZABLE THIS WEEK.
38:25 WE HAD SOME FED COMMENTARY AGAIN THAT'S BEEN HAWKISH AND WE GOT
38:29 PRODUCER PRICES TODAY. PAUL: I'M ALWAYS GOING TO BE
38:34 MORE EXCITED ABOUT THE MOVE IN BONDS THAN THOSE IN INDIVIDUAL
38:37 STOCK COMPANIES. REALLY HUGE JUMP IN TREASURY
38:40 YIELDS OVER THE PAST COUPLE OF DAYS.
38:42 PEOPLE MOVING BACK OUT OF BONDS, AND THIS SORT OF PROCESS,
38:44 THOUGH, WE STARTED WITH PAYROLLS AND THEN THE U.S. INFLATION
38:49 NUMBERS ON THE CPI, THAT WERE HIGH.
38:50 AND THEN THE COMMENTS FROM THE FED'S WALLER AND A WHOLE LOAD OF
38:54 OTHER FOMC SPEAKERS AFTERWARD TALKING ABOUT THE NEED FOR MORE
38:56 HIKES AND TALKING ABOUT THE IDEA THAT U.S. POLICY ISN'T CURRENTLY
38:58 RESTRICTIVE. AND YOU CAN SEE THAT THROUGH THE
39:01 ECONOMIC DATA. CITIGROUP ECONOMIC SURPRISE
39:02 INDEX, THE HIGHEST IN A COUPLE OF YEARS IN THE U.S. AS WELL.
39:06 SO THAT ALL -- THIS IDEA AT THAT WE WILL SEE MORE PRESSURE ON
39:08 BOND MARKETS. WE JUST ABOUT GOT THEM BACK TO
39:11 ZERO. TO FLAT FOR THE YEAR.
39:14 IN THE U.S. TREASURY MARKET. NOW WE'RE DOWN AGAIN AND FEELING
39:16 A LITTLE BIT OF PRESSURE AND A LOT OF PEOPLE ARE TALKING ABOUT
39:19 THE IDEA THAT YIELDS CAN REMAIN UNDER PRESSURE FOR QUITE A GOOD
39:22 LONG TIME. ESPECIALLY WITH THE FED STILL
39:24 HIKING. AND ON THE OTHER HAND THERE'S
39:26 PLENTY OF PEOPLE THAT WANT TO PILE BACK IN AT 5.3%, 5.4%, 5.5%
39:31 ON THE 10-YEAR. ANNA: ARE YOU SEEING KNOCK-ON
39:34 IMPACTS FROM THOSE HIGHER YIELDS, PAUL?
39:38 PAUL: YES. YES.
39:39 ASIA MARKETS A COUPLE OF INTERESTING THINGS TO OBSERVE.
39:43 OFF IN AUSTRALIA, FOR THE FIRST TIME IN OVER A YEAR AUSTRALIAN
39:46 YIELDS ARE NOW BELOW THOSE OF -- THE ONES IN THE U.S.
39:48 WHICH HAS PUSHED THE AUSSIE DOLLAR TO THE WEAKEST LEVEL
39:50 SINCE JANUARY. IN JAPAN, SIMILAR SORT OF THING.
39:53 THE YEN IS WEAKENING IT GOT THROUGH 1 160 AND A COUPLE OF
40:01 TIMES PING PONGED AND HIT A WALL AND CREATING EXTRA VOLATILITY
40:03 MAKING IT MUCH HARDER FOR TRADERS IN JAPAN TO DO IT.
40:05 SO THAT'S SORT OF IMPACT YOU GOT THE DOLLAR AT THE STRONGEST IN
40:08 MORE THAN A YEAR IS RIPPLING BACK ACROSS THE GLOBAL MARKET
40:12 COMPLEX AS WELL. TOM: PAUL, THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
40:14 HAVE A GREAT WEEKEND. PAUL DOBSON, BLOOMBERG'S
40:17 EXECUTIVE EDITOR FOR ASIA MARKETS.
40:18 LET'S GET YOU STOCKS TO WATCH THIS FRIDAY.
40:21 OLIVIA LEVIEUX IS HERE. >> HAPPY FRIDAY THE 13TH.
40:24 WE'RE LOOKING AT RICHEMONT HERE FOR A SECOND THERE IT LOOKED
40:27 LIKE FRIDAY THE 13TH WAS GOING TO PREVENT THE EARNINGS FROM
40:30 COMING OUT WITH THE MICROSOFT CO-PILOT ISSUE.
40:32 BUT WE HAVE THE RESULTS. AND IT IS A BEAT ON THEIR SALES
40:38 ON CONSTANT CURRENCY EXCHANGE RATES, THEY HAD A PARTICULARLY
40:42 STRONG PERFORMANCE ACTUALLY IN JAPAN WHICH GREW NOTABLY.
40:45 AND THAT SORT OF OFFSET THE WEAKNESS THAT WE SAW IN THE
40:47 MIDDLE EAST, EXPECTED WEAKNESS THERE GIVEN THE WAR.
40:49 RICHEMONT ACTUALLY SAID THAT THEY THOUGHT THAT THEIR
40:51 PERFORMANCE IN THE AREA HELD UP DECENTLY WHILE GIVEN THE
40:54 MACROECONOMIC HEAD WINDS THERE. THERE WERE A COUPLE OF THINGS
40:57 BENEATH THE REPORT, THOUGH, THAT WERE NOT AS ROSY, PARTICULARLY
41:02 IN THEIR JEWELRY MAISON WHICH MISSED.
41:04 AND IT COULD BE A MIXED OPENING FOR RICHEMONT.
41:06 IF IT IS LOWER, IT'S LIKELY DUE TO THAT MISS IN THE JEWELRY
41:10 MAIZON UNIT. MOVING OVER TO INSURERS,
41:15 UNIPOLE'S OPERATING PROFIT GREW BY 13% ON THE YEAR.
41:20 HOWEVER, IT ACTUALLY IN JENNE'S RESULTS THAT I WANT TO BRING
41:22 YOUR ATTENTION TO, THEY MISSED ON THIRD QUARTER OPERATING
41:24 PROFIT. EVEN THOUGH THEIR NET INCOME DID
41:26 BEAT. AND ONE OF THE THINGS THAT THE
41:29 CFO WAS FLAGGING JUST BEFORE I CAME ON SET WAS THE COST THE
41:34 CATASTROPHICS UNIT. SO THEY TOOK AN 800 MILLION EURO
41:39 HIT DUE TO THE NATURAL DISASTERS.
41:41 AND WE HAD EXTREME WEATHER IN EUROPE ALL SUMMER.
41:44 AND WE'RE FACING NOW AN EL NINO EVENT.
41:46 SO THE COST OF NATURAL DISASTERS IS DEFINITELY SOMETHING
41:48 INVESTORS ARE THINKING MORE HEAVILY ABOUT WHEN IT COMES TO
41:50 INSURERS. ESPECIALLY NOW THAT IT WAS
41:54 FLAGGED BY GENERALE IN THEIR REPORT.
41:57 STELLANTIS, A LOT GOING ON IN THE STOCK TODAY.
42:00 WE SAW IT FALL MORE THAN 4% YESTERDAY AFTER THE CEO WARNED
42:04 OF MULTIBILLION DOLLARS IN COSTS NEXT YEAR DUE TO RISING IMPUT
42:07 COSTS. TODAY, WE HAVE STELLANTIS FACING
42:11 ANOTHER POTENTIAL HEADWIND WITH CANADA'S INDUSTRY MINISTER
42:13 SAYING THAT THEY'RE OWED HUNDREDS OF MILLIONS OF DOLLARS
42:17 BY STELLANTIS DUE TO THE DISPUTE THAT THEY CURRENTLY HAVE OVER
42:20 THIS TORONTO PLANT. SAYING -- ADDING THAT CANADA'S
42:23 GOVERNMENT IS PREPARED TO SUE. ALSO, STELLANTIS REPLACED THEIR
42:26 U.S. SALES CHIEF AS THEY TRY TO MAKE INROADS IN AN AREA THAT
42:31 THEY'VE ACTUALLY BEEN SUFFERING IN RECENTLY DUE TO LACKLUSTER
42:35 NAND AND A KIND OF OLD PRODUCT LINEUP.
42:38 SO DEFINITELY A LOT GOING ON IN STELLANTIS.
42:40 ANNA: THANKS, OLIVIA. OLIVIA LEVIEUX WITH THE LATEST
42:42 ON WHAT'S GOING ON IN THOSE COMPANIES AND WE'LL CERTAINLY
42:44 WATCH ALL OF THOSE AT THE MARKET OPEN.
42:45 SHALL WE TAKE A MOMENT TO REFLECT ON WHAT IS STILL ONGOING
42:48 AT MICROSOFT? ISSUES WITH CO-PILOT AND OTHER
42:52 PRODUCT AREAS. LATEST NEWS SEEING POSITIVE
42:55 RESULTS FOR SERVER STABILITY. BUT DOESN'T SEEM AS IF THIS
42:57 ISSUE IS RESOLVED AND GONE FROM THE U.S. THROUGH THE ASIA
43:00 SESSION WHILE ALL OF EUROPE WAS ASLEEP AND GETTING SOME REALLY
43:03 NICE INSIGHTS FROM OUR TEAMS OVER IN ASIA ABOUT WHAT THIS IS
43:07 DOING TO -- TO TRADERS. TOM: TRADERS.
43:08 ANNA: TRYING TO WORK IN THE FINANCIAL SERVICES SECTOR.
43:13 SO NICE LITTLE INSIGHTS. AND GEKAS IN THEIR -- AND GEN-X
43:18 IN THEIR HAPPY PLACE. FROM CMC ON OUR REPORTING AND
43:21 EVERYONE WAS BACK ON THE PHONE AND SOMETHING THAT NORMALLY TOOK
43:24 A FEW SECONDS BY EMAIL IS REQUIRING A PHONE CALL.
43:27 A BIT OF BACK OFFICE HEADACHES COMING THROUGH IS THE WAY THAT
43:31 SOME TOKYO-BASED STRATEGISTS WERE PUTTING IT.
43:33 TOM: AND JUST IN THE CONTEXT THIS IS ONE OF THE MOST SEVERE
43:35 DISRUPTIONS THAT MICROSOFT HAS EVER SEEN.
43:39 SO TEAMS, OUTLOOK AND CO-PILOT ALL AFFECTED FOR MANY PEOPLE.
43:41 NOT EVERYONE. FOR MANY PEOPLE IT SEEMS.
43:45 AND WE'VE HAD EVEN EXAMPLES OF EMAIL ACCESS FOR JAPAN'S
43:47 MINISTRY OF FINANCE BEING AFFECTED AND TO YOUR POINT,
43:51 TRADERS, STRUGGLING TO CLOSE DEALS AT THE END OF THE WEEK IN
43:52 ASIA. BECAUSE THEY CAN'T USE THEIR
43:54 OUTLOOK. AND SO PICKING UP THE PHONES AND
44:00 USING WHATSAPP. ANNA: A DELAY OF EARNINGS, AND
44:04 WE HAD THIS MORNING'S EUROPEAN CORPORATES ALSO STRUGGLE TO GET
44:06 THEIR EARNINGS OUT. BUT THEY MANAGED IN THE END.
44:08 RICHEMONT. TOOK A LITTLE LONGER.
44:10 TOM: AND EVERYTHING IS WORKING WITH BLOOMBERG.
44:12 SO THE TERMINAL FUNCTION FINE. WE'RE HAVING NO ISSUES AT ALL.
44:15 ANNA: I WOULD HAVE NOTHING TO SAY IF IT WEREN'T.
44:17 AND EUROPEAN EQUITY MARKETS FUTURE SHALL WE BRING THOSE UP
44:20 AND SEE WHERE WE ARE? THE U.S. FUTURES PICTURE HAS
44:23 IMPROVED A LITTLE BIT IN THE LAST HALF-HOUR OR SO.
44:24 LAST HOUR. MAYBE THAT APPLIES TO EUROPE AS
44:26 WELL. JUST SEEING A LITTLE BIT OF -- A
44:29 BIT LESS NEGATIVITY PERHAPS THAN WE WERE HALF AN HOUR AGO.
44:32 TOM: CURRENTLY POINTING HIGHER BY .3%.
44:34 WITHIN THE CONTEXT THAT EUROPEAN STOCKS ARE AT RECORD HIGHS.
44:38 BUT WATCHING THE NAMES LIKE ASM INTERNATIONAL.
44:39 ASML OF COURSE IN TERMS OF THE READ ACROSS FROM THE NVIDIA AND
44:42 JENSEN HUANG DOWNFALL. AND NVIDIA CRISIS AND CHAOS.
44:46 SO WE CONTINUE TO MONITOR THE LINKAGES THERE.
44:48 INTERESTING OF COURSE THAT SOME OF THEIR COMPETITORS HAVE
44:50 PERFORMED VERY WELL INCLUDING AMD WHICH IS UP MORE THAN 40%
44:53 OVER NVIDIA JUST THIS WEEK. U.S. FUTURES POINTING A LITTLE
44:54 LOWER. THE OPENING TRADE IS COMING UP.
45:20 ANNA: WELCOME BACK FRIDAY, THE 13TH.
45:25 A FEW MINUTES TO GO UNTIL THE START OF CASH EQUITIES TRADING
45:27 ON EUROPEAN EQUITY MARKETS. THIS IS THE PICTURE FROM THE
45:31 U.S. YESTERDAY. THIS IS THE S&P.
45:33 ARE WE BREAKING THIS LINK A LITTLE BIT, WHERE THE U.S. HAS
45:36 BEEN SO FOCUSED ON NVIDIA, THE WAY TO OF THAT, AND NVIDIA HAS
45:42 PROVIDED SOMETHING OF AN ANTIDOTE, SOMETHING OF AN ESCAPE
45:45 ROUTE FROM SOME OF THOSE TRADES. BUT THIS IS THE U.S. PICTURE OF
45:47 YESTERDAY. WE DID SEE A BIT OF A DOWNDRAFT
45:51 IN U.S. STOCKS AFTER WE CLOSED EUROPEAN EQUITY MARKETS, WHICH
45:54 IS THIS REDLINE. LET'S LOOK AT THE EQUITY'S
45:56 FUTURE BECAUSE IT DOES REFLECT THAT NEGATIVITY.
46:01 WE ARE DOWN 0.25 PERCENT. WE ARE STRUGGLING TO GET THE
46:05 EARNINGS OUT. THINGS LOOK A LITTLE QUIETER
46:08 THIS MORNING. TOM: POTENTIAL EARNINGS STORIES
46:21 TO THINK ABOUT ONUR ANT INDIVIDUAL STOCK FOCUS.
46:27 JEWELRY HELPING AGAIN, CEMENTING ITS STATUS AS A LUXURY SECTORS
46:29 STAND OUT. WE WILL MONITOR THE NUMBERS, OR
46:36 AT LEAST THE REACTION, AFTER THE ESTIMATES OF 16%.
46:44 ACCIONA ON THE BACK OF A $1 BILLION DALE -- DEAL.
46:51 THEY MAY BE FACING RISKS, SO WE WILL WATCH THAT AS WELL.
46:54 STELLANTIS COMING THROUGH WITH UPDATES IN TERMS OF THE IMPACT
46:58 OF CHIP SHORTAGES AND RAW MATERIAL COSTS AND PRESSURE IN
46:59 CANADA AS WELL. THAT CARMAKER IN FOCUS.
47:07 ANNA: MOMENTS UNTIL THE START OF CASH EQUITY TRADING FOR THIS
47:09 FRIDAY MORNING. EUROPEAN STOCKS COMING OFF AN
47:13 ALL-TIME HIGH IN YESTERDAY'S SESSION.
47:14 THEIR TRAVAILS AT NVIDIA, THE DOWNFALL OF JENSEN HUANG, AT
47:18 LEAST IN THE SHORT TERM, PLAYING OUT IN EUROPE'S FAVOR.
47:24 EUROPEAN STOCKS GOING HIGHER THIS WEEK.
47:25 WE HAVE SEEN THIS NEW EUROPEAN HIGH FOR STOCKS IN EUROPE.
47:28 WHERE DOES THAT LEAVE US? THAT LEAVES US ON THE BACK FOOT.
47:34 DOWN ZERO POINT 1% ON THE FTSE 100 COME AROUND THAT FOR THE
47:37 STOXX 600. THINGS DO SEEM A LITTLE CALM HER
47:39 THIS MORNING. WE DO HAVE THIS MICROSOFT STORY
47:41 TO WATCH. THERE ARE PLENTY OTHER NEWS
47:45 LINES COMING THROUGH FROM THE ANTHROPIC IPO, SO LOTS OF TEXT
47:49 T -- TECH THEMES TO THINK ABOUT.
47:55 WE HAVE DIGESTED THAT. ON THE BACK OF ALL THAT, WE
47:58 RETREAT A TOUCH ON EUROPEAN STOCKS THIS MORNING.
48:02 TOM: WE CONTINUE TO SEE THE EFFECTS OF THE NVIDIA STORY.
48:09 ASML IS WEAKER IN THE SESSION, CURRENTLY DOWN 1.2%, JUST OVER
48:12 1%. IN TERMS OF OTHER SECTORS UNDER
48:15 PRESSURE, TELECOMS WEAKER AS WELL BY ABOUT ONE PERCENT.
48:19 TELECOMS, BASIC RESOURCES, TECH ACROSS THE LEADING LOSSES.
48:25 OIL PRICES HAVE INCREASED. PRESIDENT TRUMP SAYS HE DOES NOT
48:28 NEED A DEAL WITH IRAN. HE HAS SAID THAT AGAIN.
48:33 ENERGY IS A 0.7%. UTILITIES ALSO GETTING 0.3%.
48:40 THAT IS THE BROAD PICTURE ACROSS SECTORS.
48:44 ENERGY ON THE UPSET -- ON THE UPSIDE.
48:50 ANNA: AROUND A THIRD OF SECTORS IN POSITIVE TERRITORY.
48:52 DOWN 0.2%. NOT HUGE -- NOT HUGE MOVES.
49:02 LET'S TALK ABOUT THIS WITH J.P. MORGAN PRIVATE BANK.
49:04 NICE TO HAVE YOU WITH US. WE HAVE BEEN THINKING ALL WEEK
49:09 ABOUT THE ROLE EUROPEAN STOCKS PLAY AS WE WATCH THE NVIDIA
49:12 DRAMA UNFOLD AND WE THINK WHAT IT DOES TO THE WIDER TECH
49:15 LANDSCAPE. EUROPE IS ATTACHED TO THAT TECH
49:18 LANDSCAPE IN EUROPE HAS PLAYS AROUND AI CERTAINLY IN THE
49:22 INDUSTRIALS CONNECTED TO AI, WILL DOES IT LEAVE EUROPEAN
49:25 STOCKS IN GENERAL? >> THANK YOU FOR HAVING ME.
49:36 YOUR UNDERPERFORMED IN OCTOBER. WE HAVE SEEN A SHARP ROTATION
49:40 FROM CYCLICALS TO DEFENSIVE'S, AS WE HAVE SEEN IN THE REST OF
49:42 THE MARKET AS WELL. IN TERMS OF BEING SELECTIVE, WE
49:47 DO LIKE BANKS, FOR EXAMPLE, WHICH IS NOT LINKED TO AI.
49:49 THIS IS A COMPLETELY DIFFERENT SECTOR WHICH HAS A VERY
49:52 DIFFERENT MONTH OF OCTOBER. WE HAD A BIG D RATING IN THE
49:57 MARKETS. WHEN WE TAKE A STEP BACK AND
50:02 LOOK AT FUNDAMENTALS, THEY LOOK STRONG, ESPECIALLY ON THE LOAN
50:03 SIDE. WE ARE ALSO IN SECTORS LIKE
50:06 INDUSTRIALS AND TECH. ANNA: TELL ME ABOUT THE TECH
50:10 SELECTIVITY. WHERE DOES THAT TAKE YOU AND
50:12 WHERE DO YOU WANT TO SET ASIDE? NATALIA: WHEN YOU LOOK AT TECH,
50:18 YOU ARE BASICALLY SEEING A BIG SPIKE IN SEMICONDUCTORS.
50:21 THE MARKET IS REALLY REASSESSING HOW MUCH GROWTH THE SECTOR WILL
50:26 HAVE AFTER A VERY STRONG 2020 A LOT HAS BEEN PRICED IN, BUT IF
50:29 WE TAKE A STEP BACK AND THINK ABOUT WHERE OUR BIGGEST
50:31 CONVICTION LIES, IT IS WITH HYPERSCALERS.
50:35 TOM: IT IS WITH HYPERSCALERS. NVIDIA, IS THAT A HEADWIND?
50:42 HOW SIGNIFICANT AND CONSEQUENTIAL COULD THAT BE?
50:45 NATALIA: WITH HYPERSCALERS, WHAT IS INTERESTING AS YOU HAVE THE
50:48 UNDERPERFORMANCE, BECAUSE YOU HAD BIG ROTATION THIS YEAR,
50:52 SEMIS OUTPERFORMING THE HYPERSCALERS.
50:55 THEN YOU ALSO HAD THE CAPEX STORY.
50:56 THIS YEAR, CAPEX ALMOST DOUBLED. I THINK THAT STORY CHANGES.
51:04 AS HYPERSCALER GROWTH COMES DOWN, WE ARE GOING FROM 90%
51:09 CAPEX TO 40 AND THEN 10, WE THINK FREE CASH FLOW WHICH IS
51:15 THE KEY FOR MARKET MAY HAVE FLIPPED HIGHER FASTER THAN WHAT
51:16 THE MARKET IS EXPECTING. TOM: THE INVESTOR REACTION HAS
51:24 BEEN MIXED ON THE STORY. SOMETIMES THEY REWARD COMPANIES
51:28 AND HYPERSCALERS, SOMETIMES THEY COMMIT MORE ON CAPEX, AND
51:31 SOMETIMES THEY PUNISH HYPERSCALERS FOR COMMITTING TOO
51:32 MUCH. HOW DO YOU PLAY THAT AS AN
51:36 INVESTOR? NATALIA: IF YOU LOOK AT WHAT
51:45 HAPPENED IN THIS EARNINGS STORY, IT IS NOT TOO MUCH.
51:48 CAPEX IS GROWING BUT NOT MUCH MORE.
51:53 TO ME, WHAT IS IMPORTANT IS CLOUD GROWTH AND BACKLOG.
52:00 IT ALL COMES TOGETHER WITH HOW THEY ARE DOING FUNDAMENTALLY.
52:03 YOU HAVE TO SEE IF YOU HAVE THE ROI ON YOUR BUSINESS.
52:06 WE HAD CONFIRMATION THIS EARNINGS SEASON THAT R.O.I. IS
52:07 QUITE STRONG. ANNA: WE HAD A CONVERSATION WITH
52:11 A GUEST EARLIER ON WHO WAS POINTING US TOWARDS BOND
52:14 MARKETS, THE ROLET WAS PLAYING IN STOCKS, AND SUGGESTING THAT
52:18 BOND MARKETS, DEPENDING ON WHERE YOU GOT YIELDS, ARE GIVING YOU A
52:22 GREEN LIGHT, AMBER LIGHT, OR GREEN LIGHT FOR STOCKS TO GO
52:25 HIGHER, AND HOW QUICKLY. HE WAS CHARACTERIZING IT AS BOND
52:28 MARKETS ARE PLAYING THE ROLE THEY SHOULD AND THEY ARE SLOWING
52:31 THIS THING DOWN. THIS TRAIN WAS GOING TOO FAST
52:33 AND THEY ARE SLOWING THE SING DOWN AND PAINTING A PICTURE THIS
52:38 COULD TAKE US TO A MORE POSITIVE PLACE MEDIUM-TERM.
52:39 IS THAT IF YOU YOU WOULD SHARE? NATALIA: IT IS INTERESTING,
52:43 BECAUSE WHEN YOU LOOK AT THE EQUITY MARKET, IT HAS D RATED.
52:51 WE HAVE SEEN ALMOST FOUR TERMS DERATING TO 18 TIMES.
52:56 THE MARKET ALREADY KNOWS THAT MARKETS ARE LIKELY TO SLOW DOWN
52:58 NEXT YEAR. IN TERMS OF THE CAPEX, THAT IS
53:03 ACTUALLY GOOD FOR HYPERSCALERS BECAUSE IT MEANS THEY CAN SHOW
53:07 THE ROI WE ARE TALKING ABOUT BEFORE.
53:09 FOR US, WE DON'T WANT TO SEE. HOW YIELDS BECAUSE THAT PUTS
53:12 MORE PRESSURE ON THE EQUITY MARKET.
53:15 MARKETS. TOM: YOU ARE TARGETING 8600 FOR
53:22 THE S&P BY THE END OF 2027. WHAT DECISION ARE YOU MAKING
53:25 ABOUT RATES? NATALIA: WE HAVE RATES AROUND
53:29 5%. BASICALLY FOR US, IT IS LESS
53:33 ABOUT THE RE-RATING AND MORE ABOUT EARNINGS.
53:37 IF WE LOOK INTO EARNINGS EXPECTATIONS, WE THINK EARNINGS
53:39 CAN STILL GROW DOUBLE DIGITS NEXT YEAR AND THE YEAR AFTER.
53:43 WHICH IS THE TREND WE HAVE SEEN FOR THE LAST EIGHT CONSECUTIVE
53:47 QUARTERS AND IS HIGHER THAN THE LONG-TERM AVERAGE OF 7% TO 8%.
53:51 WE FEEL PRETTY COMFORTABLE ABOUT THIS EARNINGS GROWTH STORY
53:54 DRIVEN BY DIFFERENT SECTORS, BUT OBVIOUS THEY HYPERSCALERS IS A
53:57 BIG PART OF THAT. ANNA: IF THE SECOND DERIVATIVE
54:00 OF THE EARNINGS GROWTH COMES DOWN, IS IT THAT MARKETS CAN
54:03 DIGEST THAT? WE ARE GROWN UP ENOUGH WITH THIS
54:07 AI THEME THAT WE REALIZE YOU CAN'T KEEP GROWING AT THE PACE
54:10 YOU WERE, IS FINE IF THAT PERCENTAGE COMES DOWN AND THE AI
54:13 TRADE CONTINUES REGARDLESS? NATALIA: THIS IS WHAT THE
54:19 MARKETS HAVE BEEN WRESTLING THE LAST FEW WEEKS.
54:21 2026 HAS BEEN A FANTASTIC YEAR FOR EARNINGS.
54:23 WE ARE GOING TO SLOW DOWN. BUT WE ARE NOT REALLY GOING BACK
54:27 TO 7%, 8% OF LONG-TERM AVERAGE. WE ARE STILL GOING TO GO DOUBLE
54:30 DIGITS FOR THE NEXT TWO YEARS, SO THE MARKET FEELS COMFORTABLE
54:33 WITH THAT. AND THE VALUATION ALREADY
54:35 REFLECT THAT. AT 18 TIMES, THE MARKET IS NOT
54:38 REALLY EXPENSIVE. TOM: LET'S TURN TO A SHORT-TERM
54:45 STORY, THE ANTHROPIC IPO. HOW ARE YOU THINKING ABOUT THAT
54:49 WITH THE EXPOSURE TO THE HYPERSCALERS STORY, HOW SHOULD
54:51 INVESTORS BE FACTORING THAT IN? NATALIA: I THINK THE MARKET HAS
54:55 BEEN TRYING TO UNDERSTAND WHAT IT MEANS FOR THE DATA CENTER
54:57 BUILD OUT IN THE LAST COUPLE WEEKS.
55:01 FOR US, IT IS DIFFERENT FROM THE WHOLE AI STORY BECAUSE WE FEEL
55:03 THE AI STORY REMAINS VERY INTACT.
55:08 OVERALL, WE FEEL GOOD ABOUT THE AI STORY.
55:16 ANNA: BACK IN EUROPE, WE ARE COMING OFF OF RECORD HIGHS ON
55:18 EUROPEAN EQUITY MARKETS THIS WEEK.
55:23 YOU GAVE US A BIT OF AN INSIGHT INTO WHAT YOU THINK ABOUT
55:24 EUROPE. BUT WHICH OF THE SECTORS YOU ARE
55:30 POSITIVE ON? IS IT INDUSTRIALS SERVING THE
55:31 BUILD OUT? WILL THEY BE THE ONES FOR WHOM
55:34 THE EARNINGS STORY IS THE MOST POSITIVE?
55:37 NATALIA: WE DO LIKE INDUSTRIALS. IT IS A VERY BROAD SECTOR AND WE
55:41 LIKE THE BROAD NATURE OF IT. WE LIKE AEROSPACE, THE
55:44 ELECTRIFICATION DATA CENTER BUILDOUT.
55:48 WE THINK A LOT OF NEGATIVITY IS PRICED IN, BUT ALSO BANKS.
55:52 IT IS A VERY DIFFERENTIAL STORY. THE MARKET HAS CONCERNS ABOUT
55:56 THE TRADES EARLIER THIS MONTH. BUT WE FEEL COMFORTABLE WITH
55:59 FUNDAMENTALS. ANNA: BECAUSE RATES CAN GO UP
56:05 FOR THE RIGHT OR WRONG REASONS. SOMETIMES RATES GO HIGHER AND
56:07 BANKS DO WELL AND OTHER TIMES THEY SELL OFF.
56:10 WHAT IS THE LINK BETWEEN THE TWO AT THIS POINT.
56:15 >> WE EXPECT TO ECB HIKES WITHIN THE NEXT YEAR OR SO.
56:19 WE THINK THAT IS ACTUALLY GOOD FOR BANKS BECAUSE WE ARE NOT
56:22 SEEING THE OVERHEATING IN THE MARKETS.
56:26 THAT IS WHY THEY MOVE IN YIELDS THAT IS SO IMPORTANT FOR US.
56:29 THAT IS GOOD FOR THE SECTOR. HOW TOM: WHAT DO YOU THINK ABOUT
56:35 DOMESTIC STOCKS? NATALIA: WE NEED TO SEE BETTER
56:39 EARNINGS GROWTH. I WOULD SAY THE VALUATION HAS
56:41 BEEN VERY ATTRACTIVE BUT WE NEED TO SEE THE CONFIRMATION THAT
56:44 EARNINGS GROWTH IS STRONG. IF YOU COMPARE TO EUROPE, EUROPE
56:49 IS GROWING HIGH SINGLE DIGITS LIKELY NEXT YEAR.
56:52 THE U.S. IS GROWING DOUBLE DIGITS, SO THERE ARE OTHER AREAS
56:54 . FOR EXAMPLE, WE DIDN'T TALK
56:58 ABOUT JAPAN BUT JAPAN IS A HIGH CONVICTION IDEA.
57:00 WE EXPECT DOUBLE DIGIT NEXT YEAR IN HIGH SINGLE DIGIT IN 2028.
57:04 PLUS, YOU HAVE CORPORATE REFORMS LIFTING THE MARGINS.
57:06 THERE ARE INTERESTING STORIES GLOBALLY TO CHOOSE FROM RATHER
57:14 THAN IN EUROPE. TOM: THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
57:23 LET'S CHECK IN ON THE CORE SIX THIS MORNING.
57:27 ASML TAKING ANOTHER KNOCK, AND YOU CAN'T HAVE IT TO THE NVIDIA
57:28 STORY. IT IS NOT A HUGE MOVE BUT
57:34 NOTABLE ON A POINTS BASIS. RHEINMETALL AND THE DEFENSE
57:38 SPACE DOWN BY 10 POINTS. LVMH AND THE LUXURY SPACE NOT
57:41 GETTING SOME UPSIDE FROM THE BROADER LUXURY STORY.
57:43 RICHEMONT THE BEAT THERE. ONE STOCK THAT IS IN POSITIVE
57:49 TERRITORY AS THE CONSUMER STAPLE, NESTLE.
57:51 UP BY 0.4%. LET'S LOOK AT THE INDIVIDUAL
57:52 NAMES. OLIVIA IS HERE WITH STOCKS ON
57:55 THE MOVE. OLIVIA: THIS IS ACTUALLY A
57:58 DIFFICULT DAY AS THERE'S NOT A LOT OF STOCKS ON THE MOVE.
58:02 THERE SEEMS TO BE A MUTED DAY. INVESTORS TAKING STOCK OF THE
58:05 DEVELOPMENTS WE HAD THIS WEEK AND TRYING TO REPOSITION.
58:09 WE HAVE SOME DEALS NEWS. ERAMET STOCK IS DOWN, WHILE
58:24 TRIPLE LIE THIS DOWN. IT IS MOSTLY A TECHNICAL
58:28 CORRECTION GIVEN THE DISCOUNT THOSE SHARES WERE PLACED AT.
58:35 MOVING OVER TO THE ENERGY SPACE, ACCIONA'S DEAL.
58:44 THEY WERE SUPPOSED TO SEND A WIT SO WIND AND SOLAR ASPECTS TO
58:47 MEXICO. THAT DEAL IS NOW CONSIDERED AT
58:50 RISK. WE ARE SEEING THEM DOWN MORE
58:54 THAN 4%. WE HAD EARNINGS IN LINE.
58:59 IT SEEMS THAT INVESTORS ARE TAKING THE POTENTIAL RISK OF
59:03 THIS MEXICO DEAL OVER THE IN-LINE EARNINGS RESULT.
59:06 AND THEIR SUBSIDIARY, THE ONE MAKING A SALE, IS DOWN BY 4%
59:09 THERE. FINALLY MOVING OVER TO THE
59:18 EUROPEAN EARNINGS, RICHEMONT IS ACTUALLY DOWN MORE THAN 6.5%.
59:21 THAT IS WHAT IS WEIGHING ON THE LUXURY INDUSTRY.
59:26 CLEARLY INVESTORS ARE NOT HAPPY, DESPITE THE FACT THAT THEIR
59:29 HEADLINE WAS A BEAT. WEISS GROUP IS UP BY 5.5%.
59:38 THEY HAVE GUIDED FOR THEIR 27 GOALS AHEAD OF THE UPPER END OF
59:39 THEIR RANGE. TRYING TO MAKE A PUSH AND DATA
59:46 CENTERS OVER THE NEXT COUPLE YEARS.
59:47 INVESTORS TAKING THAT CONFIDENTLY WHILE AVIVA IS 11 OF
59:51 THE INSURANCE PLAYERS THAT IS UP TODAY AFTER A SOLID RESULT.
59:57 TOM: SOME REALLY INTERESTING MOVES.
1:00:01 THE DETAIL BENEATH THE HOOD IS CONCERNING INVESTORS WITH THAT
1:00:04 DROP IN THE STOCK PRICE FOR RICHEMONT.
1:00:06 COMING UP, OUTLOOK OUTAGE. WE WILL BRING YOU THE LATEST AS
1:00:09 MICROSOFT SCRAMBLES TO RESTORE ACCESS TO KEY SERVICES.
1:00:13 THIS IS BLOOMBERG.
1:00:34 >> WE HAD THESE BIG DRAWDOWNS IN AI.
1:00:36 WE HAVE ALWAYS BOUNCED BACK FROM THOSE.
1:00:39 WHAT WE SEE HERE IS NERVOUSNESS ABOUT IT.
1:00:41 I DON'T THINK IT IS A FUNDAMENTAL END.
1:00:43 WE HAVE TO LOOK AT HOW THE TECHNOLOGY PROGRESSES.
1:00:45 WHAT THE COSTS ARE. I DON'T SEE ANY PULLBACK ON THE
1:00:49 USAGE SIDE OF IT. IF YOU LOOK AT THAT, THERE IS
1:00:52 ONLY JUST DEMAND GROWING. >> I THINK THE MARKETS FEAR THAT
1:00:57 EARNINGS BACKDROP IS AFFECTING AN AI BUILDOUT THAT MAY BE OUT
1:01:01 OF DATE. >> AS AN INVESTORS, YOU NEED TO
1:01:15 FIND MORE DIVERSIFIERS. >> WE'RE FIRING ON ALL
1:01:16 CYLINDERS. WE HAVE HOO STRONG DEMAND FOR
1:01:20 OUR ELECTRIFICATION BUSINESS. IT IS A BUILDING BUSINESS.
1:01:25 >> IT IS A GLOBAL TRADE. I DON'T THINK THERE IS ANY WAY
1:01:28 YOU CAN REALLY HIDE FROM AI. IT IS NOT A MATTER OF WHETHER
1:01:31 YOU ARE EXPOSED IT TO. YOU HAVE TO BE.
1:01:35 >> IT IS A REGION OF POWER AND INCREDIBLE GROWTH.
1:01:37 HONESTLY WE'RE SEEING THAT PUSH FOR AI TRANSFORMATION DRIVING
1:01:42 VALUE WITH AI GOING HIGHER AND HIGHER.
1:01:44 FOR US, EVEN AS SUCCESSFUL AS WE HAVE BEEN WITH OUR GROWTH, WE'RE
1:01:52 JUST STARTING TO SCRATCH THE SURFACE.
1:01:55 ANNA: ALL OF THAT JUST THIS WEEK.
1:01:59 HOW EUROPE MAY BENEFIT AS INVESTORS SEEK SAFE HARBOR.
1:02:04 TOM: MICROSOFT'S OUTLOOK OUT VANTAGE CAUSING LOTS OF
1:02:06 HEADACHES THIS MORNING. USERS UNABLE TO ACCESS THEIR
1:02:11 E-MAILS OR CHATS. LET'S BRING IN BLOOMBERG'S
1:02:14 EXECUTIVE EDITOR FOR GLOBAL TECHNOLOGY.
1:02:18 WHAT CAN YOU TELL US ABOUT THIS OUTAGE?
1:02:19 >> HI, TOM. THIS IS ONE OF THE MORE SEVERE
1:02:24 MICROSOFT OUTAGES THAT WE HAVE SEEN.
1:02:26 USUALLY THEY DON'T LAST MORE THAN AN HOUR.
1:02:29 THEY TEND TO BE SHORT AND NARROW.
1:02:34 IN THIS CASE IT BEGAN ON THURSDAY AND SPILLED INTO
1:02:35 FRIDAY. IT AFFECTS A WIDE RANGE OF
1:02:38 SERVICES FOR THEM. OUTLOOK, TEAMS, CO-PILOT, THEIR
1:02:43 AI SERVICE ALSO AND IT'S BEEN KIND OF A WHERE HE HAD PROBLEM.
1:02:49 THE COMPANY HAS BEEN GIVING UPDATES ON THEIR WEBSITE ABOUT
1:02:51 HOW THE PROGRESS IS GOING BUT THERE IS MORE THAN 2 HUNTED
1:02:55 REPORTS OF PROBLEMS AT THIS POINT AND -- 200,000 REPORTS OF
1:03:00 PROBLEMS AND THEY HAVE NOT FIGURED OUT HOW TO SOLVE IT.
1:03:05 THERE ARE PROBLEMS WITH THE UNDERLYING SERVERS.
1:03:07 THEY ARE GIVING UPDATES BUT HAVE NOT BEEN ABLE TO FIX IT SO FAR.
1:03:12 ANNA: WE HAVE SOME INCREDIBLE REPORTING FROM THE TEAM AROUND
1:03:16 THE COMPLEXITIES OF HOW NVIDIA CHIPS ENDED UP IN CHINA.
1:03:22 AND THE ROLE OF ALICE WONG AND OTHERS IN THIS.
1:03:28 I'M SURE THERE IS PLENTY MORE TO UNCOVER.
1:03:30 >> ONE OF THE BIG QUESTIONS IN THIS NVIDIA SCANDAL IS EXACTLY
1:03:36 HOW NVIDIA CHIPSES HAVE BEEN MOVING THROUGH GLOBAL SUPPLY
1:03:40 CHAIN AND OF COURSE THE MOST ADVANCED NVIDIA CHIPS ARE BANNED
1:03:47 BY WASHINGTON FROM BEING SHIPPED INTO CHINA.
1:03:50 WE FOUND SOME HAVE MADE THEIR WAY THERE INCLUDING SOME OF THE
1:03:53 MOST ADVANCED CHIPS. THERE IS A COMPANY TIED TO ALICE
1:03:57 WONG, THE WOMAN SUSPECTED OF BEING A CHINESE SPY AND
1:04:02 SUSPECTED OF HAVING AN AFFAIR WITH JENSEN HUANG AND THEY WERE
1:04:05 ABLE TO GET SOME OF THOSE CHIPS SEPTEMBER TO CHINA.
1:04:08 THERE IS STILL A LOT TO BE UNCOVERED HERE.
1:04:11 THIS HAS GOTTEN THE ATTENTION OF WASHINGTON.
1:04:14 IT RESULTED IN THE BOARD OF DIRECTORS DECIDING TO ASK FOR
1:04:18 JENSEN HUANG'S RESIGNATION WHICH HE HAS GIVEN.
1:04:22 THERE IS A LOT MORE TO DISCOVER HOW THE CHIPS HAVE BEEN MOVING
1:04:28 THROUGH THE GLOBAL SUPPLY CHAIN. CHINA HAWKS THINK WE SHOULD BE
1:04:32 MUCH TOUGHER ON CHINA WHEN IT COMES TO THEY SEE EXPORTS.
1:04:39 IT IS AN ADVANTAGE TO HAVE AI CHIPS.
1:04:42 THERE IS MORE TO BE UNCOVERED ON THAT FRONT.
1:04:48 TOM: FROM THE HARDWARE PIECE OF THE AI STORY AND THE DRAMA
1:04:52 AROUND NVIDIA TO THE SOFTWARE AND NOTEFULLY ANTHROPIC'S IPO.
1:04:57 WE CAN DRAW THE DOTS TO SOME EXTENT.
1:05:01 THE NVIDIA INVESTMENT IN ANTHROPIC.
1:05:03 THE TURNAROUND IN NVIDIA, THE SOFTWARE PIECE IS PLAYING OUT
1:05:04 WELL. IT SEEMS LIKE THERE IS A LOT OF
1:05:12 DEMAND TO GET EXPOSURE TO ANTHROPIC.
1:05:13 >> THIS IS A BIG QUESTION. IT HAS BEEN PLANNING THIS FOR A
1:05:18 LONG TIME AND RAN INTO A HUGE AMOUNT OF MARKET TUMULT
1:05:22 ESPECIALLY WITH THE NEE CLOUDS, THERE WAS SHAKINESS AT THE
1:05:24 FOUNDATION OF THESE COMPANIES THAT ARE TRYING TO BUILD THE
1:05:29 INFRASTRUCTURE FOR THESE COMPANIES.
1:05:31 ANTHROPIC AND ITS BANKERS DECIDED TO PROCEED AND LOWERED
1:05:36 THE VALUATION A BIT BUT NOW WE HEAR THEY ARE PROCEEDING WITH
1:05:42 THE IPO AND IT IS SIX TIMES OVERSUBSCRIBED.
1:05:43 LOTS OF INVESTOR INTEREST HERE THAT COULD LEAD TO THE COMPANY
1:05:48 BUMPING UP THE PRICE RANGE FOR THE IPO AND INCREASING THE
1:05:50 AMOUNT OF MONEY THEY RAISE AND THE VALUE SITUATION THAT IS
1:05:54 IMPLICIT WITHIN THAT FUNDRAISING.
1:05:55 ANNA: PETER, THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
1:06:04 BLOOMBERG'S EXECUTIVE EDITOR OF TECHNOLOGY.
1:06:06 MICROSOFT'S OUTLOOK OUTAGE AFFECTING ONE PARTICULAR COMPANY
1:06:08 THIS MORNING. RICHEMONT WAS DELAYED NEARLY AN
1:06:11 HOUR IN REPORTING FIRST HALF RESULTS WHICH SHOWED SALES
1:06:17 GROWTH EXCEEDING EXPECT HAITIAN. LET'S GET -- EXPECTATIONS.
1:06:24 I READ SALES COME IN BETTER THAN EXPECTED.
1:06:25 THAT SEEMS TO BE THE HEADLINE YET THE STOCK IS DOWN.
1:06:30 I SEE THERE IS DISAPPOINTMENT AROUND JEWELRY.
1:06:33 GIVE US THE STORY. >> GENERALLY RICH MONTH IS STILL
1:06:38 PERFORMING VERY WELL COMPARED TO PEOPLE SELLING HANDBAGS AND
1:06:41 JEWELRY. THAT IS WHERE THE PROBLEM IS.
1:06:46 THE SECOND QUARTER OF JEWELRY SALES SLIGHTLY MISSED CONSENSUS
1:06:49 EXPECTATIONS. THAT SEEMS TO HAVE WORRIED WO
1:06:52 PEOPLE THAT THE JEWELRY BOOM IS OVER.
1:06:58 IT IS GOING TO WAY OF HANDBAGS WHERE JEWELRY FATIGUE EXPLAINS
1:07:01 THE SHARE PRICE. TOM: 19%.
1:07:05 IT MISSED THE CONSENSUS ESTIMATES.
1:07:06 YOU WERE SAYING IN THE BREAK THERE IS A LINK BETWEEN AI AND
1:07:10 JEWELRY. >> ABSOLUTELY.
1:07:13 THE WHOLE OF LUXURY HAS HAD PARTICULARLY IN THE U.S., THE
1:07:16 WHOLE OVERLOCKSLY HAS HAD A BOOST FROM THE AI WEALTH TRADE.
1:07:22 I HAVE A THEORY ABOUT IT. BASED ON NO EVIDENCE.
1:07:26 JUST A THEORY. WATCHES AND JEWELRY HAVE
1:07:29 PARTICULARLY BENEFITED. IF YOU GET A NICE LUMP SUM OF
1:07:35 MONEY OR SHARES INVESTING, YOU WANT TO BUY SOMETHING THAT
1:07:38 CELEBRATES THAT PERSONAL MILESTONE.
1:07:42 YOU CAN MAYBE BUY A BERKEN BAG. THAT IS NOT GOING TO LAST YOU A
1:07:47 LIFETIME BUT IF YOU BUY A NICE WATCH OR BEAUTIFUL PIECE OF
1:07:53 JEWELRY, YOU HAVE THAT, JUST THAT SENTIMENTAL MOMENTO OF THAT
1:07:56 TIME. ANNA: YES, THE AI TRADE HAS
1:08:00 SOMETHING TO DO WITH IT. LUXURY HAS TAKEN A BEATING.
1:08:04 CHINA AND THE DYNAMICS THERE HAVE BEEN A NEGATIVE RETAIL
1:08:09 DRIVER FOR A WHILE. RICHEMONT HAS OUTPERFORMED.
1:08:12 WHAT HAVE THEY BEEN GETTING RIGHT?
1:08:16 >> IT HAS BEEN IN JEWELRY. JEWELRY HAS BENEFITED.
1:08:21 PRICES FOR HAND BAGGS WENT UP SO MUCH.
1:08:27 ACTUALLY A PIECE OF JULIE CHENRY LOOKED A BETTER VALUE ANNOUNCER:
1:08:33 IS IT A HEDGE? >> IT IS MORE WHAT YOU CAN GET
1:08:36 FOR YOUR MONEY IN TERMS OF LUXURY.
1:08:38 THE FLIP SIDE IS JEWELRY HAS HAD SOME PRICE INCREASES BECAUSE THE
1:08:43 GOLD PRICE WENT UP AND THAT HAD TO BE PASSED ON.
1:08:46 THAT IS ANOTHER QUESTION AROUND THE FATIGUE POINT.
1:08:55 HAVE THE PRICES CAUGHT UP WITH DEMAND?
1:08:58 TOM: ANTHROPIC'S IPO. MAYBE THAT WILL GIVE A BOOST IN
1:09:01 THE DAYS AND WEEKS AHEAD. ANNA: THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
1:09:06 TOM HAS -- TOM WILL BE HERE FOR TECH SHOW BUT I'M DISAPPEARING.
1:09:10 TIME TO TALK ABOUT THE WEEKEND. I KNOW MOST PEOPLE HAVE THE
1:09:13 WHOLE DAY AHEAD OF THEM. IT BEING FRIDAY MORNING.
1:09:18 I'M PLEASED TO SEE THE LONDON JAZZ FESTIVAL MAKING AN
1:09:20 APPEARANCE. LONDON UNDERGOING A JAZZ
1:09:23 REVIVAL. TOM: AND CULTURE -- DO YOU
1:09:26 FOLLOW THAT UP WITH A COCKTAIL? I THINK YOU SHOULD.
1:09:31 GUY IS NOT HERE. WE'LL TALK ABOUT THE RUGBY
1:09:36 ANYWAY AND MAYBE BEN WHO IS IN MY EAR SAND A TRUE KIWI.
1:09:44 NEW ZEALAND VS. WALES AFTER THEIR VICTORY.
1:09:48 ANNA: ANY THOUGHTS ON WHO IS GOING TO WIN THAT?
1:09:55 TOM: COMPLETELY UNBIASED. TENNIS.
1:09:55 ANNA: I CAN'T IMAGINE WHAT IT IS THAT YOU'LL BE TALKING ABOUT ON
1:09:58 THE TECH SHOW. IT HAS BEEN A QUIET WEEK.
1:10:03 TOM: A BIT OF A GUESSING GAME. JENSEN HUANG.
1:10:05 OBVIOUSLY WE'RE GOING TO DO A DEEP DIVE ON THIS.
1:10:10 IN JENSEN HUANG OUT AT NVIDIA. WE'RE GOING DISCUSS THAT ON THE
1:10:15 SPECIAL EDITION OF BLOOMBERG TECH EUROPE.
1:10:18 THAT IS COMING UP. FRESH INSIGHTS AND ANALYSIS.
1:10:20 STAY WITH US. THIS IS BLOOMBERG.
Tech Tries to Soldier On Without Huang: Market Analysis full transcript
0:00 Everybody focused on a video, I suppose, and what it means more broadly, a sense,
0:03 perhaps from some of our guests overnight, that we were in a kind of
0:06 transitional phase where the markets are trying to work out what comes next.
0:13 Yes. Good morning.
0:13 And I think for the for this tech stock, um, sector, that's definitely, uh, the
0:18 case. Um, the market uh, started off extremely
0:22 low in the US session for Nvidia. I don't know, like 14% there or
0:26 thereabouts. Managed to come all the way back to
0:28 about 4% down by the end of the session. A lot of retail traders piling in there.
0:33 Um, from our reporting, it sounds like a lot of the rest of the world was also
0:37 interested in getting back into it after such a steep sell off.
0:40 So that left US stocks. Not all that for Dow.
0:43 And actually on the day in Asia tried to start the day positively, but by the end
0:46 that is sort of ebbed as well. So I think there's uncertainty out
0:49 there. What's it going to mean for U.S.?
0:51 China relations. Could that be a little bit more
0:53 friction? Could there be more, um, uh, guardrails
0:56 set up to prevent U.S. exports of highest, um, technology chips
1:00 over to China? Those are some of the questions that are
1:03 on people's minds. You know, a lot of the market seems to
1:05 be saying, yeah, Jensen Huang, anybody can be replaced eventually.
1:09 But others are saying, you know, this is a guy that was really was a talisman for
1:11 the entire industry, and he's going to be a big mess
1:15 and pull to some extent, or to a large extent that the Nvidia story in the
1:18 Jensen story has overshadowed for very good reasons, what's happening in the
1:22 bond markets. But the bull market moves have been
1:24 happening sizable. This week.
1:25 We've had some fed commentary again that's been hawkish.
1:27 We've got producer prices today. Yes Simon you know me.
1:32 I'm always going to be more excited about the moves in bonds than those in
1:35 individual stock companies. Uh, really huge uh, jump in Treasury
1:40 yields over the past couple of days, people moving back out of bonds is this
1:43 sort of, um, process, though, you know, we started with payrolls and then the US
1:46 inflation numbers on the CPI, the that were high.
1:49 Uh, and then the comments from the fed swallow and a whole load of other
1:53 speakers afterwards, all talking about the need for more hikes, talking about
1:56 the idea the US policy isn't currently restrictive.
1:59 You know, I think you can see that for the economic data, the Citigroup
2:01 economics surprise index, the highest in a couple of years in the US as well.
2:04 So, um, that all adds up to this idea that we're going to see more pressure on
2:08 bond markets. We just about got them back to to zero
2:12 is a flat for the year. Uh, in the US Treasury market.
2:15 Now we're down again and feeding a little bit of pressure.
2:17 And a lot of people are talking about the idea that yields can remain under
2:21 pressure for quite a good long time, especially with the fed still hiking.
2:25 On the other hand, there's plenty of people that want to pile back in at 5.3,
2:28 5.4, 5.5% on the ten year. Mhm.
2:31 So are you seeing knock on impacts then from those higher yields pull.
2:38 Yes. Yes.
2:39 And I just spoke is a couple of interesting things to observe over in
2:42 Australia for the first time in over a year.
2:44 Um Australian yields are now below those of uh the ones in the US, which has
2:48 pushed the Aussie dollar to the weakest level since January in Japan.
2:52 Similar sort of thing like the yen is weakening again.
2:54 It got through 160 a couple of times. It's sort of ping pong back both times
2:58 so far. Uh, so is hitting up against a bit of a
3:00 wall and creating extra volatility, making it much harder for traders in
3:04 Japan to do it? So that sort of impacts you've got the
3:06 dollar at the strongest in more than a year is kind of rippling back across the
3:09 global market complex as well.
China’s AI Sector Caught in the Crossfire After Nvidia Ousts Huang full transcript
0:01 I's poster boy, its biggest cheerleader and possibly its biggest value creator
0:08 is out. Nvidia is board ousting CEO Jensen Huang
0:11 of a misconduct and China espionage allegations.
0:15 The move wiping out a $180 billion in market value.
0:18 But get this. Retail investors are buying the dip like
0:23 never before, limiting the damage. Live from Singapore.
0:27 The insight with me Haslinda Amin where we dive deeper into the stories that
0:31 matter with crucial context and shop analysis.
0:35 Asian technology shares rally as investors look past Nvidia's leadership
0:39 crisis. The mood also getting a boost from the
0:41 huge demand for anthropic to IPO. With Nvidia in turmoil and anthropic
0:46 blockbuster IPO in play. We dissect the eye trade and the risks
0:51 with Constellation Research principal analyst Ray Wang and his Middle East
0:56 tension squeezed shipping lanes. We discussed supply chain resilience
1:00 with one of the world's largest independent terminal operators.
1:04 Ictsi Cristian Gonzalez will be joining us exclusively.
1:28 Our top story today, one of the i's most important executives has been ousted
1:33 from his post following reports of three extramarital affairs.
1:37 Jensen Huang's departure from Nvidia is the latest development in a fast moving
1:41 crisis, with consequences that threaten to reverberate far beyond the company.
1:47 Faced with a succession crisis, Nvidia's board has picked longtime chief
1:51 financial officer Colette Kress to take the top job in an interim capacity.
1:56 She joined Nvidia 13 years ago after stints at Microsoft and Cisco.
2:01 She spent her career in financial roles at Nvidia.
2:05 Shares initially plunged as much as 14% on news of the ouster before paring
2:09 losses. Investors are grappling with numerous
2:12 questions, including who will be able to fill the shoes of the man who grew in
2:16 Nvidia into one of the most important players in the chip industry.
2:20 Let's bring in, Bloomberg reported. Newly Pournelle and newly Jensen out
2:25 crashes in what would be her, I guess, top priority as we head into the
2:30 earnings season for for Nvidia. Right.
2:34 Hustlin. Well I think immediately you know she
2:37 would be focused on really stabilizing the ship because it's really hard to
2:41 overstate how significant this story has been.
2:44 It's not just about Jensen Huang. It's not just about Nvidia.
2:48 It's as you alluded to earlier, it's about the really the whole global AI
2:53 industry, tech policy, you name it. From the standpoint of funding.
2:57 For example, Nvidia has been a massive backer of American AI firms, of NIO,
3:02 cloud companies that are building out data centers.
3:05 There will be ramifications for its rivals, other chipmakers who might want
3:09 to step in and try to take advantage of this episode.
3:12 And then on tech policy, you know, a big question has been to what extent the US
3:16 can keep chips away from Chinese companies.
3:20 And so you can imagine that there could be China hawks on the hill in the US
3:24 saying, this is exactly why we need to get even tougher.
3:27 So there could be ramifications for that.
3:29 So it's just a massive story. Hustling
3:32 efforts on the way to find a replacement for Jensen Huang.
3:37 Who might that be? I mean, these are big shoes to fill,
3:42 huge shoes to fill, hustling. And our colleague Ian King in San
3:45 Francisco has reported a few names that have been floating around Lisa Sue of
3:50 AMD, Renee Haas of ARM and Sanjay Mehrotra of Micron.
3:55 Again, uh, the difficulty of coming in, this was not a company that was run in
4:01 ordinary way. This is a company that has been
4:04 dominated by Jenson Huang's leadership. Uh, as we have reported, he and and
4:09 others have reported he's been known to have as many as 60 direct reports.
4:13 So it's not like the the person in this case, his immediate replacement can
4:17 simply turn to, you know, vice presidents or other senior leaders and
4:21 say delegate amongst yourselves. He had an unusual amount of day to day,
4:26 um, interaction with so many subordinates.
4:28 He was known to make them list their top priorities, and he would individually
4:33 weigh in. So it's it's a massive role to try to
4:35 fill in any. Any time you take over a big and fast
4:38 moving, dynamic company with enormous clout, it's going to be challenging for
4:42 the leader at the top. But in this case, Huang wielded such
4:45 enormous control in day to day operations that it would be really
4:49 difficult. And of course, we heard from Elon Musk,
4:52 who says that he's willing to hire, uh, Jensen Huang.
4:56 And you got to wonder, uh, you know, where he goes from here.
5:01 Right. And he's so recognizable.
5:02 Hustle. And it's not as if he's sort of an
5:04 anonymous executive who could turn to another, uh, another endeavor.
5:08 Or, you know, we see tech executives sometimes taking a time out and then
5:12 becoming investors or starting VC funds or, uh, going into academia or something
5:17 like that. I mean, he has been the public, the
5:20 global face of particularly the US. I push a real celebrity.
5:24 Uh, so so he will be it will be. It will be a challenge for him, I think,
5:28 to, um, to to let things die down, perhaps, and figure out what comes next.
5:33 But you can imagine, um, the feelings he might have.
5:37 This is, after all, a human story. Um, and you can imagine how he is coping
5:41 with, um, such an abrupt change in fortune.
5:46 Uh, initially, the other issue is really chip controls, uh, on China.
5:51 Where are we with that? What are the indications so far?
5:56 Well, it's early, and we're keeping an ear to the ground, but of course, um,
6:01 Jensen Huang himself was long advocating for the US to allow, uh, chips to to
6:07 come to, uh, to to Chinese companies. Uh, an important element of, uh, U.S.
6:13 tech policy has been to try to constrain the most sophisticated, uh, eye chips
6:17 that Nvidia and others make and keep them out of the hands of Chinese rivals.
6:21 You have to also wonder to what an extent this will only accelerate or, uh,
6:26 or operationalize the plans that China has been developing to create its own
6:30 tech industries ownership industry so it doesn't have to rely.
6:33 We know that they're they're doing that. So, um, we'll we'll be watching that for
6:37 sure to see what the ramifications are for for U.S.
6:39 government. Of course, uh, Donald Trump will be out
6:41 of office in a few months. He's a lame duck now.
6:44 And so there's a big, uh, change in Washington as well.
6:47 So that's one to watch for sure. Nearly.
6:50 Thank you. Tech reporter nearly propelled off for
6:53 us. We're also keeping an eye on Chinese
6:55 tech stocks. That's amid concerns that cloud
6:57 operators access to advanced chips may face tighter US scrutiny, with a
7:02 controversy surrounding Nvidia. For more, let's bring in our North Asia
7:06 correspondent Benjamin Low in Shanghai and min.
7:08 Uh, what's the knock on impact on Chinese tech from this Nvidia saga?
7:16 Hey, guys, I'm just looking at the board there and you're seeing quite a steep
7:20 decline on some of these tech stocks. So the impact will be tremendous.
7:24 Our Bloomberg Intelligence analyst has said that some of the Chinese tech firms
7:29 are at greater risk of being banned by the U.S., especially the pure play names
7:34 on the screen you're seeing there, minimax z AI, uh, because some of them
7:39 have been so-called named and shamed by the US over allegations of distillation
7:44 by Alibaba as well Moonshot I as well. That's not yet a listed company.
7:49 They're looking to list perhaps next year.
7:51 So those geopolitical overhang will be in place as we head into the apex
7:57 summit. Uh, and then as newly mentioned just
8:01 now, uh, the removal of Jensen Huang really opens the gateway for Democrats
8:06 to push for their agenda to tighten some of these, these loopholes when it comes
8:10 to China's access to overseas data centers.
8:13 In fact, the information is reporting that the Commerce Department could be
8:17 coming up with new rules as soon as this month.
8:20 So this is going to harden the stance on China if it comes through.
8:24 And certainly setting us up, well, pretty shaky grounds as we head into the
8:28 Apex summit, where tech will likely be front and center just because of the
8:32 news flow we have been seeing. And remember, the tweet truce is
8:35 expected to end by January, and the extension of of the truce hinges heavily
8:42 on the US pausing any new tech restrictions.
8:45 So if there are new tech hubs, this really changes the calculus of how
8:50 Beijing will respond when it comes to in negotiations.
8:54 Uh, speaking of the apex summit, min. Has Beijing made an official response to
8:59 all of this? Uh, just ahead of that,
9:03 yes. We have repeatedly heard from Beijing.
9:05 Often they keep their comments, uh, and their statement very short.
9:09 So, so far, we have heard them deny any allegations of, uh, spy involvement,
9:14 saying that is a smear campaign against China.
9:16 And yesterday we heard from the Foreign Ministry a slightly longer statement
9:20 this time really defending their innovation, saying that scientific
9:23 progress in China is coming from its own indigenous innovation as well as open
9:28 cooperation. And the U.S.
9:30 shouldn't be using this saga as an excuse, a pretext to expand weight curbs
9:35 on China. And it's really been fascinating to read
9:38 some of these, uh, Chinese commentary and analysts from China.
9:41 You have the former chief editor of Global Times, a Chinese tabloid, very
9:44 high profile figure. He is saying that this is all
9:47 politically calculated, and the fact that Jensen Huang is of Asian and
9:52 Chinese ethnicity. He's being specifically targeted to take
9:55 down this Chinese person, Chinese looking person, at least from one of the
10:01 biggest tech companies in the world. And you have a former Chinese diplomat
10:06 as well, Wang Yi Wei, now with Renmin University saying that this is all
10:09 China, is suffering from the political fallout, the collateral damage from
10:14 internal strife within the US. You also have Wilson from Fudan
10:18 University here in Shanghai, saying that this saga shows that there are people
10:22 within the U.S. intelligence community who are not happy
10:25 with Trump's approach to China. So the China narrative so far, the way
10:29 they're looking at this, is that this is all a U.S.
10:31 problem, and they are using the spy allegations to put a blame on China and
10:34 using it as a pretext to expand curbs on China.
10:39 Strong words out of China. U.S.
10:42 Commerce Secretary Min Howard seems to be in trouble as well.
10:45 What is that about? Yeah, so so far, there has been a lot of
10:51 scrutiny right over who should really be accountable here.
10:54 So of course, there is the internal probe on Jensen Huang that is ongoing.
10:58 But there is also scrutiny on what role exactly did the Commerce Department
11:02 play, especially after New York Times reported that the Nvidia's general
11:06 counsel was in touch with the undersecretary of the Commerce
11:10 Department and was apparently intervening with the Commerce Department
11:15 investigation into mega speed and these alleged smuggling of advanced chips into
11:20 China. So, Howard, lightning is under a lot of
11:22 scrutiny now. There are a lot of senators calling for
11:25 how it lightning to testify in front of the Senate Banking Committee to answer
11:30 questions about to what extent should the Commerce Department be responsible?
11:34 Was there a failure of enforcement here? And of course, was Jensen, Huang and
11:39 Nvidia overly influencing the Commerce Department investigation as well.
11:44 Of course, we know Jensen Huang has been such a proponent of looser restrictions
11:48 on China. He's also been a defendant of
11:51 distillation. Right.
11:52 When you talk about some of these Chinese tech companies that has been
11:54 accused of distillation. Jensen Huang has been one of those one
11:57 of those who say that distillation is a legitimate way to improve on an AI
12:01 model. And he's been calling for more
12:03 restricted, more targeted sort of policies instead of sweeping policies to
12:07 ban or clamp down on distillation. Bloomberg's North Asia correspondent Min
12:13 Winslow, thank you. With more on Jensen Huang in our series
12:17 The Circuit with Emily Chang Phil just weeks before his ouster.
12:21 Subscribers can watch that in full on the terminal, on Bloomberg.com, or on
12:25 the Bloomberg Originals YouTube channel. Plenty more ahead.
12:28 Keep it here with us. This is Bloomberg.
13:02 Retail investors rushing to buy the dip in Nvidia on Thursday after shares
13:06 plunge more than 14% intraday. Then, the research says individual
13:11 traders snapped up a net $111 million in the opening half hour, accounting for
13:16 61% of weekly US retail stock buying. Let's get more
13:22 with Ray Wang, founder and principal analyst at Constellation Research, and
13:26 Garfield Reynolds, who leads Bloomberg's MLive Asia coverage.
13:30 Let's start with you. I mean, it is getting support.
13:32 It could be at an eight month low by Nvidia shares getting support and retail
13:36 investors in particular. Yeah, well, retail investors have been
13:42 among the main buyers across the tech space in Asia and elsewhere.
13:49 Uh, even before the Nvidia situation, when you had some of the declines in the
13:55 coffee and others, we still had reports of South Koreans piling into three times
14:01 leveraged, uh, coffee vehicles. And now overnight, you know, we've got,
14:06 uh, this, uh, report out about the idea that, uh, retail investors in the US
14:11 have been piling into leveraged ETFs for Nvidia, uh, figuring that at 100 under
14:19 $150, which it got to, uh, that was, you know, a very strong likelihood to
14:26 rebound over the long term because, you know, Nvidia is still going to go on
14:30 generating a lot of revenue, selling a lot of chips.
14:33 Uh, the concern has to be for one of the things is keeping institutional
14:39 investors mostly on the sidelines is, you know, what are the longer term
14:44 fallout implications from, uh, both the spying allegations and the concerns that
14:51 therefore are there about, uh, whether Nvidia complied properly with, uh,
14:57 controls on its chip exports. And then there's the straightforward
15:01 concern about, uh, you know, potential lawsuits in the US because of some of
15:08 the statements that were made and the looming possibility of congressional
15:16 inquiries into, you know, what has been going on.
15:20 So there are a lot of risks there, uh, that could complicate the longer term
15:24 outlook for Nvidia. But when you're looking in the short
15:26 term, are you just going it's still making money,
15:31 Ray. It's still making money.
15:32 They say that fundamentals are also intact for Nvidia, so buy the dip or
15:37 not. I would definitely buy the dip.
15:42 Uh, the fundamentals are there as Garfield saying.
15:44 I think the big thing is Jensen put out a five year roadmap.
15:47 There's really a ten year roadmap at Nvidia.
15:49 So the stock is solid. The demand for chips is solid.
15:52 We saw that with the core wave and the nebulous numbers, they were very solid
15:56 numbers. The hyperscalers are still writing the
15:57 checks. Uh the investments are still going
15:59 there. Maybe a slowdown due to permitting, but
16:02 this definitely there. I think the challenge really is what
16:04 happens after the next 5 to 10 years, uh, in place.
16:07 And I think that's really going to be the question as to who will lead that.
16:10 But for the short term, it is a bargain basement price for Nvidia at this
16:13 moment. Uh, and you may miss the bottom of the
16:16 market, but it's certainly going to be one of the lows
16:20 and really earnings coming up really shortly.
16:22 What are you looking on for. I mean it is expected to announce strong
16:25 numbers. But beyond that what should be the
16:28 focus. I would say that there are probably two
16:33 things that should be a focus. One, we have a victory for corporate
16:36 governance. I mean, it's a big loss for AI in terms
16:38 of what we're seeing here. But I think what's going to be important
16:41 is to understand who's going to lead Nvidia going forward.
16:43 What does that search look like? What controls are being put into place
16:46 to ensure that chips are not being smuggled in through Singapore, Dubai
16:49 into China? Uh, what kind of, uh, jurisdictions, uh,
16:54 what kind of lawsuits? Uh, inquiries and subpoenas that are
16:56 going to happen with the U.S. government and Nvidia.
16:59 Uh, and trying to understand the risk profile that Nvidia will face, uh, going
17:03 forward. And then, of course, understanding the
17:04 board governance, uh, making sure that this crisis with corporate governance
17:07 goes away and making sure there is a succession plan that is in there for
17:11 Jensen. Uh, the other stuff, um, well, there's
17:13 going to be a lot that may pop up is noise.
17:15 Uh, the most important part is whether, uh, Jensen and team gave China an
17:20 advantage in the chip wars. And I think that's really the piece that
17:22 your governments can be focused on. But those are the risks.
17:25 Uh, but the business model was solid. Uh, CFO.
17:28 Collette is a solid player in this business and knows what she's doing.
17:31 And of course, the question is succession.
17:33 And I think that's really what we're going to want to know in the next three
17:36 months, about to see how quickly they move into that and how they handle this
17:39 crisis. Of course, we've seen a massive selloff
17:43 in the stock. You've got to wonder how do you stop the
17:46 bleeding at Nvidia. Well, I think what Ray was outlining,
17:52 you know, those are the sort of things that investors are going to be looking
17:55 for that you do have the potential that whoever is going to take over at the top
18:00 of Nvidia will have a sort of honeymoon period where investors will go, okay,
18:05 you show us, you know, how you are going to, you know, keep Nvidia the business
18:11 going in the way that it was, you know, before all this came along.
18:15 And if, uh, you know, the board and the new CEO can satisfy investors on that
18:22 side of things, then you would have the potential that Nvidia could turn from,
18:27 uh, you know, a major drag on the eye space back into what it hasn't been for
18:32 some time, which would be Alita. Uh, you know, if I there's a sort of
18:36 what doesn't kill this makes it stronger situation.
18:41 You know, uh, Ray, of course, the focus has been circular financing.
18:45 How Nvidia has been financing hyperscale deals.
18:49 Are you expecting a slowdown without Jensen Huang at the helm?
18:57 It's going to be different setting up those partnerships.
18:59 A lot of them were Jensen's passion. He built out the next five layers of the
19:03 eye market. So seeding the next set of start ups in
19:06 the next set of photonics that's required for communications with these
19:09 high speed data centers sitting up the next level of eye investments.
19:13 So while some of that might be seen as circular financing, a lot of it was also
19:17 creating the next markets for the 510 years out.
19:20 That is what's going to be missing without a visionary leader.
19:22 I'm not saying they won't find a visionary leader that could replace, uh,
19:25 Johnson. I mean, there's names on the board.
19:27 Anyway. From Renee.
19:28 Passed that a arm to Thomas Kurian at Google Cloud.
19:31 Uh, I mean, there's some great people that are out there or Ian Buck
19:34 internally, but that vision, that relationship, that passion for where I
19:38 is, it's very hard to beat Johnson. He was the, uh, you know, he was the
19:42 poster boy for AI and, uh, definitely for all the innovations that were there.
19:46 So I think that's what's going to be missed, uh, especially in the scandal.
19:50 Uh, is this an opportunity for Nvidia rivals like AMD?
19:54 Like perhaps Broadcom might they, you know, be accelerating efforts to to I
20:01 guess uh bring down the dominance of Nvidia.
20:10 Uh I would say yes. And I would say that they have an
20:12 opportunity. They definitely have an opportunity to
20:14 get into this market. Um, if you think about the relationships
20:17 that were forged over the last 33 years, our TSMC, uh, to be able to create the
20:22 type of chips that Nvidia has been building.
20:24 I mean, those relationships are going to go away.
20:26 Uh, in the long run. It's not going to be the same.
20:29 Uh, if you look at what, uh, Lisa Su has been able to do with the epic and the
20:32 instant chips at AMD, they're getting into the data center business very
20:35 significantly. Uh, and this means that, you know,
20:38 they're going to create openings. You see, the specialized chips are being
20:40 created by Broadcom. You see what Google has been doing
20:43 releasing GPUs. Um and so so there are openings here.
20:46 Uh but Nvidia's lead is 24 to 36 months. And I think that's an important piece to
20:50 look at. If you look at the revenues we're going
20:52 to see numbers uh, next week. Uh, you'll see that, you know, they may
20:56 be widening that lead. Uh, given where their dominance is at
20:58 this moment. And of course, next week will be crazy
21:01 with the anthropic IPO as well. Of course, uh, golf is also about the
21:07 legal, uh, liabilities that we may see, uh, imposed on Nvidia.
21:13 How is that risk being factored into the market?
21:18 Well, I think at the moment, uh, you know, if you look at the charts you're
21:23 showing. Um, yeah, there's an impressive bounce
21:26 from the lows yesterday, but the stock is still, you know, a long way down.
21:30 Uh, it is likely to go on trading. Uh, what is a rare situation for Nvidia,
21:37 but at a discount on a forward earnings basis?
21:40 You know, to maybe even the S&P 500, let alone the Nasdaq and some of the other
21:45 your major tech companies that it's usually been valued at about the same
21:49 as. So
21:51 that's likely to go on, uh, for some time precisely because you have those
21:58 imponderables about, you know, what the costs might be from the legal side.
22:03 So there'll be that continuing discount on an earnings valuation base, which
22:08 makes next week's earnings all that, all the more important.
22:12 Ray, just to wrap up the conversation I want to get your views on.
22:17 Go ahead Ray. I was going to add the guards point,
22:21 right? I mean, the NASDAQ p ratios at 27 to 29.
22:24 Uh, Nvidia's at 21. I mean, it is a bargain.
22:27 Uh, and he's definitely right there. Right.
22:31 Before we let you go, what do you make of this this Microsoft outage?
22:34 It's trying to fix it, but it's not quite doing it yet.
22:40 Uh, we have been down. Um, that's why I couldn't get the zoom
22:42 link to get into the show earlier. I mean, this has been going on for quite
22:46 some time. This has been a risk Microsoft has had
22:48 for a long time. They are out of capacity.
22:50 They have been trying to figure out how to get more capacity without triggering
22:53 the Wall Street. Uh, you know, the bears in terms of the
22:56 eye trade, if they add too much capacity, they get punished that they
22:59 don't have enough capacity, they get punished.
23:01 This is one of those examples where they're being punished for not having
23:03 the right capacity in place. There's also potential that there's a
23:05 hack on the back end. Uh, and so I think both things may be
23:08 happening at the same time. Ray Wang, founder and principal analyst
23:13 at Constellation Research, and Garfield Reynolds, who leads Bloomberg's Live
23:16 Asia coverage. Thank you.
23:18 Coming up, our exclusive conversation with Philippine ports operator Ictsi.
23:24 Well, this caused the third quarter earnings beats and the outlook for the
23:27 business as the Iran war drags on. Keep it here with us.
23:30 This is Bloomberg.
23:40 Welcome back. You're watching inside.
23:42 President Trump has floated a new strategy for his war against Iran.
23:46 Leave the conflict in limbo and walk away.
23:50 The U.S. leader says he told Vice President JD
23:52 Vance not to negotiate with Tehran. He also suggests the conflict could end
23:57 without a deal to impose agreed upon limits on Tehran's nuclear weapons
24:02 program. Trump discussed the issue in a pre-taped
24:05 interview with Stephen A Smith posted to Smith's YouTube channel.
24:10 I could end it immediately, at the request of the nations that I'm looking
24:15 to protect. We are doing it a little bit longer.
24:19 Way. A little bit more severely.
24:21 Uh, Saudi Arabia has asked me to, uh, please just let it be the way it is now
24:27 for a while, because it is integrating. Uh, Qatar, if you look at that, uh,
24:32 Kuwait, UAE, Bahrain, all of them would rather would much prefer, uh, the
24:39 waiting period. The volatility in oil continues as the
24:45 Iran war drags along the elevated prices, putting import dependent
24:48 economies in the spotlight like Israel. Hong is here for a look at what's at
24:53 stake. April.
24:54 Yeah. I mean, you look at how oil prices are
24:57 trending today, pretty much holding the gains of the past two sessions,
25:00 following on from Trump's comments that, you know, the US does not need a deal
25:05 with Iran and that he's instructed his vice president not to have those talks
25:11 focus instead on the domestic issues. so hopes are dwindling.
25:15 About backchannel negotiations, which are crucial, of course, for this end to
25:20 the conflict. You're seeing that behavior in brand,
25:23 but it is still headed for its second weekly decline.
25:27 And the board, as you can imagine, that's proving to be a reprieve for
25:32 energy import dependent economies in the Asia Pacific, including India and the
25:38 Philippines. Policy policymakers there have spent a
25:41 lot of money this year trying to support local currencies.
25:45 And these occurrences, of course, that have been plumbing lows, record lows in
25:50 the year of 2026. You're seeing how FX reserves have been
25:54 eroded, for example. So looking at the performance in the
25:58 Indian rupee, Philippine peso, in the past two weeks, they have been actually
26:02 outperforming gaining ground. Now when it comes to Philippine stocks,
26:07 of course, given the specter of elevated inflation, that has not just proven to
26:13 mean higher costs for Philippine companies is also constrained
26:17 consumption in the country. And that is the overhang when it comes
26:22 to stocks. So it's really interesting.
26:24 Against that backdrop, we are still seeing bright spots in the Philippine
26:28 stock market, including companies that get most of their earnings from overseas
26:34 US. Averil thank you.
26:35 International Container Terminal Services reported net income for the
26:39 third quarter that beat estimates. Contributions from newly added
26:42 facilities drove up cargo volume. However, volumes were affected by
26:47 disruptions from the tensions in the Middle East.
26:49 Joining us exclusively now to discuss business strategy, Cristian Gonzalez, an
26:54 advisor and National Container Terminal Services Chris, good to have you with
26:57 us. I mean, profit surging 20%.
27:00 The question is whether those double digit numbers are sustainable going
27:03 forward given the current environment. A morning has to end.
27:09 Thank you for having me on. Um, look, I mean, we will certainly be
27:13 challenged by the the drop in consumer demand in, in, in the Philippines, which
27:18 is still about 20% of our, our total business.
27:24 However, um, we do see, um, tailwinds in other markets.
27:30 There are there are projects that are coming on stream doing better than we
27:34 expect in, in South Africa and in Indonesia.
27:39 Um, as well as a lot of capacity that's coming into the system from the the
27:44 hundreds of millions of dollars that we've we've recently invested over the
27:48 last couple of years, um, into places like, uh, like Australia, Mexico, um,
27:54 the DRC and a number of other facilities that we operate.
27:59 Uh, in terms of CapEx for 2027, what are you looking at?
28:03 Can it be higher than, you know, the estimated 740 million?
28:07 Where do you intend to spend? Um, we we certainly expect to continue,
28:15 um, uh, developing facilities like Mexico.
28:19 Um, we're doing some expansions in, in, um, in Australia as well.
28:23 So those are multi, multi year projects. We're doing a very we're doing a very
28:28 are building a very ambitious uh, project in, in Batangas south of Manila.
28:34 Um, to, to help support um, to help support um trade growth into the
28:40 Philippines, which we expect to pick up, um, in the mid to the long term.
28:45 Um, and you know, there are there are opportunities, of course, to also put
28:50 money into the new facilities, uh, in Batam in Indonesia and, and Durban in
28:54 South Africa, among others. Any appetite to acquire new terminals,
29:00 and if so, where might they be? Yeah, absolutely.
29:07 I mean, where, you know, despite the challenges we see all around the world
29:11 geopolitically. Um, and on the trade front, we're always
29:16 extremely active in all the regions we're in.
29:19 Um, we're we're very, very keen to continue expanding in, in, in southern
29:24 and western Africa, although there there aren't specific opportunities there at
29:30 the moment. Um, the one that's really, um, you know,
29:34 keeping our attention, um, in, in Latin America is the potential tender for a
29:41 new container terminal in Santos in Brazil, which we're extremely keen to
29:45 participate in. And in one that will be, will be very,
29:50 very aggressive. Uh, Chris, there's still no resolution
29:55 in the Iran war. I'm just wondering whether you've seen
29:58 any disruptions in your operations in the Emir region.
30:05 It not not. I mean, let's let's focus on what we
30:10 have one terminal, uh, that's in the, in the Persian Gulf.
30:14 So which is impacted by the closure or part time closure of the Strait of
30:18 Hormuz, which is in, uh, in Basra in Iraq.
30:22 Um, the over the years, it's it's made up about 4 to 5% of, of total
30:28 throughput. So the the impact hasn't been
30:31 significant. The what what I do, what I do and have
30:36 been telling, um, you know, stakeholders and, and active shareholders is that we
30:42 see this as a tremendous opportunity going forward because once the once the
30:47 strait fully reopens, um, it's like we're adding, uh, a container terminal
30:53 with $1 million of capacity and a fast growing market to our portfolio.
30:57 Um, so while there has been an impact over the last nine months, and there
31:01 will likely continue to be an impact to the tune of, say, 3 to 4% of revenue
31:06 over. Over the next few quarters.
31:10 Um, once it does open up. Um, especially given the, the cost
31:15 rebasing we've been able to do at that terminal, I think it's going to have a
31:18 material impact to, to our, our margins and profitability going forward.
31:23 So this, this there's actually a silver lining in all of this.
31:27 I'm also wondering if you're actually benefiting from the divergence from the
31:31 Red sea. Could your ports terminals in you know,
31:34 in Africa, in Asia be benefiting from that?
31:40 Well, we, we really we really focus on on operating gateway terminals.
31:45 So focus on import the import and export trade.
31:48 So um, the the short answer is no, there's no real benefit to it.
31:54 Um, however, I mean, these disruptions have um, created an environment where
32:01 where shipping lines have started increasing their freight rates, um,
32:05 which is always a, uh, an environment which, which gives us slightly more
32:10 pricing power. I mean, our, our rates are, are fairly
32:15 well regulated. 70% of our revenue is regulated.
32:18 But where, where we can where we can edge rates up.
32:22 It's it's easier to do so in an environment where, where shipping rates
32:27 are coming up as opposed to the opposite.
32:31 Uh, I'd like to take a look at your IPO plans as the mamas out there suggesting
32:37 that you're planning to move it to Hong Kong.
32:39 Can you clarify if that is happening? Um, no.
32:46 Um. No comment.
32:50 Uh, um. Staying put?
32:53 Uh, how about in terms of valuation, can can you suggest perhaps what kind of
32:57 valuation we You might be expecting. No.
33:01 I mean, you know, at the moment the plan is to stay put.
33:05 But, you know, we we always will evaluate different opportunities to do
33:12 increase liquidity in particular. What are some of the considerations
33:17 Chris. Just take us through the thinking on
33:19 this IPO. Well it I suppose it wouldn't be it
33:26 wouldn't be an IPO. And like I said, we're we're we're not
33:29 planning that at all at the moment. Um, we, you know, we we always keep an
33:35 eye on, on, on opportunities to improve the, you know, the, you know, the, the
33:42 companies, the companies, uh, performance and the performance for
33:47 shareholders. Um, and if at some stage there, there is
33:52 an opportunity to, to drive liquidity forward by, by moving on to a different
33:57 market. We will evaluate it, but at the moment
34:00 there are no no specific plans for the crisis.
34:03 Currently, the world is bracing for perhaps even more, uh, tariffs as the
34:08 Trump administration mulls over what to do next in terms of tariffs on, you
34:14 know, trading, uh, countries. I'm just wondering, how do you see that
34:17 shaping global trade? What are you seeing in terms of your own
34:21 volumes, in your own numbers? Well, I think if if we look back to, to
34:29 liberation, the so-called Liberation Day, um, that that was actually neutral,
34:35 advantageous to us, I mean, global trade continued to move.
34:39 I think there, there, you know, it gave, um, specific advantages to China in
34:45 particular. Um, and if if you look at if you look at
34:49 our exposure to the United States specifically or the markets that we're
34:52 in. Yeah, exposure to the United States is
34:55 very limited. And, you know, because of because of the
35:00 diversion of Chinese trade from, from the United States to these other
35:04 markets, we actually saw an uptick in, in, in imports.
35:09 So I, I would expect that, you know, in these consumption driven economies,
35:16 you know, inflation aside, inflationary pressure aside, people will want to get
35:22 people will want to get the products that they're used to having into the
35:25 countries, and whether they get them from from the U.S.
35:29 or the EU or China, they'll they'll find the the routes with the least friction
35:34 and, you know, continue to support growth for our business.
35:38 Is there a sense that some of the volume you're seeing right now is a result of,
35:43 you know, front loading ahead of higher tariffs, perhaps?
35:50 Um, no, I, I wouldn't say that at all. I wouldn't say that at all.
35:55 I mean, if if there is, if there is front loading, you know, again, looking
36:00 at looking at historical performance, when when we first started having to
36:04 deal with this, it it was a very, very small percentage of the growth we were
36:09 seeing, the import growth we were seeing coming through the facilities.
36:13 And again, that's just speaking speaking from from our, you know, from our
36:18 perspective in the places we operate in. Chris.
36:22 Thank you. Cristian Gonzalez, senior advisor at
36:25 International Container Terminal Services.
36:28 Coming up, an exclusive conversation with and Chandrababu Naidu, the Chief
36:32 minister of India's Andhra Pradesh state.
36:35 We'll hear from him about the state's Google AI hub and the impact of recent
36:38 youth protests. Keep it here with us.
36:41 This is been back.
36:51 Welcome back. You're watching inside.
36:53 Here's a look at the market open in India.
36:55 Stocks coming online just as the rest of the region sees investors easing back
37:00 into tech shares. The nifty is in focus after rallying for
37:03 three straight days from the get go, with the nifty currently down by 7/10 of
37:07 1%. Still in overseas, investors have
37:10 started reducing their underweight positions after an extended period of
37:14 selling, while long only funds are also beginning to allocate more money to
37:17 India. Meantime, the Chief minister of the
37:20 Indian state of Andhra Pradesh says Google's $15 billion eye hub in the
37:26 state is on track to start operations in 2028.
37:30 Chandrababu Naidu told Bloomberg exclusively that the state is taking
37:34 steps to address the growing concerns around power and water supply.
37:40 But everything, we are taking all precautions.
37:44 Andhra Pradesh we are producing nearly one 60GW green energy.
37:51 Now we are getting one project. Solar green energy transmission lines
37:59 from Rayalaseema to here. Now in the same way we are going
38:04 different ways so far. One is solar.
38:07 One is vein. One is pumped storage.
38:12 I am having so many projects. Every project I can go for pumped
38:17 storage, then ultimately to match temporarily I
38:23 can go battery. Finally I can go to again some time.
38:29 Even thermal.
38:33 Uh, I am confident. What all I am doing.
38:36 I can meet the power demand. That is one water.
38:41 Wherever water is available. Visakhapatnam.
38:44 There won't be any problem for that. Now.
38:47 Every day, two terms of order. I am bringing from God very to the
38:52 circle, but not by gravity. Now we are linking reverse.
38:57 My point on project is completing by March 2027.
39:03 From then onwards water will flow by gravity.
39:07 So that is another area. Then another problem.
39:11 Employment generation is going to come knowledge economy in a big way.
39:15 The National Green Tribunal also seems to have flagged several gaps in the
39:19 environmental clearances as well. Will you agree to an independent
39:23 assessment of the environmental clearances?
39:25 So perhaps relook at the way environmental clearances have been given
39:29 in this know everything we have obtained?
39:33 Some people may file unnecessary. Also we will address every problem.
39:38 What are you telling Google at this point of time?
39:40 No, we are with them first time.
39:44 15 billion USD investment. They are putting in the suck up, but now
39:49 they also fix it for inauguration 28 before August 15th.
39:56 We are going to start. That is the agreement we are doing.
40:00 They are going very well. Even Government of India, they need some
40:04 assurances. We got them very assurance on the
40:07 guarantee also. So at this stage, no going back.
40:12 We are to take to a logical conclusion, but at the same time public interest.
40:17 We will not compromise either myself or Google.
40:20 Right. And that is a, you know, a very, very
40:23 interesting got assurance coming in from you.
40:25 So you're confident that the Google project will meet all its deadlines as
40:29 far as completion is concerned? Everything.
40:31 They will fall in line. They are also more responsible.
40:35 They will also abide everything that way.
40:39 We are discussing continuously. We will take to the logic.
40:41 Can you tell us some of the conversations you are having?
40:44 You saying that Google will be abiding by, you know, the necessary
40:47 requirements. What are you.
40:49 You need a global company. They are also having social
40:53 responsibility. How can they ignore all these things?
40:58 One should have confidence, mutual trust.
41:03 That is where we are working with them. I also am going to shift your focus from
41:07 what's happening in the state to an investment climate that you're looking
41:09 to build, to now move towards what's happening in New Delhi, where youth
41:15 protests were the centre of all attention.
41:18 Do you think the government underestimated the level of frustration
41:22 the youth has? Is there some sort of a disillusionment
41:26 that they that the youth of the country seem to be having at the moment?
41:30 Issue is here. Aspirations are increasing.
41:36 Their means and ends are not meeting together.
41:41 It's a technology everything. If you see fastest economy and bigger
41:47 countries, India is number one. Even their aspirations are more.
41:53 Problems are coming. Now technology is playing very, very
41:59 critical role. Earlier only media like you has to
42:04 inform. Now everybody is the owner of media.
42:07 You can take put it in Instagram. Express issues and probe people.
42:13 That is also happening. So it is very
42:17 positive and very under the same time. We must be very careful also
42:23 politicians. Do you think that the ground reality for
42:27 7% growth is not visible? It is visible, but that is not
42:33 sufficient. I can tell you one thing.
42:37 For the last 12 years, honourable Prime Minister
42:41 Is a strong leader. I have seen more than ten prime
42:45 ministers. People unable to understand technology.
42:51 People are unable to understand the mood of the people.
42:54 You share a great camaraderie with the Prime Minister, for example.
42:58 Did you raise these concerns at any stage with the Prime Minister?
43:02 Did you tell him that the government needed perhaps, to handle the situation
43:05 in a better manner? If if you said that the 7% growth is
43:09 visible. But but it is not enough.
43:13 That is where I am saying we are to restructure everything
43:17 in a way to be disrupted. Thinking
43:21 everybody is thinking disrupt the way government has to think.
43:26 Disruptive. Then only we can reach that aspirations
43:29 or fulfil that aspirations. That is where PM is doing.
43:33 If you cannot do it, nobody can do. Then India will have a different
43:39 situation I'm telling. Handling and also mating.
43:43 This type of situation is very difficult to see how the concerns of the youth in
43:46 the country legitimate. Any of you
43:49 know legit what I am saying. There are genuine some problems.
43:55 Some problems. Imaginative.
44:00 Sometimes imaginative. If you see this, you would not the youth
44:05 this organization. They started with
44:09 paper leakage. Now they are talking about elections
44:14 as a political party. That is where I don't the first time.
44:20 I am confident, but issue is farmers are having problem because of so many
44:26 things. Their aspirations are different.
44:31 Their income is different. One year there is a drought.
44:36 There is a problem. Sometimes no prizes.
44:41 These are all the problems they are facing.
44:43 Youth. If anybody will go from 10th class
44:47 onwards to a polytechnic, they will get immediately
44:53 job ₹30,000 income.
44:57 Suppose you complete B. Then you go for the job.
45:02 Very difficult to get job. If you get job also, you will get only
45:05 15 20,000. That is a problem that this type of
45:10 problem is how to address. All of us has to work it out along with
45:14 it. So there is a mismatch between the
45:16 aspiration of the youth in the country and what the government of the day are.
45:21 We know not only that we are doing our best,
45:25 but their aspirations are more. We have to communicate and connect and
45:32 meet their aspirations as far as possible.
45:37 And that was under Pradesh Chief Minister Chandrababu Naidu, speaking
45:41 exclusively to Bloomberg. And Bloomberg has launched a dedicated
45:45 digital experience for India. Subscribers can visit Bloomberg.com
45:49 India for exclusive reporting and curated features, videos as well as
45:54 other content from our global newsroom. Still ahead on our show, President Trump
45:59 says the US doesn't need a deal with Iran.
46:01 We'll get Pimco view on the renewed risks to oil supplies, plus the Asia
46:07 Group's initiative as well. We'll be with us as we look ahead to
46:10 Indian Prime Minister Narendra modi's visit to Manila next week for the Asean
46:14 summit. Plenty more ahead in the next hour of
46:17 insight. Keep it here with us.
46:19 This is Bloomberg.
46:36 Nvidia's probably got the most valuable IP on the planet.
46:39 Um, the vision here of, uh, Nvidia is going to be called into question.
46:44 I think we have to view this as a transitional issue and a bit more
46:48 tactical in nature. Is the AI trade one man or is it a
46:52 company that is, you know, kind of leading the charge on a on a relative
46:56 basis is essentially losing someone who can bring, uh, together all the parties.
47:01 I also think that that, um, that we will move forward, that the underlying this
47:06 once in a generation innovation will carry through.
47:11 Hey. Welcome back.
47:13 You're watching inside. Those were some of our guests reacting
47:16 to Jensen Huang's ouster from Nvidia after his swift fall from grace as the
47:21 only CEO in the company's three decade history.
47:24 He played a key role in growing Nvidia into the dominant player in the AI
47:28 universe. Bloomberg Tech anchor Ed Ludlow looks at
47:31 the fallout from a I losing its poster boy and its most vocal cheerleader.
47:39 Jenson Wong's resignation as CEO of Nvidia and stepping down as a director
47:44 from the board is effective immediately. Bloomberg also confirmed that as it
47:49 stands on an ongoing basis, he will have no affiliation with Nvidia.
47:53 He will not be there in a consulting or advisory basis.
47:56 There will be no chairman emeritus. He will not have employee status.
48:00 He'll continue to be a shareholder, of course, but his economic ownership of
48:03 the company is relatively modest compared to his peers in the field, and
48:06 he has no sort of super voting rights or super voting power.
48:09 His exit follows revelations about affairs, but more specifically one with
48:14 Alice Wong, a mega speed executive whom U.S.
48:17 officials suspect of working for Chinese intelligence, allegedly a spy for China.
48:24 Nvidia's board had already opened an independent investigation into that.
48:28 There is still no update on that front, other than them appointing third party
48:34 and outside counsel to aid with it. Nvidia did not give a reason
48:37 specifically in its board statement for Huang's resignation.
48:41 Huang is not quoted in the announcement. CFO Colette Kress becomes CEO on an
48:45 interim basis, while Nvidia's board conducts a pretty wide search of both
48:50 internal and external candidates to lead this company that has become the leader
48:55 in chips for AI. Uh, that's an understatement.
48:59 The dominant player in AI chips around the world.
49:02 One other slightly, uh, material change is that for the first time, Nvidia's
49:06 board will have a chair. And that is Harvey Jones, who's been a
49:09 director since 1993, again alongside Colette Kress, interim CEO.
49:14 A known quantity to Wall Street, a director who is familiar as well and add
49:19 some continuity. The question everyone, uh, closed the
49:22 day with is what is Nvidia without Jensen?
49:26 This is Ed Ludlow for Bloomberg News in San Francisco.
49:31 Let's do a check in on the market reaction with April Hong April Asian
49:36 stocks mostly taking the Nvidia fallout in stride, with the exception of China.
49:40 Absolutely has. I think investors in the region are keen
49:43 to look past this Nvidia scandal, with Colette Kress at the helm as interim
49:48 CEO. Maybe there is a level of continuity and
49:52 also she can help to steady the ship. Investors are also banking on this idea
49:57 that they're still very solid. I demand you think about the memory
50:01 shortages that still exist. And then add to that anthropic IPO that
50:05 is said to be several times oversubscribed.
50:09 That being said, if you take a look at the earlier bounce that we saw on the
50:13 cost of about 3%, gains have evaporated. So you get the sense that caution still
50:19 lingers that the board the clear today, the Chinese tech names.
50:24 Don't forget Jensen Huang was the most influential opponent to tighter U.S.
50:30 restrictions on China. And now these Chinese hawks are getting
50:34 a lot more ammunition. The worry is that we see perhaps China's
50:39 access to chips being further constrained, and that, in turn holds
50:43 back AI development in China. The IPR place to pool minimax.
50:48 These are the ones that are getting hardest hit for yet another day.
50:51 The hyperscalers not spared either. Think about as well the macro backdrop
50:57 weak Chinese consumption overall, that is an added concern.
51:01 That is what we're seeing in the picture in Asian markets for the moment.
51:04 Evil. Thank you.
51:05 Let's get to Bloomberg opinion columnist Catherine Thorbecke.
51:09 She says China is a big loser from Huang's ouster.
51:12 She joins us now for more. Katherine.
51:14 Why do you say China could be the biggest loser from Huang's ouster?
51:18 What's the basis of that? Right.
51:21 So, you know, as it's been mentioned, Uh, Jensen, I was really the biggest
51:26 cheerleader for Chinese Eye in the U.S., in Washington and in Silicon Valley.
51:30 And he was one of the most influential voices really calling for China to not
51:34 be completely cut off. And, you know, I was thinking earlier, I
51:37 really for a long time thought one of Jensen's big legacies would be sort of
51:41 building these really improbable bridges between China and the U.S.
51:45 and Chinese and American eye. And obviously, his legacy has been
51:49 completely tainted. But I think with him gone, you know, I
51:52 wonder if that kind of leaves China stranded.
51:54 I do think that there's going to be a lot more vocal advocates for much
51:57 tighter restrictions on Chinese access to chips.
52:01 Uh, that's right. I mean, how does that go?
52:04 How does this crisis go beyond access to Nvidia chips in China?
52:10 Right. And I think it's not just about chips.
52:12 You know, Jensen was also one of those figures who came out in support of, uh,
52:16 open models, which, as we know, is where Chinese, uh, AI companies have really
52:20 hedged most of their bets. He also openly defended distillation,
52:23 which is this, uh, process of training one model on the outputs of another,
52:27 which has really caused a big hullabaloo in Washington and led to calls for
52:31 banning Chinese AI models in the US, whereas Jensen was very vocal in
52:35 defending that and in defending Chinese AI models, defending distillation and
52:39 really coming out and supporting that and being very influential there.
52:42 And I think with his voice gone, I think some louder voices that might be calling
52:46 for more restrictions on Chinese AI in the US and more bans, I think those will
52:50 really grow. So I think it it it's really hard to
52:54 overstate what an impact he had on sort of building these bridges, as I
52:57 mentioned, uh, it will deepen the mistrust.
53:00 Right. Katherine, how does Wong's exit?
53:02 Absolutely. What does it mean actually, for us
53:04 China, I race. So I think one thing about Wang's exit
53:10 that maybe isn't talked about enough is there was some hope that maybe it didn't
53:14 have to be a zero sum game. Maybe we could find some way to
53:16 cooperate, at least on an issues like AI safety.
53:19 And I think with Wong gone, you know, I'm not sure how that's going to go.
53:22 I think that the mutual distrust is just going to keep growing.
53:25 And I worry about sort of an even further divorce.
53:28 And I worry also that that sort of leaves China stranded on one side.
53:32 And I think with, you know, in the long run, they definitely want it to be
53:35 self-sufficient and chips. But I think a harder cutoff or more
53:38 restrictions will definitely cause a lot of pain right now.
53:41 There is a sense of perhaps even in your opinion, that this could be like the
53:46 Cold War. Yes.
53:49 I mean, we've definitely seen that. And I think, uh, especially, you know,
53:52 we were hoping for for U.S. China air safety talks this month,
53:56 actually. And I was hoping, you know, there's very
53:59 just glimmers of hope that we could find some way to cooperate, at least on sort
54:02 of these, uh, more existential catastrophic risks.
54:05 You know, remember, even a week ago, that's what everybody was talking about,
54:08 and I and now it's, of course, all this, uh, Jensen, uh, scandal.
54:12 But I think that with Jensen gone, you know, I do really worry about who are
54:16 going to be those, those sort of bridges who who can, Uh, both the U.S.
54:20 and China. Sort of find.
54:22 How can they find common ground here when it comes to these these sort of big
54:25 issues like AI safety? Catherine.
54:28 Thank you. Bloomberg opinion columnist Katherine
54:31 for bag. Later today, our special edition of
54:33 Bloomberg Quicktake Europe. Well, look at the impact of Jensen
54:36 Huang's ouster on the region's tech ecosystem and what it means for
54:40 investors that's airing at the times on your screen.
54:44 Coming up, oil prices in focus after President Trump says a deal with Iran
54:48 isn't needed because Greg Schnell joins us next with his outlook for crude.
54:54 Keep it here with us. This is Bloomberg.
54:59 President Trump has floated a new strategy for its war against Iran.
55:03 Leave the conflict in limbo and walk away.
55:07 The U.S. leader says he told Vice President JD
55:09 Vance not to negotiate with Tehran. He also suggests the conflict could end
55:13 without a deal to impose agreed upon limits on Tehran's nuclear weapons
55:18 program. Trump discussed the issue in a pre-taped
55:20 interview with Stephen A Smith posted to Smith's YouTube channel.
55:26 I could end it immediately, at the request of the nations that I'm looking
55:31 to protect. We are doing it a little bit longer,
55:35 way, a little bit more civilly. Uh, Saudi Arabia has asked me to, uh,
55:40 please just let it be the way it is now for a while because it is integrating,
55:45 uh, Qatar. If you look at that, uh, Kuwait, UAE,
55:50 Bahrain, all of them would rather would much prefer, uh, the waiting period.
55:58 And here's a look at oil prices after President Trump dimmed hopes for a swift
56:02 diplomatic end to the war. Global benchmark Brent is set for a
56:06 second weekly decline after hitting a six month high at the end of October.
56:10 For more, let's bring in our oil reporter, Nicholas Lowe.
56:13 Nick, what's the outlook here? Where do we go from here?
56:19 As always, has Linda with the oil markets.
56:21 These things are as clear as mud, right? Let's not forget that we were close to
56:25 the 120 so at the start of November, and we've lost almost like $25 because
56:33 of the sense that there was some sort of diplomatic backchannel, some sort of
56:37 attempt to bring this war to an end. Right.
56:40 And come to terms. You know, we've had whispers about the
56:43 nuclear issue of even being back on the table.
56:45 And I think with this, uh, post overnight, Trump sort of thrown the
56:48 spanner back into the works. Right.
56:50 So we've seen prices pick up 3% more than that overnight.
56:53 And we're still holding those gains precisely on the uncertainty.
56:56 If we thought a swift resolution was coming.
57:00 Trump's comments, including those he made to Steven, are suggesting that
57:03 that's not anywhere coming anytime soon. But, Nick, we were just talking about a
57:09 Saudi production at the highest levels in yes, I mean, uh, where's the buffer
57:16 from that? I'm glad you asked about that house,
57:22 because I think an important thing to remember is that part of the reason why
57:25 I was not higher than it currently already is like it's already pricing in
57:29 the fact that some of these flows have returned from major producers.
57:32 Right. Like, as you say, um, Saudi Arabia,
57:34 OPEC's largest producer, producing, uh, in fact a little bit over its, uh, OPEC
57:39 quota lately. It's all it reported.
57:41 And that's precisely because, uh, the street, although officially still very
57:46 dangerous. We've seen what, something like 36
57:48 attacks since, uh, October, uh, on tankers passing through it.
57:52 Um, actually have seen a lot of flows of crude coming out.
57:55 Right. So in some ways, while the threat of an
57:58 escalation is still there, and Trump himself has added to that earlier by
58:02 saying he would, uh, potentially attack Iran.
58:04 And of course, he's walked back that now, um, it doesn't change the fact that
58:08 actually there is a lot of oil coming out.
58:10 Right? So in some ways, the well, it's not as
58:13 on edge as it was in early March when this crisis all started.
58:18 So what are we looking for in the coming weeks, in the coming months?
58:24 I think the two things to watch out first, the physical markets and then the
58:28 geopolitics on the physical markets, let's see how much more flows come out
58:32 of the street. Crude levels are much higher than they
58:35 were when the war started. Products.
58:37 The thing I watch more closely in some ways, the stuff that affects everyday
58:40 life. Things like diesel, things like LPG for
58:42 cooking. These are things that have inflationary
58:45 pressure, right? Those haven't come out of the street as
58:47 much as we would like, but because so much crude is coming out that's being
58:51 processed in refineries around the world into the fuels that the world needs.
58:55 The other thing, of course, is to watch the Trump factor in geopolitics, how
58:59 much more, uh, unsteady diplomatic negotiations are going to go.
59:03 And that's in some ways harder to predict than physical flows.
59:08 Nick. Thank you.
59:09 Bloomberg. Oil reporter Nicholas Lowe are there for
59:11 us. Joining us now, Greg Shear now.
59:13 Commodities and real assets portfolio manager at Pimco.
59:17 Good to have you with us. I'm just wondering, what assumptions are
59:19 you making about the oil market as we head into, I guess, the winter season?
59:25 So it's thank you for having me on. Now, the problem with assumptions in the
59:29 oil market right now is when I started doing research as an economist, we'd be
59:33 looking at 300,000 barrels per day imbalances and drawing major conclusions
59:37 on oil prices. We have moving factors in our balances
59:41 right now, whether it be Chinese demand will be Middle Eastern exports, Russian
59:45 refinery activity that are on the orders of millions of barrels a day.
59:48 So it's very fluid environment. So when we think about where we are
59:51 right now, we're primarily most concerned with a re escalation because
59:55 should that happen the buffers in the global system are much lower than they
59:59 were going back 7 or 8 months ago when the conflicts it began.
1:00:03 We're also heading into winter, as you noted, which also means there's some in
1:00:06 elasticity, in demand because you want to heat your homes.
1:00:09 Regardless of the price, people are going to do their best to do so.
1:00:12 So we're in a we're on a tenterhooks, for lack of a better word right now,
1:00:17 because it is a very fine balance that we are that we're currently within.
1:00:21 So what am I worried about? I'm worried about every escalation.
1:00:24 I'm market has changed its probabilities post the US elections on the imminent
1:00:29 nature of that. But we do know that there has been
1:00:32 concerns with additional aircraft carrier moving to the region.
1:00:36 Warnings put out by US embassies. There's a lot of conflicting
1:00:40 information. And President Trump has been, uh, making
1:00:42 different statements throughout time that are inconsistent with one another.
1:00:45 So it's a lot of uncertainty. At the end of the day, I think we're
1:00:48 looking at prices muddling through. As long as we stay in this no war, no
1:00:51 peace. But after that, it will be a question of
1:00:54 if we have a conflict, what happens to infrastructure?
1:00:56 If not, we could see prices continue to trade down.
1:00:59 If we have an agreement, price is muddling through.
1:01:01 But as you said, there are lots of uncertainties.
1:01:03 How much of those certainties are being reflected at these prices?
1:01:08 Well, we think $90 to $100 is reflecting a non-trivial probability of kind of of
1:01:14 escalation, but also in reality, even in the Middle East.
1:01:17 Right now, these flows are coming out with a massive military support at a
1:01:21 huge cost. And we do see that they actually do
1:01:24 oscillate by millions of barrels a day over the course of a couple of weeks, as
1:01:28 more ships are able to get through. Versus, as the previous reporter noted,
1:01:33 35 to 40 ships have been hit already since the start of the month.
1:01:37 So it is a very fluid situation right now, and millions of barrels per day are
1:01:41 changing. And if you think about a global market
1:01:43 of 100 million barrels a day, these are big numbers that are moving underneath
1:01:46 the surface. We talk about buffers for the crude
1:01:49 market, but when it comes to refined products diesel that's tighter.
1:01:54 How tight is it. Incredibly tight.
1:01:57 Now we're making some headway and improvement because refinery runs
1:02:00 outside of the Middle East and outside of Russia are running as hard as they
1:02:04 can to produce as much product as possible.
1:02:07 They're very profitable to do so. So they are trying to capture that
1:02:10 margin. But it also means we have very little
1:02:13 spare capacity anywhere in the system. You do not want to run your power.
1:02:17 You don't want to run your water. You don't want to run your gas
1:02:19 distribution networks at 100% capacity utilization.
1:02:22 That's what the refining market is, which is what is critical to producing
1:02:26 the products that we want. So any disruptions is a big problem.
1:02:30 And then you have the other fact that a lot of these refiners deferred
1:02:33 maintenance from 2026 into 2027. They can't keep on deferring that.
1:02:38 So we're going to have persistent tight markets for the next couple of years,
1:02:42 unless we have a resolution of some of the big factors, such as Russia and the
1:02:46 Middle East, that have been impinging product export.
1:02:48 And of course, no sign in sight of any resolution for all the issues right now.
1:02:53 I mean, who's most at risk? I mean, I imagine Europe is kind of like
1:02:59 getting hit quite badly. Yes, Europe is facing up, you know, big
1:03:03 problems because of high natural gas prices as well as high product prices.
1:03:07 But they're not unique in this. The same prices are filtering through
1:03:10 the global economy. Uh, certainly an oil is a globally
1:03:13 traded commodity, and no one really escapes the high prices outside of
1:03:16 countries that regulate or subsidize their prices.
1:03:19 And they have their own issues to deal with through those subsidies.
1:03:22 And then in terms of global gas, there's only really a few places that actually
1:03:26 get to avoid the pain. The United States being one, because we
1:03:29 have access gas that we can't export fast enough.
1:03:31 Um, and then there's some other countries that also have big domestic
1:03:34 markets and are not really connected, but Asia, uh, Southeast Asia, um, Europe
1:03:41 all face a lot of the burdens and the pains from associated with high natural
1:03:45 gas prices as well. Of course, it is about demand, and part
1:03:48 of the reason why prices have remained at, I guess, contained level, simply
1:03:52 because China hasn't been dipping into, you know, the the oil market is kind of
1:03:56 coming back. They have they've actually come back.
1:03:59 The last month's data was only about a million and a half barrels a day, versus
1:04:03 four and a half to five. Only 3 or 4 months ago, China, we
1:04:08 believe, took down inventories for diesel truck, that inventories for
1:04:12 petrochemical took out inventories for crude oil fairly aggressively.
1:04:15 And they are appearing to be changing their path to actually rebuilding some
1:04:20 of their supply chains. So we think they rebuilt the inventories
1:04:23 in October. We'll have to see what November ends up
1:04:26 being. But like in 2022 when prices exploded,
1:04:30 China reduced their buying. And by the end of the year they had
1:04:33 returned to the market. We're seeing something very similar
1:04:36 today where you do see incremental changes.
1:04:39 That's part of the reason why, despite the increase in flows out of the Middle
1:04:42 East, the physical markets have not weakened nearly as much as you would
1:04:45 think with the rebound that we had. What does it mean of prices?
1:04:49 And I'm just wondering as well whether we've seen the peak,
1:04:53 the peak will actually be determined by the evolution of the events and in the
1:04:57 major geopolitical hotspots it was yet to see.
1:04:59 It's too soon to call. It is definitely too soon to salt.
1:05:03 You know, call coast clear. We are definitely an environment right
1:05:06 now or we don't know if that's true. Any projection for, you know, crude
1:05:10 prices, diesel prices in the next one six months.
1:05:13 So one of the things that we do as part of our investment process as a firm is
1:05:16 discuss the distribution of outcomes. The thing that surprised us the most is
1:05:21 how strong the global economy has been, despite the fact that we have had the
1:05:25 largest energy shock in history. Which leads us to then the following
1:05:28 conclusion of if we really needed to damage demand through price rationing,
1:05:32 we are expecting that you would need a lot higher prices than maybe what we
1:05:36 have seen to date or have seen historically, because the global
1:05:39 economy, due to the major CapEx cycles, has been so strong.
1:05:43 So we actually see a distribution as being fairly right tailed.
1:05:46 Should there be adverse events unfolding?
1:05:50 Otherwise we could easily see ourselves muddling along here.
1:05:53 And if we do get an MOU or something of this nature, which leads to a more
1:05:57 normalization of flow. While it's not our highest probability
1:06:01 event relative to the muddle along or potential renewed escalation.
1:06:05 You know, we could see prices come down 15 to 20%.
1:06:08 Uh, Greg, I mean, I'm curious to hear your views on gold because we know that
1:06:13 central banks around the world, including those in Asia, have been
1:06:15 picking up more gold amidst all the uncertainty.
1:06:18 What assumptions are you making about about demand, about prices going forward
1:06:23 so well, it tipped to real yields and on a real basis.
1:06:26 Gold is certainly high relative to history.
1:06:29 But because of what you just mentioned, which is central banks which have not
1:06:33 only been concerned because of inflation, which in this decade.
1:06:37 So starting post Covid, we have seen several bouts of supply side driven
1:06:41 inflation that has led a lot of emerging markets.
1:06:44 And developed markets have really leveraged emerging markets, short
1:06:47 inflation protection. And then you add the effects of the
1:06:51 Russian sanctions post the start of the war.
1:06:53 We've seen a real change in the way in which people, whether it be central
1:06:57 bank, sovereign wealth fund, ultra high net worth individuals viewing gold in
1:07:01 many respects, like what gold is sort of for the millenniums, like it is a
1:07:05 physical asset that retains its value. So I expect and you can see it in the
1:07:10 World Gold Council survey, that central banks will continue to accumulate.
1:07:14 They have shown some price sensitivity backing away in the first quarter of
1:07:18 this year when prices went up 30%. And now we've seen them definitely pick
1:07:22 up. So it's a tug of war between high prices
1:07:25 relative to other real assets. You know, you can have 3% real yields.
1:07:29 It's very attractive relative to gold that doesn't generate a real yield.
1:07:32 But at the same token, like the geopolitical, the global fragmentation
1:07:36 that has underpinned gold is still very much in effect.
1:07:40 Who's leading the pack in buying gold? China.
1:07:42 That is our understanding. They don't want anyone to know the
1:07:45 exact. So we're all trying to triangulate and
1:07:47 what China is purchasing and taking from the domestic market.
1:07:50 But certainly they they have been the leader of the pack for to the best of
1:07:53 our estimates. Greg.
1:07:54 Thank you. Thanks for stopping by and great shout
1:07:56 out commodities in real estate or other real assets.
1:07:59 Portfolio manager at Pimco. Silicon.
1:08:02 Indian Prime Minister Narendra modi gears up to visit Manila next week for
1:08:06 the Asean summit. The Asia groups and Asia Baseball will
1:08:09 be joining us to discuss India's pitch to Southeast Asia.
1:08:12 Keep it here with us. This is Mumbai.
1:08:21 Welcome back. You're watching insight.
1:08:23 Next week is gearing up to be a big week for diplomacy.
1:08:27 Indian Prime Minister Narendra modi will be in Manila for the Asean and East Asia
1:08:31 Summit. And later in the week, Chinese President
1:08:33 XI Jinping will chair the APEC Economic Leaders Summit in Shenzhen, where
1:08:38 President Trump is expected for more. Bloomberg's Manika Doshi joins us now.
1:08:42 And, Monica, what outcomes should we be watching on for next week and how will
1:08:47 they shape India's ties in the region? Wow.
1:08:52 I wish I had the answer to that. I'd be a very rich person.
1:08:56 I have no idea what the outcome will likely be, but as you pointed out, it's
1:09:01 going to be a few weeks of high geopolitical drama because like you
1:09:05 said, we have now, I think three big summits coming up, the Asean summit, the
1:09:11 apex summit. And let's not forget, in December we
1:09:14 have the US hosting the G20 summit. These are all opportunities for face to
1:09:19 face time between Prime Minister Narendra modi, President XI Jinping and
1:09:23 President Donald Trump. And, you know, I don't think it's just
1:09:27 the India, US or India China dialogue. If any of these take place on the
1:09:32 sidelines, uh, you know, that matters. I think it is, uh, sort of the
1:09:37 tripartite dialogue, if I can put it that way.
1:09:40 Uh, and it will be interesting to see, uh, you know, what goes on, simply
1:09:44 because already the Trump presidency has been so unpredictable.
1:09:49 Right? Let me put the unpredictability
1:09:51 quotient. You Q out there.
1:09:54 And now with that Democratic sweep. And then, of course, most recently the
1:09:59 allegations against Jensen, Wang and Nvidia, uh, you know, the accusations of
1:10:05 chip sales to the China, these are all just going to up the unpredictability
1:10:10 quotient. So yes, the next three, four weeks will
1:10:14 be very interesting to watch in terms of impact on tariffs, on visas, on
1:10:20 technology transfers. Um, you know, how US President Donald
1:10:25 Trump, uh, sort of looks at all of this, both those two big political and
1:10:30 business events. Men are going to stick around.
1:10:33 Let's break it down. Joining us now, Nisha Boswell, partner
1:10:37 of the Asia Group, a strategic advisory firm where she focuses on South Asia,
1:10:41 Middle East and energy issues. Nisha, good to have you with us.
1:10:44 We know that, uh, you know, President Trump and promises Modi will be in the
1:10:48 same space in Manila. How much is at stake here and can they
1:10:53 possibly stabilize that relationship amidst, you know, you know, the
1:10:57 stalemate, uh, in trade negotiations? Well, on the first of all, it's great to
1:11:04 be with you. Um, look, I do think that the meeting in
1:11:08 Manila is very important. Um, certainly the US and India had a
1:11:12 pretty rough year in 2025. I think they have largely stabilized
1:11:17 that relationship. Uh, the trade negotiations in 26 have
1:11:21 gotten, uh, going in earnest, and they've been constructive and intensive.
1:11:27 I don't know that we'll get any kind of an announcement in Manila on on the
1:11:32 trade front, but more likely, I think the two sides are probably aiming to try
1:11:37 to have this wrapped up by the G20. Uh, nonetheless, I think, uh, it'll be,
1:11:43 um, the second meeting this year, uh, between the two leaders, uh, and an
1:11:48 important one. Uh, to, uh, to keep our eyes on,
1:11:51 particularly since we're anticipating, hopefully, a meeting of the quad leaders
1:11:56 as well in Manila before President Trump, uh, uh, heads off to China.
1:12:03 Also, the highly anticipated meeting, possibly between Trump and XI and
1:12:09 possibly President Putin as well. I'm just wondering, is there a sense
1:12:14 that India could be sidelined on the back of that meeting?
1:12:21 I mean, I don't think that this is, uh, something that India, um, or really any
1:12:26 of the other quad countries are, are necessarily, uh, looking forward to, uh,
1:12:31 meeting between President XI, president, uh, Trump and uh, um, uh, President
1:12:37 Putin. Um, I do think that the quad leaders
1:12:41 meeting in some ways is is meant to try to, um, counter that, or at least blunt,
1:12:48 uh, the impact, uh, a try later in Shenzhen.
1:12:52 Um, you know, at the end of the day, it was Prime Minister Modi's meeting, uh,
1:12:59 and, and, uh, kind of, uh, photo op with uh, XI and Putin, uh, a year ago, that
1:13:06 kind of got the attention of the United States and in some ways, um, corrected
1:13:12 the downward spiral that had been occurring on U.S., India.
1:13:16 So, uh, so it'll be interesting to see, um, you know, a year later what might
1:13:22 come of a trilateral, uh, engagement between the United States, Russia and
1:13:28 China. Uh, these are just, you know, what do
1:13:33 you think will be the key agenda points, let's say, in terms of the ongoing
1:13:39 conversation between the between India and and the US, even if there are
1:13:43 meetings on the sidelines of all these big geopolitical summits, because it
1:13:47 seems quite clear now that India is not very keen on progressing on the trade
1:13:51 deal, given where we are on tariffs and that ten, 12.5%, uh, what other issues
1:13:58 do you feel need to be resolved within a sort of definite time frame?
1:14:05 Yeah, well, I have not given up on a trade deal.
1:14:08 Um, uh, Monica, I do think that, uh, the US is pushing very hard to try to get
1:14:14 that deal across the finish line. Uh, for the phase one agreement.
1:14:18 Uh, and there are still a significant amount of leverage.
1:14:21 Um, I think that, uh, uh, the tariff authorities are largely executive branch
1:14:27 authorities, particularly, uh, the ones that the administration is using.
1:14:31 Um, the, uh, the Graham Act on, um, Russia sanctions, I think, gives the
1:14:37 United States some additional leverage for, uh, continuing to push forward on
1:14:42 that trade agreement. What we're hearing from the Indian side
1:14:45 is that if they can get some assurances on what the tariff rate is going to be
1:14:51 for some of their competitors and neighbors, um, that would make them more
1:14:55 comfortable about, uh, uh, concluding the phase one agreement.
1:14:59 I think that that's where the two sides, uh, are continuing to meet, uh, and meet
1:15:05 point intensively, uh, and make some progress.
1:15:08 So so let's see what happens. Hopefully by the end of the year, um, it
1:15:13 would be a shame if the U.S. and India can't make this happen.
1:15:16 We've been on the precipice of some kind of a mini deal or interim deal multiple
1:15:24 times before in the past, and never quite gotten one across the finish line.
1:15:28 So I think there's a lot of expectation, uh, frankly, in both countries.
1:15:32 But the Indian anxiety is whether or not, uh, an agreement is conclusive is,
1:15:38 uh, durable and reliable, or whether additional tariffs might be imposed on
1:15:44 India or that it's, uh, it's, uh, neighbors or competitors might get a
1:15:48 better deal. So those are issues that I think the two
1:15:51 countries need to address in terms of other issues that, uh, are between the
1:15:56 two governments. I mean, there's certainly always a host
1:15:59 of issues to discuss on the economic and strategic tracks here, um, including
1:16:04 show around critical minerals. Uh, there are some defense, uh, um,
1:16:10 issues, uh, uh, you know, um, uh, pending.
1:16:13 So I imagine those are on that. I don't know that it's a very ambitious
1:16:17 agenda that's going to be, uh, addressed in Manila, but I think it's an important
1:16:22 opportunity to continue to strengthen that relationship.
1:16:27 Okay, a quick follow up to that, Nisha, how do you what should India expect now
1:16:31 that the Democrats have swept Congress? How do you see that influencing any
1:16:37 changes in US policy towards India. Given that Prime Minister Trump still
1:16:43 has significant executive power. Yeah, I, you know, uh, the Democratic
1:16:51 agenda, I think is largely going to be very domestically focused.
1:16:55 Uh, they came in on a voter sentiment and concern around affordability.
1:17:02 And I think that affordability is going to be a key, um, focus of the Democrats.
1:17:07 There will be certainly foreign policy issues, um, that you will see action on.
1:17:13 Um, certainly. I think the Iran conflict is something
1:17:16 that, um, that, uh, you know, incoming Congress is going to got to be very
1:17:22 active on, uh, in trying to put some, um, um, conditionality, uh, and
1:17:28 accountability around, um, uh, around that conflict, um, Russia, Ukraine, uh,
1:17:34 and, and and certainly in in the wake of, uh, the headlines this week on the
1:17:39 Nvidia, uh, um, US-China and, um, um, technology, uh, uh, um, prohibitions or
1:17:49 restrictions, uh, around, uh, US technology and U.S.
1:17:54 chips to China. I think there will be, um, um,
1:17:58 priorities for the incoming Congress. Uh, on India, by and large, I think what
1:18:03 you've heard from Democrats has been an appreciation of the strategic importance
1:18:09 of India. Uh, and I think that that will continue
1:18:13 to to be that focus. Uh, and, you know, whether they, um, um,
1:18:19 specifically weigh in on particular issues, uh, remains to be seen.
1:18:24 I think immigration issues are certainly ones that the Congress will take up and
1:18:28 ones that I think Indian, uh, counterparts are watching closely.
1:18:34 Uh, Nisha, you talked about how this is India's economic moment as global supply
1:18:39 chains diversify. The thing is, India tends to compete for
1:18:43 the same manufacturing investments as the rest of the Asean region.
1:18:47 How should India position itself to be seen as perhaps a partner rather than a
1:18:51 rival to Asean? Um, I would say that, uh, first of all,
1:18:58 uh, you know, there there has been a lot of supply chain movement into Asean.
1:19:03 Um, there has been some movement that is coming towards India.
1:19:07 As India starts to negotiate trade deals, uh, with a multiplicity of
1:19:13 regions and partners, including the India EU trade deal, which, uh, I
1:19:18 believe, uh, Prime Minister Modi is going to be heading to Brussels, uh, on
1:19:23 his way to the G20 to, um, sign that agreement.
1:19:27 Uh, the Indian, uh, Canada agreement is, uh, supposed to be negotiated before the
1:19:32 end of the year. And, uh, Prime Minister again is going
1:19:35 to is going to go to Ottawa before he comes to, uh, Miami for the, for the
1:19:41 G20. So let's see what happens there.
1:19:43 India has been, um, pushing on the trade deals with, uh, multiplicity of
1:19:49 partners. So far, um, the focus has not been on
1:19:52 Southeast Asia as much as, uh, one would hope, uh, particularly in light of the
1:19:57 geographic proximity, I think, um, uh, maybe that will change it.
1:20:02 You know, our RCEp has been of concern to the Indians, particularly because of
1:20:07 the potential for creating, uh, much broader access for, um, China to access
1:20:13 the Indian market. But I think the Indians are focused on
1:20:16 trying to, uh, build more trade, uh, with Asean nations.
1:20:22 Uh, I think, uh, you know, certainly a strong, um, strong economic partnership
1:20:27 between India and Singapore, very strong Strategic partnership between India and
1:20:32 Vietnam, the Philippines. And I think Indonesia is another
1:20:36 important trading partner. I see, um, the Indians looking to see
1:20:41 how they can do more with Asean. Nisha.
1:20:45 Thank you. Nisha Boswell, partner of the Asia
1:20:48 Group. Now let's focus on the Indian markets as
1:20:51 a global eye. Trade looks a little wobbly at the
1:20:54 moment. Investors are looking for safe options.
1:20:56 In the latest episode of the emerging podcast, Manika, you spoke to two
1:21:00 veteran investors about whether India can be that so-called AI hedge.
1:21:05 I mean, tell us more about what they said.
1:21:09 Has, you know, a few takeaways from that conversation.
1:21:12 Firstly, nothing you say about the markets can last for more than two
1:21:16 minutes nowadays. So it's really tough to have a
1:21:18 conversation and hope that it will have a shelf life of more than a day or two.
1:21:23 But definitely we've seen a re-emergence of foreign investor interest towards
1:21:27 India. I think we cleared about $7 billion this
1:21:31 month in both equity and debt investments, which definitely is, uh,
1:21:35 sort of cheerful news, uh, for the country, for the rupee are very
1:21:40 importantly. But I suppose the big question is how
1:21:44 long will this last? Right?
1:21:46 We've spent the last several months asking, when will the money come back to
1:21:49 India? And now I think we are talking about how
1:21:52 steady these flows will be. And there will always be pressures,
1:21:55 dueling pressures on the eye front. Whether you've got, you know, sort of an
1:22:00 Nvidia controversy, uh, sort of pitched against the anthropic IPO, which is
1:22:06 bringing a ton of flows into the US. So I think that's the context I was
1:22:11 trying to set up with my guests, and they spoke of what they saw as the
1:22:16 inherent strengths of the India story that will, in buckets of time, keep
1:22:21 bringing money back to the country listening.
1:22:26 To any hot Cineworld pockets in India. Since you invest across assets, real
1:22:30 assets, private credit, private equity can rival the US.
1:22:34 I story. I don't think we can rival the US air
1:22:38 story from a competitiveness point of view at this time, but from a capital
1:22:44 flow point of view, obviously the US is continuing to suck capital from
1:22:47 everywhere else, but there are investors who are already starting to question the
1:22:51 excessive concentration of their capital into the US.
1:22:54 So there will be conversations that are early stage conversations today with
1:22:58 regard to diversification. And when investors want to look at
1:23:02 diversification, then India definitely figures in that conversation as a
1:23:05 possible market to diversify into. Does it?
1:23:08 Because it's still not drawing any money, at least not on portfolio flows
1:23:12 into it. One in portfolio place, for example,
1:23:14 people are still talking about India doesn't offer and I play right.
1:23:19 But that's still the I related mindset. People are ignoring the fact that
1:23:23 valuations are down right now. companies continue to grow at about 15
1:23:26 to 18%, that levels of corporate India are at the lowest levels.
1:23:31 Banks are at the most healthy in terms of balance sheet, and credit growth is
1:23:35 about 15 to 18%. The second aspect of it is that people
1:23:39 are still ignoring the fact that a number of initiatives that the
1:23:43 government has done in with regard to manufacturing, and we are seeing that at
1:23:48 the ground level with the trust that is there with regard to space and defense
1:23:54 related manufacturing that's going on in India.
1:23:56 These are smaller companies, but they are growing at 30 to 40%.
1:24:00 And capital will discover those companies whether foreign capital
1:24:04 discovers it or not. It's a matter of time.
1:24:07 Domestic capital is already discovering that it's also a matter of balance, of
1:24:11 payments. Let me say that because I think the fact
1:24:14 that we are not able to draw the incremental dollars away from the US is
1:24:18 a significant pressure on our own currency.
1:24:22 And then it started this negative loop that you get stuck in.
1:24:25 So I wonder Indians are very bullish on India.
1:24:29 Mark. Why isn't the world seeing it that way?
1:24:31 I think trying to pull capital away from the U.S.
1:24:35 equity market is about the hardest thing you can do right now, given, you know,
1:24:39 the excitement and the you can't compete with the Giants right now.
1:24:43 But there's, you know, the US is not. I mean, while it is the dominant market,
1:24:47 it's not the only market in the world. Um, and so I think India has a good
1:24:52 potential of drawing capital away from the other diversifies is as strongly
1:24:57 called them with those fundamental with that growth potential credit growth
1:25:01 where this uh, it would continue stability of regulation and leadership
1:25:05 and that then people will deploy capital here over time.
1:25:13 Well, I guess it all comes down to dollar returns.
1:25:15 Right. And key to that is what's going on with
1:25:18 the rupee. And key to that is what will happen to
1:25:20 oil prices. I think the industry has great
1:25:23 strengths, but the big turning point for foreign money to come back has been
1:25:26 crude prices coming down significantly over the last couple of weeks.
1:25:31 If it stays that way, then maybe these flows will continue.
1:25:34 Who knows. That's right.
1:25:36 And crude still up 40% on the year. Monica Doshi, thank you so much for
1:25:40 that. And of course, the latest edition of
1:25:42 emerging is available now across platforms including YouTube, Apple and
1:25:47 of course, Spotify. Still to come, former President Joko
1:25:50 Widodo loses his foothold in Indonesia's government after his son's exit as vice
1:25:55 president. We'll look at how this tilts the
1:25:58 political balance in Prabowo favor and of course, its implications.
1:26:03 Keep it here with us. This is Bloomberg.
1:26:09 Mike, you're watching insight. Indonesia's vice president Gebran Rak, a
1:26:12 booming rocker, has resigned. The move strips his father, former
1:26:16 President Joko Widodo, of his biggest remaining foot hole in the government.
1:26:20 For more on what this exit means for President Prabowo Subianto, his
1:26:24 administration is bringing in a Southeast Asia economy reporter Claire
1:26:27 Chow. Claire, I mean, you have to get to the
1:26:29 bottom of this. I mean, you know, we understand that
1:26:31 this is about his high school qualification.
1:26:34 It must be more than that. Well, on paper, it is about his high
1:26:38 school qualification. It's one of the requirements needed to
1:26:40 run for office. But Bren has a university degree, so you
1:26:44 also get the feeling that they're very much using the letter of the law instead
1:26:47 of the spirit of it to get him out of his position, uh, which now turns our
1:26:52 attention to who could replace him. That would give immense power to
1:26:57 President Prabowo, and now to choose his second in command.
1:27:00 He will have 60 days to come up with two names to submit to Parliament.
1:27:04 Lots of theories about whether or not he would choose within his coalition to
1:27:08 kind of, like, strengthen their hold of the majority of parliament.
1:27:11 Or he could reach out and give that position, let's say, to the opposition,
1:27:16 and try and keep them in the fold as well.
1:27:19 But to be sure, a sense of calm is returning to the markets.
1:27:22 We see the rupiah stabilize a little bit.
1:27:24 Stock market is back up because at least now we're done with this drama of will
1:27:28 they will they stay together? And to be sure has a majority of the
1:27:33 problem. And he pretty much dictates policy
1:27:35 anyway. So Indonesia's policy direction should
1:27:38 remain intact as we know it. What it is a direction that markets are
1:27:41 actually not comfortable with. I mean, could this act of the
1:27:44 uncertainty, could this act to the risk? Yeah, I don't think the political risk
1:27:49 will fade away any time soon, not within this government.
1:27:52 I feel like that's really just the style of president proposal.
1:27:54 He can be unconventional. He can be unexpected.
1:27:57 He has a very strict focus on hitting that 8% growth goal, and he wants the
1:28:01 government to have a strong hand in doing it.
1:28:03 And that could mean unconventional, unexpected, maybe less investor friendly
1:28:08 policies. Um, and you're right now that we don't
1:28:11 have to we and his block having a stronger hold in the government.
1:28:15 He could have a great term ended in just getting what he wants.
1:28:19 And then of course, one other thing to look at is though, is, um, president,
1:28:23 uh, former presidential call. We, of course, still a very influential
1:28:26 figure. His younger son has a party.
1:28:29 He commands a strong group of supporters.
1:28:32 It remains to be seen publicly. He said he supports this government, but
1:28:36 it remains to be seen whether or not he will start to jockey for position as we
1:28:40 look towards the 2029 elections. I just want to put it out there.
1:28:43 The reason that, uh, president is actually in office is because of the
1:28:47 support from, uh, Joko Widodo. He provided about 30% of the votes for
1:28:53 Prabowo. I'm just wondering, could we see an
1:28:55 unraveling of some of the policies implemented by Jokowi, something that
1:29:00 perhaps, you know, Bo himself does not agree with?
1:29:03 Uh, that's right. And I think we've seen a steady kind of
1:29:06 like, um, sidestepping of his policies. We don't really ever hear a mention of
1:29:11 the new capital anymore. Infrastructure is way down.
1:29:14 The priority list of this government proposal has really stuck to his own
1:29:18 campaign promises, which are the free meals programme, resource nationalism
1:29:22 and just essentially Indonesia having a better share of their commodity wealth.
1:29:27 Um, but you're right, uh, Jokowi accounted for such a large part of
1:29:31 people's appeal in the last election. And I think that's also why he is toeing
1:29:36 the line between kind of breaking away from that alliance, but also still
1:29:41 paying lip service to still following, uh, problems, uh, Jacoby's priorities
1:29:46 before. And of course, front and center for
1:29:48 Indonesia is the rupiah is, you know, among the worst performing currencies.
1:29:53 Uh, a lot of things are weighing on it. How might Bank Indonesia be looking at,
1:29:58 you know, the currency and its rate trajectory from here?
1:30:03 We're expecting their meeting on Wednesday.
1:30:06 Early estimates have them hiking by 25 basis points.
1:30:09 And it will be crucial for them to kind of just like restore that confidence
1:30:12 after the recent market turmoil from the MSCI downgrade threat, as well as all of
1:30:17 this political drama. That being said, MSCI was not enough for
1:30:20 them to move in the last meeting. You get the sense that the governor is
1:30:23 resistant to hiking because of course it could derail economic growth.
1:30:28 It's hard not to look at it from a political lens.
1:30:30 You know, once that 8% and Bank Indonesia might not want to appear like
1:30:35 they're standing in the way of that. So instead, they might just look to just
1:30:38 keep intervening in the markets to strengthen the currency without outright
1:30:42 rate hikes. We are far from 8%.
1:30:45 Clare, Clare thank you. Bloomberg Southeast Asia Economy
1:30:48 reporter Clare G out there. That is it for Insight.
1:30:51 Horizons middle East and Africa is up next.
1:30:53 Keep it here with us. This is Bloomberg.
Investors Eye Europe Amid Volatility: Market Snapshot full transcript
0:00 Other foundations on which the I trade rests.
0:03 Creaking a little bit. We've had these big drawdowns, and I,
0:06 um, we've always bounced back from those.
0:08 And I think what we've seen here is it's a nervousness about it.
0:11 I don't think it's a fundamental. And we have to look at how the
0:15 technology progresses, what the costs are.
0:17 But I don't see any pullback on the usage side of it.
0:21 Um, and if you look at that there's only just demand growing.
0:24 I think the markets fear as well. That earnings backdrop is reflecting an
0:28 AI build out that might now be out of date.
0:30 But we we don't think so. Maybe it's more elongated but it'll
0:33 still be there. So market can kind of sell out of tech.
0:35 But then it's really really struggles to find where to go.
0:38 As an investor you need to find diversify it now.
0:40 Europe has always been slightly overlooked because growth of course, is
0:43 not quite as buoyant as in the US, but still it is a diversified, um, market
0:48 universe that you might find rich pickings.
0:50 We're firing on all cylinders. We have a strong demand from data
0:53 centers for our electrification business.
0:56 But not only that, it's also a building business automation business going to
0:59 data centers. Europe only has 5% of the world's a
1:04 computing capacity. The US is 75%.
1:06 We desperately need to build out computing capacity in Europe.
1:10 It's a global trade, and I don't think there's any way you can really hide from
1:13 I. I think it's not a matter of whether you
1:15 are exposed to it or not. You have to be is just where you get
1:18 that exposure. It's been, uh, a region that's powered
1:21 incredible growth. And honestly, we're seeing that push for
1:24 AI transformation actually driving value in ROI with AI going higher and higher.
1:29 Um, and for us, even as successful as we've been here with our growth, we
1:33 think that we're just starting to scratch the surface.
Nvidia Replaces Huang as Lutnick Faces Scrutiny on China full transcript
0:00 ♪ >> A VERY HAPPY FRIDAY MORNING
0:04 TO YOU, LIVE FROM BERLIN. THIS IS ""BLOOMBERG DAYBREAK:
0:07 EUROPE YURIKO I AM CHUCK THOMAS AND HERE ARE YOUR TOP STORIES.
0:11 JENSEN HUANG'S RESIGNATION AS NVIDIA CEO RIPPLES THROUGH THE
0:14 TECH SECTOR. THE CHIPMAKER LOOKS TO
0:19 EMERGE FROM DAYS OF CRISIS. BLOOMBERG LEARNS ANTHROPIC'S IPO
0:23 IS AROUND SIX TIMES OVERSUBSCRIBED AS MARKETS COUNT
0:25 DOWN TO WHAT COULD BE THE LARGEST LISTING OF ALL TIME.
0:30 AND SOURCES SAY THAT SPACEX AND TESLA COULD ANNOUNCE A MERGER AS
0:33 SOON AS NEXT MONTH, SETTING THE STAGE FOR A BLOCKBUSTER AND
0:40 POTENTIALLY WALL STREET'S BIGGEST DEAL.
0:41 TAKE A LOOK AT HOW MARKETS ARE REACTING TO ALL THIS NEWS.
0:45 IT IS A DOWN ARROW DAY ON THE BACK OF THE NVIDIA NEWS THAT WE
0:48 HAD WITH JENSEN HUANG'S RESIGNATION.
0:55 ASIAN MARKETS DOWN, ZERO POINT 31%.
0:57 EURO STOXX ALSO DOWN. NASDAQ FUTURES DOWN 0.41% OFF OF
1:03 THE BIG DROP WE SAW IN NVIDIA SHARES YESTERDAY.
1:07 A LOT TO GET TO TODAY. LET'S GET STARTED.
1:25 CHAD: ASIAN STOCKS REVERSING GAINS AS TECH SENTIMENT SOFTENS
1:28 OVERNIGHT. LET'S SEE HOW MARKETS ARE
1:32 LOOKING AT THE MOMENT IN ASIA WITH WINNIE HSU.
1:39 WHEN HE, -- WINNIE, HAPPY FRIDAY.
1:43 WINNIE: WE ARE SEEING ASIAN STOCKS LOSING MOMENTUM.
1:45 AS MENTIONED EARLIER THIS MORNING THERE WAS LOTS OF
1:48 OPTIMISM WITH THE MSCI ASIA UP BY ABOUT 1% AS INVESTORS SEEM TO
1:53 BE LOOKING PAST THE RESIGNATION OF NVIDIA'S JENSEN HUANG AND
1:55 INSTEAD FOCUSING ON THE FUNDAMENTALS AND THAT LONG-TERM
1:58 TREND FOR THE AI TRADE. HOWEVER, YOU ARE SEEING AS WE
2:03 HEAD INTO THE WEEKEND THE CONCERNS WHEN IT COMES TO
2:09 NVIDIA'S EARNINGS NEXT WEEK, AS WELL AS THE UPCOMING U.S. PPI
2:11 NUMBERS. INVESTORS SEEM TO BE TAKING MORE
2:14 OF A CAUTIOUS STANCE NOW. SOUTH KOREA'S KOSPI INDEX
2:20 REVERSING EARLIER GAINS AS 3%, TO FALL ABOUT 1% HERE.
2:28 TIME STOCKS HOLDING UP WELL, HOLDING UP 1% AFTER BEING THE
2:32 BIGGEST LOSER IN THE REGION. THE BIGGEST DAMAGE WE ARE SEEING
2:37 IS IN TECH STOCKS IN HONG KONG, DOWN BY ABOUT 3%.
2:40 AS WE TAKE A LOOK AT WHAT IS DRAGGING IN THE REGION, YOU CAN
2:45 SEE THERE ARE TWO THINGS HAPPENING.
2:50 ON THE SUPPLIER SIDE AS WELL AS THE CUSTOMER SIDE.
2:53 ON THE CUSTOMER SIDE, YOU CAN SEE THE LIKES OF ALIBABA,
2:56 MINIMAX, THEY ARE THE CHINESE NAMES AS WELL AS HYPERSCALERS
3:02 THAT RELY ON CHIPS AS WELL. SPIKE ELATION IS RISING THE U.S.
3:06 MIGHT BE STEPPING UP THEIR EXPORT CONTROLS ON CHINA GIVEN
3:11 THE CONCERNS AROUND THE JENSEN HUANG SCANDAL.
3:18 WE ARE ALSO SEEING THE LIKES OF VICTORY GIANT TECHNOLOGY DOWN.
3:21 THIS AS INVESTORS ARE CONCERNED AND DECIDING TO STEP AWAY FROM
3:25 THESE NAMES UNTIL THERE'S MORE CLARITY WHEN IT COMES TO THE
3:30 FORWARD. TAKING A LOOK AT THE MACRO
3:36 PICTURE BECAUSE AS WE MENTIONED WE HAVE U.S. PPI NUMBERS COMING
3:39 OUT LATER TODAY. THIS IS COMING AFTER THE HOTTER
3:42 THAN EXPECTED CPI NUMBERS EARLIER THIS WEEK.
3:49 FOR INVESTORS, THE FOCUS IS IF IT WILL TAKE QUITE A BIG
3:53 DOWNSIDE SURPRISED TO REVERSE THAT TREND WHEN IT COMES TO THE
3:57 BET ON THE FED TO TIGHTEN FURTHER.
3:58 YOU CAN SEE THE OVERALL YIELDS ACROSS THE CURVE AND ACROSS THE
4:02 REGION RISING, TRACKING THE MOVES IN U.S. TREASURIES
4:04 OVERNIGHT. WHEN IT COMES TO JAPANESE YEN,
4:08 WE SEE THE END HOVERING BELOW THAT 160 LEVEL AFTER BREACHING
4:10 THAT KEY LEVEL OVERNIGHT. THE VERY FIRST TIME SINCE
4:16 SEPTEMBER. OF COURSE, WE ARE ON
4:18 INTERVENTION WATCH, ESPECIALLY AFTER THE FINANCE MINISTER
4:22 WARNED ABOUT TAKING FURTHER STEPS WHEN IT COMES TO THE
4:25 WEAKNESS OF THE YEN. BACK TO YOU, CHAD.
4:28 CHAD: WINNIE HSU WITH US FOR ALL THE LATEST FROM ASIA.
4:33 JENSEN HUANG IS OUT AT NVIDIA AND WILL NO LONGER HAVE ANY TIES
4:37 TO THE CHIPMAKER. SHARES INITIALLY PLUNGED 14% FOR
4:40 PARING SOME OF THOSE LOSSES AT THE CLOSE.
4:49 THE LONGTIME CEO COLETTE CREST WILL REPLACE HIM AFTER
4:56 LET'S BRING IN TOM MACKENZIE. A WATERSHED MOMENT FOR NVIDIA.
5:02 HAS THE RESIGNATION ACTUALLY DEEPENED THE CRISIS?
5:07 TOM: THIS IS A WATERSHED MOMENT NOT ONLY FOR NVIDIA BUT FOR THE
5:10 AI ECOSYSTEM. IT IS A WATERSHED MOMENT FOR THE
5:16 U.S. ECONOMY, GIVEN THE ROLE THAT WONG PLAYED IN HELPING TO
5:18 ACCELERATE THE BUILDOUT OF AI THAT HAS ADDED TO U.S. ECONOMIC
5:20 GROWTH. I DON'T THINK IT HAS DEEPENED
5:24 THE CRISIS. YOU NOW HAVE THE CEO COLETTE
5:29 KRESS AT THE HELM ON AN INTERIM BASIS.
5:34 THAT IS A ROLE WE HAVEN'T HAD A NVIDIA BEFORE.
5:38 FORMERLY AT SYNOPSIS. HE'S BEEN ON THE BOARD FOR MORE
5:40 THAN 25 YEARS. COLETTE KRESS HAS BEEN THE CFO
5:48 FOR 13 YEARS. I SPOKE WITH SOMEONE AT NVIDIA
5:51 YESTERDAY WHO SAID SHE IS EXPERIENCED, SHE KNOWS THE
5:55 SUPPLY CHAIN, THE PARTNERS, SHE KNOWS NVIDIA'S CUSTOMERS, SHE
5:59 IS SEEN INTERNALLY AS A SAFE PAIR OF HANDS.
6:01 THE PERSON I WAS SPEAKING TO SAID THEY WERE STILL COMING TO
6:04 TERMS WITH WHAT'S HAPPENED OVER THE LAST FEW DAYS, AND NVIDIA
6:08 SAYING THEY WERE BOTH SHOCKED AND ANGRY BY WHAT THEY DESCRIBED
6:13 AS THE BETRAYAL OF JENSEN HUANG. BUT AGAIN, RE-ENSURING THAT
6:19 KRESS IS A SAFE PAIR OF HANDS IS A COMPANY LOOKS TO WHO WILL TAKE
6:21 OVER AS CEO. THE INTERNAL FAVORITE SEEMS TO
6:32 BE -- THE EXTERNAL FAVORITE IS RUN A -- RENE HAAS.
6:39 I UNDERSTAND THERE HAS BEEN OFFICIALLY NO OFFICIAL OUTREACH
6:45 AS OF NOW. BUT MAKE OF THAT WHAT YOU WILL
6:50 IN TERMS OF CUTTING SHORT THAT TRIP.
6:52 WHAT WE LOOK FOR NOW IS JENSEN HUANG WILL CONTINUE TO BE
6:53 FOCUSED. HE WILL LIKELY FACE SCRUTINY.
6:57 HE WILL LIKELY BE IN WASHINGTON, D.C.
7:00 WE KNOW THERE ARE INVESTIGATIONS INTO THE ROLE.
7:12 IT HAS BEEN REVEALED THAT HE HAS HAD MULTIPLE AFFAIRS, SO THE
7:16 PRESSURE DOES NOT GO AWAY. THE PRESSURE ON NVIDIA DOES NOT
7:18 GO AWAY. THERE WILL BE INCREASED
7:20 SCRUTINY. BUT AT LEAST THEY HAVE MADE THIS
7:26 DECISION AS WE LEAD UP TO THE EARNINGS STORY.
7:29 AND THE NUMBERS EXPECTED TO COME THROUGH NEXT WEEK.
7:32 THERE ARE A LOT OF MOVING PIECES, A LOT OF QUESTIONS TO BE
7:33 ANSWERED. ACCORDING TO PEOPLE I HAVE BEEN
7:39 SPEAKING TO, THEY ARE SOMEWHAT CONFIDENT THAT COLETTE KRESS IS
7:42 IN THIS ROLE ON AN INTERIM BASIS.
7:45 CHAD: JENSEN HUANG WAS DEEPLY INVOLVED IN ALL OF THE DETAILS
7:48 AT NVIDIA. HE HAD LIKE 60 PEOPLE REPORTING
7:51 TO HIM. WHAT DOES THIS MEAN FOR THEIR
7:54 BROADER BUSINESS, THE FACT THAT HE HAS NOW EXITED?
7:59 TOM: IT IS DEEPLY SIGNIFICANT AND THERE WILL BE A LOT OF THOSE
8:04 EXECUTIVES, COMPANIES, AND INVESTORS WONDERING WHETHER OR
8:06 NOT THOSE COMMITMENTS ARE STILL GOING TO COME THROUGH FROM
8:09 NVIDIA. THERE IS REALLY FASCINATING
8:11 REPORTING FROM THE WALL STREET JOURNAL TODAY TALKING ABOUT THE
8:13 FACT THAT COLETTE KRESS HERSELF COME FORMALLY CFO, NOW INTERIM
8:18 CEO, HAD PUSHED BACK ON SOME FINANCING DEALS JOHNSON
8:22 WONG WAS PUSHING THROUGH. -- JENSEN HUANG WAS PUSHING
8:27 THROUGH. HMMM THE NEO-CLOUDS COME
8:37 -- THE NEO-CLOUDS INVESTING HEAVILY.
8:41 IF YOU ARE A FOUNDER, CEO, YOU ARE RUNNING ONE OF THOSE CLAD
8:45 BUSINESSES OR AI START UP, YOU WILL BE QUESTIONING WHETHER THAT
8:50 CONTINUED SUPPORT FROM NVIDIA COMES THROUGH GIVEN THE CHANGES
8:53 THAT ARE LIKELY WITH THIS NEW MANAGEMENT STRUCTURE.
8:55 THERE ARE 60 REPORTS INTO THE CEO.
9:00 THAT WILL NOW BE CHANGED. THE COMMITMENTS FROM NVIDIA TO
9:05 THIS WIDER ECOSYSTEM, THAT IS A CLEAR QUESTION MARK GOING
9:08 FORWARD. CHAD: "BLOOMBERG TECH: EUROPE"
9:15 'S TOM MACKENZIE BREAKING IT DOWN.
9:17 TECH: EUROPE." TOM WILL EXPLORE HOW THE SHOCK
9:25 WAVES FROM JENSEN HUANG'S DEPARTURE ARE BEING FELT ACROSS
9:26 EUROPE. HE WILL BE SPEAKING TO RICHARD
9:32 WINDSOR, ROXANNE VARS A, AND DAN AKAIA.
9:41 BLOOMBERG UNDERSTANDS ANTHROPIC'S IPO IS ABOUT SIX
9:45 TIMES OVERSUBSCRIBED AS INTEREST INCREASES FOR WHAT COULD BE THE
9:48 BIGGEST FIRST-TIME SHARE SALE EVER.
9:51 LET'S BRING IN DAN SAVAGE, BLOOMBERG MARKETS LIVE REPORTER.
9:54 WHAT DO WE KNOW ABOUT THE DEMAND FOR ANTHROPIC, AND WHAT DOES IT
9:58 TELL US ABOUT THE TECH TRADE? DAN: GOOD MORNING.
10:04 AS YOU NOTED, THE IPO IS SIX TIMES OVERSUBSCRIBED.
10:09 IT COULD RAISE AS MUCH AS 90 BILLION DOLLARS WHEN YOU INCLUDE
10:12 THE CONCURRENT PRIVATE PLACEMENT.
10:16 DEMAND AT THIS STAGE SEEMS TO BE QUITE STRONG.
10:20 BUT OF COURSE, THE RAMIFICATIONS FROM THIS IPO, HOW IT TRADES IN
10:23 THE WEEKS TO COME GO FAR BEYOND THIS COMPANY, FOR TWO
10:27 REASONS. FIRST OF ALL, ANTHROPIC HAS
10:31 ABOUT $900 BILLION OF FUTURE COMMITMENTS FOR COMPUTING POWER
10:36 COSTS, INFRASTRUCTURE. IN MANY WAYS, IT IS UNDERWRITTEN
10:41 THE AI BUILDOUT. THE OTHER REASON IS BY LOOKING
10:45 AT REVENUES FROM ANTHROPIC, HOW IT GROWS, IT GIVES THE MARKET
10:51 ONE OF THE BEST GAUGES OF WHAT AI ADOPTION LOOKS LIKE, WHAT
10:54 DOES EXOGENOUS DEMAND LOOK LIKE, OUTSIDE OF CIRCULAR FINANCING
10:57 AND CAPEX SPEND THAT RUNS THROUGH THE AI SUPPLY CHAIN.
11:01 AGAIN, HOW ANTHROPIC WAS RECEIVED BY THE MARKET, HOW IT
11:05 TRADES IN THE COMING WEEKS WILL REALLY GIVE A PRETTY STERN TEST
11:08 FOR HOW THE AI TRADE IS GOING TO PLAY OUT GOING FORWARD.
11:17 CHAD: DOES THE TURMOIL WE HAVE SEEN AT NVIDIA CHANGE THE SET UP
11:18 AT ALL FOR ANTHROPIC? DAN: I THINK OF INTEREST OF
11:25 COURSE IS PART OF THAT PRIVATE PLACEMENT NVIDIA MADE, A $10
11:30 BILLION COMMITMENT TO ANTHROPIC. IT IS CERTAINLY GOING TO BE ON
11:37 WATCH TO SEE, DOES THE LEADERSHIP CHANGES HERE CHANGE
11:39 THAT COMMITMENT? THAT PROVIDES A BIT OF A
11:44 MICROCOSM IN TERMS OF WHERE DOES THE CONTAGION RACE FROM THE
11:53 TURMOIL THAT IS BEING SEEN IN NVIDIA GO BEYOND?
11:57 IT IS BEEN SEEN AS THE CENTRAL BANK FOR AI.
12:00 IF NEW LEADERSHIP IS UNWILLING OR UNABLE TO PROVIDE THE SAME
12:02 LEVEL OF COMMITMENT TO THE BROADER ECOSYSTEM, THAT
12:05 CERTAINLY WILL HAVE RAMIFICATIONS ACROSS TECH STOCKS
12:09 AND THE BROADER MARKET. CHAD: DAVID SAVAGE IN HONG KONG
12:16 FOR US. WE HAVE BEEN WAITING TO GET
12:21 RICHEMONT'S FIRST HALF EARNINGS, BUT THEY HAVE BEEN DELAYED DUE
12:25 TO THAT OUTAGE WE HAVE BEEN FOLLOWING OVERNIGHT FROM
12:28 MICROSOFT. MICROSOFT HAS BEEN STRUGGLING TO
12:32 RESTORE SOME OF ITS BIGGEST SERVICES FOR MORE THAN NINE
12:35 HOURS NOW AFTER AN OUTAGE THAT BEGAN YESTERDAY IN THE U.S.
12:40 OUTLOOK, TEAMS, AND COPILOT WERE UNAVAILABLE FOR SOME USERS FOR
12:44 MOST OF THE U.S. WORKDAY, WITH THE COMPANY SAYING A CORE
12:48 PROCESS ON AFFECTED SERVERS WAS BECOMING
12:49 OVERWHELMED. STILL AHEAD, WE WILL GET MORE ON
12:52 WHAT THE LATEST TECH HEADLINES WILL BE FOR MARKETS WITH
12:56 MADELINE RONNER FROM DWS. BUT FIRST, MORE HAWKISH FED
12:59 SPEAK FUELS EXPECTATIONS FOR RATE HIKES AHEAD.
13:02 WE WILL HAVE ALL THOSE DETAILS AFTER THE BREAK, AND THIS IS
13:03 BLOOMBERG. ♪
13:24 CHAD: AND WELCOME BACK TO "BLOOMBERG DAYBREAK EUROPE."
13:30 NEW YORK FED PRESIDENT JOHN WILLIAMS SAYS POLICYMAKERS HAVE
13:31 TO TAKE FURTHER ACTION TO CONTAIN PRICE PRESSURES.
13:37 HIS COMMENTS ARE THE LATEST IN A SERIES OF INTERVENTIONS FROM
13:41 OFFICIALS WARNING ON INFLATION WITH SAN FRANCISCO FED PRESIDENT
13:43 MARY DALY ALSO USING AN EVENT YESTERDAY TO SAY MORE TIGHTENING
13:45 IS NEEDED. LET'S BRING IN ANDRE DESILVA
13:49 FROM OUR MARKETS LIVE TEAM. TODAY'S PPI PRINT COMES RIGHT
13:53 AFTER THAT HOT CPI DATA FROM THE FED.
13:57 HOW MUCH TIGHTENING CAN WE REALLY GET PRICED INTO THE CURVE
14:00 FROM HERE AND WHERE IS THAT RATE REPRICING STARTING TO BITE
14:04 HARDEST ACROSS MARKETS? >> CERTAINLY IN THE PPI WILL BE
14:08 ANOTHER TEST FOR THE MARKETS TODAY, HOT ON THE HEELS OF THAT
14:11 CPI PRINT. IT IS ALREADY BAKED IN IN TERMS
14:18 OF ANOTHER FED RATE HIKE IN DECEMBER.
14:21 WE HAVE HAD A COUPLE OF SERIES OF OTHER MAJOR COUNTRIES THAT
14:24 HAVE HAD PPI RELEASES THAT WERE MUCH STRONGER-THAN-EXPECTED.
14:31 THAT WAS IN JAPAN AND CHINA, SUGGESTING THOSE UPSTREAM COST
14:33 PRICE PRESSURES ARE BUILDING SO THAT IS A WARNING SIGN FOR LATER
14:35 FOR THE U.S. PPI. TURNING BACK TO FED
14:40 EXPECTATIONS, 25 BASIS POINTS IS BAKED IN.
14:41 HOW MUCH MORE? IF YOU LOOK AT PRICING FED FUND
14:47 FUTURES, IT IS A SERIES. IT IS NEARLY UP TO 2.5, THREE
14:52 TIMES FOR THE NEXT THREE MEETINGS GOING INTO MARCH.
14:55 BUT THERE IS SOME CAUTION. AS SOME STAGE, YOU COULD ARGUE
15:02 COULD BE A CHANCE FOR A CHANGE AND PAT THE POLICY LATER DOWN
15:03 THE ROAD BUT IT IS A LITTLE BIT TOO EARLY FOR THE U.S.
15:07 ALREADY AND THERE IS TELLTALE SIGNS IN ANOTHER COUNTRY IN
15:11 TERMS OF AUSTRALIA WHERE THERE IS PEAKING PRICING AND PRICING
15:13 EASING BY THE END OF NEXT YEAR. BRING THAT FORWARD TO WHAT THAT
15:17 MEANS FOR OTHER ASSET CLASSES, IN PARTICULAR EM, YES, HIGHER
15:23 RATES, NOT JUST FED FUNDS BUT ALSO TREASURY YIELDS HAVE
15:24 SURGED. THAT HAS A BEARING FOR EM AND
15:28 FOR THE HIGH-YIELDERS. LOOKING INTO NEXT WEEK, WE HAVE
15:34 INDONESIA SQUARELY IN FOCUS BECAUSE AT THE CENTRAL BANK
15:37 MEETING, HAD A RECORD LOW IN THE CURRENCY YESTERDAY ON THE CHANCE
15:40 IS THEY NEED TO RAISE RATES BECAUSE THE PRESSURES BOILING.
15:42 CHAD: I WANT TO ASK ABOUT BITCOIN.
15:47 IT SLIPPED BACK BELOW $70,000 TO ITS LOWEST LEVEL SINCE AUGUST.
15:52 WHAT DO YOU THINK IS DRIVING THIS LEG LOWER AND HOW MUCH
15:55 FURTHER DOWNSIDE COULD WE SEE IF THE TREASURY YIELDS KEEP
15:57 CLIMBING? >> THESE DAYS, THIS IS NOT A
16:02 RISK ASSET CLASS SO WITH A HEIGHTENED RISK AVERSION,
16:05 CERTAINLY REGARDING FED TIGHTENING AND I ARE U.S.
16:09 YIELDS, AS A NON-YIELDING -- AND A HIGHER U.S. YIELDS, AS A
16:13 NONYIELDING ASSET, IT IS SEARCHING UNDER PRESSURE.
16:16 WE HEARD FROM DAVID IN TERMS OF NEXT WEEK, ANTICIPATION OF THE
16:21 THAT ALSO HAS A BEARING FOR BITCOIN.
16:25 IF YOU GO TO THE SPACE SURROUNDING VISION IPO, IN THE
16:30 RUN-UP TO THAT, YOU SAW WHAT SEEMED TO BE SOME ROTATION,
16:36 ESPECIALLY OUTFLOWS INTO THE BITCOIN ETF'S.
16:40 CAPITAL ROTATION IS ALSO PLACING PRESSURE ON BITCOIN BUT THAT
16:44 SHOULD SUBSIDE POST THE IPO. CHAD: ANDRE, THANK YOU SO MUCH.
16:53 THEIR MERGER NEGOTIATIONS. WE GET ALL THE LATEST ON THAT,
16:57 RIGHT AFTER THE BREAK. AND THIS IS BLOOMBERG.
17:09 ♪ CHAD: AND WELCOME BACK TO
17:18 "BLOOMBERG DAYBREAK EUROPE." SPACEX AND TESLA ARE PROGRESSING
17:25 IN A MERGER NEGOTIATIONS AND MAY ANNOUNCE A DEAL AS SOON AS
17:27 DECEMBER. LET'S BRING IN OUR DEALS
17:30 REPORTER IN HONG KONG. MANU, WOULD DO WE KNOW AT THIS
17:34 POINT ABOUT THIS POTENTIAL MEGADEAL?
17:41 >> CHAD, WHAT A HUGE DEAL WE HAVE IN THE WORKS.
17:44 IT IS FASCINATING TO SEE THESE COMPANIES COMBINING.
17:46 WHAT WE KNOW IS THAT THE TALKS ARE PROGRESSING.
17:51 THE ADVISORS ON THE DEAL ON BOTH SIDES ARE HAMMERING OUT THE
17:54 DETAILS, INCLUDING STRUCTURE, VALUATION, GOVERNANCE, AMONG
18:01 OTHER THINGS, AND THEY ARE REALLY RUSHING THROUGH TRYING TO
18:02 GET IT DONE AS EARLY AS THIS YEAR.
18:06 OBVIOUSLY, JUST A FEW WEEKS LEFT.
18:08 THERE IS ALSO A POTENTIAL SCENARIO IN WHICH THEY NEED A
18:12 LITTLE BIT EXTRA TIME AND THINGS SLIP INTO EARLY NEXT YEAR.
18:16 WOULD NOT BE THE FIRST TIME THAT WE SEE SUCH THING ON MAJOR DEALS
18:19 LIKE THIS. THINGS OF THIS CALIBER TAKE TIME
18:22 BUT THINGS SEEM TO BE PROGRESSING.
18:29 GLOBALLY. IT WOULD BE JUST PUTTING
18:36 TOGETHER TWO HUGE, ENORMOUS COMPANIES THAT WILL HAVE A HUGE
18:40 TRANSFORMATIVE IMPACT ACROSS INDUSTRIES REALLY GLOBALLY.
18:43 NOW ONE KEY FACTOR TO BEAR IN MIND IS WHAT THEY WOULD DO WITH
18:48 THE CHINA OPERATIONS. THAT IS SOMETHING THAT WILL BE
18:52 VERY SIGNIFICANT AND THAT WILL BE HIGHLY SCRUTINIZED.
18:57 TESLA HAS A VERY BIG PLATFORM HERE IN CHINA, SO THAT REMAINS A
19:05 BIG HURDLE THAT ADVISORS NEED TO COME TOGETHER AND KIND OF TRY TO
19:07 RESOLVE BEFORE HAND. CHAD: MANU, TALK TO US A LITTLE
19:14 BIT ABOUT THE RATIONALE BEHIND PUTTING THESE TWO HUGE COMPANIES
19:17 TOGETHER. >> EXACTLY.
19:23 EVERYBODY IS WONDERING LIKE WHY ELON MUSK WANTS TO CREATE THIS
19:25 JUGGERNAUT, THIS ENORMOUS COMPANY.
19:29 WHILE THE RATIONALE COMES DOWN TO ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE, AI
19:33 TOUCHING ON EVERYTHING THESE DAYS, AND OBVIOUSLY ALSO BEEN
19:38 VERY TRANSFORMATIVE ON BIG CORPORATIONS.
19:43 SO, THE RATIONALE COMES DOWN TO HOW AI CAN BE APPLIED INTO
19:50 EVERYTHING FROM HUMANOID ROBOTS TO SATELLITES, ROCKETS, TO
19:59 ELECTRIC VEHICLES, AND HOW THEY CAN SYNCHRONIZE ALL THOSE
20:01 PLATFORMS AND APPLY AI TO MAKE IT RUN SMOOTHER, POTENTIALLY
20:06 IMPROVE THE PRODUCTS, AND ALSO WHY NOT FIND SYNERGIES ACROSS
20:08 THE DIFFERENT BUSINESSES? CHAD: YOU TALKED ABOUT CHINA AND
20:14 THE POTENTIAL HURDLES THERE. WHAT DO WE EXPECT TO SEE IN THE
20:19 U.S., PARTICULARLY WITH THE BIG DEMOCRATIC WIN IN CONGRESS?
20:24 DO WE THINK THERE IS GOING TO BE REGULATORY SCRUTINY OF THIS DEAL
20:29 IN THE U.S. AS WELL? >> ABSOLUTELY.
20:33 CHINA IS A BIG STICKING POINT IN ANY BIG DEAL, NEGOTIATION.
20:38 JUST A FEW DAYS AGO, WE SAW A VERY INTERESTING DEAL BETWEEN
20:44 SOFTBANK AND ABB AROUND THE ROBOTICS BUSINESS GETTING
20:48 BLOCKED, THIS TIME BY CHINA AUTHORITIES.
20:52 WE CAN EXPECT A HIGH LEVEL OF SCRUTINY FROM THE U.S.,
20:58 DEFINITELY POSSIBLY ALSO FROM THE CHINA SIDE, ON A DEAL OF
21:04 THIS CALIBER FOR SURE, SO ADVISORS IN THE COMPANIES NEED
21:06 TO BE WELL PREPARED FOR WHAT COULD COME NEXT.
21:13 SOMETIMES, WE GET OVER EXCITED ABOUT WHEN DEALS GET AGREED
21:15 BETWEEN TWO COMPANIES. THAT OBVIOUSLY IS A VERY
21:19 IMPORTANT MILESTONE BUT WHAT COMES NEXT IN TERMS OF CLEARANCE
21:22 FROM REGULATORS, GOVERNMENTS, AND SO ON, IT IS VERY VERY
21:25 CRITICAL. AND THAT OBVIOUSLY CAN TAKE
21:30 DIFFERENT SHAPES OR FORMS, CAN TAKE SEVERAL MONTHS, SOMETIMES
21:35 HURDLES AND TWISTS AND TURNS ON THOSE APPROVALS.
21:39 THE MORE WORK THEY DO BEFORE HAND PROBABLY THE BETTER TO RUN
21:44 THIS AS SMOOTHLY AS POSSIBLE. CHAD: BLOOMBERG'S MANUEL JOINING
21:49 US. NOW TO SOME OF THEE OTHER TOP
21:53 STORIES WE ARE FOLLOWING THIS MORNING.
21:55 CISCO HAS FORECAST SECOND QUARTER SALES ABOVE WALL STREET
21:58 ESTIMATES AND RAISED ITS FULL-YEAR REVENUE OUTLOOK AS AI
22:02 DEMAND BOOSTS ITS NETWORKING BUSINESS.
22:05 CISCO NOW SEES ANNUAL REVENUE OF AS MUCH AS $75.8 BILLION, UP
22:12 FROM ITS PREVIOUS FORECAST OF $73.4 BILLION.
22:14 KALSHI IS SAID TO BE IN TALKS TO RAISE SOME MORE MONEY FROM
22:20 INVESTORS, VALUING THE PREDICTION MARKET AT $65
22:21 BILLION. THAT IS JUST WEEKS AFTER CLOSING
22:25 A FUNDING ROUND AT A $40 BILLION VALUATION.
22:34 THAT FUNDRAISING ROUND, ANNOUNCED IN LATE OCTOBER, WAS
22:36 EXPECTED TO BE THE LAST ONE BEFORE THE COMPANY'S ANTICIPATED
22:38 IPO BUT KALSHI IS SAID TO HAVE DECIDED TO RAISE MONEY AGAIN IN
22:42 THE PRIVATE MARKETS. WELL, COMING UP, WE WILL
22:48 CONTINUE TO DISCUSS THE FALLOUT FROM NVIDIA WITH MADELEINE
22:52 RONNER, GLOBAL EQUITIES SENIOR PORTFOLIO MANAGER AT DWS.
22:55 THAT'S AFTER THE BREAK AND THIS IS BLOOMBERG.
23:10 CHAD: AND A VERY GOOD FRIDAY MORNING TO YOU.
23:13 LIVE FROM BERLIN, THIS IS "BLOOMBERG DAYBREAK: EUROPE."
23:15 I'M CHAD THOMAS AND HERE ARE YOUR TOP STORIES.
23:18 JENSEN HUANG'S RESIGNATION AS NVIDIA CEO RIPPLES THROUGH THE
23:20 TECH SECTOR. THE CHIPMAKER TURNS TO CEO
23:24 COLETTE KRESS AS IT LOOKS TO EMERGE FROM DAYS OF CRISIS.
23:28 BLOOMBERG LEARNS ANTHROPIC'S IPO IS AROUND SIX TIMES
23:30 OVERSUBSCRIBED AS MARKETS COUNT DOWN TO WHAT COULD BE THE
23:34 LARGEST LISTING OF ALL TIME. AND SOURCES SAY THAT SPACEX AND
23:38 TESLA COULD ANNOUNCE A MERGER AS SOON NEXT MONTH, SETTING THE
23:43 STAGE FOR A BLOCKBUSTER TIE UP, POTENTIALLY WALL STREET BIGGEST
23:46 EVER DEAL. LET'S LOOK AT HOW MARKETS ARE
23:49 DIGESTING ALL OF THIS. AS YOU CAN SEE, IT IS A REAL RED
23:53 ARROW DAY. ASIAN MARKETS HAVE BEEN
23:57 TEETERING ALL DAY AS INVESTORS TRY TO PARSE WHAT THE IMPACT OF
24:00 THE NVIDIA SCANDAL IS ON THE WIDER TECH SECTOR.
24:03 EURO STOXX ALSO DOWN. NASDAQ FUTURES SLIPPING 0.29% AT
24:09 THIS POINT AFTER THAT BIG SELLOFF WE SAW WITH NVIDIA
24:10 YESTERDAY. LET'S SPEAK NOW TO MADELEINE
24:16 RONNER, SENIOR PORTFOLIO MANAGER FOR GLOBAL EQUITIES AT DWS.
24:21 TALKING TO HER ABOUT THE SITUATION WITH NVIDIA.
24:26 MADELEINE, OBVIOUSLY THIS IS A BIG DEAL FOR NVIDIA, BUT TALK TO
24:30 US ALSO ABOUT THE WIDER, BROADER RIPPLE EFFECT FOR THE TECH
24:31 SECTOR AS A WHOLE. MADELEINE: GOOD MORNING, CHAD.
24:38 I THINK LARGELY IT IS IDIOSYNCRATIC TO NVIDIA SO FAR.
24:41 I THINK THERE ARE TWO AREAS WHICH ARE THE AREAS TO SEE WHAT
24:46 IMPACTS THE TRADE. THE FIRST ONE IS FINANCING.
24:50 WE HAVE HEARD THE NEW INTERIM CEO HAS BEEN MORE SKEPTICAL OF
24:53 ALL THE DEALS JENSEN HUANG HAS BEEN REALLY PUSHING FORWARD, SO
24:58 THAT WILL BE A KEY ITEM TO SEE WHAT SHE SAYS ON THE EARNINGS
25:04 CALL. THIS COULD IMPACT THE IMPACT.
25:14 THE POSITIVE SIDE ON THIS IS THIS WILL AGAIN MOSTLY IMPACT
25:16 HYPERSCALERS. YOU GET MORE DATA POINTS WHERE
25:21 YOU SEE THAT THE HYPERSCALERS ARE BASICALLY THE SAFER PATH IN
25:26 TRADE. EVERYTHING WE HAVE HEARD IN THE
25:31 PAST WEEK AND WHAT WE ARE HEARING IN THE LAST FEW DAYS AND
25:34 HOURS IS THEY BASICALLY HAVE NO CHANGE IN THEIR INTENTION ON
25:39 WHAT THEY PLAN TO BUILD ADDITIONAL CAPACITY.
25:43 THAT IS ONE OF THE MAIN WATCH ITEMS.
25:46 THE SECOND ONE WHERE I AM CERTAINLY EXPECTING AS WE WILL
25:49 SEE MORE CHINA EXPORT RESTRICTIONS AND A STRICTER
25:50 EXPORT RESTRICTIONS. AND THAT COULD OBVIOUSLY ALSO
25:57 IMPACT THE BROADER SUPPLY CHAINS , IF CHIPS THAT PRAISING UTLEY
26:00 GOING TO CHINA ARE NOW GOING TO THE U.S..
26:03 WHAT DOES THAT LOOK? THESE ARE THE MAIN TWO ITEMS
26:06 WHICH CAN IMPACT THE WIDER TRADE.
26:10 BUT THAT WILL BE A WATCH ITEM FOR THE NEXT FEW WEEKS.
26:16 CHAD: YOU WERE TALKING ABOUT HOW THE INTERIM CEO COLETTE KRESS,
26:21 SHE HAS BEEN THE CFO, HAS BEEN MORE SKEPTICAL OF SOME OF THESE
26:23 CIRCULAR TRADES. WHAT DO YOU THINK THAT COULD
26:27 MEAN FOR THE SECTOR IF SHE WERE TO DECIDE TO TAKE THE COMPANY IN
26:30 A DIFFERENT DIRECTION FROM A FINANCING POINT OF VIEW?
26:36 MADELEINE: WE HAVE SEEN FINANCING STRESS IN THE SYSTEM
26:38 AGAIN FOR WEEKS. THAT WOULD CERTAINLY BE A
26:40 NEGATIVE POINT. BUT WE HAVE ALSO SEEN OTHER
26:44 COMPANIES ARE STARTING TO DO SIMILAR DEALS THAT COULD
26:46 POTENTIALLY STEP UP. BUT IT IS CERTAINLY A BIG
26:50 QUESTION MARK FOR NEO-CLOUDS. IT IS A BIG QUESTION MARK FOR
26:55 THAT PART OF THE MARKET AND WHERE THE CAPACITY GOES.
26:58 I AM STILL OF THE VIEW THAT THE HYPERSCALERS WOULD BE ABLE TO
27:02 PICK UP A LOT OF THE POTENTIAL CAPACITY COMING FROM THAT SIDE
27:03 OF THE MARKET. BUT AGAIN, THAT WOULD BE THE
27:11 ITEM TO SEE HOW THAT DEVELOPS. GENERALLY, AGAIN, POSITIVE
27:14 HYPERSCALERS. I STILL THINK WITH THE OVERALL
27:19 TRADE AND BUILD OUT, WE HAVE MORE INDICATIONS IT WILL START
27:21 TO SLOW. THAT COULD RELIEVE SOME OF THE
27:22 FINANCIAL STRESS. IF YOU LOOK AT THE YIELD
27:26 SPREADS, IF YOU LOOK AT WHAT CREDIT MARKETS HAVE BEEN SAYING,
27:29 THAT HAS BEEN IMPROVING A LITTLE BIT OVER THE RECENT WEEK, AND I
27:34 THINK THAT IS MAINLY DO, IF THE BUILD OUT SLOWS, IT COULD EASE A
27:41 LITTLE BIT IF IT IS A MORE SPREAD OUT CYCLE.
27:45 IT COULD ALSO BRING INFLATION WITHIN THAT SUPPLY CHAIN DOWN.
27:48 LONGER-TERM, THAT COULD BE A POSITIVE FOR THE BUILD OUT
27:52 CYCLE. IN THE SHORT TERM, IT NEEDS --
27:56 MEANS MORE VOLATILITY, MORE UNCERTAINTY.
27:58 THAT IS CERTAINLY NOT GOOD FOR INVESTOR SENTIMENT RIGHT NOW.
28:01 THE LAST THING THE TRADE NEEDED IS SOMETHING LIKE THIS
28:02 HAPPENING. CHAD: WE WERE TALKING ABOUT THE
28:10 BLOWBACK IN WASHINGTON. WHAT DO YOU THINK THIS COULD
28:14 POTENTIALLY MEAN FOR SALES TO CHINA AND SO ON?
28:19 DO YOU THINK THERE WILL BE MORE REGULATIONS IN PLACE AS A RESULT
28:20 OF THIS? MADELEINE: I THINK SO, YES.
28:26 LET'S SEE HOW MUCH PRESIDENT TRUMP CAN BLOCK.
28:29 HE WILL CERTAINLY GET MORE LEGISLATION ON HIS TABLE.
28:36 THIS IS A HUGE NATIONAL SECURITY ISSUE.
28:37 EVERY STATEMENT WE HAVE HEARD FROM POLITICIANS COMING BACK
28:40 FROM THIS IS THEY TAKE THIS VERY SERIOUSLY.
28:46 OBVIOUSLY JENSEN HUANG AND PRESIDENT TRUMP'S STANCE IS IT
28:51 IS NOT SO BAD IF WE SELL TECHNOLOGY TO OTHER COUNTRIES
28:54 BECAUSE THEY BASICALLY REMAIN MORE RELIANT ON U.S. TECHNOLOGY.
28:58 BUT WE KNOW THAT THE DEMOCRATS HAVE A MORE STRICT STANCE
29:01 ALREADY. I EXPECT THE SITUATION NOW TO
29:03 INCREASE THE SCRUTINY ON THAT EVEN FURTHER.
29:08 I WOULD 100% EXPECT SOMETHING TO COME THERE.
29:10 THE QUESTION IS TO WHAT MAGNITUDE.
29:11 SOMETHING THAT HAS BEEN TALKED ABOUT IS HOW MUCH COMPANIES
29:17 WITHIN CHINA CAN RUN COMPUTE CAPACITY FROM OTHER ASIAN
29:18 COMPANIES. IT WILL BE MORE ON THE CHIP
29:22 SUPPLY SIDE. THOSE ARE THE ITEMS TO WATCH,
29:27 WHAT WE NEED TO FIGURE OUT. THAT IS ALSO WHY WE ARE AIRING
29:37 ON THE SIDE CAUTION WITH NAMES THAT HAVE LARGE EXPOSURES THERE.
29:40 THAT IS HOW WE THINK ABOUT IT. CHAD: OF COURSE, YOU ARE TALKING
29:45 ABOUT THE BIG DEMOCRATIC WIN. WHAT DO YOU THINK THIS MEANS
29:51 U.S.? MADELEINE:MADELEINE: I HAVE A
30:00 STRONG OPINION ON THIS. I THINK THE FIRST MARKET
30:03 FUNDAMENTAL IMPACT OF THIS. I REALLY THINK THE CAMPAIGN OF
30:10 THE DEMOCRATS HAS BEEN ON BUILDING DATA CENTERS RIGHT AND
30:13 ALL. I THINK TAXATION WILL INCREASE,
30:20 THE PACE OF THE BILL THAT WILL SLOW.
30:24 BUT THE NEW TEXAS GOVERNOR, SHE ALSO CONFIRMED IF YOU ARE
30:30 ALREADY UNDER CONSTRUCTION, YOU CAN FINISH THE DATA CENTER.
30:35 DEPENDING ON THE NUMBERS TO LOOK AT, THAT MEANS 20 TO 22
30:39 GIGAWATTS OF EXPANSION NEXT YEAR.
30:40 I THINK THAT IS ENOUGH FOR MOST OF THE COMPANIES TO NOT SEE
30:45 SIGNIFICANT DOWN GRADE. THAT EFFECTIVELY GIVES YOU A
30:48 BRIDGE UNTIL YOU CAN FIGURE OUT WHAT THE NEW REGULATIONS ARE,
30:50 WHAT ARE THE BEST WAYS TO DO THIS, AND THEN YOU CAN GET MORE
30:53 PERMITTING DONE. IF THE TAXATION INCREASES, THE
30:59 INCENTIVE TO KEEP THIS INVESTMENT WITHIN THE STATE GETS
31:02 EVEN HIGHER. WE HAVE HEARD SOME STATEMENTS,
31:11 THE PLATFORM HEAD OF META SAID THEY REACHED OUT AND SAID, LET'S
31:13 FIGURE THIS OUT. I DON'T WANT TO LOSE THIS
31:16 INVESTMENT, I DON'T WANT TO LOSE THE JOBS.
31:18 I THINK THAT IS THE KEY ARGUMENT HERE.
31:21 YOU HAVE THAT BRIDGE THAT HELPS YOU.
31:25 THE IMPACT IS NEGATIVE BECAUSE HE BROADENS IT OUT MORE.
31:32 THE REACTION HAS BEEN SO HARSH, THAT HAS BEEN A BIT OVERBLOWN
31:34 AND THAT WILL FIGURE ITSELF OUT. THE QUESTION IS WHEN BECAUSE WE
31:40 ARE SITTING IN A PERIOD UNTIL DEMOCRATS BASICALLY COME INTO
31:41 OFFICE. BUT I THINK THAT IS ALSO WHY THE
31:50 MARKET HAS STARTED TO RECOVER TO THE NVIDIA TOPIC.
31:54 HEAVY? IS THIS AN OPPORTUNITY
32:01 POTENTIALLY FOR EUROPE? MADELEINE: I THINK YES.
32:07 EUROPE HAS BEEN DOING WELL. IT IS A RELATIVE SAFE HAVEN WITH
32:18 I EQUITIES. EUROPE ALWAYS WAS HOLDING UP
32:19 BETTER, EVEN WITHIN THE RELATED AI COMPLEXES.
32:26 I THINK THAT IS A POSITIVE AS INVESTORS TRY TO DIVERSIFY AWAY
32:28 FROM TRADE. DON'T COMPLETELY PULL OUT OF THE
32:39 AI TRADE BECAUSE YOU SEE THAT GOOD EARNINGS GROWTH AND YOU
32:41 STILL SEE THAT CONTINUING NEXT YEAR, BUT BALANCE IT OUT WITH
32:47 EXPOSURE IN EUROPE WITH EXPOSURE AND HEALTH CARE.
32:49 I THINK THAT HAS BEEN THE MARKET'S WAY TO GO.
32:53 SOME OF THESE DEFENSIVE AREAS HAVE BECOME MORE EXPENSIVE IN
32:55 THE RECENT WEEKS IN PARTICULAR. SO, YOU HAVE TO START IN THE
33:01 DEFENSIVE AREAS TO BE MORE SELECTIVE.
33:03 BUT I DO THINK THERE IS A GOOD CHANCE TO LOOK AT EUROPEAN
33:06 EQUITIES AGAIN, AND I THINK INVESTORS ARE DOING EXACTLY
33:07 THAT. CHAD: MADELEINE RONNER, SENIOR
33:11 PORTFOLIO MANAGER FOR GLOBAL EQUITIES AT DWS THE CRISIS THAT
33:17 NVIDIA IS REACHING DEEP INTO WASHINGTON AS WELL.
33:19 COMMERCE SECRETARY HOWARD LUTNICK IS DRAWING SCRUTINY OVER
33:25 WHETHER HIS DEPARTMENT DID ENOUGH TO KEEP THE COMPANY'S
33:28 PRIZED AI CHIPS OUT OF CHINA SANDS.
33:31 FOR MORE, LET'S BRING IN OUR CHIEF ASIA CORRESPONDENT ROSLYN
33:33 MATHESON. WE SPOKE YESTERDAY ABOUT THE
33:36 PRESSURE THIS WOULD PUT ON THE U.S. GOVERNMENT.
33:39 NO CONGRESS IS DEMANDING ANSWERS.
33:46 ROSALIND: WE HAVE QUESTIONS FROM DONALD TRUMP ABOUT THESE
33:52 QUESTIONS -- WITH QUESTIONS FOR DONALD TRUMP ABOUT HIS
33:53 RELATIONS. AT WHAT POINT TO THE BECOME
33:57 AWARE OF THESE CONCERNS ABOUT HIS RELATIONSHIP WITH A WOMAN
33:58 WHO IS ALLEGED TO BE A SPY. AND DID THEY DO ENOUGH TO TRY TO
34:06 CUT OFF THE FLOW OF HIGH-END U.S. CHIPS, AI CHIPS, TO FIND A
34:09 WAY INTO CHINESE HANDS. THAT IS POTENTIALLY WHERE THE
34:14 QUESTIONS AROUND THE COMMERCE DEPARTMENT AND THE ACTIONS OF
34:19 HOWARD LUTNICK IN THERE ARE DEMANDS THAT HE TESTIFY, AND YOU
34:23 HAVE SEEN THOSE COMMANDS COMING NOT -- DEMANDS COMING NOT JUST
34:26 FROM DEMOCRATS BUT REPUBLIK AND'S AS WELL, AND PARTICULAR
34:36 FOCUS IS WHETHER IT WAS TO SOME EXTENT MUZZLING HIS EFFORTS TO
34:38 LOOK AT EMERGING QUESTIONS AROUND NVIDIA.
34:42 AND ALSO, THERE ARE REPORTS THAT TRUMP DID AUTHORIZE A FRESH
34:45 CRACKDOWN OF COMPANIES SUSPECTED OF DIVERTING AI CHIPS TO CHINA,
34:50 AUTHORIZATIONS. SO, THERE'S A LOT OF QUESTIONS
34:55 EMERGING HERE, PARTICULARLY WHEN IT COMES TO WHAT IS HAPPENING IN
34:58 WASHINGTON. THOSE QUESTIONS ARE FOCUSING ON
35:00 LUTNICK AND THE DECISIONS HE'S MADE.
35:05 CHAD: SUPPORT IS ALSO GROWING IN CONGRESS FOR MORE EXPORT
35:08 CONTROLS ON CHIPS. WHAT PROPOSALS ARE FLOATING
35:09 AROUND AT THIS POINT? ROSALIND: THIS IS THE BUREAU OF
35:17 INDUSTRY AND SECURITY IT FALLS UNDER CONGRESS THAT MIGHT BE
35:20 LOOKING AT A NEW ROLE THAT EXTENDS TO SEVEN COUNTRIES.
35:26 THESE RESTRICTIONS ON EXPORTS. THEY WOULD INCLUDE SOUTH EAST
35:30 ASIA. THERE'S BEEN A LOT OF FOCUS
35:37 AROUND SOUTH EAST ASIA OR THESE DATA CENTERS BUILT IN COUNTRIES
35:41 INCLUDING MALAYSIA FOR EXAMPLE, WHERE A LOT OF THE BUSINESS IS
35:43 COMING TO CHINESE CLIENTS FROM AFAR.
35:48 SO, REMOTE BUSINESS FOR CHINESE COMPANIES AND WHETHER THEY NEED
35:51 TO BE EXTENDED TO THESE RULES. THERE IS A SENSE THERE IS THIS
35:53 MOMENTUM BUILDING THE TOUGHER ACTION IN WASHINGTON IN THE
36:01 SENSE THAT CHINA IS GETTING THE UPPER HAND ON BOTH SIDES OF THE
36:03 EYE A. IF THAT IS THE CASE, IT WILL BE
36:06 VERY DIFFICULT FOR DONALD TRUMP. HE CAN VETO LEGISLATION AS MUCH
36:10 AS HE WANTS, BUT IT IS NOT A GOOD LOOK TO BE VETOING EVERY
36:13 BIT OF ANTI-CHINA LEGISLATION THAT CROSSES HIS DESK.
36:20 HE IS ABOUT TO GO SIT DOWN WITH CHINESE PRESIDENT XI JINPING
36:22 WITH THIS PRESSURE ON HIM TO SOUND TOUGH, TO BRING THESE
36:25 ISSUES UP. AT THE SAME TIME, DONALD TRUMP
36:29 PROBABLY WANTS TO PRESERVE THE TRADE TRUCE THEY GOT EXTENDED AT
36:32 THIS POINT UNTIL JANUARY. AND EVEN BEYOND.
36:35 HE HAS THESE DUELING ISSUES OF NEEDING TO SOUND TOUGH, PERHAPS
36:38 RAISE THESE ISSUES WITH XI JINPING.
36:42 BUT WHILE HE IS IN CHINA, ALSO NOT SAYING ANYTHING INFLAMMATORY
36:46 AND KEEPING THAT REPORT GOING WITH XI JINPING.
36:48 IT WILL BE INTERESTING TIMES INDEED IN CHINA NEXT WEEK WHEN
36:50 THOSE TWO MEN MEET. CHAD: WE WILL DEFINITELY BE
36:54 WATCHING THOSE MEETINGS CLOSELY NEXT WEEK.
36:59 BLOOMBERG'S CHIEF ASIAN CORRESPONDENT ROSALIND MATHIESON
37:01 JOINING US. THE LATEST EPISODE OF "THE
37:07 CIRCUIT" FOCUSED ON THE RISE OF JENSEN HUANG, WITH AN IN-DEPTH
37:09 LOOK AT THE OUSTED CEO. YOU CAN WATCH THAT AND ON
37:12 YOUTUBE, BLOOMBERG.COM, AND ON THE TERMINAL.
37:18 COMING UP, VOLODYMYR ZELENSKYY SAYS PROGRESS TOWARDS PEACE HAS
37:21 BEEN MADE DURING MEETINGS WITH U.S. NEGOTIATORS.
37:22 WE WILL GET THE LATEST ON THAT FROM DUBLIN.
37:24 AND THIS IS BLOOMBERG. ♪
37:48 CHAD: BLOOMBERG WHISKEY SAYS PROGRESS HAS BEEN MADE IN A
37:51 MEETING WITH ENVOYS IN IRELAND WITH A PRISONER SWAP DEAL.
37:56 LET'S GET MORE ON THIS FROM OUR CHIEF EUROPE CORRESPONDENT,
37:59 JOINING US FROM DUBLIN. CAN YOU TELL US MORE ABOUT WHAT
38:01 IS HAPPENING AT THIS MEETING? >> ABSOLUTELY.
38:13 BEGAN IN THE EMIRATES AND ABU DHABI WITH THE TRILATERAL
38:16 MEETING BETWEEN NEGOTIATORS, DAVE GARDNER -- JARED KUSHNER
38:21 AND STEVEN WITKOFF. THERE WERE A NUMBER OF EUROPEAN
38:25 DELEGATIONS, BUT THEY WERE NOT ACTUALLY IN THE MEETINGS
38:28 DISCUSSING THESE ISSUES WITH THE RUSSIANS, THE UKRAINIANS, AND
38:30 THE AMERICANS. THEY WERE GETTING BRIEFED ON THE
38:32 SIDE. YOU GOT THAT EXCHANGE OF
38:35 PRISONERS, OVER A THOUSAND ON EITHER SIDE, THAT WAS SEEN AS A
38:40 MATERIAL BREAK THROUGH. THEN YOU HAD KUSHNER AND WYCOFF
38:44 GO TO MOSCOW, THEY MET WITH PUTIN.
38:47 PUTIN REITERATED HIS RED LINES, PARTICULARLY ON THE IDEA THAT
38:51 UKRAINE SHOULD NOT HAVE FOREIGN TROOPS PARTICULARLY ON THE DAY
38:52 AFTER THERE WAS A PIECE NEGOTIATION.
38:58 WE SHOULD SAY THAT THE SORT OF MAIN EVENT IS THE FACT THAT
39:00 THESE TRILATERAL DISCUSSIONS ACTUALLY BEGAN -- REMEMBER,
39:06 THESE WERE PUT ON HOLD, THE U.S. DIPLOMATIC EFFORT TO BRING THE
39:10 WAR TO AN END, BACK IN FEBRUARY. NOW IT SEEMS THIS WEEK, FOR THE
39:13 FIRST TIME IN A NUMBER OF YEARS, THE EUROPEANS MAY HAVE EARNED
39:17 THEMSELVES A SEAT AT THE TABLE. THERE IS A REALIZATION FROM THE
39:19 U.S. SIDE. THE UKRAINIANS HAVE BEEN PUSHING
39:23 FOR IT A LONG TIME, BUT NOW ALSO FROM THE RUSSIAN SIDE THAT YOU
39:26 CANNOT GET AN ENDURING PEACE AGREEMENT WITHOUT THE EUROPEANS
39:28 AT THE TABLE. THE EUROPEANS MAY HAVE EARNED
39:31 THEMSELVES A SEAT AT THE TABLE, BUT THEY HAVE NOT SAID WHO
39:33 SHOULD SIT AT THAT SEAT. THAT IS GOING TO PUT PRESSURE ON
39:37 THE EUROPEAN LEADERS MEETING HERE TODAY AT DUBLIN AT THE
39:38 EUROPEAN COUNCIL. IN ALL THE YEARS WE HAVE TALKED
39:43 ABOUT THIS, AND I HAVE BEEN ASKING MINISTERS, LEADERS WHO
39:45 SHOULD BE SEATED AT THE TABLE, THE EUROPEANS HAVE STILL NOT
39:47 BEEN ABLE TO ANSWER. NOW WE ARE MOVING FROM THAT
39:51 TRILATERAL MEETING TO A MULTILATERAL MEETING.
39:53 IT IS NOW UP TO THE EUROPEANS TO SELECT THE RIGHT PERSON.
39:57 IS IT GOING TO BE A LEADER OF ONE OF THE NATIONS, THE E3, THE
40:00 FRENCH, THE GERMANS, OR SOMEBODY ELSE WHO HAS A GOOD REPORT WITH
40:03 THE UKRAINIANS AND RUSSIANS? CAN CHAD: THE OTHER --
40:14 CHAD: GET A BIG TOPIC IS THE ECB SUCCESSION RACE.
40:17 WHAT ARE WE LEARNING FROM LEADERS THERE WHO MIGHT END UP
40:20 LEADING THE CENTRAL BANK? OLIVER: THAT IS GOING TO BE ONE
40:24 OF THE BIG TOPICS OF DISCUSSION HERE AT THE EUROPEAN COUNCIL
40:26 TODAY. WE EXPECT PROGRESS TO BE MADE ON
40:30 THAT. THE ECB PRESIDENT LAGARDE SAID
40:33 SHE WOULD STEP DOWN IN FEBRUARY, BUT THEY ARE TRYING TO APPOINT A
40:37 TRIFECTA OF FREE JOBS THAT WILL BE APPOINTED IN THE FIRST PART
40:40 OF THE YEAR. THERE IS THE PRESIDENT OF THE
40:42 ECB, THE CHIEF ECONOMIST, AND THEN THE SUPERVISOR OF THE
40:45 MARKETS, THE THIRD JOB ON THE ECB EXECUTIVE BOARD THAT IS
40:48 GOING TO OPEN UP. NOW IT SEEMS THAT, ACCORDING TO
40:51 REPORTS IN MAINLY THE FRENCH MEDIA, THAT THE FRENCH HAVE
40:55 ALIGNED BEHIND THE SPANISH CANDIDATE TO LEAVE THE ECB IN
41:01 FAVOR OF HIM OVER THE DUTCHMAN.
41:03 AND THERE HAVE ALSO BEEN DISCUSSIONS THAT POTENTIALLY NOW
41:07 THE GERMANS ARE ON BOARD WITH THAT ARRANGEMENT.
41:09 THAT WOULD GIVE POTENTIALLY BE GERMANS, THE CHIEF ECONOMIST,
41:12 AND THE FRENCH A MARKET SUPERVISOR.
41:17 WE COULD SAY THE GERMANS HAVE PUSHED BACK, BUT THOSE ARE THE
41:19 NAMES WE SEE FLOATING AROUND. FOR THOSE THREE JOBS, THERE'S
41:22 ALWAYS THIS QUESTION OF FORCE TRADING.
41:24 IT SEEMS LIKE THE SPANISH WOULD GET THE PRESIDENCY, THE CHIEF
41:27 ECONOMIST COULD GO TO THE GERMANS, AND THE MARKET
41:29 SUPERVISOR COULD GO TO THE FRENCH.
41:32 CHAD: OLIVER CROOK FOR US THIS MORNING IN DUBLIN.
41:37 WE WANT TO TURN NOW TO SOME BREAKING NEWS AROUND NVIDIA.
41:41 A CHINESE COMPANY FOUNDED BY ALICE WONG, THE WOMAN AT THE
41:44 CENTER OF THE CONTROVERSY DOGGING NVIDIA, PROCURED
41:48 SMUGGLED AI CHIPS THAT WERE INSTALLED IN A SHANGHAI DATA
41:52 CENTER WITH LINKS TO MEGASPEED. THAT IS ACCORDING TO DOCUMENTS
41:55 THAT HAVE BEEN REVIEWED BY BLOOMBERG NEWS.
41:58 THE DOCUMENTS OFFER THE MOST EXPLICIT EVIDENCE YET THAT THE
42:01 EXTENSIVE NETWORK OF CHINESE COMPANIES WITH ALICE WONG AT THE
42:04 CENTER MANAGED TO GET HIS HANDS ON SMUGGLED NVIDIA HARDWARE.
42:10 WE WILL HAVE MUCH MORE ON THAT AS THE MORNING UNFOLDS.
42:13 NOW TO SOME OF OUR OTHER TOP STORIES, BLOOMBERG HAS LEARNED
42:17 THE EUROPEAN UNION IS SET TO APPROVE MORE THAN 100 NEW
42:21 SANCTIONS ON RUSSIA, TARGETING BANKS, ENERGY FIRMS, AND TANKERS
42:23 MOVING RUSSIAN OIL. WE ARE TOLD FOREIGN MINISTERS
42:29 ARE EXPECTED TO APPROVE THE MEASURES ON MONDAY IN RESPONSE
42:33 TO A RISE IN SO-CALLED HYBRID ATTACKS LINKED TO MOSCOW.
42:36 THE LOWER HOUSE OF THE DUTCH PARLIAMENT HAS NARROWLY PASSED A
42:38 BILL THAT WOULD INCREASE TAXES ON WEALTHY, PUTTING PRIME
42:43 MINISTER ROB GOTTEN'S COALITION AT RISK.
42:45 THE CONSERVATIVE PEOPLE'S PARTY HAS THREATENED TO QUIT OVER THE
42:47 PLAN, WHICH STILL NEEDS APPROVAL FROM THE UPPER HOUSE.
42:52 PLENTY MORE COMING UP ON BLOOMBERG THIS MORNING.
42:53 WE WILL LOOK AT SOME OF YOUR FAVORITE -- OUR FAVORITE
42:57 TERMINAL CHARTS, COMING UP RIGHT AFTER THE BREAK.
43:24 ♪ >> NVIDIA'S PROBABLY GOT THE
43:30 MOST POWERFUL IP ON THE PLANET. THE VISION OF NP IS GOING TO BE
43:37 CALLED -- IF NVIDIA IS GOING TO BE CALLED INTO QUESTION.
43:40 >> WE HAVE TO VIEW THIS AS MORE TACTICAL IN NATURE.
43:44 >> IS THE AI TRADE ONE MAN OR A COMPANY THAT IS LEADING THE
43:46 CHARGE ON A RELATIVE BASIS? >> ESSENTIALLY USING SOMEONE
43:50 THAT CAN BRING TOGETHER ALL THE PARTIES.
43:53 >> I HAPPEN TO THINK THAT WE WILL MOVE FORWARD, THAT THE
43:57 UNDERLYING ONE SEEN A GENERATION INNOVATION WILL CARRY THROUGH.
44:03 CHAD: SOME OF OUR GUESTS ACROSS BLOOMBERG TV REACTING TO JENSEN
44:05 HUANG'S DRAMATIC DEPARTURE FROM NVIDIA.
44:08 WE WANT TO STICK WITH THIS TOPIC NOW AS WE LOOK AT OUR TERMINAL
44:14 CHARTS THIS MORNING, OUR FAVORITE CHARTS THIS MORNING.
44:19 A STEEP DROP IN NVIDIA SHARES AS THE SCANDAL AROUND JENSEN HUANG
44:23 UNFOLDED. SHARES PLUMBED YESTERDAY AS MUCH
44:26 AS 14% BUT MANAGED TO RECOVER AND CLOSE DOWN JUST 4.3%.
44:30 THAT HELPED THE COMPANY JUST MANAGE TO HOLD THE LINE AND KEEP
44:37 A MARKET VALUE OF $4 TRILLION. LET'S FLIP THE CHART.
44:41 WE SEE THE GAP BETWEEN NVIDIA AND THE REST OF ITS MAGNIFICENT
44:43 7 PEERS. NVIDIA IS THE WHITE LINE HERE.
44:50 NVIDIA HAS BEEN DROPPING SINCE ABOUT MAY OF THIS YEAR.
44:55 IT IS NOW THE LOWEST OF THE SEVEN WITH APPLE, THE PURPLE
44:57 LINE YOU SEE HERE, REALLY LEADING THE UPPER CHARGE AND
44:58 BREAKING AWAY FROM THE REST OF THE GROUP.
45:02 LET'S FLIP THE CHART AGAIN. THIS ONE SHOWS US JUST OVER THE
45:09 LAST WEEK OR SO HOW NVIDIA IS LAYING THE SEMICONDUCTOR INDEX.
45:14 THE INDEX INCLUDES SOME OF NVIDIA'S CHIPMAKING PEERS SUCH
45:17 AS BROADCOM AND ADVANCED MICRO DEVICES.
45:20 THE STOCK OF THOSE RIVALS HAVE GAINED OFF OF THE BACK OF THE
45:23 NVIDIA WOES. LATER THIS MORNING, WE ARE GOING
45:28 TO HAVE A SPECIAL EDITION OF BLOOMBERG TECH: EUROPE WITH TOM
45:32 MACKENZIE, AND HE WILL BE EXPLORING HOW THE SHOCK WAVES
45:35 FROM JENSEN HUANG'S DEPARTURE FROM NVIDIA ARE BEING FELT
45:38 ACROSS EUROPE. CATCH THE EPISODE AT 8:30 LONDON
45:42 TIME. THAT'S 9:30 HERE IN BERLIN.
45:47 THAT'S IT FOR US HERE ON "DAYBREAK: EUROPE."
45:51 "THE OPENING TRADE" IS COMING UP NEXT.
45:55 HAVE A GREAT WEEKEND, EVERYONE,
Nvidia Names Kress Interim CEO After Huang Exit as Trump Cools on Iran Deal full transcript
0:14 ABEER: GOOD MORNING. THIS IS "HORIZONS MIDDLE EAST &
0:15 AFRICA." OUR TOP STORIES THIS MORNING.
0:16 JENSEN HUANG RESIGNS AS THE RAPIDLY ESCALATING SCANDAL
0:18 ENDING HIS THREE DECADE RUN AT THE CHIP GIANT.
0:19 THE CFO TAKES OVER ON AN INTERIM BASIS AS THE COMPANY SEARCHES
0:21 FOR A PERMANENT SUCCESSOR. ANTHROPIC'S IPO IS SET TO BE SIX
0:26 TIMES OVERSUBSCRIBED AS THE CLOCKMAKER TARGETS A VALUATION
0:30 OF $1.4 TRILLION. EMIRATES GLOBAL ALUMINUM SAYS IT
0:36 IS MAKING STRONG PROGRESS RESTORING PRODUCTION AT ITS MAIN
0:41 SMELTER AFTER A STRIKE EARLIER THIS YEAR.
0:43 WE WILL SPEAK WITH CEO PAL K ILDEMO ABOUT THE RECOVERY AND
0:47 THEIR EARNINGS IN A FEW MINUTES. IT HAS GONE AT 9:00 A.M. ACROSS
0:50 THE EMIRATES. LET'S START WITH A QUICK LOOK
0:56 THIS FRIDAY MORNING INTO WHAT MARKETS HAVE BEEN DOING.
1:00 YOU ARE LOOKING AT A FLAT PERFORMANCE FOR S&P FUTURES.
1:04 YOU ARE ALSO LOOKING AT A FLAT PERFORMANCE FOR NASDAQ FUTURES.
1:08 YESTERDAY. THE BIGGEST STORY OVER THE PAST
1:13 COUPLE DAYS HAS BEEN NVIDIA, JENSEN HUANG, THE RESIGNATION
1:15 THAT CAME YESTERDAY. CFO HAS TAKEN ON ON AN INTERIM
1:21 BASIS. THE DOWNSIDE IN THE STOCK
1:26 YESTERDAY WAS PARED. AT THE CLOSE NVIDIA DROPPING 4%.
1:31 IT DROPPED IN THE AFTER HOURS AS WELL.
1:35 SOME POSITIVITY IN THE MARKET WHEN ONE COMPANY LOSES, ANOTHER
1:37 WINS. IN THIS CASE IT WAS BROADCOM AND
1:40 AMD. THESE TWO WERE THE BENEFICIARIES
1:45 OF THE DROP IN NVIDIA. WE ARE ALSO LOOKING FOR THE
1:50 ANTHROPIC IPO WHICH IS CREATING A BIT OF POSITIVITY IN THE WIDER
1:52 MARKET. OVER THE NEXT FEW DAYS, THE BIG
1:58 FOCUS WILL BE NVIDIA, ESPECIALLY WITH EARNINGS SET OUT FOR NEXT
2:03 WEEK, AND THE REPORTED ALL HANDS MEETING THAT IS SET TO HAPPEN
2:04 NEXT WEEK. YOU ARE LOOKING AT ALSO A FLAT
2:09 PERFORMANCE IN ASIA THIS MORNING.
2:11 THE STOCKS WERE FLUCTUATED BETWEEN SMALL WINS AND LOSSES.
2:16 A FLAT PERFORMANCE TO THE DOWNSIDE.
2:19 BRENT CRUDE PRICES ARE DROPPING. THEY HAD GAINED YESTERDAY AFTER
2:22 PRESIDENT TRUMP SUGGESTED ESSENTIALLY THE IRAN CONFLICT,
2:31 HE'S NOT INTERESTED IN A DEAL WITH IRAN.
2:35 WE ARE MONITORING THOSE GEOPOLITICAL DEVELOPMENTS.
2:38 LOOK AT THE YIELD ON THE 10 YEAR BENCHMARK NOTES IN THE UNITED
2:39 STATES. THEY ARE. AGAIN ABOVE FIVE
2:43 PERCENTTHIS MORNING JUST BELOW A BASIS POINT DROP.
2:47 FOR A LOOK AT WHAT IS HAPPENING IN ASIA, WE HAVE WINNIE HSU IN
2:50 OUR HOME: STUDIO. -- HONG KONG STUDIO.
2:57 WINNIE: WE ARE SEEING ASIAN STOCKS LOSE MOMENTUM A FEW HOURS
2:59 INTO THE TRADING SESSION. EARLIER TODAY MSCI ASIA WAS UP
3:04 BY 1%. THAT IS AS INVESTORS LOOK PAST
3:11 THE IMPACT OF THE RESIGNATION FROM NVIDIA'S JENSEN HUANG.
3:16 ALSO FOCUSING MORE ON THE SOLID FUNDAMENTALS OF THIS AI TRADE.
3:20 HOWEVER, INTO THE WEEKEND AND CLOSER TO THE U.S. PPI NUMBERS,
3:26 ESPECIALLY HAVING GOT THAT HOTTER THAN EXPECTED CPI
3:29 NUMBERS, SEEMS LIKE SENTIMENT IS TURNING MORE CAUTIOUS.
3:32 AS YOU MENTIONED, SOME CAUTION BUILDING AHEAD OF NVIDIA'S
3:35 EARNINGS NEXT WEEK. YOU CAN SEE SOUTH KOREA'S KOSPI
3:41 INDEX REVERTING EARLIER GAINS, NOW TRADING IN THE RED.
3:48 THE TAIEX INDEX HOLDING UP WELL AFTER BEING THE WORST PERFORMER
3:49 IN THE REGION YESTERDAY. HONG KONG STOCKS CONTINUE TO
3:57 STRUGGLE GIVEN THE EXPECTATION IS RISING THE U.S. MIGHT BE
3:59 STEPPING UP FURTHER EXPORT CONTROLS ON CHINA GIVEN WHAT HAS
4:04 HAPPENED WITH NVIDIA THAT THE CONCERNS AROUND SECURITY.
4:07 ON THE SCREEN YOU WILL LOOK AT JAPANESE YEN.
4:09 WE ARE SEEING THE YEN TRADING BELOW THAT 160 LEVEL AGAINST THE
4:15 DOLLAR AFTER HAVING BREACHED THE KEY MILESTONE YESTERDAY.
4:17 WE ARE BACK ON INTERVENTION WATCH, ESPECIALLY AFTER THE
4:24 FINANCE MINISTER WARNED OF POTENTIALLY TAKING FURTHER STEPS
4:28 GIVEN THE WEAKNESS OF THE YEN. BACK TO YOU.
4:32 ABEER: WE NEVER FORGET ABOUT THE YEN.
4:34 THANK YOU FOR THAT MARKET UPDATE.
4:40 JENSEN HUANG IS OUT OF NVIDIA, BRINGING AN ABRUPT END TO THE 10
4:43 YEAR OF ONE OF THE MOST INFLUENTIAL FIGURES IN THE
4:44 GLOBAL AI INDUSTRY. HIS DEPARTURE FOLLOWS A
4:49 FAST-MOVING CRISIS THAT PUT NVIDIA'S TIES TO CHINA UNDER
4:51 INTENSE SCRUTINY. AND FACED WITH A SUCCESSION
4:56 CRISIS, NVIDIA'S BOARD PICKED CHIEF FINANCIAL OFFICER COLETTE
5:00 KRESS TO TAKE THE TOP JOB IN AN INTERIM CAPACITY.
5:03 NVIDIA SHARES INITIALLY PLUNGED AS MUCH AS 14% ON NEWS OF THE
5:07 OUSTER BEFORE PAIRING LOSSES. THE FALLOUT COULD HAVE
5:11 IMPLICATIONS WELL BEYOND NVIDIA AT A TIME WHEN ADVANCED CHIPS
5:16 ARE ALREADY AT THE CENTER OF TENSIONS BETWEEN WASHINGTON AND
5:17 BEIJING. AND NOW FOR MORE ON THIS STORY
5:24 THAT IS SEEMINGLY DEVELOPING, LET'S BRING IN OUR NORTH ASIA
5:27 CORRESPONDENT MINMIN LOW IN SHANGHAI.
5:32 LET'S START WITH THE DRAMA WITH JENSEN HUANG.
5:36 HOW IS THAT EXPECTED TO IMPACT THOSE TIES GOING FORWARD?
5:40 LET'S BRING IT TO A MORE MACRO PICTURE BETWEEN THE U.S. AND
5:43 CHINA IF THERE IS ANY IMPLICATION TO THAT
5:44 RELATIONSHIP. MINMIN: THERE IS GOING TO BE A
5:50 LOT OF IMPLICATIONS ON U.S. CHINA TIES.
5:54 NEXT WEEK IS THE APEC SUMMIT IN SHENZHEN WHERE TRUMP IS EXPECTED
5:58 TO MEET WITH PRESIDENT XI. THE REMOVAL OF JENSEN HUANG
6:03 OPENS THE GATE FOR DEMOCRATS TO PUSH HARDER ON THE AGENDA AND TO
6:08 TIGHTEN THE POLICY LOOPHOLES WHEN IT COMES TO TECH CURBS ON
6:10 CHINA. REPORTING WAS THE COMMERCE
6:14 DEPARTMENT COULD COME UP WITH NEW LAWS TIGHTENING THE
6:19 CENTERS. THOSE NEW RULES COULD COME OUT
6:22 AS SOON AS THIS MONTH. THERE ARE AT LEAST THREE OTHER
6:26 PROPOSALS UNDER NEGOTIATION THAT COULD TIGHTEN OTHER ASPECTS OF
6:29 THE TECH CURBS ON CHINA. THE TRUCE IS EXPECTED TO EXPIRE
6:36 IN JANUARY. THE EXTENSION OF THE TRUCE
6:40 CHINA. IF WE ARE LOOKING AT CHANGES TO
6:47 TECH CURBS, THIS COULD CHANGE THE STATUS QUO.
6:52 WHO KNOWS HOW CHINA WILL RESPOND, WHETHER THERE IS
6:53 FURTHER ESCALATION OF TRADE TIES, THAT IS FRONT AND CENTER.
6:57 EVEN THOUGH PRESIDENT TRUMP WHEN ASKED IF YOU WILL RAISE THE
7:02 ISSUE OF HUANG WITH XI, HE MIGHT BE FORCED TO ADDRESS SOME
7:05 OF THOSE QUESTIONS. ABEER: WHAT WOULD BE THE
7:11 IMPLICATIONS OF SUCH A DETERIORATION IF IT WERE TO
7:16 HAPPEN BETWEEN THE CHINESE OF CHINA AND THE UNITED STATES --
7:23 TO HAPPEN WITH TIES BETWEEN CHINA AND THE UNITED STATES?
7:26 MINMIN: LOOK AT THE MARKET REACTION SO FAR.
7:29 YOU LOOK AT THESE CHINESE TECH FIRMS, THE PURE PLAYS LIKE
7:34 MINIMAX, WE SEE DECLINES. THERE ARE CONCERNS THESE
7:36 COMPANIES CAN BE IMPACTED. BLOOMBERG INTELLIGENCE IS
7:40 EXPECTING SOME OF THESE PURE PLAY NAMES COULD BE MOST AT RISK
7:46 OF BEING BANNED BY THE U.S., ESPECIALLY BECAUSE SOME HAVE
7:49 BEEN SO-CALLED NAME AND SHAME IT BY THE U.S. -- SHAMED BY THE
7:55 U.S. WITH DISTILLATION, MUGSHOT, MINIMAX -- MOONSHOT, MINIMAX,
8:01 ALIBABA. IF THAT LOOPHOLE IS CLOSED, IT
8:06 COULD AFFECT MANY COMPANIES, INCLUDING BYTEDANCE.
8:10 SOME RESEARCHERS ESTIMATE BY 2 027 THESEE OVERSEAS DATA
8:19 CENTERS COULD BE ONE THIRD OF CHINA'S COMPUTE CAPACITY.
8:23 THAT IS THE FASTEST WAY TO CUT OFF CHINA'S ACCESS TO COMPUTE.
8:27 I MENTIONED SOME OF THE BILLS UNDER NEGOTIATION INCLUDE THE
8:30 MATCH ACT, WHICH WOULD COMPEL OTHER COUNTRIES TO MATCH U.S.
8:31 EXPORT CONTROL RULES. THERE'S THE SHIP SECURITY ACT
8:35 WHICH WILL REQUIRE COMPANIES TO PHYSICALLY TRACK WHERE THEIR
8:42 CHIPS END UP IN THE SUPPLY CHAIN AND THAT WILL MAKE IT INFINITELY
8:46 WELL. SO FAR THEY HAVE BEEN HEAVILY
8:51 RELIANT ON NVIDIA'S CHIPS. IT EMERGED THAT MOONSHOT AI WAS
9:00 LEASING SOME OF THESE ADVANCED NVIDIA SERVERS AS WELL.
9:05 ABEER: MINMIN, THANK YOU FOR THAT UPDATE AND FOR FOLLOWING
9:06 THIS STORY. BLOOMBERG'S ASIA CORRESPONDENT
9:08 MINMIN LOW. LET'S ZERO IN ON THOSE TALKS.
9:14 ASIAN STOCKS HAVE ERASED AN EARLY TECH LEAD ADVENTS AS BONDS
9:17 SLUMP. TRADERS BRACE FOR THE U.S. PPI
9:23 PRINT DUE LATER TODAY. JUNE AND THIS IS A CAPITAL
9:30 PARTNER CIO -- JOINING US IS A CAPITAL PARTNER CIO.
9:35 I WANT TO START BY FOCUSING ON THE NVIDIA DEVELOPMENTS, THE
9:38 OUSTER OF JENSEN HUANG. LET'S TALK ABOUT GOVERNANCE.
9:41 DO YOU THINK THIS WILL BE CONTAINED OR DO YOU THINK IT
9:46 WILL HAVE BIGGER REPERCUSSIONS ON THE AI INDUSTRY AND GAINS
9:48 THERE? >> GOOD MORNING.
9:52 WHAT HAPPENED IN THE LAST FIVE DAYS, IT LOOKS LIKE A CENTURY IN
9:56 TERMS OF WHAT HAS BEEN HAPPENING WITH NVIDIA, WHICH IS THE
10:02 WORLD'S LARGEST COMPANY BY MARKET CAP.
10:07 THE COMPANY WHICH HAD A FIVE POINT $5 TRILLION VALUATION.
10:12 THE IMPACT OF THE FOUNDER AND CEO, CORPORATE GOVERNANCE IS A
10:20 COMBINATION OF COMPANY LAW, OF THE COMPANY'S OWN CODE OF
10:23 CONDUCT, OF WHAT THE EXCHANGE SAYS.
10:28 WHEN THE BOARD IS SET UP, IT IS MEANT TO BE INDEPENDENT.
10:33 IN NVIDIA'S CASE, SOME OF THE DIRECTORS HAVE BEEN THERE FOR 30
10:34 YEARS. THEY ARE ALSO APPOINTED BY
10:40 EXTERNAL AGENCIES AND NOT JUST CHOSEN BY THE BOARD THEMSELVES.
10:48 YOU HAVE THIS BOARD THAT IS FAMILIAR AND COMPLETELY TRUSTS
10:49 THE CEO. AT THE SAME TIME, OVERSIGHT IS
10:51 IMPORTANT. WE COME TO A CONFLICT OF
10:56 INTEREST WHEN YOU HAVE RELATIONSHIPS WITH EMPLOYEES.
10:59 ABEER: WHAT ARE THE LESSONS LEARNED FOR OTHER SILICON VALLEY
11:03 FIRMS, CERTAINLY THOSE ON WALL STREET?
11:08 >> I THINK THERE WILL BE A CHANGE IN THE OVERSIGHT OF THE
11:14 CEOS ACROSS THE WORLD TO MORE SO IN THE U.S., MORE SO FOR TECH
11:18 COMPANIES, WHERE THE FOUNDER IS THE CEO.
11:23 THEY ARE GOING TO LOOK AT THE COMPETITION ON THOSE BOARDS.
11:26 DIVERSIFICATION IS IMPORTANT. YOU NEED BOARD MEMBERS FROM
11:29 DIFFERENT INDUSTRIES. ALSO SOME OF THE BOARD MEMBERS
11:33 COULD BE SHAREHOLDERS IN THAT COMPANY.
11:36 THAT WILL BE LOOKED AT. THIS IS NOW GOING TO BECOME A
11:42 MODEL FOR A NUMBER OF THE U.S. FORTUNE 500 COMPANIES.
11:47 HOW IS YOUR BOARD CONSTITUTED? ANITA: WE SAW A SLUMP IN NVIDIA,
11:52 CLOSED 4% LOWER BY THE END OF THE SESSION, THEN DROPPED IN THE
11:55 AFTER HOURS. SEEMINGLY WITH THE JENSEN HUANG
11:59 OUSTER. THAT FEELS LIKE THE WORST THING
12:02 THAT COULD HAPPEN. WE ARE STILL GEARING UP FOR HIS
12:06 CONGRESS HEARING. COULD THAT UNRAVEL NVIDIA'S
12:11 PERFORMANCE MORE? ANITA: WHAT IS HAPPENING IS WE
12:16 ARE SEPARATING THE TWO ISSUES. ONE IS YOU HAVE THE BEHAVIOR OF
12:21 THE CEO BEING QUESTIONED. THE EXPORT OF CHIPS WHICH ARE
12:28 NOT PERMITTED INTO CHINA, THAT IS UNDER INVESTIGATION.
12:34 WE KNOW THAT CHINESE COMPANIES OUTSIDE CHINA TOO, THOSE CHIPS
12:38 GO TO CHINA, THAT IS NUMBER ONE. THERE IS A CONGRESSIONAL HEARING
12:41 HAPPENING. YOU TALKED ABOUT THE SHAPE.
12:48 EARNINGS ARE COMING UP ON THE 17TH.
12:51 THAT IS IMPORTANT FOR A COMPANY GROWING REVENUE AT 100% THROUGH
12:55 TWO SOURCES OF REVENUE. ABEER: ANALYSTS ARE EXPECTING A
12:59 GOOD PERFORMANCE THERE. THIS IS A QUESTION I GO BACK TO,
13:05 POSED AT THE START OF ALL THIS BEFORE THE OUSTER OF JENSEN
13:06 HUANG. DO YOU THINK NVIDIA IS BIGGER
13:14 THAN JENSEN, OR THE OTHER WAY AROUND?
13:18 ANITA: I WOULD SAY NVIDIA IS BIGGER.
13:20 IT IS A COMPANY. HE WILL HAVE VOLATILITY CONTINUE
13:23 FOR THE NEXT TWO OR THREE MONTHS UNTIL THE CEO WILL TAKE AT LEAST
13:29 A COUPLE MONTHS. PRESIDENT TRUMP IS LOOKING AT
13:35 THE EX-APPLE CEO. YOU HAVE A FEW CANDIDATES.
13:39 THERE ARE ALSO INSIDERS IN THE RUNNING.
13:42 YES, THE COMPANY IS BIGGER. IT HAS THE MOST POWERFUL TRIP --
13:47 CHIP AT THIS POINT. IT HAS A STRONG MARGIN.
13:51 THAT WILL NOT CHANGE. THERE ARE VERY COMPETENT
13:56 EMPLOYEES AND ENGINEERS IN THE COMPANY.
13:59 ABEER: ON THE REPERCUSSIONS ON OTHER COMPANIES, THE GOVERNANCE
14:03 ISSUES, DO YOU THINK WALL STREET'S SILICON VALLEY
14:07 OVERLOOKS SOME OF THESE ISSUES IN ORDER TO GAIN MARKET SHARE?
14:11 ANITA: I DON'T THINK THEY OVERLOOK.
14:12 I THINK THEY HAVE BEEN IGNORING THEM.
14:16 NVIDIA HAS FUNCTIONED WELL FOR 33 YEARS.
14:21 UNTIL SOMETHING GOES WRONG, PEOP LE MAY HAVE SPRUNG UP.
14:30 THIS WILL DEFINITELY BRING IT TO THE FOREFRONT FOR THE COMPANIES.
14:34 ABEER: A DEVELOPING STORY WE WILL CONTINUE TO MONITOR IN THE
14:36 NVIDIA DRAMA. FOR NOW, THANK YOU SO MUCH FOR
14:40 YOUR TIME AND SHARING YOUR INSIGHTS.
14:48 COMING UP, WE WILL SPEAK TO EMIRATES GLOBAL ALUMINUM CFO
14:50 ABOUT THE RESULTS AND RECOVERY OF ITS MAIN SMELTER.
14:55 THAT CONVERSATION UP NEXT. THIS IS BLOOMBERG.
14:58 ♪ ABEER: EMIRATES GLOBAL ALUMINUM
15:27 SAYS IT IS MAKING STRONG PROGRESS ON RESTORING PRODUCTION
15:31 AT ITS MAIN SMELTER WHICH WAS DAMAGED IN AN ARRAY AND STRIKE
15:32 EARLIER THIS YEAR. AND IT COMES AS THE FIRM
15:39 REPORTED A SUGGESTED NINE-MONTH PROFIT UNTIL THE END OF
15:43 SEPTEMBER FELL 9% TO $744 MILLION.
15:46 FOR MORE ON THESE EARNINGS AND WHAT'S HAPPENING AT EGA, WE ARE
15:50 JOINED BY CFO PAL KILDEMO. GOOD MORNING.
15:52 GOOD TO HAVE YOU WITH US. LET'S START WITH EARNINGS, THE
15:55 PROPHET. AN OVERVIEW, CAN YOU GIVE US A
15:59 QUICK GLIMPSE OF THAT. PAL: YES AND THANKS FOR HAVING
16:03 US ON TODAY. WE ARE SEEING A BIT LOWER
16:06 RESULTS BUT IF YOU LOOK AT A LEVEL BELOW, THE RESULTS ARE
16:10 ACTUALLY QUITE STRONG, BECAUSE OUR VOLUMES ARE FALLING MUCH
16:15 MORE THAN WHAT OUR RESULTS ARE COMING DOWN.
16:18 AND THAT IS THREE THINGS WHICH IS DRIVING THIS.
16:21 NOT ALL OF THEM ARE MAKING. BUT NUMBER ONE, PRICES HAVE BEEN
16:28 QUITE HIGH THIS YEAR COMPARED TO COMING INTO THE YEAR SO THAT
16:29 OFFSET SOME OF THE VOLUME SHORTFALL.
16:33 NUMBER TWO, WE ARE SELLING MUCH MORE HIGHER PREMIUM PRODUCTS.
16:38 SO AS WE HAVE LESS TO SELL, WE MAKE SURE THAT WE DO THE MOST
16:40 VALUABLE SALES. NUMBER THREE, WE HAVE BEEN DOING
16:44 QUITE AGGRESSIVE CASH PRESERVATION METRICS, AND ALSO
16:48 IMPROVING OUR OPERATIONS. ABEER: HOW DOES THE WAR AND THE
16:53 GEOPOLITICS OF EFFECTOR GROWTH STRATEGIES?
16:56 DO YOU PRIORITIZE OTHER THINGS NOW THAN YOU HAD PRE-WAR?
17:01 PAL: SO BEFORE WE GOT THE SITUATION, WE ALREADY HAD A
17:06 DIVERSIFICATION STRATEGY BECAUSE WE HAVE BEEN GROWING CLOSER TO
17:07 OUR CUSTOMERS. EUROPE, U.S., RECYCLING PRIMARY
17:13 AND WE ARE CONTINUING THIS TO THE CURRENT SITUATION.
17:15 ABEER: LET'S TALK ABOUT EXPORT. MAINLY, ARE YOU PLANNING TO
17:21 STILL EXPORT BY THE EAST COAST PORTS OR ARE YOU LOOKING MORE
17:22 TOWARDS THE NORTH? PAL: IN GENERAL, THE MOST
17:27 IMPORTANT THING IS TO GET OUR MENTAL HEALTH AND WE HAVE BEEN
17:33 RESILIENT -- METAL OUT AND WE HAVE BEEN RESILIENT.
17:37 RUNNING BELOW AVAILABLE CAPACITY.
17:40 WHEN CAN WE EXPECT FULL CAPACITY TO RETURN?
17:44 HOW DO YOU LOOK AT MAINTAINING THAT GIVEN THE ONGOING
17:45 GEOPOLITICAL TENSIONS? PAL: WHERE WE EXPECT TO BE UP IN
17:50 FULL PRODUCTION IN THE FIRST QUARTER OF NEXT YEAR, AND ARE
17:53 EXPECT TO HAVE SUPPLY CHAINS IN PLACE FOR THAT.
17:55 ABEER: OK. LET'S TALK A LITTLE BIT AND
17:59 UNPACK A LITTLE BIT MORE THE SUPPLY CHAINS AND THE IMPACT ON
18:00 THEM THROUGHOUT THE COURSE OF THE PAST SEVEN, EIGHT MONTHS.
18:06 DO YOU LOOK AT SUPPLY CHAINS NOW DIFFERENTLY?
18:12 WHAT ARE SOME OF YOUR ULTERIOR WAYS OF LOOKING AT SUPPLY CHAINS
18:14 AND MANAGING TO OVERCOME SOME OF THE CHALLENGES THAT WERE
18:16 PRESENTED OVER THE PAST COUPLE OF QUARTERS?
18:19 PAL: THE MOST IMPORTANT THING FOR US IS THAT WE FIND A WAY TO
18:24 GET OUR METALS TO OUR CUSTOMERS IN EUROPE, TO OUR
18:28 CUSTOMERS IN THE U.S., AND WE HAVE BEEN ABLE TO DO THAT.
18:32 AT THE MOMENT, WE ARE SHIPPING OUT MORE THAN WE ARE PRODUCING,
18:35 WHICH MEANS WE ARE REDUCING INVENTORIES, GETTING MORE METAL
18:39 OUT TO CUSTOMERS. AND AS OUR PRODUCTION RAMPS UP
18:43 TO 100% IN THE START OF NEXT YEAR, WE EXPECT OUR SUPPLY
18:46 CHAINS TO RUN UP TO THE SAME EXTENT.
18:48 ABEER: LET'S TALK ABOUT CUSTOMERS A LITTLE BIT.
18:53 DO YOU THINK THAT CUSTOMERS WILL RETURN OR HAVE RETURNED TO THEIR
18:54 NORMAL ORDERING PATTERNS? AND IF NOT, WENDY EXPECT THAT TO
18:58 RETURN FULLY? PAL: THE GOOD THING WHEN WE CAME
19:02 INTO THIS SITUATION WAS THAT WE HAD A LOT OF METAL SITTING ON
19:06 THE GROUND IN BOTH THE U.S. AND EUROPE, SO WE WERE ABLE TO
19:09 SUPPLY THE NORMAL ORDERING PATTERN.
19:13 THERE HAS BEEN A PERIOD NOW WHERE THEY HAVE HAD TO BUY FROM
19:17 SOME OTHER SUPPLIERS BUT REMEMBER, THESE ARE 10,
19:23 TWENTY-YEAR RELATIONSHIPS AND WE HAVE A VALUE ADDED PRODUCTS SO
19:24 THEY ARE EAGER AND WAITING FOR OUR METAL TO RETURN TO THEIR
19:27 SUPPLY CHAINS. ABEER: LET'S TALK ABOUT
19:29 EFFICIENCY. YOU HAVE STARTED A COST AND
19:33 EFFICIENCY PLAN. CAN YOU WALK US THROUGH SOME OF
19:37 THE DETAILS OF THAT AND HOW IT IS GOING AND HOW LONG THAT
19:39 PLANNING WILL STAY IN PLACE? PAL: SO, WE DO IMPROVEMENT
19:44 PROGRAM. THIS YEAR, TOGETHER WITH CASH
19:52 PRESERVATION MEASURES, IT DELIVERED $200 MILLION
19:53 ADDITIONAL ON THE BOTTOM LINE. THAT COMES FROM IMPROVING OUR
19:57 OPERATIONAL PARAMETERS. IT COMES FROM REDUCING
20:00 UNNECESSARY COSTS. AND EXCITINGLY, IT COMES FROM
20:04 TECHNOLOGY INVESTMENTS. WE HAVE DONE A LOT ON THE
20:09 YEAR. ABEER: OK.
20:14 AND JUST FINALLY, I WANT TO TALK ABOUT THE CONCENTRATION OF
20:17 INDUSTRIALIZATION IN THE REGION. HAS THE WAR SHIFT AT THE WAY YOU
20:23 LOOK AT THE CONCENTRATION OF INDUSTRIES HERE?
20:25 DO YOU LOOK AT DIVERSIFYING? BECAUSE YOU SPOKE ABOUT
20:28 DIVERSIFYING AS WELL. HAVE YOU CONSIDERED DIVERSIFYING
20:31 AWAY FROM HERE GIVEN THE GEOGRAPHY?
20:35 PAL: WE ARE DOUBLING DOWN IN THE UAE AND DUBLIN DOWN OUTSIDE.
20:38 BEFORE THE CURRENT SITUATION -- DOUBLING DOWN OUTSIDE.
20:45 IN THE U.S. AND EUROPE WITH OUR CUSTOMERS BUT AT THE SAME TIME,
20:48 WE ARE ALSO MOVING PARTS OF OUR SUPPLY CHAIN TO THE UAE.
20:54 ON THE RAW MATERIAL SIDE, WE ARE MOST LIKELY EXPANDING OUR
20:54 REFINERY AND INVESTING IN TECHNOLOGY LOCALLY.
21:00 BOTH OUT OF THE UAE AND OUT OF EUROPE AND THE U.S.
21:04 ABEER: DOUBLING DOWN ON BOTH GEOGRAPHIES.
21:07 US THIS MORNING. PAL KILDEMO OF EMIRATES GLOBAL
21:10 ALUMINUM. NOW COMING UP, SANDBOX AQ CEO
21:18 WILL BE GIVING US HIS TAKE ON A VERY BUSY WEEK OF TECH NEWS.
21:22 THAT CONVERSATION UP LATER AND THIS IS BLOOMBERG.
21:41 ♪ ABEER: SPACEX AND TESLA ARE
21:51 PROGRESSING IN NEGOTIATIONS TOWARD A MERGER THAT COULD
21:53 REDEFINE THE LIMITS OF GLOBAL DEALMAKING.
21:55 BLOOMBERG HAS LEARNED THAT ELON MUSK'S TWO LARGEST COMPANIES
22:01 DECEMBER. THE COMPANIES ARE ALSO SAID TO
22:05 HAVE DISCUSSED A SCENARIO IN WHICH AN ANNOUNCEMENT SLIPS INTO
22:08 EARLY 2027. KALSHI IS SET TO BE IN TALKS TO
22:14 RAISE MORE MONEY FROM INVESTORS, VALUING THE PREDICTION MARKET AT
22:16 $65 BILLION. THAT IS JUST WEEKS AFTER CLOSING
22:20 A FUNDING ROUND AT A $40 BILLION VALUATION.
22:24 THAT FUNDRAISING ROUND ANNOUNCED IN LATE OCTOBER WAS EXPECTED TO
22:25 BE THE LAST ONE BEFORE THE COMPANY'S ANTICIPATED IPO BUT
22:33 KLASHI IS SET TO HAVE DECIDED TO RAISE MONEY AGAIN IN.
22:37 BEFORE WE HAD TO OUR BREAK. A FLAT PERFORMANCE FOR S&P
22:42 FUTURES, DOWNSIDE A LITTLE BIT FOR NASDAQ FUTURES, ABOUT 0.2%
22:44 LOWER. EURO STOXX 50 FUTURES BUCKING A
22:50 TREND FROM A FEW DAYS AGO, NOW DROPPING ABOUT 0.4%.
22:52 COMING UP, PRESIDENT TRUMP SAYS THAT THE U.S. DOES NOT NEED AN
22:54 IRAN DEAL. WE WILL BE DISCUSSING THE
22:56 IMPLICATIONS FOR THE GULF AND OIL MARKETS.
22:58 THAT IS NEXT. THIS IS BLOOMBERG.
23:12 ♪ ABEER: GOOD MORNING.
23:15 THIS IS "HORIZONS MIDDLE EAST & AFRICA."
23:19 OUR TOP STORIES THIS MORNING. JENSEN HUANG RESIGNS AS NVIDIA
23:25 CEO AFTER A RAPIDLY ESCALATING SCANDAL, ENDING HIS THREE DECADE
23:29 RUN AT THE CHIP GIANT. CFO COLETTE KRESS TAKES OVER ON
23:33 AN INTERIM BASIS AS THE COMPANY BEGINS THE SEARCH FOR A
23:35 PERMANENT SUCCESSOR. ANTHROPIC DEMAND SOURCE.
23:42 THE A -- DEMAND SOARS. THE AI FIRM'S IPO IS SET TO BE
23:47 SIX TIMES OVERSUBSCRIBED AS THE CLAUDE MAKER TARGETS A VALUATION
23:49 OF $1.4 TRILLION. COMING UP, WE ARE JOINED BY THE
23:58 CEO. IT HAS JUST GONE AT 9:30 A.M.
24:03 ACROSS THE EMIRATES. I AM ABEER ABU OMAR IN DUBAI.
24:07 FUTURES. NASDAQ TILTING A LITTLE BIT TO
24:14 THE DOWNSIDE, ABOUT 0.2% LOWER FOLLOWING A SIMILAR PERFORMANCE
24:16 ON WALL STREET YESTERDAY. THAT IS SEEPING INTO THE ASIA
24:18 SESSION UP. WE HAD SEEN IN GAINS IN ASIA
24:22 EARLIER DRIVEN BY SOUTH KOREA'S KOSPI AND THE STOCKS IN TAIWAN
24:27 BUT NOW YOU ARE LOOKING AT ZERO POINT 3% LOWER FOR THE MSCI ASIA
24:30 PACIFIC. THIS IS MAINLY AN AI STORY.
24:36 THE OUSTER OF JENSEN HUANG REALLY WEIGHED ON THE SHARES OF
24:37 NVIDIA YESTERDAY. THEY STARTED 14% LOWER AT THE
24:44 SESSION BUT PARED A LOT OF THOSE LOSSES AT THE END OF THE
24:47 SESSION, CLOSED 4% LOWER BUT DROPPED IN AFTER HOURS.
24:52 OF COURSE, WE ARE GEARING UP FOR NVIDIA'S EARNINGS NEXT WEEK AND
24:55 AS WELL. THAT IS WHAT BLOOMBERG HAD
24:58 REPORTED. JUST WHEN A COMPANY LOSES,
25:02 OTHERS GAIN. THIS IS WHAT GAINED YESTERDAY,
25:10 BROADCOM AND AMD, OF COURSE, OTHER CHIPMAKERS IN THE UNITED
25:13 STATES, SMALLER THAN NVIDIA BUT THEY BOTH RALLIED ABOUT 5%
25:15 DURING THE U.S. SESSION. WE ARE KEEPING AN EYE ON BRENT
25:17 CRUDE PRICES. THEY'RE DROPPING NOW, STILL
25:21 ABOUT $96 ON THE BARREL. PRESIDENT TRUMP HAD SAID WE
25:26 DON'T NEED A DEAL WITH IRAN, AND AGAIN ANOTHER QUOTE, "THOSE DAYS
25:31 HAVE LONG SINCE PASSED." WHETHER THAT DEAL WILL BE
25:37 ACTUALLY ACHIEVED IS NOW VERY FAR-FETCHED.
25:42 WE ARE ALSO KEEPING AN EYE ON THE BENCHMARK YIELDS IN THE
25:45 UNITED STATES, ONCE AGAIN ABOVE 5%.
25:48 THIS MORNING THE SELLOFF IS A LITTLE BIT MORE MODERATE.
25:52 WE ARE LOOKING AT A DECLINE IN YIELDS THAT IS SLIGHTLY BELOW
25:53 ONE BASIS POINT. LET'S RETURN TO THE GEOPOLITICAL
25:56 PICTURE IN THE MIDDLE EAST. OIL IS HOLDING ONTO GAINS AFTER
26:00 PRESIDENT TRUMP CAST FRESHENED OUT ON A DIPLOMATIC SOLUTION --
26:09 CAST FRESH DOUBT ON A DIPLOMATIC SOLUTION.
26:16 TO THE CONFLICT WITH IRAN HE HAS TOLD JD VANCE TO STEP BACK FROM
26:16 STANDOFF. I AM NOW JOINED BY STUART
26:22 LIVINGSTONE-WALLACE, BLOOMBERG'S EXECUTIVE EDITOR FOR THE MIDDLE
26:23 EAST AND NORTH AFRICA. PRESIDENT TRUMP'S LATEST REMARKS
26:29 SUGGEST THAT THE CONFLICT WAS WINDING DOWN AND NOW WE ARE
26:36 GOING BACK TO -- AND MENTIONED COUNTRIES IN THE REGION WANTING
26:39 A BIT OF A LONGER PERIOD. >> THE PIVOT POINT IN TERMS OF
26:42 THE RHETORIC IS VERY MUCH THE MIDTERMS.
26:46 I DON'T WANT TO BE TOO SIMPLISTIC BUT YOU CAN SEE A
26:47 CLEAR DIVIDING LINE FROM HIS READ IT BEFORE THEN AND AFTER
26:48 THAN. I THINK HE FINDS HIMSELF
26:54 INCREASINGLY BOXED IN AND VERY AWARE OF THE DAMAGE POLITICALLY
26:56 DOMESTICALLY THAT THIS IS DOING TO HIM.
27:01 ON THE OTHER HAND, HE DOES NOT HAVE A GREAT DEAL IN THE WAY OF
27:02 GREAT OPTIONS HERE. YES, HE CAN ESCALATE, BUT I
27:07 THINK WISE COUNSEL WOULD SUGGEST THAT IS PROBABLY NOT GOING TO
27:08 GET VERY FAR. ON THE OTHER HAND, HE HAS A
27:11 REASONABLY SUCCESSFUL BLOCKADE IN PLACE, AT LEAST AT THE
27:16 MARITIME BLOCKADE. THE LAND BLOCKADE I THINK IS
27:17 GOING TO BE MORE DIFFICULT. AT THE SAME TIME, THE PARTNERS
27:22 IN THE MIDDLE EAST, PARTICULARLY THE SIDE OF THE PERSIAN GULF,
27:25 PRESSING HIM NOT TO ESCALATE AND PUSHING THE DIPLOMACY ROUTE.
27:28 IF HE IS NOW COMING OUT AND SAY NOT INTERESTED IN DIPLOMACY
27:32 EITHER OR AT LEAST THERE DOES NOT APPEAR TO BE A NEED FOR A
27:39 DON'T QUITE KNOW WHAT TO MAKE OF IT BECAUSE EXPECTED TO HAVE THIS
27:40 PERPETUAL STATE OF NEITHER WAR NOR PEACE.
27:43 ABEER: SPEAKING OF AN AWKWARD PLACE, I AM ALSO THINKING ABOUT
27:47 SUSTAINABILITY OF THE SITUATION. NO WAR, NO PEACE.
27:52 HOW SUSTAINABLE IS THAT FOR COUNTRIES IN THE REGION AND FOR
27:53 THE OIL SUPPLY AND STRAIT OF HORMUZ?
27:56 WE ARE SEEING SUPPLY -- IN THE STRAIT OF HORMUZ?
28:01 WE ARE SEEING SUPPLY, BUT NO WAR, NO PEACE IS AN AWKWARD
28:02 PLACE TO BE. >> IN TERMS OF THE OIL SUPPLY,
28:07 THEY HAVE BEEN REMARKABLY SUCCESSFUL ABOUT GETTING THROUGH
28:09 HORMUZ. SUPPLY TO THE MARKET IS THERE.
28:17 YES, THERE IS A MASSIVE BILLION, MAY BE A MULTIBILLION BEAR OR
28:18 DEFICIT TO MAKE FORK SO THAT WILL TAKE MANY MANY MONTHS, IF
28:19 NOT YEARS. IN THE SECOND BUCKET IS INVESTOR
28:23 CONFIDENCE. THIS IS NOT A GOOD ENVIRONMENT
28:30 IN ORDER TO BOLSTER FDI, BUILD NEW PROJECTS.
28:32 THEY ARE GOING AHEAD WITH THAT. THEY HAVE INCREDIBLY DEEP
28:35 POCKETS. IN THE MEDIUM AND LONG RUN, THIS
28:41 ECONOMIES. THESE ARE MULTI-TRILLION DOLLAR
28:47 TRANSFORMATIONS, VERY DIFFICULT TO DO THAT WITH EVERYTHING THAT
28:49 IS GOING ON AROUND THEM. ABEER: THANK YOU AS ALWAYS.
28:55 BLOOMBERG'S STUART LIVINGSTONE-WALLACE, EXECUTIVE
28:58 EDITOR FOR THE MIDDLE EAST AND NORTH AFRICA.
29:01 MOVING ON TO UKRAINE AND RUSSIA. UKRAINIAN PRESIDENT VOLODYMYR
29:05 ZELENSKYY SAID PROGRESS TO PEACE HAD BEEN MADE DURING A MEETING
29:09 WITH U.S. NEGOTIATORS STEVE WITKOFF AND JARED KUSHNER.
29:13 HE HAILED A PRISONER SWAP DEAL AND A DECISION TO INCLUDE
29:16 EUROPEANS IN THE NEXT ROUND OF PEACE TALKS WITH RUSSIA.
29:20 FOR MORE ON THAT CONFLICT, WE ARE NOW JOINED BY BLOOMBERG'S
29:22 GREG SULLIVAN. GOOD MORNING.
29:26 CAN YOU WALK US THROUGH MORE OF WHAT HAPPENED AT THIS MEETING?
29:29 GREG: RIGHT. A LIGHT OF THE MEETING TOOK
29:33 PLACE BEHIND CLOSED DOORS, OF COURSE, BUT WE DID HEAR FROM ALL
29:36 SIDES AFTER THESE MEETINGS TO PLACE.
29:40 OBVIOUSLY, UKRAINIAN PRESIDENT VOLODYMYR ZELENSKYY DID HAIL
29:44 PROGRESS, PARTICULARLY ON THE PRESENT EXCHANGE AND INCLUDING
29:47 EUROPE IN SUBSEQUENT ROUNDS OF NEGOTIATIONS.
29:51 HOWEVER, IT APPEARS THE MAIN STICKING POINTS STILL REMAIN.
29:54 THOSE OF COURSE ARE SECURITY GUARANTEES FOR UKRAINE ONCE THE
29:57 FIGHTING DOES CONCLUDE, AND OF COURSE, TERRITORIAL ISSUES.
30:02 MOSCOW HAS NOT BACKED DOWN FROM THEIR DEMANDS THAT UKRAINE CEDES
30:08 MILITARY. DOES REMAIN KEY STICKING POINTS
30:12 AND IT APPEARS NO PROGRESS HAS BEEN MADE ON THOSE, AT LEAST
30:14 NEITHER SIDE HAS SAID SO PUBLICLY, THOUGH IT DOES LOOK
30:18 LIKE TALKS WILL CONTINUE MOVING FORWARD.
30:26 ABEER: GREG, WE SAW THE ROUND OF TALKS THAT HAPPENED THIS WEEK IN
30:28 ABU DHABI AND THE UAE. I WANT TO FOCUS IN ON EUROPE A
30:31 LITTLE BIT. HOW IMPORTANT IS IT GOING TO BE
30:35 TO ADD EUROPEANS IN THE NEXT ROUND OF TALKS?
30:39 GREG: CERTAINLY FOR THE EUROPEANS, THIS IS VERY CRUCIAL.
30:44 ARCHITECTURE. OBVIOUSLY, IT IS TAKING PLACE IN
30:47 EUROPE. IT IS THE LARGEST AND DEADLIEST
30:51 CONFLICT IN EUROPE SINCE WORLD WAR II AND EUROPE BELIEVE THEY
30:55 NEED TO BE AT THE TABLE OR DECISIONS WILL BE MADE THAT
30:57 COULD AFFECT THEM FOR DECADES TO COME AND THEY NEED TO BE A PART
30:57 OF THAT. EUROPE OF COURSE HAS STRUGGLED
31:02 TO FIGURE OUT WHO WILL ACTUALLY BE AT THE TABLE REPRESENTING
31:07 EUROPEAN COUNTRIES AND THEY HAVE NOT BEEN ABLE TO FIND ONE SINGLE
31:09 REPRESENTATIVE. SOME OF THE BIGGER COUNTRIES
31:12 HAVE TRIED DIPLOMATIC OUTREACH ON THEIR OWN.
31:16 OBVIOUSLY, WE SAW THAT THE NORWEGIAN LEADER AND FINNISH
31:22 LEADER OPENED UP THEIR OWN CHANNEL TO VLADIMIR PUTIN BUT IT
31:23 IS UNCLEAR WHO WILL REPRESENT EUROPE.
31:27 UKRAINE IS CHEERLEADING THAT EFFORT AND SAYS THEY NEED TO BE
31:29 AT THE TABLE FOR ANY SUBSEQUENT DISCUSSIONS.
31:33 ABEER: OK. THANK YOU SO MUCH FOR THE UPDATE
31:35 ON THAT STORY. BLOOMBERG'S GREG SULLIVAN
31:39 JOINING US IN DUBAI. BACK TO AI.
31:44 AND TOPICS IPO IS SET TO BE ABOUT SIX TIMES OVERSUBSCRIBED
31:48 -- ANTHROPIC'S IPO IS SET TO BE ABOUT SIX TIMES OVER
31:52 DESCRIBED. MAKING IT BIGGER THAN SPACE --
31:59 OVERSUBSCRIBED. THE LISTING PLANS ARE UNDER
32:03 FRESH SCRUTINY AFTER NVIDIA CEO JENSEN HUANG'S DEPARTURE.
32:08 JOINING US TO IMPACT THE LATEST MOVES IN EVERYTHING AI IS
32:17 SANDBOX EQ CEO JACK HARIDY. LET'S TALK ABOUT THE LATEST
32:20 MOVES IN A I. THE PAST FIVE DAYS.
32:22 >> IT'S AN EXCITING TIME. ABEER: SO EXCITING BUT IT FEELS
32:26 LIKE IT'S BEEN A CENTURY. IT'S BEEN FIVE DAYS.
32:30 WILL THE ANTHROPIC IPO WILL BE DROWNED IN THE MIST OF
32:32 EVERYTHING THAT HAS HAPPENED WITH JENSEN HUANG?
32:36 >> N I KNOW THERE IS A LOT OF STROK WITH WHAT'S GOING ON BUT
32:42 I THINK THE ANTHROPIC IPO IS STEADY AS SHE GOES, TARGETING
32:45 ABOUT A $1.4 TRILLION VALUATION COMING OUT OF THE DOOR.
32:49 I THINK THAT THOSE WHO HOLD FOR THE NEXT TWO OR THREE YEARS
32:50 WOULD DO VERY WELL WITH THIS STOCK.
32:54 TEAM. THE TECHNOLOGY IS VERY DEEP,
32:57 VERY STRONG. THEY INVEST VERY HEAVILY IN
33:01 ADVANCING THEIR TECHNOLOGY AND THEY ARE ALSO VERY STRONG ON
33:09 B-2-B, NOT JUST B-2-C, SO THAT DUAL STRENGTH SERVES ANTHROPIC
33:10 WELL. THEY HAVE MADE KEY PARTNERSHIPS
33:16 WITH OURSELVES, WITH MANY OTHERS, SO I THINK THEY ARE IN A
33:17 REALLY STRONG POSITION. IN TERMS OF NVIDIA'S $10 BILLION
33:20 COMMITMENT FOR THE PRIVATE PLACEMENT, I THINK THAT WILL
33:24 HOLD, I DON'T SEE ANY CHANGE EVEN GIVEN THE PAST THREE DAYS.
33:27 ABEER: LET'S TALK ABOUT THAT $1.4 TRILLION VALUATION.
33:31 THAT INITIALLY. DO YOU THINK THAT POSES A
33:35 RECALIBRATION OF VALUATION METRICS AND COMPETITIVE METRICS
33:40 WITHIN AI PLAYERS OR IS ANTHROPIC A SPECIAL CASE?
33:46 >> THERE ARE LITERALLY THOUSANDS OF INVESTORS AROUND THE WORLD
33:47 WAITING FOR THIS IPO. FIRST OF ALL, THEY HAVE MANY
33:53 FIVE YEARS AND HAVE SEEN THE GROWTH OF ANTHROPIC IN REVENUES
33:56 AND TRACTION WITH CUSTOMERS AROUND THE WORLD.
34:00 NOW, THEY ARE WAITING FOR THAT LIQUIDITY EVENT.
34:02 EVEN WITH THE IPO, THERE IS LOCKUPS, SO THAT WILL TAKE SOME
34:06 TIME, JUST LIKE WITH THE SPACEX EVENT AS WELL.
34:10 MANY ARE LOOKING AT ANTHROPIC AS A KEY BELLWETHER.
34:13 I EXPECT OPENAI TO START MOVING TOWARDS ITS IPO FOR PROBABLY Q1,
34:17 Q2 THIS COMING YEAR. I THINK MANY ARE LOOKING FOR
34:22 THIS LIQUIDITY EVENT AS AN INDICATOR NOT JUST OF VALUATION,
34:27 BUT ALSO ACCESS TO LIQUIDITY FOR THE VARIOUS INVESTMENTS THAT
34:29 BEEN MADE ACROSS THE LAST THREE, FOUR YEARS.
34:32 ABEER: I AM INTERESTED IN YOUR OPINION ABOUT INDUSTRIES THAT
34:33 ARE MOVING FROM AI EXPERIMENTATION TO ACTUALLY
34:37 GENUINELY TRANSFORMATIVE DEPLOYMENTS.
34:39 WHAT DO YOU THINK THOSE ARE? >> I THINK 2027 WILL BE THE YEAR
34:45 SIDE. OF COURSE, ALL OF US ARE USING
34:54 CLAUDE, CHATGPT, GEMINI, ALL OF THE LARGE LANGUAGE MODELS.
35:01 WHEN WE LOOK AT BIOFARMA, ENERGY, WE JUST HAD THE BIG
35:06 ENERGY CONFERENCE IN ABU DHABI, AND THE ENERGY WORLD CAN TO GET
35:06 IS ASKING THE QUESTION BEYOND JUST PRODUCTIVITY WITH DOCUMENTS
35:09 AND IMAGES, WHAT CAN WE GET FROM AI?
35:14 FOR A LONG TIME, THAN IS YOUR WORLD HAS BEEN SAYING WE CAN
35:15 SUPPLY THE ENERGY FOR THE AI WORLD.
35:19 THE QUESTION IS, WHAT CAN AI DO TO HELP THE ENERGY WORLD?
35:21 GIVEN THE GEOPOLITICAL UNCERTAINTIES, GIVEN THE
35:27 INFRASTRUCTURE OF OUR WORLD MORE RESILIENT GIVEN THE FACT THERE'S
35:29 BEEN DISRUPTIONS AND HOW DO WE USE AI TO DO THAT?
35:33 ABEER: WE SAW THAT PARTNERSHIP BETWEEN ADNOC AND OPENAI TO MAKE
35:34 THAT THESIS COME TO LIFE. I WANT TO FOCUS ON YOU AND THE
35:38 KIND OF DEALS THAT YOU ARE PURSUING OUT OF THIS PART OF THE
35:41 WORLD. WHAT DO YOU THINK IS THE MOST
35:44 LUCRATIVE OPPORTUNITY COMING OUT OF THE MIDDLE EAST?
35:47 AND LET'S ZERO IN ON GCC COUNTRIES.
35:51 >> WE ARE THE GLOBAL PACESETTER FOR LARGE QUANTITATIVE MODELS,
35:54 MODELS THAT ARE USED IN THE REAL WORLD.
35:59 WE HAVE AI FOR THE DIGITAL WORLD UNBELIEVABLE LARGE LANGUAGE
35:59 MODELS BEEN USED EVERYWHERE LIKE ANTHROPIC, BUT ALSO NOW LARGE
36:04 QUANTITATIVE MODELS, MODELS USED TO MAKE NEW MEDICINES FOR
36:05 CANCER, ALZHEIMER'S. WE ARE WORKING WITH BAHRAIN AS
36:11 AN EXAMPLE TO MAKE NEW BIOTECH ASSETS, NEW MEDICINES NOT JUST
36:16 FOR BAHRAIN, BUT ALSO FOR THE WHOLE GCC AND BEYOND.
36:19 WHEN IT COMES TO ENERGY, IT IS CRITICAL WE HAVE THE CHEMISTRY
36:21 TO TURN THE ENERGY PRODUCTS INTO HIGH-VALUE PRODUCTS AND THAT IS
36:25 WITH ARAMCO, THAT IS WITH MANY DIFFERENT CUSTOMERS IN THE GCC.
36:27 THAT IS FUNDAMENTAL. THE ENERGY WORLD IS NOT JUST
36:35 THE DOWNSTREAM PLAYERS THAT ARE HERE IN THE GCC AND BEYOND.
36:38 THAT IS FUNDAMENTAL TO THE ECONOMIES RIGHT HERE IN THE
36:39 GULF. I BELIEVE THAT 2027 IS REALLY
36:46 GOING TO BE THE YEAR OF CONVERGENCE OF THE LARGE
36:47 LANGUAGE MODELS WITH HIS LARGE QUANTITATIVE MODELS AS WELL.
36:49 ABEER: LET'S SEE WHAT HAPPENS IN A COUPLE MONTHS.
36:54 2027 AROUND THE CORNER. THANK YOU SO MUCH FOR BEING HERE
36:55 ON SET WITH US. SANDBOXAQ'S CEO JOINING US IN
36:59 DUBAI. COMING UP THE CEO OF A FOOD
37:04 RESULTS. THAT CONVERSATION UP NEXT AND
37:08 THIS IS BLOOMBERG. ♪
37:21 ABEER: WELCOME BACK TO "HORIZONS MIDDLE EAST & AFRICA."
37:29 FOOD DELIVERY GIANT TALABAT HAS REPORTED ITS THIRD KROGER
37:34 JUMPED 18% TO $1.2 BILLION. THE DUBAI-BASED FIRM SAID THE
37:37 GROWTH WAS DRIVEN BY ROBUST DEMAND DURING THE SUMMER AND
37:38 BACK-TO-SCHOOL PERIODS. AND JOINING US NOT TO UNPACK
37:43 THOSE EARNINGS IS TALABAT CEO TOON GYSSELS.
37:44 GOOD MORNING. GOOD TO HAVE YOU WITH US.
37:47 CONGRATULATIONS. I HAVE TO SAY I AM A
37:49 CONTRIBUTOR. I DON'T COOK AND I ORDER EVERY
37:52 SINGLE MEAL FROM OUTSIDE. LET ME TALK ABOUT THEIR EARNINGS
37:56 TO GIVE US AN OVERVIEW OF THE RESULTS THAT YOU GUYS HAD.
37:59 JUST A QUICK GLIMPSE OF WHAT HAPPENED THERE.
38:02 TOON: THANKS FOR HAVING ME. REALLY GREAT TO BE HERE AND SO
38:06 NICE TO HEAR THAT YOU'RE A LOYAL CUSTOMER.
38:10 Q3 RESULTS WERE VERY STRONG. WE ACCELERATE YOUR GROWTH,
38:13 ACTUALLY SO THE YEAR ON YEAR GROWTH IS FASTER THAN IN H1 AND
38:18 WE ARE DOING THAT WHILE ALSO IMPROVING PROFIT MARGINS.
38:24 EBITDA NOW IF I PERCENT, NET INCOME OF 3.4 -- NOW AT 5%, NET
38:28 INCOME OF 3.4. WE SEE IT ACROSS GCC, NINE GCC,
38:33 SO IT IS A GROWTH, ACCELERATION ACROSS.
38:37 AND THAT RESULT, WE ARE DOING IT WITH GREAT ECONOMICS.
38:43 IN THE BEGINNING OF THE YEAR, WE HAD PLANS TO SPEND UP TO 0.5
38:45 PERCENTAGE POINTS OF MARGIN IN TACTICAL GROWTH SUPPORT.
38:48 WE ARE NOT EVEN SPENDING HALF OF THAT, SO THE PERFORMANCE IS
38:55 BASED ON STRONG INTRINSICS, WHICH IS WHY WE ARE ALSO
38:55 REVIVING GUIDANCE UPWARDS ACROSS ALL METRICS.
38:57 ABEER: THAT IS LOOKING FORWARD. LET'S LOOK A LITTLE BIT BACK.
39:02 NOT OUT OF THE WOODS YET. THE GEOPOLITICAL TENSIONS, MAJOR
39:06 IMPACT ON MULTIPLE INDUSTRIES. HOW DO YOU THINK SUPPLY WERE
39:11 AFFECTED DURING THE HEIGHT, THE PEAK OF THAT WAR?
39:15 AND HOW DO YOU OVERCOME THOSE CHALLENGES LOOKING FORWARD,
39:16 GOING FORWARD? TOON: IT IS NOT FINISHED YET.
39:22 I THINK THE SUPPLY CHAIN CHALLENGES HAVE BEEN PRESENT
39:26 ONGOING, AND WE STILL SEE SOME STRUGGLES DEPENDING ON THE
39:27 CATEGORY. OUR BUSINESS IS QUITE RESILIENT
39:34 EVERY DAY. OUR INVENTORY LEVELS, WE HAVE
39:39 BEEN ABLE TO ADD MORE ITEMS. IF YOU THINK ABOUT THE GROCERY
39:45 BUSINESS, WE HAVE MORE ITEMS NOW BUT IT IS ON THE AVAILABILITY
39:46 THAT WE ARE NOT GOOD AS WE WERE BEFORE THE CONFLICT.
39:50 ABEER: DO YOU THINK CUSTOMERS AND THEIR DEMAND PROSPECTS HAVE
39:52 CHANGED AS A RESULT OF THE GEOPOLITICAL TENSIONS?
39:56 TOON: COULD QUESTION. WE SEE A CHANGE IN DEMAND.
40:00 WE SEE MUCH MORE PEOPLE ADOPTING GROCERIES.
40:03 THE REGIONAL SITUATION MIGHT BE A DRIVER OF THAT.
40:06 WHAT WE ALSO BELIEVE IS A DRIVER IS THE FACT THAT NOW PEOPLE GET
40:10 IT MUCH FASTER, SO WE HAVE IMPROVED A LOT THE DELIVERY
40:13 TIMES, NOW YOU GET MOST OF IT UNDER 15 MINUTES AND WE HAVE
40:15 WIDENED THE ASSORTMENT. THESE ARE ALSO STRUCTURAL
40:18 DRIVERS WHY YOU SEE AN INCREASE IN DEMAND.
40:22 ABEER: LET'S TALK ABOUT THE APP, LET'S TALK ABOUT THE SERVICES.
40:24 FOOD IS MAJOR BUT YOU HAVE EXPANDED.
40:27 YOU HAVE PHARMACIES, YOU HAVE SERVICES ON THE APP.
40:33 WHAT ARE SOME OF THE ELEMENTS YOU WANT TO EXPAND INTO OVER THE
40:35 NEXT FEW QUARTERS? TOON: WE ARE TRULY BUILDING AN
40:39 EVERYDAY APP. WE STARTED WITH FOOD.
40:43 WHAT IS IMPORTANT TO UNDERSTAND IS THAT EVERY DAY IS NOT JUST
40:45 ABOUT ADDING MORE VERTICALS. IT IS ABOUT BUILDING THE RIGHT
40:49 EXPERIENCE FOR THE REALITY BEHIND AN ORDER.
40:52 EVEN IN FOOD, IF YOU WOULD ORDER A QUICK LUNCH TO THE OFFICE, THE
40:56 EXPERIENCE YOU WANT TO HAVE IS A DIFFERENT ONE THAN WHEN YOU ARE
40:57 ORGANIZING DINNER WITH FRIENDS. WE ARE BUILDING THE RIGHT
41:01 PRODUCT AND OPERATION EXPERIENCE FOR ALL THAT.
41:04 EVERY DAY IS ABOUT BUILDING ALL THESE OCCASIONS.
41:09 IF WE LOOK INTO THE VERTICALS WE HAVE BEEN ADDING SINCE THE
41:11 BEGINNING OF THE YEAR, WE HAVE BUILT OUR OWN BEAUTY DARK START,
41:15 8000 SKUS. MOST OF THESE SKUS NOT AVAILABLE
41:20 CUSTOMERS. WE ARE SEEING A LOT OF TRACTION
41:22 ON THAT. WE HAVE ALSO BEEN WORKING ON
41:26 FINTECH SOLUTIONS FOR OUR CUSTOMER BASE.
41:31 FOR EXAMPLE, WE HAVE A PRODUCT WHICH WE LAUNCHED.
41:33 WE HAVE NOW LAUNCHED A REMITTANCE PRODUCT.
41:37 THIS IS ALSO SOMETHING WHERE WE DON'T BUILD THEM TO BE A
41:41 FINTECH, WE BUILT THEM BECAUSE IT HELPS OUR CUSTOMERS IN THE
41:42 ECOSYSTEM. ABEER: LET'S TALK ABOUT
41:45 GEOGRAPHIES A LITTLE BIT. WHAT DO YOU THINK ARE SOME OF
41:48 THE UNTAPPED GEOGRAPHIES IN THE REGION THAT YOU WOULD LIKE TO
41:50 EXPAND? UAE IS A BIG MARKET, SAUDI
41:55 ARABIA I ALSO ASSUME IS A BIG MARKET.
41:58 WHAT ELSE ARE YOU LOOKING AT AS SOMETHING ELSE YOU WOULD LIKE TO
41:59 GET INTO? TOON: TODAY, WE ARE PRESENT IN A
42:08 MARKETS, GCC, SAUDI, JORDAN, AND WE STILL SEE A LOT OF POTENTIAL.
42:11 THE FOCUS WILL BE ON THOSE EIGHT MARKETS AND AS YOU CAN
42:17 SEE FROM THE RESULTS, WE GOT A LOT OF GROWTH IN THERE.
42:20 THE BIGGEST DRIVER OF THE YEAR ON YEAR GROWTH IS ACTIVE USERS.
42:25 CONTINUE EXPANDING THAT. ABEER: LET'S TALK ABOUT DELIVERY
42:28 HERO A LITTLE BIT. THERE WERE TALKS OF
42:31 ACQUISITIONS, THERE WERE TALKS OF THINGS HAPPENING, DEALS
42:32 THERE. DOES THAT WORRY YOU AT ALL,
42:37 HAVE? TOON: SO, IT DOES NOT WORRY ME.
42:42 THE POTENTIAL DEAL BETWEEN DELIVERY HERO AND UBER IS GOING
42:49 ONE YEAR FROM THE. THE PROSPECTS OF SUCH A YOU I AM
42:54 PRETTY EXCITED ABOUT THAT -- SUCH A DEAL, I AM PRETTY EXCITED
42:58 ABOUT THAT. WE ARE THE LEADER IN FOR
43:02 TIMES AS MUCH AS THE CUSTOMERS THE ONLY ORDER FOOD.
43:06 IF YOU THINK ABOUT A FUTURE WHERE WE WOULD ALSO ADD
43:09 RIDE-HAILING TO THAT, THAT ECOSYSTEM PLACE IS VERY SIMPLE.
43:13 WHEN IT COMES TO THAT LISTING, THAT DEAL DOES NOT IMPLY ANY
43:15 CHANGE TO THE LISTING. WE REMAIN INDEPENDENT.
43:18 WE HAVE OUR GOVERNANCE, WE HAVE OUR BOARD.
43:23 HEADLINES. THANK YOU SO MUCH FOR BEING WITH
43:27 US AND COMING TO SET. TOON GYSSELS, THE CEO OF TALABAT
43:31 , JOINING US THIS MORNING. COMING UP, DUBAI TYCOON TELLS
43:38 BLOOMBERG HE EXPECTS TO MAKE BILLIONS ON HIS INVESTMENTS IN
43:40 TECH AND AI. MORE DETAILS ON THAT, NEXT.
43:44 AND THIS IS BLOOMBERG. ♪
43:58 ABEER: DUBAI TYCOON HUSSAIN SAJWANI EXPECTS HIS INVESTMENTS
44:04 IN ANTHROPIC AND OTHER TECH FIRMS TO DRAW A HUGE RETURN.
44:08 HAVE A LISTEN. >> I AM HAPPY WITH $1.4 TRILLION
44:13 VALUATION SO I AM NOT COMPLAINING ON THAT.
44:17 IT WAS BETWEEN ONLY THREE COMPANIES, OPENAI AND SPACEX AND
44:27 ANTHROPIC, WE ARE MAKING A FEW BILLION DOLLARS OF PROFIT SO WE
44:28 ARE VERY HAPPY TO SEE IT. ABEER: MICROSOFT IS STRUGGLING
44:33 THROUGH STAR ACCESS -- TO RESTORE ACCESS TO SOME OF ITS
44:36 FLAGSHIP SOFTWARE MORE THAN NINE HOURS AFTER AN OUTAGE BEGAN.
44:42 SERVICES AND CHECK SERVICES IN ONE OF THE TECH GIANT'S MOST
44:44 SEVERE DISRUPTIONS IN RECENT MEMORY.
44:50 OUTLOOK, TEAMS, AND THE COPILOT ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE SERVICES
44:51 WERE HIT BY THE OUTAGE. AND NOW BEFORE WE GO TO THE END
44:55 OF THE SHOW AND THE START OF THE WEEKEND, A QUICK LOOK AT WHERE
44:59 EQUITY BENCHMARKS ARE SITTING. YOU'RE NOW LOOKING AT A DOWN
45:03 PERFORMANCE FOR S&P FUTURES, JUST 0.1% LOWER, NASDAQ DROPPING
45:10 0.4% AT THIS POINT, AND DOW JONES FUTURES FLAT, A LITTLE BIT
45:12 TO THE UPSIDE. EURO STOXX 50 FUTURES POINTING
45:17 TO A NEGATIVE START IN EUROPE TODAY AS OIL PRICES, BRENT CRUDE
45:22 DROPS THIS MORNING, AND IS A LITTLE BIT FLAT AT THIS POINT,
45:27 AS A MATTER OF FACT, AS NY CRUDE DROPS 0.5%.
45:30 BUT FOR TODAY, THAT IS A FOUR "HORIZONS MIDDLE EAST & AFRICA."
45:34 -- THAT IS IT FOR "HORIZONS MIDDLE EAST & AFRICA."
45:38 STICK AROUND WITH US FOR "DAYBREAK EUROPE."
45:39 THIS IS BLOOMBERG.
Traders Digest Jensen Huang's Exit from Nvidia full transcript
0:42 WEEK. TECHNOLOGY SENIOR EXECUTIVE
0:42 LONGTIME CEO JENSEN HUANG, HIS OUSTER REVERBERATING UP AND DOWN
0:45 WALL STREET. ITS BIGGEST COMPANY LOSING ITS
0:50 MOST PROMINENT CHEERLEADER. COLETTE KRESS TAKES THE HELM AS
0:52 INTERIM CEO AND WILL SPEAK TO INVESTORS ON A CALL NEXT WEEK.
0:58 YOU ARE WATCHING THE CHINA SHOW. I AM YVONNE MAN WITH AVRIL HONG
1:02 IN SINGAPORE. AVRIL: TRACKING THE FALLOUT AS
1:05 WE COUNT DOWN TO THE OPEN OF MARKET AND THE CHINA REGION.
1:08 ASIAN STOCKS SHAKEUP -- SHAKE OFF THE IMPACTS.
1:15 ANTHROPIC'S IPO IS SEVERAL TIMES OVERSUBSCRIBED BY CHINA'S TECH
1:21 STOCKS, SET TO COME UNDER MORE PRESSURE DUE TO CONCERNS OVER
1:28 THEIR ACCESS TO NVIDIA CHIPS. WE WILL TRACK ALIBABA AND
1:28 TENCENT AFTER A SLUMP IN THEIR ADRS.
1:50 YVONNE: IT HAS BEEN A ROLLER COASTER OF TWO WEEKS.
1:54 OF COURSE FOR JENSEN HUANG, WE HAVE COME TO THIS.
1:58 IT IS CONFIRMED, HE IS NO LONGER THE CEO OF NVIDIA.
2:03 COLETTE KRESS, THE CFO, HAS STEPPED UP AS INTERIM CEO AND
2:06 THE SEARCH IS UNDERWAY FOR A LEADER OF ONE OF THE LARGEST
2:08 COMPANIES IN THE WORLD. IT HAS BEEN SUCH A STUNNING
2:15 FALLOUT FOR JENSEN HUANG. THE KEY QUESTION IS, WHAT DOES
2:19 THIS AI REVOLUTION LOOK LIKE WITHOUT HIM NOW?
2:22 AVRIL: ABSOLUTELY. HE HAS BEEN SUCH A PIVOTAL
2:25 FIGURE, CENTRAL IN THIS AI ECONOMY, HAD AGAINST THE
2:31 BACKDROP AS PERHAPS THE BOARD LOOKS FOR THE NEXT CEO.
2:36 CFO COLETTE KRESS WHO IS NOW IN CHARGE PERHAPS TASKED WITH
2:39 STUDYING THE SHIP. THINK ABOUT HOW SOME OF THE
2:44 BERLIN SILICON VALLEY AND PERHAPS WALL STREET WERE TAKEN A
2:48 BIT BY SURPRISE ON HOW THE BOARD WORKED TO OUST JENSEN HUANG.
2:51 WHEN THE NEWS BROKE OF THE AFFAIR THIS WEEK, AS HE
2:54 ADMITTED, THERE WAS SOME SENSE HE COULD REMAIN AT THE HOME.
2:58 THIS IS QUITE A STUNNING TURN OF EVENTS.
3:00 AND I DON'T FORGET THE IMPACT WE COULD SEE IN TERMS OF CHINA'S
3:03 ACCESS TO CHIPS. HE HAD BEEN ONE OF THE MOST
3:08 INFLUENTIAL, IF NOT THE MOST INFLUENTIAL OPPONENTS TO TIGHTER
3:13 U.S. RESTRICTIONS ON CHINA. WHAT IS THIS GOING TO MEAN GOING
3:18 FORWARD FOR CHINA IN PARTICULAR, AS IT WORKS TO COMPETE AGAINST
3:22 THE U.S. IN THIS AI RACE? LET'S LOOK AT WHAT THE MARKETS
3:23 ARE DOING AGAINST THE BACKDROP OF THE NVIDIA SAGA.
3:30 OVERNIGHT, WE DID SEE IT CONTINUING TO GET HIT.
3:34 IF WE CAN TAKE A LOOK AT HOW IT FARED IN THE SESSION, WE ARE
3:38 SEEING A BIT OF RISE IN THE AFTER HOURS.
3:42 BUT OVERALL FOR THE WEEK, NVIDIA SHARES SLIPPING ABOUT DOUBLE
3:43 DIGITS. THIS IS A SHARE THAT IS TRADING
3:44 AT A DISCOUNT. DON'T FORGET, WE ARE GOING INTO
3:50 EARNINGS NEXT WEEK AND IT'S WORTH NOTING THAT WE HAVE SEEN A
3:53 NUMBER OF RARE DOWNGRADES TO THE STOCK ALREADY THIS WEEK.
4:00 ALSO THERE HAVE BEEN FOLKS BUYING NVIDIA AT THESE LOWS.
4:02 SOME OF THEM INCLUDE THE RETAIL INVESTOR BASE.
4:07 TAKE A LOOK AT WHAT WE SEE ON THE BENCHMARK OF ASIA STOCKS.
4:14 PUSH AND PULL FOR ASIAN TRADE, AI IN PARTICULAR.
4:17 YOU HAVE NVIDIA WORRIES BUT ON THE OTHER OF THE COIN, ANTHROPIC
4:22 REPORTING THAT SUGGESTS THAT IT IS MANY TIMES OVERSUBSCRIBED.
4:26 IF WE CAN LOOK AT NVIDIA SUPPLIERS IN THE REGION, THE
4:32 WORRY WAS WITH A LESS AGGRESSIVE NVIDIA, THIS COULD PERHAPS
4:34 CONSTRAIN EARNINGS GROWTH POTENTIAL FOR THESE FIRMS THAT
4:38 RELY ON NVIDIA FOR A SUBSTANTIAL CHUNK OF THEIR SALES.
4:43 BUT YOU CAN SEE THE REACTION IN THE EARLY GOINGS, BOTH ON
4:47 TAIWAN'S BENCHMARK BUT ALSO TSMC INCLUDED THAT WAS ALSO GETTING
4:53 HARD-HIT JUST A DAY AGO. THE KEY CONCERN IS REALLY CHINA
4:57 AND ITS ACCESS TO CHIPS. DOES THIS CONSTRAIN THE LEVEL OF
4:59 AI DEVELOPMENT GOING FORWARD? WE SAW THE REACTION IN THE ADRS
5:05 AND WE WILL CONTINUE TO TRACK THE MARKET REACTION AND FALLOUT
5:08 IN THE CHINESE SESSION TODAY. YVONNE: WE ARE WATCHING VERY
5:15 CLOSELY ANY SORT OF NEWS AROUND THE WORLD.
5:18 WE GOT THAT LINE A COUPLE MINUTES AGO THAT THEY HAVE
5:22 RELEASE. WE WILL GIVE YOU THAT
5:27 INFORMATION ONCE WE SEE ANY SIGNS OF DEVELOPMENT ON THAT
5:29 FRONT AS WELL. THE MARKET IS TAKING THE NEWS OF
5:32 NVIDIA BUS JENSEN HUANG BEING OUSTED REALLY IN STRIDE.
5:38 THE ANTHROPIC IPO IS ONE THING KEEPING THINGS AFLOAT.
5:41 LET'S BRING IT BACK TO NVIDIA. THE LONGTIME CHIEF FINANCIAL
5:45 OFFICER COLETTE KRESS HAS BECOME INTERIM CEO AFTER THE BOARD
5:48 OUSTED JENSEN HUANG FOLLOWING REPORTS OF HIM HAVING THREE
5:50 AFFAIRS NOW, INCLUDING ONE WITH A WOMAN SUSPECTED OF SPYING FOR
5:53 CHINA. AVRIL: THE SCANDAL IS ALSO
6:00 GIVING LAWMAKERS IN WASHINGTON AMMUNITION TO TIGHTEN CURVES ON
6:05 TECH SHIPMENTS TO CHINA, DAYS BEFORE PRESIDENT TRUMP'S THIRD
6:07 SUMMIT OF THE YEAR WITH HIS CHINESE COUNTERPART XI JINPING.
6:11 FOR MORE, LET'S BRING IN OUR NEXT TECHNOLOGY SENIOR TECH
6:17 EDITOR AND NORTH ASIA CORRESPONDENT.
6:23 THE TURN OF EVENTS THIS WEEK HAS BEEN STUNNING INCLUDING THE FALL
6:26 FROM GRACE OF JENSEN HUANG. WALK US THROUGH THIS AND WHAT IT
6:28 MEANS ULTIMATELY FOR THE FUTURE OF NVIDIA AND ITS PLACE IN THE
6:32 AI ECONOMY. REPORTER: WHAT'S ASTONISHING TO
6:38 ME IS THAT JUST A FEW DAYS AGO, EVEN AFTER THE REVELATION OF HIS
6:45 RELATIONSHIP WITH ALICE HUANG, THERE WAS SO MUCH SUPPORT
6:47 INCLUDING FROM THE PRESIDENT FOR KEEPING HIM IN PLACE.
6:51 THERE WERE SO MANY VOICES SAYING OK, THIS ISN'T GREAT, BUT HE
7:00 REPRESENTS -- HE PLAYS TOO BIG OF A ROLE IN THE WHOLE AI
7:03 ECOSYSTEM, DON'T REMOVE HIM. AND THEN THERE WERE MORE
7:09 REVELATIONS ABOUT HIS INFIDELITY INCLUDING WITH AN EMPLOYEE AT
7:13 NVIDIA. THERE WERE JUST TOO MANY RED
7:16 FLAGS FOR THE BOARD TO IGNORE. AS WE HAVE SEEN, THERE IS YET
7:23 ANOTHER REVELATION OF AN AFFAIR WITH AN EMPLOYEE ACCORDING TO
7:27 ONE OF OUR COMPETITORS. THIS IS TOO MUCH.
7:30 THERE WERE TOO MANY STRAWS BREAKING TOO MANY CAMELS' BACKS,
7:34 TO USE THAT METAPHOR. SO THE BOARD HAD TO ACT.
7:41 REMEMBER, THEIR CREDIBILITY AND POTENTIAL SHAREHOLDER LAWSUITS
7:44 ARE AT STAKE HERE. THEY HAD TO BE SEEN AS GETTING
7:47 ON TOP OF THIS. REMEMBER THAT WE ARE NOT DONE
7:50 HEARING FROM JENSEN HUANG. HE STILL IS GOING TO BE SUMMONED
7:55 TO CAPITOL BUILDING WASHINGTON, D.C. TO GIVE TESTIMONY ABOUT HIS
8:04 RELATIONSHIP WITH ALICE HUANG, TO DEMONSTRATE WHETHER OR NOT IT
8:07 REPRESENTED A COMPROMISE OR A THREAT TO U.S. NATIONAL SECURITY
8:10 . THE HEADLINE RISK HAS NOT GONE
8:14 AWAY IN TERMS OF WHETHER THERE WAS ANYTHING ABOUT THIS
8:17 RELATIONSHIP THAT RESULTED IN THE LOSS OF IMPORTANT IP ON THE
8:22 PART OF NVIDIA TO CHINA. BUT IN TERMS OF YOUR QUESTION AS
8:26 FAR AS THE IMPACT ON THE ECOSYSTEM, THIS WAS NOT ONLY A
8:32 SUPPLIER OF THE MOST ADVANCED SHIPS TO THE WORLD, BUT ALSO --
8:37 CHIPS TO THE WORLD, BUT ALSO A BIG BACKER OF OTHER COMPANIES IN
8:43 THE ECOSYSTEM, SUPPORTING THEM, TAKING EQUITY INVESTMENTS,
8:46 PROVIDING FINANCIAL BACKSTOPPING OF SOME OF THE BIGGEST
8:49 CUSTOMERS. IT IS THAT GOING TO SLOW DOWN
8:53 WITHOUT JENSEN HUANG AT THE HELM, MAKING THESE BIG
8:57 MULTIBILLION-DOLLAR BETS? THAT IS THE QUESTION OF THE
8:58 ALBERT. IF YOU PUT IN PLACE IS CFO THEY
9:05 ARE IN CHARGE OF KEEPING PURSESTRINGS TYPE.
9:09 WE HAVE YET TO HEAR ON WHERE SHE STANDS.
9:11 WE WILL HEAR FROM HER NEXT WEEK ON WHEN THEY RELEASE EARNINGS.
9:15 THERE ARE A BIG RAMIFICATIONS FOR THE GLOBAL ECONOMY FROM THIS
9:18 ONE CHANGE OF CEO. YVONNE: AND AS YOU MENTIONED,
9:25 COLETTE WAS VERY MUCH FOCUSED ON THE NUMBERS OF NVIDIA AND JENSEN
9:30 WAS THE VISIONARY. WHAT DO WE KNOW ABOUT THE SEARCH
9:32 FOR A NEW CEO NOW? THE PEOPLE YOU ARE TALKING TO,
9:38 IS THE FIRM LOOKING FOR SOMEONE INTERNALLY OR EXTERNALLY?
9:40 I KNOW TRUMP HAS TWEETED ABOUT POSSIBLY TIM COOK AS WELL AS HIS
9:46 POSSIBLE CHOICE TO LEAD NVIDIA. BUT WHAT HAVE WE HEARD SO FAR?
9:52 REPORTER: WE KNOW THAT AND HAVE REPORTED THAT NVIDIA'S BOARD IS
9:55 WORKING WITH AN OUTSIDE FIRM. WE KNOW THAT THEY ARE ACTIVELY
10:00 SEARCHING. WE WILL TRY IN THE COMING DAYS
10:03 TO SHED MORE LIGHT ON WHAT THE PROCESS LOOK LIKE.
10:11 THEY HAVE NOT SAID A LOT, THERE IS NOT A LOT OF PUBLIC DISCOURSE
10:14 TO GO ON HERE. ACCORDING TO PEOPLE FAMILIAR
10:17 WITH THE MATTER, THEY ARE CASTING A WIDE NET.
10:21 IT MAKES SENSE BASED ON CONVERSATIONS WITH ANALYSTS,
10:24 INVESTORS, WITH THE LARGER TECH COMMUNITY, THAT THEY WOULD LOOK
10:28 INTERNALLY AS WELL AS EXTERNALLY.
10:34 FOR A COMPANY LIKE NVIDIA, MY SENSE IS YOU WANT SOMEBODY WHO
10:39 HAS STRONG ENGINEERING, STRONG TECHNOLOGICAL SHOPS LIKE JENSEN
10:43 HUANG DID AS OPPOSED TO SOMEONE WHO IS MERELY GOING TO MANAGE
10:49 THE FINANCES OR EVEN BE JUST OPERATIONAL.
10:51 YOU CAN BEAT AN OPERATIONAL GENIUS AND RUN ORGANIZATIONS BUT
10:53 YOU WANT SOMEONE WHO HAS TECHNOLOGICAL VISION.
11:00 AVRIL: LET'S BRING YOU IN HERE. THE FALLOUT FROM THE NVIDIA SAGA
11:04 IS ALSO PERHAPS PUTTING FURTHER SCRUTINY ON CHINA'S ACCESS TO
11:06 CHIPS. AND GIVING CHINA HAWKS IN THE
11:12 U.S. MORE AMMUNITION. HOW IS THIS SHIFTED THE TONE
11:18 AHEAD OF THE TRUMP-XI MEETING NEXT WEEK?
11:23 REPORTER: CERTAINLY WE ARE ON VERY SHAKY GROUND TOWARD THE
11:24 SUMMIT. AS YOU SAID, THERE ARE CURRENTLY
11:28 ABOUT THREE DIFFERENT PROPOSALS THAT ARE UNDER NEGOTIATION NOW.
11:33 ONE IS THE MATCH ACT THAT WOULD REQUIRE OR COMPEL FOREIGN
11:35 COMPANIES TO MATCH U.S. EXPORT CONTROLS.
11:39 THE OTHER IS THAT SHIP SECURITY ACT WHICH WOULD REQUIRE TOP --
11:42 TECH COMPANIES TO PHYSICALLY TRACK WHETHER CHIPS END UP IN
11:47 THE SUPPLY CHAIN WHICH WILL MAKE IT INFINITELY HARDER FOR CHINESE
11:51 COMPANIES TO ACCESS RESTRICTED CHIPS.
11:53 THE THIRD ONE IS THAT AI OVERWATCH ACT THAT WILL FURTHER
11:57 TIGHTEN CONTROL TO LEGAL ACCESS TO THE CHIPS AND IT COULD
12:01 CONTAIN LANGUAGE THAT WOULD TRADING LOOPHOLES ON REMOTE
12:02 ACCESS THROUGH THESE OVERSEAS SERVERS.
12:08 THAT IS UNDER NEGOTIATION. SEPARATELY THE COMMERCE
12:09 DEPARTMENT ACCORDING TO THE NEGOTIATION HAS TIGHTENED THE
12:14 LOOPHOLE ON REMOTE ACCESS AND COULD ANNOUNCE NEW RULES AS SOON
12:19 AS THE CASH THIS MONTH. AS WE GO INTO NEGOTIATIONS, WE
12:23 HAVE THE TRADE TRUCE THAT IS EXPECTED TO END IN JANUARY.
12:26 THE EXTENSION OF THE TRADE TRUCE HINGES ON THE U.S. NOT STARTING
12:30 NEW EXPORT CONTROLS ON TECH. I WAS THE AGREEMENT TO PUT A
12:33 PAUSE ON THAT. SO IF THE U.S. WAS TO PUSH
12:39 THROUGH NEW EXPORT CONTROLS, THAT CHANGES THE DYNAMIC HERE
12:44 AND COULD LEAD TO FURTHER ESCALATION OF A TIT-FOR-TAT
12:45 RETALIATION BETWEEN THE BOTH SIDES.
12:50 NOT TO MENTION, EARLIER WE HAD A SERIES OF REALLY HOSTILE COMMON
12:52 TREE COMING FROM THE LIKES OF SCOTT BESSENT AND JAMIESON
12:57 GREER, SCOTT BESSENT ACCUSING CHINESE AI COMPANIES OF BEING
13:04 RESPONSIBLE FOR THIS AFFRONT AND SAYING THAT CHINESE TECH ARE
13:08 DANGEROUS WITHOUT GUARDRAILS. YVONNE: SHOULD INVESTORS MOVE
13:16 ON? IT SEEMS LIKE THEY HAVE IN SOME
13:19 WAYS GIVEN THE MARKET REACTION APART FROM NVIDIA.
13:25 ANTHROPIC IS THE BIG WHAT TO WATCH.
13:27 WILL THAT BE THE NEXT TEST OF THE AI TRADE?
13:31 REPORTER: ABSOLUTELY, THAT WILL DOMINATE HEADLINES NEXT WEEK AS
13:33 DOES NVIDIA EARNINGS. [LAUGHTER]
13:37 DON'T FORGET. WE WILL NOT HEAR THE LAST OF
13:39 NVIDIA. WE WILL HEAR FROM COLETTE AND
13:45 THE EARNINGS OUTLOOK. NVIDIA'S EARNINGS HAS NOT DIED
13:46 DOWN. ON THE CHIP CURBS, SOMETHING
13:50 IMPORTANT TO REMEMBER IS JUST TODAY, OPENAI, THROUGH ITS
13:55 SUPPORT FOR TIGHTER REGULATION OF CHIPS AND TIGHTER CONTROLS,
14:01 THIS IS A COMPANY THAT HAS BEEN DELIBERATING FOR MANY MANY
14:04 MONTHS. NOW YOU HAVE OPENAI COMING OUT
14:07 IN SUPPORT OF THE SPIRIT YOU HAVE THE REMOVAL OF ONE OF THE
14:10 BIGGEST CHEERLEADERS IN TERMS OF LOOSER RESTRICTIONS.
14:13 THERE'S A LOT OF MOMENTUM FOR THAT.
14:18 AS FAR AS NVIDIA IS CONCERNED, TAKE A LOOK AT ITS PRICE TO
14:22 EARNINGS RATIO COMPARED TO SOME PEERS.
14:27 IT HAS COME DOWN CONSIDERABLY, NOT JUST IN THE WAKE OF THE
14:29 REVELATIONS IN THE LAST COUPLE DAYS BUT OVER THE LAST SEVERAL
14:31 WEEKS. CONCERNS ABOUT DATA CENTERS AND
14:34 A SLOWDOWN IN THE U.S. IT HAS COME DOWN SUBSTANTIALLY.
14:39 AS YOU POINTED OUT, THERE IS SOME RETAIL BUYING AND WE WILL
14:42 SEE HOW MUCH LONGER BEFORE BIGGER NAMES COME BACK INTO THIS
14:43 STOCK. YVONNE: GREAT TO HAVE YOU THIS
14:54 EDITOR TOM GILES JOINING US FROM SAN FRANCISCO, AND MINMIN LOW,
14:55 OUR NORTH ASIA CORRESPONDENT JOINING US OUT OF SHANGHAI.
14:58 COMING UP, LOOKING AT THE IMPACT OF THE NVIDIA CRISIS WHEN IT
15:07 HONG KONG WHEN IT COMES TO BOB I AM PEER PLAYS.
15:08 ONE OF THE MISSED NVIDIA PRICES MEANS TIGHTER SCRUTINY --
15:12 SCRUTINY OVER ACCESS TO COMPUTING AND THE LIKE.
15:16 COUNTING DOWN THE OPENING OF TRADE IN SHANGHAI, SHENZHEN AND
15:18 HONG KONG. VIVIAN LYNN THURSTON IS NEXT.
15:33 ♪ YVONNE: THIS IS THE ONE CHART TO
15:34 WATCH WHEN IT COMES TO THIS MONTH, RIGHT?
15:36 WE ARE -- UP UNTIL RECENTLY, WE HAVE SEEN THEM OUTPERFORM THEIR
15:42 PEERS. GIVEN THE SORT OF ROTATION WE
15:47 SAW TO SOME OF THESE INTERNET PLATFORMS, THAT SORT OF HIT THE
15:50 SKIDS, THAT TRADE THIS WEEK GIVEN THE TERMINAL ON NVIDIA NOW
15:56 WHERE CERTAINLY THERE'S CONCERNS ABOUT WHAT THIS DEMOCRATIC SWEEP
16:00 ALONG WITH JENSEN HUANG AT THE HOME OF NVIDIA COULD MEAN WHEN
16:03 IT COMES TO ACCESS TO COMPUTER AND THE LIKE.
16:05 FOR MORE ON WHERE THINGS ARE HEADED, LET'S BRING IN THE
16:07 PORTFOLIO MANAGER. WE HAVE BEEN TALKING ABOUT HOW
16:14 CHINA IS GOING TO FARE IN THE FACE OF THIS NVIDIA CRISIS.
16:17 NOW THAT ESSENTIALLY BEIJING HAS LOST ONE OF ITS BIGGEST
16:22 ADVOCATES OF LOOSER CHIP RESTRICTIONS, WHAT DOES THIS
16:24 MEAN FOR THE WHOLE CHINA TECH SPACE, DO YOU THINK?
16:28 >> I THINK THIS WOULD PROBABLY JUST STEP BACK AND THINK ABOUT
16:32 WHAT THIS WHOLE DEVELOPMENT MEANS, RIGHT?
16:36 FIRST OF ALL, I DO THINK THIS RAISES FURTHER CONCERNS ABOUT
16:40 HOW LONG THIS CYCLE WILL LAST AND I THINK THIS STARTED
16:43 ACTUALLY BEFORE THE MOST RECENT DEVELOPMENT AND I WOULD SAY THIS
16:46 DEVELOPMENT PROBABLY WILL MAKE IT EVEN WORSE.
16:50 PEOPLE START TO WORRY ABOUT THAT.
16:52 THE CHINESE HYPERSCALER INTERNET COMPANIES IN THE GLOBAL AI
16:56 DEVELOPMENT ECOSYSTEM ESPECIALLY FROM THE GLOBAL INVESTORS
16:58 PERSPECTIVE. THE SECOND POINT TO THAT IS
17:01 SPECIFICALLY RELATED TO CHINA. I THINK THIS DEVELOPMENT KIND OF
17:07 RAISED PEOPLE'S CONCERN OVER THE INCREASING SCRUTINY AND THE
17:09 RESTRICTION OF THE TECHNOLOGICAL EXPORT TO CHINA FROM THE U.S.
17:14 AND THEN TO SOME EXTENT, SOME OF THE LEADING INTERNET COMPANIES
17:18 IN CHINA ALSO HAVE SOME OF THE SUPPLIERS IN THE ENTIRE SUPPLY
17:23 CHAIN AND SPECIFICALLY SOME OF THOSE COMPANIES GOT HIT PRETTY
17:26 HARD BUT LASTLY, I THINK MORE IMPORTANTLY IS THE FUNDAMENTAL
17:32 STORY OF THOSE INTERNET COMPANIES WHICH REMAIN UNCERTAIN
17:35 AND MIXED AND I THINK EVEN MOST RECENTLY, WE HAVE SEEN SOME
17:40 REBOUND OF THOSE COMPANIES. PARTIALLY, IT'S BECAUSE THEY
17:44 SOLD OFF SO MUCH YEAR TO DATE DOWN 40% AND THEN SOME MAY BE
17:49 VALUE DRIVEN INVESTORS THINK THIS IS AN ATTRACTIVE ENTRY
17:53 POINT BUT WITHOUT THE FURTHER POTENTIAL IMPROVEMENT OF THEIR
17:58 EARNINGS BOTH FROM THE CORE E-COMMERCE OR ONLINE GAMING
18:04 BUSINESS OR FROM THE KIND OF FOOTPRINT GOING FORWARD ABOUT
18:06 THE AI SPENDING, WE SAW THOSE FUNDAMENTAL EARNINGS STORIES.
18:11 I THINK THE RALLY PROBABLY WOULD BE SHORT-LIVED ANYWAY EVEN
18:12 WITHOUT THIS DEVELOPMENT. >> WHAT ABOUT THE MACRO PICTURE
18:17 AS WELL? DOES THE PULLBACK IN AI SPENDING
18:21 PERHAPS ALSO AFFECT THE KIND OF EXPORTS THAT CHINA WILL BE
18:27 BRINGING TO THE REST OF THE WORLD AND DOES THAT ALSO THEN
18:30 AFFECT EARNINGS GROWTH FOR CHINESE ASSETS OVERALL, FOR
18:31 CHINESE EQUITIES? >> I THINK THE SECOND PLAY
18:39 FACTOR HERE IS ABOUT WHETHER THE DEVELOPMENT OF THE MOST RECENT
18:44 DEVELOPMENT PLUS THE AI SLOWDOWN IN THE U.S. WILL MAKE THE U.S.
18:49 AND GLOBAL ECONOMY DECELERATE. IF THAT IS THE CASE, IT
18:53 DEFINITELY WILL IMPACT CHINESE EXPORTS MARGINALLY ON THE
18:57 NEGATIVE SIDE GIVEN THAT YOU DO NEED A STRONG GLOBAL ECONOMY FOR
19:01 THAT EXPORT TO CONTINUE EVEN THOUGH I WILL ARGUE THAT CHINESE
19:06 EXPORTS -- ESPECIALLY IN SOME GEOGRAPHIES.
19:10 THAT IS MORE THE SENTIMENT. BUT I DON'T THINK IN REALITY,
19:15 THAT WILL DERAIL CHINA'S EXPORTS.
19:21 WE WILL TALK ABOUT CHINA ENTERING THIS PHASE.
19:25 YOU CAN SEE THAT CHINESE ADVANCED MANUFACTURING AND
19:29 HIGHER TECH EXPORTS CONTINUE TO MAKE NEW HIGHS.
19:30 I THINK THAT STORY REMAINS. EVEN THOUGH WE COULD SEE SOME
19:34 IMPACT. IT DEPENDS ON HOW THE U.S. AND
19:38 GLOBAL ECONOMY THOSE BUT THAT STORY DOESN'T CHANGE.
19:44 HAVING SAID THAT, I DO THINK 2027, YOU WILL HAVE A LITTLE BIT
19:46 HIGHER BASE TO COME ON BECAUSE 2026, WE HAVE VERY STRONG
19:52 EXPORTS SO THAT IS ANOTHER THING THAT REMAINS TO BE SEEN.
19:58 >> WE HAVE SEEN A BIT OF DISPERSION BETWEEN SHORT TECH.
20:07 THOSE WERE PART OF THE AI SUPPLY CHAIN.
20:12 VERSUS WHAT WE SAW ACROSS ASIA TECH.
20:14 IS THAT WHERE YOU CONTINUE TO SEE THAT DISPERSION WHEN IT
20:17 COMES TO ONSHORE AND THE WHOLE SELF-SUFFICIENCY SORT OF THEME,
20:22 IS THAT SOMETHING YOU COULD PLAY WITH IN THE TRADE?
20:28 >> WE SEPARATE THE HYPERSCALERS OF CHINA WHICH IS INTERNET
20:32 COMPANIES VERSUS THE SUPPLIERS. WE THINK THE SUPPLIERS, YOU HAVE
20:39 ONCE SUPPLIED TO THE GLOBAL AI SUPPLY CHAIN VERSUS THE ONES
20:41 SUPPLIED TO DOMESTIC AI SUPPLY CHAIN.
20:46 I WOULD SAY THE ONES -- ESPECIALLY IN THE OPTICAL
20:49 TRANSCEIVER SPACE, THAT COULD FACE SOME NEAR-TERM CHALLENGES
20:54 BOTH BECAUSE OF POTENTIAL IF AI CYCLE SLOWDOWN IN THE U.S. AND
20:57 AT THE SAME TIME THE RESTRICTION OF CHINA EXPORTS GETTING HIGHER.
20:59 THOSE COMPANIES CAN GET HIT. THE ONCE SUPPLIED TO CHINA, I
21:06 THINK THAT STORY REMAINS AND I WILL ARGUE -- CHINA CONTINUES ON
21:14 THE AI DEVELOPMENT. THE GAP CAN NARROW.
21:20 I THINK THAT IS ONE RISK FROM THE U.S. PERSPECTIVE AND WE NEED
21:23 TO WATCH THAT SO FOR THE SUPPLIERS TO SUPPLY TO CHINA
21:26 SPECIFICALLY, I THINK THAT STORY REMAINS ESPECIALLY ON THE
21:31 TOPLINE GROWTH. I THINK I TALKED ABOUT THIS LAST
21:32 TIME. YVONNE: ABSOLUTELY.
21:39 THANK YOU SO MUCH. PORTFOLIO MANAGER, VIVIAN
21:40 THURSTON. A QUICK LOOK AT WHAT WE ARE
21:46 LOOKING AT PRE-MARKETS. THIS IS THE PICTURE.
21:48 TURNING MORE AHEAD. THIS IS BLOOMBERG.
22:04 ♪ >> HERE'S WHAT WE ARE SEEING IN
22:06 HONG KONG PRE-MARKETS AFTER ALREADY GETTING HARD HIT EARLIER
22:07 IN THE WEEK. THESE CONCERNS ABOUT CHINA'S
22:10 ACCESS TO CHIPS. YOU ARE SEEING THAT CONTINUATION
22:15 PERHAPS TODAY ESPECIALLY AMONG SOME OF THE HYPERSCALERS OR AI
22:20 DEVELOPERS THAT COULD SEE THE DEVELOPMENT OF AI BEING
22:21 CONSTRAINED, YOU YVONNE. -- YVONNE.
22:27 YVONNE: THE CHIP STOCKS OR TECH STOCKS IN CHINA HAVE BECOME THE
22:31 COLLATERAL DAMAGE. NOT ONLY ARE THEY FACING
22:37 CHALLENGES AT HOME BUT ALSO EARNINGS TO SEE HOW ARE THEY
22:42 COPING IN THE FACE OF THESE CHALLENGES EXTERNALLY NOW.
22:45 WITH OF COURSE THE LOSS OF JENSEN HUANG BUT THERE YOU GO.
22:50 THAT IS LIFTING THE CHIP SECTOR. WE HAVE THE OPEN COMING UP NEXT.
22:52 THIS IS BLOOMBERG. ♪
23:14 YVONNE: WELCOME BACK. AVRIL: YOU ARE WATCHING THE
23:19 CHINA SHOW, COUNTING DOWN TO THE OPEN OF MARKET.
23:22 THE KEY OVERHANG WHEN IT COMES TO CHINESE EQUITIES IS PERHAPS
23:26 THE EXTENT IN WHICH WE WILL SEE CONTINUED PRESSURE ON THE AI
23:30 DEVELOPERS. NOT JUST HYPERSCALERS BUT THE
23:32 PURE PLAYS AS WELL. WE COULD SEE A BIT OF A PICKUP
23:38 FROM YESTERDAY'S SELLING AGAINST BACKDROPS OF CONCERNS ABOUT
23:41 CHINA'S ACCESS TO CHIPS. CUTTING EDGE TECHNOLOGY WHEN IT
23:44 COMES TO THE AI HARDWARE. YVONNE: CAN NVIDIA MAINTAIN
23:48 DOMINANCE WITHOUT JENSEN HUANG AT THE HOME FOR THE U.S., OR IS
23:55 MEANTIME CHINA STILL NEEDS ACCESS TO THOSE CHIPS TO KEEP
23:56 UP. THAT IS THE KEY QUESTION FOR THE
24:02 HANG SENG TECH THIS MORNING. STILL UP 5% THIS MONTH BUT WE
24:07 WILL SEE IF THE RALLY CAN HOLD THE COLLATERAL DAMAGE ALREADY
24:13 WHEN IT COMES TO THE LIKES OF ALIBABA AND MINIMAX AS WELL.
24:17 WE ARE KICKING THINGS OF A FRIEND ENDING THE WEEK ON A
24:19 PRETTY POSITIVE NOTE IN JOINING IN ON THE REBOUND WE ARE SEEING
24:23 REGIONALLY WHEN IT COMES TO TECH.
24:25 CHINA NEXT, START 50, SHANGHAI UP TO PERCENT ON THE START 50
24:27 GAUGE. THAT IS SOMETHING TO WATCH
24:33 CLOSELY ON WHAT IS DRIVING THAT. WHEN IT COMES TO SMIC, THE
24:35 CHIPMAKER THAT CAME OUT WITH EARNINGS THAT WERE BEATING
24:38 ESTIMATES AS WELL. I BELIEVE PROFIT DID DOUBLE SO
24:44 THAT IS A BRIGHT SPOT AS WELL IN THE CHIP SPACE AS WELL.
24:46 HONG KONG IS LOOKING LIKE THIS, LET'S SEE HOW HSTECH IS GOING.
24:53 WE ARE SEEING MOSTLY ALL RED ACROSS THE SCREEN WHEN IT COMES
24:55 TO HONG KONG. THE HANG SENG WELL BELOW THE
24:58 24,000 THRESHOLD. SO THIS RALLY WE ARE SEEING IN
25:06 SOME WAYS IS IN JEOPARDY GIVEN THE ROTATION HIT THE SKIDS AFTER
25:11 THIS WEEK, THE WHOLE NVIDIA STORY AS WELL.
25:19 LET'S TAKE A LOOK AT HOW BABA, TENCENT, MINIMAX, YOU HAVE JD
25:23 COME UP BY DO ALL COMING UP WITH EARNINGS NEXT WEEK.
25:27 THAT WILL BE THE KEY FOCUS ON WHAT THEY ARE GOING TO SAY IN
25:30 THE FACE OF RISING GEOPOLITICAL TENSIONS AND WHAT IS HAPPENING
25:32 IN THE U.S. AS WELL. THAT COULD BE ONE THING TO WATCH
25:34 CLOSELY. MINIMAX RECOVERING A BIT.
25:40 ALIBABA AND MINIMAX EXTENDING LOSSES.
25:44 ALIBABA DOWN CLOSER TO 7%. ADR DEPLOYMENT AS WELL.
25:51 TALKING SMIC, THERE IS A LITTLE BIT OF THAT SELF-SUFFICIENCY
25:53 THEME THAT IS EMERGING. YOU ARE SEEING THE LIKES OF SMIC
26:02 AS WELL, CXMT, ALL HIGHER. THE 2026 REVENUE FROM SMIC TO
26:09 EXCEED $12 BILLION. CERTAINLY THE AI DEMAND IS STILL
26:13 IN SOME WAYS QUITE STRONG. AVRIL: IN THE MEANTIME, WE HAVE
26:22 SET TO BE CONSIDERING UP TO $3.2 BILLION IN TERMS OF A RIGHTS
26:28 ISSUE AND HAS ENGAGED BANKS TO PREPARE FOR THE ISSUE TO RAISE
26:31 AS MUCH AS THAT AMOUNT THAT I JUST MENTIONED.
26:32 THIS IS ACCORDING TO PEOPLE FAMILIAR WITH THE SITUATION.
26:37 THE NEW WORLD IS THE CONTROLLING SHAREHOLDER -- THE CONTROLLING
26:44 SHAREHOLDER OF NEW WORLD IS THE CHAIN FAMILY, SET TUBE PROJECT
26:47 CAPITAL INTO THE INDEBTED COMPANY.
26:50 WHEN WE ARE OF COURSE EATING TODAY, TRADING IN NEW WORLD
26:55 SHARES WAS SUSPENDED THIS MORNING, PENDING THE
26:56 ANNOUNCEMENT. THIS IS A STOCK THAT HAS FALLEN
27:01 DOUBLE DIGITS OVER 40% THIS YEAR.
27:02 IN THE MEANTIME AS WE CONTINUE TRACKING THAT, TALKING AS WELL
27:07 ABOUT THE REST OF ASIA AND HOW IT IS DIGESTING, PERHAPS WHAT
27:13 HAS BEEN THE KEY STORY OF THE NVIDIA NEWS, LET'S BRING IN MARK
27:14 CRANFIELD. LOOKING AT HOW ASIA IS FARING
27:20 TODAY, IT LOOKS LIKE THEY ARE TAKING THINGS IN STRIDE.
27:22 THEY WANT TO MOVE PAST THE NVIDIA SAGA.
27:25 TO WHAT EXTENT CAN THEY DO THIS AND HOW DO YOU VIEW THIS AGAINST
27:30 THE BACKDROP OF NVIDIA EARNINGS AS WELL AS ANTHROPIC'S POTENTIAL
27:32 TREATING DEBUT NEXT WEEK? REPORTER: I THINK IN THE NEAR
27:36 TERM YOU FOUND ALL THE INFORMATION YOU NEEDED TO KNOW
27:40 LAST NIGHT. EVERYBODY WAS GLUED TO THE
27:42 NVIDIA PERFORMANCE OF THE SHARE PRICE LAST NIGHT IN THE UNITED
27:46 STATES. IT OPENED VERY WEAK AND IT SPENT
27:51 THE WHOLE DAY CLIMBING HIGHER. IT DID END SLIGHTLY IN THE RED,
27:55 BUT IT COULD HAVE BEEN SO MUCH WORSE.
28:00 IF YOU TAKE IT IN ISOLATION, IT WAS ACTUALLY A VERY BULLISH DAY.
28:03 IT CONTINUE TO CLIMB ALL DAY ON MASSIVE VOLUME.
28:07 IT WAS AN ENORMOUS TRADING DAY YESTERDAY WHICH TELLS YOU ALL
28:10 YOU NEED TO KNOW. A LOT OF PEOPLE BOUGHT THE DIP
28:15 IN NVIDIA AND THEY HAVE A CONVICTION, AT LEAST IN THE
28:17 SHORT-TERM, NVIDIA WILL CONTINUE TO BE A HIGHLY PROFITABLE
28:20 COMPANY AND PROBABLY HAVE GREAT RESULTS NEXT WEEK.
28:24 THE NEW CEO WILL GO OUT THERE VERY QUICKLY TO REASSURE
28:29 EVERYONE IN THE BUSINESS AS USUAL.
28:31 OF COURSE IT MIGHT NOT BE AS EASY AS SHE HOPES, BUT FOR THE
28:35 TIME BEING, INVESTORS WANT TO BELIEVE THAT.
28:37 ONE THING THAT'S HELPING THEM IS THE FACT THAT DEMOCRATS DON'T
28:40 TAKE CONTROL OF CONGRESS IN THE SENATE UNTIL JANUARY.
28:42 THEY HAVE A LITTLE BIT OF A LAYER OF TIME WHERE THERE WILL
28:45 BE A LOT OF POLITICAL NOISE, BUT NOT TOO MUCH THAT ANYONE WILL DO
28:49 ABOUT IT UNTIL THEY SEE THE SET UP IN JANUARY.
28:53 AT LEAST BETWEEN NOW AND PROBABLY SOMETIME PAST
28:55 THANKSGIVING, TRADERS CAN SEE A LITTLE RUNWAY WHERE THERE IS AN
28:59 OPPORTUNITY TO MAKE BETTER MONEY OUT OF TECH STOCKS.
29:05 YVONNE: I WONDER IF THIS ANTHROPIC IPO WASN'T HAPPENING,
29:08 WOULD WE STILL HAVE THE SAME REACTION ACROSS THE MARKETS?
29:11 WHAT ARE YOU ANTICIPATING NEXT WEEK FOR ANTHROPIC?
29:16 REPORTER: IT HAS ACTUALLY MADE IT A BIT EASIER FOR ANTHROPIC
29:19 AND IMPROVED THE SIGNS A LITTLE MORE.
29:22 IT WILL NOT BE AN EASY IPO AT ALL.
29:24 IT'S A BIT DISTURBING THAT WE ALREADY HAVE REPORTS THAT SOME
29:28 OF THE INSIDERS WHO GOT EARLY ALLOCATIONS ARE ALREADY TRYING
29:32 TO FLIP THEIR SHARES FOR NOT VERY BIG PREMIUMS.
29:34 3% OR 5% IS A VERY SMALL PREMIUM ON WHAT IS AT ONE POINT THE
29:38 HOTTEST IPO THIS YEAR. ESPECIALLY WHEN YOU CONSIDER
29:45 THEY WILL NOT RAISE THE $2 TRILLION THEY WERE EXPECTED TO
29:48 EARLIER THIS YEAR. THE WHOLE THING IS STARTING TO
29:50 LOOK LIKE A LITTLE BIT OF A WAIT ON THE MARKET.
29:53 PEOPLE WOULD BE RELIEVED IF ANTHROPIC GOES THROUGH WITHOUT
29:56 DISTURBING THE MARKET TOO MUCH. THE BEST WE CAN REALLY HELP FOR,
30:00 INVESTORS ARE THINKING ON THE FIRST DAY OF TRADING, IF
30:03 ANTHROPIC ENDS FLAT ON THE DAY, IT WILL BE HIGHLY VOLATILE.
30:06 THERE WILL BE A LOT OF PEOPLE TRYING TO GET OUT OF IT QUICKLY.
30:09 BIGGER PORTFOLIOS MIGHT BE LOOKING FOR THE LONGER TERM.
30:15 IT WILL BE VERY CHOPPY. IF IT STAYS WITH A SMALL GAIN OR
30:16 FLAT, PEOPLE WILL BE HUGELY RELIEVED.
30:21 THE WAY THE MARKET IS SO FLUID, ON THE FIRST DAY OF TRADING IF
30:25 CONDITIONS ARE NOT GOOD, ANTHROPIC CAN BRING THE WHOLE
30:27 MARKET DOWN. IT IS A DICEY SITUATION.
30:36 YVONNE: WE FOCUSED SO MUCH OF THE EQUITY SPACE BUT WHAT'S
30:36 HAPPENING IN FIXED INCOME IN THE TREASURY CURVE IS SOMETHING THAT
30:37 I THINK HAS BEEN OVERLOOKED. THE MELT-UP IN YIELDS WE HAVE
30:42 SEEN AFTER THAT HOT INFLATION PRINT, AND THE FED HAWKS THAT
30:46 SEEM TO BE EMERGING NOW, HOW SIGNIFICANT IS THIS?
30:52 ARE WE LIKELY TO SEE MORE OF THE SELLOFF?
30:57 CURRENCY MARKET MORE THAN ANY OTHER, IS ACTUALLY HEADING FOR
31:07 ITS WORST WEEK IN A YEAR. WE'VE ALSO HAD A FED HIKE AS
31:08 WELL. YET THIS COULD BE THE WORST WEEK
31:12 FOR TWO YEAR TREASURIES OF THE WHOLE YEAR.
31:14 PRETTY AMAZING TO HAVE THAT. THAT'S A BIG PART OF WHY
31:17 DOLLAR-YEN IS AROUND THE 160 AREA AGAIN.
31:24 IT WILL BE OF TOUGH RUN IN. IF TREASURY YIELDS ARE
31:27 REPRESSING IN PEOPLE ARE LOOKING FOR THREE HIKES AT LEAST NOW FOR
31:31 NEXT YEAR, SEVERAL BANKS HAVE COME OUT AND SAID THAT'S WHAT
31:33 THEY EXPECT. AT THE HEIGHT COME QUITE.
31:42 SO THERE'S A LOT OF PRESSURE AND THAT WILL REVERBERATE ACROSS
31:42 ASIA AS WELL. YVONNE: THANK YOU, MARK
31:48 CRANFIELD, MLIV STRATEGIST OUT OF SINGAPORE.
31:50 STILL WITH US IS VIVIAN LIN THURSTON.
31:54 THANK YOU FOR STICKING AROUND. I WANT TO GET YOUR TAKE ON
31:57 CONTINUING OUR CONVERSATION WITH CHINA.
32:02 WHEN IT COMES TO 2027, PEOPLE ARE LOOKING OUT AT WHAT IS IN
32:05 STORE NEXT YEAR. HOW SHOULD I LOOK AT TRAIN
32:09 EQUITIES NEXT YEAR COMPARED TO THIS -- CHINA EQUITIES NEXT YEAR
32:11 COMPARED TO THIS YEAR? >> I THINK 2027 IS PROBABLY VERY
32:19 SIMILAR TO 2026. THE COMPANY IS MORE CATER TO
32:24 DOMESTIC CONSUMPTION SERVICES AND MANUFACTURING TENDS TO BE
32:29 WEAK, GIVEN DOMESTIC COMPANIES REMAIN DEFLATIONARY.
32:36 MORE TECH LEAD ROLES SHOULD DO BETTER.
32:38 I THINK THE SAME PATTERN SHOULD BE EXPECTED.
32:42 COMING TO MARKET BEHAVIOR, THAT IS A DIFFERENT STORY, GIVEN THAT
32:46 THERE ARE DIFFERENT FACTORS THAT COULD IMPACT THE EQUITY MARKET
32:48 ON A NONFUNDAMENTAL BASIS. ONE IS THE U.S. INTEREST RATE.
33:01 IF THEY RAISE INTEREST RATES, MS YEAR CHINA TENDS TO DO POORLY.
33:07 SECONDLY GEOPOLITICAL RISK AND U.S. CHINA RELATIONS.
33:10 THAT CAN PLAY A FACTOR. HAVING SAID THAT, I THINK
33:14 THERE'S A DISCONNECT BETWEEN THE TOP LINE AND BOTTOM LINE IN
33:21 CHINA, QUITE UNIQUE GIVEN -- THEIR EARNINGS TEND TO BE MORE
33:23 NARROW BASED. YOU HAVE TO BE VERY SELECTIVE,
33:27 ACCOMPANIED BY A COMPANY AND INDUSTRY BY INDUSTRY TO SEE
33:34 WHICH STOCK CAN BE A VERY -- BETTER INVESTMENT OPPORTUNITY.
33:37 AGGREGATE BASIS, IT REMAINS LARGELY UNCERTAIN FOR EQUITIES
33:40 IN 2027. AVRIL: THE NEED TO BE SELECTIVE,
33:49 YOU SEE THAT WITH THE CHINA ACCESSIBLE, OPTICAL STOCKS
33:59 WHEN IT TALKS ABOUT BEING SELECTIVE?
34:03 >> I WOULD FOCUS ON THE COMPANY SUPPLY TO DOMESTIC AI ECOSYSTEM.
34:09 AND LESS TO THE GLOBAL, ESPECIALLY ON THE SEMICONDUCTOR
34:11 SIDE. I THINK THE LARGE LANGUAGE MODEL
34:16 COULD BE INTERESTING GIVEN THE SELF-SUFFICIENCY OF THAT.
34:22 AND THEN LET'S SAY THE LARGER MODEL CONTINUES TO NARROW THE
34:26 GAP. THAT COULD BE A VERY INTERESTING
34:34 CATALYST NOT JUST FOR THOSE COMPANIES BUT FOR THE TECH
34:37 INDUSTRY IN CHINA IN 2027. ALSO I WOULD TRY TO FOCUS ON
34:43 THOSE COMPANIES AND EXPERTS STRONGLY INCLUDING HEALTH CARE.
34:50 THOSE COMPANIES CONTINUE TO DO WELL EVEN THOUGH THEY RELY ON
34:55 MORE OF THE U.S. CUSTOMERS AND GLOBAL INDUSTRY CYCLE.
34:59 STRONG. AVRIL: TREY TO HAVE YOU.
35:06 THANK YOU SO MUCH FOR YOUR TIME, YOUR ANALYSIS ON WHAT HAS BEEN A
35:10 REALLY REALLY INTERESTING WEEK. WILLIAM BLAIR'S PORTFOLIO
35:14 MANAGER VIVIAN LIN THURSTON. COMING UP, MORE FOR WHAT THIS
35:19 MEANS FOR AI COMPETITION. THIS IS BLOOMBERG.
35:37 ♪ YVONNE: CONTINUES TO BE PRESSURE
35:41 WHEN IT COMES TO THE CHINA TECH SPACE THIS MORNING ON THE BACK
35:44 OF THE NVIDIA SAGA. THERE'S FEARS ABOUT CHINA CHIPS
35:49 GETTING ACCESS. WHAT ARE THE CHINESE AI MODELS
35:52 GOING TO DO? IS THERE A POTENTIAL RISK OF A
35:56 WIDER U.S. BAND? JENSEN HUANG'S RESIGNATION FROM
36:02 NVIDIA MAY GIVE THE CHIPMAKER A PATH OUT OF ITS CRISIS.
36:09 CHINA IS THE BIG LOSER FROM THE OUSTER.
36:11 SHE JOINS US NOW. GREAT TO HAVE YOU ON THE
36:12 PROGRAM. TELL US WHY YOU THINK CHINA
36:16 COULD BE THE BIGGEST LOSER FROM THIS EXIT.
36:23 CATHERINE: I THINK CHINA REALLY LOST ITS BIGGEST SUPPORTER AND
36:25 ITS BIGGEST CHEERLEADER IN AMERICA IN TERMS OF NOT
36:29 COMPLETELY CUTTING CHINA OFF FROM CHIPS.
36:34 THE DETAILS ABOUT HIS ALLEGED RELATIONSHIP WITH THE SUSPECTED
36:37 CHINESE SPY, WE DON'T KNOW THE DETAILS BUT NONE OF IT LOOKS
36:38 GOOD. THE CALLS FOR FURTHER TIGHTENING
36:43 OF ACCESS TO CHIPS IN CHINA, THOSE ARE GOING TO GROW.
36:47 EVEN THE LEGAL LOU BALLS -- LOOPHOLES, THEY REALLY LOST THE
36:51 ONE VOICE THAT WAS REALLY ARGUING FOR THESE IN D.C. AND
36:54 SILICON VALLEY. I EXPECT CHIP RESTRICTIONS TO
37:01 TIGHTEN FURTHER AND THAT WILL CAUSE NEAR-TERM PAIN IN CHINA'S
37:02 AI SECTOR. AVRIL: IS THAT PART OF THE
37:10 REASON WHY YOU THINK THE CRISIS GOES BEYOND ACCESS TO NVIDIA
37:11 CHIPS IN CHINA? CATHERINE: THAT'S RIGHT.
37:16 JENSEN HUANG WAS ONE OF THE MOST ARDENT SUPPORTERS OF CHINESE AI
37:19 IN AMERICA. WHEN HE USED HIS FIRST-EVER
37:22 TWITTER POST OVER THE SUMMER. HE JOINED TO PUBLISH THIS OPEN
37:28 LETTER ARGUING AGAINST A BAN OF CHINESE OPEN-WEIGHT MODELS.
37:31 HE'S BEEN A SUPPORTER OF OPEN-WEIGHT MODELS.
37:35 HE'S VERY INFLUENTIAL IN D.C. AND AMONG POLICYMAKERS.
37:38 DISTILLATION HAS BEEN THIS HUGE DEBATE IN D.C. AND THE CENTER OF
37:44 CALLS TO BAN TRAINEES AI IN AMERICA.
37:48 JENSEN WAS ONE OF THE FEW VOICES IN THE U.S. THAT DEFENDED IT.
37:52 I WOULDN'T BE SURPRISED IF MORE CHINA HAWKS GET MORE POWERFUL
37:57 AND BECOME A LOT LOUDER. AVRIL: THANK YOU SO MUCH.
38:04 JOINING US NOW IS THE FOUNDER OF ASHTON ANALYTICS, A FORMER CHINA
38:12 AND A LIST -- ANALYSIST. IT'S BEEN A STARTLING WEEK.
38:18 THE INVESTOR COMMUNITY AND SILICON VALLEY ALSO GETTING THE
38:24 SHOCK, THE RIPPLE EFFECT. THE PROMINENCE OF NVIDIA IN THE
38:26 AI ECONOMY. HOW DO YOU THINK THIS WILL
38:30 INFORM THE U.S. CHINA AI RACE? ANNA: GOSH.
38:36 I CERTAINLY THINK THAT IT'S GOING TO MAKE TENSIONS EVEN MORE
38:38 PROMINENT. BUT AT THE SAME TIME, WE ARE
38:45 LIVING WITH AN ADMINISTRATION THAT'S RATHER UNUSUAL AND TAKES
38:50 AN UNORTHODOX APPROACH TO THINGS.
38:54 EARLIER TODAY, THE PRESIDENT SINGING THAT HE WASN'T GOING TO
38:56 BRING THIS UP IN HIS MEETINGS WITH XI.
39:00 THAT HE WAS STILL GOING TO GO TO SHENZHEN.
39:05 THAT'S INDICATIVE OF THE FACT THAT JUST BECAUSE EVERY OTHER
39:06 ADMINISTRATION MIGHT RESPOND TO THIS IN A CERTAIN WAY, DOESN'T
39:09 MEAN THAT THIS ONE WILL. CONGRESS IS GOING TO TAKE A HARD
39:13 LINE. IT'S GOING TO HAVE REALLY
39:16 SERIOUS QUESTIONS FOR JENSEN HUANG AND ANYONE ELSE INVOLVED
39:22 WHO CAN GET INTO TESTIFY. THEY ARE DEFINITELY GOING TO
39:28 LEVERAGE THIS AS A REASON TO TIGHTEN EXPORT CONTROLS AND MAKE
39:32 THE RELATIONSHIP EVEN MORE RESTRICTIVE.
39:37 AVRIL: THE WHOLE PREMISE WHEN IT COMES TO CHINA'S HEADWAY IN THE
39:45 I-8 -- AI RACE WAS SPARKED BY THE DEEPSEEK MOMENT IN EARLY
39:47 2025. THE NARRATIVE THAT EMERGED
39:52 SEEMED TO HAVE BEEN CHINA CAN MAKE THIS PROGRESS EVEN WITHOUT
39:55 ACCESS TO THIS CUTTING EDGE U.S. TECHNOLOGY OR HIGH-END AI
39:57 HARDWARE. IS THAT NARRATIVE UPENDED NOW?
40:04 ANNA: I DON'T THINK SO. I THINK THAT'S ONE OF THE
40:09 UNFORTUNATE OUTCOMES OF THE WHOLE SCANDAL.
40:12 IN MANY RESPECTS, IT DOESN'T MATTER WHETHER THIS WOMAN THAT
40:17 HE ADMITTED TO HAVING AN AFFAIR WITH WAS A SPY OR WAS NOT.
40:22 THE REALITY IS THAT SHE WAS WORKING FOR A COMPANY THAT WAS
40:25 DISTRUSTED BY THE U.S. GOVERNMENT, THAT THE U.S.
40:30 GOVERNMENT SAW AS GETTING AROUND U.S. EXPORT CONTROLS.
40:32 JENSEN HUANG SHOULD'VE KNOWN THAT.
40:39 JUDGMENT. AND HIS OBJECTIVITY.
40:46 SO HE'S BEEN THIS PERSON WHO HAS BEEN CARRYING THIS MESSAGE
40:50 AROUND THE WORLD. THAT THERE'S OPPORTUNITY FOR
40:57 COOPERATION AND FOR EACH COUNTRY'S CHAMPIONS TO BE IN THE
41:00 OTHERS MARKETS. WHICH IS IMPORTANT FOR THE
41:06 COMPETITION, THE COMPETITIVENESS OF ANY OF THESE 10 COMPANIES --
41:10 TECH COMPANIES. THAT MESSAGE WILL GET DROWNED
41:13 OUT I THINK BY THE SCANDAL OF THIS.
41:19 [CROSSTALK] YVONNE: IT'S NOT A QUESTION
41:24 ABOUT HOW MUCH THE U.S. GOVERNMENT KNEW.
41:28 ESPECIALLY WHEN IT COMES TO THE COMMERCE DEPARTMENT.
41:30 HOWARD LUTNICK, HIS JOB IN SOME WAYS, DID THEY DO ENOUGH TO KEEP
41:38 NVIDIA'S PRIZED AI CHIPS OUT OF CHINA'S HANDS?
41:43 GIVEN THIS CRISIS, DO YOU THINK HOWARD LUTNICK SHOULD BE HELD
41:44 ACCOUNTABLE FOR THIS AS WELL? WHEN IT COMES TO THIS ALLEGED
41:51 SMUGGLING OF NVIDIA CHIPS, HOW FEASIBLE IS IT TO CRACKDOWN ON
41:52 THAT? ANNA: I DON'T THINK IT'S
41:59 ENTIRELY FEASIBLE. I ALSO THINK IT'S HARD TO SAY
42:05 WHAT THE RIGHT ANSWER IS ON THE QUESTIONS AROUND LUTNICK.
42:09 THE REALITY IS, THE INTELLIGENCE COMMUNITY CAN FEEL ONE WAY ABOUT
42:13 SOMETHING AND THEIR ENTIRE JOB IS TO FOCUS ON NATIONAL
42:15 SECURITY. THERE'S ALSO A COMPETITIVENESS
42:18 LENS. THOSE THINGS HAVE TO BE BALANCED
42:21 IN SOME EXTENT. LUTNICK MAY HAVE BEEN USING HIS
42:27 JUDGMENT TO BALANCE THAT. WE DON'T KNOW BECAUSE WE DON'T
42:31 KNOW WHAT THE INTELLIGENCE SAID. THE INTELLIGENCE WAS DAMMING AND
42:32 HE'S IN TROUBLE. AVRIL: WHAT IS YOUR READ ON THE
42:38 TIMING OF THESE REVELATIONS ABOUT JENSEN HUANG?
42:41 IT'S COMING IN A WEEK FOLLOWING ON FROM THE MIDTERM ELECTIONS
42:48 WHERE THE U.S. PRESIDENT CONTINUES TO BACK JENSEN HUANG.
42:51 SUFFERED STUNNING DEFEAT. ANNA: IT CERTAINLY CHANGES THE
42:59 CONVERSATION IN D.C. AND DOMESTICALLY IN THE UNITED
43:03 STATES. WHAT IS THE REPUBLICAN PARTY
43:06 ELECTION? SOMETHING THAT'S MUCH MORE
43:13 UNIFYING POLITICALLY IN D.C. AND GETS EVERYONE FOCUSED ON
43:17 STRENGTHENING SECURITY. THAT HAS BEEN CHINA'S LONG-TERM
43:22 ROLE IN AMERICAN POLITICS. FOR AT LEAST THE LAST 15, 20
43:25 YEARS. SO IT COMES AT A TIME THAT'S
43:30 PREDICTABLE. IT'S INTERESTING THAT TRUMP IS
43:35 TAKING THE POSITION HE'S TAKING. I THINK IT'S ANYONE'S GUESS HOW
43:41 THINGS WILL UNFOLD IN THE COMING DAYS WITH THE WHITE HOUSE.
43:46 FOR JENSEN HUANG, I JUST DON'T THINK THAT HIS MESSAGE IS GOING
43:52 TO SURVIVE THIS VERY WELL. IT WILL TAKE A LOT TO RECOVER
43:56 THE IDEA THAT AMERICAN COMPANIES NEED TO BE IN THE CHINA MARKET.
44:05 BEING IN THE CHINA MARKET MAKES THE TECH MORE EXPOSED.
44:07 THAT'S THE FEAR. YVONNE: WHAT DOES THIS MEAN FOR
44:15 NEXT WEEK WHEN TRUMP AND XI ARE SUPPOSED TO MEET?
44:17 WHAT EXCITATIONS DO YOU HAVE? ANNA: IT WOULD BE REALLY NICE TO
44:22 SEE THE TWO SIDES MOVE FORWARD. AI CHALLENGES.
44:30 TECHNICAL INFORMATION SHARING. EARLY WARNING.
44:33 THAT SORT OF THING. SO A POSITIVE SIGN IS THAT TRUMP
44:50 RIGHT NOW DOESN'T WANT THE SCANDAL WITH JENSEN HUANG TO
44:52 DOMINATE. MAYBE THAT MEANS THAT THERE IS
44:55 STILL ROOM FOR THEM TO HAVE THAT CONVERSATION.
44:59 AVRIL: IT'S BEEN GREAT TO GET YOUR INSIGHTS.
45:00 THANK YOU SO MUCH FOR YOUR TIME TODAY.
45:20 ♪ YVONNE: CHECKING MARKETS RIGHT
45:22 NOW. A MIXED PICTURE ACROSS GREATER
45:23 CHINA THIS MORNING. HSTECH IS COMING BACK IN SOME
45:27 WAYS AS WELL. HANG SENG STILL SEEING SOME
45:33 PRESSURE HERE ALONG WITH WHAT WE SEE IN SHENZHEN.
45:38 STILL A LOT OF NOT MUCH CONVICTION HERE WHEN IT COMES TO
45:41 THESE MARKETS. HSTECH AND THE LIKE REMAIN IN
45:44 BEAR MARKET TERRITORY. WE ARE WATCHING CLOSELY WHAT
45:48 SORT OF EARNINGS WILL TELL US, PARTICULARLY WHEN IT COMES TO
45:51 CHINA TECH THAT DOES REPORT NEXT WEEK.
45:53 MUCH MORE IN THE NEXT HOUR. YOU ARE WATCHING THE CHINA SHOW.
46:17 ♪ >> INVESTORS WERE SHOCKED BY
46:21 JENSEN LEAVING. THE STEADY HAND THAT WALL STREET
46:24 TRUSTS. SHE WAS THE RIGHT PICK FOR AN
46:28 INTERIM CEO. SHE'S GOING TO HAVE A LOT OF
46:30 WORK ON HER HANDS. >> THERE WILL BE A SLOWDOWN IN
46:38 TERMS OF NEW CHIP ITERATIONS, NEW INFRASTRUCTURE THAT BUILDS
46:40 UP. THE SUPPLY WILL BE MORE LIMITED.
46:44 POTENTIALLY THE PRICE WILL INCREASE.
46:50 YVONNE: SOME OF OUR GUESTS EARLIER ON THE NVIDIA STALL OUT
46:57 SO. MARKETS HERE THIS MORNING.
47:06 RESILIENCE ACROSS NORTH ASIA AND IN THE REGION THIS MORNING.
47:11 THE REALITY THAT JENSEN HUANG IS NO LONGER AT THE HELM OF NVIDIA.
47:13 SOMETHING QUITE INTERESTING. THE ANTHROPIC NEWS IS KEEPING
47:19 THINGS BETTER SENTIMENT WISE. WE TALKED ABOUT HOW HEAVILY
47:22 OVERSUBSCRIBED THE IPO LISTING IS SET TO BE NEXT WEEK.
47:24 NVIDIA EARNINGS BEFORE THAT. A LOT TO CONTEND WITH NEXT.
47:30 CSI 300. WE ARE SEEING SOME GAINS THERE
47:33 WHEN IT COMES TO SHANGHAI. TAKE A LOOK AT HOW IT'S FARING.
47:41 CHIP STOCKS IN PARTICULAR SEEM TO BE CONTINUING THIS WHOLE
47:46 SELF-SUFFICIENCY THEME AFTER THIS NVIDIA CRISIS.
47:50 PRETTY BUMPER NUMBERS THERE WHEN IT CAME TO THE THIRD QUARTER.
47:54 THAT'S PROPELLING THE STOCK AS WELL AS THE CHIP CONFLICT HERE
47:56 TODAY. 5% GAINS HERE AS WELL.
48:03 AVRIL: YEAH. TWO THINGS HAPPENING WHEN IT
48:04 COMES TO THE CHIP COMPLEX FOR CHINA.
48:07 NOT JUST WHAT WE SEE IN TERMS OF EARNINGS BUT ALSO MAY BE THAT
48:11 PUSH FOR GREATER SELF-SUFFICIENCY.
48:14 YOU LOOK AT THE REST OF THE REGION AS WELL.
48:16 YOU GET A SENSE THAT THE INVESTOR COMPUTED HE --
48:21 COMMUNITY HAS DEMAND STILL INTACT DESPITE NVIDIA.
48:25 TAKE A LOOK AT WHAT WE SEE IN THE SECOND HOUR OF TRADE WHEN IT
48:28 COMES TO SOME OF THESE CHINESE TECH NAMES.
48:31 WE ARE RECOUPING FROM THE LOSSES OF YESTERDAY FOR THE MOST PART.
48:36 YOU LOOK AT MINIMAX. THEY ARE CLIMBING ONCE AGAIN
48:41 AGAINST THE BACKDROP. MAYBE A BIT OF STABILIZATION
48:42 RETURNING. THEY WERE HIT BY THOSE CONCERNS
48:48 ABOUT WHETHER THE AI DEVELOPMENT MIGHT BE CONSTRAINED BY FURTHER
48:50 SCRUTINY ON THEIR ACCESS TO CHIPS.
48:54 THE BENCHMARKS IN THE REGION ARE CLIMBING HIGHER TODAY.
48:58 THE TURNAROUND FROM THE THURSDAY PERFORMANCE.
49:01 THIS IS COMING AT A TIME WHEN INVESTORS ARE GOING TO CONTINUE
49:05 DIGESTING PERHAPS WHAT THE FUTURE HOLDS.
49:08 NOT JUST NVIDIA BUT ANTHROPIC SITE -- IPO AND TRADING DATE
49:13 NEXT WEEK. YVONNE: FOR MORE ON HOW THE
49:20 FOLLY COULD IMPACT RELATIONS. APEC SUMMIT IN SHENZHEN AS WELL
49:24 ON THE BACK OF ANTHROPIC AND NVIDIA EARNINGS.
49:28 LET'S BRING IN MINMIN LOW WHO JOINS US FROM SHANGHAI HERE THIS
49:29 MORNING. WHAT'S IN STORE NEXT WEEK?
49:41 >> PRESIDENT TRUMP SAID HE IS LIKELY TO DO SO BUT GIVEN THE
49:44 NEWS FLOW, HE MIGHT BE FORCED TO DO SO.
49:46 A BIG FOCUS HAS BEEN THE TECH CURVES.
49:51 GIVEN THE OUSTER OF JENSEN HUANG , IS GIVING AN OPENING TO THE
49:56 DEMOCRATS AND THE WHITE HOUSE TO PUSH HARD FOR AN ACCELERATION OF
50:00 THE PACE OF TECH CURVES ON CHINA.
50:01 THE TRADE TRUCE EXPIRING IN JANUARY.
50:05 IT REALLY RESTS ON THE U.S. PUTTING A PAUSE ON ANY NEW TECH
50:07 CURVES. ANY CHANGES TO THE STATUS QUO
50:11 WILL BE HARD TO MAINTAIN. IT CHANGES THE CALCULUS OF WHAT
50:14 THE TRADE TRUCE COULD LOOK LIKE. WHETHER WE WOULD EVEN GET AN
50:16 EXTENSION HERE. A LOT OF CHINESE COMPANIES ARE
50:22 WORRIED ABOUT THESE CURBS AND WHETHER THE U.S. CAN TIGHTEN
50:24 THEM ESPECIALLY ON OVERSEAS REMOTE ACCESS TO THESE OVERSEAS
50:30 DATA CENTERS ACCORDING TO THE INFORMATION THE COMMERCE
50:32 DEPARTMENT IS WORKING ON. , NEW ANNOUNCEMENTS THAT COULD
50:36 COME IN AS SOON AS THIS MONTH. THAT'S NOT COUNTING THE VARIOUS
50:42 OTHER PROPOSALS BEING NEGOTIATED RIGHT NOW AMONG LAWMAKERS
50:48 INCLUDING THE MATCH ACT WHICH COULD COMPEL FOREIGN COUNTRIES
50:51 TO ALIGN WITH THE U.S. LAWS AND EXPORT CONTROLS AS WELL AS THE
50:56 AI TRIP SECURITY ACT WHICH WILL REQUIRE COMPANIES TO PHYSICALLY
51:01 TRACK -- TRACK WHETHER TRIPS END UP IN THE SUPPLY CHAIN.
51:05 THAT WOULD MAKE IT HARDER FOR RESTRICTED TRIPS TO END UP IN
51:06 CHINESE HANDS. AVRIL: AMID THE SCRUTINY,
51:15 THERE'S BEEN REPORTING THAT ALICE WONG HAS BEEN PROMISING
51:19 SOME OF THESE NVIDIA CHIPS. WHAT DO WE KNOW ABOUT THAT?
51:24 >> THIS IS ACCORDED TO THE INFORMATION'S REPORTED.
51:28 ACCORDING TO THE REPORTING, A NETWORK OF COMPANIES TIED TO HER
51:34 AND HER FAMILY COULD BE INVESTED IN DEEPSEEK IN THE LATEST ROUND
51:38 OF FINANCING JUST A COUPLE MONTHS AGO.
51:40 DEEPSEEK INTRODUCED SOME OF THESE COMPANIES TIED TO HER AND
51:42 HER FAMILY. IT'S NOT CLEAR HOW MUCH SHE
51:45 INVESTED. BUT THIS WOULD CLEAR THE WAY TO
51:51 ALLOW THOSE COMPANIES TO CONTINUE BRINGING A STEADY
51:55 STREAM OF THOSE ADVANCED NVIDIA CHIPS TO DEEPSEEK.
52:01 HUANG. SEPARATELY, WE UNDERSTAND THAT
52:06 THE JUSTICE DEPARTMENT IS ALSO INVESTIGATING WHETHER HER
52:11 COMPANY WAS ALSO INVOLVED IN THIS CONSPIRACY TO BRING NVIDIA
52:17 POWERED SERVERS FROM SUPER MICRO TO AN UNNAMED SOUTHEAST ASIA
52:22 COMPANY WITH THE AIM OF DIVERTING IT INTO CHINA AS WELL.
52:28 EXTENDING TO MANY MORE COMPANIES.
52:28 THAT'S WHY WE DID SEE THOSE TECH SHARES AND TECH STOCKS IN CHINA
52:34 DECLINING QUITE SIGNIFICANTLY YESTERDAY, ESPECIALLY THE PEER
52:36 PLACE. WE ARE SEEING THE RECOVERY
52:37 TODAY. YVONNE: WE CONTINUE TO HEAR FROM
52:45 BEIJING, THE FOREIGN MINISTRY IN SOME WAYS DENYING THESE CLAIMS
52:46 OF ESPIONAGE. IN FACT, LET'S TAKE A LISTEN TO
52:50 WHAT THEY HAD TO SAY YESTERDAY. >> WE HAVE ALREADY MADE CLEAR
52:59 OUR POSITION ON THE SO-CALLED CHINESE ALLEGATION.
53:02 CHINA SCIENTIFIC AND TECHNOLOGICAL PROJECTS --
53:06 PROGRESS HAS BEEN DRIVEN BY OPEN COOPERATION.
53:10 THE U.S. SHOULD STOP FABRICATING SO-CALLED SPY ALLEGATIONS TO
53:14 FIND EXCUSES FOR IMPOSING A TECHNOLOGICAL CURB ON CHINA.
53:23 YVONNE: ARE WE GOING TO HAVE THIS ISSUE BEING BROUGHT UP IN
53:25 SHENZHEN NEXT WEEK WITH THE TWO PRESIDENTS MEETING?
53:29 WALK US THROUGH WHAT THE BEIJING RESPONSE HAS BEEN LIKE.
53:32 >> YEAH. THE FOREIGN MINISTRY STATEMENT
53:37 HAS USUALLY BEEN SHORT AND SWEET.
53:39 SIMPLY DENYING CLAIMS OF SPY ALLEGATIONS.
53:44 EARLIER. THEY ARE SAYING IT SHOULDN'T BE
53:49 USED AS A PRETEXT. IT'S REALLY FASCINATING IF YOU
53:52 READ THE CHINESE MEDIA COVERAGE AS WELL AS WHAT CHINESE ANALYSTS
53:55 ARE SAYING. THEY ARE SAYING THIS IS A
54:00 POLITICALLY TIMED ATTACK. THE FORMER DIPLOMAT IS SINGING
54:06 THAT THIS IS CHINA SUFFERING THE COLLATERAL DAMAGE FROM INTERNAL
54:10 STRIFE WITHIN THE U.S.. A PROMINENT VOICE.
54:12 FORMER CHIEF EDITOR OF GLOBAL TIMES.
54:15 SAYING THAT THIS IS A NATIONAL SECURITY QUEUE -- CU BECAUSE OF
54:20 HIS ASIAN ETHNICITY, HIS CHINESE ETHNICITY.
54:25 TAKING DOWN SOMEONE WHO LOOKS CHINESE.
54:28 HE SAYS THIS IS POLITICALLY CALCULATED.
54:34 WHEN UNIVERSITY SAYING THAT THIS IS REFLECTIVE OF HOW SOME PEOPLE
54:38 IN THE INTELLIGENCE COMMUNITY NOT BEING HAPPY WITH TRUMP'S
54:40 APPROACH TO CHINA. THEY ARE FRAMING THIS AS A U.S.
54:44 PROBLEM AND THE U.S. IS TRYING TO USE THE PRETEXT OF THESE SPY
54:50 ALLEGATIONS TO HAVE THE EXCUSE TO EXPAND TECH CURBS ON CHINA.
54:54 AVRIL: THANK YOU. BLOOMBERG'S NORTH ASIA
54:56 CORRESPONDENT FOR US THERE. OUR COLLEAGUES SAY IN THE
55:00 MEANTIME THAT JENSEN'S EXIT LEAVES NVIDIA'S NEAR-TERM
55:03 OUTLOOK INTACT BUT RAISES LONGER-TERM RISK AS INVESTORS
55:09 REASSESS THE SO-CALLED JENSEN PREMIUM.
55:13 A SENIOR SEMICONDUCTOR ANALYST JOINS US NOW.
55:16 TALK US THROUGH THE JENSEN PREMIUM.
55:22 HOW IS IT BEING AFFECTED GOING FORWARD GIVEN THE DEPARTURE?
55:27 >> WE TRY TO SEPARATE THE FUNDAMENTALS, THE REVENUE
55:31 ESTIMATES FROM WHAT'S HAPPENING. THE PREMIUM IS REFLECTED ON
55:36 WHAT'S HAPPENING TO THE STOCK. ON THE STREET, MOST FOLKS HAVE
55:42 NOT BROUGHT DOWN THEIR ESTIMATES FOR FISCAL 27 OR THE NEXT FISCAL
55:45 28. THE COMPANY HAD UP CITED THE
55:48 PHYSICAL 28 WHICH IS THE NEXT CALENDAR YEAR GUIDE.
55:52 ALMOST BY 100 BILLION. WE THINK THOSE NUMBERS WILL
55:54 REMAIN INTACT. WE WILL FIND OUT WITHIN A WEEK
55:56 WHEN THEY WILL REPORT AGAIN. THERE'S NOT A LOT OF RISK
56:04 UNDERWRITTEN IN THE MODELS. DEFINITELY SEEING A SIGNIFICANT
56:07 HEADLINE RISK, GOVERNMENT RISK WHICH IS EQUATING FROM THE
56:10 JENSEN PREMIUM AND HOW THE STOCK IS BEHAVING.
56:14 WE DON'T THINK NEAR-TERM THAT THE OPERATION OR THE ROADMAP FOR
56:16 THE SUPPLY DEMAND EQUATION FROM THE COMPANY CHANGES.
56:21 BUT JENSEN WAS INSTRUMENTAL AND ESSENTIAL FOR A LOT OF
56:26 DEALMAKING PROCESSES. WE THINK THE DEALMAKING WILL
56:28 DEFINITELY SLOW DOWN IN THE INTERIM OR THROUGH THE
56:34 TRANSITION UNTIL THEY FIND A PERMANENT CEO.
56:39 >> WHAT DO WE LOOK AT WHEN IT COMES TO CHINA GPU SALES?
56:43 NOW THAT WE'VE LOST THE BIG CHEERLEADER WHEN IT COMES TO
56:46 RESTRICTIONS OF EXPORT CURVES AROUND CHIPS AND STUFF.
56:51 I'M JUST WONDERING, SHOULD NVIDIA SAY GOODBYE TO THE CHINA
56:53 MARKET? HOW ARE YOU FACTORING THAT IN
56:55 NOW? >> RIGHT.
57:01 YOU LOOK AT THE PUBLIC DISCLOSURE.
57:05 NVIDIA CHIPS SHIPPING INTO CHINA LEGALLY.
57:09 FOR THE LAST TWO QUARTERS, IT WAS LESS THAN 1%.
57:13 BARELY A BILLION DOLLARS OF DATA CENTER REVENUE TO CHINA.
57:17 NOBODY WAS ACCOUNTING FOR ANY CHINA REVENUE ANYTIME SOON.
57:24 BUT THIS COULD BECOME, ESPECIALLY COMBINING WITH THIS
57:27 SCANDAL AND THE SPY ALLEGATION AND COMBINING THIS WITH THE
57:31 MIDTERM RESULTS, WE DEFINITELY NOW FEEL YOU CAN SAY GOODBYE TO
57:33 CHINA REVENUES ANYTIME SOON. WE DEFINITELY FEEL THAT THERE
57:38 WILL BE A LOT MORE SCRUTINY. NOT JUST FOR NVIDIA BUT OVERALL
57:43 MOST OF THE AI ACCELERATOR TRIPS ON HOW THEY MAKE IT TO CHINA.
57:48 WE COULD SEE MORE SANCTIONS AND RESTRICTIONS AROUND THIS.
57:52 AVRIL: SO SAY GOODBYE TO CHINA REVENUE.
57:56 AND AT THE SAME TIME, GIVEN HOW THE INTERIM CEO IS IN PLACE, THE
58:00 SCRUTINY OF THE FIRM MIGHT PULL BACK ON HOW AGGRESSIVE IT HAS
58:03 BEEN. MAYBE.
58:05 WHAT IS THAT GOING TO MEAN FOR SOME OF THESE AI SUPPLIERS OF
58:08 NVIDIA? DOES IT ALSO CONSTRAIN THE
58:10 GROWTH? >> THE GOOD NEWS ON THE SUPPLY
58:20 SIDE IS, ORGANIC DEMAND FOR ALL ACCELERATORS REMAINS HIGH.
58:25 SO IF THERE IS SOME KIND OF A HICK UP, IF IT COMES TO NVIDIA'S
58:33 DEMAND. THINK ABOUT MEMORY.
58:40 THINK ABOUT SUBSTRATE PACKAGING. THERE'S ENOUGH DEMAND FROM
58:45 COMPETITORS OF NVIDIA WHO WOULD BE REALLY HAPPY TO PICK UP THAT
58:47 SUPPLY IF IT COMES TO IT. YVONNE: ALL RIGHT.
58:54 WE WILL LEAVE IT THERE. THANK YOU.
58:58 WHAT'S NEXT FOR NVIDIA? EARNINGS COMING UP WILL BE THE
59:02 FOCUS HERE TODAY. COMING UP, THE OUTLOOK FROM
59:05 GOLDMAN SACHS WHEN IT COMES TO CHINA AND THEIR OUTLOOK FOR
59:09 2027. THE CHIEF CHINA ECONOMIST WILL
59:12 DISCUSS WHAT SHE'S EXPECTING FOR NEXT YEAR AND WHY SHE IS SEEING
59:15 MORE UNCERTAINTY AHEAD. THAT'S NEXT.
59:18 THIS IS BLOOMBERG. ♪
59:34 YVONNE: IT IS NOVEMBER SO YOU ARE STARTING TO SEE THESE
59:38 OUTLOOKS WHEN IT COMES TO 2027. GOLDMAN SACHS HAS COME OUT WITH
59:40 THEIR LATEST REPORT WHEN IT COMES TO WHERE CHINA LOOKED --
59:44 GROWTH WOULD LOOK LIKE. 4.5% NEXT YEAR.
59:51 4.6% PROJECTIONS FOR 2026. LET'S BRING IN OUR CHIEF CHINA
59:54 ECONOMIST. MORE UNCERTAINTY AHEAD FOR 2027.
1:00:00 U.S. CHINA RELATIONS MAY BECOME LESS STABLE NEXT YEAR.
1:00:04 SHE JOINS US NOW. I HAVE TO ADD THE NVIDIA CRISIS
1:00:08 TOO, HOW DO YOU THINK THIS WILL IMPACT U.S. CHINA RELATIONS
1:00:09 MOVING FORWARD? >> THE BROADER PICTURE ON U.S.
1:00:17 CHINA. WE RECENTLY HAD A SEATTLE TOUR.
1:00:23 OUR EXPERTS ALSO MENTIONED THIS. THAT 2026 IS A GOOD YEAR FOR
1:00:27 U.S. CHINA BECAUSE THE TOP LEADERSHIP WILL SEE CHINA FOUR
1:00:30 TIMES. THAT HELPED CUT THE TENSIONS.
1:00:35 YOU DON'T WANT TO ESCALATE TO THE POINT THAT THE NEXT MEETING
1:00:36 DOESN'T HAPPEN. BUT 2027 DOESN'T LOOK LIKE THERE
1:00:40 WILL BE FOUR MEETINGS. SO THE RISK IS CERTAINLY TO THE
1:00:44 DOWNSIDE WHEN IT COMES TO U.S. CHINA.
1:00:48 THE RECENT EVENTS, WHETHER IT'S NVIDIA OR CHIP ACCESS OR MIDTERM
1:00:57 OUT OF THE U.S., WHAT THAT MEANS FOR THE CHINA POLICY.
1:01:01 I THINK THAT'S WHY ARE OUTLOOK WAS MORE UNCERTAINTY THAN RISK
1:01:05 AROUND THE CORNER WHEN IT COMES TO U.S. CHINA.
1:01:07 YVONNE: HOW DO YOU THINK THAT CHINESE COMPANIES IS GOING TO DO
1:01:13 IN RESPONSE TO WHAT PEOPLE ARE TALKING ABOUT, TIGHTER EXPORT
1:01:15 CONTROLS NOW AFTER THIS CRISIS? AND THE DEMOCRATIC SWEEP THAT WE
1:01:18 SAW IN CONGRESS. >> IN TERMS OF THE TECH
1:01:24 COMPETITION, SEMICONDUCTORS ARE A KEY CONSTRAINT FOR CHINA.
1:01:30 WHETHER IT'S AT THE COMPANY LEVEL, HOW CHINESE DATA CENTERS
1:01:35 AND CHINESE TECH SECTOR WILL HAVE TO NAVIGATE THAT.
1:01:38 THIS THROWS JUST ANOTHER CHALLENGE.
1:01:41 IT DOESN'T FUNDAMENTALLY CHANGE. IT NOT -- IT'S NOT LIKE BEFORE
1:01:44 IT WAS SO EASY. CHINA IS USING THE LEVERAGE OF
1:01:50 RARE-EARTH AND U.S. USING THE LEVERAGE OF ADVANCED CHIPS.
1:01:54 IT'S A HIGHLIGHT. SHOCKS HAPPEN UNEXPECTEDLY.
1:02:01 AS INVESTORS, IT'S ANOTHER SET OF UNCERTAINTY TO NAVIGATE.
1:02:05 YVONNE: YOUR REPORT, LESS DRAG OR UNCERTAINTY.
1:02:06 WALK US THROUGH THAT HEADLINE FOR GROWTH IN CHINA.
1:02:12 >> WE ARE EXPECTING A SIMILAR PACE OF GROWTH NEXT YEAR.
1:02:16 THERE'S A LITTLE MATH BEHIND IT THAT'S GETTING A BIT WONKY.
1:02:20 DERIVATIVE. YES, PROPERTY IS VERY WEAK AND
1:02:25 CONTINUES TO DECLINE. A MAGNITUDE OF DECLINE NEXT
1:02:29 YEAR. SHOULD BE SMALLER THAN NEXT
1:02:30 YEAR. SAME THING WITH FISCAL
1:02:34 TIGHTENING. IF YOU LOOK AT CHINA'S TAX
1:02:39 COLLECTION, UP. GOVERNMENT EXPENDITURE DOWN.
1:02:41 FISCAL CONSOLIDATION. WE EXPECT A CONTINUED TIGHT
1:02:48 FISCAL POLICY BUT YOU ARE NOT GOING TO SEE THIS BIG JOIN ARMIS
1:02:51 STEP IN TIMING. THE PACE WILL SLOW.
1:02:55 THE SECOND DERIVATIVES ARE TURNING POSITIVE.
1:03:00 LET'S SAY IT'S 1%. NEXT YEAR IS A HALF OF A PERCENT
1:03:03 . POSITIVE ON A SEQUENTIAL BASIS.
1:03:08 YVONNE: IF YOU ARE THINKING 4.5 FOR NEXT YEAR, DO YOU SEE ANY
1:03:12 URGENCY FROM POLY MAKE -- POLICY MAKERS INJECT STIMULUS AT THIS
1:03:13 POINT? DO YOU EXPECT PILLAR EXPORTS
1:03:18 GOING FORWARD? >> IT'S AN INTERESTING DYNAMIC.
1:03:25 I'VE BEEN HERE MANY TIMES. WE ARE POSITIVE ON CHINESE
1:03:27 EXPORTS. WE ARE STILL POSITIVE ON CHINESE
1:03:30 EXPORTS. WHEN WE TALKED TO ONSHORE
1:03:34 CLIENTS, THERE'S A HOPE THAT CHINESE EXPORTS DON'T DO SO WELL
1:03:36 NEXT YEAR. THAT WILL FORCE POLICYMAKERS TO
1:03:43 LOOSEN FISCAL POLICY AND HELP THE DOMESTIC ECONOMY.
1:03:46 BECAUSE WE THINK EXPORTS ARE CONTINUING TO GROW VERY STRONGLY
1:03:53 EASING. YVONNE: WHAT ABOUT EXPORTS FOR
1:04:00 NEXT YEAR? >> 6% APPS -- EXPORT GROWTH IN
1:04:04 REAL TERMS. A PERCENT THIS YEAR, 6% NEXT
1:04:07 YEAR. YVONNE: WHAT ARE THE KEY PILLARS
1:04:11 THEN? IS IT GOING TO BE AI?
1:04:17 WHEN IT COMES TO THE EXPORT OF CHIPS AND HARDWARE, WHAT WE ARE
1:04:21 SEEING THAT IS KEEPING THE EXPORT NUMBER QUITE ROBUST FOR
1:04:23 MUCH OF THE YEAR. WE ARE GETTING MORE PRESSURE
1:04:30 SOME OF THIS. HOW ARE YOU SEEING THE DYNAMIC
1:04:33 LAYOUT? >> ABSOLUTELY.
1:04:36 EUROPE IS PUSHING BACK. ARMIES APPRECIATING.
1:04:43 GOVERNMENT IS DIVING BACK INTO THE EXPORT REBATE.
1:04:46 I WOULD SAY THOSE ARE CONSEQUENCES OF CHINESE EXPORTS
1:04:49 BEING TOO STRONG. IT DOESN'T REPORT -- REVERSE THE
1:04:53 FACT THAT CHINESE PRODUCTS ARE COMPETITIVE.
1:04:58 I WILL SAY THAT MARKET IS OVERESTIMATING THE IMPACT OF AI
1:05:00 ON CHINESE EXPORTS. WHEN WE LOOK AT THE DATA, THE
1:05:05 STRENGTH IS WIDESPREAD. EVEN IF NEXT YEAR, SAY GLOBAL AI
1:05:18 CAPEX COMES IN SLIGHTLY WEAKER THAN THE CONSENSUS RIGHT NOW.
1:05:22 WE STILL THINK CHINESE EXPORTS WILL CONTINUE TO GROW.
1:05:26 YVONNE: HOW DO YOU LOOK AT AI? IT LOOKS LIKE THERE'S A
1:05:29 DEFLATIONARY IMPACT THAT THIS COULD HAVE ON ECONOMIES.
1:05:32 PEOPLE ARE DEBATING ABOUT THAT IN THE U.S. AS WELL.
1:05:35 HOW WOULD THAT IMPACT CHINA'S AT IS ALREADY DEALING WITH THIS
1:05:38 DISINFLATIONARY ENVIRONMENT? >> THERE'S A COMMONALITY IN
1:05:43 TERMS OF AI RIGHT NOW. THE INVESTMENT PART OF IT,
1:05:50 INFLATIONARY PART OF IT FEEDING THROUGH THE ECONOMY,
1:05:51 PARTICULARLY IN THE U.S.. EVENTUALLY THE ALLOCATION WHICH
1:05:56 COULD BE DEFLATIONARY. WHEN WE LOOK AT OUR U.S.
1:06:03 COLLEAGUES, INDUSTRIES ARE ADOPTING MORE AI.
1:06:07 THEY DO SEE LABOR MARKET FOR THAT PARTICULAR INDUSTRY SOFTEN.
1:06:11 IT'S JUST A MATTER OF TIMING. CHINA IS DISINFLATIONARY.
1:06:16 DOMESTICALLY HAS ITS OWN CAUSES INCLUDING THE PROPERTY MARKET,
1:06:19 THE COMPETITION. SO LONG AND SO FORTH.
1:06:23 YVONNE: THANK YOU SO MUCH FOR JOINING US THERE.
1:06:27 HER OUTLOOK FOR 2027. LESS DRAG BUT MORE UNCERTAINTY.
1:06:31 COMING UP, NEW WORLD HERE. THE HONG KONG DEVELOPER HALTING
1:06:34 TRADING. LOOKING TO RAISE CASH TO SHORE
1:06:36 UP FINANCES. THE DETAILS, COMING UP.
1:06:39 THIS IS BLOOMBERG. ♪
1:06:57 YVONNE: SOME STORIES WE ARE TRACKING FOR YOU TODAY.
1:07:00 SPACEX AND TESLA PROGRESSING TOWARD A MERGER THAT COULD
1:07:03 REDEFINE THE LIMITS OF GLOBAL DEALMAKING.
1:07:08 ELON MUSK'S TWO LARGEST COMPANIES COULD ANNOUNCE WHAT
1:07:10 WOULD BE THE BIGGEST EVER DEAL AS SOON AS DECEMBER.
1:07:12 THE COMPANIES ARE ALSO SAID TO HAVE DISCUSSED A SCENARIO IN
1:07:16 WHICH AN ANNOUNCEMENT SLIPS INTO EARLY 2027.
1:07:20 KALSHI IN TALKS TO RAISE MORE MONEY FROM INVESTORS, VALUING
1:07:24 THE PREDICTION MARKET AT $65 BILLION.
1:07:25 THAT'S JUST WEEKS AFTER CLOSING A FUNDING ROUND AT A $40 BILLION
1:07:29 VALUATION. THE FUNDRAISING ROUND ANNOUNCED
1:07:34 IN LATE OCTOBER WAS EXPECTED TO BE THE LAST ONE BEFORE THE
1:07:38 COMPANY'S ANTICIPATED IPO. KELSEY DECIDED TO RATES MONEY
1:07:41 AGAIN IN THE PRIVATE MARKETS. BHP OVERHAULING ITS AUSTRALIAN
1:07:45 BUSINESS AS PART OF A COST-CUTTING DRIVE.
1:07:49 THE PLANE IS IN RESPONSE TO RISING EXPENSES AND SOFTER
1:07:50 PRICES FOR THE STEELMAKING INGREDIENT.
1:07:53 THEY HAVE CUT 300 ON-SITE WORKERS FROM THE DIVISION AND
1:07:57 SAID TO BE PLANNING TO REDUCE NUMBERS FURTHER, PRIMARILY FROM
1:08:01 ITS WHITE COLLAR BASE. THE COMPANY IS PREPARING JOB
1:08:04 CUTS ACROSS OTHER DIVISIONS. HONDA SAYS IT'S TOP-SELLING CRV
1:08:10 CROSSOVER MODEL WILL GO A SUPPOSEDLY HYBRID STARTING NEXT
1:08:12 YEAR. THE MOVE IS DESIGNED TO MEET
1:08:16 SURGING DEMAND FOR MORE FUEL-EFFICIENT HYBRID VEHICLES
1:08:20 DUE TO ELEVATED FUEL PRICES. IT ECHOES TOYOTAS HYBRID ONLY
1:08:24 SHIFT ON KEY MODELS ACROSS THE LINEUP.
1:08:29 WE CONTINUE TO SEE THIS BOUNCE BACK WHEN IT COMES TO THE
1:08:32 SEMICONDUCTOR SPACE. SAMSUNG, SK HYNIX, ALL DOING
1:08:38 QUITE WELL WITH THE LIKES OF SAMSUNG LEADING THE CHARGE HERE.
1:08:41 THERE'S ALSO NEWS OF THIS CHINESE CHIPMAKER SIGMA STAR
1:08:47 SAID TO PLAN A $300 MILLION HONG KONG LISTING AS WELL.
1:08:52 HERE. THE COMPANY IS BEGINNING TO MEET
1:08:58 PROSPECTIVE INVESTORS AHEAD OF THAT POTENTIAL OFFERING.
1:09:01 FLIP THE BOARD. AUSTRALIA CAR FINANCING STOCKS.
1:09:07 THEY ARE NOW FALLING HERE ON THE BACK OF THIS EV SUBSIDY ROLLBACK
1:09:11 . SO THIS IS AFTER THE ENERGY
1:09:15 MINISTER SAYS THE GOVERNMENT MAY REDO SUBSIDIES WHEN IT COMES TO
1:09:17 EV'S AT THE NEXT BUDGET. ZOOMING OUT.
1:09:23 TAKE A LOOK AT HOW MARKETS ARE DOING.
1:09:30 JAPAN, KOREA, TAIWAN. UP 2% HERE.
1:09:34 CERTAINLY WHEN IT COMES TO NVIDIA NEWS, THE JENSEN PREMIUM
1:09:39 CONTINUES TO GET ERODED IN SOME WAYS.
1:09:42 THE MARKET CAP HAS BEEN WIPED OUT.
1:09:45 WE ARE STILL SEEING QUITE A BIT OF A BIT ACROSS THE AI TRADE
1:09:46 HERE. THE FACT THAT DEMAND REMAINS
1:09:49 STRONG. ANTHROPIC GIVEN THE DEMAND
1:09:54 PICTURE FOR THE IPO NEXT WEEK. THAT'S WHAT'S KEEPING ASIA QUITE
1:09:59 STEADY HERE THIS MORNING. U.S. FUTURES ARE DOING THIS
1:10:00 RIGHT NOW. THIS IS BLOOMBERG.
1:10:12 YVONNE: 11:29 A.M. IN TOKYO. WE CONTINUE TO SEE THE RALLY
1:10:15 UNDERWAY. 1000 POINTS TO THE UPSIDE.
1:10:22 MORNING. THERE IS SOME WEAKNESS WHEN IT
1:10:27 COMES TO THE YEN. CLOSER TO 160 LEVELS ONCE AGAIN.
1:10:32 YIELDS ARE ALSO PICKING UP AS MARK RENFIELD TOLD US.
1:10:37 WE'VE OVERLOOKED THIS BUILDUP IN YIELDS THIS PAST WEEK.
1:10:41 HE SAYS THIS WEEK, IN TERMS OF TREASURY YIELDS ON THE SHORT
1:10:43 END, THEY'VE SEEN ONE OF THE BIGGEST IN YEAR -- IN THE YEAR
1:10:47 SO FAR. THAT IS SOMETHING TO CONTEND
1:10:51 WITH AGAINST OPTIMISM AROUND AI AND ANTHROPIC.
1:10:54 IN THE MEANTIME, NEW WORLD. SHARES HAVE BEEN SUSPENDED IN
1:10:58 HONG KONG PENDING SOME KIND OF ANNOUNCEMENT HERE.
1:11:02 WE ARE HEARING THAT THE PROPERTY DEVELOPER IS CONSIDERING A
1:11:05 RIGHTS ISSUE TO SHORE UP ITS FINANCES.
1:11:08 BAIN CAPITAL DECIDED AGAINST INVESTING IN THE PROPERTY
1:11:10 DEVELOPER. LET'S BRING IN OUR CONGLOMERATES
1:11:15 CONSUMER AND GAMING REPORTER WHO JOINS US NOW.
1:11:17 THEY SUSPENDED TRAINING. DO WE KNOW WHY?
1:11:21 >> SO FAR, WE HAVE NOT HEARD ABOUT THE SUSPENSION OF TRADING.
1:11:26 WE DID HEAR FROM SOURCES THAT NEW WORLD HAS BEEN WORKING WITH
1:11:28 SEVERAL BANKS ABOUT THE RIGHTS ISSUE.
1:11:33 THE SIZE IS ABOUT 3 BILLION U.S. DOLLARS.
1:11:37 THE NEW WORLD'S CONTROLLING SHAREHOLDER WILL ALSO
1:11:40 PARTICIPATE BY SUBSCRIBING TO THE SHARES IN PROPORTION TO
1:11:44 THEIR SHAREHOLDING WHICH IS ABOUT 45%.
1:11:47 WHAT WE HEARD IS THAT THE BANKS WILL DO SOME COST UNDERWRITING
1:11:55 WHICH MEANS THAT THE BANKS WILL LOOK FOR INVESTORS TO TAKE UP
1:12:01 ANY SHARES THAT ARE NOT TAKEN UP BY EXISTING SHAREHOLDERS.
1:12:05 >> TELL US ABOUT -- YVONNE: TELL US ABOUT THE POTENTIAL RIGHTS
1:12:06 ISSUE. SHIRLEY: THE RIGHTS ISSUE WILL
1:12:10 BE 3 BILLION U.S. DOLLARS. THE FAMILY WILL PARTICIPATE.
1:12:15 OTHER EXISTING SHAREHOLDERS AND MINORITY SHAREHOLDERS ARE
1:12:20 EXPECTED TO SUBSCRIBE TO THE SHARES IN PROPORTION TO THE
1:12:24 AMOUNT OF SHARES THEY OWN. THE BANKS WILL DO THE
1:12:25 UNDERWRITING. SO IF ANY EXISTING SHAREHOLDERS
1:12:32 ARE UNWILLING TO TAKE UP ANY NEW SHARES ISSUED BY NEW WORLD, THE
1:12:36 BANKS WILL FIND OTHER INVESTORS TO TAKE UP THE SHARES.
1:12:41 YVONNE: HOW IMPORTANT WITH THIS CAPITAL INJECTION BE?
1:12:44 SHIRLEY: IT'S REALLY IMPORTANT. NEW WORLD HAS BEEN INCURRING
1:12:49 LOSSES AMOUNTING TO BILLIONS OF DOLLARS OVER SEVERAL YEARS.
1:12:54 THEY HAVE BEEN TRYING TO SELL ASSETS TO SHORE UP THEIR
1:12:55 LIQUIDITY. BUT ASSET SALES PROGRESS HAS
1:12:59 BEEN VERY SLOW BECAUSE THE MARKET IS WEAK AND A LACK OF
1:13:06 INVESTOR INTEREST, THE FAMILY WOULD LET GO OF PRICING.
1:13:11 SO THEY ALSO HAVE 11 BILLION U.S. DOLLARS OF BANK DEBT.
1:13:16 THAT'S GOING TO COME DUE AS EARLY AS SOMETIME NEXT YEAR.
1:13:21 SO EARLIER, WE HEARD FROM SOURCES THAT NEW WORLD IS
1:13:26 TALKING TO THE BANKS ABOUT ROLLING OVER THIS AMOUNT OF DEBT
1:13:29 . THE BANKS HAVE ALREADY ROLLED
1:13:32 OVER THIS AMOUNT FOR ONCE. THIS TIME WHAT WE HEARD IS THAT
1:13:36 THEY WOULD WANT NEW WORLD OR THE JANG FAMILY TO INJECT CAPITAL
1:13:40 INTO THE NEW WORLD TO BOOST THEIR CONFIDENCE IN ROLLING OVER
1:13:43 THEIR DEBT. WHAT WE HEARD IS THAT RIGHTS
1:13:50 ISSUE AND BANK REFINANCING WOULD GO HAND-IN-HAND.
1:13:54 SO THIS WOULD BE AN IN SPORT -- AN IMPORTANT STEP FOR THE BANKS
1:13:57 TO ROLLOVER THE HUGE AMOUNT OF DEBT.
1:14:03 YVONNE: WE ARE STILL WAITING FOR THAT ANNOUNCEMENT FROM NEW WORLD
1:14:04 HERE TODAY. BACK TO OUR TOP STORY.
1:14:08 WE HEARD ALSO FROM PRESIDENT TRUMP WHO SAYS HE DOESN'T KNOW
1:14:13 IF IT HAS BEEN DETERMINED THAT ALICE LONG IS IN FACT A SPY.
1:14:18 WHEN ASKED IF JENSEN HUANG SHOULD'VE STEPPED DOWN.
1:14:21 TRUMP SPOKE IT IN INTERVIEW WITH STEPHEN SMITH POSTED TO HIS
1:14:23 YOUTUBE CHANNEL. >> WELL, THE BIG THING IS, WAS
1:14:30 THE WOMAN A SPY? I DON'T KNOW IF THAT HAS BEEN
1:14:33 DETERMINED YET. IF THE WOMAN WAS A SPY, YES.
1:14:39 IF THE WOMAN WAS NOT A SPY, PERHAPS IT WOULD BE DIFFERENT.
1:14:42 I COULD TELL YOU THIS. SOMEHOW, HE WILL END UP WITH IT.
1:14:50 YVONNE: EVEN WITH AN INTERIM CEO IN PLACE AT NVIDIA, JENSEN
1:14:54 HUANG'S EXIT RAISES QUESTIONS ACROSS ASIA'S SEMICONDUCTOR --
1:15:00 SEMICONDUCTOR SUPPLY CHAIN WHERE THEY RELY HEAVILY ON THE
1:15:01 CHIPMAKER FOR SALES. OUR COLUMNIST SAYS IT'S TIME TO
1:15:04 MOVE ON. IT'S NOT NVIDIA.
1:15:08 IT'S ABOUT ANTHROPIC AND ITS DEBUT NEXT WEEK, THAT WILL BE
1:15:11 THE REAL LITMUS TEST FOR THE AI TRADE.
1:15:16 WHY CAN WE PUSH THE NVIDIA CRISIS ASIDE NOW?
1:15:19 CAN WE CONTINUE TO IGNORE WHAT'S GOING ON?
1:15:23 >> AT THIS POINT, WE WOULD LIKE TO IGNORE NVIDIA.
1:15:29 THE PROBLEM WITH NVIDIA IS THAT IT IS THE CENTRAL BANK OF AI.
1:15:34 INFRASTRUCTURE BUILDING. ALSO HE HAS PROVIDED HUNDREDS OF
1:15:41 BILLIONS OF DOLLARS OF VENDOR FINANCING TO THOSE STARTUPS THAT
1:15:43 COULDN'T QUITE AFFORD IT. AS RECENTLY AS SEPTEMBER, NVIDIA
1:15:50 BACKSTOPPED A 35 BILLION COMPUTE DEAL THAT ANTHROPIC GOT IN.
1:15:58 THE QUESTION NOW IS, IF ANTHROPIC HAS COME TO THE U.S.
1:16:02 STOCK MARKET AND THE IPO GOES SMOOTHLY, THE UNICORN MAY GROW
1:16:06 UP WELL. IN A FACT THAT IT COULD AFFORD
1:16:08 ALL THESE CHIPS ON ITS OWN. YVONNE: YOU LOOK AT ANTHROPIC
1:16:14 THOUGH. WHAT IS THE MARKETS BIGGEST
1:16:16 WORRY ABOUT THIS IPO? SHULI: RIGHT NOW, THE IPO BOOK
1:16:21 ORDER IS OVERSUBSCRIBED. THE FIRST DAY OF TRADING MATTERS
1:16:24 GREATLY. ANTHROPIC CANNOT DO FOLLOW OF
1:16:32 THE EQUITY RAISING IN THE ME -- IMMEDIATE FUTURE.
1:16:36 OTHER HYPERSCALERS THIS YEAR. A LOT OF FOLLOW-UP OF EQUITY
1:16:38 SALES. TECH FIRMS DOING CONVERTIBLE
1:16:43 SALES. THEY CANNOT DO SALES.
1:16:50 YVONNE: HOW DO YOU LOOK AT SHIP DEMAND IN THE FACE OF WHAT WE
1:16:55 ARE SEEING WITH NVIDIA? SHULI: SO FAR, MARKETS ARE
1:17:00 TAKING A WAIT AND SEE APPROACH. ABOUT 25 TO 30% DOWN FROM ITS
1:17:06 JUNE HIGH. INVESTORS ARE GIVING CHIPMAKERS
1:17:11 THE BENEFIT OF THE DOUBT. THEY ARE WAITING TO ADD RISK TO
1:17:15 THE TRADE YET. YVONNE: THANK YOU.
1:17:20 BLOOMBERG OPINION COLUMNIST. MAKE SURE TO CHECK OUT HER
1:17:21 COLUMN. FORGET NVIDIA.
1:17:25 ANTHROPIC IS THE LITMUS TEST. PLENTY MORE AHEAD.
1:17:30 THIS IS BLOOMBERG. ♪
1:17:49 YVONNE: WELCOME BACK. TIME FOR OUR SPECIAL SEGMENT.
1:17:54 ETF IQ ASIA. THE CRISIS ROYALS.
1:17:59 LET'S BRING IN OUR BLOOMBERG INTELLIGENCE EXCHANGE TRADED
1:18:01 FUNDS ANALYST WHO JOINS US NOW. THERE STILL SEEMS TO BE DEFYING
1:18:05 WHEN IT COMES TO NVIDIA. WHAT DO YOU SEE WHEN IT COMES TO
1:18:08 THE ETF'S AFFECTED? >> THERE'S BEEN TREMENDOUS
1:18:11 DIVIDE. IF WE LOOK AT THE GRANITESHARES
1:18:17 TWO TIMES LEVERAGE, NVIDIA ETF, IT'S A RECORD INFLOW THIS WEEK
1:18:20 OF ROUGHLY $500 MILLION. IF WE LOOK ACROSS ALL THE FLOWS,
1:18:26 NOT JUST PASSIVE BUT ALSO ACTIVE, THE ACTIVE MANAGERS HAVE
1:18:27 INCREASED THEIR ALLOCATION THIS WEEK.
1:18:32 ALMOST 50%. THEY USE THIS AS AN OPPORTUNITY
1:18:35 TO INCREASE. CATHIE WOOD INCREASED ACROSS
1:18:39 OLIVER FUNDS. IN HER FLAGSHIP FUND, SHE ADDED
1:18:45 63 MILLION. ACROSS ALL OF THE ACTIVE
1:18:49 MANAGERS, THEY INCREASED BY 200 BILLION.
1:18:51 THAT'S A LOT OF MONEY GOING INTO IT.
1:18:53 THE ONLY ONE THAT REDUCE THE POSITION WAS BLACKROCK.
1:18:59 THEY HAD ONE FUNDER AND THEY REDUCED IT BY 1.5%.
1:19:01 THIS SHOWS YOU THE POWER OF INDEXING.
1:19:05 EVEN THOUGH NVIDIA IS DOWN, ACROSS ALL THE PASSIVE ETF'S,
1:19:11 THE FUND IS MOSTLY UP FOR THE MOST PART.
1:19:13 WE'VE SEEN A LOT OF INTEREST INTO THE STOCK AND ACROSS THE
1:19:14 TECH SECTOR AS A WHOLE. YVONNE: IT'S INTERESTING TO SEE
1:19:20 HOW RETAIL IS PILOTING THE STORY RIGHT NOW.
1:19:23 IN TERMS OF HEDGING, WHAT CAN INVESTORS DO AT THIS POINT?
1:19:29 >> THIS YEAR, THE FLAGSHIP PRODUCTS HAVE BEEN BUFFER ETF'S.
1:19:32 THEY CAP THE UPSIDE AND THE DOWNSIDE.
1:19:35 IN THIS MARKET CONDITION WHERE THERE'S A LOT OF VOLATILITY, YOU
1:19:39 DON'T GET THE DOWNSIDE OR THE UPSIDE.
1:19:40 YOU GET THE MIDDLE LAYER OF IT. IN SOME WAYS IT'S BEEN REALLY
1:19:42 GOOD FOR INVESTORS. THE THING IS ULTIMATELY, PEOPLE
1:19:59 ARE LOOKING TO GET ACCESS TO THE MARKET WITHOUT HAVING TO WORRY
1:20:02 ABOUT VOLATILITY. YVONNE: TELL US ABOUT THE LATEST
1:20:04 LAUNCHES. REBECCA: THE PREDICTION MARKET.
1:20:09 THIS IS THE NEWEST THING. A LOT OF PEOPLE HAVE FILED INTO
1:20:12 THE MARKET. YOU CAN PREDICT INTO WHO WILL BE
1:20:16 THE NEXT PRESIDENT OR INTO SPORTS COMPANIES.
1:20:20 THERE'S BEEN A LOT OF FUTURES CONTRACTS THAT HAVE BEEN CREATED
1:20:23 AROUND BEDDING. FOR INSTANCE, HOCKEY COMPANIES,
1:20:28 HOCKEY, BASEBALL, PREDICTION MARKETS.
1:20:30 THERE'S BEEN A LOT OF INFORMATION IN THE ETF SPACE.
1:20:34 FOR INSTANCE. THERE'S GOING TO BE ETF THAT
1:20:40 TRACKS ON -- TRACK FARMLAND. THERE'S ALSO PRIVATE MARKETS.
1:20:47 THAT'S BEEN A HUGE THING ESPECIALLY WITH THE ANTICIPATION
1:20:48 OF ANTHROPIC. THERE'S A LOT OF ETF THAT HAVE
1:20:52 BEEN FILED FOR PRIVATE COMPANIES.
1:20:55 A LOT OF PEOPLE WANT ACCESS TO PRIVATE MARKETS BUT THEY CAN'T.
1:20:58 THE ETF IS ULTIMATELY A GOOD RAMP INTO THAT PRODUCT.
1:21:03 FOR ETF INNOVATION THIS YEAR, WE ARE AT A RECORD NUMBER OF
1:21:04 LAUNCHES GLOBALLY. IN THE U.S., THEY WILL HAVE MORE
1:21:09 THAN 1000 NEW ETF'S THAT HAVE LAUNCHED THIS YEAR.
1:21:16 A LOT OF THE PRODUCTS BEING CREATED ACROSS THE BOARD.
1:21:22 ONE THING THAT'S INTERESTING, IRAN YEAR, EVERY WEEK THERE'S A
1:21:28 NEW AI OR SEMICONDUCTOR ETF. IT SHOWS YOU THE DEMAND WE SEE
1:21:31 FROM INVESTORS. YVONNE: STICK WITH US.
1:21:36 LET'S BRING IN OUR GUEST FROM PASADENA.
1:21:41 EMERGING CONSUMER TRENDS. I WILL TALK ABOUT YOUR LATEST
1:21:45 LAUNCHES IN A BIT. I WANT TO GET YOUR TAKE ON THE
1:21:48 NEWS. GIVEN THE FACT THAT ALL OF YOUR
1:21:51 ETF'S ARE ACTIVELY MANAGED, WHAT HAVE YOU SEEN IN TERMS OF THE
1:21:54 NVIDIA OF FACT? HOW DOES THIS IMPACT THE AI
1:21:57 BUILDUP MOVING FORWARD? >> IT'S DISAPPOINTING AND IT'S A
1:22:03 BIT OF A TRAGEDY FOR EVERYBODY INVOLVED.
1:22:07 BUT I'M NOT ENTIRELY CONVINCED WHEN WE LOOK BACK ON THIS IN
1:22:08 FIVE YEARS THAT WE WILL SAY THIS IS ABOUT.
1:22:15 -- A BAD THING. THE COMPANY HAD RECKLESSNESS AT
1:22:18 THE TOP. CLEARING THAT OUT IN THE MY BE
1:22:19 GOOD. -- IN THE END MIGHT BE GOOD.
1:22:26 YVONNE: WHAT ABOUT FLOWS? JIM: I'M SORRY, FOR US?
1:22:30 YVONNE: YEAH. JIM: WE JUST LAUNCHED OUR NEW
1:22:34 ETF TODAY. IT'S OUR FIRST PASSIVE FUND.
1:22:38 IT WAS AN EXCITING DAY HERE. VERY BUSY FOR US.
1:22:41 WE WERE QUITE PLEASED WITH THE TRADING THAT WE HAD TODAY.
1:22:46 WE ARE LOOKING FORWARD TO THIS. THIS IS AN EXCITING STORY WE'VE
1:22:47 GOT HERE. I'M SORRY?
1:22:55 REBECCA: I GUESS FROM A NEW PRODUCT LAUNCH, IT'S A VERY NICE
1:22:58 THEME. WE HAVE SEEN A LOT OF THEMES
1:23:02 ETF'S PICK UP THIS YEAR. MOST RECENTLY, CAPE COD ETF THAT
1:23:04 SHUT. WHY DID YOU PICK COSMETICS AND
1:23:08 SPECIFICALLY KOREAN COSMETICS? JIM: THE STORY IS QUITE
1:23:12 COMPELLING. AT THE TOP LINE, THERE'S 250
1:23:19 MILLION SOCIAL MEDIA MENTIONS EVERY WEEK.
1:23:24 WHEN YOU TAKE A LOOK AT IT, YOU FIND OUT THAT THERE'S A REAL
1:23:27 AMOUNT OF SUBSTANCE BENEATH THE SURFACE HERE.
1:23:30 KOREA HAS BEEN WORKING ON BUILDING THE ON FOR STRUCTURE
1:23:32 BEHIND K BEAUTY FOR OVER 30 YEARS.
1:23:35 IT'S GROWING EXTREMELY RAPIDLY. IT'S ENTERING OTHER PARTS OF THE
1:23:38 WORLD. KOREA IS NOW THE NUMBER TWO
1:23:44 EXPORTER INTO THE UNITED STATES OF COSMETICS.
1:23:47 NUMBER TWO EXPORTER OF COSMETICS WORLDWIDE.
1:23:51 IT'S ALL BECAUSE THERE'S THIS INFRASTRUCTURE THAT THE KOREANS
1:23:54 HAVE BEEN BUILDING FOR 30 YEARS. THERE'S A LOT OF EXCITEMENT FROM
1:23:58 THE PEOPLE THAT KNOW WHAT'S GOING ON.
1:24:01 THERE'S A LOT OF PEOPLE THAT DON'T KNOW WHAT'S GOING ON.
1:24:03 THAT GIVES US AN OPPORTUNITY HERE.
1:24:07 THERE'S A GREAT ONE RAY -- RUNWAY FOR THESE PRODUCTS.
1:24:11 YVONNE: AND WHERE IS THE REAL MONEY WHEN IT COMES TO BEAUTY?
1:24:16 IS IT THE BRANDS, MANUFACTURERS, THE AESTHETIC COMPANIES?
1:24:20 HOW DO YOU LOOK AT THE SPACE RIGHT NOW?
1:24:24 IS IT MORE ABOUT CHASING RAY TRAIL TRENDS?
1:24:28 -- RETAIL TRENDS? IS IT A LONG-LASTING THEME FOR
1:24:32 INVESTORS TO GET RETURNS ON? JIM: IT'S NOT JUST A TREND.
1:24:37 THE PRODUCTS ARE SAFE, EFFECTIVE.
1:24:41 THEY ARE CHEAPER. THEY DO A REAL JOB FOR A LOT OF
1:24:42 PEOPLE. TO ANSWER YOUR QUESTION, OUR
1:24:46 FUND INVESTS AN ENTIRE ECOSYSTEM.
1:24:50 MANUFACTURERS, AESTHETICS COMPANIES, THE BRANDS.
1:24:53 THE BRANDS HAVE A PROBLEM BECAUSE IT'S EASY TO ENTER THE
1:24:57 INDUSTRY AND THERE'S A COMPETITION PROBLEM.
1:24:59 IF YOU LOOK AT THE WHOLE ECOSYSTEM, THE BIGGER BRANDS,
1:25:06 THEY'VE ALL GOT A HUGE ADVANTAGE.
1:25:07 THEY ARE ABLE TO EXPLOIT THAT. THE RUNWAY GLOBALLY IS MASSIVE.
1:25:15 REBECCA: THIS MARKS YOUR SIXTH ETF.
1:25:18 THIS IS YOUR FIRST PASSIVE ETF. WHERE DO YOU SEE INVESTOR DEMAND
1:25:21 ACROSS ALL OF YOUR ETF'S? ARE YOU SEEING AN INCREASE IN
1:25:25 ACTIVE ETF'S? JIM: ACTIVE ETF'S ARE VERY
1:25:29 POPULAR. THE REASON WE DECIDED TO DO THIS
1:25:33 PASSIVE WAS BECAUSE WE DIDN'T THINK WE HAD THE EXPERTISE TO
1:25:36 MANAGE THIS WITH THE MANPOWER. WE SAID, HANG ON.
1:25:39 WE WANT TO GET THIS PRODUCT IN THE MARKETPLACE.
1:25:42 WE'VE DONE THE RESEARCH. HOW DO WE GET THIS OUT THERE?
1:25:45 WE FELT PASSIVE WAS THE WAY TO GO HERE.
1:25:51 REBECCA: IN TERMS OF YOUR CLIENT BASE, WHERE DO YOU THINK YOU
1:25:54 WILL SEE THE MOST DEMAND FOR THIS PRODUCT?
1:25:58 JIM: INITIALLY RETAIL. THE RETAIL EXCITEMENT IS QUITE
1:25:59 LARGE. I WILL GIVE YOU AN EXAMPLE.
1:26:04 OUR NUMBER ONE MOST TRAFFIC PAGE ON OUR WEBSITE IS OUR KB TY
1:26:06 PAGE. BY FAR.
1:26:11 THAT'S BEEN BUILDING FOR WEEKS. TODAY, OUR TRAFFIC WAS GREATER
1:26:15 THAN IT'S EVER BEEN. THAT'S BECAUSE PEOPLE ARE
1:26:16 EXCITED ABOUT THE STORY. YVONNE: THERE'S K-POP AND THEN
1:26:23 THERE'S BEAUTY. IS THERE ANY RISK TO THIS STORY?
1:26:32 JIM: I UNDERSTAND THE QUESTION. YOU CAN SAY ANYTHING AND FASHION
1:26:35 IS A TREND. IF YOU LOOK AT WHAT'S GOING ON
1:26:39 UNDERNEATH THE SURFACE IN THE INDUSTRY, THEY HAVE BUILT A
1:26:42 LARGE AMOUNT OF INFRASTRUCTURE. I WILL GIVE YOU AN EXAMPLE.
1:26:48 THEY PASTOR, -- COSMETICS ACT IN 1999.
1:26:51 THAT SAID YOU HAD TO HAVE SAFE AND EFFECTIVE INGREDIENTS IN
1:26:52 YOUR PRODUCTS. A WHOLE INFRASTRUCTURE BUILT
1:26:54 AROUND THAT. YOU END UP WITH SAFE AND
1:26:58 EFFECTIVE PRODUCTS THAT ARE CHEAPER THAN WHAT YOU MIGHT GET
1:27:00 FROM OTHER COSMETIC COMPANIES. THE WHOLE THING HAS TAKEN OFF I
1:27:04 REALLY ON SOCIAL MEDIA. THAT IS STARTING TO MOVE INTO
1:27:10 THE UNITED STATES. IT'S ALSO IN EUROPE, LATIN
1:27:13 AMERICA, INDIA. THIS IS A POPULAR INDUSTRY.
1:27:20 A LOT OF RUNWAY TO GO. REBECCA: IF WE LOOK TO NEXT
1:27:26 YEAR, WHERE DO YOU SEE THE NEXT WAVE OF INNOVATION GROWING?
1:27:29 WHAT DO YOU THINK WILL BE THE NEXT BIG THING?
1:27:33 JIM: I CAN'T TELL YOU THAT. WE ARE WORKING ON A NUMBER OF
1:27:36 PRODUCTS RIGHT NOW. THE QUESTION YOU ARE ASKING IS
1:27:41 HUGE. AS YOU WERE TALKING ABOUT,
1:27:45 THERE'S A LOT OF ETF'S AND REGISTRATION.
1:27:50 THERE'S 5000 RIGHT NOW, A LITTLE OVER.
1:27:52 2500 ETF'S AND REGISTRATION WHICH IS MASSIVE.
1:27:56 AS YOU POINTED OUT, A LOT OF THEM ARE BUFFER SHARES.
1:27:59 THE LEVERAGE, THE INVERSE. WE ARE TRYING TO GO IN A
1:28:02 DIFFERENT DIRECTION. WE HAVE AN ACTIVE PROCESS
1:28:05 UNDERWAY TO IDENTIFY THIS. REBECCA: ONE OF YOUR SPECIALTIES
1:28:11 IS LIMITING YOUR FUNDS TO 30 TO 40 NAMES WITHIN YOUR PORTFOLIO.
1:28:15 CAN YOU TELL US THE LOGIC BEHIND THIS AND HOW YOU SELECT THESE
1:28:17 NAMES? JIM: YES.
1:28:23 FAR ACTIVE FUND, WE TYPICALLY HAVE 30 OR 35 HOLDINGS.
1:28:27 WE TEND TO HAVE THEM BE EQUAL WEIGHT.
1:28:30 THE ACADEMIC SIDE WILL TELL YOU ONCE YOU GET ABOVE 25 STOCKS,
1:28:35 THE BENEFITS DIMINISH RAPIDLY. AND THEN HAVING EQUAL WEIGHT
1:28:41 PORTFOLIOS IS A HALLMARK OF HOW WE DO OUR PORTFOLIO
1:28:43 CONSTRUCTION. THE REASON THAT'S IMPORTANT TO
1:28:48 LITTLE BIT. IT GIVES YOU AN INTERESTING WAY
1:28:52 TO MANAGE WHAT YOU WILL BUY AND SELL.
1:28:56 IF WE HAVE A PORTFOLIO, 30 STOCKS IN THE PORTFOLIO.
1:29:02 IF YOU WANT TO PUT A STOCK IN, OUR PORTFOLIO MANAGER HAS TO
1:29:04 DECIDE WHAT HE WANTS TO TAKE OUT.
1:29:06 PUT IN A LITTLE BIT OF A GUARDRAIL IN TERMS OF HIS
1:29:08 DISCIPLINE. IT LIMITS THE RISK OF ANY SINGLE
1:29:13 STOCK. ONE OF THE THINGS WE'VE HEARD
1:29:16 FROM A LOT OF ADVISORS IS THAT THEY ARE HAPPY WITH THE WAY WE
1:29:20 MANAGE THE WEIGHT BECAUSE WE DON'T HAVE OUR PORTFOLIO
1:29:23 DOMINATED BY THE MAG 7 OR THE SUPER MEGA CAPS STOCKS.
1:29:27 YVONNE: WE HAVE TO LEAVE IT THERE BUT THANK YOU.
1:29:31 JIM ATKINSON, PRESIDENT AND CEO OF GUINNESS ATKINSON FUNDS.
1:29:38 YOU CAN TUNE INTO ETF IQ ASIA EVERY FRIDAY RIGHT HERE ON THE
1:29:40 CHINA SHOW. WE BRING YOU MORE ANALYSIS AND
1:29:44 CONVERSATIONS WITH TOP MARKET PLAYERS AND NEWS PLAYERS.
1:29:46 THIS IS BLOOMBERG. ♪
1:30:01 YVONNE: SOME STORIES WE ARE TRACKING FOR YOU TODAY.
1:30:06 THE FEDERAL RESERVE DROP THE SCHEDULE FOR OCTOBER 2027.
1:30:10 THE AGENCY SAYS IT WOULD STILL TAKE PLACE BUT WOULD NOT FEATURE
1:30:14 A POLICY DECISION. KEVIN WARSH SAID THAT THE
1:30:20 CENTRAL BANK WOULD PHASE IN A REDUCTION IN THE NUMBER OF RATES
1:30:24 SETTING MEETINGS WITH THE COAL MOVING TO SIX SESSIONS BY 2028.
1:30:28 PRESIDENT TRUMP THE U.S. DOES NOT NEED AN IRAN DEAL.
1:30:31 POSTING THAT VICE PRESIDENT JD VANCE SHOULD INSTEAD FOCUS ON
1:30:34 DOMESTIC ISSUES. THE DIRECTIVE DAMPENED HOPES OF
1:30:39 A DIPLOMATIC SOLUTION THROUGH THE ONGOING BACK CHANNEL PEACE
1:30:42 TALKS. IT COMES DAYS AFTER VANCE BLAMED
1:30:47 THE WAR FOR REPUBLICAN LOSSES. IT HIGHLIGHTS GROWING FRICTION
1:30:51 AHEAD OF A 2028 WHITE HOUSE RUN. UKRAINIAN PRESIDENT VOLODYMYR
1:30:55 ZELENSKYY SAYS PROGRESS HAS BEEN MADE DURING A MEETING WITH U.S.
1:30:58 ENVOYS STEVE WITKOFF AND JARED WISHON ARE -- CUSHMAN --
1:31:03 KUSHNER. HE INCLUDED EUROPEANS IN THE
1:31:07 NEXT ROUND OF PEACE TALKS WITH RUSSIA.
1:31:10 THE MEETING TOOK PLACE HOURS AFTER WITKOFF AND KUSHNER MET
1:31:15 PRESIDENT VLADIMIR PUTIN IN MOSCOW.
1:31:18 >> NEW MEETINGS. WE WILL DECIDE ABOUT ANY KIND OF
1:31:21 ESCALATION. SOME KIND OF CEASEFIRE.
1:31:25 SOME KIND OF THIS. I HOPE WE WILL HAVE THIS AGENDA.
1:31:31 YES. IT'S IMPORTANT.
1:31:36 YVONNE: HERE'S WHAT WE ARE WATCHING FOR NEXT WEEK AS WELL.
1:31:38 A BIG ONE. GIVEN THE WEEK THAT WAS ALREADY
1:31:42 A BIG WEEK WHEN IT COMES TO NVIDIA.
1:31:44 IT DEFINITELY HAS INFLUENCE ON WHAT HAPPENS NEXT WEEK AS WELL.
1:31:50 ASEAN, APEC SUMMIT. THAT'S WHERE PRESIDENT TRUMP AND
1:31:53 XI ARE SET TO MEET AS WELL. WILL THIS DISCUSSION ON NVIDIA
1:31:57 BE IN SOME WAYS INVOLVED OR INCLUDED IN THESE DISCUSSIONS?
1:32:02 IT WILL BE THE BIG ONE HERE TODAY.
1:32:03 OF COURSE, ANTHROPIC IS THE BIG TRADE DEBUT SET TO BE POSSIBLY
1:32:08 LATER NEXT WEEK AS WELL. OF COURSE, BEFORE THAT WE HAVE
1:32:10 TO DEAL WITH NVIDIA EARNINGS AS WELL.
1:32:16 TEMPORARY CFO WHO WILL PROBABLY BE TALKING MORE ABOUT NOT JUST
1:32:21 THE FUNDAMENTAL PICTURE BUT REALLY WHAT DOES THIS MEAN FOR
1:32:23 NVIDIA MOVING FORWARD NOW THAT JENSEN HUANG IS NOT AT THE TOP
1:32:26 OF THE HELM THERE. CERTAINLY THE GOVERNANCE ISSUES,
1:32:30 THE CHINA POLICY RISKS. IT WILL CERTAINLY BE A BIG FOCUS
1:32:32 HERE. MUCH MORE WHEN IT COMES TO
1:32:37 JENSEN HUANG AND ARE SERIOUS THE CIRCUIT WITH EMILY CHANG.
1:32:40 FILMED JUST WEEKS BEFORE HIS OUSTER.
1:32:43 SUBSCRIBERS CAN WATCH THAT IN FULL RIGHT NOW ON THE TERMINAL
1:32:47 CHANNEL. WE WILL LEAVE IT THERE.
1:32:51 MARKETS ARE SEEING A RALLY WHEN IT COMES TO ASIA WITH THE LIKES
1:32:54 OF TAIWAN. THIS AI TRADE LIVING ON HERE ON
1:32:58 THIS FRIDAY. THAT'S IT FOR US HERE ON THE
1:33:01 CHINA SHOW. HAVE A GREAT WEEKEND.
Jensen Huang Saga Tests AI Trade Ahead of Anthropic IPO full transcript
0:16 ♪ PAUL: THIS IS THE ASIA TRADE.
0:20 HAIDI: THE TOP STORIES THIS HOUR.
0:25 PAUL: WALL STREET STOCKS FALLING ON THE NVIDIA ROUTE AFTER JENSEN
0:28 HUANG WAS OUSTED AS CEO FOLLOWING REPORTS OF THREE
0:31 AFFAIRS, INCLUDING ONE WITH AN ALLEGED CHINESE FIGHT.
0:38 HAIDI: THE CFO WAS APPOINTED INTERIM CEO.
0:41 PAUL: WE WILL BE SPEAKING WITH OUR GUESTS ABOUT THE IMPACT ON
0:45 THE SECTOR FROM THE COMPUTING TO THE POTENTIAL FALLOUT ON SHIP
0:46 SUPPLY. HAIDI: MORE CAUTION ABOUND.
0:51 WHAT A WEEK IT HAS BEEN AND IT REALLY COMES DOWN TO THE IMPACT
0:57 OF WHAT IS HAPPENING WITH JENSEN HUANG, OUSTED AS WE HAD BEEN
1:01 EXPECTING OVER THE PAST 24 HOURS OR SO, WHEN THAT NEWS FIRST
1:02 BROKE. A LITTLE MORE CERTAINTY WHEN IT
1:07 COMES TO THE FUTURE FOR NVIDIA. THE LONG TIME CFO WHO HAS BEEN
1:10 WITH THE COMPANY FOR OVER A DECADE IS NOW IN PLACE AS THE
1:12 SEARCH FOR PERMANENT REPLACEMENT CONTINUES.
1:16 THIS IS THE SET UP WHEN IT COMES TO THE CAUTION WE'VE SEEN ACROSS
1:17 ASIA. CONTINUING TO WEIGH THE FALLOUT
1:21 IN THE SHORT-TERM AND THE MEDIUM-TERM, FOR WHAT IS
1:25 ARGUABLY THE WORLD'S MOST IMPORTANT COMPANY AT THE MOMENT.
1:30 EK FUTURES OFF BY 1.25%. SEEING MORE POSITIVITY WHEN IT
1:37 COMES TO THE START OF TRADING IN KOREA.
1:39 WE ARE ALSO SEEING A BROADER MACRO OUTLOOK BECAUSE AT THIS
1:41 TIME IT COMES WHEN THERE IS A LOT OF REASSESSMENT AS TO WHAT
1:48 THESE WAGES WHEN IT COMES TO TIGHTENING MIGHT LOOK LIKE.
1:53 BRACING FOR A STEPPING UP OF THE PACE FOR INTEREST RATES AND THAT
1:58 LINKS BACK TO WHAT WE ARE SEEING IN TERMS OF PRESSURE ACROSS
2:00 BROADER AI TRADING. PAUL: LONGTIME NVIDIA CHIEF
2:10 FINANCIAL OFFICER, COLETTE KRESS IS GOING TO BECOME THE INTERIM
2:15 CEO. THIS COMES UP TO THE OUSTING OF
2:19 JENSEN HUANG FOLLOWING THE ANNOUNCEMENT OF THREE AFFAIRS
2:21 INCLUDING ONE WITH A SUSPECTED SPY FOR CHINA.
2:25 LET'S GET TO MICHAEL SHEPARD FOR MORE.
2:27 I'M SURE NOT -- THAT I'M NOT ALONE IN WONDERING IF THERE ARE
2:30 ANY MORE BUT LET'S FOCUS ON THE KRESS ERA FOR NVIDIA.
2:38 IS THE SEARCH ON FOR A LONGER-TERM, FULL-TIME
2:40 REPLACEMENT? MICHAEL: THAT IS ONE OF THE KEY
2:45 QUESTIONS. WHO WILL PERMANENTLY SUCCEED
2:50 JENSEN HUANG? HE COFOUNDED THE COMPANY MORE
2:53 THAN 30 YEARS AGO AND CAME TO DEFINE IT IN SO MANY DIFFERENT
2:56 WAYS. HE DROVE THE DEVELOPMENT OF
3:00 GROUNDBREAKING AI CHIPS AND STEER THE COMPANY IN THAT
3:02 DIRECTION, MAKING IT A MARKET LEADER AND VAULTING THEM INTO
3:07 THE WORLD'S MOST VALUABLE COMPANY.
3:13 -- FOR THE INDUSTRY, FOR ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE, TRYING
3:16 TO PROSELYTIZE ITS ADOPTION ACROSS THE ECONOMY.
3:20 HE ALSO SERVED IN A WAY AS A CENTRAL BANKER FOR OTHER NVIDIA
3:22 PARTNERS. COLETTE KRESS HAS A HUGE JOB ON
3:28 HER HANDS AS SHE TAKES OVER EVEN ON AN INTERIM BASIS, JUST TO
3:31 KEEP ALL OF THAT MACHINERY RUNNING.
3:36 NOT ONLY THE PRODUCT SIDE, BUT THE FINANCIAL RELATIONSHIP SIDE.
3:40 SHE DOES HAS THE EXPERIENCE AS A CFO TO STEP IN AND BE LOOKED
3:45 UPON WITH SOME COMPETENCE BY WALL STREET BECAUSE THEY ARE
3:47 USED TO HEARING FROM HER ON THE QUARTERLY EARNING CALLS, AND SHE
3:52 KNOWS THE BOOKS FRONT AND BACK AND WOULD UNDERSTAND WHERE THE
3:55 FAULT LINES MIGHT LIE IN THOSE INVESTMENTS.
3:58 WE TALKED ABOUT CIRCULAR FINANCING, HOW SHE WOULD BE
4:02 ATTUNED TO THE RISKS AND WHATEVER ELSE MIGHT BE LYING OUT
4:05 THERE AS WE MOVE AHEAD IN THIS UNCERTAIN PERIOD.
4:11 HAIDI: IT IS INTERESTING BECAUSE IT COMES AT A TIME WHEN THERE
4:17 ARE EXISTENTIAL QUESTIONS BEING ASKED ABOUT THESE DEALS.
4:21 IS THERE A SENSE THAT A NEW ERA WITH LESS EVANGELISM WE'VE COME
4:27 TO ASSOCIATE WITH JENSEN HUANG, MIGHT COME AT THE RIGHT TIME FOR
4:29 THE INDUSTRY? MICHAEL: THAT'S ANOTHER GREAT
4:32 QUESTION. IT WILL DEPEND ON THE PERMANENT
4:38 SUCCESSOR, BUT FOR THE MOMENT WITH JENSEN SIDELINE, WE ARE NOT
4:42 GOING TO HEAR NEARLY MUCH OF THAT TALK.
4:45 THERE ARE SO MANY OF THOSE DEALS IN THE PIPELINE AND PERHAPS THE
4:49 BIGGEST ONE STARING AT US IS THE ANTHROPIC IPO.
4:54 AS PART OF A PRIVATE PLACEMENT, NVIDIA IS INVESTING 0 BILLION
4:56 IN THE FRONTIER MODEL DEVELOPER. THEY HAVE BEEN A BIG BACKER OF
5:03 OPENAI AND OTHER COMPANIES AS WELL, AND IT IS UNLIKELY THAT
5:06 THEY WOULD TRY TO PULL MONEY OR HOLD BACK FROM THAT ECOSYSTEM,
5:09 BECAUSE NVIDIA HAS BENEFITED SO MUCH FROM IT.
5:16 PAUL: JENSEN HUANG IS GOING TO TESTIFY IN FRONT OF CONGRESS AS
5:18 WELL. WHAT SORTS OF QUESTIONS MIGHT HE
5:19 FACE? MICHAEL: THE TESTIMONY WILL BE
5:25 BEHIND CLOSED DOORS AS FAR AS WE UNDERSTAND.
5:27 IT WILL BE SCHEDULED FOR NEXT WEEK, NEXT WEDNESDAY.
5:35 IT WILL BE VIDEOTAPED, AND WE EXPECT LAWMAKERS INVOLVED IN THE
5:40 TRANSCRIPT. WE WILL BE TRYING TO STAKE OUT
5:46 THE HEARING AS WELL, TO TALK TO LAWMAKERS.
5:49 THE KINDS OF QUESTIONS HE WILL BE FACING OUR IN TWO VEINS.
5:55 LAWMAKERS WANT TO KNOW ABOUT THE COMPANY'S SECURITY PROTOCOLS.
6:01 THERE HAVE BEEN MULTIPLE INVESTIGATIONS INTO THE
6:03 DIVERSION OF NVIDIA CHIPS BY SOME OF ITS PARTNERS AND BY
6:08 OTHER COMPANIES, TO CHINA, IN VIOLATION OF U.S. EXPORT
6:09 CONTROLS. ALSO, LAWMAKERS WANT TO KNOW
6:15 MORE ABOUT JENSEN HUANG'S INTERACTIONS WITH THE EXECUTIVE
6:19 FROM MEGASPEED WITH WHOM HE HAD THE AFFAIR, A WOMAN NAMED ALICE
6:23 WONG WHO IS SUSPECTED OF BEING A CHINESE SPINE.
6:27 SHE IS IN CHINA RIGHT NOW WITH THE KNOWLEDGE OF THE CHINESE
6:29 GOVERNMENT, SO THAT ADDS ANOTHER WRINKLE TO IT.
6:34 LAWMAKERS MAY ALSO ASK ABOUT HIS DEALINGS WITH THE CHINESE
6:36 GOVERNMENT AND SUPPLIERS ACROSS ASIA.
6:41 HAIDI: WE ARE WATCHING THE GEOPOLITICS BECAUSE THE MAIN
6:43 TAKEAWAY IS THIS DOES GIVE MORE AMMUNITION FOR THOSE WANTING TO
6:46 TIGHTEN EXPORT RESTRICTIONS TO CHINA ON CAPITOL HILL.
6:51 AS WE HEAD INTO THIS THIRD SUMMIT BETWEEN PRESIDENTS XI AND
6:57 A TRUMP, WHAT ARE THE BROADER IMPLICATIONS?
7:01 WE ARE HEARING IT -- WE ARE HEARING ABOUT THE SUSPECTED
7:05 CHINESE SPY, WE ARE HEARING SO MUCH IN TERMS OF POTENTIALLY
7:07 NVIDIA CHIPS BEING PROMISED TO DEEPSEEK.
7:10 THE INVESTIGATION LOOKING INTO SUPER MICRO AS WELL.
7:15 MICHAEL: WE HAVE REPORTING ON THE INVESTIGATION EXPANDING INTO
7:20 WHETHER SOME OF HER BUSINESS IS OR BUSINESS ENTITIES HAD
7:24 INTERACTIONS WITH SUPER MICRO AND PERHAPS IN A WAY THAT
7:26 INVOLVED SOME OF THE DIVERSION OF NVIDIA CHIPS TO CHINA.
7:32 ONE OF THE COFOUNDERS OF SUPER MICRO AND OTHER EXECUTIVES ARE
7:34 FACING CRIMINAL CHARGES FOR CONSPIRACY, TO SHIP NVIDIA CHIPS
7:38 TO CHINA. THERE IS A LOT TO DIGEST HERE,
7:43 AND THE WHOLE QUESTION MORE BROADLY IS GEOPOLITICAL.
7:49 YOU CAN'T IGNORE THE INTERNATIONAL IMPLICATIONS OF
7:52 WHAT IS HAPPENING RIGHT NOW WITH NVIDIA, AND THE PRESSURE THAT
7:55 PUTS ON THE MEETING BETWEEN PRESIDENT TRUMP AND XI JINPING.
8:00 AS EARLY AS MONDAY, TRUMP INDICATED HE HAD NO INTENTION OF
8:04 BRINGING THE MATTER UP, BUT IT MAY COME UP AS A MATTER OF
8:05 COURSE. EITHER DURING NEWS CONFERENCES,
8:11 WITH QUESTIONS FROM REPORTERS OR LOWER-LEVEL OFFICIALS RAISING IT
8:13 AS WELL. BUT TENSIONS ARE INCREASING,
8:19 ESPECIALLY COMING FROM CAPITOL HILL, THE SCRUTINY ON CHINA AND
8:27 THE COMPETITION WITH THE U.S., THE SCRUTINY FROM CONGRESS IS
8:29 VERY STRONG. WE WILL LIKELY SEE PASSAGE OF
8:33 SOME EXPORT CONTROL MEASURES BEFORE THE END OF THE YEAR.
8:38 THE BIPARTISAN MOMENTUM FOR THOSE AMENDMENTS ADDED TO A MUST
8:43 PEACE PASS OF LEGISLATION THAT HAS TO GO BEFORE DECEMBER.
8:47 WE WILL BE WATCHING THAT CLOSELY.
8:51 HAIDI: MICHAEL SHEPARD, WITH US. LET'S TAKE A CLOSER LOOK AT HOW
8:56 MARKETS ARE DIGESTING THIS NEWS FLOW.
9:01 THERE IS A SENSE OF HEADLINE FATIGUE, SWINGING BOTH WAYS.
9:07 THIS SORT OF RECOVERY MIGHT BE -- WE ARE SEEING SAMSUNG'S
9:11 TRADING UP PREMARKET, HYNEK'S ALSO LOOKING POSITIVE.
9:17 THERE SEEMS TO BE CAUTION BUT MORE CALM.
9:21 >> THE MARKET IS ISOLATING THIS TO NVIDIA AND THE DIRECT NVIDIA
9:22 FALLOUT. THERE IS THAT SUPPLY CHAIN FOR
9:26 SEMICONDUCTORS IS STILL VERY TIGHT.
9:29 DEMAND IS STILL VERY TIGHT. WHETHER THIS CREATES AN
9:36 OPPORTUNITY FOR SOME OF NVIDIA'S RIVALS LIKE AMD OR BROADCOM TO
9:39 STEP IN AND TAKE SOME CAPACITY AWAY, WITH POTENTIALLY JENSEN NO
9:47 LONGER THERE. SOME OF THE CHINESE COMPANIES
9:54 THAT HAVE BUSINESSES IN SOUTHEAST ASIA, WE HEARD SOME OF
10:00 THEM HAD ACCESS TO GP USE AND NOW WE MIGHT BE IN A REGIME
10:04 WHERE THAT SCRUTINY COMES ON THE TABLE AND REMOTE ACCESS TO GP
10:07 USE GETS TAKEN OFF THE CARDS. THE MARKET IS PICKING THROUGH
10:12 THE WINNERS AND LOSERS OF THIS JENSEN HUANG FALLOUT.
10:16 PAUL: IF WE CONTAIN IT TO THE NVIDIA STORY, PREVIOUS QUARTERS,
10:21 THE MARKET HAS HELD ITS BREATH WAITING FOR NVIDIA TO RELEASE
10:23 NUMBERS. IS THAT GOING TO BE THE CASE?
10:27 SUNNY: ABSOLUTELY. IT IS STILL A VERY IMPORTANT
10:28 COMPANY. RAMIFICATIONS ACROSS THE
10:37 ECOSYSTEM ARE WIDELY FELT. A YEAR AGO, JENSEN HUANG WAS IN
10:43 SOUTH KOREA HAVING DINNER AND LUNCH WITH CEOS OF COMPANIES.
10:48 NOW WE LOOK BACK AND SAY THAT WAS TO SECURE MEMORY SUPPLY AND
10:51 AGGRESSIVELY SECURE IT AS NVIDIA SAW THIS SHIP SHORTAGE COMING
10:53 THROUGH. THE COMPANY IS STILL VERY MUCH
10:59 AT THE FOREFRONT OF WHAT IS GOING ON, BUT INVESTORS ARE
11:05 LOOKING FOR CATALYSTS TO CLEAR THROUGH SOME OF THE ISSUES THAT
11:10 VIEW. THERE IS A DISCOUNT ON NVIDIA,
11:16 SO THIS IS LOOKING TOWARDS THOSE EARNINGS AS A CATALYST, PERHAPS
11:22 WHAT COULD REMOVE SOME OF THOSE GOVERNANCE DISCOUNTS.
11:26 HAIDI: THE PLAY FOR CHINA EQUITIES IS QUITE INTERESTING.
11:29 ALSO A BIT OF DOWNSIDE BECAUSE CLEARLY WE ARE CONCERNED ABOUT
11:32 EVEN TIGHTER RESTRICTIONS OF ACCESS TO U.S. TECH.
11:38 WHAT IS THE TAKE AWAY? DOES IT CHANGE THE TECH RIVALRY
11:39 STORY? SUNNY: HE WAS VERY PRO-OPEN
11:48 SOURCE. THAT IS NOW SOMETHING THAT WILL
11:50 BE DIFFICULT. BUT ALSO, THE CHINESE GOVERNMENT
12:01 IS PUSHING A MOBILIZATION EFFORT.
12:07 -- AND THE LOCALIZED CHIP ECOSYSTEM IN CHINA, MORE HONEY
12:10 -- MORE MONEY TO BE REDIRECTED TOWARDS CHIP MANUFACTURING IN
12:16 CHINA, DESIGN IN CHINA. WE KNOW THAT WITH CHINA,
12:25 DEFINITELY WITH POWER, IT IS GOING TO BE ALL OF THOSE
12:27 INNOVATIONS COMING BACK. DEEPSEEK LOOKING TO CODESIGN
12:37 WITH CHINESE CHIP COMPANIES. THAT IS A PUSH THAT IS GOING TO
12:40 HAPPEN AND ULTIMATELY IT IS GOING TO COME DOWN TO WHAT IS
12:44 THE FALLOUT FROM A NATIONAL SECURITY POINT OF VIEW, WHETHER
12:48 GPU ACCESS IS CUT OFF. PAUL: IS THE MEMORY OF THIS
12:53 GOING TO FADE PRETTY QUICKLY WHEN THAT ANTHROPIC IPO HITS?
12:59 SUNNY: THE INVESTOR BASE IS LOOKING FOR A NEW DIRECTION, SO
13:03 EITHER WAY, IT IS GOOD FOR ANTHROPIC TO BE IN THE PUBLIC
13:04 MARKET DOMAIN. THE SCRUTINY OF PUBLIC
13:09 SHAREHOLDERS AND THE OUTLOOK MOVING TOWARDS A 2027 OUTLOOK
13:11 FOR GROWTH. ANTHROPIC IS RUNNING ITS OWN
13:20 RACE AND I THINK INVESTORS ARE LOOKING TO BIFURCATE THE TRADE
13:23 WHERE IT'S NOT ALL DEPENDENT ON JENSEN HUANG AND NVIDIA AND
13:25 THERE IS MORE STOCKPICKING OPPORTUNITIES.
13:28 PAUL: BLOOMBERG'S EQUITY STRATEGIST SUNNY BANGIA, THANK
13:31 YOU. NOW WE HAVE MORE ON JENSEN
13:32 HUANG. SUBSCRIBERS CAN WATCH AN
13:38 INTERVIEW ON THE CIRCUIT WITH EMILY CHANG.
13:45 COMING UP, MORE INSIGHTS AND STRATEGIES.
13:50 PATRICK MOOREHEAD IS GOING TO DISCUSS CHANGES AT NVIDIA AND
13:53 WHY HE THINKS THEY WON'T IMPACT THE AI BUILDOUT.
14:20 ♪ >> NVIDIA PROBABLY HAS THE MOST
14:24 VALUABLE IPO ON THE PLANET. THE VISION HERE OF NVIDIA IS
14:30 GOING TO BE CALLED INTO QUESTION.
14:32 >> WE HAVE TO VIEW THIS AS A TRANSITIONAL ISSUE AND MORE
14:34 TACTICAL IN NATURE. >> IS THE AI TRADE ONE MAN OR A
14:40 COMPANY THAT IS LEADING THE CHARGE ON A RELATIVE BASIS?
14:45 >> EVENTUALLY SOMEONE CAN BRING TOGETHER ALL OF THE PARTIES.
14:49 >> I THINK THAT WE WILL MOVE FORWARD, THE ONES IN A
14:53 GENERATION INNOVATION WILL CARRY THROUGH.
14:58 HAIDI: SOME OF OUR GUESTS ACROSS BLOOMBERG, REACTING TO THE
15:04 LATEST NEWS AROUND NVIDIA AND OUTGOING CEO JENSEN HUANG.
15:09 LET'S BRING IN PATRICK MOORHEAD, FOUNDER CEO AND CHIEF ANALYST AT
15:12 MOOR INSIGHTS AND STRATEGY. THERE WAS SOME CERTAINTY, AT
15:16 LEAST IN THE INTERIM WITH THE CFO, COLETTE KRESS BEING
15:18 APPOINTED. SHE IS A STEADY HAND IN TERMS OF
15:23 HAVING BEEN WITH THIS COMPANY FOR A NUMBER OF YEARS.
15:26 DOES THIS REMOVE SOME OF THE HEADLINE RISK FOR NOW?
15:31 ASIAN MARKETS LOOKING CALM HER DESPITE THE ENORMOUS STRATEGIC
15:34 UNCERTAINTY THAT REMAINS. PATRICK: INVESTORS WERE SHOCKED
15:43 BY JENSEN LEAVING BUT COLETTE KRESS IS THE STEADY HAND WALL
15:46 STREET TRUSTS. SHE WAS THE RIGHT PICK AND SHE
15:52 IS GOING TO HAVE A LOT OF WORK ON HER HANDS, FIRST OF ALL, THE
15:58 BOARD NEEDS TO FIND A NEW CEO, SHE NEEDS TO READY THE SHIP.
16:04 THE INTERESTING PART WAS THAT WE WERE OFF BY ABOUT 13% AND ENDED
16:08 AT ABOUT 5%. THE IRONY IS NVIDIA SOLD OUT,
16:17 THE ROADMAP IS SET AND THEY ONLY QUESTION IS WHETHER IT KEEPS
16:20 INVENTING AT JENSEN'S PACE. HAIDI: THERE IS A LOT OF
16:28 UNCERTAINTY IN TERMS OF HOW LONG THE SEARCH IS.
16:30 THERE IS NO TIMELINE IN TERMS OF HOW LONG THIS WILL GO ON.
16:34 THERE ARE STILL OTHER QUESTIONS IN TERMS OF WHO HAD KNOWLEDGE OF
16:40 EVERYTHING GOING ON, WORRIES OVER GOVERNMENT AND TALENT
16:41 RETENTION AS WELL. PATRICK: FIRST SURE.
16:47 ON THE TALENT RETENTION, YOU HAVE A LOT OF THEIR NET WORTH
16:51 TIED IN WITH THE STOCK. SO THEY WANT TO STICK AROUND.
16:58 THERE ARE THOSE WHO DON'T LIKE THE UNCERTAINTY.
17:04 I'M SURE THEY WILL BE POACHED BY COMPETITORS.
17:09 IF YOU THINK ABOUT THE POTENTIAL PEOPLE THAT THEY CAN BRING IN,
17:14 NVIDIA HAS A VERY STRONG BENCH. THEY DON'T GET ON STAGE AS MUCH
17:21 AS JENSEN DID, BUT IAN BUCK LEAVES THE HYPERSCALER BUSINESS.
17:25 LOOKING EXTERNALLY, RENEE HAAS IS THE CURRENT -- CEO.
17:32 SPENT SEVEN YEARS AT NVIDIA, WORKING DIRECTLY FOR JENSEN.
17:39 YOU HAVE CHARLIE COLOSSUS, THE PRESIDENT OF BROADCOM CHIPS.
17:45 ALL STRONG CANDIDATES, BUT THE TIMING DOES MATTER.
17:48 I DO BELIEVE WE WILL CONTINUE TO SEE CHURN IN NVIDIA UNTIL THEY
17:58 GET A NEW CEO AND HAVE ONE OR TWO SUCCESSFUL QUARTERS.
18:03 WE COULD BE LOOKING AT A LOT OF CHURN, AT LEAST SIX MONTHS.
18:16 PAUL: BEFORE THIS, NVIDIA DID NOT HAVE A BOARD CHAIR AND NOW
18:17 IT DOES. WE WERE TALKING EARLIER IN THE
18:21 SHOW ABOUT THE CORPORATE GOVERNANCE DISCOUNT.
18:24 WITH ALL THE FUNDAMENTALS STILL IN PLACE, IS THE STOCK LOOKING
18:28 LIKE A LONG TERM BY RIGHT NOW? PATRICK: IF YOU ARE A GLASS
18:36 HALF-FULL ON AI, I THINK YOU WOULD HAVE TO GO TO A BUY.
18:43 INTERESTINGLY ENOUGH, MOST OF THE RISK IS NOT SHORT-TERM OR
18:48 MIDTERM, BECAUSE PEOPLE BEING SOLD OUT, AND HYPERSCALERS JUST
18:54 DON'T CHANGE THEIR MINDS ON THESE THINGS.
18:57 THE BIGGEST QUESTION THAT I HEARD EARLIER IN A SEGMENT IS
19:02 WILL THE U.S. SHUT DOWN REMOTE USE OF AI FROM CHINA, WHICH
19:07 CURRENTLY IS NOT AGAINST U.S. REGULATIONS.
19:12 BUT THE CHINA HAWKS REALLY WANT TO CLOSE THAT DOOR, TO ELIMINATE
19:21 ANY COMPANIES WHO WOULD DO THIS. THE CEO, THE WOMAN JENSEN WAS
19:33 CONNECTED WITH IN CHINA. PAUL: I'M GLAD YOU RAISED THAT.
19:40 IF THE HAWKS GET THEIR WAY IN THE U.S., WHAT DO YOU EXPECT TO
19:44 SEE IN TERMS OF IMPACT ON SUPPLY CHAINS, THAT KIND OF THING?
19:48 PATRICK: IT IS A GOOD NEWS, BAD NEWS SCENARIO.
19:54 THE INDUSTRY COULD LIKELY CONSUME ANOTHER 30% TO 40% IN
20:01 EUROPE AND WESTERN EUROPE, IN CLOUD SERVICES THAT DON'T SERVE
20:02 CHINA. I THINK WE ARE GOOD FOR ABOUT 18
20:07 MONTHS. THERE IS A REALISTIC RISK THAT
20:16 THERE MIGHT BE ENOUGH CHIPS NOW BECAUSE OF THIS BLOCKADE OVER
20:23 CERTAIN PARTS OF THE WORLD. DO WE HAVE ENOUGH DATA CENTERS
20:28 AROUND THE WORLD, TO CONSUME THOSE?
20:31 THAT IS SOMETHING THAT WE HAVEN'T RUN ANALYSIS ON JUST
20:32 YET. HAIDI: YOU'VE SPENT TIME AT AMD.
20:39 WE ARE SEEING SOME UPSIDE WHEN IT COMES TO AMD AND BROADCOM.
20:46 DO YOU SEE MEANINGFUL UPGRADES OR UPSIDE IN TERMS OF THAT
20:48 BUSINESS? THE ABILITY TO TAKE SOME
20:51 CUSTOMERS AWAY FROM NVIDIA? PATRICK: I THINK SHORT-TERM, --
21:01 IS FIRM AND DRIVE. IT IS DIFFICULT.
21:06 THESE DATA CENTERS ARE LOCKED IN FOR THE NEXT 18 MONTHS.
21:10 IT IS VERY HARD TO SWITCH. THE SUPPLY CHAIN, THE ABILITY
21:17 FOR AMD TO FLEX UP 25% WOULD BE DIFFICULT AS WELL.
21:22 NVIDIA AND JENSEN DID A MASTERFUL JOB, LOCKING IN THE
21:27 SUPPLY CHAIN, DOWN TO THE DIRT OF DATA CENTERS, TO BE ABLE TO
21:28 DO THAT. I THINK LONG, AMD, BROADCOM, IF
21:43 NVIDIA DOESN'T GET A LEADER SOON, WHO CANNOT ALWAYS BE THE
21:49 VISIONARY OF THE INDUSTRY, BUT ALSO ONE THING THAT IS NOT
21:56 TALKED ABOUT A LOT IS THE BATTLEFIELD DECISIONS THAT
21:58 JENSEN MAKES ON A DAILY BASIS. I SPOKE WITH THE CEOS OF SOME OF
22:04 NVIDIA'S LARGEST CUSTOMERS THIS WEEK.
22:08 WE TALKED ABOUT WHO WILL MAKE THESE DECISIONS, WHEN WE USED TO
22:13 SIT AT THE TABLE AND JENSEN WOULD MOVE AROUND SUPPLY, GIVE
22:19 US WHAT WE WANTED, OR JUST TOLD US FLAT OUT THAT'S NOT GOING TO
22:24 HAPPEN, WOULD MAKE SOME CALLS AND STUFF WOULD HAPPEN QUICKLY.
22:28 THAT'S GOING TO BE VERY HARD TO REPLACE, AND IT HAS TO BE ONE OF
22:32 COLLETT KRESS'S NUMBER ONE THINGS THAT SHE IS GOING TO HAVE
22:35 TO FIGURE OUT. WHAT I CALL, WHAT IS THE NEW
22:42 OPERATING SYSTEM OF THE COMPANY? IF JENSEN'S OPERATING SYSTEM WAS
22:46 COMMAND AND CONTROL WITH VISION. PAUL: WE ARE OUT OF TIME
22:52 UNFORTUNATELY. BUT THANK YOU SO MUCH FOR
22:53 JOINING US TODAY. THAT IS PATRICK MOORHEAD,
22:58 FOUNDER AND CEO AT MOOR INSIGHTS AND STRATEGY.
23:03 LATER ON TODAY, WE WILL LOOK AT THE IMPACT OF JENSEN HUANG'S
23:06 OUSTING ON THE EUROPEAN TECH ECOSYSTEM AT THE TIMES ON YOUR
23:19 ♪ PAUL: THE LATEST FROM THE
23:22 CORPORATE FRONT. SPACEX AND TESLA IN TALKS TO
23:28 MERGER THAT COULD REDEFINE THE LIMITS OF GLOBAL DEALMAKING.
23:32 THE MERGER OF ELON MUSK'S TWO COMPANIES COULD ANNOUNCE THE
23:34 BIGGEST EVER DEAL COME DECEMBER. KALSHI IS SET TO RAISE MORE
23:46 MONEY FROM INVESTORS, VALUING THE PREDICTION MARKET AT $650
23:57 BILLION -- THIS IS BLOOMBERG. ♪
24:44 HAIDI: WE CONTINUE AS WE HEAD INTO THIS WEEKEND TO REALLY TRY
24:49 AND DISSECT THE IMPLICATIONS OF JENSEN HUANG'S OUSTER.
24:53 I GUESS ON THE POSITIVE SIDE, THERE IS SOME CERTAINTY.
24:55 HE IS OUT. THE CFO COLETTE KRESS HAS BEEN
25:00 APPOINTED INTERIM CEO. SHE HAS OVER A DECADE
25:02 EXPERIENCE. A STEADY HAND DOES SEEM TO BE
25:07 HELPING THE SUM OF 20 COMES TO CHIPMAKERS OVERNIGHT.
25:10 IT WAS NOT QUITE AS BAD, WE ARE ON TRACK FOR THE FIRST WEEKLY
25:13 GAIN IN ABOUT SIX WEEKS, PLAYING THROUGH WHEN IT COMES TO THE
25:17 FUTURES PICTURE HERE INTO ASIA. THE LIKES OF SK HYNIX, SAMSUNG
25:22 WITH CAUTION. PAUL: THE BROADER STORY SEEMS TO
25:27 CASE. WE MAY NOT HAVE THE INFORMATION
25:35 REPORTING THAT THE WOMAN THAT COULD POTENTIAL BELIEVED TO BE,
25:38 WE DON'T KNOW, TO BE A CHINESE SPY.
25:47 SO THE STORY IS STILL EVOLVING. WE HAVE TO REMEMBER THERE ARE
25:48 OTHER THINGS HAPPENING AS WELL. [LAUGHTER]
25:52 NOT THE LEAST OF WHICH THE OIL PRICE TICKING UP AGAIN.
25:59 LET'S TAKE A LOOK AT HOW OTHER ASSETS ARE PERFORMING.
26:03 LET'S LOOK AT THE KOSPI FUTURES, PUTTING ALL THIS BEHIND THEM A
26:06 LITTLE BIT, BUT ARE BY THREE QUARTERS OF 1%.
26:10 NIKKEI FUTURES OUT OF SINGAPORE HIGHER BY 1%.
26:12 THIS DOES SORT OF DOVETAIL WITH WHAT WE SEE, THE MARKET PREPARED
26:17 TO CONSIDER THIS NVIDIA STORY IN ISOLATION AND THE BROADER AI
26:20 THEME HOLDING TOGETHER. HAIDI: IT DOES SEEM TO BE WHEN
26:26 YOU TAKE A LOOK AT THE FUNDAMENTAL OUTLOOK IN TERMS OF
26:29 NVIDIA'S BUSINESS, IT DOES NOT SEEM TO HAVE A HUGE IMPLICATION.
26:32 IT IS A QUESTION OF HER LONGER-TERM STRATEGY.
26:37 THERE'S ALSO A GEOPOLITICAL ELEMENT.
26:38 JENSEN HUANG'S EXIT DEEPLY COMPLICATING THE COMPANY WHEN IT
26:44 COMES TO U.S.-CHINA TIES, HE WAS INFLUENTIAL PUSHING THE EAST TO
26:49 WEST SHIP -- CHIP CHAIN. WE SEE THIS DEBATE REALLY
26:56 HEATING UP WITH AN CAPITOL HILL IN TERMS OF ADDING MORE
26:59 INCENTIVE FOR THOSE WHO WANT EVEN TIGHTER ACCESS RESTRICTIONS
27:03 IN TERMS OF SHIPMENTS TO CHINA. AT THE SAME TIME, WE ARE ALSO
27:10 ASSUMING THIS THROWS UP CHALLENGES AND OPPORTUNITIES ON
27:11 THE CHINESE SIDE AS WELL. WHAT DO YOU THINK ARE THE
27:15 BROADER IMPLICATIONS IN TERMS OF JENSEN HUANG BEING REMOVED FROM
27:18 THAT TOP AIE EVANGELIST RULE? REPORTER: I THINK UNDER JENSEN,
27:26 NVIDIA WAS A COMPANY, ESPECIALLY IN THE POST BIDEN TECH COLD WAR
27:31 STAGE, HE WAS CAPABLE OF OPERATING ACROSS THAT DIVIDE.
27:35 HE HAD, ESPECIALLY UNDER THE TRUMP ADMINISTRATION, LOTS OF
27:40 RELATIONSHIPS IN WASHINGTON, HE WAS A FREQUENT VISITOR TO CHINA.
27:44 CERTAINLY THE CASE THAT NVIDIA WOULD REMAIN ENGAGED EVEN WITH
27:47 THE TECH RELATIONSHIP DETERIORATING.
27:49 HE WAS A BRIDGING EFFECT. WITHOUT HIM BY THINK NVIDIA
27:52 BECOMES EXPOSED TO GOVERNMENT POLICY ON BOTH SIDES.
27:55 YOU LOSE A FOUNDER WHO COULD DIRECTLY TO LEADERS ESPECIALLY
27:59 ON THE U.S. SIDE WHAT WAS AND WAS NOT A WISE COMPANY POLICY
28:02 AND CREDIBILITY IN CHINA AS WELL.
28:07 NVIDIA MAY TAKE ON A MORE PASSIVE ROLE IN THIS SITUATION.
28:11 PAUL: THIS IS SOMETHING WE TOUCHED ON WITH OUR PREVIOUS
28:14 GUEST A FEW MINUTES AGO. WHAT WILL THIS POTENTIALLY MEAN
28:18 FOR THE U.S.-CHINA AI RACE? DOES THIS MEAN CHINA HAWKS IN
28:23 THE U.S. ADMINISTRATION HAVE A STRONGER HAND TO PLAY NOW?
28:28 REPORTER: ABSOLUTELY. IT IS TWO-SIDED IN TERMS OF THE
28:31 SLOWDOWN. ON THE U.S. SIDE, THE IDEA IS
28:34 BECAUSE JENSEN HUANG IS SO INSTRUMENTAL TO NVIDIA AND WAS
28:38 PUSHING THE FRONTIER OF AMERICAN HARDWARE IN TERMS OF QUALITY AND
28:41 QUANTITY AND GETTING THEIR SHIPS THE U.S. NEEDS FOR COMPUTER,
28:47 THIS MAY MEAN THE U.S. WILL RUN SLOWER IN THE MEDIUM TO
28:48 LONG-TERM. BUT IN CHINA IS WHERE THE POLICY
28:51 EFFECT COMES THROUGH. POTENTIALLY THEY LOSE ACCESS TO
28:55 A VARIETY OF DIFFERENT AVENUES THROUGH WHICH THEY ARE GETTING
29:00 EXISTING COMPUTE. WITHOUT JENSEN HUANG BEING IN
29:04 D.C., THE PUSH AGAINST THEM AS ONE OF THE MOST PROMINENT
29:07 ADVOCATES COME UP WITH CURRENT TIMING AND DEMOCRATS COMING INTO
29:10 POWER, WITH CONGRESS ABOUT TO DEBATE A MUST PASS DEFENSE BILL,
29:16 THE OUTCOME FOR NVIDIA COULD BE QUITE DAMAGING.
29:22 HAIDI: WHEN IT COMES TO A PARTICULAR THE CHIP POLICY
29:25 TOWARDS CHINA, DO YOU SEE THAT CHANGING AT ALL?
29:29 IT ALREADY IS QUITE RESTRICTIVE. COULD WE SEE PARTICULARLY AFTER
29:32 THE LAME-DUCK SESSION OF CONGRESS THAT WE SEE EVEN MORE
29:36 IMPETUS TOWARDS THAT? DOES IT FEED THROUGH TO THE
29:41 BROADER AI BACKLASH STORY THAT WE HAVE SEEN WITH THE PAST
29:42 MIDTERMS, TOO? REPORTER: I THINK WHERE THE
29:50 DIFFERENCE CAN REALLY COME IS THAT THE VARIOUS POLICIES THAT
29:53 ARE CURRENTLY UNDER CONSIDERATION, NOT ALL OF THEM
29:56 HAVE THE SAME VIABILITY OF BEING PASSED.
29:58 SOMETHING LIKE THEY ARE A OVERWATCH ACT POTENTIALLY MORE
30:03 VIABLE BUT OTHER THINGS LIKE THE MATCH ACT, REMOTE ACCESS,
30:05 SOMETHING NVIDIA HAS FOUGHT MORE STRONGLY AGAINST AND THAT CHINA
30:09 IS MORE SENSITIVE TO, WITHOUT THAT INFLUENCE FROM JENSEN HUANG
30:16 AND NVIDIA, IT IS EASIER FOR THE MORE AGGRESSIVE MEASURES TO PASS
30:17 THROUGH. BEFORE EXPORT CONTROL BILLS AND
30:21 AVENUES PEOPLE CONSIDER ARE NOT ALL THE SAME.
30:24 SOME OF THE RESIDENT HAWKISH ONES WITH THE CHANGE THIS WEEK
30:26 ARE NOW MORE VIABLE. PAUL: PRESIDENTS TRUMP AND
30:32 PRESIDENT XI ARE GOING TO MEET NEXT MONTH THAT THE APEC SUMMIT.
30:37 WHAT ARE THE IMPLICATIONS ON THAT MEETING?
30:41 REPORTER: I THINK THE ATMOSPHERE AROUND TECHNOLOGY WILL LIKELY
30:44 BECOME MUCH MORE CHALLENGING NOW.
30:46 WE HAD AN EQUILIBRIUM. THE U.S. WOULD HOLD BACK FROM
30:48 TECH LEVERAGE. CHINA WOULD HOLD BACK FROM
30:51 CRITICAL MINERAL LEVERAGE. THE ISSUE IS CHINA KNOWS
30:55 WASHINGTON CANNOT NECESSARILY HOLD TO HIS COMMITMENTS WITH THE
30:59 TRUMP ADMINISTRATION AND CONGRESS POTENTIALLY GOING
31:01 AROUND THE TRUMP ADMINISTRATION. EVEN IF THE LEADERS CAN TRY TO
31:05 PRESERVE THE STATUS QUO, I WOULD EXPECT IT TO BECOME
31:08 PROGRESSIVELY HARDER. ANY SUBSEQUENT TWO TO THREE
31:10 MONTH MEETING WE TRIED TO PRESERVE THIS.
31:14 SO THE OUTLOOK IS QUITE CHALLENGING.
31:19 PAUL: BLOOMBERG GEOECONOMICS TECHNOLOGY ANALYST MICHAEL DENG.
31:22 LET'S GET A LOOK AT HOW MARKETS ACROSS ASIA ARE SET TO OPEN.
31:25 WE ARE JOINED BY GARFIELD REYNOLDS LEADS BLOOMBERG'S MLIV
31:28 ASIA COVERAGE. WE OBVIOUSLY HAVE TO START WITH
31:32 NVIDIA. IT LOOKS AS IF THE MARKET IS
31:35 PREPARED TO SET THIS ASIDE. HOW MUCH OF A CATALYST WILL IT
31:36 BE TODAY? >> ONE THING TO KNOW IS FROM AN
31:44 ASIAN INVESTOR POINT OF VIEW, POST MARKET TRADING YESTERDAY,
31:49 NVIDIA WAS DOWN AROUND 100 58 AND FINISHED OFF AROUND 9:00
31:52 A.M. SINGAPORE TIME. TO SEE NVIDIA AT 166 AFTER IT
32:00 GOT AS LOW AS 148, THAT IS SOMETHING OF A WIN.
32:06 THAT UNDERSCORES THE IDEA THAT ONCE YOU GET JENSEN HUANG OUT OF
32:13 THERE AND REMOVE THE IMMEDIATE STORE POINT, NVIDIA IS STILL
32:17 THAT. FROM ASIAN INVESTOR POINT OF
32:23 VIEW, IT IS KIND OF A PLUS. PERHAPS EVEN A PARTICULAR PLUS
32:27 FOR COMPANIES HERE, BECAUSE THERE IS THE POTENTIAL THAT IT
32:31 STRENGTHENS CHINA'S ROLE IN AI AND COMPANIES LIKE TSMC ARE FAR
32:39 MORE HOOKED INTO NVIDIA AND THE U.S.-AI TRADE.
32:45 BUT FOR A LOT OF OTHER ASIAN COMPANIES, IT DOESN'T MATTER ALL
32:46 THAT MUCH FROM THEIR POINT OF VIEW THE EXTENT TO WHICH ITS THE
32:52 U.S. OR CHINA DRIVING AI. THE QUESTION IS, IS THE DEMAND
32:55 FOR THEIR PRODUCTS? ARE THEY GOING TO MAKE PLENTY OF
32:57 MONEY? YOU COULD SEE SOMETHING OF A
33:02 PIVOT TOWARDS ASIA AS BEING SHIELDED SOMEONE FROM CONCERNS
33:06 ABOUT POTENTIAL NVIDIA FALLOUT IN THE CIRCULAR FINANCING DEALS
33:11 AND WHAT MIGHT GO ON WITH AS YOUR PREVIOUS GUEST WAS
33:15 MENTIONING, WHAT MIGHT GO ON AFTER THE BLUE SWEEP WHEN IT
33:18 COMES TO INCREASED AI REGULATION IN THE U.S.
33:22 HAIDI: THAT CHINA QUESTION IS REALLY INTERESTING.
33:24 ALIBABA DROPPING 7%. THERE'S A LOT OF EXCESS NOW.
33:33 -- SOME OF THE CHIPMAKERS AS WELL IN THE SAME VEIN,
33:35 POTENTIALLY THE COMPETITION GOT A LITTLE BIT MORE INTERESTING.
33:40 WHAT IS THE BROADER UPTAKE HERE? REPORTER: THE BROAD UPTAKE
33:45 ULTIMATELY IS THAT INVESTORS, IF YOU LOOK AT WHAT IS GOING ON
33:48 WITH ANTHROPIC AND APPARENTLY STRONG DEMAND FOR THAT,
33:52 INVESTORS ARE NOT IN ANY WAY CALLING TIME ON THE AI THEME OR
33:57 THE AI BOOM. SURE, NVIDIA INCREASES SOME OF
34:03 THE CHALLENGES, SOME OF THE NERVES OUT THERE, BUT THERE IS
34:08 STILL A STRONG EXPECTATION THAT PROFITS WILL KEEP GROWING.
34:12 WE HAD THIS VERY INTERESTING REPORTING SEASON OUT OF THE U.S.
34:16 WHERE OVERALL, EARNINGS GROWTH WAS VERY GOOD, BUT EACH TIME ONE
34:20 OF THE BIG AI PLAYERS REPORTED, THEY DISAPPOINTED IN SOME WAY OR
34:24 ANOTHER AND THE OVERALL SHARE MARKET WENT DOWN.
34:26 WE ARE BEGINNING TO COME BACK OUT FROM THAT WHEN THE NVIDIA
34:32 TURMOIL HIT. IF THAT TURMOIL PASSES AND IF
34:36 THE ANTHROPIC IPO GOES OFF SMOOTHLY, INCLUDING AT NOT SUCH
34:44 A BIG MONEY SUCK AS WAS POTENTIALLY HAPPENING EVEN A FEW
34:47 WEEKS AGO, THAN A OF THAT SETS YOU UP FOR A CALMER, MORE
34:53 GRADUAL UPSIDE. THERE'S A LOT OF FEELING AROUND
35:02 ASIA YESTERDAY THAT THERE IS A DIP BUYING OPPORTUNITY HERE IF
35:06 YOU ARE BRAVE ENOUGH TO TAKE IT THAT WILL BE WORTH PURSUING.
35:09 PAUL: I HAVE A FEELING THAT IF NONE OF THIS HAD HAPPENED, WE
35:13 MIGHT SPEND MORE TIME THIS MORNING TALKING ABOUT RISING
35:16 YIELDS, A MORE HAWKISH FED. IS THERE A MACRO HERE THAT WE
35:19 ARE IGNORING? REPORTER: YES AND NO.
35:26 PART OF WHAT MAKES IT EASIER FOR EQUITY INVESTORS TO POTENTIALLY
35:28 LOOK PAST THAT EXTRAORDINARY MOVE IN YIELDS IS THAT YIELDS
35:32 HAD COME DOWN A LOT AND SO THAT STOCKS.
35:35 SO THE VALUATIONS PICTURE IS LESS CHALLENGED THAN IT WAS A
35:38 FEW WEEKS AGO WHEN YIELDS WERE SIGNIFICANTLY HIGHER AND
35:42 EQUITIES WERE ROLLING OVER TO SOME EXTENT AS A RESULT.
35:44 WE ARE NOT THERE YET. BUT WE ARE IN A SITUATION WHERE
35:53 THE FED IS DEFINITIVELY SAYING HIKING, THAT WILL TAKE THE BOJ
35:55 WITH IT. IT IS ALSO GOING TO SPREAD A LOT
35:58 OF PAIN THROUGHOUT ASIA VIA THE CURRENCY MECHANISM.
36:02 BANK OF INDONESIA FOR EXAMPLE NEXT WEEK IS DUE TO MEET ABOUT
36:07 INTEREST RATES. IT HELD LAST TIME.
36:10 IT'S HARD TO SEE HOW IT HOLDS THIS TIME AROUND.
36:12 IT WILL HAVE TO HIKE AT LEAST 25 BASIS POINTS AND GO ON
36:15 INTERVENING. HOW IS THE RBIS GOING TO COPE?
36:21 MEANTIME, THE RBA IS SEEN TO SOME EXTENT WILLING TO SAY WE
36:23 ARE DONE WITH RATE HIKES. BUT IF THE AUSTRALIAN DOLLAR
36:28 KEEPS FALLING, THEY WILL HAVE TO AT LEAST UP THEIR RHETORIC ON
36:29 THE HAWKISH SIDE. BECAUSE OF THE SIGNIFICANTLY
36:35 WEAKER AUSTRALIAN DOLLAR WILL HELP TO REVIVE INFLATION JUST
36:37 WHEN THERE MIGHT BE SOME FEELING THAT THEY'VE DONE ENOUGH ON THE
36:40 RATE HIKE FRONT TO BRING IT DOWN.
36:43 THOSE CHALLENGES ARE OUT THERE FOR ALL ASSETS WHEN YOU'VE GOT A
36:49 FED THAT HAS DUMPED AND PUMPED SO TO SPEAK.
36:54 WE HAD THE PULLING BACK FROM RATE HIKES AS WE WENT INTO THE
36:58 ELECTIONS AND THE FEELING THAT PERHAPS THEY HAD DONE ENOUGH.
37:02 THE DATA SINCE AS SHOWN THE U.S. ECONOMY IS ROARING AHEAD.
37:06 IF THEY DON'T HIKE RAPIDLY, THEY WILL RUN THE ECONOMY TO A HALT.
37:15 COVERAGE. AS WE LOOK AT THE FINAL TRADING,
37:19 A LOT FOR INVESTORS TO BE CONTENDING WITH WHAT WE DO HAVE
37:21 A LOT MORE AHEAD HERE ON THE ASIA TRADE.
37:23 THIS IS BLOOMBERG. ♪
37:47 PAUL: LET'S TAKE A LOOK AT HOW THE ASSETS IN JAPAN ARE.
37:52 THE END DID BREAK THROUGH 160 FOR A LITTLE WHILE.
37:58 NIKKEI FUTURES POINTING TO A BRIGHT OPEN AS WE'VE BEEN
37:59 DISCUSSING. IT LOOKS LIKE THE MARKETS ARE
38:02 WILLING TO LOOK THROUGH THE DRAMA AT NVIDIA.
38:07 WE WERE SPEAKING TO GARFIELD A LITTLE MORE MOMENT AGO.
38:14 WE HAVE HEARD FROM A COUPLE OF HAWKISH FED SPEAKERS OVER THE
38:18 PAST 24 HOURS, BUT THAT WAS SOMEWHAT DROWNED OUT BY OTHER
38:19 NEWS. LET'S TALK ABOUT JAPAN'S TOP
38:22 BANKS, SET TO REPORT EARNINGS LATER.
38:28 THEY ALL LOOK SET TO REAP THE BENEFITS OF THE BANK OF JAPAN'S
38:30 FASTEST POLICY NORMALIZATION IN DECADES.
38:33 MARKETS PRICING IN A THIRD HIKE LATER THIS YEAR.
38:38 JOINING US NOW IS JAPAN FINANCIALS AND FINTECH
38:45 RESEARCHER AT GOLDMAN SACHS. WE EXPECT A PRETTY SOLID SET OF
38:48 NUMBERS FROM THE BANKS ONLY GET THEM LATER THIS MORNING BUT --
38:54 BEING FLATTENED BY BANK OF JAPAN TIGHTENING.
39:00 MAKOTO: THANKS SO MUCH. JAPANESE YIELDS CONTINUE TO BE
39:04 IN A BRIGHT SPOT. TO WHAT EXTENT DOES THE BOJ RATE
39:13 CYCLE COME THROUGH ON THIS EARNING REPORT?
39:15 THAT WILL BE A FOCUS. WE EXPECT THE INTEREST TO BE 10%
39:23 TO 20% YEAR-OVER-YEAR. PAUL: HOW DO YOU SEE LOAD DEMAND
39:35 DEVELOPING WITH COMPARATIVELY HIGHER RATES IN JAPAN?
39:40 MAKOTO: LOAN DEMAND CONTINUES TO BE HIGH.
39:43 IT IS HISTORICALLY HIGH. IT CONTINUES TO TREND 5% TO 6%
39:53 YEAR-OVER-YEAR. WE EXPECT A CONTINUATION FROM
40:03 ABOUT 8% OVERALL, MAYBE 9% TO 10% ON THE MAJOR LARGE
40:07 CORPORATE'S. LOAN DEMAND IS COMING FROM
40:12 VARIOUS SOURCES. TO BE FAIR, IT IS DRIVEN BY
40:15 THINGS LIKE M&A FINANCE. WE ARE IN AN AREA -- WE ARE IN
40:21 AN ERA OF CORPORATE GOVERNANCE REFORM, WHERE COMPANIES ARE
40:24 ENCOURAGED TO INVEST IN GROWTH, AND THAT HAS DRIVEN THE CYCLE,
40:29 INCLUDING M&A AND INVESTMENTS. THAT IS LIKELY A CONTRIBUTING
40:35 FACTOR, BUT ALSO THINGS LIKE INFLATION.
40:40 WE HAVEN'T YET HAD A DRIVEN LOAN GROWTH, BUT THAT MIGHT BE NEXT.
40:52 HAIDI: TELL US MORE IN TERMS OF THE OUTLOOK AS TO WHEN WE ARE
40:55 GOING TO SEE SOME OF THESE INFLATION PRESSURES AND THE DATA
40:59 POINTS, THE BOJ IS CLEARLY FOCUSING ON.
41:03 MAKOTO: YES. CERTAINLY THESE RESULTS WILL
41:12 LIKELY REFLECT THE TAILWINDS FROM LOAN GROWTH AS WELL AS DIO
41:16 -- AS WELL AS BOJ POLICY RATE RISING.
41:20 THAT IS NOT TO MENTION THE DECEMBER MEETING COMING UP.
41:26 HAIDI: WHAT ABOUT THE AI THEME? WHERE DO YOU EXPECT TO SEE THAT
41:30 PLAY OUT, GIVEN THAT A NUMBER OF GLOBAL BANKS HAVE SEEN THAT
41:33 IMPACT MORE BROADLY. MAKOTO: I WILL BE HONEST WITH
41:40 YOU. JAPANESE BANKS HAVE NOT BEEN THE
41:48 MOST FOREFRONT, IN TERMS OF INVESTMENT IN THE LAST DECADE.
41:51 THAT IS BEGINNING TO CHANGE, ESPECIALLY IN THE FACE OF THIS
41:54 POTENTIAL AI DRIVER. THE BANKS HAVE NOT GIVEN A
42:02 QUANTITATIVE IMPACT ON THE AI OPTION, BUT WE DO THINK THAT IT
42:06 HELPS IN AREAS LIKE COST TO INCOME RATIO CONTROL.
42:11 TOPLINE GROWTH WITH LOANS. WE WOULD ALSO LIKE TO SEE
42:17 POTENTIAL INVESTMENT INTO KEEPING THE COST CONTAINED SO
42:23 THAT MORE OF THE TOPLINE GROWTH GOES TO THE BOTTOM LINE.
42:31 PAUL: LOOKING AT THE ONE-YEAR CHART OF THESE BANKS, IMPRESSIVE
42:33 NUMBERS. UP BY MULTIPLES, 40%, 50%.
42:40 WITH SUCH SOLID PERFORMANCE, WHAT DO YOU ANTICIPATE IN TERMS
42:43 OF RETURNS TO SHAREHOLDERS? MAKOTO: THE SECTOR HAS
42:55 OUTPERFORMED, BUT THE VALUATION IS MORE ATTRACTIVE.
43:00 I THINK THAT OFFERS AN ADDITIONAL --.
43:07 MOREOVER, WE DO EXPECT THE UPWARD REVISIONS TO ALSO
43:11 CONTRIBUTE IN THE FORM OF DIVIDEND HIKES OR BUYBACKS.
43:19 WE EXPECT THAT IN THE SECOND HALF.
43:26 HAIDI: MAKOTO KURODA, JAPAN FINANCIALS AND FINTECH SECTOR
43:27 ANALYST AT GOLDMAN SACHS. COMING UP, WE TAKE A LOOK AT
43:31 SECOND-QUARTER EARNINGS. ARTHUR LANGE JOINS US WITH
43:37 EXPANSION PLANS. THIS IS BLOOMBERG.
43:59 ♪ >> FOR ME, I WAS VERY
44:02 COMFORTABLE WITH THE SEPTEMBER RATE INCREASE.
44:06 I THINK THAT IS APPROPRIATE AND WITH MY BIAS THAT MORE
44:09 TIGHTENING WILL BE NEEDED. PAUL: SAN FRANCISCO FED
44:19 PRESIDENT MARY DALY, SPEAKING THERE.
44:23 UPON FUTURES WE ARE TRACKING. WE DID SEE YIELD TICKING UP.
44:28 IN THE U.S. WE HAVE HAD HAWKISH FED SPEAK.
44:33 AUSTAN GOOLSBEE ALSO MENTIONED THE U.S. IS INCHING INTO
44:37 TERRITORY THAT IS A TOUGH SPOT TO GET RID OF INFLATION.
44:40 AUSTRALIAN YIELDS TICKING HIGHER AS WELL.
44:45 ANDREW IRVINE HAS BEEN TALKING TO A PARLIAMENTARY COMMITTEE
44:50 SAYING THE AUSTRALIAN ECONOMY WILL BE MORE CHALLENGED NEXT
44:51 YEAR AND HE DOESN'T EXPECT NEXT YEAR TO BE A SIGNIFICANTLY
44:55 PROFITABLE YEAR FOR THE BANKS. LET'S TAKE A LOOK AT WHAT IS
45:00 HAPPENING AROUND THE COMMODITIES SPACE AS WELL.
45:03 A MODEST TICK UP THE OIL PRICE. WE ALSO HEARD FROM PRESIDENT
45:10 TRUMP WITH REGARDS TO IRAN, SAYING I COULD END IT
45:13 IMMEDIATELY BUT AT THE REQUEST OF THE NATIONS I'M LOOKING TO
45:15 PROTECT, WE ARE DOING IT THE LONGER WAY AND A BIT MORE
45:18 CIVILLY. OIL PRICES TICKING UP AGAIN.
45:24 THE PRESIDENT SAID EARLIER THAT HE FEELS HE DOESN'T NEED A DEAL
45:26 WITH IRAN. ENERGY PRICES FEELING A LITTLE
45:31 BIT OF PRESSURE. HAIDI: THE BROADER FX SPACE AS
45:34 WELL. THE SHIFTING OF FED EXPECTATIONS
45:43 IS IN PLAY, THE YEN FALLING TO THAT 160 LEVEL AS WELL, RAISING
45:46 THE POSSIBILITY OF INTERVENTION. THAT IS THE KEY THRESHOLD WE ARE
45:49 WATCHING. POLICY MAKERS COMING IN TO TOKYO
45:56 TO DEFEND THE CURRENCY. WE DID SEE THE CURRENCY MINISTER
46:00 SAY THE MOVES WE SEEN OVER THE PAST FEW DAYS HAVE BEEN QUOTE,
46:02 TOO FAST. A REMINDER OF THAT INTERVENTION
46:05 A FEW MONTHS AGO. 160 COULD TEST THAT TOLERANCE.
46:14 ALSO WATCHING THE CONTINUED REPERCUSSIONS OF THE NVIDIA
46:15 STORY. IT DOES SEEM CALM HER NOW THAT
46:23 WE HAVE THAT INTERIM CAO BEING -- INTERIM CEO BEING APPOINTED
46:27 WHILE THEY LOOK FOR A PERMANENT SOLUTION AFTER JENSEN HUANG WAS
46:28 OUSTED. THE FACT THAT WE ARE SEEING CALM
46:35 WHEN IT COMES TO U.S. FUTURES, KOSPI FUTURES AT SEEING A JUMP.
46:39 THAT DOES BRIGHTEN THE OVERALL REGIONAL MOOD.
46:44 OFF TO A PRETTY GOOD START, SO THAT RELIEF PERHAPS IN NVIDIA
46:48 SHARE PRICE BRINGING BACK A BIG CHUNK OF LOSSES.
46:53 THE AI NARRATIVE REMAINS -- EVEN IF THAT MEDIUM ARE OR
46:56 LONGER-TERM UNCERTAINTY REMAINS WHEN IT COMES TO NVIDIA'S
46:59 BROADER STRATEGY. THE IMPACT ON SUPPLY CHAINS IN
47:00 THE BUSINESS. ♪
47:25 PAUL: THIS IS THE ASIA TRADE AND WE ARE COUNTING DOWN TO ASIA'S
47:27 MAJOR MARKET OPENS. IT FEELS LIKE, WELL.
47:30 [LAUGHTER] IT'S HARD TO IGNORE THE
47:34 SALACIOUS DETAILS, BUT THE MARKET IS DOING JUST THAT.
47:38 HAIDI: IT IS FEAR THAT IS THE CERTAINTY MARKETS WANTED TO SEE.
47:41 WE TALKED ABOUT THIS YESTERDAY. AS SOON AS THE NVIDIA BOARD
47:45 MANAGED TO APPOINT AN INTERIM LEADER THEN PLACE OF JENSEN
47:51 HUANG, THAT'S WHAT WE ARE SEEING, COLETTE KRESS, STEADY
47:52 HAND. THE FUNDAMENTALS OF THE BUSINESS
47:57 ARE NOT BEING CHALLENGED AT THIS POINT.
48:01 WE ARE SEEING SOME COME ACROSS THE MARKETS PERHAPS DUE TO THE
48:01 LEADERSHIP. PAUL: WE SAW THAT YESTERDAY WITH
48:08 SK HYNIX AND SAMSUNG, A SHRUG OF THE SHOULDERS.
48:09 TAIWAN EXPOSED TO THE STORY. IN THE MEANTIME, WE HAVE IT
48:16 UNDERWAY. HAIDI: A LITTLE UPSIDE WHEN IT
48:21 COMES TO U.S. FUTURES, THE CHIP STOOD RELATIVELY OK.
48:25 THAT IS ALL PASSING THROUGH WHEN IT COMES TO WHAT WE ARE SEEING
48:26 IN ASIA FOR JAPAN. WE ARE GETTING TO POINTS WHERE
48:36 TYPICALLY WE HAVE SEEN LINES OF INTERVENTION AND THERE HAS BEEN
48:42 SOME FROM THE CHIEF CHAIRPERSON IN TOKYO, JUST REMEMBER THIS IS
48:45 THE LAST TIME WE DID SEE INTERVENTION.
48:46 PERHAPS THE MOVES WILL BE TOO HARD TO TOLERATE FOR
48:50 POLICYMAKERS IN JAPAN. WATCHING THAT WHEN IT COMES TO
48:55 THE SITUATION, 7/10 OF 1% HIGHER.
48:57 WE TALK ABOUT THE IMPLICATIONS FOR THE SUPPLY CHAIN PARTNERS IN
49:01 ASIA AND THINGS ARE LOOKING PRETTY STEADY AT THE MOMENT.
49:04 TAKING A LOOK AT THE KOSPI, IN THE PREMARKET WE SAW GAINS FOR
49:08 HYNEK'S AND SAMSUNG WHICH TOLD US WE WOULD GET A CALMER SESSION
49:10 FOR KOREA AS WELL. GAINS OF OVER 2% AS WELL AS
49:17 THOSE INDIVIDUAL HEAVY WEIGHT GAINS FOR THOSE COMPANIES AS
49:18 WELL. THERE ARE OF COURSE, DESPITE
49:27 SHORT-TERM RESPITE WE ARE SEEING, A LOT OF MEDIUM-TERM TO
49:29 LONGER TERM UNCERTAINTY OVER THE IMPACT OF JENSEN HUANG'S OUSTER
49:32 FROM NVIDIA AND HOW THAT PLAYS OUT MORE BROADLY FOR THE AI
49:35 ANALYSIS. WE'VE GOT OUR BLOOMBERG EQUITY
49:45 STRATEGIST SUNNY BANGIA, AS WELL AS TOM GILES.
49:49 LET ME START OFF IN TERMS OF THE MARKET IMPLICATIONS.
49:53 WE TALKED A LITTLE BIT ABOUT THE HEADLINE FATIGUE.
49:55 IS THAT WHAT IS HAPPENING HERE? WE DO SEE MARKETS INVESTORS
50:01 LOOKING FOR AN EXCUSE TO RESTORE SOME COME.
50:07 THAT HAVE HAPPENED. WE SAW A RECORD BUYING UP NVIDIA
50:09 SHARES YESTERDAY AS THE RETAIL CAME OUT IN FULL FORCE.
50:12 I THINK THE LARGEST BUYING ON RECORD.
50:17 TOWARDS EARNINGS NEXT WEEK, AS YOU POINTED OUT, COLLECT IS A
50:22 SAFE PAIR OF HANDS, VERY WELL KNOWN BY THE INVESTMENT
50:24 COMMUNITY. INVESTORS WILL HAVE SOME
50:27 SHORT-TERM CONFIDENCE THAT THEY HAVE PUT SOMEONE IN THE INTERIM
50:29 CEO THAT IS VERY CREDIBLE. NOW IT COMES DOWN TO HOW THE
50:35 COMPANY MANAGES THE TALK OVER THE NEXT FEW WEEKS.
50:52 DEEPSEEK. THAT'S ACCORDING TO ANOTHER NEWS
50:54 REPORT. WHAT MORE DO WE KNOW?
50:59 REPORTER: YEP, THE DOJ IS ALSO LOOKING INTO HER RELATIONSHIP
51:04 WITH SUPER MICRO AND WHETHER THERE WAS ANYTHING AMISS THERE.
51:08 IN THE COMING WEEKS, WE WILL PROBABLY SEE JENSEN HUANG, THE
51:13 FORMER CEO OF NVIDIA, AND UP ON CAPITOL HILL BEING INTERROGATED
51:15 BY LAWMAKERS. THERE CERTAINLY REMAINS, AS MY
51:24 COLLEAGUE POINTED OUT, HEADLINE RISKS FOR THE COMING WEEKS.
51:28 WHAT IF ANYTHING WAS SMUGGLED INTO CHINA IN TERMS OF ADVANCED
51:31 AI CHIPS AS A RESULT OF THIS RELATIONSHIP, OR MORE GENERALLY,
51:38 WHAT OF NVIDIA'S TECHNOLOGY THAT THE U.S. HAS FOUGHT SO HARD TO
51:42 KEEP OUT OF CHINA'S HANDS, WHAT IF IT HAS ENDED UP IN CHINA?
51:47 WHETHER IT'S A RESULT OF THIS RELATIONSHIP OR MORE
51:50 SOPHISTICATED SMUGGLING RINGS, THAT REMAINS TO BE SEEN.
51:55 ANYTHING THAT ERODES NVIDIA'S LEADERSHIP IN THIS AREA,
51:58 ANYTHING TO GIVE CHINA AN ADVANTAGE IN THE AREA COULD BE
52:02 SEEN AS PART OF THE HEADLINE RISK AFFECTING NVIDIA.
52:05 LOTS OF QUESTIONS ARE STILL GOING TO EMERGE.
52:09 WILL THERE BE OTHER AFFAIRS REVEALED?
52:13 WILL WE HEAR MORE ABOUT THAT? IT IS HARDER TO SAY WHAT IMPACT
52:16 THAT WOULD HAVE ON THE MARKET PER SE GIVEN THAT THEY HAVE
52:20 ALREADY MADE A VERY DECISIVE, CLEAN BREAK WITH JENSEN HUANG
52:26 FROM NVIDIA TO HAVE NO ROLE IN THE COMPANY GOING FORWARD.
52:32 IF WE GET THESE REVELATIONS, THEY CERTAINLY DO NOT REFLECT
52:35 WELL ON HIM AT ALL. IT COULD DAMAGE MOREL IN THE
52:37 COMPANY. THERE'S A DIFFERENCE BETWEEN THE
52:41 IMPACT ON THE COMPANY AT THIS STAGE NOW THAT HE HAS BEEN
52:44 COMPLETELY OUSTED. HAIDI: IS THE BIGGER CONCERN AND
52:52 FALLOUT GOING TO BE POLITICAL? WE TALKED ABOUT THIS IN TERMS OF
52:55 THE CONVERSATIONS THAT ARE NO DOUBT HAPPENING ON CAPITOL HILL
52:59 ON HOW MUCH TIGHTER THESE ACCESS RESTRICTIONS ARE GOING TO BE.
53:05 WHAT IT MEANS FOR U.S. CHINA, THE RELATIONSHIP IN THE ABSENCE
53:11 OF SUCH A CHEERLEADER FOR TRUMP, AND THAT RIVALRY?
53:22 REPORTER: IT DOES REMOVE ONE OF THE BIGGEST CRITICS OF TIGHTER
53:22 RESTRICTIONS ON CHINA. REMEMBER, THIS IS A POTENTIALLY
53:25 BIG MARKET FOR NVIDIA. HE WAS TO SOME DEGREE TALKING
53:31 HIS BOOK, BUT HE ALSO BELIEVED THAT THE TRADERS U.S. RESTRICTS
53:37 CHINA'S ACCESS, THE FASTER, HARDER AND MORE AGGRESSIVELY
53:41 CHINA WILL WORK TO DEVELOP AGGRESSIVE CHIPMAKING
53:45 ABILITIES. WE HAVE SEEN CHINA MAKING
53:50 STRIDES. THEY REMAINED BEHIND THE U.S.
53:53 TECHNOLOGICALLY, IN TERMS OF THE MOST SOPHISTICATED CHIPS, BUT
53:57 MANY PEOPLE TELL US THAT THEY HAVE MADE A LOT OF STRIDES AND
54:02 THEY ARE PRETTY DARN GOOD, FOR A LOT OF WHAT YOU WOULD NEED THE
54:03 CHIPS TO DO. PAUL: I WANT TO GET BACK TO SOME
54:11 OF THE MARKET IMPLICATIONS AND SOME OF THE ANALYST COMMENTARY.
54:16 WE ARE SEEING DOWNGRADES, FROM BUY TO HOLD.
54:20 BARRETT HAS MADE INTERESTING POINTS AROUND POTENTIAL
54:24 WRITE-DOWNS AND MORE MANAGEMENT UNCERTAINTY GOING FORWARD.
54:26 WHO KNOWS? WHAT IS THE OUTLOOK FOR THE
54:28 STOCK FROM HERE? >> THAT'S A GOOD POINT IN TERMS
54:35 BE HORRIBLE AT THIS TIME IN JUNCTURE.
54:38 SO I THINK COLETTE IS OBVIOUSLY A VERY GOOD CHOICE IN THE
54:42 INTERIM. SECONDLY, THE ROADMAP FOR NVIDIA
54:47 , FOR THE NEXT TWO YEARS ANYWAY, IS KIND OF LOCKED IN WITH THE
55:00 SUPPLY CHAIN. I THINK THIS IS LOOKING BEYOND
55:01 HAVE WILLINGLY GIVEN HIM THE BENEFIT OF THE DOUBT.
55:04 THAT CREATED A LITTLE BIT OF THE, JENSEN IS SO IMPORTANT TO
55:08 THE BUSINESS CONCERNS WE ARE FACING.
55:09 THE NEW MANAGEMENT TEAM NEEDS TO THINK ABOUT WHAT THE DIRECTION
55:14 WILL BE AND WHETHER THE BANK OF NVIDIA CAN BE THE CENTRAL BANK
55:17 OF AI ANY LONGER. THAT IS ALSO SOMETHING IN FOCUS.
55:26 I THINK A LOT OF INVESTORS ARE THINKING ABOUT THE CORPORATE
55:31 THEM IN THE SHORT-TERM. PAUL: WHERE DO WE GO FROM HERE
55:42 IN TERMS OF THE INVESTIGATION? CONGRESS OBVIOUSLY LOOKING INTO
55:45 THIS. WHAT IS THE LONG-TERM FATE FOR
55:49 JENSEN HUANG AND U.S.-CHINA RELATIONS?
55:53 REPORTER: ABSOLUTELY. HE IS GOING TO BE DRAGGED ONTO
55:56 CAPITOL HILL AND ASKED SOME VERY VERY DIFFICULT QUESTIONS.
56:05 U.S.-CHINA WILL LEARN A LOT WHEN PRESIDENT XI MEETS WITH
56:06 PRESIDENT TRUMP IN THE COMING DAYS.
56:10 THE OTHER BIG QUESTION ON OUR MIND, THERE ARE TWO BIG
56:13 QUESTIONS I WANT TO LEAVE YOU WITH.
56:15 ONE IS WHO DO THEY BRING IN AS THE PERMANENT CEO?
56:19 THERE ARE SOME HEAVY HITTING EXECUTIVES THAT THEY COULD LOOK
56:23 AT. HOWEVER, IT IS REALLY BIG SHOES
56:25 TO FILL. HE HAS BEEN THE PUBLIC FACE OF
56:29 THE COMPANY FOR ITS ENTIRETY, BEING ONE OF THE COFOUNDERS AND
56:31 THE ONLY CEO IN PLACE. IT WILL TAKE THEM A GOOD LONG
56:35 WHILE I'M SURE TO FIND THE RIGHT CANDIDATE AND THEY ARE GOING TO
56:44 HAVE TO DO A LOT TO RESTORE INVESTOR FAITH IN THE DIRECTION
56:47 NVIDIA WILL GO AND LEAVE THE COMPANY IN THE HANDS OF SOMEBODY
56:48 WHO IS VERY VERY CAPABLE. THIS IS A BOARD THAT HAS NOT PUT
56:54 IN PLACE OF SUCCESSION PLAN AND THEY ARE BEING CRITICIZED
56:56 HEAVILY AT THE MOMENT. THE OTHER BIG QUESTION IS THE
56:59 IMPACT ON THE LARGER AI ECOSYSTEM.
57:04 REMEMBER THAT IN VIDEO -- NVIDIA IS NOT JUST A SUPPLIER BUT AN
57:09 INVESTOR IN MANY CUSTOMERS, PLEASING BIG BETS ON CUSTOMERS
57:13 THAT ARE IN TURN BUYING NVIDIA CHIPS.
57:16 DO THOSE INVESTMENTS SLOW DOWN? YOU HAVE A CFO WHO CONTROLS THE
57:21 PURSE STRINGS AND WILL HAVE A SLIGHTLY DIFFERENT PERSPECTIVE
57:23 THAN THE FORMER CEO DID WHEN IT COMES TO MAKING THESE BIG BETS.
57:26 DO THEY SLOW DOWN AND WHAT IMPACT DOES THAT HAVE ON THE
57:30 LARGER GLOBAL AI ECOSYSTEM? ALL REMAINS TO BE SEEN.
57:36 HAIDI: THE SECOND POINT IS ACTUALLY ONE THAT I WANTED TO
57:37 DIG A LITTLE MORE INTO. THIS ERA OF LARGESS, OF THE
57:44 EVANGELISM STYLE OF JENSEN HUANG, THE CENTRAL BANKER FOR
57:47 AI, DOES THIS COME AT A TIME WHEN INVESTORS ARE LOOKING FOR A
57:53 MORE CONSERVATIVE TOUCH? THEY HAVE EVEN BEFORE THE
57:58 SCANDAL BEING THESE EXAMPLES OVER THE SHEER AMOUNT OF
58:00 SPENDING ON CIRCULAR FINANCING DEALS AND SO FORTH.
58:04 HOW MUCH DOES THAT PLAY, PARTICULARLY AT A TIME WHEN WE
58:07 SEE PUBLIC BACKLASH? THE MIDTERMS IN SOME WAYS WAS
58:10 ABOUT ANTI-AI. REPORTER: THERE ARE ALL THESE
58:14 SIGNALS FLASHING. THE MIDTERMS, THE PUBLIC
58:18 BACKLASH AGAINST DATA CENTERS, THE LAUNDRY LIST OF THINGS YOU
58:23 JUST ENUMERATED, AND THE POTENTIAL FOR A VIDEO TO SLOW
58:28 DOWN -- NVIDIA TO SLOW DOWN INVESTING.
58:30 WILL THAT RESULTED IN A FUNDAMENTAL SLOWDOWN AND
58:35 INFRASTRUCTURE INVESTMENT POTENTIALLY ON THE OTHER HAND,
58:39 GIVEN WHEN YOU LOOK AT THE PACE OF INVESTING AND THE SIZE OF
58:44 THESE INVESTMENTS, THE HUNDREDS OF BILLIONS OF DOLLARS, THE
58:47 LEVEL OF INDEBTEDNESS COMPANIES ARE GOING INTO IN ORDER TO
58:51 ENSURE THAT PLACE IN THE AI FUTURE.
58:54 THERE ARE MANY PEOPLE WHO SAID IT'S GETTING OUT OF HAND.
59:01 THERE IS A CLOT THAT SAYS IT'S TIME FOR THERE TO BE A BREATHER,
59:05 THERE IS A TIME TO TAKE STOCK. MAKE SURE THAT THERE WILL BE A
59:08 MARKET FOR ALL THESE TOOLS WE ARE INVESTING SO MUCH MONEY AND
59:10 CREATING ALL THE INFRASTRUCTURE FOR.
59:12 LET'S MAKE SURE THERE IS A MARKET.
59:17 WILL IT BE THAT BAD IF WE SLOW THINGS DOWN JUST A LITTLE BIT
59:18 FOR THE TIME BEING? AND GIVE EVERYBODY A CHANCE TO
59:26 CATCH UP, GIVE EVERYONE A CHANCE FOR REALITY TO KICK IN AND FOR
59:30 US TO FIGURE OUT, HOW MANY MORATORIA WILL THERE BE FOR
59:35 EXAMPLE ON DATA CENTERS ACROSS THE STATES?
59:38 IS THAT A GOOD THING FOR THE SYSTEM IN THE LONG RUN EVEN IF
59:43 IT TAKES A TOLL ON INVESTMENT? PAUL: BLOOMBERG INVESTMENT SUNNY
59:56 JOINING US ON THE NVIDIA STORY. I WANT TO GET YOU ACROSS SOME
59:56 BREAKING NEWS ON THE TERMINAL. A SENATE BANKING CHAIR HAS ASKED
1:00:02 JENSEN HUANG AND HOWARD LUTNICK TO TESTIFY AS WELL.
1:00:12 PRIOR TO THE INVESTMENT, HOWARD LUTNICK HAD REFUSED TO ADD
1:00:17 DOZENS OF CHINESE COMPANIES TO A KEY U.S. BLACKLIST.
1:00:20 POLITICAL REPORTING THAT HOWARD LUTNICK WILL HAVE TO ANSWER IN
1:00:24 FRONT OF GOD AND COUNTRY, BEING SUMMONED TO A SENATE BANKING
1:00:29 HEARING ALONG WITH JENSEN HUANG. WE WILL HAVE MORE ON JENSEN
1:00:32 HUANG IN OUR SERIES, THE CIRCUITS WITH EMILY CHANG THAT
1:00:34 WAS FILMED JUST WEEKS BEFORE HIS OUSTER.
1:00:41 ON BLOOMBERG.COM OR THE BLOOMBERG ORIGINALS YOUTUBE
1:00:42 CHANNEL. MORE AHEAD ON THE ASIA TRADE.
1:00:45 THIS IS BLOOMBERG. ♪
1:01:09 PAUL: TAKE A LOOK AT THIS BOARD. ALL THE STOCKS HAVE TWO THINGS
1:01:13 IN COMMON. THEY ARE ALL NVIDIA SUPPLIERS
1:01:16 AND THEY ARE ALL DOING VERY WELL.
1:01:20 ADVANTEST UP 7% AT THE MOMENT. SK HYNIX AND SAM SOME
1:01:26 ELECTRONICS ALSO PERFORMING VERY NICELY.
1:01:28 LOOKING THROUGH ALL OF THIS DRAMA.
1:01:34 JENSEN HUANG WAS OUSTED BY THE BOARD EARLIER TODAY.
1:01:39 NVIDIA'S LEADERSHIP CHANGE IS SET TO REVERBERATE THROUGHOUT
1:01:43 THE AI ECONOMY, ESPECIALLY IF THERE ARE CHANGES TO THE COMPANY
1:01:45 STRATEGY. DEMAND FOR COMPUTE IS ONLY GOING
1:01:53 UP SO FAR THIS YEAR, DESPITE DATA CENTER CONCERNS.
1:02:00 THANK YOU FOR JOINING US. PRETTY STRONGLY SUGGESTING THAT
1:02:06 THE AI TRADE IS BIGGER THAN JUST ONE PERSON AND JUST ONE COMPANY.
1:02:11 >> THANK YOU FOR HAVING ME. THIS RENAISSANCE OF OUR ERA, SO
1:02:27 I DO BELIEVE THAT -- JUST ONE COMPANY AND ONE PERSON.
1:02:33 PAUL: HOW DO YOU SEE GPU PRICES BEING IMPACTED BY THIS UPHEAVAL?
1:02:36 WE ARE GOING TO SEE SOME RIPPLE EFFECT FROM THIS, RIGHT?
1:02:45 CARMEN: IT IS INTERESTING. THE USE CASES DO NOT CHANGE
1:02:49 BECAUSE THE CEO IS CHANGING. WHAT IS GOING TO BE INTERESTING
1:02:55 IN THE FUTURE IS THE SUPPLY AND DEMAND CURVE.
1:02:56 IF THERE IS A SLOWDOWN IN TERMS OF NEW CHIP ITERATION, NEW
1:03:01 INFRASTRUCTURE BUILDOUT, THE SUPPLY WILL BE MORE LIMITED,
1:03:05 PRICE WILL INCREASE. IT IS ALL BASED ON THE SUPPLY
1:03:11 DEMAND CURVE FOR THE NEXT PHASE OF THE AI BUILD.
1:03:18 PAUL: CARMEN, WE ARE SEEING IN THE U.S. SESSIONS, SOME OF
1:03:23 NVIDIA'S COMPETITORS, NOT PRECISELY THE SAME, AMD AND
1:03:26 BROADCOM ARE MODESTLY UP. DO YOU SEE SOME OPPORTUNITIES AS
1:03:29 WELL? CARMEN: IT IS INTERESTING WHEN
1:03:35 YOU LOOK AT THE SUPPLY CURVE. -- WITHOUT A SUPPLY CHAIN
1:03:47 CORONATION, YOU TYPICALLY HAVE -- AT THE EDGE WHERE WE USE
1:03:48 EVERY DAY. IT DEPENDS ON HOW AGGRESSIVE THE
1:03:52 COMPETITORS CAN BE WITH THE WHOLE ECOSYSTEM.
1:03:55 RIGHT NOW, YOU DON'T SEE MUCH IMPACT.
1:04:02 IN 2027, IT COULD BE A MIXTURE OF DIFFERENT EFFECTS.
1:04:12 U.S. MIDTERM, OBVIOUSLY -- SO I DON'T KNOW.
1:04:14 IT IS INTERESTING. IT'LL BE INTERESTING TO SEE.
1:04:24 AND WE WILL SEE PEOPLE'S OPINION ABOUT FUTURE SUPPLY CURVE
1:04:26 REFLECTED IN FUTURE PRICE TRADING.
1:04:31 HAIDI: HOW MUCH IMPACT AS THE CHINA U.S. STORY HAVE,
1:04:33 PARTICULARLY IF WE DO SEE TIGHTER ACCESS FOR U.S. TECH
1:04:36 GOING TO CHINA? CARMEN: TWO MAIN THINGS.
1:04:42 NUMBER ONE IS EXPORT CONTROLS ON PHYSICAL SERVERS.
1:04:45 THAT IS MORE LIMITED TO CHINA THAN THE GLOBAL SUPPLY I,
1:04:50 MEANING POTENTIALLY MORE CHIPS FOR THE WORLD.
1:04:53 HOWEVER, YOU DO SEE TIGHTER RESTRICTIONS ON THE REMOTE
1:04:59 ACCESS OF GPU CLUSTERS FOR THE CHINESE COMPANY OVERSEAS, THAT
1:05:00 COULD MEAN A FEW THINGS. NUMBER ONE, THE CLIENTS THEY ARE
1:05:11 SERVING -- THAT TRANSLATES TO MORE SERVERS AVAILABLE FOR
1:05:14 AMERICAN, EUROPEAN AND OTHER COUNTRY CLIENTS.
1:05:20 THAT CHANGES THE SUPPLY CURVE FOR EVERYONE AROUND THE WORLD.
1:05:25 HAIDI: THAT IS AN INTERESTING POINT, AND TERMS OF HOW THAT
1:05:28 FREES UP SOME OF OUR BROADER CAPACITY.
1:05:33 WHAT DO YOU MAKE OF SOME OF THE CONCERNS OVER HOW THE
1:05:35 INFRASTRUCTURE BUILDOUT IS GOING TO HAPPEN, IN TERMS OF -- JENSEN
1:05:42 HUANG WAS SUCH A MAIN PART OF THE FINANCING AND FUNDING OF A
1:05:44 LOT OF THESE PROJECTS AND A LOT OF THESE DEALS.
1:05:47 HOW MUCH HAS THAT CHANGED? CARMEN: IT IS VERY INTERESTING
1:05:51 TIMES. FOLLOWING TODAY'S ANNOUNCEMENT,
1:06:01 -- AI INFRASTRUCTURE IS AGAIN MORE THAN ONE COMPANY AND ONE
1:06:03 PERSON. -- WHICH IS THE SERVERS, THEY
1:06:14 UNDERSTAND THE VOLATILITY OF THOSE LONGER-TERM CONTRACTS.
1:06:15 THOSE THINGS WILL COME TOGETHER. THERE WILL BE MORE
1:06:23 DIVERSIFICATION OF CAPITAL FROM -- OF THE FINANCING TRENCHES.
1:06:29 EVENTUALLY, YOU WILL RELY ON MORE THAN JUST ONE COMPANY, ONE
1:06:34 PERSON TO SUPPORT THE BUILDOUT. ALL GOOD SIDE FROM THAT POINT OF
1:06:38 VIEW BUT WE STILL NEED NVIDIA AND ALL OF THESE IN HOUSES TO
1:06:44 HELP US MAKE SURE THE MARKET HAS REALLY STRONG INDICATORS AND
1:06:45 BACKSTOPS AND EVERYTHING ELSE. PAUL: IF I COULD BE DEVILS
1:06:51 ADVOCATE FOR A MOMENT, WE HAVE SEEN PUSHBACK, NOT JUST IN THE
1:06:56 U.S. BUT IN AUSTRALIA AND OTHER COUNTRIES AS WELL, ABOUT THE
1:06:59 AGGRESSION OF THE DATA CENTER BUILDOUT.
1:07:07 IF YOU LOOK BEFORE THE DOTCOM BURST, THERE WAS AN OVER
1:07:13 BUILDOUT OF FIBER BEFORE THE BUST.
1:07:15 IS THERE A SIMILAR OVERBUILD WITH DATA CENTERS?
1:07:19 CARMEN: THIS IS A FEW DATA POINTS YOU SHOULD LOOK AT FOR
1:07:21 THE FUTURE. NUMBER ONE, OBVIOUSLY, THEY GIVE
1:07:27 YOU THE RIGHT NOW AVAILABILITY AND THE RATES KEEP GOING UP AND
1:07:28 THAT TRANSLATES TO MORE. IN THE LONGER TERM, 36 MONTH
1:07:36 MINIMUM, IN TERMS OF STRUCTURE RISKS, RATES, IN TERMS OF --
1:07:42 MARKET TERM, THE MARKET CONSENSUS VIEW OF LONGER-TERM
1:07:46 RATES, SO RIGHT NOW IT IS CONTAINED GOLD.
1:07:48 IN THE LONGER RUN, THE PRICE WILL BE HIGHER THAN THE SIX
1:07:52 MONTH RENTAL PRICES. SO PEOPLE DO NOT THINK THE PRICE
1:07:55 WILL COME DOWN. THE ONLY REASON THE PRICE IS
1:08:01 COMING DOWN IN THE FUTURE IS THE DEMAND SURPASSING SUPPLY.
1:08:06 USUALLY, A SLOWING CURVE IS CONSIDERED NORMAL IN A WAY.
1:08:09 THE LONGER TERM CONTRACT IS CHEAPER IT WILL BE PER GPU POWER
1:08:13 AND THAT IS THE FULL CURVE. RIGHT NOW THE MARKET DEMAND ONE
1:08:20 SUPPLY IN THE 36 MONTHS. WHAT IS INTERESTING IS YOU LOOK
1:08:27 AT IT A CENTER PUSHBACK IS GPU RENTAL MARKETS CAN BE ELASTIC.
1:08:31 IF YOU HAVE A SLOWDOWN IN DEVELOPMENT IN CERTAIN
1:08:34 COUNTRIES, YOU CAN CALL OTHER COUNTRIES API TO SUPPORT
1:08:35 WORKFLOW. HOPEFULLY WE WILL BALANCE OUT
1:08:41 EACH OTHER WITH AVAILABLE GPU'S FOR PEOPLE TO CONSUME BUT IN
1:08:46 TERMS OF -- NUMBER ONE IS AN NUMBER TWO IS ALL ABOUT PRICES.
1:08:49 WE DON'T SEE ANY FUTURES TRADING THAT WON'T BE HAPPENING VERY
1:08:53 SOON. MARKET CONSENSUS FOR FUTURE
1:08:55 PRICES WILL BE VERY INTERESTING AS WELL.
1:08:59 PAUL: WE HAVEN'T TALKED ABOUT ANTHROPIC RPO -- WE HAVEN'T
1:09:04 TALKED ABOUT THE ANTHROPIC IPO YET.
1:09:10 CARMEN: IT IS REALLY INTERESTING WHERE ANTHROPIC HAS BECOME FROM
1:09:15 WHICH IS TRAINING USE CASES TO COMBINATION TRAINING AND
1:09:17 INSTANCING. THAT WOULD BE TREMENDOUSLY
1:09:20 HELPFUL IN UNDERSTANDING ECONOMICS OF WHAT AI TRADE.
1:09:23 WE HAVE GPU COSTS WHICH IS THE COST OF THE WHOLE SERVICE AND
1:09:30 THE COST OF THE REVENUE AND YOU HAVE THE TOKEN REVENUE WHICH
1:09:33 COMBINES TO ISSUE YOU WILL BOTH HAVE COMPUTE --
1:09:38 ONE WAY IS HOW MUCH TOKEN ONE GPU GENERATED.
1:09:42 THAT'S YOUR REVENUE AND THE COST WILL BE THE COST GPU PER GPU
1:09:44 POWER. YOU SHOULD HAVE THE COST COMPUTE
1:10:01 -- MINIMUM FOR ANTHROPIC. HAIDI: CARMEN, GREAT TO HAVE YOU
1:10:06 WITH US. CARMEN LI.
1:10:13 WE DO HAVE BREAKING NEWS ACROSS THE BLOOMBERG.
1:10:16 GETTING MORE UNDERSTANDING OF HOW PRESIDENT TRUMP HAS
1:10:20 PERCEIVED THIS BROADER NVIDIA STORY.
1:10:23 HE'S URGING JENSEN HUANG TO FIGHT FOR HIS JOB.
1:10:29 THE PRESIDENT HAD SPOKEN WITH THE NVIDIA CHIEF, CONTINUING TO
1:10:33 PROVIDE THAT SUPPORT EVEN AS THE SPY SCANDAL HAS BEEN
1:10:35 INTENSIFYING. THAT PHONE CALL HAPPENED ON
1:10:40 TUESDAY, BEFORE WE SAW JENSEN HUANG BEING REMOVED AND THE CFO
1:10:46 BEING APPOINTED AS THE INTERIM CEO OF THAT COMPANY.
1:10:49 HE URGED THEM TO KEEP FIGHTING FOR HIS JOB.
1:10:54 CONTEXT IN TERMS OF WIND PRESIDENT TRUMP HAD KNOWLEDGE OF
1:10:56 THE ALLEGED SPYING SITUATION AS WELL.
1:10:59 THE NEW YORK TIMES HAD REPORTED A COUPLE OF WARNINGS BUT THAT
1:11:02 THE PRESIDENT DIDN'T TAKE ACTION AT THE TIME, AND WE KNOW, TOOK
1:11:09 JENSEN HUANG TO CHINA IN MAY. LATER ON, BLOOMBERG TECH EUROPE
1:11:14 LOOKING AT JENSEN HUANG'S OUSTING, AND WHAT BROADLY THIS
1:11:19 MEANS FOR MUCH OF THE SUPPLY CHAIN AND THE BROADER AI
1:11:22 NARRATIVE FOR INVESTORS. THIS IS BLOOMBERG.
1:11:32 ♪ STEPHEN: -- >> TAKE A LOOK AT
1:11:38 WHAT WE ARE WATCHING IN TERMS OF BOND MARKETS AS WELL AS SOME OF
1:11:41 THE OTHER RATE SENSITIVE ASSETS. WE ARE SEEING GOLD KIND OF
1:11:43 HOLDING PRETTY CLOSE TO THAT ONE YEAR LOW AS THE INVESTORS REALLY
1:11:52 BROADLY ARE RAMPING UP BETS TO COMBAT PERSISTENT INFLATION.
1:11:54 TREASURIES FALLING ON THE BACK OF THOSE WAGES BEING BOOSTED ON
1:11:57 MORE TIGHTENING. THIS IS BLOOMBERG.
1:12:18 ♪ >> WILL COME TOGETHER IN CHINA
1:12:26 FOR THE LEADERS SUMMIT AND BLOOMBERG WILL BE THERE.
1:12:26 IT'S A WEEK OF BIG NAMES AND BIG ISSUES YOU WON'T WANT TO MISS.
1:12:29 THE 2026 ASEAN LEADERS SUMMIT AND A PACK LEADERS SUMMIT.
1:12:33 LIVE COVERAGE ON NEXT WEEK ON BLOOMBERG.
1:12:42 >> NVIDIA HAS PROBABLY GOT THE MOST VALUABLE IP ON THE PLANET.
1:12:47 THE VISION HERE OF NVIDIA IS GOING TO BE CALLED INTO
1:12:50 QUESTION. >> WE HAVE TO VIEW THIS AS A
1:12:54 TRANSITIONAL ISSUE AND A BIT MORE TACTICAL IN NATURE.
1:12:57 >> IS THE AI TRADE ONE MAN OR IS IT A COMPANY THAT IS, YOU KNOW,
1:13:01 KIND OF LEADING THE CHARGE ON A RELATIVE BASIS?
1:13:04 >> ESSENTIALLY USING SOMEONE WHO CAN BRING TOGETHER ALL THE
1:13:06 PARTIES. >> I THINK THAT WE WILL MOVE
1:13:12 THROUGH. >> SOME OF OUR GUESTS REACTING
1:13:20 TO THE LATEST NEWS AROUND NVIDIA.
1:13:21 THE OUTGOING CEO, JENSEN HUANG. LET'S TAKE A LOOK AT HOW WE ARE
1:13:26 SEEING THIS PLAY OUT WHEN IT COMES TO BROADER MARKETS AND
1:13:28 THERE IS A SEMBLANCE OF SOME CAUTION.
1:13:32 TO BE FAIR, WE ARE PROBABLY LIKELY TO SEE SOME OF THESE
1:13:36 RALLIES GETTING CAP GIVEN THE LEVEL OF CAUTION WE ARE SEEING
1:13:38 BUT WE ARE SEEING BROUGHT UP TIGHT AS PERHAPS A BIT OF
1:13:41 HEADLINE FATIGUE IS SETTLING IN OR JUST THE FACT THAT WITH THAT
1:13:46 APPOINTMENT OF THE CFO TO THE NVIDIA TOP JOB THAT REMOVES AT
1:13:48 LEAST SOME OF THE SHORT-TERM UNCERTAINTY THAT HAS BEEN
1:13:51 PLAGUING THIS COMPANY AS WE CONTINUE TO GET REVELATIONS OF
1:13:56 THESE EXTRAMARITAL AFFAIRS BUT LET'S TAKE A CLOSER LOOK IN
1:14:00 TERMS OF HOW IT IMPACTS THE GLOBAL AND ASIAN SUPPLY CHAIN.
1:14:04 THIS FALLOUT FROM HIS REMOVAL COULD HAVE AN IMPACT ON TAIWAN
1:14:06 CHIPMAKERS. IN PARTICULAR, TAIWAN HOSTING
1:14:09 FIVE OF NVIDIA'S TOP 10 SUPPLIERS BY COST HERE POTENTIAL
1:14:15 RISK SPOTLIGHT TO CONTINUE BUSINESS AMID THESE ONGOING
1:14:17 CHANGES. MANY ABRAMS IS THE HEAD OF
1:14:20 TAIWAN RESEARCH WHO JOINS US NOW.
1:14:21 NO DOUBT YOU HAVE BEEN WATCHING THIS AS CLOSELY AS WE HAVE.
1:14:26 WHAT ARE THE RISKS FOR TAIWAN PARTICULARLY WHEN IT COMES TO A
1:14:28 GIANT LIKE TSMC WHO HAS THAT CLOSE INTEGRATED RELATIONSHIP?
1:14:34 >> OK. THANKS FOR HAVING ME ON.
1:14:35 ESPECIALLY TOPICAL TODAY. WE ARE CONSISTENT FIRST IN THE
1:14:39 INDUSTRY AT LEAST IN WHAT WE HAVE SEEN SO FAR.
1:14:47 WE HAVE BEEN VERY INSTRUMENTAL INVESTING IN THE ECOSYSTEM AND
1:14:52 SUPPLY CHAIN CAPACITY ON PRODUCT DEVELOPMENT AND EVEN THAT
1:14:54 ADVOCATE OF U.S. SUPPLY TO CHINA AND OPEN SOURCE ECOSYSTEM SO WE
1:14:58 DO HAVE TO COME BACK TO THEN WHAT DOES THIS MEAN FOR THE
1:15:02 SUPPLY CHAIN? FIRST IT MEANS FOR 2027, A LOT
1:15:06 OF THINGS ARE SET. THE MAIN ARCHITECTURE WE ARE
1:15:10 HEADING INTO, WE ARE FINE-TUNING THE FINAL DETAILS SO THAT IS
1:15:13 GOING TO HAVE VOLUME PRODUCTION INTO NEXT YEAR AND A LOT OF
1:15:18 THESE ARCHITECTURE DECISIONS MADE IN A GOOD WAY A LOT OF THE
1:15:21 HYPERSCALE CAPEX BUDGETS ALREADY SET TO BE VERY AGGRESSIVE.
1:15:27 WE HAVE GOT ABOUT 70% GROWTH TO 1.7 TRILLION FOR THE CAPEX.
1:15:32 I WOULD ALSO POINT OUT ON THESE INDUSTRY DIRECTIONS, THERE'S A
1:15:35 LOT OF CREDIT TO ONE COMPANY. THERE IS THE OPEN COMPUTER
1:15:40 PROJECT THAT THE HYPERSCALERS BACK.
1:15:42 A LOT OF THESE BIG INNOVATIONS ARE ALSO GETTING PUSHED, PUSHING
1:15:46 NETWORKING, OPTICS, ADVANCED PACKAGING, COOLING, ALSO GETTING
1:15:52 PUSHED BY THE INDUSTRY AS WELL SO AGAIN, I WANT TO COME BACK TO
1:15:57 A LOT OF THINGS FOR NEXT YEAR. CAPEX, ARCHITECTURE, LARGELY AT
1:16:01 LEAST ARE SET TO GIVE US TIME AS WE GO THROUGH THIS TRANSITION.
1:16:10 >> THE OTHER ASPECT OF WHAT POTENTIALLY GOES WITH HIS
1:16:14 LEADERSHIP AT NVIDIA IS ALSO HIS ROLE AS THE CENTRAL BANKER FOR
1:16:16 ALL OF AI AND PARTICULARLY IN THAT SHIP SPACE, RIGHT?
1:16:20 WHAT DO YOU THINK THE IMPLICATIONS ARE IN TERMS OF
1:16:22 FINANCING IN THE DEALMAKING SIDE OF THINGS WHICH ALSO COMES AT A
1:16:25 TIME WHEN PERHAPS INVESTORS IN THE BROADER MARKETS ARE LOOKING
1:16:28 FOR MORE OF A FISCALLY CONSERVATIVE APPROACH THEN MAY
1:16:32 BE THE STYLE OF DEALMAKING AND FINANCING THAT WE HAVE SEEN FROM
1:16:34 HIM. >> THERE HAVE BEEN TWO SIDES.
1:16:40 INVESTMENT AND THE SUPPLY CHAIN BUT IT'S BEEN MUCH HEAVIER
1:16:45 TOWARDS INVESTING IN THE AI LABS AND ALSO TOWARD THE NEO-CLOUDS.
1:16:50 OUR VIEW ON THE AI CYCLE, WE ARE KIND OF SET UP ALREADY FOR A BIT
1:16:56 OF MODERATION AND POTENTIALLY A BIT MORE CONCENTRATION TOWARDS
1:16:59 THE TIER ONE PLAYERS WITH THE BETTER BALANCE SHEETS TO INVEST
1:17:01 IN MORE OF THE COMPUTER. CAPITAL MARKETS ARE SAYING THAT
1:17:05 SO THIS KIND OF KEEPS THAT TRANSITION HAPPENING IN A BIGGER
1:17:07 WAY. THAT THE ONES WITH MORE OF THE
1:17:14 SELF FUNDING CASH FLOWS OR ABILITY TO RUN -- HE CAN RAISE
1:17:18 MONEY AT INVESTMENT GRADE AND PROBABLY DO IT CONCENTRATED
1:17:22 WHICH WOULD PUT OUT AS WE PUT IT OUT DIRECTLY IN THE TRILLION
1:17:24 DOLLARS. IT'S 5% TO 10%.
1:17:29 IF YOU EXPERIENCE IT TO EVEN A COUPLE OF THE NUMBER FIVE WERE
1:17:32 NUMBER SIX HYPERSCALERS, IT'S ABOUT 20% SO A LOT OF THE
1:17:35 SPENDING IS STILL CONCENTRATED IN THE CORE NAMES AND THAT COULD
1:17:39 STILL BE THE DIRECTION AND THAT IS BACK TO WHEN CAPITAL MARKETS
1:17:40 ARE LOOKING AT FUNDING. WHEN WE THINK ABOUT MODERATION
1:17:46 AS WE HEAD TOWARD 2028, IT WILL BE THAT YOU START TO LOOK AT HOW
1:17:50 MUCH DO WE FUND? THIS LOOKS LIKE MORE EFFECTIVE
1:17:56 THAT WE SET IN MOTION FOR. >> RANDY, IS THIS A RISK THAT
1:18:07 TRADERS SHOULD BE LOOKING AT? POTENTIALLY BEING SUMMONED TO
1:18:10 THE U.S. TO TESTIFY AS PART OF THIS WHOLE NVIDIA >> DRAMA? --
1:18:17 NVIDIA DRAMA? >> WE HAVE SEEN A SMALL NUMBER
1:18:21 OF CASES. NOT ACTUALLY VERY SCATTERED AS
1:18:26 FAR AS TAIWAN DIRECT SUPPLIERS WHO ARE COMING INTO THIS SO AT
1:18:27 LEAST FROM WHAT WE HAVE SEEN SO FAR, NOT SO MUCH AND I WILL SAY
1:18:32 FOR A LOT OF THE SUPPLIERS, THEY ARE DEALING DIRECTLY WITH NICK
1:18:36 WHEN THEY ARE SITTING INVESTMENTS AND WHERE THEY HAVE
1:18:41 DEDICATED CAPACITY. A LOT OF THAT IS DIRECTLY TO THE
1:18:45 DIRECT CUSTOMERS. THEY GET FEEDBACK FROM THE CHAIN
1:18:49 BUT THAT IS WHAT I WILL SAY. IT HAS BEEN SOMEWHAT ISOLATED IN
1:18:52 WHAT WE FOUND SO FAR TO A FEW CASES AND COMPANIES BUT ACTUALLY
1:18:56 NOT AS MUCH IN TAIWAN. THEY MAY TRY TO ASSESS ACROSS
1:19:03 THE CHAIN BUT SO FAR, NOT A LOT OF THINGS HAVE BEEN COVERED AT
1:19:05 LEAST FOR THE TAIWAN SUPPLY CHAIN.
1:19:09 >> IN TERMS OF TAIWAN TECH COMPANIES, WHAT SORT OF
1:19:15 INVESTMENTS DO YOU ANTICIPATE IN ANTHROPIC ESPECIALLY HEADING
1:19:15 INTO THE IPO NEXT WEEK? >> I WILL JUST SAY MAY BROADLY
1:19:22 ABOUT WHERE WE ARE SEEING THE INVESTMENT FROM THE TAIWAN
1:19:28 SUPPLIERS, THEY ARE TAKING -- THEY HAVE KIND OF BEEN THAT.
1:19:32 YOU HAVE THE LEADING FOUNDER WHO SAYS EVERYBODY IS OUR CUSTOMERS
1:19:35 SO THEY ARE LOOKING AT THE WHOLE ECOSYSTEM AND THAT IS WHY EVEN
1:19:39 THOUGH THEY HAD A TOP CUSTOMER ON THE BIG AI GPU COMPANY, THEY
1:19:45 ARE SPREAD ACROSS THE AI GPU AND THE OTHER MAJOR GPU COMPANY SO
1:19:49 IT'S MUCH MORE BROADER ABOUT WHERE THEY ARE INVESTING.
1:19:53 I WILL SAY WITH TAIWAN SUPPLIERS, TOO, WHEN THE LABS
1:19:57 WHERE THEY HAVE BEEN DEVELOPING THIS TYPE -- THESE TECHNOLOGIES,
1:20:00 THESE SUPPLIERS HAVE BUILT UP A LOT OF CAPABILITY THAT IS
1:20:08 TRANSFERABLE ACROSS THE GPU SO A LOT OF THIS IS THE BIG
1:20:11 TECHNOLOGY DEVELOPMENT, WHETHER IN THE NETWORKING, THE OPTICS,
1:20:15 WHICH APPLIES TO THE OVERALL ECOSYSTEM AND THAT IS ACTUALLY
1:20:17 WHAT IS GOING TO DRIVE THESE LABS WHEN THEY GO PUBLIC TO
1:20:20 CONTINUE TO ADVANCE THE MODELS. >> HEAD OF TAIWAN RESEARCH AT
1:20:28 UBS, THANKS SO MUCH FOR YOUR TIME TODAY.
1:20:30 NOW, WE WILL HAVE MORE ON JENSEN HUANG IN OUR SERIES, THE
1:20:34 CIRCUIT, WITH EMILY CHANG, WHICH WAS FILMED WEEKS BEFORE HIS
1:20:36 OUSTER. SUBSCRIBERS CAN WATCH THE IN
1:20:42 FULL RIGHT NOW ON BLOOMBERG.COM OR THE BLOOMBERG ORIGINALS
1:20:44 YOUTUBE CHANNEL. HAIDI: MORE HEADLIGHTS.
1:20:47 THE U.S. JUSTICE DEPARTMENT IS SET TO BE INVESTIGATING ALICE.
1:20:54 THE AGENCY IS LOOKING AT WHETHER ENTITIES LINKED TO HER WERE
1:20:58 INVOLVED. MEANWHILE, THE INFORMATION IS
1:21:01 REPORTING SHE ALSO PROMISED NVIDIA CHIPS TO CHINESE AI
1:21:05 COMPANY DEEPSEEK. THE FEDERAL RESERVE HAS DROPPED
1:21:09 -- FOR OCTOBER 2027 FROM ITS CALENDAR.
1:21:13 THE AGENCY SAYS A MEETING SET FOR OCTOBER 26 TO 2020 SEVEN
1:21:15 WILL STILL TAKE PLACE BUT IT WOULD NOT FEATURE A POLICY
1:21:17 DECISION. THE FED CHAIR SAID LAST MONTH
1:21:21 THAT THE CENTRAL BANK WOULD FACE A REDUCTION IN THE NUMBER OF
1:21:24 RATESETTING MEETINGS WITH A GOAL OF MOVING TO SIX SESSIONS BY
1:21:26 2028. PRESIDENT TRUMP SAYS THE U.S.
1:21:30 DOES NOT NEED AN IRAN DEAL, POSTING ON SOCIAL MEDIA THAT
1:21:32 VICE PRESIDENT JD VANCE SHOULD INSTEAD FOCUS ON DOMESTIC
1:21:33 ISSUES. IT AT -- DAMPENED HOPES FOR A
1:21:39 DIPLOMATIC SOLUTION. THE POST CAME DAYS AFTER VANCE
1:21:43 BLAMED THE WAR FOR REPUBLICAN MIDTERM LOSSES.
1:21:44 THE MOVE HIGHLIGHTS GROWING FRICTION AHEAD OF THE POTENTIAL
1:21:47 2028 WHITE HOUSE RUN. VOLODYMYR ZELENSKYY SAYS
1:21:54 PROGRESS HAS BEEN MADE DURING A MEETING WITH U.S. ENVOY STEVE
1:21:58 WHAT CAP -- STEVE WITKOFF AND JARED KUSHNER.
1:22:00 IN A DECISION TO INCLUDE EUROPEANS IN THE NEXT ROUND OF
1:22:03 PEACE TALKS WITH RUSSIA. THE MEETING TOOK PLACE HOURS
1:22:07 AFTER WHEN THEY MET VLADIMIR PUTIN IN MOSCOW.
1:22:11 >> OUR GROUPS WILL HAVE NEW MEETINGS.
1:22:14 WE DECIDED THEY WILL WORK ON IT. SOME KIND OF CEASEFIRE.
1:22:22 YES. >> MORE AHEAD HERE ON THE ASIA
1:22:33 TRADE. THIS IS BLOOMBERG.
1:22:56 ♪ PAUL: SINGAPORE TELECOM GIANTS
1:23:05 INTEL REPORTED FIRST HAVE EARNINGS OF 1.5 BILLION
1:23:05 AGO. JOINING US NOW IS THE COMPANY'S
1:23:07 GROUP CFO. ARE, THANK YOU SO MUCH FOR YOUR
1:23:09 TIME TODAY AND TO BE FAIR, THAT ONE-OFF DROP WAS DUE TO ONE-OFF
1:23:15 GAINS IN THE QUARTER PRIOR SO CAN YOU TALK TO US A LITTLE BIT
1:23:17 ABOUT THE OUTPUT FOR THE COMING QUARTER? I UNDERSTAND THAT YOU
1:23:22 HAD ANOTHER LOOK AT YOUR GUIDANCE.
1:23:26 >> SURE. YOU ARE RIGHT.
1:23:30 THE NET PROFIT THAT IS REPORTED SAW A DROP BECAUSE THE PREVIOUS
1:23:36 PERIOD ACTUALLY HAD A HUGE EXCEPTIONAL GAIN OF $2 BILLION
1:23:39 SO THAT IS NOT QUITE AN ACCURATE REFLECTION OF THE TRUE
1:23:41 FUNDAMENTALS OF THE BUSINESS. IN FACT, IF YOU LOOK AT THE
1:23:46 UNDERLYING PROFIT, IT'S ACTUALLY UP 10%.
1:23:49 WE ARE SEEING SIGNIFICANT MOMENTUM ACROSS THE BOARD ACROSS
1:23:53 OUR OPERATING COMPANIES AS WELL AS THE REGIONAL ASSOCIATE SO WE
1:23:57 ARE CONFIDENT ABOUT THE MOMENTUM THAT WE ARE SEEING INTO THE
1:24:00 SECOND HALF AND AS A RESULT, WE HAVE LIFTED OUR GUIDANCE.
1:24:05 IT HAS BEEN LIFTED TO MID TO HIGH SINGLE DIGIT SO WE ARE
1:24:07 LOOKING, YOU KNOW, WE ARE FAIRLY CONFIDENT ABOUT THE SECOND HALF
1:24:11 DESPITE ALL THE VOLATILITY THAT WE ARE SEEING.
1:24:16 PAUL: CAN YOU TELL US A LITTLE BIT MORE ABOUT SOME OF THE PLANS
1:24:17 FOR THAT MONEY? ARE YOU INTENDING TO RETURN MORE
1:24:24 MONEY TO SHAREHOLDERS? YOU HAVE -- IT'S UP A LITTLE BIT.
1:24:26 ARE YOU PLANNING MORE? FOLKS WELL, IT'S, YOU KNOW, AS
1:24:33 WE HAVE ALWAYS SAID IN OUR CAPITAL MANAGEMENT PLAN, IT IS A
1:24:36 BIT OF BOTH, RIGHT? WE ALWAYS NEED TO FOCUS ON
1:24:40 ENSURING THAT OUR SHAREHOLDERS GET A GOOD RETURN ON THE SHARES.
1:24:43 AT THE SAME TIME, WE NEED TO INVEST GROWTH.
1:24:47 OUR INTERIM DIVIDEND WAS NINE CENTS PER SHARE.
1:24:48 THAT'S A 10% IMPROVEMENT FROM THE PREVIOUS PERIOD AND WE DO
1:24:53 EXPECT THAT OUR OVERALL DIVIDEND FOR THE FULL YEAR WILL LIKELY
1:24:59 GROW BARRING ANY UNFORESEEN CIRCUMSTANCES BY MID TO HIGH
1:25:03 SINGLE DIGITS AND THAT IS FAIRLY CONSISTENT AND THIS IS THE SIXTH
1:25:06 CONSECUTIVE YEAR THAT WE HAVE GROWN OUR DIVIDENDS.
1:25:13 SO IT'S RETURNING THE CAPITAL TO SHAREHOLDERS.
1:25:15 WE WILL BE CONTINUING TO INVEST IN CAPEX NOT JUST IN OUR TELCO
1:25:18 BUSINESSES. WE HAVE HIGHLIGHTED CAPEX INTO
1:25:23 OUR VARIOUS BUSINESSES ACROSS OUR REGION AND ALL ASSOCIATES
1:25:25 BUT EQUALLY IMPORTANT, WE ARE TAKING A MEASURED APPROACH TO
1:25:32 CAPEX INTO OUR DIGITAL INFRASTRUCTURE BUSINESSES AND
1:25:35 THAT IS OUR DATA CENTER BUSINESS AS WELL AS OUR GPU BUSINESS SO
1:25:38 IT'S A BIT OF RETURNING TO SHAREHOLDERS AND A BIT OF PAP --
1:25:44 A BIT OF CAPEX FOR GROWTH. >> WE TALKED ABOUT, YES,
1:25:47 INVESTING IN GROWTH. I WONDER HOW MUCH OF THAT GROWTH
1:25:51 IS TO DO WITH THE DATA CENTER SIDE OF THE BUSINESS.
1:25:54 RIGHT? CAN YOU TELL US ABOUT HOW MUCH ENTHUSIASM AND COMMITMENT
1:25:57 IS THERE TO THAT GIVEN SOME OF THE GLOBAL HEADWINDS AROUND THE
1:25:58 SPACE? >> YES.
1:26:01 YOU ARE RIGHT, HAITI. THERE IS A FAIR BIT OF OPTIMISM
1:26:07 THAT WE ARE SEEING IN THE SECTOR.
1:26:09 WE ARE SEEING REAL DEMAND IN AI AS WELL AS ENTERPRISE CLOUD
1:26:16 DEMAND AND IT'S REALLY A FUNDAMENTAL SHIFT IN SECULAR
1:26:19 TREND. YOU KNOW, WE DO NOT WANT TO JUST
1:26:24 FOCUS ON THE SHORT TERM TREND SO THE APPROACH THAT WE HAVE ALWAYS
1:26:27 TAKEN FOR OUR DIGITAL INFRASTRUCTURE BUSINESS IS ONE
1:26:30 OF A MORE MEASURED APPROACH. WE WILL ALWAYS INVEST INTO DATA
1:26:35 CENTERS WHENEVER THERE IS SECURE CUSTOMER CONTRACTS AND IT HAS TO
1:26:38 BE HIGH QUALITY CUSTOMERS. WE ENSURE THAT OUR POWER AND
1:26:43 WATER ARE AVAILABLE AND EQUALLY IMPORTANT IS REALLY THE CAPITAL
1:26:45 STRUCTURE TO FUND THEIR BUSINESSES.
1:26:49 YOU KNOW, WE DON'T DO CIRCULAR FINANCING.
1:26:52 WE DON'T DO INTERESTING ESOTERIC STRUCTURES.
1:26:54 IT'S JUST PURE BALANCE SHEET BANK FINANCING.
1:27:00 SO IT'S JUST, YOU KNOW, BACK TO THE FUNDAMENTAL TYPE OF
1:27:03 FINANCING WHERE IT IS EASY TO UNDERSTAND.
1:27:05 OUR COST OF CAPITAL IS ONE OF THE LOWEST AROUND THE REGION AND
1:27:09 WE ARE LEVERAGING ON THAT SO THE STRENGTH OF THE BALANCE SHEET
1:27:12 DEFINITELY HELPS AND THAT, YOU KNOW, GIVES US I WOULD SAY
1:27:16 GROWTH BUT I WOULD SAY AT A VERY MEASURED PACE GIVEN, YOU KNOW,
1:27:19 THE VOLATILITY OUT THERE. WE ALWAYS NEED TO KEEP AN EYE ON
1:27:20 THAT. >> IS IS -- DOES THE DATA CENTER
1:27:26 BUSINESS OR MARKET SEE AN IMPACT WHEN IT COMES TO WHAT IS GOING
1:27:30 ON WITH NVIDIA WITH THE REMOVAL OF JENSEN HUANG FROM THAT TOP
1:27:31 JOB? >> I THINK FOR OUR PORTFOLIO, IT
1:27:42 HAS VERY LIMITED -- WELL, IF YOU LOOK AT BASICALLY OUR DATA
1:27:48 CENTER TENANTS, I WOULD SAY VERY INSIGNIFICANT AMOUNT OF OUR DATA
1:27:51 CENTER CAPACITY IS LEASED OUT TO THE -- THEY HAVE PERHAPS SOME
1:27:56 RELATIONSHIP WITH NVIDIA. IT'S LESS THAN 5% OR EVEN VERY
1:28:01 LOW SINGLE-DIGIT TYPE OF EXPOSURE BECAUSE OUR DATA CENTER
1:28:04 BUSINESS, THE TENANTS HAVE ALWAYS BEEN THE LARGE
1:28:07 HYPERSCALERS, LARGE ENTERPRISES, BANKS, GOVERNMENT AGENCIES, AND
1:28:09 ALL THAT. IF YOU LOOK AT THE CAPACITY OF
1:28:17 OUR DATA CENTERS, IT'S BASED IN SINGAPORE AND IT'S LARGELY
1:28:20 SINGAPORE ENTERPRISES, GOVERNMENT AGENCIES, AND ALL
1:28:21 THAT. WE ARE FAIRLY INSULATED FROM
1:28:24 WHAT IS HAPPENING THERE. IF YOU LOOK AT OUR GPU BUSINESS,
1:28:28 YES, WE DO OBTAIN CHIPS FROM NVIDIA.
1:28:31 IN FACT, SOME OF THE HIGHEST END CHIPS WE DO CONTRACT WITH
1:28:34 NVIDIA. I WOULD SAY A LARGE PART OF
1:28:38 ACTUALLY THAT'S FOR THIS YEAR, ALL OF IT HAS BEEN CONTRACTED
1:28:42 ALREADY IN MORE THAN HALF OF THE CAPACITY HAVE ALREADY INSTALLED
1:28:47 INTO OUR DATA CENTERS IN SINGAPORE SO I WOULD SAY FAIRLY
1:28:51 MANAGED LIMITED EXPOSURE TO WHAT IS HAPPENING IN NVIDIA BUT
1:28:53 ALWAYS, WE ARE KEEPING A CLOSE EYE AND NVIDIA IS NOT JUST A
1:29:00 PARTNER THAT WE WORK WITH. THERE ARE A VARIETY OF PARTNERS
1:29:04 THAT WE WORK WITH AS WELL SO I WOULD SAY WE ARE FAIRLY
1:29:07 INSULATED AND YOU KNOW, WE JUST HAVE TO KEEP OUR EYES CLOSE TO
1:29:09 THE SITUATION. PAUL: YOU MENTIONED THIS YEAR'S
1:29:15 SUPPLY IS PRETTY MUCH SECURED BUT WE HAVE BEEN REPORTING THIS
1:29:18 MORNING THAT THERE IS GOING TO BE A SENATE INVESTIGATION INTO
1:29:22 WHAT HAPPENED AT NVIDIA. THERE IS POTENTIAL THAT THERE'S
1:29:25 GOING TO BE FURTHER TIGHTENING OF RULES AROUND AI CHIP EXPORTS.
1:29:29 HOW WOULD YOU PREPARE FOR A SCENARIO LIKE THAT?
1:29:35 >> JUST TO BE ABSOLUTELY CLEAR, WHATEVER CHIPS WE PROCURE AND WE
1:29:41 ACTUALLY PROVIDE GPU SERVICES TO OUR CUSTOMERS, EVERYTHING THAT
1:29:43 IS IN SINGAPORE AT THIS TIME, THE CUSTOMERS ARE FOR SINGAPORE
1:29:44 CUSTOMERS. WE ARE EXTREMELY STRICT IN TERMS
1:29:51 OF EXPORTING. WE DO NOT WORK WITH CUSTOMERS
1:29:56 WHO RE-EXPORT CHIPS TO OTHER COUNTRIES BUT REALLY FOCUS ON
1:30:00 THE END CUSTOMER HERE IN SINGAPORE SO THEY ARE ALL
1:30:02 SINGAPORE CUSTOMERS. SO THAT IS FROM THE VERY
1:30:09 BEGINNING, WE WERE VERY CLEAR ABOUT THAT SO YES, YOU KNOW, I
1:30:13 DON'T KNOW WHETHER WE HAVE A LOT OF TIME TO TALK ABOUT ALL THE
1:30:16 U.S. REGULATION THAT IS COMING OUT.
1:30:18 WE ARE CLEARLY KEEPING A CLOSE WATCH ON THEM BUT AT THIS POINT
1:30:21 IN TIME, THERE IS NO IMPACT ON US.
1:30:26 HAIDI: I WISH WE HAD MORE TIME TO TALK THROUGH THAT BUT WE WILL
1:30:27 HAVE TO LEAVE IT THERE. CFO, WE APPRECIATE YOUR TIME.
1:30:34 THIS IS BLOOMBERG. ♪
1:30:59 >> TAKE A LOOK AT SOME OF THE STOCK WE ARE WATCHING WHEN
1:31:02 MARKETS OPEN IN HONG KONG AND MAINLAND CHINA FOR THIS FRIDAY'S
1:31:05 SESSION AND CHINESE AI IS IN FOCUS.
1:31:07 IT HAS BEEN AN INTERESTING BIFURCATED TRADE THERE.
1:31:12 WE SAW HYPERSCALERS, ALIBABA TUMBLING YESTERDAY ON CONCERNS
1:31:15 THAT ACCESS TO ADVANCED CHIPS MAY FACE FURTHER U.S. SCRUTINY
1:31:17 OR FURTHER TIGHTENING. ON THE OTHER HAND, AI MODEL
1:31:22 DEVELOPERS, THOSE ARE ALSO SEEING A SLIDE THERE AS WELL.
1:31:25 NVIDIA ANNOUNCING THE NEW INTERIM CEO COULD GET SOME SENSE
1:31:28 OF CLOSURE THERE. BUT CERTAINLY U.S. ADR IS
1:31:32 SUGGESTING WE COULD SEE A BIT MORE SELLING PRESSURE APPEARED
1:31:34 ON THE OTHER HAND, WE DID HAVE PERHAPS MORE UPSIDE I SHOULD SAY
1:31:39 WHEN IT COMES TO SOME OF THOSE CHINESE CHIP NAMES.
1:31:43 PAUL: NVIDIA HAS AN INTERIM CEO IN PLACE BUT EVEN THAT BEING THE
1:31:47 CASE, JENSEN HUANG'S EXIT DOES RAISE QUESTIONS ACROSS ASIA'S
1:31:49 SEMICONDUCTOR SUPPLY CHAIN. WE HAVE MAJOR SUPPLIERS RELYING
1:31:52 HEAVILY ON THE CHIPMAKER FOR SALES.
1:32:00 THE BLOOMBERG OPINION COLUMNIST THE REAL LITMUS TEST.
1:32:03 SHE JOINS US NOW WITH MORE. WHEN WE LOOK AHEAD TO THAT HUGE
1:32:09 LISTING, WHAT ARE THE MARKET'S BIGGEST WORRIES AROUND THAT?
1:32:13 >> SO THE BIGGEST WORRY ABOUT THE WHOLE AI TRADE IS THE ROBUST
1:32:17 DEMAND THAT WE ARE SEEING WHERE THE CHIPMAKERS MAY NOT BE THERE
1:32:21 AND MAY NOT BE SO ROBUST AFTER ALL AFTER JENSEN HUANG IS GONE.
1:32:25 JENSEN HUANG IS NOT ONLY AI DEVELOPMENTS BIGGEST ADVOCATE,
1:32:28 HE WAS NICKNAMED THE CENTRAL BANKER OF AI.
1:32:30 OVER THE LAST COUPLE OF YEARS, HE HAS -- OF VENDOR FINANCING TO
1:32:36 CUSTOMERS TO PULL UP THE DEMAND FORWARD AND TO MAKE SURE THERE
1:32:42 IS A ROBUST DEMAND FOR AI CHIPS AND ALSO, HE HAS A LOT OF
1:32:47 VENTURE INVESTING INTO STARTUPS THAT DO DATA CENTER DEVELOPMENTS
1:32:51 SO THE WORRY IS THAT NOW THAT HE IS GONE, NVIDIA WILL SLOW DOWN
1:32:54 THE PACE OF GUILT MAKING, SLOW DOWN THE PACE OF CIRCULAR
1:32:59 ROBUST. HAIDI: WHAT IS THE OUTLOOK WHEN
1:33:06 IT COMES TO CHIP DEMAND? >> I THINK THAT THIS IS WHERE
1:33:13 ANTHROPIC'S IPO COMES IN BECAUSE ANTHROPIC IS ONE OF THE BIGGEST
1:33:17 ULTIMATE CUSTOMERS OF THE CHIPS, RIGHT?
1:33:21 AND THEN IF ANTHROPIC COMES IN AND HAS A VERY SUCCESSFUL IPO,
1:33:26 IT WILL NO LONGER NEED NVIDIA TO BACKSTOP ITS CLOUD COMPUTING
1:33:31 DEALS AND THAT COULD ENSURE THAT , YOU KNOW, THE AI DEMAND IS
1:33:32 STILL THERE. IF ANTHROPIC GOES PUBLIC, IT
1:33:38 COULD DO FOLLOW-UP EQUITY RAISINS, CONVERTIBLE BONDS.
1:33:42 IT MIGHT BECOME AN INVESTMENT GRADE RATED COMPANY SO ALL THE
1:33:45 POSSIBILITIES WILL COME UP ONCE IT BECOMES PUBLIC.
1:33:51 PAUL: SUBSCRIBERS CAN READ MORE ABOUT THE COLUMN.
1:33:52 FORGET NVIDIA. THAT IS A STORY AVAILABLE NOW ON
1:33:56 THE TERMINAL. ALL RIGHT.
1:34:00 WE ARE COUNTING DOWN TO A FEW MORE MAJOR MARKET OPENS HERE.
1:34:05 WE HAVE HONG KONG AND CHINA OPENING.
1:34:07 THAT WILL BE VERY INTERESTING BECAUSE THIS ENTIRE SAGA HAS
1:34:11 REALLY GIVEN A LOT OF FUEL TO SOME OF THE CHINA HAWKS IN THE
1:34:13 U.S. ADMINISTRATION. WE HAVE ALREADY SEEN POLITICAL
1:34:17 REPORTING HOWARD LUTNICK WILL BE CALLED BEFORE A SENATE COMMITTEE
1:34:22 TO TESTIFY BECAUSE HE WAS NOT TERRIBLY ENTHUSIASTIC ABOUT
1:34:26 LIMITING ACCESS TO HIGH-END CHIPS FROM CHINA SO WE COULD SEE
1:34:29 THE CHINA HAWKS GAINING SOMETHING OF THE UPPER HAND
1:34:30 HERE, HAITI. HAIDI: TAKE A LOOK AT THE
1:34:35 RELATIVE CALM ACROSS BENCHMARKS THAT ARE TRADING AT THE MOMENT
1:34:39 AND PERHAPS THIS IS SORT OF DOWN TO JUST WANTING TO TAKE A
1:34:42 BREATHER AND CERTAINLY THE PRICE ACTION IN THE OVERNIGHT SESSION
1:34:46 DOES HELP WHEN IT COMES TO THE KOSPI AND JAPAN AS WELL FIRMLY
1:34:47 IN THE GREEN. FRIDAY, THERE'S TWO MARKETS.
1:34:52 NVIDIA'S SHARP INTRADAY RECOVERY, A PRETTY SUPPORTIVE
1:34:55 START FOR NASDAQ FUTURES HELPING KOREAN AND JAPANESE SHARES.
1:34:56 TRIPLE THREAT. IT FROM HER DOLLAR.
1:35:01 THE UNCERTAINTY OF THE ANTHROPIC IPO ALL AMONGST THEM.
1:35:05 ♪
Stocks Fall as Huang Resigns, Nvidia Turns to CFO full transcript
0:01 The countdown is on. Everything you need to get the edge at
0:05 the end of the market day. This is the close.
0:11 An AI boom and a CEO bust. Live from studio two here at Bloomberg
0:16 headquarters in New York. I'm Romaine Bostick, and I'm Jasmine.
0:19 And we're kicking you off to the closing bell here in the U.S..
0:22 Let's get a check on where markets stand right now.
0:24 The S&P 500 down just about 2/10 of a percent coming off of those lows, after
0:28 it was down as much as 9/10 of a percent earlier.
0:32 But looking at chipmakers of course Nvidia coming off those lows but still
0:35 was down as much as 14% earlier at one point erasing more than $600 billion.
0:41 But you're seeing actually if you're looking at AMD and then also Broadcom,
0:46 those are catching a bit. The two best performers in the S&P 500.
0:49 You also saw William Blair upgrading AMD to outperform previously market perform
0:54 here. As you're seeing other quarters of sell
0:57 side looking into the eye trade here. And then of course oil prices.
1:00 Brent crude actually up more than 3% right now, trading around close to $96 a
1:07 barrel. You had Trump declaring that the U.S.
1:09 doesn't need a deal with Iran. But if you look over what's happening
1:12 with the U.S. ten year Treasury yield five spot one
1:15 here. So crossing back above that 5% level
1:17 remain. Well, we go back to Nvidia.
1:19 The shares down 3% down as much as 14% on the day.
1:22 And we're going to spend most of the show discussing that stunning departure
1:26 of Jensen Wong from the chip company he and two fellow engineers sketched out 33
1:30 years ago at a Denny's restaurant in East San Jose, California.
1:34 A fabulous designer of 3D graphics chips.
1:37 Its first chip, the envy one. It was a flop.
1:39 It almost put the company out of business.
1:41 But a big breakthrough in the late 1990s with the GeForce 256, which Wong himself
1:46 dubbed the world's first GPU, that would lay the foundation for the AI juggernaut
1:51 that it would evolve into by the 2020s. But of course, in the span of two weeks,
1:56 three decades of work being put at risk. Here is what we know to be true.
2:00 Now, on October 29th, The New York Times reported that U.S.
2:04 officials had concluded a woman who had had a close relationship with Huang was a
2:08 Chinese intelligence asset. A week later, Nvidia's board opened an
2:12 independent investigation, and emails from Huang to employees admitted that he
2:19 was unfaithful to his wife. A couple of days later, the information
2:22 reported that the woman Huang was said to have been involved with facilitated
2:26 about $7.5 billion in Nvidia chip purchases, including chips.
2:32 The U.S. had banned from export because of
2:34 national security interest. By Wednesday, November 11th, multiple
2:38 news reports, including from The New York Times, cited a second personal
2:42 relationship that Huang had had that may have been in conflict with ethical
2:45 practices. And by this morning, November 12th, Huang
2:48 had resigned. CFO Colette Kress was appointed interim
2:51 CEO. Former Synopsys CEO Harvey Jones became
2:55 Nvidia's first ever board chair, and multiple members of Congress said they
3:00 were ready to launch investigative hearings into what exactly had been
3:03 going on inside the house that Jensen Huang built.
3:07 The market reaction has been mixed, with investors punishing Nvidia's stock while
3:11 bidding up Nvidia's competitors like AMD and Broadcom.
3:14 But the commentary from Wall Street, it's been anything but mixed.
3:19 So this is a freaking disaster at this point.
3:21 Unfortunately, this is a story of hubris and poor corporate governance.
3:26 We're going to see headlines coming out in dribs and drabs, probably for months
3:30 anyways. Um, it's just too much for me.
3:33 I'd rather watch the circus from outside the tent.
3:35 At this point, I just can't see anybody stepping in.
3:38 Trump should meet with President XI next week.
3:40 To make a real point of how serious we're taking this.
3:43 This could actually accelerate the decoupling in terms of the two different
3:48 technology between the US and China. So I think that could be a potential
3:53 Fundamental impact for, if anything, the market saying, yeah, I could lose a bit
3:57 of market share, we could go to AMD and Broadcom.
4:00 And you saying that reaction to mine. But it's not an all out derailment if
4:03 they all tried in any capacity at the moment.
4:06 So we kick off that discussion today with Ross Gerber co-founder president
4:10 and CEO of Gerber Kawasaki Wealth and Investment Management.
4:14 And Ross, let's first start with the transition that is taking place right
4:18 now. Colette Kress, a well-respected CFO of
4:21 this company, for a while now, in the interim seat, obviously a formal search
4:25 for a permanent replacement will be underway.
4:28 I know there's a lot to parse about what happened, but I want you to just look a
4:32 little bit into the future here. Will Nvidia be all right?
4:36 Oh, for sure. I mean, you know, we have to separate
4:39 the vision of this man and the great job he had done building the image of Nvidia
4:45 and the image of AI around his sort of Z guess.
4:50 And, you know, the actual business of Nvidia is not changing, I can't imagine.
4:56 You know, I'm a hyper scalar and I need chips.
4:58 So now I'm not going to buy an Nvidia chip over this.
5:01 That is not going to happen. People want the best technology.
5:05 Nvidia is the best technology. They want to build out their AI systems.
5:08 They have the best solutions. I don't think it changes their business
5:12 per se on the short term. I think it's more about how they sell it
5:16 to customers in the future, and how they sell the vision of AI to the public.
5:21 And this was another black eye for the PR of eye in the public.
5:25 Well, I am curious too, on this idea that people are going to still buy this.
5:29 A lot of the quotes that we played before you, I'll focus a little bit more
5:33 on what may potentially come out of Washington.
5:36 The idea that if there is a level of scrutiny with regards to national
5:40 security and whether some of the chips that weren't supposed to be sold to
5:44 China somehow got into the hands of China to do those investigations and to
5:49 look into that potentially hamper the pace of business for India going
5:53 forward? Yes and no.
5:56 You know, once again, Washington is so dysfunctional.
5:59 I mean, they really need to be investigating themselves.
6:02 The amount of malfeasance that the president of the United States is
6:06 currently doing should be investigated, not, you know, a couple billion dollars
6:11 of chips. Okay.
6:12 So not to say not to try to minimize the this incredible error in judgment that
6:17 Johnson Huang has has sort of forced the entire world to reckon with.
6:22 But I also think Washington should be the least people investigating anybody
6:29 but themselves. So the amount of conflicts and issues
6:32 are insane. So that's why I actually don't think
6:35 this will go very far. Because if they start asking too many
6:38 questions, they're going to end up snagging more people involved in
6:41 Washington. Ross, who do you think ultimately wins
6:44 and loses out of the situation, especially when you're thinking about
6:46 some of these hyperscalers like Microsoft, Amazon, Google that were
6:50 forced to buy these chips. Can they prove to the market that they
6:53 could potentially use their own chips, and could that be a game changer for
6:56 them? No.
6:57 Listen, listen. You cannot use other chips, okay?
7:01 When you're talking about inference and you're talking about AI and you're
7:04 talking about building a data center, AMD doesn't hold a torch to an Nvidia
7:08 chip. And anything that's being built custom
7:11 is still in the design and manufacture process.
7:14 And only Google I think, has some TPUs to sell and nobody can meet demand.
7:19 That's not going to change anytime soon. I think what this really is about is
7:24 about the vision and pushing the vision of the technology into the future.
7:29 And also, you know, Jensen is a phenomenal salesperson, so maybe it's
7:34 tougher on them in competition. But I just I don't see the the you know,
7:39 here's Jensen and his personal errors that have caused his downfall to I need
7:45 to build a data center so I can compete in the industry I'm in.
7:48 Let's say I'm Lily and I'm trying to, like, build AI systems to run health
7:53 care on. I'm not changing that because Jenson is
7:56 there or not there. And I think people have to separate the
7:59 man from the business. The business is a phenomenal business
8:02 run by great people, and hopefully Colette is like a Tim Cook and can calm
8:06 everything down and keep it going. You know, just the way it's been.
8:10 What will Ross I just want to just push back a little bit on the idea of
8:13 separating the man from the business. I mean, I mean, he has been kind of a
8:16 singular figure in Nvidia's rise, for better or worse.
8:18 And I know we've talked in this program a lot about these sort of outsized
8:22 founders who, um, dominate the discussion, for better or for worse,
8:26 whether it's an Elon Musk or a mark Zuckerberg or somebody like that.
8:29 And I do wonder, I mean, I understand the business itself has a foundation,
8:34 but when one man is so identified with the vision and the just, the ethos of
8:41 what a company is, and all of a sudden he's gone and particularly gone in a
8:43 manner that wasn't smooth. He basically just had the keys taken
8:46 from him. That doesn't give you a worry at all.
8:49 I'm in no shape to call it at all. But she's not Jensen.
8:52 Well, no, I'm not saying I'm happy or anything.
8:55 This was not my choice. I'm a large investor in Nvidia.
8:59 We have a lot of money that we've made fortunes on this investment over the
9:03 last decade. Our cost basis is .50.
9:07 So I don't want to minimize the incredible job that Jensen's done.
9:11 But the idea that he did this on his own without an entire company of people is
9:16 sort of like, you know, we like to think that, but that's not reality.
9:20 You know, I think many companies have deep, especially trillion dollar
9:25 companies have deep benches of very competent people.
9:28 They certainly have enough money to hire whoever they want.
9:31 I think it's about the way we view Nvidia was so intermixed with who Jensen
9:38 is that that is the hard part for us, is separating the man from the company
9:42 because he was the company in our mind, you know?
9:45 But the reality is people want the chips.
9:48 They're going to buy the chips whether Jensen is alive or dead, to be honest.
9:51 And, you know, many, many good companies have gone through these existential
9:57 crisis and they come out the other end. And and I expect that Nvidia will too.
10:01 And they've had other crises in the past as well.
10:03 But that said, I'm not trying to minimize how important of a person he
10:08 was to the company. And to your point, Ross, I mean, to be
10:11 fair, I mean, I was going through the numbers prior to this show.
10:14 There was no CEO in modern history. It has created the type of shareholder
10:18 value in such a short time at this scale.
10:21 I mean, I literally went all the way back to like the Rockefeller era.
10:24 No, I mean, it's amazing. And I mean, I ran out of steam and just
10:27 gave up. So he gets credit for that.
10:30 Um, we are talking about Jensen Wong. I brought up Elon Musk, and I do just
10:35 want to bring some breaking news to our viewers and get your opinion on it as
10:38 well. And this involves SpaceX and Tesla.
10:41 Bloomberg is now reporting that merger discussions for those two companies are
10:45 now said to be progressing, and that an actual decision or some action, it
10:50 should come within weeks. I want your reaction to that, right.
10:53 This is exactly why this is happening right now.
10:55 So so Elon can get this merger through without anybody paying too much
10:59 attention. And this would not surprise me in the
11:02 least bit. So, you know, talk about troubles and
11:06 conflicts and having affairs with women and children and all this kind of mess.
11:11 I mean, Elon's like the definition of it.
11:13 So I, I think, you know, Jensen's taken a hard pill to swallow because he held
11:19 himself to such a high standard, and then he failed in such a miserable way
11:23 by having relationships with employees and a Chinese spy, which are really two
11:28 of the worst choices you could possibly make for having an affair.
11:32 Okay, so you know, it's a self-destruction.
11:36 There's no question. You know, Elon's real good at
11:38 self-destruction, too. And I've been dealing with these guys
11:41 who have made me the most money of any two men in my career besides Tim Cook
11:47 and Steve Jobs. So I can't explain it, you know?
11:51 But I think that these companies survive.
11:53 I think they're great companies. And and maybe this will help them in a
11:57 lot of ways, these crises bring the most talented people to the top.
12:02 So I'm hoping that's what happens in this case.
12:04 Hey, Ross, if you're able to be on that conference call for earnings next week,
12:07 what would be your question that you would ask the company?
12:11 I think the biggest issue I have is where they see Jensen in the future.
12:15 So he stepped down as CEO. A lot of people are speculating he's
12:19 going to go to space. He's going to go to Apple.
12:22 Um, Tim Cook's going to you know, Trump wants Tim Cook who doesn't know anything
12:25 about AI running freaking Nvidia. You know, this is all nonsense.
12:30 What I want to know is he stepped down as CEO.
12:33 Does Nvidia have a role for him in the future.
12:35 That's not CEO but maybe its chief vision officer or something.
12:40 Or is he going to be separated from the company completely and just be done?
12:44 Because I feel a lot more comfortable with him still being involved with the
12:48 company in some capacity, even as a consultant.
12:50 Yeah, well, I don't know. Or something that maybe I don't know.
12:53 I maybe it's my question is why I don't take my particular I know you hate
12:56 Washington, but they're going to be all over this.
12:58 So maybe a clean break. Yeah.
12:59 They just want attention. But once the attention turns to them,
13:02 it'll go away. Ross always appreciate it.
13:04 Ross Gerber, Co-Founder, president CEO of Gerber Kawasaki Wealth and Investment
13:08 Management. And you know, just to Ross's point about
13:10 value creation, I was going through it. I mean, you're basically talking about a
13:13 company that went from a $300 billion market cap four years ago to almost 6
13:18 trillion last month before all of this fell apart.
13:21 Tim Cook took his company from a $300 billion range up to $4 trillion, but
13:26 that was over a 14 year stretch. I was even looking at Satya Nadella over
13:29 at Microsoft, he had a similar run, but again, that was over more than a decade.
13:34 Same thing with Steve Jobs. Jeff Bezos, you keep going.
13:37 I had to go back to like, the Jack Welch era to find anything that ever comes
13:40 close. And then after that, you're basically
13:42 talking about like the Vanderbilts and Rockefeller and Carnegie Mellon.
13:45 Well, he added more than 700,000% of his tenure there to Nvidia's stock.
13:50 Yeah. So big moves there.
13:51 Yeah. Will it be interesting to see what the
13:53 next chapter is? And of course, that is a big focus of
13:55 the close today on what that next chapter might be.
13:58 But our coverage, it does continue. Here on Bloomberg Television approaching
14:03 this angle from all sides, including the implications for US-China relations and
14:06 national security. We're going to handle our have a former,
14:10 uh, deputy U.S. Trade representative, Emily Gilcrease,
14:14 on the program in just a bit, as well as Chris Maguire, the man who actually
14:17 wrote the Chips act under Biden. That restricted a lot of those chips
14:20 that were said to have actually gone to China anyway.
14:23 Plus, from the white House to the boardroom rules, sit down with Disney,
14:27 Coca-Cola and Under Armour board member Carolyn Everson live for a look at the
14:31 inner workings of corporate transitions. And there are a lot of questions out
14:35 there about the corporate governance at India and whether it had any.
14:39 We're going to hear from Nell Mattel, chair of about Value Edge Advisors, as
14:43 well as Charles Elson, founding director of the Weinberg Center for Corporate
14:46 Governance at the University of Delaware.
14:48 Don't go anywhere. The best coverage is up next right here
14:51 on Bloomberg.
15:08 The fallout over Jensen Wong's departure at Nvidia, reverberating from Wall
15:12 Street to Washington, and now US-China relations are in the spotlight amid that
15:17 upheaval. Let's go now to the white House lawn,
15:19 where senior white House in Washington correspondent for Bloomberg News, Jeff
15:23 Mason is standing outside. And Jeff, I know we've actually heard
15:26 from the president weigh in on a couple of interesting points with regards to
15:30 this scandal. Um, should Wall Street expect maybe a
15:34 little bit more out of Washington when it comes to finding out exactly what
15:37 happened here. Good question.
15:39 I mean, this president certainly has a close relationship with Jensen Huang, so
15:45 it's possible that he knows more that he's not sharing.
15:47 It's possible that they've been in touch, but it's hard to say what he's
15:51 going to share and to what extent. Um, you know, there's there's any
15:55 involvement between the president and, uh, the board.
15:59 I mean, I don't have any reporting that suggest that other than the fact that
16:02 the president so far has been very supportive of, uh, Jensen Huang until he
16:07 stepped down and then, uh, weighed in with a post this morning saying that,
16:11 uh, Tim Cook should take over as the chief executive.
16:14 Well, I don't I'm the wrong guy to answer whether or not that there's
16:18 anything realistic about that possibility.
16:20 But it does show that the president, uh, likes to weigh in and likes to stay
16:23 connected to what has become a big story.
16:26 That said, I'll I'll add to that that it is also a big story for him as he heads
16:31 to Asia, and he's doing that next week. He has meeting scheduled with President
16:36 XI of China. And there's no question that this
16:39 controversy is going to hang over that meeting.
16:42 To what extent he brings it up, to what extent President XI brings it up is
16:46 something that we don't know now, but it's certainly something that will be in
16:50 the not just the background. I think probably the foreground of this
16:53 third face to face meeting that President Trump has with President XI in
16:57 2026. Hey, Geoff.
16:59 So Nvidia of course, is facing multiple Justice Department probes.
17:02 What do we know specifically about this so far.
17:06 TBD on some of that too. Uh, that's that's something that, uh,
17:10 we'd have to we'd have to check with the Department of Justice on.
17:13 I don't have any more details for you on that right now, but it does give another
17:17 sort of side to the fact that though President Trump has been very supportive
17:21 of Jensen Huang, there's also this this legal proceeding going on.
17:25 And there's, of course, the broad question of of national security and to
17:29 what extent national security was compromised because of this affair.
17:34 Affair with an alleged spy, Jeff Mason.
17:37 Out there on the North Lawn of the white House.
17:39 As we continue our coverage of the scandal and the fallout and what comes
17:43 next out of Washington. Our next guest used to oversee foreign
17:47 investment policy is deputy assistant U.S.
17:49 Trade representative and served on the National Security Council, with a focus
17:53 on international trade, investment and development.
17:55 Emily Gilchrist joins us now, senior fellow, director of energy economics and
17:59 the security program at the center for a New American Security.
18:03 The word security pops up a lot, Emily. And, you know, for all of us sort of
18:07 chuckling about the affairs and other things that Jensen Wong is alleged to
18:11 have done. Underpinning all of this is also the
18:13 idea of whether the Chinese got their hands on chips that they shouldn't have
18:17 gotten their hands on because of some of this purported malfeasance.
18:21 Do you think we're going to see material investigations, either out of the white
18:25 House administration or out of Congress into this?
18:29 Absolutely. I mean, you're certainly already hearing
18:31 from several members of Congress on both sides of the aisle.
18:33 This is really a bipartisan issue at this point that we need to get to the
18:37 bottom of exactly what sort of export control, circumvention and evasion may
18:42 have occurred. It's long been known that cloud service
18:45 providers in jurisdictions like Singapore could be a pretty big and
18:48 boring loophole in U.S. export control policy.
18:51 This scandal is touching on all of those sore spots in those sorts of debates.
18:55 So we're absolutely anticipating not just investigations, but that this sort
19:00 of scandal is going to give a lot of impetus to bills that have been kicking
19:04 around for a while on the hill, trying to tighten up our controls on the export
19:08 of these super sensitive chips that are critical to the AI race.
19:12 I think you're going to see that sort of legislative agenda just get a lot more
19:15 momentum right now, and then we'll see what the administration does.
19:18 I mean, hopefully the Department of Justice is taking this seriously.
19:21 It is a real, genuine national security threat here.
19:24 And hopefully they have the space from political interference to execute on a
19:29 real investigation here raises a lot of questions, too.
19:31 I mean, Nvidia is, for all intents and purposes, the flywheel in this I build
19:38 out. And I do wonder if other companies get
19:39 caught up in this. You run the PLC function on the
19:42 Bloomberg terminal. You can see who buys from them, who
19:45 supplies for them. And it is broad, not just US companies,
19:49 but obviously companies around the world.
19:51 Should other companies out there be talking to their lawyers right now and
19:54 maybe preparing to maybe either go before Congress or the Justice
19:57 Department? Absolutely.
19:59 I mean, I think you should expect a fairly sprawling investigation.
20:03 Um, you know, I think we're still waiting to see what the commercial
20:06 impact of this scandal is going to be. There's a huge transition happening at
20:10 Nvidia. They've never done a CEO transition
20:13 before. Uh, so I think companies that are
20:15 involved in the Nvidia AI ecosystem, which is pretty much every company
20:19 across the I tech stack, uh, tech stack, in one way or another, they're going to
20:23 have to think about the commercial impact, and they're going to have to
20:25 think about to what extent their commercial dealings with Nvidia are
20:29 going to come under the spotlight of investigators, as investigators just try
20:32 to get a handle on the extent of the damage, how much information may have
20:36 been shared with the Chinese side that really shouldn't have been, and what the
20:41 impact on national security has been. So I would I would expect a pretty
20:44 robust investigation, at least based on what we're hearing from Congress so far.
20:47 What do you think this means overall for the U.S.
20:49 China air race? And does this potentially slow that on
20:53 both sides with this departure? Well, I think we'll see.
20:57 There's factors that cut in both ways. On the one hand Nvidia is at a very
21:01 delicate time right now. And so if they stumble in the midst of
21:04 this CEO transition, you know that's not great for the U.S.
21:07 position in the eye race. But one of the likely political outcomes
21:10 very well could be tougher export controls on a range of issues.
21:15 And that actually helps on the U.S. side quite a bit.
21:17 Compute power chips, really powerful AI infrastructure.
21:21 That's where the U.S. has a lead.
21:22 And so if you see tighter controls to kind of reinforce that lead as a result
21:26 of this scandal. I think that actually helps the US quite
21:28 a bit. What do you think lawmakers, when they
21:30 do talk to him, will be asking him specifically?
21:35 Well, I'm sure they're going to want to try to get to the bottom of exactly what
21:39 sort of information he was sharing. To what extent was, uh, Jensen Wong
21:44 privy to policymaking decisions at the highest level of the U.S.
21:47 government? To what extent was he talking about that
21:49 with the alleged spy with whom he was having an affair?
21:53 And to what extent was there an effort to try to find gray areas or loopholes
21:57 in U.S. export control policy to ship chips?
21:59 We know that, Nvidia we know that Jensen Huang has been very opposed to U.S.
22:04 export controls for a very long time. And so I think investigators are really
22:08 going to want to take a hard look at how much of that was driven by commercial
22:12 interests, and how much of that may have been swayed by this particular
22:15 relationship. Uh, I'm curious though.
22:17 I mean, you were pretty central in kind of drafting some of these spheres of
22:21 regulations, if you will, the rules, whatever, whatever we call them.
22:24 This idea sort of, you know, looking at our technology, us, uh, born technology
22:30 and making sure that it doesn't fall into the hands of countries that could
22:33 use this in either military purposes or some other purposes that would threaten
22:38 our national security. What was the argument, though, that
22:41 Johnson long and other CEOs, for that matter, made as to allowing maybe a
22:45 little bit more free flow of these types of advanced chips?
22:48 Wasn't there an argument there that no matter how many walls we put up to
22:52 protect this, that one way or another, the Chinese, if they wanted it, we're
22:56 going to be able to get their hands on the technology.
22:59 Well, there was an argument, but to be clear, it's not one that many people in
23:03 the national security community actually thought was a good argument.
23:06 I mean, the argument was China's ecosystem is building out.
23:09 It's going to be a huge market opportunity.
23:11 We can keep them addicted to U.S. technology, and that provides the U.S.
23:15 leverage. But I think the easy counter argument to
23:18 that is, well, Nvidia's got plenty of market opportunities outside of China.
23:22 China's whole AI strategy is based on developing self-sufficiency and beating
23:27 the United States. So in that context, and given all the
23:30 other challenges we have in the relationship with China right now, I
23:34 think that you could find very few people in the national security
23:36 community who are convinced by this kind of commercial.
23:39 Let's keep China addicted to AI technology argument.
23:42 It just never really held water for many.
23:44 Emily, I appreciate it. Emily Kilkenny, senior fellow director
23:47 of energy economics and security program over at the center for New American
23:51 Security. As we continue our focus now, not so
23:55 much on what Johnson Wong did, but what exactly the board knew and why we didn't
24:01 get a little bit more of a reaction out of them.
24:04 Collette Kress, the interim CEO, a company that up until today didn't even
24:08 have an independent board chair. It has one now, a company that up until
24:13 today didn't have a succession plan. I guess maybe it has one now.
24:17 No. Minnow joins us right now.
24:19 The chair of Value Edge Advisors. And now that is where I want to start.
24:23 I was a little surprised, though not surprised, that this company had never
24:27 had an independent board chair. I was even more surprised that for a guy
24:31 who had been at the helm for 33 years, that they hadn't had any type of formal
24:36 succession plan put out there. And I know we've talked a lot on this
24:39 program about corporate governance or the lack thereof.
24:43 How does a company that, just up until a few weeks ago, was the most valuable
24:47 company in the world, not have a succession plan or any sort of
24:51 independent board oversight? That is literally the issue that boards
24:55 fail on the most, and the time that they fail on it the most is exactly this
24:59 situation. This board had the easiest job on the
25:02 planet. They got good news and they went home.
25:05 They didn't want to rock any boats. They didn't want to ask any hard
25:08 questions. And they thought that they had a 1 in
25:11 1,000,000,000,000 person running the company.
25:14 They, you know, the the job of trying to think about a replacement was just too
25:17 daunting and that is a huge mistake. You always need to have an envelope in
25:22 the desk drawer with the name of your person.
25:24 You're going to call in in an emergency, and you also have to have a list of
25:28 people within and outside of the organization that you're thinking of as
25:32 possible replacements. Uh, nobody is that valuable.
25:36 You know, we talk about Key Man and certainly a founder who was behind the
25:40 actual design of the product, who was a great salesman.
25:44 That is a hard guy to replace. And that's why boards have to get on
25:47 that right away. The other question, though, and I'm
25:50 going to be sensitive about this, is also the idea of what the board could
25:54 have known and whether they could have acted based on Bloomberg reporting, as
25:58 well as reporting by The New York Times, the Wall Street Journal, that at least
26:01 some of the directors were aware of the allegations regarding Jensen long months
26:07 ago. And what is the obligation for the board
26:10 to actually act on that, particularly given at least what we know today?
26:14 There was no definitive evidence of malfeasance.
26:18 There were plenty of red flags, including photographs that were very,
26:24 very indicative of some kind of a relationship.
26:27 Listen, let's just take the spying out of it for one minute and say that
26:32 there's absolutely all kinds of reasons that the CEO should not be having a
26:38 romantic relationship with one of his largest customers.
26:42 Uh, that is the kind of situation where, if that's happening to the CEO has got
26:46 to go to the board and say, I'm now recusing myself from all negotiations
26:50 with this customer. He did the opposite.
26:53 Uh, and, you know, I understand that it's embarrassing and it's kind of
26:56 cringe to go to a CEO and say, can you tell us if you're having an affair?
27:01 But they have to do it. And the fact that we now learn that he's
27:04 having an affair with one of his direct reports just makes it worse.
27:08 You have to ask yourself what I would. I fire a middle manager for doing this.
27:13 And if the answer is yes, then you have to take it seriously.
27:17 And we should just point out for our viewers just of course, that is based on
27:19 reporting by Reuters, citing people familiar with the situation.
27:22 Now, I'm curious what sort of precedence, if at all, can we use to
27:25 potentially glean this? Because, I mean, obviously this is a
27:28 huge company, but what could we potentially look back to for any sort of
27:31 guidance as to how this all ends up playing out for the company?
27:36 Well, there are some ways in which it's not unusual.
27:38 There have been a number of situations in the past where even major companies
27:42 have had to confront CEOs who've had inappropriate relationships and have
27:45 acted ultimately, correctly. But what makes this one different is
27:50 that this company is unique in one way, not because of its CEO, but because of
27:55 the role that it is playing in our economy and the connections that it has
27:58 to all of the companies that are driving our economy right now.
28:01 We have to think about what this company makes, the same way we thought about
28:06 nuclear secrets during the course of the Cold War.
28:09 This is something that everybody wants, and we have to be much, much more
28:13 careful about it. Uh, and the fact that this company plays
28:17 such a pivotal role that it's impinging on national security decisions, uh, is
28:24 probably something that Washington is going to take as seriously as it is
28:28 taking the, uh, in investigation into the details.
28:31 But I'm curious, getting back also to the broader issues of succession and
28:35 oversight, do you think other companies will take it seriously?
28:38 Because for all of those sort of, uh, you know, singularity that we sort of
28:42 look at when it comes to Jensen Wong and his leadership of Nvidia.
28:45 I mean, let's be honest, you know, there are several other companies that are in
28:48 the same boat. And I do wonder if this could
28:51 potentially be a wake up call for some of those boards to tighten up their
28:54 oversight, succession planning, etc.. I certainly hope so.
28:58 And I also hope that it reminds all boards, uh, that they need to be as
29:04 careful about this kind of personal hacking as they are about computer
29:08 hacking. This is the oldest way to get
29:11 information on the books going back to Mata Hari and before.
29:14 And, uh, they need to be very careful about it, I guarantee you, uh, this is
29:18 not the only executive who is having a relationship with a spy
29:24 now. Always great, always candid.
29:26 Nell Minow, chair of Value Advisors, as we continue our coverage here.
29:30 Uh, just, uh, obviously the fallout from the resignation, uh, I guess the words
29:35 of what we're calling it, ouster of Jensen Wong from Nvidia, a company, of
29:39 course, that, uh, he helped to build starting about 33 years ago.
29:43 We should point out there were two other co-founders.
29:45 Were, uh, they've kind of, you know, moved on to other things.
29:47 And Jensen has kind of become the rock star of it all.
29:50 But I think the broader question for markets right now is this just an Nvidia
29:53 story, or does this become a broader story about the AI, especially today?
29:56 You're seeing AMD as well as Broadcom catching that big.
29:59 Still some other chip stocks lower in the SoCs.
30:01 But just seeing how this all ends up playing out for some of these
30:04 competitors as well as those hyperscalers we were talking about
30:06 earlier. As far as the broad market reaction is
30:08 relatively muted. All the major indices are in the red,
30:12 but we're talking about a fraction of a percent, including for the Nasdaq 100,
30:16 which is down about a half a percent on the day.
30:19 We want to continue our conversation here and continue the focus here on
30:22 what's been going on in the boardroom and the intrigue surrounding Nvidia.
30:26 Our next guest is a front row seat when it comes to the inner workings of a
30:29 boardroom. Carolyn Everson is a board member at
30:32 Coca-Cola, Disney Under Armour and a senior advisor at Premier.
30:35 Great to see you, Carolyn. Thanks for having me.
30:37 I want to talk about this broader question of when an executive's personal
30:42 conduct becomes an interest of the corporation itself.
30:49 Um, obviously there's a lot of there's a lot we don't know, of course, about what
30:52 has been alleged about Jensen Wonka himself.
30:54 But when you're on a board and you get maybe some information about the CEO or
30:58 another executive doing something that, if not, runs afoul of the rules and
31:03 ethics of the company, but maybe gets close to that line.
31:07 What is the conversation that the board has at that time?
31:10 The most important thing a board can do for any company is CEO oversight and
31:14 Succession. And that is the most important job.
31:19 And so if an allegation were to come in, the board would be obligated to
31:23 investigate it, especially if it's against the company's code of conduct.
31:27 And every company has a different code of conduct written.
31:30 But that would be very clear. If something was against code of
31:32 conduct, it would need to investigate. You've served on boards for quite some
31:36 time, and there's been a lot of discussion that board oversight has got
31:39 overall has gotten worse than what it was some years back.
31:43 Um, obviously, a lot of people will look at succession planning not just for
31:46 Nvidia, but there are a lot of companies being run by founders who've been in
31:49 those CEO chairs for decades. And there are a lot of questions as to
31:54 is there really an envelope with a backup name in there?
31:57 Should that person get hit by a bus or or something else?
32:00 Do you think oversight has worsened? Is it about the same as what it was
32:04 years ago? I can speak from the three public boards
32:07 that I serve on, and we just completed two CEO successions.
32:11 And I will tell you, it is not a one day event that takes months of work.
32:15 We are very proud of the thorough process we ran both at the Walt Disney
32:19 Company and the Coca-Cola company, and that is the job of the board is to have
32:24 a succession plan in place to understand what the leadership benches ensure
32:29 you're developing talent for the proverbial.
32:31 What happens if the CEO were to be hit by a bus?
32:35 There are those discussions and it's called the hit the bus scenario.
32:39 And what has happened at Nvidia is every board's worst nightmare that you have to
32:43 jump in and be ready to go. And I think the board is showing
32:47 leadership here. They have put the interim CEO in place.
32:51 They've named an outside chair for the first time in Nvidia's history, and
32:55 there will be an investigation done. And I think they're taking the necessary
32:58 governance steps. And do you think this was also necessary
33:01 as soon as they did it? Because if it would have dragged out,
33:04 how else would that affect? Obviously the company, the stock price
33:07 as well, just globally when it comes to the eye trade.
33:10 I think the story is one of the most profound things that we have seen in our
33:14 lifetime. It affects not only a 33 year old
33:17 company with a founder at the helm. There are tens of thousands of
33:21 employees. There's this family, of course, first
33:24 and foremost, there are customers. Nvidia is owned widely by retail
33:29 investors. I know you've been reporting that all
33:30 day, not just retail investors, but it's in people's 401 K.
33:34 It's affecting millions of people, and it also impacts the entire technology
33:39 industry as well as America's competitiveness with China.
33:42 So this story has multiple layers. This is not a normal company having an
33:49 issue with their founder or CEO. So all this into forcing more boards to
33:53 have some sort of succession plan. If there is a lack thereof for some of
33:56 them to look, I think boards need to be on top of all of these issues.
34:01 I mean, when the United Healthcare CEO, you know, was horrific.
34:04 Murdered in New York City. I can tell you that every board, whether
34:08 it's boards I'm on or other boards that I know people on, everyone discussed, do
34:12 we have the right security levels for the CEO when something happens like
34:16 this? Or God forbid, you know, a CEO you know,
34:19 gets sick and is unable to serve. That is the primary role of a board.
34:24 And it cannot be there. You know, just happens once a year.
34:28 The succession conversation has to go on all the time.
34:32 You said something a minute ago that that kind of struck me, the idea that
34:35 this is much bigger than Nvidia. I mean, obviously they have been one of
34:38 the primary drivers for the AI boom because they basically sold the only
34:42 chip that, at least up until the last few months, could basically do the task
34:47 needed to build these large language models.
34:49 But we've seen I evolve a lot. Uh, it's become more than just about the
34:52 GPUs or the CPUs. It's now about the health care company
34:55 to find a more efficient way to run their operations, or a finance company,
34:59 uh, or media company for that matter. Um, I know you look around a lot, and
35:04 you may be a consumer products company. I don't know.
35:06 Um, but are you starting to see in your world more use cases, more real world
35:11 use cases for AI, but use cases that are providing or at least have the potential
35:16 to provide a tangible return on investment.
35:19 Yes. As a matter of fact, I am a senior
35:21 advisor at BCG, and we released a survey in September that showed upwards of 50%
35:27 of companies are now seeing some value from AI.
35:30 That is up dramatically from a year ago, where only 5% saw significant value.
35:36 So the timing of what is happening here is, is in a landscape where companies
35:42 are starting to acquire more customers, deliver new products and services
35:47 because of it. Uh, I get more efficiency.
35:50 And so arguably, it's one of the more exciting times for businesses in AI.
35:54 Not every business, for every challenge needs to use the top LMS.
35:58 They can use a variety of them. And if you head into this holiday
36:02 season, we're really optimistic about what the role of I is going to be.
36:07 We think there are going to be an enormous amount of agents shopping on
36:10 behalf of consumers. Yeah.
36:12 It'll be trillion holiday season is what the National Federation of
36:16 Retailers is expecting and consumers that are coming through.
36:20 I, after having done some research, are converting at a 90% better rate than
36:25 consumers that don't use I. What can I follow up on that?
36:28 Because I've been talking with a lot of retailers late, kind of in preparation
36:31 for, for the holiday season. And they have talked about this idea of
36:35 how the customer, the first touchpoint they're getting with customers now are
36:38 starting to come either from a generic I, uh, the agents or some other sort of
36:43 technology point. I mean, you know, consumer brands and
36:46 you understand how important it is for that brand to connect with the consumer.
36:49 Just having that middleman, a middle agent, if you will.
36:53 Does that affect your relationship with the customer as a brand?
36:57 I think brands are going to be even more important.
37:00 And and the services and product products they provide.
37:03 But there is no question that agents are going to be an intermediary between
37:09 consumers and the actual brands in terms of transactions.
37:12 I mean, just in the last 24 hours, you saw United Airlines say they were not
37:16 going to let agents complete an A ticket booking, but the agents will do the
37:21 research to look at the different fares and then make a recommendation to the
37:25 consumer. And we are entering a period where there
37:28 will be more agents than consumers. There will be more agents than humans,
37:32 both outside the office acting on behalf of consumers as well as in companies
37:37 acting in addition to employees. And companies really need to prepare for
37:43 that from a governance perspective. Back to a governance topic that I'm very
37:46 passionate about. I'm very passionate about the governance
37:49 layer that needs to exist, to allow consumers to transact with commerce
37:53 sites, to allow consumers to transact with financial institutions.
37:57 I serve as an advisor on a company called mural, just completed series A
38:01 funding tackling that. I served on the board of the um, a
38:05 company trying to provide the governance layer for robotics.
38:09 And so that is going to be a whole new area.
38:11 How far away from that I think we are. Well, we already have unbelievable
38:16 growth in muse, instinct, grok, bot dots, and the list goes on.
38:21 There's over 20 that have been funded in the VC world that I'm aware of.
38:25 So I think consumers are now using about 49% of consumers will say they have used
38:30 AI in some form, whether it's an agent or just asking it a question.
38:33 But the real power is agentic.
38:36 Uh, Commerce that's coming. I wanted to go back just quickly to talk
38:39 about that successor situation with Nvidia and Ian Buck.
38:43 He's the vice president at Nvidia. And so he really focuses on the
38:46 datacenter side of that. And people are looking for someone with
38:49 operational experience. What do you think he needs to do in the
38:51 coming days. And other executives there to kind of
38:54 give that sort of credibility. I think the most important thing in the
38:57 coming days is that the new interim CEO and the board and the chair give the
39:02 employees stability. Obviously, their earnings are coming out
39:05 next week. There is going to be an all hands that
39:07 the interim CEO has announced on November 18th.
39:09 I think they're taking the necessary steps for stability.
39:12 They need to stabilize internally as well as the external customers and all
39:17 of the companies that Nvidia is involved in, from a funding and partnership
39:21 perspective. Caroline, really great to have you.
39:24 Thanks for taking all our questions, which are probably a little bit
39:26 different than when we first got you, but that's true.
39:29 It's not what I expected today, but thank you for having me.
39:31 Your expertise is, uh, well valued here. Caroline Everson, their senior advisor
39:35 over at, uh, at a board member over at Disney Under Armour and a Coca-Cola.
39:40 And just a reminder, of course, we are going to get Nvidia earnings next week
39:43 on November 17th. Also, at one point next week, we are
39:47 expected to get anthropic coming to market with its IPO.
39:52 But believe it or not, that might actually be overshadowed by the release
39:55 of Grand Theft Auto six. Yeah, we're making a hard pivot here
39:58 because the gaming community is all over this, and we actually had a chance to
40:01 catch up with the CEO of the streaming platform Twitch, which is actually
40:05 holding its annual conference out there in San Diego today.
40:09 Here's what he had to say about the popularity of the game's launch, and
40:12 whether his platform can handle all the traffic that could come his way.
40:18 Obviously, you've spent a lot of time making sure that our system is ready for
40:21 that. Um, it could easily be one of the
40:24 biggest moments on Twitch. We've had a lot of big moments.
40:27 Um, but this one will be special, um, and unique.
40:30 We've also spent a lot of time making sure that our creators can monetize
40:34 effectively. Uh, we work closely with a number of
40:37 advertisers because, um, one of the challenges in this space is advertisers
40:42 want to be part of the GTA six launch. Um, and we build technology that makes
40:46 it so any of the parts of GTA six that they might not want to have their ads
40:50 associated with their heads won't be associated with that which giving them
40:54 an opportunity to be part of this moment.
40:56 And the thing that I think of most about this moment is it highlights.
41:01 What is really interesting about Twitch is GTA is just this rich world upon
41:07 which our creators are going to do things that we have no idea what it will
41:11 be. And it really goes back to our creators
41:13 and their creativity and their inventiveness, because GTA six is this
41:17 amazing space that people will be moving around and doing stuff.
41:20 And the one thing that everyone knows is nobody knows exactly what's going to
41:25 happen once the game launches and everyone starts exploring, uh, Vice
41:29 City, right. And there's been a lot of reports just
41:32 about the depth, uh, of what we're going to see out of this game.
41:35 So. So how does that translate on Twitch in
41:36 terms of how long sort of, uh, this explosion will be?
41:40 I mean, it's released on November 19th, as does this Peter out in a couple of
41:43 weeks. Are you preparing for this to maybe be a
41:45 month long type of a boost to traffic on the site?
41:49 Yeah, I think it's going to keep going for a while.
41:51 I think you're starting to bring people back that, you know, have loved Twitch
41:54 before, but, um, you know, have been doing other things.
41:57 They're busy. And this will be a moment for them to
42:00 rediscover the creators that they've spent so much time with.
42:03 And I think it's a game that is going to have so many nooks and crannies in so
42:08 many different ways that you can play it, that our creators will continue to
42:12 find new ways to do interesting things in the game.
42:16 They'll create challenges, will create competitions, they'll premetro.
42:20 It just they'll keep making it as long as it becomes a palette for people to do
42:25 interesting things. It's really a platform for their
42:28 creativity. I think two weeks will be long enough
42:30 for people to explore all the same branding through games, so I think
42:33 that's going to go on a while. Yeah, and then next year we expect, um,
42:37 at some point, no idea when, um, they'll continue to, um, invest because
42:42 Rockstar, um, of course this is the um, uh, single player.
42:46 Eventually they'll have online and multiplayer.
42:49 And there's also something called GTA roleplay with you on Twitch, and that's
42:53 going to kind of be reinvigorated and be a big part of things that go into
42:57 January, February. And that's Dan Clancy, of course, the
43:00 CEO of Amazon's Twitch streaming platform.
43:03 Getting ready here for the onslaught of gamers, uh, who are, of course, uh,
43:06 gonna want to show off here when GTA six is released next week.
43:09 I mean, while we have to check in on the broader markets, and we should point out
43:12 it's a down day across Wall Street, just but, uh, obviously this seems to be the
43:16 sell off a little bit more confined to Nvidia and a few of its, uh, uh, I
43:20 guess, uh, direct suppliers. That's right.
43:22 Yeah. I mean, looking at Nvidia down a little
43:24 bit more than 5%, but it was down as much as 14% earlier.
43:28 So that was briefly wiped out more than $600 billion in market value.
43:32 You're looking at the Nasdaq 100 only down around a half of a percent coming
43:35 off those lows. And the S&P 500 only down 4/10 of a
43:38 percent. You look at the stocks.
43:40 The only four stocks are higher. But it's led by AMD and Broadcom.
43:43 And those are the two best performers in the S&P 500.
43:46 is sort of offsetting those other losses in the Sox.
43:48 Well, we should point out to also, there's a lot of activity going on right
43:51 now in the Treasury market, a massive selloff right now that's pushing the two
43:55 year yield up by 13 basis points. And this is somewhat of a parallel move
43:59 13 basis points on a five year, 12 year, uh 12 points up on your ten year and
44:04 about uh, nine points up on the 30 year yield.
44:07 A lot going on across all assets, and we'll be here to cover it for you all.
44:12 We're coming back after the break with Jim Karen, CEO over CIO at Morgan
44:17 Stanley Investment Management.
44:26 I can't imagine, you know, I'm a hyperscale and I need chips.
44:30 So now I'm not going to buy an Nvidia chip over this.
44:33 That is not going to happen. Would people want the best technology?
44:36 Nvidia's the best technology. They want to build out their AI systems.
44:40 They have the best solutions. I don't think it changes their business
44:44 per se on the short term? Ross Gerber kicking us off to the close
44:48 just about 50 minutes ago. And Jess, he kind of gets to a point
44:51 because there's really two stories here. There's obviously the personal story
44:55 involving Johnson Wong, I guess maybe a third story involving espionage as well.
44:59 But there's also the fundamental story, the idea that they sell something that
45:03 as of yesterday, I think everybody wanted.
45:05 So I don't know if that necessarily changed today.
45:08 And so it's really about what the new leadership at Nvidia can do to kind of
45:12 tamp down the noise and refocus on the fundamental aspects of the business a
45:16 national intelligence issue, a supply chain issue, but checking in on the
45:19 markets here, the S&P 500, down 4/10 of a percent coming off of those lows,
45:23 remains thanks to gains at AMD and Broadcom.
45:25 Looking over at the SoCs coming off those lows was down as much as 3.7%
45:30 earlier. Now down less than 1%.
45:32 But of course looking at what's happening in the commodity space with
45:36 Brent crude up more than 3.5%, topping $96 a barrel here, that did happen after
45:42 Trump declared the U.S. doesn't need a deal with Iran, and
45:46 moving over and looking at the ten year Treasury yield five spot 11 right now,
45:51 of course, we do have those producer prices that are going to come out
45:53 tomorrow morning. And then also we have Cisco as well as
45:57 Applied Materials reporting after the bell remain.
45:59 Yeah. Kind of interesting.
46:00 You had that huge spike in yield on Tuesday.
46:03 The bond market of course was closed on Wednesday for the veterans holiday.
46:06 And that selloff continues today. Your ten year yield up 12 basis points
46:11 today. That adds to the 11 basis points of
46:14 which it rose on Tuesday. Jim Karen joins us right now, CEO of the
46:19 Portfolio Solutions Group at Morgan Stanley Investment Management.
46:23 And I do want to get your thoughts in a second on what's going on in the
46:25 Treasury space. But we have to start with the eye trade,
46:27 Jim. And obviously, there's been a lot of
46:29 talk here about the impact of the Jensen Wong scandal on Nvidia, but I'm more
46:35 interested in the sort of the flywheel that Nvidia was to the AI build out writ
46:39 large. And the idea that so much of this had
46:42 been riding on the idea of those chips and the investments that Nvidia had
46:46 made, and a lot of other companies. Do you have any sense here that this
46:50 would actually have any real disruption, longer term to the AI build out?
46:56 Well, good afternoon and thanks for having me on.
46:59 Um, look, I think it's important that we take a step back here.
47:02 Uh, you had mentioned that the fundamentals just broadly, if we if we
47:06 look at the markets today, fundamentals are strong.
47:08 The eye trade is not going away. The ecosystem that fed the AI trade,
47:14 whether it's chips or electrification or anything else, is not going away.
47:20 What we're seeing right now is a reset in prices.
47:23 There's some there's some volatility. And no question there is some unexpected
47:27 events that are taking hold of the markets these days.
47:29 Um, but the demand for the product and the demand for the infrastructure to
47:34 build out AI is going to continue to be there.
47:37 Now, does that morph into, uh, different companies, maybe taking leadership, or
47:42 does that morph into, um, you know, a different growth rate going forward,
47:46 particularly with the new, uh, policy makers and on the midterm elections and
47:50 things like that? Absolutely.
47:52 The markets are figuring this stuff out pretty quickly, and valuations have
47:56 taken a reset down. Um, so I think this is a very
48:00 interesting opportunity to think very, very clearly about where the
48:04 opportunities are and what might be getting cheap, what good technologies
48:08 that we think will be there in the future are now trading at a discount.
48:12 And that's exactly what we're looking at in our portfolios as we invest.
48:17 Well, well, that gets to the idea of the big selloff that we had a week ago,
48:20 because, I mean, there were a lot of dip buyers that came back in, uh, when I
48:23 think some people interpreted the baby being thrown out with the bathwater.
48:27 Was that a buying opportunity for you? Absolutely.
48:29 So so what we did is we sent out a note and we said that it's a reset, not a
48:33 retreat, meaning that if we look at GDP growth 3.4% in the third quarter.
48:38 Look at the unemployment rate 4.1% jobless claims, a strong job openings
48:43 and labor turnover, JOLTS survey also very, very strong.
48:47 We have to think about the vital signs, right?
48:49 So think of a patient going into going into an emergency room.
48:52 And one of these TV shows that we watch and, and the doctor assesses the vital
48:56 signs and vital signs for the economy are still relatively good.
49:01 So whenever we get this type of of a reset in prices, it does give us the
49:06 opportunity to start to think about where we think value might actually be.
49:10 Look, everybody complained about valuations being too high at the start
49:14 of this year. And they were right.
49:15 Valuations have come down. PE multiples have come down.
49:18 And in some sectors, particularly in technology and in the semi space where a
49:22 lot of the growth is going to continue to be, those are the sectors that got
49:26 hit the hardest. So, so we're leaning into this.
49:28 We're not backing away from this. We're looking at the value chain that's
49:33 going to feed the AI cycle. And and we're trying to pick up cheap
49:36 assets on the way. Jim, talk to us about what your
49:39 conversations are like with your clients right now.
49:41 What are some of their biggest concerns? I'm sure you've been taking and fielding
49:45 a lot of calls this weeks from them. Absolutely right.
49:49 So what everybody's worried about is exactly what we're talking about right
49:52 now is the eye trade over. Should we worry about this is you know,
49:56 what's the leverage like in the you know, is this going to be something
49:59 that, you know, it develops into something bigger?
50:02 There's always going to be risk around these different things.
50:04 But but what we're telling our clients is it's exactly what I laid out, is that
50:09 still the fundamental growth is is very strong, that the trajectory that we're
50:14 seeing, if we look at earnings, earnings growth rates are going to slow from
50:18 these levels. Earnings growth rates this year are
50:20 around 30%. Plus.
50:22 They're going to slow to maybe 15 or 16% in 2027 growth rates.
50:27 These that's a really strong growth rate by the way.
50:29 You know that's you know it's really strong.
50:31 But when you're slowing from a 30% to a 15% it feels like the end of the world.
50:35 However, if you look at what's happened to forward p multiples on a on a 12
50:40 month Ford, and even on a 24 month Ford basis, these PE multiples have collapsed
50:45 and in many cases for many of these technology companies, to around ten or
50:50 even 12 times forward earnings. Which to me is not a valuation or a
50:55 multiple that I think is expensive or one that I want to sell.
50:59 As long as we believe, and this is a key part, that we're not moving into a
51:03 recession, we're not, and that's not our base case.
51:06 We do not think that we're moving into a recession.
51:08 So if that's the case, the nominal growth will continue to be above trend
51:12 and we continue to look to shop on sale. What are your thoughts right now, Jim,
51:16 about nominal yields? I mean, we're up something like 30 plus
51:20 basis points on the two year this week alone.
51:22 Yeah. So I mean it's a rebound with the
51:25 rebound in the equity market. Right.
51:26 So there was a flight to quality into U.S.
51:28 treasuries. And that certainly happened.
51:30 And yields fell. And then we've got a sharp rebound
51:33 coming back. We had a very hot CPI number.
51:36 Uh, we're going to probably have a hot PPI number tomorrow and that and that's
51:39 and that's coming out and we're going to have core PCI which is also going to be
51:43 pretty high. But we do think that inflation's
51:45 peaking. And we do think that it is going to
51:47 start coming down. It's going to take some time.
51:49 You know oil prices you know have started to come down.
51:52 It takes a little while before oil prices translate into refined product,
51:56 which is a product that we all by ourselves like gasoline, heating oil and
52:00 diesel and things like that. So we do think that inflation's coming
52:04 down. What it tells me.
52:06 What it tells me is that effectively we're likely to uh stabilize in yields.
52:11 All right Jim always appreciate it. Jim Karen CIO of the portfolio solutions
52:15 Group over at Morgan Stanley Investment Management.
52:18 Counting us down to the close and our global simulcast.
52:23 The closing bell. Bloomberg's comprehensive cross-platform
52:27 coverage of the U.S. market close starts right now.
52:32 And right now we are two minutes away from the end of the trading day.
52:35 Romaine Bostick alongside just taking you through to that closing bell.
52:39 It's a global simulcast. Carol Massar.
52:41 And then they join us now. Welcome to our audiences across all of
52:44 our Bloomberg platform. Television, radio.
52:46 Our partnership with YouTube. An incredible day on Wall Street right
52:51 now. When we take a look at what's going on
52:52 in stocks, what's going on in bonds, what's going on in oil markets, but of
52:57 course, all the focus right now is on one company and one man Nvidia and
53:01 Jensen Wong. Yeah.
53:02 How rare is it that we really have one singular story that dominates not just
53:06 today but really throughout the week? Uh, we're taking a look at shares of
53:10 Nvidia. I'm just going to bring them up on my
53:12 Bloomberg down about 4.4%. Keep in mind this stock was down more
53:15 than 14%. Um, but it's interesting to see that it
53:19 hasn't necessarily taken down completely the eye trade.
53:22 And that we're also seeing some other companies like an AMD or Broadcom
53:25 actually rally and gain on the prospect of maybe gaining some market share as
53:31 Nvidia deals with its woes. Um.
53:33 We were just having a fascinating chat with Lauren Cassidy, the founder and
53:36 chief investment officer of our founders 100 ETF.
53:38 And her ETF has a remit. They only invest in companies that are
53:43 run by founders. Nvidia was the third biggest holding in
53:47 the portfolio at more than 6%. Yeah, they have 90 days to sell all of
53:52 that regardless of what the price does. And she was very clear with us.
53:55 This company without Jensen is not the same company that it once was.
53:59 Yeah. I mean checking in on retail traders,
54:01 they were actually buying the dip. According to JP Morgan, its price
54:05 actually for quarter earnings is only around 11 times forward right now.
54:08 So a lot cheaper than you get a publishing well into your flight though.
54:12 I mean it gets to this idea that okay maybe you remove demand, but has it
54:15 changed the fundamental idea of what it's been selling and the demand and the
54:19 demand, of course, it has actually been coming in for some of those products.
54:24 That remains to be seen. We should point out that there's a lot
54:27 going on in the world of AI beyond just Jensen Huang himself.
54:30 Remember, Nvidia reports earnings next week, but we're also expect to get the
54:34 IPO from anthropic and a redhead crossing the Bloomberg terminal.
54:38 That anthropic IPO is said to be six times oversubscribed.
54:42 Not necessarily a surprise as we see red across the screen parallel with all of
54:46 the major indices down just about a fraction of a percent for the Dow, the
54:49 S&P and the Nasdaq. The Russell 2000 much lower on the day,
54:53 closing down 1.7%. Everybody seems to be eagerly
54:57 anticipating that IPO. Um, in terms of the trade.
55:00 Let's go back there S&P 500. We know the index overall just a little
55:04 bit lower. But most names in that big cap index
55:07 were down today about 379 losing ground. And we did see 124 uh higher in today's
55:13 session. Materials stocks down 1.5% in the S&P
55:16 500 and followed by industrials down around 1%.
55:19 But on the flip side you have Brent crude topping $96 a barrel up more than
55:23 3%. So you're seeing energy stocks gaining
55:25 on that up more than 1.5%. All right.
55:30 Yeah. Let's, uh, let's kind of keep this
55:32 going, guys, because we talk about this idea of the chip space and the idea that
55:37 if you're not going to Nvidia, who are you going to.
55:39 We had Ross Gerber on earlier today and he said, look, you know they have the
55:43 chip everybody wants. Are you going to get that from AMD.
55:45 Are you going to get that from Broadcom. Maybe maybe not.
55:48 We are getting some earnings out of other chip makers.
55:50 That includes applied materials right now.
55:52 And we should point out the knee jerk reaction to the shares is relatively
55:55 muted right now as the company did report EPs relatively in line with
55:59 estimates $4.16 a share. That's 0.10 more than what the street
56:04 was looking for at 406 on average, sales coming in at about 0.4 billion.
56:09 The street was looking for roughly about 0.3 billion.
56:13 And semiconductor systems net sales in the most recent quarter, its fiscal
56:17 fourth quarter $8 billion. On the nose, the street was looking for
56:20 7.94. Yeah.
56:22 Interesting, right. This is a stock that's been on fire when
56:25 you're like, I mean, a lot of names in the semiconductor space have, but it's
56:27 up about 48% year to date. You're seeing kind of a tepid reaction
56:31 here in the aftermarket. Tim.
56:32 The stock right now just down about half a percent as investors work their way
56:36 through it I mean adjusted gross margin 50.6% in the fourth quarter versus 48.1%
56:42 year over year. The estimate on the street was pretty
56:44 much in line with what came in 50.4%. But right now the stock flat a little
56:49 bit in the green here. All right.
56:51 Record quarterly free cash flow $2.6 billion.
56:54 Uh, distributed over $2.4 billion to shareholders.
56:58 Gary Dickerson, the president and CEO of the company, saying that I continues to
57:01 feel strong incremental demand for semis and applied has built the most enabling
57:06 portfolio to advance the computing roadmap, putting us in a great position
57:10 for multi-year revenue and profit growth.
57:12 Uh Amat shares in the after hours up by about 1.6%.
57:15 Yeah. Of course, watching this closely because
57:17 investors wanted to know if this could potentially slow constraints with
57:21 supply, but the stock had dropped more than 45% from that peak that we saw at
57:25 the end in June coming into the. But it's still up close to 50% year to
57:29 date, guys. And we should point out, we're also
57:31 still waiting to get earnings. Uh, a little bit later, uh, in the after
57:34 hours from Cisco and of course, Tim and Carol, we're going to get Nvidia's
57:38 earnings next week, assuming that they still go through with that.
57:42 But obviously there's going to be a lot of questions about the succession
57:45 process, or I should say, the search process for a permanent CEO across, of
57:49 course, the CFO being elevated to interim status for right now.
57:53 And it raises a lot of questions, is does she become the permanent CEO?
57:56 Do they have someone internally who can actually fill those shoes, or do they
58:00 look from outside the walls? It's a really important question.
58:04 And, you know, we keep hearing how well, you know, Jensen understood this
58:07 company. He had been with the company from the
58:09 beginning, the only CEO, the only leader of this company.
58:13 And again, everyone kind of speaks to his relationships with everybody in the
58:18 industry and his ability to then manage the supply chain at Nvidia.
58:23 And this was really an important asset for the company.
58:26 So having him not in that place, you know you do wonder kind of how that goes
58:31 forward. So where are we go now.
58:33 Let's go to gainers. Oh gainer.
58:35 Sorry. Uh I got lost in my thought.
58:37 All right. So let's go to, uh, some of the
58:38 individual gainers, kind of that kind of a day, guys.
58:41 Um, we talked about AMD and Broadcom. These were definitely two outperform
58:46 number one gainers in both the end uh Nasdaq 100 and the S&P 500.
58:51 You have advanced micro up 5.8% in today's session.
58:54 You had Broadcom up about 5.5%. These two names gaining on bets that
58:59 they may possibly win business from Nvidia as it deals with all of these
59:05 woes if you will. Changes changes and certainly figuring
59:08 out who will be the next CEO. So that is something, um, that we're
59:11 going to have to figure out. We did see also William Blair raising
59:14 its investment recommendation on AMD. So there was a lot going on.
59:17 But investors uh, in a big way remain moving into the space.
59:20 Staying in the eye. Space.
59:22 Artificial intelligence infrastructure companies really burst out with its
59:25 earnings report here. I'm going to start with the most recent
59:28 quarter that just passed in the third quarter, a loss per share of $0.67,
59:33 revenue of $231 million. That is a beat.
59:36 And core hardware revenue coming in above estimates at $86 million for the
59:41 fourth quarter, the company says expect that core revenue number to jump to 310
59:46 to $330 million. That's well above street estimates, on
59:49 average. They were looking for about 271 million.
59:53 The company says that overall gross margins in the quarter will also be
59:56 higher than what the street was looking for.
59:58 Carol, 47 to 49%. The street was looking for 42.
1:00:01 All right, folks, from Cerebus to Cisco, we go and let's go right to the outlook.
1:00:05 This always catches investors attention. Uh, Cisco says fiscal year adjusted EPs,
1:00:09 $5.40, a, uh, $0.47 a share to $5.53. It had seen 505 to 511.
1:00:16 So that is definitely, uh, upping the adjusted EPs for the fiscal year
1:00:20 guidance. Also, fiscal year revenue 74.8 billion
1:00:24 to 75.8 billion. That, too, is above the earlier
1:00:28 estimates by the company that had seen 72.2 to 73.4 billion, and this stock,
1:00:32 which is up about 32% year to date. Tim, you can see it, bump it up in the
1:00:36 aftermarket, up about 4.6%. Chuck Robbins, chair and CEO of Cisco,
1:00:40 says we are in the very early stages of a multiyear networking supercycle.
1:00:44 We're confident in our ability to continue capturing the multibillion
1:00:47 dollar opportunity that it represents for Cisco.
1:00:51 Shares of Cisco in the after hours, up by more than 6% just yet.
1:00:54 And the implied move if you one day post earnings is supposed to be closer to 9%.
1:00:58 So not quite up that much right now, but we'll see how that shakes up in after
1:01:02 hours. But the stock is up more than 30% year
1:01:04 to date guys. So it's pretty important, especially
1:01:06 when we're talking so much about how this is a real gauge of eye momentum
1:01:10 right now. Yeah.
1:01:12 Um, I do wonder these conference calls for Cisco.
1:01:15 Hey, Matt. It's a Rebirth.
1:01:17 How many? How many questions do you think they're
1:01:19 going to get about it? How's your CEO been called?
1:01:22 How many questions you can think about Chinese spies, etc.?
1:01:26 Yeah, I mean, that's the thing about this whole story, Ramon.
1:01:29 And I think this is something that you guys have been talking about too.
1:01:31 Is, is even though Jensen is out of the company, this story is far from from
1:01:34 over in terms of potential implications for the company.
1:01:37 We had Bloomberg Intelligence, Robert Schiffman on earlier today and his
1:01:40 prediction on the way this this ends is is a pretty giant check from Nvidia
1:01:45 being written to the U.S. government.
1:01:46 When all is said and done, of course we have a big check.
1:01:49 Okay. But fine a fine.
1:01:51 That's what he said. Yeah.
1:01:52 Um, we have no idea how it will play out, and we have no idea how Democrats
1:01:56 and Republicans and who they will call to testify as a result of what we've
1:02:00 learned over the past few days. All right, guys, all right, that is a
1:02:04 wrap. We're going to, uh, wrap up this
1:02:06 cross-platform radio, TV, YouTube originals.
1:02:08 We do call it the closing bell. Uh, Jess.
1:02:11 And of course, remain continuing on the close on TV.
1:02:13 And Tim and I back here on daily on Bloomberg Radio will see you.
1:02:16 Same time, same place tomorrow. And our coverage does continue here on
1:02:22 the close, of course. Juggling several earnings out of tech
1:02:25 companies in the after hours trade and of course still staying on the news of
1:02:29 the day, the week and maybe potentially the year.
1:02:32 And that is the ouster of Jensen Wong as CEO of the company that he helped to
1:02:36 create, started more than 33 years ago at a Denny's in East San Jose,
1:02:41 California, built it from a gaming chip company into an AI juggernaut just up
1:02:47 until a few weeks ago, the most valuable company in the world.
1:02:51 Julie Biel, joins us right now, portfolio manager over at Kayne Anderson
1:02:54 Rudnick to talk a little bit about, I don't know what we're going to talk
1:02:58 about, Julie. I guess the big question right now is
1:03:00 this idea of how much of the alleged indiscretions by Jensen Wong actually
1:03:07 hurts Nvidia, which is, let's just be honest, kind of a singular company.
1:03:13 This is unlike other scandals like we saw at Boeing, at Donald's and BP and
1:03:17 Intel. They were all selling products that
1:03:19 could get anywhere. There aren't too many places I can get
1:03:21 these advanced GPUs from other than from Nvidia.
1:03:26 Yeah, I agree, I think when you are talking about something that's been
1:03:29 deemed critical by the government, you are playing by totally different rules.
1:03:33 And so to be taken down by a pretty standard honeypot operation is really
1:03:37 disappointing. And I think it shows a lot of hubris on
1:03:40 the part of Jensen's. It really demonstrates that.
1:03:44 I think that we all recognize that as a CEO, he really had this Midas touch.
1:03:48 And the problem with that is, you know, the downfall is very steep and very
1:03:52 painful. I agree, though, I think they're in a
1:03:55 really tricky place where if there was any knowledge that the chips that they
1:03:58 were selling were going to end up in China, that's a major felony violation
1:04:03 of trade policy. And so the at a minimum, it's a fine.
1:04:06 And if not, I'm sure they're going to be hauled in front of Congress.
1:04:09 I think it asks further questions. What percent of revenue was really
1:04:13 dependent on that. Now that's really in question.
1:04:16 If it was, you know, in the 2,022%. That's what's difficult.
1:04:20 Before they used to disclose revenue to single payer, but they stopped doing
1:04:25 that. And so that makes it uncomfortable.
1:04:27 I am a little intrigued by the Washington angle of this.
1:04:30 And I know it's easy to dismiss, you know, Congress, congressional
1:04:32 investigations and the like, as they tend to be more performative.
1:04:36 But there is this idea that if there are true national security implications
1:04:40 here, does that potentially even before we get to the point of fines and all
1:04:45 that, just sort of put a chill over the flow of these chips overall.
1:04:49 I mean, would companies back off from buying or trying to do business with
1:04:53 Nvidia because they just want to make sure that they're not even associated
1:04:57 with anything that could be seen as impropriety?
1:05:01 I think that domestically, companies are still going to be very happy to be
1:05:04 buying these chips for them. I think if there is this offshoot and
1:05:08 capacity that was going to Asia, and that's not going to go anymore.
1:05:11 Great. But then what does that mean for
1:05:13 pricing? Right.
1:05:14 What does that mean for TPU pricing, which suddenly becomes more competitive
1:05:17 if these are suddenly much more available?
1:05:20 So I think that that's the real kind of question.
1:05:22 I don't think there's going to be reputational risk for many of these
1:05:26 companies. Ellen is ready to jump in with both
1:05:28 feet. And, you know, so goes Elon.
1:05:30 So goes the rest I guess. But I think from a standard in terms of
1:05:34 national security, it would make me a little bit nervous recognizing we don't
1:05:40 know what got out. We're still so early in this story and
1:05:43 every story we read is worse. Hey Julie, I know in the many times that
1:05:46 I've spoken with you, the way that you construct your portfolio is obviously
1:05:49 you're not going to make a one day, one week change based on what's happened,
1:05:52 but how exactly have you been hedging and how much exposure to your clients?
1:05:57 Or do you think overall, when it comes to Americans and those globally that
1:06:00 have exposure towards Nvidia in this AI trade, or potentially more vulnerable or
1:06:05 maybe not? I think it's something that we think a
1:06:08 lot about is what are the correlations between the eye trade, which Nvidia is
1:06:13 one of the largest components and you know, the rest of the market.
1:06:16 And I think being able to segment the businesses that are still very strong,
1:06:20 even if there is a CapEx slowdown. So I think if you look at mega cap tech,
1:06:24 look, these are quasi monopolies. They're still going to be quasi
1:06:27 monopolies on the other side of this. I think there are some who are saying
1:06:30 maybe this is great because they'll pull back on their spending a little bit, and
1:06:34 that ends up being, you know, the back to the free cash flow geezers that they
1:06:38 were. I wonder, too, if we have this kind of
1:06:41 pacing the frontier, if that enables the financials of something like an
1:06:45 anthropic to look a lot better. Because while the inference pricing is
1:06:48 pretty good, the margins are pretty good.
1:06:51 You know, being able to train these models, it'd be great if they could do
1:06:54 it every 18 months instead of every six months.
1:06:56 So it would be transformational to their economics.
1:06:58 And so I do wonder if we actually end up getting to a place where we stop
1:07:02 spending money quite so quickly, and we are able to leverage this technology in
1:07:07 a way that is a little bit more profitable when you're looking at price
1:07:11 to earnings ratio is especially Nvidia only trading 11 times forward earnings,
1:07:14 and especially that's even less expensive than Hershey's.
1:07:17 Other staples companies even obviously the major indexes like the S&P and the
1:07:21 Nasdaq. But your clients, whenever they're
1:07:23 talking to you, do they want to get rid of their High Flyers or they want to
1:07:26 actually add to that and hang on to them?
1:07:28 And what do you think that tells us about the direction of the market here?
1:07:32 I think that there is a really strong retail bid because for all of the
1:07:36 market, right, because everyone who is investing, for the most part is 35 years
1:07:41 and younger, and they haven't actually lived through a real drawdown recession
1:07:46 that lasts more than the three months of Covid.
1:07:49 So I really think that a lot of people have done so well by by the dip.
1:07:53 I think that many professional investors, you know, pension managers,
1:07:58 they really do see the concern with the leverage.
1:08:01 I think the leverage is the thing that makes everyone feel like, are we getting
1:08:05 to the end of the party? Because it's really hard to sustain
1:08:08 itself. It becomes so much more fragile when
1:08:10 there's this much debt. And that's just the debt we can count.
1:08:13 The off balance sheet stuff is somewhere in the ether.
1:08:16 You know, this gets to the idea, though, to Julie.
1:08:18 I mean, we were talking about the big drop that we saw in Nvidia and intraday
1:08:22 down 14% and closed down 4%. And I was going through and I was
1:08:27 looking at some of the other big outers that we've had over the years.
1:08:31 Uh, and the stock reaction, it's like when Steve Easterbrook at McDonald's was
1:08:35 forced out and we saw a 10% drop in the stock, or Mark Hurd over at HP, or
1:08:39 Dennis Kozlowski over at Tyco. This is a relatively modest drop,
1:08:43 particularly given the outsized nature of who Jensen Huang was or is, I should
1:08:47 say, um, and I guess, does that give you a little bit more comfort here with
1:08:52 regards to the performance of the stock and performance of the company, for that
1:08:55 matter? Uh, irrespective of who the permanent
1:08:58 replacement ends up being? Well, I think it's the recognition that
1:09:01 the we're probably not going to see earnings fall off a cliff.
1:09:04 And I think the other thing that's very comforting is we're going to find out
1:09:07 very soon. We don't have to wait 2 or 3 months to
1:09:10 figure out exactly how this business is. They are going to have to talk about all
1:09:14 of this really quickly. And I think that that gives me at least
1:09:17 some kind of comfort that we're going to have some kind of gauges.
1:09:20 But I do think that it is a little bit concerning when you think of how many
1:09:25 carts are hooked up to Nvidia, it's not clear if they are going to continue to
1:09:30 be the backstop for a lot of these smaller companies, and that creates a
1:09:34 lot of uncertainty that I think people need to be new to be honest about.
1:09:39 Yeah. The other question has to do with just
1:09:40 personality. And let's face it, I mean, Jensen one
1:09:42 was the face of the AI boom, the insanity, the leather jacket, all that
1:09:46 stuff there. Do we need someone like that?
1:09:49 Do we need to see, like, Lisa Sue come out in a leather jacket and, you know, a
1:09:54 crown or something? Do we need that sort of jester out
1:09:57 there? I mean, can't we just have, like, a
1:09:59 normal market with CEOs just working behind closed doors to make money.
1:10:04 Yeah, I mean, it is my preference. I really like my management teams to be
1:10:08 on the boring side because then I have, you know, an understanding that less of
1:10:12 this is going to be driven by the cult of personality.
1:10:15 This business was really driven by the cult of personality.
1:10:18 And I think if you've listened to Jensen's interviews, particularly over
1:10:21 the last year or two, you've seen him become less and less relatable as a
1:10:26 human being. You know, he was last on Ezra Klein show
1:10:29 talking about how he doesn't even know his home address.
1:10:31 He does. He might not even know his home phone
1:10:33 number. It's a little bit like, uh, yeah, this
1:10:36 is the face. This is the face of, you know, the
1:10:39 decision and where we're going to end up with this very existential technology.
1:10:43 I think it would be great if we had someone who could speak in really simple
1:10:47 language and would make people feel comfortable and would maybe stop talking
1:10:51 about, like, the perfume that we should be expecting going forward.
1:10:55 Okay, so not Elon Musk, not. Julie.
1:10:58 Love it. Julie Biel, portfolio manager over at
1:11:01 Kane Anderson Rudnick. And I just want to correct myself, too.
1:11:03 I was talking about that big drop we saw at McDonald's and I got the numbers
1:11:06 mixed up. McDonald's dropped 3%.
1:11:08 Brooke was out when Mark heard was pushed out because of the allegations of
1:11:12 his affair. The shares dropped 10%.
1:11:14 And I do remember Tyco because I was working that day back in 2002, covering
1:11:18 when Dennis Kozlowski got pushed out in, the shares plunged 27%.
1:11:21 But that was a big different story. But there was obviously the underlying
1:11:24 issues of fraud that came up in there. So especially this just given the supply
1:11:28 chain and then national security questions, they come up with Nvidia.
1:11:32 Absolutely. Yeah.
1:11:33 We did point out in a while ago here that we are getting a lot of earnings
1:11:36 from other companies not named in video today, including Applied Materials,
1:11:40 Cerebus, as well as Cisco. Cisco shares has been oscillating
1:11:43 between gains and losses, up about 2% right now here, after the network
1:11:47 equipment maker raised its full year forecast and seemed to signal there was
1:11:51 strong, high demand. Let's bring in Luciano, senior analyst
1:11:54 of hardware and networking at Bloomberg Intelligence.
1:11:57 All right. Well, Jen, what did you make of the
1:11:58 earnings today? Yeah.
1:11:59 I mean just taking a quick look at their print.
1:12:01 Uh, look, earnings has been rock solid. Uh, they continue to execute on the I
1:12:05 side as well as the networking side. The big uh the big key here is that they
1:12:08 raised their I got us by by $2 billion. Right.
1:12:11 So that's lifting their guidance to roughly about, uh, $75.3 billion.
1:12:16 But that's not all of it, romaine. Uh, they're also getting a lift on, uh,
1:12:19 uh, and, uh, network corporate and, uh, network spending.
1:12:22 So corporate it is Brazilian two. Of course, three months ago, their
1:12:26 conservative outlook did disappoint investors, though.
1:12:29 Right now, their stock pulls up more than 30% year to date.
1:12:32 How do you think this will potentially shake out.
1:12:34 And you think those what we're seeing in after hours trading can hold into
1:12:37 tomorrow. Yeah I mean we will see well holding it
1:12:39 tomorrow. I think of it as a little bit more of a
1:12:42 a longer time frame than, than that. Right.
1:12:45 But there is a little bit of a quite a bit of durability here.
1:12:48 Right. If you think about last quarters, the
1:12:50 disappointment is that the conversion rates and what we're starting to see in
1:12:54 their guidance is that the conversion rates are starting to get better.
1:12:56 All right. which I know over at Bloomberg
1:12:58 Intelligence. A closer look at Cisco with just
1:13:00 reported earnings. Let's take a quick look at Applied
1:13:02 Materials. Those shares up about 1.5% in the after
1:13:06 hours trade on the back of its earnings report as well.
1:13:09 The company saying that net sales in the current quarter should be in a range of
1:13:13 about 10.6 to 1.6 billion, as many as any senior equity research analyst over
1:13:18 at Susquehanna joins us right now. What jumped out at you in this report
1:13:22 may. Well, interesting.
1:13:24 Thanks for having me on the program. Uh, reminds you that the Microsoft
1:13:27 Outlook has been out for several hours, so I'm going blind here.
1:13:30 I haven't seen the press release because I can access anything.
1:13:33 And that underscores the fact that we need a lot more investment I.T
1:13:37 investment now applied material. Yes, we were expecting better raise, but
1:13:41 I think the concern of my investor is about 28.
1:13:45 No, not next quarter or the quarter after.
1:13:47 I think there's a fear that, uh, investors that both have equivalent
1:13:51 would have a pause or decline in 2018, which I disagree.
1:13:55 I think this is a multi-year investment project, and especially with Applied
1:13:59 Materials, customer care generally, a lot of cash from operations that they
1:14:03 have their classrooms. So again, I have uh, I have a, uh, a
1:14:08 view of that overall, which I would have said would continue to increase and
1:14:12 upload material, would benefit and make it on the story short.
1:14:16 I estimate that the downside into the stock is limited to 10 to 16%, but the
1:14:21 upside to the north of 80%. So it does offer attractive risk profile
1:14:27 if you're willing to be patient. So this stock if you look at where it
1:14:32 peaked out in June, it's actually down more than 40% off of that peak.
1:14:36 But still it's up close to about 50% year to date.
1:14:40 Did you see any signs that it was showing supply constraints at all?
1:14:43 Because that's what sparked some of those concerns a few months ago.
1:14:47 I'm not sure if I disagree with that. I think the consensus June is has been
1:14:51 more about viability of an eye investment.
1:14:54 And where does your investment look like in 28?
1:14:57 I do agree that there is some supply constraint, uh, impacting supply
1:15:02 material and the peer group. But this year has always been 2028.
1:15:06 And the fear of a decline in semiconductor industry revenue and the
1:15:10 weakness of equipment would decline as a result of that.
1:15:13 As I highlighted in the industry note yesterday.
1:15:16 Even if semiconductor industry revenue were to decline in 28, I expect Applied
1:15:21 Materials market. We'll have equipment to continue to
1:15:24 increase to 2030. So overall, when we talk about the idea,
1:15:30 the trajectory of this company and where it fits in, uh, in the eye space, how
1:15:34 fast is that evolution? And I am curious about the idea as to
1:15:39 whether anything that's been going on with some of the other equipment and
1:15:43 chipmakers out there would actually benefit Applied Materials.
1:15:48 I'm not sure if, uh, the peer group will have an impact.
1:15:52 Obviously, China is becoming more independent.
1:15:55 They have their own media industry, so I play material in the peer group will not
1:16:01 benefit from investment in China. But when I look at the overall, I don't
1:16:07 know the time it takes to plan a multi-billion dollar fine for the time
1:16:11 that it actually becomes operational. This is a, uh, 2 to 4 year period.
1:16:17 So the projects you start today, uh, the equipment upload material, equipment
1:16:22 that you install today is not going to be operational until the second half of
1:16:25 20. So customers are making a bet that, yes,
1:16:29 even if there is a pause in investment, they will recover and any and their
1:16:33 customers need more capacity. It's within 28 and into 29.
1:16:38 All right. Met with any senior equity research
1:16:39 analyst over at Susquehanna International Group.
1:16:42 Uh, we should point out. Yes.
1:16:43 Uh, I think he referenced, uh, something we haven't talked about.
1:16:46 But with this big Microsoft outage of our outlook and a lot of those dates.
1:16:49 Right. Uh, going on right there.
1:16:51 He said he was having trouble even not getting to the release.
1:16:53 Uh, but it gets to this idea, obviously, how dependent we are on technology, but
1:16:57 also the idea of, uh, how fragile some of that technology can be.
1:17:00 And I do want to kind of bring this back, though, to this idea of Nvidia and
1:17:04 its importance to the broader market. November of 2022.
1:17:08 So almost four years ago was when ChatGPT was released to the public.
1:17:12 And that was kind of the marker for this AI boom.
1:17:15 And I think it's kind of the unofficial marker for the start of this bull market
1:17:19 that we've been in. And a lot of people are wondering how
1:17:21 much more life does this bull market have, particularly if Nvidia is not
1:17:24 leading it in just a month before that, in October of 2022, was when the S&P 500
1:17:28 bottomed to your point and began this bull market run.
1:17:31 So it's interesting just seeing that dynamic.
1:17:32 And then also in November 2022, that's when meta had all of those issues and
1:17:36 began those tranches, that first big tranche of job cuts.
1:17:39 That's when people were talking about whether that's sort of the end of
1:17:41 Facebook or not in the beginning of massive run.
1:17:44 So there was a lot of different things going on.
1:17:46 On the end of 2022. How many times of people call it end
1:17:49 face or metal or whatever, whatever we're calling it now, uh, it's obviously
1:17:53 been quite a ride here. When we talk about the AI boom, the
1:17:56 release of ChatGPT, uh, to the public, at least in late November of 2022, which
1:18:01 has caused a frenzy to get your hands on any stock associated with the AI boom.
1:18:05 And undoubtedly, the number one stock that people wanted to own was Nvidia
1:18:12 Bloomberg Technology. Host Bloomberg Tech host Ed Ludlow joins
1:18:15 us right now to talk a little bit more about that.
1:18:17 Ed, is this a stock you think that people will still want to own without
1:18:21 Jensen Wong leading it? Yeah, I mean, the state of play is that,
1:18:26 you know Nvidia will go ahead with its earnings next Tuesday.
1:18:29 You know I have it on pretty firm authority that that crest hands off in
1:18:33 her new role interim CEO but continuing to be CFO.
1:18:37 They take the analyst questions. And the outlook in the here and now
1:18:40 doesn't change at least for the upcoming fiscal year for Nvidia.
1:18:43 You know that that remains what, uh, customers might do now is face a choice.
1:18:48 Do they want to commit to Nvidia longer term?
1:18:51 Uh, without Jensen Wong at the helm, what is Nvidia without Jensen Wong?
1:18:55 You know, that's the question that gets posed today.
1:18:57 Yeah, but you are right. It goes well before the chat 2022 moment
1:19:01 back in 2010. Yeah.
1:19:02 You know Jensen pivoted Nvidia to AI. And in 2012 this this phase of training
1:19:08 machine learning but using Nvidia GPUs kicked it all off.
1:19:11 Well that's how they have a monopoly. Yes.
1:19:13 I want to ask you to because, you know, I know we kind of lionize him.
1:19:16 And we have this tendency, particularly in financial media, to sort of put these
1:19:20 people on a pedestal. But there are a lot of decisions he made
1:19:23 over the years with Nvidia that were very prescient.
1:19:25 Obviously, the bet on Cuda back in 2000, in the early 2000, uh, the big bet on
1:19:30 deep learning, I think starting in 2012, uh, there was a very interesting
1:19:34 conference call that took place, earnings call that took place, uh,
1:19:37 almost ten years ago today, where he talked about the acceleration in demand,
1:19:41 uh, for, uh, what at the time he was calling, uh, deep learning and I, uh,
1:19:46 and then obviously the whole move to full stack technology.
1:19:50 The big question with succession, Ed, is how many people around him or also
1:19:55 making those decisions. Do those people have the technological
1:19:59 chops and the presidents and foresight that he had to keep this company going?
1:20:04 So when Cuda was written in the early 2000, embark, who currently leads
1:20:08 Nvidia's data center business, uh, was there writing it with that team, um, how
1:20:14 it has worked to this point and, you know, in this succession context is
1:20:17 that. Yeah, Jensen was the CEO, Colette Kress,
1:20:20 the CFO underneath him. And then basically SVP, MVP level.
1:20:24 There were 60 of them that were direct reports to Jensen Huang, but that
1:20:27 represents a very deep bench of talent, ranging from chip architecture and
1:20:31 design through to hardware engineering. And that deep bench is still there.
1:20:36 The sell side principally, but others around this, this town talk about the
1:20:40 big risks now being how many people in that 60 go, uh, because of Jensen's
1:20:46 departure, that is the the unknown at this point.
1:20:48 But it is a risk that's being identified.
1:20:50 Yeah. And it's why on this short list of
1:20:52 potential successors, you know arms here Renny has is up there because he was an
1:20:57 Nvidia employee 2006 for seven years, because Nvidia's current technology is
1:21:01 based on ARM architecture as opposed to somebody of more of a financial mold and
1:21:06 that undisclosed. Right.
1:21:07 Clearly that crash with huge respect. She's highly capable, but he's there on
1:21:11 an interim basis. Absolutely.
1:21:13 I know a host of Bloomberg Tech. Uh, and just I just want to point out to
1:21:18 Ed's last point, I mean, Callie Kress has had, um, a remarkable career.
1:21:22 She was at Microsoft, at Cisco. She joined Nvidia, uh, I think about a
1:21:25 decade or so ago. Uh, I think fortune named her, like, the
1:21:28 most powerful woman in business. So, uh, to say that she's not capable
1:21:32 would be a gross, gross understatement. Exactly.
1:21:35 It's going to be really interesting to see just exactly how that all plays out.
1:21:38 But according to JPMorgan, retail investors were buying the dip on Nvidia
1:21:41 as well as Nvidia's Alphabet, Apple today as well as Baba, even though we
1:21:46 saw some of those shares. And then we talk about the bench they
1:21:49 have. I think you brought up Ben Buck a little
1:21:50 bit earlier on, Ryan Kent, Bizarro, Michael Kagan, a Bill Daley, a lot of
1:21:54 folks here, uh, that actually help, uh, Jensen sort of build this company up.
1:21:58 The question is, are one of those people going to lead this company, or do you
1:22:01 look to the outside? Our coverage of that decision continues
1:22:06 through the lens of its corporate governance structure, or lack thereof.
1:22:09 This is Bloomberg.
1:22:17 Welcome back to the closed down day on Wall Street, though it could have been a
1:22:20 lot worse. Fractional losses for the Dow, the S&P
1:22:23 and the Nasdaq. We should point out that the
1:22:25 Philadelphia Semiconductor Index only lost a half a percentage point.
1:22:29 Obviously Nvidia one of the biggest weightings in that the Russell 2000,
1:22:33 lower by about 1.7% on the day. There was a lot of activity outside the
1:22:37 world of stocks as well, with Brent crude rising 3% and a 14 basis point
1:22:42 jump in the two year yield. As far as some of the individual movers
1:22:46 in video, of course got sold at one point on the day, it was down 14%, but
1:22:50 only closed lower by about 4%. Now, some of the companies that have
1:22:54 supplies or does business with they got hit as well, which actually had a
1:22:58 somewhat concerning earnings report falling about 17% on the day.
1:23:02 Meanwhile, some of Nvidia's competitors like Broadcom and AMD, they did pretty
1:23:06 well today. AMD and Lisa suit up 7% on the day.
1:23:11 And that brings us back to our top story of the hour.
1:23:14 Hand of the day. What is Nvidia without Jensen Huang.
1:23:18 Now, in a weird twist of fate. Wong's departure comes ten years.
1:23:21 Nearly to this day, that Wall Street truly discovered what Nvidia was now.
1:23:26 The company had been around since 1993, since 99, but for years it was largely
1:23:31 viewed as a boom and bust gaming chip maker.
1:23:34 That all changed on November 10th, 2016, after Nvidia reported a 54% jump in
1:23:40 quarterly revenue to $2 billion, but buried in that release was a much
1:23:44 smaller number with much bigger implications.
1:23:48 Data center sales. They had nearly tripled to $240 million
1:23:52 with an Im on a conference call. Jensen Wong pointed to that and pointed
1:23:56 to what most investors were not yet watching artificial intelligence
1:24:00 describing, quote, incredible enthusiasm around the world for using GPU powered
1:24:06 deep learning across what he said was health care, transportation,
1:24:09 entertainment and enterprise. Every sector out there.
1:24:12 The next day, Nvidia shares surged 30%. It was then and still stands now as the
1:24:18 fourth biggest one day gain in the stock's history.
1:24:21 And it was only the beginning. The shares more than doubled over the
1:24:24 next year. Fortune wood named Jensen Huang its
1:24:26 Business Person of the year in 2017. Harvard Business Review ranked him the
1:24:31 world's best performing CEO in 2019. Then ChatGPT arrived in 2022, making
1:24:37 clear that the AI boom would run on the advanced GPUs Nvidia had spent years
1:24:42 building. Within six months, Nvidia's market value
1:24:46 reached trillion. 2 trillion followed nine months later.
1:24:50 3 trillion came in June 2024. In 4 trillion, then five.
1:24:54 Almost six. The scale of that value creation is
1:24:58 almost without precedent. The largest and fastest value creation
1:25:02 by any CEO since the Gilded Age. Tycoons a banner built after Carnegie
1:25:07 and Rockefeller. And for good reason.
1:25:10 The business behind Nvidia was, and still is striking that $240 million in
1:25:16 quarterly data. Data center revenue they reported in
1:25:19 2016. Last center last quarter, I should say
1:25:23 it was $89 billion. And that was built by selling customers,
1:25:28 not simply what they needed today, but what Jensen Huang believed they would
1:25:32 need tomorrow. Now, the defining company of the AI era
1:25:35 must confront a question few investors ever expected to ask, and maybe one the
1:25:39 board should have ask what becomes of the house of Jensen Wong now that he has
1:25:43 been forced to hand over the keys? We're going to pose that question to
1:25:47 Charles Elson, an expert on corporate governance and the founding director of
1:25:51 the Weinberg Center for Corporate Governance at the University of
1:25:54 Delaware. Charles, great to see you here in
1:25:55 person. Good to be with you.
1:25:57 Boards are supposed to oversee what's going on with the executives.
1:26:01 Um, there's always this idea that a CEO could be gone for whatever reason,
1:26:05 whether it's through malfeasance, whether it's through health issues, or
1:26:08 maybe they just want to do something else.
1:26:11 Shouldn't have Nvidia have had a more coherent and more publicly articulated
1:26:16 succession plan? Certainly.
1:26:18 That's a responsibility, a very important responsibility of the board.
1:26:22 You always should be thinking down the road what could happen if look, uh, this
1:26:27 was an unusual one in that, uh, you couldn't really have forecast something
1:26:30 like this happening. On the other hand, whether it's illness,
1:26:33 retirement. Uh, change of job.
1:26:36 Change of psyche. Uh, you have to think about who's coming
1:26:39 next. And the fact that there was apparently
1:26:43 no firm plan in place. Is troubling, because that's what a
1:26:46 board is supposed to be doing. It's not that we have the new leader
1:26:49 ready to go. It's that if something happens, if he
1:26:52 gets hit by a bus or who knows, uh, that we have someone who can basically run
1:26:57 the store until we can figure it out. And that was what was missing here.
1:27:01 And that explain the confusion earlier this week.
1:27:04 Well, I am curious, too. I mean, and you've sat on boards in the
1:27:06 past and Kirk and I. Wrong.
1:27:08 But I believe you were on the board at Sunbeam II.
1:27:10 Al Dunlap. Uh, famous chainsaw.
1:27:12 Yes, yes. Uh, was I was ousted, obviously that a
1:27:15 little bit of a different story than what's going on with the video I had.
1:27:18 I'd, I'd make the motion for his termination.
1:27:20 What what can you tell me a little bit about that process?
1:27:22 Because I am curious. There's been a lot of reports that with
1:27:24 regards to Jensen Wong, that at least some directors were aware of the
1:27:29 allegations months ago now, whether they acted on them or felt a need to act on
1:27:34 them. Who knows?
1:27:35 But I am curious as to what point when you learned some information about your
1:27:40 CEO that doesn't fit with the ethics of the company.
1:27:43 At what point do you make that motion to say, we need to move on?
1:27:48 Well, in the case of Sunbeam, uh, in my view, it was we had lost confidence in
1:27:52 him based on a board meeting that, uh, I asked question he wouldn't answer would
1:27:56 answer the question. And I thought, that's it.
1:27:58 And of the end of the game, in this instance, uh, the allegations, you can't
1:28:03 do something about someone into allegations are demonstrated.
1:28:06 Correct or not. That's not right.
1:28:08 But when allegations of the seriousness were raised, that's when you should have
1:28:11 had an independent investigation, which they did.
1:28:14 And secondly, I think, more importantly, put him on some kind of administrative
1:28:17 leave because you can't have the CEO sitting there running a business that's
1:28:21 investigating him. That's I think that's the problem.
1:28:24 And but because they said we don't have anyone else, he has to.
1:28:27 That was the issue. Now, I don't want to say conveniently,
1:28:30 but in a way. Luckily for this board, uh, a second
1:28:34 allegation came up that was very easy to resolve.
1:28:37 You know, that sort of thing is it violates company's code of ethics,
1:28:41 right? And every other employee.
1:28:43 And it would violate they would probably be asked to leave.
1:28:46 So should he doubt the issue there for the board is not necessarily the policy.
1:28:50 But why wasn't that instance reported up?
1:28:54 And you've seen this over and over there, a number of companies where this
1:28:57 has happened where, you know, CEO has something like this.
1:29:00 They are they're forced immediately to leave.
1:29:01 You've said that you felt like the Nvidia board made the right move.
1:29:05 Here is the risk out of the way. What happens if other information
1:29:09 emerges about the company? That's not helpful.
1:29:12 At any time you move a CEO on. It's like lifting up a rock.
1:29:15 All the bugs come out because you have no idea what's under there.
1:29:19 And maybe there's nothing. Maybe the allegations, the visa of China
1:29:24 were untrue, I don't know, but clearly there was enough there.
1:29:27 The board felt that it was time to a investigate and be.
1:29:32 When the second allegation appeared to suggest he resign, which I guess they
1:29:36 did. We've talked in the past about, um,
1:29:39 board oversight and maybe the decline in the, the, uh, effectiveness or, I guess,
1:29:44 the willingness to have a little bit more oversight.
1:29:46 How much of that has to do with the tech era and the idea of these founder CEO
1:29:51 that have such outsize importance, whether deserved or not?
1:29:55 Uh, on the trajectory of the company, because it's not just Jensen Wong.
1:29:58 You have so many companies now being led by founders who've been in their chairs
1:30:01 for decades, and there are a lot of questions as to is there a succession
1:30:05 plan? Is there independent board oversight,
1:30:07 which up until today we now know that it didn't really didn't exist now.
1:30:11 You know, you make a great point. I mean, it's the superstar theory.
1:30:15 The superstar can do no wrong. Or the genius theory.
1:30:18 The genius always knows the best. And that's not true.
1:30:21 I mean, people are human. They make mistakes, geniuses make
1:30:24 mistakes. And the idea of a board, a good board is
1:30:27 to prevent geniuses mistake from becoming a disaster.
1:30:30 That's why you have a board. That's the danger, by the way, of dual
1:30:33 class stock and a lot of these companies.
1:30:35 Because the genius can make a mistake and the board can say, you made a
1:30:39 mistake, and the Virginia says goodbye and the shareholders are stuck.
1:30:44 That's that's the problem and that's the issue.
1:30:46 But you're right. Another thing, though, to and a
1:30:48 colleague of mine pointed this out to me was the idea that, um, the all but one
1:30:52 of the board members had actually listed corporate governance experience, uh, as
1:30:58 part of their repertoire, that basically these are a bunch of technologists
1:31:01 there, which the fine is a technology company.
1:31:03 Yeah. But my understanding is that boards are
1:31:05 supposed to be diverse. Yeah.
1:31:06 You have to have some people who understand the business, who understand
1:31:09 that industry. But having people from outside those
1:31:12 walls to bring out the things. That's the whole idea of a board.
1:31:15 It is diverse. It's a collection of expertise in
1:31:18 different areas that comes together to oversee a business.
1:31:21 And the key is that you will listen to another director with different
1:31:25 expertise than you, and ultimately you come together and you reach the
1:31:28 appropriate conclusion, but on different issues.
1:31:30 Different directors obviously have more expertise, and that's how you build a
1:31:34 great board that everyone brings something to the table.
1:31:37 And if everyone brings the same thing to the table, it's a pretty boring
1:31:41 discussion. Ever been to a dinner and everyone does
1:31:43 to say, oh yeah. Trust, Miller.
1:31:45 Oh, man. Well, it's just that that's that's what
1:31:47 I do. The Irish goodbye.
1:31:48 And I get out of there. Uh, and I just want to say to that was,
1:31:52 uh, Nelson Mandela gave us that stat. It was like only one of Nvidia's 12
1:31:55 directors back in 2024 cited corporate governance experience in their, uh, bio.
1:32:00 Charles, always great to have you as well.
1:32:02 Obviously just an expert here on corporate governance.
1:32:04 And I guess in this case, the lack thereof, our conversation is going to
1:32:07 continue here on Bloomberg. Kim Harvey going to stop by the program
1:32:10 in a second. Take a wider look at the AI trade.
1:32:13 This is Bloomberg.
1:32:27 All the talk about the fallout of Jensen Wong's departure from Nvidia has put
1:32:31 well, renewed light here on the AI trade overall and valuations.
1:32:36 Let's bring in cam, RV professor of Finance over at Duke University.
1:32:40 And that is where I want to start here. I mean, Nvidia obviously was the
1:32:43 flywheel for the AI boom at least up until this point.
1:32:46 But obviously this is a much broader ecosystem than just Jensen Wong's GPUs
1:32:51 here. Kam, where do we go next?
1:32:53 Yeah. So again the ecosystem is important.
1:32:57 So all the focus is on the hardware, the infrastructure.
1:33:01 But there are two other major sectors the hyperscalers which have not been
1:33:06 damaged that much. And then the AI applications, uh, like
1:33:12 anthropic and anthropic, has taken a haircut in terms of what they thought
1:33:17 that they would get. But overall, this is a classic
1:33:21 Correction. It's heterogeneous across different
1:33:24 firms within these sectors. Um, but this is not a turning point.
1:33:29 This is not, in my opinion, a trend where we keep on heading down.
1:33:33 Well, I am curious about that too, because, I mean, it's funny, we've kind
1:33:37 of ignored anthropic today and obviously they're going to come to market, uh, you
1:33:41 know, based on reporting as soon as next week.
1:33:43 And it gets to this idea as to what anthropic debut in public markets
1:33:47 represents, particularly when we talk about valuations and the valuation gap
1:33:52 that we've seen between how the public market is pricing some of these names
1:33:55 and how the private market has been pricing them.
1:33:58 Yeah, it was very interesting. So that we're talking about 1.5
1:34:02 trillion, and then it was being talked up to 2 trillion.
1:34:07 And now we're expecting 1.3 a trillion. Uh, and it's very interesting that, uh,
1:34:14 the haircut that took it down from 2 to 1.3 largely happened the day after the
1:34:20 election. So November 5th.
1:34:22 Where we saw like a 6.4% decline in the Nasdaq, $2.3 trillion being wiped out.
1:34:30 So for me, analyzing the data, it's suggested that the growth rates were
1:34:37 intact. But the timing of the growth was kind of
1:34:41 pushed out due to the election. So investors were thinking, well, we've
1:34:47 got the same model for where these firms will go in the future, but the cash
1:34:52 flows have been pushed out and that largely accounts for the decrease in the
1:34:57 valuation. Hey Kim, talk to us more about earnings
1:35:01 because I know that you especially if you're thinking about valuations as well
1:35:04 ex I looking at the S&P 500 trading 17 times forward earnings.
1:35:08 But that Mag seven basket is at 23 times.
1:35:11 And if you can believe it or not the staples sector or the S&P 500 is 24
1:35:15 times. So talk to us about what you're seeing
1:35:17 with valuations in other pockets of the market.
1:35:21 Yeah. So this is something that I've
1:35:24 emphasized that investors are so focused on the eye trade.
1:35:30 And it is a great trade. And it's very important for the economy.
1:35:34 So we need higher growth in this sector provides the basis for potentially
1:35:42 spectacular GDP growth in the future. And it is really important that that
1:35:48 growth will impact not just eye stocks but none eye stocks.
1:35:53 Right. And my estimate is that maybe 5% of the
1:35:58 productivity gain that non eye stocks could actually benefit from the
1:36:04 application of AI is priced in. So there's a vast upside to the non eye
1:36:11 stocks that will benefit from the eye productivity boom that is not priced in.
1:36:17 So? So I think that the attention is too
1:36:20 focused on the eye sector and we're ignoring potential growth opportunities.
1:36:26 I'm curious because when you see dividend paying type quarters of the
1:36:29 market, like staples that are actually there for earnings and how much they're
1:36:34 pricing there for, those projections are more expensive than the major indexes
1:36:37 for the S&P and Nasdaq 100. How long do you think that can continue
1:36:40 to last? Well, again, this is very difficult to
1:36:46 do any valuation. And this is really important.
1:36:48 We can never observe the true value. We can only estimate it.
1:36:52 So we need to estimate these cash flows. We need to assume some sort of growth
1:36:56 rate, assume some sort of risk profile. And given the speed to which that the AI
1:37:03 sector is changing, it is really difficult to forecast those cash flows.
1:37:08 So what's happened over the last year? So this is not one month over the last
1:37:13 year. We're struggling with What is the total
1:37:16 addressable market? What is the growth rate that is
1:37:19 reasonable to expect? And as investors get more information,
1:37:24 they refine their forecast of the growth.
1:37:27 And this causes volatility. It's exactly what we're seeing.
1:37:31 And I guess my point is the growth forecast is relevant not just for the AI
1:37:37 stocks but for the nones eye stocks that are basically underappreciated in my
1:37:42 opinion and, uh, understudied. Uh, definitely less attention.
1:37:47 All right. I've got to leave it there.
1:37:48 Always a pleasure. Kim Harvey, professor of finance over at
1:37:51 Duke University. When we come back, our discussion
1:37:53 continues with Chris McGuire over on the Council on Foreign Relations.
1:37:58 This is Bloomberg.
1:38:08 Jensen Wong out at Nvidia. The board searches for a replacement.
1:38:12 And the investigations in Washington begins not just on the affair, but more
1:38:17 importantly, how a lot of these high end Nvidia chips that we're not supposed to
1:38:21 get into the hands of China ended up in the hands of China.
1:38:24 Chris Maguire, senior fellow for China and emerging technologies at the Council
1:38:28 on Foreign Relations, joins us right now.
1:38:29 He's also former deputy senior director for technology and national security
1:38:33 during the Biden administration, and helped to write the Chips act that
1:38:36 actually sought to impose export controls.
1:38:39 And that is where I want to start, because so kind of an undercurrent in
1:38:41 this story is this idea that a company called Mega Speed, as well as some other
1:38:45 players, in one way or another, did manage to get their hands on billions of
1:38:49 dollars of Nvidia chips. And I do wonder about the effectiveness
1:38:54 of these export controls, or rather, the effectiveness of the enforcement of
1:38:59 these export controls. Yeah, I think your your second point is
1:39:03 absolutely right. The question is not whether or not
1:39:06 export controls can be effective, it's whether or not they are being
1:39:09 effectively enforced right now. And the tricky thing I would look at is
1:39:13 actually the most relevant export control that would have prevented this
1:39:17 from happening is actually an export control that's on the books that
1:39:20 Commerce is refusing to enforce. Uh, there is a policy that says that
1:39:24 rather than saying the private sector can do the adjudication of whether or
1:39:28 not a Chinese company is Chinese or not. Uh, at the end of the Biden
1:39:31 administration, there is a control that was passed that said, for large scale AI
1:39:34 chip orders to Southeast Asia and many other countries, the government is going
1:39:38 to do the determination of whether or not the company has ties with China or
1:39:41 not. Commerce has said they're not enforcing
1:39:43 that, and that has what is enabled mega speed to get all these chips.
1:39:47 If commerce was enforcing that policy, they would have actually gotten a
1:39:50 license request and Mega Speed would have had to get a green light from the
1:39:54 US government to get the chips. But because they said they're not, they
1:39:56 were just able to order them. Well, I am curious.
1:39:59 Um, one of our colleagues at Bloomberg Intelligence said something very
1:40:02 interesting to me. She said that in, uh, Jensen Wong, and
1:40:05 I'm just going to read her words exactly.
1:40:07 Uh, as she put them was basically the strongest advocate for continued chip
1:40:12 sales to China. Do we know anything about what he was
1:40:16 advocating behind the scenes given? We know he did have close ties with the
1:40:20 white House and the Trump administration.
1:40:24 Behind the scenes, Jensen Huang was repeatedly advocating for loosening and
1:40:27 chip export controls on China. I think what he was saying publicly was
1:40:31 also what he was saying privately. Uh, he, you know, successfully got the
1:40:35 Trump administration to reduce export controls twice in, in both 2025 and in
1:40:40 early 2026. He has repeatedly also pushed the Trump
1:40:43 administration to reduce them further to allow Blackwell chips to go to China.
1:40:47 Fortunately, I think the Trump ministration has realized that that is
1:40:50 not a good idea, and b that they would face substantial bipartisan pressure and
1:40:54 push back from Congress on this and as a result, has has held the line where it
1:40:58 is now, uh, which is allowing some previous generation chips to go,
1:41:02 although not terribly many. So, uh, his lobbying hasn't been
1:41:06 terribly effective over the last, I'd say 8 or 9 months or so.
1:41:10 Um, but he's been saying privately what he said publicly as well.
1:41:14 So with a Democratic sweep of Congress and obviously a kind of a changing of a
1:41:18 guard in a couple of months here, how do you think that could potentially change
1:41:21 those export curbs coming up when you have more control there on the
1:41:25 Democratic side? Well, the first thing is what happens in
1:41:29 the next few months where there's three key bills, uh, that are pending as part
1:41:33 of the National Defense Authorization Act that would strengthen export
1:41:36 controls. Uh, the I Overwatch Act, the Match act,
1:41:38 and the Chip Security Act. Uh, I think those were somewhat likely
1:41:42 to pass before this. They are now very likely to pass, uh,
1:41:46 those although none of those would have directly prevented the mega speed, um,
1:41:51 exports that we saw. So I there does need to be action from
1:41:54 the administration. I think that the Democrats and frankly,
1:41:57 I think Republicans too, are going to demand accountability on this.
1:42:01 And you're seeing a number of senators today out there on the media asking,
1:42:05 Secretary, how could this happen? How could you have known?
1:42:08 You had known that the company was being run by Chinese spies, but you did
1:42:12 nothing to cut them off from chips. It's really stunning.
1:42:14 Mega speed is still listed on Nvidia's website as an official cloud partner,
1:42:19 and they're still not on the Commerce black blacklist despite having felled
1:42:22 their CEO. Well, this was just a lot of questions
1:42:24 to Chris as to whether it's kind of too late, whether the idea that a lot of
1:42:28 this technology is out there. Uh, you know, for China to do whatever
1:42:32 it wants to do. Can can you can you real this back in or
1:42:36 is it already over? Well, you can't really in ships that
1:42:40 have been that are going to that are in China.
1:42:42 Right. If ships are in China, I think they're
1:42:44 gone. Um, but there's a few different caveats.
1:42:46 I would say, first of all, if there are, China gets a lot of chips through remote
1:42:50 access. So actually they can get they can
1:42:53 remotely access chips from at data centers owned by Microsoft or Amazon or
1:42:56 others. Uh, and that is right now completely
1:42:59 legal. If you shut that off, that, you know,
1:43:02 those that access would go away right away.
1:43:04 Um, the other thing is, I think with respect to AI development generally, the
1:43:09 the need for compute is only going up. And as I demand goes up and the amount
1:43:14 of compute needed for training goes up. Uh, the, the, the needs for computing
1:43:19 power are only increasing. So therefore the importance of
1:43:22 maintaining that lead and actually the amount of computing power that China
1:43:26 needs, its needs as well, is also going up.
1:43:28 So there's never really a too late. Um, but I think this lack of enforcement
1:43:32 has really delayed the impact. All right, Chris, always appreciate it.
1:43:35 Chris Maguire, senior fellow over at the Council on Foreign Relations and
1:43:38 architect of the Chip act under the Biden administration.
1:43:41 And just as we wrap this up, a reminder here, we are expected to hit Nvidia's
1:43:45 earnings next week. And that's going to come a day or two
1:43:48 before we get the anthropic IPO, right? So it's going to be a big week.
1:43:50 Also retailers next week like Walmart and Target if you can believe it.
1:43:53 So a lot of potential market moving news coming out next week.
1:43:57 It'll be interesting to see how the stock trades tomorrow and of course the
1:44:00 policy implications out of Washington. Balance of power.
1:44:02 We'll have that up next.
Nvidia Fallout Looms Over Trump-Xi Meeting full transcript
0:09 >> THIS IS "BALANCE OF POWER." LIVE FROM WASHINGTON, D.C.
0:16 KAILEY: OUR TOP STORY TONIGHT, JENSEN HUANG IS OUT AS CEO OF AN
0:23 VIDEO AS REPORTS UP MULTIPLE AFFAIRS, NOW THREE, DEEP IN THE
0:25 CRISIS SURROUNDING THE CHIP GIANT.
0:30 THE COVENEY SHED BILLIONS IN MARKET VALUE TODAY ALONE.
0:37 THUS, UNDER OATH, HE HAS YET TO APPEAR FOR A BRIEFING, REG
0:43 REMAKES WILL BE IN THE ROOM AND HE JOINS US SHORTLY.
0:51 THE SECURITY QUESTION, A FRESH NATIONAL SECURITY LANDS ON
0:55 U.S.-CHINA RELATIONS JUST DAYS BEFORE PRESIDENT TRUMP HEADS TO
0:57 SHENZHEN. MICHAEL ALLEN JOINS US WITH HOW
1:00 THE FALLOUT COULD SHAPE THE BACKDROP FOR THAT VISIT.
1:02 FROM BLOOMBERG'S WASHINGTON, DC STUDIOS TO OUR TV AND RADIO
1:07 AUDIENCES WORLDWIDE, WELCOME TO "BALANCE OF POWER."
1:14 I'M KAILEY LEINZ, ALONGSIDE JOE MATHIEU.
1:18 JOE: IN A SCANDAL ONLY MADE WORSE TODAY, NEWS OF A THIRD
1:22 AFFAIR, THE SECOND WITH A SUBORDINATE AT NVIDIA, ACCORDING
1:27 TO REUTERS. OUR TEAM COVERAGE STARTS RIGHT
1:30 NOW WITH ED LUDLOW IN SAN FRANCISCO AND ROMAINE BOSTICK IN
1:31 NEW YORK. THE CONVERSATION TAKING PLACE
1:37 INTERNALLY AT NVIDIA HAS GOT TO BE SOMETHING, AS WE UNDERSTAND
1:41 THERE WAS A GATHERING OF THE TOP BRASS INSIDE THE COMPANY TODAY.
1:45 THE CFO RBC STANDING IN ON AN INTERIM BASIS.
1:48 WHAT NEEDS TO COME NEXT IN TERMS OF FINDING A PERMANENT
1:49 REPLACEMENT? ED: THERE ARE MEDIA REPORTS OF A
1:57 SECOND AFFAIR AND A MEDIA REPORT THAT THE THIRD AFFAIR WAS THE
1:59 STRAW THAT BROKE THE CAMELS BACK AS THE BOARD MET LAST NIGHT.
2:03 THEY'VE GONE THROUGH A HEADHUNTER TO FIND A LONG-TERM
2:06 SUCCESSOR, LARGELY FOCUSED ON EXTERNAL CANDIDATES.
2:09 IN THE INTERIM, IT BECAME CLEAR THAT THE INTERIM CFO WILL BE IN
2:14 PLACE TO STEADY THE SHIP. SHE HAS BEEN THERE FOR 13 YEARS
2:18 ALONGSIDE JENSEN HUANG. SHE IS A KNOWN QUANTITY TO WALL
2:21 STREET AND SHE INTERACTS WITH A VERY LARGE INVESTOR BASE VERY
2:22 OFTEN. THE ONE THING THAT NEEDS TO BE
2:26 STATED IS THAT THERE ARE A SERIES OF JUSTICE DEPARTMENT
2:30 INVESTIGATIONS GOING ON WHICH RELATE TO ONE OF THE AFFAIRS IN
2:34 PARTICULAR. THERE'S ALSO AN INTERNAL
2:37 INVESTIGATION GOING ON BY NBD'S BOARD WHO HAS RECRUITED OUTSIDE
2:39 COUNSEL. NONE OF THAT HAS BEEN RESOLVED
2:41 TODAY. THERE ARE BIG OUTSTANDING
2:47 QUESTIONS, WHICH IS WHY THERE IS CONFIRMATION THAT JENSEN HUANG
2:50 WOULD TESTIFY TO CONGRESS, NOW THERE'S A TIMELINE TOWARD THAT,
2:53 IT'S A SIGNIFICANT MOMENT BECAUSE FRANKLY, THIS IS NOT
2:54 OVER AND THERE'S A LOT WE DON'T KNOW.
2:59 WHAT I DO KNOW IS THAT NVIDIA WILL ABSOLUTELY REPORT HIS
3:01 EARNINGS NEXT TUESDAY. KAILEY: TO ED'S POINT, IT'S ONLY
3:05 JUST BEGINNING. OPUS MAKE SENSE OF THE FACT THAT
3:11 THE STOCK ONLY FELL BY 4% TODAY. I KNOW IT HAD LOST A QUARTER OF
3:14 ITS VALUE FROM THE PEAK LAST MONTH HEADING INTO THESE
3:16 REVELATIONS, BUT ARE YOU SURPRISED?
3:21 DID YOU HEAR SURPRISE TODAY THAT THERE WASN'T MORE DOWNSIDE?
3:26 ROMAINE: NO, THE EXACT OPPOSITE. AT ONE POINT IN THE DAY THE
3:31 STOCK WAS DOWN 13%. ONE MORNING AFTER -- ONE MINUTE
3:39 AFTER THE STOCK OPEN. A LOT OF PEOPLE CAME BACK IN A
3:42 DECIDED THEY WANTED TO BUY. THE STOCK ONLY CLOSED DOWN 4%.
3:50 IT'S TO TESTAMENT TO TWO THINGS, WE ARE FROM ROSS GARBER AND
3:53 OTHERS, THE IDEA THAT THEY STILL SELL A PRODUCT YOU CAN ONLY
3:55 REALLY GET FROM NVIDIA. WHETHER JENSEN HUANG IS THERE OR
4:00 NOT, THAT HASN'T CHANGED. THERE WILL BE A LOT OF
4:03 COMPANIES, AT LEAST DOMESTICALLY, THAT WILL BE
4:07 PERFECTLY HAPPY TO DO BUSINESS WITH WHOEVER IS LEADING THE
4:09 COMPANY. THERE ARE A LOT OF OTHER
4:12 QUESTIONS ABOUT SALES TO COMPANIES THAT AREN'T BASED IN
4:15 THE U.S. AND WHETHER SOME OF THE INVESTIGATIONS THAT I KNOW YOU
4:17 AND JOE WILL BE TALKING ABOUT TODAY, THAT IT WOULD IMPEDE
4:23 THOSE INTERNATIONAL SALES, BUT FOR RIGHT NOW, NO.
4:25 I WANT TO POINT OUT, ED WAS TALKING ABOUT THE CONFERENCE
4:33 CALL IN THE EARNINGS GOING ON, SHE IS WELL RESPECTED.
4:37 SHE HAD A LONG CAREER BEFORE THIS AT MICROSOFT AND A LOT OF
4:39 OTHER BIG TECH COMPANIES BEFORE SHE LANDED AT NVIDIA AND AS CFO
4:44 SHE WAS WIDELY RESPECTED. MY GENERAL GUESS IS THAT ONCE
4:47 INVESTORS HEAR FROM HER A LITTLE MORE AS CEO, AND NOT JUST
4:52 INTERIM CEO, MY GUESS IS THEY WILL BE PLEASED WITH HER THERE
4:54 AS WELL. JOE: THERE'S A BIG QUESTION
5:02 ABOUT DRAIN DRAIN AT NVIDIA, THE DIASPORA IF YOU WILL.
5:04 A LOT OF PEOPLE WHO WORK THERE HAVE BECOME BILLION EUROS BY
5:08 STOCK COMPENSATION AND STAYED LARGELY TO WORK FOR JENSEN
5:11 HUANG. WITH A D COMPELLED TO GO TO
5:15 ALPHABET OR ANOTHER HYPERSCALER AT THIS POINT IF THE MONEY WAS
5:16 RIGHT? ED: THAT IS TRUE THAT MANY OF
5:22 THEM ARE COMPELLED TO WORK FOR JENSEN HUANG.
5:24 HAVING SPOKEN TO A NUMBER OF NVIDIA EMPLOYEES, MOST OF THE
5:29 COMPANY YESTERDAY WAS OBSERVING VETERANS DAY.
5:33 THERE IS CERTAINLY, HOW WOULD YOU PUT IT, A SOMBER FEELING AT
5:38 SANTA CLARA HQ TODAY. THIS IS A RISK, THERE COULD BE
5:49 SOME BRAIN DRAIN. IN LARGE PART BECAUSE THESE
5:55 EMPLOYEES ARE LONG TENURED, WHATEVER THE REASONS FOR
5:59 STAYING, SOME OF THEM BELIEVED IN THE IDEAS THAT JENSEN HUANG
6:03 WAS PLANNING FOR THE FUTURE DEMAND.
6:04 ALSO A LOT OF PEOPLE ARE SHOCKED INTERNALLY, BASED ON THE
6:09 REVELATIONS OF THE LAST 48 HOURS.
6:13 ROMAINE: ED MAKES A GOOD POINT. IT'S INTERESTING TO SEE SOME OF
6:20 THE MOVES TODAY LIKE AMD, BROADCOM, EVEN TEXAS
6:22 INSTRUMENTS. THERE IS SOME SPECULATION ON
6:26 WALL STREET, NOT THAT THESE COMPANIES WILL SUPPLANT NVIDIA,
6:31 THE INVESTIGATIONS. I'M SURE ED KNOWS, EVERYBODY IN
6:37 SILICON VALLEY IS A HOT COMMODITY THESE DAYS.
6:42 ANYONE IN AI IS A HOT COMMODITY, SO IF YOU CAN LURE THEM AWAY, I
6:45 GUESS NOW WOULD BE THE TIME TO TRY TO DO IT.
6:50 KAILEY: ROMAINE BOSTICK AND ED LUDLOW, THANK YOU BOTH SO MUCH.
6:54 NOW WE WANT TO GO LIVE TO CAPITOL HILL PRIVY JOINING US
6:57 FOR MORE IS DEMOCRATIC CONGRESSMAN GREGORY MEEKS OF NEW
6:59 YORK, THE RANKING MEMBER OF THE HOUSE FOREIGN AFFAIRS COMMITTEE.
7:03 CUMBERSOME, WELCOME BACK TO BLOOMBERG TV AND RADIO.
7:06 I IT WOULD ASSUME YOU WILL HAVE A SEAT IN THE HEARING THAT WE
7:09 UNDERSTAND JENSEN HUANG HAS AGREED TO COME CLOSE TO HER
7:12 TESTIMONY. IS THERE A FIRM DATE ON THE
7:14 CALENDAR FOR THAT YET? REP. MEEKS: I'VE NOT HEARD OF A
7:19 FIRM DATE YET. WE WILL HAVE TO HEAR FROM THE
7:23 MAJORITY AND SEE WHEN THAT DATE IS.
7:25 KAILEY: WHENEVER THAT DATE IS PUT ON THE BOOKS, WHAT IS YOUR
7:29 FIRST QUESTION FOR HIM? REP. MEEKS: I WANT TO KNOW
7:36 ACTUALLY WHEN HE WAS INFORMED BY THE ADMINISTRATION, WHETHER A
7:41 SECRETARY RUBIO OR THE PRESIDENT, THAT THE PERSON HE
7:45 WAS HAVING THE AFFAIR WITH WAS AFFILIATED WITH CHINA IN AN
7:49 ESPIONAGE SITUATION. AND WHAT INFORMATION HE MAY HAVE
7:57 KNOWN OR BEEN REQUESTED BY HER OR ANYONE ELSE IN REGARD TO THE
8:06 COMPANY, WE NEED TO KNOW. SO IT'S JUST TO HEAR FROM HIM.
8:10 THIS IS JUST THE TIP OF THE ICEBERG, BECAUSE FOR ME, IT'S
8:16 NOT ABOUT JUST THE ILLICIT AFFAIR THAT HE HAD, IT'S ABOUT
8:19 THE INFORMATION THAT MIGHT'VE BEEN GIVEN TO CHINA AND OTHERS
8:26 THAT ENDANGERS THE NATIONAL SECURITY OF THE UNITED STATES OF
8:27 AMERICA. AND SINCE, FOR EXAMPLE, IT WAS
8:35 KNOWN ABOUT A YEAR AGO, WHEN FIRST REPORTED, AS REPORTED BY
8:39 THE MEDIA, THAT THE CHINESE INTELLIGENCE WAS THERE, ON THIS
8:47 LADY COME AND SECRETARY RUBIO FELT THAT THE INFORMATION WAS SO
8:50 IMPORTANT THAT HE HAD TO TELL THE PRESIDENT.
8:54 THE QUESTION THEN IS WHY DID THE ADMINISTRATION NOT IMMEDIATELY
8:59 NOTIFY NVIDIA, THAT'S GENERALLY THE NORMAL PROCEDURES THAT TAKE
9:02 PLACE. WHY DIDN'T THAT TAKE PLACE?
9:06 WAS HE NOTIFIED OR NOT? THAT WOULD BE ONE OF THE FIRST
9:10 QUESTIONS I WOULD ASK HIM DIRECTLY.
9:17 JOE: WHETHER HE WAS NOTIFIED, CONGRESSMAN, HE WAS INVITED ON
9:18 AIR FORCE ONE AFTER THE PRESIDENT KNEW ABOUT THIS, AFTER
9:23 HOWARD LUTNICK AND MARCO RUBIO WERE INFORMED.
9:26 THIS IS JENSEN HUANG, AN INDIVIDUAL WHO WAS VERY CLOSE TO
9:28 THE PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES.
9:30 IS AMERICA LESS SAFE BECAUSE OF WHAT JUST HAPPENED?
9:34 REP. MEEKS: IT COULD BE. WE NEED TO FIND OUT.
9:38 ONE OF THE THINGS I INTEND TO DO, ESPECIALLY ONCE I BECOME
9:40 CHAIR OF THE COMMITTEE IN THE NEW YEAR IS THE FACTS.
9:42 WHAT DID WE KNOW? IT WE KNOW THAT MS. WONG WAS
9:50 UNDER INVESTIGATION FIRST BY SINGAPORE, WHY WAS SHE UNDER
9:52 INVESTIGATION? WE DID KNOW THERE WAS AN
10:00 INTERACTION BETWEEN THE U.S. GOVERNMENT AND THE SINGAPORE
10:05 GOVERNMENT. WHAT WAS DISCUSSED THERE?
10:10 WHAT I'VE HEARD WAS THAT MANY OF THE THINGS THE SINGAPORE
10:12 GOVERNMENT NEEDED TO GET FROM THE AMERICAN GOVERNMENT, THE
10:21 AMERICAN GOVERNMENT DID NOT GIVE THEM ARE DOING THING TO HELP
10:23 THEM WITH THEIR INDEPENDENT INVESTIGATION, FROM WHAT I
10:27 UNDERSTAND, IT'S ABOUT FRAUD, NOT ABOUT ESPIONAGE.
10:30 BUT WE WANT TO KNOW WHAT TRANSPIRED THROUGH THAT WHOLE
10:31 PARTICULAR PERIOD OF TIME. AND THEN WHEN AND WHAT
10:37 INFORMATION DID THEY HAVE ABOUT THE ESPIONAGE, AS YOU SAID, HE'S
10:39 BEEN ON THE PLANE WITH THE PRESIDENT, MR. HUANG.
10:47 DID THE PRESIDENT TELL HIM THE WOMAN YOU'RE SLEEPING WITH IS
10:49 UNDER INVESTIGATION OF BEING A SPY?
10:53 DID THAT CONVERSATION EVER HAPPEN BETWEEN THE TWO?
10:57 NORMAL PROCEDURE SAYS WHEN YOU SUSPECT SOMEONE OF BEING A SPY
11:02 DEALING WITH ESPIONAGE, YOU DO NOTIFY ANYONE AROUND THAT
11:03 INDIVIDUAL THAT THAT PERSON IS UNDER INVESTIGATION.
11:09 AND A FRIENDSHIP BETWEEN THE TWO, IT SEEMS LIKE SOMETHING
11:12 LIKE THAT SHOULD'VE TAKEN PLACE, AND IF IT DIDN'T, WHY DIDN'T IT
11:14 TAKE PLACE? THOSE ARE QUESTIONS THAT WE NEED
11:18 TO HAVE ANSWERED. TICKET EARLY SINCE WE KNOW --
11:25 PARTICULARLY SINCE WE KNOW THAT NVIDIA WAS ALSO TELLING --
11:27 SELLING CHIPS TO MEGA SPEED. THEY WERE BEING SOLD TO MEGA
11:35 SPEED BECAUSE OF THE DANGER OF IT GETTING INTO THE HANDS OF THE
11:37 PEOPLE'S REPUBLIC OF CHINA. KAILEY: AND THE COMMERCE
11:43 SECRETARY HOWARD LUTNICK DID NOT STOP THAT FROM HAPPENING.
11:46 HOW MUCH BLAME DO YOU PUT ON HIS SHOULDERS AND WHAT SHOULD THE
11:47 CONSEQUENCE BE? REP. MEEKS: THOSE ARE HUGE
11:49 QUESTIONS. AND WHY WAS IT DEFERRED FROM
11:59 COMMERCE AND BIAS TO THE COMMERCE DEPARTMENT?
12:03 THESE ARE QUESTIONS THAT HAVE TO BE ASKED, BECAUSE WE DON'T HAVE
12:05 ANY ANSWERS TO THEM RIGHT NOW. THIS IS WHY WE HAVE TO DO A
12:11 THOROUGH INVESTIGATION OF HER, BECAUSE THOSE ARE ISSUES THAT
12:14 POP OUT. THESE ARE THE QUESTIONS THAT
12:19 NEED TO BE ANSWERED, AND WE WILL BE FOCUSED ON, HOPEFULLY
12:28 STARTING 119TH CONGRESS, BUT IF NOT, IT WILL BE FOCUSED ON IN
12:34 THE 120TH CONGRESS. JOE: LAST TIME YOU WERE ON, YOU
12:40 ARE ASKED ABOUT IMPEACHMENT WITH REGARD TO THE PRESIDENT.
12:43 YOU SAID I AM NOT EVEN UTILIZING THAT WORD.
12:45 HOW ABOUT WITH REGARD TO HOWARD LUTNICK?
12:49 REP. MEEKS: I THINK THAT AS YOU CAN SEE, WE WILL LOOK AT ALL THE
12:54 FACTS AND SEE WHERE THEY GO. THE ONLY ONE RIGHT NOW THAT I DO
13:03 USE THE I WORD WITH IS MR. HEGSETH, BECAUSE HE IS A FAILED
13:06 SECRETARY OF DEFENSE. IN EVERY WHICH WAY BECAUSE OF
13:17 THIS WAR THAT HAS BEEN PROSECUTED AND PERSECUTED, BOTH
13:20 OF THOSE HAVE TAKEN PLACE UNDER HIS ADMINISTRATION, AS WELL AS,
13:24 WHEN YOU LOOK AT THE MORALE WITHIN THE MILITARY NOW, THE WAY
13:29 HE JUST SUMMARILY DISMISSED INDIVIDUAL GENERALS AND OTHER
13:32 OFFICERS WHO HAVE SERVED THIS COUNTRY WITH MERIT AND FOR A
13:34 LONG PERIOD OF TIME. SOME OF IT SEEMS TO BE RACIALLY
13:38 INSENSITIVE ALSO. SO HEGSETH, AS I WROTE IT JUST
13:44 YESTERDAY, TO IMPEACH HIM, IS THE ONE PERSON THAT WE WOULD
13:51 LOOK AT AGAIN POSSIBLY COME AS FAR AS IMPEACHMENT IS CONCERNED.
13:58 AS FAR AS THE SECRETARY OF COMMERCE, WE CAN KEEP MORE
14:01 RESERVATION. KAILEY: I WANT TO RETURN TO WHAT
14:05 YOU SAID A MOMENT AGO ABOUT HOPING THIS WILL BE DEALT WITH
14:08 IN SOME FORM IN THE CURRENT 119TH CONGRESS.
14:12 IS YOUR EXPECTATION THAT TIGHTER EXPORT CROP -- CONTROLS ON CHINA
14:16 WILL PASS IN THE LAME-DUCK SESSION?
14:21 REP. MEEKS: INDY A WOULD DEFINITELY BE THE VEHICLE FOR
14:23 THAT, AND WE ARE WORKING ON IT. WE WILL GET PROPOSALS BACK FROM
14:32 THE ADMINISTRATION, WE WANT TO MAKE SURE THAT IS
14:35 DONE IN THE APPROPRIATE WAY AND IT AFFECTS ALL COUNTRIES ACROSS
14:39 THE BOARD, NO EXCEPTIONS IN BETWEEN THAT THERE ARE CLEAR
14:44 GUARDRAILS AND THEY CAN BE EASILY DETERMINED WHAT CONTROLS
14:56 ARE THERE AND WHETHER THERE ARE ALLIES THAT COULD UTILIZE THOSE
15:02 CHIPS IN WAYS THAT COULD BE UTILIZED IN WAYS THAT WE DON'T
15:05 WANT TO. THE NDAA IS VERY IMPORTANT FOR
15:12 OUR OWN NATIONAL SECURITY. JOE: WILL DEMOCRATS DEMAND IT?
15:21 REP. MEEKS: WE ARE DEMANDING IT. IT SEEMS AS THOUGH WE ARE HAVING
15:27 A DECENT DIALOGUE AND CONVERSATION AND NEGOTIATION
15:28 ABOUT WHAT IS GOING IN THERE. SO I DON'T WANT TO UNDERMINE
15:33 THAT. THAT WILL CONTINUE BECAUSE THE
15:37 PROCESS SEEMS TO BE WORKING. EACH ACTION WE ARE DOING, THEY
15:44 WANT US TO BE ABLE TO WORK TOGETHER WHERE WE CAN AND THIS
15:49 MAY BE AN ISSUE WHERE WE CAN SIT DOWN AND TRY TO HAVE SOME
15:53 NEGOTIATIONS AND COME UP WITH SOMETHING THAT KEEPS AMERICA
15:54 SECURE. WHILE THAT IS TAKING PLACE AND
16:01 NOT GOING TO GO ANYWHERE FURTHER THAN THAT.
16:07 I AM HOPEFUL WE WILL GET SOMETHING IN THE LAME-DUCK
16:11 SESSION IN THE NDAA. JOE: THANK YOU FOR JOINING US.
16:19 THE NVIDIA REACHING THE WHITE HOUSE AS PRESIDENT TRUMP WEIGHS
16:23 IN ON JENSEN HUANG'S EXIT. THE FOLLOW RACING PRESSURE ON A
16:29 MEMBER OF THE PRESIDENT'S CABINET.
16:32 STRAIGHT AHEAD ON BLOOMBERG TV AND RADIO.
16:53 JOE: IT IS "BALANCE OF POWER" ON BLOOMBERG TV AND RADIO.
16:56 PRESIDENT TRUMP WEIGHING IN ON THE STUNNING SHAKEUP AT NVIDIA
17:01 POSTING ON TRUTH SOCIAL THAT JENSEN HUANG HAS DONE A
17:04 FANTASTIC JOB, OFFERING A STRIKING SUGGESTION FOR WHO
17:09 SHOULD TAKE THE HELM, FORMER APPLE CEO, TIM COOK.IT COMES
17:19 DAYS BEFORE TRUMP HEADS TO CHINA FOR THE APEC SUMMIT.
17:23 PRESIDENT TRUMP WILL BE WITHOUT JENSEN HUANG AT HIS SIDE AFTER
17:26 HE JOINED THE PRESIDENT FOR TWO MAJOR MEETINGS WITH CHINESE
17:34 OFFICIALS. JOINING US FROM THE PRISM OF THE
17:39 WHITE HOUSE, JEFF MASON. WE KNOW IF THE PRESIDENT SPOKE
17:40 WITH TIM COOK? >> WE DON'T.
17:47 THE PRESIDENT LIKES TIM COOK JUST AS HE LIKES TIM COOK --
17:55 JENSEN HUANG. HE WAS AT HIS SIDE.
18:01 I WILL NOTE THAT THE INITIAL GUIDANCE THAT WE GOT AND WE
18:05 BROKE THE STORY OF THE CEOS WHO WERE GOING ON THAT TRIP WAS THAT
18:09 JENSEN WAS NOT COMING AND THEN THE PRESIDENT DIDN'T LIKE THE
18:12 COVERAGE AND HE ENDED UP JOINING IN ALASKA.
18:15 I REMEMBER STANDING ON THE TARMAC AND WATCHING HIM WALK
18:22 OVER AND SEEING THAT THAT WAS BREAKING NEWS REAL TIME.
18:27 THERE IS A LOT OF NEWS ABOUT HAVING STEPPED DOWN FROM NVIDIA.
18:31 THE IMPACT WILL CERTAINLY BE SEEN AFTER IT OVERSHADOWS PART
18:36 OF HIS TRIP. JOE: THERE WAS MORE THAN TIM
18:41 COOK'S NAME, WRITING THAT NOW THAT JENSEN HUANG WHO HAS DONE A
18:45 FANTASTIC JOB THERE WAS ONLY ONE MAN TO TAKE HIS PLACE.
18:47 THE PRESIDENT IS GOING OUT OF HIS WAY TO SAY THAT JENSEN HUANG
18:51 HAS DONE A FANTASTIC JOB. TODAY REMAIN FRIENDS, WILL HE
18:55 SUPPORT HIM THROUGH THIS INVESTIGATION?
18:58 >> GOOD QUESTION. HARD TO SAY WHERE THE
19:00 INVESTIGATION IS GOING TO GO BUT THE PRESIDENT HAS UNTIL NOW BEEN
19:08 VERY SUPPORTIVE, EVEN DISMISSIVE OF THE BROADER POTENTIAL
19:09 NATIONAL SECURITY CONCERNS. HIS FOCUS ON HIS EMOTIONAL TOLL
19:17 AND THE EMOTIONAL ISSUES AND THE SADNESS HE WAS GOING THROUGH AND
19:22 NOT NECESSARILY THE IMPACT IT WAS HAVING ON NATIONAL SECURITY
19:28 OR ON JENSEN'S FAMILY. I WOULD SAY HE IS A SUPPORTER.
19:39 JOE: IS ANYBODY TALKING ABOUT A PARDON?
19:42 >> HAVEN'T HEARD ANY TALKS ABOUT A PARDON BUT THERE AREN'T ANY
19:45 CHARGES HE WOULD NEED TO BE PARDON FOR AT THIS POINT.
19:48 JOE: WELL, THAT HASN'T STOPPED PRESIDENTS IN THE PAST.
19:54 KAILEY LEINZ STANDING BY WITH MARIO PARKER FOR THE DEBRIEF.
19:58 KAILEY: THE NVIDIA SCANDAL IS CREATING A CABINET LEVEL PROBLEM
20:02 FOR THE TRUMP ADMINISTRATION TALKING SPECIFICALLY OF THE
20:03 COMMERCE SECRETARY, HOWARD LUTNICK.
20:07 HE IS AT THE CENTER OF THIS WITH BROADER QUESTIONS FOR THE
20:12 POLICY. THEY SAID THE COVERAGE DESERVES
20:21 MUCH BROADER SCRUTINY. >> HOWARD LUTNICK AND HOW HE GOT
20:26 IN THE WAY OF TRYING TO ENFORCE OUR LAWS PREVENTING THE CHINESE
20:31 COMMUNIST PARTY FROM GAINING ACCESS TO SEMI CONDUCTORS.
20:36 THAT IS DEEPLY, DEEPLY DISTURBING.
20:39 THIS IS A DISASTER AT THIS POINT AND IT DESERVES TREMENDOUS
20:44 SCRUTINY NOT ONLY BY NVIDIA'S BOARD, BUT BY THE INTELLIGENCE
20:48 COMMUNITY AND THE U.S. GOVERNMENT AS WELL.
20:54 KAILEY: SO LET'S GET MORE WITH MARIO PARKER IN THIS WEEK'S
20:56 DEBRIEF. HIS HOWARD LUTNICK IN TROUBLE?
21:00 >> YES, CLEARLY HE IS IN TROUBLE RIGHT NOW.
21:05 YOU SEE REPUBLICAN LAWMAKERS WHO WILL BE TAKING CONTROL OF
21:08 WASHINGTON -- YOU SEE REPUBLICAN LAWMAKERS, NOT JUST THE
21:13 DEMOCRATS TAKING CONTROL OF WASHINGTON IN JANUARY.
21:19 YOU HAVE OTHERS CALLING FOR MORE TRANSPARENCY HERE AS TO WHAT
21:25 HOWARD LUTNICK KNEW AND WHEN HE KNEW IT AND WHY HE CHOSE TO MAKE
21:28 THE DECISIONS HE DID. KAILEY: WHAT ABOUT INSIDE THE
21:31 HOUSE? THE WHITE HOUSE RELEASED A
21:37 STATEMENT THAT PRESIDENT TRUMP STANDS BEHIND HIS COMMERCE
21:40 SECRETARY BUT THERE HAVE BEEN RUMORS ABOUT HIM BEING ON THE
21:41 OUTSKIRTS BEFORE. >> WE SAW THE FULL MEDIUM
21:53 STATEMENT FROM THE WHITE HOUSE TODAY.
21:55 IT WAS A STATEMENT OF SUPPORT, NOT NECESSARILY THE PRESIDENT
22:00 TAKING TO TRUTH SOCIAL EITHER IN THE WAY HE DID WITH HIS SUPPORT
22:05 FOR JENSEN HUANG. THE SOURCES I'VE SPOKEN TO
22:11 INSIDE THE WHITE HOUSE SAID THERE HAVE BEEN TENSIONS BETWEEN
22:13 LUTNICK AND OTHERS. THERE ARE THE REPORTS BETWEEN HE
22:22 AND SCOTT BESSENT AND HE AND SCOTT BESSENT GOING BACK TO LAST
22:25 YEAR BUT THEN THERE OTHER REPORTS THIS WEEK THAT OVER THE
22:31 LAST WEEK OR SO THAT SCOTT BESSENT IN PARTICULAR CONFRONTED
22:34 HOWARD LUTNICK AS TO WHY MEGASPEED WASN'T ON ONE OF THE
22:39 BLACKLISTS AS WELL BUT MY SOURCES TELL ME THERE HAD BEEN
22:42 SOME TENSIONS WITHIN THE SIX MONTHS AND THAT HOWARD LUTNICK'S
22:48 POSITION HAD BEEN A LITTLE SHAKY OVER THE LAST SIX MONTHS OR SO.
22:52 KAILEY: IF HE IS FINDING HIMSELF BURNED BY WHAT HAS GONE DOWN
22:56 WITH NVIDIA, DOES THIS HELP THE RISING STAR OF MARCO RUBIO AS IT
22:58 HAS BEEN REPORTED THAT HE WAS THE ONE WHO BRIEFED THE
23:01 PRESIDENT ON THIS AND TRIED TO BE THE GOOD GUY?
23:06 MARIO: WE SEE HIM COMING OUT ROSES AND A COUPLE OF WAYS AS WE
23:08 WOULD SAY DOWN SOUTH. THIS LATEST INSTANCE BEING
23:14 SOUNDING THE ALARM AHEAD OF THIS TRIP TO CHINA THAT JEFF MASON
23:22 MENTIONED BUT NEVERTHELESS JENSEN HUANG STILL DID MAKE IT
23:23 ONTO THE PLANE. HAVEN'T BEEN ABLE TO VERIFY
23:27 INDEPENDENTLY THAT MARCO RUBIO WAS RESPONSIBLE FOR RAISING
23:32 THOSE ALARMS BUT IT GOT BEAU'S FOR HIS 2028 PROSPECTS IF HE
23:34 STILL HARBORS THEM. KAILEY: WE WILL FIND OUT.
23:39 JOE? JOE: COMING UP, THE NVIDIA
23:44 FALLOUT ON A COLLISION COURSE WITH THE U.S.-CHINA TRADE
23:46 DEADLINE DAYS BEFORE PRESIDENT TRUMP AND PRESIDENT XI MEET
23:52 FACE-TO-FACE. MORE WITH MICHAEL ALLEN FROM
23:54 BEACON GLOBAL STRATEGIES ONLY HERE ON BLOOMBERG.
24:05 >> WHEN YOU ARE THE CEO OF A
24:09 COMPANY YOU HAVE TO FOCUS ON OF COURSE YOUR FAMILY, BUT I'VE GOT
24:12 A WHOLE BUNCH OF OTHER FAMILIES I'M CARING FOR.
24:16 I'M RESPONSIBLE FOR THE ENTIRE INDUSTRY, SO I THINK THE
24:18 PRESSURE OF BEING THE CEO IS HIGH, AND IT'S SUPPOSED TO BE
24:21 HIGH. IT SHOULD NOT BE AN EASY JOB.
24:26 IT SHOULD NOT BE A JOB THAT YOU TAKE FOR GRANTED.
24:31 WHEN I DECIDED TO BE CEO, I DIDN'T REALIZE THE MAGNITUDE OF
24:33 THE PRESSURE AND RESPONSIBILITIES, BUT THAT'S
24:36 WHAT I SIGNED UP FOR. KAILEY: WELCOME BACK TO "BALANCE
24:41 OF POWER," ON BLOOMBERG TV AND RADIO.
24:47 ALONGSIDE JOE MATHIEU, I'M KAILEY LEINZ.
24:49 THAT WAS PART OF AN EXCLUSIVE CONVERSATION BETWEEN THEN NVIDIA
24:56 CEO JENSEN HUANG AND BLOOMBERG'S EMILY CHANG ONE MONTH AGO.
24:59 THE COMMENTS SHEDDING LIGHT ON HOW AWARE HE WAS OF THE WEIGHT
25:03 ON HIS SHOULDERS. NOW SPILLING DIRECTLY INTO THE
25:07 U.S.-CHINA RELATIONSHIP. HIS EXIT IS FUELING NEW CALLS IN
25:11 WASHINGTON FOR TOUGHER EXPORT CONTROLS ON CHIP SALES TO CHINA
25:15 JUST DAYS BEFORE TRUMP MEETS WITH XI JINPING.
25:19 THAT COULD COMPLICATE AN ALREADY FRAGILE TRADE TRUCE.
25:22 JOINING US FOR MORE IS JENNIFER WELCH A BLOOMBERG ECONOMICS.
25:28 TIMING IS EVERYTHING, AND THE TIMING OF ALL THIS REALLY IS
25:29 SOMETHING. JENNIFER: ABSOLUTELY, IT'S RIGHT
25:37 BEFORE PRESIDENT TRUMP IS DUE TO GO TO SHENZHEN TO SIT DOWN WITH
25:42 CHINESE PRESIDENT XI JINPING, ALSO AS CONGRESS IS PREPARING
25:44 ITS END OF YEAR LEGISLATION AND DEBATING NEW CONTROLS ON
25:46 SEMICONDUCTORS. AND OF COURSE IT'S COMING AS
25:51 CONGRESS IS ALSO PREPARING TO CHANGE HANDS AND DEMOCRATS ARE
25:54 WORKING ON WHAT THEIR AGENDA WILL BE FOR THE NEXT TWO YEARS.
25:58 JOE: I'M STILL TRUCK BY THOSE COMMENTS WITH EMILY CHANG.
26:03 I'VE GOT A WHOLE BUNCH OF OTHER FAMILIES I'M CARING FOR?
26:08 THE SEX SCANDAL, SPYING, SMUGGLING, THIS HAS BECOME A
26:11 BIPARTISAN AFFAIR OVER THE PAST COUPLE OF DAYS.
26:16 DOES THIS ACCELERATE THE ADOPTION OF EXPORT CONTROLS ON
26:17 CAPITOL HILL? JENNIFER: I THINK IT LIGHTS UP
26:23 ARE UNDER THEM IN MULTIPLE WAYS. YOU ALREADY HAD INTEREST IN SOME
26:27 MEASURES, I THINK THIS IS LIKELY TO PROPEL THAT.
26:32 YOU HAVE INCREASING ATTENTION ON WHAT HAS BEEN EXECUTED ON WITH
26:35 RULEMAKING AUTHORITY AND THAT'S ALL COMING OUT AS PART OF THIS.
26:39 DEMOCRATS COME I THINK IT'S FAIR TO SAY ARE STILL DEBATING WHAT
26:43 CHINA POLICY WILL LOOK LIKE THAT THIS REALLY FORCES THAT DEBATE
26:45 IN A DIFFERENT DIRECTION AND TIES IT INTO THEIR FOCUS ON
26:50 CORRUPTION WITHIN THE ADMINISTRATION AND HOW EXTERNAL
26:52 PARTIES IN PRIVATE COMPANIES ARE SHAPING U.S. POLICY.
26:58 KAILEY: SAY THE U.S. DECIDES TO GET WAY TOUGHER ON EXPORT
27:00 CONTROLS, WHAT DOES CHINA DO IN RESPONSE?
27:06 JENNIFER: IT'S A KEY QUESTION TO SEE IF THEY WILL TRY TO GET
27:08 AHEAD OF IT IN SHENZHEN. I THINK CHINA SEES THE U.S.,
27:12 WHETHER BY LEGISLATION OR COMMERCE AUTHORITY, TO TIGHTEN
27:15 THE RESTRICTIONS. THE HISTORY IS THAT THEY HAVE
27:19 TIGHTENED RESTRICTIONS ON RARE EARTHS.
27:21 WE SAW THIS YESTERDAY AHEAD OF THE MEETING BETWEEN PRESIDENT
27:23 TRUMP AND PRESIDENT XI. THE U.S. TOOK CONTROL MEASURES
27:28 AGAINST SUBSIDIARIES OF LIKE LISTED FIRMS.
27:33 THE TRADE TRUCE HAS DELAYED ALL THOSE BUT THE TRUCE IS DUE TO
27:38 EXPIRE IN JANUARY AND THERE'S OPEN QUESTIONS ABOUT WHETHER
27:40 THEY WILL GET IT ACROSS THE FINISH LINE FOR A FULL
27:43 EXTENSION. IF WE SEE CONTROLS BETWEEN NOW
27:52 AND THEN, BEIJING DOESN'T DISTINGUISH IF IT WAS
27:53 LEGISLATIVE OR EXECUTIVE ACTION. JOE: SOME DEMOCRATS ARE CALLED
27:58 ON THE PRESIDENT -- TO CANCEL THIS TRIP ALL TOGETHER.
28:01 HE SAID NOT ONLY AM I NOT CANCELING, I MIGHT NOT BRING
28:02 THIS UP. HE DOESN'T PLAN TO MAKE IT AN
28:06 ISSUE. WOULD THIS BE THE FORUM TO BRING
28:08 UP SOMETHING THAT MAY OR MAY NOT BE PROVEN?
28:15 JENNIFER: THEORETICALLY, YOU WOULD VIEW A MEETING BETWEEN
28:18 THESE LEADERS TO DO THINGS LIKE EXTEND A TRUCE THAT IS ABOUT TO
28:21 EXPIRE. THE FACT THAT THERE ARE TENSIONS
28:29 ON BOTH SIDES AND THINGS THEY COULD NOT GET THROUGH, AT THAT
28:31 TIME I HIS OVERT U.S. FRUSTRATIONS THAT CHINA WASN'T
28:33 HOLDING UP ITS END OF THE BARGAIN.
28:36 NOW THERE WILL BE CHINESE CONCERNS ABOUT WHETHER NEW
28:37 EXPORT CONTROLS ARE COMING. THE PLAN FOR THIS MEETING HAS
28:45 BEEN LIMITED. IT MAY END UP BEING A RELATIVELY
28:48 SHORT MEETING. IT'S HARD IN A WEEKS TIME TO TRY
28:52 TO TURN THINGS AROUND AND GET A MAJOR AGREEMENT OUT OF IT.
28:56 THEY ARE TO MEET AGAIN LATER THIS YEAR AT THE G20 IN MIAMI.
29:00 THAT WOULD THEORETICALLY BE THE LAST OPPORTUNITY TO EXTEND THIS
29:02 TRUCE BEFORE IT EXPIRES IN JANUARY, BUT THAT IT THAT'S THEY
29:06 COULD ALSO JUST KICK THE CAN DOWN THE ROAD AND EXTENDED BY A
29:07 FEW MONTHS. JOE: JENNIFER WELCH FROM
29:13 BLOOMBERG ECONOMICS, THANK YOU SO MUCH.
29:16 JOINING US IS MICHAEL ALLEN, WHO SPENT SOME TIME IN THE BUSH, THE
29:20 GEORGE W. BUSH ADMINISTRATION ON THE NATIONAL SECURITY SECTOR.
29:23 YOU WORKED WITH THE NSC. GREAT TO HAVE YOU BACK.
29:27 THERE'S A HUGE SERIES OF INVESTIGATIONS INTO JENSEN HUANG
29:31 AND EXACTLY WHAT HE DID. OR THERE FAILURES INSIDE THIS
29:35 ADMINISTRATION? MICHAEL: FIRST AND FOREMOST,
29:40 CONGRESS SHOULD DIRECT ITS QUESTIONS TO THE SECURITY STAFF.
29:48 YOU HAVE EXPORT CONTROLS, SHARE JURISDICTION WITHIN THE WHITE
29:49 HOUSE, THEY OUGHT TO BE ASKING HARD QUESTIONS OF THE PEOPLE IN
29:54 THE WHITE HOUSE, WHAT WAS THE STATUS OF EXPORT CONTROL
29:56 REGULATIONS AND WHAT WAS HOLDING THEM UP?
29:59 WHY WERE THEY MOVING FASTER? ESPECIALLY IF THE SENIOR
30:03 LEADERSHIP OF THE UNITED STATES KNEW OF ALL OF THESE CHINESE
30:07 EFFORTS TO OBTAIN THIS BY SMUGGLING AND BY REMOTE ACCESS,
30:13 WHICH WE ALL KNOW THE CHINESE HAVE BEEN TRYING TO DO FOR SOME
30:14 TIME. KAILEY: SO TALK TO US ABOUT HOW
30:19 THIS THIRD-PARTY FACTOR IS AN ISSUE, BECAUSE EVEN WHEN WE ARE
30:23 TALKING ABOUT SOME OF THE LEGISLATING COMMERCE IS LOOKING
30:25 AT, WOULDN'T NECESSARILY HAVE STOPPED WHAT HAPPENED WITH MEGA
30:27 SPEED FROM HAPPENING? WHAT IS IT THAT NEEDS TO CHANGE
30:32 TO SUBVERT FUTURE TEMS TO TRY TO GET AROUND THIS?
30:36 MICHAEL: I THINK YOU HAVE TO BEEF UP THE DEPARTMENT OF
30:37 COMMERCE. I'M NOT SURE WHY I KEEP READING
30:40 THAT PARTS OF IT ARE SHRINKING. YOU NEED GREATER EXPORT
30:46 ENFORCEMENT, GREATER OVERSIGHT. WE NEED TO LAUNCH MORE
30:50 INVESTIGATIONS AND IF WE FIND INTERMEDIATE OR STAT OR BEHIND
30:54 THE SMUGGLING OR FACILITATING REMOTE ACCESS IN OTHER WAYS AND
30:59 THE CHINESE HAVE BEEN ABLE TO UNLAWFULLY GET ACCESS TO OUR
31:02 BEST TIPS, WE NEED TO GO AFTER THEM.
31:03 NOT NECESSARILY CRITICIZING HIM FOR HAVING A SPY AND TRY TO
31:06 FIGURE OUT WHAT'S GOING ON, BECAUSE THERE IS SOMETHING TO
31:09 THE ARGUMENT THAT WE DO TRY TO EACH SPY ON EACH OTHER, BUT IF
31:12 THEY ARE DOING THINGS ILLEGALLY, I WOULD CATCH IT THAT WAY IF I
31:14 WERE STILL IN THE WHITE HOUSE. JOE: WHO WOULD BE CONDUCTING
31:18 THIS INVESTIGATION INTERNALLY? MICHAEL: FIRST AND FOREMOST, YOU
31:23 WOULD WANT SOMEONE IN THE WHITE HOUSE TO LOOK MORE AGGRESSIVELY
31:26 ACROSS AND LOOK AT THE NATIONAL SECURITY COUNCIL.
31:31 I'M SURE THEY HAVE DONE PLENTY OF THINGS.
31:34 I DOUBT THEY'VE DONE ENOUGH, BUT THE QUESTION OUGHT TO BE ASKED,
31:37 AT WHAT POINT WERE THESE REGULATIONS STYMIED, AND WHAT
31:38 HAPPENED? WAS IT RUN OF THE REAL --
31:44 RUN-OF-THE-MILL BUREAUCRACY, OR WAS IT SLOW DOWN ON PURPOSE
31:48 BECAUSE WE DIDN'T WANT TO RESTRICT THINGS?
31:53 JOE: IF THAT IS PROVEN AND THIS DOES TURN OUT TO BE A SUCCESSFUL
31:58 DIVERSION OPERATION, ANYONE HAS BEEN AROUND WASHINGTON FOR A
32:04 POINT. MICHAEL: IF PEOPLE ARE LOOKING
32:08 THE OTHER WAY, IT COULD BE TROUBLE.
32:10 I THINK THEY JUST DON'T HAVE THE CAPABILITY TO DO IT.
32:15 WE DO ENTITY LISTINGS ALL THE TIME, AND THAT WAS THE SUBJECT
32:18 ESSENTIALLY THE AXIOS ARTICLE THIS WEEK, WHEN YOU SAW THE
32:24 ARGUMENT ABOUT IT. LET'S ASKED THOSE QUESTIONS, BUT
32:30 OF COURSE, THE OTHER ANSWER TO YOUR QUESTION IS CONGRESS.
32:31 CONGRESS SHOULD BE LOOKING INTO THIS EVEN IF IT WAS STILL GOING
32:35 TO BE A REPUBLICAN ADMINISTRATION.
32:37 NOW DOUBLY SO UNDER THE DEMOCRATS.
32:41 KAILEY: HOW DO YOU THINK CHINA COMES OUT ON THIS?
32:46 ON ONE HAND YOU COULD SAY CHINA WOULD BE CELEBRATING THE OUSTER
32:50 OF JENSEN HUANG, A U.S.-BASED FACE.
32:52 ON THE OTHER HAND, IF THE END RESULT IS TIGHTER EXPORT
32:55 CONTROLS AND MORE OF A CRACKDOWN ON WHAT CHINA CAN GET ITS HANDS
32:58 ON, IS BEIJING A LOSER? MICHAEL: I THINK THEY ARE A
33:03 LOSER IN THE LONG RUN. THE MORE WE ARE REMINDED OF THE
33:07 FACT THAT CHINA IS RAPACIOUS, THEY ARE TRYING TO STEAL FROM
33:08 US. THEY HAVE A HISTORY OF CYBER
33:12 INTRUSIONS AND WHAT THE HEAD OF THE NATIONAL SECURITY AGENCY
33:14 ONCE CALLED THE GREATEST TRANSFER OF WEALTH IN AMERICAN
33:16 HISTORY. IF WE ARE ABLE TO ACCENTUATE NOT
33:21 THERE SPYING SO MUCH, BUT THEIR ABILITY TO SMUGGLE, THEIR
33:23 ABILITY TO BREAK INTO ESSENTIALLY INTERMEDIARIES THAT
33:28 RUN THIS PARTICULAR TECHNOLOGY IN SINGAPORE OR WHEREVER.
33:31 LET'S OUTLINE THAT FOR THE WORLD AND THEREBY MAKE THE WORLD WHERE
33:34 YEAR OF DEALING WITH CHINA. JOE: WHAT ABOUT THE IDEA THAT
33:43 THE PRESIDENT SHOULD CONSIDER CANCELING THE TRIP?
33:47 MICHAEL: HE'S NOT GOING TO CANCEL BECAUSE HE LIKES THE
33:53 PATTERN SHE -- THE PADRON TREE -- HE LIKES THE PAGEANTRY.
33:59 THE ILLEGAL ACTIVITY, THE SMUGGLING AND THE REST, I
34:01 WOULDN'T CANCEL IT. I WE KEEP BUSINESS AS USUAL
34:03 GOING ON. NOT THAT I THINK ANYTHING WILL
34:07 REALLY BE ACHIEVED BECAUSE WE'VE HAD SO MANY MEETINGS NOW WITH SO
34:10 LITTLE AGENDA, IT'S AMAZING WE ARE STILL MEETING.
34:15 JOE: THE BAR KEEPS GETTING LOWER.
34:18 KAILEY: DOES THE PRESIDENT NEED TO RAISE THIS WITH XI JINPING?
34:23 MICHAEL: HE'S GOING TO DENY IT, WHICH HE WILL ALWAYS DO FOR
34:24 EVERMORE. KAILEY: IS THERE EVEN THE
34:28 POSSIBILITY OF IT BEING PRODUCTIVE?
34:32 MICHAEL: I THINK THE ONLY WAY HE WOULD MENTION IT IS, WE ARE IN A
34:35 COMPETITION WITH YOU AND THE REASON CONGRESS MIGHT GET IN
34:39 HERE IS BECAUSE OF YOUR ACTIVITY IN SMUGGLING AND ELSEWHERE.
34:41 NOT THE SPYING. YOU SHOULD JUST KNOW THAT GOING
34:42 FORWARD. ESSENTIALLY WHAT YOU WANT TO DO
34:49 IS WARD OFF WHAT JENNY MENTION, WHICH IS RETALIATION, THE BLOWUP
34:53 OF THE TRUCE AND OUR INABILITY TO GET CRITICAL IN ROLES.
34:58 IF CONGRESS IS GOING TO ACT ANYWAY, YOU NEED TO BEGIN TO
35:00 INSULATE THE ACCIDENT PUT THE BLAME BACK ON CHINA, NOT ON US.
35:04 JOE: ARE YOU GOING TO SEE HOWARD LUTNICK BACK ON CAPITOL HILL FOR
35:06 A HEARING? IS IT MORE LIKELY THE NEW
35:11 DEMOCRATIC CONGRESS WILL TRY TO IMPEACH HIM FIRST?
35:15 MICHAEL: I THINK THEY WILL WANT HEARINGS.
35:16 I THINK THEY KNOW IT WOULD BE REVELATORY TO HEAR WHAT HE HAS
35:20 TO SAY. THERE WILL BE A CERTAIN DEGREE
35:26 OF COMBATIVENESS IN IT, BUT I WOULD GO STRAIGHT TO THAT IF I
35:27 WERE THEM. LET'S SEE WHAT ALL HE HAS TO
35:29 SAY. AFTER ALL, THERE'S POLITICS AND
35:33 POLICY. A LOT OF THIS IS POLICY.
35:37 WHO IS THE ONE THAT GOT IN THE WAY?
35:42 KAILEY: OBVIOUSLY THIS STORY HAS TAKEN ABOUT THE OXYGEN TODAY.
35:48 THE PRESIDENT WROTE THIS MORNING THAT HE HAS ASKED VICE PRESIDENT
35:52 JD VANCE TO FOCUS HIS COMPLETE AND TOTAL ATTENTION ON THE
35:53 MASSIVE CORRUPTION AND CRIME TAKING PLACE IN DEMOCRAT RUN
35:57 CITIES AND STATES THROUGHOUT THE U.S..
35:59 HE GOES ON TO SAY, WE DON'T NEED TO DEAL WITH IRAN.
36:01 THOSE DAYS HAVE LONG SINCE PASSED.
36:09 WE GOT THEIR MONEY, HUNDREDS OF BILLIONS OF DOLLARS, AND WE'VE
36:09 GOT THERE STRAIT. IS THAT TRUE, WE DON'T NEED A
36:11 DEAL? MICHAEL: I THINK EVENTUALLY WE
36:16 NEED A DEAL. HE IS SAYING THE SLOW BURN OF
36:18 THE BLOCKADE IS WORKING. WE ARE COMING IN LOOKING LIKE WE
36:29 JUST HAD A LOSS IN THE ELECTION, I THINK HE'S TRYING TO SAY TO
36:33 THEM, WE CAN WAIT LONGER. WE HAVE A SUSTAINABLE AND
36:34 EXPENDABLE POLICY. WE ARE NOT NECESSARILY GOING TO
36:39 GET BACK INTO KINETIC FORCE BUT I THINK WE WILL SOON, OR AT
36:41 LEAST IN THE MEDIUM-TERM. I THINK IT'S JUST LIKE, LET'S
36:47 NOT RUSH OVER THERE AND TRY TO GO INTO A PLACE WHEN THEY ARE
36:50 VERY COCKY RIGHT NOW. THEY THINK THEY CONTRIBUTED, AND
36:55 MAYBE THEY DID, TO THE LOSS OF THE REPUBLICAN PARTY DURING THE
36:56 MIDTERM ELECTIONS. KAILEY: JD VANCE THANKS THEY ARE
37:02 TO BLAME. ALWAYS GOOD TO SEE YOU, THANK
37:05 YOU FOR JOINING US. STILL AHEAD, JENSEN HUANG IS
37:08 HEADING TO CAPITOL HILL, SET TO TESTIFY FOR LAWMAKERS FOR THE
37:12 THANKSGIVING RECESS AS CONGRESS DIGS INTO THE NVIDIA SCANDAL.
37:17 WE WILL HAVE OR WITH OUR POLITICAL PANEL, NEXT, ON
37:20 "BALANCE OF POWER," ON BLOOMBERG TV AND RADIO.
37:36 >> THIS IS A FREAKING DISASTER
37:41 AT THIS POINT AND IT DESERVE TREMENDOUS SCRUTINY, NOT ONLY BY
37:47 NVIDIA'S BOARD BUT BY THE INTELLIGENCE COMMUNITY AND THE
37:49 U.S. GOVERNMENT. >> BY HER ALLEGEDLY SLEEPING
37:55 WITH HUANG AND HUANG LOBBYING THE WHITE HOUSE, IT IS SHOCKING
37:58 THE CHINESE WERE SUCCESSFUL. YOU WILL SEE A SIGNIFICANT
38:02 NUMBER OF INVESTIGATIONS. >> WE HAVE TO FULLY INVESTIGATE
38:06 THIS AND IT STARTS WITH A CLASSIFIED BRIEFING.
38:08 THERE NEEDS TO BE A CLASSIFIED BRIEFING ASAP AS TO WHAT THE
38:14 INTELLIGENCE COMMITTEE KNEW AND WHAT THEY DID ABOUT IT.
38:17 >> THERE ARE ONE OF QUESTIONS OF THE NEED TO BE ANSWERED.
38:20 WHAT DID COMMERCE DO ABOUT IT? BUT DID THE SECRETARY OF STATE
38:23 DO ABOUT IT? WAS THERE A MEETING?
38:27 WHAT DID THE PRESIDENT DO ABOUT IT?
38:31 WHY DID THEY NOT TELL JENSEN HUANG?
38:37 >> IN THE MEANTIME WE SHOULD HAVE ENOUGH INFORMATION SO THE
38:40 AMERICAN PUBLIC KNOWS, CONGRESS KNOWS AND HIS SHAREHOLDERS KNOW
38:42 WHAT HAPPENED. >> WHAT KIND OF INFORMATION
38:47 COULD HAVE BEEN GIVEN TO THE CHINESE THROUGH THIS SPY?
38:51 IT IS SOMETHING VERY CONCERNING TO US.
38:54 NVIDIA PRODUCES SOME OF THE WORLD'S MOST ADVANCED CHIPS AND
38:59 THEY ARE CRITICAL TO NATIONAL SECURITY.
39:04 THIS IS A BREACH OF NATIONAL SECURITY AT A PRETTY HIGH LEVEL.
39:08 KAILEY: WELCOME BACK TO BLOOMBERG TV AND RADIO.
39:12 THAT WAS CURRENT AND FORMER OFFICIALS WHO HAVE JOINED US ON
39:15 THE STUNNING DEVELOPMENTS IN NVIDIA.
39:18 JENSEN HUANG IS NOT DONE ANSWERING QUESTIONS, AGREEING TO
39:23 APPEAR BEFORE CONGRESS AS SCRUTINY GROWS OVER THE NATIONAL
39:24 SECURITY FALLOUT. JOINING US AS OUR POLITICAL
39:26 PANEL. NEERA TANDEN, FORMER SENIOR
39:31 ADVISOR TO JOE BIDEN, ALONGSIDE REPUBLICAN STRATEGIST SARAH
39:33 CHAMBERLAIN. WELCOME TO YOU BOTH.
39:40 SARAH, I WILL BEGIN WITH YOU. THIS HEARING WILL BE LED BY
39:46 REPUBLICAN CHAIRS OF COMMITTEES. THIS IS A BIPARTISAN ISSUE.
39:51 WHAT WILL BE DONE ABOUT IT MOST IMMEDIATELY?
39:55 SARAH: HOPEFULLY THEY WILL PUT SOME PROVISIONS INTO PLACE,
39:58 MAYBE GO AFTER SOME WHITE HOUSE OFFICIALS, CALL THEM IN AND SEE
40:01 WHAT THEY KNOW WHAT THEY WILL NOT LET IT LAY THERE.
40:04 THIS IS VERY IMPORTANT TO NATIONAL SECURITY.
40:08 JOE: THE EXTENT TO WHICH AR HAS BEEN POLITICIZED, THE FACE OF AI
40:11 FOR MANY PEOPLE IS THE DATA CENTER.
40:15 THE IMAGES PEOPLE HAVE IN THEIR MIND OF ALL THE MAJOR AI
40:20 EXECUTIVES AT THE WHITE HOUSE IN THE DRIVEWAY WITH PRESIDENT
40:22 TRUMP, THOSE OBJECTS RESONATE. IS THIS AN OPPORTUNITY FOR
40:28 DEMOCRATS TO SAY, WE SAID THIS WAS GOING ON AND I WE NEED
40:33 TOO WRITE US TO LEGISLATE IT?
40:37 NEERA: ONE REASON WHY DEMOCRATS SO OUTPERFORMED IS THEY WERE
40:43 ABLE TO ATTRACT REPUBLICANS, PEOPLE WHO VOTED FOR REPUBLICANS
40:45 IN THE PAST. IN THE SENATE RACES, YOU SAW
40:49 SENATE DEMOCRATS ABLE TO GET 10%, 12% OF REPUBLICANS TO VOTE
40:54 FOR THEM, IN PART BECAUSE OF THE CORRUPTION ISSUES.
40:57 IT WAS A FEW WEEKS AGO THAT JENSEN WAS AT THE WHITE HOUSE
41:03 BROADER DISCUSSION ABOUT PAY TO PLAY AND THE CONTRIBUTIONS TO
41:09 THE PRESIDENT'S ORGANIZATIONS OF WHICH NVIDIA WAS A LARGE ONE.
41:12 THERE IS THE CONNECTION TO THE PRESIDENT HIMSELF.
41:14 NOT JUST HOWARD LUTNICK. WHAT DID THE PRESIDENT KNOW?
41:20 THERE ARE DISCUSSIONS ABOUT SOME OF THE DECISIONS OF THE
41:22 ADMINISTRATION, IT WAS HELPFUL TO CHINA.
41:25 WE HAVE TO UNDERSTAND WHETHER THERE WAS A CONNECTION BETWEEN
41:34 THIS CHINESE SPY, TRUMP OFFICIALS TO ALLOW CHIPS TO GO
41:36 TO CHINA. THAT IS A QUESTION OF NATIONAL
41:39 SECURITY. KAILEY: BUT IS A QUESTION MANY
41:43 WANT TO POST TO HOWARD LUTNICK. DO YOU THINK HE SURVIVES THIS?
41:49 SARAH: WE WILL HAVE TO SEE HOW HE DOES TESTIFY.
41:51 HE WILL CERTAINLY BE CALLED IT. WERE OPPOSED TO, THEY DID NOT
41:56 EVEN KNOW ABOUT THIS. THIS IS SERIOUS.
42:02 THE RUSSIANS ARE PAYING FOR A WEDDING.
42:06 THIS IS NOT A NEW LEVEL. THIS IS NATIONAL SECURITY.
42:09 MY LATE HUSBAND WAS CIA. THIS IS AWFUL.
42:12 IT HAS TO BE DEALT WITH. IT WILL GO RIGHT THROUGH THE
42:17 CABINETS AND FACTS WILL BE FIGURED OUT.
42:21 JOE: IT IS NATIONAL SECURITY. INSIDE THIS WHITE HOUSE?
42:25 SARAH: AT LEAST IMPEACHED. JOE: THERE HAS BEEN ONE ATTEMPT
42:29 TO IMPEACH THE DEFENSE SECRETARY.
42:33 THE COMMERCE SECRETARY COULD POTENTIALLY SEE HIS NAME.
42:38 ARE WE IN THE WORLD POSTELECTION WHERE REPUBLICANS ARE MORE
42:40 WILLING TO TAKE A STAND AGAINST THIS ADMINISTRATION?
42:43 SARAH: IT WILL DEPEND ON THE ISSUE.
42:47 AS I SAID, THIS IS TRULY NATIONAL SECURITY.
42:49 NOBODY SAW THIS COMING. YOU WILL SEE THEM STAND UP AND
42:57 TRY TO GET TO THE BOTTOM OF IT. THE IMPEACHMENT FROM A FEW DAYS
43:02 AGO IS A JOKE. IT SHOWS THE DEMOCRATS ARE
43:07 INCOMPETENT. NEERA: I WOULD DISAGREE.
43:12 WHAT IS INCOMPETENT IS HAVING A SECRETARY OF WAR WHO IS UP INTO
43:16 IMPEACHMENT AND BY A REPUBLICAN MEMBER.
43:21 I WOULD SAY HERE, THE BIG QUESTION FOR THE REPUBLICAN
43:23 PARTY IS DO THEY WANT TO CONTINUE TO OWN THE CORRUPTION
43:26 OF THIS PRESIDENT? IT HAS BEEN INTERESTING,
43:30 SENATORS WHO WERE VERY CLOSE TO THE WHITE HOUSE, SOME HAVE
43:34 GOTTEN SOME COURAGE POST-ELECTION.
43:39 WE SAW KENNEDY'S COMMENTS THAT WERE CRITICAL OF THE WHITE
43:41 HOUSE. I THINK WHAT HAS ACTUALLY
43:46 HAPPENED IS THE AMERICAN PEOPLE HAVE VOICED THEIR ANGER ABOUT
43:49 CORRUPTION AND THE REPUBLICANS ARE GETTING A BACKBONE, WHICH IS
43:53 TOO BAD BECAUSE IT IS AFTER THE FACT.
43:56 KAILEY: TALK ABOUT HAVE REPUBLICANS NEED TO HANDLE THESE
44:01 QUESTIONS AND FUTURE INQUIRIES AND TRYING TO BALANCE IT WITH
44:03 THE DRESSING AFFORDABILITY CONCERNS WHICH WERE JUST OUT
44:06 THERE WITH CORRUPTION. DO THEY RISK TRYING TO OVERREACH
44:11 TOO FAR AND NOT DOING ENOUGH PRODUCTIVELY?
44:15 NEERA: WHAT HAS TO ANIMATE THE ACTIVITIES OF CONGRESS IS HOW
44:21 ARE THEY RESPONDING TO THE NEEDS OF THE PUBLIC?
44:25 THEY ABSOLUTELY NEED TO FOCUS ON AFFORDABILITY, END THE IRAN WAR,
44:32 AND THE TARIFFS THAT ARE COSTING PEOPLE SO MUCH MONEY.
44:37 BUT, WHAT HAS REALLY BEEN CRUCIAL IS TO UNDERSTAND
44:42 CORRUPTION AND COSTS WERE CONNECTED IN THE LAST COUPLE
44:44 MONTHS OF THIS ELECTION. FINALLY, THIS IS AN ACTUAL
44:50 EXAMPLE OF HOW CORRUPTION COULD COST OUR NATIONAL SECURITY.
44:56 IF YOU FOCUS ON HOW TO PROTECT THE AMERICAN PEOPLE AT A LOWER
44:59 COST, THERE IS A LOT OF ACCOUNTABILITY THAT SHOULD
45:00 HAPPEN. THIS WOULD BE AN IMPORTANT FIRST
45:04 BIPARTISAN STEP THAT COULD SET THE TONE.
45:09 JOE: THERE IS ANOTHER ECONOMIC FACTOR, WHEN YOU COMBINE
45:12 CORRUPTION WITH AFFORDABILITY, ORN'T LAWMAKER -- AREN'T
45:20 LAWMAKERS PHONES BLOWING UP BECAUSE OF NVIDIA'S STOCK?
45:26 SARAH: ALL OF US MAYBE HERE AT THE TABLE.
45:30 JOE: ANYONE NEAR A MUTUAL FUND. SARAH: IT HAS GONE DOWN
45:32 DRAMATICALLY. THEY ARE GETTING PHONE CALLS AND
45:36 THE AMERICAN PEOPLE ARE ASKING QUESTIONS.
45:38 HOW DID WE MISS THIS? THE CEO IS HAVING A RELATIONSHIP
45:42 WITH A CHINESE SPY. HOW DOES THAT HAPPEN AND WE DO
45:47 NOT PAY ATTENTION? NEERA: I THINK THIS GOES TO A
45:52 CENTRAL QUESTION, WHICH IS THE CLASSIC -- WHAT DID THE
45:56 ADMINISTRATION KNOW? NOT JUST, WHAT DID MARCO RUBIO
46:01 KNOW, BUT WHAT DID DONALD TRUMP KNOW WHEN HE WAS FLYING AROUND
46:07 WITH THE NVIDIA CEO, TAKING HIM ON GLOBAL TRIPS, HOSTING HIM AT
46:10 THE WHITE HOUSE? THESE WERE PEOPLE APPARENTLY ON
46:14 SPEED DIAL TOGETHER. THAT MIGHT HAVE AFFECTED
46:20 GOVERNMENT POLICY, WHICH ENDED UP BEING MORE EXPOSED TO CHINA
46:23 THAT A LOT OF PEOPLE EXPECTED. THESE ARE CENTRAL QUESTIONS.
46:30 DID NVIDIA'S PAYMENTS TO THE TRUMP ADMINISTRATION, TO TRUMP
46:34 ENTITIES HAVE AN IMPACT ON WEAKENING OUR NATIONAL SECURITY
46:37 AT THE DIRECTION OF A CHINESE SPY?
46:40 IT IS A BASIC QUESTION THE PRESIDENT WILL HAVE TO ANSWER.
46:46 KAILEY: THE NDAA WILL PROFESSIONALLY PROVIDE A VEHICLE
46:50 CONTROLS. CAN THEY FORCE THE
46:54 ADMINISTRATION TO ENFORCE THEM? SARAH: PROBABLY NOT.
46:58 . THE ADMINISTRATION DOES WHAT IT
47:00 WANTS TO AND A LOT OF THESE THINGS.
47:03 WITH A DEMOCRATIC HOUSE AND SENATE, YOU MIGHT HAVE A BETTER
47:05 CHANCE. THERE ARE MORE REPUBLICANS
47:08 WILLING TO SAY TO THE WHITE HOUSE, NO, YOU HAVE GONE TOO
47:11 FAR. JOE: IS THAT HOW THE NDAA WOULD
47:15 PASS? AMAZING.
47:19 WE HAVE ACCOMPLISHED A LITTLE BIT OVER THE COURSE OF THE HOUR,
47:23 THANKS IN PART TO SARAH CHAMBERLAIN AND NEERA TANDEN.
47:27 ONLINE. WE HAVE LEARNED IN THE PAST FEW
47:32 DAYS THIS STORY KEEPS EVOLVING. KAILEY: WE WILL CONTINUE
47:35 COVERING THIS STORY ON TOMORROW'S EDITION OF "BALANCE
47:38 OF POWER," THE FRIDAY EDITION. WE WILL SEE YOU THEN ON
47:42 BLOOMBERG TV AND RADIO.
Allen Says US Needs Stronger Export-Control Enforcement full transcript
0:00 There's a huge series of investigations actually into Jensen Wong, exactly what
0:03 he did. But were there failures inside this
0:06 administration? Yeah, I think for first and foremost,
0:09 Congress should direct its questions towards the Department of Commerce, by
0:12 extension, the National Security Council process staff.
0:15 When I was there as the senior director for counter proliferation, you have
0:18 export controls, share jurisdiction within the white House.
0:22 They ought to be asking hard questions of the people in the white House, what
0:26 was the status of export control regulations and what was holding them
0:30 up? Why weren't they moving faster,
0:32 especially if the senior leadership of the United States knew of all of these
0:38 Chinese efforts to obtain this by smuggling and by remote access, which we
0:45 all know the Chinese have been trying to do for some time.
0:48 Well, so talk to us about how this third party factor, uh, is an issue, because
0:53 even when we're talking about some of the legislating that Congress is looking
0:56 at doing now, it wouldn't necessarily have stopped what happened with mega
0:59 speed? That's right from happening.
1:01 So what is it that needs to change in order to subvert future attempts to try
1:05 to get around it? I think you've got to beef up the
1:07 Department of Commerce. I'm not sure why I keep reading that.
1:10 Parts of it are shrinking. When you need it to be getting bigger,
1:14 you need greater export enforcement. You need greater oversight.
1:18 We need to launch more investigations. And if we find intermediaries that are
1:23 behind the smuggling or otherwise facilitating remote access and these
1:27 other ways, and the Chinese have been able to unlawfully get access to our
1:32 best chips, then we need to go after them, not necessarily criticizing them
1:36 for maybe having a spy that's trying to figure out what's going on, because
1:39 there is something to the argument that we do try to each spy on each other, but
1:43 if they're doing things illegally, I would couch it that way.
1:46 If I were still in the white House, so would be conducting this investigation
1:49 internally. Well, I think it first and foremost, you
1:52 would want someone in the white House to look more aggressively across.
1:57 So maybe someone in the new year in the National Security Council to say what
2:00 was the status of the regulations. And by the way, I'm sure they've done
2:03 plenty of things. I doubt that they've done nothing.
2:06 But the question ought to be asked what at what point were these regulations
2:10 stymied? And what happened was a run of the mill
2:13 bureaucracy. Was it lack of staff at the Commerce
2:15 Department, or worse? Was it slowed down on purpose because we
2:21 didn't want to restrict things that were going?
2:23 If that is proven, if this in fact does turn out to be a successful, uh,
2:28 diversion operation. Yeah.
2:31 Anyone been around Washington for a minute knows this is going to a special
2:34 prosecutor at some point, right. There'll be a special investigator.
2:37 Yeah, I if people are looking the other way, it could be trouble.
2:41 What I think is they just don't have the capability to do it.
2:44 We have some capability to do it. That's why we do entity listings all the
2:47 time. And that was the subject essentially of
2:50 the Axios article this week. Yeah.
2:52 When you saw the beast and the Commerce secretary got into a little argument
2:55 about it, why are we blacklisting more and more companies?
2:58 Why are we doing those fast? Let's ask those questions.
3:01 But of course, the other answer to your question is Congress.
3:04 Congress should be looking into this. Even if it was still going to be a
3:07 Republican administration. Now, doubly so under the Democrats.
3:11 How do you think China comes out in this on net?
3:14 Because on the one hand, you could argue China might be celebrating the ouster of
3:17 Jensen Huang, the face of the eye movement, of course, a U.S.
3:21 based face at that. On the other hand, if the end result of
3:24 this is tighter export controls, more of a crackdown on what China can get its
3:29 hands on in the hawks coming out, is Beijing a loser?
3:32 I think they're a loser in the long run. I mean, the more that we are reminded of
3:36 the fact that China is rapacious, they're trying to steal from us.
3:40 They have a history of cyber intrusions in what the head of the National
3:45 Security Agency once called the greatest transfer of wealth in American history.
3:49 If we're able to accentuate not their spying so much, but their ability to
3:55 smuggle, their ability to break into essentially intermediaries that run this
4:00 particular technology in Singapore or wherever, let's let's outline that for
4:04 the world and thereby make the world where we're of dealing with China.
4:08 What about this idea we threw past? Uh, Jennifer Welch, should the president
4:12 consider canceling this trip, or does he need it more now?
4:16 He's not going to cancel because I think he likes the pageantry and he likes the
4:19 projection of stability. I mean, it's right.
4:22 I don't know necessarily that this rises high enough to cancel.
4:26 I think it's a reason maybe to mention it to him.
4:29 Not the spying, the illegal activity, the smuggling in the rest.
4:33 But I wouldn't cancel it. I would keep business as usual going on.
4:37 Not that I think anything's going to be really achieved, because we've had so
4:40 many meetings now with so little of this agenda, it's amazing that we're still
4:44 that far. Just keeps getting lower.
4:46 We keep asking the question, does the president need to raise this with XI
4:49 Jinping? Would he do anything other than do what
4:51 China already has done, which is deny this woman was an asset in the first
4:54 place? He's going to deny it, which she would
4:56 always do for evermore. So is the thing to do.
4:58 Is there even the possibility of it being productive?
5:01 I think the only way he would mention it is we are in a competition with you.
5:06 And hey, listen, the reason Congress might get in here is because of your
5:11 activity in smuggling and elsewhere, not the spying.
5:15 So you should just know that going forward, because essentially what you
5:18 want to do is ward off what Jenny mentioned, which is retaliation.
5:22 Yeah, violation. The blow up of the boots on truce and
5:26 our inability to get critical minerals. He has to watch that.
5:29 But if Congress is going to act anyway, then you need to begin to insulate their
5:32 action and put that blame back on China and not on us.
5:35 Are we going to see Howard Nick back on Capitol Hill for a hearing?
5:38 Or is it more likely that the new Democratic Congress will try to impeach
5:42 him first. Well, I think they're going to want
5:44 hearings. I think they probably know that it would
5:47 be very revelatory to hear what he has to say.
5:51 I think it'd be a certain degree of combativeness in it, just like with most
5:54 Trump administration witnesses that fight back hard.
5:58 But I would go straight to that if I were them.
6:00 And let's see what all he has to say. I mean, after all, I mean, there's
6:03 politics and there's policy. A lot of this is policy.
6:06 A lot of this is why didn't you act faster?
6:08 And if you didn't, who is the one that got in the way?
6:11 Obviously, this story has taken up all of the oxygen today, Michael.
6:15 So we've paid less attention to things like the president posted on social
6:19 today. But I do want to ask you about this.
6:20 He wrote this morning that he has asked Vice President JD Vance to focus as
6:24 complete and total attention on the massive corruption and crime taking
6:27 place in Democrat run cities and states throughout the U.S.
6:30 he goes on to say, we don't need a deal with Iran.
6:33 Those days have long since passed. We've got their money hundreds of
6:36 billions of dollars. And we've got there straight.
6:39 Yeah. Is that true?
6:40 We don't need a deal. Uh, I think eventually we need a deal.
6:43 But what he essentially is saying here is that the slow burn of the blockade is
6:49 working. I don't want to send him over
6:51 prematurely. As if we're the impatient demander of.
6:54 Well, we really got to get a break here, and we're coming in looking like we just
6:59 had a loss in the elections. Please tin Cup our way.
7:03 No, I think he's trying to say to them we can wait longer.
7:06 We have a sustainable and explainable policy.
7:09 We're not necessarily going to get back into kinetic force, although I do think
7:13 we will soon, or at least in the medium term, maybe in the next couple of weeks.
7:17 But I think it's just like, let's not rush over there and try to go into a
7:21 place when they're very cocky right now. They think they contributed, and maybe
7:26 they did, to the loss of the Republican Party during the midterm elections.
7:30 Well, we know JD Vance thinks the war. He sure does.
7:32 He's tweeted as such. Indeed.
The Debrief: Lutnick Faces Scrutiny Over Chip Export Controls full transcript
0:00 Mario. Is Howard London in trouble?
0:01 Yes. Uh, clearly he's in trouble right now.
0:04 You see, Republican lawmakers, not just Democrats who just took control of
0:09 Washington, will be taking control of Washington in January.
0:12 But you also see calls from the Republican Party.
0:15 You've got John Kennedy, Louisiana senator, saying that he needs to testify
0:19 before God and country. You've got Brian Mast, and you have
0:22 others just who are calling for more transparency here as to what Howard let
0:27 Nick knew when he knew it and why he chose to make some of the decisions that
0:31 he did as it affects US trade policy around chips.
0:35 But what about inside the house? The white House released a statement
0:37 today. The President Trump still stands behind
0:39 his commerce secretary, but there has been rumors of his, uh, potential, uh,
0:43 being on the outskirts before Mario, which he survived.
0:47 The question is whether or not he's going to survive this one.
0:49 Yes. He's survived.
0:50 He's got a long history with the president.
0:52 We saw the full maybe medium throw in its statement from the white House
0:56 today. It was a statement of support, not
0:59 necessarily the president going to the mic, not necessarily the president
1:02 taking the truth social either, in the way that he just did, as you and Joe
1:06 outlined earlier with his support for Johnson.
1:08 One. Right.
1:10 However, that being said, the sources that I've spoken to inside the white
1:14 House tell me that there had been some some tensions between Nick and others
1:18 within the administration over like this.
1:20 The very secretary there are the reports there between he and Scott Bassett.
1:24 There have been reports about him and Scott.
1:25 Best thing going back to last year as well, if you recall.
1:28 But then there's the reports this week, uh, that uh, over the last week or so
1:33 that Scott Bassett in particular confronted, uh, Howard Lutton again as
1:38 to why Mega Speed wasn't on, uh, one of the black lists as well.
1:42 But again, my sources tell me that there had been some tensions within the six
1:47 months, and it that that Howard Lutton Exposition had been a little shaky over
1:51 at least over the last six months or so. Well, if Howard Leatherneck is finding
1:55 himself burned by what has gone down with Nvidia, does this actually help the
1:59 rising star of Marco Rubio? As it's been reported, he was the one
2:02 who briefed the president on this, perhaps tried to be the good guy.
2:06 We do. We see him coming out kind of, uh, as
2:09 they would say down south, coming out roses in a couple of ways.
2:12 Right. We see him, uh, in this latest instance,
2:15 uh, being the kind of sounding the alarm ahead of, uh, this trip to China, uh,
2:21 the Jeff, uh, Mason mentioned. But nevertheless, somehow Jensen Wong
2:26 still did make it onto the plane. Haven't been able to verify
2:30 independently that Marco Rubio was responsible for, uh, raising those
2:35 alarms. But it does bode well for his 2028
2:38 prospects if he's so harvesting.
Rep. Meeks Says Questions Remain Over Nvidia Warning full transcript
0:00 Given your role as ranking member, I would assume you will have a seat in the
0:03 hearing that we understand. Jensen Huang has agreed to closed door
0:07 testimony. Is there a firm date on the calendar for
0:10 that yet? What do you plan to make of the.
0:13 I've not heard of a firm date yet. Um, I'll wait to hear from the majority
0:18 and see when that date is. Okay, well, whenever that date is put on
0:23 the books. Congressman, what is your first
0:24 question? Question for Mr.
0:26 Wong? Well, I want to know, actually, when he
0:30 was informed, uh, by the administration whether it was Secretary Rubio or the
0:35 president, that the person that he was having an affair with was, uh,
0:41 affiliated with China, uh, in an espionage, uh, situation.
0:45 Uh, and what information? Uh, that, uh, he may have known or been
0:50 requested of him, uh, by her or anyone else in regard to, uh, the company,
0:56 especially mega speed, uh, that, uh, um, we need to know.
1:01 So it's just to hear from him, you know, and I think that this is just the tip of
1:06 the iceberg because for me, uh, it's not about, uh, just the the illicit affair
1:13 that he had. It's about the information that might
1:16 have been given, uh, to China and others that endangers the national security of
1:22 the United States of America. And since, uh, for example, that, uh, it
1:28 was known, uh, about a year ago and first reported, uh, as reported by the
1:34 media that the Chinese intelligence, uh, was there, uh, on this lady, uh, Alice,
1:40 uh, Wong, uh, and Secretary Rubio felt that the information was so important
1:46 that he had to tell the president. The question then is, why did the
1:49 administration not immediately notify Nvidia and Mr.
1:54 Wong so that that's during the normal procedures that take place?
1:58 Why didn't that take place, or did it take place?
2:00 Was he immediately notified or was he not notified?
2:03 So that would be one of the first questions that I would ask him directly
2:08 whether he was notified. Uh, Congressman, he was invited on to
2:12 Air Force One, uh, after the president knew about this, after Howard, Nick and
2:17 Marco Rubio, uh, were informed, this is in Jensen Huang, an individual who was
2:22 very close to the president of the United States.
2:25 Is America less safe because of what just happened?
2:28 It could be. We need to find out.
2:30 You know, one of the things I intend to do, uh, especially once I become the
2:34 chair of the committee in the new year, is the facts.
2:38 What did we know? We know that, uh, Miss Wong was under
2:42 investigation. First by Singapore.
2:45 Uh, what happened there? Why was she under investigation by them?
2:49 We didn't know that there was an interaction between, uh, the, uh,
2:56 United States government and the Singapore government.
3:01 What was discussed there? What I've heard was that many of the
3:04 things that the Singapore government needed to get from, uh, the American
3:09 government. The American government was not, uh, and
3:14 how did not give them or do anything to help them with their independent
3:19 investigation, from what I understand and learned is about fraud, not about
3:23 espionage, but we want to know what transpired through that whole particular
3:27 period of time. Uh, and then, uh, when and what, uh,
3:31 information that they have about the espionage and as you said, he's been on
3:35 the plane with the president, Mr. Wong.
3:37 But did the president tell Mr. Wong the woman that you're sleeping with
3:42 is under investigation of being a spy? Did that conversation ever happen
3:48 between the two? Because normal procedure does say that.
3:51 What do you suspect? Someone as being a spy and dealing with
3:54 espionage? You do notify anybody around that
3:57 individual that that person is under investigation and and the friendship
4:04 between the two. It seems that something like that should
4:07 have taken place. And if it didn't?
4:10 Why didn't it take place? Those are questions that we need to have
4:15 answered, particularly since we know that, um, Nvidia was also selling chips
4:22 to mega speed because if you didn't know, that would immediately stop those
4:26 chips from being sold to mega speed because of the danger of it getting into
4:30 the hands of the People's Republic of China?
4:35 Well, and yet the Commerce Secretary, Howard, did not stop that from
4:39 happening. How much blame, Congressman, do you put
4:41 on his shoulders and what should the consequence be?
4:44 Well, those are huge questions. And why was it then deferred from the
4:50 commerce and best biz to the Department of Justice?
4:55 These are questions that have to be asked because we don't have any answers
5:00 to them right now. And this is what we have to
5:03 do a thorough investigation about, because those are issues that pop out at
5:09 these. These are the questions that need to be
5:12 answered. Uh, and we will be focused on hopefully
5:16 starting in 119th, uh, Congress. But if it's not, we'll be focused on
5:23 that and 120th Congress. Mhm.
5:27 Congressman, last time you were on with us on Bloomberg TV and radio.
5:31 I was listening to the conversation on Bloomberg this weekend.
5:34 You were asked about impeachment with regard to the president.
5:36 You said with regard to the I word, I am not even utilizing that word.
5:41 How about with regard to Howard Budnick? Well, I think that, as you can see, that
5:46 we will look at all of the facts and see where they go.
5:52 One of the people, the only one right now that I do use the I work with is Mr.
5:58 Heck said, because he is a failed, uh, Secretary of Defense.
6:05 Uh, and every which way because of this war has been prosecuted.
6:09 Uh, and persecuted. Actually, both of those has taken place
6:13 under his, uh, administration as well as, you know, what you look at?
6:19 Uh, the morale within the military. Now, the way he's just summarily
6:23 dismissed, uh, individual generals and other officers who have served this
6:28 country with merit and for a long period of time.
6:31 Uh, and, uh, some of it seem to be racially insensitive also.
6:35 So Hexa is an, you know, as I voted, uh, just yesterday to impeach him.
6:41 Uh, is the one more person that we would look at again.
6:45 Uh, possibly, uh, as far as impeachment is concerned, as far as, um, uh, Mr.,
6:51 uh, uh, Secretary of the Commerce, uh, we would we need to get more
6:56 information. All right, Congressman, I want to return
7:00 to what you said a moment ago about hoping that this will be dealt with in
7:03 some form in the current 119th Congress. Is it your expectation that tighter
7:08 export controls on China will pass in the lame duck session with the NDAA be
7:13 the vehicle for that? India would definitely be the vehicle
7:16 for that and we are working on it. You know, we get proposals back from the
7:22 administration. Uh, we are then we're having
7:25 negotiations back and forth, uh, that we want to make sure that is done in the
7:29 appropriate way. And it, uh, it affects, uh, all
7:34 countries across the board, no exceptions in between, uh, that there's
7:38 clear guardrails and it can be easily, um, um, determined, uh, what controls
7:45 are there and for countries, uh, particularly whether as allies, uh, that
7:51 could also utilized those chips in ways that could get to the hands that, that
7:56 we don't want them to get into. But yes, uh, I'm hopeful that we will be
8:00 able to pass, uh, export controls in the NDAA, uh, is very important for our own
8:07 national security. Well, Democrats demand it as a
8:11 requirement to pass the NDAA, but we all are demanding it.
8:15 But as I said, what is taking place right now?
8:17 It seems as though we are having a decent dialogue and conversation and
8:23 negotiation about what's going in there. So I don't want to undermine that.
8:28 I want that to continue because that process seems to be working.
8:32 Uh, as I said, uh, each action that we're doing and I think this is what the
8:36 election was clear to me. They want us to be able to work together
8:40 where we can. Uh, and this may be an issue where we
8:43 can sit down and try to have some negotiations, uh, and come up with
8:47 something that keeps America secure. So while that is taking place, I'm not
8:52 going to go any further than that and negotiate.
8:55 Uh, on air here is just that it is happening, and I'm hopeful that we will
9:00 get something in the NDAA, uh, in the lame duck session.
Nvidia’s Huang Ousted by Board full transcript
0:01 This is Bloomberg Businessweek daily reporting from the magazine that helps
0:06 global leaders stay ahead with insight on the people, companies, and trends
0:11 shaping today's complex economy, plus global business, finance and tech news
0:16 as it happens. Bloomberg Businessweek daily with Carol
0:20 Massar and Tim Stent event live on Bloomberg Radio, Television, and
0:25 Bloomberg Originals. And very good afternoon, everybody at
0:30 consumer platforms. Welcome.
0:32 Welcome to Bloomberg Businessweek daily on this Thursday, November 12th, 2026.
0:38 And I gotta say, it's not often that we have one singular story that investors
0:42 are talking about. Yeah, today that one is, of course,
0:46 Nvidia and Nvidia's Jensen Huang, the lone individual most identified with the
0:50 I blew it build, boom, spend and enthusiasm ousted Carroll from his post
0:54 after reports of two affairs, including one with a woman suspected of spying for
0:59 China. Yeah.
1:00 Jenson was Nvidia's only CEO during its three decade history.
1:04 The gravity of his role was one he acknowledged recently to Bloomberg's own
1:08 Emily Chang. You know, I think you have to hold
1:11 yourself responsible. You have you have agency.
1:13 You're to see over the company, for God sakes.
1:15 Um, you have to have high standards and expectations.
1:17 I'm responsible for an entire industry. That's Jensen Huang, formerly of Nvidia,
1:22 speaking with Bloomberg's Emily Chang just last month.
1:25 Emily is going to join us in just a minute with much more.
1:28 Also, we're going to be joined by Ed Ludlow, who's spoken with Jensen Huang
1:31 many times, especially lately. Too many times.
1:35 Carol to. Yeah, exactly.
1:36 His insight invaluable. And, uh, he'll be along as Tim
1:40 mentioned. Um, we're also going to get into, um, so
1:44 many questions because there's the corporate story, there's Jensen Huang,
1:49 there's also what the US administration, the white House also, uh, knew when it
1:53 came to Nvidia's relationship with mega Speed.
1:56 This is happening as the U.S. Justice Department is probing Alice
1:59 Huang over whether entities linked to her were involved in efforts to smuggle
2:03 products made by Super Microcomputer to China and Moonstar.
2:08 Meantime, we do know she is currently living in Beijing.
2:11 Beijing has denied that she was a spy. China's foreign Ministry did not also
2:16 respond to a request for comment. Bloomberg News has reached out.
2:19 So there is a lot going on in this story.
2:21 And I feel like as we worked throughout the morning, throughout the early
2:24 afternoon, more and more things started to come out.
2:27 Well, reports to that. Also.
2:28 Singapore will not let her back in the country, at least not right now.
2:31 Shares of SMBC are down 10.7%. Shares of Nvidia were down as much as
2:35 14.4% earlier in the session. Down, though right now just about 5.2%.
2:39 All right. So let's get you go in for this first
2:42 hour Bloomberg Businessweek daily. And let's get an update on the trade for
2:45 you. Let's talk things over to Charlie.
2:46 All right I thank you very much. Carol and Tim.
2:48 Uh, quite a volatile day for the U.S. equity market.
2:51 Last update told you everything was higher right now.
2:53 Completely different picture. We've got the Dow, the S&P NASDAQ Nasdaq
2:57 100 index all very much in the red. Right now, we're looking at a one tenth
3:02 of 1% loss on the S&P 500 index, Nasdaq 100 down 2/10 of 1%.
3:08 And yes the stock everybody is watching. Nvidia down now by 5.2%.
3:13 Market cap back below $4 trillion. Jensen Huang is going to wind up
3:18 forfeiting about 108 million in invested equity compensation after being ousted
3:24 from Nvidia. That is a fraction of his total wealth.
3:26 But again, Nvidia shares widely held they are down now by just about 5.2%.
3:32 CFO Colette Kress has been named interim CEO.
3:36 The board appointed Harvey Jones as its chair.
3:39 Huang's departure threatens to reverberate far beyond Nvidia, as he has
3:43 used the company's financial strength to back dozens of major AI players.
3:49 So again, we've got the S&P down 14 right now.
3:52 That was a drop of 2/10 of 1%. The Dow Jones Industrial Average down
3:56 one tenth of 1%. We've got Nasdaq down 4/10, the Nasdaq
4:00 100 down 3/10 of 1%. All of us with the stocks.
4:03 The Philadelphia Stock Exchange's semiconductor index down now by about
4:07 8/10 of 1% ten year at 5.11%. Spot gold is down 10.
4:14 The ounce up 3877 down by about 2.8%. We are seeing a rally for crude 8849
4:20 where we stand on WTI up 2.2%, Brent 9547, Brent crude up by 2.9%.
4:28 And Bitcoin cannot ignore the move. They're down 3.8%.
4:31 Bitcoin now at $71,500 on bitcoin. So Nvidia shares their tumbling 5.3%.
4:39 President Trump this morning weighing in on who should run.
4:42 Nvidia president is suggesting that Apple's Tim Cook take over as chief
4:47 executive officer of Nvidia after the ouster of Jensen Huang, who the
4:51 president called a legend Apple little changed, are now by one tenth of 1%.
4:57 I'm Charlie. Tim and Carol.
4:59 That is a Bloomberg Businessweek Charlie.
5:02 Also a legend. I'm just going to throw it out there.
5:03 Totally a legend. Hey, we've got a great group of people
5:07 talking to us this hour over the next three hours, right here on on Bloomberg
5:10 Businessweek daily. Be part of our daily discussions.
5:13 If you want to join us or ask any questions of any of our guests.
5:17 All you have to do is go to Bloomberg.com, slash ask radio.
5:20 Bloomberg.com, slash ask radio. It is available exclusively for
5:24 Bloomberg.com subscribers and terminal clients.
5:26 If you have questions for us or any of our guests over the next few hours.
5:29 All right, folks, so talk about timing. It was just about one month ago that
5:32 Bloomberg's Emily Chang was shooting an episode of The Circuit for Bloomberg
5:35 Originals. This particular episode was about none
5:38 other than Jensen Huang talking to him over four days as he traveled to four
5:43 cities. We were delighted to have with us the
5:45 host and executive producer of The circuit, with Emily Chang joining us now
5:49 from the Bloomberg News San Francisco bureau.
5:51 Emily's episode with Jensen coming out this evening.
5:54 Emily, great to have you here with Tim and me.
5:56 Fortuitous. Your time.
5:58 Uh, with Jensen, I can only imagine, um, everything that's been going through
6:02 your head over the last week or so. His world dramatically changing, as you
6:06 know. Um, just in the last five days.
6:09 Take us back, though. About one month ago, what you set out to
6:13 do for the circuit. Um, what you did do, what you saw and
6:17 your impression of Jensen. And at all.
6:21 Well, Carol, we did what now appears to be the last big interview that Jensen
6:26 Huang will ever do as CEO. And it was Peak Jensen.
6:30 I mean, we saw the crowds where he was holding court with developers, with
6:34 world leaders, with tech CEOs, with even the press.
6:38 You had lines down the block and around the corner just to see him.
6:43 And of course, that term, Jens sanity has now taken on a different meaning.
6:47 And you can look at his comments, um, through a different lens Now I mean it.
6:54 It's hard to believe that this man who was really the chief salesman for the
6:59 and I industry, its biggest optimist, its biggest book booster, has been
7:04 humbled in this way. Chief salesman, biggest booster.
7:07 He's been called the central banker of the AI ecosystem.
7:11 Emily. He's a one of a kind leader.
7:14 I think a lot of people would argue. Is he replaceable?
7:19 Well, Nvidia will definitely survive, uh, Jensen not being at the helm.
7:25 But the question is if it can thrive in the same way.
7:27 Obviously they do have incredible technology.
7:30 They have, you know what what are widely believed to be the best AI chips in the
7:35 industry. So that's saying something.
7:38 But of course, this is a guy who was, until today inseparable from the company
7:43 he had built. He is the only person who has led this
7:45 company for 33 years. And I will say, following him through
7:49 Europe and seeing the way he interacted with world leaders in different
7:53 countries. He is fundamental to the relationships
7:56 with not just the big eye CEOs that we've been talking about, but countries
8:01 and governments around the world that are also buying in Nvidia technology and
8:06 betting big on AI and making decisions now about how to build that they that AI
8:13 and on on and you know what chips to build it with.
8:16 And so um, yes, Nvidia is going to survive this, but it's going to be a
8:21 very different company. I mean, we've all talked about how he
8:24 ran this as a very flat organization with like 60 direct reports, and there
8:28 is no clear successor. You know, Emily, on on that it sounds
8:33 like Jensen certainly knew his own weight, his own voice, his own position,
8:37 how much carried, how much it carry, not just, you know, again at the company,
8:42 but more broadly in the AI story in the tech industry.
8:45 Here's we saw a snippet of the interview.
8:47 Here's what he told you last month. You know, I think you have to hold
8:50 yourself responsible. You have you have agency.
8:53 You're the CEO of the company, for God sakes.
8:54 Um, you have to have high standards and expectations.
8:57 I'm responsible for an entire industry. Um, and so I think the pressure
9:02 of being a CEO is high, and it's supposed to be high.
9:07 It shouldn't be an it should not be an easy job.
9:09 Uh, should be a job that you take for granted.
9:13 That, of course, was Jensen Huang with Emily.
9:14 Emily, you know, you hear all of that? I'm talking about responsibility.
9:17 A job not to be taken for granted in what, as you said, was his last
9:20 interview. Major interview as CEO of the company.
9:22 You think what? You know, that was in response to a
9:27 question about succession. And we knew going into this interview
9:31 that there was and there has been no clear successor.
9:35 And so many investors have been saying for a long time, how can a $5 trillion
9:40 company, now, billion company, not have a succession plan or not have a
9:44 publicly disclosed succession plan. And what he said is I really hope this
9:48 person is at the company. I asked a question about his daughter,
9:52 specifically Madison, who was on this trip with him, and there have been many
9:55 reports that she was in line to be his replacement.
9:59 And, you know, he he he went he started to go on and on about the
10:03 responsibilities and the pressures of the job.
10:06 And obviously now you look at those comments.
10:08 Yeah. Through a different lens.
10:10 And, you know, it's pretty incredible that we were able to get him on the
10:15 record when he would have known that he wouldn't be in the job four weeks later.
10:19 You know, you mentioned Madison Fang, one of his children, who is at Nvidia,
10:24 also son in law. Their son is there as well.
10:27 What were your interactions with with her on this, on this trip that you did
10:32 for this episode of The Circuit that that comes out tonight?
10:34 What did you learn about her? I learned that she's by his side a lot.
10:39 I mean, she was with him everywhere we went.
10:42 There were moments where the press corps was waiting outside for Jensen, and she
10:45 sort of realized we were getting antsy and it was cold and we hadn't eaten.
10:48 And she had the caterers bring out food and drink.
10:52 Um, there was a moment during a presser where he couldn't remember the name of a
10:57 company he wanted to talk about, and he was like, Madison.
10:59 Madison? Where is she in.
11:01 And she came up and she knew exactly, um, the company that he wanted to
11:05 mention. I mean, she's
11:08 my understanding, very present, very pervasive at the company.
11:11 She hasn't, uh, as far as we've heard today, but been seen since this all
11:17 happened. And as you mentioned, Tim, his whole
11:20 family is very intertwined with this organization.
11:23 So that's another thing that's going to have to be dealt with and speaks to the
11:29 very major governance questions that this board is going to be dealing with.
11:34 Speaking of governance questions or just investigations in general, U.S.
11:38 uh, Justice Emily probing Alice Wong, the woman U.S.
11:41 officials suspect as a possible spy targeting, uh, Jensen Huang.
11:46 Um, and also any efforts may be involved to smuggle products made by Super Micro
11:52 to China. I mean, there's just so many different
11:54 angles here. You did though.
11:56 Ask him more broadly about the eye industry and regulation.
12:00 And he talked about that, the role of government and also really the role and
12:04 the responsibility of companies themselves.
12:07 I think it's very appropriate. And the reason for that is this before
12:10 we expect governments and, uh, third parties to regulate us, we should hold
12:17 ourselves to the highest possible responsibilities, standards,
12:20 accountability, the structure that was described as very similar to the way
12:24 that safety systems are internally audited and externally audited by many
12:28 industries, even if we would have had a government regulation
12:33 or international government regulation, who would do the auditing if we didn't
12:38 have the ecosystem of companies that have the capability to do so?
12:42 All right, Emily, again, his use of the word accountability strikes us
12:46 differently today, no doubt about it. But we could we could pass everything he
12:48 says and and look at it differently today.
12:51 Um, it is interesting about, though, accountability of governments, of
12:56 companies themselves to police themselves.
12:58 Also, at a time when he was certainly pushing for China to have, you know,
13:03 access to the most advanced Nvidia chips, like he believed in that as well.
13:07 So it's it's interesting how he juggled kind of the parameters that needed to be
13:11 kind of around the AI industry, right? I mean, you know, he's been saying the
13:16 same thing for months, if not years, that we don't need more regulation.
13:20 We already have the regulation. We need to deal with these AI companies.
13:24 He repeated the same things he's been saying about China policy that, you
13:29 know, we should be selling the best U.S. chips to China.
13:32 We want them to be developing on U.S. technology, because otherwise it means
13:36 China's own domestic capabilities are going to get stronger.
13:40 Um, we've also seen him cozying up to President Trump for the last year.
13:45 And you have to think more about the motivation for for those interactions.
13:50 Now, in retrospect, if you know the issues that we're talking about, go as
13:55 far back as we're talking about. But I also think it's important to point
13:57 out that this is a broader policy stance of the company.
14:01 You know, my understanding is that Colette Kress also believes we should be
14:05 selling the most, you know, advanced chips to China.
14:08 And if there are national security implications there, that's now a much
14:12 bigger deal. You know, as we've been talking about,
14:15 he he was and has been such an ambassador globally to this industry
14:19 flying around the world. I mean, spending so much time on a
14:21 plane, Emily, uh, and being such a cheerleader.
14:24 Jen. Sanity is, as you've described it.
14:26 Do we have to question statements that he's made in the past about what this
14:31 transformative technology can do, or how transformative it could be?
14:35 Or statements about, like, you were just talking about China in the context of of
14:39 what we've learned in the past week. You know, obviously his judgment is
14:45 being called into question. But my you know, in talking to him, the
14:53 optimism was just unwavering. I mean, on this trip, he was asked over
14:58 and over again, but what if I does this? But what if I does that?
15:01 But what if, uh, agents go rogue? You know, and his view was, I don't
15:06 believe. I don't believe it.
15:07 That's nonsense. These companies are just not controlling
15:10 them. It is fully within their power to
15:11 control these agents, and they won't get out of control.
15:14 And so there were so many times that I almost expected him to blink, but he
15:22 didn't. And so
15:25 who knows what's actually going on inside his head.
15:27 But it would lead one to believe that he he does believe that this is the best
15:32 thing that we could be doing right now, in terms of the innovation that's
15:36 happening across the industry that he doesn't think we should slow down and in
15:41 fact, that if we do, it could be detrimental to humanity and certainly to
15:47 the United States. Well, it sounds like he was, you know,
15:50 certainly ready to continue that journey.
15:52 You did talk about his journey, his mission at the company that he, uh,
15:56 co-founded and took public nearly three decades, uh, earlier.
15:59 Let's listen to some more of the conversation Emily had with Jensen Huang,
16:04 uh, 27 years ago. Mhm.
16:07 Nvidia went public. Mhm.
16:10 And they
16:14 put me in this hotel. Oh really?
16:16 Yes. It was the first time I ever had a
16:18 butler. There was a 2000.
16:20 And you'll be blown away $300 million.
16:28 It's things have changed. $300 million.
16:32 That was a lot back then, though. No, no, no, it was fine.
16:36 I was just happy to make it. You were such an unlikely winner back
16:39 then. Yeah, I was just happy to stay in
16:42 business. You know what I was doing?
16:44 Did not write a business plan. And now you know you still don't have a
16:49 right. This is.
16:53 What makes this trip a success? Is it like government commitments?
16:57 Selling chips, data centers. You know, I don't.
17:01 I don't have a endgame. I don't have a roadmap.
17:07 You know, I don't have. I don't have a plan.
17:10 I'm not trying to get anywhere. You know, there's no completion.
17:13 I'm kind of one of those. One of those people that that, uh.
17:16 The journey. The journey is the destination.
17:21 Emily Jensen's journey now includes expected testimony up on Capitol Hill
17:25 with lawmakers. We know he's hired the law firm Paul
17:28 Weiss. Um, the times citing two unidentified
17:31 people familiar with the matter. We don't know exactly what the firm has
17:33 been hired to do. How do you think about what's next for
17:37 Jensen Huang? It's hard to think about what's next
17:41 without just reflecting on how wild this ride has been, and who would have ever
17:48 believed that it would end this way. He's remarking there on the coincidence
17:52 that we, by complete chance, picked the same hotel to do this interview where he
17:58 went public 27 years ago. And the reason we picked that hotel is
18:02 because he was just rushing from place to place on this trip, and we wanted to
18:05 find the most ideally located place where we could get the most time with
18:09 him. I mean, that same day he met with Prince
18:11 William, he met with the Prime minister, he met with the mayor of London, and he
18:16 just he hadn't eaten. Yeah, he he we saw him actually eat like
18:21 a quarter of a sandwich, quarter of a half of a sandwich, which was like the
18:24 only thing he had eaten that day. And the man's pace was simply
18:29 relentless. So I think in terms of what's coming
18:31 next, yeah, he's got to deal with these investigations.
18:33 He has a lot of people to answer to, and he also has to deal with his family
18:36 because he's sure a lot of people. More chapters certainly to come.
18:39 Um, from gentleman. Emily, thank you so much.
18:43 We know you've had a busy week, uh, pulling the next episode of The circuit,
18:46 uh, with Jensen Huang. That does come up this evening.
18:49 Bloomberg Originals at 8 p.m. eastern Bloomberg Television at 10 p.m.
18:52 eastern. Emily Chang.
18:54 The host and executive producer of the circuit.
18:57 We stay on the Nvidia story or Ed Ludlow next.
19:02 It's 221 on Wall Street. We do check markets all day long here.
19:06 Bloomberg. We're looking at a 5.2% drop for in
19:09 video. Now Nvidia shares lower CEO Jensen Huang
19:13 ousted after reports of two affairs, including with one woman who is
19:17 suspected of spying for China. CFO Congress has been named interim CEO
19:24 again. Nvidia down now by 5.2% in a choppy day
19:28 for the equity market. S&P bouncing between gains and losses
19:31 lower now by six points. Little change down under one tenth of
19:35 1%. Dow industrials holding on to a 16 point
19:38 gain up under one tenth of 1%. Both Nasdaq on the Nasdaq 100 index are
19:44 up roughly 2/10 of 1%. The ten year yield at 5.10%.
19:50 Spot gold down 08 the ounce to 3880. That was a drop 2.7%.
19:56 West Texas Intermediate crude oil now higher by 2.3%.
20:01 8853 A barrel. Brent 9564.
20:04 Brent crude, up 3.1%. Oil rallying after President Trump
20:08 declared that the U.S. does not need a deal with Iran.
20:12 Again, Nvidia shares they're trading lower by 5.2%, among other semi names.
20:17 Shares of Broadcom are up 5.8%. Intel down 0.9%.
20:23 Advanced Micro Devices up now by just about five as buy up 5.2%.
20:29 Again recapping S&P lower a little change down one tenth of 1%.
20:33 Carol and Tim that is up Bloomberg Businessweek.
20:36 Yes AMD and Broadcom are two of my gainers in today's mine.
20:39 Can you guess what. Um I'm assuming by decliners.
20:42 I'm assuming Nvidia and super Micro. Oh super micro yes.
20:47 Yeah. There's a preview for the four stocks.
20:49 We'll see what happens. Story today.
20:51 We'll see what happens at the end of the trade.
20:52 No that is fair. That is fair.
20:54 Hey um we are talking about Nvidia. Of course, at the heart of the AI boom.
20:57 It's something we've talked about so much, not only this year, but of course
21:00 over the last three years and so and counting.
21:03 Um, Nvidia has cut all ties with the individual at the center of it all, the
21:08 CEO, Jensen Huang, you know that over a scandal involving extramarital affairs
21:13 and reports that he was targeted by a Chinese spying plot.
21:16 There's a lot of stuff going on. We know the CFO, Colette Kress, will
21:19 serve as interim CEO while also, uh, serving the company still as CFO.
21:24 Um, and the company is said to be seeking a successor for Jensen Huang.
21:28 With more, we go to back to San Francisco and to Ed Ludlow, the host of
21:32 Bloomberg Tech. And I think it's fair to say a lot of
21:36 us, including Jensen in the board, didn't think we'd be talking about this
21:40 at this period of time. Uh, an Nvidia without Jenson even
21:44 involved in the company. What does it mean, not having him there?
21:50 Yeah. I mean, lots of people posing the
21:51 question, what is in video without Jenson Button?
21:54 Um, and then there is a big, uh, divide across the investor base and people in,
22:02 I wouldn't say Silicon Valley. That's too narrow.
22:05 You know, this is something that will have global impact.
22:09 Those that that on the one hand say, you know,
22:13 this is sort of key man risk story. But but it was inevitable.
22:17 And then a very big camp of people that say irrespective of Jenson, someone's
22:22 infidelity and pending the outcome of an internal investigation and those being
22:27 made by US agencies. That gentleman should have stayed in
22:31 post. And so that's what people are grappling
22:33 with now. Well, it's a very sort of big extension
22:35 question. Yeah.
22:36 I mean, any chance he comes back? There have been CEOs who've been let go
22:40 who've come back. Well, I think the way that Karl put it a
22:43 moment goes really important because, you know, I read the statement the
22:47 second it hit on Bloomberg Surveillance this morning, and the one bit that was
22:50 missing from that succinct statement was, is there any relationship at all
22:54 between Jensen Huang and Nvidia? So Bloomberg went back to Nvidia and we
22:58 clarified that going forward, uh, Jensen Huang will not have an association with
23:02 the company. He will not have an advisory role.
23:05 He will not be chairman emeritus. He will not be an employee or an
23:09 executive. And that's like really important.
23:11 He will be a shareholder, of course. Um, but the principal difference between
23:15 Jensen Wong and, say, an Elon Musk or Mark Zuckerberg, which if three of us
23:19 have talked about so much recently, right, in the context of the midterms,
23:22 is that actually, Jensen Wong has relatively modest economic ownership of
23:26 this company at less than 4%, right? But he has no voting power, right?
23:30 There is not that that dual class of shares.
23:33 So can you talk to us about that? Tim and I have been talking about this
23:36 in the newsroom big time. Ed, it kind of blows my mind.
23:39 Is this individual so identified with one particular company and its dramatic
23:45 growth and creation of wealth for many investors?
23:49 Um, this company for what, three decades essentially, and that he didn't have a
23:55 more significant share of the company or that he didn't have voting shares.
23:59 When you think of something like meta or you think about Elon's universe, right?
24:04 These these are individuals who have created something so identified with the
24:08 company, but they also have voting shares.
24:10 So there's a lot of control. I'm not saying one is wrong because I
24:13 was surprised we were be answers quite straightforward because Nvidia went
24:18 public in 1999 before having a found a friendly dual class share structure was
24:24 popular. Um, simple as that.
24:26 I had a meeting relatively recently with Jensen Wong at a hotel in San Francisco,
24:31 where we were doing an interview about that delegation that came from South
24:35 Korea. And it was at the time that I was
24:38 working on that story about Sequoia, uh, the venture capital firm.
24:42 And Jensen made this kind of, um, off the cuff remark when I told him about
24:47 the story about Squires, I was reflecting on and he made the point
24:51 that, you know, when he raised money for the first time, uh, Sequoia Partners
24:56 gave him a check for million, which then was a lot of money, and he gave up
25:01 a pretty healthy chunk of equity in exchange for that million.
25:05 And it's just a world away from the economics of what we're talking about
25:09 present day. Yeah.
25:11 I mean, even the tiny chunk that he owns, he is this the largest individual
25:14 shareholder, less than 4% of the company was worth worth around 40 billion at
25:20 today's prices. I do want to talk to you about the board
25:23 and a group of people who I think, fair to say, not known individually very much
25:30 outside of Silicon Valley or in some cases, Sand Hill Road.
25:33 Um, in fact, one board member who's been there for more than 33 years, truly
25:38 since the beginning. Talk to us about the type of people who
25:42 are on Nvidia's board and their relationship in general with Jensen
25:46 Huang. What was the most important one?
25:48 Because this is the news that's come out of come out this morning is is Harvey C
25:53 Jones. And he is a known quantity in Silicon
25:57 Valley and also in the chip industry. Not not just by virtue of being a
26:01 director. Since 1993 he was executive chair of
26:05 synopsis, a company Nvidia now has an investment in.
26:08 Um, but that was part of why this morning's news and the way the market
26:12 reacted to it was so interesting. You know, CFO Clark is interim CEO and
26:18 continues the CFO. She has been there for 13 years and for
26:22 the first time, which is it's a strange thing to say out loud if you're not
26:26 familiar with the company. But Nvidia has a chair of its board for
26:29 the first time. De facto, Jensen Huang was operating as
26:33 CEO chairman. He was a director on the board, but he
26:37 did not have the title of chairman. So, you know, Harvey Jones technically
26:41 becomes the first chairman. But business continuity is what I'm
26:44 trying to say. Um, and you know what I was saying a
26:48 moment earlier, go in the internet, you can see these views being shared.
26:51 But there is a big group of investors who wish the board had put this issue to
26:56 a shareholder vote rather than take action themselves.
26:59 And I have to tell you, I got into a little bit of a heated debate
27:02 conversation with my team earlier. Not heated.
27:04 It was really productive. But I said.
27:09 What about the investigations? What about the board?
27:11 Independent board investigation? What about, you know, what the
27:15 government finds out? What they knew, how much they didn't
27:18 get, what they found. Just to be fair.
27:19 Okay. Right.
27:21 I put aside the personal stuff, but like, I keep thinking about what's
27:25 what's more significant materially in terms of the material, the impact on the
27:29 company. Jensen staying with the company or
27:31 Jensen going away. But why put it.
27:33 Well yeah. Go ahead go go for it Tim.
27:34 Well I was just going to say why why put aside the that I mean the personal
27:39 stuff. You know, every CEO who has had a
27:43 relationship with somebody at the company or has had, you know, the, the,
27:49 the line of, of of of CEOs who've had to resign as a result of less than this.
27:56 As it's pretty long, though. I mean, again, the range of views among
28:00 the, the shareholder base and those that do business with Jensen, Wong and
28:04 Nvidia, um, and those AI startups that benefit and rely on the compute or of
28:09 taking investment. The range of views is wide.
28:12 There are people that say this is absolutely behavior unbecoming of a CEO
28:17 of a public company and lead it. There are also those that say infidelity
28:21 is bad, but, uh, that doesn't mean he should be removed from post.
28:25 The point is that a lot of the shareholders would say they should have
28:28 waited for the outcome of the investigations, both internal and by the
28:31 relevant US government agencies, before making a definitive decision.
28:35 And like we discussed this a moment ago. A happy note.
28:39 Reuters now reporting that Jensen Wong had a relationship with a second Nvidia
28:44 employee. Again, headline.
28:46 That's all we've got. Yeah I mean, what I reflect on is that,
28:51 um, when the New York Times story broke last night that Jensen Wong had had a
28:59 relationship, an affair with Kimberly Powell, the vice president of health
29:03 care. Someone, by the way, that last month I
29:06 spent several hours with for an episode of Wall Street Week.
29:08 Um, uh, you know, that seemed to be the straw that broke the camel's back in
29:13 terms of then that then the report started to come out with some cadence
29:17 that the board was moving to, to a place where they would oust Jensen Wong.
29:21 Well, they know the Bloomberg's home reporting that they'd gone to a
29:23 headhunter to find an external replacement long term.
29:26 Um, yeah. The Reuters headlines pretty
29:28 straightforward. Jensen point had relationship with
29:30 second and video employee. Um, that is completely separate from
29:34 from what our ongoing processes now. Right.
29:37 So the board is investigating internally with the help of outside counsel.
29:42 Mhm. Uh, Jensen Wong's relationship with
29:45 Alice Wong of Mega Speed. And when the board issued their
29:50 statement Sunday, they said at that time there was no reason to believe that
29:55 there was any national security or trade secret IP risk that had been found.
30:01 But the investigation is ongoing. At the same time today, Bloomberg
30:05 reports that the Justice Department has a multifaceted probe, one, uh, facet of
30:11 which is that they are probing Alice Wong themselves.
30:13 This is the US Justice Department specifically.
30:16 It's an espionage probe where they're looking at Alice Wong's, uh, the alleged
30:21 spy, alleged Chinese spy in this case, relationship with Jensen Wong.
30:25 But this bit is so important. According to Bloomberg's reporting, that
30:29 Jensen Wong himself is not a subject to those probes.
30:33 They're not looking at him for any wrongdoing, necessarily, which I thought
30:37 was, uh, very interesting. That is completely separate, that
30:41 national security and trade secret concern that's out there and is yet to
30:46 resolve to to Jensen Wong's, uh, infidelity and whatever the the bylaws
30:51 of the company were about relationships with its colleagues, infidelity,
30:55 morality separate from like what was what secrets were were handed over are
31:01 not handed over. Yes.
31:02 But, uh. Okay.
31:03 Bernard Looney at BP resigned after revelations.
31:06 I'm not saying that Brian Krzanich should Intel Steve Easterbrook at
31:09 McDonald's. I'm just saying that, you know, the list
31:12 is long in terms of precedent.
31:15 Yeah, Yeah. And I'm sorry.
31:17 May I say one more thing, guys, before we go?
31:19 Because I don't know where. Out in time, you know, got about a
31:21 little of the time that Jensen Wong me included.
31:24 Journalist spent with Jensen. One.
31:26 Just one spent in front of cameras over multiple years.
31:29 Um, no one was aware of this behavior until late October or any of these
31:34 incidents so late October. There had been previously disclosed, uh,
31:37 investigations into mega speed. Um, uh, and people started asking those
31:42 questions on October 29th, and prior to that, everyone was none the wiser.
31:46 So I commend our industry colleagues at The New York Times because it took some
31:50 journalism and reporting, um, which they you know, they did very well.
31:55 Yeah. I'm safe to say now, you know, yes,
31:57 there will be more stuff coming out. But for Nvidia, the company, you know,
32:00 our focus now becomes really next week are earnings.
32:03 And what we get from the company and what we see now from Colette Kress, the
32:08 interim CEO and also the CFO of the company.
32:10 So yeah, there's going to be lots more, said Ed Ludlow.
32:13 I've been dying. We have been dying to talk to you.
32:15 Welcome back. Ed, we know you had some good days of
32:17 rest, but we missed you and are glad you are back to Eva.
32:20 He's the host of Bloomberg Tech. Catch him at 11 a.m., Wall Street time,
32:24 Monday through Friday on Bloomberg TV. When we come back, we talk a little bit
32:27 about what's maybe happening in DC. Since 240 on Wall Street, we do check
32:35 markets all day long here. Bloomberg.
32:37 We begin with a developing story. Jensen Wong had a relationship with a
32:41 second in vedere employee that according to a report from Reuters.
32:46 All of this on a day of fast moving developments.
32:48 Nvidia's CEO Jensen Huang has been ousted after reports of two affairs,
32:54 including with one woman who is suspected of spying for China.
32:57 CFO Carla Chris Kress has been named interim CEO.
33:02 The board also appointed Harvey Jones as its first ever chair.
33:06 Nvidia shares down now by 6% market cap below $4 trillion, S&P down 22.
33:12 That is a drop right now of 3/10 of 1%. S&P currently at 7597.
33:18 Dow industrials down 78. Drop there of one tenth of 1%.
33:22 Nasdaq Composite down 5/10 of 1%. Nasdaq 100 index down 4/10 of 1%.
33:28 So we are seeing a move lower now for the Dow.
33:30 The S&P and Nasdaq ten year yield 5.10%. Spot gold is down 05.
33:37 The ounce at 3882, a drop of 2.6%. An advance for crude holding above $89
33:44 now 8901 on WTI, up 2.8%. Brent back above 96 up now by 3.5%.
33:52 Microsoft says it's working to restore access to its bundle of workplace
33:56 software, saying customers may experience issues connecting to email
34:00 and other tools on a down day for much of the market.
34:03 We've got Microsoft shares up by 4/10 of 1%.
34:07 Price hikes at the Post office. The U.S.
34:09 Postal Service has filed notice with the Postal Regulatory Commission for
34:13 Domestic and international shipping price increases averaging 5.9% effective
34:20 January of next year. Now, stamp prices will not change.
34:23 First class mail prices remain unaffected by the filing.
34:27 Recapping stocks lower. Right now we've got a shares of Nvidia
34:31 down by 6%. Carolyn Tim that is a Bloomberg business
34:35 flash. Thanks, Charlie.
34:36 You know, on that Microsoft headline, I got a text from a friend in the group
34:39 chat. Uh, he said he said Alex down going to
34:42 the gym. It looks down.
34:44 Okay, Jim, that looks not working. Yes, I have no work to do going to the
34:47 gym. So yes, there are productivity
34:49 implications of stuff like this. Totally, totally.
34:52 All right, folks, um, one of the things we're thinking about is the upcoming
34:55 apex summit. Chinese President XI Jinping's third
34:58 summit of the year with president. Uh, Trump is going off script before
35:02 these meetings even get underway. As the spy allegations engulfing
35:05 Nvidia's Gen Z. Huang, uh, really reopened some old
35:08 rifts. It is all high stakes in a global race
35:12 for a dominance between the United States and China.
35:15 No doubt about it. With more, we bring in Michael Chang,
35:18 Bloomberg Economics chief economics technology analyst.
35:20 He was a former policy adviser at the U.S.
35:22 Department of Commerce. That was April 2023 to April of 2025.
35:25 He joins us from the Bloomberg News Bureau in Washington, D.C..
35:29 Your research note on the global impact of Jensen's exit and how it will hit
35:33 both sides of the US-China air race. What are the impacts that you see here
35:37 in the U.S. and impacts that you see for China?
35:41 So I think a really interesting thing with what's happened with Jensen's exit
35:45 is that fundamentally, you're actually slowing down both sides in terms of
35:49 slowing the U.S. at the at the frontier in the long term
35:52 and slowing China in the short term in terms of the policy impact.
35:55 Right. Uh, specific to the U.S., I mean, it's
35:57 well known and has been repeated by many guests already just how influential and
36:01 how impactful Jensen has been in Nvidia's leadership and Nvidia's
36:05 capabilities, and becoming just one of the most dominant technology companies
36:08 and sort of the foundation of this entire AI infrastructure boom we've had
36:12 over the past few years. And so with him gone, uh, you know, what
36:15 is allowed him to perform and outperform many of the same kind of competitors who
36:19 don't have the obstacles that China has. Right?
36:21 But at the same time, he's still able to outperform them so significantly.
36:24 So from there, you can conceptually easily see how at that U.S.
36:27 frontier, you can see a slowdown and the U.S.
36:29 not able to push that gap that they have over China as much.
36:32 And then on the policy side, this is a sort of a short term impact in that,
36:35 because Jensen Farm was one of the most powerful and influential advocates for
36:39 not having export controls for continuing chip exports to China.
36:43 Um, the loss of him really dents Nvidia's credibility in DC at a time
36:47 when there's a lot of policy waiting in the wings, ready to come online with,
36:50 you know, three different chip export proposals in the, uh, in Senate NDA
36:54 negotiations, potentially other policies coming through the Department of
36:57 Commerce. Um, so with these both combined, you
36:59 have like a potentially a short term slowdown in China, a long term, uh,
37:03 slowdown in the US. And it remains to be seen, really, when
37:06 we talk about great power competition. It's that relative power gap that
37:09 matters. Right.
37:10 And so which I suppose more is the thing that's going to be interesting.
37:13 So Michael, wait wait wait. So okay, but is this a clear win for
37:17 China? Like is it cause a slowdown on an Nvidia
37:21 at least a stumble as they have an interim CEO look for somebody next to
37:26 take over. We know one of the superpowers of Jenson
37:30 was his relationships with company. Um around the world in terms of feeding
37:36 the supply chain that was necessary for Nvidia to do what it did so quickly in
37:42 terms of development of new chips and then get them out to their customers.
37:45 So I'm just curious, is this a win potentially for China to move in a
37:51 little bit more aggressively? But at the same time, we've got this
37:54 individual that is an alleged Chinese spy.
37:58 China says, no, we've got a meeting between the two leaders of the two
38:02 biggest economies. Like, is this expected to come up at the
38:06 Apex summit. So I think this absolutely chills the
38:10 atmosphere of the Apex summit. And to the degree that, you know, we
38:14 already were not expecting much beyond maintaining a status quo with these sort
38:18 of 3 to 4 month meetings we've had over this year.
38:20 Strategic stability. I think this contributes even more to
38:22 sort of freeze again in place. I don't think Jensen's exit is a good
38:26 thing at all for China. Um, just in terms of the policy reaction
38:29 that it's now sparked in the US with so many different policy options that are
38:32 looking to come online. Um, but yeah, to the degree that I do
38:36 think it's going to get progressively harder to maintain the stability, uh,
38:39 because, you know, there was this equilibrium that we had with the US
38:42 holding back its tech leverage, China holding back its whereas leverage.
38:45 And China now knows it's going to be harder for the U.S.
38:47 to actually, um, truly hold back when the decision is somewhat taken out of
38:52 the Trump administration's hands with the Democrats taking power.
38:54 So does it does it change, in your view, how the white House views this
38:58 technology at all? I don't think the reason asked.
39:02 He was so close with President Trump. He had this.
39:05 He was constantly there, side by side with the president.
39:08 He was he was constantly, uh, mentioned by the president, too.
39:11 I mean, he jumped on that plane back in in the spring.
39:14 He jumped on Air Force One in Alaska to go to China, for example.
39:19 Yeah, yeah. I don't think it at all sort of changes
39:23 the importance of I to the Trump administration.
39:25 But I think there are uh, with his exit, it introduces more room for, um, let's
39:30 say alternative interpretations of I. Right.
39:33 So a greater emphasis on air safety. Right.
39:35 You've always had factions within the Trump administration, uh, like Secretary
39:39 Besson, for example, who's always been quite concerned about cyber safety.
39:42 And you could see this potentially taking precedent over just promoting the
39:45 industry or ensuring at max exports, which is sort of what, um, Jensen's
39:49 camp, what what would really push for. Hey, Michael, one thing I want to ask
39:52 you, we've got about, uh, two minutes or so left here.
39:55 Um, we know President Trump gave a vote of confidence to Commerce Secretary
39:59 Howard Luttig, despite reports about his department's lax efforts to prevent
40:03 China for obtaining Nvidia's advanced AI chips.
40:07 Uh, you've worked at, uh, Commerce. You were a, uh, a policy advisor.
40:11 What accountability questions must the government, the U.S.
40:15 government answer here, whether it's commerce, whether it's justice, whether
40:18 it's the white House, in your view? Yeah.
40:22 I mean, I think it really starts with like, what did they know and how early
40:25 did they know it. Right.
40:26 And it like that. The big question is we've had reports
40:29 that, you know, some of this stuff the U.S.
40:31 intelligence community was talking about a year plus prior.
40:34 Um, you add on to the fact that, uh, you know, industries and communications and
40:39 interactions with this administration have not at all been conventional in
40:42 that you have executives talking to executives, which is isn't the typical
40:46 way things are get done. Not a lot.
40:48 It's not really like driven by process. And you could easily see ways where
40:51 investment investigations maybe aren't done exactly the way they are.
40:54 Investigations are going around. And with so much reporting just in the
40:58 past few days about, um, all these different incidents, um, just on the
41:00 Nvidia side, when Democrats actually get full investigator investigative powers
41:05 oversight powers in January. I think that's the mechanism by which
41:08 you could see a lot more come out from what commerce has done, from what
41:12 justice has done, you know, and what precisely they've been holding back on.
41:15 So who are the people you think would be called to testify?
41:19 Um, I mean, I think certainly, you know, Secretary Leon will be asked to testify,
41:24 just given his centrality in this role overall.
41:26 Um, and and really, commerce is, is a central, um, implementer and executor of
41:31 anything to do with us trying to take competition.
41:33 Right. And they've been remarkably dormant over
41:35 the past 1 or 2 years. So almost to an unprecedented level,
41:38 considering or right in the middle of an air competition.
41:41 And so certainly there will be questions about, you know, why this has been
41:44 allowed to happen, um, you know, and why they've been holding back on doing
41:47 anything from someone who worked at Commerce.
41:49 Was it unprecedented the amount of access some of these CEOs, Jensen Huang
41:55 included, had to the white House and just got about 30s here real quick.
41:59 So, you know, I did leave before the bulk of this interaction started.
42:03 But just from former colleagues and discussing their, um, I will say it's
42:07 quite unprecedented. Um, just the way that we interacted was
42:10 not the typical way government interacted with the industry.
42:12 Um, in under this administration, you had to get some time with you.
42:16 Michael. Dang, thank you so much.
42:17 Bloomberg Economics, Geo economics technology analyst, former policy
42:20 advisor at the Department of Commerce. When we come back, a check on trade,
42:24 including Nvidia, we're going to get to stocks on the move on this Thursday.
42:32 This is Bloomberg Businessweek daily with Carol Massar and Tim Stent event on
42:38 Bloomberg Radio and Television. All right, everybody, we're getting
42:41 ready for the last hour of trade on this Thursday.
42:44 Carol Massar Tim of live in our Bloomberg Interactive broker studio here
42:47 in New York City. Um, on a day where we're just down about
42:51 17 points on the S&P 500, down about 78 on the Nasdaq 100, bouncing around a
42:58 little bit. Nvidia definitively lower but off its
43:01 lows of the session. Yeah, it was not as much as uh, more
43:03 than 14% earlier in the session. That's where it opened.
43:05 I mean, the news shocked. I think a lot of people, even though on
43:08 the prediction markets, there were wagers being placed about when Jensen
43:12 Huang would be out as CEO. But, you know, of course there were,
43:16 there were. And now there are predictions about
43:18 who's going to be the next. But what what's uh I mean, the, uh,
43:21 well, I know it was by that. It was literally by the day.
43:24 Yeah. Uh, and I didn't look at it after,
43:28 obviously, but, um, yeah. Before it was like that, it was expected
43:31 in the next few days. I think it's still got a lot of people
43:33 off guard. A lot of people were saying, okay, wait
43:35 a second, what is Nvidia without chance? And he could never be not be at the
43:38 company. You know, the thing is we often talk
43:40 about nobody's irreplaceable. There are some people that are more
43:44 difficult to replace. Um, I don't know.
43:48 You know, it wasn't just CEO of a major company.
43:51 He was really the key voice when it comes to the AI boom and build, um,
43:56 financially helped other companies write or invested in other companies that were
44:00 involved in kind of the AI world. Um, so there was a lot of activity that
44:06 he was involved in as to why we talk so much about AI today.
44:11 Right. Yeah.
44:12 I dunno, maybe that's why we see Nvidia shares lower today, but not at their
44:16 lows of the session. I think we have to figure out I think
44:18 earnings next week. Super super important in terms of what
44:21 we hear um from the company in terms of momentum and the way forward.
44:25 Okay. Should we move forward.
44:26 Let's move on. Um, Carol Massar along with Tim
44:28 Stenbeck. Let's get to some stocks on the move
44:30 with us to do it is Bloomberg News reporter Emily Griffith.
44:33 So she's in the house with us. Um, we have to start with Nvidia.
44:36 Yeah, we have to start with Nvidia. I mean, it's, um, it's moving.
44:40 It's down like you guys just said. Um, it did hit an intraday low earlier
44:45 in the session. It was down about 14%, the biggest
44:48 intraday retreat since 2025. It's pared some of those losses but it's
44:52 still down about 6% amid this leadership crisis.
44:56 Today's news Jensen Huang was ousted from his post amid reports of an
45:00 extramarital affair with a woman suspected of spying for China.
45:06 Then there was another affair with a suspected or suspected affair with
45:10 another Nvidia employee. And then we just got a headline about 30
45:14 minutes ago that there was a second affair with another Nvidia employee, but
45:19 that hasn't, uh, moved the stock too much, at least in this trading session.
45:23 He's out. Yeah, he's already out.
45:25 We do have seven analysts downgrading the stock trading volume five times the
45:29 average for this time of day. We look forward to earnings uh, next
45:34 week. And of course, the succession plan here
45:36 for one of the biggest companies, uh, in the world.
45:40 So a lot to watch here. But right now the stock down about 6%.
45:44 Nvidia and below $4 trillion market cap. I mean it's really come down to
45:49 practically 30% down 30% from last month.
45:52 It's a lot. It's a lot.
45:54 All right. What else got for us?
45:55 Okay, well, this is, um, kind of continuing on with this, um, story.
46:00 Um, so the Justice Department is probing Alice Wong.
46:03 This is the woman U.S. officials suspect as a possible spy
46:06 targeting Jensen Huang. We have news reporting from Bloomberg
46:10 that they're also probing, uh, whether entities linked to her were involved in
46:14 efforts to smuggle products made by super microcomputer to China.
46:18 So super microcomputer SMC. I doubt about 9% today.
46:23 The company declined to comment on prosecutors scrutiny of Alice Wong.
46:27 Um, but watching that, and that's certainly moving the stock.
46:30 It's interesting because SM Sy down, Nvidia down.
46:33 Some of the other chipmakers though are higher AMD Broadcom potentially on just
46:38 the competition may be easing in the eye space.
46:41 And just to add on to that, some of our data also come out and say Super Micro
46:45 denies mega speed has ever been a customer.
46:48 Right. Um, it was a reporter citing a super
46:51 micro statement, uh, in a post on Exo. It just continues to come out, but TBD,
46:57 right? Yeah, it was down as much as 15% today
47:00 but has recovered some losses. Maybe on that that headline from set
47:03 before. Well, another stock that is closely
47:05 aligned or tied to the I trade is core wave.
47:08 It was higher yesterday and brought a lot of sentiment with it and change
47:12 sentiment in yesterday's trade. What's going on today.
47:14 Yeah. So this is one of the NIO clouds.
47:16 They provide computing capacity for AI companies.
47:19 The stock was soaring in the post market yesterday after earnings they boosted
47:23 their revenue projection. It beat estimates.
47:25 But today we're seeing it's not enough to please shareholders.
47:29 Again this is a stock. This down over 30% year to date.
47:32 It's down today 14 analysts surveyed by Bloomberg cut their price targets today
47:37 after the result. Yeah a lot of fears about just how much
47:40 the company is tapping the debt market. Um, and again, just not enough at least
47:44 today to ease those investor concerns. This is despite the fact that Bloomberg
47:48 has reported Core Weave is actually now going to be borrowing in the investment
47:52 grade bond market. So they are a junk bond borrower, but
47:55 they work through a structure to actually lower their borrowing costs.
47:58 So again, we thought that was going to be a good to do that.
48:01 If your junk bond rating. Yeah.
48:03 How do you do that. Yeah it's all about the structuring.
48:07 If you can figure out a way to get it backed or secured by certain kinds of
48:12 payments, financing, as Wall Street will call it, so you can lower your borrowing
48:16 costs and tap that market into like buying points on a mortgage.
48:20 There's always a credit angle. I just find it that it's interesting.
48:25 The more complicated just in turns these relationships get.
48:29 Um, I don't know. It just puts it on my radar.
48:31 I'm not saying anything is wrong. It's obviously it gets done.
48:33 But, um, just something as we think about this, I do crack down about 7%
48:39 rate stuff, as always. Emily Griffith, so good to have you back
48:41 here. Check out our Stock Movers podcast.
48:42 Find it on Apple, Spotify or anywhere you get your podcast that's going to do
48:46 it for our first hour. Stick around the clothes coming your way
48:49 on TV.
What Jensen Huang’s Exit Means for Nvidia’s Future full transcript
0:00 NVIDIA's really in its biggest crisis in its three decade history of operation.
0:04 The NVIDIA board has announced that Jensen Huang is out as CEO.
0:08 That was kickstarted just days earlier.
0:11 CEO Jensen Huang has admitted to having an extramarital affair after reports he
0:16 was targeted by a suspected Chinese spy.
0:19 The woman was a former executive and a customer of Nvidia's,
0:23 the world's second most valuable company at the heart of the global AI industry.
0:27 All the hundreds of billions of dollars in investment in AI will have something
0:32 to do with Jensen Huang one way or another.
0:34 To what extent does the fallout impact chip export restrictions?
0:39 This seems to have all the elements of a movie script.
0:48 What we know is that Jensen Huang admitted to having extramarital relations with
0:52 a woman.
0:53 Her name was Alice Huang, a former executive at Megaspeed International,
0:57 an Nvidia customer accused by the Trump administration of breaking US export
1:01 controls and smuggling chips into China.
1:04 The US government reportedly suspects that she was recruited by a Chinese spy
1:07 agency to influence the Nvidia CEO.
1:10 They're going to be opening an investigation to look at whether Jensen Huang was
1:14 the target of a foreign intelligence operation.
1:17 What's extraordinary is also how the initial suspicions by US intelligence
1:22 community came reportedly last spring,
1:25 but the Trump administration sat on this intelligence without doing virtually
1:30 anything about it that we are aware of.
1:34 No, I don't think so. I think he's an honourable guy.
1:37 I think he probably has an excuse. He's done an amazing job for our country.
1:42 That endorsement wasn't enough and the board made its move praising Huang as
1:47 they showed him the door. But the scandal's impact reaches beyond the boardroom.
1:51 Nvidia is among,
1:53 if not the most strategically critical company for US efforts to
1:57 dominate China in the global chip race.
2:01 Jensen Huang is also a key advocate for releasing more chips to China.
2:05 The prize is AI supremacy,
2:09 and that is what the race is for here because you've got the US that's been
2:12 trying to restrict China's advancements in AI technology for years now with
2:16 things like export controls in place.
2:18 If you can't buy those chips through front door channels,
2:21 find out as much as you can about the man who controls them.
2:28 Jensen Huang founded and for more than three decades ran Nvidia,
2:32 whose advanced semiconductors power the AI revolution.
2:36 It's accelerated essentially the backbone of every single major AI training
2:41 cluster on the planet. On top of that,
2:44 you have Nvidia that's really at the centre of all of these concerns around
2:47 circular financing deals. On top of that,
2:50 you've got this sort of key man risk where Nvidia's CEO has been not only the
2:54 founder of the company, but the CEO of it as well since inception.
2:58 Huang was a crucial component. He was a founder, always in charge,
3:02 nearly 60 senior people reported to him, and he had no obvious successor.
3:07 That lack of a succession plan came up in October when he spoke to Bloomberg for
3:11 an episode of The Circuit.
3:13 I'm really hoping that the next CEO of the company is already at the company,
3:17 but 20 years from now,
3:19 I hope I stay healthy and I hope I continue to earn my keep.
3:23 That statement has not aged well.
3:30 Beijing responded to the scandal by denouncing reports that Alice Huang was a
3:33 Chinese agent.
3:40 But there are legitimate questions about what, if any,
3:43 additional responsibility someone at his position should bear as
3:48 the leader of a company that's strategically important to the United States that
3:53 has tremendous national security implications if any secrets were leaked.
3:57 Then reports of another extramarital affair came to light and Nvidia's board
4:01 met.
4:02 Nvidia's board weighing CEO Jensen Huang's fate,
4:04 following reports of multiple affairs.
4:07 The company and investors began reeling.
4:09 Nvidia shares are falling in pre-market trade.
4:11 Shares of Nvidia right now down more than 11%.
4:15 And then Huang was gone,
4:17 replaced on an interim basis by Nvidia CFO Colette Kress,
4:20 who joined the company 13 years ago after stints at Microsoft and Cisco.
4:25 Jensen Huang was this high flying tech leader and visionary
4:30 who appears to be at the top of the world,
4:33 whose vision brought his company a multi-trillion dollar valuation and
4:37 brought himself tremendous fame as one of the greatest tech leaders of his time.
4:42 But this episode really brought him down to earth.
Stocks Down as Nvidia CEO Resigns full transcript
0:00 And right now we are two minutes away from the end of the trading day.
0:03 Romaine Bostick alongside just Metan taking you through to that closing bell.
0:07 It's a global simulcast. Carol Massar and they join us now.
0:10 Welcome to our audiences across all of our Bloomberg platform.
0:13 Television, radio. Our partnership with YouTube.
0:16 An incredible day on Wall Street right now.
0:19 When we take a look at what's going on in stocks, what's going on in bonds,
0:22 what's going on in oil markets, but of course, all the focus right now is on
0:27 one company and one man Nvidia and Jensen Wong.
0:30 Yeah. How rare is it that we really have one
0:32 singular story that dominates not just today but really throughout the week?
0:36 Uh, we're taking a look at shares of Nvidia.
0:38 I'm just going to bring them up on my Bloomberg down about 4.4%.
0:41 Keep in mind this stock was down more than 14%.
0:44 Um, but it's interesting to see that it hasn't necessarily taken down completely
0:48 the eye trade. And that we're also seeing some other
0:51 companies like an AMD or Broadcom actually rally and, uh, gain on the
0:56 prospect of maybe gaining some market share as Nvidia deals with its woes.
1:00 Um, we were just having a fascinating chat with Lauren Cassidy, the founder
1:03 and chief investment officer of founders 100 ETF, and her ETF has a remit.
1:08 They only invest in companies that are run by founders.
1:12 Nvidia was the third biggest holding in the portfolio at more than 6%.
1:17 Yeah, they have 90 days to sell all of that regardless of what the price does.
1:21 And she was very clear with us. This company without Johnson is not the
1:25 same company that it once was. Yeah.
1:27 I mean checking in on retail traders. They were actually buying the dip.
1:30 According to JP Morgan, its price actually for earnings is only around 11
1:35 times forward right now. So a lot cheaper than you get a
1:37 commission. Well and to your point though itself I
1:39 mean it gets to this idea that okay maybe you remove the man, but has it
1:43 changed the fundamental idea of what it's been selling and the demand and the
1:47 demand, of course, it has actually been coming in for some of those products.
1:51 That remains to be seen. Uh, we should point out that there's a
1:54 lot going on in the world of IE beyond just Jensen Wong himself.
1:58 Remember, Nvidia reports earnings next week, but we're also expect to get the
2:02 IPO from anthropic and a redhead crossing the Bloomberg terminal.
2:05 That anthropic IPO is said to be six times oversubscribed.
2:10 Not necessarily a surprise as we see red across the screen, parallel with all of
2:13 the major indices, down just about a fraction of a percent for the Dow, the
2:17 S&P and the Nasdaq. The Russell 2000 much lower on the day,
2:20 closing down 1.7%. Everybody seems to be eagerly
2:24 anticipating that IPO. Um, in terms of the trade.
2:27 Let's go back there S&P 500. We know the index overall just a little
2:31 bit lower. But most names in that big cap index
2:35 were down today about 379 losing ground. And we did see 124 uh higher in today's
2:40 session. Materials stocks down 1.5% in the S&P
2:44 500 and followed by industrials down around 1%.
2:47 But on the flip side you Brent crude topping $96 a barrel up more than 3%.
2:51 So you're seeing energy stocks gaining on that up more than 1.5%.
2:55 Carol. All right.
2:58 Yeah. Let's uh let's kind of keep this going
3:00 guys, because we talk about this idea of the chip space and the idea that if
3:05 you're not going to Nvidia, who are you going to.
3:07 We had Ross Gerber on earlier today and he said, look, you know, they have the
3:10 chip everybody wants. Are you going to get that from AMD?
3:13 Are you going to get that from Broadcom. Maybe maybe not.
3:16 We are getting some earnings out of other chip makers.
3:17 That includes applied materials right now.
3:20 And we should point out the knee jerk reaction to the shares is relatively
3:23 muted right now. As a company did report EPs relatively
3:26 in line with estimates $4.16 a share. That's $10.10 more than what the street
3:31 was looking for at 406 on average. Sales coming in at about $10.4 billion
3:37 to treat was looking for roughly about $10.3 billion in semiconductor systems
3:42 net sales in the most recent quarter, its fiscal fourth quarter $8 billion.
3:47 On the nose, the street was looking for 7.94.
3:50 Yeah. Interesting, right.
3:51 This is a stock that's been on fire when you're like I mean, a lot of names in
3:54 the semiconductor space have, but it's up about 48% year to date.
3:57 You're seeing kind of a tepid reaction here in the aftermarket Tim.
4:00 The stock right now just down about half a percent as investors work their way
4:04 through it I mean adjusted gross margin 50.6% in the fourth quarter versus 48.1%
4:09 year over year. The estimate on the street was pretty
4:12 much in line with what came in 50.4%. But right now the stock flat a little
4:17 bit in the green here. All right.
4:18 Record quarterly free cash flow $2.6 billion.
4:22 Uh, distributed over $2.4 billion to shareholders.
4:25 Gary Dickerson, the president and CEO of the company, saying that I continues to
4:29 feel strong incremental demand for SMEs and applied has built the most enabling
4:34 portfolio to advance the computing roadmap, putting us in a great position
4:38 for multi-year revenue and profit growth.
4:40 Uh Amat shares in the after hours up by about 1.6%.
4:43 And of course, watching this closely, because investors wanted to know if this
4:46 could potentially slow constraints with supply.
4:49 But the stock a drop more than 45% from that peak that we saw at the end in June
4:53 coming into today, but it's still up close to 50% year to date, guys.
4:58 And we should point out, we're also still waiting to get earnings.
5:00 Uh, a little bit later, uh, in the after hours from Cisco and of course, Tim and
5:05 Carol, we're going to get Nvidia's earnings next week, assuming they they
5:09 still go through with that. But obviously there's going to be a lot
5:11 of questions about the succession process, or I should say, the search
5:14 process for a permanent CEO, of course the CFO are being elevated to interim
5:19 status for right now. And it raises a lot of questions.
5:22 Is does she become the permanent CEO? Do they have someone internally who can
5:26 actually fill those shoes, or do they look from outside the walls?
5:30 It's a really important question. And, you know, we keep hearing how well,
5:34 you know, Jensen understood this company.
5:35 He had been with the company from the beginning, the only CEO, the only leader
5:39 of this company. And again, everyone kind of speaks to
5:43 his relationships with everybody in the industry and his ability to then manage
5:49 the supply chain at Nvidia. And this was really an important asset
5:53 for the company. So having him not in that place, you
5:57 know, you do wonder kind of how that goes forward.
5:59 So where are we going now. Let's go to Gaynor's.
6:02 Oh, Gaynor. Sorry.
6:03 Uh, I got lost in my thought. All right.
6:04 So let's go to, uh, some of the individual Gaynor's kind of that kind of
6:08 a day, guys. Um, we talked about AMD and Broadcom.
6:12 These were definitely two out performers.
6:14 Number one gainers in both the end uh Nasdaq 100 and the S&P 500.
6:19 You have advanced micro, up 5.8%. In today's session.
6:22 You had Broadcom up about 5.5%. These two names gaining on bets that
6:27 they may possibly win business from and vedere as it deals with all of these
6:32 woes if you will changes changes and certainly figure out who will be the
6:36 next CEO. So that is something that we're going to
6:39 have to figure out. We did.
6:40 See also William Blair raising its investment recommendation on AMD.
6:43 So there was a lot going on. But investors uh, in a big way remain
6:47 moving into the space. Uh, staying in the AI space.
6:49 Uh, artificial intelligence infrastructure companies really burst
6:53 out with its earnings report here. I'm going to start with the most recent
6:56 quarter that just passed in the third quarter, a loss per share of $0.67,
7:00 revenue of $231 million. That is a beat.
7:04 And core hardware revenue, uh, coming in above estimates at $86 million for the
7:09 fourth quarter, the company says expect that core revenue number to jump to 310
7:13 to $330 million. That's well above street estimates.
7:17 On average, they were looking for about 271 million.
7:20 The company says that overall gross margins in the quarter will also be
7:24 higher than what the street was looking for.
7:26 Carol, 47 to 49%. The street was looking for 42.
7:29 All right, folks, from Cerebus to Cisco, we go and let's go right to the outlook.
7:32 This always catches investors attention. Uh, Cisco says fiscal year adjusted EPs,
7:37 $5.40, a, uh, $0.47 a share to $5.53. It had seen 505 to 511.
7:44 So that is definitely, uh, upping the adjusted EPs for the fiscal year
7:48 guidance. Also, fiscal year revenue 74.8 billion
7:51 to 75.8 billion. That two is above, uh, the earlier
7:56 estimates by the company. It had seen 72.2 to 73.4 billion.
8:00 And this stock, which is up about 32% year to date.
8:02 Tim, you can see it, bump it up in the aftermarket up about 4.6%.
8:06 Chuck Robbins, chair and CEO of Cisco, says, we are in the very early stages of
8:10 a multi year networking supercycle. We're confident in our ability to
8:13 continue capturing the multibillion dollar opportunity that it represents
8:17 for Cisco. Shares of Cisco in the after hours up by
8:20 more than 6%. Just yeah.
8:21 And the implied move if you one day post earnings is supposed to be closer to 9%,
8:26 so I'm not quite up that much right now, but we'll see how that shakes up in
8:29 after hours. But this stock is up more than 30% year
8:32 to date, guys. So it's pretty important, especially
8:34 when we're talking so much about how this is a real gauge of eye momentum
8:38 right now. Yeah.
8:39 Um, I do wonder these conference calls for Cisco.
8:43 Hey, Matt. Cerebus.
8:45 How many how many questions do you think they're going to give you about it?
8:48 Has your CEO been called? How many questions are you getting going
8:51 about Chinese spies, etc.? Yeah, I mean, that's the thing about
8:55 this whole story, Ramon. And I think this is something that you
8:57 guys have been talking about too, is, is even though Jensen is out of the
9:00 company, this story is far from from over in terms of potential implications
9:04 for the company. We had Bloomberg Intelligence, Robert
9:06 Schiffman on earlier today and his prediction on the way this this ends is
9:10 is a pretty giant check from Nvidia being written to the US government.
9:14 When all is said and done, of course we have a big check.
9:17 Okay. But fine a fine.
9:19 That's what he said. Yeah.
9:20 Um, we have no idea how it will play out, and we have no idea how Democrats
9:23 and Republicans and who they will call to testify as a result of what we've
9:28 learned over the past few days.
Jensen Exits, AI Debt Under Review, Treasuries Slide full transcript
0:01 SCARLET: FROM NEW YORK CITY, FOR OUR VIEWERS WORLDWIDE, I'M
0:03 SCARLET FU. "BLOOMBERG REAL YIELD" STARTS
0:05 RIGHT NOW.
0:17 COMING UP, NVIDIA FOUNDER AND
0:19 CEO JENSEN HUANG STEPPING DOWN AFTER REPORTS OF EXTRAMARITAL
0:21 AFFAIRS INCLUDING ONE WITH AN ALLEGED CHINESE SPY.
0:24 HIS EXIT TESTING THE TECH GIANT'S ROLE AS THE CENTRAL BANK
0:28 OF AI. WARNINGS THAT MORE AGGRESSIVE
0:33 RATE HIKES MIGHT BE NEEDED. TREASURY BOND YIELDS SPIKING THE
0:38 MOST SINCE THE TARIFF MELTDOWN ON THE HAWKISH FED SPEAK
0:42 FOLLOWING HOTTER THAN RESPECTED CPI REPORT.
0:44 YOU BEGIN WITH THE BIG STORY OF THE DAY, NVIDIA SHARES PLUNGING
0:50 14% AT THE OPEN, NOW DOWN ABOUT 5%.
0:55 THIS AFTER CEO JENSEN HUANG RESIGN FOLLOWING THE REVELATION
0:57 OF TWO AFFAIRS, ONE WITH AN ALLEGED CHINESE SPY.
1:03 ED LUDLOW JOINS US. THIS COMES BEFORE THE COMPANY'S
1:08 EARNINGS REPORT TUESDAY AND PLANS FOR JENSEN HUANG TO
1:11 TESTIFY BEFORE CONGRESS. WHAT CAN YOU TELL US ABOUT WHERE
1:15 THINGS STAND WITH THE EARNINGS REPORT AND THE TESTIMONY?
1:19 ED: THE CFO IS BECOMING INTERIM CEO, STILL RETAINING THE CFO
1:22 TITLE. THE BOARD OF NVIDIA WILL LOOK AT
1:25 INTERNAL AND EXTERNAL CANDIDATES FOR A LONG-TERM SUCCESSOR TO
1:31 JENSEN HUANG. BLOOMBERG CLARIFY THAT GOING
1:36 FORWARD, JENSEN HUANG WILL NOT HAVE ASSOCIATION WITH NVIDIA.
1:39 YOU WILL NOT TAKE ON AN ADVISORY ROLE, HE WILL NOT BECOME
1:43 CHAIRMAN EMERITUS. THAT HAD NOT BEEN CLEAR FROM THE
1:46 STATEMENT. THE STOCK IS ON TRACK FOR ITS
1:50 BIGGEST DROP SINCE JANUARY 2025. THERE IS THE BREAKING THE LAST
1:56 THREE MINUTES -- BLOOMBERG IS CONFIRMING THAT THE JUSTICE
1:58 DEPARTMENT IS CONDUCTING AN ESPIONAGE PROBE INTO ALICE HUANG
2:03 'S RELATIONSHIP WITH JENSEN HUANG.
2:06 JENSEN HUANG IS NOT A TARGET OF PROBES BY U.S. LAW ENFORCEMENT.
2:12 JENS NORDVIG NOT A TARGET OF PROBES BUT--JENSEN HUANG IS NOT
2:20 A TARGET OF PROBES BY U.S. LAW ENFORCEMENT.
2:24 THEY ARE MISSING REPORTS THAT ALICE HUANG SMUGGLED SERVERS
2:31 INTO CHINA, DIFFERENT FROM THE INVESTIGATION OF ALICE HUANG
2:35 SMUGGLING CHIPS INTO CHINA. SCARLET: GIVE US THE VIEW FROM
2:38 SILICON VALLEY. WHAT IS THE CHATTER LIKE, WHAT
2:42 IS THE CONVERSATION LIKE AMONG FOLKS YOU TALK TO, TE H
2:48 COMMUNITY-- TECH COMMUNITY, CLIENTS, SUPPLIERS, ALL OF THAT?
2:57 ED: PEOPLE ARE THINKING OF WHO IS THE RIGHT TECHNOLOGIST TO
2:59 NVIDIA GOING FORWARD. WITH ALL DUE RESPECT -- THIS IS
3:04 ON AN INTERIM BASIS, SHE IS NOT SEEN AS THE RIGHT PERSON TO
3:08 MAINTAIN NVIDIA'S NEAR MONOPOLY IN THE MARKET FOR COMPUTE.
3:14 OTHER NAMES INCLUDE -- THE PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES
3:15 TOUTED TIM COOK. THERE IS A VERY BIG CAMP ACROSS
3:19 INVESTORS. CEOS OF AI LABS, ECOSYSTEM THAT
3:26 RELIES ON NVIDIA COMPUTE THE FEEL IT SHOULD HAVE BEEN PUT TO
3:32 A SHAREHOLDER VOTE -- HE RESIGNED.
3:35 WE KEEP SAYING HE WAS OUSTED, BUT HE RESIGNED.
3:38 MANY PEOPLE FELT HE SHOULD STAY IN THE POST IRRESPECTIVE OF
3:41 INFIDELITY. PEOPLE MAKE MISTAKES -- AND
3:48 PARAPHRASING--I AM PARAPHRASING PEOPLE'S VIEWS.
3:53 SCARLET: THANK YOU, ED LUDLOW. KEEP IT BLOOMBERG TELEVISION FOR
3:56 ALL-DAY COVERAGE OF THE STORY. NATHANIEL ROSENBAUM JOINED US ON
4:03 BLOOMBERG TO BREAK DOWN NVIDIA'S ROLE IN THE TECH BOOM.
4:07 >> WHEN I THINK ABOUT NVIDIA, IN THE HIGH-GRADE MARKET IT IS
4:08 REALLY SMALL. $35 BILLION IN DEBT, TINY THESE
4:13 DAYS. I DON'T THINK THIS HAS BROADER
4:18 RAMIFICATIONS. CREDIT SPREADS ARE TIGHTER ON
4:22 THE BACK OF ALL OF THIS NEWS. IN TERMS OF BEING A BACKSTOP FOR
4:27 OTHERS, AND IS CLEARLY AN IMPORTANT ROLE THAT NVIDIA HAS
4:28 PLAYED IN THE BROADER AI ECOSYSTEM.
4:33 THAT IS GOING TO BE QUESTIONED IN THE DAYS AHEAD.
4:36 SCARLET: LET'S DIG INTO ALL OF THIS WITH OUR CREDIT ROUNDTABLE.
4:40 MAUREEN O'CONNOR IS THE DIRECTOR OF HIGH-GRADE DEBTS, GET AT
4:45 WELLS FARGO AND SUZANNE, GIBBONS OF KICKER.
4:49 I KNOW YOU FOCUS ON HIGH-YIELD AND OPPORTUNISTIC CREDIT, BUT
4:52 I'M CURIOUS WHAT YOUR TAKE IS ON THIS NVIDIA DEVELOPMENT ON THE
4:55 PRODUCT CREDIT MARKET. THERE IS AN ARGUMENT IS A
5:01 BIG DEAL FOR EQUITIES THAN SAFER CREDIT.
5:05 >> I'VE OBSERVED A REAL CAPAND UNDERSTOOD-- GAP IN
5:09 UNDERSTANDING BETWEEN THE CREDIT AND EQUITY MARKETS IN TERMS OF
5:11 THE CREDIT MARKETS BEING CONCERNED ABOUT THE SPEED OF THE
5:15 BUILDOUT AND HOW MUCH OF IT HAS BEEN FINANCED AND CREDIT.
5:18 EQUITY INVESTORS HAVE BEEN MORE SANGUINE.
5:22 I THINK THAT IS BECAUSE THEY ARE LOOKING AT THE HYPERSCALER DEBT
5:26 ON THE BALANCE SHEET AND THEY ARE SEEING IT IS NOT TROUBLING
5:30 IN TERMS OF LEVERAGE LEVELS AND THE CREDIT IS WELL COVERED.
5:36 FOR CREDIT INVESTORS, THEY ARE LOOKING AT THE BROADER CREDIT
5:38 ECOSYSTEM. THAT'S HITTING THE MARKET TODAY,
5:46 FROM SUPPLY, DEMAND, TECHNICAL, DATA CENTER FINANCINGS, CHIP
5:51 FINANCINGS. QUESTION WITH THIS NEWS THAT
5:57 THERE IS A CHANGE IN STRATEGY FROM THE COMPANY, THAT COULD
6:05 RESULT IN MORE DIRECT DEBT BEING ISSUED IN THE I.T. MARKET, TO
6:08 THE EXTENT THAT THERE IS A CHANGE IN THE GUARANTEES THAT
6:11 THE COMPANIES HAVE BEEN ISSUING THAT IS ALLOWED -- THINK OF
6:16 NVIDIA WITH PRIVATE CREDIT -- THAT HAS ALLOWED FOR THE
6:19 OFF-BALANCE SHEET DEBT TO BE RAISED.
6:21 SCARLET: YOU COVER INVESTMENT GRADE.
6:24 WHAT DO YOU THINK OF THE FORECAST OF MORE EDUCATED BEING
6:26 ISSUED? MAUREEN: WE HAVE A BALANCED VIEW
6:31 AROUND SUPPLY FROM THE HYPERSCALERS.
6:35 WHEN YOU LOOK AT WHAT WAS FUNDED THIS YEAR, WE WENT THROUGH A BIT
6:37 OF A SUPPLY SHOCK. OVER $200 BILLION OF HYPERSCALER
6:46 SUPPLY, JUST THE BIG FIVE NAMES, SOME OF THE DATA CENTER DEALS
6:48 THAT OF COME TO MARKET, THE NVIDIAS AND SPACEX'S OF THE
6:54 WORLD. WE ARE REACHING A POINT OF
6:57 MAXIMUM MARKET CAPACITY IN THE IG SPACE.
6:58 WHEN YOU THINK OF THE PUSHBACK FROM INVESTORS WITHOUT THESE
7:01 BORROWERS TELEGRAPH THEIR CADENCE TO MARKET, WE RECOGNIZE
7:10 A BIT OF A PIVOT POINT, AND WE ARE OVER AND ABOVE THAT SIZE.
7:17 THE CADENCE TO MARKET BEING ANY MORE FREQUENT THAN TWICE A YEAR,
7:22 INVESTMENT GRADE MARKET. ONE OF THE MORE INTERESTING
7:26 EVOLUTIONS NEXT YEAR IS THE OFF-BALANCE-SHEET GPU
7:32 FINANCINGS, WHICH WILL TAKE ON A SLIGHTLY DIFFERENT COMPLEXION IN
7:33 TERMS OF DURATION OF SUPPLY, WHERE HYPERSCALERS ISSUE LONG,
7:37 15 YEARS ON AVERAGE. A LOT OF THIS FINANCING WILL BE
7:43 FOCUSED ON A THREE-Y WAITEDEAR-- THREE-YEAR WEIGHTED AVERAGE
7:47 INSTRUMENTS. SCARLET: IF YOU LOOK AT THE
7:50 CREDIT DEFAULT SWAPS OF SOME OF THE DEBT, NVIDIA'S DEFAULT RISK
7:56 INCREASED BECAUSE OF JENSEN HUANG AND THE UNCERTAINTY OF
7:58 WHAT IS GOING TO HAPPEN NEXT. THAT IS THE WHITE LINE AT THE
8:00 VERY TOP. THE HYPERSCALERS HAVE GONE DOWN,
8:05 SIGNALING LESS RISK. MAUREEN, WHY DO YOU THINK WE
8:10 HAVE THAT DIVERGENCE? MAUREEN: THE NVIDIA STORY
8:16 IS AN EQUITY STORY MORE THAN A CREDIT MARKET STORY.
8:19 THEY WILL ENJOY DEEP ACCESS TO THE INVESTMENT-GRADE BOND
8:20 MARKETS. YES, THERE WAS A KNEE-JERK WIDER
8:25 REACTION TO THE SPREADS, BUT THE VOLATILITY IS A LOT WIDER IN THE
8:29 IG CREDIT MARKETS. I WITH YOU NORMALIZATION ONCE WE
8:34 GET PAST THIS PERIOD OF UNCERTAINTY.
8:36 THE CDI IS TIED TO THE RISK ON BANKS' BALANCE SHEETS AND VIEW
8:42 OF WHERE PUBLIC INVESTORS ARE. VOLATILITY HAS BEEN A LOT LOWER.
8:47 SPEAKING OF SOME OF THESE OFF-BALANCE-SHEET STRUCTURES,
8:50 BANKS ON A LOT OF THIS. ON THE BALANCE SHEET THEY HAD A
8:54 LOT OF HIS AND THAT IS WHERE YOU ARE SEEING SOME OF THE
8:55 VOLATILITY. SCARLET: WE KNOW THAT NVIDIA WAS
9:00 APPLYING A LOT OF CAPITAL TO THE AI ECOSYSTEM.
9:04 HE IS CALLED THE CENTRAL BANKER OF AI FOR A REASON.
9:09 PUSHED A LOT BY JENSEN HUANG AND HIS OWN CONNECTIONS.
9:12 NOW THAT HE IS OUT OF THE PICTURE, HE IS NOT GOING TO PLAY
9:14 ANY ROLE AT THE COMPANY. DOES THIS REMOVE A LOT OF THE
9:18 FROTH THAT SOME PEOPLE SAY WE SEE IN THE CREDIT MARKET AND
9:25 USES THAT RISK?-- DEBVT RISK? SUZANNE: IT'S A GOOD QUESTION.
9:30 GOING BACK TO MY EARLIER POINT, THIS YEAR ALONE WE HAVE HAD AS
9:33 MUCH CREDIT ISSUANCE AI-RELATED AS HALF THE SIZE OF THE
9:35 HIGH-YIELD BOND MARKET THE U.S. STAGGERING NUMBERS.
9:39 A LOT OF IT IS AWAY FROM IG HYPERSCALERS.
9:43 A LOT OF IT DEPENDS ON LONG-TERM LEASES FROM THOSE COMPANIES AND
9:46 COMMITMENTS FROM CHIP COMPANIES AS WELL IN TERMS OF GUARANTEES.
9:50 THERE COULD BE A CHANGE IN STRATEGY.
9:53 REGARDLESS, THE ESTIMATES ARE THAT QUANTUM ISSUANCE IS ONLY
9:58 EXPECTED TO GROW EACH OF THE NEXT TWO YEARS.
10:02 I'VE SEEN ESTIMATES OF ABOUT A TRILLION ACROSS CREDIT MARKETS.
10:04 THESE ARE STAGGERING NUMBERS. THE CONVERTIBLE BOND MARKET
10:08 ALONE HAS HAD RECORD ISSUANCE THIS YEAR.
10:10 MORE THAN HALF OF IT IS RELATED TO AI.
10:14 THE REAL STORY IS THAT EVERY SEGMENT OF CREDIT IN SOME FORM
10:17 OR ANOTHER IS GETTING HIT WITH THIS ISSUANCE.
10:19 WHETHER IT IS GOING TO BE CONCENTRATED IN PARTS OF IG,
10:26 HIGH-YIELD, ASSET-BACK CREDIT, IT COULD BE A
10:30 COMBINATION OF ALL WHEREVER THERE IS APPETITE.
10:35 THE BROADER IMPLICATION IS WHAT DOES THIS MEAN FOR OTHER NAMES
10:38 OUTSIDE ECOSYSTEM. WHAT WE ARE SEEING THIS
10:42 COMPETITION FOR CAPITAL, COMPANIES BEING WILLING TO PAY
10:46 HIGHER SPREADS BECAUSE THEY NEED THE CAPITAL OF THE DAY.
10:49 CREDITORS ARE ABLE TO ASK FOR MORE SPREADS BECAUSE THE FLOOD
10:53 OF ISSUANCE IS GIVING THAT BUYING POWER.
10:56 SCARLET: THESE ARE QUESTIONS THAT IT WILL TAKE A COUPLE WEEKS
10:57 FOR PEOPLE TO FIGURE OUT AND ASSESS.
11:00 I WANT TO ASK ABOUT NEOCLOUD COREWEAVE.
11:03 IT WAS A BIG WEEK FOR THE COMPANY.
11:07 ITS POSITIVE EARNINGS REPORT TURN THINGS AROUND.
11:11 BONDS GETTING A BIT OF A REPRIEVE.
11:14 HOW MUCH OF COREWEAVE'S CREDIT WORTHINESS WAS A JENSEN HUANG
11:16 PUT? NVIDIA'S COMMITMENTS SURVIVED
11:22 HIS DEPARTURE, BUT IF COREWEAVE WOULD NEED ANOTHER RESCUE,
11:25 ANOTHER EQUITY INVESTMENT, ANOTHER CAPACITY COMMITMENT,
11:27 SHOULD BONDHOLDERS ASSUME THAT THE NEXT NVIDIA CEO, WHOEVER
11:32 THAT MAY BE, WILL WRITE A CHECK? SUZANNE: IT'S A GOOD QUESTION.
11:38 GIVEN WHERE THE UNSECURED BONDS ARE TRADING, THE VIEW THAT THE
11:41 PATH FORWARD IS MORE ON THE SECURED FINANCING SIDE.
11:44 THAT'S THE EXPECTATION. FROM OUR STANDPOINT WITH ALL OF
11:51 THIS, IT IS OK. BUT AS THE COLLATERAL VALUE--
11:56 WHAT IS THE COLLATERAL VALUE BACKING THAT?
11:59 WHAT IS THE CONCENTRATION RISK, FRANKLY?
12:01 THAT IS KEEPING A LOT OF PREDATORS UP AT NIGHT, THAT SO
12:06 MUCH OF THIS IS --A LOT OF CREDITORS UP AT NIGHT, THAT SO
12:09 MUCH OF THIS IS PREMISED EFFECTIVELY ON A COUPLE OF
12:11 COMPANIES. IN TERMS OF ECOSYSTEM, THE WILLS
12:17 HAVE INCREASED BY--WE ALL HAVE INCREASED BY A VERY CONCENTRATED
12:19 GROUP OF PLAYERS. THERE IS UNDERWRITING OF
12:21 COLLATERAL VALUE. THE BIG RISK IS TECHNOLOGICAL
12:24 DISRUPTION. THAT COULD IMPAIR COLLATERAL
12:26 VALUE OVER TIME. THESE ARE THE QUESTIONS WE ARE
12:31 DOING. SCARLET: COREWEAVE IS A
12:36 JUNK-RATED COMPANY, IS LOOKING TO RAISE MILLIONS IN INVESTMENT
12:41 GRADE FINANCING BY BACKING THAT WITH GPU'S.
12:45 DOES THE EXIT OF JENSEN HUANG MAKE INVESTORS MORE SKEPTICAL OF
12:46 THESE STRUCTURES? MAUREEN: AGAIN, A LOT OF THESE
12:51 ASSET LEVEL FINANCINGS ARE FULLY AMORTIZING STRUCTURES.
12:55 YOU'RE TALKING ABOUT FIVE-YEAR USEFUL LIFE INSTRUMENTS WITH A
12:59 HIGH-QUALITY BACKSTOP, INVESTMENT-GRADE BACKSTOP,
13:02 WHETHER THAT BE THROUGH RESIDUAL VALUE GUARANTEE STRUCTURE OR
13:05 OTHER CREDIT SUPPORT. THE CASH FLOWS FULLY ON--THE
13:13 CASH FLOW FULLY AMORTIZED THROUGH THE LIFE OF THE BONDS.
13:17 THE CASH FLOWS FULLY SATISFY THE DEBT SERVICE ON THE STRUCTURES.
13:21 I THINK A LOT OF PEOPLE ARE LOOKING AT THE STRUCTURES AS A
13:22 UNIQUE OPPORTUNITY TO BE INVESTED IN A SPACE THAT HAS
13:27 LONGER-TERM UNCERTAINTY IN A WAY THAT IS SHORT-DURATION IN
13:30 PROFILE. YOU'RE TALKING ABOUT SEVEN TO
13:37 EIGHT OR EVEN 8%-PLUS TYPE YIELDS.
13:41 IT IS A TIME IN OUR MARKET WE HAVE NEVER SEEN AND A UNIQUE
13:43 OPPORTUNITY FOR INVESTORS TO GET LEVERED TO THE SPACE ON A
13:46 SLIGHTLY LOWER RISK INSTRUMENT. SCARLET: ARE WE SEEING GLOBAL
13:51 ASSET MANAGEMENT -- ANDRE WAS ON "REAL YIELD" LAST WEEK WHEN THE
13:58 ELECTIONS. >> WE HAVE SEEN A MASSIVE HEDGE
14:01 FUND CAPITULATION WITHIN THE SPACE.
14:09 OVER A SPACE OF A FEW WEEKS, WE HAVE SEEN POSITIONS BEING
14:11 COLLAPSED, A LOT OF SELLING GOING TO THE MARKET.
14:14 SCARLET: HE SAID FROM A TECHNICAL PERSPECTIVE THE AI
14:16 SPACE FEELS CLEANER COMPARED TO WHERE WE WERE HEADING INTO THE
14:17 SUMMER. SUSIE, YOU ARE ON THE LOOKOUT
14:20 FOR OPPORTUNISTIC CREDIT. IS THERE MORE SELLING PRESSURE
14:23 TO COME? SUZANNE: I DEFINITELY THINK IT
14:28 IS A CLEANER ENVIRONMENT TODAY THAN IT HAD BEEN.
14:31 ABSOLUTELY, WE THINK A KNOCK ON EFFECT OF THE DEBT FINANCING IN
14:36 THE AI ECOSYSTEM IS THE COST OF CAPITAL IS HIGHER.
14:40 THAT IS GOING TO HAVE IMPLICATIONS FOR OTHER PARTS OF
14:43 CREDIT, IN PARTICULAR THE PRIVATE EQUITY ECOSYSTEM,
14:46 BECAUSE WE ALSO HAVE THIS BACKDROP OF HIGHER RATES, A LOT
14:49 OF CAPITAL STRUCTURES THAT WERE FORMED IN THE LOW-RATE PEIROD
14:54 AND NEED TO BE REFINANCED, AND THAT IS INCREASINGLY DIFFICULT,
14:56 NOT ONLY BECAUSE RATES ARE HIGHER, BUT SPREADS ARE MOVING
14:58 UP. JUST IN CCC ALONE THIS YEAR, WE
15:04 HAVE HAD 400 BASIS POINTS OF WIDENING, LARGELY DRIVEN BY
15:08 INTELLIGENCE TEST NAMES AND OF WIDENED MATERIALLY AND ARE
15:13 PULLING UP THE AVERAGE. WE HAVE NOT SEEN ANYTHING LIKE
15:16 THIS IN THE GMC, WHERE THE TAIL IS MOVING -- BOTTOM 20% IS
15:20 MOVING 80% OF THE MOVE IN SPREAD.
15:27 I DO THINK FOR AN OPPORTUNISTIC CREDIT MR., THINKING ABOUT
15:29 ISSUES AROUND COLLATERAL CONSTRUCTION, POLITICAL RISK,
15:35 BUT ALSO IN LEVERAGED CREDIT, FIGHTING THE NAMES THAT AR--
15:39 FINDING THE NAMES THAT ARE UNLIKELY TO HAVE HARD DEFAULTS
15:41 BECAUSE WHAT IS HAPPENING IN THE CCC MARKET IS WHEN THE COMPANY
15:46 STARTING TO VEER ON THE PATH TOWARDS GROUP LEGACY,
15:52 VOLATILITY--BANKRUPTCY, VOLATILITY ON THE SITE.
15:56 SCARLET: EVIDENCE THAT THE FIREHOSE OF DEBT THAT TECH NEEDS
15:58 ISSUE. WHAT ARE YOU TELLING ISSUERS IN
16:02 THIS VOLATILE ENVIRONMENT? MAUREEN: FLEXIBILITY IS
16:08 UNPRECEDENTED YEAR FOR HIGH-GRADE VOLUME.
16:12 TODAY, CROSS TO THE 2 TRILLION MARK THE FIRST TIME EVER, A
16:17 BANNER YEAR FOR A LOT OF DIFFERENT METRICS.
16:20 WE HAVE ACCOUNT BALANCE OF VOLATILITY, BUT WHEN YOU LOOK AT
16:24 SPREAD VOLATILITY FROM PEAK TO T ROUGH, 10-BASIS POINT RANGE, 12
16:31 OF THE MOST. THERE ARE HIGH-BETA NAMES AND
16:37 RETURNS ARE DRIVEN WITH BY THE UNDERWAY NAMES THAN OVERWEIGHTS.
16:41 THE REST OF THE MARKET HAS ALL WELL.
16:45 BE SO NEXT YEAR. SCARLET: THANK YOU SO MUCH.
16:50 MAUREEN O'CONNOR AND SUZANNE GIBBONS.
16:58 CHECK OUT THE "BLOOMBERG CREDIT EDGE PODCAST ON THE CRIMINAL".
17:00 -- TERMINAL. ELLEN WAXMAN WARNS OF
17:04 DISTORTIONS IN THE MARKET. THIS IS "BLOOMBERG REAL YIELD."
17:28 ♪ SCARLET: TODAY'S SHAKEUP AND
17:29 NVIDIA COMES AMID BROADER CONCERNS ABOUT FINANCING
17:32 CONTINUE TO GROW. ALAN WAXMAN SAID THERE ARE
17:38 DISTORTIONS IN AI THAT COULD THE TWO DISLOCATIONS IN THE MARKET.
17:44 >> DEMAND IS REAL, THE BUILD ISRAEL, THE TRANSFORMATION IS --
17:49 THE BILL IS REAL, THE TRANSFORMATION IS REAL.
17:52 WE HAVE THE LARGEST CAPEX BOOM EVER, AND NO ONE TRULY
17:57 UNDERSTANDS UNIT ECONOMICS BECAUSE THEY KEEP EVOLVING
17:58 THROUGH THIS IS. --THROUGH THE SYSTEM.
18:02 IT IS HARD TO THINK OF IT ON THE CREDIT SIDE.
18:05 ON THE EQUITY SIDE IS DIFFERENT. I THINK THERE ARE THREE THINGS
18:10 ON OUR MIND THAT WE ARE OBSERVING CONCERNS.
18:14 THE FIRST THING IS THERE HAS BEEN A MASSIVE EXPANSION OF
18:16 CREDIT QUICKLY. THE SECOND THING IS SPECULATIVE
18:22 FERVOR, FOMO. THE THIRD IS THAT WE ARE
18:27 STARTING TO OBSERVE DISTORTIONS IN THE MARKET.
18:30 WHY DO THOSE THREE THINGS MATTER?
18:34 IN OUR INVESTING CAREER, ANY TIME WE SEE THOSE THINGS BEING
18:37 TRUE, IT RESULT IN DISLOCATION. OF TRADE GOES DOWN.
18:40 MASSIVE EXPANSION OF CREDIT. DATA CENTER CREDIT, PRIMARILY
18:47 CONSTRUCTION FINANCING, AND THEN SHIVA FINANCING.-- CHIP
18:54 FINANCING FOR YOU HAVE BANKS LOOKING TO SELL THIS.
18:56 SOME OF THEM ARE CONCERNED THEY DID NOT UNDERSTAND THE DOCUMENTS
18:59 AS WELL AS THEY SHOULD HAVE. EARLY SIGNS.
19:02 THAT IS NUMBER ONE. NUMBER TWO, SPECULATIVE FERVOR.
19:10 I AM IN THE HEART OF ALL THIS. THE AMOUNT OF FOMO SPECULATION
19:15 OF ANY VENTURE. THE ECOSYSTEM IS FULL OF
19:20 SPECULATIVE BEHAVIORS. THAT DOESN'T MEAN THEY ARE NOT
19:23 GOING TO BE GOOD INVESTMENTS. THEY COULD BE FROM AN EQUITY
19:30 PERSPECTIVE. ON THE DISTORTIONS -- THIS IS
19:35 THE THIRD PIECE, WHAT WE HAVE BEEN OBSERVING IS A FEW THINGS
19:37 THAT CONCERN US. FIRST, WHICH EVERYONE KNOWS
19:41 ABOUT, IS POWER. THERE'S NOT ENOUGH POWER TO BE
19:45 PROCURED. THE POWER THAT IS GOING TO BE
19:50 FOR CURE IS MORE EXPENSIVE. IT IS TAKING LONGER.
19:54 THAT HAS RESULTING DISTORTIONS THAT REVERBERATE.
19:59 A COUPLE OTHER ONES. EVERYONE TALKS ABOUT INSURANCE
20:05 CAPITAL IS THE HOLY GRAIL OF THE FINANCES TO IMPUTE IT IS THE MAJOR
20:10 PROVIDER, PARTICULARLY ON THE CHIP FINANCING SIDE.
20:16 YOU LOOK AND SEE AA CREDIT, GOOGLE, MICROSOFT, GOOD RISK,
20:20 BUT THERE IS THIS THING WE LEARNED A LONG TIME AGO CALLED
20:24 SINGLE-NAME CONCENTRATION. LET'S SAY YOU HAVE X ABOUT OF
20:29 EXPOSURE TO MICROSOFT, RECREDIT, OR NVIDIA, GREAT CREDIT.
20:37 THESE COMPANIES, THEY ARVEST MANAGERS, BECAUSE THEY MAKE
20:41 SMALL MARK-- ARE RISK MANAGERS BECAUSE THEY MAKE SMALL MARGINS
20:44 ON WHAT THEY INVESTED. THERE IS JUST -- THERE IS NO
20:48 MAS. FULL WE HAVE HEARD FROM OUR
20:51 CLIENTS IS THAT THEY ARE EITHER FULL -- THEY ARE EITHER FULL,
20:58 ALMOST FULL, OR GOING TO BE FULL VERY SOON.
21:03 THAT CAPITAL IS THE CHEAPEST FORM OF CAPITAL OUT THERE.
21:11 IF THAT GETS FULL IT IS EIGHT TO 9%, VERSUS 6%, OF MATERIAL
21:16 DIFFERENCE IN THE DEBT STACK. THE LAST THING I WILL SAY -- I
21:20 DON'T THINK THIS GETS COVERED ENOUGH THIS IS ONE OF THE THINGS
21:21 YOU WERE LOOKING FOR IN DISTORTIONS IS WHEN INVENTORY
21:25 STARTS GOING UP IN THE SYSTEM. $200 BILLION OF CHIPS AND
21:31 WAREHOUSES BECAUSE THE DATA CENTERS AREN'T READY.
21:35 WHEN YOU HAVE THAT DYNAMIC, IF YOU HAVE AN ASSET THAT
21:38 DEPRECIATES OVER 20 YEARS, IT'S ALL GOOD.
21:46 HEDGES CREATES DISTORTIONS.--CAP JUST CREATES DISTORTIONS.
21:50 WHEN THOSE THINGS ARE TRUE, MEANS THAT WHEN YOU GO THROUGH
21:52 PATTERNS OF HISTORY, YOU'RE EDITOR DISLOCATION.
21:57 SCARLET: THAT WAS ALAN WAXMAN ON BLOOMBERG TELEVISION.
22:05 THIS IS "BLOOMBERG REAL YIELD." OUTSIDE OF NVIDIA NEWS, U.S.
22:09 YIELDS ON THE SHORT END I'VE BEEN MOVING A LOT.
22:12 THE MARKET REOPENING FROM THE U.S. HOLIDAY YESTERDAY AND
22:16 REACTING TO FED SPEAK THAT POINTS TO HIGHER RATES.
22:20 >> CPI DATA SUGGEST THAT INFLATION PRESSURES MAY PERSIST
22:23 FOR LONGER. >> IT REMAINS CLEAR GIVEN THE
22:27 CURRENT PUBLIC THAT THE FOMC NEEDS TO MOVEMENT TWO MORE
22:32 25-BASIS-POINT INCREASES. >> THE 50-POINT HIKE SHOULD BE
22:36 CONSIDERED AFTER THE DECEMBER MEETING.
22:41 HIKING ONLY 25 BASIS POINTS WOU LD PUT OUR CREDIBILITY AT RISK,
22:46 A RISK I'M NOT WILLING TO TAKE. SCARLET: READE PICKERT JOINS US
22:51 NOW, AND THIS IS ON THE HEELS OF A CPI REPORT THAT WAS HOTTER
22:54 THAN EXPECTED BUT DID NOT INCLUDE A YEAR-OVER-YEAR PRINT.
22:56 TELL US WHAT IT MEANS FOR HOW THE MARKET IS COUNTING ON FED
23:02 RATE HIKES IN THE COMING MONTHS. READE: ABSOLUTELY.
23:08 BEFORE THE CPI REPORT, WE SAW GOVERNOR CHRIS WALLER COME IN
23:10 ON, DRAWING A LINE IN THE SAND THAT THE FED NEEDS TO HIKE
23:11 RATES. IF WE SAW A CORE CPI PRINT OF
23:19 0.3% OR HIGHER, THEY MAY NEED TO CONSIDER A LARGER 50-BASIS-POINT
23:24 HIKE AT THE DECEMBER MEETING. WE SAW CORE CPI RISE MORE THAN
23:31 EXPECTED FOR OTHER STRAIGH-- A THIRD STRAIGHT MONTH.
23:38 IT IS THE FACT THAT YOU ARE SEEING THE ENERGY SHOCK SPILL
23:40 INTO OTHER PARTS OF THE ECONOMY, YOU'RE SEEING STRONG DEMAND KEEP
23:45 SERVICES INFLATIONS STICKY AND ELEVATED.
23:49 THOSE ARE THE TYPES OF THINGS THAT ARE WORRYING FED OFFICIALS.
23:56 DIRECTION. WE SAW THAT INVESTORS ARE
24:01 BETTING FOR MORE RATE HIKES IN THE MONTHS AHEAD.
24:08 CEMENTING THAT ONE FOR DECEMBER AND THE OTHER IN THE FIRST
24:08 QUARTER OF NEXT YEAR. WE SAW FED OFFICIALS REINFORCE
24:16 THIS MESSAGE OF YES, WE NEED TO HIKE, THOUGH IT IS A QUESTION OF
24:21 TO WHAT EXTENT AND HOW SOON AND OFTEN.
24:26 SCARLET: CPI DATA POINT WAS EARLIER THIS WEEK AND WE SEE
24:28 WHOLESALE INFLATION TOMORROW. HOW DOES THAT SET US UP FOR
24:32 WHOLESALE INFLATION? IS IT PRETTY MUCH EXPECTATIONS
24:37 HAVE BEEN SET? READE: PPI REPORT, PRICES PAID,
24:44 THAT SHOWS NOT ONLY WHAT PIPELINE INFLATIONARY PRESSURES
24:48 ARE, WHICH THIS REPORT IS PROJECTED TO SHOW QUITE A BIT OF
24:52 THEM, BUT IT HAS KEY COMPONENT THAT FEEDS INTO THE FED'S
24:56 INFLATION GAUGE. ECONOMISTS WILL BE LOOKING QUITE
25:02 QUICKLY TO CALCULATE WHAT PCE LOOKS LIKE, AND THAT WILL BE
25:07 THAT LAST INFLATION PRINT THAT SAID OFFICIALS WILL HAVE GOING
25:08 INTO THE DECEMBER MEETING. IT IS UNLIKELY TO CHANGE THE
25:14 PICTURE OF INFLATION BEING TOO HIGH AND OFFICIALS FEELING LIKE
25:17 THEY LIKELY NEED TO TAKE ACTION AND POTENTIALLY SOON.
25:22 ONE THING I DID WANT TO FLAG, THERE WAS A HEADLINE EARLIER
25:27 ABOUT THE 2027 FED CALENDAR. FED OFFICIALS ARE GOING TO HAVE
25:36 ONE LESS MEETING NEXT YEAR, AS CHAIRMAN KEVIN WARSH FLAGGED
25:38 RECENTLY, DROPPING THE OCTOBER MEETING.
25:42 THINKING ABOUT WHAT POLICY ACTIONS CAN LOOK LIKE GOING
25:44 FORWARD, THERE WILL BE A BIGGER GAP BETWEEN THE SEPTEMBER AND
25:49 DECEMBER MEETING, WHICH WILL BE DROOLING TO SEE IF WE ARE IN A
25:51 TIME LIKE NOW WHERE OFFICIALS SKIPPED A MEETING AND ARE
25:55 CONSIDERING ANOTHER RATE HIKE AND WHAT THAT MAY LOOK LIKE.
26:03 SCARLET: READE PICKERT JOINS US FROM WASHINGTON.
26:07 LET'S EXPLORE THIS WITH THE PORT FOR THE BENEFIT OF JP MORGAN.
26:10 CHRIS WALLER DREW A LINE IN THE SAND.
26:16 HE PUT 50 BASIS POINTS, THE RATE HIKE THERE, ON THE TABLE.
26:19 DO THINK HE WAS FLOATING A PROBLEM, OR IS THIS IT--FLOATING
26:25 A TRIAL BALLOON, OR IS THIS A GENUINE POSSIBILITY?
26:29 >> I WOULD PUT MORE WEIGHT ON THE CONSISTENT HAWKS IN THE
26:33 POINTS. HIS VIEW HAS OSCILLATED QUITE A
26:36 BIT. I REMEMBER ONLY A FEW MONTHS AGO
26:40 HE WAS TALKING ABOUT GIVING DISINFLATION A CHANCE.
26:46 SAID TODAY. THEY CONTINUE TO INDICATE THAT
26:50 RATE HIKES ARE APPROPRIATE BUT THEY PREFER TO DO IT IN
26:57 25-BASIS-POINT INCREMENTS FOR THE THE REASON WALLER
27:02 HIGHLIGHTED THE NEED FOR 50 IS HE HAS ABOUT FRED CREDIBILITY.
27:05 I DON'T SEE THE FED CREDIBILITY CONCERN BEING PRICED IN.
27:11 WHAT YOU SEE IS HOTTER INFLATION DATA LIKE WITH THE CPI EARLIER
27:15 THIS WEEK, THE FRONT END GREEK CRISIS, THE CURVE FLATTENS, AND
27:21 LONGER-DATED EXPECTATIONS FALL WHICH INDICATES WHAT THE FED IS
27:25 LOOKING FOR, TIGHTENING OF A CONDITIONS WHEN THINGS COME IN
27:27 UNDER IN ANTICIPATION THAT THE FED IS GOING TO SHIFT MORE
27:30 HAWKISHLY. I DON'T SEE THE CREDIBILITY RISK
27:34 HE IS TALKING ABOUT, BUT I CERTAINLY AGREE THAT WITH THIS
27:42 SUITE OF DATA WE HAVE GOTTEN, THE PAYABLES REPORT AND THE CPI
27:45 REPORT, AND WE WILL SEE WITH PPI TOMORROW, THE FED SHOULD BE
27:50 HIKING 25 BASIS POINTS IN DECEMBER.
27:52 SCARLET: AS THE MARKET GOT ENOUGH ON FED PRICING?
27:57 KELSEY: I THINK THEY GOT ENOUGH IN TERMS OF DECEMBER BECAUSE IT
28:01 IS PRICED FOR 25 BASIS POINTS. SCARLET: 2027, THEN.
28:05 KELSEY: THAT IS THE QUESTION. YOU HAVE TO STYLE WITH WHAT IS
28:08 THE MINIMUM AMOUNT THE MARKET IS GOING TO PRICE.
28:14 THAT IS 75 BASIS POINTS TOTAL OF HIKES, THE REMOVAL OF INSURANCE
28:19 CUTS IN 2025. BECAUSE OF THIS VIEW OF THE
28:26 ECONOMIC DATA-- SKEW OF THE ECONOMIC DATA HAS BEEN SO
28:27 LOPSIDED TOWARDS BETTER DATA, THE BALANCE OF RISKS IS TOWARDS
28:31 MORE THAN 75 BASIS POINTS, THAT THEY MAY NEED TO HIKE 100
28:38 BASIS POINTS. I WOULD PUT THAT IN THE CATEGORY
28:39 OF A CYCLE THAT IS MORE ABOUT ADJUSTMENT, MORE ABOUT HIKES TO
28:44 CONFIRM THAT INFLATION ISN'T GETTING AWAY FROM ITSELF.
28:49 WHAT I WOULD GO BACK TO IS WHAT CHAIRMAN WARSH SAID AT THE
28:54 LAST PRESS CONFERENCE ABOUT THE IDEA OF IS THE ECONOMY
28:55 OVERHEATING. IF THE MARKET IS GOING TO PRICE
29:02 IN A SIGNIFICANTLY HIGHER TERMINAL RATE, YOU HAVE TO SEE
29:05 SIGNS THAT THE ECONOMY IS GENUINELY OVERHEATING.
29:14 WHAT I THINK WE SEE RIGHT NOW IS POCKETS OF RELATIVE STRENGTH
29:18 PRICES, BUT NOT A BROAD-BASED BUT NOT A BROAD-BASED DESIGN
29:20 THAT THE ECONOMIES OVERHEATING. PRESSURES ARE CONCENTRATED IN A
29:25 FEW AREAS THAT WE ALREADY KNOW -- AIRFARES, WHICH ARE A
29:29 FUNCTION OF JET FUEL, THE TARIFFS, WHICH ARE IMPACTING
29:34 CORE GOODS PRICES, IN THE MORE RECENT ONE, WHICH IS UNNERVING
29:40 THE FED, THE ELECTRONIC GOODS. THAT IS A FUNCTION OF THIS AI
29:44 BOOM, THE SHORTAGE OF MEMORY PRICES THAT HAS CAUSED A SURGE
29:49 IN SEMICONDUCTOR PRICES. NONE OF THE THINGS I TALKED
29:52 ABOUT HAVE ANYTHING TO DO WITH THE LABOR MARKET OR WAGES.
29:58 IF THAT CHANGES AND WE SEE WAGES WE ACCELERATE, THAT WOULD CAUSE
30:02 THE MARKET TO REALLY REEVALUATE WHAT THE TERMINAL RATE IS.
30:08 IN THE ABSENCE OF THAT, WE ARE TRYING TO FIND A RANGE ON THE
30:12 10-YEAR. WE HAVE NOT FOUND IT, WHICH IS
30:16 WHY WE'RE OSCILLATING AROUND 5%. WE ARE TRYING TO FIND WHAT THE
30:19 RANGE IS. HIGHER FOR LONGER -- WE THINK
30:23 THAT IS GREAT FOR FIXED INCOME. WE SEE STRONG INFLOWS INTO OUR
30:29 PRODUCTS BECAUSE OF THE HEIGHT ALL-IN YIELD.
30:34 ASSUMING YOU ARE NOT GOING TO SEE A SIGNIFICANTLY HIGHER
30:37 TERMINAL RATE IN THIS HIKING CYCLE, THIS IS A GOOD TIME TO BE
30:43 LAGGING INTO SOME DURATION IN YOUR PORTFOLIO.
30:46 SCARLET: IT SEEMED AS IF U.S. TREASURIES' ROLE AS A HAVEN WAS
30:54 WEAKENING BECAUSE OF HEAVY GOVERNMENT BORROWING AND
30:55 UNCERTAINTY OVERALL. WITH TE CH STOCKS UNDER
31:01 PRESSURE, INVESTORS BEGAN TRADING TREASURIES AS A REFUGE.
31:06 WE SEE YIELDS SPIKING WHEN EVERYTHING THAT HAS BEEN
31:09 HAPPENING, PARTICULARLY WITH TRUMP'S COMMENTS ON IRAN.
31:14 AS WE SEE THE RESUMPTION OF TREASURIES AS A HAVEN, WHICH
31:16 BENEFITS MOST FROM THAT? KELSEY: PROBABLY THE BELLY OF
31:24 THE CURVE, 5 TO 10-POINT CURVE. WITH THE ECONOMIC DATA THE FED
31:29 WILL HAVE IN HAD, IT WILL FORCE THEM TO DELIVER THE
31:35 25-BASIS-POINT HIKE IN DECEMBER. IF WE SEE A RESUMPTION OF THE
31:39 SAFE HAVEN TRADE,, SEE THE FRONT AND STATEAY PINNED AND A CONTINUED
31:46 CURVE FLATTENING. THAT IS WHAT IS THE MOST LIKELY
31:51 EXPECTATION FOR HOW THE SHAPE OF THE CURVE IS GOING TO EVOLVE AS
31:54 WE MOVE THROUGH THE REST OF THE YEAR.
31:56 SCARLET: BEFORE THAT YOU GO, KELSEY, I KNOW THAT YOU ARE THE
32:01 FIXED-INCOME PORTFOLIO MANAGER. THE NEWS OUT OF NVIDIA, DOESN'T
32:06 CHANGE HOW YOU LOOK AT AI CREDIT, AI-ADJACENT CREDIT?
32:12 KELSEY: IN A SHORT WORD, NO. THIS HAS GENERALLY BEEN VIEWED
32:15 AS MORE OF AN EQUITY STORY THEN AFFIXED-INCOME CREDITS-- A
32:19 FIXED-INCOME CREDITS WAY. EVEN WITH THE TREPIDATION AROUND
32:26 HYPERSCALER EARNINGS, NOT ALL OF THEM WERE RECEIVED SO
32:28 POSITIVELY, SINCE THOSE EARNINGS HAVE COME OUT, WE HAVE SEEN $75
32:31 BILLION IN HYPERSCALER INVESTMENT-GRADE ISSUANCE, AND
32:35 IT HAS ALL GONE WELL. AS YIELDS HAVE BACKED UP, THE
32:39 SPREADS HAVE TIGHTENED AND PEOPLE ARE GETTING IN I
32:44 THINK YOU ARE SEEING MORE OF A SIDE OF RELIEF ON THE CREDIT
32:46 SIDE AS WE MOVE INTO THE END OF THE YEAR AND SUPPLY STARTS TO
32:47 SLOW. SCARLET: NO REAL SIGNS OF
32:49 INDIGESTION FOR THAT THAT. KELSEY, THANK YOU FOR JOINING
32:52 US. KELSEY BERRO OF JP MORGAN ASSET
32:55 MANAGEMENT. SINCE WE MENTIONED NVIDIA, LET'S
32:58 LOOK AT THE SHARES. THOSE PLUNGED 14% AT THE OPEN
33:05 AND ARE CONTINUING TO BE UNDER PRESSURE.
33:10 THIS IS AFTER JENSEN HUANG RESIGNED AS CEO FOLLOWING THE
33:14 REVELATION OF TWO AFFAIRS, ONE WITH AN ALLEGED CHINESE SPY.
33:18 JENSEN HUANG HAS HIRED THE LAW FIRM PAUL WEISS.
33:20 THIS IS "BLOOMBERG REAL YIELD."
33:35 TIME FOR OUR MUNI MOMENT. DURING LAST WEEK'S MIDTERM
33:38 ELECTIONS, VOTERS APPROVED MILLIONS OF DOLLARS IN BONDS
33:44 HELD. JOINING US IS MISSING REPORT FOR
33:47 THE MANAGER AT COLUMBIA FUNDING--JOINING US IS A MANAGER
33:53 AT COLUMBIA THREADNEEDLE. WE HAD A BLUE WAVE, BUT WE
33:57 SALAFI GRIDLOCK, DIVIDED GOVERNMENT--WE STILL HAVE
34:00 GRIDLOCK, A DIVIDED GOVERNMENT. WHAT DOES THIS MEAN FOR MUNIS AS
34:05 A DESTINATION? >> MID TO HIGH SINGLE DIGITS,
34:11 GREAT ENTRY POINT FOR INVESTORS. THE ELECTIONS IN THE END HAVE
34:18 BEEN A NOTHINGBURGER AT THE FEDERAL LEVEL.
34:22 GRIDLOCK IS GENERALLY GOOD FOR FIXED INCOME.
34:26 THE CERTAINTY THAT IS PROVIDED IS IT IS GOING TO BE VERY
34:29 DIFFICULT TO MAKE ANY MATERIAL CHANGES OF THE FEDERAL LEVEL.
34:33 WHAT IS GOING TO BE MORE IMPORTANT FOR THE ELECTORATE AND
34:38 STATE LEVEL. THIS WAS A MANDATE FOR CHANGE.
34:46 VOTERS AND CITIZENS ARE GOING TO BE PAYING ATTENTION TO WHAT
34:50 DEMOCRATIC PARTY PRIORITIZES OF THE STATE LEVEL, WHERE THEY TOOK
34:55 CONTROL OF GOVERNMENT IN THE STATE LEGISLATIVE BRANCH.
35:00 SCARLET: STATE BALLOT MEASURES PROPERTY TAX MEASURES PASSED IN
35:05 FLORIDA THAT LIMITS -- OR I SHOULD SAY EXPANDS THE EXEMPTION
35:12 SO YOU DON'T HAVE TO PAY AS MUCH IN TAXES, DEPENDING ON THE VALUE
35:15 OF YOUR PROPERTY. IT LOWERS PROPERTY TAXES FOR A
35:17 NUMBER OF PEOPLE. IS THAT A GOOD THING OR BAD
35:21 THING FOR FLORIDA CREDIT OVERALL?
35:24 SHANNON: SURE. IT SCREENS WELL POLITICALLY,
35:30 NOBODY WANTS TO PAY HIGHER TAXES.
35:33 THIS WILL HAVE SEVERE RAMIFICATIONS IN TERMS OF
35:35 SERVICES THAT THESE CITIES AND COUNTIES CAN PROVIDE THEIR
35:36 TAXPAYERS. WE ARE LOOKING AT IT ON A CREDIT
35:41 BY CREDIT BASIS. IN GENERAL IT IS CREDIT
35:46 NEGATIVE. THAT BEING SAID, WHETHER IT
35:48 IMPACTS CREDIT MATERIALLY HAS TO BE LOOKED AT IN THE BOND ISSUE.
35:53 SCARLET: GOT IT. WHAT ABOUT IN CALIFORNIA?
35:57 ANTICIPATION OF THE ONE TIME BILLIONAIRES TAX GOT PEOPLE
36:03 EXCITED AND BROUGHT OUT A LOT OF ACTION AND ACTIVITY FROM
36:06 BILLIONAIRES WHO DIDN'T WANT TO BE TAX THAT AMOUNT.
36:11 NOW THAT IT HAS BEEN REJECTED, WHAT IS THAT MEAN FOR
36:12 CALIFORNIA'S STATE FINANCES? SHANNON: THIS WOULD HAVE BEEN
36:17 JUST A ONE-TIME $2 BILLION WINDFALL FOR THE STATE, WHICH
36:20 WOULD HAVE BEEN GREAT FOR EDUCATION, HEALTH CARE COFFERS.
36:24 BUT IT WAS GOING TO BE TEMPORARY.
36:29 BECAUSE OF THAT, WE WERE MUCH MORE FOCUSED ON THE
36:32 LONGER-TERM IMPLICATIONS THAT ANY FLEEING BILLIONAIRES FROM
36:35 THE STATE MIGHT HAVE IN TERMS OF FUTURE REVENUE GROWTH.
36:39 WE DID NOT VIEW THE BILLION OF TAX--BILLIONAIRE TAX BALLOT
36:44 MEASURE IS A CREDIT POSITIVE. THE FACT THAT IT DID NOT PASS
36:48 HIS CREDIT NEUTRAL AT BEST. SCARLET: SHANNON, THANK YOU FOR
36:51 JOINING US. SHANNON RINEHART OF COLUMBIA
36:55 THREADNEEDLE FOR THE MUNI MOMENT.
36:58 MORE ON NVIDIA AS THE SHARES REMAIN LOWER.
37:02 DOWN ALMOST 5% FOLLOWING THE EXIT OF CEO JENSEN HUANG.
37:06 WE DISCUSSED ITS ROLE IN THE ANTHROPIC IPO.
37:11 THIS IS "BLOOMBERG REAL YIELD."
37:28 SCARLET: LET'S TURN BACK TO OUR TOP STORY OF THE DAY, JENSEN
37:32 HUANG STEPPING DOWN FROM NVIDIA, WITH THE COMPANY NAMING CFO
37:36 COLETTE KRESS AS INTERIM CEO. JENSEN HUANG DUE TO TESTIFY
37:42 BEFORE CONGRESS. JOINING US IS AND THAT HUGHES
37:45 MANDEEP SINGH. JENSEN'S DEPARTURE AND THE FACT
37:51 THAT HE WILL HAVE NO ROLE IN NVIDIA THAT ALL IS A BIG LOAD
37:54 GIVEN THAT HE WAS A DEALMAKER IN THE AI ECOSYSTEM, WHETHER IT WAS
37:59 NEOCLOUD INVESTMENTS FOR ACQUISITIONS LIKE HUGGING FACE.
38:03 TALK ABOUT WHAT CHANGES FOR THE AI INDUSTRY AS WE ANTICIPATE THE
38:07 IPO OF ANTHROPIC IN THE COMING DAYS.
38:14 MANDEEP: YEAH, LOOK, JENSEN WAS VERY AGGRESSIVE AT FINANCING AND
38:16 BACKSTOPS AND WHATNOT. FROM THAT PREERSPECTIVE, HARD TO
38:23 SEE ANYONE ELSE DOING THE SAME. THE SUPPLY-SIDE SHOULD BE--COULD
38:28 BE SHIFTED MORE TO BROADCOM AND AMD IF NVIDIA WAS TO PARE BACK.
38:35 BUT ON THE FINANCING SIDE, I DON'T SEE ANYONE ELSE PLAYING
38:39 SAME ROLE IS WHAT NVIDIA WAS DOING UNDER JENSEN.
38:43 FROM THAT PERSPECTIVE, I DO FEEL THERE WILL BE A SLOWDOWN IN
38:45 TERMS OF CAPEX. HOW IT SHOWS UP IS A DIFFERENT
38:52 QUESTION BECAUSE SOME OF THESE THINGS ARE ALREADY LOCKED IN.
38:56 MAYBE SECOND HALF OF 2027 IS WHEN WE START TO SEE THE EFFECT
39:00 OF THAT CAPEX SLOWDOWN. THERE IS NO DOUBT THAT
39:06 FINANCINGWISE, IT WILL ADD TO THE CRUNCH WE HAVE BEEN
39:07 WITNESSING THE PAST FEW WEEKS. SCARLET: NOTHING IN THE NEAR
39:12 TERM OR SECOND HALF OF 2027 MIGHT BE AFFECTED.
39:15 ANTHONY, YOU COVER COMPANIES READY TO GO PUBLIC.
39:18 ANTHROPIC IS HOLDING END-INVESTOR ROADSHOW MEETING
39:20 WITH INVESTORS AND TRYING TO FIGURE OUT THE RIGHT PRICE AT
39:24 WHICH IT LISTS AT. IT IS NOT DONE ANYTHING WITH
39:26 REGARD TO HIS TIMING. MARKET CONDITIONS HAVE BECOME
39:31 MORE VOLATILE TODAY. ANTHONY: ANTHROPIC E-SPORTS
39:37 AHEAD WITH IT--ANTHROPIC HAS FORGED AHEAD WITH ITS IPO.
39:43 THE FACT THAT WE ARE HAVING SOME THING TODAY AROUND NVIDIA IS
39:48 SOMETHING THAT HAD TO DO WITH MARKET VOLATILITY THROUGH THIS
39:50 WHOLE PROCESS AND THEY ARE FORGING AHEAD.
39:52 THE EARLY INDICATIONS ARE THAT THE DEAL IS MULTIPLE TIMES
39:55 OVERSUBSCRIBED. MAY BE MARGINAL BUYER MIGHT BE
40:00 DETERRED BY WHAT IS GOING ON HERE.
40:07 SCARLET: NVIDIA IS GOING TO PLAY A BIG WILL NOT IN THE IPO, BUT
40:14 THERE IS A PRIVATE PLACEMENT. IS THAT GOING TO GO AHEAD AS FAR
40:18 AS WE KNOW? ANTHONY: AS FAR AS WE KNOW.
40:24 THERE HAS BEEN NO COMMENT FROM AN MEDIA WHETHER THERE IS ANY
40:27 CHANGETHERE FULL----NO COMMENT FROM NVIDIA WHETHER THERE IS ANY
40:30 CHANGE THERE. THE BASE OFFERING OF $64 BILLION
40:34 IS THE MONEY RAISED FROM THE BROADER MARKET.
40:38 THERE IS NO INDICATION THAT THAT PLAN'S GOING TO CHANGE.
40:44 THERE IS ALSO SEVEN OTHER COMPANIES THAT ARE PRETTY KEY TO
40:49 THE SUPPLY CHAIN IN THAT PLACEMENT AS WELL.
40:50 IT'S NOT LIKE THEY ARE LEANING ON NVIDIA ENTIRELY.
40:56 INTERESTING TO SEE IF THERE'S ANY BLOWBACK BUT AT THE MOMENT
40:57 IT DOES NOT LOOK LIKE IT WILL AFFECT THE IPO.
41:03 IT MIGHT AFFECT MARGINAL BUYERS AND KEEP THEM AWAY.
41:06 SCARLET: IN TERMS OF SENTIMENT, IT MIGHT BE AN ISSUE.
41:09 MANDEEP, FROM WHERE YOU SAID -- YOU TALKED ABOUT HOW THE SECOND
41:13 HALF OF 2027 MIGHT BE WHERE WE SEE THINGS COME UNDER QUESTION
41:16 -- WHAT IS THE BIGGEST RISK WHEN IT COMES TO THE DEPARTURE OF
41:20 JENSEN HUANG AND FOR THE COMPANY AT LARGE?
41:24 MANDEEP: YEAH, LOOK, IF SOMETHING COMES OUT RELATED TO
41:26 NATIONAL SECURITY OR THE FACT THAT THEY CONCEALED SOMETHING IN
41:32 TERMS OF WHO THE BUYERS WERE WHEN IT COMES TO THEIR CHIPS,
41:38 HYPERSCALERS AND OF DOING IN THAT CIRCUMSTANCE.
41:44 THE HYPERSCALERS ARE ALMOST 50% OF NVIDIA'S DATA CENTER REVENUE.
41:49 THE POSITIONING WILL GET CHALLENGED.
41:54 I SOMETHING COMES OUTF ALONG THE LINES OF NATIONAL SECURITY, THAT
41:57 IS WHY THE EARNINGS COULD DRAMATICALLY CHANGE FOR NVIDIA
42:00 IF SOMETHING LIKE THAT WERE TO HAPPEN.
42:04 THAT IS A MUCH BIGGER RISK IN MY MIND.
42:07 SCARLET: MANDEEP, THE NUMBER ONE THING YOU WILL BE LISTENING FOR
42:08 IN THE EARNINGS CALL NEXT TUESDAY?
42:11 WE HAVE 30 SECONDS. MANDEEP?
42:17 UNFORTUNATELY WE HAVE LOST HIS AUDIO.
42:20 WHAT WILL YOU BE LISTENING FOR FROM NVIDIA'S EARNINGS CALL AS
42:23 IT RELATES TO ANTHROPIC AND ANYTHING ELSE?
42:28 ANTHONY: MENTIONING THAT THE NVIDIA" FOR THE ANTHROPIC IPO
42:31 PRICES. IT WILL BE INTERESTING TO SEE
42:36 WHETHER ANY NEGATIVITY, FASCINATED BY WHAT COMES OUT IN
42:37 THAT CALL. IT IS A NERVOUS TIME FOR THE IPO
42:42 BECAUSE OF ALL THESE EVENTS -- SCARLET: ANTHONY HUGHES OF
42:48 BLOOMBERG NEWS AND MANDEEP SINGH OF BLOOMBERG INTELLIGENCE.
Expect Federal Gridlock, Changes in States: Columbia Threadneedle's Rinehart full transcript
0:00 During last week's midterm elections, voters approved at least 60 fem... $7,000,000,000 of state and local
0:05 government bond sales. Here now to discuss what this means for Munis is Shannon Rinehart, co
0:10 head of municipal investments and senior portfolio manager at Columbia Threadneedle. So a lot happened in
0:15 those midterm elections starting with the fact that, we had a blue wave, but we still
0:20 have gridlock. We still have a divided government. What does this mean for Munis as a
0:25 whole as just an investment destination?
0:28 Sure. I think, you know, it's a great opportunity now. Obviously, the taxable equivalent yields in
0:33 the mid to high single digits. It's a great entry point for investors. And the elections
0:39 in the end have essentially been a nothing burger at the federal level. Gridlock is generally
0:45 good for fixed income. We like policy certainty, and the certainty that that's provided is that
0:52 it's gonna be very difficult to make any, material changes at the federal level. So what's
0:58 gonna be more important for the electorate and for municipal investors is to monitor what happens
1:04 at the state level. Obviously, this was a mandate for change, and voters and citizens are
1:12 gonna be paying attention to what the Democratic party prioritizes at the state level where they
1:17 have taken over control of govern... Governor and, you know, the state legislative branch.
1:24 Right. There's also some state ballot measures, property tax measures passed in Florida, for instance, that
1:30 limits, or I I should say expands the homestead exemption, so that you don't have to
1:36 pay as much in taxes depending on the value of your property. Basically, it lowers property
1:40 taxes for a number of people. Is that a good thing or a bad thing for,
1:45 Florida credit overall, Florida Muni overall?
1:49 Sure. So it obviously screens well politically. Nobody wants to play higher taxes, But the reality
1:55 is this will have some pretty severe ramifications in terms of the services that these, cities
2:01 and counties can provide their taxpayers. So we are looking at it at a credit credit
2:08 by credit basis. I would say, in general, it's definitely a credit negative. That being said,
2:13 whether or not it impacts the credit materially has to be looked at the bond issue.
2:18 Got it. Got it. What about in California where the, you know, anticipation of the one
2:23 time billionaires tax tax certainly got people excited and brought out a lot of action and
2:30 activity from billionaires who didn't want to be taxed that amount. Now that it has been
2:34 rejected, that one time billionaires tax, what does that mean for California state finances?
2:39 Certainly. So this would have been just a one time $2,000,000,000, windfall for the state, which
2:46 would have been great for, you know, education, health care coffers, but it was gonna be
2:50 temporary. And because of that, we were much more focused on the longer term implications that
2:58 any fleeing billionaires from the state might have in terms of future revenue growth. So we
3:04 we did not view the billionaire tax ballot measure as a credit positive. So the fact
3:10 that it did not pass, think, is, you know, credit neutral Mhmm. At best.
Trump Backs Lutnick Amid Chip Uproar full transcript
0:07 >> LIVE FROM WASHINGTON, D.C., THIS IS "BALANCE OF POWER" WITH
0:10 JOE MATHIEU AND KAILEY LEINZ. JOE: NOTHING BUT QUESTIONS.
0:16 WELCOME TO THE THURSDAY EDITION, AS WASHINGTON AND WALL STREET
0:20 REACTED NEWS THAT JENSEN HUANG IS OUT AT NVIDIA AFTER THE TWO
0:23 AFFAIRS, INCLUDING ONE WITH AN ALLEGED CHINESE SPY.
0:27 I'M JOE MATHIEU ALONGSIDE KAILEY LEINZ IN WASHINGTON.
0:29 WE COULD START GETTING ANSWERS TO OUR MANY QUESTIONS AS SOON AS
0:32 NEXT WEEK. KAILEY: NVIDIA IS DUE TO REPORT
0:36 EARNINGS THAT HAVE EARNINGS CALL ON TUESDAY.
0:39 THE EXECUTIVE SHEPHERDING THAT, ONE WOULD ASSUME, IS COLETTE
0:44 KRESS, NAMED CEO ON THE BASIS. SHE HAS BEEN CHIEF FINANCIAL
0:48 OFFICER FOR SEVERAL DECADES AT THIS POINT.
0:52 HAS A SEE THE EVOLUTION OF THIS COMPANY INTO THE AI-DOMINATING
0:54 COMPANY IT IS. THE QUESTION, ONE OF THEM, IS
0:59 WHAT BECOMES OF NVIDIA AND ITS AI DOMINANCE AS THE SEARCH FOR A
1:03 FULL-TIME REPLACEMENT FOR HIM CONTINUES.
1:05 THE OTHER FROM HERE IN WASHINGTON THAT I WOULD NOT SAY
1:08 OTHER SINGULARLY. THERE ARE MANY QUESTIONS
1:10 WASHINGTON ONCE ANSWERED. THE INVESTIGATION HAS ONLY
1:12 BEGUN. JOE: THERE WILL BE ONE WE KNOW
1:19 ABOUT, A BEHIND CLOSED DOORS CONVERSATION WITH JENSEN HUANG
1:21 AND LEADERS OF KEY COMMITTEES, INTELLIGENCE, FOREIGN AFFAIRS,
1:27 WHICH GIVES US A SENSE OF THE DIRECTION IS MAYBE TAKING.
1:31 THERE ARE MULTIPLE LETTERS ASKING THE COMMERCE SECRETARY TO
1:33 PRESERVE RECORDS AND BETTER DEFINE AS PART OF A PROBE INTO
1:38 WHAT TOOK PLACE. KAILEY: THE WHITE HOUSE SAYING
1:43 THAT THE PRESIDENT STANDS BY COMMERCE SECRETARY HOWARD
1:46 LUTNICK. THAT COULD CONTINUE TO EVOLVE AS
1:48 WE COULD SEE LEGISLATION AND AN EFFORT TO ACTUAL LAW PASSED BY
1:56 CONGRESS AROUND CHIPS SENT TO CHINA, ONE OF MANY THREADS WE
2:00 HAVE TO PULL ON IS OUR. WE HAVE SPECIAL ADVISOR FOR
2:05 ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE IN THE BIDEN WHITE HOUSE.
2:10 JOE: OUT WITH A NEW BOOK, "THE BITTER STRUGGLE."
2:14 YOU WILL BE WITH US IN STUDIO. --HE WILL BE WITH US IN STUDIO.
2:19 LOOKING FORWARD TO TALKING WITH EMILY CHANG AS WELL.
2:21 IF YOU HAVE SPENT MORE TIME WITH JENSEN HUANG HIMSELF ALSO I AM
2:25 NOT SURE SHE HAS EVER BEEN ON "BALANCE OF POWER," BUT SHE WILL
2:29 JOIN US FROM SAN FRANCISCO WITH UNIQUE INSIGHTS.
2:35 KAILEY: BEFORE WE TALK TO EMILY, WE HAVE TO TURN TO OUR OTHER
2:36 RENOWNED COLLEAGUE CHARLIE PELLETT.
2:41 CHARLIE: THANK YOU VERY MUCH, JOE AND KAILEY.
2:45 DOW, S&P, NASDAQ: NSYNC. THE BIG STORY--ALL ADVANCING.
2:51 THE BIG STORY, NVIDIA, JENSEN HUANG OUT.
2:58 NVIDIA'S MARKET CAP BELOW $4 TRILLION.
2:59 THERE WAS A DEVELOPMENT 20 MINUTES AGO.
3:04 FORMER CEO JENSEN HUANG HIRING LAW FIRM PAUL WEISS.
3:09 THAT ACCORDING TO "THE NEW YORK TIMES," CITING SOURCES.
3:16 IF NVIDIA SHARES DOWN--WE HAVE NVIDIA SHARES DOWN 5.1%.
3:23 S&P 500 INDEX HOLDING ONTO AGAIN.
3:28 NASDAQ 100 FLAT ON THE DAY. NASDAQ COMPOSITE DOWN UNDER .1%.
3:35 S&P HIGHER BY .1%. DOW INDUSTRIALS UP .3%.
3:44 SOX IS DOWN BY .3%. 10-YEAR AT 5.10%.
3:52 GOLD DOWN 2.8%. GO SEEING A --WE ARE SEEING A
3:58 SURGE FOR CRUDE. BARREL OF BRENT, 95.07.
4:07 A MOVE AND DID QUITE, DOWN THREE POINT-- MOVE IN BITCOIN, DOWN
4:13 3.1 PRESENT. TOP STORY CUTTING ACROSS
4:20 MULTIPLE ANGLES, NVIDIA CEO JENSEN HUANG OUSTED AFTER
4:21 REPORTS OF TWO AFFAIRS INCLUDING WITH ONE WOMAN SUSPECTED OF
4:24 SPYING FOR CHINA. THAT IS A BLOOMBERG BUSINESS
4:26 FLASH. KAILEY: THANK YOU SO MUCH.
4:31 WE WILL TURN TO CHARLIE AS HE KEEPS TRACK OF THE MARKET ACTION
4:37 TODAY AND THE DECLINE IN NVIDIA SHARES.
4:40 IT IS OFF THE LOWS OF THE SESSION.
4:43 INVESTORS IN THAT COMPANY WONDER WHAT COMES NEXT, LOOKING AT A
4:47 FUTURE WITHOUT JENSEN HUANG AT THE HELM OF THE COMPANY HE
4:48 COFOUNDED. THERE WAS ALSO QUESTIONS ABOUT
4:54 WHAT THE FUTURE OF ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE WRIT LARGE LOOKS
4:57 LIKE WITHOUT JENSEN HUANG IS ONE OF ITS LEADING GLOBAL VOICES.
5:01 WE SAW JENSEN HUANG STANDING NEXT TO PRESIDENT TRUMP ANOTHER
5:06 TITANS OF TECHNOLOGY AND ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE AT THE
5:08 WHITE HOUSE. HE WAS A VOICE IN THE YEAR OF
5:11 THE PRESIDENT ON WHAT REGULATION OF -- EAR OF THE PRESIDENT ON
5:15 WHAT REGULATION OF AI SHOULD LOOK LIKE.
5:18 JENSEN HUANG HAS MADE MANY TRIPS TO ASIA.HE TRAVELED WITH
5:23 PRESIDENT TRUMP ON HIS RECENT TRIP TO CHINA.
5:27 HE WAS IN EUROPE MEETING WITH FRENCH PRESIDENT EMMANUEL MACRON
5:30 ANNOUNCING INVESTMENTS INTO EUROPEAN AI COMPANIES.
5:35 A MONTH LATER, IT IS A VERY DIFFERENT STORY AS TO HOW MUCH
5:38 INFLUENCE GLOBALLY JENSEN HUANG WILL BE ABLE TO WIELD.
5:41 JOE: THAT'S FOR SURE. THE FACE OF THE INDUSTRY.
5:47 THEY CALL HIM THE MAESTRO, D AA VINCI, FOR A REASON.
5:53 EMILY CHANG WAS ON THAT TRIP TO EUROPE.
5:57 SHE HAS AN IMPORTANT EPISODE OF THIS EVENING, AND :00 P.M. ON
6:00 ORIGINALS, 10:00 P.M. ON BLOOMBERG TV.
6:05 SHE HAS HAD A CHANCE TO SEE NOT ONLY AN INTERVIEW SETTINGS, BUT
6:08 IN CANDIDATE INTERACTIONS WITH OTHER-- CANDID INTERACTIONS WITH
6:14 OTHER LEADERS AND SUPPORTERS OF HIS.
6:16 HE MOVED LIKE A CELEBRITY, A ROCK STAR OF TECHNOLOGY.
6:21 EMILY JOINS US FROM THE SAN FRANCISCO BUREAU.
6:22 IT IS A TREAT TO HAVE YOU WITH US.
6:25 THERE ARE SO MANY QUESTIONS WE ALL HAVE, AS I'M SURE YOU HAVE.
6:28 IF YOU COULD START BY SPEAKING TO THE CHARISMA, THE HALO EFFECT
6:33 OF THIS INDIVIDUAL WHEN HE CAME TO THE MOST IMPORTANT INDUSTRY
6:36 IN THE WORLD, THE IDEA OF NOT HAVING HIM AS AN EVANGELIST FOR
6:41 AI MEANS WHAT? EMILY: JOE, THEY CALL IT
6:48 JENSANITY, BUT THAT TERM TAKES ON A WHOLE DIFFERENT MEANING
6:50 NOW. WE FOLLOWED HIM TO FOUR
6:54 COUNTRIES IN FOUR DAYS, THAT EVERYBODY WAS HOLDING COURT WITH
6:58 DEVELOPERS--EVERYWHERE HE WAS HOLDING COURT WITH DEVELOPERS,
7:02 TECH CEOS, EVEN WITH THE PRESS. WE GOT A SENSE OF HOW DEEPLY HIS
7:08 RELATIONSHIPS GO WITH THE PEOPLE MAKING DECISIONS AT ALL OF THESE
7:09 COUNTRIES. HE HAS FOR THE LAST SEVERAL
7:12 YEARS BEEN THE MAN AT THE CENTER OF THE AI BOOM.
7:17 OBVIOUSLY NVIDIA HAS GREAT TECHNOLOGY WITHOUT HIM.
7:23 THE QUESTION IS CAN NVIDIA FIVE IN THE SAME WAY.
7:25 IT WAS INCREDIBLE TO SEE HIM IN THESE CANDID MOMENTS.
7:28 HE WOULD COME OUTSIDE AND TALK TO THE PRESS FOR OVER 40
7:32 MINUTES, JUST TAKING QUESTIONS HERE AND THERE.
7:37 HE HAD IS ALMOST OPRAH-LIKE MOMENTS WHERE SHE WOULD BE
7:40 ANNOUNCING NEW INVESTMENTS IN AI STATEMENTS -- I'M INVESTING IN
7:42 YOU, I'M INVESTING IN YOU. THAT GOES TO THE VERY IMPORTANT
7:47 ISSUE THAT NVIDIA IS INVESTED IN SO MANY COMPANIES UP AND DOWN
7:49 THE AI STACKING ACROSS THE ECOSYSTEM THAT YOU HAVE TO THINK
7:55 ABOUT WHETHER ITS DOMINANCE IN THE INDUSTRY'S DEPENDENCE ON AN
7:59 NVIDIA AT THIS POINT IS A RISK. KAILEY: WELL, YEAH, THIS IS A
8:05 CRUCIAL BLOCK IN THE JANGO TOWER -- JENGA TOWER.
8:10 YOU ASKED HIM ABOUT THE NOTION THAT THERE IS NO SUCCESSION PLAN
8:13 IN PLACE. THE BOARD HAD TO ACT QUICKLY TO
8:19 PUT A CEO IN ON A GENERAL BASIS. WHAT WILL NVIDIA BE LOOKING FOR
8:24 WHEN JENSEN HUANG'S ARE TEH SHOE THAT NEED FILLING?
8:28 EMILY: WELL, COLETTE KRESS IS IN THAT ROLE NOW, IN OUR
8:32 UNDERSTANDING IS THAT THERE ARE A LOT OF SUCCESSFUL EXECUTIVES
8:35 OUT THERE, NAMES THAT HAVE BEEN FLOATED.
8:37 THESE ARE PEOPLE RUNNING REALLY IMPORTANT COMPANIES ALREADY.
8:42 FINDING SOMEONE WHO'S WILLING TO AND CAN GO INTO THE SITUATION
8:47 WHERE THE STRUCTURE OF THE COMPANY ISS UNIQUE -- JENSEN HAD
8:57 60 DIRECT REPORTS, IT IS A VERY FLAT ORGANIZATION.
9:00 WE DIDN'T REALIZE THIS WOULD BE THE LAST BIG INTERVIEW WITH HIM
9:04 AS CEO. WE KNEW THAT SUCCESSION WAS AN
9:05 ISSUE. THERE WAS NO OBVIOUS SUCCESSOR
9:09 AND HASN'T BEEN EVER, ESSENTIALLY.
9:13 JOE: REALLY REMARKABLE, ALTHOUGH THOSE LISTENING TO THE
9:17 CONFERENCE CALL WILL HEAR A FAMILIAR VOICE IN COLETTE KRESS
9:19 NEXT WEEK. DO WE HAVE ANY IDEA WHERE HE IS
9:25 OR WHAT HE IS DOING, WHAT HIS SECURITY SITUATION IS?
9:29 EMILY: I JUST SAW THE "NEW YORK TIMES" REPORTING THAT HE HAS
9:34 HIRED A PROMINENT LAW FIRM. FIRST ON THE DOCKET IS DEALING
9:36 WITH THESE INVESTIGATIONS. HE IS GOING TO HAVE TO SPEAK
9:39 WITH CONGRESS LAST WEEK NEXT WEEK.
9:44 I HAVE TO MENTION HIS FAMILY. HIS DAUGHTER MADISON HUANG WAS
9:48 WITH HIM ON EVERY DAY OF THE TRIP.
9:52 SHE WORKED WITH THE COMPANY AND THERE WAS SPECULATION SHE WAS
9:54 INVITED TO BE A SUCCESSFUL. HIS SON--WAS IN LINE TO BE A
9:59 SUCCESSOR. HIS FAMILIES INTERTWINED WITH
10:03 THE ORGANIZATION AND MY GUESS IS THAT HE IS DEALING WITH HIS
10:05 FAMILY OBLIGATIONS RIGHT NOW BECAUSE, GIVEN EVERYTHING THAT
10:11 WE SEE, HE HAS PROBABLY HEARD A LOT OF PEOPLE.-- HURT A LOT OF
10:14 PEOPLE. KAILEY: YEAH.
10:19 WE ARE LOOKING FORWARD TO. SEEING THEEPISODE INVOLVED YOU
10:20 CAN CATCH IT ---SEEING THE EPISODE IN FULL.
10:28 YOU CONTACTED TONIGHT ON ORIGINALS -- YOU CAN CATCH IT
10:31 TONIGHT ON ORIGINALS. IT IS A DEEPLY PERSONAL STORY
10:37 BUT IT CANNOT STAY PERSONAL WHEN IT RELATES TO ONE OF THE TOP
10:38 ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE COMPANIES IN THE WORLD.
10:46 WE TURN TO BEN BUCHANAN, FORMER WHITE HOUSE SPECIAL ADVISOR FOR
10:49 ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE IN THE INVITED ADMINISTRATION AUTHOR OF
10:51 THE NEW BOOK "THE BITTER STRUGGLE."
10:54 HE IS WITH US IN OUR WASHINGTON, D.C., STUDIO.
10:59 IT'S AN INCREDIBLE TIME FOR THIS BOOK TO COME OUT.
11:01 YOU PROBE IDEAS LIKE EXPORT CONTROLS.
11:10 THE CRUX OF ONE OF THE ISSUES AS TO HOW MUCH EXPORT CONTROL
11:12 POLICY WAS INFLUENCED BY JENSEN HUANG AND NOW MUCH JENSEN HUANG
11:16 WAS INFLUENCED BY THIS WOMAN ALLEGED TO BE AN AGENT FROM
11:19 CHINA. IS THERE DOUBT IN YOUR MIND THAT
11:21 THERE WAS SOME DEGREE OF NATIONAL SECURITY COMPROMISE?
11:27 >> THESE TIPS ARE INCREDIBLY IMPORTANT FOR NATIONAL SECURITY.
11:32 WHY JENSEN BELIEVED WHAT HE BELIEVED, I DON'T KNOW.
11:37 HE WAS A STRIDENT ADVOCATE FOR SELLING SHIPS TO CHINA BEFORE
11:40 THIS HAPPENED. CHINA WANTS ACCESS TO HIS CHIPS
11:46 AND AMERICAN CHIPMAKERS, AND FROM A NATIONAL SECURITY
11:49 PERSPECTIVE, WE SHOULD NOT GIVEN TO THEM.
11:53 JOE: BEN, IT'S GREAT TO MEET YOU, AND CONGRATULATIONS ON THE
11:54 BOOK. YOU DESCRIBE THE POLICY AS A
11:56 DRAWBRIDGE. HIS ATTEMPT TO DROP IT?--IS IT
12:01 TIME TO DROP IT? BEN: NO, IT IS ESSENTIAL,
12:06 ESPECIALLY GIVEN HOW IMPORTANT AI'S BECOMING.
12:11 JOE: JENSEN HUANG WAS AN EVANGELIST FOR THE OPEN SOURCE
12:12 AI. DOES THAT LEAVE WITH HIM NOW?
12:20 ARE THE FRONTIER MODELS GOING TO HAVE THE KEYS IN THE FUTURE AND
12:22 THAT THEY HAVE CLOSED MODELS? BEN: I DOUBT IT LEAVES WITH HIM.
12:27 NVIDIA HAS INCENTIVES. WE DIDN'T DO ANYTHING TO
12:35 RESTRICT OPEN-WEIGHT MODELS. WE DIDN'T WANT TO INVENTING THE
12:36 FRONTIER OF THIS TECHNOLOGY. IT IS FUNDAMENTALLY AN AMERICAN
12:40 TECHNOLOGY AND WE CAN REGULATE THE COMPANIES IS APPROPRIATE.
12:44 KAILEY: WE HAVE LAWMAKERS TOLD JOE AND I, SAYING IT PUBLICLY,
12:49 THAT THEY SEE THIS AS UNDERSCORING THE NEED FOR
12:54 TIGHTENING EXPORT CONTROLS. WITH THE QUESTIONS ABOUT
13:00 MEGASPEED AND ALICE HUANG'S ASSOCIATION WITH SUPER MICRO,
13:03 THERE ARE QUESTIONS ABOUT WHETHER THE PRODUCTS WERE ABLE
13:07 TO GET CHINA ANYWAY. WALK US THROUGH THE DIFFICULT
13:08 FLEET I'M NOT ONLY SETTING THE CONTROLS, BUT MAKING SURE THEY
13:11 ARE ENFORCED. BEN: IT STARTS WITH THE
13:17 ADMINISTRATION. THE TRUMP ADMINISTRATION DECIDED
13:21 NOT TO ENFORCE THE DIFFUSION RULE, TO GUARD AGAINST
13:25 TRANSSHIPMENT AND REMOTE ACCESS TO DATA CENTERS OVERSEAS.
13:29 THIS IS WHERE CHINA BEGAN WORKING AROUND THE EXPORT
13:32 CONTROLS PUT ON PLACE ON CHINESE COMPANIES IN 2022 AND 23.
13:38 THE TRUMP ADMINISTRATION ENABLED THIS ACTIVITY TO CONTINUE AND
13:39 THERE IS BIPARTISAN CONCERN IN CONGRESS ABOUT THE TECHNOLOGY
13:44 GOING TO CHINA AND IT SEEMS LIKE BIPARTISAN REACTION TO SAY WE
13:45 HAVE GOT TO DO MORE THAN WE ARE DOING NOW.
13:51 JOE: WE SPOKE TO ANNA ASHTON ABOUT THE IDEA OF EXPORT
13:55 CONTROLS PREVENTING ACTIVITIES LIKE THIS.
13:59 IF THIS WAS AN ESPIONAGE OPERATION, IT CAN BE DIFFICULT
14:02 TO CONTROL WHAT TOOK PLACE HERE. ARE THERE OTHER WAYS TO APPROACH
14:04 THIS? COULD WE PUT TRACKING DEVICES ON
14:09 BLACKWELLS? SHOULDN'T WE KNOW WHERE THESE
14:11 CHIPS ARE? BEN: WE SHOULD, AND THERE IS
14:16 LEGISLATION IN CONGRESS TO DO THAT.
14:18 I AM IN FAVOR OF KEEPING TRACK OF CHIPS, FOR SURE, BUT THE
14:22 FIRST THING IS GETTING THE POLICY RIGHT.
14:24 THE TRUMP ADMINISTRATION REVERSED KEY MOVES THAT HAD
14:30 BIPARTISAN SUPPORT AND WAS MAKING IT ILLEGAL PRESENTED
14:31 CHIPS TO THIS COUNTRY THROUGH CHINA.
14:34 KAILEY: WHEN YOU REFER TO THE TRUMP ADMINISTRATION, ARE WE
14:36 TALKING ABOUT THE COMMERCE DEPARTMENT.
14:40 WHAT WOULD YOU BE ASKING HOWARD LUTNICK?
14:43 BEN: WHAT DID YOU KNOW, WHEN DID YOU KNOW IT?
14:46 IT IS IMPORTANT TO KNOW WHAT THE COMMERCE DEPARTMENT KNEW ABOUT
14:50 MEGASPEED AND WHY CHOSE IN GENERAL NOT TO ENFORCE THE
14:57 DIFFUSION ROLE, AND WHAT IS IT DOING NOW TO PLUG
15:01 THESE LEAKS? JOE: WE KNOW THE COMPANY HAD
15:05 BEEN FLAGGED BY OUR INTELLIGENCE.
15:09 REPORTEDLY NO ONE TOLD JENSEN HUANG FROM THIS ADMINISTRATION
15:12 -- YOU WILL FIND OUT IF THAT'S TRUE.
15:14 HOW DOES HOWARD LUTNICK KEEP HIS JOB?
15:20 BEN: THE "NEW YORK TIMES" REPORTING WHERE REFERENCING IS
15:22 VERY CONCERNING AND IT NEEDS TO BE TAKEN MUCH MORE SERIOUSLY BY
15:24 THE ADMINISTRATION AND THE COMPASS DEPARTMENT, WHICH HAS A
15:28 STATUTORY---COMMERCE DEPARTMENT, WHICH HAS STATUTORY AUTHORITY
15:31 UNIQUE AMONG THE AGENCIES. KAILEY: YOU SUGGESTED THIS
15:35 ADMINISTRATION -- AT LEAST YOU SAID IS RECENTLY -- THAT'SGETS A C-
15:42 ON EXPORT CONTROL POLICY. DOES THIS REVEAL IT IS WORSE
15:49 THAN PREVIOUSLY THOUGHT THAT WE HAVE THIS INFORMATION ABOUT
15:51 WHETHER COMMERCE HAD ACCESS INFORMATION AND CHOSE NOT TO
15:54 ACT? IS THIS WORSE?
15:58 BEN: YEAH, I THINK SO. GRADING IN THE MODERN CONTEXT,
16:06 INFLATION, BUT WE ARE IN D TERRITORY.
16:09 THIS IS AN INCIDENT WHERE THE ENFORCEMENT IS NOT GOOD.
16:12 THE DECISION-MAKING HAS NOT BEEN GOOD.
16:15 JOE: YOU CONSIDER THE GAP IN KNOWLEDGE, IT REGALLY SAID THAT
16:20 CHINA IS SI--FREQUENTLY SAID THAT CHINA IS BEHIND US.
16:23 WOULD EXPORT CONTROLS INCREASE THE GAP?
16:28 KAILEY: THERE IS GOVERNMENT DEFINITELY--
16:32 BEN: THERE HAS NEVER BEEN A CHINESE AI SYSTEM TRAIN ON
16:35 CHINESE CHIPS. JOE: SO THERE WOULD BE NO
16:39 DEEPSEEK IF IT WEREN'T -- BEN: THE COMPANY WOULD EXIST BUT
16:43 IT WOULD NOT BE AS GOOD. THIS IS AN OPPORTUNITY TO BUILD
16:47 A VERY BIG LEAD FOR THE UNITED STATES, INVENTING THIS ROLE
16:50 CHANGING TECHNOLOGY. KAILEY: YOU CAN BUILD BECAUSE
16:54 CHIPS ARE HARD TO MAKE. THERE ARE VARIOUS TO DEVELOP
16:58 THIS ADVANCED TECHNOLOGY TO DO SO AT SCALE THE WAY NVIDIA HAS.
17:03 WITH THAT IN MIND, HOW HARD WOULD IT BE FOR ANY OTHER
17:07 CHIPMAKER, CHINESE ARE NOT, TO FILL THE SHOES OF NVIDIA IF THIS
17:11 DOES LEAD TO SOMEWHAT OF A MATERIAL CHANGE IN THE COMPANY'S
17:14 DOMINANCE? BEN: CHIPMAKING MAKING IS
17:19 INCREDIBLY DIFFICULT. ON THE CHIP MANUFACTURING SITE,
17:23 WHICH IS THE CRUX OF WHAT WE ARE TALKING ABOUT, THE CHINESE ARE
17:25 FAR BEHIND. HOWARD LUTNICK TESTIFIED IN 2025
17:33 THE CHINA WILL MAKE 200,000 CHIPS.
17:36 NOT NEARLY ENOUGH FOR A SINGLE DATA CENTER.
17:40 SOME OF THE MODELING I'VE SEEN SUGGEST THAT THE UNITED STATES
17:45 AND ITS ALLIES HAVE A 100 TO 1 ADVANTAGE IN CHIP MANUFACTURING
17:48 OVER CHINA. WITH A LANDSCAPE THAT IS
17:52 COMPETITIVE IN AI, THIS IS BY FAR, CHIP MAKING, DOMINANT THING
17:57 THAT DEMOCRACIES HAVE GOING FOR THEM.
17:59 JOE: WEAVER THAT IF YOU WANT TO WIN THE AI--WE HAVE HEARD THAT
18:06 IF YOU WANT TO WIN THE AI RACE, THE WORLD MUST BE ON THE NVIDIA
18:08 STACK. THE WORLD IS ON THE HUAWEI
18:12 STACK, IS THAT WRONG? BEN: THAT'S WRONG BECAUSE
18:15 WALLY'S NOT MAKING THAT MANY CHIPS -- HUAWEI IS NOT MAKING
18:19 THE MANY CHIPS. DO EXPORT CONTROLS PROMPT CHINA
18:28 TO INDIGENIZE FURTHER? NO, IT BEGAN ITS EFFORT TO
18:35 INDIGENIZE IN 2050. IT'S BEEN 200 --IT'S BEEN
18:40 HUNDRED BILLION DOLLARS TO CATCH UP.
18:44 JOE: IT'S CALLED "THE BITTER STRUGGLE" -- IS THIS THE
18:47 STRUGGLE? GREAT TO HAVE YOU WITH US ON
18:49 BLOOMBERG AND CONGRATS ON THE RELEASE.
18:52 I'M JOE MATHIEU IN WASHINGTON. WE WILL ASSEMBLE OUR POLITICAL
18:54 PANEL. JENSEN HUANG IS OUT.
18:57 THIS IS BLOOMBERG TV AND RADIO. ♪
19:03 CHARLIE: IT'S 1:21 ON WALL STREET.
19:06 WE CHECK MARKETS ALL DAY LONG ON BLOOMBERG.
19:09 NVIDIA SHARES DOWN 4.6%. JENSEN HUANG OUT, COLETTE KRESS
19:13 IS IN. JENSEN HUANG OUSTED THIS MORNING
19:21 AFTER REPORTS OF TWO AFFAIRS, INCLUDING WITH ONE WOMAN
19:23 SUSPECTED OF BEING A SPY FOR CHINA.
19:27 CFO COLETTE KRESS HAS BEEN NAMED INTERIM CEO, AND THE BOARD
19:30 APPOINTED HARVEY JONES AS ITS CHAIR.
19:34 NVIDIA STOCK IS DOWN 4.6%, WORSE LEVEL OF THE MORNING.
19:37 IN THE EARLY GOING, NVIDIA WAS DOWN MORE THAN 14%.
19:43 S&P ADVANCING SIX POINTS, LITTLE CHANGED, UP UNDER .1%.
19:50 DOW INDUSTRIALS, GAIN OF .2%. NASDAQ 100 INDEX ALSO FLAT ON
19:53 THE DAY. UNDER .1%.
20:02 10-YEAR YIELDING 5.10%. SPOT GOLD DOWN BY .7%.
20:14 BIG MOVE FOR BITCOIN, DOWN 3.%5%. CRUDE IS GAINING 2%.
20:21 88.26 A BARREL. BRENT UP 2.7%.
20:27 OIL MAJORS ARE ALL ADVANCING. SPIDER ETF XLE UP 2%.
20:36 EXXON MOBIL UP 2.1%. CONOCOPHILLIPS UP 1.9%.
20:45 ALL THREE XLE'S THREE BIGGEST HOLDINGS.
20:48 NVIDIA SHARES TRADING DOWN. COVERAGE WILL CONTINUE ON
20:50 "BALANCE OF POWER." NVIDIA DOWN 4.7%.
20:57 KAILEY AND JOE, THAT IS YOUR BLOOMBERG BUSINESS FLASH.
21:00 KAILEY: ALL RIGHT, CHARLIE PELLETT, THANK YOU SO MUCH.
21:04 THE MARKET HAS QUESTIONS AS TO WHAT THE RESIGNATION OF JENSEN
21:07 HUANG WILL MEET FOR THE COMPANY AND THE WIDER AI TRADE.
21:13 WASHINGTON HAS QUESTIONS AND MAYBE THE WHITE HOUSE AS, TOO.
21:18 I KNOW WE HAVE QUESTIONS FOR THE WHITE HOUSE AS TO WHAT HAPPENS
21:21 NEXT, SPECIFICALLY COMMERCE SECRETARY HOWARD LUTNICK WILL
21:23 FACE ANY REPERCUSSION FOR WHAT HAS GONE DOWN IN REGARD TO
21:26 NVIDIA AND EXPORT CONTROLS AND INFORMATION COMING TO LIGHT.
21:30 WHITE HOUSE SAYS IT IS STANDING BY HOWARD LUTNICK.
21:35 PRESIDENT TRUMP HAS WEIGHED IN ON THIS IN ANOTHER WAY, TAKING
21:39 TO TRUTH SOCIAL NOT ONLY TO SAY THAT JENSEN HUANG DID A
21:41 FANTASTIC JOB, BUT TO SAY THAT NOW THAT HE HAS RESIGNED, THERE
21:45 WAS ONE MENTOR TAKE HIS PLACE. ACCORDING TO PRESIDENT TRUMP,
21:51 THAT IS TIM COOK OF APPLE. HE SAYS A LEGEND REPLACES A
21:55 LEGEND. JOE: WE'LL SEE ABOUT THAT.
21:59 DO YOU THINK HE CALLED HIM, OR IS HE JUST RIFFING?
22:04 APPLE IS A CONSUMER PRODUCT COMPANY DOES NOT HAVE A LOT IN
22:08 COMMON WITH NVIDIA. CULTURALLY NOT THE SAME EITHER.
22:14 KAILEY: WE KNOW THE PRESIDENT LIKES TO MAKE ENDORSEMENTS.
22:17 ENDORSEMENT OF A DIFFERENT KIND. JOE: THERE IS A LOT OF TALK
22:20 ABOUT HOWARD LUTNICK ANYTIME JENSEN HUANG'S NAME COMES UP.
22:25 SECRETARY. " THE WASHINGTON POST" FRONTING
22:31 QUESTIONS ABOUT HIS TENURE. REUTERS REPORTING THAT OFFICIALS
22:36 ARE WONDERING IF LUTNICK SHOULD BE PUSHED OUT IN THE WAKE OF
22:42 THESE SPY SCANDAL. TYLER KENDALL JOINS US LIVE FROM
22:43 THE WHITE HOUSE. ARE YOU HEARING ANYTHING
22:47 DIFFERENTLY THAN WHAT KAILEY JUST MENTIONED, THE PRESIDENT
22:50 STANDING BY HIS MEN? TYLER: AT THIS POINT THAT IS
22:53 THE LATEST PUBLICLY FROM THE WHITE HOUSE.
22:57 A U.S. OFFICIAL CONFIRMED TO US THAT PRESIDENT TRUMP IS STANDING
22:59 BY COMMERCE SECRETARY HOWARD LUTNICK, SAYING HE IS CONFIDENT
23:04 IN HIS ABILITY TO CARRY OUT THE POSITION, KEEPING IN MIND THE
23:08 POLITICAL ANGLE HERE, WHICH IS WITH SUCH LIMITED DAYS LEFT,
23:13 WITH REPUBLICANS CONTROLLING THE UPPER CHAMBER IN THE SENATE,
23:17 THAT HAS ADDED FUEL TO THE FIRE OF THE CONVERSATION ABOUT
23:19 WHETHER OR NOT TRUMP SHOULD BE CONSIDERING THE REALITY, THAT IT
23:23 COULD BE DIFFICULT TO HAVE ANOTHER CABINET SECRETARY
23:26 CONFIRMED AFTER REPUBLICANS LOSE THE MAJORITY.
23:28 IT COMES AMID HEIGHTENED SCRUTINY ABOUT COMMERCE
23:33 SECRETARY HOWARD LUTNICK'S ROLE IN WHAT HAS BEEN A LACK OF
23:37 EXPORT CURBS ON COMPANIES SUSPECTED OF SMUGGLING CHIPS
23:39 INTO CHINA. THE COMMERCE DEPARTMENT HAS PUT
23:44 ON SOME EXPORT CONTROLS -- ONE OF THE COMPANIES AT THE CENTER
23:49 OF THE CONTROVERSY LINKED TO THE SUSPECTED CHINESE SPY HAVE YET
23:51 TO SEE THOSE CONTROLS PUT INTO PLACE.
23:57 THAT IS WHAT HAS PROMPTED SOME DEMOCRATS ON CAPITOL HILL TO SAY
23:58 THAT THEY ARE DEMANDING FURTHER ANSWERS ABOUT EXACTLY WHAT THE
24:01 ADMINISTRATION KNEW AND WHEN. THAT INCLUDED NEW THIS MORNING,
24:08 HEARING FROM TWO PROMINENT SENATE DEMOCRATS, SENATOR
24:13 ELIZABETH WARREN, POISED TO LEAD THE SENATE BANKING COMMITTEE, AS
24:18 WELL AS CHRIS COONS, POISED TO LEAD FOREIGN AFFAIRS, ASKING THE
24:21 ADMINISTRATION TO PRESERVE DOCUMENTS INVOLVING
24:25 COMMUNICATIONS BETWEEN NVIDIA AND JENSEN HUANG AND WHAT IS
24:30 SEEN AS THE PRECURSOR STEP TO A PRODUCT CONGRESSIONAL
24:34 INVESTIGATION.--BROADER CONGRESSIONAL INVESTIGATION.
24:36 KAILEY: TYLER, THANK YOU SO MUCH.
24:39 POLLY MENTIONS WHAT CONGRESS MIGHT BE LOOKING TO DO THIS.
24:42 ONE OF OUR COLLEAGUES CAUGHT UP TO THE SOON TO BE MINORITY
24:47 LEADER JOHN THUNE, WHO SAYS HE EXPECTS CONGRESS WILL HAVE SOME
24:52 COMPROMISE BY HIS RELATIONSHIP WITH JENSEN HUANG, AND HE SAID
24:55 HE WOULD BE WRONG TO MAKE ASSUMPTIONS ABOUT THAT, BUT THEY
24:58 NEED TO KNOW A LITTLE BIT MORE AND THERE WILL BE AN OVERSIGHT
25:01 PROCESS THAT WILL GET BETTER INSIGHT INTO THAT, POINTING TO
25:05 THE FACT THAT REPUBLICANS WANT MORE ANSWERS, TOO.
25:10 THIS IS NOT SICKLY ARE TAKING THE MAJORITY, ALTHOUGH
25:14 DEMOCRATS-HAVE BEEN VOTE--NOT SIMPLY DEMOCRATS WHO ARE TAKING
25:16 THE MAJORITY, ALTHOUGH DEMOCRATS HAVE BEEN VOCAL.
25:18 HERE IS HAKEEM JEFFRIES EARLIER. >> WE NEED TO CLASSIFY GRIEVING
25:24 MADE AVAILABLE TO MEMBERS OF CONGRESS AS IT RELATES TO THE
25:27 NVIDIA SITUATION AND TO THE EXTENT THAT OUR NATIONAL
25:31 ANSWERS. AND WE ARE GOING TO WORK TO MAKE
25:34 SURE THAT HAPPENS. KAILEY: AND OF COURSE WE KNOW
25:39 FROM THE CHAIR OF THE HOUSE FOREIGN AFFAIRS COMMITTEE, BRIAN
25:43 MAST, THAT JENSEN HUANG WILL BE APPEARING FOR TESTIMONY BEFORE
25:45 THE FOREIGN AFFAIRS, INTELLIGENCE, AND CHINA SELECT
25:50 COMMITTEES BEFORE THE THANKSGIVING RECESS.
25:52 LET'S GET INTO THIS WITH OUR POLITICAL PANEL.
25:56 RICK DAVIS, REPUBLICAN STRATEGIST AND STONECOURT
25:59 CAPITAL PARTNER, ALONGSIDE A DEMOCRATIC STRATEGIST AND FORMER
26:01 COMMERCE DEPARTMENT SENIOR ADVISOR DURING THE BIDEN
26:03 ADMINISTRATION. RICK, I WILL COME TO YOU FIRST
26:07 AS TO WHAT YOU THINK WE MIGHT SEE NOT JUST FROM THE NEW
26:10 CONGRESS IN JANUARY WHEN DEMOCRATS WILL HAVE CONTROL,
26:14 SUBPOENA POWER, AND WILL BE USING IT TO INVESTIGATE THIS
26:17 NVIDIA SITUATION FURTHER. WHAT COULD STILL HAPPEN IN THIS
26:22 LAME DUCK, ESPECIALLY WITH THE NATIONAL DEFENSE AUTHORIZATION
26:24 IN THE BALANCE? RICK: I THINK IT IS PRETTY CLEAR
26:29 THAT UNDER THE NDAA, THERE WILL LIKELY BE OPPORTUNITIES TO END
26:32 THE LAME-DUCK SESSION RIGHT AWAY, TO ADD ADDITIONAL
26:37 COUNTERMEASURES TO THE EXPORT RESTRICTIONS.
26:42 IN OTHER WORDS, TIGHTEN THEM UP. THERE ARE A NUMBER OF BILLS
26:44 ALREADY UNDER CONSIDERATION THAT HAVE NOT MADE ITS WAY INTO THE
26:48 NDAA THAT I WOULD FIND A LOT OF BIPARTISAN SUPPORT FOR IN THE
26:50 MOMENT WE ARE IN. I DEFINITELY SEE A MUCH MORE
26:56 BULKED UP NDAA WHEN IT COMES TO EXPORT RESTRICTIONS ON NVIDIA
27:06 --BUT ALSO ON A RANGE OF TECHNOLOGIES THAT ENABLE OTHER
27:09 COUNTRIES TO FACILITATE AI DEVELOPMENT AND SO I THINK
27:14 CONGRESS WILL TAKE A MUCH WIDER POLICY SPREAD ON THIS THAN JUST
27:17 REACTION TO THE NVIDIA SITUATION.
27:23 JOE: YOU SPENT TIME WORKING WITH GINA IN THE BIDEN COMMERCE
27:25 DEPARTMENT WHICH IS PARTLY WHY WE CALLED YOU TODAY TO GET A
27:28 BETTER UNDERSTANDING OF SORT OF THE CONTRAST BETWEEN THESE TWO
27:30 ADMINISTRATIONS APPROACH AND SOMETHING THAT BEN BUCHANAN
27:35 HELPS TO ILLUMINATE A LITTLE EARLIER THIS HOUR.
27:38 PROBABLY A FORMER COLLEAGUE OF YOURS WHO IS OUT WITH A NEW
27:39 BOOK. THE BITTER STRUGGLE.
27:44 IF THE EXPORT CONTROLS THE BIDEN ADMINISTRATION WAS CRITICIZED
27:46 OVER BY MANY ON WALL STREET HAD BEEN IN PLACE, COULD THIS SPY
27:50 SCANDAL STILL HAVE HAPPENED? >> WE STILL HAVE A LOT TO LEARN
27:56 ABOUT WHAT HAPPENED HERE. I DO THINK THIS IS NOT AS MUCH A
28:00 QUESTION ABOUT WHETHER WE HAD THE RIGHT EXPORT CONTROLS IN
28:03 PLACE BUT WHETHER THEY WERE ENFORCED OR NOT.
28:08 SO YOU KNOW, I THINK WE SAW AN HISTORIC AMOUNT OF INSTITUTIONAL
28:16 KNOWLEDGE LEAVES VIS, THE AGENCY THAT OVERSEES EXPORT CONTROLS
28:18 WHEN THE TRUMP ADMINISTRATION CAME BACK INTO POWER.
28:23 I HAVE A LOT OF QUESTIONS ABOUT WHETHER THEY REPLACED THE STAFF,
28:27 WHO THEY REPLACED THEM WITH, WHETHER THEY HAVE THE FUNDING
28:30 THEY NEEDED TO DO THEIR JOBS BECAUSE YOU KNOW, FRANKLY, IT
28:33 WAS THE FIRST TRUMP ADMINISTRATION THAT REALLY USED
28:37 EXPORT CONTROLS AS A TOOL FOR US TO MAINTAIN OUR TECHNOLOGICAL
28:42 LEAD AGAINST CHINA. THE BIDEN ADMINISTRATION
28:46 EXPANDED ON THAT AND SO IT IS A LITTLE SURPRISING THAT THIS HAS
28:50 HAPPENED IN THE SECOND TRUMP ADMINISTRATION GIVEN THE TRACK
28:52 RECORD IN THE FIRST ADMINISTRATION AND I THINK WE
28:54 JUST HAVE A LOT MORE WE NEED TO LEARN.
28:59 KAILEY: WHEN IT COMES TO EXPORT RESTRICTIONS ON WHAT CAN GO TO
29:01 CHINA SPECIFICALLY, THE PRESIDENT IS PLANNING TO GO TO
29:03 CHINA NEXT WEEK. HE'S GOING TO HAVE A SIT DOWN
29:06 WITH XI JINPING AND HE WAS SAYING HE DOESN'T NECESSARY PLAN
29:10 -- NECESSARILY PLAN TO RAISE THIS JENSEN HUANG ISSUE BUT HOW
29:13 WOULD YOU EXPECT THIS CHANGES THE NATURE OF THEIR MEETING?
29:17 IF THE U.S. WERE TO SAY AND CONGRESS WERE TO ENACT TOUGHER
29:20 EXPORT CONTROLS ON CHINA, WOULD YOU EXPECT THERE TO BE
29:23 RETALIATION FOR THAT FROM BEIJING?
29:27 JOE: I CERTAINLY WOULD EXPECT RETALIATION.
29:28 WE HAVE SEEN BEIJING RETALIATE FOR SIMILAR MEASURES IN THE
29:34 PAST, WITHHOLDING RARE EARTH MINERALS, CRITICAL MINERALS FROM
29:38 THE SUPPLY CHAIN SO YES, THEY HAVE USED THESE KIND OF MEASURES
29:43 TO TRY TO COUNTERACT AMERICAN TARIFFS ON AMERICAN EFFORTS TO
29:50 WITHHOLD TECHNOLOGY. I WOULD SAY MORE SPECIFICALLY,
29:56 IS NOT UNUSUAL TO HAVE THESE KIND OF COUNTERINTELLIGENCE
29:58 THINGS GOING ON IN THE BACKGROUND OF THESE SUMMITS, OF
30:00 THESE MEETINGS BETWEEN WORLD LEADERS.
30:04 I THINK IT'S ALMOST UNDERSTOOD THAT THE WORLD IS FULL OF THIS
30:07 KIND OF ACTIVITY AND JUST IN THIS INSTANCE, IT HAS BUSTED
30:12 OPEN INTO THE WORLD VIEW. I DON'T THINK IT MAKES IT A
30:17 POLICY ISSUE THAT WOULD RISE THE -- TO THE LEVEL AT LEAST IN THIS
30:20 ADMINISTRATION OF WANTING TO RAISE TO CHINA BECAUSE WHAT ARE
30:23 THEY GOING TO SAY? YOU ARE PERFORMING COUNTERINTELLIGENCE
30:27 ON THE MOST CRITICAL ASPECTS OF TECHNOLOGY IN THE WORLD.
30:29 WE ARE PROBABLY DOING EXACTLY THE SAME THING TO THEM AND WE
30:31 WOULD HATE TO HAVE THAT EXPOSED. JOE: AS THE PRESIDENT LIKES TO
30:37 SAY HIMSELF SOMETIMES. DOES THIS WHOLE STORY,
30:39 REGARDLESS OF HOW IT GOES, STRENGTHEN THE HAND OF DEMOCRATS
30:43 WHO WANT TO BRING FORTH EXPORT CONTROLS AND LEGISLATIVE REFORM?
30:46 THIS IS THE LEGISLATIVE ANSWER TO WHAT THE WHITE HOUSE HAS BEEN
30:47 DEALING WITH. >> ABSOLUTELY.
30:52 I THINK THIS, YOU KNOW, REGARDLESS OF WHAT YOU THINK
30:56 ABOUT DEMOCRATS OR REPUBLICANS, THIS IS ALMOST A GIFT FOR
30:59 DEMOCRATS WHO ARE COMING INTO POWER IN THE SENSE THAT THEY
31:06 HAVE AN OPPORTUNITY NOW TO SHOW REAL LEADERSHIP, REAL OVERSIGHT,
31:09 TO WORK TOGETHER WITH REPUBLICANS AND SHOW THAT AS
31:13 THEY ARE HOLDING THE TRUMP ADMINISTRATION ACCOUNTABLE, IT
31:15 IS NOT JUST PARTISAN THEATRICS BUT THAT THERE ARE VERY SERIOUS
31:20 NATIONAL SECURITY ISSUES AT PLAY THAT THEY ARE FOCUSED ON AND SO
31:26 I DO THINK THIS STRENGTHENS THEIR HANDS GENERALLY AND IT
31:28 CERTAINLY STRENGTHENS THE HANDS OF PEOPLE WHO WANT TO SEE MORE
31:29 EXPORT CONTROLS. KAILEY: TO THE POINT YOU WERE
31:35 MAKING EARLIER, WE JUST HAVE 30 SECONDS LEFT.
31:37 WHILE ALL OF THIS COME TO EXECUTIVE ENFORCEMENT?
31:45 >> YES, BUT THAT IS WHY WE HAVE TWO COEQUAL BRANCHES OF
31:46 GOVERNMENT. IF THEY DON'T LIKE WHAT IS GOING
31:50 ON, THEY CAN WITHHOLD FUNDING UNTIL THE EXECUTIVE BRANCH
31:52 STARTS TO INTERACT APPROPRIATELY.
31:56 JOE: A GREAT PANEL WITH SOME IMPORTANT THINGS TO DISCUSS.
31:59 MANY THANKS TO RICK DAVIS, BLOOMBERG POLITICS CONTRIBUTOR.
32:04 WE ARE GOING TO HAVE A CONVERSATION COMING UP WITH A
32:06 LAWMAKER IN WASHINGTON ON THIS FIRST WEEK BACK.
32:11 THE CONGRESSWOMAN FROM OREGON, DEMOCRAT, WILL WEIGH IN ON
32:13 EXACTLY WHAT DEMOCRATS ANSWER WILL BE ON CAPITOL HILL.
32:20 KAILEY: NOT JUST A QUESTION OF DEMOCRATS.
32:20 A LOT OF REPUBLICANS INCLUDING JOHN THUNE ARE SUGGESTING THERE
32:25 ARE STILL ANSWERS THEY WOULD LIKE CONGRESS TO RECEIVE.
32:27 WE WILL CONTINUE THIS COVERAGE ON BALANCE OF POWER ON BLOOMBERG
32:29 TV AND RADIO. ♪
32:35 CHARLIE: IT'S 1:40 ON WALL STREET.
32:37 WE CHECKED MARKETS ALL DAY LONG HERE AT BLOOMBERG.
32:40 STOCKS ARE ADVANCING. NVIDIA DOES REMAIN LOWER BY 4.5%
32:44 , AT THE WORST LEVEL OF THE MORNING.
32:46 NVIDIA WAS DOWN MORE THAN 14%. NASDAQ AND THE NASDAQ 100 INDEX,
32:52 BOTH HIGHER RIGHT NOW, BOUNCING AROUND AS TRADERS CONFRONT
32:55 LEADERSHIP PRICES AT NVIDIA. JENSEN HUANG OUSTED THIS MORNING
32:59 AFTER REPORTS OF TWO AFFAIRS INCLUDING WITH ONE WOMAN WHO WAS
33:03 SUSPECTED OF BEING A CHINESE SPY APPEARED AS WE HAVE BEEN
33:06 REPORTING, THE CFO HAS BEEN NAMED INTERIM CEO.
33:12 THE BOARD APPOINTED HARVEY JONES AS ITS CHAIR.
33:14 MEANWHILE, HE AGREED TO TESTIFY BEFORE CONGRESS.
33:19 AGAIN, NVIDIA SHARES ARE DOWN NOW BY 4.6 PERCENT.
33:24 STOCKS TRADING HIGHER. S&P 500 INDEX UP FOUR POINTS
33:28 NOW. LITTLE CHANGED.
33:32 NASDAQ HOLDING ONTO A GAIN OF ONE POINT.
33:34 THE NASDAQ 100 INDEX ALSO LITTLE CHANGED, UP UNDER .1%.
33:39 THE DOW UP 77 POINTS, UP BY ABOUT .1%.
33:43 THE 10 YEAR AT 5.10% AND WE HAVE GOLD DOWN $102 THE OUNCE,
33:50 DECLINING TO -- DOWN TWO .6%. AN ADVANCE FOR CRUDE, WTI, WEST
33:57 TEXAS INTERMEDIATE UP NOW BY ABOUT 1.9 PERCENT.
34:00 BRENT, A BARREL OF BRAN UP NOW BY JUST ABOUT 2.6 PERCENT.
34:08 SPACEX SAYS IT PLANS TO BUILD TWO SUPERCOMPUTING FACILITIES
34:11 INCLUDING A NEW $50 MILLION SITE IN ARIZONA.
34:13 ELON MUSK'S COMPANY ANNOUNCED IT IS BUILDING OUT MORE
34:16 INFRASTRUCTURE PROJECTS INCLUDING BOTH THE COMPUTING
34:21 PROJECTS AS WELL AS OPERATING GAS POWER PLANTS IN BOTH TEXAS
34:24 AND ARIZONA, TOTALING AN INVESTMENT OF JUST ABOUT 74
34:28 BILLION DOLLARS. SPACEX SHARES ARE GAINING NOW BY
34:32 2%. RECAPPING.
34:36 S&P 500 INDEX UP UNDER .1%. NVIDIA SHARES DOWN 4.8 PERCENT.
34:40 THAT IS A BLOOMBERG BUSINESS FLASH.
34:44 KAILEY: CHARLIE PELLETT WATCHING THE MARKETS FOR US.
34:47 THANK YOU SO MUCH. BECAUSE CHARLIE MENTIONED ELON
34:49 MUSK, I FEEL LIKE WE SHOULD JUST NOTE ELON MUSK HAS SAID WITHIN
34:53 THE LAST 24 HOURS AS ALL OF THIS WAS GOING DOWN WITH REPORTS OF
34:56 JENSEN HUANG'S OUSTER WHICH HAS BEEN FINALIZED THIS MORNING WITH
34:58 HIS RESIGNATION, HE SAID IT WOULD BE AN HONOR TO HIGHER
35:04 JENSEN HUANG AND FROM MY PERCH IN WASHINGTON, I STRUGGLE TO
35:08 IMAGINE WHAT THAT MIGHT UNLOCK IN TERMS OF DEMOCRATIC
35:10 OVERSIGHT. DEMOCRATS ALREADY COMING -- THEY
35:14 ARE PROMISING THEY WILL INVESTIGATE ELON MUSK ON HIS OWN
35:16 AND THEY WANT TO INVESTIGATE JENSEN HUANG AND NVIDIA.
35:21 JENSEN HUANG JOINED FORCES WITH ELON MUSK.
35:24 I WOULD IMAGINE THAT WOULDN'T NECESSARILY SIT WELL.
35:26 WITH A LOT OF THE INDIVIDUALS. JOE: NOT SURE WHAT THE HR
35:31 DEPARTMENT AT SPACEX OR TESLA WOULD MAKE OF THIS, KNOWING WHAT
35:35 THE HR DEPARTMENT AT NVIDIA HAS MADE UP AND WHEN THE SECOND
35:41 AFFAIR EMERGED, WHEN THAT STORY BROKE WHEN WE WERE ON THE LATE
35:45 EDITION OF BALANCE OF POWER, THAT CHANGED THE WHOLE THING AND
35:50 YOU WONDER TO WHAT EXTENT THAT ACCELERATED HIS DEPARTURE.
35:51 WE CAN START THERE. HE IS BACK WITH US NOW WORKING
35:55 OVERTIME TODAY. BLOOMBERG MIKE SHEPARD, SENIOR
35:58 EDITOR FOR TECHNOLOGY AND STRATEGIC INDUSTRIES AHEAD OF
35:59 OUR CONVERSATION WITH MAXINE DEXTER.
36:04 YOU'VE GOT DEMOCRATS WHO ARE APPARENTLY GOING TO GET JENSEN
36:06 HUANG BEHIND CLOSED DOORS AND REPUBLICANS AS WELL.
36:12 THEY ASKED FOR HIS PRESENCE OR BE SUBPOENAED.
36:14 DID WE LEARN ANYTHING FROM THAT HEARING?
36:18 >> WE SURE ARE HOPING TO COME ON JOE.
36:20 THIS IS A SESSION THAT THE HEAD OF THE HOUSE FOREIGN AFFAIRS
36:23 COMMITTEE HAD BEEN REALLY PUSHING FOR.
36:26 HE HAS THE HOUSE INTELLIGENCE IN-HOUSE CHINA SELECT COMMITTEES
36:30 HAVE BEEN DEMANDING JENSEN HUANG'S PRESENCE TO TALK ABOUT
36:33 HIS RELATIONSHIP WITH ALICE WONG AND THIS IS EVEN BEFORE THE
36:35 ADMISSION OF AN AFFAIR. THERE HAVE BEEN REPORTING GOING
36:41 BACK TO OCTOBER 29 THAT THE TWO HAD A CLOSE RELATIONSHIP AND IT
36:44 WAS REALLY ONLY AT THE END OF LAST WEEK THAT IT WAS CONFIRMED
36:49 IT WAS A ROMANTIC ONE BUT OF COURSE, LAWMAKERS EVEN AHEAD OF
36:53 THAT REVELATION WERE WONDERING NOT ONLY ABOUT THE RELATIONSHIP
36:56 BUT WHAT ABOUT THE CHIPMAKER'S SECURITY PROTOCOLS?
36:59 BECAUSE AT THE HEART OF ALL OF THIS IS WHETHER SOME OF THE
37:04 COMPANIES REALLY PRIZED AI CHIPS HAVE BEEN DIVERTED TO CHINA IN
37:06 VIOLATION OF U.S. EXPORT CONTROLS.
37:10 KAILEY: IT'S NOT JUST A QUESTION OF ALICE WONG WHEN IT COMES TO
37:13 NVIDIA BUT WE ARE REPORTING ABOUT THE JUSTICE DEPARTMENT
37:14 PROBING SUPER MICRO'S RELATIONS WITH ALICE.
37:22 HOW FAR COULD THESE INVESTIGATIVE TENTACLES SPREAD
37:25 ACROSS COMPANIES IN THIS SPACE? QUICK TO PUT INTO PLAY THE WHOLE
37:28 SOUTHEAST ASIA SUPPLY CHAIN. YOU KNOW, THERE HAS BEEN THIS
37:32 LOOPHOLE IN U.S. EXPORT CONTROLS THAT ALLOWS THE SHIPMENT OF AI
37:38 CHIPS TO DATA CENTERS WHERE CHINESE COMPANIES CAN REMOTELY
37:42 ACCESS THE CHIPS TO USE THEM. ALIBABA WAS A CUSTOMER OF
37:45 MEGASPEED WHICH IS THE COMPANY THAT ALICE WAS FOR A TIME ONE OF
37:49 THE TOP EXECUTIVES. THEY WERE DOING SO LEGALLY
37:53 BECAUSE U.S. EXPORT CONTROLS ALLOW THE CHIPS TO BE HOUSED
37:57 OFFSHORE, JUST NOT IN CHINA SO OF CHINESE COMPANIES WANT TO
38:00 ACCESS THE CHIPS, THEY CAN DO IT FROM A REMOTE LOCATION.
38:06 KAILEY: MICHAEL SHEPARD COVERING TECHNOLOGY AND STRATEGIC
38:08 INDUSTRIES IN WASHINGTON, THANK YOU SO MUCH.
38:10 WHAT HE WAS OUTLINING IS WHY MANY IN CONGRESS NOW ARE CALLING
38:14 FOR A LEGISLATIVE ANSWER TO TIGHTEN EXPORT CONTROLS AND THAT
38:16 IS WHERE WE BEGIN AS WE TURN NOW TO CAPITOL HILL TO DEMOCRATIC
38:21 CONGRESSMAN MAXINE DEXTER WHO REPRESENTS OREGON'S THIRD
38:23 CONGRESSIONAL DISTRICT FROM A MEMBER OF THE VETERANS AFFAIRS
38:25 COMMITTEE, THE NATURAL RESOURCES COMMITTEE AS WELL.
38:27 CONGRESSMAN, WELCOME TO BLOOMBERG TV AND RADIO.
38:31 IT'S GOOD TO HAVE YOU. I WONDER WHAT YOUR EXPECTATION
38:35 IS IN THIS LAME DUCK SESSION IN PARTICULAR, KNOWING THE NATIONAL
38:39 DEFENSE AUTHORIZATION ACT WILL NEED TO PASS BEFORE EVERYBODY
38:42 BREAKS BEFORE THE NEW CONGRESS. DO YOU EXPECT THAT TIGHTER
38:45 EXPORT CONTROLS WILL BE EMBEDDED IN IT?
38:49 >> I CERTAINLY DO NOT SPEAK FOR THE COMMITTEE BUT ABSOLUTELY, I
38:54 WILL BE ADVOCATING FOR NATIONAL SECURITY TO ACTUALLY BE TOP
38:57 PRIORITY AND WHAT THIS HAS REVEALED, WHICH SO MANY WERE
39:00 CONCERNED ABOUT IS THAT WE ARE NOT REGULATING AND CREATING
39:07 GUARDRAILS THAT OUR PEOPLE DESERVE AND ABSOLUTELY NEED IN
39:08 OUR NATIONAL SECURITY HAS BEEN AT RISK NOW AT LEAST SINCE
39:14 SEPTEMBER WITHOUT ACTION BY OUR EXECUTIVE -- EXECUTIVE BRANCH.
39:16 WE NEED TO TAKE LEGISLATIVE ACTION.
39:19 JOE: IF IT WAS FOUND IN THE FACT THAT THE ADMINISTRATION DID KNOW
39:23 ABOUT THIS -- WELCOME TO BLOOMBERG.
39:28 I SAW YOUR FLOOR TIME THIS WEEK IN SUPPORT OF THE IMPEACHMENT
39:32 ARTICLES FOR PETE HEGSETH. WILL YOU PURSUE THE SAME
39:33 APPROACH FOR HOWARD LUTNICK? >> YOU KNOW, I THINK THAT MY JOB
39:41 IS TO ASSERT THE IMPORTANCE OF ACCOUNTABILITY AND TRANSPARENCY
39:44 AND HOWARD LUTNICK CLEARLY HASN'T IN MY MIND RAISED TO THE
39:48 LEVEL OF ACCOUNTABILITY TO THE AMERICAN PEOPLE SO WHETHER HE
39:55 HAS BROKEN THE LAW AND HAS ARTICLES OF IMPEACHMENT THAT ARE
39:58 LEGITIMATE AND VIABLE IS SOMETHING THAT I WILL LOOK TO MY
40:02 COLLEAGUES FOR FURTHER INFORMATION.
40:04 AS YOU SAID, I AM ON THE NATURAL RESOURCES COMMITTEE SAID THIS IS
40:07 NOT IN MY COMMITTEE'S JURISDICTION BUT IS ABSOLUTELY
40:10 SOMETHING THAT MY CONSTITUENTS ARE CONCERNED ABOUT.
40:15 JOE: ARE YOU CALLING FOR HIS RESIGNATION?
40:18 >> YOU KNOW, I THINK WHAT I AM COMING FOR HIS TRANSPARENCY AND
40:20 ACCOUNTABILITY. HOWARD LUTNICK'S RESIGNATION
40:23 CERTAINLY SEEMS LIKE A RATIONAL RESPONSE TO THIS BUT WHAT I
40:28 THINK I AM MORE CONCERNED ABOUT IS THE FACT THAT OUR PRESIDENT
40:29 IS REPORTED TO HAVE HAD A BRIEFING ON THE CONCERNS AROUND
40:35 THIS AFFAIR AND POTENTIAL FOR NATIONAL SECURITY RISK AND HE
40:38 DID NOT ACT SO WE NEED TO MAKE SURE THAT PEOPLE ARE HELD
40:42 ACCOUNTABLE, AND FRANKLY, IT COMES FROM THE TOP.
40:47 KAILEY: OBVIOUSLY, CONGRESSWOMAN, THERE'S A LOT OF
40:49 QUESTIONS THAT STEM FROM THIS. ONE OF THEM, IN ADDITION TO
40:53 QUESTIONS AROUND JENSEN HUANG HIMSELF AND NVIDIA AS A COMPANY
40:55 IS SIMPLY THE ROLE NVIDIA HAS PLAYED AS BEING SO CRITICAL TO
41:01 THE WIDER ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE BOOM IN THE
41:02 BUILDOUT THAT IS ASSOCIATED WITH THAT INCLUDING THE DESTINATION
41:06 FOR A LOT OF THESE AI CHIPS WHICH IS DATA CENTERS.
41:11 I KNOW YOU HAVE A NEW BUILD IN REGARD TO DATA CENTERS AS WELL.
41:14 IS THIS ILLUMINATING FOR YOU ANY FURTHER CONCERN AROUND A
41:17 NECESSITY OF SLOWING DOWN THE PACE OF THIS BOOM AND THE
41:21 INFRASTRUCTURE THAT SUPPORTS IT? >> 100%.
41:27 THE AMERICAN PEOPLE WERE VERY CLEAR THAT THIS IS A BIPARTISAN
41:30 COALESCING AT HER BY THE AMERICAN PEOPLE TO DEMAND
41:35 ACCOUNTABILITY FOR WHAT NOT JUST DATA CENTERS TEACH OUR LANDS AND
41:40 THE ENVIRONMENT BUT WHAT DATA CENTERS REPRESENT FOR OUR
41:44 ECONOMY, OUR NATIONAL SECURITY AND JOB SECURITY.
41:47 WE NEED TO NOT JUST SLOW DOWN. WE NEED INTERNATIONAL AGREEMENTS
41:50 AROUND HOW DO WE SLOW DOWN? HOW DO WE CREATE REGULATORY
41:54 FRAMEWORKS THAT ACTUALLY ADDRESS THE ISSUE AS YOU WERE JUST
41:59 SPEAKING TO? OFFSHORE DATA CENTERS CAN STILL ALLOW THE USE
42:04 OF THESE CHIPS FOR CHINESE COMPANIES.
42:07 WE NEED TO ACTUALLY ENFORCE NATIONAL SECURITY, INTERNATIONAL
42:10 SECURITY, AND PERSONAL SECURITY. ON TOP OF THE ECONOMIC CLIFF
42:16 THAT THIS HAS CREATED, THIS IS A MOMENT OF CRISIS AND WE NEED TO
42:18 RESPOND IN KIND. JOE: THERE ARE CONCERNS ABOUT
42:24 SLOWING OR STOPPING THE DATA CENTER BUILDOUT HAVING AN
42:26 ECONOMIC EFFECT. HAVE YOU HAD THAT CONVERSATION
42:31 WITH ECONOMISTS, CONGRESSWOMAN, TO UNDERSTAND WHAT A PAUSE OR
42:35 MORATORIUM ON DATA CENTERS WOULD MEAN FOR ECONOMIC GROWTH?
42:38 >> YOU KNOW, THAT IS NOT SOMETHING I HAVE SPOKEN TO
42:40 ECONOMISTS PERSONALLY. WHAT I AM FOCUSED ON RIGHT NOW
42:45 IS FEDERAL LANDS AND MAKING SURE THAT OUR PUBLIC LANDS ARE
42:47 PROTECTED AND NOT USED FOR DATA CENTERS.
42:50 WE HAVE A PROPOSED BLM DATA CENTER IN OREGON THAT WE NEED TO
42:55 MAKE SURE THAT WE HAVE PROTECTIONS FOR THESE TREASURED
43:00 LANDS BEING PRESERVED FOR FUTURE GENERATIONS SO I AM STICKING IN
43:05 MY LANGUAGE IS NATURAL RESOURCES AND THE PEOPLE OF OREGON WANT
43:09 PUBLIC LANDS TO BE PROTECTED. DATA CENTERS ON PUBLIC LANDS AS
43:12 A GO AROUND, IT ALSO RAISES CONCERNS ABOUT THE SECRETARY AND
43:17 HIS INVESTMENTS IN DATA CENTERS AND WHETHER FEDERAL LAND SALES
43:22 ARE BENEFITING OUR DEPARTMENT OF INTERIOR OR OTHER EXECUTIVE
43:29 BRANCH APPOINTEES. WE HAVE A LOT OF QUESTIONS ON
43:33 FOCUSED ON RIGHT NOW. KAILEY: IT'S GREAT TO HEAR FROM
43:39 YOU ON THIS AS A MEMBER OF THE COMMITTEE BUT AS YOU MENTIONED A
43:42 FEW TIMES NOW, YOU ALSO ARE A MEMBER OF THE VETERAN AFFAIRS
43:45 COMMITTEE AND I WONDER YOUR REACTION TO THE PASSAGE OF THE
43:48 BILL ON THE FLOOR OF THE HOUSE YESTERDAY THAT MANY DEMOCRATS
43:49 SUGGESTED ACTUALLY WOULD WORK AGAINST VETERANS DESPITE BEING
43:54 ADVERTISED AS SOMETHING THAT WOULD BENEFIT THEM AND YET IT
43:56 PASSED BECAUSE THERE WAS SOME CONFUSION AS TO WHETHER OR NOT A
44:00 ROLL CALL VOTE WAS BEING CALLED. TAKE THAT WITH THE ATTENDANCE
44:02 ISSUES AROUND THE PROCEDURAL VOTE TO ESSENTIALLY PUNT THE
44:09 HEGSETH IMPEACHMENT. IS THERE AN ISSUE THAT
44:10 LEADERSHIP NEEDS TO TIGHTEN UP BEFORE YOU TAKE THE MAJORITY IN
44:14 JANUARY? >> YOU KNOW, WE ABSOLUTELY NEED
44:19 TO MAKE SURE THAT OUR EYE IS ON THE BALL AND THAT WE ARE DOING
44:24 EVERYTHING WE CAN TO ANTICIPATE TRICKERY AND SHENANIGANS.
44:25 THAT'S BE CLEAR, THERE WAS AN IN WRITING RECORDED VOTE EXPECTED
44:30 FOR THAT VOTE. THERE WAS A LOT OF NOISE ON THE
44:35 FLOOR. I AM NOT MAKING ANY EXCUSES.
44:39 ULTIMATELY, IT IS OUR FLOOR TEAM AND LEADERSHIP'S JOB TO MAKE
44:42 SURE WE ARE READY BUT THE REPUBLICANS ARE THE ONES WHO
44:45 BROUGHT THIS BILL TO THE FLOOR. IT IS THE BIGGEST CUT TO
44:50 VETERANS BENEFITS EVER. THEY ARE THE ONES WHO DID NOT
44:53 THEY DID NOT HAVE THE VOTES BASED ON THE NUMBER OF FOLKS WHO
45:03 HAD MOVED THE ACT FORWARD SO I THINK IT WAS A WAY FOR THEM TO
45:06 TRY TO GET SOMETHING PASSED THAT ACTUALLY GOD'S VETERANS BENEFITS
45:10 ON VETERANS DAY. IT LITERALLY MADE ME NAUSEATED
45:15 SO, SURE, WE ABSOLUTELY HAVE SOME ACCOUNTABILITY THERE.
45:18 I HAVE SPOKEN TO MEMBERS OF THE TEAM.
45:20 WE ARE ABSOLUTELY GOING TO BE VIGILANT IN ANTICIPATING THESE
45:27 KIND OF TRICKERY'S BUT LET'S BE CLEAR.
45:30 THIS WAS NOT THE EXPECTED ROLL CALL VOTE THAT WE HAD -- THE
45:36 RECORDED VOTE WE HAD ANTICIPATED.
45:38 WE KNEW THAT WE NEEDED TO BE ON THE FLOOR.
45:41 WE WERE THERE AND, YOU KNOW, WE KEPT LOOKING UP, WAITING FOR THE
45:45 BOAT TO BE CALLED AND IT NEVER CAME BECAUSE THEY WERE DIVERTING
45:48 OUR CHAIR OF THE COMMITTEE AWAY FROM THE PODIUM AND THEN
45:52 SNEAKILY CALLED FOR A VOICE VOTE.
45:56 JOE: THIS IS TRULY WATCHING THE SAUSAGE BE MADE.
46:01 DECEMBER 11, WHAT IS YOUR PERSONAL FEELING AND WHAT IS THE
46:05 DIRECTION FROM LEADERSHIP FROM HAKEEM JEFFRIES ON MANAGING THIS
46:06 FUNDING DEADLINE? DO YOU WANT TO SEE A CONTINUING RESOLUTION THAT
46:12 IS BRIEF TO GET YOU INTO THE NEXT CONGRESS OR SOMETHING
46:13 LONGER TO BUY MORE TIME? >> IT SHOULD BE AS BRIEF AS
46:18 POSSIBLE. WE NEED TO USE OUR LEVERAGE TO
46:22 PROTECT THE AMERICAN PEOPLE, THEIR HEALTH, THEIR SAFETY.
46:26 WE'VE GOT MEDICAID CLIFFS EARLY IN JANUARY.
46:29 WE HAVE SNAP BENEFITS THAT ARE AT RISK.
46:33 WE HAVE ULTIMATELY AN ENORMOUS PAIN POINT ACROSS OUR COUNTRY
46:38 THAT AS WE TAKE CONTROL OF THE HOUSE, WE NEED TO BE ABLE TO
46:43 ASSERT OUR OWN PRIORITIES FOR ANY CONTINUING RESOLUTION SO I
46:45 WOULD WANT THIS TO BE AS SHORT AS POSSIBLE SO WE CAN LEAD IN A
46:49 DIFFERENT DIRECTION WHEN WE TAKE OVER IN JANUARY.
46:53 JOE: GOOD TO HAVE YOU WITH US. CONGRESSWOMAN FROM OREGON'S
46:56 THIRD CONGRESSIONAL DISTRICT, NOT FAR FROM THE HEART OF ONE
46:58 COUNTRY. THANK YOU, CONGRESSWOMAN, FOR
46:59 BEING WITH US. SOME OF THE CONVERSATIONS YOU
47:03 ARE GOING TO BE HEARING TODAY ON BLOOMBERG, WE ARE GOING TO BE
47:06 TALKING WITH VOICES FROM CORPORATE AMERICA AND FROM HERE
47:08 IN WASHINGTON WHERE A BIG PART OF THE STORY IS GOING TO BE
47:10 PLAYING OUT POTENTIALLY FOR MONTHS.
47:15 KAILEY: NVIDIA HAS A LOT OF DECISIONS TO MAKE.
47:18 WHAT COMES NEXT WITH THE LEADERSHIP, HOW THIS AFFECTS THE
47:21 TRAJECTORY OF THE COMPANY ITSELF AND ITS DOMINANCE IN THE AI
47:26 SPACE BUT THERE ARE ALSO MASSIVE POLICY QUESTIONS HERE.
47:29 NATIONAL SECURITY QUESTIONS AND DOMESTIC POLITICAL
47:32 CONSIDERATIONS AS IT SEEMS THAT BIPARTISAN LAWMAKERS ON CAPITOL
47:35 HILL, BOTH REPUBLICANS AND DEMOCRATS, WANT MORE INFORMATION
47:38 AND WANTED TO BE MADE PUBLIC. THIS STORY IS A LONG WAY FROM
47:41 BEING OVER EVEN IF THIS RESIGNATION WAS HANDED IN TODAY.
47:45 JOE: THE TIMING HERE IS SOMETHING.
47:48 WE WILL PICK IT UP ON THE LATE EDITION OF THE LATE EDITION OF
47:50 BALANCE OF POWER. ♪
Ex-Nvidia CEO Huang Says ‘Not My Job to Agree or Disagree’ With Trump full transcript
0:00 You have President Trump on speed dial. What happens when your views differ from
0:04 the president's? How do you walk that line?
0:06 We don't have to agree on anything. It's not my job, uh, to agree or
0:13 disagree. It's my job to inform him of the
0:15 decisions that we make. Impact not just the American citizens.
0:18 The prosperity of our future. Um, it impacts, uh, the world.
0:23 And so if ever I have an opportunity to help inform him so that he could make a
0:29 better decision. Whatever the decision is, whether it
0:32 serves me where there is, um, uh, uh, counter my interests.
0:37 It's not my concern. It's only my concern that I have an
0:40 opportunity to inform him. And that's a 100%.
0:43 That's how I feel. You spent the last three months trying
0:45 to demystify I. You know, you said it's not a new
0:47 species. It's just a bunch of code.
0:49 Isn't calling it super the opposite of that?
0:52 I actually, I think calling it super is the opposite of artificial and and super
0:57 intelligence is the new word. Yeah, I think I do think it's better
1:02 than artificial. And I think President Trump's point is
1:05 that artificial is just as fake. Um, well, everything's fake.
1:09 We built it. And so I think at some level, you know,
1:12 this is fake as we're in a fake structure, it was it was built by
1:17 humans. But we don't say that.
1:19 You know, it's a, uh, it's a fake horse, you know?
1:21 Otherwise known as a car, you know, but we don't say that.
1:24 Is it superintelligence? Absolutely.
1:26 I mean, it does a better job researching than I do.
1:28 It does a better job writing than I do. It's not super at everything that we do,
1:34 but it's super many things that we do.
Open Interest 11/12/2026 full transcript
0:01 >> JENSEN HUANG NVIDIA, SHARES EXTENDING THEIR SLIDE PREMARKET.
0:12 I AM VONNIE QUINN. ALONGSIDE ISABELLE LEE, THIS IS
0:15 BLOOMBERG OPEN INTEREST.
0:17 >> LET'S START WITH ED LUDLOW IN SAN FRANCISCO.
0:26 TALK ABOUT WHAT THIS WILL MEAN FOR NVIDIA AND ITS FUTURE.
0:28 JENSEN HUANG SPENT 33 YEARS AT THE HOME OF THE COMPANY.
0:31 AND HAS BEEN SYNONYMOUS WITH THE AI REVOLUTION.
0:35 >> JENSEN HUANG'S RESIGNATION IS EFFECTIVE IMMEDIATELY.
0:41 TO WALL STREET, THAT BRING SOME FAMILIARITY.
0:43 HE'S BEEN THERE FOR 13 -- SHE'S BEEN THERE FOR 13 YEARS AND HAS
0:46 BEEN ALONGSIDE JENSEN HUANG AND SEEN THAT DRAMATIC PERIOD OF
0:49 GROWTH. SHE, TO AN EXTENT, HOLD A
0:52 RELATIONSHIP WITH WALL STREET. JENSEN HUANG HAD BEEN DOING MORE
0:56 IN RECENT QUARTERS IN RECENT YEARS.
0:58 BUT THE STOCK CLEARLY REACTED WITH A DEEPER PUSH INTO NEGATIVE
1:03 TERRITORY IN THE PREMARKET. A SIGNIFICANT UPDATE IS THAT
1:07 HARVEY C JONES, ONE OF NVIDIA'S LONGEST-SERVING DIRECTORS
1:11 BECOMES CHAIRMAN OF THE BOARD. THEY ARE SEPARATING THE CHAIRMAN
1:16 AND CEO ROLE WHICH JENSEN HUANG HELD.
1:21 THEY WILL CONTINUE WITH EARNINGS NEXT WEEK, WHICH IS A BIG
1:22 QUESTION. VONNIE: AS YOU SAID, SHE'S BEEN
1:29 ON THOSE CALLS. WILL IT BE ANY QUESTION AS TO
1:34 HOW MUCH IF ANYTHING SHE KNEW DURING THIS PERIOD?
1:38 ED: THAT IS NOT MENTIONED AT ALL IN THE STATEMENT, NOR IS THE
1:42 IDEA THAT JENSEN HUANG MAINTAINS ANY KIND OF RELATIONSHIP WITH
1:46 NVIDIA ON AN ADVISORY BASIS. THERE IS ALSO VERY LITTLE UPDATE
1:49 IN THE INVESTIGATION. REMEMBER THAT WHEN THIS HAPPENED
1:55 SUNDAY, JENSEN HUANG WROTE TO STAFF TO DISCLOSE HE HAD AN
1:58 AFFAIR AND WOULD COOPERATE IN AN INVESTIGATION.
2:01 THE BOARD SET AT THAT TIME, THERE WAS NO EVIDENCE THAT THERE
2:06 WAS A NATIONAL SECURITY OR NVIDIA TRADE SECRETS RISK.
2:09 TO THE BEST OF THEIR KNOWLEDGE THAT THEY WERE AWARE OF.
2:14 THAT DOESN'T ANSWER YOUR QUESTION ON COLLECT --
2:24 COLLETTE KRESS. NVIDIA IS OPEN TO LOOKING AT
2:26 EXTERNAL CANDIDATES FOR CEO LONG TERM.
2:30 THEY ALSO SAID SHE WOULD BE AN OPTION ON THE INTERIM BASIS AND
2:35 TRANSPIRED. ISABELLE: TALK TO US ABOUT THE
2:42 FUTURE OF THE COMPANY. HOW MUCH OF NVIDIA IS TIED TO
2:45 JENSEN HUANG'S CONNECTION AND KNOW HOW -- CONNECTIONS AND
2:49 KNOW-HOW? ED: THE FUNDAMENTAL CHANGE THAT
2:53 HAPPENED AFTER THE CHATGPT MOMENT IN 2022 IS -- SHIFTED TO
2:59 ONE MAN, JENSEN HUANG. FLYING AROUND THE WORLD AND
3:04 OPERATING WHERE HE COORDINATED POLICYMAKERS.
3:09 NOT THAT LONG AGO, THAT WAS NOT HOW THAT BUSINESS WORK.
3:14 YOU BOUGHT NVIDIA GPU'S THROUGH A MIDDLE CHANNEL, WHICH WAS THE
3:20 SERVER, DELL, HP, SUPER MICRO. THERE WAS NOT THIS RELATIONSHIP
3:26 BETWEEN THE CHIPMAKERS AND WHERE THE CHIPS ENDED UP.
3:29 JENSEN HUANG COMPLETELY BURST THAT.
3:31 IF YOU THINK ABOUT THE ENTIRE CHAIN THAT HAS BEEN BUILT OUT IN
3:35 THIS AI INFRASTRUCTURE. GOING FORWARD, IT WILL BE REALLY
3:38 HARD TO SEE THAT HAPPENING. NVIDIA HAD A STRUCTURE WHERE IT
3:41 WAS JENSEN HUANG AT THE TOP. HE HAD 60 OR SO DIRECT REPORTS
3:46 AND IT WAS LIKE A REVERSE PYRAMID.
3:47 AND YOU KNOW, WE DON'T KNOW THE ANSWER OF HOW THAT WILL SHIP
3:48 GOING FORWARD. VONNIE: WE BRING IN MANDEEP
3:52 SINGH OF BLOOMBERG INTELLIGENCE. WE WANT TO ASK ABOUT THE FALLOUT
3:58 FOR THE REST OF THE AI INDUSTRY AND THE STRUCTURE AROUND AI.
4:03 FOR THE MOMENT, THE COMPANY HAS WORKED EXTRAORDINARILY FAST.
4:05 IT'S LIKE OPERATIONS AND SUPPLIES WILL CONTINUE WITHOUT
4:07 ANY INTERRUPTION. THIS IS WITHIN DAYS OF ALL OF
4:10 THIS BREAKING. IS THERE THE POSSIBILITY THAT
4:13 THINGS WILL CONTINUE TO RUN SMOOTHLY IN THE AI UNIVERSE AND
4:16 THE DEALS HAVE BEEN DONE WHERE THE BULK OF THE DEALS THAT WERE
4:19 COMING ANYWAY AND THE MARKET WILL GET OVER THIS?
4:24 MANDEEP: NO, I THINK THERE WILL BE A TREMENDOUS LOSS OF
4:28 CREDIBILITY FOR NVIDIA OVERALL, GIVEN THEIR IMPORTANCE IN THE AI
4:30 ECOSYSTEM AND WHAT HAS TRANSPIRED, I THINK, IN TERMS OF
4:38 THE BOARD AND EVERYTHING THAT THEY WERE DOING FROM A DEAL
4:39 PERSPECTIVE. I THINK I WOULD CALL OUT TWO
4:43 ENTITIES THAT WOULD GET IMPACTED THE MOST.
4:48 NVIDIA WAS VERY SUPPORTIVE OF THE NEO CLOUD ECOSYSTEM WITH ALL
4:51 OF THE INVESTMENTS. IT WOULD BE INTERESTING TO SEE
4:54 HOW THAT PLAYS OUT. ALSO, THE OPEN SOURCE, OPEN RATE
4:59 ECOSYSTEM, BECAUSE NVIDIA WAS CLEARLY DEVELOPING ITS OWN OPEN
5:02 RATE MODELS AND IT WILL BE INTERESTING TO SEE HOW THAT
5:05 INVOLVES -- EVOLVES IN LIGHT OF THIS DEVELOPMENT WHERE JENSEN
5:10 HUANG WAS SPEARHEADING THAT STRATEGY.
5:12 THOSE TWO AND OBVIOUSLY YOU HAVE THE GROSS MARGINS THAT EVERYONE
5:16 THOUGHT NVIDIA'S GROSS MARGINS WERE TOO HIGH.
5:20 I THINK IT WILL BE INTERESTING TO SEE HOW THAT PLAYS OUT.
5:26 CREDIBILITY WISE, I THINK -- VONNIE:--
5:35 ISABELLE: LET'S BRING IN MIKE. I WANT TO TALK ABOUT THE CHINA
5:37 STRATEGY. WE KNOW JENSEN HUANG HAS BEEN
5:42 PUSHING FOR LOOSER RESTRICTIONS WHEN IT COMES TO THE CHINA CHIP
5:46 AND THE DEAL WITH THE U.S.. WHAT WILL IT MEAN FOR THAT?
5:50 WILL THE NEW CEO CONTINUE THAT PATH MOVING FORWARD IN YOUR
5:51 OPINION? MIKE: THEY MAY TRY TO CONTINUE
5:56 THAT PATH BUT THEY WON'T HAVE THE SAME LEVERAGE.
6:05 JENSEN HUANG WAS ABLE TO PERSUADE THE ADMINISTRATION TO
6:08 LOOSEN EXPORT CONTROLS THAT HAVE BEEN GRADUALLY TIGHTENED SINCE
6:10 2022. THAT WERE PREVENTING THE COMPANY
6:15 FROM SELLING SOME OF ITS MOST ADVANCED AI CHIPS TO CHINESE
6:16 BUYERS. WE SAW H2 HUNDREDS CLEARED FOR
6:23 PURCHASE BY CHINA LATE LAST YEAR, REALLY THANKS TO THIS
6:27 LOBBYING EFFORT BY JENSEN HUANG, DIRECTLY TO PRESIDENT DONALD
6:30 TRUMP, WHO MADE THAT ANNOUNCEMENT HIMSELF.
6:31 ALL OF THAT HAS CHANGED. WE ARE SEEING THIS FUNDAMENTAL
6:37 SHIFT HERE IN WASHINGTON AFTER THE ELECTION THANKS TO THE VOTER
6:41 BACKLASH AGAINST AI, BUT MORE SPECIFICALLY ON CAPITOL HILL, WE
6:45 ARE SEEING A RECKONING FOR THE COMPANY WITH LAWMAKERS FROM BOTH
6:50 PARTIES ADVOCATING STERNER EXPORT CONTROLS BEING PUT IN
6:52 PLACE, SPECIFICALLY WHEN IT COMES TO AI CHIPS AND CHINA.
6:57 VONNIE: EXPLAIN TO US WHAT LIABILITY JENSEN HIMSELF IS
7:00 EXPOSED TO NOW EVEN AFTER RESIGNING FROM NVIDIA, NEVER
7:02 MIND THE COMPANY ITSELF. MIKE: WE ARE STILL IN THE EARLY
7:09 STAGES BEST OCCASION. IT'S UNCLEAR WHERE HE COULD BE
7:12 EXPOSED IN TERMS OF WHAT HE HAS PREVIOUSLY TOLD THE COMPANY
7:14 ABOUT HIS RELATIONSHIPS, NOT ONLY WITH ALICE BUT ALSO WITH
7:19 ONE OF HIS SUBORDINATES, AND NVIDIA VICE PRESIDENT.
7:25 NEWS OF THAT CAME TO LIGHT LAST NIGHT AS ISABELLA NOTED.
7:28 THERE IS THE EXPOSURE HE COULD HAVE FROM THAT.
7:34 THERE ARE INQUIRIES FROM THE JUSTICE DEPARTMENT.
7:42 DID NVIDIA HAVE SOME SORT OF HAND IN HELPING MEGASPEED
7:49 LOOKING THE OTHER WAY? THE U.S. IS STILL INVESTIGATING
7:51 WHETHER THAT HAPPENED. MEGASPEED HAS DENIED THAT'S THE
7:54 CASE. THAT INVESTIGATION HAS NOT
7:56 CONCLUDED AND WE ARE WAITING TO SEE WHAT THE RESULTS WILL BE.
8:00 THEN I MENTIONED CAPITOL HILL. LAWMAKERS THERE ARE PREPARING TO
8:03 MOUNT THEIR OWN INVESTIGATIONS AND, AS OF LAST NIGHT, JENSEN
8:07 HUANG WAS FACING THE PROSPECT OF A SUBPOENA FROM A TRIO OF HOUSE
8:11 REPUBLICAN COMMITTEE LEADERS WHO WANTED HIM TO SHOW UP A WEEK
8:15 FROM YESTERDAY ON CAPITOL HILL TO ANSWER QUESTIONS ABOUT THIS
8:17 SCANDAL. IT'S UNCLEAR NOW THAT HE IS GONE
8:21 WHETHER THEY WILL INSIST ON THAT SUBPOENA BUT WE KNOW THAT TWO
8:25 DEMOCRATS, CHRIS COONS AND ELIZABETH WARREN IN THE SENATE,
8:30 HAVE ASKED NVIDIA TO RETAIN ALL RECORDS RELATED TO THIS MATTER.
8:36 ISABELLE: TALK TO US ABOUT THE UNIQUE STRUCTURE NVIDIA HAS,
8:37 MANDY. JENSEN HUANG HAS 60 DIFFERENT
8:46 REPORTS, WHICH IS WHY HE CAN MAKE NIMBLE AND FAST DECISIONS.
8:49 HE'S KNOWN TO REPLY TO ALL OF HIS EMPLOYEES.
8:53 HOW UNIQUE IS THAT AND DO YOU THINK NVIDIA CAN HAVE THIS SPEED
8:58 HELM? MANDEEP: RIGHT NOW, EVERYONE IS
9:04 THINKING WHY DIDN'T NVIDIA HAVE A SUCCESSION PLAN.
9:07 THAT'S WHERE I THINK EVEN THE BOARD WOULD HAVE SOME
9:08 ACCOUNTABILITY. YOU TALK ABOUT THE DIRECT
9:12 REPORTS, BUT THEY DON'T REALLY HAVE AN INTERNAL CANDIDATE THAT
9:16 THEY COULD APPOINT AS THE CEO RIGHT NOW AND THEY HAVE A CEO
9:20 SITUATION. ALL OF THOSE THINGS I THINK ARE
9:24 RIGHT NOW BEING DISCUSSED. CLEARLY, THE STRUCTURE THEY HAD
9:29 WAS NOT GOOD ENOUGH TO REPLACE JENSEN HUANG RIGHT AWAY.
9:35 INTERIM CEO IN PLACE. WHAT HAPPENS NEXT?
9:40 THE SEARCH FOR A NEW CEO, WILL IT LOOK BEYOND THE LEADERS OF
9:46 THE CURRENT CROP OF AI FIRMS? WOULD IT BE IMPOSSIBLE FOR LISA
9:51 TO TAKE ON THIS JOB AS WELL OR SOMETHING UNUSUAL LIKE THAT?
9:55 ED: TO REITERATE WHAT'S IN THE BOARD STATEMENT, THEY ARE OPEN
9:59 TO AND WILL REVIEW EXTERNAL CANDIDATES FOR THE ROLE OF LONG
10:00 TERM. LAST NIGHT, WHEN ALL OF THIS WAS
10:05 DEVELOPING, IT'S NOW CONFIRMED THAT JENSEN HUANG HAS RESIGNED
10:11 AND COLLETTE KRESS IS THE CEO ON AN INTERIM BASIS, THERE WERE
10:12 EXTERNAL NAMES. -- WAS PUT IS A FRONT RUNNER IN
10:23 PART BECAUSE HE WAS NVIDIA EXECUTIVE OR SEVEN YEARS,
10:27 JOINING IN 2006 AND LEADING THE COMPUTER BUSINESS.
10:38 PEOPLE POINT OUT YOU LISA SU -- ELISA SU IS A FIRST COUSIN ONCE
10:44 REMOVED OF JENSEN HUANG. BUT SHE'S LEADING A COMPANY IN
10:48 HER OWN RIGHT. ANOTHER PERSON THEY TALK ABOUT
10:53 IS IAN BUCK. HE'S NOT THE CHARACTER AND DOES
10:57 NOT HAVE THE CHARISMA OF JENSEN HUANG WHEN HE LED THE TEAM AT
11:02 ROKITA IN THE EARLY 2000 SWITCH CHANGED IN NVIDIA FROM A
11:04 VIDEOGAMES COMPANY TO WHAT IT IS TODAY.
11:11 -- 2000S WHICH CHANGED NVIDIA FROM A VIDEO GAMES COMPANY TO
11:12 WHAT IT IS TODAY. ISABELLE: CAN YOU OFFER US
11:18 INSIGHT ON WHAT COLLETTE KRESS IS LIKE?
11:22 DO YOU THINK SHE WILL HAVE A NEW STYLE OF LEADERSHIP?
11:27 ED: COLLETTE KRESS IS HIGHLY COMPETENT, HIGHLY RESPECTED BY
11:32 WALL STREET, BY THE SELL SIDE AND BY THE BUY SIDE.
11:39 SHE IS INTIMATELY FAMILIAR WITH THE TECHNOLOGY THAT THE BUSINESS
11:40 WORKS ON. SHE'S NOT JUST A CFO IN REVIEW
11:46 OF NUMBERS. IF YOU WERE TO HAVE A
11:49 CONVERSATION WITH HER ABOUT WHERE NVIDIA SEES MOMENTUM WHEN
11:52 THEY GIVE CONVICTION FORECASTS, WHAT THEY ARE SEEING ON THE
11:55 DEMAND SIDE AND HOW THEY MANAGE THEIR SUPPLY CHAIN AND
11:58 OPERATIONS, SHE IS STRONG ON THOSE POINTS TOO.
12:02 THE STRUCTURES INTERESTING. THEY HAVE AN INTERIM CEO AND
12:06 PREVIOUSLY A CFO. BUT THERE HAS BEEN NO SORT OF
12:14 COO OR OTHER BIG COMMERCIAL SALES LEAD.
12:15 THAT'S THE STRUCTURE, THE COO AT THE TOP AND THE CFO UNDERNEATH.
12:25 READ IT. VONNIE: CAN I ASK YOU ABOUT THE
12:30 RISKS THAT WE ARE SEEING PLAY OUT?
12:32 THIS IS A BIT OF A BLACK SWAN EVEN FOR THE AI TRADES.
12:36 NOT SOMETHING THEY WOULD HAVE HAD ON THEIR BINGO CARDS, AT
12:38 LEAST NOT THIS WAY OF GOING OUT FOR JENSEN HUANG.
12:41 AT THE SAME TIME, WE HAVE SEEN PEOPLE EXIT STAGE LEFT BEFORE
12:46 AND COMPANIES HAVE GOTTEN ON FINE WITHOUT THEM.
12:49 I'M THINKING OF THE LARGEST COMPANY IN THE WORLD RIGHT NOW
12:50 AND THAT IS APPLE. EVEN THOUGH STEVE JOBS WAS GONE,
12:55 PEOPLE THOUGHT THAT WAS IT FOR APPLE.
12:59 MANDEEP: THAT'S WHERE SUCCESSION PLANNING AND WHO THE NEXT CEO OF
13:03 NVIDIA IT WILL BE IS EXTREMELY IMPORTANT IN TERMS OF THE
13:04 EXECUTION THAT YOU TALK ABOUT. BUT LOOK, ONE THING THAT
13:13 EVERYONE THOUGHT NVIDIA PROPERLY HAD AN ADVANTAGE OF WAS THE FACT
13:17 THAT THEY HAVE THE SUPPLY RELATIONSHIPS TO SCALE THE
13:18 GPU'S. BECAUSE OF THE SUPPLY DEMAND
13:23 MISMATCH, NVIDIA HAD AN ADVANTAGE WITH THE WAY THEY KIND
13:27 OF WRAPPED UP THEIR CAPACITY WITH TSMC AND OTHERS.
13:30 I THINK YOU NEED SOMEONE LIKE THAT AT THE HELM FOR NVIDIA TO
13:35 BE ABLE TO SUSTAIN THAT KIND OF MOMENTUM.
13:36 THEY WILL HAVE A QUARTER WHERE THEY WILL HAVE 109 BILLION
13:40 DOLLARS OF REVENUE. THAT IS A CONSENSUS NUMBER.
13:43 AND THEY WILL PROBABLY BEAT THAT.
13:45 BUT, TO KEEP THAT MOMENTUM GOING, YOU NEED A LOT OF THINGS
13:51 TO GO RIGHT ALONG WITH THE PRODUCT ROADMAP.
13:54 I THINK IT WILL BE HARD FOR SOMEONE TO COME IN AND EXECUTE
13:55 LIKE THAT. ISABELLE: TO THOSE JUST JOINING
14:00 US, JENSEN HUANG HAS RESIGNED FROM HIS POST AS CEO OF NVIDIA.
14:08 COLLETTE KRESS WAS NAMED INTERIM CEO.
14:09 JENSEN HUANG IS ONE OF THE FOUNDERS OF NVIDIA AND HE'S BEEN
14:12 UNDER INTENSE SCRUTINY SINCE WE FOUND OUT ABOUT THIS ALLEGED
14:15 AFFAIR WITH A SPY. WHAT DOES WASHINGTON KNOW ABOUT
14:16 THIS? WE KNOW JENSEN HUANG HAS CLOSE
14:23 TIES TO THE PRESIDENT AND IT REMAINS TO BE SEEN WHAT THAT
14:25 RELATIONSHIP WILL BE LIKE. THIS COMES AHEAD OF THE TRUMP
14:27 MEETING NEXT WEEK. MIKE: IT'S A GREAT QUESTION.
14:32 IT IS ONE WE ARE REPORTING RIGHT NOW.
14:35 IT IS UNCLEAR HOW MUCH OF A BRIEFING THEY ARE GETTING IN
14:39 REAL TIME AS THE BOARD WAS MEETING.
14:41 THE ADMINISTRATION WAS AWARE OF SOME OF THE INTERACTIONS THAT
14:45 JENSEN HUANG HAD WITH THE MEGASPEED EXECUTIVE WHO IS NOW
14:50 SUSPECTED OF BEING A CHINESE SPY.
14:52 AND ACCORDING TO OUR EXCLUSIVE REPORTING FROM COLLEAGUES IN
14:56 ASIA, SHE IS NOW IN BEIJING WITH THE GOVERNMENT'S KNOWLEDGE.
15:01 IT ADDS A WHOLE NEW WRINKLE TO THE RELATIONSHIP WITH CHINA.
15:05 THEN AGAIN, THERE IS THE RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN PRESIDENT
15:07 DONALD TRUMP AND JENSEN HUANG. WE HAVE SEEN IT PLAY OUT SO
15:09 PUBLICLY. THEY HAD REALLY DEVELOPED THIS
15:12 BOND. AND CLEARLY, IT IS BEING TESTED
15:16 BY THIS MOMENT. THE PRESIDENT ON MONDAY, THE DAY
15:21 AFTER THE ALLEGATIONS SURFACED AND JENSEN HUANG ADMITTED TO THE
15:24 AFFAIR, THE PRESIDENT ACTUALLY SAID DURING A BRIEFING WITH
15:29 REPORTERS THAT HE FELT SOME SYMPATHY FOR JENSEN HUANG,
15:31 CALLED HIM A VERY HONORABLE MAN. BUT THE SAME TIME, HE NOTED
15:37 THERE WAS AN -- AT THE SAME TIME, HE NOTED THERE WAS AN FBI
15:40 INVESTIGATION HAPPENING WITHOUT ELABORATING.
15:43 THIS WILL RUPTURE WHATEVER HAS TRANSPIRED TO BRING JENSEN AND
15:49 THE COMPANY VERY CLOSE TO THE ADMINISTRATION.
15:51 LIKEWISE, WE COULD SEE RIPPLE EFFECTS FOR OTHER TECH COMPANIES
15:55 AS WELL THAT HAVE SOUGHT TO REALLY INGRATIATE THEMSELVES
15:58 WITH THE PRESIDENT AND SEEK SOME PAPER WHEN IT COMES TO
16:00 POLICYMAKING. NOW IN THE WAKE OF THE ELECTION
16:02 AND IN THE WAKE OF WHAT JUST HAPPENED AT NVIDIA, WE COULD
16:04 REALLY SEE A CHANGE IN THE WEATHER THERE.
16:09 VONNIE: ISABELLE MENTIONED A CHANGE IN THE WEATHER.
16:13 S&P FUTURES ARE LOWER BUT NOT QUITE BY AS MUCH, DOWN 7/10 OF A
16:21 PERCENT AS WE SEE NVIDIA DETERIORATING.
16:22 IT HAD BEEN LOWER ALL MORNING AFTER REPORTS CAME OUT LAST
16:24 NIGHT. THE RESIGNATION OF JENSEN HUANG
16:26 HAS SENT NVIDIA DOWN 12% PREMARKET.
16:30 MICHAEL, LET ME STAY WITH YOU AND ASK YOU, THIS EXPOSES OTHER
16:32 MEMBERS OF THE MINISTRATION AS WELL.
16:36 IN SOME WAYS, WE ARE GETTING A DRIP DRIP OF REPORTS ABOUT HOW
16:39 THE COMMERCE DEPARTMENT MAY HAVE BEEN INVOLVED.
16:44 HOW THE GENERAL COUNSEL AT NVIDIA MIGHT HAVE BEEN MAKING
16:45 INQUIRIES. WE DON'T KNOW WHERE THEY WILL
16:49 ALL END UP YET, DO WE? MIKE: THE LAST RADIUS FROM ALL
16:54 OF THIS IS STILL UNKNOWN BUT IT IS WIDENING.
16:56 I'M GLAD YOU BROUGHT UP THE COMMERCE DEPARTMENT BECAUSE THEY
17:00 ARE THE AGENCY THAT OVERSEES U.S. EXPORT CONTROLS.
17:03 THEY HAVE COME UNDER A HARSH CRITICISM FOR FAILING TO
17:07 EXERCISE THAT AUTHORITY IN DO FASHION.
17:09 THERE ARE CONCERNS RAISED BY A NUMBER OF LAWMAKERS THAT NVIDIA
17:15 HAS BEEN USING ITS WAY AND INFLUENCING THROUGH PRESIDENT
17:17 DONALD TRUMP AND OTHER SENIOR OFFICIALS TO STYMIE
17:19 INVESTIGATIONS AND SLOW THE ENACTMENT OF ADDITIONAL EXPORT
17:20 CONTROL POLICIES. YOU BROUGHT UP THE INTERVENTION
17:25 OF THE NVIDIA GENERAL COUNSEL. TIM TEETER HAD CALLED THE HEAD
17:33 OF THE EXPORT CONTROL AGENCY, JEFFREY KESSLER, TO INQUIRE
17:35 ABOUT WHETHER HIS AGENCY, HIS BUREAU HAD SOMEHOW INTERVENED.
17:50 VIS HAD NO ROLE WE ARE TOLD. BUT NONETHELESS, IT PUT A CHILL
17:55 ON CONGRESS'S INVESTIGATION OF MEGASPEED AND POSSIBLE EXPORT
17:57 CONTROL VIOLATIONS. THE JUSTICE DEPARTMENT IS
17:59 LEADING THAT PROBE NOW. IT REALLY DOES EXPOSE HOWARD
18:03 LUTNICK, THE COMMERCE SECRETARY AND OTHER SENIOR OFFICIALS TO
18:06 REALLY INTENSE QUESTIONS, NOT ONLY WITHIN THE ADMINISTRATION
18:11 BUT FOR LAWMAKERS THEMSELVES ABOUT THEIR CONDUCT AND THEIR
18:13 EXERCISE OF EXPORT CONTROLS AND IT RAISES THE QUESTION ABOUT
18:17 UP FOR LOST GROUND. ISABELLE: MANDY, HOW MUCH DO YOU
18:24 THINK NVIDIA'S CIRCULAR FINANCE AND ECOSYSTEM, ITS CUSTOMERS AND
18:27 AI INFRASTRUCTURE COMPANIES REFLECT JENSEN HUANG'S PERSONAL
18:32 VISION AND DO YOU THINK I COULD CHANGE UNDER NEW LEADERSHIP?
18:35 MANDEEP: ABSOLUTELY. THAT WAS A KEY PART OF HOW
18:41 JENSEN WANTED THE AI SYSTEM TO BE MORE FRAGMENTED -- ECOSYSTEM
18:46 TO BE MORE FRAGMENTED THAN THE THREE HYPERSCALERS.
18:54 HE WAS VERY KEEN ON BUILDING A LONG TAIL OF GPU PROVIDERS WHICH
18:57 IS WHY THE NEO-CLOUDS HAD DONE SO WELL.
19:00 OBVIOUSLY, NVIDIA WAS FUNDING A LOT OF THESE COMPANIES.
19:05 CLEARLY THAT WAS AT THE TOP OF HIS MIND WHEN IT COMES TO THAT
19:09 STRATEGY. ANYBODY KNEW WHO IS COMING IN,
19:13 EVEN IF IT'S AN INTERNAL CANDIDATE, THEY SAY -- THEY MAY
19:18 WANT TO PURSUE A DIFFERENT STRATEGY OVER THERE.
19:23 OPEN SOURCE AND NEO-CLOUDS ARE THE TWO SORT OF STRATEGIES THAT
19:28 AT. VONNIE: JENSEN HUANG HAS BUSY
19:36 TIMES I HAD IN DEALING WITH ALL OF THIS.
19:39 IF HE WERE TO WANT TO WORK IN THE INDUSTRY AGAIN, AND WE DON'T
19:44 HAVE ANYTHING HANGING OVER HIM CONGRESSIONALLY, CAN HE DO SO?
19:48 ENDEAVOR? MANDEEP: HE COULD BUT I DOUBT HE
19:54 IS GOING TO GO THAT WAY, SIMPLY BECAUSE I'M SURE HE IS VERY
20:00 PROUD OF THE FACT, GIVEN WHERE NVIDIA IS IN TERMS OF MARKET CAP
20:05 AND THEIR POSITIONING AS A COMPANY.
20:08 I WOULD BE VERY SURPRISED IF YOU WERE TO GO THE START OF ROUTE OR
20:13 JOIN ELON MUSK, GIVEN WHAT HE HAS ACCOMPLISHED AS A FOUNDER OF
20:15 A COMPANY AND WHERE NVIDIA IS THAT.
20:19 ISABELLE: I WANT TO BRING YOU BACK IN, ED.
20:21 THE TIMING CANNOT BE MORE CONSEQUENTIAL.
20:23 AI TRADE IS FRAGILE. HOW DO YOU THINK THE FUTURE OF
20:28 THE AI INDUSTRY WILL LOOK LIKE WHEN YOU TALK TO YOUR SOURCES
20:30 WITH NVIDIA, UNDER A NEW LEADERSHIP?
20:34 AND WELCOME BACK, BY THE WAY. ED: NVIDIA'S EARNINGS WILL GO
20:40 AHEAD AS SCHEDULED NEXT WEEK ON TUESDAY.
20:44 GOING INTO THIS, RUN THE REPORTS LAST NIGHT CAME OUT THAT THE
20:47 BOARD WAS CONSIDERING OUSTING JENSEN HUANG, LOOKING AT
20:53 EXTERNAL CANDIDATES ACROSS RESEARCH, PEOPLE POINTED OUT
20:56 THAT THE CHANGE IN THE HERE AND NOW WOULD NOT IMPACT THE NEXT
21:00 FISCAL YEAR OR EVEN THE NEXT TWO FISCAL YEARS.
21:02 MAYBE THERE WILL BE A REASSESSMENT OF THAT.
21:05 THE BIG ONE FOR ME IS ANTHROPIC'S IPO.
21:08 YOU KNOW, THE MARKET IN THE MOMENT, ONE SESSION OF THE
21:14 MARKET DOES NOT MAKE. NVIDIA IS THE TECHNOLOGICAL
21:19 UNDERPINNING OF MANY OF THE GENERATIONS OF ALL THE ANTHROPIC
21:27 HAS TRAIN. IT'S A FAIR QUESTION.
21:31 I DON'T THINK ANYONE THINK THE CREDIT RATING OF THIS COMPANY
21:34 WILL CHANGE OVERNIGHT. THE WHOLE POINT OF HAVING
21:42 CEO COLLETTE KRESS STAY IN THE INTERIM CEO ROLE IS NOT JUST
21:44 CONTINUITY, THAT'S HER JOB. THE FINANCES OF THIS COMPANY.
21:48 IT'S AMAZING, I KEEP GLANCING DOWN AT THE SCREEN FOR THAT
21:50 REASON. THAT THE SELLOFF IS ACCELERATED
21:53 10 MINUTES AHEAD OF THE MARKET OPEN.
21:56 VONNIE: WE WILL SEE HOW IT DOES OPEN IN THE FIRST FEW
22:00 MINUTES OF THE TRADE. A LITTLE BIT OF DETERIORATION
22:04 NOW THAT WE HAVE CONFIRMATION JENSEN HUANG HAS RESIGNED.
22:06 GO MAKE SOME CALLS AND LOOK AT SOME NUMBERS AND COME BACK TO
22:08 US. THAT IS ED LUDLOW, MANDEEP SINGH
22:12 AND MICHAEL SHEPARD. NVIDIA IT WAS DOWN ALMOST 13% IN
22:17 THE PREMARKET. NASDAQ FUTURES ARE DOWN 1.4
22:19 PERCENT. S&P FUTURES ARE DOWN 7/10 OF 1%.
22:24 YOU HAVE TO IMAGINE THERE WILL BE SOME SELLING AT SOME POINT,
22:27 GIVEN THAT JENSEN HUANG IS OUT OF THE SEAT AND THERE ARE BIG
22:31 QUESTIONS SURROUNDING GOVERNANCE AND WHAT'S NEXT FOR NVIDIA.
22:34 THE NEXT BIG CATALYST IS THE ANTHROPIC IPO.
22:38 BLOOMBERG TECH REPORTER RYAN REPORTS THE IPO WILL GIVE
22:42 INVESTORS A CRUCIAL LOOK AT THE HEALTH OF THE ARTIFICIAL
22:44 INTELLIGENCE INDUSTRY. RYAN JOINS US NOW.
22:49 RYAN, A 10 BILLION DOLLAR INVESTMENT FROM NVIDIA.
22:53 DOES THIS NEWS TODAY CHANGE ANYTHING ABOUT NVIDIA'S
22:55 INVESTMENT IN ANTHROPIC OR THE RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN THE TWO
22:57 COMPANIES? RYAN: I THINK EVERYONE WILL BE
23:01 REEVALUATING PRETTY MUCH EVERYTHING INVOLVING THE AI
23:03 TRADE GIVEN TODAY'S NEWS. WHAT MAKES ANTHROPIC'S IPO SORT
23:08 OF UNIQUE AND SO HOTLY ANTICIPATED IS THAT THIS IS THE
23:15 FIRST PURE PLAY AI LAB TO BE GOING PUBLIC.
23:17 THIS IS SOMETHING OF A BLACK BOX FOR INVESTORS.
23:19 PEOPLE HAVE BEEN VERY INTERESTED TO LEARN WHAT THEIR COSTS LOOK
23:21 LIKE AND THEIR REVENUE GROWTH LOOKS LIKE AND WHAT THE
23:24 PROJECTIONS ARE FOR FUTURE GROWTH.
23:28 A LOT OF THE AI TRADE HAS BEEN HINGING ON THIS IPO GOING WELL
23:32 AND HAVING ANTHROPIC REASSURE INVESTORS THAT THESE MAJOR LABS
23:36 CAN BE PROFITABLE, HIGH-GROWTH COMPANIES.
23:39 BECAUSE THAT WILL HELP SPEAK TO THE DURABILITY OF THE OVERALL AI
23:43 SPENDING TRADE AND THE OVERALL SPENDING OUTLOOK.
23:46 SOMETHING THAT I THINK IS NOW UNDER INCREASED QUESTION,
23:47 FOLLOWING THIS MORNING'S NEWS. ISABELLE: EXACTLY.
23:52 YOU HAD A GREAT STORY SAYING ANTHROPIC IS THE JANE DOE BLOCK
23:55 HOLDING UP THIS AI TRADE. DO YOU SEE PULLBACK IN SENTIMENT
23:58 AND OPTIMISM BECAUSE OF TODAY'S HEADLINES, ESPECIALLY WITH
24:02 NVIDIA'S JENSEN HUANG OUT AT HIS COMPANY?
24:08 MANDEEP: IF YOU TAKE IT -- RYAN: IF YOU TAKE A STEP OUT, WE
24:14 HAVE AT INCREASED CONCERNS ABOUT MAJOR HYPERSCALERS OF ALPHABET,
24:17 META AND AMAZON WITH THEIR NEGATIVE CASH FLOW AS THEY
24:19 INVEST IN AI. THERE IS SKEPTICISM ABOUT HOW
24:22 LONG THEY WILL BE ABLE TO MAINTAIN THIS LEVEL OF
24:23 INVESTMENT. ON TOP OF THAT, YOU HAVE THE
24:26 MIDTERM ELECTIONS WHICH FEATURED VICTORIES BY PEOPLE WHO HAD
24:30 CALLED FOR DATA CENTER MORATORIUMS.
24:32 THAT FURTHER CLOUDS THE OUTLOOK FOR AI SPENDING.
24:35 ON TOP OF THAT, YOU HAVE THE NUMBER ONE HYPE MAN FOR AI, OUT
24:42 AT THE MOST INFLUENTIAL COMPANY OF THE PAST DECADE.
24:47 THE OUTLOOK HAS BEEN COMPLETELY UP AND IT COMPARED TO WHAT
24:49 PEOPLE WERE ANTICIPATING A FEW MONTHS AGO AND THAT DOES HAVE
24:52 PEOPLE SCROUNGING AROUND, TRYING TO FIND SOMETHING SOLID TO LAND
24:55 ON, IN TERMS OF WHERE THIS TRAIT CAN GO FROM HERE.
25:00 IT SEEMS LIKE ANTHROPIC, WE HAVE RESULTS FROM NVIDIA NEXT WEEK.
25:02 I'M NOT SURE HOW RELEVANT THIS PAST QUARTER IS GOING TO BE
25:04 RELATIVE TO EVERYTHING THAT'S HAPPENED THIS MORNING BUT IT
25:08 SEEMS LIKE PEOPLE ARE LOOKING TO ANTHROPIC AS THIS VALIDATING
25:10 DATA POINT FOR HOW STRONG IS THE AI TRADE RIGHT NOW AND WHAT IS
25:13 THE GROWTH OUTLOOK FROM HERE? MAYBE THAT IS SOMETHING THAT
25:19 PEOPLE CAN USE AS SORT OF A WAY FOR TRADE TO MOVE ON AFTER THE
25:22 VOLATILITY WE HAVE SEEN. ISABELLE: I THINK PEOPLE WILL BE
25:27 MORE TUNED IN. JOINING US NOW IS SCOTT.
25:33 WE KNOW THAT YOU RAISE YOUR PRICE TARGET TO $8,100 FOR THE
25:38 S&P 500. WE HAVE TO ASK ABOUT NVIDIA,
25:40 WHAT DO YOU THINK ABOUT THE RECENT DEVELOPMENTS AND DO YOU
25:42 THINK THIS WILL THROW A WRENCH INTO YOUR PRICE TARGET?
25:47 SCOTT: WE PUT THE 8100 TARGET ON AND A LOT HAS TRANSPIRED SINCE
25:49 THEN IN JUNE. WE THINK THERE IS STILL A PATH
25:52 FOR A YEAR END RALLY. GETTING TO THE 8100 LEVEL
25:56 SPECIFICALLY IS LOOKING LIKE A STRETCH.
25:59 WHEN WE LOOK AT THE S&P 500, YOU NEED BOTH HALVES OF THE INDEX
26:01 WORKING. YOU NEED THE AI INFLUENCE COHORT
26:04 AS WELL AS THE REST OF THE INDEX.
26:08 WE ARE GETTING SOME HELP ON THE REST OF THE INDEX.
26:12 WE DO HAVE TO UPSET THAT WITH NAGGING FED CONCERNS.
26:15 AS FAR AS THE AI TRADE, OBVIOUSLY WE ARE GOING THROUGH
26:18 SOME TALL RIGHT NOW. I THINK UNDER THE SURFACE, WHAT
26:21 WE WOULD SAY IS IF THERE IS SOMETHING YOU WANT TO HANG YOUR
26:24 HAT ON, YOU ARE STILL LOOKING AT A VERY FAVORABLE DEMAND FOR AI
26:27 COMPUTE VERSUS SUPPLY. SO ULTIMATELY, WHILE WE HAVE TO
26:33 NAVIGATE A LOT OF THESE CONCERNS, WHICH ARE VERY
26:36 LEGITIMATE, VERY PREMATURE, AT THE SAME TIME, IT'S SAFE TO SAY
26:41 THE AI TRADE IS IN STRUCTURAL JEOPARDY.
26:44 VONNIE: YOU MAY NOT WANT TO COMMENT ON ONE PARTICULAR
26:47 COMPANY BUT AT THE SAME TIME, NVIDIA IS MORE THAN 5% OF MANY
26:51 FUNDS. DO YOU SEE A SITUATION WHERE
26:53 THERE WOULD BE SOME FORCED SELLING, GIVEN SOME CLAUSES THAT
26:57 FUNDS HAVE TO ABIDE BY? SCOTT: IT'S A REALLY GOOD
27:00 QUESTION. I THINK THE GOVERNANCE ISSUE
27:03 WILL COME UP. THERE PROBABLY WILL BE SOME --
27:10 INTO HOW YOU THINK ABOUT SELLING.
27:11 THE PREPONDERANCE OF FUNDS THAT HAVE A VERY STRICT ESG RELATING
27:16 TO THE GOVERNANCE OVERLAY IS LESS NOW THAN IT WAS A FEW YEARS
27:17 AGO. I THINK YOU CERTAINLY CAN'T
27:22 DISCOUNT THAT THAT IS A POTENTIAL RISK AS WE GO FORWARD
27:25 OVER THE NEXT MONTH, COUPLE OF MONTHS, THAT SORT OF THING.
27:29 BUT WHETHER AND HOW IT CHANGES THE LONGER-TERM TRAJECTORY OF
27:35 THE COMPANY AS WELL AS THE AGGREGATE AI PLAYBOOK IS STILL
27:40 REMAINING TO BE SEEN. AS IMPORTANT TO ALL OF THIS IS
27:44 GOING TO BE HOW WE WORK THROUGH POLITICAL PUSHBACK ON DATA
27:46 CENTER CONSTRUCTION, WHICH WE KNOW ULTIMATELY IS A SOURCE OF
27:51 DEMAND FOR CHIPS. ISABELLE: I GUESS AT THE HEART
27:57 OF THIS IS CONFIDENCE AT THE AI SUPER CYCLE.
28:00 SEVERAL ANALYSTS HAVE MADE THE POINT THAT JUST BECAUSE JENSEN
28:03 HUANG GOES AWAY DOESN'T MEAN THE TECHNOLOGY WOULD.
28:04 THE TECHNOLOGY IS STILL THERE BUT INVESTOR MAY -- INVESTORS
28:09 HAVE TO CONSIDER WHETHER AI HAS MORE RUNWAY FROM HERE ON OUT.
28:14 SCOTT: I THINK THIS IS ALL FAIR. WHAT I WILL FALL BACK ON, AS FAR
28:22 AS WE CAN SEE, THE CURRENT DEMAND FOR AI COMPUTE IS STRONG.
28:26 AND IF ANYTHING, GETTING STRONGER.
28:28 WE HAVE ALREADY BEEN NAVIGATING A COURSE HERE WHERE HOW MUCH
28:33 CONFIDENCE YOU WANT TO PUT IN CAPEX PROJECTIONS OUT TO THE END
28:36 OF THE DECADE, AROUND AI DATA CENTER BUILDOUT, THIS IS
28:40 SOMETHING WE HAVE BEEN TALKING ABOUT FOR A WHILE NOW.
28:42 WE HAVE SAID WE ARE FAIRLY COMFORTABLE, THAT THE MARKET HAS
28:46 ALREADY BEEN PRICING IN 26 AND PROBABLY 27 FUNDAMENTALS.
28:49 BUT YOU STILL HAVE THIS OPEN QUESTION MARK IN TERMS OF WHAT
28:55 THE 2028 TO 2030 TRAJECTORY LOOKS LIKE.
28:57 WHEN YOU STEP BACK AND LOOK AT THE AGGREGATE SEMI CONDUCTOR
29:01 INDUSTRY GROUP, YOU HAVE ALREADY SEEN FAIRLY NOTABLE COMPRESSION.
29:05 WE SAW THAT DURING Q3. IT HAS NOW CONTINUED INTO Q4.
29:10 WHAT IS HAPPENING IS IMPLICITLY THE MARKET IS RIGHTSIZING
29:12 EXPECTATIONS HERE. WHAT YOU HAVE TO REMEMBER, I
29:17 KNOW THERE IS A WHOLE OTHER STORY IN TERMS OF FINANCING THAT
29:21 BUILDOUT. BUT, THE SEMI CONDUCTORS SPACE
29:26 IN GENERAL IS A NET BENEFICIARY IN TERMS OF THE LONGER-TERM
29:29 PLAYBOOK FOR AI CONTINUING TO LOOK PRETTY DECENT.
29:33 VONNIE: JUST BRIEFLY, IF NVIDIA HAS TO BECOME A LITTLE MORE RISK
29:36 AVERSE AND LEAST IN THE NEAR TERM AT LEAST IN MAKING DEALS,
29:43 DETRIMENT? SCOTT: IT'S A GOOD QUESTION.
29:48 I THINK IT CERTAINLY, THIS HAS BEEN A POSTER CHILD.
29:52 BUT ALSO, IF YOU LOOK AT THE FREE CASH GENERATION COMING OUT
29:55 OF THIS COMPANY RIGHT NOW, IT'S LIKE NOTHING WE HAVE EVER SEEN.
29:58 THE BUSINESS MODEL IS STILL A SOUND BUSINESS MODEL.
30:02 ALWAYS RAMPANT. BUT, I THINK WHAT YOU HAVE TO
30:08 STEP BACK AND LOOK AT THIS AND SAY OK, WE HAVE A FAIRLY COMPANY
30:11 UNIQUE SITUATION THAT WILL BE NAVIGATED.
30:14 I DON'T KNOW WHAT THE OUTCOME OF ALL OF THIS IS GOING TO BE.
30:17 BUT IN TERMS OF THE UNDERLYING SUPPLY AND DEMAND, I THINK WE
30:19 ARE IN GOOD SHAPE. VONNIE: SCOTT IS STAYING WITH
30:24 US. THERE ARE THE OPENING BELLS.
30:27 THEY OPEN TODAY JUST LIKE ANY OTHER DAY EVEN THOUGH AN
30:30 EARTHQUAKE HAS HIT THE SILICON VALLEY AND THE REST OF THE AI
30:32 UNIVERSE. NASDAQ 100 FUTURES DOWN 1.5
30:37 PERCENT AS NVIDIA DROPPED 13% PLUS BEFORE THE OPEN ON THE NEWS
30:42 OF JENSEN HUANG'S RESIGNATION. AN APPOINTMENT, HARVEY JONES.
30:50 COLLETTE KRESS IS TAKING OVER ON AN INTERIM BASIS FROM JENSEN
30:50 HUANG. ISABELLE: SOME STOCKS TO WATCH,
30:56 THERE IS ONLY ONE AND THAT IS NVIDIA.
31:01 SHARES ARE LOWER BY 13% -- MORE THAN 13%.
31:03 JENSEN HUANG'S RESIGNATION RIPPLING.
31:07 ALSO, QUESTIONS ABOUT U.S. LEADERSHIP AND AI AND THE TIMING
31:10 AND CANNOT BE MORE CONSEQUENTIAL.
31:16 AND NOW INVESTORS HAVE TO CONTEMPLATE A FUTURE WITHOUT
31:18 NVIDIA LEADING IT. VONNIE: JENSEN HUANG'S
31:27 RESIGNATION RIPPLING THROUGH TRADE ALREADY.
31:31 COREWEAVE IS DOWN 16.5% TODAY. TALK ABOUT A VOLATILE NAME.
31:34 ALIBABA CAUGHT UP IN ALL OF THIS CREATE FOR ITS OWN REASONS,
31:40 IT IS DOWN 6%. YOU DON'T LIKE TO POINT TO
31:46 ANYONE BENEFITING FROM, YOU KNOW, DIFFICULT EVENTS.
31:49 BUT CERTAINLY, BROADCOM AND AMD AREN'T GOING TO SIT ON THIS
31:50 NEWS. BROADCOM ALREADY UP 3% PRAY
31:54 LET'S DISCUSS THIS WITH ED LUDLOW.
32:03 THIS IS PROBABLY ONE OF THE REASONS WHY THEY GOT OUT SO
32:05 QUICKLY. GIVE US THE LAY OF THE LAND IN
32:08 TERMS OF WHO IS READY TO GO AFTER SOME MARKET SHARE.
32:13 ED: IN TERMS OF THE MARKET REACTION, THIS DROP BY NVIDIA IS
32:14 SEVERE. IT'S ON TRACK TO BE LARGEST
32:23 ONE-DAY DECLINE SINCE JANUARY OF 2025.
32:27 IT IS NOW A SUB FOR TRILLION DOLLAR MARKET CAP COMPANY.
32:30 -- $4 TRILLION MARKET CAP COMPANY.
32:35 SOME OF THOSE SPECIALIZED PLATFORMS CLOSE THE GAP.
32:41 THE RUNNING OF MODELS. IT IS A VERY SMALL PLAYER.
32:46 IN TERMS OF PERCENTAGE OF MARK OR DOLLAR TERMS.
32:48 AMD AND BROADCOM ARE INTERESTING.
32:53 YOU GUYS HAD MANDEEP OF BLOOMBERG INTELLIGENCE ON
32:57 EARLIER. HE SEES TPU.
32:59 WHERE CUSTOMERS ARE LOOKING TO DIVERSIFY THEIR COMPUTE.
33:03 SYSTEMS. LIMERICK INTELLIGENCE'S HOUSE
33:07 CALL IS THEY WILL MAKE A DECISION BECAUSE JENSEN HUANG IS
33:11 GONE TO DIVERSIFY THAT, GOOGLE WOULD BE THE MAIN BENEFICIARY.
33:14 THAT IS ALREADY REFLECTED WITH TRADE.
33:21 IT'S A PRETTY NEGATIVE REACTION FROM MARKETS AND THE AD TRADE
33:22 OVERALL. ISABELLE: ABSOLUTELY A NEGATIVE
33:25 REACTION. NVIDIA IS SET TO RAISE NEARLY
33:28 600 BILLION DOLLARS IN MARKET VALUE.
33:32 IS IT MORE PERSONAL THAN INVESTORS REALIZE?
33:36 JENSEN HAS SPENT DECADES CULTIVATING THIS NEW SET.
33:40 HE'S TALKING TO LEADERS ACROSS THE WORLD, ASIA, EUROPE,
33:43 EVERYWHERE, TALKING TO THE HIGHEST OF THE HIGHS WHEN IT
33:46 COMES TO GOVERNMENT LEADERSHIP AND COMPANY LEADERSHIP.
33:48 COULD A SUCCESSOR COMMAND THE SAME LOYALTY AND STAMINA AS
33:50 JENSEN HUANG? ED: THAT'S WHERE THE TWO PIECES
33:56 OF NEWS WHICH ARE COLLETTE KRESS, THE CFO BECOMING INTERIM
34:00 CEO BUT ALSO HARVEY C JONES BECOMING CHAIRMAN OF THE BOARD
34:03 IS IMPORTANT. ITS CONTINUITY.
34:05 HARVEY C JONES HAS BEEN A DIRECTOR ON THE BOARD SINCE 1990
34:09 THREE. THIS INSTITUTIONAL KNOWLEDGE AND
34:10 FAMILIARITY IN THERE. I THINK A LOT OF THE CELLS HI
34:23 POINT TO THAT -- SELL HIGH POINTS TO THAT.
34:28 WHAT CHANGES MATERIALLY WHEN THEY REPORT EARNINGS NEXT WEEK
34:30 IN THE HERE AND NOW? PROBABLY NOT MUCH.
34:34 AS JENSEN HUANG SPENT SO MUCH TIME EXPLAINING, WHEN YOU COMMIT
34:38 TO BUILDING AI INFRASTRUCTURE THAT USES NVIDIA GEAR, YOU MAKE
34:40 THAT DECISION MANY YEARS IN ADVANCE.
34:44 JENSEN'S WHOLE POINT, THE REASON OF HIM FLYING AROUND THE WORLD
34:47 SUCH AS HE DID, TALKING TO SUPPLIERS AND CUSTOMERS WAS TO
34:49 SAY TO THEM HERE IS OUR VISION OF THE FUTURE, YOU GUYS SHOULD
34:50 GET MOVING NOW. AND WE WILL DO A POSTMORTEM ON
34:58 ALL OF THIS BUT HE WAS ALSO RIGHT ABOUT THAT.
35:00 AND PEOPLE RESPONDED BY MAKING INVESTMENT.
35:05 ISABELLE: POSTMORTEM NEEDED. BLOOMBERG'S ED LUDLOW JOINING US
35:09 AND BREAKING THAT DOWN. I JUST WANT TO READ SOME OF THE
35:12 BIG MOVES THIS MORNING. VONNIE DESCRIBED EARLIER, WE SAW
35:15 AN EARTHQUAKE WITH NVIDIA AND WE ARE SEEING NVIDIA MICRO SHARES
35:20 FALLING AT 11%. ON TRACK FOR ITS WORST DAY SINCE
35:22 JUNE. TALK TO US ABOUT THE AI TRADE.
35:27 AI HAS BEEN THE BIGGEST MARKET ENGINE.
35:27 WE ARE SEEING CONCERNS WHEN IT COMES TO DATA CENTER BUILD OUTS,
35:32 REGULATION AND POLITICAL ROADBLOCKS.
35:34 TALK TO US ABOUT WHY YOU'RE UPGRADING SEMI CONDUCTORS AND
35:36 DOWNGRADING HARDWARE. WHAT'S THE DISTINCTION IN YOUR
35:37 VIEW? SCOTT: THE WAY PLAYS OUT IS
35:46 GOING INTO Q4, -- THE FUNDAMENTALS STILL LOOKING
35:55 OUT TO 2027 ARE PROBABLY THE MOST SOLID AND VISIBLE OF ANY
35:59 PART OF THE S&P RIGHT NOW. THE VALUATIONS HAVE COME DOWN
36:02 NOTABLY AS I SAID. THE PROFITABILITY COMPONENTS
36:07 CONTINUE TO LOOK TERRIFIC. WHEN YOU STEP BACK AND LOOK AT
36:09 ALL OF THE TRADITIONAL INPUTS THAT NORMALLY YOU BASE
36:14 INVESTMENT DECISIONS ON AND LOOK AT IT ACROSS THE S&P 500, THE
36:17 SEMI CONDUCTORS KIND OF STAND OUT.
36:21 BEING OBVIOUSLY TESTED FOR A WHOLE BUNCH OF GOVERNANCE RACES
36:24 RIGHT NOW, UNDERLYING FUNDAMENTAL UNDERPINNING GOING
36:28 INTO 2027 IS STILL IN VERY GOOD SHAPE.
36:31 HARDWARE IS THE OTHER SIDE OF THIS.
36:33 TO THE DEGREE THAT YOU ARE PAYING MORE FOR COMMODITY,
36:39 WHETHER IT IS D RAM OR OTHER FORMS OF MEMORY, WHAT ENDS UP
36:43 HAPPENING HERE IS THAT THE HARDWARE COMPONENT IS AT A BIT
36:49 MORE MARGIN RISK IF YOU WILL, BECAUSE OF THE COST PRESSURES
36:53 FROM THE SEMI AND RELATED COMPONENTS.
36:55 THAT I THINK IS SORT OF THE KEY POINT HERE.
36:57 SOFTWARE IS THE OTHER PIECE OF THIS.
36:59 LET'S NOT FORGET SOFTWARE WITHIN TECH.
37:02 IT'S AT THIS POINT MORE OR LESS IN A NEUTRAL POSITION, WHERE IT,
37:08 WHAT DOES IT NEED? IT WANTS TO KNOW THAT HE CAN USE
37:11 AI TO ITS OWN BENEFIT. BUT, YOU ALSO WANT A PATH FOR
37:15 THE SOFTWARE COMPANIES WHERE UNLIKE THE BEGINNING OF THE
37:18 YEAR, WE ARE NOT AS CONCERNED ABOUT THEIR EXISTENTIAL RISK
37:27 BECAUSE OF THE WAY THAT AI WAS PERCEIVED BACK THEN TO REALLY
37:29 PERMEATE THE LANDSCAPE. WITHIN LARGE CAP, WE HAVE THREE
37:33 MOVING PARTS HERE. THAT ALL KIND OF HAVE THEIR OWN
37:36 NUANCES. SO, IT'S NOT ONE AI TRADE
37:38 ANYMORE. IT IS SEVERAL DIFFERENT TRADES.
37:44 VONNIE: I WANT TO MENTION THERE IS AN IMPROVEMENT, THE NASDAQ
37:48 100 IS WELL OFF ITS LOWS AND NVIDIA IS NOW DOWN JUST A .5%.
37:54 IT KEEPS AN EYE ON THE AI TRADE. DOES IT NEED TO TAKE INTO
37:58 ACCOUNT SOMEHOW THIS RESIGNATION AND WHAT MIGHT THE MARKET
38:01 REPERCUSSIONS BE BEFORE ITS NEXT MEETING?
38:07 SCOTT: THAT'S A GOOD QUESTION. THERE HAS BEEN A LOT OF CHATTER
38:11 THIS WEEK THAT PERHAPS THE FED GIVES US 50 BASIS POINTS,
38:14 ADDITIONAL RATE HIKE IN DECEMBER.
38:18 WE HAVE BEEN PRETTY COMFORTABLE THAT WE CAN GET 25 BASIS POINTS
38:22 AND THAT MAY SIGNAL THE END OF THE FED RATE HIKES FOR NOW.
38:27 IF YOU LOOK BACK AT IT, ONE OF THE STORYLINES WE NEED TO
38:31 KEEP AN EYE ON IS, I GET IT, INFLATION AND THE MIDDLE EAST
38:33 AND IRAN. BUT IT'S ALSO THE IMPORTANCE OF
38:36 THE AI SPENDING TO AGGREGATE GDP GROWTH.
38:39 WHAT YOU'RE LOOKING AT RIGHT NOW IS A CIRCUMSTANCE WHERE, IF YOU
38:43 ARE LOOKING AT 2.8% GDP GROWTH THIS YEAR, ECONOMISTS WILL VARY.
38:49 LET'S SAY A PERCENTAGE POINT OF THAT IS COMING FROM THE AI
38:51 TRADE. YOU HAVE TO BE A LITTLE CAREFUL
38:54 HERE THAT IF YOU DO SEE ENOUGH PUSHBACK ON THE AI TRADE, AT
39:00 SOME LEVEL, IT BEGINS TO DAMAGE YOUR ECONOMIC GROWTH OUTLOOK AND
39:03 AT SOME LEVEL, AT SOME POINT IN TIME, IT COMES BACK TO THINK
39:09 ABOUT HOW WE THINK ABOUT THE FED TRAJECTORY FROM HERE.
39:13 ISABELLE: HAS YOUR VIEW OF THE FED'S RATE HIKE PATH CHANGED?
39:18 WE GOT A HOTTER THAN FORECAST CPI.
39:19 THIS IS IMPORTANT TO THE AI TRADE BECAUSE IT WILL AFFECT
39:23 TECH VALUATIONS AND IT WILL IMPACT THE AI BOOM THAT RELIES
39:26 ON ENORMOUS CAPITAL SPENDING. SCOTT: WE HAVE DUG IN ON THIS.
39:33 WHAT WE HAVE TO NAVIGATE HERE IS A TRIUMVIRATE OF OIL PRICES
39:42 LEAVING -- IN TURN LEADING RATE EXPECTATIONS.
39:49 -- SO, WE ARE TAKING SOME COMFORT
39:56 HERE THAT WE ARE SEEING OIL PRICES RETREAT.
40:00 OBVIOUSLY, THERE IS STILL A LOT OF DISCUSSION AROUND THE IRAN
40:02 CIRCUMSTANCE. BUT, IN OUR VIEW, STRUCTURALLY
40:07 UNDER THE SURFACE LONGER TERM, THAT IS A REALLY IMPORTANT
40:09 DISCUSSION POINT. SO, THE LOWER OIL PRICES GO, THE
40:15 MORE COMFORTABLE WE FEEL THAT ULTIMATELY INFLATION REIGNS IN
40:17 AND TAKES PRESSURE OFF OF THE FED.
40:20 VONNIE: IT'S ONE REASON WHY CONSUMER DISCRETIONARY IS DOING
40:22 SO WELL TODAY. IT SEEMS LIKE EVERY TIME THE AI
40:26 TRADE GOES BADLY, CONSUMER DISCRETIONARY STOCKS PICK UP
40:28 THEIR EARS. AND WE SEE MANY OF THEM IN THE
40:31 GREEN. YOU WOULD THINK THAT IF THE AI
40:35 TRADE GOES BAD, IT WOULD BE BAD FOR U.S. CONSUMERS TOO.
40:40 SCOTT: THERE IS THE COMPONENT THAT'S A LITTLE MORE NARROW,
40:45 THERE'S MORE DISCUSSION ON THIS. WHAT I KEEP COMING BACK TO IS IF
40:49 YOU LOOK AT SINCE PRESIDENT TRUMP TOOK OFFICE, THE WORST
40:56 PERFORMING SECTOR, THE S&P 500 -- WORST PERFORMING SECTOR IN
40:58 THE S&P 500 HAS BEEN CONSUMER DISCRETIONARY.
41:06 NOW YOU'RE LOOKING AT POTENTIAL UPTICKS IN INTEREST RATES.
41:10 ANYTHING THAT LESSENS THE PERCEPTION OF THOSE HEADWINDS ON
41:14 CONSUMER ACTIVITY, THAT PART OF THE MARKET WILL RESPOND
41:15 FAVORABLY. SO, WE ARE CARRYING CONSUMER
41:21 DISCRETIONARY AS AN OVERWEIGHT, A CONTRARY AND FOR SURE.
41:26 -- CONTRARIAN OVERWEIGHT FOR SURE.
41:31 WE THINK CONSUMER AND IT IS IN GOOD SHAPE AND BENEFITS FROM A
41:36 CONTINUED DECLINE IN OIL PRICES, SHOULD WE FIND SOME WAY OUT OF
41:39 THE IRAN PRESS. -- BRASS.
41:46 ISABELLE: DO YOU THINK THIS IS JUST A TEMPORARY PAUSE?
41:50 SCOTT: I THINK FOR NOW, BASED ON WHAT WE KNOW OR THINK WE KNOW,
41:53 WE HAVE TO VIEW THIS AS A TRANSITIONAL ISSUE AND A BIT
41:58 MORE TACTICAL IN NATURE. IF YOU STEP BACK, WHAT WILL
42:05 ABOUT A YEAR FROM NOW? TODAY'S NEWS WILL BE LARGELY IN
42:07 THE BACKGROUND AND IT WILL PROBABLY BE A DIFFERENT PLACE IN
42:10 TERMS OF HOW WE ARE THINKING ABOUT THE AI COMPUTE BUILDOUT.
42:17 FOR NOW, WE HAVE TO TREAT THIS AS AN ISSUE TO BE CONTENDED
42:19 WITH. MARKETS IMPACTED AS THEY SHOULD
42:23 BE, GIVEN THE CONFIDENCE THAT THIS BRINGS.
42:28 USUALLY MARKETS TEND TO SELL UNCERTAINTY AND THEY TEND TO
42:30 SELL LACK OF CONFIDENCE AND ULTIMATELY THEY ARE BUYING THE
42:36 ALLEVIATION OF SET UNCERTAINTY. WE WILL GIVE THE SOME TIME TO
42:38 PLAY OUT HERE. I DON'T THINK IT'S APPROPRIATE
42:40 TO SAY THAT THE TECH TRADE HAS -- IS DONE BY ANY MEANS
42:44 WHAT WE ARE GOING THROUGH A TRANSITIONAL PHASE.
42:51 VONNIE: SCOTT, THANK YOU SO MUCH.
42:55 MUCH APPRECIATE YOUR COMMENTS AND THANK YOU FOR JOINING US.
43:00 LET'S GET A CHECK ON THE STOCK MARKET NOW.
43:02 WERE WE ANTICIPATING THIS NEWS? MAYBE NOT EXACTLY THIS MORNING.
43:05 WE CERTAINLY SAW PREMARKET THAT THERE WAS A MASSIVE DECLINE FOR
43:07 NVIDIA SHARES. RIGHT NOW, WE ARE JUST COMING
43:11 OFF A LITTLE BIT, ARE LOWS OF THE DAY.
43:16 THAT SAID, SOME OF THE BENEFICIARIES ARE SOME OF THE
43:19 COMPANIES THAT COULD BENEFIT FROM THE RESIGNATION OF JENSEN
43:23 HUANG AND THE POTENTIAL TURMOIL THAT MIGHT COME FOR NVIDIA IN
43:26 THE NEXT FEW WEEKS. WE WILL SEE.
43:31 AT THE MOMENT, THE COMPANY -- EVERYTHING WILL CONTINUE ON AS
43:33 NORMAL. COLLETTE KRESS WILL BE THE
43:35 INTERIM CEO AND WE ARE ON IT. WE HAVE A CHAIR, HARVEY JONES,
43:40 THAT USED TO BE THE CEO OF SYNOPSYS, HAS BEEN ON BOARD FOR
43:42 A LONG TIME. HE PUT OUT A MESSAGE TO
43:46 EMPLOYEES SAYING WE VALUE YOU AND EVERYTHING SEEMS TO BE AT
43:49 LEAST LIP SERVICE IS BEING PAID TO THE FACT THAT THERE IS A BIG
43:51 PROBLEM AT NVIDIA. YOU HAVE ADVANCED MICRO DEVICES,
43:57 A COUPLE OF THE SOFTWARE COMPANIES AND OTHER HYPERSCALERS
43:58 DOING WELL AS WELL. WE TAKE A LOOK AT THE STOCKS
44:02 THAT ARE LOWER. A DIFFERENT STORY, NVIDIA LOWER
44:06 OBVIOUSLY. MANY OF THE RELATED COMPANIES AS
44:09 WELL. YOU HAVE MEMORY CHIP MAKERS LIKE
44:13 SANDISK IS LOWER BY 5%. PALO ALTO NETWORKS, THE
44:16 EQUIPMENT MAKER'S, OTHER CHIP COMPANIES LIKE INTEL, YOU ALSO
44:18 HAVE SOME OF THE HYPERSCALERS HERE ON THE SIDE OF THINGS.
44:24 THIS IS GOING TO REVERBERATE THROUGHOUT THE TRADING DAY AND
44:27 WE WILL CONTINUE TO KEEP AND I ON THE STOCKS THAT WILL MAKE IT
44:29 AND THE STOCKS THAT ARE BREAKING IT.
44:33 HOPE YOU HEARD SCOTT TALKING ABOUT CONSUMER DISCRETIONARY --
44:41 YOU HEARD SCOTT TALKING ABOUT CONSUMER DISCRETIONARY.
44:45 AS YOU MIGHT IMAGINE, INFOTECH IS LOWER.
44:47 ALL RIGHT. IT'S TIME FOR OUR TOP CALLS.
44:50 HERE IS NORAH MULINDA WITH SOME OF THE ANALYST ACTION.
44:55 >> WE ARE KEEPING AN EYE ON THE MAJOR SHIFT WHEN IT COMES TO
44:58 WALL STREET SENTIMENT AS IT RELATES TO NVIDIA.
45:01 AT LEAST SEVEN FIRMS DOWNGRADING THE STOCK THIS WEEK WITH
45:04 ANALYSTS WARNING SPECIFICALLY AS IT RELATES TO LEADERSHIP,
45:07 EXECUTION RISK AND ALL OF THIS COMING BEFORE THE NEWS WE GOT
45:11 THIS MORNING THAT JENSEN HUANG OFFICIALLY STEPPED DOWN AS CEO
45:14 WITH CFO COLLETTE KRESS TAKING OVER ON AN INTERIM BASIS.
45:19 THE STOCK TUMBLING BELOW ITS FOR TRILLION DOLLAR MARK AND HEADING
45:22 TO ITS LOWEST -- $4 TRILLION MARK AND HEADING TO ITS LOWEST
45:24 MARK SINCE JULY OF LAST YEAR. NVIDIA'S PROBLEMS COULD BE A BIG
45:30 OPPORTUNITY FOR ITS RIVAL, AMD. WILLIAM BLAIR OF GRADING THAT
45:36 STOCK. SAYING RISK REWARD HAS SHIFTED
45:37 IN ITS FAVOR. THERE IS AN OPPORTUNITY FOR AMD
45:42 AS NVIDIA DEALS WITH SCRUTINY AND A LEADERSHIP VACUUM.
45:50 FINALLY, BARCLAYS OF GRADING CLEVELAND CLIFFS TO EQUAL WEIGHT
45:51 FROM UNDERWEIGHT. THE FIRM THINKS CLEVELAND CLIFFS
45:56 IS IN A BETTER POSITION TO PAY DOWN DEBT.
45:57 THOSE ARE YOUR TOP CALLS. VONNIE: THANK YOU SO MUCH.
46:02 NORAH MULINDA CHECKING ON MARKETS.
46:05 15 MINUTES INTO THE TRADE AND WE ARE PREPARING DECLINES.
46:09 THE NASDAQ IN THE S&P 500 ARE WELL OFF OF THEIR SESSION LOWS.
46:14 NASDAQ DOWN NOT EVEN 6/10 OF -- 6/10 OF 1%.
46:22 I WANT TO POINT TO YIELDS. WE ARE UP EIGHT BASIS POINTS ON
46:25 THE TWO-YEAR. NOT TOO MUCH TO DO WITH NVIDIA
46:27 ALTHOUGH I'M SURE THE FED WILL BE WATCHING WHAT HAPPENS
46:31 THERE. 4.82 ON THE TWO YEAR YIELD AS
46:36 THE MARKET CONTINUES TO PRICE IN FASTER OR MORE INTENSE FED RATE
46:38 HIKES. WE NOW TURN TO LISA ABRAMOWICZ,
46:44 WHO IS JOINED BY ED BASTIAN, DELTA AIRLINES CEO.
46:49 LISA: THANK YOU SO MUCH. I AM HERE WITH SEBASTIAN, CEO OF
46:52 DELTA HEADLINE -- AIRLINES. IT'S AMAZING.
46:56 SOMETIMES YOU ARE IN THE HOT SEAT AND THE OIL CRISIS
46:59 DEFINITELY ASCENDED THIS MORNING BUT TECH IS REALLY THE MAIN
47:00 STORY. I'M NOT GOING TO ASK WHETHER YOU
47:05 HAVE ASKED ABOUT BEING -- WHETHER YOU HAVE BEEN ASKED
47:08 ABOUT BEING THE CEO OF NVIDIA. YOU ARE SQUARELY AT DELTA BUT IT
47:13 RAISES QUESTIONS ON THE RETURN OF INVESTMENT ON AI FOR
47:15 COMPANIES THAT ARE NOT TECHNOLOGICAL.
47:18 YOU ARE A TECHNOLOGY COMPANY WHEN IT COMES TO PLANES.
47:20 HOW MUCH ARE YOU SEEING AN ACTUAL RETURN ON INVESTMENT?
47:25 >> I THINK YOU SEE A TREMENDOUS AMOUNT OF INVESTMENT GOING INTO
47:30 NOT JUST THE TECHNOLOGY, BUT CANDIDLY AND MORE BROADLY, THE
47:35 RESOURCE CONSUMPTION, THE HYPERSCALERS, THE DATA CENTERS,
47:39 THE ENERGY, THE WATER AND THE IMPACT THAT IS HAVING ON A
47:42 LARGER LEVEL. AND YOU ASK YOURSELF HOW IS THIS
47:46 MOVIE GOING TO EVENTUALLY PLAY OUT?
47:48 AND I THINK IT WILL BE, I THINK WE ARE LEARNING.
47:53 I DON'T THINK THIS IS NECESSARILY THE RIGHT TIME TO BE
47:57 ASKING WHERE ARE THE RETURNS BUT IT'S THE RIGHT QUESTION THAT WE
48:02 HAVE TO BE MINDFUL OF IN ORDER TO GOVERN HOW DEEP INTO THIS YOU
48:03 WANT TO GET. LISA: HAVE YOU PULLED BACK SOME
48:09 OF YOUR AI SPENDING BECAUSE YOU CAN'T PUT A RETURN ON INVESTMENT
48:10 NUMBER? >> WE HAVEN'T.
48:16 BUT WHAT WE HAVE DONE IS BEEN VERY CAUTIOUS AS WE HAVE STEPPED
48:17 INTO IT. WE SPENT A LOT OF TIME
48:21 INTERNALLY THINKING ABOUT HOW THE TECHNOLOGY COULD AFFORD
48:24 CHANGE. THERE IS TREMENDOUS OPPORTUNITY
48:28 FOR CHANGE IN OUR INDUSTRY. BUT, WHAT IT WILL DO IS IT WILL
48:31 MAKE US MORE EFFICIENT. IT WILL PROBABLY MAKE US MORE
48:34 PRODUCTIVE, WHICH WILL FREE UP RESOURCES TO DO OTHER THINGS.
48:38 BUT I'M NOT CERTAIN IT'S GOING TO HELP US GROW OUR BUSINESS ALL
48:39 THAT MUCH. AND IN ORDER FOR THE TECHNOLOGY
48:46 TO GENERATE THE CAN TURNS -- RETURNS IT NEEDS WITH THE AMOUNT
48:49 OF CAPITAL IT'S CONSUMING, YOU HAVE TO THINK ABOUT IF IT IS
48:51 GOING TO GROW BUSINESS. CERTAINLY IN HEALTH CARE AND
48:54 DISCOVERY BUT THERE COULD BE, I'M SURE THERE'S A LOT OF NEW
48:57 BUSINESS MODELS OUT THERE THAT ARE BOOMING.
49:00 THE AIR INDUSTRY, THIS IS GOING TO BE SOMETHING THAT HOPEFULLY
49:04 ALLOWS US TO BE A BETTER AIRLINE BUT NOT NECESSARILY A BIGGER
49:05 AIRLINE. LISA: THERE'S ALSO A QUESTION
49:11 ABOUT HOW YOU HANDLE, FOR EXAMPLE, AGENTIC AGENTS THAT GO
49:16 SHOPPING FOR CHEAPER AIRLINE TICKETS.
49:17 UNITED CAME OUT YESTERDAY AND SAID THAT THEY WERE BLOCKING
49:21 CERTAIN PERSONAL AI ASSISTANTS ON THEIR PLATFORMS.
49:24 HAVE YOU MADE A DECISION ON WHAT DELTA IS GOING TO DO ABOUT THAT?
49:28 ED: AGAIN, WE ARE BEING CAREFUL. WE CAN IDENTIFY THE AGENTS WHEN
49:31 THEY APPROACH US. WE HAVE THE TECHNOLOGY AND THE
49:33 TOOLS TO DO THAT. WE WATCH WHAT THEY ARE DOING.
49:39 THEY ARE THERE TO LOOK FOR INFORMATION ABOUT AN AIRFARE FOR
49:41 YOU, MAYBE. WE WILL RESPOND IN KIND.
49:54 WE UNDERSTAND WHO LISA IS, NOT WHO LEASES AGENT IS.
49:59 WE ALLOW LISA TO DO THINGS WE KNOW SHE WANTS TO DO SUCH AS
50:04 CHECK IN FOR A FLIGHT, PRIVACY CONCERNS AND SECURITY CONCERNS
50:05 IN OUR INDUSTRY. I THINK IT'S TOO EARLY FOR US TO
50:09 DECLARE KNOW, WE ARE NOT GOING TO WORK IN THE AGENTIC WORLD.
50:13 I KNOW CERTAIN COMPANIES HAVE TAKEN A BIT OF A BLACK-AND-WHITE
50:16 APPROACH TOWARDS IT. WE ARE A BIT MORE NUANCED.
50:21 I CAN TELL YOU THE VOLUMES ARE RELATIVELY LOWER.
50:25 THERE'S A LOT OF NEWS FLOW ABOUT IT.
50:28 BUT THE ACTUAL VOLUMES WE SEE ARE GROWING FAST.
50:34 LISA: VOLUMES ARE IMPORTANT AHEAD OF THE HOLIDAY SEASON.
50:39 THE STEADY DEMAND THAT YOU HAVE SEEN FROM CONSUMERS, CAN YOU
50:45 QUANTIFY OR GIVE A SENSE QUALIFY WHAT TRAVELER DEMAND LOOKS LIKE
50:47 HEADING INTO THE HOLIDAYS, ESPECIALLY WITH SOME OF THE
50:49 HIGHER PRICES WE HAVE SEEN? ED: THE DEMAND IS REALLY STRONG.
50:57 THE INVESTMENT CONSUMERS ARE MAKING IN THEIR EXPERIENCE
51:00 CONTINUES TO BE THE TOP OF THEIR SHOPPING LIST FOR THEIR
51:01 HOLIDAYS. THEY WANT TO TRAVEL AND GO
51:05 PLACES AND SEE PEOPLE. SO, THE EXPERIENCED ECONOMY IS
51:08 ALIVE AND WELL. AND YES, THE PRICES ARE HIGHER,
51:12 LARGELY DRIVEN BY NOT JUST FUEL PRICES BY COST IN GENERAL.
51:15 BUT IF YOU STEP BACK AND THINK ABOUT HOW AIRFARES HAVE BEEN
51:20 OVER THE LAST FEW YEARS, PARTICULARLY COMING OUT OF
51:24 COVID, WE ARE STILL BELOW WHERE GENERAL INFLATION HAS BEEN
51:26 POST-PANDEMIC. WE WENT THROUGH SEVERAL YEARS
51:28 FOLLOWING THE PANDEMIC WHERE FARES WENT DOWN.
51:35 I KNOW IT DOESN'T NECESSARILY MAKE IT EASIER WHEN YOU ARE
51:38 SEEING A 25% INCREASE ON A TICKET, WHICH MANY ARE.
51:43 BUT IT'S WHAT WE NEED TO DO TO COVER OUR COST, PROVIDING THAT
51:45 SERVICE. LISA: IF SOMEONE IN NEW YORK
51:50 WERE LOOKING TO BOOK A TICKET TO SALT LAKE CITY DURING SKI
51:53 SEASON, HOLIDAY SEASON, THEY WOULD FIND IT COSTS $1500 FOR
51:57 EVEN COACH. AT THE SAME TIME, IT'S CHEAPER
52:00 TO GO TO EUROPE. AT WHAT POINT, DO PEOPLE START
52:02 PUSHING BACK? ED: WE HAVE BEEN SEEING THE
52:05 PUSHBACK. IT IS SUPPLY AND DEMAND.
52:11 WE LOVE IT FOR THE FACT THAT WE HAVE LOTS OF DIFFERENT
52:12 ALTERNATIVES AND DIFFERENT PRODUCTS.
52:18 PARTICULARLY IN THE PREMIUM SECTORS, THAT'S WHERE YOU HAVE
52:21 THE STRONGEST PRICING RIGHT NOW, IN THE PREMIUM PRODUCTS THAT WE
52:23 OFFER. BUT, WE HAVE BASIC ECONOMY AND A
52:28 JOIN US AS WELL. LISA: THERE'S A QUESTION ABOUT
52:33 HOW MUCH FURTHER PRICES CAN GO. THERE IS SOME SPECULATION AFTER
52:38 THE TRUTH SOCIAL POST FROM PRESIDENT TRUMP THAT THERE IS
52:41 NOT GOING TO BE A DEAL WITH IRAN AND THAT THE TENSIONS COULD
52:44 CONTINUE. AT WHAT POINT DOES IT BECOME
52:48 INSURMOUNTABLE, HOW MUCH YOU CAN RAISE PRICES TO OFFSET THE
52:50 INCREASE OF THE OIL PRICES. ED: I THINK THE INDUSTRY HAS
52:56 LARGELY DONE THAT. I WOULD SAY WE ARE PRETTY CLOSE
53:04 TO HAVING MANAGED -- MANAGER SPEAKING FOR DELTA.
53:05 OUR PROFITS ARE DOWN BUT WE HAVE LARGELY HELD OUR MARGINS AT THIS
53:09 POINT. I THINK THAT'S ABOUT ALL YOU CAN
53:11 DO. LISA: IS THERE A SENSE THE
53:16 SHAKEOUT HAS ALREADY BEEN DONE WITH RESPECT TO AIRLINES THAT
53:20 ARE SMALLER, LESS ABLE TO CAPITALIZE THAN YOURSELF AND
53:23 WHETHER THEY MERGE WITH ONE ANOTHER, WHETHER THEY GO
53:26 BANKRUPT, DO YOU THINK THAT THAT IS OVER OR DO YOU THINK THERE IS
53:27 STILL A WAY TO COME? ED: YOU HAVE TO TELL ME WHERE
53:33 YOU THINK THE PRICE OF JET FUEL WILL BE 12 MONTHS FROM NOW AND
53:37 THEN I CAN ANSWER YOUR QUESTION. I THINK IT'S TOO EARLY TO
53:39 DECLARE THAT THE FUEL SHOCK IS BEHIND US.
53:44 MEASURES CAN GO HIGHER. THERE ARE CERTAINLY AIRLINES
53:49 THAT ARE CLOSER TO THE EDGE AND WEREN'T MAKING MONEY PRIOR TO
53:53 THE OIL SHOCK. LISA: ONE QUESTION THAT KEEPS
54:01 COMING UP WHEN WE TALK ABOUT FLIGHTS AND THAT HIS WIFE I.
54:03 I KNOW YOU DECIDED NOT TO GO WITH STARLINK AND SOME OF YOUR
54:06 COMPETITORS DID. ELON MUSK CAME OUT AND HAD SOME
54:09 CHOICE WORDS. YOU DECIDED TO GO WITH AMAZON,
54:13 WHICH HAS BEEN A LITTLE BIT DELAYED.
54:15 HAVE YOU REGRETTED IT AT ALL OR DO YOU EVER THINK ABOUT THAT?
54:18 HAVE YOU TALK WITH ELON MUSK RECENTLY?
54:23 ED: WE HAVE BEEN A LEADER IN THIS SPACE.
54:30 I REMEMBER WHEN WE DID THIS AND THEY SAID HOW CAN DELTA DO THAT,
54:33 WE WILL HAVE TO COPY IT. WE HAVE KNOWN STARLINK FOR A
54:35 VERY LONG TIME. WE DECIDED TO GO A DIFFERENT
54:37 WAY. WE HAVE A DIFFERENT BUSINESS
54:41 MODEL AND MAYBE SOME OF -- A DIFFERENT BUSINESS MODEL FROM
54:44 SOME OF THE OTHER HEADLINES. WE KNOW THE AMAZON PRODUCT IS
54:47 GOING TO BE A GREAT PRODUCT. IT WILL BE COMING TO THE SKIES
54:49 RELATIVELY SOON OVER THE NEXT 18 MONTHS.
54:52 I'M CONFIDENT IN OUR DECISION. ED: ED BASTIAN --
55:00 LISA: ED BASTIAN, THANK YOU FOR BEING WITH US THIS MORNING.
55:02 BONNIE, I WILL SEND IT BACK TO YOU.
55:08 VONNIE: LET'S GET A CHECK ON MARKETS.
55:10 WE HAVE SEEN SOME IMPROVEMENTS THANKS TO CONSUMER STOCKS TODAY.
55:14 IN THE AI UNIVERSE, WELL, YOU ARE NOT HAVING THE BEST DAY.
55:17 PARTICULARLY THE NEO-CLOUDS WHICH HAVE SEEN STUFF TO SHOOT
55:18 UP YESTERDAY. LET'S LOOK AT OVERALL MARKETS.
55:26 THE NASDAQ DOWN A HALF PERCENT. PRACTICALLY ON OUR BEST LEVELS
55:32 OF THE SESSION BECAUSE NVIDIA IS ONLY DOWN SEVEN
55:38 -- 7% NOW. IT WAS DOWN 13% PREMARKET.
55:47 -- IS HELPING INDIVIDUAL STOCKS LIKE CONSUMER STOCKS.
55:48 YIELDS ARE HIGHER AS WELL. ALL RIGHT.
55:53 SO, I DO WANT TO POINT AS WELL TO THE FACT THAT THERE ARE SOME
55:55 OTHER STORIES HAPPENING TODAY. SOME STRATEGY FOR EXAMPLE
56:04 THERE. ISABELLE: THIS IS NEWS THAT
56:08 PEOPLE HAVE BEEN TALKING ABOUT. TO BE TROMPED FROM THE BENCHMARK
56:10 IS A BIG DEAL. -- DROPPED FROM THE BENCHMARK IS
56:14 A BIG DEAL. IT CAN'T BE DENIED AND IT'S HARD
56:18 TO UNDERSTATE THE IMPACT OF NVIDIA.
56:20 AGAIN, IT COMES AT A CONSEQUENTIAL TIME.
56:22 NVIDIA IS THE GLUE HOLDING THE ECOSYSTEM TOGETHER.
56:26 THIS IS AN EARTHQUAKE THE AI TRADE SAW.
56:28 JENSEN HUANG'S RELATIONSHIP WITH HYPERSCALER STARTUPS AND CHIPS,
56:33 IT'S HARD TO OVERSTATE THAT. CAN THE ECOSYSTEM FUNCTION
56:34 WITHOUT JENSEN HUANG? VONNIE: JUST THREE COMPANIES IN
56:39 THE STOCKS ARE HIGHER. WE GOT IT BEHIND US TO A CERTAIN
56:44 EXTENT. COMING UP IN THE NEXT HOUR,
56:48 STEPHANIE GUILD FROM ROBINHOOD ON THE
56:52 MARKET REACTION TO JENSEN HUANG'S RESIGNATION.
57:07 VONNIE: REMEMBER, REMEMBER THE 12TH OF NOVEMBER, THAT WAS THE
57:12 DAY JENSEN HUANG RESIGNED FROM NEW NVIDIA.
57:17 I AM VONNIE QUINN ALONGSIDE ISABELLE LEE.
57:19 DANI BURGER IS OFF TODAY. JENSEN HUANG OUT AT NVIDIA AFTER
57:23 REPORTS OF TWO AFFAIRS. ONE POTENTIALLY WITH A CHINESE
57:26 SPY. THIS IS THE MARKET REACTION TO
57:28 THE RESIGNATION. IT MIGHT LOOK BAD BUT IT WAS
57:32 MUCH WORSE EARLIER, DOWN 13%. NOW WE ARE DOWN ABOUT 6.3%.
57:40 THE INTERIM CEO, COLLETTE KRESS. WALL STREET KNOWS HER FROM THE
57:42 EARNINGS CALLS. THE EARNINGS CALL WILL TAKE
57:48 PLACE ON TUESDAY AT 5:00 P.M. AS WAS SUPPOSED TO BE THE PLAN.
57:51 WE HAVE ALL OF THAT. WE ALSO HAVE THE CHAIR OF THE
57:55 BOARD, WHICH IS THE FIRST TIME NVIDIA HAS HAD AN ACTUAL CHAIR
57:59 TO ITS BOARD WHO HAS BEEN A LONG-TIME TIME BOARD MEMBER AND
58:04 ALSO THE CEO OF SYNOPSYS TAKING THINGS OVER AND SENDING IMO'S TO
58:08 EMPLOYEES AND SO ON. THE NASDAQ 100 IS LOWER TODAY AS
58:10 YOU MIGHT IMAGINE. 4/10 OF 1% RIGHT NOW.
58:18 LET'S DISCUSS ALL OF THIS NOW WITH BLOOMBERG TECH HOST ED
58:20 LUDLOW IN SAN FRANCISCO. ED, GIVE US THE BASICS AS WE
58:25 INVESTIGATIONS AND SO ON. ED: JENSEN HUANG HAS RESIGNED AS
58:31 AN INVIDIOUS CEO AND MEMBER OF THE BOARD EFFECTIVE IMMEDIATELY.
58:36 COLLETTE KRESS, THE CFO HAS BEEN IN PLACE FOR ABOUT 13 OR 14
58:39 YEARS AND IS NOW INTERIM CEO. THE BOARD EXPLAINED THEY WILL
58:42 REVIEW EXTERNAL CANDIDATES FOR THE ROLE OF CEO LONG-TERM.
58:47 ONE MAKES THE ASSUMPTION THEY WILL REVIEW INTERNAL CANDIDATES
58:51 BASED ON THE LANGUAGE. THE BOARD NOTES JENSEN HUANG HAS
58:56 HAD A PROFOUND CONTRIBUTION TO NVIDIA.
59:02 THIS IS THE COMPANY HE FOUNDED SINCE THE CHATGPT MOMENT IN
59:05 2022. THE HARVEY C JONES APPOINTMENT
59:10 AS CHAIR OF THE BOARD IS NOTABLE.
59:12 HE HAS BEEN A DIRECTOR ON THE BOARD SINCE 1993.
59:17 IT'S THE FIRST TIME NVIDIA WILL HAVE SEPARATED THE CEO AND
59:19 CHAIRMAN ROLE. THE BIG THING IS THERE IS NO
59:23 EXPLANATION AS TO WHAT THE SPECIFIC REASON FOR JENSEN
59:25 HUANG'S RESIGNATION IS. I KNOW THAT IS A STRANGE THING
59:27 TO SAY. THE STOCK IS PARING SOME OF HIS
59:30 DECLINES. -- IT'S DECLINES.
59:35 THERE IS NO UPDATE TO THE INVESTIGATION THAT THE BOARD AND
59:39 ITS INDEPENDENT COUNSEL OR THIRD-PARTY COUNCIL IS
59:41 UNDERTAKING WHICH RELATED TO THE NATURAL SECURITY AND IP RISKS OF
59:47 THE DISCLOSED AFFAIR THAT JENSEN HUANG HAD.
59:50 WE ARE STILL WAITING FOR THE OUTCOME OF THAT INVESTIGATION.
59:54 ISABELLE: IT'S THE END OF AN ERA , WHEN JENSEN HUANG FOUNDED
59:58 NVIDIA IN 1993 AND TURNED IT INTO THE CENTRAL SUPPLIER OF
1:00:00 ANYTHING AND EVERYTHING AI. DO YOU THINK'S DEPARTURE WILL
1:00:03 CHANGE THE WILLINGNESS OF HYPERSCALERS TO SPEND HUNDREDS
1:00:09 INFRASTRUCTURE? ED: ALL OF THEM MAINTAIN THEIR
1:00:17 FORECAST FOR CALENDAR 2027 AND 2028.
1:00:18 THERE MIGHT BE SOME DELAY IN SPENDING FROM 2028 INTO 2029.
1:00:27 THE EARNINGS GOES AHEAD NEXT TUESDAY.
1:00:29 WE DON'T KNOW WHAT THAT LOOKS LIKE OTHER THAN COLLETTE KRESS
1:00:32 IS THE INTERIM CEO AND HAS BEEN CFO.
1:00:38 BUT, YOU KNOW, OF THE RESEARCH THAT IS OUT THERE, I DON'T THINK
1:00:41 ANYONE THINKS THIS COULD BE A FUNDAMENTAL CHANGE TO THE
1:00:44 OUTLOOK FOR THE NEXT COMING FISCAL YEAR AT LEAST FOR NVIDIA.
1:00:47 THAT IS PREDICATED ON THEIR FORESIGHT OF DEMAND, WHICH IS
1:00:51 BASED ON LARGELY THE HYPERSCALERS THAT ARE 50% OF
1:00:53 THEIR BUSINESS. ISABELLE: WE THANK YOU FOR YOUR
1:00:57 THOUGHTS AND WE CAN'T WAIT TO WATCH BLOOMBERG TECH IN ABOUT AN
1:00:59 HOUR. ED LUDLOW IN SAN FRANCISCO.
1:01:04 FOR WASHINGTON'S REACTION TO THE NEWS, WE WELCOME MIKE SHEPARD.
1:01:10 THERE ARE SO MANY UNANSWERED QUESTIONS.
1:01:14 HOW MUCH DO INVESTORS WORRY ABOUT THE NATIONAL SECURITY
1:01:16 INVESTIGATION AND THE POLITICAL SCRUTINY AND ALL OF THE FOLLOW
1:01:18 WHEN IT COMES TO NVIDIA? MIKE: WE HAVE HEARD INVESTORS
1:01:23 TALK ABOUT THIS. TRACY FROM BERNSTEIN WAS TALKING
1:01:31 ABOUT THE PROSPECT OF TOUGHER SCRUTINY BY U.S. AUTHORITIES IN
1:01:34 THE WAKE OF ALL OF THIS. CLEARLY THERE IS AN EXPECTATION
1:01:37 ON WALL STREET THAT THERE WILL BE A CHANGE IN DIRECTION NOW,
1:01:40 HERE IN WASHINGTON. WHEN IT COMES TO ENFORCING
1:01:46 LIMITS DESIGNED TO KEEP AMERICAN TECHNOLOGY OUT OF THE HANDS OF
1:01:48 ADVERSARIES LIKE CHINA AND ESPECIALLY IN THE WAKE OF THE
1:01:51 REVELATIONS OVER THE PAST WEEK AND A HALF.
1:01:54 NOW, FROM THE MOMENT THAT WE ARE SEEING A VOTE OF CONFIDENCE FROM
1:01:59 THE ADMINISTRATION AND HOWARD LUTNICK, THE COMMERCE SECRETARY
1:02:02 WHOSE AGENCY DIRECTLY OVERSEAS THOSE PROGRAMS, THEY CREDITED
1:02:06 HIM WITH WORK ON TRADE DEALS. BUT IT'S EARLY.
1:02:09 WE ARE IN THE EARLY STAGES OF THIS.
1:02:11 AND U.S. LAWMAKERS ARE GETTING INVOLVED TOO.
1:02:15 VONNIE: IT'S HARD NOT TO GO DOWN THE RABBIT HOLE OF WHAT MIGHT
1:02:18 HAPPEN IN CERTAIN SCENARIOS AND SO ON.
1:02:22 BUT IF YOU TAKE IT TO ITS WORSE POSSIBLE OUTCOME, IS THERE ANY
1:02:30 KIND OF POTENTIAL JENSEN HUANG IN ANY CIRCUMSTANCE MIGHT BE
1:02:32 FOUND GUILTY OF ESPIONAGE IN ANY WAY?
1:02:37 MIKE: IT'S UNCLEAR RIGHT NOW, SOME OF THE REPORTING THAT WE
1:02:39 HAVE DOZEN POINT IN THAT DIRECTION TO HIM AS NECESSARILY
1:02:45 A TARGET OF INVESTIGATIONS. BUT, IT IS EARLY STAGES TOO AND
1:02:50 INVESTIGATORS ARE STILL LOOKING INTO SO MUCH OF THIS.
1:02:53 NOT ONLY HERE IN WASHINGTON BUT ALSO AT THE COMPANY AS WELL.
1:02:57 THE BOARD OF INVESTIGATION REALLY JUST KICKED OFF ON
1:02:59 TUESDAY. THEY ANNOUNCED THE HIRING OF --
1:03:04 TO LEAD THE PROBE THAT NO DOUBT WILL CONTINUE.
1:03:11 SO FAR, IT DOESN'T SEEM THAT THERE IS ANYTHING OF THE SORT
1:03:14 THAT WOULD EXPOSE HIM IN THAT WAY.
1:03:20 IT SEEMS TO BOIL DOWN TO THESE INDISCRETIONS AS THE TIPPING
1:03:23 POINT IN PROPELLING THE BOARD TO MAKE ITS DECISION.
1:03:26 WE WILL WATCH TO SEE WHAT U.S. LAWMAKERS DO.
1:03:29 WE HAVE SEEN SENATORS CHRIS COONS AND ELIZABETH WARREN
1:03:33 DEMAND THE COMPANY RETAIN INFORMATION RELATING TO
1:03:37 SUPPLIERS IN ASIA. THERE WILL BE MORE THAT THEY MAY
1:03:42 TRY TO SUBPOENA, INCLUDING THE NOW FORMER CEO ALONG WITH OTHER
1:03:45 COMPANY OFFICIALS FOR MORE INFORMATION.
1:03:49 VONNIE: MIKE, THANK YOU SO MUCH. WE WILL BE WATCHING THIS OVER
1:03:51 THE COMING DAYS AND WEEKS. THAT IS MIKE SHEPARD IN
1:03:52 WASHINGTON. ALICE WONG, THE CHINESE SPY IN
1:04:01 THE AFFAIR WITH JENSEN HUANG WHO CAUSED HIM TO RESIGN.
1:04:05 THIS IS ACCORDING TO REPORT FROM THE INFORMATION.
1:04:08 AS YOU CAN IMAGINE, THERE WILL BE A CASCADE OF INFORMATION AS
1:04:12 REPORTERS CONTINUE TO TRY TO FIGURE OUT WHAT EXACTLY -- WHAT
1:04:18 EXACTLY HAPPENED TO ALL OF THESE CHARACTERS INVOLVED.
1:04:21 JOINING US NOW IS STEPHANIE GUILD.
1:04:23 CAN YOU TELL US ANYTHING THAT IS HAPPENING IN REAL TIME WITH THE
1:04:27 STOCK IN TERMS OF WHAT RETAIL INVESTORS MIGHT BE DOING?
1:04:32 STEPHANIE: WE SAW A HUGE INFLUX OF VOLUME ON OUR PLATFORM JUST
1:04:36 BASED ON THE NEWS. WHEN I LOOKED, A LOT OF IT WAS
1:04:40 DOWN TO NVIDIA STOCK. ON A MARGINAL BASIS, IT WAS A
1:04:42 NET BY. WHEN YOU LOOK AT OUR ROBINHOOD
1:04:51 INVESTORS, NVIDIA IS ONE OF THE TOP HELP NAMES.
1:04:55 ISABELLE: NVIDIA IS ONE OF THE MOST HELD NAMES.
1:05:00 ITS DOMINANCE IS TOUGH TO ARGUE. WHAT HAPPENS WHEN YOU SEE A
1:05:03 HEADLINE LIKE THIS? DO YOU THINK IT WILL DRAG ON THE
1:05:06 AI TRADE WITH IT? STEPHANIE: ANYTHING IS POSSIBLE.
1:05:11 WE HAVE NOT EXPERIENCED SOMETHING LIKE THIS.
1:05:15 THE QUESTION IS IS THE AI TRADE ONE MAN OR IS IT A COMPANY THAT
1:05:18 IS LEADING THE CHARGE ON A RELATIVE BASIS?
1:05:23 THE CFO IS REPORTED AS TAKING OVER FOR NOW.
1:05:28 I THINK THE EARNINGS WILL BE IMPORTANT IN TERMS OF THE
1:05:29 OUTLOOK. THE STOCK IS TRADING BELOW 11
1:05:32 TIMES. IT IS DEFINITELY A TECHNICAL
1:05:38 SPACE RIGHT NOW IN TERMS OF ITS PRICE.
1:05:41 IT DOESN'T ACTUALLY NEED TO BE THE END OF IT.
1:05:43 I THINK HE IS A PROMINENT VOICE. VONNIE: FOR ALL OF THIS CAME OUT
1:05:49 TODAY, WE HAD A LOT OF VOLATILITY.
1:05:53 HE WAS UP 25% YESTERDAY. IN TERMS OF THE NEO-CLOUDS, WHAT
1:05:56 IS SENTIMENT? STEPHANIE: DEFINITELY PRO AI
1:06:00 TRADES. COREWEAVE HAS NOT BEEN AT THE
1:06:08 TOP OR NET ES, WHICH CAME OUT WITH DISAPPOINTING EARNINGS.
1:06:12 THEY HAVEN'T BEEN AT THE TOP. MOST CUSTOMERS HAVE BEEN BUYING
1:06:15 THINGS LIKE SPACEX AND NVIDIA. VONNIE: AND THEY ARE UP-TO-DATE
1:06:18 TOO. ISABELLE: DO YOU THINK INVESTORS
1:06:23 ARE GETTING AHEAD OF THEMSELVES WHEN IT COMES TO THE AI TRADE.
1:06:27 THAT IS SOMETHING BLOOMBERG HAS BEEN TALKING ABOUT, THE NEGATIVE
1:06:30 FREE CASH FLOW AND INVESTORS ARE SPOOKED WHEN THEY SEE THAT.
1:06:33 STEPHANIE: THAT'S THE BIGGEST THING.
1:06:35 WE OWNED A LOT MORE IN ROBINHOOD STRATEGIES.
1:06:38 IN JUNE, WE STARTED TRIMMING IT. AND THEN IN OCTOBER, WE TRIMMED
1:06:41 FURTHER. WE STILL HAVE AN ALLOCATION TO
1:06:42 IT. I AM MORE FOCUSED ON THE THINGS
1:06:45 THAT CAN WIN NO MATTER WHAT. NO MATTER WHAT LAB WINS OUT AND
1:06:51 NO MATTER WHAT CHIPMAKER WINS, WE ARE GOING TO NEED THOSE
1:06:54 THINGS OVER THE LONG-TERM. IT JUST REALLY DEPENDS ON WHERE
1:06:57 I THINK EXPECTATIONS ARE VERSUS THE PRICE.
1:06:59 THAT'S WHY I THINK CASH FLOW WILL MATTER MORE.
1:07:04 VONNIE: IS BITCOIN TRADING GONE? WE ARE SEEING BITCOIN TRADING
1:07:08 TODAY. BUT WE ARE JUST ABOVE $17,000
1:07:16 AND I AM CURIOUS FOR THE BITCOIN ILLUMINATI.
1:07:21 STEPHANIE: IT'S HARD TO SAY, IT IS DEFINITELY A WAKE UP OF QUIET
1:07:25 WHILE IT'S IN THE POST AUGUST RALLY.
1:07:28 I THINK OUR TEAM HAS BEEN WATCHING VERY CLOSELY.
1:07:32 I THINK LONGER TERM, BITCOIN IS THE RAIL THAT WILL SERVE
1:07:34 FINANCIAL SERVICES IN THE LONGER TERM BECAUSE NOW WITH THE
1:07:37 COMBINATION OF AI AND AGENTS, YOU NEED SOMETHING LIKE A
1:07:39 BITCOIN RAILS. WHAT YOU KNOW, WHERE THE PRICE
1:07:44 GOES IN THE SHORT-TERM, IT DEPENDS WHAT HAPPENS WITH
1:07:47 INTEREST RATES AND WHAT HAPPENS WITH INFLATION AND ALL OF THAT
1:07:50 IS VERY MUCH IN FLUX. ISABELLE: SINCE YOU MENTIONED
1:07:57 INFLATION, WE GOT HOTTER THAN EXPECTED CPI.
1:07:59 HOW DO YOU THINK THAT WILL IMPACT THE AI TRADE?
1:08:02 BECAUSE TECH VALUATIONS WILL OF COURSE BE SHAKY.
1:08:05 WE KNOW THE AI BOOM WHICH REQUIRES ENORMOUS CAPITAL WILL
1:08:07 BE PUT INTO QUESTION. IS THAT SOMETHING YOU ARE
1:08:09 FORECASTING IN YOUR RESEARCH? STEPHANIE: IF SOMETHING WE THINK
1:08:16 ABOUT WITH THE POSITIONS WE HAD IN JUNE AND THE OCTOBER
1:08:18 TIMEFRAME. BECAUSE WE SAID CASH FLOWS
1:08:20 MATTER MORE. AND IF YOU CAN MATCH OUR CASH
1:08:23 FLOWS TO THE DEBT YOU HAVE TO PAY, YOU ARE OK.
1:08:27 THERE WILL DEFINITELY BE SOME PEOPLE WHO TOOK ON TOO MUCH.
1:08:32 IF INTEREST RATES GET TOO HIGH, IT'S GOING TO BE A MOVING OF
1:08:35 TIME FRAMES WHICH WE HAVE SEEN A LITTLE BIT IN THE TRADE.
1:08:40 VONNIE: WHAT ARE YOU DOING NOW IN TERMS OF A FAVORITE HEDGE?
1:08:44 STEPHANIE: THIS IS NOT WORKING TODAY BUT WE HAVE AN ALLOCATION
1:08:46 OF GOLD AND ENERGY NAMES. AND ALSO, WHEN WE WERE MOVING
1:08:53 SOME OF THOSE AI NAMES, WE WERE OWNING THINGS WE FELT WERE MORE
1:08:55 STABLE. WE HAVE AN ALLOCATION TO SOME
1:09:01 CONSUMER STAPLES. AND ALSO, HEALTH CARE.
1:09:05 THAT SEEMS TO BE A PLACE THAT IS BACK IN FAVOR.
1:09:09 IT WAS NOT ALWAYS THROUGHOUT THE YEAR.
1:09:11 I THINK THAT IS A PLACE THAT WILL CONTINUE TO BENEFIT FROM
1:09:14 SUPER INTELLIGENCE AS THEY CALL IT.
1:09:17 VONNIE: STEPHANIE, THANK YOU SO MUCH.
1:09:19 WHAT A DAY TO BE ALIVE. STEPHANIE GUILD OF ROBINHOOD
1:09:21 JOINING US. LET'S GET A CHECK ON THESE
1:09:23 MARKETS NOW. WE SEE IMPROVEMENT FOR SOME OF
1:09:26 THE INDICES. THE S&P 500 IS DOWN ONE THIRD OF
1:09:28 1%. THE NASDAQ IS DOWN ALMOST 8/10
1:09:32 OF A PERCENT. NVIDIA DOWN NEARLY 8%, WELL OFF
1:09:36 OF ITS SESSION LOWS WHICH WERE DOWN 13% PREMARKET.
1:09:44 JENSEN HUANG'S RESIGNATION IMPACTING OWNERSHIP OF THAT
1:09:45 STOCK. BRENT CRUDE UP 1.4 PERCENT.
1:09:49 94.05. THAT IS NOT HURTING STOCKS
1:09:50 TODAY. THEY ARE HIGHER.
1:09:53 LET'S LOOK AT MOVERS ON OUR RADAR.
1:09:54 FOR THAT, WE WILL GO TO NORAH MULINDA.
1:09:59 >> KEEPING AN EYE ON TECH, AMD AND BROADCOM GAINING.
1:10:03 NVIDIA'S LEADERSHIP TERM WILL POTENTIALLY CREATING AN OPENING
1:10:06 FOR RIVALS TO ACTUALLY GAIN GROUND WITH NVIDIA CHIPS
1:10:09 ACCOUNTING FOR MORE THAN 60% OF AI COMPUTING POWER SUPPLY IN THE
1:10:10 SECOND QUARTER. NEXT UP, OTHER AI NAMES ARE
1:10:17 MOVING IN THE UPPER -- OPPOSITE DIRECTION.
1:10:21 COREWEAVE AND SANDISK AND SUPER MICRO ARE ALL FALLING AS CORE
1:10:26 INVESTORS WAY HOW NVIDIA'S CHANGE RIPPLE THROUGH.
1:10:31 -- THE WORRIES GROWING OUT OF THE
1:10:36 LATEST DEVELOPMENT'S OVER AT NVIDIA.
1:10:38 YOU ARE SEEING SHARES OF ALIBABA DOWN BY MORE THAN 7%.
1:10:41 THOSE ARE YOUR MORNING MOVERS. ISABELLE: THANK YOU SO MUCH FOR
1:10:45 THOSE. COMING UP, OUR DNA EXECUTIVE
1:10:49 PRESIDENT JOINS US TO DISCUSS AI RISKS IN PRIVATE MARKETS.
1:10:53 THIS IS "BLOOMBERG OPEN INTEREST."
1:11:09 ♪ >> I THINK THERE ARE THREE
1:11:10 THINGS THAT ARE ON OUR MIND THAT WE ARE OBSERVING THAT CONCERN
1:11:11 US. THE FIRST THING IS THERE HAS
1:11:15 BEEN A MASSIVE EXPANSION. THE SECOND THING IS SPECULATIVE
1:11:21 FERVOR OR ANALYST SPIRITS OR FOMO.
1:11:23 AND THE THIRD THING IS WE ARE STARTING TO OBSERVE DISTORTIONS
1:11:28 IN THE MARKET. WHY DID THOSE THINGS MATTER?
1:11:31 IN OUR INVESTING CAREER, EVERY TIME WE SEE THOSE THREE THINGS
1:11:35 BEING TRUE, IT RESULTS IN A DISLOCATION.
1:11:41 VONNIE: ALAN WAXMAN, THE CEO OF 6TH STREET SPEAKING ON WHAT HE
1:11:46 SEES AS SIGNS OF A PEOPLE IN THE AI BOOM.
1:11:51 JOINING US IS GLAD. THANK YOU SO MUCH FOR JOINING.
1:11:56 -- VLAD. THANK YOU SO MUCH FOR JOINING.
1:11:58 NOT GOING TO ASK YOU ABOUT JENSEN HUANG AND HIS RESIGNATION
1:12:02 SPECIFICALLY BUT SOMETHING LIKE THIS HAPPENS AND IT HAS A
1:12:06 DAMPENING EFFECT ON SEARCH AND TRADES.
1:12:08 COULD THAT BE A NET POSITIVE FOR THIS MARKET?
1:12:12 >> IT'S AN INTERESTING DAY TO BE ON THE SHOW.
1:12:18 IT SHOWS THERE HAS BEEN SOME SPECULATIVE BEHAVIOR IN THE AI
1:12:21 TRADE AND THE DATA MARKET AND DATA CENTER FINANCING FOR SURE.
1:12:25 IN THE LAST FEW MONTHS. BUT ONE THING THAT DOES NOT
1:12:29 CHANGE IS THE DEMAND ISRAEL. THE DATA CENTER CAPACITY IN THE
1:12:33 U.S. LAST YEAR INCREASED BY ROUGHLY ONE THIRD.
1:12:36 AND YET, THE VACANCY RATES ARE DOWN AT HISTORIC LEVELS AT 1%.
1:12:40 YOU LOOK AT BUSINESSES AND INDIVIDUALS, PEOPLE ARE USING AI
1:12:43 EXPONENTIALLY. EVERY NEW DATA CENTER THAT GETS
1:12:48 BILLED IS IMMEDIATELY 80% OR 90% CONTRACTED.
1:12:50 THAT PRESENTS AN OPPORTUNITY. THERE WILL BE A SLOWDOWN.
1:12:54 FINANCIAL CONDITIONS HAVE BECOME TIGHTER.
1:12:57 THERE IS ALSO SOME REGULATORY AND COMMUNITY PUSHBACK WHICH, BY
1:12:59 THE WAY IT IS HEALTHY. A LOT NEEDS TO BE THOUGHT
1:13:04 THROUGH IN TERMS OF ACCESS TO POWER AND WATER.
1:13:07 THAT'S A NORMAL PART OF THE BUILD OUT, I WOULD SAY.
1:13:09 THAT'S HAVING A DAMPENING EFFECT FOR SURE ON THE BUILDOUT.
1:13:15 AND SO, THAT MEANS THE SUPPLY IS EVEN SLOWER AND THE DEMAND
1:13:16 CONTINUES TO BE BIGGER. SO FOR US, THAT PRESENTS A
1:13:22 COUPLE OF OPPORTUNITIES. IN THE PRIVATE MARKETS, TRYING
1:13:26 TO AVOID THE SPECULATIVE AREA AND SHORT-TERM TRADING.
1:13:29 WE ARE FOCUSED ON THE LONG-TERM. I KNOW IT'S COUNTERINTUITIVE
1:13:35 RIGHT NOW TO THINK OF EUROPE AS A LAND OF OPPORTUNITY.
1:13:38 BUT IF YOU THINK OF INFRASTRUCTURE AND DIGITAL
1:13:40 INFRASTRUCTURE, IT REALLY IS RIGHT NOW.
1:13:44 THE GOVERNMENT -- GOVERNMENTS ACTUALLY WANT DATA CENTER
1:13:45 BUILDOUT. THE BUILDOUT IS BEHIND PLAN AND
1:13:47 BEHIND THE U.S. THEY WANT DATA CENTERS BUILT OUT
1:13:51 THERE. SO, YOU HAVE COMMUNITY SUPPORT.
1:13:53 YOU HAVE REGULATORY SUPPORT. WITH THE LARGEST INFRASTRUCTURE
1:13:58 INVESTOR IN EUROPE. WE HAVE BOOTS ON THE GROUND, WE
1:14:05 CAN REGULATE -- NAVIGATE REGULATORY FRAMEWORK.
1:14:09 WHEN YOU THINK OF IT, SLOWER SUPPLIES, SLOWER BUILD UP A HUGE
1:14:12 DEMAND, THAT MEANS THE EXISTING DATA CENTERS THAT ARE BUILDOUT'S
1:14:17 -- THROUGH SECONDARIES AND THROUGH
1:14:20 BUYING PRIVATE MARKET POSITIONS AND INFRASTRUCTURE FUNDS ON THE
1:14:24 SECONDARIES MARKET, YOU CAN ACTUALLY BUY INTO VERY
1:14:26 ATTRACTIVE GROWING DATA CENTER EXPOSURE THAT IS PERMITTED, CASH
1:14:29 FLOWING AND OPERATING. AND YOU CAN DO SO AND VALUATIONS
1:14:33 THAT ARE MORE INTERESTING THAN PUBLIC MARKETS.
1:14:35 SO, THAT IS AN AREA WE ARE VERY FOCUSED ON.
1:14:40 ISABELLE: FOR OUR VIEWERS, NVIDIA HAS REACHED SESSION
1:14:43 HIGHS. IT'S DOWN LESS THAN 6%.
1:14:49 IT IS SURPRISING GIVEN THE NEWS WE HAVE JUST GOTTEN.
1:14:52 YOU MENTIONED THE SLOWDOWN IS HEALTHY.
1:14:53 I WONDER WHAT LEVEL OF SLOWDOWN WILL CONCERN YOU?
1:14:59 WE DON'T WANT TOO MUCH OF A SLOWDOWN.
1:15:03 VLAD: WHEN YOU LOOK AT THE CONDITIONS BEING PUT ON NEW DATA
1:15:08 CENTERS ARE, WE THINK A LOT OF THEM ARE NOT INSURMOUNTABLE.
1:15:10 WHEN YOU LOOK AT WHAT TEXAS IS PUTTING IN PLACE FOR EXAMPLE,
1:15:14 YOU NEED TO BRING IN YOUR OWN POWER AND WATER AND HIRE LOCALLY
1:15:17 AND PAY TAXES LOCALLY. ALL OF THESE ARE VERY DOABLE FOR
1:15:24 HIGH-MARGIN BUSINESSES LIKE DATA CENTER BUSINESSES.
1:15:25 WE DON'T THINK IT IS STOPPING. WE THINK IT IS JUST GOING TO
1:15:28 SLOW DOWN A LITTLE BIT. IN THE MEANTIME, THE DEMAND IS
1:15:31 THERE. EXISTING DATA CENTERS ARE
1:15:35 GAINING IN VALUE. THERE'S AN ISSUE IN THE PRIVATE
1:15:44 MARKETS TODAY. THERE IS AN OVERHANG OF ASSETS.
1:15:50 THE NAV SITS AT AROUND $4 TRILLION, WHICH IS A HISTORICAL
1:15:52 HIGH. A LOT OF INVESTMENTS WERE DONE
1:15:57 FIVE TO SIX YEARS AGO AT HIGH VALUATIONS.
1:15:59 WHAT PEOPLE TALK ABOUT IS THOSE ARE OFTEN VERY GOOD INVESTMENTS.
1:16:03 THOSE COMPANIES ARE DOING WELL AND THEY ARE GROWING.
1:16:08 THE TEAMS ARE NOT PARTICULARLY HIGHLY LEVERAGED BUT THEY WERE
1:16:10 PAID TOO MUCH FIVE YEARS AGO. WE HAVE THIS EXIT OVERHANG IN
1:16:15 PRIVATE MARKETS. THEY OVER ALLOCATED AND THEY
1:16:18 WANT TO DEPLOY TODAY'S OPPORTUNITIES.
1:16:20 THEY ARE STUCK WITH SOME OF THE PORTFOLIOS FROM FIVE TO SIX
1:16:21 YEARS AGO. THAT HAS CREATED A BOOM IN THE
1:16:24 SECONDARY MARKET. SOME OF THE IS CONTINUATION
1:16:26 VEHICLES. THEY PUT IT IN VEHICLES SO THEY
1:16:32 CAN SEND CASH BACK TO THEIR INVESTORS.
1:16:33 THAT'S A GREAT INVESTMENT SO THEY ARE GOING TO CONTINUE THIS
1:16:36 STORY. I SEE IT AS MORE OPTIONALITY FOR
1:16:40 INVESTORS IN THE ASSET CLASS. ON THE OTHER SIDE OF THE
1:16:44 SECONDARY MARKET IS THE LP SIDE, MEANING YOU ARE BUYING
1:16:46 PORTFOLIOS OF PRIVATE EQUITY FUNDS FOR INVESTORS BECAUSE THEY
1:16:49 ARE STUCK WITH OLD ASSETS. AND SO YOU THINK OK, THEY ARE
1:16:54 BUYING THE STUFF -- WE ARE BUYING THE STUFF THEY DON'T WANT
1:16:57 ANYMORE BUT THE REALITY IS YOU ARE BUYING THEM FIVE YEARS LATER
1:17:00 AT A VALUATION THAT IS MUCH LOWER THAN WHAT THEY PAID FOR IT
1:17:02 FIVE YEARS AGO SO YOU CAN DO WELL BUYING THESE SAME ASSETS
1:17:06 TODAY AT A GOOD VALUE WHEN YOU ARE THREE TO FOUR YEARS CLOSER
1:17:08 TO THE EXIT TIMING. VONNIE: WE HAVE TO LEAVE IT
1:17:12 THERE. THANK YOU SO MUCH FOR JOINING US
1:17:13 ON SUCH A BUSY DAY. I WANT TO REITERATE THAT NOW
1:17:22 THAT WE KNOW THAT JENSEN HUANG WILL NOT HAVE ANY ROLE WITHIN
1:17:26 NVIDIA GOING FORWARD, THAT WAS ONE OF THE QUESTIONS WE HAD BEEN
1:17:28 ASKING ALL MORNING, WHETHER HE WOULD STILL PLAY SOME KIND OF
1:17:32 ROLE, HE WILL NOT, ACCORDING TO BLOOMBERG REPORTING.
1:17:35 THE STOCK NOW IS AT A SESSION HIGH.
1:17:37 STILL DOWN MORE THAN 5%. COMING UP, THE GROUND FALLS FROM
1:17:43 THE KING OF AI AS JENSEN HUANG EXITS NVIDIA.
1:17:46 WE WILL DISCUSS WITH ANTOINE, NEW STREET TECHNOLOGY
1:17:52 INFRASTRUCTURE ANALYST, NEXT. THIS IS "BLOOMBERG OPEN INTEREST."♪
1:18:05 ISABELLE: THIS IS BLOOMBERG OPEN INTEREST.
1:18:08 I'M ISABELLE LEE ALONGSIDE VONNIE QUINN.
1:18:11 JENSEN HUANG FOUNDED NVIDIA IN 1993, 33 YEARS AGO AND NOW HE
1:18:12 HAS STEPPED DOWN. S&P IS LOWER BY 3/10 OF 1%.
1:18:18 THE NASDAQ ALSO DOWN BY 5/10 OF 1%.
1:18:24 AGAIN, IT'S REALLY GOING TO BE A PUSH OF WHETHER NVIDIA CAN
1:18:26 SURVIVE. THERE IS A NEW INTERIM CEO, CFO
1:18:32 COLLETTE KRESS. COMING UP, ANTOINE OF
1:18:39 NEW STREET. THIS IS "BLOOMBERG OPEN INTEREST."♪
1:21:33 POSTING ON X. IT'S IT'S INTERESTING TO SEE WHO
1:21:37 WANTS THEIR VOICES HEARD AT A TIME LIKE THIS.
1:21:41 THAT IS CARMEN REINICKE. FOR A LOOK AT HOW WASHINGTON AND
1:21:46 WALL STREET ARE REACTING, WE ARE JOINED BY TYLER KENDALL AND
1:21:51 MICHAEL BALL. TYLER, LET ME START WITH YOU.
1:21:55 HAVE THE ROLES COME QUICKER AND FASTER FOR INVESTIGATIONS INTO
1:21:58 WHAT MIGHT HAVE HAPPENED BETWEEN JENSEN HUANG AND THIS ALLEGED
1:22:01 CHINESE SPY? >> WE HAVE GOTTEN UPDATES SINCE
1:22:07 THE NEWS BROKE EARLIER TODAY. IN THE LAST HOUR WHO DID CONFIRM
1:22:25 TWO OTHER CRITICAL HOUSE CHAIRMAN ARE DEMANDING HE APPEAR
1:22:31 BEFORE THEIR COMMITTEE AS SOON AS NEXT WEEK TO BRIEF LAWMAKERS
1:22:34 AND WITH WHAT THE COMPANY IS DOING TO TRY TO INSTITUTE SOME
1:22:36 NATIONAL SECURITY CONTROLS IN THE WAKE OF IT.
1:22:41 WE HEARD, OVERNIGHT, A LETTER FROM TWO PROMINENT SENATE
1:22:45 DEMOCRATS, SENATOR ELIZABETH WARREN POISED TO LEAD THE SENATE
1:22:47 BANKING COMMITTEE ALONGSIDE CHRIS KUNZ REQUESTING TOP
1:22:53 ADMINISTRATION OFFICIALS PRESERVE DOCUMENTS RELATED TO
1:22:57 THE COMPANY, SEEMING TO LAY THE GROUNDWORK THAT ONCE DEMOCRATS
1:23:03 RETAKE THE UPPER CHAMBER WE SHOULD EXPECT SWEEPING
1:23:04 CONGRESSIONAL INVESTIGATIONS. ISABELLE: NVIDIA HAS PARED BACK
1:23:13 SOME LOSSES, THOUGH, FOR THE WEEK, DOWN 12%.
1:23:17 MICHAEL: THE IMPLIED VOLATILITY FOR THE STOCK IS HIGHER GIVEN
1:23:20 THE MOVE WE HAVE SEEN, THE CORRECTION.
1:23:23 THE CALL DEMAND IS OUTPACING PUT DEMAND.
1:23:27 PR LOOK -- PEOPLE ARE LOOKING FOR A REBOUND.
1:23:28 THE MARKET IS UNDECIDED. WE HAVE TALKED ABOUT SUPPLY
1:23:31 CHAIN IMPACTS, FINANCING IMPACTS.
1:23:35 THE REGULATORY IMPACT MIGHT BE WORSE NOW.
1:23:40 OVERALL, YOU ARE SEEING DIP BUYING COMING IN EXPRESSED
1:23:42 THROUGH OPTIONS. VONNIE: WHY IS DIP BUYING
1:23:55 COMING IN? MICHAEL: THERE IS UNCERTAINTY
1:23:59 ABOUT FORWARD EARNINGS. THE MACRO TRADE ITSELF IS
1:24:02 AGAINST THE AI TRADE IN SOME WAYS.
1:24:03 TO THE MACRO BACKGROUND I SHOULD SAY.
1:24:07 I DON'T THINK ANYBODY THINKS THE COMPANY WILL GO AWAY.
1:24:14 IT IS WHAT MULTIPLE SHOULD YOU ASSIGN, NOT NECESSARILY THE
1:24:17 IMMEDIATE EARNINGS GROWTH FOR 2027.
1:24:21 WITH JENSEN GONE, THE ACQUISITIONS AND ABILITIES TO
1:24:23 MAKE DEALS MIGHT BE GONE AS WELL.
1:24:31 ISABELLE: CAN NVIDIA RENEGE ON ANY OF THESE DEALS THAT AGREED
1:24:34 TO UNDER JENSEN HUANG? MICHAEL: IT LOOKS LIKE THEY'RE
1:24:40 EARNINGS FOR NEXT WEEK ARE SECURE AND LOOK POSITIVE.
1:24:41 WE HAVE ALREADY GOTTEN MOST OF THE GUYS THAT COMPLETE THAT
1:24:45 PICTURE. TO PULLBACK HAS BEEN
1:24:47 SIGNIFICANT. IT IS OFFERING AN INTERESTING
1:24:51 PROPOSITION FOR VALUE. ISABELLE: TYLER KENDALL AND
1:24:58 MICHAEL BALL. LET'S CONTINUE WITH OUR NEWS FOR
1:25:04 STREET ANALYST. THIS IS AN EARTHQUAKE.
1:25:07 WHAT DO YOU MAKE OF THIS? DO YOU THINK THE DOWNFALL OF
1:25:12 JENSEN HUANG WILL BRING DOWN THE AI TRADE WITH THAT?
1:25:17 ANTOINE: I THINK YOU HAVE TO DISTINGUISH THE NEAR-TERM END OF
1:25:20 THE REAL TERM. NEAR-TERM THEY HAVE SECURED
1:25:22 MANUFACTURING CAPACITY, CUSTOMER COMMITMENTS.
1:25:26 ALL THAT REMAINS IN PLACE. VERY WELL-POSITIONED TO MAINTAIN
1:25:37 SUCCESSOR. LONG-TERM, THAT IS WHERE MY
1:25:41 BIGGEST CONCERN IS. YOU HAVE JENSEN WHO MANAGES
1:25:50 ABOUT 60 DIRECT REPORTS. HE DEALS DIRECTLY WITH
1:25:52 CUSTOMERS, SUPPLIERS, AND GOVERNMENTS AND CLERKS WHAT AI
1:25:59 SUPPLIERS NEED AND WHERE THE INDUSTRY SHOULD INVEST.
1:26:02 REVIEWING ALL THAT, THAT COORDINATION.
1:26:11 VONNIE: HAS NVIDIA OPENED ITSELF UP TO SHAREHOLDER LAWSUITS?
1:26:16 COULD THAT LIABILITY BE LARGE? GOOD SUPPLIERS DECIDE TO DO
1:26:22 BUSINESS ELSEWHERE? ANTOINE: THERE IS A RISK THIS
1:26:30 REPRESENTS FOR THE TECHNOLOGY INFRASTRUCTURE LANDSCAPE.
1:26:36 WE CAN BRING ALL THE PARTIES I MENTIONED EARLIER TOGETHER.
1:26:40 WHEN YOU LOOK AT THE IMPLICATIONS, JENSEN HAS BEEN
1:26:47 HELPING BUILD ALTERNATIVES TO NVIDIA'S BIGGEST CUSTOMERS.
1:26:55 HE HAS BEEN AIMING TO FRAGMENT THE CUSTOMER BASE.
1:27:03 IN WAS SUPPORTING -- NVIDIA WAS SUPPORTING THE CLOUD, CREATING A
1:27:05 LARGER CUSTOMER BASE. LOSING SUCH A STRATEGIC
1:27:13 COORDINATION COULD STRENGTHEN THE LARGEST BUYERS LIKE THE
1:27:14 HYPER SKATERS. THAT IS THE MAIN THING ON THE
1:27:20 BROADER AI INDUSTRY THAT WE SHOULD BE LOOKING FOR.
1:27:26 ISABELLE: HOW MUCH OF NVIDIA'S COMPETITIVE ADVANTAGES WITHIN
1:27:29 ITS SOFTWARE ECOSYSTEM AND ENGINEERING TEAM VERSUS JENSEN
1:27:34 HUANG'S PERSONAL LEADERSHIP IN YOUR VIEW.
1:27:39 ANTOINE: IT IS ONE OR ANOTHER. YOU CANNOT DISTINGUISHED ONE OR
1:27:41 ANOTHER. NVIDIA HAS BEEN THERE MULTIPLE
1:27:42 DECADES. THEY HAVE THE DOMAIN ECOSYSTEM.
1:28:04 EVERYBODY EXPECTS AMD AS WELL AND A SIX.
1:28:08 EVEN IF THEIR SHARE COMES DOWN, AT THE END OF THE DAY, THE
1:28:11 EARNINGS POWER IS MORE THAN ENOUGH TO JUSTIFY KEEPING A BUY
1:28:18 RATING ON NVIDIA TODAY. THE STOCK IS REALLY CHEAP.
1:28:21 TRADING AT SIX OR SEVEN TIMES ARE FORECAST FOR EARNINGS.
1:28:24 VONNIE: SURE. THAT'S GREAT.
1:28:29 BUT TODAY YOU HAVE TO TAKE ADVANTAGE OF THIS, NO?
1:28:33 ANTOINE: LOOK AT THE COMPUTING PLATFORMS.
1:28:35 BUT IT WILL TAKE TIME. IT WOULD NEED CUSTOMERS TO RENEW
1:28:45 THEIR DEPENDENCE ON NVIDIA. AMD, CUSTOM CHIPS.
1:28:50 THE LEADERSHIP UNCERTAINTY DOES NOT NECESSARILY OR AUTOMATICALLY
1:28:56 TRANSFER THE DOMINANCE WE TALKED ABOUT.
1:29:03 OUR CUSTOMERS NEED COMPETITIVE SOFTWARE, HARDWARE.
1:29:07 TODAY IT WILL TAKE TIME. IT WILL NOT HAPPEN OVERNIGHT.
1:29:18 ISABELLE: IS THIS A BUYING OPPORTUNITY FOR YOU OR DO YOU
1:29:21 THINK INVESTORS ARE UNDERESTIMATING THE OPPORTUNITY
1:29:24 THAT COULD BE HAD? ANTOINE: NVIDIA IS A GREAT
1:29:28 OPPORTUNITY BUYING TODAY. $160 NOW AGAINST OUR EARNINGS
1:29:39 FORECAST FOR CALENDAR 2028. THAT PRICE IS MUCH MORE THAN THE
1:29:42 DAMAGE. I SAW THE NEWS FLOW THAT JENSEN
1:29:54 WON'T TAKE ANOTHER ROLE NEAR-TERM.
1:29:56 WITHOUT THE CEO, AT SOME POINT, HE COULD COME BACK ONE WAY OR
1:29:58 ANOTHER. AND HELP NVIDIA MAINTAIN ITS
1:30:02 DOMINANT POSITION. WE HAVE SEEN IN THE PAST
1:30:06 EVIDENCE OF THAT. AT ONE NETWORK, RESIGN AS A
1:30:14 CHAIRMAN AND A DIRECTOR AFTER ALLEGATIONS OF INSIDER TRADING.
1:30:22 HE REMAINS, TODAY, THE CHIEF ARCHITECT.
1:30:31 THERE ARE MANY OUTCOMES TODAY THAT COULD BRING THAT JENSEN
1:30:35 BACK. THE STOCK IS REALLY CHEAP.
1:30:40 VONNIE: WHO ARE YOU LOOKING TO FOR A POTENTIAL REPLACEMENT?
1:30:45 THE HUGGING FACE CEO TWEETING TODAY THIS IS AN UNFORTUNATE
1:30:46 SITUATION. WOULD HE BE SOMEONE FROM OUT OF
1:30:50 THE BLUE, THAT COULD TAKEOVER THAT IS NOT THAT KNOWN TO THE
1:30:53 MARKETS ARE WOULD IT NEED TO BE AN EXECUTIVE WE ALREADY KNOW?
1:31:00 ANTOINE: IT WOULD NEED TO BE SOMEBODY WHO IS CAPABLE OF
1:31:04 DRIVING ALL OF THE STRATEGIC DECISIONS AND PARTNERSHIPS THAT
1:31:05 JENSEN HAS BEEN DRIVING. VONNIE: ANY NAMES?
1:31:10 ANTOINE: SPECIFIC NAMES? THE FORMER CEO.
1:31:19 HUGGING FACE. I DON'T HAVE ADDITIONAL INSIGHT.
1:31:26 VONNIE: WOULD TIM COOK BE A GOOD REPLACEMENT?
1:31:29 HE HAD SENT REALLY LEANED INTO AI -- HAS NOT REALLY LEANED INTO
1:31:30 AI. ANTOINE: IS -- IT IS NOT ABOUT
1:31:37 LEADING INTO AI. NVIDIA IS AN IMPORTANT SUPPLY
1:31:39 CHAIN COMPANY THESE DAYS. THE SERVERS THAT GET ASSEMBLED.
1:31:48 FOX, AND IS ALSO INVOLVED IN ASSEMBLING THE IPHONE AND NVIDIA
1:31:49 SERVERS. IT IS A SUPPLY CHAIN THESE DAYS
1:31:55 TO RUN AI INFRASTRUCTURE AND AI DATA CENTERS.
1:31:58 THAT WILL BE AN ISSUE. THAT WOULD MAKE SENSE.
1:32:09 VONNIE: THANK YOU, ANTOINE. COMING UP, AS WELL EDGEWELL
1:32:20 CEO ROD LITTLE.
1:32:39 LET'S CHECK MARKETS.
1:32:40 ON THIS Suspicious DAY, THE 12TH OF NOVEMBER, THE DAY JENSEN
1:32:45 HUANG RESIGNED. NVIDIA CLOSE TO WHAT SIZE OF THE
1:32:46 SESSION. -- IT'S HIGHS OF THE SESSION.
1:32:54 THE NASDAQ 100 DOWN .4%. THE S&P 500 AT IT'S HIGHS OF THE
1:33:00 DAY. BRENT CRUDE ERASING SOME GAINS.
1:33:07 DONALD TRUMP WAYNE IN SAYING TIM COOK SHOULD POTENTIALLY BE A
1:33:12 SUCCESSOR TO JENSEN'S LON --JENSEN HUANG.
1:33:25 LET'S LOOK AT THE RADAR MOVERS. >> ELI LILLY THE FIRST DRUGMAKER
1:33:38 TO GET A GLP-1 PILL APPROVED IN CHINA.
1:33:39 SHARES OF THE COMPANY ARE HIGHER BY 1%.
1:33:45 NEXT, YETI MISSING SALES AND EXPECTATIONS.
1:33:49 WEAKER DEMAND IN THE U.S. AND CANADA.
1:33:55 CONSUMERS REMAIN CAUTIOUS ABOUT SPENDING.
1:33:56 SHARES OF THE COMPANY DOWN MORE THAN 8%.
1:34:09 AND EDGEWELL REPORTING OF 3% SALES JUMP YEAR OVER YEAR WITH
1:34:13 SHARES HIGHER BY ABOUT .2% FOLLOWING THAT REPORT.
1:34:17 ISABELLE: LET'S GET MORE ON THOSE RESULTS ON THE OUTLOOK
1:34:20 WITH ROD LITTLE THE CEO OF EDGEWEKLL.
1:34:28 YOU CAME IN SLIGHTLY AHEAD OF ESTIMATES.
1:34:32 HOW MUCH OF THAT IS GENUINE VOLUME GROWTH VERSUS PRICING?
1:34:35 CONSUMERS ARE STILL FEELING A LITTLE PINCH.
1:34:41 WE HAVE BEEN OUT OF FAVOR. AS THE TAKE AND AI TRADE HAS
1:34:52 PLAYED OUT OVER THE LAST COUPLE YEARS.
1:35:01 BUT WHEN YOU LOOK AT WHAT IS GOOD ABOUT CONSUMER TODAY, IT IS
1:35:04 A MIX OF VOLUME GROWTH AND PRICE GROWTH BOTH.
1:35:08 THE GUIDANCE WE GAVE FOR THE YEAR AHEAD IS GUIDING SALES
1:35:14 GROWTH IN THE RANGE OF 1%-3%, ONE THIRD VOLUME GROWTH AND TWO
1:35:15 THIRDS PRICE IN OUR ESTIMATE. IT'S A MIXED BALANCE.
1:35:20 WHEN YOU PUT THE RIGHT PRODUCT IN FRONT OF CONSUMERS, THERE IS
1:35:24 A WILLINGNESS TO PAY MORE FOR A BETTER PRODUCT OR EXPERIENCE.
1:35:34 VONNIE: YOU HAD COME UNDER PRESSURE FOR YOUR MARGINS
1:35:35 EARLIER IN THE YEAR. YOU SEEM TO HAVE EXPANDED YOUR
1:35:38 MARGINS SUBSTANTIALLY AGAIN. HOW DID YOU DO THAT WITH OIL
1:35:43 PRICES SO HIGH AND EVERYTHING ELSE?
1:35:49 ROD: QUARTER FOUR WE REPORTED THE GROSS MARGIN UP TO FIVE
1:35:51 BASIS POINTS, OUR STRONGEST OF THE YEAR.
1:35:56 PRICE PER SHARE UP TO 50%. SOME OF THAT IS WHAT WAS IN THE
1:35:57 BASE. SOME WAS GOOD PRODUCTIVITY WORK
1:36:02 THAT THE TEAMS ARE DOING. WE HAVE BEEN FOCUSED ON REVENUE
1:36:05 GROWTH MANAGEMENT AND EXPANDING GROSS MARGIN WITH LESS REDUCTION
1:36:10 FROM THOSE SALES. LET'S PROPOSE SHOULD --
1:36:13 PROMOTIONAL INTENSITY, LOWER COUPONS.
1:36:16 TAKING THE PRICE DISCOUNT MONEY AND PUTTING IT INTO ADVERTISING.
1:36:22 THEY HAVE GREAT CONTENT. CONSUMERS RESPOND TO THAT.
1:36:24 IT IS HELPING THE MARGIN LINE. ISABELLE: WE ARE SEEING MORE
1:36:33 SINGLE INCOME HOUSEHOLDS. IS THAT CHANGING HOW YOU PACKAGE
1:36:34 YOUR PRODUCTS? >> HOW MANY UNITS PER PACKAGE?
1:36:41 WHAT IS THE PRICE PER UNIT? TRYING TO FIGURE OUT OPENING
1:36:45 PRICES FOR CONSUMERS ON A WEEKLY OR MONTHLY INCOME TO STILL GET
1:36:47 OUR PRODUCT. IN SHAVING, WE ARE THE LEADER
1:36:53 GLOBALLY IN PRIVATE LABEL OPENING PRICE POINT PRODUCTS.
1:36:59 IF YOU GO TO WALMART, NCE EQUATE BRAND OF RAZORS, WE MAKE THEM.
1:37:05 -- THE EQUATE BRAND OF RAZORS, WE MAKE THEM.
1:37:08 WE ARE CLOSE TO THE LOWER END CONSUMERS AND MAKING SURE THERE
1:37:09 ARE OFFERINGS THAT FIT THEIR NEEDS.
1:37:17 VONNIE: YOUR STOCK IS UP 7% YEAR TO DATE.
1:37:21 HAVE YOU RECEIVED REQUEST FOR FINANCIALS?
1:37:25 ROD: I CANNOT COMMENT ON SPECIFIC CALLS.
1:37:28 VONNIE: SO YOU HAVE HAD THEM. ROD: WE ALWAYS GET CALLS.
1:37:34 THERE ARE ALWAYS PEOPLE INTERESTED IN WHAT WE ARE DOING
1:37:36 AND LEARNING FROM EACH OTHER. I TELL YOU, THE BETTER YOU DO,
1:37:40 THE BETTER YOUR RESULTS ARE, THE MORE ATTRACTIVE YOU ARE, AND THE
1:37:42 MORE BECAUSE YOU GET. THIS IS HUMAN NATURE.
1:37:48 IN OUR SIZE AND SPACE, WHAT HAS DRIVEN THE INCREASE MORE THAN
1:37:52 ANYTHING IS CONSISTENT, RELIABLE, DELIVERED RESULTS.
1:37:57 DOING WHAT WE SAY, REFLECTING FROM A SALES DECLINE INTO SALES
1:37:59 GROWTH AND MARGIN EXPANSION COMING WITH IT.
1:38:04 THE OTHER THING IS DURABILITY. INVESTORS LOOK TO DURABILITY.
1:38:06 CAN YOU CONTINUE TO DO WHAT YOU ARE DOING?
1:38:11 IN OUR CASE, THE CONCLUSION, MORE AND MORE, IS YES.
1:38:15 THREE YEARS AGO WE WERE SPENDING 10% OF REVENUE ON ADVERTISING
1:38:20 AND PROMOTION AND TODAY IT IS 13%.
1:38:22 WE HAVE INCREASED INVESTMENT IN OUR BRANDS IN A SIGNIFICANT WAY.
1:38:26 CONSISTENCY IN OUR CATEGORY IS VERY IMPORTANT.
1:38:33 ISABELLE: GLP-1 ARE CHANGING THE WAY AMERICAN STRESS, EAT, AND
1:38:34 CONSUME. IS THAT CHANGING YOUR PRODUCT?
1:38:42 ROD: ONLY IN A POSITIVE WAY. PEOPLE CARE MORE ABOUT WHAT THEY
1:38:44 LOOK LIKE. THEY ARE TRYING TO REDUCE
1:38:45 EXPOSURE TO THE SUN. WE ARE THE NUMBER ONE
1:38:51 MANUFACTURER IN THE U.S. FOR SOME CARE.
1:38:56 AS PEOPLE CARE MORE ABOUT TAKING CARE OF THEMSELVES, WHETHER IT
1:39:00 IS WEIGHT LOSS OR HOW THEY PHYSICALLY PRESENT THEMSELVES,
1:39:02 OUR PRODUCTS ARE ABOUT SKINCARE AND HOW YOU SHOW UP AND PRESENT
1:39:03 YOURSELF. VONNIE: I CAN'T WAIT TO SEE WHAT
1:39:11 THE FUTURE QUARTERS BRING. EDGEWELL PERSONAL- CARE CEO
1:39:19 ROD LITTLE. THIS IS BLOOMBERG OPEN INTEREST.
1:39:37 VONNIE: THE NASDAQ 100 DOWN .1%.
1:39:40 NVIDIA IS DOWN 5%. BEFORE THE MARKET OPENED IT WAS
1:39:44 DOWN 30%. I WANT TO POINT TO THE S&P 500.
1:39:50 ABOUT TO GO POSITIVE. GOLD AT $3900 PER OUNCE.
1:40:00 MICRO STRATEGY OUT OF THE FSC I INDEX.
1:40:04 THE TWO YEAR YIELD CONTINUES TO RISE.
1:40:08 THE BOND MARKET REOPENS TODAY AT 48370.
1:40:13 THE HIKE PRICED IN THICKER AND FASTER.
1:40:13 THE BELLY OF THE CURVE HIGHER. AT THE LONG AND AT 53992.
1:40:24 ISABELLE: TOMORROW WE WILL HEAR FROM THE CEO OF FERRARI TO TALK
1:40:31 MARKETS AND LIZ ANN SAUNDERS OF MORGAN STANLEY AND CHARLES SCHWAB
For Ex-Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang, ‘The Journey Is the Destination’ full transcript
0:01 Uh, 27 years ago. Mhm.
0:04 Nvidia went public. Mhm.
0:07 And they
0:11 put me in this hotel. Oh really.
0:13 Yes. It was the first time I ever had a
0:15 butler. Those are 2000.
0:17 And you'll be blown away.
0:20 $300 million. It's.
0:25 Things have changed. $300 million.
0:29 That was a lot back then, though. No, no, no, I was fine.
0:33 I was just happy to make it. You were such an unlikely winner back
0:36 then. Yeah, I was just happy to stay in
0:39 business. You know what I was doing?
0:41 Did not write a business plan. And now you know I still don't have a
0:46 ride. That's what makes this trip a success.
0:52 Is it like government commitments? Selling chips, data centers.
0:57 You know, I don't. I don't have a endgame.
1:00 I don't have a roadmap. You know, I don't have.
1:05 I don't have a plan. I'm not trying to get anywhere.
1:08 You know, there's no completion. I'm kind of one of those.
1:11 One of those people that that, uh. The journey.
1:15 The journey is the destination.
Bloomberg Surveillance 11/12/2026 full transcript
0:05 >> THERE'S THIS KIND OF BLACK CLOUD AROUND AI THAT KIND OF
0:11 COMES OUT OF TH EVERY WEEK. >> THEY I TRADE ISRAEL.
0:16 >> WE ARE FOUR YEARS INTO A BULL MARKET.
0:20 IT SHOULD BE A LITTLE CREAKY OR AT THIS AGE BUT BY NO MEANS
0:20 OVER. >> THIS IS "BLOOMBERG
0:23 SURVEILLANCE" WITH JONATHAN FERRO, LISA ABRAMOWICZ, AND
0:27 ANNMARIE HORDERN. LISA: LIVE FROM NEW YORK, THIS
0:30 IS "BLOOMBERG SURVEILLANCE." PAIN DEEPENING AROUND NVIDIA AS
0:35 NEWS EMERGED OF A SECOND EXTRAMARITAL AFFAIR BY ITS CEO.
0:39 BOARD MEMBERS MEETING TO DECIDE WHETHER TO OUST JENSEN HUANG,
0:45 WILLINGNESS TO FINANCE THE BROADER TECHNICAL SYSTEM.
0:48 TECH STOCKS BROADLY INFLECTING LOWER THIS MORNING, WHILE
0:51 ANTHROPIC CONTINUES TO MARKET IS MEGA IPO.
0:55 A TEST OF RESILIENCE IN THE AI TRADE AT A TIME OF SO MUCH
0:55 UNCERTAINTY. ANNMARIE: ANOTHER TEST FOR THIS
1:01 TRADE AS ALL EYES ARE GRIPPED WEATHER ON WALL STREET OR
1:02 WASHINGTON INTO WHAT IS GOING TO HAPPEN AT THE TOP OF THIS
1:06 INCREDIBLY IMPORTANT CHIPMAKER. WE ARE TALKING ABOUT A CHIPMAKER
1:08 VALUED AT $4 TRILLION. THIS POTENTIAL VOID THAT COULD
1:12 HAPPEN IF JENSEN HUANG IS NO LONGER THE LEADER, AND WHO COULD
1:17 BE THE NEXT SUCCESSOR, AND WHAT THIS MEANS NOT JUST FOR THE TECH
1:18 TRADE, NOT JUST FOR THE FINANCING, BUT ALSO NATIONAL
1:21 SECURITY AND INTERNATIONAL RELATIONS.
1:26 LISA: ALMOST $700 BILLION OF MARKET VALUATION HAS BEEN
1:29 STRIPPED FROM NVIDIA'S COMPANY VALUE SINCE FRIDAY WHEN WE FIRST
1:32 LEARNED ABOUT SOME OF THE DRAMA INITIALLY WITH THE SUSPECTED SPY
1:38 FOR CHINA, WHO REPORTEDLY ITS NOW IN BEIJING.
1:41 NOW WITH HER SECOND PERSON, A DIRECT REPORT OF HIS, WHAT THIS
1:47 MEANS FOR NVIDIA, BUT ALSO ALL THE COMPANIES IT BACKS.
1:49 WE ARE TALKING COREWEAVE, AND INTEL, A
1:55 CENTRAL BANK TO. ANNMARIE: NVIDIA IS THE GLUE TO
1:58 THIS ENTIRE TRADE. NVIDIA IS THE BACKBONE OF AI AND
2:03 JENSEN HUANG HAS BEEN THE FACE FOR IT.
2:05 THAT IS WHY THIS IS STORY SO IMPORTANT, WHICH IS WHY A LOT OF
2:12 ABOUT WHAT THEY WANT TO DO. DO THEY DECIDE HE NEEDS TO LEAVE
2:17 OR POTENTIALLY IS THERE A SIX-MONTH LEAVE OF ABSENCE?
2:20 IT'S GOING TO BE A VERY INTERESTING MOMENT BECAUSE
2:22 WHAT'S THE SHORT LIST? THERE'S NOT A TON OF PEOPLE WHO
2:25 CAN STEP UP AND DO THIS JOB. DO THEY HAVE TO LOOK INTERNALLY?
2:31 WE HAVE SOME REPORTING THEY ARE ACTUALLY LOOKING ELSEWHERE
2:32 EXTERNAL. LISA: HAS COUSIN AT AMD, A
2:35 QUESTION GOING FORWARD. THERE IS A BIG ISSUE IN
2:41 WASHINGTON, D C, RAMPING UP AHEAD OF THE PRESIDENT'S TRIP TO
2:46 CHINA, GIVEN THE FACT THAT THIS REALLY RAMPS UP CALLS FOR
2:47 TIGHTENING EXPORT CONTROLS ON CHIPS.
2:54 BIG QUESTIONS ABOUT WHY THE COMMERCE DEPARTMENT HAS NOT
2:56 IMPLEMENTED MORE STRICTLY SOME OF THE CONSTRAINTS ALREADY
2:58 APPROVED BY CONGRESS IN THIS PRESIDENT.
3:00 ANNMARIE: AXIOS HAD THIS REPORTING YESTERDAY.
3:02 I HAVE MORE COLOR ON THIS AS WELL.
3:05 A HUGE FACE-OFF BETWEEN TREASURY SECRETARY SCOTT BESSENT
3:11 AND HOWARD LUTNICK BEHIND CLOSED DOORS WHERE BESSENT CONFRONTED
3:13 HOWARD LUTNICK. THE FINANCIAL TIMES REPORTING IT
3:17 WAS THE DEPARTMENT OF ENERGY, THE DOD, THE STATE DEPARTMENT,
3:23 SECRETARY RUBIO WAS THE ONE THAT WAS DRAFTING THAT MEMO TALKING
3:27 BUT WE NEED TO BE SUSPICIOUS OF THIS WOMAN, THIS ALLEGED CHINESE
3:32 SPY, WHO IS VERY
3:37 CLOSE CLEARLY TO JENSEN HUANG. I WILL LEAVE YOU WITH THIS ONE.
3:42 WE HEARD FROM SENATOR JOHN KENNEDY OF LOUISIANA SPEAKING TO
3:45 POLITICO. THE OBVIOUS QUESTION.
3:49 IS WHY HE CHOSE TO ADVANCE CHIPS.
3:53 SEC. LUTNICK NEEDS TO ANSWER THAT -- SELL ADVANCED CHIPS.
3:56 COUNTRY. LISA: YOU'RE SEEING THE BIGGEST
4:01 DECLINE COME FROM THE NASDAQ, ALTHOUGH IT REALLY IS A MOTLEY
4:03 PICTURE WHEN YOU TAKE A LOOK AT FUTURES.
4:06 THE NASDAQ UNDERPERFORMING THIS MORNING, DOWN ABOUT 0.8%, 0.4%
4:12 DECLINE ON S&P FUTURES. THE BOND MARKET REOPENING AFTER
4:15 BEING CLOSED YESTERDAY. WHAT DID I MISS, THE BOND MARKET
4:18 SAYS. IS THIS A HAVEN?
4:22 THAT IS THE QUESTION AFTER A SELLOFF THAT WAS BRUTAL ON
4:24 TUESDAY FOLLOWING THE HOTTER THAN EXPECTED CPI THIS MORNING,
4:27 CONTINUING WITH THAT SELLOFF. TWO BASIS POINT INCREASE AT THE
4:30 FRONT END OF THE YIELD CURVE. WE HAVE INCREASED ABOUT 25 BASIS
4:35 POINTS IN A COUPLE OF WEEKS ON EXPECTATIONS THAT THE FED COULD
4:37 RAISE RATES AT LEAST THREE MORE TIMES.
4:41 IF YOU LOOK UNDER THE HOOD, NVIDIA IS THE ONE TAKING A LOT
4:44 OF THE HEAT OUT OF ALL OF THE DISCUSSIONS THIS MORNING, BUT
4:46 THERE ARE SOME WINNERS. NVIDIA SHARES DOWN 6.7%.
4:51 LET'S TAKE A LOOK AT SOME OF ITS COMPETITORS, AMD,
4:58 BROADCOM, ALPHABET, GOOGLES PARENT COMPANY.
5:02 AMD UP 3.5% THIS MORNING AS PEOPLE SAY, WELL, MAYBE SOME OF
5:05 THE BUSINESS CAN MIGRATE ELSEWHERE.
5:09 COMING UP, ANGELO ZINO AS NVIDIA'S BOARD CONSIDERS OUSTING
5:12 JENSEN HUANG, KATE LERNER OF TOURIST, AND TED MORTONSON ON
5:16 WHAT HE CALLS A DISASTER IN CORPORATE GOVERNANCE.
5:19 BEGIN THIS HOUR WITH NVIDIA SHARES SINKING IN THE PREMARKET
5:21 AS A FUTURE OF ITS EMBATTLED CEO HANGS IN THE BALANCE.
5:25 >> YOU HAVE TO HOLD YOURSELF RESPONSIBLE.
5:27 YOU HAVE AGENCY. YOU ARE THE CEO OF THE COMPANY,
5:30 FOR GOD SIX. YOU HAVE TO HAVE HIGH STANDARDS
5:33 AND EXPECTATIONS. JUST AS I CAN BE FIRED, THE NEXT
5:37 CEO HAS TO BE HIRED. I LIKE THAT WE CAN BE NOT OVERLY
5:40 COMPLACENT ABOUT OUR POSITION INSIDE THE COMPANY.
5:42 YOU ARE ALWAYS VULNERABLE. YOU ARE ALWAYS EARNING IT.
5:46 LISA: NVIDIA'S BOARD MEETING TO DISCUSS JENSEN HUANG'S POTENTIAL
5:47 REMOVAL. MATT BLOXHAM JOINS US NOW.
5:51 THANK YOU SO MUCH FOR BEING WITH US.
5:54 I WANT TO START WITH WHAT WE KNOW ABOUT THE TIMELINE THAT THE
5:57 BOARD HAS TO MAKE A DECISION BY JENSEN HUANG'S FUTURE, AS WELL
5:59 AS BRINGING IN SOMEONE ELSE TO REPLACE HIM.
6:09 TICKING AND ALL EYES ON THE ROAD PROBABLY
6:13 LITERALLY ARE ON THE. INCREDIBLY IMPORTANT DECISION,
6:18 NOT JUST FOR THE COMPANY BEFORE THE WIDER AI ECOSYSTEM -- AI
6:31 DUTY THEY HAVE TO SHAREHOLDERS BUT THEY ALSO HAVE TO THINK
6:34 ABOUT THE POTENTIAL AND NATIONAL SECURITY ISSUES.
6:39 ERICSON WAS SUBJECT TO QUITE SUBSTANTIAL U.S. INVESTIGATIONS
6:43 AND LIMITATIONS ON THEIR ABILITY TO KIND OF TRADE BECAUSE OF KIND
6:46 OF MISDEMEANORS. I THINK THERE IS A HUGE AMOUNT
6:49 HERE AND THEY WILL WANT TO TAKE THE TIME IT NEEDS THEM TO TAKE
6:53 TO COME TO THE RIGHT DECISION. LISA: DO WE HAVE A SENSE OF WHAT
6:56 TYPE OF CEO THEY COULD POTENTIALLY TAP?
7:02 AT THIS POINT, WE HEARD JENSEN HUANG TALK ABOUT THE IMPORTANCE
7:06 LITTLE BY WAY OF ANY KIND OF SUCCESSION PLAN.
7:08 MATT: YEAH. AND OBVIOUSLY, YOU NEVER KNOW
7:14 WHO IS HIDING BENEATH JENSEN RIGHT NOW WHO IS INCREDIBLY
7:15 CAPABLE. SOMETIMES, THESE AMOUNTS DUE
7:22 BRING NEW, INCREDIBLY STRONG TALENT TO THE FOUR THAT WE'VE
7:24 NEVER HEARD ABOUT BEFORE. IF IT IS SOMEBODY WELL-KNOWN,
7:30 HAVE TO MATCH. THEY'RE GOING TO HAVE TO HAVE
7:34 JENSEN'S KIND OF DEGREE OF NETWORKING AND CREDIBILITY,
7:37 CREATIVITY, AND KIND OF INSIGHT ABOUT THE INDUSTRY, BECAUSE
7:40 YOU'RE GOING TO HAVE TO GO SHOULDER TO SHOULDER WITH THE
7:44 BIGGEST NAMES IN THE INDUSTRY, AND CUT INCREDIBLY
7:47 GOOD DEALS FOR NVIDIA. THAT KIND OF SHRINKS THE PULL OF
7:50 WELL-KNOWN TALENT THAT THEY COULD CONSIDER.
7:54 LISA: MATT BLOXHAM OF BLOOMBERG INTELLIGENCE, THANK YOU SO MUCH
7:56 FOR BEING WITH US THIS MONEY. ANGELO ZINO OF CFRA DOWNGRADING
8:06 NVIDIA TO A BUY AND LOWERING HIS PRICE TARGET.
8:10 A REST JENSEN HAS LONG BEEN THE SINGULAR ARCHITECT OF NVIDIA
8:12 STRATEGY AND CULTURE AND A FORCED EXIT WOULD CREAM AN
8:14 UNCERTAINTIES THAT WILL LIKELY LIMIT UPSIDE.
8:16 HE JOINS US NOW FROM WORK. INTERESTING THAT YOU STILL HAVE
8:21 A BUY RATING, USED TO HAVE A HIGHER TARGET EVEN AS OTHER
8:25 PROSPECTS FOR A WHILE. WHY ARE YOU STICKING WITH THAT
8:28 HIGHER PRICE TARGET? >> THANKS FOR HAVING ME.
8:33 I WOULD SAY THIS IS DEFINITELY VERY FLUID IN NATURE AND
8:35 SOMETHING THAT WE CONTINUE TO REVIEW IN TERMS OF BOTH OUR BUY
8:38 RECOMMENDATION AND TARGET PRICE. THOSE CHANGES WERE MADE EARLIER
8:41 IN THE WEEK. I WOULD SAY THIS MAY BE ONE OF
8:45 THE POSITIVES WE HAVE SEEN IN TERMS OF THE STOCK PRICE OVER
8:48 THE LAST COUPLE OF DAYS AND WHILE WE HAVE NOT NECESSARILY
8:53 GONE TO A HOLD AT THIS POINT. WE DEFINITELY GOT A WASHOUT
8:57 ACROSS THE AI ECOSYSTEM LAST WEEK WHEN YOU LOOK AT HOW MUCH
9:00 DAMAGE HAS BEEN DONE TO THE STOCK OVER THE LAST WEEK OR SO.
9:03 WE THINK IT IS LARGELY DISCOUNTING OR HEAVILY
9:04 DISCOUNTED A POTENTIAL CHANGE. I DON'T WANT TO NECESSARILY DO
9:10 MORE DAMAGE, YOU KNOW, IN TERMS OF A POTENTIAL DOWNGRADE.
9:13 WE KIND OF LOOK AT THE VALUATION OF THIS COMPANY, TRADING EIGHT
9:18 TIMES ON 28 BASIS. WE DON'T KNOW WHETHER OR NOT
9:21 JENSEN IS TRULY AT THE DOOR AT THIS POINT IN TIME OR WHO A
9:25 POTENTIAL REPLACEMENT WOULD BE, SO A LOT OF MOVING PARTS HERE AT
9:26 THIS POINT IN TIME. ANNMARIE: GIVEN THE STRUCTURE OF
9:29 THIS COMPANY AND HOW IT HAS BEEN SO FLAT, HE HAS HAD ALL THESE
9:36 DIRECT REPORTS DIRECTLY TO HIM, SOME 60 OR 70 PEOPLE, DO YOU SEE
9:39 THERE IS SOMEONE INTERNALLY, AT LEAST IN THE INTERIM, THAT COULD
9:41 SHEPHERD THIS COMPANY? OR ARE THEY GOING TO HAVE TO
9:45 LOOK EXTERNALLY ON DAY ONE? >> MY GUESS IS THEY WILL
9:49 PROBABLY HAVE TO LOOK EXTERNALLY FOR A PERMANENT REPLACEMENT.
9:53 ON AN INTERIM BASIS, I WOULD THINK THE ONES THAT WOULD BE
9:55 MOST LIKELY TO LEAD THE CHARGE WOULD BE COLLET KRESS, THE CFO,
10:06 OR IAN BUCK, BELIEVES THEIR DATA CENTER AI ACCELERANT BUSINESS,
10:10 THE GUY WHO HAS BEEN DUBBED AS THE GUY WHO HAS CREATED KUDA.
10:16 THOSE WOULD BE THE TWO INDIVIDUALS OUT THERE.
10:19 WHETHER OR NOT THERE IS SOMEONE THAT COULD POTENTIALLY BE A LONG
10:22 TIME, YOU KNOW, PERMANENT REPLACEMENT INTERNALLY, I WOULD
10:25 SAY AT THIS POINT, PROBABLY NOT. I WOULD THINK THEY WOULD
10:28 PROBABLY BE LOOKING EXTERNALLY. ANNMARIE: AT THE SAME TIME, YOU
10:32 DO HAVE THE WALL STREET JOURNAL SAYING THAT THEY ARE PREPARING
10:35 TO HANG ON? >> I THINK THERE'S ALWAYS A
10:37 CHANCE. I WOULD SAY OUR BASE CASE AT
10:41 THIS POINT IN TIME THOUGH IS PROBABLY THERE IS JUST SO MUCH
10:46 LINGERING OVER THIS WHOLE SITUATION AT THIS POINT IN TIME,
10:52 I THINK YOU ARE GOING TO, I THINK THERE IS A REAL RISK, AND
10:56 I WOULD PROBABLY SAY MORE THAN A 50% CHANCE AT THIS POINT IN TIME
10:59 THAT YOU GOT TO BE THINKING OF WHO HIS REPLACEMENT IS GOING
11:02 TO BE.
11:10 I THINK JENSEN PROBABLY MORE LIKELY HAS A FOOT
11:11 OUT THE DOOR AT THIS TIME. LISA: IS THIS AN NVIDIA PROBLEM
11:14 OR AN ENTIRE TECH TRADE PROBLEM? >> I THINK IT IS BOTH.
11:18 I THINK IT IS MORE OF AN NVIDIA PROBLEM, TO BE HONEST WITH YOU.
11:22 I THINK WE ARE ACTUALLY FAR ENOUGH IN TERMS OF THIS ENTIRE
11:24 AI ECOSYSTEM, THIS INFRASTRUCTURE BUILD, TO A POINT
11:30 WHERE, AND THE DEMAND IS JUST SO HIGH FOR AI AT THIS POINT IN
11:32 TIME AND FOR COMPUTE, IT IS REALLY ALMOST IMPOSSIBLE TO MOVE
11:33 BACKWARDS. EVERYBODY OUT THERE ACROSS THE
11:39 OF THESE NEXGEN APPLICATIONS OTHER, I MEAN, IT'S ALMOST
11:45 IMPOSSIBLE TO KIND OF REVERT BACK TO THE OLD DAYS.
11:48 THAT BEING SAID, I THINK IT IS PROBABLY MORE IMPORTANT FOR, A
11:53 GEOPOLITICAL UNCERTAINTY IS OUT THERE, THE POTENTIAL EXPORT
11:57 RESTRICTIONS THAT CAN BE THROWN HERE FOR NVIDIA.
12:02 IN MY VIEW, NVIDIA HAS PROBABLY GOT THE MOST VALUABLE IP ON THE
12:03 PLANET.
12:08 THE VISION HERE OF NVIDIA'S
12:10 GOING TO BE CALLED INTO QUESTION.
12:12 WHEN YOU THINK OF GTC COMING UP IN MARCH, IT'S PROBABLY NEVER
12:14 GOING TO BE THE SAME AGAIN. WHEN YOU THINK ABOUT GTC, IT'S
12:20 BEEN ALL OVER THE PLACE. IT'S BEEN JENSEN FROM DAY ONE TO
12:21 THE LAST DAY OF THE EVENT. THEN YOU KIND OF START THINKING
12:26 ABOUT THE LEGAL RISK, THE FUNDAMENTAL RISK POTENTIALLY.
12:29 THE SUSTAINABILITY OF THE TECHNOLOGY LEAVE DANIEL CADENCES
12:33 OUT THERE, IT REALLY OPENS UP THE ANNUAL CADENCES OUT
12:38 THERE, IT REALLY OPENS UP THE OPPORTUNITY FOR THE CUSTOMS
12:40 SILICON SPACE, SOME OF THESE OTHER PROVIDERS TO ROLL OUT SOME
12:43 COMPUTING TECHNOLOGIES. OBVIOUSLY, BROADCOM, AND THEN
12:47 AMD. I THINK LISA SU HAS AN
12:50 UNBELIEVABLE OPPORTUNITY TO REALLY CHANGE THE LANDSCAPE AND
12:51 TAKE SOME SIGNIFICANT MARKET SHARE.
12:54 LISA: G THINK YOU'RE GOING TO UPGRADE THE AMD'S, BROADCOM'S,
12:58 AND OTHERS OF THE WORLD? >> SO WE DO HAVE BUY
13:02 RECOMMENDATIONS ON THOSE NAMES. LISA: I THINK WE HAVE LOST
13:05 ANGELO ZINO OF CFRA. THANK YOU SO MUCH FOR BEING WITH
13:10 US THIS MORNING AS WE PARSE TO THE RAMIFICATIONS OF THIS STORY
13:12 AND WHAT COULD POTENTIALLY HAPPEN AT NVIDIA.
13:15 IT HAS SO MANY DIFFERENT TENTACLES BECAUSE THIS HAS BEEN
13:17 ONE OF THE BIGGEST DRIVERS OF THE RALLY SINCE 2022 WHEN
13:20 CHATGPT WAS LAUNCHED. THIS HAS BEEN AN NVIDIA STORY.
13:26 80% OF ALL OF THE AI WE USE EVERY SINGLE DAY IN EVERY SINGLE
13:29 BUSINESS IS DERIVED FROM THE CHIPS THAT NVIDIA HAS CRAFTED.
13:32 ANNMARIE: AND IT IS FINANCING EVERYONE THAT IS A PART OF THIS
13:35 ENTIRE ECOSYSTEM. BUT WHEN YOU HEAR FROM ANALYSTS,
13:38 ACTUALLY LOOK LIKE WITHOUT JENSEN?
13:41 THE CHIPS ARE THE CHIPS. EVERYBODY BELIEVES THEREY OUR
13:47 WORLD-CLASS. LISA: AN INVESTIGATION ONGOING.
13:50 LET'S GET YOU AN UPDATE ON STORIES ELSEWHERE.
13:52 HERE IS YOUR BLOOMBERG BRIEF WITH VONNIE QUINN.
13:56 VONNIE: THE SUSPECTED CHINESE SPY WHO HAD AN AFFAIR WITH
13:58 NVIDIA CEO JENSEN HUANG IS BACK IN BEIJING.
14:01 SOURCES TELLING US HERE BY BLOOMBERG MEGASPEED
14:04 INTERNATIONAL FOUNDER ALICE WONG IS LIVING IN THE CHINESE CAPITAL
14:05 WITH THE KNOWLEDGE OF SECURITY OFFICIALS.
14:08 IT IS NOT CLEAR WHEN OR WHY SHE TRAVELED TO THE CAPITAL.
14:11 BEIJING HAS DENIED THE WOMAN WAS A SPY.
14:16 DEMOCRATIC SENATORS ELIZABETH WARREN AND CHRIS COONS ARE
14:18 ASKING THE TRUMP ADMINISTRATION TO PRESERVE ALL RECORDS
14:20 REGARDING THE EXPORT OF NVIDIA SHIPS TO CHINA.
14:24 THE SENATORS TELLING MARCO RUBIO, HOWARD LUTNICK, AND
14:29 STEPHEN MILLER THEIR REQUEST COMES AFTER REPORTS THAT
14:30 ADMINISTRATION OFFICIALS NEW JENSEN HUANG WAS A TARGET OF A
14:33 SUSPECTED CHINESE INTELLIGENCE OPERATION.
14:37 COREWEAVE PLANS TO RAISE AT LEAST $4 BILLION THROUGH AN
14:38 INVESTMENT GRADE BONDS SALE. SOURCES TELLING US HERE BY
14:42 BLOOMBERG MORGAN STANLEY AND MITSUBISHI UFJ ARE LEADING THE
14:46 POTENTIAL FINANCING. THE DEAL COULD COME AS SOON AS
14:49 NEXT WEEK AND THAT IS YOUR BLOOMBERG BRIEF.
14:50 LISA? LISA: CAPITAL MARKETS TO OPEN.
14:54 UP NEXT, NVIDIA'S LEADERSHIP CRISIS.
14:57 >> ONE PERSON IS NEVER BIGGER THAN CAPITALISM.
15:00 >> IF YOU RISK NATIONAL SECURITY, THERE IS NO SURVIVAL.
15:03 >> ARE SUSPECT SHE SURVIVES UNLESS HE WAS CULPABLE.
15:06 >> THE COMPUTER WILL COME FROM NVIDIA WHETHER JENSEN IS AT THE
15:07 HOME OR NOT. >> KEITH LERNER OF RAYMOND JAMES
15:11 JOINS US NEXT. THIS IS "BLOOMBERG SURVEILLANCE.”
15:46 LISA: A LOT GOING ON TODAY. AN AUCTION OF 30 YEAR BONDS WE
15:48 HAVE PLENTY OF FED SPEAK. INITIAL JOBLESS CLAIMS COMING
15:49 OUT. EARNINGS FROM COMPANIES
15:55 INCLUDING A NEO-CLOUD PROVIDER AND YET ALL ANYONE WILL TALK
16:00 ABOUT IS THE FATE OF NVIDIA WITH THE CEO AND JENSEN HUANG
16:04 POTENTIALLY ABOUT TO BE OUSTED. MASTECH FUTURES LOWER AS A
16:09 RESULT OF THE DECLINES THAT WITH SHARES LOWER MORE THAN 6%.
16:12 A QUESTION ABOUT THE BOND MARKET REOPENING TODAY.
16:17 THIS MORNING RESUMING THE SELLOFF AT THE FRONT OF THE
16:18 YIELD CURVE. TWO YEAR YIELD FOUR POINT 76%,
16:24 5% EVEN ON 10 YEARS. A QUESTION ABOUT WHERE THEY WILL
16:32 GET COMFORT. YOU'RE SEEING INVESTORS PILE
16:39 INTO BONDS AND NOW THAT'S NOT READING.
16:42 ANNMARIE: IT FEELS LIKE THERE'S NOWHERE TO HIDE.
16:47 MAYBE AMD OR BROAD, BUT AT ONE POINT YOU SAW PEOPLE GO INTO THE
16:53 BOND MARKET SOME HOT CPI HAS SCARED EVERYONE.
16:57 THIS WILL BE A BIG TEST. LISA: IT IS GOING TO BE
17:03 IMPORTANT EVEN THOUGH WE ARE FOCUSED ON NVIDIA.
17:06 NVIDIA'S LEADERSHIP CRISIS. >> ONE PERSON IS NEVER BIGGER
17:12 THAN CAPITALISM. >> THE RISK OF HIM BEING REMOVED
17:15 FROM HIS ROLE IS A SIGNIFICANT. >> NVIDIA IS NOT SET UP TO
17:20 ACCOMMODATE HIS LOSS. >> WILL BE THE CEO WITH A LITTLE
17:26 BIT LESS POWER PERHAPS. >> I SUSPECT HE SURVIVES UNLESS
17:30 HE WAS COMPROMISED. >> COMPUTER WILL COME FROM
17:35 NVIDIA WHETHER JENSEN IS THERE OR NOT.
17:39 LISA: FOLLOWING REPORTS OF MULTIPLE AFFAIRS INCLUDING ONE
17:42 WITH AN ALLEGED CHINESE SPY. KEITH LERNER OF
17:55 TRUIST WRITING A LITTLE GOOD TO GO ALONG WAY AND THE
17:56 PSYCHOLOGY COULD QUICKLY CHANGE. ARE YOU BUYING WHAT THEY ARE
18:02 SELLING RIGHT NOW IN TERMS OF THE TECH HEAVY INDEX?
18:09 KEITH: MY NOTE WAS FROM THURSDAY , I STILL THINK ULTIMATELY
18:12 THAT'S RIGHT AS FAR AS TECH. WE HAVE THIS CAROUSEL OF
18:17 CONCERNS. I THINK FROM OUR PERSPECTIVE AT
18:21 LEAST THE MARKET IS BETTER REFLECTING AS FAR AS WE ARE
18:25 TRADING TODAY SOME OF THOSE CONCERNS.
18:33 A COUPLE OF NUMBERS INCLUDING 17.
18:36 THE AVERAGE TECH PULLBACK HAS BEEN 17% THE TECH SECTOR HAS
18:43 OUTPERFORMED THE GLOBAL MARKET BY DOUBLE SO WE HAVE THIS
18:46 LOVE-HATE RELATIONSHIP. THE NEXT ONE IS THE PE FOR THE
18:55 TECH SECTOR, THAT'S THE LOWEST OFF THE LOWS.
19:00 ANOTHER IS 2017 THE LAST TIME THE TECH SECTOR HAS TREATED A
19:03 DISCOUNT RELATIVE TO THE OVERALL MARKET.
19:08 AS I'M THINKING ABOUT THE STORY AROUND NVIDIA AND NOT TO BE
19:12 SPECIFIC BUT IT'S LIKE TEAM USA BASKETBALL.
19:17 IF MICHAEL JORDAN IS INJURED AND THE REST OF THE TEAM CARRY
19:21 FORWARD AND THAT'S THE QUESTION INVESTORS ARE ASKING THEMSELVES.
19:24 LISA: WHAT'S THE ANSWER FROM YOUR PERSPECTIVE?
19:26 KEITH: I LISTEN TO JOHN CHAMBERS THIS WEEK.
19:33 HIS PERSPECTIVE IN THE SECOND INNING OF THIS BUILDOUT.
19:38 I LIKE TO THINK WE WILL MOVE FORWARD THIS ONCE IN A
19:43 GENERATION WILL CARRY THROUGH BUT THIS WILL BE MORE
19:44 DISCRIMINATING. OVER THE NEXT FEW WEEKS WE WILL
19:55 SEE HOW IS TECH DOING X NVIDIA. AS THE EQUAL WEIGHT DOING.
20:01 THE WEIGHTING OF NVIDIA RANGES FROM 5% TO ALMOST 20%.
20:08 SEMI CONDUCTOR ETF'S ALMOST 10% I THINK IN THIS MORE AS A P.M.
20:12 PERSPECTIVE. AND YOU HAVE NVIDIA WHETHER
20:20 SMALL OR BIG YOU HAVE TO SPEND A DISPROPORTIONATE AMOUNT OF TIME
20:22 IN THIS POSITION. I THINK THAT'S KIND OF A
20:30 CHALLENGE FOR A LITTLE BIT OF THE QUESTION.
20:37 ANNMARIE: THE TECHNOLOGY IS THE TECHNOLOGY THE CHIPS OF THE
20:39 CHIPS. WOULD YOU WANT TO GET IN AND BY
20:42 THIS DIP? KEITH: I CAN'T SPEAK SPECIFIC TO
20:49 OUR STOCKS BUT MORE BROADLY IF WE SEE A SELLOFF TO THIS MORE
20:53 BROADLY FOR TECH AND SEMICONDUCTORS, MY ANSWER WOULD
20:56 BE YES. EVEN BEFORE THIS WE HAD
21:04 BASICALLY THIS SHOCK LAST THURSDAY THAT LEADS TO
21:07 VOLATILITY. JUST BE BRACED OF THIS WILL
21:10 CONTINUE. THE NUMBERS AT 17 FOR LONG-TERM
21:18 INVESTORS. ONE OF THE LAST STATS I WILL
21:28 THROW OUT IS THE TECH SECTORS PE IS ABOUT 32 YEAR AGO.
21:34 THAT'S ABOUT A 45% CONTRACTION. SINCE THIS BULL MARKET BEGAN.
21:40 ANNMARIE: HOW IMPORTANT IS NEXT WEEK FOR YOU IN TERMS OF NVIDIA
21:42 REPORTING. KEITH: IT'S SUSCEPTIBLE TO THE
21:51 KNEE-JERK REACTION. THIS IS THE MOST IMPORTANT LEAD
21:57 UP TO THE FED REPORTS. IT IS IMPORTANT.
22:02 I DON'T KNOW IF IT GETS SOLVED AND PEOPLE EXPECT EARNINGS WILL
22:06 BE STRONG ABOUT THE PATH FORWARD.
22:07 WHAT WE'VE BEEN SEEING IN MARKETS IS EVEN THIS MORNING
22:11 USING MONEY ROTATE TO OTHER AREAS.
22:17 ON MONDAY, NVIDIA WAS DOWN MORE THAN 5% AND
22:20 SEMICONDUCTORS WERE UP 7%. WE ARE SEEING ACTION IN THE
22:26 BOND MARKET. AND THEN ALSO REPORTEDLY WE ARE
22:31 SEEING CORRELATIONS WITHIN THE MARKET THERE ARE NO LONGER
22:36 MOVING IN LOCKSTEP. THE LOWEST CORRELATIONS WITHIN
22:39 THE MARKET SINCE 2000. THAT JUST MEANS THE FIGHT
22:45 BETWEEN WINNERS AND LOSERS LIKELY CONTINUE TO REMAIN WIDE.
22:52 LISA: THANK YOU FOR BEING WITH US THIS MORNING.
22:55 WHERE'S WERE LOOKING AT THE NVIDIA NEWS.
23:01 FIRST DOWNGRADED BY BAIRD YESTERDAY WE HAD NVIDIA SHARES
23:05 CAUGHT AT BERNSTEIN. AND NOW FROM DAN IVES COMING OUT
23:13 DOWNGRADING THE OUTLOOK FOR NVIDIA TILL 25 FROM 300 EARLIER
23:21 SAYING HE THINKS THIS COMPANY IS 25% LESS WITHOUT JENSEN HUANG.
23:25 ANNMARIE: A LOT OF PEOPLE HAVE SAID HE'S TOO IMPORTANT TO THE
23:27 COMPANY. IT'S GOING TO TAKE A LOT OF
23:28 TIME. THE REAL ISSUE FOR THIS COMPANY
23:33 YOU HAD THE FIRST HIT IN TERMS OF THIS AFFAIR WITH AN ALLEGED
23:35 CHINESE SPY. NOW THIS GOES TO CORPORATE
23:42 GOVERNANCE WITH EXECUTIVES IN THE PAST.
23:45 NOT ABLE TO WITHSTAND. THIS HAS HAPPENED AT MCDONALD'S
23:47 AND INTEL. THIS GOES AGAINST I'M SURE THEIR
23:52 OWN CORPORATE POLICY ESPECIALLY GIVEN THIS WAS AN INDIVIDUAL WHO
23:54 WAS A DIRECT REPORT TO THE CEO. LISA: NVIDIA ACCOUNTS FOR 7% OF
24:00 THE NASDAQ 100. IT GIVES CHIPS TO ABOUT 30% OF
24:05 THE NASDAQ 100. MICROSOFT AMAZON, META, GOOGLE.
24:09 BIG QUESTIONS BUT THE TECH TRADE.
24:11 COMING UP, ED MILLS OF RAYMOND JAMES AS THE JENSEN HUANG
24:16 SCANDAL REVIVES NEW DEMAND FOR CHIPS.
24:19 DATING COMPANIES TURMOIL BROADCOM, AMD BOTH POSITIVE
24:25 IN PRE-MARKET TRADING. THIS IS BLOOMBERG.
24:35 ♪ LISA: THERE IS SOME STRENGTH
24:37 UNDER THE HOOD IF YOU LOOK AT THE BROAD SPECTRUM OF DIFFERENT
24:40 NAMES IN THE U.S., BUT THE FOCUS VERY MUCH THIS MORNING IS ON
24:44 NVIDIA, DRAGGING DOWN THE NASDAQ 100, DOWN .9%.
24:47 THE RUSSELL 2000, WHICH IS MORE IMMUNE TO THESE NAMES, DOESN'T
24:52 HAVE NVIDIA IN IT, BASICALLY FLAT.
24:54 FUTURES LOWER BY .4%. NVIDIA ACCOUNTS FOR 7% OF NASDAQ
24:57 100. YOU ARE SEEING THAT REFLECTED
24:59 THIS MORNING. THE BOND SPACE, BONDS WERE
25:04 CLOSED YESTERDAY. WE HAD A RALLY IN SPOT MARKETS
25:07 WERE NOT ABLE TO REFLECT THE FACT THAT THEY DON'T OFFER THE
25:10 SAME TYPE OF HAVEN THEY HAVE TWO WEEKS AGO.
25:13 WE ARE SEEING A TWO BASIS POINT INCREASE AT THE FRONT END OF THE
25:14 YIELD CURVE. 4.76% AFTER THE BIG A SELLOFF
25:19 TUESDAY AFTER THE FRONT END OF THE YIELD CURVE GOING BACK TO
25:20 LIBERATION DAY. THIS GOES TO THE HEART OF THE
25:25 ANXIETY RIGHT NOW. WHERE IS THE HAVEN?
25:28 THE TECH TURMOIL WAS PUSHING PEOPLE INTO BONDS ONLY TO FIND
25:32 NOT SO SAFE IN THE FACE OF HIGHER THAN EXPECTED INFLATION.
25:35 ANNMARIE: I THINK THE HAVEN THIS MORNING HAS TO BE NVIDIA'S
25:40 BIGGEST COMPETITORS, BROADCOM AND AMD.
25:44 THESE ARE COMPANIES THAT COULD POTENTIALLY BE THE WINNERS IF WE
25:47 SEE THE FALL OF JENSEN HUANG AND THERE IS THIS MOMENT WHERE THERE
25:51 ARE THESE CONCERNS AROUND THIS COMPANY,
25:56 ESPECIALLY IF YOU SEE ANALYST CALL AFTER ANALYST CALL.
26:01 SAYING THAT WE HAVE HAD ENOUGH, DOWNGRADE.
26:04 LISA SU, BROADCOM, ALPHABET, WHICH WE NOW HAVE BEEN TRYING TO
26:08 DEVELOP CHIPS TO CATCH UP WITH NVIDIA.
26:11 LISA: IT RAISES QUESTIONS OF FINANCING OF OTHER NAMES IN THE
26:13 U.S. TECH INDUSTRY. MEANWHILE, YOU HAVE SEEN ON THE
26:16 HEELS OF THIS EXPECTATION OF HOTTER THAN EXPECTED INFLATION,
26:19 MAY BE A RESPONSE FROM THE FEDERAL RESERVE, A STRONGER
26:24 DOLLAR, THIS HAS BEEN A STEALTH GLOBAL TIGHTENING.
26:26 YOU LOOK AT THE DOLLAR INDEX, IT'S ONE OF THE STRONGEST LEVELS
26:32 GOING BACK TO APRIL WHEN WE SAW THE WAR RAMPING UP IN IRAN.
26:35 IF YOU LOOK AT THE DOLLAR VERSUS THE JAPANESE YEN, ONE OF THE
26:38 WEAKEST LEVELS GOING BACK TO EARLY SEPTEMBER, HOW MUCH DOES
26:45 IT PRESSURE THE WORLD AND THE CENTRAL BANKS?
26:48 ISABELLE LEE. ISABELLE: THE NVIDIA SAGA
26:55 CONTINUES, JENSEN HUANG ALLEGEDLY FACING ANOTHER AFFAIR
26:57 ALLEGATION WITH A DIRECT REPORT AND WALL STREET IS INCREASING
27:00 THE QUESTION IF HE CAN SURVIVE THIS CRISIS.
27:04 SEVERAL FIRMS DOWNGRADING, BAIR D, OPPENHEIMER.
27:11 SOMETHING LIKE 250 BILLION DOLLARS IN MARKET VALUE, AND
27:14 ALSO SEE ITS MARKET THRESHOLD PUSHED BELOW THE $4 TRILLION
27:16 MARKET CAP. WE HAD ANGELO ZINO HAS A BUY
27:23 RATING, PRICE TARGET, HE SAID THE SITUATION IS FLUID, WE DON'T
27:27 KNOW WHAT WILL HAPPEN, BUT BERNSTEIN MAY NOT AGREE.
27:28 HE SAYS HE DOESN'T SEE A SITUATION.
27:34 THE BOARD WILL KEEP
27:35 HIM. $225 PER SHARE WITHOUT JENSEN
27:40 HUANG AND 300 WITH JENSEN. YOU CAN SEE THE RAMIFICATION
27:42 ACROSS THE BOARD. IF YOU LOOK AT CHINESE
27:45 HYPERSCALERS THEY ARE UNDER PRESSURE THIS MORNING AS
27:49 INVESTORS WORRY THAT TIGHTER EXPORTS WHEN IT COMES TO
27:51 SEMICONDUCTORS COULD LIMIT CHIP ACCESS WHEN IT COMES TO CHINESE
27:54 HYPERSCALERS. ALIBABA SHARES ARE LOWERED
27:57 NEARLY 4.5 PERCENT. ALIBABA IN ASIA SANK BY 5%, THE
28:03 WORST PERFORMANCE. WHEN THERE ARE LOSERS THERE ARE
28:05 ALSO WINNERS. AMH MADE THE POINT THAT MAYBE
28:09 THE SAFE HAVEN IS BROADCOM AND AMD COME YOU SEE THEM IN THE
28:12 GREEN HIGHER BY MORE THAN 1.5% IN PREMARKET SHARES AS INVESTORS
28:15 LOOK FOR ALTERNATIVES WHEN IT COMES TO NVIDIA.
28:20 LISA: NVIDIA'S BOARD WEIGHING THE FATE OF JENSEN HUANG
28:24 FOLLOWING REPORTS OF ANOTHER EXTRAMARITAL AFFAIR.
28:31 SOURCES TELL US AT BLOOMBERG NVIDIA IS
28:35 WORKING WITH AN OUTSIDE FIRM. ALICE HUANG, FOUNDER OF
28:43 DENY SHE IS A SPY. HOWARD LUTNICK REPORTEDLY
28:49 BLOCKING A CRACKDOWN ON CHIP SMUGGLING.
28:51 ACCORDING TO AXIOS, PRESIDENT TRUMP IS ATTEMPTING TO CURB
28:55 SALES TO CHINA, LUTNICK STALLING EXPORT CONTROLS AS A POTENTIAL
28:58 SPY SCANDAL WEIGHS ON THE ADMINISTRATION.
29:01 A FASCINATING REPORT HIGHLIGHTING HOW CONTENTIOUS
29:03 THIS IS REALLY GETTING BETWEEN CABINET MEMBERS OF THE
29:05 PRESIDENT. ANNMARIE: AXIOS CAP THIS AND
29:07 I'VE HEARD IT FROM MY SOURCES AS WELL.
29:12 THE STANDOFF BETWEEN SCOTT BESSENT AND HOWARD LUTNICK,
29:14 SCOTT BESSENT WENT TO THE HOWARD LUTNICK IN THIS MEETING AND
29:17 SAID, WHY IS MEGANBEAT NOT ON THE ENTITY LIST?
29:20 THIS IS ACCORDING TO THE FINANCIAL TIMES AND OTHER
29:23 CABINET OFFICIALS CONCERNED AS WELL.
29:28 I WAS THINKING YESTERDAY ABOUT ALL THE RISKS TO THE PRESIDENT'S
29:31 MESSAGING WHEN THE DEMOCRATS SWEPT AND NOW YOU WILL HAVE ALL
29:34 OF THESE REGULATIONS COME TO THE FORE AND NOISE IN WASHINGTON.
29:38 THE IDEA WAS TO MAKE THE CASE TO THE AMERICAN PEOPLE WE NEED TO
29:42 CONTINUE ON A HIKE NOT JUST FOR OUR GROWTH BUT THIS IS A
29:45 NATIONAL SECURITY STORY AND WE NEED TO BE CHINA.
29:49 IT WILL BE MORE CHALLENGING TO THEM FOR THE AMERICAN PEOPLE TO
29:52 GET ON BOARD WHEN YOU POTENTIALLY ARE IN YOUR COMMERCE
29:58 DEPARTMENT HELPING CHINA GET ACCESS TO THIS HIGH-TECH
30:00 HARDWARE. LISA: DO WE HAVE A SENSE OF HOW
30:03 MUCH HOWARD LUTNICK WAS WORKING IN CONCERT WITH PRESIDENT TRUMP
30:08 TO SLOW SOME OF THIS, ALLEGEDLY, VERSUS OPERATING INDEPENDENTLY?
30:10 ANNMARIE: AT THE END OF THE DAY YOU HAVE TO COME BACK TO THE
30:12 REPORT ABOUT THEM PICKING UP JENSEN HUANG IN ALASKA.
30:16 I THINK THE PRESIDENT AT THE END OF THE DAY SAID, SURE, WE CAN DO
30:18 THAT. DO THEY KNOW HOW MUCH
30:23 POTENTIALLY THEY WERE SLOW WALKING MEGASPEED?
30:25 I DON'T KNOW IF THE PRESIDENT IS AWARE COME IN TO BE IS NOT COME
30:28 HE CERTAINLY IS NOW. LISA: CREATING COLLATERAL DAMAGE
30:30 ON CAPITOL HILL. ELIZABETH WARREN AND CHRIS COONS
30:33 CALLING ON THE TRUMP ADMINISTRATION TO PRESERVE ALL
30:36 DOCUMENTS REGARDING THE COMPANY'S CHIEF EXPORTS TO CHINA
30:40 CITING NATIONAL SECURITY CONCERNS.
30:41 BLOOMBERG'S TYLER KENDALL JOINS US WITH THE BROADENING SCANDAL.
30:46 REAL QUESTIONS ABOUT THE IMPLICATIONS IN D.C.
30:50 TYLER: THE PRESSURE IS MOUNTING IN WASHINGTON AS THIS MARKS A
30:53 PREVIEW OF WHAT TO EXPECT IN TERMS OF THE SCRUTINY THAT COULD
30:58 BE COMING, KEEPING IN MIND THAT A DOCUMENT PRESERVATION REQUEST
31:02 IS TYPICALLY SEEN AS THE INITIAL STEP BEFORE FORMAL CONGRESSIONAL
31:04 INVESTIGATIONS ARE LAUNCHED. THESE ARE TWO LAWMAKERS POISED
31:09 THAT PRETTY INFLUENTIAL ROLES IN THE NEW CONGRESS.
31:12 SENATOR ELIZABETH WARREN IS SET TO LEAVE THE SENATE BANKING
31:15 COMMITTEE WELL SENATOR CHRIS COONS IS EXPECTED TO BE THE
31:19 CHAIR OF SENATE FOREIGN AND THEY'RE ASKING FOR TOP U.S.
31:23 OFFICIALS, INCLUDING COMMERCE SECRETARY HOWARD LUTNICK, AND
31:25 OTHERS LIKE THE NEW CHIEF OF STAFF STEPHEN MILLER, AND
31:28 SECRETARY OF STATE MARCO RUBIO, TO CONFIRM THEY HAVE ASKED ALL
31:31 STAFF BY NEXT WEEK TO PRESERVE ALL RECORDS RELATED TO THIS.
31:34 IT IS HIGHLIGHTING THAT RENEWED SCRUTINY NOT JUST ON THE COMPANY
31:38 OF NVIDIA ITSELF BUT ALSO THE WHITE HOUSE THAT SAYS YOU GUYS
31:42 WERE JUST OUTLINING THIS NEW AXIOS REPORT OUT THIS MORNING
31:45 ABOUT HOW COMMERCE SECRETARY HOWARD LUTNICK HAS PERHAPS
31:49 SLOW-WALKED EXPORT CURBS ON COMPANIES, LIKE THE ONE AT THE
31:52 CENTER OF THIS, MEGASPEED, WHICH STILL DOESN'T HAVE THE CONTROLS
31:54 ON IT. WE TIE THIS BACK TO CONGRESS
31:57 LAWMAKERS ARE TRYING TO PUSH TO INSTITUTE CURBS OF THEIR OWN AS
32:00 THEY WEIGH A FEW DIFFERENT PIECES OF LEGISLATION THAT WOULD
32:03 CODIFY THEIR ABILITY TO CRACK DOWN ON CHIP SMUGGLING.
32:08 LISA: THANK YOU FOR BEING WITH US.
32:09 ED MILLS OF RAYMOND JAMES WRITING THE ALLEGED CHINESE
32:13 INTELLIGENCE OPERATION TARGETING NVIDIA CEO JENSEN HUANG HAS
32:17 MATERIALLY INCREASED THE ODDS OF ENHANCED TECH CONTROLS.
32:20 THANK YOU FOR BEING WITH US. I WANT TO START WITH HOW THIS
32:24 WILL AFFECT NEXT WEEK'S TRIP OF PRESIDENT TRUMP TO CHINA.
32:30 POLICY AS IT RELATES TO CHINA? PRESIDENT TRUMP GAVE A DIRECTIVE
32:35 TO EVERYONE IN HIS ADMINISTRATION, DON'T DO
32:41 ANYTHING THAT TARGETS CHINA. HE CAN NO LONGER GET THAT
32:44 DIRECTIVE TO CONGRESS AND CONGRESS IS LIKELY TO PASS
32:49 EXPORT CONTROLS LIKELY WITH VETO-PROOF MAJORITIES.
32:51 AS WE START TARGETING CHINA AGAIN, WHAT DOES CHINA DO IN
32:58 RESPONSE, DOES PRESIDENT XI SAY, WHAT DO YOU MEAN YOU DON'T HAVE
33:01 CONTROL OF WHICH LAWS GO INTO EFFECT IN YOUR COUNTRY?
33:05 THE DETENTE THAT HAS EXISTED THAT HAS BEEN INCREDIBLY
33:07 IMPORTANT TO THIS MARKET FOR MORE THAN A HERE IS REALLY UNDER
33:13 STRESS AS CONGRESS AND AT THE SCANDAL TAKES OVER.
33:16 ANNMARIE: TO THE PRESIDENT BE GOING TO CHINA NEXT WEEK?
33:18 ED: YEAH, I THINK HE HAS ALREADY SAID HE IS GOING.
33:23 ANNMARIE: I'M JUST SAYING THIS, BECAUSE THE BIDEN ADMINISTRATION
33:26 FEBRUARY 20 23, REMEMBER THE SPY BALLOON, WHAT THEY CALLED A
33:31 WEATHER DEVICE, WAS OVER AT THE UNITED STATES AND SECRETARY OF
33:33 STATE ANTONY BLINKEN HAD A TRIP TO CHINA AND THEY CANCELED IT
33:34 UNDER IMMENSE PRESSURE. LISA:
33:41 I THINK IF THEY WERE
33:43 TO CANCEL THE TRIP IT WOULD BE MORE OF A VIEW FROM THE
33:45 ADMINISTRATION THAT THIS WAS A CONFIRMATION THAT MS. HUANG WAS
33:50 A CHINESE SPY. I DON'T THINK THEY WANT TO
33:57 UPEND THIS DETENTE.
33:59 THEY NEED TO GET THE RARE EARTH MINERALS DEAL.
34:03 IT WAS EXTENDED TWO MONTHS. PRESIDENT TRUMP ONCE XI THE COME
34:08 TO THE G20, HE WANTS A TRILATERAL MEETING BETWEEN
34:16 HE CAN GET A DEAL ON UKRAINE. ALL THOSE THINGS AND PRESIDENT
34:19 TRUMP ALWAYS LOVES TO BE ON THE INTERNATIONAL STAGE.
34:21 THAT'S WHY I SAID "YEAH." ANNMARIE: IF CONGRESS WILL MOVE
34:25 FORWARD WITH THESE AND I BELIEVE THERE ARE THREE THEY ARE
34:27 DELIBERATING WITH BIPARTISAN SUPPORT IN TERMS OF EXPORT
34:31 CONTROLS, WHERE DOES THAT LEAVE THE COMMERCE DEPARTMENT?
34:34 WHERE HAVE THEY BEEN SLOW TO ACT WHEN IT COMES TO MEGASPEED?
34:38 ED: I THINK AT LEAST THE COMMERCE DEPARTMENT IN THE
34:41 SQUARE FOCUS OF MANY DIFFERENT CONGRESSIONAL INVESTIGATIONS, I
34:44 THINK WE ARE GOING TO BE WATCHING THESE LAWS THAT PASS
34:46 AND TO SEE IF THEY TAKE AWAY SOME OF THE RESPONSIBILITIES OF
34:50 THE COMMERCE DEPARTMENT, MOVE IT ELSEWHERE.
34:54 IS THERE GOING TO BE A REQUIREMENT THAT THE HEAD OF
34:57 EURO INTEREST RATE SECURITY, OR HOWARD LUTNICK, DOES HE HAVE TO
34:59 RESIGN OR FACE ADDITIONAL SCRUTINY HERE?
35:03 WE SAW LAST NIGHT BLOOMBERG REPORTING THE FACT THAT THE
35:09 COMMERCE DEPARTMENT SEEMS TO BE MOVING FORWARD WITH A REMOTE
35:16 MAKING IT ILLEGAL TO HAVE A SERVER IN MALAYSIA THAT GIVES
35:17 ACCESS TO CHINA. TECHNICALLY, IT IS ALREADY
35:22 ILLEGAL, BUT CAN THEY CRACKDOWN ON THAT?
35:24 I THINK YOU WILL SEE COMMERCE TRYING TO PLAY CATCH UP,
35:27 ESTABLISH ADDITIONAL CREDIBILITY THAT HAS BEEN REALLY CHALLENGED
35:30 BY THE REPORTING SEEN OVER THE PAST WEEK.
35:32 ANNMARIE: ALL MORNING LISA AND I HAVE BEEN TRYING TO WORK OUT WHO
35:35 IS THE SHORT LIST IF JENSEN HUANG IS FORCED OUT, WHO IS THE
35:38 SHORT LIST FROM THE PRESIDENT WHEN IT COMES TO RUNNING THE
35:40 COMMERCE DEPARTMENT? ED: THAT IS TO BE DETERMINED.
35:45 ONE QUESTION I HAVE IS WHO CAN GET CONFIRMED?
35:50 TO 56. WHO HE CAN GET CONFIRMED,
35:55 ESPECIALLY IF THEY NEED TO HAVE THIS HAWKISHNESS AGAINST CHINA,
36:00 THAT IS WHAT I WOULD BE LOOKING FOR.
36:02 WE GO BACK THROUGH THE REGULAR SUSPECTS THAT WERE ON THE
36:05 TREASURY -- WALL STREET, BUSINESS LEADERS -- LIST AT THE
36:11 BEGINNING, ANNMARIE. LISA: LOOKING AHEAD TO NEXT WEEK
36:21 CONGRESS TAKING THE HELM, WHAT DOES THAT MEAN IN TERMS OF
36:25 POTENTIAL VOLATILITY SHOULD RARE EARTHS NOT BE EXPORTED FROM
36:28 CHINA? SHOULD THERE BE ANOTHER PHASE
36:30 AND TRADE TENSIONS BETWEEN THE WORLD'S TWO BIGGEST ECONOMIES?
36:35 ED: WE WERE DISCUSSING THE DAY OF THE ELECTION IF THIS WOULD BE
36:39 A CLEARING EVENT OR A RETURN TO VOLATILITY.
36:41 WE HAVE BEEN IN THE VOLATILITY CAMP.
36:42 IF WE DO NOT GET THESE RARE EARTH MINERALS THAT IS A HUGE
36:46 IMPACT TO U.S. INDUSTRIAL PRODUCTION.
36:48 THAT IS WHERE WE WILL BE HAVING QUESTIONS ABOUT RECESSION OR
36:51 MAJOR ECONOMIC DAMAGE. I BELIEVE THEY ARE GOING TO DO
36:57 THE MORE WE PUT THESE TECH CONTROLS ON THE MORE OTHER RARE
37:03 EARTHS COME INTO CONVERSATION. OPTICAL RECEIVERS INVOLVED
37:09 THERE. WHAT ARE THE WAYS IN WHICH CHINA
37:10 RESPONDS? THEY ARE NOT GOING TO ALLOW US
37:17 TO PAST THE MATCH ACT, THEY KNOW YOUR CUSTOMERS -- REALLY
37:20 RESTRICT THEIR ACCESS TO THIS WITHOUT RESPONDING.
37:25 TO ME, THIS HAS BEEN THE WORST NEWS AT THE WORST POSSIBLE TIME,
37:29 BECAUSE WE ARE ALREADY DEALING WITH OTHER AI AND DATA CENTER
37:31 ISSUES. THIS IS AN UNBELIEVABLE SERIES
37:35 OF EVENTS THAT I DON'T GET THE SENSE FROM MY CONVERSATIONS
37:38 INVESTORS HAVE FULLY DIGESTED ABOUT WHAT'S ABOUT TO HAPPEN
37:41 NEXT IN
37:46 D.C. AND GLOBALLY WITH THE U.S.-CHINA RELATIONSHIP.
37:52 LISA: THANK YOU, REALLY SOBERING GIVEN THE BROADER TENTACLES OF
37:54 THIS AND A MARKET TRYING TO GET ITS HEAD AROUND HOW FAR THIS
37:55 GOES. ANNMARIE: THE KNIVES SEEM TO BE
38:00 OUT FOR THE COMMERCE DEPARTMENT. PEOPLE SEEM FRUSTRATED NOT JUST
38:02 INTERNALLY AT THE WHITE HOUSE BUT ALSO EXTERNALLY.
38:07 LISA: RIGHT NOW LET’S GET YOU AN UPDATE ON STORIES ELSEWEHERE THIS MORNING.
38:09 HERE IS YOUR BLOOMBERG BRIEF WITH VONNIE QUINN. VONNIE: THE U.K. ECONOMY GREW AT
38:13 ITS FASTEST PACE IN 2.5 YEARS HELPED BY AI SPENDING.
38:16 CONSUMER SPENDING ALSO ROSE MORE THAN ECONOMISTS EXPECTED.
38:18 STRONGER GROWTH ADDS PRESSURE ON THE BANK OF ENGLAND TO RAISE
38:21 INTEREST RATES AGAIN. UNITED AIRLINES IS BANNING
38:28 AI BOTS FROM BOOKING TICKETS. THEY'RE WORRIED BOTS TO EXPOSE
38:34 CUSTOMERS' SENSITIVE INFORMATION OR MAKE UNINTENDED PURCHASES.
38:37 THEY WILL BE ABLE TO SHOW FLIGHT OPTIONS AND PRICES BUT NOT BE
38:39 ABLE TO TRANSACT ON THE WEBSITE. YOU LOVE MOST POSTING ON X THAT
38:46 IT WOULD BE "AN HONOR" TO HOW YOUR THE EMBATTLED NVIDIA CEO
38:51 JENSEN HUANG AFTER THE NVIDIA BOARD COULD BE PREPARING TO
38:56 OUST JENSEN HUANG FROM THE COMPANY
39:00 HE FOUNDED. THAT IS YOUR BLOOMBERG BRIEF.
39:05 LISA: NEXT, FAR FROM UNTOUCHABLE.
39:09 >> THIS IS A STORY OF HUBRIS AND POOR CORPORATE GOVERNANCE.
39:11 JENSEN HUANG THOUGHT THAT HE WAS UNTOUCHABLE
39:19 NATIONAL SECURITY. LISA: THIS IS BLOOMBERG
39:23 SURVEILLANCE, GOOD MORNING. ♪
39:55 LISA: AHEAD OF THE OPENING BELL WE ARE SEEING THE DRIVEN BY
39:58 NVIDIA SHARES, LOOK AT THE INDEXES, THE S&P DOWN POINT 4%,
40:02 THE NASDAQ 100 DOWN .8%. IT IS ONE NAME IN FOCUS, NVIDIA
40:10 DOWN MORE THAN 6%, ALMOST 7%, NOW 7.3%, FALLING IN PREMARKET
40:15 TRADING NEAR SESSION LOWS AS REAL QUESTIONS EMERGE ABOUT THE
40:19 FUTURE OF THE CEO, JENSEN HUANG. UNDER SURVEILLANCE THIS MORNING,
40:21 FAR FROM UNTOUCHABLE. >> UNFORTUNATELY, THIS IS A
40:28 STORY OF HUBRIS AND POOR CORPORATE GOVERNANCE.
40:31 JENSEN HUANG, WHO HAS ACCOMPLISHED SO MUCH IN HIS
40:35 CAREER, THOUGHT THAT HE REALLY WAS UNTOUCHABLE AND MADE A
40:37 NUMBER OF MISTAKES IN HIS PERSONAL LIFE AND
40:40 ONES I BELIEVE
40:46 REALLY AFFECT U.S. NATIONAL SECURITY.
40:50 LISA: THE COMPANY WASTED FUTURE OF ITS SCANDAL-WRITTEN CEO.
40:54 TED MORTONSON WRITING THIS IS A DISASTER AND CORPORATE
40:56 GOVERNANCE. ESPIONAGE IS A FOUR LETTER WORD
41:01 THAT IS PUNISHABLE WITH JAIL TIME, NOT A SLAP ON
41:03 THE WRIST. THE ISSUE OF GOVERNANCE AS
41:07 INVESTORS IN A COMPANY LIKE NVIDIA COME THAT USE GOVERNANCE
41:09 AS ONE CHARACTER THEY CONSIDER WHEN DECIDING
41:12 INVESTMENTS. HOW MUCH ARE CONCERNS OF
41:16 GOVERNANCE AND NVIDIA GOING TO FORCE SELLS THE BIG INVESTORS?
41:26 TED: I WAS ON WITH OVER 20 PORTFOLIO MANAGERS LAST NIGHT
41:29 AND HOSTED A DINNER THAT WENT WAY INTO THE NIGHT, AND THIS WAS
41:31 THE MAJOR DISCUSSION. IF YOU LOOK AT THE WEIGHTINGS OF
41:39 NVIDIA IN THE S&P AND THE NASDAQ THEY ARE 6.6% OF TOTAL
41:42 PORTFOLIOS. THIS IS A HUGE WEIGHTING,
41:48 SECOND TO APPLE. PORTFOLIO MANAGERS DON'T HAVE A
41:50 LOT OF CHOICE ON ATTRIBUTION. I DO HAVE A FEW FUNDS THAT,
41:57 INTERNALLY, IF THEY LOSE A CEO OR CFO DUE TO BAD BEHAVIOR OR
42:02 THERE IS A GAP IN ANY ONE OF THOSE
42:08 TWO C-LEVEL SUITE
42:16 POSITIONS, THEY WON'T HAVE A CHOICE.
42:17 THAT'S NOT THE NORM. PEOPLE WILL BE DIVERSIFYING FROM
42:23 NVIDIA TO MANAGE THEIR RISK AND ATTRIBUTION.
42:25 NAMES LIKE AMD AND BROADCOM. THE WHOLE GOOGLE INFRASTRUCTURE
42:31 ON GP USE THAT INCLUDES MARVE LLE.
42:39 NAMES LIKE COREWEAVE AND NIBIUS THAT WERE GETTING A BID.
42:45 THEY WERE PUT TO THE SIDE LAST NIGHT.
42:46 ALIBABA ON ACCESS TODAY ON NVIDIA, DOWN 7%.
42:54 IT'S A RUBIK'S CUBE HERE THAT IS NOT EASY TO SOLVE WITHOUT
42:56 IMPERFECT INFORMATION. LISA: IS DIFFICULT TO EXTRICATE
43:01 NVIDIA FROM THOSE OTHER NAMES BECAUSE THEY ALL ARE INTERTWINED
43:03 WITH ALL OF THE CIRCULAR FINANCING THAT WE KEEP TALKING
43:06 ABOUT. NVIDIA AND OF THE LIKES OF AMD
43:09 AND BROADCOM, ALL OF THEM ARE INVESTED IN THE SAME NAMES.
43:13 IF NVIDIA TAKES A STEP BACK THAT WILL AFFECT EVERYTHING.
43:14 HOW DO THAT? TED: THE WORRY IS NOW NVIDIA AND
43:20 THE BOARD HAS OPENED THEM UP FOR MASS INVESTIGATIONS.
43:26 QUITE FRANKLY, I DON'T KNOW IF I WOULD LIKE TO BE THE CFO DOING
43:31 THIS, BECAUSE SHE IS GOING TO GET A HUGE
43:34 MAGNITUDE OF INVESTIGATIONS. EVERY STONE, AS YOU INDICATE,
43:42 FROM A FINANCING STANDPOINT OR INVESTMENT IS GOING TO BE TURNED
43:47 OVER UNTIL THEY CAN TOTALLY UNDERSTAND THE ARCHITECTURES.
43:53 IF, FOR EXAMPLE, THERE WERE ANY SPECIAL PURPOSE VEHICLES THAT
43:56 PEOPLE DIDN'T KNOW ABOUT, ETC. NVIDIA IS GOING TO BE UNDER
44:00 MASSIVE SCRUTINY BECAUSE, QUITE FRANKLY, JENSEN WAS THE SUPER
44:08 INTELLIGENCE LEAD, HE WAS A CAPITAL ALLOCATOR, HE WAS THE
44:09 POLITICAL FACE OF THE ADMINISTRATION.
44:13 I WOULD SAY THAT THE POLITICIANS ARE GOING TO HAVE A FIELD DAY
44:15 WITH THIS. ANNMARIE: WHEN IT COMES TO
44:19 FINANCES, WHY DID NVIDIA, TO YOUR UNDERSTANDING, STOP
44:22 BREAKING DOWN HOW MUCH THEY WERE SELLING TO SINGAPORE, ABOUT 20%?
44:26 WAS IT BECAUSE POTENTIALLY THOSE CHIPS WERE GOING TO CHINA?
44:30 TED: WE DON'T KNOW. HISTORICALLY NVIDIA HAS AROUND
44:36 20% OF THE REVENUES GOING TO CHINA.
44:37 THEY STOPPED DISCLOSING THAT, TO YOUR POINT, QUARTERS AGO.
44:44 I THINK THE INVESTIGATIONAL UNCOVER ALL OF THAT.
44:47 I THINK WE WILL GET TO SOME KIND OF DISCOVERY AT SOME POINT.
44:51 I DON'T HAVE AN ANSWER. ANNMARIE: HOW MUCH REVENUE DO
44:53 YOU THINK IS AT RISK? TED: PROBABLY 10% TO 20%.
44:59 IT'S NOT A SMALL NUMBER. SINGAPORE HAS ALWAYS BEEN A
45:00 BACKDOOR TO CHINA. AGAIN, THIS IS A CORPORATE
45:06 GOVERNANCE ISSUE, NOT ONLY INTERNALLY TO THE ADMINISTRATION
45:12 AND MR. LUTNICK, BUT ALSO, I WOULD SAY, TO NVIDIA AS A WHOLE.
45:17 WE CAN'T DISCARD THE ISSUES ON NATIONAL SECURITY AND TECHNOLOGY
45:23 THAT WAS SO DRAMATIC FOR THE AI TRADE.
45:28 WHEN YOU LOOK AT WHAT IS COMING OUT, NO ONE HAS THIS TECHNOLOGY.
45:31 NOBODY HAS IT. AND IT'S REALLY GAME-CHANGING.
45:39 JENSEN HAS CREATED A SYSTEM THAT NOBODY CAN RIVAL RIGHT NOW.
45:41 THAT IS A NATIONAL SECURITY ISSUE.
45:44 LISA: THERE'S A REAL QUESTION OF WHERE JENSEN HUANG GOES IF HE
45:46 LEAVES NVIDIA. IS THERE ANY FURTHER DISCUSSION
45:49 ABOUT THAT? ELON MUSK RAISING THE PROSPECT
45:53 TODAY ABOUT JOINING HIM AT SPACEX, BUT FROM YOUR
45:56 PERSPECTIVE, HOW MUCH MORE OF A CONSIDERATION IS THAT?
46:01 TED: THIS IS A TOUGH ONE, BECAUSE IF ESPIONAGE IS
46:03 INVOLVED, EVEN IF YOU ARE CLOSE TO IT AND YOU ARE TO SOME DEGREE
46:14 LINKED TO IT, IT WILL CREATE FROM A POLITICAL AND LEGAL
46:19 STANDPOINT A WHOLE OTHER DISCUSSION.
46:20 ESPIONAGE IS A BIG DEAL. I'M NOT SAYING ANYBODY IS GUILTY
46:25 HERE. EVERYBODY IS INNOCENT UNTIL
46:26 PROVEN GUILTY. THAT'S HOW WE SHOULD LOOK AT IT,
46:31 BUT THIS IS A BIG DEAL. I THINK WE'RE JUST GOING TO HAVE
46:35 TO WAIT. HE WILL BE MONTHS UNTIL WE GET
46:36 AN ANSWER. AS IT RELATES TO OTHER PEOPLE AT
46:41 THE TABLES LAST NIGHT THAT WE HAD THE DISCUSSION, I THINK IF
46:49 JENSEN IS REPLACED BY THE BOARD I THINK THE MOST LOGICAL ASPECT
46:56 IN THE NEAR-TERM IS AS A LEAVE OF ABSENCE AND SOMEONE FROM THE
47:02 DIRECTIONS DEPENDING ON HOW THE INVESTIGATION GOES.
47:06 THERE WERE NAMES FLOATED THROUGH MY PEOPLE YESTERDAY THAT THEY
47:11 NEED AN INDUSTRY EXPERT THAT HAS -- IF JENSEN WOULD GO -- THEY
47:18 WOULD NEED AN INDUSTRY EXPERT WITH A PRISTINE REPUTATION AND A
47:23 LEADER IN THE INDUSTRY, LIKE DEMIS HASSABIS FROM DEEPMIND.
47:29 MULTIPLE NAMES HAVE BEEN FLOATED, BUT IT IS A
47:35 BIG ISSUE. LISA: NEXT, MATT BRYSON, MIKE
47:41 PYLE, BRAD CARSON. THIS IS BLOOMBERG SURVEILLANCE.
47:59 >> WE ARE IN THE RISK RIGHT NOW THAT INFLATION KEEPS GOING UP.
48:02 >> THERE IS A LOT MORE FED UNCERTAINTY THAT SEEMS TO BE
48:06 FILTERING INTO THE MARKET. >> POINT BLANK, WE DON'T THINK
48:08 50 IS ON THE TABLE. >> IT SEEMS THE 50 IS ON THE
48:12 TABLE. >> THE FED WILL BE BETTER OFF
48:17 CONTINUING TO HIKE GRADUALLY. >> THIS IS BLOOMBERG
48:21 SURVEILLANCE WITH JONATHAN FERRO, LISA ABRAMOWICZ, AND
48:24 ANNMARIE HORDERN. LISA: WELCOME BACK TO BLOOMBERG
48:26 SURVEILLANCE COME INVESTORS FOCUS ON THE WORLD'S BIGGEST
48:30 CHIP MAKER, NVIDIA DRIVING BROADER ANXIETY IS THE BOARD
48:32 MEETS TO CONSIDER OUSTING CEO JENSEN HUANG FOLLOWING REPORTS
48:36 OF A SECOND EXTRAMARITAL AFFAIR. BOND MARKETS REOPENING WITH A
48:43 QUESTION ABOUT THE ROLE OF SAFE HAVEN IN THE TECH TURMOIL.
48:47 TRYING TO UNRAVEL THE TENTACLES OF NVIDIA.
48:49 ANNMARIE: ALL EYES ON THE BOARD AND WHAT THEY COME OUT WITH, NO
48:53 WORD ON IF THEY WILL MOVE FORWARD AND OUST JENSEN HUANG,
48:58 THE NEW YORK TIMES REPORTING THE THE SECOND STORY OF AN
49:04 EXTRAMARITAL AFFAIR WITH ANOTHER EXECUTIVE AT THE COMPANY.
49:08 WE HAVE SEEN -- HISTORY HAS TOLD US WHEN THIS HAPPENS AT THE
49:10 CORPORATE LEVEL THIS GOES AGAINST CORPORATE GOVERNANCE, ON
49:14 TOP OF THE AFFAIR HE ADMITTED TO WITH WHAT THE U.S. GOVERNMENT IS
49:19 TALKING ABOUT BEING AN ALLEGED CHINESE SPY.
49:21 LISA: WE HAD TWO GREAT CONVERSATIONS, ED MILLS AND TED
49:26 MORTONSON, REFLECTING A BROADER IMPLICATIONS.
49:30 ED MILLS REFLECTING ON WHAT THIS MEANS FOR TO POLICY IN LIGHT OF
49:33 THE TRIP TO CHINA. TED MORTONSON TALKING ABOUT
49:35 POTENTIAL FUND MANAGERS DON'T HAVE TO SELL AS A RESULT OF
49:38 GOVERNANCE CONCERNS. DEALING WITH THE FIRST ONE,
49:40 UNFORTUNATE TIMING WITH THE TRIP TO CHINA NEXT WEEK AT A TIME
49:44 WHEN THE U.S. WANTS TO KEEP THE RARE EARTH MINERALS FLOWING AND
49:47 CHINA IS REALLY BEING PUT ON THE DEFENSE OF THAT THAT WAS SOME OF
49:51 THESE ALLEGATIONS. ANNMARIE: ABSOLUTELY.
49:54 THIS IS GOING TO BE INCREDIBLY AWKWARD.
49:55 VERY WEIRD TIMING. AT THE TIME AS WELL CLEARLY
49:59 BEHIND THE SCENES THERE'S A LOT OF DISAGREEMENT WITHIN THIS
50:04 MEGASPEED. THERE IS LOTS OF REPORTING
50:10 ABOUT THIS, HOW HOWARD LUTNICK CONFRONTED BESSENT ASKING WHY
50:15 THEY WERE NOT ON THE LIST. QUESTIONS SWIRLING AROUND THAT
50:19 AND THE PRESIDENT IS ABOUT TO MEET WITH XI JINPING WHEN WE
50:21 KNOW CHINA HAS BEEN TRYING TO GET A HOLD OF U.S. HIGH
50:24 TECHNOLOGY. LISA: WE ARE SEEING
50:30 THE DOWNGRADES COME IN FAST AND FURIOUS.
50:34 EVERCORE, BAIRD, DAN IVES DOWNGRADING HIS EXPECTATIONS OF
50:37 THESE STOCKS IS SAYING IT'S WORTH 25 PERCENT LESS WITHOUT
50:47 THE ANTHROPIC IPO SET THE PRICE NEXT WEEK ON THE ROADSHOW.
50:51 ONE OF THE BIG BACKERS OF ANTHROPIC AND THESE NAMES HAS
50:53 BEEN NVIDIA. HOW DO WE TEASE APART THESE
50:55 FINANCIAL RELATIONSHIPS THAT HAVE BEEN SOMEWHAT OBSCURED IN
51:00 REPORTING TO DATE? ANNMARIE: INCREDIBLY COMPLICATED
51:04 BUT THE ANTHROPIC IPO HAS GOTTEN MORE INTERESTING.
51:06 IS IT BAD FOR ANTHROPIC BECAUSE NVIDIA IS AN ANCHOR OR IS IT
51:09 GOOD BECAUSE PEOPLE ARE TRYING TO UNWIND SOME OF THEIR
51:13 POSITIONS IN NVIDIA AND SELLING? DO THEY PUT THAT INTO THE
51:16 ANTHROPIC IPO? LISA: MARKETS ARE SEEING A DIP
51:20 IN THE MORE TECH-HEAVY INDEXES. REMEMBER NVIDIA COUNTS FOR
51:26 ALMOST 7% OF THE NASDAQ 100. FUTURES LOWER BY .8%.
51:30 S&P FUTURES LOWER BY .4%. ALMOST FLAT ON THE RUSSELL 2000.
51:35 NOTABLE TO SEE HOW OTHER NAMES CONTINUE TO OUTPERFORM,
51:37 CONTINUING TO POST GAINS. YOU LOOK AT THE BOND SPACE,
51:40 REOPENING AFTER A DAY OFF YESTERDAY WITH THE REAL CONCERNS
51:44 ABOUT INFLATIONARY PRESSURES AT THE TWO YEAR YIELD WE WERE
51:48 ALMOST DOWN TO 4.50 BACK UP TO 4.7 FIVE.
51:51 UP TWO BASIS POINTS AS PEOPLE CONSIDER THE CPI PRINT, ALL OF
51:55 THE FED SPEAK THAT HAS COME OUT INCREDIBLY HAWKISH.
51:57 10 YEAR YIELDS HOVERING AROUND THE 5% LEVEL.
52:01 A 10 YEAR AUCTION SOLD AT THE HIGHEST LEVELS OF YIELDS GOING
52:04 BACK TO 2006. LATER TODAY WE HAVE A 30 YEAR
52:06 OPTION. AGAIN, WHERE IS THE HAVEN TRADE
52:09 RIGHT NOW AT A TIME WHEN TECH IS POSTING VOLATILITY?
52:14 ANNMARIE: IT IS DIFFICULT BECAUSE OF THE VERY HOT CPI AND
52:18 GOVERNOR WALLER PUTTING POTENTIALLY 50 BASIS POINTS ON
52:22 THE TABLE, HE'S OPEN TO IT, IN DECEMBER.
52:23 WHEN IT COMES TO THE HAVEN IT HAS TO BE NVIDIA'S COMPETITORS.
52:28 AMD AND BROAD, FLYING THIS MORNING.
52:31 POTENTIALLY THESE WILL BE THE BIG BENEFICIARIES.
52:33 EVEN ALPHABET, WHICH HAS BEEN PRODUCING SOME OF ITS OWN
52:35 COMPUTER. IT IS VERY SMALL IN TERMS OF
52:38 HARDWARE, BUT THIS IS SOMETHING THEY HAVE BEEN TRYING TO WORK
52:40 FOR. POTENTIALLY YOU COULD SEE MORE
52:42 MONEY FLOWING INTO THE COMPANY AS WELL.
52:47 LISA: NVIDIA DOWN ALMOST 8% OF ALL HIS MAIN RIVALS ARE UP
52:50 ACROSS THE BOARD. COMING UP, MATT BRYSON CALLING
52:53 THIS THE WORST POSSIBLE SCENARIO FOR NVIDIA, MIKE PYLE ABOUT HOW
52:59 LEADERSHIP CONCERNS, WE A BROADER MARKET, AND THE FORMER
53:04 DEFENSE DEPARTMENT SECRETARY BRAD CARSON ON THE U.S.-CHINA
53:07 RELATIONSHIP AHEAD OF THE TRUMP-XI MEETING.
53:12 NVIDIA BOARD WEIGHING THE FUTURE OF JENSEN HUANG'S CEO.
53:15 >> YOU HAVE TO HOLD YOURSELF RESPONSIBLE.
53:18 YOU ARE THE CEO OF THE COMPANY, FOR GODS SAKE.
53:20 YOU HAVE TO HAVE HIGH STANDARDS AND EXPECTATIONS.
53:23 JUST AS I CAN BE FIRED THE NEXT CEO HAS TO BE HIRED.
53:27 I LIKE THAT WE CAN'T BE OVERLY COMPLACENT ABOUT OUR POSITION IN
53:29 THE COMPANY. YOU ARE ALWAYS VULNERABLE.
53:33 YOU ARE ALWAYS EARNING IT. LISA: SHARES OF THE TECH GIANT
53:40 REELING AFTER REPORTS OF MULTIPLE EXTRAMARITAL AFFAIRS.
53:42 MATTHEW BLOXHAM JOINS US, THANK YOU FOR BEING WITH US.
53:45 A QUESTION NOT JUST FOR NVIDIA BUT HOW IMPORTANT THIS ONE
53:49 COMPANY IS TO THE ENTIRE TECHNOLOGY TRADE?
53:53 MATTHEW: IT SITS AT THE CENTER OF EVERYTHING THAT WE'VE KNOWN
53:58 AND KNOW ABOUT AI AND WE ARE THE FUTURE IS GOING.
54:00 NOT JUST IN TERMS OF THE, KIND OF, COMMERCIAL RELATIONSHIPS AND
54:03 A SUPPLY OF THAT ESSENTIAL TECHNOLOGY, BUT THE FUNDING OF
54:07 THE ENTIRE ECOSYSTEM, INCLUDING THE LIKES OF ANTHROPIC.
54:12 THIS COULD UNRAVEL IN A LOT OF WAYS THAT WE PERHAPS HAVEN'T
54:15 EVEN THOUGHT ABOUT YET AS THINGS START TO BECOME CLEARER.
54:21 REALLY, ARGUABLY, A HARD RESET FOR THE INDUSTRY WE ARE LOOKING
54:23 AT. ANNMARIE: OUR PRIOR GUEST WAS
54:26 TALKING ABOUT HOW THIS IS EVEN GOING TO BE TOUGH FOR THE CFO.
54:33 DO YOU THINK CONTROVERSY SURROUNDING JENSEN HUANG'S
54:35 AROUND A LOT OF OTHER PEOPLE AT THE COMPANY AND WE COULD SEE
54:38 OTHER HEADS ROLL? MATTHEW: IT IS A GREAT QUESTION,
54:45 AND FOR SOME DEGREE IT HINGES ON IF THERE IS ANYTHING BEHIND THE
54:50 ALLEGED ESPIONAGE THAT HAS TAKEN PLACE AND WHETHER THERE WAS ANY
54:56 SHARING OF SECRETS, ANYTHING INCORRECT ABOUT THEIR
54:59 RELATIONSHIP WITH SOME OF THE SINGAPORE-BASED COMPANY'S WHICH
55:05 HAVE EVIDENTLY ALLEGEDLY BEEN A SOURCE OF SOME OF THE TECHNOLOGY
55:08 GETTING INTO CHINA. I THINK THAT'S AN OPEN QUESTION.
55:13 I THINK IF IT IS MORE AROUND THE ALLEGED AFFAIRS, PERHAPS IT IS
55:17 ISOLATED, BUT THERE ARE DEFINITELY QUESTIONS AND IT'S
55:19 DEFINITELY DUE DILIGENCE THE BOARD WILL HAVE TO UNDERTAKE AS
55:27 THEY WEIGH UP THE OPTIONS OF THE FUTURE OF THE COMPANY'S
55:30 LEADERSHIP. LISA: THANK YOU FOR BEING WITH
55:32 US. MATT BRYSON OF LABUBUS REMAINING
55:36 BULLISH WITH AN OUTPERFORM RATING, 345 DOLLAR PRICE TARGET.
55:41 HE IS MORNING, THIS IS THE WORST POSSIBLE OUTCOME AND A
55:46 SIGNIFICANT NEGATIVE FOR NVIDIA. REGARDLESS OF THE INVESTIGATION
55:47 WE SEE KENTON LOSING SOME OF HIS POWER AND CREDIBILITY IN
55:49 ADVOCATING FOR AI. MATT, OUTPERFORM.
55:55 HOW MUCH CONFIDENCE DO YOU HAVE IN THAT?
55:59 MATT: SO, I THINK IF YOU LOOK AT WHERE NVIDIA IS TRADING, IT IS
56:06 TRADING THIS MORNING AT 10 TIMES BY 2020, CALENDAR 2027.
56:15 I DON'T REMEMBER IN MY LIFETIME ON WALL STREET A COMPANY GROWING
56:24 THAT 70%, WITH 70% GROSS MARGINS THAT IS TRADING AT A 10X
56:28 MULTIPLE. I THINK OF A NORMAL MULTIPLE
56:30 BEING IN THE HIGH TEENS. YOU HAVE ALREADY ARGUABLY GOTTEN
56:41 COMPANY JUST BECAUSE IT'S CHEAP, BUT I THINK THERE'S A WHOLE LOT
56:45 OF DISCOUNT ALREADY BUILT INTO NVIDIA STOCK AROUND THIS
56:49 SITUATION. SO FROM THAT PERSPECTIVE, AND
56:55 FROM THE PERSPECTIVE I THINK THAT A LOT OF 2027 FINANCIAL
57:00 RESULTS ARE KIND OF SET IN STONE BECAUSE THE SUPPLY CHAIN IS SO
57:04 TIGHT AND DEMAND IS SO STRONG, YOU STILL SEE THEM EXECUTE.
57:10 IT GIVES THEM SOME CUSHION WHATEVER THIS SITUATION RESULTS
57:11 IN. LISA: TO SUM UP, BECAUSE THIS IS
57:17 AN INTERESTING POINT, THE IDEA THAT THERE MIGHT BE A LOT OF
57:22 RISKS THAT ARE UNANALYZABLE. WE CAN'T QUANTIFY.
57:27 AT THE SAME TIME THE DISCOUNT IS SO SIGNIFICANT AND BACK LOGS SO
57:32 GREAT IT STILL PAYS TO BUY IT. IS THAT ESSENTIAL YOUR ARGUMENT?
57:37 MATT: THAT'S IT. THERE'S A TON OF UNCERTAINTY BUT
57:40 I THINK A LOT OF IT IS PRICED IN.
57:44 AM I RIGHT AND PUTTING A 20 PLUS MULTIPLE ON NVIDIA?
57:48 MAYBE NOT, BUT I THINK ALSO 10 TIMES THE RATE IS TOO CHEAP.
57:53 ANNMARIE: HOW MUCH DO YOU THINK POTENTIALLY SALES ARE AT RISK
57:55 BECAUSE THESE WERE SALES THAT WERE MAYBE SLIPPING TO CHINA AND
57:58 NOW THERE WILL BE MORE CONTROL OVER THEM?
58:02 MATT: I DON'T THINK THERE ARE A TON OF CHIPS BEING SHIPPED TO
58:04 CHINA AT THIS POINT. H200'S BEING SHIPPED TO
58:12 MEGASPEED, THAT WAS PREDOMINANTLY A 2020 FOUR
58:13 PHENOMENON. YOU HAVE A REPORT FROM THE
58:18 INFORMATION LAST NIGHT TALKING ABOUT COMMERCE LOOKING AT
58:22 HALTING CHIP SHIPMENTS TO COMPANIES THAT ARE ALLOWING
58:26 CHINESE COMPANIES TO USE DATA CENTERS OUTSIDE OF CHINA.
58:30 THAT IS SOME BUSINESS FOR NVIDIA, BUT THAT AMOUNT OF
58:34 BUSINESS, BACK WHEN NVIDIA COULD FREELY SHIPPED TO CHINA, WAS
58:36 LESS THAN 20% REVENUES. I THINK IT'S MUCH LESS THAN THAT
58:41 RIGHT NOW IN TERMS OF THESE OUTSIDE CHIPS.
58:44 IT CERTAINLY MATTERS, BUT I DON'T THINK IT'S, BY ANY MEANS,
58:49 THE BULK OF WHAT THEY ARE SHIPPING.
58:50 ANNMARIE: DO YOU THINK THIS IS IDIOSYNCRATIC TO NVIDIA?
58:53 ARE WE GOING TO SEE POTENTIALLY SOME CONTAGION OF THIS TO THEIR
58:58 PARTNERS, THE FINANCING OF OTHER COMPANIES THEY SUPPLY, OR DO YOU
59:01 POTENTIALLY THINK THIS IS A MOMENT FOR OTHER BIG WINNERS TO
59:03 STEP IN? MATT: I THINK IT'S BOTH.
59:11 IF YOU SEE DISRUPTION AT NVIDIA, I THINK IT CERTAINLY YOU NEED A
59:13 THIRD PARTY SUPPLIER OF CHIPS. AMD IS THE CLOSEST ALTERNATIVE.
59:20 I THINK THERE IS POTENTIAL BENEFIT FOR THEM.
59:22 YOU LOOK AT A COMPANY LIKE CEREBUS, THE ONLY
59:29 THIRD-PARTY BEHIND AMD AND NVIDIA WHO IS SELLING TO THOSE
59:34 LARGER CLOUD CUSTOMERS OR FRONTIER LABS.
59:37 THEY PROBABLY BENEFIT. THERE ARE SOME
59:44 BENEFICIARIES THAT WAY. IN THE SAME SENSE, WHERE YOU END
59:49 UP WITH UNCERTAINTY, THE MARKET DOESN'T LIKE UNCERTAINTY.
59:54 SO FROM A SUPPLY CHAIN PERSPECTIVE, IS IT GOOD OR BAD
1:00:00 FOR TSM IF AMD OR NVIDIA IS THE SUPPLIER?
1:00:02 IT SHOULDN'T MATTER BUT PEOPLE STILL AREN'T GOING TO LIKE THE
1:00:04 UNCERTAINTY. LISA: IF YOU'RE JUST JOINING US,
1:00:09 TO GIVE YOU AN UP-TO-DATE, OVER THE WEEKEND JENSEN HUANG CAME
1:00:12 OUT, CONFESSED TO HAVING AN AFFAIR WITH AN ELECTED CHINESE
1:00:15 SPY. SAYING HE DIDN'T KNOW ABOUT IT.
1:00:18 RAISING QUESTIONS ABOUT WHO KNEW WHAT, WIN, AND WHAT KIND OF
1:00:22 ALLOCATIONS THERE WERE -- WHAT WHEN, AND WHAT KINDS OF
1:00:26 ALLOCATIONS ARE BEING MADE BY THE U.S. EXECUTIVE BRANCH.
1:00:36 ALSO HE REPORTEDLY HAD ANOTHER EXTRAMARITAL AFFAIR WITH HIS
1:00:38 DIRECT REPORT AT NVIDIA. THE BOARD IS CONSIDERING WHETHER
1:00:42 TO OUST JENSEN HUANG AND THE COMMERCE DEPARTMENT WITH THE
1:00:48 CHIPS AND THE INNER TENTACLES OF THE CENTRAL BANK OF AI, WHICH
1:00:51 HAS BEEN NVIDIA. SO INTERTWINED WITH ALL THE TECH
1:00:53 COMPANIES THAT HAVE COME TO THE FOR THE PAST COUPLE OF YEARS.
1:00:56 ANNMARIE: THAT'S WHY THIS HAS BEEN ABOUT KEY MAN RISK.
1:01:00 A LOT OF PEOPLE THOUGHT HE WOULD POTENTIALLY SURVIVE WHEN IT WAS
1:01:02 JUST THE ALLEGED CHINESE SPY THAT HE WAS HONEST ABOUT HAVING
1:01:05 THIS AFFAIR. THE ISSUE NOW FOR THIS BOARD IS
1:01:10 THE CORPORATE GOVERNANCE ISSUE AND HAVING AN AFFAIR.
1:01:12 ACCORDING TO THE NEW YORK TIMES WITH THE DIRECT REPORT.
1:01:15 THE OTHER ISSUE WITH THIS BOARD IS WHO ARE THEY GOING TO PUT
1:01:18 INTO THAT SPOT, GIVEN THIS NEEDS TO BE SOMEONE WHO IS PART OF
1:01:21 THIS ECOSYSTEM WHEN IT COMES TO THE CHIP SECTOR?
1:01:24 LISA: INTERESTING IS THE EARNINGS COMING OUT.
1:01:27 HOW MUCH THEY MATTER. NEVYAS COMING OUT FOLLOWING THE
1:01:30 EARNINGS WE GOT YESTERDAY OR TWO DAYS AGO FROM COREWEAVE, BETTER
1:01:33 THAN EXPECTED. ANOTHER NEO-CLOUD ALSO COMING IN
1:01:38 SIGNIFICANTLY ABOVE EXPECTATIONS, THIRD QUARTER
1:01:40 ADJUSTED AT 465 MILLION DOLLARS VERSUS THE ESTIMATE OF 357
1:01:44 MILLION DOLLARS. THOSE SHARES POPPING IN
1:01:46 PREMARKET TRADING. HOW MUCH CAN FUNDAMENTALS
1:01:50 OVERCOME SOME OF THE SPECULATION, LACK OF CLARITY
1:01:53 AROUND THE BIG FINANCIER OF SO MANY OF THESE TRAITS WHICH IS
1:01:55 NVIDIA. BEDIUSNEBIUS UP 2.5%.
1:02:07 VONNIE: NVIDIA'S BOARD WEIGHING THE FUTURE OF JENSEN HUANG AFTER
1:02:10 REPORTS OF EXTRAMARITAL AFFAIRS. THE BOARD IS WORKING WITH AN
1:02:14 OUTSIDE FIRM TO IDENTIFY POTENTIAL REPLACEMENTS.
1:02:16 THEY ARE CONSIDERING NAMING A TEMPORARY CHIEF WHILE SEARCHING
1:02:25 WITH NEARLY ALL VOTES COUNTED, MISSISSIPPI'S GOT COLOM
1:02:30 DEFEATING CINDY HYDE-SMITH. COLOM DELIVERED HIS VICTORY
1:02:34 SPEECH EIGHT DAYS AFTER THE ELECTION.
1:02:39 BYTEDANCE IS PLANNING TO LAUNCH AN AI ASSISTANTS SIMILAR TO
1:02:44 META'S MUSE, SOURCES TELL US A BLOOMBERG THE COFOUNDER TOLD
1:02:47 EMPLOYEES THE COMPANY WILL BE ABLE TO COMPETE WITH OPENAI AND
1:02:50 ANTHROPIC, BUT NOT UNTIL AT LEAST 2029.
1:02:52 THAT IS YOUR BLOOMBERG BRIEF. LISA: NVIDIA' BREAKING POINT.
1:02:58 CHANGE WE DON'T KNOW WHETHER OR NOT JENSEN IS TRULY OUT OR
1:03:05 WHO A POTENTIAL REPLACEMENT WILL BE.
1:03:07 YOU HAD TO BE THINKING WHO HIS REPLACEMENT IS GOING TO BE.
1:03:10 JENSEN IS PROBABLY MORE LIKELY GOT A FOOT OUT THE DOOR AT THIS
1:03:13 POINT IN TIME. LISA: MICHAEL PYLE OF BLACKROCK
1:03:17 JOINS NEXT. THIS IS BLOOMBERG SURVEILLANCE.
1:03:43 ♪ LISA: LOOKING AT STOCKS THAT ARE
1:03:45 GETTING A BIT OF A HIT THIS MORNING AS A RESULT OF NVIDIA.
1:03:47 THE BROAD INDEXES, THE NASDAQ 100 UNDERPERFORMING DOWN .7%,
1:03:50 GETTING A LITTLE BIT OF A BOOST AFTER GETTING SOME EARNINGS.
1:03:56 S&P FUTURES LOWER BY .3%. YOU SEE THE ONGOING SELLOFF AT
1:03:58 THE FRONT END OF THE CURVE. NVIDIA IS THE BIG NAME WE ARE
1:04:02 ALL FOCUSED ON TODAY. THOSE SHARES HAVE BEEN LOWER BY
1:04:05 MORE THAN 7%. THEY CONTINUE TO BE AFTER LOSING
1:04:09 ALREADY ALMOST $700 BILLION OF MARKET VALUE SINCE FRIDAY
1:04:11 AFTERNOON. IF YOU TAKE A LOOK AT SOME OF
1:04:20 THE WINNERS TODAY, NEBIUS, A NEO-CLOUD, AND COREWEAVE ALSO
1:04:26 OUTPERFORMED. NEBIUS MORE THAN $460 BILLION
1:04:36 VERSUS AN NEXT TO MOMENT OF 360 MILLION.
1:04:37 STILL GETTING IT DONE, AMH, WHEN THERE ARE BROADER FUTURE
1:04:41 QUESTIONS, FUNDAMENTALS TO LOOK AT.
1:04:43 ANNMARIE: ESPECIALLY FUNDAMENTALS OF COREWEAVE AND
1:04:47 NEBIUS. YOU SEE THE INVESTMENT COMMUNITY
1:04:53 COMING OUT WITH A DOWNGRADE AFTER DOWNGRADE, OPPENHEIMER,
1:04:54 BERNSTEIN, THE TITLE OF THEIR NOTE, WHERE DID HE HAVE THE
1:04:59 TIME? DOWNGRADING TO MARKET PERFORM.
1:05:02 LISA: ALL OF US WITH FAMILIES WANT TO KNOW THE SAME THING.
1:05:06 UNDER SURVEILLANCE, NVIDIA' BREAKING POINT.
1:05:11 >> WE DON'T KNOW WHETHER OR NOT JENSEN IS TRULY OUT THE DOOR OR
1:05:13 WHO A POTENTIAL REPLACEMENT WOULD BE.
1:05:15 DEFINITELY MORE THAN A 50% CHANCE AT THIS TIME, YOU HAVE TO
1:05:18 THINK ABOUT WHO HIS REPLACEMENT WOULD BE.
1:05:20 JENSEN MORE LIKELY HAS A FOOT OUT THE DOOR THIS POINT IN TIME.
1:05:24 THE DEMAND IS SO HIGH FOR AI AT THIS POINT IN TIME AND FOR
1:05:29 COMPUTE IT IS ALMOST IMPOSSIBLE TO MOVE BACKWARDS.
1:05:32 LISA: NVIDIA' AS BOARD WEIGHING JENSEN HUANG'S FATE FOLLOWING
1:05:36 REPORTS OF MULTIPLE AFFAIRS INCLUDING ONE WITH AN ELECTED
1:05:39 CHINESE SPY. MICHAEL PYLE OF BLACKROCK
1:05:41 WRITING THE AI STORY IS MOVING INTO A MORE NUANCED PHASE.
1:05:47 OUR CONVICTION REMAINS INTACT WHICH KEEPS US SELECTIVE ABOUT
1:05:51 WHERE WE TAKE OUR AI EXPOSURE. NUANCED IS A EUPHEMISM WHEN WE
1:05:53 START TALKING BUT THE WINNERS AND POTENTIAL LOSERS.
1:05:58 WHERE DO YOU VIEW THE NVIDIA STORY?
1:06:02 IS THIS A THREAT TO THE AI THESIS OR A ONE-TIME BLIP IN A
1:06:07 NAME THAT WILL REMAIN STRONG IN A UNIVERSE THAT WILL CONTINUE TO
1:06:08 STRENGTHEN? MIKE: WE THINK THE AI
1:06:16 TRANSFORMATION IS BIGGER THAN ANY ONE COMPANY OR INDIVIDUAL.
1:06:22 WE THINK IT IS AN EXTRAORDINARILY SIGNIFICANT
1:06:24 TRANSFORMATION FOR THE ECONOMY AND MARKETS.
1:06:25 WE THINK WE ARE MOVING INTO A DIFFERENT MOMENT IN THE AI
1:06:30 TRANSFORMATION, THAT IS LESS DIRECTIONAL AROUND THE PLAYERS
1:06:34 DOING THE BUILD OUT, IT WILL BE MORE TWO-SIDED AROUND
1:06:43 WINNERS AND LOSERS AROUND THE BUILDOUT, AROUND ADOPTION AND
1:06:46 DIFFUSION, AND WE THINK THIS WILL BE A MORE SELECTIVE MARKET
1:06:50 ENVIRONMENT THAN DIRECTIONAL. MIKE: HOW DO YOU DO FUNDAMENTAL
1:06:53 ANALYSIS WHEN THERE IS A LOT OF POLICY RISK AT PLAY?
1:06:57 THIS IS CLEARLY IN THE HAIRS OF THE GOVERNMENT ACROSS ALL
1:06:59 BRANCHES. YOU HAVE WORKED IN THE
1:07:01 GOVERNMENT BEFORE. HOW DO YOU ANALYZE THAT WHEN IT
1:07:05 COMES TO DATA CENTER RESTRICTIONS, WHEN IT COMES TO
1:07:08 NEW RESTRICTIONS ON DIFFERENT AI DISSEMINATION, OR EVEN
1:07:12 INVESTIGATIONS INTO ELECTED ESPIONAGE?
1:07:14 MIKE: I THINK, AGAIN, THE POINT I WOULD HIGHLIGHT AS WE ARE
1:07:19 FACING A TWO-CITED MARKET. I THINK YOU ARE RIGHT TO POINT
1:07:22 TO THINGS LIKE POLICY RISK. I THINK WE WOULD OBSERVE WHEN IT
1:07:25 COMES TO THINGS LIKE DATA CENTERS YOU SEE COMMUNITIES
1:07:30 EXPRESSING LEGITIMATE CONCERNS AROUND TRANSPARENCY, COMMUNITY
1:07:37 BENEFITS, INCLUDING SKILLED LABOR.
1:07:40 AT THE SAME TIME COMPANIES ENGAGING CONSTRUCTIVELY.
1:07:44 YOU SEE POLICY MAKERS AND ELECTED OFFICIALS TAKING A
1:07:47 PRAGMATIC APPROACH. THIS HIGHLIGHTS A VERY
1:07:53 PERSISTENT HIGHER COST OF CAPITAL.
1:07:55 THIS WILL BE A MORE DIFFERENTIATED STORY.
1:08:00 IN PLAYERS HAVE STRONGER BALANCE SHEETS THAT ARE FOCUSED ON DOING
1:08:03 THE HARD WORK OF COMMUNITY ENGAGEMENT ARE LIKELY TO BE THE
1:08:06 WINNERS IN THE NEXT STAGE OF THE BUILDOUT.
1:08:07 IMPORTANTLY, INVESTORS ARE TURNING TO THE NEXT STEP, WHICH
1:08:11 IS WHO WILL WIN AND LOSE IN THE CORPORATE ADOPTION SPACE, DRIVE
1:08:14 THOSE EFFICIENCIES? I THINK THAT'S THE NEXT STEP OF
1:08:17 THIS DYNAMIC AND SOMETHING WE ARE FOCUSED ON FOR 2027.
1:08:21 ANNMARIE: JENSEN HUANG WASN'T A FAN OF THE DIFFUSION RULE UNDER
1:08:24 THE BIDEN ADMINISTRATION. THE TRUMP ADMINISTRATION
1:08:25 SCRAPPED IT. WITH THAT HAVE STOPPED
1:08:28 POTENTIALLY WHAT WE ARE SEEING NOW WITH WHAT IS GOING ON WITH
1:08:31 MEGASPEED? MIKE: I WOULD TAKE A STEP BACK.
1:08:35 I THINK THERE HAS BEEN A DEBATE IN WASHINGTON.
1:08:37 I THINK ON ONE SIDE YOU HAVE A VIEW OF THE LARGELY THE
1:08:42 MOTIVATING VIEW OF THE BIDEN ADMINISTRATION AND OF WHICH I
1:08:47 WAS IN PART, THAT TOOK THE VIEW THAT ADVANCED SEMICONDUCTORS, AI
1:08:52 SEMICONDUCTORS ARE KEY TO U.S.-CHINA COMPETITION AND
1:08:54 LIMITING THE FLOW OF THOSE OF SEMICONDUCTORS IS KEY TO KEEPING
1:08:58 THE U.S. IN FRONT. ON THE OTHER SIDE YOU HAD A
1:09:01 VIEW, AND I THINK THE TRUMP ADMINISTRATION HAS BEEN AT THE
1:09:03 FOREFRONT HERE, WHICH HE SAID, LISTEN, IT IS THE MOST
1:09:06 IMPORTANT THING IS TO KEEP THE U.S. AHEAD, BUT THE WAY TO DO
1:09:10 THAT IS TO HAVE CHINA AND OTHER COUNTRIES IN THE U.S. TECHNOLOGY
1:09:14 STACK FOR THAT REVENUE TO GENERATE R&D THAT CAN KEEP THE
1:09:15 U.S. AHEAD. I THINK THE DIRECTION OF TRAVEL
1:09:21 WAS GOING MORE IN THE DIRECTION OF RETURNING TO THE FIRST.
1:09:23 I THINK WE ARE MORE LIKELY TO SEE WHERE THE PRESSURES ARE
1:09:26 BUILDING IN CONGRESS FOR STEPS THAT WOULD TAKE U.S. POLICY BACK
1:09:30 IN THE DIRECTION OF THE FIRST APPROACH.
1:09:32 I THINK THAT HAS BEEN THE DEBATE WE HAVE BEEN SEEING PLAY OUT.
1:09:36 ANNMARIE: THERE ARE THESE THREE IDEAS IN CONGRESS CIRCULATING
1:09:38 THAT MIGHT GET INCLUDED INTO THE BILL AT THE END OF THE YEAR.
1:09:41 DO YOU THINK THAT'S GOING TO IMPACT THE AI TRAIT AT ALL,
1:09:44 BECAUSE IT COULD POTENTIALLY SLOW DOWN SOME OF THE REVENUE
1:09:48 GROWTH IN TERMS OF EXPORT CONTROLS?
1:09:51 MIKE: AS I SAID, I THINK OUR VIEW IS THE DIRECTIONAL PHASE OF
1:09:55 THE AI BUILDOUT TRADE IS COMING TO A CLOSE, AND FROM HERE IT IS
1:09:58 MORE TWO-SIDED. THERE IS A RANGE OF THINGS, COST
1:10:04 OF CAPITAL, POLICY UNCERTAINTY, THAT ARE UNDERSCORING THAT, BUT
1:10:09 TO US, THE IMPORTANT POINT IS TO BE SELECTIVE, TO IDENTIFY WHO
1:10:13 HAS THE STRENGTH IN TERMS OF BALANCE SHEET, IN TERMS OF
1:10:16 BUSINESS MODEL, IN TERMS OF ENGAGEMENT TO COME OUT ON THE
1:10:18 WINNING SIDE OR LOSING SIDE. I WOULD HIGHLIGHT I THINK THIS
1:10:26 UNDERSCORES OUR CONVICTION TO TAKE ADVANTAGE
1:10:29 OF BOTH SIDES OF THE TWO CITED UNCERTAINTY ARE REALLY IMPORTANT
1:10:33 INSTRUMENTS AND PORTFOLIOS TO DELIVER GAINS TO INVESTORS
1:10:36 AGAINST A BACKDROP WHERE THE TRADITIONAL SOURCES OF
1:10:38 DIVERSIFICATION A LESS COMPELLING.
1:10:40 LISA: A WEEK AGO PEOPLE WERE SAYING BONDS WERE A GOOD
1:10:43 DIVERSIFIER TO POTENTIAL TECH TURMOIL.
1:10:45 DO YOU THINK THAT STILL STANDS? MIKE: I THINK WHAT WE HAVE SEEN
1:10:48 THIS WEEK IN TERMS OF INFLATION SURPRISES, OBVIOUSLY IN TERMS OF
1:10:54 THE JOBS OUTPERFORMANCE LAST WEEK, HIGHLIGHTS THE REASONS WHY
1:11:01 BONDS HAVE BEEN AN UNCERTAIN DIVERSIFIER, DISTINCT FROM A
1:11:05 SOURCE OF INCOME, REMAIN INTACT. I THINK IT WHILE IT WAS THE CASE
1:11:10 THAT IN OCTOBER WE SAW BONDS RALLY ALONGSIDE SOME OF THE
1:11:12 EQUITY VOLATILITY, I THINK TAKING A STEP BACK, THE BASIC
1:11:17 PICTURE THAT HAS MADE BONDS MORE UNCERTAIN, IN THAT
1:11:20 DIVERSIFICATION CAPACITY, CONTINUE TO BE THE CASE IN THE
1:11:23 IMPRESSION BRENT MADE THAT CLEAR.
1:11:24 ANNMARIE: THANK YOU FOR BEING WITH US.
1:11:27 MIKE TITLE OF BLACKROCK AS WE ASSESS THE RIPPLE EFFECTS COMING
1:11:31 OUT FROM NVIDIA AND OF THE TURMOIL AT THE C-SUITE.
1:11:35 THE BOARD HAS NOT COME TO A DECISION BUT IS DELIBERATING
1:11:38 OVER THE FUTURE OF THEIR CEO. ANNMARIE: WHETHER OR NOT HE WILL
1:11:41 BE OUSTED OR NOT. HE IS HANGING BY A THREAD WHEN
1:11:44 IT COMES TO HOLDING THE POSITION OF THE COMPANY HE FOUNDED.
1:11:48 LISA: WE HAVE A CONVERSATION WITH THE FORMER DEFENSE
1:11:51 DEPARTMENT UNDERSECRETARY BRAD CARSON ON THE U.S.-CHINA
1:11:52 RELATIONSHIP. NEXT WEEK, AWKWARD TIMING, TRUMP
1:11:56 AND PRESIDENT XI WILL MEET IN CHINA FOR THE SUMMIT, PLUS
1:12:00 ISABELLE LEE WITH YOUR MORNING MOVERS.
1:12:01 NVIDIA SHARES ARE FALLING WITH THE FATE OF THE CEO SO
1:12:04 UNCERTAIN. THIS IS BLOOMBERG SURVEILLANCE.
1:12:18 ♪ LISA: STOCKS LOWER AHEAD OF THE
1:12:20 OPENING BELL LED BY TECH. NASDAQ 100 DOWN ALMOST 1%
1:12:25 DEEPENING LOSSES AS QUESTIONS SWIRL OVER THE FATE OF JENSEN
1:12:29 HUANG AS CEO OF NVIDIA. FUTURES LOWER IN THE BOND SPACE
1:12:33 YOU SEE THE SELLOFF CONTINUING AGAIN BLACKROCK TELLING
1:12:41 UNPREDICTABLE ASPECT OF BONDS. TWO BASIS POINTS ON THE FRONT
1:12:42 END OF THE YIELD CURVE. WHAT A ROUND TRIP.
1:12:49 5% STRAIGHT ON 10 YEAR TREASURIES OUT OF THE 30 YEAR
1:12:50 OPTION. THIS IS ONE OF THE INTERESTING
1:12:57 THINGS. OCTOBER WAS THE MONTH TO 6040
1:13:02 AND THEN WE GOT THAT HOTTER THAN EXPECTED CPI.
1:13:03 WE'LL GET PPI TOMORROW. ANNMARIE: ABBY YODER YESTERDAY
1:13:10 SAYING I DON'T THINK IT WAS THE COMEBACK OF THE 6040.
1:13:15 IT'S A TOTALLY DIFFERENT MARKET. WHERE'S THE HAVEN TODAY IT'S
1:13:22 AND NVIDIA. THESE ARE THE COMPANIES THAT
1:13:29 COULD STEP IN AND TAKE MARKET SHARE AWAY FROM NVIDIA.
1:13:34 AS THEY DEAL WITH CONTROVERSY. LISA: REDIRECTING FUNDS AS A
1:13:39 RESULT OF GOVERNANCE CONCERNS. THE NEO-CLOUD OPERATOR REPORTING
1:13:45 EARNINGS BETTER THAN EXPECTED TALKING ABOUT EARNINGS AND THE
1:13:50 THIRD QUARTER THAT EXCEEDED EXPECTATIONS.
1:13:52 REVENUE CAME IN AT THE LOW END OF THE RANGE.
1:13:54 THOSE SHARES LOWER. LET'S GET MORE ON THAT AND OTHER
1:13:58 STORIES MOVING MARKETS AHEAD OF THE OPEN HEAR YOUR MORNING
1:13:59 MOVERS. >> NVIDIA CANNOT CATCH A BREAK.
1:14:05 IT WITH NEW HEADLINES THE LATEST IS THAT JENSEN HUANG REPORTEDLY
1:14:10 HAS AN AFFAIR WITH ONE OF HIS EMPLOYEES PRETTY
1:14:13 WALL STREET QUESTIONING WHETHER THEY CAN REMAIN AT THE HELM.
1:14:17 CUTTING THE PRICE TARGETS BMO RBC EVERCORE, CITI AND MORE.
1:14:25 THE CASH OPEN SOMETHING LIKE $250 BILLION IN MARKET CAP AND
1:14:30 CAPITALIZATION. HAVING GUESTS ON ALL WEEK AND IT
1:14:35 SEEMS LIKE TWO CANCER FORMING. ONE IS WHERE WITHOUT JENSEN
1:14:40 THERE'S NO NVIDIA AND THE OTHER IS NO ONE IS ABOVE THE AI
1:14:44 REVOLUTION. WE WILL SEE THAT CHECKS OUT
1:14:47 TOMORROW. YOU SEE THE RAMIFICATIONS ACROSS
1:14:49 THE MARKET. BLUE ENERGY THE STOCK WAS HIGHER
1:14:53 MORE THAN 12% YESTERDAY. YOU CAN SEE THE STOCK IS DOWN
1:14:57 TODAY MORE THAN THREE AND A HALF PERCENT EVEN AS THEY REPORTED
1:15:00 GOOD EARNINGS IS COREWEAVE. WE GOT EARNINGS TODAY AND
1:15:03 REPORTED GOOD EARNINGS. SHARE REVENUE CAME IN AT THE
1:15:04 LOWER END OF THE ESTIMATE. EBIT WAS BETTER.
1:15:08 DOWN BY MORE THAN 7%. >> NVIDIA SPORT ENLISTING THE
1:15:16 HELP OF AN OUTSIDE FIRM TO IDENTIFY WERE POTENTIAL
1:15:18 REPLACEMENTS FOR JENSEN HUANG FOLLOWING MULTIPLE REPORTS OF
1:15:21 EXTRAMARITAL AFFAIRS INCLUDING ONE WITH A SUSPECTED CHINESE SPY
1:15:27 WITH SHARES LOWER BY 7.6 PERCENT IN PREMARKET TRADING.
1:15:31 ELON MUSK OFFERING THE TECH LEAD SOME SUPPORT.
1:15:34 THE SPACEX IO SAYING HE WOULD BE HONORED TO HIRE JENSEN HUANG AND
1:15:39 NVIDIA DISCLOSED A MULTIBILLION-DOLLAR STAKE IN
1:15:42 SPACEX EARLIER THIS YEAR. I HAVE TO SAY THIS IS A COMPANY
1:15:46 THAT IS SO INTERTWINED WITH EVERY SYSTEM, EVERY ECOSYSTEM
1:15:47 EVERY PART OF THAT. SOMEONE WHO HAS A LOT OF FRIENDS
1:15:53 AND A LOT OF ENEMIES SAYING WHY NOW.
1:15:55 WHY IS THIS EMERGING AT THIS MOMENT.
1:15:58 THAT IS PART OF THE DISCUSSION BACKDROP AT A TIME WHERE THIS IS
1:16:03 CHIPMAKER. >> KNIVES ARE OUT FOR JENSEN
1:16:06 HUANG ALTHOUGH YOU LOOK AT THE REPORTING THERE'S MULTIPLE
1:16:10 PEOPLE FAMILIAR WITH THE MATTER SO SOME OF THIS HAS BEEN
1:16:13 BUILDING UP WHEN IT COMES TO ELON MUSK HE STILL THINKS MOST
1:16:18 PEOPLE DO THINK THIS IS A AN INCREDIBLE BUSINESSMAN AND
1:16:21 TECHNOLOGIST ABLE TO TAKE THESE CHIPS AND THIS COMPANY IN A
1:16:24 DIRECTION BUT ELON MUSK ALWAYS LIKES TO BE A LITTLE BIT
1:16:26 CONTROVERSIAL ON TWITTER SOMETIMES SO HE SAID HE WOULD
1:16:29 HIRE THEM. >> CHINESE FIRMS ARE REPORTEDLY
1:16:35 RUSHING TO SECURE NVIDIA'S COMPUTING CAPACITY AND DATA
1:16:39 CENTERS OUTSIDE OF CHINA. THIS ACCORDING TO REUTERS THAT
1:16:42 MANY COMPANIES ARE CONCERNED THE CONTROVERSY AROUND JENSEN HUANG
1:16:45 COULD PUSH WASHINGTON TO TIGHTEN CHIP RESTRICTIONS ALIBABA SHARES
1:16:49 LOWER BY 4%. AT A TIME WHEN EVERYONE IS
1:16:56 SAYING THIS WILL UP THE ANTE FOR TIGHTER EXPORT CONTROLS.
1:16:59 ANNMARIE: A REALLY BIG GAP WHEN IT COMES TO THIS SPACE.
1:17:03 THIS IS BEEN THE QUESTION WE KNOW A LOT OF CHINESE COMPANIES
1:17:07 RENT TO THE COMPUTE POWER WHEN IT COMES TO THESE DATA CENTERS
1:17:09 THE USE NVIDIA BUT THEY DON'T HAVE ACCESS TO THE HARDWARE AND
1:17:12 THE KEY QUESTION FOR MONTHS THAT'S BEEN IN THIS
1:17:15 INVESTIGATION AND COMMERCE THAT WE ARE STILL WAITING TO HEAR
1:17:19 MORE ABOUT IS WHETHER OR NOT WHEN IT COMES TO MEGASPEED WHERE
1:17:21 THEY JUST RENTING OUT THE COMPUTE OR WERE THEY GETTING THE
1:17:24 HARDWARE. BUT GIVEN THIS IS THE HUGE
1:17:27 QUESTION FACING WASHINGTON NOW. WE CAN SEE WASHINGTON WHEN A
1:17:32 CRISIS HITS GOES TO ONE EXTREME THAN THE OTHER AND SOMEWHERE IN
1:17:34 THE MIDDLE. YOU CAN SEE MORE EXPORT CONTROLS
1:17:40 IN THIS GRAY AREA WHICH IS THAT THESE CHINESE COMPANIES HAVE
1:17:43 ACCESS TO THE HARDWARE BUT THEY HAVE BEEN IN SOUTHEAST ASIA
1:17:44 RENTING THE COMPUTE. LISA:
1:17:51 THE JENSEN LEAD DRAMA PUTTING THAT TO THE TEST.
1:17:53 PRESIDENT TRUMP APPEARING FOR HIS THIRD SUMMIT OF THE YEAR
1:17:57 WITH CHINESE LEADER XI JINPING NEXT WEEK IN CHINA.
1:18:00 TYLER KENDALL JOINS US NOW FROM WASHINGTON.
1:18:03 DO WE HAVE ANY SENSE OF HOW MUCH THIS CHANGES THE CONTOURS OF
1:18:05 NEXT WEEK'S TRIP? TYLER: IT IS SETTING UP THIS
1:18:12 HIGH MEETING THAT WILL TAKE PLACE NEXT WEEK IN CHINA BUT HIS
1:18:15 IMPORTANTLY TESTING THE TRADE TRUCE BETWEEN THE TWO COUNTRIES
1:18:21 KEEPING IN MIND THE 500 BILLION DOLLAR ANNUAL TRADING
1:18:24 RELATIONSHIP HAD BEEN THE INTENDED FOCUS OF THIS SUMMIT.
1:18:26 THE TRUCE EXPIRES IN JANUARY AND THE RENEWAL HINGES IN LARGE PART
1:18:31 ON THE U.S. PAUSING RESTRICTIONS ON TECH SHIPMENTS TO CHINA BUT
1:18:37 NOW WE HAVE CAPITOL HILL CALLING ON THE ADMINISTRATION TO IMPOSE
1:18:40 MORE EXPORT CONTROLS ON SHIPS INCLUDING WIDENING CURBS TO
1:18:43 CAPTURE SUBSIDIARIES AND MAJORITY-OWNED BY ALREADY
1:18:47 SANCTIONED FIRMS. TENSIONS WERE THERE BEFORE THIS
1:18:48 WEEK'S DEVELOPMENT. THEY HEARD FROM MULTIPLE U.S.
1:18:54 OFFICIALS SAYING THEY HAD RAISED CONCERNS WITH THEIR CHINESE
1:18:56 COUNTERPARTS ABOUT WHETHER OR NOT BEIJING WAS MAKING GOOD ON
1:19:01 ITS TRADE COMMITMENTS INCLUDING WHEN IT COMES TO THEIR OWN
1:19:04 EXPORTS OF RARE EARTHS AND THEIR COMMITMENTS TO PURCHASE MORE
1:19:07 U.S. AGRICULTURAL PRODUCTS. WITH THAT SAID WE ALSO YESTERDAY
1:19:10 HEARD FROM THE U.S. TREASURY SECRETARY SCOTT BESSENT WHO MET
1:19:14 WITH THE CHINESE AMBASSADOR AND SAID PROGRESS HAD BEEN MADE AND
1:19:19 HE HAILED THE RELATIONSHIPS SO WE WILL HAVE TO SEE WHERE IT
1:19:21 GOES FROM HERE AND WHAT ULTIMATELY HAPPENS NEXT WEEK.
1:19:25 WE SHOULD KEEP IN MIND AFTER NEXT WEEK'S MEETING THERE IS
1:19:28 ANOTHER EXPECTED MEETING ON THE BOOKS IN DECEMBER AND THE G20
1:19:33 WHERE XI JINPING IS LIKELY GOING TO TRAVEL TO FLORIDA FOR THAT
1:19:37 MEETING. ANALYSTS ARE SAYING TO BE NEXT
1:19:41 WEEK IS MORE ABOUT COMMON TIES THAN REALLY MAKING SUBSTANTIAL
1:19:42 PROGRESS. >> RIGHT NOW JOINING US FORMER
1:19:50 SECRETARY BRAD CARSON WROTE SCRUTINY ON NVIDIA IS GOING TO
1:19:51 MAKE IT MUCH HARDER TO SUCCESSFULLY LOBBY
1:19:56 ADMINISTRATION TO PULL EXPORT CONTROL MEASURES MEANT TO KEEP
1:19:59 THE FORMER UNDER SECRETARY OF DEFENSE BRAD CARSON JOINS US FOR
1:20:02 MORE. THANK YOU FOR BEING WITH US.
1:20:05 I WANT TO START WITH YOUR ASSESSMENT OF THE POTENTIAL
1:20:10 NATIONAL SECURITY RISK THAT HAS BEEN UNFOLDING BEFORE US.
1:20:14 WHAT DO YOU MAKE OF JUST HOW MUCH HAS BEEN PUT AT RISK AS A
1:20:17 RESULT OF THE UNFOLDING SCHEDULE AT NVIDIA?
1:20:20 >> I THINK WE ARE HAVING FOR THE FIRST TIME NOTICE OF WHAT'S BEEN
1:20:25 PUT AT RISK OVER THE LAST COUPLE OF YEARS NVIDIA IS PROBABLY THE
1:20:26 MOST CRITICAL COMPANY IN THE WORLD MAKING THESE WORLD-CLASS
1:20:32 CHIPS AND ESSENTIALS THE AI REVOLUTION.
1:20:34 WE KNOW NVIDIA HAS TURNED A BLIND EYE TO THE SMUGGLING OF
1:20:38 CHIPS INTO CHINA. TODAY CHINA ESPECIALLY THE
1:20:41 CHINESE ARMY LOVE THOSE CHIPS PERHAPS ONE THIRD OF THE TOTAL
1:20:45 COMPUTE POWER IS FUELING THE CHINESE AI REVOLUTION AND ALWAYS
1:20:48 BEEN SKEPTICAL OF THIS AND NOW PERHAPS WE KNOW WHY NVIDIA HAS
1:20:53 BEEN SO BLITHE TO WHAT'S BEEN CLEARLY A SMUGGLING OPERATION.
1:20:56 ANNMARIE: DO YOU THINK COMMERCE HAS A ROLE TO PLAY AND WHERE DO
1:21:00 YOU THINK THE REAL FAILURE WAS IN TERMS OF THEIR INVESTIGATION
1:21:01 WITH MEGASPEED. AND REALLY GIVING JENSEN HUANG
1:21:05 THE RED CARPET TREATMENT. >> FAR MORE SCANDALOUS THAN AN
1:21:12 AFFAIR IS THE FACT THE DEPARTMENT OF COMMERCE LISTENED
1:21:15 TO THE NVIDIA CHIP COUNCIL AND STOP TO THE DEPARTMENT OF
1:21:18 COMMERCE INVESTIGATION INTO THE NVIDIA SMUGGLING.
1:21:22 IT IS CLEAR THAT NVIDIA IS CLOSE TO THE ADMINISTRATION.
1:21:25 THE ADMINISTRATION HAS BEEN AMBIVALENT ABOUT THESE EXPORT
1:21:28 CONTROLS PRINT ON CAPITOL HILL BOTH DEMOCRATS AND REPUBLICANS
1:21:33 ARE VERY STRONGLY IN SUPPORT OF THESE EXPORT CONTROLS.
1:21:35 BUT NVIDIA HAS LOBBIED AGAINST THEM THEY HAVE USED BOTH COVERT
1:21:40 AND OVERT MEANS TO TRY AND SUBVERT THEM.
1:21:42 NOW WE ARE REALIZING NVIDIA IS TOO IMPORTANT A COMPANY TO
1:21:46 CONTINUE THIS KIND OF INFLUENCE CAMPAIGN TO SUBVERT THE AMERICAN
1:21:48 NATIONAL INTEREST. ANNMARIE: WE SET OUR TALKING
1:21:52 ABOUT THE DIFFERENCE BETWEEN CHINA GETTING THE ACCESS TO THE
1:21:54 HARDWARE WHICH IS AT THE STORM OF THIS MEGASPEED CONTROVERSY
1:22:00 BUT THEY DO HAVE ACCESS TO COMPUTING POWER THAT THESE DATA
1:22:02 CENTERS ARE POWERED WITH NVIDIA CHIPS.
1:22:06 DO YOU THINK THAT GAP IN WASHINGTON IS GOING TO BE
1:22:08 SOMETHING THAT LAWMAKERS TRY TO GO AFTER.
1:22:13 BRAD: THESE ARE CALLED KNOW YOUR CUSTOMER LAWS.
1:22:15 WE NEED TO STOP HIM FROM GETTING ACCESS TO THE HARDWARE
1:22:18 WE'LL NEED TO MAKE SURE THEY CAN JUST ESTABLISH A DATA CENTER IN
1:22:24 THE WEST AND GIVE THEM ACCESS TO THE TOP NVIDIA CHIPS.
1:22:26 RIGHT NOW THAT IS A LOOPHOLE. MANY IN CONGRESS ARE ASKING THE
1:22:30 DEPARTMENT TO CLOSE THAT LOOPHOLE.
1:22:32 BUT COMMERCE DOESN'T SEEM TO BE PARTICULAR MOTIVATED TO DO THAT.
1:22:36 THAT IS THE NEXT FRONTIER IS MAKING SURE CHINA OR OTHER BAD
1:22:40 ACTORS CAN RENT COMPUTE FROM AMERICAN DATA CENTERS AND GAIN
1:22:42 ACCESS TO THE CHIPS THAT THEY OTHERWISE COULDN'T HAVE.
1:22:46 LISA: TO REALLY ENGAGE WITH THE MOST STRINGENT OF EXPORT
1:22:50 CONTROLS HAS BEEN THAT CHINA OWNS A LOT OF THE RARE EARTH
1:22:52 MINERALS AND HAS BEEN THREATENING TO WITHHOLD THEM
1:22:56 FROM THE U.S. IN RETALIATION SHOULD THE U.S. REALLY RESTRAIN
1:22:59 ITS EXPORTS OF CHIPS. HOW MUCH SHOULD THIS BE WEIGHED.
1:23:04 HOW MUCH DO YOU UNDERSTAND THIS DILEMMA AHEAD OF THE NEXT BIG
1:23:07 SUMMIT BETWEEN XI JINPING AND PRESIDENT TRUMP?
1:23:09 BRAD: IT SHOWS YOU HOW IMPORTANT IT IS IN THE TRUMPET
1:23:13 ADMINISTRATION IS DOING THIS TO MAKE SURE WE ARE NOT DEPENDENT
1:23:16 ON THEIR NATION FOR RARE EARTH. CHINA LARGELY DUE TO THEIR LACKS
1:23:21 ENVIRONMENTAL LAWS AS WHERE WERE PRODUCTION.
1:23:25 IT IS PREDATORY ON THE ENVIRONMENT.
1:23:28 BUT WE HAVE THAT SUPPLY. WE MUST GET CHINA AWAY FROM
1:23:34 HAVING ACCESS TO OUR CHIPS AND GET AWAY FROM ANY BARGAINING
1:23:36 POWER THEY HAVE BECAUSE THESE CHIPS ARE WHAT FUELS THE AI
1:23:40 REVOLUTION. CHINA COULD NOT COMPETE WITH US
1:23:43 WERE NOT FOR THE ILLEGALLY OBTAINED CHIPS AND IT'S PROBABLY
1:23:47 THE MOST DANGEROUS THING IN AMERICAN NATIONAL INTEREST RIGHT
1:23:47 NOW. LISA: WITH THE CHIPS OBTAINED BY
1:23:54 CHINA HOW CLOSE IS CHINA WOULD YOU SAY TO SUPERSEDING THE U.S.
1:23:56 WHEN IT COMES TO AI TECHNOLOGY? BRAD: THEY ARE NOT CLOSE TO
1:24:01 SUPERSEDING US FOR PROBABLY SIX TO EIGHT MONTHS BEHIND US.
1:24:05 IF WE WERE TO REGULAR ENFORCE THE CHIPS AND PROHIBITIONS
1:24:09 ANOTHER TECHNIQUE THEY USE CALL DISTILLATION WITH OR ACCESSING
1:24:11 THE AMERICAN MODELS AND CREATING SMALLER VERSIONS OF IT.
1:24:16 IF WE WERE TO IMPOSE BOTH OF THEM ON THEM PLUS SEMICONDUCTOR
1:24:20 MANUFACTURING EQUIPMENT RESTRICTIONS AND FORCING THOSE
1:24:22 WE WOULD PROBABLY HAVE AT LEAST A TWO TO THREE YEAR LEAD MAY BE
1:24:26 LONGER FOR CHINA WHICH ALLOW US MORE FLEXIBILITY IN U.S. POLICY
1:24:31 ABOUT PAUSING OR PACING OF THE CHINESE THREAT.
1:24:34 SO THEY WON'T OVERTAKE US. THEY ARE NIPPING AT OUR HEELS
1:24:36 BUT WE HAVE HELPED DRAG THAT ALONG.
1:24:40 LIKE TETHERING THE CORE THAT'S PULLING THEM UP.
1:24:46 LISA: FORMER DEPARTMENT OF DEFENSE UNDERSECRETARY JOINING
1:24:47 US THERE. LET'S GET AN UPDATE ON STORIES
1:24:51 WITH VONNIE QUINN. >> ELIZABETH WARREN AND CHRIS
1:24:59 COONS ASKING THE TRUMP ADMINISTRATION TO PRESERVE ALL
1:25:01 RECORDS REGARDING THE EXPORT OF NVIDIA CHIPS TO CHINA.
1:25:05 MILLER. THIS COMES AFTER REPORTS THE
1:25:10 ADMINISTRATION OFFICIALS KNEW JENSEN HUANG WAS A TARGET OF THE
1:25:12 SUSPECTED CHINESE SPY OPERATION. PRESIDENT TRUMP TAKING HUGE
1:25:20 CARAVANS OF MIGRANTS EN ROUTE TO THE UNITED STATES FROM MEXICO.
1:25:22 THE PRESIDENT POSTING ON TRUTH SOCIAL MEXICO MUST STOP THEM NOW
1:25:27 AND IF THEY DON'T DO SO THE TARIFFS WILL IMMEDIATELY BE
1:25:28 DOUBLED. CHEVRON SHARES ARE UP NEARLY 30%
1:25:35 SINCE THE U.S. CAPTURE OF VENEZUELAN PRESIDENT NICOLAS
1:25:36 MADURO AT THE BEGINNING OF THIS YEAR.
1:25:39 THE OIL GIANT CAPITALIZING TO GAIN A $7 BILLION MULTIYEAR
1:25:43 EXPANSION REFORM. >> HAD PREVENTED US
1:25:49 SENDING MORE MONEY IN VENEZUELA IT WAS REALLY THE ECONOMICS, THE
1:25:53 RETURNS WE COULD EXPECT. IT'S IN THE LAST THREE YEARS
1:25:57 WE'VE HAD THE JOINT VENTURES WITH THEM AND HAVE BEEN
1:25:59 INVESTING IN PRODUCTION. WE GO FOR 50,000 BARRELS A DAY
1:26:05 BACK IN 2022 AND WERE ALMOST 300 THIS YEAR.
1:26:11 VONNIE: SITTING DOWN WITH THE CHEVRON CEO YOU CAN SEE MORE OF
1:26:14 THAT INTERVIEW AT 9:30 TONIGHT RIGHT HERE ON BLOOMBERG TV.
1:26:16 THAT IS YOUR BLOOMBERG BRIEF. LISA: THAT WAS REALLY FUN.
1:26:23 ANNMARIE: SHE STARTED HER CAREER OFFSHORE ON AND OFFSHORE OIL RIG
1:26:29 TO WORK YOUR WAY UP TO THE CFO SUITE.
1:26:32 WE GOT TO SEE WHAT SOME OF WHAT THEY WERE DOING.
1:26:35 THEY'VE BEEN IN VENEZUELA FOR 100 YEARS.
1:26:38 NEWS THIS WEEK, EXXON IT WAS AN UN-INVESTABLE PLACE AND THEY'RE
1:26:39 LOOKING AS WELL. LISA: UP NEXT, HEIGHTENING RISKS
1:26:43 TO THE AI BUILDOUT. >> NVIDIA WILL BE UNDER MASS
1:26:50 SCRUTINY PEOPLE WILL BE DIVERSIFYING AWAY FROM NVIDIA TO
1:26:52 MANAGE THE RISK AND ATTRIBUTION. >> NATHANEIL ROSENBAUM JOINS US
1:27:00 NEXT. THIS IS BLOOMBERG SURVEILLANCE. GOOD MORNING. ♪
1:27:33 >> SEEING SHARES LOWER THIS MORNING AHEAD OF THE OPEN
1:27:35 QUESTIONS SWIRL AROUND JENSEN HUANG'S FUTURE IS CEO OF NVIDIA
1:27:38 DOWN ABOUT 1/10 OF 1% ON THE NASDAQ FUTURES AHEAD OF THE
1:27:41 OPEN. 4/10 OF A PERCENT DECLINE.
1:27:45 NVIDIA SHARES DRAGGING DOWN THE TECH SECTOR IN A SIGNIFICANT WAY
1:27:51 WHETHER TO REMOVE HIM AS CEO THE FOUNDER ALLEGEDLY INVOLVED WITH
1:27:55 SEVERAL EXTRAMARITAL AFFAIRS INCLUDING ONE WITH AN ALLEGED
1:27:57 CHINESE SPY. SHARES DOWN BY ALMOST EIGHT
1:27:59 PERCENT. ALSO TAKE A LOOK AT AND IBS.
1:28:03 EARLIER WHEN THEY FIRST REPORTED EARNINGS BETTER THAN EXPECTED IN
1:28:06 THE THIRD QUARTER. NOW SHARES HER LOWER BY MORE
1:28:10 THAN 10% WITH SOME QUESTIONS ABOUT THE FORWARD-LOOKING
1:28:12 OUTLOOK. RAISING THE QUESTIONS ABOUT SOME
1:28:15 OF THE NAMES BACK BY NVIDIA BUT ALSO THAT ARE MORE SUSCEPTIBLE
1:28:17 TO HIGHER BORROWING COSTS. THE DON'T HAVE THE SAME KIND OF
1:28:21 FORTRESS BALANCE SHEET THE HYPERSCALERS DO.
1:28:27 ANNMARIE: NET NEGATIVE CONSIDERING THE TWEAK LOWER IN
1:28:31 THE SALES GUIDEBOOK, WE'VE SEEN A LOT OF THIS FROM THESE
1:28:33 NEO-CLOUDS THEY WERE GUIDING HIGHER.
1:28:34 THAT'S WHAT HAPPENED WITH COREWEAVE.
1:28:39 THEY JUST PUT COLD WATER ON THAT WHEN IT COMES TO THIS.
1:28:44 FOR TECH. YOU ARE SEEING THAT SELLOFF IN
1:28:49 THE FRONT-END OF THE YIELD CURVE AHEAD OF PPI TOMORROW AHEAD OF
1:28:52 INITIAL JOBLESS CLAIMS IN ABOUT AN HOUR TIME OR 45 MINUTES TIME.
1:28:56 PRETTY MUCH SEEING THE FRONT-END OF THE YIELD CURVE DRIVING ABOUT
1:29:03 THREE BASIS POINTS TO 4.76 PERCENT.
1:29:04 QUESTIONS ON THE COST OF BORROWING UNDER SURVEILLANCE
1:29:06 HEIGHTENING RISKS TO THE AI BUILDOUT.
1:29:13 >> NVIDIA UNDER MASS SCRUTINY BECAUSE QUITE FRANKLY JENSEN WAS
1:29:17 THE SUPER INTELLIGENCE LEAD HE WAS THE CAPITAL OW LOCATOR.
1:29:19 THE POLITICAL FACE OF THE ADMINISTRATION.
1:29:22 PEOPLE WILL BE DIVERSIFYING AWAY FROM NVIDIA TO MANAGE THEIR RISK
1:29:25 AND ATTRIBUTION. >> THE NVIDIA SCANDAL LOOMING
1:29:31 LARGE OVER THE AI INDUSTRY. INVESTORS FEAR AND REPORTED
1:29:34 OUSTING OF CO JENSEN HUANG COULD IMPACT THE CHIPMAKER'S ABILITY
1:29:36 TO FUND THE DATA CENTER BUILDOUT.
1:29:38 NATHAN ROSENBAUM OF JP MORGAN JOINS US.
1:29:42 THANK YOU SO MUCH FOR BEING HERE.
1:29:44 I KNOW YOU FOCUS ON THE INVESTMENT RATE CREDIT UNIVERSE
1:29:46 AND WHAT THE SUPPLY DEMAND DYNAMIC IS.
1:29:50 HOW MUCH IS THIS STORY RELEVANT IN TERMS OF NVIDIA AS A BACKER
1:29:53 TO THE ENTIRE AI BUILDOUT. BOTH IN THE HYPERSCALERS.
1:29:59 >> GREAT TO SEE YOU AGAIN LEASE AND THANK YOU FOR HAVING ME ON.
1:30:05 I THINK ABOUT NVIDIA IN THE IRATE MARKET ISN'T VERY SMALL.
1:30:09 35 BILLION IN DEBT WHICH IN HIGH-GRADE IS TINY THESE DAYS.
1:30:12 THE 55TH LARGEST ISSUER IN THE MARKET AND SO I DON'T THINK THIS
1:30:17 HAS BROADER RAMIFICATIONS AND I THINK HIGHER CREDIT SPREADS ARE
1:30:19 TIGHTER ON THE BACK OF THIS NEWS.
1:30:22 IN TERMS OF BEING A BACKSTOP FOR OTHERS THAT'S CLEARLY NVIDIA HAS
1:30:29 PLAYED IN THE BROADER AI ECOSYSTEM A THAT CERTAINLY GOING
1:30:32 TO BE QUESTIONED IN THE DAYS AHEAD.
1:30:36 A LOT MORE COLOR NEXT WEEK. THIS REMAINS A COMPANY THIS
1:30:42 INCREDIBLY PROFITABLE, VERY LITTLE LEVERAGE SO IT CAN IN
1:30:47 SYSTEM. AT THE END OF THE DAY WHILE THIS
1:30:54 IS UNFORTUNATE SERIES OF EVENTS, I DON'T THINK IT REALLY CHANGES
1:30:59 THE BROADER NARRATIVE AROUND THE ECOSYSTEM.
1:31:04 >> WITH ALL OF THE HYPERSCALERS THAT HAVE BEEN TRYING TO GET
1:31:08 MORE AND MORE CASH. ARE THERE ENOUGH INVESTORS TO
1:31:11 FINANCE THIS. ARE THEY FINDING ENOUGH PENNIES
1:31:17 TO FINANCE THIS. ESPECIALLY GIVEN THAT THEY DON'T
1:31:20 STOP NEXT YEAR OR IN 2028. NATHANIEL: THAT'S THE KEY
1:31:23 QUESTION FOR THESE COMPANIES ARE LOOKING UNDER EVERY COUCH
1:31:28 CUSHION. THIS WEEK AGAIN YOU'RE ONE OF
1:31:30 THE LARGEST HYPERSCALERS IN THE MOST PROLIFIC ISSUER THIS YEAR.
1:31:36 BUT WENT AHEAD AND STARTED LOOKING AT SINGAPORE DOLLAR TO
1:31:38 CREDIT MARKETS I BARELY KNEW EXISTED A WEEK AGO.
1:31:42 SO THEY ARE DEFINITELY LOOKING FAR AND WIDE BUT THEY ARE
1:31:49 FINDING I WOULD ARGUE RELATIVELY EASILY STILL EVEN IN THE DOLLAR
1:31:51 MARKET. WE JUST HAD FOUR OF THE SIX
1:31:56 HYPERSCALERS YOU KNOW RAISE FINANCING AND JUST UNDER FOUR
1:31:58 DAYS. THIS WAS OVER THE LAST TWO
1:31:59 WEEKS. IN ALL OF THOSE DEALS HAVE GONE
1:32:03 THEY ARE SOME OF THE BEST-PERFORMING BONDS TODAY.
1:32:08 SO I DON'T THINK THERE HAVE BEEN MUCH TROUBLE FINANCING IT.
1:32:10 I THINK THAT COMES BACK TO THE FACT COMING INTO ALL OF THIS YOU
1:32:17 KNOW THE MAINSTAY FOR THE HIGH-GRADE BOND MARKET WHICH IS
1:32:19 INSURANCE COMPANIES WE ARE ACTUALLY UNDERWEIGHT THIS.
1:32:23 IT'S BEEN A LOT OF CONCERN ARE THEY TO FULL ISSUER
1:32:24 CONCENTRATION. AND OUR WORK JP MORGAN SHOWS
1:32:27 THAT THEY ARE NOT. THEY ARE STILL ACTUALLY WE'VE
1:32:32 BEEN SOMEWHAT UNDERWEIGHT THIS WEEK SO THERE IS STILL ROOM BUT
1:32:36 GIVEN HOW MUCH IS YET TO COME IF YOU LOOK AT THE CAPEX FORECAST
1:32:39 FROM SOME OF THESE FOR NEXT YEAR, THEY ARE SKY HIGH.
1:32:42 THERE IS REASON TO BE CONCERNED ABOUT THIS A LOT MORE DEBT YET
1:32:47 TO COME. BUT OUR SENSE IS AT THE RIGHT
1:32:52 PRICE AND PRICE CREATES DEMAND FOR THE RIGHT PRICE THERE WILL
1:32:53 BE DEMAND FOR THAT. ANNMARIE: MORE PREMIUMS PLACE?
1:32:59 NATHANIEL: YES. LIKE EVERY SUCCESSIVE ISSUANCE
1:33:02 THIS YEAR IS PUT SOME PRESSURE ON HYPERSCALERS SPREADS.
1:33:05 IF YOU LOOK BACK AT THE LAST ROUND.
1:33:10 HAS BEEN LITERALLY DOUBLED THE REST OF THE MARKET.
1:33:13 THIS IS AN UNFORESEEABLE WE'VE NEVER SEEN A DIVERGENCE LIKE
1:33:14 THIS BEFORE. ANNMARIE: WILL GET HARDER GIVEN
1:33:18 THE POLITICAL BACKDROP. NATHANIEL: IF YOU LOOK BACK
1:33:25 SINCE THE MIDTERMS LAST WEEK YOU HAD ONE HYPERSCALER GO AHEAD AND
1:33:27 ANNOUNCE A NEW DATA CENTER PROJECT IN A STATE THAT STAYED
1:33:31 QUITE RED AND THEN GO AHEAD AND'S OR TO RAISE MONEY PERHAPS
1:33:35 TOWARDS THAT PROJECT OVERSEAS. SO I THINK FOR NOW IT LOOKS LIKE
1:33:39 IT IS STILL FULL SPEED AHEAD. WE WILL SEE WHERE THE
1:33:45 RUBBER MEETS THE ROAD, WHAT ACTUALLY MATERIALIZES AND MOVE
1:33:49 THE RHETORIC TO POLICY. AT THE MARGIN THERE'S CERTAINLY
1:33:55 A CHANCE THAT THIS MEANS PERHAPS NEXT YEAR IT'S CAPEX FOR THE
1:33:58 SPACE. AND THEN IT STARTS TO SLOW TO 28
1:34:01 AND 29. AND THAT WOULD BE A MATERIAL
1:34:03 POSITIVE HYPERSCALE CREDIT. LISA: DO YOU FEEL ARE PEOPLE
1:34:07 RUSHING TO START BUILDING PROJECTS.
1:34:11 >> THEY'VE BEEN RUSHING FOR YEAR AND A HALF NOW.
1:34:13 WE'VE NEVER SEEN SOMETHING LIKE THIS AT THIS PACE YOU KNOW IN
1:34:19 TERMS OF THE BUILDOUT AND THE CREDIT MARKETS.
1:34:22 WE LOOK AT HYPERSCALERS, A YEAR AGO THEY WERE 2% AND NOW THERE
1:34:24 FIVE. SO THIS IS MAYBE THEY WILL RUSH
1:34:30 A LITTLE MORE BUT THEY'VE ALREADY BEEN RUSHING.
1:34:33 I THINK YOU'RE GOING AT THE MAXIMUM PACE THAT THEY CAN.
1:34:36 THERE'S ONLY SO MANY CHIPS YOU CAN BUILD THERE'S ONLY SO MUCH
1:34:40 POWER OUT THERE TO POWER THESE THERE'S A LOT OF PHYSICAL
1:34:41 CONSTRAINTS THAT I DON'T THINK YOU CAN REALLY MOVE THE NEEDLE
1:34:45 TOO MUCH ON IN TERMS OF THE PACE GOING FORWARD.
1:34:48 LISA: LET'S HAVE YOU ON AGAIN SOON.
1:34:52 NATE OF JP MORGAN. THIS WAS THE MAIN STORY WEEK AND
1:34:55 A HALF AGO AND THINKING ABOUT HOW MUCH HAS HAPPENED.
1:34:58 TALKING ABOUT THE CONSTRAINTS BEING PUT IN THE WIDENING
1:35:01 SPREADS THE QUESTION ABOUT WHETHER INVESTORS WOULD FINANCE
1:35:02 THIS. PEOPLE ARE WONDERING ABOUT THE
1:35:06 STORY. ANNMARIE: JUST ADDING ON THAT
1:35:14 THE FACE OF AI HAS BEEN THIS MAN JENSEN HUANG.
1:35:17 AND NOT ONLY IS THIS THE AFFAIR WITH AN ALLEGED CHINESE SPY BUT
1:35:19 CORPORATE GOVERNANCE THIS IS WHAT WE'LL DO HIM IN THE BOARD.
1:35:24 HAVING AN AFFAIR WITH SOMEONE ACCORDING TO THE NEW YORK TIMES
1:35:25 THAT IS YOUR DIRECT REPORT. LISA: PETER OF ACADEMY, TOM
1:35:35 PORCELLI AS WE GET INITIAL JOBLESS CLAIMS.
1:35:39 THE ECONOMY AND THE FED AND WELLINGTON MANAGEMENT AS WE
1:35:42 PARSE THROUGH THE AFTERMATH OF THIS DEVELOPING SCANDAL FROM NEW
1:35:47 YORK THIS IS BLOOMBERG SURVEILLANCE.
1:36:08 ♪ >> WHAT DOES THIS KIND OF BLACK
1:36:09 CLOUD OVER AI THAT COMES OUT EVERY WEEK.
1:36:12 >> THE GOOSE THAT SLAYING THE GOLDEN EGG AND ELIMINATING AI IS
1:36:14 PROBABLY ONE OF THE PARTS. >> WE ARE FOUR YEARS INTO THE
1:36:19 BULL MARKET. IT SHOULD BE A LITTLE CREEPIER
1:36:22 AT THIS AGE BUT BY NO MEANS OVER.
1:36:26 >> THIS IS BLOOMBERG SURVEILLANCE WITH JONATHAN
1:36:28 FERRO, LISA ABRAMOWICZ AND ANNMARIE HORDERN.
1:36:32 LISA: WELCOME BACK TO BLOOMBERG SURVEILLANCE, A FUTURES LOWER
1:36:36 HUANG. BOARD MEMBERS OF THE WORLD'S
1:36:41 BIGGEST CHIP COMPANY GATHERING TO DISCUSS WHETHER TO OUST THEIR
1:36:45 FOUNDER AND CEO FOLLOWING ADDITIONAL CLAIMS OF DIRECT
1:36:48 RELATIONSHIP WITH A REPORT. STILL NOT CLEAR WHO COULD
1:36:52 REPLACE HIM. BOND MARKETS REOPENED TO A
1:36:56 FRAUGHT MOMENT WHERE THEIR ROLE AS A SAFE ASSET IS INCREASINGLY
1:36:59 QUESTIONED BY HARDER THAN EXPECTED ECONOMIC DATA.
1:37:03 THE CENTRAL BANK OF CHIPS AND CENTRAL BANK OF THE U.S.
1:37:05 INCREASINGLY UNPREDICTABLE PLACES.
1:37:08 ANNMARIE: CENTRAL BANKER WHEN IT COMES TO CHIPS BY A THREAD.
1:37:15 WE WILL HAVE TO SEE WHERE THE SHIPS LAND BUT STILL WAITING FOR
1:37:17 THE BOARD, THEY HAVE BEEN DELIBERATING WITH WHAT THEY WILL
1:37:19 DO WHEN IT COMES TO THESE EXTRAMARITAL AFFAIRS.
1:37:24 THE ALLEGATIONS AT THIS IS A CHINESE SPY.
1:37:28 IT DIRECT REPORT TO HIM THAT LOOKS AT NVIDIA, OF THE
1:37:32 DOWNGRADES THIS MORNING ARE COMING IN OVERNIGHT FAST AND
1:37:33 FURIOUS. BERNSTEIN,
1:37:39 WILLIAM BLAIR, EVERCORE. OPPENHEIMER AND ALSO MORGAN
1:37:40 STANLEY REMOVING IT AS A TOP STOCK.
1:37:47 LISA: IS THIS AN NVIDIA OR A BROADER STORY.
1:37:49 UNCERTAINTY ABOUT THAT YOU SEE NVIDIA SHARES IN THE PREMARKET
1:37:54 TRADING SIGNIFICANTLY LOWER DOWN ALMOST 8% IN PREMARKET TRADING.
1:38:01 YOU DO SEE AMD AND BROADCOM CONTINUE TO GAIN GIVEN THE FACT
1:38:03 THEY ARE DIRECT COMPETITORS. THIS WILL BE A KEY QUESTION TO
1:38:09 WHAT DEGREE DOES THIS LIMIT THE GAINS WE SEE IN THE AI ECOSYSTEM
1:38:12 VERSUS THE PROBLEM OF NVIDIA. ANNMARIE: IT'S BASICALLY
1:38:16 TWOFOLD. THERE WILL BE CONCERNS A
1:38:22 CIRCULAR FINANCING ESPECIALLY IF NVIDIA HAS REVENUE COMING FROM
1:38:26 SOME HARDWARE THAT WAS GETTING ITSELF INTO CHINA IN THE WRONG
1:38:29 HANDS AND SOME PEOPLE SAYING THAT COULD BE BETWEEN 10 TO 20%
1:38:32 THAT'S A BIG CHUNK OF REVENUE. THAT COULD BE A CONCERN BUT AT
1:38:36 THE SAME TIME WHEN IT COMES TO THE COMPETITION, BROADCOM, THEY
1:38:40 ARE THE ONES WHO COULD GAIN FROM ALL OF THIS CHAOS SURROUNDING
1:38:41 NVIDIA. >> PREMARKET TRADING IS
1:38:48 NEGATIVITY AT LEAST IN THE TECH HEAVY NASDAQ 100.
1:38:51 LOWER BY ABOUT 1% EARLIER THIS MORNING NOW MORE THAN 1%.
1:38:56 ABOUT 5/10 OF A PERCENT DECLINE ON S&P FUTURES.
1:39:00 YOU TAKE A LOOK AT THE BOND SPACE TWOS, ATTENDS AND 30'S
1:39:04 THAT BID INTO BONDS AS A HAVEN HAS ENDED.
1:39:06 THE OPPOSITE TAKING HOLD AND THE DEEPENING SELLOFF FOR BASIS
1:39:12 POINT INCREASE ON TWO YEAR YIELDS FOUR POINT 78%.
1:39:15 10 YEAR YIELDS SQUARELY ABOVE THAT THRESHOLD EVEN 30 YEAR
1:39:21 YIELDS GETTING SOLD HIGHER BY ABOUT ONE BASIS POINT AND THIS
1:39:24 COMES AHEAD OF INITIAL JOBLESS CLAIMS COMING IN AROUND 200000
1:39:30 AND WE WILL GET IN ABOUT 25 MINUTES TIME.
1:39:33 COMING UP PETER TCHIR OF ACADEMY'S POTENTIAL CEO RATTLES
1:39:35 THE TECH TRADE. JAY GOLDBERG OF SEAPORT WITH THE
1:39:41 LOAN SELL ON NVIDIA STILL AND MAP OF WELLINGTON MANAGEMENT ON
1:39:44 WHY THE AI STORY IS BIGGER THAN ONE MAN.
1:39:48 WE BEGIN WITH OUR TOP STORY THE COST OF ACCOUNTABILITY.
1:39:52 >> YOU HAVE TO HOLD YOURSELF RESPONSIBLE FOR YOU HAVE AGENCY.
1:39:56 YOU THE CEO. YOU HAVE TO HAVE HIGH STANDARDS
1:39:58 AND EXPECTATIONS JUST AS I CAN BE FIRED THE NEXT CEO HAS TO BE
1:39:59 HIRED. I LIKE THAT WE CAN BE OVERLY
1:40:05 COMPLACENT ABOUT OUR POSITION INSIDE THE COMPANY.
1:40:08 ALWAYS VULNERABLE, ALWAYS EARNING IT.
1:40:12 >> NVIDIA SHARES FALLING IN PREMARKET TRADING IS THE BOARD
1:40:14 CONSIDERS REPLACING JENSEN HUANG.
1:40:17 JOINING US IS OUR REPORTER COVERING ALL OF TECH, ED LUDLOW
1:40:21 BACK FROM VACATION TO A FIRESTORM.
1:40:23 THANK YOU FOR BEING HERE. WHAT'S THE LATEST WHEN YOU TALK
1:40:28 TO PEOPLE IN SILICON VALLEY WITH THE LIKELIHOOD JENSEN HUANG CAN
1:40:29 STAY AT THE HELM OF THIS COMPANY.
1:40:34 >> THE BOARD HAS MET AND IS BLOOMBERG'S REPORTING THE
1:40:36 OPTIONS ON AN INTERIM BASIS. WHICH IS WORKING WITH IN OUR
1:40:41 FIRM FOR EXTERNAL CANDIDATES THEY COULD REPLACE JENSEN HUANG.
1:40:45 AND THINKING ABOUT AN INTERIM CEO AS THEY CAST A WIDER NET FOR
1:40:47 A LONG-TERM SOLUTION. THERE IS A LONG-TERM REPLACEMENT
1:40:53 FOR JENSEN HUANG GIVEN THE ROLE THAT HE'S PLAYED IN THIS AI
1:40:55 BUILDOUT. IN TERMS OF WHO THAT COULD BE,
1:41:02 THEN YOU GO TO MEDIA REPORTS AND SPECULATION A LOT OF PEOPLE
1:41:05 TALKING ABOUT CFO ON AN INTERIM BASIS ONE THAT'S BEEN THERE FOR
1:41:07 13 YEARS. ON INCREASING EARNINGS CALL IN
1:41:13 THAT PERIODS AND ONE MIGHT ARGUE HAS HELD THE RELATIONSHIP WITH
1:41:17 WALL STREET IAN BUCK LED THE TEAM THAT WROTE THE LANGUAGE IN
1:41:19 THE MID TO THOUSANDS VERY IMPORTANT LEADER IN NVIDIA'S
1:41:24 BUSINESS ON THE DATA CENTER SIDE AND THE EXTERNAL CANDIDATES ARE
1:41:27 INTERESTING. A FORMER NVIDIA EMPLOYEE KNOWS
1:41:30 THE SEMI-CUTTER INDUSTRY INSIDE AND OUT.
1:41:34 DECISION. HE WOULD LOOK TO A VERY BROAD
1:41:39 RANGE OF SOURCES HEARD I WAS ON VACATION CONSTANTLY FOR THREE
1:41:42 DAYS. THERE'S A VERY LARGE GROUP OF
1:41:48 INVESTORS AND PEOPLE IN ECOSYSTEM THAT ARE JUST
1:41:50 DEMANDING THAT THIS BOARD NOT TO RUSH THIS.
1:41:53 AND ACTUALLY MAYBE PUT IT TO A SHAREHOLDER VOTE.
1:41:55 FOR A LONG-TERM OUTCOME. MANY PEOPLE WANTING JENSEN HUANG
1:41:58 TO STAY IN THE POST. >> WE'VE HEARD THIS FROM OTHER
1:42:05 PEOPLE AS WELL CONSIDERING THEY DID CREATE THE COMPANY AND THE
1:42:08 COMPANY IS HIM. HERE'S THE VIEW FROM WALL STREET
1:42:11 WRITING GIVEN HOW MANY INTERCONNECTED THE COMPUTER
1:42:13 INDUSTRY IS AND THAT JENSEN WAS SUCH A FORCE WITHIN IT, THIS IS
1:42:17 WHERE I THINK THE TAIL RISK RESIDES.
1:42:18 PETER JOINS US FOR MORE. WHAT DO YOU MEAN BY THAT, THE
1:42:24 IDEA THIS IS WHERE THE TAIL RISK RESIDES.
1:42:27 PETER: A LOT OF ALLEGEDLY'S BUT I DO THINK THEY WILL EXPLORE
1:42:32 WHAT DEALS WERE DONE IN THEIR ABILITY TO HAVE THESE DEALS.
1:42:37 JENSEN WAS THIS FORCE WITHIN THE INDUSTRY.
1:42:39 MOVING THINGS ALONG DOES THAT CHANGE IF HE GETS SIDELINED OR
1:42:45 HAS TO STEP BACK, HE HAS BEEN SUCH A BIG PART OF THE GROWTH
1:42:49 THIS PLAY OUT. LISA: THE TAIL RISK FOR NVIDIA
1:42:55 OR THE TRADE GIVEN THE INTERCONNECTEDNESS OF FINANCES.
1:43:00 PETER: NVIDIA HAS BEEN SO IMPORTANT I WAS JUST CHECKING
1:43:03 COREWEAVE BONDS WHILE STOCKMARKETS GOT TO RALLY OR
1:43:10 BONDS UNCHANGED ON TUESDAY. NOT REFLECTIVE OF YESTERDAY'S
1:43:11 GAIN. I THINK THE CREDIT MARKETS THIS
1:43:19 IS THE END OF STORIES AND NOW YOU GOT ECHOES OF MORE QUESTIONS
1:43:20 ON THE MIND. ANNMARIE: HOW CONCERNED YOU
1:43:24 ABOUT IP THEFT? PETER: THIS IS ONE OF THE
1:43:30 COMPLAINTS, WE ARE ONE OF THE FEW COMPLAINING ABOUT CHEAP
1:43:32 CHINESE COMPUTER. THE FACT CHINA STEALS MODELS AND
1:43:35 THAT THEY ARE DOING EVERYTHING IN THEIR POWER TO CATCH UP ON
1:43:39 THEIR CHIPS DEFICIENCY. I THINK PEOPLE FORGET YOU GO
1:43:45 BACK TO 2005 YOU LOOK AT THE IP THE U.S. OWNED MOST ALL THE IP.
1:43:48 SOME WAS EASY TO REPLICATE. BUT CLEARLY THEY DID SOME
1:43:56 NOW. IN THIS COMPETITION WITH CHINA
1:44:02 WE ARE PLAYING ONE GAME IN CHINA IS PLAYING A LONGER AND
1:44:05 POTENTIAL DIRTIER GAME AND THAT'S AT THE FOREFRONT WHETHER
1:44:06 THIS GOES BY OR NOT. AMERICA HAS TO GET BEHIND THIS
1:44:11 CHIP INDUSTRY AND FIGURE OUT WHAT WE DO.
1:44:15 >> DO YOU THINK THIS WILL MOVE THE BALANCE OF POWER IN
1:44:19 WASHINGTON TOWARDS THOSE THAT SAY I DON'T CARE ABOUT MAKING
1:44:22 SURE THE WHOLE WORLD IS ON A TECH STACK.
1:44:25 WE NEED TO PUT UP THE WALLS WHEN IT COMES TO CHINA.
1:44:28 PETER: WE'VE BEEN AHEAD OF THAT A LITTLE BIT.
1:44:29 YOU SEE THAT IN THE LAST FEW MONTHS SAYING WE CAN RELY ON
1:44:33 CHINA OR AMERICA. EACH REGION IS GOING TO BE
1:44:37 TRYING HARD TO BUILD UP THE CHIP STACK AND THEIR COMPUTE
1:44:40 CAPACITY. LISA: AT THIS POINT THERE IS
1:44:45 CONCERN ABOUT WHAT THIS MEANS FOR POLICY.
1:44:49 THE IDEA COULD BE A TAIL RISK FOR THE ENTIRE TECH SECTOR.
1:44:52 CAN YOU EXTRAPOLATE THAT IS THAT BECAUSE OF THE FACT NVIDIA IS
1:44:59 FINANCING COMPANIES NOT TO MENTION THE COREWEAVE'S AND
1:45:02 EVEN THE ANTHROPIC'S OF THE WORLD.
1:45:06 PETER: TO ME IT IS JUST YOU WATCH THIS COMING THROUGH AND
1:45:11 ANYTIME THERE IS DOUBTS OR QUESTIONS ON THE MARKETS NVIDIA
1:45:12 ALWAYS CAME OUT. HOW IS THIS FINANCING GOING TO
1:45:16 GET DONE. NVIDIA WILL COME UP WITH A
1:45:17 SOLUTION. A LOT OF IT LOOKS LIKE JENSEN
1:45:22 HIMSELF. IF YOU HAVE THIS KIND OF HUGE
1:45:26 PROBLEM SOLVER WHETHER TO STEVE JOBS OR BILL GATES, JENSEN SEEMS
1:45:32 TO BE THAT SAME FORCE OF NATURE AND IF HE IS GONE OR SIDELINED
1:45:34 DO WE GET THAT GROWTH. IF THE NEXT TIME WE HAD A
1:45:37 ROADBLOCK DOES IT STOP. WHOEVER TAKES CHARGE OF THE
1:45:42 INDUSTRY IN WASHINGTON AS WELL. WASHINGTON BOTH UNDER THE BIDEN
1:45:47 ADMINISTRATION AND THE TRUMPET ADMINISTRATION TO SOMEONE ELSE
1:45:52 RULES GOING ON. I THINK MISSING HIM, HE WAS SUCH
1:45:57 A LISA: LISA: CATALYST. HOW MUCH MORE OF A CLEARING
1:46:03 EVENT IS THIS NEXT WEEK GIVEN THE PROOF IS IN THE PUDDING
1:46:06 ABOUT WHETHER YOU CAN GET A DEAL DONE WITH ALL OF THE UNCERTAINTY
1:46:10 ON THE POLICY SIDE AND NOW WITH THIS NEW DROP IN NVIDIA.
1:46:14 PETER: EVEN WITH NVIDIA NOW WE SEE HOW THIS PLAYS OUT.
1:46:18 MONDAY AND TUESDAY WE ARE RALLYING AS IT LOOKS ALL GOOD.
1:46:25 AND IT'S INTERESTING BECAUSE PUTTING PRIVATE DATA TO THE
1:46:26 PUBLIC SECTOR. WE'VE A LOT MORE QUESTIONS SO I
1:46:30 THINK THIS WILL BE THIS DEAL GETS DONE WITH EVALUATION.
1:46:40 THIS SHOULD HAVE ENOUGH MONEY TO BORROW MONEY OR RAISE EQUITY FOR
1:46:43 MONTHS IF NOT A YEAR TO COME. THAT TO ME WOULD BE A REAL
1:46:46 COMPANY MOVE. I THINK ALL THAT PRESSURE STARTS
1:46:51 BACK ON BOND YIELDS WITH EQUITIES.
1:46:56 >> WITH THE NVIDIA DRAMA MEAN FOR ANTHROPIC FOR REALLOCATION
1:46:58 OF CAPITAL? PETER: IT IS TOO EARLY FOR ME TO
1:47:05 SEE AND I THINK AS YOU POINT OUT THERE ARE OTHER CHIP COMPANIES
1:47:08 CHOMPING AT THE BIT. THAT'S WHAT REALLY SCARES ME,
1:47:17 THEY CAN FILL THE VOID IF THERE'S ANY UNCERTAINTY ANY
1:47:20 SLOWDOWN IN THIS RAPID PACE IN THE U.S. CHINA IS TRYING TO STEP
1:47:21 IN. I THINK THAT'S THE BIGGER
1:47:23 CONCERN. AND CHINA'S ABILITY TRYING TO
1:47:29 CATCH UP THEY ARE AHEAD ON THE ELECTRICITY GRID.
1:47:35 SO THAT TO ME IS THE RACE AND READ A BUNCH OF STATES I THINK
1:47:39 ULTIMATELY THAT'S BRINGING THEM BACK TO THE TABLE.
1:47:43 WAITING TO SEE THE OTHERS RAISING THEIR HANDS.
1:47:49 IT. LISA: GREAT TO HAVE YOU AS
1:47:53 ALWAYS. WE ARE LITTLE MORE THAN OUR AWAY
1:47:58 FROM THE BELL. LET'S GET AN UPDATE ON STORIES
1:48:04 ELSEWHERE WITH VONNIE QUINN. VONNIE: VICE PRESIDENT JD VANCE
1:48:10 IS REPORTEDLY CONSIDERING DIRECT TALKS WITH THE TOP RAINING
1:48:13 SECURITY OFFICIAL. THE WALL STREET JOURNAL REPORTED
1:48:16 PRESIDENT TRUMP AS EMPOWERED VANS TO NEGOTIATE ALTHOUGH
1:48:19 MEETINGS REMAIN IMPENDING.
1:48:26 BYTEDANCE IS PLANNING TO LAUNCH AN AI ASSISTANTS SIMILAR TO
1:48:31 META'S MUSE IN THE COMING WEEKS.
1:48:32 SOURCES TELLING BLOOMBERG -- THE CO-FOUNDER TOLD EMPLOYEES
1:48:36 THEY WILL BE ABLE TO COMPETE WITH OPENAI AND ANTHROPIC BUT
1:48:39 NOT UNTIL AT LEAST 2029. THE SUSPECTED CHINESE SPY WHO
1:48:43 HAD AN AFFAIR WITH NVIDIA CEO JENSEN HUANG HAS BEEN BANNED
1:48:49 FROM SINGAPORE SINCE FEBRUARY. SINGAPORE POLICE SAY THE PROBE
1:48:52 IS ONGOING. SOURCES OF BLOOMBERG SAY SHE'S
1:48:54 LIVING IN BEIJING WITH THE KNOWLEDGE OF OFFICIALS.
1:48:56 BETTER BLOOMBERG BRIEF. >> UP NEXT THE MORNING CALLS
1:49:04 PLUS JAY GOLDBERG OF SEAPORT WITH THE LONE SELL RATING ON NVIDIA.
1:49:07 THAT'S COMING UP NEXT, THIS IS BLOOMBERG SURVEILLANCE.
1:49:42 ♪ >> IT’S KIND OF LIKE TEAM USA
1:49:44 BASKETBALL. IF MICHAEL JORDAN IS INJURED AND
1:49:47 THE REST OF THE TEAM CARRY FORWARD AND THAT'S THE QUESTION
1:49:48 INVESTORS ARE ASKING THEMSELVES. I THINK WE WILL MOVE FORWARD
1:49:54 WITH THIS ONCE AND GENERATION INNOVATION WILL CARRY THROUGH.
1:49:58 >> THAT WAS KEITH LERNER OF TRUEST AS WE WENT THROUGH THE
1:50:01 WRECKAGE THAT'S BEEN LEFT IN THE WAKE OF THE SCANDAL AT NVIDIA.
1:50:05 YOU ARE SEEING SHARES BROADLY LOWER ALTHOUGH DRAGGED DOWN IN
1:50:08 THE TECH HEAVY SECTOR. MORE THAN HALF A PERCENT
1:50:13 DECLINES ON THE NASDAQ 100 FUTURES A 10TH OF A PERCENT
1:50:15 DECLINE. IT IS NVIDIA BUT THERE IS
1:50:17 ANOTHER FACTOR HERE. PRESIDENT TRUMP IS TAKING TO
1:50:22 TRUTH SOCIAL IN THE LATEST COMING HOUR HE TALKS ABOUT
1:50:27 ASKING VICE PRESIDENT VANCE TO FOCUS IS COMPLETE AND TOTAL
1:50:30 ATTENTION ON MASSIVE CORRUPTION TAKING PLACE IN DEMOCRAT RUN
1:50:33 CITIES SAYING WE DON'T NEED TO DEAL WITH IRAN THOSE DAYS OF
1:50:34 LONG SINCE PASSED. WHEN WE'VE GOT THERE STRAIGHT,
1:50:41 THANK YOU FOR YOUR ATTENTION TO THIS MATTER.
1:50:42 IF YOU LOOK AT WHAT THAT MEANS FOR OIL.
1:50:46 THE BOARD. UP ONE POINT 6%.
1:50:52 NEW YORK CRUDE UP 1.3 PERCENT. THAT IS DRAGGING THE YIELD
1:50:54 COMPLEX WITH IT. YIELDS HIGHER ACROSS THE BOARD.
1:51:00 NOW THAT TWO YEAR YIELD IS UP EIGHT BASIS POINTS, 4.82%.
1:51:07 FOR EQUITIES MAYBE WE SEE THAT 10 YEAR YIELD 5.05 PERCENT.
1:51:14 -- SIX BASIS POINTS. A MORE CONCILIATORY TONE FROM
1:51:19 THE EXECUTIVE BRANCH ALL OF A SUDDEN WE DON'T EVEN NEED A
1:51:20 DEAL. ANNMARIE: THE PRESIDENT SAYING
1:51:24 IT WILL BE STATUS QUO FROM HERE ON OUT FOR NOW ALSO AND WE HAVE
1:51:29 SEEN THIS HAPPEN WITH THE PRESIDENT BEFORE THIS COULD BE
1:51:32 FOREIGN POLICY VIA TRUTH. THIS COULD BE HIM SENDING A
1:51:37 MESSAGE TO THE IRANIANS BUT DID NOT CONCEDE SOME OF THE ISSUES,
1:51:42 SAYING IT'S A MESS OF PURE NEGOTIATING TACTIC.
1:51:45 CLEARLY THIS HAS GEO-CLINICAL RISK PREMIUMS NOW COMING BACK
1:51:47 INTO THE OIL MARKET. LISA: A TOXIC BREW SO MANY WERE
1:51:56 WORRIED ABOUT EARLIER THIS YEAR ESPECIALLY GIVEN THE OVERHANG OF
1:51:58 ONE NAME AND ONE NAME ONLY. TIME FOR THE MORNING CALLS WITH
1:52:05 ONE STOCK IN FOCUS. NVIDIA.
1:52:06 DOWNGRADING THE STOCK TO MARKET PERFORM.
1:52:10 SAYING WE'VE HAD ENOUGH CONSIDERING NEW ALLEGATIONS.
1:52:14 OPPENHEIMER DOWNGRADING THE STOCK PLUNGES CEOS SEO'S
1:52:18 POTENTIAL DEPARTURE. EVERCORE DOWNGRADING NVIDIA TO
1:52:24 IN LINE WARNING ITS LACK OF A SUCCESSION PLAN IS A RISK.
1:52:26 LET'S STAY WITH NVIDIA. JENSEN HUANG'S FATE BEING
1:52:32 WEIGHED FOLLOWING A REPORT OF MULTIPLE AFFAIRS.
1:52:35 J GOLDBERG HAS THE LOAN SELL ON THE STOCK WITH A 100 $80 PRICE
1:52:40 TARGET, JAY JOINS US FOR MORE. ABOUT 24 HOURS TO TALK TO ALL OF
1:52:45 YOUR CONTACTS AND INVESTORS. IS THE MOOD SOURING ON NVIDIA IN
1:52:48 A RAPID WAY OR DO YOU HAVE SOMETHING TO SAY HOLD ON A
1:52:52 SECOND LET'S REASSESS. THE EARNINGS WILL MATTER.
1:52:55 JAY: I THINK IT'S MORE THE FORMER.
1:53:00 I THINK THE BIG QUESTION THE BIG OVERHANG IS GOING TO BE THE CEO
1:53:03 WHEN WE GET THE EARNINGS NEXT WEEK.
1:53:05 THERE WERE A LOT OF HEADLINES THAT THE BOARD IS TRYING TO
1:53:09 MAYBE OUST HIM, WHO WILL BE -- IS THAT GOING TO HAPPEN AND IF
1:53:13 SO WHO WILL REPLACE HIM THAT'S GOING TO HAVE I THINK IT'S VERY
1:53:16 HARD FOR ANYONE TO HAVE A CLEAR VIEW ON THE STOCK UNTIL WE KNOW
1:53:18 THE ANSWERS TO THOSE QUESTIONS. LISA: TALKING EARLIER AND HE WAS
1:53:23 TALKING ABOUT A NUMBER OF INVESTORS WILL BE FORCED OR
1:53:30 COMPELLED TO SELL THE STOCK BECAUSE OF CONCERNS RUN
1:53:33 GOVERNANCE ISSUES OR A REMOVAL OF THE CEO.
1:53:36 WHAT IS YOUR SENSE OF HOW MUCH SELLING PRESSURE THAT COULD
1:53:39 CREATE IN THE SHARES IN THE UPCOMING DAYS AND WEEKS?
1:53:47 JAY: IF HE IS REMOVED THERE IS MORE DOWNSIDE HERE.
1:53:50 HE IS SEEN AS SUCH A FORCE IN THE COMPANY IN THE INDUSTRY IT'S
1:53:53 A DIFFERENT COMPANY WITHOUT HIM. AI'S CAN GO ON A DIFFERENT
1:53:56 DIRECTORY. I THINK IT'S HARD TO GET MUCH
1:54:03 CONFIDENCE UNTIL WE HAVE THE UNCERTAINTY REMOVED.
1:54:05 EVEN IF THEY SWITCH TO ANOTHER CEO, WHO WILL IT BE?
1:54:09 THAT'S GOING TO HAVE THAT WE WILL TAKE TIME TO FIGURE THAT
1:54:10 OUT. THERE IS NO OBVIOUS CANDIDATE,
1:54:16 THERE'S NO EXTERNAL CANDIDATE. HE HAS A BIG LEATHER JACKET TO
1:54:24 FILL AND SO IT'S A VERY LARGE UNCERTAINTY BUT IT'S ONE I THINK
1:54:27 PROBABLY GET SOME CLARITY ON THE NEXT ANY MINUTE NOW PROBABLY
1:54:30 TODAY. >> WE HAD TED MORTENSEN ON WHO
1:54:36 SAID THERE NEEDS TO BE AN EXPERT WITH THE PRISTINE RECORD.
1:54:38 WHO IS THAT SHORT LIST? JAY: I THINK WE LIVE IN A FALLEN
1:54:42 WORLD. CANDIDATES COME TO MIND, THERE
1:54:49 ARE A FEW POSSIBLE ONES THAT AREN'T LIKELY TO HAPPEN WITH
1:54:52 OTHER SEATS AND SOME OF HIS COMPETITORS.
1:54:57 COMING OVER IT'S VERY TOUGH TO SPECULATE.
1:55:03 I SPENT SOME TIME IN POLYMARKET WHERE THE BETS ARE.
1:55:09 THEY ALL SEEM LIKE PRETTY PLAUSIBLE CANDIDATES SO I DON'T
1:55:11 KNOW WHICH WAY IT WILL LAND. MY BEST GUESS IS IF THEY DO
1:55:14 REMOVE THEM THEY WILL GO TO AN INTERIM CEO WITH THEIR CFO.
1:55:19 AN INTERIM CEO FOR THE. AND THEN MOVED TO SOMEONE NEW.
1:55:25 >> IS THAT INDIVIDUAL POTENTIALLY ALSO GOING TO BE
1:55:27 UNDER INVESTIGATION ESPECIALLY GIVEN THE FACT A LOT OF PEOPLE
1:55:31 ARE ONCE AGAIN STARTING TO LOOK AT SOME OF THEIR SINGAPORE SALES
1:55:36 THAT THEY THEN STARTED TO STOP SHOWING CASING AND THEIR REVENUE
1:55:40 OUTLOOK AND BREAK AS WELL AS THE GENERAL COUNSEL WHOSE BEEN THE
1:55:44 DRIVING FORCE BEHIND THE COMMUNICATIONS WITH THE COMMERCE
1:55:47 DEPARTMENT OR DO YOU THINK THIS IS REALLY JUST A JENSEN ISSUE?
1:55:53 JAY: TRYING TO THINK THROUGH FROM THE BOARD'S PERSPECTIVE IF
1:55:57 IT WERE JUST THE ALLEGED SPY SCANDAL.
1:55:59 THEY CAN PROBABLY GET PAST THAT BECAUSE THERE'S NO HARD EVIDENCE
1:56:04 AS FAR AS WE KNOW YET THAT HE DID ANYTHING WRONG FROM THE
1:56:08 COMPANY'S PERSPECTIVE AND TRANSFERRED INFORMATION.
1:56:14 WE HAVE A SINGLE STORY WITH ANONYMOUS SOURCES.
1:56:15 THE BOARD CAN PROBABLY GET PAST THAT.
1:56:19 BUT NOW YESTERDAY THIS ALLEGATIONS YET ANOTHER AFFAIR,
1:56:25 MOST CORPORATIONS IN AMERICA THAT'S AN AUTOMATIC FIRING FOR
1:56:26 ANYBODY INCLUDING THE CEO. SO, THEY DON'T HAVE IT.
1:56:37 I THINK SHE STILL REMAINS UNDER A CLOUD NO MATTER WHAT THE
1:56:39 COMPANY WILL BE UNDER INVESTIGATION FOR ALL THE STUFF
1:56:42 THAT'S HAPPENING IN SINGAPORE AND SOUTHEAST ASIA.
1:56:43 THAT'S A GIVEN. THE GOVERNMENT ALREADY HAS FOUR
1:56:48 INVESTIGATIONS UNDERWAY AND A FEW MORE COMING SO I THINK SHE
1:56:54 WOULD HAVE A HARD TIME GETTING PROMOTED TO FULL-TIME CEO BUT
1:57:00 CERTAINLY INTERIM CEO SEEMS ECOLOGICAL PATH.
1:57:02 SHE'S THE ONE NAME THAT INVESTORS KNOW.
1:57:09 ANNMARIE: THAT ALMOST OPEN-DOOR POLICY JENSEN HUANG'S HAD WITH
1:57:11 THE OVAL OFFICE IS THAT OVER? >> THAT'S A POLITICAL QUESTION
1:57:16 BEYOND THE CAPABILITIES OF THIS SEMI CONDUCTOR ANALYST.
1:57:18 SO I DON'T KNOW. IT'S CLEAR TO ME THAT A LOT OF
1:57:25 WHAT'S HAPPENED IN THE LAST WEEK IS PART OF AN ORCHESTRATED
1:57:29 POLITICAL CAMPAIGN AGAINST HIM COMING FROM D.C..
1:57:35 IT IS SO SLICK AND SO WELL-TIMED , IT REALLY FEELS LIKE THIS IS
1:57:41 DELIBERATE OUSTING AND HE HAS ENEMIES IN D.C. SO I THINK IT
1:57:44 WILL BE VERY HARD. WHAT HIS RELATIONSHIP WILL BE
1:57:47 WITH THE PRESIDENT I CAN'T EVEN GUESS.
1:57:52 LISA: J GOLDBERG THANK YOU FOR BEING WITH US THIS MORNING.
1:57:56 AS WE ASSESS THIS STORY. ANOTHER STORY DEVELOPING AS WE
1:57:59 SIT HERE AND TRY TO UNDERSTAND THE NVIDIA WEB WHICH IS
1:58:03 PRESIDENT TRUMP COMING OUT WITH A TRUTH SOCIAL POST ACCUSING THE
1:58:06 DEMOCRATS OF CORRUPTION SAYING IF YOU WANT TO AND THAT THAT
1:58:11 WOULD BALANCE THE BUDGET. THEN GOING ON TO SAY WE DON'T
1:58:14 NEED TO DEAL WITH IRAN, WE'VE GOT THEIR MONEY, HUNDREDS OF
1:58:18 BILLIONS OF DOLLARS AND WE'VE GOT THEIR STRAIGHT.
1:58:21 THIS IS SENDING OIL PRICE MATERIALLY HIGHER IN THE BOND
1:58:27 YIELD ON THE TWO-YEAR UP TO THE HIGHEST LEVEL IN A WHILE ABOUT
1:58:31 SEVEN BASIS POINTS USING THE SELLOFF CONTINUE IN OIL PRICES
1:58:33 HIGHER PRETTY MUCH ACROSS THE BOARD.
1:58:36 >> A LOT OF QUESTIONS AS HE SLIPS THIS IN ABOUT WHAT'S GOING
1:58:39 ON DOMESTICALLY IS THE PRESIDENT JUST DOING THIS FOR NEGOTIATING
1:58:42 TACTICS IS HE ACCEPTING THE STATUS QUO WHICH MEANS THE
1:58:46 BLOCKADE STAYS OR POTENTIALLY SENDING A SIGNAL TO THE IRANIANS
1:58:48 THAT WERE NOT COMMITTED TO A DEAL TO MY OTHER OPTION IS GOING
1:58:52 TO BE WHAT SOME HAVE CALLED FINISHING THE JOB, DO YOU SEE
1:58:55 THIS PRESIDENT ONCE AGAIN GO BACK TO THE DRAWING BOARD IN
1:58:59 TERMS OF A MORE KINETIC WARFARE AND ATTACKS AGAINST THE REGIME.
1:59:04 LISA: IT IS NOTABLE TO SEE THE MARKETS RESPONDING TO IT AND
1:59:07 THERE WAS A JITTERY FIELD TO MARKETS OUT OF THE OPEN
1:59:10 ESPECIALLY GIVEN THE LAST ON THE BOND MARKET WAS OPEN WAS TUESDAY
1:59:14 AND USE OF A TWO-YEAR RISE OF 17 BASIS POINTS ON THE HEELS OF A
1:59:18 HARDER THAN EXPECTED CPI PRINT. A FRESH ROUND OF JOBLESS CLAIMS
1:59:21 COMING OUT IN JUST ABOUT FIVE MINUTES TIME.
1:59:24 TOMORROW WE GET PPI. THE ECONOMY STILL IN FOCUS.
1:59:28 TO CENTRAL BANKS ARE KIND OF UNCLEAR AT THIS POINT.
1:59:31 THE U.S.. AND HOW THEY RESPOND TO ALL OF
1:59:36 THIS DATA. TOM OF WELLS FARGO WILL BE WITH
1:59:39 US NEXT TO REACT AS WE GET THAT DATA AND PARSE THE ROAD AHEAD
1:59:45 FOR THE FEDERAL RESERVE. THIS IS BLOOMBERG SURVEILLANCE.
2:00:06 ♪ LISA: THE SELLOFF IS DEEPENING
2:00:07 ACROSS THE BOARD AND IT IS NOT JUST BEHOLDEN TO TECH ANYMORE.
2:00:10 YOU CAN SEE THAT IN THE S&P AND THE NASDAQ.
2:00:15 FUTURES LOWER 1.4% ON THE NASDAQ , WEIGHED DOWN BY NVIDIA.
2:00:21 S&P FUTURES LOWER AND THE RUSSELL 2000 FUTURES ALSO LOWER
2:00:23 .6%. A LOT OF THIS STEMMING FROM THE
2:00:26 BOND MARKET. THE FRONT OF THE YIELD CURVE
2:00:31 RIGHT TUESDAY THE BOND MARKET WAS OPEN THE TWO YEAR YIELD ROAD
2:00:34 17 BASIS POINTS. TODAY IT REOPENS AFTER BEING
2:00:39 CLOSED YESTERDAY UP AN ADDITIONAL SEVEN BASIS POINTS.
2:00:43 THAT IS AN ENTIRE RATE HIKE BAKED INTO THE FRONT END OF THE
2:00:49 YIELD CURVE, 4.80 1% ON THE BACK OF THE HOTTER THAN EXPECTED CPI.
2:00:52 WE ARE GETTING JOBLESS CLAIMS. MICHAEL MCKEE CAN BREAK THAT
2:00:54 DOWN FOR US. STILL GETTING A SENSE OF THE
2:00:57 U.S. ECONOMY. MICHAEL: CERTAINLY STRENGTHEN
2:01:00 THE LABOR MARKET. JOBLESS CLAIMS AT 200,000 WHICH
2:01:09 IS UP FROM A REVISED 191,000 LAST MONTH BUT WE ARE STILL AT A
2:01:13 MARKET. CONTINUING CLAIMS, 1,697,000.
2:01:21 THAT FALLS. THE FOCUS REMAINS ON INFLATION.
2:01:28 WE WILL GET A LOT OF FED SPEAK TODAY AND NOW WITH THE LATEST
2:01:33 PRESIDENTIAL COMMENTS, OIL PRICES SHOOTING UP.
2:01:35 INFLATION REMAINS FRONT AND CENTER BUT WE WILL HAVE BETH
2:01:38 HAMMACK WITHIN THE NEXT HOUR. MICHAEL BARR, AUSTAN GOOLSBEE,
2:01:43 MARY DALY, AND TONIGHT JOHN WILLIAMS, THE NEW YORK FED
2:01:47 PRESIDENT WHO MADE SUCH AS BLAST LAST TIME WHEN HE SUGGESTED THE
2:01:52 FED WOULD NOT BE RAISING INTEREST RATES AT THE OCTOBER
2:01:53 MEETING. LISA: GIVING A LINE IN THE SAND
2:02:10 THAT WAS MEANT BY THAT CPI PRINT.
2:02:12 HAVE WE HEARD ANYTHING ADDITIONAL FROM THE OTHER FED
2:02:16 MEMBERS IN SUPPORT OF THAT HIKE? MICHAEL: NOTHING IN TERMS OF A
2:02:21 50 BASIS POINT MOVE BUT THERE BEEN OTHER FED OFFICIALS SAYING
2:02:26 WE NEED A SERIES OF RATE CUTS AND WHAT SHE WOULD DO IS 25
2:02:30 BASIS POINTS IN DECEMBER AND MOVE UP ANOTHER CUT TO JANUARY.
2:02:35 THE MARKETS ARE PRICING IN A SECOND CUT IN MARCH.
2:02:39 SHE WOULD BE SOONER ON THAT. WE WILL HEAR MORE ON TODAY WITH
2:02:44 BETH HAMMACK WHO HAS BEEN ONE OF THE MORE HAWKISH MEMBERS OF THE
2:02:45 FED. EVERYONE WILL WANT TO KNOW WHAT
2:02:48 JOHN WILLIAMS THINKS. LISA: REALLY APPRECIATE THAT.
2:02:56 WE ARE LOOKING AT MARKETS TURNING OVER AND IT IS NOT
2:02:58 BECAUSE OF JOBLESS CLAIMS THAT CAME IN ON TARGET.
2:03:01 IT IS BECAUSE OF A TRUE SOCIAL POST FROM PRESIDENT TRUMP SAYING
2:03:05 THAT AT THE END OF A LONG POST THAT WE DO NOT NEED TO DEAL WITH
2:03:06 IRAN. THOSE DAYS HAVE SINCE PASSED.
2:03:10 WE HAVE THEIR MONEY AND WE HAVE THEIR STRAIT.
2:03:14 WE ARE SEEING OIL PRICES RESPOND TO THAT.
2:03:19 THE MARKET IS TAKING IT AND RUNNING WITH IT AND YOU ARE
2:03:21 SEEING A SIGNIFICANT RESPONSE. ANNMARIE: THE MARKET MIGHT BE
2:03:26 VIEWING THIS AS WE ARE GOING TO BE BACK TO ESCALATION WITH IRAN
2:03:28 AND STRIKES BACK ON THE TABLE. WHAT MINIMUM IS THIS IS SATAN
2:03:33 LIKE THAT AT THE MOMENT THE PRESIDENT IS WILLING TO ACCEPT
2:03:37 THE STATUS QUO WHICH IS THE BLOCKADE CONTINUES -- AT
2:03:42 MINIMUM THIS IS SAYING IS THE PRESIDENT IS WILLING TO ACCEPT
2:03:44 THE STATUS QUO WHICH IS THE BLOCKADE CONTINUES.
2:03:47 LISA: PRICES OF OIL ARE NOT UP THAT MUCH BUT THE MOVEMENT IN
2:03:51 THE BOND MARKET IS NOTABLE. YOU ARE SEEING AN ADDITIONAL
2:03:55 SEVEN BASIS POINT INCREASE IN THE FRONT END OF THE YIELD
2:03:56 CURVE. TOM PORCELLI OF WELLS FARGO
2:03:59 JOINING US. NOT RESPONDING TO THIS
2:04:03 PARTICULAR TRUTH SOCIAL POST BUT THE JITTERY, IS IT JUSTIFIED
2:04:08 GIVEN HOW HOT SOME OF THE INFLATIONARY DATA HAS BEEN
2:04:09 COMING IN? TOM: I THINK THE WAY YOU CAN
2:04:14 PLUG IN THE MOVE IN CRUDE TODAY HAS BEEN IT SUPPORTS THE IDEA
2:04:17 THAT THE MARKET IS EXPECTING MORE HIKES.
2:04:22 I THINK THE MARKET IS BUILDING THAT IN.
2:04:24 WE AGREE WITH THAT. YOU'RE GOING TO SEE ANOTHER HIKE
2:04:27 AT THE DECEMBER MEETING. CERTAINLY JANUARY AND MARCH ARE
2:04:31 ALSO ON THE TABLE. WHAT WE HAVE TO KEEP IN MIND IS
2:04:36 FOR ALL OF THE INFLATION RHETORIC WE HAVE HEARD, AND IT
2:04:40 HAS BEEN PRETTY NOTABLE, HOW HAWKISH IS THE FED?
2:04:44 I THINK ABOUT LORIE LOGAN WHO I SAY IS ONE OF THE MORE HAWKISH
2:04:48 MEMBERS, SHE IS TALKING ABOUT ONE OR TWO AND THEN PAUSING.
2:04:52 THIS IS NOT A FED THAT IS PARTICULARLY HAWKISH WHICH IS
2:04:54 INTERESTING GIVEN THE FACT THAT SOME OF THE INFLATION DATA WOULD
2:04:57 LEND ITSELF TO THEM BEING MORE AGGRESSIVELY HAWKISH.
2:05:04 LISA: THE DATA WE GOT ON TUESDAY WAS PRETTY BROAD-BASED, IT WAS
2:05:05 IN SERVICES AND RENT. IT SEEMED TO BE PERCOLATING OUT
2:05:11 THE SECOND-ORDER EFFECTS COMING FROM OIL PRICES.
2:05:13 HOW CONCERNING WAS IT TO MAKE YOU RETHINK HOW MANY HIKES WOULD
2:05:16 BE NECESSARY? TOM: WE WROTE THIS NOTE THE
2:05:24 OTHER DAY AND WE WERE BASICALLY -- WE SET OUT TO PACIFY FED
2:05:26 OFFICIALS BY HIGHLIGHTING THAT IF YOU LOOK AT WHERE A LOT OF
2:05:30 THE LIFT IS COMING FROM THE LIFT IS COMING IN THE MOST RANDOM
2:05:32 CATEGORIES. IF YOU GO BACK TO THREE CPI AGO
2:05:38 IT CAME FROM CELL PHONE SERVICE FEES.
2:05:41 THE NEXT MONTH IT CAME FROM COLLEGE TUITION.
2:05:46 YOU ARE RIGHT IN THE THICK OF THAT.
2:05:50 THEN IF YOU THINK ABOUT YESTERDAY IT CAME FROM
2:05:51 PRESCRIPTION DRUGS AND AUTO INSURANCE.
2:05:56 BY THE WAY, IN EACH ONE OF THOSE CATEGORIES WHEN THEY GET THIS
2:05:58 BIG BURST HIGHER THEY FALL THE NEXT MONTH.
2:06:02 IT HAS BEEN LIKE THIS ODD SET OF INDICATORS THAT KEEPS DOING THE
2:06:07 DAMAGE FROM ABOVE CONSENSUS INFLATION PERSPECTIVE AND WHEN
2:06:11 WE SET OUT TO WRITE THIS NOTE WE THOUGHT THIS WOULD MAKE THE FED
2:06:14 FEEL COMFORTABLE, IS ACTUALLY RANDOM CATEGORIES, I DO NOT
2:06:17 THINK THAT WILL BE THE CASE. I THINK THEY WILL FEEL UNSETTLED
2:06:23 BY THIS BECAUSE IF YOU KEEP HAVING THIS PATTERN PERSIST, 25
2:06:28 OR 50 BASIS POINTS MORE OF HIKES IS NOT GOING TO TAME THAT
2:06:29 INFLATION. YOU HAVE TO DO A PRETTY
2:06:33 AGGRESSIVE HIKING CYCLE TO GET THAT UNDER CONTROL.
2:06:36 ANNMARIE: DO YOU THINK GOVERNOR WALLER
2:06:39 OPENING THE DOOR TO 50 IS ON THE TABLE?
2:06:44 TOM: ALL THAT HIGHLIGHTS TO ME AS THEY PROBABLY MADE A MISTAKE
2:06:46 BY SKIPPING THE OCTOBER MEETING AND IF YOU GO 50 WE ARE
2:06:48 HIGHLIGHTING WE PROBABLY MADE A MISTAKE.
2:06:51 I AGREE WITH WITH THE LORIE LOGAN
2:06:55 APPROACH. I THINK AT THE END OF THE DAY
2:07:01 THIS KIND OF INFLATION WILL ABATE.
2:07:05 THERE ARE STILL SUPPLY SHOP ELEMENTS DOING THE DRIVING.
2:07:09 ANNMARIE: DID THEY LOSE CREDIBILITY BY NOT GOING IN
2:07:10 OCTOBER? TOM: I DON'T KNOW THAT THEY
2:07:15 NECESSARILY LOST CREDIBILITY BUT IT LENDS ITSELF TO THAT QUESTION
2:07:18 OF WHETHER OR NOT WE SHOULD BE HAVING THE DISCUSSION RATHER
2:07:20 CREDIBILITY. I THINK IF THEY DO NOT GO IN
2:07:24 DECEMBER AND YOU WILL HAVE A REAL CREDIBILITY PROBLEM.
2:07:29 LISA: THERE WAS A THOUGHT THE MARKET WAS DOING THE WORK FOR
2:07:32 THEM BECAUSE OF THE SELLOFF IN THE BOND SPACE AND ALSO THE
2:07:34 EQUITY SPACE AND YOU ARE ALSO SEEING THAT DEEP IN THE TECH
2:07:35 NAMES. HOW MUCH IS THAT AN ACCURATE
2:07:42 REFLECTION OF WHAT YOU SEE THAT POTENTIAL LOSSES OR QUESTIONS
2:07:47 AROUND TECH NAMES LIKE NVIDIA AND ALSO LESSER PLAYERS IS
2:07:50 ALLOWING SOME OF THE INFLATION TO COME OFF.
2:07:53 DO YOU SEE ANY VALIDITY? TOM: IT IS TOO EARLY.
2:07:59 I THINK THAT WILL COME OF THE BOIL AT SOME POINT.
2:08:02 THE BIGGER PROBLEM IS WHAT YOU THINK THE NEUTRAL RATE IS FOR
2:08:03 TECH? IT IS SO 4%.
2:08:08 IF SOMEONE TWISTED MY ARM TO TELL ME IT WAS 7% OR 8% I MIGHT
2:08:10 BELIEVE YOU. THAT IS THE KIND OF INFLATION
2:08:15 THE FED HAS NO ABILITY TO CONTROL WITHOUT GETTING
2:08:16 INCREDIBLY AGGRESSIVE. LISA: DO YOU THINK BECAUSE WE
2:08:25 GOT THE ELECTION WE DID AND THE PUSHBACK FROM CONSUMERS ABOUT
2:08:28 DATA CENTERS IN THEIR BACKYARDS AND MORE PUSHBACK FROM AI, DO
2:08:30 YOU THINK THAT WILL SLOW GROWTH?
2:08:34 FEWER DATA CENTERS AND FEWER
2:08:38 AI BUILDOUT. TOM: THAT WILL TAKE MUCH LONGER
2:08:44 TO ACTUALLY PLAY OUT WHEN PEOPLE APPRECIATE.
2:08:47 I THINK ABOUT 2027. WE HAVE NOT BILLED IN ANY
2:08:48 NOTABLE WEAKNESS. WE HAVE SHAVED 1/10 FROM OUR
2:08:55 FORECAST ON THE BACK OF THIS. THEY WILL FIND ANOTHER WAY TO
2:08:58 PUT A DATA CENTER ELSEWHERE. I WOULD NOT TAKE THAT IDEA AND
2:09:01 RUN WITH IT TOO MUCH. I THINK THAT IS MISTAKEN.
2:09:07 ANNMARIE: YOU MENTIONED THE FED WOULD HAVE TO HIKE THE HARD AND
2:09:10 FAR TO START TO CURTAIL WHAT WE ARE SEEING IN THE AI SPACE.
2:09:13 YOU THINK THEY HAVE IT IN THEM? TOM: I DON'T.
2:09:17 I DON'T KNOW HOW HAWKISH THIS FED IS.
2:09:20 ANNMARIE: THEY DO NOT WANT TO STOP THIS.
2:09:23 TOM: TALKING ABOUT ONE OR TWO HIKES IS NOT ENOUGH TO GET
2:09:26 INFLATION UNDER CONTROL. WE SAY THIS TO PEOPLE ALL THE
2:09:29 TIME. HIKING RATES IS NOT COST LESS.
2:09:38 THE UNEMPLOYMENT RATE WILL RISE ON THE BACK OF IT.
2:09:43 I CAN TELL YOU 75 BASIS POINTS IS WORTH .2% ON GROWTH BUT 150
2:09:47 BASIS POINTS IS NOT WORTH .4%. IT IS NOT DOUBLE THE IMPACT.
2:09:53 THAT IS SOMETHING THE FED IS ACUTELY AWARE OF AND WHY THEY
2:09:54 WANT TO GO A LITTLE BIT SLOW. LISA: A NUMBER OF ANALYSTS HAVE
2:09:59 RATCHET UP THEIR EXPECTATIONS FOR HOW MANY RATE HIKES THERE
2:10:00 WOULD BE. YOU HAVE MET AT DEUTSCHE BANK
2:10:06 SAYING THREE ADDITIONAL ONES. WHAT ABOUT YOU?
2:10:11 HOW MANY DO THEY NEED TO DO FOR MORE CREDIBILITY?
2:10:14 TOM: WE OFFICIALLY HAVE ONE MORE HIKE.
2:10:18 WE ARE THIS CLOSE TO PUTTING IN ANOTHER.
2:10:21 I THINK ONE OR TWO IS THE RIGHT WAY OF THINKING ABOUT THE CYCLE.
2:10:25 LISA: TOM PORCELLI, THANK YOU FOR BEING WITH US.
2:10:29 AS WE WERE SPEAKING NVIDIA'S PREMARKET LOSSES REACHED 9%.
2:10:33 AMBASSADOR GREER CAME OUT TALKING ABOUT NVIDIA SINGING IS
2:10:35 A STRUCTURALLY IMPORTANT COMPANY.
2:10:38 AT THE SAME TIME YOU'RE GETTING HEADWINDS FROM THE MARKET AFTER
2:10:42 PRESIDENT TRUMP'S TRUTH SOCIAL
2:10:46 POST HIGHLIGHTING THERE WAS NOT A NECESSITY FOR A DEAL WITH IRAN
2:10:50 CAUSING OIL PRICES TO GO HIGHER. ANNMARIE: WHETHER IT IS THE AI
2:10:54 TRAIT OR GEOPOLITICS THE MARKET IS LEFT IN THIS PLACE WHERE
2:10:56 THINGS ARE UNCERTAIN. WE ARE WAITING TO HEAR FROM THE
2:11:00 NVIDIA BOARD AND TO HEAR WHAT THE PRESIDENT MEANT BY WE DO NOT
2:11:01 NEED A DEAL WITH IRAN. DOES THAT MEAN A MORE KINETIC
2:11:06 WAY OF FIGHTING OR DOES THIS MEAN STATUS QUO CONTINUES?
2:11:11 CYLINDERS. LET'S GET YOU AN UPDATE ON
2:11:15 STORIES ELSEWHERE WITH VONNIE QUINN.
2:11:19 VONNIE: RECAPPING THE ECONOMIC DATA, WEEKLY JOBLESS CLAIMS
2:11:23 BETTER-THAN-EXPECTED, RISING TO 200,000 LAST WEEK.
2:11:27 ESTIMATES WERE 194,000 CLAIMS. MORE CLAIMS THAN EXPECTED.
2:11:33 CONTINUING CLAIMS FALLING TO 1.60 9 MILLION COME THE
2:11:36 EXPECTATION WAS 1.70 ONE MILLION.
2:11:38 THE NVIDIA BOARD WEIGHING THE FUTURE OF JENSEN HUANG AFTER
2:11:42 REPORTS OF TWO EXTRAMARITAL AFFAIRS.
2:11:46 THE BOARD IS WORKING WITH AN OUTSIDE FIRM TO IDENTIFY
2:11:46 POTENTIAL REPLACEMENTS. THEY CONSIDERING NAMING A
2:11:51 TEMPORARY CHEAP WHILE SEARCHING FOR A PERMANENT ONE.
2:11:56 JENSEN HUANG MAY NOT HAVE TO LOOK FAR FOR A NEW JOB.
2:12:01 ELON MUSK POSTING ON X IT WOULD BE AN HONOR TO HIRE HIM.
2:12:04 THEY HAVE KNOWN EACH OTHER FOR THE LAST DECADE AND BOTH JOINED
2:12:07 PRESIDENT TRUMP'S HIGH-PROFILE TRIP TO CHINA EARLIER THIS YEAR.
2:12:09 THAT IS YOUR BLOOMBERG BRIEF. LISA: UP NEXT, SETTING YOU UP
2:12:13 FOR THE DAY AHEAD. PLUS WHY THE AI STORY IS BIGGER
2:12:17 THAN JUST ONE MAN. TODAY ONE MAN IS DOING A LOT OF
2:12:22 DAMAGE IN THE MARKET WHEN IT COMES TO THE NASDAQ.
2:12:25 NASDAQ LOWER ACROSS THE BOARD. THIS IS "BLOOMBERG SURVEILLANCE.”
2:12:56 >> THE BIG QUESTION ON THE EARNING STOCKS WHO'S GOING TO BE
2:12:59 THE CEO WE GET TO EARNINGS NEXT WEEK.
2:13:00 OBVIOUSLY A LOT OF HEADLINES THAT THE BOARD IS TRYING TO OUST
2:13:01 HIM. IS THAT CAN HAPPEN AND IF SO WHO
2:13:06 WILL REPLACE HIM I THINK IT'S HARD FOR ANYONE TO HAVE A CLEAR
2:13:08 VIEW ON THE STOCK. LISA: WE ALL TRY TO FIGURE OUT
2:13:16 WHAT'S THE LATEST ON THE NVIDIA SAGA IN STOCK FUTURES ARE SEEING
2:13:18 THAT LOWER ACROSS THE BOARD LED BY THE TECH HEAVY NASDAQ 100 OF
2:13:23 THE CLAWING BACK SOME OF THE LOSSES DOWN 12%.
2:13:29 TAKE A LOOK AT TWOS, ATTENDS AND 30'S YIELD SELLING OFF THIS
2:13:33 MORNING AS PEOPLE ASSESS ANOTHER STORY THAT CAME OUT OF THIS
2:13:39 MORNING WITH PRESIDENT TRUMP TALKING ABOUT NOT NEEDING A DEAL
2:13:41 WITH IRAN. OIL PRICES ARE HIGHER, A TWO
2:13:46 YEAR YIELDS PRICING IN A FULL ADDITIONAL RATE HIKE SINCE WE
2:13:49 GOT THAT CPI PRINT ON TUESDAY. 24 BASIS POINT INCREASE BASED ON
2:13:52 THE MORNING MOVES. AN HOUR AWAY LET'S GET TO
2:13:56 MORNING MOVERS. ISABEL: THE STORY IS STILL
2:14:01 NVIDIA BECAUSE HOW CAN IT NOT BE.
2:14:05 THE STOCK LOWER AND THIS HOLDS BELOW 4 TRILLION DOLLARS IN
2:14:09 MARKET CAPITALIZATION WHEN THE MARKET OPENS AND AFTER REPORT OF
2:14:14 THE EXTRAMARITAL AFFAIR, THIS SENTIMENT AROUND NVIDIA STARTING
2:14:17 TO CRACK AT LEAST SEVEN BROKERS ADVANCED DOWNGRADING THE STOCK
2:14:21 AND CUTTING THEIR PRICE RBC OPPENHEIMER LOSING FAITH WHEN IT
2:14:24 COMES TO JENSEN HUANG'S LEADERSHIP.
2:14:29 IF YOU TOLD ANYONE JENSEN'S IS ON THE CUSTOMER BEING OUSTED NO
2:14:32 ONE WOULD BELIEVE YOU SO THIS IS A DEVELOPING STORY IS A LOT MORE
2:14:35 TO DISCUSS WHAT WE WOULD STILL TALK ABOUT NVIDIA NEXT WEEK
2:14:39 BECAUSE THE COMPANY IS AT REPORT EARNINGS SO MAKE SURE TO TUNE IN
2:14:43 THAT WILL BE ONE FOR THE BOOKS BUT THE SHOCKWAVES ACROSS THE
2:14:45 MARKET AND TAKE A LOOK AT MIO CLOUD THIS IS INTERESTING
2:14:49 BECAUSE JUST YESTERDAY ALL OF THESE ON THE SCREEN WERE IN THE
2:14:53 GREEN HIGHER BY DOUBLE DIGITS. THESE COMPANIES REALLY
2:14:59 RELY ON AI DATA CENTERS FOR THE REVENUE.
2:15:02 IT SEEMS NOT LONG AGO WHEN ELON MUSK CALLED FOR THE
2:15:05 CONSOLIDATION OF NEO-CLOUDS. AND AGAIN MICROCHIPS THIS IS
2:15:11 ALSO ONE OF THE COLLATERAL DAMAGE WHEN IT COMES TO THE
2:15:13 NVIDIA FALLOUT. SANDISK AND MICRON LOWER
2:15:16 INVESTORS REALLY CONCERNED ABOUT THE DEMAND FOR THESE AI CHIPS
2:15:21 AND THIS MASSIVE SPENDING CYCLE THAT UNDERPINNED THEIR GROWTH.
2:15:23 SO ALL ROADS LEAD BACK TO NVIDIA.
2:15:28 LISA: NVIDIA BOARDS WEIGHING
2:15:33 JENSEN HUANG'S FATE INCLUDING MULTIPLE AFFAIRS GOOD AND ONE
2:15:37 WITH AN ALLEGED CHINESE SPY. WHAT'S THE LATEST AS WE AWAIT
2:15:39 DELIBERATION FROM THE BOARD. ED: BREAKING RIGHT NOW THE
2:15:47 NVIDIA BOARD HAS ANNOUNCED JENSEN HUANG IS OUT AS CEO, OF
2:15:49 THE BOARD JUST ISSUING A STATEMENT SAYING THAT CFO COLLAB
2:15:57 KRESS WILL BECOME INTERIM CEO, NVIDIA CEO JENSEN HUANG HAS
2:16:01 RESIGNED EFFECTIVE IMMEDIATELY ACCORDING TO THE STATEMENT.
2:16:06 HARVEY C JONES HAS BEEN NAMED THE FIRST EVER CHAIR OF NVIDIA'S
2:16:09 BOARD. THAT HEADLINE NOW CONVERTING
2:16:14 THAT THE CFO WILL ACT AS INTERIM CEO.
2:16:20 SOMETHING OF THE MARKET IS PONDERED MIGHT TAKE PLACE WITH
2:16:23 DECLINES IN THE PREMARKET BOUNCING AROUND BECAUSE MAY BE
2:16:26 BASED ON LAST NIGHTS REPORTING THAT THE BOARD HAD ENGAGED IN A
2:16:31 THIRD-PARTY OUTSIDE TO LEAD EXECUTIVE SEARCH FOR A
2:16:32 LONGER-TERM SUCCESS IN THE INTERIM WAS THINKING ABOUT A
2:16:39 SHORT-TERM INTERIM CEO THAT NOW COMING THROUGH.
2:16:43 LISA: WE WILL CIRCLE BACK WITH YOU AND STAY CLOSE, THANK YOU SO
2:16:46 MUCH. JOINING US IN HIS WHEEL OF
2:16:50 FORTUNE WE HAVE OVER THE PAST COUPLE OF WEEKS MATTHEW OF
2:16:54 WELLINGTON MANAGEMENT JOINS US TODAY.
2:16:56 THE NEWS JUST BREAKING THAT NVIDIA'S JENSEN HUANG HAS
2:16:59 RESIGNED AS CEO. THE INTERIM CEO WILL BE CFO
2:17:04 COLETTE KRESS AND THEY'RE GOING TO GO AHEAD WITH REPORTING
2:17:07 EARNINGS NEXT WEEK. WHAT YOU MAKE OF THIS HOW
2:17:10 SIGNIFICANT IS THIS FOR THE ENTIRE AI ECOSYSTEM.
2:17:16 MATTHEW: I THINK THIS IS AN ISOLATED EVENT.
2:17:18 IF YOU LOOK AT IT HOLISTICALLY YOU HAVE A COMPANY THAT IS THE
2:17:24 DOMINANT SUPPLIER TO THE AI ECOSYSTEM AND THAT'S NOT A
2:17:29 CHANGE AND SO I THINK INDEPENDENT OF WHAT GOES ON IT
2:17:32 NVIDIA THE AI TRADE WILL CONTINUE.
2:17:36 ANNMARIE: HOW MUCH CERTAINTY DO YOU HAVE THAT NVIDIA WILL
2:17:38 CONTINUE TO ACT AS CENTRAL BANK TO THE TECH TRADE.
2:17:41 THE IDEA THEY HAVE BACKED SO MANY DIFFERENT START UPS BUT
2:17:44 ALSO MIDSIZED AND LARGER COMPANIES INCLUDING ANTHROPIC
2:17:48 WITH THEIR IPO GIVEN THE NUMBER OF SHARES THEY ARE PLEDGED TO
2:17:50 PURCHASE. IS THIS GOING TO CONTINUE GIVEN
2:17:53 THE LACK >> >> OF TRANSPARENCY AROUND THIS.
2:17:57 IT'S AN OPEN QUESTION ON THE SCENE WITH THE FUNDING.
2:18:00 WHAT I WILL SAY IS THERE IS A PERCEPTION THAT THIS FUNDING HAS
2:18:05 PROMPTED THE AI ECOSYSTEM THAT NVIDIA HAS BEEN THE SUPPLIER OF
2:18:09 CAPITAL TO BE STRUGGLING COMPANIES AND IF YOU LOOK
2:18:12 ACTUALLY UNDER THE COVERS YOU SEE THAT NVIDIA IS A SMALL PART
2:18:17 OF THE ECOSYSTEM HERE WITH THE AI TRADE.
2:18:19 SO IT IS A COMPONENT BUT IN MY OPINION IT IS NOT A CRITICAL
2:18:23 COMPONENT TO THE AI BOOM WE ARE SEEING.
2:18:27 >> SERIOUS KEY MAN RISK WITH THE STOCK-TAKING TAKING ANOTHER LEG
2:18:31 LOWER DOWN MORE THAN 10%, WHAT DOES THIS MEAN FOR THE
2:18:32 COMPETITORS OF NVIDIA. MATTHEW: IT'S AN INTERESTING
2:18:37 QUESTION BECAUSE ON ONE HAND YOU TALK ABOUT NVIDIA AND THEIR
2:18:40 PRODUCTS THESE AREN'T PRODUCTS THAT ARE RELEASED AND DEVELOPED
2:18:44 IN A MONTH OR QUARTER THESE ARE MULTIYEAR DEVELOPMENT CYCLES AND
2:18:46 RELEASE CYCLES. TAKING A STEP BACK THINKING
2:18:48 ABOUT THE IMPLICATIONS FOR NVIDIA, I THINK WE ARE LOOKING
2:18:53 AT NO CHANGE IN PRODUCT OR STRATEGY FOR TWO OR THREE YEARS
2:18:56 AT THIS POINT. ANNMARIE: IS THERE TRUE REVENUE
2:19:02 RISK GIVEN WHAT'S GOING ON IN SINGAPORE.
2:19:07 AND PEOPLE ARE SAYING MAYBE IT'S 10 TO 20% THE GETTING MOVED IN
2:19:09 CHINA. MATTHEW: I THINK THAT ANY
2:19:17 POTENTIAL WEAKNESS WITH NVIDIA'S PRODUCTS AND SUPPLY OF THEIR
2:19:21 PRODUCTS WILL BENEFIT THE OTHER CHALLENGERS TO NVIDIA'S AI
2:19:24 DOMINANCE. THAT'S COMPANIES LIKE GOOGLE,
2:19:32 AMAZON THAT WOULD BE COMPANIES LIKE BROADCOM THAT ARE
2:19:34 SUPPORTING THIS ECOSYSTEM AND IT WOULD BE A NEW CROP OF PRIVATE
2:19:38 COMPANIES THAT HAVE THE BENEFIT OF SEEING FROM A WHOLE PICTURE
2:19:41 PERSPECTIVE THE PRIVATE AND PUBLIC SIDE.
2:19:43 AND SEEING THESE NEW STARTUPS BEING ABLE TO COMPETE WITH
2:19:44 NVIDIA. LISA: WHAT IS THIS MEAN ABOUT
2:19:50 GOVERNANCE AND A NUMBER OF THESE TECH COMPANIES.
2:19:53 THERE'VE BEEN A LOT OF COLORFUL PERSONALITIES WHO BEEN THE
2:19:56 FOUNDERS AND CEOS OF THE TECH GIANTS AND THE AI FRONTIER
2:19:58 MODELS THAT HAVE COME TO THE FORE.
2:20:01 AT WHAT POINT DOES THIS BECOME AN INCREASING RISK AND >> NEEDS
2:20:02 TO BE ADDRESSED. WITH THIS PARTICULAR SITUATION
2:20:07 IS THE WAY I UNDERSTAND IT UNLIKE SOME OF THE NEWER TYPE
2:20:12 COMPANIES NVIDIA WENT PUBLIC QUITE A WHILE AGO AND JENSEN DID
2:20:15 NOT HAVE SUPER MAJORITY OF SHARES LIKELY SEEN SOME OF THESE
2:20:17 OTHER PRIVATE COMPANIES TO GO PUBLIC.
2:20:22 I THINK WHAT YOU SEE IS EVEN IN ABSENCE OF THAT YOU HAVE A
2:20:27 SITUATION THAT ENDED UNFORTUNATELY THAT ULTIMATELY
2:20:29 THE BOARDS DECIDED TO ACT ON. IT WOULD BE NO DIFFERENT IF WE
2:20:33 WERE LOOKING AT SOME OF THESE PRIVATE COMPANIES WITH SIMILAR
2:20:34 STRUCTURES. >> WOULD YOU BE BUYING NVIDIA
2:20:37 SHARES THIS MORNING. MATTHEW: I CAN'T ANSWER THAT
2:20:43 QUESTION BUT I DO THINK AS I MENTIONED EARLIER THAT
2:20:46 INDEPENDENT OF WHO IS IN CHARGE OF NVIDIA THE STRATEGY THE
2:20:49 PRODUCT LINEUP AND THE NEAR TERM DOMINANCE OF THE PUBLIC IN THE
2:20:52 MARKET THAT IS NOT GOING TO UNWIND IN THE NEXT MONTH BECAUSE
2:20:56 COLETTE BECOMES CEO INSTEAD OF JENSEN.
2:21:01 LISA: THANK YOU FOR JOINING US THIS MORNING.
2:21:05 WE ARE GETTING BREAKING NEWS THAT JENSEN HUANG HAS RESIGNED
2:21:08 AS CEO OF NVIDIA. ED LUDLOW BACK WITH US HAS BEEN
2:21:11 PARSING THROUGH THE DOCUMENTS. THE STATEMENT FROM THE BOARD
2:21:12 WHAT WE LEARNED. MATTHEW: BASICALLY NVIDIA IS
2:21:21 SEPARATING THE CHAIRMAN ROLE TO THE CEO ROLE.
2:21:23 ONE OF NVIDIA'S LONGEST-SERVING DIRECTORS A VENTURE CAPITALIST
2:21:30 EXECUTIVE CHAIRMAN OF SYNOPSIS SOMEONE WITH EXPERIENCE.
2:21:32 IT'S REALLY NOTABLE AS A DEVELOPMENT.
2:21:35 EARNINGS GO AHEAD NEXT WEEK. CFO KRESS HAS BEEN THERE FOR A
2:21:41 LONG TIME KIND OF OWNING THE RELATIONSHIP IN LARGE PART THAT
2:21:45 IS ON AN INTERIM BASIS. WITH THE BOARD IS SAYING IS THEY
2:21:50 ARE OPEN TO LOOKING AT EXTERNAL CANDIDATES FOR THIS ROLE LONG
2:21:53 TERM AND WE HAVE BEEN THROUGH SOME OF THOSE POTENTIAL
2:21:54 CANDIDATES THIS MORNING. >> DO YOU GET A SENSE IF YOU
2:21:59 WILL REMAIN ON STAFF AND SOME SORT OF CONSULTING FACTOR
2:22:03 WHETHER HE WILL HAVE A RELATION TO NVIDIA.
2:22:07 ED: ONE THING WE DIDN'T DISCUSS IS THE SHARES HE HOLDS.
2:22:10 DIFFERENT TO SAY MARK ZUCKERBERG OR GOOGLE HE DOESN'T HAVE ANY
2:22:15 SOURCE OF CREDIBLE VOTING POWER. HE HAS ECONOMIC OWNERSHIP IS
2:22:21 RELATIVELY MODEST COMPARED TO ELON MUSK.
2:22:23 YOU GUYS HAVE SEEN THE IDEA THAT WAS POSED OVERNIGHT THAT ELON
2:22:27 MUSK HIRED JENSEN HUANG WHICH HE RESPONDED TO.
2:22:31 TO ANSWER YOUR QUESTION, NO THERE'S NOTHING IN THE STATEMENT
2:22:34 OR THE LANGUAGE SAYING HE REMAINS ON STAFF AS ADVISOR
2:22:36 CHAIRMAN EMERITUS OR ANYTHING LIKE THAT.
2:22:41 LISA: HUGE NEWS THIS MORNING AFTER ALL OF THE DRAMA
2:22:45 SURROUNDING PRESIDENT TRUMP, A QUESTION HERE ABOUT THE FUTURE
2:22:47 OF NVIDIA AS JENSEN HUANG RESIGNS.
2:22:52 ANNMARIE: YOU SEE THE SHARES DOWN 11%.
2:22:54 COMING OUT SAYING IF WE LOSE HIM WE ARE GOING TO SEE THE SHARES
2:22:58 DROPPED MARKEDLY LOWER BECAUSE HOW IMPORTANT HE WAS WITH THE
2:23:01 COMPANY NOW THEY'RE PUTTING THE CFO IN CHARGE.
2:23:06 A LOT OF THE ABOVE QUESTIONS FOR THE CFO AS WELL AS THE GENERAL
2:23:08 COUNSEL WHO IS THE ONE HE'S BEEN CALLING COMMERCE AND WHAT SEEMS
2:23:11 TO BE IN TERMS OF REPORTING TRYING TO MAKE SURE THAT THEY
2:23:15 CAN GET ACCESS TO SO MANY QUESTIONS STILL EXIST AND
2:23:17 INCREDIBLY DEVELOPING STORY. >> NVIDIA SHARES LOWER BY 11%
2:23:25 COMING UP OF STRATEGIC US DAN IVES OF YORK FELL IVES.
2:23:30 J.P. MORGAN ASSET MANAGEMENT AND SHELL WEAVER OF MORGAN STANLEY
2:23:33 THE AFTERMATH OF NVIDIA BOND YIELDS UP AHEAD OF WHAT COULD BE
2:23:37 MORE DRAMA IN THE MIDDLE EAST A DIFFICULT MORNING FOR BONDS AND
2:23:43 STOCKS GOOD MORNING WAS BLOOMBERG SURVEILLANCE.
Huang Says Agentic AI Systems Need Monitoring, Containment full transcript
0:00 The agents have to be in, uh, rigorous containment systems, and those agents
0:07 must be monitored. Just jump one.
0:10 If you're not able to do that, you should not test it.
0:13 If you're not able to do that, you should not deploy it.
0:16 Well, these models that went rogue are unreleased models.
0:18 So the notion that they should shut down, shut the labs down.
0:22 Uh, no. What they should do is that they should
0:25 contain and monitor those experiments. They say they can't contain them.
0:30 No, this is made up nonsense. I cannot be proven.
0:34 You can't prove that to me. Yeah, you can absolutely contain.
0:38 You can absolutely monitor, you know, until you do, until you try to do it.
0:43 Don't tell them you can't do it. And so I'm just not going to listen to
0:46 that. So are you saying that you don't believe
0:48 what they're saying? Um, I don't know all that they're
0:52 saying. If you're developing agent ecosystems
0:54 and you can't monitor it, you should not do so.
0:56 That's just the bottom line. Even the biggest AI optimists see risks.
1:03 They also see solutions. What is the biggest risk you see
1:09 developing agent systems without containment, developing agents, systems
1:14 without monitoring. It is extremely high risk.
1:18 You should not do that. And and until you until you have the
1:22 ability to contain and monitor, you should not run large scale experiments.
1:27 It just sounds like that's already happening.
1:29 Then you just you got to stop. That's it's really, really simple.
1:33 Mhm. So that would be the message to
1:35 anthropic to OpenAI where we've seen that you should contain your technology,
1:38 contain your experiments or some monetary experiments.
The AI Chip Race with Apple’s Former Chief Chip Architect | Power On with Mark Gurman full transcript
0:05 Welcome to Power On.
0:06 We talk about Apple and the consumer tech industry.
0:09 I'm Mark Gurman.
0:09 And today
0:10 we have a very interesting conversation and a very special guest, Gerard Williams III.
0:15 Joining us to talk about the AI data center boom,
0:18 what he's building at his new startup Nuvia core,
0:20 what he built at Nuvia and Qualcomm, and of course, what he did
0:24 at Apple as the chief architect on their CPU technology.
0:29 He worked on chips starting from the A7, the first 64
0:33 bit Apple processor, all the way up to the Apple M1 chip.
0:37 We get into his time there, we get into his thoughts on John Ternus
0:40 and Johny Srouji, and what it was like when he first came up with the idea.
0:44 Almost two decades ago to build,
0:47 server side CPU at Apple.
0:50 And stay tuned till the end.
0:51 We have another round of Apple trivia.
0:55 So Gerard Williams III.
0:57 So glad to have you here.
0:59 Just to give some background to to those listening.
1:02 Gerard has had an amazing career, and there's
1:05 probably no one better to talk to right now.
1:08 About the AI data center boom,
1:10 the silicon industry and all of that coming together.
1:14 Gerard, you know, as you may be interested, if you're listening
1:17 to this podcast, he worked at Apple for a long time.
1:20 Most recently, he was a senior director, in charge of CPU work, platform work.
1:26 He worked all the way up to the M1 chip.
1:28 He worked on the A7 chip and newer.
1:31 And so he was there from not at the very beginning,
1:34 but pretty close to the start of this Apple silicon journey.
1:37 Apple making its own chips
1:38 for the iPad, for the iPhone and the watch and the AirPods.
1:42 And so forth.
1:43 And after that, he went to start a company
1:46 called Nuvia, which made cloud silicon.
1:50 It was acquired by Qualcomm and most recently he left Qualcomm,
1:53 where he was a senior VP, to start a new company called Nuvia Core.
1:57 So Gerard, thanks for joining the Power On podcast.
2:00 Thank you so much for being here.
2:02 And good to have you, man.
2:04 Oh, no.
2:04 It's, wonderful to finally get a chance to, talk to you one on one.
2:08 Well, let's let's talk about nouveau core.
2:10 I want to dive in to exactly what are you building today,
2:15 and how does your learnings from Apple and Nuvia and TI and Arm,
2:19 how did that all come together into what you're doing?
2:22 And why is this something that you couldn't build at Apple?
2:25 Why is this something you couldn't build at Qualcomm?
2:28 Why did this require a new company?
2:31 Yeah.
2:31 So, Newton knew the core journey started actually,
2:36 in early April of this year.
2:38 It was an opportunity to,
2:42 take advantage of the explosion of AI that we're seeing today.
2:47 And bring CPU to bear to the market.
2:50 That's that's one of the interesting things
2:52 that we are seeing in in today's times that the large language
2:56 models themselves are, utilizing
3:00 GPUs, accelerators, AI engines themselves.
3:04 And they've exposed what I've always, I believe,
3:07 to be there since the beginning of my career.
3:10 That CPU is an element that's front
3:13 and center in the data center, has been for some time.
3:16 And, those high performance CPUs are necessary in order to enable,
3:22 like these large language models to do their work.
3:26 They orchestrate memory, they orchestrate,
3:30 the security aspects,
3:32 and do some of the fundamental work,
3:34 and pretty much single threaded performance
3:38 as a predominant element of that CPU that makes it great and efficiency.
3:43 And throughout my career, that's been something
3:45 that I've tried to do every step of the way is to bring,
3:49 high performance
3:50 compute to every platform that I was able to partake in.
3:53 And new a core is,
3:56 beginning that journey as we and it's, it's it's,
3:59 performing that journey as we speak today, but everyone is all in on GPUs.
4:04 Obviously.
4:05 Nvidia has talked up GPUs. Everyone's talking about GPUs.
4:07 And so what was the the moment where you decided we're going to do CPUs
4:13 instead and leave the GPUs to others?
4:17 There wasn't for me, actually.
4:19 There wasn't a magical moment that I said, I'm going to leave GPU behind,
4:23 and focus on CPU.
4:25 CPU has been something that I have focused
4:28 on almost since the beginning of my career.
4:31 Very early day one.
4:33 I've always believed that,
4:36 that compute, and the CPU that you build has the ability to scale,
4:40 and that's one of, nova core fundamental, testaments
4:43 is that we want to build a great core, we call it our core first technology.
4:50 It's basically focusing
4:51 on the fundamental, capabilities of a CPU, what it offers,
4:57 how it explores, the fundamentals of an OS.
5:01 And we want to bring really solid performance to the end user
5:05 and to the data center, which is what LMS today are mandating.
5:10 Can you get a little bit nerdy and technical on this exact first product
5:13 that you're building this exact chip, like, how many cores are we talking about?
5:17 What are the technologies?
5:18 What instruction set are you using?
5:20 I know there's been some talk that you're
5:21 trying to lock in on arm versus risk five.
5:24 Right.
5:25 So what exactly from a technical standpoint
5:27 in terms of what you can share, is this first product going to look like?
5:31 We are trying to focus on a clean sheet design.
5:35 That's number one.
5:36 And what does that mean exactly.
5:37 It basically means starting at first principles of what makes a CPU great.
5:43 That means understanding things like, in technical parlance that means,
5:50 good prefectures, good branch predictors,
5:53 a fundamental sound pipeline,
5:56 a, a pipeline
5:58 that understands, the fundamentals of computer science,
6:03 things like graph theory,
6:06 pointers, linked lists, elements like that that make up everyday
6:09 programing that we all get to experience when we are using a computer.
6:14 Clean sheet design, fundamentally
6:16 says, I'm going to explore all these attributes.
6:19 I'm going to look at the processes that are available in the industry,
6:23 companies like TSMC, Samsung, Intel, all the different processes
6:27 that we have, the ability to partake in and marry these two philosophies together.
6:33 High performance process with,
6:36 sound and reasonable CPU architecture.
6:42 And then the the last ingredient, which is what core
6:45 first is trying to do, is to basically say, I want to understand
6:50 the available ISIS in the ecosystem and you name two of them.
6:54 There's basically three kind of, two more prominent ones and one upcoming one,
7:00 x86 arm
7:01 and one that's being worked on is risk five.
7:05 But understand the properties of those ISIS
7:09 and make sure the CPU's fundamental principles that we build are held,
7:14 so that they can be targeted
7:15 at any one of the three at the time that we want to do our final,
7:19 I'll call it final optimization for a core that targets
7:22 that ISIS.
7:25 I want to circle back to, to Apple
7:27 because they did a very interesting thing, and you were obviously still very much
7:31 in the thick of things there.
7:33 So the iPhone ten gets announced in 2017 and everyone's
7:36 very focused on the new design.
7:39 Face ID, the lack of the home button,
7:42 but there was some special sauce in there that doesn't get much attention.
7:44 That's the neural, that neural engine.
7:47 My understanding is that the origin story for the neural Engine
7:50 comes from the self-driving car project, where they were trying to build a car,
7:55 and they need a gigantic computer system to do the live processing for autonomy.
7:59 And they ended up with the realization that this block is going to need to be
8:03 in the consumer devices, in the phone at some point in order to power something.
8:08 Can you talk me through the origin story of the Neural Engine at Apple,
8:12 how it finally landed and what the thinking behind it was at the time.
8:15 Obviously, this has become a magical piece of
8:17 technology that is enabling so many on device workflows right now.
8:20 But nobody was thinking about that a decade ago.
8:23 Yeah.
8:24 I mean, it's I can't speak a lot about the internal workings of the projects.
8:31 As, as I no longer work there.
8:33 And I'm, it's it's just not an area I can go into.
8:38 But what I, what I, what I will say at a high level,
8:42 every company right now on the planet is actually focused
8:45 on, on trying to build accelerators,
8:49 for a variety of different things,
8:52 knowing that the AI boom is what it is.
8:55 And, yeah, I think I think I'm going to leave it at that.
9:00 No, I got you.
9:02 For you, though,
9:04 what are your thoughts on, you know, on device compute versus on cloud compute?
9:09 I mean, obviously the big difference is how much performance you're able
9:12 to get if you're putting it in the data center versus on the phone itself.
9:15 But I would like your philosophy on that.
9:18 Yeah, I, I think there is a natural desire
9:22 for every end user to be able, to utilize the,
9:27 the silicon that they have in the, in the, in the products that they have.
9:30 I think that is a huge opportunity for,
9:36 the engineering community,
9:38 including the up and coming engineers, those students
9:40 that are in, elementary, high school and university level
9:44 to be able to understand and experiment with those technologies.
9:50 So to me, I think it's a it's, it's
9:52 a, it's a beautiful property to end up with,
9:55 and it allows you to scale to eventually one day exploiting,
10:00 I'll call it the very large models that may live in the cloud, how it does
10:03 what you're building and this AI data center boom.
10:07 How does it accelerate that?
10:08 And, you know, as more people use this stuff,
10:11 is this going to slow down over time?
10:13 Because right now I feel like, you know, you and I,
10:15 others may be listening to this.
10:16 We're on the cutting edge, but at some point
10:17 everyone is going to use this stuff. Is there going to be enough bandwidth?
10:21 No, that's that's a that's a lot of good points that you brought up.
10:24 But what I will tell you is,
10:28 I came from old school engineering where you sat down with pen and paper.
10:32 Maybe it's, modern times. It's a whiteboard.
10:35 Our marker board.
10:37 And I was hesitant to step in a few,
10:40 I'd say a few years ago when when these models were ramping.
10:44 Just because I didn't understand.
10:46 Exactly. All right. What is it? Is it going to benefit?
10:48 Is it not going to benefit what I have found?
10:52 And with the, new the core engineering team, what we have found
10:56 is that these models, to be honest, are actually
11:01 an extent you should think of them as an extension of your design team.
11:04 It does not replace your design team, but it's an extension of your design team.
11:08 And what I mean by that is you still need experience.
11:12 Engineers brought into the company.
11:14 Every day we we look and look for, talented people.
11:19 They are necessary in order to vet, a lot of what these models,
11:24 expose, or introduce
11:27 as capabilities because you want to make sure
11:29 that the product that you're building is robust.
11:31 We've been in the business now for about seven months.
11:34 But we're seeing huge benefits,
11:37 for our engineering, personnel.
11:40 I look at it this way. It raises the bar for everyone.
11:42 You know, Apple, you know, likes to say that it has no problem
11:46 putting a competing product out because,
11:49 two products that are within the same company
11:51 competing with each other, it just makes the products better.
11:53 And so I think that I it's just forcing people to read up, to learn more, to get
11:58 better at their jobs and push people, to sort of beat out this technology.
12:03 And at the same time, you can't always trust these models.
12:06 It can never be. You can never do what I do. It can never.
12:08 You do, but it can help give us time back to focus on our strengths.
12:13 Right.
12:14 Can you go a little bit deeper about how AI is actually helping
12:17 with the nitty gritty development process of programing, manufacturing, testing,
12:23 making these chips more secure and comparing it to
12:27 even what you were doing a few years ago at Nuvia and farther behind that at Apple.
12:32 How has the chip development process changed and has accelerated your,
12:37 your roadmap and your ability to bring silicon out?
12:40 And has it helped defeat this idea where you've seen CPU gains slow down?
12:45 Right?
12:45 I mean, if you look at the initial charts, when Apple released the the first iPad,
12:50 and then you look at the jump to the iPad to the GPU acceleration they had on that,
12:54 I think it was 8 or 9 x now the year over year gains or 1,015%.
12:59 But do you think with AI we're going to go back to the old days here?
13:02 Yeah.
13:03 Many, many, many good points you brought up going back to, for instance, Nuvia,
13:07 because I've got two startup experiences that I can, I can relate to.
13:12 Nuvia was pre,
13:14 the dawn of I mean, I was there, but it was made a minority, in the ecosystem.
13:20 Not really used during development time.
13:22 It was engineers, going to the what?
13:25 Like I said, going to the whiteboard, doing design, exploring.
13:30 Today that has changed pretty dramatically.
13:33 So comparing and contrasting, if you were to go through the design
13:37 process, developing a CPU and it's made up of many parts,
13:41 and you want a little techie, so I'll dive in a little bit.
13:45 There are phases to CPU development that we all like to understand.
13:48 There is what I call the performance phase, where you're studying,
13:52 researching, trying to understand what you go to develop.
13:55 Sometimes that could take two months.
13:57 Sometimes it could take seven months to a year.
14:01 An extended research may take multi year.
14:04 Once you're done with and having a
14:07 have created a view of what that performance wants to look like.
14:11 There's a design process, a verification process, and a physical design process
14:15 that you go through which eventually turns this,
14:19 creative, concept of a CPU.
14:23 If I use that as the example, into a final piece of silicon
14:27 that I try to ship in, in into a product,
14:32 without the advent of AI.
14:35 And what we're, what we're experiencing at nouveau core
14:38 without that event of AI, that development cycle
14:41 and it's best typically was around two and a half to three years.
14:46 Okay.
14:47 That's basically
14:47 clean sheet design going to an end product two and a half to three years
14:52 in nouveau core.
14:53 What we have experienced actually, in these early phases
14:57 and we're still developing the CPU, as we speak.
15:01 But I can tell you in these early phases of performance
15:04 and performance modeling and characterization of a design,
15:07 what would have taken seven months to 12 months to get to a point where you,
15:14 are ready to start the design process?
15:17 We've actually collapsed that down to a 2 or 3, 2 or 3 month window.
15:21 Which is very, I'd say unexpected, but a positive.
15:27 It's a positive because now that gives me time and the engineering
15:30 team time to focus on,
15:34 potentially other ideas.
15:35 And that gets to one of your fundamental things that you talked about, which is it
15:38 looks like there's a slowdown in the industry.
15:40 What I will tell you, in my experience,
15:44 that Slow down is really
15:46 about your ability to explore
15:49 and know what to explore and how to apply it with the end goal
15:53 being that you compress
15:54 that entire two and a half to three year schedule into something that may look like
15:58 a two year type of design point that would be ideal.
16:02 Year and a half would be beautiful.
16:04 If design teams can do that.
16:06 And there have been a few examples out in the field
16:08 recently where AI has been applied and accelerated, the timeline,
16:13 and high performance, very high performance CPU design.
16:16 I think the answer is just time, to
16:19 to actually show that the full clean sheet endpoint
16:23 can actually be compressed to something, that is reasonable for the market.
16:28 Does a complex compress to a year.
16:31 Today I can't answer that question, but I think given Gen one, Gen
16:35 two of our timeline, there's a possibility for that to become true.
16:41 I still want to go a little bit deeper on why focusing specifically
16:44 on the CPU versus the complete stack, because obviously one of the big,
16:49 you know, inventions at Apple, one of the big innovations
16:53 was sort of the system on a chip design.
16:55 We were bringing together a full SoC with the CPU,
16:58 with the GPU, with the Neural Engine, the memory and everything together.
17:02 So can you go a little bit deeper on there and how this is one block
17:05 and how that will fit in with other companies here,
17:08 and how your strategy's really comparing to what you're seeing from Apple
17:11 with its private cloud compute
17:12 that they've been pushing for the security optimizations for AI.
17:16 Obviously Nvidia is working on their own cloud CPU.
17:19 And what you did at Qualcomm with with Nuvia.
17:22 Yeah.
17:22 So at Nova Core,
17:26 our, our long term ambition is to basically one day get to end product.
17:31 It's performance has to be good.
17:32 It's power efficiency has to be good.
17:34 We're working with a variety of end customers to try to understand,
17:38 how they want to integrate that.
17:41 And ultimately that could turn into a chiplet form
17:46 of silicon with many CPUs on a die that's co integrated with accelerators.
17:51 It could turn into a full scale end product, like you see in classical data
17:56 center and Hyperscaler, which is a blade based, compute device.
18:04 But yeah,
18:04 it's, it's, it's ultimately where we want to go.
18:08 So I hear technical details, I hear
18:11 AI features, I hear how my computing is going to improve.
18:14 But investors, they hear dollar signs and, supposedly you're about to raise
18:18 a whole bunch of money at a valuation between 2 and $3 billion.
18:22 Are you able to give me a little bit on that,
18:24 of what your investors are putting into the company
18:27 and how this thing is going to grow and really get off the ground here.
18:30 In terms of the exact financial investment in the company.
18:33 We have not made any of that public.
18:35 And I won't go into that right now.
18:37 But what I will tell you is the investors that we have brought on board
18:40 have been involved actively with silicon,
18:44 the strategic players that we're bringing on board have actively been
18:47 involved in silicon, and they know that this is a long term journey.
18:51 And how far you off from actually going into production?
18:56 As I said, we're
18:57 seven, seven months into the journey.
19:00 Full silicon is somewhere
19:03 between a 2 to 3 year journey,
19:07 in order to create that silicon. So,
19:11 it's it's it's roughly around
19:13 that time frame.
19:16 Let's get to your journey at Apple.
19:18 So Gerard Williams III you show up at Apple in what year?
19:22 2000, 2010, 2010.
19:25 And so that silicon in the cloud was one of your first ideas.
19:28 So, who hired you? Who brought you on?
19:30 What was the mission?
19:31 Was this to develop the, the A7?
19:34 Was that the first thing, the first 64 bit Apple chip?
19:36 Tell me.
19:37 Tell me about getting to Apple getting started and and what you did there
19:41 from the beginning.
19:42 Yeah, I joined Apple. And,
19:45 I think it was February of 2010.
19:49 Basically I joined,
19:51 as, as as, as you rightly pointed out early
19:54 on, I joined a team called Platform Architecture.
19:57 In the early days of Apple that was a very small
20:00 engineering team that was focused on,
20:04 literally looking at all silicon, and hardware being designed in the company.
20:08 And I was one of a handful of those engineers, that was a part of that team.
20:13 And we explored every design,
20:16 that would come across the desk of,
20:19 of the senior exacts and decide, with them
20:23 whether or not that that was a possible thing that could be,
20:26 developed and, and, and created in,
20:29 in an Apple product.
20:32 And, along that
20:34 journey, I had the opportunity to,
20:37 become Apple's chief architect of CPU development.
20:40 As you pointed out, the first product that,
20:43 saw the light of day that I worked on was the Apple A7.
20:49 And, I
20:50 was able to work on many other products after that, but,
20:53 but yeah, the engineering team, we focused pretty heavily in silicon development,
20:59 understanding that silicon developing a roadmap for that silicon
21:02 and trying to make sure that the products year on year,
21:06 showed benefit.
21:08 Apple really pushes this narrative about performance per watt on all its silicon.
21:12 And when the M1 came out, which you worked on, I want to get into that.
21:15 They were really pushing performance for wall versus Intel.
21:17 It's not only about the speeds and feeds, but it's about the power efficiency.
21:21 It's about battery life.
21:24 Was that something that you were pushing from the beginning?
21:26 Was that sort of one of your early innovations?
21:30 I would say that even predates Apple.
21:33 It was tell me about that, because you were a tie in arm as well.
21:36 I want to hear about the pioneer of this performance per watt idea,
21:41 because it's it's the biggest thing and on device silicon right now.
21:44 Yeah. So,
21:46 yeah, even predating Apple, if you go all the way back to,
21:50 during the arm days when I was there, we used to look at
21:53 devices and, the products that we were shipping and,
21:57 and in those days, back in the, I call it late 90s, early 2000,
22:01 you were talking about devices that were sipping 50mW, 100mW.
22:07 So to you as an engineer spending 1 million, what was was huge.
22:12 It was huge.
22:13 It was a large percentage of the, the, the the core itself that grew over time.
22:18 But that philosophy never changed.
22:21 And in the world of computing,
22:23 everyday life, us as users, I carry around laptops.
22:28 We all do.
22:29 We carry around cell phones, watches.
22:31 They all have batteries in them. So,
22:34 burning micro watts milliwatts is fundamental to those products
22:37 because it basically means at the end of the day,
22:40 can I make it through the working day with my product,
22:42 doing everything that I want to do, and it still survives.
22:45 And if that's the case, if succeeded, we all sleep at night, we all go to bed,
22:50 we can plug our device, let it charge again.
22:52 We wake up in the morning and we run all day and do everything that we do.
22:56 The beauty of that is the moment when once you understand those
22:59 those fundamental properties about how and where power goes and why,
23:04 you can bring that to the data center.
23:06 Okay.
23:06 It's a it's a property that people don't think about.
23:09 They you hear people throw out numbers like gigawatts and multi gigawatts.
23:15 I will tell you
23:16 that milliwatts are still a part of that number.
23:19 And if you can, if you,
23:20 if you, you can save milliwatts and every CPU that you constructed
23:24 by the time you multiply that out by tens, hundreds, thousands,
23:28 if not millions, of course, it's a material change that you can make.
23:32 And so one of the fundamental things that we I've always done,
23:36 I did it at Nuvia, I've done it at every company I've been at, and I'm
23:41 doing it again at Nouveau Core on this clean sheet design approach.
23:44 Power is fundamental, okay.
23:47 Even though we don't think of it as a giant battery.
23:51 It's a it's a property that you want to lower
23:54 as much as you can because at the end of the day,
23:57 if the engines, as we are seeing are driving up the core count,
24:02 demand and making CPUs what I call front and center in the data center,
24:07 if I can lower the power and I can suddenly squeeze
24:11 two, three x the number of cores into that data center, building
24:16 I've won.
24:17 So obviously you worked very closely with your product design,
24:21 with your, electrical engineering, with your hardware engineering teams.
24:25 When when you were at Apple, do you feel like you were kind of handing them a gift?
24:30 It was sort of like a magic bullet.
24:32 You were handing them those chips, allowing them to design devices.
24:35 They wanted to design and implement features they wanted to implement.
24:37 They couldn't necessarily do with Intel.
24:40 Was it seen that way internally that you guys were the Wizards
24:43 really making this happen, but not getting the credit?
24:47 I don't think about it that way.
24:50 I mean, reality is what and what I will tell
24:53 you, fundamentally, a CPU is not designed by one person.
24:56 It's not.
24:57 And some of the ideas come from a person, but it comes from the team.
25:01 It's fundamentally a team, and it's how you build that team, organize that team,
25:07 and give them the freedom to explore.
25:09 That's actually what, at the end of the day, makes products great.
25:13 And, and makes engineers
25:16 want to come to work every day, wake up and and do amazing things.
25:21 And that's one of the fundamental properties
25:23 that I've tried to instill in every team that I've created.
25:28 Obviously, being in that silicon group,
25:31 I have to ask you about a couple people first.
25:33 John Ternus, obviously the new CEO of Apple.
25:36 What do you think coming from an Apple that was, you know, you started
25:40 it was run by visionary.
25:41 Then it was run by an operations guy for, you know, 95% of your career there.
25:46 And now it's being run by a hardware engineer
25:49 who rose up the ranks very quickly.
25:51 I mean, by the time you left Apple in 2019, like, really, no one's ever
25:54 heard of the guy.
25:55 Even when I was talking about him.
25:58 Starting to tell people 2 or 3 years ago, starting to break the news that, hey,
26:01 John Ternus is going to be the next CEO. This is happening.
26:04 Everyone's like, who the hell is this guy?
26:05 No one's ever heard of him, right? Okay.
26:08 You having been there, did you work closely with him?
26:10 Was this a shock to you? Does this make sense?
26:12 What do you think of a bore? Engineering led apple?
26:15 Tell me if you have one. An interesting turn of story,
26:18 because obviously you were the guy making the chips.
26:20 He was the guy, you know, pulling together the chips with the other components
26:24 and the product design and all that.
26:27 Yeah, I
26:28 won't go into personal details about, my, my time there, but
26:32 I think, you named off to it two of the past, folks,
26:38 putting names to the two who you mentioned.
26:41 Obviously, there was Steve Jobs and an obvious visionary.
26:45 The world sees him that way.
26:46 You've got Tim Cook, the financial individual, and
26:48 and then effectively, now, John Ternus, who you who you were just asking about.
26:53 I believe they all have their different strengths.
26:56 And they, in turn, this is case times going to answer
27:01 that question, really, at the end of the day
27:03 about the decisions he makes, how he utilizes the engineering team.
27:07 But as to his strengths and weaknesses,
27:09 I'm not going to elaborate about that.
27:12 I did work with him while I was there.
27:15 Very good person.
27:16 I will say that he is a good person and,
27:20 works with his people, but beyond that, I'm not going to dive any deeper.
27:24 I wish him the best in what he's doing, and I honestly do hope that he succeeds
27:28 at everything that he does and what he what he can pull off for the company.
27:32 Maybe. Now, two more questions. Johnny Srouji.
27:34 You know, he's known for running that team with, with an with an iron fist.
27:38 Anything. Any thoughts on him?
27:40 And how is he's doing and how he runs the team and his management style.
27:44 Do you have any learnings or takeaways from working under him for so long?
27:47 Yeah, I mean, I've known Johnny for quite a long time.
27:51 Probably about 20 or 20 years of my career.
27:54 I've known him.
27:57 I have the utmost
27:58 respect for him and what he's built at Apple.
28:02 Amazing organization, year on year.
28:05 They're they're they're delivering and developing.
28:08 And I, I wish him the best and hope they continue to do so, as, as
28:12 as I do with many, many of my colleagues
28:16 and friends that, that are still there.
28:19 So I, I wish him the best
28:21 and you left Apple in 2019 right on the cusp of the M1.
28:25 Why did you decide to leave at the time?
28:27 And what was that process like?
28:28 And then how did you jump into into Nuvia?
28:33 It's the process.
28:35 The answer is yes.
28:36 It was it was, I believe, February of 2019 that I stepped away.
28:42 And you were a senior director at the time, which I was just to explain
28:45 to the audience. Senior director.
28:48 There's about 300 of them across the whole company.
28:51 It's a very, very high level position.
28:53 There's the CEO,
28:55 there's a senior VP, there's the VP's, and then there's the senior directors.
28:58 But then there's a
28:59 large tier of senior directors, which are essentially in the VP tier.
29:03 And I guess that's sort of the, you know, Venn diagram.
29:06 You were part of that.
29:07 Yeah. You've aptly described it. Yes.
29:10 Yes. Departing any company where you've you've kind of,
29:15 enjoyed the experience of working on the products, developing the products.
29:19 I mean, you end up,
29:21 you want to give everything that you can to the company as you're progressing.
29:25 So at the end of the day, when I did walk away, yeah, it was heartbreaking.
29:29 I mean, it is for many people that walk away that that invest a lot of time.
29:32 And, and they were pretty heartbroken to I hear, that they were,
29:37 they were, they were
29:39 but and ultimately I
29:42 walked away because of an opportunity that turned into nuvia,
29:47 and, that opportunity opened doors for me
29:50 to experience things in my career path that I wasn't able to experience.
29:55 I'll say, being an engineer, things like,
29:58 at the time, I was the CEO of the company,
30:01 and you are out raising money
30:04 funding, which is, the money side of the equation,
30:09 making sure EDA agreements are put in place a variety of things
30:13 hiring people, building a team, making sure that we have direction set
30:17 so that that's something that you can't experience
30:20 as an engineer inside of an organization.
30:22 And it was an opportunity for me to potentially,
30:25 call it, spread my wings and, and kind of take flight, so to speak.
30:30 In a startup world, was it easy to step away
30:33 from, from that that that Apple journey?
30:36 No, it was not.
30:37 I should note for the record that Apple did to you and Nuvia,
30:42 after you, you know, started the company, they accused you of hiring engineers,
30:47 inappropriately and trade secrets and what have you.
30:50 And then, as we see in a lot of these lawsuits,
30:54 courts determined to a large degree of being frivolous. And,
30:59 you and Nuvia obviously came
31:00 out on top here and had a very successful launch at Qualcomm.
31:05 And now you're on to your next thing.
31:08 Tell me about the chips you ended up launching at Qualcomm.
31:12 What do you see as the success there?
31:13 What do you see as the differentiator there?
31:15 And what do you think it's doing for the PC market and for competition?
31:19 Yeah, I would and on the lawsuit side, what I will tell you,
31:24 I can't go into that, just, just, just for, just for the viewers.
31:28 I can't dive into that and ask you to.
31:31 I just have to.
31:32 I just have to, You'd be weird.
31:34 Someone watching this is like.
31:35 How did he have an hour conversation with you,
31:37 Roger Williams the third, and not mention the lawsuit.
31:38 So I have to get out there
31:40 now, circling back to where we started, obviously you leave.
31:43 Qualcomm was at the beginning of this year.
31:45 Yes, it was the end of January actually into January.
31:48 You said you, left because you needed to finish painting up your new house.
31:52 How did that go?
31:53 I like that story.
31:54 It's it's made its way around the industry.
31:57 Is it finished?
31:59 I'm. Well, if you want the honest truth, I'm actually still painting to this day.
32:03 I, I recently,
32:06 have painted my daughter's bedroom.
32:08 And I'm still doing it.
32:09 I enjoy, this is the other side of me.
32:12 I enjoy the the relaxing it to me, that's relaxing.
32:17 I was going to say, at this point, I feel like you could hire
32:19 someone to paint it for you.
32:20 Like, I probably could, but, honestly, that's me being an engineer.
32:25 At the end of the day, you know, I, I like the details, and I, I enjoy it.
32:29 I get that you were asking about, like, my early, early career.
32:33 I had the opportunity.
32:35 And many don't have this opportunity.
32:38 As a small child, I got lucky.
32:39 My my father was into construction
32:41 and a variety of things like that, so I learned, honestly,
32:45 if I wasn't doing CPAs my day job, I could go into construction.
32:49 And a lot of people don't know that.
32:52 So. Yeah, it's,
32:53 it's it's it's a nice, relaxing pastime.
32:56 I love that.
32:58 And last question for you on this podcast, we focus a lot
33:01 on the hardware itself, on the products, the physical devices people can buy.
33:05 What does the industry shift look like in 3
33:08 to 5 years with a big offload of CPU into the cloud?
33:12 I mean, I'm imagining things like AR glasses
33:14 finally being able to be enabled, but what is this future that you think
33:18 you're going to enable for hardware customers?
33:21 Yeah, and by customers I'm talking about, you know, me
33:24 and you and listeners not like you know your in videos and open eyes of the world.
33:28 Yeah.
33:29 I think at the end of the day,
33:32 bringing CPU technology to bear to in a market like this
33:36 2 to 3 years down the road or five years down the road,
33:38 I think what we're going to discover is this,
33:42 this utilization
33:43 of LMS and CPU and compute technology that every end user
33:47 will get to experience, not just and you talked about glasses or devices.
33:51 It's basically everyday ordinary people picking up these devices
33:55 and exploring these devices.
33:57 And utilizing,
33:57 being able to access things that that normally you'd have to go to a library
34:01 and research and try to figure out, you can ask the language model,
34:05 these questions, you can even do it today.
34:08 And my hope is that that that actually is what happens
34:11 with all the end users, not this fear that you see in the industry.
34:14 Wherever AI is going to do this or do that.
34:16 No, it's about can it me, my working life that much better, my daily life?
34:21 And if the answer is yes, we've done something pretty amazing.
34:25 Cool. So we'll leave it at that.
34:26 Gerard Williams III.
34:28 Thank you so much for your time.
34:30 What an interesting conversation.
34:31 I think it's really important, given everything going on in the industry
34:33 right now, and I'm glad we were able to tie it back to to Apple,
34:37 to Qualcomm to arm all the hot buttons right now.
34:40 So thank you very much.
34:42 Thank you. Thank you for the opportunity.
34:46 Okay.
34:46 It's Apple trivia time.
34:47 Our producer Alexis is going to try to stump me.
34:50 What do you have Alexis?
34:52 Well it's just you.
34:53 So you really on the spot with this one?
34:55 But, you know, I like to go thematic.
34:57 So yes, I'm going to ask you a question about chips.
35:00 Okay. If you're ready.
35:01 It's very it's very chip very chip related episode.
35:05 Okay.
35:05 So the question is how many of the Apple A-series chips
35:10 carry the pro name? Ooh.
35:15 Let me know if you want the multiple choice.
35:17 Okay.
35:17 I'm trying to think when did they start giving the pro name?
35:20 Well, there was definitely the well, they did,
35:23 fusion once there was the A10 fusion, I think it was the A11 fusion.
35:28 There was the A or maybe the A11 Bionic.
35:31 They went from fusion to Bionic and then they started doing the pro chips.
35:35 Was it the A15 Pro A16
35:38 Pro I would say so A16 Pro A17
35:45 Pro, A18 Pro A19 Pro A20 Pro okay.
35:49 Give me the multiple choices okay.
35:51 So I'm gonna I'm going to give you the these numbers
35:55 correlate with the number of chips with the pro name okay.
35:58 So is it A. 5, B. 4, C. 3 or D. 10?
36:07 It's not ten. It's not three.
36:09 It's 4 or 5. I'm going to bet five.
36:12 Oh so close.
36:14 No it's four.
36:15 It's four okay.
36:16 What was the first pro chip okay.
36:18 So the first A17 Pro A17.
36:20 Yeah A17 Pro 1718 1920. Yeah exactly.
36:24 I was off and then okay. You were off by one.
36:26 Do you remember what year they switched from Bionic to Pro.
36:29 So A17 Pro
36:31 were in 26, 25, 24 I guess would be 2023.
36:35 Yes. Correct.
36:36 And that was when they split the chip into two variations having the low
36:39 end for the regular chip and having the high end, for the Pro line.
36:43 So and they eventually put the Pro chip, in the iPad mini.
36:47 And now they've, you know, expanded it, obviously the iPhone duo and the 18
36:51 Pro and Pro Max have the iPhone's, A20 Pro chip and then the iPhone
36:56 18 and iPhone 18 E
36:59 in the spring next year, we'll have the regular A20.
37:02 Well, I'll give you a half a point back because we've got the follow up
37:05 question, but I'm going to count this as a win for myself.
37:08 Okay. You go ahead.
37:10 Okay.
37:10 So the next question
37:12 I've noticed that you really like talking about different colors of products.
37:16 So I oh gosh, I had to throw a color question in here.
37:19 Okay.
37:20 So in 2023,
37:23 Tim Cook was asked what color of the iPhone Pro
37:27 Max he preferred and chose for himself the natural titanium.
37:31 Yes, yes, that was the same color I got.
37:35 It was it was the nicest color that year.
37:38 I, a family member of mine has the natural
37:40 titanium, phone right now, like a couple generations old.
37:43 I don't really don't like it at this point.
37:46 But it was a good color back then.
37:48 What is your favorite color of the iPhone of all time?
37:51 Oh. I really liked the midnight
37:56 green iPhone 11 Pro from 2019,
38:01 and I really liked the Pacific Blue
38:04 of the iPhone 12 Pro in 2020.
38:08 And this might be a little controversial,
38:11 but I am really digging the night sky iPhone duo.
38:13 I think I went with the right color
38:15 a lot of people really wanted the white, but I, I like my I like my night sky.
38:19 That's not the first time you've said that on this phone, I guess.
38:22 But I like, that you that you point that out.
38:25 Okay, well, we got Tim Cook's favorite color.
38:27 Me also got yours.
38:29 So this is another round of the apple trivia in the bag.
38:32 Thanks, Alexis.
38:34 Okay, we have several more exciting episodes in the coming weeks,
38:36 including a mailbag episode, so please send in all your questions to
38:40 [email protected] or post them in the new podcast channel in our discord.
38:45 The Power On Discord.
38:47 And we will try to get to all your questions in that mailbag episode, so
38:50 stay tuned for that.
Nvidia Shake-Up Is a Buying Opportunity, Says Analyst Chkaiban full transcript
0:00 Antoine, we do have to ask you first. This is an earthquake.
0:03 As Vonnie has said from the start of the show.
0:05 What do you make of it? And do you think that this Nvidia
0:07 downfall, or at least the downfall of Justin Huang, will bring down the AI
0:10 trade with it? Yes.
0:13 Thanks for having me on the show today. I think you have to distinguish the near
0:16 term and the long term, you know, in the near term.
0:19 Nvidia has secured manufacturing capacity.
0:22 They have customer commitments. You know, this $1 trillion of orders,
0:25 uh, that they've announced. Well, that remains in place.
0:28 Um, uh, and Colette Kress, you know, is a very well positioned, uh, to maintain
0:33 operational continuity, uh, where the board, you know, searches for a
0:36 permanent successor. Now, if you look at the long term, uh,
0:40 that's where my biggest concern, uh, is because, um, you I mean, you have
0:45 Jensen, who manages about 60 direct reports.
0:49 Uh, he deals directly, you know, with customers, with suppliers, with
0:52 governments. Uh, he connects.
0:54 You know what the either is? Need, uh, what your players in the
0:57 deliver, um, and where the industry should invest, you know, and rebuilding
1:00 all of that. Um, and that coordination under a
1:05 successor is going to take time. Yeah.
1:08 And one has Nvidia opened itself up now to shareholder lawsuits.
1:12 And could that liability be potentially quite large.
1:16 Also could its suppliers decide to do business elsewhere now?
1:21 I think, you know, if you look beyond Nvidia, the key question, you know, is,
1:24 uh, like what risk this represents for the entire, uh, technology
1:28 infrastructure landscape. Um, tech is essentially losing someone.
1:32 We can bring, uh, together all the parties, you know, that I mentioned
1:35 earlier together, uh, gets huge projects moving.
1:39 Um, and, uh, I mean, if you look at the implications, you know, Jensen, for
1:44 example, has been helping, uh, build, um, uh, turn natives to Nvidia's biggest
1:49 customers. You know, they're like, he's been
1:50 supporting. He's been, uh, uh, aiming to fragment in
1:53 between each in an interest to fragment its customer base.
1:56 You have the same hyperscalers account for about half of its revenues.
2:00 Um, so Nvidia was supporting new cloud, creating a larger customer base, uh, and
2:05 reducing the dependency of the company on the hyperscalers.
2:10 And so using, you know, such a strategic coordination could strengthen the
2:15 largest buyers, you know, like the hyperscalers, the frontier labs.
2:17 And so I think that's the main impact on the broader, uh, industry that we should
2:21 be looking. Antoine, I want to stick with Barney's
2:24 grade point, because how much of Nvidia's competitive advantage is within
2:27 its Cuda software ecosystem and its engineering teams versus Jetson Huang's
2:31 personal leadership, in your view? I mean, it's all the above.
2:35 Uh, you can't really distinguish one or the other.
2:37 Uh, I think, uh, you know, Nvidia has been there for multiple decades, uh,
2:42 establishing a dominant position in data center accelerators ahead of everyone.
2:46 Um, they have the dominant ecosystem. Uh, and even, you know, if they're sharp
2:51 inroads, uh, you know, over the coming years.
2:53 And we have, uh, like, everybody, you know, it's it's coming and everybody
2:57 expects, uh, A6 to run the exact same thing, except, uh.
3:01 So, Um expects AMD to ramp as well. Uh and E6 and so uh, even if their share
3:08 comes down at the end of the day, uh, I think their earnings power is more than
3:13 enough to justify, uh, uh, keeping it by reaching Nvidia today.
3:17 And the the stock is really cheap, is trading on 6 or 7 times or forecast for
3:20 2028 earnings despite the shirt. I said sure and that's great.
3:25 But if you're a Cristiano Amon or you're a Lisa Su, what do you do today on day
3:28 one? You have to take advantage of this.
3:30 No, I mean, of course, uh, if you look at
3:34 the competing platforms, they're going to gain in up winning, but that's going
3:37 to take time. Um, I mean, I would expect, you know,
3:39 customers, uh, to review their dependence, uh, on Nvidia.
3:43 And that's of course potentially going to help, as you mentioned, you know, AMD
3:46 uh, and custom chips uh, hooked on as well, you know, but the leadership um,
3:51 uncertainty uh, doesn't necessarily you know, it doesn't automatically transfer,
3:56 uh, you know, uh, the dominance that you talked about to Nvidia's competitors and
4:00 customers to need, uh, competitive hardware.
4:02 software, reliable delivery capacity and all of that.
4:05 You know today is just hand. So it's going to take time.
4:09 Um, and uh, yes. It's not going to happen overnight.
4:13 As an analyst, Antoine, is this a buying opportunity for you when you look at the
4:16 sell off and Nvidia or do you think that investors are still underestimating the
4:20 risk and that there could be more ahead? Uh, I think Nvidia is definitely a great
4:25 buying opportunity today. Uh, like the stock trades that's, you
4:29 know, uh, 180 $160 now. Uh, and that's again six and a half
4:34 times, you know, uh, our our earnings forecast for calendar 2028.
4:39 I think that prices in much more than the damage that we expect from the
4:43 departure of CEO. And I saw the news flow as well that,
4:46 uh, Jensen is not going to take another role, uh, at least in the near term.
4:49 But, um, I think there is still a possibility, you know, that even without
4:54 being CEO, at some point, he could, you know, uh, like, uh, come back to the
4:58 company one way or another and, uh, and still, you know, help Nvidia, uh,
5:03 maintain its dominant position, you know, and we've seen, uh, in the past,
5:06 you know, lots of evidence of that dynamic, for example.
5:09 And if you recall, the indie at the, at Arista Networks, uh, resigned as
5:13 chairman and, uh, another director, you know, after being, uh, after the
5:17 allegations, uh, of, uh, insider trading, uh, and he still today, he
5:22 remains today chief architect and the responsible advanced the silicon and
5:26 optics initiative. So I think there are many outcomes today
5:29 that could, uh, you know, um, bring Jensen back.
5:32 And in any case, the stock is really cheap.
5:34 And one who would you be looking to for a potential replacement?
5:38 So we have the hugging face CEO. I'm sure you know.
5:41 Well come on. DeLong tweeting out today that this is
5:44 an unfortunate situation and so on. I mean, would he be someone out of the
5:47 blue that could take over in some way that's not that known to the markets?
5:51 Or would it need to be some kind of an executive that we already know.
5:55 And it would have to be someone, again, who is, you know, capable of, uh, you
5:59 know, driving all the strategic decisions and all the partnerships that
6:03 Jensen has been driving. Uh, any names you might think of?
6:09 Any specific names? Um, I mean, I saw, you know, all the
6:13 names that you have heard as well, you know, like, uh, uh, I put his former
6:16 CEO, uh. Uh, you mentioned hugging face, but I
6:19 don't have any additional insights. But Tim could be a good replacement.
6:23 Tim Cook, who hasn't really leaned into I.
6:27 I mean, it's not just about leading into AI, right?
6:29 I mean, you could still have, you know, uh, people who have been leading, uh,
6:32 innovation at Nvidia, uh, you know, keep, uh, keep those responsibilities.
6:36 Nvidia is also a very important supply chain company these days.
6:39 You know, like these, uh, these servers that get assembled, by the way, it's the
6:42 the same, uh, Foxconn is, uh, is, uh, is also involved in assembling the iPhone
6:47 and, uh, Nvidia servers. Um.
6:49 Uh, it's a big supply chain problem these days to ramp.
6:52 Uh, I infrastructure, uh, I data centers, uh, that's going to be a big
6:57 issue. And Tim Cook has been uh, leading Apple
6:59 through through that, uh, the changes over the last, uh, but as years.
7:03 Right. So, uh, that would actually make sense.
Delta Sees No Pushback on Higher Fares, CEO Says full transcript
0:00 Now turn to Bloomberg Surveillance co host Lisa Abramowitz, who's joined by Ed Bastian, Delta Air
0:04 Lines CEO. Lisa?
0:05 Thank you so much, Vonnie. I am here with Ed Bastian, the CEO of Delta Air
0:10 Lines. Good morning. Great to have you on this tumultuous morning.
0:13 It's always good to to be with you, Lisa.
0:15 Thank you. You know, it's amazing. Sometimes you're in the hot seat, and the oil price
0:18 is definitely ascended this morning, but tech really the main story.
0:22 Right.
0:22 I'm not gonna ask whether you've gotten tapped about being the CEO of NVIDIA. You are
0:26 fir... Firmly squarely at, Delta, but it does raise questions about the return on investment of
0:33 AI for companies that are not technological. From your perspective, you are a technology company when
0:39 it comes to planes. How much are you seeing an actual return on investment?
0:43 I think it's early innings. I think you see the tremendous amount of investment and capital
0:48 that's going into not just the technology, but candidly, more importantly, all the the resource consumption,
0:54 the the hyperscalers, the data centers, the energy, the water, and the labor and the impact
1:01 that's having on a... At a larger level. And you ask yourself, how is this movie
1:06 going to eventually play out? And I think it will be, I think we're learning. I
1:11 think we're learning. I don't think this is necessarily the right time to be asking where
1:16 are the returns, but it's the right question that we're... We have to be mindful of
1:22 in order to govern how deep into this you wanna get.
1:26 Have you pulled back some of your AI spending because you cannot put a return on
1:29 investment number on some of the No. Output yet?
1:33 No. We haven't. But what we've done is we've been very cautious as we stepped into
1:38 it. We spent a lot of time internally thinking about how the technology could afford change,
1:45 and there's tremendous opportunity for change in our industry. But what it'll do is it'll make
1:51 us more efficient. It'll probably make us more productive, which will free up resources to do
1:56 other things. But I'm not certain it's gonna help us grow our business all that much.
2:02 And in order for the technology to generate the returns it needs with the amount of
2:07 capital it's consuming, you have to think about this as gonna grow businesses, new businesses. And
2:12 it's certainly in health care and discovery, but there could be... I'm I'm sure there's there's
2:16 a lot of new business models out there that are that are booming. The air industry,
2:21 this is gonna be something that... That's hopefully allows us to be a better airline, but
2:25 not necessarily a bigger airline.
2:27 There's also a question about how you handle, for example, agentic agents that, go shopping for
2:34 cheaper airline tickets. United came out yesterday and said that they were blocking certain personal AI,
2:41 assistance on their platforms. Have you made a decision on what Delta is gonna do about
2:45 that?
2:46 Again, we're being careful. We can identify the agents when they approach us. We have the
2:52 technology and the tools to do that. We watch what they're doing. If they're there to
2:58 look for information about an airfare for a... For a... For for you maybe, you may
3:04 you may have sent them looking for us. We'll respond in kind, but we're gonna be
3:09 very careful about making sure, first of all, you know, customer privacy. We understand who Lisa
3:14 is, not who Lisa's agent is, and we'll only allow Lisa to do things that we
3:17 know she wants to do such as checking in for a flight, all the data privacy
3:23 concerns, the security concerns in our industry. So I think it's... Again, it's too early for
3:28 us to declare, no. We're not gonna work in the agentic world. I know certain companies
3:33 have taken kind of a a bit of a black and white approach towards it. We're
3:37 a bit more nuanced. We wanna learn and understand what they're doing first, but we're... I
3:41 can tell you the volumes are relatively low. There's a lot of news flow about it,
3:45 but the actual volumes we see are... They're growing fast, but they're they're still quite modest.
3:50 The volumes are important ahead of the holiday season. And, in a conversation you had about
3:55 a month ago and earlier this morning, even you were talking about the steady demand that
3:59 you have seen from consumers. Can you, quantify or give a sense, qualify what traveler demand
4:06 actually looks like heading into the holidays, especially with some of the higher prices that we've
4:10 seen?
4:10 We continue to say... See what we've been seeing for the bulk of the year. The
4:14 demand is really strong. The investment consumers are making in their experience continues to be the
4:20 top of their shopping list for the holidays. They wanna travel. They want to go places.
4:24 They wanna see people. So the experience economy is alive and well. And, yes, prices are
4:30 higher, largely driven by not just fuel prices, cost in general. But if you step back
4:36 and think about how airfares have been over the last number of years, particularly coming out
4:40 of COVID, we're still below where general inflation has been post pandemic. We went through several
4:47 years following the pandemic where fares actually were flat to down. So a little bit of
4:52 this is also a catch up. So we're I I know it doesn't necessarily make it
4:57 easier when you're seeing a 25% increase on on a ticket, which, you know, many are,
5:02 but it's what we need to do to cover our cost in... Of doing and providing
5:05 that service.
5:06 Just theoretically, if someone in New York were looking to book a ticket to, say, Salt
5:10 Lake City during ski season, during a holiday season, they would find that it costs about
5:15 $1,500 just for even coach. At the same time, it's cheaper to go over to Europe.
5:19 I mean, at what point do people start pushing back, especially with the domestic prices that
5:23 you're seeing in certain places?
5:25 We we haven't seen the pushback. It's it's supply and demand. It's supply and demand. And,
5:29 you know, we love the... For the fact that we have lots of different alternatives and
5:33 lots of different products and fair categories, particularly the the... In the premium sectors. That's where
5:39 you have the strongest, pricing right now is is in the premium products that we offer.
5:44 But we have basic economy. We have a lot of different product categories for young folks
5:49 to to join us as well.
5:50 There is a a question, though, about how much further prices can go, especially oil prices
5:54 today are higher. There is, some speculation after the truth social post from president Trump that
6:00 there isn't going to be a deal with Iran and that the tensions could continue. At
6:06 what point does it become insurmountable in terms of how much you can raise prices to
6:10 offset the increase of the oil prices?
6:13 I I think the industry has largely done that. I'd say we are pretty close to
6:19 having managed as I was speaking for Delta. You know, we're... Our profits are down a
6:23 little bit on a year over year basis, but we've largely held held our our our
6:28 margins at this point. And that's about, I think, all you can do with today's oil
6:32 environment.
6:33 Is there a sense that the shakeout has already been done with respect to airlines that
6:39 are smaller, less well capitalized than yourself, and whether they merge with one another or whether
6:45 they go bankrupt. Do you think that that's over, or do you think that there's still
6:48 a wave to come?
6:49 No. I think you... You'll tell me where you think the price of jet fuel will
6:52 be twelve months from now. I can answer your question. I think I think it's it's
6:56 way too early to declare that the fuel shock is behind us. I mean, there's a
7:01 risk it could go higher. And, there are certainly airlines that are closer to to the
7:07 edge and and weren't making money prior to the oil shock. It's just made it all
7:13 the more difficult for them.
7:15 I just wanna finish on a question that keeps coming up whenever we talk about, flights,
7:19 and that is Wi Fi. And I know, you decided not to go to Starlink. Some
7:24 of some of your competitors did a lot of back and forth. Elon Musk came out,
7:28 had some choice words. You decided to go instead with Amazon's LEO, which has been a
7:33 little bit delayed. Have you regretted it at all, or do you ever think about that?
7:38 Do you... Have you talked with Elon Musk recently?
7:41 We, we've been a leader in this space. We first launched global free fast Wi Fi
7:45 five years ago. I remember when we did the industry was all in arms. You know,
7:49 how can Delta do that? We're gonna have to copy it now. We're gonna have to
7:52 move that way. And, you know, we've known Starlink for a very long time. We decided
7:57 to go in a different way. You know, we we have a different business model than
8:00 maybe some of the other airlines do, and we play the long game. And we know
8:04 the Amazon LEO product's gonna be a great product. It's gonna be coming to the skies
8:08 here relatively soon over the next eighteen months. And, I I... I'm very confident in our
8:13 decision.
8:14 Ed Bastianz, thank you so much for being with us this morning. Ed Bastianz, the Delta
8:18 CEO. Vonnie, I'll send it back to you.
Nvidia Scandal Could Change US-China Relationship full transcript
0:00 TO GO RIGHT ALONG WITH THE PRODUCT ROADMAP.
0:00 I THINK IT WILL BE HARD FOR SOMEONE TO COME IN AND EXECUTE
0:03 LIKE THAT. ISABELLE: TO THOSE JUST JOINING
0:08 US, JENSEN HUANG HAS RESIGNED FROM HIS POST AS CEO OF NVIDIA.
0:14 COLLETTE KRESS WAS NAMED INTERIM CEO.
0:17 JENSEN HUANG IS ONE OF THE FOUNDERS OF NVIDIA AND HE'S BEEN
0:20 UNDER INTENSE SCRUTINY SINCE WE FOUND OUT ABOUT THIS ALLEGED
0:23 AFFAIR WITH A SPY. WHAT DOES WASHINGTON KNOW ABOUT
0:25 THIS? WE KNOW JENSEN HUANG HAS CLOSE
0:29 TIES TO THE PRESIDENT AND IT REMAINS TO BE SEEN WHAT THAT
0:33 RELATIONSHIP WILL BE LIKE. THIS COMES AHEAD OF THE TRUMP
0:35 MEETING NEXT WEEK. MIKE: IT'S A GREAT QUESTION.
0:39 IT IS ONE WE ARE REPORTING RIGHT NOW.
0:42 IT IS UNCLEAR HOW MUCH OF A BRIEFING THEY ARE GETTING IN
0:44 REAL TIME AS THE BOARD WAS MEETING.
0:48 THE ADMINISTRATION WAS AWARE OF SOME OF THE INTERACTIONS THAT
0:51 JENSEN HUANG HAD WITH THE MEGASPEED EXECUTIVE WHO IS NOW
0:56 SUSPECTED OF BEING A CHINESE SPY.
0:59 AND ACCORDING TO OUR EXCLUSIVE REPORTING FROM COLLEAGUES IN
1:02 ASIA, SHE IS NOW IN BEIJING WITH THE GOVERNMENT'S KNOWLEDGE.
1:06 IT ADDS A WHOLE NEW WRINKLE TO THE RELATIONSHIP WITH CHINA.
1:11 THEN AGAIN, THERE IS THE RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN PRESIDENT
1:14 DONALD TRUMP AND JENSEN HUANG. WE HAVE SEEN IT PLAY OUT SO
1:17 PUBLICLY. THEY HAD REALLY DEVELOPED THIS
1:20 BOND. AND CLEARLY, IT IS BEING TESTED
1:23 BY THIS MOMENT. THE PRESIDENT ON MONDAY, THE DAY
1:25 AFTER THE ALLEGATIONS SURFACED AND JENSEN HUANG ADMITTED TO THE
1:31 AFFAIR, THE PRESIDENT ACTUALLY SAID DURING A BRIEFING WITH
1:35 REPORTERS THAT HE FELT SOME SYMPATHY FOR JENSEN HUANG,
1:38 CALLED HIM A VERY HONORABLE MAN. BUT THE SAME TIME, HE NOTED
1:42 THERE WAS AN -- AT THE SAME TIME, HE NOTED THERE WAS AN FBI
1:48 INVESTIGATION HAPPENING WITHOUT ELABORATING.
1:50 THIS WILL RUPTURE WHATEVER HAS TRANSPIRED TO BRING JENSEN AND
1:55 THE COMPANY VERY CLOSE TO THE ADMINISTRATION.
1:57 LIKEWISE, WE COULD SEE RIPPLE EFFECTS FOR OTHER TECH COMPANIES
2:00 AS WELL THAT HAVE SOUGHT TO REALLY INGRATIATE THEMSELVES
2:04 WITH THE PRESIDENT AND SEEK SOME PAPER WHEN IT COMES TO
2:08 POLICYMAKING. NOW IN THE WAKE OF THE ELECTION
2:09 AND IN THE WAKE OF WHAT JUST HAPPENED AT NVIDIA, WE COULD
2:12 REALLY SEE A CHANGE IN THE WEATHER THERE.
2:14 VONNIE: ISABELLE MENTIONED A CHANGE IN THE WEATHER.
2:21 S&P FUTURES ARE LOWER BUT NOT QUITE BY AS MUCH, DOWN 7/10 OF A
2:26 PERCENT AS WE SEE NVIDIA DETERIORATING.
2:29 IT HAD BEEN LOWER ALL MORNING AFTER REPORTS CAME OUT LAST
2:31 NIGHT. THE RESIGNATION OF JENSEN HUANG
2:33 HAS SENT NVIDIA DOWN 12% PREMARKET.
2:36 MICHAEL, LET ME STAY WITH YOU AND ASK YOU, THIS EXPOSES OTHER
2:40 MEMBERS OF THE MINISTRATION AS WELL.
2:43 IN SOME WAYS, WE ARE GETTING A DRIP DRIP OF REPORTS ABOUT HOW
2:46 THE COMMERCE DEPARTMENT MAY HAVE BEEN INVOLVED.
2:49 HOW THE GENERAL COUNSEL AT NVIDIA MIGHT HAVE BEEN MAKING
2:54 INQUIRIES. WE DON'T KNOW WHERE THEY WILL
2:57 ALL END UP YET, DO WE? MIKE: THE LAST RADIUS FROM ALL
3:01 OF THIS IS STILL UNKNOWN BUT IT IS WIDENING.
3:03 I'M GLAD YOU BROUGHT UP THE COMMERCE DEPARTMENT BECAUSE THEY
3:06 ARE THE AGENCY THAT OVERSEES U.S. EXPORT CONTROLS.
3:09 THEY HAVE COME UNDER A HARSH CRITICISM FOR FAILING TO
3:12 EXERCISE THAT AUTHORITY IN DO FASHION.
3:16 THERE ARE CONCERNS RAISED BY A NUMBER OF LAWMAKERS THAT NVIDIA
3:19 HAS BEEN USING ITS WAY AND INFLUENCING THROUGH PRESIDENT
3:24 DONALD TRUMP AND OTHER SENIOR OFFICIALS TO STYMIE
3:26 INVESTIGATIONS AND SLOW THE ENACTMENT OF ADDITIONAL EXPORT
3:28 CONTROL POLICIES. YOU BROUGHT UP THE INTERVENTION
3:33 OF THE NVIDIA GENERAL COUNSEL. TIM TEETER HAD CALLED THE HEAD
3:39 OF THE EXPORT CONTROL AGENCY, JEFFREY KESSLER, TO INQUIRE
3:42 ABOUT WHETHER HIS AGENCY, HIS BUREAU HAD SOMEHOW INTERVENED.
3:54 VIS HAD NO ROLE WE ARE TOLD. BUT NONETHELESS, IT PUT A CHILL
4:00 ON CONGRESS'S INVESTIGATION OF MEGASPEED AND POSSIBLE EXPORT
4:05 CONTROL VIOLATIONS. THE JUSTICE DEPARTMENT IS
4:06 LEADING THAT PROBE NOW. IT REALLY DOES EXPOSE HOWARD
4:10 LUTNICK, THE COMMERCE SECRETARY AND OTHER SENIOR OFFICIALS TO
4:13 REALLY INTENSE QUESTIONS, NOT ONLY WITHIN THE ADMINISTRATION
4:16 BUT FOR LAWMAKERS THEMSELVES ABOUT THEIR CONDUCT AND THEIR
4:21 EXERCISE OF EXPORT CONTROLS AND IT RAISES THE QUESTION ABOUT
Jensen Huang's Influence on Washington full transcript
0:00 CREDIBILITY WISE, I THINK -- --
0:08 ISABELLE: LET'S BRING IN MIKE. I WANT TO TALK ABOUT THE CHINA
0:13 STRATEGY. WE KNOW JENSEN HUANG HAS BEEN
0:15 PUSHING FOR LOOSER RESTRICTIONS WHEN IT COMES TO THE CHINA CHIP
0:19 AND THE DEAL WITH THE U.S.. WHAT WILL IT MEAN FOR THAT?
0:25 WILL THE NEW CEO CONTINUE THAT PATH MOVING FORWARD IN YOUR
0:28 OPINION? MIKE: THEY MAY TRY TO CONTINUE
0:32 THAT PATH BUT THEY WON'T HAVE THE SAME LEVERAGE.
0:39 JENSEN HUANG WAS ABLE TO PERSUADE THE ADMINISTRATION TO
0:42 LOOSEN EXPORT CONTROLS THAT HAVE BEEN GRADUALLY TIGHTENED SINCE
0:45 2022. THAT WERE PREVENTING THE COMPANY
0:48 FROM SELLING SOME OF ITS MOST ADVANCED AI CHIPS TO CHINESE
0:52 BUYERS. WE SAW H2 HUNDREDS CLEARED FOR
0:55 PURCHASE BY CHINA LATE LAST YEAR, REALLY THANKS TO THIS
1:01 LOBBYING EFFORT BY JENSEN HUANG, DIRECTLY TO PRESIDENT DONALD
1:04 TRUMP, WHO MADE THAT ANNOUNCEMENT HIMSELF.
1:07 ALL OF THAT HAS CHANGED. WE ARE SEEING THIS FUNDAMENTAL
1:11 SHIFT HERE IN WASHINGTON AFTER THE ELECTION THANKS TO THE VOTER
1:14 BACKLASH AGAINST AI, BUT MORE SPECIFICALLY ON CAPITOL HILL, WE
1:20 ARE SEEING A RECKONING FOR THE COMPANY WITH LAWMAKERS FROM BOTH
1:24 PARTIES ADVOCATING STERNER EXPORT CONTROLS BEING PUT IN
1:27 PLACE, SPECIFICALLY WHEN IT COMES TO AI CHIPS AND CHINA.
1:29 VONNIE: EXPLAIN TO US WHAT LIABILITY JENSEN HIMSELF IS
1:34 EXPOSED TO NOW EVEN AFTER RESIGNING FROM NVIDIA, NEVER
1:37 MIND THE COMPANY ITSELF. MIKE: WE ARE STILL IN THE EARLY
1:43 STAGES BEST OCCASION. IT'S UNCLEAR WHERE HE COULD BE
1:47 EXPOSED IN TERMS OF WHAT HE HAS PREVIOUSLY TOLD THE COMPANY
1:50 ABOUT HIS RELATIONSHIPS, NOT ONLY WITH ALICE BUT ALSO WITH
1:53 ONE OF HIS SUBORDINATES, AND NVIDIA VICE PRESIDENT.
1:59 NEWS OF THAT CAME TO LIGHT LAST NIGHT AS ISABELLA NOTED.
2:03 THERE IS THE EXPOSURE HE COULD HAVE FROM THAT.
2:07 THERE ARE INQUIRIES FROM THE JUSTICE DEPARTMENT.
2:15 DID NVIDIA HAVE SOME SORT OF HAND IN HELPING MEGASPEED
2:18 LOOKING THE OTHER WAY? THE U.S. IS STILL INVESTIGATING
2:26 WHETHER THAT HAPPENED. MEGASPEED HAS DENIED THAT'S THE
2:29 CASE. THAT INVESTIGATION HAS NOT
2:31 CONCLUDED AND WE ARE WAITING TO SEE WHAT THE RESULTS WILL BE.
2:34 THEN I MENTIONED CAPITOL HILL. LAWMAKERS THERE ARE PREPARING TO
2:38 MOUNT THEIR OWN INVESTIGATIONS AND, AS OF LAST NIGHT, JENSEN
2:41 HUANG WAS FACING THE PROSPECT OF A SUBPOENA FROM A TRIO OF HOUSE
2:46 REPUBLICAN COMMITTEE LEADERS WHO WANTED HIM TO SHOW UP A WEEK
2:48 FROM YESTERDAY ON CAPITOL HILL TO ANSWER QUESTIONS ABOUT THIS
2:53 SCANDAL. IT'S UNCLEAR NOW THAT HE IS GONE
2:56 WHETHER THEY WILL INSIST ON THAT SUBPOENA BUT WE KNOW THAT TWO
3:00 DEMOCRATS, CHRIS COONS AND ELIZABETH WARREN IN THE SENATE,
3:02 HAVE ASKED NVIDIA TO RETAIN ALL RECORDS RELATED TO THIS MATTER.
BREAKING NEWS: Nvidia's Jensen Huang Resigns as CEO Effective Immediately full transcript
0:00 The Nvidia board has announced that Jensen Huang is out as CEO.
0:04 The board just issuing a statement saying that CFO Colette Kress will
0:09 become interim CEO. Nvidia's CEO Jensen Huang, has resigned,
0:15 effective immediately, according to that statement.
0:18 Uh, Harvey Jones has been named the first ever chair of Nvidia's board that
0:24 read headline Now converting to a heart. That CFO Collette Kress will act as
0:29 interim CEO. Something you and I were discussing
0:32 about half an hour ago, write something that the market had pondered might take
0:35 place. The declines in the premarket bouncing
0:38 around because maybe, based on last night's reporting from Bloomberg, that
0:42 the board had engaged a third party outside firm to lead executive search
0:46 for a long term successor. And in the interim, according to
0:49 Bloomberg's reporting, was thinking about a short term interim CEO that now
0:55 coming through.
What Huang's Departure Means for the Future of Nvidia full transcript
0:01 It's official. Jensen Wong out at Nvidia
0:04 shares extending their slide premarket.
0:06 I'm Vonnie Quinn alongside Isabelle Lee.
0:08 This is Bloomberg Open interest and we
0:10 have team coverage of the Nvidia story.
0:12 Ed Lelo with the latest headlines.
0:14 Mandep Singh looking at the ripple
0:15 effect beyond Nvidia and Michael Shepard
0:17 on its impact on tech policy. Let's
0:19 start with Bloomberg tech host Ed Lelo
0:21 in Francisco. Ed, talk to us about what
0:23 this will mean for Nvidia and its future
0:25 because we have Jensen Huang who spent
0:26 33 years at the helm of the company.
0:28 Jensen Huang is synonymous with Nvidia.
0:30 Nvidia synonymous with the AI
0:31 revolution.
0:33 >> Well, Jensen Huang's resignation is
0:34 effective immediately and CFO Colet
0:37 Crest steps into the CEO role in an
0:39 interim basis and to Wall Street that
0:41 brings some familiarity. Colette Crest
0:43 has been there for 13 years. She has
0:44 been alongside Jensen Wong on all of the
0:46 earnings calls and seen that dramatic
0:48 period of growth and she to an extent
0:51 holds a relationship with Wall Street.
0:53 Right. Jensen Wong had been doing that
0:55 more in recent quarters and recent
0:57 years, but the stock clearly reacted
1:00 with with a deeper push into negative
1:02 territory uh in the pre-market. A
1:04 significant update is that Harvey C.
1:06 Jones, who's one of Nvidia's longest
1:08 serving directors, becomes chair of the
1:11 board. So, what Nvidia is essentially
1:12 doing is separating the chairman and CEO
1:15 role, which Jensen Wong had held. Um, I
1:17 guess the final update is that there we
1:19 will continue and go ahead with earnings
1:21 next week, which is a big question
1:24 >> planned November 17th at 5:00 p.m.
1:26 Eastern. Ed and as you said, Klet Car
1:29 has been on those calls, so she's known
1:30 to Wall Street. Will there be any
1:31 questions as to how much if at anything
1:34 she knew during this period? I mean that
1:38 is not mentioned at all in the
1:40 statement. Nor is the idea that Jensen
1:42 rem maintains any kind of relationship
1:45 with Nvidia on an advisory basis. Um
1:48 there is also very little update in the
1:50 investigation. Remember that when this
1:52 all happened Sunday, Jenna had written
1:54 to staff to disclose that he'd had an
1:56 affair um and that he would cooperate
1:58 with an investigation. The board had
2:00 said that at that time there was no
2:03 evidence that there was a national
2:05 security or an Nvidia trade secrets uh
2:08 risk uh to the best of their knowledge
2:11 that they were aware of. So that doesn't
2:13 really answer your question on collect
2:14 crest but this was expected right look
2:16 at the reporting last night from
2:17 Bloomberg and others that the board had
2:19 engaged third parties to look for an
2:21 external candidate long term. In the
2:23 statement, Nvidia's board says they're
2:24 open to looking at external candidates
2:26 for the CEO long term, but they also
2:29 said in these reports last night that
2:30 collect Crest would be an option on
2:32 interim basis. And here we are as of
2:33 9:00 a.m. Eastern uh on Thursday
2:35 morning, and that is what has
2:36 transpired.
2:37 >> Ed, talk to us about the future of the
2:39 company. Like, how much of Nvidia's
2:41 competitive advantage is really tied to
2:42 Jensen Wang, his connections, his
2:44 knowhow, his relationships, and his
2:46 ability to really bring the industry
2:47 together?
2:49 >> Yeah. The fundamental change that
2:51 happened after the chat GPT moment of
2:54 2022 is Nvidia's business model shifted
2:57 to one man, Jensen Wong, flying around
3:00 the world, operating in a role where he
3:02 coordinated with policy makers, the CEOs
3:05 of his key suppliers, and his key
3:07 customers.
3:09 Not that long ago, that wasn't how their
3:11 business worked. You bought Nvidia GPUs
3:14 that went into data centers through a a
3:16 middle channel which was the the server
3:18 OEMs Dell, HPE, Super Micro. There
3:22 wasn't this direct relationship between
3:24 the chip makers and where those chips
3:26 ultimately ended up that Jensen
3:28 completely reversed that right you know
3:30 if you think about the entire chain um
3:32 that has been built out in this AI
3:34 infrastructure buildout. Um so you know
3:37 going forward it's be really hard to to
3:39 to see that happening. Nvidia had a
3:41 structure where it was Jensen one at the
3:42 top. He had 60 or so direct reports and
3:45 it was kind of like a reverse pyramid.
3:47 Um and you know we don't know the answer
3:50 of how that will shift going forward.
3:52 >> Let me bring in Mandib Singh of
3:54 Bloomberg Intelligence. Mandib obviously
3:56 we want to ask about the fallout for the
3:57 rest of the AI industry and the
3:59 structure around Nvidia right the moment
4:02 the company has worked extraordinarily
4:03 fast. is saying operations and supplies
4:06 will continue without any interruption
4:08 and this is basically just within days
4:10 of all of this breaking. Is there the
4:12 possibility that things will continue to
4:14 run smoothly in the AI universe that the
4:16 deals that have been done were the bulk
4:18 of the deals that were coming anyway and
4:20 the market will get over this?
4:22 Uh no, I think there will be a
4:24 tremendous loss of credibility for uh
4:27 Nvidia overall given their importance in
4:30 the AI ecosystem and what has
4:33 transpired. I I think in terms of the
4:36 board uh and and everything that they
4:39 were doing from a deal perspective and I
4:42 think I would call out two uh entities
4:44 that would kind of get impacted the
4:46 most. One is the Neoclouds. Nvidia was
4:49 very supportive of the Neocloud
4:50 ecosystem with all the investments. So,
4:52 it'll be interesting to see how that
4:54 plays out and also the open-source
4:56 openweight ecosystem because Nvidia
4:59 clearly was developing uh its own
5:01 openweight models and it'll be
5:03 interesting to see how that evolves in
5:06 light of uh you know this development
5:08 and where Jensen clearly was
5:10 spearheading that strategy. So those two
5:12 and and then obviously you have the
5:14 gross margins that uh everyone thought
5:16 Nvidia's gross margins were too high and
5:19 they were somehow able to manage it. I I
5:22 think it'll be interesting to see how
5:23 that plays out. So credibility-wise I
5:26 think it is a big dent com uh uh the
5:28 whole thing and how this has transpired.
Nvidia Board Considers Jensen Huang's Future After Affair full transcript
0:00 The board has been caught off guard by the situation with without doubt, you
0:04 mentioned at the top of the hour about the fact that there is a lack of
0:07 succession planning here for the for the company.
0:10 If we look at other tech, um, behemoths that have had, uh, changes of CEOs,
0:18 whether it be Amazon or Apple or Microsoft.
0:21 It's been a clear path, a smooth path. Succession plans.
0:25 There is really no bench here at Nvidia. And that is a big issue, uh, for the
0:30 corporation. But the board have to act.
0:33 And what had the board have to act? I think all you need to do is actually
0:37 if you if you look at the code of conduct.
0:40 So invidious code of conduct states, personal relationships may create
0:43 conflict of interest. And any waiver of the rules involving an
0:47 executive officer specifically requires written approval by the compliance
0:52 committee. And guess what?
0:54 Is at least two of the five compliance committee members who are current board
0:59 members? So this is a a whole escalation of the
1:02 issues we saw from around just went earlier this week.
1:05 This is another level. But Neil, again, you talked to a lot of,
1:09 uh, technology investors, technology analysts out there and they're saying
1:13 Bloomberg. I mean, you know, if you look at Nvidia,
1:16 Nvidia really is Jensen Huang in. Jensen Huang is Nvidia.
1:19 His personal relationships are at the center of all of these deals that have
1:24 been hatched over the last several years with his development of AI.
1:28 How difficult will be for this company to potentially, uh, separate itself from
1:34 Jensen Wong? Uh, it is a very difficult, uh,
1:38 extraction process because as you as you mentioned, they all they are, uh,
1:42 interlinked. Um, I remember meeting Jensen way back
1:45 in 1999. I mean, the vision that he's had has
1:49 clearly come to pass into what is an AI revolution.
1:51 And he's at the center of he's at the center of that.
1:54 There is no denying that. But now we're on a path where also where
1:58 we get discussions around what we call the central bank of Nvidia for the AI
2:03 trade or the Bank of Nvidia. And if we look at what's on, you know,
2:07 we look at all of the commitments that have been signed.
2:09 If you look at filings data at the end of the second quarter, there's more than
2:13 $500 billion of disclosed strategic agreements, backstops and holdings.
2:19 They've got strategic partnerships in the like of OpenAI.
2:22 They want to be there in the S-1 of anthropic as being a $10 billion anchor
2:26 investor. So the tentacles are everywhere.
2:30 So it's a right it's an issue if we tag team as one final question.
2:34 You know, to get you back to your incredible afternoon in London.
2:37 Uh, I look at the idea of putting a team together, and all the speculation of
2:42 someone comes in from outside. His eminence group say they have a CFO
2:46 who's in the game, and they have Neil, but, uh, Ian Buck, rather Ian Buck,
2:51 who's basically general manager of the business with Princeton and Stanford.
2:56 Credit. Can the operation guy step up to choose
3:00 the upgrade path of their technology? Uh, it's a it's a great question
3:06 because, as you say, he is, uh, you know, the head of the kind of the
3:10 technology and has been there for a very long time.
3:13 And the CFO, she's well respected by the investment community, without any doubt
3:18 at all. But this is, you know, this is a huge
3:22 company that actually is facing significant challenges now because much
3:27 of its moat is being eroded away. You're seeing rival technologies now
3:31 which are fast playing, fast catch up. So is it can they do it from internally
3:37 or do they need to bring someone in externally?
3:39 Somebody perhaps like, um CEO? Um, it has been mentioned to me by some
3:43 investors this morning. It's, uh, you know, it's it's definitely
3:46 can be an interesting situation to watch, but I don't think the internal
3:50 candidates alone can do this.
Jensen Huang Resigns as Nvidia CEO full transcript
0:00 Mandy. This is a first step in this crisis for
0:03 Nvidia. The next step must be to find an
0:06 operating CEO, right? Yes.
0:10 And, uh, it sounds like, uh, the CFO, Colette Kress, is going to be the
0:15 interim CEO. But, uh, I wouldn't be surprised if they
0:19 take, uh, you know, much longer in terms of the CEO search and have Colette kind
0:25 of take care of things, uh, for maybe, uh, you know, 1 or 2 quarters and, uh,
0:31 uh, it will be hard for anyone to fill Jensen shoes, given, uh, his role at the
0:38 company and what he has done. But, uh, there are a lot of names that
0:42 we have heard. And, uh, it will be interesting to see
0:45 if they go for an internal or an external candidate in terms of the final
0:50 CEO pick. Mandy, uh, I think what a lot of our
0:53 listeners and viewers kind of understand about AI is that so many of these deals
0:58 between chipmakers, hyperscalers, software, hardware, there's so many
1:05 deals that are intra company deals, circular deals, if you will.
1:09 And many of those deals, many of those relationships have Jensen Wang as the
1:16 centerpiece here. How does that play out going forward?
1:19 I mean, it just seems like it's going to be so difficult.
1:22 It will be difficult for anyone, even if it's an internal candidate to, you know,
1:28 uh, kind of manage all the relationships in terms of the ecosystem that, uh,
1:35 Jensen had created. And, uh, I think that's where, uh, you
1:40 know, anyone stepping in new may have their own way of going about things.
1:46 Uh, you know, on the product side as well as the financing side that you
1:49 alluded to to help me with the GPU, the folks, Mandeep Singh, we underplay it.
1:54 We ask him dumb questions. He is incredibly good at the electrical
2:00 engineering and computer science on this.
2:02 What is the skill set to go from GPU chip whatever to the next GPU chip.
2:11 Is that a Mandeep Singh engineering decision?
2:15 Is it a guesstimate about the depreciation of the older chip?
2:19 How does that work? Yeah.
2:22 Look I mean what Nvidia has done is they have launched, you know, new versions of
2:28 their chips almost at a six month cadence.
2:31 And we are talking about, you know, their latest Vera Rubin architecture,
2:35 which is uh, you know, five times better in terms of throughput than their
2:39 Blackwell architecture. So to be able to iterate on these things
2:44 and stay, uh, you know, ahead of everyone else, which is why they had
2:48 such a big share in the GPU market. Uh, is is very commendable in terms of
2:53 execution. But that's where, you know, if they if
2:56 it's someone technical, uh, it will make a difference in terms of how they, you
3:01 know, approach the product side of things.
3:03 Have you met Harvey Jones, the new chair?
3:05 I mean, the dominant feature there is he's one of, I believe, off the
3:09 Bloomberg band deep for original directors.
3:12 I mean, do you have any perspective of Mr.
3:15 Jones relationship with Mr. Wong and with the rest of the team?
3:21 Yeah. I mean, look, uh, I think when it comes
3:24 to the board and, uh, you know, the new chair, uh, obviously, you know, everyone
3:30 is very close to Jensen, given he's the co-founder and, uh, you know, has been
3:36 with the company for over 30 plus years. So from that perspective, I think I
3:42 don't know Harvey in particular, but, uh, at the same time, I think, uh, it
3:46 would be somebody who Jensen knows quite well.
3:49 Well, we're going to come back. I want to talk to you about Ian back and
3:51 all that he's done for the IT company. This is a headline moment for technology
3:56 across America from the interactive broker Studios.
4:00 Continue news here on Nvidia Alexis Christopherson.
4:04 And I'm taking a look at uh shares of Nvidia right now down more than 11%.
4:09 So before we heard news that Jensen Wong was indeed stepping down, the stock was
4:14 down about 8%. So again, took another leg lower after
4:17 we found out that Jensen Wong has indeed resigned from the company he co-founded
4:22 in 1993, he is going to be replaced, at least on an interim basis, by Nvidia's
4:27 chief financial officer, Colette Kress. She joined the company 13 years ago
4:31 after stints at Microsoft and Cisco. Nvidia's board, though, is still working
4:35 with an outside firm to identify potential replacements for Wong in the
4:41 long term. Two companies, though benefiting from
4:44 all the drama at Nvidia this morning, AMD and Broadcom.
4:47 Both of them are higher. This is as investors look for exposure
4:51 to AI outside of Nvidia. And a lot of analysts are saying those
4:54 two companies are really the only two large cap options you have if you're
4:58 looking for major exposure to AI. So once again Nvidia shares down they're
5:03 volatile here in the premarket but down about 10.5% on news that Jensen Huang
5:07 has stepped down. Uh Alexa thank you so much.
5:10 Appreciate it. The tape -66 improves a few more minutes
5:14 with Mandeep Singh here. Global head of technology, media and
5:18 telecom for Bloomberg. I look Mandy at the product cycle.
5:23 Ian book seems to be incredibly important here.
5:27 He is, the Stanford technologist behind, uh, the moment here.
5:33 How important is position now and what does Ian Buck need to do in the coming
5:38 days? Yes.
5:39 So he's definitely the frontrunner when it comes to internal candidates.
5:44 Uh, and uh, clearly he is, uh, the guy with the Cuda, uh, uh, aspect of, uh,
5:51 the Bloomberg product lineup, which is why, uh, as, uh, sorry, the Nvidia line
5:55 up, which is why, uh, Nvidia has done so well.
5:58 And, uh, from that perspective, uh, you know, uh, having someone technical, uh,
6:03 will be quite beneficial at this point of time to calm down, uh, all the
6:09 anxiety that investors have and, uh, Mandeep underplays the ginormous
6:14 technology feat of Ian Buck. This was Brook br okay at Stanford, then
6:21 went over to Cuda. Cuda, which, uh, Mandeep will explain to
6:26 me over a beverage of my choice. It's some point.
6:29 And then you bring that over the mirror called that is Nvidia mandate.
6:33 What is your experience of Beast technology?
6:37 People quite frankly, like you with great respect running as a CEO company.
6:44 How can that actually work? Well, what Jensen was really good at was
6:50 he was both very good on the technology side and also great in terms of, you
6:55 know, that ecosystem that he had created and the supply chain aspect of it.
7:00 And that's a hard combination to find in terms of, you know, at the CEO level.
7:06 So clearly Ian has all the credentials when it comes to the technology side of,
7:12 uh, the Nvidia products. But, uh, I think to have those kind of
7:16 relationships with TSMC and all the suppliers, which is why Nvidia got to
7:21 this position in terms of ramping up capacity so fast.
7:24 I think that will be a true test of somebody who has got, you know, all the
7:29 different aspects of what is needed for this company.
Stocks Fall on Nvidia Worries; Nvidia Board Considers Huang's Future full transcript
0:17 >> GOOD MORNING. I AM ANNA EDWARDS WITH YOUR
0:20 BLOOMBERG BRIEF. LET'S GET YOU SET UP FOR THE DAY
0:21 AHEAD. NVIDIA'S BOARD GATHERS TO
0:27 CONSIDER JENSEN HUANG'S FUTURE AFTER REPORTS OF A SECOND
0:29 ALLEGED EXTRAMARITAL AFFAIR EMERGE.
0:38 CHINESE AI STOCKS DROP WITH POTENTIAL BENEFICIARIES GAINING
0:41 HEARING AND QUESTIONS OVER U.S.-CHINA TRADE RELATIONS AHEAD
0:47 OF THE TRUMP-XI SUMMIT LATER THIS MONTH.
0:48 WE START WITH ASIA. HERE IS WINNIE HSU IN HONG KONG.
0:56 >> WE ARE SEEING ASIAN STOCKS UNDER PRESSURE AFTER THREE DAYS
0:57 OF GAINS. THE UNCERTAINTY WHEN IT COMES'S
1:04 TO NVIDIA LEADERSHIP ROLE IS NOT JUST ABOUT WHO MIGHT POTENTIALLY
1:08 TAKE OVER JENSEN HUANG'S CEO POSITION WERE ALSO CONCERNS RUN
1:10 CONTINUITY WHEN IT COMES TO THE BUSINESS STRATEGY AND CUSTOMER
1:14 RELATIONSHIP SO INVESTORS ARE TAKING A BIT OF A CAUTIOUS
1:17 STANCE NOW AND YOU ARE SEEING TECH HEAVY GAUGES IN THE REGION
1:20 LEADING LOSSES TODAY WITH THE LIKES OF TAIWAN'S INDEX DOWN BY
1:27 2.6% FOLLOWED BY SOUTH KOREA'S KOSPI INDEX DOWN BY ABOUT .6%.
1:32 WE TAKE A CLOSER LOOK AT SOME OF THE TECH STOCKS BECAUSE THERE IS
1:36 A DIVERSION IN THE PERFORMANCE AND IMPACT FROM NVIDIA.
1:43 YOU ARE SEEING OTHER PERFORMERS, SK HYNIX AND TSMC, WHICH RELY ON
1:47 NVIDIA, AND NVIDIA IS THE BIGGEST CUSTOMER FOR BOTH THESE
1:50 COMPANIES BY REVENUE AND ON THE OTHERS OF THINGS YOU ARE SEEING
1:53 SAMSUNG ELECTRONICS HOLDING UP WELL BECAUSE OF ITS CLOSE TIES
1:57 WITH AMD, A DIRECT COMPETITOR OF NVIDIA.
2:01 ALIBABA IS DOWN ALMOST 7% ALONG WITH CHINESE AI NAMES, GIVEN THE
2:05 EXPECTATION THE U.S. MIGHT BE STEPPING UP FURTHER EXPORT
2:09 RESTRICTIONS WHEN IT COMES TO CHIPS.
2:15 ANNA: THAT TAKES US TO EUROPE, WHERE WE ARE SEEING EUROPEAN
2:18 EQUITY MARKETS ON THE FRONT FOOT UP BY AROUND .5%.
2:22 EUROPE ACTING AS A DIVERSIFIER AWAY FROM THE TECH TRADE.
2:28 WE HAVE BIG TECH NAMES LIKE ASML TRADING TO THE DOWNSIDE.
2:33 TSMC -- ASML IS A SUPPLIER TO TSMC, WHICH SUPPLIES NVIDIA, SO
2:36 THAT IS PART OF THE STORY. ARE WE ALSO PREPARING FOR THE
2:43 TOUGHER EXPORT ENVIRONMENT? MAYBE THAT THEME IS WEIGHING ON
2:44 ASML AS WELL. SIEMENS SHOWS SOME CORPORATE'S
2:50 ARE BENEFITING FROM THE AI DATA CENTER ROLLOUT AND FACTORY
2:51 AUTOMATION. LET'S CHECK WHAT IS HAPPENING ON
2:54 U.S. MARKETS. NASDAQ FUTURES AND S&P FUTURES
3:01 TO THE DOWNSIDE, NO DOUBT A WEAKNESS IN NVIDIA STORY WILL
3:05 WEIGH ON THE NVIDIA SHARE PRICE AND MAY BE THE REST OF THE
3:07 ECOSYSTEM AROUND TECH, BUT THERE COULD BE GAINS IN THE U.S.
3:11 SESSION AS WELL. AMD AND BROADCOM HAVE BEEN DOING
3:15 OK IN THE FACE OF THE RETREAT OF NVIDIA APPEAR IN THE U.S. 10
3:18 YEAR YIELD IS HOVERING AROUND THE 5% MARK.
3:22 IT HAS BEEN OVER THAT IN RECENT DAYS AS WE WATCH THE TREASURY
3:23 TRADE. FOR MORE, HERE'S OLIVIA.
3:32 >> IF YOU HAVE HEARD ANY WORD MORE THAN NVIDIA OVER THE LAST
3:34 WEEK, I WOULD LOVE TO KNOW WHAT IT IS.
3:36 LET'S KICK OFF WITH WHAT HAPPENED OVER THE LAST 24 HOURS.
3:40 WE HAVE REPORTS OF ANOTHER AFFAIR THE JENSEN HUANG HAD WITH
3:43 AN EXECUTIVE AT THE COMPANY AND REPORTS THE WHITE HOUSE WAS
3:47 SOURING ON ITS RELATIONSHIP WITH THE CEO AND FINALLY THE BIG NAIL
3:52 IN THE COMPANY FOR NVIDIA IS A REPORT'S BOARD HAS BROUGHT IN
3:56 OUTSIDE COUNSEL TO HELP WORK ON POTENTIAL SUCCESSION PLANS.
4:01 NVIDIA STOCK IS DOWN $300 BILLION FROM HIS MARKET CAP SO
4:06 FAR ALREADY THIS WEEK. THREE ANALYSTS HAVE DOWNGRADED
4:10 THE STOCK SO FAR AND THE INITIAL PREMARKET DECLINE WAS SET TO
4:13 DOUBLE THAT. POTENTIALLY DIPPING BELOW $4
4:19 TRILLION FOR THE FIRST TIME SINCE IT FOUNDED THAT ELUSIVE
4:22 CLUB. WE HAVE PAIRED SOME OF THE
4:24 DECLINE BUT IT IS SOMETHING WE ARE WATCHING THIS MORNING ON
4:28 THIS DEVELOPING STORY. IT IS NOT DOOM AND GLOOM FOR
4:32 EVERYBODY, PARTICULARLY NOT NVIDIA'S COMPETITORS WHICH ARE
4:39 BROADLY HIGHER IN PREMARKET TRADING ON HOPES THEY MIGHT BE
4:44 ABLE TO SIPHON OFF NVIDIA'S MARKET SHARE APPEAR IN ALPHABET
4:45 IS UP BY SLIGHTLY LESS AS A COMPETITOR.
4:50 THEY KICKED OFF AN INAUGURAL BOND SALE IN HONG KONG AND
4:53 ALPHABET. THERE ARE THINGS GOING ON IN THE
4:59 MARKET ASIDE FROM THE STORY. ELI LILLY IS HIGHER IN PREMARKET
5:04 TRADING AFTER BECOMING THE FIRST DRUG MAKER TO HAVE AN OBESITY
5:06 PILL APPROVED IN CHINA. ANNA: OLIVIA WITH THE STOCKS TO
5:14 WATCH AS WE HEAD TOWARD THE OPEN.
5:16 COMING UP, MORE ON THE MARKET IMPACT OF THE NVIDIA SCANDAL.
5:21 WE WILL TALK HOW MUCH THEY SCANDAL IS SHAKING PERSPECTIVE
5:23 AROUND THE AI TRADE AND TO THE U.N. SECRETARY-GENERAL, JOINING
5:28 THE TEAM FROM THE UNITED NATIONS CLIMATE CHANGE CONFERENCE A
5:35 LITTLE LATER ON THIS HOUR. FIRST COME NVIDIA IN CRISIS MODE
5:37 AFTER CEO JENSEN HUANG IS LINKED TO A SECOND EXTRAMARITAL AFFAIR.
5:43 >> THIS IS A DISASTER THIS POINT.
5:48 >> THIS IS A STORY OF HUBRIS AND POOR CORPORATE GOVERNANCE.
5:50 >> I CANNOT SEE >> ANYBODY STEPPING IN.
5:53 >>TRUMP SHOULD NOT MEET WITH PRESIDENT XI TO MAKE A POINT OF
5:58 HOW SERIOUS WE ARE TAKING THIS. >> THIS COULD ACCELERATE THE
6:02 AND CHINA. >> THAT COULD LOSE MARKET SHARE
6:07 AND GO TO MD AND BROADCOM. >> WE ARE GOING TO SEE HEADLINES
6:15 COMING OUT FOR MONTHS ANYWAYS. ANNA: AI STOCKS LINKED TO NVIDIA
6:24 SELLING OFF AFTER DAYS. THE BOARD MEETING TODAY TO
6:25 POTENTIALLY VOTE ON WHETHER OR NOT TO OUST JENSEN HUANG WITH AN
6:33 OUTSIDE FIRM WORKING TO IDENTIFY POSSIBLE CANDIDATES.
6:35 TOM MACKENZIE HAS BEEN COVERING THE STORY HERE IN EUROPE.
6:39 THIS BIG BOARD MEETING HAS BEEN HAPPENING.
6:43 WE ARE WAITING FOR ANY KIND OF SENSE OF WHAT WAS DISCUSSED, ANY
6:46 DECISION-MAKING FROM THE COMPANY.
6:50 >> IF JENSEN HUANG IS FORCED OUT, THIS WOULD BE ONE OF THE
6:51 MOST REMARKABLE CORPORATE DOWNFALLS IN HISTORY.
6:57 THE PROSPECT OF THIS HAPPENING TWO WEEKS AGO WOULD HAVE BEEN --
7:04 WOULD HAVE LEFT PEOPLE I COST -- AGHAST.
7:08 WE CONTINUE TO WATCH ANYTHING THAT COMES OUT FROM THE BOARD
7:11 MEETING AS THEY CONTINUE TO CONSIDER THE FATE OF THE CEO.
7:16 NOW HIS ROLE AS CEO LOOKS UNTENABLE IN TERMS WHAT WE HAVE
7:19 HEARD OF THE SECOND AFFAIR WITH A SENIOR VICE PRESIDENT WHO
7:21 OVERSAW THE HEALTH CARE DIVISION AND CONTINUES TO OVERSEE THE
7:24 HEALTH CARE DIVISION AT NVIDIA ON TOP OF THE ALLEGED AFFAIR
7:28 WITH SOMEONE WHO IS REPORTEDLY A SPY FOR THE CHINESE GOVERNMENT
7:32 SO THERE IS A CALL FOR GOVERNMENT ISSUANCE AND THEN A
7:34 SUCCESSION QUESTION. THERE IS NO SUCCESSION PLAN AT
7:35 NVIDIA. ANNA: DO WE HAVE A SENSE OF WHO
7:42 THEY ARE LOOKING AT? THERE ARE 60 PEOPLE WHO REPORT
7:46 TO NVIDIA ACCORDING TO SOME ANALYSTS -- TO JENSEN HUANG
7:51 ACCORDING TO SOME ANALYSTS WHICH LEAVES THE POINT OPEN OR PERHAPS
7:52 IT IS NARROWING. TOM: IT IS RELATIVELY OPEN.
7:59 THERE IS A SMALL GROUP OF PEOPLE WHO ACTUALLY HAVE THE SKILL SET
8:04 THAT JENSEN HAS IN TERMS OF ENGINEERING AND TECHNICAL
8:06 EXPERTISE AND OPERATIONAL STRATEGY SKILLS THAT HE HAS AND
8:09 THAT VISION. VERY FEW PEOPLE HAVE THAT MIX.
8:12 THE CFO DOES NOT BUT SHE DOES HAVE A TRACK RECORD OF STEERING
8:17 THIS COMPANY SUCCESSFULLY MET CFO SO ABSOLUTELY IN THE MIX,
8:25 POTENTIALLY ON AN INTERIM BASIS BUT SHE DOES NOT HAVE THE
8:27 TECHNICAL ENGINEERING AND PRODUCT EXPERIENCE.
8:32 OTHER NAMES INCLUDE A VICE PRESIDENT OVERSEEING THE DATA
8:33 CENTER BUSINESS AND CHIPS BUSINESS AND THIS SOFTWARE THAT
8:40 HAS BEEN SO INFLUENTIAL IN LOCKING IN CUSTOMERS FOR NVIDIA.
8:41 THOSE ARE TWO NAMES. THIS IS SOMEONE WHO DOES HAVE A
8:48 LOT OF SKILLS BUT HE IS THE CEO OF ARM SO PROBLEMATIC FOR
8:50 SOFTBANK. HE PREVIOUSLY WORKED AT NVIDIA
8:55 AND IF THERE'S ANYONE WHO COMBINES THE SKILL SETS, THAT
8:57 WOULD BE AN INTERESTING CHOICE. ANNA: SO WE WILL WATCH THE
9:01 SUCCESSION CONVERSATIONS REGARDLESS OF WHETHER JENSEN
9:08 HUANG STAYS IN THE TOP POST. LET'S THINK ABOUT WHO COULD
9:09 BENEFIT. WE HAVE SEEN IN PREMARKET
9:13 TRADING SOME OF THE U.S. RIVAL COMPANIES SHARES ARE MOVING
9:18 HIGHER ON EXPECTATION THAT PERHAPS THEY COULD DO GOOD
9:21 BUSINESS WHERE NVIDIA IS DISTRACTED NOW.
9:27 >> THE DISTRACTION LEADS TO SPECULATION THEY WILL NOT HAVE A
9:31 GRIP ON THE SUPPLY CHAIN BEFORE HE HAD THIS BAGGAGE HE IS NOW
9:34 HAVING TO WORK THROUGH SO THE EXPECTATION IS MAYBE WITH A
9:40 CLEAR AROUND THE LIKES OF AMD, WHICH STILL HAS A SMALLER MARKET
9:43 SHARE WHEN IT COMES TO AI ACCELERATORS, COULD BE A
9:46 BENEFICIARY. BROADCOM COULD BE A BENEFICIARY,
9:50 WORKING ON ALTERNATIVE CHIPS THAT COULD PROVE A REPLACEMENT
9:59 ON AI AND THEN ALPHABET, TP USE THEY ARE ALREADY SHIPPING TO
10:01 CUSTOMERS AND THEY COULD BENEFIT SO YOU ARE SEEING UPSIDE THERE.
10:07 IN TERMS OF THE LOSERS, INTEL HAS INVESTMENT FROM NVIDIA.
10:10 THAT STOCK HAS BEEN UNDER PRESSURE DOWN TO THE START UPS
10:14 THAT HAVE BEEN BACKED WITH SOME OF THE FINANCING FROM NVIDIA
10:16 THAT COULD FACE HEADWINDS. ANNA: THIS IS A BUSINESS THAT
10:25 ITS INFLUENCE GOES FAR AND WIDE IN THE AI ROLLOUT.
10:30 ONE OF THE GAS IN THAT CLIP WAS TALKING ABOUT THIS LEADING TO AN
10:32 ACCELERATION IN THE DECOUPLING OF TWO TECH LANDSCAPES BETWEEN
10:36 CHINA AND THE U.S. AND THAT CONVERSATION COMING BEFORE WE
10:38 SEE THE LEADERS OF CHINA THE U.S. MEETING.
10:43 TOM: SHIFTING TO A MORE HAWKISH TAKE ON CHINA AND ITS ABILITY TO
10:48 GET ACCESS ON ANY CHIPS THE U.S. MAKES.
10:49 UNTIL THIS POINT THERE HAD BEEN DEBATE WITHIN THE TRUMP
10:50 ADMINISTRATION AT PRESIDENT TRUMP HAD ALIGNED WITH A
10:54 SLIGHTLY MORE RELAXED FOR YOU IN TERMS OF GETTING SOME SHIPS TO
10:57 CHINA. THAT NEEDLE IS SHIFTING SO YOU
11:01 COULD GET A HARDENING BETWEEN THESE TWO NATIONS OF THAT WILL
11:05 BE INTERESTING TO WATCH AS THE TWO ARE SET TO MEET NEXT WEEK.
11:10 NVIDIA. NOW TO OTHER TOP STORIES
11:16 TRENDING ON THE TERMINAL. STEVE WITKOFF AND JARED KUSHNER
11:20 ARE IN MOSCOW FOR TALKS AS THE U.S. PUSHES FOR A DEAL TO END
11:23 THE WAR IN UKRAINE. THE MEETING FOLLOWS TALKS WITH
11:28 UKRAINIAN AND RUSSIAN OFFICIALS. WYCOFF AND KUSHNER TRAVELED TO
11:30 DUBLIN TO MEET WITH UKRAINIAN PRESIDENT.
11:35 THE U.K. ECONOMY GREW AT ITS FASTEST PACE IN TWO POINT FIVE
11:39 YEARS, HELD BY AI SPENDING. GDP GROWTH ACCELERATED FROM THE
11:44 PREVIOUS QUARTER. CONSUMER SPENDING GROWS MORE
11:48 THAN ECONOMISTS EXPECTED. THE STRONGER GROWTH ADDS
11:50 PRESSURE ON ENGLAND. COREWEAVE PLANS TO RAISE AT
11:56 LEAST $4 BILLION THROUGH INVESTMENT-GRADE BOND SALE.
12:00 SOURCES SAY MORGAN STANLEY AND MITSUBISHI ARE LEADING THE
12:01 POTENTIAL FINANCING. THE DEAL COULD COME AS SOON AS
12:04 NEXT WEEK. REPRESENTATIVES FROM COREWEAVE
12:06 AND MORGAN STANLEY DECLINED TO COMMENT.
12:14 COMING UP, WE WILL CATCH UP WITH BLACKROCK ON THE MARKET FALLOUT
12:17 AND MARKET TURMOIL SURROUNDING NVIDIA, THE MIDTERMS -- HOW WAS
12:22 THIS IS BLOOMBERG. ♪
12:36 >>>> YOU HAVE TO HOLD YOURSELF RESPONSIBLE.
12:39 YOU HAVE TO HAVE HIGH STANDARDS AND EXPECTATIONS.
12:42 I'M RESPONSIBLE FOR AN ENTIRE INDUSTRY.
12:45 SO I THINK THE PRESSURE OF BEING THE CEO IS HIGH AND IT IS
12:48 SUPPOSED TO BE HIGH. JUST AS I CAN BE FIRED, THE NEXT
12:54 CEO HAS TO BE HIRED. YOU ARE ALWAYS VULNERABLE,
12:56 ALWAYS EARNING IT. ANNA: JENSEN HUANG THERE, NVIDIA
13:02 CEO, SPEAKING ALMOST A MONTH AGO TO BLOOMBERG'S EMILY CHANG ABOUT
13:07 THE SUBJECT OF LEADERSHIP AND SUCCESSION.
13:09 THE BOARD OF NVIDIA IS GRAPPLING WITH THE AFTERMATH OF THE
13:12 EXECUTIVE SCANDAL AS INVESTORS WEIGH HOW IT COULD REVERBERATE
13:16 ACROSS THE GLOBAL AI SUPPLY CHAIN.
13:17 LET'S WIDEN THE FOCUS AND BRING IN A GLOBAL CHIEF INVESTMENT
13:21 STRATEGIST AT BLACKROCK. NICE TO HAVE YOU WITH US.
13:26 HELP US THINK ABOUT THE IMPACT OF THE STORY AND WHAT IT DOES TO
13:30 THE AI LANDSCAPE AND UNIVERSE. NVIDIA LED BY JENSEN HUANG HAS
13:35 BEEN A CRUCIAL PART OF THE AI STORY FROM THE EARLY BUILDOUT
13:38 AND EARLY EXCITEMENT AROUND AI TO THE RISE OF THE HYPERSCALERS
13:45 TO CIRCULAR FINANCING TO THE SUPPORT OF STARTUPS IN THE
13:49 INDUSTRY. IT IS A BUSINESS THAT GETS
13:50 EVERYWHERE SO WHAT KIND OF IMPACT DOES THIS HAVE?
13:55 WEI: GOOD QUESTION. MARKERS ARE TRYING TO FIGURE OUT
14:02 IF THIS IS A BROADER STORY GIVEN THE KEYSTONE POSITION NVIDIA
14:05 PLAYS IN THE AI BUILDOUT. IF YOU LOOK AT THE EARLY
14:10 PREMARKET TRADING DAYS, THE DEPENDENT COMPANIES ARE COMING
14:15 UNDER MORE PRESSURE THAN THE DIVERSIFIED HYPERSCALERS AND
14:20 ALTERNATE SUPPLIERS OF CHIPS SO MARKETS WANT TO BE SELECTIVE.
14:25 WHAT I'M PAYING ATTENTION TO IS RISKS OF EXPORT CONTROL BEING
14:29 TALKED ABOUT MORE AS WE LOOK AHEAD BUT IN THE BROADER STORY
14:36 OF AI IS REALLY IF THE AD BILL THAT WOULD CONTINUE APACE SO YOU
14:41 MAY REMEMBER WE DOWNGRADED U.S. EQUITIES FROM OVERWEIGHT TO
14:44 NEUTRAL ABOUT A MONTH AGO AND WE ARE NOT A JUNCTURE FIGURING OUT
14:51 WHAT TO DO NEXT AND INDEED IF AI BUILDOUT WILL CONTINUE AT PACE
14:53 IS KEY TO THE QUESTION BECAUSE A LOT OF THE REVENUES -- THE
14:56 MARKET REVENUES COMING FROM SELLING PEAKS AND TROUBLES BUT
15:02 WE ARE ALSO ENTERING THE FIFTH YEAR OF AI REVOLUTION AND IN
15:06 ADDITION TO SEEING REVENUES FROM SELLING PICKS AND SHOVELS WE
15:11 WANT TO SEE SOME GOLD AND A SHORTAGE OF PIX AND TROUBLES IT
15:13 SAYS NOTHING ABOUT HOW MUCH GOLD THERE IS IN THE GROUND SO I
15:16 THINK THAT TENSION WILL SHAPE AI.
15:21 ANNA: SO THE METAPHOR FOR GOLD IS RETURN ON INVESTMENT FOR
15:24 COMPANIES THAT ACTUALLY ARE GOING TO USE AI.
15:29 WEI: THE AI BUILDERS IN OTHER SECTORS.
15:34 ANNA: WHETHER CAR COMPANIES OR WHOEVER.
15:36 WHERE IS YOUR THINKING AT NOW? DO YOU THINK WE ARE LEANING INTO
15:40 THE PICKS AND SHOVELS OR INTO THOSE COMPANIES USING THE
15:42 TECHNOLOGY THAT IS AI? WEI: RIGHT NOW, PICKS AND
15:49 SHOVELS AND SUPPLIERS ARE THE PART OF THE MARKET SHOWING
15:52 STRONG EARNINGS DELIVERY AND IF YOU LOOK AT EARNINGS SEASON SO
15:57 FAR, A LOT OF COMPANIES TALK ABOUT HOW THEY ARE ADOPTING AI
16:02 BUT A LOT LESS ACTUALLY HAVE MEASURABLE METRICS QUANTIFYING
16:09 AI IMPACTS AND EVEN LESS HAVE QUANTIFIABLE METRICS SHOWING
16:12 PROGRESS SO I THINK WE ARE STILL IN EARLY DAYS IN TERMS OF
16:16 BROADER BASED BOOST AND REVENUE GAIN FROM AI ADOPTION BUT THE
16:25 TENSION IS GOING TO SHIFT TOWARD OUR WE SEE IN GOLD AND WHERE IS
16:28 IT COMING FROM? BECAUSE THE BUILDERS MAY NOT BE
16:32 THE ULTIMATE BENEFICIARIES ESPECIALLY IN THE FACE OF
16:36 COMMODITIZATION RISKS SO THAT IS THE NEXT PHASE OF AI THAT IS
16:40 BECOMING MORE NUANCED AND GRANULAR SO YES.
16:48 ANNA: WHAT IS THE THREAT TO THE AI TRADE?
16:49 A GUEST WAS SAYING WE SEE THE AI TRADE CONTINUING BUT UNTIL THE
16:53 MUSIC STOPS. WE WONDER WHAT MAKES THE MUSIC
16:56 STOPPED. IS IT A HIGHER RATE STORY?
17:01 IS IT REGULATION? IS IT SOMETHING ELSE THAT GETS
17:04 IN THE WAY? IS IT GEOPOLITICAL TENSIONS
17:07 BETWEEN CHINA AND THE U.S.? WHAT COULD GET IN THE WAY OF THE
17:08 AI TRADE? WEI: WE FRAMED THE AI BUILDOUT
17:15 AND AI TRANSFORMATION POTENTIALLY BEING CONSTRAINED BY
17:21 THREE POSSIBLE FACTORS. ONE IS PHYSICAL, ONE IS
17:25 FINANCIAL, ONE IS SOCIAL POLITICAL SO WE HAVE SEEN
17:26 PROGRESS ON ALL FRONTS THIS YEAR AND THE FINANCING CYCLE COULD
17:32 TURN BEFORE THE TECHNOLOGY CYCLE TURNS SO THAT IS DEFINITELY
17:36 SOMETHING THAT IS ON OUR MIND AND AS I SAID EARLIER THINGS ARE
17:41 BECOMING MORE NUANCED AND MORE GRANULAR.
17:42 SO WE ARE SEEING -- EVEN LAST WEEK ONE OF THE MOST DRAMATIC
17:46 MOMENTUM UNWIND WE HAVE SEEN IN YEARS.
17:52 EVEN LAST WEEK THE DIVERSIFIED HYPERSCALERS WERE DOING BETTER
17:55 ON A RELATIVE BASIS IN THE CREDIT SPACE BUT ALSO IN THE
17:59 EQUITY SPACE, GOING TO SHOW THAT EVEN IF WE HAVE A RISK OF SLOW
18:05 AND BUILDOUT IT DOES NOT HURT AI INVESTMENT ACROSS THE BOARD.
18:09 IT IS SUPPLIERS LIKE A HURT MORE THAN SPENDERS SO THIS IS A LOT
18:13 MORE NUANCED PEER AND EVEN IN THE MORE NARROW -- NARROW SLICE
18:19 AT THE AI TRADE, THOSE THAT HAVE DATA CENTERS CONNECTED AND
18:23 ALREADY CASH POSITIVE AND GENERATING REVENUE ARE IN A
18:26 BETTER POSITION THAN THOSE THAT HAVE BUILT A DATA CENTER BUT ARE
18:27 WAITING FOR A PERMIT. SO WE HAVE TO BE MORE SELECTIVE
18:31 ACROSS THE WHOLE UNIVERSE OF AI. ANNA: WHILE WE ARE THINKING
18:36 ABOUT THOSE THINGS, AND FINANCING IS ONE OF THEM, THE
18:40 U.S. 10 YEAR AT 4.99% PURE AND IT HAS BEEN BACK OVER FIVE.
18:43 WHAT ARE YOU EXPECTING NEXT WHEN IT COMES TO THAT COST OF MONEY
18:47 TREASURY LANDSCAPE? THAT WILL INFLUENCE THIS AI
18:50 TRADE. WEI: SO FAR THIS YEAR, THE COST
18:55 OF CAPITAL AND COMPETITION FOR CAPITAL DRIVEN BY AI HAS PUSHED
19:03 UP NEUTRAL RATES HIGHER IN THIS IS DRIVING 10 YEAR YIELDS ON A
19:05 YEAR-TO-DATE BASIS HIGHER THAT IS NOT PREVIOUS SO IT IS THE
19:12 COST OF CAPITAL PUSHING YIELDS HIGHER AND THAT IS HERE TO STAY
19:17 BECAUSE GOVERNMENT IS ISSUING MORE PRIVATE SECTOR LEVERAGE TO
19:22 THE COMPETITION FOR CAPITAL IS COMING FROM ALL ASPECTS OF THE
19:25 ECONOMY RATHER THAN ONE LEVERAGING AFTER THE OTHER PART
19:30 OF THE ECONOMY DELEVERAGING SO THAT IS HERE TO STAY AND RATES
19:33 ARE HIGHER FOR LONGER IN TERMS OF POLICY RATES.
19:36 AS A LOOK BACK ON MARKETS, FISCAL IS THE DOG THAT DID NOT
19:38 BARK. RIGHT NOW, 70 BASIS POINTS IS
19:44 THE SAME LEVEL AS THE BEGINNING OF THE YEARS'S THAT HAS NOT
19:48 REPRICED SO THERE IS A RISK AS I LOOK AHEAD TO GOVERNMENT BONDS
19:51 INTO NEXT YEAR. HAVING SAID THAT, YOU MAY
19:58 REMEMBER ONE MONTH AGO WE UPGRADED U.S. TREASURY IS ON THE
20:01 FRONT END FROM NEUTRAL TO OVERWEIGHT AND ON THE BACK END
20:04 FROM UNDERWEIGHT TO NEUTRAL AND OUR BACK END UNDERWEIGHT HAS
20:05 BEEN IN PLACE FOR ALMOST SIX YEARS.
20:09 WE HAVE DOWNGRADED LONG ANTI-TREASURY.
20:13 WHEN 10 YEAR WAS BELOW 90 BASIS POINT AND WE UPGRADED IT SO WE
20:16 THINK THAT INCOME IS ATTRACTIVE. ANNA: THANK YOU VERY MUCH, WEI
20:22 LI OF BLACKROCK. MORE ON NVIDIA NEXT.
20:24 ♪ ANNA: NVIDIA ISANNA: DOMINATING
20:33 THE FRONT PAGE IS WHAT YOUR OTHER STORIES IN THE HEADLINE.
20:38 DEMOCRAT SCOTT COLUMN -- COLOM HAS WON IN MISSISSIPPI.
20:46 RECONSTRUCTION. NO DEMOCRAT HAS WON A U.S.
20:52 SENATE ELECTION THERE SINCE 1982.
20:55 SIX PEOPLE WERE KILLED AND 20 INJURED IN AN ISRAELI STRIKE IN
21:00 SOUTHERN GAZA ACCORDING TO THE CAUSE OF CIVIL DEFENSE.
21:04 ISRAEL SAYS IT TARGETED A SENIOR HAMAS TERRORISTS.
21:05 A WITNESS SAYS A SURGEON AND HE DISABLED PATIENT WERE AMONG
21:09 THOSE KILLED. WE WILL BE BACK SHORTLY.
21:12 ♪ ANNA: 5:30 AM IN NEW YORK CITY,
21:31 GOOD MORNING EVERYBODY. I'M IN EDWARDS WITH YOUR
21:34 BLOOMBERG BRIEF. LET'S COULD YOU SET UP FOR THE
21:35 DAY AHEAD. NVIDIA'S BOARD GATHERS TO
21:40 CONSIDER JENSEN HUANG'S FUTURE OVER A SECOND ALLEGED EXTRA FAIR
21:47 RUMORS EMERGE. CHINESE AI STOCKS DROP WHILE
21:50 POTENTIAL BENEFICIARIES GAIN. THE SAGA RAISES QUESTIONS OVER
21:56 U.S. CHINA TRADE RELATIONS AT OF THE TRUMP XI JINPING SUMMIT
21:57 LATER THIS MONTH. LET'S CHECK OUT U.S. FUTURES
22:02 AHEAD OF THE START OF U.S. TRADING.
22:03 FUTURES ARE WEAKER. WE COULD SEE OTHER PARTS OF THE
22:10 U.S. TECH LANDSCAPE GAINING ESPECIALLY THOSE SAID TO BE
22:14 BENEFICIARIES OF DIFFICULTIES OR DISTRACTION OVER AT NVIDIA.
22:18 LET'S GET MORE ON YOUR STOCKS TO WATCH WITH OLIVIA.
22:24 OLIVIA: NOWHERE ELSE TO START BUT WITH NVIDIA.
22:28 THE BOARD MEETING TO DISCUSS POTENTIAL SUCCESSION PLANS.
22:32 THE PRIMARY REASON WHY IT'S BEING SENT DOWN.
22:37 NO ONE KNOWS WHO COULD POSSIBLY REPLACE JENSEN HUANG RIGHT NOW.
22:40 WHAT'S BEING FLOATED IS POTENTIALLY THE CFO COULD TAKE
22:44 OVER AS INTERIM CEO IN THE MEANTIME BUT THERE'S A LOT OF
22:48 CONCERN ABOUT HOW THE COMPANY COULD POSSIBLY MOVE FORWARD
22:49 WITHOUT JENSEN. IT'S NOT DOOM AND GLOOM FOR
22:56 EVERYBODY, T NVIDIA COMPETITORS ARE HIGHER IN PREMARKET TRADING.
23:00 WITH HOPES THEY COULD MAYBE SIPHON OFF SOME OF THE MARKET
23:03 SHARE FROM NVIDIA. EARNINGS ARE HAPPENING IN THE
23:05 BACKGROUND OF ALL OF THIS. DOWN AFTER PREMARKET TRADING
23:11 AFTER CUTTING GUIDANCE ON RESULTS IN BRAZIL.
23:15 A SOLID FOURTH QUARTER RESULTS. ANNA: LET'S CHECK IN ON NVIDIA.
23:23 SHARE SET TO OPEN AT THEIR LOWEST IN OVER A YEAR AFTER THE
23:28 BOARD HAS BEEN MEETING TO DISCUSS JENSEN HUANG'S FUTURE.
23:32 GOOD MORNING. WE ARE WAITING LET'S START WITH
23:37 JENSEN HUANG'S FUTURE. WE DON'T KNOW WHERE THIS TAKES
23:38 US YET. MEETING TO DISCUSS WHO COULD
23:45 TAKE OVER, UNDERSCORED THE IMPORTANCE OF THIS MATTER.
23:50 TO THE BROADER AI LANDSCAPE HAS BEEN REALLY INFLUENTIAL.
23:54 MATT: WE HAVE KIND OF SHARED A LOT OF THIS WITH THE AUDIENCE
24:00 ABOUT THE CENTRAL NVIDIA PLAYS TO THE INDUSTRY NOT JUST IN
24:02 TERMS OF THE COMMERCIAL SIDE OF IT BUT ALSO THE FINANCING OF IT.
24:05 THIS COULD POTENTIALLY HAVE A SIGNIFICANT IMPLICATIONS FOR THE
24:11 WHOLE INDUSTRY AND -- OF A NEWCOMER COMES IN AND DECIDES
24:15 FOR SOME OF THE OPTIONS THAT JENSEN HUANG HAS MADE REALLY A
24:19 VERY SIGNIFICANT DECISION NOT JUST ABOUT THE COMPANY BUT THE
24:22 WIDER RAMIFICATIONS FOR THE INDUSTRY.
24:27 ANNA: THIS BUSINESS SUPPORTED SMALLER STARTUPS BUT IS ALSO A
24:30 BUSINESS THAT IS USED ITS BALANCE SHEET AS A SERVICE.
24:34 USING TO DESCRIBE WHAT NVIDIA WAS PREPARED TO DO FOR THESE
24:37 CUSTOMERS WHO MAY BE NEEDED A LITTLE BIT OF HELP TO WARM UP TO
24:40 BUY MORE NVIDIA CHIPS. THAT WIDENS THE LENS WITH NVIDIA
24:42 INSTANTLY. >> NVIDIA'S INVESTED IN THE BIG
24:49 ONES AS WELL SO IT REALLY IS AN INTRICATELY INTERCONNECTED
24:50 INDUSTRY. I THINK A COUPLE OF DAYS I
24:57 SHARED THE VIEW IT WOULD TAKE SOMETHING QUITE SIGNIFICANT FOR
24:59 THE BOARD TO MOVE TO OUST JENSEN SO YOU HAVE TO ASSUME THERE'S A
25:05 LOT THERE THAT THEY ARE HAVING TO GET THEIR HANDS AROUND.
25:08 THEY KNOW THE IMPORTANCE OF HIM TO THE BUSINESS AND THAT
25:11 FIDUCIARY DUTY TO DO THE RIGHT THING FOR THE COMPANY SO I THINK
25:14 IT'S A VERY DIFFICULT DECISION THEY HAVE TO MAKE.
25:19 ANNA: SOMEBODY SO CRUCIAL TO THE REINVENTION OF NVIDIA FROM THE
25:24 WHAT DO WE MAKE OF THE PEOPLE WHO COULD BENEFIT OR WHO COULD
25:30 SUCCEED JENSEN HUANG IF HE GOES WE STILL DON'T KNOW.
25:33 MATT: IT'S HARD TO NARROW IT DOWN TO ANY SPECIFIC
25:37 INDIVIDUALS. THIS CLEARLY MORE THAN
25:40 INCREDIBLY CAPABLE PEOPLE THAT KNOW THE INDUSTRY PROBABLY AS
25:46 WELL SO I THINK AGAIN A DIFFICULT CHOICE FOR THE BOARD
25:52 TO KIND OF MAKE THE RIGHT CHOICE IT BECOMES A LITTLE BIT THE
25:55 INDUSTRY IF THE ABOUT MANCHESTER UNITED YOU HAVE ONE REALLY
26:00 DOMINANT SUCCESSFUL FIGURE AND THEN PERHAPS IT TAKES A LONG
26:04 TIME TO KIND OF FIND SOMEBODY SO A DECISION THERE.
26:08 ANNA: NOT A METAPHOR THEY WANT TO LEAN INTO.
26:11 THANK YOU VERY MUCH MATT BLOXHAM.
26:13 THANK YOU FOR THE INSIGHTS. LET'S CONTINUE WITH THE STORY
26:14 FROM A DIFFERENT ANGLE. JOINING US TO TALK ABOUT THE
26:20 IMPLICATIONS FOR U.S. CHINA RELATIONS.
26:22 ALL OF THESE REVELATIONS, JUST AHEAD OF THIS MEETING BETWEEN
26:26 TRUMP AND XI JINPING NEXT WEEK. I WONDER HOW THIS WEIGHS IN THIS
26:29 STORY CONTRIBUTES AND HOW IT SETS THE STAGE.
26:35 >> THE TIMING IS VERY AWKWARD GIVEN WE'VE GOT THIS MEETING
26:38 COMING UP BETWEEN XI JINPING AND DONALD TRUMP IN CHINA IT'S
26:42 AWKWARD FOR BOTH OF THEM AT THE CENTER OF ALL OF THIS IS ALLEGED
26:48 TO BE A SPY FOR CHINA AND AT THE SAME TIME JENSEN HUANG HAS BEEN
26:50 VERY CLOSE FRIEND OF THE U.S. PRESIDENT AND PUSHING VERY
26:54 AGGRESSIVELY TO HAVE GREATER ACCESS TO THE CHINESE MARKET.
26:58 HOW THEY NAVIGATE ALL OF THAT WHEN THEY CHAT.
27:04 OUR XI JINPING PRESENTS THE ACCOUNTING PARTICULAR ISSUE OF
27:06 THE APEC SUMMIT AS THE HOST IN CHINA HE WANTS TO BE AGENDA AND
27:13 SHOWCASING CHINA TO THE WORLD. HE WANTS TO BE APPEARING AS A
27:17 STATESMANLIKE LEADER DEALING WITH THE FALLOUT OF NVIDIA.
27:22 SO HOW HE MANAGES TO KEEP THAT ON THE AGENDA REMAINS TO BE SEEN
27:26 AND HOW IT DOESN'T BLEED INTO THE CONVERSATIONS BETWEEN XI AND
27:32 TRUMP FOR THE OVERALL TRADE RELATIONSHIP QUESTIONING WHETHER
27:33 THIS TRADE TRUCE WILL BE EXTENDED AGAIN IN THE NEW YEAR.
27:39 THERE ARE CHALLENGES ALREADY AROUND THAT RELATIONSHIP IS A
27:43 CAN BRING FRESH PRESSURE ON THAT TRADE TRUCE ANOTHER QUESTION OF
27:47 SECURITY AROUND TECHNOLOGY AND SO ON IS THAT GOING TO BE A
27:50 PROBLEM IN THOSE DISCUSSIONS. FOR DONALD TRUMP BRINGING THESE
27:57 ISSUES WITH HIM TO CHINA AND THE QUESTIONS ARE ON HIS
27:58 RELATIONSHIP AND DOMESTIC PRESSURE THAT WILL COUNT ON
28:02 DONALD TRUMP TO TAKE A TIGHTER STANCE WHEN IT COMES TO CHINA.
28:09 >> JOINING US WITH A GEOPOLITICAL ANGLE OF THE NVIDIA
28:12 STORY. LET'S SWITCH GEARS WE HEAD OVER
28:16 TO TURKEY AS REPRESENTATIVES FROM 200 NATIONS CONVENING FOR
28:20 THE U.N. CLIMATE CHANGE CONFERENCE.
28:20 THE U.S. IS NOTABLY ABSENT. JOINING US NOW FROM COP 31.
28:31 >> THANKS SO MUCH. THE U.N. SECRETARY GENERAL
28:34 YESTERDAY AT THE BEGINNING OF THE WORLD TODAY SUMMIT SAID THE
28:40 PLANNING WAS ON A PATH AND MUTUALLY ASSURED PATH TO
28:44 DESTRUCTION JOINING ME TO TALK A LITTLE BIT MORE ABOUT THE
28:46 DISCUSSIONS THAT HE IS HAVING RIGHT NOW DURING THE LEADERSHIP.
28:54 THANK YOU SO MUCH FOR YOUR TIME. THERE IS SO MUCH THAT'S HAPPENED
28:59 IN THE LAST FEW MONTHS OF YOUR MANDATE THERE'S GEOPOLITICAL
29:02 TENSIONS, THERE IS AN ENERGY CRISIS THERE IS AN ENERGY CRISIS
29:05 THERE'S AI THAT'S DOMINATING THE BUILD OUT IN ELECTRICITY
29:07 CONVERSATION. HOW DO YOU SEE THIS CURRENT
29:11 MOMENT AND YOUR OWN MANDATE AT THIS POINT?
29:15 >> IT SEEMS TO BE A PERFECT STORM COMBINATION OF
29:20 GEOPOLITICAL DIVIDES AND WITH THE MULTIPLICATION OF CONFLICTS
29:23 AND WITH TWO MEASURED CONFLICTS THAT REPRESENT AN ENORMOUS
29:29 THREAT TO THE WORLD AS A WHOLE, UKRAINE RUSSIA WAR AND THE
29:35 SEMI-WAR SEMI-PEACE BETWEEN THE U.S. AND IRAN AND ALL THIS
29:44 COMBINES WITH THE ACCELERATION OF THE RISKS OF CLIMATE CHANGE
29:51 AND WITH THE FACT THAT WE REMAIN WITH DEVELOPMENTS OF ARTIFICIAL
29:53 INTELLIGENCE WITHOUT ANY KIND OF CONTROL OVER SITES ALL OF THIS
29:59 CIRCUMSTANCES COMING TOGETHER CREATE AN ENORMOUS RISK FIRST
30:03 GLOBAL SOCIETY. MORE THAN EVER FOR COUNTRIES TO
30:12 UNDERSTAND THAT WE NEED TO RESPECT INTERNATIONAL LAW.
30:17 WE NEED TO TAKE SERIOUSLY THE EXISTENTIAL THREATS OF CLIMATE
30:22 CHANGE AND OF ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE.
30:27 AND THAT WE NEED TO RESPECT SOLUTIONS.
30:31 JENNIFER: DO YOU SEE THIS AS A TURNING POINT IN MULTILATERALISM
30:33 CONSIDERING THE RISKS THAT ARE OVERHANGING THIS NOW.
30:37 ANTONIO: IT'S AN OPPORTUNITY THE REFORM BECAUSE ALL THOSE
30:44 INSTITUTIONS THE POLICY THE UNITED NATIONS.
30:49 THERE WERE CREATED IN THE 1945. AND THEY WERE CREATED WITH THAT
30:57 CONVERSATION AND WITH THE SET OF RESPONSIBILITIES THAT
31:01 CORRESPONDED TO THE PROBLEMS OF THAT PERSON THERE ARE FIVE
31:11 PERMANENT MEMBERS, EUROPE IS NOT SO IMPORTANT THAT IT TRULY 3/5
31:16 OF THE VETO POWER WITHIN IT. AND IF YOU LOOK AT THE SYSTEM,
31:27 THE QUOTAS ARE THE PARTS OF CAPITAL COUNTRIES BUT WHEN WE
31:31 SEE THE EMERGING ECONOMIES THAT'S GOING VERY FAST IT IS
31:37 CLEAR THERE UNDERREPRESENTED. TO ADDRESS THE ENORMOUS
31:43 CHALLENGES TODAY. THESE REFORMS ARE ESSENTIAL.
31:52 IT IS -- AND THE GOAL OF THE REFORMS IS TO ADAPT THOSE TO THE
31:56 DESK TO MAKE THEM REPRESENTATIVE TODAY AND WITH THE PROBLEMS OF
31:59 TODAY. JENNIFER: TWO OF THE BIGGEST WE
32:04 DON'T HAVE THE LEADERS HERE. FROM THE VERY TOP, THE U.S. IS
32:11 PULLED OUT OF THE PARIS AGREEMENT, CHINA HAS
32:13 REPRESENTATION HERE BUT THE HEAD OF STATE -- NOT THE HEAD OF
32:17 STATE. HOW DO YOU SEE THE U.S. EVOLVING
32:22 AS POTENTIALLY A LEADER IN THIS ONGOING FIGHT AGAINST CLIMATE
32:26 AND REALLY SAVING MULTILATERALISM IF THEY CAN.
32:30 ANTONIO: I THINK THE U.S. IS NOT THE U.S. GOVERNMENT.
32:35 THE U.S. IS A MARKET ECONOMY AND OBVIOUSLY THE ORIENTATION HAS
32:44 BEEN CONTRARY TO THE NEED TO BE VERY EFFECTIVE IN CLIMATE --
32:47 FIGHTING CLIMATE CHANGE. THE MARKET HAS DEMONSTRATED THAT
32:53 TODAY, RENEWABLE ENERGY IS CHEAPER RENEWABLE ENERGY IS MORE
33:01 PROFITABLE AND IT IS SAFER ESPECIALLY WHEN IT COMES TO THE
33:07 MIDDLE EAST TO THE EXCESS MORE DIFFICULT AND THE PRICES ARE
33:09 EXTREMELY HIGH. FOR REASONS OF SECURITY AND
33:17 ECONOMY AND NOT ONLY FOR THE QUESTIONS OF ENVIRONMENT OR
33:21 CLIMATE CHANGE, WE SEE THE PRIVATE SECTOR IN THE U.S.
33:26 CLEARLY MORE AND MORE INVESTING IN RENEWABLES AND WE SEE MORE
33:31 GOVERNORS AND MORE AND MORE PLAYERS COMMITTED TO THAT.
33:36 I HOPE THE UNITED STATES AS A WHOLE WILL BECOME AGAIN AN
33:37 IMPORTANT PART. JENNIFER: DO YOU THINK THE U.S.
33:41 GOVERNMENT HAS LOST ITS CREDIBILITY IF IT DECIDES TO GO
33:43 BACK TO THE PARIS AGREEMENT. ANTONIO: WE WANT THE U.S. AND
33:49 THE PARIS AGREEMENT, WE WANT ALL COUNTRIES IN THE PARIS
33:50 AGREEMENT. JENNIFER: HAS THE CREDIBILITY
33:54 LOST AT THIS POINT? ANTONIO: THE FACT THAT THE WEST
34:02 TO THE PARIS AGREEMENT WOULD MEAN THE U.S. WILL RECOGNIZE THE
34:08 NEED TO ADDRESS CLIMATE CHANGE AS A MAJOR THREAT TO THE WORLD
34:09 TODAY. JENNIFER: I WANT TO TALK ABOUT
34:13 THE PRIVATE SECTOR BECAUSE YOU SPECIFICALLY TARGETED FOSSIL
34:19 FUEL LOBBYISTS AND SPECIFICALLY THEIR WORK HERE AT COP BUT
34:23 YESTERDAY YOU WERE TALKING ABOUT THE FACT THE WORLD'S NINE
34:28 LARGEST OIL COMPANIES COMBINED MADE 95 BILLION DOLLARS IN
34:29 PROFITS. WE ARE STILL WAITING FOR
34:32 DEVELOPING ECONOMIES TO GET SOME OF THEIR OWN LOST IN DAMAGE
34:33 FRONT. HOW DO YOU SEE THIS LOSS AND
34:38 DAMAGE FUND REALLY WORKING. HOW DO YOU -- HOW COULD IT MORE
34:41 EFFECTIVE. >> YOU SPOKE ABOUT $95 BILLION
34:49 IN PROFITS OF NINE COMPANIES. WE'VE HAVE 600 MILLION, THIS
34:55 LOOKS LIKE A JOKE. AND WHAT FOR ME IS MORE
35:02 DIFFICULT TO UNDERSTAND NOT ONLY FROM A POLITICAL POINT OF VIEW
35:07 AND A MARKET POINT OF VIEW BUT EVEN FROM A MORAL POINT OF VIEW
35:11 THAT YOU HAVE EVERYBODY IN THE WORLD PAYING HIGH PRICES FOR ALL
35:23 OIL AND GAS PRODUCTS, AND AT THE SAME TIME WITH A SACRIFICE THAT
35:32 IS SHARED ALL OVER THE WORLD, THIS STABILITY WE SEE
35:35 DEMONSTRATIONS IN THE STREETS, PROTESTING THE GOVERNMENT
35:41 BECAUSE THE PRICES OF THE FUEL. AND AT THE SAME TIME NINE
35:47 COMPANIES HAVE 95 BILLION DOLLARS OF PROFITS.
35:50 SOMETHING FUNDAMENTALLY FROM THE MORAL POINT OF VIEW THE
35:56 SITUATION AND ESPECIALLY BECAUSE NOT ONLY ARE THEY MAKING THESE
35:59 PROFITS BUT THEY ARE MAKING THESE PROFITS WITH INACTIVITY --
36:06 WITH AN ACTIVITY CAUSING SEVERE DAMAGE TO THE GLOBAL ENVIRONMENT
36:12 AND SEVERE DAMAGE IN THE ACCELERATION OF CLIMATE CHANGE.
36:14 JENNIFER: HAVE YOU BEEN ABLE TO TALK TO THEM ABOUT THE SO CALLED
36:16 THE WINDFALL TAX. ANTONIO: I SEE IT IS OBVIOUS
36:22 THAT WE HAVE PROFITS OF THIS NATURE CREATED IN THE SITUATIONS
36:24 THE ARTIFICIAL SITUATIONS BUT WE HAVE TODAY THERE SHOULD BE TAXES
36:33 ON RECORD PROFITS AND THOSE SHOULD BE USED TO ALLEVIATE THE
36:34 SITUATION OF THOSE WHO ARE SUFFERING MORE IN THE SITUATION.
36:40 JENNIFER: HAVE YOU HAD DISCUSSIONS WITH THAT.
36:46 ANTONIO: WITH THE COMPANIES IT'S DIFFICULT TO DISCUSS THESE
36:49 TIME. ANTONIO: ALL THE MECHANISM STATE
37:04 POLITICAL DECISION. JENNIFER: MAYBE WE FINISH ON AI
37:10 BECAUSE YOU HAVE A CONCERN ABOUT SOME OF THE BUILDOUT OF AI.
37:15 DO YOU POTENTIALLY SEE OPPORTUNITIES FOR SOME OF THE
37:17 COMPANIES THAT ARE BUILDING OUT THE AI INFRASTRUCTURE TO ALSO
37:22 CONTRIBUTE TO SOME OF THE FUNDS TALKING ABOUT DAMAGE AND THE
37:23 LIKE. >> THE MOST IMPORTANT QUESTION
37:31 NOW IS TO GUARANTEE AI SERVES PEOPLE THAT AI CREATES CHANCES
37:41 OF WHICH ALL COUNTRIES OF THE WORLD CAN BENEFIT BECAUSE THERE
37:46 ARE ENORMOUS POTENTIAL IN ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE.
37:49 I HAVE A POSITIVE VISION ABOUT THE ROLE OF ARTIFICIAL
37:55 INTELLIGENCE IN THE REALIZATION IN THE ECONOMIC GROWTH, IN
38:00 BETTER EDUCATION AND BETTER HOUSING MANY OTHER ASPECTS.
38:05 BUT IT'S ALSO TRUE WE HAVE SEEN AI BEING USED FOR NEGATIVE
38:11 PURPOSES, SPREADING HATE, FACILITATING THE WORK OF
38:19 ENTITIES THIS ALREADY COMES FROM THE INTERNET FROM THE BEGINNING
38:23 SO IT'S NOT NEW WITH AI. BUT NOW WE HAVE A NEW PROBLEM
38:30 WHICH IS IN THE FRONTIER EVEN THOSE DEVELOPING AI PRODUCTS ARE
38:34 NOT SURE IF THEY ARE RELIABLE AND THEY ARE NOT SURE IF THEY
38:41 MIGHT OR NOT BE A THREAT TO HUMAN LIFE.
38:44 THIS IS SOMETHING THAT I BELIEVE REQUIRES THAT SOMETHING IS DONE
38:49 TO MAKE SURE THAT WE CAN BELIEVE THESE SYSTEMS ARE SAFE.
38:56 AND I ADVOCATE FOR MULTILATERAL SYSTEM OF OVERSIGHT OF THE
39:06 SAFETY RESOURCES THAT AI CAN CREATE AND I BELIEVE IT IS IN
39:10 THE INTEREST OF THE COMPANY'S TO MAKE SURE THEY THEY ARE LIMITED
39:17 BECAUSE IT'S ALSO THE GUARANTEE OF THEM BECAUSE IF THE COMPANIES
39:24 LOSE CONTROL OF PRODUCT THEY WILL NOT BE ABLE TO MAKE WITH
39:27 THOSE PRODUCTS. JENNIFER: WE KNOW YOU'RE BUSY
39:35 OVER THE NEXT TWO WEEKS, THANK YOU SO MUCH FOR YOUR TIME.
39:39 YOU AND SECRETARY GENERAL ANTONIO GUTERRES JOINING US AT
39:41 COP 31 IN TURKEY. ANNA: BLOOMBERG'S JENNIFER
39:48 ZABASAJJA THANK YOU VERY MUCH. THIS IS BLOOMBERG.
39:49 ♪ ANNA: THIS IS BLOOMBERG BRIEF.
39:58 WELCOME BACK U.S. ENVOYS STEVE WITKOFF AND JARED KUSHNER
40:00 ARRIVED IN MOSCOW TO MEET WITH PRESIDENT PUTIN AS WASHINGTON
40:03 PUSHES FOR RUSSIA UKRAINE PEACE DEAL.
40:06 JOINING US AS OLIVER CROOK. UKRAINE IS A STORY IN A PART OF
40:10 THE WORLD THE FEATURES VERY HEAVILY WHERE YOU ARE IN DUBLIN.
40:16 OLIVER: WE ARE HERE THE EUROPEAN POLITICAL COMMUNITY WHICH IS THE
40:20 LARGEST SORT OF FORMAT OF EUROPEAN LEADERS MEETING HERE IN
40:24 DUBLIN WATCHING FILE IN TO PREPARE FOR THESE TALKS AND IT
40:27 SEEMS THE CENTER OF THE DISCUSSIONS FOR THE SUMMIT WILL
40:30 BE UKRAINE. WE'VE HEARD IT FROM A NUMBER OF
40:33 DIFFERENT PEOPLE OVER THE LAST COUPLE OF WEEKS, THERE ARE BEEN
40:37 SO MANY MOVING PARTS, THE FINANCING FOR UKRAINE.
40:41 THE DEATH COUNT IN RUSSIA TALKING ABOUT THE ECONOMIC
40:43 SITUATION IN RUSSIA. THE MIDTERM ELECTIONS IN THE
40:47 UNITED STATES ALL OF THESE MOVING PIECES SEEM TO BE OPENING
40:50 SOME WINDOWS OF OPPORTUNITY IS THE TERM FOR THESE NEGOTIATIONS
40:55 TO BRING THIS WAR AT LEAST CLOSER TO AN END AND THAT'S THE
41:00 AMBITION THAT THE U.S. ENVOYS ARE TRYING TO UNDERTAKE AS THEY
41:03 MEET WITH VLADIMIR PUTIN RIGHT NOW IN MOSCOW.
41:06 WHAT WE EXPECT IS FOR STEVE WITKOFF AND JARED KUSHNER TO
41:10 COME OVER THE DUBLIN. MAYBE THIS EVENING OR MAYBE
41:13 TOMORROW AND FURTHER SOME OF THOSE DISCUSSIONS WITH THE
41:15 EUROPEANS AND VALLARTA ZELENSKYY.
41:19 THE TWO MAIN ISSUES, ONE IS THE QUESTION OF TERRITORIAL
41:20 CONCESSIONS. BUT DOES NOT SEEM TO BE ANY SORT
41:24 OF PROGRESS ON THAT AND A QUESTION ABOUT WHAT THE SECURITY
41:25 ARRANGEMENTS MIGHT BE GOING FORWARD.
41:28 THE RUSSIANS LIKELY DIAL BACK NATO.
41:32 THEY WOULD LIKE FORCES TO BE PULLED FROM THE EASTERN FLANK.
41:35 IF THERE IS A SEAT AT THE TABLE FOR THE EUROPEANS AND IF SO, WHO
41:39 WILL OCCUPY THAT SEAT AND THAT SOMETHING LEADERS WOULD LIKE TO
41:42 MAKE PROGRESS FOR TO COME UP WITH A NAME TO SPEAK FOR EUROPE.
41:50 ANNA: OLIVER CROOK IN DUBLIN THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
41:52 GETTING YOU SET UP FOR YOUR DAY UP NEXT.
42:08 ANNA: NOW I LOOK AT WHAT'S AHEAD TODAY.
42:11 JOBLESS CLAIMS 8:30 EASTERN TIME FOLLOWED BY FED SPEAK INCLUDING
42:15 HAMMOCK, DAILY. CEREBRAS AND CISCO EARNINGS
42:20 AFTER THE CLOSE. WE WILL FOCUS ON TECHNOLOGY.
42:24 THAT'S A QUICK LOOK AT WHERE WE ARE.
42:27 NVIDIA PREMARKET DOWN THAT HAS NOT GOTTEN ANY WORSE SINCE WE
42:32 STARTED TRADING IN THE LONDON SESSION.
42:33 WE LOOK AHEAD TO THE U.S. SESSION WITH FUTURES ON THE
42:37 NASDAQ POINTING LOWER. NVIDIA WILL BE A WEAK SPOT.
42:40 GOOD TO BE OTHER COMPANIES THAT LOOKED TO GAIN FROM THE
42:44 DISTRACTIONS CURRENTLY TAKING PLACE AT NVIDIA AS WE WAIT TO
42:45 HEAR FROM THE NVIDIA BOARD. SURVEILLANCE IS NEXT, THIS IS
42:48 BLOOMBERG.
Nvidia CEO Out — 10 Stocks To Buy Before S&P 500 Hits 8,000 full transcript
0:00 Joining me now, Robert Schein chief investment
0:02 officer of Blanke Schein Wealth Management. Robert, great
0:03 to have you here at the good.
0:05 To be with you.
0:06 All right. So big day today. And Jensen Huang
0:09 is out. And Nvidia (NVDA) the stock was
0:12 plunging down about 5% right now. Do you look
0:14 at this as a temporary leadership shakeup or
0:17 is the fundamental story changing for Nvidia (NVDA) here.
0:20 Well let's be honest. This is as a month
0:23 ago, the largest company in the world. Right. So
0:26 this isn't a little story. This is the story.
0:29 And so what we're seeing today, especially with
0:32 the market basically trading down. And Nvidia (NVDA), it's
0:35 a market clearing event for the stock because there's
0:38 a lot that still is going to come out.
0:41 We believe that on the stepping down wood Jensen
0:44 did was the right thing to do. Because where
0:46 there's smoke, there's fire and this thing is going
0:49 to get drawn out further and further. So to
0:52 for the for the greater good of the company
0:55 moving forward. There's 42,000 employees. Again, the most valuable
0:58 company at the core of the AI buildout I
1:01 think unfortunately, as as terrible as this whole situation
1:04 has been playing out right now, live real time.
1:07 You can't make this up. This is like a made
1:10 for TV movie, unfortunately. But that being said, for the
1:13 greater good of the company, and the guidance moving forward,
1:16 it's a market clearing event and investors, if you're not.
1:19 And I couldn't imagine most, if not all have exposure
1:22 by way of the indices or the individual stock itself.
1:25 But yeah, it's giving investors a ride for
1:27 their money right now. So it's interesting.
1:30 It's a market clearing event. Do you look
1:33 at Nvidia (NVDA) more than 30% off the
1:35 highs as a huge buying opportunity though. Or
1:38 is this a turning point for the company.
1:40 You know I think the leadership succession plan that they
1:44 have in place right now, is Nvidia (NVDA). Nvidia
1:48 (NVDA) is going to be fine moving forward. There obviously
1:52 Jensen is hard to replace. He made a lot
1:56 of those deals one on one handshake. And ultimately with
2:00 Jensen was is access right as we're finding out. So
2:04 those that had front of the line access really
2:07 put their company at a competitive advantage for the chips.
2:11 Right. They're jumping the line. They're getting the most
2:14 needed in the eye trade. Moving forward I think
2:17 it's going to be level setting and it's going
2:19 to be more for other companies. It's going to
2:22 be more of a competitive environment, I think
2:25 more of a sort of a natural environment. If
2:27 you're asking about the demand, we're going to find
2:30 out about that about 109 billion next, next week.
2:32 And in terms of what they're supposed to be
2:35 reporting, we expect that to be guided up to
2:38 about 125 billion. So as an opportunity for investors,
2:41 if you don't own it moving forward, I still
2:44 believe it's one of the best stories in
2:47 the AI play moving forward. And let's be honest,
2:50 we're still at the early stages, the first or
2:53 second inning of this great industrial revolution build out.
2:56 So do you buy here or
2:57 do you wait until earnings next week?
2:59 If you're interested in a roller coaster ride, you
3:02 buy it here, right? Because traditionally and historically
3:05 in Wall Street, when you have that negative headline
3:07 as you're seeing today, moving forward again, the market
3:10 clearing event, as I referred to moving forward, that
3:13 has been the time to buy. If you're
3:16 really taking a look at the Nvidia (NVDA) today.
3:19 We're also seeing a pop though in shares
3:21 of Broadcom (AVGO) and AMD (AMD), some of Nvidia
3:24 (NVDA)'s biggest competitors. If you could only buy one
3:26 of those here, which one would it be?
3:29 Broadcom (AVGO) is the one to go with right
3:32 now the strongest position. But then AMD (AMD) is a
3:35 close second. So those are going to be sort
3:37 of the byproducts of this shakeout in this fall
3:40 out of Nvidia (NVDA) again next week. We're going
3:43 to see on the earnings. Are there going to be
3:46 any cancellations for these chips? I don't believe so.
3:48 But they would be the beneficiaries
3:50 Broadcom (AVGO) and AMD (AMD).
3:51 Number one and two over Nvidia (NVDA).
3:53 Or if you could if you were
3:55 choosing between the three which would go.
3:56 With Broadcom (AVGO) today. Just because if you're staying away
3:59 from the headlines and you have some certainty there.
4:01 You talk about succession planning. We know Colette Kress
4:04 the CFO, is stepping in as interim CEO.
4:06 President Trump just weighed in on Truth Social, saying
4:09 that former Apple (AAPL) CEO Tim Cook is the
4:12 man for the job. Do you agree? I
4:14 think what's the likelihood that Tim Cook stepped in?
4:17 I am so underqualified to answer that question. I
4:20 think most are, I'm surprised that even President Trump
4:23 or not surprised that he's weighing in on that.
4:26 All right. So Nvidia (NVDA) is part of
4:29 the Dow the Nasdaq and the S&P 500.
4:32 It's off more than 30% from the highs. As
4:34 I said is this a market that can
4:37 move higher if Nvidia (NVDA) remains a laggard.
4:40 It already has. And we're seeing the good news
4:43 is if you look at the S&P 500, even
4:46 this last quarter, over 80% of the companies have
4:50 reported to date, in about a 31% increase in earnings.
4:53 And it's not just from the technology sector, the
4:56 sector itself, the broadening out from all the other
5:00 sectors. Obviously, energy is leading the charge this year.
5:03 But industrials, health care, financials, once we get
5:06 a handle on interest rates I think there's
5:10 a lot of opportunity. But the earnings underlying this
5:13 market are really the bedrock and they're increasing.
5:16 But it wasn't all that long ago that Nvidia
5:19 (NVDA) was at all time highs. We saw this
5:21 kind of huge fall from grace just really
5:24 over the past month or so. So the market
5:26 already has, but it hasn't been able to achieve
5:29 new highs from here. So do you think that.
5:32 Well, but if you let's take a step back.
5:34 If you look at the market weighted index it's actually
5:37 creating. It's close to a new high year to
5:40 date. And so the market weighted. So if you take
5:43 out the weighting rate of Nvidia (NVDA) or some
5:45 of these other tech heavy over weights, it just proves
5:48 the thesis that I just laid out for you.
5:51 So you're still targeting 8,000 for
5:52 the S&P by year end.
5:54 We can get there.
5:55 Are all of the ingredients for that rally
5:58 then starting to come together or or is.
6:00 There I mean last week we had one heck
6:03 of a market, right. The drawdown on the Nasdaq
6:07 was primarily S&P and the Dow. That was the
6:10 story leading into this weekend. And then we got
6:13 the news on Nvidia (NVDA) on Sunday breaking, which
6:16 kind of just reset expectations moving forward. You're seeing
6:19 money move back into technology. And a lot of
6:22 these names multiples are actually looking a lot better
6:26 now as that we saw that market clearing reset.
6:29 And so moving forward you know on the S&P 500
6:33 you have 17.7, you know, forward on a P/E multiple.
6:37 And then earnings guidance for next year is across
6:40 all the sectors looking very positive as well. Very strong.
6:44 So what is it that gets
6:46 us there by December 31st?
6:48 I think it's going to be the other sectors, like
6:51 I said before that outside of tech, I think technology
6:54 is still going to be okay. But outside of technology
6:57 you're also going to see the industrials continue. Again,
7:00 health care, there's some names in health care. But also
7:03 it's been crazy creeping up lately is the consumer discretionary.
7:06 And so that has had a rebound since this summer.
7:10 A lot of the names have got we're extremely
7:13 beaten down. There's a lot of opportunity. They've turned
7:16 positive. And I believe the consumer discretionary sector will
7:19 also see the market rise higher and could get
7:22 us contribute to getting us to that 8,000 mark.
7:25 Okay. I want to get into all of your picks
7:28 here. What to buy now, what to buy in a
7:31 pullback. You say every good investor should have a shopping
7:34 list for the next pullback, but shouldn't try to time
7:37 the bottom right. So how do we know when the
7:40 pullback is enough and when it's time to start buying.
7:43 Well there's a multiple factors that we look at.
7:46 Not only the trend in earnings the forward guidance
7:49 by management the sector itself. Is it cyclical in nature.
7:52 Where are we in the business cycle as it
7:55 relates to the economy, but also the technical aspect
7:58 of the chart itself on some of these names
8:01 and some of the names that I brought you
8:04 technically are turning around from a chart perspective, which also
8:07 provides an additional sort of litmus test for us
8:10 to say, okay, this is an opportunity moving forward.
8:13 Okay. So we'll get into the picks.
8:15 The first pick here, it sounds like Nvidia
8:16 (NVDA) is a pick at this point.
8:18 I believe it is.
8:19 Okay so Nvidia (NVDA) check. Yeah Apple (AAPL)
8:22 sitting near all time highs. So not necessarily
8:24 a stock you're looking for a turnaround for. But
8:27 you think that this is a stock you
8:29 can still buy here. Oh you move higher.
8:32 The innovation is continuing. We're seeing the iOS devices
8:36 that are just now we've got a new generation
8:40 of the flip phone or the fold phone I believe
8:44 is incredible. So their installed base of just those
8:47 that have to re-up on improving or upgrading for
8:51 Apple (AAPL) is just a it's a cash cow.
8:55 So yeah. Okay. So Nvidia (NVDA), Apple (AAPL), Microsoft (MSFT)
8:58 and Amazon (AMZN) both on your list as well.
9:01 Yeah. Both Microsoft (MSFT) and Amazon (AMZN) Microsoft (MSFT) very
9:05 specifically is showing that you can preserve your cash
9:08 flow. You don't have to spend all that's on
9:12 your net free cash flow at the bottom of your
9:16 balance sheet and still show profitability in the AI spend,
9:20 and with Amazon (AMZN) specifically, if you look at
9:23 their cloud computing, this last sector or this last
9:27 quarter, they're up 39% just on AWS, about $46 billion.
9:31 They reported for that component of the company. If
9:34 we go back to 2020 on AWS's, Amazon (AMZN)
9:37 just earned more in one quarter than they did
9:41 for all of the calendar year for AWS's
9:44 in 2020, what that shows, what that tells us
9:47 is that they have leverage in the ramp up
9:50 is real, and that story is not going away.
9:54 It's just increasing. So that's one of the
9:56 reasons why we like Amazon (AMZN) as well.
9:59 Margin expansion as well. So but yeah okay.
10:01 And noticeably missing meta (META) alphabet (GOOGL) Tesla
10:04 (TSLA) intentional or did you just not let us
10:07 know that those are your picks as well?
10:09 I think that's who we like right now in terms
10:12 of the Amazon (AMZN) and the Microsoft (MSFT) Meta
10:15 (META) is very interesting. But it's also very volatile.
10:18 But I think it's it's poised for a quality 2027
10:21 as well. And then, you know, Tesla (TSLA) is they're
10:24 going to go through some who knows what Elon's
10:27 going to do with SpaceX and Tesla (TSLA) next
10:30 year, but it's not on our buy list right now.
10:33 Alphabet (GOOGL)'s 30% off the highs. That's a pullback.
10:36 It's very attractive. You're not buying. Well I think in
10:40 this last quarter. What was concerning is is how
10:43 much chat or all the other applications that are out
10:46 there are actually taking from the search capabilities of alphabet
10:50 (GOOGL). And the advertising revenue, I think was a
10:53 little bit they got a little bit weaker. So I
10:57 don't know about you, but if you go to Google
11:00 right now and search something where you can go to
11:03 chat or one of the others in search something,
11:07 they're going to search about 20 websites versus just one.
11:10 And then this timesaver is really the story here.
11:13 So the question is can you trust the information
11:16 that you're getting out of but that's the
11:20 case for any, any one of the search engines.
11:23 You have picks outside of tech that we
11:25 will get to. But just going back to
11:28 Nvidia (NVDA) for just a second, what would
11:30 make you change your mind about Nvidia (NVDA)?
11:33 Again, the market clearing event today for the stock was
11:37 very positive. Next week's earnings is going to tell
11:41 us a lot more that we don't know right now.
11:45 So what could you hear next week or what is
11:48 it that would make you say, you know what I
11:51 think you sell here or you certainly don't buy here?
11:54 I think there was a breach of national security
11:57 and a level that now is being disclosed that
12:00 nobody knows internally. So again, if if this story
12:03 continues to evolve internally and then the more
12:06 that everyone learns, I mean, there's investigations the FBI,
12:09 DOJ, like this thing could, could really turn into
12:12 something where no one has ever expected or anticipated.
12:15 So yeah. So if but I believe that
12:18 the negative headline is really clear the market
12:20 right now and Nvidia (NVDA) and I'm really curious
12:22 to see what the forward guide looks like.
12:24 Okay. All right. Outside of big tech like visa (V)
12:27 up about 20% year to date 4% off the
12:30 highs. You waiting for a pullback there you'd buy here.
12:33 No we would accumulate. We'd love the dividend growth
12:36 story for our clients. Love companies that grow their earnings
12:40 but also grow their dividend. Visa (V) grew their
12:43 dividend last quarter by 17%. And they've had 17
12:47 consecutive years of raising their dividend. So it's rewarding
12:50 shareholders especially in the market today where you have a
12:53 lot of retirees that are living off of income.
12:57 It's always nice to have that phone call to them
13:00 and say, hey, listen, you're getting an increase in income.
13:02 And we use our visa (V)'s to buy our
13:05 discretionary purchases. You mentioned that consumer discretionary is
13:08 has been really in favor for the past few
13:11 weeks. Back in favor today as well. What
13:14 names do you like in the consumer discretionary space.
13:17 Well it's.
13:17 Worse. Would you avoid.
13:18 Yeah a turnaround story is Estée Lauder (EL) right now
13:22 I think if you look at it, their top
13:25 five brands internationally, it's more of an international growth story.
13:29 Number one, their top five brands are really seeing
13:32 traction for their last earnings report in China. And so
13:35 the growth of even that consumer, particularly for all
13:39 of their brands within Estée Lauder (EL) are very attractive.
13:43 The stock was down about 35% this summer and
13:46 now it's turned positive. We believe that they're still,
13:48 it's a turnaround story that we can continue to
13:51 see operating leverage. And so it's a quality brand,
13:54 basically a collection of brands, but not just for
13:57 the United States, but globally as well, and that
14:00 there's evidence of growth across the globe on that.
14:03 Any other names in the consumer
14:05 discretionary space that you like right now?
14:08 You know, you asked me earlier what I would avoid.
14:11 I'd say, you know, it's a crowded space in
14:14 the consumer discretionary environment. The one name I would
14:17 avoid still is like Lululemon (LULU), okay. Because there's so
14:20 much competition. And, you know, I have three, you know,
14:23 daughters that are like 20 something to, you know.
14:26 And they're not wearing it.
14:27 Well, I have you know, I have the Peter
14:30 Lynch ability, right where I you know, Peter Lynch was
14:33 famous in the 1980s going to this, you know,
14:36 the mall with his daughter and finding Gap (GAP)
14:39 and gap (GAP) became one of his best contributors.
14:42 So I do take notice when my daughters give me
14:45 the sort of a Christmas list, if you will.
14:48 But Lululemon (LULU) hasn't been on the top
14:51 of that for the last 2 or 3 years.
14:53 There have been other competitors, the Alo Yogas, the
14:55 Vuoris and a few others in that. So
14:58 it's a crowded space and they they could
15:00 be a turnaround story, but I would avoid the.
15:02 Lululemon (LULU) certainly a pullback if that
15:05 is that criteria. What about Nike (NKE).
15:08 Nike (NKE) is very interesting. Now I think they
15:12 they just it could be a serious turnaround story. The
15:15 brand is not going away. So if they get
15:19 their story right moving forward and they get a lot
15:22 of their cost controls, moving forward, Nike (NKE) is
15:26 attractive, especially at these depressed levels. So but I don't
15:29 see Nike (NKE) for the, you know, long run.
15:33 Yes. In the short run, I think there's other opportunities.
15:36 So that one's not on the Christmas list either.
15:38 For my son. It is.
15:39 So you you mentioned the health care industrials.
15:42 What other areas of the market should investors
15:45 be focused on right now if they already
15:48 feel like they have enough exposure to tech?
15:50 Yeah, healthcare is very interesting. As I said, we've
15:54 been a long holder and believer in Eli Lilly (LLY).
15:57 The GLP one market again is in the early
16:00 stages. And you're seeing, you know, even if the consumer
16:03 who might not want a shot a week can
16:06 take a pill. So I mean they're constantly evolving at
16:09 Eli Lilly (LLY). Lilly the the results are there.
16:13 So it's really impacting the health in a positive
16:16 way, not only in America but but also outside
16:20 the US. But we can see that story continue
16:24 for many years. The total addressable market is unbelievable.
16:27 Which names it sounds like all of those
16:29 names you would buy here. So which names
16:31 are on your pullback list? Which names are
16:34 you waiting for a better entry point on?
16:36 I think Eli Lilly (LLY) is at a close
16:39 to a all time high, so I would be
16:41 waiting for an opportunity for that one. But you
16:44 know, we've had like I said before last week
16:47 we had a market's pullback. And I believe that
16:50 we're still going to continue to see strong earnings
16:53 not only for the fourth quarter but foreseeable future.
16:56 And so I think right now depending upon each name
16:59 is is unique. You got to watch where the valuation
17:01 is. And the P/E is But at the end of
17:04 the day, there's a lot of attractive things that that.
17:07 Bringing it back to tech with big tech and AI
17:11 stocks swinging ten, 20, 30%, you know, in a matter
17:14 of sometimes days, weeks. How can investors tell the difference
17:18 between okay, this is a good buying opportunity or okay,
17:21 the investment thesis has changed here because we've seen this
17:25 in the memory space in the neoclouds. You know, there's
17:28 still stocks that look like they're on pretty steep sale.
17:32 You know you want to look at the the
17:36 second derivative beyond the Nvidia (NVDA) right of the
17:39 AI story or the tech story. We're in a
17:43 technological revolution. And that's going to continue the
17:46 amount of efficiencies and scale that's bringing to every
17:50 business throughout. You know, we're talking about how energy
17:54 is impacting and tariffs are impacting the consumer technology.
17:57 In terms of the inflation technology is the deflationary counterbalance
18:01 to that. So within technology, one could say a
18:05 company, you know, one could say even Apple (AAPL) is
18:09 too expensive today, but they're waking up every single
18:13 day reinvesting and innovating for something that no one's even
18:17 thinking about or considering for tomorrow. So that's not
18:21 priced into today's multiple. That's not priced into today's earnings.
18:25 I made reference to Amazon (AMZN) earlier. If you look
18:29 at Amazon (AMZN)'s AWS right the cloud computing space five,
18:34 six years ago they just started it. Now it's
18:38 contributing over, you know, $150 billion of revenue with the
18:42 bottom line that didn't exist, didn't exist five years ago.
18:46 Those are second derivative plays.
18:49 Yeah. Especially on the, Amazon (AMZN) cloud space.
18:52 Okay. And what derails this bullish thesis? You
18:55 know, you think we don't have that much
18:57 time between now and year end S&P
19:00 8,000. What gets in the way of it?
19:03 Well we have the Federal Reserve in December.
19:06 So S&P 8,000 if we see
19:08 another. So we have a rate hike.
19:10 No I think 25 basis points already factored in,
19:13 especially the economic data that's just been released. And
19:16 I think if the fed goes with 50 basis
19:19 points, which I don't think it's a bad idea,
19:22 to be honest with you. Let's get that in. Let's
19:25 maybe shake the market out. That could not have
19:28 us achieve the 8,000 mark by year end and
19:32 sort of push pause on the Santa Claus rally.
19:35 So it's not know for ever. But it's no,
19:38 for right now. I do believe we'll see the 8,000
19:41 mark. But if you were to ask me, it's
19:44 the Federal Reserve historically has been the one that has
19:47 stopped a lot of these bull markets in the
19:50 past by being too aggressive. But I don't believe they
19:53 would be super aggressive at this point in time.
19:55 I think a 50 basis point is called for.
19:58 If we look at ten year Treasury and
20:01 now we're back above 5%, we are about 5.30.
20:04 Just about a month ago. And so we could
20:06 see that would be a welcome, like, let's get
20:09 it over with. And that provides cover for
20:12 the fed in 2027 to a pullback if needed.
20:15 But would that end the bull market
20:17 or it would just cause additional volatility.
20:19 Just additional volatility.
20:20 And would you change anything about your investment strategy? If
20:23 the fed does hike by 50 basis points, you
20:26 would just be ready to buy anything or we'd take.
20:29 Advantage of that. And also where we have been
20:31 the last quarter and even as early as this
20:34 summer, re a debt repricing of readjusting risk for
20:37 our client portfolios. By that I mean when
20:40 we got up to over 5% on the ten
20:43 year or even the 530, as I mentioned earlier,
20:46 treasuries are sexy again, right? Bonds are sexy again.
20:49 We haven't been able to say that for a good
20:52 long time. So we've been strategically rebalancing, de-risking client
20:55 portfolios, selling into the strength of some of these names
20:58 or some of these sectors, and then reallocating into
21:01 the fixed income market. One, just to be prudent. That's
21:04 our job at the same time is adjust the
21:07 risk. But two, we also have some dry powder, right.
21:10 If we do see a drawdown beyond a 5%,
21:12 that we would see something greater. If we do
21:15 see, let's say the fed does get out
21:18 of hand, we could take advantage of that volatility.
21:21 So for a risk on portfolio. So mine
21:23 okay I'll take the free investment advice here. I
21:26 have a ways to go before retirement. How
21:28 much of my portfolio should be in cash right
21:31 now and how much should be in bonds.
21:34 Again thanks for put me on
21:35 the spot on that one.
21:36 And don't even say it depends
21:38 on your situation. I don't know enough.
21:40 You know, I think over equity is right now,
21:44 given where inflation is, is not a bad idea for
21:49 real assets, equities, real estate, private equity, commodities, gold.
21:53 So those are growth assets that stay above inflation
21:58 over time. We're in an inflationary environment. And so
22:02 you need that growth in the portfolio. Again everyone's living
22:07 longer I have a client that's 104 years old.
22:11 She's completely independent. She takes her portfolio every single
22:14 day. And if a dividend doesn't hit I have
22:17 to say Nettie, refresh the browser and then it
22:20 shows. Right. I don't think that's what most Americans
22:23 are actually thinking about, is they're still in the. You
22:26 know, I'm only gonna have 20 years in retirement.
22:29 I think you could have 30, maybe 35 to
22:33 40 years plus adding in the health care costs.
22:36 You're going to need something that's going to grow
22:39 way above and provide that opportunity in the future.
22:41 So how much in cash? How
22:43 much in bonds for me? Zero.
22:46 No that's not we always have cash. So typically
22:48 we have anywhere from 5 to 10%. We say
22:51 cash equivalents okay. So I'll break down the asset
22:54 allocation for you. So 5 to 10%. We we traditionally
22:57 carry 5% for just about all of our clients
22:59 at the bare minimum in a in a client
23:02 portfolio, simply because we take advantage of the volatility.
23:05 And again that cash is not cash. It's an
23:09 alternative, investment that's actually in the cash money market, if
23:12 you will, that's earning over 4%, up to 10%
23:16 depending upon risk tolerance and age moving forward, maybe another
23:20 25% in fixed income and the remainder in equities.
23:24 And where specifically in fixed income right now.
23:27 So we like the basically the middle of the yield
23:30 curve right now. Again, we were short duration for
23:34 the longest time. But as rates rise we're going
23:38 further out. So the 7 to 10 range again treasuries
23:42 are looking really good. Some of the corporates even municipal
23:45 bonds, that we have for our high income earners.
23:49 Okay. All right. I think this is a great thank
23:52 you for that advice. I think this is a
23:55 great time to pivot to our rapid fire round of
23:57 this or that you've played before. Our quick questions,
24:00 quick answers. No hedging okay. Are you ready bringing it
24:02 back to Nvidia (NVDA) Nvidia (NVDA)'s next move. Rebound
24:05 or more pain rebound. Nvidia (NVDA)'s next CEO Tim Cook.
24:08 Or a new face.
24:09 It'll be a new face.
24:11 Next AI leader chipmakers or software.
24:14 Software.
24:16 Software name you like here that's not Microsoft (MSFT).
24:19 ServiceNow (NOW).
24:19 Now AI spending boom continues or slowdown ahead.
24:24 Oh boom continues.
24:26 AI selloff: bubble bursting or a buy the dip moment.
24:28 Buy the dip.
24:29 Market's next big move for tech
24:31 led or broad based rally.
24:33 Tech. Red tech led.
24:34 Bigger risk missing the rally or
24:36 getting caught in a sell off.
24:38 Missing rally.
24:39 Cash smart protection or missed opportunity.
24:42 Smart protection.
24:43 Fed rate hike, rally killer or market noise.
24:46 It will be market noise.
24:48 More likely in 2027. S&P 7,000 or 9,000.
24:53 9,000.
24:54 Market leadership in 2027. Mag Seven or the other 493.
24:57 The other 493.
24:58 Finish this sentence. The biggest market
25:02 catalyst for 2027 will be.
25:05 It's a good one. The biggest.
25:11 Say it again.
25:12 The biggest market catalyst for next year will be.
25:16 It'll be the it'll be interest rates coming down.
25:21 That's the biggest surprise for investors in 2027 will be.
25:26 Interest rates coming down.
25:27 The stock market is most wrong about.
25:33 The a story where we are in a cycle.
25:38 Where are we in the cycle?
25:39 Early.
25:40 The S&P 500 will end 2026 at.
25:45 8,000.
25:45 And I will turn bearish if.
25:49 Inflation continues to get out of hand.
25:51 What does out of hand look like.
25:53 Above the Fed's target for a sustained period of
25:57 time and stubbornly, really dipping into the consumer's pockets.
26:00 Okay. All right. Thank you so much I think
26:03 that was great. Really appreciate it. That's Robert Schein,
26:06 chief investment officer, Blanke Schein Wealth Management. If you like
26:09 what you're seeing, check out our ETF spotlight with
26:12 Jonathan Molchan He breaks down how investors can navigate
26:15 tech volatility while generating income along the way. And don't
26:18 forget to like, subscribe, comment and check out our
26:21 community polls to share your take on the market.
26:23 We want to hear from you.