Video transcripts, November 14, 2026
Video transcripts
101 of 103 videos with a full transcript
Could Democratic Gains Bring Tariff Relief For Canada? full transcript
0:00 Canada's benchmark index
0:01 gained 2.3% on November 4th,
0:04 the day after the 2026
0:06 midterm election, its
0:07 biggest daily gain in seven
0:09 months. Investors appear to
0:11 be betting on an easing of
0:13 the U.S.' tariffs on a
0:14 variety of Canadian goods.
0:16 But change could come
0:18 slowly. Democrats won't
0:19 control both chambers of
0:20 Congress until 2027,
0:23 and President Trump still
0:24 has two years left in
0:26 office.
0:26 I'm kind of cynical in the
0:27 sense that if the tariffs go
0:29 away, if businesses see that
0:31 consumers are trained now
0:32 for the higher prices,
0:33 do they really have
0:34 incentive to then lower the
0:35 prices, or do they just kind
0:37 of eat the margins?
0:38 So will trade relations
0:39 between the U.S. And Canada
0:41 improve? And who stands to
0:43 benefit? The U.S.
0:49 and Canada are major trading
0:51 partners with their supply
0:53 chains in the auto and
0:54 energy sectors closely
0:56 connected. Total trade
0:57 between the two countries
0:58 hit $872 billion in 2025,
1:03 down 4.6% from 2024.
1:06 Canada spends about 70% of
1:08 its exported goods to the
1:09 U.S. President Trump first
1:12 imposed tariffs on Canada in
1:13 March 2025, and over the
1:16 following 20 months,
1:17 there was a steady
1:18 escalation of trade
1:19 barriers, including shifting
1:20 rates, retaliatory
1:22 counter-tariffs and legal
1:23 challenges. Following their
1:25 victory in this month's
1:26 midterm election,
1:28 some Democrats say they want
1:29 to end those tariffs,
1:31 but doing so may be
1:33 difficult. The Constitution
1:34 gives Congress the power to
1:36 impose tariffs,
1:37 though it has delegated
1:38 some of its authority to the
1:39 president. Relief has
1:41 already arrived for some
1:43 Canadian exporters after
1:44 Trump exempted plywood
1:46 sheets, paper products and
1:48 refrigeration equipment just
1:49 before the midterms in an
1:51 attempt to help Maine's
1:52 Senator Susan Collins.
1:54 Over the next two years. For
1:55 example, we might see a
1:56 reduction in tariffs.
1:58 I don't think it will be
1:59 linear because I think it'll
2:01 be more two steps forward,
2:02 one step back. But the trend
2:04 line, I think will be clear
2:05 for a while.
2:06 If U.S. tariffs are eased,
2:08 some Canadian companies
2:09 could benefit, including
2:11 steelmakers like Algoma
2:12 Steel and lumber producers
2:14 like West Fraser Timber.
2:16 Cases like agriculture,
2:18 where we're importing
2:19 Canadian dairy products,
2:20 for example, you may see an
2:22 immediate impact if those
2:23 tariffs were to be removed.
2:25 But even with the
2:26 trade-friendlier Congress,
2:27 relief may take time.
2:29 President Trump still has
2:30 executive powers over trade,
2:32 and tariffs could remain
2:34 part of negotiations with
2:35 Canada for a while.
2:37 On top of that,
2:38 some Rust Belt Democrats
2:40 support targeted tariffs as
2:42 a legitimate trade policy
2:43 tool.
2:44 The tariffs that Canada most
2:46 wants to get rid of are on
2:47 steel and aluminum, and
2:49 those are the tariffs that
2:50 the Democrats are most
2:52 interested in keeping.
2:53 For security reasons,
2:55 for economic reasons,
2:56 and for domestic political
2:58 reasons, I don't think we're
2:59 going to go back to an
3:01 assumption that zero tariffs
3:02 is the goal, that free trade
3:04 is the objective. I think
3:06 we're going to see a lot
3:07 more regulated trade,
3:09 a lot more limits put on
3:11 the movement of goods and
3:12 services.
3:13 Canada's retaliatory tariffs
3:15 and unresolved disputes add
3:17 another layer. And some
3:18 provinces have restricted
3:19 U.S. companies from bidding
3:21 on public projects and have
3:22 removed U.S. alcohol
3:23 products from their shelves.
3:25 It's more likely that
3:26 between now and the end of
3:28 the year, he and
3:29 Prime Minister Carney worked
3:30 something out that is
3:31 mutually satisfactory,
3:33 then I wouldn't say it goes
3:35 away, but it becomes of
3:37 lesser urgency for the
3:38 Democrats if that happens.
3:41 Canada was the top export
3:43 market for U.S. goods in
3:44 2024, accounting for 16.8%
3:48 of all U.S.
3:49 exports. That relationship
3:51 is especially visible in
3:53 Michigan, which sent more
3:54 than $23 billion in goods to
3:57 Canada in 2025,
3:59 about 40% of its total goods
4:01 exports. General Motors and
4:03 Ford rely on Canadian
4:04 production in their supply
4:05 chains, including engines
4:07 made in Canada for trucks
4:08 and SUVs sold in the U.S.
4:11 Canada was also Maine's
4:13 largest export market,
4:14 accounting for $1.3 billion,
4:17 or 41% of its goods exports,
4:19 in 2025.
4:21 Key exports include $299
4:23 million of fish and
4:25 lobsters, $219 million of
4:28 natural gas, and $132
4:30 million dollars
4:31 of wood products.
4:32 There's a lot of cross
4:33 border trade.
4:35 To some extent, those
4:36 northern states and those
4:37 provinces have largely been
4:39 integrated economically
4:40 in all sorts of ways.
4:41 We have a city or that
4:43 border town being built upon
4:44 tourism, manufacturing,
4:46 cross traffic, maybe
4:48 sporting events and kind of
4:49 all this consumer action.
4:50 We should see jobs open up.
4:51 We should see wages go up.
4:53 We should see a nice healthy
4:54 economy develop or return.
4:56 These potential gains are
4:58 also part of the debate in
4:59 Michigan. Senator-Elect
5:01 Abdul El-Sayed opposes
5:02 Trump's tariffs on Canada
5:04 and campaigned on bringing
5:06 them down. But past trade
5:07 talks between the U.S.
5:09 and Canada have collapsed
5:10 before, and key issues such
5:12 as steel, lumber and auto
5:15 manufacturing remain
5:16 unresolved.
5:17 I think the one thing that
5:18 this election demonstrated
5:20 is that trade and tariffs
5:21 are not going to go away as
5:22 an election issue. And
5:23 they're probably here to
5:24 stay two years later.
5:26 And both parties are going
5:27 to have to confront that.
Nvidia In Crisis: The Rise Of Jensen Huang’s Empire At The Center Of The AI Boom full transcript
0:00 Nvidia is facing the biggest crisis in its 33 year
0:03 history. Founder Jensen Huang accused of multiple
0:06 affairs, including with a direct report,
0:09 and Alice Huang, an alleged Chinese spy who
0:12 also worked with a major Nvidia customer Megaspeed,
0:15 based out of Singapore, that put her in the middle
0:17 of a sprawling effort to accumulate AI chips across
0:21 Southeast Asia and possibly get them into the hands of
0:23 restricted Chinese companies.
0:25 Now he's out as CEO.
0:28 Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang has officially resigned his post
0:32 following reports of a second affair in one of the
0:34 biggest shakeups in corporate America's history.
0:37 The entire story feels like it's a script for a movie.
0:40 The fact that she may be a spy, that she worked for a
0:44 distributor or a neocloud that was supplying,
0:46 potentially, compute into China.
0:48 If there was anything that breached the trust of the
0:50 country or that breaks the trust of how he handled
0:53 company secrets, I don't know that you
0:55 can survive that.
0:56 The relationship between Jensen Huang and Alice Huang
0:58 dates back to 2023, a turbulent time for Nvidia,
1:02 as it navigated the first in a series of strict export
1:05 controls that the Biden administration placed on
1:07 sending its most advanced chips to China in an effort
1:10 to keep the world's second largest economy from
1:13 leapfrogging the U.S.
1:14 in AI. It's also the year we sat down with Jensen Huang
1:17 for an in-depth interview about the history of his
1:19 company. That same day, we also interviewed another
1:22 Nvidia executive who, it turns out,
1:24 he also reportedly had an affair with.
1:35 This isn't the first time Nvidia has found itself
1:37 teetering on the edge of an uncertain future.
1:40 It nearly went bankrupt a handful of times in early
1:42 years, when Jensen Huang bet the company on impossible
1:45 seeming ventures.
1:47 Every company makes mistakes,
1:48 and I make a lot of them, and you know,
1:51 some of them some of them puts the company in peril,
1:55 especially in the beginning because we were small and
1:58 and we're up against very, very large companies and
2:01 we're trying to invent this brand new technology.
2:04 Three decades and many AI chips later,
2:07 and Nvidia's place at the very center of all AI
2:10 computing sent its stock up 17 fold at its peak and gave
2:14 Jensen Huang a net worth over $150 billion before it
2:18 all took a tumble. That's remarkable for a man who
2:21 dreamed up the idea with two fellow engineers out of a
2:23 Denny's in the early 90s in hopes of bringing better 3-D
2:27 graphics to PCs for better video games.
2:30 In his humble beginnings, certainly played a role in
2:32 him becoming great.
2:34 But you know, he's been on the cover of
2:35 Time Magazine. I think by now he certainly knew he was
2:38 important as he flew around the world with the president
2:41 of the United States.
2:42 As investigations by Nvidia's own board and
2:44 government entities from House committees to the FBI
2:47 dig into exactly what happened here,
2:49 we take a look back at Nvidia's history from our
2:51 own interviews with Jensen Huang and other company
2:53 leadership to get a clear picture of where Nvidia
2:56 stands today and all it stands to lose.
3:11 In the first months of the AI boom,
3:13 as Nvidia was on the cusp of becoming a household name,
3:16 Jensen Huang had long term aspirations for leading his
3:19 company. You are the longest running tech CEO.
3:23 Is there any end in sight?
3:24 Well, as you could tell, I'm sprightly and quite
3:28 enthusiastic and energetic, yet,
3:30 um. Uh, I'm surrounded by amazing people.
3:34 They keep me inspired.
3:36 And I feel that we could do great things together.
3:39 I feel that I'm making a real contribution to the
3:42 company and to them.
3:43 And so I think for so long as I,
3:45 I believe I could do that.
3:47 And, um, uh, I don't know exactly how that how long
3:50 that's going to be, but 3 or 4 decades,
3:53 I would say. And so hopefully,
3:54 hopefully I'll get to enjoy this for a very long time.
3:57 Three years later, the question isn't whether
3:59 Huang's contributions were meaningful,
4:00 but whether his mistakes were,
4:02 in fact just that.
4:03 The fact that he may have used his influence in some
4:07 way to help gain more access to compute in a region where
4:11 it was clearly sensitive or not supposed to be available
4:14 at all. In many cases, that's the question,
4:17 because there is a chance that Jensen has done nothing
4:21 different than Jeff Bezos and Sergey Brin and Bill
4:26 Gates, and made a mistake in his personal relationship
4:31 that has cost him dearly,
4:32 reputationally and financially.
4:36 Because until now, Nvidia was one of the rare
4:38 Silicon Valley giants that still had
4:40 its founder at the helm.
4:49 Jensen is so important to this company.
4:53 The company has been built in his light.
4:55 It's a reflection of who he is.
4:57 The autocratic style that he imposes,
5:00 the leaders that he has selected that are basically
5:02 the execution of his will inside of the business.
5:06 You can't send him off and just bring Jensen to it.
5:10 63-year-old Jensen Huang immigrated to the U.S.
5:13 from Taiwan as a kid and studied engineering at
5:16 Stanford and Oregon State, where he met his wife,
5:19 Lori Mills. Marrying her in 1985.
5:22 In the early 90s, Huang met fellow engineers
5:24 Chris Malachowsky and Curtis Priem at Denny's,
5:27 where they talked about dreams of enabling PCs with
5:30 3D graphics, the kind made popular by movies like
5:33 Jurassic Park at the time.
5:34 If you go back 30 years, at the time,
5:36 the PC revolution was just starting and there was quite
5:39 a bit of debate about what is the future of computing
5:43 and how should software be run.
5:45 And there was a large camp, and rightfully so,
5:50 that believe that CPU or general purpose software was
5:53 the best way to go, and it was the best way to
5:55 go for a long time.
5:57 We felt, however, that there was a class of
5:59 applications that wouldn't be possible
6:02 without acceleration.
6:05 The friends launched Nvidia out of a condo in Fremont,
6:07 California, in 1993.
6:09 The name was inspired by envy for next version and
6:12 invidia, the Latin word for envy.
6:14 They hoped to speed up computing so much everyone
6:16 would be green with envy.
6:18 Data center chips remain its primary business.
6:21 Led by industry leading graphics processing units
6:23 originally sold as cards that plug into a PC's
6:26 motherboard and now dominate in data centers,
6:28 too, they accelerate, add computing power to
6:31 central processing units, CPUs that primarily come
6:34 from Intel and AMD.
6:36 Although Nvidia now makes its own CPUs as well.
6:38 You know, there were one among tens of GPU makers at
6:41 that time. They are the only ones,
6:43 and them and AMD actually who really survived.
6:45 Um, because they.
6:47 Nvidia worked very well with the software community.
6:50 This is not a chip business.
6:53 This is a business of figuring out
6:55 things end to end.
6:57 But at the start, its future was
6:58 far from guaranteed.
7:00 In the beginning, there weren't that many
7:01 applications for it, frankly,
7:03 and we smartly chose one particular combination that
7:07 was a home run. It was computer graphics,
7:11 and we applied it to video games.
7:14 Now, Nvidia is known for revolutionizing gaming and
7:16 Hollywood with rapid rendering of visual effects.
7:19 Nvidia designed its first high performance graphics
7:22 chip in 1997. Designed, not manufactured.
7:25 Because Huang was committed to making Nvidia a fabless
7:28 chip company, keeping capital expenditure
7:30 way down by outsourcing the extraordinary expense of
7:33 making the chips to TSMC.
7:35 On behalf of all of us.
7:36 You're my hero.
7:38 Thank you, thank you, thank you.
7:43 Nvidia today wouldn't be here if and nor nor the
7:47 other thousand fabulous semiconductor companies
7:49 wouldn't be here if not for the pioneering work that
7:54 TSMC did.
7:56 In 1999, after laying off the majority of workers and
7:59 nearly going bankrupt to do it,
8:01 Nvidia released what it claims was the world's first
8:03 official GPU, the GeForce 256.
8:06 It was the first programable graphics card that allowed
8:09 custom shading and lighting effects.
8:11 By 2000, Nvidia was the exclusive graphics provider
8:13 for Microsoft's first Xbox.
8:16 Microsoft and the Xbox happen at exactly the time
8:19 that we invented this thing called the Programable
8:21 shader, and it defines how computer
8:24 graphics is done today.
8:25 Nvidia went public in 1999, and its stock stayed largely
8:29 flat until demand went through the roof during the
8:31 pandemic. In 2006, it released a software
8:34 toolkit called Cuda that would eventually propel it
8:36 to the center of the AI boom.
8:38 It's essentially a computing platform and programing
8:41 model that changes how Nvidia GPUs work from serial
8:44 to parallel computing.
8:46 Parallel computing is, let me take a task and
8:50 attack it all at the same time using much smaller
8:53 machines, right?
8:55 So it's the difference between having an army where
8:58 you have one giant soldier who is able to do things
9:02 very well, but one at a time,
9:05 versus an army of thousands of soldiers who are able to
9:09 take that problem, right and do it in parallel.
9:12 You know, they they quickly realized that the smartphone
9:14 market wasn't for them.
9:16 So they exited right from that.
9:19 Nvidia also made early moves toward data center CPUs in
9:22 2020 when it tried to acquire ARM,
9:24 which licensed its signature processor architecture to
9:27 major companies making their own chips like Apple,
9:29 Google and Amazon.
9:31 The $40 billion deal fell through because of
9:33 significant regulatory challenges,
9:35 and instead, Nvidia made a series of other big deals to
9:38 drive its tech forward from a $7 billion acquisition of
9:42 networking chip company Mellanox to its biggest
9:44 purchase yet — $20 billion to acquire assets from AI
9:48 chip designer Groq, which led to a new type of
9:50 chip Nvidia calls a language processing unit and a $5
9:54 billion investment in Intel with a plan to develop
9:57 custom Intel CPUs for data centers and PCs.
10:07 Since 2023, Nvidia has grown fast from 26,000 to 42,000
10:12 employees across 38 countries.
10:14 Its polygon themed headquarters in Santa Clara,
10:16 California, was redesigned in 2022 in an ode to the
10:20 polygon as a basic building block of 3D computer
10:23 graphics. The billions of chips it designs there now
10:26 span far more industries, from data centers to
10:28 autonomous cars, robots, and,
10:30 of course, AI.
10:32 We're in every cloud made by every computer company.
10:34 And then all of a sudden, one day, a new application
10:37 that wasn't possible before discovers you.
10:40 More than a decade ago.
10:41 Nvidia's Cuda and GPUs were the engine behind AlexNet.
10:45 What many consider AI's Big Bang moment.
10:47 It was a new, incredibly accurate neural
10:49 network that obliterated the competition during a
10:52 prominent image recognition contest in 2012.
10:54 Turns out, the same parallel processing needed to create
10:57 lifelike graphics is also ideal for deep learning,
11:00 where a computer learns by itself rather than relying
11:03 on a programmer's code.
11:04 We had the good wisdom to go put the whole company behind
11:08 it. We saw early on, about a decade or so ago,
11:12 that this way of doing software could change
11:14 everything, and we changed the company from the bottom,
11:17 all the way to the top and sideways.
11:19 Every chip that we made was focused on
11:21 artificial intelligence.
11:24 Bryan Catanzaro was the first and only employee on
11:27 Nvidia's deep learning team in 2016.
11:30 Last year, Nvidia's overall research roster had grown to
11:32 around 400 people.
11:34 For ten years, Wall Street asked Nvidia,
11:36 why are you making this investment?
11:38 No one's using it.
11:39 And they valued it at $0 in our market cap.
11:42 And it wasn't until around 2016 that after ten years
11:45 after Cuda came out, that all of a sudden people
11:48 understood this is a dramatically different way
11:51 of writing computer programs,
11:52 and it has transformational speedups that then yield
11:56 breakthrough results in artificial intelligence.
11:59 In 2023, we also talked to Kimberly Powell.
12:02 It's now come out that Jensen Huang reportedly had
12:04 an affair with her, too.
12:06 As Nvidia's VP of healthcare,
12:07 she was excited about the real world power of AI to
12:10 help with faster drug discovery and DNA sequencing
12:13 that takes hours instead of weeks.
12:15 We were able to achieve the Guinness World Record in a
12:18 genomic sequencing technique to actually diagnose these
12:21 patients and administer one of the patients in the trial
12:24 to have a heart transplant, a 13-year-old boy who's
12:27 thriving today as a result, and then also a
12:30 three-month-old baby that was having epileptic
12:33 seizures. And to be able to prescribe an
12:35 anti-seizure medication.
12:37 And when crypto started to boom,
12:39 Nvidia's GPUs became the coveted tool for mining the
12:41 digital currency.
12:43 Which is not really a recommended usage,
12:45 but that has created, you know,
12:47 problems because crypto mining has been a boom or
12:51 bust cycle. So gaming cards,
12:53 right, go out of stock prices,
12:55 get bid up, and then when the crypto mining boom
12:58 collapses, then there is a big crash right
13:01 on the gaming side.
13:02 Although Nvidia did create a simplified GPU made just for
13:05 crypto, it didn't stop miners from buying up gaming
13:08 GPUs, sending prices through the roof and causing sticker
13:11 shock among Nvidia's original loyal fan base of
13:14 video gamers. Now, of course,
13:16 it's AI that's leaving those gamers brokenhearted,
13:18 as Nvidia prioritizes its limited supply of memory
13:22 wafers and substrates for its flagship data center
13:24 GPUs. In 2023, Huang showed us the A100,
13:28 its Ampere line of GPUs that were packaged into $200,000
13:32 server boards used to train the earliest iterations of
13:36 OpenAI's ChatGPT.
13:37 When we ship them, we don't ship them in packs
13:41 of one. We ship them in packs of eight.
13:46 That A100 was the original Nvidia chip the Biden
13:48 administration banned from being sold to China in 2022.
13:52 About a quarter of your revenue comes from mainland
13:54 China. How do you calm investor fears over the new
13:56 export controls?
13:58 Well, Nvidia's technology is export controlled.
14:02 It's a reflection of the importance of the technology
14:04 that we make. The first thing that we have to do is
14:06 comply with the regulations.
14:07 And it was a turbulent, you know,
14:11 month or so as the company went upside down to
14:15 re-engineer all of our products so that it's
14:17 compliant with the regulation.
14:19 The regulation is going to be just fine. We're going to
14:21 be able to work through it.
14:22 But as export controls got tighter and tighter,
14:25 Nvidia ended up redesigning three different chips from
14:27 2022 to 2024 to keep its GPUs legally selling in
14:31 China. But after China's deep sea launched in 2025,
14:35 trained on Nvidia chips, the Trump administration
14:38 placed even stricter limitations that Nvidia said
14:40 would cost it $5.5 billion in canceled orders.
14:44 A few months later, Huang said,
14:45 we are 100% out of China.
14:48 In reality, the company maintained business in the
14:50 region. In its most recent annual report,
14:53 Nvidia said about 9% of its revenue came from China,
14:56 including Hong Kong.
14:57 Although that includes segments outside of
14:59 restricted data center chips such as gaming,
15:01 auto and industrial.
15:03 A report in May from short seller Culper Research
15:06 alleged Nvidia's China exposure was much higher.
15:09 The firm said that more than 20% of Nvidia's fiscal 2026
15:13 compute revenue was driven by China,
15:15 supported by illegal GPU diversion and Southeast
15:18 Asian intermediaries.
15:19 According to the report, Nvidia didn't respond to
15:22 requests for comment because it turns out there's a
15:24 loophole that allows Chinese companies to rent Nvidia
15:27 graphics processing units and data centers,
15:29 even when they're restricted from buying them outright.
15:32 And that's why Jensen Huang and Alice Huang's
15:34 relationship gets even messier,
15:36 because just months after those 1st October 2022
15:39 export controls, Megaspeed set up a
15:41 subsidiary in Malaysia and reportedly purchased nearly
15:44 $5 billion worth of Nvidia's most advanced chips,
15:47 leading the Commerce Department and Singapore
15:49 Police to launch investigations into
15:51 Megaspeed over alleged China export violations.
15:55 Fast forward to 2026, and Huang's cozy
15:58 relationship with President Donald Trump led to a shift
16:01 as he advised the White House on AI safety and
16:03 pushed for looser regulations.
16:05 And he was a last minute addition to the roster of
16:07 tech executives who joined Trump on a trip to China in
16:10 May after the president was briefed on intelligence
16:13 concerns, according to The Times.
16:15 In December, Trump said Nvidia would be allowed to
16:17 ship its A200 chips to China again,
16:20 provided the U.S. gets a 25% cut of sales.
16:23 But now China is restricting those sales.
16:26 The U.S. has licensed sales to Chinese companies like
16:28 Alibaba, Tencent and ByteDance,
16:31 but Beijing hasn't approved large scale imports and H200
16:35 shipments to China made up less than 1% of data center
16:38 revenue in the most recent quarter.
16:40 Another major geopolitical risk for Nvidia is its
16:42 dependance on TSMC in Taiwan.
16:44 There's two issues. One, Will China take over the
16:48 island of Taiwan at some point?
16:50 And two, is there a viable, you know,
16:52 competitor to TSMC?
16:54 And as of right now, you know,
16:57 Intel is trying aggressively to to get there.
17:00 And we will see.
17:01 And this is not just an Nvidia risk.
17:03 This is a risk for AMD, for Qualcomm,
17:06 even for Intel.
17:07 This is a big reason why the Biden administration passed
17:10 the Chips act in 2022, which set aside $52 billion
17:14 to incentivize chip companies to manufacture on
17:16 U.S. soil. Now, TSMC is spending $265
17:20 billion to build a massive campus of chip fabrication
17:24 plants fabs in Arizona.
17:26 The fact of the matter is, TSMC is a really important
17:28 company and the world doesn't have more than one
17:31 of them. It is imperative upon ourselves and them for
17:36 them to also invest in diversity and redundancy.
17:38 And will you be moving any of your
17:40 manufacturing to Arizona?
17:41 Oh, absolutely. We'll use Arizona.
17:43 Yeah. Yeah, absolutely.
17:47 Another risk to Nvidia's dominance comes from custom
17:49 AI accelerators, now made in-house by some of
17:52 Nvidia's biggest customers.
17:53 As Google, Amazon, meta, Microsoft and OpenAI
17:57 seek an alternative to Nvidia's costly,
17:59 supply constrained GPUs.
18:01 See, the biggest question for them is how do they stay
18:05 ahead? Because their customers can be their
18:08 competitors also.
18:10 Um, you know, Microsoft, uh,
18:12 can try and design these things internally.
18:14 Amazon and Google are already designing
18:16 these things internally.
18:17 The amount of power that the world needs in the data
18:19 center will grow. And you can see in the recent
18:22 trends, it's growing very quickly and that's a real
18:25 issue for for the world.
18:27 Now, agentic AI has taken over from call and answer
18:29 chatbots, and those agents require much more
18:32 orchestration and data retrieval,
18:34 leading to a resurgence in demand for the CPU.
18:36 Nvidia announced its first data center CPU,
18:39 Grace, in 2021, and now has an entire CPU
18:42 only rack for its latest Vera processors,
18:45 from GPUs to CPUs, Cuda software to full rack
18:49 scale systems like Vera Rubin,
18:50 there is no doubt that Nvidia's technology is the
18:53 very backbone on which AI is built.
18:55 The questions now go far deeper for the man who built
18:58 Nvidia and for the future of Nvidia itself.
19:01 Is Nvidia too big to fail?
19:04 Yes. This is a company that has hundreds of billions of
19:07 cash on the balance sheet, owns meaningful shares of
19:09 the most important companies in the world. The unwind
19:12 would be almost impossible.
19:15 There's no way there's enough capacity in the world
19:16 to move what they have planned to build to others,
19:19 so I think it can survive.
19:20 It is bigger than an individual.
How Democrats Won Back Union Voters full transcript
0:00 Democrats seem to be getting their mojo back in a big way
0:03 with union households.
0:04 In the 2026 midterms, they won these voters by a
0:08 whopping 22 percentage points,
0:10 according to the CNBC Voter Poll.
0:12 That's nearly three times the eight point advantage
0:14 Kamala Harris held in 2024.
0:17 And about one out of every six voters in the CNBC Voter
0:20 Poll said they were either a union member themselves or
0:23 lived in a household with one. It's a pretty dramatic
0:26 turnaround for a party whose relationship with organized
0:29 labor has been showing signs of strain.
0:31 So what changed, and can Democrats keep this
0:34 momentum going into 2028?
0:43 Unions have long been considered a core voting
0:45 bloc for Democrats, but their lead with these
0:47 voters had been shrinking.
0:49 In 2020, they had a 16 point advantage.
0:53 By 2024, that was down to just eight points.
0:57 Then came 2026.
0:59 Suddenly, their advantage was bigger than at any point
1:02 over the last eight years.
1:04 Just two years ago, the relationship between
1:06 Democrats and organized labor looked a lot less
1:09 certain. When do we want it?
1:11 Now! The Teamsters, one of the country's largest
1:13 labor unions, declined to endorse any
1:15 presidential candidate, breaking a streak of six
1:18 consecutive Democratic presidential endorsements.
1:21 And the union's own polling showed more participating
1:23 members favored endorsing Donald Trump than Kamala
1:26 Harris. Now, the Teamsters were hardly representative
1:30 of every union, and some of their local
1:32 chapters backed Harris anyway.
1:34 But the decision illustrated a broader political tension.
1:37 Democrats could no longer take overwhelming support
1:40 from organized labor for granted.
1:42 The United Auto Workers took a different approach,
1:45 endorsing Harris in 2024.
1:47 But its president says party affiliation alone isn't
1:50 enough to win the union's backing.
1:52 The days of just blindly giving our endorsements to
1:54 people because of party affiliation are over.
1:56 They're going to earn our support, and the candidates
1:58 that do not earn it will not get it.
2:02 Fast forward to 2026, and Michigan offers a
2:05 particularly interesting example of this reversal.
2:08 It's a state with a significant union presence,
2:11 especially in the auto industry.
2:13 And the United Auto Workers were actively campaigning
2:16 for Democrats this election.
2:18 According to the UAW, its volunteers knocked on
2:21 100,000 doors in Michigan and made half a million
2:23 phone calls. It called the initiative one part of its
2:26 biggest political organizing efforts in recent history.
2:30 The union also focused on competitive congressional
2:32 districts where its members could make a difference.
2:35 And it was really member driven. They recruited over
2:38 a thousand UAW members to volunteer.
2:41 And look at the results among Michigan Union
2:43 households. In 2024, Kamala Harris won them by
2:47 ten points. This year, Democrat Abdul El-Sayed won
2:50 union households by 25 points in his Senate race.
2:54 And Jocelyn Benson won them by 27 points in the
2:56 governor's race. Now, these are different races,
3:00 and polling alone can't tell us how much that organizing
3:03 contributed. But it does show just how substantial
3:06 Democrats advantage was in a state where unions were
3:09 mobilizing on a massive scale.
3:13 And Michigan wasn't the only place where unions were
3:15 organizing. The AFL-CIO, which is the country's
3:19 largest federation of labor unions,
3:21 says its volunteers to reach nearly 15 million voters
3:24 nationwide since Labor Day.
3:26 That's through door knocking, phone calls and
3:28 workplace outreach. But that activity doesn't mean
3:32 organized labor is suddenly united behind Democrats.
3:35 In fact, Teamsters President Sean O'Brien said he
3:38 personally voted for a Republican Senate candidate
3:40 in Florida this year. The Teamsters declined CNBC's
3:44 request to participate in this report.
3:46 And there's still the question of what motivated
3:49 union household voters.
3:50 The polling doesn't give us a definitive answer on that.
3:53 The richest people in the world keep getting richer,
3:55 and working class people can't afford to live. And so
3:57 I really think this election was a mandate on that.
4:00 People are fed up. They're fed up with being left
4:02 behind, scraping to get by.
4:03 But AFL-CIO data shows that,
4:05 at the very least, there was a lot of
4:07 enthusiasm this time around.
4:09 The organizations had 83% of union voters were very
4:13 motivated to head to the polls this year. That's up
4:15 ten percentage points from 2022.
4:19 But this shift is significant because unions
4:22 have historically been an important part of the
4:24 Democratic coalition.
4:25 And even as union membership has declined over the past
4:28 few decades, nearly 15 million American workers
4:32 still belong to unions.
4:33 The 2026 results suggest Democrats have regained a
4:36 significant advantage with this group.
4:38 But midterm elections and presidential elections can
4:41 look very different.
4:42 I think this election should be a huge wake up call.
4:46 It should be a wake up call for Democrats, too. Because,
4:48 you know, winning is the easy part.
4:50 Taking actions is the big part of this job.
4:53 And with another presidential election coming
4:55 in 2028, the next question is whether that
4:57 advantage can last.
Why Cheaper Car Sales Have Fallen full transcript
0:01 Affordability has been one
0:02 of the biggest themes in the
0:04 auto industry, and data show
0:06 car buyers are
0:07 feeling the pinch.
0:08 The market has changed a
0:09 lot. Really concerned about
0:11 continued escalation in the
0:13 fuel price. We're seeing 84
0:15 month financing which a year
0:16 ago was not really popular.
0:18 Almost a third of the market
0:19 for new vehicles.
0:20 So people are stretching
0:21 more and more to
0:23 buy that new Ford.
0:24 Those 84 month loans Farley
0:26 mentioned have hit record
0:28 levels. Now 1 in 4 car
0:30 buyers are getting them,
0:32 and monthly payments record
0:33 high payments over $1,000 a
0:36 month, record high for both
0:38 new and used car buyers.
0:40 Total interest paid also hit
0:43 an all time high.
0:44 Has it gotten any better?
0:46 No way. We're at like
0:47 breaking points with people.
0:50 High-end vehicle sales
0:51 dropped through the third
0:52 quarter of 2026,
0:54 while midsize and mainstream
0:56 vehicles rose even midsize
0:58 cars and minivans were up,
1:00 but some of the least
1:01 expensive cars on the market
1:03 aren't seeing that same
1:05 bump. More affordable
1:06 segments like compact SUVs
1:08 and compact cars priced less
1:10 than $40,000 have fallen
1:13 year over year.
1:21 Even though sales in
1:22 affordable segments are down
1:24 year to date. Lower priced
1:25 vehicles on dealer lots were
1:27 selling faster in Q3 than in
1:30 Q1 and faster than higher
1:32 priced vehicles.
1:33 So if cheap cars are selling
1:35 faster, why are sales still
1:37 down? There are a few
1:38 possible reasons.
1:40 One fewer options two
1:42 customers unwilling to trade
1:44 down and three,
1:46 many buyers are still priced
1:48 out. First, there is an
1:50 argument that there aren't
1:51 enough cars available or the
1:53 selection that customers
1:54 would like. For one thing,
1:56 the compact car segment has
1:58 shrunk dramatically.
1:59 We've seen a whole number of
2:01 inexpensive vehicles
2:02 disappear from the
2:03 marketplace, and we still
2:05 have Civic's and Kia K4 and
2:07 Toyota Corollas on the
2:09 market. But you don't have a
2:10 Chevy, you don't have a
2:11 Ford, you don't have a
2:12 Dodge. You have all these
2:13 brands that have just
2:15 abandoned the marketplace,
2:16 and those buyers would
2:18 typically move into those
2:19 showrooms. Are going to the
2:21 used car market and having
2:22 to buy an entry level
2:25 leftover 20,000,
2:27 30,000 mile compact
2:28 or subcompact car.
2:29 In the wholesale used
2:30 market, compact car prices
2:32 have risen faster than for
2:34 every segment besides EVs.
2:37 Compact vehicle buyers are
2:39 very price sensitive,
2:40 and so when the price of gas
2:42 goes up, that eats into
2:44 their car payment. That
2:45 means that they can't afford
2:47 a $500 or $600 a month car
2:50 payment, and they have to
2:51 move into the used market.
2:53 That's pushing up the prices
2:54 of used cars.
2:55 A few popular SUVs in the
2:57 lower price range have been
2:58 in short supply as well.
2:59 Ford discontinued production
3:01 of the escape to make way
3:02 for its new midsize EV
3:04 pickup, and some production
3:05 changes have constrained the
3:06 supply of the extremely
3:08 popular Toyota Rav4.
3:10 But analysts like Ivan Drury
3:12 also think the degree to
3:13 which consumers are
3:14 stretching themselves
3:15 financially suggests some
3:17 are just not stepping down
3:19 into a smaller,
3:20 less well-equipped car.
3:22 The moment you get into that
3:23 other vehicle and it's a
3:24 little bit smaller,
3:25 it's not as comfortable.
3:27 It doesn't fit all your
3:28 stuff, all your kid's
3:29 equipment for soccer
3:30 practice, you're done.
3:32 And as long as we can't give
3:33 those things up, we're going
3:34 to continue to persist with
3:35 people taking out longer
3:36 loan terms, stretching
3:38 things financially,
3:39 or just saying, you know
3:40 what, I'll cut in other
3:41 places in my life just to
3:43 afford this vehicle.
3:45 The one small vehicle
3:46 segment that did see some
3:47 growth was subcompact SUVs.
3:50 Drury said that's a segment
3:52 that attracts a lot of first
3:53 time buyers because this is
3:55 their first car, these
3:56 buyers don't feel like
3:57 they're stepping down from
3:58 something better. There are
4:01 also a number of other
4:02 financial and economic
4:03 factors working against
4:04 affordability. Manufacturers
4:06 are being more disciplined
4:07 about production, which
4:08 means they are trying to
4:09 match production with
4:10 demand, so they don't have
4:12 to rely so much on
4:13 incentives and leasing.
4:14 This is great for their
4:15 financial performance, but
4:17 it means there are fewer
4:18 deals to be had by
4:19 consumers. Automakers are
4:21 offering fewer incentives.
4:23 Leasing, which offers a
4:24 lower monthly payment,
4:26 is less common than it was
4:27 in 2019.
4:29 We have kind of a resilient
4:30 core of the market,
4:32 but that entry level buyer
4:33 has kind of priced out and
4:35 that's brought it's brought
4:36 a smaller, more profitable
4:37 market overall than entry
4:39 level buyer is looking at a
4:41 daunting landscape.
4:42 Nearly 1 in 3 shoppers
4:44 trading in a vehicle have
4:45 negative equity,
4:47 meaning the outstanding cost
4:49 of the loan is greater than
4:51 the value of the vehicle.
4:52 That balance is often rolled
4:54 into the next loan,
4:55 which raises the new payment
4:57 cost. Lenders have been
4:59 extending credit to
5:00 customers with lower credit
5:01 scores, but that comes with
5:03 costs, too.
5:05 If you have a lower credit
5:06 score and most lenders do
5:08 risk based pricing,
5:09 so a lower credit score gets
5:11 you a higher interest rate.
5:12 All else being equal.
5:14 Well, that is going to add
5:15 to that monthly payment.
5:16 And consumers are facing
5:18 higher gas prices and higher
5:19 costs overall.
5:21 There's like three dials you
5:22 can turn to to do a deal to
5:24 make a vehicle more
5:25 affordable. There's the
5:26 income of the buyer,
5:28 there's the price of money,
5:30 interest rate, and there's
5:32 the cost of the vehicle.
5:33 And there's no relief coming
5:35 on any of those three
5:36 any time soon.
How 3D Printing Is Transforming The Auto Industry full transcript
0:00 3D printing. It's a technology that's been
0:03 around for decades, but is now increasingly
0:05 being used by automakers to cut costs and save time.
0:10 Both the technology and the business cases have gotten
0:12 stronger, enough to start installing machines in auto
0:16 factories. Automakers like Ford and Rivian are using 3D
0:20 printing for prototypes, specialized tools,
0:23 and even replacement parts.
0:26 Also known as additive manufacturing,
0:28 3D printing builds an object from a digital design,
0:31 adding material layer by layer.
0:34 Depending on the machine, that material can be
0:36 plastic, ceramic, or even something harder,
0:39 like metal or carbon fiber composite.
0:42 Rivian says it has spent more than $5 million on
0:45 these types of machines.
0:46 Materials for the operations now cost about $1.7 million
0:51 per year. At the company's Michigan Research and
0:54 Development Center, smaller printers sit
0:56 alongside industrial machines that can cost
0:59 hundreds of thousands of dollars.
1:01 They make prototypes for design and testing,
1:03 including electric motors, steering wheels and other
1:06 interior parts.
1:08 Rivian told CNBC the machines typically pay for
1:11 themselves within a year just by saving on supplier
1:14 tooling and logistics and, of course,
1:16 time saved. It's a similar story at Ford.
1:20 The company has increasingly used 3D printing at its
1:22 factories. At the River Rouge plant,
1:25 where the automaker builds its crucial F-150 pickup
1:28 truck, about two dozen printers produce thousands
1:31 of tools, including hood holders,
1:33 torque bit sockets, and tools for smoothing
1:36 adhesive. When one of Ford's plants needed a large
1:39 machining wheel to keep its operations going,
1:42 the company printed a temporary replacement while
1:44 it waited for the production and delivery from a
1:46 supplier. Mercedes-Benz, Toyota and even EV startup
1:51 Slate also use 3D printing in their operations as well.
1:55 General Motors has even started using 3D printed
1:57 parts for some of its low volume Cadillac vehicles,
2:01 such as a medallion and a manual gear shifter,
2:04 marking the technology's growth from prototyping to
2:07 production parts.
2:08 Executives believe the future for 3D printing,
2:11 like the parts they build, is limitless as machines
2:14 continue to come down in cost and
2:16 efficiency increases.
Despite new headline risks, Big Tech may keep getting bigger, say ETF experts full transcript
0:00 You saw the election outcome. You saw
0:02 the immediate and then kind of after
0:04 price action with regard to the tech and
0:07 AI trade. How much is the fundamental
0:10 tech thesis for investing going to
0:12 change in your mind because of what we
0:14 saw with that blue wave coming to
0:16 Congress in the coming year?
0:18 >> Yeah. And we've said I mean the blue
0:20 tidal wave I view that was an
0:22 overreaction last week and I think
0:24 you're seeing a little bit of that
0:25 today. Now with that said, data centers
0:28 like you said probably 10% on the low
0:30 end don't happen. Maybe 15 20% on the
0:32 high end don't happen. Still demand and
0:34 supply is 4 to one. Hypers scalers the
0:38 compute is just that much more valuable
0:40 in the capacity today than it was a week
0:42 ago. So I could argue just more and more
0:44 bullish strong get stronger but I think
0:46 a lot of confusion a lot of sort of
0:48 grandstanding but the reality is like
0:50 look the game is going to change for big
0:52 tech. It will slow it down, but there's
0:54 no there no overbuilt, no bubble
0:57 concerns, and I view that as actually a
0:58 positive thing.
0:59 >> All right. And then Dave, before we let
1:01 you go, final question and the last word
1:02 to you. You actually run an ETF tied
1:05 towards that so-called Magnificent 7
1:07 trade, those mega cap tech and
1:09 communication services companies. I I
1:11 wonder, have you seen anything that you
1:13 can glean from the price action and the
1:15 flows around some of those types of ETFs
1:18 that makes you believe that we are maybe
1:20 due for any kind of a catalyst to the up
1:23 or downside with regard to investor
1:25 sentiment around mega cap tech?
1:29 >> Yeah, it's interesting. Of course, we
1:30 know the Magnificent 7 as a group was
1:32 sort of left for dead for most of 2026
1:34 and it really came roaring back uh in
1:36 September almost for its defensive
1:38 characteristics. um so investors could
1:40 play offense with its great revenue
1:42 growth um but also have that defensive
1:44 component uh when it comes to just how
1:46 much cash they generate. Now of course
1:48 the market started questioning um is
1:50 that cash actually going to good uses
1:52 and does it does this buildout from
1:54 capex need to be funded with debt? Um
1:56 but if it's interesting when we look at
1:57 the flows into our magnificent 7 ETF
2:00 mags um or conversely our Neocloud ETF
2:05 Ncloud um it's really really fascinating
2:08 because to you know to the earlier point
2:10 uh if if anything actually the
2:12 hyperscalers may actually in a weird way
2:15 may continue to benefit from this
2:16 because they have the compute available.
2:18 um it's going to be more valuable if the
2:20 demand is there and some of the
2:22 companies that Nvidia has really been
2:24 you know fostering on this new cloud
2:26 buildout um are the ones that are
2:28 getting hammered worse. So again, we may
2:30 end up in an environment as much as
2:32 investors have sort of been looking for
2:34 areas outside of big tech where netn net
2:37 big tech ends up as the winner once
2:39 again.
Experts assess the fallout from Nvidia's spy scandal and what it means for AI stocks full transcript
0:44 Let's get to the story of the morning, Becky. Nvidia CEO
0:47 Jensen Huang admitting he had an affair with a woman who's been
0:51 accused of being a Chinese spy. The company has opened an
0:54 investigation into that relationship. I actually bought
0:57 it for the first time in July when the stock was at 200, so
1:02 obviously now underwater. At the time, I thought the valuation
1:06 was so compelling. I mean, it was trading at that time 18
1:09 times forward estimates for a company that's going to grow in
1:12 the next two years, 70% of revenues.
1:15 It traded at that time cheaper than Hershey's, and to me, and
1:19 to me, that was just such a disconnect, and it had also
1:23 underperformed the SOXX by 50 percent year to date. So those
1:27 were all the reasons. I think the fundamentals are amazing,
1:30 but the fundamentals throw that right out the window. The New
1:33 York Times reporting on Tuesday that President Trump was aware
1:36 of allegations that Jensen Huang of Nvidia was dating a woman who
1:41 allegedly was a Chinese spy, and not only that, the president was
1:44 made aware of those allegations on Air Force One on his way to
1:49 China last spring for his summit with Xi Jinping. The drama of
1:52 all of this is the minute-by-minute tick-tock,
1:55 because you remember that last spring there was this question
1:58 of why Jensen Huang wasn't on the manifest for the Air Force
2:02 One trip to China when so many other technology executives of
2:06 prominence were on that list. I want to know what kind of
2:09 influence
2:14 has been very active in lobbying against legislation that would
2:20 prohibit advanced chip sales to China, and they've been very
2:23 much active in promoting this idea that we want to sell as
2:27 much as we can to keep China dependent on us. Nvidia can
2:32 produce really a limited number of chips. Were they giving some
2:36 kind of preference to China, and how did that affect the supply
2:39 of chips to American companies because we want to win this AI
2:43 competition, and clearly this CCP influence has multiple
2:49 concerns raised. There's two good corporate strategy reasons
2:54 for Nvidia to want to sell into China. The first is the one that
2:57 you mentioned: simply diversifying the customer base.
3:01 If OpenAI is the only one buying the chips, then they have a veto
3:04 over every decision that NVIDIA wants to make. The second is
3:08 NVIDIA is trying to defend the strength of its CUDA software
3:12 moat. Effectively, the more people who use CUDA, the harder
3:17 it is to come up with competing chips. Even if they're
3:19 attractive on hardware, they won't be competitive on software
3:23 ecosystem. But those are two good reasons from a corporate
3:26 strategy perspective. But they are overwhelmed by the reality
3:30 of the geopolitical concerns. China is willing to spend
3:34 whatever it takes. They're willing to ban whatever they
3:37 have to ban. They're willing to steal whatever they have to
3:39 steal to get off of Nvidia technology, and all Nvidia is
3:44 doing is strengthening a bunch of cloud giants in China who are
3:49 absolutely committed to getting off of Nvidia technology once
3:54 it's ready. We've seen now Kevin Cramer, senator from North
3:58 Dakota, Republican, widely respected on Capitol Hill,
4:02 saying that he feels that Jensen Huang is simply a national
4:06 security risk. That anything involving these highly sensitive
4:10 chips and allegations of Chinese spying means that Jensen Huang
4:14 should step down. There's no question that Congress is going
4:17 to push for a complete ban on the sale of advanced
4:20 semiconductors into China. That was President Biden's decision
4:23 four years ago, and it had tremendous Republican as well as
4:27 Democratic support. And just looking at the comments from
4:30 Capitol Hill in the last 24 to 48 hours, close the loopholes.
4:34 Don't allow Nvidia, Intel, AMD to sell the advanced
4:38 semiconductors into China. And the reason is because we don't
4:41 want that technology in the hands of the People's Liberation
4:44 Army to compete with our military. We certainly also
4:47 don't want to give Chinese tech firms a leg up. The two places
4:50 where I think there are some important points of concern are
4:53 one, you know, whether or not investors are going to be are
4:56 going to be trading this news in advance of earnings, and two,
5:00 whether or not we have to think about export controls that are
5:03 going to actually be a little bit tighter. And right now, you
5:07 know, there is something like an estimate of up to 20% of the
5:11 data center revenue coming from Nvidia that could be going, you
5:15 know, to Singapore. So that's a really, really big chunk. And
5:17 so, if the export controls tighten, then I think it creates
5:19 a structural problem, but that has something less to do, I
5:22 think, with the founder and a little bit more to do with the
5:24 United States and the company itself. Jensen Huang is
5:27 resigning effective immediately. This was kind of I felt like we
5:30 were kind of on
5:33 smoke watch for the Pope throughout this time after
5:36 hearing this news last night. So Jensen Huang saying that he is
5:38 resigning.
5:39 Immediately from Nvidia, Nvidia shares, which have been down
5:42 more than 8% this morning, now down by about nine, nine and a
5:45 half percent. Today looks like what we see as a near-term
5:48 washout, and I say near-term carefully because this story may
5:52 have legs. We don't know the China espionage part of the
5:55 story, but we know the Jensen story is done, and what they've
5:58 done today, I think, assuaged one major fear. All right, what
6:02 happens? Is Jensen going to stay? Is he going to go? We have
6:04 Colette Kress. You know the smart person in the room. She's
6:07 been there since 2013.
6:09 She's going to handle this earnings call with class. And
6:12 you know, unfortunately, we're not going to focus on the
6:14 earnings. They're going to be the guy should be solid, but
6:16 we're going to focus on what is next. I think you could argue,
6:19 given where the stock is, that this could be a clearing event
6:22 for the company. The stock is now trading at 10 times GAAP
6:26 earnings on calendar '27.
6:30 It's going to generate over 300 billion dollars in free cash
6:32 flow next year. We think that there is certainly a lot of
6:37 talent in the company. Certainly, retention of that
6:39 talent becomes extremely important going forward.
6:42 It's Friday, folks. We've actually made it here. Forget
6:45 about the 13. We'll take that as a lucky day. But it is Friday,
6:48 and we have made it to this point so far. So yay for us!
6:51 We got shares of Nvidia this morning. Let's show you where
6:54 they stand. That stock fell as much as 14% yesterday, but
6:57 recovered to the end of the day, just about down about 4% in
7:02 total. $1.7 trillion, though, of Nvidia's market cap has been
7:06 wiped out since the stock's peak last month. And now lawmakers
7:09 are eager to get former CEO Jensen Huang to D.C. for
7:13 testimony on the scandal that led to his ouster. We learned
7:16 earlier yesterday that Wong has agreed to testify before
7:19 Thanksgiving.
7:20 I can tell you there was coordination.
7:22 Treasury, War, USTR, and State they were in favor of putting
7:29 MegaSpeed on the entity list for months. But Commerce has the
7:33 pen. Commerce BIS has the pen, and you will have to have to ask
7:37 them about their internal processes. It's important to to
7:41 look at how markets have absorbed everything. The S&P
7:44 equal weight hit an all-time high last week, so broader
7:47 stocks are absorbing the news well. The handoff has been going
7:51 on for some period of time, from just seven names to the the
7:54 broader index. And the one thing we all know for sure is that the
7:57 AI demand is not going away. What company out there is going
8:01 to stop using it? The large companies, in particular, are
8:04 all scaling it very rapidly. So the demand is there, and and
8:08 markets are going to figure out a way to satisfy that demand.
Mad Money 11/13/26 full transcript
0:01 My mission is simple, to make you money.
0:05 I'm here to level the playing field for
0:06 all investors. There's always a market
0:09 somewhere and I promise to help you find
0:11 it. Mad Money starts now.
0:17 Hey, I'm Kramer. Welcome to Mad Money.
0:19 Welcome to Kramer America. I do my
0:21 friends. I'm just trying to make a
0:23 little money for you. It's my job, not
0:24 just entertain, but to put everything in
0:26 context. So call me 1800 743 CBC. Tweet
0:29 me, Jim Kramer. Investing isn't easy,
0:31 but it can be a whole lot easier and
0:33 much less daunting with a little
0:35 instruction. The whole business of
0:37 managing your money is made infinitely
0:39 more confusing by all the arcane
0:41 technology and authentic Wall Street
0:44 gibberish
0:46 you need to wait through to learn
0:48 anything about a stock or its underlying
0:49 business. If you're not clued into the
0:51 jargon, it can sound like the
0:52 professionals are speaking an entirely
0:53 different language. You got to remember
0:55 that there's an entire industry of
0:56 people who need you to be happily
0:58 convinced that investing is too hard for
1:00 you. That ordinary people just can't do
1:02 it. And that the safest thing to do is
1:04 to give your money to a pro. Hey, by the
1:06 way, that's a huge reason why I started
1:08 my charitable trust. When you join the
1:10 CNBC investing club, our goal is to show
1:12 you that you can do it yourself and to
1:14 teach you how it's done. Of course,
1:16 maybe giving your money to a
1:18 professional is right move for some of
1:19 you. Of course, maybe you don't have the
1:20 time. But if you put in a little effort,
1:22 if you do the homework, then I think you
1:24 can do at least as well as the pros or a
1:26 lowcost index fund, possibly the better
1:29 comparison. Because in any given year, a
1:31 lot of the pros really lose the index
1:32 funds. The fact of the matter is that
1:34 the financial industry is full of people
1:35 who are just after your fees. They're
1:38 more interested in taking your money
1:40 than in making you money. And if you're
1:42 a hedge fund or a mutual fund manager
1:44 trying to fund raise, you've got every
1:46 incentive to keep regular people sadly
1:49 ignorant. Why would they make any of
1:51 this investing stuff sound accessible
1:53 when they could make it sound
1:54 impenetrable? If it sounds too
1:56 straightforward, it's harder for them to
1:57 raise money and harder to convince
1:59 people, convince you to pay high
2:01 management fees. They're kind of like
2:03 the Wizard of Oz. They don't want you
2:05 peeking at the man behind the curtain.
2:07 They don't want you to understand
2:08 because if you did, then you'd take
2:10 control of your own finances. you pick
2:12 your own stocks and not pay someone else
2:15 potentially exorbitant fees to do the
2:17 things you are perfectly capable of
2:19 doing yourself. And after all these
2:21 years doing the show, I know you can do
2:22 it. And that's where I come in. See, I'm
2:24 pulling back the curtain and explaining
2:26 everything. Because while authentic Wall
2:28 Street gibberish can sound complex,
2:32 even impenetrable, it's not rocket
2:35 science or brain surgery. You don't need
2:37 to go to business school or work at an
2:39 investment bank to understand it. You
2:41 can comprehend all the mystical sounding
2:43 vocabulary that we throw around here as
2:45 long as you have a translator, a coach
2:47 like me who can explain what the darn
2:49 words mean. I want you to think of me as
2:52 a defector. Someone who played for the
2:54 other team, managing $500 million of
2:56 already rich people's money at my old
2:58 hedge fund, but who's now playing for
3:00 you, teaching you how to navigate your
3:02 way through the minefield of the stock
3:04 market every weekn night here on Mad
3:06 Money and of course constantly for the
3:08 CNBC Investing Club. Forget about the Da
3:10 Vinci Code. Forget Enigma. Forget the
3:12 NAVO code talkers. To be a great
3:14 investor, first you have to break the
3:15 Wall Street code. And I'm here to help
3:17 you crack it. That's why tonight I'm
3:19 giving you my Wall Street gibberish to
3:21 plain English dictionary. Consider a
3:23 glossery of the most important terms
3:25 you'll absolutely must understand if
3:27 you're going to actively manage your own
3:28 portfolio of individual stocks the way I
3:30 want you to. words and concepts that
3:32 many people in the financial industry
3:33 don't want you to get your heads around
3:35 because then you might actually feel
3:37 empowered enough to pull your money out
3:39 of their expensive mutual funds.
3:43 And hey, even if you're not a pro, you
3:46 may not know enough. So why not take
3:47 advantage of my 40 plus years of
3:49 investing experience to give yourself an
3:51 extra edge. Let's start with a couple of
3:53 extremely important terms that go hand
3:55 in hand. Cyclical and secular. Now, you
3:59 hear these all the time, yet no one but
4:01 me ever bothers to explain what they
4:03 mean, even though they're crucial when
4:05 it comes to picking stocks. Cyclical has
4:07 nothing to do with the spin cycle on
4:09 your washing machine or Vagner's ring
4:11 cycle. Somewhat my classical music. And
4:14 secular isn't about the separation of
4:16 church and state or or public versus
4:18 parochial schools. Oh yes, and kudos to
4:21 the late great Lou Rukiser who first
4:23 cracked that cyclical washing machine
4:24 joke. And I've always remembered it's
4:26 probably been about 50 years now. We say
4:28 a company's cyclical if it needs a
4:29 strong economy in order to grow. It's
4:31 cyclical because it depends on the
4:33 business cycle. Cyclical cycle. So
4:35 metals and mining companies and oil and
4:37 gas really any kind of raw materials
4:39 plus most of the industrials are
4:40 cyclical. The home builders are
4:42 cyclical. The oil makers are cyclical.
4:43 The commodity chemical makers like DA
4:45 are cyclical. You want a bunch of copper
4:47 and iron mines like BHP. That's the
4:49 definition of cyclical. These companies
4:51 are all hostage to the vicissitudes of
4:53 the economy. When the economy heats up,
4:55 they earn a lot more money. and were
4:57 willing to pay more for those earnings.
4:59 And when the economy slows down or
5:01 shifts into a recession mode, they earn
5:04 a lot less money and investors pay less
5:06 for their shares. I always say the
5:08 sickles are boom and bust names.
5:11 Ah, secular growth company on the other
5:13 hand is one where the earnings keep
5:14 coming regardless of the economy's
5:16 overall health. Think anything you eat,
5:19 drink, brush your teeth with or use as
5:21 medication. So you've got consumer
5:22 staples like Proctor and Gamble or Cross
5:25 the foods companies like General Mills,
5:27 the drug stocks like Fizer or Merc or
5:29 Eli Liy. These are the classic recession
5:31 proof names that you want to buy when
5:34 the economy slows down. Investors flock
5:36 to the companies that can generate safe
5:38 consistent earnings. Uh unless the GLP-1
5:42 drugs actually really take over the
5:44 world because you don't stop eating food
5:46 or brushing your teeth just because of
5:48 recession. Okay. So, why is this the
5:51 secular versus cyclical distinction so
5:52 important? Why is it the first piece of
5:54 Wall Street jargon I'm translating for
5:56 you? Because it helps you figure out how
5:58 much companies can earn in a given
6:00 environment. And because it matters to
6:01 the big institutional money managers,
6:03 the guys who have so much cash to throw
6:05 around that they're buying and selling
6:06 pretty much defines the whole market at
6:08 least in the short term. See, the whole
6:11 hedge fund playbook is about when to buy
6:13 and sell cyclical stocks or secular ones
6:15 based on how economies around the world
6:17 are doing. This is what drives the
6:20 decision-m process. Now, in the old
6:21 days, 50% of the performance of any
6:23 individual stock came from its sector,
6:25 which is just a fancy word for the
6:27 segment of the economy a stock falls
6:28 into, like tech, energy, machinery,
6:31 healthcare, finance. And when it comes
6:32 to sectors, much of their moves are
6:34 driven by whether they fall into the
6:35 secular or cyclical camps. These days,
6:38 it's much more uh than 50%. And that's
6:41 really thanks to the rise of sector
6:42 ETFs. You don't want to own much in the
6:45 way of cyclical when the economy is
6:46 slowing. These stocks are simply going
6:48 to get crushed because their earnings
6:50 tend to fall apart as they have during
6:53 every meaningful slowdown sell
6:56 >> including Chinese slowdowns and there's
6:58 nothing about that you can do it what do
7:00 you do but by the same token when
7:02 business heats up and the cyclicals are
7:03 all doing well nobody wants to own the
7:06 boring consistent secular growth names
7:08 the food and the drugs and you won't h
7:10 make as much money in them during those
7:12 periods either you have to accept that
7:14 you're not a trader you just accept it
7:16 now you always want some cyclical stocks
7:18 and some secular stocks in your
7:19 portfolio because you can never be
7:20 completely sure where the economy is
7:21 headed. But when business looks like
7:23 it's booming, you want a lot more
7:24 cyclical exposure. And when business
7:26 looks like it's falling off a cliff,
7:30 you want a lot more secular exposure.
7:32 The bottom line, investing ain't easy,
7:34 but it doesn't have to be mystifying.
7:36 You just need to learn the language,
7:38 know the difference between cyclical and
7:40 secular growers, and always stay
7:43 diversified. Shane in Alabama. Shane,
7:47 >> hey Jim, thanks for taking my call.
7:50 >> Absolutely.
7:50 >> When when building a balanced portfolio,
7:54 is the 6040 rule still fundamental? And
7:58 how much of that percentage should be in
8:00 cash?
8:01 >> Okay, I'm blowing out of all that. I
8:03 think that we want to bet against our
8:04 don't want to bet against ourselves. We
8:06 want to bet with ourselves. I am betting
8:08 that people are gonna have a long life,
8:09 hopefully a happy life. So, we're buying
8:11 and keeping a lot of stock right almost
8:13 to the end. when you're 60 70 I still
8:16 think that's young and I think you
8:18 should have 70% stock. I know that's
8:20 higher than what I've usually said but I
8:22 just think that you're not going to get
8:23 the return from bonds then people that
8:25 people want and I'd rather have you in
8:27 stock and then take it down to 30 than
8:29 20 uh 30 or 20 and if depending upon how
8:32 you feel about yourself. I want you to
8:34 be thinking about living long and I
8:35 think you'll live longer. That's my own
8:37 psychology. Joseph in Florida. Joseph.
8:41 >> Hey Jim. How's it going?
8:42 >> Not bad Joseph. How about you? Thank you
8:44 for calling.
8:46 >> It's doing I'm doing awesome, man. Good.
8:48 >> Uh, so I wanted to get some insight on a
8:52 529 plan and or an index fund for my
8:55 one-year-old child, Jared.
8:57 >> All right. So, you look, 529 plan is
8:59 perfect and put them in in a low fee S&P
9:03 500 index fund. I did that for my kids
9:05 and they are eternally grateful and
9:07 you're going to do it for yours, too.
9:09 How about Edna in New York? Edna.
9:12 >> Booyah. Mr. Kramer,
9:14 >> I'm a new member of your investing club
9:16 and wanted to thank you for all I've
9:18 earned so far.
9:19 >> You turned my husband and I into active
9:21 investors.
9:22 >> Well, I want you to be informed active
9:23 investors. Absolutely. How can I help?
9:26 >> I recently rolled over an old employee
9:29 IRA into a brokerage account and have 20
9:32 to 30 years before I'll need the funds.
9:35 >> Right.
9:35 >> Right now, it's sinning in a money
9:36 market account earning 5%. So, would you
9:40 recommend I put it in an S&P 500?
9:43 >> Here's what I want you to do. I want you
9:44 to take starting now, every month, take
9:48 a 12th of that money and put it to work.
9:50 We're not going to put it all to work at
9:51 one level. 1112th. And then we get to if
9:54 we have a really bad month, I want you
9:56 to double down and put 16th in. And when
9:59 we're finished in the third and fourth
10:00 quarters, well, we'll figure out whether
10:02 you need to have a little more cash. But
10:04 that's how I want you to invest that
10:06 money. That's long-term money and that
10:07 should be in stock, not bond. But over
10:10 time, not all at once. Investing isn't
10:12 easy, but it doesn't have demystifying.
10:14 You just need to learn the language.
10:15 Homemade money tonight. Forget Miriam
10:17 Webster. I'm helping you demystify all
10:19 that Wall Street speak. That's what you
10:21 need. From PE multibles to Garp and much
10:23 more. I'm cracking on my dictionary to
10:25 help you navigate the market and take
10:26 charge of your portfolio. That's what I
10:29 want. So stay with Kramer.
10:37 Don't miss a second of MadMoney. Follow
10:40 Jim Kramer on X. Have a question? Tweet
10:42 Kramer #madmentions.
10:45 Send Jim an email to [email protected]
10:48 or give us a call at 1800743CNBC.
10:53 Miss something? Head to
10:54 madmoney.cnbc.com.
11:08 Tonight, I'm helping you translate the
11:10 cryptic and occasionally unfathomable
11:12 terminology that makes owning stocks so
11:14 darn difficult. Yep, I'm giving you the
11:17 phrase book to navigate your way through
11:19 the world of investing. Hey, but why do
11:20 we call it the Michelin Guide to Fine
11:22 Stock Tining? Consider it the televised
11:25 encyclopedia of crime America for
11:26 tearing back the cloak of mystery that
11:29 can make managing your own money seem
11:30 like an impossible task. The process of
11:32 picking stock shouldn't seem as
11:33 difficult as say conducting triple
11:35 bypass heart surgery on yourself. And
11:37 you don't have to be Stephen Hawking or
11:39 Albert Einstein to understand this
11:40 stuff. Although with the the way a lot
11:42 of the pros talk about stocks, I bet
11:44 even Einstein would have a tough time
11:46 figuring out what the heck they're
11:47 saying. Now, I just explained the
11:49 difference between cyclical companies,
11:51 think industrial smoke stack businesses
11:53 that need a healthy economy in order to
11:55 grow earnings versus secular growth
11:57 names. Think toothpaste, okay, that
11:59 consistently expand at about the same
12:01 pace regardless of where we are in the
12:02 business cycle. How you have to sell the
12:04 cyclicals and buy secular growth when
12:06 the economy starts to slow, then do the
12:08 reverse as it starts to pick up steam.
12:10 This is the playbook that all the hedge
12:12 funds use. And even though these hedge
12:14 funds can often behave like herd
12:16 animals, wilderbeasts who often buy and
12:18 sell the same stocks at the same time,
12:20 they operate this way because their
12:22 playbook works. The reason for that has
12:25 to do with another piece of Wall Street
12:27 gibberish lexicon that you absolutely
12:29 must know if you're going to pick stocks
12:32 by yourself. It's called the price
12:34 toearnings multiple or PE
12:39 multiple or just the multiple. They all
12:41 refer to the same thing and it's the
12:43 cornerstone of how we value stocks. In
12:44 fact, when you hear talking heads
12:46 pontificate about how some stock has
12:47 become overvalued or undervalued,
12:49 they're almost always really talking
12:50 about the price or multiple. When you
12:52 hear someone say that Pepsi is more
12:53 expensive than Coke, okay, they don't
12:55 mean that Coke's cheap because it's
12:56 trading in the 50s while Pepsi is
12:58 trading in the triple digits. No, the
13:00 share price tells you nothing about a
13:02 stock's valuation visa v another stock.
13:04 To make any kind of apples to apples
13:06 comparison, you take a step back. See,
13:08 when you buy a stock, you're actually
13:10 buying paying for a piece small piece of
13:12 a company's future earning stream.
13:14 That's what the stock is. So, to value a
13:17 stock, you have to look at where it's
13:18 trading relative to the earnings per
13:20 share, which you often see rendered as
13:22 EPS. And that's what the multiple allows
13:24 you to do. Now, here's the basic
13:26 algebra, not even math, that any fourth
13:29 grader, I think, should be able to do.
13:31 The share price P equals the earnings
13:33 per share E times the multiple M. Okay,
13:37 the multiple tells you how much
13:38 investors are willing to pay for a
13:40 company's earnings. We don't care that
13:41 Coke stock might be at $55. We care that
13:44 it sells for 19 times earnings. We don't
13:46 care that Pepsico say might be at the
13:47 time 165. We care that it sells for more
13:50 than 20 times earnings. Or to put it
13:52 another way, the multiple is the special
13:53 sauce of valuation. The main ingredient
13:55 in that sauce, growth. How much bigger
13:58 the earnings will be next year than they
13:59 were this year and the year after that
14:01 and the year after that on and on. The
14:04 stocks of companies with faster growth
14:05 tend to get rewarded with higher price
14:07 earnings multiples. Why? Okay, remember
14:09 the multiple is all about what we're
14:10 willing to pay for future earnings. And
14:12 the more rapidly a business grows, the
14:14 bigger its earnings will be down the
14:15 road. So if a fast growing software sell
14:17 stock sells for, let's say, at 25 times
14:19 earnings, that doesn't make it more
14:20 expensive than a slow but steady grower
14:23 like Pepsi at 20 times earnings, the
14:25 faster grower actually deserves the
14:27 bigger multiple. Now, here's where it
14:29 gets real interesting. Price to earnings
14:31 multiples aren't static. In different
14:33 markets, people pay more or less for the
14:35 same amount of earnings. When they pay
14:37 more, we call that multiple expansion.
14:39 And when they pay less, it's called
14:41 multiple contraction. Two more terms
14:43 that sound much more complicated than
14:44 they really are. For example, whenever
14:46 interest rates skyrocket, making the
14:48 bond market competition a lot more
14:50 attractive. We see marketwide multiples
14:53 contract because everybody's future
14:55 earnings are suddenly worth less by
14:57 comparison. Of course, the earnings
14:58 aren't static either. When you buy a
15:00 stock, you're either making a bet that
15:02 the E or the M part of the valuation
15:05 equation is heading higher. So, what
15:08 goes into the earnings? How do you make
15:09 sure that they're increasing and not
15:11 about the collapse? Okay, here's some
15:12 more vocabulary. When you hear people
15:14 talking about a company's bottom line or
15:17 perhaps net income, they all mean the
15:19 same things. Earnings, we call it the
15:21 bottom line because the number is the
15:23 bottom figure on a company's income
15:24 statement. to figure out how quickly a
15:26 company's earnings could grow in the
15:28 future. You have to look for clues when
15:29 it reports its quarterly results. That's
15:31 why I'm always telling you to listen to
15:32 the conference calls. By the way, we do
15:34 that homework for you in the investing
15:36 club with all the charitable trust
15:37 holdings. That's why I think it's such a
15:38 good idea to member of the club. Step
15:40 one to getting your head around the
15:41 future earnings is trajectory. You need
15:44 to look at the top line. Oh boy, another
15:46 unnecessary piece of Wall Street
15:47 gibberish that's totally interchangeable
15:49 with revenues OR SALES. THEY ALL MEAN
15:51 THE SAME THING. YOU want to see strong
15:53 revenue growth, which tells you that
15:54 there's demand for a company's product.
15:56 This is ultimately the key to the
15:57 ability of most businesses to
15:58 sustainably grow their earnings long
16:00 term. And that's why it's especially
16:02 important for younger, smaller companies
16:03 to have fast growing revenues. Oh, and
16:05 investors will really pay up for
16:07 accelerating revenue growth.
16:08 Accelerating revenue growth. Let's see.
16:10 A RG ARG, which means the sales are
16:13 growing at a higher and higher rate.
16:15 With a more mature company, it should be
16:16 able to turn its revenues into profits
16:18 by cutting costs and then it can return
16:20 those profits to shareholders in the
16:21 form of dividend or potentially a
16:23 buyback. Beyond the top line and the
16:25 bottom line, it's also crucial to
16:26 consider the gross margin, which is in
16:28 no way disgusting and not the least, but
16:30 marginal. The gross margin tells you
16:32 what's left after you subtract the cost
16:34 of goods sold from the sales. It's a key
16:37 profitability metric. To figure out the
16:39 gross margins, you have to consider the
16:40 competition, the cost of production, and
16:42 the cost of doing business in general.
16:44 Businesses with cutthroat competition
16:46 like supermarkets tend to have terrible
16:48 margins while a virtual monopoly like
16:50 Microsoft has margins that are down at
16:53 they're obese. In some industries the
16:55 margins can vary widely. Take the oil
16:57 bis where the margins swing up and down
16:59 with the price of crude. In that case
17:00 you need to watch supply across the
17:02 whole industry. Oil production for
17:03 energy inventories for retail uh too
17:05 much oil pushes price down right. Too
17:08 much retail inventory forces store uh
17:10 stores to discount their goods
17:11 aggressively in order to make space for
17:13 the new merchandise. Both are what we
17:15 call margin killers. So here's the
17:16 bottom line. You need to know the
17:18 vocabulary before you can evaluate a
17:19 stock. When you're comparing, look at
17:22 the price toearnings multiple or PE, the
17:25 growth rate, the top line, the bottom
17:28 line, and the gross margins. I know this
17:30 might sound basic to many of you, but
17:32 I'm here to educate people and I don't
17:34 want anybody trying to pick stocks
17:36 without a firm understanding of the
17:38 basics. It's another great reason, by
17:40 the way, to join the CBC Investing Club.
17:43 Mad Money is back after the break.
17:46 Coming up, finance is full of $5 words,
17:49 but don't despair. Kramer is breaking
17:51 down the Wall Street lexicon. Some key
17:53 terms made easy next.
18:09 Tonight, I'm going into pen and teller
18:11 mode, demystifying all the overly
18:13 complicated technical sounding Wall
18:14 Street gibberish that you hear
18:16 constantly but might not understand. I
18:18 want to translate the most overused,
18:20 underexplained terms in the business,
18:22 putting them into a language that's fit
18:23 for human consumption. Consider the show
18:25 your Wall Street to English dictionary,
18:28 a televised glossery that'll help you
18:30 navigate your way through tough markets
18:32 and the tough sounding terminology that
18:34 keeps so many people out of stocks. Not
18:37 doing myself justice. I'm not and I got
18:39 to help you to understand this stuff so
18:42 you can be better. Of course, joining
18:43 the club is going to help. Now, again,
18:45 all this investing terminology sounds
18:47 difficult because the pros who speak
18:48 Wall Street chippers fluently, well,
18:50 they want it to sound difficult. They're
18:52 the opposite of me. They want you
18:54 terrified. They want you feeling totally
18:56 ignorant
18:57 and at a complete loss when it comes to
18:59 managing your own money. My mission is
19:01 just the opposite of theirs. I am here
19:04 to try to enlighten you to teach because
19:06 I know that you can do better for
19:07 yourself than the professionals. I've
19:09 been down here for 40 years on Wall
19:10 Street. I know this stuff. And most of
19:12 the professionals, they they kind of
19:14 just want your fees. I'm not managing
19:16 anyone else's money. I don't own stocks
19:18 except for my charitable trust. So, I
19:19 give away my winnings to charity and I
19:21 walk you through the whole process of
19:22 running the trust for the CNBC Investing
19:24 Club. It's the anti- well establishment.
19:28 It's not, look, it's not just enough to
19:29 come out here and tell you which stocks
19:31 I like because you can't own them if you
19:33 can't understand them. Knowing what you
19:35 own is a must. It's one of my cardinal
19:37 rules. Says, if you don't have a good
19:39 grasp of how you of what you own and
19:42 what your holdings are, you won't have
19:44 any idea what to do when the stocks turn
19:45 against you. And believe me, inevitably,
19:47 at some point, they will. You can't know
19:49 when to hold them and know when to fold
19:51 them, in the immortal words of stock
19:52 sage Kenny Rogers, unless you know what
19:54 the heck it is that you're actually
19:56 holding and what might make you fold.
20:00 Unfortunately, the profusion of arcane
20:01 terminology on Wall Street makes it much
20:03 harder to know what you will. So, let's
20:05 continue our vocabulary lesson with
20:06 another ultra important piece of
20:08 verbiage that's hardly ever explained to
20:10 you, even though it's used constantly.
20:12 Riskreward.
20:14 The riskreward analysis pretty much
20:16 defines short-term stock picking. So,
20:18 what does it mean? All right, let's
20:19 break it down into into its component
20:21 parts. Assessing risk is all about
20:22 figuring out the downside, how much you
20:24 potentially stand to lose in a given
20:26 stock, how far it can considerly fall in
20:28 the near term. Assessing the reward, on
20:30 the other hand, means figuring out the
20:31 potential upside, how much the stock
20:33 could rally if everything goes right.
20:35 Too many investors only focus on the
20:37 potential upside when they're analyzing
20:39 stocks. And that is a great great
20:40 mistake. It's much more important for
20:42 you to understand the risk side of the
20:43 equation because the pain from a big
20:45 loss hurts a lot more than the pleasure
20:47 from an equivalent size gain. Trust me.
20:51 But how exactly do we figure out the
20:52 riskreward? Okay, these are determined
20:55 by two different cohorts of investors.
20:57 The reward, the upside is defined by how
20:58 much growth oriented money managers
21:00 could be willing to pay for a stock.
21:02 They create the top. The risk, the
21:04 downside is created by what what uh
21:06 valueoriented money managers do. What
21:08 value oriented money managers would pay
21:11 on the way down. They create the bottom.
21:14 To figure out the risk, you need to
21:15 consider where the value guys will start
21:16 buying on the way down. To solve for the
21:18 reward, you need to think about where
21:19 even the most bullish of growth guys
21:21 would start selling on the way up. When
21:23 you when asked, I usually boil the
21:26 riskreward down to something quick and
21:27 dirty like five up, three down. But how
21:29 do I get there? How do you know whether
21:31 growth money money managers will start
21:33 selling and value guys will start
21:35 buying? Okay, for that you need some
21:37 insight into how they think and that
21:38 requires translating another piece of
21:40 esoteric Wall Street lingo. It's called
21:43 growth at a reasonable price. I really
21:45 believe this by the way growth at a
21:46 reasonable price aka a GARP. When we
21:49 talk about growth at a reasonable price,
21:50 that's not subjective. It's a method of
21:51 analyzing stocks first popularized by
21:53 the legendary Peter Lynch by comparing a
21:55 stock's growth rate to its price to
21:56 earnings moldable. If you want to figure
21:58 out the maximum the growth guys would be
22:00 willing to pay for a stock, you need to
22:02 be able to look at the world according
22:03 to Garp.
22:07 You want to learn more from Peter Lynch?
22:08 It's easy. Go to Amazon and buy One Up
22:10 on Wall Street or Beat the Street. These
22:12 are two of the most in important
22:14 investing books ever written. Now,
22:16 here's a quick and dirty rule of thumb
22:17 that's hardly ever let me down, although
22:19 there are some exceptions. a rule that
22:21 can really help us figure out when a
22:23 stock might be overvalued or undervalued
22:25 based on what the growth and value
22:27 managers would be willing to pay. If a
22:29 stock has a price earnings multiple
22:30 that's lower than its growth rate, then
22:31 that stock's probably cheap. And any
22:33 stock selling at a multiple that's more
22:35 than twice the size of its growth rate,
22:38 probably too expensive. So, if a stock's
22:40 trading at 20 times earnings and it has
22:42 a growth rate of 10%. Then it probably
22:45 doesn't have much up more upside. It's
22:47 reached the two times growth ceiling.
22:49 Always remember that. Here's another
22:51 piece of Wall Street gibberish that can
22:52 help simplify the process. The PEG
22:54 ratio, PEG. That's the price to earnings
22:57 to growth rate or the PE multiple
23:00 divided by a stock's long-term growth
23:02 rate. A PEG of one or less is extremely
23:05 cheap and two or higher is prohibitively
23:08 expensive. Sell, sell, sell. A high
23:11 octane super fast grower could suffer 40
23:13 times earnings and still be inexpensive
23:15 because if it has a 40% plus long-term
23:17 growth rate giving it a peg of just one
23:20 right at the cheap end of the spectrum
23:21 and the growth keeps accel kept
23:22 accelerating sending the stock to a new
23:24 high after new high that makes sense to
23:26 me where did I come up with these
23:28 numbers observation the value investors
23:31 who will be attracted to stocks selling
23:32 at pegs of one or less create a floor
23:35 you'll usually be able to find a buyer
23:36 if a stock's multiples at or below its
23:38 growth rate the growth investors who
23:40 buying high multiple stocks hardly ever
23:42 pay more than twice the growth rate, a
23:44 peg of two, which means there's almost
23:46 no way that stocks go higher. So stick
23:48 with the example of Google back when it
23:50 still held that mega growth mojo with a
23:53 30% long-term growth rate. It would have
23:55 be become become a sell if it traded to
23:58 60 times earnings, just too darn high as
24:01 I have learned over and over and over
24:02 again since the show began oh so many
24:04 years ago. Like with any of of of my
24:07 methods or anyone else for that matter,
24:09 this one is rough approximation, a bit
24:12 of subjectivity. It's useful especially
24:14 when you're trying to figure out the
24:16 risk reward, but it's not always right
24:18 and it only applies to companies that
24:19 trade on earnings, not unprofitable
24:21 companies with stocks that trade on
24:23 sales. Plus, stocks will often get cheap
24:25 on an earnings basis simply because the
24:27 estimates are too high. You see this all
24:29 the time going into a slowdown. In those
24:31 cases, the stock could trade well below
24:32 the one times growth floor. its peg
24:35 could just keep sinking and sinking. And
24:37 the fact that it looks cheap, it's a
24:39 value trap. It's not a buy signal. On
24:42 the other hand, the best time to buy
24:43 cycle stocks, think the smoke stack
24:44 industrial types, is when their
24:46 multiples look outrageously expensive
24:48 because the earnings estimates are way
24:49 too low and need to be raised to catch
24:51 up with reality. That's happens when the
24:53 economy is bottoming and about to
24:55 rebound. The bottom line, know what you
24:57 own and know what others will pay for
24:59 it. That means you need to understand
25:01 the riskreward, the potential downside
25:04 and potential upside before you purchase
25:06 anything by figuring out where the
25:08 growth investors put in the ceiling and
25:10 where the value investors create the
25:13 floor. Nicholas in Nevada. Nicholas,
25:17 >> how's it going, Mr. Kramer? This is uh
25:19 Nick Michelle from Las Vegas, Nevada.
25:21 I'm a college freshman out here in
25:23 California trying to start my own
25:25 investment management company. I was
25:27 just looking for some quick advice and
25:28 kind of personal, I guess, advice on how
25:31 to run that from a freshman's
25:33 perspective.
25:34 >> Well, I'll tell you, you're young and
25:36 that means you have to go with higher
25:37 risk stocks than I typically talk about
25:39 on the show. Maybe some smaller cap
25:41 stocks, maybe some biotechs, maybe some
25:43 companies that are on the ground floor
25:44 of AI. I don't want you to be loaded up
25:47 with companies that are older because
25:49 you have your whole life to make it back
25:51 if they go away. Um, a lot of our older
25:53 viewers and middle middle-aged viewers
25:55 cannot afford that to happen. So, go
25:57 with high risk, potentially highreward
26:00 stocks. Mark in Iowa. Mark,
26:02 >> hi Jim. I'm a happy club member and
26:05 thanks for taking my call.
26:06 >> Thank you for being a member of the
26:07 club. It's terrific. How can I help?
26:09 >> Well, Jim, I have a real estate question
26:12 for you.
26:12 >> Okay.
26:13 >> Higher interest rates make it more
26:15 difficult for families to afford a new
26:17 mortgage. What effect will this have on
26:20 REITs containing single and multifamily
26:22 units?
26:23 >> Well, I think they're going to be under
26:24 pressure and I think it's natural that
26:26 you ask that question and it's one of
26:28 the reasons why I'm not recommending any
26:29 of those stocks because you correctly
26:32 have thought about what is the nemesis
26:35 of those particular stocks. Now, as long
26:37 as you understand the riskreward, the
26:38 GARP and the PEG ratio associated with
26:40 picking stocks, you're much better
26:42 prepared to know what you own and know
26:45 what your what others more importantly
26:47 will pay for it. Now, much more made
26:48 money. Do you know the difference
26:50 between a rotation and a correction? I'm
26:52 not done cracking the Wall Street code.
26:54 And you better be seated when Professor
26:56 Kramer opens the dictionary. Plus, my
26:58 colleague Jeff Marks and I are taking
27:00 all of your burning investing questions.
27:01 So stay with Kramer.
27:05 Coming up, what big investment lesson
27:07 can you learn from a bottle of milk?
27:09 Kramer's working till the cows come
27:11 home. Keep it here.
27:23 Managing your own money is a whole lot
27:25 less daunting than it seems when you
27:27 have a translator, someone like me, who
27:29 can help you decode the intentionally
27:31 obscure terminology that the experts use
27:33 to talk about stocks all the time. And
27:35 that's why I've been giving you my
27:36 televised Wall Street gibberish to
27:38 English dictionary so that you can see
27:40 through the mystery and understanding of
27:42 and understand. I got to get you to the
27:44 essentials of investing. It's the most
27:45 important thing I can do. That's what I
27:47 do for a living. So far, I've been
27:49 explaining the complicated sounding
27:50 pieces of jargon that are actually
27:52 pretty simple stuff we do every day at
27:54 the CBC Investing Club. But the
27:56 difficulty goes in two directions. Just
27:58 as there are many concepts that seem
27:59 misleadingly complicated, there are also
28:01 plenty of other terms that are much less
28:03 simple than they appear. Take the notion
28:05 of a trade versus the notion of
28:07 investment. A lot of people would say
28:08 these two words are interchangeable,
28:10 that there's no difference. But that
28:11 couldn't be further from the truth.
28:12 They're distinct. And in the immortal
28:14 words of those 90s stock gurus,
28:17 offspring, you got to keep them
28:18 separate. Isn't this just splitting hair
28:21 something that's not recommended for the
28:23 fally challenge like myself? Isn't it
28:24 cajuous tree? That's a SAT word of the
28:27 day that might send you searching for a
28:29 real dictionary. Nope. A trade is not
28:31 the same as an investment. And if you
28:33 treat the one like the other, if you
28:35 treat a trade, if you turn a trade into
28:37 investment, breaking my first
28:39 commandment of trading, then in true Mr.
28:41 key fashion alla best of the Rockies
28:43 Rocky three my prediction for your
28:45 portfolio is pain when you buy a stock
28:48 as a trade you're buying for a specific
28:50 catalyst some anticipated future event
28:53 you think will drive the stock higher
28:55 maybe the company's about to report its
28:56 quarterly results and you think it will
28:58 deliver better than expected numbers
28:59 although I don't recommend trying to
29:01 game earnings there's just too much
29:02 chaos and confusion in individual
29:04 earnings report which can cause the
29:06 stock to get clobbered even if it
29:07 delivered stellar numbers the catalyst
29:09 could be news about some event you're
29:11 predicting. For example, let's say a
29:12 pharma company getting FDA approval for
29:14 a big new drug or even just some
29:16 clinical trial data you think will be
29:18 positive. These are data points that can
29:19 send a stock story if they go your way.
29:22 So, when you make a trade going into it,
29:24 you know that there's a moment to buy
29:26 before the catalyst and a moment to sell
29:28 after the catalyst happens. Sometimes
29:29 your trades won't work out. The event
29:31 you're waiting for won't happen. Or
29:32 maybe the data point you're expecting
29:34 simply turns out to be less positive
29:36 than you expected. Either way, when you
29:38 buy a stock as a trade, it has a limited
29:40 shelf life. There's only a brief window
29:42 where you want to own it. Once the
29:44 window passes, you must sell. Hopefully,
29:46 you'll turn out to be the right it'll be
29:48 the right catalyst and you'll rack up a
29:49 nice game. If that happens, no point in
29:51 sticking around. Ring the register and
29:52 lock in your profits before they
29:54 evaporate. But if you turn out to be
29:56 wrong, well, guess what? You still need
29:58 to sell. I want you to think of it like
29:59 this. When you buy a bottle of milk, you
30:01 don't drink it after the expiration
30:03 date, right? You throw it away. The
30:05 logic of trading is pretty similar. You
30:06 can't just buy more and call it a
30:08 longerterm investment because without
30:10 the catalyst, you got no reason to own
30:12 the darn stock. And you never ever
30:14 should own anything without a reason.
30:16 I've watched an endless parade of people
30:18 lose money by turning trades into
30:19 investments. They come up with alibis
30:21 for staying in a stock long after its
30:23 expiration date. They're really fooling
30:25 themselves into believing they're doing
30:26 the right thing, and then more often
30:28 than not, they get crushed. So remember,
30:30 without a catalyst, you don't have a
30:31 trade. If you find yourself in that
30:33 position, then you better sell and cut
30:35 your losses. No catalyst, no point. An
30:39 investment, on the other hand, is based
30:40 on a long-term thesis. The idea that a
30:43 stock has the potential to make you
30:44 serious money over an extended period of
30:47 time. You're not just banking on one
30:49 specific catalyst. You're expecting many
30:51 good things will happen in the company's
30:53 not too distant future. And that's not
30:55 an excuse to buy a stock and then forget
30:57 about it, though. Investments can go
30:59 wrong, too. Which is why I'm always
31:02 telling you to keep examining your
31:04 stocks after you buy them. That's called
31:06 buy and homework, not buy and hold. Of
31:09 course, we help you with that homework
31:10 for our charitable trust teams in the
31:12 CBC Investing Club. So, when a stock you
31:14 like as an investment goes down in the
31:16 short term, it makes sense to buy more
31:18 as long as the fundamentals are still
31:19 sound. The corner here is that you don't
31:21 ring the register after the first time
31:22 the stock jumps in price. With an
31:24 investment, you're looking for a longer
31:26 gains, larger gains. And what you do is
31:29 you measure it not in terms of trade and
31:32 sell but a much longer period of time.
31:35 And again, that is what we do at the
31:37 investment club. Bottom line, not all
31:39 Wall Street gibberish is deceptively
31:41 complicated. Some of it's deceptively
31:43 simple, like the distinction between a
31:44 trade and an investment. Don't confuse
31:46 them. Remember, they're not the same.
31:48 And it's a big mistake to turn a trade
31:50 based on a catalyst, whether successful
31:52 or unsuccessful, into an investment,
31:54 which is a long-term bet on the future
31:57 of the business. Their money's back
31:59 after the break. Coming up, if only the
32:02 market were as reliable as Joe Deaggio.
32:05 When the tape turns red, remember the
32:07 Yankee Clipper. Kramer explains next.
32:20 Welcome back to the Wall Street
32:22 gibberish to plain English translation
32:24 guide edition of Mad Money. All night
32:26 I've been explaining overly arcane and
32:28 esoteric investing concepts and
32:30 financial jargon to help you become a
32:33 better investor and make the whole
32:34 process of managing your money seem less
32:36 daunting. So, what else do you need to
32:38 know? Okay, here's one of the most
32:39 dreaded and poorly understood terms in
32:41 the business. The correction. What a
32:43 euphemism. corrections went after the
32:45 market's been roaring and turns around
32:46 and then it gets crushed. Maybe the
32:48 climb of as much as 10% make you feel
32:50 like the world is ending. Of course, the
32:52 sky is falling and you never want to own
32:54 another stock again in your life. And
32:56 that's precisely the wrong reaction. It
32:59 may feel horrible, but stocks can come
33:00 back from corrections. They bounce back
33:02 from big declines all the time,
33:04 especially coming off a major run
33:05 higher. Think of it like this. When the
33:08 market goes on a 56game hitting streak
33:10 like Joe Deaggio and then doesn't get on
33:13 base the next day, that doesn't mean
33:14 you'll never make money again. It
33:16 doesn't mean all your holdings will be
33:17 pulverized. It's just what happens when
33:19 we go up say too far too fast. And
33:21 that's why you should expect
33:22 corrections. They can happen to an
33:24 individual stock, an index, the whole
33:26 market. They can even happen to bonds as
33:28 we saw in the great bond retreat that
33:30 started in 2022, then rage beginning in
33:32 the spring of 2023. And you'll most
33:35 likely never see these corrections
33:36 coming. So, you shouldn't beat yourself
33:39 up for not anticipating them. Selloffs
33:41 are a natural feature of the stock
33:43 market landscape. We don't have to like
33:45 them. I don't. But we do need to
33:47 acknowledge that they will happen no
33:48 matter what. So, you shouldn't get
33:50 flustered or worse, panic when they
33:53 inevitably smack you right in the face.
33:55 Let me give you another piece of
33:56 investing vocabulary. Execution. Now,
33:58 this is a tough one because it's
33:59 comparatively subjective. When we talk
34:01 about execution, we mean management's
34:02 ability to follow through with its
34:04 plans. When you own a stock, there are
34:06 all kinds of risks associated with
34:08 execution. Messed up mergers, uh, failed
34:10 new product launches, bad cost controls.
34:13 The number of ways a bad management team
34:14 can screw up in business is practically
34:16 infinite. That's one of the reasons why
34:18 I like companies with proven management
34:20 teams because they're much less likely
34:22 to make these kinds of unforced errors.
34:24 And it's a big reason why, for instance,
34:26 it's so important for you to pay
34:28 attention when I bring CEOs on the show
34:30 with those interviews. Nobody knows a
34:32 company better than the people running
34:33 it. And since you probably can't get
34:34 these CEOs on the phone yourself, you
34:36 want to hear what they have to say about
34:38 their business firsthand on the show.
34:41 This notion of execution is also crucial
34:43 when it comes to understanding why it's
34:44 worth paying up for best of breed
34:46 companies. Big emphasis there. Best of
34:48 breed. The top players in any given
34:50 industry almost always come with proven
34:52 executives. Best of breed stocks are
34:54 typically more expensive than their
34:55 cheaper competitors, but they're worth
34:57 the price. A good management team is
34:59 less likely to make mistakes and more
35:01 important less likely to get buried by
35:03 big problems and more likely to figure
35:05 out how to solve them. Finally, one last
35:07 piece of Wall Street chippers, the
35:09 dreaded rotation, which is just when
35:11 money flows out of one sector into
35:13 another or one big group into another
35:15 big group, like a cyclical to secular
35:18 rotation. The kind of thing we get when
35:20 the economy is slowing so the cycl go
35:22 out of style. Now, this is probably
35:24 completely antithetical to what you've
35:26 been told about the right way to invest.
35:28 The conventional wisdom is that you're
35:29 going to pick your own stocks. Something
35:31 which, by the way, the conventional
35:32 wisdom regards as being the height of
35:33 idiocy because you're not supposed to be
35:35 able to beat the market. See, they sell
35:37 you short. And then you should find high
35:39 quality companies and stick with them
35:40 through thick and thin. Then eventually,
35:42 if you hold out long enough, you'll make
35:44 some money. Now, this is this is a brain
35:47 dead philosophy of buy and hold that I
35:48 spend so much time trying to debunk to
35:50 you. It's a zombie ideology that refuses
35:53 to die, even though it's been utterly
35:54 discredited by the market's
35:55 performances. We're always teaching you
35:57 in the CBC Investing Club. That doesn't
35:59 mean that you should play the rotation
36:01 game and only own the group that's in
36:03 stylo. Not at all. Remember the need for
36:05 diversification. Another important piece
36:07 of investing vocabulary, which simply
36:08 means making sure you don't have all
36:10 your eggs in one basket. One sector
36:12 basket. To me, you're diversified when
36:14 no more than 20% of your portfolio is in
36:16 any single sector. That way, you won't
36:18 get annihilated. If for example a sector
36:20 rotation takes down your cyclical stocks
36:22 because you have some secular growth
36:24 names that are holding up much better or
36:25 even making you money at the same time
36:27 all tech very bad because tech trades
36:30 together. Bottom line don't be afraid of
36:32 rotations and corrections. Don't be
36:33 intimidated by people who use the words.
36:35 And remember even though it's hard to
36:37 quantify execution is a crucial factor
36:39 when it comes to picking stocks. You
36:42 want companies with proven seasoned
36:44 management teams that are less likely to
36:46 drop the ball.
36:49 Stick with Kramer.
36:51 >> Coming up, Jeff Marx joins Kramer to
36:53 help handle your most urgent questions.
36:56 The floor is yours when we return.
37:02 >> Booyah. Jim Kramer, I'm a firsttime
37:04 caller, a happy club member, and want to
37:06 thank you for being the people's
37:08 champion of investing. Thank you for
37:10 helping me become a millionaire.
37:21 I always say my favorite part of the
37:22 show it's answering questions directly
37:24 from you. Then I'm bringing in Jeff
37:25 Marx, my portfolio analyst partner in
37:27 crime. Help me answer some of your most
37:29 burning questions. Now for those of you
37:31 who are a part of the investing club,
37:33 well look, you're going to need no
37:35 introduction. For those of you aren't
37:36 members though, I I hope you will be
37:39 soon. And I would say that Jeff insights
37:41 and our back and forth help me to do a
37:43 better job for you. So please, I want
37:46 you to join the club tonight. Jeff and I
37:47 are covering all grounds, going directly
37:49 to phone lines and answer some of your
37:50 email questions. So let's take some
37:52 calls. Andrew in New Jersey. Andrew.
37:55 >> Hey Jim, Mr. Kramer. Booya.
37:58 >> Booyah.
37:59 >> How you doing?
38:00 >> Not bad. How are you?
38:02 >> I'm doing pretty good. I'm a 66 year old
38:05 guy, T uh Xtech guy and um I'm all about
38:09 dividends and in this cash environment
38:12 right now um and the returns we're
38:14 getting on them. I have more of a
38:15 request than a question and get your
38:17 thoughts on being able to do that in the
38:19 future. I was wondering if at times you
38:23 could do more of a contrasting
38:26 acknowledging that you're not a tax
38:27 advisor but not acknowledging more often
38:30 which um which which companies which
38:33 investments have the favorable 20%
38:36 capital gains rates versus
38:38 >> cash which you know for you know the
38:41 income tax brackets range from anywhere
38:43 from 25 to 37% for some of those
38:46 higherend people they show and then Part
38:49 two of my question real extra credit is
38:52 at the end of the year as we approach
38:54 the end of the year and we do think
38:56 about a lot of tax harvesting uh of the
38:59 losses uh loss harvesting for tax
39:01 purposes. Would you ever uh go so far to
39:04 say this stock I'm recommending a hold
39:07 but if you're thinking about the 30-day
39:08 wash rules maybe you want to sell it uh
39:11 harvest the loss and then buy it back in
39:13 30 days. Would you ever go that far?
39:15 Yeah. No, these are
39:17 >> the these are very interesting issues.
39:19 And I've got to tell you, in my first
39:21 book I wrote, do not fear the tax man.
39:23 What matters are the quality of the
39:26 stocks. So, I would not ever sell a
39:28 stock if I thought it was going to be
39:30 great uh for a wash sale. Again, if I
39:33 thought it was going to be great, get
39:34 improved. And I really don't want to
39:36 sell any stock based on because you
39:39 might be long-term, short-term. Jeff, I
39:42 think that we're investing and we're
39:44 investing for the long term and if a
39:46 company does poorly, we sell it and if a
39:48 company does well, we don't touch it.
39:50 And I don't think the tax person should
39:51 figure into our equation.
39:53 >> No. And of course, uh, all of our
39:55 capital gains and dividend income the
39:58 charitable trust has each year gets
40:00 donated to charity. But yeah, I think if
40:03 you do have a really specific tax
40:05 question, seek a tax advisor because
40:07 they'll give you the best qualified
40:08 advice. But yeah, but we're we're
40:10 focused. We're very focused on how
40:12 stocks are performing.
40:13 >> And people could all be in all different
40:14 practice and have all different ideas.
40:17 Why don't we go to Kevin in Maine?
40:18 Kevin.
40:20 >> Jimmy. Booyah.
40:21 >> Booyah. Booyah. Kev, what's up?
40:24 >> Thank you for helping millions of people
40:26 build themselves into a better investor.
40:29 You are single-handedly responsible for
40:31 encouraging millions of Americans to get
40:34 into the stock market who otherwise
40:36 would not have, myself included. So,
40:38 thank you, Jimmy.
40:39 >> Oh, man. You make my day.
40:41 >> Okay. Thank you.
40:42 >> Thanks, buddy. I do appreciate
40:43 everything that you do for all of us
40:44 regular people. Jimmy, quick question.
40:47 My charts have only three tools on them.
40:49 Price, volume, and OBV or onbalance
40:53 volume. I'm sitting on a few 10 bags and
40:55 130 bag. Jimmy, if you were forced to
40:58 choose only one tool on your chart other
41:01 than price and volume, which one would
41:04 it be?
41:05 >> Okay. Uh, this is terrific. Uh what I
41:08 would check is to see uh uh the
41:11 oversold, overbought. Is it too down,
41:13 far down, is it too far up? And I use
41:16 the same thing for stocks. I wish we had
41:19 an oscillator for I mean for the stock
41:21 exchange, the S&P. I wish we had an
41:23 oscillator for each individual stock.
41:25 That's what I'd be looking at.
41:26 >> Yeah. Look, I'm not a technician. Uh so
41:28 a little harder for me to say, but I
41:30 think also moving averages is is
41:32 something technicians often uh often
41:35 quote. So that would be my the other
41:37 one.
41:38 >> Some of the stuff that Larry Williams
41:39 says I really really like. All right. So
41:41 now let's go for some emails. Uh we're
41:44 going to uh let's start with Diane in
41:46 Ohio and she asks, "I am trying to build
41:49 a position in the company at the stage
41:51 of not owning as much desired. How do
41:54 you balance taking profits and building
41:55 a position?" Thank you. Okay. So if you
41:58 own you put on a small position and if
42:00 it jumps up, you just sell it. You that
42:02 means you missed it, you didn't get it.
42:03 That's okay. We'll get the next one. Uh
42:06 otherwise what you do is you build it on
42:08 the way down in pyramid style and what
42:10 you'll do is you'll have a better basis
42:12 trying to improve the basis uh provided
42:14 the thesis is still right and that's
42:16 what matters.
42:17 >> Yeah. I think just because it's a
42:18 smaller position that doesn't that
42:21 doesn't mean you should break discipline
42:22 and be greedy if the stocks had a huge
42:24 run looks a little bit overextended but
42:26 we also don't want to chase stocks
42:28 either and just because it's small just
42:30 start buying because uh you think it may
42:32 go higher right
42:33 >> you don't want to discipline it always
42:34 comes back to
42:35 >> yeah I mean look I I hate having to wait
42:38 I hate having to build a pyramid it
42:41 doesn't matter this is not a game of
42:42 emotions it's a game of empirical
42:44 analysis and it's worked all right now
42:46 let's go Go to Chris in Illinois who
42:49 asks, "How do you address the waiting of
42:51 different sectors in a diversified
42:52 portfolio? Do you match the S&P or
42:54 market waiting or do you specify sector
42:56 weightings based on macro trends, etc."
42:58 All right. Now, this is another one
42:59 where the club is very different from
43:01 most people. What we do is we look for
43:03 good good companies and if the companies
43:05 are good, we don't care about the
43:07 sector. Now, we don't want to have all
43:08 semiconductors, but we are about finding
43:11 the right stocks and if there are a lot
43:13 of stocks in that sector, we pick the
43:14 best one in the sector. But it's not the
43:16 way we think of things.
43:17 >> No, we're diversified. But if there's a
43:19 uh a mega theme that we like, whether it
43:22 be uh electrification, clean energy, um
43:25 infrastructure, then uh we're not
43:27 opposed to investing more heavily in
43:29 that space because these are multi-year
43:31 trends that are seeing a huge flow of
43:33 investment.
43:34 >> Exactly. And that's why you come to the
43:35 club. We are unconventional, but we are
43:37 rigorous. I like to say there's always a
43:39 bull market somewhere, and I promise I'd
43:41 find it just for you right here on May
43:42 of Money. I'm Jim Kramer. See you next
43:45 time.
43:49 >> All opinions expressed by Jim Kramer on
43:51 this podcast are solely Kramer's
43:52 opinions and do not reflect the opinions
43:53 of CNBC or its parent company or
43:55 affiliates and may have been previously
43:56 disseminated by Kramer on television,
43:58 radio, internet, or another medium. You
44:00 should not treat any opinion expressed
44:01 by Kramer as a specific inducement to
44:03 make a particular investment or follow a
44:04 particular strategy, but only as an
44:06 expression of his opinion. Kramer's
44:08 opinions are based upon information he
44:09 considers reliable, but neither CNBC nor
44:11 its affiliates or subsidiaries warrant
44:13 its completeness or accuracy, and it
44:14 should not be relied upon as such. To
44:16 view the full MadMoney disclaimer,
44:17 please visit cnbc.com/madmoney
44:20 disclaimer.
Homeland Security Sec. Mullin: President Trump has been briefed on nationwide ground stop full transcript
0:00 THE DESK TONIGHT, STEVE GRASSO,
0:01 COURTNEY GARCIA, DAN NATHAN AND
0:02 OUR GUEST TRADER THIS HOUR, JOE
0:04 ZIDEL, CHIEF MARKET STRATEGIST
0:06 AT CRESSET CAPITAL MANAGEMENT.
0:07 JOE, WELCOME. AND WE'LL GET TO
0:09 ALL OF THIS WEEK'S MARKET
0:10 ACTION IN JUST A MOMENT. WE
0:12 START OFF WITH THE LATEST
0:13 HEADLINES ON THIS FAA GROUND
0:14 STOP THE AGENCY HALTING ALL
0:15 FLIGHTS NATIONWIDE DUE TO AIR
0:17 TRAFFIC CONTROL COMMUNICATIONS
0:18 ISSUES. LET'S GET TO PHIL
0:19 LEBEAU, WHO'S GOT THE LATEST.
0:21 PHIL?
0:22 >> MELISSA, WE ARE ABOUT AN
0:23 HOUR INTO THIS GROUND STOP. AND
0:25 THIS IS VERY RARE. THIS HAS
0:27 ONLY HAPPENED TWICE SINCE NINE
0:28 OVER 11. THE LAST TIME BACK IN
0:30 2023 WHERE YOU HAVE A
0:31 NATIONWIDE GROUND STOP. BUT
0:34 THAT'S WHAT HAS HAPPENED. THE
0:35 FAA ISSUING A STATEMENT JUST
0:36 OVER ABOUT 35 MINUTES AGO
0:39 SAYING THE FAA ISSUED A
0:41 NATIONWIDE GROUND STOP FOR ALL
0:43 U.S. AIRPORTS FOLLOWING
0:44 COMMUNICATION ISSUES IMPACTING
0:46 MULTIPLE AIR ROUTE TRAFFIC
0:48 CONTROL CENTERS. FAA
0:50 TECHNICIANS ARE INVESTIGATING
0:52 THE ISSUE. WE WILL PROVIDE
0:53 UPDATES, A COUPLE OF THINGS
0:54 THAT ARE TO KEEP IN MIND HERE.
0:56 FIRST OF ALL, THERE ARE 22 OF
0:58 THOSE AIR ROUTE TRAFFIC CONTROL
1:00 CENTERS BASICALLY SET UP AROUND
1:02 THE COUNTRY. THEY NOT ONLY HELP
1:04 THE AIRCRAFT AT THE AIRPORTS
1:06 BEFORE THEY LEAVE. AND THERE'S
1:07 ALSO THE AIR TRAFFIC CONTROL
1:09 CENTERS AT AIRPORTS THAT
1:10 ACTUALLY WORK WITH THE AIRCRAFT.
1:12 BUT THESE NATIONWIDE AIR
1:13 TRAFFIC CONTROL CENTERS,
1:15 THEY'RE THE ONES THAT OFTEN ARE
1:16 COMMUNICATING WITH THE AIRCRAFT
1:18 THAT ARE IN ROUTE TO A CERTAIN
1:20 DESTINATION. SO WHAT THE FAA
1:21 HAS DONE IS THEY'VE SAID
1:23 ANYBODY WHO HAS NOT TAKEN OFF
1:25 YET, THOSE PLANES ARE STAYING
1:26 IN PLACE. WE'RE NOT GOING TO
1:27 ADD MORE TRAFFIC TO THE SKIES
1:29 UNTIL WE FIGURE OUT EXACTLY
1:30 WHAT HAS HAPPENED HERE. THE
1:32 OTHER THING TO KEEP IN MIND IS
1:33 THAT THE FAA, I'VE HAD A COUPLE
1:35 OF PEOPLE ASK THIS. WELL, HAVE
1:37 THEY DETERMINED IT'S GOING TO
1:38 BE X NUMBER OF HOURS, SIX HOURS,
1:41 SEVEN HOURS? THERE ARE SOME OF
1:42 THOSE REPORTS THAT ARE OUT
1:43 THERE ONLINE. SOME OF THOSE
1:44 REPORTS YOU SHOULD KEEP IN MIND
1:46 ARE COMING FROM PILOTS WHO SAY,
1:47 WELL, I'VE BEEN TOLD BY THE
1:49 LOCAL AIR, THE GROUND AIR
1:50 TRAFFIC CONTROL CENTER, TO
1:51 EXPECT IT TO BE AT LEAST SIX
1:53 HOURS. IT MAY BE SIX HOURS, IT
1:55 MAY BE A COUPLE OF HOURS.
1:56 NOBODY KNOWS, BECAUSE WE STILL
1:57 DON'T KNOW THE EXACT NATURE OF
1:59 WHAT CAUSED THIS OUTAGE. SO FOR
2:02 THE PEOPLE WHO ARE FLYING
2:03 TONIGHT, YEAH, THIS IS
2:04 MADDENING. BUT ON THE OTHER
2:05 HAND, THE FAA DOESN'T DO THIS
2:07 UNLESS THEY BELIEVE THERE IS A
2:09 SERIOUS SAFETY ISSUE AT HAND.
2:10 AND THAT'S WHAT YOU HAVE WHEN
2:12 IT'S IMPACTING EVERY AIR
2:13 TRAFFIC CONTROL CENTER. SO WE
2:14 ARE CONTINUING TO MONITOR THE
2:16 SITUATION. MELISSA, AS SOON AS
2:17 WE HAVE ANY INFORMATION FROM
2:19 THE FAA REGARDING A WHEN WE
2:21 MIGHT SEE THE GROUND STOP
2:23 LIFTED OR BE THE CAUSE OF THIS
2:25 OUTAGE, WE CERTAINLY WILL LET
2:26 YOU KNOW.
2:27 >> YEAH, WE'RE WATCHING DHS
2:28 SECRETARY MARKWAYNE MULLIN
2:30 SPEAK RIGHT NOW. PHIL, HAVE
2:32 THEY SAID ALREADY THAT IT IS
2:33 NOT A CYBER ATTACK?
2:36 >> THERE ARE REPORTS OF THAT. I
2:37 HAVE REACHED OUT TO. PEOPLE AT
2:39 THE FAA HAVE NOT BEEN TOLD THAT.
2:41 THEY'VE DEFINITIVELY SAID IT IS
2:42 NOT A CYBER ATTACK. SO THAT HAS
2:45 BEEN REPORTED, BUT WE HAVE NOT
2:46 CONFIRMED THAT.
2:48 >> ALL RIGHT, PHIL, KEEP US
2:49 POSTED. THANK YOU. PHIL LEBEAU,
2:50 WE'RE GOING TO LISTEN IN TO THE
2:52 DHS SECRETARY RIGHT NOW.
2:54 >> SEEN SOME PLANES LAND AT
2:56 SPECIFIC AIRPORTS. IS THAT
2:57 GOING TO BE THE CASE AT ALL
2:59 AIRPORTS? ANY FLIGHTS IN THE
3:00 AIR WILL BE ALLOWED TO LAND.
3:01 >> THE FLIGHTS THAT ARE
3:02 CURRENTLY IN THE AIR. WE HAVE A
3:04 GROUND STOPPAGE. WE STILL GOT
3:05 TO GET THE FLIGHTS OUT RIGHT.
3:07 AND SO WE'RE GOING TO BE
3:08 DEALING WITH THOSE CASE BY CASE.
3:10 IT I THINK YOU SAID SPECIFIC.
3:12 IT'S A TELECOMMUNICATION OUTAGE.
3:14 I'M NOT GOING TO GET AHEAD OF
3:16 FAA. THAT'S THEIR LANE TO TALK
3:18 ABOUT. WE WERE WANTING TO
3:19 ASSURE ALL THE AMERICAN PEOPLE
3:21 THIS ISN'T A A SAFETY TO THE
3:25 AMERICAN PEOPLE OR, OR ANOTHER.
3:26 911 I THINK THAT'S WHAT A LOT
3:28 OF PEOPLE ARE TRYING TO MAKE
3:29 THE COMPARISON TO, AND THAT'S
3:30 NOT THE CASE.
3:31 >> THE PRESIDENT, WHAT KIND OF
3:33 ALL OF GOVERNMENT RESPONSE IS
3:35 BEING ASSEMBLED RIGHT NOW?
3:36 WHO'S INVOLVED?
3:37 >> WE'RE THROWING EVERYONE THAT
3:39 HAS A STAKE IN THIS.
3:41 EVERYBODY'S INVOLVED RIGHT NOW.
3:43 SO THIS IS A THIS IS
3:46 UNPRECEDENTED. WHEN WE WHEN YOU
3:47 SEE SOMETHING LIKE THIS AND
3:47 WE'RE GOING TO CONTINUE TO
3:48 THROW THE ASSETS WE NEED AT IT
3:51 TO MAKE SURE THAT ONE AS NOT TO
3:53 REPEAT MYSELF, BUT THAT WE GET
3:55 THE FLIGHTS DOWN AND THEN WE
3:57 GET NORMAL OPERATIONS BACK UP.
4:00 BUT THERE WAS SEVERAL OF US
4:01 THAT WAS INVOLVED IN IT. YES.
4:03 >> MR. SECRETARY, THE PRESIDENT.
4:04 >> RIGHT BACK HERE. BACK HERE
4:05 IN BLUE TIE. SORRY.
4:06 >> THANK YOU, MR. SECRETARY. SO
4:09 IS IT CURRENTLY, THE
4:10 COMMUNICATIONS IS DOWN AS WE
4:12 SPEAK RIGHT NOW.
4:12 >> YES.
4:13 >> AND THEN SECONDLY.
4:14 >> THERE IS LET ME EXPERT THERE.
4:16 WE ARE ABLE TO COMMUNICATE TO
4:19 AT CERTAIN LEVELS. BUT BUT IT'S
4:23 OVERWHELMED SOME OF THE SYSTEMS
4:24 WE HAVE. ONCE AGAIN, SEAN DUFFY,
4:26 SECRETARY DUFFY IS ON THIS. HE
4:28 WAS ON THE PHONE EARLIER WITH
4:29 WITH THE PRESIDENT AND SEVERAL
4:31 OF US. AND THEY'RE DOING A
4:33 PHENOMENAL JOB IN THE CRISIS
4:35 MODE.
4:35 >> IS IT DAYS OR WEEKS?
4:37 >> THAT'S EARLY. THAT'S THE
4:38 EARLY TALE.
4:39 >> RIGHT NOW. THERE ARE REPORTS
4:40 THAT THERE ABOUT SEVEN HOURS
4:41 RIGHT NOW THAT PILOTS ARE
4:42 TELLING US PEOPLE. IS THAT THE
4:44 TIME FRAME?
4:45 >> WE WE HAVE NOT DISCUSSED ANY
4:47 TIME FRAME FOR. YOU GOT. I'LL
4:50 JUST THINK ABOUT THIS AS A
4:52 WHOLE. IF I HAVE A LOVED ONE AT
4:53 THE AIRPORT, IT'S JUST TO GET
4:57 EVERYBODY STARTED BACK UP IN
4:59 THE GROUND AND THE FLIGHTS
4:59 GOING AGAIN. IT'S GOING TO TAKE
5:01 SOME TIME. AND SO THIS ISN'T
5:03 GOING TO JUST BE BE RESOLVED
5:06 AND AND TURNED AROUND WITHIN
5:08 THE HOUR. THIS IS THIS IS GOING
5:10 TO TAKE TAKE SOME TIME. BUT
5:11 ONCE AGAIN, EVERYBODY IS SAFE.
5:14 THE FLIGHTS ARE ACCOUNTED FOR.
5:15 AND THERE'S NO THERE SHOULD BE
5:17 NO FEAR TO THE PUBLIC AT ALL IN
5:19 THIS.
5:19 >> THE FAA.
5:20 >> JUST THE PRESIDENT HAS BEEN
5:22 BRIEFED. YOU'VE TALKED TO HIM?
5:24 >> YES. WELL, THERE WAS I
5:26 WASN'T THE ONLY THE ONLY PERSON
5:28 IN THE ROOM, OBVIOUSLY.
5:29 >> AND THEN THERE ARE THOUGHTS
5:31 THAT, YOU KNOW, THIS COULD BE
5:32 AN AI RELATED ERROR OR ISSUE.
5:35 >> WE CALL IT'S I REMEMBER S I,
5:38 YOU KNOW, I, YOU, YOU JUST
5:41 CAN'T RULE OUT ANYTHING AT THIS
5:42 POINT. WE'RE GOING THROUGH THAT
5:46 PROCESS AND WE'RE GOING TO FIND
5:47 OUT WHAT HAPPENED. AND WHEN WE
5:48 DO, WE'LL TAKE THE, YOU KNOW,
5:52 THE APPROPRIATE ACTIONS TO MAKE
5:53 SURE IT DOESN'T HAPPEN AGAIN.
5:54 >> WHILE YOU ARE STILL WITH THE
5:56 SYSTEMS. ARE THERE ANY.
5:57 >> EXTRA PRECAUTIONS THAT ARE
5:58 GOING ON FOR THE PRESIDENT TO
6:00 KEEP HIM SAFE WHILE YOU ARE
6:01 STILL INVESTIGATING?
6:02 >> WELL, THERE'S NO FEAR TO THE
6:03 PUBLIC AS I WANT TO MAKE SURE
6:05 WE SAY THIS AGAIN. THERE'S NO
6:06 REASON FOR THE PUBLIC TO BE
6:09 AFRAID OR SCARED FOR YOUR LOVED
6:10 ONES. THIS ISN'T A ANOTHER NINE
6:13 OVER 11. I JUST CAN'T REPEAT
6:14 THAT ENOUGH. PEOPLE ARE MAKING
6:17 THAT ASSUMPTION, BECAUSE THAT'S
6:18 THE LAST TIME WE HAD A
6:19 NATIONWIDE GROUND STOPPAGE.
6:21 THIS IS A TELECOMMUNICATION
6:23 OUTAGE. THIS IS MUCH DIFFERENT.
6:26 >> AND JUST FOLLOWING UP ON
6:27 CAITLIN'S QUESTION, THERE ARE
6:28 REPORTS THAT THE FAA WAS
6:29 ROLLING OUT A NEW AIR TRAFFIC
6:31 CONTROL SYSTEM TODAY. HAS THERE
6:33 BEEN ANY LINK BETWEEN THAT?
6:35 >> WE'RE LOOKING AT THAT THAT
6:36 THAT THAT WE'RE THAT'S PART OF
6:38 SOMETHING THAT OBVIOUSLY
6:41 THROUGH CISA AT DHS, WE ARE.
6:44 WE'RE TAKING A LOOK. WE'RE
6:46 WORKING WITH OUR WITH OUR
6:47 COUNTERPARTS THROUGHOUT ALL
6:49 AGENCIES.
6:49 >> THE PLANES IN THE AIR, THE
6:52 FAA ISN'T ABLE TO COMMUNICATE
6:53 WITH.
6:54 >> RIGHT NOW. NO, NO, IT'S JUST
6:55 AT A DIFFERENT LEVEL. THE
6:58 CLARITY AS MY UNDERSTANDING. SO
7:00 I'M NOT TRYING TO GET AHEAD OF
7:02 MYSELF ON THIS ONE. MY
7:03 UNDERSTANDING IS THAT WE CAN
7:04 STILL COMMUNICATE. IT'S JUST
7:05 THAT AT IT'S AT DIFFERENT
7:07 LEVELS AND THE CLARITY THAT WE
7:09 CAN GET TO. BUT THERE'S
7:10 REDUNDANCY IN MOST
7:11 COMMUNICATIONS. SO AS YOU CAN
7:13 SEE, THERE'S STILL PLANES
7:16 LANDING, AND SO THERE'S STILL
7:17 COMMUNICATIONS GOING ON. AND WE
7:19 AT AN ABUNDANCE OF CAUTION IS
7:21 WHAT IS THE REASON WHY WE WE
7:22 DECIDED TO GROUND EVERYTHING.
7:26 LET ME.
7:26 >> GO HERE.
7:27 >> THANK YOU SIR. THIS IS A
7:28 GROUND STOP FOR THE UNITED
7:29 STATES. YES. IS THIS AFFECTING
7:31 OTHER COUNTRIES AS WELL?
7:32 >> NOT THAT. NOT THAT WE'RE
7:33 AWARE OF. THERE'S TWO AREAS
7:36 THAT WE ARE THAT WE KNOW THAT
7:38 ARE NOT AFFECTED. I DON'T THINK
7:40 I'M AT THE ABILITY TO SHARE
7:43 THOSE RIGHT NOW. BUT THERE'S
7:44 TWO AREAS INSIDE THE UNITED
7:46 STATES THAT THAT ARE STILL ABLE
7:47 TO COMMUNICATE JUST FINE.
7:48 >> MR. SECRETARY.
7:49 >> I DON'T UNDERSTAND THAT.
7:50 WHAT IS THAT? WHAT DOES THAT
7:52 MEAN.
7:52 >> TO THIS? AND CAN YOU
7:53 DESCRIBE WHO IS HELPING IN
7:54 INVESTIGATING THE ROOT CAUSE OF
7:56 IT AS FAR AS WHAT AGENCIES.
7:57 >> WE'RE. EVERY AGENCY THAT HAS
8:00 A HAS AN ASSET THAT IS INVOLVED
8:03 IN THIS. FROM THE COMMUNICATION
8:04 SIDE, FADOW STATE DEPARTMENT,
8:08 WE'RE ALL WORKING TOGETHER, BUT
8:11 THAT'S WHAT WE DO. RIGHT. AND
8:14 AND I DON'T WANT TO SAY THAT
8:15 THIS IS A CRISIS, BUT IT IS
8:16 BECAUSE WE'RE DROWNING. WE'RE,
8:18 YOU KNOW, WE HAD TO DO A
8:19 NATIONWIDE GROUND STOP, WHICH
8:20 IS WHAT THE GOVERNMENT WORKS
8:23 WELL AT. THAT'S WHAT WE'RE HERE
8:24 FOR. AND SO WE ARE WELL
8:28 POSITIONED AND COMMUNICATING
8:30 VERY WELL. THE PRESIDENT TOOK A
8:33 LEAD IN THIS IMMEDIATELY, AND
8:35 HE GAVE US THE THE ASSETS AND
8:39 THE COMMUNICATION TO, TO, TO,
8:41 TO MOVE FORWARD IN A FAST WAY.
8:42 THAT'S WHAT LEADERS DO. THE
8:44 PRESIDENT TRUMP'S THE BEST AT
8:45 LEADING US.
8:47 >> WE'VE BEEN LISTENING TO
8:48 HOMELAND SECURITY SECRETARY
8:50 MULLEN SPEAK IN FRONT OF THE
8:51 WHITE HOUSE ABOUT THIS FAA
8:53 NATIONWIDE GROUND STOP DUE TO A
8:55 COMMUNICATIONS ERROR. LET'S GET
8:56 BACK TO PHIL LEBEAU AND PHIL.
8:57 THE SECRETARY TALKED ABOUT A
8:59 NUMBER OF THINGS. THE MESSAGE
9:01 SEEMS THAT HE WANTS TO SAY IS
9:03 IT'S NOT A NINE OVER 11. AND I
9:04 THINK THE COMPARISON HE'S
9:05 MAKING, HE'S MAKING IS
9:06 BASICALLY, THIS IS ONE OF THE
9:08 LAST TIMES A NATIONWIDE GROUND
9:09 STOP HAS HAPPENED. AND SO
9:10 PEOPLE MIGHT ASSOCIATE THAT
9:11 WITH SOME SORT OF ATTACK. BUT
9:13 HE'S SAYING THAT THERE'S
9:14 NOTHING TO FEAR HERE.
9:16 >> WELL, AND I THINK WHAT HE'S
9:18 ALSO MAKING VERY CLEAR THERE IS
9:20 THEY DON'T HAVE DEFINITIVE
9:22 INFORMATION IN TERMS OF A
9:24 EXACTLY WHAT WENT WRONG AND B,
9:26 WHEN IT WILL BE FIXED, BECAUSE
9:27 YOU HEAR PEOPLE SAYING, WELL, I
9:29 HEAR IT'S GOING TO BE SEVERAL
9:30 HOURS. THEY'RE TRYING TO MAKE
9:31 SURE THAT THEY KNOW EXACTLY
9:32 WHAT HAS HAPPENED AND HOW LONG
9:34 IT WILL TAKE TO FIX IT BEFORE
9:36 THEY SAY, OKAY, WELL, WE'RE
9:37 GOING TO LIFT THIS GROUND. STOP.
9:39 LET'S, I DON'T KNOW, 45 MINUTES,
9:40 AN HOUR, WHENEVER IT MIGHT BE,
9:41 WHENEVER THEY GET TO THAT POINT.
9:43 THOSE ARE TWO THINGS THAT STOOD
9:44 OUT WHEN I LISTENED TO HIS
9:45 COMMENTS. ALSO, THE FACT THAT
9:47 HE SAID TIME AND AGAIN, THIS IS
9:48 NOT A NINE OVER 11 SITUATION.
9:50 THERE IS NO REASON TO BELIEVE
9:51 THAT THERE IS SOMETHING
9:52 NEFARIOUS THAT CAUSED THIS
9:54 NATIONWIDE OUTAGE. IT'S A
9:56 TELECOMMUNICATIONS ISSUE. BY
9:57 THE WAY, THE FAA HAS JUST
9:58 ISSUED A NEW STATEMENT SAYING
10:00 THERE HAS BEEN A TEMPORARY
10:02 TELECOMMUNICATIONS OUTAGE. OUT
10:03 OF AN ABUNDANCE OF CAUTION, ALL
10:05 FLIGHTS HAVE BEEN HALTED, EVERY
10:07 FLIGHT HAS BEEN ACCOUNTED FOR,
10:09 AND INTERNATIONAL FLIGHTS WILL
10:11 BE HANDLED ON A CASE BY CASE
10:13 BASIS. SO THAT'S THE LATEST
10:14 FROM THE FAA, MELISSA. AND LOOK,
10:16 IT MAY BE THAT WE'RE HERE FOR A
10:18 COUPLE OF HOURS WAITING TO SEE
10:19 HOW THIS GETS RESOLVED AND WHEN
10:21 IT WILL BE RESOLVED. AND
10:22 OBVIOUSLY FRUSTRATING FOR
10:23 PEOPLE WHO WERE SCHEDULED TO
10:25 TAKE A FLIGHT TONIGHT, WHO ARE
10:27 NOW WAITING AND WONDERING WHEN
10:28 THEY'LL TAKE OFF.
10:30 >> WHAT WAS ALSO INTERESTING TO
10:31 ME, PHIL, WAS THAT SECRETARY
10:32 MULLEN DIDN'T RULE ANYTHING OUT,
10:34 REALLY, IN TERMS OF THE CAUSE.
10:35 WE KNOW IT'S AN OUTAGE. WE
10:37 DON'T KNOW NECESSARILY IF WHAT
10:39 IT WAS CAUSED BY, WHETHER IT BE
10:40 JUST, YOU KNOW, MAYBE A WIRE
10:42 BEING SNIPPED OR A CYBER ATTACK.
10:44 BUT HE ALSO SAID HE WASN'T SURE
10:46 ABOUT WHETHER OR NOT IT WAS
10:47 CAUSED BY AI. AND THE FAA HAS
10:49 JUST IMPLEMENTED A SMART,
10:51 SO-CALLED SMART SYSTEM. RIGHT.
10:53 $875 MILLION IN THIS AI SYSTEM
10:55 THAT WILL HELP THEM LAND PLANES
10:57 BASICALLY THAT.
10:58 >> SO MELISSA I SHOULD POINT
11:00 OUT THAT SMART SYSTEM IS AN
11:02 ADVISORY SYSTEM WHICH
11:03 ESSENTIALLY IS TELLING AIRCRAFT
11:05 THEIR SPACING WHEN THEY'RE
11:06 GOING INTO A PARTICULAR AREA
11:07 WHERE THEY'RE GOING TO LAND.
11:09 AND IT IS NOT NATIONWIDE AT
11:10 THIS POINT. IT IS SPECIFICALLY
11:12 FOR CERTAIN ROUTES ALONG THE
11:13 EAST COAST. THIS SOUNDS MORE
11:15 LIKE AND AGAIN, THIS IS PURELY
11:17 GOING OFF OF WHAT WE HEARD FROM
11:19 THE HOMELAND SECURITY SECRETARY,
11:20 A TELECOM, A TELECOMMUNICATIONS
11:22 ISSUE. AND AS A RESULT, THEY'RE
11:24 TRYING TO FIGURE OUT EXACTLY
11:25 WHAT HAPPENED. AND B, HOW DO
11:27 YOU FIX IT AND
State Secretary Marco Rubio delivers keynote address at National Lawyers Convention full transcript
0:00 Born in Miami, Florida in 1971,
0:03 he is the son of Cuban immigrants who
0:05 left Cuba in pursuit of the American
0:07 dream. His father worked as a banquet
0:09 bartender while his mother split time as
0:12 a stay-at-home mom and hotel maid. From
0:14 an early age, Rubio learned the
0:16 importance of faith, family, community,
0:19 and dignified work. His commitment to
0:22 public service was deeply influenced by
0:24 conversations with his grandfather who
0:26 had witnessed firsthand the devastating
0:29 effects of communism on his homeland.
0:31 Inspired by his family story and his
0:34 beha and his belief in the promise of
0:36 America, Rubio embarked on a career in
0:38 public service that would take him from
0:40 local government to the highest levels
0:42 of national leadership. After marrying
0:45 his wife Janette, Rubio began his
0:47 political career as a city commissioner
0:49 in West Miami before serving in the
0:52 Florida House of Representatives where
0:53 he ultimately rose to become speaker. In
0:57 2010, he was elected to represent
0:59 Florida in the United States Senate,
1:01 where he served for nearly 14 years.
1:04 During his tenure in the Senate, Rubio
1:06 served on several influential
1:08 committees, including the Senate Foreign
1:10 Relations Committee, the Senate Select
1:12 Committee on Intelligence, the Senate
1:14 Appropriations Committee, and the Senate
1:16 Committee on Small Business and
1:18 Entrepreneurship. He became particularly
1:20 active on issues involving US foreign
1:23 policy, national security, and America's
1:26 relationships with countries across the
1:27 world.
1:29 Among his legislative accomplishments,
1:31 Rubio was a leading force behind the
1:32 Weaguer Forced Labor Prevention Act,
1:35 co-led legislation supporting human
1:37 rights and democracy in Hong Kong, and
1:40 worked with President Trump to increase
1:42 pressure on the Cuban regime, including
1:44 efforts targeting the regime's
1:45 militarycontrolled business empire.
1:48 In November 2024, President Donald Trump
1:52 nominated Rubio to serve as the 72nd
1:54 Secretary of State. On January 20th,
1:58 2025, the United States Senate
2:00 unanimously confirmed his nomination by
2:02 a vote of 99 to zero, making him the
2:05 first member of President Trump's second
2:07 cabinet. Rubio was sworn in as Secretary
2:10 of State on January 21st, 2025. As
2:14 America's chief diplomat, he leads the
2:16 Department of State in carrying out the
2:19 president's foreign policy and advancing
2:21 Americans interests around the world.
2:23 His stated priority is to lead a
2:26 department that puts America first. In
2:28 his capacity as the president's national
2:30 security adviser, he leads the national
2:33 security council and coordinates the
2:34 America first foreign policy across the
2:37 inner agency.
2:39 And while all of these professional
2:41 achievements are truly remarkable, his
2:43 greatest accompl accomplishment cannot
2:45 be measured by titles, awards, or
2:47 accolades. Beyond all that he has
2:49 achieved professionally, his greatest
2:52 legacy will always be the value he has
2:54 instilled. The importance of always
2:56 putting the Lord first. And this is the
2:58 example that he has set for my family.
3:01 His love for a great nation and the
3:02 defense of our basic rights. And for
3:05 that reason, more than any other, I am
3:08 most proud and most grateful and most
3:10 fortunate to call him dad.
3:25 Now, without further ado, please join me
3:28 in welcoming the 72nd Secretary of State
3:30 of the United States, my father, Marco
3:32 Rubio.
3:54 Thank you. Thank you very much.
4:02 Thank you very much. Thank you.
4:06 Thank you.
4:08 Thank you.
4:11 Is that cool or what? You know, huh? My
4:14 kids, I used to bring them on stage and
4:16 show them up. Now they're introducing. I
4:17 don't know where she got this uh has no
4:21 stage fright. She's not afraid to speak.
4:22 I mean, I don't really like public
4:24 speaking that much, but she uh she
4:28 on the other hand, that's fantastic.
4:30 That's great. Thank you, Danielle. You
4:31 did very good. She's a She's a thirdyear
4:33 law student at the University of
4:35 Virginia. I heard that's a good law
4:36 school. I hope it is.
4:39 I hope it is. It's expensive law school.
4:44 I hope it is. No, she's great. And of
4:46 course, my wife Janette is here as well.
4:48 And um you know, I was also a lawyer,
4:50 but I was a different kind of lawyer. I
4:52 was a land use and zoning attorney. And
4:55 I always tell them as a land use and
4:57 zoning attorney, if you ever wind up in
4:59 court, something went horribly wrong.
5:02 She on the other hand is going to be
5:03 like a real lawyer. So, uh, we're she's
5:06 fantastic and it's an honor to be with
5:07 all of you here today. And thank you.
5:09 And, um, you know, primarily I am here
5:11 in this collection of lawyers. How many
5:13 lawy are there any lawyers here?
5:16 >> Good. Thank you. Because on election
5:18 night there was a congressman that said
5:19 we all needed to lawyer up. So, here we
5:21 are.
5:30 Anyway, anyway, so and on a serious
5:33 topic, you know, um you know, less than
5:36 two years into Ronald Reagan's uh first
5:38 term in office, you know, that
5:40 everything sort of seemed headed in the
5:42 wrong direction. It's hard for us to
5:44 remember that right now, but that's what
5:45 it was like after his first two years in
5:47 office. Things seemed headed in the
5:49 wrong direction. He had won a stunning
5:51 landslide victory. He had been hailed as
5:53 a conservative which was hailed as a
5:55 conservative revolution and upended the
5:58 political establishment. He'd been swept
6:00 into office with this ambitious
6:01 political mandate. He survived an
6:04 assassination attempt and he promptly
6:06 delivered on a signature campaign
6:08 promise which was a historic tax cut. He
6:10 did all of this in the first eight
6:11 months of his presidency.
6:14 But by early 1982, which by the way I
6:17 think I was in sixth grade. Um, but by
6:20 early 1982, celebrations had given way
6:22 to a growing sense of gloom. The Reagan
6:25 administration was facing its first
6:27 major political crisis. In less than a
6:29 year, the approval ratings of the Reagan
6:33 administration had plummeted from by 25
6:35 points from 68% down to 43%.
6:39 By March of 1982, think about this what
6:42 I'm about to tell you for a moment. By
6:44 March of 1982,
6:46 President Reagan was four points less
6:49 popular than Jimmy Carter. At the same
6:52 point at his term, the economy had taken
6:55 a nose dive. In fact, it faced a
6:58 full-fledged recession. Unemployment was
7:00 approaching double digits, the worst it
7:02 had been in 40 years, with many fairly
7:06 or unfairly blaming the president for
7:08 all of this. Even his foreign policy
7:10 ambitions were beginning to lose ground
7:12 with rising fears of nuclear war with
7:15 Russia spilling out into a popular
7:16 revolt against his efforts to take on
7:19 Soviet communism around the world. On
7:22 all fronts, the Reagan administration
7:25 and the conservative movement at that
7:26 time was on the defensive. But it was
7:30 against that backdrop that I just
7:31 described to you in 1982, which by the
7:34 way also culminated in a devastating
7:37 losses for the president's parties in
7:39 Congress. It was against that backdrop
7:42 amid the plummeting morale, the anxiety,
7:44 the despair that something new began to
7:46 stir. And it was at that time it was
7:49 little more than just an idea. It was
7:51 germinating in just a few law schools
7:53 common in the law in the common rooms of
7:55 several law schools and lecture halls.
7:57 But soon, what was stirring would remake
8:01 the whole landscape of American politics
8:02 and law, forever changing the course of
8:06 the nation. In April of 1982,
8:10 in the middle of everything I just
8:12 described to you, there were four law
8:13 school students that organized a
8:15 symposium on federalism in New Haven,
8:18 Connecticut. About 200 people came. One
8:22 of the speakers that came was this 46-y
8:25 old professor from Chicago. His name was
8:28 Anthony Scalia.
8:30 And he diagnosed a basic problem to the
8:32 room. He said, "Conservatives
8:34 have simply been outgunned at the
8:36 federal level for half a century."
8:39 And of course, nowhere was that more
8:41 obvious at the time than in the courts.
8:43 Republicans had won three of the last
8:45 four presidential elections. Seven of
8:47 the nine justices at the time on the
8:49 Supreme Court had been appointed by
8:51 Republican presidents and yet none of it
8:54 seemed to matter much at all. Nine years
8:57 earlier, the court had delivered its
8:59 ruling in Roie Wake. Five of the seven
9:02 votes for the decision were Republican
9:04 appointees. The majority opinion was
9:06 written by a justice who had been
9:08 nominated by President Richard Nixon.
9:11 The most cons consistent conservative on
9:14 that court was William Renquist
9:16 and he spent much of his time as the
9:18 lone voice of disscent. So much so that
9:21 his law clerks gifted him a doll of the
9:24 lone ranger.
9:26 At the time only one major law school in
9:29 the country had a conservative student
9:32 journal. By the way happened to be
9:33 Harvard. It had been founded four years
9:35 earlier. And the very term originalism
9:40 itself was only two years old and it
9:42 wasn't coined by an originalist. It was
9:44 coined by a liberal Stanford professor
9:46 in an article written to criticize and
9:48 refute the concept. Just a few years
9:50 later, a sitting justice in the Supreme
9:52 Court would dismiss this idea of
9:54 originalism. He would dismiss it as
9:55 quote little more than arrogance cloaked
9:58 as humility, sneering that its advocates
10:01 were persons who have no familiarity
10:03 with the historical record.
10:06 This
10:07 was how the Federalist Society began.
10:11 But your critics aren't sneering
10:12 anymore. The Federalist Society helped
10:15 to change and advance America. And there
10:18 are many lessons for us to learn today
10:20 from that success.
10:22 One of those lessons is that politics
10:26 requires more than simply winning
10:28 elections.
10:30 Because the government is not the only
10:32 source of political power. Power also
10:36 lives in the universities. Power lives
10:38 in the press. Power lives in the whole
10:40 expanse of civil society. All of the
10:43 institutions that define and shape our
10:45 understanding of ourselves as a nation
10:48 and as a people.
10:51 Every society, and I mean every society,
10:54 has an elite, has a ruling class. And in
10:57 ours, that class resides not just in the
11:00 white house, not just in Congress or the
11:03 courts. It also resides in academia, in
11:07 powerful nonprofits, and in
11:09 non-government organizations. It resides
11:12 in corporate boardrooms and sea suite,
11:15 in think tanks and journals, in
11:17 foundations and in mass media stretching
11:21 across the commanding heights of
11:22 business and education and culture.
11:27 This is something that the left over the
11:30 last six decades has frankly often
11:32 understood better than the right.
11:35 Elections elections decides who holds
11:38 office for a season. But elections they
11:42 do not they do not decide by themselves
11:45 what our institutions teach or what our
11:48 lawyers believe. which ideas are treated
11:52 as respectable or normal and which are
11:56 deemed beyond the pale. The government
11:59 of course can and does play a critical
12:01 role in shaping these things but the
12:04 government can't fundamentally transform
12:06 them into two or four or can't transform
12:08 them in just two four or eight years.
12:11 That kind of change, that kind of change
12:13 is implemented over the course of a
12:15 generation or more. And even then, only
12:19 through the dedicated work of a
12:21 coalition of allies across institutions
12:24 working together
12:26 both inside and outside of the state.
12:31 The Federalist Society's victories were
12:33 built on this insight. It's not just
12:35 about placing good judges in positions
12:37 to interpret the law. It's about shaping
12:41 the world in which they do so. About
12:44 shaping the norms and the values, the
12:46 ideas and beliefs, the expectations and
12:49 the assumptions that underpin how they
12:52 think and reason and act.
12:56 Who defines these things and to what
12:59 end? That is what power is. That's not
13:04 unique to our country's legal system. At
13:07 the State Department, we have seen the
13:09 same thing firsthand in the realm of
13:12 what is called international law. We've
13:15 heard the concept international law
13:17 invoked against nearly every major
13:19 foreign policy decision or action of
13:22 this administration. So, for example,
13:24 when President Trump ordered our
13:25 military to sink cartel boats in the
13:28 Caribbean, we were told that they were
13:30 violating international law. The
13:32 founding chief prosecutor of the fake
13:35 and illegitimate International Criminal
13:37 Court even accused us of crimes against
13:40 humanity.
13:42 When American forces captured Nicholas
13:44 Maduro, a fugitive of American justice,
13:48 and brought him to the United States to
13:49 face that justice,
13:52 we heard the same
14:01 when we did that, we heard the same
14:03 accusations
14:04 from the highest levels of the
14:08 I'm not going to call him the name, the
14:10 United Nations. Um,
14:13 even the enforcement of our own
14:15 immigration laws, even the enforcement
14:17 of our own immigration laws here on
14:19 American soil has faced this attack.
14:21 Earlier this year, for example, groups
14:23 like the ACLU were petitioning the
14:25 United Nations to investigate ISIS
14:28 blatant violations of international law
14:31 here in the United States. Over the past
14:33 decade, we've received an endless
14:34 barrage of claims about America's
14:37 alleged violations of international
14:38 rules and norms, ranging from our
14:40 foreign policy to our border enforcement
14:42 to even what they call what they call
14:45 our systemic racism.
14:48 Even on the issue of abortion, for
14:49 example, when Roie Wade was overturned
14:51 by the Supreme Court in 2022, it was
14:54 swiftly denounced by a cadre of, you
14:57 guessed it, UN human rights experts, an
14:59 oxymoron.
15:01 uh as a betrayal of America's binding
15:05 legal obligations under international
15:08 law.
15:09 None of this has anything to do none of
15:11 this has anything to do with any real
15:14 higher standard of justice. It is a
15:16 function of the people who control the
15:19 official organs of global governance.
15:22 It is the function of the sprawling
15:24 network of NOS's and agencies staffed by
15:27 international activists and bureaucrats
15:29 along with their patrons here in the
15:31 United States and around the world. For
15:34 this global elite, international law is
15:37 not a neutral body of rules.
15:40 International law is an instrument, an
15:43 instrument to advance their interest
15:45 under the pretense of universal
15:47 principles.
15:49 For example, they're staunch defenders
15:51 of democracy
15:53 until particular elections challenge
15:56 their interests. They lecture us on the
15:58 importance of sovereignty
16:01 even as they demand that nations
16:03 surrender control of their borders and
16:06 outsource their immigration laws to
16:08 unelected international courts. They
16:11 oppose, they say, all forms of
16:13 imperialism,
16:15 of conquest, domination,
16:18 but they seek to exercise authority over
16:20 every country and every government on
16:23 Earth.
16:25 That's why earlier this year, President
16:27 Trump made the unprecedented decision to
16:29 sanction the fake International Criminal
16:32 Court.
16:41 a fake court, which is an unelected
16:43 world tribunal, which claims to
16:45 supersede the laws and constitutions of
16:48 sovereign states, even those who never
16:50 signed up for it. Americans
16:54 have never agreed to submit to the ICC's
16:56 authority. But that court and its allies
16:59 in the global bureaucracy have appointed
17:01 themselves judge and jury and
17:03 executioner of the international order.
17:06 Ruling over all but account ruling over
17:09 all. They're ruling. They think they
17:11 have the right to rule over everyone.
17:13 But they are accountable to no one.
17:16 armed with the power to investigate, to
17:18 prosecute, to persecute, and to jail our
17:21 citizens according to laws with neither
17:24 consent
17:26 nor control.
17:28 They can certainly try, I would say. But
17:30 if they're foolish enough to try to
17:32 enforce their paper decrees on
17:34 Americans, our answer will probably be
17:36 the same as the uh Roman general Pompei
17:38 when he said to those who were trying to
17:41 invoke their city's charters against his
17:42 legions. He said, "Stop quoting laws to
17:46 men with swords."
17:51 Not politically correct to say that, but
17:53 that's what he said. That's what he
17:55 said. Anyway,
17:58 the look, the weaponization of
18:00 international law is not altogether
18:02 different from what we've seen here at
18:03 home. The activist courts who seek to
18:06 govern by injunction twisting the law to
18:08 fit whatever their preferences happen to
18:10 be at any given place or time. Their
18:13 allies in the academy, in the press, the
18:15 professional activist class. The same
18:17 people who just a few years earlier were
18:20 denouncing the Constitution. Okay, these
18:22 are the same people who just a few years
18:23 ago were saying and denouncing the
18:25 Constitution as a racist and backwards
18:28 document that was written by slave
18:29 owners designed only to protect the
18:31 interest of wealthy white men. These
18:34 same people now wax poetic about how
18:37 defending our principles of government
18:39 and how they're carrying out their
18:41 constitutional duties.
18:44 For these people,
18:46 for these people, the fundamental
18:47 purpose of the law, American law and
18:50 international law alike, is to weaken
18:53 the United States. It is to undermine
18:56 our power as a sovereign nation to act.
18:59 It is to hinder the American
19:00 government's ability to defend American
19:02 interests at home and abroad.
19:06 They tell us that we are compelled by a
19:09 sacred legal obligation to give up our
19:11 power, to surrender our sovereignty, to
19:14 submit to the whims of our enemies, to
19:16 allow our cities to descend into violent
19:18 anarchy, to welcome in any foreigner
19:21 from anywhere in the world who arrives
19:23 at our doorstep without permission. To
19:25 transform our towns into refugee camps
19:28 for the entire planet and beyond our
19:30 borders, too. They would have us believe
19:33 that we must allow our rivals to act
19:35 against us with impunity. That those who
19:38 flood our country with drugs and crime
19:40 and death should be met with little more
19:44 than the occasional and polite
19:46 complaint.
19:48 There is nothing there is nothing in our
19:51 history or the history of any other
19:54 great nation that requires us to
19:56 recognize the authority or legitimacy of
19:59 any of these ridiculous ideas.
20:03 Quite the opposite.
20:05 It is not only alien to our political
20:07 and and legal tradition,
20:10 it is alien to who we are.
20:13 It is an attack on our essential
20:16 character as a people. A rejection of
20:19 the qualities and the instincts that
20:20 have defined Americans
20:23 since before the founding itself.
20:26 America has always and I believe will
20:30 always be a nation of irreressible
20:33 ambition. Ambition which since the very
20:36 beginning extended far beyond our
20:38 borders. Low ceilings and small horizons
20:42 were never our destiny.
20:46 Even the American Revolution itself was
20:49 driven in part by our forefathers anger
20:52 at British limits on our westward
20:54 expansion. A grievance cited in the very
20:57 Declaration of Independence itself.
21:00 The history of our nation and our people
21:01 brims. It brims with a hunger to expand,
21:06 to grow, to explore, to conquer, to
21:10 stake a claim to new frontiers. It can
21:12 be found, by the way, in the opening
21:14 paragraph of the Federalist Papers,
21:16 where Hamilton begins by announcing to
21:18 his readers that the ratification debate
21:20 would decide the fate of an empire, and
21:24 many respects the most interesting in
21:27 the world.
21:30 We
21:31 Americans, we are not passive and
21:34 inward-looking people. To submit to the
21:37 sterile vision of radical judges or
21:39 soulless global bureaucrats, would be to
21:41 betray who we are, to betray ourselves.
21:45 the real America, the nation that
21:48 actually exists in the text of our
21:49 founding documents, that actually exists
21:52 in the history of our people, in the
21:54 conduct of the men who built backwater
21:56 colonies into the greatest superpower on
21:58 Earth,
22:00 was always destined to go beyond, to be
22:03 greater and stronger,
22:05 more than which had come before. Our
22:09 laws, our constitution, our legal norms,
22:12 and our political traditions developed
22:14 because
22:16 not in spite of that fact. This is the
22:20 true American genius of self-government.
22:22 The unique and distinctive structure of
22:24 our constitution, marrying a remarkable
22:26 freedom and independence
22:29 with an equally remarkable strength for
22:31 collective action.
22:33 It's the expression of these
22:34 characteristics and instincts.
22:36 Our institutions developed to organize
22:39 and channel our ambition,
22:41 not to suffocate them. Our laws were
22:44 written by and for a people who were
22:46 called upwards
22:48 and eventually even outwards to the
22:50 stars.
22:52 From the very beginning,
22:55 America was on the move. It was alive.
22:58 It was dynamic and it was expanding. A
23:01 nation advancing across the continent,
23:03 settling land, building cities, laying
23:06 roads and railways,
23:09 subduing the wilderness,
23:11 and painting a great civilization
23:14 upon the canvas of a new world.
23:18 In 1776, our our new republic was 13
23:22 states clustered along the eastern coast
23:24 and a handful of scattered frontier
23:27 outposts just beyond the Appalachians.
23:30 In 1848,
23:32 this is just in just 72 years later, the
23:35 American flag flew over a continental
23:37 empire spanning nearly 3 million square
23:40 miles in size, running from the eastern
23:43 cities of Boston and New York to the
23:46 port of San Francisco Bay, to the ports
23:48 of San Francisco Bay. So, think about it
23:51 this way. A child that was born the year
23:53 we declared our independence could have
23:56 lived to see his or her country stretch
24:00 from the Atlantic to the Pacific.
24:03 And our as our territory expanded, our
24:05 horizons only grew. No sooner had we
24:08 reached the western edge of Oregon than
24:10 we began building new systems, networks,
24:12 and technologies that extended out
24:14 across the world. Cutting canals across
24:17 continents that rewrote the rules of
24:18 geography and forging satellites and
24:21 spaceships that reached beyond the
24:23 boundaries of Earth itself.
24:26 None of this
24:28 happened by accident.
24:30 When our predecessors first arrived in
24:33 North America, when they first came,
24:35 there were no factories. There were no
24:37 railroads. There were no skyscrapers.
24:41 These things exist
24:44 because we built them, because we acted.
24:55 These things exist because we acted
24:57 without fear or moral doubt and overcame
25:00 all of all that which threatened or
25:03 stood in our way.
25:06 But today we are told by some that the
25:09 age of great nations pursuing great
25:11 destinies is over. That we cannot act.
25:15 We cannot impose ourselves upon the
25:17 world. that we must surrender our dreams
25:19 to the consensus of distant tribunals
25:22 and submit to our place as merely one
25:24 nation among the many. That we must
25:28 accustom ourselves
25:30 to the comfortable and to quiet decline.
25:34 We are told that our determination to
25:35 act in our own interests on our own
25:37 terms is an assault on the universal
25:41 quote unquote rules-based order. For
25:44 example, under this theory, the
25:46 president himself cannot execute the
25:47 foreign policy of the United States. He
25:50 cannot restrict trade or immigration or
25:52 even examine the way in which we spend
25:54 our citizens tax dollars abroad without
25:57 facing the fury of international lawyers
26:00 and jurists and NOS's and UN bureaucrats
26:04 condemning his threats to glo condemning
26:07 his threats to global values and norms.
26:10 All of this at home and abroad is a
26:14 child of the leveling and pessimistic
26:16 spirit of the age. It entices us to
26:20 relinquish responsibility for our own
26:22 destiny and to relieve ourselves of the
26:25 burdens of greatness and seek refuge in
26:29 these glittering generalities of
26:31 international law.
26:33 Even as we defeated the institution of
26:35 Soviet communism,
26:38 we did not triumph over the spirit of
26:42 Marx.
26:43 That spirit of Marx, it lives. It lives
26:46 on in these new forms and doctrines
26:50 which would subordinate the national
26:51 will to the menial consensus of the
26:54 world. Marxism sought to abolish the
26:58 extin the distinctions between men and
27:00 women. The radicals of our time seek to
27:04 abolish the distinctions between nations
27:06 themselves.
27:09 The ultimate question of our time is
27:12 whether Americans have a moral right to
27:14 exist as a distinct nation and a
27:17 distinct people and thus to demand a
27:20 government that defends and pursues our
27:23 interests above all else. Those who tell
27:27 us that we are living on stolen land, as
27:29 an example, that our nation was founded
27:31 and built upon slavery and genocide and
27:33 oppression, are telling us clearly that
27:36 they do not believe that we do.
27:40 They would have us think that America
27:42 that America and more broadly that the
27:44 West are uniquely burdened by guilt.
27:47 Guilt that we can only atone for through
27:50 total surrender. by opening our borders,
27:54 by renouncing our laws, by retreating
27:56 from the world and allowing them to
27:57 remake our society in their image.
28:02 We should understand clearly that these
28:05 these are the stakes of our political
28:08 struggle. We should remember that this
28:11 is what many in the universities, on the
28:13 courts, or in the halls of government
28:15 what they really believe. As recently as
28:18 2021, we had a president telling us that
28:22 hatred hatred was systemically embedded
28:26 in our laws and our culture.
28:30 Today, few of any of these people
28:32 involved on that side of our political
28:34 debate have renounced those ideas.
28:36 Their fundamental beliefs have not
28:38 changed. And in the coming months, we
28:41 can expect to hear a lot about their
28:43 deep concern for the Constitution, the
28:46 law, the principles and axioms of
28:49 justice.
28:50 But that concern
28:53 seems to only appear when it can be
28:56 wielded as an obstacle or a weapon to
29:00 advance their interests.
29:02 politics both here in the United States
29:04 and on the international stage.
29:07 Frankly, it is not a marketplace of
29:08 ideas where good faith interlocators can
29:11 debate and reason together and the
29:12 better argument always prevails.
29:15 Persuasion matters, but not everyone is
29:18 always persuadable.
29:20 The lessons of the Federalist Society is
29:22 that victory requires something beyond
29:24 good arguments.
29:26 Victory is secured through institutions
29:29 and networks and systems fixated on a
29:32 shared goal
29:34 capable of shaping and exercising
29:37 influence.
29:39 This organization's long march through
29:41 the institutions of American law was
29:42 carried out by men and women who were
29:45 armed not just with ideas but with
29:48 ambitious plans of action, cultivating
29:51 and recruiting the most promising young
29:53 conservative minds of their generation,
29:55 funneling them into the pipelines to
29:57 power, carrying their cause from the
30:00 lecture halls to the highest courts in
30:03 the nation. Those who believe that one
30:07 setback, one defeat, one bad election
30:11 spells the end of the republic
30:15 should look to you as an example for
30:17 inspiration.
30:18 And it is the same lesson, by the way,
30:20 that is written in the fabric of our
30:22 country,
30:24 a lesson written in the fabric of our
30:26 revolution that gave birth to this
30:28 nation itself.
30:29 You know, too often we we tell the story
30:31 of American independence as some
30:34 inevitable and certain triumph. As if
30:36 Washington and the Continental Army were
30:38 always faded to prevail, students of our
30:41 history know that nothing could be
30:43 further from the truth.
30:45 The first year of the revolution was an
30:48 almost unbroken line of devastating and
30:52 humiliating defeats. By December of
30:55 1776,
30:57 General Washington had less than 3,000
30:59 men fit for duty, limping, starving,
31:03 freezing, and sick. And they were in
31:06 desperate retreat with the greatest
31:09 empire of the age in hot pursuit.
31:12 All across the colonies, the
31:15 revolutionary spirit seemed to be in
31:17 collapse. In fact, something not often
31:21 featured in the movies and in the
31:23 documentaries and perhaps even the books
31:25 about this era, thousands of Americans
31:28 took British pardons and renewed their
31:31 allegiance to the crown. That's how bad
31:33 things were. Men who had cheered the
31:35 cause of independence only months
31:37 earlier made their peace with what
31:40 seemed to be inevitable defeat. That
31:43 month,
31:45 Washington wrote a letter to his brother
31:49 He said, 'Unless something changes soon,
31:51 he wrote, I think the game is pretty
31:53 near up. And he concluded his letter
31:56 with this. He said, it was a quote. You
31:59 at a distance can form no idea of the
32:01 perplexity of my situation. No man, I
32:04 believe ever had a greater choice of
32:06 difficulties and less means of
32:07 extricating self than I have. However,
32:10 under a full persuasion of the justice
32:12 of our cause, I cannot but think the
32:16 prospect will brighten, although for
32:19 wise purposes it is at present hidden
32:22 under a cloud.
32:25 Well, he was ultimately right. 5 years
32:28 later, Washington, and we acknowledge
32:30 his French allies, surrounded the
32:33 British army at Yorktown. Cornwallis
32:36 surrendered. The revolution prevailed.
32:39 and a nation was born.
32:42 We have much more to do over the next
32:44 two, the next six, the next 20 years.
32:49 Great things that last are built in
32:52 decades, not election cycles. There will
32:56 be more victories and there will be more
32:58 defeats.
33:00 There will be more triumphs
33:02 and there will be more disappointments.
33:05 This is the nature of all undertakings
33:08 of this weight and of this magnitude.
33:11 There are no great men or great causes
33:14 in the pages of history that did not
33:17 suffer the same. But we are persuaded
33:21 of the justice of our cause. And we too
33:25 will triumph in the end. And I am con
33:40 And though we are prepared for the
33:42 twists and turns and the ups and downs
33:44 of the road ahead of this I believe with
33:47 all my heart that we in this generation
33:51 will leave for our children and our
33:53 grandchildren
33:55 what Americans always leave for their
33:56 children and their grandchildren
33:58 the single greatest nation.
34:01 in the history of the world. Thank you
34:04 very much.
34:14 Heat.
34:30 Heat.
34:56 Thank you.
35:00 Thank you.
35:03 All right. Thank you.
35:06 They told me to stay up here. Why am I
35:08 am I answering questions?
35:11 >> I don't have a second. I mean, I do have
35:13 another speech, but uh
35:16 they didn't tell you there was an
35:17 intermission, did they? All right, go
35:18 ahead. Are you our first question? Okay,
35:20 great.
35:20 >> Thank you so much for being here. Uh my
35:22 name is Morgan Hughes. I'm a 3L at the
35:24 Florida State College of Law. So, goals.
35:27 Um
35:30 they're baiting me. Go Gators.
35:37 So, it seems as though Christian
35:39 attorneys are consistently told that
35:40 they have to leave their faith at the
35:41 door whenever they're practicing law. As
35:44 a believer and an attorney, how do you
35:45 believe we're supposed to respond to
35:46 this pressure?
35:47 >> Well, remember, I did land you some
35:48 zoning. Okay. So,
35:53 >> uh so, uh no, um the uh the hardest
35:56 thing to zone in the world is a church
35:58 and a funeral home, as you know. So, I'm
35:59 telling you, nobody wants either one
36:01 next to them because of the parking. But
36:02 anyway,
36:05 No, that's an important question. Look,
36:06 I don't so I think your faith
36:09 attorney is what you do. Your faith is
36:12 who you are. And so I I think that
36:20 and if you speak specifically about
36:22 Christianity as your faith, then I would
36:23 say this is a faith that teaches that
36:25 your job is to care for the less
36:27 fortunate, to feed the hungry and clothe
36:29 the naked and visit the prisoner, which
36:31 you'll do often if you're a defense
36:33 attorney. And uh and but I and I also
36:36 think embedded in our system of
36:37 government in our system of laws is very
36:40 powerful Judeo-Christian principles
36:41 about the dignity of the human being and
36:43 of the individual which our legal system
36:45 ultimately recognizes. If you think
36:46 about our criminal justice system for a
36:48 moment, it's built on the notion that no
36:50 matter how guilty someone may be, they
36:52 are entitled to the most vigorous
36:53 defense and that it is the state's job
36:56 to prove the case against this person.
36:58 Because a human life and human freedom
36:59 is so valuable that you must overcome
37:02 extraordinary obstacles in order to
37:04 ensure that if you're going to put
37:05 someone in jail, you the evidence and
37:07 the burden is on your side to prove it.
37:09 In essence, not the other way around. We
37:10 take that for granted. But in many parts
37:12 of the world, you're presumed guilty.
37:13 And your job is to go in there and
37:15 convince them that you're not guilty. In
37:17 our country, in our system of law,
37:18 you're presumed innocent, even though
37:20 everybody knows you did it
37:23 right. But that isn't because we're nice
37:25 people. It's because that embedded in
37:27 our Judeo-Christian values is the belief
37:29 that the individual and the freedom of
37:31 that individual is s is something that's
37:35 sacred because it's given to us by our
37:37 creator. Our very founding documents
37:38 speak to the fact that our rights don't
37:40 come from government. Our rights don't
37:42 come from the law. Our rights are not
37:43 determined by whoever happens to be
37:45 leading us every 2, four, six years. Our
37:47 law, our rights come from our creator.
37:49 They are they are inherent in us as a
37:51 person. So I think you bring that into
37:53 the legal profession. Now I don't know
37:54 how it applies to a real estate
37:55 contract, but I can tell you how it
37:57 applies to a criminal justice system and
37:59 to our broader system. So I would just
38:00 say that your faith should inform you in
38:02 what you do. And I think ultimately it's
38:04 a faith. You spoke again that you're a
38:06 Christian. Christianity teaches us, as
38:08 you said, not just to care for the less
38:09 fortunate, but also to value human
38:11 dignity and the dignity of all people uh
38:14 irrespective of the circumstances they
38:15 come from. And I think these are things
38:17 we want to encourage in the legal
38:18 profession, not discouraged.
38:28 >> Thank you so much for being here,
38:30 Secretary Rivio. My name is Cher
38:31 Gansburg. I'm a 3L and the president of
38:33 the Berkeley chapter.
38:34 >> Of the where chapter?
38:35 >> Berkeley Law. Oo,
38:38 we're we're very loved. So, f first, as
38:41 a service member, I want to thank you
38:43 for your service to our country and all
38:44 all that you're doing and all your many
38:45 roles. Thank you.
38:51 So many young Americans seem to have
38:53 anxiety about the future and are drawn
38:55 to extremes, whether that be
38:56 anti-semitism, communism, socialism. As
38:59 a son of Cuban immigrants, how do we
39:01 instill the values to the next
39:02 generation of love for our freedom, love
39:04 for the values of our country as you
39:06 clearly have so successfully done with
39:07 your own daughter? Um, well, my home was
39:10 not a democracy. So, it begins.
39:16 And by the way, I was not the dictator
39:18 either. I was I was I was the minister
39:21 of defense. Uh but
39:25 but uh all kidding aside, uh kind of uh
39:28 the uh no all joking aside, no look, I
39:31 think, look, I have no problem with
39:33 people like going through the phases of
39:35 life where they explore different
39:36 thinking and so forth and so on. But I
39:38 do think there are a couple things that
39:39 are important that I think should be at
39:41 the foundation of everything. The first
39:42 is I and I just believe this because I
39:44 think history backs it. The American
39:47 story is exceptional. It's
39:48 extraordinary. It has no precedent in
39:50 the history of the world anywhere.
39:56 And I think that I think we've neglected
39:58 to say that. I think we've spent 20 or
40:00 30 years sort of be for for a
40:02 combination of reasons in our education
40:04 system sort of infusing in people all
40:06 the terrible things that are that have
40:07 happened in the history of our country.
40:08 To which I say I've never said our
40:10 history is perfect. I have only said our
40:11 history is better than anybody else's.
40:14 And I and I truly mean that. If you
40:15 think about all, for example, what is a
40:17 proper teaching of our history and some
40:19 of its worst moments? If you think about
40:20 all the great justice movements in our
40:22 history, the end of slavery, the end of
40:25 segregation, the women's right to vote,
40:27 all of these advances, every single one
40:29 of them, okay, was not a rejection of
40:32 our founding principles. You know what
40:33 each one of them was? It was a demand
40:35 that we live up to our founding
40:36 principles.
40:38 Every single one of them.
40:42 In fact,
40:44 one of the best lines in Dr. King's I
40:47 have a dream speech is a demand that we
40:49 live up to the ancient words of our
40:50 founding. He didn't say overthrow the
40:53 government. He didn't say reject the
40:54 constitution, walk away from the
40:56 principles of the declaration of
40:57 independence. What he was accusing us of
40:58 is that we were not living up to the
41:01 principles of who we were. The second on
41:03 the on the point of economics and this
41:05 is just my personal point of view. Look,
41:07 I believe in the free market but I don't
41:09 worship the free market. I think the
41:10 market exists to serve people, not
41:13 people to serve the market. The market
41:14 is a tool to achieve to to provide for
41:17 human achievement and prosperity.
41:20 But but there's also a national interest
41:22 that has to be balanced. I think the
41:23 market works when it does two things. It
41:25 provides wealth and prosperity, but it
41:27 also provides opportunity for people to
41:29 find dignified work. So we have to do a
41:31 better job of understanding that there's
41:32 no absolutes here. And ultimately the
41:34 market is an example is a tool. I think
41:36 we have to recognize that people are
41:37 struggling. There's no doubt about it.
41:39 There's no doubt and I think the numbers
41:41 are clear that younger people today are
41:44 further behind than their peers were 20,
41:45 30, 40 years ago. And to ignore that
41:47 would be to close our eyes. I think we
41:49 sometimes forget that yes, I'm not
41:51 saying the stock market is irrelevant
41:52 and unimportant. But for most people,
41:54 the health of our economy has nothing to
41:56 do with the stock market. The health of
41:58 their economy is whether they have
41:59 enough money to be able to afford the
42:00 things they need and want. That's how
42:02 they judge the health of our economy.
42:04 So, we do have a lot of work to make
42:06 these arguments. People call it
42:07 populism. I just call it common sense. I
42:09 think it's important though that it all
42:11 starts with a founding belief or the
42:14 foundation of making these arguments
42:16 that's expressing to people the
42:17 extraordinary story of America. And one
42:19 of the things that's most extraordinary
42:21 about our history is this unbroken chain
42:23 of each generation leaving the next
42:24 better off with a safer, better, more
42:26 prosperous country. And that's the
42:28 challenge before us now. Because I do
42:30 think there's a legitimate fear that we
42:32 will be the first generation to leave
42:33 the next worse off. And that can't
42:36 happen. That's unamerican. And it runs
42:37 against our story. It run against our
42:39 history. And I I think the foundation
42:41 for all of it is explained to people
42:42 that America is exceptional, but it's
42:44 not self-perpetuated. It has always
42:46 required those in charge to do what it
42:48 takes to keep it moving forward and that
42:51 that's what we're called to do and that
42:52 and and then have confidence that we can
42:54 do it. Um it's an enormous undertaking.
42:57 And it's like I said in my speech, it's
42:59 something that happens over, you know,
43:01 years and decades, not election cycle to
43:03 election cycle.
43:13 Hi,
43:14 >> thank you for being here. My name is
43:16 Mariah Ser and I'm currently a 3L at the
43:18 University of Texas. Recently in Gree,
43:21 >> we beat Texas this year. Florida.
43:24 >> I am a Florida grad as well.
43:26 >> We We also lost to a couple other
43:29 I'm sorry. Go ahead. It's not your
43:31 fault. You don't You're not on the team,
43:33 so I'm not
43:35 Recently in Greece, you spoke on the
43:37 balance between our nation's domestic
43:40 sovereignty and our international
43:42 security demands as a leader of the
43:43 Western world. How can the
43:45 administration adequately address both
43:47 of these needs without forfeiting the
43:49 support of the American electorate which
43:51 has clearly expressed a focus on
43:54 domestic concerns?
43:54 >> Yeah, they're interrelated, but they're
43:56 always going to be. Look, let me start
43:57 with this. I think the job of America's
44:00 government and its leaders is to work
44:02 for Americans. I mean that sounds kind
44:04 of strange but in the realm of foreign
44:05 policy we've almost lost it but we've
44:06 also lost it in the realm of economics
44:09 these are my personal views but I've
44:10 argued them in writing I've argued them
44:12 in speeches I think there came a point
44:14 in which we forgot like the end of the
44:15 cold war
44:17 um everybody thought okay the whole
44:19 world is now going to become free
44:20 enterprise democracies
44:22 and it just didn't work out that way it
44:24 was never going to work out that way the
44:26 second is we placed this confidence in
44:28 the markets in global markets and
44:29 basically saying it's okay if a bunch of
44:31 jobs leave our country and relocate
44:33 somewhere else. They'll make it cheaper
44:35 over there, which means prices will be
44:36 cheaper over here, which is true. The
44:38 prices will be cheaper over here, but
44:39 you just wiped out a bunch of jobs,
44:40 gutted a bunch of communities, and now
44:42 you have a bunch of people that don't
44:43 feel like they can move forward. All of
44:45 this happened because we lost our focus.
44:47 We forgot that our job is we're not
44:48 against the world. We're not our job is
44:50 not to harm the world, but our number
44:52 one objective must always be what's in
44:54 the national interest of the United
44:55 States, and we shouldn't feel guilty
44:57 about it. Okay? Next week I will get on
44:59 an airplane with the president and we
45:00 will fly, for example, to the
45:02 Philippines for the Azon conference and
45:04 then we will fly to China for the APEC
45:05 conference. And I was asked by a
45:07 reporter the other day, well something
45:09 about a disagreement we have with China.
45:11 And I said, look, the Chinese government
45:12 is in favor of what's good for China and
45:15 they don't apologize for it. We are the
45:17 only country in the world that seems to
45:18 have forgotten it. I'm on the American
45:20 side of every issue
45:23 and
45:30 And that I even that I even have to say
45:33 that is stunning. But think about it.
45:35 The fact that I even have to say that is
45:37 stunning. I always remind people I am
45:38 the secretary of state of the United
45:40 States. Not there was a huge outrage.
45:42 You know I we did a we have these flags
45:45 at the state department when you walk in
45:47 and we had all these flags of all these
45:48 different countries. I look I didn't go
45:50 in with like a crusade to remove the
45:52 flags. We left it there for a year and a
45:53 half. But then for America 250, we made
45:55 them all American flags. Okay? And then
45:57 we left them there after 250. And people
45:59 were going crazy. Oh my god, they're
46:00 abandoning the world. I said, "No, we're
46:01 not the United Nations. Take the flag.
46:03 The United Nations can have all those
46:04 flags. It's the State Department of the
46:06 United States." And
46:10 so
46:16 so the way I view it is that what what
46:18 we need to do on I I think the question
46:20 was probably geared towards more why is
46:22 the United States involved in things
46:23 around the world? Well, we have to be
46:24 involved in things around the world
46:25 because whether we're involved in the
46:27 world or not, the world will be involved
46:28 with us. There are things happening in
46:30 other countries and in other places that
46:32 do have an impact on the national
46:33 security of the United States but and
46:36 our economic interests as well. We can
46:38 make the greatest products in the world,
46:39 but if we don't have markets that are
46:41 open to us as an example, that's going
46:42 to be a problem. We can if if if there's
46:45 instability and insecurity in our
46:47 hemisphere, we will eventually have
46:48 migratory pressures because this
46:51 administration has made the decision
46:52 that it's going to protect our borders.
46:54 But the next administration may not. And
46:57 so I would argue that America is safer
47:00 and better off if we are surrounded by
47:02 countries that are stable, safe, and
47:03 prosperous. But ultimately,
47:07 and we should do things in our policy
47:09 because it's in our national interest.
47:10 But in the end, on any topic, the number
47:13 one question we have to always ask
47:15 ourselves is what is in the best
47:16 interest of the United States? And we
47:18 had not only have we forgotten it, we've
47:20 actually abandoned it for far too long.
47:22 And I think this administration is
47:24 returning to that idea. And that's how
47:26 we try to pursue it. Again, that doesn't
47:28 mean we don't meet with other countries
47:29 and it doesn't mean we don't work with
47:30 other countries because often times when
47:32 our national interests align with the
47:34 interest of another country, that's
47:36 where you build alliances. When your
47:38 national interests are in conflict with
47:40 other countries, that's where the work
47:41 of diplomacy happens to see how you can
47:43 balance the two. But in the end, if we
47:45 can't balance it, I know whose side we
47:47 need to be on. And that is on the side
47:48 of our people, our country, our economy,
47:50 and our security. And and I think that
47:52 every nation governs itself that way. We
47:54 forgot it and we're restoring it.
48:04 >> Thank you so much for being here. My
48:06 name is Tasha Donbacher. I'm a 2L at
48:08 Harvard Law School.
48:09 >> 2L. The rest are three L's. Two L.
48:12 Excellent.
48:13 Uh, one of the remarkable things about
48:15 the United States is that people from
48:17 every corner of the world have come here
48:19 and they've come here not just to become
48:21 residents but to become patriotic
48:22 Americans. Um, that has depended on a
48:25 shared national identity, a common civic
48:27 culture and an expectation that
48:29 newcomers will embrace American values
48:32 rather than simply bring the divisions
48:33 of the old world with them. Today, we're
48:36 increasingly reluctant to insist that
48:38 assimilation is a good thing. Have we
48:40 lost confidence in the idea that there
48:42 is a distinct American identity that is
48:44 worth preserving? And how do we restore
48:46 a culture of patriotic citizenship that
48:48 fosters assimilation without losing what
48:50 has historically made America
48:51 exceptional?
48:52 >> That's a great question. That's a
48:54 fantastic question and it's at the heart
48:55 of everything I did. Well, the first is
48:58 that you're right. I mean, and there
48:59 were practical reasons why. First of
49:01 all, I don't want to like go into all
49:02 great details, but if you came here 100
49:04 years ago, you probably were never going
49:06 back to where you came from. I mean,
49:07 just you're not going to get there
49:08 because you're not getting back on that
49:09 ship and sailing at 180 days the other
49:11 way. You know, it didn't happen. Now
49:12 you're just a flight away. So, that's
49:13 the reality of the world is more
49:15 connected in that regard. I think the
49:17 other thing some of the things that have
49:18 changed about immigration and look I let
49:21 me start let me preface it by saying
49:23 this. It's not that I don't understand.
49:24 If you live in a place that's dangerous,
49:26 if you live in a place that's poor and
49:28 like the freest most wealthy economy in
49:31 the history of the world is nearby, I
49:33 understand that allure. I get it. I
49:35 really do. I understand the human
49:36 behavior. Again, I go back to our
49:37 national interest. We we still can't
49:39 just be a place that says you can come
49:41 here from anywhere in the world that you
49:42 want and you don't have to follow any
49:44 rules. But on the point of assimilation,
49:46 I think there's a difference between
49:48 coming to live and work in America and
49:51 coming to be an American. They're not
49:53 always the same thing. And I think
49:54 that's incredibly important for us to
49:56 remember because we do have a
49:57 distinctive national character. And
50:00 people ask me though, what you know,
50:01 we're not the United States. We're not a
50:04 common ethnicity. We're not a common
50:06 race. We're not a We're not bound. You
50:08 know what binds us? That we're all I
50:09 truly believe this. America is a nation.
50:12 We are all the descendants of
50:14 go-getters. If you think about
50:21 whether you came here on a ship that
50:23 sailed across the Atlantic, whether you
50:26 came here because you refused to accept
50:28 the restrictions of their nation of
50:29 birth, whether your ancestors overcame
50:32 the horrors of slavery and after that of
50:34 segregation. We are the descendants of
50:36 people that refused the limits and said,
50:38 "We're going to continue to strive and
50:40 build for ourselves a better life." That
50:42 blood literally runs through our veins.
50:43 That's who we are as a people and as a
50:45 nation. And I think America will always
50:46 be a nation that welcomes people from
50:48 other places so long as we have certain
50:50 rules and controls and restrictions in
50:52 place that determines how many people
50:54 can come, when they can come, who can
50:56 come. Those are that every sovereign
50:58 nation makes that. But to go back to
51:00 your central question about assimilation
51:02 of the national character, that's
51:03 absolutely essential. And look, I think
51:05 it happens more often than I think we've
51:07 lost it in some places. I think in
51:09 others it's still very well alive. Some
51:11 of the most patriotic people in this
51:13 country, and this is not a criticism of
51:15 anybody, but some of the most patriotic
51:17 people you ever meet are people that are
51:19 Americans by choice, not people that are
51:22 Americans.
51:24 And I'll tell you why.
51:28 And I and I'll tell you why. Because if
51:30 I've I've lived in America my entire
51:32 life. I was born in the United States.
51:34 I've grown up here. I don't know what
51:36 life is like. But when you meet someone
51:38 who knows what life is like somewhere
51:39 else, when you meet someone that knows
51:41 what it's like to live in a society
51:43 where you don't have polit not just
51:44 political freedoms, but where your very
51:46 future is determined on the day you are
51:48 born by what your parents did and
51:50 whether they were connected or not. When
51:52 you meet people like that, they know
51:54 that life in this country is special.
51:56 They know that life in this country is
51:57 different and they have a lot to
51:59 contribute. So Americans by choice,
52:02 people that did it the right way and
52:03 chose to be Americans, oftent times I
52:06 think understand how special this
52:08 country is more than someone like me
52:10 even who was born here and lived their
52:12 entire life and have never had to live
52:14 under a different system or a different
52:15 and I think we need to hear more from
52:17 those voices as well. I think they're
52:18 very powerful in that regard.
52:29 Mr. Secretary, thank you so much for
52:31 being here. Um, we're really grateful
52:32 that you're here. Um, I'm Lucy Griffin.
52:34 I'm a 2L. I'm the president of the
52:36 Federalist Society at William and Mary.
52:39 Um, we don't play you in sports.
52:41 >> No, but they have a team. No, no, but
52:43 they have a team. I know all about it.
52:44 Go ahead.
52:46 >> Um,
52:46 >> I'm like a sicko on football and college
52:48 football, so I know everybody that has a
52:49 team. In fact, I judge schools by their
52:51 team.
52:54 We're D2. Don't hold it against
52:55 >> I don't care about US News and World
52:57 Report rankings.
53:00 >> Go ahead. I'm sorry.
53:03 >> You've you've described you've you've
53:05 demonstrated a victorious American
53:07 mentality? So, at this point in the
53:10 conflict in Iran, what would you
53:13 consider an American victory?
53:15 >> That's a great question. I think the two
53:17 things are important is to understand
53:18 why we're in it in the first place. Iran
53:21 has been waging, whether we want to
53:22 believe it or not, they've been waging
53:24 war on the United States since 1979. And
53:26 the problem with this
53:34 and the the problem with this regime is
53:38 it's the revolutionary nature. One thing
53:41 is to be a country because you can have
53:43 disagreements with countries. The
53:45 problem is the country of Iran is
53:47 governed by an elected class of people
53:48 who we don't agree with. And I'm not
53:50 arguing or moderate to people we can
53:51 agree with. That's the government runs
53:54 the country. But the country is led by a
53:57 religious Shia clerical class. Not just
54:01 Shia clerics, but radical Shia clerics
54:03 who are motivated in their
54:05 decision-making by theology. Now this
54:07 sounds very strange because people, you
54:08 know, that's you don't often hear this
54:10 conversation when it comes to
54:11 geopolitics. But if you don't understand
54:12 this, you don't understand Iran. And
54:14 these people are not governors of Iran.
54:16 They could care less what Iran's economy
54:18 looks like. These people are
54:19 revolutionaries. If you look at the
54:21 founding documents of this Islamic
54:23 Republic, it says that the supreme
54:24 leader is not the leader of Iran. Says
54:26 the supreme leader is the leader of all
54:28 Muslims, including Sunni, who by the way
54:31 don't agree. Uh and and that their job
54:34 is to export the revolution. And what
54:36 does export the revolution look like?
54:38 Well, it looks like Hezbollah, who they
54:40 have created and funded and helped to
54:43 grow to have capabilities that rival the
54:45 nation state and in many cases is more
54:47 powerful than even the Lebanese state.
54:49 The same Hezbollah that blew up a bunker
54:51 that a barracks that killed over 280
54:54 American Marines in 1982 83 um and have
54:58 conducted acts of terrorism to the very
55:00 present day. It looks like the militias
55:02 in Iraq who as I speak to you now are
55:05 plotting and have plotted for years not
55:06 just to attack America but to attack
55:08 regional neighbors with very
55:10 sophisticated weaponry. It looks like
55:12 their constant sponsor. It it looks like
55:14 the Syrian civil war which they were
55:16 clearly behind the destruction of that
55:18 country that at one time was a place
55:20 that had all these different elements of
55:22 society. They had Sunni and Shia and
55:24 Christian and Drews and Bedwin all
55:25 living along it and Aloise all living
55:27 along each other. Then it became a
55:29 dictatorship supported by Iran and
55:31 ultimately and that's the fundamental
55:32 problem with them. The second is they're
55:34 the world's leading sponsor of
55:35 terrorism. No nation state in the
55:38 history of humanity has spent more time
55:41 or money sponsoring acts of terrorism
55:44 around this planet than the Iranian
55:46 regime because through their proxies in
55:48 Hezbollah just an example in our own
55:50 hemisphere in the early 1990s they blew
55:53 up a Jewish center in Buenos Iris
55:56 Argentina in our own hemisphere
55:59 this is who we're dealing with and these
56:01 people want a nuclear weapon and they
56:04 want a nuclear weapon and they'll always
56:05 say oh we're not interested in a nuclear
56:06 weapon. No, they're just interested in
56:07 all the things you need for a nuclear
56:09 weapon.
56:11 Okay? They built missiles for nuclear
56:13 weapons. They enrich uranium well beyond
56:15 the need. If what they wanted was
56:17 nuclear energy, they could have had it
56:18 like South Korea has it, like Japan,
56:20 like other countries do. They argue it's
56:23 like saying, "Oh, I'm not interested in
56:24 committing an act of violence. I just
56:26 want to buy ammunition and I want to buy
56:27 a gun, but the ammunition's not in the
56:29 gun, but it would take a second to put
56:31 the ammunition in the gun and become a
56:32 weapon that can kill people." And that's
56:34 what they've done. And they built
56:36 themselves to a point where they have
56:37 over the years of neglect on this topic.
56:40 We have allowed them to build up so many
56:42 missiles and so many drones and so many
56:44 that they were going to hide behind that
56:46 conventional shield to do whatever they
56:48 wanted with their nuclear capability and
56:50 it had to be addressed. And I know it's
56:52 unpopular. Believe me, no war is
56:54 popular. No conflict, military conflict
56:56 is popular. And right now, frankly, the
56:59 economic pain that we are inflicting on
57:01 that regime is so great that there's no
57:03 need for for for military action because
57:06 we've weakened them so much. But I think
57:08 victory is ensuring that they never have
57:09 a nuclear weapon. As simplistic as that
57:11 may sound, I assure you that as bad as
57:13 things may appear today, you think that
57:15 them shooting at ships on the in the
57:16 streets of Warmuz is bad right now, even
57:18 though 13 to 14 million barrels are
57:20 getting out every night. Imagine if they
57:22 had a nuclear weapon. They would hold
57:24 the entire region hostage. They would
57:27 hold this nation hostage. Imagine North
57:30 Korea, but North Korea is just governed
57:33 by a guy that's a little, you know, you
57:36 know, and uh but no, no, what I mean is
57:39 he's not interested in like conquering
57:40 Japan, okay? He just wants to survive in
57:43 his regime. And I'm not excusing the
57:45 terrible things that have happened
57:46 there. I'm just saying but he's not um
57:48 expansionist. He's not looking to like
57:50 invade Japan and, you know, invade
57:52 China, whatever. He's not. These people
57:54 are expansionists. They're
57:55 revolutionaries and armed with a nuclear
57:57 weapon.
57:59 Last point I would make. Every problem
58:02 in the Middle East, every major problem
58:04 in the Middle East, the Houthies
58:06 attacking Saudi Arabia, the Shia
58:07 militias that destabilized Iraq, the the
58:10 the fighting elements that supported
58:11 Assad and the destruction of Syria,
58:13 Hezbollah in Lebanon. Everywhere you
58:15 turn, there's one common denominator.
58:18 The Shia clerics of Iran and their
58:21 expansionist mentality. This is an
58:23 extraordinary historic danger and one
58:24 that cannot be ignored because I know we
58:26 think it's a half a world away, but
58:28 nothing is half a world away anymore.
58:31 Nothing is. It will reach eventually and
58:33 threaten our country. And it's a threat
58:35 that has to be addressed and it's not
58:36 easy to address these things because
58:37 it's not popular to address them. But to
58:39 ignore them, which would have been the
58:41 easiest thing for the president to do,
58:42 frankly, four years in office, leave it
58:44 for the next person to worry about. But
58:46 that's what he inherited. And he said,
58:47 "I'm not going to leave it unressed."
58:49 But it's hard. It's not easy. And it's
58:51 difficult. And often times it inflicts,
58:53 you know, pain, economic pain and
58:55 otherwise. So we recognize that. But
58:57 victory is they can never have a nuclear
58:59 weapon one way or the other. If it means
59:00 they don't have the money for one or
59:02 they don't have the the equipment for
59:04 one, we we can never allow ourselves to
59:06 live in a world or our children or any
59:08 of you to inherit a planet in which
59:10 those people who have done these things
59:13 and inherit have a nuclear weapon. They
59:16 have killed tens and tens of thousands
59:18 of their own people. Slaughtered them in
59:20 the streets. Then when you're injured,
59:22 they go in the hospitals and they kill
59:23 you in your hospital bed. And oftentimes
59:25 they will also kill the doctors and the
59:27 nurses who treated you. That's what they
59:29 do to their own people. Imagine what
59:31 they would do to us if they had a
59:34 nuclear weapon.
59:44 Heat.
59:46 Heat.
59:56 Yeah.
1:00:03 Heat.
1:00:21 Heat. Heat.
Fed releases financial stability report, respondents raised concerns around AI full transcript
0:02 MACRO OR FUNDAMENTAL MESSAGE
0:03 THAT'S BEING SENT.
0:04 >> EXACTLY. WE GOT SOME
0:05 BREAKING NEWS ON THE FED. LET'S
0:07 GET TO STEVE LIESMAN. WHO'S GOT
0:08 THE DETAILS. STEVE.
0:10 >> MELISSA, THE FEDERAL RESERVE
0:11 OUT WITH ITS SEMIANNUAL
0:12 FINANCIAL STABILITY REPORT, IN
0:13 WHICH IT MAKES VERY CLEAR THAT
0:15 IT IS CLOSELY MONITORING JUST
0:16 WHAT YOU WERE TALKING ABOUT.
0:18 AND THAT IS THE FINANCING IN
0:19 THE AI WORLD. THEY SAY THE
0:21 COMPLEX DATA CENTER FINANCING
0:23 AND ALL THE LINKAGES POSE RISKS
0:25 THAT NEED CLOSE MONITORING.
0:27 THEY GO ON TO SAY THAT BANK
0:29 CREDIT COMMITMENTS TO OTHER
0:30 FINANCIAL INSTITUTIONS
0:31 SURPASSED 2.8 TRILLION IN THE
0:34 SECOND QUARTER. INCLUDED IN
0:35 THAT WAS PRIVATE EQUITY AND
0:38 PRIVATE CREDIT, ACCOUNTING FOR
0:39 ABOUT A QUARTER OF THAT. THE
0:41 LARGEST U.S. BANK, U.S. BANK
0:42 HOLDING COMPANIES HAVE $1
0:43 TRILLION OF EXPOSURE TO TECH.
0:46 AI RELATED DEBT ISSUANCE WAS UP
0:49 $680 BILLION THROUGH OCTOBER,
0:50 UP FIVE FOLD FROM 2023. TOTAL
0:52 DEBT ESTIMATED AT 1.1 TRILLION.
0:55 NOW, THE FED IS UNCLEAR HOW
0:56 MUCH DEBT THERE IS IN THE
0:58 PRIVATE CREDIT MARKETS. MOVING
1:00 ON. COMBINED DEBT LEASES,
1:02 GUARANTEES, ALL OF THAT STUFF.
1:03 A LITTLE BIT OF APPLES AND
1:04 ORANGES MIXING HERE, BUT IT'S
1:06 $3 TRILLION FOR THE MAJOR
1:08 HYPERSCALERS. THE FED, LOOKING
1:09 CLOSELY AT THE TEN KS AND THE
1:11 QS OF AMAZON, ALPHABET,
1:13 BROADCOM, META, MICROSOFT,
1:14 NVIDIA AND ORACLE. AND COMING
1:15 UP WITH THAT NUMBER, THE FIRM'S
1:18 ECONOMIC EXPOSURE TO FUTURE
1:19 DOWNTURN MAY BE LARGER THAN
1:21 IMPLIED BY WHAT'S ON BALANCE OR
1:23 ON THEIR ON BALANCE SHEET
1:25 LIABILITIES. THE LARGEST TECH
1:26 FIRMS, HOWEVER, THEY COULD
1:27 ABSORB LOSSES OF SMALLER FIRMS,
1:28 THE FED SAYS IN THE EVENT OF A
1:30 FINANCIAL DOWNTURN THAT WOULD
1:32 LESSEN THE OVERALL IMPACT ON
1:34 THE FINANCIAL SYSTEM. THEY DID
1:35 A SURVEY. THEY DO THIS EVERY
1:36 TIME. NOW WITH THE FINANCE
1:38 SURVEY OF MARKET CONTACTS
1:40 CONDUCTED BY THE NEW YORK FED.
1:41 SO THIS IS NOT THE FED'S
1:43 OPINION, BUT THOSE SURVEY
1:44 RESPONDENTS SHARPLY RAISED
1:45 THEIR CONCERNS FOR ARTIFICIAL
1:48 INTELLIGENCE AND FINANCING. IF
1:49 YOU LOOK AT THE RESPONSES, 87%
1:52 SAID IT'S A RISK OUT THERE.
1:54 THAT'S UP 37 POINTS SINCE MAY.
1:56 52% SAID THE RISK CORRECTION
1:58 AND RISK ASSET PRICES UP 17
2:01 POINTS OVERALL. ACROSS THE
2:02 BOARD. YOU CAN SEE THEIR RISKS
2:04 ARE HIGHER AMONG THOSE
2:06 RESPONDENTS CONTACTED BY THE
2:08 FED, INCLUDING THE DEBT RISKS
2:10 AS WELL AS CYBER ATTACK RISKS
2:12 ARE ALSO A MAJOR CONCERN FOR
2:15 THE REPORT, UP 13 POINTS FOR
2:17 FISCAL DEBT SUSTAINABILITY.
2:19 THAT'S ONE ISSUE OUT THERE.
2:21 JUST A COUPLE OTHER ONES THEY
2:22 NORMALLY DO ARE FORWARD PES
2:23 WELL ABOVE HISTORICAL MEDIAN.
2:25 BUT HOUSEHOLD DEBT. WELL THAT'S
2:26 PRETTY GOOD. IT'S BELOW THE
2:28 HISTORICAL RANGE. INVESTMENT
2:29 GRADE CORPORATE QUALITY WAS
2:31 STRONG. HEDGE FUND LEVERAGE,
2:32 HOWEVER, IS AT AN HISTORICAL
2:34 HIGH THE HIGHEST SINCE OH SORRY,
2:35 THE HIGHEST SINCE 2013. THE
2:37 BANKING SYSTEM. THIS IS THE
2:38 IMPORTANT THING THAT THEY END
2:39 UP EVALUATING IS SOUND AND
2:42 RESILIENT. RESILIENT. THERE ARE
2:44 VULNERABILITIES ASSOCIATED WITH
2:45 THE FINANCIAL LEVERAGE. HOWEVER,
2:46 THEY REMAIN NOTABLE. THAT'S A
2:49 WORD THEY USE KIND OF A
2:50 EUPHEMISM. FINALLY, NEAR TERM
2:52 RISKS INCLUDING INCLUDE
2:53 DISAPPOINTING RETURNS ON U.S.
2:54 BUSINESS INVESTMENT, CYBER
2:55 ATTACKS AND A RISE IN
2:57 GEOPOLITICAL RISK. SO A LOT
2:58 THERE, GUYS. IT'S A LONG REPORT,
3:00 BUT WHAT YOU SEE OVERALL WHEN
3:01 YOU STEP BACK IS THE FED IS
3:03 TAKING A CLOSE LOOK AT AI
3:04 FINANCING AND WHAT'S GOING ON
3:06 WITH ALL THOSE LINKAGES. NOT
3:07 CLEAR WHAT THEY'RE GOING TO DO
3:08 ABOUT IT OTHER THAN SAYING THEY
3:10 ARE MONITORING IT AS WELL AS
3:11 MOST CLOSELY WHAT THE FED DOES.
3:12 AS YOU KNOW, MIKE AND MELISSA,
3:14 THEY MONITOR THE REGULATED
3:15 FINANCIAL SYSTEM. SO THEY'RE
3:17 MONITORING THAT CLOSELY AND
3:17 THAT CONNECTION THERE.
3:19 >> AND STEVE, THAT TRILLION
3:21 DOLLARS WAS IT OF KIND OF AI
3:23 RELATED EXPOSURE AMONG THE
3:24 LARGE BANKS? YOU KNOW, WHAT
3:28 COMMERCIAL BANK ASSETS IN TOTAL,
3:29 LIKE 25 TRILLION OR SOMETHING
3:31 LIKE THAT. I'M JUST TRYING TO
3:33 SCALE IT.
3:35 >> YEAH, I THINK THAT'S A GOOD
3:36 POINT. IT IS A PIECE OF IT.
3:38 IT'S A GROWING PIECE OF IT. AND
3:40 WE ALSO DON'T KNOW THE TERMS OF
3:42 THAT. MIKE, YOU AND I BOTH KNOW
3:44 THERE ARE TIMES WHEN THERE ARE
3:45 COVENANTS AND TIMES WHEN IT'S
3:47 COVENANT LITE. AND THE EXTENT
3:48 TO WHICH THESE BANKS HAVE
3:49 EQUITY AND OTHER ASSETS IN
3:52 FRONT OF THAT DEBT, THAT
3:53 CHANGES THINGS. SO THE FED IS
3:55 WATCHING THIS. IT IS STILL
3:56 CALLING THE BANKING SYSTEM
3:57 SOUND AND RESILIENT. I GUESS
3:59 THE ONE AREA OF CONCERN THAT I
4:00 THINK THE FED HAS AND EVERYBODY
4:02 HAS ABOUT THE FINANCIAL SYSTEM
4:04 IS HOW MUCH VISIBILITY THEY
4:05 HAVE INTO THE NON-BANK SECTOR.
4:07 AND THEY'RE KIND OF
4:08 ACKNOWLEDGING THEY DON'T SEE
4:10 EVERYTHING THERE. THEY'RE
4:11 TRYING TO COUNT UP WHAT'S IN
4:12 THE PRIVATE CREDIT MARKET.
4:13 THEY'RE TRYING TO COUNT UP THE
4:14 BANKS EXPOSURE TO THAT MARKET,
4:16 BUT THAT'S AN AREA OF OPACITY
4:19 THAT CREATES FINANCIAL RISK AND
4:20 THAT NOBODY CAN REALLY EVER
4:21 FULLY ANSWER BECAUSE IT IS
4:23 OUTSIDE THE REGULATED SYSTEM.
4:25 >> YEAH. BUT THAT'S THAT'S THE
4:26 RUB. THAT'S THE PROBLEM, STEVE.
4:27 I MEAN, I DON'T THINK MANY
4:29 PEOPLE THINK THAT BANKS, JUST
4:30 BECAUSE OF, OF ALL THE
4:31 REGULATIONS THAT HAVE BEEN PUT
4:32 IN PLACE SINCE THE GREAT
4:33 FINANCIAL CRISIS WERE EVER AT
4:34 RISK IN THIS, BUT IT'S ALL THE
4:36 CIRCULAR FINANCING. IT'S ALL
4:37 THE DEBT THAT'S ISSUED PRIVATE
4:39 CREDIT THAT IS THE CONCERN HERE.
4:41 SO REWIND TO WHEN MICHELLE
4:43 BOWEN WAS TALKING ABOUT RISK TO
4:45 FINANCIAL STABILITY. WHAT DO
4:46 YOU THINK SHE WAS TALKING ABOUT?
4:47 IF THERE'S NO RISK TO THE
4:49 REGULATED ENTITIES?
4:52 >> WELL, THE RISK IS THIS.
4:53 FIRST OF ALL, I THINK, MELISSA,
4:55 YOU'LL REMEMBER THAT WE ALL
4:57 LEARNED DURING THE FINANCIAL
4:58 CRISIS, WE ALL THOUGHT THEY
4:59 WERE IN THESE SPVS IN THESE
5:01 REMOTE VEHICLES. WELL, GUESS
5:02 WHAT? IT DID COME BACK TO THE
5:04 FINANCIAL SYSTEM OR TO THE
5:05 BANKS. SO THAT'S THE FIRST
5:07 THING IS ARE THERE CONNECTIONS
5:08 THERE WE'RE NOT AWARE OF? ARE
5:10 THERE HEDGES OUT THERE THAT
5:12 WILL WHEN THE WHEN THE WHEN,
5:14 WHEN THINGS GO TO GO TO GO TO
5:16 HELL, ESSENTIALLY THAT THE
5:18 CORRELATIONS GO TO ONE. THOSE
5:19 ARE CONCERNS OUT THERE. SHE'S
5:21 MO
Bitcoin hits three-month low full transcript
0:10 >> WELCOME BACK. BITCOIN
0:11 HITTING ITS LOWEST LEVEL IN
0:12 THREE MONTHS. MACKENZIE SIGALOS
0:14 BACK WITH US WITH MORE MAC.
0:16 >> SO JOHN BITCOIN BRIEFLY
0:18 FALLING BELOW $68,000 EARLIER
0:20 TODAY. BREAKING THROUGH ITS
0:22 CLOSELY WATCHED 200 WEEK MOVING
0:24 AVERAGE, IT IS NOW DOWN 17% IN
0:27 THE PAST MONTH AND ON TRACK FOR
0:28 A SIXTH STRAIGHT WEEKLY LOSS.
0:30 ADDING TO THE PRESSURE, MSCI
0:32 SAYS IT WILL DROP STRATEGY, THE
0:33 LARGEST CORPORATE HOLDER OF
0:35 BITCOIN FROM ITS MAJOR STOCK
0:37 INDEXES AT THE END OF THIS
0:38 MONTH, EFFECTIVELY FORCING
0:39 FUNDS THAT TRACK THOSE
0:41 BENCHMARKS TO SELL. CEO FANG LI
0:43 TELLING CNBC YESTERDAY THAT THE
0:44 MOVE IS IMMATERIAL, SINCE ONLY
0:46 ABOUT 3% OF STRATEGY SHARES ARE
0:48 TIED TO THOSE INDEXES. BUT HE
0:50 ACCUSED MSCI OF WAGING A
0:52 MULTIYEAR CAMPAIGN AGAINST
0:54 DIGITAL ASSETS STRATEGY.
0:56 COINBASE, ROBINHOOD AND BITMAIN
0:59 IMMERSION ALL TRADING IN THE
1:00 RED TODAY. AND THE BROADER
1:02 BACKDROP ISN'T HELPING THE
1:03 CRYPTO MARKET A STRONGER DOLLAR
1:05 AND SURGING BOND YIELDS ARE
1:06 PULLING MONEY OUT OF RISKIER
1:08 ASSETS, CHICAGO FED PRESIDENT
1:10 AUSTAN GOOLSBEE TELLING CNBC
1:12 THIS MORNING THAT INFLATION IS
1:13 SPREADING BEYOND ENERGY,
1:15 FUELING EXPECTATIONS THAT THE
1:17 FED STAYS HAWKISH FOR LONGER.
1:18 AND OF COURSE, THE LEADERSHIP
1:20 CRISIS AT NVIDIA AFTER JEN-HSUN
1:21 HUANG EXIT IS WEIGHING ON TECH
1:24 DRAGGING DOWN MORE SPECULATIVE
1:26 ASSETS LIKE CRYPTO, ALL OF THAT
1:29 TRIGGERING A WAVE OF FORCED
1:31 SELLING, WIPING OUT $1.3
1:33 BILLION IN LEVERAGED POSITIONS
1:34 OVER THE PAST 24 HOURS. AND BIG
1:37 INVESTORS ARE NOT STEPPING IN
1:38 TO BUY THE DIP. MORE THAN HALF
1:40 $1 BILLION HAS FLOWED OUT OF
1:42 THOSE U.S. SPOT BITCOIN ETFS
1:44 THIS WEEK, MOST OF IT FROM
1:46 BLACKROCK'S FUND. THERE IS,
1:47 THOUGH, ONE POTENTIAL BRIGHT
1:48 SPOT HERE TRADERS ARE
1:50 INCREASINGLY BETTING AGAINST
1:52 BITCOIN, WITH FUNDING RATES IN
1:53 THE FUTURES MARKET TURNING
1:55 NEGATIVE FOR THE FIRST TIME IN
1:56 A MONTH. THAT KIND OF PESSIMISM
1:58 HAS IN THE PAST MARKED A SHORT
1:59 TERM BOTTOM, RAISING HOPES THAT
2:01 THE WORST OF THE SELLING MAY BE
2:03 OVER HERE. JOHN.
2:04 >> OUR QUESTION FOR YOU, THOUGH,
2:06 NOT TO PILE ON WITH THE
2:08 PESSIMISM HERE, BUT I THINK
2:09 IT'S FAIR TO SAY I'M GOING FOR
2:11 UNDERSTATEMENT OF THE WEEK,
2:12 THAT THE DEMOCRATS ARE NOT AS
2:13 BIG A FANS OF BITCOIN AND
2:17 CRYPTOCURRENCIES AS THE TRUMP
2:18 ADMINISTRATION. AND SOME
2:19 REPUBLICANS HAVE BEEN. SO
2:21 SENTIMENT WISE, ONCE WE SEE
2:23 WHAT THE LEGISLATIVE AGENDA
2:24 LOOKS LIKE AND DOESN'T LOOK
2:25 LIKE WHEN IT COMES TO
2:28 CRYPTOCURRENCIES, WHAT DOES
2:29 THAT MEAN FOR THIS MARKET?
2:30 >> IT'S SUCH A GREAT POINT
2:31 BECAUSE YOU THINK ABOUT THE
2:32 ELECTION CYCLE TWO YEARS AGO
2:34 WHERE YOU HAD COINBASE BEHIND
2:35 STAND WITH CRYPTO. THEY HAD A
2:37 LOT OF MONEY TIED UP. IN FACT,
2:39 PROBABLY THE MOST INFLUENTIAL
2:42 VOTING BLOC IN TERMS OF WHAT
2:43 THEY RAISED AND THE PEOPLE THAT
2:44 THEY PUT INTO CONGRESS. AND
2:46 THEN IT WAS A COMPLETE REVERSAL
2:47 OF THAT TREND. AND THE OVERHANG
2:48 HERE IS THAT THE CLARITY ACT
2:50 DID NOT GET PASSED INTO LAW
2:51 WHEN THEY HAD THE MOST
2:52 FAVORABLE SENATE AND HOUSE SET
2:55 UP FOR THAT LEGISLATION TO GO
2:57 THROUGH. AND SO THE ARGUMENT IS
2:59 THAT WITH THE TURNOVER THAT
3:00 WE'VE SEEN, THAT THAT DOESN'T
3:03 BODE WELL FOR THE CLARITY ACT.
3:04 THAT REALLY IS WHAT HAS BEEN
3:05 STANDING IN THE WAY OF WALL
3:06 STREET BEING ABLE TO GET MORE
3:08 INVOLVED, INVEST MORE MONEY,
3:10 CREATE MORE INFRASTRUCTURE
3:11 AROUND THE CRYPTO MARKET. AND
3:12 THAT IS A MAJOR OVERHANG. AND
3:15 WHEN YOU ADD ON WHAT'S GOING ON
3:16 WITH STRATEGY THIS WEEK, THE
Market Close: Stocks Mixed, Nvidia Down 12% This Week Amid Controversy, ANT IPO Coming full transcript
0:01 CNBC business news update. I'm Jessica
0:04 Edinger. Wall Street will open Monday
0:06 morning after a mixed Friday for the
0:07 major averages amid the Nvidia scandal
0:11 fallout and a wild week for stocks. AMD
0:14 and Broadcom balanced out the Nvidia
0:17 losses. Let's start with the Dow. It was
0:19 up 50 points on Friday. The S&P 500
0:23 index down 30 points. The Nasdaq was
0:26 down 229/ten
0:28 of a percent. major averages all had a
0:31 winning week, each up at least 2%.
0:34 >> Positive for the week and you know S&P's
0:36 up a couple of percent week to date. Um
0:38 it's still though in this really kind of
0:40 soggy zone that we haven't been able to
0:42 escape going back several months.
0:44 Seasonally, positioning wise, everything
0:47 does suggest that you should have some
0:49 kind of upside air pocket coming in
0:51 here. Maybe it's going to be about
0:53 getting up to and through the anthropic
0:54 IPO. That's going to be a little bit of
0:56 a, you know, a clearing uh signal.
0:59 >> That's CNBC's Mike Sani. Nvidia was down
1:02 12% on the week. It lost nearly a third
1:05 of its value since the high on October
1:08 6th. Investors may spend the weekend
1:10 digesting the tremendous Nvidia shock
1:13 that saw the co-founder and CEO of 33
1:15 years, Jensen Wong, apologized to his
1:19 family and staff for an extrammarital
1:20 affair that then grew into reports of
1:23 numerous affairs. one that some believe
1:25 was with a Chinese asset or spy and
1:29 fingerpointing in Washington over
1:30 whether Nvidia's advanced chips have
1:33 been sold to companies that may have
1:34 then spun them around to China. Here's a
1:37 take from New Jersey Congressman Josh
1:39 Godheimer on CNBC who hopes to question
1:41 Wong in the coming week.
1:43 >> Three of the committees that have
1:44 jurisdiction here asked Jensen to come
1:46 testify. We've not heard officially.
1:48 They threatened to issue subpoenas to
1:50 get the information we need. And I think
1:52 that's the key here. We we have to
1:53 really understand what went on here.
1:55 You've got very advanced chips uh that
1:58 we do not want to get in the hands of
2:00 China, our top adversary here.
2:01 >> Nvidia's CFO, Colette Crest, is in the
2:05 CEO role temporarily. Now, Nvidia
2:08 reports quarterly results this Tuesday.
2:10 >> You know, is this stock was one of the
2:12 most widely held, most reliable, it's
2:14 just such a stunning turn of events.
2:15 >> It is a stunning turn of events,
2:17 especially because the fundamentals are
2:20 incredible. They're going to blow it
2:21 away on Tuesday and the valuation is
2:23 trading at nine times fiscal 28 numbers.
2:26 They're going to generate so much cash,
2:28 but throw all of that out the window
2:30 because the overhang from this whole
2:32 saga is just going to dominate. That's
2:34 High Towers Stephanie Link and CNBC's
2:37 Kelly Evans. President Trump meets with
2:40 China's President Xiinping in the coming
2:42 week amid the Nvidia CEO fallout and
2:45 questions surrounding whether Nvidia
2:46 chips were being funneled to China.
2:48 Here's a take from Evercore ISI's Sarah
2:51 Bianke on CNBC.
2:53 >> The China US China meeting. It's next
2:55 week and while it will be polite and
2:58 cordial behind the scenes there's a lot
3:00 of questions Congress is asking about
3:02 escort controls uh the Busousan Dutant
3:05 is already rather fragile and I think
3:08 this means 2027 uh the US China Day tant
3:12 could be under a lot of stress
3:13 >> in the coming week. Investors are also
3:15 setting up for the highly anticipated
3:17 anthropic IPO, an initial public
3:20 offering of shares by an AI pioneer.
3:22 >> I hope it does very well. I think
3:24 everyone involved in that transaction
3:26 knows what a bellweather moment this
3:29 will be.
3:30 >> That's former national economic director
3:32 and the first Trump administration Gary
3:34 Con on CNBC. Anthropic will trade under
3:37 the ticker symbol ENT. Shares are priced
3:40 at the high end at about $78 a piece and
3:43 there are reports saying it's six times
3:46 overs subscribed.
3:48 The business of hockey is booming. The
3:50 average NHL team now worth $2.7 billion
3:54 dollars, up more than 20% from last year
3:56 in a CNBC analysis. Here's CNBC's Mike
4:00 Ozanian.
4:01 >> There's a lust for all sports teams in
4:03 any league. uh limited supply, real
4:07 content that people want to see in real
4:08 time. With the NHL, you have very strong
4:11 TV ratings. You have several teams that
4:13 have gotten or going to get new arenas
4:16 with the economics are a lot more
4:17 lucrative.
4:18 >> The Toronto Maple Leafs team is the
4:20 league's most valuable, worth a whopping
4:22 $5.7 billion. You can see the full list
4:26 at cnbc.com.
4:28 on the coming week's watch list. In
4:30 addition to Nvidia earnings and
4:32 Anthropics IPO, major retailers are set
4:36 to share some quarterly results like
4:37 Home Depot and Lowe's, Target and
4:40 Walmart. And Grand Theft Auto 6, the
4:42 video game, is set to be released on
4:45 Thursday following years of delays.
4:48 Jessica Edinger, CNBC.
Hightower's Stephanie Link: Overhang from the Nvidia saga will dominate for many months full transcript
0:00 COMMITMENTS, FINANCING,
0:02 SYNDICATIONS AND STRATEGIC
0:03 PLANNING. WE'RE LOOKING AT THE
0:04 STOCK DOWN ABOUT 2% AT THIS
0:06 HOUR. KELLY AND BRIAN.
0:07 >> ALL RIGHT. THANK YOU VERY
0:09 MUCH. WE APPRECIATE IT. DESPITE
0:10 TODAY'S SLIDE, THE MAJOR
0:12 INDEXES ARE STILL TRYING TO
0:13 CLOSE OUT THE WEEK IN THE GREEN.
0:15 AND THAT INCLUDES THE NASDAQ
0:16 100 WHICH HAS OUTPERFORMED
0:17 NVIDIA. YOU CAN SEE IT ON YOUR
0:19 SCREENS THERE BY ABOUT 15
0:21 POINTS. AND ITS VALUATION IS
0:23 NEAR A SIX YEAR LOW. IN OTHER
0:26 WORDS, TRADING AT A DISCOUNT.
0:27 SO IS NOW THE TIME TO BUY?
0:29 LET'S ASK INTERACTIVE BROKERS
0:30 CHIEF STRATEGIST STEVE SOSNICK
0:31 AND HIGHTOWER, CHIEF INVESTMENT
0:33 STRATEGIST STEPHANIE LINK, WHO
0:34 IS ALSO A CNBC CONTRIBUTOR.
0:36 STEVE AND STEPHANIE. STEVE,
0:38 IT'S THE SAME. WHATEVER. STEPH,
0:41 LET'S START US OFF. NVIDIA. HOW
0:42 DO YOU THINK ABOUT IT? WHAT
0:44 WHAT WHAT I KNOW YOU'RE THESE
0:46 ARE THE I HAVE PEOPLE EMAILING
0:47 ME SAYING THEY'RE LITERALLY IN
0:49 TEARS. THEY BOUGHT AT THE HIGHS.
0:50 THEY SOLD AT THE LOWS. YOU KNOW
0:53 THIS STOCK WAS ONE OF THE MOST
0:54 WIDELY HELD, MOST RELIABLE.
0:56 IT'S JUST SUCH A STUNNING TURN
0:57 OF EVENTS.
0:57 >> IT IS A STUNNING TURN OF
0:59 EVENTS, ESPECIALLY BECAUSE THE
1:01 FUNDAMENTALS ARE INCREDIBLE.
1:02 THEY'RE GOING TO BLOW IT AWAY
1:03 ON TUESDAY. AND THE VALUATIONS
1:05 TRADING AT NINE TIMES FISCAL 28
1:08 NUMBERS, THEY'RE GOING TO
1:08 GENERATE SO MUCH CASH ALMOST
1:10 $50 BILLION IN CASH IN THE
1:11 QUARTER ALONE AND 300 BILLION
1:13 NEXT YEAR. BUT THROW ALL THAT
1:15 OUT THE WINDOW BECAUSE THE
1:17 OVERHANG FROM THIS WHOLE SAGA
1:19 IS JUST GOING TO DOMINATE THE
1:21 HEADLINES FOR THE NEXT MANY
1:23 MONTHS. AND SO I SOLD IT. I GOT
1:26 A LOT OF PUSHBACK FROM IT. I
1:27 KNOW I HATE TO DO IT, BUT I WAS
1:29 DOWN A LITTLE BIT AND I THOUGHT,
1:31 YOU KNOW WHAT? THIS IS DEAD
1:33 MONEY BECAUSE YOU HAVE, YOU
1:33 KNOW, LEADERSHIP CHANGES IN
1:35 QUESTIONS. YOU HAVE
1:35 DISTRACTIONS. YOU MAY HAVE
1:36 PEOPLE THAT ACTUALLY LEAVE. SO
1:38 THERE'S SO MANY DIFFERENT
1:39 THINGS TO CONSIDER. AND SO I
1:42 TOOK THE MONEY AND I PUT MORE
1:43 INTO MICRON BECAUSE BY THE WAY,
1:44 THEY'RE BOTH DOWN ABOUT THE
1:46 SAME AMOUNT FROM THEIR HIGHS IN
1:48 ABOUT THE 30, 35%. YET MICRON
1:51 IS JUST A CLEANER STORY. IT HAS
1:53 GOOD FUNDAMENTALS AND YET THEY
1:55 DON'T HAVE THIS OVERHANG. AND
1:57 OH AND BY THE WAY IT TRADES AT
1:58 FOUR TIMES EARNINGS. AND
1:59 THEY'VE GOT A LOT OF FREE CASH.
2:01 >> SO I THINK THIS IS AND AS
2:02 ALWAYS LINK YOU NAILED IT.
2:05 WE'VE ALL BEEN DOING THIS A
2:06 LONG TIME. RIGHT. AND I THINK
2:08 THIS IS ONE OF THOSE STORIES
2:09 WHERE IF WE JUST TALK ABOUT
2:11 VALUATIONS, IT MAKES A LOT OF
2:13 SENSE. RIGHT? TO YOUR POINT
2:14 EARNINGS TUESDAY PROBABLY GOING
2:15 TO BLOW IT OUT OF THE WATER.
2:17 NUMBERS LOOK GOOD 17 TIMES
2:18 EARNINGS YADA YADA YADA. I JUST
2:21 WORRY EVERY NIGHT THAT THERE
2:23 COULD BE A STORY IN THE NEW
2:24 YORK TIMES OR CNBC.COM OR WALL
2:26 STREET JOURNAL, BLOOMBERG,
2:26 WHEREVER IT IS THAT SO-AND-SO
2:28 DID THIS OR SO AND SO DID THAT.
2:30 AND STOCK FALLS ANOTHER 10%.
2:32 WOULD YOU OWN THE STOCK RIGHT
2:33 NOW? DO YOU OWN THE STOCK RIGHT
2:34 NOW?
2:35 >> I DO NOT OWN THE STOCK RIGHT
2:36 NOW. I SOLD IT A WHILE AGO
2:38 ACTUALLY, BUT JUST THAT WAS
2:39 BECAUSE OF JUST TAKING PROFITS.
2:41 BUT THIS IS THIS IS MORE OF A
2:42 QUESTION OF WE'VE SEEN OUR
2:45 CUSTOMERS BUYING THE DIP
2:46 RELENTLESSLY IN THIS STOCK. AND
2:48 ONE OF THE THINGS THAT I THAT I
2:50 TRY TO COUNSEL PEOPLE WHEN THEY
2:51 WHEN THEY DO IT, I'M NOT GOING
2:52 TO TELL SOMEBODY NOT TO TRY TO
2:54 BUY A DIP. IT WORKS MOST. IT'S
2:56 WORKED ALMOST FLAWLESSLY, YOU
2:57 KNOW, BUT THERE ARE
2:59 DISTINCTIONS. IF A STOCK IS
3:00 DOWN. JUST. WE'VE SEEN THIS A
3:01 LOT WHERE STOCKS GO DOWN AFTER
3:03 EARNINGS ON DECENT NEWS. AND
3:05 YOU KNOW WHAT. THEY TEND TO
3:06 BOUNCE BACK BECAUSE THAT'S JUST
3:07 MORE OF A QUICK TRADING
3:09 REACTION WHEN THEY GO DOWN
3:10 BECAUSE OF FUNDAMENTAL NEWS.
3:12 AND THIS IS NOT JUST NVIDIA.
3:13 THIS WAS THINK ABOUT INTEL LAST
3:15 EARNINGS REPORT. THINK ABOUT
3:16 GOOGLE'S LAST EARNINGS REPORT
3:17 WHERE THERE WAS SOME MATERIAL
3:19 CHANGE TO THE COMPANY THAT MADE
3:20 INSTITUTIONAL INVESTORS RETHINK
3:22 IT. TRADERS REACT. INSTITUTIONS
3:25 DECIDE. THEY PONDER. AND SO
3:27 WHEN YOU HAVE INSTITUTIONS
3:28 LEAVING A HOLDINGS, A BIG
3:30 HOLDING THAT KEEPS PRESSURE ON
3:32 THE STOCK FOR A WHILE. AND
3:33 THAT'S WHY, TO STEPHANIE'S
3:34 POINT, I THINK THIS BECOMES
3:36 DEAD MONEY. WE'RE GOING TO HEAR
3:37 NOTHING BUT STUFF ABOUT
3:39 CONGRESS. THEY'RE GOING TO BE
3:40 ALL HAULED IN FRONT OF CONGRESS.
3:41 THIS IS NOT ENDING.
3:42 >> THIS IS PROFESSIONAL
3:44 LIABILITY TO OWN IT,
3:45 POTENTIALLY. AND IT'S
3:45 INTERESTING TO THINK THROUGH
3:46 HOW THIS IS GOING TO WORK,
3:48 BECAUSE ANYBODY WHO MANAGES
3:49 MONEY OR PUTS IT IN A PORTFOLIO
3:50 HAS TO THINK ABOUT KIND OF THE
3:52 THE RISK MANAGEMENT OF THAT.
3:53 WHEN VAHAN JANJIGIAN LAST HOUR
3:55 SAYS, YOU KNOW, YOU KNOW,
3:56 COMPANY COULD BE SHUT DOWN IF
3:57 IT LIKE YOU CAN'T OWN A STOCK
3:59 THAT PEOPLE COULD SPECULATE TO
4:01 THAT DEGREE ABOUT WHAT MIGHT
4:02 HAPPEN HERE. NOW, TO YOUR POINT
4:04 ABOUT RETAIL, THOUGH, FOR
4:05 RETAIL COULD RETAIL COULD SAY,
4:08 THIS IS MY MONEY. I'M NOT
4:09 RUNNING SOMEONE ELSE'S MONEY.
4:10 THIS IS ME. YEAH. I, YOU KNOW,
4:12 I'M, I'M PERCEIVING WHAT I
4:14 THINK IS A DECENT NUMBER. SO I
4:16 TAKE YOUR POINT, BUT I THINK
4:17 THOSE, THOSE TWO SOURCES OF
4:19 BUYING AND SELLING KIND OF HAVE
4:20 TWO VERY DIFFERENT THINGS GOING
4:21 ON RIGHT NOW.
4:21 >> BUT ARE YOU STANDING IN THE
4:23 WAY OF, YOU KNOW, THERE'S ONE
4:24 THING TO STAND, YOU KNOW, LIKE
4:26 TO BE AT THE BEACH AND YOU'RE
4:27 SORT OF, YOU KNOW, DEALING WITH
4:29 THE SMALL WAVES. IT'S ANOTHER
4:30 THING TO BE DEALING WITH A
4:31 TIDAL SHIFT. AND IN THIS CASE,
4:32 I'VE NEVER SEEN NUMBERS FROM
4:34 OUR CUSTOMERS WITH THE LEVEL OF
4:35 BUYING THAT THEY'VE BEEN DOING
4:36 THIS WEEK. IT WAS THE MOST
4:38 BOUGHT STOCK ON FRIDAY WITH.
4:40 AND I WAS ASTOUNDED AT A WEEK
4:42 AGO BEFORE THIS ALL REALLY HIT
4:43 THE FAN.
4:44 >> THAT'S WHEN MY FRIEND
4:45 FRIENDS OF MINE WERE SAYING,
4:46 WE'RE BUYING, BUYING. AND THEN
4:47 BY YESTERDAY THEY'RE CRYING.
4:49 >> IT WAS THE MOST. IT WAS THE
4:50 MOST BOUGHT STOCK WHEN I RAN,
4:52 WHEN WE WHEN I SAW THE NUMBERS
4:53 AS OF AS OF FRIDAY, AS OF TODAY,
4:56 IT'S FIVE TIMES LARGER THAN
4:57 WHAT IT WAS A WEEK AGO. SO
5:00 THEY'RE OUR CUSTOME
Anthropic CEO Amodei speaks with JPMorgan CEO Dimon about compute commitments full transcript
0:07 NOMINATIONS.CNBC.COM.
0:10 >> WALL STREET IS COUNTING DOWN
0:11 TO ANTHROPIC HIGHLY ANTICIPATED
0:13 IPO NEXT WEEK. IT'S COMING AT A
0:15 TOUGH TIME FOR THE AI TRADE,
0:17 THOUGH, BUT CEO DARIO AMODEI IS
0:20 STRIKING AN UPBEAT TONE LAST
0:21 HOUR WHEN HE SPOKE WITH JAMIE
0:23 DIMON, THE JPMORGAN CEO. J.P.
0:25 MORGAN IS PART OF THEIR
0:26 UNDERWRITING GROUP. LET'S GET
0:27 OVER TO KATE ROONEY, WHO'S GOT
0:28 ALL THE DETAILS FOR US IN
0:30 TODAY'S TECH CHECK. HI, KATE.
0:33 >> HI, KELLY. WELL, THIS WAS
0:34 PART OF ANTHROPIC IPO ROADSHOW,
0:36 SO IT WAS THE LATEST STOP. WE
0:38 DID HEAR FROM JPMORGAN CEO
0:40 JAMIE DIMON. THIS WAS SORT OF A
0:42 FIRESIDE CHAT WITH HIM AND
0:43 DARIO AMODEI. HIS FIRM IS AN
0:45 UNDERWRITER IN THIS IPO. IT'S
0:46 ALSO HELPING LEAD THE RETAIL
0:48 INVESTOR PUSH. WIDE RANGE OF
0:50 TOPICS FROM THESE TWO. BUT
0:51 DARIO AMODEI DID ADD SOME
0:53 NUANCE TO ANTHROPIC STRATEGY ON
0:55 COMPUTE. HE CALLED THE $900
0:57 BILLION ARE SET TO SPEND A
0:59 LARGE AMOUNT. BUT HE DOES SAY
1:00 THAT THEIR MOVE RIGHT NOW HAS
1:01 BEEN TO TO BUY RELATIVELY
1:03 LITTLE COMPUTE, AS HE PUT IT,
1:05 COMPARED TO COMPETITORS. HE
1:06 TOLD DIAMOND, QUOTE, WE TEND TO
1:08 BUY ON THE LOW SIDE AND BUY
1:10 RELATIVELY LITTLE COMPUTE FOR
1:12 RELATIVELY LOW COST AHEAD OF
1:13 TIME. AND THEN HE SAYS, IF
1:15 THINGS DON'T GO WELL RELATIVE
1:16 TO EXPECTATIONS, THEN THEY'RE
1:18 COVERED. BUT IF THINGS GO
1:19 REALLY WELL, THEN THEY HAVE AN
1:21 OPPORTUNITY TO BUY MORE COMPUTE
1:23 AND ADDITIONAL COMPUTE ON THE
1:24 SPOT MARKET, HE SAYS. SO FAR,
1:26 IT'S ALWAYS BEEN AVAILABLE, AND
1:27 THEY BELIEVE IT WILL CONTINUE
1:29 TO BE AVAILABLE. SO, KELLY,
1:31 THERE HAS REALLY BEEN THIS
1:32 DEBATE IN THE INDUSTRY ABOUT
1:34 OVERBUILDING OVERSPENDING. SO
1:36 ANTHROPIC CLEARLY HERE DOES
1:37 WANT TO BE MORE ON THE
1:38 CONSERVATIVE SIDE. OTHERS,
1:39 THOUGH, HAVE ARGUED THAT
1:40 ANTHROPIC IN THE END MIGHT NOT
1:41 HAVE ENOUGH COMPUTE, SO
1:43 PROBABLY TOO SOON TO TELL. BUT
1:44 WE GOT SOME NUANCE IN HIS
1:45 STANCE THERE. ALSO SAID THERE
1:46 IS A BUFFER OF CASH ON THE
1:48 BALANCE SHEET FOR ANTHROPIC.
1:50 THEY PLAN TO RAISE MORE. OF
1:51 COURSE, THROUGH THIS IPO.
1:52 REVENUE IS GROWING QUICKLY. HE
1:53 TALKED ABOUT GROSS MARGINS
1:55 BEING BETTER THAN COMPETITORS
1:57 AT LEAST, AND THEN TALKED ABOUT
1:58 EFFICIENCY OF THESE AI MODELS.
1:59 KELLY HE CALLED IT A MISNOMER
2:01 THAT THERE ARE JUST THESE
2:02 EXPENSIVE MODELS THAT THEY HAVE
2:03 THAT ARE REALLY GOOD, AND THEN
2:05 CHEAP MODELS FROM OTHERS. HE
2:06 TRIED TO MAKE THE CASE THAT
2:07 ANTHROPIC IS ABLE TO DO BOTH.
2:08 >> ALL RIGHT. SO NOTHING THERE
2:10 THAT INDICATES A BIG CHANGE TO
2:11 THEIR PLANS. HOW ABOUT IN THE
2:14 MEANTIME, KATE ROONEY WHAT WHAT
2:15 HAPPENED WITH MICROSOFT? I SAW
2:17 IF I'M NOT MISTAKEN, THEY I WAS
2:19 CONVINCED IT WAS AN AGENT SWARM
2:20 OR SOMETHING. RIGHT. THEY SAID
2:22 NO. DO WE KNOW ANYTHING MORE
2:24 ABOUT WHAT HAPPENED? WHAT TOOK
2:26 DOWN THIS COMPANY FOR THE
2:28 BIGGEST OUTAGE? ONE OF THE
2:29 BIGGEST OUTAGES THEY'VE EVER
2:30 HAD?
2:31 >> NO. IT WAS IT'S SUCH A GOOD
2:32 POINT. KELLY THAT'S WHERE MY
2:34 MIND ALSO WENT IMMEDIATELY AND
2:35 SAID, OH, IT'S A CYBER ISSUE.
2:36 THEY HAVE SAID EXPLICITLY, NO,
2:38 THERE'S NO EVIDENCE THAT
2:39 THERE'S ANYTHING MALICIOUS
2:39 GOING ON. IT WAS NOT A CYBER
2:42 ATTACK. AND THEY SAID THEY'RE
2:43 GOING TO BE UPDATING PEOPLE IN
2:44 THE NEXT COUPLE OF DAYS HERE
2:45 AND DOING A LITTLE BIT OF A
2:47 POSTMORTEM. BUT THEY APOLOGIZED
2:49 OFFICIALLY, SAID, SORRY FOR THE
2:51 INCONVENIENCE. YOU THINK ABOUT
2:52 HOW WIDELY OUTLOOK IS USED,
2:54 TEAMS IS USED AND HOW
2:56 CONCENTRATED A LOT OF PEOPLE'S
2:57 WORKLOAD IS ON ON MICROSOFT. I
2:59 MEAN, THEY'VE MADE THE PITCH TO
3:01 ENTERPRISES THAT IT SHOULD BE
3:02 THE GO TO, AND IT'S HELPFUL TO
3:03 HAVE EVERYTHING IN ONE PLACE.
3:05 THIS IS CLEARLY THE EXAMPLE
3:06 WHERE IT DOESN'T WORK OUT THAT
3:07 WAY. ALTHOUGH SOME PEOPLE WERE
3:09 CALLING IT AN ADULT SNOW DAY, I
3:10 THINK A LOT OF PEOPLE WERE
3:12 RELIEVED TO NOT HAVE AS MUCH
3:13 GOING ON IN OUTLOOK, BUT THEY
3:14 SAID BASICALLY THAT THEIR
3:15 SERVERS WERE OVERLOADED. AND
3:16 THAT IS SORT OF THE SIMPLE
3:18 EXPLANATION. TOO MUCH GOING ON
3:19 IN THE SERVERS. THEY COULDN'T
3:22 GET UP TO SPEED QUICKLY ENOUGH.
3:23 BUT THINK ABOUT IT. I MEAN,
3:24 THIS HAPPENED MIDDAY, THURSDAY,
3:25 MIDDAY YESTERDAY, DIDN'T COME
3:27 BACK ONLINE UNTIL THIS MORNING.
3:29 AND THEY'RE STILL PATCHING THIS.
3:30 SO IT DOESN'T SEEM LIKE THERE'S
3:32 A SEAMLESS EXPLANATION. BUT THE
3:33 ONLY THING WE DO KNOW FOR SURE,
3:35 OR AT LEAST THEY HAVE SAID NOT
3:36 A CYBER ISSUE.
3:37 >> I WASN'T AFFECTED. WERE YOU
3:39 AFFECTED?
3:41 >> OH YEAH. OH MY GOSH,
3:42 EVERYBODY. I COULDN'T SEND AN
3:44 EMAIL, COULDN'T GET AN EMAIL.
3:46 BUT I TWEETED, I THOUGHT IT WAS
3:48 ACTUALLY KIND OF RELAXING. YOU
3:49 REALIZE HOW HOOKED YOU ARE TO
3:50 YOUR EMAIL.
3:51 >> WELL, NOW.
3:51 >> MY TEAM SORT OF, YOU KNOW,
3:53 JUST SAT BACK, HAD A REAL LUNCH.
3:55 THEY JUST SAID, BUT.
3:56 >> TORI, YOU THINK I WAS
3:57 AFFECTED?
3:59 >> YOU MUST HAVE BEEN AFFECTED.
4:00 >> MY WORK.
4:01 >> I THINK WE WERE ALL OUT. I
4:02 MEAN.
4:03 >> I WAS CHECKING IT OUT.
4:04 >> YOU WEREN'T RESPONDING TO MY
4:05 EMAIL SCALE AI NOW. WELL, IT'S
4:07 FUNNY. I MEAN, THAT'S WHY I
4:08 DIDN'T HEAR FROM, YOU KNOW,
4:09 THESE THESE LARGE ENTERPRISES.
4:10 I MEAN, A LOT OF PEOPLE ARE
4:12 AFFECTED. I'VE TALKED TO
4:13 INDIVIDUALS WHO SAID, YES, SAME
4:14 THING, BUT SMALL BUSINESSES TO
4:16 SAY, YEAH, SURE. I MEAN, THE
4:17 REST OF YOU GUYS, BUT WE NEED
4:19 THIS TO DO TO DO OUR BUSINESS.
4:20 YOU THINK A LOT OF THESE SORT
4:22 OF BANKS, PRIVATE EQUITY FIRMS
4:23 ARE MAYBE IN THE MIDDLE OF
4:25 DOING A DEAL AND SAY, THIS IS
4:26 JUST THE WORST TIMING. SO.
4:28 >> OH, I HAD.
4:28 >> FAMILY MEMBERS WHO WERE
4:29 MICROSOFT, ALTHOUGH NOT REALLY.
4:30 >> YEAH, I.
4:31 >> SAID.
4:31 >> SWITCH TO GMAIL. THEY'RE
4:32 LIKE, I'M A PROFESSIONAL. I
4:34 CAN'T SWITCH TO GMAIL.
The Investment Committee's Nvidia strategy: Kevin Simpson trims, Jim Lebenthal holds full transcript
0:01 SEE THE TEN YEAR WELL ABOVE A
0:02 5% YIELD AT 5.13. IMPORTANT TO
0:05 NOTE THE MAJOR AVERAGES ARE
0:06 POSITIVE FOR THE WEEK, WITH THE
0:08 S&P UP ABOUT 2% ON THE WEEK. WE
0:10 ALSO WANT TO CHECK SHARES OF
0:12 NVIDIA RIGHT NOW. OBVIOUSLY
0:13 NVIDIA THE STORY OF THIS WEEK.
0:14 NVIDIA SHARES PULLING BACK JUST
0:16 ABOUT THREE AND THREE QUARTERS
0:17 OF 1% OVER THE LAST WEEK.
0:19 NVIDIA SHARES PULLING BACK MORE
0:20 THAN 14% AS INVESTORS DIGEST
0:22 ALL THE CONTROVERSY AROUND
0:24 NVIDIA CEO JENSEN HUANG AND HIS
0:26 DECISION TO RESIGN AS THE CEO
0:28 OF THE CHIP GIANT. WITH THAT,
0:29 WE WANT TO BEGIN OUR
0:30 CONVERSATION. JIM LEVINTHAL,
0:31 GOOD TO SEE YOU. RIGHT HERE TO
0:33 MY LEFT.
0:33 >> FRANK.
0:34 >> WHAT DO YOU MAKE OF TODAY'S
0:36 ACTION AFTER YESTERDAY? PEOPLE
0:37 JUST KIND OF WERE SHOCKED BY
0:38 JEN-HSUN HUANG RESIGNING TODAY.
0:39 WHAT DO YOU THINK WE'RE SEEING
0:41 IN THE MARKETS?
0:41 >> YEAH. WELL, IT'S BEEN A
0:43 SHOCKING WEEK. AND IT IT GOT
0:44 WORSE AS THE WEEK WENT ON. I
0:46 THINK WHAT WE'RE GOING TO SEE
0:48 FROM NVIDIA THE STOCK FOR THE
0:49 FORESEEABLE FUTURE IS THIS TUG
0:50 OF WAR BETWEEN THE BULLS AND
0:52 THE BEARS. THE BULLS LIKE
0:53 MYSELF ARE GOING TO POINT TO
0:55 THE STRONG ORDER BOOK THE
0:56 GROWTH THAT'S PROJECTED. WE'LL
0:57 GET AN UPDATE ON THAT WITH NEXT
0:59 WEEK'S EARNINGS. I'M NOT
1:00 EXPECTING A MAJOR CHANGE. WE'RE
1:01 GOING TO TALK ABOUT THINGS LIKE
1:02 FREE CASH FLOW OVER 300 BILLION
1:05 THE FORWARD MULTIPLE OF TEN AND
1:07 SAY, WAIT A SECOND, HOW CAN WE
1:09 BE SELLING THIS HERE? AND I'M
1:10 NOT I'M NOT SELLING IT HERE.
1:12 AND NEW MONEY THAT COMES INTO
1:13 ACCOUNTS I AM PUTTING INTO
1:14 NVIDIA, THE BEARS ARE GOING TO
1:16 SAY, LISTEN, THERE'S GOING TO
1:18 BE EXPORT CONTROLS AND THE
1:19 CHINA BUSINESS IS GOING TO BE
1:21 CURTAILED. THAT'S PROBABLY
1:22 RIGHT FRANK. IT IS PROBABLY
1:23 GOING TO BE CURTAILED. NOW
1:24 CHINA IS ABOUT 11% OF OVERALL
1:27 REVENUE. I DON'T THINK THAT
1:29 GOES TO ZERO. BUT AGAIN AT TEN
1:31 TIMES EARNINGS FREE CASH FLOW
1:32 GENERATING WELL ABOVE 300 IN
1:34 THE COMING 12 MONTHS, 300
1:36 BILLION THAT IS I HONESTLY
1:37 THINK THE BULLS WIN OUT IN THE
1:39 LONG RUN. BUT BUT FOR THE NEXT
1:41 WEEK, TWO WEEKS IT'S GOING TO
1:42 BE BACK AND FORTH THIS TENSION
1:44 BETWEEN THE BULLS AND THE BEARS.
1:45 AS I SAID, I'M STICKING WITH MY
1:47 POSITION. NEW MONEY THAT COMES
1:49 INTO ACCOUNT. I THINK THIS IS A
1:50 GREAT TIME TO BUY IT.
1:51 >> YOU KNOW, ONE QUICK POINT,
1:53 JIM. I THINK YOU'RE SETTING
1:54 THIS GOLDMAN REPORT THAT CAME
1:55 OUT YESTERDAY THAT OUTSIDE
1:56 TAIWAN AND THE U.S. CHINA, HONG
1:58 KONG AND THE REST OF THE WORLD
1:59 MAKE UP ABOUT 11%. SO WE DON'T
2:01 KNOW.
2:01 >> I'VE ALSO HEARD 20% AS A
2:03 NUMBER TWO. SO I DON'T YOU KNOW.
2:05 >> THERE'S A LOT OF DIFFERENT
2:06 ESTIMATES OUT THERE. I WANT TO
2:08 I WANT TO ASK YOU ABOUT THE
2:10 VALUATION OF NVIDIA AND WHY
2:11 YOU'RE SAYING YOU'RE PUTTING
2:12 NEW MONEY TO WORK IS THE FACT
2:14 THAT THE VALUATION IS SO LOW
2:15 THAT IT'S ATTRACTIVE. DO YOU
2:16 THINK ALL THE PAIN HAS COME OUT
2:18 OF THIS STOCK WITH ALL THE
2:20 CONTROVERSY, OR DO YOU DO YOU
2:21 NOT SEE MORE PAIN POTENTIALLY
2:22 IN.
2:23 >> THE FUTURE? SO GOOD QUESTION.
2:24 NO, THERE IS LIKELY MORE PAIN.
2:26 I'M NOT SITTING HERE SAYING
2:27 THAT. 1591 60 IS ABSOLUTELY THE
2:28 BOTTOM. ANYBODY WHO KNOWS ME
2:30 KNOWS I'M NOT A DAY TRADER. I'M
2:31 A LONG TERM INVESTOR. AND WHAT
2:33 I SEE IS THAT THE HYPERSCALERS
2:34 AGAIN, THIS QUARTER REPORTED
2:35 THAT THEY'RE GOING TO STICK
2:37 WITH THEIR CAPEX SPENDING PLANS.
2:38 I ALSO KNOW THAT THE TONE OF
2:40 THE MARKET RIGHT NOW HAS BEEN
2:41 SLIGHTLY MORE THAN SLIGHTLY
2:42 NEGATIVE. WITH REGARDS TO THE
2:43 BLUE WAVE THAT CAME OUT OF THE
2:45 ELECTION AND THE POTENTIAL FOR
2:46 SLOWING THE DATA CENTER BUILD
2:48 OUT. I'M STRONGLY OF THE
2:49 OPINION THAT SLOWING THE DATA
2:50 CENTER BUILD OUT IS A GOOD
2:52 THING, THAT IT ALLOWS CASH
2:54 FLOWS FROM THOSE HYPERSCALERS
2:55 TO CATCH UP WITH THEIR CAPITAL
2:57 EXPENDITURE PLANS, TAKING
2:59 PRESSURE OFF OF FINANCING IN
3:00 THE CAPITAL MARKETS. BUT ALL OF
3:02 THIS THAT COMES IN FROM
3:04 FINANCING, AND I'M TALKING
3:05 ABOUT CAPITAL MARKETS COMING UP
3:06 NEXT WEEK WITH ANTHROPIC, 60 TO
3:10 80 BILLION IS GOING TO FLOW
3:12 THROUGH TO THE LIKES OF NVIDIA
3:13 AND THE OTHER CHIP
3:14 MANUFACTURERS. SO IS THE PAIN
3:16 OVER? NO. AND THAT'S WHERE I'M
3:17 SAYING THE NEXT COUPLE OF WEEKS
3:19 PROBABLY GOING TO BE VOLATILE.
3:20 BUT THIS IS A PRICE GIVEN THE
3:22 FUNDAMENTALS GOING FORWARD FOR
3:23 THE NEXT YEAR I'M VERY
3:24 COMFORTABLE BUYING.
3:25 >> SO NVIDIA SHARES DOWN ABOUT
3:27 3.5% RIGHT NOW. WE WANT TO TALK
3:28 A BIT MORE ABOUT NVIDIA. WE'RE
3:30 GETTING SOME NEWS. OUR SEEMA
3:31 MODY JOINING US NOW WITH THE
3:32 LATEST ON NVIDIA.
3:33 >> HEY FRANK. SO THE FINANCIAL
3:34 TIMES REPORTING THAT NVIDIA'S
3:36 BOARD HAS APPROACHED ARMED CEO
3:37 RENE HAAS AS A POTENTIAL
3:39 SUCCESSOR TO JEN-HSUN HUANG.
3:40 BLOOMBERG REPORTED YESTERDAY
3:42 THAT HAAS WAS ONE OF THE
3:43 EXTERNAL CANDIDATES THAT NVIDIA
3:45 WAS CONSIDERING. FRANK, THIS
3:47 TELLS US, THOUGH, THAT THE
3:48 BOARD IS TRYING TO MOVE FASTER.
3:50 EVER SINCE HUANG'S RESIGNATION
3:52 ON THURSDAY MORNING THAT NOW
3:54 THE BOARD IS MOVING FAST TO
3:56 SECURE A LONGTIME CEO, SOMEONE
3:57 WHO CAN BE A PERMANENT
3:58 REPLACEMENT TO HIM, AS RIGHT
4:00 NOW THEY HAVE INTERIM CEO
4:02 COLETTE KRESS, WHO WAS CFO
4:04 CURRENTLY IN PLACE. RIGHT AS WE
4:06 EXPECT EARNINGS NOW ON TUESDAY,
4:07 MORE AS WE GET IT, FRANK.
4:09 >> YEAH, CERTAINLY A LOT OF
4:11 ANTICIPATION FOR THOSE TUESDAY
4:12 EARNINGS. OUR SEEMA MODY WITH
4:13 THE VERY LATEST ON NVIDIA. NEW
4:14 REPORTING FROM THE FTC THAT THE
4:16 BOARD IS CONSIDERING. RENE HAAS
4:17 OBVIOUSLY THE CEO IS A
4:18 POTENTIAL SUCCESSOR TO JEN-HSUN
4:21 HUANG RIGHT NOW. AGAIN SHARES
4:22 OF NVIDIA DOWN ABOUT 3.5%. I
4:23 WANT TO COME OVER TO YOU
4:25 GENTLEMEN RIGHT HERE. AND ALSO
4:26 LIZ WE WANT TO BRING YOU IN THE
4:28 CONVERSATION. CERTAINLY A FAST
4:29 MOVING DEVELOPMENT WHEN IT
4:30 COMES TO A POTENTIAL
4:31 REPLACEMENT FOR JEN-HSUN HUANG.
4:32 IS THAT COMFORTING OR DO YOU
4:34 THINK THAT COULD BE CONCERNING.
4:35 A LOT OF TALK, INCLUDING MY
4:37 COLLEAGUE JOHN FORTT, THAT IF
4:38 YOU BRING AN OUTSIDER IN, SOME
4:39 TALENT MAY LEAVE BECAUSE THEY
4:41 FEEL LIKE THEY WERE PASSED OVER?
4:42 >> NO, I THINK I THINK THAT'S I
4:44 THINK THAT'S A POSITIVE
4:45 DEVELOPMENT. AND OBVIOUSLY THE
4:46 LEADER OF ARM HAS BEEN AT
4:48 NVIDIA BEFORE HE LEFT, I THINK
4:49 IN 2013. SO I THINK, YOU KNOW,
4:51 THERE'S SOME SOME CALM WITH
4:53 THAT WITH THAT POTENTIAL
4:54 DECISION. WHAT I WILL SAY TO
4:56 JIMI'S POINT, OF COURSE, FROM A
4:57 BEARS PERSPECTIVE, THERE'S A
4:59 MOUNTAIN OF HEADWINDS. YOU KNOW,
5:01 FROM A TACTICAL PERSPECTIVE, AT
5:03 LEAST, I THINK THERE ARE
5:03 CONCERNS AROUND EXPORT CONTROLS.
5:05 AS JIMMY MENTIONED, NATIONAL
5:07 SECURITY OBVIOUSLY IS AN ISSUE.
5:09 WHAT WHERE WHERE ARE THE CHIPS
5:11 GOING? ULTIMATELY, YOU KNOW, IN
5:13 PARTS OF THE FAR EAST, WHETHER
5:14 IT'S MALAYSIA, VIETNAM, ARE
5:15 THEY ULTIMATELY GETTING TO
5:16 CHINA, THE MORE ADVANCED CHIPS?
5:18 I THINK THAT'S A CONCERN. BUT
5:19 WHEN I LOOK AT THIS STOCK FROM
5:21 A FUNDAMENTAL BASIS THAT JIMMY
5:22 ALREADY KIND OF SHARED, ALLUDED
5:23 TO 115 TO 115, $17 BILLION
5:28 WORTH OF REVENUE THIS QUARTER,
5:29 70 PLUS PERCENT MARGINS TO
5:31 JIMMY'S POINT AS WELL. 10%. I
5:33 MEAN, TRADING AT TEN TIMES
5:35 FORWARD. I MEAN, IF YOU REMOVE
5:38 THE NAME AND LOOKED AT A STOCK
5:39 LIKE THAT, YOU'RE LIKE, HEY,
5:40 THIS IS SOMETHING I WANT TO
5:41 LEAN INTO. IT'S DOWN. I KNOW
5:43 CLOSE TO 20% THIS MONTH, BUT I
5:45 THINK THERE POTENTIALLY MIGHT
5:46 BE AN OPPORTUNITY. I THINK
5:47 THERE'S MORE TO COME. SADLY.
5:49 WE'LL HEAR THAT, YOU KNOW,
5:51 TESTIFYING BEHIND CLOSED DOORS.
5:52 AND THERE'S A LOT MORE TO
5:55 EVOLVE IN THIS STORY. BUT I DO
5:58 THINK THERE WILL BE AN
5:59 OPPORTUNITY AS A LONG TERM
6:01 INVESTOR.
6:01 >> TO YOUR POINT ABOUT MORE TO
6:03 COME. YESTERDAY I WAS ACTUALLY
6:04 SPEAKING TO A DEMOCRAT THAT'S
6:05 IN CONGRESS NOW WHO HAS BEEN
6:07 REELECTED. SO THEY'LL BE IN THE
6:08 NEW CONGRESS. AND THEY TOLD ME
6:10 JUST FLAT OUT, HE'S GOING TO
6:11 HAVE TO COME BACK. HE WILL BE
6:13 BACK ON THE HILL. SO IT LOOKS
6:15 LIKE THE DEMOCRATS ALSO WANT TO
6:16 HAVE SOME CONVERSATIONS WITH
6:17 THEM. I ALSO DO WANT TO POINT
6:19 OUT NVIDIA SHARES HAVE GAINED
6:20 ABOUT A HALF A PERCENT STILL
6:22 LOWER. BUT SINCE THIS NEWS
6:23 BROKE AND IF YOU LOOK ON CAL,
6:25 SHE HAS ODDS OF BECOMING THE
6:26 NEXT NVIDIA CEO AT 35%. THEY
6:28 SPIKED UP AS SOON AS THIS
6:29 REPORT CAME IN.
6:30 >> AND YOU DON'T THINK THAT'S
6:32 BECAUSE OF OUR POSITIVE TALK ON
6:33 IT, FRANK?
6:34 >> AND PERHAPS PERHAPS KEVIN, I
6:35 WANT TO COME OVER TO YOU. JUST
6:37 YOUR THOUGHTS ABOUT A NEW CEO
6:38 FOR NVIDIA. PERHAPS, YOU KNOW,
6:40 A DECISION BEING MADE. I DON'T
6:41 KNOW WHEN HE WOULD TAKE OVER
6:43 THE ROLE, BUT, YOU KNOW, DAYS
6:44 OR THE DAY AFTER JEN-HSUN HUANG
6:46 STEPPED DOWN.
6:46 >> I MEAN, YOU CAN REPLACE THE
6:48 CEO, BUT IT WILL BE VERY
6:49 DIFFICULT TO REPLACE THE
6:50 VISIONARY THAT WAS JEN-HSUN
6:51 HUANG. I THINK THAT THE STREET
6:53 WOULD PREFER AN OUTSIDER. I
6:54 THINK THAT'S WHY THERE IS SOME
6:56 ENTHUSIASM HERE. I THINK THE
6:57 BOARD HAS TO MOVE QUICKLY. THIS
6:58 IS NOT SOMETHING YOU WANT TO
7:00 LINGER IN ANY WAY, SHAPE OR
7:01 FORM. I THINK THAT THERE WILL
7:03 BE PEOPLE THAT LEAVE NVIDIA,
7:04 REGARDLESS OF WHETHER THEY
7:05 PROMOTE FROM WITHIN OR THEY
7:06 BRING FROM WITHOUT ALL OF THE
7:09 FUNDAMENTAL CASE THAT THE
7:10 GENTLEMEN HAVE LAID OUT IS
7:12 ACCURATE. IF THIS WAS A BLIND
7:13 TICKER TO JASON'S POINT, YOU'D
7:14 BE BUYING IT. BUT IT IS NOT.
7:16 AND THERE WILL BE MORE THINGS
7:18 TO COME FOR SURE. WHERE THERE'S
7:20 SMOKE, THERE IS FIRE. AND
7:22 YESTERDAY WE SOLD FRANK HALF OF
7:23 OUR POSITION ON PURE PRICE
7:25 ACTION ALONE. AND IT'S
7:27 HEARTBREAKING FROM THE
7:28 STANDPOINT OF LOOKING AT THE
7:29 PORTFOLIO, THE ADMISSION THAT
7:31 YOU'RE WRONG AND YOU TAKE A 20%
7:32 LOSS, LIKE WE LITERALLY BOUGHT
7:34 THIS STOCK AT 200 AND SOLD IT
7:36 YESTERDAY IN THE ONE 60S, NOT
7:38 BECAUSE WE DON'T LIKE THE
7:39 FUNDAMENTALS, BUT I HAVE A RULE
7:41 BASED ON PRICE ACTION FROM OUR
7:42 ENTRY POINT, MOST OF THE WORLD
7:44 BOUGHT IT, YOU KNOW, AT LIKE
7:45 $0.05. AND THEY'VE OWNED IT FOR
7:47 TWO YEARS AND IT'S DOUBLED
7:48 EVERY 20 MINUTES. WE DIDN'T
7:50 HAVE THAT LUXURY. THEY'VE
7:51 RECENTLY INITIATED A DIVIDEND,
7:52 A SHARE BUYBACK. WE PUT THEM IN
7:54 OUR PORTFOLIO. WE ONLY GOT
7:56 STOPPED OUT OF HALF OF IT. IF
7:57 THE PRICE CONTINUES TO PULL
7:59 BACK, WE'LL PROBABLY LOSE THE
8:00 REST OF IT. MAYBE THE ROONEY
8:02 HAAS NEWS GIVES IT A LITTLE BIT
8:04 OF A STABILITY POINT HERE,
8:06 WHICH I WOULD LIKE TO SEE, BUT
8:08 I THINK THE FUNDAMENTALS ARE
8:09 GREAT. BUT SOMETIMES THERE'S
8:10 MORE TO A STORY.
8:11 >> SO CAN I ASK, AND I HATE TO
8:14 PRESS YOU ON THIS, BUT YOU TOOK
8:15 A LOSS ON THIS.
8:16 >> IT DOESN'T HAPPEN OFTEN,
8:18 FRANK. LET'S TALK ABOUT IT.
8:19 >> DID YOU WANT TO GET OUT
8:21 BECAUSE YOU WERE WORRIED.
8:22 >> ABOUT THIS?
8:22 >> NO.
8:23 >> WERE YOU WORRIED ABOUT WHAT
8:24 COULD HAPPEN WITH JEN-HSUN
8:25 HUANG GOING FORWARD AND HOW
8:27 THAT COULD IMPACT NVIDIA? OR
8:28 WERE YOU WORRIED THAT THE
8:29 COMPANY JUST BASICALLY LOST ITS
8:30 VISION? I MEAN, WHY WHY TAKE A
8:32 LOSS ON SOMETHING WHEN THERE'S
8:33 SO MANY DEVELOPMENTS LEFT TO
8:35 HAPPEN?
8:35 >> IT'S AN EXCELLENT QUESTION.
8:36 I THINK IT'S A GREAT TIME FOR
8:38 TRADE SCHOOL. I DON'T HAVE ANY
8:39 EMOTION TO ANY OF THE TICKERS.
8:41 I LOOK AT IT PURELY FROM A MATH
8:43 EQUATION. I PAID 200. WE GOT
8:44 STOPPED OUT ON RELATIVE
8:45 UNDERPERFORMANCE ON HALF OF IT.
8:47 I THINK EVERYTHING THAT THESE
8:48 GUYS HAVE SAID IS ACCURATE. I
8:49 THINK THAT THERE'S LOTS OF
8:51 REASONS THAT IF YOU DON'T OWN
8:52 IT AND YOU WANT TO TAKE A RISK
8:54 AND GET INTO SOMETHING THAT'S
8:55 UNDER A LOT OF PRESSURE, YOU
8:57 CAN HAVE TREMENDOUS REWARD ON
8:58 IT. BUT
Rep. Josh Gottheimer on Nvidia: We want more facts; we have to understand what went on full transcript
0:00 ITS PART BELOW 4000. I THINK
0:02 IT'S NEGATIVE ON THE YEAR. NOW
0:03 IT'S ALMOST NEGATIVE ON A 12
0:05 MONTH BASIS. AND BITCOIN AT
0:07 68,000. JUST INCREDIBLE MOVES
0:09 THERE LATELY. BUT WE BEGIN ONCE
0:11 AGAIN WITH THE STORY OF THE I
0:13 DON'T KNOW YEAR DECADE NVIDIA
0:16 DOWN ANOTHER 3% AS JENSEN
0:18 WONG'S RESIGNATION DOES NOT
0:19 MEAN THE COMPANY'S CHALLENGES
0:21 ARE OVER. COULD BE FAR FROM IT.
0:22 OUR FIRST GUEST SERVES ON ONE
0:24 OF THE THREE COMMITTEES THAT
0:25 WILL HOLD A CLOSED DOOR
0:27 BRIEFING WITH JEN-HSUN HUANG AS
0:29 EARLY AS NEXT WEEK. NEW JERSEY
0:31 DEMOCRATIC REPRESENTATIVE JOSH
0:32 GOTTHEIMER JOINS US IN OUR
0:33 OPENING EXCHANGE. IT'S GREAT TO
0:35 HAVE YOU HERE, CONGRESSMAN.
0:35 WELCOME.
0:36 >> THANKS FOR HAVING ME.
0:37 >> ALL RIGHT. SO WHAT'S THE
0:38 TIMELINE? WHAT HAPPENS NOW?
0:39 >> WELL, ACTUALLY YESTERDAY,
0:41 CONGRESSMAN DARIN LAHOOD AND I,
0:42 WE BOTH OVERSEE THE
0:44 SUBCOMMITTEE THAT HAS
0:45 JURISDICTION HERE ON THE
0:47 INTELLIGENCE COMMITTEE. AND YOU
0:49 ASKED YESTERDAY OF OF THE
0:50 INTELLIGENCE COMMUNITY,
0:52 INCLUDING THE CIA AND THE DNI,
0:53 AS WELL AS THE DEPARTMENT OF
0:55 JUSTICE AND THE FBI. WHAT DID
0:56 YOU KNOW? WHEN WE WANT MORE
0:58 FACTS, WE WANT TO UNDERSTAND
1:00 EXACTLY THE TIMELINE HERE AND
1:01 THE INFORMATION AT HAND. SO I'M
1:03 HOPING WE GET QUICK ANSWERS
1:05 THERE AS WE LEAD INTO JENSEN
1:07 COMING TO TESTIFY. THE OFFICIAL
1:10 RESPONSE FROM JENSEN HAS NOT
1:12 COME IN YET. YOU KNOW, THREE OF
1:14 THE COMMITTEES THAT HAVE
1:15 JURISDICTION HERE ASKED JENSEN
1:16 TO COME TESTIFY. WE'VE NOT
1:18 HEARD OFFICIALLY. THEY
1:19 THREATENED YESTERDAY TO ISSUE
1:21 SUBPOENAS TO GET THE
1:22 INFORMATION WE NEED. AND I
1:23 THINK THAT'S THE KEY HERE. WE
1:24 HAVE TO REALLY UNDERSTAND WHAT
1:26 WENT ON HERE. YOU'VE GOT CHIPS,
1:28 RIGHT? VERY ADVANCED CHIPS THAT
1:30 WE DO NOT WANT TO GET IN THE
1:32 HANDS OF CHINA, OUR TOP
1:33 ADVERSARY HERE. AND SO IF THEY
1:35 WERE ABLE TO GET THERE, YOU
1:37 KNOW, WHAT KIND OF DEALS WERE
1:38 MADE? WHAT EXACTLY DO THEY HAVE?
1:41 AND AND MISS HUANG, WHAT DID
1:42 SHE WHAT DID SHE ALLOW? WHAT
1:43 DID SHE GIVE? IS SHE PART OF
1:45 THIS? YOU KNOW, THOSE ARE ALL
1:46 QUESTIONS WE HAVE TO UNDERSTAND.
1:47 >> YOU MENTIONED THERE ARE
1:48 THREE COMMITTEES. DOES THAT
1:49 MEAN THAT ONE OF YOU ENDS UP
1:51 MOVING FORWARD, OR WILL ALL
1:52 THREE.
1:53 >> WELL, I BELIEVE KIM JEFFRIES
1:54 EARLIER TODAY SAID THAT THE
1:56 INTELLIGENCE COMMUNITY WOULD
1:57 TAKE THE LEAD. BUT LISTEN,
2:00 THERE'S MULTIPLE JURISDICTIONS
2:01 HERE. I THINK WE ALL HAVE
2:02 QUESTIONS THAT ARE RELEVANT FOR
2:04 OUR OUR COMMITTEES. FROM AN
2:06 INTELLIGENCE COMMITTEE
2:07 PERSPECTIVE, YOU CAN IMAGINE
2:08 FROM AN AI PERSPECTIVE HOW
2:10 IMPORTANT THIS IS FOR OUR
2:11 NATIONAL SECURITY, FOR OUR
2:12 CRITICAL INFRASTRUCTURE AND
2:13 UNDERSTAND WHEN IT COMES TO
2:15 CHIP POLICY, WHAT EXACTLY GOT
2:18 TO CHINA AND WAS WHAT DID MEGA
2:20 SPEED DIVERT CHIPS? YOU KNOW,
2:22 THAT'S ANOTHER BIG STORY HERE.
2:23 WHAT WAS DIVERTED AND WERE
2:25 THERE, YOU KNOW, THAT'S BEEN AN
2:27 INVESTIGATION THAT'S ONGOING OF
2:27 MEGA SPEED. YOU KNOW, CERTAIN
2:29 PEOPLE IN THE ADMINISTRATION,
2:30 ESPECIALLY THE COMMERCE
2:31 DEPARTMENT, WAS BLOCKING MY
2:33 UNDERSTANDING, BLOCKING CERTAIN
2:35 RESTRICTIONS THAT OTHERS IN THE
2:37 ADMINISTRATION, LIKE THE
2:38 TREASURY SECRETARY WANTED.
2:39 >> AND I JUST WANT TO REMIND
2:41 THE AUDIENCE, I MEAN, YOUR TECH
2:42 BACKGROUND MAKES YOU ESPECIALLY
2:44 INTERESTING TO SPEAK TO HERE.
2:44 YOU WORKED AT MICROSOFT FOR
2:46 YEARS. YOU KNOW A LOT ABOUT
2:47 WHAT'S GOING ON. I WON'T ASK
2:48 YOU ABOUT THE MICROSOFT OUTAGE
2:49 UNLESS, I MEAN, DO YOU KNOW
2:51 ANYTHING ABOUT THAT, BY THE WAY,
2:52 ABOUT WHAT HAPPENED THERE?
2:53 >> NO, I'VE BEEN THERE A WHILE.
2:55 YEAH.
2:55 >> NO, I JUST MEAN EVEN.
2:56 >> WHERE, YOU KNOW.
2:57 >> WE.
2:58 >> HAVE CONGRESS. NO, I HAVEN'T
2:59 HEARD. IN FACT, I ASKED FOR A
3:00 BRIEFING ON THAT QUESTION. IS
3:02 THERE SOMETHING WAS THERE
3:03 SOMETHING THAT WENT ON THAT'S
3:04 NEFARIOUS HERE OR IS THIS JUST
3:05 SOMETHING ELSE? YOU KNOW, THESE
3:06 OUTAGES OCCUR IN A LOT OF THE
3:08 COMPANIES, BUT THE THE SIZE OF
3:09 IT AND THE LENGTH OF IT, RIGHT.
3:11 SO THAT AND THE TIMING OF IT.
3:12 RIGHT. SO LOTS OF INTERESTING
3:14 QUESTIONS, BUT THOSE ARE I KNOW
3:15 WHAT YOU THOUGHT OF IS EXACTLY
3:16 WHAT I ASKED ABOUT YESTERDAY,
3:18 BUT, YOU KNOW, GOING BACK TO
3:20 NVIDIA STUFF, YOU KNOW, THIS IS
3:22 A, AS YOU POINTED OUT, A MAJOR
3:24 ISSUE BECAUSE THERE'S A LOT OF
3:25 PIECES INVOLVED. AND, AND THE
3:28 CHIP PIECE OF THIS, REMEMBER,
3:30 GIVEN THE BATTLE WE'RE IN WITH
3:32 CHINA, YOU UNDERSTAND WHY THIS
3:34 IS SUCH AN IMPORTANT THING TO
3:35 UNDERSTAND.
3:36 >> THERE WERE SOME REPORTS ON
3:37 SOCIAL MEDIA FROM, I THINK, A
3:39 FORMER OPENAI EMPLOYEE WHO WAS
3:40 ASSERTING THAT BASED ON HIS
3:42 ANALYSIS, THAT NVIDIA CHIPS
3:43 WERE DIRECTLY THEIR LEADING
3:44 EDGE CHIPS WERE DIRECTLY BEING
3:45 USED TO TRAIN CHINESE LOW COST
3:47 RIVALS LIKE DEEP SEA. DO YOU
3:50 KNOW ANYTHING ABOUT THAT? DO
3:51 YOU EXPECT US TO. WHAT WOULD
3:53 YOU SAY THE CURRENT STATE OF
3:54 AFFAIRS IS?
3:55 >> YOU KNOW, OUR. OUR POLICY
3:56 HAS BEEN TO NOT ALLOW THE
3:58 LATEST CHIPS TO GO THERE, RIGHT.
4:00 TO TO BE BEHIND. THAT'S, YOU
4:01 KNOW, THAT'S POLICY THAT'S
4:02 CONTINUED IN THIS
4:03 ADMINISTRATION, STARTED IN THE
4:04 LAST ADMINISTRATION. AND GIVEN
4:07 THAT, I WOULD HOPE THAT'S
4:08 ACTUALLY WHAT'S HAPPENED.
4:08 THAT'S WHY YOU HAVE TO. THE
4:10 QUESTION WE SHOULD ALL WANT TO
4:12 GET TO THE BOTTOM OF AS PART OF
4:13 THIS, NOT JUST WHAT HAPPENED
4:15 BETWEEN JENSEN AND MISS HUANG,
4:17 BUT BUT TO ALSO UNDERSTAND
4:18 WHERE CHIPS DIVERTED. THERE'S
4:19 BEEN AN ONGOING INVESTIGATION.
4:22 AND YOU WOULD HOPE THAT AS PART
4:24 OF THIS THAT'S NOT WHAT'S
4:25 HAPPENED. WAS ANY TECHNOLOGY
4:26 SHARED. YOU KNOW, THIS IS WHAT
4:28 EXACTLY HAPPENED BETWEEN THE
4:29 TWO OF THEM? WERE THERE
4:30 QUESTIONS ASKED AND ANSWERED
4:32 AND WAS AND THE CHAIRMAN OF THE
4:35 INTELLIGENCE, SORRY, THE
4:36 RANKING MEMBER OF THE
4:36 INTELLIGENCE COMMITTEE, JIM
4:37 HIMES, WAS ASKED ABOUT ABOUT
4:39 WHAT WHAT HAPPENED SPECIFICALLY
Cerebras CEO Andrew Feldman on data centers: 'We are behind schedule' on builds full transcript
0:00 Welcome back. Take a look at shares of
0:01 Cerebra Systems. The chipmaker higher
0:03 this morning after reporting a beat on
0:05 the top and the bottom line in Q3
0:06 raising guidance into year end and then
0:08 announcing this new cloud deal with
0:10 Microsoft. Joining us this morning in a
0:12 first on CNBC interview is Cerebra
0:14 Systems co-founder and CEO Andrew
0:16 Feldman. Andrew, welcome back. Thanks
0:17 for the time.
0:19 >> Thanks for having us back. It's good to
0:21 see you.
0:22 >> Yes. Uh under much more much brighter
0:24 circumstances. In fact, everyone's
0:26 buzzing about the Microsoft angle. Is
0:28 there any detail or granularity you can
0:30 give us on it?
0:32 >> We'd love to give you detail, but
0:34 unfortunately we we can't at this time.
0:36 I think we will have all sorts of
0:38 exciting stuff to talk about in the
0:39 first part of the year.
0:41 >> What does the quarter tell us about the
0:42 trajectory of the business at the
0:44 moment? Then
0:45 >> I think it tells you a fair bit. I I
0:48 think there is big momentum in in AI
0:51 compute. I think there's particular
0:53 momentum around uh the the part of the
0:56 market we service which is fast
0:58 inference which is delivering the
1:01 results from your queries quickly. And
1:05 what we're seeing is that that our
1:07 customers who who who deliver this to to
1:09 the users, they're able to charge more
1:12 when it's fast and that premium is
1:16 expanding.
1:18 Looks like there's some we're definitely
1:19 we mentioned Microsoft, but Oracle 2 is
1:21 a part of the puzzle, right?
1:23 >> Yeah, we've had a pretty good good
1:25 six-month run. We we added three
1:27 hyperscalers over that time. So AWS,
1:31 Oracle, and Microsoft. Uh I think you
1:35 will see that that in our numbers next
1:38 year as those deployments roll out. Uh
1:41 that's a pretty good run for a for a
1:43 company in 6 months.
1:45 >> What about OpenAI? Since we're going
1:46 through some of the partners here and
1:48 and delay here in in building data
1:50 centers, what can you tell us for
1:51 OpenAI?
1:52 >> Well, I I think uh data centers are
1:54 unfortunately delayed across the
1:56 industry and and we're no exception. I
1:58 think these are enormous construction
2:00 projects. There's tremendous energy and
2:02 drive to to build them out and get them
2:05 on time. Uh like others in the industry,
2:08 ours are late. the others are late is
2:10 obviously no excuse for us, but uh our
2:13 builders are are doing their best to to
2:16 execute and deliver on time, but we are
2:18 we are behind schedule and that is a
2:21 challenge to our partners.
2:23 >> Is it have they canceled any capacity?
2:25 Could any of the contract be at risk
2:27 from it?
2:28 >> Um nothing's been cancelled at this
2:30 time. Uh, one of the things we we said
2:33 on our earnings call is the the contract
2:35 does permit if we are uh late that there
2:39 be um service credits acrew. We have the
2:42 same relationship with our our data
2:44 center builders. And if we're super
2:46 late, both sides have have opportunity
2:48 to cancel tanches, which are uh delivery
2:52 units of of capacity.
Anthropic's IPO will be a bellwether moment, says IBM's Gary Cohn full transcript
0:00 FAR LOWER LEVEL? THEY'RE STILL
0:03 FOCUSED ON THE ENTERPRISE. YEAH.
0:05 YEAH.
0:05 >> WELL, I HAVE A FEELING OUR
0:07 NEXT GUEST HAS SOME THOUGHTS ON
0:08 ALL OF THIS AND WHETHER THE THE
0:10 TOKEN PRICES ARE WORTH IT.
0:11 JOINING US NOW AT POST NINE IS
0:13 THE FORMER DIRECTOR OF NATIONAL
0:15 ECONOMIC COUNCIL. DURING
0:15 PRESIDENT TRUMP'S FIRST TERM,
0:16 GARY COHN. GARY'S ALSO A FORMER
0:18 PRESIDENT OF GOLDMAN SACHS. AND
0:19 HE'S CURRENTLY THE VICE CHAIR
0:20 AT IBM. WELCOME BACK. IT'S GOOD
0:22 TO HAVE YOU. THANKS FOR HAVING
0:23 ME. I MEAN THESE THESE NUMBERS
0:25 THAT WHAT WE'RE TRYING TO SHOW
0:26 HERE IS JUST GROWING ADOPTION
0:28 AND GROWING SPENDING ON AI AND
0:29 A GROWING PART OF THE OVERALL
0:31 ECONOMY, RIGHT? GROWING WALLET
0:33 SHARE IN TERMS OF SPENDING ON,
0:35 ON AI PRODUCTS. HOW DO YOU LOOK
0:37 AT THESE? HOW DO YOU LOOK AT
0:39 THIS?
0:39 >> LOOK.
0:40 >> SARAH, NO ONE SHOULD DENY
0:41 HOW IMPORTANT AI HAS BECOME TO
0:43 US AS INDIVIDUALS AND TO THE
0:45 ENTERPRISE. THERE IS NO COMPANY
0:46 TODAY THAT IS NOT USING AI FOR
0:48 SOMETHING IN THEIR ORGANIZATION.
0:50 I THINK WE'RE FINDING OUT WHERE
0:52 THE REAL OPPORTUNITIES FOR AI
0:53 ARE TODAY. YOU KNOW, WE'VE SEEN
0:55 ENORMOUS PROGRESS IN THE
0:57 PROGRAMING SIDE OF AI. AI CAN
0:59 PROGRAM EXTRAORDINARILY
1:00 EFFICIENTLY. WE'VE SEEN AI BE
1:02 USED REALLY EFFECTIVELY IN HR.
1:04 THERE'S A LOT OF TASKS IN HR
1:06 THAT INDIVIDUALS DON'T WANT TO
1:07 DO, WHERE AI IS REAY GOOD AT
1:09 DOING THOSE TASKS. SO COMPANIES
1:10 ARE CONTINUING TO PUSH THE
1:12 FRONTIER, BUT COMPANIES ARE
1:13 ALSO TO THE POINT NOW WHERE
1:15 THEY'RE BEING FORCED TO
1:16 EVALUATE THE RETURN ON
1:17 INVESTMENT AND THE INVESTMENT
1:19 IS TOKENS. YOU KNOW, IF I'M
1:21 BUYING $1 MILLION OF TOKENS, AM
1:23 I GETTING $1 MILLION OF VALUE
1:24 BACK? AM I GETTING $2 MILLION
1:26 BACK OR AM I GETTING $500,000
1:28 BACK? WE HAVE SEEN MIXED
1:30 RESULTS ON THIS. I THINK IT'S A
1:32 LITTLE BIT TOO EARLY IN THIS
1:34 JOURNEY TO MAKE A DECLARATION
1:36 THAT WE'RE GETTING A HUGE
1:38 RETURN, BUT I THINK THERE'S TOO
1:39 MUCH RISK FOR COMPANIES TO NOT
1:42 TRY, BECAUSE IF IT IS A REAL
1:44 EFFICIENCY CREATOR, YOU, YOUR
1:46 COMPETITOR WILL OUTCOMPETE YOU
1:47 IF THEY'RE MORE EFFICIENT THAN
1:48 YOU ARE.
1:49 >> SO WHAT DOES THAT MEAN FOR
1:51 ANTHROPIC IPO NEXT WEEK?
1:53 >> WELL, I THINK ANTHROPIC IPO
1:55 IS GOING TO BE THE FIRST
1:57 BELLWETHER OF A PURE FRONTIER
2:00 MODEL. AND IT'S IMPORTANT TO
2:00 SAY THAT FRONTIER MODEL.
2:02 >> YOU GUYS ARE IN THE OPEN
2:04 WEIGHT CAMP.
2:04 >> FRONTIER MODEL COMPANY. I
2:06 THINK IT WILL DO VERY WELL. I
2:09 HOPE IT DOES VERY WELL. I THINK
2:11 EVERYONE INVOLVED IN THAT
2:12 TRANSACTION KNOWS WHAT A
2:15 BELLWETHER MOMENT THIS WILL BE.
2:17 IT LOOKS AND FEELS LIKE THEY
2:18 ARE GOING TO PRICE IT AT AN
2:20 APPROPRIATE PRICE, AND THEY ARE
2:21 GOING TO PRICE IT TO TRADE WELL
2:24 INITIALLY. AND LOOK, THE
2:25 UNDERWRITERS CAN ONLY PRICE IT
2:27 TO TRADE WELL INITIALLY. YOU
2:28 KNOW MORE AND MORE SUPPLY COMES
2:29 ON THE MARKET. EMPLOYEES GET
Watch CNBC’s extended interview with Estée Lauder CEO Stéphane de La Faverie full transcript
0:00 Well, thank you for having us here. Oh,
0:01 >> thank you for having me.
0:02 >> It's a treat. So, I I want to talk about
0:04 the financial performance because you
0:06 just raised your outlook. You've seen
0:07 five quarters of growth.
0:09 >> It's been a turnaround story. What's the
0:11 what's the single biggest change you've
0:13 made that has led to the performance?
0:16 >> Well, I think there's multiple changes
0:17 that we've brought to this performance.
0:19 I think if you remember two years ago,
0:20 we've announced beauty reimagine, which
0:22 is the new strategy that we've put in
0:24 place to become the best consumer
0:25 centric prestige beauty company in the
0:27 world. I think many of the things we've
0:29 done is really making sure that we go
0:31 after the consumers where she or he is
0:34 basically everywhere around the world.
0:36 So really positioning our brands where
0:38 the consu where the consumers are but
0:40 also giving them more innovation. In the
0:42 postcoid world we've seen consumer more
0:45 excited about seeing new product and we
0:47 needed to accelerate it and reinvest in
0:49 our brand. Now to do all of that we had
0:52 to just obviously take some difficult
0:54 and bold decision for the company to
0:56 transform the company to be much more
0:58 agile to be faster and you know to
1:00 really be able to just position our
1:02 brand and our product in the right
1:03 places for our consumers
1:05 >> you mentioned you've been here almost
1:06 two years now when when you came in what
1:08 what was your what's your diagnosis
1:10 about what went wrong
1:11 >> I think what I saw when I've been in the
1:13 company for over a decade is I knew we
1:16 had strong brands we have a beautiful
1:17 portfolio of brand from the Esteler to
1:19 Mac to Joe Malone here the ordinary
1:21 today but we were not agile we were not
1:25 fast enough to react like you know to
1:26 the trend and to the speed that the
1:28 consumer were so we needed to make some
1:30 change and to reignite the
1:31 entrepreneurial spirit on which this
1:33 company has been built for so many years
1:35 >> so what's giving you the confidence now
1:37 to to raise guidance what do you see
1:38 from the consumer
1:39 >> first what you said like five quarters
1:41 in a row of growth especially the last
1:42 two quarters have been very strong a
1:44 much more balanced growth around the
1:46 world like you know from east to west I
1:48 think you know obviously we had always
1:50 very strong position in the east with
1:52 like you know China, Japan, like you
1:54 know Korea where we continue to gain
1:55 market share but now reacelerating our
1:59 trend also in the US, Latin America and
2:01 in Europe and in the emerging market. So
2:04 we're seeing a lot more agility, a lot
2:06 more speed. We're seeing an organization
2:08 also that is like moving that is much
2:10 more that is bolder more ambitious and
2:13 more importantly we're seeing a lot of
2:14 our innovation and our brands like you
2:16 know working in many places around the
2:18 world
2:18 >> especially fragrance I mean that that
2:19 20% growth I think profit almost doubled
2:22 there why is fragrance growing so much
2:24 faster than say makeup
2:26 >> well I think you know what we've seen
2:28 first is like in the postcoid world
2:30 fences being the category we've seen a
2:32 lot of expansion but there's two part of
2:34 fences there's what we call the luxury
2:36 fances where brands like Joe Malone, Tom
2:38 Ford, Kilian Fer, Malabo have been very
2:41 very strong for us and been growing
2:43 because there's new entrance to the
2:45 category younger consumers that no
2:47 longer wants a signature fence. They
2:50 want a wardrobe of fences. They use
2:52 different fances for different occasion,
2:54 different moods and there's still a big
2:56 part of the business that is in prestige
2:58 fances what I call the$1 to $150. And we
3:02 never really played in the last decade
3:04 in this category. So with the launch of
3:06 Estello Glimmer, Balman beauty, but also
3:09 Tom Ford signature and Kilian cocktail,
3:12 we have now the ability to go after
3:14 market share. So having this dual
3:16 strategy of going after the luxury
3:18 consumer and the prestige consumer has
3:20 allowed us to expand and to have a great
3:23 success of you saw in the last quarter
3:25 but also in the prior fiscal year where
3:27 we grow double digit growth. I I wanted
3:28 to ask about prestige in particular
3:30 because some parts of the luxury market
3:32 are not holding up as well as prestige
3:35 beauty. Why is that?
3:37 >> Well, I think you know for us generally
3:39 speaking when we see in beauty is a
3:40 strong resilience. I think around the
3:42 world I just come back from Asia and
3:44 here in the US the resilience of the
3:46 beauty consumer is very strong. It is
3:48 part of like little luxuries that people
3:50 want to have access every day. Remember
3:53 beauty is anywhere of this brand like
3:55 the ordinary between an average of $102
3:58 price point all the way to brand like La
4:00 Mer or Labo that are $200. So it's still
4:04 what I would call an accessible luxury
4:07 and prestige. So this category is very
4:09 resilient for multiple thing. One
4:11 because lifespan is expanding. Consumers
4:14 are starting younger and staying older
4:16 also. People are living older. So this
4:19 concept of longevity and people wants to
4:21 take care of themselves and there is
4:22 also the phenomenon of new emerging
4:25 consumers around the world. We're seeing
4:27 between now and 2030 more than doubling
4:29 the number of emerging consumer around
4:31 the world that comes into the middle
4:33 class. Usually when consumer comes in
4:35 the middle class they tend to go to the
4:37 beauty category first. I think I feel
4:39 like it also goes with the spending
4:40 we've seen on experiences,
4:42 >> on travel, on concerts, on going out, on
4:46 restaurants where there's been strong
4:47 growth despite sort of weaker consumer
4:49 confidence.
4:50 >> Yeah. And I think it's part of the
4:51 experience. Beauty is part of
4:52 experience. I always say beauty is
4:54 culture and culture is beauty. People
4:55 wants to be part of a cultural movement.
4:58 And one of the thing that I've said with
5:00 the team part of the beauty reimagine is
5:02 also putting back the concept of
5:04 experience at the center in a world
5:06 where online is growing so fast and
5:08 we're doing extremely well online and
5:10 it's like you know more than 30% of our
5:12 business growing strongly and we're
5:13 getting market share in many markets
5:15 around the world. We need to put back
5:17 the excelon experience. consumer wants
5:18 to be able to sit down in a chair like
5:20 you and I are doing it and go through a
5:23 simple makeover a discussion about
5:25 ingredients or like you know
5:26 storytelling behind like you know
5:28 Florence brand and we're seeing that
5:30 much more so when we give back the
5:32 experience and the time for the consumer
5:34 call it like slow retail people come
5:36 back and sit in the chair and engage
5:38 with our brand so this basically goes
5:41 beyond like you know consumer resilience
5:44 it's just like you know it's something
5:45 that I want to own a brand that I want
5:46 to engage And so there's multiple way
5:49 you can do it physically, you can do it
5:50 digitally. But this is like you know,
5:52 >> but isn't Tik Tok I mean isn't that
5:54 hasn't that been a huge part of the game
5:56 in terms of selling beauty?
5:57 >> Tik Tok has been a game changer like any
6:00 social platform has been a game changer
6:02 because it allows like you know the
6:03 consumer to discover the brand but today
6:05 you have to think about the ecosystem.
6:07 You may discover the brand on a social
6:10 media platform like Tik Tok. you may
6:12 engage uh in an LLM, you know, like you
6:15 know, an AI platform to ask, you know,
6:18 more information, then you may go to the
6:20 store to learn a little bit more and
6:22 ultimately buy online. So there's an
6:24 entire ecosystem that you have to
6:25 harness today and when you are there at
6:27 every single touch points for the
6:29 consumer this is where you are creating
6:31 the excitement and like you know even
6:33 when consumer confidence is lower this
6:35 is a category that they
6:37 >> I was going to ask about AI and agentic
6:39 commerce because I can just type in
6:41 what's the best skinincare routine for
6:43 me. How do you make sure your brands
6:45 stand out in that environment?
6:47 >> I think it's just like the same we need
6:48 to be in the different touch points.
6:50 Today we are using creators around the
6:52 world. You know we come we are 80 years
6:55 young as a company. I love to see it. We
6:57 started at the counter with beauty
6:58 advisor. Beauty advisor were the
7:00 ultimate influencer for the brand. Today
7:03 is no longer just the beauty advisor is
7:05 anybody in the street that wants to talk
7:07 and engage with our brand. So we're
7:08 engaging with tens of thousands of like
7:10 you know creators around the world in
7:12 every market. So they like you know talk
7:14 about our brand in their own voice and
7:16 it's very authentic and the more
7:18 authentic it is the more the LLM
7:20 platforms picks up on this language and
7:23 the more you like you know they create
7:24 demand and virality behind the
7:26 >> I mean how much have has your marketing
7:28 budget changed in terms of going toward
7:29 these influencers on Tik Tok and these
7:32 these authentic users versus where it
7:34 was
7:34 >> yeah I think you know the the marketing
7:37 budget has always been about performance
7:39 marketing and equity but how you using
7:41 the network of creative around the world
7:44 is critical today. So because consumer
7:46 wants an authentic discussion with the
7:49 brand. It's no longer a one-way street
7:50 where the brand tells the consumer what
7:52 to do and what to wear or you know what
7:55 product to use. It is a two-way
7:57 conversation. And so the marketing
7:58 budget has fundamentally evolved and
8:00 today one of the reason why we've
8:02 completely restructured our P&L is to be
8:05 able to fuel back the consumerf facing
8:07 and we've been now on seven consecutive
8:10 quarter of increased investment not only
8:13 to build equity but also to just engage
8:15 with this larger.
8:16 >> How do you compete with the indie brands
8:19 that you know can can they sometimes
8:22 cost less? They're very close to the
8:24 consumer. They're good at social media
8:25 and they catch on to the trends.
8:27 >> Yeah. But so today competing here is the
8:30 perfect example. We're sitting at the
8:31 ordinary store like in so the ordinary
8:34 is actually the ultimate like you know
8:36 indie brand. So when we acquired this
8:39 which is the house of which we're like
8:41 the ordinary part of we kept them in
8:44 [clears throat] the as an indie and what
8:45 we're doing is today we are learning
8:47 from the indie mindset while leveraging
8:49 the scale of the company. So what the
8:51 ordinary is benefiting is the scale of
8:53 the estellar company that operates in
8:55 150 countries around the world.
8:56 Manufacturing network, distribution
8:58 network, you name it. But at the same
9:00 time, the rest of the portfolio of the
9:02 est company is learning from how do you
9:05 get on the trend? How do you launch
9:07 product you know faster? Because one of
9:09 the thing that I said as increasing
9:10 innovation is not only increasing
9:12 innovation is increasing the speed at
9:14 which we're bringing innovation to
9:16 market. This is a brand that can bring
9:18 any product in less than a year,
9:20 sometimes six months to market. And so
9:24 this is like the spirit of what we are
9:26 learning from an esto brand that just
9:28 turned 80 years old that has the scale
9:30 and at the same time an ordinary that
9:32 has the agility. My role with the team
9:34 is to bring everybody under the same
9:36 model.
9:37 >> What about Korean beauty? How much how
9:39 much market share has the Korean players
9:41 brought? I feel like they are on the
9:42 leading edge here. Yeah, Korean beauty
9:45 has been a phenomena, but it's not the
9:46 first time. We've seen J beauty, the
9:48 Japanese brand. We've seen the C beauty
9:49 in China. Now it's the Korean beauty.
9:51 We'll see like I beauty, I think, in the
9:53 future with Indian beauty and many
9:55 others. So, we have actually a Korean
9:57 brand. Dr. Jart is one of the original
9:59 brand like you know in Korea. What the
10:01 Korean brands are doing and even Dr. J
10:04 is the speed of the innovation. But for
10:06 us, it's very important that yes, the
10:08 speed innovation, but we always think
10:10 about recruitment and retention. is not
10:13 innovation for innovation. It is
10:15 innovation to just bring a consumer that
10:16 is going to stay for a long time. So the
10:19 number one KPI that I drive is brand
10:22 love. [snorts] Brand love comes from
10:23 this ability to repeat purchase with the
10:26 consumer. In our industry with such a
10:28 high gross margin, the more you fuel the
10:32 brand love, the more you fuel the
10:34 repeats, the more you can invest and
10:36 like you know continue to just bring
10:37 great innovation and obviously
10:39 profitability.
10:40 >> You mentioned China. Obviously that's
10:41 been key for this the stock and the and
10:43 the performance. You you've called it a
10:45 mature market. Yes.
10:46 >> So how do you win in China and sustain
10:49 this kind of growth?
10:50 >> Yeah. So China being the second largest
10:53 beauty market in the world. When I say
10:54 it's no longer an emerging market is a
10:56 mature market still growing mid mid
10:59 single digit is a lot of additional
11:01 business. It's a lot of new consumers
11:03 that are coming. What we're seeing in
11:05 China is the same phenomenon we're
11:06 seeing everywhere around the world. You
11:08 have an aging population but you still
11:10 have a young population coming and also
11:13 a growing emerging consumer. Remember
11:16 there's 1.4 billion people in China but
11:18 only today I would say 7 to 800 million
11:21 people have access basically like you
11:23 know to regular consumption including
11:25 beauty. So there still new consumers
11:27 lifespan is expanding also in China. So
11:30 we've been in China for more than 30
11:32 years. We've built capabilities there
11:34 from an innovation from a fulfillment
11:36 center but also bringing product for
11:39 China. 30% of our global innovation
11:42 today is developed in China today
11:44 because of the Chinese need
11:45 >> in China for China
11:46 >> in China for China and China for the
11:49 world because we're also bringing some
11:50 of this innovation. Think of things like
11:52 cushion compact. There's been something
11:54 very successful in Asia. Asian consumer
11:57 tend not to use as much liquid
11:58 foundation. they more use touch up
12:00 throughout the day with cash and combine
12:02 has not been the way that consumers done
12:04 it but now we're seeing the trend you
12:06 know coming to this part of the world so
12:07 it allows us to just be you know China
12:10 for China for the world but we have very
12:13 strong position now it's seven quarters
12:14 in a row that we're getting market share
12:16 >> what is your economic read of the
12:18 Chinese consumer right now because that
12:20 that's also been sort of a frustration
12:21 for a lot of global brands the lack of
12:23 spending
12:24 >> I just come back from China where we did
12:26 our capital de market like you know and
12:28 we showed one the operation and the
12:30 quality of the operation of what we've
12:32 done but also the resilience of the
12:33 beauty consumer while there may be some
12:35 discussion about the overall consumer
12:37 sentiment in China the beauty consumer
12:39 is still very strong and we are in an
12:41 industry that is growing mid single
12:43 digit we're growing above the market and
12:45 we've done it for seven consecutive
12:47 quarter and we intend to continue to do
12:49 it so I'm very bullish on the future of
12:51 China but importantly for us part of our
12:54 beauty reimagine is a balanced growth
12:56 around the world so while We may have
12:58 been too dependent on the east in the
13:00 past. Today, my number one mission is
13:04 continue to drive the growth that we
13:06 have in the east, including China, but
13:08 also reacelerate everything that we're
13:10 doing with great innovation, great
13:12 consumer coverage here in the US, but
13:15 also in Europe and throughout the
13:17 emerging markets.
13:17 >> What about the US consumer? What do you
13:19 see right now in terms of value seeeking
13:21 behavior and the fact that, you know,
13:23 there are affordability challenges with
13:25 gas prices and groceries? Where does
13:28 where does that leave the consumer and
13:29 how they view their beauty budgets?
13:31 >> One of the thing I've learned after over
13:33 20 years in New York and more that in
13:35 the US never bet against the American
13:36 consumer. They're very strong and very
13:39 resilient. Beauty is part of their
13:41 regimen. And today we see here in the US
13:44 the same phenomenon we're seeing
13:45 everywhere around the world. The famous
13:47 K economy, the luxury consumers
13:49 extremely resilient. La Mer Labo a very
13:53 very strong brand and growing very
13:55 strongly. But here today we're sitting
13:56 at the ordinary which is a brand that
13:58 has been four consecutive quarter in
14:00 double digit growth and this brand is
14:02 knocking on the door of the billiond
14:04 dollar club with the rest of our brand.
14:06 So we think today the portfolio of the
14:08 company is perfectly designed from the
14:11 most affluent luxury consumer to the
14:13 prestige to the entry prestige consumer
14:15 to be able to sustain like you know the
14:17 demand and while I cannot control the
14:20 macroeconomic environment I can react
14:23 with the brands and the price point and
14:25 innovation.
14:26 >> Well on the price points what what are
14:27 you seeing in terms of cost inflation
14:28 right now with everything that you know
14:30 we've seen tariffs and and higher gas
14:32 and transportation prices. what's
14:35 happening on cost and then does that
14:37 result in higher consumer prices?
14:39 >> The beauty of uh our network is that now
14:42 we have nine manufacturing sites around
14:44 the world. So I've been able to like you
14:46 know navigate some external disruption
14:48 that came from like tariff or inflation
14:50 and this network was always designed to
14:52 be close to the consumer. So we source
14:54 where we make. So it allows us to be
14:57 just like cut a lot of cost. We have not
14:59 passed you know increase to the
15:01 consumer. Over the past year, we have
15:04 barely increases price. So the consumer
15:06 within any of the other company brand
15:08 have not seen price increase. But what
15:10 we're doing is reinvesting in our brands
15:13 to really make sure that again we're
15:14 creating the desiraability that is
15:16 needed
15:16 >> and that and that will continue if as
15:18 long as prices even if they still go up.
15:20 >> Yeah. Part of like you know obviously I
15:22 cannot control what where the
15:24 inflationary environment is going but
15:26 today we have a good part of like you
15:28 know our beauty reimagine. You've seen
15:30 how much we've improved our gross margin
15:32 over the past two years. It's been more
15:34 than 400 basis point of improvement of
15:36 gross margin because of a lot of
15:38 efficiency without necessarily passing
15:40 the higher cost to the consumer.
15:42 >> Yeah. How much are you using AI
15:43 internally and and what's it doing for
15:46 you? Is it productivity or is it is it
15:48 also helping you with innovation and
15:50 growth? So one of the things I said when
15:52 I become CEO is that we are hardwiring
15:54 AI throughout the enterprise in
15:56 marketing in planning in sourcing of the
15:59 insights. So today I see a lot of
16:01 efficiency to free up time for my team
16:04 to ultimately create the magic. We talk
16:07 about in the company about two things
16:09 the math and the magic. The math is
16:11 really what AI is allowing us to do
16:14 create a lot of efficiency. The magic is
16:17 what my team needs to do what we are
16:18 doing day in and day out to delight the
16:20 consumers with new product, new
16:22 campaign, new store like you know
16:24 activation around the world. So there's
16:26 a reason why I always say like AI is
16:30 your best copilot. It is not replacing
16:33 the creativity in any way, shape or
16:35 form. It allows us to be much more
16:36 efficient to be faster in our decision
16:39 making but also source insights from
16:41 everywhere around the world. uh but so
16:43 we have it today in supply chain in
16:45 marketing in HR through art and we will
16:48 continue to use it to create more
16:49 efficiency. I mean the stock has come
16:51 back a lot but it still is you know well
16:53 off of historical highs. I I do wonder
16:56 in terms of use of cash why dividends
16:58 and buybacks are a good use of capital
17:00 at a time where you could be reinvesting
17:02 that more into the business for growth.
17:04 >> Yeah. So today look I don't follow the
17:06 stock like you know every day obviously
17:08 I have to worry about it but we are here
17:10 for the long run you know we are running
17:12 a marathon we're not running a sprint
17:14 you know the recovery of stock is
17:16 important but us being able to reignite
17:19 growth by reinvesting in the business
17:21 cutting fixed cost will improve our
17:23 overall profitability over time and you
17:26 saw as part of our capital dem market
17:28 experience last week we communicated our
17:30 2030 ambition it is a bold ambition it
17:33 is one that is just going to bring us
17:35 back to historical high in term of
17:36 profitability between 16.5 and 18.5
17:40 operating margin. This is really strong
17:43 ambition but it is also for us by we are
17:46 doing it by investing in the business
17:48 investing in growth. Today it's about
17:50 growth cost efficiency and investing in
17:52 the consumer through like you know great
17:54 innovation and great companies as well.
17:56 >> Do you feel that the investors that you
17:57 talk to get it understand how big of a
17:59 change the organization has been
18:01 through? I think you know from the
18:02 discussion I've had with analysts and
18:04 investors last week I think everybody
18:06 realized it's a enormous change. It's a
18:09 bold change that we've done for the for
18:11 the company on its 80th anniversary. I
18:13 think we've never been so agile faster
18:16 you know really to just capture like you
18:18 know the trend and the future of like
18:19 you know the beauty growth and I feel
18:21 very good about this ambition that we've
18:23 put out there and my team and I we are
18:25 all ready to just like you know go and
18:27 delight our consumers around the world.
18:29 >> All right. So what's the what's the
18:30 hottest trend right now? The hottest
18:31 beauty trend.
18:32 >> I think one of the hottest trend is
18:33 longevity. I think we're all going to
18:35 live longer, but we also live want to
18:38 live better. So one of the things
18:39 >> we all want to look younger
18:40 >> and we don't want to look younger. So
18:42 the Estellar brand has launched actually
18:44 a lot of product on longevity. There's a
18:46 new uh reutri estive cream called age
18:50 reversal that is really allowing us to
18:52 just like you know reverse aging. And
18:54 this is one thing that consumers are
18:56 focusing on. It's interesting at a time
18:58 where everybody's talking about the
18:59 younger consumer and we are laser
19:01 focused on the brand like the ordinary
19:03 to do it. But there's also like you know
19:05 the aging population
19:07 between now and 2050 the number of
19:10 consumers around the world above 65
19:12 years old will double to 1.5 billion.
19:14 This is a mega mega trend for beauty and
19:17 being able to tap in longevity which
19:19 we've been pioneer for the last 20 years
19:21 is I believe a big big trend.
19:23 >> Helping them not age would be I guess
19:25 the holy grail then. It is absolutely
19:27 the holy grail and I'm happy that the
19:28 est company is going to help them to do
19:30 so.
19:31 >> Okay, Stefan, thank you so much.
19:32 >> Thank you so much. Appreciate it.
Market Midday: Stocks Lower, Nvidia Falls, Treasury Flags Commerce Over China Chips full transcript
0:01 CNBC business news update market midday.
0:04 I'm Jessica Edinger. Major averages all
0:06 in the red on this Friday afternoon,
0:08 although they are on pace for a winning
0:10 week. Nvidia shares are sliding again
0:13 today. Let's start with the Dow. It's
0:16 down 86 points. Cisco shares, they're
0:19 down almost 6%, dragging the Dow lower.
0:22 Nvidia down three and a half% this
0:25 afternoon. The S&P 500 index falling 61
0:28 points. That's 8/10en of a percent. The
0:31 Nasdaq is down 335 points, 1.3%.
0:36 Most all of the chip makers are in the
0:38 red this afternoon. AMD plunging 10%.
0:41 One name is in the green. Cerebrous
0:44 Systems up 8%. Treasury Secretary Scott
0:48 Bessent on CNBC blaming Howard Lutnik's
0:51 Commerce Department for Nvidia chip
0:53 leakage to China. Here's CNBC's Aean
0:56 Jaffers. There's a real split now inside
0:58 the Trump administration over how
1:00 Nvidia's partner Mega Speed was treated
1:02 by the US government and whether more
1:04 scrutiny should have been placed on the
1:06 potential for illegal shipments of
1:08 advanced chips to China. Treasury
1:10 Secretary Scott Bessant was on CNBC this
1:12 morning and pointed the finger directly
1:14 at the Commerce Department, which of
1:16 course is run by Secretary Howard Levik.
1:18 I can tell you there was coordination.
1:20 Tre, Treasury, WAR, USR, and state, they
1:25 were in favor of putting megaspe on the
1:28 entity list for months. The uh but
1:30 commerce has the pin. Commerce BIS has
1:33 the pin.
1:34 >> Secretary Howard Lutnik is now scheduled
1:36 to testify about all this on Capitol
1:38 Hill in December. That announcement came
1:40 amid a swirl of news reports that senior
1:42 Trump administration officials are
1:44 considering Lutnik's future at the
1:46 Department of Commerce.
1:48 >> Former Nvidia CEO Jensen Wong, who has
1:51 resigned under a cloud of scandal
1:53 related to an affair with an executive
1:55 at a customer Mega Speed, had pushed to
1:58 ease restrictions on the export of
2:00 advanced AI chips to China. Here's a
2:03 take from Evercore ISI Sarah Bianke on
2:06 CNBC. There's a lot of concerns on a
2:09 national security grounds and obviously
2:12 the leaking and such and even Vesson's
2:14 comments, you know, don't give you a lot
2:16 of comfort uh here. If if they were told
2:19 to be uh putting these companies on the
2:21 entity list and didn't, uh that is a
2:23 real uh a real concern and and why
2:25 didn't it happen? Inflation at the
2:27 wholesale level rose last month 3/10en
2:30 of a percent putting the annual rate at
2:33 6 and a half% the highest in nearly four
2:36 years in the PPI producer price index
2:38 for October. This after a consumer read
2:41 that was hotter than expected that came
2:43 out earlier this week. Here's Chicago
2:45 Fed President Austin Goulsby on CNBC.
2:48 >> These have been signs of trouble. We've
2:50 had some signs of trouble now for
2:52 several months in a row. Um, if you look
2:55 at how broad-based the inflation is,
2:59 it's not just that we're above the
3:01 target and have been for for some time,
3:04 it's that in categories that are not
3:07 driven by oil prices and not driven by
3:10 tariffs, you're still seeing stalled
3:13 progress and in some cases going the
3:15 wrong way. Open AI launching a chat GPT
3:19 wallet allowing its DOTS agent to make
3:22 purchases for you with your permission.
3:25 It's only available to pro subscribers
3:27 though who are 18 years old. Open AAI
3:30 has partnered with MX Mastercard and
3:32 Visa for this product. Microsoft says
3:35 email delivery and service availability
3:37 is improving today across more of its
3:39 infrastructure after yesterday's outage
3:41 that virtually shut down Outlook teams
3:44 and 365. The company says it does not
3:46 suspect malicious activity was the
3:48 cause. Today's Friday the 13th.
Squawk Pod: Treasury Secretary Bessent: ‘F’ the Iranian leadership full transcript
0:00 Bring in show music, please.
0:04 >> Hi, I'm CNBC producer Katie Kramer.
0:07 Today on Squawk Pod, the story of the
0:10 week, Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang's
0:13 departure and the drama.
0:14 >> If our reporter [music] in Beijing can
0:16 go out and find a smuggler to talk to
0:18 about these things, how come our
0:19 government couldn't?
0:20 >> Author of the Nvidia way, a history of
0:23 the company told through more than 100
0:25 interviews with Wong and others. Take
0:27 him. It's complete shock. I've been
0:30 talking to Nvidia employees all week and
0:32 they're disappointed. They're angry and
0:34 it's utter disbelief.
0:35 >> The company culture [music] that made
0:37 Nvidia and how important it is for
0:39 shareholders to preserve it.
0:41 >> That's his management style. He berates
0:43 and insults them. That's the [music] way
0:45 he kind of pressures them to come up
0:47 with miracles and and better
0:49 performance.
0:50 >> Then Treasury Secretary Scott Bessant.
0:53 Did Jensen Hang risk national security
0:56 in his extrammarital affair and what was
0:58 the administration's role in shutting it
1:00 down?
1:01 >> I think that there is a lot of [music]
1:03 uh leakage in the system and we are
1:06 constantly uh working to close that down
1:09 >> where he sees markets going.
1:11 >> I spent a lot of time on financial
1:13 stability in my career [music] and
1:16 there's nothing that's setting off any
1:17 alarm bells for me right now.
1:19 >> And he has moved into military housing.
1:22 his message to those watching.
1:23 >> You know what I got to say, Joe, is f
1:25 the Iranian leadership. I'm not going to
1:27 be coward that they have initiated death
1:30 threats against me.
1:32 >> It's Friday, the 13th of November, 2026.
1:36 Squawk Pod begins right now.
1:39 >> Stand back by in 3 2 1. Cure, please.
1:44 >> Good morning, everybody. Welcome to
1:46 Squawkbox right here on CNBC. We are
1:48 live from the NASDAQ markets and NASDAQ
1:51 market site. Let's say I'm Becky Quake
1:53 along with Joe Kernan and Andrew Ross
1:55 Orcin. And the big news is it's Friday,
1:57 folks. We've actually made it here.
1:59 Forget about the 13. We'll take that as
2:00 a lucky day. But it is Friday and we
2:02 have made it to this point so far. So,
2:04 yay for us.
2:05 >> We got shares of Invidia this morning.
2:07 Let's show you where they stand. That
2:09 stock fell as much as 14% yesterday, but
2:11 recovered uh to the end of the day. Just
2:13 about down about 4% uh in total. $1.7
2:17 trillion though of Nvidia's market cap
2:19 has been wiped out since the stock's
2:21 peak last month. And now lawmakers are
2:23 eager to get former CEO Jensen Wong to
2:26 DC for testimony on the scandal that led
2:28 to his ouster. We learned earlier
2:30 yesterday that Wong has agreed to
2:32 testify before Thanksgiving. Meanwhile,
2:35 the Select Committee on China gave Wong
2:37 a deadline now of 8:00 tonight to accept
2:40 an interview request or it said it would
2:42 subpoena him. Wong has hired law firm
2:45 Paul Weiss in the wake of that scandal.
2:47 This all comes as Reuters now reported
2:49 that Wong had an intimate relationship
2:51 with a second Nvidia uh employee.
2:54 Uh that's on top of the original
2:58 employee and on top of the potential
3:00 spy. President Trump calling Wong's
3:03 downfall, in his words, a horrible
3:05 thing. Uh the president told
3:07 conservative commentator Hugh Hwitt uh
3:09 the US would be in bad shape if it lost
3:12 its edge in AI. Nvidia replacing Wong
3:15 with CFO Colette Crest in a interim on
3:18 an interim basis. This is and the Wall
3:20 Street Journal now saying earlier this
3:22 summer Wong said during a meeting that
3:24 Crest wasn't someone who could help him
3:27 define a strategy or make decisions. is
3:29 there's been some other reporting out
3:31 there uh that uh she doesn't have a
3:33 great relationship with his children uh
3:36 at the company. So uh the soap opera if
3:40 it if it is a soap opera continues.
3:43 >> Yeah. it um the anecdotal uh sort of the
3:48 Andrew the narrative about a a meeting
3:52 recent meeting I guess maybe not that
3:53 recent with uh with Crest and it it
3:55 almost sounded like like um Jensen
3:59 didn't really take her seriously almost
4:01 in terms of overall strategy and and
4:03 felt uncomfortable giving her um you
4:06 know too much
4:07 >> authority and making the big
4:09 >> and now she's been the person
4:11 >> Yeah.
4:11 >> Yeah.
4:14 and some you know sad you know I read
4:16 Jensen and and we we knew this but he
4:18 must be I mean you we I don't think we
4:20 can imagine after 30 years and founding
4:23 the company what what it must feel like
4:26 uh Andrew and Becky at this point to you
4:30 hopefully you know I guess
4:32 >> it's a fall from grace
4:33 >> it's a it's a fall from grace and
4:35 >> it's tough no matter how
4:36 >> it's not just the fall from grace from
4:38 from video but from everything I hear of
4:40 all the people that I know that are
4:41 around him. It's really what's happened
4:43 with his family that's that's on his end
4:46 that's made that's that's been the
4:49 emotional roller coaster this
4:52 >> the devil comes from you when you're
4:53 right on on top. I think who Denzel told
4:57 Will Smith that. Meanwhile, President
5:00 Trump telling sports cer A. Smith it's
5:02 not yet clear whether Alice Wong was in
5:06 fact a Chinese spy. That message was
5:08 echoed yesterday by Attorney General
5:10 Todd Blanch. But according to
5:12 investigative findings shared with CNBC
5:14 by private intelligence firm Tasari Wang
5:18 um uh the the female Wang may have owned
5:22 stakes in firms in China that benefited
5:25 tech giant Huawei at the same time she
5:26 was in business with Nvidia and
5:29 romantically involved with Jensen. uh
5:31 Wong. One report said a network of
5:33 companies tied to Alice Wong recently
5:35 invested in deepseek in an effort to
5:38 create a pathway to funnel advanced
5:40 Nvidia Blackwell chips to Chinese AI
5:44 companies. And it it certainly looks
5:46 like some of those made their way to uh
5:49 >> I mean I think that's the bigger
5:51 question here is how have we policed
5:53 these um
5:54 >> Oh yeah.
5:56 >> Yeah.
5:56 >> Any of these export controls? How
5:58 effective have they been? how much of
6:00 Nvidia's sales um if not directly how
6:04 much indirectly have have been
6:06 [clears throat]
6:07 going to China and that's going to be
6:08 the question for the company um going
6:11 forward
6:11 >> and the whole idea about whether we want
6:14 to be the
6:17 custom or the the maker of the world's
6:20 chips and or do they what's better do
6:23 they should they have their own
6:24 ecosystem to make all the chips
6:27 >> I I would assume that China's goal is to
6:30 eventually have their own ecosystem to
6:31 use ours
6:32 >> could lag behind. Yeah. Or I mean they
6:35 steal everything, right? Couldn't they
6:37 figure out how to
6:39 >> I mean the technology I'm sure they
6:41 could figure it out.
6:41 >> Can you use these databases remotely,
6:43 right? If there's a database that's a
6:45 data center that's based in well that is
6:47 happening Malaysia, right? they're using
6:49 those things. And then the question is
6:51 how directly go through and I I think
6:53 Ununice Yun brought us our our best
6:56 story yesterday where she had actually
6:57 spoken with a smuggler who talked about
6:59 the price going up for these chips
7:01 because the assumption is it's going to
7:03 be a lot harder to get your hands on
7:04 these things. If our reporter in Beijing
7:07 can go out and find a smuggler to talk
7:09 to about these things, how come our
7:10 government couldn't? How come anybody
7:12 who's supposed to actually be policing
7:14 these exports control has a tougher time
7:16 than Ununice Yun does going out and
7:17 finding some of this information? And I
7:19 think those are some of the big
7:20 questions and those are the implications
7:21 of what this means for the stock from
7:22 here.
7:24 >> I was going to say Becky, I think the
7:25 complicated part and I think you put
7:27 your your finger on it is not only that
7:30 but you had uh the company Nvidia
7:33 blessing mega speed. In fact, there was
7:35 several times where they they
7:37 effectively said they looked into it
7:38 themselves. So here you have a situation
7:41 where as as you said if Ununice can find
7:43 the smugglers um if these if there's any
7:46 evidence at all that anyone inside the
7:48 company either looked the other way or
7:49 sort of thought one thing and then said
7:51 another thing then then the whole thing
7:53 sort of opens up into a whole other
7:55 terrible place.
7:56 >> Yeah. And that's that's the what we just
7:59 don't know yet about where things go.
8:01 And that explains the stock's reaction
8:03 yesterday. Um, you know, on top of
8:05 Jensen being removed, Jensen Wong
8:07 stepping down, resigning, being removed,
8:10 and not knowing what the longerterm
8:12 implications are uh for the company's
8:13 strategy as a result because in its 33
8:16 years, he's been the only u CEO of the
8:19 company. You can see this morning that
8:20 Nvidia shares are up by about 3%. Um,
8:23 year-to- date still down 8%. And you
8:25 look at that decline over the last week
8:27 or so. Uh, that Wong saga enveloping
8:30 commerce secretary Howard Lutnik as
8:32 well. Lutnik coming under fire within
8:35 the Trump administration for his efforts
8:37 to try and slow restrictions on US chip
8:39 chip exports. A report earlier yesterday
8:42 said that some in the White House were
8:43 discussing whether Lutnik should be
8:45 pushed out of the administration. The
8:47 White House said that President Trump
8:48 maintains complete confidence in Lutnik.
8:51 And we'll see.
8:55 Nvidia [music] investors are awaiting a
8:56 permanent replacement for Jensen Wong.
8:58 Joining us right now with a look at the
9:00 company's road forward is Take Him. He
9:02 is the founder of the key context
9:04 Substack. He's also the author of the
9:06 2024 book, The Nvidia Way, a history of
9:10 the company and its founder through more
9:11 than a hundred direct interviews with
9:13 Jensen Wong, his co-founders, early
9:15 backers, early employees, and others.
9:18 And Tay, it's great to have you here.
9:19 >> It's great to be here.
9:20 >> You know, welcome back to CNBC. Good to
9:22 see you again. [laughter]
9:24 Let's talk a little bit about what's
9:25 happened this week because you know this
9:27 company, you know this man incredibly
9:29 well. I suppose you were just as
9:31 surprised as the rest of us.
9:33 >> It's complete shock. I've been talking
9:35 to Nvidia employees all week and they're
9:37 disappointed. They're angry and it's
9:39 utter disbelief. Uh for one of the
9:43 greatest CEOs in American history, for
9:46 his tenure to end in this way is just
9:48 incredible and it's unbelievable.
9:50 >> Yeah. 33 years um as a co-founder of the
9:53 company, the only CEO that the company's
9:55 ever known. Um, in your book in 2024,
9:58 you said that this company would be lost
10:00 without Jensen. I think you've changed
10:02 your mind at this point.
10:03 >> Yeah. Um, it's been two and a half years
10:05 since since I've written the book and a
10:08 lot of people have cited those passages
10:10 saying, you know, the video way Tay said
10:13 this and Nvidia would would be dead
10:16 without Jensen. And I've evolved my
10:19 thinking. Um, I've met more people and
10:23 the company is in different stage at
10:25 this point. Did you evolve your thinking
10:26 before Sunday night?
10:28 >> Yes. Yes. Yes.
10:29 >> Okay. So, explain what what kind of got
10:31 you to that point.
10:32 >> Um I I did more I did I've been
10:34 following the company the last few years
10:36 meeting all the kind of mid-level
10:38 executives, senior executives, going to
10:40 different conferences and I do think
10:42 there's a deep talented bench here. I
10:44 mean, no one's going to replace Jensen,
10:46 but three or four people might be able
10:48 to do what he does today.
10:49 >> What about Colette Crest who's in the
10:51 position as interim CEO right now?
10:53 >> I think she's excellent. I used to talk
10:54 to her every quarter for years. She'll
10:57 do a great job in uh managing the
11:00 finances. She's one of the best CFOs
11:02 ever and she's going to do a fine job uh
11:05 in on the interimm basis. But I don't
11:07 think she's going to be the permanent
11:08 CEO.
11:08 >> Why not?
11:09 >> Um I think for a job like Nvidia where
11:12 it's disruption, innovation, you have to
11:14 be have your finger on top of all these
11:16 technology trends, you need a CEO that
11:18 has uh more technical expertise.
11:21 >> And I think she'll do great. um managing
11:24 the supply chain and doing the numbers.
11:26 But there are two ideas I think that if
11:30 the board chooses these two people,
11:32 Nvidia can continue to be successful.
11:34 >> The two ideas are
11:35 >> uh ARM CEO Renee Hos and the internal
11:38 candidate I I believe that will do a
11:40 great job is Ian Buck who heads their
11:43 hypers scale business.
11:44 >> We'll talk more about those in just a
11:46 moment. Andrew, you have a quick
11:46 question.
11:47 >> Okay. I was curious, you know, the Wall
11:49 Street Journal had this report that the
11:51 relationship
11:52 uh between what is now going to be the
11:55 new CEO and Jensen uh could be tense at
11:59 times and that without overstating it,
12:01 it appeared that he had a dim view of
12:04 her view of her ability uh to make or
12:08 help him make big strategic decisions.
12:11 There was also a report in the
12:12 information that suggested that her
12:13 relationship with his kids uh was
12:16 strained and quite complicated. Um what
12:19 do you know about all of that?
12:21 >> So I laughed when I read that article
12:23 because that's exactly the way Jensen uh
12:26 treats his executives for the last 33
12:28 years. That's his management style. He
12:31 berates and insults them uh when they
12:33 present something and then he instills
12:36 fear the the fear of God. our company's
12:39 gonna go bankrupt in 30 days. Like
12:42 you're completely incompetent. And
12:44 that's the way he kind of um pressures
12:47 them to come up with miracles and and
12:49 better performance. That's just the way
12:51 he he uh manages meetings. He's
12:54 hyperbolic,
12:55 pressures people, curses them out. That
12:58 that's just the way he manages people.
12:59 So that's been like that for 33 years.
13:01 So I I didn't think that was any
13:03 different from the way he uh treats his
13:06 executives in the past. Let's talk. I
13:08 mean, that's a longer story there, but
13:09 we're almost out of time. And I do want
13:11 to get back to uh Renee Hos, the ARM CEO
13:14 who was at Nvidia until 2013. Why do you
13:17 think that he's the one for the role
13:18 potentially?
13:19 >> So, he has great uh CEO public facing
13:21 skills. He's well respected inside
13:23 Nvidia. Uh multiple people told me when
13:25 he was at Nvidia, they loved working for
13:27 him. He was on the ball, did a ton of
13:30 preparation, and he has a grasp of uh
13:32 the technology trends. So I I think he
13:34 has a skill set that he'll do a great
13:36 job. Um I think he has to ret uh whoever
13:39 is the CEO has to retain the top three
13:41 two three people Colette Ian Buck and
13:44 Jonah Albam who heads GPU engineering.
13:47 But if the CEO retains the top bench the
13:50 deep bench that they have I think Nvidia
13:52 will continue to be successful. And the
13:54 stock is so cheap right now it's 11
13:56 times. It's the cheapest it's ever been
13:57 in 15 years. And even if you haircut the
14:00 70% you have revenue growth next year to
14:02 say 50 to 40%.
14:05 >> I mean the stock works because it's been
14:07 being down so much.
14:08 >> Take him Tay. [music] Thank you.
14:11 >> Keys will be next.
14:13 >> Coming up on Squawk Pod, Treasury
14:15 Secretary Scott Bessent with questions
14:17 of his own when it comes to Nvidia's spy
14:19 scandal. Did Nvidia know their client
14:23 and was there a robust [music] uh effort
14:26 the at Nvidia to make sure that there
14:29 was no leakage and [music] that they
14:31 were selling to what were obviously
14:33 passed through shell companies and I
14:35 [music] think it's important that anyone
14:37 at the company there be held accountable
14:39 for that.
14:45 >> This is Squawkpot from CNBC.
14:48 You're watching Squawkbox right here on
14:50 CNBC. I'm Becky Quick along with Joe
14:52 Kernan and Andrew Ross Sorcin.
14:54 >> And now to the news maker of the hour,
14:56 Treasury Secretary Scott Bessant. Mr.
14:59 Treasury Secretary, welcome. Good to see
15:00 you.
15:01 >> Joe, good to see you.
15:03 >> What can you tell us uh just right out
15:06 off the bat, Mr. secretary about um your
15:08 quarters, where where you are, where
15:11 you're maybe you don't want to tell us
15:13 anything, but can you just fill us in on
15:14 on uh the situation you find yourself in
15:17 and and and how that played out?
15:20 >> Uh yeah, Joe, you know what I got to
15:21 say, Joe, is f the Iranian leadership.
15:24 The I'm not going to be coward. Uh that
15:27 they have initiated death threats
15:30 against me. Uh the other members of the
15:32 cabinet were not going to be coward. And
15:34 it means what we are doing with
15:36 operation economic outcast is working.
15:39 And you know what? Why am I going to be
15:41 afraid when our the brave military
15:44 personnel in the Gulf, President Trump
15:46 constantly receives death threats and
15:49 you know what we are doing is working
15:51 and the the IRGC they're they're like a
15:54 dangerous [clears throat] cornered
15:56 animal. So, uh, I follow the Secret
15:58 Service, uh, instructions and have moved
16:01 from my home, uh, to a military base.
16:03 And what I will tell you, Joe, the, uh,
16:05 I I do want to say that one of the
16:07 reasons I've had to move is because the
16:09 Wall Street Journal printed a photo of
16:11 my house the day I bought it. The, uh,
16:14 that has geoloccate on it. And in a
16:16 highly irresponsible way, the editor,
16:19 the we pleaded with her not to uh, print
16:22 the location of my house, but she did
16:24 anyway. highly irresponsible and
16:27 dangerous and things like that have to
16:29 stop too.
16:30 >> Let's turn to if we have time we we'll
16:33 try and get back to uh what's happening
16:35 in Iran. But I guess you've noticed
16:38 something that the financial media has
16:40 been focused on uh this week and the
16:42 markets and the world and um and that is
16:46 what what's happening with Jensen Wong
16:48 uh and Nvidia. There have been reports
16:51 that there was some tension between you
16:53 and and Secretary Lutnik about why um
16:57 Mega Speed was not placed on the entity
17:00 list and and I I'm just wondering about
17:02 the inter agency coordination. Could
17:04 Treasury have done that? Was it was it
17:07 only um
17:10 you know Lutnik that could have commerce
17:13 that could have done that? What what
17:14 about the coordination?
17:16 >> Uh yes. Well, I I can tell you there was
17:18 coordination. Tre, Treasury, Ward, USR,
17:22 and state, they were in favor of putting
17:26 megaspe on the entity list for months.
17:29 The uh but commerce has the pin.
17:31 Commerce BIS has the pin and you will
17:33 have to have to ask them about their
17:35 internal processes.
17:37 >> Have you been frustrated, Secretary
17:39 Bessant, by um potential delays with
17:42 this? We had our our correspondent in
17:45 Beijing, Ununice Yun, yesterday gave a
17:47 report where she had found a smuggler um
17:49 in in Beijing or in China and talked to
17:52 them about chips that were available and
17:54 how much more expensive they were
17:55 yesterday on the concern that the expert
17:58 controls were going to get much more
18:00 stringent than they've been to this
18:01 point. Have you been frustrated to this
18:03 point with how they've been enforced?
18:05 Well, the Becky, I I am frustrated when
18:09 you President Trump made it very clear
18:11 that uh China should not receive any
18:14 Nvidia chips above H100s and so any
18:18 leakage is very frustrating because it
18:21 hurts the uh our uh hurts our great
18:24 companies in the AI race gives the uh
18:27 the Chinese an advantage. Couldn't you
18:32 do do you expect that Treasury will do
18:34 something with through the Office of
18:36 Foreign Assets Control and and just take
18:39 it upon Treasury yourself to uh to get
18:42 involved if you don't see it from from
18:44 commerce?
18:45 >> Yeah, Joe, the the OFAC has no control
18:49 over the things like this in in terms of
18:53 e exports. uh you know this is the a BIS
18:57 decision and you know per perhaps the
19:00 FTC could put something on their
19:02 restrictive list.
19:03 >> We are unable to ask Secretary Lutnik
19:05 what what his plans are and what
19:06 happened. We can only we can only ask
19:09 you what was is was there an incident
19:12 where you confronted uh Secretary Lutnik
19:14 and said what what is going on and and
19:17 why did you not do this and now look
19:19 look how everything has come back
19:21 >> on the administration at this point.
19:23 Yeah, Joe, we we we don't repeat
19:25 conversations in the situation room.
19:28 >> Uh, okay. I I have seen though that uh I
19:32 I guess some reporting that that it
19:35 happened and then I think the
19:36 administration said that you don't know
19:38 what you're talking about. So, you can't
19:39 confirm uh one way or another, but you
19:41 think it should be done at this point.
19:43 And if you were Secretary of Commerce,
19:46 you would do things differently.
19:48 Uh I'm not going to say if I were
19:50 Secretary of Commerce. I'm going to say
19:51 as a Treasury Secretary uh Treasury and
19:55 the my deputy has been pushing for this
19:57 for months the at the deputies level.
20:00 >> Does the way that we're doing it now
20:02 whether you know where they're we're
20:04 sharing revenues and uh it's not a
20:06 strict embargo is that working
20:08 everywhere else would you say? Does that
20:10 need to change to to a to to a more
20:13 strict ban? Do you expect Congress to
20:15 take a look at this and and will that
20:17 force their hand? They've got a lot of
20:19 uh proposals that they're they're
20:20 considering.
20:21 >> Yeah, Joe, I think we have all the
20:23 authorities that we need. They just need
20:25 to be implemented. And you know what
20:27 what I would say is you know up to up to
20:29 the H100s that the that's not a
20:33 technological advantage. While Huawei
20:35 has a combination of chips that can be
20:38 put together to get to H100 level. uh it
20:42 kind of looks like a Borg uh uses a lot
20:44 more electricity, much less efficient.
20:47 So by selling them H100s, there's no
20:50 advantage. And you know, I would say
20:52 that all the authorities that we need
20:54 exist. Would you I guess you'd be
20:56 hesitant to comment on what Secretary
20:59 Letic thinking or or whether he it had
21:03 to do with not you know not making the
21:05 trade war with China worse or c he knew
21:08 how close Jensen Wong was uh to the
21:11 president. Did that go into his
21:13 thinking? What do you think was behind
21:15 the the inability to to do what probably
21:18 Okay, then let me ask you. Do you think
21:20 that uh that that higher level chips
21:23 have made it uh to China through Mega
21:26 Speed? I mean obviously it's not sitting
21:28 in Singapore. Those chips probably went
21:30 somewhere, didn't they?
21:32 >> Well, I I think that there is a lot of
21:35 leakage the uh in the system and we are
21:38 constantly uh working to close that
21:41 down. And you know, one one thing here
21:44 is, you know, the the story has been
21:46 thus far on Jensen Wong's personal
21:48 foyables. The the real story here should
21:52 be uh did Nvidia know their client and
21:56 was there a robust uh effort the at
22:00 Nvidia to make sure uh that there was no
22:03 leakage and the that they were selling
22:06 to what were obviously passed through
22:08 shell companies. And I think it's
22:10 important that anyone at the company
22:12 there be held accountable for that.
22:16 >> Mr. Secretary, what what would the
22:18 situation be if you found out that
22:20 someone at the company knew that these
22:22 were passed through shell entities?
22:23 There was a Bloomberg report earlier
22:25 this week that suggested the general
22:27 counsel at NVIDIA
22:29 called up the commerce department and
22:31 intervened on behalf or a asked if the
22:34 United States was behind Alice Wong at
22:37 mega speed being detained at one point I
22:41 think in in Singapore or Malaysia. Um,
22:45 what would it be if it if it found out
22:48 that that they did not investigate
22:50 clearly or if it found out that they
22:52 even knew that this was a pass through
22:54 company? What would the repercussions be
22:55 for the company?
22:56 >> Well, I I'm not going to speculate on
22:58 what the repercussions would be. But,
23:00 you know, let's just say if this were
23:02 was happening, then there were not
23:04 robust controls at the the company. And,
23:07 you know, we we don't know the for a
23:10 fact that Jensen Wong knew this. uh you
23:13 know the the GC seems to have been very
23:15 involved here uh probably should have
23:18 done more oversight rather than the uh
23:21 heranging and I am sure that the board
23:24 now having woken up to what's going on
23:26 is going to do a thorough investigation
23:29 and you let let me just say here too
23:32 that Nvidia is a fantastic company and
23:34 as we saw uh Apple and Steve Jobs you
23:38 can move on to the founder and Tim Cook
23:41 at Apple took Apple to new heights. So,
23:45 you know, I I think all these things
23:46 have a cycle. Uh Jensen Wong was an
23:49 incredible innovator and you know, I I
23:52 believe President Trump has praised him
23:54 for his innovation.
23:56 what at this point the tension between
23:59 wanting China to be a customer for for
24:04 uh for Nvidia or or for any of the
24:07 companies that are involved in AI at
24:08 this point versus not wanting them to be
24:12 able to get our technology that they're
24:14 going to steal it anyway. Are are they
24:16 customers or do we do we want them to
24:18 have their own ecosystem? Where does
24:20 that stand right now? Is it somewhere in
24:22 in the middle?
24:23 >> Well, Joe, I I don't think there's any
24:25 tension. We've been very clear and we've
24:27 drawn a line at the Nvidia H100 chips
24:32 and in terms of being customers uh they
24:36 can buy what's further down the tech
24:38 stack they they do and you know that
24:41 that's fine. If they want to innovate
24:43 domestically they can do that too. uh
24:46 the you the the great companies here in
24:48 the US whether it's Nvidia a AMD uh our
24:53 frontier labs are giving us uh by far
24:56 the lead in the SI race and we're we're
25:00 going to continue that. Do you think
25:02 that the president should raise this
25:04 issue with she Xiinping next week and
25:09 this is obviously you mentioned the
25:10 journal already and I I know you're not
25:13 happy with the journal but um they point
25:16 out that Joe Biden didn't mention the
25:18 balloon and and didn't hold them uh to
25:21 account for for the spy balloon and that
25:24 it would be a mistake if the president
25:26 didn't bring it up uh with Xiinping and
25:28 they go on to say don't fall for your
25:30 own honey trap. Uh, Mr. President, by by
25:33 not bringing it up. You think that he
25:35 should?
25:36 >> Uh, yeah. I think the uh, look, I I like
25:39 the other side of the paper a lot. I
25:41 think the editorial crew over there, the
25:44 is fantastic as opposed to the news
25:46 department, uh, which is the TMZ of
25:49 financial news these days. Uh, but, you
25:51 know, I I would say that I think in that
25:53 editorial they're they're wrong. uh
25:55 because uh what what what is there to
25:58 bring up that you there was a breach the
26:01 uh protocols and we're we're going to
26:03 make sure that the breach doesn't occur
26:05 again. Well, we have you here the um
26:08 we'll maybe return to uh inv video
26:10 because it's u it's it's quite a quite a
26:14 soap opa but we did have an election
26:16 believe it or not and do you think that
26:18 there was anything that in reading the
26:21 the exit polls or in trying to analyze
26:23 what happened will there be any change
26:25 in in the fiscal uh policy the tax
26:29 policy the tariff policy of the
26:32 administration
26:34 following the what was a pretty bad
26:36 drubbing.
26:38 >> Uh Joe, look that the American people
26:41 have spoken and um you know we we see
26:44 that postcoid post the Biden inflation
26:47 of 22% that uh the the American people
26:51 they uh are rightly uh ve very skittish.
26:55 Uh we the underlying economy is very
26:58 strong. We had 3.4% growth last quarter.
27:02 Atlanta Fed GDP now shows 3.5% this
27:06 quarter. We had a blowout jobs number.
27:08 We're bringing back manufacturing. But
27:11 I've always said what I'm not going to
27:12 do is tell the American people how they
27:14 feel. And you know, I think our our job
27:18 is to make sure that they feel the uh
27:21 these good numbers in their personal
27:23 lives. And I think they will. With with
27:26 the Iran conflict, we have a short-term
27:28 spike in energy prices. It's supply
27:32 constrained, but you've already seen uh
27:34 oil's down $20 this month. Gasoline's
27:37 back below $4. Uh diesel is down 10%.
27:41 So, you know, I I think once we get this
27:44 behind us, the American people will be
27:46 able to feel the strength of the
27:48 economy.
27:49 >> Mr. Secretary, with Iran, uh the
27:51 president just yesterday saying that he
27:53 doesn't think we need a deal with Iran
27:55 and redirecting the vice president JD
27:57 Vance saying u pulling him out of the
27:59 negotiations with Iran. Where do things
28:00 stand? How do you see that situation at
28:02 this point?
28:03 >> Uh, as I said earlier, uh, we we are
28:07 squeezing the regime. I think that they
28:09 are panicked in what they're seeing. For
28:11 the first time, Becky, since they began
28:14 producing oil, they have no oil on the
28:16 water. They have no revenues. And we we
28:20 have cut them off. Uh, and I think when
28:23 everyone says that sanctions don't work,
28:26 well, I can tell you what works is you
28:28 have a six-w week kinetic war where you
28:30 destroy Iran's navy, their air force,
28:34 uh, a substantial portion of their
28:36 missiles and drones. Importantly, you
28:37 destroy about 85 or 90% of their ability
28:41 to reconstitute those. Then you put up
28:44 the the iron blockade and our naval
28:47 blockade. Nothing's going in, nothing's
28:49 coming out. And then uh in August I
28:53 implemented operation economic outcast
28:56 and we are isolating the regime like no
28:58 one's ever been isolating before. We're
29:00 getting cooperation from our Gulf
29:01 partners and for those financial
29:04 institutions who haven't cooperated. Uh
29:06 we have sanctioned three banks. We will
29:09 not hesitate to do it again. We have cut
29:12 them off uh for most of their airline
29:15 flights. So, you know, when the regime
29:17 members want to go see their relatives
29:18 in London, their girlfriends in Paris
29:20 and visit their money in Geneva, they
29:22 can't. So, they better love their
29:24 country cuz they're stuck there. And it
29:26 is falling apart around them. 200%
29:28 inflation. They've already warned the
29:30 people that there's going to be a gas
29:32 shortage, a gas shortage in the country
29:34 that has the third most energy resources
29:37 in the world. So, it's it's falling
29:39 apart around them.
29:41 >> And and and what happens next? I mean,
29:43 you mentioned they're they're cornered
29:45 at this point. Cornered animals t tend
29:48 to get desperate and you don't know what
29:49 they're going to do.
29:51 >> Uh well, I think what they're going to
29:52 do is they will eventually uh want to
29:55 make a deal and you know they they
29:58 didn't stick to the memorandum of
30:00 understanding from Islamabad this
30:02 summer. They started firing on the so
30:04 but you we're we're getting uh some
30:07 nights more
30:10 crude through the straight of Hormouth
30:13 than preconlict levels. I think the
30:16 other night there was mid uh 20 million
30:19 barrels. So right now, Becky, the score
30:22 since we put up the blockade is about
30:25 USA 1.7 billion barrels, Iran zero, and
30:30 eventually gravity is going to uh kick
30:33 in. It's going to be a long cold winter
30:35 for the Iranians.
30:37 >> Just about anything we ask you about,
30:40 Mr. Secretary, could have an asterisk
30:42 and and that is the Iran war. So
30:44 underlying inflation seem to be uh
30:48 behaving better than it is now.
30:50 Obviously before the war, your your uh
30:52 your efforts to reduce uh the deficit
30:55 and bring down debt debt to GDP that was
30:58 headed the right way uh as well. Uh
31:01 wages were growing faster than
31:03 inflation. Um
31:06 you know that was headed the right way.
31:07 All those things are are headed the
31:09 wrong way at this point. Is is is it
31:11 that simple that that it was worth it to
31:14 to do what needed to be done after 47
31:16 years in Iran? Uh because the the
31:19 obviously the deficit this year is is
31:21 not where you wanted it to be or
31:23 predicted it would be.
31:25 >> Uh well Joe 100% it was worth it that
31:28 President Trump took action that had
31:30 been needed for 47 years and we we'll
31:34 get on the the other side of this. We're
31:36 already seeing uh the energy prices come
31:39 down and I think what was very
31:41 unfortunate for the Iranians. Uh they
31:44 they were offered a deal and they
31:46 probably would have gotten a better deal
31:47 before the election. Now President Trump
31:50 doesn't think we we need a deal and
31:52 we're just going to keep squeezing them.
31:55 And as I said uh and you said Joe core
32:00 inflation remains the quite under under
32:03 control. It's an energy shock and we'll
32:06 get to the other side of it. I think the
32:08 oil market's going to be even better
32:10 supplied on the other side of this. You
32:12 see that Saudi production's hitting
32:14 records. UAE production is hitting
32:16 records. Uh Venezuela in a few years
32:19 will be up to back up to over a million
32:22 barrels a day. And thanks to President
32:24 Trump's energy dominance that the US is
32:27 an energy superpower.
32:30 But we did have a a rough number CPI
32:33 number earlier this week. We get another
32:34 number uh today that has uh predictions
32:38 for for more rate hikes uh from the Fed
32:40 and Chair Wars. Um a very high
32:44 probability of that. Is that the right
32:46 thing for the Fed to do at this point?
32:47 Would you give cover to to to Chair Wars
32:49 to do what needs to be done? You you
32:51 have in the past, but I don't know if
32:52 the president would. Well, I I I think
32:55 that the Fed should understand that this
32:57 is an energy supply shock. And Joe, in
33:02 central bank history, I think everyone
33:04 agrees that one of the great mistakes of
33:06 all time was the ECB in the summer of
33:09 2008. Uh crude spiked to $147. The ECB
33:14 panicked. They hiked rates into the GFC.
33:18 So, uh, you know, I I think that to hike
33:22 too much into an energy supply shock
33:24 when it's coming down. These are very
33:26 noisy numbers. LA last week's, uh, the
33:29 number that got published for October is
33:31 a noisy number. Then with, uh, gasoline
33:35 down
33:37 below $4, crude down $20, diesel down
33:40 10% thus far, then we're going to get a
33:44 benign number likely next week. So, you
33:47 know, the the the Fed's supposed to look
33:48 into the future, not look in the
33:51 rearview mirror.
33:52 >> Mr. Secretary, the reason that the ECB's
33:54 move was so um egregious, I suppose, is
33:57 because it came just before the market
33:59 crash, the great financial crash, uh the
34:02 great financial downturn. Uh do you
34:05 foresee anything like that in the
34:06 markets at this point?
34:08 >> Uh not at all, Becky. I you know, we
34:10 we've seen the markets are very very uh
34:14 resilient here. uh the equity markets at
34:17 at new highs. Uh at Treasury, uh the ten
34:21 the tenure is above 5%, but we've had
34:24 four of the strongest bond auctions in
34:26 the past 20 years. Uh the dollar dollar
34:29 is well well bid. Uh the economy is very
34:33 very strong. We're seeing job growth the
34:36 across uh small business, large
34:39 businesses. So, uh, I I'm quite
34:42 confident that the economy is in very
34:44 good shape and, you know, I I've spent a
34:46 lot of time on financial stability in my
34:49 career and there's nothing that's
34:51 setting off any alarm bells for me right
34:53 now. But would you dissuade the Fed from
34:58 would do you think it's a wrong move to
35:00 raise rates further or and would you
35:02 call it political or would you say given
35:05 the the set of circumstances that Kevin
35:07 Worsh finds himself in right now at
35:10 least a quarter point or even a half
35:12 point makes sense?
35:14 >> I again I'm not going to tell the Fed
35:17 what to do. I I am going to say they
35:20 should have an open mind. And Joe, let's
35:22 let's keep let's let's keep this in
35:24 context that this is the same Fed that
35:27 did three rate cuts over this same
35:29 period last year and now to to reverse
35:33 just based on an energy supply shock. Uh
35:37 a a reversal in a dramatic way uh isn't
35:41 something that I would do if I were on
35:42 the Fed, but I'm not on the Fed. Let's
35:45 get back to to the Nvidia situation
35:47 again because we we are going to see the
35:49 Democrats take control in January.
35:51 They're already promising subpoenas uh
35:54 about a wide range of things I'm I'm
35:56 sure. But just about the Invidities
35:59 Nvidia situation um itself, how will
36:03 Treasury um handle those requests? And
36:06 it I know the president said that he has
36:08 full confidence in Secretary Lutnik. Do
36:11 you think that
36:13 there has to be some administration
36:15 official held accountable uh for that?
36:17 And and I I think he'd be the the prime
36:20 candidate. [snorts]
36:21 >> Uh
36:22 I'm not sure what you mean by how
36:24 Treasury is going to handle the
36:25 situation. You know, we we come in every
36:28 day and you know, do do our job as
36:32 prescribed.
36:34 there will be the oversight
36:37 investigation on the administration's
36:38 handling of of mega speed, right? That
36:40 th those will strictly go to to commerce
36:43 at this point.
36:44 >> Uh I I I believe that is a as I said
36:47 that's a B bis function. the do you
36:51 expect um the tariff regime to to
36:56 continue after January and and how will
36:59 it make it much more difficult with with
37:01 both houses of of Congress now and
37:03 controlled by Democrats? Well, I I think
37:05 what we've seen after the Supreme Court
37:07 decision, USR ambassador Jameson Greer
37:11 has been ve very uh deliberate in his
37:14 methodology and uh in terms of his 301
37:19 investigations and we are seeing many uh
37:23 tariffs reconstituted. We have a series
37:26 of trade deals that are fantastically
37:29 favorable for the United States and you
37:32 know I think that we will stick with
37:35 those and I am optimistic that we can
37:38 get trade deals with Canada and Mexico.
37:42 >> Yeah. All right. Secretary, we uh we
37:44 appreciate all your time and and we
37:47 obviously are considerate of your safety
37:50 as well and wish you well. Uh, and it
37:53 it's it's a uh these are unprecedented
37:56 times obviously, but but be well and we
37:58 hope [music] to see you again soon.
37:59 Thanks for all your time.
38:02 >> SquawkPod will be right back.
38:09 >> A widespread Microsoft outage spreading
38:12 into a second day. Outlook, Teams, and
38:15 multiple Microsoft 365 services like
38:17 Copilot and SharePoint have been
38:19 affected. And by affected, we mean not
38:21 available. Microsoft initially blamed
38:24 the problem on a traffic surge in part
38:26 of its infrastructure and issues with
38:28 the component responsible for processing
38:30 server health. In an update just now,
38:32 Microsoft said that it's made additional
38:34 progress towards service recovery with
38:36 some actions completed in the
38:37 Asia-Pacific region. It says that
38:40 traffic is being gradually restored. The
38:42 company's not aware of any malicious
38:44 activity causing that outage. The stock
38:46 is off by about 2.1%, but this is a big
38:49 deal. I know it's affected all of our
38:50 outlook.
38:51 >> Just take your time. Don't, you know,
38:53 whenever.
38:54 >> This is the largest outage that I
38:55 remember in any of these situations. I
38:57 don't want to cause the extra traffic.
38:58 Is it AI agents that are out there?
39:01 >> With the extra traffic on some of these
39:02 things, but I assume we'll be getting
39:04 more answers in the days to come.
39:06 >> Right.
39:07 >> Maybe you can ask them next week. You've
39:08 got Satcha and Nadella.
39:09 >> Things trickle in. I've got a couple.
39:12 Yeah,
39:12 >> we'll talk to Satcha. Well, the comment
39:14 I was going to make is we always talk
39:16 about our our deep fear that AI is going
39:20 to upend the world and one of the things
39:22 that we fear is that it's going to turn
39:24 off our email or it's going to, you
39:26 know, create a blackout either for a
39:28 couple of hours or a day or whatever.
39:30 Um, and I I'm not minimizing the
39:33 situation at all, but it's interesting
39:36 that the sun came out this morning and
39:38 we're on the air this morning and
39:40 >> Yeah, but they said there's no this I
39:42 don't know what this was. They said
39:43 there was no malicious intent. There was
39:45 no breakin with this and if this is what
39:46 we we can do to ourselves without
39:48 meaning to do it.
39:50 >> But that but my suggestion is that there
39:52 will be things that will happen with
39:54 agents without agents uh that are
39:57 problematic. AWS if you remember went
39:59 down
40:00 >> last year for for six or eight hours.
40:03 >> Wasn't great. Um, but I only say that
40:06 because I know there's a lot of doomers
40:07 out there and uh while I fear lots of
40:10 things, uh, this is actually one of the
40:12 things I don't fear.
40:13 >> Yeah.
40:14 >> Yeah. Nobody can email us. Woo! Woo!
40:16 >> Right.
40:16 >> Good luck catching us.
40:17 >> It's not like like Wi-Fi went down at
40:19 home or something. That's
40:22 >> That is a far more serious outage.
40:24 >> Just totally stopped. Uh, or the cable's
40:27 out, but that's because I'm
40:29 >> I'm still a cable
40:30 >> cable guy. That uh does it for us. It
40:33 has been a heck of a week, guys. I've
40:35 been pretty pretty remarkable.
40:39 [music]
40:40 >> Just give me a second. I'm looking
40:41 through all my emails that are hitting
40:43 uh right now. [music] Um
40:45 >> I don't have any yet.
40:46 >> Mine are hitting 647 647 645. So,
40:50 they're trickling in uh [music] more
40:52 more and it's picking up speed a little
40:56 bit. Uh and you know what? [music] I
40:57 really didn't miss there's nothing here
40:59 that I needed. Squawkbox is hosted by
41:03 Joe Kernan, Becky Quick, and [music]
41:04 Andrew Ross Sorcin. Tune in weekday
41:06 mornings on CNBC starting at 6 Eastern.
41:09 To get the smartest takes and analysis
41:11 from our TV show right into your ears,
41:14 please follow Squawk Pod wherever you
41:15 get your podcasts. We'll meet you right
41:17 back here [music] on Monday. Have a
41:19 great weekend.
41:21 >> We are clear. Thanks, guys.
Amodei and Dimon hosting livestream ahead of Anthropic's IPO full transcript
0:08 POSSIBILITIES.
0:11 >> WELCOME BACK, ANTHROPIC CEO
0:12 DARIO AMODEI AND JPMORGAN CEO
0:14 JAMIE DIMON HOSTING A FIRESIDE
0:15 CHAT IN JUST A FEW MOMENTS.
0:17 KATE ROONEY HAS THE DETAILS. AS
0:19 PART OF THE ROAD SHOW.
0:22 >> YEAH. SO JAMIE DIMON IS
0:24 GOING
0:28 EXPECTING THIS AROUND NOON
0:29 EASTERN IN NEW YORK TODAY AND
0:31 IT WILL BE LIVE STREAMED.
0:32 ANTHROPIC JUST CONFIRMED THAT
0:34 THEY PUT OUT A TWEET WITH THE
0:36 LINK. IT'S GOING TO BE ON X,
0:38 AND JP MORGAN AND JAMIE DIMON
0:39 RAN THIS PLAY BACK IN JUNE.
0:41 DIAMOND INTERVIEWED ELON MUSK
0:42 DURING THE SPACE X ROAD SHOW,
0:44 AND THAT CONVERSATION ALSO
0:45 STREAMED ON X THIS TIME. JP
0:47 MORGAN IS ONE OF THE FIRMS
0:49 LEADING THE US RETAIL PUSH FOR
0:52 ANTHROPIC, WHICH IS OF COURSE,
0:53 THE COMPANY BEHIND CLOUD AND
0:54 THAT CHATBOT ANTHROPIC COULD,
0:55 FROM WHAT WE'RE HEARING, MAKE
0:56 AS MUCH OF A FIFTH OF THE
0:58 OFFERING AVAILABLE TO
0:59 INDIVIDUAL INVESTORS, RETAIL
1:01 INVESTORS, THROUGH BROKERAGES.
1:02 YOU'VE GOT ROBINHOOD, FIDELITY,
1:03 ETRADE, FOR EXAMPLE. THAT WILL
1:05 BE PART OF THE OFFERING. IT
1:06 GIVES THEM A SHOT OF BUYING AT
1:08 THE IPO PRICE BEFORE THE STOCK
1:10 IS GOING TO START TRADING.
1:11 THERE'S ALSO SOME EARLY SIGNS
1:12 THAT WE'VE SEEN OF RETAIL
1:13 INTEREST, SO VANTA RESEARCH
1:15 TRACKS THIS ONE CLOSELY. THEY
1:16 SAY TRADING IN SOME OF THE MORE
1:18 SPECULATIVE CONTRACTS TIED TO
1:19 ANTHROPIC AHEAD OF THE IPO
1:20 SUGGEST THAT FIRST DAY RETAIL
1:22 BUYING COULD EVEN TOP SPACE X.
1:24 THE TEST DOES COME WHEN THAT
1:26 STOCK OPENS, OF COURSE, BUT
1:27 THAT IS EXPECTED. GUYS. NEXT
1:28 THURSDAY WE'RE GOING TO SEE HOW
1:29 MUCH MAINSTREAM INTEREST THERE
1:31 IS, HOW MUCH THEY ACTUALLY BUY.
1:32 AND LESLIE PICKER HAS REPORTED
1:34 THAT INSTITUTIONAL INTEREST FOR
1:35 THIS DEAL HAS BEEN QUITE STRONG.
1:37 SO WE'LL SEE HOW THAT
1:39 TRANSLATES TO SORT OF THE
1:40 AVERAGE MAINSTREAM INVESTOR, AS
1:41 I SAID. BUT JAMIE DIMON WILL
1:43 WILL PUT THAT ON DISPLAY TODAY.
1:44 WE'LL SEE WHAT THEY SAY GUYS.
1:45 >> YEAH I MEAN GOOD THEY'RE
1:47 LIVE STREAMING IT. IF THEY IF
1:48 THEY'RE TRYING TO SELL IT TO
1:50 RETAIL INVESTORS. BUT KATE, YOU
1:51 KNOW, JUST TO CONNECT THE TWO
1:53 BIG STORIES WITH THE ANTHROPIC
1:54 IPO AND THEN THE JEN-HSUN HUANG
1:56 EXIT, A LOT OF PEOPLE ARE
1:57 SAYING THAT, YOU KNOW, JENSON'S
1:59 EXIT FROM NVIDIA MARGINALLY
2:01 BENEFITS THESE COMPANIES, THE
2:03 ANTHROPIC AND THE OPEN EYES,
2:04 THE FRONTIER MODELS BECAUSE HE
2:06 WAS HE WAS THE SPOKESPERSON FOR
2:08 THE OPEN WEIGHT MODELS, WHICH
2:09 SORT OF GOES AGAINST THEIR
2:11 BUSINESS MODEL.
2:11 >> NO, IT'S IT'S A REALLY GOOD
2:13 POINT. WE SHOULD ALSO SAY
2:14 NVIDIA IS AN INVESTOR IN
2:16 ANTHROPIC. SO THERE'S A SORT OF
2:18 TANGLED WEB OF INTEREST HERE.
2:20 BUT AT THE SAME TIME, DARIO
2:22 AMODEI HAS BEEN AMONG THE MORE
2:23 HAWKISH WHEN IT COMES TO CHINA
2:24 HAS REALLY, YOU KNOW, SAID THAT
2:26 HE WANTS TIGHTER EXPORT
2:28 CONTROLS AND SORT OF HAS BEEN
2:29 IN SOME WAYS ON THE OPPOSITE
2:30 SIDE OF JENSON JEN-HSUN HUANG.
2:32 BUT THEY ALSO DO HAVE COMPETING
2:34 INTERESTS. I MEAN, NVIDIA WAS
2:36 SUPPORTING OPEN SOURCE. THAT IS
2:37 THE OPPOSITE AND DAMAGING
2:38 POTENTIALLY TO THEIR BUSINESS
2:39 MODEL. THEY WROTE ABOUT IT
NHL's Toronto Maple Leafs valuation hits new highs at $5.4 billion full transcript
0:16 >> CNBC SPORTS 2026 OFFICIAL
0:20 NHL TEAM VALUATIONS ARE OUT.
0:23 RECORD VIEWERSHIP, STRONGER
0:25 METEORITES AND POTENTIAL
0:26 EXPANSION ARE FUELING THE
0:28 GROWTH. THE TORONTO MAPLE LEAFS
0:30 ARE PRO HOCKEY'S MOST VALUABLE
0:31 TEAM, VALUED AT $5.4 BILLION.
0:34 THE NEW YORK RANGERS, THE
0:37 MONTREAL CANADIENS AND THE LOS
0:40 ANGELES KINGS AND EDMONTON
0:42 OILERS ROUND OUT THE TOP FIVE.
0:44 THE AVERAGE TEAM IS NOW WORTH
0:47 $2.71 BILLION, UP 23% IN A YEAR.
0:50 JOINING US NOW IS THE MAN
0:52 BEHIND THE LIST, CNBC SENIOR
0:54 SPORTS REPORTER MICHAEL OZANIAN.
0:56 PRETTY NICE NUMBERS ABOUT. AND
0:58 THAT'S WHAT LIKE ROUGHLY HALF
1:00 OF AN NFL TEAM.
1:01 >> YEAH. YEAH THAT'S ABOUT
1:02 RIGHT. AND WE'VE.
1:03 >> SEEN SOME OF. THESE
1:05 VALUATIONS.
1:05 >> WITH SMALL.
1:06 >> STAKES BEING SOLD RECENTLY.
1:08 SO YOU'RE IN THE PROCESS OF
1:09 SEEING 15% OF THE NEW YORK
1:11 ISLANDERS BEING SOLD AT A 3
1:13 BILLION VALUATION. BEFORE THAT,
1:16 YOU HAD 12.5% OF THE CAROLINA
1:19 HURRICANES BEING SOLD AT A
1:22 $2.66 BILLION VALUATION BECAUSE
1:23 THERE HAVEN'T BEEN ANY CONTROL
1:24 STAKE SALES RECENTLY. THE
1:26 PENGUINS WERE SOLD FOR 1.8
1:27 BILLION, BUT THAT WAS A DEAL
1:29 NEGOTIATED LIKE OVER A YEAR AGO.
1:30 >> WHY UP 23% OVER THE LAST.
1:33 >> COUPLE OF REASONS. ONE IS
1:35 THE NEW DEAL WITH ROGERS FOR
1:37 THE CANADIAN NATIONAL RIGHTS
1:38 THAT MORE THAN DOUBLED. THERE'S
1:41 ANTICIPATION THAT THE NEXT U.S.
1:43 DEAL, WHICH IS TWO YEARS AWAY,
1:45 CURRENTLY PAYS A LITTLE LESS
1:46 THAN $650 MILLION. THAT DEAL
1:49 COULD POSSIBLY DOUBLE AS WELL.
1:51 AS JOE MENTIONED RATINGS HAVE
1:52 BEEN STRONG. AND AGAIN AS WITH
1:54 SPORTS TEAMS ACROSS ALL LEAGUES
1:56 THERE'S A BIG DEMAND FOR THESE
1:58 TEAMS. AND THE SUPPLY IS VERY
1:59 LIMITED.
2:00 >> HAVE THEY OUTSTRIPPED THE
2:01 DEMAND FOR OTHER CLUBS OR FOR
2:03 OTHER SPORTS, OR IS IT KIND OF
2:05 IN LINE WITH WHAT YOU'VE SEEN
2:06 WITH SPORTS ACROSS.
2:07 >> MORE IN LINE? AND I THINK
2:09 WITH EXPANSION COMING UP, WE'LL
2:10 GET A TRUE TEST OF WHAT THE
2:12 DEMAND IS FOR HOCKEY OUTSIDE OF
2:14 THE OTHER LEAGUES. THEY'RE
2:15 GOING TO EXPAND TO PROBABLY
2:17 HOUSTON AND ATLANTA. I THINK
2:19 HOUSTON WILL BE THE DEAL
2:20 ANNOUNCED FIRST, AND I WOULD
2:21 EXPECT THAT DEAL. I'M HEARING
2:22 OVER $2 BILLION, WHICH WHEN YOU
2:24 LOOK BACK TO FIVE YEARS AGO,
2:26 THE LAST EXPANSION TEAM SEATTLE
2:29 KRAKEN, THAT PRICE WAS ONLY
2:31 $650 MILLION. SO THAT SPEAKS TO
2:32 HOW STRONG THE NHL IS. I MEAN
2:35 IT'S YOU KNOW IT'S NOT NFL BUT
2:37 IT'S NOT PICKLEBALL EITHER. I
2:38 MEAN IF YOU'RE GOING TO GO DOWN
2:40 THE LIST FOR LIVE SPORTS WHICH
2:43 WE JUST NOW KNOW NEWS AND LIVE
2:44 SPORTS SEEMS TO BE, YOU KNOW,
2:46 WHETHER IT'S STREAMING, WHETHER
2:47 IT'S CABLE, NO MATTER WHAT IT
2:48 IS, THAT'S WHERE THE VALUE IS.
2:51 AND, YOU KNOW, YOU GOT TO WATCH
2:53 THE ADS UNLESS I GUESS YOU YEAH,
2:55 YOU GOT TO WATCH IT LIVE. SO
2:57 YOU'RE STUCK. THE KEY TO THE
2:58 NHL IS, YOU KNOW, YOU'RE
2:59 TALKING ABOUT THE NFL. OVER 60%
3:01 OF THE NFL'S REVENUE IS SHARED
3:03 EVENLY ACROSS ALL TEAMS.
3:05 DOESN'T MATTER WHAT CITY YOU'RE
3:06 IN OR HOW GOOD OR BAD YOU ARE,
3:08 THAT'S AN EVEN SPLIT. IN THE
3:10 NHL, IT'S LESS THAN 20%. SO IF
3:11 YOU LOOK AT THE TOP OF OUR LIST,
3:13 YOU KNOW, LOOK AT TORONTO.
3:15 THAT'S WHY, YOU KNOW, WHEN WAS
3:16 THE LAST TIME THEY WON A
3:18 STANLEY CUP? IN THE 60S, THEY
3:19 GET $140 MILLION IN TICKET
3:22 REVENUE, JUST TICKET REVENUE.
3:23 THREE OF YOUR THE AVERAGE IS 83
3:25 MILLION. SO IT'S HOW WELL YOU
3:27 RUN YOUR ARENA. DO YOU CONTROL
3:28 YOUR ARENA ECONOMICS? THAT'S
3:30 REALLY A BIG THING IN THE NHL.
3:32 >> OKAY, THREE OF THE TOP FIVE,
3:33 THOUGH, ARE CANADIAN TEAMS
3:34 BECAUSE CANADIANS PLAY HOCKEY.
3:36 THEY LOVE THIS SPORT. IT'S
3:38 THEIR NATIONAL SPORT. HOW WELL
3:39 DO YOU THINK EXPANSION TEAMS IN
3:41 THE SOUTH WILL WILL DO?
3:44 >> THE NHL HAS IS BEING VERY
3:48 METICULOUS IN TERMS OF WHO
3:49 THEY'RE GOING TO ALLOW TO BUY
3:50 THESE TEAMS. AND BY THAT I MEAN
3:52 THEY'RE MAKING SURE THEY'RE
3:53 WELL CAPITALIZED, BECAUSE WE'VE
3:54 ALREADY HAD TWO EXPANSION TEAMS
3:56 IN ATLANTA THAT SUBSEQUENTLY
3:57 MOVED. BUT IN THIS CASE,
3:58 THEY'RE BEING VERY METICULOUS
4:00 ALSO IN TERMS OF FINANCING NEW
4:03 ARENAS BECAUSE OF HOW IMPORTANT
4:04 THE ARENA ECONOMICS ARE AND WHO
4:05 THESE OWNERS ARE. WE'VE HAD
4:07 GREAT SUCCESS WITH SOME OF THE
4:09 SOUTHERN FRANCHISES RECENTLY.
4:10 YOU KNOW, THE HURRICANES WON
4:12 THE CUP. YOU'VE HAD THE TAMPA
4:14 BAY RAYS, LIGHTNING WINNING.
4:16 YOU'VE HAD FLORIDA WIN IT. GOOD
4:18 OWNERSHIP THAT HAVE DONE A GOOD
4:20 JOB OF ALSO RUNNING THOSE
4:22 BUILDINGS.
4:22 >> SO SO THAT PUTS SEATS IN THE
4:24 BUTTS IN THE SEATS, I SHOULD
Rocket Lab CEO Peter Beck: Fastest commercial rocket to reach 100 launches full transcript
0:00 Peter, it's great to have you back on
0:01 the show. Welcome to you. Um, record
0:03 revenue for the quarter, record backlog,
0:05 which is up more than 50% uh,
0:07 consecutively here too. Uh, I guess just
0:10 the the state of Rocket Lab, the state
0:12 of the industry right now, which does
0:13 seem to be I'm going to use the pen to
0:15 the moon.
0:17 >> Yeah. Oh, it's great to talk to you
0:19 again, Morgan. Yeah. you know, it was a
0:20 it was a great uh a great uh quarter and
0:23 um you know, we we booked uh nearly just
0:26 slightly over in fact a billion dollars
0:27 worth of launch uh in this quarter
0:29 alone. So uh you know, launch continues
0:31 to grow and um and also all our space
0:34 systems business and and uh you know, as
0:36 you pointed out, it's it's it's been a
0:38 great quarter for us.
0:39 um 100th launch of your Electron rocket.
0:42 That is a very small and elite club of
0:45 vehicles that have done uh tripledigit
0:48 launches here. Uh how significant is
0:51 that? And how does it speak to a new era
0:54 that's being ushered in because you're
0:56 going to bring Neutron online, your
0:57 bigger, more powerful rocket next year.
0:59 Uh and you're already seeing very strong
1:01 demand for that.
1:03 >> Yeah. Yeah. No, I mean 100 launches is
1:05 is a you know is a great milestone as
1:06 you point out and um you know it's uh
1:09 you know 90 96% reliability for the
1:12 vehicle. So that's the sort of number
1:13 you want. Uh and uh but I guess one of
1:16 the the things that the team's really
1:18 proud of is that uh you know we're the
1:20 fastest uh commercially developed rocket
1:22 to to ever get to 100 launches. So um uh
1:26 you know we're able to to get there but
1:28 also get there in uh in record time. And
1:30 as you point out, uh, you know, Neutron
1:32 is coming online here shortly. So, um,
1:34 you know, that will be the, you know,
1:35 the next vehicle in the stable for, um,
1:37 for medium class lift.
1:39 >> You and I have had this conversation
1:40 before, but I've had it with a number of
1:41 other companies and executives,
1:43 including Blue Origin at UpSummit last
1:44 week as well, and that is the fact that
1:47 demand is outpacing capacity when it
1:49 comes to launch services.
1:51 uh how quickly can you bring Neutron
1:54 online and then ramp that cadence
1:56 especially with now a Pentagon um uh
2:00 debt deal under your belt I believe as
2:02 of this week too and what does that mean
2:04 for pricing?
2:07 >> Yeah, exactly right. I mean well that is
2:08 that that is the multi-billion dollar
2:10 question and and you know um uh the
2:13 first rocket to fly is obviously very
2:14 very important but I think you know the
2:17 question that I I would expect people to
2:18 ask me is is like what about the 10th
2:20 because you know the speed in which you
2:22 can scale them as you point out is is
2:24 super important and uh you know if you
2:26 look at the speed we scaled electron as
2:28 we talked about before we did it you
2:30 know faster than anybody else in history
2:32 uh so we hopefully to you know hope to
2:34 to apply that to to neutron as as well
2:36 and yeah I um launch has always been uh
2:40 uh pent up um and uh we you know we we
2:42 we knew that um for the medium lift
2:45 class uh of course that was that was
2:47 going to be the same. So you know it's
2:49 great to bring a product to market um
2:51 that uh you know that when there's such
2:53 demand and you know we basically sold
2:55 out until 2030 um at prices you know the
2:59 the original list price was 55 million
3:01 um you know they're selling in excess of
3:03 70 million now um before it's even
3:05 flown. So that you know that I think
3:07 that speaks uh volumes to the you know
3:10 the community's um uh trust in us that
3:12 we can you know bring that vehicle to
3:14 market and scale it quickly.
3:15 >> Yeah. And you also have a satellite and
3:17 spacecraft manufacturing business. Um
3:19 you're getting ready to I think soon
3:21 here close on your Aridium deal too
3:23 which brings you into space services
3:25 [clears throat] and communications as
3:26 well. Um, one of the things I've been
3:29 I've been hearing I've been on the
3:30 conference circuit and one of the things
3:32 I've been hearing at a number of
3:33 different conferences is how great the
3:36 opportunity is right now to invest in
3:38 and do business in places like Europe uh
3:41 which are looking for um more more
3:44 homegrown industries, more homegrown
3:46 companies, but also just um more
3:49 competition versus the likes of SpaceX.
3:52 So, how how are you assessing that? What
3:54 does that mean for Rocket Lab?
3:56 Yeah. Well, look, we've we've we've been
3:58 a global company since day one. So, you
4:00 know, moving into different continents
4:02 certainly doesn't bother us. Um, and you
4:04 know, this year we've uh we acquired uh
4:06 a German company called Bernaric and
4:08 also opened Rocket Lab Europe. So, uh
4:11 you know, we're taking all of our
4:12 knowledge and experience uh you know
4:14 into those other markets. And you know,
4:16 to your point, the next biggest market
4:18 after the US market is the European
4:20 market. And uh there's there's great
4:22 desire and and a huge amount of
4:23 resources and capital flowing right now
4:25 to build those sovereign capabilities.
4:28 So uh yeah, we we think we're very well
4:30 placed to, you know, to to lend a
4:32 helping hand in in doing that. I realize
4:34 that you're not necessarily partnered up
4:36 with or um you know count counts Nvidia
4:40 as a as an investor um in your company
4:43 but they have done a lot and under now
4:46 former CEO Jensen Wong had did a have
4:48 done a lot to invest in and sort of seed
4:50 this new space economy uh and worked
4:53 with a lot of space startups. The fact
4:55 that you are seeing a leadership change
4:56 there a shakeup happen there. How do you
4:58 expect that to ripple out into some of
5:00 the other technologies above and beyond
5:02 AI, including space?
5:05 >> Yeah, it's an interesting question. I
5:06 haven't really thought about it that
5:07 much, but I mean um look, the the vast
5:10 our market is pretty much um or our
5:12 customer base is pretty much broken to
5:14 broken into 50% government and 50%
5:16 commercial. And um and while it's true
5:19 I'm I'm sure a number of those
5:20 technologies sort of flowing into some
5:22 of those some of those spacecraft and
5:24 and missions um I don't I don't see it
5:27 as a is a huge um you know huge impact
5:29 for us. Um but I think um you know we
5:33 everybody wants a an extremely buoyant
5:36 stock market and uh so we we seem to get
5:38 affected um in the the highs and the
5:41 lows uh of you know of any volatility.
5:44 So, um, that's probably the the the
5:46 bigger effect to us is is probably, you
5:48 know, second order rather than first
Cisco CEO Chuck Robbins on Q1 earnings beat full transcript
0:00 DEALDASH.COM FOR $50 OF
0:02 FREE CREDIT AND YOU'RE
0:03 FIRST WIN GUARANTEED.
0:08 GUARANTEED.
0:11 >> CRAZY STUFF HAPPENING THIS
0:12 WEEK, GUYS. CISCO SHARES ARE
0:15 DOWN. LISTEN TO THE CONFERENCE
0:16 CALL. PRETTY DARN GOOD. BUT
0:17 WE'LL FIND OUT. AND DESPITE
0:19 DELIVERING EARNINGS BEAT AND A
0:21 FORECAST FOR AI INFRASTRUCTURE
0:23 REVENUE TO DOUBLE THIS FISCAL
0:25 YEAR. JOINING US NOW FIRST ON
0:27 CNBC CISCO CHAIR AND CEO CHUCK
0:29 ROBBINS. HEY CHUCK THANKS FOR
0:31 COMING UP.
0:31 >> IT'S GOOD TO BE HERE. YOU
0:33 GUYS HAVE BEEN BORED THIS WEEK.
0:34 >> YEAH. IT'S BEEN ASLEEP.
0:36 SORRY. YEAH. GIANTS.
0:39 >> I WATCHED THAT GAME LAST
0:40 NIGHT. OH, OKAY. ALL RIGHT, ALL
0:42 RIGHT. GO AHEAD.
0:42 >> ALL RIGHT. SO, SPORTS. I
0:44 WANT TO START BY HOW YOUR
0:46 COMPANY HAS DONE THE LAST TWO
0:47 YEARS. AND THEN HOW GOOD IS THE
0:51 ORDER GROWTH THAT YOU SEE IN
0:52 THE FUTURE?
0:54 >> YEAH. JIM, I THINK FIRST OF
0:55 ALL, THE TEAM HAS DONE AN
0:57 AMAZING JOB AND WE POSTED 24%
0:59 REVENUE GROWTH, 40% EPS GROWTH.
1:03 AND, AND I THINK 21% PRODUCT
1:05 ORDER GROWTH AT THE SAME TIME.
1:07 AND SO JUST, JUST AN
1:09 EXCEPTIONAL JOB. THE, THE DATA
1:10 POINT THAT I REALLY THINK IS
1:12 IMPORTANT IS THAT IF YOU GO
1:13 BACK FISCAL 25 UNTIL THE END OF
1:16 THE FISCAL YEAR, WE'RE IN NOW.
1:17 27 AND THE GUIDANCE WE GAVE
1:19 YESTERDAY WILL EFFECTIVELY ADD
1:20 $20 BILLION OF REVENUE, WITH
1:22 ACTUALLY SEVERAL THOUSAND FEWER
1:24 EMPLOYEES THAN WE HAD AT THE
1:26 BEGINNING OF 2025. SO THE SCALE
1:28 AND THE EFFICIENCY OF RUNNING
1:30 THIS BUSINESS RIGHT NOW THROUGH
1:31 A COMBINATION OF THE SCALE OF
1:33 DOING THE BUSINESS WITH THE
1:34 HYPERSCALERS AS WELL AS
1:36 CANDIDLY, AI AND THE AUTOMATION
1:38 AND THE CAPABILITIES THAT WE'RE
1:40 RUNNING THROUGH THE COMPANY.
1:41 IT'S I HAVEN'T HAD ANYBODY ON
1:42 MY TEAM ASK FOR HEADCOUNT IN
1:44 ABOUT A YEAR. SO IT'S, IT'S
1:45 PRETTY STUNNING.
1:47 >> YOU TALK ABOUT A SUPERCYCLE.
1:49 I, I SEE YOU THINK, CORRECT ME.
1:52 THREE SUPERCYCLES SECURITY AI
1:55 AND I NEVER THOUGHT CAMPUS
1:56 WOULD COME BACK LIKE THIS. AM I
1:58 WRONG THAT THIS ISN'T THIS IS
2:00 PERHAPS THE SINGLE TIME IN YOUR
2:02 YEARS AT CISCO THAT ALL THREE
2:04 ARE HITTING.
2:04 >> ALL THREE. PLUS, YOU DIDN'T
2:06 EVEN COVER SOVEREIGN
2:07 INFRASTRUCTURE OR HYBRID DATA
2:09 CENTER BUILD OUT. WE'VE HAD,
2:10 YOU KNOW, NINE OUT OF 11
2:12 QUARTERS. WE'VE SEEN DOUBLE
2:13 DIGIT GROWTH IN OUR ENTERPRISE
2:15 DATA CENTER NETWORKING BUSINESS
2:16 AS WELL. BUT THE CAMPUS REFRESH
2:19 IS ON. WE'RE WE'RE STILL LESS
2:21 THAN 10% OF, OF, OF THROUGH THE
2:24 TRANSITION ON THAT FRONT. SO
2:25 THAT'S GOING REALLY WELL. THE
2:28 POST MYTHOS AI ACTIVITY. AND WE
2:30 BEGAN TO SEE THE IMPROVEMENT IN
2:31 THAT PORTFOLIO THAT WE'VE BEEN
2:32 TALKING ABOUT FOR QUITE A WHILE
2:34 THIS QUARTER. I THINK IT'S
2:36 CLEAR THAT OUR CUSTOMERS ARE
2:38 WORKING ON UNDERSTANDING HOW
2:40 THEY UPGRADE THEIR
2:42 ARCHITECTURES TO DEAL WITH
2:43 THESE NEW THREATS THAT ARE
2:44 BROUGHT FORWARD BY AI. AND, AND
2:47 THEN THE HYPERSCALER ACTIVITY
2:49 THAT WE'VE SEEN, WE'VE HAD 18
2:51 DESIGN WINS IN THE LAST FIVE
2:52 QUARTERS. AND SO THAT CONTINUES
2:53 TO BE A REAL BRIGHT SPOT FOR US
2:55 AS WELL.
2:56 >> BEFORE I GIVE THIS OVER TO
2:57 MY COLLEAGUES, MORGAN STANLEY
2:59 HAS A PIECE THIS MORNING ON
3:00 QUOTE DIRECTLY. YOU CAN TELL ME
3:01 HOW TO FEEL ABOUT THIS. WE
3:04 EXPECT GROSS MARGINS TO STEP
3:06 DOWN IN THE BACK HALF AS
3:07 HYPERSCALER MIX INCREASINGLY
3:09 OUTWEIGHS THE BENEFIT FROM
3:11 CAMPUS STRENGTH. PRODUCT ORDERS
3:13 EXCLUDING HYPERSCALERS SLOWED
3:16 TO 14% YEAR OVER YEAR FROM 25%.
3:19 NOW, THIS IS A PERSON, A HIGHLY
3:20 PAID PERSON, META. MARSHALL.
3:24 >> META.
3:24 >> META. YEAH. HEY, YOU KNOW
3:26 WHAT? THERE'S NO ACCOUNTING FOR
3:27 NAMES. I'D LIKE TO KNOW WHETHER
3:29 THAT'S RIGHT OR WRONG.
3:31 >> I JOKE WITH MY TEAM THE
3:33 OTHER DAY. I SAID, I WISH
3:34 SOMEBODY TOLD ME FIVE YEARS AGO
3:36 MY BIGGEST PROBLEM THIS QUARTER
3:37 WAS GOING TO BE THAT 21%
3:38 PRODUCT ORDER GROWTH WASN'T
3:39 GOOD ENOUGH. IT'S IT'S IT'S
3:42 FUNNY, THE FOCUS ON GROSS
3:44 MARGINS. I GET IT BECAUSE IT'S
3:45 ALWAYS BEEN SOMETHING THEY CARE
3:47 ABOUT. BUT AT THE END OF THE
3:48 DAY, OPERATING MARGINS AND
3:50 OPERATING INCOME DRIVES EPS.
3:51 AND SO WHEN YOU SEE THIS
3:53 BUSINESS AND OUR OPERATING
3:54 MARGINS ARE DOWN 2 TO 2 AND A
3:58 HALF POINTS FROM A YEAR AGO,
3:59 SOMETHING LIKE THAT. AND OUR
4:00 OPERATING MARGINS ARE AT RECORD
4:02 HIGHS. AND THE REASON IS
4:03 BECAUSE THE SCALE OF THIS
4:05 BUSINESS. AND SO WHILE THE
4:06 GROSS MARGINS MAY BE LOWER, THE
4:08 PROFITABILITY OF THIS BUSINESS
4:08 IS INCREDIBLE. SO FROM A
4:10 SHAREHOLDER PERSPECTIVE, IF
4:11 YOU'RE LOOKING AT JUST EPS AND
4:12 YOU'RE LOOKING AT THE MULTIPLE
4:13 OF EPS,
Sec. Bessent: Commerce did not add Megaspeed to export control list full transcript
0:02 PRINT THE LOCATION OF MY HOUSE,
0:03 BUT SHE DID ANYWAY. HIGHLY
0:06 IRRESPONSIBLE AND DANGEROUS AND
0:07 THINGS LIKE THAT HAVE TO STOP
0:09 TO.
0:09 >> WELL, LET'S RETURN TO. IF WE
0:11 HAVE TIME, WE'LL TRY AND GET
0:13 BACK TO WHAT'S HAPPENING IN
0:14 IRAN. BUT I GUESS YOU'VE
0:17 NOTICED SOMETHING THAT THE
0:18 FINANCIAL MEDIA HAS BEEN
0:19 FOCUSED ON THIS WEEK AND THE
0:22 MARKETS AND THE WORLD. AND, AND
0:24 THAT IS WHAT'S HAPPENING WITH
0:26 JEN-HSUN HUANG AND NVIDIA.
0:28 THERE HAVE BEEN REPORTS THAT
0:31 THERE WAS SOME TENSION BETWEEN
0:32 YOU AND SECRETARY LUTNICK ABOUT
0:35 WHY. MEGA SPEED WAS NOT PLACED
0:39 ON THE ENTITY LIST. AND I'M
0:41 JUST WONDERING ABOUT THE
0:43 INTERAGENCY COORDINATION. COULD
0:44 TREASURY HAVE DONE THAT? WAS IT
0:46 WAS IT ONLY. YOU KNOW, THEY
0:51 COULD HAVE COMMERCE THAT COULD
0:52 HAVE DONE THAT. WHAT ABOUT THE
0:54 COORDINATION?
0:56 >> YES. WELL, I CAN TELL YOU
0:57 THERE WAS COORDINATION,
1:00 TREASURY, WOR, USTR AND STATE.
1:03 THEY WERE IN FAVOR OF PUTTING
1:05 MEGA SPEED ON THE ENTITY LIST
1:07 FOR MONTHS. BUT COMMERCE HAS
1:10 THE COMMERCE BIS HAS THE PIN,
1:12 AND YOU WILL HAVE TO HAVE TO
1:13 ASK THEM ABOUT THEIR INTERNAL
1:15 PROCESSES.
1:17 >> HAVE YOU BEEN FRUSTRATED,
1:18 SECRETARY BEST BUY POTENTIAL
1:20 DELAYS WITH THIS? WE HAD OUR
1:23 OUR CORRESPONDENT IN BEIJING,
1:25 EUNICE YOON, YESTERDAY GAVE A
1:26 REPORT WHERE SHE HAD FOUND A
1:27 SMUGGLER IN BEIJING OR IN CHINA
1:31 AND TALK TO THEM ABOUT CHIPS
1:32 THAT WERE AVAILABLE AND HOW
1:34 MUCH MORE EXPENSIVE THEY WERE
1:35 YESTERDAY. ON THE CONCERN THAT
1:37 THE EXPORT CONTROLS WERE GOING
1:38 TO GET MUCH MORE STRINGENT THAN
1:40 THEY'VE BEEN TO THIS POINT.
1:41 HAVE YOU BEEN FRUSTRATED TO
1:42 THIS POINT WITH HOW THEY'VE
1:44 BEEN ENFORCED?
1:45 >> WELL, THE BECKY, I AM
1:47 FRUSTRATED WHEN PRESIDENT TRUMP
1:49 MADE IT VERY CLEAR THAT CHINA
1:52 SHOULD NOT RECEIVE ANY NVIDIA
1:54 CHIPS ABOVE AGE 100. AND SO ANY
1:58 LEAKAGE IS VERY FRUSTRATING
2:00 BECAUSE IT HURTS THE OUR HURTS,
2:03 OUR GREAT COMPANIES IN THE AI
2:05 RACE GIVES THE CHINESE AN
2:09 ADVANTAGE.
2:10 >> COULDN'T YOU DO. DO YOU
2:12 EXPECT THAT TREASURY WILL DO
2:14 SOMETHING WITH. THROUGH THE
2:16 OFFICE OF FOREIGN ASSETS
2:17 CONTROL AND JUST TAKE IT UPON
2:20 TREASURY YOURSELF TO TO GET
2:22 INVOLVED IF YOU DON'T SEE IT
2:23 FROM FROM COMMERCE.
2:25 >> YEAH. JOE THE THE OWNER HAS
2:28 NO CONTROL OVER THE THINGS LIKE
2:30 THIS IN TERMS OF EXPORTS. YOU
2:34 KNOW, THIS IS THE A, BIS
2:37 DECISION. AND, YOU KNOW,
2:39 PERHAPS THE FTC COULD PUT
2:41 SOMETHING ON THEIR RESTRICTED
2:42 LIST.
2:42 >> WE WERE UNABLE TO ASK
2:44 SECRETARY LUTNICK WHAT WHAT HIS
2:45 PLANS ARE AND WHAT HAPPENED. WE
2:46 CAN ONLY WE CAN ONLY ASK YOU
2:48 WHAT WAS WAS THERE AN INCIDENT
2:51 WHERE YOU CONFRONTED SECRETARY
2:54 LUTNICK AND SAID, WHAT IS GOING
2:56 ON AND WHY DID YOU NOT DO THIS?
2:58 AND NOW LOOK. LOOK HOW
2:59 EVERYTHING HAS COME BACK ON THE
3:01 ADMINISTRATION AT THIS POINT.
3:03 >> YEAH, JOE, WE DON'T REPEAT
3:05 CONVERSATIONS IN THE SITUATION
3:06 ROOM.
3:08 >> OKAY. I HAVE SEEN, THOUGH,
3:10 THAT I GUESS SOME REPORTING
3:13 THAT THAT IT HAPPENED. AND THEN
3:15 I THINK THE ADMINISTRATION SAID
3:17 THAT YOU DON'T KNOW WHAT YOU'RE
3:18 TALKING ABOUT. SO YOU CAN'T
3:19 CONFIRM ONE WAY OR ANOTHER, BUT
3:21 YOU THINK IT SHOULD BE DONE AT
3:22 THIS POINT. AND IF YOU WERE
3:24 SECRETARY OF COMMERCE, YOU
3:26 WOULD DO THINGS DIFFERENTLY.
3:28 >> I'M NOT GOING TO SAY IF I
Market Open: Stocks Mixed, Wholesale Inflation at Four-Year High, Nvidia Fallout full transcript
0:01 CNBC business news update. Market open.
0:04 I'm Jessica Edinger. Wall Street's in
0:06 the green on lighter thanex expected
0:09 inflation at the wholesale level and a
0:11 rebound for Nvidia shares as investors
0:13 scoop up the company on sale. Out of the
0:16 gate, the Dow is up 139 points. It's
0:19 being led higher by shares of Google
0:21 parent Alphabet. Those are up almost 2%
0:23 this morning. The S&P 500 index up 14.
0:27 The NASDAQ up three points now dipping
0:30 into the red down three. Nvidia shares
0:34 were higher in pre-market trading. They
0:36 are now ticking lower. Wholesale prices
0:39 rose 3/10en of a percent in October,
0:42 putting the annual rate of inflation at
0:44 6 and a half%,
0:46 the highest in nearly four years.
0:48 >> We still have this pressure coming from
0:51 uh uh wholesale prices into consumer
0:54 prices. We've said several times it
0:56 doesn't pass through one for one. There
0:59 are barriers. There's margin. There's
1:00 all kinds of things holding the line. Uh
1:02 businesses can can spread out the uh
1:04 pass along of these costs. But that's
1:06 been a reason why there have been people
1:08 concerned about inflation, not just
1:10 because of what's happening now, but
1:11 because of the pressure up the pipeline
1:13 to come through.
1:14 >> CNBC senior economics reporter Steve
1:16 Leman. Nvidia shares have dipped into
1:19 the red this morning and Jones Trading's
1:22 Mike Oor is cautioning buyers today that
1:24 Nvidia is going to be a different
1:26 company without CEO Jensen Wong.
1:28 >> A lot of people were seeing Jensen's
1:30 exit as maybe a clearing event,
1:32 potential clearing event for the stock.
1:33 A lot of people were waiting for that to
1:35 buy the stock and that's what what
1:37 that's what we saw and I think anyone
1:38 who wanted to buy Nvidia probably bought
1:40 it yesterday. But I'm not sure that that
1:43 paints a, you know, a real a proper
1:46 outlook for where we're going. Is a is a
1:48 Nvidia without Jensen Wang worth as you
1:50 know is a 10% discount, 11% discount
1:54 enough for investors? I don't think so
1:56 because obviously the whole complexion
1:58 of the company's going to change going
2:00 forward here.
2:00 >> Investors are waiting for a permanent
2:02 replacement for Jensen Wong. The CFO,
2:06 Colette Crest, is now temporarily in the
2:09 role. Wong stepped down after admitting
2:11 an extrammarital affair with a woman
2:13 some believe to be a Chinese spy or
2:15 asset. This week, it's been reported
2:17 Wong had affairs with two other women.
2:19 Author Tay Kim wrote the book The Nvidia
2:22 Way. He's here with CNBC's Becky Quick.
2:25 >> Been talking to Nvidia employees all
2:26 week and they're disappointed. They're
2:28 angry and it's utter disbelief. One of
2:31 the greatest CEOs in American history.
2:33 For his tenure to end in this way is
2:36 just incredible and it's unbelievable.
2:38 >> Yeah. 33 years um as a co-founder of the
2:40 company, the only CEO that the company's
2:42 ever known. Um in your book in 2024, you
2:46 said that this company would be lost
2:48 without Jensen. I think you've changed
2:49 your mind at this point.
2:51 >> Yeah. Um it's been two and a half years
2:53 since since I've written the book and
2:55 and I've evolved my thinking. The
2:58 company is in a different stage at this
3:00 point. and a take on Nvidia and its
3:03 board governance from CNBC's Steve
3:06 Sedwick in London.
3:08 >> The company has also announced its first
3:09 ever board chair. Think about that. Just
3:12 one second. Just one second. Hold. Let's
3:14 all hold off for two seconds. A company
3:17 which is arguably one of the most two or
3:19 three important on the planet didn't
3:21 have a chair. I know some of you out
3:23 there think ESG is absolute border dash,
3:26 but the G of ESG seems to be quite
3:28 important at this moment, doesn't it?
3:29 The company's announced its first ever
3:31 board chair after Hang had long resisted
3:34 such a role. Now, the former Synopsis
3:36 CEO, Harvey Jones, has been appointed to
3:38 the role after having sat on the Nvidia
3:40 board since 1993.
3:42 Microsoft this morning says email is
3:44 almost back to normal after an outage
3:46 that also affected 365 and Teams and
3:50 slammed hundreds of millions of
3:51 businesses and personal accounts
3:53 globally. The company said it did not
3:55 suspect malicious activity was the
3:58 cause. The Toronto Maple Leafs NHL team
4:01 is the league's most valuable in a new
4:04 analysis by CNBC. For the first time,
4:07 hockey team valuations have crossed the
4:09 $4 billion mark. The Leafs are valued
4:13 now at 5.4 billion, followed by the New
4:16 York Rangers at 4.7 billion and the
4:19 Montreal Canadians Leabon at $4.1
4:23 billion. The average NHL team now worth
4:27 2.7 billion. That's up 23%
4:32 from a year ago. It's Friday the 13th.
4:35 I'm Jessica Edinger, CNBC.
Colette Kress 'is one of the best CFOs ever': 'The Nvidia Way' author Tae Kim full transcript
0:10 >> NVIDIA. INVESTORS ARE
0:12 AWAITING A PERMANENT
0:13 REPLACEMENT FOR JENSEN WONG.
0:14 JOINING US RIGHT NOW WITH A
0:15 LOOK AT THE COMPANY'S ROAD
0:17 FORWARD IS TAE KIM. HE IS THE
0:18 FOUNDER OF THE KEY CONTEXT
0:20 SUBSTACK. HE'S ALSO THE AUTHOR
0:21 OF THE 2024 BOOK
0:28 100 DIRECT INTERVIEWS WITH
0:29 JENSEN WONG, HIS CO-FOUNDERS,
0:31 EARLY BACKERS, EARLY EMPLOYEES,
0:32 AND OTHERS. AND HEY, IT'S GREAT
0:35 TO HAVE YOU HERE.
0:36 >> IT'S GREAT TO BE HERE.
0:37 >> YEAH. WELCOME BACK TO CNBC.
0:39 GOOD TO SEE YOU AGAIN. LET'S
0:40 TALK A LITTLE BIT ABOUT WHAT'S
0:41 HAPPENED THIS WEEK BECAUSE YOU
0:43 KNOW THIS COMPANY YOU KNOW THIS
0:44 MAN INCREDIBLY WELL. I SUPPOSE
0:46 YOU WERE JUST AS SURPRISED AS
0:48 THE REST OF US.
0:49 >> IT'S COMPLETE SHOCK. I'VE
0:51 BEEN TALKING TO NVIDIA
0:52 EMPLOYEES ALL WEEK AND THEY'RE
0:53 DISAPPOINTED. THEY'RE ANGRY AND
0:55 IT'S UTTER DISBELIEF. FOR ONE
0:58 OF THE GREATEST CEOS IN
1:01 AMERICAN HISTORY, FOR HIS
1:02 TENURE TO END IN THIS WAY IS
1:04 JUST INCREDIBLE. AND IT'S
1:06 UNBELIEVABLE.
1:06 >> YEAH. 33 YEARS AS A
1:08 CO-FOUNDER OF THE COMPANY, THE
1:09 ONLY CEO THAT THE COMPANY HAS
1:10 EVER KNOWN. IN YOUR BOOK IN
1:13 2024, YOU SAID THAT THIS
1:15 COMPANY WOULD BE LOST WITHOUT
1:16 JENSEN. I THINK YOU'VE CHANGED
1:17 YOUR MIND AT THIS POINT.
1:19 >> YEAH.
1:20 >> IT'S BEEN TWO AND A HALF
1:21 YEARS SINCE SINCE I'VE WRITTEN
1:22 THE BOOK, AND A LOT OF PEOPLE
1:24 HAVE CITED THOSE PASSAGES
1:26 SAYING, YOU KNOW, NVIDIA WAY
1:28 TAY SAID THIS AND NVIDIA WILL
1:31 WOULD BE DEAD WITHOUT JENSEN.
1:32 AND I'VE EVOLVED MY THINKING.
1:36 I'VE MET MORE PEOPLE AND THE
1:39 COMPANY IS IN A DIFFERENT STAGE
1:40 AT THIS POINT.
1:41 >> DID YOU EVOLVE YOUR THINKING
1:43 BEFORE SUNDAY NIGHT?
1:44 >> YES YES YES.
1:45 >> OKAY. SO EXPLAIN WHAT KIND
1:46 OF GOT YOU TO THAT POINT.
1:48 >> I DID, I DID. I'VE BEEN
1:50 FOLLOWING THE COMPANY THE LAST
1:51 FEW YEARS, MEETING ALL THE KIND
1:53 OF MID-LEVEL EXECUTIVES, SENIOR
1:55 EXECUTIVES, GOING TO DIFFERENT
1:56 CONFERENCES. AND I DO THINK
1:58 THERE'S A DEEP, TALENTED BENCH
2:00 HERE. I MEAN, NO ONE'S GOING TO
2:01 REPLACE JENSEN, BUT 3 OR 4
2:03 PEOPLE MIGHT BE ABLE TO DO WHAT
2:05 HE DOES TODAY.
2:06 >> WHAT ABOUT COLETTE KRESS
2:07 WHO'S IN THE POSITION AS
2:08 INTERIM CEO?
2:09 >> RIGHT. I THINK SHE'S
2:10 EXCELLENT. I USED TO TALK TO
2:11 HER EVERY QUARTER FOR YEARS.
2:13 SHE'LL DO A GREAT JOB IN
2:15 MANAGING THE FINANCES. SHE'S
2:16 ONE OF THE BEST CFOS EVER. AND
2:19 SHE'S GOING TO DO A FINE JOB ON
2:21 THE INTERIM BASIS. BUT I DON'T
2:22 THINK SHE'S GOING TO BE THE
2:24 PERMANENT CEO.
2:24 >> WHY NOT?
2:25 >> I THINK FOR A JOB LIKE
2:27 NVIDIA WHERE IT'S DISRUPTION
2:29 INNOVATION, YOU HAVE TO HAVE
2:30 YOUR FINGER ON THE TOP OF ALL
2:32 THESE TECHNOLOGY TRENDS. YOU
2:33 NEED A CEO THAT HAS MORE
2:35 TECHNICAL EXPERTISE. AND I
2:37 THINK SHE'LL DO GREAT MANAGING
2:40 THE SUPPLY CHAIN AND DOING THE
2:42 NUMBERS. BUT THERE ARE TWO
2:43 IDEAS, I THINK THAT IF THE
2:46 BOARD CHOOSES THESE TWO PEOPLE,
2:48 NVIDIA CAN CONTINUE TO BE
2:49 SUCCESSFUL.
2:50 >> THE TWO IDEAS ARE.
2:52 >> CEO RENEE HOSS AND THE
2:54 INTERIM CANDIDATE. I BELIEVE
2:55 THAT WILL DO A GREAT JOB IS IAN
2:57 BUCK, WHO HEADS THEIR
2:59 HYPERSCALE BUSINESS.
3:00 >> BUT WE'LL TALK MORE ABOUT
3:01 THOSE IN JUST A MOMENT. ANDREW,
3:03 YOU HAVE A QUICK QUESTION.
3:04 >> HEY, I WAS CURIOUS. YOU KNOW,
3:06 THE WALL STREET JOURNAL HAD
3:07 THIS REPORT THAT THE
3:08 RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN WHAT IS
3:09 NOW GOING TO BE THE NEW CEO AND
3:12 JENSEN COULD BE TENSE AT TIMES,
3:15 AND THAT WITHOUT OVERSTATING IT,
3:17 IT APPEARED THAT HE HAD A DIM
3:19 VIEW OF HER VIEW OF HER ABILITY
3:22 TO MAKE OR HELP HIM MAKE BIG
3:25 STRATEGIC DECISIONS. THERE WAS
3:26 ALSO REPORTING THE INFORMATION
3:28 THAT SUGGESTED THAT HER
3:30 RELATIONSHIP WITH HIS KIDS WAS
3:32 STRAINED AND QUITE COMPLICATED.
3:34 WHAT DO YOU KNOW ABOUT ALL OF
3:36 THAT?
3:36 >> SO I LAUGHED WHEN I READ
3:38 THAT ARTICLE.
3:39 >> BECAUSE THAT'S EXACTLY THE
3:40 WAY JENSEN TREATS HIS
3:43 EXECUTIVES FOR THE LAST 33
3:44 YEARS. THAT'S HIS MANAGEMENT
3:45 STYLE. HE BERATES AND INSULTS
3:48 THEM WHEN THEY PRESENT
3:50 SOMETHING, AND THEN HE INSTILLS
3:52 FEAR, THE FEAR OF GOD. OUR
3:54 COMPANY IS GOING TO GO BANKRUPT
3:56 IN 30 DAYS. LIKE YOU'RE
3:58 COMPLETELY INCOMPETENT. AND
3:59 THAT'S THE WAY HE KIND OF
4:02 PRESSURES THEM TO COME UP WITH
4:04 MIRACLES AND BETTER PERFORMANCE.
4:06 THAT'S JUST THE WAY HE HE
4:08 MANAGES MEETINGS. HE'S
4:10 HYPERBOLIC PRESSURES
'Inconceivable' that SpaceX, Tesla wouldn't merge: 'Elon Musk' author Isaacson full transcript
0:09 >> WELCOME BACK TO SQUAWK BOX
0:10 MERGER NEGOTIATIONS BETWEEN
0:11 SPACEX AND TESLA. THEY ARE
0:13 PROGRESSING TOWARDS A POTENTIAL
0:15 ANNOUNCEMENT AS EARLY AS
0:17 DECEMBER, I SHOULD SAY. JOINING
0:19 US RIGHT NOW TO TALK ABOUT THE
0:20 BIGGER PICTURE AND THE IMPACT
0:22 ON ELON MUSK. CNBC CONTRIBUTOR
0:24 WALTER ISAACSON. HE IS A TWO
0:26 LANE UNIVERSITY PROFESSOR,
0:27 PERELLA WEINBERG, ADVISORY
0:28 PARTNER AND THE AUTHOR OF ELON
0:30 MUSK. GOOD MORNING TO YOU. WE
0:32 DID SEE THAT THINGS ARE
0:34 PROGRESSING. I DON'T KNOW
0:35 WHETHER YOU THINK THAT THIS IS
0:36 GOING TO HAPPEN COME DECEMBER
0:38 OR GET PUSHED INTO 2027. IT
0:39 SOUNDS LIKE THERE'S STILL THE
0:41 POSSIBILITY THAT THAT'S THE
0:42 CASE. I THINK THE BIGGER
0:44 QUESTION I'D ASK YOU OF THOSE
0:46 WHO ARE INVESTED IN BOTH OF
0:47 THESE COMPANIES OUT THERE,
0:49 THEY'RE ALL, I THINK, SITTING
0:50 THERE SAYING, AM I IF I'M A
0:52 TESLA SHAREHOLDER, AM I GOING
0:53 TO GET A PREMIUM? AM I JUST
0:54 TRADING MY SHARES FOR SHARES?
0:57 WHAT KINDS OF CONVERSATIONS DO
0:58 YOU THINK ARE HAPPENING BEHIND
0:59 THE SCENES WHEN IT COMES TO HOW
1:02 THIS COULD ALL PLAY OUT?
1:03 >> WELL, I DEFINITELY THINK
1:05 THIS MERGER IS GOING TO PLAY
1:06 OUT, AND I THINK YOU'LL KNOW
1:08 MORE DECEMBER 3RD WHEN WE GET
1:09 TO THIS TESLA SHAREHOLDERS
1:11 ANNUAL MEETING. I DON'T KNOW IF
1:13 IT'LL ALL BE SOLVED BY THEN,
1:14 BUT IT'S SOMETHING THAT WILL BE
1:16 DISCUSSED. IT'S ALMOST
1:18 INCONCEIVABLE THAT YOU WOULD
1:19 NOT MERGE THESE COMPANIES NOW,
1:21 ESPECIALLY WHEN THINGS LIKE
1:22 TERRA FAB, THIS, YOU KNOW,
1:25 ENORMOUS CHIP FABRICATION PLANT
1:28 BEING BUILT UP BY A JOINTLY BY
1:32 SPACEX AND TESLA, THEY'RE
1:35 INTERCONNECTED IN DOING IT. AND
1:37 IT'S AN ERA WHEN NVIDIA IS
1:39 HAVING SUCH PROBLEMS. THESE
1:41 CHIPS, WHICH ARE VERY
1:42 SPECIALIZED AND NOT JUST LIKE
1:44 NVIDIA'S GPUS, ARE SPECIALIZED
1:47 FOR FULL SELF-DRIVING CARS OR
1:50 FOR SPACEX. THIS MEANS THAT
1:52 THOSE TWO COMPANIES ARE GOING
1:54 TO BE DOING, YOU KNOW, THE
1:57 FABRICATION AND THE DESIGN OF
1:59 CHIPS TOGETHER. SO I THINK YOU
2:01 HAVE TO HAVE A MERGER. IT MAKES
2:03 NO SENSE. OTHERWISE.
2:05 >> YOU JUST TOUCHED ON THE
2:07 WATCHWORD OF THE WEEK. INVIDIA
2:09 HOW DEPENDENT IS THE THE MUSK
2:13 UNIVERSE ON NVIDIA? THEY'VE
2:14 BEEN EXCLUSIVE TO THEM FOR A
2:15 LONG TIME. ELON HAS SPOKEN VERY
2:18 HIGHLY OF COURSE, OF JENSEN AND
2:20 THE COMPANY. AND I REMEMBER
2:21 BACK IN THE DAY WHEN I THINK
2:23 JENSEN WENT TO GO VISIT, HE
2:24 BROUGHT OVER THE FIRST CHIPS TO,
2:26 I THINK, ELON AND SAM ALTMAN
2:28 FROM OPENAI BACK, I THINK IN
2:31 2017, MAYBE 100%.
2:33 >> YEAH. THAT'S RIGHT. AND YES,
2:37 MUSK'S COMPANIES, ESPECIALLY
2:39 SPACEX AI, HAS BEEN GETTING A
2:42 WHOLE LOT OF NVIDIA CHIPS. AND
2:45 SPACEX AI IS BUILDING HUGE DATA
2:48 CENTERS OR COMPUTER CAMPUSES OR
2:49 WHATEVER. THEY COMPUTE CAMPUSES,
2:51 WHATEVER THEY WANT TO CALL THEM
2:52 NOW. AND THEY'VE GOTTEN SPECIAL
2:55 BIG DELIVERIES OF. HOWEVER, AND
2:58 I ASSUME THEY'LL STILL GET
3:00 THOSE DELIVERIES OF CHIPS.
3:01 THAT'S NOT GOING TO STOP.
3:03 HOWEVER, WHAT I'M SAYING IS YOU
3:05 NEED A NEW TYPE OF CHIP IF
3:07 YOU'RE GOING TO BE OPTIMIZED
3:09 FOR, SAY, FULL SELF-DRIVING OR
3:11 FOR THE ROBOT, THAT IS GOING TO
3:14 BE ONE OF MUSK'S BIGGEST
3:16 PRODUCTS. AND THE GPUS THAT
3:18 NVIDIA CREATES ARE GREAT, AND
3:20 THEY'RE PRETTY GOOD FOR
3:21 TRAINING AI, BUT THEY WERE
3:24 MAINLY DESIGNED FOR GAMING. AND
3:26 SO I THINK WHEN YOU SEE THESE
3:28 NEW AI FIVE, SIX CHIPS THAT ARE
3:31 BEING DESIGNED BY SPACEX AND,
3:35 AND BY TESLA NOW TOGETHER ON
3:37 TERRA FAB, THAT WILL MEAN THAT
3:40 MUSK WILL HAVE AN ALTERNATIVE
3:42 SOURCE OF SUPPLY IN
Nvidia's China chip diligence fell short: 'Chip War' author Chris Miller full transcript
0:07 >> BEAUTIFUL LIVE SHOT OF THE
0:08 CAPITOL THERE. MEANTIME,
0:10 LAWMAKERS PUSHING FOR AN
0:11 INVESTIGATION NOW INTO THE
0:13 TRUMP ADMINISTRATION'S APPROVAL
0:14 OF NVIDIA CHIP EXPORTS TO CHINA.
0:16 WANG HAS AGREED TO TESTIFY
0:17 BEFORE CONGRESS SOMETIME BEFORE
0:20 THANKSGIVING. JOINING US RIGHT
0:21 NOW IS CHRIS MILLER, ASSOCIATE
0:23 PROFESSOR AT TUFTS FLETCHER
0:24 SCHOOL AND AUTHOR OF CHIP WAR.
0:27 GOOD MORNING TO YOU, CHRIS.
0:28 YOU'VE BEEN OUR EXPERT FOR
0:29 QUITE SOME TIME ABOUT THIS
0:31 SPACE. AND SO I'LL JUST ASK YOU
0:33 AS CANDIDLY AS I CAN. DO YOU
0:35 ULTIMATELY BELIEVE THAT INSIDE
0:38 OF NVIDIA, EITHER JEN-HSUN
0:40 HUANG HIMSELF OR OTHERS HAVE
0:42 EVER BEEN AWARE THAT WHEN THEY
0:44 WERE SELLING CHIPS TO COMPANIES
0:46 LIKE MEGA SPEED OR OTHERS IN
0:47 MALAYSIA OR OTHER PARTS OF ASIA
0:49 THAT THEY WERE BEING SMUGGLED
0:51 OR BEING SHARED WITH OR BEING
0:54 ALLOWED TO ALLOW CHINESE TO USE
0:57 THESE CHIPS TO TRAIN THEIR
0:59 MODELS.
1:01 >> I THINK WE CAN SAY WITH HIGH
1:03 CONFIDENCE THE LEVEL OF DUE
1:04 DILIGENCE WAS INSUFFICIENT. WE
1:05 KNOW THAT NVIDIA OFFICIALS WERE
1:08 LOBBYING THE COMMERCE
1:09 DEPARTMENT TO SLOW DOWN
1:11 INVESTIGATIONS OF MEGA SPEED,
1:12 EVEN AS THE SINGAPOREAN
1:13 GOVERNMENT WAS ITSELF
1:15 INVESTIGATING MEGA SPEED FOR
1:16 DIVERTING CHIPS INTO CHINA. SO
1:20 THE WILLINGNESS TO DO BUSINESS
1:21 WITH FIRMS THAT WERE, AT BEST,
1:23 QUESTIONABLE SEEMS LIKE IT
1:25 OUGHT TO HAVE BEEN A RED FLAG.
1:29 >> I APPRECIATE THE
1:30 INSUFFICIENCY OF IT. I THINK
1:32 THE BIGGER QUESTION TODAY,
1:33 GIVEN EVERYTHING WE KNOW, IS
1:36 WHETHER THERE IS A HIGH
1:38 PROBABILITY OR I'M ASKING YOU
1:40 WHETHER YOU THINK THERE'S A LOW
1:41 PROBABILITY THAT ONCE EMAILS
1:44 AND TEXT MESSAGES AND ALL OF
1:47 THAT GETS SUBPOENAED, WHETHER
1:49 IT'S THROUGH CONGRESS OR THE
1:51 FBI OR SHAREHOLDER LAWSUITS,
1:54 THAT WE'RE GOING TO FIND
1:56 MATERIALS WHERE IT WASN'T JUST
1:58 INSUFFICIENT, IT WAS, AT BEST,
2:01 LOOKING THE OTHER WAY.
2:03 >> WELL, I THINK LOOKING THE
2:05 OTHER WAY IS PRETTY LIKELY. NOW,
2:06 IS THAT A VIOLATION OF THE LAW?
2:08 I THINK THAT WILL DEPEND ON THE
2:10 CIRCUMSTANCES. BUT IT'S CLEAR
2:11 THAT NVIDIA KNEW THAT MANY OF
2:13 ITS PARTNERS WERE ENGAGED IN
2:15 BUSINESS. THAT BROUGHT THEM IN
2:17 CLOSE CONTACT WITH CHINESE
2:18 CUSTOMERS THAT HAD EVERY
2:19 INCENTIVE TO VIOLATE THE LAW
2:21 AND BRING CHIPS INTO CHINA. AND
2:24 THE FACT THAT THESE
2:25 RELATIONSHIPS CONTINUED AT
2:27 SCALE, AT A TIME WHEN MULTIPLE
2:28 GOVERNMENTS WERE CONDUCTING
2:30 INVESTIGATIONS INTO THESE
2:31 CUSTOMERS, THAT, AGAIN, SHOULD
2:32 HAVE BEEN A RED FLAG. AND
2:33 THAT'S WHY CONGRESS IS GOING TO
2:34 DEMAND THAT NOT ONLY JENSEN,
2:36 BUT ALSO OTHER SENIOR NVIDIA
2:37 OFFICIALS COME IN AND TESTIFY
2:38 ABOUT THAT.
2:40 >> I JUST WONDER LONG TERM AND
2:41 I, YOU KNOW, HERE WE ARE
2:44 SPECULATING, YOU KNOW, WHAT
2:45 KIND OF PROBABILITY OR RISK YOU
2:48 PUT ON NOT JUST A CRIMINAL
2:51 INVESTIGATION, BUT A SETTLEMENT
2:52 OR FINE OF SOME SORT AGAINST
2:55 THE COMPANY. AND THEN, YOU KNOW,
2:57 WHAT DO YOU THINK THAT MEANS TO
2:58 SOME OF THE INDIVIDUALS AT THE
3:00 COMPANY?
3:01 >> I THINK IT'S CERTAINLY,
3:02 CERTAINLY POSSIBLE. AND I THINK
3:04 THERE'S A LOT OF FOLKS IN
3:05 WASHINGTON WHO WANT TO
3:06 INVESTIGATE THIS ALL THE WAY TO
3:08 THE END, BECAUSE THERE'S A
3:10 GENERAL SENSE IN WASHINGTON
3:12 THAT NVIDIA WAS ALWAYS TESTING
3:14 THE LIMITS OF WHAT WAS WRITTEN
3:16 DOWN IN THE LAW, WHILE IT WAS
3:18 SIMULTANEOUS LOBBYING TO HAVE
3:19 THE LAW CHANGE, TO ENABLE THE
3:22 COMPANY TO EXPORT EVEN MORE TO
The Housing Freeze 11/13/26 full transcript
0:00 with a CNBC your money minute. I'm
0:02 Jessica Edinger. We're heading into one
0:05 of the slowest times of the year for the
0:07 real estate business. The holidays loom
0:09 and wow, mortgage rates are still above
0:12 7% for a 30-year fixed home loan, and
0:15 that's a block for a lot of people.
0:17 >> We've crossed a very real psychological
0:19 threshold of 7%. The pressure on the
0:21 firsttime home buyer at any decision
0:23 point is affecting everything. That's
0:25 EXP Realy CEO Leo Perea on CNBC.
0:29 >> For the American consumer, it's tough
0:31 right now. Oil crossed $100 a barrel,
0:33 which translates to higher diesel prices
0:36 for freight and groceries and affecting
0:39 everything.
0:39 >> Parea tells CNBC that high prices
0:41 everywhere. That puts pressure on
0:44 wouldbe home buyers.
0:45 >> When you think about what drives
0:46 consumer demand for housing, it's always
0:49 human condition. We need more space. Uh
0:51 we got relocated to another job. You are
0:53 coming out of a lease. you have 90 days
0:55 left on it. You're deciding whether to
0:56 buy a house. You open the news and you
0:59 see it's kind of the perfect storm of
1:00 pressure, right? Cuz the diesel prices
1:02 translates to pressure at the grocery
1:04 store, which makes people think twice
1:06 before spending money.
1:08 >> The home builders have been trying to
1:09 relieve some of that pressure by
1:11 lowering their prices and buying down
1:12 mortgage rates for people just to get
1:14 them into completed new homes. Parea
1:18 says wouldbe buyers should look at newly
1:20 built communities and in towns that got
1:23 popular in CO because people are leaving
1:26 those now and home prices there have
1:28 been coming down.
1:28 >> Parts of Southwest Florida, Texas, most
1:31 of the COVID postboom markets um are
1:34 seeing sharp declines. I live in Miami,
1:36 Florida. We're seeing quite a bit of
1:38 days on market for single family homes.
1:40 >> You can read a lot more on buying a home
1:43 at cnbc.com.
1:45 I'm Jessica Edinger, CNBC.
Mad Money 11/12/26 full transcript
0:01 My mission is simple, to make you money.
0:04 I'm here to level the playing field for
0:06 all investors. There's always a bull
0:09 market somewhere and I promise to help
0:11 you find it. May have money starts now.
0:13 [music]
0:17 Hey, I'm Kramer. Welcome to Mayoney.
0:19 Welcome to Cra, my friends. I'm just
0:22 trying to make a little bit of money
0:23 here. My job is not just to entertain,
0:25 but to do some teaching. So, call me
0:26 1800 743 CNBC. Tweet me, Jim Kramer.
0:31 In the end, Jensen Wong was more of a
0:34 liability to the company he founded and
0:36 ran than a positive. The possibility of
0:39 him being a mark for a Chinese spy,
0:42 giving up key secrets, or even helping
0:45 them get the latest chips, having them
0:48 find their way to the People's Republic
0:50 cannot be ruled out. The ill- advised,
0:52 not very well, a hidden affair with one
0:54 of his direct reports, something five
0:56 invidia executives confirmed to the New
0:58 York Times, is flat out against the
1:00 rules at most companies and is
1:03 embarrassingly unprofessional.
1:07 So, his staying on as CEO of Nvidia just
1:10 because he was Nvidia to many and the
1:13 stock price would be much higher if he
1:15 went removed simply wasn't an option.
1:18 This morning he resigned and yes he did
1:20 resign in disgrace. Did we want him to
1:22 go? If we are shareholders pre- disgrace
1:25 of course not. He was an amazing CEO.
1:27 Post disgrace knowing what we know now
1:30 about the way that this brilliant man
1:32 put the institution he said he loved
1:34 into jeopardy. I have to say yes. In any
1:37 case I don't think the board had any
1:39 other choice. I'm not a mor morality
1:42 coach nor am I a board member of Nvidia.
1:45 I pine on stocks for a living. So in
1:47 this day where the Dow dipped 189
1:49 points, the S&P fell.35% the NASDAQ
1:51 dropped.39%. We have to figure out what
1:54 a Jensenless Nvidia is worth clinically.
1:58 First, let's take something I heard all
2:01 day off the table. He will not be
2:03 allowed to participate in Vidia's
2:04 affairs either in a public or or a
2:07 sidebar fashion. No, Jensen Wong has
2:09 left the building. The company wants him
2:11 as far away as possible because it wants
2:13 to isolate him and keep the multiple
2:15 investigations his actions have caused
2:17 from tainting the day-to-day operations
2:19 of this company.
2:21 Remember this, the board represents you,
2:24 not Jensen. It's bad enough that there
2:26 will be employees investigated to see if
2:28 they turned a blind eye to what might
2:29 have been a clear pipeline of high-end
2:32 Nvidia chips to the PRC via his
2:35 paramor's ties to the Communist Party.
2:37 There will also have to be an
2:38 investigation of the sorted affair Jason
2:41 Jensen Wong had with Kimberly Pal,
2:43 Nvidia's vice president of healthcare,
2:45 an important position that might not
2:47 have been handled as well as it should
2:49 have because of the relationship. So
2:51 then you ask, how come the stock didn't
2:53 go down even more today? First, I remind
2:56 you that it's been going down for months
2:58 and it's not exactly like it's expensive
3:00 here. The company reports next week and
3:02 I believe it'll be a huge quarter.
3:03 Remember this isn't sendant or Enron or
3:06 Worldcom. Horrendous financial scandals
3:10 where there was little to nothing in the
3:12 bank. That's the kind of scandal you
3:13 must run from no matter what. There's
3:15 tens of billions of dollars in the bank
3:17 here. No accounting irregularities.
3:19 This is scandal involving potential
3:22 liability from those orders procured by
3:24 a spy and the sanctions that might be
3:27 placed on Nvidia by the government.
3:29 something that is less likely now that
3:30 Jensen has been cut loose.
3:34 Second, the person named interim CEO
3:37 Colette Crest who is the current CFO. I
3:40 know people think I was close to Wong
3:42 and maintain a good relationship, but
3:44 let me tell you something. My principal
3:45 contact at the company have been Colette
3:47 Crest. She runs the conference call, an
3:50 amazing conference call. She's the
3:52 person who explains things to me and
3:53 answers my questions. Crest knows more
3:56 about the company than Wong does. Not
3:58 the technology, but how the company
4:00 works. She is tough as nails. Yeah, the
4:03 kinds of nails that come out of a nail
4:04 gun. To say that she doesn't suffer
4:06 fools gladly understates her precision
4:09 and her rigor and the lack of viewers if
4:12 you ask something stupid, which I have
4:14 done and regretted immediately. She will
4:17 hold things together well in the
4:19 interim. And with Crest at the helm, the
4:21 idea that there is a financial scandal,
4:23 the kind that makes you have to sell the
4:24 stock goes away because she is the
4:26 keeper of the numbers. She will be on
4:28 full display when they report next
4:30 Tuesday, as she always is on the
4:32 conference calls. I say bravo. The last
4:35 reason that the market didn't fall apart
4:37 today is the upcoming anthropic IPO.
4:39 We're on the verge of what might be the
4:40 biggest IPO of all time and the
4:42 ramifications for the semi, especially
4:44 Nvidia. and that the ecosystem that
4:46 Jensen created with all these
4:48 investments are now going to pay off.
4:50 They may be actually be able to recoup
4:52 most of those investments once this
4:53 happens. Now remember your across
4:55 disciplines here people as I told CBC
4:57 Investing Club members today during our
4:59 morning meeting streaming show at 10:20.
5:01 If you're one of the myriad Nvidia
5:03 millionaires the club and Jensen Wong
5:04 created, thank you Jensen for doing
5:06 that. You need to be sure you take at
5:09 least some of those profits off the
5:11 table. Don't ever turn a successful
5:13 investment into an unsuccessful trade,
5:15 no matter who it's with. We don't know
5:17 what else is going to come out from what
5:20 will almost certainly be multiple
5:21 investigations. Whatever it is, I I
5:23 don't think it's going to be any good.
5:25 You don't want to give up all of your
5:26 gains if the stock falls further. It
5:29 fell further today after many of the
5:30 analysts jump ship and downgrade the
5:32 stock from buy to hold, but I think
5:33 there could be many more of those ahead.
5:36 We don't know what Nvidia's competitor
5:38 is going to do. We know that AMD has
5:39 been catching up with its own product
5:41 lines. Broadcom's quite competitive.
5:42 Google and Amazon less so, but Amazon
5:44 does have what may soon be a $50 billion
5:47 semiconductor business. That's the
5:48 second half of 27. Can they catch up to
5:51 Nvidia with its clear four-year product
5:53 roadmap? If you think, as the analysts
5:56 seem to believe that the other 42,000
5:59 other employees don't matter much, then
6:02 you're going to get cold feet. Even if
6:04 you see the great numbers next Tuesday,
6:06 I can hear the rousing about last good
6:07 quarter all over the place.
6:09 We know that the investigations might
6:11 lead to international export
6:12 curtailments which would would hurt the
6:15 business and lead to number cuts. That
6:17 means that no matter how low the price
6:18 during each multiple gets, the stock
6:20 could still go lower. So where do I come
6:22 out? We've made, you know, look, we've
6:25 made fortunes in Nvidia for the travel
6:27 trust, but we still have too much with
6:29 the stock here at 166. That means it it
6:32 cuts to selling some when we are not
6:35 restricted from doing so. and we've been
6:36 restricted for ages and ages and had to
6:38 ride this one down. But here's something
6:41 you might be happy about. I did a small
6:43 canvas today of executives who I thought
6:45 could be that Tim Cook to Jensen Steve
6:48 Jobs tall order as Cook was a first
6:52 ballot hall of famer. But the caliber of
6:54 candidates here who were interested in
6:56 this job made me feel that there won't
6:59 be a better Nvidia, just a different
7:02 one. one that is better organized
7:04 perhaps and not just throwing money
7:06 around to wrap up companies in the
7:08 Nvidia ecosystem. Maybe we'll get
7:10 someone who decides it's okay to take
7:12 profits on the company's successful
7:14 investments in other companies now that
7:16 the anthropic deal will liquefy the
7:18 ecosystem that Jensen created. Maybe
7:20 we'll have a CEO who does more to
7:22 highlight the company's other 42,000
7:25 employees. The ones who I think are
7:26 insulted by what's happening. The ones
7:29 that don't wear the leather jackets.
7:31 They exist, too. The bottom line, am I
7:34 mad about Jensen? Yes. I liked him so
7:37 damn much. I am crushed by this. I
7:40 thought he was a better guy. Did he
7:42 betray me? Nah. No. It's my job to not
7:45 be betrayed, to be smarter, to have my
7:47 eyes more wide open. He didn't betray
7:49 me. Did he betray you, the shareholders?
7:52 Yeah. End of story. Dennis in Ohio.
7:55 Dennis.
7:56 >> Hey, how are you, Jim?
7:58 >> Dennis, I'm okay. How about you? Hey, I
8:00 woke up today, so it's a good day,
8:02 right?
8:03 >> You know what? I actually said that this
8:05 morning, so yeah, the answer is yeah to
8:07 that. Okay, [laughter]
8:09 >> I'm calling on SNOK. It's gone from 80
8:12 in August down in the low 60s now.
8:14 >> Yeah,
8:15 >> they're having having another record
8:16 year. Uh keep raising their dividends,
8:19 low PE ratio. I just don't get it.
8:22 >> No, I like it. Well, it's going down
8:24 because people feel the war's over. I I
8:25 remember the day it came public and I
8:27 thought, what a great idea. But then
8:28 ago, I was a a son of, you know, grew up
8:30 in Philadelphia. I think this thing's a
8:32 great piece of paper. I think you're in
8:33 good shape. Just own it. If it goes down
8:35 to 6%, buy more. Let's go to Robert New
8:37 York. Who's Robert?
8:39 >> Jim, so nice to hear your voice and how
8:41 positive you are. And I got to tell you
8:43 something. You're doing a great job for
8:45 us with the ups and downs. You're making
8:48 us steady and you're basically telling
8:50 us what to do, which is nibble away at
8:52 some of the stocks going down. And in
8:55 the end, it doesn't matter because this
8:57 has happened 50 times throughout Wall
8:58 Street where the market has corrected up
9:01 10% down 15%. So if you play the Kramer
9:04 rule, which is how to make money in any
9:06 market, you can't lose in the end. You
9:09 will not lose if you listen to Robert.
9:11 You can't see right now, but I'm walking
9:12 down a street right now that I walked
9:15 down in 1981 when the Dow was at a
9:18 thousand and everyone told me it is so
9:20 ridiculously overvalued. Keep your money
9:23 in CDs. I didn't know what a CD was, but
9:25 I knew what a stock was, and I crushed
9:26 it. All right. So, go ahead. I'm sorry.
9:27 >> You cr That's why you are the top guy on
9:30 Wall Street. That's why you're here to
9:31 help.
9:32 >> And there's like guys who are
9:33 billionaires and they're like, "All we
9:34 do is hear from them." And they're
9:35 fantastic because when you're a
9:36 billionaire, you're fantastic.
9:38 >> Just kidding.
9:39 >> You're fantastic because you help the
9:41 common man. And then
9:42 >> I did good. That's what I want. That's
9:44 what Emma wants me to do. That's my
9:46 daughter. Go ahead.
9:47 >> And she's great, your daughter.
9:48 Phenomenal. But anyway,
9:49 >> I like the folds and potato chips. Yeah.
9:52 Let's make the Let's make the listeners
9:54 some money. Or you tell me if I'm wrong
9:56 here. Okay. This next company's latest
9:58 results throw a sharp earnings reset
10:01 with weak appliance demand, inflation,
10:02 and housing softness, pressuring the
10:04 sales and the margins. Now, the
10:06 management is relying on price
10:07 increases, manufacturing changes, and a
10:10 $290 million structural savings to
10:12 support a profitability recovery in
10:14 2027. Now, I own this stock. I bought it
10:18 when the earnings got touted. I met this
10:20 guy out. He used to work for the
10:21 company. He goes, "This is a good
10:22 company down the road. It shouldn't be
10:24 this cheap."
10:27 >> Baby,
10:28 >> uh, you know, okay, so listen, I love
10:30 the I love the product, but maybe it may
10:32 need a kind of a CEO refresh. Uh,
10:35 because someone has to pay for that
10:37 decline, [music] and I think it has to
10:39 be the CEO. I like the guy very much,
10:41 but the decline is too much. I thank you
10:43 for your kind words. If I help the
10:45 common for the regular person, [music]
10:46 that's a heck of a lot better than
10:47 helping all the billionaires I used to
10:49 help. They were never that appreciative
10:51 anyway during group. Anyway, on May
10:54 money tonight, Craft Hind gave a very
10:56 optimistic investor [music] day
10:57 presentation. It could ring today's NYC
10:59 bell. I'm finding out more about the
11:01 path [music] for packaged goods with the
11:03 with the CEO who I just think is great.
11:05 Then I'm rounding out my series [music]
11:06 on anthropics hotly anticipated IPO with
11:10 some of the more unusual aspects of the
11:11 deal [music] that you need to know
11:12 about. And Mona's promising cancer
11:14 vaccine has been propelling the stock
11:16 higher this year. What else is in the
11:18 pipeline? I'm going to find out with a
11:19 company CEO. [music] So stay with RAM.
11:25 [music]
11:30 >> Don't miss [music] a second of MadMoney.
11:31 Follow Jim Kramer on X. Have a question?
11:34 [music] Tweet Kramer #madmentions.
11:38 Send Jim an email to [email protected]
11:41 or give us a call [music] at
11:42 1800743CNBC.
11:45 Miss something? Head to madmoney.c
11:48 cnbc.com. [music]
11:56 [music]
12:01 This will be exciting and it's not about
12:03 Nvidia. This morning, Craft Hinds, the
12:05 package food giant, rang the opening
12:07 bell to celebrate the move from the
12:08 NASDAQ to New York Stock Exchange. Then
12:10 it's a terrific investor day. The
12:12 company said it expects sales and
12:13 operating profits to start growing again
12:15 in the second half of next year. She's
12:17 consistent in accelerated growth by
12:19 2029. Since taking the helm nearly a
12:22 year ago, CEO Steve Kaine has invested
12:24 700 million into the business, hired 400
12:26 new employees. This is so different from
12:28 the old one. Let's check in with Steve,
12:30 the CEO of Craft Clients to find out
12:31 more about his comeback plan. Steve, I
12:33 am so glad to see you're here and I just
12:35 had how much you invest in the company,
12:38 but let's just get started by how much
12:39 have you invested yourself.
12:41 >> Well, thanks for having me, Jim, as
12:42 always. So, shortly after I started with
12:45 the company, obviously I'm paid a lot in
12:47 uh in in stock, but I went into the open
12:49 market and bought $5 million worth of
12:50 Craftine shares because I like to put my
12:52 money where my mouth is on the team that
12:55 I'm going to put together.
12:56 >> I know you sure do. I was going through
12:57 your amazing deck and you had this line.
13:00 I think it kind of epitomizes where we
13:01 are. We always had the right assets to
13:04 win. Now, we are realizing their full
13:07 potential. Those assets are pretty
13:08 great, aren't they?
13:09 >> They're fantastic. Think about the Hines
13:11 brand. I mean, Hines is loved everywhere
13:13 around the world, rejected nowhere,
13:15 right? We've got a huge opportunity to
13:17 grow Hines in its home market of the
13:19 United States, which we've returned it
13:20 to growth. We've got huge opportunities
13:22 all around the world. Hines in Brazil is
13:25 doing phenomenally well. Hines in China
13:28 is opening up whole new occasions with
13:30 eggs and breakfast. And so, Hines plays
13:33 everywhere. Hines soup has just been
13:35 introduced in Canada. It's off to a
13:37 flying start. So, Hines is a phenomenal
13:40 brand and it it really is gold.
13:42 >> Now, you are actually reaching people
13:44 differently from just traditional
13:46 advertising. You've embraced the
13:48 channels that I always thought people
13:49 should start embracing, Meta and Tik
13:50 Tok.
13:51 >> Yeah, there's no question. Look, today's
13:53 consumer shows up differently than they
13:55 did historically. You still have to be
13:56 in historic traditional places, but we
13:59 have to be where the consumer are. We
14:01 has to we have to go meet the consumer
14:02 where they are. That's social, that's
14:04 digital, and the future is it's agentic
14:07 as well. So, we have to continue to
14:09 evolve our capabilities. We have to
14:11 invest in our capabilities, and we have
14:12 to meet the consumer where they are.
14:14 >> State of the consumer seems to be um
14:16 able to buy both your highest end
14:18 products and your more middling
14:19 products.
14:20 >> Yeah. I think, you know, the the
14:21 consumer right now, it stopped getting
14:23 worse, right? The consumer is not in a
14:25 great spot. Uh but they're not in a
14:27 terrible spot. The job market's strong.
14:29 Uh you know, inflation is still a little
14:31 too challenging. gas prices a little too
14:33 challenging, but you know, we're a
14:35 staple in many, many cases, and we're a
14:37 treat in other cases. But we've been
14:39 able to connect with consumers, hold up
14:41 our business, improve our trends, uh, in
14:44 this country and around the world. And
14:45 we expect into next year, probably the
14:47 first half of 27 is still going to be
14:49 somewhat of a challenge, a little bit
14:51 more inflation, but that's okay. That's
14:53 okay. The back half of 27, we start to
14:56 see a lot more a lot more opportunities
14:58 to really get ourselves back to growth.
14:59 Well, one of the reason besides the ex
15:01 moving to the exchange that I wanted to
15:03 have you on was is that I've always
15:05 liked your work, but I did doubt you and
15:07 Kellogg. I thought that Kellogg were
15:08 dead brands that there was nothing
15:10 there. I didn't do it on air, but uh you
15:14 uh did something rather remarkable
15:15 Kellogg. You created a huge amount of
15:17 wealth. How did you go about doing that
15:19 when other people didn't see anything?
15:21 Well, I think the mistake that was made
15:24 at Craft Hind before I arrived in the
15:26 last several years is this notion that
15:28 there's a forever brand. That brands can
15:30 just live on the history of their past.
15:32 That's not true. But equally, brands
15:34 that are existed for a long time are not
15:37 necessarily destined for the dust spin
15:39 of history. And that's what a lot of
15:41 people thought about the brands at Craft
15:42 Hind. And there's simply not. When you
15:44 look at Hines, which I've already talked
15:46 about, but craft mac and cheese, people
15:48 said 90 years old, best days are past,
15:51 new innovation is coming from smaller
15:55 companies. Best days are well, we
15:56 innovated. We launched Craft Power Mac.
16:00 We launched Craft Restaurant Mac and
16:02 Cheese Restaurant Edition. And the brand
16:04 is back to growth. And in Canada, we
16:07 launched a ramen, a cheesy ramen.
16:09 >> Cheesy ramen
16:10 >> under the KD.
16:10 >> Now, I saw that I said, "You got to be
16:12 kidding me." We sold out uh three months
16:14 worth of stock in a week. We're going to
16:16 introduce that next year. So, you have
16:18 to innovate. You have to bring new news.
16:19 You have to bring excitement with your
16:21 brands.
16:22 >> So, is high pre high protein Jell-O is
16:24 that going to be in in a a Costco or a
16:26 Walmart? Yeah, absolutely. And it tastes
16:28 delicious. You know, one of the problems
16:30 with protein is you can't necessarily It
16:33 doesn't go with everything. It's hard to
16:35 match the flavors. Sometimes it's
16:36 chalky. Sometimes it's off-putting to uh
16:39 you know, put into existing brands. But
16:41 [clears throat] our R&D team has cracked
16:43 the code. The chocolate's my favorite.
16:45 Chocolate um jello- pudding with protein
16:47 I think is going to be a real hit.
16:48 >> Okay. So, Philadelphia Cream Cheese is a
16:50 nice brand. Always felt that it was
16:52 under marketed, underdone. Are you
16:54 blowing it out?
16:56 >> Yeah. So, um Philadelphia Cream Cheese
16:58 is a phenomenal brand. We're doing a lot
17:01 especially next year. Uh and it's going
17:03 to be protein le as well. We've got a
17:04 big opportunity to drive protein to
17:07 steal some share from Cottage Cheese.
17:09 Uh, and that's going to come through the
17:10 Philadelphia name. We're going to do
17:12 other things in the back half of next
17:14 year that I think will be equally as
17:16 exciting. But it's a it's one of our
17:18 biggest share gainers this year.
17:20 Philadelphia Cream.
17:21 >> Now, people wanted before, you know, the
17:23 original plan was to split the company
17:24 in two. What did you see that you knew
17:27 that wasn't right?
17:28 >> I saw a lot that was fixable. I saw a
17:31 lot of own goals that we had done. And
17:33 if we spent all of this year separating
17:36 the business into two separate
17:37 companies, we would have continued to
17:39 underinvest in it and we would have
17:41 invested in the wrong things which are
17:43 bankers and lawyers to separate the
17:45 business. We would have ended up with
17:46 two suboptimal businesses. By pausing
17:49 that and by stopping it and by putting
17:51 the 700 incremental dollars on top of
17:54 what we're already spending against the
17:56 brands, I thought we'd be one bigger,
17:58 stronger company. The other thing that a
18:00 lot of businesses like ours have
18:02 forgotten about is scale can be an
18:04 advantage, but you have to know what to
18:06 do with that scale. And so we were going
18:08 to cut the company in half and become
18:10 subscale, but instead we're a $25
18:13 billion business that's going to be
18:15 growing. Again, that's much more
18:17 powerful than two businesses that are
18:18 separated, that are suboptimal, that are
18:20 not growing.
18:21 >> All right, la last question for you,
18:22 Steve, is is that I did you mention
18:25 about the brands or forever brands. I do
18:27 think that certain brands I thought had
18:30 aged out. I thought that both Craft and
18:32 Hind had aged out. That's clearly not
18:35 the case.
18:36 >> It's not the case. And I'll give you an
18:37 example. So, we we rang the bell of the
18:39 stock exchange this morning. Before
18:40 that, we were outside. You know, it was
18:42 all wonderful. We had the Kool-Aid Man
18:44 outside. We had a crowd of New Yorkers
18:47 so excited about seeing the Kool-Aid
18:49 Man, right? They'll buy the t-shirt, but
18:51 we have to contemporize it. We have to
18:53 innovate. We have to get people to want
18:55 to buy the product as well. And we can
18:57 do that because the brands loved.
18:59 >> You sound as fired up as when you did
19:01 the Kellogg. One of the greatest trades
19:03 ever.
19:03 >> Fired up. It's a great company. It's an
19:05 important company. It deserves a bright
19:07 future. And that's what my team and I
19:09 are bound and determined to deliver. A
19:11 bright future for Craft Hind.
19:13 >> I I got to go all in because I I I seen
19:16 you do it once. I think you're going to
19:18 do it again.
19:19 >> I want to thank Steve K. Lane, CEO of
19:21 Craft Hinds. Look guys, I often point to
19:23 decks and they're hard to understand. Is
19:26 there really anything hard to understand
19:27 about ketchup [music] and Philly cream
19:29 cheese? No. May have money's back after
19:31 the break. Thank you, Steve. Thanks,
19:33 Jim.
19:35 Coming up, Kramer's wrapping up his
19:37 anthropic IPO series by identifying what
19:40 else you need to know beyond the
19:42 company's financials. Next,
19:56 Every night this week, I've been
19:58 spending some time trying to prepare you
20:00 for next week's historic Anthropic IPO.
20:04 I've been covering the story from all
20:05 angles, explaining the stakes and the
20:07 broad terms of the deal, looking at
20:08 Anthropic's impressive growth, and
20:10 examining the company's complicated
20:13 profitability profile. Tonight, I want
20:15 to wrap things up for this know your IPO
20:18 series with a quick run through of all
20:19 sorts of other considerations for this
20:21 anthropic deal. Things that aren't
20:23 reflected in the company's financials,
20:24 which is what I focused on so far. I'm
20:26 going to start with the pros. And the
20:28 first thing to call out is the huge cash
20:30 balance that Anthropic will have after
20:33 its IPO. I've noted the company had $132
20:36 billion in cash, cash equivalents, and
20:37 short-term investments at the end of
20:39 September. And it could add around
20:41 hundred billion in cash from next week's
20:43 offering. Now, we do know that they're
20:45 going to need that cash with some $900
20:48 billion in compute commitments on the
20:50 horizon. That's a great buffer to start.
20:53 Another thing I like is the fact that
20:54 90% of contributions to Anthropic's code
20:57 base are actually being written by
20:59 Claude at this point. Just in the third
21:01 quarter, Anthropic saw a 45 times
21:04 increase in code contributed per
21:06 engineer from 2024 levels. That's called
21:09 productivity. In other words, the
21:11 product is increasingly making itself
21:12 and also finding ways to improve itself.
21:14 For example, using compute more
21:16 efficiently. This has all sorts of
21:18 positive benefits. It makes Anthropic
21:20 more efficient. Of course, I don't think
21:21 it's coincidence that the company reach
21:23 profitability at least on an adjusted
21:25 basis as this has happened and it allows
21:28 Anthropic to build new models and
21:30 products faster. All right, now to the
21:32 open questions. The first one is about
21:34 pricing. Anthropic has been cutting
21:36 prices for many of its models recently,
21:38 which some have seen as a bearish
21:41 development and acknowledgment that
21:43 customers are chafing at their claw
21:45 bills and looking for other options like
21:47 the openweight models that are so
21:48 inexpensive. That said, I was encouraged
21:51 to see that Anthropic's revenue growth
21:53 remains strong in October after many of
21:55 these price cuts went through. So, hey,
21:56 they may have the swing right companies
21:58 finding other ways to boost
21:59 [clears throat] revenues as it cuts base
22:01 prices like adding search charges. It's
22:04 actually speed search charges and lower
22:06 prices might be encouraging more overall
22:08 use of claw. Still, I'm going to watch
22:10 the next few months closely to see how
22:11 these price cuts impact the business.
22:14 Now, the next question, what's the next
22:17 big use case going to be? I've told you
22:21 that the extreme growth for Anthropic
22:24 recently has come from primarily code,
22:26 Claude Code, okay, the company's coding
22:29 agent gaining traction in the
22:31 enterprise. And I still think Claude
22:32 Code has plenty of growth ahead, but for
22:36 Anthropic's revenue to reach the levels
22:38 it needs to, and there's some incredible
22:39 levels that they got to reach, I want to
22:41 see more hit products from the company.
22:44 Anthropic debuted the next major
22:45 product, Claude Co-work, earlier this
22:47 year, and they offer some compelling
22:49 stats about re about revenue ramping for
22:52 co-work much more quickly than it did
22:54 for Claude Code. They also rolled the
22:56 out the industry specific tools and just
22:59 this week Anthropic announced some new
23:01 products that intend to take on
23:02 Microsoft Office. Hey, maybe those catch
23:05 on. But what are the use cases that are
23:07 going to lead to the next 100 billion in
23:09 revenue for Anthropic? It might be cyber
23:12 security given how good Claude is at
23:14 spotting code vulnerabilities. Anthropic
23:16 also says that life sciences and
23:17 robotics could be major end markets, but
23:20 we'll have to see if those things pan
23:22 out as well as they expect them to.
23:25 Finally, for the unknowns, how is
23:27 anthropics safety ethos going to impact
23:30 the story? Anthropic CEO Dario Amade
23:34 loves to remind everyone periodically
23:36 about how dangerous frontier AI models
23:38 can be. If he is serious about pacing
23:41 the frontier, is that negative for
23:43 revenue growth? But Anthropic has also
23:45 built its brand about around safety. And
23:47 perhaps that's an asset in a world where
23:49 customers are both eager to adopt AI for
23:51 their business and somewhat wary of it.
23:53 I don't know, a little contradictory to
23:54 me though. The that leads directly to my
23:58 first con. Remember I did the pros.
24:00 Here's the cons, which is the question
24:02 of regulation, even potential liability.
24:03 On the regulatory front, we've already
24:05 seen this year that a new precedent has
24:07 been set where the leading AI labs have
24:10 to work with the government before
24:11 releasing new frontier models. And after
24:14 last year's election, I also wonder
24:16 whether more Democrats in Washington is
24:18 a bad thing for the AI industry. Soon,
24:20 we'll look to 2028 and speculate about
24:23 what a new less AI friendly
24:26 administration really might mean. For
24:28 now, I just worry that there will be
24:30 more regulatory constraints for the
24:31 company either at the infrastructure
24:33 level or at its for its more powerful
24:35 new models. As for liabilities,
24:38 I see here uh there's some issues either
24:42 that an anthropic model is used for some
24:44 major cyber attack and that creates
24:47 legal risk for the company or as the
24:50 company's models get increasingly
24:51 autonomous. They do something they
24:53 shouldn't which negatively impacts the
24:54 customer. Now, I'll add here that I
24:56 think these regulatory and liability
24:58 risks are more of a concern for OpenAI
25:00 than they are for philanthropic given
25:01 the latter safety first culture, but
25:03 they are still risk you need to consider
25:05 for this first major AI IPO. Finally, I
25:09 want to talk about the company's float
25:10 and you got to pay attention. This is
25:12 the biggest issue for me. Uh the float
25:14 and its lockup expiration schedule.
25:17 Important details that will go a long
25:18 way determining how the stock trades
25:21 initially based on the current numbers.
25:24 Next week's offering represents around
25:26 6% of anthropic shares outstanding. Very
25:28 similar proportion to what we saw from
25:30 SpaceX in June. The one difference here
25:32 is that a trunch of shares from
25:34 nonfounder employees will be unlocked on
25:37 the first day of trading. That would
25:38 bring Anthropics float up to around 7%
25:40 on the first day of trading,
25:43 but that's still very small. The rest of
25:46 the shares will be unlocked gradually
25:47 over the course of the next year via a
25:50 series of 22 different lockup releases
25:53 which start less than a month after the
25:55 IPO. The concern here is that we will
25:56 see a big pop initially as excited
25:58 investors are competing for a small
26:00 number of shares. Then as more shares
26:02 get unlocked every few weeks that's
26:04 going to put downward pressure on
26:06 entropic the people who are too eager
26:08 they get hurt. Basically, I fear that
26:10 we're going to see a repeat of what
26:11 happened with SpaceX where the stock
26:12 squeezed from its IPO of 27.35 to a high
26:15 of $225 on its third day of trading,
26:18 then came right back down. SpaceX hasn't
26:21 come close to that initial high since
26:22 then, but not because the story hasn't
26:25 gotten better. I'd argue it has. It's
26:27 just supply and demand. Unfortunately,
26:28 as I told you last Friday, there's still
26:30 many more SpaceX shares that have yet to
26:32 be unlocked. So, there you go. There are
26:34 all kinds of unique considerations for
26:36 this anthropic deal. Some are positive,
26:38 some are negative, and some are
26:39 legitimate open questions, just things
26:41 I'm not sure about. I'll have more on
26:43 the deal next week, of course. But for
26:45 now, I hope this series that we have run
26:49 has you feeling more informed about
26:51 whether to participate in this historic
26:53 IPO. Here's the bottom line. When the
26:55 deal terms are finalized next week, I'm
26:57 going to give you my more formal opinion
26:59 on whether you should buy anthropic
27:01 shares initially or not. For now, I'll
27:03 just tell you that I'm wary of doing so.
27:06 Why? Well, because I I fear a hot open.
27:09 But either way, this is the deal to
27:11 watch. Let's take some calls. Let's go
27:14 to Mark in Michigan. Mark,
27:17 >> Mr. Kramer, it's an honor to speak with
27:19 you, sir.
27:20 >> Oh, thank you, Mark. What's happening?
27:23 >> Well, I've heard you talk a lot about
27:24 lamb research and I'm wondering if at
27:26 this point it's a good entry point.
27:28 >> I think it is. I think it's come down
27:30 enough. I think Tim Archer does a
27:31 terrific job. It is absolutely my
27:32 favorite. Remember all the intellectual
27:34 property when it comes to semiconductors
27:36 really is from the semiconductor capital
27:37 equipment and Lamb's got the best. All
27:39 right, much more mad money ahead
27:41 including my exclusive with Mona.
27:43 [music] Then like I said earlier, I am
27:45 deeply saddened by the news out of
27:46 Nvidia. I'm leaving you with [music] a
27:48 few more thoughts, some a degree costic
27:52 about the situation and oil falls rapid
27:54 fire in tonight's edition of the
27:55 lightning round. So stay [music] with
28:02 >> [music]
28:07 >> Well, you look at the stock of Maderna
28:08 go on August 18th, Madna was a $63
28:11 stock. The next day, it closed above 174
28:15 after Mona and Merc announced that
28:18 adding their personalized cancer shot to
28:20 Merc's Kruda helped keep melanoma from
28:23 coming back after surgery. Merna is now
28:25 up more than 680% for 2026. It did fall
28:29 7% today though. Last week, strong
28:31 vaccine sales helped MONA turn a
28:33 surprise profit and the company raised
28:36 its fullear sales forecast. Today, Mona
28:38 held this analyst day at the
28:40 Massachusetts plant that's already
28:41 making those personalized shots for
28:43 clinical trials. Earlier today, we
28:45 caught up with Stefan Vansel, Merna CEO.
28:49 Take a look.
28:52 Stefan, welcome to the show on a very
28:54 big day for you.
28:57 Yeah, thank you Jim for having me.
28:58 >> Well, I've got to tell you, I've been
29:00 following your progress and first I I
29:02 want to just cover the numbers. You're m
29:04 you're doing so much better. You've got
29:06 a the best flu shot that I can tell.
29:08 You're doing uh co vaccines. People are
29:10 telling me they're the ones that don't
29:12 hurt and don't make you sick. So, you've
29:14 done some traditional things that are
29:15 really just making you a lot of money.
29:18 Correct.
29:20 >> Yeah. I mean, we have really invested on
29:21 our infectious disease business. You
29:23 know, historically that's why we started
29:25 our first product, but we never slept on
29:27 our laurels. You know, the MXP spike
29:29 product, which is the new COVID vaccine,
29:31 is not only new because of a strain,
29:33 which of course we have to do to give
29:34 you the best protection, but we totally
29:37 re-engineered the product. It's a new
29:38 product, like a 2.0 COVID shot, and the
29:41 dose is 1/5if of a dose of what we had
29:44 initially. So, that's why the side
29:45 effect is much better.
29:46 >> All right, that's the one I've got to
29:48 get. Now, I I just want to I usually
29:50 don't do this, but I want to get
29:52 personal for a second. My daughter had
29:55 melanoma bad.
29:57 >> Oh, I'm sorry.
29:57 >> No, but listen. Listen. Your hope
30:02 is that your vaccine can make it so she
30:05 can go back outside and lead a normal
30:08 life and perhaps have a greater chance
30:11 of it being cut back. So we're following
30:14 this thing intensely with everything
30:16 that I can't read the journal and newing
30:18 journal and understand but can you tell
30:20 us where this is because you are the
30:22 hope for tens of thousands of people.
30:26 Oh you're very kind. Well as you know
30:28 we've been working on 10 years on this
30:30 idea of can you teach the immune system
30:33 of a patient
30:35 how to recognize the cancer of a patient
30:37 and to go eat the cancer. That was the
30:39 basic idea and as you I'm sure read a
30:42 lot of people thought it was undoable
30:44 and it's true that the track record of
30:46 cancer vaccine behind us was not very
30:48 good but we thought with a progress with
30:51 made in MRA with what we learned with
30:53 infectious disease vaccine that our
30:55 approach had a serious chance and we
30:57 took that chance and to be fair MC was a
31:00 fantastic partner to take that chance
31:02 and that risk with us and what it does
31:04 basically is when somebody has cancer
31:07 you take a biopsy of a tumor. You take a
31:10 blood draw of a blood and then you
31:13 sequence you next gen sequence. You read
31:14 all the letters of the DNA of a cancer
31:16 and the healthy cell. You send them to
31:18 the cloud and you compare letter by
31:20 letter where is the mutation where is
31:22 the cancer because what we know today is
31:24 cancer is a disease of DNA mutation of
31:28 DNA and then what we do is we
31:30 individualize and I'm just behind me. We
31:32 basically individualize we make a
31:34 product for one human at a time where we
31:36 put in a cassette of one mRNA molecule
31:39 34 mutation of cancer of that patient.
31:43 It's injected in intramuscular every 3
31:45 weeks for nine doors and as you know you
31:48 saw the data recently the data are
31:50 fantastic. I mean compared to ketra
31:52 which is an amazing drug in melanoma
31:54 nobody has been able since 2018 to do
31:57 better than than kitra in melanoma.
31:59 Several companies tried there was three
32:01 phase three that failed but we were able
32:04 to show a 42% improvement for patient
32:07 and what is even more remarkable if you
32:09 look at a phase two study where we have
32:11 five years of data the phase three had
32:13 only two years of data so far we'll of
32:15 course share more data as we get the
32:17 data we show that the data improves over
32:19 time why because the T- cell we created
32:22 in your body because of our mRNA have
32:25 memory
32:26 >> they stay with you to fight cancer
32:28 coming back
32:29 >> wow Well, uh dare I ask when? Uh we're
32:34 all waiting. Uh we have oncologists that
32:37 we check with. They want to be sure that
32:39 things are right before we plunge in.
32:42 When do you think?
32:44 So, as we've said with our partners at
32:46 Mercer, we are working very very
32:48 deliberately to try to get the filing to
32:51 the FDA before the end of the year and
32:53 then we're expecting assuming a good
32:56 review by the regulators that we should
32:58 be able to get the product available to
33:01 Americans.
33:01 >> Well, I'm so glad. I mean, I think if
33:03 you don't have it or you don't even
33:04 look, you can go to the Reddit page for
33:06 the melanomies. You can feel for what
33:08 people have. But as a parent and the
33:10 daughter, we are I never create false
33:13 hopes for for cancer. Lost my mom for
33:16 kidney cancer very very young. I know
33:18 that those who create false hopes are
33:20 not good. You have done the opposite.
33:22 You've not played it high. You have
33:25 waited and waited. How about other
33:27 cancers? Are there hopes for it without
33:30 getting too far ahead and making feel
33:33 people feel that there's a a magic
33:35 bullet out there? Sure. And I agree with
33:38 you Jim. It's very important people are
33:40 suffering with cancer. It's very
33:42 important for them and the family not to
33:43 have false hope. So what we're doing
33:46 beyond melanoma is we have studies on
33:48 going in five different tumor types
33:50 including lung cancer. In lung we're
33:53 both looking at people that have stage
33:55 two or three of lung disease. But we're
33:57 also trying in tisaran. That's the name
34:00 of our medicine in tisaran by itself in
34:03 people that have stage one lung cancer
34:06 because we think given it has a very
34:08 good safety profile our medicine it
34:10 could potentially be used earlier in
34:12 disease to help people get back to a
34:14 normal life without sometime the
34:15 terrible side effect of cancer
34:17 treatment. So we should get data in
34:20 kidney cancer pretty soon either end of
34:23 this year or next year. Those are
34:25 eventdriven studies when people have
34:27 recurrence of disease. So of course we
34:29 do not control the timing. The one after
34:31 should be bladder cancer and the one
34:33 after should be lung. So when we have a
34:35 data like we've always done we will
34:37 share the data with the community
34:38 including the medical community so we
34:40 can review the data. Last night the New
34:43 England Journal of Medicine as you know
34:44 the most prestigious journal release the
34:47 full data set with all the appendix so
34:49 all the melanoma doctors can look at the
34:52 data and understand what the product can
34:54 do and what the product doesn't do. And
34:56 that's where we are and we're going to
34:58 keep investing in the science because as
35:00 you know software is part of drug
35:02 because we have to select from hundreds
35:03 of thousands of mutation 34 that goes in
35:06 the cassette. We think we can learn by
35:09 going and mining the data in a phase
35:11 three study and figure out what can we
35:13 tweak in the software what was working
35:15 well in the software what maybe can we
35:18 improve so we can potentially even
35:19 improve that success rate. Again, it's
35:21 an hypothesis. We need to do the work
35:23 and look at the data. But I'm really
35:25 believing that because of the progress
35:27 that the medical field is making and
35:29 because of the access of AI, when we can
35:31 look at all those data, think about it,
35:34 a, 100 patients, that's a lot of data.
35:37 When you look at all the T- cell and the
35:40 biomarkers and so on, but looking at
35:42 that with big data, this should be able
35:44 to get insight and then to have a
35:46 discussion with the regulators. Is is
35:48 there a way to upgrade the software?
35:50 >> Well, look, congratulations and thank
35:52 you for helping everyone who has this
35:54 disease and their family members. Uh we
35:58 all look forward after that New England
36:00 Journal of Medicine to start getting
36:02 lined up and getting our doctors to be
36:04 aware. Uh remarkable job. I remember
36:06 when I met you, you said this could
36:08 happen and then we got way laid by CO of
36:10 which you helped solve. But uh this is
36:13 nothing short of remarkable and I want
36:15 to thank you uh for everything you've
36:17 done not just for the shareholders but
36:18 for the parents and for the patients.
36:20 Good to see you Stephan.
36:22 >> Thank you so much very kindly.
36:24 >> Absolutely. That's Stephan Benelli. He's
36:26 the Mona CEO at a remarkable moment
36:29 [music] and a great shareholder meeting.
36:31 >> Coming up you've got questions. Kramer's
36:34 got the answers. Get charged up for a
36:36 fast fire lightning round next.
36:43 >> [music]
36:47 >> It is time for the lightning round
36:53 [music]
36:57 and then the lightning round is over.
36:59 Are you ready?
37:01 Dick in Virginia. Dick.
37:04 >> Hi Jim. I'm a club member and I just got
37:07 your book in the mail. Yay.
37:09 >> Oh, thank you. Thank you. Let's go to
37:11 work.
37:12 >> Yeah, I I saw that stock. It said it's
37:16 called Comvault. They're in the [music]
37:18 data recovery business. Um any thoughts
37:22 on it?
37:23 >> I saw the CEO on [music] Dayside. That's
37:25 what we call the watching TV during the
37:28 daytime. And he was excellent. I thought
37:30 he did a very good job. I thought he
37:32 made a good good case for a stock even
37:33 though it's up a lot. I mean, it's good
37:34 good call by you, Jeffrey in
37:36 Massachusetts. Jeffrey,
37:39 >> what's up, my man? How are you on this
37:41 beautiful day?
37:41 >> I'm doing well, Chief. How about you?
37:43 Good to have you on the show.
37:44 >> Not too bad.
37:45 >> Excellent.
37:47 >> So, this stock I've got is down nearly
37:49 48% year to date. Bright Horizons, BFAM.
37:52 [music]
37:52 Fast thoughts?
37:53 >> Well, it's a very inexpensive stock, but
37:55 that typically means to me the earnings
37:56 aren't going to come through. I don't
37:58 want you to mess around with it. I don't
37:59 I'm not done. That's ridiculous. I feel
38:01 like I taken like one call. Let's go to
38:03 Dennis in New York. Dennis.
38:06 Dennis from Hampton Bay. Jim, big fan.
38:08 Thank you.
38:10 >> My executive producers from Hampton Bay.
38:11 I'm going to do a big shout out to her.
38:13 Regina, I'm sorry. [music] Go ahead.
38:16 >> Texas Pacific Land.
38:18 >> You know, I'm not really into the oil
38:19 stocks and we used Well, we made a big
38:21 deal about that stock when it was the
38:22 right time. And I'm glad we got off
38:24 [music] that horse. I'm going to say no
38:26 to Texas Pacific. And that lends up the
38:29 conclusion of the LIGHTNING ROUND.
38:34 THE LIGHTNING Round is sponsored by
38:36 Charles Schwab. [music]
38:38 Coming up, as we wrap up another busy
38:41 day, Kramer has some final thoughts.
38:43 Don't miss his No Huddle next.
38:49 >> Booyah, Jim. Your integrity makes you
38:52 the booyah Saint of Wall Street.
38:56 >> Booyah. Jimmy Chill.
38:57 >> Booyah. Jimmy Chill.
39:00 Booyah. Jim.
39:01 >> Quadruple. That's a lot of booas.
39:07 [music]
39:15 Look, uh, I'm sad. I did love the guy in
39:18 the leather jacket. I liked him from the
39:20 first time I interviewed him in 2010
39:21 when the stock was around 30 cents,
39:23 counting for the various splits over the
39:25 years. Called it a Kramer fave. I
39:27 continued to hear more and more about
39:28 the company in the years that followed,
39:30 including from the CEO of Audi North
39:31 America, who told me that Nvidia's chips
39:33 were the secret behind his self-driving
39:35 technology. At the time, everyone just
39:37 thought this was a gaming chip company.
39:39 In 2017, frustrated how people didn't
39:41 know about the company. I renamed my dog
39:44 Everest, changing it to Nvidia to call
39:47 attention to the incredible company that
39:49 Nvidia was. That late mut half pit bull
39:53 half whatever got a lot of people's
39:55 attention including Jensen. He made a
39:57 badge for Nvidia to get into
39:58 headquarters anytime he wanted to.
40:00 That's kind of that's Jensen's pixie
40:02 humor. Couple months later is when I
40:04 bought the stock for my chapel trust for
40:05 the first time. The stock was around
40:07 four bucks. But I only fully realized
40:09 how special this company was after I
40:11 spent some time at headquarters and saw
40:13 amazing things. And not just the
40:15 employee badge Jensen made for the dog.
40:17 Things like robots being rewarded for
40:19 picking up Jell-O. things like a machine
40:22 drawing a saison seascape in 10 seconds
40:24 when I knew he never painted one but I
40:26 asked the machine to do it anyway. The
40:28 colors were spot on shading amazing. I
40:30 talked about what I say at Nvidia and
40:32 almost at what I saw at Nvidia and
40:34 almost every day for weeks on this show
40:37 and on squawk on the street. You know,
40:39 at one point my partner David told me he
40:41 was sick of my touting Nvidia. I didn't
40:44 care. I kept doing it.
40:47 There were so many other things Jensen
40:49 showed me over the years, especially
40:50 when I started getting going to the
40:52 company's GTC event every year. Each
40:54 time I went out, I learned some new
40:56 things. Sometimes they were hysterical,
40:58 sometimes they were somber, but they
41:00 were always brilliant. He introduced me
41:02 to the Neoclouds like Anibius and I ran.
41:04 He made me realize that his partners
41:06 like Dell and HPE were obvious buys as
41:08 the AI era began. These stocks made
41:11 fortunes for people. I saw robots make
41:13 hospital corners, 10 bar, really super
41:15 stuff. His ke they were dazzling. But
41:18 one of the most meaningful things he did
41:19 was attend a lunch right here at the New
41:21 York Stock Exchange for CBC Investing
41:23 Club members. Most of whom had become
41:25 millionaires because they bought the
41:27 stock of Nvidia. We had 70 guests. I
41:29 wanted a group picture. He said no. He
41:31 wanted individual selfies with
41:33 individual people. Every one of them all
41:35 regular people like you club members who
41:37 believed. I saw his graciousness
41:39 repeatedly. I rejoiced in it. He was
41:42 always so polite and well-meaning. I
41:44 introduced my wife to him. He's one of
41:45 just a few execs in the 22 years I've
41:47 been doing this that I did that. She
41:49 thought he was terrific. He took her
41:51 seriously, asking plenty of questions
41:52 right in her eyes, looked at her,
41:54 showing amazing respect. She was
41:56 impressed. She thought he was
41:57 sensational. Over the last couple years,
41:59 I saw Jensen all over the place. I
42:01 thought he was kind of changing. He's
42:02 having a grand time. Why not? Seemingly
42:04 celebrating and ping around with the
42:05 president. As much as he was working,
42:07 although that was just an impression. At
42:10 one point, I saw him sign a woman's
42:11 shirt in a place that I thought was
42:12 inappropriate. Well, maybe that was the
42:14 new more successful cooler. Why not
42:16 Flora Jensen? But he was right back to
42:19 being serious at the next GTC in San
42:21 Jose.
42:22 At all times, I admit I was thrilled to
42:24 spend time with him. Just thrilled. You
42:26 know, I tried not to idolize him for his
42:28 brilliance. I tried not to put him on a
42:30 pedestal for spectacular innovations.
42:32 And I defended everything, including his
42:34 push to sell previous generation chips
42:36 to Chinese customers because I thought
42:37 he was earnest when he said it was in
42:39 the best interest of our country to hook
42:41 Chinese customers on the Nvidia
42:42 ecosystem rather than have them build
42:44 their own. I still do. Never once did I
42:47 think that there might be other
42:49 motivations, and I still really hope
42:50 that's not the case. In the end, unlike
42:53 so many others, I wanted everything
42:54 negative said about him stopped. At the
42:57 very least, give him a chance to
42:58 explain. Don't take this fine man apart.
43:00 He's too important to our nation's
43:02 future. His body of work was too
43:04 stellar. We can't afford to lose him if
43:06 we are going to be the world's AI
43:07 leader.
43:09 But it was not to be. The man in the
43:12 leather jacket let his wife down. He let
43:15 his kids down. He let his company down.
43:18 He let his co-workers down. He let his
43:20 shareholders down. He let his country
43:22 down. Sadly, he let me, a person who
43:26 just loved the guy down. My dog Invidia
43:29 died a half dozen years ago. Come to
43:31 think of it, maybe he was the only one
43:34 who didn't get let down by the man in
43:36 the leather jacket. He just didn't live
43:39 long enough to see it.
43:41 I like to say that there's always a
43:43 market somewhere, and I promise I find
43:44 it just for you right here on Mad Money.
43:46 [music] I'm Jim Kramer. See you next
43:48 time.
43:51 >> [music]
43:51 >> All opinions expressed by Jim Kramer on
43:53 this podcast are solely Kramer's
43:54 opinions and do not reflect the opinions
43:56 of CNBC or its parent company or
43:58 affiliates and may have been previously
43:59 disseminated by Kramer on television,
44:00 radio, internet, or another medium. You
44:02 should not treat any opinion expressed
44:04 by Kramer as a specific inducement to
44:05 make a particular investment or follow a
44:07 particular strategy, but only as an
44:09 expression of his opinion. Kramer's
44:10 opinions are based upon information he
44:12 considers reliable. But neither CNBC nor
44:14 its affiliates or subsidiaries warrant
44:15 its completeness or accuracy, and it
44:17 should not be relied upon as such. To
44:19 view the full MadMoney disclaimer,
44:20 please visit cnbc.com/madmoney
44:22 disclaimer.
Nvidia’s financing web raises new risks after Jensen Huang’s exit full transcript
0:00 The resignation of Nvidia
0:00 founder and CEO Jensen Huang
0:05 sets up a test for the US economy.
0:07 Jensen Huang was a co-founder of this company,
0:10 has been the only CEO to ever lead this company,
0:13 and the stock has suffered greatly over the
0:16 course of this last week.
0:17 California-based chip maker Nvidia is at the heart of
0:20 the AI boom. Reports of CEO Jensen Huang's affair with a
0:25 woman allegedly recruited by Chinese intelligence agents
0:28 added to a sour month for the broader technology
0:31 sector. In the months leading up to this moment,
0:35 central bankers and regulators began to openly
0:37 wonder: is the AI industry becoming too big to fail?
0:46 Nvidia has an estimated $400 billion in commitments to
0:51 various companies within the AI ecosystem.
0:54 The beneficiaries include frontier AI labs,
0:58 private equity firms, banks,
1:00 and cloud computing providers.
1:02 Take, for example, the frontier AI labs.
1:05 These are companies that build large language models.
1:09 Those LLMs rely on Nvidia's graphics processing units to
1:13 run the massive sets of calculations that deliver
1:16 artificial intelligence.
1:19 In August, Huang estimated that an AI agent could use
1:22 15 to 100 times more computing power than a
1:26 typical human user.
1:27 Estimates like that have led to a rush of financing,
1:31 permitting, and construction of new data centers.
1:34 Nvidia in August told investors that it's put
1:38 nearly $50 billion into these frontier labs to
1:41 assist with further AI infrastructure projects.
1:44 Nvidia also partnered with major asset managers
1:47 including Apollo, BlackRock and Brookfield,
1:50 in a bid to raise up to $500 billion in financing for
1:54 further infrastructure buildouts.
1:57 Nvidia has disclosed guarantee arrangements with
2:00 OpenAI, but hasn't named other labs in a public
2:03 capacity. However, the company acknowledged
2:06 that virtually all the major closed models rely on Nvidia
2:10 hardware. Nvidia is also backstopping some $36
2:15 billion in cloud computing operations,
2:17 also known as neocloud's.
2:19 Nvidia didn't name its specific partners,
2:22 but some neocloud's, including CoreWeave and
2:25 Iren, have separately disclosed their
2:27 relationships with Nvidia.
2:30 In relevant partnerships, Nvidia creates agreements
2:33 that give lenders the confidence to
2:35 underwrite the project.
2:36 They have been a great partner for us for years
2:39 that they will continue to be a great partner for us.
2:43 Bank regulators don't believe that this moment for
2:46 Jensen Huang or Nvidia resembles anything like a
2:49 re-run of the 2007-2008 financial crisis.
2:54 But if things do turn out the worst for Nvidia,
Nvidia needs an outside CEO fast, says D.A. Davidson's Gil Luria full transcript
0:00 IT'S A DISASTER. SO I THINK WE
0:01 ALL SHOULD JUST TAKE A
0:03 COLLECTIVE BK AND BRIAN DNN DAN,
0:05 TIM AND I ARE FINE AND LET'S
0:06 JUST GET ON WITH IT. BACK TO
0:08 YOU.
0:09 >> ALL RIGHT. WELL LET'S GET ON
0:10 WITH MORE ON NVIDIA AND THE
0:12 FALLOUT THERE. DA DAVIDSON HEAD
0:13 OF TECH RESEARCH GILL LORIA. HE
0:15 JUST REITERATED A BUY RATING ON
0:16 NVIDIA, CUT HIS PRICE TARGET TO
0:18 $200, DOWN FROM 300. GILL GREAT
0:20 TO SEE YOU. GOOD TO SEE YOU. SO
0:22 YOU'RE STILL TELLING PEOPLE TO
0:23 BUY THIS STOCK. WHAT DO YOU
0:26 WHAT DO YOU SEE AS THE PATH
0:28 FORWARD HERE. I MEAN AS
0:29 JEN-HSUN HUANG HEADS UP TO THE
0:30 HILL BEFORE THANKSGIVING,
0:32 NVIDIA IS IN THE CROSSHAIRS OF
0:33 I DON'T KNOW HOW MANY
0:35 CONGRESSIONAL COMMITTEES AT
0:36 THIS POINT. WE DON'T KNOW WHAT
0:37 KIND OF PENALTIES THE COMPANY
0:39 MIGHT FACE FOR VIOLATIONS,
0:42 POTENTIAL VIOLATIONS OF
0:43 NATIONAL SECURITY. WE DON'T
0:44 KNOW IF ASIA SHOULD BE
0:45 COMPLETELY COUNTED OUT OF ITS
0:47 MODEL. WHAT DO YOU SEE?
0:51 >> THE PROBABILITY WEIGHT OF
0:53 OUTCOMES IS STILL THAT THEY ARE
0:54 ABLE TO DELIVER THE NUMBERS FOR
0:56 NEXT YEAR, AT WHICH POINT THE
0:57 STOCK WILL BE HIGHER. EVEN IF
1:00 THERE WAS WRONGDOING. EVEN IF
1:01 THEY HAVE TO LIMIT THEIR SALES
1:03 TO ASIA, THEY COULD PROBABLY
1:04 STILL SELL ALL THE CHIPS THEY
1:06 WERE PLANNING TO SELL NEXT YEAR
1:07 AND AND GET TO THOSE SAME
1:09 NUMBERS. THAT DOESN'T MEAN THIS
1:11 ISN'T A RISK. AS YOU'VE TALKED
1:12 ABOUT, THERE COULD STILL BE A
1:14 LOT OF BAD THINGS THAT HAPPENED.
1:16 AND THAT'S THE PRIMARY RISK, IS
1:18 THAT THEIR SALES INTO ASIA ARE
1:20 MORE LIMITED. SO NVIDIA SHOULD
1:23 STILL GO UP NEXT YEAR. THAT'S
1:24 WHY WE KEPT THE BUY. BUT WE
1:27 DEPRIORITIZED IT. AMD BROADCOM
1:29 AND MICRON ARE PROBABLY A
1:31 BETTER WAY TO PLAY THAT SAME
1:33 TREND OF GROWING AI DEMAND.
1:35 THAT WILL TRANSLATE TO MORE
1:36 DATA CENTER BUILD OUT.
1:38 >> GIL THAT'S THAT'S WHERE I
1:38 WANTED TO GO BECAUSE AMD NOW
1:40 TRADES AROUND 60 TIMES FORWARD.
1:42 YOU KNOW, I DON'T KNOW WHERE
1:43 YOUR NUMBERS ARE HERE, BUT BUT
1:45 WE WERE JUST HAVING A
1:46 DISCUSSION ABOUT IS THIS REALLY
1:48 A SUBSTITUTION EFFECT? AND
1:50 HAVEN'T THESE STOCKS PRICED IN
1:51 MAYBE MORE OF THAT IN THE SHORT
1:53 TERM? IN A WORLD WHERE THEY
1:54 WERE DOING EVERYTHING THEY
1:55 COULD DO YESTERDAY?
1:57 >> YEAH. SO AMD IS THE PRICIEST
1:58 OF THE THREE. BUT IF YOU LOOK
2:00 AT BROADCOM AND MICRON THEY'RE
2:01 STILL TRADING AT A MUCH LOWER
2:03 MULTIPLE. AND THEY WILL
2:05 PARTICIPATE IN THE DATA CENTER
2:06 BUILD OUT. REALLY YOU ADD AMD
2:08 TO THAT MIX TO RECONSTRUCT WHAT
2:11 NVIDIA DOES TO THE MARKET.
2:12 NVIDIA IS THE BIGGEST PROFIT
2:13 POOL. BUT IF YOU ADD THE OTHER
2:15 THREE YOU CAN REPLICATE THAT
2:17 PROFIT POOL AND THE BLENDED
2:19 MULTIPLES STILL LOWER THAN THE
2:20 MARKET MULTIPLE. BUT CLEARLY
2:21 AMD IS THE PRICIEST. IT'S
2:23 BECAUSE THEY'VE EXECUTED SO
2:24 WELL AND THERE'S UPSIDE TO
2:25 NUMBERS. BUT BROADCOM AND
2:27 MICRON STILL TRADING AT A BELOW
2:29 MARKET MULTIPLE OR A SINGLE
2:31 DIGIT MULTIPLE IN THE CASE OF
2:32 MICRON. AND THEY'RE GOING TO
2:34 PARTICIPATE REGARDLESS OF WHAT
2:35 HAPPENS TO NVIDIA. THEY'RE A
2:37 BETTER WAY TO PLAY THIS TREND
2:39 RIGHT NOW.
2:39 >> GIL HOW IMPORTANT IS THE
2:40 QUARTER NOW TIM BROUGHT UP
2:42 EARLIER THAT YOU KNOW A LOT OF
2:43 MAYBE WE WOULD BE HERE
2:45 REGARDLESS IF THE QUARTER WAS.
2:46 BUT IS THERE GOING TO BE THERE
2:48 HAS TO BE. I WOULD THINK AN
2:50 ADDED LEVEL OF SCRUTINY GIVEN
2:51 THE QUARTER THEY'RE GOING TO
2:52 REPORT NEXT WEEK. SO THE
2:53 QUESTION IS, IS THIS THE MOST
2:55 IMPORTANT QUARTER WE'VE SEEN IN
2:56 QUITE SOME TIME OUT OF NVIDIA?
2:58 >> ABSOLUTELY. THERE IS NO WAY
2:59 THEY CAN MISS IF THEY MISS
3:01 THERE'S ANOTHER BIG LEG DOWN.
3:03 SO THEY THEY HAVE TO SHOW UP.
3:05 THEY HAVE TO MAKE THE NUMBERS.
3:07 THEY HAVE TO REITERATE THE
3:08 GUIDANCE INCLUDING INTO NEXT
3:09 YEAR. THEY HAVE TO WAIT. THEY
3:10 HAVE TO FIND A WAY TO MAKE THAT
3:12 NUMBER. AND THEY HAVE TO
3:14 COMMUNICATE A VERY CLEAR PLAN
3:15 FOR REPLACING THE CEO. THAT'S
3:16 GOING TO BE REALLY THE KEY ITEM
3:18 RIGHT NOW. THEY CAN'T LET THIS
3:20 DRAG OUT. THEY NEED TO FIND THE
3:22 RIGHT CANDIDATE. WE THINK
3:23 THERE'S SOME REALLY GOOD
3:24 CANDIDATES OUT THERE. IT HAS TO
3:26 BE SOMEBODY EXTERNAL YOU, AS
3:28 YOU TALKED ABOUT IN THE PANEL,
3:30 IF SOMETHING IF THERE WAS
3:31 WRONGDOING, EVERYBODY
3:33 INTERNALLY AT NVIDIA IS
3:34 IMPLICATED. YOU CAN'T FIND
3:35 SOMEBODY INTERNALLY TO TAKE THE
3:37 ROLE RIGHT NOW, BECAUSE YOU MAY
3:38 HAVE TO MOVE ON FROM THEM. AS
3:40 SOON AS THE INVESTIGATION IS
3:41 DONE. IT HAS TO.
3:42 >> BE SOMEBODY, THOUGH, STILL.
3:43 >> I MEAN, I'M JUST WONDERING,
3:45 YOU KNOW, DO YOU THINK THERE'S
3:47 A POSSIBILITY THAT THAT'S WHAT
3:48 IT IS? I MEAN, JEN-HSUN HUANG
3:50 IS NOT THE ONLY ONE SHIPPING
3:52 THOSE CHIPS TO SHELL COMPANIES
3:53 IN SINGAPORE AND MALAYSIA. I
3:55 MEAN, HE'S NOT ACTUALLY PACKING
3:56 THE CHIPS. I MEAN, THERE ARE A
3:58 LOT OF LAYERS THERE, TOO, IN
3:59 TERMS OF PEOPLE WHO MUST HAVE
4:01 KNOWN WHAT WAS GOING ON.
4:02 >> THAT'S RIGHT. SO YOU NEED
4:04 SOMEBODY FROM THE OUTSIDE. LET
4:05 ME GIVE YOU MY FAVORITE
4:06 CANDIDATE, THE ONLY CANDIDATE
4:07 THAT I THINK IS A CLEAN
4:09 CANDIDACY. THAT'S JOHNY SROUJI
4:10 FROM APPLE, THE PERSON WHO WAS
4:12 A CEO CANDIDATE REPLACED JOHN
4:14 TURNER WHEN JOHN TURNER BECAME
4:16 CEO. HE'S BUILT HIS LIFE AROUND
4:18 CHIPS. HE'S BEEN IN THE CHIP
4:19 INDUSTRY, AND HE COMES FROM
4:21 THIS VERY CLEAN STORY. CLEARLY,
4:23 HE HAS CEO AMBITIONS AND HE'S
4:25 READY TO GO. IF I WAS THE BOARD,
4:27 I WOULD GET HIM HIRED RIGHT
4:29 AWAY. SO THERE'S NO TRANSITION
4:31 PERIOD. SO SOMEBODY CAN COME IN
4:32 AND REBUILD THE COMPANY WITHOUT
4:34 ALL THE PEOPLE THAT COULD BE
4:36 IMPLICATED, WITHOUT HAVING 60
4:37 DIRECT REPORTS IN A MANNER THAT
4:40 NVIDIA CAN MOVE FORWARD. NVIDIA
4:41 STILL HAS THE BEST PRODUCTS OUT
4:42 THERE. THAT'S NOT GOING TO
4:43 CHANGE. THEY'RE NOT TO THE
4:45 POINT YOU MADE IN THE PANEL.
4:46 THEY'RE NOT LOSING SHARE IN THE
4:48 NEXT 12 MONTHS TO AMD AND
4:49 BROADCOM. THAT'S NOT WHAT'S
4:50 GOING TO HAPPEN. THEIR PRODUCT
4:52 IS STILL THE MOST
AllianceBernstein's Nelson Yu: Nvidia's concentration was a warning sign full transcript
0:09 >> WELCOME BACK. THE TECH
0:10 SECTOR LOWERED TODAY, BUT ONE
0:11 OF THE TOP PERFORMERS ON THE
0:13 WEEK IS THE NVIDIA SCANDAL,
0:14 OVERSHADOWING A DURABLE BOUNCE
0:15 BACK IN THE AI TRADE. JOINING
0:16 US NOW IS NELSON YU. HE IS HEAD
0:18 OF EQUITIES AT
0:19 ALLIANCEBERNSTEIN NELSON GREAT
0:20 TO HAVE YOU WITH US.
0:21 >> THANK YOU FOR HAVING ME ON.
0:23 >> I WANT TO ASK YOU TO OPINE
0:25 ABOUT NVIDIA AND WHAT HAPPENS
0:26 THERE. BUT IN TERMS OF THE
0:28 IMPACT ON THE AI TRADE, HOW DO
0:29 YOU VIEW THIS. BECAUSE WHAT WE
0:31 SAW THIS WEEK WAS, YOU KNOW
0:32 NVIDIA'S MARKET CAP GOES TO AMD
0:34 AND BROADCOM. THAT'S RIGHT. BUT
0:35 LONGER TERM WHAT WILL WE SEE.
0:37 >> YOU KNOW I THINK. TODAY AND
0:38 THIS WEEK HAS BEEN REALLY GOOD
0:40 REMINDER OF THE IMPORTANCE OF
0:41 TWO THINGS. ONE IS CORPORATE
0:43 RESEARCH AND BOTTOM UP COMPANY
0:45 RESEARCH AND ALSO THE IMPACT OF
0:47 DIVERSIFICATION. I MEAN YOU
0:48 TALKED ABOUT NVIDIA JUST A
0:50 MONTH AGO. NVIDIA WAS OVER 8%
0:52 OF THE OF THE S&P 500. AND NOW
0:54 IT'S AT 6%. AND SO JUST PUTTING
0:57 ALL YOUR SO MUCH OF YOUR EGGS
0:58 INTO THAT ONE BASKET CAN REALLY
1:00 HURT YOUR PORTFOLIO. BUT THE
1:02 SECOND PART IS IF YOU THINK
1:04 ABOUT COMPANY RESEARCH, IT'S SO
1:06 IMPORTANT TO BE DOING THAT
1:07 CORPORATE GOVERNANCE RESEARCH,
1:08 REALLY THINKING ABOUT THE
1:10 STRENGTH OF MANAGEMENT, REALLY
1:11 THINKING ABOUT THE CREDIBILITY
1:12 OF SUCCESSION PLANS. THIS IS
1:13 STUFF THAT WE THINK ABOUT ALL
1:15 THE TIME FOR ALL OF OUR
1:16 COMPANIES.
1:16 >> SO YOU THINK THAT NVIDIA
1:19 WOULD HAVE BEEN KIND OF A
1:20 YELLOW FLAG JUST ON THAT BASIS
1:22 A MONTH AGO?
1:23 >> THE NVIDIA WAS A VERY HIGH
1:25 QUALITY COMPANY. YEAH. RIGHT.
1:26 IT WAS GENERATING LOTS OF
1:27 PROFITS. CASH FLOWS WERE REALLY
1:30 STRONG. THE QUESTION WAS ABOUT
1:31 THE FINANCING AND THE CIRCULAR
1:32 FINANCING. BUT WE WERE REALLY
1:35 WORRIED ABOUT CONCENTRATION.
1:36 AND THAT WAS SOMETHING THAT I
1:38 THINK HAS BEEN, YOU KNOW,
1:40 REALLY HAS COME THROUGH. YOU
1:42 KNOW, WE TALKED ABOUT, YOU KNOW,
1:42 AND YOUR QUESTION WAS AROUND
1:44 THE AI TRADE. I THINK ACTUALLY,
1:45 IF YOU THINK ABOUT HOW HOW MUCH
1:49 CONCENTRATION WAS IN THAT AI
1:51 TRADE, INDEXES WERE MOVING IN
1:52 PERFECT CORRELATION TO WHATEVER
1:54 AI WAS DOING THAT DAY. AND I
1:56 THINK IT'S SO IMPORTANT FOR
1:57 INVESTORS TO THINK BEYOND THIS
1:58 TRADE, RIGHT?
1:59 >> BUT WHEN YOU'RE TALKING
2:00 ABOUT CORPORATE GOVERNANCE, IT
2:01 ALMOST MAKES IT SEEM LIKE
2:03 EVERYBODY SHOULD HAVE BEEN
2:04 SHOULD HAVE KNOWN THAT THIS
2:06 COULD HAVE HAPPENED OR THAT THE,
2:07 YOU KNOW, THE OUTCOME OF
2:08 JEN-HSUN HUANG LEAVING WOULD
2:09 HAVE BEEN REALLY DETRIMENTAL TO
2:10 THE COMPANY BECAUSE OF THE WAY
2:12 THE BOARD WAS, BECAUSE OF THE
2:13 FLAT MANAGEMENT STRUCTURE, ETC.
2:14 BUT YET IT DIDN'T DIDN'T SOUND
2:16 ANY ALARMS. MAYBE IT'S ALMOST A
2:19 SHAME ON ALL OF US FOR NOT
2:20 SEEING THAT. I MEAN, DO YOU SEE,
2:22 DO YOU FEEL THAT A LITTLE BIT,
2:24 BECAUSE I WOULD IMAGINE THAT
2:25 YOUR FUND STILL HELD NVIDIA AT
2:27 LEAST MARKET WEIGHT AND THAT
2:28 THERE WASN'T AN ISSUE ON THAT
2:29 FRONT?
2:29 >> WELL, I WOULD SAY IT IS A
2:32 FLAG THAT WE GO THROUGH WHEN WE
2:33 WHEN WE TALK ABOUT OUR
2:35 CORPORATE RESEARCH AND WE THINK
2:37 ABOUT, WELL, WHAT'S THE QUALITY
2:38 OF THE CASH FLOWS? WHAT'S THE
2:39 QUALITY OF THE BALANCE SHEET?
2:41 WHAT'S THE QUALITY OF
2:41 MANAGEMENT? AND THESE ARE
2:42 THINGS THAT WE CHECK THROUGH.
2:44 NVIDIA WOULDN'T HAVE GOTTEN
2:45 FULL MARKS BECAUSE OF THAT.
2:46 >> WHERE IS THE WORK TAKING YOU
2:49 BOTTOM UP AT THIS POINT IN
2:50 TERMS OF OUTSIDE THE AI TRADE?
2:53 WHAT SEEMS TO MAKE SENSE? HOW
2:54 MUCH OF IT IS DEPENDENT ON, YOU
2:56 KNOW, THE MACRO ENVIRONMENT
2:57 INTO NEXT YEAR AND HOW MUCH OF
2:59 IT IS IS, YOU KNOW, IS NOT.
3:01 >> SO I THINK, YOU KNOW, BEFORE
3:02 WE GO INTO THAT, I THINK IT'S
3:04 REALLY IMPORTANT TO SET UP
3:05 WHAT'S THE BACKDROP? WE'VE GOT
3:07 A BACKDROP WHERE A LOT OF
3:08 GROWTH HAS BEEN DRIVEN BY AI.
3:10 SO YOU REALLY NEED TO HAVE
3:11 THINGS THAT CAN GROW
3:12 INDEPENDENTLY OF AI. THE SECOND
3:14 PART IS YOU ARE IN A HIGHER
3:16 COST OF CAPITAL ENVIRONMENT
3:17 BECAUSE OF THE RISING RATES. SO
3:19 I THINK THE WAY THAT WE LOOK AT
3:21 THINGS IS YOU NEED TO ANCHOR IN
3:23 QUALITY COMPANIES THAT CAN
3:24 GENERATE DURABLE PROFITABILITY,
3:26 YOU KNOW, AHEAD OF THEIR COST
3:27 OF CAPITAL. YOU NEED TO THINK
3:28 ABOUT DIVERSIFICATION AND YOU
3:30 NEED TO THINK ABOUT HOW DO I
3:32 REDUCE VOLATILITY. AND SO WHEN
3:33 I THINK ABOUT THOSE THINGS THAT
3:35 LEADS ME TO YOU HAVE HEALTH
3:37 CARE THAT HAS ACTUALLY BEEN
3:39 ABLE TO GENERATE RETURNS,
3:41 GENERATE CONTINUED EARNINGS
3:42 GROWTH BECAUSE OF AGING
3:43 DEMOGRAPHICS. AND ACTUALLY IT'S
3:45 A BENEFICIARY. IF AI WORKS OUT,
3:47 IT ACTUALLY WORKS AT A REALLY
3:48 GOOD HEDGE. IF TECHNOLOGY
3:50 FALTERS, YOU'VE ALSO GOT IF YOU
3:52 THINK GLOBALLY IN JAPAN, YOU'VE
3:54 GOT STORIES LIKE THIS,
3:55 CORPORATE GOVERNANCE REFORM,
3:57 AGAIN, FOCUSING ON COMPANY
3:59 COMPANY PROFITABILITY,
4:01 COMPANIES THAT CAN CAN COMMIT
4:03 TO RAISING THEIR SHAREHOLDER
4:04 RETURNS AND RAISING
4:05 PROFITABILITY HAVE SEEN
4:06 TREMENDOUS RETURNS.
4:07 >> RIGHT. YOU ALSO MENTIONED
4:08 COMPANIES THAT THRIVE IN RISING
4:10 RATES. AND YOU SAID EUROPEAN
4:11 BANKS. THAT'S RIGHT. BUT NOT
4:12 U.S. BANKS. IS THAT IS THAT A
4:14 VOTE ON VALUATION HERE?
4:16 >> THAT'S THAT'S REALLY MORE
4:16 TOWARDS VALUATION. AND WHAT I
4:18 SEE, WHAT I THINK OF IS IN
4:20 EUROPE, YOU'VE GOT A SET OF
4:22 BANKS THAT ARE VERY HIGH
4:23 QUALITY. THEY'VE REALLY BOOSTED
4:25 THEIR RESERVES. AND WITH THE
4:27 RISING RATE ENVIRONMENT THAT'S
4:28 A BENEFIT TO TO THE EUROPEAN
4:31 BANKS.
4:31 >> AND JUST QUICKLY DO YOU
4:32 EXPECT RATES TO CONTINUE GOING
4:34 UP EITHER PUSHED BY THE FED OR
4:36 MARKET YIELDS NEXT YEAR?
4:38 >> THE TO BE HONEST WITH YOU,
4:39 WE DON'T HAVE I DON'T HAVE A
4:41 CALL ON RATES, BUT I DO THINK
4:44 THAT THIS COST OF CAPITAL IS
4:45 GOING TO BE HIGHER. THIS IS
4:47 REALLY MORE TOWARDS WHAT
4:49 NORMALLY WE SEE. I THINK
Market Close: Stocks Lower, Nvidia Falls After CEO Exit, Oil and Yields Rise full transcript
0:01 CNBC business news update. Market closed
0:04 Thursday. I'm Jessica Edinger. Wall
0:06 Street will open Friday morning after
0:08 the CEO of Nvidia resigned and major
0:11 averages finished lower. Oil and bond
0:13 yields higher Thursday. The rate on the
0:15 10-year note topping 5.1%.
0:18 Let's look at the major averages. The
0:20 Dow down 189 points, 3/10en of a
0:24 percent, led lower by shares of Nvidia
0:27 down 4.3% on Thursday. The S&P 500 index
0:32 was down 26 points. The Nasdaq fell 100
0:35 points. Chipmaker shares were mixed.
0:38 Broadcom and AMD shares were each up 5%.
0:41 Companies whose shares hit fresh
0:42 all-time highs on Thursday include
0:44 Apple, Johnson and Johnson, Eli Liy,
0:47 Costco, Coca-Cola, and Bergkshire
0:49 Hathaway. Class B shares embattled
0:52 Nvidia CEO Jensen Wong resigning
0:54 Thursday after last weekend admitting an
0:57 affair with a woman and apologizing to
0:59 the company's staff and his family. The
1:02 government alleges that woman is a
1:04 Chinese asset or spy. Reports Thursday
1:07 that there are two more women. CNBC's
1:10 Megan Cassella has more from Washington.
1:13 >> That's right, a third reported affair
1:14 now for Jensen Hang and the second one
1:16 believed to be with an employee. This is
1:18 according to Reuters reporting. They
1:20 site two people familiar with the
1:21 matter. Now in Washington, guys, the
1:23 fallout from the news of Fong's affair
1:24 with an alleged spy is only just
1:26 beginning. We now expect to see him on
1:28 Capitol Hill next week testifying in a
1:31 closed- dooror meeting with lawmakers.
1:32 Republican Senator Tom Tillis now is
1:34 also among a growing group of lawmakers
1:36 calling for Commerce Secretary Howard
1:37 Lutnik to also testify before Congress.
1:40 And the top Democrats on two powerful
1:42 committees, Senate Finance and House
1:43 Ways and Means, wrote to Lutnik today to
1:46 say they are launching an investigation
1:48 into the administration's scheme, as
1:49 they call it, to approve and tax exports
1:52 of Nvidia chips to Chinese companies
1:54 with links to the Chinese government,
1:56 military, and sanctioned entities.
1:58 Nvidia's chief financial officer,
2:01 Colette Crest, has been named temporary
2:04 CEO at the company. Here's the author of
2:07 The Thinking Machine, Steven Wit, with
2:09 CNBC's Sarah Eisen.
2:11 >> Everyone's just kind of sad and and
2:14 surprised that someone so brilliant
2:16 could do something so dumb. I mean, are
2:18 you surprised?
2:18 >> You know, I've been hearing rumors this
2:20 year, so I'm not totally surprised. Uh,
2:23 I am very disappointed.
2:25 You know, it's just a classic tale of of
2:27 masculine hubris, right? Classic tale of
2:31 >> overconfidence and believing that you
2:32 can get away with everything until you
2:34 can't, right? Jensen, he had made the
2:37 people around him so wealthy and so they
2:39 were very incentivized to protect him.
2:41 >> The news on Nvidia is fastm moving. Get
2:44 the absolute latest on CNBC television,
2:47 CNBC.com, and the CNBC app on your
2:50 phone. Cisco shares popped up 5% in
2:53 after hours trading on Thursday on
2:55 strong quarterly results. Microsoft with
2:58 an Outlook outage on Thursday for hours
3:01 with Amazon Web Services and Google
3:03 users also reporting issues. Family
3:06 Dollar paying $63 million to settle
3:09 claims it overcharged shoppers. The
3:12 Federal Trade Commission and 17 states
3:15 accused the retailer of charging more at
3:17 the register than it advertises on its
3:20 website and its mobile app. The post
3:22 office adding shipping sir charges 11%
3:25 as diesel prices have soared since
3:27 President Trump sent US missiles into
3:29 Iran back in February. The USPS joins
3:33 FedEx and UPS with new added search
3:36 charges. The new contribution limits for
3:39 retirement accounts are out from the IRS
3:41 for next year. For a 401k, $1,000
3:44 increase, you can put in $25,500.
3:48 The IRA limit is unchanged at 7500. For
3:53 those 50 and older, the catch-up limits
3:55 are going up for a 401k. You can put in
3:57 another $8,500.
4:00 People from age 60 to 63 get a super
4:02 catch-up allowance. They can put in an
4:05 extra $11,750.
4:08 On Friday's watch list, all eyes on
4:11 Nvidia and its next moves and new in
4:14 theaters. Bleecker Street's Victorian
4:15 Psycho, Amazon, MGM's How to Rob a Bank,
4:19 and Paramount's Ebenezer. It's also
4:22 Friday the 13th. Jessica Edinger, CNBC.
Deals with Iran are 'absolutely not' over, says Real Macro's Jeff Currie full transcript
0:07 PLUS.
0:09 >> ALL RIGHT. WELCOME BACK TO
0:11 THE EXCHANGE, EVERYBODY. KELLY
0:12 WILL BE BACK TOMORROW. AND
0:13 BELIEVE IT OR NOT, THERE IS
0:14 NEWS OUTSIDE OF NVIDIA AND
0:17 JEN-HSUN HUANG. AND A BIG PART
0:18 OF THAT INVOLVES ENERGY.
0:19 BECAUSE WHILE OIL ISN'T MOVING
0:20 A LOT RIGHT NOW, THIS IS, MAKE
0:22 NO MISTAKE, A VERY TENSE TIME
0:25 FOR THE GLOBAL ENERGY MARKET,
0:26 BECAUSE THERE'S ALSO SOME REAL
0:28 HOPE FOR SOME SORT OF DEAL OR
0:30 PEACE DEAL WITH IRAN. PRESIDENT
0:32 TRUMP POSTED ON TRUTH SOCIAL
0:34 EARLIER TODAY, QUOTE, WE DON'T
0:35 NEED TO DEAL WITH IRAN. THOSE
0:37 DAYS HAVE LONG SINCE PASSED.
0:39 WE'VE GOT THEIR MONEY, HUNDREDS
0:41 OF BILLIONS OF DOLLARS, AND
0:42 WE'VE GOT THEIR STRAIGHT. MAYBE
0:44 A LOT OF THAT IS UP FOR DEBATE.
0:46 I THINK PEOPLE FORGOT TO MAYBE
0:47 TELL THE HOUTHIS. ANYWAY, LET'S
0:49 TALK MORE ABOUT ALL OF THIS AND
0:50 MORE WITH JEFF CURRIE. HE IS
0:53 THE CEO OF REAL MACRO. THERE'S
0:57 SHIPS THAT ARE STILL BEING HIT
0:58 IN THE REGION. JEFF, DO YOU
1:00 THINK DEALINGS WITH IRAN ARE
1:02 OVER?
1:04 >> ABSOLUTELY NOT. IF ANYTHING
1:06 THEY JUST GOT A LOT MORE
1:07 DIFFICULT. YOU KNOW I LIKE TO
1:09 CALL THE STRAIT THE SCHRODINGER
1:10 STRAIT. REMEMBER THE
1:11 SCHRODINGER CAT. YOU DON'T KNOW
1:12 IF IT'S ALIVE OR DEAD. WE DON'T
1:14 KNOW IF IT'S OPEN OR CLOSED.
1:16 AND I THINK WHAT THAT DOES,
1:18 BECAUSE WE DO HAVE A LOT OF
1:20 VOLUMES COMING OUT. IT CAPS THE
1:21 PROMPT BARREL. BUT IT MAKES THE
1:24 NEXT ONE DOESN'T MAKE IT ANY
1:26 CHEAPER. SO YOU'RE KIND OF
1:27 STUCK IN THIS LIMBO LAND OF US.
1:29 CALL IT 95. YOU KNOW, LET'S SAY
1:32 85 TO $100 RANGE WITHOUT REALLY
1:34 ANY ABILITY TO ESCAPE TO THE
1:36 UPSIDE OR ANY ABILITY TO REALLY
1:38 DROP MUCH LOWER. SO, YOU KNOW,
1:40 THE MARKET IS IN THIS HOLDING
1:42 PATTERN BECAUSE IT'S VERY
1:43 UNCLEAR HOW WE'RE GOING TO GET
1:45 A RESOLUTION HERE.
1:46 >> WELL, WITHOUT GETTING INTO
1:47 THEORETICAL PHYSICS PROBLEMS IN
1:49 THAT CAT, LET'S LET'S TALK
1:53 ABOUT IRAN BECAUSE RIGHT NOW
1:55 THERE'S A LOT OF BARRELS MOVING
1:57 THROUGH THE STRAIT. WE KNOW
1:58 THAT, BUT THEY'RE MOVING
1:59 THROUGH THE STRAIT WITH HUGE
2:01 HELP FROM THE UNITED STATES
2:03 NAVY THAT WILL NOT OR CANNOT
2:05 LAST FOREVER. IRAN KEEPS KIND
2:07 OF CHANGING WHO'S IN CHARGE. WE
2:08 DON'T NEED TO GO INTO IRAN
2:10 POLITICS BECAUSE THEY'RE A
2:11 MYSTERY TO ME AS WELL. BUT IRAN
2:13 COULD RESTART HOSTILITIES AT
2:16 ANY TIME BECAUSE THEY THINK
2:17 THEY NEED TO BE PAID FOR SHIPS
2:19 TO GO THROUGH SAFELY.
2:21 >> YEAH. I MEAN, YOU'RE SEEING
2:22 IT. I MEAN, THEY'RE THEY'RE
2:25 TAKING HITS BACK. THERE WAS ONE
2:26 TODAY, A BIG VLCC GOT HIT BY
2:28 SOME MINES. SO I MEAN THAT'S
2:30 THE POINT HERE. YES. YOU'RE
2:31 GETTING THE VOLUMES OUT. BUT
2:32 THE COST OF THOSE VOLUMES ARE
2:34 EXTRAORDINARILY EXPENSIVE. YOU
2:36 KNOW EVERYTHING FROM LOGISTICS
2:37 TO, YOU KNOW, THE INSURANCE
2:40 INVOLVED, YOU KNOW, THE ABILITY
2:41 TO REFINE THEM, YOU KNOW, TO,
2:43 TO, TO ARGUE THAT HISTORICALLY
2:45 THESE COMMODITY MARKETS WERE
2:46 RELATIVELY SIMPLE. THE
2:48 CONSTRAINT WAS IN THE UPSTREAM
2:49 AND THAT'S ALL YOU REALLY HAD
2:51 TO LOOK AT. YOU KNOW, I LIKE TO
2:53 CALL THIS THING A BUBBLING
2:54 CAULDRON OF SUPPLY AND DEMAND
2:56 IMBALANCES. IS IT INSURANCE
2:57 THIS WEEK? IS IT REFINING THIS
2:59 WEEK? IS IT UPSTREAM? IS IT THE
3:01 TANKERS? I DON'T KNOW WHICH
3:03 ONE'S GOING TO BE THE
3:04 CONSTRAINT. THE ONE THING I
3:05 DEFINITELY KNOW A DELIVERED
3:07 BARREL OF OIL TO A CONSUMING
3:08 PART OF THE WORLD IS FAR MORE
3:10 EXPENSIVE TODAY THAN IT HAS
3:11 BEEN AT ANY OTHER POINT.
3:13 >> BUT IS THERE A.
3:14 >> SUPPLY DEMAND IMBALANCE FOR
3:15 OIL BECAUSE YOU'VE GOT QATAR
3:17 PUMPING A LOT, YOU'VE GOT IRAQ
3:19 PUMPING A LOT. UGI IS ALLEGEDLY
3:21 TALKING ABOUT A THIRD A THIRD
3:24 PIPELINE. SAUDI ARABIA'S
3:26 PUMPING BACK TO PREWAR LEVELS.
3:28 WHO KNOWS WHAT THE REST OF OPEC
3:30 MAY DO? WHAT'S THE THE BARREL
3:33 COUNTING ON THE PHYSICAL BARREL
3:36 RIGHT NOW? JEFF.
3:38 >> I WOULD PUT THE MARKET AS
3:39 RELATIVELY BALANCED, AND THAT'S
3:41 THE WAY IT'S PRICING RIGHT NOW.
3:42 THE FRONT END IS RELATIVELY
3:43 FLAT. IT'S RELATIVELY TAME. BUT
3:45 LET'S NOT FORGET WHILE IT CAPS
3:48 THE PROMPT BARREL, IT DOES
3:49 NOTHING TO CHEAPEN THE NEXT ONE,
3:52 WHICH IS WHY YOU CAN'T GET
3:53 BEARISH HERE, NOR CAN YOU GET
3:55 REALLY BULLISH. SO YOU HAVE
3:59 REALLY EXPENSIVE BARRELS OF OIL
4:00 BEING PUT OUT ONTO THE GLOBAL
4:01 MARKET AND A TENUOUS BALANCE,
4:04 BUT IT DOES NOTHING TO SHIFT
4:07 THE FORWARD. LOOK FOR OUTLOOK
4:08 FOR THE PRICE. IN FACT, YOU
4:10 KNOW, WE PUT OUT A PIECE
4:11 RECENTLY WHERE WE TALKED ABOUT,
4:13 YOU KNOW, WE WANT TO GET, YOU
4:14 KNOW, THE, THE WAR TRADE IS
4:16 OVER. ANY TYPE OF UPSIDE IN
4:17 PRICE IS OVER, BUT THE REGIME
4:19 TRADE IS STILL THERE. YOU WANT
4:20 TO OWN THINGS LIKE THE DRILLERS,
4:22 THE LONG TERM, YOU KNOW,
4:24 STRUCTURAL STORY HERE IS VERY
4:25 MUCH INTACT. SO, YOU KNOW, WE
4:27 LIKE THE THE STRUCTURAL STORY
4:29 LONG DATED OIL, YOU KNOW,
4:31 DRILLERS, PRODUCERS, YOU KNOW,
'AI is still going to dominate the world,' says Strategy CEO Phong Le full transcript
0:10 >> OF COURSE, WE'RE WATCHING
0:11 NVIDIA AND THE TECH TRADE TODAY,
0:14 BUT WE'RE ALSO KEEPING AN EYE
0:15 ON CRYPTO. BITCOIN IS DOWN MORE
0:17 THAN 3%, FALLING BELOW THE
0:19 72,000 MARK TO ITS LOWEST LEVEL
0:21 SINCE AUGUST. STRATEGY. THE
0:23 WORLD'S LARGEST CORPORATE
0:25 BITCOIN HOLDER IS ALSO UNDER
0:27 PRESSURE, DOWN ABOUT 50% FROM
0:29 ITS 52 WEEK HIGH. SO WHAT'S THE
0:32 STRATEGY GOING FORWARD? JOINING
0:34 US NOW IN AN EXCLUSIVE
0:35 INTERVIEW, FENG LI, CEO OF
0:37 STRATEGY. IT'S GREAT TO SEE YOU
0:39 TODAY. FIRST OF ALL, GIVE ME A
0:41 SENSE OF MSCI TAKING STRATEGY
0:46 OUT OF ITS INDEX. WHAT DOES
0:47 THAT MEAN FOR YOU AND FOR THE
0:49 COMPANY AND FOR YOUR ACCESS TO
0:51 CAPITAL.
0:52 >> YEAH. LOOK MSCI HAS BEEN ON
0:54 A MULTIYEAR CAMPAIGN AGAINST
0:56 DIGITAL ASSETS. AND IT'S
0:58 INTERESTING BECAUSE THEIR ROLE
0:59 IS TO BE AN INDEPENDENT ARBITER
1:01 OF THE MARKETS NOT PICKING
1:03 WINNERS AND LOSERS. AND THEY'VE
1:04 CLEARLY DECIDED THAT BITCOIN
1:06 ISN'T SOMETHING THAT PEOPLE
1:07 SHOULD BE INVESTING IN. PUT
1:09 THAT ASIDE. ABOUT 3% OF OUR
1:11 SHARES ARE RELATED TO MSCI
1:14 INDICES, SO IT'S REALLY NOT A
1:16 BIG ISSUE FOR US. I WOULD CALL
1:17 IT IMMATERIAL. THE BIGGER
1:19 QUESTION IS WHY IS MSCI PICKING
1:21 WINNERS AND LOSERS IN THE
1:22 MARKET.
1:23 >> I MENTIONED THAT YOUR SHARES
1:25 ARE DOWN ABOUT 50% FROM YOUR 52
1:27 WEEK HIGH. WHY? TO WHAT DO YOU
1:30 ATTRIBUTE THAT DECLINE?
1:32 >> OVER THE LAST YEAR THERE'S
1:33 BEEN UNPRECEDENTED VOLATILITY
1:35 IN THE MARKET. THERE'S
1:37 VOLATILITY RELATED TO MONETARY
1:38 POLICY, TRADE POLICY, FOREIGN
1:41 POLICY, GEOPOLITICAL U.S.
1:43 POLITICAL ENVIRONMENT AND
1:45 BITCOIN BREEDS ON VOLATILITY
1:47 GOES UP AND DOWN QUITE A BIT IN
1:49 THE LAST YEAR. AND AS BITCOIN
1:50 HAS DECLINED IN THE LAST YEAR,
1:52 SO HAS MSR FONG.
1:54 >> OUTSIDE OF THAT, WE'VE HAD
1:55 THIS THING CALLED THE ELECTION.
1:57 AGAIN. I KNOW IT'S GOTTEN LOST
1:58 IN THE NVIDIA NEWS, BUT IT'S
2:00 KIND OF A BIG DEAL AND IT'S A
2:02 BIG DEAL FOR REGULATION. WE'RE
2:03 GOING TO HAVE A NEW CONGRESS
2:04 COMING IN. WHAT DO YOU THINK
2:06 ABOUT IT. WHAT IS YOUR MESSAGE
2:07 TO THE NEW CONGRESS AND HOW
2:09 MIGHT IT IMPACT THE REGULATORY
2:10 FRAMEWORK THAT YOU AND THE
2:11 ENTIRE CRYPTO INDUSTRY HAS TO
2:13 DEAL WITH EVERY DAY?
2:14 >> I DON'T REALLY THINK BITCOIN
2:16 AND CRYPTO ARE PARTIZAN ISSUES,
2:17 RIGHT? BITCOIN AND CRYPTO ARE
2:19 ABOUT HOW DO WE MODERNIZE THE
2:21 FINANCIAL MARKETS AND HOW DO WE
2:22 CREATE FINANCIAL FREEDOM FOR
2:25 350 AMERICANS AND 8 BILLION
2:27 PEOPLE AROUND THE WORLD? AND
2:30 WHAT YOU SEE HAPPENING THROUGH
2:32 THE EXECUTIVE BRANCH, THE SEC,
2:34 THE CFTC IS A SET OF RULES THAT
2:36 ARE GOING TO ALLOW TOKENIZATION
2:38 OF SECURITIES AND ACCESS TO
2:41 STABLECOINS AND MODERNIZATION
2:42 OF FINANCIAL RAILS. IF I'M A
2:44 DEMOCRAT, I LOVE THAT. IF I'M A
2:46 REPUBLICAN, I LOVE THAT. SO
2:48 SURE, THERE WILL BE SOME SHORT
2:49 TERM VOLATILITY AND AND PERHAPS
2:53 SOME CHANGE RELATED TO WHO'S IN
2:56 CONGRESS. BUT I THINK LONG TERM,
2:57 IT'S A GOOD SETUP FOR CRYPTO
2:59 REGARDLESS OF WHO'S IN THE
3:00 WHITE HOUSE. CAN I ASK YOU.
3:01 >> ABOUT THE THE BINANCE THEFT?
3:04 YOU KNOW, YOU'VE GOT BILLIONS
3:05 OF DOLLARS MANAGING TO LEAVE
3:07 THESE ACCOUNTS. WHAT DID THAT
3:09 MEAN TO YOU AND HOW DID YOU
3:11 INTERPRET WHAT THAT SHOULD,
3:13 WHAT SHOULD BE THE IMPACT FOR
3:14 YOU AND FOR STRATEGY IN TERMS
3:17 OF DEFENSE? GOOD DEFENSE?
3:21 >> YEAH, IT'S A COUPLE OF
3:22 THINGS. WELL, FIRST OF ALL,
3:24 $6.3 BILLION WERE WERE WERE
3:26 TAKEN. ABOUT HALF OF THAT WAS
3:28 RETURNED ALREADY BECAUSE IT WAS
3:29 BASED ON STABLECOINS. AND ALL
3:32 OF IT HAS BEEN REFUNDED TO THE
3:35 OWNERS THAT WERE SITTING ON
3:36 BINANCE. SO I THINK THAT'S A
3:37 PRETTY GOOD STORY OVERALL. THAT
3:39 SAID, YOU KNOW, NOBODY LIKES
3:40 HACKS. NOBODY LIKES THE FACT
3:41 THAT SOME NATION STATE, NORTH
3:43 KOREA, HAS BEEN ABLE TO
3:44 INFILTRATE THAT KIND OF WEALTH.
3:47 WHAT DOES IT MEAN? LOOK, AI IS
3:49 REAL AND PEOPLE HAVE TO BE MORE
3:51 SECURE WHEN IT COMES TO RUNNING
3:52 AI FRONTIER MODELS AGAINST
3:54 THEIR SOFTWARE AND AGAINST
3:56 THEIR CUSTODIANS. WE HOLD ALL
3:58 OF OUR BITCOIN AND US BASED
4:00 CUSTODIANS IN COLD STORAGE. SO
4:03 I DO AGREE IT CREATES
4:05 REPUTATIONAL RISK TO THE SPACE,
4:07 BUT IT'S NOT A REAL HARD RISK
4:09 TO HOW WE'RE HOLDING OUR
4:10 BITCOIN. BUT WE HAVE TO STAY
4:11 VIGILANT.
4:12 >> I GOT TO ASK YOU ABOUT
4:13 NVIDIA TODAY. WHAT ARE YOUR
4:15 THOUGHTS ON THE CHALLENGES
4:16 FACING THAT COMPANY.
4:17 >> WELL I, I, I THINK JENSEN'S
4:19 DONE AN AMAZING THING OVER THE
4:20 LAST 30 YEARS BUILDING A
4:22 COMPANY FROM SCRATCH THAT UNTIL
4:24 TODAY WAS THE MOST VALUABLE
4:25 COMPANY IN THE WORLD.
4:27 EVERYTHING THAT WE TALK ABOUT
4:28 BECAUSE OF AI IS UNDERPINNED BY
4:31 THE TECHNOLOGY HE'S BEEN
4:32 CREATED. CEOS ARE HUMAN, RIGHT?
4:35 AND I DON'T REALLY KNOW WHAT'S
4:36 BEHIND WHAT OCCURRED MOST
4:38 RECENTLY. AI IS BIGGER THAN
4:40 JENSEN AT THIS POINT IN TIME,
4:42 IS A HUGE AREA OF CAPITAL
4:45 INFLOWS. IT'S A HUGE AREA OF
4:47 REALLY FREEDOM FOR INDIVIDUALS
4:50 AND INTELLIGENCE FOR
4:51 INDIVIDUALS AND ABUNDANCE FOR
4:53 INDIVIDUALS. SO I THINK I
Alice Huang owned stakes in Chinese businesses that benefited Huawei during affair with Jensen Huang full transcript
0:01 HAPPEN. JENSEN WAS SUCH A
0:03 COMFORTING. YEAH. ANYWAY.
0:04 >> FOR SURE. EVERYBODY HOLD
0:05 TIGHT. WE GOT SOME BREAKING
0:06 NEWS. LET'S GET TO EAMON JAVERS
0:08 I BELIEVE IN DC EAMON YEAH.
0:11 >> JOHN THAT'S RIGHT. CNBC HAS
0:13 LEARNED OF A SURPRISING
0:14 CONNECTION BETWEEN ALICE WONG,
0:16 THE CHINESE TECH EXECUTIVE AT
0:17 THE CENTER OF THE NVIDIA SEX
0:18 AND SPYING SCANDAL. AND HUAWEI,
0:21 THE CHINESE TECH COMPANY THAT'S
0:22 NVIDIA'S BIGGEST COMPETITOR IN
0:24 THAT COUNTRY. NOW ALICE WONG
0:26 MAY HAVE SIMULTANEOUSLY OWNED
0:29 STAKES IN COMPANIES UP UNTIL
0:31 2024 THAT BENEFITED HUAWEI,
0:33 EVEN AS SHE WAS HAVING AN
0:34 AFFAIR WITH JEN-HSUN HUANG OF
0:35 NVIDIA. NOW, THAT'S ACCORDING
0:36 TO THE PRIVATE INTELLIGENCE
0:37 FIRM TESSERAE, THE FIRM
0:40 ANALYZING CHINESE CORPORATE
0:41 RECORDS AND NEWS ARTICLES
0:42 CONCLUDES THAT THE COMPLICATED
0:44 TANGLE OF INTERLOCKING
0:45 CORPORATIONS CONNECTED TO THE
0:46 ALLEGED SPY ULTIMATELY PROVIDED
0:49 COMPUTING POWER TO HUAWEI IN
0:52 CHINA. NOW, HUAWEI IS
0:53 CONSIDERED A KEY PART OF THE
0:54 CHINESE GOVERNMENT'S PUSH FOR
0:55 GLOBAL TECHNICAL DOMINANCE AND
0:57 IS CLOSELY LINKED TO THE
0:59 CHINESE COMMUNIST PARTY.
1:00 TESSERAE SHARED ITS FINDINGS
1:02 EXCLUSIVELY WITH CNBC. TESSERAE,
1:04 BY THE WAY, PROVIDES
1:05 INTELLIGENCE RESEARCH TO
1:07 PRIVATE COMPANIES AND THE US
1:08 GOVERNMENT. THIS ACTIVITY,
1:10 WHICH SURFACED THROUGH OUR
1:11 ANALYSTS OUR ANALYSIS OF
1:12 ALYSSA'S NETWORK, WARRANTS A
1:14 NATIONAL SECURITY AND
1:16 COUNTER-PROLIFERATION
1:17 INVESTIGATION. THAT'S FROM
1:18 BRIAN ANDERSON, TESLA'S VICE
1:20 PRESIDENT FOR NATIONAL SECURITY
1:22 APPLICATIONS AND A FORMER
1:23 SUPERVISORY SPECIAL AGENT WITH
1:25 HOMELAND SECURITY
1:27 INVESTIGATIONS. HE SAID IF THE
1:28 COMMERCE DEPARTMENT'S BUREAU OF
1:29 INDUSTRY, SECURITY AND HOMELAND
1:31 SECURITY'S INVESTIGATIONS FOUND
1:32 EVIDENCE THAT ANYONE
1:33 TRANSFERRED CONTROL EQUIPMENT
1:36 TO HUAWEI WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION,
1:39 POTENTIAL CHARGES MIGHT INCLUDE
1:40 EXPORT CONTROL VIOLATIONS,
1:43 CONSPIRACY AND SMUGGLING,
1:44 ACCORDING TO DOCUMENTS REVIEWED
1:45 BY CNBC. AT THE END OF A CHAIN
1:48 OF COMPANIES IS A DATA CENTER
1:49 IN SHENZHEN, CHINA, WHICH WAS
1:51 PART OWNED BY AN ALICE WONG
1:53 ENTITY AND RECEIVED LOAN
1:55 GUARANTEES FROM A FIRM THAT WAS
1:56 LINKED TO HER. THAT DATA
1:58 CENTERS KEY CUSTOMER WAS HUAWEI
2:00 CLOUD, A SUBSIDIARY OF THE
2:02 BROADER COMPANY. NOW WE'VE
2:03 REACHED OUT TO HUAWEI, NVIDIA,
2:05 AND THE CORPORATE ENTITIES
2:06 ASSOCIATED WITH ALICE WONG FOR
2:08 COMMENT, BUT WE'VE NOT HEARD
2:09 BACK FROM ANY OF THEM JUST YET.
2:11 BACK OVER TO YOU.
2:12 >> EAMON QUESTION HERE. I'M
2:13 PRETTY SURE THAT MEGA SPEED,
2:15 THE COMPANY THAT WE FIRST HEARD
2:17 OF, ASSOCIATED WITH ALICE WONG,
2:19 SHE WAS SORT OF RUNNING OR IN A
2:22 POSITION TO HAVE VERY MUCH
2:23 INFLUENCE. THERE IS ALSO TIED
2:24 TO ALIBABA. NOW THIS IS A TIE
2:26 TO HUAWEI. THOSE ARE TWO OF THE
2:29 OF THE DOMINANT, IF YOU CAN SAY,
2:32 TO HAVE DOMINANT TECH COMPANIES
2:33 IN CHINA. SO A COUPLE OF THE
2:35 BIGGEST SORT OF LIKE A
2:37 MICROSOFT AND A GOOGLE AT LEAST
2:39 SIZE WISE. YES. SO HOW UNUSUAL
2:42 WOULD IT BE FOR SOMEONE TO HAVE
2:44 HOLDINGS OR CONNECTIONS TO
2:47 COMPANIES THAT HAVE A LOT OF
2:49 TENTACLES THROUGHOUT THE
2:51 ECONOMY OF ASIA?
2:52 >> WELL, IT CERTAINLY SHOWS A
2:53 DEEP DEGREE OF CONNECTION TO
2:55 THE TOP CHINESE COMPANIES IN
2:57 CHINA. RIGHT? THIS IS A COMPANY
2:59 IN MEGA SPEED THAT WAS SET UP
3:01 IN SINGAPORE AND WAS OSTENSIBLY
3:03 SAFE TO EXPORT TO BECAUSE IT
3:05 WAS A SINGAPOREAN COMPANY. BUT
3:07 AT THE SAME TIME, YOU'RE SEEING
3:08 NOW THIS CONNECTION BETWEEN
3:10 ALICE WONG AND HUAWEI AT THIS
3:13 SHENZHEN DATA CENTER IN
3:15 MAINLAND CHINA. AND SO YOU CAN
3:17 START TO CONNECT THE DOTS
3:18 BETWEEN ALICE WONG AND MAINLAND
3:22 CHINA. AND THE QUESTION WILL BE,
3:23 DID THE NVIDIA CHIPS MAKE THEIR
3:25 WAY TO THAT DATA CENTER IN
3:27 MAINLAND CHINA? AND WAS THAT
3:29 ILLEGAL? RIGHT. THAT'S WHAT
3:30 INVESTIGATORS ARE GOING TO WANT
3:31 TO LOOK AT. AND THE QUESTION
3:33 HERE IS, WILL INVESTIGATORS
3:35 EVER GET A CHANCE TO QUESTION
3:37 ALICE WONG? IT'S NOT ENTIRELY
3:38 CLEAR WHERE SHE IS RIGHT NOW.
3:41 THE CHANCES OF HER ENDING UP
3:42 BACK ON U.S. SOIL OBVIOUSLY
3:43 PRETTY SLIM. SO INVESTIGATORS
3:45 ARE GOING TO HAVE TO DO A LOT
3:46 OF THIS RESEARCH FROM A
3:48 DISTANCE AND FROM A REMOVE, BUT
3:49 THEY'RE GOING TO WANT TO LOOK
3:51 AT THE FLOW OF OWNERSHIP, AS WE
3:53 JUST LAID OUT FOR YOU, OF THESE
3:55 SHELL ENTITIES AND INTERLOCKING
3:56 ENTITIES AND THE DATA CENTER IN
3:57 CHINA,
Experts react to Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang’s resignation and succession plan full transcript
0:00 Nvidia's Jensen Huang is stepping down immediately,
0:03 resigning from his post as chairman and CEO of Nvidia.
0:07 Colette Kress is appointed interim CEO.
0:11 The CFO had been the name had been most mentioned as a
0:14 potential replacement for Jensen Huang.
0:16 President posting just moments ago this.
0:19 He says 'now that Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang,
0:21 who has done a fantastic job,
0:23 has resigned. There is only one man to take his place.
0:27 Tim Cook of Apple.
0:29 A legend replaces a legend.'
0:38 Look, she's natural.
0:39 She is someone who has been leading the calls.
0:43 That's funny, Carl, there's 42,000 people
0:46 there. A lot of people feel there's never been anybody
0:50 who really stands for the company or means anything.
0:52 Colette's been my contact person other than Jensen for
0:55 years. She's no nonsense and she is absolutely the one
1:00 that you need right now.
1:01 Because she has the bearing,
1:03 she will accept no nonsense.
1:05 Now I think what what I think everyone feels like
1:07 because it's so political right now, okay, what does
1:09 she know about what did she know about Kimberly Powell?
1:12 And I know Kimberly well.
1:13 She's been the person to run health care for a long time.
1:16 What does she know about this? What does she know
1:17 about that? And all that I can tell you is, is that I
1:20 think that Colette is above all this stuff.
1:23 Now you can say, well, Jim, you thought did
1:25 you like Jenson?
1:26 But you know what?
1:27 At least when it comes to running the call and being
1:30 organized and telling you about the cash,
1:32 which I think at some point people are actually going to
1:34 be worried about because everything else is on the
1:35 table, I trust her.
1:37 I think there is a lot of evidence to suggest this
1:40 board was very deferential to Jensen Huang,
1:42 right? Um, there was no board chair.
1:45 There was no succession plan.
1:47 Um, five of the individuals sitting on the board,
1:50 including Jensen, have been on the board since
1:52 the start. So they have developed very close
1:55 relationships over this period of time and the board
1:58 has a track record of being quite deferential to him.
2:01 And, you know, I this is the difficult
2:04 thing when you have a company with a visionary
2:07 superstar CEO, right?
2:09 Um, this person is creating a lot of value.
2:12 They have a big vision.
2:13 You know, you don't want to rein them in if it's going
2:17 to be costly for the company,
2:18 the company, its prospects, its shareholders.
2:21 Um, and so I think up until this point,
2:24 the board has been playing that role.
2:27 This is the number one thing to figure out right now is
2:29 who is going to lead this company forward. They have a
2:31 great interim CFO or interim CEO who is their former CFO,
2:35 but I don't think she has the operational experience
2:38 that's necessary to move this company forward and so
2:40 this is a five alarm fire moment for the board is how
2:45 do we navigate through this so to minimize the damage?
2:48 And yeah, that's the focus now.
2:50 Um, I think you could argue,
2:52 given where the stock is, that this could be a
2:54 clearing event for the company.
2:56 The stock is now trading at ten times GAAP earnings on
3:00 calendar '27. It's going to generate over $300 billion
3:04 in free cash flow next year.
3:05 We think that there is certainly a lot of talent in
3:09 the company. Certainly retention of that talent
3:11 becomes extremely important going forward.
3:14 But, uh, you know, hopefully the company can
3:17 turn the page and move forward. We're happy with,
3:19 uh, the interim CEO.
3:22 Uh, and we assume that the board will do a rigorous
3:25 search process and we encourage them to obviously
3:29 consider both external and internal candidates.
3:32 There's clearly a lot of talent that's helped Nvidia
3:35 build what they've done over the last number of years.
3:39 Um, and so I think it's appropriate to both consider
3:42 both internal as external.
3:44 There's obviously a question of, you know, who could be
3:46 the logical candidate to run Nvidia,
3:48 whether that's an internal or an external candidate.
3:51 There's a lot of questions about you know, does
3:53 anything change in the strategy? You know, how much
3:54 of the strategy was tied to Jensen's deep convictions
3:57 about where this industry goes,
3:59 how they use their balance sheet, what that look like
4:01 with their ecosystem. So I think a lot of that calls
4:03 into question. Obviously, things we don't have the
4:06 answer for. But I think anytime something like this
4:08 happens and we observe this,
4:10 you know, back in the day with Apple when Steve Jobs
4:12 had cancer and then, you know, inevitably,
4:14 inevitably died, it creates a huge shakeup
4:16 and an impact to the industry and we're going
4:19 through that process right now.
4:21 It is a very sad day.
4:22 Um, you know, we are giving up the lead in
4:26 AI, in my view, to China.
4:28 Uh, Jensen was the most optimistic supporter of AI.
4:32 Obviously created the foundational technology that
4:35 is enabling frontier models and for the US to be a
4:38 leader in AI. And I think that him being forced out,
4:42 uh, is a, is a major loss for Nvidia and also a major
4:45 loss for the United States. So,
4:47 uh, again, a very sad day for not only,
4:49 you know, Jensen, not only for Nvidia,
4:51 but I think also for the country.
Squawk Pod: Jensen Huang resigns: what’s next, & who is Alice Huang? full transcript
0:00 Bring in show music, please.
0:05 >> Hi, I'm CNBC producer Katie Kramer.
0:07 Today on Squawk Pod, Jensen Wong resigns
0:10 from Nvidia.
0:11 >> I felt like we were kind of on smoke for
0:14 the Pope.
0:14 >> The drama hitting Silicon Valley, Wall
0:17 Street, and Washington. CNBC's Aean
0:19 Javvers.
0:20 >> Clearly, there were people in and around
0:22 Jensen Wong's inner circle who knew
0:25 about this, who, you know, were taking
0:27 steps to protect him from himself. Wong
0:29 steps down with an announcement that
0:31 broke while we were on the air.
0:33 >> Colette Crest is appointed the CEO.
0:37 She's the CFO and had been the name had
0:39 been most mentioned as a potential
0:41 replacement for Jensen Wong.
0:43 >> The CFO was perhaps the only person that
0:45 they felt that they that the investment
0:47 world knew.
0:48 >> We check in with Ununice Yun in Beijing
0:50 about the scandal. And who is alleged
0:52 spy Alice Wong? She's uh viewed here as
0:56 in China publicly as what's known as a
1:00 chenu. So somebody who is a commercial
1:03 fixer. Plus who in the Trump
1:05 administration knew what when the sexion
1:08 geopolitics with US trade representative
1:10 Jameson Greer.
1:11 >> I'll just say that our intelligence
1:13 community is is active of course.
1:14 They're always trying to track all kinds
1:16 of issues, national security, economic
1:17 security issues. The president and other
1:19 members of the cabinet, myself included,
1:21 are are briefed regularly.
1:23 It's Thursday, November 12th, 2026.
1:26 Squawk Pod begins right now.
1:29 >> Stand back by in three, two, one. Fuel,
1:32 please.
1:35 >> Good morning everybody. Welcome to
1:36 Squawkbox right here on CNBC. We are
1:39 live from the NASDAQ market site in
1:40 Times Square. I'm Becky Quick along with
1:43 Joe Kernan and Andrew Ross Sorcin. And
1:45 here we go. It's Thursday.
1:47 >> Let's get right to the top story of the
1:49 morning. Nvidia's board weighing now
1:51 whether to remove co Jensen Wong
1:53 following a report of that second
1:54 extrammarital affair with an employee of
1:57 the company. Aean Javvers joining us now
1:59 with the latest. Aean.
2:01 >> Yeah, Andrew. That's right. The New York
2:03 Times reported late Wednesday that
2:04 Nvidia CEO Jensen Wong had a second
2:07 affair in addition to the previously
2:09 reported diance with an alleged Chinese
2:12 spy. In this case, the Times reports his
2:15 partner was Kimberly Powell, Nvidia's
2:17 vice president of healthcare. The paper
2:19 reports that the couple were caught on
2:22 video being affectionate at a San Jose
2:25 hotel during an Nvidia conference this
2:27 past spring. The paper cites five people
2:30 who worked at the company describing the
2:32 relationship between the two and the
2:35 Times notes that Pal is also married to
2:38 another person. separately. The Wall
2:40 Street Journal reported last night that
2:42 the board of Nvidia was preparing to
2:45 meet at that time to consider Wong's
2:47 future at Nvidia. And guys, I would also
2:50 direct your attention to a fascinating
2:53 Wall Street Journal report this morning
2:55 uh which suggests that the person who
2:57 introduced uh the alleged Chinese spy
3:01 Alice Wong to Jensen Wong was in fact
3:04 her husband and business partner. uh
3:07 they had partnered in uh computer gaming
3:10 companies over the years and the husband
3:12 apparently according to the Wall Street
3:14 Journal reporting this morning was the
3:15 one who introduced his wife to Jensen
3:18 Wong and apparently over time uh didn't
3:21 seem to mind that she had a very close
3:24 relationship with Jensen Wong which has
3:26 now been exposed as a romantic
3:28 relationship. So uh there's some human
3:30 entanglements here, there are corporate
3:32 entanglements here, there national
3:33 security entanglements here. very
3:35 complicated situation and the question
3:36 is will Jensen Wong survive the day in
3:39 his job as CEO guys
3:42 >> uh Aean that that second reference by
3:44 the way on the human nature of it with
3:46 the the husband who uh was unbelievable
3:49 the other uh little detail that I
3:52 thought was extraordinary but really
3:54 more importantly about this affair that
3:55 he had had with an employee at the
3:57 company uh was that the team security uh
4:01 sought an NDA from somebody who took a
4:04 picture of it.
4:06 >> Yeah.
4:06 >> And I wonder whether that security team
4:09 >> Yeah.
4:11 >> Yeah. According to the New York Times
4:12 reporting and you know, Andrew, we can't
4:14 match this. I mean, the New York Times
4:15 has been fantastic on this and was way
4:17 ahead of everybody else. Um, but
4:19 according to the Times's reporting, uh,
4:21 there was a an Nvidia employee or a
4:24 group of NVIDIA employees who witnessed
4:25 this canoodling romantic moment,
4:28 whatever it was, uh, and one of them
4:31 pulled out a cell phone and captured
4:33 some of it on video and the security
4:34 team converged on that person and asked
4:36 them to sign an NDA to not disclose
4:39 that. Uh so clearly there were people in
4:42 and around uh Jensen Wong's inner circle
4:45 who knew about this uh who you know were
4:48 taking steps to protect him uh from
4:50 himself. And you got to ask the question
4:52 Andrew you know if you're the board of
4:53 directors here looking at this I mean
4:54 this is aggressive risktaking and you
4:57 know potentially self-destructive risk
4:59 takingaking when you're dealing with an
5:00 employee of your own company. um you
5:03 know does that is that judgment just in
5:05 his personal life or is he also taking
5:07 aggressive and potentially uh
5:09 self-destructive risks in his business
5:11 life as well and that's the kind of
5:13 decision that the board is faced with
5:15 this morning
5:16 >> right Aman let's briefly talk about
5:18 what's happening in Washington as it
5:20 relates to the spy case because that
5:21 seems to be to be the larger overhang
5:24 longer term of the entire company in
5:27 terms of its ability to sell into China
5:28 or rather to sell say sell into
5:31 different parts of the country or the
5:32 world rather. Uh, another report uh that
5:35 came from Axios yesterday uh seemed to
5:38 suggest that there was a real fight uh
5:40 between the commerce department um uh
5:43 Howard Lutnik and Scott Bessant uh and a
5:47 whole number of other members of the
5:49 cabinet about what uh was happening and
5:53 how long um Nvidia has been allowed to
5:56 sell into some of these markets at a
5:58 time when it appears the president had
6:00 been telling uh the commerce department
6:02 uh that they shouldn't be allowed to.
6:05 >> Yeah, fascinating, you know, sort of
6:07 infighting and we don't know exactly
6:09 what happened there, Andrew. But it does
6:11 appear from the reporting uh that there
6:13 is a real schism inside the Trump
6:15 administration about how to handle uh
6:17 Nvidia, how to handle mega speed, and
6:20 this question of chip sales to China. Um
6:22 a and you know, clearly it seems that
6:25 Jensen Wong was courting Donald Trump as
6:28 his sort of political protector so he
6:30 could continue to expand chip sales.
6:32 that was his goal, you know,
6:33 self-announced goal uh to expand that.
6:36 Uh but there's real questions here,
6:38 right? So around the intelligence piece
6:39 and the Chinese spying is one thing, but
6:41 there's also a law enforcement question
6:43 here for Nvidia. And I think, you know,
6:45 it's clear that there's some potential
6:48 criminal exposure uh for Jensen Wong and
6:51 anybody inside Nvidia who knew about
6:54 deliberate efforts to circumvent US
6:56 export controls of advanced chips to
6:59 China. Right. The relationship with
7:00 Megape, Mega Speed's relationship with
7:03 domestic uh data centers in China uh is
7:06 the real question here. Did anybody
7:08 inside Nvidia know that there was a
7:12 deliberate effort and chips were going
7:14 around US law uh into China? If that's
7:16 the case, you know, there are laws on
7:18 the books about that, Andrew, and
7:20 there's jail sentences that are
7:22 potentially attached to that if people
7:24 are investigated and convicted. So that
7:26 risk exists for Nvidia as we sit here
7:29 right now. And the question is how
7:31 aggressively will US law enforcement
7:34 pursue that uh whether or not Jensen
7:37 Wong is to remain as CEO of this
7:39 company. There are other people inside
7:41 the company who could have been aware of
7:44 something like that if it happened. So
7:45 there's a there's legal criminal
7:47 potential exposure here. And then on the
7:49 intelligence side, obviously there
7:51 there's an intelligence uh breach here
7:54 uh that US intelligence is going to have
7:55 to get its arms around and figure out
7:57 how much information was transferred to
7:59 the Chinese and when.
8:01 >> Right. Uh Amy Jabvers, we appreciate it
8:03 this morning. Thank you. Uh Joe, there's
8:06 a lot of supporters though out there for
8:08 him uh at the moment in in Silicon
8:11 Valley.
8:12 >> Yeah, Elon too. Like we were saying, if
8:15 if you know it's a big word, but if it
8:18 wasn't a spy and if it wasn't an
8:19 employee, it's like I'm tired of even
8:21 hearing about it. But I'll tell you one
8:23 thing, we both uh Becky and I both think
8:24 Eric Schmidt, there's a uh
8:28 Why not? Uh okay, that's a good idea. Uh
8:31 but Elon Musk, Andrew,
8:35 I don't know who
8:35 >> I think he's unlikely to get the job
8:37 though
8:39 because I was looking through the list
8:40 of people.
8:40 >> You know the history. You know the
8:41 history. You know what I'm saying? Of
8:42 course I do. Just blow it off.
8:44 >> No, I know exactly what you're saying.
8:45 >> But I would say interestingly the two
8:47 people that are on that list that to me
8:50 make the most sense.
8:51 >> Yeah.
8:52 >> Uh the second though may be
8:53 disqualifying as you said about Eric
8:55 would be Tim and Eric. Tim Tim Cook
8:58 >> on end
9:01 actually Eric's it's all out there. So
9:03 maybe who gives a crap at this point?
9:07 >> It's like finding about him. And you
9:10 know the the name are interesting like
9:12 Tim Cook would be amazing but why would
9:13 he come back if he didn't want to run
9:15 after this to step down and the other
9:17 name would be Lisa Sue but she's she's
9:19 got her own company that has been
9:21 amazing and is taking off. Why step away
9:24 from AMD? Andrew, was that yesterday or
9:26 the day before? There's something with
9:27 his latest paramore that that um
9:30 >> she's mad about
9:31 >> she wants about an he has a stake in
9:33 anthropic that she supposedly
9:35 >> she wants
9:37 back there and and the page six. Yes.
9:39 Okay.
9:40 >> It's crazy. But it's all out there. It's
9:42 like But that's what I mean. Even
9:44 >> but it's reckless for for for I think
9:47 for Jensen. That's that's the problem.
9:49 It's it shows some I mean some it's
9:51 reckless. I I don't care, you know, but
9:53 it just seems reckless.
9:56 >> I don't know. I want to go back to the
9:57 Tim Cook idea for a second. I I the
10:01 what's so interesting about the job
10:02 itself of replacing Jensen, which is
10:05 almost irreplaceable unto itself, um is
10:08 that so much of the job is about having
10:10 the relationship with TSMC, probably
10:13 most especially a lot of the governments
10:15 in Asia. That becomes a particularly
10:17 important point.
10:18 >> He's the ambassador. How do you find an
10:20 ambassador? the engineering piece of it
10:23 uh in a certain way. Um and then and
10:25 then obviously having government
10:26 relations in the US and elsewhere.
10:29 >> I don't know for Tim. I mean, Tim did
10:31 want to step down from Apple, but I feel
10:32 like maybe maybe he he made his run at
10:35 Apple and you know what, everybody's
10:36 looking for an encore, and this could be
10:38 a fascinating uh
10:40 >> no question. He'd be amazing from the
10:42 from being an ambassador with all of
10:44 this because the other thing you think
10:45 about with with Jensen is the bigger um
10:49 ability to move the AI trade. He's been
10:51 the person who has been looking at the
10:53 bottlenecks for AI as an industry and
10:56 trying to find ways to bring it. The
10:57 most recent one being the idea that
10:59 there's not enough financing. He got six
11:01 Wall Street CEOs together and came up
11:03 with half a trillion dollars in
11:05 financing that they were going to put
11:06 together for this. You know, it's it's
11:09 what he does, which by the way is not
11:11 happening right now.
11:12 >> Yeah. Right.
11:13 >> Interesting.
11:14 >> What happens with this? Tim Cook could
11:16 certainly do something like that. Uh
11:18 would he want to? I think would be my
11:19 bigger question.
11:21 >> Right.
11:21 >> I just think of him as a guy who
11:22 understands supply chain. That's a huge
11:24 part of this uh
11:25 >> sort of component part. I it'll be
11:27 interesting. But by the way, with if you
11:29 put the page six piece of it aside, Eric
11:32 Schmidt, given his knowledge of AI and
11:34 how deep he is on also on supply chain,
11:37 I mean, he's been working on some of the
11:38 drones and and things in Ukraine and
11:40 this guy would know how to do it. Again,
11:44 given given some of the history, I don't
11:45 know.
11:45 >> I mean, I wish I didn't care
11:47 >> blackmail somebody who's
11:48 >> right. I wish I didn't care about
11:50 Jensen, but there's um
11:52 >> I do I like him. I know, but I mean I I
11:54 I I wish it wasn't a a fate, you know,
11:59 complaint that that that he's out, but I
12:01 don't that he's I don't see any way
12:02 around it. Uh really, Elon, uh let's
12:05 talk about what
12:06 >> for months on end. Don't you think just
12:07 for months on end this is going to go
12:09 on? I mean, how it'd be hard to manage
12:11 the company during
12:12 >> Not unless Yeah. Not unless they do it
12:13 today.
12:14 >> And as Joe pointed out, look, a Chinese
12:16 spy in one hand trouble with the United
12:18 States government and then an employee
12:20 on the other HR. How does the board not
12:22 handle
12:23 >> exactly
12:25 >> right Elon uh and then you know Elon's
12:29 personal life pretty interesting uh
12:30 anyway he's joining the conversation
12:32 saying not that I care and not that it's
12:34 any of my business saying he's open to
12:35 hiring Jensen Wong if uh inv video lets
12:37 its CEO go last night the financial blog
12:40 Zero Hedge wrote on X uh Elon please
12:45 hire Jensen Musk responded that would be
12:47 an honor
12:49 >> coming up uh much Yeah. Yeah. Go ahead,
12:52 Andrew.
12:52 >> Well, no. All I was going to mention is
12:54 if you really think about the companies
12:56 that are exposed in a certain way to
13:00 Nvidia,
13:02 Elon 500 as
13:05 >> as connected as anything. No, no. in so
13:07 far as Elon's gone all in on Nvidia
13:09 chips, open AI too, but you know
13:12 >> the the vehicles, uh, Optimus,
13:15 >> um, everything he's trying to do in
13:17 terms of the terapabs, it's all based on
13:20 Nvidia chips. He's and and he has this
13:23 special relationship with with Jensen 2,
13:25 who's privileged him in terms of access
13:27 to those chips. And so, you know, you
13:29 start to think about you start to think
13:31 about the access. You certain companies
13:32 have had better access. Core, we've got
13:34 some early access. There's other
13:35 companies got, you know, Apollo's trying
13:37 to have
13:39 >> That's interesting. Does that change the
13:41 chips?
13:42 >> Yeah.
13:42 >> Yeah.
13:43 >> If you had a different CEO, it is all
13:45 based on personal relationships. How
13:46 would all of that work? That actually is
13:48 where the implication is, I think.
13:49 >> That's interesting.
13:50 >> And it's also if he leaves Nvidia, okay,
13:53 so he he paid the price, then he could
13:56 go somewhere else. Well, yeah, we've
13:57 already litigated that and we already we
14:00 knew we knew what we were getting and he
14:02 could go somewhere else, Andrew.
14:04 just he's got to leave Nvidia it seems
14:06 like.
14:06 >> Yeah. But then if you're if you're the
14:08 Nvidia board, you look at this and
14:10 you're like, how do you not from a
14:11 governance perspective take it on,
14:13 >> right?
14:14 >> Then if you have the idea that, oh my
14:15 gosh, now we're going to compete against
14:16 the only guy who has ever run the
14:18 company, one of the co-founders of the
14:19 company who's been there 30 years. Um,
14:22 >> right,
14:22 >> that's a scary prospect, too.
14:24 >> And then you just have to the AI trade
14:26 is so big and it's so all-encompassing.
14:28 It's not one person, but there are
14:30 articles written that the whole AI trade
14:33 is now in question or at least at risk
14:36 or at least uh trembling because
14:39 >> what Andrew mentioned about that, you
14:40 know, half a trillion dollars in
14:41 financing not necessarily being there at
14:43 this point. Um
14:44 >> it's uh we didn't expect this, I'll tell
14:47 you that much.
14:50 >> SquawkPod will be right back.
14:57 You're listening to Squawk Pod.
14:59 >> Good morning. Welcome back to Squawk
15:01 Fox. We are live at the NASDAQ market
15:02 site in Times Square.
15:05 That's where Joe and Becky are this
15:06 morning.
15:07 >> Nvidia shares down again this morning as
15:09 the company's board considers ousting
15:11 its CEO. In the meantime, we're learning
15:13 more about Alice Wong, the woman accused
15:15 of being a Chinese spy who had an affair
15:18 with Jensen Wong. Ununice Yun joins us
15:20 right now with the latest on that.
15:22 Ununice, good morning. Good morning,
15:24 Becky. Well, Alex Wong is reportedly in
15:26 Beijing. Bloomberg is citing sources as
15:29 saying that uh she is here under the
15:31 close close um watchful eye of the
15:34 Chinese authorities. Uh when asked about
15:36 this, the foreign ministry had no
15:39 comment and when we called her number
15:42 that was listed on her business card, uh
15:44 no one picked up. Now, Alex Wong, Alex
15:47 Wang is uh someone who has built a
15:49 career in finance before moving into uh
15:52 the data center business um essentially
15:54 being an executive running a Singaporean
15:57 company that's been accused of smuggling
16:00 Nvidia chips. She's uh viewed here as in
16:04 China publicly as what's known as a
16:07 chenu. So somebody who is a commercial
16:10 fixer and that is a business persona who
16:13 uh drifts uh towards money-making
16:15 opportunities and then leverages off of
16:18 her contacts. So this is how people here
16:20 are explaining why she would be so
16:23 public about her connections with Jensen
16:26 Hong. It was seen as a marketing uh a
16:29 way for her to market her access to
16:31 those chips. And it's also a reason why
16:33 there are many people within the Chinese
16:35 business community who think that she
16:36 might not have been a spy in the sense
16:38 of um a trained intelligence agent, but
16:42 she could have been approached uh for
16:45 information uh by the Ministry of State
16:48 Security. Uh there has been an impact
16:50 though um this whole scandal has had an
16:53 impact on the underground trade of
16:55 Nvidia chips. Um I was speaking with uh
16:58 one uh chip smuggler who said that
17:01 there's been a pause now into next week
17:04 uh through APEC u because of the scandal
17:07 and also because of the expectation that
17:09 there's going to be greater US scrutiny
17:11 uh due to President Trump coming in.
17:13 I've been told that the price of eight
17:16 um B300 chips has uh now reached uh come
17:20 up five times from May at now nearly $3
17:23 million. This is versus the official US
17:26 price of $550,000.
17:29 China AI stocks tank today because of
17:31 this expectation here that the US is
17:34 going to hit harder when it comes to
17:36 export curbs on Nvidia chips. The uh
17:40 traders though uh don't think that the
17:43 demand is going to go away anytime soon.
17:46 They see the prices remaining quite
17:48 robust uh because they said that they're
17:50 seeing hoarding. Guys,
17:52 >> Unice, that's really interesting. I mean
17:54 the the stock market reaction there
17:56 suggests that these were chips that were
17:58 far easier to get your hands on than
18:01 would be implied by what the US export
18:05 controls have said to this point
18:07 >> and just the idea that the prices have
18:09 jumped that much at the idea of
18:11 additional scrutiny.
18:13 >> Right. Absolutely. I mean that's why we
18:14 saw like Alibaba's stock is down 7%. uh
18:18 you know that was one company that um
18:20 was supposedly a uh potential customer
18:23 of Mega Speed, the company that Alice
18:25 Wong had helped manage. Uh Alibaba has
18:28 no comment about that, but there was
18:31 this expectation or this belief that a
18:33 lot of these Chinese companies have been
18:35 looking for different workarounds in
18:36 order to gain access to Nvidia chips.
18:39 >> What do we think of the idea that, you
18:41 know, these H200 chips from Nvidia were
18:44 allowed to be sold earlier this year?
18:47 And the reports were, well, the Chinese
18:49 government didn't want them. Was was
18:51 that just a cover? Were these companies
18:53 looking for those chips anyway?
18:55 >> From from what I understand, the H200
18:57 chips are still very advanced. Uh but
19:00 you know, as we've seen throughout this
19:02 year, the Chinese government has a very
19:04 conflicted relationship um when it comes
19:06 to Nvidia because um we've already heard
19:09 like earlier this week, there were um
19:11 reports that there were, you know,
19:12 600,000 uh H200 chips that were sitting
19:16 in a Hong Kong port that were supposed
19:17 to be coming in, but then weren't
19:19 allowed to come in. And that uh because
19:21 the government here does want to develop
19:23 its own um industry, it doesn't
19:26 necessarily want to have so many Nvidia
19:28 chips here. But when I speak to uh
19:31 people who um are in the AI industry um
19:34 they have said that they cannot do
19:36 without the NVIDIA chips and a lot of
19:38 them said that they don't even want to
19:39 mess around with some of the um local
19:42 chips if they don't have to.
19:44 >> Uh Nikki Haley suggested that President
19:48 Trump should not meet with President Xi
19:50 next week because of the fallout from
19:52 this. What what would be the push back?
19:55 What would happen if that meeting did
19:56 not play take place next week?
19:59 I think that would be pretty bad uh
20:01 because of the fact that the marketing
20:04 around APE is that uh this is uh
20:07 Xiinping's time. He's here to have all
20:10 these different companies uh countries
20:12 and companies actually come to him and
20:15 it's really a time for for China to be
20:16 able to show off and shine. So, um, a
20:19 lot of people have told me that that
20:20 the, um, authorities here want these,
20:23 uh, leaders and the companies to walk
20:25 away thinking that China is essential to
20:28 their business or to their trade. And so
20:31 if President Trump uh decided suddenly
20:33 to pull out at this late stage and not
20:35 show up um that could be taken very
20:38 badly especially because um culturally
20:41 here a Chinese the Chinese you know face
20:44 is just so much more important here than
20:46 it is say in the United States.
20:48 >> Right. Ununice Yun Ununice thank you
20:51 very much. So guys, um I immediately
20:54 thought that Stone Cipher, remember
20:56 Boeing, uh he had Ander, he had some
20:58 apartment in Chicago that that went and
21:01 but
21:01 >> moved the company headquarters there.
21:02 >> Yeah, moved it. This just joged my
21:04 memory though. Mark Herd,
21:06 >> anyone? Anyone? Hullet Packer. Brian
21:09 Kzanic. Anyone in Intel?
21:12 >> Intel. Yeah.
21:13 >> Um Steve Rasterbrook.
21:15 >> McDonald's.
21:16 >> McDonald's. That one I thought of
21:17 earlier. McDonald's.
21:17 >> Um I forgot all these several.
21:20 >> Best Buy. Um it just uh it's not
21:23 >> you go down the list
21:25 >> and every one of those CEOs is gone. It
21:27 >> it's gone. But then
21:29 >> you can manage around it like you know
21:31 if you have divorces and stuff like
21:34 >> single like that was that I thought
21:36 maybe he would survive that at first.
21:38 >> Exactly. But guys get divorced and you
21:40 know Bezos or whatever things happen and
21:43 and um you can be too big to fail I
21:46 think. Um is is there any way that's the
21:49 case here? I I can't I don't know. What
21:51 do you think?
21:53 >> I think the Chinese spy one is the
21:54 toughest one and issues of national
21:56 security.
21:58 >> I think the employee one, oddly enough,
22:01 I I think the employee one might be the
22:03 one that's harder for the board or maybe
22:05 the combination of both.
22:07 >> I don't know.
22:08 >> You know,
22:09 >> if you're the board if you're the board,
22:11 >> look, the board's already being sued. Um
22:14 so, you know, there are going to be
22:16 lawsuits that come from this. That's got
22:17 to play into some of these issues, too.
22:20 Um,
22:21 >> well, but it also glad you're not on
22:23 right now.
22:24 >> I just think if you're the board, how do
22:25 you how would how are you going to
22:27 operate the company?
22:28 >> Yeah.
22:28 >> Meaning, how could he operate the
22:30 company on a daily basis right now?
22:32 >> You you can't, right? Cuz you're going
22:34 to be with lawyers yourself all day.
22:39 >> Up next, China chips. What's left for
22:42 our policy with US Trade Representative
22:44 Jameson Greer. but a view inside the
22:47 administration uh that for whatever
22:49 reason commerce has not moved as fast on
22:53 this as the president has wanted. Can
22:55 you speak to any of this?
22:56 >> Well, I I usually don't comment on on
22:58 the gossip rags and certainly not with
23:00 conversations that that may have
23:01 happened in the local office and
23:03 situation rooms or sensitive
23:04 discussions. I I'll just say that uh you
23:07 know national security is of paramount
23:08 importance to the president.
23:15 Welcome back to Squawk Pod from CNBC.
23:17 We'll jump right into it. Here's Joe.
23:21 >> Joining us now, United States Trade
23:23 Representative, Ambassador uh Jameson
23:25 Greer. Mr. Ambassador, it's good to uh
23:27 to have you on this morning. Welcome.
23:29 >> Good to be here. Thanks for having me.
23:31 >> I don't see how we can um we can just
23:33 talk about anything other than uh what
23:35 we've been talking about all morning. Uh
23:37 what do you make of the the situation at
23:40 Nvidia? uh Jensen Wong, do do you know
23:43 anything we don't know about uh getting
23:46 around export controls and and what may
23:49 have happened, what might have
23:50 transpired? Well, obviously Nvidia is a
23:54 structurally important company. Uh we're
23:56 seeing fluctuations of course and their
23:59 stock value and things like that. Those
24:00 are dayto-day. Uh the reality is the the
24:03 AI buildout, data centers, the next
24:05 industrial revolution that's happening.
24:07 Um obviously from time to time you have
24:10 uh you have scandal or you have
24:12 developments at companies with
24:13 leadership etc. uh that's being you know
24:16 if you listen to Nvidia they have their
24:17 own investigation going on the board's
24:19 looking at it on the US government side
24:21 uh export control agency and the
24:23 commerce department uh they have things
24:25 they go through they have a career staff
24:27 that focus on uh you know potential
24:30 problems. There have been uh a number of
24:32 enforcement actions over the past year,
24:34 two years uh looking into a variety of
24:36 of issues and obviously we remain
24:39 concerned. Uh we want to make sure that
24:41 uh when we're selling our chips to the
24:43 world, we want the world to be on the AI
24:44 stack, but we want the crown jewels uh
24:46 to remain in US hands or in the hands of
24:48 our allies. you you have rec recently
24:52 made some just overall comments uh about
24:56 China and and past trade commitments
24:59 that they've made and and you would like
25:01 them to comply. Are they not complying
25:04 at this point?
25:05 >> Well, it's a it's a partial compliance
25:07 is how we look at it. They committed to
25:10 buy 25 million metric tons of soybeans
25:12 this year. They've done that or they've
25:14 made purchases to that effect or they've
25:15 or they've booked orders to that effect.
25:17 When it comes to rare earths, uh, we're
25:19 getting some of what we need. We always
25:22 want to have it at a at a quicker pace
25:24 and in a higher volume. We'd like it to
25:26 be at the same levels that it was, you
25:27 know, a few years ago, uh, before they
25:29 started cracking down on rare earth at
25:31 the tail end of the Biden administration
25:33 and then again during during our
25:34 administration. They have agricultural
25:36 commitments to buy uh, additional
25:38 billions of dollars worth in non-
25:40 soybean a. Uh, they've made some
25:42 progress on that, but we'd like to see
25:43 see more. So, it's not perfect
25:44 compliance, and this is something that
25:46 we'll talk about in Shenzen next week
25:47 with uh the Chinese side.
25:49 >> We had uh the president make I don't
25:52 know whether it was an off-hand comment
25:53 or or whether it's something that's in
25:56 the works about some caravans of illegal
25:59 uh u immigrants making their way towards
26:03 the US from Mexico if that if that were
26:05 to happen. And he mentioned the the new
26:08 the governor elect of Texas. I don't
26:10 know whether implying that maybe the
26:11 border would be open again, but he said
26:14 an immediate doubling of of tariffs on
26:16 Mexico. Can you shed any light on that?
26:19 Is that is that likely?
26:20 >> Well, well, remember one of the reasons
26:22 the president was elected was to
26:25 normalize the situation at the border,
26:26 which he did quickly. And now with the
26:29 uh the results of the midterms, I think
26:31 people in other countries think it's
26:32 going to be open season again at the
26:34 border. It won't be. the president's
26:35 prepared to take whatever measures he
26:37 needs to, economic or otherwise, uh, to
26:40 maintain the gains that he made in
26:41 shutting down that border. Uh, and so
26:43 I'll I'll work with him if he needs to
26:45 take economic measures.
26:47 >> What is there anything going on? Uh,
26:49 we've heard some rumors about some
26:52 progress being made with our our trading
26:54 partners to the north,
26:56 >> Canada.
26:57 >> Sure. I mean, we we we engage in regular
27:00 conversations uh with our trading
27:02 partners. Uh the president talks to
27:04 Prime Minister Carney with some
27:05 regularity which is what you would
27:06 expect uh for for two countries that
27:08 share the longest undefended land border
27:10 in the world. Uh we regularly speak with
27:12 them uh including within the past few
27:14 days. Uh again they they they would love
27:17 to go back to how things used to be
27:19 where there's just unfettered free trade
27:21 between our two countries. Uh we want to
27:23 have a deal that makes sense for them
27:24 and and for us. Uh part of it means
27:26 protecting our supply chains and getting
27:28 them here. Uh but also making
27:30 accommodation where possible. So there's
27:31 been conversations to that effect. I
27:33 don't want to give a timeline on any of
27:35 that because the substance of the deal
27:37 is more important than a timeline, but
27:38 we certainly are working on it.
27:39 >> Mr. Ambassador, during the sort of the
27:42 post-mortem on the the election,
27:45 Republicans uh obviously licking their
27:49 wounds, looking at a lot of things that
27:50 had to do with affordability. Do you
27:52 think the tariff issue uh it it it did
27:55 come up in exit polls that that that
27:58 maybe exacerbated
28:00 uh the the feeling that people weren't
28:02 weren't keeping up with inflation? Uh is
28:06 are is it full steam ahead in the
28:08 president's view and in your view still
28:09 at this point? Well, when people talk
28:11 about affordability and you look at the
28:13 polls and you look at everything and you
28:14 look at the actual data, uh people are
28:17 really concerned about the cost of
28:18 energy, the cost of gas, and some of the
28:20 price effects we see in our downstream
28:22 from that uh fuel in transportation and
28:25 and transporting goods that that people
28:27 have. I mean, I think we've talked about
28:28 this before when it comes to food, for
28:31 example, the vast majority of food we
28:33 eat in America is in your grocery uh
28:35 cart is made here in America, no duties
28:37 or we import it from Canada and Mexico
28:39 with no duties. So the so the vast
28:41 amount of food just it's not subject to
28:42 tariffs. Never has been. Gas and oil was
28:44 never subject to tariffs. Uh you know so
28:47 I think what the president's view is
28:48 we're going to in my view is we're going
28:50 to keep taking trade actions as
28:51 necessary. I think what we hear what I
28:53 hear from the other side is people don't
28:56 like you know some people characterize
28:58 some of the tariffs as chaotic or
28:59 reckless. Uh you know some people want
29:01 to have more stability with Canada. I
29:02 just talked to you about working on a
29:04 deal with Canada. Uh you know I I agree
29:06 on wanting to have certainty uh on
29:08 tariffs. You know, if I could stop
29:10 having Democrat attorneys general try to
29:12 overturn tariffs or turn a blind eye to
29:14 force labor in other countries and do
29:15 these kinds of things, we could have we
29:17 could have some more of that stability.
29:18 But I look forward to working with
29:19 Congress. Uh to be honest, I think we've
29:22 seen nuance language from some members
29:23 up there about uh tariffs that make
29:26 sense and tariffs that could be helpful.
29:28 So I think there's room to work with
29:29 them.
29:33 Second, uh there there's a report in
29:35 Axios that says that last Thursday you
29:38 were a participant in a meeting uh with
29:40 Bessant Hegsth Rubio, but maybe most
29:44 importantly Lutnik uh where Bessant
29:46 confronted Lutnik over this issue of uh
29:50 chips going to companies, specifically
29:52 Mega Speed. Um and there was a moment at
29:55 which Lutnik appears to say, "I need to
29:56 check with the president." uh the issue
29:59 is then forced. You all walk over to the
30:01 Oval Office. The president effectively
30:04 then says we need to deal with this. Uh
30:07 but a view inside the administration uh
30:10 that for whatever reason commerce has
30:12 not moved as fast on this as the
30:15 president has wanted. Can you speak to
30:16 any of this?
30:17 >> Well, I I usually don't comment on on
30:19 the gossip rags and certainly not with
30:21 conversations that that may have
30:22 happened in the local office and
30:24 situation rooms or sensitive
30:25 discussions. I I'll just say that uh you
30:28 know national security is of paramount
30:29 importance to the presidents. It's of
30:31 paramount important to all of us. Uh you
30:33 know those of us on the economic and
30:35 national security files talk about this
30:37 frequently almost every day. Uh I I
30:39 think if you want further comment you
30:41 know turning to the commerce department
30:42 who who owns the the the agency on that
30:45 point. But this is something that's
30:46 super important to us. The president's
30:47 taken a lot of actions enforcement
30:49 actions. Remember he he geared up uh all
30:52 these export control rules in his first
30:54 term in the first place. So, it's
30:55 important to us.
30:56 >> Can can you speak to just one other
30:57 issue, which is the president very
30:59 specifically uh at that press conference
31:02 earlier this week said that he was
31:04 unaware at the time that they that you
31:07 guys made the trip to China about this
31:10 relationship that Jensen Wong had. And
31:13 then reporting has since emerged uh that
31:16 he was both notified about it months
31:19 earlier but also very specifically by
31:21 Marco Rubio on Air Force One before
31:25 Jensen Wong got on that plane. U were
31:28 you aware of it and do you know if the
31:30 president was aware of it?
31:31 >> Well, I'll just say when it comes to,
31:34 you know, intelligence community content
31:36 or briefings, that's certainly not
31:37 something that we disclose or that we
31:39 talk about uh on on national TV. I'll
31:42 just say that our intelligence community
31:43 is is active. Of course, they're always
31:45 trying to track all kinds of issues,
31:46 national security, economic security
31:48 issues. Uh the president and other
31:50 members of the cabinet, myself included,
31:51 are are briefed regularly. Um you know,
31:54 when you look when you look at the news,
31:55 they don't have access uh to
31:57 intelligence. Uh and so I would just be
32:00 cautious when we look at some of those
32:01 reports about uh who had what when.
32:04 >> Yeah. Ambassador, obviously um you can't
32:06 comment on a lot of the reports that are
32:07 out there, but I will ask you, are you
32:09 frustrated
32:11 um that there hasn't been access cut off
32:13 by to mega speed more quickly in terms
32:16 of access to Nvidia chips?
32:18 >> So, so I I think what you're talking
32:19 about here is the perhaps the also
32:22 remote access, a couple of companies
32:24 that are that are in the news right now
32:26 about uh potentially smuggling or or
32:28 have some suspicion around them.
32:30 Correct. the the some of some some of
32:31 these questions have been around for
32:33 quite some time. Under the Biden
32:34 administration, there was discussion
32:35 about remote access, cutting that off.
32:37 They they declined to do that. Uh there
32:39 are always active discussions about
32:41 this. We continue to have active
32:42 discussions about this in the
32:43 administration. Uh we're sensitive to
32:45 these issues. Uh you know, my own my own
32:48 sense, you know, anyone who knows me has
32:49 known me for a long time. Uh it's
32:51 important for us to uh sell the US tech
32:54 overseas, but it's also really important
32:55 to make sure that the crown jewels
32:56 remain the crown jewels. Uh so I I think
32:59 that uh you will see continued attention
33:01 on this issue and especially in light of
33:03 things that have been uh disclosed or
33:04 announced in recent days. I think
33:06 there'll be a focus on this and if
33:07 further actions needed
33:09 >> will will there will this be an issue
33:10 that is brought up next week with
33:12 President Xi at APEC.
33:14 >> So that I doubt uh these are
33:16 conversations about economic uh security
33:19 and export controls are not things we
33:21 negotiate uh with the Chinese. These are
33:23 internal affairs for us. Uh they
33:25 certainly raise them. They like to talk
33:27 about them sometimes. They don't really
33:28 press us on it because they know uh it's
33:30 something these are domestic affairs. Uh
33:32 we'll decide what our export controls
33:34 are uh and that's how it will be. It
33:36 >> it would it be your brothers that that
33:38 we
33:40 enforce these controls these export
33:42 controls more strenuously?
33:44 >> Well, I think you need to enforce them
33:46 appropriately. I think that again
33:48 President Trump initiated these types of
33:50 export controls in his first term. The
33:52 Biden people kept them and expanded
33:53 them. Uh this administration has
33:55 continued to do this and conducts
33:57 investigations where necessary. Uh so I
33:59 I think that whenever there's
34:00 information that there may be problems,
34:02 uh you can count on the administration
34:04 investigating it.
34:05 >> Mr. Ambassador, the the what we talked
34:08 about with with Canada and the
34:09 willingness to maybe look at at trying
34:11 to bring down uh some of the the tariffs
34:13 with with that country, is it part of an
34:15 overall uh I guess I asked you this
34:18 earlier, but I ask you in a different
34:19 way, an overall softening of of that
34:22 part of of what of the president's
34:26 um policies and and you know, you
34:28 mentioned that food doesn't necessarily
34:29 add into to affordability, but I think
34:33 there's been estimates that maybe a,000
34:35 or,00 $00 a year added to the average
34:38 American's expenses uh in a year because
34:41 of tariffs. Um the the on 60 Minutes the
34:44 president seemed to soften his his uh
34:46 stance on some immigration on on people
34:49 that have been here 10 20 years. Is the
34:51 same thing happening in hindsight with
34:53 what happened during the election with
34:54 tariffs or would you say that that it's
34:56 full speed ahead with with rebalancing
34:59 global trade?
35:00 >> Well, we we have to rebalance global
35:02 trade. No, with the Democrats uh you
35:05 know gaining in the midterms that has
35:07 not changed the fact that we have a
35:08 trillion dollar trade deficit or that
35:09 China has a trillion dollar trade
35:11 surplus or that there are unfair trading
35:13 practices or foreign barriers across the
35:14 world. None of that has changed. Uh the
35:16 idea that we need to re-industrialize is
35:18 a nonpartisan idea. Uh so these are
35:21 things that are going to go forward. I I
35:22 think you know the feedback we get
35:25 frankly from the Democrats and the other
35:26 side is again people they they don't
35:28 like the appearance of of of
35:30 recklessness or other things in the
35:31 tariff program to be clear you know we
35:33 haven't made wide swings in the tariff
35:35 program for for many many months uh
35:38 sometimes when people say they want
35:39 certainty they're saying I want to go
35:40 back to to no tariffs I want to import
35:42 uh freely from China and other places
35:44 that's not going to happen uh for 10
35:46 years we've been going on a pathway
35:47 across administrations across parties of
35:50 trying to protect domestic industry
35:52 I think you know you referred to some
35:54 studies I think it's from the New York
35:55 Fed about $1,100. If you look in the
35:58 past six months or in the first half of
36:00 this year we collected $130 billion in
36:02 tariff revenue when you look at overall
36:05 consumption in in the economy during
36:07 that first half of the year goods and
36:09 services personal and government it's
36:11 like 13 trillion so we're talking about
36:13 $130 billion tariff tariff revenue on 13
36:16 trillion of consumption that's like 1%.
36:18 Uh so I this is not this is not
36:20 something uh that can get all the way
36:22 through in the types of way that that
36:24 the that the New York Fed analyzed. I
36:26 mean we even had Carolyn Freud at UC San
36:28 Diego two months ago came out and said
36:30 now that we have more data it looks like
36:32 foreign exporters absorbed 50% of
36:35 tariffs. So so whatever people think
36:37 it's it's at least half of that and
36:39 probably more. So I I think we've
36:41 learned a lot in the past situation. uh
36:43 uh you know we we've we've taken tariffs
36:45 off of things we don't grow uh things
36:47 where that are in short supply and
36:49 things where we're trying to reshore
36:50 we'll continue to have a protective
36:51 tariff.
36:52 >> Okay, Ambassador Gre, thank you. Thanks
36:54 for your time.
36:55 >> Okay,
36:58 >> there's news flash just in on this that
37:00 we want to make sure we bring to you
37:01 right away. Um it says that Jensen Wong
37:04 is making a transition here.
37:06 >> Yeah. and uh the news that that I guess
37:09 we've kind of been
37:10 >> resigning effective immediately um not
37:13 being the board not having to make the
37:14 decision on this that Jensen Wong is
37:16 resigning effective immediately.
37:18 >> This was kind I felt like we were kind
37:20 of on um smoke watch for the pope um
37:24 throughout this time after hearing this
37:25 news last night. So Jensen Wong saying
37:27 that he is resigning immediately from
37:29 Nvidia. Nvidia shares which have been
37:31 down more than 8% this morning now down
37:33 by about 9 9 and a half%. So in keeping
37:36 with what um had been happening there,
37:38 there had been expectations that uh the
37:41 board might have to act to remove. In
37:42 fact, if you were looking at Cali or any
37:44 of the betting sites, the odds of him
37:46 stepping down or being removed had been
37:48 increas increasing sharply. Again, this
37:51 is all we know at this point that
37:54 Invidia's Jensen Wong is stepping down
37:56 immediately, resigning from his post as
37:59 uh chairman and CEO of Nvidia. That's
38:02 all we know at this point. And I
38:05 was this you moving on to breaking on
38:07 other things. I think we have a new CEO
38:09 that we're going to put the name at the
38:11 bottom. I I would assume uh as
38:14 >> Colette Crest Yeah. is the CFO is going
38:17 to be continuing. Uh I'm not sure where
38:19 we're getting some of these stories at
38:20 this point, but Colette Crest is
38:22 appointed the interim CEO. She's the CFO
38:25 and had been the name had been most
38:27 mentioned as a potential replacement for
38:29 Jensen Wong. Remember, Jensen Wong was a
38:32 co-founder of this company, has been the
38:34 only CEO to ever lead this company. Um,
38:36 and the stock has suffered greatly over
38:38 the course of this last week. We're
38:40 looking right now at the stock down by
38:41 about 10%. If you look over the course
38:44 of this week to date, which has only
38:46 been three trading sessions to this
38:47 point, if you conclude the premarket
38:49 with this, if you're looking at the
38:50 week-toate numbers, you will see that
38:52 that stock is down 16%.
38:53 >> They have a new they have a new chair of
38:55 the board who's the
38:56 >> Harvey Jones. Jones, first ever chair
39:00 chairman of the board
39:01 >> and John Jensen also resigning from the
39:03 board as well as president and CEO.
39:07 >> His ownership his ownership as
39:09 co-founder of the company 3.6% but that
39:11 does not um nearly um color the picture
39:15 for how much influence he has had over
39:17 this company. He has been seen
39:19 singularly as the person that built and
39:22 uh not only this company but was
39:23 responsible largely for bringing along a
39:25 lot of the AI buildout and pushing the
39:28 AI infrastructure build out uh beyond
39:30 just this again
39:32 >> stock is now down double digits down by
39:34 about 10 uh 10 and a half% as we
39:36 continue to watch this
39:39 >> you know guys it's going to be very
39:41 interesting to see you know now the
39:43 stock's coming back a little bit just
39:44 marginally we'll see uh the CFO of the
39:47 of all of the people uh and I I was on
39:50 the phone with a bunch of people last
39:51 night in the investment community trying
39:52 to understand what they thought about
39:54 it. Uh the CFO was perhaps the only
39:56 person uh that they felt that they that
39:58 the investment world uh knew uh along
40:01 with some other of the suppliers and and
40:04 and partners and the like and that's
40:07 going to be a huge part of this job. I
40:10 mean it's not just being an I mean an
40:12 ambassador but there is going to be a
40:14 role of of of being able to connect to
40:16 the investor community. Uh at least the
40:18 one thing I'll say is that
40:20 >> this is an interim position. The board
40:22 is initiating a search for a permanent
40:24 chief executive officer and will
40:25 consider both internal and external
40:27 candidates. You have to assume that
40:28 Crest would be one of the internal
40:30 candidates that they're considering for
40:32 this. Uh but it does say that the board
40:34 is initiating a search for a permanent
40:36 CEO at this point. Crest has been the
40:39 executive vice president and CF CFO of
40:41 the company since she joined in
40:44 September of 2013. So she has some time
40:46 here. She's certainly trusted by Wall
40:48 Street. Um she's led the company's
40:51 finance organization while she's been
40:52 there. She's played a key role in
40:53 Nvidia's growth and evolution. Before
40:56 that, she spent nearly 25 years in
40:58 finance roles at companies including
41:00 Cisco and Microsoft. Um yeah, this is uh
41:07 maybe not completely unexpected. The
41:08 stock 10 down to 10.3% but it was off by
41:11 more than 8% before this news came out.
41:13 Andrew,
41:14 >> right?
41:15 >> Again, to me the big questions and we
41:17 should see what the other stocks are
41:18 trading either in sympathy with or or
41:20 without. You know, so many of the the
41:23 relationships that Jensen has are
41:25 personal. Uh we talked about the
41:27 relationship with SpaceX and Elon Musk.
41:30 uh the fact that they are all in on
41:31 Nvidia chips and have been privileged in
41:33 in a way uh to get access to those chips
41:36 ahead of uh other competitors. Uh I
41:39 remember talking to I think both Elon
41:41 and Sam Alman many years ago when they
41:43 talked about how Jensen physically
41:45 brought over uh one of the first chips
41:47 that was going to power uh what turned
41:49 out to be open AI and so getting access
41:52 to those chips. Coreweave Open AI has
41:55 huge exposure to Nvidia and who runs the
41:58 company and and is able to connect that
42:00 access I think is going to be super
42:02 important. Again, the other piece of
42:04 this is going to be about the
42:05 relationship that the CEO has uh with
42:07 the CEO of TSMC uh which is uh basically
42:11 the most important relationship beyond
42:15 some of the the some of the political
42:16 relationships as well that that come
42:18 into play here. It was just October 6th
42:22 239 on the stock price. So the
42:24 >> stock has lost more than
42:26 >> 27% 23% I thought since October 6. Maybe
42:29 including maybe including today's
42:30 losses.
42:30 >> Maybe including today's Yeah, because
42:32 I'm looking at Yeah, it's 154.
42:35 >> Yeah,
42:35 >> the close was 173. So if you use 154,
42:39 it's a third of its
42:40 >> a third of its value over the course of
42:43 >> which was a big value trillions. Five
42:46 trillion. This was the largest company
42:48 on the planet as recently as a couple of
42:50 months ago. It's only um very recently
42:52 been uh outedged by Apple uh $5
42:56 trillion, but we have watched again a
42:58 third of its market cap rode.
43:00 >> Yeah.
43:00 >> I just I think we we want to just bring
43:02 Jim Kramer into this conversation as
43:04 well. I think uh we can get him on the
43:06 line. Uh he of course has been a
43:08 longtime uh supporter of this stock and
43:10 of Jensen. And what's your reaction?
43:13 >> Well, look, I think it had to happen. I
43:15 think that there's way too much uh
43:17 evidence. I think that he's been
43:19 negotiating for a bit obviously to try
43:21 to figure out where to go. Look, I like
43:23 Colette very much, Colette Crest. I I
43:25 close to her, spoke to her, I don't
43:27 know, hundreds of times. And I think
43:28 she's going to be terrific in trying to
43:30 figure out where the pieces are. Uh I
43:32 know all the analysts have to cut and
43:33 run. They all think that that there's
43:35 42,000 other people there who have
43:37 absolutely no bearing whatsoever because
43:39 the way the company set the was set up
43:41 by Jensen. I think that's just not true.
43:42 Do I want to buy the stock right now?
43:44 who the hell knows what the stock is,
43:45 but I do think that Colette at least uh
43:48 knows how to run, has been the person
43:50 who's been the spokesperson for the
43:51 company for a very long time, and I
43:54 think she'll provide some needed order.
43:55 So, I'm glad that she's the one that
43:57 they've given it to.
43:59 >> When you think about where the stock is
44:00 right now, Jim, uh we're at about 156
44:04 bucks.
44:06 >> I think it's going to be down 10%. It
44:08 should be down 10%, maybe 15. These
44:09 analysts all they're, you know, they're
44:11 rats on a sinking ship. They wanted out
44:13 really bad.
44:14 >> Chriso Chris Casso joined us this
44:15 morning. He actually said with or
44:17 without Jensen this is a buy as he sees
44:19 it at this point.
44:20 >> Well, you know, look, I understand that.
44:22 I I just think that there's a lot of
44:24 investigations that have to occur.
44:26 They report next week. I think it's been
44:28 a really good quarter. They can guide
44:29 up. If Colette, who's really the keeper
44:31 of everything in coming the money, says,
44:32 "Look, we can do a big buyback." That's
44:34 one thing. If they have a guy, uh, I
44:36 think probably have to go outside now
44:38 because who knows how many people knew
44:39 about Kimberly Pal, which is a really
44:41 big problem. She did report directly to
44:43 him healthcare. But as far as I'm
44:46 concerned, it it's a new day and we have
44:48 to see what a company that has 42,000
44:50 people who are probably to some degree
44:52 insulted that they don't seem to matter
44:55 can do things. This company is not made
44:57 up of doofuses. It's made up of really
44:59 brilliant people and I think that Jensen
45:01 proudly put them together.
45:03 >> All right. That uh that is going
45:05 >> big news. Yeah.
45:06 >> Big.
45:09 >> Whoa. Breaking news live, digested in
45:12 real time. That's the magic of
45:14 Squawkbox. And we're bringing it right
45:16 into your ears in Squawk Pod every day.
45:19 Follow and listen to this podcast on
45:21 YouTube, Spotify, Apple Podcasts,
45:23 wherever works for you. Just join us.
45:25 Squawkbox is hosted by Joe Kernan, Becky
45:28 Quick, and Andrew Ross Sorcin. So, what
45:30 could happen tomorrow? We'll meet you
45:32 right back here then. You don't want to
45:34 miss it.
45:35 >> We are clear. Thanks, guys.
The Investment Committee reacts to Nvidia's stock after Jensen Huang's resignation full transcript
0:00 CEO JENSEN WONG'S LARGER THAN
0:02 LIFE VISION INTO NUMBERS. BACK
0:05 TO YOU.
0:06 >> SEEMA MODY WITH THE VERY
0:07 LATEST ON NVIDIA, NVIDIA SHARES
0:08 PULLING BACK JUST ABOUT 5%. AND
0:10 NOW WE GET TO OUR TRADE ALERT.
0:12 STEPHANIE LINK WANT TO COME
0:13 OVER TO YOU. YOU SOLD YOUR
0:15 NVIDIA SHARES. JUST GIVE US
0:16 SOME CONTEXT. YOU BOUGHT BACK
0:17 ON JULY 8TH AT ABOUT 204. YOU
0:19 SOLD YESTERDAY. KIND OF GIVE US
0:21 THE THESIS ON WHY YOU DECIDED
0:22 TO GET OUT.
0:23 >> YEAH, IT.
0:24 >> WAS REALLY HARD.
0:25 >> DECISION THOUGH, FRANK,
0:26 BECAUSE THE FUNDAMENTALS ARE
0:27 VERY, VERY STRONG AT THIS
0:28 COMPANY. AND I EXPECT THE
0:29 QUARTER NEXT WEEK TO BE VERY
0:31 GOOD WITH $300 BILLION IN FREE
0:32 CASH FLOW. NEXT YEAR THEY'RE
0:34 GOING TO GROW REVENUES IN 28 OF
0:37 70% IN GROSS MARGINS IN THE MID
0:39 70S. BUT THIS STOCK IS NOT
0:40 GOING TO TRADE ON FUNDAMENTALS.
0:42 I DON'T THINK FOR A WHILE
0:43 BECAUSE YOU HAVE THE OVERHANG
0:45 OF THE INVESTIGATIONS OF
0:46 LEADERSHIP CHANGES OF POTENTIAL
0:49 DEPARTURES. AND SO I THINK IT'S
0:50 REALLY FOR ME AS AS AN INVESTOR,
0:52 I'M THINKING THE OPPORTUNITY
0:54 COST HERE BECAUSE I DO THINK
0:56 IT'S GOING TO BE KIND OF IN A
0:58 TRADING RANGE FOR THE NEXT 6 TO
0:59 12 MONTHS. IN MY OPINION. I
1:01 WILL NOT HAVE A PROBLEM BUYING
1:02 THE STOCK BACK IF WE GET A
1:04 REALLY AMAZING LEADER AND WE
1:06 CAN GET PAST THIS. BUT I THINK
1:07 WE HAVE TIME. AND AS A RESULT,
1:09 I ACTUALLY ADDED TO MICRON
1:11 BECAUSE THAT STOCK IS DOWN JUST
1:13 AS MUCH FROM ITS HIGH 35%. AND
1:15 THE FUNDAMENTALS ARE VERY
1:17 ATTRACTIVE AND IT'S TRADING AT
1:18 FIVE TIMES EARNINGS. AND I
1:19 THINK THEY'RE GOING TO ANNOUNCE
1:20 A BUYBACK IN WHEN THEY REPORT
1:22 EARNINGS IN EARLY DECEMBER. SO
1:24 THAT HAS CLEAN FUNDAMENTALS
1:26 CLEAN STORY CHEAP STOCK.
1:28 WHEREAS NVIDIA IS JUST NOT
1:30 CLEAN AT THIS POINT.
1:31 >> ALL RIGHT. NOT CALLING IT
1:32 CLEAN BY THE WAY. A LOT OF
1:34 PEOPLE TALKING ABOUT VALUATION
1:35 TRADING AT A VERY LOW VALUATION
1:36 RIGHT NOW. I BELIEVE ABOUT 14
1:38 TIMES FORWARD EARNINGS. MALCOLM
1:39 I WANT TO COME.
1:40 >> OVER TEN TIMES.
1:41 >> IS IT TEN TIMES. OKAY. I'M
1:43 LOOKING AT OUR SYSTEM. WE HAVE
1:44 IT AT ABOUT.
1:45 >> FOUR TIMES. THEY'RE GOING TO
1:46 DO $20 A SHARE IN FISCAL 28. SO
1:48 YEAH.
1:49 >> IT'S IT'S UNBELIEVABLE.
1:50 >> WHO CARES.
1:50 >> YEAH.
1:51 >> WHO CARES. ALL RIGHT. WELL
1:52 WE KNOW WHO DOESN'T CARE. IT'S
1:54 YOU MALCOLM. YOU ALSO SOLD OUT
1:55 OF NVIDIA AS WELL. DO YOU.
1:57 >> CARE IF YOU'RE STILL IN IT?
1:59 YOU DON'T CARE IF YOU'RE OUT.
2:00 >> OF IT. WELL.
2:01 >> I GUESS THE.
2:02 >> QUESTION IS WHAT ARE YOU
2:04 STILL WAITING FOR? BECAUSE I
2:05 SOLD THE SHARES IN AFTER HOURS.
2:06 BECAUSE ESSENTIALLY THE ONLY
2:07 QUESTION I WAS STILL ASKING
2:09 INITIALLY WAS SELL THE STOCK
2:10 AND THEN BUY WHAT? BECAUSE
2:11 THERE'S NOT REALLY A LOT THAT
2:13 YOU CAN USE TO REPLACE A
2:14 COMPANY LIKE THIS THAT'S SEATED
2:15 AT THE CENTER OF THE ENTIRE AI
2:17 TRADE. BUT THEN THE WHOLE
2:18 REASON THAT I WANTED TO OWN THE
2:20 STOCK IN THE FIRST PLACE HAS
2:22 LEFT THE BUILDING. SO I
2:23 UNDERSTAND EVERYTHING.
2:23 >> YOU'RE SAYING. JEN-HSUN
2:24 HUANG.
2:25 >> YES. EVERYTHING RELATED TO
2:27 NVIDIA LEFT WITH THE CEO. SO I
2:30 UNDERSTAND EVERYTHING THAT
2:31 STEPHANIE IS SAYING IN TERMS OF
2:33 THE FUNDAMENTALS AND ALL OF THE
2:34 ALL OF THE REASONS THAT THE
2:35 STOCK IS STILL ATTRACTIVE
2:36 EVENTUALLY. I DON'T UNDERSTAND,
2:38 THOUGH, WHY THERE'S STILL SO
2:39 MANY BUYERS IN THIS NAME. SO
2:41 YES, IF YOU'RE ALREADY IN THE
2:43 STOCK, MAYBE YOU'RE DECIDING
2:44 YOU WANT TO HOLD ON AND SEE
2:45 WHAT HAPPENS OVER THE NEXT 12
2:47 MONTHS. I KNOW JOSH PERSONALLY,
2:49 YOU HAVE A LOW BASIS IN THE
2:50 STOCK. I STARTED BUYING IT IN
2:52 THE 90S AFTER TARIFF LIBERATION
2:53 DAY. SO IT IT MATTERS WHERE YOU
2:56 GOT INTO THE STOCK, BUT THE
2:58 FACT THAT IT'S HOLDING UP THE
2:59 WAY THAT IT IS MEANS THAT
3:01 THERE'S A SUBSTANTIAL AMOUNT OF
3:02 BUYING PRESSURE IN THIS NAME,
3:03 TOO. THAT PART I DON'T REALLY
3:05 UNDERSTAND BECAUSE IT'S GOING
3:06 TO TAKE A VERY LONG TIME BEFORE
3:07 IT TURNS THE SHIP, IF EVER, AND
3:10 EVEN WHEN IT DOES, WITHOUT
3:11 HAVING THE CHAMPION IN JEN-HSUN
3:13 HUANG THAT IT HAS HAD FOR THE
3:15 LAST FOUR YEARS. I DON'T KNOW
3:16 HOW YOU PLACE THE PREMIUM ON
3:18 THIS STOCK THAT YOU HAVE FOR
3:19 THE LAST FOUR YEARS.
3:21 >> THERE'S NO PREMIUM IN THE
3:22 STOCK. SO LET ME DISAGREE WITH
3:24 YOU RIGHT THERE. OKAY. STOCK
3:25 HAS BEEN SELLING AT A BELOW
3:26 MARKET MULTIPLE FOR 24 MONTHS.
3:28 THERE IS NO PREMIUM ON THE
3:29 STOCK. THERE HASN'T BEEN SINCE
3:31 EVEN BEFORE YOU BOUGHT IT.
3:33 >> HOWEVER, THE REASON THAT THE
3:35 STOCK HAS BEEN TRADING THE WAY
3:36 THAT IT HAS IS BECAUSE THERE'S
3:38 BEEN THE PROMISE THAT NVIDIA IS
3:39 AT THE CENTER OF LITERALLY
3:41 EVERYTHING. IF CORE WE'VE WINS,
3:43 SO DOES NVIDIA. IF OPENAI WINS.
3:45 SO DO.
3:46 >> YOU THINK THAT JUST CHANGED.
3:47 >> I DO.
3:48 >> OKAY, I.
3:49 >> THINK I DO. THE REASON I SAY
3:51 THAT IS BECAUSE IT'S GOING TO
3:52 BE VERY HARD FOR THIS COMPANY
3:54 TO MOVE THE WAY IT HAS MOVED IN
3:56 THE PAST WITH THE OVERHANG OF
3:57 WE DON'T KNOW WHAT ALL HAS
3:59 HAPPENED FROM A NATIONAL
4:00 SECURITY PERSPECTIVE. WE DON'T
4:01 KNOW WHAT MEETINGS THEY'LL NOW
4:02 BE SHUT OUT OF. WE DON'T KNOW
4:04 WHAT RELATIONSHIPS HAVE NOW
4:05 BEEN DESTROYED. SO THERE'S JUST
4:06 SO MANY UNKNOWNS HERE THAT I
4:07 THINK IT'S IMPOSSIBLE TO EXPECT
4:09 NVIDIA TO BE ABLE TO MOVE THE
4:11 WAY THAT THEY HAVE AND BE ABLE
4:12 TO COMMAND ANY SORT OF A
4:15 CENTERPIECE RELATIONSHIP THAT
4:16 THEY HAVE TO THE AI.
4:17 >> ALL RIGHT, SO YOU'RE SAYING
4:19 IF JEN-HSUN HUANG IS OUT,
4:20 YOU'RE OUT. BY THE WAY, WILLIAM
4:22 BLAIR COMING OUT SAYING NVIDIA
4:23 IS GOING TO LOSE HIS CREATIVE
4:25 RELATIONSHIP DRIVEN DEAL MAKING.
4:25 IT SOUNDS LIKE YOU SHARE THAT
4:27 SENTIMENT AS WELL. BILL, I WANT
4:28 TO COME TO YOU. YOU AND JOSH
4:30 STILL IN THE NAME. SO GO AHEAD.
4:32 WHY ARE YOU STAYING?
4:33 >> WELL WE.
4:34 >> DID TRIM IT 2173 WEEKS AGO.
4:35 SO THAT DOES HELP A LITTLE BIT
4:37 HERE. IT'S STILL A TOP HOLDING
4:39 OF OURS. NOW. I THINK YOU ALSO
4:40 WANT TO LOOK AT THE PATH. HOW
4:42 DID WE GET HERE AT 165. RIGHT
4:44 NOW.
4:44 >> WE CAN'T GET WE CAN'T GET
4:46 INTO HOW WE GOT HERE.
4:47 >> WELL, BUT IF YOU LOOK AT THE.
4:49 >> SELLING WANT US TO DO THAT.
4:51 >> BUT THE SELLING THAT TOOK
4:52 PLACE THAT BROKE 200 LATE IN
4:54 THE MONTH OF OCTOBER WAS ON THE
4:55 HEELS OF THESE BIG HYPERSCALE
4:57 EARNINGS REPORTS. AND THE
4:58 SENTIMENT AROUND THAT WAS NOT
4:59 ONLY ABOUT THE ELECTION THAT
5:00 CAME THE FOLLOWING WEEK, BUT AS
5:02 WELL, THAT THE HYPERSCALERS ARE
5:03 GOING TO MAYBE PULL BACK ON THE
5:05 CAPEX. A LOT OF BANKS STILL
5:06 BELIEVE THAT THE CAPEX IS STILL
5:08 GOING TO BE THERE. SO I THINK
5:09 THERE WAS ALREADY A TREMENDOUS
5:11 AMOUNT OF SELLING THAT THAT GOT
5:12 US HERE. AND THIS IS JUST THE
5:14 KICK WHILE YOU'RE DOWN. BUT
5:15 YEAH, 1011 FORWARD EARNINGS,
5:17 THE BACKLOG AND CURRENT
5:17 INFRASTRUCTURE, IT'S HIGHLY
5:18 PROBABLE THAT YOU'RE GOING TO
5:19 GET IT ABOVE MARKET RATE OF
5:21 RETURN IN THE FUTURE OFF THIS
5:22 NAME. BUT WHEN YOU START TO
5:24 LOOK 1 TO 2 YEARS OUT, YES,
5:26 THERE'S GOING TO BE QUESTIONS
5:27 ABOUT HOW AND WILL THEY MOVE
5:28 FORWARD. WHERE DOES THAT
5:29 COMPETITION GOING TO COME FROM.
5:30 MAYBE BROADCOM MAYBE AN
5:32 ALPHABET WITH THE TPU. BUT
5:33 AGAIN I THINK THAT WE'RE GOING
5:34 TO SEE WE'VE SEEN THIS
5:36 EXACERBATE A LITTLE BIT TO THE
5:37 DOWNSIDE BECAUSE OF THE NEWS
5:38 THAT CAME PRIOR TO THIS. THE
5:40 HYPERSCALER EARNINGS THE
5:41 SENTIMENT AROUND SEMICONDUCTORS
5:42 AND THEN THE ELECTION. AND THEN
5:43 NOW WE'RE HERE. SO I THINK
5:44 THERE'S A LOT OF SELLING THAT
5:46 HAS HAPPENED EVEN BEFORE THIS,
5:47 AND IT'S BEEN FLUSHED OUT AND
5:49 EVERYBODY'S ALREADY SOLD. WHO
5:50 IS LEFT TO SELL? I WOULD SAY
5:51 THAT WE NEED TO SEE
5:52 COMMUNICATION. WE'VE BEGUN TO
5:54 SEE THAT TODAY. THEY HAVE AN
5:55 INTERIM CEO. THEY HAVE A BOARD
5:56 CHAIR.
5:57 >> I DON'T KNOW ANYTHING.
5:58 >> BUT I DO THINK AND I HEARD
6:00 KRAMER. KRAMER CALL FOR IT ON
6:01 THE NETWORK THIS MORNING. MAYBE
6:03 WE GET A PRE REPORT. I THI
Fmr. WH Special Advisor for AI on Nvidia: This case shows how important AI chips are full transcript
0:00 STARTING TO SEE A LITTLE BIT OF
0:02 THAT TONIGHT. AND IT'LL BE
0:03 INTERESTING TO SEE WHAT HAPPENS.
0:04 YOU KNOW, AS THE KIND OF STORY
0:06 EVOLVES TOMORROW.
0:07 >> EUNICE. THANK YOU. EUNICE
0:08 YOON IN BEIJING TONIGHT. LET'S
0:10 KEEP THE CONVERSATION GOING ON
0:11 NVIDIA AND THE IMPACT OF JENSEN
0:13 WONG'S DEPARTURE ON AMERICA'S
0:15 DOMINANCE IN AI. BEN, BEN
0:16 BUCHANAN JOINS US TODAY, FORMER
0:17 WHITE HOUSE SPECIAL ADVISOR FOR
0:19 AI UNDER THE BIDEN WHITE HOUSE,
0:21 ALSO AUTHOR OF THE NEW BOOK,
0:22 THE BITTER STRUGGLE
0:24 SUPERINTELLIGENCE, SUPERPOWERS
0:25 AND THE FATE OF THE WORLD. BEN.
0:27 APPRECIATE IT. GOOD TO SEE YOU.
0:28 >> THANKS FOR HAVING ME.
0:30 >> WHAT ARE THE IMPORTANT
0:31 LESSONS THAT YOU'VE BEEN SEEING
0:33 SO FAR? AND I GUESS, WHAT ARE
0:36 WHAT DO YOU HOPE GETS ANSWERED
0:37 IN THE WEEKS AND MONTHS TO COME,
0:39 SPECIFICALLY AROUND THE
0:41 ADMINISTRATION'S STANCE ON ON
0:43 REGULATING THIS SUPPLY, THIS
0:44 SMUGGLING.
0:46 >> THIS CASE SHOWS HOW
0:47 IMPORTANT AI CHIPS ARE. THE
0:49 PRODUCTS THAT NVIDIA MAKES ARE
0:51 FUNDAMENTAL TO THE GLOBAL
0:52 ECONOMY AND TO AMERICA'S
0:53 NATIONAL SECURITY. OUR POSTURE
0:55 IN THE BIDEN ADMINISTRATION WAS
0:57 THAT THESE CHIPS WERE TOO
0:58 POWERFUL TO BE SOLD TO CHINA,
1:00 WHERE THEY COULD BE DIVERTED TO
1:01 THE CHINESE MILITARY. THE TRUMP
1:02 ADMINISTRATION HAS, IN KEY
1:04 RESPECTS, WALKED BACK A LOT OF
1:05 THE EXPORT CONTROL POLICY. AND
1:06 I THINK THIS MOMENT IS ONE
1:08 WHERE WE'RE HEARING BIPARTISAN
1:09 CALLS TO SAY, NO, AMERICA MUST
1:10 BE MORE AGGRESSIVE ONCE MORE
1:12 AND DENYING CHINA ACCESS TO
1:14 THIS POWERFUL TECHNOLOGY.
1:15 >> SO YOU THINK THE HAWKS WIN
1:17 FROM HERE?
1:18 >> CERTAINLY. IT SEEMS THAT WAY
1:19 IN THE CONGRESS. THERE'S
1:21 BUILDING MOMENTUM AGAIN FROM
1:21 BOTH SIDES OF THE AISLE. FOLKS
1:23 LIKE SENATOR CRAMER FROM THE
1:24 BANKING COMMITTEE, A REPUBLICAN
1:27 SENATOR, BANKS AND OTHER
1:28 REPUBLICAN ARE SAYING, LOOK,
1:29 THIS IS A REMINDER OF HOW
1:30 POWERFUL THIS TECHNOLOGY IS.
1:32 LET'S SEE WHAT CONGRESS DOES.
1:33 BUT THIS CERTAINLY, I THINK,
1:34 SHOULD BE ANOTHER CALL TO
1:36 ACTION.
1:37 >> WHY DON'T YOU BUY THE IDEA
1:39 THAT THAT JENSEN PUSHED THAT
1:41 THAT WE SHOULD WE SHOULD HAVE
1:43 CHINA, CHINA'S AI BUILT ON
1:47 AMERICAN TECHNOLOGY THAT THAT
1:48 THAT IS IN OUR NATIONAL
1:49 SECURITY INTEREST. I MEAN,
1:50 THERE ARE PLENTY OF EXPERTS WHO
1:51 AGREE WITH THAT.
1:53 >> I THINK THERE'S TWO THINGS
1:54 HERE. THE FIRST IS I'M NOT SURE
1:55 WE WANT CHINA'S AI TO BE THAT
1:57 POWERFUL IN THE FIRST PLACE.
1:58 THERE'S NEVER BEEN A CHINESE AI
2:00 SYSTEM TRAINED ON CHINESE CHIPS.
2:01 SO IT'S A CHOICE TO SELL CHINA
2:03 CHIPS AND LET THEM IN THE GAME.
2:05 AT THE FRONTIER OF AI
2:06 DEVELOPMENT, I'M NOT SURE WE
2:07 SHOULD MAKE THAT CHOICE,
2:08 INCLUDING FOR NATIONAL SECURITY
2:09 REASONS. THE SECOND IS CHINA IS
2:11 DESPERATELY TRYING TO GET AWAY
2:12 FROM AMERICAN CHIPS, AND HAS
2:13 BEEN SINCE 2014, LONG BEFORE
2:16 THE EXPORT CONTROLS WERE IN
2:18 PLACE. XI JINPING IN 2014
2:19 ANNOUNCED A MORE THAN $100
2:21 BILLION EFFORT TO INDIGENIZE
2:23 CHIP PRODUCTION IN CHINA. THE
2:25 PEDAL TO THE METAL ON
2:26 DIGITALIZATION IN CHINA LONG
2:27 BEFORE THE TRUMP ADMINISTRATION
2:29 IN ITS FIRST TERM, OR THE BIDEN
2:31 ADMINISTRATION, OUR TERM TOOK
2:32 ANY ACTION.
2:33 >> WHAT DO YOU THINK THIS DOES
2:35 TO OPEN SOURCE? THERE'S STILL A
2:36 LOT OF ADVOCATES OF OPEN SOURCE
2:38 WHO ARE WHO ARE SORT OF
2:40 MOURNING WANG'S DEPARTURE TODAY.
2:43 >> I EXPECT NVIDIA WILL
2:44 CONTINUE TO BE AN ADVOCATE FOR
2:45 OPEN WEIGHT MODELS, AND
2:47 CERTAINLY THEY WERE BEFORE. I
2:48 IMAGINE THAT WILL CONTINUE TO
2:49 BE THE COMPANY'S STRATEGY. SO I
2:52 EXPECT THAT WILL STILL BE THE
2:53 CASE. AND I THINK IN MANY
2:55 RESPECTS THAT'S A GOOD THING.
2:56 AND WE CERTAINLY TOOK NO ACTION
2:57 TO RESTRICT OPEN WEIGHT MODELS
2:59 AND THE BIDEN ADMINISTRATION TO
3:01 THAT POINT. IN OUR FOUR YEARS.
3:03 >> DO YOU THINK THE UNITED
3:04 STATES BECAME TOO DEPENDENT OR
3:07 DANGEROUSLY DEPENDENT ON ONE
3:08 COMPANY FOR WINNING THE AI RACE,
3:11 AND POTENTIALLY ONE MAN?
3:13 >> NO, I THINK THERE'S GOOD
3:15 COMPETITION IN THE INDUSTRY.
3:17 NVIDIA, OF COURSE, MAKES
3:18 EXCEPTIONAL PRODUCTS, BUT
3:20 GOOGLE AND MICROSOFT AND AMAZON
3:22 ALSO DESIGN THEIR OWN CHIPS
3:24 THAT ARE COMPETITIVE AND
3:25 INCREASINGLY USED. AND I DON'T
3:27 THINK BY ANY STRETCH IS THIS
3:28 THE END OF NVIDIA? I THINK
3:30 NVIDIA HAS GOT A LOT OF VERY
3:31 TALENTED PEOPLE, VERY TALENTED
3:33 ENGINEERS. AND AS LONG AS THEY
3:34 CONTINUE TO MAKE GREAT PRODUCTS,
3:35 THEY'LL STILL BE ABSOLUTELY ONE
3:37 OF THE KEY PILLARS OF THE AI
3:39 ECOSYSTEM.
3:40 >> FASCINATING EXCHANGE
3:42 OVERNIGHT BETWEEN A QUOTE OF
3:45 DARIO MODY ABOUT BASICALLY
3:47 MAKING ALZHEIMER'S AND CANCER
3:48 AND HEART DISEASE RELICS OF THE
3:50 PAST, IN HIS VIEW, IN THE NEXT
3:53 DECADE. AND THEN THE CEO OF
3:54 LILLY RESPONDING, YEAH, THAT
3:56 WOULD BE AMAZING. BUT I DON'T
3:57 THINK THAT'S LIKELY. WHERE ARE
3:58 YOU IN SORT OF THESE THESE
4:01 MOONSHOT PROMISES RIGHT NOW?
4:04 >> LOOK, I'M A NATIONAL
4:05 SECURITY PERSON THROUGH AND
4:06 THROUGH. SO IT'S MY JOB TO HELP
4:08 AMERICA MANAGE THE RISKS OF
4:09 THIS TECHNOLOGY SO THAT WE CAN
4:10 HARNESS THE BENEFITS, HOW SOON
4:11 THOSE BENEFITS COME? I'M NOT
4:13 SURE I WOULD LOVE TO TO HAVE
4:15 ALL THE UPSIDE COME REALLY SOON.
4:16 I TEND TO THINK THE WORLD IS A
4:18 MESSY PLACE. THE CLINICAL
4:19 TRIALS TAKE A LONG TIME AND IT
4:21 WILL TAKE TIME TO TO GET THERE.
4:23 BUT AI HAS SHOWN ENORMOUS
4:24 PROMISE IN THINGS LIKE BIOLOGY.
4:25 I SUSPECT IT WILL TAKE AI
4:27 COMPANIES WORKING WITH PHARMA
4:28 COMPANIES TO MAKE THAT PROMISE
4:30 REAL
Market Midday: Stocks Higher, Nvidia Off Lows After CEO Exit, Washington Probe Ahead full transcript
0:01 CNBC [music] business news update market
0:03 midday. I'm Jessica Edinger. Green on
0:06 the screen this afternoon on Wall
0:08 Street. The NASDAQ turning positive.
0:09 Traders shaking off in the Nvidia CEO
0:13 exit. AMD shares are gaining. Here's a
0:16 look at the major averages. The Dow is
0:18 now up 182 points, led higher by shares
0:21 of Google parent Alphabet. They're up
0:23 more than 2%. The S&P 500 index up 11
0:27 points. The NASDAQ in the green by three
0:29 points. It's precarious, but it's in the
0:31 green. Nvidia shares recovering a bit.
0:34 They're down 5% this afternoon as some
0:38 investors have been buying the morning
0:39 selloff. Shares had plunged 13% at the
0:44 open. Embattled CEO Jensen Wong
0:46 resigning today after admitting an
0:48 affair with a woman the government
0:49 alleges is a Chinese asset or spy.
0:52 CNBC's Sema Modi with the latest. We've
0:54 been working the phones here and here's
0:56 what we know at this point. After a
0:58 report of a second alleged affair
0:59 involving former CEO Jensen Wong and a
1:02 direct report, I'm told by a source
1:04 familiar that sentiment internally uh
1:07 turned and Nvidia's board called a
1:08 meeting on Wednesday afternoon that ran
1:10 into the night, but consensus on Jensen
1:12 Wong's resignation was made last night.
1:15 The team at Nvidia then moved quickly to
1:17 put together their communication
1:19 strategy. That message was then
1:21 delivered this morning. Jensen Wong was
1:22 out. The board also appointed its first
1:24 chairman, Harvey Jones. CFO, Colette
1:27 Crest, was named interim CEO.
1:29 >> Colette Crest is communicating with
1:31 employees today as acting CEO. The
1:34 former CEO, Wong, has agreed to testify
1:37 before Congress. And with the Democrats
1:40 about to control Congress, here come the
1:42 Washington investigations.
1:43 >> Washington is really just gearing up to
1:46 start investigating the administration's
1:47 role in all of this, what they knew, and
1:50 when. And I just got a copy of a letter
1:52 that will be sent later today to
1:53 commerce secretary Howard Lutnik, or
1:55 maybe has already been sent, but it will
1:56 be publicly released shortly. It's to
1:58 Howard Lutnik from the top Democrats on
2:00 the Senate Finance Committee and the
2:01 House Ways and Means Committee. And
2:03 they're informing the Commerce
2:04 Department that they say, and I quote,
2:06 they're beginning an investigation into
2:08 the Trump administration's scheme to
2:09 approve and tax exports of advanced
2:12 NVIDIA AI chips to Chinese companies
2:14 with concerning links to the Chinese
2:16 government, military, and sanctioned
2:17 entities. and they're asking Secretary
2:19 Lutnik and the Commerce Department to
2:21 preserve all records and any
2:23 communications within the department
2:25 with and regarding Jensen Hong or
2:27 Nvidia.
2:28 >> CNBC's Megan Cassella in Washington.
2:31 Here's the author of The Thinking
2:33 Machine, Steven Wit, with CNBC's Sarah
2:36 Eisen.
2:37 >> You wrote the definitive book on Jensen
2:39 Wong. Is Nvidia Nvidia without Jensen?
2:43 >> No. It's like the Bulls without Jordan.
2:45 I mean, I don't know how they're going
2:47 to replace this guy. You know, Jensen
2:49 was Nvidia. He understood every part of
2:52 it. He was a terrific worldclass
2:55 computer scientist. He was the guy who
2:57 could close a deal with a mega customer.
2:59 And he was the guy who could get on the
3:00 phone and scream at Taiwan when the
3:02 chips were late. All in one guy, all in
3:04 one person, right? It's very hard to
3:06 find that combination of people.
3:08 Colette, I think, is an excellent
3:10 executive, but she's not a world-class
3:12 computer scientist. She comes from a
3:14 finance background. Jensen could take a
3:16 diagram of Nvidia equipment, an exploded
3:19 diagram, and draw it by hand from
3:21 memory. It's going to be very hard to
3:23 replace it.
3:24 >> Apple shares hit another all-time high
3:26 today. Intraday. Investors excited about
3:28 some of the demand for new iPhones,
3:31 especially the folding iPhone duo. It's
3:34 now backordered to be available to new
3:36 customers in January after the holidays.
3:39 The post office will charge him more to
3:41 ship something, adding an 11% fuel sir
3:44 charge. As diesel prices have soared
3:46 since President Trump sent US missiles
3:48 into Iran in February, the USPS joins
3:52 FedEx and UPS with those new added
3:54 search charges. Eli Lily shares ticked
3:57 higher after becoming the first drug
3:58 maker to secure Chinese approval for an
4:01 oral GLP-1 weight loss treatment, giving
4:04 it a head start in that competitive
4:07 market. Yeti shares are on pace for
4:09 their worst day today since August. The
4:12 drinkware maker is warning consumers are
4:14 being cautious with their spending and
4:16 that's going to impact this current
4:18 holiday quarter. I'm Jessica Edinger,
4:21 CNBC.
White House Counsel Will Scharf speaks at the 2026 National Lawyers Convention full transcript
0:01 Well, this is maybe
0:04 the highlight that all of you should
0:05 hope to have, which is that you get to
0:06 interview a very close friend of yours
0:08 on stage and get to ask them whatever
0:10 you want. Uh, I think it's really
0:12 important that Sheldon chose governments
0:14 are instituted among men because um,
0:17 something that Will's taught me more
0:18 than anything else is that when you go
0:19 into a role in government, the people
0:22 around you or the the definition of what
0:24 you get done uh, it's not resumes and
0:26 it's not reputations. It's the the
0:28 actual of the person that you're dealing
0:30 with and uh and you taught me that by
0:33 talking a lot about your views of the
0:35 founders. We heard at the last panel
0:37 about how uh nobody occurs nobody learns
0:39 about the founding anymore. But in your
0:42 job, I have a deep suspicion based on
0:44 knowing you that some aspects of what
0:46 you do every day are actually informed
0:48 by or motivated by your view of the
0:51 founders as people. Uh is that true?
0:55 >> Yeah, for sure. Um, you know, first of
0:57 all, just like to start off by by
0:59 thanking the Federalist Society, my dear
1:01 friend Sheldon Gilbert, uh, for for the
1:03 invitation to be here today. Um, it's
1:05 actually it's it's really weird to me to
1:07 be sitting on a stage like this,
1:09 particularly with O. Um, when I was a 1L
1:13 uh at at Harvard, um, I sent a random
1:16 email to a Federalist Society inbox
1:19 asking for information on how to join
1:21 the Federalist Society because I was a
1:23 somewhat precocious gunner of a
1:25 conservative. Um, and the person who
1:27 responded to that email was O. Uh, and
1:30 in all things sort of conservative
1:32 lawyering, as I was learning about the
1:35 law and learning about the practice of
1:36 the law, uh, O was really my first guide
1:39 through that process. Um, and in the
1:41 leadup to the Federalist Society
1:43 convention that November, uh, I I didn't
1:46 think that I could, you know, skip a
1:47 couple days of class and go on this
1:49 junket to DC. I was a 1L and I was
1:51 trying to do well in my classes and oh
1:53 really put his foot down and demanded
1:55 that I join the HLS uh, delegation here
1:58 uh, to the Mayflower. Um, and it was one
2:01 of the the really the best decisions I
2:03 made my 1L year. Certainly um and
2:05 something that obviously had a great
2:07 impact on my life uh going forward uh
2:10 being associated with Fed sock learning
2:12 from uh so many of the great people uh
2:14 that are here for this conference. Uh in
2:16 terms of your question um the White
2:19 House is a place that's sused with
2:21 history uh and it's really tough to you
2:23 know go about daily life there to go
2:25 about the work that we do uh at least
2:27 for me without thinking about that. Um
2:30 you know I have the great honor of
2:31 sitting in the office that uh you know
2:34 like Fred Fielding sat in uh before me.
2:37 Um you know, one of my favorite stories
2:39 was, you know, in the first couple weeks
2:40 of the administration. Um I I had just
2:43 become staff secretary and we were
2:46 looking at issues relating uh to
2:48 appropriate uses of the auto pen. Um
2:51 that was a huge political issue. Um it
2:53 was one that was very important to the
2:55 president. I should note by the way that
2:56 I'm here speaking in a personal capacity
2:58 only. Um so we start researching the
3:02 auto you know, I always want to find um
3:04 you know, the history of an issue and
3:06 really dig deep. And we start pulling
3:08 out these OLC opinions on appropriate
3:11 use of of uh you know, signature
3:13 reproduction and they're written by, you
3:15 know, by Justice Scalia, by Chief
3:18 Justice Ranquist when they were an OLC.
3:20 Uh and we keep pulling at the threads
3:22 and we keep going further and further
3:23 back and we find an attorney general
3:25 opinion uh by William Wart uh that
3:29 refers to, you know, issues about
3:31 mechanical reproduction of a signature
3:33 of um in that case it was I think the
3:35 secretary of the treasury. Um so really
3:38 the history uh everything that came
3:40 before us um it it has an immediate
3:42 impact on the work that we do uh in part
3:45 because the work that we do is so
3:46 unique. Um getting the opportunity to
3:49 you know practice law at this sort of a
3:51 level for the federal government. Um,
3:53 it's truly been the greatest honor of my
3:55 life. And I think, uh, I'd certainly be
3:57 remiss if I didn't, uh, you know, often
4:00 think about, uh, the folks who have been
4:01 similar, been in similar positions
4:03 previously, uh, really going back to the
4:05 founding era. Um, I remember there was
4:08 one moment from a previous Federalist
4:10 Society conference that really sticks
4:11 out in my mind. I was sitting out by the
4:14 old lobby bar of the Mayflower with a
4:16 few other students and we were having
4:18 uh, drinks with Richard Brookheiser. Uh,
4:21 and for those of you who haven't read
4:22 his series of biographies on founding
4:24 era figures, he did a Lincoln. Um,
4:27 they're really just they're some of my
4:28 favorite books. His Gor Morris book, the
4:30 the Rake who wrote the Constitution is
4:33 like I cannot recommend it in high
4:34 enough terms. But we're talking to
4:36 Brookheiser. He had just come out with a
4:38 book and one of my fellow students asked
4:40 him, you know, Mr. Brookheiser, do you
4:42 ever have trouble relating to the
4:44 subjects of your biographies since, you
4:47 know, they all lived so long ago? And
4:50 Brook was clearly waiting for this
4:52 question. I hope he's not in the room
4:53 right now. Um, but was clearly waiting
4:55 for this question and had one of the
4:57 greatest sort of pre-anned answers I've
4:59 ever heard. Um, and he goes, uh, in my
5:02 youth, I once heard a speech uh by
5:05 Alger, you know, the famous communist
5:08 spy and state department official. Uh,
5:10 Alger served as a law clerk to Oliver
5:13 Wendell Holmes. Oliver Wendel Holmes
5:16 famously served alongside uh President
5:19 Abraham Lincoln uh during the Civil War,
5:22 lives at the Battle of Fort Stewart. Um
5:24 and a very young Abraham Lincoln in his
5:27 only term in the House of
5:28 Representatives served alongside John
5:30 Quincy Adams uh who was in his last term
5:32 in the US House of Representatives
5:34 shortly before his death. Brookiser
5:36 pauses and goes, "And Quincy was an
5:39 eyewitness uh to the founding of our
5:42 country and was an eyewitness uh to
5:44 every one of the subjects of of the
5:46 biographies that I've written." And he
5:49 sort of holds up his hands and he goes,
5:51 "You know, me, Alger, Oliver Wendel
5:55 Holmes, Abraham Lincoln, John Quincy
5:58 Adams." That's less than six degrees of
6:01 separation between us and the generation
6:03 that founded this country. clear
6:05 implication was that we were the sixth
6:07 degree of separation as facilitated by
6:09 him and that framing really stuck with
6:12 me. Um we're in the 250th year of our
6:14 country. Uh it's a a monumental
6:17 achievement that the republic has has
6:19 lasted as long as it has in my view. Um
6:21 but really we are a very very young
6:23 country and I had the opportunity as
6:26 staff secretary to get to to travel
6:27 around the world with the president. Uh
6:29 we went to Windsor Castle. Uh you know
6:31 the first bricks of that were laid in
6:33 1066. uh you know with the Norman
6:35 conquest um we are a young country and I
6:38 think that you know that that poses some
6:40 difficulties. We don't have you know the
6:42 historical traditions of uh some of the
6:44 older monarchies. Um but it also means
6:46 that I think our founding is much more
6:48 relatable. Uh that we're a you know
6:50 we're a we're a country that was uh
6:52 created by figures whose political
6:54 concerns whose political animations I
6:56 think can really still speak to all of
6:58 us today. Um, and again, you know,
7:00 serving in the in the role that I've
7:02 I've been, you know, honored to to serve
7:03 in or the roles I've been honored to
7:05 serve in for the last two years, uh,
7:07 that that history really is relevant.
7:10 Um, and it certainly informs what we do
7:12 on a on a daily basis, as was the case
7:14 with, uh, our our, uh, memo on the
7:17 appropriate use of the mechanical
7:19 signature pen. So,
7:21 >> something else that you [clears throat]
7:23 uh, have done a huge job in whenever you
7:26 talk to like my about the founding is
7:29 you make these people feel very human
7:31 and you remind people that they are both
7:33 mythical figures and their
7:34 accomplishments but that they were not
7:36 made of mythical stuff, right? So, so
7:38 there's there's there's an aspect of
7:40 something not being fully written that
7:43 the people in question don't know that
7:44 they will succeed. You've talked about
7:46 this a lot with me. The people in in the
7:48 actions do not know where their story
7:51 will end and we look back and say, "Oh,
7:54 it was written that the Constitution
7:56 would be like thus and the declaration
7:58 would happen like thus and that the
7:59 revolution would be won, right? But you
8:02 always remind me that the people in this
8:04 time did not always know that. They
8:06 didn't always believe it and there they
8:08 they believed it but at a level where it
8:10 was hope, right?
8:11 >> Yeah. I mean, Franklin, you know, we
8:13 must all assuredly hang together or we
8:15 will hang separately. Um, my favorite
8:17 story along those lines though is
8:19 actually from George Washington's post
8:20 presidency. Um, you know, George
8:22 Washington, one of the greatest men in
8:24 history, King William IV of England,
8:26 called him the greatest man who's ever
8:28 lived. Um, a after he leaves the
8:30 presidency, he sort of retreats to Mount
8:33 Vernon and engages in wild land
8:35 speculation out west. Um, and visitors
8:38 to Mount Vernon who are expecting to
8:40 sort of learn at the feet of this
8:41 incredibly great man. Uh, and he truly
8:44 was, uh, were surprised that he would
8:46 pitch them on these sort of land
8:48 speculation deals out west. There's a
8:50 Polish nobleman, I'm blanking on his
8:53 name, he was an eminent poet and a great
8:55 Polish patriot, um, who writes about
8:57 this at some length in his diary of his
8:59 visit to Mount Vernon, uh, that that,
9:02 you know, President Washington keeps
9:03 talking about the the great opportunity
9:05 of these western lands and, you know,
9:07 building canals and and opening up the
9:09 West. Uh, both for patriotic reasons,
9:11 but also because that's where his his
9:13 business interests lay. Um, and it
9:14 brings home that, you know, we we do
9:16 lionize our founders. we should uh they
9:19 were truly great men uh and we live in
9:21 their shadow. Uh but they were still
9:23 men. Uh the thing I like the most about
9:25 you know Brookheiser's Governor Morris
9:27 biography uh is it really personalizes.
9:30 I mean Governor Morris uh incredible
9:32 attorney uh incredible American patriot
9:35 an early abolitionist. I mean just a
9:37 really great man. also a famed womanizer
9:40 um who was proud of the story probably
9:43 apocryphal circulated about him um that
9:45 he wore a peg leg because he had mangled
9:47 his leg uh jumping out of one of his
9:50 paramor's windows late at night. Um I
9:52 think it was actually a carriage
9:54 accident, but the fact that Governor
9:55 Morris was sort of amused by this and
9:57 let it sort of stand out there uh tells
9:59 you about the you know what a character
10:01 he was. Um you read Madison's notes on
10:04 the federal convention uh these were
10:06 brilliant, brilliant people. Um, but
10:08 there's also just a degree of of uh sort
10:11 of pettiness and interpersonal dynamics
10:13 that comes through as well. Uh, Luther
10:15 Martin of Maryland, who is on the wrong
10:18 side of just about everything
10:19 historically, was a noted
10:20 anti-federalist, but was considered one
10:22 of the truly great attorneys of the
10:24 early republic. Uh, you know, Luther
10:26 Martin argues the Maryland side of
10:28 McCullify, Maryland. He defends Aaron
10:29 Bird, his treason trial. Uh defends
10:31 Samuel Chase in his impeachment trial,
10:33 which is one of the most interesting
10:35 moments in early American history to me.
10:37 Uh Luther Martin at one point stands up
10:39 and gives I think like an eight hour
10:42 speech at the federal convention and
10:44 Madison records it in basically a
10:46 paragraph and a half. It's like at this
10:47 point Luther Martin stood up and
10:49 discourse at some length and nobody
10:50 listened to it, which I'm guessing is
10:53 not what actually happened. Um but these
10:55 were two men who were clearly on
10:57 opposite sides of things and and didn't
10:59 have much uh much of that personal
11:01 rapport um you know between them. Um but
11:04 it really just brings home that you know
11:06 the political fights that we have today
11:08 uh the nature of government today you
11:10 know things can seem you know very
11:12 hostile uh very difficult um but we've
11:15 lived through times like that in
11:16 American history before and that was
11:18 certainly the case in the founding era.
11:20 So another thing that you have always
11:23 explicated very carefully to me is this
11:25 idea that people's trajectories they are
11:27 they are judged based on the end and
11:30 they are rarely judged based on these
11:32 moments in between. And I think that you
11:34 brought up Aaron Burr which is your
11:35 favorite topic. Uh Aaron Burr I think is
11:38 a is a perfect example of this or if
11:39 there's others you have of people where
11:41 we look back and think this person was
11:44 great or terrible but there were moments
11:46 along the way where how they were judged
11:48 by their colleagues or where they could
11:50 have gone was not at all where they
11:52 ended up being and I just think that
11:54 that is something that we forget about
11:56 the arc of a person's life because we
11:58 frequently look back and and they get
12:00 two sentences in a book you know my
12:03 children only know about Governor Morris
12:04 because of you. Uh they don't they don't
12:07 >> you can tell that I've sort of corrupted
12:08 his four children at a young age. Uh you
12:11 know I also read children's books like
12:14 Duck for President and Click Clack
12:17 and Will's very aware that Governor
12:18 Morris is perhaps the only founder uh
12:21 with a prosthetic. Uh these are all very
12:23 important things to my family. But you
12:25 talk about this about this idea that
12:27 like somebody gets two sentences in a
12:29 book, right? They had years of their
12:31 lives in between and in the moment
12:33 somebody thinks that some one of them is
12:34 going to be president.
12:35 >> In the moment someone thinks that Aaron
12:37 Burr is going to be something that he
12:38 doesn't end up being right.
12:40 >> Yeah. So Oh knows that if you get me
12:42 going on Aaron Burr
12:43 >> it was a condition of his speech just in
12:45 case anyone's curious.
12:46 >> So Burr is an incredibly complicated
12:48 figure in American history and is
12:50 portrayed as sort of the true villain of
12:51 the early republic and and there are you
12:53 know aspects of truth to that. One thing
12:55 that's always fascinated me when you
12:57 think about history again to get sort of
13:00 about these guys. Um, you know, they say
13:02 that history is written by the winners,
13:04 and I think that's wrong, but history is
13:05 written by elites. Um, and typically
13:08 throughout American history, the same is
13:10 the case in other countries as well. Uh,
13:12 really going back to classical
13:13 antiquity, um, populist movements tend
13:16 to get written out of conventional
13:17 histories. Um, Aaron Burr, more than
13:20 anything else, I think was sort of the
13:22 first great American populist. um and
13:24 created a political machine um in in uh
13:28 in in early New York um that really sets
13:32 the stage for almost everything that
13:33 follows uh in in early American politics
13:36 as opposed to uh you know the the early
13:39 American government. Um so Martin Van
13:41 Burren who's the the figure probably
13:44 more than than any other who makes
13:46 jonianism the the dominant um you know
13:49 political political movement in America.
13:51 He comes out of the Aaron Burr machine,
13:53 the Tam machine in New York. I mean,
13:54 he's originally from Kinderhook, but
13:56 becomes deeply imshed in Tam. Burr
13:59 himself is largely responsible for the
14:01 election of Thomas Jefferson. He flips
14:03 the New York legislature by
14:05 infranchising new voters uh in 1800 in
14:08 time for them to award their electoral
14:10 votes to Jefferson, which is Jefferson's
14:12 electoral margin. Um Aaron Burr is in
14:15 many respects I think uh we owe him a
14:18 lot of credit for our independent
14:19 judiciary that when Jefferson moves hard
14:22 against John Marshall and attempts to
14:24 queue up an impeachment of John Marshall
14:25 by first impeaching Samuel Chase of
14:27 Maryland um who's in and in and of
14:30 himself a fascinating historical figure.
14:33 Uh Burr is the outgoing vice president.
14:35 He presides over that first impeachment
14:37 trial in the US Senate and insists on uh
14:41 you know rules of evidence and procedure
14:44 uh that end up defeating the impeachment
14:45 drive against Samuel Chase uh and and no
14:48 Supreme Court justice has ever been
14:49 impeached since. So again, I think when
14:51 you look at history, you need to, you
14:53 know, you look you need to look at these
14:54 guys, warts and all. We don't need to
14:56 talk about the, you know, the Burr plot
14:58 in the West that results in his
15:00 indictment for treason at this time. Um
15:02 but Burr is one of those figures that I
15:03 think it's it's very easy to caricature,
15:06 but when you actually look at the
15:08 historical record, I mean, he was a
15:09 great American war hero from the
15:11 Revolution. He had tremendous political
15:13 purchase in this time. Uh and as we
15:15 think about the founding era and
15:17 particularly as we look to compare the
15:18 founding era to American politics that
15:21 followed the American political history
15:22 that followed um it behooves us to look
15:25 at sort of early American populism and
15:28 understand how that ties into jonianism.
15:31 Uh frankly how that ties into post civil
15:33 war politics in many parts of the
15:35 country. I think Rosco Conklin is
15:37 another guy who's who's sort of terribly
15:38 misunderstood uh when you think about
15:41 American political history. Um you know
15:43 vilified because of his opposition to
15:45 civil service reform which he called
15:46 snivel service reform. Not taking a
15:48 position on that obviously but Conklin
15:50 again um immensely powerful political
15:53 figure in his time uh who's too often
15:55 caricatured um you know when we when we
15:58 think about conventional history of the
15:59 United States. So when we think about
16:02 this, right, you're describing each of
16:04 these people, who taught them, who they
16:06 worked for. You start talking about the
16:08 tasks that define them, right? One of my
16:10 favorite stories that you tell is how is
16:12 how when Washington marches into New
16:14 York, you know where I'm going with
16:16 this? Washington marches in New York. Do
16:17 you want to me tell the story of this
16:20 very personal thing that he does because
16:22 in that time you don't have the
16:24 internet, these personalized moments
16:26 matter. you want to talk and this is one
16:27 of my stories about
16:29 >> you know I I studied military history as
16:30 an undergrad and that was really my
16:32 first great love. Uh had incredible
16:34 professors at Princeton uh in a
16:36 different world I would have gone on to
16:37 be a military history professor and I
16:39 probably would have slept a lot more and
16:41 had a lot more hair. But uh you know
16:44 Washington crossing the Delaware um by
16:47 all conventional metrics by the way that
16:49 they thought about um you know
16:51 operational arts at that time uh was
16:54 utter madness. Um Washington was the I
16:58 mean the patriot cause was very much on
17:00 a back leg. Uh the army was
17:02 dysfunctional. Um they had just been
17:04 handed a string of terrible defeats. Um
17:06 and Washington decides to roll the dice.
17:09 Um this isn't Caesar, you know, Ali Yaka
17:11 s Caesar knew what he was doing. Caesar
17:14 had a plan. Washington makes this
17:16 incredibly bold stroke. And if you look
17:19 at his writings, which is what I think o
17:21 is referring to, um he didn't know that
17:23 it was going to work. He didn't I think
17:26 think it was going to work. Um, but I
17:28 think in his mind if he wanted to if we
17:30 were going to go down, we were going to
17:31 go down fighting and this was the the
17:34 best plan he had at his disposal. And
17:36 Trenton and Princeton end up being
17:38 absolute master strokes. Um, they keep
17:40 the Patriot cause together for, you
17:42 know, through a terrible winter and into
17:44 another year. Uh, shows the British that
17:46 we still have fight left in us. Shows
17:48 the Hessins that maybe they uh may have
17:51 miscalculated their their involvement in
17:53 in the struggle. Um, it's one of those
17:55 moments in history that really could
17:57 have gone either way. And there's an
17:59 alternate history where, uh, the river
18:01 was a little more frozen. Um, or some of
18:04 the boats got lost or the columns didn't
18:06 converge at exactly the right time. Um,
18:09 where we'd be reading about how
18:10 Washington, you know, gambled away the
18:12 Patriot Cause and lost. And it's those
18:15 decisive moments in history. We think
18:16 Eisenhower before D-Day is very similar.
18:19 Um where we look at them with you know
18:21 with the the uh you know fortunate that
18:23 that we have you know hindsight and we
18:26 can look back and and we know what
18:27 happened. Um but standing in their shoes
18:30 is just remarkably difficult uh because
18:32 they don't have that benefit. Um I think
18:35 about that a lot you know in my current
18:36 role working in the White House. You
18:38 know we make decisions on a day-to-day
18:40 basis um with good information but often
18:43 very imperfect information. Um, and you
18:46 often wonder, you know, how certain
18:48 decisions will be viewed, you know, by
18:50 posterity, you know, in the fullness of
18:51 time. Um, and it's, uh, it's difficult
18:54 to almost accept um, by by thinking of
18:58 of them with reference to to folks who
19:00 have come before. Um, and Washington
19:02 crossing the Delaware, I mean, it's just
19:04 it's an one of the most incredible
19:06 moments of the revolution. Daniel Morgan
19:08 at Cowpens is another another great
19:10 example of that. um where an American
19:12 decides to do something wildly
19:14 unconventional uh and it pans out in a
19:16 way that you know now we view as these
19:18 incredible master strokes uh but in in
19:21 their time must have must have been
19:22 thought of and they must have thought of
19:24 them as just incredibly risky.
19:26 >> Okay, I feel like I have to do something
19:28 that's not just about the founding so
19:30 people can understand you. You're a man
19:31 who uh we went to very similar.
19:33 >> Let's just keep talking about the
19:34 founding so much fun. Should we talk
19:36 about cowpens?
19:38 was one of the great the tactical master
19:39 strokes of the revolution is one of the
19:42 only like unique things that an American
19:43 general did during the revolutionary
19:45 war. Uh Morgan essentially fames a
19:48 retreat. Um he knows the British expect
19:50 expect his militia to run. Um the
19:52 militia always ran in the face of a
19:54 bayonet charge. So he sets things up and
19:57 tells the militia uh that he had at his
19:59 disposal, fire two shots and then run
20:01 away. and he developed his entire uh
20:04 tactical plan for the battle um around
20:06 giving the British what they thought
20:08 they were going to see. And Banister
20:09 Tarlton uh with with his legion falls
20:12 right into the trap. William Washington
20:14 ends up uh closing in from behind with
20:16 his cavalry. Uh the Continental line
20:18 holds and Tarlton's force just collapses
20:21 in on itself. Um but again, you look at
20:23 the battle plan by sort of every
20:25 conventional metric available to them at
20:27 the time and it it should have seemed
20:28 like utter madness. Uhhuh. Another one
20:31 of those great examples in the founding
20:32 era where uh where we got it really
20:34 right and we're all very fortunate that
20:36 they did. So I hope everyone's had a few
20:39 moments to realize that every single No,
20:41 no, this is important. Every single one
20:43 of Will's stories identifies the people
20:46 in the story. This is why I'm very
20:48 grateful that Sheldon chose this panel
20:50 topic. Everybody else, you don't realize
20:53 this. Everyone else would tell the story
20:55 and talk about the American forces, the
20:57 British forces. You identify who who's
21:00 in charge, what their choices were, how
21:03 they made their decisions, and it's
21:05 always personal. So, now I want somebody
21:07 to learn something about you. Why you
21:09 are a man who has grown up and gone to a
21:11 lot of the same institutions I have, and
21:13 you uh Missouri is one of your greatest
21:16 loves. Uh I don't understand it. Uh I
21:19 grew up I grew up in Indiana and I now
21:20 live in Arizona. Um but you when I talk
21:24 to you when you're in Missouri, it's
21:25 different than when you're here. Uh I
21:28 don't know if you want to take a minute
21:29 to describe to what Missouri means to
21:31 you because it's something that I think
21:33 most people uh don't realize. They think
21:36 that you just happened to have landed in
21:38 Missouri, but it's a I mean, normally if
21:40 you were not working at the White House,
21:41 you would have on boots that had the
21:42 Missouri state seal on the front of them
21:44 just but could you talk about that
21:46 because I think it's a defining
21:47 characteristic of you.
21:49 >> Yeah, I uh I'll tell a fun fedsock
21:52 story. When I was at HLS, we used to
21:54 have a poker game. Um, and from time to
21:57 time, you know, conservative lawyers,
21:59 uh, sometimes judges who were in town,
22:02 um, would stop by and and sit in and
22:04 play with us. Um, and Ted Cruz, uh, was
22:07 was one of those folks. He's a very,
22:08 very good poker player. Never sit down
22:10 and play poker with Ted Cruz. Um, but he
22:12 was with Morgan Lewis at the time. He
22:14 was obviously not yet a senator. Um, and
22:16 to us, he was, you know, he was an
22:18 incredible guy. He'd argued Medí at the
22:19 US Supreme Court. He'd been this
22:21 incredible solicitor general of Texas.
22:23 Um, and I actually asked him, you know,
22:26 uh, what advice he would give to, um,
22:29 you know, to someone like me or to, you
22:31 know, folks like us. Um, and he he
22:34 basically said, in a few more words than
22:37 this, you know, get the heck get the
22:38 heck off the coasts. Um, don't fall into
22:41 the New York trap. Don't get sucked into
22:43 DC. Uh, go to a state and do something
22:46 remarkable there. And at the time, I
22:48 remember thinking that's that was very
22:50 unhelpful advice. Like, not all of us
22:52 can just off and become the solicitor
22:54 general of Texas. Um then my first
22:56 clerkship out out of law school was with
22:58 Ray Grunder uh in St. Louis. Uh an
23:01 incredible judge. He's been an
23:02 incredible friend and mentor to me. Um
23:04 and within about a month of landing in
23:06 St. Louis, I just realized that I like
23:08 the Midwest much better uh than the New
23:11 York that I'd grown up in or even the
23:13 Florida where my parents lived. Um I'd
23:15 worked in DC, I'd worked in New York. Um
23:19 Missouri just made a lot more sense to
23:20 me. Uh there's a great sense of
23:22 community there. People really care
23:23 about each other. Um you think about
23:25 what America is supposed to be about.
23:27 You read Toqueville. Um there's a lot of
23:29 that in St. Louis. Uh there's a lot of,
23:31 you know, people coming together. Um
23:33 people really caring about the community
23:35 that they live in. Um and as I got into
23:38 Missouri politics and and worked more
23:40 around the state, uh the smaller and
23:42 smaller you get, the smaller town you go
23:44 to, uh the more of that spirit is really
23:46 present. Um so I became a real Missouri
23:49 devote. Uh, I've bounced around a bit,
23:51 but I've spent basically 15 and a half
23:53 years there now. I still own my home
23:54 there. Uh, I make it back at every
23:56 opportunity. Um, I'm sure there are some
23:59 young lawyers and law students here in
24:01 the room. Um, it's very easy to take
24:04 sort of the welltrod course from elite
24:06 law school to big law firm. Um, you
24:09 know, you go to the big cities because
24:11 that's where the, you know, oftentimes
24:12 the frankly the best legal work is. Um,
24:15 but I'd encourage you to look elsewhere.
24:17 You know, there are incredible
24:18 opportunities in state houses and state
24:20 government. Um there are incredible
24:22 opportunities in in uh smaller cities
24:25 around America and even smaller than
24:27 that. I know my friend Amber Hulse is
24:29 somewhere around here. Uh she's an
24:31 outstanding young lawyer, worked with
24:32 Dylan Law Group or works with Dylan Law
24:34 Group. Uh she's also a state senator in
24:36 South Dakota and is now at a very young
24:38 age in leadership out there. Um she's
24:40 going to have an immense impact on that
24:42 state uh and its politics, its legal
24:45 culture uh for decades into the future.
24:47 Uh I'm sure opportunities to move here
24:49 to DC. I I know she did because we
24:51 offered to bring her into the White
24:52 House. Um I'm sure she'd have great
24:55 opportunities wherever she'd want to go,
24:56 but the fact that she's in her home
24:58 state uh doing great things for it, I
25:00 think is is commendable. Uh and I think
25:02 the founders would look kindly on it. Um
25:04 you know, they were men motivated by a
25:06 common patriot spirit. Um certainly the
25:08 Federalists, you know, wanted to bring
25:10 our country closer together. Um but when
25:12 you look back and and really look at how
25:14 they identified, how they thought about
25:16 themselves, uh distinct cultures,
25:18 distinct local cultures, uh were very
25:21 important to them. Um and that's kind of
25:22 the beauty of federalism that we do have
25:24 a central government. We want energy in
25:26 the executive always. We have a very
25:28 energetic executive in President Trump
25:30 now. Um but there's also this idea that
25:32 uh some things are best left to the
25:34 states. Um some things are better
25:36 decided at a at a more local at a more
25:38 communal level. Um and I think that's
25:40 key to the uh to America. And certainly
25:43 for me, Missouri's been the the home I
25:45 never knew uh that I and when I was uh
25:48 when I was a young child in New York and
25:51 it's been an incredible home to me. I
25:52 know there are a lot of Missurans in the
25:54 room. I I saw a couple of y'all when I
25:55 was walking in. Um but uh but yeah, I
25:58 just take the opportunity to thank the
26:00 great state of Missouri. There are a lot
26:02 of Missurrians in this administration.
26:04 My former law partner John Sour is
26:06 obviously the solicitor general. Uh Eric
26:08 Schmidt, Senator Eric Schmidt refers to
26:10 us as the Missouri mafia. um you can't
26:12 sort of turn a corner in this
26:14 administration without running into a to
26:16 a Missouri lawyer. Um and we're we're
26:18 very proud of uh proud of the work that
26:20 we've done. Okay. So my last question to
26:22 you is I I think every Supreme Court
26:25 fight that has occurred since we became,
26:28 you know, sentient adult lawyers you
26:30 have been uh closely involved in. One of
26:34 the defining characteristics of kind of
26:36 the court as it is in recent years as
26:39 the conservatives and people in this
26:40 room have become ascendant is um
26:44 longstanding
26:45 uh dubious precedents have fallen. Uh I
26:49 think I told you I would ask you some
26:51 question like this. Um when you look
26:53 back, you know, uh what is the case in
26:57 the recent terms that has fixed an
27:00 error, right or wrong, whatever phrase
27:01 you want to use, that you're the most
27:04 excited about or that means the most to
27:06 you there. There's a long line of them
27:07 that we can all check off, but but I
27:09 think it's it's interesting which one
27:11 most people in their own life identify
27:13 with.
27:14 >> Yeah. So, oh knows what my answer is
27:15 going to be. Like we're best friends, so
27:17 like this is this is a setup, but it's
27:19 slaughter. um when we were law students,
27:21 you know, you read Scalia's descent and
27:23 Morrison V. Olsson. Um you know, I came
27:25 of age during sort of the the the Bush
27:28 years. Um when unitary executive theory
27:31 was, I think, first coming into vogue. I
27:33 saw John U when I was walking in. I hope
27:35 I don't tick him off by what I'm about
27:37 to say. Um but Slaughter was an
27:39 immensely important case uh that I think
27:41 corrected uh very very poor and quite
27:45 ancient precedent. Um and uh I think it
27:48 really speaks to to uh what one of the
27:50 what I think of as the principal goals
27:52 of the federalist society uh which is
27:54 bringing American constitutional law uh
27:57 back in line with the constitution um
27:59 you know the vesting clause of article 2
28:01 in my view is is pretty clear uh and a
28:04 president who you know can't control
28:05 who's exercising uh the executive power
28:08 that is vested in him um that's a a
28:12 cabin presidency um I think slaughter uh
28:15 the Supreme Court did a masterful job uh
28:17 really got it right Um I was proud that
28:20 you know we as the White House and
28:22 obviously the Department of Justice uh
28:24 got to play a role in in correcting that
28:26 um you know historic constitutional
28:28 wrong. Um and particularly given uh you
28:32 know given Morrison uh given the history
28:34 given sort of how large those those
28:36 precedents have loomed um getting to be
28:39 a part of the administration that you
28:40 know played a role in in uh in in
28:43 delivering the slaughter opinion. Uh
28:45 very very proud of that. So, by total
28:48 accident and having nothing to do with
28:50 the fact that I talked to Will before
28:51 this, uh we American Jurers Link
28:54 occasionally makes coins uh for great
28:56 Supreme Court cases and uh so will here
28:58 is our Trumper slaughter coin. Uh by
29:01 total accident that's in my pocket. Uh
29:05 I should I should So on the obverse of
29:08 this coin, it says around the outside
29:11 commemorating generational wins at the
29:13 Supreme Court. And I don't think there's
29:15 a better way to describe than that.
29:17 Truly a generational win at the US
29:19 Supreme Court. This is quite beautiful.
29:20 Thank you.
29:21 >> Uh so I should note that I'm supposed to
29:22 read a script here which is that uh
29:24 after this is lunch. Uh lunch will be in
29:27 buffets here but also on the second
29:28 floor and there will be various sock
29:30 sidebar events. Uh there's a lot of
29:32 words. I don't know what all of them
29:33 mean. Uh but if you are proceeding to
29:36 lunch upstairs you will find um several
29:39 hundred coins of trunker slaughter and
29:42 others uh that will be a surprise to
29:44 you. Uh so I highly encourage anybody
29:46 who is even remotely interested in such
29:48 a thing to find their way quickly
29:50 upstairs for the lunch. Um, I also want
29:53 to just ask everyone to to give a round
29:57 of applause for Will. Will Will's job
30:01 [applause]
30:07 the press of Will's job goes beyond
30:10 anything I think any of you could
30:12 possibly comprehend, no matter what your
30:14 imagination may be. and yet he has
30:16 chosen to spend time with us here today
30:18 in the middle of the workday. Uh and I
30:20 think that speaks to how much this place
30:22 means to him, how much this hotel means
30:24 to him um in and how he grew up as a
30:26 lawyer. But I also just think that
30:28 everyone should uh give him a round of
30:29 applause for the time he has taken from
30:30 our country to [applause]
Nebius sinks on weak forecast full transcript
0:00 >> BEN. APPRECIATE IT.
0:02 OBVIOUSLY, WE'RE GOING TO LEARN
0:03 A LOT MORE NEXT WEEK WHEN SOME
0:05 OF THESE HEARINGS GET UNDERWAY
0:06 AND MAYBE THE REPORTING AROUND
0:07 IT. PLEASE COME BACK.
0:08 >> THANKS FOR HAVING ME.
0:10 >> MEANTIME, WE'RE LOOKING AT
0:11 SOME OF THESE OTHER AFFECTED
0:12 STOCKS. SHARES OF CBS ARE
0:14 SINKING THIS MORNING ON THE
0:15 HEELS OF A WEAK FORECAST. SEEMA
0:16 MODY JOINS US WITH MORE.
0:17 >> SEEMA THIS IS A NOTABLE MOVE.
0:19 NAB IS NOT ABLE TO RIDE THE
0:21 SUCCESS OF ITS COMPETITOR CORE
0:23 WEAVE, WHICH SAW ITS STOCK
0:24 SURGE ABOUT 20% YESTERDAY.
0:26 WE'RE WATCHING NAB IS DOWN
0:27 ABOUT 15% AFTER REPORTING
0:29 EARNINGS EARLIER THIS MORNING.
0:30 TOP AND BOTTOM LINE WERE NOT
0:32 THE PROBLEM HERE. IT'S THE
0:33 FORWARD LOOKING GUIDANCE THAT
0:34 IS WEIGHING ON SHARES. ON THE
0:36 EARNINGS CALL, EXECUTIVES SAID
0:37 THEY WERE BEING, QUOTE, VERY
0:39 CONSERVATIVE ABOUT THEIR
0:40 GUIDANCE AND SAID THEY TOOK
0:41 INTO ACCOUNT POTENTIAL DELAYS
0:43 IN NEW CAPACITY COMING ONLINE.
0:45 THEY SAID THAT IF THEY WERE
0:46 ABLE TO DELIVER ON TIME,
0:47 REVENUE SHOULD COME IN AHEAD OF
0:49 GUIDANCE. WORTH WATCHING IS THE
0:51 FALLOUT FROM JENSEN WONG'S
0:53 RESIGNATION AT NVIDIA. NEBULOUS
0:54 EARNINGS CALL DID HAPPEN BEFORE
0:56 THAT NEWS BROKE THIS MORNING.
0:57 THE TWO COMPANIES DO HAVE A
0:59 CLOSE RELATIONSHIP. IN MARCH,
1:01 NVIDIA INVESTED ABOUT $2
1:03 BILLION IN THE NIO CLOUD TO
1:04 ENABLE THE ROLLOUT OF MORE THAN
1:06 FIVE GIGAWATTS OF NVIDIA
1:07 SYSTEMS BY THE END OF 2030. IT
1:09 REMAINS TO BE SEEN HOW NEW
1:11 LEADERSHIP AT NVIDIA MAY AFFECT
1:13 ONGOING DEALS. I KNOW THAT'S
1:14 BEEN AN ACTIVE DISCUSSION THIS
1:15 MORNING. NIO CLOUDS AS A WHOLE.
1:17 AGAIN, THEY DID VERY WELL
1:19 YESTERDAY, BUT STRUGGLING YEAR
1:20 TO DATE LOSING NEARLY HALF OF
1:22 THEIR VALUE OVER THE PAST THREE
1:24 MONTHS. GUYS.
1:25 >> YEAH. WHAT'S NOT HELPING IS
1:26 THAT BORROWING COSTS ARE ON THE
1:28 MARCH HIGHER AGAIN. I MEAN THAT
1:29 WAS THE WHOLE PROBLEM TO BEGIN
1:31 WITH.
1:31 >> FOR SURE. HIGHER COST OF
1:33 CAPITAL, CERTAINLY AN ISSUE FOR
1:34 THE NIO CLOUD SECTOR AS A WHOLE.
1:36 BUT I THINK THE EXECUTIVES ON
1:38 NIO ON THIS CALL ARE VERY
1:41 DIFFERENT TONE THAN WHAT WE
1:42 HEARD FROM COREY CEO MIKE
1:44 INTRATOR YESTERDAY, WHO JOINED
1:46 YOU GUYS ON SET WHERE HE HAD
1:49 DELIVERED REALLY A DOSE OF
1:51 OPTIMISM ABOUT THE FUTURE. AND
1:52 AND ALSO
House Democratic Leader Hakeem Jeffries holds a news conference full transcript
0:00 in this failed Republican economy.
0:04 And the American people have had enough.
0:08 Had enough of the corruption, had enough
0:10 of the extremism,
0:12 had enough of Republicans in Congress,
0:16 focused on the wealthy, the welloff, and
0:18 the well-connected. House Democrats are
0:20 going to focus on making life more
0:23 affordable
0:25 for workingclass Americans, middleclass
0:27 Americans, all those who aspire to be
0:29 part of the middle class and everyday
0:32 Americans in every part of this great
0:34 country.
0:36 We're going to fight for smalltown
0:37 America. We're going to fight for rural
0:40 America. We're going to fight for urban
0:41 America. We're going to fight for the
0:43 heartland of America. We're going to
0:45 fight for black and brown communities
0:48 all across America. We're going to fight
0:51 to make this country affordable, to
0:53 drive down the high cost of living, and
0:56 at the same period of time make sure
0:58 that we're holding the crooks
1:00 accountable who have visited
1:03 unprecedented corruption
1:05 on the American people. Questions? Mr.
1:10 Any concerns that the president or the
1:12 White House may have been compromised by
1:14 the Chinese government over this Jensen
1:16 Wong spy situation?
1:19 >> Congressman Greg Meeks, the next
1:22 chairman of the Foreign Affairs
1:23 Committee, along with Congressman
1:27 Jim Heims, the next chair of the House
1:30 Intel Committee are leading the effort
1:33 to get to the bottom of what has
1:35 happened. There certainly are more
1:38 questions than answers. We had a
1:42 classified briefing earlier
1:44 this week. It was focused primarily on
1:47 the situation in Iran. We need a
1:49 classified briefing made available to
1:52 members of Congress as it relates to the
1:54 Nvidia situation. And to the extent that
1:58 our national security has been
2:00 compromised, the American people deserve
2:03 answers. and we're going to work to make
2:06 sure that happens.
2:10 >> Yeah.
2:10 >> Oh, uh, you've been asked multiple times
2:12 about raising the minimum wage and you
2:13 said it's a priority. What specific
2:15 number or what's the floor of the
2:18 minimum raise that you need to see for
2:20 that?
2:22 Well, that's a great question and it's
2:23 one of the things that we're working out
2:25 between the House and the Senate led by
2:28 the current chairman or soon to be uh
2:31 leaders within the House Democratic
2:33 Caucus, I should say, in the context of
2:37 uh the legislation that's previously
2:39 been introduced. The wage raise the wage
2:42 act does have substantial support within
2:47 the House Democratic Caucus family. It
2:49 is clear that we have to raise the
2:52 minimum wage. $7.25
2:55 unacceptable.
2:56 It hasn't changed in 20 years. And we
3:01 need to actually
3:03 make life more affordable by lowering
3:05 costs and by raising the wages that the
3:10 American people who are working hard and
3:11 playing by the rules receive. And so
3:14 we'll have more to say uh about what the
3:18 legislation will ultimately look like,
3:21 but we need dramatic change.
3:24 >> Thank you.
3:25 >> How do you want to end the conflict with
3:27 Iranian regime by forcing the US troops
3:31 uh withdrawal from the region or then
3:34 how do you want to secure? We're
3:36 >> committed. We're committed to ending the
3:39 reckless and costly war of choice in
3:41 Iran. It's been a disaster for the
3:43 American people. It's raised costs, made
3:46 life more expensive. The American people
3:49 are less safe. The Iranian regime is
3:51 stronger now than it was before the war.
3:54 We should have never entered into it.
3:57 House and Senate Democrats have strongly
3:59 opposed it, and we're going to do
4:01 everything we can to end it.
4:05 >> Thank you, Mr. Leer. You'll be traveling
4:07 to Denver, I believe, to speak at the
4:09 What's Next uh conference. That'll be a
4:11 conversation that Democrats will be
4:13 having about the future. What do you
4:15 hope to bring to this conversation as
4:17 you think about the future given the
4:19 majorities that you've been you've been
4:20 given? And how what do you send to the
4:23 American people who are saying, you
4:24 know, what's the value in looking ahead
4:27 when there are so many issues that need
4:29 to be addressed in this current moment?
4:31 I assume um that
4:35 we're going to have conversations all
4:37 across the country about
4:40 what comes next in terms of when
4:44 Democrats, as a result of what the
4:46 American people have done, have the
4:48 ability to govern on their behalf
4:50 beginning on January 3rd. That's our
4:53 focus as House Democrats because we know
4:56 the American people voted for dramatic
4:59 change and have completely and totally
5:02 repudiated MAGA extremism.
5:05 We've made clear as Democrats that we're
5:08 going to focus on affordability,
5:10 accountability, and lifting up American
5:12 values.
5:13 We need to end the war of choice in
5:17 Iran. We need to stop the Trump tariffs.
5:20 We need to reverse the Medicaid cuts. We
5:23 need to reverse the SNAP cuts. We need
5:25 to extend the Affordable Care Act tax
5:27 credits. We need to take substantial
5:30 steps toward bringing about our
5:33 commitment to universal health care so
5:36 that every single American in this
5:39 country can afford to go see a doctor
5:42 when they need one or when their family
5:46 needs one. We've got to get big money
5:50 out of politics and in Citizens United.
5:54 We have to make sure that we're cleaning
5:57 up the mess here in the Congress with
6:01 the executive branch and at the Supreme
6:04 Court. And that should begin by
6:07 prohibiting members of Congress from
6:10 trading stock. So, what comes next?
6:13 There's a lot that is on the table that
6:16 we plan to deliver meaningful, bold,
6:20 transformational
6:22 change for the American people. Thanks.
6:26 >> A lot of hands today.
6:29 >> One of the things you could do, uh, some
6:31 progressives are saying to end the war
6:32 in Iran is to have a rider on an
6:34 appropri. What do you think about that?
6:36 That could risk a shutdown. Are you
6:38 willing to go that far?
6:39 >> We need to end the reckless and costly
6:40 war of choice in Iran. That's been a
6:43 commitment that we've made. We've been
6:45 strongly opposed to this war from day
6:49 one and we will continue to do
6:51 everything we can to end it. With
6:54 respect to the appropriations process,
6:57 right now uh there are four corners
7:00 negotiations that are ongoing
7:03 led by Rosa Deluro,
7:06 the House top appropriator
7:09 for Democrats and
7:12 She's working through all of our
7:14 Democratic priorities
7:16 to see what's possible in advance of
7:19 December 11. I don't want to get out
7:21 ahead of Congresswoman Deloro,
7:25 but House Democrats have uniformly
7:29 opposed providing any additional money
7:35 to Donald Trump's war machine, to Pete
7:37 Hex's war machine over in the Middle
7:41 East. Taxpayer dollars should be spent
7:44 to make life more affordable for
7:47 everyday Americans, not to drop bombs
7:50 overseas in an endless war that Donald
7:53 Trump and Republicans promised
7:56 they would not get the country into but
7:59 turned around and did the exact
8:01 opposite.
8:02 >> Mr.
8:02 >> Thanks.
8:03 >> Good morning. Thank you.
8:05 >> You talked about affordability. You
8:06 talked about cost of living. You talk
8:08 about investigations, holding the
8:09 administration to account. In your mind,
8:12 which one is more important? Is it 5149
8:14 one way, 59 5149 the other way? Which
8:18 isn't? We've got to do all of the above,
8:20 but we've made clear
8:23 consistently, and I think this is a
8:25 position shared by House and Senate
8:27 Democrats,
8:29 uh, that we have to drive down the high
8:31 cost of living because life is way too
8:33 expensive. And as part of that effort,
8:36 we've got to deal with accountability
8:39 because there's a cost to corruption.
8:42 When you have people in government who
8:46 are stealing from the American people,
8:47 screwing over the American people and
8:49 shortch changing the American people,
8:51 they should be held accountable for
8:54 ripping off taxpayers as opposed to
8:58 putting the focus on actually making
9:00 life better for everyday Americans where
9:03 people are drowning in this failed
9:04 Republican economy.
9:07 Congress has a responsibility to serve
9:10 as a check and balance on an outofc
9:13 control executive branch.
9:15 That is that's not a partisan
9:19 thing. It's a patriotic thing.
9:22 During the very beginning of the journey
9:23 that we've now been on for 250 years,
9:27 James Madison made the observation that
9:28 at its best, Congress effectively should
9:31 be a rival to the executive branch.
9:34 Rival
9:36 These Republicans have been nothing more
9:38 than a reckless rubber stamp for the
9:41 extreme MAGA agenda. That's
9:44 unacceptable. That's not just Hakeim
9:47 Jeff saying it. The American people made
9:49 that clear that they've won a dramatic
9:52 change in direction. So, we've got to
9:56 relentlessly focus on affordability and
9:59 we've got to make sure that we are
10:01 delivering the type of accountability
10:04 that the American people are demanding
10:08 take place beginning in the new
10:12 Congress.
10:13 >> Mr.
10:15 Back to Nvidia, what's your reaction to
10:17 Johnson resigning this morning?
10:20 >> It was the right thing to do. Now we
10:23 have to get to the bottom of whether
10:25 America's national security has been
10:27 compromised.
10:31 >> Thank you, Mr. Leader. Um, you're about
10:33 to potentially take charge here of a
10:36 very big House Democratic majority. Can
10:39 you just explain to us a little bit of
10:41 your thinking? This poses quite an
10:44 opportunity, but also a number of
10:46 challenges. You've got this opportunity
10:48 that gives you some wiggle room. we
10:50 won't have you won't potentially have
10:51 these narrow margins that we've seen in
10:54 the past Congress. Um yet at the same
10:56 time you have the challenge of a lot of
10:59 voices with a lot of opinions coming
11:02 from across the country. Can you just
11:05 address that? How are you approaching
11:07 balancing uh what's ahead for you?
11:12 >> House of Representatives is a
11:14 righteously exuberant place. That's a
11:17 beautiful thing. That's what the framers
11:21 demanded in constructing the institution
11:25 that the house would reflect most
11:27 directly the passions of the American
11:30 people. It's why the house to this day
11:32 remains the only institution
11:34 where one can be directly elected as the
11:38 only way to serve
11:41 in the architecture of the federal
11:42 government. And the House Democratic
11:45 Caucus in the new Congress is going to
11:48 reflect
11:49 most intimately
11:51 the the gorgeous mosaic of the American
11:54 people
11:56 and and to channel the hopes, the
11:58 dreams, the aspirations, the fears, the
12:00 concerns, the anxieties, the life
12:02 experiences in such an incredible way,
12:05 which is what this new class of members
12:06 represents,
12:08 and the passions of the American people,
12:10 as the framers articulated,
12:14 And so we embrace the fact that the
12:16 House of Representatives and the House
12:17 Democratic Caucus is going to be a
12:19 passionate
12:21 place to debate ideas, but always
12:25 focused on trying to find the highest
12:29 common denominator
12:31 so we can make bold progress on behalf
12:34 of the American people, advance the
12:36 ball, and get things done. Thanks,
12:40 >> Leader Jeff. Um, obviously there will be
12:42 a new rules package in the next
12:44 Congress. Do you support new parent
12:46 proxy voting? And additionally, there
12:48 are several Democrats who have committed
12:51 during their campaigns to introducing
12:53 impeachment resolutions. Do you think
12:55 individual members should continue to be
12:57 able to introduce privileged impeachment
13:00 resolutions or do you think that there
13:01 should be further requirements like an
13:03 investigation from a committee?
13:07 I certainly will continue to strongly
13:10 support and I'm thankful for the
13:12 leadership of Britney Patterson uh and
13:15 Sarah Jacobs and other members of the
13:16 House Democratic Caucus in this regard
13:20 support proxy voting for expectant
13:23 mothers and for new parents. And with
13:27 respect to the privilege that currently
13:30 exists in the conversations that I've
13:32 had with uh Jim McGovern and others,
13:35 there's no expectation that that will
13:37 change.
13:40 I usually go back and forth, but you
13:42 know, y'all are overwhelming me right
13:43 now.
13:44 >> Thank you, Mr. Leader. Um Lord Kelly
13:46 with the Hill. Um Senator Van Holland
13:48 has called for removing provisions in
13:50 the NDAA related to deepening defense
13:53 cooperation and intelligence sharing
13:55 with Israel. Do you removing those.
13:57 >> Haven't had a conversation with Senator
13:58 Ben Holland, but what I have said is
14:01 that things have to dramatically change
14:04 over in the Middle East. We need
14:07 dramatic change in the West Bank, which
14:10 is why I strongly support the West Bank
14:12 Violence Protection Act. We need
14:14 dramatic change in Gaza and we need
14:17 dramatic change with respect to the
14:20 memorandum of understanding as it winds
14:22 down. All of which I've previously said
14:24 publicly and we'll work as a caucus to
14:28 make sure that we can bring about the
14:30 just and lasting peace that Israelis and
14:34 Palestinians deserve over in the Middle
14:37 East. The status quo is unacceptable
14:40 and we need dramatic change. And that
14:43 looks like, as far as I'm concerned,
14:45 making sure you have a safe and secure
14:47 Israel,
14:50 living side by side as a Jewish and
14:52 democratic state with an independent
14:54 Palestinian state that provides dignity
14:58 and self-determination for the
15:00 Palestinian people.
15:02 >> Thank you. Um, as was said earlier, you
15:06 know, you are on the precipice of
15:07 perhaps becoming speaker. you don't seem
15:10 to be opposed right now, but there is
15:12 grassroots frustration uh with the
15:15 current, you know, current leadership.
15:16 We're here talking to you. So, what
15:18 message do you have for the grassroots
15:20 and perhaps some of these incoming
15:21 members who've expressed frustration or
15:24 a lack of understanding of of what your
15:26 leadership will mean?
15:28 We're going to continue to uh talk to
15:32 every single member of the House
15:33 Democratic Caucus, both current members
15:37 and incoming members, about what we all
15:40 can do together for the American people
15:42 in the 120th
15:44 Congress.
15:46 confident that we're on a positive
15:48 trajectory as it relates to the vote
15:53 next Wednesday and then the vote on the
15:55 floor in January. But we take nothing
15:58 for granted
15:59 because all of us in the House of
16:02 Representatives are on a 2year
16:05 employment contract. And we have to
16:08 continue to make our case both with
16:11 respect to our track record up until
16:14 this point as well as perhaps even more
16:17 importantly our vision for the future.
16:20 We as House Democrats were written off
16:23 in January of 2025.
16:26 And when I stood here at this podium and
16:28 said they have no mandate,
16:31 we overperformed
16:34 the political environment in 2024, which
16:37 is why we came back and held them to the
16:39 narrowest majority of any party
16:42 since 1930 in the Great Depression.
16:46 I said in February of 2025, confidently
16:50 that House Democrats were going to take
16:52 back control.
16:55 And we did. I made clear that we were
16:58 going to battle Republicans and MAGA
17:01 extremism on every issue.
17:04 And we battle them on the one big ugly
17:06 bill,
17:08 which became the most unpopular
17:11 piece of legislation in modern American
17:14 history. We battled them on the Medicaid
17:16 cuts, battled them on the Affordable
17:18 Care Act tax credits, and forced
17:19 Republicans to vote on it over the
17:22 objection of Mike Johnson and Donald
17:25 Trump. And it passed. We forced votes on
17:28 extending
17:30 TPS for Haitian migrants, forced votes
17:33 to extend benefits to veterans
17:36 successfully, forced votes to override
17:39 Donald Trump's executive order on
17:42 collective bargaining. We force votes
17:45 with respect to making sure we fund our
17:47 allies
17:49 as opposed to supporting brutal
17:51 dictators
17:53 like Vladimir Putin. We force votes
17:56 repeatedly and successfully to end the
17:58 reckless and costly war of choice in
18:00 Iran and we're not going to stop
18:03 until we prevail. We've successfully
18:06 forced votes on Epstein transparency and
18:10 the Epstein files, and we're going to
18:12 continue to work with the brave and
18:14 courageous survivors until they get the
18:18 transparency
18:19 and the accountability that they
18:22 deserve. We've battled them on ICE
18:25 funding. We said we were not going to
18:28 provide an additional dime
18:33 to Donald Trump's violent mass
18:34 deportation machine and we haven't.
18:38 We've battled them on every issue. We
18:42 made clear to the American people
18:45 despite all the skepticism that was out
18:48 there
18:50 that the Republican gerrymandering
18:52 scheme was not going to be successful.
18:56 You had Republican operatives close to
18:59 the president saying that the
19:00 gerrymandering scheme was going to yield
19:03 them 16 seats.
19:06 16 seats.
19:09 Every single Democratic incumbent in a
19:12 gerrymandered district came back. Every
19:16 single one in Texas, in North Carolina,
19:20 in Ohio,
19:22 in Florida, every single
19:26 one came back. And in those states that
19:29 were gerrymandered, we flipped seats in
19:33 Ohio. We flipped a seat in Tennessee. We
19:38 flipped seven seats in North Carolina.
19:43 We held every single gerrymandered seat
19:46 in Florida. We flipped seats in Texas.
19:52 And of course, we flipped five seats
19:54 in California.
19:57 I stood here and said, "Republicans
20:01 have started this gerrymandering war.
20:03 Democrats were going to end it. Promise
20:06 made, promise kept." So, the record
20:10 speaks for itself. But that doesn't mean
20:13 it's not important to talk to every
20:16 single member of the House Democratic
20:18 Caucus family about what the future
20:21 looks like and how we can build upon
20:23 this record
20:26 where everyone doubted our ability to
20:29 aggressively fight back and continue
20:33 to bring about the type of bold,
20:35 dramatic, and decisive change that the
20:38 American people deserve. Thank you
20:41 everyone.
20:52 I
Huang was a 'trendsetter for the industry': Creative Strategies CEO Ben Bajarin full transcript
0:00 WITH INDISPENSABLE MEN. CFO
0:02 COLETTE KRESS HAS BEEN TAPPED
0:03 TO SERVE AS NVIDIA'S INTERIM
0:05 CEO, AS THE COMPANY SAYS IT
0:06 WILL NOW EVALUATE INSIDE AND
0:08 OUTSIDE CANDIDATES FOR A
0:09 PERMANENT REPLACEMENT. OUR NEXT
0:10 GUEST IS A TECH EXPERT AND
0:12 INDUSTRY INSIDER. HIS FIRM
0:13 WORKS CLOSELY WITH TECHNOLOGY
0:15 LEADERSHIP TEAMS. JOINING US IS
0:17 CREATIVE STRATEGY CEO BEN
0:19 BAJARIN. IT'S GREAT TO HAVE YOU,
0:20 BEN. I'M SURE YOUR PHONE IS
0:21 BLOWING UP LIKE OURS IS. ARE
0:23 THERE QUESTIONS ABOUT THE NEXT
0:25 CEO OR JUST PEOPLE IN SHOCK
0:26 ABOUT JENSEN OR WHAT ARE YOU
0:28 HEARING?
0:29 >> YEAH, I THINK IT'S BOTH.
0:31 THERE'S OBVIOUSLY A QUESTION OF,
0:32 YOU KNOW, WHO COULD BE THE
0:34 LOGICAL CANDIDATE TO RUN NVIDIA,
0:35 WHETHER THAT'S AN INTERNAL OR
0:36 AN EXTERNAL CANDIDATE. THERE'S
0:38 A LOT OF QUESTIONS ABOUT, YOU
0:39 KNOW DOES ANYTHING CHANGE IN
0:41 THE STRATEGY. YOU KNOW HOW MUCH
0:42 OF THE STRATEGY WAS TIED TO
0:44 JENSEN'S DEEP CONVICTIONS ABOUT
0:45 WHERE THIS INDUSTRY GOES, HOW
0:46 THEY USE THEIR BALANCE SHEET,
0:47 WHAT THAT LOOK LIKE WITH THEIR
0:49 ECOSYSTEM. SO I THINK A LOT OF
0:50 THAT CALLS INTO QUESTION,
0:51 OBVIOUSLY, THINGS WE WE DON'T
0:53 HAVE THE ANSWER FOR. BUT I
0:54 THINK, YOU KNOW, ANY TIME
0:55 SOMETHING LIKE THIS HAPPENS AND
0:57 WE OBSERVE THIS, YOU KNOW, BACK
0:58 IN THE DAY WITH APPLE WHEN
1:00 STEVE JOBS HAD CANCER AND THEN,
1:01 YOU KNOW, INEVITABLY,
1:02 INEVITABLY DIED, IT CREATES A
1:03 HUGE SHAKEUP AND AN IMPACT TO
1:05 THE INDUSTRY. AND WE'RE GOING
1:06 THROUGH THAT PROCESS RIGHT NOW.
1:08 >> WELL, IT SORT OF REMINDS ME
1:10 OF THIS OF THIS BLANKFEIN TWEET,
1:11 THAT POST THAT WE JUST THAT WE
1:13 JUST SHARED. IS HE AN
1:15 INDISPENSABLE MAN WHEN IT COMES
1:16 TO NVIDIA AND THE BROADER
1:19 ECOSYSTEM?
1:20 >> I THINK THE CHALLENGE IS HE
1:22 WAS VERY CHARISMATIC. AND
1:23 ANYTIME YOU YOU LEARN YOU LOSE
1:25 A FOUNDER LEVEL, YOU KNOW, TYPE
1:26 OF CHARISMA WHO REALLY HAS BEEN
1:28 LOOKED UPON AS KIND OF THE THE
1:30 TRENDSETTER FOR THE INDUSTRY,
1:32 RIGHT? THE, THE SPOKESPERSON
1:33 FOR THIS MOMENT THAT WE HAVE IN
1:35 THIS TECHNOLOGY BUILD OUT, YOU
1:36 KNOW, THAT'S, THAT'S GOING TO
1:37 BE A LOSS. THAT DOESN'T MEAN
1:39 THAT THEIR PRODUCT ROADMAP IS
1:40 STRONG. THAT DOESN'T MEAN THAT
1:41 THEIR EXECUTION CAN CHANGE. YOU
1:43 KNOW, AGAIN, APPLE IS THE BEST
1:44 COMP. WE HAVE TO SEEING HOW NEW
1:46 LEADERSHIP CAN, CAN GROW AND
1:47 SCALE A COMPANY AT AN
1:48 OPERATIONAL LEVEL. BUT THAT
1:50 DOESN'T CHANGE THE FACT THAT
1:51 THERE IS A CULTURE RIGHT SET
1:52 THAT THAT WAS SET, THAT HAS TO
1:54 BE PRESERVED. AND, AND THAT'S
1:56 WHAT WE JUST DON'T KNOW. RIGHT.
1:57 IT WAS A LITTLE BIT EASIER WITH
1:59 APPLE. YOU HAD SOME FAITH IN
2:00 TIM COOK. YOU KNOW, HE'D BEEN
2:02 THERE FOREVER. IT'S DIFFERENT
2:03 WITH NVIDIA UNTIL WE KNOW RIGHT.
2:04 WHO TAKES OVER.
2:05 >> YEAH. I MEAN THAT IS A GOOD
2:07 POINT. AND I SAW YOU POSTED
2:08 THAT AS WELL. THE CULTURE
2:10 SETTER AT CEO AS CULTURE SETTER.
2:11 YOU KNOW WE'RE LEARNING HOW
2:13 MANY ROLES THAT CEOS HAVE TO
2:14 HAVE TO TAKE ON. AND, AND, AND
2:16 IT'S HARD TO FIND, YOU KNOW,
2:17 SOMEONE THAT, THAT ENCOMPASSES
2:19 ALL OF THEM. YOU THINK THAT IAN
2:20 BUCK IS SOMEONE TO WATCH?
2:22 >> YEAH, I THINK IAN'S BEEN
2:23 AROUND, YOU KNOW, REALLY AS
2:24 JENSEN'S RIGHT HAND MAN. HE'S
2:26 DEEPLY TECHNICAL IN THE WEEDS.
2:27 HE UNDERSTANDS THE BUSINESS. I
2:29 THINK HE'S BEEN, YOU KNOW,
2:31 REALLY ONE OF THE FRONT RUNNERS
2:32 IN WORKING WITH ALL OF THEIR
2:33 CUSTOMERS AND ECOSYSTEM. SO HE
2:35 HAS THOSE RELATIONSHIPS. SO I
2:36 MEAN, I THINK HE'S THE MOST
2:38 LOGICAL CANDIDATE. I ASSUME
2:40 THAT THEY'RE GOING TO DO, YOU
2:42 KNOW, EXTERNAL SEARCHES. I KNOW
2:43 YOU'VE HAD, YOU KNOW, NAMES
2:45 THROWN AROUND LIKE JOHNY SROUJI
2:46 FROM APPLE. BUT I THINK, YOU
2:48 KNOW, AGAIN, I THINK WHEN IT
2:50 COMES TO A, A CULTURE, A, A SET
2:54 OF INNOVATION, I THINK INTERNAL
2:55 CANDIDATES ARE TYPICALLY BEST.
2:56 SO I WOULD EXPECT THAT THEY
2:57 LOOK THEIR FIRST.
2:59 >> YEAH. I'M CURIOUS ON THAT
3:01 THOUGH. SO WHY DO YOU FEEL
3:03 INTERNAL CANDIDATES WOULD BE
3:04 BEST IN THIS SITUATION? BECAUSE
3:05 IT IS SORT OF A UNIQUE
3:07 SITUATION TO A CERTAIN EXTENT.
3:08 AND THEY'RE OBVIOUSLY GOING TO
3:09 BE INVESTIGATIONS OF MR. WONG
3:10 IN PARTICULAR OVER TIME. IN
3:13 TERMS OF NATIONAL SECURITY. I
3:14 JUST WONDER WHY YOU DON'T THINK
3:16 IT WOULD BE BENEFICIAL, PERHAPS,
3:18 TO BRING IN AN OUTSIDER.
3:20 >> I MEAN, I THINK THERE'S A
3:21 FEW THINGS, RIGHT? IT'S
3:22 TYPICALLY HARDER FOR AN
3:23 OUTSIDER TO COME IN AND EXECUTE
3:25 AT THIS LEVEL WITH A COMPANY
3:27 WHO, AGAIN, YOU HAVE TO HAVE
3:29 DEEP SEMICONDUCTOR EXPERTISE.
3:29 LIKE IT CAN'T BE SOMEBODY
3:31 OUTSIDE OF THE SEMICONDUCTOR
3:33 INDUSTRY. AND IT'S JUST A VERY
3:34 SHORT LIST, RIGHT? LOOK AT WHAT
3:36 INTEL WENT THROUGH IN REPLACING
3:37 PAT GELSINGER. IT'S A VERY
3:38 SHORT LIST OF PEOPLE WHO CAN DO
3:40 THAT AT THIS SCALE. WHO HAS THE
3:42 SUPPLY CHAIN RELATIONSHIPS. YOU
3:43 KNOW, IAN HAS BEEN AROUND IN
3:45 THAT, YOU KNOW, I DON'T IT
3:47 WOULD BE SPECULATIVE TO SAY
3:48 HE'S GOT ANY TIES TO ANYTHING
3:50 THAT WENT ON WITH JENSEN. BUT
3:52 JUST THE LENGTH OF TIME HE'S
3:53 HAD IN INDUSTRY GROWING THIS
3:56 COMPANY BEEN THERE SINCE VERY,
3:57 VERY EARLY DAYS. IT MAKES HIM
3:59 THE MOST REALISTIC CANDIDATE.
4:01 AND AGAIN, BECAUSE THE SUPPLY
4:04 CHAIN LIKE THIS INDUSTRY,
4:06 SEMICONDUCTORS, IS VERY
4:06 DIFFERENT THAN MANY OTHER
4:08 INDUSTRIES. TYPICALLY, WHY YOU
4:09 WANT PEOPLE WHO'VE, WHO'VE BEEN
4:10 IN THAT ROLE AND INVOLVED IN
4:12 THAT ECOSYSTEM FOR A LONG TIME.
4:14 >> YOU ALSO WANT SOMEBODY WHO
4:15 CAN MAKE SURE YOU KEEP ALL THE
4:17 ENGINEERS. I MEAN, THAT'S THE
4:18 KEY TALENT, ISN'T IT?
4:19 >> THAT AGREED.
4:20 >> THAT WILL GO TO THE FUTURE
4:21 OF THE COMPANY IN ITS SUCCESS.
4:23 >> AGREED. AND THAT GOES BACK
4:24 TO, I THINK, RIGHT. JUST YOU
4:26 KNOW, JENSEN WAS A PERSON THAT
4:27 A LOT OF PEOPLE LOOKED UP TO,
4:29 RIGHT? THEY WANTED TO WORK FOR
4:31 THIS PERSON. THERE WAS PASSION
4:32 AND CONVICTION. THIS IS A
4:33 STRESSFUL INDUSTRY, RIGHT? THIS
4:34 IS A STRESSFUL TIME TO WORK IN.
4:36 AND SO YOU GOT TO BELIEVE IN
4:38 YOUR LEADER. AND I THINK THAT'S
4:39 ALSO REALLY WHAT'S WHAT'S
4:40 WHAT'S HARMING HERE. AND WHAT
4:41 THEY
Faber Report: OpenAI raised $15B at $.125 valuation full transcript
0:08 NOMINATIONS.CNBC.COM.
0:10 >> IF YOU'RE JUST WAKING UP OUT
0:12 WEST, JEN-HSUN HUANG RESIGNS AS
0:13 CEO AND BOARD MEMBER OF NVIDIA
0:15 COMPANY LAUNCHES A SEARCH. CFO
0:17 COLETTE KRESS WILL BE INTERIM
0:19 CEO. STOCK GOT TO 148 80 THIS
0:23 MORNING ON THAT NEWS, ALTHOUGH
0:25 REBOUNDING NOW BACK TO 160 AND
0:27 CHANGE OF COURSE. GUYS THIS WAS
0:28 A $210 STOCK LAST TUESDAY. SO
0:32 WE'LL WATCH IT CLOSELY.
0:33 >> YEAH LOOK IT THERE. THIS IS
0:35 A COMPANY THAT OBVIOUSLY THE
0:37 MOST IMPORTANT PERSON IN
0:40 SEMICONDUCTORS MORE EVEN THAN
0:42 ANDY GROVE. MORE THAN GREG BEAR.
0:43 MORE YOU KNOW MORE THAN GORDON
0:45 MOORE. YES. AND YES. BECAUSE HE
0:47 MADE IT MORE THAN SEMIS.
0:48 REMEMBER SEMIS WERE REALLY
0:49 SECOND RATE TO SOFTWARE.
0:52 >> ANOTHER COMPANY THAT WE OF
0:53 COURSE FOLLOWED CLOSELY HERE
0:55 THAT IS PRIVATE STILL IS OPEN
0:56 AI. AND I DID WANT TO SHARE
0:58 SOME RECENT NEWS ON THAT
0:59 COMPANY. BY THE WAY, A COMPANY
1:00 THAT HAS TAKEN IN SOME $30
1:02 BILLION FROM NVIDIA, SOME $65
1:05 BILLION FROM SOFTBANK, BUT HAS
1:07 HAD THE NEED TO CONTINUE TO
1:08 RAISE MORE MONEY AS A RESULT OF
1:10 WHAT IS AN ENORMOUS CASH BURN,
1:12 DESPITE WHAT IS ALSO
1:13 SIGNIFICANT REVENUE GROWTH AT
1:14 OPEN AI. REMEMBER, WE REPORTED
1:16 YESTERDAY ABOUT 50% REVENUE
1:18 GROWTH FROM THE SECOND TO THE
1:19 THIRD QUARTER FOR THE COMPANY
1:20 CAN TELL YOU NOW, ACCORDING TO
1:22 PEOPLE FAMILIAR WITH WITH THE
1:23 SITUATION, THEY'VE RAISED 15
1:25 BILLION IN THEIR LATEST EFFORT
1:27 TO DO SO AT A $1.25 TRILLION
1:30 VALUATION. RECENT REPORTS HAD
1:31 THE COMPANY AT 11 BILLION. I
1:33 CAN NOW TELL YOU THEY'RE AT 15.
1:35 UNCLEAR WHETHER THEY WILL GO
1:36 BEYOND THAT OR WHETHER THAT
1:38 WILL BE SORT OF WHERE THEY END
1:39 THIS LATEST FUNDRAISING AT OPEN
1:42 AI. AND AGAIN, AT A $1.25
1:45 TRILLION OVERALL VALUE. YOU MAY
1:46 RECALL THE COMPANY ACTUALLY DID
1:48 GO TO THE MARKET WITH THE
1:49 INTENT OF RAISING AS MUCH AS
1:51 $30 BILLION AT A $1.4 TRILLION
1:54 VALUATION. IT HAD A PULLBACK.
1:55 BOTH VALUATION AND ITS
1:57 AMBITIONS FOR RAISING NEW
1:58 CAPITAL AT LEAST BASED ON WHAT
2:02 IT ACTUALLY WAS ABLE TO TO GET
2:05 FROM EXISTING. AND SOME NEW
2:08 INVESTORS AS WELL. THIS OF
2:10 COURSE, COMES AS WE ARE LESS
2:12 THAN A WEEK AWAY GUYS FROM
2:13 ANTHROPIC'S IPO IN WHICH IT IS
2:15 GOING TO BE RAISING AT LEAST
2:16 LET'S CALL IT 80 PLUS $84
2:19 BILLION. SOME $26 BILLION FROM
2:21 STRATEGIC PARTNERS THAT DO
2:22 INCLUDE NVIDIA AND OF COURSE
2:25 FROM THE PUBLIC AS WELL BOTH
2:27 INSTITUTIONAL INVESTORS AND
2:28 INVESTORS AROUND THE WORLD AND
2:31 RETAIL INVESTORS ALSO YOU KNOW
2:33 I AM HEARING SOME POSITIVE
2:35 CHATTER AROUND ANTHROPIC. JIM.
2:37 THE HOPE THAT AS I SORT OF SAID
2:39 ON MONDAY THAT, YOU KNOW, THEY
2:40 TALK ONE 3 TO 1 FOUR, BUT
2:42 REALLY THEY MAY MOVE PRICING UP
2:43 TO AS HIGH AS 1.5 TRILLION.
2:45 >> 1.5, 1.6, 1.6.
2:47 >> AND THEN YOU SEE WHERE IT
2:48 TRADES IN THE AFTERMARKET.
2:50 AGAIN, WE SHALL SEE. UNCLEAR
2:53 EXACTLY HOW THIS NEWS FROM
2:54 NVIDIA THIS MORNING IS GOING TO
2:55 PLAY OUT. BUT I DID OFFER UP
2:57 THE IDEA THAT TO THE EXTENT
2:58 THAT IT LESSENS THE INFLUENCE
3:00 OF OPEN SOURCE GIVING, YOU'VE
3:01 TAKEN THE LARGEST SINGLE
3:04 SUPPORTER OFF THE FIELD IN
3:06 JEN-HSUN HUANG MIGHT BE SEEN AS
3:08 A POSITIVE FOR THE FRONTIER
3:09 LABS.
3:09 >> HOW MUCH DO YOU THINK IT
3:11 MATTERS THAT THEY HAVE THE BIG
3:13 STOCK BASED COMPENSATION? THAT
3:14 IF YOU TOOK AWAY THE YOU KNOW,
3:16 THERE'S THEY'RE SPENDING A LOT
3:18 OF TIME DEFENDING THEIR ACTUAL
3:21 PROFITABILITY.
3:21 >> THIS IS ANTHROPIC YOU'RE
3:22 TALKING ABOUT.
3:23 >> YEAH, BUT THE STOCK BASED
3:24 COMPENSATION IS HUGE.
3:25 >> IT IS HUGE, ALTHOUGH FRANKLY,
3:27 IT'S HUGE THAT A LOT OF OTHER
3:28 PUBLIC COMPANIES AS WELL. AND
3:29 THEN WE SIT HERE AND WE TALK
3:31 ABOUT ADJUSTED EBITDA. AND
3:32 EVERY SO OFTEN I'LL POINT OUT,
3:34 OH, BY THE WAY, IF YOU ADJUST,
3:35 IF YOU ACTUALLY ADD BACK STOCK
3:37 BASED COMPENSATION, THE
3:38 DIFFERENTIAL BETWEEN GAAP
3:39 EARNINGS AND NON-GAAP WAS
3:39 ENORMOUS. SO I DON'T KNOW IS
3:41 THE ANSWER HOW MUCH IT'S GOING
3:42 TO MATTER.
3:43 >> I'M JUST THINKING I MEAN TO
3:45 ME I'VE BEEN GOING OVER THE
3:46 VALUATION. I THINK THE
3:47 VALUATION IS STUNNING. AND I
3:48 KNOW THAT THE NUMBER THAT
3:50 GOLDMAN PUT OUT FOR 2030
3:51 REVENUES IS EXTRAORDINARY,
3:52 RIGHT. SO THEY CAN BE BEAT.
3:53 >> I MEAN, THE NUMBER THAT
3:55 MATTERS IS THE ONE
WNBA Finals MVP Gabby Williams On Golden State’s Championship, WNBA Politics And What Comes Next full transcript
0:00 Coming up this week on CNBC Sport the Podcast, WNBA
0:05 Finals MVP Gabby Williams on how her life has changed already
0:09 since winning the WNBA Championship last week. I'm just
0:13 smiling a lot more, which is great. Plus, what she wants to
0:17 see from the next WNBA Commissioner. I just hope our
0:20 next commissioner takes the time to like get to know us as
0:22 people, and if she thinks the recent election results will
0:27 quiet down outside political attention on the league, being a
0:31 female athlete just automatically becomes
0:33 politicized because we're in a space where maybe we weren't
0:36 welcome before. That's all coming up next this week on CNBC
0:41 Sport the Podcast.
0:45 I am happy to be joined by the reigning WNBA Finals MVP, Gabby.
0:51 Thank you for joining us. Thanks for having us. Is this a
0:54 whirlwind for you? Yeah, absolutely. Every day is like a
0:57 new adventure. I mean, well, all right. I have a couple questions
1:01 to start off with. First of all, let's talk about Game Six. Okay,
1:04 you get the news that the venue is going to be changed, that the
1:07 time is going to be this bizarre time, 1230 in the afternoon.
1:12 What are you thinking when you hear all of this?
1:15 I mean, I
1:17 was worried on a lot of other things. Honestly, that that
1:20 wasn't
1:21 time and place didn't matter too much by game six. I think our
1:25 minds were kind of spiraling, but yeah, it was a tough it was
1:29 a tough start, but we didn't really mind it. So yeah, that
1:33 didn't throw you off. You weren't thinking in the back of
1:35 your head, you know, I can't believe this that they're doing
1:37 this or anything like that. No, not at all. The only thing would
1:40 have been like if we were to have won the ceremony, that
1:44 would have been unfortunate, but a good thing we just did. That's
1:46 what I was gonna say. So in the end, in the back of your mind,
1:49 are you are seriously when then that game's over and you're
1:52 thinking, oh wow, I get to play game seven at home now at
1:55 Valhalla. Are you thinking this is better? Not necessarily
2:00 better, because I mean there's so much stress and unknown.
2:03 Definitely mixed emotions of just like, okay, was that our
2:06 shot? Did we just lose it? But then also I try to stay positive
2:09 and be like, okay, but how good is that going to feel if we do
2:12 get it done? Maybe this is just meant to be and meant for us. So
2:15 try to think of it that way. And now let's talk about Game Seven
2:17 a little bit. 28 points in the second half.
2:20 As you're going through that, this is sort of a question for
2:23 like you know laymen like myself that are not professional
2:27 athletes. Is there some point where you're feeling, oh, I've
2:32 got it today? Like, oh, I've I've like I've hit my flow
2:35 state, or or is it? Are you too in the moment so that it never
2:39 really registers like that. I've had games where you can like
2:43 really recognize
2:45 it. Like I think like Dallas game too. I was like, oh, okay,
2:48 like I'm not missing today, you know. Or there's a couple games
2:50 against Vegas where I was like, oh, I have it. That game, I I
2:54 was just so in the moment and I think like under the pressure
2:56 that I didn't really realize
2:59 how much of like a zone I was in until I like rewatched the game
3:02 back, and I was like, "Oh wow, I really was in the zone." But in
3:06 the moment, I was just there was a lot of pressure, so I think I
3:09 was just taking possession by possession. I've heard you say
3:12 that in the off season when you decided to join Golden State,
3:16 that one of the things that made you make the decision was Joe
3:21 Laco? Is
3:23 that what? What is first of all? What did he say to you to make
3:25 you join the team? But what is your relationship with him like?
3:29 And is it unusual for an owner and a player to have a
3:32 relationship like that, especially right off the bat? I
3:35 think it just depends on the owner how much they want to be
3:38 involved. You know, I've had certain owners who maybe want to
3:41 keep a you know heat or distance than others who are very
3:44 involved and like you can't go to their house have dinner with
3:46 them, but he what stood out to me was just his competitiveness
3:50 on the phone call. Like I didn't expect that to be like what what
3:54 got me to come. You know that was kind of like the tipping
3:56 point for me to come to Golden State. I didn't expect that when
3:58 I got on the call with him, but hearing him talking about his
4:02 investment into the sport, into the franchise, what he had
4:05 envisioned for his athletes,
4:07 that just showed me that, like, okay, this guy's gonna help me
4:09 win one day. Was he super confident that you were gonna
4:12 win a title? Yeah, yeah, absolutely. I mean, I wanted to
4:15 go somewhere that we were gonna contend. He was, you know, he
4:18 talked about how he'd done it before. He it sounded like he
4:21 knew how to build the right culture and have the right
4:23 people, and yeah, he's been proven right. I know you got a
4:26 text from Michael Jordan. Any other interesting texts that
4:30 you've received in the past few days?
4:32 It's just been great. I was at the UConn game yesterday, and
4:36 like I was talking to Alicia Clark, and I was like, the best
4:39 messages I've received have been from players like her, like Sue
4:43 Bird or Nafisa, like players who have kind of seen my trajectory
4:47 for like the last eight years and have seen like you know from
4:50 from the ground up. Those messages meant a lot to me. The
4:52 WNBA is going through a little bit of a transition period now
4:55 in the sense that Kathy Engelbert is leaving as the
4:58 commissioner. What are you?
5:00 For out of the next commissioner of the league, I just hope our
5:03 next commissioner
5:05 takes the time to like get to know us as people. I think
5:08 that's a. I think that will. There's a bit of a disconnect
5:12 sometimes, and I think that can just be easily solved by just
5:14 like I don't know taking a team out to dinner, having a meeting
5:17 with them, getting to know them, hearing their side of the story,
5:19 and realizing like we can work together and we can get to know
5:23 each other. It could also allow us to be more empathetic to the
5:25 commissioner and understand like what that person has to do as
5:28 well in their role. How would you assess the job Kathy did
5:30 with the league? I think obviously we've made great
5:33 strides. I do understand, you know, the positive and the
5:37 negative sides of it. Like I said, I think just her having a
5:40 bit more of a human relationship with the players would have gone
5:42 a long way, but I mean we can't deny what she's created and what
5:46 she's helped grow this league to be. I think she is a big part of
5:50 that as well. There is an association, particularly I
5:54 would say over the past year with the league and cultural and
5:58 political issues. We see it all the time in the media, and some
6:01 of that has to do with gender and sexuality and trans rights,
6:04 which I know you've been particularly outspoken about. We
6:06 just had an election, which was this, you know, blue tsunami. Do
6:11 you think that the election results
6:15 will change the way the outside world treats the league, or do
6:20 you do you can do you think that the connection between sort of
6:25 this political and cultural and the league and these sort of hot
6:29 button issues will just continue?
6:32 I think as a female athlete, we are
6:36 just our existence is political. Unfortunately, you know, we're a
6:39 lot of women who are
6:41 either queer women of color, and just kind of being a female
6:45 athlete just automatically becomes politicized because
6:48 we're in a space where maybe we weren't welcome before. So I
6:51 think that's something that we embrace as athletes. You know, I
6:54 think we understand that we are the the kind of leaders you see
6:57 as
6:58 you know when we were trying to elect Warnock back in 2020, you
7:02 know, the standing up for Black Lives Matter movement, obviously
7:04 being for trailblazers and queer rights. So I think that'll
7:07 continue. Did you expect that coming into the league?
7:11 It was something I remember, like 2016, watching Minnesota,
7:14 the Minnesota Lynx, and that like really,
7:17 like that's like a core memory for me. Watching that while I
7:19 was in college and realizing, like, oh wow, these aren't just
7:21 basketball players; like, these are leaders in our community. So
7:24 I was actually looking forward to that part of the W. There's
7:28 sort of associated with that. I think there's been a lot of
7:31 attention paid on how the league treats Caitlin Clark. Should the
7:35 league be protecting her more? Then I think there was some
7:38 pushback among certain players about, like, should she be the
7:41 face of the league? I'm curious, just your opinion, sort of on
7:46 all of that, like the league's relationship with Caitlin Clark,
7:49 and from a player's perspective, is it fair that people see her
7:52 as the face of the league?
7:55 I think everyone is just everyone's winning right now,
7:58 right? You know, we just had this amazing,
8:01 this prolific CBA, you know, we're hearing a lot more stories
8:04 than Kaylin's. I think the way what Kaylin has to carry is
8:07 probably very, very heavy, and I think she herself would be the
8:11 first person to say like she doesn't need to be protected.
8:13 And I think she's just as competitive. And and I mean,
8:17 I've played against her, and I you can see that. I don't think
8:19 she asks for anything to be easy, as none of us do. We're
8:22 all just athletes, you know. But it's been great just seeing just
8:27 multiple stories be told, multiple women kind of earn
8:31 their praise, and just seeing the game grow collectively. How
8:34 do you expect your life will change now?
8:39 I hope not too much, to be honest, I'm just smiling a lot
8:42 more, which is great. But I, I don't know. I'm still me. I
8:46 still just just love being where I'm at, and I just I just play
8:49 basketball. Well, from a business perspective, have you
8:52 started to talk to your agent at all? Like, are sponsors now
8:55 starting to knock on the door and say, "Hey, let's talk" ? Of
8:59 course, yeah. And I'm obviously embracing that part and loving
9:02 it. My agent is doing a phenomenal job, but I don't
9:06 think it's like it's not changing me. I would love to
9:09 like do more stuff. I think it's an opportunity for me to like do
9:11 more stuff in the community and people recognizing me more.
9:14 Maybe I can have more of an impact to that in that way,
9:16 especially in the Bay Area where I grew up. So looking forward to
9:19 that part. Well, is it gonna physically change you, or are
9:21 you gonna get a new tattoo? That's been the question of the
9:23 day. Everyone's been asking me, so I think eventually, yeah,
9:26 it'll happen. So you haven't thought about it yet, is what
9:29 you're telling me, though. No, King Seven was too much. We
9:32 forgot about it, and we'll come back if we're onto it. What do
9:36 you foresee for Golden State moving forward? Like, how how do
9:40 you maintain this, and how do you repeat? I've told the story
9:42 a couple times, but it's my favorite story from the night
9:44 that we won. Was being in the lounge with with Joe Lacob and
9:48 just congratulating him on what he's created and telling him,
9:51 you know, like about where I came from and just how amazing
9:54 he's done with this franchise. And I was like, you know, you're
9:56 setting the standard. Everyone's going to try to copy you now.
9:58 And he was just like, I hope it.
10:00 Catch up, and that's kind of his goal is just to keep being the
10:03 best franchise. Is there like a secret sauce going on, though? I
10:07 mean, take us inside a little bit. Like you just experienced
10:10 this. You've played on several other teams. Like, was this year
10:13 different in a certain way from other years? Yeah, loads
10:16 different. I've never been a part of anything like this,
10:18 honestly. I mean, it's. I think it's the investment. Obviously,
10:22 it's the investment. It's the dedication. It's the time. I
10:24 mean, he's at every game. He was at every away game. Clearly,
10:27 he's built an atmosphere that's different. Like Valhalla stands
10:30 out as a unique atmosphere that must have contributed to the
10:33 winning environment. I would think. Oh, it did. And being in
10:37 Valhalla allowed me to be myself.
10:39 As soon as I got there, I felt so welcomed. In the preseason
10:42 game, I didn't even play, and people were like screaming for
10:44 me and welcoming me, and it just gives me a confidence that I
10:49 think I can only get from Bajala. You mentioned UConn. I
10:52 did want to ask you a question because we I spoke to your old
10:55 coach Gino Oriama, and he's known for this sort of like
10:59 tough love persona with his players.
11:03 Does that fly in college and not in the WNBA? I'm curious, or
11:06 that player coach relationship. Like, do athletes kind of grow
11:12 out of that a little bit?
11:14 I think you go through like your different phases with coach. I
11:18 think
11:20 you like take so maybe time to reflect on like your college
11:23 career, and then you know if you go pro, you kind of get focused
11:27 on that, and then you look back, and then you well as soon as you
11:29 go pro, you are grateful for everything he taught you about
11:32 being a pro.
11:34 Like you notice the UConn kids are like the ones who run during
11:37 a timeout, you know, run to the bench, who like are always
11:39 cheering, are always good teammates. I think that's part
11:41 of UConn culture, but then as you get older, you really start
11:44 to reflect, and I think he does too, on like what he's built and
11:48 the the legacy that you've become a part of.
11:52 Can you spot a UConn player at the pro level? Like, is there
11:55 something that carries over? I mean, you obviously know who
11:58 they are to some degree, but is there something that makes them
12:02 stand out. Yeah, I think,
12:05 like I said, it's it's the little things. It's like
12:08 the like no phones in locker room, like some of these like
12:10 little things that just kind of stick. But it's just I think the
12:13 way they are as people,
12:15 very unselfish, team before individual kind of mentality,
12:19 and it's just kind of the kid that they go after when they
12:21 recruit. Gabby Williams, Gabby's agents taking your call. If
12:24 you're watching this,
12:26 congratulations. Thank you.
Market Open: Nvidia Shares Plunge 13% After CEO Resignation, Stocks Mixed full transcript
0:01 CNBC business news update. I'm Jessica
0:04 Edinger. Market open Thursday morning.
0:07 Nvidia's embattled CEO stepping down.
0:10 >> And I'm sorry we have to interrupt you.
0:11 If you can hold on for just a moment.
0:12 There is news flash [music] just in on
0:14 this that we want to make sure we bring
0:15 you right away. Um it says that Jensen
0:19 Wong is making a transition here. the
0:21 news that that I guess we've kind of
0:23 been expecting
0:24 >> immediately. Yeah. Um not being the
0:27 board not having to make the decision on
0:28 this that Jensen Wong is resigning
0:30 effective immediately. This was kind I I
0:32 felt like we were kind of on um smoke
0:36 watch for the Pope um throughout this
0:38 time after hearing this news last night.
0:39 >> That's CNBC's Becky Quick with Joe
0:42 Kernan. Nvidia shares down almost 12%
0:45 out of the open this morning, but the
0:47 Dow holding up. It's up 29 points. The
0:50 S&P 500 index is down 56 points
0:53 threequarters percent at the open and
0:55 the Nasdaq plunging 344 points 1.3%.
1:01 Chipmaker shares are mixed. More on
1:04 Nvidia from CNBC's Carl Kintineia.
1:06 >> Big news out of Nvidia today. The
1:08 company's board of directors announcing
1:10 that Jensen Wong has resigned as
1:12 president, chief executive officer, and
1:14 a member of the board effective
1:16 immediately. Colette Crest, the CFO, has
1:18 agreed to serve as interim CEO. She will
1:21 continue to serve as EVP and CFO until a
1:25 permanent successor has been named. The
1:27 board says it is initiating a search for
1:29 a permanent chief executive officer and
1:31 will consider internal and external
1:34 candidates.
1:35 >> A take from Yale's Jeffrey Sonnenfeld
1:38 before the official announcement on
1:40 CNBC.
1:41 >> There are some good people in there
1:42 though. The the sec the chief financial
1:44 officer, she's terrific. Um, I think you
1:46 know, Colette Crest could be a fantastic
1:48 leader here.
1:49 >> And here's a take from Advisers Capitals
1:52 Joanne Feny before the announcement on
1:54 CNBC.
1:55 >> We have very likely not seen all the bad
1:57 news that's going to come out about
2:00 Jensen and and potentially, you know,
2:02 throwing more suspicion on a significant
2:05 chunk of their sales, those sales
2:07 associated with Singapore, right? So,
2:09 even if though we took out those sales,
2:11 right? that still leaves the company uh
2:14 trading at a pretty attractive multiple
2:17 and and so really from here the question
2:19 is what kind of growth can the company
2:21 generate? Full coverage of the change at
2:24 the top of Nvidia at CNBC television,
2:26 CNBC.com and the CNBC app on your phone.
2:30 Meanwhile, William Blair immediately
2:32 upgraded chipmaker AMD. It's seen as
2:35 benefiting from the turmoil at Nvidia.
2:38 AMD shares are up a little more than 1%.
2:41 Broadcom up 4%. Oil prices are jumping
2:44 after President Trump said that no Iran
2:47 deal is needed to end the war. Quote,
2:50 "We've got there straight."
2:52 US crude oil back above $86 a barrel
2:55 today. AAA says the national average for
2:57 a gallon of regulars below $4 for a
3:00 second straight day. Prices plunged 20
3:03 cents a gallon for drivers from one week
3:06 ago today post election as traders
3:08 believed Democrats will try to end the
3:10 war sooner rather than later when they
3:13 take control of Congress in January.
3:15 Scout Motors has nearly a quarter
3:18 million vehicle reservations as its new
3:20 $2 billion South Carolina plant nears
3:23 completion. Scout was an American
3:25 vehicle brand from 1961 to 1980. It's
3:28 coming back now with backing by
3:30 Volkswagen pickups and SUVs in all
3:32 electric and hybrid versions. It's
3:34 taking reservations. American Airlines
3:37 is bringing back fresh food to first
3:39 class between New York and Chicago for
3:41 the first time since before the
3:42 pandemic. Today is the one-year
3:44 anniversary of the US Mint striking the
3:46 final US penny, ending 232 years of
3:50 production. Thanksgiving is two weeks
3:53 from today. Walmart is starting the
3:55 first phase of a three-part Black Friday
3:58 sale today.
Jeffrey Sonnenfeld: There are serious problems with the Nvidia board full transcript
0:00 Firstly, your reaction um to what we're
0:02 seeing here in real time and who would
0:06 actually step in for this company
0:08 assuming that he is in fact ousted.
0:10 >> Well, I'm I'm I'm just blown away and
0:12 flattered that you've read all the
0:13 material. I've shoveled your way all
0:14 through the night. So, thank you. And it
0:16 must be we are both drinking the same
0:18 coffee that the Nvidia board must be
0:20 drinking because the reports are that
0:22 they still haven't broken yet. Maybe
0:24 they have, but so far everybody thinks
0:26 they're still meeting through the night.
0:28 Um, and yes, these monarchs are a
0:30 certain type where we do see they often
0:32 have a strangle hold in a creative
0:34 business. They're in the media world.
0:36 They're often in retail world. We've
0:38 seen the Dub Charie situation. If you
0:40 remember American Apparel where he used
0:42 to show up at meetings wearing a sock
0:44 and the sock wasn't on his feet. Uh, but
0:46 not wearing nothing else. Uh, but there
0:48 are problems where we've seen it in the
0:50 hospitality. Even McDonald's had this
0:52 problem. But but the idea of that
0:54 somebody who get is um identified with
0:56 the company and they co-brand it so you
0:59 you almost can't separate them. This is
1:01 a problem for the company to wrestle
1:02 with and yes shareholders have a lot of
1:05 times I'm cautious about shareholder
1:07 litigation in this case with no
1:08 succession plan 60 direct reports by
1:11 intention so that there was no threat to
1:13 him and you also then have um of course
1:16 a board where there's nobody equipped to
1:18 step in. none of them were former CEOs
1:20 or ever reported to boards of directors
1:22 and things like that. So, they're not
1:23 known to the outside. Uh that uh these
1:26 are a lot of problems and the questions
1:27 that you were, you know, teeing up
1:28 before the break, who knew what when is
1:31 Yeah. I mean, here you've got a company
1:33 that some people say was worth 34
1:35 million $34 million. People over there
1:37 in Singapore, I was just on with some
1:39 Singapore uh experts. They're telling me
1:41 was valued at $4 million that they were
1:43 buying in excess of $5 billion of chips.
1:46 They knew this if this was a drug trade
1:48 this would be called a mule that they
1:50 were a shill for distributing these
1:52 chips. Uh so this is a great concern a
1:55 great risk that the board just didn't
1:57 ask these questions and the board was
1:59 issuing denials even recently saying
2:01 that well we don't we don't know that
2:03 these chips were being sent elsewhere.
2:04 They were these chips are being found in
2:07 the military research universities going
2:09 into weapons in China. So that's just
2:11 seconds away from going into Russian and
2:15 uh you know uh Iranian weapons that is
2:17 coming out of China. So serious problems
2:20 about this board and the uh the sexual
2:23 conduct issues. It's not that we're
2:25 being puritanical here is they have a
2:27 code of conduct.
2:28 >> Yeah.
2:28 >> If the CEO is not held to it, then how
2:30 does it have any credibility for anybody
2:32 else both with the customer uh who turns
2:34 out to apparently be a spy and also
2:37 employees? And it's sort of like a water
2:39 over the dam. You know, once you see a
2:41 little trickle, then the dam bursts, it
2:44 breaches when people don't pay attention
2:46 to these signs.
2:46 >> I mean, above and beyond Nvidia, to me,
2:48 it seems like this raises two major
2:50 questions, two larger stories that will
2:52 continue despite what happens uh at
2:54 NVIDIA with with succession planning and
2:56 as the dust dust settles. The first one,
2:58 I think, is this raises key questions
3:00 about governance. I mean, you got
3:01 Anthropic getting ready to go public
3:03 next week. Um and they have a really
3:06 interesting and exotic maybe not so
3:08 exotic when you look at Palanteer but
3:09 governance structure. I mean similar
3:11 situation at SpaceX and they didn't have
3:12 quite those shareholder structures but I
3:15 mean the idea that you have companies
3:17 increasingly large powerful companies
3:19 that are tied to founders or CEOs or or
3:22 or senior leadership. Um
3:26 do we see a push back by investors in
3:29 Wall Street and others in terms of some
3:31 of these governance structures because
3:32 as we're seeing in real time there's
3:33 such risk associated with it.
3:35 >> Yeah, there a lot of times they're
3:36 beholden. There's this they're smitten
3:38 by the CEO kind of idolatry. There are
3:40 times where I would criticize some of
3:42 the decisions that Elon Musk would make
3:44 and I' I'd hear from Larry Ellison
3:45 saying, you know, who are you of Dustin
3:47 Ashes to challenge the Almighty back
3:48 when Ellison was still on the board and
3:50 he has some of these qualities himself
3:51 at Oracle is as brilliant as they are.
3:54 They've taken on the daunting odds, you
3:56 know, the 99% or more of people would
3:58 fail doing what they did. So, of course,
4:01 we celebrate them. how it's said. You
4:02 know, Ellison will say, "Can you send a
4:04 a a rocket ship a couple hundred
4:06 thousand miles off into space and land
4:08 it within inches in the ocean and then
4:10 reuse that of where it's supposed to
4:11 land?" You know, you know, we can't, but
4:13 still that we can't mean we can't ask
4:15 them questions. So, you often have a
4:17 board that is uh very submissive to the
4:19 CEO. You know, it's been said, Aristotle
4:21 actually said it, there's no genius
4:23 without a a touch of madness, but it
4:26 doesn't mean that the whole company has
4:28 to have that touch of madness. somebody
4:30 needs to ask uh some questions and
4:32 that's that's what's missing here. Of
4:34 course, I really worry about what's
4:35 going on in the government side of this,
4:37 too. And we there's plenty to ask on on
4:39 the the corporate governance side and
4:41 worried about this company and you But
4:44 here you have a company that is uh
4:47 selling um they're buying billions of
4:49 dollars of of this stuff and it turns
4:52 out as you just had Bob Grifile on
4:54 before the break and he was reminding us
4:56 that 21 22% of the revenues of this
5:00 company are going into Singapore, 6
5:02 million people. What's 6 million people?
5:04 That's the size of Atlanta or Miami or
5:06 Philadelphia has 22%. Nobody's asking
5:08 questions. How could Philadelphia or
5:10 Atlanta Miami by 22% of the chips that
5:13 somebody should be asking those
5:15 questions about, you know, what this
5:17 what this place was, who they were and
5:19 uh and in government.
5:20 >> Uh well, that's it. That and that's sort
5:22 of the next thing I wanted to bring up
5:24 with you because that also raises the
5:25 question about what's going on within
5:26 the administration and specifically at
5:28 commerce as we continue to have more
5:30 reporting here. I mean the Biden
5:32 administration according to Wall Street
5:34 Journal launched investigations into
5:36 companies including Alice Wongs for
5:38 diverting US chips to China. Some of
5:40 those uh I think um moves and regulatory
5:44 steps seem to have been according to
5:46 reporting reversed under the current
5:47 commerce department. And even just last
5:49 night, you have Axios reporting that
5:51 Lutnik stalled in Trump's Nvidia China
5:53 chip curves after Oval talks. And
5:56 apparently others in the administration
5:58 uh going after Lutnik in recent days. To
6:01 me, it seems like this is actually
6:02 perhaps the larger story, especially if
6:04 Jensen Wong wasn't even ever briefed on
6:06 the fact that he was potentially
6:07 engaging with a spy, alleged spy.
6:09 >> Yeah. That he wasn't briefed and the
6:10 company wasn't briefed. Now, they didn't
6:12 do their due diligence. shame on them.
6:14 But that that the that the government
6:16 didn't tell them and President Trump
6:17 knew this and didn't tell them and that
6:19 for some reason he was excluded on that
6:21 trip back in May 15th through 17th uh to
6:24 goes to to China and he winds up hopping
6:27 on board in Alaska as a lastminute ad
6:29 because Trump had President Trump had
6:31 been briefed on this and uh that was
6:33 going on after a memo came out in March
6:36 uh of course with with Secretary of
6:38 State Marco Rubio and coming out of the
6:40 National Security Council that there
6:42 This this is a a problem. This is an
6:45 espionage ring happening here. Uh that's
6:47 out in March. And we have a shoutdown
6:48 that's widely reported on. Axios has it
6:51 out this morning with with six very
6:54 solid sources behind it. Nobody denying
6:56 it that Secretary of Treasury Scott
6:58 Besson had one of his famous or infamous
7:01 shoutdowns against with Howard Ludnik
7:03 that was coming close to fisticuffs.
7:05 Who's in the room with him? The attorney
7:07 general Todd Blanch. Who else is there?
7:09 The Secretary of State Marco Rubio. and
7:11 they are not on Secretary Ludnik's side.
7:13 I'm not sure who is right now other than
7:15 perhaps President Trump. You really got
7:17 to ask a question in terms of who's on
7:19 whose side there, who's on whose side in
7:20 the United States. This is not a
7:22 patriotic move to be funding these, you
7:25 know, diverting these highly sensitive
7:27 uh weapons uh artificial intelligence.
7:30 Artificial intelligence is now even
7:32 shockingly showing up in North Korean.
7:34 Now, we don't have Blackwell. Nobody's
7:36 discovering Blackwell chips in there or
7:37 even H200s, but even North Korea now has
7:39 guided missiles with uh that we're we're
7:42 seeing with with AI. If you were asking
7:44 this two months ago, weapons, people
7:46 would tell you, "Oh, no, North Korea
7:47 doesn't have it." They do. Not this
7:49 particular chip. U but this is a a huge
7:53 problem that's got to be asked. And and
7:54 we see that in the government. We
7:56 certainly have the the Senate Banking
7:58 Committee uh of all things is as Senator
8:02 Kramer and Elizabeth Warren uh feel that
8:04 this is their domain and they're asking
8:05 some tough questions and they are
8:06 calling for uh for of course for Jensen
8:09 Hong to to step down already. But it
8:11 goes into the domain of the the Senate
8:14 Intelligence Committee and and that is a
8:17 very strong committee. It's it's Tom
8:18 Cotton and Mark Warner who have very
8:21 different political views, but they
8:22 function as a team very very well. And
8:24 some of the best people in the Senate
8:26 are on the Democrats and Republicans on
8:28 that intelligence committee. We're
8:30 hearing and talking about, you know, the
8:31 House is going to get it together on the
8:33 18th. The Senate's already working on
8:34 it. These are a lot of investigations.
8:36 So, it was impossible for a CEO to even
8:39 if he were being exonerated that he
8:41 couldn't do his job with all these
8:42 investigations taking place. And
8:44 >> there's so much here.
8:46 >> So, yeah, so much. There are some good
8:48 people in there though that the sec the
8:49 chief financial officer, she's terrific.
8:52 I think you know Colette Crest could be
8:54 a fantastic leader here and and the guy
8:56 who actually created you know a lot of
8:58 people wonder about the this the the
9:00 software behind it the Koopa software it
9:02 really it came from a guy who's u Ian
9:05 Bach who's very talented they could be a
9:07 great pairing
9:08 >> he's the u uh the guy really in charge
9:10 of uh you know the key relationships
Jim Cramer on interim Nvidia CEO: 'I like Colette very much,' 'will provide needed order' full transcript
0:00 OVER FOR YOU. YOU TAKE OVER FOR
0:01 ME, ANDREW. IT'S ALL HIS FAULT
0:05 IN THE FIRST PLACE, I THINK WE
0:06 HAD IT WORSE. I KNOW, I KNOW,
0:08 HIS IMMUNE SYSTEM IS LIKE A
0:10 ROCK. CHRIS, WE TALKED EARLIER.
0:13 IT'S HAPPENED. I GUESS.
0:16 >> IT DID.
0:16 >> IT'S SAD, ISN'T IT?
0:18 >> IS IT KIND OF. IT IS SAD. IT
0:20 IS TO SEE IT. IT'S I ICARUS, I
0:24 THINK. TOO CLOSE TO THE SUN
0:25 MAYBE. RIGHT.
0:27 >> YEAH. I MEAN, SOMEONE WHO'S
0:28 BEEN, YOU KNOW, SO IMPORTANT TO
0:30 THE INDUSTRY, THIS IS THIS IS
0:32 NOT HOW YOU WANT IT TO END. BUT
0:35 IT'S AS YOU SAID, IT'S NOT A
0:37 SURPRISE THIS MORNING AT THIS
0:38 POINT.
0:41 >> ANDREW.
0:42 >> HEY, I JUST I THINK WE WANT
0:44 TO JUST BRING JIM CRAMER INTO
0:46 THIS CONVERSATION AS WELL. I
0:48 THINK WE CAN GET HIM ON THE
0:49 LINE. HE, OF COURSE, HAS BEEN A
0:51 LONG TIME SUPPORTER OF THIS
0:52 STOCK AND OF JENSEN. AND WHAT'S
0:54 YOUR REACTION.
0:56 >> WELL LOOK I THINK IT HAD TO
0:58 HAPPEN. I THINK THAT THERE'S
0:59 WAY TOO MUCH EVIDENCE. I THINK
1:01 THAT HE'S BEEN NEGOTIATING FOR
1:02 A BIT OBVIOUSLY TO TRY TO
1:03 FIGURE OUT WHERE TO GO. LOOK I
1:05 LIKE COLETTE VERY MUCH. COLETTE
1:06 KRESS, I CLOSE TO HER SPOKE TO
1:08 HER, I DON'T KNOW, HUNDREDS OF
1:10 TIMES, AND I THINK SHE'S GOING
1:12 TO BE TERRIFIC AT TRYING TO
1:13 FIGURE OUT WHERE THE PIECES ARE.
1:15 I KNOW ALL THE ANALYSTS HAVE TO
1:17 CUT AND RUN. THEY ALL THINK
1:18 THAT THERE'S 42,000 OTHER
1:19 PEOPLE THERE WHO HAVE
1:20 ABSOLUTELY NO BEARING
1:21 WHATSOEVER BECAUSE OF THE WAY
1:22 THE COMPANY SET THE WAS SET UP
1:24 BY JENSEN. I THINK THAT'S JUST
1:25 NOT TRUE. DO I WANT TO BUY THE
1:27 STOCK RIGHT NOW? WHO THE HELL
1:29 KNOWS WHAT THE STOCK IS? BUT I
1:31 DO THINK THE COLETTE AT LEAST
1:32 KNOWS HOW TO RUN. HAS BEEN THE
1:34 PERSON WHO'S BEEN THE
1:35 SPOKESPERSON FOR THE COMPANY
1:36 FOR A VERY LONG TIME, AND I
1:38 THINK SHE'LL PROVIDE SOME
1:39 NEEDED ORDER. SO I'M GLAD THAT
1:40 SHE'S THE ONE THAT THEY'VE
1:41 GIVEN IT TO.
1:43 >> WHEN YOU THINK ABOUT WHERE
1:44 THE STOCK IS RIGHT NOW, JIM,
1:46 WE'RE AT ABOUT 156 BUCKS.
1:49 >> COULD THIS BE. I THINK IT'S
1:51 GOING TO BE DOWN 10%. IT SHOULD
1:53 BE DOWN 10%, MAYBE 15. THESE
1:54 ANALYSTS. ALL RIGHT. THEY'RE
1:55 YOU KNOW, THEY'RE RATS ON A
1:56 SINKING SHIP. THEY WANT IT OUT
1:58 REALLY BADLY.
1:59 >> CHRIS CASO JOINED US THIS
2:00 MORNING. AND HE'S HERE AGAIN
2:01 JIM. AND HE ACTUALLY SAID WITH
2:03 OR WITHOUT JENSEN THIS IS A
2:04 BIAS. HE SEES IT AT THIS POINT.
2:06 >> WELL YOU KNOW LOOK, I
2:07 UNDERSTAND THAT. I JUST THINK
2:09 THAT THERE'S A LOT OF
2:10 INVESTIGATIONS THAT HAVE TO
2:11 OCCUR. THEY REPORT NEXT WEEK. I
2:13 THINK IT'S A REALLY GOOD
2:15 QUARTER. THEY CAN GUIDE UP IF
2:16 COLETTE, WHO IS REALLY THE
2:17 KEEPER OF EVERYTHING, INCLUDING
2:18 THE MONEY, SAYS, LOOK, WE CAN
2:20 DO A BIG BUYBACK. THAT'S ONE
2:21 THING. IF THEY HAVE A GUY I
2:23 THINK PROBABLY HAVE TO GO
2:24 OUTSIDE NOW, BECAUSE WHO KNOWS
2:25 HOW MANY PEOPLE KNEW ABOUT
2:27 KIMBERLY POWELL, WHICH IS A
2:28 REALLY BIG PROBLEM BECAUSE SHE
2:29 DID REPORT DIRECTLY TO HIM.
2:30 HEALTH CARE. BUT AS FAR AS I'M
2:32 CONCERNED, IT'S A NEW DAY AND
2:34 WE HAVE TO SEE WHAT A COMPANY
2:36 THAT HAS 42,000 PEOPLE WHO ARE
2:37 PROBABLY TO SOME DEGREE
2:38 INSULTED THAT THEY DON'T SEEM
2:40 TO MATTER, CAN DO THINGS. THIS
2:42 COMPANY IS NOT MADE UP OF
2:43 DOOFUSES. IT'S MADE UP OF
2:44 REALLY BRILLIANT PEOPLE. AND I
2:46 THINK THAT JENSEN PROBABLY PUT
2:47 THEM TOGETHER.
2:50 >> ALL RIGHT. AND IF I CAN,
2:52 LET'S LET CHRIS GO. CHRIS, ANY
2:54 FINAL COMMENTS BEFORE WE
3:00 AGAIN, REMEMBER THE SILVER
3:01 LINING HERE IS THE INDUSTRY IS
3:03 IN IS IN DEEP, DEEP SHORTAGE
3:05 RIGHT NOW. SO, YOU KNOW, NVIDIA
3:07 SOLD OUT THROUGH THE END OF
3:09 NEXT YEAR. THE ROADMAP IS SET
3:11 THAT THAT CERTAINLY HELPS TO
3:13 AVOID ANY, YOU KNOW SHORT TERM
3:20 GET TO REPLACE. JENSEN. I AGREE
3:22 WITH JIM THAT COLETTE IS GOING
3:23 TO BE A VERY GOOD INTERIM
3:26 REPLACEMENT. AND, YOU KNOW,
3:28 IT'S SORT OF LIKE THE APPLE
3:29 STEVE JOBS MOMENT. YOU KNOW
3:30 THAT THERE'S GOING TO BE
3:32 SOMEBODY NEW. THAT'S NOT JENSEN.
3:33 BUT
Nvidia shareholders want CEO Jensen Huang to stay: Intelligent Alpha's Clinton full transcript
0:00 PLANNING TO RAISE AT LEAST $4
0:02 BILLION THROUGH AN INVESTMENT
0:03 GRADE LOAN OFFERING. IT COULD
0:05 HIT THE MARKET AS SOON AS NEXT
0:07 WEEK. JOE.
0:09 >> ALL RIGHT. THANKS, ANDREW.
0:10 SHARES OF NVIDIA SLIDING THE
0:13 CHIP MAKER CONSIDERS THE FATE
0:15 OF CEO JENSEN HUANG AFTER
0:17 REPORTS OF ANOTHER AFFAIR, THIS
0:19 TIME WITH A COMPANY EXECUTIVE.
0:20 JOINING US NOW IS DOUG CLINTON,
0:22 INTELLIGENT ALPHA FOUNDER AND
0:24 CEO. I DON'T KNOW WHERE YOU
0:26 WERE WAITING WAITING IN THE
0:27 WINGS. I DON'T KNOW IF YOU
0:29 HEARD OUR PROFESSOR FROM THE
0:30 UNIVERSITY OF CHICAGO EARLIER.
0:32 I DON'T WANT TO PUT WORDS IN
0:33 HIS MOUTH. AND I'M GOING TO
0:35 OVERLY SIMPLIFY WHAT HE SAID,
0:37 BUT HIS VIEW WAS THAT YOU COULD
0:40 ALMOST GET PAST THE SPY, YOU
0:42 KNOW, BEING SORT OF CLUELESS.
0:45 AND IF HE DIDN'T DO ANYTHING
0:47 WRONG OR CHANGE HIS BEHAVIOR,
0:49 HE JUST GOT HONEY TRAPPED FOR
0:51 WHATEVER REASON. THAT'S NOT A
0:52 BIG DEAL. BUT THE HR ISSUE,
0:55 BECAUSE SHE REPORTS TO HIM IN
0:58 THE CURRENT WORLD THAT WE LIVE
1:00 IN, IS ACTUALLY A BIGGER DEAL.
1:02 HOWEVER, HE'S SO IMPORTANT TO
1:05 SHAREHOLDER VALUE THAT HE KIND
1:07 OF INSINUATED THE COMPANY COULD
1:09 MAKE AN EXCEPTION BECAUSE OF
1:11 HIS WORTH TO THE COMPANY. MAYBE
1:13 LOOK THE OTHER WAY ON THE AND
1:15 HE I DON'T WANT TO I DON'T WANT
1:17 TO TELL YOU WHAT MY OWN
1:18 FEELINGS ARE BECAUSE I. PEOPLE
1:20 SAY, OH, WHAT A TERRIBLE PERSON
1:22 I AM FOR NOT, YOU KNOW, NOT
1:24 IMMEDIATELY THINKING ARKO HR
1:25 ISSUES ARE SO IMPORTANT, BUT I.
1:27 IT ALMOST MADE SENSE TO ME THAT
1:29 HE'S SO IMPORTANT THAT. ALL
1:31 RIGHT, SHE REPORTED. IS THERE
1:33 ANY WAY THEY GET AROUND DOING
1:34 THAT OR. NO, I GUESS NOT
1:36 PROBABLY.
1:36 >> I THINK THERE'S A WAY, JOE.
1:38 AND I'LL SAY THE UNCOMFORTABLE
1:39 THING.
1:40 >> ARE YOU A SHAREHOLDER? I'M
1:41 NOT GOING TO.
1:42 >> AND I WOULD LIKE JENSEN TO
1:43 STAY. DESPITE ALL OF.
1:44 >> THIS, YOU'VE GOT A BETTER
1:46 VOTE THAN ANY OF THE REST OF US
1:48 DO.
1:48 >> AND I THINK ULTIMATELY
1:50 THAT'S THE THING THAT REALLY
1:51 MATTERS. IF YOU ASK ALMOST ANY
1:52 NVIDIA SHAREHOLDER, WHAT DO YOU
1:53 THINK THE COMPANY SHOULD DO?
1:55 THEY WILL ALMOST UNIVERSALLY
1:56 TELL YOU THAT THEY WANT JENSEN
1:57 TO REMAIN THE CEO. NOW, TO YOUR
1:59 POINT, JOE, EARLIER PRECEDENT,
2:00 WE LOOK BACK THE LAST TEN YEARS,
2:02 THERE WERE TEN CASES OF A HIGH
2:03 LEVEL EXECUTIVE AT A FORTUNE
2:05 100 COMPANY HAVING ONE OF THESE
2:06 ISSUES. NINE OUT OF TEN DID END
2:08 UP GETTING PUSHED OUT. SO
2:09 THERE'S PRECEDENT, BUT THEY'RE
2:10 NOT. JENSEN, THE CEO OF BEST
2:13 BUY, WAS THE ONE THAT THERE WAS
2:16 AN INVESTIGATION WE NEVER HEARD
2:17 THE RESULTS.
2:17 >> OF IT. IS THAT THE ONE.
2:19 >> I BELIEVE IT WAS BEFORE.
2:21 >> OH, BEFORE. YEAH. I
2:22 SHOULDN'T SAY THAT. YEAH. I
2:23 LOOKED AT IT. YEAH. NO IT WAS
2:25 HE MADE IT. MAYBE HE TOOK OVER
2:27 FOR THE PERSON.
2:28 >> BUT I THINK, YOU KNOW, THE
2:29 LONGER THE BOARD SORT OF WAITS
2:31 HERE, I ACTUALLY THINK THE ODDS
2:32 OF JENSEN STAYING ARE HIGHER
2:33 AND HIGHER. THE EASIEST TIME TO
2:35 GET HIM OUT, IF THAT'S
2:36 ULTIMATELY WHAT THEY WANT TO DO,
2:38 IS WHEN YOU'RE SORT OF AT PEAK
2:40 HYSTERIA.
2:40 >> I DON'T KNOW IF THE BOARD
2:42 WANTS TO GET HIM OUT. AND THE.
2:43 >> OTHER THING.
2:44 >> IS WE DON'T KNOW WHAT THE
2:46 BOARD KNOWS. HE DIDN'T KNOW
2:47 WHAT THE US.
2:48 >> BRYAN DUNN DID RESIGN. THIS
2:49 IS IN 2012 AMID A BROAD PROBE
2:51 INTO AN INAPPROPRIATE
2:52 RELATIONSHIP WITH A 29 YEAR OLD
2:53 FEMALE SUBORDINATE. SO BRYAN
2:54 DUNN DID. BUT THEN AND THEN IT
2:56 ALSO LED TO THE DEPARTURE OF
2:58 FOUNDER RICHARD SCHULZE,
2:58 BECAUSE HE DIDN'T ALERT THE
3:00 BOARD WHEN HE FIRST LEARNED OF
3:01 THAT RELATIONSHIP. SO I DON'T.
3:03 >> IT IS TOUGH. I THINK THAT
3:05 RELATIONSHIP IS ACTUALLY HARDER
3:07 THAN THE FIRST ONE YOU DO. I DO
3:10 JUST BECAUSE AGAIN, YOU GO TO.
3:12 SO WHAT ARE THE PRECEDENT.
3:13 >> AND WHAT DO YOU PUT IT AT?
3:15 YOU STILL PUT IT AT 80%, HE
3:17 GOES OR WHAT?
3:17 >> BEFORE, YOU KNOW, ON MONDAY
3:19 WE THOUGHT, OKAY, MAYBE IT'S
3:20 20% THAT HE GETS PUSHED OUT.
3:22 WHEN WE HEARD THE NEW
Nvidia Spy Scandal, Nationwide Ground Stop Lifted, Starship’s Longest Test Flight full transcript
0:02 DAVID: COMING UP ON "BLOOMBERG THIS WEEKEND," THE NATIONWIDE
0:06 GROUND STOPS LIFTED. THE MESS REMAINS.
0:09 >> DOES THAT MEAN EVERY FLIGHT IS GOING TO FLY?
0:12 RIGHT NOW, IT IS GOING TO BE SLOW.
0:14 IT WILL TAKE US SOME TIME TO UNWIND WHAT HAS HAPPENED.
0:19 DAVID: WHAT THE SECRETARY OF HOMELAND SECURITY AND
0:20 TRANSPORTATION SAY IF THEY NEED TO KEEP THE SKIES SAFE.
0:25 CHRISTINA: PLUS, PRESIDENT TRUMP PREPARES TO HEAD TO CHINA AS THE
0:32 NVIDIA CRISIS EXPLODES. >> THEY WERE IN FAVOR OF PUTTING
0:37 MEGASPEED ON THE ENTITY LIST FOR MONTHS, BUT COMMERCE HAS --
0:43 DAVID: AND A SETBACK FOR SPACEX AS IT TRIES TO MAKE THE WORLD'S
0:47 FIRST FULLY REASONABLE ROCKET. IT CAN IT BRING THE REST OF THE
0:50 SPACECRAFT BACK TO EARTH SAFELY? CHRISTINA: HAPPY SATURDAY.
0:59 WELCOME TO "BLOOMBERG THIS WEEKEND."
1:04 NEW YORK. I AM USING THE ROUBINI.
1:10 DAVID: I AM DAVID GURA ALONGSIDE LISA MATEO.
1:11 WELCOME TO OUR LISTENERS AND VIEWERS ACROSS OUR BLOOMBERG
1:15 PLATFORMS, STREAMING ON BLOOMBERG RADIO.
1:22 HELLO TO THE WEARY TRAVELERS FROM NEWARK.
1:24 I'VE BEEN THERE, WATCHING BLOOMBERG FROM THE GATE.
1:27 CHRISTINA: FOR OUR VISUAL VIEWERS, WE HAVE A SOMEWHAT
1:31 CHEERY SUNRISE OVER ATLANTA, WHERE THINGS HOPEFULLY ARE
1:32 LOOKING UP FOR TRAVELERS. BUT WE THOUGHT WE KNEW WHAT OUR
1:36 STORE WAS GOING TO BE TODAY. WE WERE GOING TO BREAK DOWN THE
1:41 WARS, TALK ABOUT JENSEN HUANG, NVIDIA.
1:43 THEN AROUND 5:00, ALL OF OUR PHONES STARTED BLOWING UP.
1:46 I DO NOT KNOW ABOUT YOU. EVERY FRIEND I'VE EVER KNOWN AS
1:48 WHAT IS GOING ON WITH THE AIRPLANES?
1:53 DAVID: NATIONWIDE GROUND STOP IN THE 4:00 OR 5:00 HOUR FOR FOUR
1:56 HOURS. FIRST, LET'S GO TO LISA MATEO
1:59 FOR A CHECK ON THAT. LISA: THE TRUMP REGISTRATION --
2:06 ADMINISTRATION IS ASKING FOR EMERGENCY FUNDING TO HELP UPDATE
2:10 THE AIR TRAFFIC CONTROL SYSTEM. THAT FOUR HOUR SHUT DISRUPTIVE
2:14 THOUSANDS OF FLIGHTS NATIONWIDE. THE FAA SAID IT WAS DUE TO A
2:19 DATA OVERLOAD THAT CRIPPLED AIR TRAFFIC CONTROL COMMUNICATIONS
2:21 AND RADAR. TRANSPORTATION SECRETARY SEAN
2:22 DUFFY -- >> WE HAVE TDM TELECOMS, SO THIS
2:29 IS ANALOG TELECOMS. OUR SWITCHES, ROUTERS GOT
2:31 OVERLOADED WITH DATA. WE WENT DOWN.
2:35 I SHOULD NOT SAY THEY WENT DOWN. THEY STARTED TO GIVE US
2:36 INCONSISTENCY IN THE DATA. LISA: AMERICAN AIRLINES AND
2:43 JETBLUE WARNED OF DELAYS INTO TODAY, WHILE OFFICIALS SAY THE
2:47 SYSTEMS WILL BE BACK TO NORMAL BEFORE THE THANKSGIVING HOLIDAY.
2:50 LAST NIGHT, THIS TRAVEL IN DALLAS WAS HOPING TO MAKE IT IN
2:52 TIME FOR A SPECIAL FAMILY EVENT. >> MY DAUGHTER IS GETTING
2:58 MARRIED TOMORROW, SO WE ARE TRYING TO THINK ABOUT HOW WE CAN
3:00 GET THERE. HOPEFULLY THIS LETS UP.
3:03 LISA: HOPE SHE DOES. WHILE FLIGHTS WERE GROUNDED,
3:07 WHAT DID LAUNCH WAS SPACEX'S MASSIVE STARSHIP.
3:12 IT BLASTED OFF FROM THE STARBASE FACILITY IN TEXAS.
3:15 THE COMPANY IT HOPED TO PERFORM A DOUBLE CATCH OF BOTH HALVES OF
3:21 STARSHIP ON THIS FLIGHT, BUT IT CANCELED PLANS TO RETRIEVE THE
3:23 BOOSTER USING THOSE ABSTRACTS -- OUTSTRETCHED ARMS.
3:30 THE STARSHIP HOPES TO PERFORM A LANDING ON EARTH TODAY.
3:33 MIRACLE ON THE MISSISSIPPI AFTER ALL PASSENGERS AND CREW MEMBERS
3:36 WERE RESCUED FROM A RIVER CRUISE SHIP AFTER COLLIDING WITH A
3:38 TANQUERAY. THE ATLANTIC ASPHALT TANKER HAD
3:42 LOST CONTROL AND STRUCK THE AMERICAN HERITAGE RIVER CRUISE
3:45 FRIDAY AFTERNOON AT THE PORT OF NEW ORLEANS.
3:47 THE CREW SHOULD BEGAN TO SHIP BEFORE TIPPING OVER, SENDING
3:48 PASSENGERS INTO THE MISSISSIPPI RIVER.
3:53 THE SEARCH CONTINUES FOR A SUCCESSOR TO FORMER NVIDIA CEO
3:56 JENSEN HUANG COPTER BEING OUSTED FOR REPORTS OF MULTIPLE
3:59 EXTRAMARITAL AFFAIRS. BLOOMBERG CAME OUT WITH A LIST
4:06 OF EXECUTIVES LIKELY AS INTERIM CEO COLETTE KRESS --
4:14 POSITION. ARM HAS A CLOSE PARTNERSHIP WITH
4:21 NVIDIA AND HAAS IS A FORMER NVIDIA EXECUTIVE.
4:24 AND THERE'S ALSO AMD CEO LISA SU, WHO HAPPENS TO BE JENSEN
4:27 HUANG'S COUSIN. AND PRESIDENT TRUMP HAS FLOATED
4:33 THE IDEA OF NVIDIA HIRING FORMER APPLE CEO TIM COOK.
4:35 THERE ARE A FEW MORE NAMES OF COMPANIES, LIKE AMAZON WEB
4:40 SERVICES, MICRON, GOOGLE AS WELL.
4:41 CHECK OUT THE TERMINAL FOR THAT COMPLETE LIST.
4:45 DAVID: I FORGET THE LINE FROM THE PRESIDENT ON THE LEDGE
4:47 LEGEND OR SOMETHING LIKE THAT. CHRISTINA: HAS ANYONE ASKED TIM
4:49 COOK? MAYBE HE IS ENJOYING RETIREMENT.
4:54 LISA, THANK YOU SO MUCH. FIRST, WE WILL BEGIN WITH WHAT
4:57 EVERYBODY IS TALKING ABOUT. THE DEVELOPING STORY AT AMERICAN
5:01 AIRPORTS. NATIONWIDE HALT IN AIR TRAVEL AT
5:03 A SCALE NOT SEEN SINCE SEPTEMBER 11.
5:08 DAVID: THE FAA CALLED IT A TEMPORARY TELECOMMUNICATIONS
5:08 ISSUE, NOT A SECURITY INCIDENT. BUT THE CHAOS LEFT TRAVELERS
5:15 SCRAMBLING. SOME 16,000 FLIGHTS DELAYED OR
5:18 CANCELED FRIDAY, WITH THOUSANDS MORE CANCELED TODAY.
5:20 JOINING US NOW IS GEORGE FERGUSON, SENIOR AIRLINES
5:25 ANALYST AT BLOOMBERG INTELLIGENCE.
5:26 LET ME START WITH A BIT OF TAPE. THIS IS FROM THE PRESS
5:28 CONFERENCE THAT TOOK PLACE LAST NIGHT.
5:32 THE SECRETARY OF HOMELAND SECURITY TALKING ABOUT WHAT
5:33 HAPPENED. >> THEY WERE PUTTING NEW
5:36 EQUIPMENT AND NEW TECHNOLOGY, AND THAT NEW EQUIPMENT, NEW
5:40 TECHNOLOGY, IT WAS OVERWHELMING THE OLDER SYSTEM.
5:43 WHICH IS WHY SECRETARY DUFFY MADE IT VERY CLEAR.
5:45 THE PATCHWORK DOES NOT WORK. WE NEED ONE COMPLETE SYSTEM.
5:51 DAVID: LET ME JUST HAVE YOU PARSE WHAT WE HEARD FROM THE
5:55 SECRETARY, TALKING ABOUT PATCHES, NEW TECHNOLOGY.
5:56 WHAT DO YOU MAKE OF WHAT HAPPENED?
5:59 HOW HOLISTIC OF AN UNDERSTANDING DO WE HAVE OF WHAT HAPPENED
6:00 FRIDAY? GEORGE: WE HAVE A VERY SMALL
6:05 UNDERSTANDING AT THIS POINT. BUT WE KNOW THERE IS A LARGE
6:11 AMOUNT OF LEGACY SYSTEMS, THAT U.S. AIR CONTROL SYSTEM, AND IT
6:13 WILL BE VERY DIFFICULT TO GET A SINGLE FIXED.
6:19 YOU HAVE TO CONTINUALLY LAY IT INTO AN EXISTING SYSTEM, SO YOU
6:21 CAN KEEP AIR TRAVEL GOING. IT IS A CONSTANT JOB.
6:29 IT WILL BE A CHALLENGE IF YOU GET ONE BIG $40 BILLION, 50
6:36 BILLION DOLLARS TO UPDATE IT RIGHT AWAY.
6:37 THESE SYSTEMS CONTINUE. SOUNDS LIKE THEY LAID NEW
6:42 EQUIPMENT THAT IS NOT MUTATING CORRECTLY WITH OLD COMMUNITY.
6:45 THANK GOODNESS THEY FOUND HER BEFORE THANKSGIVING WEEKEND,
6:47 BECAUSE IT WILL GET EVEN BUSIER. I AM KIND OF SURPRISED THAT IS
6:49 BREAKING DOWN HERE. CHRISTINA: I WANT TO ASK ABOUT
6:53 THE TIMING OF THIS. I HAVE TWO QUESTIONS.
6:56 ONE IS NOBODY KNEW THERE COULD BE AN INHERENT RISK UPDATING
7:00 JUST HALF OF THE SYSTEM WHEN SO MUCH OF IT IS OLD, ANALOG, STILL
7:02 COPPER WIRE? I WAS TALKING TO SOMEBODY LAST
7:08 NIGHT THAT OF COURSE YOU ARE OUTPUTTING SOME SORT OF
7:10 TRANSLATOR BETWEEN THOSE TWO SYSTEMS, WILL OVERWHELM IT.
7:13 HOW DID THEY NOT KNOW THIS WAS A RISK BEFOREHAND, AND WHY WOULD
7:15 THEY BE DOING THESE UPGRADES IN THE MIDDLE OF A FRIDAY AHEAD OF
7:16 A TRAVEL WEEKEND? GEORGE: THAT IS A QUESTION I'VE,
7:19 TOO. I WOULD EXPECT THEM TO BE DURING
7:26 THIS DURING THE WEE HOURS OF THE MORNING ON A MONDAY OR SOMETHING
7:28 LIKE THAT, WHERE YOU HAVE MINIMAL AIR TRAVEL.
7:33 BUT CLEARLY THEY ARE TRYING THIS AT PEAK HOURS, OR AT LEAST THE
7:38 EFFECTS NOT FELT IN PEAK HOURS. THESE ARE VERY COMPLEX SYSTEMS,
7:43 WITH REDUNDANCIES BUILT IN. I THINK THEY WOULD HAVE -- IT IS
7:51 ALWAYS HARD TO KNOW ALL OF THE RAMIFICATIONS IN THE SYSTEM.
7:56 SOMETIMES EVEN THE SYSTEMS ARE NOT AROUND ANYMORE AND THERE IS
7:59 NOT ANY COMPLETE DOCUMENTATION CARE THAT CAN BE A PROBLEM.
8:04 DAVID: I REMEMBER AFTER THAT MIDAIR COLLISION OVER NATIONAL
8:06 AIRPORT, A LOT OF IMPULSE FOR THE SAKE GET TAKEN CARE OF MORE
8:08 QUICKLY. THERE HAVE BEEN A LOT OF TALK
8:11 ABOUT MODERNIZING THE SYSTEM. I THOUGHT WE WERE WELL ON THE
8:13 WAY OF THAT HAPPENING. WHAT IS THE STATUS SINCE WE HEAR
8:17 THE TRANSPORTATION SECRETARY TALK ABOUT THE NEED FOR $50
8:20 BILLION TO DO ALL IT? WHAT ACCOUNTS FOR THE HOLD UP?
8:25 GEORGE: AGAIN, YOU GOT TO BUILD IT INTO A SYSTEM WORKING TODAY.
8:29 YOU CANNOT SHUT THE SYSTEM DOWN TO REJUVENATE THE WHOLE THING.
8:32 THE CHALLENGE IS HOW DO YOU BUILD NEW, BETTER SYSTEMS INTO
8:36 OLD EXISTING SYSTEMS AND NOT HURT SAFETY?
8:41 I THINK THEY ARE CONSTANTLY MAKING IMPROVEMENTS TO THE
8:43 NETWORK. TECHNOLOGY HAS COME A LONG WAY,
8:47 AND AIR TRAVEL CONTINUES TO GROW 3%, 4% A YEAR.
8:52 THE BURDEN WILL CONTINUE. MY SENSE IS WE ARE BEHIND THE
8:55 CURVE, AND WE PROBABLY NEED TO SPEND MORE MONEY.
9:01 MORE EFFORT TO GET OUT OF THE CURVE.
9:02 A LOT OF TIMES WHAT I FIND TODAY IS IT IS NOT EVEN THE MONEY, IT
9:05 IS THAT PROFESSIONALS TO GET THE WORK DONE, LABORERS TO GET THE
9:11 WORK DONE, THEY ARE TO HANG UP, BECAUSE IT IS HARD TO FIND THEM.
9:13 EVERYTHING COSTS MORE. EVERYTHING TAKES LONGER.
9:16 I SUSPECT THE FAA IS FINDING THAT SAME THING.
9:20 THEY NEED TO REDOUBLE EFFORTS TO GET AHEAD OF THE CURVE.
9:24 CHRISTINA: IF YOU ARE TRAVELING WERE ARE INSPIRING -- OR WERE
9:31 ASPIRING TO TRAVEL YESTERDAY, THE TRANSPORTATION SECRETARY
9:33 SAID WE WILL ARRANGE THE CRUISE AND FLIGHTS AND HAVE AS MANY OF
9:35 THEM TAKE OFF AS WE CAN GET HOW MUCH CONTROL DOES THE FEDERAL
9:38 GOVERNMENT HAVE OVER THAT? ISN'T A LOT OF IT, IF NOT ALL OF
9:43 IT COME UP TO THE AIRLINES? GEORGE: I HAVE NOT SEEN THE SIZE
9:47 OF THE STAFF OF IT BUT I THINK THAT STAFF AT THE AIRLINES ARE
9:52 MUCH LARGER. AMERICAN, DELTA, UNITED,
9:55 JETBLUE, THEY ARE SOME OF THE BEST CARRIERS IN THE WORLD AND
9:58 THEY KNOW HOW TO HANDLE THESE KINDS OF INTERRUPTIONS.
10:00 I THINK IT IS REALLY FALLING ON THEM.
10:02 I THINK HE USED SORT OF THEROYAL "US," BUT MY GUESS IS
10:07 IT IS ALL FALLING ON THE AIRLINES.
10:09 THEY ARE SMART, PROFESSIONAL FOLKS WHO GET IT DONE.
10:11 CHRISTINA: GEORGE FERGUSON, THANK YOU FOR LAST MINUTE
10:14 AVAILABILITY. I KNOW YOU WERE -- WE WERE
10:16 BUGGING YOU LAST NIGHT. DAVID: WE WILL CONTINUE TO TRACK
10:21 THIS. THE OTHER BIG STORY, NVIDIA.
10:24 TECH STOCKS CONTINUED THEIR SLIDE IN THE WAKE OF NVIDIA CEO
10:29 JENSEN HUANG'S RESIGNATION GIVEN NASDAQ LOST MORE THAN 1% FRIDAY
10:34 WITH THE S&P DOWN 0.5%. MUCH OF THIS WAS DRIVEN BY
10:36 NVIDIA'S PLUNGE. THAT COMPANY'S STOCK DOWN 12% ON
10:42 THE WII, 30% OVER THE COURSE OF THE LAST MONTH, ALL OF THE
10:46 ANNOUNCING -- AMOUNTING TO $2 TRILLION RAISED.
10:51 CHRISTINA: NVIDIA NAMED AN INTERIM CEO.
10:54 JOINING US NOW COME ALSO AN EARLY VOLUNTEER FOR THE 7:00
10:59 HOUR, MIKE SHEPARD, BLOOMBERG'S SENIOR EDITOR FOR TECHNOLOGY AND
11:00 SENIOR INDUSTRIES. I DID NOT REALLY KNOW WHERE TO
11:02 START. I GUESS I WANT TO START WITH
11:07 HOUSE -- HAS THE BOARD DONE ENOUGH TO CALM INVESTORS?
11:10 IT SOUNDS LIKE EVERYBODY I RAN INTO THIS WEEK WAS TALKING ABOUT
11:13 WHAT THIS WAS GOING TO DO FOR THE COMPANY, THE STOCK, MARKETS
11:14 AS A WHOLE? MIKE: THIS IS A GREAT QUESTION
11:18 TO START WITH. THERE HAS BEEN A HUGE -- PEOPLE
11:22 HAVE BEEN WONDERING, IS THIS BOARD UP TO THE TASK OF A
11:23 CRISIS? BECAUSE IT IS LARGELY A GROUP OF
11:28 INSIDERS AND PEOPLE WHO HAVE KNOWN JENSEN IN THE COMPANY FOR
11:30 SO LONG. THEY HAVE STEPPED IN AND DONE
11:36 JUST ABOUT EVERYTHING THEY CAN. REALLY SINCE SUNDAY, WHEN JENSEN
11:39 HUANG ADMITTED TO THE AFFAIR, AND THE BOARD SAID IT WOULD BE
11:41 LAUNCHING AN INVESTIGATION RIGHT AWAY.
11:45 THEY MOVED QUICKLY TO ENGAGE IN OUTSIDE LAW FIRM.
11:49 AS FURTHER RESIGNATION -- REVELATIONS TUMBLED IN, THEY
11:53 WORKED QUICKLY TO OUST JENSEN HUANG AS CEO AND ELEVATE CFO
11:57 COLETTE KRESS AS THE INTERIM CHIEF OF THE COMPANY.
12:02 BY DOING SO AND PUTTING KRESS IN PLACE, IT OFFERED REASSURANCE TO
12:05 INVESTORS. THEY KNOW HER.
12:09 SHE HAS BEEN IN THE POSITION FOR ABOUT 13 YEARS AS FINANCE CHIEF.
12:13 THEY KNOW HER FROM FREQUENT APPEARANCES AND CONFERENCE
12:15 CALLS, AND ALSO INDUSTRY GATHERINGS.
12:19 SHE PROVIDES SOME CONFIDENCE TO THE MARKET, AND ALSO TO THE REST
12:25 OF SILICON VALLEY, BECAUSE SHE WILL UNDERSTAND THE INTRICACIES
12:29 OF ALL THE COMPANY'S DEALMAKING. SHE WILL HAVE QUITE A LOAD ON
12:32 HER SHOULDERS, THOUGH, AS WE LOOK TO THEIR EARNINGS CALL NEXT
12:34 WEEK TUESDAY. THERE WILL BE A LOT RIDING ON
12:36 THAT. LESS SO IN THE NUMBERS BUT FAR
12:41 MORE SO ON WHAT SHE HAS TO SAY IN HER FIRST PUBLIC REMARKS AS
12:45 THE COMPANY'S NEW CHIEF. DAVID: CERTAINLY A PLUS SHE HAS
12:49 BEEN ON THOSE CALLS BEFORE. I WANT TO ASK ABOUT THE
12:51 CONTAGION. I WAS RATTLING OFF THOSE STATS
12:55 ABOUT THE WEEK. CANDIDLY, I AM A BIT SURPRISED
12:57 IT WAS NOT MORE WIDELY FELT THAN IT WAS.
12:59 IT IS SIMPLY THAT YOU HAVE NVIDIA'S COMPETITORS NOW LOOKING
13:03 AT THIS OPPORTUNISTICALLY? WHY DO YOU THINK THIS HAS NOT
13:07 HAD BROAD MARKET IMPACT? MIKE: PART OF IT IS THE BROAD
13:12 APPEAL OF ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE ITSELF.
13:15 YOU CAN SEE THE INITIAL PUBLIC OFFERING FOR ANTHROPIC IS
13:17 OVERSUBSCRIBED SIX TIMES. THAT GIVES YOU A SENSE OF THE
13:23 DEMAND FOR THE SOFTWARE PRODUCT. BY COROLLARY, THE UNDERLYING
13:28 INFRASTRUCTURE, THE HARDWARE THAT POWERS AI, THAT IS GOING TO
13:32 BE IN DEMAND FOR QUITE SOME TIME.
13:36 WHEN YOU LOOK AT NVIDIA, IT'S SOLD OUT, ESSENTIALLY, OF ITS
13:39 SUPPLY THROUGH 2028 CLEAR THAT JOE SIGNALS THERE IS DEMAND FOR
13:41 THE PRODUCT. AS FAR AS NVIDIA'S COMPETITORS
13:45 GO, THIS CREATES AN OPENING FOR THEM.
13:50 THEY FINALLY WILL BE ABLE TO GET IN A WORD EDGEWISE WITH THE REST
13:53 OF THE MARKET NOW THAT JENSEN HUANG, WHO HAS BEEN A REAL
13:57 EVANGELIST AND SALESMAN OR HIS COMPANY'S -- FOR HIS COMPANY'S
14:03 PRODUCTS, THEY WILL BE ABLE TO GET ATTENTION FOR THEIRS.
14:08 AND BROADCOM AND GOOGLE HAVE BEEN TRYING TO DEVELOP COMPETING
14:09 PRODUCTS. THEN OF COURSE AMD, LISA SU AT
14:14 THE HELM THERE, THEY ARE COMPANY'S SHARES HAVE RISEN SO
14:18 MUCH IN THE OPENING. THEY ARE REALLY TRYING TO MOVE
14:21 INTO THIS AREA OF AI CHIPS AS WELL, AND THEY HAD BEEN GAINING
14:24 SOME GROUND ON A VIDEO. BUT NVIDIA STILL REMAINS THE TOP
14:29 OF THE HEAP AND WILL BE THERE FOR QUITE SOME TIME.
14:33 AS FAR AS THE REST OF THE INDUSTRY AND ALL THE FINANCING,
14:36 THAT IS A QUESTION WE WILL HAVE TO LOOK AT MORE CLOSELY FURTHER
14:41 DOWN THE ROAD COME UP THEY HAVE NAMED A PERMANENT REPLACEMENT
14:43 FOR JENSEN HUANG. WE WILL HAVE TO SEE IF THE
14:48 PERSON HAS THE SAME THINGS AS AND FOR ALL THE CIRCULAR
14:50 FINANCING AND INVESTMENT WE HAVE SEEN IN THE HAS BEEN CRITICIZED
14:52 BY SOME, INCLUDING WALL STREET. CHRISTINA: WE TALK SO MUCH
14:56 ABOUT THE SINGULARTECH LEADERS AND HOW INTEGRAL THEY ARE TO
15:01 THESE BRANDS FOR YOU LOOK AT HOW APPLE DID MANAGE TO KEEP AN
15:04 IDENTITY AFTER STEVE JOBS. BUT WHEN YOU LOOK AT CEOS AND
15:08 MESSY PERSONAL LIVES, I DO NOT THINK JENSEN HUANG WAS HIGH UP
15:10 ON OUR LIST, WHEN YOU HAVE OTHER CHARACTERS -- ELON MUSK COMES TO
15:16 MIND, WITH THE SPACEX IPO'D FROM OF THE QUESTION WE ASKED WAS IF
15:20 SOMETHING HAPPENS TO HIM, WHAT HAPPENS TO THIS COMPANY?
15:24 DO COMPANIES NEED TO REEVALUATE AND ISOLATE THESE FIGURES FROM
15:26 THE VALUE OF A COMPANY OR PUT SOME SORT OF SEPARATION THERE SO
15:29 THIS IS NOT SUCH A RISK TO AN INDUSTRY THAT JUST HAS A FEW KEY
15:32 FIGURES I CAN MAKE SUCH A KEY DIFFERENCE IN THE INDUSTRY AND
15:33 MARKETS? MIKE: IT IS INTERESTING YOU ALSO
15:37 BROUGHT UP ELON MUSK. IN A WAY, ELON WITH SPACEX AND
15:48 TESLA, NVIDIA HAS BEEN SHAPED BY JENSEN HUANG, WHO FOUNDED THE
15:50 COMPANY 30 YEARS AGO. HE WAS, IN MANY WAYS, THE
15:54 COMPANY. HE HAD 60 PEOPLE REPORTING TO
15:57 HIM DIRECTLY. THEY ALL SAT IN THIS ROOM WITH
16:01 THIS CAN OPTICON FEEL TO IT, LOOKING TO HIM AND REPORTING TO
16:05 HIM AND CHECKING IN WITH HIM. ON ONE LEVEL, IT SOUNDS LIKE
16:08 MICROMANAGEMENT. ON ANOTHER, IT IS HIM MAKING
16:11 SURE THE COMPANY LOOKS EXACTLY THE WAY HE WANTS IT.
16:15 HE HAD NO INTENTION OF STEPPING DOWN HERE THE INTERVIEW HE DID
16:21 EMILY CHANG JUST A FEW WEEKS AGO, HE INDICATED HE WAS
16:23 PREPARED TO STAY ON THE JOB OR ANOTHER 20 YEARS AND THAT HE DID
16:27 NOT REALLY SEE A SUCCESSOR IN THE RANKS JUST YET.
16:30 BUT IT ALSO POINTS TO WHAT BOARDS NEED TO DO.
16:33 THE NVIDIA BOARD DID NOT EVEN HAVE A CHAIRMAN BEFORE THIS ALL
16:38 UNFOLDED, AND NOW THEY HAVE NAMED HARVEY JONES, ONE OF THE
16:42 LONGTIME DIRECTORS AS CHAIR, THERE -- THE FIRST CHAIR IN
16:47 THEIR HISTORY. HE IS SOMEONE WHO HAVE A TASK
16:51 AHEAD OF HIM IN TERMS OF ESTABLISHING THAT GOVERNMENTS WE
16:51 SEE AT OTHER FIRMS. DAVID: MIKE SHEPARD, SENIOR
16:56 EDITOR IN WASHINGTON, THANK YOU. 60 DIRECT REPORTS.
16:57 ONLY CHRISTINA HAS THAT MANY HERE AT BLOOMBERG.
17:01 CHRISTINA: I DO NOT EVEN REPORT TO MYSELF.
17:02 [LAUGHTER] YOU CERTAINLY DO NOT LISTEN TO
17:04 ME. [LAUGHTER]
17:09 DAVID: FASCINATING, THIS CORPORATE GOVERNANCE PART OF THE
17:10 STORY. BUT THE MOVES NVIDIA HAS MADE
17:14 HERE SINCE JENSEN HUANG HAS RESIGNED, REALLY INDICATING
17:15 PERHAPS THEY WILL TRY TO REMEDY WHAT HAS MADE THEM A POORLY LIT
17:23 -- POORLY-LOOKED AT BOARD FOR A LONG TIME.
17:26 CHRISTINA: AND IF THE STOCK IS STILL DOING WELL, DO YOU REALLY
17:27 WANT TO ENGAGE? DAVID: MIKE MENTIONING EMILY
17:32 CHANG'S INTERVIEW WITH JENSEN HUANG.
17:34 WE WILL TALK TO EMILY IN A BIT. COMING UP, A NEW OFFER AT ENDING
17:39 THE WAR BETWEEN RUSSIA AND UKRAINE, BUT WILL BOTH COUNTRIES
17:41 AND EUROPE ACCEPT THAT OFFER. HE WILL DISCUSS WITH BECCA
17:45 WASSER, STRAIGHT AHEAD. ♪
17:56 LISA: THANK YOU FOR JOINING US LIVE ON "BLOOMBERG THIS WEEKEND
17:57 ." MICROSOFT SAYS ACCESS HAS BEEN
18:02 FULLY RESTORED TO ITS FLAGSHIP SOFTWARE AFTER AN OUTAGE
18:05 AFFECTED GOVERNMENT OFFICES, TRADERS, AND BUSINESSES
18:07 WORLDWIDE. ACCORDING TO DOWN DETECTOR,
18:12 PEOPLE IN MORE THAN 70 COUNTRIES REPORTED PROBLEMS ACROSS
18:15 OUTLOOK, TEAMS, AND THE COPILOT AI TOOL.
18:17 IT HAPPENED DURING A NETWORK CAPACITY UPGRADE.
18:20 THE U.S. LOST ITS MEASLES ELIMINATION STATUS.
18:21 THE WALL STREET JOURNAL SAYS THE PAN-AMERICAN HEALTH ORGANIZATION
18:26 REVOKED AS OUTBREAKS CONTINUE TO RISE.
18:30 IN ORDER TO REGAIN THE STANDING, THE U.S. MUST STOP THE SPREAD OF
18:32 MEASLES FOR AT LEAST 12 MONTHS. THE NATIONAL ECONOMIC COUNCIL
18:38 DIRECTOR KEVIN HASSETT SAYS HE HAS NO PLANS TO LEAVE HIS POST
18:42 AS PRESIDENT TRUMP'S ECONOMIC ADVISOR.
18:45 IT COMES AFTER A REPORT THAT HE WAS LEAVING.
18:47 HE SAID HE JOKED ABOUT IT WITH THE PRESIDENT FRIDAY.
18:49 WHITE HOUSE OFFICIALS ALSO SAID THE REPORT WAS NOT TRUE.
18:54 SENATOR CHRIS VAN HOLLEN, WHO IS CHALLENGING SENATOR CHUCK
18:56 SCHUMER FOR THE POSITION OF DEMOCRATIC LEADER, SAYS
19:00 DEMOCRATIC -- DEMOCRATS MUST BREAK WITH BUSINESS AS USUAL.
19:05 THE DEMOCRATIC LEADER -- SENATOR FROM MARYLAND SPOKE WITH
19:06 REPORTERS. >> THE TRUST --
19:10 [INDISCERNIBLE] THAT IS WHY I DECIDED.
19:21 LISA: VAN HOLLEN SAYS HE KNOWS HE IS THE UNDERDOG IN THE RACE,
19:24 BUT HE SAID MANY OF HIS COLLEAGUES WON A DIFFERENT
19:26 APPROACH TO THE SENATE AND DEMOCRATIC CONGRESS -- CAUCUS.
19:30 DAVID: SO MUCH DEBATE. LEADERSHIP CORAL?
19:34 DEBATE? DISCUSSION?
19:38 CHRISTINA: A LOT OF OUR FRIENDS AND COLLEAGUES GOT STUCK IN
19:39 DENVER. DAVID: I WAS GOING TO SAY, THE
19:42 GROUND STOP. CHRISTINA: A LOT OF REPORTERS AT
19:46 DENVER. YOU THIS MORNING, UKRAINIAN
19:54 PRESIDENT ZELENSKYY SAID AMERICAN ENVOYS OFFERED A PEACE
19:56 TRAY THAT COULD POTENTIALLY MAKE THE COUNTRY A MEMBER OF NATO.
20:00 THE COST OF ADMISSION WOULD BE UKRAINE GIVING UP THE ENTIRE
20:01 DONBAS REGION TO RUSSIA. DAVID: THIS AFTER STEVE WITKOFF
20:06 AND JARED KUSHNER SPENT TIME IN MOSCOW WITH RUSSIAN PRESIDENT
20:09 PUTIN, THEN IN DUBLIN WITH PRESIDENT ZELENSKYY.
20:13 BECCA WASSER, BLOOMBERG'S DEFENSE LEAD, JOINS US NOW ON IF
20:17 THIS COULD LEAD TO A TRUCE. BECCA ALSO IN THE NEW YORK
20:21 TIMES. LET'S STICK WITH UKRAINE.
20:25 WHAT DO YOU MAKE OF THIS ANNOUNCEMENT?
20:29 WE DID HEAR FROM PRESIDENT ZELENSKYY.
20:31 HE SAID, QUOTE, IT WAS THE FIRST TIME THIS HAD BEEN RAISED.
20:35 WE ARE DISCUSSING IT WITH OUR PARTNERS.
20:37 A CONFERENCE OF SECURITY PACKAGE THAT COULD BE OFFERED TO US.
20:39 WHAT DO YOU MAKE OF THIS NEWS, AND DO YOU THINK YOU HAVE ANY
20:42 LIKELIHOOD OF COMING TO PASS? BECCA: I THINK UKRAINE HAS BEEN
20:47 LOOKING FOR A WIDE ARRAY OF SECURITY GUARANTEES IN A
20:49 POTENTIAL POSTWAR ENVIRONMENT, AND ONE OF THE ONES THAT HAS
20:52 BEEN VERY ESSENTIAL HAS BEEN THIS IDEA OF NATO MEMBERSHIP, OR
20:59 NATO-LIKE GUARANTEES. AT THE END OF THE DAY, NO MATTER
21:02 HOW THIS WAR ENDS, UKRAINE WILL NEED TO ENSURE ITS FUTURE
21:04 TERRITORIAL SOVEREIGNTY AND SECURITY AND STAVE OFF ANY
21:10 THREAT OF POTENTIAL FUTURE RUSSIAN AGGRESSION AGAIN.
21:15 REALLY, THAT IS SOMETHING THAT HAS BEEN TOP OF MIND FOR
21:17 PRESIDENT ZELENSKYY. BUT IT IS WORTH NOTING HE SAID
21:23 IT IS NOT HIS DECISION TO MAKE ALONE, TO ESSENTIALLY TRADE
21:29 UKRAINIAN TERRITORY, THE DONBAS, FOR SECURITY GUARANTEES.
21:31 IF YOU WOULD HAVE TO PUT THAT FORWARD TO THE UKRAINIAN PEOPLE.
21:35 ULTIMATELY, IT IS NOT ONLY UP TO THE UKRAINIAN PEOPLE WHETHER
21:38 THIS MOVES FORWARD, BUT TRULY IT IS ALSO UP TO WHAT HAPPENS RIGHT
21:42 NOW ON THE BATTLEFIELD IN UKRAINE AS ESSENTIALLY RUSSIA IS
21:49 TRYING TO SET THE CONDITIONS IT CAN SUE FOR PEACE AT THE
21:50 NEGOTIATING TABLE. CHRISTINA: HOW DO YOU HOLD A
21:54 REFERENDUM IN A COUNTRY AT WAR? THERE HAS NOT BEEN AN ELECTION
22:00 FOR THIS REASON WHEN THE COMBAT STARTED.
22:03 I REACHED OUT TO SOME DIPLOMATS IN DUBLIN.
22:06 ONE, THEY THOUGHT THE DONBAS WAS TOO BIG AN ASK.
22:11 THE OTHER WAS THAT NATO CANNOT AGREE TO ALLOW UKRAINE INTO ITS
22:14 TERRITORY WHILE IT IS STILL IN CONFLICT IN THE CURRENT
22:18 SITUATION. THIS IS ONE OF THE ARGUMENTS IN
22:21 THE BIDEN ADMINISTRATION. THEY KEPT PROMISING UKRAINE WILL
22:24 BECOME A MEMBER OF NATO. ON ITS FACE, EUROPEAN ALLIES
22:29 WERE WITH IT. BUT ARTICLE FIVE, YOU CANNOT
22:35 ADMIT A COUNTRY IN ACTIVE WAR. I DO NOT KNOW IF EUROPEANS WILL
22:39 GET ON BOARD WITH THIS. I WONDER WHAT YOUR TAKE IS?
22:43 BECCA: RUSSIA KNOWS ALL OF THIS AS WELL, THAT IS WHY IT IS
22:46 ENTERTAINING THIS DEAL, WHICH COULD FRANKLY END UP IN MOSCOW'S
22:49 FAVOR MORE THAN UKRAINE'S. BUT FOR EUROPE, IT IS A BIG
22:53 QUESTION. AND LET'S BE HONEST.
22:57 NATO IS NOT NECESSARILY IN LOCKSTEP.
23:00 IT IS NOT THIS SOLELY UNIFIED BRAIN THAT THINKS LIKE.
23:04 THESE ARE DIFFERENT NATIONS THAT HAVE DIFFERENT THREAT
23:09 PERCEPTIONS AND RISK TOLERANCES. IT WILL BE DIFFICULT TO GET ALL
23:15 NATO MEMBERS ON BOARD WITH EVERYTHING.
23:17 IT IS A PROPOSAL THAT IS NEW AND DIFFERENT AND IS SHOWING SOME
23:21 TYPE OF PROGRESS AT THE NEGOTIATING TABLE.
23:22 WHETHER IT IS REALISTIC AND WHETHER IT CAN BE ACHIEVED IS
23:27 THE OPEN QUESTION RIGHT HERE. HOWEVER, THESE DISCUSSIONS ARE
23:31 WORTH HAVING, BECAUSE UKRAINE IS COMING UP AT THE END OF ITS
23:34 FIFTH YEAR. AT THIS POINT, EVERYONE WANTS
23:36 THE CONFLICT TO END. BUT IT NEEDS TO END ON TERMS
23:43 THAT DO NOT COMPROMISE UKRAINE'S SOVEREIGNTY, AS WELL AS EUROPEAN
23:44 SECURITY ARCHITECTURE. DAVID: I WOULD LIKE YOUR
23:48 OBSERVATIONS OF THE SHUTTLE DIPLOMACY TAKING PLACE HERE, LED
23:51 BY JARED KUSHNER AND STEVE WITKOFF.
23:57 ASIDE FROM JARED KUSHNER DRESSING AN APPROPRIATE WAY FOR
24:00 THE WEATHER IN RUSSIA. WHEN THE SNOW IS FALLING ON THE
24:02 TARMAC. ?
24:04 WHAT YOU MAKE OF THESE TALKS? DO THEY SHOW SIGNS OF BEARING
24:07 FRUIT? WHAT ARE YOU WATCHING FOR AS
24:11 THIS CONTINUES TO PLAY OUT? BECCA: DEFINITELY WATCHING TO
24:18 SEE WHAT JARED IS WEARING, THAT IS FOREMOST --
24:20 CHRISTINA: I ENJOY WE ARE DISCUSSING WHAT A MAN IS WEARING
24:24 [LAUGHTER] BECCA: BUT IT IS PROGRESS BEING
24:29 MADE. BUT THEY NEED TO BE HAD IN GOOD
24:32 FAITH. ALL OF THIS IS NOT HAPPENING IN
24:34 A VACUUM. IT IS NOT LIKE THERE IS A
24:37 STANDSTILL ON THE BATTLEFIELD AS THESE CONVERSATIONS ARE TAKING
24:38 PLACE. THERE IS STILL A WAR OF GRINDING
24:42 ATTRITION GOING ON. THERE ARE STILL BARRAGES OF
24:46 MISSILES AND DRONES HITTING CAPITAL CITIES EVERY EVENING.
24:47 THIS IS IMPORTANT TO KEEP IN MIND.
24:50 AS THESE CONVERSATIONS ARE HAPPENING.
24:55 THERE IS THIS RENEWED FLURRY OF DIPLOMACY, AS JARED KUSHNER AND
24:57 STEVE WITKOFF ARE BACK AT IT. BUT WHETHER THEY CAN ACTUALLY BE
25:02 SUCCESSFUL IN CHANGING ANYTHING ON THE GROUND, PARTICULARLY AS
25:06 WE ARE CONTINUING TO SEE NOT ONLY NIGHTLY TERRITORIAL
25:13 BARRAGES, WE ARE ALSO CONTINUING TO SEE THINGS LIKE OUTAGES OF
25:18 STAR SHIELD AND STARLINK THAT ARE HAVING A MATERIAL EFFECT.
25:22 CHRISTINA: AS I WAS DOING A SWEEP OF HEADLINES IN THE WEE
25:27 HOURS THIS MORNING, ONE I CAME ACROSS WAS FRANK.
25:29 UKRAINE IS RUNNING OUT OF OPTIONS, AND RUSSIA KNOWS IT.
25:31 ONE OF THE THINGS PLAYING INTO THAT IS THE STAR SHIELD FOR MORE
25:36 ACCUSATIONS IT WAS THROTTLED, AGAIN FROM PRESIDENT ZELENSKYY,
25:41 DENIALS FROM YOU ON THE -- FROM ELON MUSK IN THE WHITE HOUSE.
25:45 DO YOU KNOW WHAT IS GOING ON? BECCA: OPEN QUESTION AS TO WHY
25:48 IT KEEPS HAPPENING AND WHO IS AT FAULT.
25:52 LAST TIME THIS OCCURRED, THERE WAS A BIT OF A POINTING THE
25:57 FINGERS AND BLAME GAME FROM ELON MUSK AND THE WHITE HOUSE, BOTH
26:01 POINTING FINGERS AT EACH OTHER. BUT IT IS VERY CLEAR THAT THIS
26:07 KEEPS ON HAPPENING IN A WAY TO ESSENTIALLY HALT SOME OF
26:11 UKRAINE'S MOMENTUM. RUSSIAN ADVANCES AT THE LINE OF
26:17 BATTLE HAVE SLOWED. THEY HAVE NOT BEEN ABLE TO TAKE
26:20 AS MUCH TERRITORY AS THEY HAVE IN YEARS PAST.
26:24 THEY ARE ALSO HAVING SIGNIFICANT RECRUITMENT CHALLENGES AS,
26:30 FRANKLY, LOSSES ARE OUTPACING RECRUITMENT.
26:31 THINGS ARE NOT LOOKING GREAT FOR RUSSIA ALONG THE FRONT LINES.
26:37 SOME OF THESE OUTAGES AND SOME OF THESE EFFORTS ARE SLOWING
26:40 DOWN UKRAINE'S ABILITY TO NOT ONLY DEFEND THAT FRONTLINE BUT
26:47 ALSO DEFEND FURTHER BACK AND PURSUE SOME OF ITS STRATEGY TO
26:51 TRY AND HOLD RUSSIA. ALL OF THIS MEANS THAT IT SHIFTS
26:56 THINGS ON THE BATTLEFIELD IN RUSSIA'S FAVOR, WHICH ALLOWS
26:59 NEGOTIATING TABLE. DAVID: WARS ON TWO FRONTS.
27:05 THIS IS AN INTERVIEW ON TWO FRONTS AS WELL.
27:09 WE HAD PRESIDENT TRUMP ON TRUTH SOCIAL WRITING WE DO NOT NEED A
27:13 DEAL WITH IRAN, WE GOT THEIR MONEY, HUNDREDS OF BILLIONS OF
27:16 DOLLARS, AND WE GOT THERE STRAIT .
27:19 DAYS LATER, HE SAID THIS -- >> IT IS AN EVIL EMPIRE.
27:24 WE'VE KNOCKED THE HELL OUT OF THEM.
27:27 THEY WILL HAVE A NUCLEAR WEAPON. >> WHY IS THIS STILL GOING ON?
27:32 >> WHY HAVEN'T THIS BEEN FINISHED?
27:36 I HAVE HEARD YOU SAY YOU COULD TAKE THEM OUT.
27:40 >> I COULD AND IT IMMEDIATELY, AT THE REQUEST OF THE NATIONS I
27:42 AM LOOKING TO PROTECT. WE ARE DOING IT A LITTLE BIT
27:46 LONGER WAY, LITTLE BIT MORE CIVILLY.
27:50 SAUDI ARABIA HAS ASKED ME TO PLEASE JUST LET IT BE THE WAY IT
27:54 IS NOW FOR A WHILE, BECAUSE THEY ARE DISINTEGRATING.
28:00 DAVID: TEPHEN A. SMITH ASKING ABOUT THE CONCLUSION OF THE WAR.
28:02 I MENTION THAT P0 IN THE NEW YORK TIMES.
28:05 THERE YOU GO, HOLD IT UP. TALK ABOUT THE WAY YOU ARE
28:10 THINKING ABOUT WHAT U.S. INVOLVEMENT IN THE MIDDLE EAST
28:13 MIGHT LOOK LIKE AFTER THIS CONFLICT COMES TO AN END?
28:18 BECCA: WHENEVER THAT HAPPENS ON HOWEVER IT HAPPENS.
28:21 THE U.S. IS NOT GOING TO JUST WALK AWAY.
28:23 I THINK THAT IS A BIT OF A MISCONCEPTION A LOT OF FOLKS
28:24 HAVE. THE U.S. IS GOING TO REMAIN
28:28 ENGAGED IN THE REGION. BY ITS TERMS ARE GOING TO BE
28:30 QUITE DIFFERENT. I DO THINK IT WILL BE A MORE
28:35 NARROW DEFINITION OF PROTECTING ITS CORE INTERESTS.
28:40 BUT THERE ARE ALSO OPERATIONAL REASONS WHY THE U.S. MILITARY IS
28:42 NOT GOING TO GO BACK TO THE BASIS, WHERE IT ONCE STOOD IN
28:48 REALLY LARGE FORMATIONS, WITH REALLY EXPENSIVE EQUIPMENT JUST
28:50 SITTING THERE. PART OF THAT IS THE OPERATIONAL
28:56 RISKS TO THEM, BASED ON IRAN'S ABILITY TO THREATEN THOSE BASES
29:00 AND THOSE LOCATIONS. IT PROVIDES AN OPPORTUNITY, AS
29:08 INVERSE AS THAT MIGHT SEEM, FOR THE UNITED STATES TO REGAIN ITS
29:11 POSTURE, RESET ITS LINE SO IT HAS A MORE RESILIENT APPROACH IN
29:13 THE MIDDLE EAST. BUT IT ALSO ALLOWS FOR THE GULF
29:18 STATES IN PARTICULAR, TO TAKE GREATER AGENCY AND GREATER
29:21 RESPONSIBILITY FOR THEIR OWN SECURITY.
29:25 THAT IS, FRANKLY, THE WAY THE REGION OUGHT TO MOVE FORWARD.
29:29 IT REQUIRES A REGIONAL SECURITY ARCHITECTURE, NOT ONE THAT IS
29:32 ESSENTIALLY PROTECTED FROM AFAR BY THE UNITED STATES.
29:38 CHRISTINA: YOU AND OUR COLLEAGUES ARGUE THAT WHAT THAT
29:40 LOOKS LIKE HIM INSTEAD OF THESE BUT BASES ARE ALMOST
29:43 INDEFENSIBLE BECAUSE THEY ARE SO BIG AND OUTDATED, SMALLER
29:47 INSTALLATIONS AND ALLIED NATIONS LIKE SAUDI ARABIA, JORDAN,
29:49 ISRAEL -- AS YOU WERE JUST TALKING ABOUT, MORE DIFFUSE
29:54 PRESENCE. THOSE THINGS MADE THOSE
29:58 COUNTRIES A TARGET FOR IRAN IN THIS CONFLICT.
30:00 DO YOU THINK THERE IS A WILLINGNESS FOR THEM TO HOST
30:02 SUCH OUTPOSTS? BECCA: YOU HAD ON THE MOST
30:06 IMPORTANT PART. THE U.S. CAN HAVE ALL THESE
30:09 PLANS, BUT THEY ARE NOT THE ONES WHO FULLY GET TO DECIDE.
30:12 ALL OF THIS HINGES ON ALLIES AND PARTNERS PROVIDING ACCESS,
30:18 OVERFLIGHT, BASING OPPORTUNITIES.
30:20 FRANKLY, IT IS NOT JUST IN THE MIDDLE EAST.
30:20 IT IS ALSO VERY RELEVANT TO EUROPE.
30:24 IF I WANT TO BRING THIS CONVERSATION BACK TO WHERE WE
30:26 STARTED. IF THE UNITED STATES IS GOING TO
30:28 HAVE A SMALLER, MORE DISTRIBUTED PRESIDENT -- PRESENCE IN THE
30:32 MIDDLE EAST, IT WILL NEED TO PROJECT POWER FROM EUROPE.
30:37 THAT MEANS HAVING ACCESS TO OVERFLIGHT AT EUROPEAN BASES.
30:39 AT THE SAME TIME THE U.S. IS TRYING TO REDO SOME OF ITS
30:42 COMMITMENTS TO NATO. DAVID: BECCA WASSER, THANK YOU
30:46 VERY MUCH, WITH THAT PIECE IN THE NEW YORK TIMES.
30:50 CHECK THAT OUT AS WELL. APPRECIATE YOUR TIME.
30:54 CHRISTINA: SCIENTISTS HAVE BEEN TRYING TO DISCOVER RELIEF FOR
30:58 MORE THAN 50 MILLION PEOPLE LIVING WITH DEMENTIA AROUND THE
30:59 GLOBE. NOW, BRITISH PRIME MINISTER
31:04 DAVID CAMERON IS SHARING HIS PERSONAL STORY IN HIS MISSION TO
31:09 END ALZHEIMER'S. WE SPOKE WITH HIM ON SET.
31:26 ♪ CHRISTINA: WELCOME BACK TO
31:31 "BLOOMBERG THIS WEEKEND." TENS OF MILLIONS OF PEOPLE
31:37 WORLDWIDE ARE LIVING WITH DEMENTIA, AND EVERY YEAR, THERE
31:41 ARE ABOUT 10 MILLION NEW DIAGNOSES, ACCORDING TO THE
31:43 WORLD HEALTH ORGANIZATION. ALZHEIMER'S IS THE MOST COMMON
31:47 FORM OF DEMENTIA AND IS ESTIMATED TO CONTRIBUTE TO 60%
31:50 TO 70% OF CASES. DAVID: FOR FORMER PRIME MINISTER
31:55 DAVID CAMERON, HE AND HIS SIBLINGS LOST HIS MOTHER
32:00 DEMENTIA LAST YEAR. WE SAT DOWN WITH A FORMER PRIME
32:03 MINISTER AND. STARTED BY ASKING ABOUT HIS MOM.
32:07 MR. CAMERON: IT'S PERSONAL, BECAUSE WE LOST MY MOTHER TO
32:09 ALZHEIMER'S LAST YEAR. IT IS A TERRIBLE ILLNESS AND
32:11 DISEASE. IN THE END, IT IS SO PAINFUL,
32:15 FOR THEM AND THE FAMILY. BUT MY INTEREST GOES RIGHT BACK
32:17 TO WHEN I WAS A MEMBER OF PARLIAMENT.
32:22 MY INTEREST CAME FROM MY OWN EMBARRASSMENT ABOUT MY
32:23 IGNORANCE. I ALWAYS THOUGHT, DEMENTIA, THAT
32:27 IS SORT OF WHAT HAPPENS TO PEOPLE WHEN THEY GET OLD.
32:31 IT ISN'T IT IS CAUSED BY DISEASES OF THE BRAIN.
32:35 ONCE I UNDERSTOOD DOC AND SAW HOW LITTLE THAT WAS UNDERSTOOD,
32:38 I THOUGHT THERE WAS A CHANCE, AS PRIME MINISTER, TO PUSH THIS
32:40 ISSUE. THAT IS WHY WE HAD THE DEMENTIA
32:45 CHALLENGE IN 2012, TRIED TO SWITCH THE WHOLE WORLD ONTO
32:47 PURSUING THIS WITH THE SAME VIGOR THAT WE PURSUE CURING
32:49 CANCER. CHRISTINA: WHY DO YOU THINK THAT
32:53 HAD NOT BEEN DONE UNTIL NOW? MR. CAMERON: I THINK IT WAS A
32:59 MISUNDERSTANDING THAT LOTS OF PEOPLE HAD.
33:01 THE CHARITIES -- ONE OF WHICH I AM NOW PRESIDENT OF -- HAVE DONE
33:05 A LOT TO MOVE PUBLIC OPINION, BUT THERE IS STILL A LOT TO BE
33:08 DONE. BUT DR. ALZHEIMER DISCOVERED
33:13 THIS DISEASE 120 YEARS AGO, AND FOR ABOUT 100 YEARS, REALLY NOT
33:16 MUCH PROGRESS WAS MADE. I THINK A LOT OF PEOPLE JUST
33:18 THOUGHT THIS IS SOMETHING WE WILL HAVE TO DEAL WITH.
33:23 AND THERE IS RENEWED ATTENTION TO IT, HAS LED TO REAL
33:26 BREAKTHROUGHS. THERE IS A SENSE THAT WE ARE
33:29 CURING CANCER, WE HAVE A CHANCE OF DOING THAT FOR THE DISEASES
33:32 THAT CAUSE DEMENTIA. DAVID: HOW WELL DO WE UNDERSTAND
33:36 THE PATHOLOGY OF THIS NOW? HOW FULLY DO WE UNDERSTAND WHAT
33:39 THE DISEASE IS? MR. CAMERON: THE ANSWER IS NOT
33:41 FULLY. WE KNOW THE BUILDUP OF THESE
33:49 PLAQUES IN THE BRAIN, AND THE TANGLES IN YOUR NERVE ENDINGS,
33:52 WE KNOW THEY ARE IMPORTANT GAVE A SIMPLE WAY OF THINKING OF IT
33:54 IS NOT EVERYONE WHO HAS THESE PLAQUES HAS DEMENTIA, BUT
33:58 EVERYONE WITH DEMENTIA HAS THOSE AMYLOID PLAQUES.
34:05 TRYING TO WORK OUT THE EXACT CAUSATION AND SEQUENCING STILL
34:06 NEEDS TO BE DONE. BY THESE DRUGS YOU CAN NOW TAKE
34:12 THAT STOP THE BUILDUP OF PLAQUES AND REMOVE THEM DO SEEM TO BE
34:15 HAVING POSITIVE EFFECTS. WHETHER THAT IS THE FINAL
34:17 ANSWER, WE DON'T KNOW. BUT 10 YEARS AGO, THERE WERE
34:22 VERY FEW DRUG TRIALS IN THIS AREA GOING ON.
34:26 TODAY, THERE ARE 190 DRUG TRIALS GOING ON AROUND THE WORLD AND A
34:27 REAL SENSE WE ARE MAKING BREAKTHROUGHS.
34:29 CHRISTINA: THE OTHER PART OF THIS THAT IS A REALLY IMPORTANT
34:33 COMPONENT IS THE DIAGNOSTICS. A LOT OF PEOPLE DON'T KNOW YOU
34:38 CAN POSSIBLY NOW GET A BLOOD TEST TO DIAGNOSE THIS AND IT IS
34:41 CHEAPER AND EASIER AND LESS INVASIVE THAN CT SCANS OR
34:45 FUNCTIONAL IMAGING. HOW RELIABLE IS THAT TEST?
34:49 MR. CAMERON: MORE PROGRESS IS NEEDED, BUT IT IS GOING TO
34:52 HAPPEN AND IT IS A BIG BREAKTHROUGH.
34:55 TODAY, BRITAIN, A COUNTRY OF 166 MILLION, 1 MILLION WITH
35:03 DIMENSION, PROBABLY ONLY 1 IN 3 OF THOSE HAVE A PROPER DIAGNOSIS
35:06 CARE THAT WILL BE BASED ON A COGNITIVE TEST, NOT A BRAIN
35:08 SCAN. THE IDEA YOU CAN HAVE A BLOOD
35:10 TEST, WHERE YOU ARE LOOKING FOR THOSE PARTICULAR MARKER, BIOMA
35:16 RKER, THAT YOU HAVE THE BUILDUP OF THE PLAQUES, THAT IS A GAME
35:18 CHANGER. THAT BEING WIDELY AVAILABLE IS A
35:20 YEAR OR TWO AWAY. DAVID: THIS IS A DEEPLY REPORTED
35:24 SERIES. YOU REPORT FROM LONDON, LOS
35:28 ANGELES, LAS VEGAS, NEW JERSEY AS WELL.
35:30 YOU SIT DOWN WITH SENATOR ANDY KIM, WHO HAS GONE THROUGH THIS
35:32 HIMSELF. LET'S TAKE A LISTEN TO WHAT HE
35:34 HAD TO SAY. >> ONE OF THE QUESTIONS WAS,
35:38 WHAT WAS YOUR WORK, WHAT DID YOU DO OVER THE COURSE OF YOUR
35:40 CAREER? MY FATHER JUST LOOKED AT ME AND
35:44 LOOKED AT THE DOCTOR AND SAID, I DON'T KNOW.
35:52 AND IT WAS REALLY HEARTBREAKING. MR. CAMERON: IT WAS A MOMENT OF
35:59 TRAGIC IRONY AS SENATOR KIM WATCHED HIS FATHER, WHO WORKED
36:02 IN ALZHEIMER'S RESEARCH, NOW ON THE OTHER SIDE OF THE DISEASE.
36:06 SEN. KIM: IT WAS HEARTBREAKING, THE IDEA THAT ALZHEIMER'S HAS
36:10 ERASED FROM MY FATHER'S MEMORY HIS LIFE'S WORK OF TRYING TO
36:13 CURE ALZHEIMER'S. I OFTEN SAY, YOU CAN'T HELP BUT
36:18 FEEL LIKE ALL TIMERS WON. DAVID: SENATOR KIM TALKS ABOUT
36:24 LOOKING AT HIS FATHER'S WRITINGS AND HIS DIVINATION OF HIS
36:28 ABILITY TO HOLD THOUGHTS AND WRITE THOSE DOWN.
36:29 SOMETHING HE HAS BEEN PASSIONATE ABOUT IS MAKING IT EASIER FOR
36:32 LOVED ONES AND PEOPLE DEALING WITH THIS DISEASE TO CARE FOR
36:35 THEM. AS WE TALK ABOUT TREATMENTS AND
36:38 DIAGNOSTICS, THIS IS A CRUCIAL PART OF THE DISEASE.
36:45 MR. CAMERON: IT WAS AN INCREDIBLY MOVING INTERVIEW.
36:46 I DID NOT KNOW SENATOR KIM BEFORE, AND I DID NOT KNOW ABOUT
36:51 HIS FATHER. EXTRAORDINARY HE SPENT HIS WHOLE
36:55 LIFE TRYING TO UNDERSTAND THIS DISEASE, AND THAT HIS BRAIN WAS
36:57 SORT OF WIPED OUT. BUT I THINK SENATOR KIM IS
37:00 RIGHT. HOW WE GET GREATER UNDERSTANDING
37:05 AND HELP RELATIVES CARE, IT'S REALLY HARD.
37:07 IT IS LITTLE THINGS. WHEN YOU SEE YOUR PARENT, THE
37:09 FIRST THING YOU NORMALLY SAY IS, "HI, MOM, WHAT DID YOU DO
37:13 YESTERDAY?" YOU CAN'T DO THAT, BECAUSE IT
37:19 CAN BE REALLY DEPRESSING WHEN THEY CANNOT REMEMBER.
37:21 TRYING TO EXPLAIN BETTER HOW THE DISEASE WORKS AND HOW TO HANDLE
37:23 IT IS IMPORTANT. AND THEN THE MASSIVE ISSUE OF
37:26 HOW DO WE PAY FOR THE CARE? WE ARE HAVING A BIG DEBATE ABOUT
37:29 THAT IN THE U.K. EVEN BETTER WOULD BE IF WE CAN
37:33 FIND SOME CURES TO THE DISEASE SO WE CAN REDUCE THE LEVEL OF
37:36 SUFFERING AND COST THAT HAS TO BE BORNE BY SOMEONE.
37:39 CHRISTINA: CAN YOU TALK A BIT ABOUT WHAT THIS WAS LIKE FOR
37:41 YOU? THIS HAD TO BE HARD ,TO RE-LIVE
37:48 SOME OF THIS STUFF, TO RETHINK THE LAST COUPLE DAYS OR YEARS
37:50 WITH YOUR MOTHER. CAN YOU TALK ABOUT WHY YOU
37:52 DECIDED TO DO THIS, AND WHAT WAS YOUR FAMILY'S REACTION WHEN HE
37:56 SAID I WANTED TO PUT THIS DOWN ON A PODCAST?
37:59 MR. CAMERON: I HAVE TWO YOUNG -- I'VE TWO WONDERFUL SISTERS.
38:06 I HAD A BIG INTEREST, THEN MUM GETS THIS DISEASE.
38:11 WHEN SHE PASSES, I REMEMBER TALKING TO THEM ABOUT IT.
38:15 THEY DIDN'T HESITATE. THEY SAID STRAIGHTAWAY, YES, YOU
38:19 SHOULD DO IT. WE HAVE TO THE SPREAD
38:20 UNDERSTANDING. THEN ONE NIGHT AS IF THEY WANTED
38:23 TO BE INTERVIEWED, THEY JUMPED AT THAT AS WELL --
38:26 CHRISTINA: HAVE YOU EVER INTERVIEWED YOUR SISTERS BEFORE?
38:31 MR. CAMERON: AS EVER, WOMEN ARE MORE PERCEPTIVE THAN MEN.
38:32 THEY HAD SPOTTED -- WE WERE TRYING TO DATE THE START OF
38:38 MOM'S ALL TIMERS, AND THEY BOTH THOUGHT IT WAS MUCH EARLIER THAN
38:39 I DID. I THINK THEY HAD SPOTTED SOME OF
38:41 THE SIGNS. DAVID: LET'S TALK ABOUT PROGRESS
38:44 TOWARDS A CURE. I AM CURIOUS IF YOU THINK THE
38:49 BIG PHARMACEUTICAL COMPANIES ACKNOWLEDGE IT IS A DISEASE AND
38:54 ONE THAT NEEDS TREATMENT, IF THE INVESTMENT'S COMMENSURATE WITH
38:56 HOW BIG A BURDEN THIS IS? MR. CAMERON: I THINK WE ARE
38:59 GETTING THERE. IN 2014, A PAPER CALLED THE 99%
39:10 PAPER CAME OUT JOE 99% OF DRUG TRIALS WERE FAILING.
39:14 AT THAT MOMENT, IT FELT LIKE WE WOULD GO NOWHERE.
39:17 FAST-FORWARD, WE HAVE 190 DRUGS IN DEVELOPMENT, TWO OR THREE
39:21 USED HERE IN THE UNITED STATES. WE HAVE TESTS COMING ONLINE,
39:27 BLOOD TESTS. A MUCH BETTER UNDERSTANDING OF
39:28 WHAT IS HAPPENING IN THE BRAIN, A MUCH BETTER UNDERSTANDING OF
39:32 HOW TO GET DRUGS ACROSS THE BLOOD BRAIN BARRIER SO THEY
39:36 WORK. WE WILL STILL NEED PHILANTHROPY.
39:41 THE PHARMA COMPANIES WILL DO THE TRIALS, BUT THERE ARE STILL GAPS
39:45 TO FILL IN OUR BASIC SCIENTIFIC KNOWLEDGE.
39:47 WE STILL NEED THE PHILANTHROPY, THE CHARITIES TO DO THEIR WORK.
39:51 AND WE NEED GOVERNMENTS TO BE MORE CREATIVE AND HOW DO WE
39:55 TRIED NOVEL MEDICINES, FUND TREATMENTS, RECRUIT PEOPLE FOR
39:59 CLINICAL TRIBALS -- TRIALS? DURING COVID, WE WERE RECRUITING
40:05 PEOPLE FOR A NICKEL TRIALS ON THE INTERNET.
40:09 THAT WARP SPEED FOR COVID DRUGS, WE NEED TO TIMERS DRUGS, TOO.
40:13 DAVID: THE LACK OF DATA WE HAVE, AND IT IS REALLY SOMETHING THAT
40:17 IS A PART OF MEDICINE THAT NEEDS PEOPLE TO PARTICIPATE, TO BE
40:21 EXAMINED, FOR US TO KNOW MORE ABOUT HOW BRAINS WORK?
40:23 MR. CAMERON: WE DEFINITELY WANT PEOPLE TO SIGN UP, BUT WE ALSO
40:27 NEED GOVERNMENTS TO MAKE IT EASIER.
40:29 SO IN THE U.K., THE DRUGS ARE NOT CURRENTLY LICENSED ON THE
40:32 NHS BECAUSE OF THE EXPENSE. BUT WE COULD DO MUCH BIGGER
40:35 CLINICAL TRIALS. I THINK THAT IS A GOOD WAY IN.
40:39 DAVID: HOW ARE THINGS TO THE RIGHT HONORABLE LORD --
40:46 OUR THANKS OT -- TO THE RIGHT HONORABLE LORD DAVID CAMERON.
40:51 YOU CAN LISTEN TO IT ON BLOOMBERG.COM.
40:55 CHRISTINA: COMING UP, A HISTORIC LAUNCH ATTEMPT FOR THE SPACEX
40:57 MISSION. WE WILL HAVE ALL YOUR SPACE
41:01 INFORMATION. DAVID: YOU ARE VERY EXCITED
41:04 ABOUT THIS. THIS IS REVOLUTIONARY.
41:07 THEY ARE TRYING TO REUSE THE ENTIRE SPACECRAFT.
41:10 CHRISTINA: I APPRECIATE IT, I JUST DO NOT REALLY GET EXCITED.
41:13 DAVID: WE WILL TRY TO GET YOUAMPED.
41:15 CHRISTINA: I DON'T WANT TO BE THE SPACE GRINCH.
41:27 ♪ DAVID: WELCOME BACK TO
41:29 "BLOOMBERG THIS WEEKEND." A FASCINATING STORY BY OUR
41:36 COLLEAGUE MORGAN BAKER CAUGHT OUR EYES, INVOLVING THE USE OF
41:38 AGENTIC AI IN RELATIONSHIPS. CHRISTINA: AFTER WE DID THIS
41:43 CHAT WITH HER, I BEEN ASKING EVERYBODY IN MY LIFE IF THEY USE
41:44 IT OR NOT. SHE CAN EXPLAIN OR US.
41:51 DAVID: GREAT TO SPEAK WITH YOU. YOU START YOUR MORE RECENT PIECE
41:54 WITH A REFLECTION, AN ARGUMENT YOU HAD WITH YOUR HUSBAND, AND
41:57 THE WAY HE REACTED TO IT. HE DECIDES HE DOES NOT WANT TO
42:02 TALK ANYMORE, AND HE TAKES OUT CHATGPT.
42:04 WHAT DID YOU MAKE OF HIS IMPULSE TO DO THAT, AND HOW INFORMATICS
42:12 IS OUT OF THE WAY -- >> I DON'T WRITE ABOUT MYSELF A
42:18 LOT, BUT THIS WAS A PERSONAL EXPERIENCE WITH HOW LOTS OF
42:21 INTERESTING THINGS ARE HAPPENING.
42:25 DURING THIS DISPUTE, MY HUSBAND PULLED OUT HIS PHONE AND WANTED
42:29 TO START TALKING TO CHATGPT INSTEAD OF ME.
42:31 THAT WAS SLIGHTLY UNNERVING. WHAT WAS REALLY UNNERVING WAS
42:34 LATER, WHEN WE WERE TALKING ABOUT IT, HE DESCRIBED CHATGPT
42:40 AS A WARM HUG, THE INTERACTION HE HAD WITH A CHATBOT AS A
42:41 WARMHUG. THAT GAVE ME THIS REALLY STRONG
42:46 IMPRESSION THAT SUDDENLY, AS I HAD WALKED OUT OF THE ROOM TO
42:49 GIVE HIM SPACE, CHATGPT HAD WALKED IN AND SAT BESIDE HIM ON
42:52 MY SOFA AND GIVEN HIM THE COMFORT THAT I OBVIOUSLY WAS NOT
42:54 GIVING HIM IN THAT MOMENT. THAT MADE ME THINK ABOUT, IF
42:59 THIS IS HAPPENING TO ME, THIS IS OBVIOUSLY HAPPENING TO OTHER
43:00 PEOPLE. WE HAVE READ SO MUCH ABOUT THOSE
43:05 VERY EXTREME STORIES ABOUT PEOPLE WHO FALL IN LOVE WITH
43:09 CHATBOTS, BUT I WANTED TO REALLY EXPLORE THE MORE MUNDANE AND
43:13 MORE PERVASIVE WAYS CHATBOTS ARE KIND OF SQUATTING PEOPLE'S
43:18 RELATIONSHIPS AND MOVING THEM, SHAPING THEM -- ONE THERAPIST
43:25 DESCRIBED IT TO ME AS THE THIRD ENTITY PROBLEM.
43:29 SUDDENLY, THERE ARE NOT TWO ENTITIES IN MONOGAMOUS
43:32 RELATIONSHIPS ANYMORE, THERE IS THIS OTHER CHATBOT ENTITY.
43:36 CHRISTINA: I'VE READ SO MUCH ABOUT HOW OUR THRESHOLDS OF
43:38 BEING BORED OR UNCOMFORTABLE HAS LESSENED SO MUCH IN THATERA OF
43:45 TECH AND ACCESS TO MOVIES AND THINGS TO BE ENTERTAINED.
43:50 BUT OUR THRESHOLDS OF BEING UPSET AND ENGAGE IN CONFLICT,
43:51 EVEN WITH PEOPLE WE LOVE, WILL BE LESS.
43:56 BECAUSE YOU CAN JUST TAKE YOUR PHONE OUT AND HAVE THIS THING
43:59 ANYTHING WRONG. MORGAN: YEAH.
44:04 AND I SPOKE TO A COUPLE THERAPISTS AND DIVORCE LAWYERS.
44:08 THEY ARE SEEING CHATBOTS FILTER THROUGH IN THEIR CLIENTS.
44:12 I THINK PEOPLE ARE USING CHATBOTS IN THEIR RELATIONSHIP
44:13 IN DIFFERENT WAYS. ONE WAY IS THEY ALREADY TURNING
44:17 TO CHATBOTS FOR ADVICE OR VALIDATION WHEN THEY ARE MAYBE
44:20 NOT GETTING IT FROM THEIR PARTNER.
44:21 OR MAYBE THEY ARE NOT EVEN TRYING TO GET IT FROM THEIR
44:22 PARTNER. MAYBE THEY ARE TAKING ALL THEIR
44:30 LITTLE QUERIES, THE TINY QUERIES THAT BUILD INTIMACY, LIKE I HAVE
44:34 THIS DILEMMA AT WORK, MAYBE THEY ARE TAKING TO THE CHATBOT FIRST.
44:37 BUT ALSO LOTS OF THERAPISTS I SPOKE TO SAY, IN THE HEAT OF THE
44:41 MOMENT, WHEN THERE IS AN ARGUMENT OR DISPUTE, PEOPLE TURN
44:45 TO CHATBOTS AND THEN WHEELED WHAT CHATGPT OR CLOGGED --
44:50 CLAUDE SAID AND TURNED TO THEIR PARTNER AND SAY IT, LOOK, THIS
44:53 VALIDATES MY ARGUMENT. CHRISTINA: IT IS LIKE THE
44:57 WEAPONIZATION OF THERAPY SPEAK. NOW WE WILL HAVE THE
44:59 WEAPONIZATION OF CHATBOTS. DAVID: AS YOU LOOK AT THIS ON A
45:04 SPECTRUM, AS YOU SPEAK TO EXPERTS, INCLUDING
45:06 PSYCHOTHERAPISTS, IS THERE A POINT THIS BECOMES A PROBLEM?
45:10 THAT BECOMES A BETRAYAL OR KIND OF TANTAMOUNT TO HAVING AN
45:13 AFFAIR WITH A THING? MORGAN: I SPOKE TO ONE THERAPIST
45:19 WAS LIKE, WE CAN USE CHATBOTS IN POSITIVE WAYS.
45:21 FOR EXAMPLE, IF YOU ARE SOMEONE WHO REALLY STRUGGLES IN CONFLICT
45:25 SITUATIONS, YOU COULD USE A CHATBOT TO ROLE-PLAY HOW YOU
45:28 RESPOND, SO YOU DO NOT GET DEFENSIVE.
45:31 I SPOKE TO ONE SOFTWARE ENGINEER, WHO SET HE AND HIS NOW
45:37 GIRLFRIEND WERE USING CLAUDE AS AN INTERMEDIARY.
45:38 THERE WERE GOING THROUGH A ROUGH PERIOD IN THEIR RELATIONSHIP.
45:42 THEY WOULD SEND ALL THE MESSAGES THEY WOULD SEND TO EACH OTHER TO
45:47 CLAUDE FIRST, CLAUDE WOULD GIVE THEM FEEDBACK, THEN THEY WOULD
45:50 SEND THEM TO EACH OTHER. HE FELT THAT WAS PRODUCTIVE AND
45:53 IT MEANT THEY COULD STRIP AWAY ALL THE ANGRY LANGUAGE THAT IS
45:57 NOT ACTUALLY HELPFUL WHEN YOU ARE TRYING TO COMMUNICATE HOW
45:58 YOU FEEL. ONE THING THAT IS DIFFERENT THAT
46:05 TECHNOLOGY HAS COME BETWEEN COUPLES FOR A LONG TIME.
46:09 THERE WAS THE MAGAZINE COVER, THE NEW YORK MAGAZINE COVER, IN
46:12 THE 1980'S, WHERE THERE WERE TWO PEOPLE IN BED BOTH DISTRACTED
46:16 FROM EACH OTHER, STARING AT THEIR GADGETS.
46:19 WHAT IS DIFFERENT NOW IS PEOPLE PERSONIFY AI, WHICH IS NOT THE
46:21 SAME WHEN YOU HAD A BUSY BANKER HUSBAND ON HIS LAPTOP ALL THE
46:23 TIME. PEOPLE KIND OF GET JEALOUS OR
46:28 FEEL THE PRESENCE OF ANOTHER PERSON, ANOTHER ENTITY, IN A WAY
46:29 THAT IS NEW. DAVID: I SAW A NEWS THIS WEEK
46:37 THAT GOOGLE GEMINI WILL BE INTEGRATED WITH APPLE CAR PLAY,
46:40 AND YOU COULD HAVE A CONVERSATION WITH A CHATBOT
46:41 WHILE DRIVING TO THE OFFICE OR WHEREVER.
46:46 THERE IS GOING TO BE A POINT WHERE YOU NO LONGER NEED TO TAKE
46:49 OUT YOUR PHONE TO HAVE THESE KINDS OF CONVERSATIONS, THAT YOU
46:51 WILL HAVE MORE PRESENCE FROM THESE THIRD ENTITIES IN YOUR
46:52 LIFE. WHAT DOES THAT LOOK LIKE IN
46:54 TERMS OF RELATIONSHIPS FOR THE FUTURE?
46:58 MORGAN: I THINK WE ARE STILL NAVIGATING THAT.
47:02 ONE THING I FEEL PERSONALLY ANNOYING TO ME IS WHEN YOU'RE
47:04 OUT TO DINNER WITH A FRIEND AND YOU ARE HAVING A SPECULATIVE
47:07 CONVERSATION, AND THEY ARE LIKE, LET'S STOP TALKING AND LET ME
47:09 GOOGLE IT. I FEEL LIKE THE CONVERSATION
47:13 AFTER SOMEONE HAS GOOGLED IT DIES.
47:15 I FEEL LIKE WE ARE STILL NAVIGATING HOW THE PREVIOUS AREA
47:26 -- ERA OF TECHNOLOGY PLAYS OUT AND HOW IT ENHANCES OUR
47:29 CONVERSATIONS RATHER THAN DISTRACTS US.
47:33 SOCIAL MEDIA AND HOW IT WAS ALL ABOUT MESSAGING YOUR FRIENDS,
47:36 TIME. HEY JUST SUPERCHARGES THAT, TO
47:42 BE LIKE HOW DO WE USE THESE TO -- USE THESE CAN VACATION
47:46 TECHNOLOGIES TO COMMIT GET BETTER?
47:49 CHRISTINA: MORGAN MEAKER, THANK YOU.
47:50 AND THANK YOU TO YOUR HUSBAND FOR LETTING YOU WRITE ABOUT HIM.
47:53 [LAUGHTER] SEEMS LIKE A GOOD SPORT.
47:57 MORGAN: MAYBE NEVER AGAIN. DAVID: WE RUN OUR MESSAGES
48:01 THROUGH CHATBOTS BEFORE WE COMMUNICATE.
48:03 CHRISTINA: TRY TO MAKE SURE THEY ARE PALATABLE.
48:07 DAVID: COMING UP, THE NEXT HOUR OF "BLOOMBERG THIS WEEKEND."
48:11 IT STARTS RIGHT NOW. ♪
48:31 >> WELCOME TO "BLOOMBERG THIS WEEKEND."
48:32 LIVE FROM NEW YORK, DAVID GURA, CHRISTINA RUFFINI, AND LISA
48:35 MATEO. THE LATEST HEADLINES, KEY
48:39 ANALYSIS, BIG INTERVIEWS, AND THE STORIES THAT HIT HOME ON
48:50 YOUR DAYS OFF. CHRISTINA: WELCOME BACK TO
48:51 "BLOOMBERG THIS WEEKEND." IT IS 8:00 A.M. IN NEW YORK FROM
48:55 OUR WORLD HEADQUARTERS HERE IN MANHATTAN.
48:56 I'M CHRISTINA RUFFINI. DAVID: I'M DAVID GURA ALONGSIDE
48:58 LISA MATEO. THIS GROUND STOP, HUGE NEWS
49:01 YESTERDAY, UNEXPECTED, FOUR TO FIVE HOURS OF NO FLIGHTS LEAVING
49:05 FROM U.S. AIRPORTS. WE'RE GOING TO DIG INTO THAT
49:08 WITH OUR COLLEAGUE, JEFF MASON, WHO HE WAS FOLLOWING THE NEWS
49:12 CONFERENCE LAST NIGHT WITH THE SECRETARIES OF HOMELAND SECURITY
49:13 AND TRANSPORTATION. CHRISTINA: THAT'S WHAT WE ALL
49:16 WANT TO DO ON FRIDAY NIGHT, STAY UP LATE.
49:19 DAVID: AT THE WHITE HOUSE. TO JEFF, BUT FIRST, AN UPDATE
49:22 WITH LISA MATEO. LISA: THE NATIONWIDE GROUND
49:25 STOP, YES, IT HAS BEEN LIFTED AFTER THE FOUR-HOUR SHUTDOWN.
49:29 AND NOW AIRLINES ARE SCRAMBLING TO GET BACK ON TRACK.
49:34 THE F.A.A. IS BLAMING A DATA OVERLOAD THAT PULLED AIR TRAFFIC
49:38 CONTROL COMMUNICATIONS AND RADAR.
49:39 U.S. HOMELAND SECURITY SECRETARY MARKWAYNE MULLIN SAYS THE PUBLIC
49:43 WAS NEVER IN ANY DANGER. >> THERE WAS NEVER ANY LIVES AT
49:47 RISK. THERE WAS NO FLIGHTS AT RISK.
49:50 F.A.A. WAS ABLE TO HANDLE IT. WE DID IT OUT OF AN ABUNDANCE OF
49:55 CAUTION. CHRISTINA: AMERICAN AIRLINES,
49:58 JET BLUE WARNED OF DELAYS INTO TODAY, WHILE OFFICIALS SAY THE
50:00 SYSTEMS WILL BE BACK TO NORMAL BEFORE THE THANKSGIVING HOLIDAY.
50:05 LAST NIGHT SAVED PASSENGERS FROM SEATTLE HAD JUST GOTTEN THEIR
50:08 CHILD TO SLEEP WHEN THEY HAD TO DEBOARD THE PLANE.
50:12 >> MY DAUGHTER IS GETTING MARRIED TOMORROW.
50:15 WE ARE TRYING TO THINK ABOUT HOW WE CAN GET THERE, AND HOPEFULLY
50:18 THIS LETS UP. CHRISTINA: THAT WAS ANOTHER
50:21 WOMAN WHO WAS GOING TO A WEDDING.
50:23 IN OTHER NEWS, ALL PASSENGERS EXAMINE YOU&CREW MEMBERS HAVE
50:25 BEEN RESCUE FROM THE A RIVER CRUISE SHIP AFTER COLLIDING WITH
50:29 A TANKER. THE TANKER LOST CONTROL, STRUCK
50:33 THE RIVER CRUISE FRIDAY AFTERNOON AT THE PORT OF NEW
50:35 ORLEANS. THE CRUISE SHIP BEGAN TO SINK
50:38 BEFORE TIPPING OVER, SENDING PASSENGERS INTO THE MISSISSIPPI
50:40 RIVER. THE SEARCH CONTINUES FOR A
50:45 SUCCESSOR TO JENSEN HUANG AFTER BEING OUSTED FOR REPORTS OF
50:48 MULTIPLE EXTRAMARITAL AFFAIRS. BLOOMBERG CAME OUT WITH A LIST
50:52 OF EXECUTIVES LIKELY IN THE RUNNING, AS INTERIM C.E.O.
50:55 COLETTE KRESS HOLDS DOWN THE FORT.
50:57 HIGH ON THE LIST IS THE C.E.O. OF ARMS HOLDINGS.
50:59 THE "FINANCIAL TIMES" REPORTING THAT NVIDIA'S BOARD HAS ALREADY
51:03 APPROACHED HIM ABOUT THE POSITION.
51:05 NVIDIA DOES DENY THAT. ARM HAS A CLOSE PARTNERSHIP WITH
51:09 NVIDIA, AND HE'S A FORMER NVIDIA EXECUTIVE.
51:11 THERE'S ALSO ADVANCED MICRODEVICES C.E.O. LISA SU, WHO
51:14 ALSO HAPPENS TO BE JENSEN HUANG'S KIFFIN.
51:16 UNDER HER LEADERSHIP, A.M.D.'S STOCK HAS SURGED NEARLY
51:20 174-FOLD. PRESIDENT DONALD TRUMP HAS
51:22 FLOATED THE IDEA OF NVIDIA HIRING FORMER APPLE C.E.O. TIM
51:25 COOK. THERE ARE A FEW MORE NAMES OF
51:27 COMPANIES LIKE AMAZON WEB SERVICES, MICRON, GOOGLE, CHECK
51:31 OUT THE TERMINAL FOR THAT COMPLETE LIST.
51:34 AND FINALLY, MICROSOFT SAYS ACCESS HAS FULLY BEEN RESTORED
51:37 TO ITS FLAGSHIP SOFTWARE AFTER AN OUTAGE THAT AFFECTED
51:40 GOVERNMENT OFFICES, TRADERS, AND ALSO BUSINESSES AROUND THE
51:42 WORLD. ACCORDING TO DOWN DETECTOR,
51:46 PEOPLE IN MORE THAN 70 COUNTRIES REPORTED PROBLEMS ACROSS
51:50 OUTLOOK, TEAMS, AND CO-PILOT. THE ERROR HAPPENS DURING A
51:52 NETWORK CAPACITY UPGRADE. IT WAS INTERESTING TO SEE WHAT
51:55 PEOPLE DID ON THE DOWN TIME, TOO.
51:57 DAVID: WHAT THEY WERE DOING, AND THEN ALSO THE DELAYS IN GETTING
51:59 MESSAGES BACK. I GOT ALL OF THESE MESSAGES BACK
52:04 LIKE DAYS LATE. OH, YOU KNOW, I WAS EVENTUALLY
52:08 WISE THAT THERE WAS THIS OUTAGE, PEOPLE WERE JUST NOT RESPONDING
52:09 TO ME. CHRISTINA: SOME OF MY
52:12 GIRLFRIENDS WERE SAYING IT WAS LIKE HAVING A SNOW DAY.
52:17 DAVID: BLOOMBERG PLATFORM WORKING WELL, WORKING
52:19 EXCELLENTLY. CHRISTINA: ALSO WORKING WELL,
52:21 LISA MATEO. THANK YOU SO MUCH.
52:24 AS WE MENTIONED, IT WAS A ROUGH FRIDAY NIGHT FOR A LOT OF AIR
52:27 TRAVELERS, AND IT WAS A SCRAMBLE FOR OUR REPORTERS AND COLLEAGUES
52:30 OVER AT THE WHITE HOUSE, WHO HAD A LATE NIGHT PRESS CONFERENCE
52:32 WITH THE TRANSPORTATION SECRETARY AND SECRETARY OF THE
52:34 DEPARTMENT OF HOMELAND SECURITY. OUR OWN JEFF MASON WAS THERE.
52:39 JEFF, YOU AND I WERE TEXTING. THIS IS WHAT WE WANT TO SPEND
52:42 OUR FRIDAY NIGHT DOING. DAVID: ALWAYS.
52:44 CHRISTINA: ALWAYS. UNFORTUNATELY, JUST YOU AND I
52:47 SPEND A LOT OF OUR FRIDAY NIGHTS TEXTING ABOUT THE
52:49 ADMINISTRATION, BUT WE'LL PUT THAT ASIDE.
52:51 JEFF: WE'VE GOT A GREAT SOCIAL LIFE.
52:52 IT'S AWESOME. CHRISTINA: WE ARE SO COOL.
52:56 JEFF: WE ALWAYS RESPOND TO EACH OTHER'S EMAILS.
52:59 TELL DAVID THAT. DAVID: THANK YOU.
53:01 WOW. I'M LEARNING SO MUCH ABOUT YOU
53:05 TWO. JEFF: I'M KIDDING, I'M KIDDING.
53:08 CHRISTINA: WHEN THIS PRESS CONFERENCE STARTED, THE FIRST
53:11 THING IS SECRETARY MULLIN CAME UP AND THIS IS SAID WHAT IS THE
53:15 LEADERSHIP OF THE TRUMP ADMINISTRATION LOOKS LIKE.
53:18 AND I WROTE THAT DOWN, BECAUSE I THOUGHT, FOR BETTER OR WORSE.
53:21 BUT WE DO HAVE YOU ASKING A QUESTION, GETTING A RESPONSE
53:25 SHORTLY THEREAFTER. LET'S PLAY IT FOR YOU.
53:27 >> I THINK IT UNDERSCORES HOW IMPORTANT AVIATION IS TO OUR
53:29 ECONOMY. WE HAVEN'T DONE A CALCULATION.
53:33 I WAS ON THE AIRPLANE, AN AIRPLANE FROM DALLAS WHEN THIS
53:36 HAPPENED, HENCE MY ATTIRE. AND HAVEN'T GONE TO CHANGE, SO A
53:39 APOLOGIZE FOR WEARING A JACKET AND JEANS WITH YOU.
53:44 THERE WILL BE TIME TO DO AN ECONOMIC ANALYSIS.
53:47 BUT THIS IS CRITICAL FOR THE AMERICAN ECONOMY, WHICH IS WHY
53:50 THE CONGRESS, I'M GOING SAY IT A MILLION TIMES, THE CONGRESS HAS
53:53 TO GIVE THE RESOURCES TO THE PRESIDENT SO HE CAN FINISH THIS
53:55 BILL. CHRISTINA: THAT WAS YOU ASKING
53:58 SECRETARY DUFFY ABOUT THE ECONOMIC IMPACT OF THIS, AND
54:01 THAT IS A BIG ISSUE, HAVING ALL THE FLIGHTS OVER THE U.S. SHUT
54:03 DOWN. HOW SERIOUSLY IS THE
54:06 ADMINISTRATION TAKING THIS? JEFF: CERTAINLY VERY SERIOUSLY.
54:08 THE FIRST PART OF THE QUESTION THAT I ASKED HIM WAS, HOW DID
54:12 THIS ACTUALLY MANIFEST IN THE AIR?
54:14 THEY HADN'T REALLY EXPLAINED. AND ONE OF THE THINGS THAT HE
54:18 SAID THERE WAS THAT THERE WAS A PERIOD WHERE FLIGHTS, WHERE CAP
54:21 DANCE WERE NOT ABLE TO COMMUNICATE WITH THE AIR TRAFFIC
54:26 CONTROL SYSTEM. SO DESPITE THE FACT THAT BOTH
54:30 MEN SPENT THE MAJORITY, OR A GOOD CHUNK THAT HAVE PRESS
54:32 CONFERENCE LAST NIGHT SAYING THAT THERE WAS NO SAFETY RISK TO
54:36 THE AMERICAN PUBLIC AND TO PEOPLE IN THE AIR, IT'S HARD NOT
54:41 TO CONCLUDE THERE WAS. CERTAINLY THEY EMPHASIZED THAT
54:43 THE REASON THAT THERE WAS IS BECAUSE THEY TOOK THE ACTION
54:47 THAT THEY DID, HAVING THAT FOUR-HOUR-PLUS GROUND STOP.
54:51 BUT IT CERTAINLY UNDERSCORES WHAT THEY PORTRAYED AS AN OLD
54:56 BUT CREEKY SYSTEM, TURNING INTO A NIGHTMARE FOR COMMUNICATIONS
55:03 BETWEEN PILOTS AND AIR TRAFFIC CONTROLLERS ON AN OTHERWISE
55:06 NORMAL WORKDAY. DAVID: TO WANT GET TO SECRETARY
55:10 DUFFY ACENE TREATY. THIS IS AN EMERGENCY, HE SAID, I
55:13 WANT CONGRESS TO GIVE US EMERGENCY FUNDING, THIS IS
55:15 BIPARTISAN, THIS IS AMERICAN. I WON $50 BILLION, AND I HAVE TO
55:19 NOTE HERE, COST OF THE WAR IN IRAN RIGHT NOW, ABOUT $50
55:22 BILLION. WITH THAT NUANCE ASIDE HERE, HAS
55:27 THIS BEEN SO DIFFICULT TO MODERNIZE THE SYSTEM?
55:29 WE WERE TALKING TO OUR COLLEAGUE AT BLOOMBERG INTELLIGENCE ABOUT
55:31 THE COMPLICATIONS OF WHOLESALE TAKING AN EXISTING SYSTEM,
55:34 TAKING THAT OUT AND PUTTING A NEW ONE IN.
55:37 YOU HAVE TO DO IT IN THIS HE TARIFF WAY.
55:40 WHY IS GETTING FUNDING, EVEN AFTER THE COLLISION WE SAW IN
55:43 WASHINGTON A COUPLE OF YEARS AGO?
55:44 JEFF: I THINK THAT'S A GREAT QUESTION, DAVID, AND I
55:48 APPRECIATE THE FACT THAT YOU COMPARED THAT TO THE COST OF THE
55:52 WAR IN IRAN, BECAUSE IT UNDERSCORES, AGAIN, IT'S NOT
55:54 JUST A SMALL ASK ON BEHALF OF THE ADMINISTRATION.
55:57 A COUPLE OF ANSWERS TO THAT QUESTION.
56:00 NUMBER ONE, THEY DID GET $12 BILLION IN WHAT WAS CALLED THE
56:03 ONE BIG BEAUTIFUL BILL, PRESIDENT TRUMP'S KEY SIGNATURE
56:07 LEGISLATIVE VICTORY OF THE FIRST TERM LAST YEAR.
56:13 ALSO IMPORTANT TO NOTE, AND ONE OF MY REPORTER COLLEAGUES ASKED
56:18 ABOUT THIS LAST NIGHT, THAT REPUBLICANS CONTROL THE HOUSE
56:19 AND THE SENATE, AS WELL AS THE WHITE HOUSE, OF COURSE, AND HAVE
56:24 FOR THE LAST TWO YEARS. SO IT'S NOT SOMETHING AS EASY AS
56:31 BLAMING DEMOCRATS, OR BLAMING PRESIDENT JOE BIDEN FOR NOT
56:36 UPGRADING HIS SYSTEM, WHICH THIS PRESIDENT SAYS PREVIOUS
56:38 PRESIDENTS SHOULD HAVE DONE. THAT'S ANOTHER ARGUMENT THAT HE
56:43 USES ABOUT THE IRAN WAR AS WELL. WHY?
56:45 IT'S HARD FOR ME TO ANSWER THAT, OTHER THAN TO SAY ASKING FOR
56:49 THAT BIG CHUNK OF CHANGE IS TRICKY AND TRICKY TO GET
56:52 CONGRESS BEHIND IT, AND CERTAINLY THE SECRETARY OF
56:57 TRANSPORTATION TRIED TO USE A GOOD CRISIS LAST NIGHT TO
57:00 ENCOURAGE THAT THAT FUNDING COME THEIR WAY.
57:02 CHRISTINA: JEFF, YOU HAVE A PERSONAL STAKE IN THIS STORY, AS
57:05 YOU ARE HOPEFULLY ALLEGEDLY HEADING TO ASIA TONIGHT FOR THIS
57:10 TRUMP-XI BILAT. IT NOW SEEMS THAT ELON MUSK IS
57:13 TRAVELING WITH THEM. I WONDER IF WE KNEW IF JENSEN
57:16 HUANG WAS EVER PLANNED TO BE ON THIS TRIP, AND HOW MUCH OF THAT
57:20 DISCUSSION WE EXPECT TO BE ABOUT WHAT'S HAPPENING WITH NVIDIA.
57:25 JEFF: GREAT QUESTION TOO. THE PRESIDENT DOESN'T LEAVE
57:28 UNTIL MONDAY FOR ASIA. HE'S STARTING IN THE
57:31 PHILIPPINES, AND THEN GO TO CHINA, WHERE HE'LL HAVE THE
57:35 MEETING WITH PRESIDENT XI, ALSO A TRILATERAL WITH PRESIDENT XI
57:38 AND PRESIDENT PUTIN, WHICH IS SOMETHING THAT HE'S WANTED TO
57:42 HAVE FOR A LONG TIME TO DISCUSS DENUCLEARIZATION.
57:43 TO YOUR SPECIFIC QUESTION, WE DON'T KNOW IF JENSEN HUANG WAS
57:47 INITIALLY SUPPOSED TO BE PART OF THIS OR NOT.
57:51 I THINK IT'S POSSIBLE THAT HE WASN'T, BECAUSE I WAS ON A
57:53 CONFERENCE CALL ALONG WITH ANOTHER COLLEAGUE OF MINE LAST
57:57 NIGHT WITH WHITE HOUSE OFFICIALS TALKING ABOUT THE TRIP.
58:00 ONE OF THE QUESTIONS THAT WAS POSED WAS, IS THERE A C.E.O.
58:02 DELEGATION? THE ANSWER WAS NO, OTHER THAN
58:04 ELON MUSK. THERE IS A C.E.O. FORUM THAT IS
58:11 HAPPENING IN CHINA THAT IS A SEPARATE INVITE, SO THERE WILL
58:13 SOMEBODY C.E.O.'S WHO SHOW UP FOR THAT.
58:16 BUT IT'S NOT LIKE LAST SPRING WHEN THE PRESIDENT WAS DOING A
58:20 STATE VISIT TO CHINA AND BROUGHT A WHOLE BUNCH OF C.E.O.'S WITH
58:24 HIM. DAVID: JEFF MASON, OUR WHITE
58:26 HOUSE CORRESPONDENT, THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
58:28 GOOD LUCK ON THAT TRIP. WE LOOK FORWARD TO CATCHING UP
58:30 WITH YOU ON THE OTHER SIDE. CHRISTINA: NVIDIA SHARES
58:34 FINISHED LOWER ON FRIDAY AFTER A CHAOTIC WEEK, AS WE'VE BEEN
58:37 TALKING ABOUT, SAW ITS FOUNDER JENSEN HUANG RESIGN AFTER
58:41 REPORTS OF SEVERAL EXTRAMARITAL AFFAIRS, INCLUDING ONE WITH A
58:44 SUSPECTED CHINESE SPY. NVIDIA DROPPED ANOTHER 2% ADDING
58:47 TO THE RECENT NOSE DIVE THAT BROUGHT THE MARKET CAP BEFORE $4
58:51 TRILLION, FAR BEHIND APPLE AS THE WORLD'S MOST VALUABLE
58:53 COMPANY. DAVID: AN INTERIM C.E.O. HAS
58:56 BEEN NAMED AM ITS SEARCH FOR A PERMANENT REPLACEMENT WILL
58:59 INCLUDE BOTH INTERNAL AND EXTERNAL CANDIDATES.
59:02 BLOOMBERG'S EMILY CHANG SAT DOWN WITH HUANG JUST ONE MONTH AGO
59:06 BEFORE THIS NEWS BROKE, AND SHE ASKED HIM ABOUT THE PRESSURES OF
59:09 LEADING ONE OF THE WORLD'S MOST VALUABLE COMPANIES AND WHO MIGHT
59:12 ONE DAY SUCCEED HIM. JENSEN: I'M RESPONSIBLE FOR AN
59:18 ENTIRE INDUSTRY, SO I THINK THE PRESSURE OF BEING THE C.E.O. IS
59:21 HIGH, AND IT'S SUPPOSED TO BE HIGH.
59:25 IT SHOULD NOT BE AN EASY JOB. IT SHOULDN'T BE A JOB THAT YOU
59:28 TAKE FOR GRANTED. WHEN I DECIDED TO BE C.E.O., I
59:33 DIDN'T REALIZE THE MAGNITUDE OF THE PRESSURE AND
59:35 RESPONSIBILITIES, BUT YOU KNOW, LOOK, THAT'S WHAT I SIGNED UP
59:38 FOR. SO NOW THAT MY FAMILY AND ALL OF
59:45 THE PEOPLE THAT ARE NEAR ME SEE THE RESPONSIBILITIES OF THE JOB
59:48 WHAT IT TAKES, THEN THEY JUST GET TO ASK THEMSELVES WHETHER
59:52 THIS IS THE LEVEL OF SACRIFICE AND RESPONSIBILITY YOU WANT.
59:55 AND I'M REALLY HOPING THAT THE NEXT C.E.O. OF THE COMPANY IS
1:00:00 ALREADY AT THE COMPANY, BUT 20 YEARS FROM NOW, I HOPE I STAY
1:00:05 HEALTHY AND I HOPE I CONTINUE TO EARN MY KEEP.
1:00:07 BUT SO LONG AS I CAN DO THAT 20 YEARS FROM NOW, I HOPE THEY'RE
1:00:12 ALREADY HERE AND THEY HAVE TO EARN IT.
1:00:14 DAVID: EMILY JOINS US FROM SAN FRANCISCO.
1:00:17 EMILY, JUST WILD TO WATCH THAT, TAPED JUST A FEW WEEKS AGO.
1:00:20 I IMAGINE IT'S EVEN MORE WILD FOR YOU TO HAVE WATCHED IT IN
1:00:23 LIGHT OF ALL THAT'S HAPPENED HERE.
1:00:25 HOW ARE YOU THINKING THROUGH WHAT HE WAS SAYING, WHAT'S
1:00:27 HAPPENED SINCE? HOW ARE YOU PROCESSING THESE
1:00:29 DEVELOPMENTS? AGAIN, YOU WERE TRAVELING WITH
1:00:31 HIM ON THIS BIG TRIP THROUGH EUROPE, AND AS YOU'VE WRITTEN,
1:00:35 HE WAS AT THE PRIME OF HIS POWERS.
1:00:38 IT WAS KIND OF A VICTORY TOUR FOR HIM.
1:00:43 JEN-SANITY AT ITS UTMOST. EMILY: WE WENT WITH HIM TO FOUR
1:00:46 COUNTRIES IN FOUR DAYS, AND OBVIOUSLY THIS ISN'T HOW WE
1:00:49 EXPECTED THE STORY TO PAN OUT, BUT WE REALIZE NOW THAT WE GOT
1:00:53 THE LAST WIDE-RANGING SITDOWN WITH HIM AS C.E.O.
1:00:56 AND WE WENT INTO IT KNOWING THAT THIS IS A COMPANY THAT DIDN'T
1:01:01 HAVE A CLEAR SUCCESSOR, NEVER DISCLOSED PUBLICLY A SUCCESSION
1:01:04 PLAN. THERE HAS BEEN SPECULATION HIS
1:01:06 DAUGHTER WORKS AT THE COMPANY, HIS SON WORKS AT THE COMPANY,
1:01:08 HIS SON-IN-LAW WORKS AT THE COMPANY.
1:01:12 SO I ASKED WHO MIGHT BE NEXT, BECAUSE INVESTORS HAVE SAID OVER
1:01:18 TIME, HOW CAN A $5 TRILLION COMPANY NOT HAVE A DESIGNATED
1:01:20 SUCCESSOR? AND HIS FAMILY IS SO INTERTWINED
1:01:23 IN THE COMPANY THAT THAT'S ANOTHER QUESTION HERE.
1:01:27 BUT HE BASICALLY PAINTED HIMSELF SO INDISPENSABLE IN TERMS OF THE
1:01:31 WAY HE RAN THE COMPANY WITH THIS FLAT MANAGEMENT STRUCTURE AND 60
1:01:34 DIRECT REPORTS THAT THERE WAS NO SECOND PERSON IN LINE, AND HE
1:01:38 OBVIOUSLY HAD THE EXPECTATION THAT HE WAS GOING TO BE THERE
1:01:42 FOR A COUPLE MORE DECADES. CHRISTINA: DO YOU THINK THAT WAS
1:01:43 STRATEGIC ON HIS PART? YOU SEE THIS WITH MUSK SOME OF
1:01:47 THE OTHER TECH LEADERS WHO ARE VERGING ON, YOU KNOW, ICON
1:01:51 STATUS, IF YOU ASK THEM, THAT THEY DON'T REALLY WANT TO
1:01:54 DESIGNATE A SUCCESSOR BECAUSE IN A WAY THAT DIMINISHES THEIR
1:01:56 INFLUENCE AND THEIR POWER AT THE CENTER OF THESE LITTLE
1:02:00 UNIVERSES. EMILY: QUITE POSSIBLY.
1:02:04 I MEAN, HE OBVIOUSLY CARES DEEPLY ABOUT THIS COMPANY,
1:02:07 HAVING RUN IT FOR 30 YEARS AND GROWN IT INTO THIS BEHEMOTH.
1:02:11 AND LIKE YOU MENTIONED, DAVID, WE SAW HIM AT SORT OF PEAK
1:02:17 JEN-SANITY WHERE THERE WERE DEVELOPERS OUT THE DOOR AND
1:02:19 AROUND THE BLOCK WAITING TO SEE HIM, EVERYONE WANTING TO GET A
1:02:21 PICTURE WITH HIM. YOU REALIZE HE'S NOT JUST THE
1:02:24 GUY AT THE CENTER OF THE A.I. BOOM AND NVIDIA'S CHIEF
1:02:28 SALESMAN, BUT HE'S ALSO SORT OF THE CHIEF DIPLOMAT.
1:02:31 HE WAS MEETING, GLAD HANDING WITH WORLD LEADERS AND TECH
1:02:34 C.E.O.'S. IN EACH OF THESE COUNTRIES, I
1:02:38 REALIZED HOW DEEPLY INTERTWINED HE IS IN NOT JUST NVIDIA'S
1:02:41 RELATIONSHIPS WITH COMPANIES, LIKE BIG A.I. COMPANIES, BUT
1:02:45 WITH COUNTRIES, AND WITH GOVERNMENTS.
1:02:48 YOU KNOW, HE MET WITH FRENCH PRESIDENT HE MAN I'M MACRON.
1:02:51 HE MET WITH THE PRIME MINISTER OF THE U.K. WHILE WE WERE THERE.
1:02:55 AND YOU HAVE TO WONDER IF THOSE RELATIONSHIPS ARE GOING TO BE
1:02:58 COMPROMISED IN THE NEXT PHASE OF THIS COMPANY.
1:03:00 DAVID: PICK AGO PART WHAT HE SAID THERE, THAT LINE ABOUT HOW
1:03:03 I HOPES THE NEXT C.E.O. WILL BE AT THE COMPANY ALREADY, SO
1:03:06 COLETTE KRESS ELEVATED TO THIS POSITION ON AN INTERIM BASIS.
1:03:09 WHAT DO YOU THINK ABOUT HER LONGER TERM PROSPECTS?
1:03:11 WHAT DO YOU THINK ABOUT THE SEARCH THAT IS, I ASSUME,
1:03:14 ALREADY UNDERWAY TO FIND A PERMANENT C.E.O.
1:03:16 AND AS I KNOW SO WELL, ALL OF THESE COMPANIES HAVE A UNIQUE
1:03:18 CULTURE TO THEM. HOW IMPORTANT IS IT THAT
1:03:22 SOMEBODY WHO IS ELEVATED TO C.E.O. COMES FROM WITHIN
1:03:25 NVIDIA'S RANKS? EMILY: EVERYTHING THAT I'VE
1:03:28 HEARD ABOUT COLETTE KRESS IS THAT SHE IS OBVIOUSLY A VERY
1:03:31 SEASONED EXECUTIVE WHO KNOWS THE COMPANY INSIDE AND OUT.
1:03:36 THERE WAS SOME SPECULATION THAT MAYBE SHE WOULD BE NAMED A SORT
1:03:41 OF CO-C.E.O. STRUCTURE WITH IAN BUCK, WHO IS THE CREATOR OF
1:03:45 KUDA, ALSO A VERY POWERFUL PERSON AT THE COMPANY.
1:03:48 I THINK NVIDIA PROBABLY WANTED TO GIVE ITSELF SOME FLEXIBILITY
1:03:53 IN TERMS OF LOOKING BOTH INSIDE AND OUTSIDE THE COMPANY.
1:03:57 AND THERE ARE A LOT OF GOVERNANCE ISSUES THAT THEY'RE
1:04:00 GOING TO HAVE TO DEAL WITH AS THEY FIGURE THIS PROCESS OUT.
1:04:04 THERE HAVE BEEN A NUMBER OF OUTSIDE NAMES FLOATED.
1:04:08 RENEE HAAS, THE F.T. JUST REPORTED SOMEONE REACHED OUT TO
1:04:10 HIM. HE OBVIOUSLY WORKED AT NVIDIA
1:04:11 PREVIOUSLY. HE KNOWS THE CHIP BUSINESS VERY
1:04:14 WELL. LISA SU, THE C.E.O. OF AMEND,
1:04:17 HER NAME HAS BEEN FLOATED, BUT SHE'S RUNNING A VERY SUCCESSFUL
1:04:20 COMPANY. AND ANYONE WHO COMES INTO THIS
1:04:23 SITUATION IS GOING TO HAVE TO DEAL WITH A LOT OF GOVERNANCE
1:04:28 ISSUES, WITH GOVERNMENT INVESTIGATIONS, WITH THIS WHOLE
1:04:32 CHINA ISSUE. AND ON THE CHINA PART OF IT,
1:04:38 OBVIOUSLY JENSEN, WE TALKED ABOUT WHEN WE WERE IN EUROPE,
1:04:41 AND HE SORT OF REITERATED THE STANCE THAT THE U.S. SHOULD BE
1:04:44 SELLING ITS MOST ADVANCED CHIPS TO CHINA, BECAUSE OTHERWISE
1:04:50 CHINA WILL DEVELOP ITS OWN CAPABILITIES AND THAT PUTS U.S.
1:04:53 IN A BAD POSITION. MY UNDERSTANDING IS COLETTE
1:04:56 KRESS FELT THE SAME WAY. SO IF THERE ARE NATIONAL
1:04:58 SECURITY IMPLICATIONS HERE, THAT'S A MUCH BIGGER ISSUE.
1:05:02 AND LAWMAKERS ARE GOING TO WANT TO KNOW WHAT EVERYONE KNEW AT
1:05:06 THE COMPANY, NOT JUST JENSEN HUANG.
1:05:07 CHRISTINA: I WAS TRYING TO EXPLAIN TO SOMEBODY WHO'S NOT IN
1:05:10 THIS WORLD AT ALL WHY THIS MATTERS TODAY.
1:05:12 THEY'RE SAYING, WHAT IS THE BIG DEAL, WHAT'S GOING ON?
1:05:15 IT'S NOT JUST THAT HE HAS A MESSY PERSONAL LIFE, IT'S THAT
1:05:18 PART OF THIS MESSY PERSONAL LIFE IS WITH SOMEONE WHO MIGHT HAVE
1:05:21 BEEN AN AGENT OF THE CHINESE GOVERNMENT, AND THIS IS THE
1:05:25 PERSON WHO WAS THE FACE OF THIS ISSUE ON THE DIPLOMATIC FRONT,
1:05:27 LOBBYING THE WHITE HOUSE. YOU JUST MENTIONED, LOBBYING
1:05:30 FOREIGN GOVERNMENTS. WE HAVE SOUND FROM YOUR
1:05:32 INTERVIEW WHERE YOU ASKED HIM ABOUT THIS ISSUE.
1:05:38 JENSEN: I DID MY BEST TO INFORM THE POLICY MAKERS IN THE UNITED
1:05:42 STATES OF THE IMPORTANCE OF ENGAGING THE CHINESE MARKET AND
1:05:46 MAKING SURE THAT WE SERVE THAT MARKET FOR AS LONG AS WE CAN.
1:05:52 I THINK WE MADE A MISTAKE, AND THIS MISTAKE IS HARD TO UNWIND.
1:05:56 BUT I DID MY BEST. THAT'S ALL I COULD DO.
1:06:01 THERE ARE MORE CHINESE A.I. RESEARCHERS THAN ANY OTHER
1:06:05 NATION IN THE WORLD. AND MANY OF THEM WORKING AT THE
1:06:07 LABS. I'VE BEEN VERY CLEAR THAT EVEN
1:06:12 THOUGH, ALTHOUGH WE COMPETE AGAINST CHINA, THEY'RE NOT OUR
1:06:18 ENEMIES. CHRISTINA: HE WAS A VERY
1:06:20 SINGULAR ADVOCATE FOR THIS POLICY, AND I'M WONDERING EVEN
1:06:22 IF COLETTE KRESS, EVEN IF WHOEVER IS DESIGNATED HIS
1:06:24 EVENTUAL SUCCESSOR FEELS THE SAME WAY, WILL PEOPLE LISTEN IN
1:06:29 THE SAME WAY? EMILY: YOU KNOW, I THINK
1:06:32 OBVIOUSLY HIS CREDIBILITY IS UNDERMINED, AND THERE ARE A LOT
1:06:34 OF QUESTIONS ABOUT WHAT PEOPLE AT THE COMPANY KNEW.
1:06:38 AND YOU HAVE TO LISTEN TO THOSE COMMENTS THERE NOW AND LOOK AT
1:06:40 IT WITH A DIFFERENT LENS, BECAUSE IF HE WAS BEING
1:06:44 INFLUENCED BY A POTENTIAL ASSET FOR THE CHINESE GOVERNMENT OVER
1:06:49 MAYBE SEVERAL YEARS, I MEAN, THE REPORTING IS THAT HE WAS FIRST
1:06:51 INTRODUCED TO ALICE HUANG BASICALLY A DECADE AGO, THAT'S A
1:06:58 LONG TIME FOR SOMEONE ELSE TO POTENTIALLY SHAPE YOUR VIEWS.
1:07:03 AND SO THIS IS NOT JUST AN NVIDIA DECISION NOW.
1:07:06 I MOON, HE'S GOING TO BE TESTIFYING BEFORE CONGRESS NEXT
1:07:09 WEEK, THE COMMERCE SECRETARY, HOWARD LUTNICK IS NOW UNDER
1:07:12 SCRUTINY, AND LAWMAKERS HAVE MADE IT VERY CLEAR THEY'RE NOT
1:07:16 GOING TO LET THIS COMPANY OFF EASY.
1:07:18 I THINK THERE WAS SOME THOUGHT THAT MAYBE NVIDIA WAS TRYING TO,
1:07:21 YOU KNOW, IF JENSEN WAS OUT THE DOOR, THAT MAYBE THAT WOULD BE
1:07:23 THE END OF IT. BUT I THINK WE'RE HEARING FROM
1:07:28 GOVERNMENT LEADERS THAT THEY WANT MORE ANSWERS, AND THEY WANT
1:07:33 TO KNOW WHO KNEW WHAT WHEN. DAVID: YOU'VE WRITTEN A BOOK
1:07:37 ABOUT CULTURAL SEXUAL POLITICS OF SILICON VALLEY, AND IT'S HARD
1:07:40 TO PUT ASIDE WHAT LED TO THIS, THAT IS, HE HAD AN AFFAIR WITH A
1:07:45 CUSTOMER OF NVIDIA AT THE VERY LEAST.
1:07:47 AND TWO RELATIONSHIPS THAT WE KNOW OF REPORTEDLY WITH MEMBERS
1:07:50 OF HIS STAFF. WHAT IS THE REACTION IN SILICON
1:07:53 VALLEY MORE BROADLY HERE TO WHAT'S HAPPENED AT NVIDIA OVER
1:07:57 THE LAST COUPLE OF WEEKS? EMILY: I WOULD SAY GROUP CHATS
1:08:00 IN SILICON VALLEY ARE HAVING A MOMENT OF JEN-SANITY.
1:08:06 I MEAN, THEY HAVE EXPLODED. AND OF COURSE, THERE ARE A LOT
1:08:10 OF WOMEN IN THESE CHATS SAYING NOT AGAIN.
1:08:11 EVEN JENSEN, RIGHT? I MEAN, THIS IS LIKE A TALE THAT
1:08:18 WE HAVE HEARD TOO MANY TIMES IN SILICON VALLEY WITH PEOPLE THAT
1:08:24 WERE ICONS AND DEEPLY RESPECTED PEOPLE THAT OUR CHILDREN LOOK UP
1:08:29 TO, RIGHT? I SPOKE A WOMAN WHO MADE A
1:08:32 REALLY GREAT POINT THAT WE'RE KIND OF COMPLICIT IN MAKING A
1:08:36 LOT OF THESE PEOPLE FEEL LIKE THEY ARE GODS, AND WHEN YOU HAVE
1:08:40 SO MUCH MONEY AND POWER, YOU DO THINGS -- AND NO ONE EVER SAYS
1:08:42 NO TO YOU. YOU DO THINGS THAT CAN
1:08:46 POTENTIALLY BE VERY, VERY BAD. THE OTHER INTERESTING THING, AND
1:08:49 I'M SURE YOU GUYS HAVE SEEN THIS ON SOCIAL MEDIA, IS THERE ARE A
1:08:52 LOT OF PEOPLE DEFENDING JENSEN AND SAYING WE SHOULD GIVE HIM
1:08:56 ANOTHER CHANCE. IN MANY OF THESE CASES, I
1:09:01 BELIEVE JENSEN HAS MADE A LOT OF PEOPLE A LOT OF MONEY, SO THE
1:09:04 PEOPLE WHO ARE SAYING THAT AREN'T NECESSARILY DISCLOSING
1:09:10 WHY THEY'RE SAYING THAT. SO HE DOES HAVE -- AND LOOK,
1:09:14 NVIDIA IS AN INCREDIBLE COMPANY, AN INCREDIBLE ORGANIZATION.
1:09:18 THEY HAVE THE BEST A.I. CHIPS ON THE MARKET.
1:09:23 IT'S SUCH A DEEP BENCH OF TALENT AND SUCH INCREDIBLE TECHNOLOGY,
1:09:31 BUT YOU CAN'T LOOK PAST THE HEAD OF THE COMPANY VIOLATING THE
1:09:36 COMPANY'S OWN POLICY MULTIPLE TIMES.
1:09:42 AND THERE IS A RANGE OF REACTIONS FROM THEORY TO
1:09:46 OBVIOUSLY SUPPORT, BUT IN THIS CASE THIS IS A MAN AND A COMPANY
1:09:52 THAT MADE A LOT OF PEOPLE PROFITABLE.
1:09:53 CHRISTINA: AN INTERESTING REACTION FROM THE MAN HIMSELF.
1:09:56 BLOOMBERG HAS REPORTED THAT YOU JUST TALKED ABOUT THE BRAVADO,
1:10:01 AND WE KNOW THE JACKETS, AND A VERY CONFIDENT HUMAN.
1:10:03 THAT IS NOT HOW HE REACTED IN FRONT OF THE BOARD, CALLING
1:10:08 HIMSELF A PIECE OF EXPLETIVE. DO WE KNOW, I MEAN, HAVE YOU
1:10:10 REACHED OUT TO HIM? DO WE KNOW WHAT HE'S DOING NEXT?
1:10:13 WHAT CAN HE DO NEXT? EMILY: I DID REACH OUT TO HIM.
1:10:18 I DID NOT HEAR BACK. I DIDN'T NECESSARILY EXPECT TO.
1:10:25 MY GUESS IS THAT HE IS FOCUSING ON HIS FAMILY FIRST, BECAUSE
1:10:29 HE'S HURT A LOT OF PEOPLE. AND AS I SAID, HIS FAMILY WAS
1:10:33 DEEPLY INTERTWINED WITH THE COMPANY AS WELL.
1:10:34 WE KNOW HE'S GOING TO BE TESTIFYING BEFORE CONGRESS NEXT
1:10:36 WEEK. ELON MUSK HAS SAID IT WOULD BE
1:10:39 AN HONOR TO HIRE HIM. CHRISTINA: I SAW THAT.
1:10:44 EMILY: THIS IS A GUY WHO WILL BE CERTAINLY SOUGHT AFTER IF HE
1:10:48 INDEED FULLY MOVES ON. BUT HE'S GOT A LOT OF THINGS TO
1:10:52 WORRY ABOUT BEFORE TAKING A NEW JOB.
1:10:56 DAVID: LET ME ASK YOU WHERE YOU THINK THE STORY IS NEXT.
1:10:58 DOES IT REMAIN IN SILICON VALLEY WITH THE FOCUS ON EARNINGS AND
1:11:01 THE TOWN HALL NEXT WEEK? DOES IT SHIFT TO THIS CONFERENCE
1:11:05 WHERE THE PRESIDENT IS GOING TO BE, MEETING WITH HIS CHINESE
1:11:08 COUNTER PART? OR IS IT WASHINGTON?
1:11:10 WHAT'S GOING TO BE THE GEOGRAPHY OF THE MOST IMPORTANCE IN THE
1:11:12 WEEKS AHEAD? EMILY: THIS STORY IS ALL OF
1:11:14 THOSE THINGS. THIS STORY IS HUGE.
1:11:19 AND IT'S ONLY GOTTEN BIGGER, YOU KNOW?
1:11:21 THERE'S CLEARLY GOING TO BE A CONTINUING STORY IN WASHINGTON
1:11:24 WITH WHAT LAWMAKERS HAVE SAID ABOUT NOT WANTING TO GIVE UP ON
1:11:26 THIS. THERE'S CLEARLY A HUGE STORY
1:11:29 HERE IN SILICON VALLEY WHERE THIS COMPANY IS SCRAMBLING, AND
1:11:32 IT'S GOING TO BE A DIFFERENT COMPANY AFTER JENSEN.
1:11:35 IT WILL SURVIVE, BUT THE QUESTION IS WILL IT THRIVE IN
1:11:41 THE SAME WAY, AND OVERALL, I THINK THERE'S THIS RECKONING
1:11:44 WITH THE TECH INDUSTRY IN GENERAL, WHERE THE TECH INDUSTRY
1:11:47 HAS LOST A LOT OF TRUST OVER THE YEARS.
1:11:48 THIS IS JUST ANOTHER EXAMPLE OF THAT.
1:11:49 AND THEN YOU HAVE WHAT'S GOING ON IN CHINA.
1:11:53 THERE'S THIS MEETING BETWEEN PRESIDENT TRUMP AND PRESIDENT
1:11:55 XI. THERE'S MALAYSIA LOOKING INTO
1:11:59 CHIP EXPORTS AND WHERE SOME OF THESE CHIPS HAVE BEEN ENDING UP.
1:12:05 IT'S AN INTERNATIONAL EVENT, AND I THINK IT'S GOING TO CONTINUE
1:12:08 TO KEEP UNFOLDING. DAVID: EMILY CHANG, CALL THAT
1:12:13 KISMET. THE ENTIRE PIECE IS INCREDIBLE.
1:12:16 YOU CAN WATCH THE BLOOMBERG ORIGINALS EPISODE OF "THE
1:12:19 CIRCUIT," AVAILABLE NOW AT BLOOMBERG.COM AND ON YOUTUBE.
1:12:23 AS EMILY MENTIONED, COMMERCE SECRETARY HOWARD LUTNICK IS
1:12:25 FACING QUESTIONS FROM CONGRESS OVER THE NVIDIA CRISIS AND HIS
1:12:28 MANAGEMENT OF AMERICA'S CHIP POLICY.
1:12:30 BUT IF HE'S LOOKING FOR SUPPORT FROM THE TREASURY SECRETARY,
1:12:36 THAT DOES NOT SEEM LIKELY. >> TREASURY WARNED USTR AND
1:12:40 STATE THEY WERE IN FAVOR OF PUTTING MEGASPEED ON THE ENTITY
1:12:46 LIST FOR MONTHS, BUT COMMERCE HAS THE PEN, AND YOU WILL HAVE
1:12:50 TO ASK THEM ABOUT THEIR INTERNAL PROCESSES.
1:12:53 CHRISTINA: JOINING US NOW IS AXIOS A.I. REPORTER MARIA.
1:12:57 YOU HAVE A COUPLE OFABLES THIS WEEK ABOUT THE TENSIONS -- A
1:12:59 COUPLE OF ARTICLES THIS WEEK ABOUT THE TENSIONS AMONG THE
1:13:02 CABINET AND IN THE OLD OFFICE AT TIMES.
1:13:05 AT ONE POINT YOU ASK THAT'S AN ASK HUT LICK POINT-BLANK, WHY
1:13:08 ISN'T MEGASPEED -- OF COURSE, ALICE HUANG'S COMPANY -- WHY
1:13:11 WASN'T IT ON THE LIST? WHAT WAS THE RESPONSE, AND HOW
1:13:19 HAS LUTNICK BEEN RUSS CENT TO LIST THE COMPANY?
1:13:23 MARIA: SECRETARY LUTNICK SAYS I'LL LOOK INTO IT, AND HE
1:13:26 STUMBLES INTO THAT RESPONSE, IN A SIGN FOR OTHER HIGH-LOVELY
1:13:29 ADMINISTRATION OFFICIALS IN THAT MOMENT THAT THE SECRETARY DIDN'T
1:13:33 NECESSARILY HAVE THE BEST HANDLE ON A COMPANY THAT WAS AT THE
1:13:40 CENTER OF POTENTIAL CHINESE ESPIONAGE THROUGH ONE OF THE
1:13:43 MOST IMPORTANT AMERICAN C.E.O.'S.
1:13:45 WHAT WE JUST HEARD THERE FROM TREASURY SECRETARY SCOTT BESSENT
1:13:48 IS ESSENTIALLY CONFIRMATION OF OUR REPORTING THAT THROUGHOUT
1:13:52 THE COURSE OF THE YEAR, YOU HAVE VARIOUS SENIOR-LEVEL
1:13:54 ADMINISTRATION OFFICIALS THAT FOR MONTHS HAVE HAD THIS
1:13:57 INTELLIGENCE, THAT JENSEN HUANG HAD THIS AFFAIR WITH ALICE
1:14:02 HUANG, A SUSPECTED CHINESE SPY, AND THAT THIS COMPANY THAT SHE
1:14:07 IS AN EXECUTIVE AT SHOULD BE PLACED ON THIS THING CALLED AN
1:14:11 ENTITY LIST, WHICH WOULD ESSENTIALLY MEAN THAT YOU CANNOT
1:14:16 EXPORT SENSITIVE TECHNOLOGIES TO THIS COMPANY BECAUSE OF
1:14:19 SUSPICIONS THAT THEY ARE BEING REROUTED ILLEGALLY TO CHINA.
1:14:22 OF COURSE, THE COMMERCE DEPARTMENT AND B.I.S., THE
1:14:25 AGENCY WITHIN THE COMMERCE DEPARTMENT THAT IS HEADED BY
1:14:30 UNDERSECRETARY JEFF KESSLER, THEY'RE IN CHARGE OF CREATING
1:14:32 THIS LIST OF COMPANIES THAT NEED TO BE ON THIS LIST ARE ON THERE,
1:14:35 AND THAT HAS NOT HAPPENED ALL YEAR.
1:14:38 DAVID: I WANT TO ASK ABOUT THE RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN SECRETARY
1:14:39 LUTNICK AND JENSEN HUANG. IT WAS ABOUT A YEAR AGO I WAS IN
1:14:45 WASHINGTON FOR THE BIG NVIDIA CONFAB.
1:14:47 I WAS CATCHING ONE OUR COLLEAGUE, ED LUDLOW, ON THE
1:14:49 SIDELINES OF THAT. IT WAS A HUGE EVENT.
1:14:52 PART WAS A ON-SCREEN CONVERSATION BETWEEN THE
1:14:53 SECRETARY OF COMMERCE AND THE NOW FORMER C.E.O. OF NVIDIA.
1:14:57 LET'S LISTEN TO WHAT JENSEN HUANG HAD TO SAY.
1:14:59 >> HOWARD IS THE PERSON I TALK TO MOST IN THE ADMINISTRATION.
1:15:03 AND HE'S ON TOP OF THE TECHNOLOGY.
1:15:05 HE'S LEARNING ABOUT THE INDUSTRY QUICKLY.
1:15:07 I ANNOUNCED A HISTORIC PARTNERSHIP TODAY, AND HE WAS
1:15:09 THE FIRST TO KNOW ABOUT IT. DAVID: WE WERE TALKING ABOUT HOW
1:15:13 DIFFERENT CABINET OFFICIALS ARE POSITIONED HERE.
1:15:16 HOW ABOUT THIS RELATIONSHIP? HOW INTEGRAL WAS IT?
1:15:19 HOW DID THESE TWO BECOME SO TIGHT?
1:15:21 WHAT DO WE KNOW ABOUT THE RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN LUTNICK AND
1:15:23 HUANG? MARIA: WHAT WE KNOW IS NVIDIA
1:15:28 AND JENSEN HUANG HAS BEEN LOBBYING THE TRUMP
1:15:30 ADMINISTRATION WRIT LARGE VERY HARD FOR A WHILE NOW, TO ENSURE
1:15:34 THAT THE POLICIES THAT THE COMPANY WANTS ARE IN PLACE, AND
1:15:37 THAT THE CHINESE MARKET IS OPEN TO NVIDIA.
1:15:42 IRRESPECTIVE OF THIS AFFAIR WITH ALICE HUANG, JENSEN HUANG FOR A
1:15:48 WHILE HAS WANTED H200 CHIPS, NOT THEIR MOST ADVANCED CHIPS, BUT
1:15:52 STILL POWERFUL TECHNOLOGY GOING TO CHINA.
1:15:55 THE ARGUMENT BEING THAT IT WOULD MAKE THIS U.S. ADVERSARY RELIANT
1:15:58 ON THE U.S. SO THAT WAS THE PITCH THE TRUMP
1:16:02 ADMINISTRATION AND THE MOST IMPORTANT PERSON TO CONVINCE OF
1:16:05 THAT ARGUMENT, NUMBER ONE, WAS PRESIDENT TRUMP, AND NUMBER TWO,
1:16:10 WAS COMMERCE SECRETARY HOWARD LUTNICK, BECAUSE HE DOES OVERSEE
1:16:13 THE DEPARTMENT THAT INFLUENCES THAT WE FEEL.
1:16:16 SO YOU HEAR THERE, JENSEN HUANG SAYING HE'S THE PERSON THAT I
1:16:19 SPEAK THE MOST TO, HOWARD LUTNICK.
1:16:21 BUT THEN YOU ALSO HAD JENSEN HUANG CALLING PRESIDENT TRUMP
1:16:23 DIRECTLY ON THE STAGE, AND PRESIDENT TRUMP ANSWERING THE
1:16:26 PHONE CALL. I THINK THAT HE HAD VERY CLOSE
1:16:30 RELATIONSHIPS WITH THE PEOPLE HE NEEDED TO HAVE IN ORDER TO
1:16:32 INFLUENCE POLICY, AND IT'S IMPORTANT TO REMEMBER HERE THAT,
1:16:35 YES, COMMERCE SECRETARY HOWARD LUTNICK IS THE PERSON IN CHARGE
1:16:39 OF THIS DEPARTMENT, BUT THE ULTIMATE DECIDER IS PRESIDENT
1:16:40 TRUMP. CHRISTINA: I'M WONDERING IF YOU
1:16:45 HAVE ANY INSIGHT INTO WHY LUTNICK SEEMS TO STILL BE
1:16:47 MARRIED TO THIS POLICY, WHY HE SEEMS TO BE THE LONE HOLDOUT.
1:16:51 I MEAN, IT'S IMPORTANT TO SAY THE COMMERCE SECRETARY DENIES
1:16:53 SOME OF THIS CONFRONTATION REPORTING AND SAYING IT'S FALSE.
1:16:56 BUT YOU WRITE THAT TRUMP CALLED TECH ADVISOR ELON MUSK AND
1:17:00 AGREED TO MOVE FORWARD WITH LIMITS ON MEGASPEED.
1:17:07 MUSK SUPPORTERS RUBIO, LUTNICK, HEGSETH WERE PRO IMPOSING
1:17:09 CONTROLS, AND LUTNICK SEEMS TO SLOW WALK THIS AND NOT BE
1:17:12 WILLING TO TAKE IMMEDIATE ACTION.
1:17:13 DO WE HAVE ANY IDEA WHAT STAKE HE HAS IN THIS OR WHY HE WOULD
1:17:16 BE MARRIED TO THIS POLICY? MARIA: WE KNOW THAT ONE OF THE
1:17:19 THINGS HE BROUGHT UP IN ONE OF THESE MEETINGS WAS THE TRADE WAR
1:17:25 WITH CHINA AND WANTING TO CONTINUE TO HAVE GOOD RELATIONS
1:17:29 WITH CHINA AHEAD OF POTENTIALLY ANOTHER TRIP THIS MONTH.
1:17:34 IN TERMS. COMMERCE DEPARTMENT DENYING THIS
1:17:38 REPORTING, WE DID HEAR DIRECTLY FROM SECRETARY BESSENT
1:17:41 CONFIRMING THIS DISAGREEMENT HAS EXISTED, THAT YOU HAVE A WIDE
1:17:45 RANGE OF ADMINISTRATION OFFICIALS WANTING TO TAKE ACTION
1:17:47 AGAINST MEGASPEED, AND THE COMMERCE SUPPORT KIND OF BEING
1:17:50 THE LONE HOLDOUT. THERE HAS BEEN MORE REPORTING AS
1:17:55 WELL THE COMMERCE TO TAKE ACTION AGAINST MEGASPEED.
1:17:57 THERE HAS ALSO BEEN REPORTING THAT THE ADMINISTRATION IS
1:18:00 TAKING ITS LEAD FROM PRESIDENT TRUMP.
1:18:02 STEPPING BACK A LITTLE BIT, YOU ARE POTENTIALLY ALSO SEEING WHO
1:18:05 WILL BE THE PERSON WHO IS HELD THE MOST ACCOUNTABLE FOR THESE
1:18:08 REVELATIONS, ESPECIALLY AS SCRUTINY ON THE HILL HEATS UP.
1:18:13 RIGHT NOW, ALL THE FOCUS IS ON JENSEN HUANG AND
1:18:18 JEFFREY KESSLER. BUT WHEN DEMOCRATS TAKE CONTROL
1:18:24 PRESIDENT ITSELF. -- ON THE PRESIDENT HIMSELF.
1:18:33 DAVID: YOU HAVE THE TREASURY SECRETARY CONFIRMING REPORTING.
1:18:36 MAYBE YOU CAN UNDERLINE HOW IMPORTANT OR SEISMIC THAT WAS,
1:18:39 HIS COMING OUT AND SAYING EXPLICITLY HE HAS BEEN FOLLOWING
1:18:42 FOR SO MANY YEARS NOW THE INTERNAL POLITICS BETWEEN THESE
1:18:43 TWO INDIVIDUALS. THEY WERE JOCKEYING FOR THE JOB
1:18:46 THAT SECRETARY BESSENT ULTIMATELY GOT.
1:18:50 MARIA: I THINK IT ILLUSTRATES THE INTERNAL STRIFE WE ARE
1:18:52 SEEING IN THE TRUMP ADMINISTRATION AS WELL AROUND A
1:18:55 REALLY KEY POLICY. I MEAN, AT THE END OF THE DAY,
1:19:00 IT SHOWS HOW DIFFERENT ADMINISTRATION OFFICIALS HAVE
1:19:03 HAD DIFFERENT GOALS, AND IT ULTIMATELY HAS BEEN AT THE
1:19:10 SPENCE OF -- AT THE EXPENSE OF U.S. NATIONAL SECURITY.
1:19:14 THIS HAS EXISTED SINCE AT LEAST MAY WIN STATE SECRETARY MARCO
1:19:16 RUBIO OVERSAW THE DRAFTING OF THIS MEMO AND SHARED IT WITH
1:19:22 HIGH-LEVEL ADMINISTRATION OFFICIALS AND PERSONALLY HANDED
1:19:22 IT TO PRESIDENT TRUMP HIMSELF ON AIR FORCE ONE.
1:19:26 WHY NO ACTION HAS BEEN TAKEN SINCE THEN, I'M NOT SURE.
1:19:31 THE COMMERCE DEPARTMENT, IT IS WORTH NOTING, HAS BEGUN US DROP
1:19:34 IT -- A PROCESS OF STOPPING REMOTE ACCESS, WHICH IS ALSO
1:19:38 REACHING CHINA. BUT MORE HAS TO BE DONE.
1:19:47 CHRISTINA: MARIA CURI, THANK YOU FOR JOINING US.
1:19:52 DAVID: SPACEX'S MOST AMBITIOUS TEST OFF TO A ROCKY START AS THE
1:19:54 BOOSTER EXPLODED OVER THE WATER. CHRISTINA: NOW THE FOCUS TURNS
1:19:59 TO THE ATTEMPT LATER TODAY TO CATCH THE ROCKET ITSELF.
1:20:03 JOINING US IS ROSS HAMILTON, COFOUNDER OF SPACE NETWORK.
1:20:05 EVERYONE HERE HAS BEEN CALLING YOU THE SPACE GRINCH.
1:20:06 [LAUGHTER] DAVID: THE SKEPTIC.
1:20:11 CHRISTINA: WHY IS THIS DIFFERENT?
1:20:12 WHY IS THIS COOL? WHY SHOULD I BE EXCITED ABOUT
1:20:14 THIS? ROSS: GOOD TO SEE YOU AGAIN.
1:20:18 THERE ARE A COUPLE THINGS QUITE HISTORIC ABOUT THIS LAUNCHING
1:20:21 AND THERE ARE TWO PARTS TO IT. THE FIRST PART IS THE START
1:20:30 ITSELF, THE ONE ON OF THE HEAVIEST AND BUSIEST ROCKETS
1:20:31 EVER. BUT THE STARSHIP THAT SITS AT
1:20:35 TOP OF IT REPRESENTS WHERE THE COMPANY IS GOING WITH
1:20:38 REUSABILITY, AND WHAT IS ABOUT TO HAPPEN HOPEFULLY THIS
1:20:41 AFTERNOON IS THEY ARE GOING TO CATCH THAT STARSHIP, AND THAT IS
1:20:48 GOING TO REPRESENT REAL PROGRESS WITH NOT JUST RECYCLING AND
1:20:50 REUSING THESE ROCKETS WERE REALLY INCREASING THE RATE AT
1:20:58 WHICH ELON MUSK WILL BE PITCHING THINGS INTO SPACE.
1:21:00 ALL OF THAT HAS IMPLICATIONS FOR THE BROADER SPACE INDUSTRY.
1:21:04 DAVID: LET'S TALK ABOUT THOSE IMPLICATIONS.
1:21:06 WE CAN PUT ASIDE THE MOON AND MARS, BUT NEARER TERM, WHAT IS
1:21:09 SPACEX TRYING TO DO WITH THE REGULAR USE OF THE SPACECRAFT?
1:21:14 ROSS: THERE ARE A COUPLE THINGS. ONE IS THE ACTUAL CAPACITY.
1:21:18 PUTTING THE ROCKETS UP WILL ALLOW THEM TO DEPLOY THEIR NEW
1:21:22 STARLINK CONSTELLATION. THAT IS GOING TO CHANGE THE GAME
1:21:26 IN TERMS OF CONNECTING EARTH. IT IS GOING TO DRIVE AND BE
1:21:32 DRIVEN BY THEIR OWN AI AMBITIONS IN TERMS OF MANUFACTURING CHIPS
1:21:36 AND REALLY BECOMING MAY BE SECOND TO NVIDIA IN TERMS OF AI.
1:21:45 IT ALSO MEANS A ORBITAL DATA CENTERS WHICH PEOPLE HAVE TALKED
1:21:46 ABOUT WILL START TO BECOME MORE OF A REALITY AS WE ARE ABLE TO
1:21:50 GET THAT EQUIPMENT UP IN SPACE. A FEW OTHER THINGS ARE TIED
1:21:55 TO THIS. I KNOW YOU DON'T WANT TO TALK
1:21:57 WITH THE MOON AND MARS, BUT IT WILL START TO SHOW US WHAT THIS
1:22:00 STARSHIP CAN REALLY DO WHEN IT WANTS TO LEAVE EARTH'S ORBIT.
1:22:05 REFUELING OTHER STARSHIPS AND REALLY GETTING THE PASS --
1:22:10 THE CAPACITY TO GET TO THE MOON. CHRISTINA: WHEN WE TALK ABOUT
1:22:14 SPACEX, WE TALK ABOUT THE PARTS THAT ARE PROFITABLE, AND THE
1:22:17 PARTS THAT ARE NOT. IS THIS PART OF THE COMPANY
1:22:18 PROFITABLE? WILL IT BE IN THE NEAR TERM?
1:22:22 ROSS: THE LAUNCH PART? CHRISTINA: THE IN GENERAL.
1:22:26 ARE THEY MAKING MONEY OFF THESE MASSIVE ROCKET SHIPS?
1:22:29 ROSS: THE ROCKET SHIPS THEMSELVES ARE NOT MAKING MONEY.
1:22:31 BUT OVER TIME, IT IS TO BRING DOWN THE COST AND RING AND MORE
1:22:35 CUSTOMERS, THAT COULD BE PROFITABLE.
1:22:37 BUT I THINK THE REAL GROWTH WILL BE IN AI, THE CHIPS, AND THE
1:22:39 STARLINK CONNECTIVITY. DAVID: ROSS HAMILTON JOINING US
1:22:45 HERE AS WE WAIT FOR THE RETURN OF THE SECOND PART OF THE
1:22:46 SPACECRAFT LATER TODAY. IT WILL BE SOMETHING TO BEHOLD.
1:22:52 MAYBE WE WILL GET YOU TO WATCH IT.
1:22:55 CHRISTINA: I AM AS LIKELY TO WATCH THAT AS I AM THE MANY
1:22:58 KNICKS GAMES YOU TRY TO GET ME TO WATCH.
1:23:01 DAVID: WOW. THE GAUNTLET HAS BEEN THROWN.
1:23:04 I AM RENDERED SPEECHLESS AS A RESULT.
1:23:07 COMING UP, JENSEN HUANG'S ABRUPT DEPARTURE ADDED MORE ANXIETIES
1:23:09 AND MARKETS ALREADY RATTLED OVER AI AND DATA CENTER SPENDING.
1:23:14 WE WILL TALK WITH OUR GUEST IN JUST A MOMENT ON "BLOOMBERG THIS
1:23:17 WEEKEND" I'M BLOOMBERG TELEVISION AND THE BLOOMBERG
1:23:19 APP. ♪
1:23:24 LISA: THANK YOU FOR JOINING US. LET'S UPDATE YOU ON TODAY'S TOP
1:23:27 STORIES. THE U.S. HAS LOST ITS MEASLES
1:23:28 ELIMINATION STATUS. THE WALL STREET JOURNAL SAYS
1:23:33 PAN-AMERICAN HEALTH ORGANIZATION HAS REVOKED IT AS OUTBREAKS
1:23:38 CONTINUE TO RISE AND VACCINE UPTAKE FALLS.
1:23:41 IN ORDER TO REGAIN THE STANDING, THE U.S. MUST STOP THE SPREAD OF
1:23:44 MEASLES FOR AT LEAST 12 MONTHS, WHICH COULD TAKE YEARS OF PUBLIC
1:23:47 HEALTH WORK. POPE LEO RETURNED TO THE CITY
1:23:51 WHERE HE SPENT EIGHT YEARS AS BISHOP BEFORE HE WAS CALLED TO
1:23:52 ROME. THE PONTIFF SAID IT WAS A JOY TO
1:23:58 BE HOME AND THE PEOPLE WERE TEACHING HIM -- THANKED THE
1:24:00 PEOPLE FOR TEACHING HIM HOW TO BE A SHEPHERD.
1:24:03 ONE MILLION PEOPLE LINED HIS MOTORCADE ROUTE ON THE WAY TO
1:24:07 MASS THAT 5000 PEOPLE ATTENDED.
1:24:10 ROCKY FANS GATHERED AT THE PHILADELPHIA MUSEUM OF ART TO
1:24:14 HONOR HIS LEGACY 50 YEARS AFTER THE FILM WAS RELEASED.
1:24:17 THEY WERE DRESSED IN THE SIGNATURE BLACK BEANIE, GRAY
1:24:20 SWEATSUIT, AND BLACK HIGH TOP CONVERSE.
1:24:24 THEY BROKE A WORLD GUINNESS RECORD.
1:24:28 >> TO SEE THAT EVERYONE ELSE FEELS INSPIRED BY ROCKY, THAT
1:24:31 NEVER GIVE UP ATTITUDE, JUST KEEP PERSEVERING AND KEEP
1:24:34 PUSHING THROUGH NO MATTER WHAT ADVERSITIES YOU FACE, IT IS JUST
1:24:36 OTHERWORLDLY. LISA: GOT TO LOVE IT.
1:24:43 TODAY, 45,000 RUNNERS WILL PARTICIPATE IN A ROCKY RUN
1:24:46 THROUGHOUT THE CITY. AS YOU KNOW, SYLVESTER STALLONE
1:24:48 WROTE AND STARRED IN THE FILM. DAVID: AND HIS MEMOIR AS WELL.
1:24:55 I HAVE NEVER SEEN THE MOVIE. LISA: YOU'VE NEVER SEEN ROCKY?
1:25:00 CHRISTINA: I'VE SEEN PARTS OF IT.
1:25:02 LISA: OH MY GOSH. CHRISTINA: I'VE NEVER SEEN THE
1:25:05 MOVIE. I TOTALLY WOULD HAVE DONE THAT
1:25:06 RUN, THOUGH. [LAUGHTER]
1:25:10 DAVID: FIRST THINGS FIRST, SEE THE MOVIE.
1:25:12 IT WAS WHIPLASH ON WALL STREET THIS WEEK FOR INVESTORS LOOKING
1:25:15 TO MAKE SENSE OF WHERE THE ECONOMY IS GOING.
1:25:17 STOCKS RALLIED AFTER LAST WEEK'S ELECTION ONLY TO SINK AGAIN ON
1:25:19 CONCERNS OVER DATA CENTER DEVELOPMENT AND JENSEN HUANG'S
1:25:27 CATASTROPHIC IMPLOSION THAT SENT STOCKS PLUMMETING.
1:25:31 CHRISTINA: THAT PAIRED WITH A REPORT SHOWING THE HIGHEST JUMP
1:25:35 IN CONSUMER PRICES. JOINING US IS OUR GUEST, THE
1:25:41 HOST OF THE MASTERS AND BUSINESS PODCAST ON BLOOMBERG RADIO AND
1:25:43 ALL YOUR VARIOUS PLATFORMS. I WANT TO ASK YOU THE QUESTION
1:25:48 PEOPLE HAVE BEEN ASKING ME, AND ONCE AGAIN, I WANT TO SAY NO ONE
1:25:50 SHOULD EVER ASK ME FOR FINANCIAL ADVICE.
1:25:52 DAVID: GOD NO. [LAUGHTER]
1:25:54 CHRISTINA: SHUSH. [LAUGHTER]
1:25:58 EVERYONE IS VERY CONCERNED ABOUT THEIR TECH INVESTMENTS.
1:25:59 WHAT SHOULD THEY DO? BARRY: YOU LOOK AT THE DATA
1:26:06 POINTS THAT GIVE YOU SOME INSIGHT AS TO WHAT IS THE MOST
1:26:11 LIKELY PATH OF MARKETS GOING FORWARD.
1:26:13 WE NEVER KNOW BUT WE TRY TO MAKE THE BEST PROBABILISTIC
1:26:15 ASSESSMENTS WE CAN. FOR ALL THE STURM AND DRANG, ALL
1:26:24 THE VOLATILITY WE SAW THE LAST COUPLE MONTHS, S&P 500 IS 3.3
1:26:30 PERCENT OFF ITS ALL-TIME HIGHS. THAT TELLS ME THIS IS A BROAD
1:26:31 MARKET. WE HAVE HEARD FROM THE
1:26:36 CONCENTRATION BEARS FOR, I DON'T KNOW, FIVE YEARS.
1:26:38 SO FAR, MAYBE ONE DAY THEY WILL BE RIGHT, BUT SO FAR THEY ARE
1:26:43 NOT. YOU SEE THE NASDAQ IS OFF, WHAT,
1:26:45 10% FROM ITS HIGHS? AND WHAT LOOKS LIKE A VERY, VERY
1:26:55 SPECIFIC FOCUS ON ONE COMPANY MORE OR LESS TURNS OUT TO BE
1:26:58 JUST ONE COMPANY. IT IS NOT THE ENTIRE MARKET.
1:27:04 WHEN WE LOOK AT WHAT HAPPENS WITH MAJOR TECHNOLOGY FIRMS,
1:27:09 WHEN THE CEO STEPS DOWN, YEAH, THERE'S A TEMPORARY DROP IN THEN
1:27:13 MARKETS RECOVER. THINK ABOUT COMPANIES LIKE APPLE
1:27:21 OR ALIBABA, OR GO DOWN THE LIST OF COMPANIES WERE MAJOR CEOS
1:27:24 HAVE LEFT. THE ONE EXCEPTION HAS BEEN WHEN
1:27:28 STEVE BALLMER STEPPED DOWN FROM MICROSOFT.
1:27:31 THE MARKET RALLIED BECAUSE IT TURNED OUT HE WAS NOT A
1:27:33 PARTICULARLY GOOD CEO. [LAUGHTER]
1:27:38 SO, YOU HAVE THOSE DATA POINTS. AND HERE IS A CRAZY DATA POINT
1:27:42 THAT PEOPLE FACT-CHECKS ME WHEN I SAID THIS.
1:27:46 SINCE 1950, EVERY TIME THERE IS A MIDTERM ELECTION, MARKETS ARE
1:27:51 HIGHER BY THE FOLLOWING JUNE. AND HIGHER BY AN AVERAGE OF
1:27:54 ABOUT 15%. IT RUNS FROM ABOUT 2.5 TO 29.
1:28:04 19 FOR 19, THAT IS A CRAZY NUMBER.
1:28:06 I DON'T WANT TO TAKE THE OTHER SIDE OF THAT THAT.
1:28:09 DAVID: WE ARE PUTTING THAT IN JUST TO VERIFY THAT.
1:28:10 [LAUGHTER] CHRISTINA: SHUSH.
1:28:12 [LAUGHTER] BARRY: DOUBLE CHECK MY MATH.
1:28:18 CHRISTINA: I REMEMBERED OUR GUEST SAYING A SIMILAR THING.
1:28:22 AFTER MIDTERMS, THE MARKETS ARE USUALLY HIGH.
1:28:29 BARRY: I WAS GOING TO SAY, I DON'T TRUST ANY AI DATA.
1:28:32 SO, ANY TIME I HAVE A DATA POINT LIKE THAT, I WILL GO TO CLAUDE,
1:28:38 I WILL GO TO CHAT, AND WHEN THREE OF THEM SAY, YES, THAT
1:28:41 DATA IS ACCURATE, OK, I CAN RELY ON IT A LITTLE BIT.
1:28:44 CHRISTINA: I APPRECIATE THAT SKEPTICISM.
1:28:47 DAVID: YOU HAVE THE OPPORTUNITY TO SIT DOWN WITH SO MANY GREAT
1:28:50 INVESTORS AND OBSERVERS OF CORPORATE AMERICA AND GLOBAL
1:28:52 WALL STREET. WHAT I AM WONDERING ABOUT IS THE
1:28:56 CORPORATE GOVERNANCE ASPECT OF THIS STORY.
1:28:59 THIS COMPANY EXISTED SUCH AS IT DID FOR SO LONG WITH A VERY WEAK
1:29:02 BOARD WITHOUT A CHAIRMAN. WHAT DO YOU THINK ABOUT THE
1:29:06 LESSONS WE CAN LEARN FROM THIS INSTANCE AS APPLIED TO OTHER
1:29:13 ? TERMS OF CORPORATE GOVERNANCE?
1:29:18 BARRY: THERE IS AN ISSUE THAT TOOK PLACE OVER THE LAST 20
1:29:21 YEARS WHERE FOUNDERS HAVE BEEN GIVEN SPECIAL DISPENSATION.
1:29:25 SOMETIMES IT IS SUPER VOTING SHARES, SO YOU LOOK OVER AT META
1:29:29 AND THERE HAVE BEEN A NUMBER OF MISSTEPS, AND THERE'S NOTHING
1:29:35 THE BOARD CAN DO. OTHER TIMES, YOU SEE JUST A
1:29:40 CHARISMATIC EITHER FOUNDER OR THE PERSON WHO IS RESPONSIBLE
1:29:45 FOR SO MUCH OF'S THE COMPANY'S GROWTH -- OF THE COMPANY'S
1:29:49 GROWTH, AND THE BOARD IS VERY DIFFERENTIAL TO THAT PERSON.
1:29:54 IT IS POTENTIALLY PROBLEMATIC. WHAT WAS INTERESTING WAS
1:29:59 WATCHING THE BETTING ON KALSHI AFTER THE FIRST REVELATION ABOUT
1:30:02 AN AFFAIR WITH A SPY. HE WAS BARELY OVER 50% WHETHER
1:30:05 HE WILL LOSE HIS JOB. AND I THINK WHEN THE SECOND AND
1:30:15 THIRD REVELATIONS CAME OUT IT WAS NOT, THIS IS A ONE-TIME
1:30:18 MISTAKE, THIS WAS A PATTERN OF POOR JUDGMENT AND RECKLESSNESS.
1:30:22 I AM KIND OF PLUGGED INTO A LOT OF DIFFERENT TRADING DESKS AND I
1:30:25 HEAR ALL THEIR JOKES, AND MY FAVORITE RESPONSE WAS, WOW,
1:30:29 IMAGINE HOW MUCH BETTER NVIDIA WOULD HAVE DONE IF JENSEN
1:30:33 ACTUALLY HAD TIME TO FOCUS ON THE COMPANY INSTEAD OF RUNNING
1:30:35 AROUND ALL OVER THE PLACE. BUT THE BIG TAKEAWAY'S COMPANIES
1:30:44 SURVIVE THE LOSS OF A FOUNDER. THEY SURVIVED THE LOSS OF A CEO.
1:30:49 THE CEMETERIES ARE FILLED WITH IRREPLACEABLE MEN.
1:30:53 DAVID: HE IS QUOTING LLOYD BLANKFEIN.
1:30:54 I SAW HIM TWEETING THAT THIS WEEK.
1:30:57 BARRY: THAT IS NOT FROM LLOYD BLANKFEIN.
1:31:00 DAVID: I SAW HIM USING THE QUOTE.
1:31:01 OF COURSE. NO BETTING ON KALSHI.
1:31:04 JUST EVENT CONTRACTS. THERE IS NO BETTING THAT TAKES
1:31:05 PLACE ON KALSHI. BARRY: IT IS ALL GAMBLING.
1:31:12 CHRISTINA: I FELT LIKE THE SUBMIT WOULD WRAP UP OFF THE
1:31:12 RAILS. [LAUGHTER]
1:31:17 SPEAKING OF GOING OFF THE RAILS, IF YOU ARE AN INVESTOR, IF YOU
1:31:20 ARE WATCHING YOUR CEO ENGAGE IN DANGEROUS, UNETHICAL, CONCERNING
1:31:27 BEHAVIOR, THERE ARE PHOTOS OF THESE WOMEN.
1:31:28 PEOPLE HAD TO KNOW THIS WAS GOING ON.
1:31:34 AT WHAT POINT DO INVESTORS HAVE TO DEMAND, WILL THEY DEMAND
1:31:36 BETTER BEHAVIOR FROM CEOS BECAUSE IT COULD IMPACT
1:31:39 THEIR BOTTOM LINE? OR AS LONG AS STOCKS ARE HIGH,
1:31:42 COULD YOU SEE THEM LOOKING THE OTHER WAY?
1:31:47 BARRY: THAT IS NOT A FINANCE QUESTION, BUT A HUMAN BEHAVIOR
1:31:50 AND PSYCHOLOGY QUESTION. WHEN YOU HAVE A CHARISMATIC CEO
1:31:55 WHO IS SITTING ON TOP OF 700,000% IN GAINS, GUESS WHAT?
1:32:03 YOU ARE NOT GOING TO GET THAT SORT OF OVERSIGHT THAT YOU WANT
1:32:06 BECAUSE NOBODY WANTS TO KILL THE GOOSE THAT LAID THE GOLDEN NAG.
1:32:10 -- THE GOLDEN EGG. ON THE OTHER HAND, THERE IS
1:32:14 SOMETHING ABOUT PUBLIC MARKET STRUCTURES THAT LEND THEMSELVES
1:32:16 TO A POOR SET OF GOVERNANCE. YOU MENTIONED A PODCAST THIS
1:32:21 WEEK. THIS WEEK, I HAVE THE CEO OF
1:32:26 VANGUARD. WHAT IS FASCINATING IS ALL OF
1:32:28 HIS PREDECESSORS BUT THE IMMEDIATE ONE BEFOREHAND SERVED
1:32:36 A DECADE-LONG TERMS AS CEOS. THE CEO BEFORE HIM WASN'T QUITE
1:32:41 WORKING OUT, AND 18 MONTHS LATER HE GOT REPLACED.
1:32:44 VANGUARD IS NOT A PUBLICLY TRADED COMPANY.
1:32:47 IT IS MORE LIKE A MUTUAL. SO, IT RAISES THE QUESTION, WHEN
1:32:52 THE PRICE RAISES UP, BOARDS TEND TO LOOK THE OTHER WAY, AND IT IS
1:32:53 JUST A PROBLEM. DAVID: BARRY, GREAT TO SPEAK
1:32:57 WITH YOU. BARRY RITHOLTZ ON BLOOMBERG
1:33:02 RADIO. AVAILABLE AS A PODCAST AS WELL.
1:33:05 CHRISTINA: I SENSE YOUR SYMPATHY.
1:33:09 COMING UP, LISA MATEO WITH BTDUBS.
1:33:17 JENSEN HUANG'S ICONIC CLOTHING CHOICES, WERE THEY A HARBINGER
1:33:18 OF HIS DOWNFALL? ♪
1:33:26 CHRISTINA: WELCOME BACK TO BLOOMBERG THIS WEEKEND.
1:33:29 DAVID: IT'S UNFAIR. YOU ALWAYS GET TO DO THE INTRO
1:33:30 THIS SEGMENT. CHRISTINA: IT'S ALMOST LIKE I
1:33:34 HAVE ALLIES IN THE CONTROL ROOM FOR THE WAY I SAY BT DUBS
1:33:38 VERSUS THE WAY YOU SAY IT. LOYAL FAN OF THE SHOW AND NOT
1:33:45 [LAUGHTER] HE SAID, OH, BTDUBS.
1:33:53 I'M BLOOMBERG THIS WEEKEND. I NEVER PUT THAT TOGETHER.
1:33:56 IN CASE ANYONE MISSED IT, BLOOMBERG THIS WEEKEND, BTW.
1:34:03 CHRISTINA: JOEY -- DAVID: JOEY, THEY ARE MAKING FUN OF
1:34:04 YOU. I AM NOT.
1:34:05 [LAUGHTER] SORRY, OK?
1:34:09 CHRISTINA: LISA WILL CATCH US UP ON THE STORIES WE MAY HAVE
1:34:10 MISSED. LISA: WE HAVE BEEN TALKING ABOUT
1:34:13 JENSEN HUANG AND NVIDIA. NOW SOME TALK ABOUT THE FAMOUS
1:34:16 LEATHER JACKETS THAT HE WORE. IT HAS BEEN CRAZY.
1:34:23 THIS ONE SPECIFICALLY IS FROM NEW YORK MAGAZINE'S THE CUT.
1:34:26 JENSEN HUANG'S LAMBERT -- LEATHER JACKET CONFESS BEFORE HE
1:34:27 DID. HE IS KNOWN FOR WEARING THEM,
1:34:31 LIKE STEVE JOBS HAD THE BLACK TURTLENECKS.
1:34:32 IT IS A THING. IN JULY, EVERYONE WANTED IT.
1:34:39 DO YOU REMEMBER THAT? DAVID: DO WE KNOW WHO?
1:34:45 LISA: KNOW, AND DO WE KNOW HOW MUCH IT IS WORTH NOW?
1:34:48 THAT IS THE QUESTION. BUT THE THING IS, A 9000 DOLLARS
1:34:56 JACKET IS OF A MAN WHO FAITHFULLY -- NOT ONE OF A MAN
1:34:59 WHO GOES HOME TO HIS WIFE AND KIDS AT THE END OF THE DAY.
1:35:01 THAT IS A MAN IN CRISIS. SO, IT HAS BROUGHT SO MANY OTHER
1:35:04 STORIES. NEAR POST HAD A STORY THAT
1:35:12 JENSEN HUANG SLUG LEATHERED THE LEAD THIRD JACKETS -- THE NEW
1:35:15 YORK POST HAD A STORY THAT JENSEN HUANG'S LEATHER JACKETS
1:35:16 TOLD US SOMETHING. SOMEONE SAID IT BETRAYS THE
1:35:20 LEATHER JACKET COMMUNITY. DAVID: CARA SWISHER SAID SHE IS
1:35:25 RECLAIMING IT. CHRISTINA: I SAW ONE THIS
1:35:29 MORNING THAT IT IS NOT ANY LEATHER JACKET, IT IS THAT TYPE,
1:35:34 VERY STIFF, IT IS NOT WORN IN, IT LOOKS OVERLY POLISHED.
1:35:36 DAVID: NO RIVETS. CHRISTINA: THE MIDLIFE JACKET
1:35:39 CRISIS. -- THE MIDLIFE CRISIS JACKET.
1:35:44 I HAVE NO OPINION ON THIS. DAVID: I WOULD GET MINE FROM THE
1:35:49 BOOT BARN. CHRISTINA: I DID JUST BUY ONE
1:35:54 THAT HAS STUDS AND STUFF IN IT. THAT IS TOO FANCY.
1:35:58 IT DOES NOT HAVE RHINESTONES, IT HAS RIVETS.
1:36:01 LISA: WHY DOES IT HAVE TO HAVE RHINESTONES?
1:36:03 DAVID: I DON'T KNOW. LISA: THE MICROSOFT OUTAGE.
1:36:08 THIS ONE IS FROM BLOOMBERG. THE MICROSOFT OUTAGE SENDS
1:36:10 TRADERS BACK TO PHONES AND FAX. IF THEY KNOW HOW TO USE THE FAX
1:36:15 MACHINE. WE HAVE ONE HERE, IT IS PART OF
1:36:19 THE PRINTER, BUT DO YOU KNOW HOW TO USE IT?
1:36:20 [LAUGHTER] CHRISTINA: IT DOES.
1:36:25 OH GOSH. LISA: THE PEOPLE WERE
1:36:31 STRUGGLING, THEY COULD NOT GET ACCESS TO ALL THESE THINGS.
1:36:35 BUT IT GOES BACK TO WHAT YOU WERE SAYING.
1:36:37 PEOPLE CALL IT A SNOW DAY. PEOPLE WERE ENJOYING DIFFERENT
1:36:40 THINGS THEY DIDN'T GET TO DO BEFORE.
1:36:42 THEY WERE SAYING, FORGET THIS, I AM GOING FOR COFFEE, I'M GOING
1:36:45 [LAUGHTER] DAVID: WE KNOW WHAT YOU WERE
1:36:48 DOING. LISA: AND OF COURSE SOCIAL
1:36:52 MEDIA. PEOPLE SAID, TEST IT OUT FOR A
1:36:54 FEW DAYS. #4DAYWEEKEND.
1:37:00 PEOPLE WANTED TO GO LONGER BECAUSE THEY WERE ENJOYING THIS
1:37:02 DETACHMENT MOMENT THEY WERE GETTING.
1:37:03 I DON'T KNOW. EDEN BERGER TWEETED SOMETHING.
1:37:08 WHOEVER IS WORKING ON THE OUTAGE, TAKE YOUR TIME.
1:37:10 GO OUT AND GET A WHOPPER. [LAUGHTER]
1:37:13 EVERYONE IS PITCHING IN. CHRISTINA: UNFORTUNATELY FOR US,
1:37:17 THE TERMINAL WORKED GREAT. EMAILS CAME RIGHT THROUGH.
1:37:20 VERY GOOD TECH HERE AT BLOOMBERG.
1:37:22 LISA: EVERYONE IS LIGHT, DID IT BOTHER YOU?
1:37:26 NO. THE COMPETITION FOR AI TALENT WE
1:37:30 KNOW IS HUGE. THIS IS FROM THE WALL STREET
1:37:31 JOURNAL. COMPANIES DOLE OUT MEGA PAYDAYS
1:37:38 AND LUXURY TRIPS TO COMPETE FOR AI TALENT.
1:37:39 WE HAVE KNOWN A LOT OF TECH WORKERS HAVE BEEN GETTING LAID
1:37:43 OUT DUE TO TECHNOLOGY, BUT THERE ARE CERTAIN CORNERS OF THAT
1:37:47 SECTOR WHERE THEY ARE HEAVILY RECRUITED.
1:37:49 THIS IS A I START UP SERVAL. THEY ARE OFFERING $30,000
1:37:54 SIGN-UP BONUS. $30,000 TO ANY EMPLOYEES WHO
1:38:06 RECOMMEND SOMEONE WHO GETS HIRED.
1:38:10 DAVID: ASKED LEATHER JACKETS. -- SIX LEATHER JACKETS.
1:38:17 LISA: AND A VACATION WORTH $10,000.
1:38:20 DAVID: WHERE YOU CAN WEAR YOUR LEATHER JACKETS.
1:38:21 WOW. LISA: BUT THE PROBLEM IS THAT
1:38:25 OPENAI AND ANTHROPIC ARE TAKING ALL THE TALENT.
1:38:27 THERE IS A SMALLER POOL AND EVERYONE IS GOING FOR THESE
1:38:30 SOFTWARE ENGINEERS. AND IT IS NOT JUST SOFTWARE
1:38:32 ENGINEERS. PEOPLE IN CONSTRUCTION,
1:38:35 MANUFACTURING, THEY ARE GETTING MORE BY SWITCHING JOBS BECAUSE
1:38:38 YOU NEED THOSE PEOPLE FOR DATA CENTERS AND THINGS LIKE THAT.
1:38:41 THESE PEOPLE ARE IN HIGH DEMAND. THEY ARE GETTING VACATIONS.
1:38:49 CHRISTINA: I WONDER IF I HAVE ANY SKILL TO THAT.
1:38:53 [LAUGHTER] LISA: THERE IS A BARGAIN FOR A
1:38:59 FIRST CLASS TICKET. DID YOU KNOW THAT?
1:39:05 I SEE THE SIDE I. THIS IS FROM THE LOS ANGELES
1:39:08 TIMES. FRONTIER AIRLINES OFFERING FIRST
1:39:11 CLASS SEATS STARTING AT $129. IT STARTS MARCH 5, BUT IT IS NOT
1:39:16 WHAT YOU THINK. CHRISTINA: DEFINE FIRST CLASS.
1:39:23 LISA: A LITTLE MORE LEG ROOM. THERE IS NO MIDDLE SEAT.
1:39:27 EACH PASSENGER GETS YOUR OWN POWER PORT.
1:39:30 BUT HERE IS THE THING. IT DOES NOT INCLUDE MEALS
1:39:34 OR SNACKS. [LAUGHTER]
1:39:37 YOU HAVE TO PAY FOR YOUR OWN FOOD.
1:39:40 CHRISTINA: SO IT FIRST CLASSES IN QUOTATION MARKS.
1:39:42 LISA: YEAH. SOME WERE SAYING THE SEATS DON'T
1:39:44 EVEN RECLINE. [LAUGHTER]
1:39:47 BUT IT IS A BARGAIN. YOU GET A PORT TO CHARGE YOUR
1:39:48 PHONE. CHRISTINA: IF IT IS SLIGHTLY
1:39:52 LESS MISERABLE THAN THE EXPERIENCE IN THE BACK OF THE
1:39:55 PLANE, I WOULD PROBABLY PAY FOR IT.
1:39:56 BUT IT IS A SAD STATE OF AFFAIRS THAT THEY CAN EVEN HAVE PRETZELS
1:39:59 AND A WARM SODA. LISA: YOU HAVE TO PAY FOR THAT.
1:40:05 DAVID: BTW WITH LISA MATEO ON BLOOMBERG THIS WEEKEND.
1:40:07 CHRISTINA: COMING UP ON 9:00 A.M.
1:40:10 THE NEXT HOUR STARTS RIGHT NOW. DAVID: COMING UP, THE NATIONWIDE
1:40:28 GROUND STOP IS LIFTED BUT THE MESS REMAINS.
1:40:32 >> DOES THAT MEAN EVERY FLIGHT IS GOING TO FLY RIGHT NOW?
1:40:37 IT'S GOING TO TAKE A SOME TIME TO UNWIND WHAT HAS HAPPENED.
1:40:41 DAVID: WITH THE SECRETARIES OF HOMELAND SECURITY AND
1:40:42 TRANSPORTATION SAYING THEY NEED TO KEEP THE SKIES SAFE.
1:40:45 CHRISTINA: PRESIDENT TRUMP PREPARES TO HEAD TO CHINA.
1:40:50 NOW'S CABINET IS POINTING FINGERS ABOUT EXPORT CONTROL.
1:40:55 >> TREASURY, USTR AND STATE WERE IN FAVOR OF PUTTING MEGASPEED ON
1:40:59 THE LIST FOR MONTHS. COMMERCE HAS THAT --
1:41:06 DAVID: A SETBACK FOR SPACEX AS IT TRIES TO MAKE THE WORLD'S
1:41:09 FIRST FULLY REUSABLE ROCKET.
1:41:12 CAN YOU BRING THE REST OF THE SPACECRAFT BACK TO EARTH
1:41:16 SAFELY? ♪
1:41:22 CHRISTINA: WELCOME BACK TO BLOOMBERG THIS WEEK AND LIVE
1:41:24 FROM OUR WORLD HEADQUARTERS IN NEW YORK.
1:41:26 I'M CHRISTINA RUFFINI. DAVID: I'M DAVID GUERRA.
1:41:32 YESTERDAY. IT LASTED ABOUT FIVE HOURS.
1:41:38 UNEXPECTED AND REALLY UPENDED A LOT OF PLANS.
1:41:41 CHRISTINA: PEOPLE NOT KNOWING WHAT WAS GOING ON.
1:41:45 THE DHS AND TRANSPORTATION SECRETARY'S SAID A TECHNICAL
1:41:46 ISSUE. THEY DO NOT BELIEVE IT WAS A
1:41:51 CYBER ATTACK OR TERRORISM ATTACK BUT IT WAS AN ISSUE.
1:41:53 FIRST, LISA MATEO'S UPDATES. LISA: THE TRUMP ADMINISTRATION
1:41:59 ASKING CONGRESS FOR $50 BILLION IN EMERGENCY FUNDING TO HELP
1:42:01 UPDATE THE NATION'S AIR TRAFFIC CONTROL SYSTEMS.
1:42:06 THAT SHUT DOWN DISRUPTED THOUSANDS OF FLIGHTS NATIONWIDE.
1:42:10 THE FAA SAID IT WAS DUE TO A DATA OVERLOAD THAT CRIPPLED AIR
1:42:13 TRAFFIC CONTROL COMMUNICATIONS AND RADAR.
1:42:16 THE TRANSPORTATION SECRETARY SEAN DUFFY.
1:42:20 >> WE HAVE TELECOMS. THIS IS ANALOG TELECOM.
1:42:24 OUR SWITCHES, ROUTERS GOT OVERLOADED WITH DATA AND IT WENT
1:42:26 DOWN. I SHOULD NOT SAY THEY WENT DOWN.
1:42:30 THEY GAVE US INCONSISTENCY IN THE DATA.
1:42:35 LISA: AMERICAN AIRLINES, JETBLUE ARE WARNING THE DELAYS WILL LAST
1:42:38 TODAY BUT THE SYSTEMS WILL BE BACK BEFORE THE THANKSGIVING
1:42:40 HOLIDAY. LAST NIGHT THESE PASSENGERS HAD
1:42:45 JUST GOTTEN THEIR CHILD TO SLEEP WHEN THEY HAD THAT D BOARD THE
1:42:46 PLANE. >> WE HAD TO TAKE ALL OF OUR
1:42:49 STUFF. NO ONE CAN TOUCH THEIR CHECKED
1:42:51 BAGS. EVERYONE'S BAG IS STUCK AND NO
1:42:57 ONE CAN TOUCH IT. THEY SAY WE SHOULD JUST GO HOME
1:42:57 WITHOUT IT. LISA: ALL PASSENGERS AND CREW
1:43:03 MEMBERS HAVE BEEN RESCUED FROM A RIVER CRUISE SHIP AFTER
1:43:06 COLLIDING WITH ATTACKER. IT LOST CONTROL AND STRUCK THE
1:43:10 AMERICAN HERITAGE RIVER CRUISE FRIDAY AFTERNOON AT THE PORT OF
1:43:12 NEW ORLEANS. THE CREW SHOULD BEGIN TO SING,
1:43:16 SENDING PASSENGERS INTO THE MISSISSIPPI RIVER.
1:43:19 THE NEW ORLEANS MAYOR SAID IT WAS A JOINT RESPONSE.
1:43:22 >> IT WAS AN ALL HANDS ON DECK APPROACH WITH HARBOR POLICE
1:43:27 RESPONDING FIRST WITH TREMENDOUS BRAVERY, GOING INTO THE WATER
1:43:32 EVEN TO START PULLING PEOPLE OUT.
1:43:36 LISA: THE MAYOR SAYS THEY WERE 32 PEOPLE THAT WERE HOSPITALIZED
1:43:37 BUT NONE CRITICALLY INJURED. THE WHITE HOUSE AS A TRILATERAL
1:43:43 MEETING WILL BE HELD BETWEEN PRESIDENT DONALD TRUMP, XI
1:43:45 JINPING, AND RUSSIAN PRESIDENT VLADIMIR PUTIN.
1:43:49 IT WILL TAKE PLACE ON THURSDAY ON THE SIDELINES OF THE
1:43:50 ASIA-PACIFIC ECONOMIC COOPERATION SUMMIT.
1:43:53 PRESIDENT TRUMP HAS PREVIOUSLY SAID SUCH A MEETING WOULD FOCUS
1:43:55 ON DENUCLEARIZATION. UKRAINIAN PRESIDENT VOLODYMYR
1:44:01 ZELENSKYY SAYS U.S. PEACE ENVOYS HAVE ASKED WHETHER UKRAINE WOULD
1:44:05 BE WILLING TO GIVE UP THE DONBAS REGION TO RUSSIA IN EXCHANGE FOR
1:44:06 NATO MEMBERSHIP. HE SAID THE PACKAGES INCLUDES
1:44:11 SPECIFIC SECURITY GUARANTEES FROM NATO AND THE EUROPEAN
1:44:15 UNION, A STRONG UKRAINIAN ARMY AND RECOVERY PLAN BACKED BY
1:44:18 FUNDING. THIS TAKES PLACE AS THE CONFLICT
1:44:20 CONTINUES. AT LEAST 30 PEOPLE, INCLUDING
1:44:27 SIX CHILDREN WERE INJURED IN A RUSSIAN ATTACK IN SOUTHEAST
1:44:28 UKRAINE. THE ATTACKED DAMAS DEPARTMENTS
1:44:31 AND RESIDENTIAL BUILDINGS. DAVID: THANK YOU FOR THE UPDATE.
1:44:36 AN INCREDIBLY BUSY WEEK. WE HAD ALL THAT JEN-SANITY.
1:44:43 JENSEN HUANG RESIGNING. WE HAD THE GROUND STOP THAT TOOK
1:44:50 HOUSE. SEAN DUFFY TWEETING THIS MOMENT
1:44:54 AGO. "OPERATIONS ARE SLOWLY RETURNING
1:44:59 TO NORMAL THIS MORNING. PLANES ARE PUSHING BACK AND
1:45:03 TAXIING, TAKING OFF AND IT'S SAFE TO FLY.
1:45:07 WE ARE IN CLOSE COORDINATION WITH THE AIRLINES TO SUPPORT THE
1:45:08 ONGOING RECOVERY." CHRISTINA: THERE'S A KNOCK ON
1:45:13 EFFECT AND AMERICANS WILL SEE DELAYS AND CANCELLATIONS AS
1:45:15 CARRIERS TRY TO RESCHEDULE. WE GO TO ED LUDLOW, THE HOST OF
1:45:18 BLOOMBERG TECH. YOU WERE UP LATE WITH SOME OF
1:45:24 OUR COLLEAGUES TRY TO FIGURE OUT WHAT EXACTLY HAPPENED.
1:45:26 I LISTENED TO THE ENTIRE PRESS CONFERENCE AND I'M STILL NOT
1:45:27 SURE. DAVID: IT IS A TECH STORY.
1:45:31 CHRISTINA: SOMETHING WITH ROUTERS.
1:45:35 ED: SECRETARY DUFFY WAS TALKING ABOUT ROUTERS.
1:45:40 THE FAA HAS A REALLY OLD TELECOMS NETWORK CALLED FTI.
1:45:45 THEY IDENTIFIED THE PROBLEM. ROUTERS STARTED GETTING
1:45:48 OVERLOADED. THAT HAD A CASCADING EFFECT.
1:45:53 CONTROL AND COMMUNICATIONS WERE IMPACTED AND RADAR DATA GOT
1:45:54 IMPACTED. THE WORRYING BIT AND SOMETHING
1:45:59 THEY HAD NOT CLARIFIED AS THEY DON'T KNOW WHETHER ROUTERS
1:46:00 BECAME OVERLOADED. THEY KNOW THEY DID.
1:46:04 THEY ARE INVESTIGATING WHAT IT IS GOING ON SO IT'S A BIG
1:46:05 SCRAMBLE. THERE WERE PHONE CALLS WITHIN
1:46:09 THE FAA, THE INTELLIGENCE SERVICES, THE CARRIERS.
1:46:12 DOES ANYONE KNOW WHY THIS IS HAPPENING?
1:46:16 WHAT DO WE DO ABOUT IT NEXT? YOU COVERED THE HEADLINES AND
1:46:21 HOW THE COUNTRY THINKS IT NEEDS TO NOW MODERNIZE, WHICH AT THIS
1:46:23 STAGE OF THE GAME SEEMS A LITTLE LATE.
1:46:28 THE OTHER PIECE IS L3 HARRIS IS INVOLVED IN DIVERTING WHAT IS
1:46:30 GOING ON. I AM DO TO FLY TO NEW YORK
1:46:34 TOMORROW. I HOPE I SEE YOU GUYS NEXT WEEK.
1:46:38 DAVID: I DO HOPE YOU GET HERE. L3 TECHNOLOGIES HELPS MAINTAIN
1:46:41 THE OLDER TELECOMMUNICATIONS NETWORK.
1:46:45 IT HAS BEEN TASKED TO DIAGNOSE THE CAUSE OF THE DATA OVERLOAD.
1:46:50 WITHOUT QUESTION THE BIG STORY OF THE WEEK WAS THE ONE
1:46:52 INVOLVING NVIDIA AND FOR SO MANY YEARS NOW YOU HAVE INTERVIEWED
1:46:54 JENSEN HUANG. I WAS SAYING AS WE DEALT WITH
1:46:59 THE STORY IN THE LAST HOUR SEEING YOU IN WASHINGTON AFTER
1:47:01 ONE OF THOSE BIG CONFERENCES THAT TOOK PLACE, YOU HAD
1:47:04 OCCASION TO SPEAK WITH HIM THERE.
1:47:08 TALK ABOUT -- LEGACY IS THE WRONG WORD BUT AS THE COMPANY
1:47:10 LOOKS TO HIRE A NEW PERMANENT CEO, WHO MIGHT BE A GOOD
1:47:13 CULTURAL FIT FOR THE COMPANY? HOW DIFFICULT WILL IT BE TO
1:47:16 REPLACE HIM GIVEN THE KIND OF BUSINESS ACUMEN HE HAD BUT ALSO
1:47:20 THE TECHNOLOGICAL EXPERTISE HE BROUGHT TO BEAR AS ONE OF THE
1:47:23 COFOUNDERS OF THE COMPANY? ED: I HAVE SPENT A REASONABLE
1:47:27 AMOUNT OF TIME AT JENSEN HUANG OVER THE LAST THREE OR FOUR
1:47:28 YEARS. I POSTED ABOUT THIS DURING THE
1:47:30 WEEK. THE LESSON IS ACCESS TO SOME IT
1:47:35 IS NO SUBSTITUTE FOR THE REPORTING.
1:47:41 NONE OF US ARE -- ALL OF US WERE IN THE WISER.
1:47:46 THE REAL QUESTION IS WE ARE STANDING WITH IS WHAT IS NVIDIA
1:47:47 WITHOUT JENSEN HUANG? THERE ARE A LOT OF TALENTED
1:47:50 PEOPLE THERE. DEEP TALENT FROM SOFTWARE TO
1:47:55 CHIPS DESIGN AND ARCHITECTURE AND HARDWARE ENGINEERING BUT
1:47:57 IT'S A REAL THING. WHAT DOES THAT LOOK LIKE GOING
1:47:59 FORWARD? THERE ARE INITIATIVES FROM
1:48:05 DIFFERENT CORNERS, REAL INITIATIVES -- THERE WERE SOME
1:48:07 FAKE ONES TO TRY TO PUSH THE BOARD TO CONSIDER BRINGING
1:48:09 JENSEN HUANG BACK. THERE WAS A REPORT IN THE
1:48:13 FINANCIAL TIMES THAT RENEE HOSS, THE ARM CEO HAD BEEN
1:48:19 APPROACHED. THE NVIDIA BOARD ISSUED A
1:48:25 STATEMENT IN RESPONSE, SAYING THEY HAD NOT MADE ANY FORMAL
1:48:26 APPROACH TO ANYONE. RENEE HAAS WAS AT NVIDIA FOR
1:48:35 A LONG TIME. HE HAD A SEVEN YEAR STINT
1:48:36 LEADING THE COMPUTER BUSINESS. ALL THE TECHNOLOGY TODAY, THE
1:48:43 BLUEPRINT IS BASED ON ARM DESIGNS AND ARCHITECTURE.
1:48:47 THERE IS A LOT OF LOGIC. THERE IS SO MUCH WE DO NOT KNOW.
1:48:54 SO MUCH WE DO NOT KNOW WITH BOTH THE NVIDIA BOARD INVESTIGATION
1:48:58 GOING ON INTERNALLY, RELYING ON OUTSIDE COUNSEL, AND VARIOUS
1:48:59 U.S. JUSTICE DEPARTMENT INVESTIGATIONS THAT SPAN A BROAD
1:49:02 RANGE OF QUESTIONS. SOME OF THE QUESTIONS BEING
1:49:06 POSED ARE PRETTY OFF THE MARK AROUND JENSEN HUANG.
1:49:12 CHRISTINA: HE'S GOING TO HAVE AN INTERESTING COUPLE OF WEEKS.
1:49:17 I'M WONDERING, IS IT REALISTIC IF YOU HAVE A REDEMPTION ARC AND
1:49:20 COME BACK AT THIS LEVEL -- THIS HIGH-PROFILE LEVEL?
1:49:22 DOES HE HAVE TO SHOW SOME SORT OF PENANCE?
1:49:26 HE WILL HAVE TO TESTIFY IN FRONT OF LAWMAKERS.
1:49:29 DOES HE GET RID OF THE LEATHER JACKETS WHICH WE HAVE BEEN
1:49:37 TALKING ABOUT AD NAUSEEUM? WHAT ARE HIS OPTIONS QUESTION
1:49:41 MARK ED: AS OF WEDNESDAY NIGHT UP UNTIL LATE WEDNESDAY JENSEN
1:49:47 HUANG WAS HOLDING ON, THEN HE CONCEDED.
1:49:52 THE BOARD -- WE WROTE JENSEN WAS OUSTED.
1:49:58 HE RESIGNED EFFECTIVE IMMEDIATELY.
1:50:01 THE BOARD MOVED TO MAKE THIS HAPPEN.
1:50:08 THE THING WE NEED TO BE SUPER CLEAR ON IS ARE THREE BASIC
1:50:09 SEPARATE ISSUES. THERE IS JENSEN HUANG'S
1:50:13 INFIDELITY. NVIDIA'S CODE OF CONDUCT
1:50:17 ACCOUNTS FOR THAT. HE HAD ONE OR MORE AFFAIRS.
1:50:23 THAT'S AN ISOLATED ISSUE. IN ONE SPECIFIC AFFAIR WITH
1:50:27 ALICE HUANG, THERE'S REPORTING ON THIS.
1:50:32 THE U.S. AUTHORITIES AND NVIDIA ARE LOOKING AT WHETHER THAT
1:50:38 RELATIONSHIP MEANT NVIDIA'S TRADE SECRETS OR IP OR ANY
1:50:43 NATIONAL SECURITY CONSIDERATIONS WERE DISCLOSED TO PARTIES THEY
1:50:44 SHOULD NOT HAVE BEEN. SHE IS AN ALLEGED FIVE-FER
1:50:48 CHINA. THAT IS BEEN DISPUTED AND
1:50:50 DEBATED. THAT AND A THIRD SEPARATE BUCKET
1:50:58 FROM WHETHER THE SECRETS WERE DISCLOSED OUTSIDE OF A SAFE
1:51:01 ZONE. THEN YOU HAVE SEEN SO MUCH ABOUT
1:51:08 ALICE HUANG AND WHETHER CHIPS THAT WERE BANNED FOR EXPORT MADE
1:51:10 THEIR WAY INTO CHINA SOMEHOW. THOSE ARE ALL SEPARATE AND WE
1:51:14 DON'T HAVE UPDATES ON THEM. WHEN THE BOARD ISSUED A
1:51:19 STATEMENT SUNDAY, JENSEN HUANG CONFIRMED HE HAD AN AFFAIR.
1:51:23 THEY SAID THERE WAS NO REASON TO BELIEVE ON SUNDAY A WEEK AGO
1:51:29 SECURITY LEAKAGE. YOU JUST HAVE TO WAIT I'M
1:51:31 AFRAID. DAVID: AS I THINK OF THESE
1:51:34 BUCKETS -- CHRISTINA: MY LEGENDARY
1:51:36 PATIENTS. -- PATIENCE.
1:51:44 DAVID: REGARDLESS OF THE ALLEGATIONS OF SPYING, TALK
1:51:47 ABOUT THE MEETING THIS WEEK. WE ARE LOOKING FORWARD TO
1:51:50 EARNINGS AND THERE'S A TOWN HALL THAT WILL FOLLOW THAT 24 HOURS
1:51:52 LATER. I'M CURIOUS WHAT YOU'RE LOOKING
1:51:58 FOR FROM THE INTERIM CEO, WHO WILL BE A FAMILIAR VOICE TO MANY
1:51:59 INVESTORS AND ANALYSTS ON THE CALL.
1:52:03 SHE HAS BEEN ON IT BEFORE. SHE'S BEEN AT THE COMPANY FOR
1:52:05 MORE THAN A DECADE. WHAT ARE YOU LISTENING FOR?
1:52:13 WHAT DO YOU WANT TO LEARN AT THAT TOWN HALL?
1:52:17 ED: MY UNDERSTANDING IS EARNINGS WILL GO AHEAD IS COMPLETELY
1:52:20 NORMAL. SHE WILL CARRY ON AS CFO.
1:52:26 SHE'S BEEN THERE FOR 13 YEARS IT WILL TAKE QUESTIONS FROM
1:52:27 ANALYSTS. NO ONE THINKS THAT THE EVENTS OF
1:52:34 THE PAST WEEK -- IT GOES -- EXTENDS TO LATE OCTOBER.
1:52:39 THE NEAR TERM. MOST ANALYSTS DON'T REALLY SEE
1:52:45 ANYTHING HAPPENING DIFFERENTLY THROUGH THE BALANCE OF 2027.
1:52:49 THEY SEE OPPORTUNITY FOR SOME OF NVIDIA'S RIVALS THAT JENSEN
1:52:52 HUANG IS NOT AT THE HELM. MAYBE CUSTOMERS ARE LIKE, OK,
1:52:56 MAYBE I WILL GO WITH A DIFFERENT OPTION.
1:53:01 VERY QUICK ON THE TOWN HALL, A MEMO WAS SENT OUT TO THE STAFF
1:53:05 SEEN BY BLOOMBERG. IT'S A NORMAL THING POST
1:53:10 EARNINGS TO HAVE A TOWN HALL, CALL IT WHAT YOU WILL.
1:53:13 WE JUST DON'T KNOW. KRESS DID SAY THAT WILL GIVE
1:53:19 STAFF SOME ANSWERS. THE ANSWERS WE ARE ALL CHASING.
1:53:25 CHRISTINA: YOU TALKED ABOUT THE THREE BUCKETS WITH JENSEN
1:53:26 HUANG'S ISSUES. THERE'S ALMOST A FOURTH AND THAT
1:53:32 IS HIM AS THE CHIEF ADVOCATE OF CHANGING U.S. POLICY WITH CHINA
1:53:35 ON THESE CHIPS AND PUSHING TO LIMIT THESE EXPORT CONTROLS AND
1:53:38 TRYING TO INFLUENCE THE WHITE HOUSE ON THIS ISSUE WHERE HE IN
1:53:42 FACT POSSIBLY COULD HAVE BEEN INFLUENCED ON THAT PERSPECTIVE
1:53:43 DURING THAT TIME. GO AHEAD.
1:53:49 ED: ONE OF THE U.S. JUSTICE DEPARTMENT PROBES BLOOMBERG HAS
1:53:53 REPORTED IS AN ESPIONAGE PROBE. IT LOOKS AT JENSEN HUANG'S
1:53:59 RELATIONSHIP WITH ALICE HUANG, BUT TO BE COMPLETELY CLEAR,
1:54:05 THAT PROBE. THEY ARE LOOKING AT THE
1:54:10 RELATIONSHIP AND UNDER THE BROADER ESPIONAGE.
1:54:16 THAT IS WHERE BLOOMBERG'S REPORTING STANDS ON THE
1:54:18 ALLEGATION THAT ALICE HUANG IS A SPY.
1:54:23 RELATIONSHIP JENSEN HUANG HAD WITH A CUSTOMER AS THE
1:54:28 FOUNDER OF MEGASPEED. MEGASPEED WAS ABLE TO GET ACCESS
1:54:36 TO SYSTEMS AND TRANSFER THE SYSTEMS INTO MAINLAND CHINA
1:54:38 WHERE U.S. EXPORT CONTROLS PREVENT THEM FROM GOING.
1:54:46 THAT IS BEING LOOKED AT AND IS ONE OF THE COURT QUESTIONS
1:54:51 CONGRESS HAS FOR JENSEN HUANG AND IN PART WHY THEY HAVE SOME
1:54:53 JENSEN HUANG TO TESTIFY. YOU MAY HAVE SEEN LATE MORNING
1:54:59 YESTERDAY THEY EXPANDED THEIR REQUEST TO INCLUDE NVIDIA'S
1:55:03 CORPORATE COUNSEL AND REPRESENTATIVES FROM THE
1:55:05 COMMERCE DEPARTMENT. YOU HAVE BEEN OVER THE IDEA THAT
1:55:09 THERE'S A LITTLE BIT OF TENSION BETWEEN THE TREASURY
1:55:12 -- CHRISTINA: JUST A LITTLE BIT.
1:55:17 ED: TREASURY SAID WE HAD ALL THE POWER TO PREVENT MEGASPEED FROM
1:55:20 MOVING THIS TECHNOLOGY ACROSS BORDERS.
1:55:24 DAVID: I WANT TO DOVETAIL THE STORY WITH THE ANTHROPIC IPO.
1:55:29 THERE ARE A LOT OF TWEETS ABOUT ANTHROPIC MAY BE SETTING ALL
1:55:32 THIS UP. TOTALLY UNFOUNDED BUT IT WILL
1:55:37 DOVETAIL THE TWO STORIES, MAY BECOME PERSONALLY --
1:55:45 CUMBERSOMELY.HOW IS THIS LIKELY TO SHAPE THE WAY
1:55:48 THE IPO UNFOLDS NEXT WEEK? ED: THE REPORTING IS THE
1:55:53 ANTHROPIC IPO WILL TRADE NEXT WEEK.
1:55:57 ALL THE CONVERSATIONS I'VE HAD IN THE LAST 48 HOURS SEEM LIKE
1:56:01 IT IS FULL STEAM AHEAD. WHEN ALL THE HEADLINES STARTED
1:56:06 TO BREAK LAST WEEKEND, IT WOULD BE COMPLETELY REASONABLE TO SAY
1:56:12 UHOH-OH, IS THIS GOING TO DERAIL THE IPO?
1:56:16 ANTHROPIC'S ON THE HOOK FOR SEVERAL HUNDRED BILLION DOLLARS
1:56:17 OF NVIDIA GEAR. NVIDIA WAS DO TO PUT $10 BILLION
1:56:21 INTO THE PRIVATE PLACEMENT PORTION OF THE RAISE.
1:56:29 $10 BILLION OF THE 90.4 BILLION DOLLARS ANTHROPIC WANTS TO RAISE
1:56:30 ACROSS THE IPO AND PRIVATE PLACEMENT.
1:56:37 IT'S THE IDEA THAT IF WE ZOOM OUT, THE THING THAT CONNECTS ALL
1:56:41 OF THIS -- IT'S IN ALL THE RESEARCH.
1:56:45 WHY IS IT SUCH A DISASTER TO MANY PEOPLE'S MIND FOR THE AI
1:56:46 ECOSYSTEM THAT JENSEN HUANG IS GONE?
1:56:52 HE WAS THE MAESTRO, THE GLUE BETWEEN THE FRONT LABS, THE
1:56:55 SUPPLY CHAINS ON THE HARDWARE SIDE, THE POLICY SIDE.
1:56:59 PEOPLE WILL BE ASKING THOSE QUESTIONS THIS WEEK.
1:57:03 CHRISTINA: DO YOU EXPECT THIS TO BE BIGGER THAN SPACEX?
1:57:07 IT IS SIX TIMES OVERSUBSCRIBED. ED: SPACEX PITS ITSELF AS BEING
1:57:16 AN AI IPO AS WELL, BUT ANTHROPIC IS THE FIRST PURE AI LAB TO GO
1:57:17 PUBLIC. IT IS THE PUBLIC BENEFIT
1:57:20 CORPORATION ELEMENT. ALL THE SIGNALS ARE THIS WILL BE
1:57:25 A MASSIVE IPO THAT WILL OVERTAKE SPACEX'S.
1:57:30 THE LESSON LEARNED IS THAT IT'S AN AMAZING MOMENT IN TIME AND
1:57:31 THAT EVERYONE IS SHOCKED BECAUSE WEEKS LATER THEY TRY TO RAISE
1:57:35 MORE MONEY THROUGH DEBT MARKETS OR OTHER MECHANISMS.
1:57:39 AI NEED MONEY. THAT IS THE STORY REALLY.
1:57:43 CHRISTINA: THE PERSISTENT PERENNIAL STORY.
1:57:46 DAVID: HOPE TO SEE YOU NEXT WEEK.
1:57:49 BEST OF LUCK. DAVID: ED LUDLOW COMING HERE TO
1:57:56 COVER THE ANTHROPIC IPO EXPECTED TO TAKE PLACE IN THE DAYS AHEAD.
1:58:01 WAS IT JUST AN AFFAIR OR WAS THE CEO OF AMERICA'S MOST VALUABLE
1:58:02 COMPANY THE TARGET OF AN INTERNATIONAL SPY?
1:58:08 WE ARE TALKING WITH THE FORMER CIA COUNTERINTELLIGENCE ANALYST,
1:58:10 AN EXPERT ON CHINA. THAT IS STRAIGHT AHEAD ON
1:58:14 "BLOOMBERG THIS WEEKEND." ♪
1:58:25 LISA: LET'S UPDATE YOU ON TODAY'S TOP STORIES.
1:58:29 THE AIR FORCE HAS RESPONDED TO SPECIFIC DRONE ACTIVITY AT A
1:58:31 BASE IN EASTERN ENGLAND. NO PERSONNEL, AIRCRAFT OR
1:58:36 INFRASTRUCTURE WERE AFFECTED. SKY NEWS REPORTED STAFF WERE
1:58:42 FORCED TO TAKE SHELTER. MARCO RUBIO MET WITH THE
1:58:45 HONDURAN PRESIDENT ON FRIDAY IN WASHINGTON AT THE DEPARTMENT OF
1:58:48 STATE. HIS LAST VISIT WAS BACK IN
1:58:54 FEBRUARY OF 2026 AFTER WINNING THE ELECTION A MONTH EARLIER.
1:58:57 NATIONAL ECONOMIC COUNCIL DIRECTOR KEVIN HASSETT SAYS HE
1:59:01 HAS NO PLANS TO LEAVE HIS POST AS PRESIDENT TRUMP'S ECONOMIC
1:59:05 ADVISOR AFTER A REPORT THAT HE WAS LEAVING.
1:59:08 HE SAID HE JOKED ABOUT IT WITH THE PRESIDENT ON FRIDAY.
1:59:11 THE WHITE HOUSE OFFICIAL SAID THE REPORT WAS NOT TRUE.
1:59:15 MICROSOFT SAYS IT'S BEEN RESTORED TO ITS FLAGSHIP
1:59:20 SOFTWARE AFTER AN OUTAGE THAT AFFECTED BUSINESSES WORLDWIDE.
1:59:25 PEOPLE IN MORE THAN 70 COUNTRIES REPORTED PROBLEMS WITH OUTLOOK,
1:59:30 TEAMS, AND THE COPILOT AI TOOL. BARCLAYS IS PREPARING TO CUT
1:59:37 ABOUT 200 POSITIONS ACROSS ITS INVESTMENT BANK NEXT WEEK.
1:59:41 THE LAYOFFS WILL AFFECT WORKERS AT DIFFERENT LEVELS BUT IT TAKES
1:59:44 PLACE MAINLY IN NEW YORK AND LONDON.
1:59:48 THIS IS IN ADDITION TO THE 5000 JOBS BARCLAYS SAID LAST MONTH HE
1:59:50 WAS PLANNING TO TRIM ACROSS THE BANK.
1:59:54 DAVID: APPRECIATE THAT. THE OUSTING OF JENSEN HUANG
1:59:57 BEGIN WITH A SCANDALOUS AFFAIR WITH A LIST CHINESE FIVE -- AN
2:00:04 ALLEGED CHINESE FIVE. CHRISTINA: WHAT WERE HER
2:00:06 OBJECTIVES AND THE TRUE NATURE OF HER WORK?
2:00:09 WHEN HE IS NOW HIS COUNTER INTEL ANALYST PETER MATTIS, PRESIDENT
2:00:15 OF THE JAMESTOWN FOUNDATION AND THE BOOK "CHINESE COMMUNIST
2:00:19 ESPIONAGE." WHEN YOU LOOK AT THIS WOMAN
2:00:23 THERE ARE SO MANY DIFFERENT QUESTIONS.
2:00:28 WHAT IS UNCLEAR IS, WHY SHE AN AGENT OR AN ASSET?
2:00:32 DOES THAT MATTER AND WHAT IS THE DIFFERENCE?
2:00:36 PETER: THANK YOU FOR HAVING ME THIS MORNING.
2:00:42 THE FIRST THING TO REMEMBER IS YOU HAVE AN OFFICIAL, A CASE
2:00:46 OFFICER, SOMEONE WHO'S AN INTELLIGENCE OFFICER HANDLING
2:00:49 SOURCES AND SPIES AND DIRECTING THEM AT TARGETS FOR INFORMATION.
2:00:53 SHE ALMOST CERTAINLY WAS THAT. THERE IS SOMETHING IN THE
2:00:58 CHINESE SYSTEM THAT'S A LITTLE MORE SORT OF A THAN AN ASSET.
2:01:05 SHE WAS NOT IT INSIDE AN ORGANIZATION TO BE RECRUITED BUT
2:01:07 SHE DID A LOT OF THINGS IN BUSINESS WE CAN SEE SHE PROBABLY
2:01:11 HAS BEEN CONNECTED TO THE CHINESE POLITICAL ELITE,
2:01:15 CONNECTED TO THE ELITE IN THE UNITED STATES.
2:01:18 THE MINISTRY OF STATE SECURITY HAS CO-OPTEES, COLLABORATORS AND
2:01:26 CAN BE TAPPED WHEN NECESSARY. IN SOME CASES THERE IS A MUTUAL
2:01:29 BACKSCRATCHING. WE DO A FAVOR FOR YOU, YOU DO A
2:01:32 FAVOR FOR US. IT GOES BACK AND FORTH.
2:01:39 DAVID: I KNOW HOW THE CIA OPERATES, THE DIFFERENCE BETWEEN
2:01:41 IT AND THE FBI. I HAVE WATCHED ENOUGH BRITISH
2:01:48 SHOWS THE KNOW THE DIFFERENCE BETWEEN MI5 AND MI
2:01:50 SIX. HOW SHOULD WE THINK ABOUT, MANY
2:01:55 THE OTHER INTELLIGENCE AGENCIES AROUND THE WORLD?
2:01:58 PETER: LIKE THE OLD KGB. A ROBUST DOMESTIC MISSION AND
2:02:03 INTERNATIONAL MISSION. THEY COLLECT INTELLIGENCE THE
2:02:07 SAME WAY WE DO, THE SAME WAY OTHERS DO.
2:02:11 THINK OF INTELLIGENCE AS ACTIVATING PART CATALYTIC
2:02:12 KNOWLEDGE. INFORMATION THAT SOLVES
2:02:15 DECISION-MAKING PROBLEMS. THESE ARE QUOTESES FROM
2:02:24 TEXTBOOKS THEY PUT EFFORT INTO WHAT WE CALL COVERT ACTION.
2:02:27 SOMETHING WE CONSIDER SPECIAL THAT REQUIRES A PRESIDENTIAL --
2:02:31 IT IS SOMETHING THEY CONSIDER TO BE ROUTINE, ORDINARY, JUST
2:02:39 ANOTHER DAY THAT ENDS IN WHY. THIS IS NOT THE FIRST TRANSFER
2:02:43 AND YOU CAN GET THE SENSE THAT INTELLIGENCE IS FLOATING IN THE
2:02:45 BACKGROUND. ITS USE AS A WAY TO FACILITATE
2:02:51 CRITICAL BUSINESS OR STRATEGIC BUSINESS THAT HAS A BENEFIT FOR
2:02:53 THE CHINESE STATE. CHRISTINA: BECAUSE THE
2:03:00 PUBLIC-PRIVATE PARTNERSHIP IS DIFFERENT AND CHINA, THE
2:03:02 CORPORATE ESPIONAGE SIDE WORKS DIFFERENTLY AS WELL.
2:03:05 COULD YOU BE GOING ABOUT YOUR BUSINESS AS A LEGITIMATE PERSON
2:03:09 WORKING IN AN INDUSTRY AND GET A TAP ON THE SHOULDER FROM THE MSS
2:03:12 AND YOU ARE DOING WORK FOR THE CHINESE GOVERNMENT?
2:03:16 PETER: THAT IS ABSOLUTELY THE CASE.
2:03:20 THE 2017 LAW REQUIRES YOU TO COOPERATE WHEN SOMEONE PRESENTS
2:03:22 CREDENTIALS AND SAYS DO THIS FOR US.
2:03:24 THERE ARE A COUPLE OF BIG DIFFERENCES IN THE WAY THEY
2:03:28 THINK ABOUT ECONOMIC ESPIONAGE AND HOW THEY FUNCTION.
2:03:32 YOU MIGHT REMEMBER THE MINSK RAID.
2:03:38 THE RIO TINTO RAID IN SHANGHAI ALMOST 20 YEARS AGO.
2:03:44 THIS IS WHERE THE ADMINISTRATIVE STATE SECURITY
2:03:45 COUNTERINTELLIGENCE WAS DEPLOYED TO PROTECT THE FINANCIAL
2:03:47 ENTRANCE OF THE CHINESE PARTY STATE, OF BUSINESSES THAT HAD A
2:03:51 PARTY STATE STAKE IN THEM. YOU HAVE THIS PROTECTED SIDE.
2:03:59 THE SECOND THING IS THAT WE TEND TO THINK OF INTELLIGENCE AS
2:04:00 BEING A COLLECTION OF CLASSIFIED INFORMATION.
2:04:04 IT'S ABOUT SUPPORTING DECISIONS. YOU THINK ABOUT WHERE THE
2:04:08 CHINESE COMMUNIST PARTY IS, THEY LOOK AT THE UNITED STATES AND
2:04:12 THEY SEE AND EXISTENTIAL COMPETITION.
2:04:16 SCIENCE AND TECHNOLOGY IS THE CRUX OF THAT COMPETITION.
2:04:19 THEY SEE ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE AS FUNDAMENTAL TO WHAT WILL
2:04:21 HAPPEN. WE HAVE SEEN TREMENDOUS CHANGES
2:04:26 IN SCIENTIFIC DISCOVERY AND THE ABILITY TO LAUNCH INFORMATION
2:04:29 OPERATIONS, MILITARY OPERATIONS BECAUSE OF AI.
2:04:35 IF YOU HAVE THE PARTY'S WORLDVIEW, YOU WILL BE TARGETING
2:04:37 COMPANIES. THEY ARE OF CRITICAL NATIONAL
2:04:39 IMPORTANCE. NO CONVERSATION BETWEEN THE TECH
2:04:44 EXECUTIVE AND THE PRESIDENT THAT IS PROBABLY CLASSIFIED.
2:04:49 IT'S INCREDIBLY USEFUL. YOU GUYS WOULD CONSIDER THAT TO
2:04:52 BE REPORTABLE AND INTERESTING. THEY HAVE AN INTEREST IN TRYING
2:04:59 TO FACILITATE ACCESS TO THE THINGS THAT THEY NEED TO LEAD IN
2:05:01 THE AI RACE. DAVID: I WANT YOUR PERSPECTIVE
2:05:06 ON JENSEN HUANG'S AWARENESS OF THIS OR HIS RECOGNITION HE COULD
2:05:10 BE SUBJECT TO SOMETHING LIKE THIS.
2:05:13 I THINK OF THE TRIPS I HAVE TAKEN TO CHINA WITH VARIOUS
2:05:15 COMPANIES AND THE INFORMATION SECURITY I HAD TO DO BEFORE
2:05:18 SWAPPING OUT A PHONE OR TAKING A DIFFERENT COMPUTER.
2:05:21 I AM PRIMED TO THINK I'M ENTERING AN ENVIRONMENT WHERE
2:05:24 THINGS ARE DIFFERENT AND I COULD BE APPROACHED IN A DIFFERENT WAY
2:05:26 OR LOOKED AT IN A DIFFERENT WAY. HERE HE IS, ONE OF THE
2:05:30 WEALTHIEST MEN IN THE WORLD RUNNING PERHAPS THE MOST
2:05:32 IMPORTANT COMPANY OF THE MOMENT SUPPLYING CHIPS, THE VANGUARD OF
2:05:37 THE TECHNOLOGY TO COMPANIES ALL OVER THE WORLD.
2:05:40 WHAT DO YOU MAKE OF WHAT SEEMS REAL NAIVETE HERE?
2:05:46 PETER: I HAVE GIVEN BRIEFINGS TO MANY CORPORATE EXECUTIVES.
2:05:50 ONE THING THAT'S ASTONISHING AS PEOPLE SAY I DON'T HAVE
2:05:52 CLASSIFIED INFORMATION, WHY WOULD I BE A TARGET?
2:05:54 THAT IS THE FIRST THING. I DON'T THINK IT IS UNIQUE.
2:05:59 NOT UNIQUE TO JENSEN HUANG AND CERTAINLY NOT UNIQUE TO
2:06:00 AMERICANS. IT IS SOMETHING -- IF YOU HAVE
2:06:07 NOT LIVED IN THAT WORLD, YOU HAVE NOT THOUGHT ABOUT IT.
2:06:10 YOU THINK OF SPYING IS BEING THIS GLAMOROUS THING OR YOU CAN
2:06:15 GET OUT THAT THESE HIGH-VALUE PRECISION POINTS OF INFORMATION.
2:06:19 SOMETIMES YOU CAN BUT THAT IS NOT ALWAYS HOW IT WORKS.
2:06:22 I THINK A LOT OF PEOPLE THINK OF SECURITY AND PERSONAL
2:06:25 PROTECTION. PERSONAL PROTECTION IS ONE THING
2:06:29 BUT THAT IS NOT WHAT THIS IS. THE THIRD, A LOT OF PEOPLE DON'T
2:06:35 HAVE THE RECOGNITION OF QUESTIONS THEY SHOULD BE ASKING
2:06:39 ABOUT INDIVIDUALS OR THINKING ABOUT WHAT MIGHT BE USED AGAINST
2:06:42 THEM. DAVID: GIVE US A FEW OF THOSE
2:06:45 TOOLS. WHAT SHOULD EXECUTIVES WONDER
2:06:51 OUT IF THEY GO TO CHINA? PETER: THIS DOESN'T NECESSARILY
2:06:57 HAPPEN JUST IN CHINA. IT COULD HAVE BEEN IN SINGAPORE,
2:07:02 HONG KONG, KUALA LUMPUR, BRUSSELS OR PARIS.
2:07:04 IT DOESN'T MATTER WHERE IT IS. THE FIRST IS, NO WITH THE RED
2:07:09 LINES ARE. WHAT ARE THINGS THAT CANNOT BE
2:07:11 TALKED ABOUT. KNOW WHAT YOUR VALUE IS FROM A
2:07:14 POLITICAL SIDE. YOU COULD SEE THERE IS CLEARLY A
2:07:20 THESE CHIPS. THERE'S ALSO ACCESS TO POLITICAL
2:07:26 INTELLIGENCE AND CONCEIVABLY THE ABILITY TO INFLUENCE U.S.
2:07:27 POLICY. THESE THINGS ALL EXIST TOGETHER.
2:07:34 PEOPLE SHOULD BE COGNIZANT OF WHO IS IN THE POLITICAL CIRCLE.
2:07:38 , WHO IS IN THEIR SOCIAL CIRCLE. IF YOU'RE TRAVELING ABROAD AS AN
2:07:42 AMERICAN, DON'T TALK ABOUT OTHER AMERICANS IF YOU CAN HELP IT.
2:07:47 YOU DON'T NECESSARILY KNOW WHO YOU ARE DEALING WITH OR WHO THEY
2:07:49 ARE REPORTING TO. CHRISTINA: THERE IS A MEME GOING
2:07:55 AROUND, HOW TO TELL IF YOUR GIRLFRIEND IS A CHINESE SPY.
2:07:59 IT'S A JOKE AND IT'S, ARE YOU IN TECH?
2:08:01 IS SHE MORE ATTRACTIVE THAN YOU? SPY.
2:08:04 IT'S RIDICULOUS. THERE HAS TO BE SOME SORT OF
2:08:07 BRIEFINGS. I HAVE HEARD OF PEOPLE IN HIGH
2:08:14 INTELLIGENCE JOBS BEING WARNED ABOUT THIS, WARNED ABOUT YOUNG
2:08:16 ATTRACTIVE WOMEN APPROACHING THEM FOR INFORMATION.
2:08:20 I HAVE SEEN IT HAPPEN HAVE BEEN WITH AN INTELLIGENCE OFFICER AT
2:08:22 A CONFERENCE WHEN A YOUNG WOMAN WENT UP AND TRY TO GET THAT
2:08:26 PERSON'S INFORMATION AND THE OFFICER KNEW IMMEDIATELY WHAT IT
2:08:27 WAS AND SHUT IT DOWN. DAVID: YOU CAN SAY A HONEY POT.
2:08:32 CHRISTINA: I'M NOT SAYING THAT THE TELEVISION.
2:08:36 MORE? IS IT UP TO PEOPLE AT THE
2:08:39 COMPANIES WHO ARE WATCHING THIS HAPPEN TO QUESTION SOME OF THESE
2:08:42 RELATIONSHIPS? PETER: IT COMES DOWN TO PERSONAL
2:08:48 AWARENESS AND CHOICES. UNFORTUNATELY, YOU KNOW, THERE
2:08:55 IS A STANDARD PHRASE FOR THE KIND OF LEVERS OF ESPIONAGE
2:08:57 CALLED MICE. MONEY, IDEOLOGY, COERCION AND
2:09:01 EGO. UNFORTUNATELY IT WORKS BECAUSE
2:09:06 THESE THINGS PLAY ON EGOS. PEOPLE LIKE TO TALK WITH SMART
2:09:10 PEOPLE. THEY LIKE TO TALK WITH OTHERS
2:09:14 THAT ARE CLOSELY RELATED TO WORK BUT NOT QUITE --
2:09:20 CHRISTINA: DOES SHE HAVE AN UNNATURAL INTEREST IN CLOUD
2:09:21 COMPUTING? PETER: THOSE ARE THE THINGS YOU
2:09:25 SHOULD BE ASKING. ARE THE QUESTIONS OUT OF ORDER?
2:09:29 ARE THEY DETAILED? ARE THEY BUSINESS QUESTIONS?
2:09:36 ARE THE POLITICAL QUESTIONS? IF YOU DON'T THINK ABOUT THIS
2:09:38 YOURSELF ABOUT WHERE YOU DRAW YOUR LINES ABOUT WHAT IS
2:09:42 IMPORTANT AND WHAT DO YOU WANT TO DO, IN THE MOMENT THAT IS
2:09:45 WHEN YOU ARE GOING TO BE THE MOST VULNERABLE.
2:09:47 IT'S ABOUT PREPARING YOUR MENTALITY, PREPARING YOUR
2:09:51 THOUGHTS AND SAY HERE'S HOW I HANDLE IT AND WHY IT MIGHT BE A
2:09:54 TARGET. I DON'T THINK A LOT OF PEOPLE
2:09:59 OUTSIDE OF GOVERNMENT REALLY THINK OF THEMSELVES AS BEING
2:10:02 VALUABLE. OBVIOUSLY THEY ARE.
2:10:09 IT IS NOT ALWAYS FOR THE REASONS THEY THINK.
2:10:13 DAVID: WE TALK ABOUT SOMEBODY INVOLVED IN AI ABOUT THE ROLE
2:10:16 THEY ARE PLAYING IN THIS SPY CRAFT.
2:10:21 HOW IS IT CHANGING THE GAME FOR AN ORGANIZATION LIKE MSS?
2:10:27 PETER: IS THE ONLY STRATEGIC CIVILIANS SIGNAL INTELLIGENCE
2:10:31 THAT IS MOSTLY A MILITARY ORGANIZATION.
2:10:33 IT IS LIKE THE NSA. THEY ARE INCREDIBLY ACTIVE WITH
2:10:36 COMPUTER NETWORK EXPLOITATION. AI FACILITATE TOOLS DEVELOPMENT
2:10:41 AND PROCESSING. IT'S BEEN REPORTED FOR YEARS
2:10:45 THEY HAVE ROBUST RELATIONSHIPS WITH THE CLOUD COMPUTING
2:10:49 COMPANIES IN CHINA AND THEY LEVERAGE THOSE COMMERCIAL
2:10:50 RESOURCES TO SUPPORT THEM. IT ALLOWS THEM TO PROCESS THIS
2:10:57 HUGE REAMS OF DATA, LIKE THE HACK ON UNITED, ON MARRIOTT, ON
2:11:02 THE OFFICE OF PERSONNEL MANAGEMENT AND COMBINED THESE
2:11:06 THINGS AND USE THAT TECHNICAL KNOWLEDGE AND THE INSIGHTS
2:11:10 GAINED TO TIP OF HUMAN OPERATIONS.
2:11:13 THE MSS FOCUSES ON THE HUMAN ELEMENT, HENCE THE EMPHASIS ON
2:11:18 POLITICAL ACTION AND INFLUENCE IN FACILITATING THROUGH HUMAN
2:11:22 RELATIONSHIPS THE TRANSFER OF TECHNOLOGY.
2:11:27 IT SUPERCHARGES WHAT THEY CAN DO AND SHARPENS THEIR TOOLS.
2:11:31 CHRISTINA: THANK YOU SO MUCH. I PROMISE TO RUN ALL
2:11:35 RELATIONSHIP APPROACHES FOR YOU TO MAKE SURE THEY ARE ON THE UP
2:11:37 AND UP. DAVID: THE FOUNDERS OF THE
2:11:46 PROBIOTIC SODA ARE NOW MILLIONAIRES.
2:11:49 WE ARE WITH THE HUSBAND TEAM NEXT ON "BLOOMBERG THIS WEEKEND
2:11:52 ." ♪
2:11:56 LISA: THANK YOU FOR JOINING US LIVE.
2:11:58 TODAY'S TOP STORIES. SPACEX'S MASSIVE STARSHIP
2:12:05 BLASTED OFF IN TEXAS YESTERDAY. THE COMPANY HOPED TO PERFORM A
2:12:08 DOUBLE CATCH ON BOTH HALVES OF THE STARSHIP ON THIS FLIGHT, BUT
2:12:11 HE CANCELED PLANS TO RETRIEVE THE BOOSTER USING THAT
2:12:13 OUTSTRETCHED ARM. THE SPACECRAFT DID STILL DEPLOY
2:12:17 ALL THE SATELLITES IT WAS CARRYING IN HOPES OF PERFORMING
2:12:21 A NOVEL LANDING ON EARTH TODAY. THE U.S. LOST ITS MEASLES
2:12:24 ELIMINATION STATUS. THE PAN-AMERICAN HEALTH
2:12:29 ORGANIZATION HAS REVOKED IT AS OUTBREAKS CONTINUE TO RISE AND
2:12:32 BACKING UPDATE FALL. TO REGAIN THE STANDING OF THE
2:12:35 U.S. MUST STOP THE SPREAD OF MEASLES FOR AT LEAST 12 MONTHS,
2:12:40 WHICH COULD TAKE YEARS OF PUBLIC HEALTH WORK.
2:12:43 POPE LEO RETURNED TO THE PERUVIAN CITY WHERE HE SPENT
2:12:45 EIGHT YEARS AS BISHOP BEFORE HE WAS CALLED TO ROME.
2:12:48 THE PONTIFF SAID IT WAS A JOY TO BE HOME AND CREDITS THE PEOPLE
2:12:51 WITH TEACHING HIM HOW TO BE A SHEPHERD.
2:12:56 THE VATICAN ESTIMATES ONE MILLION PEOPLE LINED UP THE MASS
2:12:59 YESTERDAY AND 500,000 PEOPLE ATTENDED.
2:13:05 SOUTH LONDON. THEY HAVE TO PITCH IN FOR THE
2:13:10 REAL ST. NICK WHEN HE'S BUSY AT THE NORTH POLE.
2:13:15 AT THE MINISTRY OF FUN, THEY LEARN FACTS, FIGURES, TIPS AND
2:13:17 TRICKS TO HELP THEM ON THE JOB. WHAT ARE WE TALKING ABOUT?
2:13:22 WHAT ARE THE COOLEST TOYS AND HOW TO RESPOND TO HIS REQUEST
2:13:24 FOR THINGS THAT SANTA MIGHT NOT BE ABLE TO DELIVER.
2:13:28 DAVID: DID YOU USE YOUR MAGIC KEY LAST YEAR?
2:13:30 I DID KNOW ABOUT THE MAGIC KEY. LISA: WHAT IS THAT?
2:13:36 DAVID: GETS ON THE POWERPOINT PRESENTATION.
2:13:38 CHRISTINA: YOU HAVE BETTER VISION THAN I DO.
2:13:42 DAVID: THE MINISTRY LIVES ON. THE MAGIC MOVES ON.
2:13:45 CHRISTINA: I MISS THE MALL SANTA.
2:13:46 WE HAD OUR PICTURES TAKEN. DAVID: DO A TEAM PHOTO.
2:13:51 CHRISTINA: WE SHOULD DO A TEAM PHOTO.
2:13:55 DAVID: ALLISON AND STEPHEN ELLSWORTH MADE A HUGE PAYDAY
2:14:00 THANKS IN PART TO AN APPEARANCE ON SHARK TANK THAT PAVED THE WAY
2:14:02 TO WIDER SALES OF THE DRINK POPPY.
2:14:05 CHRISTINA: THEY SOLD THE PREBIOTIC SODA TO PEPSICO
2:14:09 FOR NEARLY $2 BILLION. LISA: WE SAT DOWN WITH THEM TO
2:14:15 FIND OUT HOW THEY STILL HAVE PLENTY OF POP IN THEIR PLAYBOOK.
2:14:20 WELCOME AND THANK YOU FOR JOINING US IN THE BLOOMBERG
2:14:21 STUDIO. EVERYONE KNOWS ABOUT POPPY.
2:14:25 YOU HAD THE SUPER BOWL COMMERCIAL.
2:14:28 NOT MANY PEOPLE KNOW ABOUT THE STORY BEHIND IT, THE DECADES TO
2:14:32 GET THERE, THE STRUGGLE. TALKING ABOUT MAXING OUT CREDIT
2:14:37 CARDS, TALKING ABOUT SELLING A CAR TO GET BOTTLES.
2:14:41 CAN YOU DESCRIBE WITH THE BEGINNING PART OF THIS JOURNEY
2:14:42 WAS LIKE FOR YOU? ALLISON: IT WAS A DECADE IN THE
2:14:49 MAKING. EVERYONE LOVES TO STAY OVERNIGHT
2:14:51 SUCCESS. THEY DON'T SEE ALL THOSE
2:14:55 NITTY-GRITTY THINGS. I WAS DOING DELIVERIES TO
2:14:57 GROCERY STORES WITH MY BABY STRAPPED TO THE BACK OF ME.
2:15:01 BOTTLING IT OURSELVES AND MAXING OUT THE CREDIT CARDS.
2:15:05 I LOVED EVERY SECOND OF IT. THE CHAOS.
2:15:09 IT'S THE BEST JOB IN THE WORLD AND YOU HAVE GOT TO LOVE THIS
2:15:12 HIGH STRESS MOMENTS. DAVID: WHEN DID IT FEEL VIABLE
2:15:17 TO YOU AND YOU HAD FAITH IT WOULD TAKE OFF?
2:15:24 STEPHEN: I THINK THERE WAS -- THERE WERE THE WINS ALONG THE
2:15:27 WAY. I THINK THE MOMENT THAT I KNEW
2:15:33 IT WAS GOING TO BE REALLY HUGE WAS AFTER OUR FIRST SUPER BOWL
2:15:34 COMMERCIAL. WE WERE ALREADY SIZABLE BUT WE
2:15:40 DOUBLE DOWN AND BROUGHT IT -- BOUGHT A SUPER BOWL AD AND IT
2:15:43 TOOK IT TO THE NEXT LEVEL. 4X OVERNIGHT AND IT WAS
2:15:48 TREMENDOUS. ALONG THE WAY WE HAVE THOSE
2:15:51 WINS, ENOUGH TO STAY EXCITED ABOUT WHAT THE FUTURE HELD.
2:15:54 CHRISTINA: ONE WAS "SHARK TANK." YOU ARE NINE MONTHS PREGNANT.
2:15:58 SHE'S READY TO GO. WHAT WAS THAT EXPERIENCE LIKE?
2:16:03 HOW DID THAT CHANGE THE TRAJECTORY OF THE BUSINESS?
2:16:06 YOUR BRAND EVOLVED RIGHT AFTER THAT.
2:16:09 ALLISON: THERE WERE SO MANY EARLY INDICATORS FROM THE
2:16:12 FARMERS MARKET AND WHOLE FOODS APPROACHING US SAYING THIS NEEDS
2:16:15 TO BE IN GROCERY STORES, TO "SHARK TANK."
2:16:19 LAUNCH WAS INSANE. WE WERE ONE OF THE FIRST FOUNDER
2:16:22 LED BRYAN'S TO PUT OURSELVES OUT ON SOCIAL MEDIA -- BRANDS.
2:16:29 THERE WERE A LOT OF MICRO WIN MOMENTS.
2:16:32 WE FEEL LIKE WE WERE LIVING THE AMERICAN DREAMING.
2:16:37 OBVIOUSLY CRAZY TO DO IT AGAIN BUT WE LOVE IT.
2:16:40 DAVID: TALK ABOUT THE SOCIAL MEDIA STRATEGY, THE ROLE THAT
2:16:43 PLAYED IN THE SUCCESS OF THE BRAND.
2:16:47 ALLISON: I THINK IT MEANS DIGITAL FIRST FROM DAY ONE.
2:16:50 WE LAUNCHED ON MARCH 3, 2020. THE FIRST WEEK OF COVID, WHICH
2:16:54 IS CRAZY WHEN YOU THINK OF IT. EVERYBODY WAS FORCED TO BE IN
2:16:57 THEIR HOUSE. HOW DO YOU CONNECT WITH THEM?
2:17:01 THEY WERE DESPERATE FOR HUMAN CONNECTION.
2:17:05 WE WERE TRYING TO THINK THROUGH DISRUPTIVELY OF HOW WE COULD HIT
2:17:09 THIS WILD WEST I WAS TIKTOK AT THE TIME.
2:17:13 EVERYONE TOLD ME IT WAS NOT A GREAT IDEA AND JUST ABOUT THE
2:17:14 KIDS DANCING. HEY, I THINK THIS WHERE
2:17:18 COMMUNITY IS AND I STARTED MAKING RECIPE VIDEOS.
2:17:23 I WAS DANCING. LITERALLY ANYTHING TO GET AS
2:17:25 MANY PEOPLE TO SEE POPPY AS POSSIBLE.
2:17:28 IT WAS JUST ME SITTING DOWN AND TELLING THE STORY OF BEING
2:17:29 AUTHENTIC THAT REALLY BROKE THROUGH.
2:17:32 I THINK I HAVE THAT ORIGINAL VIDEO I POSTED THAT BROKE THE
2:17:36 INTERNET AND CHANGED THE WHOLE TRAJECTORY OF THE BUSINESS.
2:17:39 250 MILLION VIEWS ON IT. IT IS UNREAL.
2:17:43 IT MADE US THINK DIFFERENTLY FROM DAY ONE.
2:17:48 CHRISTINA: WHAT LESSONS HAVE YOU GUYS LEARNED THE HARD WAY?
2:17:53 ALLISON: SO MANY. STEPHEN: THE BIGGEST ONE IS
2:17:59 MAKING SURE THAT YOU OVERINVEST IN PEOPLE EARLY ON.
2:18:05 AS ENTREPRENEURS YOU FEEL LIKE YOU HAVE TO DO EVERYTHING
2:18:06 YOURSELF. A LOT OF THE TIMES YOU DO.
2:18:10 YOU DON'T HAVE ACCESS TO THE GREAT TALENT.
2:18:13 YOU HAVE ACCESS TO THE CAPITAL REQUIRED FOR GREAT TALENT.
2:18:17 THERE IS A TRANSITION MODE THAT WE WENT THROUGH WHERE WE STARTED
2:18:22 TO DELEGATE AND RELEASE SOME OF THOSE RESPONSIBILITIES TO OTHER
2:18:23 FOLKS. THAT IS PROBABLY THE BIGGEST
2:18:25 LESSON. WHO YOU SURROUND YOURSELF WITH.
2:18:29 WHO ARE YOUR INVESTORS AND ADVISORS THAT ARE CHALLENGING
2:18:33 OUR THOUGHTS AND PROVIDING THE DIVERSITY OF THOUGHT TO GROW THE
2:18:36 BUSINESS AND PUSH IT FORWARD. DAVID: LET'S TALK ABOUT JETTY.
2:18:41 WHAT ARE YOUR HOPES FOR THE BRAND?
2:18:47 ALLISON: WHEN WE WEAR POST-EXIT THERE WAS SUPPOSED EXIT BLUES
2:18:49 AND YOU ARE FINDING YOURSELF AGAIN.
2:18:51 IT IS CRAZY. YOU GET TO THE OTHER SIDE AND WE
2:18:56 PLAYED GOLF FOR A LITTLE BIT AND HUNG OUT WITH THE KIDS.
2:19:02 WE MISSED THE CHAOS. IS CRAZY THE EXCITEMENT YOU SEE
2:19:08 WHEN SOMEONE TRIES IT FOR THE FIRST TIME.
2:19:09 IT IS SUCH A CREATIVE OUTLET TO BE ABLE TO CREATE SOMETHING
2:19:12 PEOPLE FALL IN LOVE WITH. WE WERE KIND OF NOT SURE WHAT WE
2:19:16 WERE GOING TO DO. WAIT, I HAVE NOT HAD WATER
2:19:20 TODAY. IT WAS 2:00 AND I HAD TWO
2:19:24 COFFEES AND I WAS TRYING THESE ELECTROLYTE MIXES.
2:19:28 I REALIZED EVERYTHING WITH HYDRATION HAS BEEN MADE FOR THE
2:19:29 EXTREMES. FOR SPORTS OR 1000 VILLA GRAMS
2:19:33 OF SODIUM. IT IS SO INTENSE.
2:19:37 WHY DON'T WE MAKE APPROACHABLE EVERYDAY HYDRATION?
2:19:40 IT'S A PRODUCT MADE FOR ME AND MY KIDS.
2:19:43 WE HAVE 100 MILLIGRAMS OF SODIUM COMPARED TO SOME OF THE OTHERS.
2:19:48 WE HAVE POWDERS AS WELL. WE WERE THE FIRST HYDRATION
2:19:50 BRAND LAUNCH POWDERS AND THE DRINK AT THE SAME TIME.
2:19:53 CHRISTINA: HOW IS IT DIFFERENT THIS TIME AROUND?
2:19:55 ARE YOU SELF-FUNDED? STEPHEN: WE HAVE SELF-FUNDED.
2:19:59 WE HAVE ACCESS. ACCESS TO RETAILERS,
2:20:04 DISTRIBUTORS, TO A GREAT TEAM THIS TIME.
2:20:09 DAVID: YOU HAVE THE EXPERIENCE OBVIOUSLY.
2:20:11 THAT MEANS YOU DID NOT HAVE BEFORE.
2:20:16 YOU MENTIONED THE IMPORTANCE OF PEOPLE.
2:20:19 BEFORE? DAVID: AS A SECOND TIME FOUNDER
2:20:27 IT'S EASY FOR ME TO SAY I DON'T KNOW EVERYTHING.
2:20:31 I FEEL COMFORTABLE SAYING THAT AND I GET EXCITED ABOUT THAT.
2:20:34 I LOVE BEING IN THE ROOM WITH OTHER PEOPLE THAT ARE BETTER AND
2:20:35 SMARTER THAN I AM. THAT IS HOW WE FOCUS ON BUILDING
2:20:38 A TEAM. WE TALKED ABOUT HIRING PLAYER
2:20:44 COACHES, ESPECIALLY EARLY ON. FOLKS I CAN BE STRATEGIC AND
2:20:48 DEVELOP THE PLAN BUT ALSO NOT AFRAID TO ROLL UP THEIR SLEEVES
2:20:50 AND GET THEIR HANDS DIRTY AND GET TO WORK.
2:20:57 IS HIRING A PLUS TALENT, PAYING WHAT THEY ARE WORTH,
2:21:00 BRINGING IN TOP-TIER TALENT AS OPPOSED TO TRYING TO NICKEL AND
2:21:03 DIME AND SAVE $2000 HERE AND FIVE DOLLARS AND DOLLARS HERE --
2:21:07 $5,000 HERE IN BRINGING IN SOME PLAYERS.
2:21:10 PEOPLE THAT ARE OPERATING AT THAT LEVEL PUNCH FAR ABOVE THEIR
2:21:12 WEIGHT. WE WANT DRIVERS, NOT PASSENGERS.
2:21:18 CHRISTINA: WELL SAID. THANK YOU SO MUCH.
2:21:21 ALLISON: THANK YOU FOR HAVING US.
2:21:24 DAVID: YOU MISSED IT. YOU ARE OUT.
2:21:27 LISA: YOU DID A LOT OF FUN INTERVIEWS.
2:21:29 YOU DID ALL THE COOL FOODSTUFF. CHRISTINA: WE HAD CUPCAKES AND A
2:21:32 BUNCH OF STUFF. LISA: BUT I WAS NOT HERE.
2:21:37 DAVID: COMING UP, IT IS TIME ONCE AGAIN FOR THE POINTED NEWS
2:21:40 QUIZ. DRY ERASE BOARDS ARE OUT.
2:21:45 MARKERS ARE OUT. CHRISTINA: WE WILL SEE A ONE OF
2:21:48 US CAN FINALLY WIN ONE OF THESE THINGS.
2:21:51 DAVID: WE WILL BE RIGHT BACK. ♪ ♪
2:21:57 DAVID: WELCOME BACK TO "BLOOMBERG THIS WEEKEND."
2:22:01 TIME FOR ONE OF MY FAVORITE PARTS OF THE SHOW, THE NEWS
2:22:02 QUIZ. LISA MATEO BACK WITH US ONCE
2:22:05 AGAIN. YOU HAVE TEA TO SPELL.
2:22:14 LISA: YOU GUYS ARE GOING TO LOVE THIS.
2:22:16 DAVID: SET THE STAKES. LISA: FOR THOSE PLAYING ALONG,
2:22:19 PLAY WITH US BECAUSE IT IS A LOT OF FUN.
2:22:22 THERE ARE THREE CATEGORIES AND THEY HAVE 30 CHIPS IN FRONT OF
2:22:24 THEM. THEY ARE GOING TO PLACE THEIR
2:22:28 BETS. CHRISTINA: IT IS HARDER THAN
2:22:31 USUAL. DAVID: HOW WAS THE FINGER DOING?
2:22:37 CHRISTINA: I TOOK THE CAST OFF SO YOU WOULD NOT MARK IT ON TV.
2:22:40 DAVID: IT DID NOT STOP ME. LISA: ARE YOU READY FOR YOUR
2:22:43 CATEGORIES? YOU WILL WRITE YOUR ANSWERS ON
2:22:46 YOUR WHITEBOARDS. THE CATEGORIES FIRST.
2:22:53 IPO'S, MOVIES, AND THE THIRD CATEGORY IS M&A.
2:22:56 MERGERS AND ACQUISITIONS. HOW DO YOU FEEL?
2:23:02 DAVID: NOT GREAT AT ALL. I WAS TEMPTED TO DO THAT BUT I
2:23:07 DON'T HAVE MUCH MORE FAITH IN THE OTHER CATEGORIES.
2:23:11 THE EVEN STEPHEN. LISA: YOU ARE BOTH DOING THE
2:23:16 SAME. BOO.
2:23:20 CHRISTINA: HAPPY SATURDAY TO YOU TOO.
2:23:25 LISA: LET'S GET IPO'S. ANTHROPIC IS SAID TO GO PUBLIC
2:23:30 WITH A VALUATION OF $1.4 TRILLION.
2:23:34 NAME WHAT COMPANY VALUED HIGHER DURING ITS DEBUT.
2:23:38 WHO VALUED HIGHER THAN THAT? IT WAS ONE COMPANY WHO DID.
2:23:44 DAVID: ARE YOU READY? SPACEX.
2:23:50 CHRISTINA: I THOUGHT IT WAS GOOGLE.
2:23:52 LISA: SPACEX. CHRISTINA: THAT IT IS EASIER
2:23:56 THAN I THOUGHT IT WAS. LISA: YOU MADE IT HARDER THAN IT
2:23:59 WAS. CHRISTINA: I WAS LOOKING AT THE
2:24:05 OVER SUBSCRIPTIONS AND -- ALL RIGHT.
2:24:09 LISA: SPACEX DEBUTED AT $1.8 TRILLION.
2:24:13 YES, YES, YES. NO WORRIES.
2:24:15 I WILL HOLD ON TO THESE BECAUSE YOU CAN GET THEM BACK IN THE
2:24:16 BONUS ROUND. YOU CAN EARN THEM BACK,
2:24:19 CHRISTINA. CHRISTINA: BE A LITTLE LESS
2:24:21 SMUG. LISA: MOVIES.
2:24:28 JEREMY LACH THEM HAS BEEN TAPPED BY SKYDANCE TO BE THE PRESIDENT
2:24:31 OF WHAT STUDIO? CHRISTINA: I DO KNOW THIS ONE.
2:24:36 LISA: WHAT IS THE NAME OF THAT STUDIO?
2:24:38 HE IS THINKING. JEREMY LACHUM.
2:24:44 DAVID: I WROTE PARAMOUNT. CHRISTINA: DC.
2:24:49 LISA: CHRISTINA. CHRISTINA: JAMES GUNN IS OUT AND
2:24:53 THIS GUY IS IN. LISA: THERE IS A GIANT NERD AND
2:24:59 THE RUFFINI HOUSEHOLD THAT'S UPSET ABOUT THIS STUFF HE'S A
2:25:02 MEMBER OF THE FOUNDING TEAM OF MARVEL.
2:25:10 THAT IS THE WHOLE THING. HE'S ONE OF THE FOUNDING TEAMS
2:25:14 THOSE THINGS. CHRISTINA: AND SUCCESSFULLY.
2:25:20 LISA: EXCEPT FOR SUPERGIRL. WE HAD A TIE RIGHT NOW.
2:25:28 DAVID: WE HAVE M&A TO DECIDE. CHRISTINA: THANKS FOR THIS,
2:25:31 LISA. LISA: WHAT ARTIFICIAL
2:25:36 INTELLIGENCE ON DEMAND DR. SERVICE WAS RECENTLY ACQUIRED BY
2:25:39 AURA? WHAT IS THE NAME OF THIS
2:25:43 ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE ON DEMAND DOCTOR SERVICE?
2:25:51 IT'S A TOUGH ONE. CHRISTINA: I DON'T KNOW.
2:25:56 LISA: THIS WHEN I HAD NOT HEARD UP SO I WILL GIVE IT TO YOU HAVE
2:25:57 EITHER OF YOU GET THIS. CHRISTINA: IT WAS ALSO A LEGAL
2:26:01 WORD. WAS A COUNSEL?
2:26:07 LISA: YOU DID NOT GET IT RIGHT. IT'S COUNSEL.
2:26:11 LOOK AT THAT. CHRISTINA: A LATE SEARCH FOR THE
2:26:14 LADY. THAT WAS SHOCKING.
2:26:20 LISA: ACQUIRED FOR $625 MILLION. IT'S ACTUALLY ON THE AURA APP,
2:26:28 DRAWING ON THE INFORMATION THAT'S ALREADY IN THERE.
2:26:34 PASS THEM ALONG. THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
2:26:38 LISA: CHRISTINA IS IN THE LEAD. YOU CAN'T STEAL HER CHIPS.
2:26:46 CHRISTINA: DAVID GURA JUST PILED -- TOOK A STACK OF CHIPS OUT OF
2:26:48 HIS POCKET. DAVID: THERE'S NO EVIDENCE OF
2:26:50 THAT. CHRISTINA: WE HAVE TO TALK TO
2:26:53 DIRECTOR TIM. DAVID: WHAT ARE WE IMPLICATING
2:26:56 HERE? LISA: IT WAS A VERY SMOOTH MOVE.
2:27:02 CHRISTINA: PUT THEM BACK IN YOUR POCKET FROM WHENCE THEY CAME.
2:27:05 IF I DON'T GET THIS BONUS, I AM COMING FOR YOU.
2:27:08 LISA: PULLED THEM OUT OF HIS JACKET.
2:27:11 YOU CAN EARN THEM BACK. YOU CAN KEEP THEM IN YOUR
2:27:13 POCKET, DAVID GURA. FOOD AND BEVERAGE IS THE BONUS.
2:27:22 WHICH POPULAR BRAND OF FRUIT-BASED TREATS IS GETTING
2:27:25 $60 MILLION INVESTMENT FROM MARS?
2:27:29 DAVID: FRUIT-BASED TREATS? LISA: AND $60 MILLION FROM MARS,
2:27:35 BECAUSE THEY ARE GOOD. YOU KEEP THEM IN THE FRIDGE.
2:27:40 CHRISTINA: I DON'T REMEMBER WHAT THEY ARE CALLED.
2:27:42 LISA: I LOVE THESE THINGS. CHRISTINA: IT IS SOMETHING LIKE
2:27:45 TUTTI-FRUTTI BUT IT'S NOT. LISA: YOU ARE CLOSE.
2:27:49 NOT EVEN A GUESS? DAVID: LIFESAVERS?
2:27:55 LISA: FROUFROU. THEY ARE LIKE A FROZEN DRIED
2:28:01 FRUIT AND COVERED IN DARK CHOCOLATE OR MILK CHOCOLATE.
2:28:05 CHRISTINA: FEWER CALORIES THAN A GIANT HUNK OF CHOCOLATE.
2:28:08 THEY ARE QUITE EXPENSIVE, I SHOULD SAY.
2:28:11 DAVID: TIED IT UP AGAIN. YOU CAN TEST YOUR KNOWLEDGE ON
2:28:15 ALL 10 QUESTIONS AND TAKE THE QUIZ AT BLOOMBERG.COM/-- NOBODY
2:28:19 WILL JUDGE YOU. PLAY ON THE BLOOMBERG BUSINESS
2:28:24 APP OR BLOOMBERG.COM. CHRISTINA: THANK YOU FOR
2:28:27 SUFFERING WITH ME. "BLOOMBERG THIS WEEKEND" WILL BE
2:28:31 BACK TOMORROW STARTING AT 7:00 A.M.
2:28:35 DAVID: MASTERS OF BUSINESS IS UP NEXT FOR OUR TV AUDIENCE, WALL
2:28:38 STREET WEEK WITH DAVID WESTIN. ♪
Pointed! Bloomberg’s Weekly News Quiz For Risk-Takers full transcript
0:00 I would like tea like you've got tea to spill.
0:02 I do like my ambitions for this segment. Wow.
0:05 Alright. It's gonna be fantastic. You guys are gonna love this. Okay.
0:07 Set the stakes.
0:08 I will... Here it is for you. Okay? Yes. So for those of you playing along,
0:12 please do play with us because it's a lot of There are three categories, and they
0:16 each have 30 chips in front of them. As they hear each category, they are going
0:20 to place their bets.
0:22 It's harder than usual on how they feel about finger categories.
0:24 She has hurt her finger. We should note that. How's the finger doing?
0:27 It's good. I took the cast off so you wouldn't mock it on TV. It's doing
0:30 much better
0:30 for stop me.
0:31 I'm sorry. Nothing will stop it. Nothing will stop it. Alright. Are you ready for your
0:35 three categories? Absolutely.
0:36 And then you're gonna
0:37 write your answers on your whiteboards. Okay. Let's get to the categories first, and then you
0:40 place your bets. That's the first move. Uh-huh. Okay. First is IPOs. Okay. Second category is
0:45 movies, and third category is m and a. Wow. Mergers and acquisitions. Wow.
0:50 I see who am or saved this week.
0:52 How? I know. So how do you feel then? So maybe you won't put
0:55 it all
0:55 on m and a? I don't know. No.
0:58 I'm I was tempted to do that, but I don't have much more faith in these
1:01 other categories. So I might just pull the Raffini Even? Even
1:04 Steven. Even Steven. Split. Yeah.
1:06 And Steven.
1:07 Oh, you're both doing the same. Boo. Okay. Here we go. Let's go
1:11 to the. Happy Saturday to you too. Category question. Our international audience, Lisa Mateo.
1:17 Let's go to IPOs. IPOs. Oh, wait. Anthropic is set to go public with a valuation
1:22 of $1,400,000,000,000. So name what company valued higher during its debut.
1:29 Okay. Well
1:30 Who valued higher than that? Okay. There was one company who did.
1:37 Yeah. Okay. You ready? Are you ready? I'm ready. I'm ready. SpaceX.
1:40 Let's see. Christina? No.
1:41 I thought
1:41 it was Google. No. SpaceX. It was SpaceX. Oh, that was alright. No. That was that
1:47 was easier than I thought it was.
1:49 You know?
1:50 You made it harder than it was.
1:52 Because when we were getting ready to talk to Barry, was looking at easy with your
1:55 finger. Something something about the oversubscriptions and the... Alright.
1:59 Well
1:59 I get your chips. Actually, SpaceX debuted at 1,800,000,000,000.
2:02 That was really dumb
2:03 of me. Yes.
2:04 Yes. Okay.
2:05 Overthought it.
2:05 There we go.
2:06 No worries. No worries. I will hold on to these because you can get them back
2:09 in the bonus back in the bonus
2:11 round. Back, Christine.
2:12 Save me
2:12 to grow up. Be a little less smug. Little less.
2:14 Sorry.
2:14 Lisa, let's go to movies.
2:16 Movies. You're Okay. You've got this.
2:18 Jeremy Lacham has been tapped by Skydance to be the president of what studio?
2:23 Oh, I do know this one. Oh, yes. Yes. I love it.
2:26 I love it. What is the name of that studio? He's thinking he's thinking tick tock
2:32 tick tock. Jeremy Lacham.
2:35 Okay. I wrote Paramount.
2:37 DC. DC, Christina. Alright.
2:40 Well So what does that mean, Christina? Tied.
2:42 That means So James Gunn is out. This guy is in.
2:45 Wow. You knew the names.
2:46 I did.
2:46 Wow. How is that the case?
2:48 I... There is a giant nerd in the Raffini household who's very upset about this.
2:52 Yep. Well, he... Because he's a member of the founding team of Marvel. Then right
2:56 at Marvel is so drag on this show today.
2:59 It's in your poor brother. But that's the whole thing with this. So he... He's one
3:03 of the founding teams of a Marvel, know, who does Iron Man and Guardians of Galaxy
3:06 and all those things. So
3:08 And very successfully. Yes. Yes. Yes.
3:10 Controversial. So it's been... Except for Supergirl, which was me. Yeah. This is... There's but always
3:13 one.
3:14 Winners. Can't all be winners.
3:15 There's only one. Supergirl. So we're at a tie right now because I have both of
3:19 yours.
3:19 Thanks for your to
3:21 Yeah. It's an
3:21 M and A.
3:22 It's gonna be the exciting factor. Thanks for this, Lisa. Alright.
3:24 Here is your question for M and A. What artificial intelligence on demand doctor service was
3:30 recently acquired by Aura? You know, the artificial
3:33 intelligence What
3:34 is the name of this artificial
3:36 intelligence on doctor service?
3:39 I know
3:40 if not.
3:42 It's a tough one. I don't know. This one, I I I have not heard of,
3:47 so I will give it to you if either of you get this. I don't know.
3:51 It's something to do that was also a legal word. It... Was it counsel?
3:55 You did not
3:56 get it right. Really? Yes. It is.
3:58 I wrote what's up doc. It's not
3:59 what's up doc. Counselor advocate. It was counsel? It's counsel. Wow. Christine, at that. Late search
4:06 coming for the Alright. That was as shocking as me for me.
4:09 So they acquired them for $625,000,000. Council is actually in the Oura app, so it allows
4:15 you to kind of ask questions about your health and then receive AI answers to draw
4:19 on that Oura data that's already in there. So, Council, who knew? I did this video.
4:24 That means that
4:25 I get your chips. Come on. Pass them along. Pass them. Thank you very much. Christina
4:30 is in the lead. But we have a book.
4:32 Wait a minute. You can't steal her chips. Wait a minute. Okay. For our radio listeners,
4:37 David Gerard just piled a... He just took a stack of chips out of his pocket
4:41 that we received. Camera. There's no evidence of that.
4:44 Tim, we gotta talk to director Tim. I can't believe you missed this shenanigans.
4:47 Why were we implicating you?
4:48 Very sly
4:49 with that.
4:49 That was a very smooth move. Put those away.
4:52 Back in my pocket?
4:53 Put them back in your pocket from whence they came. Alright, Lisa. I swear if I
4:57 don't get this phone, I'm coming for you.
4:58 He's watching. You know?
5:00 Pulled him out of his pocket.
5:01 It was very fast.
5:02 Alright. She... You could earn him back, so don't worry. Okay? You keep them in your
5:05 pocket, David girl. Food and beverage is our bonus. You don't deserve
5:09 them back. Alright. Food and beverage.
5:10 Food and beverage.
5:11 You're gonna
5:11 get this. You're gonna get this. Which popular brand of fruit based treats is getting $60,000,000
5:18 investment from Mars.
5:20 Fruit based treats?
5:22 Yes. They are fruit based treats. Oh. And they're getting 60,000,000 from Mars. I know what
5:27 this is. Because they're good. Keep them
5:29 in the
5:29 fridge. I eat them.
5:31 I still can't remember what they're called.
5:32 Yes. Yes. They're so yummy. I love these things. Okay.
5:35 I actually don't
5:35 know what you're
5:36 It's something like tootie fruity, but it's not tootie fruity.
5:39 You're correct. It's not tootie fruity, but you're close. You keep not even a guess.
5:42 I couldn't even guess lifesavers.
5:44 No. No. It's not a lifesaver. Fruit. Fruit. Fruit.
5:47 Fruit. Yes.
5:48 These are really good.
5:50 They are good. They're like a frozen, like, snack dried fruit, and they're covered in, like,
5:54 dark chocolate or milk chocolate. They're so
5:56 They're great. They have fewer calories than giant hunk of chocolate. I love them. They are
5:59 quite expensive, I will say. The lady
6:01 at didn't get the the bonus, but you
6:03 can't Oh,
6:04 look at that. Tied it up again. Thank you very much. You can test your knowledge
6:07 on all 10 questions. You can take the point of your quiz at bloomberg.
6:10 While playing this quiz.
6:11 Point. Nobody's gonna judge you. You can play it yourself on the Bloomberg business app or
6:15 bloomberg.com.
By The Way: Headlines You May Have Missed full transcript
0:02 Welcome back to Bloomberg this weekend. Or Bet it's unfair.
0:05 You always get to do the intro to this segment.
0:08 It's almost like I have allies in the control room before the way.
0:10 And I say beat dubs versus the way you say BT does the right way.
0:14 So I got to tell you, loyal viewer of the show and not the brightest crown in
0:18 the box. My brother Joey Ruffini, I was talking
0:20 about this morning Joe and he said, oh, BT dubs Bloomberg this
0:25 weekend. I never put that together.
0:27 He never understood it. So in case other Charlie, we missed it.
0:31 Bloomberg this weekend bt w Joey they're making fun of you.
0:37 I'm not I just want to point that out here.
0:39 So if you'd like to change the way that you saying please feel free.
0:42 Sorry okay. That have you released on the show.
0:45 So she's going to catch us up on some of the stories we might have missed.
0:47 Let's go. So we've been talking right about Gen
0:49 wrong Nvidia of course. Okay, so now some talk about the famous
0:53 leather jackets that he wore. That has been it's been crazy.
0:57 Okay. So this one specifically is from New
0:59 York magazine's The Cut. Okay.
1:00 It says Jensen Huang's leather jacket confessed before he did.
1:03 Okay. So he's known for wearing them, right?
1:06 Just like Steve Jobs had the black turtlenecks, you know, it's like a
1:08 thing. Um, everyone wants it in July.
1:11 Wanted by Thompson. Everyone wants it.
1:13 Someone paid $960,000. Do you remember that?
1:17 So there be this. Do we know?
1:19 Who know? And do we know how much it's worth now?
1:22 Much less. Well, yeah.
1:23 No kidding. That's the question.
1:25 But the thing is, is that the cut of, say, a $9,000 leather jacket is a Tom
1:30 Ford wearing of a man. Yes.
1:32 Who faithfully goes home to his wife and kids after a long day of work.
1:36 They say that's a man in a midlife crisis.
1:39 Okay, so it sparked so many other stories, like The Washington Post had
1:43 this story saying Jenson One's leather jacket were telling us something, right?
1:47 It says it reads as a textbook midlife crisis.
1:49 I think of the New York Times saying, this is an opinion piece.
1:52 Gentleman betrayed the leather jacket community.
1:54 It is somebody who wears leather jackets saying, you know what?
1:57 You're making us look bad. Kara swisher saying the very same thing
1:59 to me yesterday really said reclaiming it.
2:01 She said from Jensen, when I saw one this morning, that was it's not any
2:05 leather jacket. It's that type of leather jacket, the
2:08 very stiff leather with the, you know, it's not worn in.
2:11 It looks almost overly polished. That specific leather jacket?
2:13 No rivets. Is the midlife crisis jacket.
2:16 I have no kidding on this now. I like the motorcycle, just to be clear
2:20 about that. You know.
2:21 Oh, well, hang out with Matt Miller. Were I to buy one, it would be from,
2:24 like, the boot barn. I would want a distressed one, or I
2:27 just. I did just buy one that has, like, studs
2:29 and stuff in it. That's not too fancy for not does not
2:32 have rhinestones. It has rivets.
2:34 Oh, I don't know.
2:36 Okay. Anyway.
2:38 All right, all right. What did take a good one.
2:39 The other top story okay Microsoft outage okay.
2:41 Remember we were just talking about this earlier.
2:43 Okay. So this one's from Bloomberg.
2:45 Microsoft outage sends traders back to phones and fax if they remember how to
2:49 use the fax machine. Okay, Sheen, we have one here Bloomberg.
2:53 It's part of the printer. But do you know how to use it?
2:56 Is it hooked up? Does it work?
2:57 She doesn't print. She doesn't print.
2:59 It does. Oh, God.
3:01 Let me get you back on track and out of trouble.
3:03 Literally printed for you yesterday. Yeah.
3:06 So. All right.
3:07 People were struggling, right? They couldn't get access to all these
3:09 things. But the thing is, it's goes to back what
3:11 you were saying, Christina. People call it like a snow day.
3:14 So people were enjoying different things that they didn't get to do before.
3:16 Like they said, you know what? Forget this.
3:18 I'm going for coffee. I'm going to the gym.
3:21 I'm going to go do some yoga. I'm going to.
3:23 Do you know what you were doing? Let's switch to the gym.
3:26 And yoga. Yes, gym and yoga.
3:28 And of course, social media. People were saying, you know, test it
3:31 out for a few days. Hashtag for day.
3:33 Weekend. Okay.
3:34 So people wanted to kind of go a little bit longer because they were enjoying
3:36 kind of this detachment moment that they were getting.
3:39 I don't know, I'm even Burger King did tweet something and it said whoever's
3:43 troubleshooting and working on the outage, take your time, go out and get a
3:46 Whopper. Very nice.
3:47 See here. So everyone is pitching and pitching,
3:51 unfortunately for us, the terminal. That's great.
3:53 It was excellent emails. Great team.
3:56 Very good. Take care of the bird.
3:58 All right. Everybody was like, did it bother you?
3:59 I was like, absolutely. I don't even know.
4:01 It was going on for quite a while. Yeah, exactly.
4:03 Okay. The competition for air talent we know
4:06 is huge. Right?
4:06 Okay, so this one's in the Wall Street Journal.
4:08 Listen to what they're getting offered. Companies dole out mega paydays and
4:12 luxury trips to compete for air talent. Okay, so we've known that a lot of tech
4:17 workers have been getting laid off, right, due to technology.
4:19 But there are certain corners of that sector where they're heavily recruited.
4:23 So let me give you example. This is a startup serval.
4:26 They're looking for software engineers. Here's what they're offering them.
4:29 $30,000 signing bonus three. Tom, for the jacket.
4:33 That sure is you. Thank you for that math.
4:36 There might be a deal with you by three. I don't know, they're called discount
4:40 offering. It doesn't stop 30,000 to any employees
4:43 who recommend somebody who gets hired. Okay, six leather jackets.
4:47 And you can do this the whole time. Ready?
4:49 One more leather jacket, David, because they're throwing in a vacation worth of
4:52 0,000. Wow.
4:54 Which you could wear the leather jackets.
4:55 I could see an attempt, a leather jacket, depending on the climate.
4:59 But the problem, OpenAI anthropic, like they're taking all the talent.
5:02 So now there's a smaller pool, and everyone's kind of going for these
5:04 software engineers. And that's why they're being offered
5:07 these things. And it's not just software engineers.
5:08 People are in construction manufacturing.
5:11 They're getting more by switching jobs, because now you need those people for
5:14 like data center building and things like that.
5:16 Yeah. Of course.
5:17 So these people are in high demand. They're getting vacations.
5:20 I want a nine 0,000 figure trying to think if I have any skills, that I'm
5:25 good enough to warrant that kind of recruitment.
5:27 And as I'm sitting here, I'm coming up empty.
5:29 Next story. You got one more place, Thank you.
5:32 Let's switch first. Okay.
5:34 There's a bargain for a first class ticket.
5:36 Guys, did you know that? Okay.
5:38 Sorry. I'm busy getting David.
5:39 Is there any, like, spoiled? Okay, I see this ID.
5:42 This is from the Los Angeles Times. Okay.
5:44 Frontier. Frontier Airlines offering first class
5:47 seats starting at 29. Okay, so it starts March 5th, but it's
5:53 not what you think. Okay, so you have a defined first
5:56 flight. First class for frontier is a little
5:58 more legroom right okay. There's no middle seat.
6:00 They've eliminated that. So you only have two rows each passenger
6:03 you get your own power port okay. Which would you I know I know, but
6:07 here's the thing. It does not include meals or snacks.
6:11 You kind of pay for your own food if first class is kind of in quotation
6:15 marks. Yeah, yeah yeah, yeah.
6:16 So I mean, the points guy is saying that the seats don't even realize you're
6:21 sick, but it's a bargain. You get an outlet.
6:24 I mean, you get a you get a port to charge your phone.
6:27 I mean, if it is slightly less miserable than the experience in the back of the
6:30 plane, I would probably pay for it. But it's a sad state of affairs that
6:34 can't even have pretzels in a worm. So I know you can't.
6:37 Now you got to pay for that. Yeah, right.
6:38 Well.
The Entrepreneurs Behind Poppi Start Over full transcript
0:00 Allison and Stephen Ellsworth went from making an apple cider vinegar based drink in their home
0:04 to a huge payday, thanks in part to an appearance on Shark Tank that paved the
0:08 way to wider sales of the drink, Poppy.
0:10 That's right. Last week, the couple sold the prebiotic soda to Pepsi Co for nearly $2,000,000,000.
0:14 Now they're back with a new beverage in the hydration game for everyday consumers.
0:18 Yeah. That happened last year. David and I sat down with Allison and Stephen Ellsworth to
0:21 find out how they still have plenty of pop in their playbook. Allison, Stephen, welcome. Thank
0:27 you for joining us here in the Bloomberg studio. Everyone knows about Poppy. Right? I mean,
0:31 you had the Super Bowl commercial. I mean, come on. But not many people know about
0:35 the the story behind it, like the decades it took to kinda get there, the struggle,
0:40 talking about maxing out credit cards, talking about selling a car to get bottles, like all
0:45 that. Can you guys describe what the beginning part of this journey was like for you?
0:50 Oh
0:50 my goodness. It was a decade in the making almost. Really, it was ten years. Everyone
0:55 loves to say overnight success. And to your point, they don't see all of those, like,
0:59 nitty gritty things of... I mean, I was doing, like, deliveries to grocery stores with my
1:04 baby strapped to the back of me and, like, bottling it ourselves and maxing out the
1:09 credit cards, and I loved every second of it. The chaos, I think it's... You know,
1:15 to be an entrepreneur, it's the best job in the world, and you gotta love those
1:18 high stress moments for sure.
1:20 Stephen, when did it feel viable to you so you had faith that this was gonna
1:23 take off? Mhmm. When were you sure that it was going to?
1:28 I think that there was... The the great thing is there was there was those wins
1:32 along the way. I I think the moment that I knew it was going to be
1:38 really, really huge was after our first Super Bowl commercial. We were already a sizable business
1:43 at that point, but when we doubled down and bought a Super Bowl ad, it just
1:47 took it to the next level. The business overnight year over year. It was actually really,
1:53 really tremendous. But along the way, we had those wins enough to keep us going and
1:57 excited about what the future held.
1:58 Another one of those big wins was shark tanky, I guess. You were nine months pregnant
2:01 when you were there. I remember seeing her. I was like, there's the belly. She is
2:05 ready to go.
2:05 Go pregnant.
2:06 So what was that experience like for you? How did that change kind of the trajectory
2:10 of your business? Because your brand evolved right after that too.
2:13 Yeah. There were so many, like, early indicators from being at the farmer's market and Whole
2:17 Foods approaching us and saying, hey. This needs to be in grocery stores to getting a
2:21 deal on Shark Tank, and then virality at launch was insane. We were one of the
2:26 first, like, founder led brands to really put ourselves out there on social media. And so
2:31 I think there was, like, all of these, like, micro win moments, and Shark Tank, like,
2:36 changed our lives absolutely. And we we feel like we... We're living the American dream at
2:39 the end of the day. And so, you know, obviously crazy to do it again, but
2:44 we love it.
2:45 Can you talk a bit about that social media strategy, how unique it was, and sort
2:49 of the the role that that played in the success of the brand?
2:51 You know, I think it made us digital first from day one. Because keep in mind,
2:55 we launched Poppy 03/03/2020, like, first week of COVID, which is, like, crazy
3:01 to really think
3:02 of it.
3:02 So everybody was, like, forced in their house. How do you connect with them? Well, everyone
3:06 had a phone in their hand, and they were desperate for human connection. And so we
3:10 were just trying to really think through disruptively of, like, how we could, you know, kinda
3:14 hit this wild, wild west that was TikTok at the time. And I remember everyone telling
3:18 me it was not a great idea and that it was just a bunch of kids
3:21 dancing on there, and I was like, hey. No. Like, I think that this is where
3:24 community is. And I started making recipe videos. I was dancing. I... Literally anything to get
3:31 as many people to see Poppy as possible. And then, honestly, it was just me sitting
3:35 down and telling the story and being authentic that really broke through. And I think I
3:39 have that original video that I posted that kinda, like, broke the Internet and changed the
3:43 whole trajectory of the business has, like, 250,000,000 views on it. It's unreal. So I think
3:49 it made us think differently from day one. It did. On the
3:52 business side of things, Stephen, what do you think... What what lessons have you guys learned
3:57 the hard way? I'm sure there's a lot. Yeah. So many. So
4:00 many lessons. I think the biggest one is just making sure that you overinvest in people
4:06 early on. As entrepreneurs, you feel like you have to do everything yourself because a lot
4:14 of the times you do. You don't have the access to the great talent. You don't
4:18 have access to the capital required to hire great talent. And so there definitely is this
4:23 transition mode, at least both Allison and I went through it, where we started to delegate
4:27 and release some of those responsibilities to other folks. But that's probably the biggest lesson is
4:33 is not only the team, but who you surround yourself with. Who are your investors or
4:37 advisers that are challenging your thoughts, providing that diversity of thought to ultimately grow the business
4:43 and push it forward?
4:44 So let's talk about this next chapter. Let's talk about Jettie. What is it and what
4:47 are your hopes for for the brand?
4:49 Yeah. You know, when we were kind of post exit, there's the post exit blues, and
4:55 you're, like, finding yourself again and perk outside of... Like, it's crazy. Yeah. You know? And
4:59 then you kinda get at the other side, and we're like... We played golf for a
5:02 little bit, and we, like, hung out with the kids. And Mhmm. You know, it was
5:06 really... We missed chaos. We missed the chaos. Like, it's crazy. Like, just the the excitement
5:13 you see when someone tries it for the first time. Like, it's such a creative outlet
5:16 to be able to, I don't know, create something that people fall in love with. And
5:20 so we were kind of not sure what we're gonna do. And one day, I was
5:24 like, oh, wait.
5:25 I haven't had water today, and
5:28 it was, like, 02:00, and I'd had two coffees. And I was trying all these electrolyte
5:31 mixes, and I just realized everything within hydration has been made for the extremes. Right? For
5:37 Yeah. For sports or a thousand milligrams of sodium. It's just so intense. And so I
5:42 was like, why don't we make just approachable everyday hydration? And so it's a product I
5:46 made for me and for my kids, and we only have a 100 milligrams of sodium
5:50 compared to some of the others. And we have powders as well, so we're the first
5:55 hydration brand to launch powders and drink at the same time.
5:58 Mhmm. So how is it different launching a product this time around? You self funded?
6:03 We have self funded. I I think what's different this time is we have access. Yeah.
6:08 Access to retailers, to distributors, to to a great team this this time.
6:13 But I could ask you lastly, you have the experience obviously means now that you didn't
6:18 have before. You mentioned a moment ago the importance of of people. Mhmm. How have you
6:22 thought through the way that you structure this company based on your experience building the company
6:26 that you did before?
6:28 Yeah. Listen. As a as a second time founder, it's very easy for me to say
6:34 I don't know everything. Uh-huh. I feel very comfortable saying that, and I actually get excited
6:38 about that. I love being in the room with other people that are better and smarter
6:42 than I am. And so that's really how we focus on building the team. We always
6:47 talk about hiring player coaches, especially early on. Those folks that can be strategic, that can
6:53 develop the plan, but are also not afraid to roll up their sleeves and get their
6:56 hands dirty and and get to work. And and really just focusing on hiring a plus
7:01 talent, paying them what they're worth, bringing in that top tier talent as opposed to, like,
7:07 trying to nickel and dime and save $2,000 here or $5,000 here, whatever it may be,
7:12 and bringing in a couple of b players. We've just found the people that are operating
7:17 at that level, like, punch far above their weight. So we we want drivers, not passengers.
7:23 Excellent. Well said. Allison and Stephen, thank you so much.
7:25 Very much. Appreciate it.
7:26 For having us.
7:26 Yeah. This was great. Thanks.
Anthropic IPO Tests Investor Appetite for AI full transcript
0:00 Sean Duffy, the treasury... Transportation secretary, excuse me, tweeting this just moments ago, ten minutes ago
0:04 here. Operations are slowly returning to normal this morning. Planes are pushing back and taxiing and
0:10 taking off, and it is safe to fly. Writes, we are in close coordination with the
0:15 airlines to support the ongoing recovery.
0:18 That's right. But, of course, there's a knock on effect, and Americans will continue to see
0:21 delays and cancellations as carriers try to reschedule. We're gonna go now to Ed Ludlow, who
0:26 is the host of Bloomberg Tech. But, Ed, I understand you were up late with some
0:30 of our colleagues trying to figure out what exactly happened here. I confess I listened to
0:34 the entire press conference, and I'm still not sure.
0:36 So maybe story, though. It is
0:38 a text something with routers. Please explain.
0:40 Yeah. So you you know, you have secretary Duffy on Friday the thirteenth talking about routers.
0:45 And, basically, the the FAA has a really old telecoms network. It's called FTI. And the
0:52 good news is they identified the problem. Routers started getting overloaded that had a cascading effect.
0:58 Controller communications got impacted, and radar data got impacted. The worrying bit and something important to
1:05 clarify is that they don't know why the the routers became overloaded. So they know they
1:10 did. Still investigating what's going on. So what happened last night was a big scramble. There
1:14 were phone calls between the FAA, the intelligence services, the carriers themselves, all gonna say, does
1:20 anyone know why this is happening? And and what do we do about it next? And,
1:25 you know, you guys have covered the headlines on on how the the country thinks it
1:28 needs to now modernize, which at this stage of the game seems a little late. And
1:33 the other piece is that I think l three Harris is a company, a name that's
1:36 involved in diagnosing what's what's going on. But I think, you know, I'm due to fly
1:41 to New York tomorrow. I hope I'll see you guys next
1:42 week. We're looking forward to that, and likewise, hope that you get here on on time.
1:46 Yes. L three Harris Technologies, according to our colleagues at Bloomberg News, operates and helps maintain
1:49 the older telecommunications network. It has been tasked here to diagnose the cause of the data
1:55 overload. Without question, the big story of your week, Ed, was the one involving NVIDIA. And
2:00 for so many years now, you have interviewed Jensen Huang. I remember I was saying a
2:04 few moments ago as we dealt with the story in the last hour. Seeing you in
2:07 Washington after one of those big NVIDIA conferences that took place Yes. There, you had occasion
2:11 to speak with him there. Talk a bit about... I guess legacy is the wrong word
2:16 here. But but as this company looks to hire a new permanent CEO, who might be
2:20 a good cultural fit for this company? How difficult it will be to replace him given,
2:24 yes, the kind of business acumen that that he had, but also the technological expertise that
2:29 he brought to bear as well as one of the cofounders of this company?
2:31 Sure. I mean I mean, I spent, you know, a reasonable amount of time with over
2:36 the last three or four years, and, you know, I posted about this during the week.
2:39 But the lesson is that the access to to someone is no substitute for the reporting.
2:45 And, you know, frankly, all of us were none the wiser. Right? So the the the
2:50 real question that we were still standing with is what is NVIDIA without Jensen one? There
2:56 are lots of very talented people there, a deep, deep bench of talent from software to
3:01 chip design and architecture to hardware engineering, but it's a it's a real thing. Right? You
3:06 know, what does that look like going forward? And you guys may have seen overnight there
3:09 are initiatives from different corners, real initiatives. There were some fake ones circulating too to try
3:15 and push the board to consider bringing Jensen one back. There was a report in the
3:20 Financial Times that Renee Haas, who is the ARM CEO, had been approached, about the role
3:27 as as NVIDIA CEO long long term. NVIDIA's board issued a statement in response to that
3:32 saying they have not made any formal approach to anyone. But Rene Hasleth is is is
3:37 one of the names in the running because he was at NVIDIA for quite a long
3:40 time. In 2006, he had about a seven year stint leading the compute business. All of
3:45 NVIDIA's technology today, the blueprint for it is based on ARM designs, ARM architecture. So there's
3:52 a lot of logic in that, but it seems very early. And, again, you know, like,
3:57 there is so much we do not know. There is so much we do not know
4:00 with, both an NVIDIA board investigation going on internally, relying on outside counsel too, and then
4:06 various US justice department investigations that span a very broad range of questions. And some of
4:13 the questions being posed are pretty off the mark too around Johnson Wong, so it's interesting.
4:17 I mean, he's gonna have an interesting couple weeks ahead of him. And I'm wondering, is
4:22 it at all realistic that he could have a redemption arc and come back at this
4:26 level, this high profile level? What does that look like? Does he have to show some
4:31 sort of penance? He obviously is gonna have to testify in front of lawmakers. Does he
4:35 get rid of the leather jackets, which we've been talking about ad nauseam and kind of
4:38 rebrand physically as well as, within the company? What are his options?
4:43 Sure. You... So as of Wednesday night, right up until late Wednesday, you know, Jensen Huang
4:52 was holding on based upon our reporting, and then he he conceded. And and the board...
4:59 You know, we wrote Jensen Huang was ousted. A lot of people came back to us
5:02 and said, no. He resigned. You know, in the board statement, it says Jensen Huang resigned
5:05 effective immediately. That that, you know, the board moved to to make this happen. The the
5:12 the thing is that that that we need to be super clear on is there are
5:16 three basic separate issues. There is Jen Sun Huang's infidelity. You know, NVIDIA's code of conduct
5:24 accounts for that. Right? You know, he had one or more affairs. That... That's a a...
5:30 An isolated issue. Mhmm. In one specific affair with Alice Huang... Alice Huang, there's lots of
5:36 reporting on. The US authorities and NVIDIA are looking at whether that relationship meant that NVIDIA's
5:45 trade secrets or IP or any national security considerations were disclosed to parties that they shouldn't
5:52 have been. Xi is an alleged spy for China. That that idea is being disputed and
5:59 debated, but that as well is a third separate bucket from whether, you know, those those
6:03 secrets were were disclosed outside of of of a safe zone. And then you guys will
6:11 have seen so much on the Bloomberg about Alice Wong and whether chips that were banned
6:17 for export made their way into China somehow. You know? And those are all separate, and
6:21 we don't have updates on them. When the board issued a statement Sunday and gentleman confirmed
6:26 he'd had an affair, they said there was no reason to believe at that time, Sunday,
6:31 almost a week ago, that there had been any IP trade secret or national security leakage.
6:37 So, you know, you just have to wait, I'm afraid. Christina, sorry.
6:40 As I as I think of these buckets
6:41 like my legendary patience,
6:43 I'd love love. Yeah. I I also just think of Alice Wong as a customer of
6:46 NVIDIA. So as you talk about kind of that first bucket of code of conduct, I
6:49 imagine that, you know, regardless of the allegation here for being a spy, that that an
6:53 issue as well. Talk about this meeting this week. We're looking ahead to earnings, Ed, and
6:58 there's a town hall that will follow that, what, twenty four hours later. And I'm curious
7:02 what you'll be listening for from Khaled Kriz, the the interim CEO of the company, who's
7:06 gonna be a familiar voice to many investors and analysts on the call. She's been on
7:10 it before. She is, of course, somebody who's been at the company for, what, more than
7:13 a decade. What are you listening for at the... What you... If you... I don't know
7:17 if you'll be able to hear it yourself in real time, but but what do you
7:19 wanna learn of what she has to say at that town hall?
7:22 Yes. So so my understanding... My firm understanding is, like, earnings will go ahead as completely
7:27 normal. Colette Crest is both interim CEO and Carrie's on as CFO. And, yes, she's been
7:33 there for thirteen years. She'll take questions from analysts. And, you know, net net, no one
7:37 thinks that the events of the past week... Actually, it goes... Extends to sort of late
7:42 October, doesn't it? Let's be honest. But nothing will change the sort of trajectory of the
7:47 financials in the near term. You know, most analysts don't really even see anything happening differently
7:52 through the balance of 2027. They see opportunity for some of NVIDIA's rivals. If Jensen Huang
7:59 is not the the helm, maybe there are customers that are like, okay. I was gonna
8:03 buy NVIDIA chips. Maybe I'll I'll go with a different option. And just very quick on
8:08 the town hall Wednesday, we know that because of a memo that collect sent out to
8:13 staff that was seen by Bloomberg. It's a very normal thing post earnings for NVIDIA to
8:17 kinda have a sort of town hall call it what you will. We just don't know.
8:21 But, you know, in the memo, Crest did say that, you know, they will give NVIDIA
8:25 staff some answers. The answers we're all chasing, I guess.
8:30 You talked about those three buckets with, Chen Huang's Yeah. Issues. But there's a... There's almost
8:36 a fourth here, and that's him as the chief advocate of changing US policy with China
8:42 on these ships and pushing to limit these export controls and trying to influence the White
8:46 House on this issue where he, in fact, possibly could have been being influenced on that
8:51 perspective during that time. Where does this go? And... Yeah. Go ahead.
8:54 No. No. Just to clarify. So so one of the the US justice department probes that
8:59 Bloomberg's reported is an espionage probe, and it looks at Jensen Huang's relationship with Alice Wong.
9:06 But very... Like, to be completely clear and underscore it, Bloomberg's reporting states that Jensen Huang
9:12 himself is not a target of that probe. So they're looking at the relationship and and
9:18 in the... Under the broad umbrella of espionage, and that is where Bloomberg's reporting stands on
9:23 on the allegation that Alice Wong is a spy. But you're absolutely right that the bigger
9:29 question is that, okay, there was a relationship that had with a customer. She was the
9:33 founding executive in Megaspeed. And the accusation and the reporting is that Megaspeed was able to
9:40 get access to systems and and transfer those systems into Mainland China where US export controls
9:47 prevent them going. Right. And that is is in itself being looked at, and and is
9:54 one of the core questions that congress has for Jensen Huang and and in part why
9:59 they have summoned Jensen Huang to testify. But they have also now... You guys may have
10:04 seen... I think it was late morning yesterday, expanded their request to include NVIDIA's corporate council
10:10 and representatives in the commerce department. And I think you guys also, in the last couple
10:14 of hours, have been over the idea that there's a little bit of tension between the
10:18 treasury Just a little bit. Department because the treasury are basically saying, well, hold on. We
10:22 had all the power in the world to prevent mega speed moving this technology across borders.
10:29 I wanna dovetail this story with the one that you'll be covering next week, and that
10:32 is the Anthropic IPO. And you're somebody who wades in Twitter or exes waters, and there
10:37 were a lot of scurrilous tweets about Anthropic maybe setting all of this up. Again, totally
10:42 unfounded, but it's kind of dovetailed these two stories maybe cumbersomely. Let me pull back from
10:47 that, casting that aside, and just ask you how how this incident involving NVIDIA and Jensen
10:52 Huang is likely to shape the way that this IPO unfolds next week.
10:56 Well, I mean, the the reporting is that that the Anthropic IPO will price and trade
11:01 next week, and all of the conversations I've had in the last forty eight hours seem
11:08 like it's full steam ahead. I mean, it it... You know, when all of these headlines
11:11 started to break last weekend, you know, it would be completely reasonable to say, uh-oh. You
11:17 know, is this gonna derail Anthropic's IPO? Anthropic is on the hook for several $100,000,000,000 of
11:24 NVIDIA gear. NVIDIA was due to put $10,000,000,000 into the private placement portion of the raise
11:32 10, just NVIDIA itself putting $10,000,000,000 of the 90.4 that Anthropic wants to raise across the
11:38 the IPO and the private placement. And, you know, it's this idea that, you know, if
11:45 we just zoom out, the the thing that that connects all of this, and it's in
11:49 all the research. Why do we... Why is it such a disaster to many people's mind
11:53 for the AI ecosystem that Gentleman has gone? He was the conductor, the maestro, the glue
11:59 between the Frontier Labs, the supply chain on the the hardware side, the policy side. And
12:05 so, you know, people will be asking those questions this week.
12:09 Ed, we've got about a minute left. Do you expect this to be bigger than SpaceX?
12:13 It is six times oversubscribed. What does that tell us?
12:17 Yeah. I... You know, SpaceX pitched itself as being an AI IPO as well, but Anthropic
12:23 is the first pure AI lab to go public. It also has the public benefit corporation
12:28 element. And all of the signals are that this will be the massive IPO. It will
12:33 overtake SpaceX's. But the lesson learned from SpaceX is that it's an amazing moment in time,
12:38 and then everyone's shocked because weeks later, they try and raise even more money through debt
12:43 markets or or other mechanisms. So AI need money, and so that's the story, really.
How China’s Intelligence Operations Target Tech full transcript
0:00 The ousting of NVIDIA CEO Jensen Huang began with a scandalous affair with whom it alleged
0:04 to have been a Chinese spy.
0:06 This left many wondering who exactly is Alice Huang, what were her objectives, and what was
0:11 the true nature of her work. Joining us now is former CIA counterintel analyst Peter Mattis.
0:17 He is now the president of the Jameson Foundation and author of the book Chinese Communist
0:22 Espionage, which is why we thought it might be good to talk to you. I have...
0:27 When you look at this woman, there are so many different questions. I think what is
0:31 unclear at the moment is, was she an agent or was she an asset? Does it
0:37 matter, and what is the difference?
0:41 So thank you first. Thank you for having me this morning, David and Christina. I think
0:45 the first thing to remember is that you could have an MSS official. Right? That's a
0:49 case officer. That's someone who is an intelligence officer who's handling sources, handling spies, directing them
0:55 at targets, or trying to exploit information coming. She almost certainly was not that. And there's
1:02 something in the Chinese system that's a little more sort of vague than an asset. Right?
1:08 This... She wasn't inside an organization that wanted to be recruited, but she was doing a
1:12 lot of things in business where you could see that she probably is connected to the
1:16 Chinese political elite. She's clearly connected to the tech elite in The United States, where the
1:24 Ministry of State Security has what we call co op these. And these are people who
1:28 are just collaborators, cooperative. They can be tapped when necessary. And in some cases, there's kind
1:33 of a mutual back scratching of, you know, you you... We do a favor for you.
1:38 You do a favor for us. And it it kind of goes back and forth.
1:44 Of course, I know how the CIA operates, the difference between it and the the FBI.
1:47 I've watched enough British shows to know the difference between MI five and MI six.
1:52 How about this? Documentaries on IT and TV.
1:54 Uh-huh. Ex... Explain sort of how the Ministry of State Security operates. How should we think
1:58 of it kind of in complement with those other intelligence agencies around the world?
2:02 In some ways, we should kind of think of it as being like the the old
2:04 KGB of having a a robust domestic mission and the international mission. You know, they collect
2:10 intelligence the same the same way that we do, the same way that others do. Right?
2:14 They think of of intelligences as activating or catalytic knowledge. Right? Information that solves decision making
2:21 problems. These are quotes from from some textbooks. The difference though that they have is that
2:28 they put a lot of effort into what we would call covert action, something that we
2:32 consider exceptional or special that requires a presidential finding. In their case, it's something that they
2:37 consider to be sort of routine, ordinary, you know, just another day that ends in y,
2:42 so to speak. And this is not the first kind of tech case where we've seen
2:46 transfers, and you can kind of get a sense that that intelligence is floating in the
2:51 background. Right? Because it's also used as a way to facilitate sort of critical business or
2:56 strategic business that that has a benefit for the Chinese state.
3:00 Because the public private partnership works very differently in China, I would imagine the corporate espionage
3:07 side works a little differently as well. Is it possible you can be going about your
3:10 business as a a legitimate person working in industry and and get a tap on the
3:15 shoulder from the MSS and you are suddenly doing work for the Chinese government?
3:20 That's absolutely the case. The 2017 intelligence law requires you to cooperate when someone presents legitimate
3:26 credentials and says, you know, do this for us. But there are a couple of big
3:31 differences in the way that they think about economic espionage and how they and how they
3:35 function. You may remember the Minsk raid... The raid many years ago. You may remember the
3:41 Rio Tinto raid in Shanghai almost twenty years ago. That this is where the Ministry of
3:47 State Security's counterintelligence resources were deployed to protect the financial interests of the Chinese party state...
3:54 Of Chinese businesses that had a that had a party state stake in them. So you
3:58 have this protective side. The second thing that you have is that we tend to think
4:05 of intelligence as being the collection of classified information kind of popular. As I mentioned, it's
4:10 about supporting decisions. And if you think about where the Chinese Communist Party is, they look
4:14 at The United States and they see themselves as being an existential competition. They see science
4:19 and technology as being the crux of that competition. And in particular, they see artificial intelligence
4:25 as fundamental to what will happen. And we've already seen tremendous changes in scientific discovery, in
4:31 the ability to launch information operations, in military operations because of AI. So if you are...
4:39 If you if you have the party's worldview and you see this, you're also gonna be
4:42 targeting companies because they're of critical national importance. They'll have, you know, no conversation between a
4:48 tax executive and the president. It's probably classified. So it's probably just sort of unclassified but
4:54 incredibly useful. You guys would probably consider it to be reportable and and interesting. And, you
5:00 know, they have an interest in in trying to facilitate access to the the things that
5:05 they need to to lead in the AI race.
5:07 Peter, I wanna get your perspective on Jensen Huang's awareness of this or his recognition that
5:15 he could be subject to something like this. And I think of the trips that I've
5:18 taken to China at various companies, the kind of information security I've had to do before
5:23 going off and swapping out a phone or taking a different computer. I'm primed to think
5:27 that I'm entering an environment where things are different and I could be approached in a
5:31 different way or or looked at in a different different way. Here he is, one of
5:35 the wealthiest men in the world, running perhaps the most important company of the moment, supplying
5:39 chips at the vanguard of this new technology to companies all over the world. What do
5:44 you make of what seems like real naivete here?
5:48 Look. I've given security awareness briefings to to many corporate executives, and one of the things
5:54 that's kind of astonishing is that a lot of people say, well, I don't have classified
5:57 information. Why would I be a target? Right? That's kind of the first thing. And I
6:01 don't think it's unique. Certainly not unique to Jensen Huang, and it's certainly not unique to
6:07 Americans. It's just... It's something that we're... We haven't... If you haven't lived in that world,
6:12 you haven't really thought about it. And so you think of you think of spying as
6:15 being this particularly glamorous thing or or that you can get after these high value, you
6:20 know, precision points of information. Sometimes you can, but that's not always how it works. The
6:26 second thing is that I think a lot of people think of security and personal protection.
6:32 And... Right? Personal protection is one thing, but that's not what this is. The third, I
6:36 think a lot of people just don't have the the recognition of questions that they should
6:42 be asking about individuals who are thinking about what might be used what might be used
6:48 against them. Right?
6:49 Give give us a few examples of that. Give us give us a few of those
6:51 tools. What what should executives who may be watching wonder about or or the questions that
6:55 they should be asking if they go to China?
6:57 Well, they should be... Well, they shouldn't... I mean, first, this doesn't necessarily happen in China.
7:02 Correct. This can happen in Singapore. It could happen in Hong Kong. It could happen in
7:06 Kuala Lumpur. It could happen in Brussels or Paris. Right? It doesn't matter where where it
7:11 is. I think the first is, you know, know what know what your red lines are.
7:15 What are the things that that can't be talked about? Second, know what your value is,
7:19 particularly from a political side. Right? In one sense, you could see that there's very clearly
7:23 a benefit to the Chinese state in this operation in getting access to the chips, but
7:27 there's also access to political intelligence, conceivably the the ability to influence US policy. Right? These
7:34 things all exist together, and people should be cognizant of who is in their political circle,
7:40 who are they... Who's in their social circle. Right? What is it that I should be
7:44 talking about? I think a good rule, though, is if you're traveling abroad as an American,
7:48 don't talk about other Americans if you can possibly help them because you don't necessarily know
7:52 who you're dealing with, and you don't know who they're reporting to.
7:55 There's this meme that's been going around. Yes. I'm going there. And it's how to tell
8:00 if your girlfriend is a Chinese spy. And it's a joke, and it's tongue in cheek.
8:04 And it's, are you in tech? Yes. Is she more attractive than you? Yes. Spy. It's
8:08 it's ridiculous. But there has to be some sort of briefings, opsec. I have... I've heard
8:15 of people in high intelligence jobs being warned about this exact thing, being warned about young
8:21 attractive women approaching them for information. I've seen it happen. I've been with an intelligence officer
8:26 at a conference when a young woman went up and tried to get that person's information,
8:30 and that intelligence officer knew immediately what it was and shut it down.
8:34 You can say it on the new part.
8:36 I'm not... I am not saying that on television. How are these big CEOs not questioning
8:42 these relationships more, and is it up to people at these companies who could be watching
8:46 this happen to question some of these relationships?
8:51 All is gonna come down to personal awareness and personal choices. Right? And, unfortunately, you know,
8:58 the... There's a standard phrase for for the kind of levers of espionage called MICE. You
9:04 know, money, ideology, coercion, and ego. And, unfortunately, it works because these kinds of things play
9:12 on egos. People like to talk with smart people. People like to talk with others that
9:17 are kind of, you know, closely related to work, but maybe not quite, know, one
9:23 person an unnatural interest in cloud computing? Maybe we should question this.
9:28 Right. Right. Those those are the kinds of things that you should be asking. Like, are
9:32 the questions out of order? Are they are they detailed? Are they exactly business questions? Are
9:37 they political questions? And, you know, first and foremost, where do you... If you don't think
9:42 about this yourself about where do you draw your lines about what is important, what are
9:47 you going to do, then when you're in the moment, that's when you're going to be
9:50 the most vulnerable. So I think mostly, it's it's about preparing your your mentality, preparing your
9:55 thoughts, and saying, okay. Here's how I handle it. And by the way, here are the
9:59 reasons why it might be a target. I don't think a lot of people who are
10:02 outside of government, outside of holding a security clearance, really think of themselves as being as
10:07 being valuable.
10:08 Interesting.
10:09 But, obviously, they obviously, they are, and it's not for... Always for the for the reasons
10:14 that they think they would be.
10:16 Peter, we have about a minute left. I I am very curious as we talk about
10:18 somebody who was involved in AI, about the role that AI is playing in this kind
10:22 of spy craft. How is it changing the game for an organization like the MSS?
10:28 The Ministry of State Security is also one of the, I think, the only strategic civilian
10:33 signals intelligence services worldwide. They're mostly a military organ... Mostly military organizations like the NSA. And
10:39 the MSS is incredibly active with computer network exploitation. So AI, facilitates tool development. It facilitates
10:46 processing. They... It's been reported now for years that they have pretty robust relationships with the
10:52 cloud computing companies in in China and that they leverage those commercial resources to support them.
10:59 It allows them to process, you know, those huge reams of data that we've seen, like
11:03 the hack on United, Anthem Health, on Marriott, on the office of personnel management, and to
11:09 be able to combine all of these things and then use that technical knowledge and the
11:13 insights and leads gained to tip-off human operations. Yeah. Right? The the MSS focuses a lot
11:19 on the human element. Right? Hence, the emphasis on political action, on political influence, on facilitating,
11:26 you know, through human relationships, transfer of technology.
11:29 Okay.
11:29 So, you know, it supercharges what they can do and sharpens sharpens their teams.
11:34 Alright. Peter Mattis, thank you so much. Thank you for your insight. I promise to run
11:38 all future relationship approaches through you so you can make sure that they're on the up
11:42 and up. We appreciate your time.
The Stadium Bidding War Shaking Up the Midwest full transcript
0:00 Westin: This is a story about thinking with your heart.
0:03 Pretty much every city in the U.S.
0:05 would love to be home to an NFL team.
0:07 And there's plenty to tug at the heartstrings of fans
0:10 and politicians,
0:11 especially if we're talking about the Chicago Bears,
0:15 the seventh most valuable team in the league
0:17 and one of the original NFL franchises
0:20 dating back to 1920.
0:30 -When you talk to Chicago Bears fans,
0:32 one thing that they are very, very positive about
0:35 is that they want to make sure
0:36 that their hometown team stays here.
0:39 -So for the Bears, why not Indiana?
0:42 Why not Hammond?
0:44 It's 20 minutes from downtown Chicago.
0:46 -It's different, first of all,
0:47 because there's an emotional content to it
0:50 as well as a business content.
0:51 Of course, I'm rooting for Indiana.
0:53 Westin: The Bears lease at Soldier Field
0:55 ends in 2033,
0:57 and there are 3 major contenders for its next home.
1:00 One, a new stadium on the current site
1:03 in downtown Chicago,
1:04 one in the suburb of Arlington Heights,
1:07 and one across the border in Hammond, Indiana.
1:10 It's not just the emotional tug
1:12 that's in play.
1:13 It's also claims, hopes and even promises
1:16 of revenue
1:17 fom the stadium itself
1:19 and from surrounding commercial development
1:21 and the taxes it could bring,
1:22 along with an up to $5 billion all in price tag.
1:26 -When you look at stadium economics,
1:28 the question can't just be how much money
1:30 is going to be spent here.
1:31 I think the money, the conversation
1:33 has to be incremental.
1:34 How much of this money would not be spent in Illinois
1:36 if this stadium was not here?
1:38 And we have to have an honest conversation
1:39 about that.
1:41 Westin: State Representative Kam Buckner
1:42 represents Chicago's 26th District,
1:45 where he hopes the Bears will remain
1:47 and build a new enclosed arena.
1:49 If a person spends 100 bucks at Soldier Field on a Sunday,
1:53 well models also tell us that they're going to...
1:55 that if they didn't go to that football game,
1:56 they would spend that same amount of money
1:58 at a restaurant in Chicago's South Loop neighborhood
2:01 next week, right?
2:02 Is that money fungible? Is it transferable?
2:04 Those are real questions we have to have.
2:06 -The opportunity that we're facing right now
2:08 is just tremendous.
2:09 Westin: Tom McDermott is the mayor of Hammond,
2:11 Indiana.
2:13 - Hammond gets a brand new city.
2:15 First off, it took a lot of foresight
2:16 to get here.
2:17 We put together all that acreage.
2:19 I've been mayor 23 years now,
2:21 and it took us well over a decade
2:23 to assemble all the land that we're talking about right now.
2:26 And we had no idea the Chicago Bears
2:27 were going to be interested one day.
2:29 We were doing it just to clean up our city
2:31 and to give us better access to the Wolf Lake area.
2:33 And along comes the Chicago Bears.
2:36 It's an incredible story.
2:38 We're going to get the things that Chicago has
2:40 and Chicago takes for granted. And it's going to be new.
2:43 Westin: After serving as President George W. Bush's
2:45 budget director,
2:47 Mitch Daniels returned to Indiana
2:48 to become its governor
2:50 and presided over the building
2:51 of the Colts' new Lucas Oil Stadium
2:54 in downtown Indianapolis.
2:55 -I think you really have to zoom in on hard
3:00 and press on the...
3:01 on the projections of the new activity
3:05 that will be generated.
3:06 Now, as I said, in the Indianapolis context,
3:08 very wisely,
3:10 this was all part of a convention center,
3:13 an expanded convention capability,
3:15 you could forecast and as a matter of fact,
3:18 they have beaten the forecast
3:20 for how many, you know,
3:21 new visitors would come and so forth.
3:23 And I frequently pointed out to people,
3:27 more than 90% of the events in that building
3:30 would not be football games.
3:32 So there were other revenue sources.
3:34 And where that's the case,
3:35 I think the argument for the public stepping in
3:38 can be rationalized on a business case basis.
3:42 But there are many other stadia I've seen built
3:46 where it didn't look to me
3:48 as though that sort of business judgment
3:50 had been brought to bear.
3:51 Westin: You don't have to look too far
3:52 to find stadiums built without the business judgment
3:55 Daniels is talking about.
3:57 For every successful project like SoFi Stadium,
4:00 in Los Angeles,
4:01 there's at least one Edward Jones in St. Louis,
4:04 which ended up suing the Rams' owner
4:06 after the team moved back to Los Angeles
4:08 and it left the city and state
4:10 with large bond payments they couldn't recoup.
4:13 How is a stadium like another big business deal?
4:17 And how is it different?
4:18 -It's different.
4:20 First of all, because the...
4:23 there's an emotional content to it,
4:25 as well as business content.
4:26 And I think that has to be factored in
4:28 by the decision makers.
4:29 But the primary reason it's different
4:31 is because too often politicians are making the decision.
4:34 And nothing more dangerous than turning a politician loose
4:37 with a public checkbook in a situation like this.
4:41 Incentives, of course, are to do whatever it takes,
4:44 cut the ribbon, bask in the glory,
4:47 and then pass the bill on to somebody,
4:49 2 or 3 down the line.
4:50 The public should be very, very guarded
4:53 about this.
4:55 To me, there are certain rules, no cash,
4:57 and that's sometimes...
4:58 sometimes politicians have forked over cash.
5:00 I just think that's unconscionable.
5:02 If you want to help with the financing,
5:04 where the prospect is very strong
5:06 that it'll get paid back through taxes
5:10 and new economic activity,
5:12 then... then maybe.
5:15 The cost has escalated, you know,
5:17 beyond anything that we saw.
5:19 -There are a lot of folks who walk up on the street
5:21 or who will text and tweet and say,
5:23 "Just give them what they want.
5:24 "Give them what they want,
5:25 "because we don't want them to leave."
5:26 To us, we believe that there is a balance here
5:29 that we can be smart
5:31 and fiscally responsible to the people we represent,
5:34 but also put together a package
5:36 that works for this organization to keep the football club here.
5:39 But here's the rub.
5:40 That same kind of preponderance of people
5:42 who say that we want the Bears to remain in Illinois
5:45 also say, "But we don't want to pay for it."
5:47 So that is the delicate balance that you find
5:49 when you deal with sports and economics.
5:51 And the question now is about creating
5:53 the economic value to one, keep the team here,
5:56 but also to make sure that we're not putting
5:57 the taxpayers on the hook.
5:58 An economic development should be competitive,
6:02 but it should not be desperate.
6:03 Westin: Making a sound decision on the Bears new stadium home
6:06 is all the more difficult
6:07 because there's something of an auction going on
6:10 with 3 top bidders in the race.
6:13 I'm not aware that there was an auction
6:15 involved in Indianapolis and Lucas Oil Stadium.
6:18 I once worked for a really good CEO
6:20 who said he'd never won an auction
6:22 and never would because the last 10% is ego.
6:25 How do you avoid that?
6:26 -It's especially, I think, risky in this case
6:29 because there is this emotional component.
6:32 I've seen this show a few times, not in the sports context,
6:36 but we had many occasions when I was in public life
6:39 in which a business was dissatisfied in Illinois
6:43 and the environment was very different over here.
6:45 Some of them, many of them came across the line.
6:47 Others auctioned themselves off and leveraged the lower taxes,
6:52 the better regulatory environment,
6:55 the better infrastructure and so forth, in Indiana,
6:58 to get a deal out of the government of Illinois.
7:01 -The projections are done mostly by the state,
7:03 the ones financing this,
7:04 but the implementation of the taxes
7:06 are going to be up to people like myself.
7:08 Here in Hammond, we're going to be expected
7:09 to pass the admissions tax,
7:11 12% on every ticket sold,
7:13 and that has to be implemented by me as mayor
7:16 and the Hammond City Council.
7:17 Locally here in Lake County,
7:19 there has to be a food and beverage tax passed,
7:21 1% that's going to pay for the debt on this.
7:24 And for hotel stays,
7:26 the rate's going to go from 5% to 10%
7:28 on the innkeeper's tax to help finance this debt.
7:31 Westin: My understanding, Mayor,
7:32 is that the proceeds of those taxes
7:34 will go to pay off the bonds,
7:35 to basically pay the money due on the bonds.
7:38 What happens if there's a shortfall?
7:39 Who's left holding the bag?
7:41 -It would be the state of Indiana
7:42 if there was a shortfall.
7:44 They're financing this project.
7:45 And let's be honest,
7:47 Hammond had to partner with the state.
7:48 And when I say partner,
7:50 we're expected to basically hand over
7:53 the entire acreage
7:55 that we're talking about under state control.
7:57 There's going to be an authority put together,
7:59 a 3-member board.
8:00 Hammond will have one appointment to that board,
8:02 but two-thirds of that board is going to be run
8:03 by the state of Indiana
8:05 because they're putting the money forward
8:06 and they expect to get paid back.
8:08 And I would complain if I thought Hammond
8:11 was being treated any differently
8:12 than Indianapolis was
8:13 when they brought the Colts to town.
8:15 But this is the exact model that they used
8:17 to help bring, you know,
8:18 to help build Lucas Oil Stadium in Indianapolis.
8:21 So it's consistent.
8:22 Westin: For their part,
8:24 the contenders for the new stadium
8:25 think they can strike the right balance
8:27 between giving the Bears a good deal
8:29 and getting their money's worth.
8:31 -It's not our job to say,
8:33 "You need to go to Arlington Heights"
8:34 or "You need to stay in Chicago" or "You need to go to Evanston"
8:36 or any type of town or municipality
8:38 here in the state.
8:39 Our job is to lay forth an entree of options
8:42 here in the state of Illinois
8:44 to give the Bears the runway they need
8:46 to make the right fiduciary responsibility
8:49 for their organization.
8:50 Westin: When you look at the Chicago Bears stadium
8:53 and the pluses and minuses,
8:55 or really the costs and the revenues.
8:57 It's one thing to have to write a check.
9:00 It can look at least different
9:01 if you're making tax concessions.
9:03 How do you make sure that you really fully evaluate
9:06 the tax concessions,
9:07 because in a sense giving a tax concession
9:09 is writing a check.
9:10 -In many ways. So I think when you...
9:11 These are all numbers that you got to calculate.
9:13 But the number that you have to start with
9:14 for me is zero,
9:16 and zero is what happens if nothing happens.
9:19 What does it look like if we do nothing.
9:22 Westin: This is obviously Hammond versus Chicago
9:25 versus Arlington Heights.
9:28 It's also Indiana against Illinois.
9:31 So as you stack up that competition
9:34 what gives Indiana the advantage.
9:36 -The Bears will make far more money
9:38 by coming to Hammond Indiana than anywhere else in Illinois.
9:42 No doubt about it.
9:43 And so I've been asked the question,
9:44 "Well, mayor, what if... what if Illinois offers
9:47 "the Bears $1.5 billion, like Indiana is?"
9:50 And I said, OK, well that'd be great,
9:52 in year zero.
9:53 However in year 1 through 35
9:55 the Bears are going to lose money
9:56 every single year if they stay in Illinois
9:58 versus coming to Indiana
10:00 where you have property tax certainty
10:02 to the effect that we have our property taxes
10:04 enshrined in our Constitution.
10:05 Westin: A crucial point.
10:07 The Arlington plan's property tax relief
10:09 is long-term but not permanent.
10:12 A crucial detail for a stadium that will stand for decades.
10:16 When we talk about building an entire environment around,
10:19 what's going to be in that in your vision?
10:22 If you succeed in doing that, what's going to occupy that?
10:25 -The amenities that Chicago has,
10:27 I would love to see things like that up,
10:29 and up in my city, like a Ruth's Chris Steak House.
10:32 If I went to Ruth's Chris right now and said,
10:34 "I'd like you to open a location in Hammond"
10:36 they'd be nice about it, I'm sure,
10:37 but they'd say, "You know, Mayor,
10:39 "we're looking elsewhere."
10:40 But if we close a deal like this with the Chicago Bears
10:43 to get a Ruth's Chris is not such a stretch anymore.
10:48 Westin: The Bears choice of a new home
10:50 will have large repercussions for everyone concerned:
10:53 the franchise, the fans, the political officials,
10:57 the taxpayers
10:58 and two neighboring states.
11:00 Everyone involved says
11:01 they have to make the right decision,
11:04 but finding the balance of the heart and the mind
11:07 will not be easy.
11:09 -Of course I'm rooting for Indiana.
11:10 But with the proviso that I don't want us
11:14 to make a dumb deal to do it.
11:17 And I think the elements are there
11:20 and that there may well be, as I say,
11:23 a business case that makes this
11:25 a reasonable investment for the state.
11:28 So that that'd be the outcome I'm rooting for.
11:31 But as in all such matters
11:33 and first rule of life up to a point.
Looking Beyond Tech’s Recent Market Turmoil full transcript
0:00 With us now, Barry Ritholtz. He is founder and chief investment officer of Ritholtz Wealth Management
0:04 and, of course, host of the masters in business podcast on Bloomberg Radio and all your
0:09 various Bloomberg platforms. Barry, I wanna ask the you question people have been asking me, and
0:14 once again, I want to say no one should ever ask me for financial advice.
0:17 God, no. Everyone
0:22 is very concerned right now about their tech investments. What should they do?
0:28 Well, you look at the data points that give you some insight as to what's the
0:33 most likely path of markets going forward. We never know, but we try and make the
0:39 best probabilistic assessments we can. You know, for all the..., for all the the volatility we
0:48 saw over the past couple of weeks, S and P five hundred is 3.3% off of
0:54 its all time highs. That tells me this is a broad market, not, you know, we've
0:59 we've heard from the concentration bears for, I don't know, five years. Mhmm. And so far,
1:04 maybe one day they'll be right, but so far they're not. You you see the Nasdaq
1:09 is off, what, 10% from its highs. And what looks like a very, very specific, focus
1:19 on one company, you know, more or less turns out to be just one company. It's
1:25 not the entire market. When we look at what happens with major, especially technology firms, when
1:32 the CEO steps down, yeah, there's a temporary drop and then markets recover. Think about companies
1:39 like Apple or Alibaba or or go down the list of of companies where where major
1:48 CEOs have left. The the one exception has been when Steve Ballmer stepped down from Microsoft,
1:55 the market rally, because it turned out he wasn't a particularly good CEO. So so you
2:02 have those data points, and then, you know, here's a crazy data point that people fact
2:07 check me when I say this. Since 1950 Mhmm. Every time there is a midterm election,
2:15 markets are higher by the following June and and higher by an average of about 15%.
2:22 Wow. It runs from about two and a half percent to 29%. But, hey, 19 for
2:27 '19, that's a crazy number that... I I don't wanna take the other side of that
2:32 bet.
2:33 Christina putting that into ask me right now just
2:35 to clarify. Was
2:36 Shush. Double check. Absolutely double check my math.
2:40 Was backing you up because I remembered I remembered Amin Agatti when she was on our
2:44 show saying a similar thing. But, yes, year after midterms, the markets are usually high.
2:50 Barry, I really want... Go ahead. Go ahead.
2:52 I was gonna say, I don't trust any, AI data. So anytime I have a data
2:59 point like that, I'll go to Claude. I'll go to ask b. I'll go to chat.
3:03 And when three of them say, yes, that data is accurate, alright. I can rely on
3:08 a little bit.
3:08 Trust but bear
3:09 with me. Appreciate that skepticism.
3:11 You have the opportunity on your podcast to sit down with so many great investors and
3:15 observers of of corporate America and and global Wall Street. And what I'm really wondering about
3:20 here is the corporate governance aspect of of this story, that this company existed such as
3:24 it did for so long with a very weak board No chairman. Without a chairman. How
3:29 do you think about the the lessons we can learn from from this as applied to
3:33 other businesses? As you're looking at companies into which you might invest, do you think about
3:37 what needs to be satisfied in terms of corporate governance?
3:40 Yeah. There's an issue that, took place over the past twenty years where founders have been
3:46 given, special dispensation. Sometimes it's supervoting shares. So you look over at Meta, and, you know,
3:55 there have been a number of missteps, and there's nothing the board can do. Other times,
4:02 you see just a charismatic either founder or the person who is responsible for so much
4:09 of the company's growth, and the board is just very, different... Deferential to that person. It's
4:17 potentially problematic. What was interesting was watching the betting on after the first revelation about an
4:27 affair with a spy, he was barely over 50% whether he'll lose his job. And I
4:34 think when the second and then the third revelation came out, it wasn't, oh, this was
4:39 a one time mistake. This is just a pattern of poor judgment and recklessness. We... We've...
4:46 I I am kinda plugged into a lot of different trading desks and hear all the
4:51 jokes, and my favorite response was, wow. Imagine how much better NVIDIA would have done if
4:57 if Jensen actually had time to focus on the company instead of running around like a
5:01 lothario all over the place. But the the big takeaway is, companies survive the loss of
5:08 a founder. They survive a loss of a CEO. The cemeteries are filled with irreplaceable men,
5:15 and that's just... That was true in World War two, and it's true now.
5:18 He's quoting Lloyd Blankfein there on Twitter. I saw him tweeting that this week. Also, Barry,
5:22 you said that
5:22 it not from Lloyd
5:23 Well, I saw him using the quote. Of course. It's not... Of course. Of course. But
5:26 you noted betting on... No betting on Cal Shi. Just event contracts, Barry. There's no betting
5:31 that takes place on Cal Shi.
5:32 It's all gambling, and anybody who says otherwise is selling something.
5:35 I feel like this segment has gone rapidly off the rails. I do wanna ask... Speaking
5:40 of going rapidly off the rails, if you are on a board, if you are an
5:43 investor, if you are watching your CEO engage in dangerous, unethical, concerning behavior, as I'm assuming
5:51 people... You know, there are photos of these women. The... People had to know this was
5:54 going on. At what point do boards, do investors start having to demand? Will they demand
6:01 better behavior from CEOs because it could impact their bottom line? Or as long as stocks
6:06 are high, do you see them looking the other way?
6:09 So you... That's a really, not a finance question, but a human behavior and psychology question.
6:15 Look. When you have a charismatic, CEO who's sitting on top of 700000% in gains, guess
6:24 what? You're you're not gonna get that sort of, oversight that you want because nobody wants
6:32 to kill the goose that laid the golden egg.
6:34 Yeah.
6:34 On the other hand, there is something about, public market structures that lend themselves to a
6:42 poor set of governance. You know, you you mentioned the podcast this weekend. I have Saleem
6:47 Ramji, the
6:48 Vanguard.
6:48 CEO of of Vanguard. Yep. And what's fascinating is all of his predecessors, but the immediate
6:55 one before him served, you know, decade long
7:00 terms as CEOs. The the CEO before him wasn't quite working out, and eighteen months later
7:06 he got replaced. Vanguard is not a publicly traded company. It's more like a mutual. And
7:12 so it raises the question, when the stock price is up, boards tend to look the
7:18 other way, and and it's just
7:19 a problem. Barry, great to speak with you. Barry, an expert on investing and human behavior.
7:23 I think we can say Barry Ritholtz, the host of Masters in Business on Bloomberg Radio,
7:27 available as a podcast as well at Bloomberg.
7:29 Thank you, Barry. I I can sense your sympathy for what I'm dealing with here today.
7:33 Alright.
SpaceX Pushes Starship Reusability to New Test full transcript
0:00 And now that SpaceX launch Friday night in South Texas, the company's most ambitious test yet
0:04 off to a somewhat rocky start after the booster exploded over the water.
0:09 Alright. Now the focus turns the attempt later today to catch the rocket itself for the
0:13 first time. Joining us now is Ross Hamilton. He's the cofounder of Space Network. Ross, everyone
0:18 here has been calling me the space grinch.
0:20 Well, skeptic.
0:22 So why is this different? Why is this cool? Why should I be excited about this?
0:28 Good morning. Good to see you again. I think there's a couple of things that are
0:31 quite historic about this launch, and there's two parts to it. The first part is the
0:36 the booster itself, which we saw had a unfortunate incident. It's one of the heaviest, biggest
0:42 rockets ever. But the Starship that's sitting on top of it really represents where the company
0:48 is going with reusability. And what's about to happen, hopefully, afternoon is that they're gonna catch
0:54 that Starship in in in the Mechazilla, and that's gonna represent real progress with not just,
1:02 recycling and reusing these rockets, but really increasing the the rate at which, Elon Musk is
1:08 gonna be putting stuff into space. All of that has a lot of implications for the
1:13 broader space industry.
1:14 Let's talk a bit about those implications. We can maybe put aside the moon and Mars
1:18 here for for a moment. But in the nearer term, what is SpaceX trying to do
1:21 with the more regular use of the spacecraft?
1:24 Yeah. So there's... There really are a couple of things there. One is this... The the
1:27 actual amount of capacity and the frequency that they're putting in rockets up is gonna allow
1:32 them to deploy their new, Starlink constellation. That's gonna change the game in terms of connectivity
1:38 with Earth. It's going to drive and be driven by their own AI, ambitions in terms
1:46 of manufacturing chips and really becoming, you know, maybe second to NVIDIA in terms of where
1:52 they sit on AI. It's also going to mean that orbital data centers, people have talked
1:57 about, are gonna start becoming, more of a reality as we're able to get that equipment
2:02 up into space. And there are a few other things that are tied to this. I
2:06 know it's not... You know, we don't talk about the moon and Mars, but it's going
2:10 to start showing us what this Starship can really do when it wants to leave, you
2:15 know, Earth's orbit, you know, refueling, other Starships and really giving NASA a capacity of... Get
2:22 to the moon.
2:22 Ross, quickly before you let go, when we talk about SpaceX, we talk about the parts
2:26 of the company that are profitable, like Starlink and the parts of the company that are
2:29 not. Is this part of the company profitable? Will it be in the near term?
2:33 The launch part?
2:35 The space part in general. Are they making money off of these massive rocket ships?
2:39 Yeah. I mean, I don't think the the rocket ships themselves are not making money, but
2:43 I think over time is to bring down the cost and to find more customers. I
2:47 think that could become profitable, But I think the real growth is gonna be around the
2:51 AI, the chips, and the Starlink connectivity.
2:54 Ross Hamilton, thank you very much. The cofounder of the space, network joining us here as
2:57 we wait for the return of that second part of the spacecraft, later today.
3:01 I think
3:02 I believe in this afternoon, and it will be something to behold. Maybe we'll get you
3:05 to watch it. Actually, clips after.
3:07 I am as likely to watch that as I am the many Knicks games you guys
3:10 try
3:10 to tell me to watch. Wow. The gauntlet has been thrown. I'm speechless. I'm rendered speechless
3:16 as a result.
Bessent, Lutnick Clash Over Nvidia China Curbs full transcript
0:00 Joining us now is Axios AI reporter Maria Curi. Maria, you have a couple articles this
0:05 week about the tensions among the cabinet and and in the Oval Office at times. At
0:10 one point, you say Bessent asked Letnick point blank, why isn't Mega Speed? Of course, that's,
0:16 Alice Wong's company. Why wasn't it on the list? What was the response, and why has
0:22 Lutnick been, it seems based on your reporting, reticent to list this company?
0:27 Right. So secretary Lutnick in that moment says, you know, I'll look into it, and he
0:31 stumbles into that response, I think, in a sign for other high level administration officials in
0:37 that moment that the secretary didn't necessarily have the best handle on a company that was
0:42 at the center of, you know, potential, Chinese espionage through one of the most important, American
0:49 CEOs. And so what we just heard there from, treasury secretary Scott Bessent is essentially confirmation
0:55 of our reporting that throughout the course of the year, you have various senior level administration
1:02 officials that for months have had this intelligence that Jensen Huang had this affair with Alice
1:08 Huang, a suspected Chinese spy, and that this company that she is an executive at should
1:14 be placed on this, you know, thing called an entity list, which would essentially, mean that
1:19 you cannot export sensitive technologies to, this company because of suspicions that they are being rerouted
1:27 illegally to China. Of course, the commerce department and BIS, the agency within the commerce department
1:33 that is headed by undersecretary Jeff Kessler, they're in charge of creating this list of making
1:38 sure that, the companies that need to be on this list are on there, and that
1:42 has not happened all year.
1:43 Maria, I wanna ask you about the relationship between secretary Ludlow Huang. I remember it was
1:48 now about a year ago. I was in Washington for the big NVIDIA confab that that
1:52 took place there. I was catching up with our colleague Ed Ludlow and on the sidelines
1:55 of that, and it was a it was a huge event. And part of that was
1:58 this onstage conversation between the secretary of commerce, and the now former CEO of of NVIDIA.
2:02 Let's take a listen to what Jensen Huang had to say then. Howard is the person
2:06 I talk to most, in the administration, and, he's on top of the technology. He's learning
2:12 about the industry quickly. And I announced a historic partnership today, and he was the first
2:17 to know about it. We were talking about sort of how different cabinet officials are positioned
2:21 here. How how about this relationship? How integral was it? How did it become... How did
2:26 these two become so tight? What what do we know about the relationship between Ludlow Wong?
2:31 Well, what we do know is that NVIDIA and Jensen Huang has been lobbying the Trump
2:35 administration writ large very hard for a while now to ensure that the policies that, the
2:42 company wants are in place and that the Chinese market is open to NVIDIA. Right? So
2:47 irrespective of this affair with Alice Huang, Jensen Huang for a while has wanted h 200
2:55 chips, you know, not their most advanced chips, but still powerful technology going to China. The
3:01 argument being that it would make This US this US adversary reliant on The US. And
3:06 so that was the pitch to the Trump administration. And the most important person to convince
3:12 of that argument, number one, was president Trump, and number two was commerce secretary Howard Lutnick
3:17 because he does oversee the department that influences that policy. And so you hear there, you
3:22 know, Jensen Huang saying he is the person that I speak the most to, Howard Lutnick,
3:27 but then you also have Jensen Huang calling president Trump directly on a stage and president
3:32 Trump answering the phone call. I think that he had very close relationships with exactly the
3:37 people that he needed to have in order to influence policy. And it's important to remember
3:41 here that, yes, commerce secretary Howard Lutnick is an... Is a person in charge of this
3:46 department, but the ultimate decider is president Trump.
3:49 I'm wondering if we have any insight into why Lutnick seems to still be married to
3:54 this policy, why he seems to be the lone holdout. I mean, it's important to say
3:58 the commerce secretary denies, some of this confrontation reporting and saying it's false. But you write
4:03 that Trump called tech adviser Elon Musk, this is in the oval, and agreed to move
4:07 forward with with limits on on Mega Speed. Musk supporter, Rubio, Bessent, Greer, and Hager, were
4:13 pro imposing controls, and let Nick seem to slow walk this and not be willing to
4:20 take immediate action. Do we have any idea what stake he has in this or why
4:23 he would be married to this policy?
4:25 Well, we know that one of the things he brought up in one of these meetings
4:28 was the trade war with China and wanting to continue to have, you know, good relations
4:35 with China ahead of, you know, potentially another trip this month. But, you know, in terms
4:40 of the commerce department denying this reporting, we did hear directly from treasury secretary Scott Bessent
4:46 confirming, that this disagreement has existed, that you have a wide range of administration officials wanting
4:53 to take action against mega speed and the commerce department kind of being the lone holdout.
4:57 There has been more reporting as well that the commerce department is also taking its instruction
5:02 and its lead from president Trump. And so I think, you know, stepping back a little
5:06 bit here, you are potentially also seeing who is going to be, the person that is
5:11 held the most accountable for these revelations, especially as scrutiny on the hill heats up. Right
5:17 now, all of the focus is on Jensen Huang and on commerce secretary Howard Lutnick and
5:22 even to a certain extent undersecretary Jeff Kessler. But come next year when Democrats take control
5:28 of both chamber... Chambers, we do expect that scrutiny to also ramp up on the president
5:32 himself.
5:33 Maria, I wanna put a fine point on something here. So you have the treasury secretary
5:36 confirming your reporting, a great good thing for for you, of course. But maybe you can
5:40 just underline how important or how seismic that was. His coming out and saying this explicitly
5:45 is we followed for so many years now the kind of internal politics between these two
5:49 individuals. Of course, they were jockeying for the job that secretary Bessent ultimately got.
5:54 I think it really illustrates the internal strife that we are seeing in the Trump administration
5:59 as well around a really key policy. I mean, at the end of the day, I...
6:04 It shows how, different administration officials have had different, goals, and it ultimately has been potentially
6:12 at the expense of US national security. And so this intelligence has existed since at least
6:18 May when, state secretary Marco Rubio oversaw the drafting of this memo and shared it with
6:24 high level administration officials and personally handed it to president Trump himself on Air Force One.
6:30 And so why no action has been taken has been taken since then? I'm not sure.
6:35 You know, the commerce department is worth noting has begun a process of stopping a remote
6:40 access, which also is important, to preventing, these sensitive technologies from reaching China. But more has
6:48 to be done.
6:49 Alright. Maria Curi from Axios, thank you so
6:51 much
6:51 for joining us. We appreciate it.
Nvidia Looks for a New Era After Huang full transcript
0:00 Video shares finished lower on Friday after a very chaotic week that, as we've been talking
0:04 about, saw its founder and longtime CEO, Huang, resign after reports of several extramarital affairs, including
0:10 one with a suspected Chinese spy. NVIDIA dropped another 2%, adding to the recent nosedive that's
0:16 brought the market cap below $4,000,000,000,000 far behind Apple as the world's most valuable company.
0:21 While an interim CEO has been named, the company says its search for a permanent replacement
0:25 will include both internal and external candidates. Bloomberg's Emily Chang sat down with Huang just one
0:31 month ago before this news broke, and she asked him during that interview about the pressures
0:36 of leading one of the world's most valuable companies and who might one day succeed him.
0:41 I'm responsible for an entire industry. And so I think the the pressure of being the
0:47 CEO is high, and it's supposed to be high. It shouldn't be an... It should not
0:52 be an easy job. It shouldn't be a job that you take for granted. When I
0:56 decided to be CEO, you know, I didn't didn't realize the the the magnitude of the
1:00 pressure and and responsibilities, but, you know, look, that's what I that's what I signed up
1:05 for. And so now now that my family and all of the people that are near
1:10 me see see the the the responsibility of this job and what it takes, then they
1:17 they just gotta ask themselves, you know, whether this is the level of sacrifice and responsibility
1:21 you want. And I'm really hoping that the next CEO of the company is already at
1:25 the company. But but twenty years from now, I hope I stay healthy, and and I
1:30 hope I I continue to earn my my keep. But so long as I I can
1:35 do that twenty years from now, I hope I hope they're already here and... But they
1:39 have to earn it.
1:41 Twenty years from now. Emily joins us now from San Francisco. Emily, just wild to watch
1:45 that taped just a few weeks ago. I imagine it's even more wild for you to
1:48 have watched it. In light of all that... That's happened here, how are you thinking through
1:53 what he was saying then and what's happened since... How are you processing these developments in
1:57 yours... Yourself? Again, you were traveling with him on this big trip trip through Europe. And
2:01 as as you've written, he was kind of at the prime of his powers. It was
2:03 a a kind of a victory tour for him. Gensanity at its utmost, over the continent
2:09 of Europe.
2:10 That is what we saw. We went with him to four countries in four days, and,
2:14 obviously, this isn't how we expected the story to pan pan out, but we realize now
2:18 that we got the last wide ranging sit down with him as CEO. And we went
2:24 into it knowing that this is a company that didn't have a clear successor, never disclosed
2:29 publicly a succession plan. There has been speculation. His his daughter works at the company. His
2:35 son works at the company. His son-in-law works at the company. And so I asked who
2:39 might be next because investors, you know, have said over time, how can a... At that
2:44 time, $5,000,000,000,000 company
2:46 Mhmm.
2:46 Not have a designated successor? And his family is so intertwined in the company that's that's
2:51 another question here. But he basically paid himself so indispensable in terms of the way he
2:56 ran the company with this flat management structure structure and 60 direct reports that there was
3:02 no second person in line, and he obviously had the expectation that he was gonna be
3:07 there for a couple more decades.
3:10 I mean, do you think that was strategic on his part? You you see this with
3:13 Musk and some of these other tech leaders who are verging on, you know, icon status
3:18 if you ask them, that they don't really want to designate a successor because in a
3:23 way that diminishes their influence and their power at the center of these little universes.
3:28 Quite possibly. I mean, he obviously, you know, cares deeply about this company having run it
3:34 for thirty three years and and grown it into this behemoth. And like you mentioned, David,
3:40 we saw him at sort of peak Gensanity where there were developers and fans out the
3:45 door and around the block waiting to see him, everyone wanting to get a picture with
3:49 him. You realize he's not just the guy at the center of the AI boom and
3:52 NVIDIA's chief salesman, chief salesman, but he is also sort of the chief diplomat. He was
3:58 meeting and glad handing with world leaders and tech CEOs. And in each of these countries,
4:03 I realized how deeply intertwined is he is in in... Not just NVIDIA's relationships with companies,
4:11 like big AI companies, but with countries and with governments. You know? He met with French
4:16 president Emmanuel Macron. He met with the prime minister of The UK while while we were
4:21 there. And you have to wonder if those relationships are going to be compromised in the
4:26 next phase of this company.
4:28 Picking apart what he said there, that line about how he hopes the next CEO will
4:31 be at the company already. So Colette Kress elevated to this position on an interim basis.
4:36 What do you think about her longer term prospects? What do you think about the search
4:40 that is, I assume, already underway to find a a permanent CEO? And as you know
4:44 so well, all of these companies have kind of a unique culture to them. How important
4:48 is it that somebody who is elevated to CEO comes from within NVIDIA's ranks?
4:52 So, look, everything that I've heard about Colette Kress is that she is she's obviously a
4:57 very seasoned executive who knows the company inside and out. There was some, speculation that maybe
5:03 she would be named in in a sort of co CEO, structure with Ian Buck, who
5:10 is the the creator of CUDA and also a very powerful person at the company. I
5:15 think that NVIDIA probably wanted to give itself some flexibility in in in terms of, you
5:21 know, looking both inside and outside the company. And there are a lot of governance issues
5:26 that they're going to have to deal with, as they figure this process out. There have
5:31 been an, you know, a number of outside names floated. Rene Haas, the Feet, just reported
5:35 that, someone reached out to him. He obviously worked at NVIDIA previously. He knows the chip
5:40 fit business very well. Lisa Sue, the CEO of AMD, her name has been floated, but
5:44 she's running a very successful company as anyone busy. And anyone who comes into this situation
5:50 is gonna have to deal with a lot of of governments ish... Governance issues with government
5:56 investigations, with this whole China issue. And, you know, on the on the on the China
6:02 part of it, you know, obviously, you know, Jensen, we we we talked about when when
6:08 we were in Europe, he... And he sort of reiterated its stance that The US should
6:11 be selling its most advanced chips to China because otherwise, China will develop its own domestic
6:15 capabilities, and that will put The United States in a bad competitive position. My understanding is
6:20 that Colette Kress felt the same way. Right? And so if there are national security implications
6:26 here, that's a much bigger issue. And lawmakers are gonna wanna know what everyone knew at
6:32 the company, not just Jensen Huang.
6:34 Well, that's... I was trying to explain to somebody who's not in this world at all
6:37 why this matters today. And they're saying, what is the big deal? What's going on? And
6:41 I said it's it's not just that he has a messy personal life. It's that part
6:46 of this messy personal life is with someone who might have been an agent of the
6:49 Chinese government, and this is the person who was the face of this issue on the
6:55 diplomatic front lobbying the White House, as you just mentioned, lobbying foreign governments. We have some
6:59 sound from your interview where you asked him about this issue.
7:02 I did my best to inform the policymakers of The United States of the importance of
7:10 engaging the Chinese market and making sure that we serve that market for as long as
7:16 we can. I think we made a made a mistake, and and this mistake is hard
7:22 to unwind. But I did my best. That's all I could do. There are more Chinese
7:28 AI researchers than any other nation in the world, and many of them working at the
7:35 labs. I've been very clear that even though... Although we compete against China, they're not our
7:42 enemies.
7:44 He was a very singular advocate for this policy. And I'm wondering even if Colette Kress,
7:50 even if whoever is designated his eventual successor feels the same way, will people listen in
7:55 the same
7:55 way? You know, I think, obviously, his credibility is undermined, and there are a lot of
8:02 questions about what people at the company knew. And you have to listen to those comments
8:06 there now and and look at it with a different lens. Because if he was being
8:11 influenced by a potential asset for the Chinese government over maybe several years, I mean, the
8:16 reporting is that he was first introduced to Alice Wong basically a decade ago, that's a
8:23 long time, for someone else to potentially shape your views. And so this is not just
8:29 an NVIDIA decision now. I mean, he's going to be testifying before congress next week. The
8:36 commerce secretary, Howard Letnick, is now under scrutiny, and lawmakers have made it very clear they're
8:42 not gonna let, this company off easy. I think there was some thought that that maybe
8:47 NVIDIA was trying to... You know, if if Jensen was out the door, that maybe that
8:51 would be the end of it. But I think we're hearing from government leaders that they
8:56 want they want more answers, and they wanna they wanna know who knew what when.
9:01 Emily, you've written a book about cultural sexual politics of of Silicon Valley, and it's hard
9:07 to put aside sort of what led to all of this. That is he had an
9:10 affair with a customer of NVIDIA at the very least and two relationships that we know
9:14 of reportedly with members of of his staff. What has the reaction been in Silicon Valley
9:21 more broadly here to to what's happened at NVIDIA over these last couple of weeks?
9:25 I would say group chats in Silicon Valley are having a moment of gensanity Uh-huh. Of
9:31 their I mean, they have exploded. And, of course, there are a lot of women in
9:36 these chats saying, not again. Gen... Even Jensen. Right? I mean, this is, like, a tale
9:43 that we have heard too many times in Silicon Valley with people that were icons and
9:49 deeply respected people that our children look up to. Right? And so, you know, I spoke
9:56 to a woman who who made a really great point that we're kind of complicit in
10:02 making a lot of these people feel like they are gods. And when you have so
10:07 much money and power, you do things... And no one ever says no to you. You
10:11 do things that can potentially be very, very bad. The other interesting thing, and I'm sure
10:17 you guys have seen this all on social media, is there are a lot of people
10:19 defending Jensen and saying we should give him another chance. And in a lot... In many
10:26 of these cases, I believe Jensen has made a lot of people a lot of money.
10:30 And so the people who are saying that aren't necessarily disclosing why they're saying that. And
10:37 so he does have... And and look. NVIDIA is an incredible company, an incredible organization. They
10:44 have the best AI chips on the market. You know? This... It's such a deep bench
10:50 of talent and such incredible technology, but you can't look past, you know, the head of
11:00 the company violating the company's own policy multiple times. And there is a a range of
11:08 reactions from fury to obviously support. But in this case, this is this is a man
11:15 in a company that made a lot of... That a lot of people have profited from.
11:20 And an interesting reaction from the man himself. Bloomberg has reported that, you know, you just
11:24 talked about Jensenity and the bravado, and we know the jackets and and a very confident
11:30 human. That is not how he reacted in in front of the board calling himself a
11:34 piece of expletive. Do we know... I mean, have you reached out to him? Do we
11:39 know what he's doing next? What can he do next?
11:42 I did reach out to him. I did not hear back. I I didn't necessarily expect
11:46 to. I... My guess is that he is is focusing on his family first because he's
11:55 hurt a lot of people. And as I said, his family was deeply intertwined with the
12:00 company as well. We know he's gonna be testifying before congress next week. Elon Musk has
12:05 said it would be an honor to hire him.
12:07 I saw that. Yes.
12:08 This is a this is a a guy who will be certainly sought after, if he
12:14 indeed fully moves on, but he's got a lot of things to worry about before taking
12:20 a new job.
12:21 Before we let you go, let me ask you where you think the locus of this
12:23 story is next. Does it remain in Silicon Valley with the focus on earnings and the
12:28 town hall next week? Does it shift to Shenzhen to this conference where the president's going
12:32 to be, meeting with his Chinese counterpart, or or is it Washington? What's gonna be the
12:37 geography of most importance here in the weeks ahead?
12:39 David, this story, it's all of those things. This story is... It's it's huge, and it's
12:45 it's only gotten bigger. You know? There's clearly going to be a continuing story in Washington
12:51 with what lawmakers have said about not wanting to give up on this. There's clearly a
12:55 huge story here in Silicon Valley where this this company is scrambling, and it's certainly... It's
13:00 gonna be a different company after Jensen. It it it it will survive, but the question
13:05 is, will it thrive in the same way? And, you know, overall, I think there's this
13:10 reckoning with the tech industry in general where the tech industry has lost a lot of
13:14 trust over the years, and this is just another example of that. And then you have
13:18 what's going on in China. There's this meeting between president Trump and president Xi. There's Malaysia
13:24 looking into chip exports and where some of these chips have been ending up. It's it's
13:30 it's an international event, and I think it's going to continue to keep unfolding.
13:36 Bloomberg's Emily Chang. I think call that kismet. She was on that trip with me just
13:40 a few weeks before all this happened, and the entire piece is incredible. You can watch
13:43 the Bloomberg and originals episode of the circuit with Emily Chang available now at bloomberg.com and
13:48 on YouTube. And as Emily mentioned just a moment ago, commerce secretary Howard Lutnick is facing
13:53 questions from
Trump Heads to China for Talks With Xi and Putin full transcript
0:00 It was a rough Friday night for a lot of air travelers, and it was a
0:03 a scramble for our reporters and colleagues over at the White House who had a late
0:06 night press conference with the transportation secretary and the secretary of the Department of Homeland Security.
0:11 Our own Jeff Mason, of course, was there. Jeff, you and I were texting. Again, this
0:16 is what we wanna spend our Friday night doing. But That's right. It was good to
0:19 hear. Always. Always. Unfortunately, if you and I spend a lot of our Friday nights texting
0:23 about the administration, but we're gonna put that aside.
0:25 So we've got great social life, you and I, Christine. It's awesome.
0:29 We are
0:29 so cool. Too. We always respond to each other's emails. I was just gonna say, who's
0:33 gonna tell David the people are reporting?
0:35 My god. Thank
0:36 you. Just an outlet. Wow.
0:38 I'm learning so much about
0:39 it I'm kidding. I'm kidding.
0:42 I... When this press conference started, the first thing, is secretary Mullins came up and said,
0:48 this is what the leadership of the Trump administration looks like. And I wrote that down
0:52 because I thought, well, for for better or worse, but we do have you asking a
0:58 question getting a response shortly thereafter. I'm gonna play it for you.
1:03 I think it underscores how important aviation is to our economy. We haven't done a calculation.
1:08 We've been... I got off an... I was on the airplane an airplane from Dallas when
1:11 this happened, hence, attire, and haven't gone to change. So I apologize for wearing a jacket
1:16 and jeans with you. There'll be time to do an economic analysis. But this is critical
1:22 for the American economy, which is why the congress... I'm gonna say it a million times.
1:27 The congress has to give the resources to the president so we can finish this bill.
1:32 So, Jeff, that was you asking secretary Duffy about the economic impact of this. And that
1:36 is a big issue having all the flights over The US shut down. How seriously is
1:40 the administration taking this?
1:42 Well, certainly very seriously. And the first part of the question that I asked him was
1:46 how did this actually manifest in the air, which they hadn't really explained. And and one
1:51 of the things that he said there was that there was a period where flights... Where
1:55 captains were not actually able to communicate with the air traffic control system. So it... Despite
2:03 the fact that both men spent a majority or a good chunk of that press conference
2:07 last night saying that there was no safety risk to the American public and to people
2:12 who were in the air, it's hard not to conclude that there was. Certainly, they they
2:17 emphasized that the reason that there wasn't is because they took the action that they did,
2:21 having that four hour plus ground stop. But it it certainly underscored the... What what they
2:28 portrayed as an old and creaky system turning into a a nightmare for communications between pilots
2:37 and air traffic controllers in... On an on an otherwise normal workday.
2:42 Wanna get to his entreaty, secretary Duffy's entreaty. This is an emergency, he said. I want
2:47 congress to give us emergency funding. This is bipartisan. This is American. I won $50,000,000,000, and
2:53 I have to note here the cost of the war in Iran right now, about $50,000,000,000.
2:58 With that nuance aside here, why has this been so difficult to modernize the system? We
3:03 were talking to George Ferguson, our colleague at Bloomberg Intelligence, just about the complications of kind
3:07 of wholesale taking an existing system, taking that out, and putting a new one in. You
3:11 have to kind of do it in this iterative way. But why is getting funding to
3:14 do this been such an issue even after that collision that we saw in Washington a
3:17 couple of years ago?
3:19 I think that's a a great question, David, and I appreciate the fact that you compared
3:23 that 50,000,000,000 number to the cost of the war in Iran because it underscores, again, the
3:28 fact that that's not just a it's not just a small ask on behalf of the
3:31 administration. Couple answers to that question. Number one, they did get $12,000,000,000 in what was called
3:38 the big beautiful bill, president Trump's key signature legislative victory of of the first term last
3:45 year. And and it's also important to note, and one of the... My reporter colleagues asked
3:51 about this last night, that Republicans control the the house and the senate as well as
3:56 the White House, of course, and have for the last two years. So it it... It's
4:01 not something as easy as blaming Democrats or blaming president Joe Biden for for not upgrading
4:09 a system, which the the... This president says previous presidents should have done. That's another argument
4:15 that he uses about the Iran war as well. Why otherwise? It's hard for me to
4:20 answer that other than to say asking for that big chunk of of change is tricky,
4:26 and it's tricky to get congress behind it. And, certainly, the secretary of transportation tried to
4:32 use a good crisis last night to encourage that that funding come their way.
4:37 Jeff, you have a a personal stake in this story as you are hopefully, allegedly heading
4:42 to Asia tonight for this Trump Xi bilat. I'm wondering... It now seems that Elon Musk
4:48 is traveling with them. I'm wondering if we knew if if Jensen Huang was ever planned
4:52 to be on this trip and how much of that discussion we expect to be about
4:56 what's happening with NVIDIA.
4:58 Yeah. It's a great question too. The the the president doesn't leave until Monday for Asia.
5:04 He's starting in The Philippines and then going to Shenzhen in China where he'll have that
5:09 meeting with president Xi. Also a trilateral with president Xi and president Putin, is something that
5:14 he's wanted to have for a long time to discuss denuclearization. But to your specific question,
5:20 we don't know if Jensen Huang was initially supposed to be part of this or not.
5:25 I think it's possible that he wasn't because I was on a conference call along with
5:29 another colleague of mine last night with White House officials talking about the trip. And one
5:35 of the questions that was posed was, is there a CEO delegation? And the answer was
5:39 no other than Elon Musk. There is a CEO forum that is happening in China that
5:45 is a separate invite, and and so there will be some CEOs who show up for
5:50 that. But it's not like last spring when the president was doing a state visit to
5:55 China and brought a whole bunch of CEOs with him, including Jensen.
5:59 Taking a
5:59 break
5:59 as he packs his luggage.
Couples Are Bringing AI Into Their Arguments full transcript
0:00 Fascinating story by our colleague Morgan Meaker. Caught my eye. I know it caught yours. Involving
0:05 the use of agentic AI in relationships.
0:09 Do you know after we did this chat with her, I've been asking everybody in my
0:12 life if they use it or not. Let's go to Morgan. You can... She can explain
0:15 for us.
0:17 Morgan, great to speak with you, and and you start your more recent piece here with
0:20 a reflection on an argument that you had with your husband and the way that he
0:24 reacted to it. He decides he doesn't wanna talk anymore, and he takes out chat GPT.
0:30 What what did you make of his impulse to do that, and how emblematic is that
0:34 of way kind of couples are interacting with one each... With each other and a third
0:37 a third party, I guess, we could say in this day and age?
0:40 Yeah. So I don't write about myself a lot, but this was kind of a personal
0:45 experience that I think was a way into lots of interesting things that are happening. So,
0:50 yeah, in... During this view, my husband pulled out his phone and wanted to start talking
0:56 to chat GPT instead of me. And, I mean, that was slightly unnerving, but what was
1:00 really unnerving is later when we're kind of talking about it, he described Chat GPT as
1:05 a warm hug, the interaction he had with the chatbot as a warm hug. And that
1:09 just gave me this really strong impression that suddenly, as I had walked out of the
1:15 room to give him space, kind of Chat GPT had walked in and kind of sat
1:19 beside him on my sofa and given him the kind of comfort that I obviously wasn't
1:23 giving him in that moment. And so that just made me think about if I... This
1:26 is happening to me. This is obviously happening to other people. And I think we've read
1:31 so much about those very extreme stories about people who fall in love with chatbots. But
1:37 I wanted to really explore the more mundane and much more pervasive ways that chatbots are
1:42 kind of squatting in people's relationships and and kind of moving them, shaping them in in
1:48 in kind of... In in this one therapist described it to me as the third entity
1:53 problem. Suddenly, you're not the only entity. You... There's not two entities in monogamous relationships anymore.
1:59 There's this other chatbot entity.
2:01 It's so interesting because I've read so much about how our thresholds for just being bored
2:05 or being uncomfortable has lessened so much in the era of tech and access to movies
2:10 and things to keep yourself being entertained. But now it seems like our thresholds for being
2:15 upset or or engaging in conflict even with people that we love is gonna be less
2:20 because, like you said, you can just take out your phone and have this thing tell
2:23 you that you're right and you're lovely and, you're you're not doing anything wrong.
2:29 Yeah. And I spoke to couples therapists and actually divorce lawyers, and they're both seeing, like,
2:34 chatbots kind of filter through into their clients. And I think, people are using chatbots in
2:40 their relationships in different ways. So one way is they're kind of turning to chatbots for
2:45 advice or validation when they're maybe not getting it from their partner, or they're maybe even
2:49 not trying to get it from their partner. Maybe they're taking all their little queries, all
2:53 those tiny queries that build intimacy like, oh, I have this dilemma at work or with
2:58 my friend. What should I do about it? Maybe they're taking them to the chatbot first.
3:02 But there's also, lots of therapists I spoke to were saying that in the kind of
3:06 the heat of the moment, when there's an argument or a dispute, people turn to chatbots,
3:11 and then they sort of wield what chat GPT or Claude has says at their partner
3:14 to be like, look. They agree with me. Like, they kind of validates my argument. And
3:19 so there's kind of different ways, different roles that they're playing.
3:23 This is like the weaponization of therapy speak. Now we're gonna have the weaponization hand
3:27 in your pocket. Yeah. As as you look at this on a spectrum, as you talk
3:31 to experts, including psychotherapists about, is there a point at which this becomes a problem? There
3:34 becomes kind of some form of betrayal or tantamount to having a kind of affair with
3:39 a thing. Again, not a person, but a but a thing. Yeah.
3:42 And I think I especially spoke to one therapist who is like, we can use chatbots
3:46 in positive ways. For example, if you're someone who really struggles in conflict situations, you could
3:53 use a chatbot to role play how you respond so you don't get defensive. I spoke
3:58 to one software engineer who said him and his now girlfriend were using Claude as kind
4:03 of an intermediary. They were going through a rough period in their relationship, and they would
4:07 send all their messages that they were going to send to each other to Claude first.
4:11 And Claude would give them feedback on those messages, and then they would send them to
4:15 each other. So they had this kind of third party, and they... He felt that that
4:19 was really productive, and it meant that they could strip away all that angry language that
4:23 isn't actually, helpful when you're trying to communicate how you feel. I think one thing that's
4:29 different, I mean, that we've kind of... Technology has come between couples for a really long
4:33 time, and there was the the magazine cover... The New York magazine cover from the nineteen
4:37 eighties where there was two people in bed both distracted from each other staring at their
4:42 gadgets. And what's different now is that people personify AI, which which wasn't the same when
4:47 kind of you had a busy banker husband on his laptop all the time. And so
4:52 people kind of get jealous or feel the presence of another person, another entity in a
4:57 way that is new, and I think that's really interesting.
5:00 Maybe I could end by asking you where all of this is headed. So I saw
5:02 news this week that Google Gemini is now gonna be integrated with Apple CarPlay, and you
5:06 can have a conversation with a chatbot while you're driving to the office or wherever. There's
5:12 gonna be a point at which you no longer need to take out your phone to
5:15 have these kinds of conversations that you're gonna have even more presence from this kind of
5:18 third entities you call it in your life. What does that look like in terms of
5:21 relationships in the future?
5:23 Yeah. And I think we're still navigating that. So, I mean, even... One thing that I
5:28 feel is, like, personally annoying to me is when you're out to dinner with a friend
5:32 and you're kind of having a kind of speculative conversation, and they're like, oh, no. Let's
5:36 stop talking and let me Google it. And then kind of... I feel like the conversation
5:39 after someone's, like, googled it kind of just dies. And so I feel like we're still
5:44 navigating how, like, the previous era of technology plays in our relationships in a way that
5:51 it enhances our connections as opposed to distracts us from them. I mean, social media is
5:57 a good example about how it started where it was all about messaging your friends, and
6:01 now lots of people are just looking at influencers all the time. And I think AI
6:05 just really supercharges that to be like, how do we use these communication technologies to communicate
6:13 better as opposed to pulling us apart?
6:16 Alright. Morgan Meaker, thank you, and thank you to your husband for letting you, write about
6:20 it. Think he seems like a good sport, so we appreciate it.
6:23 Maybe never again. Never again.
David Cameron Sees Hope in Alzheimer’s Research full transcript
0:00 Tens of millions of people worldwide are living with dementia, and every year, there are about
0:04 ten million new diagnoses according to the World Health Organization. Alzheimer's is the most common form
0:09 of dementia, and it's estimated to contribute to sixty to seventy percent of those cases.
0:13 And for former prime minister David Cameron, this is personal. He and his siblings lost their
0:17 mother married to the disease last year, and he spoke with them and many others as
0:21 part of his new Bloomberg podcast, ending Alzheimer's. We sat down with the former prime minister
0:26 and started by asking about his mom.
0:29 It's personal because we we lost my mother to Alzheimer's last year, and it's a it's
0:33 a terrible illness and disease. And the end is is is really so painful for them
0:39 and for the family. But my interest goes right back from when I was a member
0:43 of parliament. And and really, interest came from my own sort of embarrassment about my ignorance.
0:49 You know, I was thought, well, dementia, that's sort of what happens to people when they
0:52 get old. It isn't. It is caused by diseases of the brain. And once I got
0:56 to understand that and saw how little that was understood, I thought, well, there's a chance
1:01 as prime minister really to push this issue. And that's why we had the dementia challenge
1:06 in 2012 and tried to switch the whole world onto how we ought to be pursuing
1:10 this with the same vigor that we pursue curing cancer.
1:13 Why do you think that hadn't been done until now? Why do you think it had
1:17 just been kind of accepted as something that happens when you get older?
1:20 I think it was just a misunderstanding that lots of people had. The charities, one of
1:25 which I'm now president of Alzheimer's Research UK, had done a lot to move public opinion,
1:29 but there's still more to be done. And then I think the fact that Doctor. Alzheimer
1:34 discovered this disease one hundred and twenty years ago. And for about a hundred years, really
1:38 not much progress was made. And so I think a lot of people just thought, well,
1:43 this is something we're gonna have to deal with. And this renewed attention to it has
1:47 led to some real breakthroughs. And so now there's a sense, look, we are curing cancer.
1:52 We got a real chance of doing that with the diseases that cause dementia of which
1:55 Alzheimer's is the most prominent.
1:57 How well do we understand the pathology of this now? So hundred twenty years since it
2:01 was first discovered as you say. How fully do we understand what the disease is?
2:05 I think the answer is not fully. I think we know that the buildup of these
2:08 plaques in the brain, the so called amyloid plaques and these tau tangles in your nerve
2:13 endings, we know they're important. I mean, the the simple way of thinking of it is
2:17 know, not everyone who has amyloid plaques has dementia, but everyone with dementia has those amyloid
2:24 plaques. So trying to work out the exact causation and trying to work out the exact
2:29 sequencing still needs to be done. But these drugs that are you can now take that
2:34 stop the buildup of plaques and remove them do seem to be having some very positive
2:39 effects. Whether that's the final answer, we don't know. But, you know, ten years ago, there
2:44 were very few drug trials in this area going on. Today, there's a 190 drug trials
2:48 all over the world and a real sense that we're making breakthroughs.
2:52 The other part about this that is a really important component that I didn't think about
2:55 until I was reading up on this is the diagnostics because I think a lot of
3:00 people don't know that you can possibly maybe not get a blood test to diagnose this,
3:03 and it's cheaper and it's easier and it's much less invasive than CT scans or functional
3:07 imaging. How reliable is that test, and does more progress need to be made there?
3:11 Well, more progress is needed, but this is gonna be a it's gonna happen, and it's
3:15 a big breakthrough. So today, you know, Britain, country of sixty six million people, one million
3:20 people with dementia, probably only one in three of those actually have a proper diagnosis. And
3:27 that would probably be based on a cognitive test, not a brain scan. So the idea
3:31 that you can have a blood test, we are looking for this particular marker, biomarker that
3:38 you've got the buildup of the plaques, that could be a real game changer. And I
3:41 think that is... You know, that being widely available is is a year or two away.
3:46 Wow.
3:46 This is a deeply reported series. You report from London and from Los Angeles, Las Vegas,
3:52 New Jersey as well. You sit down with senator Andy Kim who's gone through this himself.
3:56 He's had a loved one developed Alzheimer's. Let's take a listen to what he had to
3:59 say.
4:00 One of the questions was, what was your work? What did you do over the course
4:04 of your career? And, you know, my father just looked at me and looked at the
4:09 doctor and just said, I don't know. And it was it was really heartbreaking.
4:18 It was a moment of tragic irony as senator Kim watched his father who worked in
4:24 Alzheimer's research, now on the other side of the disease.
4:29 It was heartbreaking the idea that Alzheimer's has erased from my father's memory his life's work
4:36 of trying to cure Alzheimer's. And I often say you can't help but feel like Alzheimer's
4:43 won.
4:44 Senator Kim talks about looking at his father's writings, his notebooks, and seeing this diminution in
4:48 his ability to hold thoughts and write those thoughts down. Something he's been quite passionate about
4:54 is making it easier for loved ones of people who are dealing with this disease to
4:58 to care for them. And as we talk about treatments and diagnostics, this is a crucial
5:02 part of this diseases placement in our society right now as well.
5:06 Yeah. It it was an incredibly moving interview because I didn't know Senator Kim before and
5:12 I didn't know about his father, but extraordinary that, you know, he spent his whole life
5:16 trying to understand this disease. And then his brain was just sort of wiped out. And
5:21 and... But I think senator Kim's right. How we how we get greater understanding and how
5:26 we help relatives care, it's really hard because in his little things, like when you go
5:31 and see your your parent, you know, the first thing you normally say is, hi, mom.
5:34 You know, what did you do yesterday? What have you been up to? You can't do
5:37 that because it can be really depressing when they... For them when they can't remember. So
5:41 trying to explain how the disease works and how better to to handle people with it
5:46 is important. And then, of course, there's massive issue of how do we pay for the
5:49 care, and we're having a big debate that... About that in The UK. But even better
5:54 would be if we could find some cures to this disease to reduce the level of
5:59 suffering and the level of cost that inevitably has to be borne by someone.
6:03 Can you talk a little bit about what this was like just for you? I mean,
6:07 this had to be hard to relive some of this stuff, to rethink, you know, the
6:11 last couple days or years with your mother. Can you just to us about why you
6:15 wanted to do this, and what was your family's reaction when you said, hey. I wanna
6:18 I wanna put this all down on a podcast? Well,
6:20 I've got two wonderful sisters, an older one and a younger one. And because I've been
6:26 president of Alzheimer's research for a decade, I've had a big interest, and then mom gets
6:30 this disease. And then when she passes, you know, I remember talking to them about it.
6:36 And and they didn't hesitate, actually. They said straight away, yes. You should do it. We
6:40 gotta spread understanding about this. And then when I said, would you like to be interviewed
6:44 for it? They jumped at that as well. And then the the the program interviewed
6:50 your sisters before? Or was quite it
6:52 was quite interesting actually because, as ever, women are more perceptive than men. And and they'd
6:57 spotted. We were trying to date the start of mom's Yeah. Alzheimer's, and they both thought
7:02 it was much earlier than than I did. Really? Because I think they'd they'd spotted some
7:06 of the signs.
7:06 Let's wrap up by talking about progress toward a a cure. And I'm curious if you
7:10 think big pharma, the big pharmaceutical companies acknowledges we have here that it is a disease
7:15 and one that needs treatment. And if the the investment is commensurate with how how big
7:19 a burden this is on so much of the world.
7:21 I think we're getting there. I mean, if you look back, so I launched the dementia
7:25 challenge in 2012. In 2014, a paper came out called the 99% paper, which showed that
7:31 ninety nine percent of drug trials have been unsuccessful. Devastating paper. So, you know, it felt
7:35 like at that moment, we're gonna go nowhere. Fast forward twelve years, we've got a 190
7:39 drugs in development. We've got two or three being used here in The United States. We
7:45 got a whole lot of new tests coming online in terms of blood tests, a much
7:49 better understanding about what's happening in the brain, a much better understanding about how to get
7:53 drugs across the blood brain barrier so they work more effectively. So I think we're in
7:58 the right place. We're still going to need philanthropy. The the the the pharma companies will
8:03 do the trials, but there are still gaps to fill in in our basic scientific knowledge.
8:08 So we still need the philanthropy. We still need the charities to do their work. And
8:13 then we need governments to be more creative about how do we trial novel medicines, how
8:17 do we fund new treatments, how do we recruit people for clinical trials. During COVID, we
8:22 were recruiting people for clinical trials on the Internet. We were doing things much faster. That
8:27 sort of warp speed approach, which we used for COVID drugs, we gotta use for Alzheimer's
8:32 drugs too.
8:32 Can you make this pitch very clearly? Because it is in the podcast. The the lack
8:35 of data that we have, and it really is something where this is a part of
8:39 medicine that needs people to participate, to sign up to be examined, if if not go
8:43 through clinical trials, but at least for us to know more about the way the brains
8:45 work.
8:46 We we definitely want people to sign up, but we also need governments to make it
8:50 easier and to say... So in The UK, the drugs aren't currently licensed on the NHS
8:55 because of the expense, but we could do much bigger clinical trials. And I think that's
9:01 a good way in.
9:02 Our thanks to the right honorable lord David Cameron for joining us there. The first episode
9:06 of the Ending Alzheimer's podcast will be released on Monday. A coproduction of Kaleidoscope and Bloomberg.
9:10 You can watch and listen at bloomberg.com and Bloomberg podcasts on YouTube.
Ukraine Peace Push Turns to NATO and Donbas full transcript
0:00 New this morning, Ukrainian president Vladimir Zelensky has said American envoys offered a peace trade that
0:06 could make potentially the country a member of NATO. The cost of admission would be Ukraine
0:11 giving up its entire Donbas region to Russia.
0:14 This comes after Steve Woodkow and Jared Kushner spent time this week in Moscow with Russian
0:18 president Putin and then in Dublin with president Zelensky. Becca Wasser, Bloomberg Economics' defense lead, joins
0:24 us now to discuss if this latest offer could lead to a truce. Becca, also in
0:28 the pages of the New York Times this morning. We're gonna talk about that in just
0:32 a little bit. I don't wanna bury that lead. We're gonna get there.
0:35 As well. Yes.
0:35 And we're gonna come back
0:36 to Let's stick with Ukraine first. What do you make of this announcement? We did hear
0:39 from president Zelensky. He spoke with reporters just a few hours ago. He said, quote, it
0:42 was the first time this had been raised. We're discussing it with our partners, a comprehensive
0:47 security package that could be offered to us in these negotiations. What do you make of
0:51 this news, and and do you think that it has any likelihood of coming to pass?
0:55 I think Ukraine has been looking for a wide array of security guarantees in a potential
1:01 postwar environment. And one of the ones that has been very essential has been this idea
1:06 of NATO membership or NATO like guarantees. Because at the end of the day, no matter
1:12 how this war ends, Ukraine is going to need to ensure its future territorial sovereignty and
1:18 security and stave off, any threat of potential future Russian aggression again. So, really, that is
1:26 something that has been top of mind for president Zelensky, but it is worth noting that
1:31 he said it is not his decision to make a loan to essentially trade Ukrainian territory,
1:38 the Donbas, for security guarantees, and he would have to put that forward to the Ukrainian
1:44 people. So I think, ultimately, it is not only up to the Ukrainian people whether this
1:49 moves forward, but truly it is also up to what happens right now on the battlefield
1:54 in Ukraine as essentially Russia is trying to set the conditions so it can sue for
1:59 peace at the negotiating table.
2:01 And even that in itself is complicated. How do you hold a referendum in a country
2:05 at war? This is of the debate. I mean, there hasn't been an election for this
2:08 reason since the combat started. But I reached out to some European diplomats who were in
2:12 Dublin, and they had a couple thoughts on this. One, that the Donbas is too big
2:17 of an ask. That's too much territory. Ukraine could not agree to see that entire part.
2:22 The other was that NATO cannot agree to allow Ukraine into its territory while it is
2:28 still in conflict in the current situation. This was one of the arguments. In In the
2:32 Biden administration, they kept promising Ukraine would become a made... A member of NATO. And on
2:36 its face, European allies were okay with it, but you can't... If you have article five,
2:40 which is a mutual defense pact, you can't admit a country that's actively at war. There's
2:44 a lot of complications there. I don't know how realistic this is, and I don't know
2:48 if Europeans would get on board with this. I'm wondering what your take is.
2:52 I mean, I think Russia knows all of this as well, and it's... That's why it's
2:55 entertaining this deal, which frankly could actually end up in Moscow's favor more than Ukraine's. But
3:03 for Europe, it is a big question. And, also, let's be honest, you know, NATO is
3:08 not necessarily in lockstep. It is not this, solely unified, you know, brain that things like.
3:15 These are all individual nations that have different threat perceptions and different risk tolerances. So it
3:21 will be really difficult to get all NATO members on board with everything. So it is
3:26 a proposal that is new and is different and is showing some type of progress, you
3:32 know, at the negotiating table. But whether it is realistic and whether it can be achieved
3:36 is really the open question right here. However, these discussions are worth having because Ukraine is
3:43 coming up at the end of its fifth year. And at this point, everyone wants the
3:49 conflict to end, but it needs to end on terms that do not compromise Ukraine's sovereignty
3:55 as well as European security architecture.
3:58 Becca, I'd like to get your observations of the shuttle diplomacy that's been taking place here
4:01 led by Steve Witkow and Jared Kushner aside from the fact that we can all remark
4:04 on Jared Kushner dressing inappropriately for the weather in Moscow. Dani Burger
4:08 is very upset that Marino
4:09 Vinak when the snow was falling, on the tarmac there in in Moscow. What do you
4:14 make of the status of those talks? Do they show any signs of bearing fruit, to
4:19 use? Or what what are you watching for as they continue to play out here, in
4:22 in in capitals around the world?
4:25 Well, definitely watching to see what Jared is wearing. Obviously, that's the first and foremost, thing
4:30 top of mind.
4:30 You know, actually, I enjoy that we're discussing what a man is wearing for one cell
4:34 television, so I'm gonna endorse this conversation. Becca, please continue.
4:37 But, you know, there is progress being made, and it is good for these conversations to
4:41 be had, but they need to be had in good faith. And all of this is
4:44 not happening in a vacuum. It is not like there is a standstill on the battlefield
4:48 as these conversations are taking place. There is still a war of grinding attrition going on.
4:54 There are still barrages of missiles and drones that are hitting capital cities every evening. And
5:00 this is important to keep in mind as these conversations are happening. You know, there is
5:05 this renewed flurry of diplomacy as, you know, Jared Kushner and Steve Woodkow, are back at
5:11 it, but whether they can actually be successful in changing anything on the ground, particularly as
5:18 we are continuing to see not only, you know, nightly territorial, barrages, we are also continuing
5:26 to see things like outages of Star Shield and Starlink that are having a material effect.
5:32 Okay. I wanted to ask you about that because as I was doing a sweep of
5:35 headlines, in the wee earlier hours of this morning, one of the ones I came across
5:38 was pretty frank. Ukraine is running out of options, and Russia knows it. And one of
5:43 the things playing into that, of course, is the star shield, more accusations that it was
5:48 throttled, again this last week from president Zelensky, denials from Elon Musk and the White House.
5:54 Do we know what's going on there and why this seems to be a habitual issue?
5:58 You know, open question as to why it keeps on happening and who is, at fault
6:03 with last time this occurred. You know, there was a bit of a pointing the fingers
6:07 and blame game from, you know, Elon Musk and the White House both pointing fingers at
6:13 each other. But, you know, it is very clear that this keeps on happening, in a
6:19 way to essentially halt some of Ukraine's momentum. Russian advances at the, you know, at the
6:27 line of battle essentially have slowed. They have not been able to take as much territory
6:32 as they have in years past. They are also having significant recruitment, challenges as, frankly, losses
6:41 are outpacing recruitment. And things aren't looking great for Russia along the front lines. And some
6:48 of these outages and some of these efforts are slowing down Ukraine's ability to not only,
6:55 defend that front line, but also defend further back and pursue some of its strategy to
7:01 try and hold Russia at risk. So all of this means that it shifts things on
7:07 the battlefield in Russia's favor, which allows Russia to have a more advantageous position at the
7:12 negotiating table.
7:13 There are wars on two fronts. This is an interview on two fronts as well. I
7:17 promise we'd get to the Middle East. So let's let's go there. We had president Trump
7:19 on Truth Social this week writing, we don't need to deal with Iran. Those days have
7:23 long since passed. We got their money, hundreds of billions of dollars, and we've got their
7:27 straight. And days later, said this to Stephen a Smith. Let's take a listen.
7:31 It's an evil empire, and we've knocked the hell out of them. And, they won't have
7:36 a nuclear weapon. We've taken that away, and we'll make sure we take it away. That's
7:40 why I'm there. Why is this still going on? Why haven't they been finished? Because I've
7:43 heard you say, you could take them out. You can end this. Why haven't you? I
7:49 could end it immediately Yes. At the request of the nations that I'm looking to protect.
7:55 We are, doing it a little bit longer way, a little bit more civilly. Saudi Arabia
8:01 has asked me to, please just let it be the way it is now for a
8:06 while because they're disintegrating.
8:08 Stephen Engle Smith asking about the conclusion of this war, and I mentioned that piece that
8:12 you've written with Tina in in New York Times. You're thinking about the region after this
8:16 war... There you go. Hold it up. The region after this war ends. Talk a bit
8:20 about sort of the the way that you're thinking about what US involvement in The Middle
8:24 East might look like after this conflict comes to an end when indeed that happens.
8:28 You know, whenever that happens and however it happens, The US is not just going to
8:32 walk away, and I think that is a bit of a misconception that a lot of
8:37 folks have. The US is going to remain engaged in the region, but its terms are
8:42 going to be quite different. And I do think it is going to be a more
8:45 narrow definition of protecting its core interests. But there's also operational reasons why the US military
8:53 is not going to go back to the bases, where it once stood in really large
8:58 formations with really expensive equipment just sitting there. And part of that is the operational risks
9:04 to them based on, Iran's ability to, threaten those bases and those locations. And so it
9:13 provides an opportunity as, you know, inverse as that might seem, an opportunity for The United
9:19 States to remake its posture, to reset its line so that it has a more resilient
9:24 approach within the Middle East, but it also allows for the Gulf States in particular to
9:29 take greater agency and to take greater responsibility for their own security. And that is frankly
9:36 the way in which the region ought to move forward. It requires a regional security architecture,
9:42 not one that is essentially protected from afar by The United States.
9:46 You and our colleague, Dina Esfandiari, argue that what that looks like instead of these behemoth
9:52 bases that are almost indefensible because they're so big and outdated, smaller installations and allied nations
9:58 like Saudi Arabia, Jordan, Israel, as you're just talking about a more diffused presence. My question
10:03 for you is, those things made those countries a target for Iran in this latest conflict.
10:08 Do you think the willingness is there for them to host such diplomatic outposts for The
10:12 US?
10:13 I think you hit on the most important part in what we wrote, which is The
10:17 US can have all of these plans, but, ultimately, they are not the ones who fully
10:21 get to decide. All of this hinges on allies and partners providing access overflight basing opportunities.
10:29 And frankly, it's not just in The Middle East. It also is very relevant to Europe
10:33 if I wanna bring this conversation back to, where we started. If The United States is
10:38 going to have a smaller, more distributed presence in The Middle East, it's going to need
10:43 to project power from Europe. And that means having access and overflight at European bases at
10:49 the very same time that The US is trying to reduce some of its commitments to
10:53 NATO.
Air Travel Chaos Puts FAA Systems in Focus full transcript
0:00 First, we're going to begin with what everybody's talking about.
0:02 That's a developing story at American airports, a nationwide halt in air
0:06 travel at a scale not seen since September 11th.
0:08 The FAA called it a temporary telecommunications issue and not a
0:12 security incident. Flights resumed after about five hours,
0:15 but the chaos left travelers scrambling inside packed airports.
0:18 Some 16,000 flights delayed or canceled on Friday, with thousands more canceled
0:24 today. Joining us now is George Ferguson,
0:25 senior airlines and airlines analyst for Bloomberg Intelligence.
0:28 It's great to speak with you. Let me start with a bit of tape here.
0:31 This is from the press conference that took place last night.
0:32 The Secretary of Homeland Security, Mark Wayne Mullen, talking about what
0:35 happened on Friday afternoon into the system.
0:39 They were putting new equipment, um, and, uh, new technology and that new
0:48 equipment, new technology just wasn't it was overwhelming the older system, which
0:52 is why Secretary Duffey made it very clear the patchwork doesn't work.
0:56 We need one complete system. Um, George, let me just have you pass
1:02 what we heard there from from the secretary talking about patches.
1:05 New technology. What do you make of what happened?
1:07 How holistic of an understanding do we have of what happened here on Friday?
1:11 Well, some I think we just have a very small understanding at this point.
1:15 But, uh, we know there's a large amount of legacy systems inside us, uh, you
1:21 know, air control system. And it's going to be very difficult to
1:24 get a single fix. Right?
1:27 You're going to have to lay it into an existing system so you can keep air
1:31 travel going while you're improving the system.
1:33 And it's a it's a constant job. So I think it'll be a challenge when I
1:37 hear them say, you know, that they need sort of one big, uh, 40 or $50 billion
1:42 to upgrade it all, uh, right away. And I think these kind of problems
1:45 continue. And again, it sounds like they laid in
1:48 some new equipment that isn't communicating correctly with old
1:51 equipment. I'm glad they found it before.
1:54 Uh, Thanksgiving, uh, weekend, because it's going to get, uh, even busier out
1:57 there. So I'm kind of surprised is breaking
1:59 down here. I want to ask you about the timing of
2:02 this. I mean, I have two questions.
2:05 One is nobody knew that there could be an inherent risk updating just half of
2:10 the system when so much of it is old analog still copper wire.
2:14 I was talking to somebody last night that said, yeah, of course, if you're
2:16 not putting in some sort of translator between those two systems, it's going to
2:19 overwhelm it. Of course it is.
2:21 How did they not know this was a risk beforehand?
2:23 And why would they be doing these upgrades in the middle of a Friday ahead
2:27 of a travel weekend? Yeah, I mean, that's another question I
2:30 have too. I've got an unfortunate I have a good
2:32 answer for that. I would expect them to be doing this
2:34 during the wee hours of the morning on, I don't know, a Monday or something like
2:38 that where you have minimal air travel, but uh, uh, you know, clearly they sort
2:43 of they're trying to set at peak hours, or at least the effects got felt in peak
2:48 hours. Um, and I think these are, these are
2:50 very complex systems with redundancies built in.
2:53 And I think, you know, we all would like to think we, um, they would have known
2:57 all the ramifications. But I think it's, I think it's very hard
3:00 to always know all the ramifications in the system.
3:03 Sometimes even the engineers, that they'll build the systems on the ground
3:07 anymore, and there's not even complete documentation and everything.
3:10 That could be a problem sometimes. George, I remember after that mid-air
3:13 collision over national airport. Uh, a lot of impulse to get this taken
3:17 care of more quickly. I mean, there's been talk for years, of
3:19 course, of modernizing the system, but I thought that we were well on the way to
3:22 that that happening. What's your sense of the status of this?
3:24 And as we hear the transportation secretary talk about the need for $50
3:28 billion to to do all of this, what accounts for the holdup?
3:33 But again, I think you've got to build it into a system that's working today,
3:36 and you can't shut the system down to to rejuvenate the whole thing.
3:41 Right. So the challenge is how do you build
3:43 new, better systems into old existing systems and don't hurt safety?
3:48 Um, I think they're constantly making improvements to the network, but, uh,
3:54 technology has come a long way and air travel continues to grow.
3:58 You know, three, 4% a year. And so the burdens continue to rise in
4:01 the system. So my sense is we're behind the curve.
4:04 And, uh, and I think we, you know, probably need to spend more money but
4:09 more effort to get ahead of the curve. Right?
4:11 A lot of times what I find nowadays is not it's not even the money.
4:15 It's the professionals to get the work done, the laborers to get the work done.
4:19 Just there, the hang up because it's hard to find them.
4:22 Everything costs more and everything takes longer.
4:25 And I suspect the FAA is finding the same thing.
4:28 But it seems like they've got to really redouble efforts to get ahead of the
4:31 curve here. Before we let you go, if you are
4:34 traveling or you were aspiring to travel yesterday, one of the things I found
4:37 kind of remarkable is, uh, Transportation Secretary is saying we're
4:41 going to get the cruise and we're going to arrange the flights, and we're going
4:43 to have as many of them take off as we can.
4:46 How much control does the federal government have over that?
4:49 Isn't a lot of it, if not all of it up to the airlines and how fast they can
4:52 recombine it after this massive shutdown?
4:55 Yeah, I haven't seen the size of his staff, but, uh, I think the staff at the
4:59 airlines are much larger and like United, American, Delta, JetBlue,
5:03 they're some of the best carriers in the world, and they know how to handle these
5:07 kind of interruptions. I'd leave it to them.
5:09 I think it's really falling on them. I think you kind of use that sort of
5:12 maybe the royal US, but, uh, my guess is that it's all falling on the airlines,
5:17 and they're smart, professional folks. They'll get it done.
“Bigger Than a Business Story”: Nvidia Shakeup full transcript
0:00 We start with the biggest story
0:01 of the week.
0:02 Jensen Huang's stepping down as head of NVIDIA
0:05 after news of an inappropriate relationship
0:07 with someone alleged to be a Chinese spy.
0:10 It is a huge story for investors
0:12 and for a world consumed with building out AI.
0:15 But it's bigger than that.
0:16 Richard Haass served as the head
0:18 of the Council on Foreign Relations
0:20 and now is a senior counselor to Centerview Partners.
0:24 The business world was rocked by news
0:25 coming out of NVIDIA
0:27 about the problems of Jensen Huang.
0:28 Normally, you'd say that's a business story.
0:31 But this is the most valuable company in the world
0:33 on the cutting edge with AI microchips
0:36 and really... really in that intersection
0:38 of U.S.-China competition over AI.
0:41 What are the ramifications
0:43 for international diplomacy here?
0:44 -Well, it is a business story, and at the same time,
0:46 it's much more than a business story.
0:48 The business story is going to be governance at the company.
0:51 They got some real issues to contend with.
0:53 Let's park that to the side.
0:54 No, this is not just any company.
0:56 They are producing the largest number
0:59 of the most advanced capable chips in the world.
1:02 So what happens there, shall we say,
1:04 affects the U.S. and global economy.
1:06 Then, as you say, you've got the China connection.
1:08 If all the reports are true,
1:10 they seem to be that this woman
1:11 was not simply a paramour, but was a spy.
1:14 It's actually a central part of the Chinese growth model,
1:16 the theft of intellectual property.
1:19 So it would totally fit with... with that tradition.
1:22 But then there's some also very interesting
1:24 national security aspects.
1:25 What did the president know, and when did he know it?
1:28 Months ago, he had been informed
1:30 through the intelligence community,
1:32 through the National Security Advisor,
1:33 Marco Rubio's second hat,
1:35 that this woman was most likely a Chinese spy.
1:38 Why was this individual allowed to travel
1:40 with the president, have the access?
1:42 Why did the Justice Department
1:44 not investigate every aspect of his life?
1:47 And then it raises other issues. Is it just the China connection?
1:50 Well, where else has NVIDIA
1:51 been selling large amounts of chips, David?
1:53 To the United Arab Emirates.
1:54 Well, what about that?
1:56 That is not, shall we say, a place that has a...
1:58 necessarily where the technology stops there.
2:01 And this administration and, you know,
2:04 the personal figures around the president,
2:06 the family, have all sorts of business ties
2:08 with that part of the world.
2:10 So this is a really interesting set of political issues,
2:13 business issues, and national security issues.
2:16 And I would say if the Justice Department,
2:18 as is likely, is unwilling to look into this,
2:21 then I would think this is actually a legitimate topic
2:23 for the new Congress
2:24 and one of its committees to get to the bottom of this.
2:28 Westin: There's been a lot of talk about, and use,
2:30 of export controls for national security purposes
2:33 to make sure that we're not exporting,
2:35 particularly to China,
2:36 particularly some advanced technology.
2:38 What does this say about that whole apparatus
2:40 if you can get around it that easily?
2:42 -It's an interesting question,
2:43 because I think export controls are intellectually well-disposed
2:46 towards them in principle.
2:48 But in practice, I'm not sure they work that well.
2:50 In a global economy there's so many connections
2:53 where the people can talk about something
2:54 or physically hand over something,
2:56 and then people can copy it or what have you.
3:00 So my guess is export controls
3:03 aren't nearly as effective as we would like them to be.
3:06 And in some cases,
3:07 that might even be counterproductive,
3:09 that they require and stimulate someone else
3:11 to become more self-sufficient, that if denied something,
3:15 then they make it an urgent priority
3:17 to produce it themselves.
3:19 So my guess is when the historical record
3:20 of export controls is written,
3:23 it won't be quite as positive
3:24 as its advocates would have it to be.
3:26 Westin: There was a midterm election.
3:28 -Thank you, David.
3:30 Westin: We've had a lot of ramifications
3:31 for the Congress,
3:32 where you had both houses switch.
3:35 Generally think of that as domestic, the Congress.
3:39 What possible effects could it have
3:40 on international relations and President Trump's position?
3:43 Well, the first point to make
3:44 is a version of the point you made,
3:46 that historically,
3:48 the lion's share of the control
3:50 over American foreign policy
3:51 has been the prerogative of the executive.
3:54 What, 50, 60 years ago,
3:55 Arthur Schlesinger Jr. wrote a book, what?
3:57 "The Imperial Presidency."
3:58 And that was in the context of Vietnam.
4:00 But every president since has gone to war
4:02 or used military force without congressional approval.
4:06 Congress has delegated enormous powers.
4:08 For example, when it comes to tariffs,
4:10 presidents can do what they want in diplomacy and so forth.
4:14 So the short answer to your question, David,
4:16 is the election won't matter that much.
4:18 So if tomorrow Donald Trump wants to make a new proposal,
4:21 more pro-Russian, more pro-Ukrainian,
4:24 when it comes to that war, he can do it.
4:26 But for 95% or more,
4:29 presidential leadership
4:31 on foreign policy is going to remain.
4:33 Plus, this administration doesn't have ambassadors,
4:35 for the most part.
4:36 About three-quarters of our embassies are empty.
4:39 The way policy is made gives informality a new meaning.
4:42 So again, there's not a lot of entry points
4:45 for the Congress here.
4:46 Westin: You have dealt with U.S. diplomacy
4:48 at the highest levels of government,
4:50 both in the White House as well as the State Department.
4:52 So you've seen this over years.
4:54 To what extent does the political standing
4:56 of the president in the United States
4:58 domestically affect his position
5:00 with respect to others, like Vladimir Putin,
5:02 and even more important, perhaps,
5:03 President Xi that he's meeting with at the ASEAN summit?
5:06 -No, you're exactly right.
5:07 I think it hurts Donald Trump with the Iranians.
5:10 They are pretty good readers
5:11 of the American political system.
5:13 A lot of their senior people went to school here.
5:15 So they're watching. They saw the midterms.
5:17 My guess is they've decided they can drive a harder bargain,
5:21 that one of the takeaways from the election
5:23 is the American people
5:24 don't have much more stomach for this.
5:25 Donald Trump's standing is diminished.
5:27 So I think we'll see probably a tougher line,
5:29 if possible, tougher.
5:31 It's been pretty tough up to now out of Tehran.
5:33 Yeah, and you've got these upcoming meetings
5:35 with President Xi and with Vladimir Putin.
5:39 So yeah, they've taken note of what's happened.
5:40 Funnily enough, though, David,
5:41 I think all 3 are somewhat weakened.
5:43 Donald Trump comes out of the midterms
5:45 with very little wind that is back, so to speak.
5:47 Vladimir Putin's not winning,
5:49 and over the last couple of months
5:50 has been more losing the war against Ukraine.
5:52 His economy is in shambles.
5:55 Xi Jinping also, as you know, has enormous economic problems.
5:58 So the so-called "big 3" ain't so big right now.
6:02 And that's an interesting context for this meeting.
6:05 Westin: Another hallmark of President Trump's
6:06 foreign policy has been tariffs,
6:09 including those he levied on Canada.
6:11 Chrystia Freeland, former Canadian Deputy Prime Minister
6:14 and author of the book "Unreliable Boyfriend,"
6:16 negotiated a trade deal
6:18 with the first Trump administration.
6:20 Bring us up to speed, if you can,
6:22 on the nature of U.S.-Canadian relations right now.
6:25 Particularly when it comes to trade.
6:26 We've talked a lot about it.
6:28 There were some statements coming out
6:29 of the Trump White House just on the eve of the election.
6:31 Things are getting better. It's hopeful with Canada.
6:33 Maybe it'll work out.
6:34 From your point of view, is that right?
6:38 -Not yet.
6:39 And, you know, what I think Americans
6:42 need to remember
6:44 is we have a trade deal with the United States.
6:48 According to that trade deal,
6:50 we're not supposed to impose tariffs on each other.
6:53 According to that trade deal,
6:54 if we have problems with each other,
6:57 we have a whole system of tribunals
7:00 to work those problems out.
7:02 We went through Trump 1.
7:04 We negotiated a really good deal.
7:07 And then out of the blue,
7:09 new tariffs are imposed on us
7:12 directly in contravention of that deal.
7:16 And those tariffs are all still in place.
7:18 I find those comments, though, that you cite really telling.
7:23 And one of the things that happened
7:25 as we got closer to the election
7:27 is you saw U.S. officials getting really nervous
7:31 that the tariffs were hurting Republicans politically.
7:35 Westin: And I must say, as an American,
7:38 I was a little surprised,
7:39 not disappointed, but surprised,
7:41 the extent to which Canadian relations
7:43 played into elections, particularly in border states,
7:46 in my host state of Michigan, in Ohio, in Maine.
7:49 It was a real issue where people were saying,
7:51 "We don't want to pick a fight with Canada."
7:52 Is that a source of some encouragement
7:54 for someone like you from Canada?
7:56 -Huge encouragement.
7:58 You know, I really believe, again,
8:01 a little bit to my surprise,
8:03 Canada was on the ballot
8:05 and Americans voted
8:07 for a good relationship with Canada.
8:09 American voters are also really smart
8:11 and they get that tariffs and like a trade war with Canada
8:16 is not only kind of ridiculous, but actually that it hurts them.
8:21 And I think especially in the border states,
8:23 Americans are seeing it's raising prices.
8:27 It's maybe hurting my business,
8:28 partly because I'm not getting those Canadian tourists anymore,
8:32 partly because, you know,
8:33 about 60% of Canada's exports
8:35 to the United States are intermediate goods.
8:39 So tariffs on Canada
8:41 are quite literally a tax on U.S. manufacturers.
8:45 I think Americans saw all of that.
8:48 And for me, a moment when I thought,
8:50 you know, maybe this is all going to work out
8:53 is when Obama started talking about Canada in his speeches.
8:57 And, you know, he would say, like,
9:00 "This fight with Canada, isn't it ridiculous?"
9:03 And those were his biggest laugh lines.
9:05 So I'm now cautiously optimistic.
9:08 Westin: Pulling back more broadly
9:10 from U.S.-Canada to the world, as it were,
9:13 you served in various very senior positions in Canada,
9:16 including as foreign minister.
9:18 What does an election like this mean
9:20 for a world leader like Donald Trump
9:22 as he sits down with his counterparts,
9:25 whether they're their adversaries
9:26 or their friends and allies?
9:28 How does it change potentially his position with them?
9:30 And could it change our policy?
9:32 -I think, David, it weakens Donald Trump,
9:36 and I think it strengthens America.
9:39 I think prior to these midterms,
9:42 there was a real question mark around the world
9:45 about whether American democracy was going to endure.
9:50 There was a real question about was it going to be possible
9:54 to have a fair and uncontested vote?
9:57 And remember, of course,
9:58 the reaction to the presidential elections.
10:01 So the fact that there was this blue tsunami
10:07 and that it was recognized by Republicans,
10:11 I think means something really important,
10:14 which is, you know,
10:15 a lot of the world,
10:17 especially America's Democratic allies,
10:19 had been losing faith in America as a democracy,
10:24 as a leader of the free world.
10:26 And I think this vote means a lot of us,
10:30 you know, America's traditional friends,
10:32 are thinking actually American democracy works.
Nvidia’s Leadership Shakeup Tests AI Chip Giant full transcript
0:00 NVIDIA's named a new interim CEO as the company tries to turn the page. Joining us
0:04 now, also an early volunteer as two group for the 7AM hour. We appreciate you, Mike
0:08 Shepard. He's Bloomberg's senior editor for technology and strategic industries. Mike, I don't really know where
0:14 to start. I guess I wanna start with, has the board done enough to calm investors?
0:20 It seems like everybody I ran into this week was talking about what this is going
0:24 to do for the company, for the stock, and for the markets as a whole.
0:28 This is a great question to start with, Christina, because there's been a huge... People have
0:34 been wondering, is this board up to the task of a crisis? Because it's largely a
0:39 group of insiders, and people have known Jensen and the company for so long. And yet
0:44 they're... They have stepped in and really done just about everything that they can really since
0:48 Sunday when Jensen Huang admitted to the affair and the board said it would be launching
0:53 an investigation right away. They moved quickly to engage an outside law firm. And then as
0:58 further revelations tumbled in, they acted quickly to, oust, Jensen Huang as CEO and then elevate,
1:07 CFO, Colette Kress, as, the interim chief of the company. And by doing so and putting
1:13 Fraher into place, it offered some reassurance to investors. They know her. She has been in
1:19 the position for about thirteen years as finance chief, and they know her from, frequent, appearances
1:25 on conference calls and also at industry gatherings as well. So she provides some confidence to
1:33 the market and also to the rest of Silicon Valley too because she will also understand
1:38 the intricacies of all the company's deal making. And, you know, she will have quite a
1:43 load on her shoulders though as we look to their earnings call next week on Tuesday.
1:48 There will be a lot riding on that, less so in the numbers, but far more
1:51 so on what she has to say in her first public remarks as the company's new
1:57 chief.
1:57 Certainly a plus that she's been on those calls before, has experience on those those earnings
2:01 calls. Mike, I I wanna ask you about the contagion so much as we've seen it
2:04 here, and I was rattling off those stats about the week. I, candidly, am a bit
2:08 surprised that it wasn't more widely felt than it was, and I wonder what you make
2:11 of that. Is it simply that you have NVIDIA's competitors now looking at this kind of
2:15 opportunistically? Why do you think that this hasn't had a more kind of broad market impact?
2:20 Part of it is just the, broad appeal of artificial intelligence itself. You can see that
2:26 the initial public offering for Anthropic has oversubscribed six times. That just gives you a sense
2:32 of the demand for, the, software product. And then by corollary, the underlying infrastructure, the hardware
2:40 that powers AI, that is going to be in demand for quite some time. And when
2:45 you look at NVIDIA, it's sold out, essentially through... Of its supply through 2028, and that
2:52 just signals that there's demand for the products. As far as NVIDIA's competitors go, though, this
2:57 really does create an opening for them. You know, they finally will be able to get
3:02 an award edgewise with the rest of the market now that Jensen Huang, has been a
3:07 a real evangelist and salesman for his company's products, they'll be able to, get a little
3:13 bit more attention for theirs. And a number of them including Broadcom and Google, even have
3:19 been trying to develop competing products. And then there is, of course, AMD, Lisa Su at
3:25 the helm there. Their company's shares have risen so much as Lisa noted in the opening.
3:31 They are really trying to move into this area of AI chips as well, and they
3:35 have been gaining some ground on NVIDIA. But NVIDIA still remains the top of the heap
3:40 and will will be there for quite some time. Now as far as the rest of
3:44 the industry and all the financing, that is a question that we will have to look
3:49 at more closely further down the road once they have named a permanent replacement for Jensen
3:54 Huang. We'll have to see if that person has the same enthusiasm for all the circular
3:59 financing and investment that we've seen, and that's been criticized by some including on Wall Street.
4:04 I wonder if we talk so much about these singular tech leaders and how integral they
4:09 are to these company brands. If you, you know, you look at Apple, did manage to
4:13 keep an identity after Steve Jobs. But when you look at CEOs and messy personal lives,
4:19 I don't think Jensen Huang was high up on our list when you have other characters.
4:23 Elon Musk comes to mind. I remember with the SpaceX IPO, a question we asked a
4:27 lot is if something happens to him, what happens to this company? Is there a way
4:31 these companies need to reevaluate and isolate these figures from the value of the company or
4:38 put some sort of separation there so that this is not such a risk to an
4:41 industry that only has a few key figures that can make such a huge difference in
4:45 the industry and the markets.
4:47 Well, it's interesting you also brought up Elon Musk because, in a way like Elon with
4:52 SpaceX and Tesla, NVIDIA has been defined and shaped by Jensen Huang who cofounded the company
4:58 more than thirty years ago and really not only just put his stamp on it. I
5:02 mean, he was in many ways the company. I mean, he had 60 people reporting to
5:07 him directly. They all sat in this kind of room with this sort of panopticon feel
5:12 to it, looking at him and reporting to him and checking in with him. And, you
5:17 know, on one level, it sounds like micromanagement, but on another, it is really him trying
5:21 to make sure the company looks exactly the way he wants it. And he had no
5:26 intention of stepping down. In that interview that Emily Chang did with him just a few
5:30 weeks before all this unfolded, he indicated that he was prepared to stay on the job
5:34 for another twenty years and that he didn't really see a successor in the ranks just
5:40 yet. But it also points to what boards need to do, Christina, because, you know, the
5:46 NVIDIA board didn't even have a chairman before this, all unfolded. And now they have named
5:52 Harvey Jones, one of the longtime directors, as chair, the first chair in their history, and
5:57 he is somebody who will have a a task ahead of him in terms of establishing
6:01 some of that governance that we see at other firms.
Carrie Underwood on Her New Wellness Brand, HiNote full transcript
0:00 Now Carrie Underwood might be known for her Grammy award winning music, eight times a Grammy
0:04 winner, but she's also pushing into the wellness space through her new brand called High Note.
0:09 It's a lifestyle and nutrition company that's just secured a new investment to expand production of
0:13 its flagship drink mix. I sat down with Carrie and Kerrigan Behrens, the cofounder and CEO
0:19 of Hynote, about the creation of this brand and their plans for its future. Have a
0:24 listen.
0:27 I've been excited about health and wellness for really my whole life, but I started making
0:34 it a priority in my twenties. And I feel like I've learned a lot along the
0:39 way. I continue to learn, But basically, you know, wanted to share some of the things
0:46 that I've learned over my own journey with with people. We started a fitness app and
0:52 kind of through that, we we branched out and we, created High Note Life. And, we
1:01 are always expanding, always learning. We wanted to create things that could meet consumers where they
1:09 were and just help help health, help people get healthy.
1:14 And I love that your catchphrase or one of them is making wellness doable, and I
1:19 think that will resonate with a lot of people that are maybe just starting out on
1:23 their journey. Kerrigan, you're obviously savvy with the consumer space. How did you shape this product
1:29 so that it would meet a certain niche?
1:32 Yeah. We really have been thinking about consumers that are underserved. So not just coastal high
1:39 income consumers, but actually three out of four of our customers are based in the Midwest
1:44 and South. And so making sure that the products are going to fit into their lifestyles
1:51 and also fit into their budgets was a really big thing. We also heard from a
1:56 lot of women that one of the issues that they're constantly dealing with is just that
2:01 they're tired, which makes sense. If you're a working mom, you can certainly resonate with that.
2:05 And so, when we were thinking about the kinds of ingredients we could use to help
2:11 women be less tired, we were thinking about things like protein and fiber and fruits and
2:16 veggies, the kind of energy that you get from eating well. And that's really what we
2:21 created with our high note everyday energy daily nutrition drink mix.
2:24 Exactly. And this is really the first product. Right? It costs about $36 for a big
2:30 pouch of it, and you get several drinks out of it. So maybe, Carrie, explain to
2:34 us how this came about as the first product, how it was developed in conjunction with
2:39 doctors and so on, and what makes it special to you?
2:42 Well, I feel like our main objective was looking at what was missing. I'm all about,
2:52 trying to get things into my life that are just an easy fit. And, you know,
2:58 you you go to the store, you look at, you know, protein powders and greens mixes
3:03 and all this stuff, and it's very kind of for bros, you know, for, like, gym
3:09 bros. And I'm I'm sitting there. I love reading labels, and I'm sitting there looking at
3:13 labels, and things are very confusing. And there's all these, you know, giant tubs of, you
3:17 know, muscle growth gains, you know, all all those buzzwords. And I'm like, how does this
3:23 fit into my life? And if I'm having this problem, I'm sure everybody else is having
3:27 this problem as well. You know, we we want it to be something that is easily
3:33 easily implementable into your life and can help you, on your journey no matter where your
3:41 journey is at the moment. My mom loves our daily nutrition drink mix, but also my
3:48 brother-in-law who does, like, iron man competitions, like, multiple multiple drinks a day of of our
3:57 nutrition drink mix. So I love that it's for everybody, but we're really just trying to
4:02 simplify and just meet you where you are and help give you the energy that you
4:07 need to, you know, to be a mom, be a friend, like, do your job, work
4:12 out, all the things that we are all constantly juggling.
4:16 Carrie Underwood there and Kerrigan Behrens, cofounders of High Note.
The Billion-Dollar Business of Virtual Public Schools full transcript
0:00 Online education in the United States has just boomed in recent years.
0:05 While virtual classrooms were a band-aid
0:07 for the real thing during pandemic lockdowns,
0:09 now the promise of flexibility
0:11 and self-paced learning has wooed many parents to go all in.
0:15 K12-powered schools are tuition free in the comfort of your own home.
0:18 Texas families. This is big news.
0:21 This is full-time school just done in a completely online environment.
0:26 As of the most recent data that we have available, about one
0:29 in every 80 public school children attend a fully online school.
0:34 And nowhere in the US has this expansion happened faster than in Texas.
0:39 If you are a Texas resident and you have considered virtual school, good news.
0:43 In Texas virtual school enrollment has more than doubled since 2020.
0:47 Texas offers many virtual school options, and 56% of students enrolled in them
0:52 attend a school operated by a publicly traded company called Stride.
0:57 With millions in taxpayer funds flowing into these private companies,
1:01 the question is who's benefiting the most, the students or the business?
1:12 The biggest school
1:13 in Texas is 25,000 students,
1:16 and almost all of them will never step foot in the actual school district.
1:20 That school is Texas Virtual Academy, located in Hallsville
1:24 Independent School District.
1:26 It's operated by Stride, formally known as K12, which has received
1:30 more than $1 billion in Texas taxpayer money
1:33 over the last five years for which data is available.
1:36 Stride makes money by operating these online public schools
1:41 where the public funding gets sent to the school district.
1:44 The school district keeps the cut and then the rest is sent over to Stride.
1:48 Whatever Stride doesn't spend on the school,
1:50 it can keep.
1:51 Schools in Texas are funded in large part by property taxes
1:56 from richer areas redistributed to poorer areas.
2:00 Before Texas Virtual Academy, Hallsville ISD didn't get very much from the state.
2:05 But then when it added all of these thousands of students
2:08 to its roles, it saw its state funding balloon.
2:11 Bloomberg reviewed public school finances across Texas,
2:15 as well as financial statements by Stride to show how spending on the average Texas
2:19 student compares to spending on the average Stride student nationwide.
2:24 Texas is spending more than $12,000 per student,
2:27 with over $9,000 of that going towards instruction.
2:30 The rest filters into brick-and-mortar related expenses.
2:34 Now look at Stride’s model.
2:35 The company receives an average of about $10,000
2:38 per enrolled student, $6,000 of that goes towards instruction,
2:42 while the remaining $4,000 goes towards administrative costs and profit.
2:46 We see that around $400 per enrolled student is going toward
2:50 advertising and marketing.
2:52 Advertising is a big part of Stride’s business
2:54 because their investors really want to see enrollment growth.
2:57 These ads, including social media ads, are effectively being funded by taxpayers.
3:05 While a new bill aimed at expanding
3:06 virtual learning opportunities across Texas has been signed into law.
3:10 This 2025 Texas law made the online model even more lucrative.
3:15 First, it guaranteed that virtual schools were received
3:18 the same per student funding as brick-and-mortar schools.
3:22 Even though those brick
3:22 and mortar schools have costs that you wouldn't see in a virtual school.
3:26 It also got rid of a requirement that said virtual students
3:30 would only receive funding if they completed a course.
3:33 So what that means is that from a funding perspective,
3:36 attendance at the virtual school doesn't really matter.
3:39 But if attendance doesn't affect funding, how many students are actually showing up
3:44 and participating?
3:45 We filed dozens of public records request, including
3:48 with Hallsville ISD, which oversees the Texas Virtual Academy.
3:52 The documents we received showed that 14,000 students at Texas
3:55 Virtual Academy were truant for the 2024 to 2025 school year.
4:00 And that's a number that the school district has confirmed
4:03 stayed pretty consistent last academic year, too.
4:06 In Texas, a student is considered truant if they have ten
4:09 or more unexcused absences in six months.
4:12 We've spoken to families that go to these Stride schools,
4:15 and what we've heard from a lot of folks is that they're choosing online school
4:19 because their student might have a disability
4:21 that made traditional brick-and-mortar school challenging, that they were bullied
4:26 and feared for their safety, concerns around school safety more broadly.
4:30 Then you have some unique situations.
4:32 Maybe a child does rodeo or competes competitively
4:35 in gymnastics, and a traditional in-person school
4:38 was no longer supportive of those goals and aspirations.
4:43 This cohort of students that are now numbering 51,000 in the state
4:48 have already shown they excel with virtual instruction.
4:51 Testing scores do not bear this out.
4:54 Academic performance during the 2024-2025 school year was below state average.
5:00 Just 26% of tested Virtual Academy students met grade level
5:04 expectations in reading, and just 5% did so in math.
5:08 Results like those would normally put a Texas school at risk of a failing grade.
5:13 But Texas Virtual Academy is classified as a dropout recovery school.
5:18 That means that even though the school
5:19 students are not meeting grade level expectations on standardized testing,
5:24 the school can still receive
5:25 passing marks from the state because they're graded on a more lenient scale.
5:29 Stride said that the school's dropout recovery designation
5:32 reflects an accurate understanding of the student population.
5:38 With schools
5:38 now operating in 32 states and Washington, D.C.
5:42 Stride has built a nationwide footprint.
5:46 Stride now has a market cap of more than $3 billion
5:49 and its two largest investors are Blackrock and Vanguard.
5:53 During the last school year, Stride was responsible for educating
5:56 more than 240,000 students nationwide.
5:59 We're seeing a foundational shift in the way US children are being educated,
6:03 and the academic results are raising serious concerns.
Wall Street Week | Nvidia Shakeup, Midwest Stadium Bids, Care Work Gap, India’s Wedding Economy full transcript
0:12 David Westin: This is "Wall Street Week."
0:14 I'm David Westin, bringing you stories of capitalism.
0:17 Cities have long spent taxpayer money
0:19 chasing professional sports teams.
0:21 Now, Indiana and Illinois are competing
0:24 for one of the NFL's most storied franchises,
0:27 the Chicago Bears,
0:28 leaving taxpayers facing the risk
0:30 of paying too much for something that they love.
0:33 Plus, the move to AI doesn't appear to be affecting
0:36 the growing need for caregivers for the elderly.
0:39 But will the market provide the workers we need
0:41 with the living wage they need?
0:44 And it's the wedding season in India,
0:47 where people pay more to tie the knot
0:48 than anywhere else in the world
0:50 as a share of income,
0:52 what the wedding business
0:53 means for the Indian economy overall,
0:55 and why it makes sense for families
0:57 to spend as much as 5 times their annual income
1:00 for what they hope will be a once-in-a-lifetime event.
1:04 But we start with the biggest story
1:06 of the week.
1:08 Jensen Huang's stepping down as head of NVIDIA
1:10 after news of an inappropriate relationship
1:12 with someone alleged to be a Chinese spy.
1:15 It is a huge story for investors
1:17 and for a world consumed with building out AI.
1:20 But it's bigger than that.
1:22 Richard Haass served as the head
1:23 of the Council on Foreign Relations
1:25 and now is a senior counselor to Centerview Partners.
1:29 The business world was rocked by news
1:31 coming out of NVIDIA
1:32 about the problems of Jensen Huang.
1:34 Normally, you'd say that's a business story.
1:36 But this is the most valuable company in the world
1:39 on the cutting edge with AI microchips
1:41 and really... really in the intersection
1:44 of U.S.-China competition over AI.
1:47 What are the ramifications
1:48 for international diplomacy here?
1:49 -Well, it is a business story, and at the same time,
1:52 it's much more than a business story.
1:53 The business story is going to be governance at the company.
1:56 They got some real issues to contend with.
1:58 Let's park that to the side.
1:59 No, this is not just any company.
2:02 They are producing the largest number
2:04 of the most advanced capable chips in the world.
2:07 So what happens there, shall we say,
2:09 affects the U.S. and global economy.
2:11 Then, as you say, you've got the China connection.
2:14 If all the reports are true,
2:15 they seem to be that this woman
2:17 was not simply a paramour, but was a spy.
2:19 It's actually a central part of the Chinese growth model,
2:22 the theft of intellectual property.
2:24 So it would totally fit with... with that tradition.
2:28 But then there's some also very interesting
2:29 national security aspects.
2:31 What did the president know, and when did he know it?
2:34 Months ago, he had been informed
2:36 through the intelligence community,
2:37 through the National Security Advisor,
2:39 Marco Rubio's second hat,
2:40 that this woman was most likely a Chinese spy.
2:43 Why was this individual allowed to travel
2:45 with the president, have the access?
2:47 Why did the Justice Department
2:49 not investigate every aspect of his life?
2:52 And then it raises other issues. Is it just the China connection?
2:55 Well, where else has NVIDIA
2:56 been selling large amounts of chips, David?
2:58 To the United Arab Emirates.
3:00 Well, what about that?
3:01 That is not, shall we say, a place that has a...
3:03 necessarily where the technology stops there.
3:06 And this administration and, you know,
3:09 the personal figures around the president,
3:12 the family, have all sorts of business ties
3:13 with that part of the world.
3:15 So this is a really interesting set of political issues,
3:18 business issues, and national security issues.
3:21 And I would say if the Justice Department,
3:23 as is likely, is unwilling to look into this,
3:26 then I would think this is actually a legitimate topic
3:28 for the new Congress
3:30 and one of its committees to get to the bottom of this.
3:33 Westin: There's been a lot of talk about, and use,
3:35 of export controls for national security purposes
3:39 to make sure that we're not exporting,
3:40 particularly to China,
3:41 particularly some advanced technology.
3:43 What does this say about that whole apparatus
3:45 if you can get around it that easily?
3:47 -It's an interesting question,
3:48 because I think export controls, I'm intellectually well-disposed
3:51 towards them in principle.
3:53 But in practice, I'm not sure they work that well.
3:55 In a global economy there's so many connections
3:58 where the people can talk about something
4:00 or physically hand over something,
4:02 and then people can copy it or what have you.
4:06 So my guess is export controls
4:08 aren't nearly as effective as we would like them to be.
4:12 And in some cases,
4:13 that might even be counterproductive,
4:14 that they require and stimulate someone else
4:17 to become more self-sufficient, that if denied something,
4:20 then they make it an urgent priority
4:22 to produce it themselves.
4:24 So my guess is when the historical record
4:26 of export controls is written,
4:28 it won't be quite as positive
4:29 as its advocates would have it to be.
4:32 Westin: There was a midterm election.
4:34 -Thank you, David.
4:35 Westin: We've had a lot of ramifications
4:36 for the Congress,
4:38 where you had both houses switch.
4:41 Generally think of that as domestic, the Congress.
4:44 What possible effects could it have
4:45 on international relations and President Trump's position?
4:48 Well, the first point to make
4:49 is a version of the point you made,
4:51 that historically,
4:53 the lion's share of the control
4:55 over American foreign policy
4:56 has been the prerogative of the executive.
4:59 What, 50, 60 years ago,
5:01 Arthur Schlesinger Jr. wrote a book, what?
5:02 "The Imperial Presidency."
5:04 And that was in the context of Vietnam.
5:05 But every president since has gone to war
5:08 or used military force without congressional approval.
5:11 Congress has delegated enormous powers.
5:13 For example, when it comes to tariffs,
5:16 presidents can do what they want in diplomacy and so forth.
5:19 So the short answer to your question, David,
5:22 is the election won't matter that much.
5:24 So if tomorrow Donald Trump wants to make a new proposal,
5:27 more pro-Russian, more pro-Ukrainian,
5:29 when it comes to that war, he can do it.
5:32 But for 95% or more,
5:34 presidential leadership
5:37 on foreign policy is going to remain.
5:38 Plus, this administration doesn't have ambassadors,
5:40 for the most part.
5:41 About three-quarters of our embassies are empty.
5:44 The way policy is made gives informality a new meaning.
5:48 So again, there's not a lot of entry points
5:50 for the Congress here.
5:52 Westin: You have dealt with U.S. diplomacy
5:53 at the highest levels of government,
5:55 both in the White House as well as the State Department.
5:58 So you've seen this over years.
6:00 To what extent does the political standing
6:01 of the president in the United States
6:03 domestically affect his position
6:05 with respect to others, like Vladimir Putin,
6:07 and even more important, perhaps,
6:09 President Xi that he's meeting with at the ASEAN Summit?
6:11 -No, you're exactly right.
6:12 I think it hurts Donald Trump with the Iranians.
6:15 They are pretty good readers
6:16 of the American political system.
6:18 A lot of their senior people went to school here.
6:21 So they're watching. They saw the midterms.
6:22 My guess is they've decided they can drive a harder bargain,
6:26 that one of the takeaways from the election
6:28 is the American people
6:29 don't have much more stomach for this.
6:31 Donald Trump's standing is diminished.
6:32 So I think we'll see probably a tougher line,
6:34 if possible, tougher.
6:36 It's been pretty tough up to now out of Tehran.
6:38 Yeah, and you've got these upcoming meetings
6:40 with President Xi and with Vladimir Putin.
6:44 So yeah, they've taken note of what's happened.
6:45 Funnily enough, though, David,
6:47 I think all 3 are somewhat weakened.
6:48 Donald Trump comes out of the midterms
6:50 with very little wind at his back, so to speak.
6:53 Vladimir Putin's not winning,
6:54 and over the last couple of months
6:56 has been more losing the war against Ukraine.
6:58 His economy is in shambles.
7:00 Xi Jinping also, as you know, has enormous economic problems.
7:03 So the so-called "big 3" ain't so big right now.
7:07 And that's an interesting context for this meeting.
7:10 Westin: Another hallmark of President Trump's
7:12 foreign policy has been tariffs,
7:14 including those he levied on Canada.
7:16 Chrystia Freeland, former Canadian Deputy Prime Minister
7:19 and author of the book "Unreliable Boyfriend,"
7:22 negotiated a trade deal
7:23 with the first Trump administration.
7:25 Bring us up to speed, if you can,
7:27 on the nature of U.S.-Canadian relations right now.
7:30 Particularly when it comes to trade.
7:31 We've talked a lot about it.
7:33 There were some statements coming out
7:34 of the Trump White House just on the eve of the election.
7:36 Things are getting better. It's hopeful with Canada.
7:38 Maybe it'll work out.
7:39 From your point of view, is that right?
7:43 -Not yet.
7:44 And, you know, what I think Americans
7:47 need to remember
7:49 is we have a trade deal with the United States.
7:53 According to that trade deal,
7:55 we're not supposed to impose tariffs on each other.
7:58 According to that trade deal,
8:00 if we have problems with each other,
8:02 we have a whole system of tribunals
8:05 to work those problems out.
8:07 We went through Trump one.
8:09 We negotiated a really good deal.
8:12 And then out of the blue,
8:15 new tariffs are imposed on us
8:17 directly in contravention of that deal.
8:21 And those tariffs are all still in place.
8:24 I find those comments, though, that you cite really telling.
8:28 And one of the things that happened
8:30 as we got closer to the election
8:32 is you saw U.S. officials getting really nervous
8:36 that the tariffs were hurting Republicans politically.
8:40 Westin: And I must say, as an American,
8:43 I was a little surprised,
8:44 not disappointed, but surprised,
8:46 the extent to which Canadian relations
8:48 played into elections, particularly in border states,
8:51 in my host state of Michigan, in Ohio, in Maine.
8:54 It was a real issue where people were saying,
8:56 "We don't want to pick a fight with Canada."
8:58 Is that a source of some encouragement
8:59 for someone like you from Canada?
9:01 -Huge encouragement.
9:03 You know, I really believe, again,
9:06 a little bit to my surprise,
9:08 Canada was on the ballot
9:10 and Americans voted
9:12 for a good relationship with Canada.
9:15 American voters are also really smart
9:17 and they get that tariffs and like a trade war with Canada
9:21 is not only kind of ridiculous, but actually that it hurts them.
9:26 And I think especially in the border states,
9:28 Americans are seeing it's raising prices.
9:32 It's maybe hurting my business,
9:34 partly because I'm not getting those Canadian tourists anymore,
9:37 partly because, you know,
9:38 about 60% of Canada's exports
9:41 to the United States are intermediate goods.
9:44 So tariffs on Canada
9:46 are quite literally a tax on U.S. manufacturers.
9:50 I think Americans saw all of that.
9:53 And for me, a moment when I thought,
9:55 you know, maybe this is all going to work out
9:58 is when Obama started talking about Canada in his speeches.
10:03 And, you know, he would say, like,
10:05 "This fight with Canada, isn't it ridiculous?"
10:08 And those were his biggest laugh lines.
10:11 So I'm now cautiously optimistic.
10:13 Westin: Pulling back more broadly
10:15 from U.S.-Canada to the world, as it were,
10:18 you served in various very senior positions in Canada,
10:21 including as foreign minister.
10:23 What does an election like this mean
10:26 for a world leader like Donald Trump
10:27 as he sits down with his counterparts,
10:30 whether they're, they're adversaries
10:32 or they're friends and allies,
10:33 how does it change potentially his position with them?
10:35 And could it change our policy?
10:38 -I think, David, it weakens Donald Trump,
10:41 and I think it strengthens America.
10:44 I think prior to these midterms,
10:47 there was a real question mark around the world
10:51 about whether American democracy was going to endure.
10:55 There was a real question about was it going to be possible
10:59 to have a fair and uncontested vote?
11:03 And remember, of course,
11:04 the reaction to the presidential elections.
11:06 So the fact that there was this blue tsunami
11:12 and that it was recognized by Republicans,
11:16 I think means something really important,
11:19 which is, you know,
11:20 a lot of the world,
11:22 especially America's Democratic allies,
11:24 had been losing faith in America as a democracy,
11:29 as a leader of the free world.
11:31 And I think this vote means a lot of us,
11:35 you know, America's traditional friends,
11:37 are thinking actually American democracy works.
11:41 Westin: Coming up, what does it take to get
11:43 an NFL stadium to move to your town,
11:46 and is it worth it?
11:47 We go to Illinois and Indiana to see what each state
11:50 is doing to keep its beloved team.
11:55 Westin: This is a story about thinking with your heart.
11:58 Pretty much every city in the U.S.
12:00 would love to be home to an NFL team.
12:03 And there's plenty to tug at the heartstrings of fans
12:06 and politicians,
12:07 especially if we're talking about the Chicago Bears,
12:10 the seventh most valuable team in the league
12:13 and one of the original NFL franchises
12:15 dating back to 1920.
12:25 -When you talk to Chicago Bears fans,
12:27 one thing that they are very, very positive about
12:30 is that they want to make sure
12:32 that their hometown team stays here.
12:35 -So for the Bears, why not Indiana?
12:38 Why not Hammond?
12:39 It's 20 minutes from downtown Chicago.
12:42 -It's different, first of all,
12:43 because there's an emotional content to it
12:45 as well as a business content.
12:47 Of course, I'm rooting for Indiana.
12:49 Westin: The Bears lease at Soldier Field
12:51 ends in 2033,
12:53 and there are 3 major contenders for its next home.
12:56 One, a new stadium on the current site
12:58 in downtown Chicago,
13:00 one in the suburb of Arlington Heights,
13:02 and one across the border in Hammond, Indiana.
13:06 It's not just the emotional tug
13:07 that's in play.
13:09 It's also claims, hopes and even promises
13:12 of revenue
13:13 fom the stadium itself
13:14 and from surrounding commercial development
13:16 and the taxes it could bring,
13:18 along with an up to $5 billion all in price tag.
13:22 -When you look at stadium economics,
13:23 the question can't just be how much money
13:25 is going to be spent here.
13:27 I think the money, the conversation
13:28 has to be incremental.
13:30 How much of this money would not be spent in Illinois
13:32 if this stadium was not here?
13:34 And we have to have an honest conversation
13:35 about that.
13:36 Westin: State Representative Kam Buckner
13:38 represents Chicago's 26th District,
13:41 where he hopes the Bears will remain
13:43 and build a new enclosed arena.
13:45 If a person spends 100 bucks at Soldier Field on a Sunday,
13:48 well models also tell us that they're going to...
13:50 that if they didn't go to that football game,
13:52 they would spend that same amount of money
13:54 at a restaurant in Chicago's South Loop neighborhood
13:56 next week, right?
13:57 Is that money fungible? Is it transferable?
14:00 Those are real questions we have to have.
14:01 -The opportunity that we're facing right now
14:04 is just tremendous.
14:05 Westin: Tom McDermott is the mayor of Hammond,
14:07 Indiana.
14:08 - Hammond gets a brand new city.
14:10 First off, it took a lot of foresight
14:12 to get here.
14:13 We put together all that acreage.
14:15 I've been mayor 23 years now,
14:16 and it took us well over a decade
14:19 to assemble all the land that we're talking about right now.
14:21 And we had no idea the Chicago Bears
14:23 were going to be interested one day.
14:25 We were doing it just to clean up our city
14:26 and to give us better access to the Wolf Lake area.
14:29 And along comes the Chicago Bears.
14:32 It's an incredible story.
14:33 We're going to get the things that Chicago has
14:36 and Chicago takes for granted. And it's going to be new.
14:38 Westin: After serving as President George W. Bush's
14:41 budget director,
14:42 Mitch Daniels returned to Indiana
14:44 to become its governor
14:45 and presided over the building
14:47 of the Colts' new Lucas Oil Stadium
14:49 in downtown Indianapolis.
14:51 -I think you really have to zoom in on hard
14:56 and press on the...
14:57 on the projections of the new activity
15:00 that will be generated.
15:02 Now, as I said, in the Indianapolis context,
15:04 very wisely,
15:06 this was all part of a convention center,
15:08 an expanded convention capability,
15:11 you could forecast and as a matter of fact,
15:13 they have beaten the forecast
15:15 for how many, you know,
15:17 new visitors would come and so forth.
15:19 And I frequently pointed out to people,
15:23 more than 90% of the events in that building
15:26 would not be football games.
15:28 So there were other revenue sources.
15:29 And where that's the case,
15:31 I think the argument for the public stepping in
15:34 can be rationalized on a business case basis.
15:38 But there are many other stadia I've seen built
15:42 where it didn't look to me
15:43 as though that sort of business judgment
15:45 had been brought to bear.
15:46 Westin: You don't have to look too far
15:48 to find stadiums built without the business judgment
15:51 Daniels is talking about.
15:52 For every successful project like SoFi Stadium,
15:55 in Los Angeles,
15:57 there's at least one Edward Jones in St. Louis,
15:59 which ended up suing the Rams' owner
16:01 after the team moved back to Los Angeles
16:03 and it left the city and state
16:05 with large bond payments they couldn't recoup.
16:08 How is a stadium like another big business deal?
16:12 And how is it different?
16:14 -It's different.
16:16 First of all, because the...
16:18 there's an emotional content to it,
16:20 as well as business content.
16:22 And I think that has to be factored in
16:23 by the decision makers.
16:25 But the primary reason it's different
16:26 is because too often politicians are making the decision.
16:29 And nothing more dangerous than turning a politician loose
16:33 with a public checkbook in a situation like this.
16:37 Incentives, of course, are to do whatever it takes,
16:40 cut the ribbon, bask in the glory,
16:42 and then pass the bill on to somebody,
16:44 2 or 3 down the line.
16:46 The public should be very, very guarded
16:49 about this.
16:50 To me, there are certain rules, no cash,
16:53 and that's sometimes...
16:54 sometimes politicians have forked over cash.
16:56 I just think that's unconscionable.
16:58 If you want to help with the financing,
16:59 where the prospect is very strong
17:02 that it'll get paid back through taxes
17:05 and new economic activity,
17:08 then... then maybe.
17:10 The cost has escalated, you know,
17:12 beyond anything that we saw.
17:15 -There are a lot of folks who walk up on the street
17:17 or who will text and tweet and say,
17:18 "Just give them what they want.
17:20 "Give them what they want,
17:21 "because we don't want them to leave."
17:22 To us, we believe that there is a balance here
17:24 that we can be smart
17:26 and fiscally responsible to the people we represent,
17:30 but also put together a package
17:32 that works for this organization to keep the football club here.
17:35 But here's the rub.
17:36 That same kind of preponderance of people
17:38 who say that we want the Bears to remain in Illinois
17:40 also say, "But we don't want to pay for it."
17:42 So that is the delicate balance that you find
17:44 when you deal with sports and economics.
17:47 And the question now is about creating
17:48 the economic value to one, keep the team here,
17:52 but also to make sure that we're not putting
17:53 the taxpayers on the hook.
17:54 An economic development should be competitive,
17:57 but it should not be desperate.
17:59 Westin: Making a sound decision on the Bears new stadium home
18:02 is all the more difficult
18:03 because there's something of an auction going on
18:06 with 3 top bidders in the race.
18:08 I'm not aware that there was an auction
18:10 involved in Indianapolis and Lucas Oil Stadium.
18:13 I once worked for a really good CEO
18:15 who said he'd never won an auction
18:17 and never would because the last 10% is ego.
18:21 How do you avoid that?
18:22 -It's especially, I think, risky in this case
18:25 because there is this emotional component.
18:28 I've seen this show a few times, not in the sports context,
18:31 but we had many occasions when I was in public life
18:34 in which a business was dissatisfied in Illinois
18:39 and the environment was very different over here.
18:41 Some of them, many of them came across the line.
18:43 Others auctioned themselves off and leveraged the lower taxes,
18:48 the better regulatory environment,
18:51 the better infrastructure and so forth, in Indiana,
18:54 to get a deal out of the government of Illinois.
18:56 -The projections are done mostly by the state,
18:58 the ones financing this,
18:59 but the implementation of the taxes
19:01 are going to be up to people like myself.
19:04 Here in Hammond, we're going to be expected
19:05 to pass the admissions tax,
19:07 12% on every ticket sold,
19:09 and that has to be implemented by me as mayor
19:12 and the Hammond City Council.
19:13 Locally here in Lake County,
19:14 there has to be a food and beverage tax passed,
19:16 1% that's going to pay for the debt on this.
19:20 And for hotel stays,
19:21 the rate's going to go from 5% to 10%
19:23 on the innkeeper's tax to help finance this debt.
19:26 Westin: My understanding, Mayor,
19:27 is that the proceeds of those taxes
19:29 will go to pay off the bonds,
19:31 to basically pay the money due on the bonds.
19:33 What happens if there's a shortfall?
19:35 Who's left holding the bag?
19:36 -It would be the state of Indiana
19:38 if there was a shortfall.
19:39 They're financing this project.
19:41 And let's be honest,
19:42 Hammond had to partner with the state.
19:44 And when I say partner,
19:45 we're expected to basically hand over
19:48 the entire acreage
19:50 that we're talking about under state control.
19:53 There's going to be an authority put together,
19:54 a 3-member board.
19:56 Hammond will have one appointment to that board,
19:57 but two-thirds of that board is going to be run
19:59 by the state of Indiana
20:00 because they're putting the money forward
20:02 and they expect to get paid back.
20:04 And I would complain if I thought Hammond
20:06 was being treated any differently
20:08 than Indianapolis was
20:09 when they brought the Colts to town.
20:10 But this is the exact model that they used
20:13 to help bring, you know,
20:14 to help build Lucas Oil Stadium in Indianapolis.
20:17 So it's consistent.
20:18 Westin: For their part,
20:19 the contenders for the new stadium
20:21 think they can strike the right balance
20:23 between giving the Bears a good deal
20:25 and getting their money's worth.
20:27 -It's not our job to say,
20:28 "You need to go to Arlington Heights"
20:30 or "You need to stay in Chicago" or "You need to go to Evanston"
20:32 or any type of town or municipality
20:34 here in the state.
20:35 Our job is to lay forth an entree of options
20:38 here in the state of Illinois
20:39 to give the Bears the runway they need
20:42 to make the right fiduciary responsibility
20:44 for their organization.
20:46 Westin: When you look at the Chicago Bears stadium
20:48 and the pluses and minuses,
20:50 or really the costs and the revenues.
20:53 It's one thing to have to write a check.
20:55 It can look at least different
20:57 if you're making tax concessions.
20:59 How do you make sure that you really fully evaluate
21:01 the tax concessions,
21:02 because in a sense giving a tax concession
21:04 is writing a check.
21:05 -In many ways. So I think when you...
21:07 These are all numbers that you got to calculate.
21:09 But the number that you have to start with
21:10 for me is zero,
21:11 and zero is what happens if nothing happens.
21:15 What does it look like if we do nothing.
21:18 Westin: This is obviously Hammond versus Chicago
21:20 versus Arlington Heights.
21:24 It's also Indiana against Illinois.
21:26 So as you stack up that competition
21:29 what gives Indiana the advantage.
21:32 -The Bears will make far more money
21:34 by coming to Hammond Indiana than anywhere else in Illinois.
21:37 No doubt about it.
21:38 And so I've been asked the question,
21:40 "Well, mayor, what if... what if Illinois offers
21:43 "the Bears $1.5 billion, like Indiana is?"
21:46 And I said, OK, well that'd be great,
21:47 in year zero.
21:49 However in year 1 through 35
21:51 the Bears are going to lose money
21:52 every single year if they stay in Illinois
21:54 versus coming to Indiana
21:55 where you have property tax certainty
21:57 to the effect that we have our property taxes
21:59 enshrined in our Constitution.
22:01 Westin: A crucial point.
22:02 The Arlington plan's property tax relief
22:05 is long-term but not permanent.
22:08 A crucial detail for a stadium that will stand for decades.
22:11 When we talk about building an entire environment around,
22:15 what's going to be in that in your vision?
22:17 If you succeed in doing that, what's going to occupy that?
22:20 -The amenities that Chicago has,
22:22 I would love to see things like that up,
22:24 and up in my city, like a Ruth's Chris Steak House.
22:27 If I went to Ruth's Chris right now and said,
22:29 "I'd like you to open a location in Hammond"
22:32 they'd be nice about it, I'm sure,
22:33 but they'd say, "You know, Mayor,
22:34 "we're looking elsewhere."
22:36 But if we close a deal like this with the Chicago Bears
22:39 to get a Ruth's Chris is not such a stretch anymore.
22:44 Westin: The Bears choice of a new home
22:45 will have large repercussions for everyone concerned:
22:49 the franchise, the fans, the political officials,
22:52 the taxpayers
22:53 and two neighboring states.
22:56 Everyone involved says
22:57 they have to make the right decision,
23:00 but finding the balance of the heart and the mind
23:03 will not be easy.
23:04 -Of course I'm rooting for Indiana.
23:06 But with the proviso that I don't want us
23:10 to make a dumb deal to do it.
23:12 And I think the elements are there
23:15 and that there may well be, as I say,
23:19 a business case that makes this
23:21 a reasonable investment for the state.
23:24 So that that'd be the outcome I'm rooting for.
23:27 But as in all such matters
23:29 and first rule of life up to a point.
23:33 Westin: Up next,
23:34 as we age we need more caregivers than ever.
23:37 -America today is experiencing a huge growth
23:41 in the need for care.
23:42 Westin: But are we willing to pay for what we need?
23:49 Westin: This is a story about paying for what you need.
23:52 For much of American history the kinds of work people do
23:55 has changed.
23:57 Farmers moved into factories.
23:59 Factory workers into offices and services.
24:01 Now, as we face new changes coming from AI
24:05 and an aging population,
24:06 we are facing an increased opportunity
24:08 for caregivers,
24:10 jobs we badly need and should value,
24:13 but which may or may not provide the pay, stability,
24:16 and opportunity workers need to build a life around them.
24:19 Our special contributor Chrystia Freeland
24:21 tells us this story.
24:26 -For Jacqueline Lamar,
24:27 care work started with her own family.
24:29 -My great-grandmother had tooken sick,
24:32 and she had had a couple of strokes
24:35 and became sickly.
24:37 So we took shifts as a family taking care of her,
24:41 and we just decided that, you know,
24:43 this is what we're doing.
24:45 We had no experience, no training.
24:47 And we just did what we felt that was common sense to do.
24:52 -Eventually, Lamar turned that experience into a job.
24:56 -After taking a moment to gather myself
24:59 and my thoughts, I was like, you know what,
25:01 there are other grannies.
25:02 There are other grandmothers that need care.
25:06 And who's going to do it?
25:08 You know, somebody needs to care.
25:11 And why not me?
25:13 -But doing work she valued didn't mean it paid.
25:16 -It is very hard right now to support a family,
25:20 especially a single mom family,
25:23 on a caregiver salary today.
25:25 You have to take on basically two jobs
25:28 to support your family now just on a caregiver salary,
25:32 because the pay is so low right now.
25:34 -Lamar's experience points to a long-running tension
25:37 in the American labor market.
25:39 Demand is growing in parts of the economy
25:41 where the jobs are essential,
25:43 but don't pay well enough to fund a stable life.
25:46 And nowhere is that divide more apparent
25:49 than in caregiving.
25:50 -America today is experiencing a huge growth
25:54 in the need for care,
25:56 and that's across the lifespan,
25:58 but particularly on the growing aging population
26:00 in our country.
26:02 Every single day, an unprecedented 11,400 people
26:06 turn 65,
26:08 and we're all living longer,
26:10 and about 70% of us
26:11 will need long-term care in our country.
26:14 And we just don't have the workforce in place
26:17 to support that.
26:19 -The demand is there.
26:21 But as Ai-jen Poo,
26:22 president of the National Domestic Workers Alliance,
26:25 sees it, the bigger question
26:27 is whether the economics of the jobs
26:29 are strong enough to attract workers
26:32 and keep them.
26:33 -The median income for a home care worker
26:35 in America is about $23,000 per year,
26:39 which is impossible to support a family on
26:42 and sustain and,
26:44 and so if we made these good jobs,
26:46 this could be a huge opportunity for economic mobility
26:50 and real, yeah, access to good jobs
26:54 for workers for the future.
26:57 And so that is the opportunity,
26:59 but it's also a challenge because we're not there yet.
27:02 -That tension has surfaced before.
27:05 As the American economy has changed,
27:07 workers have repeatedly moved into new jobs.
27:10 Some of those shifts created new pathways
27:13 into the middle class.
27:15 Others did not.
27:17 Harvard economist Larry Katz
27:18 has spent much of his career studying those changes,
27:22 including one of the country's earliest big shifts,
27:25 as workers moved off the farm and into an industrial economy.
27:30 -19th century, the vast majority of the workforce
27:33 worked in agriculture,
27:35 and we had rising demand for clerks,
27:39 for engineer types,
27:42 for a wide range of skilled, you know, manufacturing jobs,
27:46 and service sector jobs.
27:49 -In that transition,
27:50 many of the jobs workers found offered something important,
27:53 a chance to earn more and move up.
27:56 -As the wages of workers in such occupations
28:00 rose with the big demand from industry,
28:03 what you saw was a grassroots movement
28:06 in the U.S. to provide access to high schools.
28:09 Town and city after city built them and hired teachers.
28:15 And in some sense,
28:16 the race between education and technology
28:19 was a very even match in this period.
28:22 The next generation, you know, had the skills
28:25 and were able to move out of the farm
28:27 into the new industry jobs.
28:30 -How are we doing with the subsequent waves?
28:34 -You know, in the mid 20th century,
28:37 you know, 90% of kids, you know,
28:40 had higher incomes than their parents
28:42 if you measured them both at age 30.
28:44 Today, it's more like a coin flip
28:47 in terms of the share of children
28:48 who end up with higher earnings than their parents.
28:51 It's, you know, much less upward mobility.
28:53 Some of that is slower productivity growth,
28:58 but not a lot.
28:59 Most of it is the distribution of income has become
29:03 much more skewed and unequal.
29:05 And the opportunities for moving up seem
29:08 to have been not, we have not done as good
29:11 a job in investing.
29:12 And you've seen since 1980,
29:16 a large increase in inequality
29:18 and in some measures, much slower growth
29:21 than the real living standards of typical workers,
29:25 even though overall productivity
29:27 and those who are at the top have done very well.
29:32 -But history also shows that jobs offering strong wages,
29:35 benefits and security
29:37 don't necessarily start out that way.
29:40 Manufacturing, the sector that eventually helped millions
29:43 of Americans build a middle class life,
29:47 once looked very different.
29:49 It took unionization
29:52 and some pretty intense political battles
29:56 to turn blue collar manufacturing jobs
29:59 into, quote unquote, good jobs with high wages,
30:03 with benefits, with security.
30:06 Is it going to take some of that political pressure,
30:10 including unionization,
30:12 to turn care jobs into good jobs?
30:14 -Absolutely, it will.
30:16 It is actually striking the parallels
30:18 to the Second Industrial Revolution,
30:21 where manufacturing jobs used to be
30:24 dangerous sweatshop jobs
30:26 that were poverty wage jobs.
30:28 A lot of immigrants did that work.
30:30 And through, as you say,
30:32 a combination of union organizing and bold policy.
30:36 Right?
30:37 The New Deal really enabled an unprecedented era
30:41 of shared prosperity in our country,
30:44 the largest on ramp to the middle class
30:45 in the history of the world,
30:47 with manufacturing as an anchor sector
30:50 for that transformation.
30:52 And I see a very similar role for the care sector now
30:57 if we invest in these jobs which are surging
31:00 in demand and growth,
31:02 if we make them good jobs
31:04 and there's great organizing,
31:06 political pressure
31:07 and bold leadership.
31:10 What FDR did with the New Deal was really about
31:13 a set of promises to the workers of this country
31:16 that we will be there
31:19 when you have done-- taken responsibility
31:22 for your work and your family.
31:24 And it's not enough.
31:25 The federal government is going to be there
31:28 and to make sure that you don't fall.
31:31 -Care differs from manufacturing in one key way.
31:35 Factories could raise wages as workers produced more.
31:39 Care doesn't scale like that.
31:41 And much of the bill is paid by the government.
31:44 That makes care workers' pay, in large part,
31:48 a public budget decision.
31:50 So it's so interesting that you mention the role
31:53 of the government,
31:55 because one of the features of jobs in the care economy is
31:59 they tend to be, they're more likely to be
32:02 jobs that are in the public sector.
32:05 And the public sector is under great fiscal pressure.
32:09 The debt is at record levels.
32:12 The deficit is high.
32:14 How do you find the money to make
32:19 care jobs good jobs?
32:21 And does it mean that there has to be
32:24 a willingness to raise taxes?
32:26 -It may mean that.
32:27 And it also means that there has to be
32:29 tax fairness, I think, across the economy.
32:33 We keep cutting taxes for the wealthiest among us
32:38 and also cutting services
32:41 for the people who need it the most in our country.
32:43 And that pattern is putting us deeper and deeper,
32:46 both in debt at a fiscal level.
32:50 I think we need to be thinking about care
32:53 as a shared responsibility.
32:55 And the architecture of responsibility should be
32:59 borne both by families,
33:01 which it currently is in an outsized way,
33:04 but also by our cities,
33:06 our states, our federal government,
33:07 because honestly,
33:09 families are doing the very best they can.
33:11 And it is not enough for them to bear on their own.
33:15 -For Katz, the lessons
33:17 from past transitions still hold.
33:19 -There are jobs in the care sector
33:22 that I think, you know, could be attractive.
33:25 But I think a big issue in the care sector
33:28 is that it replicates
33:31 the inequality of the economy.
33:34 You know, a high-level specialized nurse is
33:36 a very lucrative one, a physician is,
33:39 but a home health aide,
33:41 someone who works as a certified nursing aide
33:44 in a nursing home, those are very important jobs.
33:48 They're not very well compensated
33:50 in the United States.
33:52 Creating some more pathways for people to mix
33:57 doing those jobs with essential, with the possibility
34:01 of moving up and becoming a registered nurse,
34:05 a physical therapist, the more lucrative,
34:07 I think is a very important issue in the U.S.
34:10 Care jobs are not going to go away,
34:12 but we don't want, we're not going to be
34:14 very successful displacing people out of office
34:18 and, you know, manufacturing work
34:21 into low-paid care jobs
34:23 that don't seem to have a pathway to higher paid jobs.
34:27 -And for Jacqueline, making care a better job
34:29 starts with something more immediate.
34:31 -If they would raise the wages that we're paid,
34:36 we could have a substantial life set up
34:40 for our families, as well as feel better
34:44 about going to work every day.
34:46 And it would definitely clear up a lot of burnout
34:49 that nurses and caregivers feel
34:52 when they're at work.
34:54 At some point, we're all going to need care.
34:57 No matter how you look at it,
34:59 no matter how you flip the coin,
35:01 we're all aging.
35:03 -Most economic transitions
35:04 create new kinds of work.
35:07 But history shows
35:08 that creating jobs and creating opportunity
35:11 are not always the same thing.
35:13 As jobs like caregiving become a bigger part
35:16 of the American economy,
35:18 that distinction is getting harder to ignore.
35:20 And so is the question of whether workers
35:22 like Jacqueline can build a future around them.
35:29 Westin: Coming up, we go to the country that spends
35:31 more on weddings relative to income
35:33 than anywhere else:
35:34 India, where families start saving from the moment
35:37 a daughter is born.
35:39 What do they get for their money
35:41 and what do they spend it on?
35:48 Westin: This is a story about upfront investment.
35:51 People all over the world invest
35:53 over the course of their lifetimes
35:54 in their families,
35:55 in their marriages and children and houses.
35:58 But in India, much of that investment comes
36:00 at the very beginning, in the weddings themselves,
36:03 which are so big, so expensive, so extravagant,
36:07 that a meaningful portion
36:08 of India's overall economic activity
36:10 comes from its wedding industry alone.
36:15 -I think I really like this picture.
36:17 This was one of the traditional ceremonies.
36:20 Westin: When New Jersey couple Deep Haria and Noopur Dedhia
36:24 returned home to India to get married,
36:26 they wanted a small, intimate affair.
36:30 - We had about 350 to 400 guests.
36:34 -We had a small wedding.
36:35 We both didn't want a lot of guests,
36:37 so we were sure that we don't want
36:39 to cross like 500.
36:41 -Yeah, traditionally, you know, it's very easy
36:44 if the bride and groom are from the same city
36:47 and it's a metropolitan city
36:48 where the wedding is happening, like let's say Mumbai
36:51 or Delhi or any of these areas.
36:53 The guest list could easily surpass
36:55 1,000 attendees and that's normal
36:58 for Indian weddings.
37:00 Westin: While their wedding may have been small
37:03 by India's standards, it was still a significant event,
37:06 underscoring the importance of weddings in Indian society.
37:10 -A wedding is a very, very large event for the family.
37:14 Westin: Neeraj Dhawan is a wedding planner and chairman
37:17 of the India Weddings Industry Association.
37:20 So how did you get started in this business?
37:22 -So it's a long and a funny story.
37:25 So I was doing, so we started off
37:27 being an events manager.
37:28 There was a gentleman, he came up
37:30 and said, "I'd like to take you to my events.
37:33 I would like you to do my daughter's wedding."
37:36 That's how it started.
37:38 Westin: Weddings are very important in India.
37:40 Perhaps more important in India than in any other country
37:43 around the world.
37:44 Why do you think that is?
37:46 Why are weddings so important?
37:48 -So wedding, you know, so in an Indian scenario,
37:52 there are three important things
37:53 which are part of everybody's life.
37:56 One, when a child is born,
37:58 so that is the starting of the family.
38:00 Second is to buy a house for the family.
38:04 Third is to do a wedding for the children.
38:07 So weddings has been the oldest form of celebrations
38:09 in India.
38:11 We are the oldest living civilization in the world.
38:14 You know, we go back much, much, 3000 BC
38:17 in terms of what we are.
38:19 So marriage has been there always, all around.
38:21 And in India, the aspect is that we have many cultures.
38:24 So a wedding in Kashmir would be different.
38:27 Weddings in Tamil Nadu would be different.
38:30 A wedding in Punjab would be different.
38:31 A wedding in Goa would be different.
38:33 But traditions are deep-rooted.
38:36 Westin: The importance of the Indian wedding
38:38 is reflected in the economics.
38:40 Of the country's 2025 nominal GDP of $4 trillion,
38:44 $130 billion
38:46 or 3.25%
38:48 came just from weddings.
38:50 And the average wedding costs about 5 times per capita GDP,
38:54 far more than other major countries.
38:57 Sonalde Desai is a professor and director
38:59 of the National Center of Applied Economic Research
39:02 in New Delhi.
39:04 -So the worldwide fertility has been falling,
39:06 particularly in Europe, U.S., and so on.
39:08 And usually when we think in terms of Western countries,
39:12 we say that, well, people are much more concerned
39:15 about themselves, their own lives.
39:17 They don't want to invest in children.
39:19 Taking care of children is a lot of work, and so on.
39:22 And so what has been happening is, actually,
39:25 there has been a decline in marriage.
39:26 And along with it is decline in childbearing,
39:29 including East Asia, where we see decline in marriage.
39:32 India, actually, is very different.
39:34 Marriage remains the big portion of people's life.
39:38 Virtually, every Indian woman gets married.
39:40 You know, 97% of Indian women are married
39:42 by the age 30.
39:43 So family remains central in India.
39:47 Westin: 95% of women under 30 get married.
39:53 Weddings are a very large part of the Indian culture,
39:57 I think larger than any other country
39:59 in the world I'm aware of.
40:00 -Probably. Westin: Why?
40:02 -I think there are two things that are involved.
40:05 First, arranged marriages still remain major in India.
40:10 Even today,
40:11 roughly about 93% to 94% of marriages
40:16 are arranged by parents.
40:18 Increasingly, women and men get asked about who they want
40:21 to marry, and they are given a choice of partners
40:23 from which they would make a selection.
40:25 But the marriages still remain arranged,
40:28 which also means this is a family affair.
40:30 And there is this notion of, you know, yes,
40:33 this is sort of family's opportunity
40:35 to make their mark within the society.
40:38 There is also a sense that, you know,
40:42 you somehow need to arrange for a wedding
40:45 in which there is a sort of a certain level
40:47 of show or conspicuous consumption,
40:50 which makes sure that your family status
40:52 looks better to the other party,
40:54 to other relatives, and so on.
40:56 So, you know, I was just having a conversation with my driver
40:58 who's trying to arrange for his daughter's wedding,
41:00 and planning to spend about 4 years' worth
41:04 of his salary on this wedding.
41:06 And so I said, you know,
41:07 what are you going to get out of this?
41:09 You know, why not give the money to the girl and the groom
41:11 and let them make their life?
41:14 And he said, "But no, you see,
41:16 I have been to everybody's wedding.
41:18 Now it is my turn to return it.
41:19 If I don't do it, it will look bad in my society
41:22 and my caste.
41:24 Also, it might affect my ability to marry off
41:26 my younger child."
41:27 And so that's where you are.
41:30 Westin: When you're spending 4 times your annual salary
41:33 on a wedding,
41:34 that money has to come from somewhere.
41:36 Where does it come from in the household budget?
41:39 I mean, what does not get spent?
41:41 You know, first thing I think is that the moment anybody has
41:45 a daughter, they start saving.
41:47 There is a sort of a sense that,
41:49 okay, this is going to be what we'll be spending on.
41:52 There is a fair amount of borrowing that happens.
41:54 But really, I think what it is is
41:56 that parents ultimately end up having very little savings
42:00 for their old age.
42:02 Westin: So where does the money go?
42:04 Catering, events, and photography
42:06 are all big categories,
42:08 but the biggest is jewelry,
42:10 and particularly gold.
42:12 -When a girl is born, usually parents do tend
42:15 to accumulate some gold as and when they can.
42:19 So, like, the preparation starts way ahead than you think,
42:23 and they don't have that in mind, but it just happens.
42:27 Westin: Households in India hold almost 35,000 tons of gold,
42:32 more than the central banks of the U.S.,
42:34 Germany, France, and China combined.
42:37 And a good portion of those 35,000 tons
42:41 are worn or otherwise taken by brides to their new homes.
42:45 -Most of it, 90% of it, is in the form of ornaments.
42:50 Westin: George Alexander Muthoot
42:51 is the billionaire Executive Vice Chairman
42:53 of the Muthoot Conglomerate.
42:55 Their finance arm is India's biggest gold lender.
42:59 -Sometimes they come to us for purchasing gold.
43:02 "My daughter's marriage is there,
43:04 I want to purchase
43:05 200 grams of gold." So they take a loan from us.
43:08 Purging the old jewelry.
43:10 But then,
43:11 other than that, there is lot of marriage
43:13 expenses also.
43:14 A lot of marriage expenses for the functions, etc.
43:18 For that, they also take.
43:19 So just like you take for your business,
43:21 some people take for their marriage.
43:23 It's also an expense.
43:25 So if you don't give them the money,
43:26 he will take the money from his business.
43:28 Because he has to conduct the daughter's marriage
43:30 or son's marriage for expenses.
43:32 So either he takes it from his business,
43:34 or he takes it as a separate loan
43:36 without affecting his business.
43:37 So in that way, for marriages, etc.,
43:41 there is people
43:42 who would like to take a gold loan
43:45 for the marriage expenses.
43:47 Westin: Gold now accounts for about 11%
43:50 of outstanding consumer loans in India,
43:52 and big investors are piling in.
43:55 What was once a last resort loan option
43:57 has now become a mainstream source of credit,
44:00 making the gold given at a wedding
44:02 not just an ornament, but a valuable financial asset.
44:06 -One very interesting fact about gold loan
44:09 is that for taking it - availing a gold loan,
44:12 you do not need to have a credit score.
44:14 Because the loan is given
44:16 mainly based on the collateral, which is the gold.
44:21 We don't look at this repayment capacity.
44:24 We don't look at this repayment history.
44:26 We don't look at this credit score, CIBIL score, etc.
44:30 So, it's a very easy, quick loan.
44:33 The other loans and all other loans,
44:36 you need a lot of paperwork.
44:38 You need a lot of forms, etc. to be filled.
44:40 You need to convince the person
44:42 that you are taking the money for some purpose
44:44 and that you will be returning it
44:46 month on month, etc.
44:48 All those things are not there.
44:49 It's a very convenient loan.
44:52 The convenience is the most important factor
44:54 and the second is a trust factor.
44:56 They should trust me with their gold.
44:59 Because they're giving me 100 or 120 rupees worth of gold
45:02 and taking only 75 rupees from me.
45:05 So, he needs to trust me more
45:07 further than I trust you.
45:08 So, when somebody goes for other type
45:11 of a personal loan or a house loan
45:14 or a business loan, etc.,
45:15 he has to convince the bank
45:17 about the repayment capacity, etc.
45:20 Westin: There is no doubt that an Indian wedding
45:22 is the occasion for a great celebration.
45:25 -So, my favorite memory from, like, all the events
45:28 was ring ceremony, where we exchanged our rings
45:30 in the rain, very unexpected,
45:33 not the location or the decor we had thought of.
45:36 It was very beautiful and magical.
45:38 Sometimes, like, unexpected and sudden change of plans
45:42 turn out to be very beautiful and that was for me.
45:46 -I think for me, I had planned a surprise dance
45:49 for her on the music night,
45:52 but because of the rains, I couldn't perform it.
45:55 So, she had no idea about it.
45:57 So, on the day of the wedding,
45:59 when I first saw her,
46:01 when I first met her as part of the ceremony,
46:04 that's when I performed the surprise dance for her,
46:07 which she did not know.
46:09 You know, everyone thought that the bride
46:12 is going to dance on a certain song,
46:14 but, like, very last moment,
46:16 the song completely changed and it was a surprise.
46:20 But that celebration is very much part
46:22 of a major economic investment,
46:25 likely the largest a couple or family will ever make.
46:28 It's an investment that might have strong returns.
46:31 Fewer than 1% of Indians are divorced or separated
46:34 compared to around 14% in the U.S.
46:38 But it's also an investment meant to last
46:40 much longer than just about any other one
46:42 you can imagine.
46:44 Indeed, the way the Indian culture sees it,
46:47 it's meant to last an entire lifetime and then some.
46:50 -In our tradition,
46:52 and especially the Hindu tradition,
46:53 it says that you don't marry for one lifetime.
46:56 You get married for 7 lifetimes.
46:58 So, you have to choose your partner carefully
47:00 because you are getting the same for the next 7 years, yeah.
47:03 Not 7 years, 7 births.
47:06 So, that's how it works.
47:08 That's why the marriage is so important.
47:12 Westin: Next, what the Democratic sweep
47:14 in Congress could mean for the banks.
47:19 Westin: The overwhelming Democratic win
47:21 in the midterm elections
47:22 has the potential to affect just about every corner
47:25 of the country.
47:27 And that certainly includes the nation's banks,
47:29 starting with the likely promotion
47:31 of Senator Elizabeth Warren
47:32 to head the Senate Banking Committee.
47:34 Bill Dudley dealt with congressional oversight
47:36 for years when he served as president
47:39 of the New York Federal Reserve.
47:43 With the majority of the Democrats in the Senate
47:45 and the House,
47:47 how might that affect bank regulatory policy?
47:50 Because certainly, Elizabeth Warren may or may not,
47:52 but it looks like she might be chair
47:54 of the Senate Bank Committee.
47:55 She's been pretty activist, at least in what she said.
47:57 -Yeah, I think they're certainly going to look
47:59 at what the Federal Reserve is doing.
48:01 For example, the Federal Reserve has announced a bunch
48:02 of changes to the stress tests,
48:04 the capital stress tests that they propose each year.
48:07 Michelle Bowman has talked a lot about changing supervision
48:11 but I don't think those are really where the issues are
48:14 that Congress should be focusing on.
48:15 I think really the issues that I'd be focusing on,
48:17 if I was Elizabeth Warren,
48:18 is really the non-bank financial sector
48:21 and the rapid accumulation of debt to finance
48:23 the AI build-out, where that debt sits,
48:27 what terms and conditions are the debt,
48:29 what's the counterparty risk?
48:31 We don't have a lot of transparency
48:33 into what's actually happening there.
48:35 And I think that would be an area, if I were her,
48:36 I would be carving out.
48:38 Westin: Is there a potential systemic risk in all the money
48:40 being borrowed for AI?
48:41 Because you have to have a return on investment
48:43 at some point and there's enormous amounts
48:45 being borrowed.
48:46 -Yeah, I think there is a potential systemic,
48:48 certainly we should be examining it at a minimum.
48:51 And the reason why we need to be examining it
48:53 is the amount of money being borrowed
48:54 is a lot and there's a real question
48:56 whether people can generate an adequate return
48:59 on that investment.
49:00 So the total build-out people are talking about,
49:01 if everything is done,
49:03 is about $10 trillion through 2032.
49:05 You're probably going to need to generate $3 trillion
49:07 a year of revenue to get an adequate return
49:09 on that investment.
49:10 Look, I think AI is going to be really important.
49:12 I think it's going to be transformational,
49:14 but I also think it's going to be a bubble.
49:15 So if it is a bubble
49:17 and everything starts to deflate,
49:20 people are not going to get the returns they want.
49:22 There are going to be defaults.
49:23 And so you really want to ask yourself the question,
49:25 who has that obligation
49:28 and how do they act if the obligation turns out
49:30 to default?
49:33 Now, I think in the Great Financial Crisis,
49:34 we saw things go really bottoms up.
49:37 And part of the reason was
49:39 there were a lot of long-term illiquid assets
49:41 financed by very short-term liabilities.
49:44 So when the stress hit during the Great Financial Crisis,
49:48 the short-term funding evaporated
49:50 and then people actually had to sell
49:51 their long-term assets, which drove the price
49:53 of those assets down very, very sharply.
49:55 I think this time we don't have
49:57 that same kind of asset liability mismatch.
50:00 So I think that the risk of a fire sale of assets
50:03 is less.
50:05 So it makes me a little bit more comfortable
50:07 that it's not going to be like the GFC.
50:09 That said, we don't have visibility into this sector.
50:13 We don't really actually know who owes what to whom
50:15 and under what conditions.
50:17 So my first order of business would be
50:19 get a lot more information and get a lot more transparency
50:21 so people can make informed decisions.
50:23 Westin: Bill Dudley isn't alone in thinking
50:25 there may be a new chapter
50:26 in government oversight of banks
50:28 following the midterm elections.
50:30 Kathryn Judge of Columbia Law School
50:32 expects Congress to crack down
50:34 on financial firms under new leadership
50:36 of the Senate Banking Committee.
50:37 In the wake of the midterm elections,
50:39 President Trump's immediate response was,
50:41 "I have the veto pen, you know,
50:42 and you don't have a veto-proof majority
50:45 in the Congress," which is certainly true.
50:48 At the same time, there is such a thing
50:49 as congressional oversight,
50:51 and I wonder how that might work
50:53 with respect to banking regulation in particular.
50:55 -I expect it to be transformative.
50:57 So a core power that the Congress has
51:01 under the Constitution is
51:02 to engage in meaningful oversight
51:04 of the executive and administrative agencies.
51:07 One of the things we've seen
51:08 over the last couple of years
51:10 is very aggressive use
51:12 by the different financial regulatory bodies
51:15 of the authorities vested in them.
51:17 We've seen, for example, the comptroller of the currency
51:19 that regulates national banks getting very, very creative
51:23 in the issuance of national trust charters.
51:26 We've already seen Senator Warren very critical
51:29 of some of these decisions,
51:31 very concerned that the OCC
51:33 is actually taking actions that are inconsistent
51:36 with the underlying statutory scheme.
51:37 And again, a core role of Congress is to say,
51:39 are you following the law
51:41 or are you deviating from the law?
51:43 So I expect we'll see significant hearings
51:45 in ways that actually double on some
51:47 of the lawsuits that have already been filed,
51:49 challenging some of the regulatory actions
51:51 we've seen.
51:52 Westin: You mentioned Senator Warren,
51:54 who we don't know,
51:55 but it looks like she may well be the chair,
51:57 actually, of the Senate Banking Committee.
51:58 She is somebody who knows the area well,
52:00 has been very outspoken in the area, very critical
52:02 at times of what's going on in banking regulation.
52:06 So if in fact she becomes chair, what does that lead to?
52:10 -Very aggressive oversight
52:11 and a very different set of dynamics as well
52:13 for confirmations.
52:15 Another distinct role that the Senate plays
52:17 that the House doesn't play
52:19 is to confirm any appointees.
52:21 Right now that's getting a little press with questions
52:24 over whether Justice Alito is going to retire,
52:26 but I actually think it's going to be much more impactful
52:29 when it comes to the Federal Reserve
52:31 and financial regulation.
52:32 So for example, we've seen ongoing efforts
52:34 to fire Lisa Cook.
52:36 The upside of trying to remove Lisa Cook from office
52:39 really went down for President Trump
52:41 after last Tuesday because it means
52:44 he's not going to readily get the appointment
52:46 that he wants, even if that seat becomes open.
52:49 Westin: At the very least, it may be difficult
52:51 to have some of the deregulatory efforts
52:53 that were ongoing with the Trump administration.
52:56 But where, specifically, what areas would you expect
52:59 for Congress, and particularly
53:02 the Senate Banking Committee,
53:03 to have really an effect on oversight
53:05 in terms of what gets done in banking regulation?
53:08 -One of the areas that I expect we'll see
53:10 something relatively early on
53:11 is the Corporate Transparency Act.
53:13 It was an effort to bolster anti-money laundering laws.
53:18 It was passed in early 2021.
53:20 It was a bipartisan effort at the time.
53:22 It had been years in the making.
53:25 And the core idea is that we use the finance system
53:27 to try to combat illicit financing
53:30 and terrorist financing.
53:31 And right now we have very heavy burdens on banks,
53:34 but we make it very easy to create
53:36 shell corporations and shell trusts
53:38 so it doesn't create transparency
53:39 throughout the system.
53:41 And so the core idea behind the Corporate Transparency Act
53:43 is we need there to be a registry
53:46 of beneficial owners of all of these shell corporations,
53:48 and that's going to allow us
53:50 and allow law enforcement
53:51 and allow tax authorities
53:53 to do a much better job identifying illicit flows.
53:57 What this administration did is it exempted
53:59 all U.S. companies from this act.
54:01 And so we've already seen letters from Senator Warren
54:05 as well as some Republicans, like Senator Grassley,
54:08 saying, "Look, this regulation does not comport at all
54:12 with the underlying statutory scheme."
54:14 Westin: There is also continuing,
54:15 but maybe intensifying,
54:17 discussion about the relationship
54:19 between banks and non-bank financial institutions,
54:22 which includes some of the crypto organizations,
54:23 but it goes well beyond that.
54:25 What could Congress do in terms of oversight to affect that?
54:29 -So that's going to be one of the areas
54:31 that, again, is quite significant.
54:32 So we've seen a lot of different efforts,
54:35 both in securities regulation
54:36 and market regulation as well
54:38 as in banking regulation,
54:39 to facilitate fintechs,
54:41 banking as a service,
54:43 and the crypto industry, generally speaking.
54:45 One of the big issues that we saw in the past election
54:48 were concerns about corruption.
54:49 Crypto has been one of the mechanisms
54:51 through which I think many people are concerned
54:53 that the Trump family
54:55 and others might be enriching themselves.
54:57 And that is the target that Senator Warren
54:59 would love to hit on.
55:00 So I expect we'll see significant oversight,
55:03 particularly in areas where, again,
55:04 it looks like regulators have gone beyond
55:07 what Congress allows them to do.
55:09 Westin: One of the things that we've been talking about,
55:10 certainly since the Great Financial Crisis,
55:12 is reserves, particularly of the very large banks,
55:14 the too-big-to-fail banks.
55:16 Do you expect that may be affected
55:18 by the shift in Congress?
55:20 -It could be.
55:21 I mean, there's a couple of different things
55:23 going on there, right? So one, there's been
55:24 a whole host of deregulatory efforts
55:26 with respect to stress testing
55:28 and Basel III implementation.
55:32 I expect we'll see significant criticism.
55:34 I don't know how much that will slow down
55:37 the deregulation that has been underway.
55:40 There are some other changes
55:42 that I think have been less controversial.
55:44 So some of the changes with liquidity regulation
55:48 are really an effort to address
55:49 some of the problems we saw in 2023.
55:51 We saw in 2023 that banks were not ready to use
55:55 the discount window.
55:56 It was operationally not fit for purpose.
55:58 They'd really come to rely on this other lender
56:01 of second-to-last resort, the federal home loan banks.
56:04 And as a result, they didn't have the collateral,
56:06 they didn't have the capacity to borrow
56:08 from the discount window when they really needed to.
56:11 So some of the more modest changes are,
56:13 how can we just learn from past experience?
56:18 Westin: That does it for us here at "Wall Street Week".
56:20 I'm David Westin.
56:21 See you next week for more stories of capitalism.
All Airports Are Ground Stopped Until Further Notice: FAA full transcript
0:10 >> THIS IS "BALANCE OF POWER" LIVE FROM WASHINGTON, D.C.
0:17 JOE: TONIGHT, GROUNDED, BREAKING KNOW, THE FAA ISSUING A
0:19 NATIONWIDE GROUND STOP FOR ALL AIRPORTS DUE TO WHAT TERMS
0:25 EXTRAORDINARY CIRCUMSTANCES, AND FOR REASONS OF SAFETY.
0:28 THE TRANSPORTATION SECRETARY NOBLY MADE A COMMUNICATION ISSUE
0:30 IMPACTING ALL AIR ROUTE TRAFFIC CONTROL CENTERS.
0:34 WE WILL HAVE THE LATEST AND TALK ABOUT HOW THIS IS IMPACTING
0:35 AIRLINE STOCKS AFTER HOURS. PLUS, THE KNIVES ARE OUT,
0:40 FALLOUT FROM JENSEN HUANG'S OUSTER AT NVIDIA BRINGS NEW
0:44 ACCUSATIONS THAT COMMERCE SECRETARY HOWARD LUTNICK DID NOT
0:46 DO ENOUGH TO STOP THE CHIPS FROM GETTING INTO CHINA WITH NVIDIA
0:51 STOCK SUFFERING ITS WORST WEEK IN MORE THAN 18 MONTHS.
0:54 WE WILL BRING A NEW REPORTING FROM BLOOMBERG ABOUT HIS FINAL
0:56 HOURS AT THE HELM. AND SENATE LEADER CHUCK SCHUMER
1:01 LOPEZ SENATOR CHRIS VAN HOLLEN IN THE FACE WERE LEADERSHIP IN
1:02 THE NEW CONGRESS. WE WILL TALK TO OUR POLITICAL
1:06 PANEL ABOUT THE FIRST FORMAL CHALLENGE TO SCHUMER'S
1:08 LEADERSHIP. FROM OUR WASHINGTON STUDIOS TO
1:12 OUR AUDIENCES WORLDWIDE, WELCOME TO "BALANCE OF POWER."
1:16 I AM JOE MATHIEU ALONGSIDE KAILEY LEINZ.
1:21 KAILEY: YOU WANT TO GO TO MARKWAYNE MULLIN WHO IS BRIEFING
1:22 THE PRESS. HE SAYS THIS GROUND STOP IS NOT
1:24 DUE TO A THREAT. >> OUTAGE AS OF RIGHT NOW.
1:30 >> YOU ARE SAYING THERE IS NO INDICATION YET THAT THIS WAS A
1:33 CYBERATTACK. DOES THAT MEAN THAT WE HAVE NOT
1:38 SEEN THE EVIDENCE AND IT'S POSSIBLE THIS COULD BE EITHER A
1:41 CYBERATTACK OR SOME KIND OF AI INTRUSION?
1:44 >> WE DON'T WANT TO GET AHEAD OF OURSELVES.
1:48 ANY TIME LIKE THIS HAPPENS -- LAST TIME I BELIEVE WE HAD A
1:50 NATIONAL GROUND STOPPAGE WAS 9/11.
1:56 THROUGH DHS, WE ARE GETTING A TON OF CALLS SAYING, IS THIS A
1:57 TERRORIST ATTACK? EVERYBODY IS SAFE.
2:02 THERE IS NO REASON TO BE CONCERNED ABOUT YOUR LOVED ONES,
2:05 FLYING IN OR ANYTHING LIKE THAT, JUST WANT TO MAKE SURE EVERYONE
2:07 IS AT EASE ABOUT THAT. AS WE INVESTIGATE WHAT CAUSED
2:16 THIS, YOU ALWAYS HAVE TO ASSUME THAT AS MANY CYBERATTACKS THAT
2:18 TAKE PLACE, YOU MAKE THAT ASSUMPTION, BUT AS OF RIGHT NOW,
2:22 IT IS NOT NONE. WE ARE GOING TO CONTINUE TO
2:24 WORK. THE FIRST THING WE WANT TO DO IS
2:28 MAKE SURE WE RESTORE THE COMMUNICATIONS, GET ALL THE
2:32 FLIGHTS ON THE GROUND, AND THEN GET BACK TO NORMAL OPERATIONS.
2:35 WE WILL CONTINUE TO WORK TO FIND OUT WHAT THE ROOT OF THE CAUSE
2:36 IS. >> IS THERE AN ASSESSMENT THAT
2:42 MICROSOFT YESTERDAY, THE FAA TODAY IS A COINCIDENCE?
2:47 >> I DON'T SEE ANY REASON TO CONNECT THOSE TWO AT ALL.
2:50 THOSE ARE SEPARATE ISSUES. >> TO BE CLEAR, CAN YOU
2:56 DEFINITIVELY RULE OUT THAT THIS IS NOT A CYBERATTACK?
3:00 HOW LONG DO YOU EXPECT THIS OUTAGE TO LAST?
3:03 >> WE ARE WORKING WITH SECRETARY DUFFY ON THIS.
3:06 WE ARE NOT RULING ANYTHING OUT AT THIS POINT.
3:08 THE FIRST THING IS THE SAFETY OF EVERYONE FLYING.
3:11 WE ARE ASSURED EVERYONE IS SAFE. EVERYONE THAT IS GOING TO BE IN
3:17 THE AIR, CURRENTLY ON A PLANE, LOVED ONES, LIKE I SAID, WE ARE
3:19 GOING TO GET YOU ON THE GROUND IN A SAFE MANNER.
3:22 TO SAY THAT WE CAN RULE OUT ANYTHING, THAT IS NOT WHAT WE DO
3:24 AT THIS POINT. WE WANT TO MAKE SURE EVERYONE IS
3:27 SAFE AND WE RESTORE OPERATIONS. >> CAN YOU TALK ABOUT THE
3:32 SPECIFIC SYSTEM BEING AFFECTED RIGHT NOW?
3:35 WE HAVE SEEN SOME PLANES LAND AT SPECIFIC AIRPORTS.
3:39 IS THAT THE CASE AT ALL AIRPORTS, ANY FLIGHT WILL BE
3:40 ALLOWED TO LAND? >> WE HAVE A GROUND STOPPAGE.
3:44 WE STILL HAVE TO GET THE FLIGHTS OUT.
3:47 WE WILL BE DEALING WITH THOSE CASE-BY-CASE.
3:52 I THINK YOU SAID SPECIFIC, IT IS A TELECOMMUNICATIONS OUTAGE.
3:55 I WILL NOT GET AHEAD OF THE FAA. THAT IS BARELY TO TALK ABOUT.
4:00 WE WANT TO ASSURE THE AMERICAN PEOPLE THAT THIS IS NOT A SAFETY
4:03 TO THE AMERICAN PEOPLE OR ANOTHER 9/11.
4:07 THAT IS WHAT A LOT OF PEOPLE WERE TRYING TO MAKE THE
4:08 COMPARISON TO, AND THAT IS NOT THE CASE.
4:12 >> WHAT KIND OF ALL OF GOVERNMENT RESPONSE IS BEING
4:15 ASSEMBLED RIGHT NOW, WHO IS INVOLVED?
4:21 >> EVERYONE THAT HAS A STAKE IN THIS, EVERYONE IS INVOLVED.
4:25 THIS IS UNPRECEDENTED WHEN YOU SEE SOMETHING LIKE THIS.
4:28 WE WILL CONTINUE TO GROW THE ASSETS THAT WE NEED AT IT TO
4:33 MAKE SURE, ONE, NOT TO REPEAT MYSELF, BUT THAT WE GET THE
4:37 FLIGHTS DOWNED, AND A NORMAL OPERATIONS BACKUP.
4:39 THERE ARE SEVERAL OF US INVOLVED IN IT.
4:42 BACK HERE. BLUE TIE.
4:49 >> IS IT CURRENTLY THE COMMUNICATIONS ARE DOWN AS WE
4:50 SPEAK RIGHT NOW? >> YES.
4:58 WE ARE ABLE TO COMMUNICATE AT CERTAIN LEVELS, BUT IT HAS
5:02 OVERWHELMED SOME OF THE SYSTEMS WE HAVE.
5:05 ONCE AGAIN, SECRETARY DUFFY IS ON THIS.
5:09 HE WAS ON THE PHONE EARLIER WITH THE PRESIDENT AND SEVERAL OF US.
5:12 THEY ARE DOING A PHENOMENAL JOB IN THE CRISIS.
5:15 >> IS IN DAYS OR WEEKS? >> TOO EARLY TO TELL.
5:21 >> LAST ABOUT SEVEN HOURS RIGHT NOW, THE PILOTS ARE TELLING US.
5:23 IS THAT THE TIMEFRAME? >> WE HAVE DISCUSSED ANY
5:26 TIMEFRAME. JUST THINK ABOUT THIS AS A
5:30 WHOLE. IF I HAVE A LOVED ONE AT THE
5:36 AIRPORT, JUST TO GET EVERYONE STARTED BACK UP, THE FLIGHTS
5:40 GOING AGAIN, IT WILL TAKE SOME TIME.
5:46 SO THIS ISN'T GOING TO BE JUST RESOLVED AND TURNED AROUND
5:47 WITHIN THE HOUR. THIS WILL TAKE SOME TIME.
5:52 ONCE AGAIN, EVERYONE IS SAFE, THE FLIGHTS ARE ACCOUNTED FOR.
5:55 THERE SHOULD BE NO FEAR TO THE PUBLIC AT ALL.
5:59 >> THE PRESIDENT HAS BEEN BRIEFED?
6:02 YOU HAVE TALKED TO HIM? >> YES.
6:07 I WAS NOT THE ONLY PERSON IN THE ROOM, OBVIOUSLY.
6:11 >> THERE ARE THOUGHT THAT THIS COULD BE AN AI RELATED ERROR OR
6:13 ISSUE. >> WE CALL IT SI AROUND HERE,
6:17 REMEMBER. YOU JUST CANNOT RULE OUT
6:21 ANYTHING AT THIS POINT. WE ARE GOING THROUGH THAT
6:23 PROCESS. WE ARE GOING TO FIND OUT WHAT
6:26 HAPPENED. WHEN WE DO, WE WILL TAKE THE
6:31 APPROPRIATE ACTIONS TO MAKE SURE IT DOESN'T HAPPEN AGAIN.
6:36 >> ARE THERE ANY EXTRA PRECAUTIONS THAT ARE GOING ON
6:38 WITH THE PRESIDENT TO KEEP HIM SAFE WHILE YOU ARE STILL
6:39 INVESTIGATING? >> THERE IS NO FEAR TO THE
6:42 PUBLIC. I WANT TO MAKE SURE WE SAY THIS
6:44 AGAIN. THERE IS NO REASON FOR THE
6:48 PUBLIC TO BE AFRAID OR SCARED FOR YOUR LOVED ONES.
6:52 THIS IS NOT ANOTHER 9/11. I CANNOT REPEAT THAT ENOUGH.
6:57 PEOPLE ARE MAKING THAT ASSUMPTION BECAUSE THAT IS THE
6:59 LAST TIME WE HAD A NATIONWIDE GROUND STOPPAGE.
7:01 THIS IS A TELECOMMUNICATION OUTAGE.
7:03 THIS IS MUCH DIFFERENT. >> JUST FOLLOWING UP ON KEVIN'S
7:08 QUESTION, THERE ARE REPORTS THAT THE FAA WAS RULING OUT A NEW AI
7:11 TRAFFIC CONTROL SYSTEM TODAY. HAS THERE BEEN ANY LINK TO THAT?
7:16 >> WE ARE LOOKING AT THAT. THAT IS PART OF, OBVIOUSLY
7:24 THROUGH CISA, DHS, WE ARE TAKING A LOOK, WORKING WITH OUR
7:26 COUNTERPARTS THROUGHOUT ALL AGENCIES.
7:31 >> ARE THERE PLANES IN THE AIR THAT THE FAA IS ABLE TO
7:32 COMMUNICATE WITH NOW? >> JUST AT A DIFFERENT LEVEL.
7:40 THE CLARITY -- MY UNDERSTANDING. I'M NOT TRYING TO GET AHEAD OF
7:41 MYSELF ON THIS ONE. MY UNDERSTANDING IS WE CAN STILL
7:47 THAT WE CAN GET TO. THERE IS REDUNDANCY IN MOST
7:50 COMMUNICATIONS. AS YOU CAN SEE, THERE ARE STILL
7:54 PLANES LANDING. THERE ARE STILL COMMUNICATIONS
7:56 GOING ON. OUT OF AN ABUNDANCE OF CAUTION
8:01 IS THE REASON WE DECIDED TO GROUND EVERYTHING.
8:07 >> THIS IS A GROUND STOP FOR THE UNITED STATES.
8:09 IS THIS AFFECTING OTHER COUNTRIES AS WELL?
8:13 >> NOT THAT WE ARE AWARE OF. THERE ARE TWO AREAS THAT WE KNOW
8:16 ARE NOT AFFECTED. I DON'T THINK I'M ABLE TO SHARE
8:22 THOSE NOW. TWO AREAS IN THE UNITED STATES
8:27 IT BETTER ABLE TO COMMUNICATE JUST FINE.
8:30 >> WHAT DOES THAT MEAN? >> CAN YOU DESCRIBE WHO IS
8:35 INVESTIGATING THE ROOT CAUSE OF IT, INVOLVING AGENCIES?
8:39 >> EVERY AGENCY THAT HAS AN ASSET THAT IS INVOLVED IN THIS
8:46 FROM THE COMMUNICATIONS SIDE, THE FAA, P.O.W., STATE
8:48 DEPARTMENT, WE ARE ALL WORKING TOGETHER.
8:51 THAT IS WHAT WE DO. I DON'T WANT TO SAY THAT THIS IS
8:57 A CRISIS, BUT IT IS, BECAUSE WE HAD TO DO A NATIONWIDE GROUND
8:58 STOPPAGE. THIS IS WHAT THE GOVERNMENT
9:02 WORKS WELL AT. THAT IS WHAT WE ARE HERE FOR.
9:09 WE ARE WELL-POSITIONED AND COMMUNICATING VERY WELL.
9:13 THE PRESIDENT TOOK A LEAD IN THIS IMMEDIATELY.
9:17 HE GAVE US THE ASSETS AND THE COMMUNICATION TO MOVE FORWARD IN
9:21 A FAST WAY. THAT IS WHAT LEADERS DO.
9:24 PRESIDENT TRUMP IS THE BEST THAT LEADING US.
9:30 >> I HAVE NOT GOTTEN YOU, GO AHEAD.
9:34 >> YOU SAID THIS IS NOT A 9/11 STYLE EVENT BUT IF IT IS A
9:36 WIDESPREAD TELECOMMUNICATIONS ISSUE, CYBERATTACK RELATED TO
9:41 SOME SORT OF TERROR, INVERSION OF TERROR?
9:46 >> THIS IS NOT THE SAME COMPARISON TO 9/11.
9:50 THAT IS A ROAD I WILL NOT GO DOWN.
9:53 PEOPLE ARE MAKING THAT ASSUMPTION BECAUSE IT IS A
9:54 STOPPAGE. DO WE KNOW WHAT HAS CAUSED IT
9:56 YET? WE ARE GOING TO GO THROUGH IT.
10:01 BUT I'M NOT GOING TO MAKE ASSUMPTIONS.
10:05 AS I SAID MULTIPLE TIMES, IT IS DIFFICULT TO DEAL WITH
10:07 ASSUMPTIONS. WE ARE GOING TO DEAL WITH THE
10:09 FACTS AND THEN ROLLED THEM OUT TO YOU AS WE GET THEM.
10:15 JOE: THERE YOU HAVE IT COME ALIVE FROM THE WHITE HOUSE, THE
10:16 SECRETARY OF HOMELAND SECURITY MARKWAYNE MULLIN BRIEFING
10:19 REPORTERS. WE WANTED TO BRING YOU THAT
10:22 CONVERSATION BECAUSE THAT IS THE FIRST REAL TAPE WE HAVE HEARD
10:23 FROM THE ADMINISTRATION. A NATIONWIDE GROUND STOP IS HOW
10:28 WE START THE PROGRAM THIS EVENING LIVE FROM WASHINGTON
10:29 WITH A SERIES OF HEADLINES, SOME OF THEM READ ON THE TERMINAL.
10:34 AS SECRETARY MULLIN SAYS, IT WILL TAKE SOME TIME TO RESOLVE
10:36 THIS ISSUE. HE WAS NOT ABLE TO SAY HOW LONG.
10:42 NO INDICATION, AND HE RETURNED TO THIS MULTIPLE TIMES, THAT THE
10:44 GROUND STOP IS DUE TO A THREAT. HOWEVER, WHEN HE WAS PRESSED ON
10:48 SOME OF THE POTENTIAL FOR A CYBERATTACK, SOMETHING INVOLVING
10:54 AI, THE SECRETARY SAID "YOU CANNOT RULE OUT ANYTHING AT THIS
10:55 POINT." AND WE DID SEND A RED HEADLINE
11:01 . WE WILL HAVE FURTHER COVERAGE ON
11:05 THIS AS WE WORK OUR WAY THROUGH THE HOUR.
11:09 WE WANT TO TURN IMMEDIATELY TO NICK WADHAMS WHO HAS SPENT YEARS
11:12 COVERING NATIONAL SECURITY, IS WITH US HERE IN OUR WASHINGTON,
11:13 D.C. BUREAU. WHAT DO YOU MAKE OF THE
11:20 SECRETARY'S POSTURE AND REPEATEDLY GOING BACK TO 9/11,
11:22 WHICH HE SAID WAS THE LAST TIME THERE HAS BEEN ONE, A NATIONWIDE
11:25 GROUND STOPPAGE. THEY ARE CONCERNED ABOUT PANIC
11:28 IN THIS COUNTRY. NICK: WHAT WE ARE HEARING NOW
11:33 FROM THE FBI, FOR EXAMPLE, THEY HAVE NO INDICATION THIS WAS A
11:35 CYBERATTACK OR A TERRORISM THREAT.
11:39 SECRETARY MULLIN WAS INCORRECT. THE LAST TIME THERE WAS A FULL
11:44 GROUND STOP WAS 2023 OVER A COMMUNICATIONS ISSUE WITH
11:46 EMERGENCY NOTIFICATION SYSTEMS. THERE IS PRECEDENT FOR THIS
11:52 HAVING HAPPENED IN A NON-TERRORISM RELATED WAY.
11:56 THE BIG THING HE IS NOT TALKING ABOUT ALSO IS THE FAA
11:58 COMMUNICATIONS SYSTEM HAS BEEN UNDERFUNDED FOR YEARS, AND EVEN
12:02 THIS ADMINISTRATION HAS SAID THIS IS A MAJOR PROBLEM.
12:07 LAST YEAR, THEY GOT ANOTHER $12.5 BILLION FROM CONGRESS TO
12:09 DO THE SORTS OF UPGRADES THEY ARE TRYING TO DO THAT MAY HAVE
12:13 BEEN A CAUSE FOR THIS OUTAGE. KAILEY: WE KNOW SEAN DUFFY HAS
12:17 TALKED A LOT ABOUT THE PLANS TO MODERNIZE THE SYSTEM, AND PART
12:21 OF THAT IS INCORPORATING ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE, WHICH
12:24 IS WHY THE HOME AND A SECRETARY WAS ASKED THAT QUESTION.
12:29 I DON'T WANT TO GET TOO TECHNICAL HERE BUT DO WE KNOW IF
12:33 ANY U.S. ADVERSARIES WOULD HAVE THE CAPABILITY TO DO SOMETHING
12:34 LIKE THIS NATIONWIDE WHEN WE CONSIDER CYBER THREATS?
12:39 THE HOMELAND SECURITY SECRETARY SAID THERE IS NO EVIDENCE OF
12:40 THAT YET BUT THEY ARE NOT WILLING THAT OUT.
12:46 NICK: CYBERATTACKS AND THE CYBER WAR BETWEEN THE U.S. AND CHINA
12:49 AND OTHER ADVERSARIES, RAN, HAVE BEEN GOING ON FOR SO LONG.
12:53 WE HAVE THIS ISSUE RIGHT NOW IN EUROPE WITH U.S. MILITARY BASE
12:56 IS THAT THERE IS SOME SUSPICION IRAN WAS TARGETING REFRIGERATION
12:57 SYSTEMS. THERE'S A LOT THAT WE DON'T KNOW
13:00 ABOUT THAT SORT OF THING. WE KNOW IN THE PAST THERE HAVE
13:06 BEEN EFFORTS TO DEVELOP THE CAPABILITY TO HIT ELECTRICAL
13:07 SYSTEMS AND THINGS LIKE THAT. I THINK IN THIS CASE, ALL THE
13:11 EVIDENCE WE ARE SEEING RIGHT NOW, THAT IS NOT THE CASE.
13:17 WE HAVE NOT SEEN ANOTHER COUNTRY EXHIBITED THE CAPABILITY OF
13:20 TARGETING AN AIR TRAFFIC CONTROL SYSTEM.
13:23 EVERYTHING WE ARE GETTING RIGHT NOW SEEMS TO INDICATE THAT
13:25 INDEED THIS WAS AN UPDATE. ON THE ISSUE OF WANTING THE
13:31 UPGRADES, SEAN DUFFY, ACTUALLY THIS WEEK, ASKED CONGRESS FOR
13:35 ANOTHER $30 BILLION TO CONTINUE WITH THOSE UPGRADES.
13:39 THAT IS THE REAL BACK STORY HERE SO FAR AS WE AWAIT MORE
13:40 INFORMATION. JOE: IT'S BEEN SUGGESTED THIS
13:44 NEEDS TO BE REBUILT FROM THE BOTTOM FLOOR WITH A PATCHWORK OF
13:48 TECHNOLOGY THAT MIGHT MAKE IT IMPOSSIBLE TO HACK ON A NATIONAL
13:51 LEVEL. WE WILL HAVE MORE OBVIOUSLY FROM
13:56 THE TRANSPORTATION SECRETARY WHEN HE DECIDES TO ADDRESS THAT.
14:00 THANK YOU SO MUCH, NICK WADHAMS IN WASHINGTON.
14:04 WE WANT TO BRING IN TYLER KENDALL WHO IS ON THE PHONE FROM
14:06 SAN FRANCISCO INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT.
14:09 TYLER WAS STANDING BY FOR A FLIGHT OVERSEAS WHERE SHE'LL BE
14:12 COVERING THE PRESIDENT ON HIS TRIP TO CHINA.
14:15 THANK YOU FOR CHECKING IN HERE. WHAT ARE THEY TELLING PASSENGERS
14:16 ON THE GROUND RIGHT NOW? TYLER:
14:22 TYLER: NOT MUCH INFORMATION HAD BEEN RELEASED RELATED TO
14:24 PASSENGERS. WE GOT AN UPDATE OVER THE
14:29 LOUDSPEAKER SAYING ALL PASSENGERS ARE DELAYED UNTIL
14:30 FURTHER NOTICE. AT SAN FRANCISCO INTERNATIONAL
14:37 AIRPORT, THIS IS MY CONNECTION. WE WERE ABLE TO LAND MOMENTS
14:40 BEFORE THE GROUND STOP WAS ANNOUNCED.
14:45 FOR THE LONGEST TIME, IT SHOWED ALL THE FLIGHTS WERE ON TIME,
14:48 INCLUDING MINE EVEN WHEN WE WERE WELL PAST THE INITIAL STARTING
14:49 BOARD TIME. OUR FIRST UPDATE 30 MINUTES
14:54 AFTER THE STOPPAGE DID NOT GIVE US ANY UPDATE ON THE DEPARTURE
14:58 TIME BUT RATHER WAS A MESSAGE FROM THE AIRLINE SAYING WE COULD
15:02 EXPECT ANOTHER UPDATE IN OVER AN HOUR AND TO REMAIN NEAR OUR
15:03 GATE. IT ALSO SAID THE DELAY WAS DUE
15:09 TO WHAT IS BEING CALLED AN AIR TRAFFIC CONTROL COMMUNICATION
15:12 TECHNOLOGY ISSUE BUT ALSO OFFERED A LINK TO REBOOK.
15:18 WE WERE JUST HEARING FROM THE SECRETARY SAYING THEY ARE
15:20 CONTINUING TO WORK TO DETERMINE THE CAUSE OF THIS BUT THE
15:23 ADMINISTRATION IS NOT RULING ANYTHING OUT.
15:27 A PERSON FAMILIAR SAYS THE FBI DOES NOT BELIEVE THIS IS DUE TO
15:30 CRIMINALITY. THIS OUTAGE COULD HAVE BEEN
15:35 CAUSED BY A SOFTWARE UPDATE. THERE ARE A FEW OTHER
15:39 JOURNALISTS ON OUR FLIGHT AS WE TRIED TO MAKE OUR WAY OVER TO
15:41 ASIA AND OF THE PRESIDENT. THE INTERNATIONAL TERMINAL IS
15:44 PRETTY BIG AND STARTING TO FEEL MORE CROWDED AS THIS CONTINUES
15:47 TO GO ON. KAILEY: I WANTED TO ASK IF YOU
15:54 SEE PLANES STILL LANDING AT SFO AND IF THE PASSENGERS ARE ABLE
15:59 TO DEBOARD AND GO INTO THE TERMINAL.
16:05 TYLER: OUR PILOT ADDRESSED THIS AS WE WERE LANDING INTO SFO AND
16:11 TOLD US WE SHOULD BE PREPARED, THAT WE MAY BE ON THE TARMAC FOR
16:12 QUITE A WHILE. ON THE GROUND, IT DID APPEAR WE
16:18 WAITED 10 MINUTES OR SO AND WERE ABLE TO GET TO A GATE.
16:21 OUR FLIGHT HAD A LOT OF PASSENGERS THAT HAD VERY CLOSE
16:23 CONNECTIONS. ALL OF THOSE CONNECTIONS ARE
16:26 BEING DELAYED. IT DOES GO TO UNDERSCORE HOW
16:32 THERE CLEARLY WAS THIS CONVERSATION ABOUT HOW EXACTLY
16:34 THEY WERE GOING TO MOVE THROUGH ALL OF THE TRAFFIC.
16:40 THIS INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT IS A MAJOR HUB, ESPECIALLY ON A
16:41 FRIDAY NIGHT. THIS IS CONSIDERED TO BE ONE OF
16:45 THE BUSIEST TIMES TO FLY DURING THE WEEK.
16:49 I CAN TELL YOU I AM PERCHED ON TOP OF A PILLAR ALMOST BECAUSE
16:57 THERE IS SUCH FEW REAL ESTATE ON THE GROUND.
16:59 YOU HAVE PEOPLE LAYING ON THE GROUND LOOKING FOR SEATS.
17:05 THEY ARE INDEED LAYING ON THE GROUND BECAUSE IT IS GETTING
17:08 PRETTY CROWDED. JOE: IT SOUNDS LIKE IT COULD
17:12 BECOME NIGHTMARISH. WHAT IS THE POSTURE OF THE TSA
17:18 IN SAN FRANCISCO? HAVE YOU SEEN ANY ADJUSTMENTS IN
17:21 SECURITY OR HOW THEY ARE DEALING WITH PEOPLE?
17:25 TYLER: I WILL GO DO A LAP AFTER I GET OFF THE PHONE WITH YOU
17:26 GUYS. WE HAVE NOT SEEN THAT.
17:30 THE INITIAL RESPONSE WAS ALMOST LIKE NOTHING WAS HAPPENING.
17:33 I WENT TO LOOK AT THE HUNDREDS OF FLIGHTS COMING IN AND OUT.
17:38 FOR AT LEAST 30 MINUTES AFTER THE GROUND STOP WAS ANNOUNCED,
17:44 IT SHOWED EVERYTHING WAS ON TIME OR DEPARTING AS SCHEDULED.
17:46 IT WAS NOT UNTIL ABOUT 30 MINUTES LATER WE GOT THE UPDATE
17:51 THAT WE SHOULD EXPECT AN UPDATE SOON.
17:55 MOMENTS BEFORE I GOT ON WITH YOU, WE GOT THE ANNOUNCEMENT
17:59 EVERYBODY SHOULD SIT TIGHT FOR NOW.
18:02 JOE: THANK YOU SO MUCH, TYLER KENDALL.
18:05 WE HOPE YOU GET BACK ON THE AIRPLANE AND OFF THE GROUND.
18:07 WE WILL BE CHECKING BACK WITH YOU UNTIL YOU DO.
18:11 JOINING US IS GEORGE FERGUSON WHO COVERS THE AEROSPACE
18:13 INDUSTRY FOR US. WE ARE SEEING SOME OF THE
18:18 AIRLINE STOCKS TO LOWER. THIS IS NOT AN AIRLINE ISSUE,
18:19 RIGHT? EVERYTHING WE HAVE SEEN TELLS US
18:24 THIS IS AN AIR TRAFFIC CONTROL ISSUE.
18:27 WHAT DID YOU MAKE OF THE SECRETARY OF HOMELAND SECURITY
18:28 NOT EVEN ABLE TO GIVE US A TIMELINE ON WHEN THIS COULD BE
18:31 FIXED? GEORGE: NOT HAVING A TIMELINE IS
18:35 NOT SURPRISING. IT IS SURPRISING TO THINK IT
18:40 WOULD BE A SOFTWARE CHANGEOVER. IT SEEMS LIKE A REALLY BAD TIME
18:46 TO BE CHANGING SOFTWARE ON A FRIDAY EVENING AT A REALLY BUSY
18:50 TIME FOR AIR TRAVEL. WE WILL SEE.
18:55 MAYBE IT IS FROM SOMETHING THAT HAPPENED EARLIER IN THE DAY.
18:58 I'M SURPRISED HOW WIDESPREAD IT IS.
19:03 THAT MAKES ME THINK PERHAPS IT IS A CYBERATTACK OR SOFTWARE
19:09 DRIVEN. I WOULD BE SUPERIOR SURPRISED TO SEE
19:15 THEM CHANGING THINGS AT THIS TIME OF DAY.
19:19 KAILEY: WE WILL HAVE TO WAIT TO HEAR FROM RELEVANT AUTHORITIES.
19:22 THE SECRETARY SAID THEY CANNOT RULE ANYTHING ELSE OUT.
19:27 MARKWAYNE MULLIN SAID YOU WILL SEE PASSENGERS ABLE TO TAKE OFF
19:29 WITHIN THE HOUR. HOW COMPLICATED WILL IT BE FOR
19:33 EVERY AIRLINE IN THE UNITED STATES TO FIGURE OUT NEW FLIGHT
19:39 PATHS AND TIMES OF DEPARTURE AND ARRIVAL?
19:42 I WONDER WHEN THE ISSUE IS RESOLVED, WHICH DOES NOT HAVE A
19:45 CLEAR TIMELINE YET. GEORGE: IT IS GOING TO BE A
19:49 SUPER BUSY NIGHT IN THE OPERATION CENTERS FOR AIRLINES.
19:53 HOPEFULLY, IT IS JUST ONE BUSY NIGHT.
19:56 WITH THE GROUND STUFF, YOU WILL HAVE AIRPLANES THAT PROBABLY
19:59 LANDED PLACES THEY WERE NOT SUPPOSED TO LAND SO THEY COULD
20:03 LAND AS SOON AS POSSIBLE SO YOU WILL HAVE EQUIPMENT OUT OF PLACE
20:13 , OBVIOUSLY TO GET PASSENGERS WHERE THEY NEED TO GO BEFORE
20:14 REPLACING IT. THE OPTION TO TAKE OFF AND LAND
20:19 IS LIMITED. DEPENDING ON HOW MANY RUNWAYS
20:25 YOU HAVE AT MAJOR AIRPORTS, YOU WILL HAVE TO CUE EVERYBODY UP
20:29 AND START GETTING THEM OUT OF THEIR.
20:31 IT IS GOING TO BE A MESS. MY GUESS IS EVEN NOW YOU
20:35 PROBABLY HAVE MULTIPLE DAYS OF EQUIPMENT OUT OF PLACE WHICH
20:38 WILL COST THE AIRLINES A BUNCH OF MONEY TO GET BACK IN THE
20:40 RIGHT ORDER. JOE: IT IS GOING TO BE A MESS,
20:44 SAYS GEORGE FERGUSON. CAN YOU ESTIMATE THE HIT FOR A
20:48 TWO-DAY STOPPAGE LIKE THIS? GEORGE: I DON'T HAVE ONE YET.
20:52 I WOULD HAVE TO LOOK. IT IS LIKE HAVING A SNOWSTORM
20:55 ACROSS THE ENTIRE COUNTRY. WE WILL HAVE TO LOOK AT THAT.
21:04 KAILEY: ARE THE AIRLINES IN A SITUATION LIKE THIS OBLIGATED TO
21:07 PROVIDE ANYTHING TO CUSTOMERS STRANDED, BE IT HOTEL VOUCHERS
21:12 OR WHAT HAVE YOU? IS THERE NO LEGAL ENFORCEMENT
21:16 AROUND THAT IN A CASE LIKE THIS? GEORGE: IN THE U.S., WE HAVE
21:22 LESS OF THOSE REQUIREMENTS TO PROVIDE FOR THE PASSENGER.
21:26 THIS IS GOING TO BE A FORCE MAJEURE, ACT OF GOD.
21:33 IF THIS LASTS OVERNIGHT, THERE WILL NOT BE ENOUGH HOTEL ROOMS.
21:36 THERE WILL NOT BE ENOUGH FOOD. IT WILL BE A ROUGH NIGHT FOR
21:42 THOSE PASSENGERS OUT OF PLACE. I DON'T EVEN KNOW HOW THE
21:47 AIRLINES WOULD COMPENSATE IF THEY WERE REQUIRED TO AT ALL.
21:51 JOE: THIS IS GOING TO BE SOMETHING TO WITNESS AS WE
21:54 UNTANGLE ALL OF THIS. IS EACH AIRLINE EQUALLY PREPARED
21:58 TO DEAL WITH THIS? ARE SOME BETTER POSITIONED TO
22:03 RECOVER? GEORGE: THE BIG CARRIERS WOULD
22:06 BE BEST PREPARED. UNITED, DELTA, AMERICAN.
22:13 THEY HAVE LARGE FLEETS AND ARE USED TO MANAGING PROBLEMS ACROSS
22:14 THE COUNTRY. THEIR OPERATION CENTERS ARE VERY
22:17 SOPHISTICATED. I THINK THEY WILL BE IN
22:22 PARTICULARLY GOOD SHAPE TO DO THIS.
22:25 THE SMALL YOUR AIRLINE, THE MORE CHALLENGING THE EVENING
22:28 ESPECIALLY AS THINGS DRAG OUT. KAILEY: QUICKLY AS WE HAVE BEEN
22:35 DISCUSSING THIS IS DUE TO ANTIQUATED SYSTEMS AND
22:40 TECHNOLOGY, THE FAA, WHAT WITH THAT KIND OF INVESTMENT ENTAILED
22:43 TO IMPROVE THESE SYSTEMS? DO THE AIRLINES THEMSELVES HAVE
22:48 ANY ROLE TO PLAY IN THAT IF THIS IS AFFECTING THEM AND THEIR
22:51 BOTTOM LINES? GEORGE: IT IS ALWAYS A FIGHT
22:56 BETWEEN HOW MUCH MONEY IS NEEDED AND THE RIGHT PLACE TO RAISE IT.
23:02 THE AIRLINES ARE GOING TO FIGHT HOW MUCH TO PUT ON A TICKET
23:05 BECAUSE THEY DON'T WANT TO HURT FLYING DEMAND.
23:11 THEY WOULD RATHER SEE IT TAX THE ENTIRE COUNTRY.
23:14 IT IS COUNTRY INFRASTRUCTURE. EYES SEE PRICES ON
23:21 INFRASTRUCTURE -- I SEE PRICES ON INFRASTRUCTURE THAT GOES $30
23:26 BILLION, $40 BILLION, OR MORE. YOU HAVE INFRASTRUCTURE WORKING
23:31 AND YOU HAVE TO COME OVER TO NEW TECHNOLOGY WHILE YOU KEEP THE
23:35 AIRWAYS MOVING. THAT MEANS YOU CANNOT JUST KNOCK
23:41 DOWN ALL OF YOUR SYSTEMS AT ONCE AND MAKE THEM CUTTING EDGE.
23:44 YOU NEED TO MAKE SURE ALL THE SYSTEMS ARE EXTREMELY STABLE.
23:50 YOU END UP IN THIS ENVIRONMENT WHERE YOU HAVE TO DOVETAIL NEW
23:54 TECHNOLOGY WITH LEGACY SYSTEMS THAT COST MORE MONEY, TAKE MORE
23:58 TIME, NEED REDUNDANCY. EVEN WHEN WE PUT PRICE TAGS ON
24:03 IT FOR CURRENT FIXES, THIS IS AN ONGOING INVESTMENT THE COUNTRY
24:08 HAS TO MAKE PERENNIALLY. IT HAS A LOT OF NUANCE TO IT SO
24:12 YOU CANNOT JUST TEAR IT DOWN AND START OVER AGAIN.
24:17 IT IS ONE OF THE CHALLENGES. IT IS A GOOD CHALLENGE OF A
24:23 STRONG, ROBUST AIR TRAVEL SYSTEM IN THE UNITED STATES.
24:27 IT IS ONE WE CONSTANTLY HAVE TO BE ADDRESSING AND SPENDING MONEY
24:29 ON. KAILEY: GEORGE FERGUSON OF
24:35 BLOOMBERG INTELLIGENCE, THANK YOU.
24:38 SO MUCH WE WANT TO GO TO THE IMPACT ON THE AFTER OUR TRADE.
24:42 NORAH MULINDA, WHAT ARE THE STOCKS DOING?
24:46 TRADE. JETBLUE WAS PLUNGING MORE THAN
24:49 3%. NOW LOWER BY ABOUT 2.6%.
24:55 AMERICAN AIRLINES ALSO IN MY VIEW, UNITED, ALL THESE NAMES IN
24:57 THE RED. THIS IS A SECTOR PRESSURED MUCH
25:03 OF THE YEAR WHEN YOU THINK ABOUT THE WAR IN THE MIDDLE EAST.
25:06 THAT DRIVING UP FUEL COSTS AND INFLATION.
25:10 THESE ARE NAMES SQUARELY IN THE MIDDLE OF THE WHIRLWIND.
25:12 WE ARE SEEING ALL THESE NAMES DOWN DOUBLE DIGITS YEAR-TO-DATE.
25:19 AMERICAN AIRLINES DOWN 14%. WE ARE KEEPING AN EYE ON ALL THE
25:24 HEADLINES IN THE CURRENT MOMENT. IT WILL BE INTERESTING TO SEE ON
25:31 MONDAY HOW LONG IT TAKES FOR ALL OF THIS TO TRICKLE THROUGH.
25:35 CERTAINLY SEEING THE ENTIRE SECTOR PUSHING DOWN INTO THE
25:37 RED. JOE: THANK YOU, NORAH MULINDA.
25:41 HAVE A GREAT WEEKEND. WE WILL BE BACK WITH MORE AHEAD.
25:45 MORE BREAKING NEWS AND ANALYSIS. THERE IS A NATIONWIDE GROUND
25:50 STOP UNDERWAY ORDERED BY THE FAA.
25:52 THE WHITE HOUSE SAYING WE CANNOT RULE OUT ANYTHING.
26:09 JOE: IT IS "BALANCE OF POWER" ON BLOOMBERG TV AND RADIO.
26:13 ALONGSIDE KAILEY LEINZ, I AM JOE MATHIEU IN WASHINGTON AS WE
26:18 FOLLOW BREAKING NEWS WITH THE NATIONWIDE AIRPORT GROUND STOP
26:21 ORDERED BY THE FAA. WE HAVE HEARD SOME SKETCHY
26:26 REASONING BEHIND THIS IN TERMS OF A COMMUNITY AND BREAK THEM.
26:29 SOME COMPROMISING OF THE AIR TRAFFIC CONTROL SYSTEM.
26:34 IT IS CLEAR AUTHORITIES HAVE NOT ISOLATED THE SPECIFIC PROBLEM.
26:37 WE DID RECEIVE A BRIEFING AT THE TOP OF THE HOUR FROM HOMELAND
26:40 SECURITY SECRETARY MARKWAYNE MULLIN WHO MADE IT CLEAR
26:47 REPEATEDLY THERE IS NO THREAT THAT FORCED THIS GROUND STOP.
26:54 HOWEVER, HE SAYS IT WILL TAKE TIME TO RESOLVE THE ISSUE AND
26:58 THE ADMINISTRATION CANNOT RULE OUT ANYTHING HE SAID AT THIS
27:02 POINT WHEN ASKED SPECIFICALLY ABOUT THIS INVOLVING AI AND A
27:05 POTENTIAL UPGRADE TO THE SYSTEM. THAT WAS THE ANSWER.
27:10 COURTNEY SUBRAMANIAN JOINS US STEPS FROM WHERE THE SECRETARY
27:14 JUST GOGGLED WITH REPORTERS. WHAT IS THE SENSE OF URGENCY
27:19 INSIDE THE ADMINISTRATION? >> OFFICIALS ARE TRACKING THIS
27:25 EVERY STEP OF THE WAY. AS YOU CAN IMAGINE, A LOT OF
27:27 PEOPLE ARE ON EDGE. THIS IS ONLY THE THIRD TIME IN
27:33 RECENT HISTORY A NATIONWIDE GROUND STOP HAS BEEN ISSUED.
27:38 ONCE IN 20 OVER A PILOT NOTIFICATION SYSTEM GOING DOWN
27:41 AND OF COURSE THE SEPTEMBER 11 ATTACKS IN 2001.
27:50 SECRETARY MULLIN CAME OUT TO ALLAY CONCERNS ABOUT SAFETY.
27:54 HE SAID THIS IS NOT A SEPTEMBER 11 SITUATION.
28:00 AGAIN ECHOING TRANSPORTATION SECRETARY DUFFY'S COMMENTS THAT
28:04 THIS IS A TELECOMMUNICATIONS OUTAGE.
28:07 REFUSED TO RULE ANYTHING OUT. WILL NOT GIVE ANY SORT OF
28:10 TIMEFRAME. HE DID SAY THE PRESIDENT HAD
28:15 BEEN BRIEFED BY SECRETARY DUFFY AND HIMSELF EARLIER.
28:20 WE ARE STILL WAITING FOR MORE UPDATES ON WHAT EXACTLY IS
28:25 BEHIND THIS AND WHEN IT WILL END.
28:28 KAILEY: WAS THE PRESIDENT HIMSELF SCHEDULED TO TRAVEL THIS
28:31 WEEKEND? DO WE KNOW IF THIS WILL CHANGE
28:34 ANYTHING IN TERMS OF HIS PLANS? COURTNEY: HE IS NOT.
28:39 HE IS DUE TO STAY IN D.C. THIS WEEKEND.
28:42 HE IS TRAVELING TO ASIA FOR THE SUMMIT IN MANILA AND CHINA NEXT
28:46 WEEK. BUT THAT IS NOT UNTIL MONDAY.
28:51 IT IS UNCLEAR IF THIS WILL AFFECT ANY TRAVEL FOR HIM AS
28:52 WELL. JOE: DO WE EXPECT ANY FURTHER
28:55 UPDATES? I REALIZE YOU PROBABLY CANNOT
28:57 ANSWER THAT. HAVING HEARD A NEWS CONFERENCE
29:04 FROM TOGETHER WITH THE HOMELAND SECURITY SECRETARY, YOU WOULD
29:07 LIKE TO THINK THEY WILL BE KEEPING THE AMERICAN PEOPLE
29:08 UP-TO-DATE. COURTNEY: WHITE HOUSE OFFICIALS
29:12 HAVE BEEN FIELDING OUR QUESTIONS.
29:16 WE ARE EXPECTING THEM TO KEEP US UPDATED BUT IT IS UNCLEAR IF
29:19 THEY PLAN TO SPEAK TO REPORTERS AGAIN THIS EVENING.
29:22 WE WILL KEEP YOU POSTED. KAILEY: PLEASE DO.
29:26 COURTNEY SUBRAMANIAN ON THE WHITE HOUSE LAWN FOR US.
29:28 THANK YOU SO MUCH. JOINING US AS A FORMER U.S.
29:31 TRANSPORTATION SECRETARY, RAY LAHOOD, WHO SERVED IN THAT ROLE
29:35 DURING THE OBAMA ADMINISTRATION. HE IS JOINING US FROM PEORIA,
29:39 ILLINOIS, AT THE INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT WHERE HE IS AFFECTED BY
29:43 THE GROUND STOP. I AM SURE THIS IS AN INTERESTING
29:49 EXPERIENCE FOR YOU HAVING SERVED IN A ROLE THAT OVERSEES THE FAA
29:58 AND NOW DEALING WITH THE EFFECTS OF THIS GROUND STOP.
30:00 WHAT ARE YOU HEARING ON THE GROUND?
30:05 YOU ARE IN A POSITION TO KNOW WHAT QUESTIONS TO ASK OF
30:06 AUTHORITIES AT THE AIRPORT. >> I JUST TALKED TO THE AIRPORT
30:14 MANAGER IN PEORIA. HE TOLD ME WE WERE SUPPOSED TO
30:21 LEAVE TONIGHT TO GO TO SARASOTA FOR A GOLF WEEKEND IN SARASOTA,
30:23 FLORIDA. HE TOLD ME THERE IS PROBABLY NO
30:29 CHANCE WE WILL GET OUT OF HERE FOR A COUPLE OF DAYS.
30:32 KAILEY: A COUPLE OF DAYS? >> HE SAID EVEN IF THEY GOT THE
30:37 SYSTEM UP AND RUNNING RIGHT NOW, WE DEFINITELY WOULD NOT GET OUT
30:40 UNTIL TOMORROW. HE SAID IT IS UNLIKELY THEY WILL
30:46 GET IT UP AND RUNNING AT THIS HOUR.
30:51 I THINK PEOPLE BETTER MAKE SOME HOTEL RESERVATIONS OR CAR RENTAL
30:56 AGREEMENTS AND TRY AND FIGURE OUT HOW THEY EITHER STAY IN
31:01 PLACE OR GET TO THEIR DESTINATION BY AUTOMOBILE.
31:06 JOE: I HOPE FOR THE SAKE OF OUR AUDIENCE THEY ARE HEEDING
31:10 THE ADVICE OF THE TRANSPORTATION SECRETARY.
31:13 HE KNOWS WHAT HE IS TALKING ABOUT.
31:16 IT MAY BE TIME TO TAKE THINGS IN YOUR OWN HANDS.
31:19 WHAT IS SECRETARY DUFFY UP TO RIGHT NOW?
31:23 HE IS NOT OUT IN FRONT OF REPORTERS BECAUSE HE IS WORKING.
31:28 WHAT WOULD HE BE UP TO AT THIS POINT AND UNTIL WE FIGURE OUT
31:29 THE CAUSE? >> I THINK PROBABLY HE IS OUT IN
31:36 VIRGINIA WHICH IS THE MAIN HUB FOR THE FAA GUIDING PLANES IN
31:41 AND OUT OF AIRPORTS. AT THAT LOCATION, THEY HAVE UP
31:51 ON SCREENS WHAT THE ACTION IS GOING ON ALL OVER THE COUNTRY.
31:56 THAT IS WHERE THEY ARE PROBABLY TRYING TO IDENTIFY THE PROBLEM
32:01 OF WHAT SHUT DOWN THE SYSTEM. YOU HAVE DONE STORIES AND HEARD
32:06 STORIES, EVERYBODY HAS HEARD THE HORROR STORIES.
32:09 WE HAVE THE MOST ANTIQUATED EQUIPMENT.
32:13 I GIVE SECRETARY DUFFY CREDIT. HE HAS WORKED HARD THIS YEAR TO
32:18 PERSUADE CONGRESS TO GIVE HIM THE MILLIONS AND BILLIONS OF
32:21 DOLLARS NEEDED TO GET THIS EQUIPMENT UPGRADED.
32:29 THIS IS SOMETHING HE HAS MADE A PRIORITY SINCE HE BECAME
32:30 SECRETARY. I CONGRATULATE HIM FOR DOING
32:34 THAT. I GUARANTEE CONGRESS WILL PAY
32:39 THEIR CONSTITUENTS. I ALSO GUARANTEE YOU THERE ARE A
32:45 LOT OF MEMBERS OF CONGRESS TRYING TO GET OUT OF WASHINGTON,
32:47 D.C., RIGHT NOW. KAILEY: THERE IS A LOT OF PEOPLE
32:51 ALL OVER THE COUNTRY. I IMAGINE THERE ARE PROBABLY
32:56 SOME COLLEGE FOOTBALL PLAYERS WHO HAVE GAMES TOMORROW THAT
32:58 WILL NOT BE MAKING IT TO THE STADIUMS IN WHICH THEY ARE
33:00 SUPPOSED TO PLAY. PLEASE.
33:04 >> THIS IS A NATIONAL CALAMITY. I AM NOT A SUPERSTITIOUS PERSON.
33:11 BUT FOR IT TO HAPPEN ON FRIDAY 13 LEADS ME TO BELIEVE MAYBE I
33:14 WILL BECOME A SUSPICIOUS PERSON. JOE: [LAUGHTER]
33:17 KAILEY: I THINK A LOT OF PEOPLE JOIN YOU IN THAT, MR. SECRETARY.
33:23 WHEN TALKING ABOUT THE ANTIQUATED SYSTEMS AND SECRETARY
33:28 DUFFY'S ATTEMPTS TO MODERNIZE THEM, WE HAVE SEEN SOME
33:31 MODERNIZATION IN THE FORM OF NEW AI SYSTEMS BEING INTRODUCED.
33:33 THAT WAS EXPANDED THIS WEEK. THERE IS A QUESTION AS TO
33:38 WHETHER SOFTWARE MAY HAVE PLAYED A ROLE HERE.
33:40 WOULD YOU BE SURPRISED IF THE ISSUE WAS CREATED BY TRYING TO
33:45 UPGRADE THE SYSTEMS THAT NEED IT?
33:48 >> I WOULD BE A LITTLE SURPRISED AND I TELL YOU WHY.
33:52 THE FAA HAS VERY PROFESSIONAL PEOPLE THAT HAVE WORKED LONG AND
33:57 HARD ON TRANSITIONING FROM THE OLD SYSTEM TO THE NEW SYSTEM.
34:05 WHAT I MEAN IS A TEST RUN THESE SYSTEMS BEFORE THEY EVER GO UP
34:09 WITH THEM. THEY LOOK AT THEM CAREFULLY.
34:14 I BELIEVE IT IS MORE A CASE OF OLD, ANTIQUATED SYSTEM THAT
34:19 FAILED RATHER THAN TRYING TO TRANSITION FROM ONE SYSTEM TO A
34:22 NEW ONE. OBVIOUSLY, I AM GUESSING.
34:29 BUT I KNOW THE FAA AND I KNOW THEY ARE PROFESSIONAL PEOPLE.
34:32 I KNOW THE PEOPLE THAT HAVE WORKED HARD TO TRANSITION FROM
34:34 THE OLD TO THE NEW. I GUARANTEE YOU THERE HAVE BEEN
34:37 A LOT OF TEST RUNS BEFORE THEY EVER DID THAT.
34:40 JOE: INTERESTING. WE ARE SPENDING SOME TIME WITH
34:45 THE FORMER TRANSPORTATION SECRETARY RAY LAHOOD.
34:48 WE HAVE A LIVE VIEW OF O'HARE INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT IN CHICAGO
34:55 ON BLOOMBERG TV AND YOUTUBE. WHAT IS THE DECISION-MAKING
35:00 PROCESS BEHIND A NATIONWIDE GROUND STOP?
35:02 WE HAVE ALREADY MADE CLEAR IT DOES NOT HAPPEN OFTEN.
35:08 IS THIS A CALL THE SECRETARY HIMSELF MAKES OR A COLLABORATIVE
35:10 EFFORT WITH ANY NUMBER OF PEOPLE AROUND THE COUNTRY?
35:14 >> IT IS A CALL SECRETARY DUFFY MAKES BASED ON RECOMMENDATIONS
35:18 FROM THE FAA. IT IS HIS CALL.
35:27 OBVIOUSLY, HE DOES IT CONSULTING WITH OTHER PEOPLE INCLUDING THE
35:28 WHITE HOUSE. THIS IS A NATIONAL CALAMITY.
35:38 HE IS SMART ENOUGH TO KNOW HE NEEDS TO KEEP FOLKS AT THE WHITE
35:39 HOUSE. THE ANSWER IS THAT IT IS HIS
35:43 CALL. KAILEY: WE DON'T KNOW YET WHEN
35:49 HE IS GOING TO REVERSE THE CALL. THERE IS NO OBVIOUS TIMELINE.
35:56 THE EFFECTS OF THIS EVEN IF IT IS RESOLVED IMMEDIATELY COULD
35:59 LAST FOR DAYS. DO AIRPORTS HAVE THE NECESSARY
36:03 INFRASTRUCTURE TO SUPPORT A SITUATION LIKE THAT?
36:06 I KNOW THERE ARE CIRCUMSTANCES WITH EXTREME WEATHER THAT AFFECT
36:13 DIFFERENT PARTS OF THE COUNTRY AND THE INFRASTRUCTURE AROUND
36:15 THEM IS STRESSED AND TESTED IN THAT REGARD.
36:18 AT THIS SCALE NATIONALLY, IT MAKES YOU WONDER WHEN NO ONE IS
36:22 ABLE TO GET OFF THE GROUND AND PEOPLE ARE LANDING IN PLACES
36:27 THEY DID NOT INTEND TO STAY IF ALL OF THESE PEOPLE ARE GOING TO
36:30 BE OK TONIGHT. >> MAJOR AIRPORTS AROUND THE
36:36 COUNTRY HAVE THE CAPACITY TO HANDLE THIS KIND OF SITUATION.
36:44 THEY PLAN FOR IT. THEY TRAIN THEIR PEOPLE FOR IT.
36:52 I AM SURE ALL HANDS ARE ON DECK ON ALL MAJOR AIRPORTS.
36:55 I AM SURE PEOPLE WHO LEFT WORK TODAY HAVE BEEN CALLED BACK IN.
36:59 THE ANSWER IS THAT AIRPORTS ARE PREPARED.
37:02 THEY TRAIN FOR IT. I GUARANTEE ALL HANDS ARE ON
37:05 DECK FOR THE MAJOR AIRPORTS. JOE: SECRETARY MARKWAYNE MULLIN
37:10 SAID SOME AIRPLANES ARE STILL LANDING.
37:14 FOR THOSE WATCHING AND LISTENING WHO HAVE FRIENDS AND FAMILY
37:17 STILL IN THE AIR, WHAT HAPPENS WITH PLANES STILL IN FLIGHT?
37:20 >> IT IS INTERESTING. I AM SITTING AT THE PEORIA
37:24 AIRPORT, A MIDSIZED AIRPORT. THE FLIGHT I WAS GOING TO BOARD
37:29 THE GO TO SARASOTA IS AN ALLEGIANT FLIGHT.
37:33 WHEN I TALKED TO THE AIRPORT MANAGER A FEW MINUTES AGO, HE
37:38 SAID THE PLANE IS ON THE WAY. I SAID IS THERE A PROBLEM WITH
37:40 THE PLANE LANDING SAFELY? HE SAID ABSOLUTELY NOT.
37:46 THE CONTROL TOWER IN PEORIA IS IN CONTACT WITH THE PILOT AND
37:49 THAT PLANE WILL LAND SAFELY. THERE IS NO WORRY INTERNATIONAL
37:54 FLIGHTS FLYING INTO KENNEDY IN NEW YORK AND DULLES ARE NOT
37:59 GOING TO LAND SAFELY. KAILEY: MR. SECRETARY, WE WISH
38:05 YOU LUCK WITH YOUR CURRENT SITUATION AT THE AIRPORT.
38:08 WE SO APPRECIATE YOU JOINING US, FORMER TRANSPORTATION SECRETARY
38:13 RAY LAHOOD. IF ANYONE IS WATCHING OR
38:17 LISTENING AT THE AIRPORT, I'M SURE THERE ARE ROOMS AVAILABLE.
38:25 U.S. HOMELAND SECURITY SECRETARY MARKWAYNE MULLIN EARLIER
38:28 ADDRESSED THE NATIONWIDE GROUND STOP.
38:32 HE SAYS THERE IS NO CLEAR SIGN THIS IS DUE TO A THREAT.
38:34 LISTEN. >> CAN YOU DEFINITIVELY RULE OUT
38:39 THIS IS NOT A CYBERATTACK? HOW LONG DO YOU EXPECT THE
38:41 OUTAGE TO LAST? >> WE ARE WORKING WITH SECRETARY
38:45 DUFFY ON THIS. WE ARE NOT RULING OUT ANYTHING
38:48 AT THIS POINT. THE FIRST THING IS THE SAFETY OF
38:50 EVERYBODY FLYING. WE ARE ASSURED EVERYBODY IS
38:53 SAFE. EVERYBODY THAT IS GOING TO BE IN
38:57 THE AIR, THAT IS CURRENTLY ON THE PLANE, WE ARE GOING TO GET
39:01 YOU ON THE GROUND AND DO IT IN A SAFE MANNER.
39:05 TO SAY THAT WE CAN RULE OUT ANYTHING, THAT IS NOT WHAT WE DO
39:07 AT THIS POINT. THE FIRST THING IS TO MAKE SURE
39:10 EVERYBODY IS SAFE AND WE RESTORE OPERATIONS.
39:16 KAILEY: JOINING US FOR THEIR THOUGHTS ON THIS IS OUR
39:16 POLITICAL PANEL, JEANNE SHEEHAN ZAINO AND RICK DAVIS.
39:26 HOW IMPORTANT WAS IT THAT THE WHITE HOUSE SENT OUT THE
39:31 HOMELAND SECURITY SECRETARY TO ADDRESS THE PUBLIC GIVEN THE
39:35 NATION EXPERIENCED THE 9/11 ATTACKS 25 YEARS AGO?
39:39 JEANNE: IT IS CRITICALLY IMPORTANT.
39:42 THIS IS THE THIRD TIME IN MODERN HISTORY WE HAVE SEEN A SHUTDOWN
39:45 OF OUR AIR LIKE THIS. MOST OF US REMEMBER 9/11.
39:50 THAT IS A REALLY SCARY MOMENT. WHAT IS REQUIRED AT THESE
39:56 MOMENTS WHEN YOU HAVE AN EMERGENCY IS INFORMATION.
40:00 I THINK IT IS IMPORTANTLY SO MARKWAYNE MULLIN CANNOT AND TRY
40:02 TO PROVIDE THAT. I'M NOT SURE SAYING THINGS LIKE
40:10 WE CANNOT RULE ANYTHING OUT IS THE WAY TO ASSUAGE PEOPLE THERE
40:15 IS NOTHING TO BE CONCERNED ABOUT.
40:19 GO BACK TO THE ORIGINAL STATEMENT FROM THE FAA, "DUE TO
40:22 EXTRAORDINARY CIRCUMSTANCES AND FOR REASONS OF SAFETY," I ALMOST
40:26 FELT LIKE HE WAS ABOUT AS CLEAR AS MUD WHEN HE CAME OUT TO TALK.
40:31 HE DID NOT EVEN GIVE US A SENSE AS TO WHEN THEY WOULD BE BACK
40:36 OUT, A COMMON TACTIC, WE WILL COME BACK AT 6:00, 7:00 AND GIVE
40:38 YOU UPDATES. WE HEARD NONE OF THAT.
40:43 TO HANDLE. THERE IS A WAY THAT THIS IS
40:45 DONE. WE SEE IT AT THE LOCAL AND STATE
40:48 LEVEL ALL THE TIME. THIS WAS NOT A PARTICULARLY
40:57 CALMING KIND OF CIRCUMSTANCE OR STATEMENT HE MADE.
41:03 JOE: RICK DAVIS, WEIGH IN ON THE COMMUNICATION STRATEGY SO FAR IF
41:04 YOU WISH. I'M CURIOUS HAVING JUST SPOKEN
41:10 TO SECRETARY RAY LAHOOD IF THIS UNLOCKS THE MONEY SEAN DUFFY HAS
41:13 BEEN ASKING FOR TO UPGRADE THE AIR TRAFFIC CONTROL SYSTEM.
41:18 RICK: THIS IS THE KIND OF THING THAT CAN BRING FOCUS TO THE
41:19 CONGRESSIONAL EFFORTS. NO NEW SYSTEMS LIKE THIS HAVE
41:24 BEEN PUT IN PLACE SINCE LYNDON JOHNSON WAS PRESIDENT.
41:27 FOR SURE, THIS COULD BE A POSITIVE DEVELOPMENT IN THE
41:30 SEARCH FOR MONEY. KAILEY: RICK DAVIS AND JEANNE
41:36 SHEEHAN ZAINO, THANK YOU BOTH FOR HOPPING ON WITH YOUR
41:38 THOUGHTS ON THIS. WHILE NO PLANES IN THE UNITED
41:43 STATES CAN TAKE OFF RIGHT NOW, IN JUST A FEW MINUTES, A SPACEX
41:46 ROCKET IS SCHEDULED. SPACEX IS LOOKING TO EXECUTE ONE
41:51 OF ITS MOST AMBITIOUS FLIGHTS YET.
41:55 HAPPENING NATIONWIDE. LET'S GO TO ED LUDLOW WITH THE
41:59 COUNTDOWN. LAUNCH SCHEDULED JUST TWO
42:02 MINUTES AWAY. WHY CAN A ROCKET LAUNCH INTO
42:08 SPACE WHEN NO PLANES ARE SAFE TO TAKE OFF RIGHT NOW?
42:12 ED: SPACEX HAS ITS OWN COMMERCIAL SPACE LICENSE.
42:17 IT WAS A PRETTY BIG MOVE ABOUT 40 MINUTES AGO WHEN THEY STARTED
42:21 LOADING THE PROPELLANT, THAT THEY HAD TO CLEARANCES NECESSARY
42:22 TO MAKE THIS HAPPEN. I KNOW YOU'VE HAD A ROUGH HOUR
42:27 AS HAVE MANY AMERICANS IN AIRPORTS AROUND THE COUNTRY.
42:29 BUT THIS IS A BIG MOMENT. THIS WILL BE THE FIRST TIME
42:33 SPACEX TRIES TO BRING BOTH STAGES, THE FIRST STAGE BOOSTER
42:39 AND SECOND STAGE SPACECRAFT, BACK TO THE PLACE THEY LAUNCHED
42:43 FROM AND CATCH THEM ON THE LAUNCH TOWER YOU SAW A SECOND
42:44 AGO. IN THAT MOMENT, SPACEX WILL TRY
42:51 AND REACH A GOAL IT HAS BEEN TRYING FOR A LONG TIME WHICH IS
42:54 RAPID REUSABILITY. THE GOAL IS TO BE ABLE TO LIFT
42:57 OFF A ROCKET, BRING IT BACK TO EARTH, AND IMMEDIATELY HAVE IT
43:02 LIFT OFF AGAIN LIKE AN AIRPLANE. THIS IS A BIG MOMENT.
43:06 JOE: FASCINATING. IF YOU ARE WITH US ON BLOOMBERG
43:11 TV OR YOUTUBE, WHAT A BEAUTIFUL SHOT OF THE ROCKET SET TO TAKE
43:14 OFF MINUTES FROM NOW. THAT IS HOW YOU GET 2000'S OF
43:20 LAUNCHES A YEAR, RIGHT -- THAT IS HOW YOU GET TO THOUSANDS OF
43:23 LAUNCHES A YEAR, RIGHT? ED: YES.
43:30 ELON MUSK OUTLINED THE PLAN WHICH IS TO GO FROM MULTIPLE
43:33 LAUNCHES IN A WEEK IN THE NEAR FUTURE TO MULTIPLE LAUNCHES PER
43:39 DAY, ALL TO REACH THE GOAL OF ORBITAL DATA CENTERS.
43:46 IT IS THE STARSHIP SPACECRAFT THAT WILL FULFILL THAT DREAM.
43:50 IT IS SCI-FI BUT SPACEX STILL HOLDS THAT AMBITION TO MAKE
43:53 HUMANKIND A MULTI PLANETARY SPECIES.
43:57 I'M GOING TO GIVE YOU A SECOND BECAUSE I JUST SAW THE COUNTDOWN
43:59 DISAPPEAR FROM MY SCREEN. MIGHT HAVE TO HELP ME OUT A BIT.
44:03 JOE: THIS IS IT, RIGHT? DO WE HAVE COMMS?
44:07 THERE WE GO. >> 7, 6, 5, 4, 3, 2, 1.
44:22 JOE: WE ARE NOW COUNTING UP WITH LIFT OFF OF THE ROCKET JUST NOW
44:26 CLEARING THE TOWER. ED, GIVE US THE PLAY-BY-PLAY.
44:39 ED: SO FAR, EVERYTHING NORMAL. THE NEXT 90 SECONDS --
44:44 [INDISCERNIBLE] THAT IS THE MOMENT WHERE THEY
44:50 ARE UNDER MAXIMUM AERODYNAMIC PRESSURE.
44:56 THAT IS WHERE THE AIR RESISTANCE IS GREATEST.
45:01 AND THEN, WE WILL GET STAGE SEPARATION OF THOSE TWO PARTS OF
45:05 THE STARSHIP SYSTEM AROUND THE 2:30 MARK.
45:09 THE REAL DEMONSTRATION IS ABOUT 6:30 IN, PART ONE, WHEN THEY TRY
45:15 TO CATCH THE BOOSTER, THE FIRST STAGE, AT THE SAME TOWER IT
45:20 LIFTED OFF, WITH WHAT THEY CALL THE CHOPSTICKS.
45:25 IN 23 HOURS, AFTER ORBITING THE EARTH AND BRINGING VERY
45:31 INTERESTING TRAJECTORY AND CORRIDOR OVER THE TEXAS DESERT,
45:36 BACK TO THE SAME LAUNCHPAD, THE SPACECRAFT WILL TRY TO BE CAUGHT
45:39 BY SPACEX IN WHAT WOULD BE AN ABSOLUTE FIRST.
45:44 KAILEY: JUST INCREDIBLE TO THINK ABOUT THE TECHNOLOGICAL
45:45 ADVANCEMENT HERE. THIS IS FIGHT 15.
45:50 HAVE THEY MADE ADJUSTMENTS SINCE FLIGHT 14 TO BETTER FACILITATE
45:56 THE ATTEMPTS ED: ED: TO MAKE THIS GO SMOOTHER?
45:59 ED: THIS IS FLIGHT 15. IT IS THE 40TH ITERATION OF THE
46:02 SYSTEM. IT HAS THE WORDS "DON'T PANIC"
46:09 STENCILED ON THE SIDE WITH THE NAME OF THE CRAFT.
46:15 GIVEN TODAY, THAT IS AN APT DESCRIPTION GOING THROUGH THE
46:16 PROCESS. WATCHING ON BLOOMBERG
46:19 TELEVISION, YOU WILL SEE THE TILES ON THE SCREEN.
46:22 THERE ARE 18,000 OF THOSE CERAMIC HEATPROOF TILES.
46:30 EACH MISSION IS NOT GOING TO JUST BE ABOUT LANDING SAFELY BUT
46:33 THE INTEGRITY OF THE HEATSHIELD. THOSE TILES MAKE UP THE
46:35 HEATSHIELD. THAT IS A REALLY BIG PART OF THE
46:41 ENGINEERING THAT GOES INTO THE RAPID REUSABILITY.
46:44 WE ARE ABOUT TO HAVE THE SEPARATION.
46:46 WE MIGHT PAUSE FOR THAT. JOE: THERE WE GO.
46:53 CAN WE HEAR THE COMMS? THERE WE GO.
46:56 >> SUCCESSFUL SEPARATION. WE HAVE SIX LIT.
47:03 WE HAD A 32-ENGINE LIFT BACK. >> NOMINAL.
47:06 >> THAT IS NOT GOING TO BE A CONCERN FOR OUR LANDING
47:10 MANEUVERS, SO LOOKING GOOD THERE.
47:13 THE BOOST BACK BURNING WILL CONTINUE FOR A COUPLE MORE
47:15 SECONDS. WE HAVE BOOST BACK SHUTDOWN.
47:25 SO, THE BOOSTER HAS DONE ITS BOOST BACK SHUTDOWN.
47:29 IT'S ON ITS WAY BACK TO US AT STARBASE.
47:33 THE BOOSTER AND THE TOWER WILL CONTINUE TO DO THESE AUTOMATED
47:34 CHECKS TO MAKE SURE EVERYTHING LOOKS GOOD.
47:39 WE DO HAVE THE MANUAL OPERATOR STATUS SET TO GO FOR A BOOSTER
47:42 RETURN, SO WE ARE CURRENTLY EXPECTING A SUPERHEAVY BOOSTER
47:46 IN ABOUT THREE MINUTES FROM NOW TO HOPEFULLY COME BACK HERE.
47:51 WE HAVE SIX RAPTOR ENGINES LIT ON STARSHIP.
47:55 THEY WILL GO FOR ANOTHER 4.5 MINUTES UNTIL THEY SHUT DOWN IN
47:58 SPACE. JOE: WE HAVE A COUPLE OF MOMENTS
48:04 BEFORE THE MAIN MOMENT. WE ARE WATCHING SPACEX SHARES IN
48:07 AFTER HOURS TRADING. HOW IMPORTANT IS THE SUCCESS OF
48:16 THIS MISSION TO THE NEAR TERM FUTURE OF THE STOCK?
48:19 ED: EVERYTHING SPACEX WAS TO DO IS PREDICATED ON STARSHIP
48:22 WORKING AND BEING RAPIDLY AND FULLY REUSABLE.
48:31 WHAT SPACEX OUTLINED IN ITS IPO WAS A CONSTELLATION OF DATA
48:35 CENTERS IN THE FORM OF SATELLITES AROUND THE EARTH.
48:39 STARSHIP IS THE ONLY SYSTEM CAPABLE OF DELIVERING THAT
48:41 PAYLOAD TO ORBIT. A LOT OF THE AUDIENCE MAY NOT BE
48:47 FAMILIAR WITH SPACEX. THEY MIGHT SAY, WHAT ARE YOU
48:53 TALKING ABOUT WHEN I SAY THE FOUNDING PRINCIPLE OF THE
48:56 COMPANY WAS TO MAKE HUMANKIND A MULTI PLANETARY SPECIES.
48:59 THEY REALLY BELIEVE THAT. WHATEVER THE COMMERCIAL
49:02 AMBITIONS ARE FOR DATA CENTERS IN SPACE AND AI, ELON MUSK AND
49:07 HIS COLLEAGUES ALSO BELIEVE STARSHIP IS THE VEHICLE THAT
49:09 GETS HUMANS TO MARS. ITS ABILITY TO WORK IS IMPORTANT
49:13 FROM THAT STANDPOINT. TAXPAYERS SHOULD PAY ATTENTION
49:20 AND LOOK AT WHAT SPACEX IS OBLIGATED TO PROVIDE FOR NASA IN
49:24 THE UNITED STATES GETTING HUMANS BACK TO THE MOON BECAUSE THIS
49:29 VEHICLE WILL ALSO PLAY A ROLE. JOE: JUST ABOUT ONE MINUTE AWAY
49:32 FROM THE POTENTIAL CAPTURE. KAILEY: WE ARE EXPECTING TO SEE
49:38 THE HEAVY LANDING BURN START IN ABOUT 50 SECONDS.
49:41 JUST AFTER SIX MINUTES INTO THE FLIGHT.
49:45 AND THEN THEY WILL CATCH IT BETWEEN THE CHOPSTICKS, AS ED
49:48 HAS DESCRIBED. ALL OF THIS WAS LAUNCHED FROM
49:52 AND THE LANDING WILL HAPPEN IN TEXAS.
49:54 WITH THE AFTERMATH OF THE MIDTERMS AND ELON MUSK NOT
49:59 GETTING THE CANDIDATES TO VICTORY HE WANTED IN TEXAS, IS
50:04 THERE ANY CONVERSATION ABOUT FUTURE OPERATIONS AT THIS
50:05 LOCATION? SHOULD WE EXPECT THIS ALL COMING
50:10 FROM CAPE CANAVERAL FOR THE TIME BEING?
50:14 ED: SPACEX SAYS IT IS A MASSIVELY JOB CREATING
50:18 ENTERPRISE, NOT JUST IN TEXAS BUT IN FLORIDA.
50:23 THEY JUST COMPLETED ADJACENT TO THE EXISTING FACILITIES A NEW
50:25 LAUNCHPAD AT KENNEDY SPACE CENTER.
50:30 KAILEY: THERE IS THE BURN. ED: I WILL PAUSE HERE SO WE CAN
50:32 SEE WHAT HAPPENS. HOW ABOUT THAT?
50:36 JOE: AMAZING. >> 13 ENGINES, DOWN TO FIVE NOW,
50:43 DROP DOWN TO THREE SHORTLY. >> WE JUST GOT THE SONIC BOOM.
50:49 [LAUGHTER] WOW.
50:52 JOE: WOW. >> SUCCESSFUL SPLASHDOWN OF THE
50:57 SUPERHEAVY BOOSTER BACK INTO THE WATER OFF THE COAST.
51:05 EVERYTHING LOOKING GREAT ON THE SHIP.
51:06 [LAUGHTER] WOW.
51:09 WE COULD FEEL THE RUMBLE OF THE SPLASHDOWN THERE.
51:14 KAILEY: ED LUDLOW, THAT WAS NOT A CATCH BETWEEN THE CHOPSTICKS.
51:19 THERE WAS A SONIC BOOM. IS THAT A PROBLEM?
51:23 ED: WE ARE CLOSE TO THE END OF THE PROGRAM SO I WILL ANSWER
51:26 JOE'S ORIGINAL QUESTION ABOUT THE STOCK DOWN 2%.
51:31 THEY SCRUBBED THE ATTEMPT TO CATCH THE BOOSTER FOR SOME
51:33 TECHNICAL REASON. THERE ARE CONTINGENCIES IN PLACE
51:36 FOR A SAFE SPLASHDOWN IN THE GULF.
51:43 LAUREN ON-SITE AT STARBASE JUST SIT ME A MESSAGE SAYING "WOW, IT
51:47 JUST EXPLODED IN FRONT OF US." DISAPPOINTMENT REFLECTED IN THE
51:50 AFTER HOURS TRADE. WE NEED TO FIND OUT IF THEY WILL
51:57 ATTEMPT TO CATCH THE SPACECRAFT WHICH THEY HAVE NOT ATTEMPTED.
52:01 THAT WAS DUE TO TAKE PLACE ABOUT 22 HOURS FROM NOW.
52:05 BOOM, LITERALLY. KAILEY: A SONIC BOOM, AT THAT.
52:11 JOE: A SONIC BOOM FOLLOWED BY SPLASHDOWN.
52:14 NOT WHAT WE HAD IN LINE FOR TONIGHT.
52:18 WE COULD HAVE A REALLY IMPORTANT DEVELOPMENT 22 HOURS AWAY.
52:20 KAILEY: ED LUDLOW, THANK YOU SO MUCH.
52:23 WE WILL SEE WHAT HAPPENS WITH THE SECOND COMPONENT AND WHETHER
52:28 A CHOPSTICK CATCH WILL HAPPEN ALTHOUGH THE FIRST WAS SCRUBBED.
52:30 THANKS FOR JOINING US ON "BALANCE OF POWER."
52:34 THE NATIONWIDE GROUND STOP IS STILL IN EFFECT WITH MANY
52:37 QUESTIONS REMAINING UNANSWERED. THE TRUMP ADMINISTRATION IS
52:40 SAYING IT DOES NOT APPEAR TO BE A THREAT TO THE PUBLIC, ALTHOUGH
52:44 NOT RULING ANYTHING OUT EITHER. STICK WITH BLOOMBERG FOR
52:47 COVERAGE AND. HAVE A GREAT WEEKEND.
52:48 . HOPE YOU ARE NOT TRAVELING.
52:49 THIS IS BLOOMBERG.
Nvidia’s Board CEO Hunt, Stocks Finish Week Higher, Retail in Focus full transcript
0:01 The countdown is on. Everything you need to get the edge at
0:05 the end of the market day. This is the close.
0:11 A downbeat end to a week of upheaval for the AI economy.
0:14 Live from studio two at Bloomberg headquarters in New York.
0:17 I'm Vonnie Quinn and I'm Bailey. Live shows.
0:19 We're kicking you off to. The closing bell is here in the US.
0:22 Varney with a bit of red on the screen. A little bit of red on the screen.
0:25 Could be worse. It was worse earlier, but it is still
0:28 down, particularly for the Nasdaq 100, down 1.2%.
0:31 The Dow actually trying to break into the green as we head into the final hour
0:35 of trading of Friday the 13th and obviously into the weekend, the Nasdaq
0:41 100, as I said, down 1.25%. You see the dollar index continuing to
0:44 climb Brent crude off its highs of the day, still above $96 a barrel.
0:49 That's impacting equities as well. Obviously beyond the big stories of the
0:53 week. And then that ten year yield up a couple
0:55 of basis points. We saw yields just a little bit lower at
0:58 the front end of the curve. After some more comments today, Boston's
1:02 Susan Collins saying she's also very much looking at potentially a rate hike
1:07 and maybe even quickening the pace of tightening a lot going on.
1:10 Let's take a look at some of the movers underneath the hood on a one week basis.
1:15 Yes, there's a read on the screen. Vonnie for the Nasdaq 100 still up 3.5%
1:19 on the week. Looking at some of those outperformance
1:21 and underperformers, though, all eyes and ears have been on Nvidia down 13%
1:26 this week. That is on pace for the worst weekly
1:28 performance since April 2025. If anyone remembers the tariffs and
1:33 obviously DBS in that in the cloud space, heavily relying on AI, heavily
1:37 relying on Nvidia down almost 10%, sharply underperforming and as much as
1:41 Nvidia is losing, there are some semi stocks winning.
1:44 AMD up almost 20% on the week, followed by Broadcom.
1:48 Those are your two top performers the Nasdaq 100 over the last week again.
1:52 Nvidia's pain showing up in the game. Well I'm glad you said it because AMD
1:56 down about 9% right now in today's trade.
1:58 So it just shows you how much they benefit of.
2:00 Is it whiplash though? It's like up and down, up and down.
2:03 Is it the potential for the loss of leadership?
2:05 I mean, we know that Renee House of arm was asked according to the FTC.
2:09 Was Lisa Sue also asked. I mean, just who knows?
2:12 I think it's going to take a long time for this failed, but this is
2:14 particularly ironic. Microsoft and Nvidia, they have
2:18 converged at the same market capitalization right now.
2:21 Can you believe that the green line is Nvidia?
2:24 It was up into the heavens and now it has come down to Microsoft level.
2:27 And as we know, the Microsoft outage has impacted the whole entire world, from
2:33 government agencies to businesses to trading to just general folks trying to
2:38 get about their day. And obviously Microsoft hasn't really
2:41 been suffering too much from that. But again, I just thought it was a very
2:45 interesting thing to behold. Nvidia coming down to Microsoft's
2:48 valuation. Well, let's kick things off now with
2:51 Chris Gallop, head market strategist at the Franklin Templeton Institute.
2:55 Chris, when will all this have shaken out enough that we can come to some
2:59 conclusions about all of this repricing? Well, it's as you said, I agree.
3:05 It probably takes a little bit. You know, I think what's really
3:07 interesting, though, is that this rotation has been underway for the
3:12 better part of two years. And what I mean is, if you think about
3:17 Nvidia as a good example, is underperformed the S&P by 8% for the
3:20 last two years. So market leadership really has been
3:23 rotating quietly for almost 24 months. And I think what we saw in October and
3:28 certainly last week was, you know, the most violent part of it, I think it's
3:33 probably closer to the end than we are to the beginning.
3:37 When you say the end, do you mean the end of the rotation?
3:39 Do you mean the end of the selloff in certain stocks doing a little more
3:43 fragility in the AI trade? Yeah, I think the pounding that's
3:47 happened here and large cap growth last week was really, you know, an
3:51 exclamation point on Thursday. It's probably going to shop around here
3:55 for a little bit. But I think, you know, by and large the
3:57 worst is probably behind those stocks. I do think we'll continue to see high
4:02 levels of volatility. I do think the rotation is going to, you
4:05 know, stay in full force. I just my point there was I think the
4:08 risk reward at the margin is better now. And some of the bigger names, the
4:12 hyperscalers for example, maybe some of the semis than it was, you know, let's
4:16 say in May and June. Well, Chris, with that in mind, just
4:18 thinking through some of the pain that I've been hearing from the hedge fund
4:21 community in particular, but also long. How are you thinking about that?
4:24 Potential areas that you could pile into heading into your and you mentioned
4:28 hyperscalers. Is that an area that you would look to
4:30 outperform, you know, ahead of anthropic next week and going into the
4:33 Thanksgiving holiday? Right, Billy.
4:36 So anthropic is the next big test, right?
4:38 But I think the multiples in evaluations have reset here very significantly for
4:42 those, you know, big hyperscalers names. And so at the margin, as I said, I think
4:46 the risk reward gets better. I don't think you need to be in a hurry.
4:49 I think you need to be diversified. Right.
4:51 That's been our call for the last couple of years.
4:53 Yeah, I want to stay with that call. But people forget that when stock prices
4:57 come down, you know what else is coming down?
4:59 The risk and owning them. And people forget that.
5:01 And I just want to remind your viewers of that fact.
5:04 Well, because I want to look at it thinking about some other areas in the
5:07 market, keeping an eye on the two year yield 4.8% right now, markets pricing in
5:10 a hike next month. When we think about it from across
5:13 aspect perspective, where are you thinking clients should be putting more
5:18 capital to work? Is it still very much an equity market,
5:20 or are we seeing kind of the bond market playing out and shaking out over the
5:23 coming days? Yeah.
5:25 Great question. So your reference to your yields is
5:27 something I watch closely every day and talk to our clients about.
5:31 And really the relationship between two year yields and the federal funds rate.
5:34 So now it's about 80 basis points. That's pricing at three heights on a go
5:38 for basis. We definitely get one in December
5:40 probably January. And it looks like March.
5:43 I think at the margin as you're picking away, um, using the weakness in the
5:47 volatility to be your friend and equity space at the same time, you basically
5:51 run the same play in the bond market. So any significant backup in yields from
5:55 here? About 514 last trades north of five and
5:58 a quarter toward 550. And we saw that a few months ago.
6:01 We want to get on the buy side there in Muni space.
6:04 And, you know, in core bond space. I don't think you need to be in a hurry.
6:08 But I think you also need to be mindful that you're starting.
6:10 Yield in fixed income is roughly going to approximate your five year annualized
6:15 return on a realized basis. So use the weakness in equities, use the
6:18 backup in yields. Don't think you need to be in a hurry,
6:21 but you need to be prepared to act. Chris, just curious.
6:25 One more question, if you don't mind about the eye trade.
6:29 So many people have been worried about this trade for so long, and yet it's,
6:32 you know, it's been fine, right? And sure, we've had some volatility in
6:36 the last few days, but really the Nasdaq is down 1.25%.
6:39 It's not going to kill any portfolio out there right.
6:43 I'm curious though what is the smart money doing though because there's
6:46 enough potholes here for them to maybe move on to the next trade.
6:49 It's a little bit too fragile now. Know, I think that, you know, when
6:53 you're running money, you're always assessing the risk reward for, you know,
6:57 with the names that you own. And you have a list on your whiteboard
7:00 in your office of names that you want to own.
7:03 And so PMS are going through making sure they understand their, you know, their
7:07 base case, their bull case, in their bear case.
7:09 And as stocks trade, the scenarios change.
7:12 Right. So the think of it this way.
7:15 Think of it as the notion of upgrading portfolios.
7:18 And that's what active stock selectors are in the process of doing here now and
7:22 rethinking it a little bit. Has the story really changed that much.
7:25 I'm not so sure it has. The problem is, if you look at stocks
7:29 that seem like they might be undervalued, you know, some consumers
7:31 stocks and so on, a lot of that economy is a little bit dependent on the eye
7:35 trade as well. So is it really the time to, you know,
7:39 rotation to those sectors of the economy.
7:41 Or would you be looking for something just a little bit more, maybe risky, but
7:43 also, you know, with a little extra reward if things do go wrong.
7:49 Yeah, I, I've never been a big fan of rotating, you know, into a defensive
7:53 posture. The multiples on those stocks are high.
7:55 I mean they're great companies. I'm not a big fan of that because I
7:58 think that can wax and wane very quickly.
8:00 I think what you want to try and do here, certainly when you're running a
8:03 portfolio, you need the portfolio. Excuse me to be diverse.
8:06 So you want to try and use the pullbacks here to get some exposure.
8:11 But the other thing with the eye trade that I don't think I don't hear a lot
8:15 about talked, you know, talked about on TV or even read.
8:18 Is this that the next phase of this entire thing, we spend all of our time
8:22 talking about the build up, the CapEx. Got it.
8:25 The next phase of this is what companies are able to harness the technology to
8:31 improve efficiency, productivity and ultimately profitability.
8:35 That's where the puck is going. And I'd say in the last two quarters,
8:38 we're starting to hear from S&P 500 components, the companies, the
8:42 management teams that's starting to happen.
8:45 So I would put that in baseball terms at the first inning of a nine inning game.
8:49 And I think that's really what that's something that we really need to pay
8:52 attention to on a go for bases. Ultimately, that is going to be the
8:56 measure of discernible ROI. And I think that's what everybody's been
8:58 waiting to see. And I think we're starting to see some
9:00 of that. All right, Chris, thank you so much for
9:02 speaking to us this Friday 13th. That is Chris Kelly, head market
9:06 strategist at the Franklin Templeton Institute.
9:09 Coming up, growth in the era of stubborn inflation.
9:12 We'll talk to the CEO of Exemplar Luxury Group, the parent company of Saks Fifth
9:16 Avenue and Neiman Marcus, about achieving profitability and what he sees
9:20 ahead for the consumer. Plus, from the department store to the
9:23 runway, Paige Thomas, the new CEO of Rent the Runway, joins the clothes for
9:28 her first televised interview since taking the top job at the luxury rental
9:32 business. And we'll end on a high note with a very
9:36 special conversation. Country music legend Carrie Underwood
9:39 joins us to talk her latest venture in the world of wellness.
9:43 All that and more. This is the clothes on Bloomberg.
9:48 Um.
10:02 I think amazing CEO. Sad to see, uh, him leave, but, you
10:07 know, Nvidia will survive. Uh, and, you know, I think, sure, the
10:11 company will do great. Pershing square CEO Bill Ackman they're
10:17 offering his thoughts on Jensen Wong's departure from India.
10:20 Our next guest says Nvidia's board not only failed the company, but Jensen Wong
10:25 as well. Joining us live is Randall Peterson,
10:27 professor of organizational behavior and founding director at the London Business
10:31 School Leadership Institute. Randall, you're going to have to explain
10:34 those remarks because, uh, I don't think the board told Jensen to have an affair
10:38 with a spy. So what do you mean?
10:41 No, of course not. But what I mean is, um, this could have
10:45 been a handle. Much of this could have been handled
10:47 really outside of the media attention, if they'd have been on top of things.
10:51 Um, advised help, figured out what to do so that when the media picks it up, we
10:56 can say, look, we've dealt with it, and, you know, it doesn't go through the
10:59 public execution that we've seen. What do they do now, Randall?
11:04 I mean, I imagine you would give them a ten out of ten for how quickly they
11:08 moved. What's the next step?
11:10 Do they need to put in place a successor quickly, or do they have time to just
11:15 let things reset with Chris? Look, the sudden departure of any CEO is
11:21 destabilizing for the business. So the most important thing is to
11:24 stabilize the ship first. Um, and the most typical appointment is
11:29 typically the CFO, because the CFO is the other person with the kind of whole
11:32 organization view, which is exactly what they've done.
11:35 I just hope they don't rush into appointing a CEO without really thinking
11:39 through what they want, what they need, or not necessarily just taking the
11:43 obvious, you know, first candidate. So they take the time and do it well.
11:48 Then they, you know, there's no reason why that business can't continue to
11:53 thrive. Um, the fundamentals are really strong,
11:57 right? They just need to find the right leader
11:58 to take on the business right now. Well, Randall, how do you think about
12:02 the fact that we are seeing a CFO step into the CEO seat, like, from all for
12:05 all intents and purposes, some of the conversations I have with investors is
12:09 what the business is kind of set up to succeed and come along for the next two
12:12 years. You have bought quite a bit of time, and
12:14 you're having someone step into the spotlight who knows the business.
12:17 Just walk us through how you think about kind of that, I guess button being
12:21 handed, haphazardly rushed, or what you would expect from here on out for the
12:25 kind of coming weeks and months. Yeah, going to the CFO is kind of a
12:30 normal business, and in fact, the most likely appointment is probably the CFO.
12:35 That is not unique to this business. It's kind of standard.
12:40 Um, the best way to become a CEO is to have been CFO.
12:43 Well, how to do that? And I think that would, you know,
12:46 whether but I would want it to be predetermined if that's not what they
12:49 think ultimately that the business needs.
12:52 Well, it is again, arguably the most high profile company in the world.
12:56 I mean, again, maybe behind Elon Musk or Mark Zuckerberg in terms of people who,
13:01 uh, Main Street and Wall Street can point towards, especially given the the
13:04 AI boom as it is right now. How do you think about the polarization,
13:08 though, of these characters? We have built an economy.
13:10 We have built a market increasingly on making CEOs who historically maybe would
13:15 give a media interview here or there into superstars.
13:20 Yeah, we certainly have. And the superstar CEO, the highly
13:22 charismatic CEO, what we know from research is it draws a lot of attention,
13:27 a lot of investment, not necessarily based on the what's behind the business.
13:33 Right. And that's where I think we, you know,
13:36 they need to be careful to think, right. That draws a lot of positive attention,
13:40 right? Because there's no doubt this guy's a
13:42 very charismatic character. Um, do they need that?
13:45 Or do they need someone who can run the business who may not be, uh, draw so
13:48 much attention? But you're absolutely right.
13:50 We have made stars out of of, uh, generation of tech leaders.
13:54 But it's not like we haven't done that before.
13:57 Right. Looking back, I mean, you know, over the
13:59 last three, 4 or 5 decades, you can probably you and I can probably both
14:03 name, um, you know, a fair list of CEOs who were charismatic, famous in their
14:09 day. They don't always end up, you know, that
14:13 positive in our final evaluation of them.
14:15 Mhm. Because a lot will depend on what
14:17 follows. One of the things that folks made
14:19 initially, I want to say before the formal resignation, formal ousting took
14:23 place, was comparing it to Steve Jobs 1.0 when he was pushed out of Apple.
14:27 What do you look at for history for comparables?
14:30 Obviously, this isn't something that happens every given, uh, every year.
14:35 I think that's a very reasonable part of, uh, kind of look at it.
14:40 And of course, Steve Jobs got like three bites of the cherry before they, you
14:45 know, they finally found the right place for him.
14:48 Uh, and, you know, which wasn't necessarily in the leadership role, but
14:51 in the CTO role. So that was his true talent.
14:55 Um, whether that will happen here or not.
14:58 We'll see. Right.
14:59 I mean, the guy's clearly got a lot of talent, a lot to offer still, even if he
15:03 wasn't CEO. Although they may not want to.
15:06 Given the scandal. And I suppose that's the difference
15:07 between Steve Jobs. And here is it didn't have that.
15:12 You know, the smell of the scandal we've got here.
15:14 Recording suggests he won't be playing a future role in the company, though.
15:17 Of course, these things can change, Randall.
15:19 What's the lesson here? So obviously, he was a founder.
15:22 There was no succession plan in place. He had a very, you know, individual type
15:27 of leadership structure where there were 60 direct reports, but he only owned
15:32 3.6% of the company is the lesson for founders that they should really make
15:36 sure that they own enough of the company, that it's a real problem if the
15:39 board wants to get rid of them. Or is the lesson for boards that if
15:42 you're going to have a founder doing it his way, you don't want them owning, you
15:47 know, more voting shares. The real lesson of this is these
15:53 founders, CEOs like this. Elon Musk and others is you need some
15:59 some. You need a board that will positively
16:02 challenge you, really challenge you so that you can preemptively deal with
16:06 whatever the outside world may think about what you're doing.
16:10 Right. It's actually in your interests to do
16:13 so. Mhm.
16:14 Um, you know, a lot of I mean, who wants to have somebody, you know, hanging over
16:18 them, a board, a chair, whatever, you know, you know, constantly saying, look,
16:23 is this an issue. Is that an issue.
16:25 Is that an issue. It's annoying in the moment, which is
16:28 why, you know, people like this try to avoid it, but it's actually in their
16:32 interest to have it to make sure that you don't make those kind of mistakes.
16:36 Or if you do that, they're dealt with out of the limelight.
16:40 And I think that that's what I meant by my first comment about if he'd had the
16:45 right kind of board, the right people around him really questioning him and
16:50 not just, you know, hoping the money keeps coming, um, he probably would have
16:54 meant we could well have ended up with a somewhat different story here, and one
16:57 that may be not as damaging to him and certainly not as damaging to him being
17:01 well, and that's what we believe precipitated it all in the end.
17:04 Anyway, the general counsel going to his house and really just putting it up to
17:06 him. But yeah, I don't know why leaders don't
17:09 tend to want people who will push back on them.
17:12 It's a question. No, exactly.
17:13 And that's something that we want to do. It's it's the uninformed and but
17:18 we've got to leave it there and I'm sure we will have plenty to talk about is
17:21 this board has a new job again trying to find a replacement for Jensen.
17:23 While Randall Petersen, the professor of organizational behavior and founding
17:27 director of the London Business School Leadership Institute.
17:31 Well, coming up, we'll break down what the blue wave in Congress means for the
17:34 federal budget going forward. With Maya macGuineas of the Committee
17:38 for a Responsible Federal Budget. This is the close on Bloomberg.
17:56 New data from the Treasury Department showing the gap in the federal budget
17:59 grew to $404 billion in October, up 42% from the prior year.
18:05 It comes as the new Democratic majority in the Congress looks to reverse
18:09 spending cuts made by the Trump administration.
18:11 Joining us live now is Maia McGinnis, president of the Committee for a
18:15 Responsible Federal Budget. Maia, just thinking through some of the
18:18 data, thinking through the blue wave that we saw.
18:21 How do you view the current economic backdrop, expectations for the fed to
18:25 hike again with the fact that, hey, now we're eventually going to have to talk
18:28 about the federal deficit at some point sooner than later.
18:31 Now that we've all, at least for the interim, maybe moved past the NIMBYism
18:35 of data centers. Yeah.
18:37 Well, I mean, I think the deficit is absolutely related to the core issue of
18:42 this, the midterm elections, which is affordability.
18:45 So the first thing to keep in mind is that this new Congress will be
18:48 inheriting basically the worst fiscal situation ever outside of emergencies.
18:55 So near record levels, debt deficit, interest payments, you name it, any of
18:59 the indicators has been not only warning, as I have been for years, but
19:03 the pace of deterioration almost seems to be quickening in a lot of different
19:07 areas. So that's number one.
19:10 Number two, there have been a lot of promises made to get at this really
19:14 difficult issue of affordability, high prices, high mortgages, etc.
19:19 but the promises that have been made in many ways are things that would give tax
19:24 cuts, spending increases, none of which people are talking about paying for.
19:27 And they would make this terrible fiscal situation worse.
19:31 And ultimately, it's big budget deficits that are one of the major contributors
19:35 to inflation, high interest rates, lower wages.
19:39 And so all the things that are contributing to the affordability
19:41 problem. So we are now about to face the reality
19:44 of a bad fiscal picture, and the difference between political promises
19:48 and the actual policies that could get at the center of some of the things they
19:51 would like to make improvements in. Maya, how can you know, politicians even
19:59 start thinking about the budget deficit when inflation is such a problem?
20:03 Gas prices are still incredibly high, and all of the reasons that Republicans
20:08 were voted out in terms of affordability and so on are all still valid and
20:13 nothing has been fixed. Well, that's sort of the beauty of
20:17 needing to fix the fiscal situation and the fact the benefit of fixing the
20:21 fiscal situation. One of those tangible benefits is it
20:25 will have less pressure on interest rates and prices or inflation.
20:29 So that's the good news. The bad news is nobody really
20:32 understands that linkage. It wasn't sold to voters that way.
20:35 People haven't talked about it that way. And I think one of the challenges is how
20:38 do you get credible voices from both parties and outside of government,
20:42 explaining that fiscal responsibility is a central tenet of affordability.
20:47 Um, and that's this. Herein lies the biggest problem with
20:50 getting our fiscal house in order, which is everybody hates the solutions.
20:54 Nobody in the right mind is really eager to have tax increases or spending
20:58 reductions. But after decades of borrowing, that is
21:02 what we're going to have to face at some point.
21:04 Um, and there are few, you know, there there aren't the Ross Perot's out there
21:07 anymore making those promises. So there's not a mandate for it.
21:11 I think we need to have, uh, some leadership to help put this back on the
21:16 agenda and help voters understand that anything else will just be kind of a
21:20 patch on the affordability challenges if you give people tax cuts for gasoline,
21:24 for instance, that is not going to have any sustaining effects.
21:28 In my just about 30s here, just wondering what you're looking forward to
21:31 in terms of data or even just commentary from government officials as we again
21:36 head into the week before Thanksgiving and the year will be over before we know
21:40 it. The thing I'm really looking forward to,
21:42 and I'm not sure if that's the right term, but you're seeing what happens for
21:45 the end of the year spending package. That's often where everybody throws in
21:49 everything and the kitchen sink. I think we're at the real risk of that.
21:52 But you do have these bad fiscal numbers starting to make a lot of our political
21:57 leaders nervous, both in dealing something that and doing this other
22:01 issue, fixing Social Security. So I'm hoping that they will rein in
22:05 their, uh, tendencies to make this a huge Christmas tree and try to offset
22:09 any of the end of the year packages before we turn to next year.
22:12 And the big agenda that's going to be coming down is a few more workdays for
22:16 us than there are for everybody in Congress.
22:18 I think a third to say, Maya, thank you so much for joining us today.
22:22 That is Maya McGinnis, president of the Committee for a Responsible Federal
22:26 Budget. All right.
22:28 Coming down. Coming up, we're going to drill down on
22:30 one big economic needle mover, and that is oil.
22:32 We'll micro founder and CEO Jeff Curry joins us live to discuss what's ahead.
22:39 We'll also take you through the close this Friday the 13th after an incredible
22:42 week. This is the close on the break.
22:51 And it's just about 330 in New York City.
22:55 This is the countdown to the close. I'm Vonnie Quinn and I'm Bailey.
22:58 Live. Schultz.
22:59 Vonnie. All eyes have been on Nvidia, but
23:01 there's a lot going on in DC. There's a lot going on outside of the
23:04 equity markets. Talking oil, talking fertilizers,
23:07 talking goals, all the thing. Then.
23:08 Um, yeah. I mean, I don't know if you noticed it,
23:09 but Brent was almost at $98 a barrel again earlier, but we're way back off
23:13 that now. It seems to have something to do with
23:15 President Trump extending the Jones Act waivers.
23:18 So the shipping waiver for oil and fertilizer, I mean, it's good for a
23:21 couple of bucks and the extension is good for 90 days.
23:25 But really, what is it going to do in the overall scheme of things?
23:27 Well, I think that's the point, right? It comes back to what's going on in the
23:30 Strait of Hormuz. What's actually going to happen with the
23:32 ongoing war in Iran? You can put together as many stopgap
23:36 things like extending this waiver for 90 days.
23:38 But ultimately, when push comes to shove, you have to kind of find some
23:41 kind of resolution that truly ends the issue.
23:44 Yeah. And, you know, the prices of oil that we
23:46 follow, they've been pricing in headlines.
23:49 Right. And but the actual reality on the ground
23:51 has been priced in by other things, products, you know, far away from the
23:55 pumped month Brent and WTI futures contracts.
23:59 But you know what. Let's talk to somebody who knows a lot
24:01 more about this than we do. Jeff Curry, CEO and founder at Real
24:05 Macro and senior advisor at Carlyle. Jeff, thanks for joining.
24:09 We will get to oil in just a second. But I do want to ask you about gold,
24:13 because we had this incredible run back about 4000 and suddenly we're back to
24:17 about 3800 and change again. What is gold trading off right now?
24:23 I it's the perfect place to begin. And you know, what it's trading off is
24:28 there's a dollar shortage right now. Um, you know, between what was going on
24:33 with the video pullback and Nasdaq, people having to create liquidity there.
24:37 Then you have all of that dollar funding around all that debt issuance around I.
24:42 And then you have the energy security. And then you have central banks in
24:46 places like the Middle East trying to create liquidity.
24:49 And what, you know, I to point out, gold is a hedge against a solvency crisis
24:54 down the road. It is never a hedge against liquidity
24:57 that always goes down. So when you see gold going down like
25:00 this, that's usually a signal that people are selling gold to raise cash
25:04 for liquidity. Also, copper is down.
25:07 Why? Because when you have a liquidity type
25:10 of event like we have right now, you sell these hard asset commodities to be
25:15 able to create the liquidity. So the question is, does this evolve
25:18 into something more serious or do we get through it and then we, you know, start
25:23 in the basement again. And when I think about commodities,
25:25 there's two things that drive them scarcity.
25:28 In debasement you can think about scarcity is the fear of running out of
25:31 the commodity like we had with diesel and oil and other commodities.
25:35 Debasement is the fear of running out of money.
25:38 And so when we think about when oil first went down, the scarcity fear went
25:43 away. And then the deficit fears came back
25:46 again. And oil our gold rally.
25:48 So oil down, gold up. But as you're pointing out right now,
25:52 gold is coming down. Which is telling you right now what you
25:55 have is a liquidity situation. Yeah.
25:57 Jeff, are you saying that we should actually look to gold to see how serious
26:00 this the Nvidia affair is? Absolutely.
26:03 When you when you go to one of these environments like this and people get
26:07 really scared about what's going on in their equity portfolios, the first thing
26:12 that they turn to you to cell is almost always gold.
26:15 Um, and then it's not only just a veneer.
26:17 You got the all of the debt issuance that was, you know, creating dollar
26:21 problems and the other things. The big sellers of this are a lot of the
26:24 central banks in places like the Middle East.
26:26 So the the only buyer in this market right now are the Chinese.
26:31 And by the way, the, the demand from Asian buyers of physical gold, um, this
26:36 last month was record level. So they see this thing go down sub 4000.
26:40 They start buying but they're fighting a wall selling, coming out of like central
26:44 banks in places like the Middle East trying to raise cash.
26:48 Um, and also from, um, you know, investors in the West dealing with
26:52 situations where it's going on and, you know, the I mean, yes.
26:55 Just one more question, though, on gold, what level would you look at for either
26:59 some support or kind of a look out below moment?
27:01 As you mentioned, we're south of 4000 right now.
27:03 It's about 38, 79 an ounce right now on gold.
27:07 Uh, you know, you get down in that 3750 range.
27:10 We saw, you know, a few weeks ago. You know, the bind really begins to kick
27:14 in, particularly from Asia. Okay.
27:16 Um, so, you know, the question is, you know, how high can it rally before the
27:20 selling starts to come in again? Um, you know, that's the big question.
27:24 But, you know, at this point right now, you know, I'm watching this liquidity,
27:27 dollar, liquidity. And you can look how strong the dollar
27:29 is because it's telling you, um, you know, that it's a it's, you know,
27:33 finding young greenbacks right now is a difficult thing to come by.
27:37 And so the easiest way to generate them is with gold.
27:39 So I would watch gold very carefully. Um, you know, if you start to seeing a
27:44 lot of weakness, it's telling you you got a problem with dollars.
27:47 You know, somebody actually made the argument.
27:49 I won't make it here either. But you are here.
27:51 But made the argument you watch gold over right now because really what?
27:55 And you look at any type of a serious crisis.
27:58 What happens? Gold settles down, the liquidity crisis
28:01 starts to become really significant. And then policymakers, central banks,
28:05 whatever set it and release the liquidity, that's when you get long the
28:09 gold and you're just off to the races. You know, you look at every event that's
28:12 ever occurred like that. That's when you lock and load on gold,
28:15 and that's when it really takes off. And when we look at commodities, when we
28:19 look at oil, we were talking about, uh, crude right now, just south of $90 a
28:23 barrel. When we look at expectations from, uh,
28:26 the Strait of Hormuz, you made a point comparing it to Schrodinger Strait.
28:29 How are you thinking about products, the knock on effects from what's going on in
28:33 Iran right now and what that ultimately means, not only for oil, but throughout
28:37 the entire supply chain, uh, here in the U.S.
28:39 and around the world. Well, that's the reason why I call it
28:42 the Schrodinger straight, because, you know, like a Schrodinger cat, it's
28:45 either it can be both dead and alive at the same time.
28:49 The strait can be opened and closed at the same time.
28:51 And the reason why I say that is, yeah, we're getting volume out right now,
28:55 which caps the upside on oil. Why?
28:57 It struggles to go up towards 100. But let's not forget the next barrel is
29:03 not cheaper. So you have the supply out there, but
29:06 the cost is really high. Why?
29:07 It's a combination of transportation, logistics and, as you point out,
29:11 refining. And so when I'm looking at, you know,
29:14 the overall cost of those barrels. Yeah, you're getting them out, but
29:18 they're really expensive. And the way I could describe and I've
29:21 made this point, you know, for the last several years, the supercycle in
29:25 commodities that we're going through right now is what I like to call a
29:29 bubbling cauldron of little supply and demand imbalances.
29:32 You know, back in the 2000, it was, hey, all you have to do is get long the
29:36 upstream. And it just went up here.
29:38 I don't know, to be long transportation, oil on refining.
29:42 Do I want to be long insurance? The entire supply chain has different
29:46 bottlenecks. And sometimes one of those bottlenecks
29:49 engages and the others don't. So that's why I like to call it a
29:51 bubbling cauldron of the little supply and demand imbalances across the entire
29:56 supply. And I think it's a very illustrative
29:59 analogy, Jeff, should we be concerned that we haven't seen the worst of it in
30:03 terms of prices for things like fertilizers or farmers, you know, out of
30:07 the woods, or are they literally just waiting to see what's coming around the
30:09 corner? Oh, I think you got a lot more problems
30:13 down the road. I like to say, um, all other commodities
30:16 are dirt in diesel. And when you have, um, you know, diesel
30:21 prices, remember, diesel still like $6.16 at the pump.
30:25 You still have a $90 a barrel diesel crack, you know, and I think you're
30:28 making the point that, you know, these products are still tight.
30:31 So the ramifications of this further down on the cost of all sorts of
30:36 manufactured transportation goods that we're going to feel this way into 2027,
30:41 this is not a one and done type of event.
30:44 Um, the ramifications are further, I think we need to bring it back to
30:47 agriculture. Not only do you have the problems going
30:51 on with, um, you know, the fertilizer, but let's not forget the Ukrainians have
30:55 taken out the Black Sea grain corridor. You've lost, you know, shortages there,
30:59 there they there's talk of a deal which has brought wheat prices down.
31:02 But the reality is you still have have disruptions.
31:05 And let's not forget El Nino. So you have the weather.
31:10 I could call it the three x. You have the client, you know, the
31:13 climate shock. You have the conflict shock, and then
31:16 you have the cost shock with higher diesel.
31:18 So you put it together. It's a it's a toxic concoction.
31:22 Well, there's a fourth siege, Jeff. China I mean is China going to help out
31:26 here by not, you know, experiencing as much demand?
31:31 I think in copper you're already seeing a copper is off because let's take this
31:35 dollar this dollar squeeze. It's going to the dollar shortage.
31:38 The one that really impacts is China has a credit impact.
31:41 Because when you have the dollar this strong, it puts a cap on how much that
31:46 they can lower their own interest rates. So it starts to create credit problems
31:50 in China. And then let's not forget you know you
31:53 when you're trying to raise you know that these commodities are priced in
31:56 dollars. You need to raise dollars.
31:57 You don't you. So you reduce you have an inventory.
31:59 Basically you dump your, your your copper to raise cash.
32:03 At the same time you have credit squeeze in the ability for China to grow.
32:08 So you know this right here I'm very cautious on you know, usually I'm
32:11 pounding the table on copper. Rah rah rah.
32:13 I'd be a little cautious on on copper, you know, in the metal space right now,
32:18 just given what's going on in China. All right, Jeff, we have to leave it
32:20 there. We covered Schrodinger's Straight, a
32:22 bubbling cauldron of supply and demand imbalances.
32:25 It was really like a Bloomberg TV bingo on this Friday.
32:28 So thank you so much. To Jeff Curry, CEO and founder at Real
32:31 Macro and senior advisor over at Carlyle.
32:34 Well, coming up, the outage felt around the world.
32:37 Microsoft is still working to restore access to its software.
32:41 It's today's stock of the hour. Up next this is the close on Bloomberg.
32:59 Our stock of the hour is Microsoft and well shares not really moving, but they
33:04 did cause a bit of a kerfuffle, if you will, around the world.
33:08 The company now saying it does not yet have full timing for a full recovery
33:12 from its outage, yet impacting users of outlook teams and Copilot in more than
33:17 70 countries. Bloomberg's Matt Day has been following
33:19 the story. He joins us live.
33:21 Matt, just walk us through what this ultimately means for Microsoft, because
33:25 I feel like if I asked someone on the street, you would assume the stock's
33:27 under pressure. But here we are up a couple points.
33:31 Yeah, I mean, it really does show us kind of how Wall Street thinks they are
33:34 impervious to challenges in their productivity software.
33:37 You know, the default way to send email to work with documents to calculate
33:41 things. It's it's Excel, it's word.
33:43 It's it's outlook. And I think just the stock going to not
33:46 budge on this shows how entrenched they are.
33:48 And just the futility of of folks last couple decades trying to to take a piece
33:53 of that. You know the challenge though is if
33:55 these types of instances keep happening, that's only going to happen to open
33:59 doors for people to ask hard questions of Microsoft and say, hey, why shouldn't
34:02 we go explore getting some of the product somewhere else?
34:05 Yeah, I mean, the language they're using, it sounds like an operation.
34:07 Apparently they're still draining huge messages and rebalancing traffic.
34:11 It sounds disgusting. I mean, this has been going on for more
34:13 than 24 hours now. You know, at what point do people stop
34:16 giving Microsoft a pass? Everybody in the world uses Microsoft to
34:21 a certain extent. Well, I think we're we're close to that.
34:24 I mean, we were quoting traders talking about how, you know, 24 hours is pretty
34:27 unacceptable. Um, you know, foreign ministries posting
34:31 schedules by hand, you know, school districts not able to communicate about
34:35 kids, like when Microsoft goes down at this scale, you know, and globally, it's
34:38 it's a big enough issue that I think customers are going to be demanding
34:41 answers from them and some transparency on what went wrong.
34:43 And, you know, to what extent they can guarantee this is not going to happen
34:46 again. Yeah.
34:47 Because yeah, the centralization just hits.
34:49 And they say certainly convinced that it's not anything malicious.
34:52 But at the same time they're not telling us what it is.
34:53 So how are they so sure it's not malicious.
34:56 Yeah. Well look, they've told us so far.
34:58 It's a bit vague, but they said that there was an issue with a networking
35:01 update that they rolled out. You know, I was watching the sort of
35:04 periodic status reports yesterday, and it looked like sort of their first
35:07 efforts to fix it didn't go very well. It took a while to find out even what
35:10 was wrong. So they're pretty convinced it's a it's
35:13 a benign issue with their own networking.
35:15 They've also ruled out interestingly I as a culprit here.
35:18 They say it wasn't caused by a rogue agent or something like that.
35:21 They're saying, you know, human networking error or so we'll see when we
35:23 get a full post-mortem. But yeah, a lot of a lot of questions so
35:25 far. It's been a while since we've had a
35:27 technical outage this big. All right.
35:30 Thank you so much. As for Microsoft, well, it's up 8% year
35:33 to date and very slightly up in the session coming up.
35:36 We're going to take you to the closing bells.
35:38 We'll be speaking with Mark Stuckey, chief portfolio manager for equities at
35:41 Northwestern Mutual Wealth Management. This is the close on Bloomberg.
35:53 I think. What's really interesting, though, is
35:58 that this rotation has been underway for the better part of two years.
36:03 And what I mean is, if you think about Nvidia as a good example, is
36:07 underperformed the S&P by 8% for the last two years.
36:09 So market leadership really has been rotating quietly for almost 24 months.
36:15 And I think what we saw in October and certainly last week was, you know, the
36:20 most violent part of it, I think it's probably closer to the end than we are
36:24 to the beginning. That was Chris Kelly, head market
36:27 strategist at the Franklin Templeton Institute, kicking off the show.
36:30 And I hear what he's saying, Baillie but you have to also consider that some of
36:35 that had to do with the fed, right? We had the end of one cycle and the
36:38 beginning of a new rate hike cycle. And also it's this is a difficult market
36:42 to trade, rotation or no rotation. Would you be comfortable even deciding
36:45 that it was time to rotate now? Well, funny, even when we look at
36:48 post-election, the rotation was okay the Wednesday after Will.
36:52 Now this is great for you know, neo clouds.
36:54 Maybe not or not great for neo classical, free for hyperscalers.
36:57 And all of a sudden everyone woke up Thursday morning and thought, well,
36:59 let's actually flip that over on its head.
37:01 It's just been kind of mind blowing. I've been getting whiplash.
37:03 I don't know if only was up 25% in the following morning.
37:06 It had given up most of those gains, remember?
37:08 Yeah. I mean, I would not want to be on.
37:10 Well, I would want to be on a trading desk, but I may not be doing very well
37:14 on that trading desk. Let's put it that way.
37:16 All right. Well, it looks like we're headed towards
37:18 a better conclusion to the week that we might have anticipated at the beginning
37:21 of today, because the Nasdaq 100 is now down less than 1%, and the S&P almost
37:27 looks like it wants to go green. We obviously have some dip buyers coming
37:30 in. I mean, how many times we said that
37:32 before and how smart of these dip buyers.
37:34 We'll see you next week. And you can see crude oil up about $0.26
37:38 96. So it is still elevated.
37:40 And obviously we're continuing to watch yields across the curve.
37:43 Five 1596 they are on the ten year up three basis points.
37:47 And just a little bit of curve steepening.
37:49 We have the two year yield down just a couple of basis points.
37:52 And you mentioned Vonnie. It's interesting to see weakness, albeit
37:54 not as bad as expected going into the weekend.
37:57 But looking at the week that was Nvidia down 13% on pace for its worst weekly
38:02 performance since Tariff Day. And then in that whole ecosystem,
38:06 talking about the NIO clouds and Airbus down on the week, almost 10%.
38:10 As much as we've focused on Jensen and the entire kind of effort to replace him
38:15 as CEO at Nvidia, his loss has led to the gain for some others in the
38:18 ecosystem. As you can see AMD up 19%, Broadcom just
38:22 slightly trailing and on a weekly basis up 18%.
38:25 So a lot going on under the surface. Again as much as we want to talk about
38:29 rotation from a macro level we're seeing real rotation within the same sector.
38:33 Again though my point rests because if you look at AMD today we're down 9%.
38:39 Like that is is such a huge move a stock like that.
38:42 Let's get to Matt Stucky, chief portfolio manager for equity at
38:46 Northwestern Mutual Wealth Management, for maybe hopefully a little bit of
38:49 clarity, Matt. I mean, we're not used to seeing these
38:52 kinds of moves for these kinds of stocks, right?
38:55 Really well-established players. Are we going to continue to see this, or
38:59 are we just now figuring out that, you know,
39:03 the Nvidia problem is going to go away. The anthropic you know, problem is going
39:07 to be over by the end of next week. And then we can sort of relax and reset
39:11 again. Look I mean I think volatility is going
39:14 to be with us for a little while. Um, just in terms of the factor kind of
39:19 nature of this trade has been very high beta, very high momentum.
39:23 And since those peaked, uh, in late June.
39:26 Um, this volatility profile has only been elevated.
39:29 And what you're seeing is this affects rotation away from momentum into
39:33 quality. Uh, and that has necessitated, you know,
39:37 a deep roasting type of tape, kind of with that waterfall last week, uh, which
39:41 has reversed somewhat, uh, in the semiconductor trade X and Nvidia this
39:46 week. So, um, you know, there's a lot of
39:48 fundamental questions investors continue to have just based on the idiosyncratic
39:52 development we saw with India this week. Is is the new leadership of India going
39:57 to continue to be aggressive with the financing needs of the NIO clouds?
40:01 Are they going to, uh, be aggressive in making sure the supply chain is ready
40:05 for the entire ecosystem? Those are all, uh, questions that
40:08 there's just not an answer to. And so that uncertainty premium it has
40:12 been building in, uh, in markets throughout this weekend until those
40:16 questions are answered, are likely to persist.
40:17 Well, Matt, talking about who will replace Jensen and Nvidia and the
40:21 uncertainty around that, who would you want to see step into the seat.
40:25 You know, I think there's a number of candidates internal and external.
40:28 Um, you know, I think the ideal candidate would do a couple of things.
40:31 One is, you know, have the, uh, buy in with the investor base, that the
40:36 execution in front of them is going to continue to be at the pace that we've
40:39 been expecting with Nvidia. Um, and that's kind of been the bread
40:43 and butter of, of, of this company over the years is the execution has just been
40:47 flawless. And then the visionary layer on top of
40:49 it, uh, to continue to position the company from a supply chain perspective,
40:54 as well as kind of where the industry going and making sure the product
40:56 leadership is there to take advantage of that.
40:59 Uh, that's what you want in the ideal candidate.
41:01 Externally, there's a couple of names that really come to mind.
41:03 Reed Hossack arm would be a fantastic hire Lisa Sue uh AMD would be a home run
41:09 and might have investors. But internally I think there's good
41:12 candidates too. It's a unique culture that's had low
41:14 attrition over the years. Uh, and that's a critical part to
41:17 continue to maintain, uh, if you're if you're taking over in the CEO seat.
41:23 Yeah. And it's amazing how quickly somebody
41:25 can move on from the cult of personality.
41:26 If, you know, one of those names were to be announced as the new CEO, then maybe
41:30 the whole trade would be fine. Marty, are you giving Microsoft a pass
41:34 on this outage today? Would you be at all tempted to reduce
41:38 your stake? You know, it's not a good sign, but I
41:41 you know, I think just in terms of the context of the factor trade, Um, you
41:45 know, Microsoft is a lower beta version of Tech Train similar to Apple.
41:50 And so in days like today where semiconductors are selling off, uh, the
41:53 lower beta side of the trade is going to catch a bit.
41:56 Microsoft is, uh, the preeminence in a version of that.
41:59 So while yes, it's it's not a good look. Uh, and it's been frustrating for the
42:03 last 24 hours for myself included, um, with a, with the program being down.
42:09 Uh, this is something that probably, if we're looking at a week from now, is not
42:11 something that's going to be discussed very much.
42:14 And, Matt, quickly here on the topic of some of the largest tech companies in
42:17 the world, anthropic going public next week, how are you thinking about the
42:20 targeted .4 trillion valuation and kind of where that could shake out and
42:24 what it means for the ecosystem? It's positive for the ecosystem if it
42:28 goes on without a hitch. Um, and there's going to three catalysts
42:31 next week that potentially could revive the trade higher.
42:34 You know, you have in the day earnings on Tuesday, the potential for a CEO to
42:37 be named as well as the anthropic IPO. Um, you know, the sentiment has just
42:42 shifted 180 from where we were a couple of years ago to where we sit today.
42:46 Uh, and fundamentally, there hasn't been a shift yet in terms of estimates being
42:50 adjusted lower, even though the price momentum has moved in the opposite
42:54 direction. Uh, and so, you know, this presents the
42:57 opportunity next week, anthropic IPO included, where maybe that sentiment is
43:00 shifting in the other direction, depending on, uh, depending on how it
43:04 goes. All right.
43:05 And at least we know the following week is Thanksgiving week.
43:07 So there's one fewer day in the who wants to go to 24 over seven trading
43:11 after this week. Matt, thank you so much.
43:13 Matt Stuckey is chief portfolio manager for equities at Northwestern Mutual
43:17 Wealth Management. Although who knows, maybe it would make
43:20 it easier if it was 24 or 7 because you wouldn't be waiting for, you know, the
43:23 market to open to figure out what was, but then it would make the weekend more
43:27 stressful. I'm even just worried about Thanksgiving
43:29 week with a shortened window on Friday. What that ultimately shakes?
43:32 Yeah, it's fun to wait for the market to open.
43:34 They'll stay open all the time. It's no fun.
43:37 All right, well, we are moving closer to the closing bell this Friday the 13th.
43:41 Full market coverage right here on Bloomberg, with just two minutes to go
43:46 to the close. Of the closing bell.
43:52 Bloomberg's comprehensive cross-platform coverage of the U.S.
43:56 market close starts right now, about two minutes away from the end of the trading
44:01 day and the trading week. Vonnie Quinn unveiling live shows, and
44:04 here to help take us through those guys and bells a global time.
44:07 Of course. We're joined now by Carol Massar and
44:09 Tim. Some of the bringing together on
44:11 Bloomberg Television, radio and YouTube all of our audiences worldwide to parse
44:16 through the most crucial moments of the trading day.
44:18 And I think if we had to pick one, well, we'd be a little bit stuck.
44:22 Carol. Yeah, I gotta say, I mean, how many
44:24 times have we said Nvidia this week? I'm just amazed that we're here on on
44:27 this Friday getting ready to wrap. We know Nvidia was the major story this
44:31 week. We've got a market that I feel like, you
44:33 know, most names actually in the S&P are higher in today's session despite the
44:38 index being down just about half a percent.
44:41 We've got 389 names higher. So investors are finding finding
44:45 opportunities in this market. Yeah I certainly the Nvidia story was
44:49 big in the tech story was was big this week.
44:51 Also big this week were the declines that we saw in oil.
44:54 Uh just looking at Brent futures right now back above $96 a barrel WTI uh up to
45:00 close to $89 a barrel. Uh, both of those up right now by just
45:04 about more than 2/10 of 1%. But we did see a lot of volatility in
45:07 that sector this week as investors thought wait a second.
45:10 Okay. There could be some sort of ending to
45:12 this war in Iran. And I just want to say, if you ask me,
45:15 Tim, at the beginning of the week, hey, Nvidia will be down almost 13%.
45:20 What does the S&P 500 do? I would have never said 2.5% is such a
45:24 good point. Yeah.
45:26 I mean, uh, you know, there's a lot of people out there that are having, you
45:30 know, worse Friday evenings, particularly if you founded a company
45:33 that you are no longer belonging to. But, you know, it does feel like one
45:37 catalyst for potential downside is out of the way.
45:39 Now we know that the board is already on to getting a successor.
45:43 All right. Let's take you right up to the closing
45:45 bell. You know something?
45:48 We're finishing positive on the Dow. Tim, you were not wrong.
45:51 The S&P 500 down just 4/10 of 1% on even the Nasdaq did a big effort dip buyers
45:58 coming in at the end of the Friday session.
46:00 Obviously there's some optimism about next week.
46:02 Um yeah. Well I think, you know excite me an
46:05 interest waiting to see what happens with Nvidia's result.
46:10 We've got an anthropic IPO so that's a big deal.
46:13 Bailey. Bailey, do you know that I haven't
46:14 heard. What is it, Kara?
46:16 What's the company? Uh, anthropic.
46:18 Can you learn something new to me? Yeah, I've heard that one.
46:21 Philanthropic. I'm confused.
46:22 New word. So maybe your vacation plans for next
46:24 week, right? I wish.
46:25 Okay. You're going to be working a lot there,
46:27 buddy. Hey, um, you're going to take us to the
46:29 iMap. I mentioned earlier, 370 names, barely
46:32 in the S&P 500. Actually higher today.
46:35 Yeah. Interesting trade.
46:36 I will say we've talked rotation ad nauseum.
46:38 Kind of a risk off trade. You're leaders in the sector level.
46:42 Consumer staples up more than 1%. Energy right behind it about a percent.
46:46 Financials up 8/10 of 1%. But the big read on the screen for today
46:50 Vonnie and I have been talking about on BTV tech tech down 1.7%.
46:54 And the big driver for that AMD down more than 8.5%.
46:58 Cisco down six. Dell down more than seven.
47:00 So again a rotation away from some of those tech companies and into some of
47:03 those safer plays like energy and financials.
47:06 All right. So let me go to some of the individual
47:08 gainers. And one was a name that we were talking
47:10 about last night after the closing bell. Uh Cerebro that stock up more than 11%
47:15 in today's session. Uh shares jumping after the company gave
47:18 a sales forecast for the current quarter that exceeded analyst estimates.
47:21 So signaling that a push to challenge and video in artificial intelligence
47:25 chips is apparently paying off. They said revenue roughly 320 million in
47:30 the fourth quarter. That topped the 271.2 million average
47:34 analyst estimate, according to data compiled by Bloomberg.
47:37 The company also touted recent customer deals with Microsoft and Oracle, so.
47:42 Some enthusiasm. Just keep in mind 14% of the float is
47:45 short. So a little bit of negative sentiment
47:48 out there on Sirius, even though it gained in a big way today.
47:51 This the next name Modine Ticker is mod. Thank you very much.
47:55 Tim Stead of Rocker said you got to do this name Messer.
47:58 Uh, stock up 27% soaring. It's about a $7.2 billion market cap,
48:03 soaring the most intraday in six years, up at one point during the day 30%, 38%
48:09 higher, but finishing the day with a gain of about 27%.
48:13 So here's the story. Samsung Electronics is in talks to
48:16 acquire this company. Its a maker of cooling systems for data
48:19 centers, uh, according to people familiar with the matter.
48:22 If the companies are talking about a potential transaction that could come
48:26 together as soon as the coming weeks. No final decision, though, has been made
48:30 and the talks could still fall apart. So, uh, interesting to see that one.
48:34 And then I'm just gonna throw in Domino's Pizza.
48:36 Is the ticker stock up after Baird raised the recommendation to outperform
48:40 from neutral, citing its view of a clearer path to better same store sales
48:44 performance and franchise profitability. Price target raised to 400 from 320.
48:49 And you can see the stock closing, uh, just under $342 a share, up about 2.5%
48:54 in today's session. Tim.
48:56 Okay. Those are some of the well, this pizza
48:58 night. I'm getting hungry.
48:59 It is pizza night, so not Domino's. Okay, sorry.
49:02 I'll on. Maybe not for you.
49:03 Okay. Exactly.
49:05 Uh, let's go to some of the decliners. What would it be like if I didn't
49:07 include Nvidia as a decliners today? Uh, it would be.
49:11 It would be brave. I'd be brave.
49:13 Maybe there's some people out there who would be grateful because they're like,
49:16 okay, enough with this already. But you know what?
49:18 It was one of the most actively traded stocks.
49:20 This is one that certainly has to be on our radar, at least when it comes to the
49:23 performance this week. When it comes to the performance since
49:26 October 5th, uh, this stock is now traded at
49:30 $2.85. It was down another 2% today.
49:33 It actually started the day up by uh uh, over 3%, but I think it was over 3%.
49:38 Excuse me. Um, but then it ended up turning
49:41 negative very early in the session. Uh, Nvidia's board, uh, according to the
49:45 Financial Times, has approached arm CEO Rene Haas in its search for a potential
49:48 successor to Jensen Wong again. The Financial Times reported this out,
49:52 citing people familiar with the matter. But if you've been paying attention to
49:55 any of the reporting around the short list of candidates who might succeed,
49:59 Jensen Wong might succeed Colette Kress, the CFO who's serving as interim CEO.
50:04 If she doesn't stay, then. Uh, Rene Haas has certainly been on that
50:08 list once again. Tim is your co-host to consider, though
50:10 I know she's rocking the leather jacket, so I didn't know if that was like, you
50:13 know, it was an honor kind of itch. Someone's got to pick up the leather
50:17 baton. Uh, let's move on to the socks.
50:22 Uh, part of the socks. And it is my goal to get a leather
50:26 jacket on. Tim, I'm just going to tell you about.
50:27 Not going to happen. I'm working on it.
50:29 Uh, it is. It is down today.
50:32 Uh, by 3.4%. It was down as much as 6.5% earlier in
50:35 the session. So off its worst levels of the day,
50:37 still, all 30 components of the Sox were down today.
50:41 And some pretty notable components of the Sox were significantly lower on the
50:45 day. Today.
50:46 Uh, should know to. It's down about 30% from those highs
50:49 reached back in June. And finally, let's check in on shares of
50:52 Virgin Galactic. SPC is the ticker.
50:56 Uh, shares fell by 31%, fresh record low after the company CEO said on the
51:01 conference call that the first commercial spaceflight for a period,
51:05 it's the lead spaceship of the Delta class fleet, is now expected in early in
51:09 the second quarter instead of in February.
51:11 The delay adds to concerns about the company's capital position, according to
51:15 analysts over at KeyBanc. Uh, Virgin Galactic shares today down by
51:18 more than 31%. A fresh, all time low.
51:20 Tim, I'm just gonna bring you this headline.
51:22 The FAA says that all airports are ground staffed until further notice.
51:27 Wow. Quite the headline to be receiving just
51:30 at the market close on a Friday. The FAA saying all airports are ground
51:35 stopped. Until further notice, we will obviously
51:38 keep an eye on everything that's happening to do with that.
51:40 Why it might be happening, whether it has anything to do with software outages
51:45 or what have you. And can I just throw on because Reuters
51:48 also throwing in on this reporting on X. And they say due to extraordinary
51:53 circumstances and for reasons of safety, attention to all aircraft operators, by
51:58 order of the FAA, as you said, all airports are ground stopped.
52:03 All departing traffic should remain ground stopped until further notice.
52:06 Inbound international flights will be managed on a case by case basis.
52:10 And just flagging that United's down about 3/10 of 1% in inflight trading.
52:14 But if you're watching the stocks, airline stocks are moving slowly
52:17 concerning because they're going to be a lot of flights in the air, there will
52:20 have to circle or move on, right. All right.
52:23 We will keep you updated. Yeah.
52:25 Sorry to keep uh, jumping on this to Bailey's point.
52:27 American, uh, lower now by about 8/10 of 1%.
52:30 But this is pretty extraordinary, especially as the report cites safety
52:34 reasons. We don't know exactly what they are at
52:36 this point. It's a story that we're going to
52:37 continue to follow, but absolutely extraordinary that you'd see this happen
52:40 across the country at airports. Yeah.
52:42 All airports ground stopped until further notice.
52:45 Let's take a look at yields. Because the other thing that was on
52:47 traders minds, even if they weren't front of mind today, was the fed.
52:51 What is going to do next. Obviously the October meeting is now
52:54 never going to be a live meeting again because it won't be dealing with
52:57 monetary policy. But we did have two more fed members
53:01 say, look, we are very, very concerned about inflation.
53:03 Are Michael McKee sitting down with the Boston Fed president, Susan Collins,
53:07 saying she's noticing that it's very, very strong out there.
53:11 And she, you know, didn't want to say that she was definitely going to hike or
53:16 hike twice in the next few months. But she did sort of lean in that
53:20 direction. And of course, had Mary Daly as well.
53:23 That had. French front end yields down just a
53:27 couple of basis points because market had broadly priced this in anyway.
53:30 But also we're seeing a belly and the back end of the curve up a couple of
53:33 basis points a tiny bit of steepening. So let's just recap.
53:37 You already said that there are some airlines we're seeing moving a little
53:40 bit lower on this news here in the aftermarket.
53:42 But the FAA has issued a nationwide ground, a nationwide ground stop, citing
53:47 extraordinary circumstances and reasons of safety.
53:51 They put this out in a statement. Again, we don't have a lot of
53:54 information. They did say all departing traffic
53:56 should remain ground stopped until further notice.
53:58 So no planes going out. Inbound international flights will be
54:02 managed on a case by case basis. I would imagine inbound is is kind of
54:07 rough when you're coming on a long trip. They've got to figure out where they're
54:09 going to put these planes and where to let them let them land.
54:12 Yeah. There.
54:13 Um, I mean, when I think of ground stop, I think nationwide ground stop there a
54:17 couple memories that come to mind. One is, of course, September 11th.
54:20 And what happened there? And then also, of course, a big failure
54:23 back in 2023. Back in 2023, uh, due to a catastrophic
54:28 failure of. Notice to air mission systems caused by
54:31 a file replacement error due to routine maintenance.
54:33 So this is not something that happens very frequently.
54:35 No, exactly. As they say, extraordinary
54:37 circumstances. All right, folks, I know you guys over
54:39 there are going to be keeping on this. We will tell you.
54:41 That is a wrap. Our cross platform radio, TV, YouTube,
54:44 Bloomberg Originals. We do call it the closing bell.
54:47 Varney and Bailey, of course, continuing on the close on TV, Tim and I back here
54:51 on BW daily on Bloomberg Radio. We'll see you on Monday.
54:57 Coming up, smartphone chip inventor is huge.
55:00 King new joins us live to react to Nvidia's week of upheaval and also
55:05 preview Nvidia's earnings report, which is still coming Tuesday and also gauge
55:09 the implications for the semiconductor industry more broadly.
55:11 This is the close on Bloomberg.
55:22 The countdown is on. Everything you need to get the edge at
55:26 the end of the market day. This is the close.
55:32 Welcome back to the clothes. I'm Vonnie Quinn.
55:34 Let's take a look at where markets closed on Friday the 13th and the entire
55:38 week. In fact, the Nasdaq off its lows of the
55:42 session. It was down 9/10 of a percent.
55:44 The Nasdaq 100 was down 1.2%. If you look at the stocks though, that
55:48 was a big problem. Today again finished off its lows of the
55:52 session but down 3.4%. All of the elements in that index were
55:56 lower. Good look at the S&P 500.
55:59 But really the story of the week was the Nasdaq 100.
56:02 Look at the two year yields. Obviously we've been bouncing around as
56:05 markets reprice fed hike expectations down another point in a bit across the
56:11 front part of the curve. All of this news now about the FAA
56:15 ground stoppage nationwide that is perhaps impacting the flight to safety
56:20 of treasuries as well. We're seeing just a little bit of
56:23 movement at the back end. And then Brent.
56:25 Well, we were elevated and we are elevated, but just up $0.43 at the end
56:30 of the session. Let's take a look at some of the day's
56:32 biggest movers. I threw in Microsoft even though it
56:36 actually wasn't that big of a mover in the end.
56:38 You would think it would be because we've had problems now for more than 24
56:43 hours. And that ground still apparently is due
56:47 to ATC frequency issues and the air current.
56:50 All right. Well, it said extraordinary
56:51 circumstances, the FAA so it could be weather related extraordinary
56:56 circumstances. That's at least what the website is
56:59 saying right now. Some of the other big movers aimed down
57:03 9%. This came out of nowhere because of
57:06 course, we saw potential competitors to Nvidia rising off the back of Nvidia's
57:11 woes. Well, Nvidia hasn't done too badly as it
57:14 turns out, was down well at 4% and change yesterday, down another 2% today.
57:19 Whereas AMD and some of these other competitors who, by the way, may also
57:23 have CEOs that could replace Jensen Huang.
57:26 So that could be part of the trade here. Well, they're down quite substantially.
57:29 So are some of the NIO clouds. So our top story this hour Nvidia
57:33 uncertainty set to overshadow an expected record quarter.
57:37 The chipmaker down more than 12% over the last week just ahead of earnings
57:40 this coming Tuesday. Analysts largely shifting to wait and
57:43 see mode in the wake of Jensen Wong's scandal, with at least 13 analysts
57:47 downgrading shares this month. The turmoil rippling through the broader
57:51 chip sector, with the Sox ending the week on a sour note.
57:54 As we saw down more than 3% today. CJ Lu, president of the National Academy
57:59 of Engineering, joins us now. Doctor, thank you so much for joining.
58:04 So as an engineer, when you see something like this happen and you say,
58:08 well, I'm an engineer, how would you solve a problem like this?
58:10 You get an engineer just as good to stand in Jensen Wong shoes.
58:16 And that's your problem solved. Uh, yes.
58:23 So of course, part of the, um, the turmoil this week has really been the
58:28 change in leadership. And of course, engineering leadership
58:31 would be fantastic for an Nvidia to be able to maintain because it is a leader,
58:34 a tech leader. And I do think most people believe that
58:37 an engineering background is necessary for the next leader to succeed.
58:41 Um, but just in general, you know, these developments don't change the fact that
58:47 with society depends more and more on information and communication
58:50 technology. The, um, the airport stoppage right now
58:53 probably is due to some, um, widescale information technology or
58:59 communications technology glitch. Um, also this week with the Microsoft um
59:04 outage, we saw that affected millions of people, businesses, governments, schools
59:09 around the world. And so like I said, that doesn't change
59:13 the fact that suicide is becoming more and more dependent on information and
59:16 communication technologies is as well as I.
59:19 Um, and that's not going to change because the chips underlying are the
59:24 foundation of running all those applications for society.
59:27 Doctor who, when you see something like the Microsoft outage, which, by the way,
59:30 still isn't fully solved. I mean, one thought that comes to my
59:33 mind is, you know, how are we ready for AI?
59:36 If you know, at this late stage in the game, copilot can cause such problems
59:40 for everybody from the, you know, reserve Bank of Australia to the
59:43 Ministry of Finance in Japan, to the National Health Service in the UK.
59:47 Are we ready for AI? Um, I would say it depends on the
59:55 country that you're in. Uh, as you know, China has taken a
59:58 pretty, um, uh, conservative. Well, actually a control, that
1:00:02 centralized control approach. Uh, Europe is also taking it a slightly
1:00:06 different, even more conservative approach in the United States.
1:00:09 I think there hasn't been consensus on what approach is best to help ensure
1:00:12 that I development. It's not going.
1:00:14 It's going to safeguard humanity. Um, so I think this is an example of the
1:00:19 work that the National Academies can do to bring the stakeholders together,
1:00:22 people who are developing the AI, people who are using it, and government leaders
1:00:26 to figure out what is the process by which we should even develop safety
1:00:30 codes for AI going forward. And I'm sure that now that we see the
1:00:34 urgency that we can work together to make a rapid progress, to allow AI to
1:00:39 continue to to grow in applications to benefit our nation.
1:00:43 Doctor Liu, is it possible to make any generalizations after the events of this
1:00:47 week and frankly, the last several years, you know, about engineers, maybe
1:00:51 how they're being taught in schools. Do they make good CEOs, or is it better
1:00:56 to have somebody who maybe isn't an engineer, but is good at knowing the
1:01:01 corporate rules? Well, as technology has advanced over
1:01:08 the last few decades, it's become more and more complex.
1:01:11 And this is why I do believe that you do need someone with engineering education
1:01:15 or training and experience to lead the leading edge tech company.
1:01:19 That being said, we do need to improve how we train future engineering leaders
1:01:24 so that they are more aware of the societal impacts.
1:01:27 In addition to the economic and ethical impacts of the technologies that they
1:01:31 will be developing, and to be able to relate to the users more fully
1:01:37 and to engage productively with leaders and government to do what's right for
1:01:42 that, for the people. So, doctor, do the consensus, at least
1:01:45 among the political class that, you know, we've had on this week, gas wise,
1:01:51 is that China is about six months behind the US when it comes to AI development.
1:01:56 As an engineer, you know, watching what you think, China's managed to get its
1:02:00 hands on how quickly it's developing data centers and, you know, Inner
1:02:04 Mongolia and places like that. Would that be a good guess about six
1:02:08 months. Well, it's hard to say unless you're
1:02:15 actually you've actually been in China. But certainly I think from the hardware
1:02:18 standpoint, the AI hardware standpoint, that they definitely have not caught up
1:02:22 yet in terms of Apple, patience is hard to say because they
1:02:26 have more data to train the AI models. They have more people and talent to work
1:02:32 on developing and using AI. So we should not take things for granted
1:02:36 that even if we are ahead, that we will remain ahead.
1:02:38 And so this is why we need to work together across industry, academia and
1:02:42 government to really set forth a plan for ensuring I develop quickly and
1:02:47 efficiently and used, uh, in principled manners to benefit, um, businesses and
1:02:52 just in general, um, life in, in the, in the nation.
1:02:56 W pleasure to have you today. Thank you so much.
1:02:59 That is Sujay Lu, president of the National Academy of Engineering.
1:03:06 All right. Let's take a look at the airlines.
1:03:07 Because in the aftermarket we are seeing them dip.
1:03:11 American Airlines down more than 1%. United Delta this of course as we hear
1:03:16 from the FAA that all airports are ground stopped until further notice.
1:03:21 Now we do have some more details. It's due to an air traffic control
1:03:25 frequency issue. And that has to do with air currents.
1:03:29 So extraordinary circumstances, according to the FAA.
1:03:32 And Sean Duffy says that the issue impacting all air routes and traffic
1:03:38 control centers. And he will bring us more information as
1:03:41 he gets it. But it is a communication issue and it
1:03:45 is, as we know, at least for right now,
1:03:49 nothing malicious. This is Bloomberg.
1:04:09 Nvidia's longtime CFO, Colette Kress, now assuming the CEO role on an interim
1:04:13 basis after Jensen Huang's departure. Newly appointed Nvidia chair Harvey
1:04:17 Jones, noting Kress as quote, helped lead Nvidia through a period of
1:04:21 extraordinary growth and has a deep understanding of our business.
1:04:24 Joining us now for more on this move is Nina Trautman, senior editor at
1:04:28 Bloomberg News. So you've spoken to Colette?
1:04:30 I feel like the street knows her very well, but then we thought we knew Jensen
1:04:33 Huang as well. Right?
1:04:34 So when we do get her in on an interim basis, will she's be a little bit more
1:04:40 transparent about the special purpose vehicles, about the fund raising, about
1:04:44 the sort of financing? Jensen was able to get away with it, but
1:04:47 he's gone though. Yeah, I think we'll certainly hear more
1:04:50 from her than we've had before, because in the past, as you pointed out, of
1:04:53 course, Jensen Huang was the face of the company and was also taking up most of
1:04:56 the air, not just in the public domain, but also in earnings calls.
1:05:00 Chris, of course, has talked about the business on earnings calls, but always
1:05:03 sort of like playing the second, the second.
1:05:06 I don't want to say fiddle, but the second position basically, and I think
1:05:09 now as interim CEO, we'll hear more from her, not just on the finances but also
1:05:13 on the company's overall performance and also the plan specifically as we go into
1:05:17 next year. As CFO, will she have been intimately
1:05:21 involved in all of those deals that Jensen planned, and will she potentially
1:05:26 be able to continue making them? She's certainly been involved in them.
1:05:29 I'm not sure if she's been involved in all of them.
1:05:31 And of course, most of them were also spearheaded by Hwang.
1:05:34 But she was very, very key to to many of the deals.
1:05:37 And so I think she will get more questions on on these circular financing
1:05:41 deals as, as, you know, stepped up. What's wrong with keeping her on as full
1:05:46 time CEO? Is there any consideration of that?
1:05:51 It seems like the board has put her in the interim spots and then decided to
1:05:56 look outside the company, but, uh, I mean, could could she not do a good job?
1:06:00 I think she's certainly going to be considered as one of the candidates for
1:06:03 the permanent job. The company will look inside as well as
1:06:05 outside. But oftentimes what we hear from
1:06:07 recruiters is this that if you as a CFO want to become a permanent CEO, you have
1:06:12 to have, um, demonstrable experience of having run a business or having
1:06:16 operating experience. And if we look at, uh, Colette, Chris's
1:06:19 CV, she's been in finance most of her life.
1:06:23 Um, she was at Microsoft. She was, um, at Texas Instruments.
1:06:26 Um, she was at Cisco, but she wasn't. She's never really, as a CEO, for
1:06:31 example, been running a division or a business that was revenue generating.
1:06:35 So for the last two days, she said, that's true experience.
1:06:38 That's true. That's true.
1:06:39 Of course, it depends on how long this goes on.
1:06:41 Exactly, exactly. Tell us a little bit about her.
1:06:44 Yeah, she's an interesting character. Um, less so than than Huang in terms of,
1:06:48 uh, her personality. At least it hasn't really shone through
1:06:51 yet. Um, the times that I've spoken to her,
1:06:53 she was always very rude. To the point, um, sharp, but also not
1:06:56 losing too many words. And I think that's also what we've heard
1:06:59 from people who've worked with her in the past, who've observed her.
1:07:02 She's rather shunned the light so far. And, um.
1:07:07 Now, of course, that's going to change. Is there any concern?
1:07:10 And certainly that doesn't seem to be so far, that she will come under scrutiny.
1:07:13 Because, after all, as CFO, you're very, very close to the CEO.
1:07:18 Might she have known things? Did she look the other way on certain
1:07:21 things? Should she have been more vigilant?
1:07:22 Should she have warned him? She will probably be under more
1:07:26 scrutiny. But I think as we're thinking about the
1:07:28 regulatory probes that are going on that will focus more on on Jensen Huang
1:07:33 himself. Um, of course there is this big, big
1:07:35 question, not just what did people know, but also what's going on with governance
1:07:39 at the company. And I think, of course, that is the
1:07:42 question that goes to the board and, and will also be posed.
1:07:45 So I think as part of this leadership team, of course, she will be posed some
1:07:50 of those those questions as well, given that she's been with the company for 13
1:07:53 years, which is a very long time in that seat.
1:07:55 Many CFOs in S&P 500 and fortune 500 companies only stay on for like five
1:08:00 years. So she's been there for a really long
1:08:02 time. And so of course, she will also be
1:08:04 asked, what did you know about this? Yeah, exactly.
1:08:06 And she will have to answer that. She will likely be asked on Tuesday as
1:08:09 well on the earnings call. This may not answer it on Tuesday.
1:08:12 Nina, thank you so much. Nina, gentleman has the ear of all of
1:08:16 the CFOs. She's senior editor at Bloomberg News
1:08:18 and the editor of the CFO briefing newsletter.
1:08:21 And you should subscribe to it with this QR code or go to bloomberg.com and
1:08:25 subscribe. It is a fascinating newsletter.
1:08:27 You don't so much from what could be potential CEOs.
1:08:31 Let's take a look at airlines, because of course, we had that very serious
1:08:34 announcement from the FAA just few moments ago, which is causing airlines
1:08:38 to trade lower in the post market. The FAA ordering a ground stop.
1:08:43 Now, the Transportation Secretary Duffy saying that this is after a
1:08:46 communications issue, air traffic control frequency issues, no word on why
1:08:53 the air traffic controllers may be experiencing Frequency issues, but that
1:08:57 is what we're hearing as the reason for an entire ground staff at all airports
1:09:03 right now. This is Bloomberg.
1:09:26 Saks Fifth Avenue, Neiman Marcus, Bergdorf Goodman, some of the biggest
1:09:30 names in the world of retail and all under the same umbrella of exemplar
1:09:34 luxury group. Bloomberg's Romaine Bostick caught up
1:09:36 with the CEO of Saks, reemerges from bankruptcy.
1:09:42 But we're very healthy. We are a company that has 500 million of
1:09:46 terminal owned, and we are a $7 billion company this year in terms of GMV.
1:09:52 We are profitable. We are exceeding our plan and we have
1:09:56 900 million of gross available liquidity.
1:09:58 And so the world of example of luxury group today financially is worlds apart
1:10:02 from what it was. And I think that's the stable ground on
1:10:05 which we intend to build growth. And the growth is going to be profitable
1:10:09 growth. It's going to be focus on luxury, and
1:10:11 it's going to be in a world where we generate cash flow.
1:10:14 Well, give me a sense though, too. I mean, you talk about the $7 billion in
1:10:18 gross merchandise value. I know you had a target to get to 9
1:10:20 billion by 2030. You still think you're going to achieve
1:10:23 that. But we on track to our plan.
1:10:25 And the goal is really to move from the 7 billion that we are to the 9 billion.
1:10:29 But the question is not about how fast or how big it is.
1:10:34 It's making sure that we get there in a quality way.
1:10:37 And so for me, it's very important that we get to 9 billion through building
1:10:41 relationship with customers who are loyal to us, through selling to them
1:10:45 full price and really building a business that as it grows is profitable.
1:10:50 It generates cash flow so that we can reinvest in the business.
1:10:53 And so our focus is clearly growth. But it's profitable steady growth.
1:10:57 And that's how we can comply and fulfill our promise to the brands to be the best
1:11:03 partner. And all growth is going to be that
1:11:05 growth alongside us. With regards, though, to sales itself, I
1:11:09 mean, since coming out of bankruptcy in June, are there any sort of comp sales
1:11:12 figures that you can share with me? Are things better now on a relative
1:11:16 basis and where they were a year ago? Yes.
1:11:18 It's a stabilization year for us. What we've seen is that we are ahead of
1:11:22 the plan we put out publicly. And every quarter on a like for like
1:11:26 basis, we've seen consecutive improvement or stores have been positive
1:11:31 for the most part across Saks and Neiman and Bergdorf since May.
1:11:36 And the performance is really becoming steadier and steadier.
1:11:39 And we know it's a dynamic environment. One week, one month will move.
1:11:43 But when you look at a trajectory, the trajectory is really steady and
1:11:47 positive. Your EBITDA target as well.
1:11:50 What was it like 85 million or something you're still on track to hit, so we're
1:11:53 still on track to achieve the 85 million of a beat that I would set out for it.
1:11:59 Do you have you put out any sort of public guidance in terms of what you
1:12:01 want that to be in the future? No, we are a private company, so we're
1:12:05 not burdened by providing guidance. What we are very focused is on that
1:12:09 profitable and sustainable growth, and to adjust to the environment and to do
1:12:15 the focus on the controllable. So we've not set out a target, but we
1:12:19 are very clear that we are on track to continue to stabilize and to grow with
1:12:24 our customer. And ultimately, our goal is to grow
1:12:26 faster than the industry, because we believe as the collective of those three
1:12:31 banners, we have a moat, a competitive advantage that is very strong.
1:12:35 Do all of those three brands grow at a comparable rate, or is one, in your
1:12:40 view, potentially have the they have the potential to do better than the others?
1:12:44 They all have great potential in different parts of the market and in
1:12:48 different ways Today, we are very much leaning in the strength that we have in
1:12:52 our stores because our business is anchored in Rome, says associates.
1:12:56 We have 1500 says associate, who sell more than a million.
1:12:59 Collectively, they sell close to $3 billion a year.
1:13:03 And that is really the strength of our business.
1:13:05 They have a relationship with customers. Customers trust them.
1:13:08 And so as we look at this year of stabilization, the focus is very much on
1:13:12 stores and leaning into strength that we have there.
1:13:15 Ultimately, we're going to grow across all our channels, in all of banners.
1:13:19 But the focus right now is really the relationship.
1:13:22 Well, I do want to talk about the identity of the umbrella company of
1:13:25 exemplar. I think what a lot of people saw that
1:13:27 name when the company came with Saks Global came out of bankruptcy.
1:13:31 There are a lot of questions as to why drop the Saks name from the parent
1:13:35 company. I assume that was intentional.
1:13:37 Did that have to do with the restructuring, or was that more about
1:13:40 marketing? It is really intentional because it's a
1:13:43 new example. A luxury group is that collective that
1:13:46 unites Saks Neimann and Bergdorf
1:13:48 And if you attached a name to only one of the banner, you lose what's
1:13:52 collective about it, and what's collective about it is that those three
1:13:55 businesses are born based on relationship with the customers.
1:13:58 And it's they're the gateway to the luxury customers in the US.
1:14:01 And so we wanted to bring them under an umbrella that shares all the same
1:14:06 values, but in a little each of the brands Saks, Neiman and Bergdorf to
1:14:10 express and differentiate themselves in the marketplace.
1:14:12 So what's the relationship like with the your lenders?
1:14:15 And really, I should say the investors and I'm talking primarily about pent
1:14:18 water and Bracebridge. I mean, they have four seats on the
1:14:20 board right now effectively controlling this.
1:14:23 Um, but they're hedge funds and they basically are, you know, distressed
1:14:27 lenders to a certain extent. Um, their general playbook is to
1:14:31 basically help companies restructure and then they move on.
1:14:35 What's their goal for shareholder pent water and Bracebridge are invest in the
1:14:40 business. They've invested 1.5 billion.
1:14:42 And I joined them alongside three of the uh Leadership to support the transition
1:14:47 to transformation. They have invested that money, that
1:14:50 patient, you know, ability to stabilize the business and recover.
1:14:54 And in ultimately this they're unnatural owners and they're very committed to get
1:14:58 us to the place where we are cashflow positive, where we are growing, where we
1:15:03 are stable. And then we will look for an owner that
1:15:05 is a long term owner. But the the belief and the partnership
1:15:09 we have, when we decided to do this together, it was very clear to me that
1:15:13 they were going to support us with the level of cash that we needed and that
1:15:16 they had the patience to see this business.
1:15:19 We revitalize it and if it's potential, who becomes the potential long term
1:15:25 owner is that just find another buyer. Is that maybe going back into public
1:15:28 markets with an IPO? So we are not focused on anything that
1:15:32 is towards an exit. We are very focused on the core of our
1:15:35 business. How do we delight customers?
1:15:37 How do we engender loyalty, and how do you build a business that is profitable
1:15:42 and growing and generate free cash flow. The rest is an outcome and eventually,
1:15:46 at the right time, we will look at what is a transaction that could happen.
1:15:51 But it is. You only get to be successful if you are
1:15:55 devoted to the customer and you run these businesses with discipline, but
1:15:58 with also with passion. I know the holidays are big for
1:16:00 retailers, but obviously you have to sort of manage this business year round
1:16:04 when people aren't necessarily gifting. How do you get people into the store?
1:16:09 How do you create that magic come January, or in the middle of the summer,
1:16:13 when nobody's thinking about the extravagance and opulence of the
1:16:17 holidays? So we get a lot of traffic during the
1:16:19 holidays, but we also get enormous traffic across all our properties during
1:16:24 the year. And a lot of it comes from, I would say,
1:16:27 newness and far more sales associated. And so newness is we have multiple
1:16:32 brands that bring on the fashion cycle products.
1:16:35 And when the season starts, customers want to see what's new.
1:16:38 Then in the season, we have a lot of brands that do exclusive launches,
1:16:42 capsule activation events for us, and these are all reasons to come to the
1:16:48 store. And so the notion of the newness is
1:16:50 really important. And then the notion of the sales
1:16:53 associate, this is associate who calls you, who texts you and basically tells
1:16:57 you there's something new, it's unique for you, and you really have to have a
1:17:00 look at it. If we look at Saks and Neiman, about 20% of
1:17:03 the sales in stores are driven by sales associate who sell to a customer who's
1:17:08 not in the store. And if you look at Bergdorf, that's 30%.
1:17:12 And so the that is how we create the desirability.
1:17:16 And thank you to the CEO of Exemplary Luxury Group, the parent company of
1:17:19 Neiman Marcus, Saks Fifth Avenue and Bergdorf Goodman speaking there with
1:17:23 Romaine Bostick. Let's take a look at how markets closed
1:17:26 out the day and the week. The Nasdaq was down 1.2%, which could
1:17:31 have been a lot worse. If you look at the semiconductor index
1:17:33 was down 3.5%. Several companies that are competitors
1:17:37 to Nvidia down almost 10% including AMD. We had Broadcom falling.
1:17:43 We had the Nio clouds falling. And for all of us you actually had the
1:17:47 S&P down only 4/10 of a percent. Because of course other stocks did well
1:17:51 in the turmoil. The two year yield at 485 down about 2
1:17:55 to 3 basis points. As it looks like we might be getting a
1:17:59 hike in December but maybe not that 50 basis point hike.
1:18:02 The PPI data came in pretty benign, a little bit lower than anticipated.
1:18:07 And then let's take a look at some movers in the after hours.
1:18:10 I want to specifically look at airlines every airline from JetBlue to United
1:18:15 American and Delta. Although we're now in post-market
1:18:18 trading. This as the US issued an order to hold
1:18:21 flights nationwide in the last half hour.
1:18:24 Transportation Secretary Sean Duffy, citing a communication issue affecting
1:18:29 all air road traffic control centers. And that said, we also have
1:18:33 cybersecurity stocks higher. Well guys Bond of Bloomberg joins us
1:18:38 now. Well, what exactly do we know about
1:18:40 what's happened at our nation's airports in the last 20 minutes?
1:18:44 Hey. Good afternoon.
1:18:45 Yeah. You know, we don't know much.
1:18:47 And I think that's probably just concerning for, uh, a lot of travelers
1:18:50 heading out on various weekend trips. As you mentioned, the secretary said
1:18:54 this is related to a communications issue.
1:18:57 And this comes as the US government works to try to modernize the system.
1:19:01 Um, the secretary this week again asked for $30 billion in funding from Congress
1:19:07 to try to fix, uh, uh, the pretty old system here, from communications to
1:19:11 radars, uh, and so on. So we'll be standing by the, uh, to get
1:19:15 more information. But there is there is not much we know
1:19:17 right now as the agency tries to figure this out.
1:19:20 Yeah. No real suggestion that there's anything
1:19:22 malicious going on, but also will there's no denial.
1:19:26 I mean, it also could be malicious, am I right?
1:19:28 We literally don't know what's causing this, except that it's a communication
1:19:31 issue. Yeah, I would say, you know, we were
1:19:34 correct. We have not seen anything that said this
1:19:37 would be malicious. And I would say, obviously that those
1:19:39 situations are rare. Also add that unfortunately,
1:19:43 communications outages are pretty common in the US from an air traffic control
1:19:48 perspective. Again, not to this scale.
1:19:50 The last time that we had a nationwide ground stop, as the FAA calls it, was in
1:19:54 2023, uh, after a key uh, safety notification system went down.
1:19:59 And sure, anyone traveling at that time can recall the sort of stories of
1:20:03 meltdown, but we have not seen anything to indicate this is malicious.
1:20:07 And, um, these these communication outages are quite common.
1:20:11 Well, thank you so much for all of the context.
1:20:13 That is Bloomberg's will guys on there giving us the lowdown on what's
1:20:17 happening at the airports. This is Bloomberg.
1:20:35 The holiday shopping season underway, putting retailers to the test run
1:20:38 through one new CEO, Paige Thomas, discussing her vision for the company
1:20:42 since taking the reins from former CEO Jennifer Hyman.
1:20:47 She also discusses the strength of the consumer right now.
1:20:50 Take a listen. I obviously, um, joined the organization
1:20:57 in the June time period. Um, I will say there's no question.
1:21:01 I spend an incredible amount of time really getting to know the team, um,
1:21:06 getting closer to the customer feedback, voice of customer.
1:21:10 And to be clear, I really see this opportunity as not a strategic shift,
1:21:17 but actually just building on the incredible foundation that, um, of
1:21:22 Jennifer's vision. Um, and also what, you know, the team
1:21:26 collectively has built in capabilities, platform and, and an incredible
1:21:32 relationship with with our customer. So so I really see this as a build on.
1:21:37 So talk about then what are you building on.
1:21:39 Because, you know, a lot of people look at Rent the Runway as kind of a category
1:21:42 creator to a certain extent. And obviously anytime you create
1:21:45 something that's popular, you get a lot of imitators.
1:21:48 Uh, and then all of a sudden you're faced with competition that you didn't
1:21:50 have before. What is the competitive landscape like
1:21:53 right now for Rent the Runway? Yeah, I think that, you know, the way
1:21:59 that I think about our original brand promise doesn't change.
1:22:05 And that's really about bringing extraordinary fashion to women so that
1:22:10 they can experience and enjoy, um, which is such an emotional kind of attachment,
1:22:16 a community. I mean, I grew up as a merchant, and so
1:22:20 the love of fashion is, is, is near and dear to my heart.
1:22:24 But what but what rent the runway put on the map is really the concept of Access
1:22:32 without the requirement of ownership. And while I recognize that there are new
1:22:37 competitors within the space, we really position ourselves in a premier luxury
1:22:42 space and how that connects to a true experience.
1:22:47 And so that's really the work that we have to continue and continue to
1:22:51 elevate. You've always got you know, I've learned
1:22:55 that there's always going to be new players, but you've got to stay true to
1:22:59 your core, which is really what put us on the map.
1:23:01 Well, give me a sense. I mean, you kind of hit on something
1:23:03 this idea of basically being able to wear some of these fashions or some of
1:23:08 these brands without actually having the commitment of buying them itself.
1:23:12 And that, of course, was the big appeal of rent.
1:23:15 The runway was for the customer. What was the appeal and what is the
1:23:20 appeal now for the brands themselves to partner with you on that front?
1:23:26 Oh, I would tell you that the way that our customers really engage with our
1:23:32 brands. There's such a moment of discovery and
1:23:36 that's what we do. Not only do we hear that from Voice of
1:23:39 Customer, but we actually see that in the engagement and through our customer
1:23:44 research. So the value to the brand is our
1:23:48 opportunity to introduce brands to customers as they're learning fashion as
1:23:53 they're discovering. In many cases, they actually push their
1:23:56 fashion sense with Rent the Runway. And I think that's the real value that
1:24:01 we bring as a shared partnership with our brands.
1:24:05 I mean, obviously, you know a ton about merchandising inventory.
1:24:08 You worked at Nordstrom, Nordstrom Rack, Saks off.
1:24:11 Fifth thing that I might be forgetting a couple of other stops in your career.
1:24:14 But when you're going to some of these brands and particularly looking at your
1:24:17 own inventory at Rent the Runway, um, what's the balance in making sure that
1:24:23 you have enough that's there for the people who do run to rent it, but you're
1:24:27 not overextending yourself financially with things that may not actually move.
1:24:32 Yeah. The way that I think about and listen,
1:24:35 our team in merchandising at Rent the Runway is incredibly experienced.
1:24:41 And you referenced a few of the retailers that I've worked for that I
1:24:45 have an incredible amount of respect for.
1:24:47 And you've hit the nail on the head in the sense that a merchant's role is
1:24:53 really to drive curation and have the right level of newness, have the right
1:24:59 level of fashion, and also really for us to own and have a point of view to lead
1:25:05 our customers. And so when I think about, you know, the
1:25:09 success in my career and, and, and bringing that to a leadership role for
1:25:15 Rent the Runway, it really starts with the customer and the signals that the
1:25:19 customer's giving us. And so there's an incredible amount of
1:25:23 metrics. I call it sort of the art and science,
1:25:26 Which is what is the customer telling us through signals, but what's also
1:25:29 happening in the industry? And that's the role that we have to
1:25:33 constantly be evolving our assortments, delivering newness to customers, while
1:25:39 also really owning and having a point of view of what they want and what they
1:25:43 wear and what they rent were all based on the last a quarterly filing, though.
1:25:47 I mean, it talked a lot about the amount of money that you're spending on
1:25:50 inventory, but also what has become, uh, a little bit more of a reliance on
1:25:54 revenue sharing, consignment, etc. are the brands have the brands been
1:25:58 relatively receptive to that type of arrangement rather than outright
1:26:02 purchases like we shot like we saw in the past?
1:26:06 Well, here's how I would answer that question, because I think what's really
1:26:09 important and you touched on this, you know, in a few previous questions, is
1:26:15 that the value of a relationship with our brands is really the customer at the
1:26:22 center. And so our customer is incredibly
1:26:25 valuable and I've worked in many different environments.
1:26:28 And so I think about the psychographic and the demographic of our customer.
1:26:32 And that comes through a household income that comes through their
1:26:36 psychographic of ambition. And, um, you know, how their lifestyle
1:26:43 comes to life. And that's really where we spend the
1:26:46 majority of our time. Um, as we think about the partnership,
1:26:51 that was Paige Thomas, Rent the Runway CEO, sitting down with our very own
1:26:55 Romaine Bostick know, Carrie Underwood might be known for her Grammy Award
1:26:59 winning music eight times a Grammy winner, but she's also pushing into the
1:27:03 wellness space through her new brand called High Note.
1:27:06 It's a lifestyle and nutrition company that's just secured a new investment to
1:27:09 expand production of its flagship drink mix.
1:27:12 I sat down with Carrie and Kerrigan, Barron's, the co-founder and CEO of
1:27:16 Hinode, about the creation of this brand and their plans for its future.
1:27:20 Have a listen. Yeah.
1:27:24 I've been, uh, excited about health and wellness for, um, really my whole life.
1:27:31 But I started making it a priority in my 20s, and, um, I feel like I've learned a
1:27:35 lot along the way. I continue to learn.
1:27:38 Um, but basically, you know, wanted to, um, share some of the things that I've
1:27:43 learned over my own journey with, with people.
1:27:46 We started a fitness app and, um, kind of through that, um, we, we branched out
1:27:53 and we, uh, created high net life. And, um, we are always expanding, always
1:28:01 learning. We wanted to create things that could
1:28:04 meet consumers where they were and just help, help health, help people get
1:28:10 healthy. And I love that your catchphrase are one
1:28:13 of them is making wellness doable. And I think that will resonate with a
1:28:18 lot of people that are maybe just starting out on their journey.
1:28:20 Kerrigan. You're obviously savvy with the consumer
1:28:24 space. How did you shape this product so that
1:28:26 it would meet a certain niche? Yeah, we really have been thinking about
1:28:32 consumers that are underserved. So not just coastal high income
1:28:36 consumers, but actually three out of four of our customers are based in the
1:28:41 Midwest and South. And so making sure that the products are
1:28:46 going to fit into their lifestyles and also fit into their budgets was a really
1:28:50 big thing. Um, we also heard from a lot of women
1:28:53 that one of the issues that they're constantly dealing with is just that
1:28:58 they're tired, which makes sense. If you're a working mom, you can
1:29:01 certainly resonate with that. And so, um, when we were thinking about
1:29:04 the kinds of ingredients we could use to help women be less tired, we were
1:29:10 thinking about things like protein and fiber and fruits and veggies.
1:29:14 Um, the kind of energy that you get from eating well.
1:29:17 And that's really what we created with our high note everyday and our daily
1:29:20 nutrition drink mix. Exactly.
1:29:22 And this is really the first product where I cost about $36 for a big pouch
1:29:27 of it, and you get several drinks out of it.
1:29:29 So maybe, Carrie, explain to us how this came about as the first product, how it
1:29:34 was developed in conjunction with doctors and so on.
1:29:37 And what makes it special to you? Well, I feel like our main objective was
1:29:43 looking at what was missing. Um, I'm all about, um, trying to get
1:29:50 things into my life that are just an easy fit.
1:29:53 And, um, you know, you go to the store, you look at, you know, protein powders
1:29:59 and greens mixes and all this stuff, and it's very, um, kind of for bros, you
1:30:05 know, for, like, Jim Bros. And I'm, I'm sitting there, I love
1:30:08 reading labels, and I'm sitting there looking at labels, and things are very
1:30:11 confusing. And there's all these, you know, giant
1:30:13 tubs of, you know, muscle growth gains, you know, all those buzzwords.
1:30:18 Um, and I'm like, how does this fit into my life?
1:30:21 And if I'm having this problem, I'm sure everybody else is having this problem as
1:30:25 well. Um, you know, we we want it to be
1:30:28 something that is easily, easily implementable into your life and can
1:30:34 help you, um, on your journey no matter where your journey is at the moment.
1:30:40 Uh, my mom loves our daily nutrition drink mix, but also my brother in law
1:30:46 who does like Ironman competitions, like drinks, multiple, um, multiple drinks a
1:30:52 day of of our nutrition drink mix. So I love that it's for everybody, but
1:30:58 we're really just trying to simplify and just meet you where you are and help
1:31:03 give you the energy that you need to, you know, to be a mom, be a friend.
1:31:08 Like, do your job, work out all the things that we are all constantly
1:31:12 juggling. Carrie Underwood there and Carrigan
1:31:15 Barron's, co-founders of High Notes. Let's look at what we're watching for.
1:31:21 Over the next week, it's going to be another big, big week.
1:31:24 So get your rest in this weekend. We start off Monday.
1:31:26 Fed chair war speaks. We are closely listening to what he has
1:31:30 to say. The deadline for 13 F quarterly filings
1:31:34 takes place on the Asean Summit in Manila takes place and then Tuesday.
1:31:38 Nvidia earnings, of course, that's going to be the main events, but we do have
1:31:42 some retail sales data Wednesday. We have the APEC economic Leaders
1:31:47 meeting. And that's going to begin with President
1:31:49 Trump expected to attend. Plus we get earnings from Palo Alto
1:31:52 Target and Lowe's. So more readings on the consumer.
1:31:56 And then another big day Thursday. Anthropic expected us to start trading.
1:32:01 Plus this is what I'm really talking about.
1:32:03 It's the release of take two Grand Theft Auto six money.
1:32:06 People will actually be taking the day off.
1:32:08 Logitech gives their employees a day off to play video games, and apparently many
1:32:12 of them are going to take it off on that particular day because it's November
1:32:15 19th and people cannot wait for Gddr6. Okay.
1:32:18 Besides that, we have University of Michigan sentiment data on Friday as
1:32:21 well. Let's take a look at what's happening at
1:32:24 the nation's airports, though, because we are seeing all of the airlines that
1:32:28 we track pretty much lower, including Delta, American, United and JetBlue.
1:32:34 This as we see a stoppage at the nation's airports, the FAA calling it
1:32:38 earlier, saying it was for reasons of safety and it was due to a
1:32:41 communications issue. So an air traffic control frequency
1:32:46 issue. Now, we have since had some statements
1:32:49 from some of the airlines. United is going to continue on with
1:32:52 flights that are already in the air. It's going to not take off in terms of
1:32:56 flights that are on the ground and haven't taken off yet.
1:32:59 And it says it will work with customers once this issue is resolved.
1:33:03 So that's pretty much the statement from United.
1:33:06 We will bring you obviously the details as we get them.
1:33:09 But for the moment flights are grounded due to air traffic control issues.
1:33:13 Absolutely no indication of whether this is something routine or something
1:33:18 malicious, but no signal that it is anything malicious either.
1:33:22 And again, we have CNN reporting that it doesn't appear to be a cyber attack.
1:33:26 That said, we are seeing some of the cybersecurity companies higher, Palo
1:33:30 Alto Networks, for example, and CrowdStrike hire.
1:33:34 Let's take a look at how the markets finished out this week as we approach
1:33:38 another week chock full of events. So we finished today with the Nasdaq
1:33:41 down 1.25% or just shy of us. The fully Sox index off its lows of the
1:33:46 day, down almost 3.5%. That two year yield really pricing in a
1:33:51 full rate hike now in December for 85. Big move this week but down three basis
1:33:55 points today. And then Brent crude still above $96 a
1:33:59 barrel. That does it for us.
1:34:01 Balance of power is up next. And keep you updated on the FAA issues.
1:34:06 Have a great evening and weekend. This is Bloomberg.
LaHood Says Antiquated FAA System Likely Failed full transcript
0:00 I'm sure this is an interesting experience for you.
0:02 Having, of course, served in a role that oversees the FAA and now to be, uh,
0:08 along with everyone else in that airport and the airports across the country
0:11 dealing with the effects of this ground stop.
0:14 What are you hearing? First and foremost on the ground, you
0:18 are in a position to know what questions to ask of the authorities at the
0:22 airport. Well, I just talked to the airport
0:25 manager here in Peoria. Uh, and, uh, he told me we were supposed
0:30 to leave tonight, uh, to go, uh, to Sarasota on Allegiant flight, uh, for a
0:37 golf weekend, uh, in Sarasota, Florida. Uh, and he told me there's probably no
0:42 chance we're going to get out of here for a couple of days, he said.
0:45 Even if they got a couple of days, even if they got the system up and
0:51 running, like right now, we definitely would not get out until tomorrow.
0:56 Uh, and, uh, he said it's unlikely they're going to get it up and running
1:01 uh, at this hour. And so, uh, I think people, uh, better
1:07 make some hotel reservations or car rental, uh, agreements and, uh, try and
1:12 figure out how they either stay in place or get to their destination by
1:17 automobile. Well, I hope for the sake of our
1:21 audience, they are heeding the advice of the transportation secretary here.
1:25 He knows what he's talking about. And it might be time, if you haven't
1:28 already, to take things into your own hands.
1:31 Mr. Secretary, what is Secretary Duffy up to
1:34 right now? If you still had this job, obviously
1:37 he's not out in front of reporters because he's working.
1:39 What would he be up to at this point? And until we figure out the cause, you
1:44 know, the I think probably he's out in Virginia, uh, where which is the main
1:51 hub for, uh, FAA guiding planes in and out of airports and at that, at that
1:57 location, uh, they, they have, uh, up on screens.
2:03 Uh, What? What?
2:05 The action is going on all over the country.
2:09 And that's where they're probably trying to identify the problem of what?
2:13 Shut down the system. It's my guess that and, you know, you've
2:19 done stories and heard stories and everybody's heard the horror stories.
2:22 We have the most antiquated equipment, and I give Secretary Duffy credit.
2:28 He has worked hard this year to persuade Congress to give him the millions and
2:34 billions of dollars that are needed to get this equipment upgraded.
2:39 Uh, and, and, um, this is something that he has made a priority, uh, since he
2:46 became secretary. And I congratulate him for doing that.
2:49 I guarantee you, Congress is going to pay attention to him next week when they
2:53 start hearing from all their constituents.
2:55 And I also guarantee you, there are a lot of members of Congress that are
2:59 trying to get out of Washington, D.C. right now and are stranded.
3:02 Mhm. Yeah, there's a lot of people all over
3:06 the country. I'm imagining there's probably some
3:08 college football players who have games tomorrow who aren't going to be making
3:10 it to the stadiums at which they're supposed to, uh, play.
3:14 Mr. Secretary, could you talk about.
3:16 Yeah, please. I was just going to say this is a
3:18 national calamity, and, uh, I am not a superstitious person, but, uh, for it to
3:25 happen on Friday the 13th, uh, leads me to believe that maybe I will become a
3:30 suspicious person. I think a lot of people probably join
3:35 you in that. Mr.
3:36 Secretary, when you're talking about the antiquated, uh, systems and Secretary
3:40 Duffy's attempts to modernize them, we have seen some of that modernization in
3:44 the form of, uh, new AI systems being introduced.
3:47 In fact, that was expanded, uh, just this week.
3:50 There is a question as to whether or not software might have played a role here.
3:54 Would you be surprised if, if this issue were created by trying to upgrade the
3:59 very systems that, uh, so need it? I would be a little surprised.
4:04 And I'll tell you why. The FAA has very, very professional
4:09 people that have worked long and hard on transitioning from the old system to the
4:14 new system. And, uh, what I mean by that is they,
4:18 they test run these systems, uh, before they ever go up with them.
4:23 Uh, they look at them carefully. Uh, I, uh, I believe it's more, uh, a
4:29 case of, uh, old antiquated system that has failed.
4:33 Uh, rather than trying to transition from one system to a new one that that's
4:38 just, um, you know, I'm, I'm he's obviously.
4:40 I'm guessing, but I know the FAA and I know they're professional people, and I
4:45 know the people that have worked hard to transition from the old to the new.
4:50 Uh, and I guarantee you, there have been a lot of test runs before they ever did
4:54 that. Interesting.
4:57 Uh, we're spending some time with the former transportation secretary, Ray
4:59 LaHood. If you're just joining us on Bloomberg
5:02 TV and radio, we've got a live view of O'Hare International Airport in Chicago,
5:06 on Bloomberg TV and on YouTube. Mr.
5:08 Secretary, what's the mechanism in the decision making process that goes behind
5:14 a nationwide ground stop? We've already made clear that this
5:17 doesn't happen too often. Is this a call that the secretary
5:21 himself makes, or is this a collaborative effort with any number of
5:25 people around the country? It's a it's a call that Secretary Duffy
5:30 makes based on recommendations from the FAA.
5:33 Uh, and, uh, it is his call, but obviously he does it with and you had
5:39 the secretary of Homeland Security on. I mean, he consults with other people,
5:43 including the white House. I mean, obviously, this is, uh, you
5:47 know, this is a national calamity, and and, uh, so, um, he's smart enough to
5:52 know he needs to keep, uh, folks at the white House.
5:56 But it's his call. The answer is it's his call.
5:59 Mhm. Well, and we don't know yet what he is
6:03 going to reverse this call as there is no obvious timeline.
6:06 But as you told us, Mr. Secretary, the effects of this, even if
6:09 this issue is resolved immediately could last for days.
6:14 Do airports have the necessary infrastructure to support a situation
6:18 like that? I know obviously there are circumstances
6:20 in which there is extreme weather that affects different parts of the country,
6:25 and the airport and infrastructure around them obviously is stressed and
6:30 tested in that regard. But at this scale nationally, it just
6:33 makes you wonder when literally no one is able to get off the ground.
6:37 And people are also landing in places where they didn't intend to stay.
6:41 If all of these people are going to be okay tonight,
6:45 well, uh, look at major airports around the country, uh, have the capacity to
6:53 handle this kind of situation. Uh, and what I mean by that is, uh, they
6:59 plan for it, uh, they train their people for it.
7:03 And, um, so it's I'm sure all hands are on deck on all major airports.
7:08 I'm sure people that, uh, left work today have been called back in.
7:12 The answer is. Airports are prepared.
7:15 They train for it. And I guarantee you, all hands are on
7:19 deck on the major airports. Secretary Mark Wayne Mullen said some
7:24 planes are still landing. Mr.
7:26 Secretary, for those who are watching and listening right now, our friends and
7:29 family are still in the air. What happens with planes that are still
7:33 in flight? Well it's interesting.
7:36 I'm sitting at the Peoria airport, which is which is a mid-size airport, and the
7:40 flight that I was going to board, uh, to go to Sarasota is in the Legion flight.
7:47 And when I talked to the airport manager just a few minutes ago, he said, that
7:50 plane is on the way. And I said, is there a problem with that
7:53 plane landing safely? He said, absolutely not.
7:56 He said, the control tower here at Peoria is in contact with the with the
8:02 pilot, and that plane will land safely. So there's no worry that these
8:07 international flights that are flying into Kennedy and New York and, and
8:11 Dulles, uh, are not going to land, um, are not going to land safely.
SpaceX Starship Launches on Flight Test full transcript
0:00 7 6 5 4 3 2 1
0:14 And we're now counting up with liftoff
0:18 of the rocket just now clearing the
0:19 tower. Ed, give us the playbyplay.
0:24 >> That's a lot of stuff. 33 engine so far.
0:29 Everything nominal
0:31 the next 90 seconds
0:37 travel
0:39 that's the moment where they're under
0:41 the moment of maximum aerodynamic
0:43 pressure. You see that max Q for the
0:45 eagleeyed of those of you looking on TV.
0:48 It's where the air resistance is graded.
0:51 Um and then we'll get stage separation
0:53 of those two parts of the the Starship
0:56 system at around the 2 minute and 30
0:58 mark. Um the real demonstration is about
1:01 6 minutes and 30 seconds in part one
1:04 when the whole point of why we're
1:06 observing this. They try and catch the
1:08 booster, the first stage at the same
1:10 tower it just lifted on off with from
1:13 with what they call the chopsticks. And
1:15 then in 23 hours time, Joe, uh, after
1:19 orbiting the Earth, um, and bringing a
1:21 very interesting trajectory and corridor
1:23 over the Texas desert back to that same
1:26 launch pad, the the spacecraft 2 will
1:29 try and be caught by by SpaceX in what
1:31 would be an absolute first.
1:34 >> No doubt.
1:34 >> Yeah, just incredible uh to think about
1:37 the technological advancement here. Of
1:39 course, Ed, this is flight 15. Have they
1:41 made any adjustments since flight 14 to
1:44 better facilitate the attempt to catch
1:46 uh both of these uh parts or to make
1:48 this all go smoother?
1:50 >> Yeah, this is flight 15, but it's the
1:52 42nd iteration of the system. This is
1:55 S42, by the way. It's got the words
1:58 don't panic stencled on the side. That's
2:00 the name of [laughter] the craft. I
2:02 think given today that apt description
2:05 and name as we go through this process.
2:08 If you guys are watching on Bloomberg
2:10 television, you'll see those um tiles
2:13 right there on the left hand side of the
2:14 screen. There are 18,000 of those
2:16 ceramic heat proof tiles. And that
2:19 really is each um mission. It's not just
2:22 about going to be about um landing it
2:24 safely, but the integrity of what is the
2:26 heat shield. Those tiles make up the
2:28 heat shield. That's a really big part of
2:30 the engineering that goes into not just
2:33 the rapid reusability. And we're about
2:35 to have the stage separation, so I might
2:37 pause for that.
2:38 There we go.
2:43 >> Can we hear the coms coming from? There
2:46 we go.
2:46 >> Successful stage separation. Hot
2:48 staging. We've got six ship raptors lit.
2:52 We had a 32 engine boost back. We had
2:55 one on the outer range
2:57 >> nominal,
2:58 >> but that is not going to be a concern
3:01 for all of our landing maneuvers. So,
3:02 looking good there.
3:05 That boost back burn is going to
3:06 continue uh for just a couple of more
3:09 seconds
3:11 and we've got boost back shut down.
3:14 >> So the booster has done its boost back
3:17 shutdown. It is now on its way back to
3:19 us here at Starbase.
3:22 >> Reminder that the booster and the tower
3:24 going to continue to do these automated
3:26 checks, make sure everything looks good.
3:29 We do have the manual operator status is
3:32 set to go for a booster return. So, we
3:35 are currently expecting a super heavy
3:37 booster in just about 3 minutes from now
3:39 to hopefully come back here. We do have
3:42 six Raptor engines lit on Starship.
3:45 They're hopefully going to go for about
3:46 another 4 and 1/2 minutes until they
3:49 shut down
3:50 in space.
3:54 >> All right. So, we could have a couple of
3:55 moments here
3:56 >> uh before the main moment. Ed, I'm
3:58 watching SpaceX shares in after hours
4:01 trading. Um, how important is success of
4:04 this mission to the future, near-term
4:06 future of this stock?
4:08 >> Everything that SpaceX wants to do is
4:11 predicated on Starship working and
4:14 Starship being rapidly and fully
4:15 reusable. So you know in the first
4:18 instance um that what SpaceX outlined in
4:21 its IPO was uh a constellation of data
4:26 centers in the form of satellites around
4:28 the earth and Starship is frankly the
4:31 only system that is capable of
4:34 delivering that payload to orbit. Um,
4:36 and again this is, you know, Joe, I I a
4:39 lot of the audience may not be familiar
4:40 with SpaceX and they might say, "What
4:42 are you talking about, man, when I say,
4:44 you know, the founding principle of this
4:46 company was to make humankind a
4:48 multilanetary species?" And they really
4:51 believe that. So whatever their
4:52 commercial ambitions are for data
4:55 centers in space and AI, Elon Musk and
4:57 his colleagues also do believe that
4:59 Starship is the vehicle that gets humans
5:02 to Mars. Um so so its ability to work is
5:05 important from that standpoint. They're
5:07 also on the hook with NASA, right? You
5:09 know, taxpayers should pay attention and
5:11 look at what um SpaceX is obligated to
5:14 provide for NASA and the United States
5:16 in getting humans back to the moon. Um
5:19 because this al this vehicle also play a
5:21 role.
5:22 >> We're just about a minute away from this
5:24 potential capture, Kaylee.
5:26 >> Yeah, of course. Uh we're expected to
5:27 see uh the heavy uh landing burn start
5:31 in just about I believe 50 seconds uh Ed
5:34 just after 6 minutes into this uh flight
5:36 and then they will catch it between the
5:37 top chopsticks as Ed uh has described
5:39 for us. All of this of course Ed uh was
5:41 launched from and this landing will
5:43 happen at Starbase uh in Bokhica, Texas.
5:45 With the aftermath of the midterms and
5:47 Elon Musk not getting the candidates uh
5:50 to victory he wanted in Texas, is there
5:52 any conversation about SpaceX X's future
5:55 operations at this physical location or
5:57 should we expect that all of this is
5:58 going to be coming uh from here in Cape
6:00 Canaveral for the time being? Yeah, you
6:02 know, SpaceX by what it would say is
6:05 massively job creating enterprise,
6:08 right? Not just in Texas, but in
6:10 Florida, they have just uh completed uh
6:14 adjacent to the the their existing
6:16 facility is a new launch plad at Kennedy
6:18 Space Center. Um where we're really
6:23 >> Yeah, I'll pause here and so we can see
6:25 what happens. How about that?
6:26 >> Once again, we are doing the ox divert.
6:30 >> Amazing. And it's 13 engines down to the
6:32 five now. It'll drop down to three
6:36 here shortly.
6:38 Great. And we just got the sonic boom.
6:42 Wow.
6:43 >> Landing [laughter] bird shut down.
6:45 >> Wow.
6:46 >> And successful splashdown of the super
6:48 heavy booster back into the water off
6:51 the coast.
6:56 >> Everything looking great on the ship.
7:00 Wow. We could feel the rumble of that
7:02 splash down there. [laughter]
7:05 >> Ed Ledllo, that was not a catch between
7:08 the chopsticks. If it went in the water
7:10 and there was a sonic boom,
7:12 >> is that a problem?
7:13 >> Close. We're close to the end of the
7:14 program. So, I'll answer Joe's original
7:16 question. Why are we looking at the
7:17 stock in after hours down 2%. I don't
7:20 the technical reason, but they scrubbed
7:22 the attempt to catch the booster for
7:24 some technical reason, but there are
7:26 obviously contingencies in place for a
7:28 safe splash down in the Gulf. And
7:30 Bloomberg's Lauren Gra, who's on site,
7:32 by the way, at Starbase, just sent me a
7:34 message saying, "Wow, it just exploded
7:37 in front of us." So, obviously, there's
7:39 a bit of disappointment here reflected
7:41 in that late Friday after hours trade.
7:43 Um, but [clears throat] now I guess we
7:45 need to find out if they will try and
7:46 attempt to catch the the Starship
7:48 spacecraft, which they've not yet ever
7:50 done. You know, they've not attempted
7:51 that from a de-orbit. That was due to
7:53 take place about 22 hours from
Tanker Hits Cruise Ship in New Orleans, Triggering Rescue partial transcript
0:00 A tanker collided with a cruise ship operated by American Cruise Lines carrying more than 100 passengers at the Port of New Orleans as it was docked on the Mississippi River.
0:12 The Atlantic Asphalt tanker collided with the American Heritage ship which had docked approximately two hours earlier, according to a spokesperson for the port.
0:28 Rescues were underway on the Mississippi River, officials said.
Flights Grounded Across US Over Air Traffic Control Problems full transcript
0:00 This is pretty extraordinary that the FAA would do something, something like
0:03 this. Um.
0:05 Just give us some context here. Sure.
0:08 Um, definitely is extraordinary. So, uh, from what I understand, they're
0:12 having communication issues with their RTX.
0:16 And these are the Enroute controllers. Uh, for U.S.
0:19 airspace. I think there's some 22 of these around
0:22 the country. And, uh, you know, I think these are the
0:25 folks that are going to keep people, uh, keep airlines, their airplanes moving on
0:30 the jetway is keep them, uh, from, you know, from conflicting
0:35 with each other. Uh, and so a pretty vital portion of
0:39 the, uh, the, um, uh, the airway system in the US.
0:42 Right? Obviously.
0:43 And so I think what they've probably done is the ground stop is going to keep
0:46 any, any more airplanes from filling up U.S.
0:49 airspace while they try to figure out the communications at these systems or
0:54 these centers. I can't tell each one of them has a
0:57 large number of antenna antennas that they communicate with airplanes, uh,
1:02 directly through. Uh, we we've not been told whether or
1:05 not this communication problem is with those antennas that the communicate to
1:08 the airplanes with or between each other, because these centers will hand
1:13 over airplanes from one center to another as they move across the country.
1:18 But again, this is all about setting deconfliction traffic up in airspace.
1:22 And I think the most challenging part of that will be areas right now that are
1:27 experiencing IFR conditions where the pilots can't.
1:30 They have limited visibility. What is that IFR?
1:32 Well, yeah. Go ahead.
1:34 What is IFR instrument flight rules. Right.
1:36 Like you're in a situation where you have limited or no visibility out of the
1:40 cockpit. Am I understanding the RTC is is once an
1:45 aircraft leaves the terminal area? So you're talking, as you just said, the
1:49 high altitude where you don't necessarily have a lot of visibility
1:52 because it's the hand-off system, right? As you get closer, you hand it off to a
1:57 different thing. So, um.
1:58 Yeah. Do you think about international
2:00 flights? Right.
2:01 That are flying at high altitudes? Yeah.
2:03 And so again, my guess is that they're going to probably until they could
2:07 figure out the communication problem we're going to try to empty, uh, U.S.
2:11 airspace. If you're in route, you know, over the
2:14 Atlantic or over the Pacific. There's points where you just really
2:17 can't turn around. Go back to your own airspace.
2:19 Right. So I think they'll keep you coming.
2:21 Uh, if you're in the US, they may turn you around and get you back to the
2:24 airport you came from. Really?
2:26 If that's sort of the safest and most direct manner.
2:28 But you're right. I think you leave sort of that tower
2:31 control center, and they hand you off to the, um, the arc, and they guide you the
2:38 rest of the way along your way. And so, you know that, hey, look,
2:41 there's there's rules also about what altitude you take if you're flying, uh,
2:46 northeast or southwest. Um, and so, you know, there's rules for
2:50 deconfliction, but these, uh, centers help to make sure that everybody stays
2:55 well separated up in the airways. George, I'm just looking at, um, uh, in
2:59 the after hours, shares of Delta Airlines got about 1.2%, American
3:02 Airlines down about 1.7%. Uh, how disruptive, uh, is this?
3:08 Obviously, safety is paramount here, and that's why, you know that that's the
3:11 story. But you cover this?
3:14 You cover this. This is also a business story.
3:16 I mean, if you are, if a major disruption such as this, this is going
3:20 to cost airlines, right? It will.
3:23 Uh. Look, I think that, uh, you know, if it
3:27 lasts for a short period of time, it's not terrible.
3:30 Uh, they'll caveat it in their financial statements.
3:32 They'll give us, you know, some, uh, costs for it and then cut it out.
3:36 But, I mean, look, I think it, um, air travel is super safe in the US, and it's
3:41 super efficient, and that's, uh, that's a great thing we enjoy.
3:45 Right. And so anything that hurts, that hurts
3:48 these businesses, I don't think this is going to be a long term problem.
3:51 But the airlines, you know, generally like to have things running pretty
3:54 smoothly. It also starts to knock some of their
3:56 equipment out of the right places. And then you get sort of multiple days,
4:01 depending on how long this lapse of trying to recover from an event like
4:04 this. But again, we have a really, really
4:06 safe, uh, environment in the US. And, uh, that's what keeps the
4:10 passengers coming, keeps, uh, the growth coming.
4:12 They always like to see it pretty stable and not a problem, especially Friday
4:15 afternoon. Yeah, exactly.
4:17 Folks trying to get places or get home. Hey, one thing before we leave.
4:21 George, I feel like we've talked with you about this.
4:23 Um, is the outdated equipment. We know the administration has been
4:28 looking to make upgrades, but, I mean, is that still a problem that some of
4:33 these systems are just. They need updates.
4:35 They're old. Um, I don't know.
4:38 I think it's. Yeah, it's constantly a problem.
4:40 If there's a heavy level investment inside the, uh, uh, inside airspace, uh,
4:44 the US airspace, there's a lot of legacy equipment you have to work around, which
4:48 makes it challenging and expensive. You know, they've done some, uh,
4:52 automation recently. They're automating in Florida and
4:55 Alaska, I think on the sixth in November, they're automating control
4:59 towers. Uh, so we keep seeing a rollout of this
5:02 technology. Uh, and I think sometimes when you roll
5:05 the technology out again, you always run the risk that as you cut it into the
5:09 system, you have a problem. Uh, but, yeah, there's a constant need
5:12 to be investing in the U.S. airspace and improving it.
5:14 And it's not, uh, it's definitely not cutting edge at this point.
5:17 It's not supposed to be cutting edge. Yeah, it's supposed to be a lot more
5:20 stable, but it's got plenty of plane investment.
Ground Stop Fix Will 'Take Some Time,' Mullin Says full transcript
0:00 LEADERSHIP. FROM OUR WASHINGTON STUDIOS TO
0:01 OUR AUDIENCES WORLDWIDE, WELCOME TO "BALANCE OF POWER."
0:05 I AM JOE MATHIEU ALONGSIDE KAILEY LEINZ.
0:06 KAILEY: YOU WANT TO GO TO MARKWAYNE MULLIN WHO IS BRIEFING
0:12 THE PRESS. HE SAYS THIS GROUND STOP IS NOT
0:14 DUE TO A THREAT. OUTAGE AS OF RIGHT NOW.
0:17 YOU ARE SAYING THERE IS NO INDICATION YET THAT THIS WAS A
0:23 CYBERATTACK. DOES THAT MEAN THAT WE HAVE NOT
0:26 SEEN THE EVIDENCE AND IT'S POSSIBLE THIS COULD BE EITHER A
0:29 CYBERATTACK OR SOME KIND OF AI INTRUSION?
0:31 WE DON'T WANT TO GET AHEAD OF OURSELVES.
0:35 ANY TIME LIKE THIS HAPPENS -- LAST TIME I BELIEVE WE HAD A
0:39 NATIONAL GROUND STOPPAGE WAS 9/11.
0:43 THROUGH DHS, WE ARE GETTING A TON OF CALLS SAYING, IS THIS A
0:47 TERRORIST ATTACK? EVERYBODY IS SAFE.
0:50 THERE IS NO REASON TO BE CONCERNED ABOUT YOUR LOVED ONES,
0:54 FLYING IN OR ANYTHING LIKE THAT, JUST WANT TO MAKE SURE EVERYONE
0:56 IS AT EASE ABOUT THAT. AS WE INVESTIGATE WHAT CAUSED
1:02 THIS, YOU ALWAYS HAVE TO ASSUME THAT AS MANY CYBERATTACKS THAT
1:06 TAKE PLACE, YOU MAKE THAT ASSUMPTION, BUT AS OF RIGHT NOW,
1:10 IT IS NOT NONE. WE ARE GOING TO CONTINUE TO
1:13 WORK. THE FIRST THING WE WANT TO DO IS
1:16 MAKE SURE WE RESTORE THE COMMUNICATIONS, GET ALL THE
1:18 FLIGHTS ON THE GROUND, AND THEN GET BACK TO NORMAL OPERATIONS.
1:24 WE WILL CONTINUE TO WORK TO FIND OUT WHAT THE ROOT OF THE CAUSE
1:26 IS. IS THERE AN ASSESSMENT THAT
1:30 MICROSOFT YESTERDAY, THE FAA TODAY IS A COINCIDENCE?
1:33 I DON'T SEE ANY REASON TO CONNECT THOSE TWO AT ALL.
1:38 THOSE ARE SEPARATE ISSUES. TO BE CLEAR, CAN YOU
1:44 DEFINITIVELY RULE OUT THAT THIS IS NOT A CYBERATTACK?
1:48 HOW LONG DO YOU EXPECT THIS OUTAGE TO LAST?
1:50 WE ARE WORKING WITH SECRETARY DUFFY ON THIS.
1:53 WE ARE NOT RULING ANYTHING OUT AT THIS POINT.
1:56 THE FIRST THING IS THE SAFETY OF EVERYONE FLYING.
1:59 WE ARE ASSURED EVERYONE IS SAFE. EVERYONE THAT IS GOING TO BE IN
2:03 THE AIR, CURRENTLY ON A PLANE, LOVED ONES, LIKE I SAID, WE ARE
2:08 GOING TO GET YOU ON THE GROUND IN A SAFE MANNER.
2:10 TO SAY THAT WE CAN RULE OUT ANYTHING, THAT IS NOT WHAT WE DO
2:13 AT THIS POINT. WE WANT TO MAKE SURE EVERYONE IS
2:16 SAFE AND WE RESTORE OPERATIONS. CAN YOU TALK ABOUT THE
2:21 SPECIFIC SYSTEM BEING AFFECTED RIGHT NOW?
2:24 WE HAVE SEEN SOME PLANES LAND AT SPECIFIC AIRPORTS.
2:27 IS THAT THE CASE AT ALL AIRPORTS, ANY FLIGHT WILL BE
2:29 ALLOWED TO LAND? WE HAVE A GROUND STOPPAGE.
2:33 WE STILL HAVE TO GET THE FLIGHTS OUT.
2:35 WE WILL BE DEALING WITH THOSE CASE-BY-CASE.
2:38 I THINK YOU SAID SPECIFIC, IT IS A TELECOMMUNICATIONS OUTAGE.
2:44 I WILL NOT GET AHEAD OF THE FAA. THAT IS BARELY TO TALK ABOUT.
2:48 WE WANT TO ASSURE THE AMERICAN PEOPLE THAT THIS IS NOT A SAFETY
2:52 TO THE AMERICAN PEOPLE OR ANOTHER 9/11.
2:55 THAT IS WHAT A LOT OF PEOPLE WERE TRYING TO MAKE THE
2:58 COMPARISON TO, AND THAT IS NOT THE CASE.
2:59 WHAT KIND OF ALL OF GOVERNMENT RESPONSE IS BEING
3:03 ASSEMBLED RIGHT NOW, WHO IS INVOLVED?
3:05 EVERYONE THAT HAS A STAKE IN THIS, EVERYONE IS INVOLVED.
3:14 THIS IS UNPRECEDENTED WHEN YOU SEE SOMETHING LIKE THIS.
3:17 WE WILL CONTINUE TO GROW THE ASSETS THAT WE NEED AT IT TO
3:20 MAKE SURE, ONE, NOT TO REPEAT MYSELF, BUT THAT WE GET THE
3:24 FLIGHTS DOWNED, AND A NORMAL OPERATIONS BACKUP.
3:28 THERE ARE SEVERAL OF US INVOLVED IN IT.
3:31 BACK HERE. BLUE TIE.
3:34 IS IT CURRENTLY THE COMMUNICATIONS ARE DOWN AS WE
3:40 SPEAK RIGHT NOW? YES.
3:43 WE ARE ABLE TO COMMUNICATE AT CERTAIN LEVELS, BUT IT HAS
3:51 OVERWHELMED SOME OF THE SYSTEMS WE HAVE.
3:54 ONCE AGAIN, SECRETARY DUFFY IS ON THIS.
3:56 HE WAS ON THE PHONE EARLIER WITH THE PRESIDENT AND SEVERAL OF US.
4:00 THEY ARE DOING A PHENOMENAL JOB IN THE CRISIS.
4:02 IS IN DAYS OR WEEKS? TOO EARLY TO TELL.
4:07 LAST ABOUT SEVEN HOURS RIGHT NOW, THE PILOTS ARE TELLING US.
4:12 IS THAT THE TIMEFRAME? WE HAVE DISCUSSED ANY
4:15 TIMEFRAME. JUST THINK ABOUT THIS AS A
4:19 WHOLE. IF I HAVE A LOVED ONE AT THE
4:22 AIRPORT, JUST TO GET EVERYONE STARTED BACK UP, THE FLIGHTS
4:27 GOING AGAIN, IT WILL TAKE SOME TIME.
4:31 SO THIS ISN'T GOING TO BE JUST RESOLVED AND TURNED AROUND
4:36 WITHIN THE HOUR. THIS WILL TAKE SOME TIME.
4:41 ONCE AGAIN, EVERYONE IS SAFE, THE FLIGHTS ARE ACCOUNTED FOR.
4:44 THERE SHOULD BE NO FEAR TO THE PUBLIC AT ALL.
4:46 THE PRESIDENT HAS BEEN BRIEFED?
4:50 YOU HAVE TALKED TO HIM? YES.
4:55 I WAS NOT THE ONLY PERSON IN THE ROOM, OBVIOUSLY.
4:57 THERE ARE THOUGHT THAT THIS COULD BE AN AI RELATED ERROR OR
5:01 ISSUE. WE CALL IT SI AROUND HERE,
5:06 REMEMBER. YOU JUST CANNOT RULE OUT
5:09 ANYTHING AT THIS POINT. WE ARE GOING THROUGH THAT
5:12 PROCESS. WE ARE GOING TO FIND OUT WHAT
5:15 HAPPENED. WHEN WE DO, WE WILL TAKE THE
5:21 APPROPRIATE ACTIONS TO MAKE SURE IT DOESN'T HAPPEN AGAIN.
5:22 ARE THERE ANY EXTRA PRECAUTIONS THAT ARE GOING ON
5:27 WITH THE PRESIDENT TO KEEP HIM SAFE WHILE YOU ARE STILL
5:29 INVESTIGATING? THERE IS NO FEAR TO THE
5:31 PUBLIC. I WANT TO MAKE SURE WE SAY THIS
5:33 AGAIN. THERE IS NO REASON FOR THE
5:37 PUBLIC TO BE AFRAID OR SCARED FOR YOUR LOVED ONES.
5:39 THIS IS NOT ANOTHER 9/11. I CANNOT REPEAT THAT ENOUGH.
5:44 PEOPLE ARE MAKING THAT ASSUMPTION BECAUSE THAT IS THE
5:47 LAST TIME WE HAD A NATIONWIDE GROUND STOPPAGE.
5:49 THIS IS A TELECOMMUNICATION OUTAGE.
5:51 THIS IS MUCH DIFFERENT. JUST FOLLOWING UP ON KEVIN'S
5:57 QUESTION, THERE ARE REPORTS THAT THE FAA WAS RULING OUT A NEW AI
6:00 TRAFFIC CONTROL SYSTEM TODAY. HAS THERE BEEN ANY LINK TO THAT?
6:03 WE ARE LOOKING AT THAT. THAT IS PART OF, OBVIOUSLY
6:09 THROUGH CISA, DHS, WE ARE TAKING A LOOK, WORKING WITH OUR
6:15 COUNTERPARTS THROUGHOUT ALL AGENCIES.
6:16 ARE THERE PLANES IN THE AIR THAT THE FAA IS ABLE TO
6:21 COMMUNICATE WITH NOW? JUST AT A DIFFERENT LEVEL.
6:27 THE CLARITY -- MY UNDERSTANDING. I'M NOT TRYING TO GET AHEAD OF
6:30 MYSELF ON THIS ONE. MY UNDERSTANDING IS WE CAN STILL
6:33 COMMUNICATE, IT IS JUST AT DIFFERENT LEVELS OF THE CLARITY
6:37 THAT WE CAN GET TO. THERE IS REDUNDANCY IN MOST
6:39 COMMUNICATIONS. AS YOU CAN SEE, THERE ARE STILL
6:42 PLANES LANDING. THERE ARE STILL COMMUNICATIONS
6:45 GOING ON. OUT OF AN ABUNDANCE OF CAUTION
6:50 IS THE REASON WE DECIDED TO GROUND EVERYTHING.
6:53 THIS IS A GROUND STOP FOR THE UNITED STATES.
6:58 IS THIS AFFECTING OTHER COUNTRIES AS WELL?
6:59 NOT THAT WE ARE AWARE OF. THERE ARE TWO AREAS THAT WE KNOW
7:05 ARE NOT AFFECTED. I DON'T THINK I'M ABLE TO SHARE
7:12 THOSE NOW. TWO AREAS IN THE UNITED STATES
7:16 IT BETTER ABLE TO COMMUNICATE JUST FINE.
7:17 WHAT DOES THAT MEAN? CAN YOU DESCRIBE WHO IS
7:23 INVESTIGATING THE ROOT CAUSE OF IT, INVOLVING AGENCIES?
7:25 EVERY AGENCY THAT HAS AN ASSET THAT IS INVOLVED IN THIS
7:31 FROM THE COMMUNICATIONS SIDE, THE FAA, P.O.W., STATE
7:37 DEPARTMENT, WE ARE ALL WORKING TOGETHER.
7:39 THAT IS WHAT WE DO. I DON'T WANT TO SAY THAT THIS IS
7:43 A CRISIS, BUT IT IS, BECAUSE WE HAD TO DO A NATIONWIDE GROUND
7:48 STOPPAGE. THIS IS WHAT THE GOVERNMENT
7:51 WORKS WELL AT. THAT IS WHAT WE ARE HERE FOR.
7:54 WE ARE WELL-POSITIONED AND COMMUNICATING VERY WELL.
8:00 THE PRESIDENT TOOK A LEAD IN THIS IMMEDIATELY.
8:03 HE GAVE US THE ASSETS AND THE COMMUNICATION TO MOVE FORWARD IN
8:09 A FAST WAY. THAT IS WHAT LEADERS DO.
8:12 PRESIDENT TRUMP IS THE BEST THAT LEADING US.
8:15 I HAVE NOT GOTTEN YOU, GO AHEAD.
8:20 YOU SAID THIS IS NOT A 9/11 STYLE EVENT BUT IF IT IS A
8:25 WIDESPREAD TELECOMMUNICATIONS ISSUE, CYBERATTACK RELATED TO
8:30 SOME SORT OF TERROR, INVERSION OF TERROR?
8:32 THIS IS NOT THE SAME COMPARISON TO 9/11.
8:39 THAT IS A ROAD I WILL NOT GO DOWN.
8:42 PEOPLE ARE MAKING THAT ASSUMPTION BECAUSE IT IS A
8:44 STOPPAGE. DO WE KNOW WHAT HAS CAUSED IT
8:46 YET? WE ARE GOING TO GO THROUGH IT.
8:49 BUT I'M NOT GOING TO MAKE ASSUMPTIONS.
8:51 AS I SAID MULTIPLE TIMES, IT IS DIFFICULT TO DEAL WITH
Alice Huang Firm Procured Banned Nvidia Chips in China full transcript
0:00 Bloomberg has learned that a Chinese company founded by Alice Wang, who is at
0:03 the center of invidious controversy, procured smuggled AI chips that were
0:08 installed at the Shanghai Data Center with links to Mega Speed International.
0:12 Now, the documents offer the most explicit evidence yet that an expansive
0:16 network of Chinese companies managed to get its hands on smuggled Nvidia
0:21 hardware. Joining us now is Palmi Olson, Bloomberg
0:23 opinion columnist covering technology. And Azi Mazar, founder of Exponential
0:27 View. So thank you both for joining us.
0:29 I just want to start with you, because it's now taking on, you know, much more
0:34 of a concerning nature of the relationship between the U.S.
0:37 and China. Do you think this is where the story is
0:39 going next? Yeah.
0:43 I mean, I think, um, you know, this is great.
0:46 What's happened to Jensen Huang is great for the so-called China hawks.
0:50 Anyone that is against the idea of flooding the Chinese market with a
0:55 powerful AI chips, which is something that Fong had argued for for a long
1:00 time. His view was, let's make Chinese
1:03 companies dependent on American technology.
1:06 And that's kind of the road to supremacy for them.
1:09 Um, but not everybody agrees with that in the white House.
1:12 So I think anybody who is kind of pushing for that has lost a very
1:16 important advocate. Um, China also doesn't want to bring in
1:21 lower powered chips into into the country.
1:25 They have their own export ban on that because companies like fall can actually
1:29 produce those chips just fine. Um, what it means for the relations
1:34 between China and the US on AI regulation, I think that's going to make
1:37 even something like that much more difficult to to pull together.
Anthropic’s Amodei Doesn’t Want AI Agents to ‘Run Wild’ full transcript
0:00 You raised the course of agents, which of course is news today for everybody using
0:04 agents. Uh, so if you're if you need to be
0:08 trusted and company regulated, uh, what do you think people have to do before
0:12 they actually point agents at their sensitive information?
0:15 Yeah. So, uh, you know, I think the number one
0:18 thing is, is actually safety. Uh, these agents are getting incredibly
0:24 capable incredibly quickly. The difficulty is not whether an agent
0:29 can do this incredibly difficult task in, you know, life sciences or, you
0:34 know, writing software architecture. The pace at which they're progressing is
0:38 incredible. The thing that actually limits us in our
0:42 development of the technology, limits us in our internal deployment and also
0:47 limits customers is is doing it safely. We don't want these agents to run wild.
0:52 And that's why anthropic has invested, I think, more than than any other company
0:57 in the space, in building this technology safely, in making sure that
1:01 we have the right safeguards that that run from, you know, when we originally
1:06 trained the model, making sure we get safety in alignment, right.
1:09 You know, we have a we have a very large alignment team.
1:11 We're very paranoid. Every few months we say we've put all
1:14 this effort into safety and security alignment, and we need to do another
1:18 sprint to put even more effort into safety and safety and security in
1:21 alignment. From the beginning, anthropic has been a
1:25 company that's been focused on enterprises, and we know that
1:27 enterprises care about this more so than consumers do.
1:31 We sort of deliberately chose enterprise as a focus because we understood that it
1:37 was synergistic with our focus on safety, right.
1:39 We care about safety for values reasons. We thought about that at the beginning
1:43 when we started the company. Safety is what matters.
1:46 We want to get this right. We want to build this technology in the
1:49 right way. And then we said to ourselves, what is
1:52 the focus? What is the business focus that will
1:55 give us the right incentives to pursue safety?
1:57 And that turned out to be enterprise. Because enterprises care about trust.
2:02 They care about long term relationships. They and they, you know, they they they
2:07 care about preserving their reputation and making sure that models don't wreak
2:12 havoc. And so it's been very helpful to us as
2:15 an incentive, as a pro-social incentive in aligning our own business incentives
2:20 with what we ultimately want to accomplish in society, which is building
2:24 this technology in a way that's good for society.
FAA Grounds All Flights Nationwide full transcript
0:00 PPI DATA CAME IN A LITTLE BIT LONGER THAN ANTICIPATED.
0:05 LET'S TAKE A LOOK AT SOME MOVERS IN THE AFTER HOURS.
0:08 I WANT TO SPECIFICALLY LOOK AT AIRLINES.
0:14 EVERY AIRLINE FROM JETBLUE TO UNITED, AMERICAN, DELTA ALL
0:16 LOWER AND POST-MARKET TRADING AS THE U.S. ISSUED AN ORDER TO HOLD
0:19 FLIGHTS NATIONWIDE IN THE LAST HALF-HOUR.
0:22 TRANSPORTATION SECRETARY SEAN DUFFY CITING A COMMUNICATION
0:26 ISSUE AFFECTING ALL AIR ROUTE TRAFFIC CONTROL CENTERS.
0:31 WE ALSO HAVE CYBERSECURITY STOCKS HIGHER.
0:36 WILL GUYS BOND OF BLOOMBERG NEWS JOINS US NOW.
0:38 WHAT DO WE KNOW ABOUT WHAT HAS HAPPENED IN AIRPORTS THE LAST 20
0:41 MINUTES? GOOD AFTERNOON.
0:44 WE DON'T KNOW MUCH. THAT IS CONCERN FOR A LOT OF
0:47 TRAVELERS HEADING OUT ON VARIOUS WEEKEND TRIPS.
0:50 AS YOU MENTION, THE SECRETARY SAID THIS WAS RELATED TO THE
0:54 COMMUNICATIONS ISSUE. THIS COMES AS THE U.S.
0:57 GOVERNMENT WORKS TO MODERNIZE THE SYSTEM.
0:59 THE SECRETARY THIS WEEK AGAIN ASKED FOR 30 BILLION DOLLARS IN
1:04 FUNDING FROM CONGRESS TO FIX A PRETTY OLD SYSTEM HERE FROM
1:08 COMMUNICATIONS AND SO ON. WE WILL BE STANDING BY TO GET
1:12 MORE INFORMATION. THERE IS NOT MUCH NO -- WE KNOW
1:16 RIGHT NOW AS THE AGENCY FIGURES THIS OUT.
1:17 VONNIE: NO REAL SUGGESTION THERE IS ANYTHING MALICIOUS GOING ON
1:22 BUT ALSO NO DENIAL THAT IT COULD BE MALICIOUS.
1:26 WE LITERALLY DON'T KNOW WHAT IS CAUSING THIS OTHER THAN A
1:29 COMMUNICATION ISSUE. WILL: CORRECT.
1:33 WE HAVE NOT SEEN ANYTHING TO SAY THIS IS MALICIOUS.
1:36 I WOULD SAY OBVIOUSLY THOSE SITUATIONS ARE RARE.
1:40 ALSO ADD, UNFORTUNATELY, COMMUNICATIONS OUTAGES ARE
1:44 PRETTY COMMON IN THE U.S. FROM AN AIR TRAFFIC CONTROL
1:45 PERSPECTIVE. AGAIN, NOT TO THIS SCALE.
1:49 THE LAST TIME WE HAD A NATIONWIDE GROUND STOP WAS IN
1:52 2023 AFTER A KEY SAFETY NOTIFICATION SYSTEM WENT DOWN.
1:58 I'M SURE ANYONE TRAVELING AT THAT TIME CAN RECALL STORIES OF
2:00 MELTDOWN. BUT WE HAVE NOT SEEN ANYTHING TO
2:04 INDICATE THIS IS MALICIOUS. THESE COMMUNICATION OUTAGES ARE
2:07 QUITE COMMON. VONNIE: THANK YOU SO MUCH FOR
2:10 THE CONTEXT, WILL GUISBOND, GIVING US THE LOWDOWN ON WHAT IS
Jensen Huang Scandal Fallout Grows full transcript
0:00 >> THIS IS "BLOOMBERG BUSINESSWEEK DAILY," REPORTING
0:05 FOR THE MAGAZINE THAT HELPS GLOBAL LEADERS TO STAY AHEAD
0:08 WITH INSIGHT ON THE PEOPLE, COMPANIES, AND TRENDS SHAPING
0:09 TODAY'S COMPLEX ECONOMY. PLUS GLOBAL BUSINESS, FINANCE,
0:13 AND TECH NEWS AS IT HAPPENS. "BLOOMBERG BUSINESSWEEK DAILY"
0:17 WITH CAROL MASSAR AND TIM STENOVEC LIVE ON BLOOMBERG
0:22 RADIO, TELEVISION, AND BLOOMBERG ORIGINALS.
0:27 PLATFORMS. THIS IS "BLOOMBERG BUSINESSWEEK
0:32 DAILY" FOR FRIDAY, THE 13TH. TIM: IS SHE GOING TO SAY IT?
0:37 I HAVE BEEN DOING WITH YOU FOR SIX YEARS.
0:41 A FEW FRIDAYS THE 13TH. SHE SAID IT.
0:46 CAROL: FOR GOES BACK TO COLLEGE. I LIVED ON THE 13TH FLOOR BUT I
0:49 DID NOT SAY IT WAS A 13TH FLOOR. CAME OFF THE ELEVATOR, PUT A
0:55 SIGN-UP THAT WAS JUST -- SO EVERYONE KNEW YOU WERE STEPPING
0:56 ONTO THE 13TH FLOOR. TIM: YOU LEARN SOMETHING NEW
0:59 EVERY DAY. CAROL: THERE YOU GO.
1:02 LOOKING AT A MARKET. INVESTORS ARE A LITTLE TIRED.
1:07 WE ARE DOWN ABOUT 41 POINTS ON THE S&P 500.
1:11 THE DOW IS DOWN ABOUT 23 POINTS. SOME SMALL POINTS MOVES.
1:18 NASDAQ 100 CONTINUES TO PULL BACK A LITTLE BIT.
1:26 TIM: IS THE SOX. EVERYTHING WAS LOWER.
1:27 NOW IT IS DOWN ABOUT 4%. STILL UNDER PRESSURE BUT OFF THE
1:29 WORST LEVELS OF THE DAY. CAROL: WE GOT ANOTHER INFLATION
1:33 PRINT. EASING A LITTLE BIT.
1:37 MAYBE EASING CONCERN ABOUT AGGRESSIVE FED RATE HIKES BUT IT
1:40 IS THE FOCUS ON THE SEMICONDUCTORS AND THE FOCUS ON
1:43 A NAME LIKE NVIDIA, WHICH IS SOMETHING WE ARE GOING TO BE
1:45 TALKING ABOUT AS WELL. WE WILL GET INTO THE MOST READ
1:53 STORY ON THE BLOOMBERG, JENSEN HUANG'S LAST HOURS AS NVIDIA
1:54 CEO. IT'S BEEN ALL AROUND.
1:57 THERE'S A LOT OF PICK UP ON THIS STORY.
2:01 TIM: YOU JUST HAVE TO SEE IT TAX TO THE BELIEVE THAT HE'S BEEN
2:04 CALLING HIMSELF IN RECENT DAYS. CAROL: NOT THE JENSEN HUANG WE
2:08 HAVE SEEN IN PUBLIC FOR THE PAST FEW YEARS.
2:10 A VERY DIFFERENT SIDE OF HIM BUT WE GET IT.
2:14 IT IS STILL A KILLER STORY. GLOBAL EQUITY FUNDS DRAWING
2:16 RECORD INFLOWS ACCORDING TO THE B OF A.
2:19 WE WONDER HOW THAT NVIDIA STORY IS PLAYING OVERSEAS.
2:29 OUR BUREAU CHIEF AND SEOUL IN A MOMENT.
2:36 TIM: AND GLOBAL X ETF SAYS THE GLOBAL TRADE IS NOT DEAD.
2:38 MAYBE JUST SLEEPING. CAROL: WE WILL GET INTO IT.
2:46 SOUNDS LIKE JENSEN. WE HAVE TO TALK ABOUT MICROSOFT.
2:52 LONGEST OUTAGES. STILL WORKING ON IT.
3:03 TIM: I'M THE ONLY PERSON NOT AFFECTED IN MY FAMILY
3:04 BECAUSE I USE THE BLOOMBERG TERMINAL.
3:07 WE DON'T USE OUTLOOK. WE HAVE A DIFFERENT SYSTEM.
3:10 SO MANY COMPANIES RUN ON THIS TECHNOLOGY.
3:14 THEY HAVE BEEN UNDER PRESSURE IN THE LAST 24 HOURS.
3:15 UNPRODUCTIVE. CAROL: INCLUDING IN THE
3:18 FINANCIAL SPACES. THEY SAY THEY ARE MAKING
3:20 PROGRESS. WE WILL UNPACK THAT STORY.
3:23 LET'S GET AN UPDATE ON THE TRADING SESSION.
3:25 HERE IS CHARLIE PELLETT. CHARLIE: HAPPY FRIDAY.
3:30 FRIDAY THE 13TH. MICROSOFT SAID IT'S MAKING
3:31 PROGRESS. SHARES UP BY ABOUT .2% ON A DAY
3:36 WHEN STOCKS ARE SELLING OFF. NVIDIA DOWN ANOTHER 2.3%, WELL
3:41 OFF SESSION LOWS ON NVIDIA. SOX DOWN BY 3.9%.
3:48 S&P AS A BASELINE DOWN 41, DROP OF .5%.
3:53 AGO. RIGHT NOW DOWN BY LESS THAN 1/10
3:56 OF 1%. DOW DROPPING BY 18 POINTS.
4:00 NASDAQ LOWER BY 1%. NASDAQ 100 INDEX DOWN 1.4%.
4:06 THE S&P 500 INDEX DOWN .5%. IT IS ON TRACK FOR A WEEKLY
4:12 GAIN, LOOKING AT A POTENTIAL GAIN OF 2.4% FOR THE WEEK FOR
4:13 THE S&P. SOX DOWN 3.9%.
4:22 10-YEAR AT 5.1 4% AFTER THIS MORNING'S INFLATION DATA.
4:25 GOLD IS LITTLE CHANGED ON THE DAY COME UP JUST ABOUT $1.50.
4:35 WEST TEXAS INTERMEDIATE CRUDE STRUGGLING FOR DIRECTION.
4:39 BRENT, $95.92. UP BY ABOUT 1/10 OF 1%.
4:46 NVIDIA ON TRACK TO NOT TO ITS WORST WEEKEND MORE THAN 18
4:47 MONTHS. AT LEAST 13 ANALYST COVERING THE
4:51 CHIPMAKER HAVE DOWNGRADED THE SHARES THIS MONTH.
4:55 RIGHT NOW DOWN BY 2.2%. NVIDIA'S BOARD IS SAID TO HAVE
5:03 APPROACHED ARM CEO RENEE HAAS FOR A POTENTIAL SUCCESSOR TO
5:04 JENSEN HUANG. THAT'S ACCORDING TO THE FT.
5:09 HAAS IS IN NVIDIA LOAN. STOCKS TURNING POSITIVE COME UP
5:12 BY ONE POINT. S&P DOWN .5%.
5:16 THAT IS A BLOOMBERG BUSINESS FLASH.
5:19 THANK YOU'S -- CAROL: THE CHINESE COMPANY
5:27 DOGGING NVIDIA PROCURED CHIPS THAT WERE INSTALLED IN A
5:32 ACCORDING TO DOCUMENTS REVIEWED BY BLOOMBERG NEWS.
5:40 TIM: AND JENSEN HUANG'S AFFAIR WITH ALICE HUANG LED TO --
5:45 WE'RE CURIOUS HOW THIS IS PLAYING OVERSEAS.
5:49 CAROL: GLOBAL EQUITY FUNDS ARE TRACKING RECORD INFLOWS.
5:52 INVESTOR MONEY HAS BEEN MOVING INCREASINGLY AROUND THE WORLD,
5:54 NOT JUST THE UNITED STATES. WHAT A GLOBAL VIEW OF THAT STORY
5:58 AND MORE IS CAP BARTON. -- KAT BARTON.
6:04 WE ARE DELIGHTED TO GET SOME TIME WITH YOU.
6:08 OUR TIME FRAMES DON'T ALWAYS -- THE TIME DIFFERENCES WITHOUT HOW
6:12 IS THE NVIDIA STORY OF PLAYING AROUND THE WORLD?
6:16 KAT: IN SOUTH KOREA THEY LOVED JENSEN HUANG.
6:19 THEY WERE SUCH BIG FANS. HE CAME TO SOUTH KOREA AND HAD
6:23 THIS BIG SUMMIT WHERE HE SAT DOWN AND DRINK BEER AND ATE
6:31 FRIED CHICKEN WITH SAMSUNG AND SK HYNIX.
6:34 AND THEY ARE HUGE CUSTOMERS OR SUPPLIERS.
6:35 NVIDIA IS THEIR BIGGEST CUSTOMER.
6:38 JENSEN HAD THIS ROCK STAR WELCOME.
6:40 PEOPLE WERE QUEUING OUTSIDE THE RESTAURANT TO CATCH A GLIMPSE OF
6:41 HIM. THE LAST FEW DAYS SINCE THE
6:46 STORY BROKE THE LOCAL MEDIA COVERAGE HAS BEEN REALLY
6:47 DISAPPOINTED. PEOPLE ARE LIKE WE FEEL
6:50 PASSIONATELY LET DOWN. CAROL: DO THEY FEEL LIKE YOU
6:53 SHOULD A STATE OF THE COMPANY? CAT: NO, BUT THEY FEEL LIKE A
6:58 SENSE OF PERSONAL BETRAYAL. WHY DID HE DO THIS?
7:02 WE LOVED HIM. THE CONCERN IS WHAT IS THE
7:06 IMPACT ON SAMSUNG AND SK HYNIX. FOR NOW WE HAVE HAD THE MINISTER
7:12 OF ICT COME OUT AND SAID EVERYTHING IS LOCKED IN.
7:14 NO SUDDEN MOVEMENTS. IT WILL BE FINE.
7:17 CAROL: ICT IS? CAT: INFORMATION AND
7:21 COMMUNICATION TECHNOLOGY. THE GUY IN CHARGE OF THEIR
7:24 SEMICONDUCTORS AND ALSO A DEPUTY PRIME MINISTER.
7:28 YES, DON'T WORRY. THE AGREEMENTS ARE SECURE.
7:31 WE NOT EXPECTING ANY BIG CHANGES.
7:34 OBVIOUSLY IT DEPENDS ON WHO THE NEXT NVIDIA LEADER IS.
7:38 WHAT'S GOING TO CHANGE. TIM: TO WHAT EXTENT IS THE
7:42 RELATIONSHIP THAT JENSEN HAD WITH THE LEADERS OF SK HYNIX AND
7:46 THE LEADERS OF SAMSUNG AND THE LEADERS OF OTHER COMPANIES IN
7:51 THE REGION -- TO WHAT EXTENT DOES THE NEXT CEO HAVE TO
7:54 CONTINUE THOSE RELATIONSHIPS? WE TALK A LOT ABOUT THE FACT HE
7:59 WAS THE AMBASSADOR TO AN ENTIRE TECHNOLOGY AND INDUSTRY.
8:06 IT IS HARD TO IMAGINE ANYONE FILLING THAT PART OF ISSUES.
8:10 CAT: HE WAS SUCH A BIG PERSONALITY AND YOU REMEMBER
8:14 WITH SAMSUNG ELECTRONICS, SK HYNIX, IT IS LIKE THESE BIG
8:18 FAMILY-RUN -- TIM: CAN YOU EXPLAIN THE
8:21 SIGNIFICANCE OF THOSE COMPANIES IN KOREA?
8:26 CAT: THEY ARE HOW THE SOUTH KOREAN ECONOMY RUNS.
8:30 THEY HAVE DOMINATED SINCE THE 1970'S AND THEY HAVE BEEN RUN --
8:33 WE ARE IN A THIRD-GENERATION. SAMSUNG IS THIRD-GENERATION AND
8:39 THEY ARE RUNNING THESE AMAZING COMPANIES.
8:43 WITH SAMSUNG AND SK, THEY HAVE COME INTO THEIR OWN IN THE LAST
8:45 FEW WITH THE SEMICONDUCTOR AI PLAY.
8:49 THE PERSONAL RELATIONSHIPS REALLY MATTER.
8:51 WHEN YOU ARE DOING BUSINESS IN ASIA, CUSTOMER RELATIONSHIPS
8:54 MATTER. THE NEW LEADER WILL HAVE TO COME
8:58 IN AND REBUILD THAT. IT IS A TINY BIT EMBARRASSING
9:03 FOR SAMSUNG AND SK THAT THEY WERE SO CLOSE TO THIS GUY WHO
9:07 HAS HAD TO STEP DOWN. WE WILL HAVE TO RECONFIGURE.
9:09 I THINK THERE'S A BIT OF BRIDGE BUILDING.
9:14 NOT THE LEAST WITH CHINA AND THE SIGNIFICANCE THEY ARE.
9:19 CAROL: THE GLOBAL AI RACE, SAMSUNG AND SEMICONDUCTOR, SK
9:21 HYNIX MAKE UP HALF THE KOSPI. MANY TIMES THERE IS CONCERNS IT
9:24 PLAYS OUT ON THE KOSPI. THE GLOBAL AI RACE, CHINA WAS TO
9:31 EXPAND COOPERATION IN EMERGING AREAS, INCLUDING AI AND
9:33 BIOMEDICINE. THE FORD MINISTERS WERE MEETING
9:37 IN BEIJING. -- FOREIGN MINISTERS WERE
9:40 MEETING IN BEIJING. HOW IS EVERYBODY LOOKING?
9:48 WE ARE SO U.S. CENTRIC HERE IN THE BIG U.S. PLAYERS AND WE
9:50 UNDERSTAND IT'S A RACE BETWEEN U.S. AND CHINA.
9:54 WHAT IS THE PERSPECTIVE THAT YOU GUYS DO WHEN YOU THINK ABOUT THE
9:56 AI AND GLOBAL RACE? CAT: SOUTH KOREA IS ANY UNIQUE
10:01 POSITION. THEY ARE ONE OF THE ONLY PLACES
10:04 IN THE WORLD THAT IS ALREADY MAKING SERIOUS, SERIOUS MONEY
10:05 FROM THIS. IN THE GLOBAL GOLD RUSH THEY ARE
10:11 SELLING SHOVELS, THESE CHIPS. FOR THEM, THEY WANT TO KEEP
10:14 EVERYONE HAPPY. IN SOUTH KOREA IT'S EXISTENTIAL,
10:22 THE U.S. RELATIONSHIP. IT IS THEIR SECURITY.
10:24 THEY ARE COMMITTED TO WASHINGTON.
10:27 WHATEVER ADMINISTRATION IT IS, THEY WILL TRY TO MAINTAIN THAT
10:28 RELATIONSHIP. THERE ARE 27,000 U.S. TROOPS TO
10:32 PROTECT THEM AGAINST THE NUCLEAR ARMED NORTH.
10:35 THAT IS A FUNDAMENTAL THING. ECONOMICALLY, GEOPOLITICALLY.
10:40 THEY ARE NOT -- THIS ADMINISTRATION IS OPEN TO TRADE.
10:47 CHINA IS A TRAITOR -- MAJOR TRADING PARTNER FOR THEM.
10:51 THEY SEE THE AI TRADE FROM A DIFFERENT PERSPECTIVE.
10:55 IT IS 50% OF THE KOSPI. IT IS A HUGE DEAL FOR THEM.
11:00 THEY NEED THIS TO CONTINUE. THEY ARE BANKING ON THE EXCESS
11:04 TAX REVENUES FOR THE NEXT MULTIPLE YEARS.
11:07 THE GOVERNMENT IS PLANNING TO HAVE A FUTURE DEFENSE FUND AND
11:09 HOW THEY SPEND THIS TO BRING SOCIETY TOGETHER.
11:13 THIS IS A HUGE DEAL FOR THEM. IT IS A NATIONAL STRATEGIC
11:16 ASSET, SEMICONDUCTORS. THEY BELIEVE HE CAN TRANSFORM
11:21 THEIR COUNTRY'S FATE AND DO NOT WANT TO SEE IT CRUSHED
11:25 BY A POWER BATTLE BETWEEN WASHINGTON AND BEIJING.
11:29 TIM: I WANT TO END ON BEIJING. YOU MENTIONED NORTH KOREA.
11:35 YOU INTIMATED CHINA AND THE COMPLICATED RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN
11:36 KOREA AND CHINA. THE SIGNIFICANCE -- WE DON'T
11:41 KNOW THE STORY OF ALICE HUANG. CHINA IS DENYING SHE'S A SPY.
11:48 SHE IS ALLEGED TO HAVE BEEN OR TO BE A SPY FOR CHINA.
11:52 HOW DOES THAT COMPLICATE FACTORS WITH THE JENSEN STORY?
11:56 CAT: IT IS TRICKY. THERE ARE SO MANY RESTRICTIONS
11:58 ON WHAT CAN GO TO CHINA. THE MOST HIGH-END CHIPS.
12:06 SAMSUNG AND SK ABIDE BY THAT BECAUSE OF THEIR RELATIONSHIP
12:07 WITH THE WAS BEING SO CRUCIAL FOR THEM.
12:10 IT'S DEFINITELY A COMPLICATING FACTOR IF YOU THINK NVIDIA HAS
12:16 POTENTIALLY BEEN -- WHO KNOWS WHAT COULD HAVE HAPPENED IN THAT
12:19 SPHERE IS WITH THE U.S. THAT IS THE CASE.
12:24 CAROL: DIFF THAT WAS THE CASE, WILL THAT TARNISHED NVIDIA'S
12:29 VIEW NO MATTER WHO TAKES OVER? CAT: THEY COULD PROBABLY -- IF
12:34 THE COMPANY WERE CAREFUL ABOUT HOW THEY MANAGED IT, YOU COULD
12:37 CLEARLY ARGUE THIS WAS A PERSONAL RATHER THAN COMPANY
12:43 FAILURE, ALTHOUGH THERE MIGHT BE SOME NEED TO EXPLAIN.
12:48 IT WOULD BE PROBLEMATIC FOR SAMSUNG AND SK WHO HAVE TO BE
12:51 VERY CAREFUL. THEY HAVE OTHER CUSTOMERS AND
12:56 OTHER INTERESTS THEY HAVE TO LOOK OUT FOR.
13:01 NVIDIA HAS BEEN SO IMPORTANT FOR THEIR STRATOSPHERIC GROWTH IN
13:02 THE LAST FEW YEARS. IT'S GOING TO BE A VERY
13:07 DIFFICULT RECOVERY PERIOD. CAROL: WE ARE GLAD WE COULD
13:14 CARVE OUT SOME TIME WITH YOU. COME BACK SOON.
13:16 CAT BARTON. WE WILL WATCH NVIDIA AS THE
13:21 HEADLINES CONTINUE AND WE WILL HAVE MORE ON JENSEN HUANG'S LAST
13:24 HOURS AS CEO IN A MOMENT. WE HAVE ANOTHER NAME ON THE
13:26 RADAR. TIM: MICROSOFT MAKING EFFORTS TO
13:35 RESTORE ITS FLAGSHIP OUTLOOK. WE HAD TO THE BLOOMBERG SEATTLE
13:41 BUREAU AND MATT DAY. ARE WE BACK?
13:49 MATT: THINGS SHIFTED INTO RECOVERY MODE THIS MORNING.
13:54 MICROSOFT SEEMED TO NOT KNOW WHAT THE ISSUE WAS IN THE EARLY
13:56 RECOVERY EFFORTS. NOW THEY SAY THEY ARE MOSTLY
14:01 BACK AND THEY ARE BRINGING THING BACK IN STAGES THAT WILL NOT
14:02 CAUSE OTHER ISSUES. I HEARD FROM A CONTACT AT A
14:05 SEATTLE COMPANY THEY ARE STILL HAVING PROBLEMS WITH OUTLOOK.
14:09 THERE'S A LOT OF BACKLOG OUT THERE.
14:12 WE SHOULD EXPECT EMAILS TO START ROLLING IN TODAY.
14:14 TIM: WHY DID THIS HAPPEN? MATT: THE VAGUE VERBIAGE FROM
14:20 MICROSOFT IS THERE WAS A NETWORK CONFIGURATION CHANGE THAT THEY
14:23 THINK CAUSED THIS. WE UNDERSTAND THAT THEY TRIED TO
14:28 RUN EXCHANGE, THE BACKEND FOR A LOT OF THE EMAIL SERVICES THAT
14:32 THEY OFFER AND IT CRIPPLED THE SERVER AND USING ALL OF ITS
14:36 WORST POWER TO MAKE THE THING UNUSABLE AND WHY THAT WAS THE
14:38 CASE TOOK THEM QUITE A WHILE. CAROL: IS THAT BAFFLING?
14:42 PERPLEXING? THIS IS A COMPANY THAT TONS OF
14:48 ENGINEERS. THEY UNDERSTAND THE STUFF.
14:52 TIM: THEY BUILT IT FROM THE GROUND UP.
14:54 CAROL: WHY DID IT HAPPEN? COULD IT HAVE BEEN SOMETHING
14:59 THEY COULD HAVE CAUGHT BECAUSE IT BECAME A BIG IMPACT?
15:02 MATT: BEST PRACTICES FOR CLOUD SERVICES, IF YOU LET ANY SORT OF
15:05 CHANGE, DO IT IN A CONFINED AREA.
15:08 YOU WAIT TO SEE IF ANYTHING BREAKS AND THEN ROLL IT UP
15:09 BROADLY OVER TIME. THAT'S A QUESTION THEY HAVE TO
15:13 ANSWER, HOW THIS SEEMED TO GO GLOBAL VERY QUICKLY OVER THE
15:16 COURSE OF A COUPLE OF HOURS YESTERDAY AFTERNOON NEW YORK
15:17 TIME. THEN IT TOOK THEM SO LONG TO FIX
15:20 THIS. IT SEEMS LIKE EVERY YEAR WE HAVE
15:24 HAD A VERSION OF THESE. AWS LAST YEAR, CROWDSTRIKE A
15:28 COUPLE OF YEARS AGO. YOU THINK ONLINE HE KNOWS SHOULD
15:33 BE RELATIVELY SOLVED PROBLEM. I KNOW THAT'S WAY TOO SIMPLE FOR
15:36 OUR PALS AT MICROSOFT. THIS MORE TECHNICAL STUFF
15:40 BENEATH THE COVERS BUT UNACCEPTABLE IN THE EYES A LOT
15:41 OF CUSTOMERS. TIM: IT SHOWS HOW FRAGILE
15:44 EVERYTHING IS. -- I HAVE FRIENDS WHO WORK IN
15:50 REAL ESTATE AND FINANCE WHO WEREN'T ABLE TO DO WORK AND WENT
15:59 TO THE GYM YESTERDAY, A BROTHER IN SCHOOL WHO WASN'T ABLE TO DO
16:02 WORK, PEOPLE WEREN'T GETTING EMAILS, THEY WERE SUPPOSED TO
16:05 HAVE EMAILS AND COULD NOT ACTUALLY MEET, THIS IS SO BIG.
16:10 CAN YOU EXPLAIN THE WAY MICROSOFT TOUCHES SO MANY
16:11 COMPANIES AROUND THE WORLD? >> IN OUR PERSONAL LIVES, A LOT
16:16 OF FOLKS USE GMAIL. THERE ARE THOUSANDS OF
16:21 ALTERNATIVES. BUT FOR THE CORPORATE WORLD,
16:25 MICROSOFT IS THE BIGGEST GAME IN TOWN.
16:31 450 MILLION USERS OF THEIR M 300 65 BUNDLE.
16:33 IT IS JUST PICKUPS, IT IS A HUGE DEAL.
16:35 THERE IS OF THE QUIP THAT CLOUD IS REALLY SOMEBODY ELSE'S
16:36 COMPUTER. IN THIS CASE, THAT CLOUD IS
16:38 MICROSOFT COMPUTER. THE EXCHANGE AND ADMINISTRATORS,
16:46 YOU REMEMBER THAT JOB, USED TO RUN IN THE BACK ROOM.
16:49 THAT HAS DISAPPEARED IN FAVOR OF CENTRALIZED OPERATIONS LIKE
16:49 MICROSOFT. THIS IS A PROBLEM OF THAT.
16:56 SO MANY EGGS IN ONE BASKET THAT IS MAINTAINED, BUT THERE ARE
16:57 DAYS LIKE YESTERDAY. CAROL: I'M NOT SURE WHETHER IT
17:03 IS MORE PERPLEXING -- THEY KNOW THE PROBLEM, RIGHT?
17:08 >> IT SEEMS LIKE THEY FIGURED IT OUT.
17:10 ONE OF THE ISSUES WAS IT TOOK A WHILE TO DO SO.
17:12 I WAS WATCHING THE UPDATES ROLLOUT HOURLY THROUGH THE
17:16 AFTERNOON AND NIGHT YESTERDAY. A BUNCH OF FALSE STARTS WHERE
17:19 THEY PROPOSED A FIX AND COULD NOT FIGURE OUT IF IT WAS WORKING
17:21 BECAUSE THAT SERVER WAS PARALYZED, TOO.
17:25 THEY PROMISED US A FULL AFTER ACTION REPORT TO GIVE FOLKS
17:27 DETAILS. BUT WE ARE SCRATCHING OUR HEADS
17:28 FOR NOW. CAROL: WHAT IS TOP OF MIND WHEN
17:33 WE COME OUT ON THE OTHERS THIS FOR THIS COMPANY?
17:38 THIS IS A COMPANY WHO UNDERSTANDS THIS WORLD, AND I
17:41 UNDERSTAND PROBLEMS HAPPEN, THAT IS THE DIGITAL WORLD.
17:44 WHAT WOULD BE THE NUMBER ONE QUESTION YOU WOULD ASK THEM?
17:48 >> YOU START TO WONDER HOW MANY CAN THEY TAKE?
17:54 THESE -- IT IS NOT JUST THESE INCIDENTS, THEY'VE HAD SECURITY
17:55 INCIDENTS. GO BACK A NUMBER OF YEARS,
17:58 ISSUES WITH UNAUTHORIZED FOLKS GETTING ACCESS TO GOVERNMENT
18:02 EMAIL SYSTEMS, ALL MAINTAINED BY MICROSOFT.
18:05 THE STOCK HASN'T MOVED A WHOLE LOT TODAY.
18:10 THERE IS A BIG MOAT AROUND MICROSOFT OFFICE GENERALLY.
18:15 AS THESE EVENTS PILE UP, YOU WONDER WHEN BIG CORPORATE I.T.
18:18 BUYERS ARE GOING TO MAKE OTHER CHOICES.
18:19 THERE IS NOT A SUITE AS COMPREHENSIVE AS MICROSOFT, BUT
18:26 THE BIG QUESTION IS WHAT ARE YOU DOING TO PROVE THE VALUE OF THIS
18:29 SYSTEM THAT IS SO RELIABLE? IS THERE AN OPPORTUNITY THERE
18:31 FOR COMPETITORS? CAROL: MICROSOFT SHARES WERE
18:37 DOWN AS MUCH AS ONE POINT 8%. THEY ARE UP ABOUT ONE THIRD OF
18:40 ONE PERCENT TODAY. THANK YOU SO MUCH.
18:44 THAT IS MATT DAY, BLOOMBERG NEWS TECHNOLOGY REPORTER.
18:46 TIM: ACROSS THE BLOOMBERG TERMINAL, THREE PEOPLE FAMILIAR
18:50 WITH THE MATTER THAT KEVIN HASSETT IS EXPECTED TO DEPART
18:53 THE WHITE HOUSE IN THE COMING WEEKS.
18:55 THIS IS BLOOMBERG. ♪
19:03 CHARLIE: IT'S 2:21 P.M. ON WALL STREET.
19:07 WE CHECKED MARKETS ALL DAY LONG. THE DOW JONES INDUSTRIAL AVERAGE
19:09 SWINGING BETWEEN GAINS AND LOSSES.
19:10 RIGHT NOW LOOKING AT A DECLINE OF -- FLAT ON THE DAY FOR THE
19:15 DOW. S&P 500 INDEX DOWN .50%.
19:21 CHIP NAMES HIT HARD. MASTEC 100 INDEX DOWN 1.2%.
19:27 THE PHILADELPHIA STOCK EXCHANGE SEMICONDUCTOR INDEX DOWN BY
19:30 ANOTHER 3.4% OFF OF SESSION LOWS.
19:33 NVIDIA DOWN AGAIN. SHARES TRADING LOWER.
19:37 NVIDIA DOWN BY JUST ABOUT 2.1%. THE 10 YEAR CURRENTLY YIELDING
19:45 5.15% HEADING INTO THE WEEKEND. 30 YEAR, 5.47 PERCENT.
19:51 THE TWO-YEAR, FOUR POINT 86%. GOLD, LITTLE CHANGE.
19:59 WEST TEXAS INTERMEDIATE CRUDE DOWN .20%.
20:03 A BARREL OF BRENT 95.79, DOWN UNDER .10 PERCENT.
20:08 NVIDIA'S BOARD HAS REPORTEDLY APPROACHED RENEE HOSS IN HIS
20:14 SEARCH FOR A POTENTIAL SUCCESSOR TO JENSEN HUANG.
20:19 SHARES DOWN BY 4.4 PERCENT. ISABELLE LEE CAUGHT UP WITH THE
20:23 PERSHING SQUARE CAP MANAGEMENT CEO AND SAID IT IS SAD TO SEE
20:27 JENSEN HUANG DEPART THE COMPANY HE COFOUNDED.
20:33 >> AMAZING CEO, SET TO SEE HIM LEAVE.
20:36 NVIDIA WILL SURVIVE. THE COMPANY WILL DO GREAT.
20:44 >> CAPITAL CEO BILL SPEAKING WITH BLOOMBERG.
20:48 SHARES DOWN BY 2.8 PERCENT. STOCKS LOWER, S&P 500 DOWN FIVE
20:52 .1%. PHILADELPHIA STOCK EXCHANGE
20:55 TRADING LOWER, DOWN BY 3.5%. I'M CHARLIE PELLETT.
20:59 CAROL AND TIM. CAROL: THE MOST READ STORY ON
21:04 THE BLOOMBERG TODAY, JENSEN HUANG'S LAST HOURS AS THE CEO OF
21:12 NVIDIA, HOW IT EVENTUALLY LED TO HIS GETTING TO THAT POINT,
21:17 BECOMING THE FORMER CEO. BASICALLY HOW HE RESIGNED TO
21:19 RESIGNING. IT IS A BLOOMBERG EXCLUSIVE THAT
21:23 HAS BEEN PICKED UP BY MANY ON SOCIAL.
21:25 HERE TO TELL US ABOUT IT, IAN KING IN THE BLOOMBERG SAN
21:29 FRANCISCO NEWS BUREAU. THANK YOU FOR JOINING US.
21:33 I KNOW YOU HAD A BUSY WEEK. WHATEVER, I DON'T CARE, AND
21:37 WORSE. THESE ARE UNUSUAL WORDS FROM AN
21:41 INDIVIDUAL WE USUALLY SEE BEING VERY DIRECT, FULL OF ENERGY,
21:44 CHARISMATIC, A TAKE CHARGE KIND OF GUY.
21:48 WHAT LED TO THE GIVING UP OF JENSEN HUANG?
21:52 YOU GUYS HAVE INCREDIBLE REPORTING HERE.
21:58 >> THE SITUATION HE PUT HIMSELF IN AND THE SITUATION THEY ARE
22:04 FORCED TO DEAL WITH WAS SUCH THAT THERE WAS NO CHOICE.
22:09 THERE WERE RUMORS AND SPECULATION OF ADMISSION OF AN
22:15 AFFAIR WITH SOMEBODY WHO WAS A CUSTOMER.
22:16 WHEN YOU FACTOR IN AN AFFAIR WITH SOMEONE WHO ACTUALLY WORKS
22:20 FOR THE COMPANY, SOMETHING THAT IS EXPLICITLY NOT PERMISSIBLE
22:27 UNDER THE COMPANY STATED RULES, THEY WERE IN A POSITION WHERE
22:32 THEY HAD NO CHOICE BUT TO BRING THIS TO HIM.
22:33 HE HAD NO CHOICE, THERE WAS NO WAY AROUND IT.
22:37 TIM: CAN YOU DESCRIBE, AND YOU DO IT IN THE PIECE YOU WROTE SO
22:41 WELL WITH JAKE BENNETT, THE THREATS THAT EMERGED IN THE LAST
22:43 FEW DAYS, THE DISCUSSIONS HE HAD WITH CONFIDENCE AND MEMBERS OF
22:48 THE BOARD, AND HIS DEMEANOR, THE WAY HE WAS TALKING, VERSUS THE
22:52 JENSEN HUANG THAT FOR SO MANY YEARS YOU COVERED, THIS PERSON
22:57 WHO BECAME KNOWN AS THE CENTRAL BANKER OF THE AI INDUSTRY.
23:02 >> WE HAVE ALL SEEN HIM ON STAGE, AT EVENTS, ON TV,
23:11 APPEARING WITH THE PRESIDENT, AND THERE WAS NOTHING APART FROM
23:14 ABSOLUTE CONTROL OF HIMSELF AND THE MESSAGE.
23:20 THE BRILLIANCE, THE HUMOR, CHARISMA, CONFIDENCE, AND
23:22 ABSOLUTE DRIVE TOWARDS THE SAME GOAL.
23:26 AND WHAT ACCORDING TO OUR REPORTING HAPPENED IN THE LAST
23:31 FEW DAYS IS HE TRIED TO CAUTERIZE THE WOUND'S, ACCEPT
23:33 RESPONSIBILITY. IN HIS LETTER INTERNALLY, HE
23:39 TOOK RESPONSIBILITY FOR HIS ACTIONS AND APOLOGIZED.
23:43 BUT IN THE END, THAT WASN'T ENOUGH.
23:47 HE WASN'T ABLE TO REMAIN IN CONTROL.
23:50 HE WAS REDUCED TO BECOMING SELF-CRITICAL, TO RESIGNATION.
23:57 CAROL: IT CERTAINLY SPEAKS TO HIS STATE OF MIND.
24:01 ONE CAN UNDERSTAND WHY. I'M ALSO CURIOUS AS YOU REPORTED
24:05 THIS OUT, HOW CONFLICT AT BOARD WAS -- HOW CONFLICTED THE BOARD
24:09 WAS? IT WAS HIS BOARD, AND ANYONE WHO
24:14 HAD BEEN AT THE COMPANY A LONG TIME ONLY KNEW JENSEN HUANG AS
24:16 CEO OF THE COMPANY. >> SEVERAL MEMBERS OF THAT BOARD
24:21 HAVE LITERALLY BEEN ON THE BOARD FOR THREE DECADES.
24:27 THIS IS NOT A BOARD OF PEOPLE WHO HAVE BEEN BROUGHT IN TO HOLD
24:30 HIS FEET TO THE FIRE AND TO CONTROL A COMPANY THAT WAS IN
24:34 TROUBLE. EVERYONE HAS BEEN ALONG FOR THE
24:37 RIDE, WHETHER IT IS EMPLOYEES, BOARD MEMBERS, THEY HAVE ALL
24:40 DONE VERY WELL, THEY HAVE NO REASON TO BE EXPOSING HIM TO
24:46 SEVERE SCRUTINY BECAUSE THIS COMPANY HAS DONE EXTREMELY WELL.
24:50 I THINK WHAT MATTERS NOW THAT HE'S NO LONGER A PART OF THAT
24:53 COMPANY IS HOW THE BOARD WILL PROCEED AND HOW THE PEOPLE WHO
24:59 USED TO WORK FOR HIM VERY CLOSELY RESPOND TO THIS.
25:03 WHETHER THEY GROW, WHETHER THEY SHOW UP IN A WAY THEY WEREN'T
25:04 PREVIOUSLY ALLOWED TO. WHETHER THEY CONTINUE TO BE THE
25:10 WORLD CHAMPION ENGINEERS, BECAUSE THEY ARE.
25:13 THAT IS GOING TO DETERMINE WHAT NVIDIA'S FUTURE LOOKS LIKE.
25:18 TIM: I WANT TO TALK ABOUT MORE ABOUT THEIR FUTURE IN A MINUTE,
25:21 BUT JENSEN HUANG'S FUTURE, HE'S HIRED A HIGH-POWERED LAW FIRM AT
25:24 THIS POINT. WHAT HAPPENS NEXT FOR HIM?
25:29 >> BECAUSE OF THE NATURE OF SOME OF THE REPORTS, THE NATURE OF
25:33 THE INTEREST THAT HAS BEEN TAKEN IN THAT POLITICALLY, AND FROM A
25:40 LEGAL PERSPECTIVE, HE'S GOING TO PROBABLY FIND HIMSELF IN FRONT
25:43 OF COMMITTEES, IN CONGRESS, OR FIND HIMSELF FACING POTENTIAL
25:47 SUBPOENAS AND LEGAL ACTION. HE'S GOING TO HAVE TO NAVIGATE
25:49 THAT PROCESS. THAT IS PERSONALLY IMPORTANT FOR
25:54 HIM, WHETHER HE EVEN HAS A FUTURE IN PUBLIC LIFE OR IN
25:57 PROFESSIONAL LIFE. HE'S GOING TO HAVE TO REACH AN
26:01 ARRANGEMENT OF SOME KIND WITH HIS FAMILY WITH HOW THEY FEEL
26:05 AND HOW THEY ARE GOING TO REACT TO IT.
26:07 ALL OF THESE THINGS ARE IMPORTANT.
26:13 ALSO IN THAT PROCESS, WILL PEOPLE WHO CURRENTLY WORK FOR
26:16 NVIDIA BE EXPOSED AS HAVING TAKEN ACTIONS THAT WERE NOT
26:20 AGAINST THE INTERESTS OF AMERICA OR THE COMPANY?
26:24 CAROL: THAT IS WHERE I WANTED TO GO.
26:30 ANY FEEL FROM YOUR REPORTING THAT IN TERMS OF THE SCOPE OF
26:32 THE PEOPLE WHO MIGHT HAVE BEEN AWARE OF JENSEN HUANG'S
26:37 INDISCRETIONS, OR MIGHT HAVE BEEN AWARE OF ANY CONCERNS
26:39 AROUND NVIDIA'S RELATIONSHIP WITH MEGAN SPEED?
26:44 >> I THINK THE ONLY REPORTING WE HAVE DONE THAT WE HAVE PUBLISHED
26:51 HAS CONCERNED THE GENERAL AND HIS POTENTIAL ROLE WITH
26:57 OVERSEEING OR TRYING TO BROKER A RELIEF TO TRY TO LESSEN THE
27:05 SCRUTINY THAT THAT COMPANY WITH BEING PLACED UNDER.
27:06 THAT IS OUR REPORTING AND WHAT WETIM: IT IS -- ONE THING THAT
27:17 CAME ACROSS IN YOUR PIECE WAS THE DISTINCTION BETWEEN THIS MAN
27:21 WHO'S BEEN TRAVELING AROUND THE WORLD ON BEHALF OF THIS COMPANY,
27:26 ON BEHALF OF THE UNITED STATES AND ON BEHALF OF AN ENTIRE LAYER
27:33 OF TECHNOLOGY THAT ASSERTED -- THAT IS SORT OF UNDERGIRDING THE
27:36 FUTURE OF THE GLOBAL ECONOMY. A LOT OF PEOPLE NOW HAVE A
27:42 DIFFICULT TIME UNDERSTANDING THE DEVELOPMENT OF THAT WITHOUT HIM.
27:46 CAN YOU HELP US MAKE SENSE OF THAT?
27:53 IAN: WHEN A BAND LOSES ITS LEAD SINGER, PEOPLE SAY THE BAND
27:54 CANNOT GO ON. THAT IS THE ONLY ANALOGY I CAN
27:57 THINK OF. VERY FEW BANDS ARE ABLE TO DO
28:04 THAT, ABLE TO REPLACE WHOEVER IS THE PERSON UP THERE ON THE MIC
28:07 AND THAT HAS BEEN HIM. WHETHER IT IS LOBBYING
28:13 POLITICIANS, CAJOLING OTHER COMPANIES, PUBLICLY SHOWING UP
28:16 AT EVENTS AND SAYING HERE IS SOME MONEY.
28:19 WHETHER IT IS HIS OWN EVENTS. HIS RESPONSIVENESS TO WHATEVER
28:25 THE ZEITGEIST, WHICH DIRECTION THE WIND WAS BLOWING IN TERMS OF
28:28 PUBLIC OPINION IN TERMS OF THE INDUSTRY'S OPINION ABOUT WHERE
28:34 AI HAS BEEN GOING, HE'S THE PERSON EVERYONE TURNED TO.
28:37 HE'S NOT IN A POSITION TO DO THAT ANYMORE.
28:39 IS IT A GOOD THING? WE WILL SEE.
28:43 GOING FORWARD I MORE FOCUSED ON HOW THE COMPANY RESPONSE.
28:47 HOW THESE PEOPLE REACT. CAROL: I AGREE.
28:51 NOW WHAT? SPEAKING OF NOW WHAT, THE
28:57 FINANCIAL TIMES IS TALKING ABOUT THE POSSIBILITY OF RENEE HAAS
29:04 WHO SPENT TIME.AT NVIDIA -- SPENT TIME AT NVIDIA.
29:11 TIM: THAT SHOULD NOT SURPRISE PEOPLE.
29:14 CAROL: YOU ARE RIGHT. THE NAMES ARE KICKED AROUND
29:18 UNTIL THEY ARE NOT BASICALLY. I THINK ABOUT -- WE HAD ON CAT
29:28 BARTON FROM BLOOMBERG NEWS AND -- IN SEOUL, SOUTH KOREA.
29:35 JENSEN'S LOOKED AT BY A STAR. SO CRUCIAL TO THE GLOBAL CHIP
29:40 STORY AND HOW JENSEN MET WITH THEM, HAVE A WITH THEM -- HAD
29:47 RELATIONSHIPS WITH THEM AND THAT IS IMPORTANT TO ANY ASIAN
29:48 COMPANY. YOU HAVE TO WONDER WHAT HAPPENS
29:50 NEXT. CAN THERE BE SOMEBODY -- IS IT
29:55 RENEE HAAS? HOW DO YOU THINK ABOUT WHO NEEDS
30:02 TO BE THE NEXT LEADER OF NVIDIA?
30:05 IAN: IF HIS RELATIONSHIPS WITH TSMC -- WE KNOW HE WAS A FRIEND
30:11 OR CONFIDENT OF LAURA'S CHANG. IF THE RELATIONSHIP WITH TSMC
30:18 WENT THROUGH HIM, IF THE RELATIONSHIP WITH SAMSUNG AND SK
30:21 WENT THROUGH HIM -- I HAVE BEEN IN A ROOM WITH THE LEADERS OF
30:23 THOSE AND JENSEN AND SEEN THEM INTERACT.
30:26 IT IS CLEAR THERE WAS A RELATIONSHIP AND HE WAS THE
30:28 FRONT MAN. HOW QUICKLY NEW RELATIONSHIPS
30:33 CAN BE FORGED OR NEED TO BE FORGED IS GOING TO BE PROBABLY
30:39 ONE OF THE TOP PRIORITIES OF WHOEVER THEY BRING IN TO REPLACE
30:47 HIM OR FOR COLETTE KRESS AND THE TEAM PICKING UP THE
30:50 PIECES, IT'S IN EVERYONE'S INTEREST.
30:52 NVIDIA IS STILL THE KING WHO HAS THE BEST PRODUCTS TO STAY
30:58 WORKING WITH THEM FOR THE TIME BEING.
31:02 THEY HAVE TO KEEP PROVING IT. THEY HAVE TO KEEP EARNING IT.
31:07 THERE IS NO SALESMAN FOR THEM RIGHT NOW.
31:12 TIM: THERE IS STILL ONLY ONE SELL RATING ON NVIDIA TRACKED BY
31:15 BLOOMBERG. WHAT IS THE BULL CASE IN RECENT
31:23 DAYS THAT STILL EXISTS FOR NVIDIA?
31:27 IAN: JENSEN DID NOT DESIGN THE CHIPS.
31:31 JENSEN DID NOT INVENT THE OPERATING SYSTEM.
31:36 JENSEN IS NOT THE PERSON WHO HAS BUILT THE DATA CENTERS.
31:38 JENSEN DID NOT DESIGN THE RACKS OF SERVERS.
31:42 HE WAS A FRONT MAN FOR THE ROLLOUT BUT THERE MUST BE A
31:49 COMPANY. THE ENGINEERS AT GOOGLE AND
31:54 MICROSOFT ARE NOT IDIOTS. THEY WOULD NOT BE BUYING NVIDIA
31:59 PRODUCTS UNLESS NVIDIA PRODUCTS WERE THE BEST.
32:02 THIS IS NOT A DEFAULT STATUS. RIGHT NOW AND PROBABLY FOR SOME
32:07 TIME TO COME NVIDIA WILL HAVE THE BEST PRODUCTS OUT THERE.
32:11 HOW THE ENGINEERS REACT TO THE CHALLENGE THEY ARE FACING WILL
32:12 DETERMINE THAT. CAROL: WE TALKED TO IAN FOR A
32:18 LOT OF REASONS. HE'S IN THE ROOM WITH JENSEN AND
32:23 THAT HAS A TMC, ALL THE KEY PLAYERS.
32:26 THANK YOU SO MUCH. ♪
32:33 CHARLIE: IT IS 2:40 ON WALL STREET.
32:36 THE DOW HIRED. LITTLE CHANGED.
32:42 UNDER 1/10 OF 1% BUT THE AVERAGE REVERSING EARLIER LOSSES.
32:46 UP BY 13 POINTS. THE S&P 500 INDEX HIGHER --
32:48 LOWER BY .5%. DOWN 37%7 POINTS.
32:58 NASDAQ DOWN .9%. NASDAQ 100 DOWN 1.3%.
33:05 THE PHILADELPHIA SEMICONDUCTOR INDEX IS LOWER BY 3.7%.
33:10 10-YEAR, 5.14% RIGHT NOW. GOAL LITTLE CHANGED. -- GOLD
33:16 LITTLE CHANGED RIGHT NOW. EVERY RETREAT FOR CRUDE.
33:21 WTI DOWN .2%. , BRENT $95.77.
33:30 NVIDIA LOWER AGAIN TODAY, DOWN 2.2% RIGHT NOW, OFF SESSION LOWS
33:36 BUT HIT BY WORRIES ABOUT ITS FUTURE AFTER JENSEN HUANG'S
33:38 OUSTER. WE HAVE BARCLAYS REPAIRING SOME
33:44 JOB CUTS, ROUGHLY 200 POSITIONS ACROSS ITS INVESTMENT BANK
33:46 BEGINNING NEXT WEEK. ADR DOWN BY JUST ABOUT 1/10 OF
33:49 1%. BARCLAYS WILL BEGIN CUTTING JOBS
33:55 OF VARYING SENIORITY IN NEW YORK AND LONDON AS EARLY AS TUESDAY.
34:01 ASTRAZENECA IS CUTTING ABOUT 600 JOBS FROM ITS RESPIRATORY AND
34:08 COMMERCIAL TEAMS IN THE U.S. AS PART OF HIS COST-SAVING PROGRAM.
34:14 ASTRAZENECA UP BY .3%. DOW INDUSTRIALS UP TO POINTS
34:18 RIGHT NOW. THE SOX IS DOWN 3.7%.
34:22 THAT IS A BLOOMBERG BUSINESS FLASH.
34:27 CAROL: THANK YOU SO MUCH. GOLDMAN SACHS STRATEGISTS ARE
34:29 BULLISH ON U.S. STOCKS 427. EVERYONE IS PUTTING OUT THEIR
34:31 OUTLOOKS. TIM: DID ANYONE SEE THE NVIDIA
34:35 THING COMING? CAROL: THERE WAS.
34:41 TIM: THAT ONE GUY. WASN'T IT AT A YOUNG INVESTOR?
34:47 SOMEONE IN THE NEWSROOM. MOST PEOPLE, NOT SO MUCH.
34:52 GOLDMAN IS OUT. THERE S&P 500 PREDICTION, THEY
34:59 SAY IT WILL ADVANCE AFTER A SELLOFF IN THE BIGGEST TECH
35:01 COMPANIES LEFT THEIR VALUATIONS HISTORICALLY CHEAP.
35:05 ONE THING THEY ARE HIGHLIGHTING IS CHEAPER HYPERSCALER
35:06 VALUATIONS. WE SEE TECHNOLOGY AND THE
35:09 HYPERSCALERS AS RELATIVELY DEFENSIVE.
35:14 THE BIGGEST COMPANIES HAVE TURNED TO CASH FLOW NEGATIVE BUT
35:17 BALANCE SHEETS MEASURES SUCH AS NET DEBT AND EQUITY REMAIN
35:18 HEALTHY. TIM: I WANT TO BRING IN LIS
35:25 AGOSTO. THE NVIDIA STORY HAS BEEN BIGGER
35:31 THAN JUST NVIDIA. CERTAINLY CHIP STOCKS THIS WEEK
35:35 AND WE ARE SEEING THAT PLAY OUT IN THE MARKET TODAY.
35:38 HOW WOULD YOU DESCRIBE WHAT YOU HAVE SEEN IN TERMS OF INVESTOR
35:40 ACTIVITY AROUND THIS NARRATIVE THIS WEEK?
35:46 LIS: IF WE THINK THROUGH THE LONGER-TERM VISION WHERE WE
35:50 STAND FIRM ON, A LITTLE BIT OF NOISE, LITTLE CONCERN AND
35:51 RIGHTFULLY SO. QUESTIONS AROUND MONETIZATION
35:56 AND REVENUE GROWTH BUT ONE PARTICULAR PERSON DOES NOT
35:59 DEFINE NVIDIA AND NVIDIA DOES NOT DEFINE THE BROADER
36:00 ECOSYSTEM. IT IS ONE OF THE THINGS WE HAVE
36:04 BEEN PAYING ATTENTION TO, HOW BROAD THE ECOSYSTEM ACTUALLY IS
36:07 AND TO SOME EXTENT UNDERAPPRECIATED.
36:11 THE APPLICATIONS WE WOULD EXPECT TO SEE, THE INFRASTRUCTURE AND
36:12 RESOURCES THAT UNDERPIN ALL OF THAT IS WHAT WE ARE PAYING
36:18 ATTENTION TO NOW. THE STORY IS UNCHANGED LARGELY.
36:23 CAROL: NOTHING HAS CHANGED WITH JENSEN HUANG OUT?
36:28 HE IS THE CENTRAL BANKER TO THE AI WORLD.
36:31 HE IS THE CHIEF CHEERLEADER AND HAS BEEN.
36:35 IF YOU THINK ABOUT WHOSE UNDERPINNING THIS IN SO MANY
36:37 WAYS, NOT JUST CHIPS BUT THERE IS INVESTMENTS IN OTHER
36:39 COMPANIES THAT ARE PART OF THAT AI SUPPLY CHAIN OR PART OF THAT
36:43 INFRASTRUCTURE BUILD. YOU REALLY DON'T THINK THERE'S
36:46 THAT MUCH OF A DIFFERENCE? LIS: NOT REALLY.
36:53 IF WE THINK REVENUE-WISE FOR LONGER-TERM, LARGELY UNCHANGED.
36:56 CAROL: WHAT IS LONGER-TERM FOR YOU GUYS?
36:59 LIS: THE NEXT YEAR OR SO. FROM THERE WE DON'T EXPECT TOO
37:05 MUCH CHANGE IN TERMS OF THEIR ROLE IN THE INDUSTRY.
37:08 WE MIGHT HAVE QUESTIONS AS TO HOW THAT MIGHT PLAY OUT IN THE
37:09 NEXT FEW WEEKS AND MONTHS. EVEN EARNINGS IN THE NEXT WEEK
37:13 BUT AS WE THINK THROUGH WHAT THAT MIGHT LOOK LIKE, THE
37:15 REVENUE VISIBILITY IS REALLY STRONG AND NOT NECESSARILY
37:20 SOMETHING WE WOULD POTENTIALLY REVISIT OUR CONVICTION AROUND
37:24 SEMICONDUCTORS AND AI. IT
37:30 -- IT IS NOT GOING TO CHANGE HOW MUCH YOU AND I USE AI.
37:38 CAROL: DOWN ABOUT 3.7 PERCENT. WE HAVE TALKED ABOUT IF YOU GET
37:40 IT TO LOAD. IT WAS DOWN MORE.
37:44 BUT I THINK ABOUT FROM THE RECENT HIGHS.
37:49 WE HAVE TALKED ABOUT IN OVER 30% CORRECTION BEAR MARKET.
37:52 CALL IT WHAT YOU MAY. THERE HAS BEEN A READ FROM
37:57 INVESTORS PULLING BACK FROM THIS SPACE.
37:59 IF YOU CAN ROLL OFF NVIDIA, CAN YOU BLOW THAT OFF?
38:02 >> THAT IS A GOOD QUESTION. WE'VE HAD CLIENTS COME TO US AND
38:05 SAY WE SEE MARKET CONCENTRATION BEING REALLY HIGH LARGELY
38:11 BECAUSE WE SEE NEWS FLOW, THE S&P 500 TRENDING, AND IS IT
38:12 BIGGER THAN THIS? WHAT IS THE POTENTIAL RISK OF AI
38:17 LONGER-TERM? WE HAVE BEEN ENCOURAGING CLIENTS
38:20 TO THINK OUTSIDE THE BOX, SO MANY AREAS BEYOND SEMICONDUCTORS
38:25 THAT UNDERPIN THIS TREND. THAT IS WHERE WE SEE THE
38:28 CONVERSATION GO IN. IT IS ECHOING WHAT WE HAVE LONG
38:30 THOUGHT ABOUT THE OVER INDEXING. CAROL: WHAT IS OUTSIDE THE BOX?
38:34 IT IS ALSO CONNECTED. TIM: DEMAND ENERGY IS SO BIG.
38:42 CAROL:CAROL: IF DEMAND DOESN'T CONTINUE, THE BILL DOESN'T
38:45 CONTINUE, ANYTHING THAT IS IN SO BULLISH, THE POWER NEEDED IS IN
38:48 SO BULLISH. IT IS JANGO.
38:55 DOWN. >> IT IS A GREAT QUESTION.
39:02 AS WE THINK THROUGH THE INFRASTRUCTURE, THE ENERGY, THE
39:05 RESOURCES NEEDED FOR AI INFRASTRUCTURE, AI IS ONE OF
39:08 MANY. EVEN IF WE MOVE THE DATA CENTER
39:13 CONVERSATION, THE ENERGY PIECE LOOKS FAVORABLE.
39:15 A HISTORIC LOW WHEN WE THINK ABOUT ENERGY.
39:20 WHETHER IT IS THE GRID THAT CONTINUES TO HAVE INVESTMENT
39:24 COME THROUGH, NATURAL GAS, DIVERSIFICATION OF THE ENERGY
39:28 GRID, ALL OF THESE STAND FOR LONGER TERM.
39:31 SAME WITH COPPER. WE EXPECT THE GREATEST GROWTH OF
39:39 PROPERTY DEMAND FOR ELECTRIFICATION IN THE GRID.
39:43 HOW MUCH OF THAT IS BECAUSE OF DATA CENTERS?
39:45 >> A SMALL PART. IF WE LOOK AT WHAT THE DEMAND
39:48 WILL LOOK LIKE IN THE NEXT FEW YEARS, WHAT WE EXPECT IT TO LOOK
39:54 LIKE, ONE TON OF COPPER IN THE AD DATA CENTER MIGHT HAVE ABOUT
39:57 1.8 TONS OF COPPER FOR THE GRID. THE MAJORITY WILL BE COMING FROM
40:05 X A AGRI-DEMAND. AS WE THINK ABOUT THAT, IT
40:10 DOESN'T CHANGE THE INVESTMENT IN COPPER FOR EXAMPLE.
40:15 TIM: WE HAVE BEEN TALKING IN THE CONTEXT NEWS OF NVIDIA, TALKING
40:19 ABOUT THE DEMOCRATS SWEEPING THE MIDTERMS AND THE PUSHBACK VOTERS
40:21 HAVE HAD OVER DATA CENTERS. TO WHAT EXTENT IS THAT A
40:24 HEADWIND? >> IT IS GOOD FOR INVESTORS AND
40:29 FOLKS FUNDING DATA CENTERS TO BE ASKING THEMSELVES.
40:34 IT HAS BEEN -- THE BUILDOUT HAS BEEN QUITE QUICK.
40:37 WE SEE THE QUESTION AROUND WHAT IT LOOKS LIKE, WHAT COINVESTMENT
40:40 WE MIGHT NEED FROM DATA CENTER PROVIDERS TO BUILD OUT THE GRID
40:46 FOR THOSE COMMUNITIES, HOW MUCH CONVERSATION PER ZIP CODE OR
40:49 AREA MAKES SENSE LONGER-TERM. SO HAVING THOSE IS A REALLY GOOD
40:53 PAUSE FOR BROADER BUILDOUT. WE BELIEVE THE BUILDOUT WILL
40:57 HAVE TO COME. IT IS EASY FOR US TO ENVISION A
41:02 WAY TO DIVERSIFY FROM JUST TEXAS OR JUST VIRGINIA INTO OTHER
41:04 POCKETS THAT MAY NOT HAVE HAD ENOUGH BUILDOUT.
41:08 THE CURRENT DATA CENTER CAPACITY REALLY FAVORABLY.
41:11 RATES ARE UNDER 1% AT THE MOMENT.
41:15 WE HAVE SEEN THE RATES INCREASE. WHAT IS CONNECTED, IT HAS POWER
41:18 AVAILABILITY, BECOMES MORE FAVORABLE.
41:24 BUILDOUT WILL CONTINUE. CAROL: ABOUT 30 SECONDS LEFT.
41:33 THE XAI, DOWN ABOUT 12% SINCE EARLY OCTOBER YEAR TO DATE.
41:40 100 COVER, ETF, YOUR PERCENT DOWN 6% SINCE OCTOBER.
41:43 INVESTORS, WHERE ARE THEY TAKING MONEY OUT?
41:48 OR ARE THEY PULLING OUT MONEY IN THE COUPLE OF WEEKS?
41:51 >> TO SOME EXTENT RETHINKING THAT EXPOSURE AND THINKING OF
41:55 OTHER POCKETS TIED TO THE AI TRADE.
41:57 >> PULLING MONEY OUT OF THOSE FUNDS?
41:58 >> NOT THAT WE HAVE SEEN SIGNIFICANTLY.
42:03 WE CONTINUE TO SEE SOME SIGNIFICANT INTEREST.
42:06 WHERE ARE WE THINKING OF BROAD AI, POTENTIALLY THINKING OF
42:10 THOSE DATA CENTERS FOR EXAMPLE. >> COME BACK, THANK YOU.
42:17 LISA GUSTO, DIRECTOR OF PRODUCT RESEARCH AND STRATEGY JOINING US
42:20 RIGHT HERE IN STUDIO. WHEN WE COME BACK, CHECKING ON
42:23 TRADING. ♪
42:34 >> THIS IS BLOOMBERG BUSINESSWEEK DAILY.
42:37 TELEVISION. CAROL: COMING UP TOWARDS TRADING
42:46 THIS FRIDAY -- ALMOST THERE. TIM: WHAT IS GOING TO BREAK OVER
42:48 THE WEEKEND? FORTUNATELY, DAVID GURA AND
42:55 CHRISTINA RUFFINI WILL BE HERE ALL WEEKEND, 7:00 TO 10 :00 A.M.
43:01 MOVING AROUND. POTENTIALLY MOVING AROUND,
43:07 WASHINGTON, THE NVIDIA STORY WILL CONTINUE TO BE POINTED OUT.
43:12 AS WE GET READY FOR A BIG WEEK THAT WILL BE NVIDIA EARNINGS,
43:17 THE ANTHROPIC IPO, I'M SURE I'M MISSING SOMETHING.
43:18 GRAND THEFT AUTO. TIM: I CAN'T BELIEVE YOU
43:24 FORGOT THE ONE THAT IS IMPORTANT TO YOU.
43:28 CAROL: THE APEC SUMMIT. TIM: YOU KNOW WHO IS ALWAYS ON,
43:33 TATYANA, MARKET STRATEGIST FOR BLOOMBERG, JOINS US IN THE
43:35 BLOOMBERG BUSINESSWEEK STUDIO. I WANT TO TALK A LITTLE BIT
43:41 ABOUT NEXT WEEK AND NVIDIA. YOU HAVE A CALLING OUT ABOUT HOW
43:46 COSTS WILL SHAPE CAPEX OUTLOOK. IN THE CONTEXT OF NVIDIA
43:50 EARNINGS NEXT WEEK AND WHAT WE HAVE HEARD FROM ALL OF THE
43:54 HYPERSCALERS THUS FAR AND THE CONTEXT OF WHAT WE HEARD FROM
43:59 NVIDIA'S BOARD YESTERDAY, JUST BEFORE 9:00 IN THE MORNING, WHAT
44:00 DOES IT MEAN? >> FOR HYPERSCALERS, LET'S NOT
44:07 FORGET THESE COMPANIES ARE ALSO WORKING ON THEIR CUSTOM CHIPS.
44:12 SO THEY HAVE THEIR OWN SILICA AND IN-HOUSE, WHICH IS STARTING
44:17 TO BECOME A BIGGER BUSINESS FOR THE LIKES OF ALPHABET AND
44:20 AMAZON, POTENTIALLY SELLING THAT EXTERNALLY.
44:24 THIS IS TURNING OUT NOT TO BE A BIG NEGATIVE FOR THEM.
44:30 THE COST STORY REFERS TO THE GENERAL COST OF CAPITAL THAT HAS
44:34 BEEN RISING FOR THE HYPERSCALERS.
44:36 YOU THINK THAT IS BECAUSE OF THAT.
44:38 THAT IS ACTUALLY BECAUSE OF EQUITY.
44:42 IT IS ACTUALLY THE ANALYZE RATE OF THE RETURN INVESTORS REQUIRED
44:44 TO HOLD THESE STOCKS. RIGHT NOW THEY ARE NOT DOING
44:49 VERY WELL ON THAT METRIC. BASICALLY THE METRICS FEEDING
44:53 INTO THIS ARE YOUR BENCHMARK YIELD RATE WHICH KEEPS RISING,
44:57 WHICH HAS AFFECTED BY THE EARNINGS VOLATILITY.
45:02 ALL OF THE SHARES AROUND THE AI TRADE IS PUSHING UP THE COST OF
45:03 CAPITAL FOR THESE COMPANIES. AT THE TIME ONE RETURNS ON
45:07 INVESTMENT ARE NOT SHOWING AN IMPROVEMENT, WHICH I THINK CUTS
45:13 TO THE CHASE OF THE AI ANXIETY. >> THE COST OF CAPITAL IS GOING
45:19 UP OR THE COST OF ACCESSING THE CAPITAL, OR THE RETURN ON THAT
45:21 INVESTMENT CAPITAL IS COMING DOWN, WHICH IS NOT WHAT YOU WANT
45:23 TO SEE AS AN INVESTOR. I'M CAROL MASSAR WITH TIM
45:25 STENOVEC. STOCKS ON THE MOVE ON THIS
45:31 FRIDAY BECAUSE IT HAS BEEN AN INTERESTING DAY.
45:34 TATYANA IS WITH US. WE ARE GOING TO BEGIN WITH A
45:41 NAME WE HAVE TALKED ABOUT SO MUCH.
45:43 NVIDIA. >> IT BEARS REPEATING, DOWN 2%,
45:49 WRAPPING UP THE WEEK OF A 13% DECLINE.
45:52 THE WORST WEEK SINCE THE TARIFFS SELLOFF OF APRIL 2025.
45:59 THE STORY IS ALL ON THE ANR, ANALYST RECOMMENDATION PAGE ON
46:01 NOW. CAROL: AND HE SELLS?
46:07 TIM: ONE. BUT THERE ARE NO NEW SELLS ON
46:11 IT. >> IT HAS BEEN CUT TO A DOWN
46:17 HOLD. EVERYONE HAS TO PAUSE AND ASSESS
46:18 WHAT IS GOING ON. THE LATEST CAME FROM HSBC CITING
46:25 LEADERSHIP UNCERTAINTY, SAYING INVESTOR CONFIDENCE HAS BEEN
46:30 SHAKEN DESPITE FUNDAMENTALS. WHAT CAUGHT MY EYE WAS PRICE
46:37 TARGET TO 100 $70 FROM $365, WE ARE BELOW THAT.
46:41 THAT TELLS YOU THAT THE MASSIVE REASSESSMENT THAT WALL STREET
46:48 HAS DONE THIS WEEK AND WHY IT IS SO HARD TO FIGURE OUT WHAT IS
46:49 NEXT FOR THIS COMPANY. WE DID SOME WORK ON MLIV, AND IT
46:54 IS A TOUGH ACT TO FOLLOW FOR ANY CEO BECAUSE NVIDIA'S EXCESS
47:02 RETURNS UNDER LEADERSHIP AMONG THE TOP FIVE HISTORICALLY.
47:05 CAROL: WHERE WERE YOU WHEN THE STOCK WAS AT 239?
47:08 IN JULY WHEN IT WAS AT 190? TIM: I WAS SITTING HERE WITH
47:12 YOU. BOUGHT THIS STOCK IN JULY OF
47:21 2025, YOU ARE IN LUCK BECAUSE IT IS AT THAT LEVEL.
47:24 CAROL: LET'S GO TO CEREBRAS. WE GOT EARNINGS LAST NIGHT.
47:29 >> THIS NAME IS ACTUALLY IN THE GREEN, 12% AFTER BEATING
47:35 ESTIMATES ACROSS MEASURES AND TOUTING NEW DEALS WITH
47:38 HYPERSCALERS LIKE ORACLE AND MICROSOFT.
47:40 THIS IS ONE OF NVIDIA'S COMPETITORS.
47:45 SO IT COMES AT AN OPPORTUNE TIME FOR THEM, FOR THE COMPETITORS TO
47:47 SHINE. IT MAKES LARGER PROCESSORS
47:53 DESIGNED SPECIFICALLY FOR AI AND SELLS CLOUD ACCESS.
47:58 THEY SAID ON THEIR EARNINGS CALL THEY CANNOT FIND ENOUGH CLOUD
48:00 CAPACITY AND THEY ARE RUNNING BEHIND SCHEDULE.
48:05 BUT THEY PUSH BACK AGAINST SPECULATION THAT THERE IS A
48:06 DELAY IN THEIR CONTRACT WITH OPENAI HELP SENTIMENT FOR THE
48:09 NAME. CAROL: IN 20 SECONDS, CAN WE DO
48:13 CISCO SYSTEMS? >> DOWN 6% AFTER MIXED EARNINGS
48:20 ORDER GROWTH DISAPPOINTED. THEY SAID IT ONLY WILL 21%, BUT
48:28 ANALYSTS WERE WAITING FOR A LOT MORE.
48:32 THIS IS A REAL TURNAROUND FOR THIS COMPANY CAROL: AT 24%.
48:37 THANK YOU SO MUCH. ON APPLE, SPOTIFY, OR, WE DO
48:42 UPDATES THROUGH THE DAY. THAT WOULD DO IT FOR THE FIRST
48:48 DOWN I COMING BACK ON RADIO. THE CLOSE STARTS NOW ON TV.
Inside Jensen Huang’s Last Hours as Nvidia CEO full transcript
0:00 Whatever, I don't care. And worse, these are unusual words for
0:04 an individual that we usually see being very direct, full of energy,
0:08 charismatic, and take charge kind of guy.
0:11 Um, what led to the giving up of Jensen one?
0:14 Because you guys, um, you do some incredible reporting here.
0:19 Yeah. I mean, the situation that he put
0:23 himself in and the situation that the board, um, were forced to deal with was
0:28 such that there was no choice. There were, of course, rumors and
0:33 speculation and an admission of an affair with somebody who was at a
0:38 customer. But then when you factor in an affair
0:41 with somebody who actually works for the company, something that is explicitly,
0:46 uh, not permissible under the company's stated rules, then the board were in a
0:52 position where they had no choice but to bring this to him, and that he had no
0:58 choice. There was no way around this.
1:00 Can you describe when you do it so well in the peace that you rode with Drake
1:03 Bennett, the Jensen Wong that emerged in the last few days behind closed doors,
1:09 the discussions that he had with confidants, with members of the board,
1:13 his demeanor, the way he was talking versus the Jensen Wang that for so many
1:17 years you covered as as this person who became known as the central banker of
1:22 the AI industry. I mean, we've all seen him literally.
1:27 We've all seen him on stage, uh, events on TV, appearing with the president.
1:34 And there was nothing apart from absolute control of himself, absolute
1:40 control of the message, ebullience, that humor, charisma, confidence and absolute
1:46 drive towards a certain goal. And what, according to our reporting,
1:52 happened in the last few days as he tried to, you know, cauterize the
1:57 wounds. He tried to accept responsibility.
2:00 He obviously, in his letter, internally took responsibility for his actions and
2:05 apologized. But in the end, that wasn't enough.
2:08 In the end, he wasn't able to remain in control.
2:11 And according to our reporting, he was reduced to becoming self-critical and,
2:17 um, to resignation. Yeah, it certainly speaks to his state
2:23 of mind, and one can understand why. I am also curious, as you reported this
2:28 out in, um, how conflicted the board was.
2:32 Um, you know, this was Jensen's board. Um, and anybody who'd been at the
2:38 company for a long time only knew Jensen Wong as the CEO of this company.
2:43 Yeah, I mean, several members of that board have literally been on that board
2:46 for three decades. Mhm.
2:48 Right. Um, this is not, uh, a board of, uh, of
2:52 people who have been brought in to, you know, hold his feet to the fire and to
2:56 control a company that, you know, that was in trouble.
2:59 Everybody's been along for the ride, right?
3:01 Whether it's employees, whether it's board members, they've all done very
3:05 well to have had no reason to to be exposing him to severe scrutiny, because
3:10 this company has done extremely well. I think what matters now that he's no
3:16 longer a part of that company is how the board proceed, and also how the people
3:21 who used to work for him very closely respond to this, whether they grow,
3:26 whether they, you know, show up in a way that they weren't previously allowed to
3:30 publicly, but more importantly, whether they continue to be the world champion
3:34 engineers, because they are, that's going to determine what Nvidia's future
3:38 looks like. I want to talk more about Nvidia's
3:40 future in a minute, but first, I want to talk about Jensen Wong's future.
3:44 Um, we learned yesterday that he's hired a high powered law firm at this point.
3:49 What what happens next for him? Well, Because of the nature of some of
3:54 the reports, because of the nature of the interest that's been taken in that
4:00 politically and also from a legal perspective, he is going to probably
4:04 find himself in front of committees in Congress or find himself facing
4:10 potential subpoenas and legal action. So he's going to have to navigate that
4:14 process. And that, again, it's personally
4:17 important for him as to whether he even has a future in public life or in
4:22 professional life. Obviously, he's going to have to reach
4:26 an arrangement of some kind with his family as to whether they feel about
4:30 what's happened and how they're going to react to it.
4:32 So all of these things are important. Um, but also in that process, will
4:37 people who currently work for Nvidia be exposed as having taken actions that
4:43 were either not against the interests of America or indeed the company?
4:48 Ian. That's where I wanted to go.
4:50 Any any feel from your reporting that in terms of the scope of the people who
4:58 might have been aware of Jensen's indiscretions, or who might have been
5:02 aware of any concerns around Nvidia's relationship with mega speed.
5:08 I mean, the only reporting that we've done that has gone, you know, that we've
5:12 published has concerned the general counsel and his potential role in sort
5:19 of overseeing or trying to broker, um, relief for mega speed and to try to sort
5:26 of lessen the the scrutiny that that company was being placed under.
5:30 That's obviously our reporting and that's what we've done so far.
5:33 Mhm. Right.
5:36 You know I it's I think one thing that came across in your piece was the
5:43 distinction between this, this man who's been traveling around the world
5:49 On behalf of this company, on behalf of the United States, and on behalf of an
5:53 entire layer of technology that is sort of undergirding for many people, not
5:59 just the US economy, but the future of the global economy.
6:03 And I think a lot of people right now have a difficult time understanding the
6:09 development of that without him. Can you help us make sense of that in.
6:15 Yeah. I mean, you know, when a bank leads, it
6:18 loses its lead singer. People say the band can't go on, right?
6:21 That's that's the only analogy I can think of.
6:24 Very few bands are able to do that. Right.
6:26 Very few bands are able to replace that. Whoever's the person out there on that
6:31 mic night after night. And that's been him.
6:34 Right. It's whether it's lobbying politicians,
6:36 whether it's cajoling of the companies, whether it's publicly showing up other
6:41 companies events and saying, here's some money.
6:43 Um, whether it's his own events, you know, whether you know, his
6:47 responsiveness to whatever, the zeitgeist, whatever to which direction
6:52 the wind was blowing in terms of public opinion, in terms of the industry's
6:55 opinion about where I was going, he's been that he's been the person that
6:59 everybody stand to. Clearly, he's not in a position to do
7:02 that anymore and is unnecessary. Is it a good thing that he's gone?
7:06 We will see. But, you know, I'm going forward.
7:09 I'm more focused on how this company responds, how these people react.
7:15 Yeah I agree. It's like, okay, so now what?
7:18 Um, speaking of now what the Financial Times is out talking about the
7:24 possibility of, um ALM CEO Renee Haas who spent time at Nvidia, uh, which
7:30 shouldn't surprise a lot of people. Yeah.
7:32 Aline, given the reporting that that Ian has done and what our team has done
7:36 about sort of the short list of internal and external candidates, you're
7:39 absolutely right. Like, you know, so these names are, you
7:42 know, kicked around until they're not basically.
7:46 But I do think about we just had on Kat Barton, who is the bureau chief, um, for
7:51 Bloomberg News in Seoul, South Korea. And she talked about how Jensen has
7:56 looked as a star and that, you know, Samsung and SK Hynix so crucial to the
8:02 chip story, global chip story and how, you know, Jensen met with them like had
8:08 relationships with them. And that's so important, especially to
8:11 any kind of Asian, you know, company. Um, and so you have to wonder kind of
8:15 what happens next. Um, can can there be somebody is it a
8:20 renaissance or how do you think about who needs to be the next leader of
8:25 Nvidia? I mean, that's a very good practical
8:28 point. If his relationships with TSMC, for
8:32 example, and we've certainly know that he was a friend or a confidant of Morris
8:36 Chang over there. If the relationship with TSMC went
8:41 through him, if the relationship with Samsung with SK went through him, and
8:46 I've been in a room with the leaders of those on Jensen and seen him interact
8:50 with them. So it's absolutely clear that there was
8:53 a relationship and he was certainly the front man.
8:55 And how quickly new relationships can be forged or need to be forged is going to
9:02 be probably one of the top priorities of whoever they bring in to replace him.
9:06 Or for Colette Kress, the CFO, and her team of people who are basically picking
9:11 up the pieces right now. Um, it's in everybody's interest because
9:16 Nvidia is still looking. They still have the best products to
9:21 stay working with them, uh, for the time being.
9:26 But they have to keep proving it. They have to keep earning it.
9:29 Um, and there's no salesman there for them right now.
9:35 So we. And before we let you go, there's still
9:36 only one celebrating. Uh, on Nvidia by analysts who are
9:40 tracked by Bloomberg. What is the what is the bull case that
9:44 analysts have come out with in recent days that is still exist for Nvidia?
9:49 Yeah. And that that's what we just mentioned.
9:51 Right. Jensen did not design their chips.
9:55 Right. Jensen did not invent Cuda the operating
9:58 system that based at all. Jensen is not the person who, uh, built
10:03 the data centers. Jensen is not the person who designed
10:05 the racks of servers. He was a front man for all of the
10:08 rollouts and everything like that. But there absolutely must be a group of
10:13 engineers who are more than competent inside this company, because, you know,
10:18 the engineers at Google, at Microsoft, they're not idiots, right?
10:21 They wouldn't be buying Nvidia products unless Nvidia products were the best,
10:27 right? This isn't a default status right now,
10:29 and probably for some time to come, Nvidia will have the best products out
10:34 there. How these engineers react to the
10:37 challenge that they're facing and how they go forward will determine.
Stocks End Week Higher Amid Tech Turmoil full transcript
0:00 About two minutes away from the end of the trading day and the trading week.
0:03 Vonnie Quinn and Bailey live shows sun here to help take us through those
0:06 closing bells. A global simulcast.
0:08 We're joined now by Carol Massar and Tim.
0:10 Some of the bringing together on Bloomberg Television, radio and YouTube
0:14 all of our audiences worldwide to parse through the most crucial moments of the
0:18 trading day. And I think if we had to pick one, well,
0:22 we'd be a little bit stuck. Carol.
0:23 Yeah, I got to say, I mean, how many times have we said Nvidia this week?
0:26 I'm just amazed that we're here on on this Friday getting ready to wrap.
0:30 We know Nvidia was the major story this week.
0:32 We've got a market that I feel like, you know, most names actually in the S&P are
0:37 higher in today's session despite the index being down just about half a
0:41 percent. We've got 389 names higher.
0:43 So investors are fine finding opportunities in this market.
0:47 Yeah I certainly the Nvidia story was big in the tech story was was big this
0:52 week. Also big this week were the declines
0:54 that we saw in oil. Uh just looking at Brent futures right
0:57 now back above $96 a barrel WTI uh up to close to $89 a barrel.
1:03 Uh, both of those up right now buy just about more than 2/10 of 1%.
1:06 But we did see a lot of volatility in that sector this week as investors
1:10 thought, wait a second. Okay.
1:11 There could be some sort of ending to this war in Iran.
1:14 And I just want to say, if you ask me, Tim, at the beginning of the week, hey,
1:18 Nvidia will be down almost 13%. What does the S&P 500 do?
1:22 I would have never said, I know 2.5% is such a good point.
1:27 Yeah, I mean, you know, there's a lot of people out there that are having, you
1:30 know, worse Friday evenings, particularly if you founded a company
1:33 that you are no longer belonging to. But, you know, it does feel like one
1:37 catalyst for potential downside is out of the way.
1:40 Now, we know that the board is already on to getting a successor.
1:43 All right. Let's take you right up to the closing
1:46 bell. You know something?
1:48 We're finishing positive on the Dow. Tim, you were not wrong.
1:52 The S&P 500 down just 4/10 of 1% on even the Nasdaq did a big effort dip buyers
1:58 coming in at the end of the Friday session.
2:00 Obviously there's some optimism Carol about next week.
2:03 Um yeah. Well, I think, you know, excite me an
2:06 interest waiting to see what happens with Nvidia's result.
2:10 We've got an anthropic IPO, so that's a big deal.
2:13 Bailey. Bailey, do you know that I haven't
2:15 heard. What is it, Kara?
2:16 What's the company? Uh, anthropic.
2:19 Can you learn something new to me? Yeah.
2:21 I haven't heard that one. Philanthropic.
2:22 I'm confused. So maybe your vacation plans for next
2:25 week, right? I wish, okay, you're going to be working
2:27 a lot there, buddy. Hey, um, you're going to take us to the
2:29 Omap I mentioned earlier. 370 names, barely in the S&P 500
2:34 actually higher today. Yeah.
2:35 Interesting trade. I will say we've talked rotation ad
2:38 nauseum. Kind of a risk off trade.
2:41 You're leaders in the uh sector level. Consumer staples up more than 1%.
2:45 Energy right behind it at about a percent.
2:46 Financials up 8/10 of 1%. But the big read on the screen for today
2:51 Vonnie and I have been talking about it on BTV tech tech down 1.7%.
2:55 And the big driver for that AMD down more than 8.5%.
2:58 Cisco down six Dell down more than seven.
3:01 So again a rotation away from some of those tech companies and into some of
3:04 those safer plays like energy and financials.
3:06 All right. So let me go to some of the individual
3:09 gainers. And one was a name that we were talking
3:11 about uh, last night after the closing bell, uh, Cerebus that stock up more
3:15 than 11% in today's session, uh, shares jumping after the company gave a sales
3:19 forecast for the current quarter that exceeded analyst estimates.
3:22 So signaling that a push to challenge and video in our artificial intelligence
3:26 chips is apparently paying off. They said revenue roughly 320 million in
3:31 the fourth quarter. That topped the 271.2 million average
3:35 analyst estimate, according to data compiled by Bloomberg.
3:38 Uh, the company also touted recent customer deals with Microsoft and
3:41 Oracle. So, uh, some enthusiasm.
3:44 Just keep in mind 14% of the float is short.
3:46 So a little bit of, um, negative sentiment out there on Sirius, even
3:50 though it gained in a big way today. This the next name Modine Ticker is Mod.
3:55 Thank you very much. Tim Stead of that said, you got to do
3:57 this name Messer. Uh, stock up 27% soaring.
4:01 It's about a $7.2 billion market cap, soaring the most intraday in six years,
4:06 up at one point during the day 30% 38% higher, but finishing the day with a
4:12 gain of about 27%. So here's the story.
4:14 Samsung Electronics is in talks to acquire this company.
4:18 It's a maker of cooling systems for data centers.
4:21 Uh, according to people familiar with the matter, the companies are talking
4:24 about a potential transaction that could come together as soon as the coming
4:27 weeks. No final decision, though, has been made
4:30 and the talks could still fall apart. So, uh, interesting to see that one.
4:34 And then I'm just gonna throw in Domino's Pizza.
4:37 Is the ticker stock up after Baird raised the recommendation to outperform
4:41 from neutral, citing its view of a clearer path to better same store sales
4:45 performance and franchise profitability. Price target raised to 400 from 320.
4:50 And you could see the stock closing, uh, just under $342 a share, up about 2.5%
4:55 in today's session. Tim.
4:57 Okay. Those are some of the well, this pizza
4:58 night. I'm getting hungry.
4:59 It is pizza night, so not Domino's. Okay.
5:02 Sorry. Okay, well, maybe not for you.
5:04 Okay, exactly. Uh, let's go to some of the decliners.
5:07 What would it be like if I didn't include Nvidia as a decliners
5:10 It would be. It would be brave.
5:13 I'd be brave. Maybe there's some people out there who
5:15 would be grateful because they're like, okay, enough with this already.
5:17 But you know what? It was one of the most actively traded
5:20 stocks. This is one that certainly has to be on
5:23 our radar, at least when it comes to the performance this week.
5:25 When it comes to the performance since October 5th.
5:28 Uh, this stock is now traded at $162.85. It was down another 2% today.
5:33 It actually started the day up by, uh, over 3%.
5:37 But I think it was over 3%. Excuse me.
5:39 Um, but then it ended up turning negative very early in the session.
5:43 Uh, Nvidia's board, uh, according to the Financial Times, has approached arm CEO
5:47 Rene Hoss in its search for a potential successor to Jensen Wong again.
5:51 The Financial Times reported this out, citing people familiar with the matter.
5:55 But if you've been paying attention to any of the reporting around the short
5:57 list of candidates who might succeed Jensen Wong or might succeed Colette
6:02 Kress, the CFO who's serving as interim CEO if she doesn't stay.
6:06 And Renee Haas has certainly been on that list once.
6:10 Tim is your co-host to consider, though I know she's rocking the leather jacket,
6:13 so I didn't know if that was like, you know, it was an honor kind of itch.
6:17 Somebody's got to pick up the leather baton.
6:20 Uh, let's move on to the the socks, uh, being a part of the socks.
6:24 And it is my goal to get a leather jacket on.
6:27 Tim, I'm just going to tell you about not going to happen.
6:29 I'm working on it. Uh, it is it is down today, uh, by 3.4%.
6:34 It was down as much as 6.5% earlier in the session.
6:36 So off its worst levels of the day, still, all 30 components of the socks
6:40 were down today. And some pretty notable components of
6:43 the socks were significantly lower on the day.
6:46 Today, uh, should know to. It's down about 30% from those highs
6:49 reached back in June. And finally, let's check in on shares of
6:53 Virgin Galactic. SPC is the ticker.
6:56 Uh, shares fell by 31%, fresh record low after the company CEO said on the
7:02 conference call that the first commercial spaceflight for a period,
7:06 it's the lead spaceship of the Delta class fleet, is now expected in early in
7:10 the second quarter instead of in February.
7:12 The delay adds to concerns about the company's capital position.
7:15 According to analysts over at KeyBanc. Virgin Galactic shares today down by
7:19 more than 31%. A fresh all time low.
7:21 I'm just going to give you this headline.
7:22 The FAA says that all airports are ground staffed until further notice.
7:28 Wow. Quite the headline to be receiving just
7:31 at the market close on a Friday. The FAA saying all airports are ground
7:35 stopped. Until further notice, we will obviously
7:38 keep an eye on everything that's happening to do with that.
7:41 Why it might be happening, whether it has anything to do with software outages
7:45 or what have you. And can I just throw on cause Reuters
7:48 also throwing in uh, on this um, reporting on X and they say due to
7:53 extraordinary circumstances and for reasons of safety, attention to all
7:57 aircraft operators, by order of the FAA, as you said, Vonnie, all airports are
8:02 ground stopped. All departing traffic should remain
8:05 ground stopped until further notice. Inbound international flights will be
8:09 managed on a case by case basis. And just flagging that United's down
8:12 about 3/10 of 1% in inflight trading. But if you're watching the stocks,
8:16 airline stocks are moving slowly concerning because there are going to be
8:19 a lot of lights in the air that will have to circle or move on, right.
8:23 All right. We will keep you updated.
8:25 Yeah. Sorry to keep jumping on this to
8:27 Bailey's point. American.
8:28 Uh, lower now by about 8/10 of 1%. But this is pretty extraordinary,
8:32 especially as the report cites safety reasons.
8:35 We don't know exactly what they are at this point.
8:37 It's a story that we're going to continue to follow, but absolutely
8:39 extraordinary that you'd see this happen across the country at airports.
8:42 Yeah. All airports ground stopped until
8:44 further notice. Let's take a look at yields.
8:46 Because the other thing that was on traders minds, even if they weren't
8:49 front of mind today, was the fed. What is going to do next.
8:53 Obviously the October meeting is now never going to be a live meeting again
8:57 because we won't be dealing with monetary policy.
8:59 But we did have two more fed members say, look, we are very, very concerned
9:03 about inflation. Are all Michael McKee sitting down with
9:05 the Boston Fed president, Susan Collins, saying she's noticing that it's very,
9:11 very strong out there. And she, you know, didn't want to say
9:14 that she was definitely going to hike or hike twice in the next few months?
9:19 But she did sort of lean in that direction.
9:21 And of course, we had Mary daily as well.
9:24 That had French front end yields down just a couple of basis points because
9:28 market had broadly priced this in anyway.
9:30 But also we're seeing a belly and the back end of the curve up a couple of
9:34 basis points a tiny bit of steepening. So let's just recap.
9:37 Bailey you already said that there are some airlines we're seeing moving a
9:40 little bit lower on this news here in the aftermarket.
9:43 But the FAA has issued a nationwide ground, a nationwide ground stop, citing
9:48 extraordinary circumstances and reasons of safety.
9:51 They put this out in a statement again. We don't have a lot of information.
9:55 They did say all departing traffic should remain ground stopped until
9:58 further notice. So no planes going out.
10:01 Inbound international flights will be managed on a case by case basis.
10:04 I would imagine inbound is is kind of rough when you're coming on a long trip.
10:09 They've got to figure out where they're going to put these planes and where to
10:11 let them let them land. Yeah.
10:13 There. Um, I mean, when I think of ground stop,
10:16 I think nationwide ground stop there. A couple memories that come to mind.
10:19 One is, of course, September 11th. And what happened there?
10:22 And then also, of course, a big failure back in 2023, back in 2023, uh, due to a
10:28 catastrophic failure of notice to air emissions systems caused by a file
10:31 replacement error due to routine maintenance.
10:33 So this is not something that happens very frequently.
10:36 No, exactly. As they say, extraordinary
10:38 circumstances. All right, folks, I know you guys over
10:40 there going to be keeping on this. We will too.
10:42 That is a wrap. Our cross platform radio, TV, YouTube,
10:45 Bloomberg Originals. We do call it the closing bell.
10:48 Varney and Bailey, of course. Continuing on the close on TV, Tim and I
10:51 back here on BW daily on Bloomberg Radio.
10:53 We'll see you on Monday. Coming up, smartphone chip inventor is
11:00 huge. Can you joins us live to react to
11:03 Nvidia's week of upheaval and also preview Nvidia's earnings report which
11:07 is still coming Tuesday. It also gauged the implications for the
11:10 semiconductor industry more broadly. This is the close unknown break.
Deciphering Nvidia Noise, US Retirement Gets C+, Anthropic IPO Ahead full transcript
0:32 TOM: GOOD NOON. "BLOOMBERG MONEY."
0:35 WHAT A WEEK IT HAS BEEN. SCARLET FU AND TOM KEENE.
0:43 SCARLET LOOKED AT THE WEEKEND SAID I AM NOT DOING THIS.
0:47 TALK ABOUT WORK FROM HOME. SCARLET FU WORKING FROM HOME
0:50 TODAY. WE WILL HAVE HER HERE NEXT WEEK
0:53 FOR HER GREAT WEEK. WE SAY AGAIN GOOD NOON.
0:57 WONDERFUL CONVERSATIONS COMING UP.
1:03 WE HAVE A SPECIAL TREAT. ON HYDROCARBONS AND
1:08 INTERNATIONAL RELATIONS. HE NAILED A LOWER OIL PRICE NOT
1:14 LONG AGO. IT IS A BLISTERING POWERPOINT
1:22 FROM CHRISTINE MAHONEY ON THE FAILURE OF THE AMERICAN
1:24 RETIREMENT SYSTEM. NO OTHER WAY TO PUT IT.
1:28 CAROL MASSAR AND I WERE TALKING EARLIER.
1:30 WE ARE NEVER GOING TO RETIRE. NOT GOING TO HAPPEN.
1:35 MOVE. STOCKS CANNOT FIND A BID.
1:43 52,000 GETS MY ATTENTION. NASDAQ HAVING AN NVIDIA DAY DOWN
1:47 2%. VIX BACK ABOUT 20 WHICH IS
1:55 SOMETHING. THE S&P 500 DOWN 1%.
2:02 THE YIELD IS THE STORY. SARAH FRIER WILL BE WITH US.
2:10 THE DOLLAR CANNOT GET OUT OF ITS OWN WAY.
2:12 RESILIENT DOLLAR. WE SHOW A BREAKTHROUGH, $95,
2:19 WEST TEXAS INTERMEDIATE BENEATH THAT THIS MORNING.
2:21 LET'S DO THIS. THIS HAS BEEN A HELLACIOUS WEEK.
2:27 WE HAVE 15, 20 PEOPLE TO TALK TO.
2:29 HERE ARE THE CHOSEN FEW. SARAH FRIER IS WITH US.
2:38 CAROL MASSAR SAID I WANT IN AS WELL.
2:49 ERIC BALCHUNAS' BOOK AGENT SAID YOU HAVE TO GIVE HIM TIME, A NEW
2:51 BOOK OUT. IT IS THE CELEBRATION OF A NEW
2:55 BOOK BUT NOT ETF'S, RIGHT? >> IT IS MY THIRD BOOK.
3:04 THE BITCOIN ETF'S ARE STRUGGLING LATELY.
3:06 THEY ARE THE MOST SUCCESSFUL LAUNCH.
3:09 I FELT THE ETF WAS IN BETWEEN THESE WORLD'S.
3:14 THE ETF IS IN THE MIDDLE OF THE MERGER OF THESE TWO WORLD'S
3:20 WHETHER IT IS BITCOIN AS A STORE OF VALUE OR TOKENIZATION.
3:22 THIS IS AN INTERESTING, FASCINATING TOPIC.
3:26 THE PRICE ACTION NOT THE GREATEST TO LAUNCH A BOOK BUT IT
3:32 IS BETTER NOW THAN IT WAS. TOM: WITH ALL OF YOUR WORK AND
3:43 EXCELLENCE ON ETF'S, IS BITCOIN AN INVESTMENT OR SPECULATION?
3:47 ERIC: A LITTLE OF BOTH. WE CALL IT TEENAGER GOLD.
3:52 CAROL: CAN'T GO WRONG WITH A NAME LIKE THAT.
3:59 ERIC: IT IS 18 YEARS OLD. I HAVE A 15-YEAR-OLD, VERY
4:00 PREDICTABLE. IT HAD BEEN THROUGH SEVEN 50%
4:05 DRAWDOWNS. WE DON'T HAVE TO INVEST IN IT.
4:09 WE GIVE YOU BOTH SIDES. JUST THE RESILIENCE, IF YOU WANT
4:17 IT. TOM: SPEAKING OF TEENAGE GOLD,
4:24 ARE TEENAGERS TO YOUNG TO WEAR CARTIER?
4:29 WHAT YOU DO WHEN THE DAUGHTER COMES HOME AND SAYS SUZY HAS A
4:32 CARTIER BRACELET? CAROL: SHE IS WORKING AND
4:37 LEARNING THE VALUE OF MONEY. SHE KNOWS HOW TO SAVE IT.
4:47 TOM: WHAT STANDS OUT IN TECHNOLOGY?
4:49 CAROL: NVIDIA. I THINK THERE ARE STILL SO MANY
4:51 QUESTIONS. WE NEED TO KNOW HOW MUCH WAS
4:55 KNOWN WITHIN THE COMPANY. WE NEED TO KNOW FROM THE
4:59 GOVERNMENT SIDE HOW MUCH THEY WERE AWARE OF A RELATIONSHIP.
5:03 WHAT IF ANY SECRETS WERE KNOWN? IT IS A DIFFERENT COMPANY
5:06 WITHOUT JENSEN HUANG. TOM: WE DRAG OURSELVES OVER TO
5:09 THE STORY OF THE WEEK. SARAH FRIER HAS BEEN IN THE
5:16 DENNY'S IN SAN JOSE WHEN THEY FOUNDED NVIDIA WHICH MAKES YOU
5:17 QUALIFIED. I HAVE SUCH RESPECT FOR YOUR
5:19 HOLISTIC VIEW. YOUR SINGLE THOUGHT ON THIS
5:25 COMPLEX STORY? SARAH: A LOT OF PEOPLE ARE
5:28 LOOKING AT THE STORE AND CALLING IT AN AFFAIR SCANDAL.
5:33 THE TWO OR MAYBE THREE AFFAIRS HE REPORTEDLY HAD.
5:37 I THINK YOU GOT AT THE HEART OF IT, CAROL.
5:40 THIS IS ABOUT U.S.-CHINA RELATIONS.
5:43 THIS IS ABOUT TO WHAT EXTENT JENSEN HUANG WAS TAPPED AS A
5:49 RESOURCE TO GET TO TRUMP, TO UNDERSTANDING WHAT WAS HAPPENING
5:51 IN THE U.S. GOVERNMENT. HOW WAS HE IMPLICATED IN THIS?
5:57 WHAT DID NVIDIA DO WITH THE CHIPS THAT ENDED UP IN CHINA?
6:01 WE HAD A GREAT SCOOP A FEW HOURS AGO THAT SOME OF THE NVIDIA
6:07 CHIPS THAT WENT TO SINGAPORE DID MAKE THEIR WAY TO SHANGHAI TO A
6:10 COMPANY THAT HAD TIES -- TOM: ANDY POOLS AND ALL-NIGHTER
6:16 IN HONG KONG AND WE HAVE A STORY -- ANDY PULLS AN ALL-NIGHTER IN
6:22 HONG KONG AND WE HAVE A STORY ABOUT CHIPS IN SHANGHAI.
6:27 DO YOU PERCEIVE IT AS THAT BIG OF A DEAL?
6:30 SARAH: WE HAVE SEEN EVIDENCE OF THIS FOR A WHILE.
6:33 MACKENZIE HAWKINS HAS BEEN SKIPPING A LOT OF THIS.
6:40 WHAT IS THIS MYSTERY AMOUNT OF CHIPS THEY CANNOT ACCOUNT FOR?
6:45 ORDINARY. THESE CHIPS ARE IN SINGAPORE.
6:51 WE FOUND EVIDENCE THEY ARE NOT, THAT THEY WERE IN CHINA.
6:55 I THINK THAT IS AT THE HEART OF THIS.
6:59 I HAVE HEARD A LOT OF SILICON VALLEY PEOPLE SAY OTHER CEO'S
7:03 ARE ALLOWED TO HAVE AFFAIRS, IT. HE IS SO INTEGRAL TO THE AI
7:10 BOON TOM:M. TALKING ABOUT DEALMAKING, IT IS
7:14 JENSEN HUANG. TOM: HEAT IS ONE OF THE CEO
7:24 POSSIBILITIES. DO YOU HAVE AN IDEA OF WHO COULD
7:29 DO THIS WITH NVIDIA? SARAH: IT IS A SECRET SAUCE I
7:34 THINK IS GOING TO BE VERY DIFFICULT FOR AN OUTSIDER.
7:38 WE NEED SOMEBODY THAT HAS THE CHARISMA, THE CONNECTIONS.
7:43 A LOT OF THESE DEALS JENSEN HUANG DID WORK PERSONALLY DONE.
7:50 HE HAD 60 PEOPLE REPORTING TO HIM.
7:53 HE WAS THE ONE DOING THE FINAL SIGN OFF ON ALL OF THE
7:55 ARRANGEMENTS. WHEN YOU BRING SOMEONE IN, THEY
8:00 ALSO HAVE TO HAVE CONNECTIONS. TOM: TELL ME ABOUT DOUBLE,
8:05 TRIPLE LEVERAGED ETF'S. ERIC: PEOPLE ARE BUYING IT.
8:11 IT KEEPS GOING DOWN. TRADERS LOVE TO BUY DIPS.
8:16 THEY GOT A BIG ONE IN NVIDIA. THE REST OF THE ETF WORLD IS
8:19 BUSINESS AS USUAL. THE S&P 500 IS UP 3%.
8:24 NVIDIA IS DOWN 9%. THIS IS WHY WE SAY INDEXING IS A
8:28 TEAM SPORT. YOU CAN HAVE ONE STOCK BLOWUP A
8:33 LITTLE BIT IN THE INDEX MOVE ON. A LOT OF THE VANGUARDS ARE
8:38 INVESTING AS USUAL. TRADERS ARE BUYING THE DIP FOR
8:41 NOW. THEY THINK IT WILL SNAP BACK.
8:48 TOM: THERE IS A FEAR OF MISSING OUT.
8:51 YOU WERE JUST IN ASIA. ERIC: IT FELT LIKE EIGHT WEEKS.
8:59 TOM: WHAT DID YOU LEARN IN ASIA ABOUT THE FEAR OF MISSING OUT?
9:05 ERIC: THERE IS SO MUCH GAMBLING, LOVE GAMBLING THERE.
9:07 EUROPE HAS NONE OF IT. WE HAVE A LOT OF IT.
9:13 THEY DON'T HAVE THE VANGUARD THING.
9:15 THEY ARE EITHER INEXPENSIVE MUTUAL FUNDS OR INVESTING IN
9:17 REAL ESTATE. THEY DON'T HAVE INDEPENDENT
9:20 ADVISORS. THAT IS ONE THING YOU TAKE FOR
9:24 GRANTED IN THE U.S. YOU HAVE TO HAVE BROKERS HAVOC
9:29 PRICES OF CONSCIOUS AND SAY I CANNOT KEEP PUTTING MY CLIENT IN
9:32 THESE AWFUL FUNDS, THERE ARE BETTER WAYS.
9:37 TOM: J.P. MORGAN IS GOING TO BE SPEAKING WITH DARIO AMODEI.
9:42 CAN OUR BANKS GO THERE? CAN J.P. MORGAN MOVE TO ASIA?
9:47 ERIC: ABSOLUTELY. THEY HAVE ALREADY GONE TO AN
9:50 INDEPENDENT ADVISOR MODEL. COMMISSIONS FROM MUTUAL FUNDS
9:55 ARE ALL OVER THE WORLD BUT NOT IN THE U.S..
9:59 IT IS BETTER FOR THE INVESTOR. TOM: SEE HOW HE BRINGS IT BACK
10:06 TO "BLOOMBERG MONEY"? GIFTED.
10:10 CAROL: INSTITUTIONAL INVESTORS HAVE BEEN EXCLUDED THIS HAS TO
10:20 DO WITH WHAT IS GOING ON, OR SO IT IS BELIEVED.
10:25 ERIC: IN ASIA, GOVERNMENTS RULE. THE CHINESE GOVERNMENT JUST BUYS
10:28 STOCKS WHEN THEY ARE DOWN. THEY GO DOWN, THEY JUSTIFY THEM.
10:32 JAPAN POT STOCKS. I THINK IT IS A GLIMPSE INTO OUR
10:37 FUTURE. THEY BOUGHT INTEL.
10:45 TOM: I HAVE TO GO. SARAH FRIER, COME BACK.
10:51 ERIC, NICE TO HAVE YOU BACK FROM ASIA.
10:53 THIS IS A HUGE TREAT FOR "BLOOMBERG MONEY."
11:00 ED MORSE OF CITIGROUP. HE MAILED LOWER OIL PRICES
11:05 BEFORE THE WAR IN THE MIDDLE EAST.
11:07 ED MORSE IS NEXT. IT IS "BLOOMBERG MONEY."
11:25 ♪ TOM: "BLOOMBERG MONEY."
11:30 ON PERSONAL FINANCE, RETIREMENT, WEALTH MANAGEMENT, ALL CENTERED
11:35 AROUND THE RECENT MEMORY OF BRENT CRUDE AT $117 A BARREL.
11:38 WATCHING NEWS RIGHT NOW. THE MARKET RECOVERING A LITTLE
11:41 BIT FROM WHERE WE WERE AT THE TOP OF THE SHOW.
11:48 JOINING US IS EDWARD MORSE, SENIOR ADVISOR, DABBLES IN
11:51 COMMODITIES, DEFINITIVE AT CITIGROUP YEARS AGO.
11:53 HE IS DELIGHTFULLY 79 AND HOLDING.
11:56 THANK YOU SO MUCH FOR COMING IN TODAY.
11:58 DO YOU REMEMBER THE FIRST OPEC CRISIS?
12:02 I DON'T KNOW IF YOU WERE AT THE STATE DEPARTMENT THEN.
12:04 HOW DID YOU AND YOUR FAMILY REACT TO THE PRICE OF OIL
12:10 EXPLODING FROM $15 OR $20 A BARREL?
12:14 ED: I WAS TEACHING AT THE TIME, I WAS TEACHING A COURSE ON
12:17 INTERNATIONAL POLITICAL AUTONOMY.
12:21 I NEVER THOUGHT ABOUT TEACHING ABOUT OIL.
12:25 OUR CAR HAD BEEN UNDER REPAIR AND WAS STOLEN FROM THE PARKING
12:28 LOT OF THE DEALERSHIP. WE WERE SCRAMBLING AS PRICES
12:33 WERE RISING TO FIND AN INEXPENSIVE CAR.
12:41 TOM: SO YOU BOUGHT A VW DESELECT THE REST OF AMERICA?
12:44 ED: WE BOUGHT A NOT EXPENSIVE CAR.
12:46 TOM: EVERYBODY HAD TO ADAPT THEN.
12:50 NOW WE HAVE A WAR AND UNIMAGINABLE SHUTDOWN OF A SR
12:57 TRAIT IN THE MIDDLE EAST. WE SEEM TO BE GOING THROUGH THIS
13:08 MUCH CALMER THAN OPEC 1 AND 2.
13:12 ED: IT IS CALMER FOR THE WORLD. WHEN THE EARLY 1970'S CRISES
13:22 TOOK PLACE, THE OIL INTENSITY OF GDP OF THE WORLD WAS GROWING AT
13:23 A PHENOMENAL RATE. WE HAD HIGHWAYS BEING BUILT
13:28 AROUND THE WORLD AFTERWARD TOO. OIL DEMAND WAS GROWING MOSTLY AS
13:36 A TRANSPORT FUEL AT A FASTER PACE THAN GDP.
13:41 GDP WAS GROWING MAYBE 4%. OIL DEMAND WAS GROWING AT 6%.
13:47 WE ARE NOW IN A WORLD WHERE THE OIL INTENSITY OF GDP IS FALLING.
13:54 WHEN YOU HAVE LOWER INTENSITY OF OIL, WE ARE NOT GOING TO SEE THE
13:58 PRICE SHOCK. TOM: DAVID GURA IS GOING TO BE
14:03 WITH US LATER ON ELECTION. AMERICA IS WEDDED TO A GALLON
14:14 OF GAS AND YET YOU ARE TELLING US THE INTENSITY IS NOT THE
14:16 SAME? ED: AMERICANS LIKE OTHERS IN
14:26 ADVANCED ECONOMIES ARE LIVING IN A VERY INFLATIONARY ENVIRONMENT.
14:29 OIL IS PART OF THAT INFLATIONARY ENVIRONMENT.
14:32 OTHER COMMODITIES ARE PART OF IT AS WELL.
14:35 THE COST OF LIVING IS GROWN FOR MOST OF THE POPULATION.
14:41 TOM: BRING UP THE CHART. I HAD TO GO BACK AND PRESS ED
14:44 MORSE. THIS IS BACK IN THE 1950'S WITH
14:48 THE FIRST BOOM AND THE FIRST OPEC BOOM AS WELL.
14:52 THAT IS 70 YEARS OF OIL. THE BRACKET AT THE BOTTOM IS THE
14:57 GREAT ED MORSE CALL THAT WILL WOULD FALL -- OIL WOULD FALL
15:01 BEFORE THE WAR INTO THE 40'S AND 50'S.
15:03 THAT WAS A LONELY CALL. IF WE GET OUT OF THE WAR IN ONE
15:08 PIECE, CAN WE GET BACK TO THE ED MORSE $50 A BARREL?
15:16 THE WORLD THEN. IT IS NOT INSIGNIFICANT THE UAE
15:22 SAID WE ARE NO LONGER BEING MEMBERS OF OPEC.
15:27 IT IS NOT INSIGNIFICANT OPEC AT ONE POINT COULD CONTROL PRICES
15:31 AND PUT A FLOOR UNDER IT. OPEC'S ROLE IN THE WORLD IS
15:36 INSIGNIFICANT. IT IS NOW IN THE 30 MILLION
15:41 BARRELS A DAY RANGE. IT IS 110 MILLION BARRELS A DAY.
15:48 OPEC DOES NOT COUNT MUCH. YOU GET TWO LARGE PLAYERS.
15:57 IRAQ IS VERY MUCH LIKE THE UAE SAY WE WILL NOT BE HAMPERED.
16:01 VENEZUELA IS NOT GOING TO BE HAMPERED BY HOW MUCH WE GROW.
16:07 THEY ARE COUNTRIES THAT HAVE A VERY LOW PRICE TO PRODUCE.
16:10 THEY DON'T CARE IF THE PRICE IS $40.
16:12 TOM: I HAVE ABOUT EIGHT WAYS TO GO WITH YOU.
16:14 GOING TO BE A TWO-HOUR INTERVIEW ON "BLOOMBERG MONEY."
16:19 IF CHINA IS THE ELEPHANT IN THE ROOM, AND THE GREAT THING WE
16:22 HAVE LEARNED THAT BLOOMBERG IS POLLUTION IN CHINA, IF YOU TAKE
16:32 THE WORK ON COAL IN CHINA AND PELOSI, WHERE IS CHINA IN
16:37 THE ED MORSE -- DRAG IT FORWARD, WHERE IS CHINA IN THE ED MORSE
16:38 WORLD? ED: IT IS NOT WHERE IT IS TODAY.
16:43 CHINA HAS THIS INCREDIBLE ADVANTAGE.
16:47 WHEN IT JOINED THE INTERNATIONAL MONETARY FUND, WHEN IT BECAME A
16:53 MORE ADVANCED ECONOMY, THE DEAL THEY STRUCK IS THE DEAL THEY
16:55 STRUCK IS THE IMF WILL USE CHINA'S SUFFICIENT NUMBERS ON
16:58 THEIR GDP. CHINA NOW CLAIMS THEIR GDP IS
17:02 RISING AT 4.6%. THERE IS NO WAY IN THE ROAD
17:08 CHINA'S GDP IS GROWING -- THERE IS NO WAY IN THE WORLD CHINA'S
17:13 GDP IS GROWING AT THAT RATE. SOME SAY YEAR-TO-DATE CHINA'S
17:18 GDP GROWTH HAS BEEN ZERO. NOT ONLY ZERO BUT THE INTERNAL
17:22 MECHANISMS IN THE COUNTRY ARE FAILING.
17:24 TOM: THIS IS PERFECT. IT IS A RETIREMENT SHOW AND HE
17:28 REFUSED TO RETIRE. COME BACK WITH ED MORSE AND TALK
17:32 ABOUT AMERICA'S RETIREMENT SYSTEM AND PERSONAL FINANCE AS
17:35 WELL. IT IS "BLOOMBERG MONEY."
17:55 TOM: "BLOOMBERG MONEY."
17:58 WE WELCOME ALL OF YOU ON PERSONAL FINANCE AND WEALTH
18:00 MANAGEMENT. ED MORSE WITH US WITH HARTREE,
18:06 CITIGROUP, LEHMAN, WHAT IS IT LIKE TO NOT RETIRE?
18:14 EXPLAIN THAT TO AMERICANS FOCUSED ON AGE 65.
18:19 ED: IT MEANS WHEN I WAKE UP IN THE MORNING, I HAVE TO READ THE
18:20 NEWSPAPERS. I HAVE TO GET ON THE AIR AND
18:23 EDUCATE MY MIND. I HAVE GOTTEN USED TO DOING
18:26 THAT. I DON'T WANT TO NOT DO THAT.
18:31 TOM: IT IS SUCH AN ADVANTAGE. SO MANY AMERICANS ARE BEING
18:35 FORCED TO EXTEND OUT THERE WORKING YEARS BECAUSE THEY
18:40 CANNOT RETURN YOU -- THEY CANNOT RETIRE.
18:43 HOW DID WE GET HERE WITH SUCH A FAILED RETIREMENT SYSTEM?
18:48 ED: OUR RETIREMENT SYSTEM IS A LOT BETTER THAN A LOT OF OTHER
18:50 RETIREMENT SYSTEMS. IT IS HARD TO DO A RETIREMENT
18:53 SYSTEM RIGHT. IT IS PARTICULARLY HARD TO GET
18:57 THE DEMOGRAPHICS RIGHT FOR THE COUNTRY.
19:00 IN THE U.S., WE ARE IN A MUCH BETTER POSITION THAN JAPAN,
19:04 KOREA, OR CHINA EVEN. CHINA HAS GOT THIS TREMENDOUS
19:14 DIFFICULTY IN WHICH THE AGED POPULATION DOES NOT HAVE A
19:15 PENSION SYSTEM. THE YOUNGER GENERATION HAS TO
19:19 WORK IN ORDER TO PAY FOR THE ADULTS WHO ARE NO LONGER ABLE TO
19:22 WORK. WHAT WE ARE SEEING IN THE
19:30 COUNTRY IS THEY HAVE THE ONE CHILD PER COUNTRY THAT THEY
19:35 TRIED TO CHANGE BUT THEY HAD THE DIVORCE RATE GROWING FASTER THAN
19:38 THE MARRIAGE RATE. THEY ARE IN DEEP TROUBLE WHEN
19:40 YOU THINK ABOUT HOW THEY WILL SUPPORT AN OLDER POPULATION.
19:45 WE AT LEAST HAVE A CHOICE IN TERMS OF PROVIDING AN OPENING
19:46 FOR IMMIGRANTS TO INTO THE COUNTRY.
19:50 IF WE WERE LOOKING AT FINANCING THE PENSION SYSTEM, THAT OUGHT
19:52 TO BE PART OF IT. TOM: WHAT IS YOUR ADVICE WITH
19:59 ALL THE DECADES OF ALLOCATION TOWARDS RETIREMENT?
20:03 HOW WOULD YOU ALLOCATE A RETIREMENT PLAN TODAY FOR A
20:06 YOUNG BRAT 30 YEARS OLD? ED: I DON'T KNOW HOW TO ANSWER
20:09 THAT. I THINK YOUNG BRAT WEATHER 22 OR
20:19 35 HAS TO UNDERSTAND THEY NEED TO PUT MONEY AWAY IN ORDER TO
20:21 HAVE MONEY THERE WHEN THEY NEED IT.
20:25 TOM: EQUITIES? ED: EQUITIES AND BONDS.
20:30 DIRECTION. THERE ARE SO MANY THINGS THAT
20:32 ARE MISLEADING. THE MAIN THING MISLEADING AT
20:38 THIS MOMENT IS FROM THE ENERGY SIDE.
20:41 IN A WORLD MOVING TO HIGHER ELECTRICITY AS A PORTION OF GDP.
20:49 THE SOURCES OF ELECTRICITY ARE CONTROVERSIAL.
20:51 SOME ARE FOSSIL FUELS, SOME ARE NOT.
20:54 IT IS GOING TO BE A DIFFICULT EPISODE TO GET THROUGH.
20:59 BUT WHERE YOU INVEST ON THE EQUITY SIDE OR BOND SIDE, IT
21:02 WILL BE A FUNCTION OF HOW THE ENERGY INTENSITY WORKS.
21:04 THERE ARE SOME EQUITIES THAT WILL BE SCREAMINGLY PERFECT TO
21:08 LOOK AT. TOM: THIS HAS BEEN FABULOUS.
21:11 LET'S DO IT AGAIN. ED MORSE, THANK YOU.
21:15 PLEASE STAY WITH US. CHRISTINE MAHONEY ON YOUR
21:19 RETIREMENT, NEXT.
21:29 TOM: "BLOOMBERG MONEY," AND WE SAY GOOD NOON TO YOU.
21:33 SCARLET FU ON ASSIGNMENT TODAY. SOMETHING ABOUT WORK FROM HOME.
21:35 WE HOPE SHE HAS A WONDERFUL THREE-DAY WEEKEND.
21:39 IT IS ON PERSONAL FINANCE AND WEALTH MANAGEMENT.
21:41 CANNOT DO THAT IF STOCKS ARE GOING DOWN.
21:44 LET'S LOOK AT THE STOCK MARKET. IT IS GOING DOWN HERE ON A
21:45 FRIDAY. IT IS GIVEN THE SHOCK OF NVIDIA,
21:49 WE ARE SLIPPING INTO THE WEEKEND.
21:53 WE HAD THE VIX ABOVE 20, MAYBE 20 AS THE NEW 30, I'M NOT SURE
21:59 WEEK. HERE'S WHAT THE STORY IS FOR
22:03 NEXT WEEK. THAT IS ANTHROPIC.
22:06 WE WILL FOCUS ON THAT HERE AT THE BACK END OF THIS HALF-HOUR.
22:13 THE DOLLAR, A HUGE DEAL. I CANNOT SAY ENOUGH ABOUT HOW
22:18 YEN AT 1.6 ZERO GETS EVERYONE'S ATTENTION WORLDWIDE.
22:24 YIELDS UP AS WELL AS WE GET TO THE DECEMBER 9 FED MEETING.
22:27 IT IS PERSONAL FINANCE AND ALL OF THAT.
22:31 IT IS ALSO EVERY ONCE IN A WHILE A STORY THAT COMES OUT IS JUST
22:32 GREAT. OF COURSE, HERE IT IS A
22:38 CROSS-PLATFORM EFFORT AT BLOOMBERG.COM/MONEY.
22:42 THIS WEEK THERE WERE SOME GREAT STORIES.
22:44 SARAH FOSTER STEPS IN. YOUR STORY ON THE COUPLE FROM
22:49 STATEN ISLAND WAS EXTRAORDINARY. WHAT YOU HAVE DONE IS AWAY FROM
22:53 THE SUITS AND BOWTIES YOU HAVE ACTUALLY TALKED TO REAL PEOPLE
22:55 ABOUT AFFORDABILITY. WHAT WAS THE ONE INSIGHT YOU
22:59 LEARNED? >> I THINK STATEN ISLAND IS A
23:04 WINDOW TO A LOT OF ECONOMIC NARRATIVES WE HAVE HEARD THAT
23:06 WERE AMPLIFIED THROUGHOUT THE ELECTION.
23:10 I MET A WOMAN WHO WAS LAID OFF FROM HER JOB AS A SOFTWARE
23:14 ENGINEER AND A COUPLE WHO SOLD THEIR CAR TO LOWER THEIR GAS
23:15 BILLS. I MET A RETIREE WHO WENT BACK TO
23:18 WORK BECAUSE OF AFFORDABILITY ISSUES.
23:23 THINK WHAT IS CLEAR IS A LOT OF THIS PESSIMISM ABOUT AMERICANS'
23:26 FINANCES IS THE MAIN NARRATIVE AROUND THE MIDTERM ELECTIONS.
23:30 ELECTION. WHAT DO THOSE PEOPLE WANT FROM
23:36 THE POLITICIANS IN THE UPHEAVAL THEY JUST CREATED NOVEMBER 3?
23:39 SARAH: IT IS DIFFICULT FOR A LOT OF THEM TO ANSWER THAT QUESTION.
23:44 THEY WOULD LIKE TO SEE MORE WORKER PROTECTIONS.
23:46 I THINK COMING OUT OF THE CORONAVIRUS PANDEMIC WHEN THEY
23:49 GOT THOSE AMPED UP STIMULUS CHECKS AND EMPLOYMENT BENEFITS A
23:51 LOT OF THEM WISHED YOU HAD THAT SAME KIND OF SAFETY NET IN A
23:55 MASSIVE JOB MARKET UPHEAVAL FROM AI, FOR ENTRY-LEVEL
23:57 OPPORTUNITIES. THEN, OF COURSE, THERE IS A LOT
24:02 OF PEOPLE WHO ARE NOT HOPEFUL THAT CONGRESS CAN DO MUCH TO FIX
24:03 THESE. TOM: LAST SENTENCE OF YOUR
24:12 ARTICLE WAS JAW-DROPPING. ABOUT THIS DEARTH OF HOPI.
24:16 SARAH: I THINK HOPE IS HARD FOR THESE, ESPECIALLY YOUNG PEOPLE
24:19 TO FEEL RIGHT NOW WHEN THEY HAVE TAKEN ALL THE STEPS THEY WERE
24:22 TOLD TO TAKE AND STILL KIND OF FEEL LIKE THEY ARE LEFT BEHIND.
24:27 TOM: HUGELY EMOTIONAL ARTICLE. THANK YOU SO MUCH FOR THAT.
24:29 ON AFFORDABILITY. THE FANCY PEOPLE IN NEW YORK,
24:36 WASHINGTON, OR OTHER CLIMATES. EVERY ONCE IN A WHILE YOU GET A
24:38 POWERPOINT THAT COMES ACROSS. I HATE POWERPOINT AS A GENERAL
24:39 STATEMENT. WERE YOU JUST -- WHERE YOU JUST
24:44 STOP. I NOTICED IT BECAUSE SEE FA
24:45 INSTITUTE WAS ON THERE. GOOD MORNING TO ALL OF YOUR
24:49 WORLDWIDE, BUT MORE IMPORTANTLY, MARSH WAS ON THERE.
24:53 THERE IS A HERITAGE THEY ARE NOT GOING TO GO INTO.
24:57 YEARS. CHRISTINE MAHONEY, MARSH GLOBAL
25:02 DEFINED CONTRIBUTION LEADER IS WITH US.
25:05 WHY IS YOUR POWERPOINT SO EMOTIONAL?
25:08 I WAS SHOCKED ABOUT THE UNITED STATES NOT IN LAST PLACE, BUT
25:14 FLUNKING WITH A C PLUS OR A QUALITY C.
25:20 WRITE PEOPLE. WHEN YOU RATE THEM A, B, C, THAT
25:26 CAPTURES PEOPLE'S ATTENTION. BUT THE PURPOSE OF THE INDEX WAS
25:29 TO GIVE YOU THE TOOLS TO CLIMB UP FROM A C PLUS TO AN A IN THE
25:33 DETAILS. TOM: BRING UP THE QUOTE HERE.
25:38 WE HAVE PRETTY FLAGS. IT'S LIKE WHEN I HAD A MIRIAM
25:41 WEBSTER DICTIONARY IN MY YOUTH. THE MONEY MUST READ HERE IS
25:45 SIMPLE. THE NETHERLANDS, DENMARK,
25:48 ICELAND, AND THREE OR FOUR OTHER COMPANIES -- COUNTRIES, THEY GET
25:53 AN EIGHT, MAY A MINUS. THE UNITED STATES -- IT IS NOT
25:58 EVEN A QUALITY C. WE ARE TAKING IT.
26:02 ADDRESSED. WHY ARE WE A C OR C PLUS AND THE
26:07 NETHERLANDS IS AN A? CHRISTINE: THE LARGEST REASON IS
26:14 THE WAY WE PROTECT OUR LOWEST-INCOME EMPLOYEES AND THE
26:16 VOLUNTARY NATURE OF OUR PENSION PLANS.
26:20 THE OTHER THING I WOULD SAY, NOT ONLY VOLUNTARY, EMPLOYERS DON'T
26:21 HAVE TO HAVE THEM. PLEASE DON'T HAVE TO JOIN THEM
26:26 AND DOLLAR AMOUNT YOU PUT IN IS VOLUNTARY AND IT COULD BE HIGH,
26:28 IT COULD BE LOW. IT IS NOT TRUE IN THE
26:31 NETHERLANDS, SO THAT DISTINCTION IS THE BEST MAJORITY OF THE
26:34 DIFFERENCE. WE ALSO NEED TO TACKLE SOCIAL
26:36 SECURITY. MAKE IT MORE SUSTAINABLE SO
26:39 PEOPLE CAN RELY ON IT. TOM: IS ICELAND AN A BECAUSE
26:46 THEY DID NOT SCREW IT UP LIKE THE UNITED STATES?
26:51 OR ARE WE AT A C, AND THEY DID SO MUCH BETTER?
26:53 WHICH EMOTION THERE IS CORRECT? CHRISTINE: IT IS IMPORTANT TO
26:57 THINK ABOUT THE CULTURES. I'M GOING TO COMPARE THE
26:59 NETHERLANDS TO THE U.S. THE NETHERLANDS IS VERY
27:03 COMMUNITARIAN. A DUTCH MAN SAID YOU CANNOT
27:08 STATES. WE WERE STOPPING THE WATER FROM
27:12 DROWNING OUR NEIGHBORS AS WE WATCHED OUR OWN HOUSE GO UNDER.
27:18 WE ARE A MUCH MORE INDIVIDUALISTIC SOCIETY, SO WE
27:20 HAVE A VOLUNTARY SYSTEM AND NOT SURE WE ARE IN A PLACE WHERE WE
27:23 ARE GOING TO TURN THAT AROUND, BUT WE CAN MAKE IT EASIER.
27:26 WE CAN PUT IN MINIMUMS. WE CAN DECREASE REGULATION.
27:28 THERE ARE THINGS WE CAN DO TO MAKE IT MORE ADVANTAGEOUS.
27:41 20 PAGES OF THINKING ABOUT WHAT WE NEED TO DO.
27:43 YOU ARE SITTING HERE WITH PETER ORSZAG OR THE FORMER TREASURY
27:46 SECRETARY. WHAT DO YOU SAY TO THEM IS THE
27:50 PRIORITY OF THINGS WE MOST ACCOMPLISHED?
27:53 CHRISTINE: FAKE SOCIAL SECURITY WOULD BE NUMBER ONE.
27:55 DON'T LET PEOPLE TAKE MONEY OUT BEFORE RETIREMENT AGE.
27:58 AND BEGIN TO FIGURE OUT HOW WE CAN INCREASE THE AMOUNT OF
28:03 PEOPLE COVERED AND THE AMOUNT THAT THEY PUT AWAY.
28:05 I DON'T KNOW IF THAT IS BETTER TAX VANTAGES, MAYBE WE COULD DO
28:11 A MANDATORY, AND ONE THING AUSTRALIA DID WAS, THEY BUILT
28:14 THEIR LEVEL OF CONTRIBUTION. THEY DID NOT START AT A HIGH
28:16 MANDATORY CONTRIBUTION. THEY STARTED WITH 1% OR 2%
28:20 MANDATORY AND SLOWLY INCREASED IT.
28:24 I WOULD SAY SOCIAL SECURITY FIRST, DON'T LET PEOPLE TAKE THE
28:28 MONEY OUT, MAKE SURE THEY CAN INVEST IT, AND THEN THINK ABOUT
28:30 HOW WE GET MORE MONEY IN. TOM: IS IT FEASIBLE?
28:36 WHAT IS YOUR TIMELINE TO 2032 WHERE WE MUST FIX SOCIAL
28:40 SECURITY, AS GREENSPAN HELPED FIX IT IN 1986?
28:43 CHRISTINE: I THINK THEY WILL DO IT.
28:45 I'M DISAPPOINTED THEY WAITED UNTIL THEY HAD TO DO IT, BUT I
28:48 DON'T THINK THEY HAVE ANY CHOICE BUT TO DO SOMETHING BETWEEN NOW
28:51 AND 2032. THE QUESTION WILL NOT BE, IS IT
28:55 THERE, IT IS, WHAT WILL IT LOOK LIKE?
28:59 TOM: SCARLET EMAILS IN FROM HOME.
29:00 THANK YOU FOR WATCHING. SCARLET FU SAYS, THIS IS GREAT,
29:04 CHECK? THAT SEEMS TO BE TANGIBLE AMONG
29:07 YOUNGER PEOPLE. CHRISTINE: ABSOLUTELY.
29:11 I'M NOT A DOOMSDAY OR ON SOCIAL SECURITY.
29:12 TOM: YOU ARE THE PRO. CHRISTINE: I BELIEVE IT WILL BE
29:17 THERE, BUT IT IS A QUESTION OF WHAT IT LOOKS LIKE AND IT
29:19 PROBABLY WILL NOT LOOK LIKE WHAT IT LOOKS LIKE TODAY, AND
29:22 GUARANTEES WILL NOT BE SIMILAR FOR THE MILLENNIALS THAT IT WAS
29:26 FOR THE BABY BOOMERS, BUT I BELIEVE WE WILL FIX THIS SYSTEM.
29:29 I DON'T BELIEVE WE HAVE ANY CHOICE BUT TO FIX THIS SYSTEM.
29:33 I DON'T KNOW IF YOU HAVE SEEN THIS, BUT RECENTLY THERE HAVE
29:35 BEEN STUDIES THAT MILLENNIALS ARE STARTING TO CATCH UP
29:38 FINANCIALLY, AND ACTUALLY ARE IN A MUCH BETTER POSITION NOW THAN
29:39 FIVE YEARS AGO. I THINK IT WILL BE DIFFERENT FOR
29:45 THE MILLENNIALS, FOR SURE, BUT I THINK IT WILL BE THERE.
29:48 TOM: THEY HAVE HAD THREE ONCE-IN-A-LIFETIME EVENTS.
29:51 WE DIDN'T HAVE THAT. JUST THE NEWS FLOW THIS WEEK
29:54 WITH NVIDIA AND THE REST OF IT, BECOMES A BLUR.
29:59 SO, YOU START IN AND AS YOU MENTIONED EARLIER, ARE YOU
30:02 PUTTING ENOUGH ASIDE? IT IS A MOST BIBLICAL, THE
30:05 CONCEPT OF TITHING. HOW MUCH MATHEMATICALLY IS THE
30:07 APPROPRIATE AMOUNT TO PUT ASIDE? CHRISTINE: I THINK THAT IS GOING
30:11 TO DEPEND ON WHAT YOU WANT IN RETIREMENT, BUT IT IS MORE THAN
30:13 WHAT WE ARE SEEING TODAY. DOUBLE DIGITS WOULD BE THE
30:15 ANSWER. DOESN'T ALL HAVE TO BE EMPLOYEE
30:19 MONEY. EMPLOYERS CAN MATCH.
30:21 THE GOVERNMENT CAN BE INVOLVED. BUT IT IS DOUBLE DIGITS.
30:27 TOM: DID WE SCREW THIS UP BY RUNNING FOR THE DEFINED BENEFIT
30:28 PROGRAMS OF OUR GRANDPARENTS? -- RUNNING FROM THE DEFINED
30:33 BENEFIT GRANT -- PROGRAMS OF OUR GRANDPARENTS?
30:39 WERE HAPPENING? BABY BOOMERS HAVE BEEN AROUND
30:43 FOR A LONG TIME, BUT FERTILITY RATES DROPPED FASTER.
30:48 FERTILITY MATTERS IN TERMS OF IMMIGRATION, SO I THINK THERE
30:51 ARE MASSIVE EXTERNAL FACTORS AND WE ARE RESPONDING TO THOSE.
30:56 TOM: ARE YOU BLIND TO EQUITIES VERSUS BONDS?
30:57 DO YOU HAVE AN ALLOCATION? CHRISTINE: AT MARSH IT IS GOING
31:02 TO DEPEND ON WHAT YOUR ACTUAL REQUIREMENTS ARE.
31:06 IN FAIRNESS, IN DEFINED CONTRIBUTION PLANS WE HAVE
31:10 SPECIFIC PRODUCTS WE OFFER IN VARIOUS COUNTRIES ACROSS THE
31:11 GLOBE THAT ARE MORE PRESCRIPTIVE.
31:15 TOM: IS YOUR POWERPOINT AVAILABLE ON YOUR WEBSITE?
31:16 CHRISTINE: IT IS. TOM: THIS IS A JEWEL.
31:21 IT IS NOT THE EMOTION OF SOMEONE GOT AN A, B, OR C.
31:23 DID YOU FLUNK ANYONE? CHRISTINE: THERE ARE A COUPLE OF
31:27 D'S. TOM: THAT SOUNDS FAMILIAR.
31:32 FOR MY ACADEMIC CAREER. THIS IS A KILLER POWERPOINT FROM
31:37 MARSH AND THIS EFA INSTITUTE. PRISTINE MAHONEY, DEFINITIVE ON
31:43 RETIREMENT WITH GLOBAL BENEFIT AND DEFINED CONTRIBUTION AT
31:45 MARSH. I CANNOT SAY ENOUGH ABOUT THIS
31:48 EFFORT. I WILL GET IT OUT ON SOCIAL THIS
31:52 WEEKEND, LINKEDIN AND TWITTER, ALONG WITH OUR DIFFERENT
31:53 INTERVIEWS. COMING UP, THE SENATOR FROM NEW
31:58 YORK, THE GENTLEMAN FROM THE HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES, THEY
31:59 ARE GAINING MOMENTUM. DAVID GURA, SLEEPLESS SINCE
32:05 TUESDAY, NOVEMBER THIRD, WILL BE WITH US.
32:08 WE WILL DIVE INTO A LITTLE BIT OF THE ELECTION DYNAMICS AROUND
32:10 YOUR PERSONAL FINANCE. FROM NEW YORK CITY, IT IS
32:14 "BLOOMBERG MONEY."
32:30 YES, THE FISH ARE REAL. SOMEBODY EMAILED AND SAID, THE
32:33 FISH ARE FAKE. NO, THOSE ARE IS TO BLOOMBERG'S
32:38 AQUARIA, I THINK IT IS. AFTER THIS EXHAUSTING WEEK AND
32:44 BACK TO HIS WONDERFUL ELECTION COVERAGE, HE IS STEELED FOR
32:47 "BLOOMBERG THIS WEEKEND." DAVID GURA JOINS US FOR A CHAT.
32:53 WE ARE DEEP INTO A LAME-DUCK SESSION.
32:57 SCHUMER, JEFFRIES, AND ALL OF THIS, THE GENTLEMAN FROM
32:59 MARYLAND, VAN HOLLEN. HOW DO WE GET TO MONDAY?
33:02 WHAT ARE YOU GOING TO LISTEN FOR THIS WEEKEND TO GET TO MONDAY AS
33:07 WE TRY TO GET TO 2027? DAVID: I THINK THE LEADERSHIP
33:11 FIGHT IS INTERESTING. YOU HAVE THE DEMOCRATS MEETING,
33:14 ELEVATING THE VICTORY, BUT TAKING ABOUT WHAT THE FUTURE
33:17 LOOKS LIKE AND THEY HAVE TO BE RESPONSIVE TO A LOT OF AMERICANS
33:20 WOULD LIKE TO SEE CHANGE IN THE WAY THE PARTY IS A STRUCTURE.
33:23 I THINK CHRIS VAN HOLLEN THROWING HIS HEAD IN THE WING IT
33:27 CASH HAD IN THE RING IS INTERESTING.
33:30 I THINK CHUCK SCHUMER IS LIKELY TO HOLD THE POSITION BUT I THINK
33:32 HAVING THAT DIALOGUE IS IMPORTANT.
33:35 TOM: IN TERMS OF BLOOMBERG "THIS MONEY."
33:41 WHICH IS DIFFERENT FROM "THIS WEEKEND," IN THIS MASSIVE
33:46 ORIGINAL CENTRIST TRUST, PUT COLOR ON THAT NOW.
33:48 DAVID: I THINK WHAT YOU ARE HEARING FROM LEADERSHIP, GREGORY
33:52 MEEKS WAS ON LAST WEEK. HE TALKED ABOUT HOW CENTRISTS
33:56 ARE STILL THE CORE OF THIS PARTY AND THE VICTORY DEMOCRATS GOT
33:59 WAS SIGNIFICANT BECAUSE IT IS A BIG COALITION, BUT THE CENTRIST
34:03 BLOCK OF IT IS LARGE. I THINK WE ARE GOING TO SEE THEM
34:08 COMING TO LIFE, GOVERNING THE GENERAL POLICY TRAJECTORY HERE.
34:11 IT IS GOING TO MAKE THINGS EASIER FOR WHOEVER LEADS THEM IN
34:13 THE HOUSE AND SENATE BECAUSE YOU'RE GOING TO HAVE THIS
34:14 DIVERSITY OF VOICES. BUT THERE IS GOING TO BE A
34:16 COURT. TOM: I'M SUPPOSED TO -- TO DO A
34:22 QUESTION ON TAX POLICY. I DON'T KNOW IF THERE IS GOING
34:23 TO BE A POLICY. DEFINE GURA GRIDLOCK.
34:30 DAVID: THEY NEED TO PASS A FUNDING BILL.
34:32 THAT IS LIKELY TO BE THE FOCUS OF THIS LAME-DUCK.
34:34 I THINK A LOT OF DEMOCRATS WOULD LIKE TO SEE THE CHILD TAX POLICY
34:38 EXPANDED IN THE WAY IT WAS A FEW YEARS BACK.
34:41 THERE IS MOVEMENT THERE, BUT HE GETS TO THIS ISSUE OF, HOW DO
34:43 DEMOCRATS WHEN THEY ARE IN POWER RESPOND TO THE ANGER THAT
34:46 ELEVATED THEM TO THIS POSITION WHILE MAKING POLICY THAT THAT
34:53 GROUP OF PEOPLE WILL APPRECIATE? TOM: I TALK ABOUT JON EDWARDS
34:57 COMING UP WITH TWO AMERICANS. YOU HAVE A BOOK HERE ON THIS
35:01 POLITICAL MOMENT BY ONE OF HIS FORMER SPEECHWRITERS.
35:03 TOM: DAVID: THIS IS BY ADAM GENTLE SIN.
35:06 HE WAS HARRY'S CHIEF OF STAFF. HE WRITES, WHAT DEMOCRATS SHOULD
35:12 LEGISLATION DONE. IT WAS WHEN PRESIDENT OBAMA WAS
35:18 IN OFFICE THE DEMOCRATS HAD THAT LAST BUD AND HIM GENTLE SIN WAS
35:22 A STAFFER FOR JON EDWARDS AND IS INSPIRED BY THEIR POPULIST BRAND
35:24 YOU ARE TALKING ABOUT. YOU LOVE A CARTESIAN PLANE.
35:31 HE SAYS, DON'T LOOK AT THIS AS A SPECTRUM FROM PROGRESSIVES TO
35:34 CENTRISTS TO TRADITIONAL DEMOCRATS.
35:36 THINK ABOUT IT IN A MULTIFACETED WAY.
35:38 THAT IS THE BIG TAKEAWAY. YOU DON'T HAVE A WHOLE LOT OF
35:40 TRADITIONAL DEMOCRATS BUFFETING THIS PARTY.
35:43 HAD ALL KINDS OF PEOPLE COMING INTO THE TENT.
35:47 TOM: CAN THEY PICK UP DISAFFECTED REPUBLICANS AND
35:49 BRING THEM OVER MORE TO A DEMOCRATIC CENTER?
35:53 DAVID: I THINK THIS ELECTION SHOWS THEY CAN.
35:56 THE QUESTION IS, CAN THEY KEEP THEM THERE?
35:59 IT IS IN THE POLICY THAT THEY ARE ABLE TO PUSH THROUGH THAT IS
36:01 GOING TO LEAVE THEM THERE. TOM: I WILL HAVE MUCH MORE THIS
36:07 IN THE COMING DAYS. I'M UP TO THE GILDED AGE.
36:11 THIS IS THE DEFINITIVE BOOK ON THE HISTORY, THE STORMY HISTORY,
36:17 AND FRANKLY THE BRUTAL HISTORY OF RACISM AND ANTI-SEMITISM
36:19 WITHIN AN OLDER DEMOCRATIC PARTY.
36:21 WHAT IT TOOK TO WIN. THIS IS EXTRAORDINARY.
36:26 DAVID, WHAT IS SO VISCERAL HERE, WE THINK IT IS NEW, ALL OF THIS
36:27 EMOTION. THIS EMOTION HAS BEEN OVER THE
36:31 ARK OF THE COUNTRY. WE HAVE SEEN THIS EVERY STEP OF
36:32 THE WAY. DAVID: LONG-STANDING.
36:36 HAVING THIS CONFERENCE AT WHICH THERE IS CELEBRATION, YET
36:41 CONSTRUCTIVE DIALOGUE, IS IMPORTANT.
36:43 SOMETHING THAT IS STRESSED IN THIS BOOK IS, WE SHOULD BE
36:45 WELCOMING THE CONVERSATION. IT SHOULD BE FRACTIOUS.
36:49 THAT IS THE HISTORY OF THIS COUNTRY, HAVING THESE FRACTIOUS
36:51 CONVERSATIONS. TOM: LET'S TALK ABOUT THE FAR
36:54 RIGHT. PICKING UP THE PIECES OF A TRUMP
36:57 DEFEAT THAT WE SAW. ARE YOU OPTIMISTIC THAT THE FAR
37:01 RIGHT CAN COALESCE TO A NEW MESSAGE AFTER TRUMP?
37:05 DAVID: I THINK THAT IS A HUGE OPEN QUESTION WHETHER THAT IS
37:08 GOING TO HAPPEN AND WHAT THE REPUBLICAN PARTY LOOKS LIKE
37:09 POST-TRUMP. A CONVERSATION WE WERE HAVING ON
37:13 ELECTION NIGHT AS THE RESULTS WERE COMING IN IS, WHAT HAPPENS
37:17 TO TRUMPISM? IS IT SOMETHING TIED TO TRUMP OR
37:20 WILL THE LEGACY LIVE ON? THAT IS THE QUESTION, HOW MUCH
37:23 HE HAS SHAPED THIS PARTY. WE TALKED ABOUT FOREIGN POLICY
37:29 AND ALL THE PRESIDENT TRUMP HAS DONE TO MOVE AMERICAN FOREIGN
37:32 POLICY FROM THE TRADITIONAL STEP IT WAS BEFORE.
37:35 HE THINKS IT IS FOREVER CHANGED. I TEND TO AGREE WITH HIM.
37:39 TOM: ARE WE REALLY GOING TO HAVE DEBATES OR PRIMARY MEET AND
37:45 GREETS OF 10 CANDIDATES ON EACH SIDE?
37:46 IS HE GOING TO BE THAT MUCH? DAVID: I THINK IT WILL BE A
37:52 DONNYBROOK LIKE THAT ON THE DEMOCRATIC SIDE.
37:54 THE REPUBLICAN PARTY IS LOOKING AT THE PATH FORWARD IN A
37:56 DIFFERENT LIGHT. IT MIGHT BE FEWER CANDIDATES,
38:01 BUT I THINK IT WILL BE, AS IN CYCLES PAST, A BIG GROUP AT THE
38:02 BEGINNING. TOM: DAVID GURA, THINK -- THANK
38:07 YOU SO MUCH. SUPER MAJORITY.
38:08 I HATE THEM. I HAVE TO READ THIS BOOK NOW.
38:13 OF COURSE, BLOOMBERG "THIS WEEKEND," SATURDAY AND SUNDAY.
38:16 7:00 A.M. CANNOT SAY ENOUGH ABOUT THE
38:22 CONVERSATIONS TO GET YOU TO THE SUNDAY TALK SHOWS AND ON INTO
38:23 THE NEXT WEEK. OF COURSE, NEXT WEEK IT IS
38:26 ANTHROPIC. DAVID GURA'S CHILDREN HAVE THEIR
38:33 ALLOCATIONS AS WELL. WE ARE GOING TO TOUCH UPON THAT.
38:39 FINANCE. GET YOUR SHARES NOW.
38:43 "BLOOMBERG MONEY."
39:00 TOM: "BLOOMBERG MONEY." WE ARE OUT ON DIGITAL.
39:05 IT SORT OF DRIBBLES OUT SATURDAY AND INTO MONDAY, BUT OUR DIGITAL
39:10 PRESENTATION AND WHAT WE DO HERE, THESE IMPORTANT
39:13 CONVERSATIONS WITH PEOPLE, IS REALLY QUITE SOMETHING WE ARE
39:15 HAPPY WITH OVER THE LAST COUPLE WEEKS.
39:19 LOOK FOR THAT ON LINKEDIN, TWITTER, YOUTUBE, AND ALL OF OUR
39:21 BLOOMBERG SITES AS WELL. IT IS FRIDAY, AND I'VE GOT TO
39:26 STAGGER INTO THE WEEKEND, INTO NEXT WEEK.
39:32 MAX CHAFKIN SHOWED UP AND -- SHOWED UP HERE ON ANTHROPIC.
39:35 WE HAVE NVIDIA NOW. WE HAVE ALL OF THE REST OF IT.
39:39 I'VE GOT TO TURN MONDAY TO A PRICING ON WEDNESDAY?
39:43 EXCUSE ME, PRICING ON WEDNESDAY AND TRADING ON THURSDAY?
39:47 EIGHT TIMES OVERSUBSCRIBED, SIX TIMES OR WHATEVER?
39:48 WHAT IS YOUR REPORTING? >> MY REPORTING SHOWED THAT
39:53 THERE IS A STRONG DEMAND FROM THE RETAIL SIDE.
39:56 A LOT OF THEM HAVE PARTICIPATED IN SPACEX BEFORE AND THEY ARE
40:01 STRATEGIZING TO SEE HOW THEY CAN MAXIMIZE THEIR ALLOCATION.
40:04 TOM: IT IS JUST GREAT. STOP IT.
40:06 SPEAKING OF GREED, MAX IS WITH US.
40:11 I REMEMBER WITH SPACEX THERE WAS THIS ROLLING, THE SHARES BECOME
40:12 AVAILABLE OF PEOPLE SELLING. WE GOING TO HAVE THE SAME THING
40:14 HERE? MAX: I BELIEVE SO.
40:21 TOM: WELCOME TO "BLOOMBERG MONEY."
40:22 [LAUGHTER] MAX: I THINK THE RETAIL, VERY
40:26 MUCH THE AI TRADE HAS BEEN A RETAIL PHENOMENON.
40:32 A MEME STOCKY PHENOMENON. WHEN YOU LOOK AT THE COMPANIES
40:38 THAT HAVE BENEFITED, SPACEX, AS WELL AS PALANTIR.
40:40 I THINK WE ARE GOING TO SEE ANTHROPIC, IF THEY ARE SMART
40:43 THEY WILL TAKE ADVANTAGE OF THE EXACT SAME DYNAMIC, WHICH IS
40:46 THAT THERE ARE A LOT OF PEOPLE WHO ARE REALLY EXCITED TO
40:47 ESSENTIALLY GAMBLE ON THIS. AND PUT A LITTLE MONEY BEHIND
40:54 THE IDEA OF COMMUNAL, AI SUPER INTELLIGENCE.
40:57 TOM: NOT THAT THE TWO OF YOU KNOW WHAT A RED HERRING IS BUT
40:59 WE USED TO HAVE A DOCUMENT AND IT WAS 28 PAGES, AND NOW THEY
41:04 ARE 200 PAGES WITH THE RISK FACTORS.
41:05 IS ANYBODY LOOKING AT THE FINANCIALS?
41:11 MAX: AS YOU KNOW, YOU READ THE S1 AND IT IS A STRANGE AND
41:12 STAGGERING DOCUMENT. YOU KNOW, ANTHROPIC IS SORT OF
41:18 PERFORMATIVE LEE A WEIRD AND DIFFERENT COMPANY.
41:21 THE OWNERSHIP STRUCTURE IS DIFFERENT.
41:24 THE BET IS THAT INVESTORS ARE GOING TO SAY, HEY, I'M ALONG FOR
41:26 THE RIDE. TOM: JAMES DIMON -- I CAN ONLY
41:33 CALL HIM -- WHAT'S HIS NAME? DARIO, BECAUSE OF SATURDAY NIGHT
41:36 LIVE. DID YOU SEE THAT?
41:37 IT WAS BRILLIANT. DARIO ON SNL.
41:44 COMPUTE IS A BUSINESS DILEMMA. WE ARE PARANOID ABOUT AI RISK.
41:51 DOESN'T WANT AI AGENTS TO RUN WILD.
41:52 THAT IS NOT A NORMAL ADDITIONAL PUBLIC OFFERING, IS IT?
41:56 >> NO, BUT IT IS NOT DETERRING THOSE COMMITTED BELIEVERS OF AI.
42:00 IT IS INTERESTING, BECAUSE THE RETAIL INVESTORS INTERESTED IN
42:02 ANTHROPIC ARE DIFFERENT THAN SPACEX.
42:06 SPACEX YOU HAVE THE ELON FACTOR, THE SPACE ENTHUSIASTS.
42:10 FOR ANTHROPIC IT IS THOSE TECH WORKERS, THE AI NERDS.
42:13 SO, THEY READ THE ANTHROPIC REPORTS, THEY MONITOR INDUSTRY
42:17 BENCHMARKS FOR PROGRESS. TOM: HELP ME HERE.
42:21 I FEEL SO OLD. MAX, GREED, THEY ARE GOING TO
42:28 COME OUT, IT IS GOING TO POP. DOES EVERYBODY SELL?
42:34 MAX: THE TRENDS ON INITIAL PUBLIC OFFERINGS AND THE PERIOD
42:38 OF -- AFTER AN IPO OR NOT GREAT AND WE SAW WITH SPACEX.
42:41 I DON'T FEEL QUALIFIED TO PREDICT, YOU KNOW, THE EXACT
42:42 MARKET DYNAMICS. I DO THINK THE AI MARKET RIGHT
42:48 NOW IS IN A VERY TENUOUS PLACE. I HAVE FOR WEEKS BEEN WONDERING,
42:52 ARE THEY REALLY GOING TO DO THIS?
42:56 I THINK IT INSPIRED A LITTLE BIT OF CONFIDENCE IN THE MARKET THAT
43:00 THEY APPEAR TO BE MOVING FORWARD WITH THIS IPO DESPITE THE NVIDIA
43:03 ISSUES, DESPITE THE FACT THAT MANY AI STOCKS ARE WAY DOWN OVER
43:07 THE PAST COUPLE OF MONTHS. SO, IT IS UNCERTAIN AND I THINK
43:11 PEOPLE WHO GET INTO THIS SHOULD REALIZE THAT.
43:14 TOM: I HAVE A MINUTE. THE TWO OF YOU JUMP IN HERE
43:15 TOGETHER. IF ANTHROPIC IS SUCCESSFUL WHO
43:19 DOES IT BENEFIT MOST IN THE AI DERBY?
43:22 WHAT IS THE NEXT COMPANY THAT WOULD LEARN FROM THIS?
43:27 >> I THINK IT WILL SET A TONE FOR OPENAI.
43:28 INVESTORS ARE HOPING ANTHROPIC PROVES THAT THIS IS -- THIS AI
43:31 TRADE IS GOING STRONG. TOM: I AGREE WITH THIS.
43:36 THERE IS A HUGE FOLLOW-ON MODEL TO THIS.
43:40 MAX: CONVENTIONAL WISDOM SAYS ANTHROPIC AND OPENAI ARE RIVALS
43:42 BUT IF THIS IPO DOES NOT GO WELL I THINK THAT BODES VERY POORLY
43:47 FOR OPENAI, BECAUSE EVEN THOUGH THE TWO COMPANIES HAVE THEIR
43:48 DIFFERENCES THEY ARE KIND OF SELLING THE SAME THING, AND IF
43:52 THERE IS NOT A MARKET FOR THE ONE IT IS HARD TO IMAGINE THERE
43:53 IS GOING TO BE A MARKET FOR THE OTHER.
43:56 TOM: ARE YOU KEEPING FROM US -- DO YOU KNOW WHO IS GOING TO TAKE
43:58 OVER AT NVIDIA? DO YOU AND STACY KNOW WHO IS
44:01 GOING TO TAKE OVER? MAX: THE WHOLE THING WITH THIS
44:05 TRANSITION IS THAT NO ONE KNOWS. IT DID NOT SEEN -- SEEM LIKE
44:09 JENSEN KNEW OR THE BOARD OR ANYONE.
44:11 TOM: LET'S DO THIS AGAIN. LET'S DO IT NEXT WEEK AFTER
44:14 ANTHROPIC COMES OUT AND WE WILL SEE.
44:19 THANK YOU SO MUCH FOR YOUR ATTENDANCE TODAY.
44:21 "BLOOMBERG MONEY" ON ALL OF OUR DIGITAL WORK.
44:23 GOOD MORNING.
Retail Investors Get Ready For Anthropic IPO full transcript
0:00 Max chef can show up. But even more importantly, his digital
0:02 song showed up here on anthropic. We got Nvidia.
0:07 Now we've got all the rest of it. Yes, and on a dime.
0:10 I've got to turn Monday to a pricing on Wednesday pricing, excuse me on pricing
0:15 on Wednesday and trading on Thursday eight times oversubscribed six times
0:20 whatever. What's your reporting?
0:22 Well I my reporting showed that there's strong demand from retail side.
0:26 Of course a lot of them have participated in space before and they
0:30 are strategizing to to see how they can maximize their allocation.
0:35 It's just greed. Come on, stop it.
0:36 It's freaking greed. Max is with us.
0:38 Max, I look at this and I remember with space X there was this rolling.
0:43 The shares become available of people selling.
0:45 Are we going to have the same thing here?
0:47 Uh, yeah, I believe so. I actually haven't looked closely at the
0:50 schedule, but I believe. Welcome to Bloomberg Money.
0:53 Um, you know, I think the retail, it's very much the eye trade has been a
0:58 retail phenomenon, a meme stock phenomenon.
1:02 When you look at some of the companies that have really benefited, uh, most
1:05 notably Elon Musk and SpaceX, as well as Tesla, also Palantir, uh, I think we're
1:11 going to see anthropic. If they're smart, they will try to take
1:14 advantage of the exact same dynamic, which is that there are a lot of people
1:19 who are really excited to essentially gamble on this and to and to put a
1:22 little money behind the idea of, of, you know, I see not that the two of you
1:27 know, what a red herring is, but we used to have a document here that you did
1:30 launch, and it was 28 pages, and now they're 200 pages with all the risk
1:34 factors. Is anybody looking at the financials
1:37 that you read this? As you know, Tom, I mean, you read the
1:41 S-1 and it is a very strange and staggering document.
1:46 Um, you know, anthropic is sort of performative.
1:49 Lee a weird and different company. The the ownership structure is
1:54 different. I think the bet is that, you know,
1:57 investors are going to say, hey, I'm, I'm along for the ride.
2:00 I mean, James Diamond with what I can only call him, what's his name?
2:04 Dario. Dario, because it's Saturday Night Live.
2:07 Yes. That was funny.
2:08 Did you see that? It was brilliant.
2:10 I mean, they're doing Dario and SNL. Compute is deepest business dilemma.
2:16 We're very paranoid about AI risks. Doesn't want agents to run wild.
2:22 That's not a normal initial public offering, is it?
2:24 No, it's not, but it's not deterring those really committed believers of eye.
2:29 It's interesting because the retail investors who are interested in
2:33 anthropic are kind of different from space, because space X, you've got the
2:36 Elon factor, you've got the Tesla, the space enthusiasts.
2:39 Whereas for anthropic it's those tech workers, the the I nerds kind of sort
2:43 of. So they read the anthropic reports, the
2:47 they read uh, they monitor industry benchmarks for model program to help me
2:52 here. I feel so old in this conversation.
2:56 Max agreed. They're going to come out.
2:58 It's going to pop X number of point. Does everybody sell?
3:02 I mean, you know, the trends on initial public offerings in the period
3:06 immediately after an IPO are not great. And we saw it.
3:09 We saw it happen with space X. Uh, I don't feel qualified to, to
3:13 predict, you know, the exact market dynamics.
3:16 I do think the AI market right now is in a very tenuous place.
3:21 I have for weeks been wondering, are they really going to are they really
3:26 going to do this? I think it was, uh, it inspired a little
3:28 bit of confidence in the market that they, that there they appear to be
3:32 moving forward with this IPO despite the Nvidia issues, despite the fact that
3:37 many AI stocks are way down over the past couple of months.
3:40 So so it's uncertain. And I think people who get into this
3:43 should realize they got a minute to the two of you jump in here together.
3:47 If anthropic is successful at this, who does it benefit most in the AI Dhabi?
3:52 Which is the next company that would learn from this?
3:55 I think it'll set a tone for OpenAI, and that's what a lot of investors are
3:58 watching for, too. Um, they're kind of hoping that
4:01 anthropic proves that this is AI trade is still going strong.
4:05 I agree with this. There's a huge follow on model to this.
4:08 100% agree. I think conventional wisdom says
4:11 anthropic and OpenAI are rivals. But if this IPO does not go well, I
4:15 think that bodes very, very poorly for OpenAI, because even though the two
4:19 companies have their differences, they're kind of selling the same thing.
4:23 And if there isn't a market for the one, it's hard to imagine there's going to be
4:26 a market for the other. No.
4:27 Are you keeping from us? Do you know who's going to take over the
4:30 Nvidia? Do you and Stacy?
4:31 No. But as you said, I've got this.
4:33 You're willing to take over. Uh, I mean, the whole the whole thing
4:36 with this, with this transition is that no one knows.
4:39 It didn't seem like Jensen knew or the board or anyone.
What Comes Next For Dems After ‘Blue Wave’ full transcript
0:00 We are deep into. I think it's like a lame duck session or
0:03 what it is the uproar. Schumer, Jeffries and all this.
0:07 The gentleman from I think it's Maryland and Holland are that.
0:10 How do we get to Monday. What are you going to listen for this
0:13 weekend to get the Monday as we try to get to 2020?
0:17 I do you think the leadership fight is interesting?
0:19 You have the Democrats meeting in Denver this week, obviously celebrating the
0:22 victory that they had on Tuesday. But thinking about what the future looks
0:25 like, and they have to be responsive to a lot of Americans who would like to see
0:29 change in the way the party is structured.
0:31 So I think Chris Van Hollen, the senator from Maryland, throwing his hat in the
0:33 ring, is interesting. I think Chuck Schumer is likely to
0:36 retain the position, but encouraging and having that level of dialogue among
0:40 leadership, I think, is important in terms of Bloomberg money, which is a
0:43 different show. Yes.
0:44 This weekend to me, what the arch question now of the Democratic Party is
0:49 the liberals, the progressives in this massive original centrist thrust, put
0:55 caller on that right now. I think that what you're hearing from
0:58 leadership, Gregory Meeks was on our show, the congressman from New York last
1:02 week. He talked about how centrists are still
1:04 the core of this Democratic Party. And I think that the victory that
1:06 Democrats got on Tuesday was significant, in part because, yes, it's
1:10 a big coalition, but the centrist bloc of it is so large, and I think we're
1:13 going to see them coming to life kind of governing the general policy trajectory
1:17 of the party here. It's going to make things a bit easier
1:20 for whoever leads them in the House and the Senate, because, yes, again, you're
1:23 going to have this diversity of voices, but there's going to be a core that's
1:26 very said so quickly. Or I'm supposed to do a question on tax
1:29 policy or that Monica Morgan Stanley's like, I don't know if there's going to
1:33 be a policy to find a gridlock right now.
1:36 Look, they need to pass a funding bill. I think that's what's likely to be the
1:39 focus of this lame duck session. We'll see what happens there.
1:42 In terms of hope for tax policy, I think a lot of Democrats would like to see the
1:45 child tax policy expand in the way in which it was a few years back.
1:48 I think there's movement there. But it gets to this broader issue of how
1:52 do Democrats, when they're in power, respond to the anger that elevated them
1:56 to this position? Well, all the while, making policy that
2:00 will that that group of people will appreciate one.
2:02 I talk all the time about John Edwards coming up with two Americas in that
2:07 you've got a book here on this political moment by one of his former
2:11 speechwriter. Yes.
2:12 This is a book by Adam, and it's called supermajority.
2:14 He was Harry Reid's chief of staff. And what he writes about is how
2:17 Democrats should be striving for super majorities having significant control of
2:20 the House, in the Senate and the white House to really get legislation done.
2:24 And it was when President Obama was in office, the Democrats had that last.
2:28 But Adam Wilson was a staffer for John Edwards and really was inspired by that
2:32 populist brand that you're talking about here.
2:34 And you love a Cartesian plane. He says, don't look at this as kind of a
2:38 spectrum of progressives to centrists to, uh, you know, more traditional
2:42 Democrats. Think of it in a more multifaceted way.
2:45 And to me, that's a big takeaway from what we saw on Tuesday.
2:47 Uh, you don't have a whole lot of traditional Democrats buffeting this
2:51 party. You had all kinds of people coming into
2:52 the tent. That's what he encourages.
2:53 Arch question can they pick up disaffected Republicans and bring them
2:58 over more to a Democratic center? I think this election showed that they
3:02 can. I think the new question now is, can
3:04 they keep them there? And getting back to what I said a moment
3:06 ago, it's in the policy that they're able to push through that's going to
3:10 keep them there or have them leave again.
3:11 My book for you folks in a much more honest in the coming days, I'm up to the
3:16 Gilded Age right now. Michael Kazin this is the absolute
3:19 definitive book on the history, the stormy history, and, frankly, the brutal
3:26 history of racism and anti-Semitism within an older Democratic Party.
3:31 What it took to win this is extraordinary.
3:33 And and, David, what's so visceral here? We think it's new.
3:37 All this emotion, this emotion has been over the arc of the country.
3:41 We've seen this every step of the way, long standing.
3:43 And going back to what I said a moment ago, having this conference at which
3:47 there is celebration but also constructive dialogue.
3:49 I think it's important here, and I think that something that's really stressed in
3:52 this book that I brought here today is we should be welcoming, that we should
3:55 be welcoming the conversation. It should be fractious.
3:57 That is sort of the history of this country is having these fractious
3:59 political conversations. We get the far right, the far left.
4:02 Let's talk about the far right, the picking up the pieces of, I'm going to
4:05 call it a Trump defeat that we saw. Are you optimistic that the far right
4:10 can coalesce to a new message after Trump.
4:13 I think that that is a huge open question, whether that is going to
4:17 happen here and what the Republican Party looks like post-Trump.
4:19 I think a conversation that we were having on election night, Joe Kelly and
4:23 I, as the results were coming in, is what happens to Trumpism.
4:26 Is it something that's tied to Trump or will the legacy live on?
4:29 I think that is the open question, how much he has shaped this party and his
4:33 image. And we had a conversation on the Big
4:35 Tech podcast this week with Nick Wadhams, where we talked about foreign
4:37 policy and all that President Trump has done to kind of move American foreign
4:41 policy from the traditional set that it was before.
4:44 He thinks it's forever changed. I tend to agree with him.
4:46 I think that he has moved in a different direction.
4:47 Are we going to really have debates or primary meetings, if you will meet and
4:52 greets of ten candidates on each side? Is it going to be that much of a
4:57 donnybrook? I think that it will be a donnybrook
4:59 like that. On the Democratic side.
5:01 I think the Republican Party obviously is looking at the path forward here in a
5:04 different light after what happened on Tuesday.
5:05 It might be a fewer number of candidates on the Republican side.
5:08 But but I do think it will be, as in cycles past, uh, a big group at the
5:13 beginning.
Social Security Will Be There, But Different: Mahoney full transcript
0:00 Is it feasible? What's your timeline to 2032?
0:03 Where we must fix Social Security? Is Greenspan help fix it in 86?
0:09 I think they'll do it. I'm disappointed that we waited till
0:12 they had to do it, but I actually don't think they have any choice but to do
0:15 something between now and 2032. And the question will not be, is it
0:19 there? It's what will it look like?
0:21 Okay. Scarlett emails in from home.
0:23 Thank you, Scarlett, for watching the show today.
0:26 And Scarlet Fu says, okay, this is great, but do I need to fear that I'm
0:31 not going to get a Social Security check?
0:33 That seems to be tangible among younger people.
0:36 Absolutely. I am not a doomsday or on Social
0:39 Security. Not even a professional.
0:41 Yeah, I believe it will be there, but it will be a question of what it looks
0:44 like. Um, and it probably will not look like
0:47 what it looks like today. And the guarantees will not be similar
0:51 for the millennials that it was for the baby boomers.
0:53 But I believe we will fix the system. I don't believe we have any choice but
0:57 to fix the system, I do think. I don't know if you've seen this, but
1:00 recently there have been all these studies that millennials are starting to
1:03 catch up financially and actually are in a much better position now five years
1:08 ago. So like I think it will be different for
1:11 the millennials for sure, but I think it'll be there.
1:14 I mean, they've had three once in a lifetime events.
1:17 I mean we didn't have that. I mean just the news flow this week
1:20 folks with Nvidia and and the rest of it, it becomes a blur here.
1:25 So you start in and as you mentioned earlier, are you putting enough aside.
1:30 It's almost biblical. The concept of tithing.
1:33 How much mathematically is the appropriate amount to put aside?
1:37 I think that's going to depend on what you want in retirement, but it's a lot
1:40 more than what we're seeing today. Double digits would be the answer.
1:44 Doesn't all have to be employee money. Employers can match, the government can
1:47 be involved, but it's double digits. It's significantly higher than what
1:51 we're doing.
Lutnick Under Fire in Nvidia Crisis full transcript
0:05 Live from Washington, D.C. this is Balance of Power with Joe,
0:10 Matthew and Kailey Leinz. Washington.
0:14 Gourds for the hearings. Welcome to the Friday the 13th edition.
0:19 As Jensen Huang prepares to testify behind closed doors on Capitol Hill, and
0:22 now Howard Slotnick prepares to do the same.
0:25 I'm Joe Matthew alongside Kailey Leinz in Washington.
0:28 Kelly. The knives are out for both of these
0:30 players, and all Wall Street can do is wait and watch.
0:34 Yeah, and unfortunately for Wall Street and the rest of us, they're going to be
0:36 waiting for some time. These hearings aren't scheduled until
0:39 December, December 1st. In the case of Jensen Huang, or at the
0:42 very least, that's what's been requested by the Republican leaders, a variety of
0:46 House committees. And December 10th, before the Senate
0:48 Banking Committee in the case of Howard Nick lot.
0:50 Nick. Of course, under even greater pressure,
0:53 uh, today after the Treasury Secretary, Scott Benson, went after him live on TV
0:58 on another network, suggesting that all of the other departments his Department
1:02 of the Treasury, the State Department, the USTR, everybody wanted mega speed on
1:05 the entity list. It's a question, he said, for the
1:08 Commerce Department. Commerce has the pen, he said, on brand
1:12 X, and indeed, the knives may not only be out on Capitol Hill, they may be
1:16 inside the house. This is going to be a remarkable
1:19 political and corporate drama playing out over what could be the next many
1:23 months. And investors again.
1:24 We saw a little bit under Nvidia this morning, but it's now lower.
1:27 This is going to be a tough one to decipher.
1:29 Yeah. And this is going to be a tough one for
1:30 President Trump to navigate to as he prepares to next week.
1:33 Travel to Shenzhen, China to meet with XI Jinping.
1:37 Uh, and this obviously throws a big wrench in the digital map between the
1:41 U.S. and China because of tighter export
1:43 controls are coming down the pipe, which Congress suggests, indeed, they will be.
1:47 China might have a problem with that and be threatening retaliation, and I would
1:51 imagine that could very much filter into those conversations.
1:53 Absolutely. We're going to have, uh, some of these
1:55 conversations ahead with Jeff Mason, our white House correspondent, is standing
1:59 by with the latest from the administration.
2:01 President's not doing much today, at least publicly.
2:04 Presumably packing for this trip, actually, with reporters already on
2:07 their way to the region. And retired Lieutenant General Karen
2:10 Gibson is going to be with us. Former deputy director of National
2:13 Intelligence would be a fascinating time to talk with her about everything that's
2:16 going on. Yeah, we're looking forward to that
2:17 coming up shortly. But first, as always, we begin with a
2:20 check on the markets on this Friday. Charlie Pallett is watching from New
2:23 York. Charlie TGIF, indeed.
2:26 What a week. But we seem to say that every single
2:28 Friday we are looking at an up week. However, for the S&P 500 index, a down
2:32 day to day with the Dow, the S&P, Nasdaq all and the red do want to begin with a
2:35 developing story. If you're taking the day off blaming
2:38 outlook, there is an update from Microsoft that out there that update
2:41 basically back to work. Microsoft says it is seeing a broad
2:45 recovery and stability across its services.
2:48 Also says this was a technical issue and not related to cyber AI agents.
2:54 Microsoft shares are up now by about 2/10 of 1%.
2:57 Bottom line, as I mentioned, those stocks are sliding again.
3:00 Let's begin with the stocks the Philadelphia Stock Exchange
3:03 semiconductor index. It is down 4.6%.
3:06 Nvidia tumbling again down now by 3.2%. S&P down 8/10 of 1%.
3:12 Dow industrials down 2/10 of 1%. And Nasdaq law now by 1.3%.
3:17 The Nasdaq 100 index down 1.7%. The ten year 5.13%.
3:24 Right now we've got the 30 year, 5.47% that two year, by the way, 4.85%.
3:30 Gold just about flat on the day. 3882 the ounce.
3:33 It is up one tenth of 1%. West Texas Intermediate crude little
3:37 changed. WTI down one tenth of 1% 8866 A barrel.
3:42 Barrel of Brent little changed flat on the day 9583.
3:46 Nvidia's board has reportedly approached arm CEO Rene Haas and its search for a
3:52 potential successor to Jensen Huang that, according to the Ft.
3:55 Citing sources. Uh, right now we do have Nvidia shares
3:59 trading lower by 3.3%. ARM Holdings, uh, down now by 6.2%.
4:04 S&P recapping here down 8/10 of 1%. The Sox right now down 4.8% Kaylee and
4:10 Joe lots going on. That is a Bloomberg business flash
4:14 always going on Charlie Pellet thank you so much I'm glad Charlie pointed us to
4:18 that reporting in the Financial Times today that the CEO has been at least,
4:22 uh, sought out, uh, as the Nvidia board looks for a permanent replacement to
4:26 Jensen Huang, knowing that the CFO, Colette Kress, is in, uh, the chief
4:30 executive position for the time being. President Trump, of course, made it
4:33 clear yesterday he has succession ideas of his own when it comes to Nvidia.
4:36 He suggested the CEO, former CEO of Apple, Tim Cook, is another legend that
4:42 could to replace a legend in Jensen Huang.
4:45 Uh, the president actually spent a good deal of time talking about the Jensen,
4:49 Huang and Nvidia issue yesterday, not publicly, but in a couple of
4:53 pre-recorded interviews, including sitting down for apparently a 40 minute
4:57 conversation with Stephen Smith for his YouTube show where he talked about
5:01 Jensen Alison. Well, the big thing is, was the woman a
5:08 spy? And I don't know if that's been
5:10 determined yet, but if the woman was a spy, yes, but the woman was not a spy.
5:15 Perhaps it would be different. But I can tell you this
5:20 somehow. He'll end up in his feet.
5:24 Uh, it wasn't the words as much as the sigh that we heard from President Trump
5:30 knowing, uh, that the swirl around him is likely about to intensify, uh, the
5:36 spat between Scott Benson and Howard Lutton, the congressional investigations
5:41 that will bring Nick to Capitol Hill, the allegations that are being made
5:45 about turning a blind eye to what may have already been known involving Jensen
5:50 Huang. Jeff Mason is covering all of this for
5:52 us and joins us now live from the white House as the president prepares to head
5:55 to China on this important trip. Here, Jeff, he must be aware of the
6:00 drama that's unfolding behind him. Oh, no doubt, Joe.
6:04 And you said earlier that he was probably packing.
6:06 I need to pack because I'm leaving for this, uh, this weekend.
6:09 And I can tell you that in addition to just thinking about what I need to
6:13 bring, we'll definitely be bringing some questions about this, because it's
6:17 almost certainly going to hang over this trip.
6:20 The president, uh, making clear in the last week that he still supports Jensen,
6:24 but as you emphasize with that deep sigh, um, very reluctant to encourage
6:30 him, uh, to step down from that position.
6:33 Uh, and, and also emphasizing, as his attorney general did this week, uh,
6:38 which was interesting and perhaps a little unusual, that there's still not
6:41 clarity on whether Alex Wong is a spy. China, of course, denying that it is.
6:46 Um, and and that will raise some questions to about, uh, whether
6:50 President Trump discusses this with President XI when they see each other
6:54 and whether he'll take his word for it. Uh, it's almost to harken back to a
6:59 press conference in Helsinki many years ago, uh, that I happened to be at and
7:04 asked the question at where the president, uh, seemed to take President
7:07 Putin's word, uh, on whether Russia had been, um, spying on the US.
7:13 Uh, lots of questions there, and certainly, um, lots of answers that we'd
7:18 like to get about what is actually the deal and what the president will press
7:21 on. How much is Howard Nix word still worth
7:25 to the president? Jeff, because we now have other cabinet
7:28 secretaries like Scott Besson openly, uh, essentially throwing the the
7:33 commerce secretary, uh, out to the wolves here.
7:36 Is President Trump going to take that bite?
7:38 Because we've seen this floated before, that there were knives out
7:42 for the Commerce secretary. And yet Howard Leatherneck has prevailed
7:45 before. Is this time different?
7:47 He's had staying power. That's absolutely right.
7:49 I Kayla. And your question is a good one.
7:52 I don't know the answer. It's certainly one that we're all
7:54 interested in. Uh, the fact that Secretary Bassett came
7:58 out in such a sort of open way, uh, today, throwing him or throwing his
8:04 colleague essentially under the bus about export controls, uh, was, um,
8:08 actually unusual for a term to, of President Trump where, um, a lot of the
8:13 infighting, if there is a lot of infighting, has been kept behind the
8:17 scenes. That was not a characteristic of Trump.
8:19 1.0, I can tell you, uh, where we often found out about that, um, through
8:24 through good reporting. But this time it's, um, more unusual.
8:27 Uh, and as you say, certainly puts pressure, uh, more pressure on Secretary
8:31 Lot. Nick and raises the question of whether
8:33 this is a final straw for President Trump or whether that long relationship
8:37 that he has had with with Howard. But Nick will sustain, uh, through this,
8:42 uh, controversy as well. All right.
8:46 Jeff Mason live at the white House for us before traveling with the President
8:49 to Egypt. Jeff, good luck packing.
8:51 Thank you so much for joining us. And on the Commerce Secretary, of
8:56 course, it's not just us in the media that are speculating about his future.
8:59 You're hearing a lot of rumblings on Capitol Hill as well, including from the
9:04 presumed incoming chair of the Senate Foreign Relations Committee, Senator
9:07 Chris Coons, the Democrat from Delaware, joined our colleagues on Bloomberg
9:10 Surveillance earlier this morning taking issue with Howard.
9:13 Let Nick in particular. Listen, I don't really care about Jensen
9:17 Huang's, you know, personal affairs. He let his family down, he let his
9:21 company down. But I would argue that it's Howard
9:24 Platnick who let America down. Uh, and if intelligence reports,
9:28 credible intelligence reports were provided, uh, that this uh, company, uh,
9:32 Mega speed was receiving advanced chips through illicit channels and they didn't
9:37 act on it. That's putting the American people at
9:40 risk. So let's get more on this now as we turn
9:43 to Lieutenant General Karen Gibson. She's former deputy director of national
9:47 intelligence and now is member at the Academy Security's geopolitical
9:51 intelligence group. And she's here with us in our
9:53 Washington, D.C. studio.
9:54 It's great to see you back. Uh, general, always good to have you
9:57 here. On balance of power.
9:59 It does seem that the conversation now really centers around export controls,
10:04 the enforcement of them, and whether there were decisions inside the Commerce
10:07 Department, in some instances, to look the other way, if indeed ships were
10:12 allowed to get into China. That should not have been.
10:15 What is the direct national security implication of that of simply the chips
10:19 that may already be there? Yes.
10:20 So I think, well, there's an opportunity sometimes to reverse engineer things to
10:24 advance and further accelerate China's efforts to create large language models
10:29 and other kinds of AI capabilities that would catch up to or rival that of the
10:34 United States. Any kind of advanced technology where we
10:38 have a significant edge is something that we want to keep to ourselves.
10:41 I would say it's a fallacy, though, to believe that Technological supremacy is
10:46 a given. You know throughout history that your
10:49 adversaries aren't ever going to, um, develop something that's better than
10:53 yours. And so it is especially important to
10:55 safeguard critical intellectual property, things that we have developed.
11:00 It's certainly the last thing I'll say there.
11:01 Is it without spending the money to develop it, without spending the money
11:06 on R&D or investing necessarily in the intellectual power that's required to
11:10 develop it, you get to short cut, short circuit and not make those kind of
11:14 expenditures. What's the equivalent here, general,
11:16 this isn't the recipe for Coca Cola that that was given away.
11:20 Uh, the way the market is reacting, the way Washington is reacting, is this the
11:26 modern version of selling the nuclear codes to China?
11:32 Have we ever seen anything that we can compare to this?
11:34 Well, I don't know that it's the modern version of the nuclear codes, um, you
11:37 know, which could, uh, devastate humanity.
11:40 But people think I could, too, in, in if if misapplied, perhaps one day.
11:45 Yes, I would agree with that. I think China has a long history,
11:48 though, of intellectual property theft, and they have worked very hard to,
11:53 whether it's through, you know, people who are not not every Chinese student,
11:57 not every, you know, professor, but embedding people in our educational
12:01 institutions, particularly research institutions attending business
12:04 conferences, you know, we're we're frankly, a pretty porous society.
12:08 I want to live in a free country where, you know, we're able to talk about
12:12 things freely. It is it is a disadvantage, in a sense,
12:16 of being in a Western liberal democracy. But we're pretty porous and they've
12:19 taken advantage of that. Well, talk to us about the extent to
12:23 which China really has been able to take advantage of it, because we consistently
12:27 hear that China remains behind, even if they have had access to these chips,
12:30 even if they're trying to distill, uh, American models doing the best they can
12:34 to cheat off our test. General, they still lag.
12:38 I guess the question is how much more materially export controls would
12:42 increase that lead time that the U.S. and even at that, you know, it wouldn't
12:46 be a permanent. I guess my point is, it's not always a
12:48 permanent advantage, because people are always they could track their own point.
12:52 Exactly. And and your adversaries are always
12:55 working on things that could one day potentially be stronger than yours.
12:58 I think when we look at what they gain by having the highest end chips, um,
13:03 it's important to note that that's probably for the highest end kind of,
13:07 um, capabilities, perhaps something that might lend itself to breaking quantum
13:11 computing. Right.
13:12 But the regular like our equivalent of or their equivalent of Chad or Claude or
13:17 an advanced Google search, they have chips and capabilities that do that
13:21 perfectly fine. And what you and I might use AI for in
13:25 our daily work. China has that capability, and they have
13:30 something that is good enough for your average person's use.
13:33 It's the really very high end applications where we have the concern.
13:37 We're talking about the newest, most advanced technology in the world, but in
13:40 this case, the oldest trick in the book. Mhm.
13:43 Uh, based on your experience, how prolific is the honey trap?
13:47 The honeypot in Chinese geopolitical espionage?
13:50 Yeah. So, you know, counterintelligence was
13:53 not my area of expertise. But, you know, as you you're right.
13:56 The oldest trick in the book I remember Clayton low entry, I think, at the
14:00 Moscow embassy, a U.S. marine who was enticed by an attractive
14:04 Russian woman to provide all kinds of secrets in this movie.
14:08 Yes. It's, you know, it's a it's a it's an
14:10 enduring, uh, human weakness, I guess I would say, and not one that's going
14:14 away. We spend a lot of time thinking about
14:17 things like NSA and exploiting, you know, advanced cryptography or how
14:21 people communicate. But human intelligence is still a, you
14:25 know, a means by which our adversaries can glean really critical or important
14:30 information. Well, so can you characterize for us,
14:33 uh, the strength China has, uh, right now, more broadly, geopolitically,
14:38 knowing that we have diverted resources away from the Asia-Pacific to deal with
14:41 the conflict in the Middle East. The president, of course, uttered some
14:45 pretty kind words for XI Jinping. He doesn't seem particularly concerned
14:50 about Taiwan. That is the backdrop, uh, against which
14:53 President Trump is making this trip to visit.
14:57 Does she have good reason to feel like he has the upper hand in this
15:00 relationship right now, and potentially has the opportunity to take advantage of
15:04 it? I would say one way that he does still
15:06 have the upper hand and it won't be forever.
15:08 Like perhaps in the same way that our chip supremacy may not be forever.
15:12 And that is, they still monopolize much of the access to refined, um, critical
15:18 minerals, rare earth minerals. And that is that is something that
15:21 everyone would like to have more of from China.
15:24 And that is a leverage that we have not yet done enough to erode.
15:29 I do believe it is shrinking and diminishing, but not fast enough.
15:33 And that is a great advantage of theirs. I'd love to ask you about what's
15:36 happening or not happening in this case. Uh, on this day at least, uh, with Iran.
15:40 Mhm. There is a thought in the markets and it
15:44 was brought about in research by Rapidan Energy Group, the Pentagon, uh, may well
15:49 be planning to use the three carrier strike groups that it has in theater
15:54 right now. Otherwise it probably wouldn't be having
15:56 them sit there through the holidays. And maybe you have a thought on that
16:00 Iran escalation. Odds are at 80%, according to Rapidan.
16:03 The president just yesterday says he doesn't need a deal with Iran and
16:06 started moving oil prices again. Are we in for more action?
16:09 Yeah. Middle East.
16:10 So I'd say a couple of things there. One, Centcom has done planning for
16:15 attacks. That's their job.
16:16 Yes, Centcom is ready to conduct such attacks.
16:18 That is also their job. But the president has not yet, I think,
16:22 authorized those and and has even indicated, for instance, in his most
16:26 recent meeting with the Qatari prime minister and foreign minister, that it
16:30 was probably not in the offing in the near term, I think.
16:33 I'm not a domestic political analyst, but I think certainly the midterms have
16:36 shaped perhaps his views on how acceptable those kinds of attacks are by
16:42 the U.S. Army.
16:42 It looks to me like the likely strategy is continued military and economic
16:50 coercion while, you know, trying to although although we've suspended
16:54 negotiation, military and economic coercion, that maritime blockade is
16:57 actually pretty effective. It just takes a really long time.
17:00 The various economic sanctions that we're putting in place, the periodic
17:04 strikes, like the ones that occurred last week on an island, um, if if they
17:08 were considering real significant air attacks, my question would be, what do
17:13 you think those airstrikes are going to accomplish?
17:17 That operation epic fury in eight months of economic and military coercion have
17:21 not. How will they be different?
17:23 In what way are those actually going to compel the Iranian leadership to make
17:28 some concessions regarding their nuclear program, which, remember, is the reason
17:32 we got into this to begin with? Yeah, but the president still says that
17:35 repeatedly, just on this notion that we don't need a deal because in the
17:38 president's words, we control the streets, speaks to the blockade that you
17:41 were referring to. That is not a long term, sustainable
17:44 position for the United States to hold, is it?
17:46 Well, you know, there is that because it does consume a lot of our naval
17:50 readiness. Um, you know, while those three carrier
17:53 strike groups are tied up in the Middle East, then it limits our ability to
17:56 respond to another emerging strategic requirement somewhere else, like the
18:01 Indo-Pacific. But I think also, even though oil is now
18:05 flowing through the strait, um, at fairly high volumes, um, there it is at
18:10 an elevated insurance premium which is driving and raising the cost of oil
18:15 globally, which is contributing to inflation globally.
18:19 And so I think from that standpoint, it's perhaps militarily feasible to
18:23 continue, but economically, it's not in our long term interest to allow the
18:28 Strait of Hormuz issue to go unresolved or to create a precedence in which a
18:33 nation like Iran can can dictate who gets to flow through.
18:37 In general, it's really great to have you.
18:39 We always learn something when you join us, and we hope that it won't be too
18:41 long before you do again. Lieutenant General Karen Gibson, former
18:44 deputy director, National Intelligence, now a member of the Academy Security's
18:48 geopolitical intelligence group. I'm Joe Matthew, alongside Kailey Lines
18:52 in Washington, will assemble our political panel next with more live from
18:55 Washington only here on Bloomberg TV and radio.
19:02 Is 121 on Wall Street. We do check markets all day long.
19:06 Dr. Bloomberg, I'm Charlie Pettit, the U.S.
19:07 stock market wrapping up a turbulent week for the AI ecosystem.
19:13 Nvidia's market cap below 4 trillion. And video shares right now down another
19:18 3.1%. The Nasdaq 100 index is down 1.7%.
19:23 We've got the Nasdaq Composite Index down 1.2%.
19:27 S&P keeping it all in context, down 7/10 of 1%.
19:30 Now the Dow industrials down one tenth of 1%.
19:34 A lot of damage to the stocks today. Down again dropping another 4.5%.
19:39 That is the Philadelphia Stock Exchange semiconductor index.
19:42 The ten year yield 5.13% gold up 2/10 of 1% 3886 the ounce.
19:49 West Texas Intermediate crude, now down one tenth of 1% 8863 a barrel.
19:54 Brent 9577. It is down by one tenth of 1%.
19:59 Microsoft says it is making solid progress in efforts to restore access to
20:04 its flagship software and end an outage that has paralysed government offices,
20:08 traders and businesses globally. Right now, Microsoft shares are gaining
20:12 on a down day for many tech names. Microsoft shares are up now by 2/10 of
20:17 1%. Again, recapping here S&P 500 index on
20:21 track for a winning week. We're looking at a 2% gain on the week.
20:24 Right now S&P is down 7/10. The Sox down by 4.5% John Kelly That is
20:31 a Bloomberg Businessweek. All right, Charlie Pellet watching the
20:35 Friday trade for us. Thank you so much.
20:37 What has been an insane week is coming to an end.
20:40 But the story that has driven the week, the resignation of CEO Jensen Huang in
20:44 the face of reporting on multiple affairs, including with an alleged
20:47 Chinese spy. That story is only just beginning.
20:49 Washington's not going to let this one go for a long, long while.
20:53 This is certainly going to extend well into next month, because that is when
20:56 hearings are scheduled for both Jensen Huang and the Commerce Secretary, Howard
21:01 Lehtinen, because agreed to sit before the Senate Banking Committee on December
21:04 10th. December 1st is when the House Foreign
21:07 Affairs China Select an intelligence committee, is hoping Jensen Huang will
21:11 sit down for potentially closed door testimony and the ranking member going
21:17 to be chair in January of the Foreign Affairs Committee.
21:20 Congressman Gregory Meet, the Democrat from New York, joined us on balance of
21:23 power last night and detailed for us the questions he has for Jensen Huang.
21:28 this is just the tip of the iceberg because for me, uh, it's not about, uh,
21:34 just the the illicit affair that he had. It's about the information that might
21:40 have been given, uh, to China and others that endangers the national security of
21:46 the United States of America. The question, then, is, why did the
21:49 administration not immediately notify Nvidia and Mr.
21:53 Wong so that that's during the normal procedures that take place?
21:57 Why didn't that take place, or did it take place?
22:00 Was he immediately notified or was he not?
22:04 Reports suggest he was not. And it's not only Jensen.
22:07 Huang was gearing up for a grilling in Washington.
22:11 Howard Lutton is going to have to drag back up to Capitol Hill, as well as the
22:15 Senate. Banking chair Tim Scott calls on him to
22:18 testify. Commerce Department saying that Lutton,
22:22 quote, has proactively agreed to appear voluntarily, uh, unquote.
22:27 That will take place next month as well. So we've got some doozies to look
22:31 forward to here. And it's always a pleasure to compare
22:33 notes with Ashley Davis, who joins us in studio.
22:36 And Jeannie Manzano, our great panel today, Ashley is, of course, our
22:39 Republican strategist partner at S3. And Jeannie is our Bloomberg Politics
22:44 contributor, democracy visiting fellow at Harvard Kennedy School's Ash Center.
22:48 Ashley, you spent enough time on Capitol Hill and working with Senate committees
22:52 to know what these gentlemen are in for. Why don't you give us a sense Jeannie is
22:56 a better title than me. I like hers and mine.
22:59 Um, no, seriously, it's China's something that always will unite
23:03 Republicans and Democrats. I mean, this is not just you.
23:06 Obviously. You have a soon to be Chairman Meeks,
23:08 but, uh, last night in her what he said. But Republicans are just as angry, not
23:12 just Tim Scott, but also Senator Kennedy.
23:15 Now, listen, Latinx going to have to be held responsible, or someone on Latinx
23:20 team will see what happens. Obviously, you saw yesterday and this
23:25 morning the president is still supporting him.
23:27 Uh, but you also saw someone who is leaking that they're all discussing his
23:31 future right now at the white House. So we'll see what happens.
23:34 But it's going to be a bloodbath. Remember the TikTok days, which just was
23:38 a very short while ago? That was one thing that really did.
23:41 You know, by the way, this isn't going to end with banking.
23:43 This is going to be banking. It's going to be national security.
23:46 Um, it's going to be obviously the China Select, which will probably still
23:49 continue. There was a question if it won't.
23:51 Yes. But um, it's serious.
23:53 If she did get some sort of information from him.
23:58 It's serious. Obviously this is something China and
24:01 the United States have done for ever in regards to spying on each other.
24:06 But because of the significance of Nvidia, the fact that it's 7% of the
24:11 overall S&P, I mean, it's significant and also it's significant for their
24:15 board to make sure that they were doing their fiduciary responsibility to their
24:20 shareholders to make him step down. And obviously that's a question that the
24:25 company is dealing with right now internally, including who will replace
24:29 him. Uh, Jeannie, but there is the wider
24:32 question of how much of this is fault that lies with Jensen Huang and Nvidia,
24:35 and how much may, in fact live with the administration and the Commerce
24:38 Department specifically, if they looked the other way and allowed whatever
24:42 transpired to transpire for Howard Lutton, if he's set to appear in just a
24:46 matter of weeks on December 10th before the committee, knowing we have seen
24:50 committee hearings fell, uh, cabinet members of of Trump's this term already.
24:55 Look at Kristi Noem who didn't have the right answer about that.
24:57 Hundreds of millions of dollars, uh, advertising campaigns she started.
25:01 And all of a sudden she was out as DHS secretary.
25:04 Could it go the same way for Howard lot, Nick?
25:06 Or do you expect he'll be able to retain his position?
25:08 Uh, until that hearing happens? Could we see a head roll sooner than
25:12 that? Uh.
25:13 We could. I mean, I think the concern of people in
25:16 the white House is that this is reaching to the highest levels.
25:20 I mean, let's not forget spring of 2025. Jenson Wong goes to a million a plate
25:27 dinner at Mar a Lago, right after the president has said he's going to tighten
25:31 export controls in the wake of that dinner.
25:34 Those export controls are loosened, and we understand that Nvidia is going to
25:39 invest in AI data centers across the country.
25:42 Now it's impossible, at least at this point, to draw a straight line between
25:46 the two. But it is one of the many questions that
25:49 reaches right up to Donald Trump. Just as the case of was this woman a
25:54 spy? He says on the air yesterday, he's not
25:57 sure. I hope he is sure and just saying that
26:00 in an interview. But he says he's not sure.
26:02 And he says he doesn't know when he was told about this.
26:06 So my point is these questions are reaching right up to Donald Trump.
26:10 And they should. And that means that it is very, very
26:14 possible that Howard Nix had roles. Let's face it, he hasn't been popular in
26:18 the white House for a long time, going back to Liberation Day relation with
26:22 Jeffrey Epstein. And now this.
26:24 We heard you talked about Scott. That's not today.
26:27 So I wouldn't be surprised if he goes. But on the other hand, a long term
26:30 relationship, three decades with the president and he is a survivor.
26:35 So hard to tell. But if he gets up on Capitol Hill, there
26:38 are big questions to answer, including how much did his family and he benefit
26:43 from his relationship with with Jensen Huang.
26:46 And in video, you know, how much did that play into decisions made as
26:50 commerce secretary that put the entire United States future at risk?
26:56 Those are big questions for one man to answer, and he's going to have to answer
26:59 them if he doesn't leave his position before then, or even if he does.
27:03 It's interesting. Yeah, yeah, it's interesting the extent
27:07 to which this has become bipartisan. You were mentioning earlier that
27:11 recalling how TikTok brought Democrats and Republicans together.
27:15 You know, you're in trouble if you've got both parties coming after you here.
27:18 Of course, Democrats still have to figure out their leadership.
27:21 And that's something that we wanted to ask you about.
27:23 Um, Chuck Schumer, for the first time in ten years, has a challenger.
27:28 Do you think Chris Van Hollen knew it was going this way?
27:30 Even a couple of weeks ago. But he made it official last evening en
27:33 masse. Now, the Democrat from Maryland made it
27:36 clear here he is. This is a generational opportunity for
27:42 the Senate to respond to the call of the American people for change.
27:46 The scale and scope of this victory, 56 Senate Democratic seats really gives us
27:52 a mandate and the votes to do big things.
27:56 But it should be very clear. While, you know, voters have rejected
28:00 the Trump policies, they've not yet hired Democrats.
28:04 They've given us a chance. We have to earn their trust.
28:07 And my view is that you can't earn that trust with old leadership.
28:13 Okay, Genie. The old leadership is the one who raised
28:19 $550 million and helped orchestrate this new majority that's coming into the
28:24 Senate. What is it about Chris Van Hollen?
28:26 Why would he be a better leader right now as as, frankly, another mild
28:31 mannered white man from the Amtrak corridor who shares the politics of
28:35 Chuck Schumer, doesn't he? And not only that, Joe, he's also a baby
28:40 boomer. I mean, this general generational change
28:43 notion is real. But Chuck Schumer is 75.
28:46 Chris Van Hollen is 67. You know, that's nine years.
28:50 I mean, we're not talking babies like you measure them in months.
28:53 I mean, it's really interesting. The other thing is that, you know, and
28:57 Chris Van Hollen, we should say, just out in Denver talking at this big
29:00 Democratic conference about what's next, being held there, um, trying to make his
29:05 pitch. But I think the big question for Van
29:07 Hollen is what can you offer? And there are real policy differences
29:12 here on everything from Medicare and also Israel in terms of foreign policy.
29:17 Those are big. But Chuck Schumer has a real benefit.
29:20 He won the Super Bowl, as you said. And also he is the incumbent, which
29:25 means he's been spending his days talking to senators about what
29:29 committees they would like to sit on and doling out those kinds of goods.
29:33 Raised a lot of money, recruited good candidates.
29:35 Those are big things. And so, you know, this is going to be a
29:39 hard fight. If Chris Van Hollen wants to do it.
29:42 He obviously he's doing it now. But this is tough.
29:44 And it's also a secret ballot. And remember what Nancy Pelosi said.
29:48 The only people you can trust, and this is the people who tell you no to your
29:52 face, everyone else is probably lying. Mhm.
29:56 Well so how does Steve Slate squeeze that.
29:59 Well yeah. He was feeling confident going into the
30:01 secret ballot this week and came up more than 30 votes short.
30:04 Um actually how do Republicans look at this.
30:07 Does it matter to John Thune if Democrats are going to have 55 or 56
30:11 seats in the Senate anyway? Who the leader of those Democrats is no.
30:16 But I do think if I'm Chris Van Hollen, I do give him credit because he's been
30:20 trying to take on the administration publicly, especially over some of the
30:24 border issues, Ice issues overall and several other issues over the last two
30:28 years. So for him, what does he really have to
30:31 lose? He's not that close with Schumer anyway,
30:33 and it gets his we're all talking about him.
30:36 So if you know everything that's affecting his stage setting for
30:39 presidential. Correct.
30:40 So even if he loses his name it is going to be much higher than it was yesterday.
30:45 Yeah. And um, the the problem is, is I don't
30:49 know how Schumer doesn't have the numbers, but I think Schumer does
30:52 probably come forward with some, like Nancy Pelosi did, some sort of
30:56 concession either. I'm only going to I'm not going to run
30:59 again in two years or something to make sure that he gets the vote.
31:03 Well, you know, that's my prediction. But I think she states, uh, and, you
31:06 know, I welcome any discussion about the future of our caucus, but I have the
31:11 votes to continue serving as Democratic leader.
31:13 That was his response on X. If you're Chris Van Hollen, I realize
31:17 you're getting some PR here, but isn't this a little bit of Joe Pesci being let
31:21 into the room when he thinks he's going to be a made man?
31:23 Like, but what happens to him if he can't win and his relationship with the
31:28 leader? Well, I don't think he's being stood up
31:30 to it. I mean, but so is Schumer going to be a
31:33 sore loser or not and take his committees away?
31:35 I mean, that's one thing on the Democrat side, it's not as much based on
31:38 seniority as you know, the leader really does have the power to do what they want
31:43 to if you ain't the king. But you know what?
31:45 That may help that Van Hollen. It's not like Chuck Schumer is beloved
31:49 by this next generation of leaders. And so if he's looking at taking on the
31:53 establishment, which obviously, not only was this, uh, economy anti-Trump
31:58 election, but it was also an anti-incumbent election.
32:01 So I don't think he has much to lose. Interesting.
32:03 Yeah. At all.
32:04 I just wonder if this influences the decision making over government funding,
32:08 which expires on December 11th. We'll have to save that conversation.
32:11 Remember the days ahead. Ashley Davis, Jeannie San Zeno, our
32:15 political panel on this Friday. Thank you so much for joining us.
32:18 And there's more coming up on balance of power up ahead.
32:20 We'll speak with the CEO and co-founder of loom, Bre Aaron Brown is on his way
32:24 into the studio next. And in book TV entering.
32:32 In this 140 on Wall Street. We do check markets all day long here
32:35 Bloomberg. We are have session lows.
32:37 But we're seeing a selloff in chipmakers today that is dry dragging down stocks
32:42 overshadowing this morning's inflation data.
32:44 That did ease concern about aggressive fed rate hikes Nvidia shares down again
32:49 today down 2.5% right now. But off session lows in video by the way
32:53 currently trading at 162 S&P 500 index down 6/10 of 1% right now.
32:59 Lower by 44 points. Dow industrials little change now down
33:03 under one tenth of 1%. We've got Nasdaq lower by 1%.
33:07 The Nasdaq 100 index down 1.4%. The Sox, meanwhile, hit hard again
33:13 today, down 4%. Right now we have got the tenure 5.13%
33:18 spot gold just about flat on the day, up one tenth of 1% at 3882 the ounce.
33:23 West Texas Intermediate crude, now higher, has been swinging between gains
33:27 and losses, up 2/10 of 1%. WTI 8884 barrel.
33:32 Brent right now at 96 09A Brent crude up by about 3/10 of 1%.
33:38 Bitcoin meanwhile down 3.8%. Bitcoin at 68,775.
33:45 After earnings Cisco system shares they're down 6.4% after earnings.
33:49 Applied materials down by 4.1%. And again Nvidia which reports next week
33:54 down now by 2.4%. John Kelly that is up Bloomberg
33:59 Businessweek. All right Charlie Pellet thank you so
34:04 much Charlie. We'll be back for more at the top of the
34:06 next hour on Bloomberg Businessweek daily with another check on the markets,
34:10 which is Charlie just outlined, are taking a leg lower, uh, today, at least
34:14 when it comes to equities and chip stocks in particular.
34:17 It's been a wild ride for the stocks index in the last week and a half since
34:20 the midterm election. Today, as Charlie mentioned, the stocks
34:24 index is lower by about 4%. The question, of course, is why today is
34:27 different than yesterday, where we saw a bit of a rebound in some of these names.
34:32 Melinda is Bloomberg Television market's correspondent, is going to try to help
34:35 us answer that question, I hope, from New York.
34:37 Uh, Nora, what is, uh, the driving force of the drag today?
34:42 Why, uh, end the week on a down note when it looked like we found a little
34:45 bit of resilience earlier this week? Yeah.
34:48 You're really seeing the market reevaluating how they're thinking about
34:51 this Nvidia situation, which we know has really been the biggest news of the week
34:56 and perhaps, uh, arguably the year. And it's been weighing on other
34:59 companies, as you mentioned. You did see Broadcom.
35:01 You saw AMD they were higher, uh, especially as we think about them as
35:05 potential beneficiaries for some of the clients that Nvidia was working with.
35:09 But we are seeing, uh, the market really changing its tune a bit as we think
35:13 about how this might shuffle as it relates to the entire industry as a
35:16 whole. I will point out, though, that the
35:18 Philadelphia Semiconductor Index, if you take a look at the weekly scope there,
35:21 that's actually still up about 7% on the week.
35:24 And so if that holds us, will be, of course, a pretty decent gain on a weekly
35:29 scope. But there's also just been this whole
35:31 conversation about, you know, market clearing events.
35:34 If you think back to the midterms, that was a thought in the market as to
35:37 whether or not that might be a market clearing event.
35:38 You also have a lot of folks looking ahead to that anthropic IPO, which we're
35:42 going to be getting next Thursday. So there's a lot of things to kind of
35:45 digest in this moment. And the question is, is this the right
35:48 time for anthropic to be doing this, given the broader tech environment that
35:51 we've been keeping an eye on? Well, it just feels like too much.
35:54 I mean, you're going into a weekend here.
35:56 Why go long when you see headlines like we did this morning?
35:59 Nora, I'm a piece of s Jensen Huang's last hours as Nvidia's CEO.
36:05 The headline in the Wall Street Journal at Bloomberg.
36:08 Before his ouster, Jensen Huang belittled the executive, replacing him.
36:11 He's actually calling the CFO now running the company.
36:14 A deer in the headlights. Can you imagine the headlines we get
36:18 Saturday? Sunday?
36:19 I mean, isn't that part of the hesitation?
36:22 Absolutely. And we're continuing to see all of these
36:25 chips. Uh, or, I guess I should say, the chips
36:26 falling ironically, talking about chipmakers here.
36:29 Uh, but as you mentioned, we had that amazing exclusive, uh, green be out on
36:33 the terminal about that story about Jensen Huang's last days as CEO, the
36:38 last hours saying that he was saying, whatever, I don't care.
36:41 Using these different phrases that were completely opposite to what a lot of
36:45 folks, uh, specifically here internally, like the likes of Ed Ludlow and other
36:48 folks saying that they've had experiences in terms of his personality.
36:52 So it really shows you how much that this situation has really weighed on
36:55 him, and it's clearly created a bit of an overcast for the market as a whole,
36:59 especially when you think about the fact that so many folks have really seen him
37:02 as the king of artificial intelligence. And so when you think about Nvidia as
37:06 the bellwether, it feels as though it really destabilised the market as a
37:09 whole as we think about just growth. But I will say that a lot of the sauce
37:14 that I'm speaking with are still saying there are other opportunities.
37:17 I mean, Nvidia is one company in this whole broader ecosystem.
37:21 And while Jensen Huang may have been a person that helped build this, um, you
37:25 know, this buoyant development that we've been seeing in the space, he's not
37:28 the only one that's been contributing to this.
37:30 And there will be a next chapter. All right, Laura, it's good to have you
37:35 back, as always, with us on the Friday edition.
37:38 Normal. Linda, live from world headquarters in
37:40 New York, covering the markets for us. We'll have a full wrap on the markets,
37:43 of course, in the late edition of Balance of Power, 5 p.m.
37:46 Eastern Time. Charlie will be back with another read
37:48 on the Friday trade at 2 p.m.. Sticking with this Nvidia story, it's
37:52 been driving our conversations all week, from Washington to Wall Street and back
37:57 again. Somebody who knows a little bit about
37:59 this technology, uh, is joining us right now in our Washington studio.
38:04 Aaron Brown is the CEO, co-founder of Luma.
38:07 He's also a retired U.S. Army Ranger and CIA operations officer
38:12 who was swimming in the choppy waters of the I industry.
38:16 Aaron, it's great to see you. Thank you for joining us today on
38:18 Bloomberg TV and radio. Uh, we'd like to get into what your
38:21 company is up to, because you've crafted a bit of a shock absorber.
38:25 If if I could even use that term for those who are using the large language
38:30 models that present any number of risks. But I'm just curious your thoughts on
38:34 all of us now as a former, uh, CIA officer and and somebody who's now in
38:39 the industry, the questions that you're asking when it comes to espionage and
38:44 where we should be looking from the company to right here in Washington on
38:47 the Commerce Department. First, thanks for having me today.
38:50 It's a dynamic day to be a day for you to come in here and, uh, you know,
38:55 having been a CIA officer as well, I didn't, uh, actually retire.
38:58 I resigned to go into the private sector, which is something of a
39:01 fascinating thing to do for a lifelong, uh, operator behind the scenes to come
39:06 out. Uh, and, you know, this is just one of
39:09 those moments where it's it's surreal to be sitting here.
39:12 Uh, believe you, it is. Yeah, it's really interesting.
39:15 This is just such a dynamic story. There's so many pieces moving here in
39:19 the world. You know, we need.
39:21 We all need Nvidia. Uh, I think the everyday person walking
39:23 around the street and Main Street has no idea how much Nvidia influences our
39:27 lives. Uh, I think we need Nvidia to be
39:29 successful. And this is where the dynamism just
39:31 becomes so tricky. They could lose by not being able to
39:35 sell to China, at which point the American economy suffers.
39:39 They could lose by selling to China because then China catches up, at which
39:42 point the the American economy suffers. Uh, we can have these unexpected
39:46 developments like we have, uh, in the last couple of days.
39:49 Uh, and there's some suffering there. It's really, uh, it's just such an
39:53 interesting thing to think about. And then you think about a company like
39:55 ours at Luma where, you know, we're both trying to give intelligence advantage at
40:01 scale with these agent systems to try and track things like these Nvidia chips
40:05 and see where they're being misused or delivered to.
40:07 Places are not supposed to, uh, while at the same time being totally reliant on
40:11 them to run our technology. I mean, it's just a web.
40:14 It's hard to make it up. Well, well.
40:15 And I wonder, uh, with the former CIA, uh, view, if you feel that what actually
40:22 was potentially more dangerous here is that more Nvidia chips were able to make
40:26 their way to China, or that there was a human intelligence asset who was this
40:30 close to the leader of one of the world's most valuable technology
40:34 companies, who just so happens to spend a lot of time up close and personal with
40:38 the president of the United States? Is it is it more a question of what else
40:41 she may have been able to access and influence?
40:43 Yeah. I mean, again, it's hard to know exactly
40:47 what happened here. I don't have any inside, uh, knowledge.
40:50 But, you know, one can make a lot of guesses.
40:52 Uh, I think what I, what I'd like to see come out here is just how much of an
40:55 intelligence asset was she really? You know, the the People's Republic of
40:59 China is very well known for making use of resources that they discover along
41:03 the way. You know, if someone has a business
41:06 access point, uh, the Chinese intelligence services are very good at
41:09 making use of that. And so until we know more about exactly,
41:13 you know, what was her status here, I think it's hard to know how risky this
41:17 actually was. But again, it's not surprising to me at
41:19 all. Uh, I advised a number of, uh, AI
41:22 companies and others in this space over the years, uh, to watch out for exactly
41:26 this threat. I mean, this is if this isn't China's
41:28 number one topic, it's right there. Uh, how can they beat us?
41:32 Uh, in the iRacing and and for the United States?
41:34 I don't think there's a more critical topic.
41:36 You know, when I talk to people on, uh, Main Street, uh, these days about, you
41:39 know, how do they feel about data centers and, uh, you know, the speed of,
41:43 uh, AI or superintelligence progress. I find that they don't they aren't able
41:47 to connect what's happening with their everyday lives.
41:49 And I think this is, uh, a messaging problem we need to solve.
41:52 You know, if they wish to see the solution for dementia or cancer, uh,
41:56 heart drugs, uh, Nvidia chips are going to be involved in that.
41:59 And if China gets there first, that undermines, uh, the U.S.
42:02 economy and the U.S. position in the world in ways I think
42:04 most people are underestimating. Well, that's fascinating.
42:06 So with all of the said here and what we've learned so far with this case, you
42:12 help to advise the Biden administration, uh, even just informally, as we
42:17 understand when it came to export controls.
42:19 Is it about turning the screws or enforcing export controls more
42:23 effectively, or do we need to start treating AI companies like this, like we
42:26 do defense contractors? This is simply not a tech firm we're
42:30 talking about anymore. So I think it's tricky.
42:32 I think, you know, I I've sort of offered up my, my advice or thoughts
42:36 really to, to anyone that comes, uh, asking for it.
42:39 You know, if you spend your life inside the, the CIA and, you know, one of my
42:43 last jobs was inside, uh, our department for Southeast Asia in Japan, you know,
42:48 China's backyard. Uh, and I got to see up front, you know,
42:52 what happens when an autocratic power can sort of move around, um, freely in
42:56 those environments. And and as they stretch that out, it
42:58 comes closer and closer to our borders. You know, the advice I just continue to
43:02 give really anyone bipartisan, any, any one that wants to come in and chat about
43:07 our thoughts on this is, uh, these things need to be protected.
43:10 I don't know if I go to the extent of protecting them like we do some of our
43:14 more, uh, military critical technologies because we need for Nvidia to thrive.
43:19 We need the other chipmakers, uh, to thrive.
43:21 They have to be able to sell, uh, you know, balancing a national security
43:26 dilemma like this one, trying to beat, uh, China and the Irish, which I think
43:29 is absolutely critical, while also providing the free market for the sale
43:33 of these critical systems. The AI stack needs to be a Western and
43:37 American AI stack around the world. That's absolutely critical and
43:41 autocratic. Power gets a hold of that, and the
43:43 amount of control they have over the world economy and everyday lives is
43:46 extraordinary. Wow.
43:48 Well, that's exactly what the Commerce secretary told Joe recently about why,
43:51 uh, the world needs to be operating, uh, on the American stack.
43:55 Let's talk more about what Bloomberg specifically is doing, because you
43:58 essentially, uh, if I can summarize it, uh, in broad terms, have an operating
44:02 system to use, uh, for agents in high consequence environment.
44:06 I would imagine this is making sure that there aren't hallucinations that could
44:10 be detrimental to write, uh, a potential analysis or what have you.
44:14 How could that help the U.S. gain a greater foothold in the
44:18 deployment of this technology, at least from a national security and defense
44:21 perspective over, uh, China, where, of course, there's much more of an emphasis
44:26 on open, weak models. And there's just a question of as to how
44:28 China overall is approaching issues like security of an agent.
44:32 Yeah, absolutely. I mean, you hit it right on the head.
44:35 You know, um, the AI labs are building the brain, uh, in my opinion.
44:38 Right. They're bringing this massive amount of
44:39 intelligence into play. Uh, we are building the coordination
44:42 layer, the control layer. And while it's still to a degree about
44:46 hallucinations, I think hallucinations are starting to be something of a bygone
44:49 era. That the the speed that this moves so
44:51 fast, it's hard to even keep up with what these models are good at and what
44:54 they're not good at. I still hear people saying they're not
44:56 good at math. I'm like, uh, did you see two weeks ago
44:58 they solve some of the hardest math problems in the history of the world,
45:01 right? And so it's more now about scale, right?
45:04 Uh, and so how can we take huge volumes of information, take the watching, uh,
45:09 how, uh, Russia or China or Iran are evading sanctions with either chips or
45:14 oil. You can watch these things happen in the
45:16 world now. It's at scales you were never able to do
45:19 as an intelligence officer, even 2 or 3 years ago.
45:21 We can watch all the ships moving around.
45:23 We can watch all the satellite imagery simultaneously.
45:25 These systems can speak every language on the planet, such that you don't need
45:29 linguists as much as you used to. Are you only really need them for these
45:32 really important final decisions. And so we're building the system to be
45:35 able to run that huge scales. We're talking about decisions in the
45:39 millions a day versus thousands or less a day in just the recent past.
45:44 And so with that type of decision advantage, uh, the United States in the
45:48 West has the ability to think about what China brings, uh, into this fight and
45:53 try to deter them well before there's a conflict.
45:56 Which is always, I think, the role of intelligence fascinating into who's your
46:00 client. Is this for corporate?
46:01 Is this for government or both. So, both in fact.
46:04 So we just raised, uh, $25 million. And that was in part to scale us to
46:10 commercial high consequence investments. You know, companies that are thinking
46:12 about making high risk insurance decisions or thinking about their supply
46:16 chain. So they want to be able to think about
46:17 them at scale with these systems. Right now, though, uh, our biggest
46:20 client is the Department of War. Uh, the, uh, the department is really
46:26 running out in the ice strategy very aggressively right now.
46:29 And, uh, we're Lumumba is one of the best examples of a company that is
46:33 making great roads that the inroads with these, uh, technologies leading it along
46:38 with Palantir right now, which is just inexplicable except in this era.
46:41 So you've got a protective layer. I describe it as a shock absorber, which
46:45 probably was not right. It's more sounds like it's more of a
46:47 traffic cop and a bodyguard for people who are using these systems and are
46:51 remaining moment. How would you better describe it?
46:53 Yeah, giving people control over thousands to hundreds of thousands of
46:58 artificial minds such that they can consume and control those minds to do
47:02 the work that, you know, would have taken them months or years before.
47:05 That can now be done in 30 minutes. Amazing.
47:08 Very cool. Lumber CEO and co-founder Aaron Brown
47:11 here with us in our Washington, D.C. studio.
47:12 Congrats on the round and thank you for coming in to see us.
47:16 Of course, is also a retired U.S. Army Ranger and CIA operations officer.
47:21 And that'll do it, Joe, for this early edition of Bound to Power.
47:24 But we have more coming up in the 5:00 hour as we continue to explore this
47:28 Nvidia story in the implications, not just for the company, but for what will
47:32 happen here in Washington, including what could happen inside the
47:35 administration itself as the pressure is growing on Commerce Secretary Howard
47:38 Bottom. Yeah, it sounds like the knives are out
47:40 and will pursue all of these storylines coming up on the late edition of Balance
47:43 of Power. As Kelly said, meet you here at 5:00
47:45 Eastern time and will take a look at what the markets did this week on
47:48 Bloomberg.
Richer on Paper, Americans Still Feel Price Pain full transcript
0:00 Terah Foster, uh, steps in right now. Your story.
0:03 Um, a couple from Staten Island. It was extraordinary.
0:07 What you've done is away from the suits and bow ties.
0:10 You actually talk to real people about affordability.
0:13 What was the one insight you learned? I think that's really interesting about
0:17 Staten Island is it's kind of like this window to a lot of economic narratives
0:21 that we've heard that really were amplified throughout the election.
0:24 I met a woman who was laid off from her job as a software engineer.
0:28 I met a couple who sold their car to lower their gas bills.
0:32 I met a retiree who went back to work because of affordability issues.
0:36 And I think what's really clear is that a lot of this pessimism about Americans
0:40 finances is really kind of the main narrative around the midterms.
0:44 I got David Gura coming up and we'll talk about the election, all that.
0:47 Let's flip that on its head. What do those people want from the
0:50 politicians of the upheaval they just created November 3rd?
0:54 I think it's really difficult for a lot of them to answer that question.
0:57 Uh, they of course, would like to see more worker protections.
1:00 You know, I think coming out of the coronavirus pandemic, when they got
1:03 those amped up stimulus checks, unemployment benefits, a lot of them
1:06 kind of wish that you had that same kind of safety net in a massive job market
1:11 upheaval from AI for entry level opportunities.
1:14 And then, of course, there is a lot of people who are not really hopeful that,
1:18 uh, Congress can do much to fix these. Well, your last sentence of your article
1:24 was jaw dropping about this dearth of hope.
1:28 Uh, it was extraordinary. Discuss quickly here.
1:30 Yeah, I think hope is really hard for a lot of these, especially young people,
1:34 to feel right now when they've taken all the steps that they were told to take
1:38 and still kind of feel like they're left behind.
Grading Global Retirement Plans, US Receives C+ full transcript
0:00 Christine Mahoney, Marsh Global defined benefit, defined contribution, leader is with us. Why is your PowerPoint
0:07 so emotional? I was shocked about The United States, not in the last place, but flunking
0:14 with a c plus or a quality c?
0:17 I think it's shocking, and we do it intentionally when you rate people. When you put
0:21 them up and down, you give them an a, you give them a b, you give
0:24 them a c. I think that captures people's attention. But the purpose of the index was
0:30 to give you the tools to climb up from a c plus to an a Okay.
0:34 In the details.
0:35 Okay. Well, that's great. Bring up bring up the quote here. Well, we have pretty flags.
0:39 It's like when I had a Merriam Webster dictionary in my ute. And the the money
0:44 must read here is just real simple. The Netherlands, Denmark, Iceland, and three or four other
0:48 companies, Bessent systems, they got an a, maybe an a minus. The United States, it's it's
0:55 not even a quality c. We're tanking it. Has major risk and or shortcomings that should
1:01 be addressed. Let's just begin with the why. Why are we a c or c plus
1:06 and The Netherlands is an a?
1:08 The largest reason is the the way we protect our lowest income employees and the voluntary
1:17 nature of our pension plans. The the other thing I would say, not only voluntary. Right?
1:21 Employers don't have to have them. Employees don't have to join them, and the dollar amount
1:26 you put in is voluntary. And it can be high. It can be low. That's not
1:30 true in The Netherlands. And so that distinction is the vast majority of the difference. We
1:36 also need to tackle Social Security, make it more sustainable so that people can rely
1:40 on On a behavioral basis, are they in a? Is Iceland an a because they didn't
1:47 screw it up like The United States? Or are we in a c and they just
1:52 did so much better? Which emotion there is correct?
1:54 You know, I actually think it's important to think about the cultures, and I'm actually gonna
1:58 compare The Netherlands to The US. Please. The Netherlands is a place that is very communitarian.
2:03 A a Dutch man once said to me, you can't build The Netherlands retirement system in
2:07 The United States. In The Netherlands, we were stopping the water from drowning all of our
2:13 neighbors as we watched our own house go under. We're a much more individualistic society, and
2:18 so we have a voluntary system. And I'm not sure we're in a place where we're
2:22 gonna completely turn that around, but we can make it easier. We can put in minimums.
2:27 We can decrease regulation. You know, there are things we can do to make it more,
2:32 more advantageous for us.
2:35 Of your March PowerPoint is not only the scorecard, but all of the thinking behind it.
2:40 20 pages of thinking about what we need to do. You're sitting here with Peter Orzaga
2:45 Lizzard or Jack Lew, the former treasury secretary. What do you say to them is the
2:50 priority of things we must accomplish?
2:53 Fix Social Security would be number one. Don't let people take money out before retirement age
2:59 and begin to figure out how we can increase the amount of people covered and the
3:04 amount that they put away. I don't know if that's better tax advantages. Maybe we could
3:09 do a mandatory. And, you know, one thing that Australia did was they built their level
3:14 of contribution. They didn't start at a high mandatory contribution. They started with one or 2%
3:19 mandatory, and then they slowly increased it. So maybe I would say Social Security first. Don't
3:26 let people take the money out. Make sure they can invest it, and then think about
3:31 how we get more money in.
3:32 Is it feasible? What's your timeline to 2032 where we must fix Social Security as Greenspan
3:40 helped fix it in '86?
3:42 I think they'll do it. I'm disappointed that we waited till they had to do it,
3:46 but I actually don't think they have any choice but to do something between now and
3:49 2032. And the question will not be, is it there? It's what will it look like?
3:54 Okay. Scarlet emails in from home. Thank you, Scarlet, for watching the show, today. And Scarlet
4:00 Fu says, okay. This is great, but do I need to fear that I'm not gonna
4:04 get a Social Security check? That seems to be tangible among younger people.
4:09 Absolutely. I am not a doomsdayer on Social Security. I'm not either, but you're the pro.
4:14 Yeah. I believe it will be there, but it will be a question of what it
4:17 looks like. And it probably will not look like what it looks like today, and the
4:22 guarantees will not be similar for the millennials that it was for the baby boomers. But
4:26 I believe we will fix this system. I don't believe we have any choice but to
4:30 fix this system. I do think... I don't know if you've seen this, but recently, there
4:34 have been all of these studies that millennials are starting to catch up financially. And, actually,
4:38 they're in a much better position now five years ago. So, like, I think it will
4:43 be different for the millennials for sure, but I think it'll be there.
4:47 I mean, they've had three once in a lifetime events. I mean, to me, we didn't
4:51 have that. I mean Right. Just the news flow this week, folks, with NVIDIA and and
4:55 the rest of it, it becomes a blur here. So you start in, and as you
5:00 mentioned earlier, are you putting enough aside? It's almost biblical, the concept of tithing. How much
5:06 mathematically is the appropriate amount to put aside?
5:10 I think that's gonna depend on what you want in retirement, but it's a lot more
5:13 than what we're saying... Seeing today. Double digit would be the answer. Doesn't all have to
5:18 be employee money. Employers can match. The government can be involved, but it's double digits. It's
5:23 significantly higher than what we're doing.
5:24 You mentioned The Netherlands and others. Did we screw this up by running from the defined
5:28 benefit programs of our grandparents?
5:31 I think, and an earlier guest mentioned this, I think demographics is what has screwed this
5:36 up. Could we have, anticipated that demographics were happening? Well, the baby boomers have been around
5:42 for a long time. But, honestly, fertility rates dropped a lot faster. Net migration matters Fair.
5:47 Fair. In terms of immigration into countries. So I actually think there are massive external factors,
5:53 and we are responding to those.
5:54 Are you blind to equities versus bonds? I mean, do you have an allocation at March
5:58 that seems to be the way
6:00 we go? March, it's gonna depend on what your actual
6:03 Of a careful balance.
6:04 Yes. No. But in fairness killing me. In defined contribution plans, we do have very specific
6:09 products that we offer in various countries across the globe that are more prescriptive.
Hard To Get A Retirement System ‘Right’: Ed Morse full transcript
0:00 What's it like not to retire? Explain that to Americans.
0:04 Focused on age 65. Well, it means that when I wake up in
0:08 the morning, I have to read the newspapers, I have to get on the air,
0:12 and I have to agitate my mind, and I it's.
0:16 I've got used to doing that, and I don't want to not do that.
0:19 Why do you. It's such an advantage.
0:21 I would suggest to you that so many Americans are being forced to extend out
0:26 their working years because they can't retire.
0:29 With all of your work and the academics of finance.
0:32 How did we get here with such a failed retirement system?
0:37 Well, our retirement system is then a lot better than a lot of other
0:40 retirement systems. So, uh, it's hard to do a retirement
0:43 system, right? And it's particularly hard to get the
0:46 demographics right for the country. I mean, we are in the US in a much
0:51 better position than Japan or Korea, right?
0:54 Or China, even in China. We talked about that a little bit
0:57 earlier. China's got this tremendous difficulty
1:01 in which the note age population does not have a pension system and do not
1:06 have a health system. The younger generation has to work in
1:10 order to pay for the adults who are no longer able to work.
1:14 Uh, and we're seeing in the, in the country, uh, is they had the one child
1:20 per family and that they try to change, but they have a divorce rate that's
1:24 growing at a faster rate than their marriage rate, and they are in deep
1:28 trouble. When you think about how they're going
1:31 to support an older population, we at least have a choice.
1:34 And we have a choice in terms of providing an opening for immigrants to
1:38 come to the country. And if we were looking at financing the
1:42 the pension system, that ought to be a part of it.
1:45 What's your advice with all the decades at worst of the misallocation towards
1:50 retirement, how would you allocate a retirement plan today for a young brat
1:55 30 years old? I don't know how to answer that.
2:00 I think the young brat who's, whether they're 22 or 35, uh, really has to
2:08 understand that they need to put money away in order to have money there when
2:12 they need it. The equities are bonds.
2:15 It's equities and bonds. And you have this.
2:17 Yes. And you have to have you have to have a
2:19 good advisor pointing you in the right direction because there's so many things
2:23 that are misleading. And the main thing that is misleading at
2:26 this moment is that we're from the energy side.
2:28 In a world moving to a higher electricity intensity of GDP.
2:34 Uh, and the sources of electric power, you know, are very controversial because
2:38 some of them are fossil fuels. Some of them are not.
2:41 Uh, and it's it's going to be a difficult episode to get through.
2:46 But when where you invest on the equity side
2:50 or on the bond side, it's going to be a function of how that energy intensity
2:54 works. There are some equities that are going
2:56 to be screamingly perfect to look at.
We’re Living In An Inflationary Environment: Morse full transcript
0:00 Joining us is Edward Morse with Hartree Partners.
0:03 Their senior advisor dabbles in commodities and of course, definitive.
0:07 Its Citigroup years ago and he's delightfully 79 and holding.
0:11 Thank you so much for coming in today. Do you remember the first OPEC crisis?
0:18 You were I don't know if you were State Department then, but how did you and
0:22 your family react to the price of oil exploding from over 15 or $20 a barrel?
0:28 I was teaching at the time, and I was teaching a course on international
0:31 political economy, and I never thought about talking about oil.
0:35 And here we had a 400% increase in the price of oil.
0:39 Uh, our car had been under repair and was stolen from the parking lot, which
0:44 was at the dealership. And, uh, and we were scrambling as
0:49 prices were rising to find an inexpensive car.
0:51 So you bought a VW diesel like the rest of America?
0:55 We thought it was a very. That's a long story, but we bought.
0:58 But we bought, uh, we bought a not expensive car.
1:01 I mean, I mean, everybody had to adapt then.
1:04 Now we have a war, an unimaginable shut down of a straight in the Middle East,
1:10 in the Persian Gulf. And we seem to be going through this.
1:14 Except for the military. People at risk.
1:16 We seem to be going through this much calmer than we did an OPEC one, OPEC two
1:21 up to 86. It's a lot calmer.
1:24 And it depends on where you are and who who you are.
1:26 But it's common for the world. And I think there's one thing we have to
1:30 bear in mind when the early 70s crises took place.
1:35 Oil, the oil intensity of GDP for the world was growing and was actually
1:39 growing at a phenomenal rate. We had, you know, highways being built
1:43 around the world. After World War Two, we had
1:46 intercontinental highways being built across the U.S..
1:48 Oil demand was growing mostly as a transport fuel at a faster pace and GDP.
1:53 GDP was growing at maybe 4% for the world as a whole, and oil demand was
1:59 growing at 6%. And we're now in a world where the oil
2:03 intensity of GDP is falling. And that was really my remarks.
2:07 I don't worry this time around as much as last year.
2:09 The next explain when you got lower intensity of oil?
2:12 Right. Then we're not going to see the price.
2:15 That was the case. But we have David Gurr is going to be
2:17 with us later of the election. In the election.
2:20 I'm sorry. It was still a gallon of gas at Morse.
2:24 Is the Americans wedded to a gallon of gas?
2:27 And yet you're telling me our intensity isn't there like it used to be?
2:30 Are you surprised, however, wedded to what the price of a gallon is?
2:35 I'm not surprised because, you know, Americans, like others in the advanced
2:39 economies of the world, uh, are living in a in a very inflationary environment.
2:45 Oil is part of that inflationary environment, other commodities, a part
2:48 of it as well. And the cost of living is growing for
2:51 most of the population at a faster rate than wages are growing.
2:56 I want to go to your great call here. Bring up the chart.
2:58 If you would allowed to go back and depress Ed Morse here.
3:00 This is Arab light back to the 1950s with the first boom and the first OPEC
3:05 boom is well, that's 70 years of oil. And the red bracket down at the bottom
3:11 is the great Ed Morse call that oil would fall down before the war into the
3:17 40s and 50s. That was a lonely call.
3:20 If we get out of this war in one piece, can we get back to an Emmaus $50 a
3:25 barrel? We can.
3:26 Whether we do or not is an open question.
3:28 And the reason I say we can. Is that the world now is very different
3:33 from the world then. It's not insignificant that the UAE said
3:38 we no longer be being members of OPEC. It's not insignificant that OPEC at one
3:44 point could really control prices and really put a floor under them, or keep a
3:48 ceiling to em. But OPEC's role in the world of oil and
3:52 liquids is really insignificant. It's now, you know, in the 30 million
3:57 barrels a day range. In a world where you look at total
3:59 liquid consumption, it's it's 110 million barrels a day.
4:04 So, you know, OPEC doesn't count much. And when you get two large players and
4:09 I'd say there are two because Iraq like very much like the UAE is saying, hey,
4:14 we're not going to be hampered by how we how much we know Venezuela is not going
4:18 to be hampered by how much we grow. They are countries that have a very low
4:23 price in order to produce. And they don't care if the price is 40.
4:28 I got eight ways to go here with you and I've got it's got a two hour interview.
4:31 Folks here on Bloomberg money with at Morse China is the elephant in the room.
4:36 And the great thing we've learned at Bloomberg is the pollution in China
4:40 seems to be real. If you take the work of Elizabeth
4:42 economy on coal and China and pollution and you drag it forward, where is China
4:49 in the Ed Morse world in five years? China is not where it is today, in the
4:54 next five years. And you can see it today depending on
4:58 where you're looking. China has this incredible advantage in
5:03 that when it joined the International Monetary Fund as a donor, when it became
5:08 a more advanced economy, the deal they struck with them is that the IMF is
5:11 going to use China's official numbers, what their GDP is.
5:15 So China now claims that their GDP is rising at 4.6% year to date.
5:22 There is no way in the world China's GDP is growing at that rate.
5:25 You take and you've interviewed people from the rhodium Group.
5:28 Rhodium Group says that year to date, Chinese GDP growth has been zero.
5:33 Yes. And, uh, and not only has it been zero,
5:37 but the internal mechanisms in the country are failing.
5:40 What's it like not to retire? Explain that to Americans focused on age
5:46 65. Well, it means that when I wake up in
5:48 the morning, I have to read the newspapers, I have to get on the air,
5:52 and I have to agitate my mind, and I it's I've got used to doing that, and I
5:58 don't want to not do that. We do.
5:59 You. It's such an advantage.
6:01 I would suggest to you that so many Americans are being forced to extend out
6:06 their working years because they can't retire.
6:09 With all of your work and the academics of finance.
6:12 How did we get here with such a failed retirement system?
6:17 Well, our retirement system is then a lot better than a lot of other
6:20 retirement systems. So, uh, it's hard to do a retirement
6:24 system, right? And it's particularly hard to get the
6:26 demographics right for the country. I mean, we are in the US in a much
6:31 better position than Japan or Korea, right?
6:34 Or China, even in China. We talked about that a little bit
6:37 earlier. China's got this tremendous difficulty
6:41 in which the no age population does not have a pension system.
6:46 They do not have a health system. The younger generation has to work in
6:50 order to pay for the adults who are no longer able to work.
6:54 Uh, and we're seeing in the, in the country, uh, is they had the one child
7:00 per family and that they try to change, but they have a divorce rate that's
7:05 growing at a faster rate than their marriage rate, and they are in deep
7:08 trouble. When you think about how they're going
7:11 to support an older population, we at least have a choice.
7:14 And we have a choice in terms of providing an opening for immigrants to
7:18 come to the country. And if we were looking at financing the
7:22 the pension system, that ought to be a part of it.
7:25 What's your advice with all the decades at worst of the misallocation towards
7:30 retirement, how would you allocate a retirement plan today for a young brat
7:35 30 years old. I don't know how to answer that.
7:40 I think the young brat who's, whether they're 22 or 35, uh, really, um, has to
7:48 understand that they need to put money away in order to have money there when
7:52 they need it. The equities are bonds.
7:55 It's equities and bonds. And you have to yes, you have to have
7:59 you have to have a good advisor pointing you in the right direction because
8:02 there's so many things that are misleading.
8:04 And the main thing that is misleading at this moment is so we're from the energy
8:08 side. In a world moving to a higher
8:11 electricity intensity of GDP. Uh, and the sources of electric power,
8:17 you know, are very controversial because some of them are fossil fuels.
8:20 Some of them are not. Uh, and it's it's going to be a
8:24 difficult episode to get through, but when where you invest on the equity side
8:31 or on the bond side, it's going to be a function of how that energy intensity
8:34 works. There are some equities because they're
8:36 going to be screamingly perfect to look at.
Ackman on Huang's Exit, Anthropic IPO Roadshow full transcript
0:00 How did you find the event? What happened there?
0:01 We listen to the live stream, but that's it.
0:04 Uh, I thought I liked him where the Jackson hung out.
0:09 How do you allay fears of the I treat? And I know you also tweeted about, um,
0:13 Jenson Button. Well, I think Jenson amazing CEO.
0:16 Sad to see him leave, but, you know, Nvidia will survive.
0:21 Well, uh, and you know, I'm sure the company will do great.
0:24 What do you think of Nvidia. And I think I think Jenson will do
0:26 something else. Great.
0:28 And Nvidia being the central bank of AI, what do you make of the key minor risk
0:32 and how one companies at the heart of all the I mean, there are a lot of
0:36 iconic CEOs and and you know, Apple had an iconic CEO and company did pretty
0:40 well after. I'm not I'm not an investor at Nvidia.
0:43 Uh, I always admired the company. Are you invested in something?
0:47 Uh, not. Not directly.
0:49 No. I'm in a fund that has a position in
0:52 anthropic, and I was impressed with art. So he seems like a good guy.
0:55 You can invest more in that. I am okay.
0:58 Actually, we're going to take. We're taking a hard look.
1:00 Yeah, yeah. Anything more?
1:02 We're gonna do the work. Are you feeling confident about what?
1:05 The heart looks like? That for you?
1:07 I know, okay? Yeah.
1:09 And any risks that you foresee for the AI trade down the line?
1:12 Yes. Many, many, many, many of them.
1:15 I don't think I have a unique insights, but I was impressed.
1:18 I thought, uh, that Dario was most impressive.
1:21 You seem like a very thoughtful, measured, you know, CEO.
1:26 And, uh, I liked how he talked about culture and talent, and
1:30 so it's good. Good job, good conversation.
1:33 I know you're probably at the height of the hype in finance, but how did you get
1:35 invited to this one? And how did people get invited?
1:38 You? Uh, just clients of J.P.
1:39 Morgan. I think I think I have a great job.
Ed Morse Says Oil Can Drop to $50 a Barrel full transcript
0:00 On wealth management. And of all of that centered around the recent memory of Brent crude
0:06 at a $117 a barrel. We're watching some news here right now. Market recovering a little
0:11 bit off of where we were at the top of the show. Joining us is Edward
0:16 Morris with Hartree Partners, their senior adviser, dabbles in commodities and, of course, definitive at Citigroup
0:23 years ago, and he's delightfully 79 and holding. Thank you so much for coming in today.
0:29 Do you remember the first OPEC crisis? You were... I don't know if you were at
0:34 state department then, but how did you and your family react to price of oil exploding
0:40 from over 15 or $20
0:41 a barrel? Was teaching at the time. Yeah. And I was teaching a course on international
0:46 political economy, and I never thought about talking about oil. And here we had a 400%
0:52 increase in the price of oil. Our car had been under repair and was stolen from
0:57 the parking lot, which it was, at the dealership. And, and we were scrambling as prices
1:04 were rising to find an inexpensive car.
1:06 So you bought a VW diesel like the rest of America?
1:09 We we... It was a very... That's a long story, but we bought but we bought
1:13 a we bought a not an expensive car.
1:16 I mean I mean, everybody had to adapt then. Now we have a war, an unimaginable
1:22 shutdown of a straight in the Middle East and the Persian Gulf, and we seem to
1:27 be going through this except for the military people at risk. We seem to be going
1:32 through this much calmer than we did in OPEC one, OPEC two up to '86.
1:37 It's a lot calmer, and it depends on where you are and who who you are,
1:41 but it's calmer for the world. And I think there's one thing we have to bear
1:45 in mind. When the early seventies crises took place, oil... The oil intensity of GDP for
1:52 the world was growing. Mhmm. And it was actually growing at a phenomenal rate. We had,
1:56 you know, highways being built around the world after World War two. Mhmm. We had intercontinental
2:01 highways being built across The US. Oil demand was growing mostly as a transport fuel at
2:06 a faster pace than GDP. GDP was growing at maybe 4% for the world as a
2:12 whole, and oil demand was growing at 6%. And we're now in a world where the
2:17 oil intensity of GDP is falling. And that was really my remarks were. Don't worry this
2:22 time around as much as last
2:24 time. Can you then explain...
2:25 When you got lower intensity of oil Right. Then it... We're not gonna see the price
2:29 shock that we had
2:30 to far. But we have... David Greifeld is gonna be with us later off the election.
2:33 In the election, I'm sorry, it was still a gallon of gas at Morse. Is... The
2:39 America's wedded to a gallon of gas, and yet you're telling me our intensity isn't there
2:44 like it used to be.
2:45 Are you surprised how we're wedded to what the price of a gallon is? I'm not
2:50 surprised because, you know, Americans like others in the advanced economies of the world, are living
2:57 in a in a very inflationary environment. Oil is part of that inflationary environment. Other commodities
3:03 are part of it as well. And the cost of living is growing for most of
3:07 the population at a faster rate than wages are growing.
3:10 I wanna go to your great call here. Bring up the chart if you would. I
3:13 had to go back. I had to press Ed Morse here. This is Arab light back
3:16 to the nineteen fifties with the first boom and the first OPEC boom as well. That's
3:21 seventy years of oil, and the red bracket down at the bottom is the great Ed
3:27 Morse call that oil would fall down before the war into the forties and fifties. That
3:33 was a lonely call. If we get out of this war in one piece, can we
3:37 get back to an Ed Morse $50 a barrel?
3:40 We can. Whether we do or not is an open question. And the reason I say
3:44 we can is that the world now is very different from the world then. It's not
3:49 insignificant that The UAE said we're no longer be... Being members of OPEC. It's not insignificant
3:56 that OPEC at one point could really control prices and really put a floor under them
4:02 or keep a ceiling to it. But OPEC's role in the world of oil and liquids
4:07 is really insignificant. It's now you know, in the 30,000,000 barrel a day range in a
4:12 world where you look at total liquid consumption. It's it's a 110,000,000 barrels a day. So,
4:19 you know, OPEC doesn't count much. And when you get two large players, and I'd say
4:23 there are two because Iraq like... Very much like The UAE is saying, hey. We're not
4:29 gonna be hampered by how we... How much we grow. Venezuela is not gonna be hampered
4:33 by how much we grow. They are countries that have a very low price in order
4:39 to produce. Right. And they don't care if the price is 40.
4:42 I got eight ways to go here with you, and I've got... It's got a two
4:45 hour interview folks here on Bloomberg money with Ed Morse.
Microsoft Struggles to Restore Access to Software full transcript
0:00 Thanks for taking the time. What can you tell us about this outage?
0:04 Hi, Tom. Yeah. This is one of the more severe Microsoft outages that we have seen.
0:10 Usually, these don't last more than an hour. They tend to be quite short and quite
0:15 narrow. In this case, this began on Thursday. It's spilled into Friday. As you mentioned, it
0:19 affects a wide range of services for them. It affects Outlook teams, Copilot, their AI service
0:27 also, and it's been it's been kind of a widespread problem. The company has been giving
0:32 updates on their on their on their website about how the progress is going, but there's
0:38 there's more than 200,000 reports of problems at this point, the company has said it's not
0:43 been able to figure out exactly how to solve it. There's some problem with their underlying
0:47 servers. They're working on that. Again, they've been giving, status updates quite regularly, but they haven't
0:52 been able to fix it so far.
Fallout from FAA Ground Stop; Trump to Meet Putin, Xi | Bloomberg This Weekend: Nov 14th, 2026 no transcript
US Stocks Fall As NVIDIA Leads Tech Sell-Off | Nasdaq, S&P 500 End Lower full transcript
0:00 The S&P 500 and the Nasdaq closed lower
0:03 on Friday as concerns about Nvidia
0:06 pressure technology shares with
0:08 uncertaintity about its leadership,
0:11 raising concerns about the durability of
0:13 the AI race and the AI trade.
0:17 US stocks closed mostly lower on Friday
0:20 with the Dow the only outlier, ticking
0:22 up a tenth of a percent while the S&P
0:25 500 shed 4/10en of a percent and the
0:27 Nasdaq lost almost 1%. Nvidia shares
0:31 continued their slide, recording their
0:34 sixth straight week of declines, the
0:36 stock's longest streak since October
0:38 2012. It follows the resignation of CEO
0:41 Jensen Hang, who stepped down after
0:44 revelations of extrammarital affairs,
0:46 including one involving a Chinese
0:48 businesswoman who was reportedly under
0:50 suspicion of being a Chinese spy. Jim
0:53 Warden is chief investment officer at
0:55 the Wealth Consulting Group.
0:57 >> The market right now is uh really trying
0:59 to uh digest the news with Jensen Hong
1:04 and Nvidia.
1:05 How does that change things? We're also
1:09 still digesting I think the midterms and
1:12 potential policy shifts. Does AI build
1:15 out slow a little bit. Um so that's I
1:19 really I think the market's looking at
1:20 that we we got an inflation print. It's
1:23 trying to digest that too. The good news
1:26 is that some of those things now are
1:28 behind us and so I think some of this
1:31 uncertainty is getting uh you know uh
1:33 priced in uh that we are moving forward
1:37 uh typically November, December,
1:40 January, even going into February often
1:42 very good months uh for the market. So,
1:45 I'm I'm optimistic we we might move
1:48 sideways a little bit longer. Uh but I'm
1:51 confident that um the market will get
1:54 its bearings and and we can move
1:55 forward.
1:56 >> Among Friday's stock moves, Neocloud
1:59 companies Cororeweave and Nebus ended
2:02 lower as did data center related firms I
2:06 applied digital. The losses come ahead
2:08 of next week's anthropic IPO and
2:11 quarterly earnings from Nvidia. Both
2:14 will serve as major tests for the
2:16 tumultuous AI trade.
2:18 >> The S&P 500 and the NASDAQ closed lower
2:21 on Friday as concerns about Nvidia
2:24 pressure technology shares with
2:26 uncertaintity about its leadership,
2:29 raising concerns about the durability of
2:31 the AI race and the AI trade.
2:36 US stocks closed mostly lower on Friday
2:38 with the Dow the only outlier, ticking
2:41 up a tenth of a percent while the S&P
2:43 500 shed 4/10en of a percent and the
2:46 Nasdaq lost almost 1%. Nvidia shares
2:49 continued their slide, recording their
2:52 sixth straight week of declines, the
2:54 stock's longest streak since October
2:56 2012. It follows the resignation of CEO
3:00 Jensen Hang, who stepped down after
3:02 revelations of extrammarital affairs,
3:04 including one involving a Chinese
3:06 businesswoman who was reportedly under
3:08 suspicion of being a Chinese spy. Jim
3:11 Warden is chief investment officer at
3:13 the Wealth Consulting Group.
3:15 >> The market right now is uh really trying
3:18 to uh digest the news with Jensen Wong
3:22 and Nvidia.
3:24 How does that change things? We're also
3:27 still digesting I think the midterms and
3:30 potential policy shifts. Does AI build
3:34 out slow a little bit? Um so that's I
3:37 really I think the market's looking at
3:39 that we we got an inflation print. It's
3:41 trying to digest that too. The good news
3:44 is that some of those things now are
3:46 behind us and so I think some of this
3:49 uncertainty is getting uh you know uh
3:52 priced in uh that we are moving forward
3:55 uh typically November, December,
3:58 January, even going into February often
4:00 very good months uh for the market. So,
4:03 I'm I'm optimistic we we might move
4:06 sideways a little bit longer. Uh but I'm
4:09 confident that um the market will get
4:12 its bearings and and we can move
4:13 forward.
4:14 >> Among Friday's stock moves, Neocloud
4:17 companies Cororeweave and Nebus ended
4:20 lower as did data center related firms I
4:24 applied digital. The losses come ahead
4:26 of next week's anthropic IPO and
4:29 quarterly earnings from Nvidia. Both
4:32 will serve as major tests for the
4:34 tumultuous AI trade.